Read - American Jewish Archives
Transcription
Read - American Jewish Archives
MS-603: Rabbi Marc H. Tanenbaum Collection, 1945-1992. Series C: lnterreligious Activities. 1952-1992 Box 21 , Folder 1, Graham, Billy, 1967-1969. 3101 Clifton Ave, Cincinnati, Ohio 45220 (513) 221-1875 phone, (513) 221-7812 fax americanjewisharchives.org [start] Original documents faded and/or illegible '.; ,_., ,. •" ..,... ~rieads 1 I h~ cour.i.ging but chat Jews are not certain {judged on the basis of their treatment of in Jordm, is conYinad that how enthusi:istically co accept Oiristian \the Jews." · Jerusalem• will be tt·oni~. u a Jewish fun<bmentalist support offered on the Billy concluded: "I suppott the signi· ciq·. He certain thar Jews:will provide basis of a literalist .readicg of prophecy /.ficance of Israel for the Jew~ven apan Christians and Muslims free access to all io Scriprure. In Jewish experience, such from the missionaries' hopes for Jewish · holy places. · • · Christian affirmations of the "chosen" conversion. Israel bas a meaning fot Jews Billy was coovioc:ed that all of the ~ concept and the gathering of the exiles apan from any New Testament hopes. ritory from the Nile to ~ Euehq.tcs was :ts fulfillment of prophecy h~ been ac- It is a promised condfrion of their ex- pro~ to· the Jews by God tb..."OUgb. the companied frequendy by warnings that istence, revealed by God in Hebrew Scrip- prophea:. He feels th3t recent Israeli ac· "'."'- Israel would be descroyed in a cicastrophk rure, that J ews be connected to this Janel quisicion of parts of this ceuitmy may b:ucle, seen by some ev:ingelists as a con- It is chcre ·that rbey muse struggle co live be a fuJ61tmear of some of ch~ propbfronration between America and the So- a national existen~ that wJl hopefully re- ecies. He s:iid that if he were an hneli viet Union or Chioa. Some had given this Bea the glory of God and serve as a sigo . official he would not yield. to ptessures intcrpreradon with such entbusi:wn that to man that the God of Abraham. is a God tb3r could jeopatdi%c lselel's phrsical seit :tppeired almost co be a wish that the ·faithful co His promises. He Jives." curity. Israel was. rigbc to seek negociaca::i.strophc would occur soon. In their Chri.sc·im·guilrfor·past sw committed tioos with the Arabs. be said, addiog view the battle would usher in· the age \. against the Jewish people played a role in that tie hopes Israel will bo jusr~en of the Messiah: This kind of thinking, I Billy Graham's sympathecic attitude. He magnanimow-in her relacioris toWUd s:iid, lends itself co passivir:y ia the fa~ was truly anguished · by Quistian short· A.cabs, paniculatly the Arabs in bet midst. .--sf harsh political realities. The will to coming and believed it ·most important, Billy and 1 disc:us.1td his views oo the pre'VCOt incern.:uional ch.a.o9 :i..ad <lisotder \therefor~ for 01.ristiaiu· at chis point in. Jewish tole in the auciUion.. ·· ·· · is it:prcsscd as the fuodame:r:ailisl, in history to tdraio from manipolariDg· or- · ~"The· Ittimiiils JalW··on.;.· ~ · - sm.ug, self-righteousness, sits OUt che [ misusing Jews. ''Jews have a right to ·be dared.-...All 61 the people of that day had crouble. Therefore, what appeared ro be respected for whac they are-a people who a part in the tragedy. It was man's sin support of Israel might, in faa, be a dis· live srill by the light of God in the Old as man that was rcspqasible, not the sin \1, ..guised expression of hostility. I noted, Testament," Billy declared.· of man as Jew oc as Gentile Even God too, that fundamentalist support for the . played a role in ~drama, foe. it wu . · gathering of Jews in Israel was frequently DtSCUSStNG Christian. responsibility to 's will that Jesus be saai6~ as a accompanied with an appeal for inteosi- law and social reform, he said both meth- reconciling atonement for man with God... fied missionary ".'"'ork and an anticipation ( ~.of change w~ unrcl~ble without in- . 4£...0n the t~ching o~ Paul in th.e N~ of mass conversion. Thus Jews were un- d1v1dual regeneration. Unlike some funda- Tcs~em, Billy· e:z~ "Go4 fo!bid: dersrandably leery that Israel was not be- mentalist opponents of Ouistian social The Jews are ocx. a people: rcjea,ed of · ing ·supported for her own integrity or aaion, Billy insisted that Christians. in- God." Then be added, "Had all cbc J~ judged oa her own merits. but was being ~ividually and through their corporate chm accepted Jesus. the Kingdoal°ol God evaluated instead in the context of a structures, must eater che social arena and would have been osbcred in fonhwUh. Christian timetable of cveocs. seek to improve society. In recent years, It worked out to our bmdit u Gaitiles, Billy was taken aback. H e had not through his own crusades and public however, th.at . we were givm :tbt oprcal.iz.ed how important it was to spell ~estimony, he has ttied to set an example. porruoity, through Jewish obstinacy, to our fully the implications of his words. Negroes arc members -of his team. He come t9 know~ We Qai.stil.M.must He elaborated. He agreed that at endill nor lead a crusade or meeting UD· acknowledge that th,ough out. faith in time, there would be a coo.Bagratioo-of less it is integrated. I found Billy con- Christ, w~ are grafted oo to the Jewish is . , .-~... < ·~ .. ·''. l .·,f ; l f! }J_·.·. -:·I . >·{ ; ~~1 _ ::. :1 ;:-. 1 ~- the Mid-East, and particularly at Anna- conftia. He expressed dismay at the anti- sings of God. ·. · .. geddon. But this was an end-time predic- Semitic course taken by some Black Pow"It is not that we displacc me Jews, « t tion, he said. It was not a n<>w·tPme ex- er excrem.i.scs and he questioned me close- that J ews arc .rejected. ot accw:se<f.: BJ· horrarioo. Furthermore., aceordin~ tohis ly 'on my own views. .. ·•· God's foreknowledge, not·. all J~ acreadin~ of Scripeutt, Jews. ~d be pre--· k., "ADti~ism, no matter.. wha_t ics ccpred Jesus so ~ GmtiJc;t ~t ~ served, nOt destroyed. ori~ins, no mimer where it is found, is to share wirh the Jrirs God'1 piom.ises · · His blue eyes sparldin& Billy offered a blatll.Dt denial of God in rhe Jew. It foe the futuJ'C. The Jews with whom wrhis belief that the fuUill.mcnt of prophetic muse be repudiated," Billy said. "We must arc now engrafted arc n0t only those Jews · ·u ttcrmces re~rdina the ianthering of · attack .any shred of anti-Semitic discrimi- who accept Jesus as the promised M~ Jews is now being fulfilled. "The land is nation. We must purge ourselves com- siah, buc also those Jews who still aWait ·.'.· important," he said. "It is a ~ift of God plercly of this foul blemish from a former the Messiah's first coming. · to the Jews. Redemption itself is mysreri· period of apostacy." "It is wrong to presWDf: that the suf. ously interconnected with that land." The We concluded our discussion on the ferings of the Jews. are a ~ end-time battle, he repeaced, will see Jews Middle East by dealing with concret·e alone of their denial of Jesus. Ceftajnly resrored in ~earer securiry co their home policical problems. While Billy is a grear it is Biblical to suggest that man suffers and then ..the nations of the world will be admirer of !9ng. Hussein and has many Continued .,. poge 8 . t 1 I g[ BullmH Publlah..t montbl7 ezcept Jo~ and Au l'\llt b7 th• Antl·Detomation 1-n• of B'oal B'rlth. lli Lahistoa A - Ne• Yorlc, N. Y. 10016. Dore Scbary. cbalno&D : B en,y E. ScJaults, Meler Stalnbrlnk. boDOl"U'F di.at,.....: Lmeud AbeN, Bam~ Balaban. Hany Brandt, Artliur J. Coldbu1r. Jacob k . Jari1:a. Philip Ill.. Klutsialck, 1-n ~ eteln. Abrah•m A. Rlbleolf. William Sacha, Neloin R. Schlesin1rer. bonorsrT •lee chainlN!ll: Jaclr Y. S.-n. s..,.. mour Graubard. Mrs. Lout. Perlm•n. n ...;.t A. 'Rcse. Chftter H. Roth. Simo• Well. YI~ cba l.,.... : 8ftJU11hl Gr.,.,nbel"!r, honora..,. tr-euu...,,.. R ieb.ant M. ~crtt :Sr. , t reuurn. l!urton J0M1>1'. uai.tant _.....,. ; Ed_..rd Go!<!~ JU Lnlwtt- Aft., H. Y. 10016 ~c<reto..,.: S. O. Shapiro, a ..wunt aec~tar.r; B""j unin R. Eo,•t.ein. national dir-.<:tor: Pall! H. Samplhler, dlalnna1t aecutive cnmmit~: Norma n Scblooaman, •ice-<hairman : Willia m A. Wnler, preldent. B•oal s·r!t!I, :Sa7 Kaor-a. a-OW Vol U Ho. 10 • Deumbw, 1967 vi~ 11...,.tdent: MrS. Arthur G. Roolenblutb. preide"t. B'cai B"rith Wo men. Editorial Boar4: N. C. Beith. chainn&a, Oocar Cob'""· Benjamli> R. Epewln, A mold Fon1W... Alezaoda F . Miller. J . Harold Sa'ka, Charles L !!Cw, ~ J. Wa~.o.. . ;. ~"" _j Su'b3icription Rate: $2.00 for two years. SUbeeriben mut ~rt cbanre of add,._ sivfsw oW a:oc1 MW addrwe· ud t·. a ccount dslrnatioo. Second cl. . po1ta1• paid at Poet Offttt, New York. N.Y. Print.ad ln U.S.A. . . · : · Executive Editor: N. C. BELTH Editor: LYNNE IANNIELLO Art Director: EDWARD GOlDMAN • ·~{j . .· i-: . . ,, ..: '. ;=.-~ ~ :--~:~~.~ ~·~.{~t~ - .. .... "'-·. ·-·#>.,,. ......,~: ~:~ . :.'";=:::r:t;~~ .., ..... : • • n.._·~i >:.!6?ra cornphir:ts with the ciry's Human Rela- . ~ions Cornmi>sioa. The dis:ribution of the· docurr.enracion caused a flurry of discussion within rhe building, especi:illy iii ,·ie.-: of the L"Illninence of .th·e annual m~e•ir.g of the apanmeoc owners. Th:: mee•ing produced a dramatic C•)•!tror,c:t~ion. A resolution was pre;;~rr:~d by a board member asking th:n the .1pmment owners approve the boaitl"s $~i.;;·r;·:e policy based on vague qualificaiuns of :ipplicam merit. Our group intro0 cuc;·d a subscirute motion staring chat ··chert shlll be no discrimination 6a the ~:i.sis of race or religion." He:irtd discussion lasced for over ao hour. Evenly divided at first, the audience rhey Jive. We mUSt distinguish . be ,who ·. live$ by no revelatioa from cne who koows thar God is ie~Cd in nature, io~·; the world, and in histaix· The believing._ Jew's. whole awroaduo _life is ~imooy ; to his fairhfuJaess 'to the "GOd of his fath. ers. Cbrisdaa.s.muS;i respect such__devoted- · 0 DCSS to God." · . . · · . . . · · .· tatked · sub. Btr.LY AND ·1 of still other jects, the plight of Jews beh.ia4- the Iron Curtain. the rclatedn~ 0£ posr-~il> tiol rabbin.ic Judaism aad the New· Test· amenr, distorted Oir.iscia:o: nations of rbe Pbazistts, the moral~ i::i.orolnd- jn rhe .. ness. Jews a.re: uodct no !·pecial gu.ilr and,. Viecnam war, the. dialogue between Jews · in fact, the Church. stands in the same and Ollistians. He .is a brilliant JIWJ~ ~-.itb:~ of l 00 perSO!lS seemed gradually to move mward our point of view. The real issue ha.cl been further impressed oo chem, perhaps, by the action of ~ lllinois Supreme need. of forgiveness. · . a . perceptive miocl,, and. mosc- im~ a"It is my conviction," continued- Billy· heart that c;ares deq>ly_ ab9ut people. •. Graham, ."chat Ollist is the way to-God's · I left ·Momreu.-satisfied tbsr our di~·; forgiving love, ;but it ill behooves me to alogue would continue, encouiaged that · Cou~ ·which . on judgc~~Josc.cuualvacioo..-....eY~..fuogcc_i~~.i;ssibl~.,.,l _, ___ _ . the eve of-Ute-mttring-. h:id upheld Chiago's Fair Housing Ordin.ince. Sensing the swing in popular feeling, the male.er of the original motion suddenly withdrew it, clearing the way for an almost unanimous voice-vote passage of che mocion barring discrimi· nation. IN THl! aftermath, the brokers involved in the · conciliartion hearings held by the Commission on Human Reluions as a resulr of the AOL complaints agreed to · · f h serve appropnace nocu:e. o t e now established policy of Vista Homes. The two realto"'signed ·formal agreements • .., }ed!rino ro offer the aaOT"ieved UniverP o -0 oosity couples the opportunity to concracr for any available property offered through ·them. ThPV that all their -, also d pledged be !Led empl oyees woul not.in in writing · ' obl" · Of t h e agencies 1gauoos und er t h e Fair Housing Ordinanc,.. m"d;..... t;"g that . • • -. .._ "' any employee v1olat1ons. would be grounds f~ dismissal· that all listing aareements . '.: BILLY GRAHAM from pog• 2 . punuhm~t :is a consequence of s~fuJ ness, but rbere is also· a suffering that is a martyrdom. Cbrist.iaos h~ve also suffer· cd io history. Are we to explain all snffering as punishment? Certainly cot. .. "Furthermore, we must confess · that Ou-isrians sinned against Jews in the name of Christ.ian.ity. Not God, but men whe> . failed to claim 9f God in their beans perpettatecl every terrible bloody thing. We mllSC repudiate that past nor defend it, nor even· explain it away. · ..AU men are in need of God's fotgive-.;. Continued • . . o- God, in His own time and wry, will jaJ,gc all men by the light according co which STATEMEl'll' OF OWNERSHIP MANAGEMENT AND CIRCULATION !Act of October 23, 1962( Section -4369, Titl• 39, U"ited Stota Code1 I. Dot• of filir19: Octobet- I, 1967. 2. Tjtle Publlcotto": AOL BULLETIN. · 3 · F;eque"cy of Issue: Monttl!) mccept July and August. 4. Location of 1uio.,.,, office of riubllcotl°" (Street, City, County, Sttite, Zif> Code): 315 Lexl"Qton Ave., N- York, N.V. 10016. 5. Location of the tleodQuorten « q.nercl busineu offices of the publi.tlers (r10tV'.rinren): ll5 t · t A N Y-'- N 10016 .· exing on ve., """• . • . 6. Nomes and cdcltesses of publ;.tier, editor, and monogl"g editor: Publisher (Nome ond CJddress): Antl-Defomotlon Loogue of B'ooi B'rith, 315 Le)(ington Ave., New York, N.Y. 10016. Editor (Nome ond oddr~J: Lynn& Ianni.Ila, llS Lexington Ave., New York, N.Y. 10016. Mor>00lno Editor: "°"9. 7• Owner Clf owned by 0 corporat~. Its nome ond oddress must be stoted and obo lmmedimely thereum!er the n.omes cilld od-elf~ of ato-ckhold~ . owning or holding l petcCf"lt or more of total a.m~t of stoc.k. If not owned by 0 corpo.-cition, the names ancJ addresses of the ir>dividool ownen must be give". If owned by ci portnenhip or other uni1">COrpo1ated · firm, In nome ond addt11U, os well <1$ thot o_f each individual m~t ~given): Antl-Oefomot10n League of B'ncu B'rith, 31 S of · left Momrear respeaful of Qri$riimicyand suengthenec;I iq ~y Judaism. · .. · · · · · · ·• trust-. secwl{y ~ wt!O·C:JO· nOt ~ Up0,, tt.e·· books of the COl'l\PCIAf' m hoid stock end secwlties in a ccpcw:lfY ottwr"thon that . of o borlo· fide OWMr. Nolnes end of lndi~la ,..f» ~ shd<h~ o-f a , corporotlof\ whicti. inalf Is a stockhalder or· • hold9r of bondll, ~ 0r ott.r sec:urftle-;.. of the publishino corporation ...,_ beef\ in. · eluded In parcgl'Cll:lha 7· crid 8 ..t11in ti. ir... te-rem of llUd\ lndivlduclla eris ~ fl) •• , 1 per~ oi mot• of 1+10 totot ciincWrt af tti• · · ~k « sec:wities of fl:le. publilhing .corpo.. ;· . rot.an. . . . . . . .•• . ,.. 10. Ext8'1t ond ~ of cfrculotton; . 11.veroli• ' Striol• No.~ ·tseue ... , . • iss.... r:rearest.. •: ·• . during . . to .·.". . . P!DC~ --fll!no. '1211\0!'tfti ·:.'?&ifir· ' · . -..•• o> Totol No. CopM!s ·~ .. · :·~ ·- ·. odd...,.., eadl ~~~- <Ne•. in,900" .. is3-,0oo Prea. b'' Po·,... Cl~·._.'-.· ·.· .· "' ,_,..,_, . ·- ···:· -. 1. Sale$ ttvouoh deal- ., . etS ·cncf corrfen - ;..- ah"eet vendori . ·· a;.d' · . ·; ./ count..- soles · ·' · · '· None 2.Mail subscript~ ' 171.000 c) Total POid . . . ~·, .· cln:1.1lotlor> · , . . 171,000 d} Free cfistributton ·"Oft. . ·· - NoN - . 17&.300:. · ··. • ·· '_i1~.:ioQ:,..~· · ·· •· ... · • -~- :···.·,·. --=:. -=:rr!.,c:~ wrply'~:.U~-- -·~~~;t_~,J~~~~ -.--·- ~-~ ~r:·- ·.:·:· .. c, 01!v~~~1 . • • ..,,,.....,.,, ~ro en.. ,..,~ m s s: ,,..,_. '" . . . .• . . . ),.900 · :4 /JOIJ .·;:, ,- • :. ; :. . J 1 ;; '1 ~ • J ] i. f Ordmance; ·aod that w1thm ten days a · _a:.da · uld L.:. b . _.1 swo:n IWl vrt wo oe SU mm:c:o certifyrno- that oone of cheir applications for -o · . . sales or lease cormuned any reference to race reHgion, or national origin.. • The Olicago onl inaoce deals only with the acnons . • d.1v1"du:iI o f b r okers, not o f m · ll b ch a Iaw at or cooperanve se ers, ut SU least makes it impossible m · use a broker 8. known bondhold°"• ,.,_,~, ond ottiersecurityholderso-•ngorholdi"~lpercent or mo<e of total. a~t of boTldS;. ..-tgages.or other securities (of or• none, oo ~tote}. None. . 9. Porogrophs 7 ond 8 lneh.ldclho wtisre the stockholder « secwlty Id« oi>pears upon the books of the company os trustee or In <l"Y ottitt fiducia'ry relation, the nome of the person or corporation fOf .mom sud> tr"'t" b acting, olso the statemenn i,, the two pcro9rophs 1how the oHiont's full i.tnowledge a"'1 belief O$ to the c;ra.tnstonces _ond conditi°"s under which stockholdors and th.,.• m- e} Totol distribution -. • (svmofCandO) ·· f) Office uso, teft..;over, Ul'IQccounted,, )74,900 · 180300: - ·. ·. ' ? . ' spoil.ad · l)>oO . · 2,i'Oer" · · ·. E. & - '·'~(.". · ,:. F-V.O...ld ec;uol ·net ll.· press run shown in A) in,900 1a:i,Ooo . · . . . I certify tnot the stcternenb. made bj. .,,. . . Gbove 0 ,.. cC>rJect ond comps.ta . , · -~· · ~ • . . (S;gn.d) LY".!"• '°""19uo; Editor ofter pnntlng g) Total- s.,,.. of in the process of discriminatory selling, · a.ad the inability to use brokers would cramp sales coru.iderably. :fl _ . .. It would seem that our democracy has . · · ~ evolved to.the point where relatively few persons are wiliing to defend discrimina- SUPPORT THE 1967 ADL APPEAL ' tory howing publicly. In the Visra Homes icmance, the evidence was sufficiently clea.r so that further evasive maneuvers :l AN · 1$ '()t ~lLi >ioC.\ Abf~8t1 'IC £t r')Jlii si:.,,, , 1f t~Oft)~ ",",,1 )I J JaW><i' ssop puz so ~ . . .,,.. ...... ~ :. c}1 91001 'l'DA...,.. '"e>oy ~ SIE lllmDt](filfi. . . . r- . . . . ....~ ~ lf)_l'<t JS)~ ')•f'I on the pare of discriminacory persons bee.me impossible. ·, ···- ·: ; . .-.. . ~- .. ,_ ~-: . .: [end] Original d©coame111ts faded ar:idfor illegible ..... - ,. - Febro.uy s. 1969 Hare ·rane!th1Nm Gerald Strober · .Vi.81.t ~th Dr. 2Gbert ·Fens Dr. "%. W. WllaOD of Hanuiut. North CarollDa coecerD!ag the .Iraqi aleu.tloo and the poaetbllity of Dr. Bill)' Craba f.aauiQg a at:a~e.mt on tba fate of the Iraqi Jeila. Dr. Wlhon 1"11'tioned that Dr. Gra!Mm was very CODCened with . . . . the la.ql problelt ad tbat ·ID Che last several daya bad talked with ·-· bigb officials iD Vah1ngt:on conceming the altuatioa. He iadl~ted that part of me pmb1- Dr. (Maha bu tn det..tahg --~ to make public atatm•ta oa •pee.iflc teaues. h iafomatlona1. that J.a, Dr. Grahm is. ~Eten not clear u to the face. surron.-Hng • given problem. For exeaple., Dr. Wilaori menctanad tbat .bU flt•t n.cttoo . to tha baog1ngs .a... ~ dou' ·t the &aqi .Jews luve the couna:y?" He d1cl not realize that .Jevlah edgutlon la bamaed. Be 81.l&IUted ·ttaat t COllblet Dr. -.obert l"ftll vbQ is York· City uranatng · ·0n Jannlry 31et .I •Poke by telepbofte _b> in._ . . J>r• . GrCI•'• June meetlnga at Madison Squatt ~. Be said t;bat Dr. ·l'ema vou1d report. to Dr. Ooh• dlrectly _, iafomatJ.oa. we could gift Ida c~ the situation of Iraqt ~- . 1 contacted Dr~ Fem thK dteraooo Ga w mauged for b~ to ccme to oar offices Oil Tuesday• Feb. 4tb. Jlabbl Rudin, Mn. Bank1 and I .bad a lengthy dlscuul.aa vitb Dr. Fem.. l>r.. Fe.- biped the dlscussian. Be said that he would •end the tape to Dr. Grabml al<mg vit:h Ms evaluation of our •etlng. . We bd.eft!ld Dr. Fam on the situation ·c QDfroncing Iraqi .Jt!.'ftr7 ad gave hta aeveul docments includiog ·a fact ahaee-•an Iraq, a con of the petitlOll of the Grand Rabbi of Bagda4 ~o die haql gwe-iwnt~ • copy of .Jews. 1D Arab Led•. a co" of cbe Everett Paner releue and telegram ad copiea of letters to U l!umt fraa Rev.. Bllheiaer .ad Msgr. O..terreicher.. l>r. Ffta t.adicated that Dr. Grahaa 1s quite inttttea~·ed 1n the fate of tbe renaint.Qg Iraqi J'e11t1 and · ~ buicatly h1a ·ra J>athies would certaWy be with diem. Be wu concerned as to the souxcea of our inf~ ... matli:IQ. • stated tbat lf Dr. Grahaa were to issue a st:ittemezic he voald •swedutel7 be called. upon to cit;e the sources ~f bis lnfomatioll. Dr. Fexm theref0%e asked us to provide him vltb the auurcea of the lnfozmation con~lned in the fact· sheet. · ,· I .,,.. • r - -2He said that a letter from Justice Arthur Goldberg to Dr. Graham · confirming the reliability of the information in the fact sheet would be sufficient, Dr .. Ferm left us with· the feeling .that if such a lette1." ~ould be sent, Dr. Graham may issue a public statement on the Iraqi situation. · · · We also di·s cussed in general tea:ms some theological aspects of the Jewlsh-<Ju1.stian relationship as it ~elates to evangelical <Jiristians. 1 think that the I A D· staff felt that this waa a godd contact and that Dr. Ferm would be open to future ccimmmtcations from us. He stated that _h e would be happy i-eceive from us any f\n:thei- infor.;. mation we have on the lraqi situation and we will put him on our Christian mailing list •. to . One final note is of interest. . When I esc.e;>rted Dr. Ferm to. tb:e lobbY.~. he .stated that there are .SQ!De .Cbristians who would be quite concemed to !mow that Dr:. Graham had sent. him to the. American· Jewish Committee . for a briefhlg. Br,., Fel!ID indicated that the feet that he had: come evidences a willingness· on _ the part of Dr. Grahsin- to seek out information on vital cantanporaey is~s. · · · Mrs. .B anki is following-up ·the. J~t!ce· Gol~arg ·comnuni.cation. ·. .GS:as cc: . .J. Budin .J. Banki .· F~ruary 12~ <kllclber~ Arthur. J .. Judith Re: 1969 B. Banki Attached As part of· our effort to mobili-zc <2lri$Cian opinion in prot.e s.t of the Iraqi trials and hangings, Rabbi James Budin• Gerald Sttobe.r · and I -m et with. Dr. Bobert o .• Ferm, an associate of Dr. Billy Graham for the past 18 yeara. · Dr.. Fem te>ld us that Dr. -Graham bad already made known privatel7 his "personal concern" ~ the Xraqi sibiation:J. but .mmt be particul.41:'1y cautious- about any pub1i~ .eta~e ment because .anyth_tug be :says 1a sure to be challenged. He questioned us about the sources of our statements during the briefing, and then added. uOf course l f -a ma of the stature of Mr. Justif:e Goldberg were to verify chi& infcmnat!C)ll, 1 am sure Dr. Graham would be 11e>re .than satisfied. n . : . . . , . Accord!Dgly, 'I drafted a letter :iD your name to be sent ~ Dr. Graham. The. enclosures 1 ill addition to ·o ur fact . s~t~ · includeJ' some -copies of statements made by leaders in the f.bI"lstian c<Ju111wd'ty and of the. lraqi leglalatioa discriminating agatoe1: Jews. I hope.· you will find the letter acceptable. Mrs.. Selma Hirsh will follow up with your ~etary to determine whether or ~t you are .sendtng · it. · "fhaQk you for your coopera~ion•. JHB:as En.cs. . . Please note that although the lettei: is addJ;essed P.S. to Dr. Graham beadquar~ ~ No~th Carolina• it will ·be dellve-red to his ~s9Ciate, Dr. Fei'Jn at the New York headquarters. ~· think _it .pref~able to send the lette~ by personal messenger .and will arrange for its transmittal. Fem1; willtth~ f~ward . lt to Dr- Billy Graham. at bis »r. CC: B. Gold s. Birsh Fe!mtary t~~ 1969 y// The Bev. Dr.. Billy Grahm Montreat. Bo:rth Ca'oltna · Dear Dr. Graban: . At- a ~ent. meectng. betlleen 7oui' assocJate. Dr. RObert o. Fem• mtd staff ~s of die Ame.ricm J'ewiab Coilpnft:tee, Dr. Fft1D Sugge$t.ed that you wollld welcome saae pe:rsou;al nassurance by · :me ftgard1og the st.atus of the Jewish c,..mtcy in Iraq and ~be r~_enc .seuet: ~ and public 110Qgfngs ID Baghdad and Basra. . . The in:fomatloa.-contained·ln· the enclosed fact ·s heet ts accurate~ Ohviousty. tam not ~vy t.o the -records¢ the s.ecret tt.i.a.ls, ~t the facts coted .ia the attached she~t and· elsewhe-re, sucb· as the 111iter~ of the .alleged ~~·~ of tbe' "~ionage rl.1lg" and the .constaat:·survelllance •mder whtch the Jen .have lived In .Iraq et.nee June 1967•. make the charges particularly dubiaus 9 a.s does tbe very utme of die trtala and esecutlotas . . k& tOr the legislatiotl wblcb. bas increasjugl;F restricted the civil and penonal liberties · : of .Jews ta Iraq sioce a early as '1950 and• ~tty · as 1968~ · that ·u a matter of Public rec.orc1 (d~ ataaebecl).. · · · . . ~ · A maber of appeals have been ll8de to the Inq1 gcwerment Jly' ~... ' presenutives.. of aad.anat. g0Vf.!nnet1t:S as well as 1'y ioterilatianal organiza~ ~ Teliglou.s leaders. . Copies of 8~ of these atate111e1ata are ~losect. Ve woul.d ve:ry 1111Ch appreciate . your adding yei:n: · . voice Co tba't of otllei· eminent a.rlstiaia Qake-.m lilho have pi:otested the barbarity of· the IYaqt. ac.ttoDS. . Perbapa even more important iD ·, ·· . order bl. $ave ~ lives . 0£ .t:he -rem•Wag aa:ben. of · the harassed and . . . terrorized remnants of t!Je Jewiah conmun1.ty tu Iraq would be a stat~ . · . . meat urging. tile &aqf. gover.Qment to ·allcaJ the remefn.lng .J~ to 1~ . . . . . ' .. .. . . .. . -· . the country.· Your lnt:ernaticmal stature as a religious ·leader and ·y our penonal reputation ·for outstaracU.n g integrity wO\ild do mlieh to further ·such -an ~1. .· · . . . If I may be. of fvrtber assistance tn dlf.3 Wlt.~~. pleas·e ·d o not · ·. hesitate to c:ont:ac.~ me. · · Yo"8 .siacerely•· . Artlmr J. Goldberg ·President AJG!as F&iCa. - .· J ' ... .. . . . ·. ··.. .Jun~ S, 1969 Dr. BQbert Ferm · 1500 Bergen Blvd. · ·11t. Lee• New ·Jersey . Dear Dr. Ferm: · This is to confizm the ·c1ace ancJ time ~4t_~eting with Dr~ Billy · .Graham. We ,,t.11 be bapw to have Dr.~. his colleagues meet at our offtce on Mmiday, .June 23rd between .10 and ll · in the morning. ·. We are now putting together a . lis~ of people Who will be present at the meeting and when thiS list is finalized l will be happy to share it with you. lf .Jt is possible. I would appreciate learning from you the names .o f those f.Ddividuills who will .be accompanying Dr. Graham on the 23rd. · · . . ' I appreciate your efforts .in helping to ·arrange the meeting ·and .. ~k foJ;Ward to seeing you · in the tlOt _ t oo distant 6Jbre. · Cordially yours, Gerald ·strober. Consultant . Ioten.-eligioua Affairs Department '. GS:as THIE £ME~DCAN dante QO 9rom subDect JIEWISH COMMITTEE r June 9, 1969 7 Marc Tanenbatnn Gerald Strober Program for /~; ~he~illy · Grciham/ Meetfng l~ The following is a suggested program for the meetmng with Dr. Billy Graham on June 23rd. 1. Opening Remarks of Welcome Mr. Philip E. Hoffman, Pres. American Jewish Connnittee 2. Introductions Mr. Bertram Gold, Exec. V. P. American Jewish Conmittee 3. Introduction of Subjects and Moderation of Discussion - Rabbi Marc Tanenbaum Possible subjects for discussion: .., a. Israel and the Middle East Crisis b. The relationship between American Jews and Evangelical Protestant conununity. c. Christian teaching and anti-Semitism. d. Proselytism, Conversion, theology of the people of God. e. Church and State. r There will, of course, be an opportunity for Dr. Graham and his colleagues to introduce subjects f~iscussion. GS:as · •· ·: ..J\IDe 9. 1969 . - Marc Taq~ Gerald Strober . ~ for ahe Billy Graham Meeting -ihe folla.tag is a suggested. FOP'• for the .meeting with Dr• Billy Graham OD -June 23J:d. . .. . 1. . ~ . 8-aarka- of-Welcome Hr. Philip E~· Boffiaan, hes. · · ~ .Jewish Carmittee . Hr. Bertram Gold, Exec. v. p ~ Ameriean Jewish Comnittee - 3. . Introduction of &Jbjecte aad Moderation of Dlscuaalon - Rabbi Ma%'c Tanenbaum Possible auhjecta for dlscussi.oo: . a. Israel and 'the Middle P.asi: - ~is b. Die relatlonsblp betweell American. .Jews and Evangelical Protestant .c oammtey. c. Qristl.an. eeachtng and an~i-Semltlsm. 4. Proselytism. Conversion, dleology of -tbe e. Qmrc:h amt people of Goel.. · State. · · · !here will, of course, be an opportunity for Dr. Graham and bis colleagues GS:aa . co introduce subjects for discussion. / ·.1 / / l THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE Institute of Human Relations • 165 East 56 Stre~t. New York,: N. V. 10022 • Plaza 1-4000 • Cable Wishcom, New York Office of the President June 10, 1969 Dear Friend, Dr •. Billy Graham, nationally prominent Protestant leader, will be visiting New York City within the next several weeks. We have· arranged an informal, off the record, meeting between Dr. Graham and Jewish academic and com·munal leaders, 0n June 23, from 9:30-11 ~.M. It is our hope that in such a session, a frank exchange of views will take place. The meet·i ng will be held on the 8th floor of the Institute of Human Relations, 165 East 56 Street, New York City. I hope you will join us on this occasion. Given the shortness of time, please excuse the use of a form letter. It would help us in making arrangements if you would let us know if you can attend (PL 1-4000, Extension 206). We look forward with pleasure to meeting you on June 23. Cordially, ... . /? ;.:// 1· ~.::~.: . /../--~,,,I-r,,,,, ·- . - {}.; •·,:· --; . .-,,¥ .·~( / .• ' i. ;;..~·&.--;/ ~ ~. . ':-! ~ // /; / , / . Philip E. Hof£man President PHILIP E. HOFFMAN, President Board Chairmen MAX M. FISHER, Executive· Board DAVID SHER, Board of Governors ELMER L. WINTER, Board of Trustees EMERY E. KLINEMAN, Treasurer MRS. SANFORD SAMUEL. Secretary MORRIS H. BERGREEN, Associate Treasurer BERTRAM H. GOLD, Executive Vice-President MORRI S B. ABRAr_,1, Honorary President JACOB BLAUSTEIN, Honorary President LOUIS CAPLAN, Honorary President HERBERT B. EHRMANN, Honorary President IRVING M. ENGEL, Honorary President ARTH U R J, GOLDBERG, Honorary President JOSEPH M. PROSKAUER, Honorary President NATHAN APPLEMAN, Honorary Vice-President JOSEPH KLINGENSTEIN, Honorary Vice-President FRED LAZARUS, JR,. Honorary Vice-President· JAMES MARSHALL, Honorary Vice-President WILLIAM ROSENWALD, Honorary Vice-President MAURI CE GLINERT, Honorary Treasurer JOHN SLAWSON, ~ecutlve Vice-Presi dent Emeritus REUBEN W, ASKANASE, Houston, Vice-President MORTON K. BLAUSTEIN, Baltimore, Vice-President MATTHEW BROWN, Boston, Vice-President ROBERT T. CUTLER, Philadelphia, Vice-President OeJONGH, FRANKLIN, .Atlanta, Vice-President JACK A. GOLDFARB, New York, Vice-President ARTHUR GROMAN, Los Angeles, Vice-President ORIN L.EHMAN, New York, Vice-President WILLARD L. LEVY, St Louis, Vice-President· SAM RUBINSTEIN, Seattle, Vice-President MAYNARD I. WJSHNER, Chicago, Vice-President - . . .. · .. :J_,.';}', '.~ · .- .: ·. ·: . . ; : ~ .. . .... .. ; ·'. - 't · • ., ••. : · ,.,· .·· .. EXHIBIT. , . "2'" ·..... RELIGIOUS -2~- DOlill~TlC S~ilVIC~ ... MONDAy I JUNE 23 J 1969 co;.r~:.:::~~s BILLY GilA!IAl.l WITH JE\'iIGH SERVICE HEWS LE!i.D:..::r~s By Raliaious New_s Service (6-23-GD) HE\'l YORK (UNS)- -- An ALlerican Jewish COimni ttce official praised evangslist Billy Grahnm :!'.or breaking down stereotypes about Ba~tist insensitivity to scci~l co~1cerns. Rabbi Lici.rc T~ncn'l:lr:.um, director· of the ·Jewish Commi ttec 's ·department of i-nterreligious aff2.irs, confirocd that the Bn..ptist preacher . had met- with :ibout 30 JeY;ish reliciou$ and comrauni ty lcaC:ers after ·the evanc;elist mentioned the me~ti11cr in a pl,"ess confe:&.·ence ma:t•ldng the encl of a 10-d~y crusade here. The meetincr, it \'Ins e::plained, grew ·o ut of planning for a National Baptist-Jzwi~h Scholars Con:'.:erence schec!ulccl Aue; .. 18-20 a.t the Southern Baptist Thcolo~icnl- Seminn!.·~.r in Louisville, lCy 0" That neeti ng will be . spo11sored Jewish b~,r the Southern !3aptist Eor:ic Co;~1rd ttee 's intcrreligious t~issioi::. Bo:ai•<l ~n<l the Ame1·ican ~f_fairs ui.1~ t. n~bti T~.nenbaum St'.iCi- th~t in his. introckction of tlr 1 Gra.ha~1 to· the Jewish p oup !1..e "had sZ'.icl he was "greatl!' impress eel by the sensi tity ancl c.:ir..ceri1 that he (G14 ~ham) ex:n·essetl for ::ocial justice a~1cl for 4 vi cornm tme~"J:~ to confront such basic wal• and the gene:-i:ation issu~s r\s r~cial g:i~:>." injustice 1 poverty, 1.i.nyo!le, who l~no-.vs the ClGlssical 13r.ptis'i; heri t'~gc which ei,\phr-.sizc::1 incli vic.lual poety nnc1 pe1·son::-.l . sa: vat ion," l'Cli-:0.1 !::ecl the rabbi 1 "h:::.s carried nrounci en im~ge tha~ ccrt~in versions of the Baptist tradition . · 11 4 were ra tber in.s ensi ti VG to social or g:;.·oup coi~cerns. · "Uy imp1·ession is th.at L!r. Gr~l"!am, clm:inc bis ·recent scrrr.ons, has helped to !'e:;:ov~ th<t t cr..1·icn.Ji:u~·e 1 ancl hz..s ccr~o;:Jst:i.·~ tcd that pci-sonal reliaion can _ex~)!.'CSs i t£:0lf in a ve1•y gc;:u_i!1C co::cera :fo1· grout> raorali ty e.11d gro\.1p just~ c c. ·_ "I,ly own f~clin3 is tl18.t he cont1·ih1_; tcc~ ·co n b::-c::-.~':-tln.·ou;:;l;. in cv~~: ·cornin3 some of t~!c rr.:y·i:holo[D' cLb ot~t t11c 13:!. p'cis t l0~C:~::ship :s concc;.·n fo1· soci~:.l ~r;d ccc.no:;1ic iss'l:.cs. 11 nnbbi Tancnbuum s::-"id t!1c:::e W2.S a "genuine fcclinc of rti.pport" Jc~ish lca dGrship~ Ha snid those nt between the evanBclist nnd tha .the r.!~cti n~ ha cl 11 f:.:~ccd f:..--nnl~J.y 11 • :t,!1~oloc;ic:;~1 ~1-:.::.1 so.c ioJ.ogical di f f C}~cnc0s ·between the trnc~i tions, n.ncl h:t~l c::~lore:c1 11 thG st·:.: 0!1:; coi;,r.1on bcn(}s \•:c feel ns pcqp:!.c wi10 sll~.1·c ~ coiL:-.on rc1.'c:rence ·:ro1• thG Dible and B.t blic~l inl!cri ta.nee~ 11 -0- .- BILLY GRAHAM RECEPTION June io, 1969 · ~THEODORE ELUJioFF /RABBI HuoLD..GORmN RABBI ARTHUR HERTZBERG /RABBI Git.BERT ·K.lAPEBMAN jQSEPIJ: KLINGENSTEIN .. V RABBI BENJAMIN KREI'IMAH --.:..__ ... /RABBI MORRIS ICERTZER ~ ·,"" RICHARD MAASS ,/!ERTRAM ~I I. MOWSHOWITZ /EW'ARD ~LDOVER . R!}Je• '''Ul&lii~ ~RABBI u>ms· I. NEWMAN . RABBI' JACOB. PHILIP RUDIN . . .RABBI SOLOMON' 'SHARFMAN· RABBI A. SCHINDLER · RABBI B. SF.GAL ~BBl SEmO~- SIEGEL VDA.VlD SHER . . /~BBI DAVID sn~ V~ST£IN /RABBI BERNARD WEINBEt.1«:ER ~OU cJd. r. 'R(!)l'f t'.! ~ H. GOLD . · RABBI MAllC TANEHBADM ~BI A. JAMES RUDIN GERALD STROBER VMORTON YABHON -./'SIMON SEGAL. -~~:!8 FINE s~ _a~~,,_ "' . \\ \ \ , . ; ,. 1 _ RELIGIQUS NEWS SERVICE, 43 WEST 57TH ST., N. Y. 10019 ~;~'COFFEESUCCESS PR~ SOLID BI HOUSE' .. -.. _THURSDAY, JUNE 19, 1969 By Religious News Service (6-19-69) NEW YORK (RNS) -- Colored lights played over the large ballroom, and huge flowers fluoresced under "black" lights. On the stage a rock group from Pittsburgh played current hits, and at the tables the young people -- no one over 25 was admitted -- talked about Christ. The coffee house sponsored by Billy Graham's New York Crusade has been a solid success in the numbers it has drawn -- some 800 to 1,000 have come each night -- and has also given an unusual opportunity for Christian witness. Thre~ musical groups, one from Australia, one from Pittsburgh and one f:com Washington, D.C., have provided music for the young people who came to drink Pepsi, eat potato chips and talk 1 and tJ.eobers of . the -troupes have made their own witness to Christ. At the tables, volunteers trained by the Crusade team talked with visitors about the need for following the Christian way, but the musical groups have been the focus of attention. · On tbe sixth night of the New York campaign lllike Johnson, the lead guitarist for the Exkursions, a "ha~d-rock" group from Pittsburgh, finished a round of secular songs, and then began to tal~ quietly of his religious.experienceo He and other members of the band had made the "drug scene," Mike said, but had not been satisfied until they turned to ·christ. Since his conversion, he said, he had found that "you can really dig life ••• and reality" when you follow Jesus. Before the show began, he told an RNS reporter that a few since his conversion, he had gone back -- briefly -- to drugs, that each time, even though the dr~gs got him "high," they had satisfied him, and he felt that he had betrayed Christ's trust times but . not in him. The mustached, side-burned guitarist urged those in the hushed room to make their. own decisions for Christ. : The young people filed slowly out. Some stopped to talk with Cr.usade counsellors. The cc)f.f ee ·house has - foliowed the Crusade evangelism meeting's · in Madison Square Garden. The services, led by Mr. Graham.,'h::ve drawn 9 in six days, more than 131,500, and resulted in 5,634 personal decisions for Christ. ·· · ·· The largest attendance was on the sixth night of the Cr~sade -a Wednesday -- as 20,000 _filled .the Garden arena and 4,500 were directed to the Garden'~ Felt Forum, where they watched the. services on a huge, closed circuit color TV screen.· Mr. Graham, in his sermon, said that wars and tbe evils of mankind "come from within." (more) PAGE -1-· R E L I G I 0 US DOMESTIC SERVICE NEWS -2- SERVICE TIIURSDAY, JUNE 19, 1969 "It is a heart problem," he said. "We have to get the heart changed. we have to get the heart transformed. " An estimated 972 persons came down the aisles to respond to his call, The· largest numbe~ of decisioQs, ~owever, came on Saturday night, the second of the Crusade, as 1,009 registered their commitment to Christ~ -0- MULTI-MEDIA J"AZZ ORA TOR IO SET AT INTERCHURCH CENTER By Religious News Service (6-19-69) NEW YORK (RNS) -- With a necessary nod to Johann Sebastian Bach, the Manhattan premiere of a mJlti-media jazz oratorio has been set for June 25 at the Interchurch Center here. Titled "Christ Lag in Todesba::iden" (Christ Lay in Death's Bonds), it is mo'1eled on the famous Bach cantata of the same name and carries t ee sub-title, "Where Do We Go from Here?" Co-sponsors o~ the prog~am are the School of Social Music at Union Th€ological Seminary and the Department of Church and Culture of the Nat ional Council of Churches. The score fo~ the musical happening is by Ed Summerlin, composer of the first jaz~ ).::.turgy performed in a church. Roger Ortmayer, pe'3t and ::i.irector of the NCC' s culture department, has written the text w~icli is intended to create a contemporary expression of the Easter s t ~ry. The m~sic employs traditional and unorthodox effects of voice and instruments, including strings 7 trumpets, trombones, alto saxophone, bass, drums, tap recorder, transistor radio, and overhead projectors. Direc~ion of t he composition will be in the hands of Herbert Beattie, a singer with the New York City Opera and San Francisco Opera Companies. Ya-. Beattie was in charge of direction when the work received its world premiere last March in Massepequa, N.Y., at a concert sponsored by the Nassau Council of Churches. The composition's presentation at the seminary's workshop has the primary purpose, according to a se~inary spokesman, of stimulating "the cre~tion of new music, new repertoire, new techniques to inspire local choirs and congJ;"ega tions." -0PAGE -2- . .· . ~ Philip B. Hoffman ~\) lllaer L.. Winter AJ cl .Max M. Fisher David Sher 'i 4 Jack A. Goldfarb 1Je:. Joseph Kllngenstein f lttcbard Maass l'rank Al~scbul. w~ Mervin Rf..seman ~• Newton G11ckel -~ -,-e.s Bernard Abrams S. H. Scheuer . Jewish CmmuniSJ PeOple .. Abraham J. Beschel ,.i,, Wolfe Kelman NO Balfour Brickner-f o· · Irving Greenberg ~ · Bernard Handlebaum {ti 9 Seymour Sieg(;!l y·Q .· . Fmam1el 1'ackman )Jo · · . Arnold Jacob Wolf 1.1-0 . · Bernard Weinberg~r·{ e.S. Gilbert Klappeman (e.S . Israel Howsbowitz 'f e..S · . Isaiah Htnkoff ffe..,"'-( J. Ste/~,,,; ti~ ff2..1N ~ 2J/,;J' j~ ,.~ pt,Cf 1c . !( ~+ Ge>~~.· . A-~ j/€rf;.6~t . . . sd ee~ ~ c:s( ~ 1-1a..tJ . . /~"~ £k~ (_e! . ~u #.J_<l~no.-; i:~.> fd~/1~~ ~ T.d- ak"~ .? r l~·•·t~fN /;I- (~+/'\~ y '€J . ~~~ ~~ .... . ' 23"r d . 9:30-11 .. . . ~ --~ .... . . -~INSCRIPTION FOR ..GRAHAM Gll'r to COMMEMORAtE THE FIRST VISIT .OF THE REVEREND IJOCTOR BILLY .GRAHAM 'tO THE INSTITUTE OF 81JMAN RELATIONS* . THE ~ICAN JAWISH. COMMITTEE IS HONORED TO PllESENr THIS UNIQUE VOLUME OF SACRED $~ AND ~ARY• THE SPDUTUAL. B~ ·. OF GOD~S . WOii> WRICH LINKS· CHUSTtANS AND . . ,' . JEWS ··~···•::·=- 7 ....... _Tammu.z : 5729 · . Jube 23, 1969 .. .. ; . . . ·, .. . ' .. ' ,· ..' ·. •. ~· .;. · . 3 (D 3 ,0 THE AMERl ,C AN JEWISH COMMITTEE DI !- May 13, 1969 date to from Marc H. Tanenbaum Gerald Strober subject Dr, Billy 1" / - ~11 be in New York City from June 13"".23 to hold a major crusade at Madison Square Garden. I think we might explore the possibility of :holding a private luncheon for Dr. Graham. The purpose of such an event could be to establish an interreligious relationship with Dr. Graham, to meet key members of his staff, including T.W. Wilson who will very likely be in New York during the crusade, and to explore issues such as the Middle East and Jewish-Evangelical relations in the U.S. I am certain he would be interested in the August colloquium with the Southern Baptists. If we decide to set up a meeting we might have a good contact in Dr. Robert Ferm who visited our office several months ago to discuss the Iraqi crisis. I would suggest that if you are inclined to arrange a meeting that we begin immediately to set it up since there will be a tremendous danand on Dr. Graham's time when he is in the city. ~ GS : rd cc: Judith Banki James Rudin ·.; •f -/ ,_;· ~ a. c 3 ..• N E \'I .S RELIGIOUS ·n or,msTIC S~RVICE . I . I S E R V I C E ·MOHDAY, JUNE 23, 1969 ·· -2C- B!LLY GnMIA!'.1 CmJFERS l'IITll J E\"/IGH LEADERS By Religious News Service (6-23-69) . . :. i.JE\'l YORI( ( RNS) -- An Aro1erican Jewish Committee offici.a l praised evan3elist Billy Graham !or brealdpg clown stereotypes about Baptist inseusi ti vi ty to sccial co:1cerns. nn.bbi ),Jarc Tanen-;,,~um, director of the Jewish Collllui ttec.' s departrp.en-t of ·i -nterreligious "-ffairs, confirraed that the Eaptist preacher ha<l met with about 30 Jewish religious and community leaders. after the evanc;elist mentioned the mcetL13 in a press conference marking the end of a 10- d~y crusndc here. The raeetin[;, it was e;;plai:ied, grew out of plauning for a National Baptist-Jewish Scholars Couierence sche~uled Au3. 18-20 at the Southern · Baptist Theolo;;ical Seminary in Louisvill~, !Cy.· That meeting wi ll be sponsore<l by the Soutl1ern !3<!.ptist F.ol:le r:iission Board and the Ame1~ican Jewish Co;;if:'.it tee 1 s interreli gious affairs unit. naMJ'l Tanenbaum said· that in his introclt~ction of Mr , Graham to· the J_ewis .t~ group he ~hacl s::i.id he was 11 greatl~r impi·essed by the sensi tivi ty a1!cl. c.:.oncern that he (Graham) eX~)l'essed :for social .justice and for co1nr.tl tr.ie.-1-;; to coil front such basic i ssues as i·acial injustice, poverty, war and the generation gav. " Anyo11e , who knows the classical. Baptis·i:: heritage which er.ipi1nsized inc1ivickal pcie-ty and personal ::;a~vation,. re1il.a:rl~ecl the rabbi, "~rns carried a::'.'otmd an ir:m.{;e that certa;in versions o::J the Baptist tradi t:ion were rather in.s ensitive · · : . to social or group cbi1cerns. 11 11 -·-.. "Uy impression is that Tfil• . Graham , ciurin:; his recent sermons 1 hns helpecl to remove that .caricatu;.·e, anc1 ·ha? · tki~oastratcd that personal reliGion can e·x press itself in a very genuine co:~cern for group raorality an~ group justice, · ''i•iY own feelin~ is ·that he contributed to a break- through in overcomin3 some of the rr..ytholocry abot~t t:1e · Baptist l eadership's concern for socitq. ·ar.:d economic issues." nnbbi Taneub<ium sa.ic1 thei·e \V::!.S a "genuine feeling 'o f rapport" between the evanBelist ancl the Jev;ish leadership . He said those at the meetinG had "faced frankly" theological and soc i ological differences between the traditions, and had e;~plorccl "the strong couunon boncls we fee l as people wilo sll~.re n. commoa reverence 'for the Eible and Biblical inheritance~ 11 -0~· .. ' .. .~ PAGE - 21J- 3 3 • ,0DI THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE date to from subi~Ct June 4, 1969 Rabbi Marc Tanenbaum CONFIDENTIAL a. c 3 Gerald · Strober ·Meeting .with Dr •. Billy Graham I received a telephone call today from Dr. associate of Dr. Billy Graham. Dr • . Ferm reported would like to accept ·our invitation for ·a meeting New York ' City later ·this month • . Dr. Graham would our ·office on Monday, June 23rd between 10:00 and ::s Robert Ferm, an that . Dr. Graham while he is in like to meet at 11:00 A.M• . I mentioned to Dr. · Ferm that · I would have to consult with you to clear the date an~ time and that r ·would cormnunicate with ' him in the next two ·or three days to solidify the appointment. Dr, Ferm said that Mr. Graham was especially interested in having as many of the proposed participants in the June 23rd meeting as possible attend, as individuals, one session of his New York .Crusade which is to be held at Madison .Square Garden from June 1322nd • . Dr. Ferm is sending several reserve seat tickets to me • . I have discussed this with Judy Banki and we both feel that the invitation to attend the 'Gr.aham meeting reflects an . anxiety on Dr. Graham's part concerning the June 23rd meeting at the AJC. Ap·parently Dr. Graham is concerned that some of the individuals who may be present at our meeting will have a stereotyped view of his activities. He evidently feels that if participants in the June 23rd session can see him in one of his CrUsade settings they will have a more balanced view of his intentions and work. Dr • . Ferm stressed that Mr. Graham was most interested in having the participants in the June 23rd session understand what his New York meeting involves • . I mentioned to him that several of the Jewish participants would not be in New York during the period of Dr. Graham's Madison Square Garden meetings and, of course, we are under . no obligation to attend these meetings. I definitely feel that we should go ahe.ad :with the June 23rd session for the following reasons: A. To establish an interreligious relationship with Dr. Graham. B. To, in a preliminary way, discuss American Jewish concerns for Israel and the Iraqi Jews. C. To discuss the -Southern Baptist -Colloquium and other aspects-of our activities involving evangelical Protestants. GS:FM - c.c. Judy Banki - Rabbi A. James Rudin n . . . MondC\y, June 23, 1969 ' I • l MEETING \-/ITH BILLY GRAHAM ANO J£\./ISH LEADERS AT AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE Ronald Kronish The American Jewish Committee convened a meeting of a small number of Jewish··~. · leaders to talk informally with Billy Graham. Present at the meeting were members of the American Jewish Comm ittee staff as welt as representatives of Reform, Con.servative and Orthodox rabbinical leadership. I represented t~e UAHC. To say the least, hearing Billy Graham talk in this small group setting was a fantastic learning experience for me (and It seemed so for everyone present). My image of the man as a wild raving fundamentalist evangelist was severely shattered. He talked softly and ~uccinctly. and his position vis a vis Israel was very impressi ve. After prefacing his remarks with the usual statements about the need for diaw logue and communication, he talked mostly about his relationship to Israel. First he explained why he felt so at home in Israel when he was there, the main reason being that he has studied the Bible so much. (At this potnt, he sidetracked with a 0 quick story about how his wife, upon looking down at Jerusalem from atop the Mount of ~Olives. referred to it as a "Biblical smorgasbord".) He P.ointed :o ut that, con1 I trary to the worries of many Jews, he went to Israel not to proselytize but to visit the Holy Places and talk to people. In addition to his love for Israel as the land of the Bible. Mr. Graham related some of h.is personal ties to Israel. He sends a tour of American people to Israe l every month (100-150 go with his "Protestant expert on Israel" for a 2 week I visit). Also, one of his daughters married a Swiss and . ~hey have gone to Israel to I ~~rk (he claims that they are mo re Zionist than many Zionists). daughter are In Israel working on motion pictures. Another son and They've made one on Jerusalem and they are working on another one now. Before dealing with some of the political implications of rsrael vis a vTs the Chri st ian community, Rev. Graham briefly waxed th~ologlcal on the subject of • 2 - Israel. He stated that he believes that Israel is God's chosen people and that no- thing wlll dislodge Israel from the face of the earth. · (He cited portions from Deuteronomy and Isaiah as proof.) He said, "No combination of powers wfl l dis Iodge :. I Israel because God is with them." On his most recent trip to Israel, Rev. Graham met wlth Golda Meir and Abba Eban (his "old friend 11 ) and he offered his help in whatever way possible. He told Mrs. Meir that because Chrlstians in Arab countries are worried about his proIsrael statenents (for fear of reprisals against them), he wil1 refratn from publlc pronouncements on behalf of Israel but instead he promised to work privately in using his influence whe.rever possible. that he has dlscus~ed In connection with this, Rev • . Graham mentioned Israel a number of times with President Nixon, and as of his most recent visit with Nixon in Key Biscayne, he described the President as "ext reme 1y sympathet i c 11 towards Israel. After his short talk, Rev. Graham responded to a few questions. asked htm what the Christian reaction has been in the United States to his pro-Israel positlon. I He didn't directly answer this, but instead explained brief1y some aspects of the : factional ism in Christianity. Some Protestant eschataloglst~ believe that prophecy is being fulfilled in Israel (e.g. reconquest of Jerusalem and expansion of territory, as promised by God in the Old Testament). Onthe other hand, there are still some funclamental lst Christians wlth deep-rooted prejudice who uphold the belief that Jews put Christ to death (a belief which Rev. Graham preaches against). I ..I When asked about the alleged silence of the Christian churches concerning israel after the June 1967 war, Rev. Graham responded that this had to do wfth lead- 1· ership rather than with the lay people. He feels that most American· Protestants are pro-Israel, but the church leaders have had to be cautious oecause they fear upsetting the Christian situation in Arab countries. I c; ~· ....... ·~ ' ... 3In addition to these statements coocerning Israel, Rev. Graham responded to a few questions dealing with separatfon of church and state. He explatned that there is now a movement to pull out of businesses owned by the church. that one should pay tax on business owned by the church. formed a separate, tax-paying org~nization He feels In his own case, he which sells his books and records. Rev. Graham stated that he believes in total separation of church and state; his denomination doesn't even tak~ loans from the government, although. some Baptist untversTties (Stetson, Wake Forest, Baylor) are now beginning to get federal money. On the issue of prayer tn the public schools, R~v. Graham mentioned that even though most Baptists are against it, because they believe in separation of church I .i .' and state, he happens to favor prayer in the public schools because he feels that "our youth need moral teaching". He objects to forcing certain prayers on students, but he cJoes suggest that something like reading the Ten Commandments daily or having students memorize them wou ld be beneficial to their moral education. In talking with us, Rev. Graham conveyed great integrity and honesty. not loud and pompous, as one might have expected. He was i When he didn't fully know an i I answer to a question, he humbly said that he didn't know. well and succinctly. I· He answered quest ions In short, this did not appear to be the same Billy Graham of ~ TV and Madison S~uare Garden. Those of us who were fortunate to talk with him fn- ,,- f orma 11 y came away wrth an Impression of ·a powerful, yet extremely senstttve, human being, who expressed an unusual love for lsrael and the Jewish '. i I I peopt~. juqe .- 23, 1969· Rev~ Dr. 8111y ahatn Montrea.c ~ lfor·t h C&roll.Da The My· deS:i- Rev. Graham; In behalf ·qf· m,· colleagues in the Rabbinate• the American Jewish .Com-· -mittee and myself personallYJ· I want to express our deepest .apprecia·cion for ·your _visit with- us this -~~ I \ As I hope you -may bave felt from the response o£ those present. you elicited m unprecedented warmth~ cordiality$ and respect for· your position -that bas· alree.d y .made this· experience a ;nemorable one for all of us. - We are especially g1:ateful · for your· -candor and forthrightness- on the ·. · several -questions that we calked about. -Clearly., you ·h elped overcoa· . a nuinbl!r of misconceptioQs and .strengthened the bonds of fellowship between our peoples •. We are especially appreciative of your strcm..g . supportive ·u nders.t andtng of the rigb1: of ·t he people end tbe St:ate of Israel co · survive as well .as 7our forthright ·views on the deicide question.• prejudice end :antl.•$end.tism, QDd .O il the .p rofound Biblical bond& tbat l:ldt us together. · Under separate cl>Ver I atb hk:lng the liberty of sending you a booklet tbat l have wri.tten OD 0 An. 11ltroductiOD to Jewish eustoms :and Holy Days," with its .accoq>all1f.ng record of llturgicel selections &om the religious· servic.e~ e»f Judaism • .Also. in response to your· ~t. l am -enclos~ a draft copy of the program that we. are @Ollsor1Dg with. the Southern Baptist Convention• August 18-20 at the Loaisville Theological Seminary. If there is the. (. ..... ., The Rev.. Dr. Billy Graham .June 23 • ·1 969 least possibilit:y .o f your attending ·t he conference for even a short time. 1 bow that .all of us wauld be honored by your presence. In· any case. we plan to publish the ·proceedings and will be more than happy tt> share them with you. I do hope that. we will have the privilege of meeting ·w ith you again 1n the near futur:e. We take seriously your expression about wanting ·eo have an opportunity to pue questions before our group. Nothing would give· us greater pleasu.re duan ·to· .arr$tge .f or· such an occasion at the earllest: <tppor.tunity that is convenient for you. · . Again, . With Ollr heartfelt @POd wishes ttd ()ur prayers for God' 8 con• tf.nued cue over you and yoUX" fitmily, i am . Cordia.Uy yom:"s. llabbi Marc· B. tanenbauin !tettonal Director · lnterrelig1ous Mlrr:HSB·Bncls. P. s. Should your children in lsrae~ ~fairs Department: ever find themselves in need -of any assletanee of whatever kind, ple.ase feel free to inform them that the American Jewlsb ·ColllDittee maintains an o ·f fiee in .Jerusalem 9 Ethiopia s·treet • under the di.rec tion of Dr. Louis Shub a If you wish. 1 would be glad to let him know that members of your family are in "Israel. and that he should make himself available for _whatever co• operation they might wish 1;o have • . I: :! ( I ·HEBUNG .Wl'l'B DR. BILLY GRAHAM· - JUNE 23, 1969 ·Opening Remarks. of Welcome - ·Mr. Philip Hoffman .. It is most fitting · that this mom~ we meet in the same roCID. whieb ·was·· the site in 1963 Qf the historic meeting between American .Jewish leaders and the late ·v atican official of ·b lessed. memory, Cardinal Bea. · oecasf:on, a frank _cliscussion On that ensued, vhich was to become the · basis. of the beglnniilg of a n~ .relati'cmhip ·between the . Boman Catholic and Jewish commmi· ties. '1'bat 4ession, which we .recal.1 with such fond memories, testified ln sUigular fas~ion open interchange carried OD to by the value of dlalogue and men of good will in SD · atmosphere of mutual resp·e ct.. ·it is in such a spirit Chat we meet today. As Jews we are indebted to the enormous contributions our Baptist neighbors have made to the cause of religious liberty and the understanding of problems of religion and state. As indi.viduals we recoplze Dr •. Graham's concern. for tbe moral and spiritual well being c;>f the nation and we ~e most happy to tielcame him and bis colleagues to our midst. Our meeting will procede. aa follows: Mr., Bertram Gold will. introduce those present ·and Rabbi Marc Tanenbaum will lead the discussion._ ~ . PROSPECTIVE INVITEES TO BILLY GRAHAM MEETING JUNE 23, 1969 Philip Hoffman Elmer ·L. Winter Max M. Fisher \/David Sher Jack A. Goldfarb Joseph Klingenstein Richard Maass Frank Altschul Mervin Riseman Newton Glickel Bernard Abrams S. H. .Scheuer · aewish Connnunity People Abraham J. Heschel Wolfe Kelman Balfour Brickner Irving Gr~e~berg aernard Mcindlebaum vSeymour Siegel Emanuel Rackman Arnold Jacob Wolf I/Bernard Keinberger /Gilbert Klapperman ~srael Mowshowitz Isaiah Minkoff -Siegman 11 -"Prinz ~cobQ,Philip Rudin Robert Gordis Arthur Hertzberg Solomon Sharfman JI Hannah Stein Louis Newman v'Edward Muldover ~Ted Ellenoff .Bernard Segal /Benjamin Kreitman \/Harold Gordon Charles Liebman Gershon Cohen VDavid Silverman /Morris Kertzer Julius Goldberg William Rosenthal Arnold Kaiman · Albert Vorspan V'Ronald Kronish Alexander Schindler Staff People ~ertram H. Gold v-Rabbi Marc Tanenbaum vRabbi A. James Rudin vGerald Strober ~rton Yarmon VSimon Segal vMC>rris Fine vSelma Hirsh ~ Katz PllOSPBCTIVB INVITEES TO BILLY GBAHAM .MEETING Amer1c8n .Jewish Caamittee .Jewish Onrmnmity Philip B~ Hoffman Elmer L. Winter Abraham J. Beachel Max. M. Fisher David Sher ~- dJ TA I t .Jack A. .Goldfarb ..JOseph Kl.ingenstein liltllt a •swwald Menln lliseman ~- · · Marc Tanenbaum A. .James 1'Jdin Judith Bank1 Simon Segal $am Katz . . Gerald. Strober Arnold Jacob Wolf Gilbert Klappeman N~~;J · .s. Jf. Cl_~(: s IJ"l.(~ ~w~ Seymour Siegel · . 8nanuel Backioan Bernard Weinberger . Rf.chard Maass Fr8ok Altachul Bertram Gold Wolfe Kelman Balfour Brickner ·1rviilg Greenberg Bernard Man~lebaum Israel Mowshowit:z Isaiah Minkoff - •· .{( . june 24, 1969 ~Bev. Dr. Billy eham Montreat, Horth ~olina In behalf of .die of&ers ~staff of Tbe American Jewish ·Comrd.ttee, I want :tO thaitk ·you mst ·wa=l7 £or nklng tlJe time and ~le out · of your .obri.ously· ~ schedule m meet -with us yesterday. Prom: all ·the ~s dtat we have nceived ·f rom ~he participants it ·was a most aaeful meed.1'a• We appreciate espectall7 your openness and c&JJdor in· dealing with the several diftieolt questions to wbicb you addresse_d )'OUrself. We do hope ~t you wtll fllld ft possible to. come back and visit with u& in ~he near future • . I know tbat ~ ._colleagues would~ much "Hel• CQme an opportunity to became better acquainted with JOU on a personal basis and .t.o be able to excbanp news on the· many .m atters in which we baVe such obvious co~ interests. With warmest. tpo.d wishes-,. I am Sincerely., Ba"tram B. Gold Executive Vlce•President ..June 24·, 1969 · -. . . Dr.· Robert Fem a D fl .Jeffemon. Georgia · Dear l)r • . i'eni: I w~ to thank you for all the" efforts· you made 1n settlng~up . · . 1•terday' e · meeting involvi!ag. Dr. BilJ.v Or.au.· and representative$ of 't he .Jewish camunicy. . . . . . l ~Ink I speak for a genuine CCJll#ensuS . when i ..say .that those present ~e impressed ·by Hr. Grabam's sincerity, warmth and grasp· of issues. of CtJNllAOD concern. I perscmally feel i t was· . a most meaningful elicoua.ter and one, i aust, ·that shall· be · . followed-up ~ tbe days co CC1De;. _· · I hope that_y~teraY•a meeting maq· be ~ forenlnner of a new . . dialogue between Bnngelical Gttistians and .the American ·.Jewish · cormnmity. I waa most interested .tn Dr. Graham's ccmneats con..: cemlng bis desire to ask questions. and I hope that la the tiot · too distant future we will be able- to have another session .iD . which rq colleagges Wot.sld be able to dlscusa with Dr. Craban · those matters of interest to both-. co1rs1unltie1J which are on his · ·mind. .. . . .Ag•fn. please be ·assjired of my persmial appreeiation for an · of · your effofts. Witb warm ftgards. Cordially yours • . Geraid Strober, Consultant . · lnterreliglous Affairs Departmeilt : GS:as ·. ·D ll AFT .... - --- ... GBABAM 6/24/69 to the Jewish· people: rell$i0usly through_the Old T~st~t. 'nle ~rtance ·· . Dr. · Graham .said he -felt that he related . 1. ·of the Old· Testament. in his .preaehing:• JGwisb backgroun!-f of ~esus . ·. . Here . he also mentioned the and. the. early·. dis~iples •.. . . . Sociologically - h_e re he discussed the history of per- ::· . . 2. sec~tion against: Jew ·donduc_ted by "so called Christians"; that all . Christians are guilty· as far a8 Jewish experience ~he · cerned also asks forgiven.es~ of .the Jewish He said i.~ c~ity con- · .as a - Christian. Politi~ally. - 3." Here Graham ~tioned bis positive·. feting for the ·state .o f iarael~ ... Be ·said that -his da\aght.e r. and son-in-law . . . have comnitted their lives ..to Israel and will be . working · ~ a ·. . \R .. . .~s~ the ~t ff!'1 m0nths . : One. of Mr. Graham's sons is also i:n working in Israel. .· · ·Graham said ~ months ~o he had a two . hour meeting with Golda Meir and sAid at that time it was difficult . ~or hfin to speak ·out~ in favo~ of Israel be~ause of pressure .of ChriSt~ living in . the •. · ~ab s~tee. promised ~s. _Be feels that he . is a spokesmen for Israel • . Graham Heir that _he wo:Uld c~tinue speaking privat~ly to government officials .concerning Israel's problems and he made . the . . ple~e that ·if a crisis did arise and . if ~8 statement .she should inform him through the • ._ M eir needed . a ~lie ~raeli ambassador to the United States. · Graham said that he feels that Israel . even~ually will . . hold all of the land promised to Abr<'" ..-J81D and that Israel -whall be the greatest world. power. .Graham said t~t three w~eks ago. he. had dis• -Z· cussed the Israel situation with · President . Nixon and he assured · the group that President Nixon is personally .pro Israel and indeed . . . . . . · is more sympathetic to Israel ~ban be· .·~as ·one year ago. It was also. interes. t ing .to note that. Dr. Graham in· describing · . . . . . . . . his ~ ideological stanee . theologically and as a char~terized l~be~al ~ himself as a corieervative ·s ocial issues. Earlier he had· · stressed the Jewish concern for the social . welfare of huoianiey . . . . and here . ~e ' . seemed to . be identiflng himself with this . concem. I - . .· I . ,· )' --,~ . •. PROSPECTIVE INVITE§ TO BILLY GRAHAM MEETING Philip Boffman JUNE 23 •. 1969 ,. Blmer L. Winter. ~ M. Fishe~ ~avid Sher .. Jack A. ·Goldfarb Joseph Kl.ingenst~in " Richard Maass Frank Altschul Mervln ·liseman Newton Glickel Bernard Abram.a s: R. Scheuer .. .Bewish Ccmimmitv Peoele ~rtram Abraham J. · Beschel Wolfe le1man- B. Gold · · L.lt&bbl Marc Tanenbaum '""ilabbl A. James Rudin Balfour. Brickner · Irving Greenberg Bernard· Mandlebaun v1eymaur .stegel Emanuel . . ·Staff People· . ~rald Strober L-Motton Yarman ·. · ~tmon Segal LJilorrls nne · 4elma Hirsh Backman Arnold Jacob Wolf ..Sam Katz .· vlernard Weinberger "61.lbert ·llapper:man '--Israel Mawshawitz Isaiah Hlnkoff Henry Si~gman · . · .¥cob1~Prins Jacob Philip Budin · . Robert Dorclis · · Arthur Hertzberg Solomon Shar.fman vllannah Stein ~is Newman ~ard lllldover V"Ted Bllenoff · ·· Bemard Segal . . t;)Jenjamln Xrelbnan · . ~old GordoJl .. · Quarles Liebman · Gershon Cohen t.-David Silverman &Morris -K ertzer Julius Goldberg · William Rosenthal Amold. Kafman Albert Vorspan . ~ld ·K ronlsh · . Alexander Schindler I , ·. ,,,,,wrOFFICERS' Rabbi Gllbert Klape rman President Rabbi Wiiiiam Berkowitz Rabbi Sol Roth Rabbi Harold I. Saperstein Vlce·Prosldents ,1-v : ... b);-1irJ -~,J!..c..'- .il-l1if-' . Ill )1.J' f6hit DtUt15orlt :Board or:R»hllbs. • Orthodox Conservative Reform 10 EAST 73rd STREET ·NEW YORK, N. Y. 10021 Telephone TRafalgar 9-8415 Rabbi Samuel A.Berman Rabbi Herachel Levin Treasurers Rabbi Judah Nedlch Corresponding Secretary Rabbi Harold H. Gordon Encutlve Vlc..Pruldent & Director ot Ch11p/a/ncy Serv/,es Rabbi Murrey Grauer Flnencla/ SacrallllY Rabbi I. Fred Hollander Aaeocleta Director Rabbi Saul Teplltz Recording Secretary Rabbi Louis Finkelstein Rabbi Nelson Glueck •Rabbi Stephen S. Wise Honorery Vlce·Ptesldentll Rabbi Edward T. Sandrow Ch11/rman, . Boo.rd of Governors J. June 24, 1969 8 Tammuz 5729 BOARD OF GOVERNORS Oft/cors, Put Presidents and Rabbi Max Arzt Rabbi Philmore Berger Rabbi Samuel Berllant · · •. Rabbi Morris Borman · · Rabbi Bernard L. Berzon . Rabbi Ban Zion Boksar Rabbi A. Stanley Dreyfus Rabbi Ezra M. Finkelstein Rabbi Morris s. Friedman Rabbi Max Gelb Rabbi Louis C. Gerstein Rabbi Simon Glustrom Rabbi David W. Gordon Rabb I Max Gruenewald Rabbi David S. Halpern Rabbi Abraham L. Hartstein Rabbi Gunter Hirschberg Robbi Leo Jung Rabbi Norman Kahan Rabbi Arnold G. Kaiman Rabbi Wolle Keirnan Rabbi Morris N. Keitzer Rabbi Herman Kleval Rllbbl Kurt Klappholz Rabbi Israel Klavan Rabbi Isaac Klein Rabbi Bomord Kll11feld Rabbi Irving Koslowe Rabbi Harold I. Krantzler Rabbi BenJnmln Z. Krellma.n Rabbi Robert L. Lehman Rabbi Haskel Lookstein Rabbi Alvin M. Marcus Rabbi Julius Mark Rabbi Amos W. Miiler Rabbi Israel Miiier Rabbi William A. OrenUlcher Rabbi David H. Panitz Rabbi Ely E. Pllchik Rabbi Alvin M. Popleck Rabbi Sidney L. Regner Rabbi Emanuel Schenk Rabbi Arthur Schneler Rabbi Jacob K. Shankman Rabbi Solomon J. Sherfman Rabbi Baruch Silverstein Rabbi Joseph I. Weiss Rabbi Marc H. Tanenbaum The American Jewish Connnittee 165 East 56th St. New York, N. Y. 10022 Dear Marc: Once again I want to co~end yo~, Bert Go~ld Mr: Sher.and the entire American Jewish Committee fo~ dom in arranging yesterday's meeting with Bill Graham. Enough was said to emphasize that in which we are deeply interested and the message was loud and clear. His res~onse on the subject of Israel especially, was particularly gratifying. We are sending him a letter expressing this aspect of our meeting. With all good wishes. Cordially, ~ Rabbi Harold H. Gordon HHG:gg Milchell Salem Fisher Counsel 69 'Rabbl Henry S. Jacobs, 1881·93 'Rabbi Kaufmann Kohler, 1893-1902 *Rabb I H. Pereira Mendes, 1902-06 •Rabbi Joseph Silverman, 1906-07 *Rabbi F. de Sola Mendes, 190&-09 'Rabbi Maurice H. Harris, 1910-11 •Rabbi Bernard Drachman, 1912·13 'Rabbi Rudolph Grossman, 1914-15 • Ooceased ' ' Rabbi David do Sola Pool, 191~17 •Rabbi raaac s. Moses, 1918 *Rabbi Moses Hyamson, 1919 •Rabbi Nathan Stem, 1920 'Rabbi Clifton H. Levy, 1921·22 *Rebbl Simon R. Cohen, 1923-24 Rabbi Israel Goldsteln, 192>26 'Rabbi Barnett A. Elzu, 1927·28 •Rabbi Elias L. Solomon, 1929-30 'Rabbi Harry Weiss, 1931-32 •Rabbi Max Drob, 1933-34 •Rabbi Samuol J. Levinson, 1935-36 'Rabbi Israel Goldfarb, 1937-38 •Rabbi J.X.Cohen, 1939-40 'Rabbi Joseph Sarachek, 1941-42 Rabbi Joseph H. Looksteln, 1943-44 Rabbi A. M. Holter, 1945-46 Rabbl"Thecdore N•.Lewls, 1947-48 Rabbi Simon G. Kramer, 1949-60 ... ' ! . Rabbi Morris M. Goldberg, 1951-52 Rabbi David J. Seligson, 1953-54 Rabbi Emanuel Rackman, 1955-56 •Rabbi Joseph Miller, 1957 Rabbi A. Alan Steinbach, 1958 Rabbi David I. Gclovensky, 1959-60 Rabbi Harry Halpern, 1961 Rabbi laraol Mowahowltz, 1962·63 Rabbi Max Schenk, t964-6S Rabbi Edward T. Sandrow! 196M7 ..._ _ _,.. .· June 30. 1969 . . Dr. "f. .Box w. VilsoD an _ , Montreat,. Bo. Car. Dear Dr. Wllson: · 1 an enclosing the .Religious 1leri1a Service article I ment:ionecl to ycm in oar telephone canversation ·o f June 27th. I can ·only repeat again what I wrote to Dr. Boben: rerm that the meeting was. oveft1helm1ngly successful and hopefully the - : ~ 0£ future contact: and discu8sion. ·- Cord1ally, -Gerald Strober ~ Consultant . Interreligioua Affairs Department GS:as ~ Enc. .Y: ; ·. ·Yf!e Rev. Dr. Billy ' / . ~ugust . . 6, 1969 · . GraMai ·Montreat, North caroliDa· Dear Rev. · ctabam:- · . . . ·Tb.is· ·f.JJ. to acknowledge belatedly your gracious" let.ter of July .2nd tC> Rabbi Marc Tauenbaum. · Rabbi Tanenbaum has been -away :from the office on a combined vacation and short sabbatical. Re is expected to return to the office the. latter part ·of Atigust and your. letter will be bi:"ougbt tO ·M s attention at that time. We ·have· received the ·beautiful autographed photograph of your·· self.. Many thanks. · . Sincerely yours. Miriam MSB::Dlll s. ·B inder Secretary to Rabbi 'Tanenbaum \ B I L LY GRAHAM · July 2, 1969 My dear Rabbi: Thank'",'.· ypu for your good letter. of June 23. Indeed·, ~~:(qe~;r friend, I am the one that should be thanking you for giving me such a wonderful opportunity to meet a remarkable group of people . I .certainly hope we can have a repetition of this meeting at some future date. I especially appreciated the remarks made by yourself, Mr. Gold and Mr. Sher. You gave me one of the warmest and most gracious receptions I. have .ever had from any group anywhere . I am deep,ly ·grateful that you sent me your booklet · 'An ·Introduction to Jewish Customs and Holy Days". Both my wife and I will enjoy it. I shall convey to my children in Israel your kind offer. I shall be most honored to send you an autographed photograph. Most ·: ~· .... Rabbi ·Marc H~ Tanenbaum The American Jewish Committee 165 Fa.st 56 Street New York, New York 10022 R E L I G I 0 US DOMESTIC SERVICE NEWS -4- SERVtCE _TIIURSDAY, SEPTEMBER. 11, 1969 Mr. Graham said the need for .revival was pointed up by the of churches, _declining eni~ollments in seminaries, and declining church giving. f~lling membership~ Many clergymen are discouraged and have lost their message, he said. One minister toid him he planned _to leave the ministry unless he found what he was looking for at ~he evangelism congress in Minneapolis. · In _discussi.ng campus disturbances, Mr • .Graham said "there are many idealists among student dissenters who are seeking a sense of Christian justice, but there . are others . \vho wan~ 'to burn'. the COUllt:t"y down." He sa-id the evang~lism congress woul,d explore the- relation of evangelism to social action and acknowledged this w9uld bring di~agree ment ~mong t'he participants. . As for hioself_,_. Dr. Graham said: '~You cannot separate ~onversion from social .invo;lvement •••• we must bring the church back to the poin~ where we see that both 'personal conversion and -social ip.volvement are taught in the Scriptur_ e ." -0CHURCH-RELATED SCHOOL TEAMS LAUNCHED TELEVISED FOOTBALL By Religious News Service (9-11-69) NEW YORK (RNS) -- It's Saturday afternoon and the male members of the family are anchored to a seat in front of the television set. Did you ever wonder how this Saturday "football madness" began? The waves on Catholic College, 50 miles first televised football ga~e was sent out over the air Sept~ 30 7 1939. T~e · contest ;involved Fordbam University, a institutio·n here operated -by the Jesu;l.ts, and Waynesburg a United .Presbyterian school in .western Pennsylvania about south of Pittsburgh. The game, won by Fordhan .34-7, . was t~lev,ised by the National Broadcasting Company. ·-~ It ·was __ pla.Y.ed. _in, .t he . ~tadium at _R andall's Island on New York's East River and was seen by .an estimated 200 viewers who had sets in those piqneer video days. Ro~er J. Hackett, cUre.c tor of sports. information at Fordham, said that plans are not complete fo.r a celebration of the 30th anniversary of the first TV gr id game. One idea , he sai d, would be to televise the school's.opening. game this year. He admitted, however, that it might be difficult to fipd a TV ·stati,on willing to ha'1dle the event. Fordham, once a big-:-time football power which accepted bowl bids,· curre~tly plays _w~ t is · called "club football" in which the team is operated by students. PAGE -4-0- •' S E R V I C E R EL -3- THUR3DAY, SEPTEMBER 11,. 1969 SCBOCLSf T&'\CHERS EDUCATION By Religious News Service (9-11-69) MINNK4POLIS (aNS) -- Some sex education in the nation's public schools is "going too far," and some te?..chers are not qualified to teach the subject, evangelist Billy Graham said at a news conference !here •. He said fourth, f:l.fth and sixth grade:i'.'s arc "too young" for some courses that would be better left to students of big~ school age. Mt'. Graham, attending thP. u.s. Congress on Evaagelism, said he objected to thF.l kind of sex educa t1.on which teaches "just an animal act." "I would not like my children s'.ibje.cted to a sex ~ducation in which God, the bea1Jty and joy of marriage are not taught," he said. He predicted thexs would be "a lot nore. controversy (over sex education) before we settle it" and ob:;~rved that some northern Europea:l cations are not happy with thE: result$ of a "permissive" society. - Mr. Graham exp~assed sorrow over the death of r~signed Episcopal Bishop ,Ja.cie:3 A. Pi~9 whose liberal theoJ,.ogy was so distant from his own that "h~ and I hardly agreed on anything ." "The only thing we added. agr~ed on was our friendship," the eva.ngelist · Dr. Pike bad the effect of "mak:!.ng psople search their own hearts as to what they believe;" Mr. Graham said. He thought the controversial bishop hRd a negative effect on the · nation as far as his espousal of the "cew morality" was concerned. "In theologk.a.l areas, I don't think he did any harm to the church," the evangr:.:list said. Mr . Grahara defended President N=.xon' s practice of holding religious services in the White House ar.d of his own appearances on such television shows as "Laugh-In." Through the TV appearances, he said, he can reach people who would never ent&r a church. The evangsl:!.st revealed that he has do nned old clothes and lii~ipl.es iil the No!'·th ~aea~h-of San ~':t'<ancisco and · along Sunset St-rip in Los Angeles. talked with ~ P.e found that many hippies "are talking about love but do not have th~ capacity to lovs." Pe sa.id they are turning to sex and drugs instead of the churcb because of the church's failure to present the · Gospel properly and because parents have fail~d to teach the Gospel. (more) PAGE -3- [start] Original docamerr1ts faded and/or illegible . -· · . _..:. / ···· .:.~--~ ·-·-. .... J JJE c· 8 • .... · :f.f,',•,•tJ:.: ~:-~; = ··\.\ (.!·1'i.:,."::"·I l\: ~ t'\ta A.1 1,,c.~i ·~........:. \ :.·':::~1!) ;,,!- ....,. .f~E ,:;:./ ~:· ;: ~- . .. r-'"~~~., .~ "' .. . . !°\ .~1t· v~::':~"'! ~..-z>· .· ~- -. . .•A"""!..· .~·· ··ll'-, ~ :;::...~.... ..1:.,l, ·";~ ~si, ~..:.;:-, . ~ ...-'!- P.o~" .sso - Gt:!:;·r..t...r'50:·: ?~!,;~ s~,..~ile, s-:..-~!A Si, P,,;i~~~':"_;, l''lc~.f.._"J .3J7t.1? EV>.NGELlS T l~ A.55. 0C!AT ! Or~ T E AM GFF~C~. · P.C:. 8t:1x /.0·3C19, Ai :'~o:t Brae..:~. -"tia:--,t.:, G~. 3JJ~(, ~.:Jn~ (~04) 7·~-$-522 1 ftI #" C.;..T~.'l I_ }J q . {~ t t-'-.J,,r,:,....~ - P..--.:L..< F,...;.;. 1969 y,!-'V;;-'".r' Mr\) San;ual L~ 5cr.cin:.:.: (_!- 211 Produce Sa~k Building lCO North 7~ Street ;.~iniie~pclis, ;'~ir:nes!Jta l\_N,j' .,\ 611r.~l.-....1 i .T. 551,,0:~ Oe:.n f :ri l2r:d: H~~ kind cf you to b•rtte me! We did appreciate your letter of Novamber 2 4it. c.c-: ::·1:..ich o r it :;; graat hona~· :i b2 cansida·ed 2 fz·i2rid e:f Isr;:.:2L I ci:1}.'y I dc;!?;e :r•·,1 2 Uiat c.i::Js ;:natio,:. In :;1v j:.;dg1nent, thB re-.:i~. ~~.r; r;f ·the Stat ~ of ls:r·c:c:!l is ~.12 ci:: :esta::-;t E:Vf:~nt tri t3:,2 place. j_n o:._:r litet.!. ,"":'8, and pc:ss~bly ciu:ring_ t~;e p2sr. 1900 yser s . Having bee:n ·.a BioJ.e--beEc:-.v::.:::.· s:t nc2 "I L;a-:; 2.i:;it~te8r1 ysars of ::;ge , 1 m;.1;:;{; t:e r::.;ri;ber;:d i.ii th ethers o f tf',e :.;ame co:P; ictio r~ in deep appre cic:ti on f.o~~ slJ. tt121t the Gad of .i:.1Gr::i~1 <:.m , Isar:;c a;1rJ J:~1c~;b t1=1S ·gi ·Jen to t.:s through Israf:! J.. car;:iid e1~ heps tr.~t: ~1ro Scr;e iner.., (J£!lieving ti12 di,1!.n?. ly t hat. t!t(~rs ~..:ilJ. alw<:i'/E <t~ 3n !s.rar:-l, inspiTe:~j .p rap~iets as ~c: do, we ~~::.:it:..: an~ ss u BitJl.2-L:e~ie'.:.i ng A1"~~ in B-ilir-u t told~-==, uThc:..i;h R:.:ssia, Unit(.d St2·~~s. Englen:i er:d F"r·ance :::;L go egain ~ t Isra::-::, they wtll Ell lusi::; This l ::ir:::.1 ~elongs to tile ~""!e •,;s,': Ther-a may riot :;l•.J~y? b2 a li.L.a .. but tnere i!li U alur11,1s be Iar<.~eL l!~-ui' I ~·i~ '.:J:.\.. th th t:: <:: , saith th<; i...~ 2~:; , <.;:; :!:? .;1.: th ~;: ; tho ug :·; I 'nai< !?. :J f u i. l end of ~11 nstibns ta which I have scattered t~ee, yet Gi ll I net m2ke a full St~~ Qf th8i~c.c~H (JE:!'f?trd.8 ~1 30:11) It ~s~ Dean rny ~~2at joy and p~ivilege tc !pesk in ~eh2lf of Israel in menv cities ~f tha world. Thus far this y8ar in Auck land , O~~adin, 0 Xrw s.;-c2~·9ill, States. ,-i g~lnJ.ttn ffa:...1 Z~;nla nd ; Aust::.'alia; 2r:d s:·,12rsl cittes in the U:.~:1:0'.Cl Alec, I have baar~ tc Isr5al s2ven !i~s s t his y~ar, and will b3 the 36~~ visit 5.n ab:iut tl.;c !._':::ek:s .. Vt,i,u shot;ld c::;:; t6ct Mra. Lc.1.s ll.ietgsnd at the S~. lly G?uh31r, o f f~lcie ln ~! it~: h~tn he!· rc::fr, progi"-:::::: _e;r.:J wi'c ii h1;n gifted pe n, she M.tn:ied;mlis .. °C!":8 ·~ h~ f'1g~ir1 th =:r ~k ~,:ou fo:r 'iC:Jr lo,}81\/ l8't!-~ r.~ yCJ'.J. i !1 m.nn:-; ::'(!G L~ 3 er::::. cf t!i'.:; .:J~ dffjS. l.·. . -- • •• •p • . • •, _ ~, -- ·ft·- .......... \. ...........- : ................. . .~ I :!Ji J.l leek • 0 ""::'~-- . . . --·~·· ...... -. :- ·--· _,_:·.-:. [end] Original d©coame111ts faded ar:idfor illegible R E L I GI q US DOMESTIC SERVICE NEWS SERVICE -2- MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 15 1 1969 He said that salvation can be obt~ined only through Christ and asked his listeners to repent, believe and witness to others; Because of the great crowd, l\ir o Graham did not ask persons to come forward, but he did ask those ''rilling to receive Christ publicly to stand where they were Ushers then broug~t literature to those making decisions o' 0 Members of the arra!lgen•ents committee said the congress was "a tremendous success" and had exceeded all expectations 0 Dr~ Paul P. Fryhling, chairman of the executive and program committee, cited the genuine spirit of unity anc1 onenass that had devclcped 11despite:the gamut of theological posture and variety of church emphases~" -0·· DR. CALDERONE TELLS NCC cmJR~!IES MUST WITNESS FOR SEX EDUCATH.i1'l' ' By Religious News Service (9-12-69) INDIANAPO!.iIS, INDo (1Ui3)--The director of the controver.sial Sex I nformation and Education Council in the United States (SIECUS) toid the Nati~nal Council o:f Churches here that ch\1.rches must stand up and witness fo~ sex e ducation in the public schools~; Dr~ Mary s. Calderone, addressing the NCC's General Board, declared that "deliberately concocted lies in the name of Christianity" have brought SIECUS under heavy fire 0 She rapped the John . Birch Society and Billy Hargis' Christian Crusade as the attackers 0 Dr~ Calderone asserted that teaching sex in the schools is needed to counteract the "raw sex all around us," including the implication in family magazines that unmarried sex relations is the ••in" thing.' "If the pareP..ts teach only in terms of negatives - - and we know how the young rep:-:::'.iate negatives in this <;lay -- then the school must teach positives, 11 the s _p ealter said 0 Dr. Ca1derone said SIECUS is i.>. voluntary health organization that has no program for sex education in the schools but provides basic background information for those who v1z.nt it 0 · She denied charges that sexual experirr!entation is encour3.ged by SIECUS or that it even goes on in schools~ And she a,nswered- questi-ons - · from the floor -- in wl1ich she was "t.iuoted" as ha.ving enc~rnraged extramarital sex - - by reading what she said were the actual quotes which had virtaully the opposite meaning~ Dr~ Calderone vowed she would continua her fight for sex education · and she was greeted with a standing ovation at the close of her addressc -0- PAGE - 2- RELIGIOUS NEWS SE~VICE, 43 WEST 57TH ST., N. Y. 10019 . . S1'ADll.Th.i JAMMED, THOUSANDS TURNED' AWAY AT EVAHGELISM 'CONGRESS 'FINAL PROGnAM MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 15·, 1969 By Religious News Service (9-15-69) MI NNEAPOLIS (RNS)--The first u.s. Con~ess on Evange~is ended here with a gigantic rally addressed by evangeli~t Billy raham t which thoµsar.ds of persons had to be turned away~ An estimate d 21,·ooo pe1·sons jammed into the Metropolitan Sports Center in suburban Bloomington, which has a seating capacity of 18 1 000~ Thousands ·more .heard the program via loudspeaker outside the arena.· Poiice estimated from 6 1 000 to 8 1 000 cars containing persons headed for the rally were not allowed to leave the freeways because the parking lots were already jammed. · It was the second mass expectations. eve~t of the Congress that exceeded all On the· previous night, 101 000 young people turned out for a youth musical "turn-on" starring singer i>at Boone. Of these, some .12.,.0 00 .cr.ow.ded:-.i,.nto. ·: the _Mi;t.lnea;pel:i.s ' .Ar.J!K>r..Y .and .s.ame 6., 000 more. follo~ ed the event on closed circuit ·televis.ion 'i·n an ·aualt'6 rium several blocks away·~· · The closing rally at the sports center started 40 minutes earlier than planned because it filled up so · early~ Dr~ Oswald C.J.Hoff~nn chair~an of the Congress, arrived 45 minutes late, despite a police escort, because of the traffic jam. Mr. Graham suggested that one reason so many people came was "to see what a Lutheran and a Baptist looked· 'like together," referring to Dr. Hoffmann, preacher on the Lutheran Hour,- and himself, a southern Baptist. · ; For his address, Mr. Graham took a text from Hebrews 12 which predicts that God will shake not only· the earth . but also the heaven 1 but promi~ed a kingdom that cannot be shaken. Th~ evangelist ~ited changes taking place in society and in . religion but said some things ~ever change--the nature of God; God's word, the moral law, human natlJ!e, Go~'s . purP,OS~ in· th~ world, the waY. __ of personal salvation~ - Mr. Graham said the world is headed for judgment and that ·at the end of the judgment, the Kingdom of .God w~ll come in the person of .resus Christ and there w1·11 ·be "Utopia~·" (more) PAGE -1- oz --) i 1 Bmy · 6rahamJi;~tq;:c-;q"i;;;T;,s-;;:ysc;tyNe~d;-,A~keDi~i'I - ------ • ·-·-· Billy Graham, looking tan~ed . and healthy after a week of ]'vacation in Florida, steppe<t , off a train at Pennsylvania l Station yesterday and began final preparations for his first . •day•:. and "1:o~ight" s.~ows,jnot expect any di;ficulty. from th~ . Merv Gnffm Sho":" ..a~d James Forman, .he _militant ~1lh~m Bu~klcy Jr. s Fir· blac~ leader who ~i~rupted mg Lme. . s~rv1ces at Manha'.tan s RiverLast night several routines s1d_e Church. as part of. 3: ca'?he had taped previously were pa1gn to raise $500-milhon m .f- I "reparations" from whitcj~r~," ·u~e ev.angclist remarked.' ! ~h.urc~cs and synagogues for I m gomg to do the preaching, m1us~1ces allegedly done lo If he were. to come, we would ( '-~.encan, Nei;roes. , .. welcome him with a big smile · . I don t think w~ re going t<: and. hfpe he . enjoyed the i have any outside speak service.' _ . lJ I ~wY~~Adcsi~l~~s~~oo~w~a~M~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~5~~~~~=~~~~~~ On Friday ever.ing the 50- "Laugh-In." Mr. Graham said:year-old evani;elist will open that the producers had given' a tcn-dav crusade at Madison him control over material that Square Garqen. He hopes to was used before and after his fill the arena's 20,000 scats sections of the· show, and he !each night and to reach nddi- added that he even wrote somG J tion~I millions of people i>y of the gags himself. turning t~e Garden. into wh~t. he · In 1957 Mr. Graham con1tcrm.cd11 a g1gr.nt1c telev1S1on ducted a 16-wcck crusade in . the old Madison Square Garden '. studio. ; At a n<;ws. conference short- that drew 2.3 million people. • I~ _after his arrival, Mr. Grn~am More than 56,000 of them camo ) .s,ud tha.t ~e h_Qped t<;:> r~;-ital- forward to make "decisions for pze the city s spiritual life. Any- Chrst.. ! 1 jOne walkiilg down Times Square I • , , • • ;can sec why New York 1s in E~ch nights meetings, which I nccd of 11 great . moral and begin at 7:30 on ~eekdays and 1 spiritual awakening," he de- 7 on Sundays, will be taped I clared. and televised later the same During the next few days evening in New York, Detroit, ~ he will make a series ot tcle· Philadelphia, Boston, Washingvision and radio appearances, t !l~~--Cleveland. . I . aham said that he did i 1in~l~ding spots on the "To--~ ; l l I i · ····----........:_ I