ILMC Technnical Review print version with appendices
Transcription
ILMC Technnical Review print version with appendices
Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD Recycling of ULAB in Central America and the Caribbean Brian Wilson, ILMC ILMC Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Environmentally Sound Management of Used Lead Acid Batteries in Central America and the Caribbean Basel Convention Project Workshop San Salvador El Salvador November 18 – 20 2002 Recycling of ULAB in Central America and the Caribbean A Technical Review Brian Wilson International Lead Management Center 1 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Uses of LAB § Automobiles, trucks & buses CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute § Electric vehicles & wheelchairs § Standby and peak loading § Telephone systems UNCTAD ILMC § Computer systems – UPS § Remote Area Power Supply § Domestic power Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Uses of Lead Acid Batteries Lead-acid batteries either start or power cars, trucks, buses, boats, trains, rapid mass-transit systems, recreational vehicles and electric wheelchairs all over the globe. The car battery also provides a stable electrical supply to a vehicle’s electrical system. During power outages, lead-acid batteries provide quiet, pollution-free emergency power for critical operations such as air-traffic control towers, hospitals, railroad crossings, military installations, submarines, and weapons systems. This is when lead-acid batteries come to the rescue, as enormous arrays of batteries delivering large amounts of electricity for short periods of time until additional capacity is added to the grid. In these situations the telephones stay on and this is because every major telephone company in the world, including mobile telephone service providers, uses lead-acid batteries as backup power to the telecommunications systems. In the office and at home many of you have units to provide an “uninterrupted power supply” (UPS) for computer systems. Increasingly in remote areas of the region lead acid batteries are being coupled with solar panels to store energy generated by the sun during the day to provide electrical power at night to the local communities. Furthermore in many parts of the region where electrical power supplies are not reliable many households keep a 12 volt lead acid battery as a domestic standby power supply for lighting and television. 2 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Benefits of Recycling § § § § § § § § § ULAB in approved storage Saves natural resources Pb is recovered and reused Plastic is recycled Good environmental practice Reduces exposure risks No landfill Protects the future Creates jobs Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Benefits of Recycling All of the reports documented recovery activities for ULAB ranging from collection right through to recycling. However, due to the adverse environmental and occupational health effects widely reported it is important to remind ourselves why environmentally sound ULAB recycling should be encouraged. First of all if there is the necessary infrastructure, regulation and financial incentives to promote recycling, then ULAB would be stored under cover in safe and environmentally sound conditions. Valuable resources such as lead and polypropylene and increasingly the battery acid would be recovered and reused. Such recycling operations represent good environmental practice, especially for non-ferrous metals as recycled materials normally require four times less energy to produce than primary commodities and in the case of lead it reduces the environmental footprint of mining operations. Well managed recovery operations for ULAB from collection to the production of refined lead ingots reduce the threat of population lead exposure from the illicit dumping of ULAB into municipal landfill sites or “backyard” recycling that blights many communities around the world. In this small way a contribution can be made to protect the environment for future generations. In addition there is a social dimension because recycling of ULAB creates jobs and provides an invaluable income for many small businesses and families. 3 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Methods of Recycling Formal Sector Informal Sector CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Regulated Structured Unregulated Opportunist Collectors Integrated Scavengers Fragmented Recyclers Reconditioners Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Methods of Recycling The studies readily identify two distinct industrial sectors, that is, the “formal” and “informal” sectors. Examination of these two sectors shows that the “formal” sector comprises licensed and regulated businesses, and the “informal” sector is made up from a multitude of shops and garages, some registered, some not, but all earning a living by whatever means including legitimate as well as environmentally unfriendly activities. Those companies in the formal sector are structured with a developed customer and resource base while those in the informal sector rely on opportunities and good fortune. This means that the formal sector collect ULAB through an established network of retailers and suppliers, whereas the informal sector tend to be “scavengers” relying on whatever can be found wherever that might be. Two of the main secondary lead smelters in the region are fully integrated companies, in that, other divisions in the group are battery manufactures and rely on the smelting division to provide the refined lead. The informal sector do not have a main customer base, but are somewhat fragmented in their activities, sometimes making fishing weights from lead recovered from ULAB and on other occasions selling the lead bullion to the battery manufactures. In essence the formal sector comprises of organizations that are focused on recycling ULAB and are almost exclusively part of large corporations or dealerships with international partners or trading links that require environmentally sound management as a key business principle. The informal sector, however, is a mixture of some battery retailers that send the majority of ULAB collected to a licensed recycler while also engaging in battery reconditioning in small backroom workshops causing acid and lead contamination of the sanitation system; and others who produce lead bullion by melting and smelting ULAB without any control mechanisms in the most environmentally unacceptable way. 4 Inter-Relationships Battery Reconditioner Unregulated Recycler Used Battery Collection Battery Retailer DUMP Licensed Recycler Battery Manufacturer Life Cycle Scenarios of the Lead Acid Battery It is helpful when considering battery recycling to examine possible life cycle scenarios in order to determine likely sources of information. For example: • A battery manufacturer will sell a battery to a retailer • The retailer will sell the battery to the owner of a vehicle • When the battery is “spent” the vehicle owner will need a replacement and he could return the used battery to the retailer for recycling and a possible discount on the new battery. • In which case the retailer will send the battery to a licensed recycler and the recovered lead will be sold to the manufacturer. The non metal components will also be treated in a environmentally sound manner, some recycled, others neutralized prior to disposal. • A battery manufacturer will sell a battery to a retailer • The retailer will sell the battery to the owner of a vehicle • When the battery is “spent” the vehicle owner will need a replacement and he could return the used battery to the retailer for recycling and a possible discount on the new battery. 5 • In which case the retailer will send the battery to a licensed recycler and the recovered lead will be sold to the manufacturer. The non metal components will also be treated in a environmentally sound manner, some recycled, others neutralized prior to disposal. • However, the retailer might not take back used batteries and the vehicle owner may have to take the used battery to suitable used battery collection point. • The battery scrap collector will then send the used batteries to the licensed recycler for recovery of the recyclable materials. • However, depending on the prevailing market conditions there might be a better financial reward for the vehicle owner if the used battery was sold to a battery reconditioner. Sometimes a reconditioner can reclaim a used battery by cannibalizing another and using those components with some “life” left in them. These reconditioned batteries will not have a long life, but often find a ready market amongst the poorest in society. • Those “spent” components that the reconditioner cannot reuse are usually sold to an unlicensed recycler, often referred to as a “backyard” recycler. This secondary lead sector of the industry is called the “informal” sector, although a more appropriate term would be “unregulated” as operating practices will rarely conform to sound environmental and occupational performance standards. • In order to establish an accurate picture of the life of a battery in Central America account must be taken of all of the possible scenarios outlined above. • Nevertheless, the informal secondary lead sector will often supply the battery manufacturers and the licensed recyclers with unrefined lead bullion. Anther outlet for the lead bullion produced by the informal sector is fishing sinkers. • Sometimes the vehicle owner is unable to take a used battery to any recycling collection point and the battery is disposed of in the nearest municipal “dump”. This scenario not only poses serious long term problems for the environment, but is a loss of a valuable resource. • Where municipal authorities have sorting facilities, any used batteries are segregated and either sent to the nearest used battery collection point for shipment to a licensed recycler or directly to the licensed recycler. • In many cases, particularly in the developing world, scavengers scouring rubbish dumps for anything of value will recover the used battery as a saleable recyclable commodity and sell it to a secondary lead plant, usually an unlicensed recycler. 6 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Collecting ULAB Retail Outlets • Deposit/discount scheme Garages and Repair Shops • Exchange for reconditioned LAB Breakers and Spares Shops • ULAB removed from vehicles Scavengers & Community Groups • Waste dumps and car wrecks • Houses Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Collecting ULAB There are many ways that ULAB are collected. By far the most efficient is through the battery retailer where a discount is given against the purchase price of a new battery provided the customer returns the used battery. In some countries a deposit has to be paid when a new battery is purchased and is only returned to the customer when the battery is returned to the retailer for recycling. However, other sources of ULAB have been identified, in particular garages and repair shops where new and reconditioned batteries are offered for sale. In the Caribbean islands there is a thriving second-hand auto trade and thousands of used Japanese cars are imported into the region every year to be broken up for spares. Many of these vehicles have a used lead acid battery, which is removed from the vehicle and shipped to Venezuela for recycling. Finally there are those in local communities, sometimes in groups, that scavenge for discarded materials that can be reused or recycled. They will scour waste dumps, strip abandoned vehicles and wrecks and even collect LAB that have been used for standby power in domestic houses. 7 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Basel Guidelines Section 3.2 Collecting CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute 1. Infrastructure 2. Economic incentives UNCTAD ILMC 3. Control Measures ü Do not drain electrolyte ü Use secure storage Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Basel Guidelines for the Recovery of ULAB, Section 3.2 - Collecting Technical Guidelines for the Environmentally Sound Management of Lead Acid Battery Wastes were adopted by the Technical Working Group and are to be considered by the Conference of the Parties (COP) in December. Section 3.2 deals with Collecting ULAB and the guidelines advocate that: 1. The only way to implement a successful lead acid battery recycling program is to install an appropriate and efficient lead acid battery collection infrastructure. 2. The most spontaneous process of ULAB collecting occurs through the dual system of distribution and collection when manufacturers, retailers, wholesalers, service stations and other retailing points provide new batteries to users and retain the used ones to be sent to recycling plants. Such a scheme is sustainable because is is based on the economic value associated to the lead content of the ULAB. 3. Some control measures must be carried out at the collection points in order to minimize the risk of accidents that may cause personal injury or environmental contamination. Batteries should not be drained at collection points: The drainage of battery electrolyte poses threats to human health and the environment because: a) It contains high lead levels as dissolved ions and suspended particles. b) It is highly acidic and may cause burns to the skin if accidentally spilled. c) The high acidity of the battery electrolyte is detrimental to plant growth. ULAB should be stored in a secure compound: to minimize the risk of accidental spillage, to allow any batteries found to be damaged or leaking to be contained and to provide a safe workplace. 8 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC ULAB Storage § Store on impermeable surface § Store batteries upright § Store leaking batteries in sealed 5 gallon plastic drums § Provide • water wash down supply • Drainage and a sump • PPE/first aid Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB ULAB Storage Always store ULAB under cover on flat even impermeable surfaces and if they are being stored on asphalt or concrete, coat the surface with an acid-resistant epoxy, fiberglass or plastic coating, otherwise pave the area with upturned concrete filled heavy polypropylene used battery cases, as “Baterias de El Salvador” have done in their water treatment plant, in order to create an impermeable surface. Store batteries upright to prevent leaking from any vent holes or cracked or missing caps. It is important to inspect and electronically test all ULAB to determine whether battery could be recharged and reused. This practice is a legitimate and worthwhile activity because firstly it ensures that any batteries still charged are identified and thereby reduces the risk of sparking during transit; and secondly it returns some batteries to the market without the need for recycling while earning the collector additional income. It is surprising how many batteries that just need recharging are discarded or dispatched for recycling. I only observed this practice in Mexico City and whilst I am sure that it is more common than that more collectors should be encouraged to adopt these practices. Sealed five-gallon plastic (polyethylene) drums are adequate for storing a leaking or cracked battery. Wherever ULAB are stored ensure that there is: • Water to wash down the storage area and any batteries that are leaking • Drainage to an isolated sump to contain any spillage of acid or lead oxide • Personal protective equipment (PPE), namely neoprene gloves, safety glasses, steel capped safety boots/shoes, dust mask, overalls and a first aid kit with eye wash water bottles. (Also recommend – shower) 9 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC ULAB Storage The innovative use of polypropylene battery cases to provide an acid resistant floor at the Baterias de El Salvador plant Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CAR IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ULAB Storage Covered drainage channel at the Comercializadora de Baterias SA storage yard in Mexico City. ILMC Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB 10 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales ULAB Storage CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Local Collection Points It was evident from the studies that local ULAB collection facilities were not necessarily easy to manage. ULAB were often stored on open ground at the rear or the side of a retail shop, or a garage or even a house. Occasionally ULAB were seen to be stored in the street outside a repair shop. Such storage practices are most unsatisfactory as acid can leak uncontrollably and children can “play” with the batteries. Nevertheless, it is difficult to police or monitor such activities at a local level and in similar circumstances an idea has been developed in the Philippines to resolve this problem. The solution adopted in the Philippines was the introduction of wire mesh cages on wheels. The cages are made of stainless or heavy gauge steel with a open mesh floor and wheels running on nylon bearings. The cages are chained to the outside of the shop or garage and the ULAB are placed inside the cage, which also has a lockable lid to prevent anyone removing a ULAB. Use of a cage eliminates the risk of the build up of explosive gases and keeps the ULAB of the ground, enabling any spillage to be seen and the appropriate action to remove the contamination taken. The cages can also be used to send the ULAB to the local collection center, provided they are secured to the inside of the vehicle used for transport. Such use of the cages also minimizes the need to handle the ULAB, thereby reducing the risk of accidents and personal injury. In Manila these cages can be seen positioned adjacent to garages, repair shops and even in local communities. 11 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Basel Guidelines Section 3.3 Transporting 1. Pack the ULAB well 2. Use sealed containers 3. Label the hazardous waste 4. Safety • Equipment and PPE • Notify scheduled route • Trained staff Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Basel Guidelines for the Transport of ULAB, Section 3.3 – Transporting ULAB must be considered as hazardous waste when making arrangements to transport them to the recycler. Once again the main risk is associated with the battery electrolyte which may leak from ULAB in transit. It is therefore vital to package the ULAB in a manner that renders batteries easy to move mechanically while reducing the risk of any movement during transit to avoid damaging the battery cases. As a further precaution the guidelines recommend that the UALB are transported in a sealed shock resistant container that will not leak any electrolyte in the event of unforeseen leakage. The vehicle used to transport the ULAB, whether it is a ship a truck or a van, must be correctly identified, following international conventions and local legislation using the appropriate symbols and colors to identify the fact that corrosive and hazardous waste is being transported. Due regard must be given to safety of those transporting the ULAB and anyone else who may have to assist in the event of an accident. Each vehicle should have a set of equipment necessary to combat any simple spillage or leakage problems and there should be personal protective equipment available to wear. The appropriate authorities and emergency services should be notified of the transport route and wherever possible a route should be chosen that minimize the risk of possible accidents, avoids populated areas or other specific problems. Finally it must not be forgotten that it is important to train personnel that have to transport hazardous wastes in emergency procedures, including fire, spillage and skin burns. It is also essential they they know how to contact local and national emergency response teams. 12 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Packaging Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Mate Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Auto AutoAuto MateMate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate UNCTAD Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate ILMC Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Auto Mate Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Packaging I saw two examples of good practice in the packing of ULAB for transport to the recycler. Both the companies, “Comercializadora de Baterias SA” in Mexico City and “Automotive Components Ltd. (ACL) in Trinidad use similar procedures. Prior to packing it is important to ensure that all the ULAB have the vent caps shut to avoid spillage during shipping. If possible replace a missing vent cap or seal the inspection hole. Obtain a selection of caps from your nearest smelter and always have them readily available. None of the reports commented on what to do with damaged batteries that might be prone to leaking. From a practical point of view damaged batteries can be transported with intact batteries if they are properly contained in sealed plastic containers or drums. ULAB should be stacked onto wooden pallets or skids no more than four high to minimize the risk that the stack will become unstable. A sheet of corrugated heavy duty cardboard is placed between each layer of batteries to reduce movement, absorb any electrolyte that might spill and prevent the terminal posts from the batteries puncturing the plastic case of the battery stored above. A sheet of corrugated heavy duty cardboard is also placed on top of the final layer of ULAB so that the palletised ULAB can be stored on top of each other. Finally the whole stack is shrink wrapped in plastic as tight as possible to minimize any movement during transit. When storing palletised ULAB prior to transportation or shipment the layers of pallets should not be stacked more than two high. Working practices at ACL were to the highest safety standards and employees handling and packing the batteries were wearing personal protective equipment, including steel toe capped shoes, goggles, dust masks, neoprene gloves and overalls. 13 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Packaging CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Stacked & shrink wrapped on a skid Comercializadora de Baterias SA Mexico City, Mexico Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Packaging CAR IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Stacked & shrink wrapped on skids Automotive Components Ltd. Trinidad and Tobago. Tobago. Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB 14 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Recycling Technologies Rotary Furnace § Mexico Enertec § El Salvador Baterias de El Salvador § Dominican Republic MetaloXsa Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Recycling Technologies The most common smelting technology employed to recycle ULAB in the Region is the Rotary Furnace or Kiln. It is the chosen technology in Mexico at the Enertec secondary lead plant in Monterrey, in El Salvador at the Baterias de El Salvador recycling and battery manufacturing plant just outside San Salvador and in the Dominican Republic at the MetaloXsa lead oxide and secondary lead plant. Rotary furnace technology has a long pedigree in the non ferrous metals industry and is widely used in Europe and the Far East because it is so versatile and can smelt almost any leaded material including all the refining and battery manufacturing by-products and flue dusts. Its only drawback is that the traditional use of soda ash (sodium carbonate) flux produces a leachable and degradable furnace residue that cannot pass the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP) test and is therefore classified as a hazardous waste. However, in recent years Rotary Technology has been given a new lease of life with the development of charging and smelting procedures that produce an inert non toxic and non hazardous waste that passes the TCLP test and can be disposed of safely in landfill sites together with domestic waste. Indeed this is the case in Monterrey, where Enertec are able to dump their inert and stable furnace residues in the local non hazardous landfill site. The two main technologies that enable Rotary furnaces to produce inert and stable residues are Lead Metal Technologies and Boliden Contech. 15 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD “Green slag” Process Rotary Furnace Technology Secondary & By–Product Materials • New concept - fully computer controlled smelting process. • Unique charge preparation procedures & smelting process controls consistently guarantee non-hazardous residue. ILMC Stable and Inert “Green slag” Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB “Green slag” Process Over the past 7 years the Mexican based Lead Metal Technologies has developed and improved the rotary furnace smelting of secondary lead materials to achieve the production of a non-hazardous “Green Slag” complying with the stringent USA EPA TCLP standards. In order to produce a “green slag” existing Rotary Furnaces will need to be re-engineered with specialized auxiliary equipment and the smelting process controlled by a specially written Lead Metals Technologies software program, in conjunction with carefully blended and precise charge materials, including refinery by products and baghouse fume. (Typically 5 different charge mixes) The process has been successfully commissioned at leading secondary Lead recycling operations in Canada, Mexico, Venezuela and Brazil. In fact it is this technology that is used at the Enertec Smelter in Monterrey. Joe Littleton USA Director, Lead Metal Technologies, Inc., New Port Richey, Nr. Tampa, Florida. Tel/fax 1 - 727 857 1230 16 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Kaldo Furnace CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Boliden Contech Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Kaldo Furnace Boliden’s Kaldo Process is a based on a rotary furnace design, but the furnace is angled so that the burner flame can be directed onto the liquid bath. It was primarily developed for smelting of lead concentrates (sulphides or carbonates), but can also be used for secondary materials such as ULAB, by products and drosses. The lead oxides and sulfates are smelted by mixing fluxes and a reducing agent in the furnace, such as coke breeze, followed by smelting with an oxygen/fuel burner. The Kaldo furnace’s tilting technology also incorporates oxygen flame enrichment to reduce smelting cycle times and lower the back pressure on the furnace enabling a significant reduction in the ventilation requirements. The technology can be scaled to suit the expected material throughput and has eliminated the use of soda-based fluxes so that an inert stable slag that passes the TCLP test is produced. BOLIDEN CONTECH AB P.O. Box 745 SE-931 27 SKELLEFTEÅ Sweden Tel: +46 910 876 00 Fax: +46 910 890 50 E-mail: [email protected] Internet: www.boliden.com 17 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Rotary - Center Tapping Tap hole CA R IRI Door Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD Burner ILMC Tap hole Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Rotary Hygiene Control Whilst the Rotary furnace technology is suited to the smelters in the region some of the furnaces in use have the tap holes in the center of the furnace drum. This design does enable the furnace to be completely drained, but at the lead tapping temperature, fugitive emissions are very difficult to control as the fume rises around the whole furnace. Employees working in such conditions will be exposed to high lead in air levels and without respiratory protection could be poisoned. Furthermore lead fumes that are vented to atmosphere will exposure any populations living or working close to the smelter to lead contamination. The fumes can be contained if a large hood is used to completely encapsulate the furnace. However, such a large hood will restrict the tapping operation and be very expensive to operate because the electrical demand required to a power the extraction fans necessary to produce an air flow of at least 1m/s will be expensive. 18 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Rotary – Front End Tapping Tap hole CA R IRI Door Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Burner Tap hole Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Rotary Hygiene Control A relatively inexpensive solution would be reposition the tap holes to the front of the furnace. This could be done when the refractory brick in the furnace is changed. The center holes in the drum can be sealed and a new front plate fabricated and fitted with at least two tap holes 180 degrees apart. This configuration will allow a ventilation hood located just over the front of the furnace to efficiently capture any emissions during the tapping operations at a fraction of the cost of a center tapping hood configuration. 19 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Tilting Rotary Furnace ü ü ü ü ü ü ü Quicker charging Faster tapping Reduced cycle times Greater thermal efficiency Lower noise levels Reduced maintenance Improved emission control Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Tilting Rotary Furnace The front tapping and hygiene hood configuration has since led to the introduction of the tilting rotary furnace. The tilting rotary furnace permits: •Quicker charging •Faster tapping as the furnace can be tilted to accelerate the flow of furnace materials •Reduced cycle times, not only because of quicker charging and tapping, but also due to the fact that the burner can now be angled directly into the charge material during the smelt •The new burner configuration provides improved thermal efficiency •This in turn reduces noise levels as the burner does not need some much compressed air •Maintenance levels and refractory wear and tear are reduced •And there is a further improvement in hygiene control as the drum can be angled towards the ventilation. 20 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Tilting Rotary Furnace CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Major Engineering Group Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Tilting Rotary Furnace An Australian Company, The Major Engineering Group, has developed a particularly innovative design. Their furnace comprises a refractory lined rotating cylinder, a swing aside refractory lined charge door with integral burner and flue, tilt cradle, stationary floor mounted supports, tilting fume hood and control cabinet. Charging and discharging are both achieved through an opening in the front of the furnace, thereby eliminating the need for separate tap holes and the time taken to open and reseal them each cycle. The charge/discharge door houses the burner and flue which allows the flue gases to attain a double pass through the furnace further increasing the thermal efficiency. Opening the door is actuated via a hydraulic actuator which moves about a pivot located to the side allowing a total rotational travel of 180 degrees. When closed, the front section is a close fit to the rotating body thus leakage of the flue gases during normal operation is minimal. The flue canopy is directly mounted on to the tilt cradle with the duct terminating on the pivot axis so that fumes may continue to be extracted via a rotating joint throughout the full range of tilt. Major Engineering Group The Major Engineering Group (Major) supplies the heavy industrial, mining, petrochemical, and utilities markets both in Australia and Internationally with a broad range of products and services (http://www.majoreng.com.au/). 21 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Tilting Rotary Furnace CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Dross Engineering Ltd. Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Tilting Rotary Furnace Another fine example of an energy efficient double pass furnace and innovative ventilation system is the Dross Engineering tilting rotary furnace which also angles the exhaust gases up into the extraction ducting located just above the front end of the furnace. Dross Engineering is a Franco-British company dedicated to the design and manufacture of furnaces and equipment for processing non-ferrous metals. The team behind Dross Engineering has designed, built and installed over 1100 furnaces worldwide. The tilting rotary furnaces have been developed as a useful tool for the aluminium, zinc and lead recycling and foundry sectors. Contact: John Simpson Commercial Director DROSS Engineering PO Box 5771, Alfreton, Derbyshire DE55 1ZL, UNITED KINGDOM Tlf: +44(0)1773 528900, Fax: +44(0)1773 528902 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.dross-engineering.com 22 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Tilting Rotary Furnace CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Dross Engineering Ltd. Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Another example of an energy efficient double pass furnace showing the front end configuration for the ventilation hood. Note that the exhaust gases from the furnace will be directed into the ventilation system through a flue located in the swing door. Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Tilting Rotary Furnace CAR IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Dross Engineering Ltd. Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB This photograph shows the extent of the tilt employed during tapping. 23 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute Automotive vs Cycling § Automotive Battery • Shallow Cycling, 0% - 20% • 1 to 2 years life § Cycling Lead Acid Battery UNCTAD ILMC • Deep Cycling, 50% - 80% • 5 – 15 years life Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Domestic Use of Lead Acid Batteries Apart from the possible improvements that could be made to the collection procedures, the transport arrangements and the recycling facilities, there are other changes that should be considered that would also have a positive environmental impact. Firstly, there are many households in the region that keep a 12 volt car battery for use in the event of a power failure. Understandably when these batteries are in use they are invariably run down until the battery is flat and then at the first opportunity they are recharged. Whilst this might appear to be perfectly normal, an automotive battery is not designed to be completely discharged. An automotive battery is designed to provide a short, but powerful, surge of current to start a vehicle with an effective discharge of no more than 20% of the battery’s capacity. A deeper discharge only shortens the battery’s useful life. Using an automotive battery to provide a constant current until virtually flat will mean that despite the fact that a television and a lighting circuit do not demand high current output the battery will not normally last more than two years. If those amongst the population of the region who find it necessary to have a standby battery were to purchase a “deep cycle” battery, that is one designed and capable of thousands of deep discharge cycles between 50 and 80% of the battery’s capacity without shortening its service life, what initially may have been seen as an expensive battery to purchase, now with a life of between 5 and 15 years is seen as a good investment. Furthermore, and at a stroke, the recycling burden has been reduced. 24 Ministeriode de Ministerio MedioAmbiente Ambiente yy Medio RecursosNaturales Naturales Recursos CA AR R II R RII C CaribbeanIndustrial IndustrialResearch ResearchInstitute Institute Caribbean UNCTAD ILMC Formalizing the “Informal” § Promote retail exchange § Add more collection points § Extend infrastructure § Encourage battery servicing • Testing • Maintenance • Re-charging Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Formalizing the “Informal” Illicit attempts to recover lead from ULAB in fields and backyards together with the unwanted battery reconditioning undertaken in many repair shops and retail outlets are detrimental to the environmental and the health of those involved in these activities. Many of the country reports make recommendations to, promote exchange programs at retail outlets so that a when a new battery is purchased the ULAB is taken by the retailer to be passed onto to the recycler. Another idea would be to extend the number of collection points to include gasoline stations. At the same time the infrastructure necessary to educate the motorist and the general population to be more discerning in the way that they dispose of ULAB needs to be strengthened. Above all every encouragement should be given to those working in the informal sector to improve the level of service that some outlets and repair shops already provide to the population. During a visit to one of the most untidy auto repair and spares shops in Santa Domingo I was very impressed to observe that when a motorist asked the owner of the shop to inspect his car battery because he suspected that it needed replacing, the shopkeeper did not sell the motorist a new or reconditioned battery. Instead, and without being asked by the motorist, the owner of the shop took out a small battery testing meter and carried out a number of tests on the battery to determine it state of charge and condition. After some minutes the owner advised the motorist that the battery was flat, but did not need replacing only recharging. He then went on to advise the motorist that the most likely reason for the flat battery was that the alternator on the vehicle was not functioning correctly and therefore not charging the battery as it should. He suggested to the motorist that he should the vehicle to the auto-electrician to have the alternator repaired or replaced and then return to the shop to have his battery recharged. The owner of the repair shop could easily have sold the motorist a new or reconditioned battery, but he did not and his actions in a small, but significant way help to extend battery life and reduce the recycling burden. Accordingly battery testing, maintenance and re-charging should be encouraged. To this end I have attached some further information to the notes detailing the correct and safe way to undertake these tasks. 25 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC LMLA vs VRLA Batteries § LMLA û Can be Reconditioned û Short life span üCheap § VRLA üCannot be reconditioned üUp to 5 years life û Expensive Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Low Maintenance verses Valve Regulated Lead Acid Batteries Technology can also provide help in reducing the impact of the battery reconditioners. Most automotive batteries on sale in the region are the low maintenance or sealed lead acid battery. These batteries are the mainstay of the industry, but they can be cut open and reconditioned in back yards and repair shops. They have a short life of no more than two years, but they are relatively cheap. The new generation of batteries coming onto the market are the valve regulated lead acid batteries. Valve regulated batteries normally release very little or no gas during charge and discharge, as they are designed to operate with a small positive gas pressure inside the battery casing. These batteries also have their electrolyte immobilized with some the acid electrolyte is in the form of a gel, in another version called the “absorbed electrolyte type” the acid is in liquid form, but trapped in a glass fibre mat between the plates. The slight pressure applied to the battery and the close proximity of the positive and negative plates enable the battery to deliver more power per pound or kilo of lead. However, in terms of their contribution to the demise of the reconditioner the good news is that the VRLA battery cannot be reconditioned, because once the factory seal is broken the integrity of the battery design is compromised and it will not function properly. Furthermore it can provide up to 5 years life against the one or two years expected from the conventional auto battery. The one drawback is that it is expensive compared to the low maintenance batteries, but it is anticipated that as they come into more general use the price will come down. 26 What Is “Green” Technology? “Green” – No Waste Clean Products Clean Polluting Hazardous Inert Slag Waste Waste Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB So What is “Green” Technology? This study is about the EMS management of ULAB. The Basel Convention focuses on the management of wastes, and this includes waste minimization and elimination. The reports give careful consideration to the management of hazardous wastes and certainly, there are Lead Industry residues classified as “hazardous” and these are potentially polluting. Increasingly, however, the industry is producing “inert” slags, either directly or indirectly, that are non hazardous and can be considered as a “clean” product. As both hazardous and inert residues are solid wastes and require landfill. Dumping solid waste to landfill, even non hazardous wastes, is not sustainable and therefore cannot be regarded as “green”. Ideally, a “green” technology is one that consumes all materials involved in the production process to produce only re-useable or new saleable products without generating any solid waste that requires disposal to landfill, as already demonstrated at the Cominco Plant in Canada. So let us look at some more examples of where the lead industry has introduced successful “clean” and “green” technologies to address solid waste management issues. The first example is the “Green Slag” Process that successfully converts a secondary smelter from being a producer of hazardous waste to producing an inert and “clean” residue. The second example will demonstrate how the concept of the “Green Technology”, producing only saleable “clean” products and no waste, can be fulfilled through the PLACID Process for recycling used lead acid batteries. 27 Hydrometallurgical Recycling The PLACID Process Paste Melting & Casting Leaching Residue Washing Electrowinning Inert Residue Purification 99.99% Pb Ingots TÉCNICAS REUNIDAS, S.A. Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Bi, Cu, As, Sb... The PLACID Process Advances in hydrometallurgical technology for the recycling of used lead acid batteries promoted by, in particular, the Spanish Company Técnicas Reunidas, are providing increasingly simple and clean processes. Essentially following from conventional battery breaking, the paste is leached in dilute hydrochloric acid in a brine solution to dissolve the lead oxides and sulphates. The sulphate contamination is removed with lime in a carefully controlled manner to precipitate a commercial form of Gypsum, which is then removed by filtration. Lead powder is then injected into the leachate to precipitate the metallic impurities such as Cu, Bi, Sn, Ag, As, Sb and so on. The electrolyte for the two electrodes in the PLACID electrolytic cell are different, and separated by a membrane that is permeable only to proton ions (H+). On the cathode, lead chloride is stripped of its lead atom, leaving two negatively charged chloride atoms, which in turn combine with protons passing through the membrane from the anode to reform hydrochloric acid, which is returned to the leaching bath for reuse. The electrolysis deposits lead as dendrites (spongy form of lead). The dendrites are shaken off, collected and removed from the bath on a semisubmersed conveyor belt. The dendrites are pressed to expel excess electrolyte to form platelets of pure lead which can be melted in a conventional refining kettle and cast into ingots of 99.99% pure lead. 28 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Hydrometallurgical Recycling Environmental Benefits CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC ü No liquid effluent discharges ü Leaching residue is inert ü No SO2 or CO2 emissions ü Dusts & drosses are recycled ü Leaded residues can be treated TÉCNICAS REUNIDAS, S.A. Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Environmental Benefits of the PLACID Process The Environmental benefits of the PLACID hydrometallurgical process are: 1. There are no liquid effluent discharges and the hydrochloric acid used in the initial leaching process is regenerated. 2. The process produces half the amount of solid residues compared to conventional pyrometallurgical recycling and the residue is a saleable commercial grade lead free Gypsum, suitable for sale to the cement and construction industry. 3. There are no sulfurous or greenhouse gas emissions from the plant. 4. Any dust or drosses collected during the recycling process can be recycled through the leaching process. 5. Lead contaminated residues from pyrometallurgical recovery operations and contaminated soils from abandoned mine sites and disused lead smelters can be treated using the PLACID process and the lead content removed. Técnicas Reunidas: http://www.technicasreunidas.es PLACID Process Project Manager - Carlos F Gomez mailto:[email protected] 29 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales SEMARNAP – Clean Industry Award CA R IRI Caribbean Industrial Research Institute UNCTAD ILMC Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB SEMARNAP – Clean Industry Award Whenever ULAB are being shipped from one country to another it is incumbent on those responsible for the export to ensure that the batteries will be recycled in environmentally sound manner. In a region such as Central America and the Caribbean it is not an easy matter to visit and inspect a recycling plant. The Basel Secretariat has recognized this problem and has been considering the introduction of a certification scheme to verify environmental compliance. Indeed in the European Community and the Far East more and more companies require ISO 14001 certification as a condition of “doing business”. Mexico is the largest trading partner of the USA and in an effort to provide American companies with an assurance of sound environmental performance amongst its trading partners in 1992 the Mexican Ministry of the Environment, Natural Resources and Fishing (La Secretaría de Medio Ambiente, Recursos Naturales y Pesca) or SEMARNAP introduced the “Clean Industry Award”. This is a voluntary program of environmental audits leading to the “Clean Industry Award”. Needless to say, ENERTEC in Monterrey were certified in 2001 having satisfied SEMARNAP that the company’s secondary lead operations complied with the required environmental standards. As this Award now has International recognition there is no need for suppliers of ULAB to ENERTEC to visit the plant to ensure Environmentally Sound Management. Such a scheme deserves further consideration by the countries in the region as a means of setting and maintaining high standards of environmental performance. 30 Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales Best Practices § Collection – El Salvador CA R IRI • Baterias de El Salvador Caribbean Industrial Research Institute § Packaging – Trinidad • Automotive Components Ltd. UNCTAD ILMC § Recycling – Mexico • ENERTEC - Monterrey Environmentally Sound Management of ULAB Best Practices Finally I would like to say that within the region you have examples of “Best Practices” at every stage of the cycle in the EMS of ULAB. Baterias de El Salvador have the most impressive network to collect ULAB in El Salvador, Costa Rica, Nicaragua and Guatemala. Automotive Components in Trinidad have the best packaging operation for ULAB. And the ENERTEC plant in Monterrey is a world class secondary smelter. I would urge you to share the expertise that you have in the region to raise standards and improve environmental performance. 31 Example Material Safety Data Sheet for ULAB – Prepared by the ILMC Material Safety Data Sheet 1. Identification of Waste Materials and the Company Product Used Lead Acid Battery Product Name Jack Tarr Automotive Battery Importer The Best Recycling Company Technical/Emergency Support Telephone Numbers 2. Composition/Information about the Materials in Transit Main components Lead, Lead Sulfate, Sulfuric Acid (20%) Other components Polypropylene, 3. Hazard Identification Lead Acid Battery Electrical hazard if short circuited. Battery can produce high current if the positive and negative terminals are short circuited which can result in sparks leading to fire hazard. Maximum Voltage per battery 12 Volts. Constituents Lead and Lead Alloys toxic if ingested. Sulfuric Acid – corrosive. If the battery case is broken acid leaks can damage skin and eyes on contact. Damage will also occur if in contact with materials and clothing. 4. First Aid Measures Sulfuric Acid Skin contact – flush with water, seek medical assistance if contact area is large or blisters form. Eye contact – flush with plenty of water until medical assistance is provided. Ingestion – flush mouth with water – give patient milk or sodium bicarbonate solution until medical assistance arrives. 5. Fire-Fighting Measures In the event of fire Keep containers cool by spraying with water The plastic components may release toxic fumes, advisable to wear breathing apparatus. Example Material Safety Data Sheet for ULAB – Prepared by the ILMC 6. Accidental Release Measures Damaged batteries Use goggles, rubber gloves and protective clothing to prevent direct contact with hazardous substances. Have eyewash bottle and clean water available. Put any damaged items into a plastic acid proof container and identify as a corrosive hazard. Dilute any spillage with clean water and neutralize with sodium bicarbonate. 7. Handling and Storage Precautions Store in cool dry conditions out of direct sunlight. When packed for transport the terminals should always be protected from short circuit. Do not store with items that could cause short circuit. Prevent sparks and naked flames in the vicinity. Wear protective footwear - the batteries are heavy. 8. Exposure Control & Personal Protection Precautions Do not remove any ULAB from the packing or the containers. Wear neoprene cloves when handling the packed batteries or any of the containers with ULAB. Wear protective footwear - the batteries are heavy. 9. Physical and Chemical Properties Lead-Acid Battery Some sealed and will not spill, some liable to leak. Lead Appearance: Colour: Odour: Flammability: Density: Solubility: Melting Point: ºC (Boiling) Solid Silver-grey metal None None 11.34 None 327.4 oC Lead Sulfate Appearance: Colour: Odour: Flammability: Density: Solubility: (15ºC) Melting Point: ºC (Boiling) Powder White None None 6.2 40mg/l 1,070 Example Material Safety Data Sheet for ULAB – Prepared by the ILMC Lead Dioxide Appearance: (compressed as solid) Colour: Odour: Flammability: Density: Solubility: Melting Point:(Boiling) Powder Brown None None 9.4 None 290º C Sulphuric Acid Appearance: Colour: Odour: Flammability: Density: Solubility: Melting Point: Liquid Colourless Acidic None 1.3 approx. 100% 114oC approx. (Boiling) Plastics Appearance: Colour: Odour: Flashpoint: Density: Solubility: Softening point Solid Various None 400oC 0.9 – 2.6g.cm3 at 25oC None 95oC 10. Lead Stability and Reactivity Oxidizes (If battery case split and lead is exposed) Sulfuric Acid Corrosive Plastic Combustible 11. Toxicology Lead and Lead Compounds Toxic if ingested - seek medical help Sulfuric Acid Corrosive and irritant 12. Environmental Lead Acid Battery 13. Recycling Lead Acid Battery Do not dispose of battery in household/domestic waste. Return complete battery for recycling. Under no circumstances incinerate. Local regulations apply – consult Environment Agency for nearest recycling ULAB collection center. 14. Transport Regulations Lead Acid Battery Local/National/International regulations apply. BW/ILMC/Nov. 2002 NEW CLEAN TECHNOLOGIES TO IMPROVE LEAD-ACID BATTERY RECYCLING C. Frías, M. García and G. Díaz TÉCNICAS REUNIDAS, S.A (R&D Centre) Sierra Nevada 16, 28830 San Fernando de Henares Madrid, Spain INTRODUCTION Advances in hydrometallurgy promoted by Técnicas Reunidas are providing increasingly simple and clean means for controlling the entire lead recycling chain. Used in parallel with pyrometallurgy, these processes allow furnace temperatures to be reduced to the minimum, fumes and atmospheric pollution are minimised, furnace slags are digested, and residues (mainly gypsum) are non-toxic and convertible into marketable products. In addition, the global economy of the process is substantially improved by reducing operating cost, increasing lead recovery above 99% and obtaining 99.99% pure lead product. These new PLACID and PLINT processes provide the cleanest and healthiest practicable means for recycling lead from batteries. This paper describes advances in PLACID and PLINT technologies that seem to be opportune for lead secondary industries in general. They have all been identified by recent and current work in the Research and Development Centre of Técnicas Reunidas S.A. (TR) at San Fernando de Henares near Madrid in Spain. As is usual in hydrometallurgy, lead is extracted with the PLACID process by electrowinning. But while electrowinning is generally acceptable for the extraction of valuable metals, the high capital cost of the electrolytic system appeared disadvantageous to established smelters when compared with the current (and possibly the future) market price of lead. Electrowinning is superior for plants producing more than about 20,000 tonnes a year of electrolytic lead. However, one smelter, who had witnessed the operation of the PLACID pilot plant at TR’s R&D Centre, suggested that it might be possible to process the electrolyte to precipitate a pure lead compound that could be fed into a furnace for decomposition or reduction. TR has since worked on this concept for three years, leading to the definition of the PLINT (PLacid INTermediate) process described below. The confidence engendered by this success has caused TR to review its conception of the scope of hydrometallurgy for lead processing. No longer is the aim to promote a best hydrometallurgical process, as measured against conventional standards, but to design processes that best take account of the constraints within which users operate. The emergence of this confidence can be seen in the chapters that follow. To complete this presentation, economics of a selected base case are discussed and results and conclusions are included. OBJECTIVES Existing battery recycling technologies present important deficiencies that need to be revised and adapted to meet the most restrictive environmental regulations and to reach a sustainable growth model for lead secondary industry in the new century. Most relevant shortcomings of current technologies are as follows. · Many technological inconveniences are due to the usual pyrometallurgical processing of battery pastes and its associated lead sulphate content. This sulphate produces sulphurous gases that require costly capture and neutralisation techniques. Fine fraction of battery pastes generates lead fumes that need to be retained by using large electro-precipitators and bag filters. · Conventional techniques for battery pastes desulphurisation, based on sodium hydroxide or sodium carbonate, are expensive and produce large volumes of undesirable sodium sulphate solution, which very frequently is a waste difficult for handling and disposal. · When refined lead quality is needed, addition of sodium hydroxide and sodium nitrate to refining kettles is a common practise. This technique generates large amount of drosses containing soluble sodium salts. · In addition, sodium carbonate is a quite usual flux for lead smelting, giving leachable sodium slags, very difficult for disposing of. · Lead extraction from battery pastes by smelting requires addition of fluxes and high temperature (1100 ºC or above) for decomposition of lead sulphate. The inconvenient that such high temperatures entrain is well understood. On the contrary, smelting operation would be substantially simplified when freesulphate lead oxide materials are treated. The proposed new processes intend to deal with all the above mentioned deficiencies in a reasonable and efficient way, aiming the following objectives: 1. PLACID and PLINT processes intend to complement and improve existing battery recycling factories, but not to substitute them. 2. Metallic lead components from batteries together lead scraps would be treated by conventional melting process, while battery pastes would be sent to hydrometallurgical processing. In this way, sulphurous gases and lead fumes would be minimised and even eliminated. 3. Not any pastes desulphurisation step is required. Lead sulphate is dissolved in brine and removed in form of gypsum. Gypsum is an inert residue and, eventually, could be converted in a commercial by-product. 4. Pure lead is produced when PLACID or PLINT technologies are applied. Conventional lead refining in kettles is not needed. Sodium based drosses and sodium leachable slags are avoided. 5. Any produced small amount of fume, drosses and slags are internally recycled to the hydrometallurgical line. In conclusion, not any toxic solid residue is generated. 6. Both processes run in a closed brine circuit. The water balance is controlled by evaporation, if necessary. In conclusion, not any liquid effluent does exist. 7. When PLACID or PLINT processes are used in parallel to a lead smelting plant, both alloyed and pure lead quality are produced. Alloyed lead would be converted to grids or other battery components, while pure lead would be ideal for new battery pastes manufacturing. In this way, lead secondary chain would be closed in an efficient manner, ensuring a sustainable growth model without additional needs of primary lead. 8. Other important advantage for obtaining pure lead would be manufacturing of longer life batteries, reducing significantly the yearly recycling tonnage of lead. For instance, by increasing one year the average service life of a battery in Europe, annual tonnage of recycled batteries would be 20% reduced, approximately, with the subsequent positive effects on environment, energy saving and sustainability. ELEMENTS OF PROCESS DESIGN Proposed new processes design is conceptually very simple, easy to be understood and very efficient from chemical and energetic points of view. Those processes include a series of properly combined unit steps. Description of each individual stage is as follows. Hydrometallurgy and Pyrometallurgy In espousing hydrometallurgy as its speciality, TR is not contemptuous of pyrometallurgy the processing of materials in furnaces, the advantages of which are fully recognised, but hydrometallurgy is cleaner, more exact, and more easily controlled for treating battery pastes, lead fumes and drosses, etc. Pyrometallurgy is ideal for metallic lead components treatment, but present many disadvantages when is applied to battery pastes processing. Hydrometallurgy makes it easier. Proposed hydrometallurgical processes are cleaner in themselves, and in combined cycle plants they can be used to reduce furnace temperatures also, so reducing the energy demands and environmental impact of smelting, and increasing the productivity of any existing pyrometallurgical plant. It should be remarked that aim of PLACID and PLINT technologies is to complement existing battery recycling plants, yielding the best synergy and complementing both ‘pyro’ and ‘hydro’ lines. Leaching This is the initial step in which all accessible soluble lead in the feedstock is selectively dissolved. Feed materials to hydrometallurgical processes is varied, including battery pastes (principal feed material) together lead fume, drosses and slags. Also a small portion of lead sulphide concentrate could be fed. Even more, old slags deposits and lead contaminated soils could also be treated. Lead dissolution efficiency is very high. When, in a PLACID-Pyro or PLINT-Pyro combined process, the measured extraction rate was 99.5% overall, this was because the leaching process extracted available lead from slags and other products already rejected by the furnace operation. The composition of the leachant is dilute hydrochloric acid in brine solution, which has the ability of dissolving lead oxides and lead sulphate in an efficient manner. In the two final campaigns of PLACID pilot plant operation, leaching efficiency from representative battery pastes/fumes mixtures was 99.4 to 99.7% after treating above fifteen tonnes of feed materials. Main involved reactions are: PbO + 2 HCl + 2 NaCl (1) ® PbCl4Na2 + H2O Pb + PbO2 + 4 HCl + 4 NaCl (2) ® 2 PbCl4Na2 + 2 H2O PbS + 4 PbO2 + 8 HCl + 12 NaCl ® 5 PbCl4Na2 + Na2SO4 + 4 H2O (3) PbSO4 + 4 NaCl ® PbCl4Na2 + Na2SO4 (4) Na2SO4 + 2 HCl + Ca(OH)2 ® CaSO4 + 2 NaCl + 2 H2O (5) In the case of PLACID process, hydrochloric acid is regenerated in the electrolytic cells, so just lime is the only consumption. When PLINT process is applied, make-up acid addition is necessary, so sulphuric acid can replace hydrochloric acid because its lower cost. Sulphate Removal Not any previous battery pastes desulphurisation step is necessary, avoiding generation of undesirable sodium sulphate solution. Pastes from battery breaker are fed as well to the hydrometallurgical processes. Drying is not required. In this case in which sulphur is present in lead sulphate the preference is for a reaction with lime (about the cheapest material suitable for this purpose) to form gypsum, which is then removed by filtration. TR has developed techniques whereby the gypsum can be produced pure in any of its three morphologies (hydrated, hemi-hydrated and anhydrous) to suit market demands. Therefore, obtained gypsum residue could be converted to commercial gypsum products, if commercially feasible. The real benefit in this is not having to pay for its disposal. Purification Used purification technique is very simple and involves injecting lead powder into the leachant or electrolyte to enable an electrochemical reduction of metal impurities more noble than lead. The purification reaction is: MeCln + n/2 Pb0 ® n/2 PbCl2 + Me0 (6) “Me” means any metallic impurity such as Cu, Bi, Sn, Ag, As, Sb... The leachant is then filtered to remove the cement. The efficiency of this process is good enough to produce a pure electrolyte that ensures ‘four-nines’ lead final product. Of course, the concentration of impurities in the electrolyte does not translate directly to the concentration of impurities in the lead because competitive electrodeposition. Metallic lead content of the cement is above 90%, so this cement is re-melted and absorbed into secondary alloyed or other commercial grades of lead in the factory. Lead Extraction Steps Electrowinning The PLACID electrolytic cell is the core of this technology. The electrolyte for the two electrodes the anode and the cathode are different, and are separated by a membrane that is permeable only by proton ions (H+). On the cathode, lead chloride is stripped of its lead atom, leaving two chloride atoms which are negatively charged. These negatively charged chloride atoms combine with protons passing through the membrane from the anode to reform hydrochloric acid that is returned to the leaching bath for reuse. Main electrochemical reactions are as follows: Cathodic: PbCl2 + 2 e- ® Pbo + 2 Cl- (7) Anodic: H2O - 2 e- ® 2H+ + ½ O2 (8) GLOBAL: PbCl2 + H2O ® Pbo + 2 HCl + ½ O2 (9) The design of this cell is unusual: instead of depositing lead on to metal plates, as is conventional, electrolysis deposits lead as dendrites or sponge, which are subsequently shaken off and collected on a conveyor belt. Immediately after leaving the electrolyte, the dendrites are pressed to express the liquid and to form platelets of pure lead which can then be conveyed to a kettle for casting into ingots. There is no special virtue in the conventional practice of depositing the lead on to plates: the plating process must be interrupted periodically while plates are replaced, and there is no application for lead in the form of discrete thin flat plates. There are important cost and convenience virtues, by contrast, in depositing lead as dendrites or sponge because then the amperage can be increased by a factor of between 4 and 10, greatly reducing the number of electrolytic cells that must be provided for a given throughput of lead product. And the whole of the extraction process can be run continuously, without interruption. Labour for cathode stripping and replacement is not needed. Electrowinning is a capital-intensive process largely because of the electrical transformers and rectifiers needed and although direct operating costs are lower than for pyrometallurgical extraction processes, the amortisation costs are not insignificant. Electrowinning is most advantageous for large plants. It is strongly recommended that advantage be taken of the cost reduction made possible by use of combined cycle generating plant. Electricity would be used for electrowinning and motors while waste heat from the engine can then be used to maintain leachant temperatures at appropriate levels (typically about 80º C) and effect drying and evaporation where required. Pure Lead Oxides Smelting In the case of the PLINT process, a pure lead hydroxide (oxides) or lead carbonate concentrate is produced from purified pregnant solution. Various reagent or a combination of them can be used, depending on local price, availability and process constrains. PbCl4Na2 + Ca(OH)2 ® Pb(OH)2 + 2 NaCl + CaCl2 (10) PbCl4Na2 + 2 NaOH ® Pb(OH)2 + 4 NaCl (11) PbCl4Na2 + Na2CO3 ® PbCO3 + 4 NaCl (12) This concentrate should be sent to smelting in furnace or kettle. Pyrometallurgical treatment of this lead concentrate would be quite simple and efficient because only some reductant addition is required. A low temperature would be enough and the amount of energy that must be provided to heat a charge is low in comparison to present operation, and the time taken to smelt this charge is substantially reduced. The existing ‘pyro’ facilities would have some over-capacity to increase actual production. PLACID AND PLINT PROCESSES The PLACID Process Much about this process has already been described in previous sections. The conceptual block diagram is shown in Figure 1. The leachant is dilute acid brine, and the desulphurisation sequence is quite interesting. The lead sulphate reacts with salt to form lead chloride and sodium sulphate, and the sodium sulphate then reacts with hydrochloric acid and lime to yield the gypsum, at the same time reforming salt ready for reuse in the leachant. Because hydrochloric acid is regenerated in the electrowinning section, just lime is the only consumption. Different feed materials would be suitable for this process besides battery pastes, e.g. lead fume, drosses and slags, even a small fraction of lead sulphide concentrate. Pilot plant development in the laboratories of the R&D Centre was carried out in several campaigns (above 1000 hours total operation), during which 10 tonnes of pure electrolytic lead were produced. Energy consumption was 0.9 kWh/kg Pb. Representative samples of electrolytic lead gave above 99.99% Pb, containing 3 ppm Cu, 6 ppm Sb, 2 ppm As, 1 ppm Sn, 2 ppm Bi. Those data likely would be improved in a continuous industrial plant. PLACID process would be perfectly integrated if it were used in parallel with a pyrometallurgical smelter. In this way, any lead fumes, drosses and slags from the pyrometallurgical line can be passed to the leaching bath of PLACID line, and the cements from the purification step to be fed into the furnace. Important gaining would be obtained from environmental, process efficiency, product quality and economics points of view. PASTES Lime Leaching Electrowinning Sulphate Removal Purification Inert Residue (Gypsum) Melting and Casting 99.99 LEAD INGOTS Lead Powder Lead Cement (Bi, Cu, As, Sb) Figure 1 – PLACID Process. Conceptual Block Diagram The PLINT Process A conceptual block diagram is shown in Figure 2. As can be seen by comparison of the both PLACID and PLINT block diagrams, the only difference in principle is in the substitution of a precipitation step for electrowinning. In the subsequent kettle, the lead hydroxide product is first decomposed and then reacted with hard coal to obtain pure lead. All that takes place at a temperature much lower than is required by current smelting process. Because the leaching and purification processes are unchanged, the leaching efficiency of this process and the purity of the lead produced should be the same as in the PLACID process. The PLINT process needs addition of acid make-up, so sulphuric acid can replace hydrochloric acid because its lower cost. Any sulphuric acid is converted to gypsum. Obviously, it would be possible to integrate a PLINT process line with a pyrometallurgical line, creating a system similar to that in the PLACID-Pyro process, but to give the division of 99.99+% purity lead and recycled lead it would then be necessary to have separate, dedicated kettles or furnaces. PASTES H2SO4 Lime Leaching Lead Precipitation Low Temperat. Smelting Melting and Casting Lime Sulphate Removal Purification 99.99 LEAD INGOTS Inert Residue (Gypsum) Lead Powder Lead Cement (Bi, Cu, As, Sb) Figure 2 – PLINT Process. Conceptual Block Diagram Development of these new PLACID and PLINT processes has proceeded to the stage where a demonstration plant is needed. ECONOMIC EVALUATION PLACID Process Selected Base Case for final feasibility study included the following conditions: a) The new PLACID plant would be annexed to an existing battery recycling plant. Global lead recovery of the combined PLACID-Pyro plant would be above 99.5%. b) Lead production would be 20,000 t/y electrolytic lead, 99.99 purity. Feed materials would be 27,500 t/y battery pastes and 2,500 t/y fumes and slags. c) The energy consumption has been optimised. After a detailed study about electricity cost optimisation it was decided to implement a co-generation energetic plant by natural gas to supply electricity and heat to the process. It has been a very attractive option, reducing substantially the operating costs. The basic engineering of the base case has been developed in detail, performing material and heat balances. Operating costs were estimated from the previous information. Main consumption are shown in the Table I. The most important cost is natural gas for the co-generation plant. Table I. PLACID Process Consumption Concept Lime kg/t Pb Sodium Hydrosulphide, kg/t Pb Process Water, m3/t Pb Natural Gas, Mcal/t Pb Value 143 1.5 2.2 1,625 An operating cost break down at current prices in Spain is depicted in Table II in US Dollars at the prevalent exchange rate, 170 PTA per USD. A 10% contingency factor has been allowed. Residue disposal cost has been included, assuming that gypsum was not sold; obviously this would be the worst scenario. Table II. PLACID Operating Cost Break Down Concept Consumable Reagents Residue disposal Labour Maintenance Contingency TOTAL $/t Pb 30.8 9.2 20.0 36.0 16.3 12.0 124.3 The estimated total investment cost, based on good practice engineering standards with a +25% contingency factor, is 19.0 Million USD, including co-generation plant investment. The high contingency factor makes this study fairly conservative. The PLINT Process A similar Base Case has been selected for PLINT process, according to the following: a) The new PLINT plant would be annexed to an existing battery recycling plant. Global lead recovery of the combined PLINT-Pyro plant would be above 99.5%. b) Production would be about 23,000 t/y lead concentrate (oxides or carbonate), containing 20,000 t/y lead, 99.99 purity. Feed materials would be 27,500 t/y battery pastes and 2,500 t/y fumes and slags. In a similar approach to PLACID, the basic engineering of the PLINT base case has been developed in detail. Operating costs were estimated based on material and energy balance. Main consumption is presented in Table III. Table III. PLINT Process Consumption Concept Lime kg/t Pb Sulphuric Acid, kg/t Pb Lead Powder, kg/t Pb Process Water, m3/t Pb Electricity, MWh/t Pb Value 520 320 40 1.5 0.1 Operating costs are presented in Table IV in US Dollars at the prevalent exchange rate, 170 PTA per USD. A 10% contingency factor has been allowed. Higher cost is corresponding to reagents make-up consumption. Residue disposal cost has been included, assuming that gypsum was not sold; obviously this would be the worst scenario. Low temperature smelting cost is not included in this estimation. Table IV. PLINT Operating Cost Break Down Concept Consumable Reagents Residue disposal Labour Maintenance Contingency TOTAL $/t Pb 32.1 40.2 20.0 20.5 9.5 13.0 135.3 The estimated total investment cost, based on good practice engineering standards and with a +25% contingency factor, is 7.1 million USD. The high contingency factor makes this study fairly conservative. Profitability Based on the above operating and investment costs, several DCF (discount cash flow) calculations have been carried out. IRR (internal rate of return) in the range 16% to 28% have been worked out, which indicates that both PLACID and PLINT processes are very economically attractive. CONCLUSIONS When PLACID or PLINT hydrometallurgical processes would be implemented in parallel to any existing pyrometallurgical battery recycling plant, the whole environmental, technical and economic aspects of the integrated plant would be substantially improved. The proposed new processes are simple, efficient, very flexible and profitable, which make them ideal for being adapted to the customer needs and local requirements. The final evaluation study of both PLACID and PLINT processes, applied to a selected Base Case producing 20,000 t/y 99.99% lead presents very satisfactory results, which will facilitate their industrial implementation in a short term period. The availability of this technology has opened a window of opportunity for lead secondary industries, and inquiries are invited. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The European organisations that have developed the PLACID Process into the BriteEuram Programme show their gratitude to the European Community for its encouragement, support and partial funding of the project. REFERENCES 1. “Proceso PLACID: Recuperación del Plomo de Pastas de Plomo”, Internal Report No. ITR/P4618/005/1988. 2. “Proyecto de Planta de Producción de 25.000 t/a de Plomo por el Proceso LEADCLOR”, Internal Reports No. ITR/P4628/029/1988 and ITR/P4650/017/1991. 3. D. Martín and G. Díaz, "Hydrometallurgical Treatment of Lead Secondaries and/or Low Grade Concentrates; The PLACID and the LEADCLOR Processes", Conference organised by ILZSG on Recycling Lead and Zinc-The Challenge of the 1990's, Rome, Italy, 1991, 315-336. 4. R. D. Prengaman, “Recovering Lead from Batteries”, Journal of Metals, Vol. 47, 1995, 31-33. 5. G. Díaz, “Lead Recycling”, Letter Journal of Metals, June 1995, 3-4. 6. G. Díaz, C. Frías, L.M. Abrantes, A. Aldaz, K. van Deelen, and R. Couchinho, “Lead-Acid Battery Recycling by the PLACID Process - A Global Approach”, TMS Third International Symposium on the Recycling of Metals and Materials, Point Clear, Alabama, 1995, 843-856. 7. G. Díaz and D. Andrews, “Placid - A Clean Process for Recycling Lead from Batteries”, Journal of Metals, Vol. 48, 1996, 29-31. 8. G. Díaz and D. Andrews, “Placid Lead for Batteries”, Batteries International, April 1996, 73-74. 9. C. Frías, M.A. García and G. Díaz, "Industrial Size Placid Electrowinning Cell", TMS Annual Meeting at Orlando, Florida, USA, Aqueous Electrotechnologies: Progress in Theory and Practice, D.B. Dreisinger Ed., 1997, 101-113. Vehicle Jump Starting Before carrying out any work on the electrical system beyond the battery, the air bag system must be electrically disabled. Never indiscriminately probe the electrical wiring/connector in the vicinity of the steering column. The wiring and harness connector of most air bag systems are bright yellow; do not interfere with any harness of this colour. As an added safety measure it is recommended that no person should remain seated behind the steering wheel while any electrical service work is carried out on the vehicle. WARNING Modern vehicles with electronic management systems should not be jump started without “protected” jump starter leads and it is necessary to refer to the owner’s handbook for jump starting procedures for such vehicles. Vehicle Jump Starting procedure is as follows and should be followed carefully: • Check batteries are the same voltage. • Turn off all electrical loads, check vehicles are not touching and are in park or neutral. • Check that vehicles have same terminal earthed. If not, refer to manufacturers instructions. • Check that cables are not frayed or damaged. • Carry out following steps in sequence: 1. On negative grounded system, connect both ends of one cable to positive (+) terminal of both batteries. 2. Connect one end of other cable to negative (-) terminal of booster battery. 3. Connect other cable away from battery, to engine block or car frame of vehicle to be started. 4. Make sure cables are away from fan blades and other moving vehicle parts. 5. Start engine of booster car. 6. Attempt to start engine of vehicle with discharged battery. 7. If vehicle does not start within 30 seconds, call an auto electrician. 8. After starting, remove cables in reverse order, starting with one connected to engine block or car frame. GENERAL PRECAUTIONS: 1. Make sure the engine, lights and any accessories are turned off before removing old battery. 2. Check if vehicle has a computerised electrical system. 3. Vehicles with on board computer systems require an alternative power source to maintain electronic memory when battery is disconnected. 4. Disconnection of the battery on such a vehicle may cause damage to the main computer or other segments of the vehicle’s electronically controlled equipment, without a memory minder. Charging Batteries Before attempting to charge a battery, be aware of all the safety precautions you should observe during the charging operation. • Always turn the charger off before attaching, rocking, or removing the terminal clamps. • Keep vent caps in place. • Keep open flames and sparks away from the battery. • Charge in well ventilated area. • Follow the battery charger manufacturer’s instructions. Specific charging rates or times are difficult to detail due to a number of other features such as: 1. The electrical capacity of the battery. 2. Temperature of the electrolyte. 3. Battery state of charge at the start of the charging period. 4. Battery age and condition. Battery Charging Guide REMOVAL OF OLD BATTERY: 1. Note location of positive terminal and mark polarity on positive cable. Remove the ground terminal first. This precaution is necessary to avoid damage to wiring and the battery by accidentally grounding tools. 2. Remove second terminal. Undo hold down and remove battery. NEW BATTERY INSTALLATION: 1. Inspect tray and area for corrosion. If necessary, scrub the area with water and baking soda and rinse with water. 2. Corroded steel parts should be dried and painted with acid proof paint. Terminals should be cleaned and brushed. 3. Cable and starter motor connections should be checked and tightened if necessary. 4. If terminal clamps or cables are badly corroded, they should be replaced. 5. Place the new battery in the tray ensuring it sits level and that terminal posts are positioned as for the old battery. 6. Place and tighten hold downs securely so that the battery cannot move in the tray. 7. Apply a thin coating of high temperature grease to the posts and cable connections. 8. Replace cables ensuring that the ground terminal is connected last. Tighten connections. NB: Do not over tighten. Never hammer cable connections onto battery posts, as this can damage the battery posts and cover. New Battery Installation SAFETY PRECAUTIONS Vehicles fitted with an Air Bag: Removal or replacement of battery terminals will not unintentionally trigger an air bag system. However removal of battery terminals with the ignition remaining “on” can cause damage to electronic components, including the SRS. Always check to ensure that the ignition is “off” before removing either of the battery terminals. Battery Safety • EXPLODING BATTERY: Batteries generate explosive gases during vehicle operation and when charged separately. Flames, sparks, burning cigarettes or other ignition sources must be kept away al all times. • ALWAYS SHIELD EYES WHEN WORKING NEAR BATTERIES: • BATTERY ACID CAN CAUSE BURNS. Use extreme care when handling acid. If electrolyte is spilled or splashed onto clothing or the body, wash with water and neutralise with a solution of baking soda and water. Electrolyte splashed into eyes is extremely dangerous. If this occurs, gently open eyes and wash with cool clean water for 5 minutes. Call a doctor. • IF ELECTROLYTE IS SWALLOWED: Drink large quantities of water or milk and follow with milk of magnesia, beaten eggs or vegetable oil. Call a doctor. If it is necessary to prepare electrolyte: Always add concentrated acid to water - never water to acid. Store electrolyte in plastic containers with sealed cover. Do not store in the sun. 8 9 When charging batteries, work in a well ventilated area - never in a closed room. Always turn battery charger or ignition off before disconnecting a battery. BOSCH IS ENVIRONMENTALLY CONSCIOUS Every Bosch battery now carries the Recycle Logo. It’s a fact that up to 97% of each Bosch battery is recyclable, meaning Bosch takes environmental issues seriously. Bosch prides itself on being a good corporate citizen. Today’s customers will find our concern very reassuring and they can choose Bosch with confidence. Why did the battery fail? Century Yuasa in January 1995. A battery date coded M4 was dispatched by Century Yuasa in December 1994 etc. A January G July B February H August C March J September D April K October E May L November F June M December FACTORS AFFECTING BATTERY LIFE It is important that the reason for any battery failure is identified, as a battery replacement may only solve the symptom of the problem. BATTERY INSPECTION Check electrolyte level - fluid below the tops of the separators indicates overcharging or poor maintenance. Overcharge condition may be due to incorrect voltage setting, low voltage caused by heat or internal defects, or old age deterioration. Is there electrolyte on the top of the battery? This can indicate overcharging or over filling. Is the battery loose in the carrier? This can cause failure from vibration. Has the battery signs of damage or mistreatment? This can also cause failure. DISCHARGED (FLAT) BATTERIES A flat battery should be checked with a Hydrometer. A low Specific Gravity reading of 1.220 or less, in all cells indicates a discharged battery and it must be charged before further examination and testing can occur. The discharged condition may be due to a problem in the electrical system (slipping alternator belt, poor voltage regulator, faulty alternator, high resistance due to corrosion). Internal shorts may also be due to manufacturing defects, or shorts through the aging process or vibration damage. OLD AGE Batteries have an average age of 2-3 years. Assessment of the life of the battery can be done by checking the sale code of the battery terminal. Bosch Batteries have a code which uses a letter and a number. Numbers are 0-9 Example: A battery date coded A5 was dispatched by Automotive batteries have an average ‘life’ of 2-3 years. Over that age they gradually lose their capacity as their function is performed. They constantly charge and discharge which eventually leads to failure. Components corrode over time, electrical shorts occur in the battery, vibration causes damage that eventually causes failure. Overcharging and undercharging of a battery will also have a bearing on battery life. Try to follow charging procedures correctly. Battery servicing as detailed, helps extend battery life. Batteries fail when least expected. The usual warning is a slower than normal battery ability to crank the engine but other less noticeable factors such as changed driving patterns (holidays), colder or hotter weather will all have an effect on the life of a battery. Encourage your customers to ask for a ‘FREE Battery Test’. It’s good public relations and if the battery is old it may lead to a sale. IS BATTERY REPLACEMENT NECESSARY? A percentage of batteries, allegedly faulty, are merely “flat” or discharged so the battery (and sometimes the vehicles electrical system) needs to be checked - refer battery test procedures and installation. GENERAL BATTERY INFORMATION • Vehicle batteries last for an average of 2-3 years. They wear out like tyres and need to be replaced. • Vibration can reduce a battery life. Bosch starting batteries have Polyethylene Envelopes around each positive plate which catch active material and help to prevent short circuits thereby ensuring long battery life. • Many alleged ‘dead batteries’ are merely flat batteries. Drivers simply leave lights on or can have faulty voltage regulators. Make sure you go through the warranty procedure check thoroughly before replacing a battery. • It’s impossible to know exactly when a battery might fail. A slow starting engine could be a fair indication. Old batteries can give trouble in colder weather. Equally, if an engine area becomes overheated in very hot weather and the battery is under strain from air conditioners it may fail. • Regular battery checks are always advised. 10 Stock storage and rotation procedure Proper stock management and rotation procedures are essential to ensure only first class stock is presented for sale to customers. • Batteries are a perishable product with limited shelf life. • Stock them upright in a cool place. Do not store in direct sunlight. Charged batteries displayed in the sun will require recharge within 6-8 weeks. • Do not over stock as this will cause a rotational problem, and require additional battery service to maintain the battery in saleable condition. • Rotate stock on a ‘First in - First out’ principle. Place older batteries at the front of your display. Battery Servicing Battery servicing can be carried out during vehicle servicing or during a normal refuelling stop. Routine servicing of the battery should include the following: 1. Check for defective cables, loose connections, corrosion, cracked cases or covers, loose hold downs and deformed or loose terminal posts. 2. Correct if possible, replace or repair parts that are damaged. 3. Where there is corrosion on the terminal posts or on hold down trays, it is recommended that the whole area be neutralised, cleaned and painted. This can be done using a wire brush, paint scraper and a solution of water and bicarbonate of soda (Baking Soda). 4. Check the electrolyte level. If it is below the separator tops, add clean distilled or good quality water to bring it back to the correct level. Never over fill cells as this will cause corrosion. How to select the right battery for the vehicle Modern vehicles require more power than ever before. Electronic ignitions and management systems in modern vehicles require the battery voltage to be maintained at a higher percentage of charge to that of a few years ago. With all the original manufacturer equipment, plus added optional equipment, it is very important to fit the correct replacement battery, with an adequate reserve. 11