state of downtown pittsburgh - The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership
Transcription
state of downtown pittsburgh - The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership
2012 STATE OF DOWNTOWN PITTSBURGH TABLE OF CONTENTS 01 02 04 07 12 16 19 23 26 29 Foreword Rankings Excellence of Environment Office and Employment Residential Market Restaurants and Retail Visiting and Entertainment Transportation Downtown Development Acknowledgements Getting Here Notable Rankings and Accolades Setting the Stage Business Happens A Place to Call Home A Vibrant Mix The Perfect Getaway The Hub of the Region Prospering as a City Thank You for Your Support BID (Business Improvement District) Greater Downtown State of Downtown Pittsburgh is produced by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. The data presented in this report is derived from many sources and covers activity within the boundaries of the Business Improvement District and Greater Downtown. For more information about the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, its reports, data, and studies, or to become a member, please visit www.DowntownPittsburgh.com or email [email protected]. Foreword State of Downtown Repor t We are pleased to share with you the State of Downtown Pittsburgh 2012 which furthers our efforts to maintain unique, consistent and reliable data about Downtown Pittsburgh. Since our inception, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership (PDP) has served as an information resource for developers, businesses and residents, collecting and disseminating data that encourages investment in Downtown. The State of Downtown Pittsburgh is meant to build upon the research efforts of past and present in order to track, benchmark, and report data, specific to Downtown Pittsburgh. The report also highlights areas of opportunity and current challenges as we strive to build upon the vitality of the center of the region. As a business or property owner, developer or resident with investment stakes in Downtown Pittsburgh, we hope this data proves to be indispensable. Downtown’s residential population continues to increase with more units being delivered in 2012, and office vacancy has decreased while lease rates continue to grow. The boundaries of Downtown are expanding to the Lower Hill with the completion of the Consol Energy Center and future development of the Civic Arena site, and to the popular North Shore with completion of the light-rail extension, connecting hundreds of thousands of visitors with seamless access to the Golden Triangle. The country is beginning to realize that Pittsburgh is a great place to live and visit, with frequent accolades, most notably as the Most Livable City in the United States by three different publications. Through our research and advocacy, we aim to be the go-to resource for developers and businesses looking at Downtown as the Center of Opportunity.The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership is committed to knowing the people, businesses and organizations of Downtown, and supporting their efforts to grow the residential and commercial investments underway. We will continue to advance initiatives that foster economic vitality and improve life in Our Essential Downtown, and appreciate your support of this endeavor. Jeremy T. Waldrup President & CEO Thomas J. Harrington Chairman of the Board PITTSBURGH The Most Livable U.S. City - The Economist (29th worldwide) 2011, 2009; Forbes 2010; Places Rated Almanac 2007, 1985 “Pittsburgh certainly is one of the most remarkable examples of a city that has re-engineered itself.” – Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, 2010 “Pittsburgh stands as a bold example of how to create new jobs and industries while transitioning to a 21st century economy.” – President Barack Obama, 2009 “Places like Pittsburgh have shown that a city can stay vibrant as it shrinks, by redeveloping its core to attract young professionals and creative types, and by cultivating high-growth services and industries.” – Richard Florida, The Atlantic Cities, 2009 N o table R an k ings and A cc o lades nBest of the World 2012 (National Geographic Traveler Magazine, 2011) nWorld’s Most Affordable Cities – 177(Mercer, 2011) nTop 200 World Universities – 21st (CMU), 59th (Pitt) (Times of Higher Education, 2011) nAmerica’s 50 Best Bike Cities (Bicycling.com, 2011) nTop 100 List of Best Places to Live – 46th (Pittsburgh) (CNNMoney.com, 2011) n6th Most Recession-Resistant City for Real Estate (Zillow.com, 2011) n11th Highest Vitality Index Ranking (CreativeCities.org, 2011) nMost LEED Certified Projects in the Country (Pittsburgh 15th) (Green Building Alliance, 2011) n4th Best City for Working Mothers (ForbesWoman, 2011) n9th Best City in U.S. to Find a Job (Monster.com, 2011) nTop-Earning County in Pennsylvania (Allegheny County 1st) (U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, 2011) nOne of Ten Places to Retire in 2012 (U.S. News and World Report, 2011) n10th Best City for Growth in Tech Jobs (BusinessWeek.com, 2011) n10th Strongest Retail Market (Nation’s Restaurant News, 2010) n10th Best U.S. Market for Created Jobs (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2010) n4th Best City for Working Mothers (Forbes.com, 2010) n2nd Best City for Recent Graduates (Huffington Post, 2010) nNation’s Most Affordable City to Buy a Home (Forbes.com, 2010) n2nd Most Affordable U.S. City (Forbes.com, 2010) nAmerica’s 7th Best Place to Raise a Family (Forbes.com, 2010) nTop 25 Hotels in the United States – 23rd (Renaissance Pittsburgh) (TripAdvisor.com, 2010) nNation’s Most Charity-Conscious City in America (Charity Navigator, 2010) nNation’s Best City to Relocate to in America (CNBC, 2010) n20th Best in Economic Performance during the Recession (Brookings Institution, 2010) nNation’s Best U.S. Sports Cities (Sporting News Magazine, 2009) nNation’s Best U.S. Commercial Real Estate Market (Moody’s, 2009) n3rd Best U.S. City (Kiplingers, 2009) n10th Best Walking City (Prevention Magazine, 2009) n3rd Best City for Job Growth (Forbes, 2009) nTop Economic Performance (Brookings Instituion, 2009) n9th Best North American City of the Future (fDi Magazine, 2009) n6th Best City for Job Growth (Forbes, 2009) n13th Best City for Young Professionals (Forbes, 2008) E x cellence o f E n v ir o nment Downtown is a special place – the heart of the region and the center of commerce – and its patrons expect a clean and safe environment in which to visit, work and live. Their experience is the deciding factor in choosing to make a return trip or continue to invest in the core. It is imperative for property owners, business operators and the public sector to provide a high quality experience that is consistent with the vision of Downtown as essential to the health and well-being of the region. The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership (PDP) is committed to the continued vibrancy of Downtown and dedicated over 31,000 labor hours in 2011 to remove 1.1 million pounds of trash and 4,677 graffiti tags, install 150 new cigarette urns, and power wash the equivalent of 26.3 miles of sidewalks. Nearly 200 volunteers joined the PDP to perform 1,442 hours of service projects, including mowing, weeding, leaf and garbage pick-up, graffiti removal, painting and gardening within the Downtown area. Adding to the culture of an excellent environment, the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy has been instrumental in greening the streetscapes and pedestrian environments of Downtown. In 2010 and 2011 the Conservancy placed 470 planters and 420 hanging baskets, transforming Downtown streets and bridges with color and greenery. The organization depends on staff and volunteers to change seasonal plants, water planters and baskets, and is an integral partner in making Downtown a better place through their work. Downtown helps to lead the way in greening in more ways than one, with over six million square feet of LEED certified space, and another 900,000 square feet anticipated with the completion of The Tower at PNC and The Gardens at Market Square. Within Downtown is the world’s first LEED Gold convention center, the only LEED Gold NHL facility, and one of the largest green walls in North America. Pittsburgh ranks 15th in U.S. cities for the number of LEED certified projects and Pennsylvania ranks 7th amongst the fifty states, setting an example of creating excellent environments for people, while conserving natural resources. The City of Pittsburgh’s Storefront Renovation and Downtown Façade Restoration programs, together with the Paris to Pittsburgh Façade Grant through the PDP, assisted with 17 building facade improvements or restorations between 2010 and 2012. These programs are changing the face of Downtown and encourage the improvement of Downtown’s beautiful architecture while creating a safe pedestrian environment. A common misconception is that Downtown is unsafe. The total number of criminal offenses was down 29% in 2011, decreasing from 1,797 in 2010 to 1,280 offenses in 2011. Of the 24 types of offenses tracked in 2011, only two increased over 2010; embezzlement from 3 to 4 offenses, and robbery from 71 to 87 offenses. Downtown is experiencing a new energy and vibrancy that can be seen in a range of facts and figures but is also seen by people’s perception. A November 2010 survey of PDP members, residents and Downtown stakeholders sought the respondents’ perception of Downtown characteristics for the preceding 12 months. The vast majority of responses fell into the categories of “much better” or “slightly better.” Over 81% of respondents perceived that the overall vitality of Downtown improved, while 57.5% thought that Downtown safety was improved. Nearly 90% of all respondents stated Downtown maintains a strong appearance and improved over the previous 12 months. The Downtown of today is not the Downtown of a decade ago – take Market Square as a prime example. The Square’s renovation served as a major catalyst for the burgeoning restaurant scene, with people eating and enjoying the public space at all times of the day. The enhancement of public spaces and the overall Downtown environment will continue to leverage other public and private investments, and continue to build upon the economic vitality of the region. By capitalizing on the improved environment, Downtown will continue to reposition itself as a dynamic 21st century urban center. Page 5 Excellence of Environment State of Downtown Repor t By the Numbers Numbers Ranking of Pittsburgh in # of LEED certified projects investment of $400,000 Annual planters and baskets certified square 6,170,415 LEED footage in Downtown Miles of sidewalks 26.3 powerwashed in 2011 Number of cigarette butts 18,076 removed each week 52.8° Average daily temperature 15 Criminal Offenses by Month 200 140 150 100 84 50 Sources: Green Building Alliance, Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, PDP, NOAA The total number of criminal offenses were down in all but two months of 2011 over 2010 JAN DEC 2010 2011 Sources: Pittsburgh Police Deparment, PDP This island of tranquility in the middle of a bustling Downtown corridor has brought liveliness and beauty to Downtown Pittsburgh since 1955. The 1.37 acre Square is located within the Central Downtown Historic District and draws upon the significant architectural gems that surround it. Spotlight The Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy, in conjunction with the City of Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh Parking Authority, is undertaking a restoration to return Mellon Square to its former glory and make it an integral and positive part of Downtown Pittsburgh. The Parks Conservancy intends to restore the original design of landscape architect John O. Simonds and architect Dahlen K. Ritchey. Based on an original concept by Simonds and Ritchey, a new Terrace will be created on the current roof overlooking Smithfield Street. Fundraising and construction are now underway and will continue into 2013. The first phase of the Parks Conservancy’s restoration project focuses on the area from the top of the two staircases down to Smithfield Street, including the Cascade Fountain. In addition to fundraising for construction dollars, the Parks Conservancy is raising funds for the continued maintenance and management of the Square – never again allowing it to deteriorate. The Parks Conservancy and the City of Pittsburgh will jointly maintain and program the space with concerts and other activities. Photo Credit: Robert Bowden OFFICE & E M P L OY M E N T Business happens in Downtown Pittsburgh. Downtown, much like the businesses that live within it, is big enough to be impressive and small enough to be accessible. Downtown Pittsburgh is the core of the regional economy with the largest number of corporate headquarters of any other Western Pennsylvania location, providing world-class professional services and amenities that host four Fortune 500 companies in the Golden Triangle, and one in Station Square. As the region’s primary financial center, Downtown is home to the The PNC Financial Services Group, the nation’s fifth-largest bank, Federated Investors, a major operating hub for BNY Mellon, as well as such important national and regional banking institutions as Citizens Bank, Dollar Bank, Fifth Third Bank, First Niagara Financial Group, First National Bank, and Huntington Bank. It is the headquarters to some of the world’s most recognizable brands such as Alcoa, DelMonte, EQT, GNC, Heinz, Koppers Inc., PPG, StarKist, U.S. Steel, UPMC, and WESCO. Downtown Pittsburgh is the second largest employment center in Pennsylvania and as shown in the most recent Workforce Profile from 2010, is the workplace to over 126,000 employees. Two-thirds of Downtown workers are employed in the service or finance industries, with legal services accounting for 30% of the service segment workforce. The Downtown workforce represents 31.9% of the estimated workforce of 394,752 in the City of Pittsburgh, serving as the center of activity for the ten-county Pittsburgh region which, according to the 2010 census, is workplace to over 2.5 million individuals. Even as businesses continue to recover from the global recession, the region as a whole is faring better than most. Based on seasonally adjusted data, the Pittsburgh region’s December 2011 unemployment rate was 6.9%, well below Pennsylvania at 8.5%, and the national rate of 9.4%. Retail employment grew by 14% and employment in the services industry increased by 10% over 2007, even in the midst of a deep, long-lived economic recession. As unemployment rates hold steady and commercial vacancy rates decrease, it is anticipated that the number of Downtown employees is on the rise. At of the fourth quarter of 2011, the CBD Class A vacancy rate was 7.4%, while the CBD Class B rate was 15.1%. At the same time, the average lease rate in the CBD for Class A space was $23.86 per square foot while Class B averaged $17.51 per square foot. As Class A buildings continued to fill in 2011with new leases, expansions and renewals, Class A lease rates are predicted to pass $25 per square foot in next the 18-24 months and Class B lease rates are predicted to top $19.25 in the same time period. The Class B inventory continues to shrink with building conversions into other uses, such as the redevelopment of 201 Stanwix Street into residential and educational uses, the former State Office Building at 300 Liberty Avenue into Rivervue Apartments, the conversion of 200 Ross Street into residential, and the potential reuse of the upper floors of the Henry W. Oliver Building at 535 Smithfield Street into hotel space. Highlights of the Downtown commercial market in 2011 include notable high-profile property transactions with a wide range of institutional investors. An investment group led by Mark Karasick purchased the U.S. Steel Tower for $250 million, while GLL Real Estate Partners, a Munich, Germany based real estate investment fund, purchased 11 Stanwix Street for $62.8 million. Later in the year, Highwoods Properties, a publicly traded real estate investment trust from North Carolina, completed the sale of PPG Place for $180 million with plans for an additional $25 million in building and tenant upgrades. Moving into the first quarter of 2012, Health Trust of America purchased Penn Avenue Place for $54 million, continuing their fast-paced entrance into the market after the purchase of two North Shore buildings, the Alcoa Business Center and Federal North Building, for a combined $77.6 million in 2010. All of these major commercial building transactions provided greater diversity in the profile of investors that are now in Downtown Pittsburgh. Their presence is certain to attract continued national and global interest in assets within the CBD. The willingness of owners to make capital investments and improvements was the reason many high impact leases were signed in 2011. Downtown was happy to welcome Maya Design, ShowClix, and dck worldwide with new leases bringing these three growing firms into Downtown with approximately 20,000, 12,000, and 24,000 square foot spaces, respectively. The continued expansion of UMPC in the U.S. Steel Tower continues to drive demand into the tightening Class A market, while large renewals such as Federated Investors and Duquesne Light took a combined 340,000 square feet off the market for the foreseeable future. Looking further ahead into 2012, demolition is well underway at the site of the future 800,000 square foot Tower at PNC on Wood Street between Fifth and Forbes Avenues, and site preparation is anticipated to begin this summer for The Gardens at Market Square that will add approximately 100,000 square feet of Class A inventory to the CBD in 2014, in addition to retail and hotel uses. More recently announced in the Strip District is a 120,000 square foot Class A office building by The Buncher Company and the conversion of the former Wholey’s warehouse at 1501 Penn Avenue into 225,000 square feet of Class A office space and indoor parking. This combined 445,000 square feet of space may prove to be essential to the Downtown market if new lease signings and renewals continue at their current pace. Downtown has experienced a substantial amount of public and private investment over the last decade that has helped position the Golden Triangle and adjacent areas for continued investment and growth. The increasing strength of the Downtown market will continue into 2012 as more companies and corporations realize that Downtown Pittsburgh is the Center of Opportunity. Office & Employment Downtown State of Downtown Repor t CBD and Downtown Fringe Vacancy Rates Class A Class B ■ CBD Vacancy Rate ■ Fringe Vacancy Rate 16% 12% 7.4% 8% ■ CBD Vacancy Rate ■ Fringe Vacancy Rate 25% 20% 15% 10% 4% 5% 0% 4Q11 3Q11 2Q11 1Q11 4Q10 3Q10 2Q10 1Q10 4Q09 3Q09 2Q09 1Q09 4Q08 4Q11 3Q11 2Q11 1Q11 4Q10 3Q10 2Q10 1Q10 4Q09 3Q09 2Q09 1Q09 4Q08 0% Source: CBRE Research Class B ■ CBD Class A Avg Lease Rate ■ Fringe Class A Avg Lease Rate $24.01 ■ CBD Class B Avg Lease Rate ■ Fringe Class B Avg Lease Rate $26 $24 $ Per Sq. Ft. $28 $26 $24 $22 $20 $18 $16 $14 $22 $20 $18 $16 4Q11 3Q11 2Q11 1Q11 4Q10 3Q10 2Q10 1Q10 4Q11 3Q11 2Q11 1Q11 4Q10 3Q10 2Q10 $14 1Q10 $ Per Sq. Ft. CBD and Downtown Fringe Lease Rates Class A Source: CBRE Research Pittsburgh Office Market Square Footage Distribution Fortune 500 Companies in Downtown Company Rank United States Steel PNC Financial Services Group PPG Industries H.J. Heinz WESCO International 148 151 181 232 443 Revenue (millions) $17,374 $17,096 $13,423 $10,558 $5,063 Source: Fortune.com Source: CBRE Research Page 9 Office & Employment Downtown State of Downtown Repor t High Impact Sales Transactions in Downtown By the Numbers Building Buyer Price US Steel Tower Mark Karasick et. al. $250,000,000 Square Feet 2,300,000 PPG Place 11 Stanwix Street Henry W. Oliver Building Highwood Properties GLL Real Estate McKnight Realty Partners $191,600,000 $62,800,000 $12,000,000 1,524,435 429,663 468,914 High Impact Lease Transactions in Downtown Address Type Square Quarter Footage UPMC Health Plan Federated Investors Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, PC FiServ Cir, Inc Price WaterhouseCoopers LLP Edysys, Inc Kaplan Higher Education Allegheny Technologies Morgan Lewis Bockius Allegheny County McGuire Woods AECOM dck Worldwide AIG Insurance Maya Design HDH Group Littler Mendelson, PC Elias Savion First Commonwealth Highmark, Inc US Steel Tower Liberty Center Two PPG Place 912 Ft Duquesne Blvd US Steel Tower 201 Stanwix Street 933 Penn Avenue Six PPG Place One Oxford Center Frick Building EQT Plaza Gulf Tower One PPG Place EQT Plaza Four Gateway Center KL Gates Building EQT Plaza EQT Plaza Frick Building 501 Penn Avenue New Lease Renewal Renewal Renewal Renewal New Lease New Lease Renewal Renewal Renewal Renewal New Lease New Lease Renewal New Lease New Lease Renewal Renewal New Lease New Lease 267,498 240,000 105,286 95,580 81,244 78,184 57,950 44,496 36,126 34,277 32,582 27,864 23,664 20,339 19,228 18,299 16,291 16,291 15,338 15,154 Austin Boston, Dallas, New York, Seattle, San Francisco Peninsula Baltimore, Denver, San Antonio Page 10 1Q 4Q 4Q 1Q 1Q 3Q 3Q 4Q 4Q 2Q 4Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 3Q 3Q 1Q 4Q 1Q 2Q CBD and Downtown Fringe Map ■ Downtown ■ Downtown Fringe Source: CBRE Research United States Office Clock Q4 2011 PITTSBURGH, Houston, Class A Occupancy Downtown Employees PNC’s commitment to Downtown Real Estate Development Sq. Feet of Office Space Source: Fortune.com, CBRE, Grant Street Associates, PDP Name San Francisco Silicon Valley 92.6% 126,370 $725M 26.3M Sources: CBRE, Grant Street Associates – Cushman Wakefield, Jones Lang LaSalle Sources: CBRE, Grant Street Associates – Cushman Wakefield, Grubb and Ellis, Jones Lang LaSalle Numbers Fortune 500 Companies 5 Source: Jones Lang LaSalle Peaking Market Falling Market Rising Market Bottoming Market Cincinnati, Cleveland, Detroit, Westchester County Fort Lauderdale, Hampton Roads, Jacksonville, Sacramento, West Palm Beach Fairfield County, Los Angeles, New Jersey, Phoenix, San Diego, St. Louis Chicago, Charlotte, Orange County, Orlando, Raleigh-Durham Atlanta, Indianapolis, Miami, Minneapolis, Oakland-East Bay, Philadelphia, Richmond, Portland, Tampa, United States, Washington, DC Top Four Industry Classes in Downtown Services Number of Workers Legal Services Eng, Acct, Research & Mgmt. Related Srvcs Health Services Business Services Social Services Educational Services Hotels and Other Lodging Places Membership Organizations Amusement and Recreational Service Automobile Repair, Services and Parking Personal Services Motion Pictures Museums, Art Galleries Miscellaneous Services Miscellaneous Repair Services Total Finance 15,012 9,226 5,523 5,184 3,657 2,922 2,854 1,713 1,631 661 615 432 281 202 151 50,064 Number of Workers Insurance Carriers Security and Commodity Brokers and Services Depository Institutions Insurance Agents, Brokers and Services Real Estate Holding and Other Investment Offices Non-Depository Credit Institutions Total Retail Number of Workers Eating and Drinking Places Home Furniture, Furnishings and Equipment Food Stores Miscellaneous Retail Apparel and Accessory Stores General Merchandise Stores Building Materials and Garden Suppliers Automobile Dealers and Gas Service Stations Total Public Programs 5,682 2,246 1,355 1,196 429 343 93 37 11,381 Number of Workers Exec, Leg. and Gen. Govt. (Except Finance) Justice, Public Order and Safety Administration of Human Resource Programs Public Finance, Taxation and Monetary Policy Administration of Economic Programs Admin. of Environ. Quality & Housing Programs National Security and International Affairs Total Source: PDP Worker Profile, 2010 13,200 9,349 3,924 2,455 2,443 1,258 320 32,949 5,233 2,680 1,122 624 317 242 108 10,326 Spotlight After 160 years in Downtown Pittsburgh, The PNC Financial Services Group plans to stick around for the next 160 by building the world’s greenest tower to serve as its new world headquarters. Standing at 33 stories and encompassing 800,000 square feet, the Tower at PNC Plaza is expected to exceed LEED Platinum, the U.S. Green Building Council’s highest certification rating, and will reinvigorate a distressed block at Forbes Avenue and Wood Street. “While we could have invested anywhere, the improvements to Downtown Pittsburgh and the reality that young professionals, the future leaders of this region, love city life convinced us that our first home should remain home,” said James E. Rohr, chairman and chief executive officer, The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. Deconstruction and recycling of the existing buildings has begun to make way for the Tower’s anticipated completion in the summer of 2015. This is just the latest of PNC’s ‘green’ developments Downtown. The LEED certified Three PNC Plaza is another example, the completion of which helped spur additional investments along Fifth Avenue and into Market Square. PNC Firstside Center opened in 2000 as the nation’s largest, corporate green building, while the neighboring Firstside Park stands on site of a deconstructed building. Photo Credit: The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. RESIDENTIAL MARKET Downtown has been the economic epicenter for the Pittsburgh region. But unlike other major cities across the United States, the Golden Triangle never served as a major residential neighborhood, rather, catering to big business and industry. With time, this trend has reversed and residential development is rapidly growing. More apartments and condominiums are being developed as interest in urban living increases and residents continue to call the heart of the city their home. When looking at the residential sector of Greater Downtown, the geographic area is inclusive of the Golden Triangle, North Shore, Near Strip (to 26th street) and the Lower Hill/Bluff. The population according to 2010 U.S. Census estimates was approximately 7,796, up 21.3% over the 2000 population of approximately 6,425. All of the areas within Greater Downtown experienced an increase in population in 2010 over 2000. The Golden Triangle grew the most, an increase of nearly 1,000 residents, or over 33%. The 2010 U.S. Census statistics confirmed the PDP’s assessment that new and existing apartment units were not sitting empty. According to quarterly rental market surveys conducted by the PDP, the rental occupancy rate for Greater Downtown apartments hasn’t fallen below 90% since the second quarter of 2009, and has maintained an average of 94%. In that time, 219 new apartments have come online, with an additional 346 units under construction at: RiverVue (218) located at 300 Liberty Avenue, Lot 24 (96) next to the Cork Factory in the Strip District, and the expansion of Penn Garrison (32) at 915 Penn Avenue. Residential Market State of Downtown Repor t Occupancy Rate for Greater Downtown Rental Units 98% 96% 94% 93.6% 92% 90% 158 units came online at 201 Stanwix in 4Q11 The recent growth and success of Downtown living is evidenced by the increase in population and number of units. The City and Urban Redevelopment Authority continue to leverage private dollars with programs like the Upstairs Life-Safety Fund, helping to mitigate the high cost of making life-safety improvements such as fire suppressant systems and additional means of egress. The Local Economic Revitalization Tax Act (LERTA) district encourages investment by lessening the tax burden on new development. Downtown’s landscape will continue to evolve because of the investment that continues to build upon the growing residential neighborhood. Source: PDP Average Price Per Square Foot of Greater Downtown Rental Units 1.8 $1.70 1.6 1.2 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 1.4 Source: PDP Number of Greater Downtown Rental Units 2,100 2,079 2,000 1,900 1,800 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 On the condominium side, 76 units sold in 2011, consisting of 44 new and 32 re-sales, and averaging 114 days on the market. The average sales price per square foot was $208 up from $204 in 2011. New unit sales were significantly higher, averaging $280 per square foot, while re-sales averaged $131. In 2011, the completion of the Otto Milk Condominiums at 2434 Smallman Street in the Strip District brought 58 new units to the market. At the same time, work commenced on L’Enfant Lofts at 806 Penn Avenue to add six units in the Cultural District building. 86% $ Per Sq. Ft. PMC Property Group entered the Downtown residential market at the beginning of 2011 with the purchase of 201 Stanwix Street and subsequent conversion of the building into a charter school and 152 apartment units. As of the beginning of 2012, the finished building is nearly 90% leased. Their presence quickly grew with the purchase of the Penn Garrison and plans for 32 additional units to this popular Downtown address, in addition to its proposal to renovate 200 Ross Street into 100 apartment units. More recently, PMC closed on the Regional Enterprise Tower at 425 Sixth Avenue with initial plans to consolidate the 30 stories of office space to 15, adding residential units to the remaining floors. 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 88% Source: PDP Page 13 Residential Market State of Downtown Repor t Average Size of Rental Units Greater Downtown Rental Market Unit Distribution 1,736 1800 60 Sq. Ft. 1500 1,067 1200 900 600 1,145 1,280 863 528 644 300 0 983 Studio 2 1 2 1 Bedroom Bedroom Bedroom Bedroom 2 Bath + Den Larger Units 92 129 Source: PDP ■ 1 Bedroom ■ 1 Bedroom + Den ■ 2 Bedroom ■ 2 Bedroom + 2 Bath ■ Larger Units Source: PDP Primary Reason for Moving Downtown Close to Work/School Convenience/Central Location/Accessible to Everything City Living/Get Out of Suburbs Appeal of Building/Property Job Transfer/Relocation Other Cultural District and Events/the Arts Public Transportation Social/Lively/Fun Downsizing Change in Marital Status Close to Sports Events/Stadiums Change of Lifestyle Walkabililty Close to Family Members Live/Love Downtown Born There or Lived There Before Top 4 Reasons Same in 2010 & 2008 “Close to Work/School” “Convenience/Accessibility” “City Lifestyle/City Living” “Appeal of Building/Property” 0% Source: PDP Resident Profile, 2010 Page 14 10% 20% 30% 40% Greater Downtown Condominium Sales 234 Total Sales 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 ■ All Units ■ New Units ■ Re-Sales Source: PDP, West Penn Multi-List A new, local development company dove deep into the Downtown residential market in 2011 with the purchase of three construction-ready buildings. Penn Renaissance, LP started in April with a six-unit residential conversion at 806 Penn Avenue, now known as L’Enfant Lofts. Average Sales $ Per Square Foot for Greater Downtown condominiums $500 $400 $300 $208 $158 $116 $200 $100 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 $0 ■ All Units ■ New Units ■ Re-Sales Source: PDP, West Penn Multi-List Satisfaction Rate with Downtown Living Percent of Residents 60% 50.5% 50% 40% 1 = Not Satisfied at All 9 = Very Satisfied 30% Spotlight 22.5% While still working on the 1,650 square foot units, each encompassing the entire floor of the slender building, Penn Renaissance jumped at the opportunity to redevelop a visibly neglected eight-story building at 524 Penn into a mix of one- and two-bedroom units with restaurant and retail spaces on the first two floors. The units will range in price from $150,000 to $470,000 and will bring a population of residents to the other end of Penn Avenue at a lower price point than other available new condominiums around Downtown. “As a Downtown resident, I spend a lot of time accidentally stumbling upon opportunities and then thinking about how they fit into our residential mix,” says Todd Palcic, owner of Penn Renaissance, LP. “Clearly, we found a need for entry-level condos for those committed to spending their young lives to live, work and play Downtown. The margins are tighter, but we were fortunate enough to find three buildings that were distressed or unwanted – making them economically viable.” 20% 10% 0% 1 2 3 4 Source: PDP Resident Profile, 2010 5 6 7 8 9 With no intent on slowing down, Penn Renaissance says work will begin later in 2012 on the conversion of 907/909 Penn Avenue into 28 loft apartments, with the bottom two floors devoted to restaurant space. R E staurants and retail In March of 2011, Nation’s Restaurant News released a study of the nation’s healthiest retail markets as an analysis of vacancy rates, rental rates, unemployment and the housing market. Pittsburgh ranked tenth behind markets like Washington, D.C., New York City, San Diego and Seattle. Downtown continues to feed the masses with the latest count of over 300 dining establishments in Greater Downtown, including 180 with evening and weekend hours. Helping to reestablish Downtown as the predominant nighttime destination in 2011 was the first full year of Market Square’s reopening. After 14 months of construction, a long list of new restaurants opened, ten in 2011 alone, including Noodles & Co., Winghart’s Burger and Whiskey Bar, Diamond Market Grille, and La Cucina Flegrea, all of which have outdoor dining. Since 2007, the PDP has awarded more than $800,000 in matching grants to 41 restaurants through the Paris to Pittsburgh program, encouraging inviting outdoor dining elements such as retractable awnings, tables and chairs, new lighting and landscaping. Around the same time that Market Square started to flourish, Fifth Avenue between Wood and Liberty transformed into an upscale, predominantly men’s, fashion destination with Heinz Healey’s, Larrimor’s and the Nettleton Shop. The Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, in partnership with the URA, hopes to capitalize on this success to create a women’s boutique destination as a part of the Downtown Preservation Project to restore buildings along the Fifth and Wood corridors. After more than 60 years in Downtown, Saks Fifth Avenue closed its doors in mid-March 2012. A month before the Saks closure was announced, Macy’s released plans to consolidate their current footprint, downsizing the store from 12 floors to six, in an effort to reconfigure the store for better flow. The 86,000 square feet in the former Saks building and the 250,000 square feet now available in the Macy’s building add to the 130,000 square feet available in the vacant Lord and Taylor store, for a total of 466,000 square feet of vacant department store space along Smithfield Street. Downtown’s growth and continued evolution will cause retail vacancy to decrease as underutilized buildings are taken out of the market. Half of a city block of vacant and visibly run-down buildings were sold to The PNC Financial Services Group for the construction of a new headquarters. Diagonal from that development, Millcraft Industries is finalizing plans for The Gardens at Market Square a $76.6 million mixed-use office and hotel project. Both of these new Class A buildings will feature upscale retail options, with 25,000 square feet of space at The Gardens and an undetermined amount at the Tower at PNC. These projects will concentrate a large daily population in the area that will have a tremendous impact on the retail sector. Downtown workers and businesspeople spend $102 per week, on average, at Downtown establishments, and $56 on food and beverage alone. The Mayor’s office is helping to set the future of Downtown retail on two fronts, the first through Project Pop-Up: Downtown (PPU:D), a project in partnership with the PDP and URA that brings temporary retail stores and art installations to Downtown, including a book store and craft cooperative. The second is the Downtown Retail Attraction and Retention task-force that will create a three-year action plan to revitalize Downtown retail through a branding campaign, urban design enhancements to the public realm, and attraction and retention efforts. The group is comprised of property owners, the brokerage community, retailers, and Downtown stakeholders, including the PDP. Promoting a vibrant restaurant and retail scene is critical to an engaging Downtown, and these endeavors will help to support the economic vitality of an evolving CBD. Spending by Type of Pedestrian Average Total Weekly Amount $200 $150 $100 $50 $0 $183 ■ Retail ■ Services $34 $18 $55 $131 $17 $12 $45 $76 $57 $121 $36 $6 $35 $44 ■ Food & Bev ■ Entertainment $102 $16 $4 $56 $27 Resident Shopping Entertain- Work/ ment Business $44 $5 $5 $22 $14 School Source: PDP Pedestrian Study 2010 Page 17 Restaurants & Retail State of Downtown Repor t Improving Downtown Dining Residents’ Ideas for Improving Their DT Dining Experience Stay Open Later/Weekends More Casual/Family/Chains More Ethnic Options More Mid-Price/Moderate $ More Variety/Choices More Healthy/Organic/Vegtrn Other More Outdoor Places More Fast Food Better Parking More Breakfast/Brunch More Upscale Choices More Bars/Sport Bars More Take-Out Choices More Clubs/Entertainment Less Fast F/Chains/Stk House More Delivery Choices Need BYOB Places Based upon the top mentions, residents will support and patronize mid-priced, casual restaurants that stay open late and on weekends. 10% Source: PDP Pedestrian Study, 2010 20% Downtown Anchor Retail Total Sq. Ft Sq. Ft Sq. Ft Occupied Available Macy's 750,000 Burlington Coat 155,000 Factory Lord & Taylor* 130,000 Saks Fifth 86,000 Avenue** Brooks Brothers 27,000 TOTAL 1,148,000 Includes mentions such as: “American Comfort Food” “Like Union Grill in Oakland” “Eat N Park,” “Panera” 0% Downtown Anchor Retail Space 30% 500,000 155,000 250,000 - - 130,000 86,000 27,000 682,000 466,000 *Lord & Taylor closed in 11/04 ** Saks Fifth Avenue closed in 3/12 Source: Pittsburgh Regional Alliance, PDP Greater Downtown Retail Establishments Dining Shops Services 313 197 148 Source: PDP Since the completion of the Square, Downtown visitors have noticed the positive transformation and numerous new businesses to frequent and enjoy throughout the year. The new design of the Square has received regional and national recognition as a great public space and is now host to more events than it has ever seen. The improvements within the space have also served as a major catalyst for the burgeoning restaurant scene, with people eating and enjoying the public space. Spotlight Sixteen new restaurants. Hundreds of new residences. The Market Square renovation, a $5 million improvement project spearheaded by Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, has become a major stimulant for private investment in and around the Square. What was once a place the public avoided has become a Downtown destination at all hours of the day. In an effort to continue the momentum of Market Square throughout the rest of Downtown, the City, the URA and the PDP implemented a new program to activate vacant properties via Project Pop Up: Downtown. Since November 2011, seven storefronts have been activated, including the popular Fraley’s Robot Repair, Awesome Books, and Boutique 208. Property owners generously donated space for a six to twelve month term for use by the participants. PPU:D has provided grants of up to $10,000 to fund eleven projects in the Golden Triangle. A curatorial committee, organized by the Greater Pittsburgh Arts Council, selected the finalists from a field of 90 applicants based on their innovative approach through the use of retail, pop-up art, education, performance, or any such combination. VISITING & E N T E R TA I N M E N T If the recent performance of the hospitality and entertainment industries is an indicator of the recession’s end, Pittsburgh is coming out on top. National research has shown that discretionary spending during the global recession dropped to a level lower than any previous economic downturn. But by looking at attendance numbers and hotel sales year over year, visitors and locals are finding Downtown to be the perfect getaway in a tough economic climate. The entire region benefited from the major stories and accolades about Pittsburgh that were featured nationally. In 2011, VisitPittsburgh hosted travel writers and broadcast media, resulting in stories being placed in AAA World, Miami Herald, The Washington Times and American Style magazine, to name a few. These stories become a major player in the tourism industry by continuing momentum and adding to the $4.7 billion in visitor spending in the Pittsburgh region on over 27 million trips in 2009. Pittsburgh hotels continued to perform at an exceptionally high level. VisitPittsburgh and Smith Travel Research report that the Pittsburgh market’s overall occupancy rate of 68.2% in 2011 was the highest in our competitive set, and significantly above the national average of 60%. In addition, 2011 marked the highest occupancy rate in more than 10 years for Pittsburgh area hotels. More specifically, Downtown occupancy peaked at 80.2% in October and averaged 65.1% for 2011, up from 64% in 2010. Downtown conventions and events continued to support the regions’ hotels and restaurants. Among the many major conventions and events held Downtown in 2011 was the National Rifle Association national conference that brought 71,000 attendees to Pittsburgh over a three day period with nearly $24 million in direct spending. The NHL Winter Classic hosted at Heinz Field on New Year’s Day accounted for $22 million in direct spending while the six-day Mennonite Church USA convention led to $9.7 million in direct spending. The NRA and Mennonite Church conventions helped the David L. Lawrence Convention Center attract a 2011 event attendance of 506,118, exceeding its 2009 attendance of 500,390 after a drop in 2010 to 382,234, due to fewer bookings during the recession. Between visitors keeping themselves occupied and local residents spending time Downtown, nearly 6 million people attended over 2,528 Greater Downtown events in 2011. Downtown performing arts venues alone hosted over 2,300 events with an audience of 1.3 million, up 4% over 2010. Helping the attendance numbers grow is the ability of the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust to attract big name touring productions such as WICKED and War Horse, both having arrived at Downtown venues in 2011. The three professional sports venues within Greater Downtown are also important to the Pittsburgh economy, hosting a combined 220 events with 4.4 million attendees in 2011. Downtown events such as First Night®, the Pittsburgh Three Rivers Arts Festival and Light Up Night® have become major draws for people from the region.The 51st Duquesne Light Light Up Night® and the following day Horse-Drawn Carriage Parade entertained more than 800,000 people combined, with an estimated economic impact of over $21 million for the 2011 holiday season. Downtown Pittsburgh’s premier holiday celebration is one of the largest in the country and continues to attract a growing number of visitors as we welcome the holiday season. Visitors and residents alike can find the perfect getaway in Downtown, and VisitPittsburgh and the Allegheny Conference are making sure others know through an aggressive marketing campaign. “Best of the World” will promote Pittsburgh and its specific offerings in performing and visual arts, outdoor activities and children-oriented activities to outside markets. Downtown and the Pittsburgh region continues to be seen as a must-see place to visit. Page 20 Source: VisitPittsburgh Competitive Set United States Comp Set Average Louisville, KY-IN Cincinnati, OH-KY-IN Cleveland, OH Indianapolis, IN Memphis,TN-AR-MS 2011 OCCUPANCY Milwaukee, WI Columbus, OH Detroit, MI Charlotte, NC-SC Baltimore, MD Sheraton Station Square Wyndham Grand Pittsburgh Downtown Fairmont Pittsburgh Renaissance Pittsburgh Hotel Courtyard Pittsburgh Downtown The Westin Convention Center Hotel Hampton Inn & Suites Downtown Omni William Penn Hotel Doubletree by Hilton Hotel & Suites Pittsburgh City Center Pittsburgh Marriott City Center Cambria Suites Pittsburgh at Consol Hyatt Place Pittsburgh – North Shore Residence Inn Pittsburgh – North Shore SpringHill Suites Pittsburgh – North Shore Philadelphia, PA-NJ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 100% 2011 Pittsburgh Market 90% Hotel Occupancy vs. 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Pittsburgh, PA Greater Downtown Hotels Visiting Downtown & Entertainment State of Downtown Repor t Percent Occupancy for Downtown Hotels 2010 vs. 2011 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% David L. Lawrence Convention Center ■ 2010 Halls 2 Hall D Certified Square Footage 76,206 38,109 Hall E Second Floor 3 Hall A Hall B Hall C 38,097 236,900 109,000 82,450 45,100 ■ 2011 First Floor JAN DEC Third Floor Source: VisitPittsburgh, Smith Travel Research Average Daily Rate for Downtown Hotels $180 $160 $140 $120 $100 $80 $60 $40 $20 $0 ■ 2010 3 Ballroom A Ballroom B Ballroom C 38 Meeting Rooms Total 33,058 16,244 8,299 8,515 346,164 ■ 2011 Conventions, Tradeshows and Events Year Events Attendance Total Visitors JAN DEC 2009 2010 183 176 500,390 382,234 764,837 633,042 2011 185 506,118 760,106 Source: David L. Lawrence Convention Center Source: VisitPittsburgh, Smith Travel Research Downtown Performing Arts Venues and Attendance Benedum Center Byham Theater Cabaret at Theater Square Heinz Hall O'Reilly Theater Harris Theater Trust Arts Education Center August Wilson Center Total 2010 Attendance 611,833 128,200 92,310 311,421 78,339 14,198 14,400 52,000 1,302,701 Downtown Arts and Entertainment Venues 2011 Attendance 648,725 149,673 92,049 327,540 80,423 14,100 9,000 33,560 1,355,070 Source: August Wilson Center, CLO, Cultural Trust, PBT, PPT, Pittsburgh Opera, Pittsburgh Filmmakers, PSO • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 707/709 Penn Gallery Art Institute of Pittsburgh Gallery of Art Bricolage Production Company CAPA Gallery Carnegie Science Center/Highmark SportsWorks Children’s Museum of Pittsburgh Fort Pitt Museum Future Tenant: a space for art Pittsburgh Playwrights Theatre Company Senator John Heinz Regional History Center SPACE Gallery The Andy Warhol Museum The ToonSeum Wood Street Galleries Xplorion Page 21 Visiting Downtown & Entertainment State of Downtown Repor t Downtown Sports Venues and Attendance 2011 Consol Energy Center Events 120 41 Attendance 1,343,992 754,592 Other Events 79 589,400 Pittsburgh Steelers University of Pittsburgh Panthers Other Events 20 8 8 4 1,106,682 504,279 368,022 368,022 Pittsburgh Pirates 80 80 1,940,429 1,940,429 Pittsburgh Penguins Heinz Field PNC Park Source: Steelers, Pirates, Penguins, University of Pittsburgh, Consol Energy Center Spotlight Three rivers. Two Andys. One reinvented city. No wonder National Geographic Traveler named Pittsburgh among the best places in the world to experience in 2012. “On all counts, the Steel City’s transformation over the past long concluded, this western Pennsylvania city changed jobs and reclaimed major assets: a natural setting that rivals Lisbon and San Francisco, a wealth of fine art and architecture, and a quirky sense of humor,” writes the National Geographic Traveler. “To be among 20 destinations worldwide selected for this ‘Best Of’ list is incredibly exciting. Those of us who live here know that the city’s amazing amenities combine to create a tremendously desirable place to live and visit,” said Craig Davis, president and CEO of VisitPittsburgh, the official tourism promotion agency for the Pittsburgh region. In addition to the National Geographic Traveler ranking, Pittsburgh was ranked in the top ten of the best cities for sports, and as one of America’s 50 best cities for biking. These accolades continue to change the public perception of Downtown and the Pittsburgh region as a whole. Photo Credit: VisitPittsburgh Downtown’s vibrant 14-block Cultural District is home to the highest concentration of performing arts venues between New York City and Chicago. Beautifully restored performance halls and contemporary theater spaces offer more than 2,300 shows each year. Downtown’s historic Market Square – Pittsburgh’s “piazza,” an award-winning public space that is alive with restaurants, outdoor cafes and entertainment. “For Pittsburgh to be included among the world’s most outstanding destinations speaks volumes about the city’s journey over the last 30 years.” – Craig Davis, VisitPittsburgh T R A N S P O R TAT I O N Downtown Pittsburgh is the center of the region’s transportation network. With major bus routes, free rail service within the Golden Triangle and North Shore, direct national train and bus service, and easy highway access to the airport, all roads lead to and from Downtown. 279 Downtown Pittsburgh is only 16 miles, or a 20-minute drive, from Pittsburgh International Airport (PIT).With service from 13 airlines moving 8,268,440 passengers in 2011, a 1.3% increase over 2010, PIT is served by 155 flights per day to and from 37 non-stop destinations, including San Francisco, Las Vegas, Denver, Toronto, Boston and Paris. 579 s n mo E m ne es wi x th er ty Av e Mellon Square St Cli ff S Wa y Market St Wood St Av e ste rA ve Liberty Bridge Smithfield Street Bridge ge W eb l Re ed St Fo res ide P e idg Br Brid W ylie Be dfo rd Av e d Cherry Way Stanwix St Commonwealth Pl 376 t ee Str itt t ff S Blu th For tP alk ic W dem Aca 10 Station Square St r n St ory Vick u Loc yD W Carso Seit t st S Second Ave Firstside Park First Ave First Ave 376 837 z St e s Av nult Blvd of the Allies MO NO NG A H EL A R IV ER n St tso Wa McA St Third Ave Fort Pitt Blvd OH I O R IV ER Ave e giss No rth Fifth d St Forbes Ave Pl b For Fourth Ave 279 579 Fifth Ave Market Square Point State Park Mellon Green Shin ark eP or Sh erry East Sixth Ave Oliver Ave on Sq Boy r th No Ave Bigelow Blv Pe nn Av e Fif St e idg Br St th am Try St Te n qu an Six Pl Smithfield St vd Bl e ss uq ue sn yp a tB tD re e th Fo r cil gt ath t St Ce hin Ch ee S Du St St t tree ell S Colw ay rW u O CONSOL Energy Center Mag n he eg All th W as St on fro er iv yR Katz rk Plaza er sP l ve eA ntr Ce Seventh Ave Prid r Pa nt St ens Stev Ba k R St e EN Mulb th idg Br H Ave in te EG Pen n N e en Se ve n h Pl idg em Cl ht Civic Arena e eux mi St Br o ay W LL 579 th l ho rt Eig t or dS t Mario L n Te ar W be ki rt Fo A Y R E IV rty e eS aw f Bus way Br idg Ro os er Sho r on Vin Cr Ross St St az e ive Dr rs Grant St al PNC Park M e Av ny Dr ive Dr re Sho r th No Carnegie Science Center Stage AE David L. Lawrence Convention Center Ca dy An er t Heinz Field ay W oll kN uc Ch ve yA ne oo tR St t le S sda St lla be Isa in ob lR ra ne Ge St 279 he ay W at ro Sp o sin Ca Rivers Casino le da leg Al R ds ee St 65 Ar 65 le da tin d Ree 1 Mile = 20 Min. Walk or 6 Min. Bike Ride 1 /2 Mile = 10 Min. Walk or 3 Min. Bike Ride 1 /4 Mile = 5 Min. Walk or 11/2 Min. Bike Ride Ave Beaver d Fe tS ar M n so el St B St t ch Twe lfth St S ky Ra t th en ev El us nd jo Ca an ch er Parks / Riverfront Trails Taxi Stands Bike Rack Locations Bus / T Free Zone Bike & Walking Trails Subway Stop n St St Sa ay uW M L EG EN D Sma llma s on on m rs de An m S m Co th S William Penn Place Co s n mo Lib W 279 Wa ter ay ’s W fron t n re St ve eA dg Ri teen Libe ild Ch ch Ar Pl Thir t s on m m Co E Sq ny he leg Al Co N Eight airlines reported an increase in 2011 passengers with an average growth of 16% over 2010. A recent study by the Allegheny County Airport Authority indicates that the average airfare at PIT is 9.91% lower than the national average of $334.78. The success of PIT is getting noticed, PeoplExpress, a new start-up low-cost carrier, recently announced its expected entrance to PIT in September 2012 providing direct flights to Florida, Rhode Island and Virginia. Serving as the hub for Greyhound and AMTRAK service, the Grant Street Transportation Center is the major transit center for the region. Greyhound services 17 direct cities, providing access to its more than 2,300 nationwide destinations, in addition to two Direct Express routes with non-stop service to Philadelphia and New York City. The addition of Megabus to the Pittsburgh market over the past two years has provided fifteen low-cost direct destinations and the company continues to look at access to other markets. The Pittsburgh AMTRAK station services five major cities through two routes, the Capital Limited and the Pennsylvanian, with connection opportunities to other major destinations around the country. AMTRAK’s weekday ridership averaged 2,570 passengers in 2011, serving 133,855 total riders at the Downtown Pittsburgh station, making it the fifth busiest in Pennsylvania. Even with the widely used public transit network, commuters and residents have parking options in 38 garages and 31 parking lots in the Greater Downtown vicinity. Parking in the Golden Triangle can be a challenge, with many garages and lots at or near maximum capacity on a given weekday. Waiting lists of up to four years for parking leases are common at many garages within the Golden Triangle, with an average cost of $245 per month. The March opening of the North Shore Connector, now known as TPlus, provides even easier access to an additional 5,000 lower-cost parking opportunities on the North Shore. Page 24 Workers coming to Downtown from every direction now have the opportunity to park on the North Shore and use the 1.2-mile extension of the light-rail system at no additional cost to arrive at their final destination. A strong public transportation network is critical to the success and vitality of Downtown Pittsburgh, with 54% of Downtown workers using public transportation to commute to work in 2010, a 20% increase over the same measure in 2003. Of the 98 Port Authority bus routes in service per day, 83 enter Downtown. Faced with mid-year fare hikes and a 15% service reduction in March of 2011, the Port Authority only saw a 2.47% decrease in ridership in 2011 over 2010. However, Downtown is at risk of losing 35 routes entering the Golden Triangle from outlying areas due to a proposed 35% reduction of service, affecting up to 20,000 daily commuters that could take place as early as September of this year. Downtown will benefit from recently announced transportationrelated investment projects. The $3.8 million Downtown traffic light improvement project will replace and improve traffic signals and implement pedestrian crossing signals with countdown features, all added benefits to pedestrians, bikers, walkers and vehicular commuters. The Port Authority and Downtown stakeholders have recently embarked on the creation of a Downtown Circulation Study to provide recommendations to improve bus and vehicular circulation in and through Downtown. At the same time preliminary discussions and conceptual studies have begun to better connect Downtown and Oakland making travel between the two population centers more convenient and efficient with a bus rapid transit system. Whether walking the one-mile distance between the fountain at Point State Park and the Consol Energy Center, or biking along the streets and other pedestrian corridors, it is as easy to get around Downtown as it is to get to Downtown. Workday & Weekend Average Totals Weekday Ridership Weekend Ridership 2011 ridership decreased by only 2.6% over 2010, even with a 15% service reduction. Bus Ridership Rail Ridership 205,000 185,000 165,000 145,000 125,000 182,573 135,981 2009 27,500 23,250 19,000 14,750 10,500 Incline Ridership 2010 2011 23,972 11,946 2009 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 2010 2011 3,993 1,615 2009 2010 2011 Bus Routes Coming into Downtown Express 6 4 10 4 24 North South East West Total Local 14 12 24 9 59 Annual Ridership on Port Authority System Bus Rail Incline Total 2009 57,632,643 7,149,450 702,740 65,486,842 2010 55,290,371 7,012,931 644,986 62,950,298 2011 53,926,472 6,751,023 627,530 61,307,035 Source: Port Authority of Allegheny County PIT Passenger Traffic 8,800,000 8,673,014 8,500,000 8,268,440 8,200,000 7,900,000 2008 2009 2010 2011 By the Numbers Garages/Spaces/Avg Lease Cost Lots/Spaces/Avg Lease Cost Zip Cars Sheltered Bike Stations Downtown T Stations Direct Destinations via Bus Direct Destinations via Train Direct Destinations via Air Spotlight Numbers 38/25,311/$236.05 31/10,367/$210.00 21 9 7 27 9 36 On March 25, 2012, the Port Authority’s expanded light-rail system began servicing the public for the first time. Known as TPlus, the extension to the North Shore provides access to an additional 5,000 parking facilities that are of short supply in the Golden Triangle and the growing entertainment and sporting venues that call the North Shore home. Financed primarily with the help of competitive federal and state grant dollars specific to this project, the 1.2-mile extension supported about 4,000 jobs through the design and construction phases of the project, including the boring of twin tunnels under the Allegheny River and the ongoing construction of three new stations. Because of underwriting by the Pittsburgh Steelers, Rivers Casino, Pittsburgh Stadium Authority, and Alco Parking, the free-fare zone in effect within the Golden Triangle has been expanded to the North Shore. Commuters are now able to take advantage of more affordable parking options on the North Shore while quickly getting into Downtown for work. Visitors coming Downtown to attend major events at the many entertainment venues will be able to park in one location within the free-fare zone and travel quickly and easily to another. Downtown stakeholders expect that the ease of access to the North Shore, and more specifically the additional parking, will decrease the impact that the many sporting and entertainment events, in addition to weekday commuter traffic, have on Downtown traffic circulation. TPlus has expanded the boundaries of Downtown and provides opportunities for future development at “T” stations throughout the free service area. D o wnt o wn D e v el o pment As evidenced by recent national and global accolades, Pittsburgh has fared better in the global economic recession than many other cities. While access to capital was hindered locally, developers and investors found ways to keep projects alive. Downtown has seen a tremendous amount of public and private investment in the past decade. From January 2006 through December 2011 alone, over $4.8 billion worth of investment projects have been completed, are actively under construction, or have been announced in Greater Downtown. Capital investments in Downtown are important no matter the size because they show Downtown continues to evolve for a variety of users. Projects like Point Park University’s Village Park and One Fifth Avenue, a combined $8.5 million investment, change the urban fabric much like The Tower at PNC and RiverVue Apartments, which account for $445 million in total investment. 2012 has brought the start of construction on the Downtown Preservation Project, investing $9 million into key properties along the Fifth and Forbes corridor to bring the upper-floors compliant with today’s codes and façade improvements to restore the historically sensitive buildings. The number of building permits issued in Downtown has increased from 96 in 2009 to 169 in 2011. The cost of improvements recorded at the time of application dropped from $312,479,507 to $49,432,238 in the same time period; however, it is important to note the permit for the Consol Energy Center was recorded in 2009 with a cost of $220 million. Permitted projects in 2011 included sidewalk and greenscape improvements at Fifth Avenue Place and PNC Plaza, commercial space build-out at the historic Burke Building at 209 Fourth Avenue, and the conversion of 806 Penn Avenue into condominiums. Center. Announced in 2011 were the residential conversion of One Fifth Avenue, two phases of facility improvements by The Cultural Trust, and the final phase of the Point State Park renovation with the rebuilding of the iconic fountain at the point. With anticipation, Downtown awaits continued investment on the North Shore with additional retail, restaurants, and office space to supplement the popular Stage AE that was recently completed. The beginning of demolition of the Civic Arena in the Lower Hill has set the stage for what will become a 28-acre mixed-use development that bridges the gap between Downtown and the Lower Hill District. And the restoration of Mellon Square will bring back to life a much-needed public space to support the growing number of Downtown residents and visitors, while providing a much needed respite for Downtown office workers. Distribution of Active and Announced Projects $233,200,000 While Downtown also felt the tightening of the credit market that halted a few redevelopment projects, especially in the residential sector, many significant projects forged ahead and were completed in 2011, including the restoration and renovation of 308 Forbes Avenue into the Penn Avenue Fish Company with two apartments on the upper floors, Otto Milk Condominiums in the Strip District, and the official opening of the riverfront park and trail in front of the David L. Lawrence Convention $259,640,000 $201,500,000 $117,500,000 $24,400,00 $553,500,000 $806,766,000 ■ Education/Civic ■ Hotel/Entertainment ■ Mixed Use ■ Office/Retail ■ Park/Trail ■ Residential ■ Transportation Page 27 Downtown Development State of Downtown Repor t Total Complete, Active & Planned Investment Since January 2006 Percent Change in Complete Active and Announced Downtown Investment Year 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 50% Investment $3,376,238,333 $3,698,999,879 $4,478,643,333 $4,779,346,430 $4,525,782,615 $4,850,478,697 These values fluctuate as projects move into and out of the pipeline. The global economic downturn affected local projects as evidenced in the decrease in project value between 2009 and 2010. Source: PDP 40% 30% 20% Building Permit Issuance in Downtown Year #Permits 2009 96 2010 137 2011 169 $4.8 Billion Recorded Cost $312,479,507 $61,851,741 $49,432,238 Source: Bureau of Building Inspections and Department of City Planning The recorded cost for building permits in Downtown was much greater in 2009 due to the issuance of a permit for the construction of the Consol Energy Center. 10% $3.3 Billion %0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Source: PDP “It takes a community of dreamers and doers to build an Academic Village,” said Paul Hennigan, president of Point Park University. “The successes to date, and those yet to come, are a testament to our partners as we all make the Academic Village a reality.” Spotlight There’s a village under construction in Downtown Pittsburgh – the Academic Village at Point Park University, to be exact. Passersby have noticed the changing landscape along the Boulevard of the Allies and Wood Street corridor over the past year. In September 2011, Point Park University opened the Village Park, a 12,000 square foot outdoor urban space featuring a canopy of trees, plantings, a glass stair tower, dramatic water feature and a restaurant, Osteria 100, with premier indoor and outdoor seating. Photo Credit: Jim Schafer The Village Park is one of several academic and economic development projects of the Academic Village Initiative. Formerly the site of a gas station and parking lot, the Village Park continues the transformation of the Wood Street corridor into an inviting urban campus and reinvigorated neighborhood. In addition to the park, Point Park has completed the restoration and renovation of turn-of-the-century buildings along the Boulevard of the Allies into additional student housing. Other Academic Village projects include Wood Street streetscape enhancements (completed in Spring/Summer 2012), the new Pittsburgh Playhouse (to be constructed along Forbes Avenue) and a new Student and Convocation Center along the Boulevard of the Allies.With the completion of these projects, construction and design spending is expected to add nearly $280 million to the local economy and result in the creation of 3,700 full- and part-time jobs through direct and indirect spending over the lifetime of the projects. 2012 Investment Map 279 579 ns mo Co Cl iff Av e er Av e W ylie Bus way l eP Re ed St d Bigelow Blv Fo res id East Libe rty Ross St Grant St Smithfield St W eb st Ave Pen n Ave B St OFFICE & RETAIL PROJECTS Second Ave Try St Market St Be dfo rd Av e n St Mulb erry Wa y Pl fron t er ty Av e Cherry Way Stanwix St William Penn Place nA ve Pe n Lib Wood St vd Bl e sn s ue as 376 13 21st and Smallman 17 North Shore “Option Area” Development 82 Wholey Building Conversion 107 One Smithfield Street 110 The Tower at PNC Plaza 114 Burke Building 125 PPG Place Upgrades ge rid tB 99 Smithfield Street Bridge ge For t 21 Liberty Bridge yp tB re e Fo r St th Te n Commonwealth Pl t ff S ee Str Brid alk ic W Blu 376 MONONGAHEL A RIVER Pitt St e St No rth ion Mar Prid St dem Aca Fort Pitt Blvd 136 St ory Vick th W Carson 138 Firstside Park First Ave 21 Mon Wharf Trail: Switchbacks 105 Mellon Square Park 131 Allegheny Landing Park Restoration 134 Point State Park Fountain Rehabilitation 135 Point State Park Connector 10 78 First Ave 107 104 St 837 15 Civic Arena Site and Lower Hill Redevelopment 26 Cultural District River Front Development 47 The Gardens 118 Strip Produce Terminal Redevelopment 119 Strip District Development 121 PNC Triangle Building 124 811 Liberty Avenue 127 Downtown Preservation Project 137 Liberty Avenue Cigar 142 Regional Enterprise Tower on MIXED USE PROJECTS ens Stev 106 PARK & TRAIL PROJECTS r Third Ave 58 Blvd of the Allies 117 t St us Loc yD Fourth Ave 35 125 109 128 nult 77 Seit McA 116 135 O H IO RIVER Forbes Ave z St ve es A St Point State Park 110 n St tso Wa b For giss 134 47 Pl ve hA d St Market Square 579 Fift Fifth Ave 114 127 92 Mellon Green Shin Dr 279 105 Oliver Ave 121 St 53 Carnegie Science Center 137 on Sq Boy 45 ark eP 115 th gt t Fif St St am ee S x th hin t tree ell S Colw ay W r Ou CONSOL Energy Center Mag wi Six Pl Mellon Square Pl cil ve eA ntr ath 142 or dS Ce W as Ch Sixth Ave t e 15 Seventh Ave 60 101 124 129 27 45 North Shore Connector and Light Rail Stations 96 Liberty Tunnel Rehabilitation 99 10th Street Bridge Rehabilitation – Phase 1 108 Sister Bridges Rehabilitation 109 Traffic Signalization Upgrade (CBD) 128 Bus Rapid Transit Corridor 141 Allegheny Valley Commuter Rail Line eS eux mi an St St Civic Arena St Vin t Mario L th 130 120 TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS aw f 579 St Ce St th in ge Al th Katz rk Plaza er sP l 102 Cr n Te N ge rid id Br yR en h leg th en ev El lB ho igh th 26 St te en Sho r St ar W dy An EG Y ive or Sh 113 em 45 LL EN on rfr ge r th No e Cl A H V RI St 141 62 Ba rid eB sn e riv Br to ue uq tD ve yA ne oo eD on Se ve n k ar tP ER welf th rs E ay iW 17 r Fo tR rt No h hS ive Dr ore e Av ny o sin Ca Rivers Casino he ay W at ro Sp Ave Beaver Heinz Field leg s ed 45 St Al Re le da Ca idg r be sk ro 45 el David L. Lawrence Convention Center 108 Ro PNC Park e az M St ay W oll kN uc Ch Ar 65 llma on St 131 e en 279 Stage AE Wa ter rs ky us St n so bin Ro al er St l ra St ch b Isa t 13 82 103 118 119 Ra St a ell G le sda d nd Sa d Fe nt St M 65 27 The Granite Building 35 Commonwealth Building 60 L’Enfant Lofts 92 RiverVue 101 711 Penn Avenue 103 Residences at the Strip / Cork Factory II 115 One Fifth Avenue 116 201 Stanwix 117 First Avenue Townhomes 120 907 / 909 Penn Avenue 138 John P. Robin Building de s on m 73 t ar Ree ay uW jo Ca a ch er M le a ind RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS An m s on mm o SC th S IN THET STRIP DISTRICT S ma Co Ri uq W dg 77 Point Park University: Pittsburgh Playhouse Complex 78 Point Park University: Student Center 102 Connelly Building / Pittsburgh Green Innovators 106 Point Park University: Wood Street Enhancements 113 933 Penn Avenue / Kaplan Career Institute 129 Cultural Trust Facility Improvements – Phase 1 130 Cultural Trust Facility Improvements – Phase 2 279 tD St ve eA teen St s on m m Thir ay W n’s re ild Ch ch Ar EDUCATION & CIVIC PROJECTS E Sq ny he leg Al N E m Co 96 Station Square 376 837 } $4,996,878,697 E Carson PROJECTS COMPLETED $2,800,372,697 PROJECTS ACTIVE $590,616,000 PROJECTS ANNOUNCED $1,605,890,000 * This ongoing list represents active and publicly announced projects in Downtown Pittsburgh as of 12/31/11. The study area includes the Golden Triangle, North Shore, South Shore, Lower Hill/Uptown, and the Near Strip (to 26th Street). Projects are listed in three categories. Announced: meaning a project has been publicly announced and/or a construction schedule has been determined and due diligence is under way. Active: meaning ground has been broken. Completed: meaning there is no longer active construction at the project site. This list is compiled and maintained by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. Omissions are purely clerical, and no malice was intended. on ars EC 837 St HOTEL & ENTERTAINMENT PROJECTS St TOTAL INVESTMENTS JANUARY 2006 THROUGH DECEMBER 2011 Italic Font I Conceptual Projects Regular Font I Projects that are in Planning or Under Construction 53 Wyndham Grand Pittsburgh Renovations 58 Ross Street Kratsa Hotel Development 62 Convention Center Hotel 73 Fairfield Inn & Suites – Federal Street 104 Fort Pitt Boulevard Hotel 136 Riverhounds Stadium Acknowledgements The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership thanks the following organizations and individuals for their support in producing the 2012 State of Downtown Pittsburgh: The State of Downtown Pittsburgh was generously funded by: Supporting Sponsor INFORMATION SOURCES PDP BOARD Alco Parking Allegheny Conference on Community Development Allegheny County Airport Authority AMTRAK August Wilson Center for African American Culture BikePGH Bureau of Labor Statistics CBRE City of Pittsburgh City of Pittsburgh Bureau of Building Inspections City of Pittsburgh Department of City Planning City of Pittsburgh Police Department Consol Energy Center David L. Lawrence Convention Center DemographicsNow Fortune.com Grant Street Associates Grant Street Associates – Cushman Wakefield Green Building Alliance Greyhound Grubb and Ellis Jones Lang Lasalle Kathy Wallace Megabus NOAA Penn Renaissance, LP PGHSnap Pittsburgh Ballet Theatre Pittsburgh Business Times Pittsburgh CLO Pittsburgh Cultural Trust Pittsburgh Filmmakers Pittsburgh International Airport Pittsburgh Opera Pittsburgh Parking Authority Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy Pittsburgh Penguins Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh Public Theater Pittsburgh Steelers Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra Pittsburgh Today Point Park University Port Authority of Allegheny County Project Pop-Up: Downtown Smith Travel Research The PNC Financial Services Group Urban Redevelopment Authority VisitPittsburgh Western Pennsylvania Conservancy Western Pennsylvania Multi-List Service Zipcar Pittsburgh Thomas Harrington, Chair Grant Mason, Vice Chair William Clarkson, Jr., Treasurer E. Gerry Dudley, Secretary Jim Blue, BNY Mellon Richard Beynon, Beynon & Company Mark Broadhurst, Eat’n Park Hospitality Group Inc. Herbert Burger, Speedwell Enterprises Jamie Campolongo, Pittsburgh Transportation Group David Case, Production Masters, Inc. Kevin Clarke, Grubb & Ellis Company Debra Donley, Hertz Gateway Center Eric Feder, Allegheny County Mariann Geyer, Point Park University David Gleason, First Lutheran Church Thomas Grealish, Henderson Brothers, Inc. Andre Kimo Stone Guess, August Wilson Center for African American Culture Melanie Harrington, Vibrant Pittsburgh Larry Jackson, Acusis, LLC John Java, BNY Mellon Kevin Joyce, The Carlton Restaurant R. Daniel Lavelle, City of Pittsburgh Kathleen McKenzie, West Penn Allegheny Health System Barbara McMahon, Renaissance Pittsburgh Hotel Kevin McMahon, Pittsburgh Trust for Cultural Resources Clare Meehan, AlphaGraphics Tom Michael, Larrimor`s Romel Nicholas, Sr. , Gaitens, Tucceri & Nicholas, P.C. David Onorato, Pittsburgh Parking Authority Joseph Petak, CB Richard Ellis Lucas Piatt, Millcraft Industries John Roach, Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC F. Brooks Robinson, Jr. , Commonwealth of PA, Office of the Governor Janice Smith, Cohen & Grigsby, P.C. Merrill Stabile, ALCO Parking Corporation J. Randall Staggers, Highmark Craig Stambaugh, UPMC Aaron Stauber, Rugby Realty Company, Inc. Kyra Straussman, Urban Redevelopment Authority of Pittsburgh Thomas VanKirk, Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney Jake Wheatley, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania George Whitmer, PNC Bank Yarone Zober, City of Pittsburgh PDP STAFF Jeremy Waldrup, President and CEO Lucinda G. Beattie, Vice President of Transportation Brooke M. Fornalczyk, Director, Marketing and Communications Robyn L. Williams, CPA, CMA, Director of Finance Kathleen Zawrotniak, Program and Events Manager Geof Comings, Economic Development Manager Brian Kurtz, Research Project Manager Lynda Fairbrother, Administrative Assistant Paul J. Hochendoner, Manager, PDP Clean and Street Team Programs Photography: All photography is by John Altdorfer, unless otherwise noted Graphic Design: FSC Marketing + Digital For Errata,Visit: DowntownPittsburgh.com/SODP Page 29 Downtown is essential to the region – the metropolitan heartbeat where business, culture and entertainment intersect. THE CENTER OF OPPORTUNITY Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership 925 Liberty Avenue, 4th Floor Pittsburgh PA, 15222 www.DowntownPittsburgh.com