A History of High-Rise Council Flats in the Black Country
Transcription
A History of High-Rise Council Flats in the Black Country
LIVING IN THE SKY A HISTORY OF HIGH-RISE COUNCIL FLATS IN THE BLACK COUNTRY FREE PUBLICATION ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This is a small book but it represents a much bigger project – a project which has only been possible with the help and support from dozens of individuals and organisations. Groups which supported the original idea included Sandwell Community Information and Participation Service, Walsall Tenants and Residents Association and Wolverhampton Federation Tenants of Tenants’ Associations, all of whom were partners to the project funding bid. I’m grateful to Corinne Miller at Wolverhampton Art Gallery, Amanda Smith at English Heritage, Ros Watkiss at Wolverhampton University, Malcolm Dick at Birmingham University, and Ian Cawood and Chris Upton at Newman University for their support and encouragement in the early stages of the project. My colleagues in Planning Services at Wolverhampton City Council as well as those at Wolverhampton Culture, Arts & Heritage Service were also very helpful. Of vital importance to the ‘Block Capital’ project, as it became known, was our grant and we are grateful to Heritage Lottery Fund for having the confidence to invest in the idea. The Block Capital project has subsequently benefitted from the time, energy and commitment of more than fifty volunteers whose names are listed on the inside back cover. I would also like to thank everyone who has contributed to our Block Capital digital archive (details on page 20) by either giving time to record an oral history interview, providing images or donating other material. Miles Glendinning has been particularly helpful in 2 allowing us to use his data and images, as has Simon Briercliffe in creating a database of all the high-rise flats in the area. A team of voluteers has also helped in cataloguing the archive, and I would like in particular to thank Jessica Bassam and Dawn Hazlehurst. The staff of the four public archives services in the Black Country have also been of great assistance in providing advice on the project design, training to volunteers, and helping during the sourcing of archive images and other material. Ros Watkiss, Sue Whitehouse and Harriet Devlin have also provided invaluable training to volunteers. I’d particularly like to thank our community engagement officers, Chaz Mason and José Forrest-Tennant for their energy, enthusiasm and patience. Several people have given me useful feedback on the draft of this document including Bob Deacon, Carol Thompson, Cat Fuller, Dawn Hazlehurst, Marguerite Nugent and Meave Haughey. As usual, any errors of any kind remaining in this document are entirely the responsibility of the author. Paul Quigley The distinctly black country network Wolverhampton Art Gallery March 2015 CONTENTS 27 DEMOLITION & RENEWAL 3 A MISREPRESENTED HISTORY? 33 A WORK-INPROGRESS 5 THE BLACK COUNTRY’S PART IN THE STORY 37 LIST OF ORAL HISTORY INTERVIEWS 7 ‘RISING HEAVENWARD’ C 11 ‘LIVING IN THE SKY’ 39 19 ‘IN QUITE A BAD STATE’ 41 20 THE BLOCK CAPITAL ARCHIVE INDEX LIST OF VOLUNTEERS 1 A MISREPRESENTED HISTORY? It is now half a century since the peak of tower-block housing construction in Britain. Over that period millions of people have lived in high-rise flats. As you might expect, in a group of this size there have been different types of people - some have led difficult lives, others have been more successful. Yet the persistent view of the history of high-rise flats in Britain is one of almost unmitigated architectural and social failure. Top: Three blocks on Parkview Road, Stowlawn. Approved by Bilston Municipal Borough Council in 1963, they were named after (from the left) the then leader of the Labour Party, Hugh Gaitskell, and the wartime leaders Winston Churchill and Clem Atlee (Photo taken in 2013 by Matthew Whitehouse, © Wolverhampton City Council) Left: Sandbank Estate in Bloxwich (Walsall), pictured in 2013, is run by a tenant management organisation, an arrangement which the area has been in the forefront of developing. 2 As we were writing this, two incidents illustrated this point. Prince Charles published his ‘geometric principles’ to guide the architects of new buildings – he wrote in a very straightforward way, without room for doubt, that ‘high-rise tower blocks alienate and isolate’. As Prince Charles was writing, a major UK greetings card manufacturer put on sale a ‘comedy’ Christmas card which carried a picture of a high-rise tower block and suggested all its residents were in effect workshy, alcoholic criminals. Recipients of the card were doubtless expected to laugh out of recognition. that it is okay to blame any problems related to British high-rise council housing on either the idea of high-rise itself or, alternatively, on the people who (not even always by choice) have lived in councilbuilt tower blocks. Our investigation of multi-storey flats in the Black Country has found a more complex story. We have found a history in which high-rise blocks have certainly not always led to isolation and alienation, and have sometimes hosted largely happy and active communities. Indeed, in the history we have found, the people who lived in them haven’t always been very different from those living in other types of social housing. One of our Facebook followers summed up a similar view:“I lived in one in late ‘90s for about 3 years. Good neighbours ...not always the horror stories people perceive there to be”. We have found that, although there have been serious design mistakes, a more common cause of past failure has been the way in which the blocks have been managed. The card was later withdrawn, but these events still seemed to support the view 3 In terms of their reputation, tower blocks have coloured many people’s views of the whole British social housing programme, even though they actually only represent a small fraction of it. For that reason alone, a better understanding of their history is not only important in itself, but also because it can help us understand how the history of Council housing more generally has been represented – or perhaps misrepresented. This booklet is based on an archive created by Block Capital, a community heritage project conducted in the Black Country between 2013 and 2015 and supported by a Heritage Lottery Fund grant of £52,500. It draws on more than sixty oral history recordings of tenants, housing officers, planners and construction workers, as well as more than 300 photographs and other historical documents. A large part of the project’s work was completed by volunteers - people who were willing to give their own time out of commitment to the preservation - or rediscovery - of this history. The Black Country’s part in the story In some ways the history of high-rise in the Black Country is like other large urban areas in Britain. But there are key differences. The Black Country has more residents than Birmingham but it is not a city. It does not have the same urban structure as, for example, Manchester, Leeds or Glasgow. Rather than having one centre, it is a network of towns on a disused coalfield. This has affected the development of its public housing in general, and particularly the construction of high-rise flats. Each Black Country town has, historically, had its own local authority and many of these commissioned highrise housing schemes, often with different approaches. City centre land-values have not generally applied. But there have been the extra costs of making large areas of derelict ex-colliery land fit for development. There have not generally been the large outlying estates created by some cities, but rather they have been within the urban area. They have included many scattered blocks built in isolation or in pairs. In the early 1960s the press were still using the word ‘skyscrapers’ to describe the nine-storey blocks at Lakefield Road, Wednesfield. These would later be dwarfed by buildings more than twice as high. Wolverhampton Chronicle, August 1962 (Courtesy Wolverhampton Archives and Local Studies) 4 Lastly, in the late 20th century, some important government attempts to take public housing in the Black Country out of local authority control were withdrawn in the face of local opposition 5 ‘RISING HEAVENWARD’ 1930-55 Top: Arthur Greenwood was the Labour Minister who, in 1930, announced the first subsidy for multi-storey flats. Ten years later after his death he was commemorated in the name of Bilston’s first high-rise tower block and, a year later, his son Anthony Greenwood would visit the Black Country to preside at the official opening of the flats at Bolton Court, Tipton. Right: Arthur Greenwood Court, Bilston (Photo taken in 2013 by Matthew Whitehouse, © Wolverhampton City Council) 6 Plans to build high-rise flats arose at a time of a desperate need for new homes. In mid-20th century Britain the public authorities responsible for urban areas were faced with the task of re-housing thousands of families from substandard Victorian accommodation. In 1948, for example, more than twenty three thousand houses in the central Black Country alone were identified as ‘property which should be condemned’, more than one in every five homes in the area. On top of this, nearly half a million British homes had been destroyed by war in the 1940s. It is often assumed that the expectation that these homes would be replaced, coupled with the lack of available space, pushed local authorities to build upwards. In fact, there were other economic forces at play - in particular central government subsidies. As early as 1930, the then Minister of Health, Arthur Greenwood, announced that a payment would be made from the Exchequer to allow the building of ‘tenements’ above three storeys on expensive land. He said: “Much as I would prefer to see our population spreading out rather than rising heavenward in their dwellings, one has to face the fact that, for a limited number of our people… tenement provision must be made” Later, Aneurin Bevan’s Housing Act in 1946 also added a specific subsidy for lift construction. So, both before and after the war, these subsidies would have influenced discussions in the Black Country and elsewhere about what kind of housing should replace the Victorian streets earmarked for clearance. Multi-storey flats had already been pioneered in continental Europe before the war. Britain followed, with more than eighty blocks having been approved in London by 1948. In 1952, the only residential high-rise flats which had been approved by any English local authority outside London or the South East were in Birmingham, an example being the (still surviving) flats at Duddeston. But by the mid-1950s tower blocks were starting to gain approval in most other English regions. 7 With more than four thousand highrise flats approved by 1957, the West Midlands region had the largest concentration outside the South East. Three quarters of these were in Birmingham, but there were also approvals in the Black Country. The first in the Black Country, in 1953, were a set of six-storey blocks on the Yew Tree estate (later overlooked by the junction of the M5 and M6 motorways), closely followed in 1954 by two much higher eleven-storey blocks on the top of Cape Hill, Smethwick (opposite). The twin blocks of Boulton Place and Murdock Place on Suffrage Street were approved by Smethwick Council in 1954. These images were taken by Joe Russell ten years later and are reproduced with permission of Sandwell Community History & Archives Service. On the bottom right the chimneys of the flats’ open fireplaces are visible and, in the centre, the playground referred to by Marianne Monro (see page 9). 8 However, it is probably fair to say that there was not a clamour to build high-rise flats in the Black Country. The two blocks on Cape Hill, Murdock Place and Boulton Place, stood as the tallest residential buildings in (what is now) the Borough of Sandwell for several years. Their hilltop position would have not only have given their residents a commanding view of both Birmingham and the Black Country but also made them a very visible symbol of a new age in housing design. Murdock Place and Boulton Place, named after local manufacturers, had been designed as a pair of blocks with a public open space between them. But there were plans afoot to construct much larger planned landscapes of multistorey housing. In 1955, on the other side of the Black Country, the Borough of Wolverhampton had just issued its annual handbook to housing tenants with a futuristic impression of the Dale Street flats, a twelve acre development which included the Borough’s first high-rise. In fact, the next two decades - between the mid-1950s and the mid-1970s - saw the construction of all the Black Country’s high-rise council housing. As in the rest of the UK, it was a change in national housing policy which triggered this. Except, as it happens, their design wasn’t all new. Today it seems to clash with our ideas about what is ‘modern’ but the flats in these blocks were heated by open coal fireplaces. Marianne Monro lived in Murdock Place as a child and (in 2014) described the heating arrangements: “We had a coal fire, it was really odd. I didn’t think it was odd at the time, but looking back I’m thinking how did that happen?” 9 ‘LIVING IN THE SKY’ 1956-75 The boom in high-rise construction was in large measure due to the Conservative Government’s 1956 Housing Subsidies Act. This strengthened the payments to local authorities for multi-storey housing first put in place a generation before. It is not clear whether the County Borough of Wolverhampton foresaw this change, but work started at the same time on Dale Street. This was the first post-war reconstruction of an area so close to the town centre and, unlike the flats on Cape Hill, it was also an all-electric affair. Dale Street flats were Wolverhampton’s first high-rise and their opening in 1958 illustrated the very mixed feelings there were to elevated living. The sculptor Charles Wheeler spoke at the opening ceremony and seemed to express the view that flats were inevitable rather than necessarily a good thing: “I am a Victorian and I am not altogether sure that the absence of the little backyard and a little garden is an advantage. But we have to move with the times.” Top: The Graiseley Estate on Dale Street close to its opening in 1958 (courtesy of Wolverhampton Homes). There were also reports that, at least among existing tenants, there was no great desire to swap their house for a flat. Of all Wolverhampton tenants at the time, only 40 responded to an invitation to apply for a flat on the estate. An artist’s impression of Dale Street (from: Martin Cook, ‘Building recording at Wulfruna Court and Grange Court, Dale Street, Wolverhampton’ 2007) 10 The estate included three eleven storey ‘point’ blocks (equalling the height of the Cape Hill flats) and two ‘slab’ blocks - the latter with exterior deck access on each 11 Top: Dale Street flats in 1958 (Courtesy Wolverhampton Archives & Local Studies). Bottom: St Marks Road, Tipton in May 1969. On the right of the road are Jellico and Beatty Houses and, in the far distance, Bolton Court (image by Alan Price, courtesy Keith Hodgkins) floor. This also maximised the number of flats accessing the lift, thereby getting most return on the available subsidy. Along with the Yew Tree Development in West Bromwich, Dale Street was among the first high-rise estates in the Black Country. But, by the end of the 1950s, the use of multi-storey flats in a wider process of house building had spread to several nearby authorities - including Oldbury, Smethwick, Tipton, and Walsall. The County Borough of West Bromwich continued to be the most active. By the end of 1959, it had approved at least 18 blocks, mostly on the Yew Tree Estate. They were not particularly tall - mostly six or eight storeys - but they represented a prolific collaboration with two building firms, Wates and Wimpey, in a way which mimicked Birmingham. Wates would become the largest local builder of highrise - described as a ‘trusty mainstay’ of Black Country boroughs - and erecting two fifths of all blocks in the area. Wates’ Midlands subsidiary operated an unusual approach to the production of prefabricated parts. Most constructors would deliver these from regional production locations. Wates on the other hand liked to operate ‘factories on site’. Another early Wates commission in the Black Country was the construction of two eight-storey blocks on Green Lane, Walsall. With the addition of four later blocks, this would become known as the Burrowes Street estate. opened it to influence from outside the region. One still tantalising link is the one between West Bromwich’s commissioning of the Charlemont Farm estate (starting in 1960) and the development at Meaux, near Paris, which had opened the previous year. Whatever the full story, the physical resemblance was striking. In any case, members of Black Country councils were inspired by visits to London and Birmingham. After seeing 15-storey blocks in Hackey a Halesowen councillor said it “made his own authority, which thought it was progressive, look like a snail which had lost its way”. Thus, by 1964, councils in the south and west of the Black Country had also started approving tower blocks, joining Wolverhampton and those bordering Birmingham. Along with Halesowen, these newcomers included Brierley Hill, Dudley, Rowley Regis and Stourbridge. Meanwhile in the north, Willenhall, Wednesfield, Aldridge-Brownhills and Bilston all built their first high-rise in the first half of the 1960s, the latter naming it’s first block after the former Minister, Arthur Greenwood. Only Coseley, Sedgley and Wednesbury held out - the latter finally approving two blocks in 1966. In 1964 more than half of all council housing built in Britain was flats, and this was also the peak year for high-rise in the Black Country - twenty-eight blocks were completed and a further twenty-five new blocks were approved. Clearly, the Black Country’s use of national and international contractors 12 13 However, despite all this activity, in a wider national debate the tide was now turning against high-rise. This culminated in the subsidy regime for high-rise being ended in 1967 by Harold Wilson’s first Labour Government. This fundamental change in approach came some months before the event which, for many, now symbolises the end of the tower block era. The disaster at Ronan Point, London in 1968 (when an 18th floor gas explosion destroyed one side of a block), is now iconic, but it did not itself cause the end of tower block construction - that was already underway. For a short period at least, a few high-rise continued to be built after both the cut in subsidies and Ronan Point. Between 1967 and 1968 Smethwick started building four towers of more than twenty storeys - ultimately some of the Black Country’s tallest. Wolverhampton had in any case already started building what became the area’s largest concentration of high-rise, the Heath Town estate, including four twentystorey blocks. Designed by the Borough Architect and built by Wates, it replaced the old Victorian heart of the town with a new, Modernist village. The estate consisted of both low and high-rise blocks as well as communal facilities - a shopping centre, pub, school, and coal-powered boiler house which heated all the properties in the development. Officially opened in 1969, it came more or less at the end of the building of multi-storey council flats and, along with the Chapel Street development in Brierley Hill stands as the largest cluster of high-rise in the Black Country. Indeed, only four blocks were approved in the Black Country in the 1970s: two by Wolverhampton in the suburb of Whitmore Reans; and the last high-rise council flats in the Black Country, Alma and Leys Courts in Darlaston which were approved by Walsall in 1973. In all, 275 high-rise blocks were built by Black Country councils. Although this was far fewer than Birmingham (458), it represented a third of all high-rise blocks in the West Midlands. Furthermore, it was more than the total for three English regions (East Anglia, the East Midlands and the South West) and Wales combined. The French Connection? Flats at Charlemont Farm (top), approved by West Bromwich County Borough n the early 1960s, compared with those at Meaux, near Paris, opened in 1959 (Sources: www.skyscrapercity.com and http://astudejaoublie.blogspot.co.uk). 14 15 Top: Joe Russell’s shot of children playing outside Boulton Place (from: ‘Alton Douglas presents Joe Russell’s Smethwick’, 1984, Streetly Printing) Bottom: Ann Worth and her daughter Tracy in their flat on the 4th floor of Moorlands Court, Rowley Regis. Tracy has been a Block Capital project volunteer (image courtesy Mrs Ann Worth) In the period since the 1950s, thousands of Black Country families had been given a new perspective on their neighbourhood as they moved from houses to high-rise flats. Part of the early criticism of multistorey flats, and which led in part to the termination of the subsidy, was that flats were being used to accommodate young children in a way they were never intended to. According to this argument, flats should be used to meet a (newly discovered) post-war demand to provide homes for households of one or two adults, or for families with older children. Young families on the other hand were expected to be accommodated in, for example, the maisonettes often built alongside high-rise. “…they designed (the flats) with a play area with a swing and slide… and it was always ruined…but all the kids would come together… about a hundred of us, and we’d play hide and seek… or this thing called thunder and lightning where we’d knock on someone’s door and run” Kids in tower blocks were even depicted on TV when, in 1969, the animation ‘Mary, Mungo & Midge’ was screened on BBC1. Brendan Hawthorne, who lived in a 7th floor flat, felt it was an attempt to normalise the idea of children in high-rise: “I think it was a actually a cartoon that was made to get kids to appreciate the tower block and to associate with where they lived” Whatever the wider intention, young children did live in Black Country high-rise. Kevin Aston and Brendan Hawthorne, both lived as children in the Bolton Court flats in Tipton from the mid 1960s. Kevin was thrilled by moving in: People who lived in flats as adults during this period are also known to talk about it in positive terms. Winifred Shelly was the first person to move into Highfields Court, Wolverhampton when it opened in November 1967. “I was so chuffed about it that I went to school the one day, and I brought three of my school teachers home to show them the flats – much to my mum’s surprise.” “Well we liked living in the sky” After 48 years, she still lives in the same flat. A six year-old Marianne Monro lived in a 9th floor flat in Smethwick with her sister in the early 1970s: 16 17 Top: Juanita Williams celebrates Christmas in her flat on the Lion Farm estate in Oldbury in the early 1970s. ‘IN QUITE A BAD STATE’ 1976-1995 Bottom: Lion Farm in the 1990s (©Rob Clayton Photographer / www. lionfarmestate.co.uk). Although many high-rise blocks continued to be well-maintained and appreciated by their residents, the 1970s is the period in which some felt that the longer-term problems started to appear. In the context of growing homelessness and unemployment some estates started to house tenants with deeper social problems, and the disaffection which accompanied them affected the blocks’ wider reputation. It has also been argued that these problems were seized upon and exaggerated by the tabloid media which had little sympathy for the ideals of social housing. Whatever the cause, it affected tenants who had previously been comfortable in high-rise blocks. Dave Woodhall had, since 1965, lived on the 9th floor of the 17-storey Ryder House in West Bromwich and described it as ‘a nice place to grow up’. However his family had moved out by 1983: “the flats were going downhill… it wasn’t a pleasant place to live anymore… we knew less and less of the people who had moved in…the neighbour was anti-social, a notorious violent drunk” 18 Lack of maintenance, vandalism and offensive behaviour, the break-up of the first generation of occupants and/or the arrival of newcomers have all been cited as features of the onset of low demand and stigmatisation. The poor reputation of some estates fed a spiral of decline and, in some places a ‘ghettoisation’. This prompted a discussion of who or what was to blame including, as has been mentioned, the idea that high-rise housing was always doomed to failure. In this context, the Thatcher Government’s introduction of ‘Right to Buy’ (RTB) in 1980 was the first and most notorious move to encourage the transfer of housing stock out of local council control. Councils had always been able to sell their houses (indeed the Conservative chair of Wolverhampton’s housing committee was advocating as much in 1969), but until RTB they could not be forced to do so. Combined with a decline of council house building, RTB led to a shrinking public housing stock overall and also an imbalance - more houses than flats were bought. Continued on page 22 19 LOCATIONS OF TOWER BLOCKS IN THE BLACK COUNTRY 1980 THE BLOCK CAPITAL ARCHIVE SANDWELL DUDLEY 1954 1955 1956 1958 1965 1967 1968 1969 1973 1975 1980 1980’s 1985 1986 1989 1990 1995 in io n ol it ts F in irst th d e em Bl o ac lit k ion C s ou o nt f h ry ig hris T e Ac he tio Go n ve in rn iti m a R H aid tive ent ea o st ’s E th n ar s ts ta To pu te Sa wn b r e Tr n us dw riot por te t a el d ba l H as nd ou th on sin e ed g Ac tio n Data provided by Simon Briercliffe, based on the publication ‘Tower Block’ (1994) by Miles Glendinning and Stephan Muthesius L th ate e s Bl t h ac ig k hC ris ou e nt d ry em 1946 1953 WALSALL ‘D re ec vi en ew t s Ho of m hi es gh ’ -ri pro se m p 1945 WOLVERHAMPTON See the catalogue of the archive by visiting distinctlyblackcountry. org.uk/blockcapital/archive or by emailing distinctlyblackcountry@ wolverhampton.gov.uk or, if you live in the Black Country, by asking at your local public archives. G co ov ns ern tru m ct en i Ap on t su in p bs r Bl ov id is ac a es k lo C f lif Fi ou firs t Bl rst nt t 6 ac 1 r y s 1 k -s to C to re ou r y nt ey fla ry b ts lo ck s G bu hi ov ilt gh er in -ri nm se e bo nt s W hi olv om ub gh e si di -ri rh es se am cr op pt ea en on te s ’s fi rs t It is all material collected by volunteers or donated to the project. It includes more than 150 items, including photos, official guidebooks, such as the one marking the opening of the Bolton Court flats (pictured), as well as municipal tenants’ handbooks. It includes testimony from people who have lived in or who have had experience of high-rise blocks such as Dave Cocker (pictured). You can also listen to some of our interviews with current and former residents on our oral history webpage, Sharing Storeys. The archive also includes council reports which led to the demolition of many tower blocks. It features a list of all 275 tower blocks built in the Black Country based on the one published by Miles Glendinning and Stefan Muthesius in their book ‘Tower Block’ (pictured), and mapped opposite. W hi ils gh on -ri G se o Ex su ver b nm fla p ts los sid en in ion y t en E ds H as at W ea t L Ro o n ol th ve T nd an o P r o L ha wn n oin hi ast mp es t gh o to ta -ri f B n te se la op en ap ck ed pr Co Th ov un in ed tr en a y’s rig ac tch c h t e 27 ho oun t to s th r 5 us ci b e l u in y g The archive is a collection of digital resources on the subject of the history of high-rise council housing in the Black Country since the 1960s. 2000 2011 2005 2015 TIMELINE 20 21 Left: This image taken from the twentystorey Bover Court, Wednesfield in 1976 accompanied a news story about a residents’ protest over a broken lift. The flats had only been approved for construction eight years before (courtesy Express and Star). The complete redevelopment of the site of these blocks was, for some years at least, very much an exception. And by no means all high-rise was in dire straits raising questions about was claimed to be the inherent hopelessness of multi-storey flats. In a survey perhaps never to be repeated, Miles Glendinning and Stefan Muthesius viewed first-hand all high-rise blocks in the UK:‘During our own investigations, we visited all multi-storey blocks of public housing in the UK, and were surprised to discover how few were in a state of serious dilapidation - in contrast to high flats’ general ‘media image’’ Other initiatives introduced in the mid-1980s included the Estate Action Programme, which involved councils bidding to the (then) Department of the Environment for funding to improve council estates. Funds were, for example, obtained to improve the Burrowes Street estate in Walsall. Richard Worrell, now a resident of the estate but a local 22 Councillor at the time, describes how this became a turning point in the life of the estate: “During the ‘80s and ‘90s … it was in quite a bad state… we used to call this place ‘The Ice Blocks’…but we were able to get some progress” But it was as if this was the start of a divergence in the journeys taken by different high-rise blocks in the Black Country. Some would go on to survive well into the 21st century, others were deemed to be beyond salvation. The first Black Country blocks to be turned to rubble were among the oldest - the mid-1980s saw the demolition of Boulton Place and Murdock Place in Smethwick. In the Black Country, this media image was influenced by the reporting of a disturbance in Heath Town following a police drugs raid on a local pub in May 1989, reported in the national media as a ‘riot’. Although this may in fact have come at a turning point in the estate’s fortunes, it remains shorthand for the decline of the area and the undesirability of its high-rise. 23 Following the purchase of individual homes under ‘Right-to-buy’, the government opened the possibility of large-scale transfer of council housing to new landlords. Significantly in the Black Country, the Secretary of State attempted a transfer of high-rise and other stock to a proposed Housing Action Trust (HAT) on three estates: Lion Farm in Oldbury; and Cape Hill and Windmill Lane in Smethwick. The move was actively opposed by both tenants and the local authority and was abandoned as a result. However the attempt (and the local response to it) left a mark on both the local skyline and the organisation of both the tenants and local housing authority. Much of Lion Farm was demolished, impetus was given to the growth of a tenants’ movement in the Black Country, and a more decentralised approach to managing council housing was adopted in the Borough. Tenant management organisations (TMOs) started to become significant in the Black Country in the late 1980s and early 1990s. In Walsall they were to take on the management of four high-rise estates - Chuckery, Burrowes Street, Leamore and Sandbank. And by the end of the 1990s there would be eight TMOs in the area. Left: Written at almost the end of the Borough’s high-rise programme, the 1969 tenants’ handbook included several promotional images of tower blocks including, on the front cover, three blocks at Merry Hill flats built two years earlier (Courtesy Wolverhampton Homes). 24 25 DEMOLITION & RENEWAL 1996-2014 By the mid 1990s the challenges of high-rise council housing had provided more fuel for opponents of both multistorey flats and large scale publicallyowned housing in general. The trend was swinging further towards either the transfer out of public ownership or, in the case of high-rise blocks especially, demolition. By the end of the twentieth century 37 tower blocks had already been demolished in the Black Country - the vast majority by Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council. As a housing authority, Sandwell had never commissioned a tower block itself, having only come into existence in 1974. But it was to gain a national reputation for pulling them down. In the ‘80s and ‘90s the Borough’s demolitions had included a large number of the older multi-storey flats built in the 1950s, including 13 of the original 15 blocks on the Yew Tree estate. In the years either side of 2000 the residents of Sandwell were frequently disturbed by the sound of high-rise being detonated. Here onlookers view the explosive demolition of Hamilton House in Smethwick (Images with kind permission ©Phil Hill) 26 In 1995 the Government returned to the idea of transferring council housing en masse to new landlords with the creation of the Estate Renewal Challenge Fund (ERCF). Attracted by the promised funding, Sandwell MBC was one of the early bidders, although the estates identified did not include the Borough’s high-rise. Following a contested ballot of tenants, the vote to transfer was not supported and this rejection, like that of the HAT some years before, would go on to influence the future ownership of public housing in the Black Country. In the same period there were other transfers in the Black Country - for example Sanctuary Housing Association took over the vacant 23-storey Alder House on the Heath Town estate, since renaming it Hampton View. The Labour government’s ‘Decent Homes’ programme from 2000 again spurred councils to transfer their housing stock to a new landlord or at least a separate company to manage it. The first option was taken by Walsall Council and in 2003 its entire stock was passed to two new landlords, Walsall Housing Group and WATMOS. WATMOS was a further development of the local TMOs and it is now landlord for most of the remaining high-rise blocks in the Borough. 27 In Sandwell and Wolverhampton stock transfer was less popular, in part because of the tenants’ rejection of the HAT and ERCF in the 1990s, and instead Arms Length Management Organisations (‘ALMOs’) were created in 2004 and 2005 respectively. Only Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council, with the fewest tower blocks - thirty or so - decided to continue to own and manage its housing stock. But by then the vast majority of towerblock demolitions had already been completed. In the first handful of years of the 21st century a further 34 blocks had been demolished. Sandwell still made the running, disposing of three 17-storey blocks on the Lyng estate in West Bromwich, and Jellico and Beatty Houses in Tipton for example. But this time Wolverhampton and Walsall were also in the fray, demolishing eight and nine blocks respectively. It was the end of the line for three 1950s blocks at Blakenhall Gardens and two 1960s blocks in Darlaston. More surprising was the demolition in 2001 of Leys and Alma Courts, the Black Country’s newest blocks, which had only stood for a little over 25 years. This phase of Wolverhampton’s demolitions had in part been informed by a study published in 2000. This took into account tenants’ views on a range of subjects including the condition of their flat and block, the reputation of the area, and community solidarity. The three Portobello blocks, built by Willenhall in the early ‘60s and later acquired by Wolverhampton, scored lowest in the survey and they were demolished three years later. 28 A similar review by Sandwell MBC in 2007 recommended consulting with residents over the demolition of the surviving blocks of Bolton Court in Tipton and Beaconview House on the Charlemont Farm estate. In the event Beaconview survived and Bolton Court - ‘The Gateway to Tipton’ - finally bit the dust in 2011. This was the last of more than 60 demolitions by Sandwell MBC, about half of which have been carried out by controlled explosion. Beaconview House is only one example of a block reprieved from demolition. Another is St Mary’s Court in Willenhall, closed by Walsall Council in 1997 and earmarked for demolition. A change of plan later saw it sold off instead - it was refurbished by a private construction company and re-opened under a new name, The Pinnacle. Top Left: Bover Court and Wodensfield Tower in Wednesfield, in advance of their recent refurbishment (Photo by Miles Glendinning 1987; University of Edinburgh/Heritage Lottery Fund ‘Tower Blocks’ Project’) Bottom Left: St Mary’s Court was closed by Walsall Council in 1997 and earmarked for destruction. After a review of the economics of demolition, a change of plan saw it sold to the private sector (Photo by Chaz Mason) 29 Indeed, given that a large majority of 1960s tower blocks remain, and that many of those demolished are not so dissimilar from those that are left, the pattern of demolition defies a simple architectural explanation. There are however, one or two marked trends. After Wates, Wimpey was the construction company most used to build Black Country high-rise, but Wimpey’s blocks have not survived as well as those of other large builders. In fact more than half of Wimpey’s blocks have gone, in proportion a loss rate of twice that of Wates. In general, and although it is not difficult to find former occupants who have been glad to see them come down, the trend towards demolition has passed. Only two blocks have been brought down the in Black Country in the last five years, and demolition is not now always seen as the way forward for high-rise flats. Of those that remain, the experience of occupants has varied considerably Wulfruna and Grange Courts were the only high-rise blocks to have been included on Council’s local list of buildings with architectural or historical interest. They were demolished in 2009. Right: Image courtesy Dave Cocker 30 between blocks. Some have provided homes to newcomers to the country: in the early 2000s for example, Heath Town drew national attention for the range of nationalities among the asylum seekers and refugees housed there. Until the arrangement was terminated in 2011, the estate was for some time the largest single concentration of these groups in the Black Country. Partial redevelopment is now proposed on Heath Town, with the removal of most of the 1960s deck access and the use of much of the original green space for individually heated private housing - thus diluting the original vision of a communal boiler facility for the estate. The last few years have seen some elements of the older order return. The arms-length management organisation ‘Sandwell Homes’ returned to direct council control in 2012 and the first council housing in Sandwell for decades was built, as it happened, on the site of a demolished tower block. Across the Black Country, refurbishment supported by the Decent Homes programme has transformed many high-rise blocks, often including brightly coloured exterior thermal cladding. This has provided a sharp contrast to earlier duller concrete and brick exteriors but perhaps also, to the casual observer, disguised their origins in mid-twentieth century postwar housing crisis. 31 A WORK-IN-PROGRESS Within this very brief history, lots of questions remain unanswered about the story of high-rise council flats. However, one issue does seem to be relatively clear: it is difficult to argue that high-rise flats are inherently doomed or somehow always ultimately uninhabitable. While their economics will certainly be questioned, it is clear that multi-storey flats can provide some people with a home they are glad to occupy. Top: The Chapel Street Estate is the largest development of high-rise in the south of the Black Country and on a clear day is visible from the Malvern Hills, 30 miles away. Left: The boiler serving the estate-wide district heating scheme was one of a number of community facilities designed into the Heath Town development in the late 1960s. 32 First there is the inconvenient fact that the Black Country’s tallest residential building was not built in the 1960s but much more recently - in the 21st century in fact. The student accommodation at Victoria Hall is as tall as any council tower block built in the area and its existence seems to suggest that the construction of new high-rise has not been abandoned by everyone. But there are other clues. It might be true that no other type of social housing has been demolished at the same rate as high-rise tower blocks, but often the low-rise or maisonettes built as part of the same development have also been demolished - and sometimes before the high-rise. This seems to suggest that problem is one of failed estates rather than necessarily a failed housing form. Whether the demolitions were all absolutely necessary might also be a question worth asking in the context of the successful refurbishments (and reprieves) which have taken place since. Certainly some of them did not, it seems, take place in the face of clear demand for an alternative use of the land. The sites of former high-rise estates like those at Portobello and Bolton Court have lain vacant for years for example. That said, the stories of urine-in-the-lift, noise, burnt-out garages, and sky-high heating bills are not made up. Multi-storey flats, and no-less those commissioned by councils in the 1960s can be, and have been, at times, horrible places to live. But how then can it be that in the surveys of tenants’ opinions mentioned above there can be such a diversity of responses? While some blocks have been rife with problems and dissatisfaction, others have been appreciated and valued. 33 The answer may be in the tenants’ responses themselves. If their concerns are addressed (and these might include, for example, some attentive security system, thermal insulation, timely maintenance and local facilities) opinions can be positive. Top: Tenants celebrate the refurbishment of Russell House, Wednesbury in 2012 (Courtesy Express and Star). Bottom: Lancaster House, Rowley Regis in 2008 and 2015, before and after refurbishment (Photo on right taken by Matthew Whitehouse, © Wolverhampton City Council) Perhaps the most encouraging story to emerge from this study is the way in which tenants and tenants’ organisations have been able to claim some influence over the management and ownership of high-rise flats in the Black Country. The Black Country has played some part in this story. Both Sandwell and Walsall have, for example, gained national reputations for the achievements of highrise tenants. But there is some way to go. Not only do difficult problems in high-rise housing still persist, but the documented history of council housing in the Black Country is littered with unanswered questions. We hope this study will at least encourage further exploration of a subject relevant to the lives of thousands of local people. If anyone were to read the ‘tenants handbooks’ issued by Black Country local authorities in the 1950s and 60s they could surely only remark that the overtly paternalistic attitudes they represent now appear to be from a completely different age. The fact that they do seem out of time is in part a tribute to the historic change in the position of tenants and the way they are viewed by local authority housing departments. Right : St Anne’s Court and, at the rear, St Giles’ Court were built by Bryant in the early 1960s for Willenhall Urban District Council (Photo taken in 2013 by Matthew Whitehouse, © Wolverhampton City Council) 34 35 ORAL HISTORY INTERVIEWS Heath Town, Wolverhampton in 2012 (Photo taken by Matthew Whitehouse, © Wolverhampton City Council) 36 Interviewee Date of Interview Interviewer Mins. Location Jessica Archer K Aston & P Whiting Tony Bason James Bunce Norman Bracken-Ridge Malcolm Cartridge Vincent Clarke Dave Cocker Victor Collins Barry Cotgrove Luke Caulton Elaine Daws Bob Deacon Geoff Deakin V Foster Thomas Furnival Brendan Hawthorne Mavis Hawthorne June Mary Haydon Jack Hoult David Hubball Don Jones Colin Lewis Wendy Lloyd Godfrey Minay Marianne Monro Madeline Moorcroft Shaun Pritchard Trevor Purcell Sandra Purcell Emma Rennocks Victor Roden Winifred Shelley Elieen Smith Jean Smith Dave Spittle Nicki Statham Martyn Steed Peter Thompson Louise Ward Lynda Whitebeard Juanita Williams 25 Sept 2014 25 June 2014 21 Feb 2015 28 Jan 2015 29 July 2014 25 Sept 2014 07 Aug 2014 29 July 2014 29 May 2014 20 June 2014 25 Sept 2014 25 Sept 2014 26 Nov 2014 25 June 2014 31 May 2014 25 Sept 2014 06 May 2014 25 June 2014 25 Sept 2014 25 June 2014 24 Feb 2015 31 July 2014 02 July 2014 24 Feb 2015 09 Dec 2014 25 Sept 2014 25 Sept 2014 03 July 2014 14 May 2014 14 May 2014 25 Sept 2014 07 Oct 2014 16 Dec 2014 25 Sept 2014 17 June 2014 25 June 2014 25 Sept 2014 30 May 2014 26 Feb 2015 22 July 2014 25 Sept 2014 09 Oct 2014 4 22 29 24 30 10 15 23 26 20 10 22 24 10 9 11 21 22 12 7 42 15 29 29 4 30 11 10 7 20 7 18 33 6 7 7 13 18 22 32 8 21 T Shelly T Shelly R Collins D Cocker P Rodwell D Cocker D Cocker C Bason C Bason P Rodwell H Crawford H Crawford C Bason B Dakin C Bason D Cocker P Rodwell C Bason D Cocker B Dakin P Rodwell C Bason T Shelly C Bason S Pennell P Rodwell A Mohammed C Bason P Rodwell P Rodwell T Shelly C Bason S Pennell T Shelly C Bason T Shelly D Cocker C Bason R Collins D Cocker D Cocker P Rodwell Burrowes St., Walsall Bolton Ct., Tipton Heath Town, W’ton Graiseley Estate, W’ton Grosvenor Ct., Wednesfield Burrowes St., Walsall Long Ley, Heath Town Various, W’ton Longfield Hse., Heath Town Darley Hse, Rowley Regis Regent Hse., Burrowes St. Burrowes St., Walsall Heath Town Bolton Ct., Tipton Heath Town, W’ton Burrowes St., Walsall Bolton Ct., Tipton Bolton Ct., Tipton Burrowes St., Walsall Bolton Ct., Tipton Eve Hill, Dudley Various Wilson Hse., Lion Farm Whitmore Reans Heath Town, W’ton Various, Sandwell Burrowes St., Walsall Various St Giles Ct., Rowley Regis St Giles Ct., Rowley Regis Burrowes Hse. Arthur Greenwood Ct Highfields Ct., W’ton Burrowes St., Walsall Heath Town, W’ton Bolton Ct., Tipton Burrowes St., Walsall Heath Town, W’ton Wychbury Ct., Dudley Blakenhall Estate, W’ton Burrowes St., Walsall Chiltern Hse., Lion Farm 37 Interviewee Date of Interview Interviewer Mins. Location Dave Woodhall Richard Worrall A & R Worth (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) (Anonymous) 02 Oct 2014 25 Sept 2014 3 Feb 2015 06 Aug 2014 06 Aug 2014 10 Aug 2014 25 Sept 2014 10 Aug 2014 18 July 2014 25 Sept 2014 11 Aug 2014 21 May 2014 10 Aug 2014 25 June 2014 07 Oct 2014 25 June 2014 18 11 17 4 8 11 14 21 6 12 22 12 18 7 8 7 P Rodwell A Mohammed P Rodwell T Shelly T Shelly C Bason D Cocker C Bason T Shelly D Cocker C Bason T Shelly C Bason C Bason C Bason T Shelly Ryder Hse., West Bromwich Burrowes St., Walsall Moorlands Court Bolton Ct., Tipton Moorlands Ct., Rowley Regis Heath Town, W’ton Burrowes St., Walsall Heath Town, W’ton Romsley Ct., Queens Cross Burrowes St., Walsall Heath Town, W’ton Darley Hse Rowley Regis Heath Town, W’ton Bearwood Hse., Smethwick Arthur Greenwood Ct., Bilston Shelley Ave., Tipton Chervil Rise on the Heath Town estate, Wolverhampton (Photo by Miles Glendinning 1987; University of Edinburgh/Heritage Lottery Fund ‘Tower Blocks’ Project) 38 INDEX 1930s, 6, 7 1940s, 7, 20 1950s, 7, 9, 11, 17, 20, 25, 27 1960s, 13, 17, 20, 27, 29 1970s, 9, 15, 17, 19, 21 1980s 19, 21, 22, 23, 25 1990s 18, 21, 25, 27-30 2000s, 21, 26-31, 34 2010s, 21, 29, 31, 35 Alder House, 27 Aldridge-Brownhills, 13 Alma Court, Darlaston, 15, 29 ALMOs, see Arms Length Management Organisations Aneurin Bevan, 7 Arms Length Management Organisations, 29, 31 Arthur Greenwood, 6, 7, 13, 37 Asylum seekers, 31 Beaconview House, West Bromwich, 29 Beatty House, Tipton, 12, 29 Bilston, 2, 6, 12, 13 Birmingham, 5, 7, 9 Blakenhall Gardens, 27 Bolton Court, Tipton, 12, 17, 20, 21, 29, 33, 37 Boulton Place, 8, 9, 16, 23 Bover Court, Wednesfield, 22, 23, 28 Brierley Hill, 13, 15 Burrowes Street, 13, 22, 25, 37 Cape Hill, 9, 11, 25 Chapel Street, Brierley Hill, 15, 32 Charlemont Farm, 13, 14, 29 Charles Wheeler, 11 Children, 9, 16, 17 Chuckery, 25 Cladding, 31 Clem Atlee Court, Bilston, 2 Coal, 5, 9, 15 Coalfield, 5 Coseley, 13 Criminals, 3 Dale Street, 9-13, See also Graiseley Darlaston, 15, 21, 29 Decent Homes, 21, 27, 31 Deck access, 11, 31 Demolition, 20, 21, 23, 26, 27, 29-31, 33 By controlled explosion, 26, 29 Dilapidation, 23 Duddeston, 7 Dudley, 13, 21, 29 East Anglia, 15 East Midlands, 15 Estate Renewal Challenge Fund, 27, 29 Estate Action, 21, 22 Families, 7, 17 Government, 5, 7, 11, 15, 19, 20, 21, 25, 27 Graiseley estate, Wolverhampton, 10, 20, 37, See also Dale Street Grange Court, Wolverhampton, 10, 11, 30 Green Lane, Walsall, 13 Hackey, 13 Halesowen, 13 Hamilton House, Smethwick, 26 Hampton View, 27 Harold Wilson, 15 HAT, See Housing Action Trust Heath Town, 15, 20, 21, 23, 27, 31, 37, 38 Heating, 9, 32, 33 Highfields Court, 17 Housing Action Trust, 21, 25, 27 Hugh Gaitskell Court, Bilston, 2 Jellico House, Tipton, 12, 29 Land-values, 5 Leamore, 25 Leys Court, Darlaston, 15, 29 Lift construction, 7 Lion Farm, 18, 25, 37 London, 7, 13, 15, 20 39 Maisonettes, 17, 33 Mary, Mungo & Midge, 17 Merry Hill flats, Wolverhampton, 24, 25 Miles Glendinning, 23 Modernist, 15 Murdock Place, 8, 9, 23 Neighbours, 3, 19 Newcomers, 13, 19 Oldbury, 13, 18, 25 Paris, 13 The Pinnacle, 29 ‘Point’ blocks, 11 Portobello, 29 Prefabricated parts, 13 Private housing, 28, 29, 31 Public open space, 9 Refugees, 31 Reputation of high-rise, 5, 19, 29 Right-to-buy, 19, 23, 25 Ronan Point, 15 Rowley Regis, 13 Russell House, Wednesbury, 34 Ryder House, 19 Sanctuary Housing Association, 27 Sandbank, 2, 25 Sandwell, 8, 9, 21, 25- 27, 29, 31, 35, 37 School, 15, 17 Sedgley, 13 Smethwick, 9, 11, 15, 17, 20, 23, 25, 26, 38 South West, 15 St Mary’s Court, 29 Stefan Muthesius, 20, 23 Stock transfer, 27 Stourbridge, 13 Stowlawn, Bilston, 2 Subsidies, 11 Subsidy by government, 7, 11, 15, 17 Tenant management organisations, 2, 23, 25 Tenants, 2, 5, 9, 11, 19, 20, 25, 27, 29 Thatcher, 19 40 The Lyng estate, 29 The Pinnacle, 27 Tipton, 6, 11, 12, 13, 17, 29, 37 TMOs, See Tenant Management Organisations Victorian, 7, 11, 15 Wales, 15 Walsall, 2, 11, 13, 15, 21, 22, 25, 27, 29, 35, 37, 38 Walsall Housing Group, 27 War, 7, 11, 17 Wates, 13, 15, 31 WATMOS, 27 Wednesbury, 13, 34 Wednesfield, 13 West Bromwich, 11, 13, 19, 29 West Midlands, 9, 15 Whitmore Reans, 15 Willenhall, 13, 29 Wimpey, 13, 31 Winston Churchill Court, Bilston, 2 Wodensfield Tower, Wednesfield, 22, 23, 28 Wolverhampton, 9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19, 29 Wulfruna Court, Wolverhampton, 10, 11, 30 Yew Tree, 9, 11, 25 VOLUNTEERS The Block Capital project volunteers have been: Andrew Howlett; Andy Lopez; Anna Silvani; Ben Hall; Brendan Hawthorne; Brian Dakin; Chris Parsons; Christine Bason; Clive Wilson; Damian Hansford; Dave Cocker; David Burbidge; Dawn Hazlehurst; Derek Woodmass; Elaine Powney; Eve Phillips; Glenys Roberts; Greg Worwood; Hannah Crawford; James Yates; Jessica Bassam; Julie Wilde; Kari Nyakunu; Kate Gomez; Leah Bond; Lewis Barton; Louise Thomas; Luke Price; Marian Innes; Mary Cartwright; Mary Collins; Matthew Terry; Matthew Whitehouse; Morgan Miller; Nicholas Banda; Pat Rodwell; Phillip Pennell; Ray Parton; Rosalind Watkiss; Roxie Collins; Ruth Beardsmore; Sal Pennell; Shaun Pritchard; Simon Briercliffe; Stephen King; Susan Dangor; Susan Woolnough Holt; Tony G. Bason; Tracy Shelly; Victoria Hillman; and Wendy Lloyd. LIVING IN THE SKY A HISTORY OF HIGH-RISE COUNCIL FLATS IN THE BLACK COUNTRY The Block Capital Project A Participative History of High Rise Council Flats A distinctly black country project, supported by Heritage Lottery Fund In association with Sandwell Community Information and Participation Service, Walsall Tenants and Residents Association and Wolverhampton Federation Tenants of Tenants’ Associations. Copies of this booklet can be obtained by contacting: Wolverhampton Art Gallery WAVE (Wolverhampton, Arts, Venues, Experiences) Wolverhampton WV1 1DU [email protected]