Chapter 9 : Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE
Transcription
Chapter 9 : Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE
Chapter 9 : Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE Non Scheduled Time (Nichtbetriebszeit) Operations Time (Betriebszeit) Down Time (nicht bereit) Unscheduled Down Time (ungeplante Nichtbereitschaft) * holidays * Installation/rebuild/ shutdowns * training * run out op.material * out of specs * Repair Scheduled Down Time (geplante Nichtbereitschaft ) * maintenance * maintanence delay * Material refill * set-ups Up Time (bereit) Engineering Time (...) * process tests * software tests * experiments cleanroom 7% Manufacturing Time (Produktionszeit) Productive Time (Produktive Zeit) Standby Time (Wartezeit) * regular production * work for 3rd party * rework * engineering runs * no operator * no product * no support OEE = Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 others 5% building 8% capital costs 10% equipment 70% Theoretical time for effective tools Total Time Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 1 9 Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Equipment Manufacturers and Organisations 9.3 Semi-Standards 9.4 SEMI-E10 9.5 SEMI-E79, Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.6 From OEE to Overall Factory Efficiency OFE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 2 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Some News and Data about Semiconductor Fabs 2004-2007 The following news are from the www and only examples to get some data, also showing historical developments: May 2004: http://www.xbitlabs.com/news/other/display/20040517085938.html, AMD broke ground on its 300mm manufacturing facility on November 20, 2003. The new facility, named AMD Fab 36, is part of AMD Fab 36 LLC & Co. KG and is being built in Dresden, Germany, adjacent to AMD Fab 30. The Fab36 will cost about $2.4 billion in total. AMD gets $1.5 billion as help, which is $500 million as subsidies, grants, etc, $700 million is a loan and remaining $300 as an equity from 2 partners - Saxony and some European investors. The rest $900 million are expected to come from AMD itself. AMD projects the building to be completed in late 2004. The company will start the installation of equipment just before the end of 2004 and plans to start qualifications of the factory in the late 1H 2005. AMD Fab 36 is expected to be in volume production in 2006. The new facility will employ roughly 1000 people. The Fab 36, as expected, will manufacture chips in 300mm wafers using 65nm technology process. This will allow AMD to cost-effectively make its MPUs and this seems to be the company’s primary goal for the new foundry. Even though there is 20% to 30% gap between the costs of manufacturing using 200mm wafers and 300mm wafers as well as shrink of fabrication technology to 65nm process also provides some cost benefits, CPUs also get more and more complex, as a result, there are no breakthroughs in margins or costs expected by the company’s management. The initial capacity of the fab is 13 000 300mm wafers per month, but the building itself allows AMD to expand the foundry to produce up to 20 000 wafers per month. Oct 2006: Siltronic, Samsung Team Up to Build Wafer Fab, http://techon.nikkeibp.co.jp/article/HONSHI/20061110/123391/ Siltronic AG and Korean semiconductor company Samsung Electronics have announced a joint venture to construct a 300mm wafer fab in Singapore. Siltronic is a division of Wacker Chemie AG of Germany, a silicone and polymer chemistry company specializing in fine chemistry, polysilicon production and semiconductor technologies. Construction of the new wafer fab, which will adjoin Siltronic's existing complex, commenced in August this year. Both companies expect production to start mid-2008; their aim is to reach 300,000 wafers per month in capacity by 2010, by which time about 800 new employees should be working at the fab. The fab will be jointly operated by both Samsung and Siltronic; Siltronic will put in place the new CEO and the CTO, while Samsung will select the new CFO and the COO. The fab is likely to be used solely for production; no major R&D activities are expected to be conducted at the fab. The venture is expected to benefit both companies. "Samsung has a clear-cut expansion strategy and intends to invest US$33 billion in developing the semiconductor industry up to 2012," said Park Sung-Hae, public relations manager at Samsung Electronics. "This joint venture is an important part of our plan to ensure a stable source of supplies for the rapidly growing 300mm market." Locating the new fab near Siltronic's existing 200mm wafer plant in Singapore is a logical technical and business move. "Geographical proximity of the new 300mm fab should substantially facilitate the transfer of know-how, implementation of production processes and leveraging of synergies regarding the joint use of existing infrastructures," explained Christof Bachmair, spokesperson for Wacker and Siltronic. According to Bachmair, benefits of the venture to Siltronic include a significant boost in innovation, time to market and quality. Secured delivery of the fab's output to Samsung translates into a stable utilization rate, which is critical for profitability. Samsung, meanwhile, will have access to a constant supply of 300mm wafers of the highest quality specifications. April 2007: http://www.fabtech.org/content/view/2760/ Intel Corp. has invested $3 billion in a new 1,000-employee semiconductor fabrication plant, or "fab," that opens Thursday in Chandler. Fab 32 is the only full-scale semiconductor-production facility in the world to employ the latest 300 millimeter/45 nanometer technology. Die gesamte Fläche der Anlage beträgt gut 92.000 m², die Reinraumfläche beläuft sich hingegen auf 17.000 m². Während der Planungs- und Bauzeit wird Intel allein knapp 3.000 Leute beschäftigen; in der Fab 32 werden später gut 1.000 hochqualifizierte Menschen arbeiten. Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 3 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Some News and Data about Semiconductor Fabs March 2007: Intel announces new China 300mm wafer fab, http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/108728/intel-announces-new-china-300mm-wafer-fab.html Intel is strengthening its ties with China with the announcement of a new 300mm wafer fab in the city of Dalian, in the north-east province of Liaoning. While Intel has a number of such chip factories around the world - in Israel and Ireland, as well as the US - this is its first in Asia. In what is described as a $2.5 billion investment, Fab 68 is Intel's first new wafer fab at a new site in 15 years. 'China is our fastest-growing major market and we believe it's critical that we invest in markets that will provide for future growth to better serve our customers,' said Intel President and CEO Paul Otellini. 'Intel has been involved in China for more than 22 years and over that time we've invested in excess of $1.3 billion in assembly test facilities and research and development. This new investment will bring our total to just under $4 billion, making Intel one of the largest foreign investors in China.' 'This is one of the major cooperative projects between China and the United States in the area of integrated circuits manufacturing in recent years,' said Zhang Xiaoqiang, vice chairman of the National Development and Reform Commission. 'The project will further strengthen Intel's leadership position in the semiconductor manufacturing in the world.' Work will start on the new fab later this year and production is scheduled to begin in the first half of 2010. At that point there will be eight such 300mm plants in Intel's manufacturing network. The advantage of the larger 300mm wafers - as opposed to previous 200mm sizes - is the manufacturing efficiency that can be achieved by cutting more chips from a single wafer. Intel states that 300mm manufacturing technology consumes 40 per cent less energy and water per chip than a 200mm wafer factory. Sep. 2007: Toshiba and SanDisk Inaugurate New 300mm Wafer Fab 4 for NAND Flash Memory at Yokkaichi Operations Toshiba Corporation and SanDisk® Corporation today celebrated with a traditional ceremony and reception the opening of Fab 4, the latest 300mm wafer fabrication facility at Toshiba’s Yokkaichi Operations, in Mie Prefecture, Japan. Responding to continuous rising demand for NAND flash memory used in a wide range of digital applications, including digital media players, mobile phones, PCs and memory cards, Toshiba started construction of Fab 4 in August 2006. Fab 4 is expected to start mass production in December 2007 and reach a production capacity of 80,000 wafers a month in the second half of CY2008. The fab has space to expand capacity and further investment could take output to 210,000 wafers per month, in response to the projected increase in future market demand. Fab 4 will employ cutting-edge 56-nanometer (nm) process technology at start-up, and plans call for a gradual transition to 43 nm technology, starting from March 2008. “Toshiba and our partner SanDisk are delighted to celebrate the construction of this new facility,” said Mr. Shozo Saito, Corporate Senior Vice President of Toshiba Corporation and President & CEO of Toshiba’s Semiconductor Company. “Fab 4 will feature world-class manufacturing capabilities, both in scale and productivity. It will support us in reinforcing our leadership in the fast growing global market for higher density NAND flash memories, and provide a powerful engine of growth for both companies.” Dr. Eli Harari, Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of SanDisk Corporation, said, “Fab 4 is testimony to the success of the great partnership and long-term commitment between Toshiba and SanDisk. The enormous size and technology scope of Fab 4 reflect our confidence and optimism for the future, and we believe will enable us to competitively meet the growing demand for flash storage from our global customers in the years ahead.” Outline of Fab 4 at Yokkaichi Operations - Structure of Building: Steel frame concrete, five stories (two clean room stories) - Building Area: approx. 35,500m2 (approx. 382,000 in square feet) - Floor Area: approx. 181,000m2 (approx. 1,948,000 in square feet) - Start Construction: August 2006 - Completion of Building: July 2007 - Start Mass Production: December 2007(plan) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 4 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Some News and Data about Semiconductor Fabs 2009 GlobalFoundries held a groundbreaking ceremony for Fab 2 in Malta, N.Y. The foundry's goal is to have the first tool move in by October 2011, with commercial production by the second half of 2012. By David Lammers, News Editor -- Semiconductor International, July 24, 2009 As an Albany, N.Y., taxi driver ferried a visitor to the GlobalFoundries Fab 2 groundbreaking ceremony near the village of Malta, he said, "For three years they've been talking about this, but I never thought they would actually build it." Planning began in June 2006, and it was this year on June 19 that GlobalFoundries began clearing portions of its 230-acre site, located ~24 miles from Albany and seven miles from Saratoga Springs. Fab 2 is expected to be making volume silicon by the second half of 2012, employing 1400 directly and an estimated 5000 indirect workers. The spinoff of Advanced Micro Devices (AMD, Sunnyvale, Calif.) has room for two additional modules at the site. That shift was supported by a $6B investment in GlobalFoundries by the Abu Dhabi Investment Co. (ATIC). The money will be spent to build Fab 2 at Malta, expected to cost $4.2B, as well as to expand and upgrade the GlobalFoundries Module 2 in Dresden, Germany. The state of New York is providing an estimated $1.2B in subsidies for Fab 2, and is investing additional funding to expand the University at Albany's nearby College of Nanoscale Science and Engineering (CNSE). AMD contributed its existing manufacturing complex in Dresden as well as other assets, but no cash, providing AMD with access to a new fab without capital outlays. Because the site is not space-constrained, Fab 2 will be a two-level building rather than three-level. All of the wafer production will be on one floor, eliminating the need to move wafers-in-progress (WIP) up and down floors. A "zero footprint storage" approach will put some wafer stockers above the tools, he added. Implant will be located off of the main waffle slab, reducing construction costs, and maintenance shops will be on the upper production floor to further improve efficiencies. Though its labor costs in both Dresden and Malta will be higher than at many Asian fabs, manufacturing innovations will make GlobalFoundries cost-competitive with Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. Ltd. (TSMC, Hsinchu, Taiwan). GlobalFoundries is investing in the midst of a severe downturn, which also will reduce costs compared with the more expensive 24/7 construction schedules used when fabs are built in a hurry. Armour said it may take 18 months to build Fab 2, which is expected to have a 220,000 sq. ft. cleanroom with an option to expand cleanroom space to 300,000 sq. ft. The goal is to have the first tool move in by October 2011, with qualification coming in early 2012 and commercial production by the second half of 2012, a schedule that could be accelerated somewhat "depending on market conditions," Armour said. Sonderman said construction begins at a time "of a lot of pent-up demand for advanced foundry capacity." Fab 2 will start at 28 nm technology, and then bring up a 22 nm SOI process for CPU production. GlobalFoundries will support AMD's manufacturing needs with the current 45 nm production, moving to 32 and 22 nm production. For foundry customers, however, most of the interest is at the half nodes, including 40 nm bulk technology immediately at Dresden and 28 nm high-k/metal gate technology late next year when 28 nm customer designs start to be accepted. Sonderman said GlobalFoundries is accelerating its effort to support 40 nm bulk production, which he said comes as customers express concerns about yields at TSMC. "We definitely want to be a counterbalance to TSMC," Sonderman said, outlining plans to offer, by 2013, 600,000 wspy at Dresden and 400,000 wspy at Fab 2. Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 5 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Some News and Data about Semiconductor Fabs (2011) Intel: Neue Chipsatzfabrik Fab 42 Intel: Neue Chipsatzfabrik Fab 42 für 14 Nanometer Fertigung Bereits ab 2013 möchte Intel die neue Fab 42 für die Fertigung von 14 Nanometer Transistoren in Betrieb nehmen. Damit vergrößert sich der Campus in Arizona um ein 5 Milliarden US-Dollar Komplex. von Felix Sold, Sonntag 20.02.2011 Im Zuge des Zusammenkommens von US-Präsident Barak Obama und den Größen der amerikanischen IT-Branche am 18. Februar 2011 hat Intel CEO Paul Otellini den Bau einer neuen Chipsatz-Fabrik angekündigt. Die Fab 42 soll ab Mitte 2011 auf Intels Campus in Chandler, Arizona, entstehen. Ab 2013 soll die Produktion von modernen 14 Nanometer Transistoren anlaufen. Die späteren Chipsätze sollen auf großen 300 Millimetern Wafern Platz finden. Nach Otellini wird die neue Fab 42 nach Fertigstellung die modernste Halbleiterfabrik der Welt sein. Das gesamte Projekt wird Intel nach eigenen Angaben zirka 5 Milliarden US-Dollar kosten, aber zugleich Tausende Arbeitsplätze in den Vereinigten Staaten schaffen, was unteranderem ein Anliegen von Obama war. Die Zeitung Arizona Republic steht diesem Vorhaben kritisch gegenüber, da unter Berufung auf das Greater Phoenix Economic Chouncil (GPEC) nur rund 1000 feste Mitarbeiter eingestellt werden sollen. Für die geplante dreijährige Bauzeit der Fab 42 werden hingegen 14.000 Mitarbeiter benötigt, die demnach keine feste Zukunft im Unternehmen haben sollen. Toshiba und SanDisk eröffnen in Japan gemeinsame Fab 5-Produktionsstätte für 300-mm-NAND-Flash-Speicher (PresseBox) Yokkaichi, Mie, Japan, 12.07.2011, Toshiba Corporation (TOKYO: 6502) und SanDisk Corporation (NASDAQ: SNDK) feierten heute die Eröffnung von Fab 5, der dritten 300-mm-Wafer-NAND-Produktionsstätte auf dem Gelände von Toshiba Yokkaichi Operations in der japanischen Präfektur Mie. Die Nachfrage nach Smartphones, Tablet-PCs und anderen elektronischen Geräten und der damit verbundene weltweite Bedarf an NAND-Flash-Speichern steigt rasant an. Der Grundstein für den Bau von Fab 5 wurde im Juli 2010 durch Toshiba gelegt. Der Herstellungsprozess in dieser neuen Produktionsstätte, die von Toshiba und SanDisk technisch ausgestattet wurde, startet im Juli 2011. Die Produktion in Fab 5 basiert derzeit auf der 24-nm*-Technologie, die ersten Speicher-Chips werden das Werk im August verlassen. Nach und nach wird in Fab 5 zudem auf noch fortschrittlichere Prozesse umgestellt. So wurde bereits vor kurzem die Umstellung auf eine 19-nm*-Technologie angekündigt; hierbei handelt es sich um die weltweit kleinste und leistungsstärkste Fertigungstechnik. Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 6 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Fab Investment Costs Situation: Investment costs of a ready-to-start semiconductor fab 2012 TSMC, FAB14, 20nm Fab Costs [Mill. US$] 10000 1000 Samsung, China,300mm, Flash, 10nm Toshiba, Japan, NAND Intel, Fab42, 450mm, 14nm GlobalFoundries, 28nm INTEL, FAB28, 3. 45nm FA AMD, FAB36, Dresden, 300mm, 65nm announced in www various sources Split-up of costs: 100 cleanroom 7% ~ Factor 10 in 15 years => Factor 1.6 in 3 years others 5% building 8% capital costs 10% equipment 70% 10 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 Year The investment cost for a semiconductor fab are increasing exponential (~ factor 10 in 15 years) Equipment costs are about 2/3 of investment costs Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Equipment must be profitable ! Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 7 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Fab Equipment Costs About every 2 years a new generation ( = smaller dimensions) of equipment is needed (see change to new color in figure) Total equipment spending is the sum of node-specific tools and node-independent tools Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 8 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Fab Equipment Costs CAPEX = capital expenditure = money for invest Some numbers to see where the money goes: Gartner: Semiconductor equipment spending to boost by 15 percent » http://www.siliconsemiconductor.net/ Wednesday 9th July 2014 Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 9 9. OEE 9.1 Intro Cost Breakdown for a Semiconductor Fab Typical Invest for a 200mm Fab ( ~ year 2002 ): see previous pages -> Equipment 70% 1´400 Mill. -> Hook-up 10% 700 Mill. -> Building 8% 160 Mill. -> Cleanroom 7% 140 Mill. -> Utilities 5% 100 Mill. ---------------------------------------------------------------------~ 2´500 Mill. € Typical Operational Costs (27k waferstarts per month WSPM): from various company reports -> Equipment Depreciation 36% 9,72 million / week -> Facility Depreciation 6% 1,62 million / week -> Silicon 15% 4,05 million / week Semiconductor fabs are not ! personnel -> Personnel 6% 1,62 million / week cost intensive ! -> Utilities 10% 2,70 million / week -> Process chemicals & gases 8% 2,16 million / week -> Maintenance 7% 1,89 million / week -> Others 10% 2,70 million / week -------------------------------------------------------------------------------27 million € / week = 4 mill.€/day Due to huge invest and operating costs for tools, minimal improvements result in high cost reduction again: Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Equipment must be profitable ! Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 10 9. OEE 9.1 Intro The Goal of Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 4-Partner Model Optimization strategy: Operator, 90% Tool, 80% Single partner availability and synchronization WIP, 85% Process, 85% Analysis of the synchronization degree new loop Increase of availablity of the single partners OEE deals with the increase of productivity of equipment Increase of synchronization Increase of availability of the worst partner Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 11 9 Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Equipment Manufacturers and Organisations 9.3 Semi-Standards 9.4 SEMI-E10 9.5 SEMI-E79, Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.6 From OEE to Overall Factory Efficiency OFE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 12 9. OEE 9.2 Tool Manufacturers Leading Equipment Manufacturer During the years not many changes in the top 10 equipment suppliers Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 13 9. OEE 9.2 Tool Manufacturers Leading Equipment Manufacturer 2007 Company Applied Materials, USA Value [Mill.€] (total assets *) Employees Revenue 2007 [Mill. $US] 9´700 14´000 8´400 http://www.appliedmaterials.co m/investors/fundamentals.html Tokyo-Electron, Japan www.tel.co.jp ASML, NL 4´400 34 % 9´500 5´100 coater/developers, furnaces, dry etchers, CVD and PVD systems, wet cleaning systems, and test systems 7´100 6´200 4´500 44 % Equipment for lithography, CVD, oxidation 3´600 www.kla-tencor.com LAM Research, Growth % (1998-2001) All tools (with exception of lithography, cleaning), metrology tools, consulting www.asml.com KLA-Tencor, USA EU / US /Asien % 6´000 2´700 % Global over 50% of all metrology tools, CMP, etch, lithography 1´700 2´400 1´600 59 % Etching Systems Advantest, Japan 2´800 3´700 www.advantest.co.jp/ Novellus, USA 1´900 Electron beam lithography, IC-Test systems 1´800 3´700 1´700 www.novellus.com 26 % CVD, PVD, Most companies values can be found with: http://finance.google.com/ * Assets: counting the value of all existing things (money, area, buildings, cars, inventory, ..) But because the company is creating money and the development is taken into account and the number of existing stocks the companies´ market values usually is a factor 2-3 higher than total assets (see numbers on next page) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 14 9. OEE 9.2 Tool Manufacturers Leading Equipment Manufacturer 2001 Historic values to compare: Company Value [Mill.€] Employees Revenue 2001 [Mill.€] EU / US /Asien % Growth % (1998-2001) 47´000 17´000 7´340 15 / 29 / 56 22 % Applied Materials, USA www.appliedmaterials.com KLA-Tencor, USA All tools (with exception of lithography, cleaning), metrology tools, consulting 14´000 www.kla-tencor.com ASML, NL 6´400 13´000 7´000 1´800 8´500 3´000 1´300 1´300 500 700 www.emcore.com 240 450 1 / 79 / 21 37 % 41 / 16 / 43 63 % 130 20 / 19 / 61 60 % wet-chemical cleaning, spin-coater 340 1´100 www.semitool.com Emcore, USA 33 % MOCVD (for compound semiconductors) www.sez.com Semitool, USA 15 / 28 / 48 CVD, PVD, www.aixtron.com SEZ, A 22 % Equipment for lithography, CVD, oxidation www.novellus.com Aixtron, D 19 / 34 / 47 Global over 50% of all metrology tools, CMP, etch, lithography www.asml.com Novellus, USA 2´100 250 26 / 36 / 16 12 % wet-chemical cleaning, Electroplating 360 870 180 6 / 52 / 42 62 % tools for compound semiconductors, manufacturer of compound semiconductor devices source: various company reports 2001 Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 15 9. OEE 9.2 Tool Manufacturers Two Leading Organisations SEMI (Semiconductor Equipment and Materials International) represents about 2´500 equipment manufacturers and material suppliers of semiconductor and flat-panel industry. http://www.semi.org/ SEMI was founded in 1970 to strengthen the members by corporate appearance (e.g. at exhibitions like SEMICON) and concerted action. The members occupy an annual market volume of about 20´000 Mill.€ (semiconductor manufacturers about 200´000 Mill.€). introducing many equipment standards http://www.sematech.org/ International SEMATECH, (SEmiconductor MAnufacturing TECHnology), headquartered in Austin, Texas, USA is a global consortium of leading semiconductor manufacturers that represent about 50% of the world’s semiconductor production. (e.g. AMD, Hewlett-Packard, Infineon, IBM, Intel, Motorola, Philips, TSMC, and Texas Instruments). SEMATECH was founded in 1986 as a cooperation of 14 US semiconductor manufacturers, supported by the U.S. government, to strengthen the position of U.S. semiconductor industry (Japan, Taiwan, Korea gained market leadership). By cooperation resources and risks should be shared, industry infrastructure should be improved, and particularly a support of domestic equipment suppliers should be forced. In 1994 the support of the U.S. government ended, SEMATECH had to look for global funding. In 1995 SEMATECH founded the so-called "International 300mm-Initiative I300I" together with 6 US companies and 7 non-US companies to develop tools, standards and specifications. In 1998 SEMATECH renamed itself in International SEMATECH. The goal of SEMATECH still remains the same: to coordinate semiconductor manufacturers and equipment suppliers to solve common challenges and to guaranty the existence and prosperity of semiconductor industry. www.sematech.org/public/index.htm Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 16 9 Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Equipment Manufacturers and Organisations 9.3 Semi-Standards 9.4 SEMI-E10 9.5 SEMI-E79, Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.6 From OEE to Overall Factory Efficiency OFE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 17 9. OEE 9.3 SEMI-Standards SEMI-Standards for Measurement of Tool Productivity Around 1995 the semiconductor industry recognized, that further growth could only be achieved by increasing wafer size from 200mm to 300 mm. For this task new process tools had to be developed. At the same time the investment costs of a semiconductor fab (mainly due to equipment costs) touched the financial limit of single companies. To avoid this danger co-operations and consortia (like SEMATECH, SEMI) were founded or boosted, in addition possibilities to improve productivity (more working chips for less costs) were investigated. During the investigations for productivity it was found, that a lot of the very expensive fabrication tools of a semiconductor fab were only used less than 50% of time for production of sellable chips. For the improvement of this low productive time a measurement standard had to be developed, which defines the status of each tool and also could be controlled automatically. Initiated by SEMI these standards and specifications were developed and defined in so-called E(quipment)-Standards. E116 Tool productivity and cost management E35 Automated Equipment Performance Tracking (= data exchange with computer and software) E79 Cost of Ownership Definitions and calculations for tool productivity Tool status management E10 1995 E58 Definition of tool status to calculate availability and reliability E30 Definition of control commands between tool and computers Tool communication management E4, E5 Definition of data interface tool and computer (RS-232, TCP/IP) year 1997 1998 1999 2000 Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 2001 2002 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 18 9. OEE 9.3 SEMI-Standards Example for Equipment Status Typical semiconductor equipment: implantation tool Typical process flow: signals: red/white = tool breakdown yellow = tool stand-by green = tool working material (waiting) 1 wafer input 2 wafer loading on stage 3 process (implantation) 4 wafer unload from stage 5 wafer output tool load locks process control operator (assist) for these basic processes several status commands must be controlled Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 19 9. OEE 9.3 SEMI-Standards Example for Equipment Status For the calculation of productivity first must be done: 1. within the tool all possible statuses must be defined 2. these statuses must be reported to external user (data interface, operator, computer) Example for the definition of technical conditions within a tool: wafers on transport disk load wafers loaded in load lock operator loads wafer by hand disk loaded beam adjust implant implant in hold assist in disk stop waiting for unload ready for loading Standby: Waiting for operation stand-by assist out disk unload wafers in load lock disk unloaded Because standards were defined in 2000 still tools exist without these requirements Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 20 9. OEE 9.3 SEMI-Standards Need for Standards in a 300 mm Fab Source: Sematech, I300Iand J300 E Global Joint Guidance Document, 1997 Due to wafer transport automation a lot of new standards had to be defined for new 300 mm fabs Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 21 9 Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Equipment Manufacturers and Organisations 9.3 Semi-Standards 9.4 SEMI-E10 9.5 SEMI-E79, Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.6 From OEE to Overall Factory Efficiency OFE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 22 9. OEE 9.4 SEMI-E10 The SEMI-E10 Standard The task of the SEMI-E10 Standard is the definition of the various operating statuses as a time model Non Scheduled Time (Nichtbetriebszeit) Operations Time (Betriebszeit) Down Time (nicht bereit) Unscheduled Down Time (ungeplante Nichtbereitschaft) * holidays * Installation/rebuild/ shutdowns * training Family in holidays (non scheduled time) * run out op.material * out of specs * Repair Switch defect (unscheduled) Up Time (bereit) Scheduled Down Time (geplante Nichtbereitschaft) Engineering Time (...) * maintenance * maintanence delay * Material refill * set-ups Refill salt (maintenance) * process tests * software tests * experiments Manufacturing Time (Produktionszeit) Productive Time (Produktive Zeit) Standby Time (Wartezeit) * regular production * work for 3rd party * rework * engineering runs * no operator * no product * no support New washing powder (=engineering) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Machine works (=productive time) Machine empty (=stand-by) Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 23 9. OEE 9.4 SEMI-E10 From SEMI-E10 to SEMI-E79 (OEE) Non Scheduled Time (Nichtbetriebszeit) Operations Time (Betriebszeit) Down Time (nicht bereit) Unscheduled Down Time (ungeplante Nichtbereitschaft) * holidays * Installation/rebuild/ shutdowns * training * run out op.material * out of specs * Repair Up Time (bereit) Scheduled Engineering Time Down Time (...) (geplante Nichtbereitschaft) * maintenance * maintanence delay * Material refill * set-ups * process tests * software tests * experiments Manufacturing Time (Produktionszeit) Productive Time (Produktive Zeit) Standby Time (Wartezeit) * regular production * work for 3rd party * rework * engineering runs * no operator * no product * no support Using the known informations in E10 status will be defined, which describe the production status of the tool -> 6 main statuses with sub-states the tool informs about its status Manufacturing Execution System (MES) (knows a lot: where is which lot, what is about the support,...) the computer system adds additional informations with this informations calculations of productivity can be performed (E79) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 24 9 Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Equipment Manufacturers and Organisations 9.3 Semi-Standards 9.4 SEMI-E10 9.5 SEMI-E79, Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.6 From OEE to Overall Factory Efficiency OFE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 25 9. OEE 9.5 SEMI-E79 The SEMI-E79 Standard (Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE) Using the E10-states the productive time as a parameter of productivity or efficiency can be determined. But for an absolute calculation the time value efficiency is not sufficient, because it may be possible, that the tool is working for production, but much too slow. For this reason with an additional E79-standard efficiency losses are defined. SEMI E79 : * uses E10 as a base for time recording * defines efficiency losses on a time base * defines with this efficiency losses an Overall Equipment Efficiency (OEE) * is applicable also for complexe equipment (Cluster-tools) E10 time states Non Scheduled Down Time Scheduled Down Time Unscheduled Down Time E79 efficiency losses Availability Efficiency Losses (Verfügbarkeitsverluste) Engineering uptime Total Time Standby Operational Efficiency Losses (Betriebsverluste) Rate Efficiency Losses (Durchsatzverluste) Performance Efficiency Losses (Leistungsverluste) Overall Equipment Efficiency, OEE * loss based (verlustbasierend) Productive Time Quality Efficiency Losses (Qualitätsverluste) Theoretical productive time for effective tools Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Overall Equipment Efficiency, OEE *time based (zeitbasierend) Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 26 9. OEE 9.5 SEMI-E79 Definitions for Equipment Efficiency Availabili ty Efficiency Rate Efficiency RE Salt must be refilled -> E10: scheduled down but no salt available -> maintenace delay -> E79: availability loss uptime AE total time theoretica l production time for actual units actual production time Machine filled, but forgotten to start -> E10: standby -> E79: operational loss production time Operationa l efficiency OE up time Rate of Quality cleaning time too long, because temperature sensor defect -> E10: productive -> E79: throughput loss theoretica l production time for effective units RQ theoretica l production time for actual units Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Machine worked, but dishes not clean, cannot be used -> E10: productive -> E79: quality loss Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 27 9. OEE 9.5 SEMI-E79 Definitions of Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE Overall Equipment Efficiency Definition following SEMI - E 79 OEE = Availability Efficiency OEE = x Operational Efficiency Availability Efficiency OEE = x x Rate Efficiency Performance Efficiency x x Rate of Quality Rate Efficiency Theoretical time for effective tools Total Time Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 28 9. OEE 9.5 SEMI-E79 Example for Calculation of OEE Example: A Load lock In a cluster-tool for metal deposition two processes A,B are performed. For calculation of OEE using E10 the following times (and processed wafers) are recorded: B Total Time 1 week = 7 days = 168 h Non Scheduled Time (Nichtbetriebszeit) cluster tool Operations Time (Betriebszeit) Down Time (nicht bereit) 0h Unscheduled Down Time (ungeplante Nichtbereitschaft) * holidays * Installation/rebuild/ shutdowns * training * run out op.material * out of specs * Repair Scheduled Down Time (geplante Nichtbereitschaft) * maintenance 10h Up Time (bereit) Engineering Time (...) * process tests * software tests * experiments * maintenance delay 4h 8h 5h Manufacturing Time (Produktionszeit) Productive Time (Produktive Zeit) Standby Time (Wartezeit) * regular production * no operator * no product * no support A 20,4h 427 w B 68,7h 1033 w 24,6h * rework * Material refill h: hours w: wafers A 3h 47 w B 5,6h 65+3w 2h * Setups 68 wafer processed, but 3 are scrap * engineering runs 12h A 4,7h 97+2w B 0h 0w 99 wafer processed, but 2 are scrap of all wafers = 1´674 The theoretical process times are due to the equipment supplier: A: 2.5min/wafer und B: 3.3 min/wafer Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 29 9. OEE 9.5 SEMI-E79 Example for Calculation of OEE Availabili ty uptime total time Availabili ty uptime 5h 102,4h 24,6h 132h 78,6% total time 168h 168h n Rate Efficiency theoretica l production time RE actual production time RCT n number of wafers n all processes n production time n all processes Rate Efficiency Operationa l efficiency RE 2.5 min/ wafer 427 47 99wafer 3.3 min/ wafer 1033 68 0wafer 5065 min 0,824 82,4% 20,4h 3h 4,7h 68,7h 5,6h 0h 60 min/ h 6144 min production timen production time all processes OE up time eng .time s tan dby production timen all processes Operational Efficiency Rate of Quality Total Wafers Pr ocessed reworked scrap Total Wafers Pr ocessed OEE = Availability Efficiency x Rate of Quality Operational Efficiency x OE 28,1h 74,3h 0,776 77 ,6% 5h 24,6h 28,1h 74,3h 1674 47 2 65 3 0.928 92,8% 1674 Rate Efficiency x Rate of Quality OEE = 0,78 * 0,82 * 0.77 *0.93 = 0.46 = 46% !! Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 30 9. OEE 9.5 SEMI-E79 Computer Assisted Manufacturing CAM for OEE From the reported tool states and the information from the computer system (MES) the productivity can be calculated for single tools and for complete tool groups by software. Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 31 9 Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Equipment Manufacturers and Organisations 9.3 Semi-Standards 9.4 SEMI-E10 9.5 SEMI-E79, Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE 9.6 From OEE to Overall Factory Efficiency OFE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 32 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE From SEMI-E79 (OEE) to SEMI-E?? OFE With SEMI-E79 the productivity of the equipment can be calculated. But in a semiconductor fab the tools are not working isolated, they must be supported (infrastructure = electricity, clean water, clean air, computer system, ...). Disposals are created, which must be handled, and also additional equipment (support = transport system, metrology and analysis instruments) exists. All these supporting systems consume money, can break down and reduce productivity of the fabrication tools. It suggests itself using the Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE to develop an Overall Factory Efficiency OFE. FAB productivity and cost management Tool productivity and cost management E35 E124 E79 Cost of Ownership Provisional Guide 2003 Definitions and calculations for tool productivity Tool status management E10 1995 E58 Definition of tool status to calculate availability and reliability E30 Definition of control commands between tool and computers Tool communication management E4, E5 Definition of data interface tool and computer (RS-232, TCP/IP) year 1997 1998 1999 2000 Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 2001 2002 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 33 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Bottom Up Approach - Facilities and Production Model: Fab Production Supply Wet Etch Disposal CMP Ion Implant Diffusion Process Area Process Equipment prod idle down Equipment States T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 34 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Cost input for one special tool: Wet Bench W 3.1 - W 3.9 cleanroom air CDA UHP-O2 HP-N2 Production H2O2 HCl HF IPA NH4OH PCW supply UPW supply UPW hot supply city water Different costs for stand-by and production Standby 0.00 $ 48.44 $ 0.00 $ 0.12 $ 2116.20 $ 403.72 $ 515.16 $ 212.24 $ 438.79 $ 0.00 $ 411.09 $ 211.22 $ 0.70 $ EP-208-3P 13.67 $ EP-400-3P 97.46 $ cleanroom air CDA UHP-O2 HP-N2 H2O2 HCl HF IPA NH4OH PCW supply UPW supply UPW hot supply city water wafer in 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 853.42 $ 48.97 $ 41.47 $ EP-400-3P 49.77 $ cleanroom air acid exhaust general exhaust solvent exhaust PWW-HF-SO4 0.00 $ disposal chemicals IPA UPW return 19.64 $ 0.00 $ PCW return service 0.00 $ wafer out 23.00 $ 21.81 $ 46.67 $ 57.82 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 18.36 $ 191.30 $ 163.82 $ 8.19 $ EP-208-3P 10.72 $ 0.00 $ 8.80 $ 1.87 $ 22.24 $ 0.28 $ 0.00 $ 491.01 $ 16.13 $ 0.00 $ T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) cleanroom air acid exhaust general exhaust solvent exhaust disposal chemicals IPA PWW-HF-SO4 PCW return service E4 Technologies Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 35 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Cost input for several tools in a process modul: cleanroom air CDA UHP-O2 UHP-N2 HP-N2 CO2 BHF EKC EG H2O2 H2SO4 H3PO4 HCl HF IPA NH4OH-2 BOE PCW supply UPW supply UPW hot supply city water EP-208-3P EP-220-1P EP-400-3P 198.01 $ 205.79 $ 52.08 $ Wet Processes wafer in 38.97 $ 141.42 $ 1.12 $ 0.00 $ 328.57 $ 10813.08 $ 1664.69 $ 2708.16 $ 40.02 $ 377.83 $ cleanroom air 5.13 $ acid exhaust caustic exhaust 79.16 $ 0.28 $ general exhaust 309.51 $ solvent exhaust disposal chemicals EKC 301.57 $ 51.39 $ disposal chemicals EG disposal chemicals H2SO4 disposal chemicals H3PO4 296.01 $ 400.52 $ 10.82 $ 499.06 $ 557.35 $ 260.57 $ 1210.92 $ 0.00 $ PCW return UPW return 494.56 $ 328.57 $ 0.00 $ 787.82 $ UPW hot return 66.21 $ 1524.33 $ 1740.00 $ 505.50 $ 0.00 $ 0.02 $ 0.00 $ 8.89 $ 127.55 $ 6.58 $ 0.00 $ 79.30 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ wafer out disposal chemicals HF-NH4F disposal chemicals IPA PWW-HF-SO4 free PWW-HF-SO4 PWW-UPW-recycling PWW-As-acid process waste water- final rinse model parameter 260.86 $ T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 36 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Cost input for all process modules in a FAB Support Production 53.98 $ cleanroom air Diffusion cleanroom air UHP-H2 UHP-Ar UHP-O2 UHP-N2 HP-N2 AsH3-H2 HCl (gas) N2O NH3 SiH2Cl2 SiH4 PCW supply TEOS TEAS EP-208-3P EP-220-1P EP-400-3P 273.11 $ 10.38 $ 2.65 $ 46.36 $ 44.03 $ 1953.80 $ 4.13 $ 0.82 $ 17.11 $ wafer in 143.68 $ 286.46 $ 0.60 $ 2.63 $ 399.47 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air PCW return model parameter 0.00 $ UHP-He toxic exhaust 0.00 $ SF6 cleanroom air general exhaust toxic exhaust PCW return model parameter 0.00 $ 387.08 $ 20.21 $ PCW supply BF3 PH3 EP-208-3P EP-400-3P UHP-He B2H6-N2 HCl (gas) NF3 NH3 0.00 $ 759.66 $ 78.62 $ 531.36 $ 54.04 $ 1985.99 $ 34.24 $ 252.12 $ PCW return 484.23 $ 3.04 $ 0.00 $ model parameter wafer in toxic exhaust CDA PCW supply EP-208-3P UPW hot supply 815.14 $ PCW supply EP-400-3P cleanroom air CDA UHP-O2 UHP-N2 HP-N2 CO2 BHF EKC EG H2O2 H2SO4 H3PO4 HCl HF IPA NH4OH-2 BOE PCW supply UPW supply UPW hot supply city water EP-208-3P EP-220-1P EP-400-3P cleanroom air CDA UHP-Ar UHP-O2 UHP-N2 HP-N2 P-N2 UHP-He BCl3 C2F6 C4F8 CF4 CH4 CHF3 Cl2 CO HBr HCl (gas) He/O2 NF3 SF6 CH3F SiF4 PCW supply UPW supply EP-208-3P EP-220-1P EP-400-3P 205.79 $ 52.08 $ Wet Processes CDA HP-N2 40.02 $ wafer in 141.42 $ cleanroom air 377.83 $ 38.97 $ 5.13 $ 0.00 $ 1.12 $ 79.16 $ 328.57 $ 0.28 $ 10813.08 $ 309.51 $ 1664.69 $ 301.57 $ 2708.16 $ 51.39 $ 10.82 $ 400.52 $ 0.00 $ 499.06 $ 260.57 $ 557.35 $ 79.30 $ 1210.92 $ 0.00 $ 494.56 $ 0.00 $ 328.57 $ 787.82 $ 66.21 $ 1524.33 $ 1740.00 $ 0.00 $ 8.89 $ 0.02 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 127.55 $ 6.58 $ 0.00 $ wafer out F2-Kr-Ne caustic exhaust Kr-Ne general exhaust poly solvent exhaust PR-1 disposal chemicals EKC PR-2 disposal chemicals EG PR-3 disposal chemicals H2SO4 296.01 $ 505.50 $ UHP-He acid exhaust PR-4 disposal chemicals H3PO4 PR-5 disposal chemicals HF-NH4F PR-DUV-1 disposal chemicals IPA PR-DUV-2 PCW return UPW return UPW hot return PR-DUV-3 PGMEA (DUV) PGMEA PWW-HF-SO4 free TMAH-1 PWW-HF-SO4 TMAH-2 QZ PWW-UPW-recycling PCW supply PWW-As-acid process waste water- final rinse UPW supply EP-208-3P model parameter EP-220-1P 260.86 $ UPS-240-1P 182.61 $ 0.00 $ 49.33 $ 13.04 $ 1.57 $ 13.68 $ 14.36 $ 31.58 $ 32.60 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 124.10 $ Lithography 68.95 $ 24.91 $ cleanroom air PCW return model parameter Parts Cleaning UPW supply 395.13 $ EP-208-3P 170.84 $ 0.00 $ 590.42 $ wafer out 27.49 $ TEOS 0.00 $ 209.97 $ 0.00 $ 508.78 $ 300.94 $ TEPO 198.01 $ 25.00 $ wafer out 50.07 $ C6H15BO3 cleanroom air model parameter Wafer Test cleanroom air general exhaust 8588.40 $ 1712.17 $ WF6 PCW supply wafer out PCW return 0.00 $ wafer out 306.45 $ SiH4 478.78 $ wafer out cleanroom air 1.31 $ 0.00 $ 516.91 $ SiH2Cl2 1.55 $ 68.86 $ 0.00 $ 74.37 $ 0.00 $ 76.93 $ N2O PH3-H2 1420.24 $ 869.19 $ AsH3 0.00 $ 46.33 $ 138.93 $ 56.95 $ 169.78 $ 29.83 $ P-N2 acid exhaust EP-220-1P 1.36 $ 9.28 $ P-N2 14.37 $ HP-N2 general exhaust wafer in 36.63 $ HP-N2 0.04 $ UHP-Ar wafer in PCW supply 107.90 $ UHP-N2 0.00 $ 13.90 $ CDA Metrology PECVD 6.78 $ UHP-O2 138.49 $ cleanroom air 4.64 $ 57.70 $ CDA UHP-H2 UHP-Ar wafer in 0.00 $ 54.05 $ 460.32 $ 415.46 $ 809.35 $ 135.88 $ 2207.79 $ 144.31 $ 56.68 $ 1288.66 $ Implant 192.13 $ wafer in PWW-HF-SO4 PWW-UPW-recycling model parameter 0.00 $ cleanroom air 0.00 $ cleanroom air 1155.33 $ 119.06 $ general exhaust 355.07 $ 7.15 $ solvent exhaust 1666.29 $ 28.52 $ 918.59 $ 0.00 $ 6660.87 $ 15.58 $ 953.58 $ 0.00 $ 6025.12 $ 0.00 $ 347.43 $ 125.35 $ 158.21 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air model parameter Backend disposal chemicals PR disposal chemicals poly PWW TMAH PWW-UPW-recycling 2066.12 $ 0.00 $ 29.49 $ EP-208-3P 49.34 $ 99.55 $ 73.73 $ EP-220-1P 1586.42 $ UPW return PCW return model parameter 4986.70 $ Die Separation (Dicer/Grinder) wafer in cleanroom air CDA P-N2 2929.08 $ PCW supply 217.59 $ UPW supply 32.77 $ grinding disc 0.00 $ 478.58 $ sawing blades 29.15 $ PCW return Transport System 1.90 $ 25.30 $ 25026.28 $ cleanroom air EP-208-3P wafer out 2.91 $ 6.06 $ 30.40 $ 0.00 $ 2.99 $ 2.75 $ 15.01 $ 1.79 $ 22.12 $ 31.96 $ 22.02 $ 319.14 $ 0.00 $ 33.99 $ 0.00 $ 65.49 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air general exhaust PCW return PWW dicing PWW grinding solid waste grinding disc solid waste sawing blades model parameter wafer out 4.43 $ Die Attach and Wire Bonding 48.06 $ 5.69 $ 0.30 $ Dry Etch cleanroom air P-N2 HP-N2 PCW supply UPW supply 1.13 $ 4.81 $ wafer in 10.37 $ 62.91 $ 0.00 $ CDA IPA NH4OH-1 slurry A slurry B slurry C EP-208-3P EP-400-3P EP-220-1P 0.84 $ 29.70 $ 306.19 $ 68.86 $ 257.49 $ 20.25 $ 0.25 $ 1409.28 $ 51.71 $ 48.04 $ 23.49 $ 3.65 $ 64.93 $ 39.56 $ 0.00 $ 0.67 $ 0.00 $ 0.16 $ 156.34 $ 4012.38 $ 23.67 $ 1.38 $ 391.45 $ 0.07 $ 202.22 $ 3.87 $ 3.84 $ 0.00 $ wafer out cleanroom air toxic exhaust die in CMP 49.75 $ 31.00 $ 12.00 $ 9.25 $ 236.22 $ 29.48 $ 0.58 $ 8.34 $ 1017.02 $ 5936.27 $ 1278.40 $ 7.16 $ 91.80 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air wafer in CDA 9.54 $ 0.00 $ 18.13 $ 12.95 $ 30.61 $ 0.00 $ 56.09 $ 193.96 $ 81.60 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ leadframe cleanroom air general exhaust bonding wire caustic exhaust EP-400-3P PCW return UPW return molding press paste Sputter wafer in model parameter cleanroom air CDA P-N2 UHP-O2 UHP-N2 H2-N2 CF4 PCW supply EP-208-3P 3.67 $ 0.08 $ 2.41 $ 3.05 $ 1.54 $ 7.25 $ 316.97 $ 92.01 $ 127.68 $ cleanroom air CDA 0.00 $ 12.31 $ 3.70 $ 50.21 $ 0.00 $ UHP-Ar cleanroom air general exhaust PCW return model parameter UHP-N2 HP-N2 Al-Cu targets Ti-targets 0.00 $ wafer out PCW supply EP-208-3P 107.52 $ 6.91 $ EP-400-3P 0.85 $ 1.10 $ 0.00 $ 2262.88 $ 0.00 $ 3269.39 $ 0.00 $ 155.02 $ 203.47 $ 2.48 $ 80.01 $ 0.42 $ 0.00 $ 2.04 $ 0.88 $ 0.00 $ 16.36 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air 0.00 $ cleanroom air general exhaust solid waste molding press paste chip model parameter Final testing general exhaust PCW return solid waste Al-Cul targets solid waste Ti targets model parameter CDA L-N2 PCW supply EP-208-3P EP-400-3P wafer out model parameter die out 19.62 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 2048.20 $ wafer in 0.01 $ chip 0.00 $ 2.25 $ 2.44 $ 1.92 $ cleanroom air die in cleanroom air wafer out Asher 6.66 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 405.53 $ Packaging PWW/CMP org PWW/CMP inorg PWW-HF-SO4 model parameter CDA UPW return 0.00 $ 2.67 $ die out general exhaust PCW return 0.00 $ 81.84 $ die in 0.00 $ 223.33 $ 103.85 $ 238.73 $ 274.49 $ 0.00 $ 191.23 $ 580.61 $ cleanroom air PCW return model parameter 0.00 $ die out T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 37 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Cost input for all facilities Facilities Process Cooling Water System (PCW) PCW return from production 9149.14 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ heat recovery PCW of make up air system 0.00 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V exhaust PCW supply to production PCW supply cold water 18°C return system 12/18 heat recovery PCW to make-up air system 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ UPS-400V 472.76 $ natural gas 0.00 $ 380.39 $ PCW return cold water 12°C supply system 12/18 Heating System 0.00 $ heat recovery N2 generation 0.00 $ heat recovery - CDA heating 25°C return system 55/25 0.00 $ heating 55°C return system 80/55 0.00 $ Compressed Dry Air System (CDA) 0.00 $ exhaust 0.00 $ heat recovery N2 generation (heat difference) 0.00 $ heat recovery CDA (heat difference) heating 55°C supply system 55/25 heating 80°C supply system 80/55 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V supply air 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 3858.43 $ 0.00 $ recooling 25° C supply 31/25 heat recovery CDA (heat difference) EF-400V 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ N2 recooling 31°C return system 31/25 heat recovery - CDA 0.00 $ L-N2 recooling 25° C supply 31/25 0.00 $ heat recovery N2 generation (heat difference) 0.00 $ waste water to cooling towers cold water 11°C return 5/11 CW return system (heat recovery) recooling 31°C return system 31/25 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 125.29 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ exhaust waste water cold water 5°C supply system 5/11 cold water 12°C supply system 12/18 recooling 25° C supply 31/25 EF-400V 3184.12 $ P-N2 UPW recycling cold water 18°C return system 12/18 heating 55°C supply system 55/25 EF-400V 19.64 $ UPW return cold water 12°C supply system 12/18 EF-400V 0.00 $ exhaust 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 3430.31 $ 0.00 $ divergency waste water heating 25°C return system 55/25 2443.80 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ waste water waste water to cooling towers 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 29526.69 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ PWW /TMAH PWW/HF-SO4 PWW/HF-SO4 free PWW/HF-SO4 EF-400V UPW hot return heating 80°C supply system 80/55 heating 55°C supply system 55/25 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ exhaust city water PWW/CMP org EF-400V 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ DI water supply 0.00 $ EXT 0.00 $ 4000.91 $ exhaust 9280.53 $ DI water supply 0.00 $ PCW supply 0.00 $ 1.73 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ PWW/HF-SO4 45.35 $ EXA 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 380.25 $ general exhaust (mass) waste water EXA (heat) PWW/HF-SO4 PCW return 69.35 $ 39.82 $ L-Ar 0.00 $ EF-400V 0.00 $ recooling 25° C supply 31/25 0.00 $ exhaust UHP-N2 to production 0.00 $ 0.00 $ recooling 31°C return system 31/25 0.00 $ EF-400V exhaust P-O2 (facilities) He UHP-O2 (facilities) 0.00 $ 4815.04 $ exhaust 5005.80 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V UHP-O2 to production UHP-He to production PCW return L-H2 exhaust UHP-Ar PCW return 0.00 $ 1287.97 $ PCW supply EF-400V 0.00 $ 904.31 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ exhaust UHP-H2 to production H2 (facilities) 0.00 $ PCW return city water 0.00 $ city water Air Handling Make-up Air System Recirculation Air System outside air 0.00 $ heat and water difference 0.00 $ 1329.73 $ 21640.18 $ 1013.79 $ 11451.67 $ Electricity Facilities (EF) 22919.30 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ UPS exhaust 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ general exhaust (heat) general exhaust (mass) 0.00 $ 0.00 $ PWW/HF-SO4 free cold water 5°C supply system 5/11 0.00 $ cold water 12°C supply system 12/18 0.00 $ heating 55°C supply system 55/25 0.00 $ heat recovery PCW to make-up air system 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 104.24 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ gases in cleanroom air supply air 28.82 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ waste water EP-208V-3P EP-220V-1P process vacuum to general exhaust EF-400V 0.00 $ 0.00 $ Air Handling Support 0.00 $ cold water 18°C return system 12/18 circulation air return from production heating 25°C return system 55/25 circulation air return from support heat recovery PCW of make up air system 0.00 $ EF-400V EF-6.6kV outside air excess heat and water in outside air exhaust UPS-220V-1P UPS-400V supply system 12/18 heating 55°C supply system 55/25 EF-400V cleanroom air to production 202.50 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V cleanroom air to vacuum 0.00 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air to support cold water 18°C return system 12/18 circulation air to production circulation air to support 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ circulation air to production 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ Light and Transport Air Handling Facilities heat and water difference in outside air 967.36 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ circulation air return from production exhaust EP-400V-3P exhaust EF-220V 0.00 $ cold water 12°C supply system 12/18 exhaust 1.30 $ 0.00 $ waste heat cold water 11°C return 5/11 0.00 $ 0.00 $ heat 0.00 $ cold water 12°C UPW recycling supply air 0.00 $ 0.00 $ General Exhaust general exhaust 6789.08 $ 12380.49 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ Electrical Supply 0.00 $ 0.00 $ in outside air DI water supply EF-400V EF-400V 0.00 $ 303.38 $ 0.14 $ 0.00 $ PCW supply excess heat and water in outside air 0.00 $ 1329.73 $ EXA (mass) electricity 20kV recooling 31°C return system 31/25 heat recovery N2 generation 0.00 $ 1803.86 $ 0.00 $ UHP-H2 general exhaust (heat) 0.00 $ exhaust PWW/HF-SO4 free 0.00 $ EXA (mass) 0.00 $ 0.00 $ natural gas DI water supply UPW hot supply 0.00 $ 548.98 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V HP-N2 UHP-Ar 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 3883.67 $ P-O2 (facilities) 0.00 $ EF-400V heating 55°C return system 80/55 heating 25°C return system 55/25 waste heat (waste water) PCW supply 842.32 $ 3883.67 $ waste water 6708.71 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ general exhaust (mass) HP-N2 H2 (facilities) UHP-O2 (facilities) UHP-He 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 730.25 $ 0.00 $ L-O2 P-N2 0.00 $ 76.54 $ UPW supply electricity 20kV PWW/CMP inorg 1803.22 $ 0.08 $ DI water supply cold water 18°C return system 12/18 0.00 $ 0.00 $ P-N2 to production HP-N2 to production 0.00 $ EF-400V UPW recycling PWW/UPW recycling EXS 0.00 $ exhaust Toxic Exhaust (EXT) 108.73 $ Electricity Production (EP) 4537.25 $ general exhaust (heat) Acid Exhaust (EXA) 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 1454.08 $ EF-400V City Water 0.00 $ UPW to UPW hot UPW hot 1194.17 $ 0.00 $ EXS facilities 109.74 $ UPW to UPW polishing 0.00 $ 89.68 $ 0.00 $ recooling 31°C return system 31/25 EF-400V PWW/HF-SO4 free CW return system (heat recovery) 0.00 $ 0.00 $ Polishing P-N2 heat difference raw water 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ Solvent Exhaust (EXS) PWW/grinding PWW/As 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 109.33 $ 842.32 $ UHP-O2 and P-O2 0.00 $ EXC 576.19 $ DI water supply PWW/dicing Pretreatment process waste water final rinse city water recooling 25° C supply 31/25 EF-400V exhaust process vacuum to general exhaust PWW/HF-SO4 0.00 $ 15336.64 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ EF-6.6kV Caustic Exhaust (EXC) 0.00 $ 1.30 $ 1.30 $ 0.00 $ Process Waste Water Treatment (PWW) Ultrapure Water System (UPW) raw water cleanroom air to vacuum 1.30 $ 1349.13 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V Exhaust Process Vacuum System 0.00 $ 4734.58 $ EF-220V Chiller System and Cooling Towers UHP-N2 HP-N2 and P-N2 exhaust CDA 0.00 $ 0.00 $ Bulk Gas Supply System 0.00 $ 0.00 $ EF-400V waste heat 0.00 $ Support 0.00 $ 0.00 $ exhaust 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ cold water 18°C return system 12/18 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 202.50 $ 617.97 $ 0.00 $ heating 25°C return system 55/25 0.00 $ general exhaust (mass) EXA (mass) 0.00 $ cleanroom air to support circulation air to support 1803.22 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ EXC (mass) EXT (mass) EXS facilities circulation air return from0.00 support$ 0.00 $ T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 38 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Cost input for the complete production and support Basic Supply Facilities Facilities and Production outside air N2 (air) L-N2 He L-Ar L-O2 H2 city water raw water Bulk Gases Water < Supply 448.25 $ 205.82 $ 2166.57 $ 125.99 $ 210.51 $ 10.87 $ 709.88 $ 68.07 $ Supply Production Chemicals Specialty Gases Other Material BHF BOE C6H15BO3 EG EKC H2O2 H2SO4 H3PO4 HCl HF IPA L-HP-N2 NH4OH-1 NH4OH-2 PGMEA PGMEA-DUV poly PR-1 PR-2 PR-3 PR-4 PR-5 PR-DUV-1 PR-DUV-2 PR-DUV-3 QZ slurry A slurry B slurry C TEAS TEOS TEPO TMAH-1 TMAH-2 AsH3 AsH3/H2 B2H6/N2 BCl3 BF3 C2F6 CH3F C4H2F8 CF4 CH4 CHF3 Cl CO CO2 F2/Kr/Ne H2/N2 HBr HCl He/O2 Kr/Ne NF3 NH3 NO PH3 PH3/H2 SF6 SiF4 SiH2Cl2 SiH4 WF6 Al-Cu targets bonding wire grinding disc leadframe molding press sawing blades Ti targets 328.57 $ 328.57 $ 300.94 $ 1664.69 $ 10813.08 $ 2708.16 $ 296.01 $ 400.52 $ 499.06 $ 557.35 $ 1211.50 $ 103.85 $ 8.34 $ 494.56 $ 125.35 $ 347.43 $ 25026.28 $ 1586.42 $ 1155.33 $ 355.07 $ 1666.29 $ 918.59 $ 6660.87 $ 953.58 $ 6025.12 $ 2929.08 $ 1017.02 $ 5936.27 $ 1278.40 $ 2207.79 $ 531.02 $ 27.49 $ 2066.12 $ 4986.70 $ heat and water excess (air) natural gas electricity 20kV Exhaust and Waste Water 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ exhaust waste water heat and water difference in outside air heat difference in raw water waste heat in waste water additional transition cleanroom air compressed dry air P-N2 HP-N2 UHP-N2 UHP-O2 UHP-Ar UHP-He UHP-H2 Water 3138.72 $ 2090.35 $ 518.55 $ 8.89 $ PCW supply UPW cold supply UPW hot supply city water Energy 2984.29 $ 244.38 $ 2760.42 $ 4.43 $ EP-208V-3P EP-220V-1P EP-400V-3P UPS-240V-1P Gases/Air Return 1022.98 $ 378.43 $ 18.08 $ 753.86 $ 7.43 $ 3454.85 $ Water Return 1736.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.02 $ 15.58 $ 0.00 $ 787.82 $ 1637.50 $ 56.09 $ 193.96 $ 0.00 $ 22.12 $ 22.02 $ 1420.24 $ 4.13 $ 759.66 $ 29.70 $ 20.21 $ 306.19 $ 23.67 $ 68.86 $ 574.45 $ 0.25 $ 51.71 $ 23.49 $ 3.65 $ 1.12 $ 1.90 $ 7.25 $ 39.56 $ 532.85 $ 0.16 $ 25.30 $ 8744.74 $ 88.29 $ 501.33 $ 869.19 $ 3.04 $ 4012.38 $ 1.38 $ 766.77 $ 2127.63 $ 50.07 $ 2262.88 $ 107.52 $ 319.14 $ 405.53 $ 2048.20 $ 33.99 $ 3269.39 $ Energy Gases/Air 895.38 $ Disposal Facilities Facilities 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ cleanroom air acid exhaust caustic exhaust general exhaust solvent exhaust toxic exhaust PCW return UPW hot return UPW return PWW/As PWW/TMAH PWW/UPW recycling PWW/HF-SO4 free PWW/HF-SO4 PWW/CMP org PWW/CMP inorg PWW/final rinse PWW/dicing PWW/grinding Disposal Production chip > Disposal Production Chemicals and Solid Waste 309.51 $ 301.57 $ 51.39 $ 10.82 $ 260.57 $ 28.52 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ wafer in 0.00 $ wafer out 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ disposal chemicals EKC disposal chemicals EG disposal chemicals H2SO4 disposal chemicals H3PO4 disposal chemicals IPA disposal chemicals PR disposal chemicals poly disposal chemicals HF/NH4F solid waste Al-Cu targets solid waste Ti targets solid waste molding press paste solid waste grinding disc solid waste sawing blades model parameter T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 39 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development Cost input for the complete production and support Basic Supply Facilities outside air N2 (air) Bulk Gases L-N2 L-O2 L-Ar Water He H2 city water Energy raw water natural gas E-20kV heat and water excess in outside air Supply Production Chemicals 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ BHF BOE C6H15BO3 EG EKC H2O2 H2SO4 H3PO4 HCl HF IPA L-HP-N2 NH4OH-1 NH4OH-2 PGMEA PGMEA-DUV poly PR-1 PR-2 PR-3 PR-4 PR-5 PR-DUV-1 PR-DUV-2 PR-DUV-3 QZ3501 slurry A slurry B slurry C TEAS TEOS TEPO TMAH-1 TMAH-2 Specialty Gases AsH3 AsH3/H2 B2H6/N2 BF3 BCl3 C2F6 C4F8 CF4 CH3F CH4 CHF3 Cl2 CO CO2 F2-Kr-Ne H2-N2 HBr HCl He-O2 Kr-Ne NO NF3 NH3 PH3 PH3-H2 Other Material SF6 SiF4 SiH2Cl2 SiH4 WF6 Al-Cu targets bonding wire grinding disc leadframe molding press paste sawing blades Ti targets General View 328.57 $ 328.57 $ 300.94 $ 1664.69 $ 10813.08 $ 2708.16 $ 296.01 $ 400.52 $ 532.85 $ 557.35 $ 1211.50 $ 103.85 $ 8.34 $ 494.56 $ 125.35 $ 347.43 $ 25026.28 $ 1586.42 $ 1155.33 $ 355.07 $ 1666.29 $ 918.59 $ 6660.87 $ 953.58 $ 6025.12 $ 2929.08 $ 1017.02 $ 5936.27 $ 1278.40 $ 2207.79 $ 531.02 $ 27.49 $ 2066.12 $ 4986.70 $ Disposal Facilities wafer in 0.00 $ Exhaust and Waste Water 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ exhaust waste water heat and water difference (air) heat difference in raw water waste heat (waste water) Disposal Production Chemicals and Solid Waste 301.57 $ 309.51 $ 51.39 $ 10.82 $ 0.00 $ 260.57 $ 0.00 $ 28.52 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 1420.24 $ 4.13 $ 759.66 $ 20.21 $ 29.70 $ 306.19 $ 68.86 $ 574.45 $ 23.67 $ 0.25 $ 51.71 $ 23.49 $ 3.65 $ 1.12 $ 1.90 $ 7.25 $ 39.56 $ 499.06 $ 0.16 $ 25.30 $ 501.33 $ 8744.74 $ 88.29 $ 869.19 $ 3.04 $ 4012.38 $ 1.38 $ 766.77 $ 2127.63 $ 50.07 $ disposal chemicals EG disposal chemical EKC disposal chemicals H2SO4 disposal chemicals H3PO3 disposal chemicals HF/NH4F disposal chemicals IPA disposal chemicals poly disposal chemicals PR solid waste Al-Cu targets solid waste Ti targets solid waste molding press paste solid waste grinding disc solid waste sawing blades model parameter 0.00 $ wafer out 2262.88 $ 107.52 $ 319.14 $ 405.53 $ 2048.20 $ 33.99 $ 3269.39 $ E4 Technologies T. Vonderstrass, E. Mueller ( M+W Zander) Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 40 9. OEE 9.6 OEE to OFE Method for Overall Factory Efficiency Development COO – cost of ownership Output Input Gases/Air Chemicals Water Energy Wafer Process Module Fixed costs Operational costs Equipment Depreciation Transport Custom Installation Training Floor Space Interest Material Energy, Heat Exhaust (air, gases) Wastewater Solid waste Wafer Yield costs Whole Wafers Defect Dies Input (standby) Input (production) Output (standby) Output (production) Maintenance Personnel Testwafer COO = Lifetime F$ + O$ + Y$ LxTxYxU Throughput Cost per good wafer Composite yield Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Utilization Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 41 Chapter 9 : Overall Equipment Efficiency OEE Integrated Circuit Manufacturing Modul 1278 Prof.Dr.W.Hansch, Dipl.-Ing.E.Schober ICM, 9 - 42