Pages 21 - Insurancewest Media Ltd.
Transcription
Pages 21 - Insurancewest Media Ltd.
education – Grade 13, as required in Ontario – at a private school in Neuchatel, Switzerland. “My parents didn’t like the school in Oakville, so they sent me away. The idea was that you lived with Swiss families and learned French.” In 1977, after attending university for a couple of terms, MacAulay moved to Edmonton with her husband-to-be. “I was hired as a claims clerk with Economical.” Ten years later, after spending time away from the business with her first child, she went to work with Shumka, Craig & Moore, the forerunner of SCM. “The firm was very accommodating. They allowed me Husband Doug is a to set up an office at home.” For the first few years land after the move to Canmore, surveyor. MacAulay spent a couple of days a week in SCM’s Calgary office and the rest of the time working from home. In 1999, when she became branch manager, the firm opened a new 400-square-foot office space for her in Canmore. A close friend and business associate, Mike Leedham, says with MacAulay you get what you see. “Oh, I could tell you stories about Jennifer,” Leedham says, before breaking out in laughter. Leedham, who is part owner of Edmonton’s Townsend & Leedham Adjusters, has known MacAulay since 1978, when they both worked for Economical Insurance. “Jennifer is an intelligent person who is dedicated to her family. She’s very good at what she does and good at anything she puts her mind to.” IW Booking Now! Closes May 25 FEATURE July issue Western Adjusters A special advertising section with success stories about some of the leading independent adjusting firms operating in B.C., Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and the north. r Adjustoer Locatlisting et Internluded! inc at Adjusters: Please call Linda Helme 604-874-1001 or 1-800-888-8811 Vital Stats • The MacAulays have two adult children: Allan, 23, attending Queen’s University in Toronto, and TC (Terrance Curtis), 20, enrolled at the University of Calgary; • The couple lives in a two-storey split beside a wildlife corridor; • They enjoy hiking, but take along bear spray. (In 2005 a female hiker was killed near town by a grizzly.); • MacAulay plays squash and does needlework (cross-stitching); • She reads a lot, mostly novels, and likes all types of music, but is “not a huge” country fan; • She has three older brothers. One lives in B.C., the other two in Ontario. www.insurancewest.ca March 2007 Insurancewest 21 Host Liquor Liability And E&O or Professional Liability Added Liability capacity for western brokers. TechProtecTM Builders Risk Contractors Equipment Manufacturers Vacant Properties EsuranceTM Unoccupied Buildings Hotel / Motel Mortgage Impairment Resource Industries Restaurants, Bars, Cargo / Auto E&O Pubs w/Liquor Receipts Host Liquor Liability Physical Damage Woodworkers Under 40% (Ont. only) Professional Liability Foreign Risks Bed & Breakfast Jewellers Block Recycling Plants Marinas / Resorts Risks Kidnap High-value Homes Yachts Rental / Rooming Houses Stand-alone CGL Oil/Gas Contractors Canada WorldWide Underwriting Agencies Inc. Canada WorldWide Underwriting Agencies Inc. Canada WorldWide Underwriting Agencies Inc. Canada Mondial Agences de Souscriptions inc. #100 1400 1st Street SW, Calgary, Alberta T2R 0V8 (403) 263-4666 or 1-888-263-5146 Fax: (403) 237-9976 2 Norfolk Street South, Simcoe, Ontario N3Y 2V9 (519) 428-1688 or 1-866-401-3858 Fax: (519) 428-6307 920 Yonge Street, Suite 602, Toronto, Ontario M4W 3C7 (416) 925-2793 or 1-888-745-5502 Fax: (416) 925-7260 300, Rue St. Sacrement, Suite 320, Montréal, Quebec H2Y 1X4 (514) 844-2541 or 1-888-840-2541 Fax: (514) 843-5926 22 Insurancewest I March N S 2007 UR www.cana d a w o r l d w i d e . c a ANCE UNDERWRITING P R O F E S S I O N A Lwww.insurancewest.ca S profile Ryan Nitchie with receptionist Alicia Saunders In 1996, just 23, the affable, sports-minded Nitchie won a seat on city council in Armstrong, B.C., a ranching and agricultural community of about 4,000 souls in the Spallumcheen Valley north of Kelowna. The accomplishment made him the youngest councillor in those civic elections. Now serving his fourth term in that role, Nitchie looks on his involvement as payback to the community. After all, he says, the Nitchies have lived in the area for a century. Loyalty to the community was also why he helped revitalize a moribund lacrosse league in 1994, and why he’s moonlighted as GM for the league’s Armstrong Shamrocks for 13 years. The sport is historically popular in the area. The day we dropped in for a chat, Nitchie had insurance brokerage recruitment on his mind. “The question of how to maintain and manage employees is the biggest challenge the industry faces today. It’s an issue where, as an industry, we’re sort of falling down. We’re not recruiting young people to get involved. “Take a look around most of the offices and you’ll see a pretty big gap between brokers my age and the guys who’ve been in the industry a long time. Within five or 10 years, considering the looming number of retirements, there could be an employment crisis.” The Hub International Barton Insurance office he manages on the main drag in Armstrong serves a scattered community of 9,500 residents living about halfway between Calgary and Vancouver. As a full-service brokerage with 14 staffers, he says his operation does good business in both commercial and personal lines. The only competition is a small credit union. But typical of rural communities, Armstrong has a shallow pool of potential employees to draw upon – a serious Recruitment woes redux Ryan Nitchie, manager of a Hub International Barton Insurance agency in Armstrong, B.C., believes something must be done to recruit and train employees in an industry facing a future labour shortage. Fortunately, he works for an operation committed to the idea of a centralized training facility. www.insurancewest.ca By Stan Sauerwein A t 33, Ryan Nitchie has already cut a wide swath. In just six years he’s moved from practising the insurance fundamentals in a small independent broker’s office to managing a thriving outlet for a mega agency. Armstrong 101 Armstrong is 70 kilometres north of Kelowna, B.C. in the heart of the Spallumcheen Valley, one of the prime agricultural areas in the province. Numerous heritage homes and storefronts sport a charming Old West motif. The landscape is dotted with horse ranches, vegetable gardens, orchards, vineyards and wheat and alfalfa fields broken by stands of pine and evergreen. A century ago the dominant crop in the area was celery. Nearby is the 20,000-acre O’Keefe Ranch, founded in 1867 and once the largest cattle ranch in B.C. The town was named after E.C. Heaton-Armstrong, a London banker who helped finance the railway in 1892. Prior to the settlement, according to one pioneer, the area was nothing more than “willows and swamp.” Though best known for its cheese makers – Dutch immigrants settled there after the Second World War – the largest employer, with over 800 workers, is Riverside Forest Products. Armstrong businesses also manufacture bathtubs and showers, plumbing products, RVs and horse-drawn carriages, which accounts for the large pool of skilled trades people in the vicinity. The province’s only flour and cereal mill and the largest miniature horse ranch in Canada is also located there. The median price of a home in the Armstrong area in 2006 was $271,500. Last August, on a farm outside town, a crop circle appeared. It was said to resemble a note of music. IW March 2007 Insurancewest 23 Work with us in Vancouver! Part-time project work – listings coordinator We seek a take-charge, well-organized, meticulous and mature self-starter to confirm, verify, research and enter all listings data for the two recognized insurance industry trade directories in Western Canada. For more details please visit www.insurancewest.ca or call me, Bill Earle, Group Publisher at 604-874-1001. 2008 2008 Barton’s Armstrong office PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY INSURANCE Insurance Brokers Errors & Omissions the product speaks for itself! Program Highlights: •Full Prior Acts • Broad coverage •Retroactive Claims-made form •Broad definition of insured •First-dollar defense •In-house loss prevention program •Competitive premiums •Registry extension available •Experienced Western Canadian loss & legal counsel • $20,000,000 limits available • Employment Practices Liability extension • Premium finance plan available Underwritten at Lloyd's London England As Managing Brokers for leading domestic and London markets, we can show you the way to successful placement of these products for your clients: •Professional Liability Specialist (Misc.) •Subscription Participation •Excess & Umbrella •Medical & Health-care Providers Professional •Architects/Engineers Professional •High-value Dwellings •Commercial General Liability •Builders Risk/COC •High Value Automobiles •Manufacturers & Suppliers Professional Indemnity •CONTRACT BONDING Surety & Miscellaneous Bonds Contact us today! •Design Consultants E&O •Directors & Officers Liability Insurance for Non-profit & Profit Organizations •Commercial Property and Casualty Insurance for industrial and commercial classes of business 200, 11210 - 107 Avenue Edmonton AB T5H 0Y1 Phone (780) 422-0568 Fax (780) 425-6776 Toll-free phone Canada: 800-561-1713 Toll-free fax Canada: 866-425-6774 [email protected] online at www.monarchins.com 24 Insurancewest March 2007 problem if he wants to grow the business. “I knew I couldn’t be the only one facing this dilemma, so after a few sleepless nights I sat down and tried to think of a way to deal with my staffing issue. I came up with a comprehensive training and education strategy.” Nitchie presented a proposal to the executive team at the Hub International Group, which was timely given their mutual concern about recruitment and retention. Barton was already committed to the idea of a centralized training facility. The Hub Group has 51 locations and employs 500 people throughout the province. The training facility will likely be based in Chilliwack, about 100 kilometres east of Vancouver. “It’ll be established for our company alone to create its own training program and will involve recruiting employees with the right attitudes for the insurance industry and then training them with hard skills. “I envision the facility employing a trainer to teach core skills such as the fundamentals and essentials of insurance and using Sagitta, our in-house computer system. The trainer might also teach the Leadersway process, a personal development and leadership course Barton Insurance started for employees about two years ago. After graduating from the centralized training centre, staff would arrive in our offices with the core skills they need.” Len Bosch, Hub’s VP sales, Interior Shuswap region, says, “Ryan quite rightly points out that getting employees on board who are already trained will go a long way to helping face the challenge. His vision . . . certainly was a catalyst (for the Hub training facility) and his suggestions and recommendations will be included in the curriculum.” Richard Burley, Hub’s VP operations, southern and Vancouver Island regions, also agrees with Nitchie’s point about the need for trained staff. “As Ryan says, our managers need a way to recruit new people who can show up for work with fundamental knowledge and skills already in place.” IW www.insurancewest.ca Services&Suppliers W e s t e r n C a n a d a ’ s An advertising supplement AIG > 28 The edge in premium financing AMAC > 28 Are brokerage prices about to fall? Barclay > 34 Storms, boom in West, create challenges BMO > 31 Putting the kaibosh on debit-card fraud Canstar > 30 Drying process is more than just hot air On Side > 38 New lab an industry first in B.C. Paul Davis > 37 Innovation leads to franchise success ReClaim > 26 One-stop insurance-replacement Wagner’s > 33 Restoring fabric the European way Winmar > 39 New machine saves soft goods www.insurancewest.ca March 2007 Insurancewest 25 services & suppliers 2007 ReClaim VP Bob Golden The best and biggest In just two years ReClaim Insurance Replacement, a division of Best Buy Canada Ltd., has blossomed from an ambitious idea to a 26-person team with 22 offices coast-to-coast. Already this feisty upstart is the largest provider of consumer electronics and appliances for the insurance industry outside Quebec. But it won’t be long before even that achievement will require amending, as the game plan calls for an office in La Belle Province next year. By Don McLellan T he French novelist Victor Hugo, he who changed the world with Les Misérables and The Hunchback of Notre-Dame, once said, “No army can withstand the strength of an idea whose time has come.” At Best Buy Canada Ltd., with headquarters in Burnaby, B.C., just a stroll from the banks of the Fraser River, the time was two years ago, the idea was a little something called ReClaim Insurance Replacement. “Our vision, if you will,” explained Bob Golden, ReClaim’s VP commercial sales, “was to become the name that automatically comes to the minds of adjusters and customers when consumer electronics need to be replaced.” There’s a pause, and then he adds, “I believe we’ve done that, and from there we want to be an integral part of the way the insurance companies do business – partnering in people, technologies and systems to make the process of replacement quicker, easier and more cost effective. 26 Insurancewest March 2007 “Once we have landed our Canadian business and ensured that we have achieved and delivered on our vision here, we plan to partner with Best Buy in the U.S.” A lofty ambition, to be sure, however considering how far and how fast ReClaim has advanced suggests these folks are serious players. “We plan to open another eight to 10 locations this year alone.” What began two years ago with a small team of four has today grown to a 26-person team of insurance replacement consultants, with 22 offices from Vancouver Island to Halifax. The only province without representation is Quebec, and that’s coming in 2008, possibly sooner. ReClaim, as the name suggests, quotes on and supplies replacement products to insurance company customers, products that include TV and video; home audio; computers; personal electronics; photo and imaging equipment; music, movies and games; phones; car audio with installation; major appliances and a long, long list of accessories. In other words, just about anything electronic that a claimant has lost to weather, damage, fire or theft. Though insurance replacement is a competitive field, Golden says ReClaim has an “edge.” With the support of two established brands – Best Buy and Future Shop – as well as the parent company’s long-standing history in the consumer electronics business, ReClaim can offer competitive pricing through leveraging unmatched buying power, an incomparable inventory – 600 major brands in-store – and Accurate Like, Kind and Quality replacement quotations, at no charge, in less than 48 hours. Its claims consultants are dedicated full time to insurance replacement and noncommissioned, so there is no pressure to replace with items the store has advertised or is trying to move. “It’s all about looking after the customer and getting them back to where they were before the loss,” said Golden. There’s delivery and set-up service, in-home technical support and car audio inspection and installation available. www.insurancewest.ca services & suppliers 2007 ReClaim even holds “preferred customer events” several times a year. “With us,” Golden said, “customers and adjusters have a choice of shopping faceto-face at Best Buy or Future Shop, or they can price or replace lost items through our web-fulfillment service. We provide a complete solution for the customer. “We’ve also started a special-orders department, where customers have access to products beyond what you see on our shelves. Through our extended lines, there’s almost nothing we can’t supply in electronics and media.” Strigl ReClaim was launched as a separate entity under the Best Buy Canada Ltd. family of businesses, which includes the wholly owned subsidiaries – and competing brands – Future Shop (121 stores) and Best Buy (47 stores), as well as the Geek Squad, the 24-hour computer-support force. Best Buy Canada Ltd., with some 20,000 employParsons ees (almost a thousand of them working at its bustling Burnaby headquarters), is a wholly owned subsidiary of Best Buy Co. Inc., which has more than 700 stores in the United States. Best Buy’s North American operations employ 120,000. There is one Best Buy store operating in China and more than 100 under the name Five Star. For his first decade with Best Buy, Golden was VP store development. Which means he took stores to market, from their design, layout and merchandise presentation to fixturing and visuals. It’s the kind of work the Vancouver native had done much of his working life, on the West Coast and in Ontario, with outfits such as Zellers, Fields, Fedco and Consumers Distributing. His background in retailing, merchandising and operations has given him the impetus and knowledge to land and grow this new business for Best Buy Hender Canada. He’s even owned a few concerns of his own, including Fila sports apparel stores in Ontario. Said Golden:“Back in 2005, Kevin Layden (the Best Buy Canada president) and I were talking about new opportunities in the marketplace and building some new businesses in Canada. The first step was the formation of a commercial sales group, which led to supplying our wide array of products to lotteries, incentive programs, condo builders and hotels. “For the insurance replacement business, I went looking for people who had a background in insurance.” First to join Golden, in February 2005 – and presently manager, B.C. region – was Maureen Strigl, who has been in the industry of insurance replacement of consumer electronics for over 10 years. “I helped Bob get things up and running,” said Strigl, born in Germany but raised in Vancouver. “I knew a lot of the adjusters from the previous replacement company I worked for, so I received a warm welcome when I went out marketing ReClaim. I must say, most adjusters were pleased that we had started this service, as there had been a void for a while. Of course we are differentiating ourselves from other replacement services – evolving and creating something better and bigger that will serve all our customers’ needs coast-to-coast.” “For the first 18 months or so we had an orange light, we were being tested by the shareholders, by Best Buy and by the insurance companies,” recalled Golden. “It was a very demanding and laborious time, but well worth the effort, as Best Buy Canada has given us its trust and confidence, and we’ve gotten the green light, which has allowed us to grow. “We’re one of the preferred suppliers for most insurance companies and the largest provider of consumer electronics and appliances outside Quebec for the insurance industry. About 45 insurance companies and 40-odd independent adjusters are now using our services.” Golden said two people in particular – Ed Nolan, VP claims Canada for ING, and Tom Davis, Wawanesa’s senior claims manager for B.C. – gave the fledgling ReClaim an opportunity to prove its worth. “Tom met with us and agreed to give us a try, but he was very clear that customer service was of the utmost imLouie portance to him, the adjusters and Wawanesa as a company. We assured Tom that our claims consultants were noncommissioned and hand-picked for their customer service and product knowledge. He said he’d give us a chance, but warned Continued on page 40 Professional Restorative Dry-cleaning Specialists • European certification and education • 24 hour emergency service • Computerized item tracking • In-house ozone facilities • Window cover cleaning, including take-down and reinstall • Special item restoration • Laundry services 34 - 7621 Vantage Way, Delta BC V4G 1A6 604•952•6677 24 hour emergencies 604• 812 • 2536 www.wagnersfabricare.com www.insurancewest.ca March 2007 Insurancewest 27 services & suppliers 2007 Buying and selling brokerages: do the laws of gravity apply? By Renate Mueller look at the reasonable payback period of the investment. The street talks about a or anyone who has spent the greater multiple of net commissions – commispart of their career building up an sions net of contingent profit commissions – however, the process of determining what insurance brokerage, the concern multiple to offer is based on normalized is when to sell, who to sell it to and how earnings-before-interest, tax, depreciation much to ask. Multiples of commission for and amortization (EBITDA). brokerages being sold have reached Once this EBITDA figure has been historic highs. calculated, a reasonable purchase There are a number of factors price is usually five to seven times this contributing to the overheating of figure. This would allow the purchaser the market. One is the law of supply to pay for the acquisition in less than and demand – far more buyers than ten years. Anything that improves the sellers. Another is relatively low interMueller profit of the brokerage will drive up est rates, which of course reduce the the asking price. cost of acquisitions. At the moment many Does what goes up necessarily have to insurers are eager to provide financing. The come down? There are a number of factors point is, the money is there, it’s relatively that suggest the law of gravity may indeed easy to come by and it’s relatively cheap. make its presence felt sooner rather than Deep-pocketed insurers themselves are later. For example, the average age of a also in the market for brokerages, which is brokerage owner in Ontario is about 60. increasing selling prices. An increase in supply will inevitably lead Still, any sensible acquirer will need to F to a reduction in prices. Also, if interest rates rise, the cost of borrowing will as well, which should, in turn, lower prices. And, as commission incomes stagnate or fall at the same time expenses increase, it lowers the EBITDA, which will reduce the purchase price. Brokers with a short time line for selling may not be prepared to wait for the next hardening of the underwriting cycle. They may wish to sell now. Although the selling price of brokerages is not subject to the physical laws of nature, the question buyers and sellers should be asking themselves is: will that which has risen steadily over the past three years come hurtling down? IW Renate Mueller, C.A., is president of AMAC Consultants Inc., specialists in acquisitions, mergers, consulting and executive searches in the insurance industry. The firm, which has offices in Vancouver and Toronto, can be reached at 1-866-315-2622 or by e-mail: amac@ execcentre.com. Resources and creative ability matter when shopping for premium financing W e were talking with AIG Credit’s business development manager Paul Monczynski recently about what his firm has over its competitors, when he said, “It is important to realize how resources and creative ability matter in commercial premium financing. We offer many products, including creative solutions to complex risks, to our large and smaller broker clients, all providing benefits to their customers.” AIG Credit Corp. of Canada (AIG Credit), explained Monczynski, “is a leading premium-financing company which has operated in Canada for over 13 years. With offices in Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto and Montreal, we service insurance brokers from coast to coast, whose customers in Canada, the United States and Puerto Rico finance their premiums in both Canadian and U.S. currencies.” When asked about customer service, Monczynski responded: “Everybody’s busy. Customers naturally want their questions and problems taken care of right away. And 28 Insurancewest March 2007 our Internet-based service products have received great reviews.” AIG Credit appears to want to make financing as effortless as possible. “Time-saving features such as our integration with The Agency Manager (TAM) mean that a broker can create a contract with just a few clicks of a mouse. However, for those who prefer the phone,” says Monczynski, “we’re always here to talk to you in person. Our intention is to develop processes that work best for brokers and AIG services the Canadian marketplace, with accounts ranging from a few thousand to several million dollars. enable them to use them to sell more insurance.” Monczynski said that AIG Credit truly why shouldn’t they? People want to get back services the entire Canadian marketplace, to their own businesses. At AIG Credit, we with accounts ranging in size from a few are most proud of our customer service thousand to several million dollars. Nearly resources. Our service centre is staffed to 50 per cent of the accounts are sized less answer broker and customer phone calls than $11,000. and e-mails from across the country and www.insurancewest.ca Opening our THIRD LOCATION, to house our Expanded Contents, Water Damage & Construction divisions «In the Port Kells Industrial Park «Easy access from Hwy 1 and the new crossing to Maple Ridge «Full pack-out and storage US!Our constantly expanding fleet PLof vehicles and larger staff mean FASTER RESPONSE TIMES to all areas of the GVRD. • IICRC protocol • Fire, flood & contents restoration • Structural repairs • Electronics restoration • Xactimate • Residential and commercial Your one source for Service & Quality at competitive prices If disaster strikes, call us! Barclay Restorations Vancouver Tel: 604-294-2922 • Fax: 604-294-9924 Surrey Tel: 604-455-0366 • Fax: 604-455-0367 www.barclayrestorations.ca 24 Hour Emergency Service 604-294-2922 www.insurancewest.ca March 2007 Insurancewest 29 services & suppliers 2007 The company is also proud of its flexibility. When asked to explain, Monczynski indicated that AIG Credit routinely designs customized premium-finance products. Customization includes providing simple alternative loan structures for basic transactions and programs while also providing solutions for self-insured risks or multinational concerns. Maintaining an understanding of the always-changing dynamics of various industries is critical to AIG’s success. “Some insureds in niche markets require particularly special terms and conditions. We are known for our ability to address unusual circumstances and sometimes it takes a lot of research to develop appropriate solutions for these situations. Our solution framework embodies the concept that most businesses use debt to keep as much cash as possible in their own operation where it provides them with the greatest return. This approach proves very beneficial for many of our Canadian customers.” Says Monczynski: “In each of our branch offices we have a global scope yet local knowledge. We understand what’s happening in small and large companies, in the broker’s backyard and across the country. We provide product education either in person or on the web. Our scalability and array of products is unrivalled. At AIG Credit, it’s one-stop shopping at its best. Why choose a premium-finance partner with any less to offer you and your customers?” IW For more information about AIG Credit and its premium-finance products, see the ad on page 36. 30 Insurancewest March 2007 New system means shorter drying time By Art Johnson W cr wls mended zone, the drying effectiveness is lost, resulting in longer drying times. Now, with the advent of air exchangers introducing the use of heat, like the technology found in “Water Out” equipment (www. wateroutvancouver.com), this challenge is removed. The Water Out drying system replaces warm humid air with hot dry air along with rapid evaporation by fans. Large areas can be dried significantly faster and with less destructive methods, thus reducing disruption to tenants and businesses. This, along with state-of-the-art motorized extraction tools, has contributed to very rapid, less intrusive restoration processes. But while the restoration scene is changing, be careful. No matter how good the tools may be, your first line of defense should be qualified, especially certified, water damage professionals. IW hile water is the most important ingredient for the survival of the human race, it proves the least favourite when it enters a building due to failure of either the water distribution lines or the sewer collection system. We have contributed to Johnson the risk by ensuring everyone in our homes and offices has a bathroom on each floor and fridge icemakers, dishwashers, water coolers and automatic coffeemakers in our kitchens, lunchrooms and offices. New technology designed for rapid, efficient drying has had a significant impact on the drying process in the event of an abovementioned failure. For many years the Business downtime was greatly reduced A Water Loss Specialist fine balance needed when Canstar’s Water Out system dried 37 and a Certified Restorer, for effective refriger- units in a Vancouver hotel in four days. Art Johnson is the operaant dehumidificationtions manager at Canstar type drying has been a real challenge. As Restorations’ two plants in Vancouver. He is widely an example, if the temperatures within the published in industry journals and has been featured on news and talk shows. affected area fail to remain in the recom- www.insurancewest.ca