Broadsheet Article - By
Transcription
Broadsheet Article - By
the broadsheet BPCA SEIZES NORTH COVE MARINA Volume 19 Number 1 Guards Posted in Apparent Defiance of Call by Five Elected Officials to Halt Troubled Bidding Process; Town Hall Meeting Slated for January 8 By Matthew Fenton A Loose Cannon: A security guard orders Michael Fortenbaugh, operator of the sailing school and club at North Cove Marina for the past ten years, to leave the facility after the Battery Park City Authority forcibly took possession of the yacht basin on January 1 few days after Community Board 1 (CB1) and five elected officials representing Lower Manhattan formally requested that the Battery Park City Authority (BPCA) stop the bidding process for the contract to operate North Cove Marina, and start anew with a structure that allows for greater transparency and community input, the Authority forcibly seized control of the yacht harbor from Michael Fortenbaugh, the Battery Park City resident and small businessman who has operated the facility for ten years. On January 1, guards from FJC Security appeared at the marina and prevented Mr. Fortenbaugh, who is among the bidders hoping to be awarded a contract to manage the yacht harbor through 2025, from entering the facility to inspect or maintain the boats moored there. When questioned by a Broadsheet reporter, one of the guards, who de- clined to give his name, was unable or unwilling to say who had hired his company. (He claimed not to know whether the security service was retained by the Authority. When asked whether FJC had been hired by new marina manager who has not yet been publicly identified, he answered, “I don’t know.”) A spokesperson for the BPCA was initially unable to confirm that the Authority had retained the company to restrict access to North Cove Marina. But the Authority issued a statement within 24 hours, saying, “the prior license holder was made aware several weeks ago that the BPCA would assume responsibility for the North Cove Marina and its associated operations when his term expired on December 31. As soon as the BPCA Board makes a final decision on the 2015-2025 licensee, arrangements will commence to ensure the upcoming sailing season at continued on page 3 Under STRESS? In PAIN? can enhance your well-being ACUPUNCTURE Dr. Jonathan L. Harwayne In Battery Park City Board Certified Acupuncturist 212-786-9292 Accepting BlueCross BlueShield ACUPUNCTURE-DOC.COM Robert Simko All Rights Reserved © 2015 The Broadsheet Inc. ebroadsheet.com January 6 - 20, 2015 Co-op Closer to Cash Out T “Be at War with your Vices, at Peace with your Neighbours, and let every New-Year find you a better Man.” —Benjamin Franklin Of Arches, Angles, and Artifacts STATE REGULATOR AND ATTORNEY GENERAL SIGN OFF ON RESULTS OF SOUTHBRIDGE PRIVATIZATION VOTE NEWS & COMMENT By Matthew Fenton he campaign to privatize Southbridge Towers, the 1,651-apartment cooperative complex near the Brooklyn Bridge, has cleared two additional hurdles. The State’s Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) on November 24 concluded its review of the September vote by residents to withdraw from the Mitchell-Lama affordability program, and found no fault with the balloting or the result. (The referendum, which was contested by opponents of privatization, was won by supporters of the proposal by a margin of ten votes more than the legally required minimum of two-thirds.) The next day, the State Attorney General certified the result of the voting as legally valid, which marked the beginning of a 90-day “exclusive period” (ending on March 3), during which residents must decide whether to sign participation agreements. If two-thirds of eligible resident sign these agreements, the privatization process will move on to the next step. If fewer than this number agree to participate, the process may have to start all over. But if this minimum threshold is reached, the final steps in the process are expected to take up to one year, before the Attorney General’s office finally signs off and Southbridge can formally cease to participate in the Mitchell-Lama program. “People are now signing participation agreements,” says Wally Dimson, who has lived in Southbridge Towers for 40 years, has served as chair of its board of directors since 2007, and supports privatization. “We are not anticipating that there will be any issues meeting twothirds threshold by March 3.” The debate over privatization at Southbridge revolves around two, mutually exclusive goals. Supporters wish to take possession of the full, market-rate value of their apartments, which (in some cases) may amount to more than a million dollars on units for which most residents originally paid less than $20,000. (For decades, the prices of apartments at Southbridge have been regulated by the State’s Mitchell-Lama affordability program, which enabled buyers to purchase apartments at below-market prices, but capped the amount owners could collect when they sold.) Opponents want to preserve this affordability for future generations of Lower Manhattan residents. Sources within the group opposed to Southbridge privatization say that they are still considering legal and procedural challenges to the plan. The financial predictions about what will happen if the required twothirds of residents sign participation agreements are another flashpoint in the controversy between those supporting privatization and those opposing it. “There are different budget scenarios,” says Mr. Dimson. “We believe that initial transfers of apartments, which will generate a firsttime transfer fee to the cooperative of between 28 and 33 percent, will provide adequate income to avoid large maintenance increases. But the one expense is that we will face is the regular, full real estate tax.” For every year since Southbridge opened in the early 1970s, its annual tax liability has been reduced by more than 90 percent—relative to similar, private cooperatives—as part of the government subsidy for MitchellLama housing. But this abatement would go away, beginning in the first year that Southbridge becomes private. “Our accountants believe the tax will amount to $8.5 million per year, and our assumption is that roughly three percent of apartments will be sold per year, which will give us not only enough income to cover increased taxes, but also a large surplus,” says Mr. Dimson. Another looming issue for any Mitchell-Lama cooperative considering privatization is a lawsuit currently under review by the State’s Court of Appeals, which will decide whether such a conversion amounts to a change of ownership (subject to a transfer tax), or merely the conveyance of property from one cor- Cultivating Creative Kids Amid recent grumbling about the ultimate price tags for the Calatrava Transit Hub (above) and One World Center (below), both of which are still unknowable, we had this thought: Does anybody remember the cost of the Pyramids or the Taj Mahal? While we will doubtless be paying for these modern monuments for decades to come, there is reason to hope that the structures themselves will endure for centuries. And if they do, ours will be remembered as a community that sculpted gleaming civic greatness from the smoldering ruins of a profoundly uncivilized moment. The value of that message to the future is, we submit, priceless. For Yoga Bears The Battery Park City Parks Conservancy is launching a Parent and Baby Yoga program for new parents and young children (aged newborn to crawling). Instructor Mary Barnes will combine Anusara Yoga with breath-work, alignment, and strength training to teach postures and exercise specifically tailored to new parents in a safe, supportive environment. Seven weekly classes will be held on Mondays (January 5 through March 2) in either early (1:00 through 2:15 pm) or late (2:30 through 3:45 pm) sessions at Six River Terrace (next to Le Pain Quotidien, across from the Irish Hunger Memorial), for a fee of $157. To register or to request more information, please call 212-267-9700 (ext. 363), or e-mail [email protected]. Complimentary Classics continued on page 3 Piano or Guitar Lessons 212-786-4376 2 South End Avenue in Battery Park City 212-786-1688 The perfect holiday gift to a loved one. All ages, all levels, all types of music. Many years of experience, first lesson on me!! email: [email protected] Tuesday, January 13th 6:00 pm - 7:30 pm Learn how to make the most of every square foot and redefine your living space. Presented by Orlie Katsiris Staging & Interiors and Rightsized Rooms RSVP to [email protected] www.bpcdaynursery.com 212-945-0088 Lower Manhattan has for years been a mecca for free movies, but only in summer. But thanks to Trinity Church, free flicks Downtown are no longer seasonal. The 2015 Neighborhood Movie Night at St. Paul’s Chapel series (located on Broadway, between Fulton and Vesey Streets) will offer family-friendly cinema on the fourth Friday of each month. The program kicks off on January 23 with E.T., followed by West Side Story on February 27, then Goonies on March 27, and Adventures in Babysitting on April 24. All films start at 7pm. For more information, browse www.trinitywallstreet.org/movies. WORLD TRADE CENTER DENTAL GROUP, PC Our 41st year in Lower Manhattan Urban Family: Design Secrets for Apartment Living 215 South End Ave Walking toddlers through pre-kindergarten age children (along with an accompanying adult) are invited to join interactive play, art making, and more in the Battery Park City Parks Conservancy’s Preschool Play and Art program, which begins on January 8 and continues every Thursday through April 9. The program meets at Six River Terrance (opposite the Irish Hunger Memorial), where a fee of $350 buys a spot for one child and one adult (grownups will participate throughout the program) in either the morning (10:00 to 11:30 am) or afternoon (3:30 to 5:00 pm) sessions. Additional siblings can join for a discounted rate of $315. To register or to request more information, please call 212-267-9700 (ext. 363), or email [email protected]. Services Offered: •Cleaning •Restorative Crown •Bleaching •Implants •Veneers Dr. Richard Marchitto DDS 42 Broadway just up the street from the Bowling Green Bull Putting a smile on the face of New York Insurances accepted Aetna PPO, Cigna PPO, Delta Dental PPO,Guardian PPO, EmpireDental PPO Richard Marchitto, DMD 42 Broadway, Suite 1536 212.968.0631 [email protected] wtcdentalgroup.com Cosmetic & Restorative Dentistry the broadsheet Page 2 LETTERS January 6 - 20, 2015 THE UPS AND DOWNS (AND UPS) OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION continued from page 4 In addition, in light of the widespread support that has been expressed for Mr. Fortenbaugh, I urge you to consider modifications of your RFP process with regard to this matter. First, it is imperative that the RFP include Battery Park City community members in the selection process. Currently, only one member of the BPCA’s Board resides in Battery Park City, and she has recused herself from voting on this bid. I encourage you to consider the creation of a community-based task force to provide residents a meaningful voice in this process, as your agency so admirably did when selecting the operator for the Battery Park City ball fields and community center. Second, the RFP process should be open and transparent, with all bidders releasing their proposals to the public and opening their plans for public comment. Third, the substance of the RFP itself should be revised to give greater weight to community programming. The RFP states that only 15% weight will be given to “quality and strength of proposed community-based programming, including educational opportunities for children and teenagers, that is accessible at every income level.” Meanwhile, the RFP affords greater weight to other factors such as the bidder’s financing plan and proposed marina use program. I urge you to revise the RFP to give greater weight to affordable community-based programming. It is my understanding that the BPCA has the authority to withdraw the current RFP and rework the RFP process and that there is existing precedent for the BPCA to use community-based task forces when overseeing major community projects. As you likely are aware, operators of small businesses in Lower Manhattan are facing growing challenges to their viability. In such an increasing difficult environment, it is essential to my constituents that visionary small business owners such as Michael Fortenbaugh are able to survive and thrive here. It is similarly important to my constituents that the stewards of public space are community-minded and community-based, qualities which Mr. Fortenbaugh has amply demonstrated throughout his tenure as operator of the Marina. Thank you for your consideration. Please feel free to contact me if I can be of any assistance in your process. —Hon. Jenifer Rajkumar To the Editor: Everyone, including an article in the New York Times, points out many salient points about the management of North Cove. Yes, it’s “populist,” but it’s so much to many different groups. Mr. Fortenbaugh has brought many different groups together under this umbrella: ships which ply the waters with tourists and visitors, yachts that are for charter, private yachts of the rich and famous, a sailing school, sailing club, jr. sailing programs, international regattas, participants in ocean races, corporate leagues and team building regattas. He has opened the harbor clubhouse to the public, opened the marina clubhouse yacht to residents and civic groups. He rebuilt the marina after 9/11 when everyone was moving out of BPC, and again after Hurricane Sandy when the electrical vaults were destroyed. He brought recreational sailing as well as private yachts to New York City. No other entity would ever offer such an ecumenical or diverse array of players to our city. Sailing is a sport that in New York City has grown exponentially since Mr. Fortenbaugh began 27 years ago. Diversity has not. —Claire Morda T The News Is Good, Then Not So Good, Then Semi-Good for the Tribeca Trust By Matthew Fenton he campaign by the Tribeca Trust to enlarge the borders of the Tribeca Historic Districts recently received good news, followed by bad news, followed again by good news. The first encouraging development came in October, after the City’s Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC) responded to a months-long effort by the Trust, and agreed to hear a presentation outlining the case for expanding the Historic Districts that are supposed to protect the streetscape in one of Manhattan’s most venerable (and vulnerable) neighborhoods. The Trust hopes to redraw the map of the four Historic Districts that cover Tribeca. “These borders were set in 1992,” says Lynn Ellsworth, one of the founders of the Tribeca Trust. “They are jagged, irregular lines that cut through the middle of blocks and saw-tooth left and right. Our goal is to create a Historic District that more closely resembles the traditional polygon-shape of Tribeca. We need new borders that will navigate around what has already been destroyed, and protect what is left.” The Trust, “is not a traditional preservation group,” says Lynn Ellsworth. “We have a big emphasis on urban design and we’re not opposed to development.” Ms. Ellsworth, who started Friends of Duane Park in 1994, joined with like-minded neighbors to start the Tribeca Trust to educate the public about the neighborhood’s history and architectural heritage and mobilize residents to preserve, protect, and enhance its architectural character and quality of life. The Trust began asking for a hearing before the LPC early last year, shortly after the administration of former Mayor Michael Bloomberg had departed, but before the administration of new Mayor Bill de Blasio had got its bearings. For months, these requests were greeted by silence. In May, the de Blasio administration appointed Meenakshi Srinivan as new head of the LPC, which signaled a possible change in direction. “Under the previous chair, Robert B. Tierney, I felt a distinct lack of concern about Tribeca’s interests,” says Ms. Ellsworth. “So we were pleasantly surprised when the Srinivan team agreed to see us. This was a good thing that I can’t imagine happening under Tierney.” The Tribeca Trust delegation included Ms. Ellsworth, Signe Nielsen (a former president of the City’s Public Design Com- mission), Michael Sorkin (a highly regarded architectural critic, a faculty member at the City College of New York, and a columnist for the Nation Magazine), and James Sanders (a Tribeca resident, architect, historian, and author of New York, An Illustrated History). Ms. Srinivan, “gave us about 45 minutes to outline our positions, and then asked a few questions,” Ms. Ellsworth recalls. “She’s in a difficult position of not knowing how the original 438 Washington Street is typical of the unofficial local landmarks for which Tribeca Trust is seeking formal, protected status boundaries were laid out under then-commissioner David Todd. We made the case that those boundaries reflect the preservation thinking of 20 years ago. The theory and practice of preservation has changed a lot since then. So Tribeca merits a new look. It is very common for the LPC to do extensions of historic districts. There is a record of this having happened many times.” The Trust also submitted to the LPC an in-depth preservation survey of Tribeca North, as well as a preliminary draft for a similar study for Tribeca East Historic District. Ms. Ellsworth and the Tribeca Trust team came away with the impression that LPC would follow up with requests for additional information. Then came the discouraging news. On the night before Thanksgiving, word leaked out that the LPC planned unilateral administrative action to “decalendar” more than 100 proposed individual landmarks and historic districts that had been under consideration for years. Moreover, the agency planned to do so with little or no opportunity for public comment. Preservationists were outraged. The New York Landmarks Conservancy said, “nothing is more central to the Commission’s functions than reviewing and acting on these important sites,” and urged the LPC to “reconsider the proposed de-listing.” The preservation group Landmarks West said that the action would “essentially sentence the buildings and districts to death by bulldozer.” On December 2, one week before the planned purge of the LPC’s lists of buildings and districts under consideration for protection, the new good news emerged: The Commission reversed itself, announcing that it would defer the decalendaring action. Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer, who had opposed the LPC action, said, “I’m delighted that the Landmarks Preservation Commission has decided to delay implementation of its plan to drop almost 100 items from landmarks consideration. We need a proper public hearing on proposed decalendaring and I will introduce such legislation in the Council shortly. It’s the kind of clarity we need from every agency in City government.” Ms. Ellsworth said, “it is a very good thing for a regulatory body like the LPC to listen attentively to the public, as the public, and not REBNY,” the Real Estate Board of New York (an industry advocacy and lobbying group), “as the constituency of the LPC. We are a democracy, after all.” She added, “I do have a nagging worry that the LPC may have rushed to judgment in thinking these properties were not worth landmarking. REBNY have tried to seize the public discourse so as to make landmarking out to be a bad thing.” Ms. Ellsworth argues that a combination of rhetoric and lobbying may lead to reluctance on the part of the LPC to consider requests for new or expanded Historic Districts, such as the Tribeca Trust is advocating for in Lower Manhattan. “While landmarking may not be good for real estate developers who want to build hyper-dense skyscrapers on every site in Manhattan,” she says, “landmarking is unquestionably a great public good and economically important for the long-run future of New York City.” DECEMBER 7 Gateway Tenants’ Association Honors Senator Daniel Squadron at Annual Holiday Event On Sunday evening, December 7, the Gateway Plaza Tenants Association (GPTA) hosted its annual holiday reception at SouthWestNY restaurant. State Senator Daniel Squadron was presented with an award in honor of his leadership in the struggle by Gateway tenants to improve living conditions in the giant rental complex. While enjoying complimentary wine and hors d'oeuvres, the neighbors celebrated the progress that was made this year, with the assistance of Senator Squadron. As GPTA president Glenn Plaskin said, "The Senator has worked tirelessly with GPTA on vital quality-of-life issues, such as energy conservation, electrical usage, emergency preparedness, and protecting our pet population." 212-912-1106 [email protected] PIANO / GUITAR LESSONS The perfect holiday gift to a loved one. All ages, all levels, all types of music. Many years of experience, first lesson on me! 212-786-4376 HOUSEKEEPING Home Health Attendant seeks FT babysitting and/or companion position. Available anytime. 14 years experience as hotel housekeeping attendant. Excellent refs and resume available. Call Audrey 646-346-9219 WE BUY JEWELRY & GOLD Located in Battery Park City Appointments made citywide. 212-213-4000 MAKE TIME FOR ART! Ages 6 - adult. Certified art Parker [email protected] Fb: vzulyz, inc SPANISH LESSONS from a native Spanish speaker (Spain). Adults, children, test preparations. [email protected] Leo Siegel MD with Ruth Ohman POCKET WATCHES and wristwatches sought Any condition 212-912-1106 Yume Kitasei Chief of Staff for Council member Margaret Chin with Paul Goldstein, district office manager for State Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver State Senator Daniel Squadron with the award that was presented to him by GPTA President Glenn Plaskin. Robert Braunfeld Former police commissioner Ray Kelly, with his wife Veronica and Karlene Wiese, GPTA Treasurer Rosalie Joseph and David Spencer, both co-presidents of BPC Chamber with Lee Blake. BPC Chamber is a newly formed network supporting BPC businesses. Jack’s Hair Salon New York Mercantile Exchange 1 North End Avenue 212-619-4030 7:30am - 5:30pm Monday - Friday Alison Simko, editor of Metropolitan Waterfront Alliance’s WaterWire with Shirley Feinberg, long time BPC resident and community gardener Trade Center Locksmith & Hardware Robert Braunfeld David Levine and Ray Kelly Jenifer Rajkumar, Democratic District Leader for Downtown Manhattan, and Commodore Michael Fortenbaugh, founder and president of the Manhattan Yacht Club Terri Paladini-Baumgarten, president of the Financial District Lions Club with Paula Galloway, Co-Founder of The BPC Dog Association Swaps & Trades Respectable Employment LOST AND FOUND OCCASIONAL BABYSITTING Former NYC Teacher Experienced BPC Resident [email protected] Also attending were Congressman Jerrold Nadler, Community Board 1 chair Catherine McVay Hughes, former police commissioner Ray Kelly and his wife Veronica, and many Gateway residents. Robert Braunfeld EXCELLENT CARE GIVER with 14 years of exp. seeks Live-in or Live-out position as Home Attendant or Elder Care Companion to care for your loved ones. Refs avail. Please call Iona or Pollyann 347-730-2817 IT HAPPENED Glenn Plaskin, president of the Gateway Tenants’ Association with Community Board 1 chair Catherine McVay Hughes and Congressman Jerrold Nadler CLASSIFIEDS & PERSONALS We either have it or we'll get it for you! Paul Newell, Democratic District Leader, toasts State Senator Daniel Squadron as the crowd looks on. photos by Robert Simko and Robert Braunfeld 45 New Street 212-962-1086 tradecenterlocksmith.com SUNDAYS SUNDA SUND AYS AT AT ST. ST. PAUL’S PA P AUL UL’S ’S NEW 45-minute 45-min ute se service rvice SSundays undayys at 9:15am. unda Relaxed. Participatory. Joyful. St. Paul’s Chapel | Broadwa wayy and Fulton Street trinit initywal ywallstreet.org/stpauls the broadsheet January 6 - 20, 2015 Page 3 BPCA SEIZES CONTROL OF NORTH COVE MARINA continued from page 1 BATTERY PARK VISION ASSOCIATES, PC Doctors of Optometry “We Cater to the Hard to Fit” Dr. David Naparstek Dr. Michele Maxwell 2015 is our 27th Year in Battery Park City 101 Battery Place 212-945-6789 batteryparkvision.com the North Cove Marina is as exciting munity that Michael Fortenbaugh munity-based boating and sailing and engaging as ever for the Battery should be afforded a fair opportunity programs at the Marina. I ask you to Park City community.” to retain the lease on the North Cove consider the interest of current comThe timing of the process for Marina and to continue his long- munity-based program operators and designating an operator for North standing commitment and vital serv- to require the winning bidder to deCove Marina has taken on new ur- ice to Lower Manhattan. Support for vise a plan to give them the maxigency because of repeated delays on his position has been offered by our mum possible chance to stay at the part of the BPCA, which ex- residents, community boards, local North Cove Marina. I support the tended the deadline for submission political organizations and elected of- Resolution passed by Community of proposals last fall, then unexpect- ficials alike. Those views should not Board 1 in support of withdrawing edly postponed announcing the current North Cove Maa decision at its December 4 rina Operator RFP and reboard meeting. This effecplacing it with an RFP that tively meant that the operaincludes community input tor who was supposed to and transparency to ensure take the helm at North that the selection of any opCove as of January 1 would erator will support the pubnot be identified until (at lic good, be stewards of… the earliest) the Authority’s parkland, and generate a reaJanuary board meeting, no sonable revenue stream.” date for which has yet been BPCA has an ‘out’ clause announced. and can withdraw the curFrustration at this rent RFP.” chaotic and uncertain situa- More than 300 supporters turned out for a December 15 rally on Ms. Brewer continued, tion boiled over on Decem“I join the community in the Esplanade to show support for Michael Fortenbaugh’s bid to continue operating North Cove Marina ber 15, when more than 300 worrying that the current people gathered for a rally on the Es- and cannot be cast aside by the line-up of long-term, successful planade to voice support for Mr. BPCA if it is to fulfill its obligation community sailing programs will exFortenbaugh, and air concerns about to act in the best interests of our perience major difficulties, from what other bidders might be plan- community.” steep fee hikes to outright access terning for North Cove Marina. The Ms. Rajkumar is also a member mination if BPCA chooses not to next day, Mr. Fortenbaugh, who has of the executive board of Down- award the contract to Michael built a widely lauded record of com- town Independent Democrats, an in- Fortenbaugh, the current concession munity service, leadership, and ac- fluential Lower Manhattan political holder. The community is also not tivism during his tenure at North club that on December 15 unani- pleased that the current RFP process Cove Marina, made the terms of his mously enacted a strongly worded does not include any form of public bid public. In addition to continuing resolution decrying, “the Continued participation outside the stated highly regarded public programs, Corporatization Of Our Public BPCA board meetings. There has such as a sailing school and summer Land,” endorsing Mr. Fortenbaugh’s been no public meeting, no hearing, sailing camp for children and proposal to stay on as operator of and no public comment period.” At teenagers, Mr. Fortenbaugh’s bid North Cove, and calling upon the the same time, Ms. Brewer told the would increase the annual rent he BPCA to give greater weight to com- Broadsheet, “I share CB1’s concerns pays by some $80,000, bringing the munity benefits when deciding which and its ultimate goal: making sure yearly total to approximately bidder to select for the contract. that the marina continues to enrich $400,000. This sum would be further The posting of guards at North this neighborhood by hosting accesincreased by revenue-generating spe- Cove Marina came shortly after CB1 sible, affordable programs like the cial events, the profits from which passed, by a unanimous vote of 36 to sailing school. It would be tragic if would be shared with the Authority. zero at its December 18 meeting, a the marina became just another parkNone of the other bidders have resolution that noted, “the Marina ing lot for the wealthiest New Yorkmade similar disclosures. Other aspi- Request for Proposals [RFP] Evalu- ers’ boats and nothing more.” rants are believed to include Brook- ation Criteria only assigns a weight of The BPCA declined to comment field Properties (owners of the 15 percent of a total 100 percent to on Ms. Brewer’s letter to Mr. Mehiel, nearby Brookfield Place retail and of- ‘quality and strength of proposed or her statement to the Broadsheet. fice complex, who once proposed community-based programming…,’ Six days later, on December 29, decking over North Cove Marina which we believe diminishes those four more elected officials representwith a platform that would house a criteria and the value of our park- ing Lower Manhattan joined Ms. permanent circus tent) and billionaire land” The resolution called upon the Brewer in echoing CB1’s call for a real estate developer Andrew Farkas. BPCA to, “exercise its right (per the halt to the RFP process. In a joint letBoth Brookfield and Mr. Farkas were RFP) to withdraw the current North ter to the BPCA signed by State Asmajor contributors to the recent Cove Marina Operator RFP so that sembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, State campaign for reelection by Governor it can be reviewed with more com- Senator Daniel Squadron, City CounAndrew Cuomo, who directly over- munity input and transparency to en- cil member Margaret Chin, and U.S. sees the BPCA. sure that the selection of any Congressman Jerrold Nadler (along Another public meeting is now operator will support the public with Ms. Brewer), the officials said, scheduled for Thursday, January 8, at good, be stewards of our parklands “as you know, we support a signifi6:00 pm in the Battery Park City and generate a reasonable revenue cant role for community boards in branch of the New York Public Li- stream. Until such time as a new RFP general and the Battery Park City brary (located at 175 North End Av- is released and the final selection is community in the governance of enue, near the corner of Murray made, CB1 asks that the contract BPCA in particular. When a board Street). Called by Battery Park City with the current operator be ex- speaks with a unanimous voice, we resident and Democratic District tended.” The resolution also ex- believe that its position must be given Leader Jenifer Rajkumar, the event pressed “concern and disappoint- serious consideration.” will offer residents and stakeholders ment” with the BPCA’s handling of The BPCA declined to comment the opportunity to speak and share the North Cove Marina bidding on the letter signed by the five opinions about the pending fate of process, and called upon local elected elected officials. North Cove Marina. “This Town officials to meet with the BPCA and Mr. Fortenbaugh said of the Hall meeting is being called to create “work toward implementing the ap- BPCA’s seizure of North Cove, “it’s the opportunity for public comment propriate changes in this process.” very sad, because this is a time of and community input that the BatThe BPCA responded to the year when people would normally be tery Park City Authority never pro- CB1 resolution with a statement say- visiting the marina and asking about vided,” Ms. Rajkumar said. “We want ing, “the North Cove Marina is a memberships or sailing classes for to give voice to the resounding and public asset and as such, the Author- the coming season. Instead, they are overwhelming sentiment in our com- ity is required to select an operator met by security guards who tell them through a competitive bid process. the public is no longer welcome.” Recognizing the value of this asset to He also claimed that the BPCA both the community and the public had been disingenuous in recent at large, the bids requested by the Au- statements that it had offered to let thority require operators to continue him stay in the Marina for 90 days, althe ongoing operation of a sailing leging that the Authority had instead school at a reasonable cost to users offered a “dockage agreement” that as well as enhanced programming allowed two vessels, but placed reand opportunities for greater access strictions on access, use of the vesto the waterfront.” sels, as well as other requireBut local elected officials were ments—including additional security quick to echo CB1’s call for the deposits and a $10 million insurance BPCA to call a halt to the troubled policy (in addition to existing insurRFP process. On December 23, ance coverage). “It is an offer deManhattan Borough President Gale signed to be refused, but allows them Brewer sent a letter to BPCA chair- to say they have offered one,” said man Dennis Mehiel, which said, “the Mr. Fortenbaugh, adding, “perhaps Battery Park City community is very the most revealing clause is that they concerned that BPCA may select a intend to show other potential concession holder who will host lux- lessees around the Marina. This is an ury boats and yachts in lieu of com- exit agreement, not a chance to com- IN BUSINESS D By Suzette espite the American first name and the Portuguese spelling of his last name, Andy Rodrigues is a Frenchman. In high school, he and his best friend, Guillaume Blanchard, became enamored of American entrepreneurs like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates. They loved that these entrepreneurs started with nothing but an idea. While still in business school the friends thought of launching a chain of creperies. “We noticed there are chains of pizza, burgers and burritos, but there is no chain of creperies,” said Mr. Rodrigues. “Probably because crepes are French and French people are not very willing to launch businesses. We French like small things. When we open a store we don’t have the idea to open many the way Americans do.” But the idea was sidelined as school continued. Upon graduation, they had to decide whether to work in finance, a bank, or do something else. Nothing seemed appealing. At lunch in Paris, Mr. Blanchard nudged Mr. Rodrigues and said, “Why don’t we go to Central Park and sell crepes in carts?” Mr. Rodrigues replied mockingly, “We made five years of business studies to sell crepes in a cart?” But, in truth, he loved the idea. As it turns out, Mr. Rodrigues’ wife’s grandmother may be the best crepe maker in France, making them in Brittany for 40 years. An article was even written about Andy Rodrigues her in France’s biggest newspaper. She made just the crepe shells, savory or sweet, on eight crepe grills in her garage. The scent was so heavenly everyone wanted them. Restaurants and retail customers bought them by the dozens or the hundreds. The young partners studied with her, learning her recipes and techniques and later importing the same ingredients she used. A French entrepreneur with a company in New York helped them launch their business, telling them to forget about the cart and that a small store would be easier to get established. In three months they had a plan, and they moved to New York City on June 8, 2013. After finding a space in Tribeca they opened almost a year later on April 8, 2014. Both men realized early on that New Yorkers like food to go so they designed their own packaging. It’s a rather ingenious self-locking box with a pull out drawer to hold one crepe. This keeps it warm longer and lets the customer eat it either one-handed while cradled in the box or with a knife and fork on the flattened drawer. By Suzette 78 Chambers Street 212-321-2626 by-suzette.com —Marti Ann Cohen-Wolf pete in an open and fair process.” “We have asked to meet with chairman Dennis Mehiel and the other members of the Authority Board,” Mr. Fortenbaugh continued, “But they have declined. In the ten years we have operated the Marina, we never once ordered security guards to keep people out. Perhaps that is the difference between a community-based operator and one that is not. But is this the way our government is meant to act?” After the BPCA barred Mr. Fortenbaugh from North Cove, CB1 chair Catherine McVay Hughes reflected that, “a Community Board can’t interfere in a private commercial transaction. But yesterday I walked by the North Cove, and—now that the marina is gone—it is plain for everyone to see that what we enjoyed there was a facility that was vibrant, diverse and neighborhood-oriented. That combination was indispensable to the recovery of Battery Park City and Lower Manhattan after September 11, 2001, and it’s a vital part of our future as a community.” SOUTHBRIDGE PRIVATIZATION continued from page 1 porate entity to itself as a successor. (For example, if Corporation A sells a plot of land to Corporation B, that transaction is taxable. But if Corporation A changes its name to Corporation B, the plot of land is deemed to have been owned by the same entity throughout, and no tax is due.) The case currently before the Court of Appeals relates to a pair of Mitchell-Lama cooperatives in Brooklyn and hinges on the question of whether the new, privatized cooperative is a separate corporation (to which real estate has been transferred) or merely a “reconstituted” successor. But if the panel endorses the former view, the fiscal consequences for Southbridge (and other cooperatives weighing an exit from the Mitchell-Lama program) could be significant. The City’s Department of Finance says that the tax liability for Southbridge in such a case would be $26 million. Regatta New York Realty Licensed Real Estate Brokers Serving Battery Park City for 25 years 300 Rector Place Ste. 3R Bill Graizel [email protected] 212-945-2121 www.regattany.com Gary Seiden [email protected] the broadsheet LETTERS The Broadsheet has been cc’d on many a letter addressed to the BPCA and electeds with regard to the North Cove Marina RFP process. Here is a sample: TO: Dennis Mehiel, Chairman Battery Park City Authority cc’d: The Broadsheet Dear Chairman Mehiel and BPCA Board Members: I am an elected District Leader in Lower Manhattan and a resident of Battery Park City. I am writing concerning the Battery Park City Authority’s current bidding process to select the operator of the North Cove Marina for the 10 years beginning 2015. As District Leader in Battery Park City, I want to ensure that you are aware of the uniform community support throughout the Battery Park City community for Commodore Michael Fortenbaugh’s continued operation of the North Cove Marina. Just two weeks ago, some 400 people gathered in Battery Park City to rally for the continuation of Mr. Fortenbaugh’s leadership of the marina. Commodore Fortenbaugh is widely viewed as a cornerstone of our community. He rebuilt the Marina after the 911 terrorist attacks, opened boats to our community, and set up a sailing school for children. His community-based programming is woven into the very fabric of Battery Park City. I am a resident of Gateway Plaza, Battery Park City’s largest residential complex, with nearly 4,000 residents. Many of my constituents here have expressed to me that if Mr. Fortenbaugh were to lose his lease, it would be a devastating blow to the community. I have heard the same concerns from constituents in Battery Park City South (including Rector Place, Battery Place, and Albany Street) as well as from residents in Battery Park City North (including River Terrace and North End Avenue). I have seen clear indicators of the widespread and uniform support for Mr. Fortenbaugh’s continued operation of the Marina. The Broadsheet, an influential news source in Lower Manhattan, stated in its most recent issue: “In the 17 years during which the Broadsheet has been published, many issues have galvanized readers.. . But no issue (not even the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001) had ever sparked the volume, the passion, or the unanimity [as the issue of Fortenbaugh losing his lease].” The editor continued: “Residents are speaking with one voice, and appear to be resolved with one mind that the community is better served by the facility continuing to be managed by an operator with strong community ties.” Community Board 1 added its voice of support by unanimously passing a resolution calling for the BPCA’s RFP process to be restarted with more community input and transparency, and for the RFP itself to be reformulated to give more weight to community-based programming. The Downtown Independent Democrats (DID), one of Lower Manhattan’s oldest and largest political clubs, unanimously passed a resolution in support of Commodore Fortenbaugh’s bid. Another group of influential small business owners, the Battery Park City Chamber of Commerce, also unanimously voted to support Mr. Fortenbaugh’s application. I urge you to consider the clearly expressed support of Mr. Fortenbaugh throughout the Battery Park City community when selecting an operator pursuant to the RFP. continued on page 2 THE BROADSHEET INC Editor in chief ~ Matthew Fenton BroadsheetDAILY Editor ~ Jack Pickering Contributors ~ Marti Ann Cohen-Wolf, Cora Frederick, Caroline Press, Brian Rogers, Sarah Smedley Advertising manager ~ Kris Frederick Publisher ~ Robert Simko [email protected] 212-912-1106 Next Issue: January 20 Ad Deadline: January 14 [email protected] ISSN# 1539-9060 375 South End Avenue, NYC 10280 To subscribe to the BroadsheetDAILY go to ebroadsheet.com Annual print subscriptions ($60) are available. Page 4 January 6 - 20, 2015 Volume 19 Number 1 Eyes to the Sky January 5 - 11, 2015 Arrivals & Departures Planetary Drama at Dawn and Dusk Cruise Ships in the Harbor As the year 2015 begins, Saturn and Jupiter delight our eyes in the early morning along with the constellations of a stunning, late spring sky. Later, in the very early evening, Venus and Mercury engage in a drama that culminates in their closest pairing, to take place from January 8 - 12. Mars remains a constant, appearing in the southwest at nightfall. Many ships pass Battery Park City on their way to and from the midtown passenger ship terminal. Others may be seen on their way to or from docks in Brooklyn and Bayonne. Stated times, when appropriate, are for passing the Colgate Clock and are based on sighting histories, published schedules and intuition. they are also subject to tides, fog, winds, freak waves, hurricanes and the whims of upper management. Uniquely, right now it is easy for relatively late risers to enjoy the beauty and wonder of celestial dawn. Since Tuesday, December 30, through Saturday, January 10, sunup is at 7:20am, the latest of the year. Given that these are the darkest mornings, the most luminous planets and stars can be seen until about 7am. INBOUND OUTBOUND 4:30p Eastern Caribbean Friday, Jan 2 Norwegian Gem 9:15a Saturday, Jan 3 Queen Mary 2 6:00a (RedHook) 2:30p Transatlantic Quantum of the Seas 6:15a (Bayonne)4:30p Eastern Caribbean 4:30p Southern Caribbean Sunday, Jan 4 Norwegian Breakaway 7:15a Sunday, Jan 11 Quantum of the Seas 6:15a(Bayonne)4:40p Southern Caribbean 4:30p Eastern Caribbean 9:15a Monday, Jan 12 Norwegian Gem 6:30p Cruise to nowhere Friday, Jan 16 Norwegian Breakaway 7:15a 6:00a (Brooklyn) 2:30p Auckland Sunday, Jan 18 Queen Elizabeth Norwegian Breakaway 7:15a 4:30p Southern Caribbean January’s Wolf Moon arrived at full phase at 11:54pm on the 4th, making for several subsequent long nights into mornings lit by a full or nearly full moon. Planet Saturn shines pale yellow rather low in the southeast during the hour before sunrise. The brightest star-like object in the southwest is the planet Jupiter. Jupiter and the waning gibbous moon can be seen rising together in the east around 7:30pm on the 7th, and then traveling the heavens all night until they set in the west on the morning of the 8th. To enjoy planets Venus and Mercury, find a location with an unobstructed view to the Keep watch as Mercury edges up closer to Venus day by day southwest skyline. Brilliant Venus will be close above the spot where the sun set and will disappear into the horizon by nightfall. Less bright Mercury appears below Venus at first. this week. Keep watch as Mercury edges up closer to Venus day by day this week and next. The two will be closer together every evening until they appear side by side on the 8th, closest on the 10th, and on the same plane until about the 15th. Courtesy skyandtelescope.com Judy Isacoff NaturesTurn.org CALENDAR WED 7 Skyscraper Museum Curator's Tour Director Carol Willis will lead a Curator’s Tour on the current exhibition TIMES SQUARE, 1984. Curators tours are free with admission, no RSVP required. Free with admission. 3pm. Skyscraper Museum, 39 Battery Place. www.skyscraper.org Museum of Jewish Heritage Storytime Drop-in story hour series for children ages 0 to 4 and their caregivers. Free. 3:30pm4:15pm. Museum of Jewish Heritage - A Living Memorial to the Holocaust, 36 Battery Place. 646-437-4202. www.mjhnyc.org Budding Bookmakers Budding Bookmakers is designed to introduce students to a wide variety of books and excite them about reading. Each session begins with an interactive book reading followed by an art activity exploring the techniques used by the illustrator. the latest news and DAILY calendar of events in lower Manhattan sign up at: ebroadsheet.com Please confirm information with each individual venue. Details may have changed since we compiled this calendar listing. Author/illustrators studied include Eric Carle, Denise Fleming, Ed Emberly, and Ezra Jack Keats. Presented by Children's Museum of Manhattan. For ages 5 and older. Free. 4pm. New York Public Library, Battery Park City branch, 175 North End Avenue. www.nypl.org A Path Appears This special screening of A Path Appears: Breaking the Cycle of Poverty, follows intrepid reporters Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn and celebrity activists Malin Akerman, Mia Farrow, Ronan Farrow, Jennifer Garner, Regina Hall, Ashley Judd, Blake Lively, Eva Longoria, and Alfre Woodard on a journey across the country, and across the globe, to reveal the incredible adversity faced every day by millions of women and girls, while also presenting glimpses of hope and change. Space limited. Reservations recommended. Free. 6:30pm. Anne Frank Center, 44 Park Place. 212 431 7993. www.annefrank.com Lower Manhattan’s first International Baccalaureate for elementary & middle school Pine Street School combines two globally recognized best practices — Montessori and International Baccalaureate — for a uniquely powerful learning experience. The curriculum includes real world applications, mastery in English and Spanish, community service, travel, substance, diversity and absolute engagement. It is a truly innovative way to prepare students to be problem solvers and thought leaders. Now enrolling Kindergarten, 1st Grade & 2nd Grade for 2015-2016 THU 8 TUE 13 The first of a suite of queer pieces that addresses the representation of the dancer, the physical and emotional labor of performance, tropes about the aging gay choreographer, the interaction of art making with administration, the idea of queer time and futurity, and mid-life anxieties about relevance, sustainability, and artistic burnout. At 6pm and 8:30pm and also on January 9 and 10; check website for times. $20. 6pm. Gibney Dance, 280 Broadway, Entrance at 53 Chambers St. www.gibneydance.org Core Exhibition, which explore Jewish Life a Century Ago; The War Against the Jews; and Jewish Renewal. Interested visitors should meet the Gallery Educator in the lobby of the Museum. The tour is recommended for visitors who are at least 12 years of age. Parents are advised to preview the exhibition and use their discretion. Free with admission. 3pm. Museum of Jewish Heritage - A Living Memorial to the Holocaust, 36 Battery Place. 646-437-4202. www.mjhnyc.org Age & Beauty Part 1: Museum of Jewish HerMid-Career Artist/Suicide itage Guided Tour Drop-in tours include all three floors of the Note or &:-/ FRI 9 Fourth Annual International Maqam Fest The Fourth Annual international Maqam Fest features exceptional ensembles that have a unique approach and perspective on maqam. Developed over millenia, maqam is a complex system of musical modes and represents one of the great legacies of the Arab-Islamic world, pervading musical cultures from the Maghreb (Northwest Africa) to Western China, and from the Balkans to the Sudan. Maqam Fest articulates the tradition of maqam within an evolving world that musically constructs, connects and redevelops convention. Maqam Fest 2015 celebrates a line-up that pays tribute to this tradition featuring long-honored practices, explorations of historic ties between diverse musical styles and an examination of contemporary compositions and improvisations. $30, $25. 7pm. Alwan for the Arts 16 Beaver Street, 4th floor. www.alwanforthearts.com Alexis P. Suter Join us for a tour or an upcoming open house. 25 Pine Street between William & Nassau Sign up for your BroadsheetDAILY and get Open House Dates 11/19, 12/10 9:30-10:30am 5:30-6:30pm Refreshments and childcare will be provided. Space is limited. Please RSVP for a tour or open house at [email protected]. Guided Tours Available on Mon, Wed and Fri at 10am. Early decision application deadline is December 1st. Pine Street School Alexis P. Suter is a rising star on the roots, blues and soul scene. Her powerful bass/baritone voice, seasoned with raw emotion and a wide streak of attitude, has won the praise of greats from B.B. King to Levon Helm. $15. 8pm. Tribeca Performing Arts Center, 199 Chambers Street. www.tribecapac.org Pedestrian Modern: Shopping and Modern Architecture, 1925-1956 Book talk. In "Pedestrian Modern," David Smiley reveals how the design for places of consumption—stores and shopping centers— informed emerging modernist tenets. Tracing the history of architecture’s relationship with retail environments during a time of significant transformation in urban centers and in open suburban landscapes, Pedestrian Modern expands and qualifies the making of American modernism. Free with admission. 6:30pm. Skyscraper Museum, 39 Battery Place. www.skyscraper.org Museum of American Finance Gala This year, the Museum of American Financial History Gala honors David M. Rubenstein, Co-Founder and Co-CEO of The Carlyle Group, one of the world’s largest and most successful private equity firms, with more than $203 billion in assets under management. He will receive the Whitehead Award for Distinguished Public Service and Financial Leadership at the Museum’s 2015 gala. The annual award is named after John C. Whitehead, former Deputy Secretary of State and co-chair of Goldman Sachs, who has headed numerous public service organizations. 6:30pm-9:30pm. Museum of American Finance, 48 Wall Street. 212.908.4110. www.moaf.org Winter Poetry Night The Pen Parentis Literary Salon opens its thirteenth season with its annual Winter Poetry night! Five notable poets — Diana Whitney, Adam Penna, Sarah Gutowski, Jared Harel, and Jennifer Michael Hecht — will read from new works and discuss how they balance a career in poetry with an active young family at home. Free. 7pm. At the Hotel Andaz, 75 Wall Street. www.penparentis.com production combines the iconic voices of Anne Frank and Martin Luther King, Jr. Developed from excerpts from Anne Frank’s The Diary of a Young Girl and Dr. King’s Letter from Birmingham Jail, the piece evokes the important messages from these legendary figures, as they write of their hopes and plans for a peaceful and unified world. Author Jonathan Rieder, professor of sociology at Barnard College, will provide historical context with a reading from his new book Gospel of Freedom: Martin Luther King, Jr.’s Letter from Birmingham Jail and the Struggle That Changed a Nation. A Q&A with the author and actors will follow the program. $8, $5. 6:30pm, Anne Frank Center, 44 Park Place. 212 431 7993. www.annefrank.com Ian Williams and Mantra Percussion Guitarist and composer Ian Williams has been a member of some of the most influential American progressive rock groups: the ‘90s math-rock innovators, Don Caballero; the experimental rock trio, Storm and Stress; and currently the powerhouse pioneers, Battles. He has undoubtedly expanded the aural lexicon of rock and roll through his virtuosic technique and innovative compositional voice. Williams joins Mantra Percussion, hailed by Time Out New York as both “forward thinking” and “superhuman,” for a full evening of intensely driving percussion, guitar and electronics that intersects Williams’ music at its core. Free. 8pm-9pm. Winter Garden. www.artsbrookfield.com FRI 16 Mantra Percussion, Wet Ink & Deborah Lohse and the Shakedown Dance Collective For more than a decade, the New Yorkbased Wet Ink Ensemble has commissioned, premiered and recorded works by many of today’s most promising emerging composers, while also continually collaborating with a broad international range of highlyrenowned artists. For this performance, Mantra Percussion performs three new works written by the founding composers of Wet Ink – Sam Pluta, Alex Mincek and Eric Wubbels – to be accompanied by the beautiful choreography of Deborah Lohse and the Shakedown Dance Collective. Contemporary classical music and the art of percussion will be reinvented and paired with dance to create a unique experience. Free. 8pm-9pm. Winter Garden. www.artsbrookfield.com SAT 17 Hard Hat Area: Introduction to Construction Young learners will be introduced to the basics of skyscraper construction through a group reading of Susan L. Roth's picture book Hard Hat Area. After the story, the young architects will design their own skyscraper. Maybe one day their design will make it to the construction site! Ages 2+. $5. 10:30am-11:45am. Skyscraper Museum, 39 Battery Pl. www.skyscraper.org for more calendar listings, please visit ebroadsheet.com A^XZchZY7dcYZY HeZX^Va^o^c\^c=dbZDg\Vc^o^c\ 9ZXajiiZg^c\ EgZeVg^c\Ndjg=dbZ[dgBdkZh EVX`^c\VcYJceVX`^c\ Call Jessica & Maryann ~ (646) 801-7499 THU 15 Letters from Anne and Martin Join The Anne Frank Center USA in marking Martin Luther King Jr. Day with a performance of the signature theater piece, Letters from Anne and Martin, and a reading by Professor Jonathan Rieder. This original Formerly in Tribeca, Chander Auto Repair has relocated to Mott Haven in the Bronx and for your convenience is now offering Pick Up and Delivery of your vehicle for repairs and NYState Inspection Call Derrick 347-682-7429 [email protected]