Five Year Conservation and Demand

 Five Year Conservation and Demand Management Plan 2014-­‐2018 Prepared June 2014 by: Property Management, City of Belleville & VIP Energy Services Inc. With the Support of The City of Belleville Council After filling below items; •
•
select all (ctrl+a) and hit “F9”, then select all text on this page and put font color to white City of Belleville The City Municipality Table of Contents 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................. 1 2 KEY COMPONENTS ....................................................................................................... 3 3 HISTORICAL ENERGY MANAGEMENT .......................................................................... 6 4 CURRENT STATE OF CORPORATE ENERGY ................................................................... 8 5 CURRENT ENERGY CONCERNS ................................................................................... 10 6 SCOPE OF THE CDM PLAN .......................................................................................... 11 7 ENERGY BASELINE AND CURRENT ENERGY PERFORMANCE ...................................... 12 8 MISSION AND VISION ................................................................................................. 17 9 GOALS AND OBJECTIVES ............................................................................................ 19 10 ENERGY MANAGEMENT TEAM .................................................................................. 21 11 FINANCIAL ASSESSMENT ............................................................................................ 22 12 CORPORATE ENERGY BUDGET ................................................................................... 23 13 ENERGY MANAGEMENT ACTIONS ............................................................................. 24 APPENDIX A Energy Data ............................................................................................... 30 APPENDIX B Energy Use Breakdown ............................................................................. 33 APPENDIX C Energy Conservation Measure Schedules ................................................. 35 1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Ontario Provincial Government has committed to help public agencies better understand and manage their energy consumption. As part of this commitment, Ontario Regulation 397/11 under the Green Energy Act 2009 requires public agencies, including municipalities, municipal service boards, school boards, universities, colleges and hospitals to report on their energy consumption and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions annually beginning in 2013, and to develop and implement energy Conservation and Demand Management (CDM) Plans starting in 2014. The purpose of the City of Belleville’s (The City) energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan is to develop a framework for the City of Belleville to understand the historical impact of its operations on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and to take action by setting GHG reduction targets. The first objective of this report was the development of an energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan that addressed the facets of energy consumption in the community, for both corporate and community based assets. This included the development of a GHG emissions inventory, benchmarking the City of Belleville's existing energy intensity performance relative to other jurisdictions, identifying potential energy efficiency projects, and establishing a GHG emissions reduction target. This strategic approach to energy management (“energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan”) supports the City of Belleville’s Strategic Plan 2012-­‐2032. Energy efficiency and the wise use of energy are two of the lowest cost options for meeting energy demands, while providing many other environmental, economic and social benefits, including reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, cost avoidance and savings. Along with the aforementioned benefits, energy efficiencies and the wise use of energy also promote local economic development opportunities, energy system reliability, improved energy supply security, and reduced price volatility. There are a variety of low cost/no cost initiatives available to the City of Belleville, which can jump-­‐start energy consumption and dollar savings. Simple actions such as turning lights and appliances off, shutting off heaters in the summer, establishing efficient usage times, efficient production requirements, and many other actions can result in energy savings. Such actions, along with energy efficient capital and operating process improvements and project implementation, are key components, which are outlined within the energy Conservation, and Demand Management Plan (CDM Plan). This CDM Plan is the culmination of a non-­‐linear process involving the: •
Integration of establishing a baseline for performance to be measured against, •
Setting of future performance goals and objectives, •
Continuous improvement through identification of energy conservation potential, •
Strategic alignment of measure implementation and fiscal constraints, and Page | 1 •
Evaluation, measurement and communication of results achieved. This CDM Plan contains three perspectives: historical, current and future. It looks at “what we have done”, “what we are doing”, and “what are we planning to do”. The City has developed a prioritized list of potential energy savings measures based on a series of facility energy audits. These measures are broken down into A, B and C priority projects based on cost and potential simple payback calculations. The City will use this list to implement strategies to reduce energy use over the next five years as funding is available. The complete list is found in Appendix C. Page | 2 2
KEY COMPONENTS The Big Picture Sustainability is a concept which meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own, needs. This is sometimes referred to as the “triple bottom line”. •
Environmental Sustainability: Managing the effects of human activity so that it does not permanently harm the natural environment. •
Economic Sustainability: Managing the financial transactions associated with human activities so that they can be sustained over the long term without incurring unacceptable human hardship. •
Social/Cultural Sustainability: Allowing human activity to proceed in such a way that social relationships between people and the many different cultures around the world are not adversely affected or irreversibly degraded. An Energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan is the sum of measures planned and carried out to achieve the objective of using the minimal possible energy while maintaining the comfort levels (in offices or dwellings) and production rates (in factories). It can be applied to any process or building where energy use is required. To make an efficient use of the energy and, as a consequence, to save it, the actions are focused on: •
Energy Conservation, •
Energy Recovery, •
Energy Substitution, •
Corporate Goals and Objectives, and •
Corporate Fiscal Management. Analysis and Benchmarking It is important to recognize the value of benchmarking and comparison as a starting point. By examining the Municipality’s current energy consumption patterns and comparing them with others, a better understanding of the opportunities and the pitfalls of energy conservation and sustainability planning as experienced by other public agencies is gained. This exposure, combined with the information gleaned from the energy audits, will allow The City to focus on strategies that have been proven successful elsewhere and can be tailored to the unique nature of the City. It is apparent that energy conservation is being considered and implemented in most Public Sectors across Ontario and Canada. While the Ontario government, in particular, has set guidelines for what they consider a ‘Green’ community to be, there are still opportunities for the City of Belleville to mold these definitions into a strategy to achieve a viable CDM plan. As well, the insights gained through their Page | 3 experiences with energy conservation can be used as a springboard to further The City’s sustainability strategies to encompass both operational and policy improvements. Many public agencies are taking their understanding of environmental issues and conservation beyond energy consumption and recycling, by addressing the more complex issues of water management, heat island effect, and light pollution, to name a few. Regulatory Requirements Under Ontario Regulation 397/11 (Part of the Green Energy Act, 2009), all public sector agencies must now comply with mandatory reporting requirements. By 2013, all energy consumption at Municipality facilities will have to be recorded and submitted to the Ministry annually. By 2014, the requirements become more stringent as the City will have to submit a CDM Plan, which encompasses measures taken to date with results, as well as a five year plan for further energy conservation measures to be implemented. The City is well positioned to meet this requirement as audits have been completed at most facilities, resulting in a compiled list of energy reduction projects, some of which are already implemented. The full list is reviewed throughout this Plan while the implementation program is outlined later in this report. This Plan itself is meant to serve as The City’s CDM Plan and will help assist The City to meet all of its mandatory reporting requirements. Key Factors and Constraints It is important to both The City’s future and to its image in the public at large to understand the value of a comprehensive CDM Plan. Many people around the world are beginning to embrace the notion that the earth’s environment and precious resources need to be conserved. However, the necessary changes will not happen overnight. To be successful, a comprehensive energy management plan should embrace long-­‐term thinking, taking advantage of “low hanging fruit” to achieve immediate cost savings which will be redirected to more complex projects involving higher initial costs with larger net benefits. Public agencies should realize that each of their circumstances is unique and may not lend themselves to ‘boiler plate’ solutions used in many private sector segments. Those who have met their goals have utilized the advantages of the unique physical and non-­‐physical attributes of their facilities, including green power generation on large flat roofs and community gardens on their large properties. While it is easy to be focused on the larger solutions, even seemingly small efforts can make a major long-­‐term impact on the overall goal. A good example of this is Energy Awareness training which encourages Staff to take simple and effective actions such as turning off lights and computers when not in use. Ongoing professional development is also a key factor in the success of a CDM Plan to ensure that Staff Members understand their role in the greater goal. The CDM Plan and accompanying education should be a required part of their daily activities. Page | 4 While realities of budget restrictions are an important consideration in any planning activity, it is possible to achieve energy savings while adhering to the financial constraints of a publicly-­‐funded Municipality system. As Municipalities are generally the closest entities to the constituents, it is important to be viewed as a leader in Energy Conservation while ensuring that financial responsibility remains an important part of any implementation program. It is clear that new technology and ideology changes have produced continued operational cost reductions while improving indoor comfort and environmental sustainability. These cost saving projects can often fund themselves by avoiding the use of previously allocated funds. As long as the savings are reinvested, these improvements can continue for the foreseeable future, ensuring a sustainable process. Many industries have had environmental programs running for over a decade and continue to hit their 3%-­‐5% intensity reduction goals without sacrificing product quality. Page | 5 3
HISTORICAL ENERGY MANAGEMENT Historically, The City has addressed Energy Conservation and Demand Management on a project-­‐by-­‐
project basis through the activities of the Property Management Division of the Recreation, Culture and Community Services Group. Capital projects were implemented based on equipment’s expected useful life or in response to equipment emergency breakdowns. Utility savings, realized as a result of the implementation of these individual projects, have not historically been uniquely reported formally, but have been considered as a component of general operations. Thus, they have been reported through utility expenses in the Accounting System. Sustainability and long-­‐term energy reduction goals, through this CDM Plan, will become integral components of the business reporting system. Utility costs were viewed as a fixed overhead cost. The management of these costs relied on an exception-­‐based investigation approach. In other words, utility costs were only reviewed if a utility bill was much higher, or lower, than typical. In 2013, The City embarked upon a strategic energy auditing project. This effort is ongoing. The purpose of these audits was to identify and analyze potential energy conservation and demand management opportunities. These efforts have been instrumental in assisting The City in aligning the CDM Plan with the Municipality’s Strategic Plan 2012-­‐2032. Page | 6 Historical Energy Reduction Projects Summary Year Facility Police Services Building 2011 2012 Action Taken Replaced all T12 lighting with energy efficient T8 lighting. Installed a solar heated HVAC fresh air intake Replaced 5 HVAC roof top units with energy efficient units.
Thurlow Community Centre Replaced 2 HVAC roof top units with energy efficient units. Various All roofing replacements included increased insulation for heating and cooling savings. Transit Terminal Installed a 10K MicroFit Solar Photo Voltaic System.
Canteens, Community Centres and City Offices Replaced T12 lighting with energy efficient T8 lighting in Canteens, Community Centres and City offices. Meyers Pier Installed a 10K MicroFit Solar Photo Voltaic System. 179-­‐185 Pinnacle Street Replaced an HVAC roof top unit with an energy efficient unit. Various All roofing replacements included increased insulation for heating and cooling savings. Quinte Sports and Wellness Installed a 499K Fit Solar Photo Voltaic System. Centre Gerry Masterson Thurlow Community Centre Replaced an HVAC roof top unit with an energy efficient unit. Replaced T12 lighting with energy efficient T8 lighting. 2013 Gilead Hall Community Centre Joe Angelo Public Works Quinte Rowing Club Various Replaced old furnace and air conditioning unit with energy efficient system. Replaced T12 lighting with energy efficient T8 lighting. Replaced old gas boiler with energy efficient boiler system. Replaced T12 lighting with energy efficient T8 lighting. All roofing replacements included increased insulation for heating and cooling savings. Page | 7 4
CURRENT STATE OF CORPORATE ENERGY Energy Data Management While The City has an admirable history of managing its energy consumption, the Ontario government has required an increase in Municipality energy management practices. This has resulted in the need to enhance current practices and develop new approaches. To meet this need, The City will design a comprehensive program for collecting and analyzing monthly energy billing information, and ensuring Staff is informed about energy consumption. This effort will produce an energy costs and consumption database that will be used for monitoring excessive variations, targeting facility follow-­‐up evaluations, and highlighting areas that could be candidates for improved conservation. These monitoring enhancements will improve The City’s understanding of the bottom line impact of energy management. Energy Supply Management The City has currently adopted a strategy of procuring its electricity from two sources. The City has chosen to contract its natural gas through the AMO LAS program. This strategy is reviewed annually during the budgeting process. Service Provider Electrical Energy Supply Facilities Veridian Connections Inc. Archives Building (Church), Arena -­‐ Dick Ellis, Arena – Memorial, Belleville Public Library, City Hall, City Professional Building, Club -­‐ Rowing – Indoor, Club -­‐ Tennis – Outdoor, Community Centre -­‐ Elderly Person, Community Centre – Hillcrest, Community Centre -­‐ Opportunity Shop, Community Centre – Parkdale, Fire Hall #1, Fire Hall #2, Glanmore National Historic Site, Kinsmen Pool and Hall, Meyers Pier, Parks Building (North Parks), Police Services Facility, Property Maintenance-­‐ Sidney Smith, Public Utilities & Veridian -­‐ N. Britton, PW -­‐ Joe Angelo Operations Centre, Quinte Exhibition and Raceway, Quinte Sports Centre, Transit Garage, Transit Terminal, Water Treatment Plant Hydro One Networks Inc. Archives Building (Cannifton), Canteens -­‐Thurlow, Fire Hall #3, Fire Hall #4, Parks Building (Ritz), Pump House, Street Lights and Signals Energy Use in Facilities The City Staff Members have retained a great deal of knowledge with regard to their facilities’ energy use. This knowledge base has been enhanced by a series of comprehensive audits completed at the The City’s facilities. Through the deployment of energy management software, The City Staff will be equipped with the information necessary to make effective energy management decisions. This will make it possible to implement an effective energy procurement process, pursue appropriate capital projects, and implement successful conservation and demand management programs. Page | 8 Equipment Efficiency The City has pursued many measures to improve the energy efficiency of the City equipment. Some of these measures include: •
Heating and cooling equipment retrofits, •
Building envelope improvements, •
Electrical systems upgrade, and •
The pursuit of the feasibility of solar thermal and solar photovoltaic applications. As the understanding of corporate energy consumption improves, The City Staff will be equipped with the knowledge necessary to make informed decisions. This improved understanding will also reveal how simple actions like commissioning and maintenance procedures can improve existing equipment efficiencies. Organizational Integration Day to day management of energy has been primarily the responsibility of the The City Property Manager. Current practices will be enhanced with future plans including: •
The creation of an interdepartmental energy management team, •
Improved energy monitoring and feedback, and •
Interactive energy training and awareness. Staff across all departments will be given the necessary tools to address corporate energy concerns such as budgeting, procurement, conservation, and generation. Prior to the development of the CDM Plan, VIP assessed The City’s energy management practices. This assessment was completed by speaking to The City Staff and reviewing relevant City material. Upon completion of this review, VIP determined that The City had provided Staff Members with a mandate to pursue proper energy management, and through The City Staff ingenuity, The City was able to direct resources to energy management. However, VIP also noted that if The City is to achieve the Ministry’s mandate, it will require the development of this CDM Plan that will address The City’s energy management needs. Page | 9 5
CURRENT ENERGY CONCERNS Environmental, societal, and fiscal pressures accentuate the need for an energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan (CDM Plan). Environmental Concerns surrounding energy consumption with regard to climate change and air pollution have been well documented. Since 1990, Ontario’s greenhouse gas emissions have increased 14%. The Government of Ontario estimates that 75% of Ontario’s greenhouse gas emissions are associated with the consumption of fossil fuels for energy purposes. Increased smog and air pollution are also connected to the consumption of energy. Ontario’s electricity generation is the Province’s second largest source of sulfur dioxide and the third largest source of nitrogen oxides. These pollutants can cause irreparable harm to human health. Societal The 2003 Blackout heightened societal concerns surrounding the stability and security of our energy supply. Energy has been imbedded into most societal practices. If energy consumption is not managed appropriately, the frequency of energy interruption and the subsequent societal disruption will increase. Fiscal The fossil fuels traditionally used for the generation of energy are no longer financially accessible or environmentally acceptable. This has resulted in the promotion of renewable energy generation which comes with an additional expense. Energy costs are also anticipated to increase as Ontario’s existing energy infrastructure is taken off-­‐line or refurbished. Coming off of the lows of the 2009 recession, national electricity and natural gas prices are 27% and 21% greater than they were at the start of the decade. It is not anticipated that this upward trend will be altered in the short to medium future. The Province of Ontario has recently projected an annual 3.5% to 7.9% increase in electricity costs over the next 20 years. Natural gas is also projected to trend upward. In recent years, The City has experienced a 1% population growth in recent years. This growth pattern projected to continue into the foreseeable future. As The City grows so will The City’s environmental, societal, and fiscal energy concerns. The City recognizes that proper energy management must be pursued if these concerns are to be addressed. Page | 10 6
SCOPE OF THE CDM PLAN City of Belleville Facilities -­‐ General Information Building Name Address City Postal Code Total Floor Area (m2) Average Hours per week City Professional Building 179-­‐185 Pinnacle ST Belleville K8N 3A5 966 40 Archives Building 154 Cannifton Road Belleville K0K 1K0 234 10 Archives Building 315 Church St Belleville K8N 3C7 650 40 Arena -­‐ Dick Ellis 14 Harder Drive Belleville K8P 1H2 2,701 70 Arena -­‐ Memorial 15 Market Square Belleville K8N 1G8 4,171 40 Quinte Sports Centre 265 Cannifton Road Belleville K8N 4V8 16,165 133 Belleville Public Library 254-­‐256 Pinnacle St Belleville K8N 3B1 3,530 60 Public Utilities & Veridian -­‐ N. Britton 195 College St W Belleville K8P 2H1 2,914 40 Canteens -­‐ Thurlow 516 Harmony Rd Belleville K0K 1K0 134 49 City Hall 169 Front ST Belleville K8N 2Y8 3,292 60 Club -­‐ Tennis -­‐ Outdoor 221 Dufferin Belleville K8N 3X1 105 20 Club -­‐ Rowing -­‐ Indoor 35 Keegan Pkwy Belleville K8N 5R1 1,121 30 Community Centre -­‐ Elderly Person 116 Pinnacle Belleville K8N 3A4 521 50 Community Centre -­‐Hillcrest 69 Centre St Belleville K8N 4W6 275 20 Community Centre -­‐ Opportunity Shop 29 Market Square Belleville K8N 1G8 77 10 Community Centre -­‐ Parkdale 599 Sidney St Belleville K8P 4A5 260 25 Community Centre -­‐ Thurlow 516 Harmony Road Belleville K0K 1K0 565 25 Fire Hall #1 72 Moira St W Belleville K8P 1S5 465 168 Fire Hall #2 316 Dundas St E Belleville K8N 1E2 427 168 Fire Hall #3 658 Pointe Anne Belleville K8N 4Z4 93 20 Fire Hall #4 516 Harmony Road Belleville K0K 1K0 232 20 Glanmore National Historic Site 257 Bridge St E Belleville K8N 1P4 518 40 Kinsmen Pool and Hall 151 Dundas St E Belleville K8N 1C3 697 20 Meyers Pier 1 South Front St Belleville K8N 2Y5 695 40 Police Safety Village 131 South John St Belleville K8N 1B9 93 10 Police Services Facility 93 Dundas St E Belleville K8N 1C2 3,112 168 Property Maintenance-­‐ Sidney Smith 74 South Foster Belleville K8N 3P3 234 40 Parks Building 259 North Parks ST Belleville K8P 2Z2 791 70 Parks Building 29 Ritz Road Belleville K0K 1V0 1,858 35 PW -­‐ Joe Angelo Operations Centre 75 Wallbridge Cres Belleville K8P 1Z5 4,780 50 Quinte Exhibition and Raceway 158 Bridge St E Belleville K8P 5L6 1,382 20 Transit Garage 400 Coleman St Belleville K8P 3J4 780 50 Transit Terminal 165 Pinnacle St Belleville K8N 4A6 93 80 Yardmen & Wally Dever 265 Cannifton Road Belleville K8N 4V8 11,706 133 Water Treatment Plant Water Pollution Control Plant 2 Sidney Street 131 St Paul St Belleville K8P 3Y7 Belleville K8N 1A9 7,525 1,793 168 168 Page | 11 7
ENERGY BASELINE AND CURRENT ENERGY PERFORMANCE Effectively managing energy requires implementing appropriate energy monitoring procedures. The establishment of an accurate energy baseline is essential in this process. It will assist with energy conservation and greenhouse gas reduction target setting, energy procurement and budgeting, bill verification, energy awareness, and the selection and assessment of potential energy projects. The City, like many Municipalities, relies on its utility bills to establish its energy baseline. To date, the following City buildings have been audited: Audits Performed by VIP Energy Services, Inc. (2014) •
Belleville City Hall •
Quinte Sports Centre •
Joe Angelo Operations Centre (completion July 2014) •
Parks Building (completion July 2014) •
Transit Garage (completion July 2014) Facility Assessments performed by Burman Energy Consultants Group Inc. (2013) •
Belleville Library •
Belleville Water The audits consist of a detailed analysis of historical consumption and demand information as well as a walkthrough of the facility by a qualified energy auditor. Based on the auditor’s survey, a detailed equipment list and an energy consumption breakdown have been created, as well as a comprehensive list of potential energy conservation measures for each facility. Further audits are planned for City facilities throughout the period covered by this Plan. BASELINE PERFORMANCE (2011) The City has elected to utilize the consumption data from 2011 to represent its baseline energy consumption performance. Based on this information, and normalizing for weather conditions, the baseline energy performance may be represented by a normalization analysis. Page | 12 City of Belleville Facilities -­‐ 2011 Energy
Building Name
City Professional Building
Archives Building
Archives Building
Arena -­‐ Dick Ellis
Arena -­‐ Memorial
Quinte Sports Centre Belleville Public Library
Public Utilities & Veridian -­‐ N. Britton
Canteens -­‐ Thurlow
City Hall
Club -­‐ Tennis -­‐ Outdoor
Club -­‐ Rowing -­‐ Indoor
Community Centre -­‐ Elderly Person
Community Centre -­‐Hillcrest
Community Centre -­‐ Opportunity Shop
Community Centre -­‐ Parkdale
Community Centre -­‐ Thurlow
Fire Hall #1
Fire Hall #2
Fire Hall #3
Fire Hall #4
Glanmore National Historic Site
Kinsmen Pool and Hall
Meyers Pier
Police Safety Village
Police Services Facility
Property Maintenance-­‐ Sidney Smith
Parks Building
Parks Building
PW -­‐ Joe Angelo Operations Centre
Quinte Exhibition and Raceway
Transit Garage
Transit Terminal
Yardmen & Wally Dever
Water Treatment Plant
Water Pollution Control Plant
Annual Flow
(Mega Litres)
Total Electricity Total Natural Gas Consumption Consumption
(kWh)
(m3)
99,764 16,011
1,545 3,859
14,755 6,984
612,361 19,523
110,894 34,355
1,363,125 270,228
436,276 51,783
377,939 10,084
3,174
386,772 32,239
4,272 229
3,411
93,738 10,823
11,048 2,648
16,411
34,425 6,430
5,402
88,021 14,327
33,556 14,737
18,710
4,862
48,266 6,317
58,756 3,368
1,805
0
430,169 19,470
4,270 1,401
82,357 28,134
49,785 10,411
283,062 48,536
34,062 23
141,030 24,752
11,896 1,403
3,310,682 270,228
8482 3,930,764 137,170
11693 3,442,765 105,918
20,174 15,545,267 1,156,254
Energy GHG Emissions Intensity
(kg)
(ekWh/ft2)
38,252 26
7,419 17
14,385 13
85,899 28
73,825 11
619,949 24
132,804 26
49,301 15
254 2
91,894 21
774 6
273 0
27,961 37
5,891 13
1,313 20
14,911 37
432 1
34,129 48
30,546 41
1,497 19
9,192 21
15,805 21
11,068 13
144 0
0 0
71,225 19
2,991 8
59,780 45
23,665 8
114,409 16
2,768 2
58,080 48
3,605 27
775,754 49
573,799 67
475,672 237
3,429,666 34
Energy Intensity
(GJ/m2)
1.01
0.66
0.49
1.09
0.41
0.94
1.01
0.60
0.09
0.80
0.23
0.01
1.44
0.51
0.77
1.42
0.03
1.86
1.60
0.73
0.80
0.80
0.49
0.01
0.00
0.74
0.29
1.74
0.31
0.60
0.09
1.86
1.04
1.90
2.58
9.17
1.34
Energy Intensity
(ekWh/Mega Litres)
635
391
1380
CURRENT PERFORMANCE (2012) It is imperative to understand the energy characteristics of each facility. By understanding these values, baselines can be established and future retrofits and improvements to the buildings can be monitored and tracked to ensure that the intended benefits are fully realized. The City’s most recent energy consumption inventory was completed in 2012. This inventory took into account the electricity and natural gas consumption of The City facilities, streetlights, and parks. In 2012, The City’s total energy use, including electricity and natural gas, was 24,975,292 equivalent kilowatt hours (ekWh). This total consisted of 15,228,600 kWh of electricity and 917,096 m3 of natural gas, which is equivalent to 9,746,692 ekWh. The 2012 combined total cost of electricity and natural gas was $2,068,533. Page | 13 In all, The City has lowered its energy intensity from 2011 to 2012 indicating an improvement in energy utilization from 1.34 GJ/m2 to 1.17 GJ/m2. Page | 14 BENCHMARKING Market Sector Energy Intensity (ekWh/ft2) Sector Municipal Minimum 0.0 Average 219 No. of Organizations Maximum 56,932 410 The City’s facilities have an average 30 ekWh/ft2 energy intensity, well below the industry average, based on the Ministry of Energy’s 2011 Public Sector Energy Consumption Data. The City Facilities Page | 15 Page | 16 8
MISSION AND VISION We, the Council and staff of the City of Belleville, are committed to excellence and openness in local government by ensuring accessible and responsive representation, providing innovative and efficient services in support of our community‘s vision. The City addresses this mission/vision through the application of five foundational areas of focus: Excellence, Openness, Accessible, Responsive and Innovative and efficient. These strategic priorities are linked with the energy conservation goals in the following section of this CDM Plan. The CDM Plan has been developed to address the fiscal, societal, and environmental costs and risks associated with energy consumption. Proper energy management will allow The City to display leadership, improve the delivery of services, and enhance the overall quality of life with respect to the community. This CDM Plan outlines key actions that must be pursued to make this vision a reality. The completion of these actions will assist The City to meet its energy conservation targets and its greenhouse gas emission reduction commitment. Achieving these goals will assist The City in securing a strong energy management reputation and will allow for cost savings that can benefit The City, its employees, and its constituents. It is acknowledged that, for this vision to come to fruition, energy management at The City must become an inclusive process. Recognizing that energy affects everyone differently, this Plan was created to address a variety of energy related concerns, while capturing innovative and relevant actions that will lead to meaningful change. This CDM Plan will allow energy management to be incorporated into all The City activities, including organizational and human resource procedures, procurement practices, financial management and investment decisions, and facility capital, operations, and maintenance. Overview This CDM Plan is designed to meet the current energy needs and obligations of The City. The intent is to guide The City in the development of an energy management foundation. This will be a living Plan that will evolve as The City’s energy needs are revealed and better understood. The City’s approach to energy management is three pronged. It begins with: •
Elimination of waste, •
Improving efficiencies, and •
Optimizing energy supply. Page | 17 Prior to pursuing these actions, The City must be aware of the facility and Staff behaviours that influence energy consumption. Once encapsulated, this knowledge must be dispersed throughout the organization, allowing for the development of a culture of sustainability. An improved understanding of corporate energy consumption will require improvements in energy management and awareness. Energy awareness campaigns will strive to make energy a tangible asset that Staff Members can appreciate when it is being consumed or wasted. In addition to increasing energy awareness, this energy Plan will integrate energy efficiency into the capital and operational decision making of the organization. Page | 18 9
GOALS AND OBJECTIVES It is of critical importance to improve energy efficiency and reduce The City’s operating costs. Equally important is displaying our commitment to the environment through the reduction of greenhouse gases, while improving our air quality. It is also important that these actions are carried out without adversely impacting The City’s operations. All The City Staff will have an essential role in the success of this energy management Plan. It will be the responsibility of the Energy Management Team to ensure that energy management measures are properly communicated and effectively implemented. An Energy Mandate for The City has been developed and is an integral component of this CDM Plan. The City’s CDM Plan was completed to help support the following strategic priorities: •
Excellence o We will strive to implement the best methods and techniques to the management of the municipal corporation, delivering municipal services that employ best practices. •
Openness o We will ensure that governance of the City is undertaken in an open and transparent manner to enable the public to have full access to the workings of their local government. •
Accessible o We will ensure all City departments are accessible by the public in order to obtain information and receive assistance and guidance. •
Responsive o We will respond to the needs of the community in a proactive fashion, anticipating needs and developing solutions, through use of a consultative approach. •
Innovative and Efficient o We will use new technologies and best practices in the delivery of services in order to achieve a high degree of efficiency and obtain the maximum benefit for the least cost. The primary objective of this Plan is to improve the management of The City’s energy consumption. Part of this objective is setting a conservation target that will see The City reduce its 2011 energy consumption by 5% by the end of 2018. Recognizing that The City is a growing community, The City’s energy conservation target will be intensity based. It is also the objective of this Plan to improve The City’s understanding of energy consumption, which is essential for The City to meet its corporate energy management goals. •
Encourage reduced greenhouse gas emissions and energy consumption in The City by promoting built forms and transportation systems that create more sustainable, efficient, healthy, and live able communities, Page | 19 •
Maximize the use of operational budgets by ensuring that The City’s facilities are operating in as energy efficient manner as possible, thereby supporting and improving service delivery to constituents, •
Ensure that minimizing energy use is considered throughout the various aspects of The City operations including purchasing where financially viable, •
Recognize the importance of the input and participation of The City Staff members in supporting energy conservation and sustainability initiatives through education, awareness and training Measurements of Success The measurements of success will be based on a variety of indicators: •
Reaching the CDM Plan’s energy conservation target, •
Assisting with the corporate greenhouse gas reduction target, •
Achieving the savings outlined in the Plan’s budget section, and •
Imbedding energy management in The City’s capital and operations decision-­‐making process. Reporting Standards The CDM Plan will allow for the monitoring and reporting that is necessary for The City to meet the regulatory requirements of the Green Energy Act and The City’s greenhouse gas reduction targets. Regular energy monitoring and feedback to the Ministry and The City Management and Staff will improve knowledge and help make energy consumption a tangible asset, making possible appropriate behavioural changes. The intent of monitoring and reporting on energy consumption is to make energy management transparent and the consumer accountable. The Ministry will be provided with annual updates on the state of energy management at The City. Energy consumption feedback provided to Staff will be imbedded into The City’s regular business. Page | 20 10 ENERGY MANAGEMENT TEAM Responsibility for developing and implementing Energy Conservation Plans and Projects currently resides with the Property Management Division. The City plans to develop a multi-­‐disciplinary Energy Management Committee to oversee the City’s Energy Conservation Program. Historically, The City addressed Energy Conservation and Demand Management on a project-­‐by-­‐project basis through the activities of the Building Services Group. Strategic directives have been provided by the The City of Belleville Council. This CDM Plan outlines a commitment to integrate Energy Conservation and Demand Management into the operations of the The City. Within the duration of the CDM Plan, CDM planned activities will become an integral component of the annual budgeting process. A collaborative effort will be undertaken to achieve this integration, involving: •
Internal Staff (which may include but will not be limited to Facilities Management, Finance, and Procurement), •
Advisement from the Ministry of Energy, and •
Consultations with Energy Management experts. Page | 21 11 FINANCIAL ASSESSMENT The energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan’s financial assessment philosophy is to treat fiscal resources as if they were energy assets. Therefore, financial investments follow the same three pronged approach used for the management of energy: •
Elimination of waste, •
Improving efficiencies, and •
Optimizing energy supply. If initiated and monitored effectively, it can be anticipated that these savings can be sustained. It should also be noted that the price of energy is anticipated to increase, whereas the costs of capital projects will likely decrease with advancements in technology. This could potentially lead to increased savings and decreased costs in the later years of the plan. The potential for avoided costs adds to the relevance of a plan of this nature. This fiscal assessment does not take into account the economic benefits of achieving all of the corporate energy management goals. Due to the difficulty in quantifying the economic value of extended equipment longevity, improved comfort and productivity, and climate change mitigation, it should not be discounted. Page | 22 12 CORPORATE ENERGY BUDGET Prior to requesting funding for energy actions, The City will consult with utility representatives and/or energy consultants, allowing The City to schedule project launch dates in parallel with applicable incentive funding programs. The projects may be moved forward or delayed based on changes to incentive programs as well as changes to the CDM Plan. However, The City will not make significant alterations to the Plan in a quest for incentive funding. This is not a prudent approach to planning. Actions will be pursued only when they coincide with The City’s objectives and are appropriate to be pursued at that time. As The City continues to evolve and its energy needs become greater, it will be essential to reassess and clarify, as necessary, the financial indicators that are applied to investment analysis and prioritization of proposed energy projects. Energy efficiency projects must be weighted appropriately relative to other investment needs. There will also be a need to develop procedures for the annual allocation of capital resources for energy efficiency measures in the capital budget. Page | 23 13 ENERGY MANAGEMENT ACTIONS The economic feasibility of proposed actions played a large role in the prioritization of the processes, programs, and projects. Equally important in this prioritization exercise was the evaluation of The City’s internal capacity to complete the proposed initiatives. Recognizing the need to develop The City’s internal capacity, the initial years of the Plan focus heavily on processes and programs. The implementation of the recommended processes and programs will result in an improved understanding and awareness of energy consumption. This will allow for improved decision making and greater success with future energy projects (See Appendix C for the CDM Plan timeline). As these actions are completed, the Energy Management Team will meet to discuss monitoring results and how they can be used to enhance the Plan. The CDM Plan is intended to be a living document. Anticipated improvements in knowledge and capacity will result in enhancement of the proposed actions. Annual Reporting An Annual Conservation and Demand Management Plan Update Report will be provided that details The City’s activities and results relating to this 2014-­‐2018 Energy Conservation and Demand Management (CDM) Plan. The Report will describe the CDM Plan related activities that have happened in the previous year and will focus on linking actions to results. In addition, the Report will take a forward view of the upcoming year to lay out the roadmap and identify any changes or adjustments that should be considered based on what the current market conditions are. The overarching goal of the report is to make the 5 year CDM Plan a living document that is reviewed and updated on a yearly basis. Future Energy Projects Energy projects at The City were evaluated prior to the development of the CDM Plan. The City Staff Members have advocated for some ambitious energy initiatives that were investigated and determined to be not feasible for a variety of reasons. The City has developed a prioritized list of potential energy savings measures based on a series of facility energy audits. These measures are broken down into A, B and C priority projects based on cost and potential simple payback calculations. The City will use this list to implement strategies to reduce energy use over the next five years, as funding is available. The complete list is found in Appendix C. Any potential alternate funding or incentive opportunities will also be explored and utilized as available. It is anticipated that as The City grows and energy management practices improve, these actions will be reassessed. Page | 24 Renewable Energy Feasibility and promotion of renewable energy technologies were examined throughout the development of the CDM Plan. These technologies have been incorporated into the CDM Plan where it made sense to do so, strategically or fiscally. The City currently operates two 10K MicroFit Solar Photo Voltaic System at Myers Pier and the Transit Terminal. Other renewable energy projects are currently in the feasibility review stage. Page | 25 Purchasing Practices Traditionally, purchasing practices in the public sector were designed to favour equipment or physical retrofits at the lowest cost in order to ensure the highest possible financial responsibility. As energy conservation best practices emerged, it was revealed that there is a major issue in doing this. Almost all wasteful energy consuming equipment is less expensive than their energy conserving counterparts. The practice in itself does not encourage energy efficiency, as most energy intensive alternatives such as standard efficiency motors are less costly than their higher efficiency counterparts. When dealing with energy intensive hardware, the initial capital cost is only a fraction (5%-­‐10%) of the total lifecycle cost. The practice of ‘low bidder wins’ purchasing limits the Staff when trying to make the right environmental decision. Making a specific amount of money available to include the conservation upgrades allows the Municipality to take advantage of necessary investments in order to reduce their impact on the bottom line after the cost of purchase. For example, when purchasing a motor, all suppliers will specify standard efficiency motors. An energy smart buyer will know that 90%+ of the motor’s lifecycle cost is in its energy use. Therefore, buying a premium efficiency motor at a small incremental cost has a payback of less than three years. Missing this opportunity translates into a long-­‐
term financial increase. In fact, the incremental cost between a less efficient and a more efficient alternative is often less than 5% of the capital cost. That 5% capital cost difference is often recuperated in less than three years. This allows Staff to make the right environmental decision based on industry best financial practices. Energy Management and Information Systems An Energy Management and Information System (EMIS) is an important element of a comprehensive Energy Management Program (EMP), as it helps to ensure that the full benefits of other energy conservation efforts are achieved and sustained. In fact, a quality EMIS can reduce energy use and cost by at least 5%. (Ref: Office of Energy Efficiency, National Resources Canada). Current industry and international standards, such as the International Performance Measurement & Verification Protocol (IPMVP), use an average of an 8%-­‐10% reduction in energy consumption and costs. VIP Energy Services has documented a conservation average of 17% over customers served to date. However, in order to be as conservative as possible in its financial calculations, VIP generally uses NRCan's conservative numbers (5%) to ensure objectivity in the investment matter. The savings from an EMIS result from the following measured impacts: •
Early detection of poor performance, •
Support for optimal decision making, •
Effective performance reporting, •
Auditing of historical performance, Page | 26 •
Identification and justification of energy projects, •
Evidence of implementation success, •
Support for energy budgeting and accounting, and •
Provision of energy data to other systems (such as Building Automation Systems, BAS). When looking at performance reports, an EMIS facilitates ensuring that upgrades or changes actually meet forecasted savings, as well as the quantification of losses or gains. However, it is important to note that placing meters to isolate individual retrofit projects determined by their scope is generally cost ineffective and typically does not allow incorporation of out-­‐of-­‐scope project factors that directly affect equipment performance. A one-­‐time, comprehensive metering solution allows for a much more cost effective view, while enabling accountability to 90% of the planned projects budgeted to date. Reporting can be the most essential part of this plan as multiple portions of the organization rely on this data to make periodic decisions. The Finance Team can use this information to verify billing accuracy and other potential costs, such as construction back-­‐charges. Energy Conservation Managers generally look at this data for building performance, future opportunity and functional trending. Project Managers rely on this information to ensure that vendors are supplying and meeting contractual obligations. Collecting the information in any EMIS program is really only the first step, as the data must then be used to instigate change and push action. This can only be done through analysis and warning systems built on baseline information. In order for an EMIS system to function properly, communication loops must also be established between departments in order for the maximum benefit to be realized. The following figure illustrates how the City could use an EMIS system and the associated data collected in an efficient manner, thereby maximizing the impact of the EMIS system. These systems can be as simple as an online Data Storage, Retrieval and Reporting System using billing data to form the basis and baselines for future comparison. Building Re-­‐Commissioning Building re-­‐commissioning, or retro-­‐commissioning, refers to the optimization of the current automation, controls and energy consuming systems. As buildings age, both the functionality of the equipment and the functions that they serve can undergo significant changes. A re-­‐commissioning program generally focuses on ensuring that the equipment operations are modified to include any new or deleted duties. The following is a list of common problems found in re-­‐commissioning projects that result in increased energy costs: •
Inefficient scheduling of HVAC equipment, •
Simultaneous heating and cooling, •
Economizer sequences not optimized, Page | 27 •
Incorrect airflow and water balance, •
Malfunctioning sensors or incorrect calibration, •
Fan VFD control overridden, •
Supply air static pressure set-­‐points not optimized, •
Boiler controls not operating efficiently, •
Balancing dampers and valves not installed or installed in poor or unusable locations, •
Incorrectly piped water coils, •
Process or space classification changes (lab space to office, etc.), •
Incomplete or incorrect control component installation, •
Control sequence incorrectly implemented, •
Substituted control components, •
Incomplete installations (missing control valve, actuators, etc.), and •
Testing, adjusting, and balancing (TAB) not completed or only partially completed. National Resources Canada (NRCan) has published several guidelines for costing and expected returns from re-­‐commissioning projects. Building re-­‐commissioning is an increasingly important practice, not only from an energy standpoint, but also from a comfort and safety perspective as well. The more complex building controls and ventilation become, the more risk there is that one or more components will fail or deliver incorrect measurements. Current practices in re-­‐commissioning indicate that the cost to complete these initiatives is between $2.90 and $4.50/m2. Expected savings from the projects are typically between $1.00 and $4.00/m2, depending upon the starting efficiency of the building, thus creating very attractive paybacks in this area. Energy and Resource Awareness (ERA) Programs Independent studies done by organizations such as Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) show that initiatives directed at Staff and facility users, in particular ERA Programs, can lead to significant savings on their own. In fact, NRCAN reports indicate that dedicated, consistent Energy Awareness Programs are proven to be the most effective way to reduce energy usage with no capital costs and minor operational expenses. A conservative estimate of savings for an effective ERA Program can be as high as 5% -­‐7% of annual utilities spending. An effective ERA Program is designed to assist organizations to attain energy savings by promoting a fundamental shift in the personal philosophies of Staff and facility users towards reducing their energy use. The Program utilizes community-­‐based social marketing to develop influential communication Page | 28 materials and in-­‐house displays that are carefully designed to inform and motivate employees to effectively decrease energy consumption. In many cases, an ERA Program has proven to be the most effective way to lower energy usage without any capital costs and minimal operational expenses. A typical ERA Program would include features such as: •
A detailed ERA Program written plan including a GANTT chart, •
The creation of a program email address for suggestions and concerns and access to ERA experts to answer questions, •
A customized identity and marketing program, •
Training and support for an Energy Steward Team, •
ERA displays with various relevant conservation themes, and •
Annual Marketing Effectiveness Reports and Feedback system. A continuous and consistent ERA Program is not only an effective way to lower energy use within a facility, but can also serve to be an effective marketing tool to spread the word that The City is a community leader in energy conservation and environmental sustainability. Page | 29 APPENDIX A
Energy Data
Page | 30 ENERGY CONSUMPTION City of Belleville Facilities -­‐ 2011 Energy Annual Flow (Mega Litres) Building Name City Professional Building Archives Building Archives Building Arena -­‐ Dick Ellis Arena -­‐ Memorial Wally Dever and Yardman Arena, Quinte Sports Centre Belleville Public Library Public Utilities & Veridian -­‐ N. Britton Canteens -­‐ Thurlow City Hall Club -­‐ Tennis -­‐ Outdoor Club -­‐ Rowing -­‐ Indoor Community Centre -­‐ Elderly Person Community Centre -­‐Hillcrest Community Centre -­‐ Opportunity Shop Community Centre -­‐ Parkdale Community Centre -­‐ Thurlow Fire Hall #1 Fire Hall #2 Fire Hall #3 Fire Hall #4 Glanmore National Historic Site Kinsmen Pool and Hall Meyers Pier Police Safety Village Police Services Facility Property Maintenance-­‐ Sidney Smith Parks Building Parks Building PW -­‐ Joe Angelo Operations Centre Quinte Exhibition and Raceway Transit Garage Transit Terminal Water Treatment Plant Water Pollution Control Plant TOTAL Electricity Natural Gas Consumption Consumption (kWh) (m3) 99,764 16,011 1,545 3,859 14,755 6,984 612,361 19,523 110,894 34,355 4,673,807 270,228 8,482 11,693 436,276 377,939 3,174 386,772 4,272 3,411 93,738 11,048 16,411 34,425 5,402 88,021 33,556 18,710 48,266 58,756 1,805 0 430,169 4,270 82,357 49,785 283,062 34,062 141,030 11,896 3,930,764 3,442,765 51,783 10,084 32,239 229 10,823 2,648 6,430 14,327 14,737 4,862 6,317 3,368 19,470 1,401 28,134 10,411 48,536 23 24,752 1,403 137,170 105,918 20,174 15,545,267 886,026 Page | 31 City of Belleville Facilities -­‐ 2012 Energy City Professional Building Archives Building Archives Building Arena -­‐ Dick Ellis Arena -­‐ Memorial Wally Dever and Yardman Arena, Quinte Sports Centre Belleville Public Library Public Utilities & Veridian -­‐ N. Britton Canteens -­‐ Thurlow City Hall Club -­‐ Tennis -­‐ Outdoor Club -­‐ Rowing -­‐ Indoor Community Centre -­‐ Elderly Person Community Centre -­‐Hillcrest Community Centre -­‐ Opportunity Shop Community Centre -­‐ Parkdale Community Centre -­‐ Thurlow Fire Hall #1 Fire Hall #2 Fire Hall #3 Fire Hall #4 Glanmore National Historic Site Kinsmen Pool and Hall Meyers Pier Police Safety Village Police Services Facility Property Maintenance-­‐ Sidney Smith Parks Building Parks Building PW -­‐ Joe Angelo Operations Centre Quinte Exhibition and Raceway 81,153 26,181 12,885 185,582 54,507 Natural Gas Consumption.
(m3) 14,699 3,302 7,080 8,697 42,027 7,466,678 370,273 432,683 48,901 411,960 15,964 5,002 -­‐ 427,287 41,093 5,148 4 2,127 96,501 11,305 10,673 2,690 16,675 32,776 5,778 960 2,797 106,001 13,085 42,410 15,339 19,609 1,048 1,083 53,756 10,095 37,230 5,523 1,743 448,964 26,198 4,935 9,088 88,847 24,042 31,209 9,082 249,230 24,125 36,037 1,056 47,157 175,692 1,412 124,997 133,161 4,077,012 3,810,215 137,098 Transit Garage Transit Terminal 8,821 Water Treatment Plant Water Pollution Control Plant 13,447 TOTAL Electricity Consumption (kWh) Annual Flow (Mega Litres) Building Name 22,268 18,577,713 1,032,154 Page | 32 APPENDIX B
Energy Use
Breakdown
Page | 33 ENERGY USE BREAKDOWN 2011 Energy Breakdown (percent) 44% 56% Electricity Natural Gas 2012 Energy Breakdown (percent) 39% 61% Electricity Natural Gas Page | 34 APPENDIX C
Energy Conservation M easure Schedules
Page | 35 City of Belleville Energy Management Strategies City of Belleville Proposed Energy Conservation Measures Facility City Hall North Park St Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building North Park St North Park St Ritz Rd City Hall Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building North Park St North Park St North Park St City Hall City Hall Main Public Works Building City Hall City Hall Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building North Park St North Park St North Park St North Park St North Park St North Park St North Park St North Park St North Park St Ritz Rd Ritz Rd Ritz Rd Proposed Measure Install Faucet Aerators Replace old incandescent Exit lights with LED PM on HVAC – Filter for wash bay Furnace dirty Repair running Urinal Replace High Flow washroom fixtures Replace Incandescent and T12 bulbs Shut off Exterior and wash bay hoses water when not in use Replace Incandescent and T12 bulbs Replace Window AC in Mechanical office Replace Incandescent and T12 bulbs Install Automatic Vent Damper for Boilers Replace Multi hand-­‐wash sink Seal Wall breach from Exhaust duct Replace / Upgrade Welding EF Replace Multi hand-­‐wash sink Seal Wall breach from Exhaust duct Install Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) on Pump Motors Replace Electrical Domestic Hot Water with Instant Natural Gas T8 32W with T8 25W Install Lighting Control System Replace All Water Closets with Low Flow Computers with Laptops Door Seal replacement and repairs Lighting Motion sensors where applicable Replace Electric DWH Replace NON-­‐Energy Star Appliances Replace old incandescent Exit lights with LED Seal old combustion exhaust in wash bay Computers with Laptops Door Seal replacement and repairs Interlock door with EF Lighting Motion sensors where applicable Replace old Green house EF Replace Electric DWH by washer / Dryer with NG DWH Replace GH electric DWH with HX to near by Boiler Replace wood shop windows T8 32W with T8 25W Computers with Laptops Lighting Motion sensors where applicable Replace Electric DWH by washer / Dryer with NG DWH Estimated Cost $400 800 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000 $3,000 $3,500 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Page | 36 Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre City Hall City Hall Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building North Park St North Park St North Park St Ritz Rd Ritz Rd Ritz Rd Ritz Rd Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre City Hall Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre City Hall Main Public Works Building Main Public Works Building North Park St City Hall City Hall Quinte Sports Centre City Hall Main Public Works Building Quinte Sports Centre City Hall Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Quinte Sports Centre Repair Leaking Faucets Replace Incandescent and T12 bulbs Energy and Resource Awareness Install Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) for Supply Fan Insulate RTU ducting to second floor window Replace Exterior MH with LED Upgrade Radiant Tube Heaters Replace / Upgrade Compressor Replace Exterior MH with LED Replace NON-­‐Energy Star Appliances Replace / Upgrade Compressor Replace Exterior MH with LED Replace NON-­‐Energy Star Appliances Replace old incandescent Exit lights with LED Seal Roof Breaches from flue Replace High Flow washroom fixtures Lighting Motion sensors where applicable Replace old incandescent Exit lights with LED Re-­‐Commissioning HVAC System Replace NON-­‐Energy Star Appliances Power factor correction for old part of building Upgrade Hand Dryers Computers with Laptops Replace exiting Boiler with Modulating and Variable Speed Condensing Boiler Exterior Refinishing Upgrade Garage MAU Exterior Refinishing Replace Existing Electrical Baseboard Heaters with Hydronic Hot Water System Install Low-­‐E Film on Glass Windows EBCx -­‐ FPT Lighting Upgrades Central Air to replace multiple Window and portable A/C units Heat Reclaim from Yardman Arena MAU Upgrade Building Automation System (BAS) Replace MH with LED BAS upgrade to DDC Old rink chilling system upgrade Roof replacement -­‐ Original building $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $7,500 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 $13,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $20,000 $24,000 $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $35,000 $36,000 $40,000 $42,000 $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 $100,000 $100,000 $100,000 $100,000 Page | 37