Well-‐Being Design Submitted to the Faculty of the Furniture Design
Transcription
Well-‐Being Design Submitted to the Faculty of the Furniture Design
Well-‐Being Design Submitted to the Faculty of the Furniture Design Department In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Fine Arts in Furniture Design at Savannah College of Art and Design Tanner N. Svoboda Savannah, Georgia © May 2015 George Perez, Committee Chair Charles Boggs, Committee Member John Pierson, Committee Member Dedication Page This thesis is dedicated to all those in the health care industry working to improve the quality of life of others. Table of Contents List of Figures 1 __________________________________________________________________________ Abstract 4 __________________________________________________________________________ Part 1: Introduction 5 __________________________________________________________________________ Part 2: Well-Being Design 8 __________________________________________________________________________ - 2a. Human Centered Design 9 - 2b. Universal Design 15 - JPMA Certification - 2c. Systems Furniture 17 19 Part 3: Hear __________________________________________________________________________ - 3a. Identify a design challenge 20 - 3b. Recognize existing knowledge 21 - Assistive Technology 21 - Existing Assistive Technology 28 - 3c. Identify people to speak with 34 - 3d. Choose research methods 37 - 3e. Develop an interview approach 38 - 3f. Observe vs. Interpret 39 Part 4: Create __________________________________________________________________________ - 4a. Develop the approach 41 - 4b. Share stories 41 - 4c. Identify Pattern/ Find themes/ Create Framework 41 - 4d. Create opportunity areas 42 - 4e. Brainstorming new solutions 42 - 4f. Make ideas real 47 - 4g. Gather feedback 53 Part 5: Deliver __________________________________________________________________________ - 5a. Identify capabilities required for delivering solutions 55 - 5b. Create an implementation timeline 58 - 5c. Track Indicators 58 - 5d. Evaluate Outcomes 59 Part 6: Conclusion 66 __________________________________________________________________________ Part 7: Appendix 67 __________________________________________________________________________ Works Cited 68 __________________________________________________________________________ Svoboda 1 List of Figures Figure 1 Tempur-Pedic Positional mattress 6 Figure 2 PresslitCare Height Adjustable Kitchen Countertop 6 Figure 3 Well-Being Design Venn Diagram 8 Figure 4 Human Centered Design Venn Diagram 9 Figure 5 Human Centered Design Bell Curve 11 Figure 6 Human Centered Design Relationship Map 13 Figure 7 Touch Sink 16 Figure 8 Perceptible Wall Sign 17 Figure 9 ASTM Standards for Toddler Beds 18 Figure 10 JPMA Certification Logo 19 Figure 11 Herman Miller: Canvas Office Landscape Collection 19 Figure 12 Human Centered Design Process Bell Curve 20 Figure 13 Well-Being Design Mind Map #1 21 Figure 14 Assistive Technology Evaluation Diagram 25 Figure 15 Theraposture Safe-T Bed 29 Figure 16 Medline Hospital Bed 29 Figure 17 Human Solution Height Adjustable Desk 30 Figure 18 Kid Kraft Platform Toddler Bed 31 Figure 19 Wharfside Princess Desk 32 Figure 20 Personalized Bed 33 Figure 21 Well-Being Design Mind Map 2 41 Svoboda 2 Figure 22 Well-Being Bed Sketch 43 Figure 23 Well-Being Swing Sketch 44 Figure 24 Well-Being Desk Sketch 45 Figure 25 Well-Being Storage Sketches 46 Figure 26 Well-Being Bed 3D Model 47 Figure 27 Well-Being Bed Scale Model 48 Figure 28 Well-Being Bed Full-Scale Mock-Up 48 Figure 29 Well-Being Swing 3D Model 48 Figure 30 Well-Being Swing Scale Model 49 Figure 31 Well-Being Swing Full-Scale Mock-Up 49 Figure 32 Well-Being Desk 3D Model 50 Figure 33 Well-Being Desk Scale Model 50 Figure 34 Well-Being Desk Full-Scale Mock-Up 51 Figure 35 Well-Being Storage 3D Model 51 Figure 36 Well-Being Storage Scale Model 52 Figure 37 Well-Being Storage Full-Scale Mock-Up 52 Figure 38 Fabrication Schedule & Check list 58 Figure 39 Well-Being Bed Image 59 Figure 40 Well-Being Bed Step and Bumper Element 60 Figure 41 Well-Being Bed Front Board Slide Element 60 Figure 42 Well-Being Storage Image 61 Figure 43 Well-Being Storage Drawer Element 62 Figure 44 Well-Being Storage Hinge and Way-finding element 62 Svoboda 3 Figure 45 Well-Being Desk Image 63 Figure 46 Well-Being Desk Bumper Element 64 Figure 47 Well-Being Desk Cubby Element 64 Figure 48 Well-Being Swing Image 64 Figure 49 Well-Being Swing Rubber Element 65 Figure 50 Well-Being Swing Rope and Lock Element 65 Svoboda 4 Abstract Well-‐Being Design Tanner N. Svoboda May 2015 Assistive technology is an integral part of the everyday lives of anyone with a disability, and having access to it is crucial in their comfort and safety. This thesis examines the current state of health care furniture and its complex relationship with the pediatric community. It will go in depth on how assistive technology is being used in residential furnishings made available by the residential and commercial markets, as well as how pediatric patients and their caregivers perceive it. The research will include an extensive look into what type of assistive technology is needed for a broad range of disabilities, as well as first hand accounts, expert interviews, and potential user interviews (which include both pediatric patients and caregivers) to determine what is needed in today’s residential furnishings as well as its aesthetic. Thus, it proposes a viable alternative market that integrates assistive technology into residential pediatric furnishings to allow adequate functionality for users with disabilities and their caregivers. Keywords: Well-‐Being, Pediatric, Furniture, Assistive Technology, Universal Design, Human Centered Design, Systems Furniture, Health-‐Care. Svoboda 5 Part 1: Introduction What do you think of when you think of health care furniture? The typical picture that comes to mind is a hospital room filled with furniture lacking in both quality and aesthetics creating a depressing setting. In recent years research has shown that the integration of contemporary styling, colors, textures, and patterns into these pieces will increase patients and employee’s moods, as well as improving the healing time of patients. The health care industry has been successful in creating better living environments in hospital settings by integrating these details, but what happens when they design furnishings for the residential setting? These are pieces that have assistive technology integrated into them for the aid of someone with a disability, whether permanent or temporary, making everyday living easier in the home. The health care industry is still producing cheap, institutional looking pieces. If we don’t want these types of pieces in the hospital setting, why would we want them in our own home? Our home is a place where one would want to feel as comfortable as possible, and having cold sterile furniture takes away from that comfort. Companies, such as Herman Miller and Tempur-‐Pedic, that do not directly design products for the health care industry, are producing furnishings that help serve the same function as the health care industries pieces, but have the aesthetic qualities that would be welcome in a home. Herman Miller, a commercial office furniture company, makes furniture that has a very appealing design, but also has the added benefits of being able to adapt to the users needs. Tempur-‐Pedic, which designs mattresses (Fig. 1), took the concept of the hospital bed and integrated its memory foam mattresses, allowing the user to position their body into the most comfortable position while supporting the body with Svoboda 6 their innovative foam. Other companies, such as PressalitCare, are integrating the technology needed for people with disabilities into the contemporary kitchen environments (Fig. 2), whether it is a height adjustable counter top, or a cabinet with wheelchair accessible Figure 1. Tempur-Pedic Positionable Mattress shelving. They, along with Herman Miller and Tempur-‐Pedic, have integrated this technology into residential furnishings in a way that makes the user feel not like a patient, but a productive and coping individual. Although there is a necessity for assistive furniture for the general public, there is also a great need for an unexplored genre: assistive furniture for Figure 2. PressalitCare Height Adjustable Kitchen Countertop children with disabilities. Pieces that have the functionality of health care furniture, but designed specifically for children with a residential aesthetic. These are pieces that function in rooms like the bedroom, where children learn, play, and spend a large amount of their time, as well as areas where anyone with a disability would still need access to furnishings with assistive technology. While only a few options such as beds and desks exist, they are oversized, expensive, lack aesthetics, and primarily designed for functionality. Several health care companies make beds for the home that fulfill the functional requirements, but are made from materials that can be easily damaged, and aren’t aesthetically pleasing such faux veneer and particleboard. This gap in both the health care and residential markets Svoboda 7 leaves much to be desired. With the simple integration of assistive technology into aspects of bedroom furniture, the physical and emotional well-‐being of disabled children could greatly improve. This thesis is based around answering the questions: “what is assistive technology?”, and “how is it used in the home by not only the user, but also the caregivers who heavily rely on assistive technology?” The answers will lead to a better understanding of what is working and what is not working with current pediatric assistive technology as well as what they want to see in the future. The findings will help develop creative solutions, which can then be evaluated by potential users to determine if they are viable. Having a disability doesn't need to make a child feel alienated by making everyday tasks incredibility difficult. Children suffering handicaps or battling disabilities need to live normal and self-‐sufficient lives, whether they are temporarily in therapy or facing a life-‐ long disability. Furniture designers have the opportunity to design pieces that allow the user to adapt to any space and be as comfortable as possible, no matter what situation. Also recognizing areas in the market that aren’t being utilized is very important to the growth of the furniture industry. Creating a new approach to residential health care furnishings will hopefully fill a gap in the market and provide products that can assist the greatest amount of people. Svoboda 8 Part 2 Well-Being Design Well-Being design is the concept of integrating assistive technology into everyday furnishings to assist someone with a disability. They are pieces that have the aesthetic value of ones found in the residential industry, but meet the functions of those found in the health care industry. Well-Being furniture is not meant to be specifically for someone with a disability. It is intended for everyone, but has the added benefit of assisting someone with a disability. There is furniture today that does meet these criteria, such as the Tempur-Pedic bed mentioned earlier. However, this product intended to perform one type of function where Well-Being designed pieces take a broader approach to disabilities, and can assist a greater amount of people. To achieve this goal, three different design areas are being combined into one concept. Integrating the users needs through Human Centered Design, accommodating for the user with Universal Design, and using mechanisms found in systems furniture as the tools for how the designs will function. Figure 3, Well-Being Design Venn Diagram Svoboda 9 2a. Human Centered Design Human Centered Design is a process and set of techniques used to design products, environments, and modes of interactions with an empathetic approach (Human Centered Design: Toolkit). Jodi Forlizzi, a Professor of design and human-computer interaction at Carnegie Mellon University states that human centered design is where you “take actions that support the needs of those whose lives they are trying to improve, actions that are potentially not in agreement with their own social or philosophic codes.” It is called Human Centered Design because it starts with the people we as designers are designing for, and they are the ones who know what the best solutions are. The Human Centered Design approach takes three “lenses” into account: Desirability- what people want, Feasibility- what is possible with today’s technology and resources, and Viability- what can be financially viable (Human Centered Design: Toolkit). By taking these into account one can create a completely successful piece that meets the users Figure 4. Human Centered Design Venn Diagram needs. To achieve this goal, human centered design is broken up into three stages; Hear, Create, and Deliver. Hear consists of collecting stories and inspiration from people. Create takes these stories and translates them so you can recognize opportunities areas, design problem solutions, Svoboda 10 and create prototypes. Finally, Deliver is where you launch new ideas and solutions into the world. Hear The goals of the Hear stage is to find out what someone’s needs, hopes and aspirations are for the future through qualitative research. This type of research provides a deeper understanding of the issue, rather than a general overview, and can help determine specific obstacles or barriers in their everyday lives by understanding why these things happen, and how they can be changed. With regards to this thesis, understanding the obstacles someone with a disability and their caregivers might have with the furniture they use, and what they would like to see change to better adapt to their needs will be the primary goal for the hear phase. This first stage can be broken down into 6 steps: (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 33). 1) Identify a design challenge. This consists of finding challenges that people are facing that are broad enough to discover other areas that might parallel, but narrow enough so that the topic can be manageable. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 34) 2) Recognize existing knowledge Researching what we know about a topic is very important in knowing what is needed or wanted. Once documented you can focus on what will be new instead of what already exists. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 39) 3) Identify people to speak with According to the Human Centered Design toolkit, “recruiting appropriate and inspirational participants is crucial.” Identifying those who represent the extreme sides of the issue, as well as those make up the majority, can be the most effective way to get quality Svoboda 11 information. Figure 5 shows a bell curve that displays the proportion of people who should be representative of these three categories. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 40) 4) Choose research methods By choosing specific types of research methods, one can ensure they have gained thorough information for the context of the topic. Individual interviews, group interviews, and expert interviews will be used in this thesis. Individual interviews allow a deeper Figure 5. Human Centered Design Bell Curve understanding of the behaviors, reasoning, and lives of people. Group interviews generate general ideas on the topic quickly, and expert interviews allow for in-depth technical information. They can provide details on the topic like the history, regulations that might affect it, and the technologies associated with it. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 42) 5) Develop an interview approach. Finding a balance between discovering relevant information, and talking as an empathetic friend is crucial when interviewing. It is important to start with questions they are comfortable with, then ask broad questions on the topic, and finally probe deeply. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 58) 6) Observe vs. Interpret. Finally throughout the interview process one needs to understand the difference between observing what they do, and interpreting what they say. This gives you a better understanding of the behavior and context they are referring to. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 68) Svoboda 12 Create The overall goal of Create is to translate your research into real world application through the process of synthesis and interpretation. “Synthesis is the act of making sense of what we’ve seen and heard during the observations” (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 83). It takes us from ideas and inspiration and moves them forward in a more strategic direction, allowing both the logical side of the brain (left) to work in tandem with the creative side (right) to create innovative design solutions. Throughout the Create stage one will go through almost all of the design process, starting with brainstorming, and moving into sketching, modeling, and finally prototyping. It is broken down into 7 steps. 1) Develop the Approach. The first step is to choose what type of approach you want to take to the design problem. The Human Centered Design Toolkit identifies two different methods to approach the design process. Method one is a participatory co-design approach, where you design the product or idea with people of the community. This is most beneficial with the adoption of the idea within the community. The second method is an empathic design approach. Through empathy, you receive a deep understanding of the needs of the user. Essentially you get a sense of what it feels like to “walk in their shoes.” It is more beneficial when you want to design products that have a deeper connection to the users thoughts and feelings. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 84) 2) Share stories. Through this step you turn the information you gained through the interviews and turn it into data that can be used as ideas or inspiration for your final product. These stories should be descriptive and specific, yet should not include hypothesizing or judgment of what the user says. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 92) Svoboda 13 3) Identify Pattern/ Find themes/ Create Framework. Once the data has been collected from step 2, the next step is to put it into structured framework. This can include Venn diagrams, process maps, and relational maps. A relational map, shown to the right in Figure 6, shows how specific parts or your research relate to each other. From this framework you can extract key insights and identify patterns and themes that lead to larger relationships that can be incorporated into the final product. (Human Centered Figure 6. Human Centered Design Relationship Map Design: Toolkit, Page 94-101) 4) Create opportunity areas. Once you have identified patterns and themes within your research, the next step is to take these relationships and funnel them into finite groups. Within these groups the question “How might we…?” needs to be answered. For example, if research was done on kitchen layouts, and a relationship between the distance of the refrigerator and kitchen island was found. The question of, “how might we bring these two closer together, while still keeping a functional work flow within the space,” needs to be asked. It is important to not design solutions, just create opportunities. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 102) 5) Brainstorming new solutions. Once the opportunities have been narrowed down, the next step is to brainstorm solutions. No idea is too large or impractical; “generating truly impractical solutions often spurs ideas that are relevant and reasonable” (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 104). Svoboda 14 6) Make ideas real. By integrating your new ideas into sketches, models, and prototypes you can get a better understanding of how your product or idea will look as well as function. Specifically, prototypes are a powerful form of communication that allows us to think in realistic terms. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 106) 7) Gather feedback Once prototypes have been completed, it is important to gather feedback from those you interviewed, as well as those who could provide important information. It is important to allow them to give honest unbiased feedback. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 108) Deliver The overall goal of Deliver is to take your most successful ideas and move onto implementation. In the case of this thesis, it is the fabrication of the pieces. This includes taking all the feedback from the Create phase and integrating them into the finalized design. This phase has 4 steps. 1) Identify capabilities required for delivering solutions Knowing what will be needed in order to complete your product or idea will greatly inform the feasibility of it. Asking what kind of human and technology capabilities, as well as what materials will be needed, and whether they can be found locally or in other areas. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 131) 2) Create an implementation timeline Mapping out a timeline is an important way to stay on schedule. Having a detailed timeline of each product or idea can ensure that your product will be done on time, as well as allow you to see opportunities where you can improve or add additional elements. (Human Svoboda 15 Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 138) 3) Track Indicators Track indicators are important to integrate onto your timeline. These can be weekly meetings to ensure that a schedule is met, or they can be goals to be attained during production. It is important to note that not all track indicators should be positive. Negative indicators identify problems that need to be resolved. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 146) 4) Evaluate Outcomes To finish the human centered design process, evaluation of your final outcome is important in determining the successfulness of the idea or product. Whether it is a positive or negative outcome, a thorough evaluation is needed for the next stages of the product or ideas development. (Human Centered Design: Toolkit, Page 148) 2b. Universal Design Universal design is a movement that started in the early 20th century when the average lifespan of a person changed from 46 to 76 years. Two World Wars created a large population of people with disabilities, and advancement in medicine made previously fatal illnesses livable. The need for accessibility was high and it sparked a change in the needs of products and environments. This was first seen through the barrier free movement in the 1950’s. According to The Center for Universal Design, it was “established in response to demands by disabled veterans and advocates for people with disabilities to create opportunities in education and employment rather than institutionalized health care and maintenance.” Standards that assisted the person with the disability grew out of this, but because they were seen as “special” or “ugly” they typically segregated the user from the general public. A new way of approaching this idea had to be created, one that accommodated the user with the disability in an attractive way, but Svoboda 16 also benefited the general public. It is based upon 7 general principles, all of which need to be taken into account in Well-Being products. (Universal Design Principles) 1) Equitable Use Equitable use means that the design is helpful to people with diverse abilities. The uses should be the same and should avoid segregation or stigmatizing. Details such as privacy, security, and safety should also be available to all users. (Universal Design Principles) 2) Flexibility in Use Flexibility provides the user a choice of method to use while accommodating for a wide range of preferences and abilities with the user. The movement should be done at any pace by either a left or right hand and without the use of accuracy or precision. (Universal Design Principles) 3) Simple and Intuitive Use Figure 7. Touch Sink The design should be easy to understand and use without any previous training, knowledge of the design, or concentration level of the user. By eliminating the complexity of the design, and being consistent with the information given, the design should be able to be used by anyone no matter what language spoken. (Universal Design Principles) 4) Perceptible Information The design should communicate important information successfully no matter what environmental conditions or users sense abilities. The use of verbal or tactile information can provide contrast between important information and the surroundings, and differentiate Svoboda 17 directional and instructional elements and allow for a variety of devices used by people with sensory disabilities. (Universal Design Principles) 5) Tolerance for Error The tolerance for error protects against accidental or unintended actions by eliminating hazards and errors by either isolating or shielding them from the general public, or providing warnings. (Universal Design Principles) Figure 8. Perceptible Wall Sign 6) Low Physical Effort This allows for the design to be used without much effort that can cause fatigue, or without any need for repeated actions or unreasonable forces. It also allows for the body to be kept in a neutral body position. (Universal Design Principles) 7) Size and Space for Approach and Use The design can function in any appropriate size and space no matter the size, posture, and mobility of the user. If seated the design should provide a clean line of sight for important elements, as well as provide enough space for other assistive technology or assistance. (Universal Design Principles) Juvenile Products Manufacturing Association (JPMA) Certification The JPMA is a national trade organization that sets standards for products going into the market place that are designed for child use. They have been dedicated to creating safe environments for children for over 50 years, and their products range from cribs and car seats to bedding and decorative items. In order to have a product achieve JPMA certification it has to pass a 5-step process. (Certification for Manufacturers) Svoboda 18 1) ASTM Standards are developed Each product being submitted for possible certification will have a different set of standards to be passed. These standards are developed by the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM), which has over 12,000 standards in effect today. These standards are in place to “improve product quality, enhance safety, facilitate market access and trade, and build consumer confidence.” (About ASTM International) They range from the materials used in children’s toys to the production of aircraft parts. Figure 9 is an example of ASTM codes Figure 9. ASTM Standards for Toddler Beds pertaining to toddler beds that must be met in order to achieve JPMA certification. The full list of ASTM standards for children’s furniture can be found at the end appendix in the forms pages. 2) Product Sample Submitted for Testing In order to attain certification the piece must be submitted to the JPMA for testing. 3) Testing Testing of the product occurs in independent laboratories. 4) Certification Criteria Met There are four sets of criteria that must be met in order to achieve certification. 1. ASTM Standards 2. Federal Laws 3. State Laws 4. Retailer Requirements Svoboda 19 5) Certification is Achieved If JPMA Certification is achieved, the product will receive their stamp of approval. Having this stamp on a product lets the public know that the product is safe for your child to use. ("Certification for Manufacturers.") Systems Furniture Systems furniture, also known as action furniture, is a concept Figure 10, JPMA Certification Logo that allows office furniture to change or adapt to the ongoing evolution of design. It originated in the 60’s by the designer Robert Prospt while he was working for the commercial furniture company Herman Miller. Prospt looked at how offices were functioning, and knew a change was needed. His action furniture allowed for space saving benefits, durability, design options and interchangeable components. The term action comes from its ability to reconfigure and update easily. Figure 11 is an example of this transformation. Canvas Office Landscape is a collection from Herman Miller’s systems furniture division. It has the ability to transform from individual desks to a collaborative setting. (Canvas Office Landscape)It is this ability to adapt to the users needs that makes systems furniture the perfect tools for how Well-Being designed furniture will function. Figure 11. Herman Miller: Canvas Office Landscape Collection Svoboda 20 Part 3 The design process used in this thesis follows the same process used in Human Centered Design. It is split up into three stages. In Hear, the first stage, research is gathered and interviews with potential users and industry professionals take place. During the Create stage all the information gathered from the Hear stage is taken and integrated into designs. Finally the Deliver stage includes fabrication of the product as well as final evaluations. Figure 12. Human Centered Design Process Bell Curve Hear 3a. Identify a design challenge. Enhancing the lives of those with disabilities is the key idea behind this thesis. A starting point was to research the area of assistive technology, and determine if this topic has merit. The significant insight from this process was that anyone with a disability, whether it is temporary or long term, man or woman, young or old, assistive technology is imperative to living normal everyday lives. The design challenge of this thesis was to create furniture that integrates assistive technology into the residential furniture. This will allow the user to feel completely comfortable in the home setting, while still getting the function and utility needed. Svoboda 21 3b. Recognize existing knowledge A thorough investigation into assistive technology was needed to fully understand the functions as well as the importance of AT in the health care field. To generate potential research areas a mind map was created. This allowed for ideas to be put together in a structured way and to show relationships between topics. Figure 13. Well-Being Design Mind Map #1 What is Assistive Technology (AT)? “Assistive Technology is any piece of equipment, or system, whether acquired commercially, modified, or customized that is commonly used to increase, maintain, or improve functional capabilities of individuals with disabilities” (What is Assistive Technology? How Is It Funded). When one thinks of how this type of technology relates to disabilities, the typical image is of someone using wheelchairs, hearing aides, or crutches. They are the most commonly used types of AT, and easiest to get. However, most disabilities require AT that is less noticeable to the average person. These could be items such as specialized door handles and knobs for someone who has dexterity problems, or way-finding colors or textures that help someone with vision problems find their way around safely. These types of AT assist the user indirectly, and could be perceived by the average person as design details rather than technology designed to assist someone with a disability. It is this type of AT that will be primarily used in this thesis. Svoboda 22 How many people use Assistive Technology? As of 2010, “1/6th of all Americans have a disability that makes everyday functions challenging” (How many people use assistive devices?). Each of these individuals requires some sort of AT to assist in these everyday functions. The types of disabilities that require AT are broken down into four different categories; cognitive disabilities, physical disabilities, visual disabilities, and hearing disabilities. Someone with a cognitive disability would have difficulty with one or more mental tasks than the average person, and it affects 6.3% of the population (Brault). They can be broken down into two categories; ones that are severe and affect almost every aspect of someone’s life, and those that are less severe. An example of a severe cognitive disability would be Down Syndrome. Down syndrome is a genetic disorder that causes lifelong intellectual and developmental problems. Someone with this disability would require constant supervision and access to assistive technology (What is Down Syndrome). A less severe example of a cognitive disability would be dyslexia. This is a learning disability that causes “difficulty reading due to problems identifying speech sounds and learning how they relate to letters and words” (Dyslexia). It is most prominent in children, and in those who have normal vision and intelligence. Unlike Down syndrome, dyslexia does not affect all aspects of someone’s life, and can be remedied with trained tutors. Someone with this type of disability might require AT such as specialized computers with larger keys for learning, specialized lighting as a mood stabilizer, or visual cues for memory loss. A physical disability is one that puts limitations on a person’s physical functioning, mobility, dexterity or stamina, and affects 12.6% of the population (Brault). As with cognitive disabilities, physical disabilities can also be broken down into severe and less severe categories. Svoboda 23 An example of a severe physical disability is muscular dystrophy. It is a series of diseases that cause progressive weakness and loss of muscle mass. It is more prominent in boys, and can cause someone to lose their ability to walk, breathe or swallow (Muscular Dystrophy Information Page). Muscular dystrophy affects almost all aspects of someone’s life and requires constant care if the disease is evolved enough. A less severe example of a physical disability would be a broken ankle. This would affect someone’s ability to move, but is typically temporary, and does not affect their everyday life. Some examples of AT required for physical disabilities are wheelchairs, canes, or support accessories. Visual disabilities affect 3.3% of the population and are anyone who has suffered loss or near loss of vision (Brault). A severe example of a visual disability would be complete loss of vision. This is someone who has lost all sight in both eyes. They would require access to AT such as a walking stick to help them get around. A less severe example would be nearsightedness, which is caused when the eyeball is too long for the cornea. It causes objects at a far distance to be blurry, where close objects are seen clearly (Myopia). Someone with this disability would require less invasive AT as someone who might be blind. Some examples of AT for visual disabilities would be walking sticks, glasses, or textured flooring to identify changes in area of elevation. 3.1% of the population has a hearing disability, which is defined as anyone who has suffered loss or near loss of hearing (Brault). There are two main types of hearing loss, conductive hearing loss and sensorineaural Hearing Loss. “Conductive hearing loss occurs when sound is not conducted efficiently through the outer ear canal to the eardrum and the tiny bones (ossicles) of the middle ear,” which denies the person to hear faint sounds (Types of Hearing Loss). On the other hand, sensorinearual hearing loss occurs when the inner ear, cochlea, or Svoboda 24 nerve pathways are damaged (Types of Hearing Loss). Conductive hearing loss can be corrected with hearing aides, but sensorinearual cannot because it is permanent hearing loss. Someone with a hearing disability would require AT such as hearing aides or light cues to signal alerts. How do people know what type of Assistive Technology to get? When someone is diagnosed with a disability, their doctor will recommend them to one of two professionals; a Physical Therapist or Occupational Therapist. Physical Therapists are professionals who help patients reduce pain and improve or restore mobility. They might help someone who was born with a lifelong disability, or has a temporary disability from an accident. They do this by helping their patients manage their conditions by developing a plan of treatments. The overall goal is to provide or return their patients to a healthier and more active lifestyle (Who Are Physical Therapists?). Occupational Therapists are professionals who help the patient learn, or re-learn everyday activities through therapeutic techniques. They most commonly help children with disabilities that need to learn basic skills to participate in school and social situations, or someone recovering from injury that needs to regain skills. Occupational Therapists are also trained on different types of AT, and are more formally trained on how to assess what type of AT is right for the patient (About Occupational Therapy). The Physical and Occupational Therapists will work with the doctor to determine what kind of AT is required to meet the patients needs. They will do this through an evaluation that is personalized to each patient, since each patient will have different needs. This evaluation will take into account things like the needs for the patient’s specific disability, their physical environment, home environment, and school environment if needed. Figure 14 below is an example of an outline of this type of evaluation. It should be thorough and take almost all aspects Svoboda 25 of the patient’s life into consideration. Once this evaluation is complete, and the patient receives the assistive technology, the therapists will then teach the patient to use the device. Figure 14, Assistive Technology Evaluation Diagram If the physical therapist and occupational therapists do not know how to use the assistive technology, then they can consult with an Assistive Technology Professional. This is a person who is specially trained and certified by RESNA (Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America) to work with someone with a disability to teach him or her how to use the AT (Get Certified). The ATP can also be brought in during the evaluation phase to help determine what kind of AT will be right for the patient. Can someone receive funding for Assistive Technology? Assistive technology in general is very expensive. A standard wheelchair starts out at $1000, and increases depending on how sophisticated it is. Having access to financial assistance is very important to someone with a disability, especially if the AT is required for everyday Svoboda 26 functioning. According to Marilyn Field, author of “The Future of Disability in America,” health care companies are more likely to cover doctors and therapy visits then they are AT. Medicare only covers certain AT such as medical equipment, prosthetic devices, and orthographic devices, and they specifically exclude hearing aides and eyeglasses. For AT to qualify as medical equipment it must meet these four requirements (Field). (1) Can withstand repeated use (2) Primarily and customarily used to serve a medical purpose (3) Generally is not useful to an individual in the absence of an illness or injury (4) Appropriate for use in the home This excludes any AT that are considered “convenience” items such as grab bars and bath seats (Field). Medicaid is a national program that operates under federal standards. It gives states the authority to determine who should get AT. It covers more AT than Medicare, but it puts restrictive caps on how much can be given. It is the same for private insurance companies. They tend to put a yearly cap of $1,500 for AT, and the patient must meet strict requirements (Field). Does the user use the Assistive Technology? According to Cathy Bodine, “Depending on the technology, nonuse or abandonment rates can be as low as 8% or as high as 75%”. This of course depends greatly on how intrusive the AT is on someone’s life or how severe their disability is. Someone who uses glasses to correct a visual disability would be less likely to abandon their AT compared to someone who uses a more unusual type of AT that their living a day to day life is not dependent on. There are several reasons for this type of abandonment, but the most notable is the stigma behind using AT. A stigma is a mark of disgrace on ones reputation and can affect people in different ways. For example, someone might reject AT if they are fearful of being defined as disabled. The stigma Svoboda 27 that someone with a disability is less capable than the average person could compel him or her to want to abandon the AT in social settings or all together. For example, having to use large, intrusive, or institutionalized AT in their homes might create a level of embarrassment that would prohibit them interacting socially, which could lead to isolation and other behavioral problems (Brady). A study done between Illinois State University and the Institute for Matching Person and Technology with regards to assessing AT for children with developmental disabilities says “stigmatization is often a reality having varying effects, including, but not limited to (a) less than ideal treatment; (b) disrupted social relations; (c) person avoidance, anxiety, and depression; (d) a distorted self-image and resulting poor self-esteem” (Parette). Since a lot of the children taken into account in this thesis have levels of development disabilities, combating this stigmatization is very important. Another reason for abandoning AT is that it does not complement one’s lifestyle. Professionals not taking the users environment and everyday lifestyle into account when assessing proper AT can cause this. Even thought this may sound like a minor reason for abandoning AT, a person’s conformability is very important. Phil Parette, a Professor at the University of Rochester, states that, “An assumption sometimes made by many AT professionals is that certain devices prescribed for children with developmental disabilities satisfy multiple user needs and thus should be used across environmental settings.” The study found that professionals deal on a level of generalization when it comes to assessing AT, that taking peoples specific lifestyle needs are not as highly addressed. Below are some other reasons for abandoning AT. - Not having personal access to accessible technologies - Not knowing that accessible options exist Svoboda 28 - Not having the time or resources to buy or learn how to use AT - Difficulty with learning new devices - Dissatisfaction with existing devices What type of Assistive Technology is available? There are thousands of different AT products on the market today. They range anywhere from basic products like wheelchairs, walkers, and canes to assist in movement. Hearing aides, smart tablets and computer software for someone with sensory disabilities, or even page-turners and specialized light switches for someone with dexterity problems. There are more extreme examples of AT such as lift attachments for transportation, physical therapy, and home use, or specialized equipment and prosthetics. A majority of these products come directly from the health care industry, but there are a few exceptions. These are products that are designed for the home or public sector but have AT integrated into them. As mentioned before, Tempur-Pedic is a good example of this. They have modified their beds so now they can move to put the body in a more comfortable position, while still having their revolutionary foam to give your body support. Research was done into furniture designed for home use that is meant for or could be used by children age 4-10 from both the health care and residential industries. Even though these are two completely different industries, the same information was looked for in each. This includes how the pieces assist the user in its function, how the piece integrated safety measures into it, the aesthetic qualities, and finally the price. All of these are factors when designing furniture for the greatest amount of people. Health Care Industry There are many health care companies that design furniture for children with disabilities. Some of them rely completely on the function of the piece, while others attempt to integrate Svoboda 29 aesthetic value into them. The ones described below are companies that produce products that most met the requirements mentioned earlier. Theraposture is a British company that has designed AT beds, chairs, and mattresses for 35 years. They design several different types of beds for children and toddlers, but the Theraposture Safe-T Bed (Fig. 15), is their newest and most highly regarded bed. It is height adjustable, can be put at a 45-degree angle, has padded sides that fold up and down, and can easily be moved. It is made of solid beech wood and metal construction. The specialized latch components on the padded sides allow for added safety, but more importantly it negates any gaps for potential entrapment of the user. Unfortunately, this bed costs $5,000, and cannot adapt to a growing child. It is ideal for the caregiver because of its height Figure 15. Theraposture Safe-T Bed adjustable qualities, but there is no way for a child to get up into the bed without the help of a parent or caregiver. Overall it is a completely functional and safe bed, but because of its aesthetic and price it is not the ideal bed for consumers. Unfortunately, it is this type of bed that is available for both infants and toddlers because Figure 16. Medline Hospital Bed Svoboda 30 when designing beds for children with disabilities you have to take into account that even though a child may be large enough for a twin or queen size mattress, they still require details like safety rails or bumpers, which are not found on larger beds. Some hospital beds have rails along the sides, but they do not go all the way around. Figure 16 is an example of a typical hospital bed with a rail, made by the health care company Medline. For a child who might who might be prone to night terrors, or random muscle spasms, which is common in children with cognitive and nervous system disorders, they require a bed that allows for 360 degree structure. This bed has many different types of side rail accessories, but they do not provide structure all the way around the child, nor are the cutouts in the railings safe for a small child. Even though this type of bed is the most commonly found in the health care industry, in terms of being suitable for children, it is not. Desks from the health care industry are primarily designed to meet a functional need, Figure 17. Human Solution Height Adjustable Desk but take little aesthetic quality into account. Figure 17 is an example of what 90% of the desks from the health care industry look like as well as how they function. This desk comes from the company The Human Solution, and is designed to adapt to wheelchairs as well as different physical statures. It has a push button that adjusts the tabletop from between 24 and 38 inches, which can allow for either a child or adult size wheelchair. It comes in a variety of hardwood tops and metal support options, and it costs between $800 and $1,500 depending on the size and material used. Overall, it is a very functional desk for an office or school environment, but not Svoboda 31 for the home. Even thought it comes in a variety of hardwoods that gives the table a warm appeal, it still has an institutionalized look. The desk also does not have any sort of storage for objects which would be needed for when the desktop is being raised or lowered to prevent from them falling off. Residential Industry When looking at furniture examples from the residential industry, pieces that have similar functions as the ones form the health care industry were reserached. Whether it somehow provided a level of safety, or performed a function that someone with a disability could benefit from. KidKraft is a company that has been making wooden children’s furniture for over 40 years. They make pieces such as chairs, tables, and beds that are designed for safety as well as durability. Their toddler beds, such as the one show in Figure 18. Kid Kraft Platform Toddler Bed Figure 18, are designed to be low to the ground for ease of access, and have rails along each side to keep kids secure. This bed costs $129 and has the aesthetic value that most would want in his or her homes. Unfortunately this bed would not be the ideal bed for a child with a disability. According to the ASTM standards a guardrail has to be at least 5 inches above the top of the mattress (ASTM International). A bed like this would not meet that requirement, nor does it provide 360-degree structures around the user. The low level could also be problematic for a caregiver who repeatedly has to move the child. Even though this bed has the aesthetic qualities and a decent price, it does not provide the function and safety required. Svoboda 32 Wharfside is a luxury furniture company that specializes in hard wood Scandinavian furniture. Their princess desk, shown in Figure 19 below, is designed to adapt to the growing individual through a height adjustable top. It is made out of solid hardwood, and has both a sliding drawer as well as a top piece that folds up to make an easel. This desk seems like the perfect desk for a child with a disability because of its functionality and aesthetic qualities. Unfortunately this desk costs $3,000, and it doesn’t take into account how an individual with a disability would use the piece. Figure 19. Wharfside Princess Desk Because it is solid hardwood throughout, someone with a low vision might not be able to see where the drawer might come out of the desk. It doesn’t have any handles, which would make it impossible for someone with dexterity problems to open the drawer. These of course are very minor details, but when you are designing for the greatest amount of people you have to take these into account. Svoboda 33 Personalized Because of the lack of products available on the market, some families have resorted to having custom furniture built. Figure 20 shows a bed build for a girl with Rett Syndrome. One that combined the aesthetic they wanted in their home with the function required for their needs. They had originally bought a medical/institutional bed because her disorder causes her to toss and turn throughout the night, but she kept falling out of bed or injuring herself on the metal side rail. As a solution they designed a bed that had walls that flip up to create a 360-degree barrier around her. Unfortunately, they didn’t expect that the acrylic and hardwood sides of the bed still cause harm as she tossed and turned at night. To resolve this they bought long body pillows to act as bumpers along the sides. This is an example of the need for furniture that has the same functions as the safe health care beds, but with sensitivity to the residential market and aesthetic. Figure 20. Personalized Bed Svoboda 34 3c. Identify people to speak with The mind map mentioned during the Hear stage identified three different groups of people to talk to about assistive technology. The first were potential users, those who use AT or those who might be a caregiver of those who use AT. Without their insight one cannot truly understand what is it is like to use AT, as well as what needs to change. The second were health care professionals such as Physical Therapists, Occupational Therapists, and Assistive Technology Professionals. As mentioned before, Occupational and Physical Therapists are great sources for information that pertain to what type of AT is required for different disabilities, as well as information about how to receive AT. The last group of people to talk to are industry professionals, who in this case are furniture and interior design professionals who are well versed in how furniture is fabricated as well as how it functions best in a space. Potential User’s Profiles Hunter- Age 7- Down Syndrome Guiliana- Mother- Primary Caregiver Riley- Age 7- Rett Syndrome Jess- Mother- Primary Caregiver “Around the age of 2 Riley was diagnosed with Rett syndrome. Since that time, there has been a gradual decrease in her functionality. The near 20 words that she used to be able to verbalize are now down to one single word, Mama. She now communicates via an eye-gaze augmentative communication device. The hands that used to hold her own drink now can hold nothing for more than a few seconds. She has no purposeful hand functionality. This means that she cannot feed herself, do any personal hygiene herself, or even color a picture or write her name. She also cannot walk a greater distance a 100 feet without support. This means that in public, she is 90% wheelchair Svoboda 35 bound. When she is out of her chair, she has someone with her at all times. She does not know where she is in space due to her disorder. This translates to losing her balance easily. She is timid around thresholds, items on the floor, and change of colors on the floor. She cannot navigate stairs. She does not have self-protective skills so if she falls, she will not put her hands out to save herself. She cannot climb into or out of bed. She cannot stand on her own accord. Literally everything in Riley's life is impacted by her condition.” (Jess) Mary- Age 18- Cerebral Paulsy “Incorporating assistive technology into residential furniture would certainly make my life easier, especially since so much of my daily routine involves having to use furniture that just isn’t made for me. Tables, dressers and counters are just some of the things that pose a challenge for me. For example, the height of my dresser drawers renders me unable to reach them. In addition, tables and desks are often too high or too low, and counters are almost always unable to accommodate my chair and are extremely hard to get close to. If there was a way to make one’s residential furniture more adjustable to one’s personal needs by incorporating assistive technology, I’m sure it would be invaluable to me and many others. It would do a great deal to lessen the stress of daily life and make it easier, not only for myself, but for those around me as well.” (Mary) Caroline- Age 8- Confined to Wheelchair Linda- Mother- Primary Caregiver Health Care Professionals Sarah Scheisser- Senior Occupational Therapist “21 years of professional experience in pediatric occupational therapy. Currently a Clinical Level IV therapist. Function with a full case-load as well as take on a variety of non-clinical responsibilities including payroll, staffing, tech and volunteer coordinator, and high school intern Svoboda 36 coordinator. Previously greater than eleven years in managerial role serving as both clinician and co-manager for Pediatric Rehabilitation. Responsible for the core critical measures of team member satisfaction, patient satisfaction, quality care and safety, and positive financial outcomes. Other responsibilities include: managing team member conflicts, coaching team members for personal and professional growth, and developing departmental growth in our Savannah location through expansion of services and in surrounding communities through the development of a satellite office.” (Scheisser) Industry Professionals George Perez- Furniture Design Professional “George Perez has been a professor in the Furniture Design Department at the Savannah College of Art and Design since 1996. He received his masters in Fine Arts from the University of Massachusetts at North Dartmouth. He worked in the custom furniture and cabinetry industry before coming to the university to teach. He has acquired numerous contacts and a diverse body of knowledge of the home furnishings industry as he has cultivated the Furniture Design Department's growing relationship with the industry and the American Society of Furniture Designers in which he is an education member.” (Perez) John Pierson- Furniture Design Professional “John Michael Pierson graduated with an MA from SDSU in 1984. He owned and operated JM Pierson and Company, Fine Contemporary Furniture Makers from 1984 – 1997. He taught Furniture Design classes at Miracosta, Palomar, Southwestern, and Mesa community colleges. His work has been exhibited and published primarily in California. His article “Bent Lamination” appeared in the December 1995 issue of Fine Woodworking Magazine. In 1997, he Svoboda 37 accepted a position as Professor of Furniture Design at the Savannah College of Art and Design.“ (Pierson) Charles Boggs- Interior Design Professional “Professor Charles Boggs received Bachelor of Architecture degree from the University of Cincinnati and his Masters of Arts in Interior Design from Florida International University. Professor Boggs brings considerable professional experience having worked for firms such as Gensler, dag architects, Ayers/Saint/Gross, and RTKL before joining SCAD in 2011. While having worked on a wide variety of projects, Professor Boggs's primary expertise is within hospitality design with an emphasis on cruise ship design. While an Associate at RTKL, Professor Boggs worked on such notable projects as Royal Caribbean's Oasis and Allure of the Seas, Celebrity Solstice-class, and the just released Quantum of the Seas. He continues to consult while teaching full time in the Interior Design Department at SCAD.” (Boggs) 3d. Choose Research Methods As mentioned earlier in part 1, individual interviews, group interviews, and expert interviews will be used in this thesis. Individual interviews will be done with the potential users mentioned above. These interviews will provide a deeper understanding of how important AT is in their daily lives, as well as what they would like to see change. Individual interviews will also create empathy for the user by putting one in their shoes, which will help make a more successful product. Group interviews will be done with both health care professionals as well as industry professionals. Occupational and Physical Therapists often work in large communal areas with their patients, and information will be gathered during one of these appointments. In addition, throughout this process meetings with industry professionals, or thesis committee members, will Svoboda 38 occur. Topics such as the progression of the development and fabrication of the pieces will be discussed. Expert interviews will be done with both Occupational and Physical Therapists throughout the design process. They will be a good source of information pertaining to AT, disabilities, and other medical queries I might have about my topic. 3e. Develop an Interview Approach Before meeting with potential users for the individual interviews, a set of questions will be prepared. These questions will start out generic, and move to be more in depth to get a deeper understanding of the users needs and wants. Understanding that the interviews will take place at the rehabilitation center during the child’s therapy appointment, no strenuous or difficult questions will be asked to cause the child or parent duress. Below are the questions that will be asked. 1) What is your name? 2) What is your diagnosis? 3) Do you use any type of AT? 4) Do you think any room in your house is more dangerous, when it comes to furniture? Why? 5) What would you like to see change with existing AT furniture? During the group interviews with the health care professionals, a set of similar questions will be created. These questions however will be more broad than those asked during the individual interviews. Below are some examples of those questions. 1) What do you think is important when it comes to furniture? 2) What would you like to see change with existing AT? Svoboda 39 3f. Observe vs. Interpret. Expert Interviews Meeting with Sarah Scheisser and Kate Woodworth (Spring 2014) - Discussed AT and current state of industry - Discussed whether Well-Being Designed products could be viable in the market today - Developed ideas on what is missing in the industry and what is needed for certain types of disabilities. Meeting with Sarah Scheisser (Summer 2014) - Discussed different companies that manufacture AT for children. - Specialty wheelchairs, swings, beds, bathroom essentials. - Made plans to meet with potential users Individual interviews (Summer 2014) Hunter- Down Syndrome Riley- Rhett Syndrome 3) Do you use any type of AT? - None 3) Do you use any type of AT? - Specialized wheelchair 4) Do you think any room in your house is more dangerous, when it comes to furniture? Why? - Bedroom - Drawers can potentially fall out - Bed can be dangerous to get in and out of 4) Do you think any room in your house is more dangerous, when it comes to furniture? Why? - Bedroom and Bathroom - Where she spends a majority of her time - Dangerous corners 5) What would you like to see change with existing AT furniture? - Locking system on drawers - Steps that swing up and down from bed - Knobs - Tactile and lock down - Safer environment 5) What would you like to see change with existing AT furniture? - Moveable chair with a detachable footrest - Bed with body pillow bumpers, structure on all sides, and can be taken apart and put back together easily. Steps that raise and lower so you can easily lift child into bed. - Shelving that can hold odd sized objects such as medical supplies. Drawers that are easy to open - Desk that adjusts to different sizes of wheelchairs - Swing nook that provides vestibular input. Svoboda 40 Mary- Cerebral Paulsy Caroline- Confined to wheelchair 3) Do you use any type of AT? - Specialized wheelchair 3) Do you use any type of AT? - Specialized Wheelchair 4) Do you think any room in your house is more dangerous, when it comes to furniture? Why? - Bedroom - Hard to get in and out of bed the way they are designed - Storage is too high to see in the drawers 4) Do you think any room in your house is more dangerous, when it comes to furniture? Why? - Bedroom and office - Materials are not made for wheelchairs. Damages easily - Desks can’t adapt to different wheelchair heights 5) What would you like to see change with existing AT furniture? - Desk any wheelchair can fit under with a wider base and larger work surface. - Bed that is easier to get in and out of. Headboard and footboard for support. - Dresser with low drawers that come out and lift up. - Lounge chair with footrest that makes transfer from wheelchair to chair easier 5) What would you like to see change with existing AT furniture? - Desk with a comfort lip and a cuff for special AT gear that all wheelchairs can fit underneath. - Day bed that is height adjustable and has a headboard that can conceal machinery. - Storage with low drawers and an open bookcase. - Cloth covered wood for comfort - Pottery Barn aesthetic Group Interviews Health Care Professionals (Summer 2014) 1) What do you think is important when it comes to furniture? - Ergonomics, durability, accessibility, washability, and taking into account gross motor skills and fine motor skills. 2) What would you like to see change with existing AT? - Integration of footrests and seat belts on high chairs - More materials that are water resistant and washable - Integration of foam or padding on chairs. Provides more support for the child and is washable. - Tables that are removable, but can be raised and lowered. Svoboda 41 Part 4: Create 4a. Develop the Approach Before taking the information collected throughout the Hear stage and implementing it into designs, an approach to how to interpret the information had to be decided. Because an empathetic design approach was chosen, the designs need to be thoroughly informed by the information given by the potential users, health care professionals, and industry professionals. This means that any design that is created must embody their expressed needs and wants when it comes to function and aesthetic. 4b. Share stories The information gathered through the hear stage will next be processed into coherent ideas and shared with the thesis committee. These will be proposed solutions and insights that will continue on to the next step. Meeting with Industry Professionals (Fall 2014) - Discussed the information gathered through the individual interviews and expert interviews - Gathered feedback from Professionals on the next step of design process. - Research into JPMA Certification - CPSC- Consumer Product Safety Commission - NIST- National Institute of Standards and Technology - ASTM- American Society of Testing and Materials 4c. Identify Pattern/ Find themes/ Create Framework After all the information was gathered, another mind map was made to find connections between the ideas give by the potential users and health care professionals (Fig. 21). Figure 21. Well-Being Design Mind map 2 Svoboda 42 4d. Create opportunity areas From the second mind map, sets of opportunity areas were discovered. The bedroom was mentioned several times as the most important area of the home when it comes to time spent in by the children, as well as area that the users and caregivers would like to see changed. The mind map also identified four distinct areas within the bedroom that the potential users would like to see changed, or had ideas of how to make them better. These include a bed, storage, desk and swing. Specific opportunity areas within each piece also came from the second mind map. These areas are seen below. Bed 1) 360 Structure 2) Bumpers 3) Height Adjustable 4) Way finding 5) Steps 6) Easy access Desk 1) Height Adjustable 2) Slightly raised comfort lip 3) Way finding 4) Wider base/Surface 5) Cubbies Swing 1) Kneel 2) Straddle 3) Stand 4) Lay 5) Sit Storage 1) Locking System 2) Customizable 3) Odd sized objects 4) Safer 5) Easy access Drawers 4f. Brainstorming new solutions The next step is figuring out how to integrate these opportunity areas into residential bedroom furniture while taking the universal design principles into consideration. It is impossible to meet all seven of the principles in each piece, but taking them into account can still ensure that the product can be usable by the greatest amount of people. Also meeting the JPMA requirements for each piece will provide a level of safety for the product. Svoboda 43 Bed Function JPMA Requirements 1) 360 Structure 2) Bumpers 3) Height Adjustable 4) Way finding 5) Steps 6) Easy access Mattress retention Mattress Support System Mattress support system attached to end structure Guard Rails End Structure The bed design has to integrate the six functions found during potential user interviews, which are listed above. Questions like “how do I create 360-degree structure around the user?” and “how do I add bumpers to provide a safe zone for the user?” have to be answered. Beds in the health care industry as well as storage systems from the commercial furniture industry were looked at for inspiration for the function of the bed. Companies in the residential industry such as Kid Kraft and Pottery Barn were looked at for the Figure 22. Well-Being Bed Sketch aesthetic of the bed. All seven universal design principles were taken into account for the brainstorming of this piece, but several stuck out as more important. Simple and Intuitive use, tolerance for error, and low physical effort are important in ensuring the piece can be used easily and safely for the user and caregiver. JPMA requirements such as the guardrail height, which has to be 5 inches over the mattress of the bed and can withstand 80lbs of forward backward pressure, and the mattress support systems were highly considered. Svoboda 44 Swing Function JPMA Requirements 1) Kneel 2) Straddle 3) Stand 4) Lay 5) Sit Stability test for preventing tip over Test to prevent unintentional folding Tests on restraint system Requirements for cradle swing orientation Specific requirements for battery operated swings Unlike the other pieces, the swing does not have to meet certain functional requirements. It has to be used as it would be used for therapy to “engage the children while simultaneously improving their function and mobility” (Ruge). Kneeling, straddling, standing, lying, and sitting all create different types of movements and sensations for the children using the swing. The swings available in the health care and the residential market were used as inspiration for this piece, and the dimensions came from the average human dimensions of a Figure 23. Well-Being Swing Sketch child between the after of 4 and 10. Safety was the most important aspect, so having a product made at the same quality as ones found in the industry was desired. The prominent universal design principles taken into account were tolerance for error, size and space for approach and use, flexibility in use, and equitable use. The JPMA requirements to take into account are tipping over, folding in on itself, and stability of the restraint system. Svoboda 45 Desk Function JPMA Requirements 1) Height Adjustable 2) Slightly raised comfort lip 3) Way finding 4) Wider base/Surface 5) Cubbies None specified The desk is the most functional piece in this collection. In order to brainstorm how to create a product that meets all of the functions listed above, inspiration was taken from systems furniture desks and different ways desks are used in the computer industry. Research into the general sizes of children’s furniture as well as wheelchairs was also done. All universal design principles were integrated into the brainstorming of the desk. There were no JPMA requirements when it came to desks. Figure 24. Well-Being Desk Sketch Svoboda 46 Storage Function JPMA Requirements 1) Locking System 2) Customizable 3) Odd sized objects 4) Safer 5) Easy access Drawers No hazardous sharp points or edges, or small parts • Any exposed wood part shall be smooth and free from splinters • Requirements for latching or locking mechanisms and entrapment hazards • Requirements for scissoring, shearing, or pinching hazards • Warning labels must be permanent • Tests for structural integrity, dynamic and static loads, leg openings, stability and motion resistance As with the desk, the storage has numerous functions that need to be addressed. Systems furniture was the main source of inspiration for the desk. How storage pieces are assembled, as well as different options for doors and storage components were researched. All universal design principles were considered with this piece. The main concern with this piece was safety, so tolerance for error and low physical effort were emphasized. The JPMA requirements for stationary activity centers are rather extensive, so taking those into account will be important. Figure 25. Well-Being Storage Sketches Svoboda 47 6) Make ideas real Once all the information was gathered and ideas were sketched for the four pieces, the next step was to create 3d models, scale models and prototypes for each piece. These allow a designer to see how the pieces will look aesthetically and if they will function properly. Bed 3D Model 1. 360 Structure: When the front of the bed is pulled up, and the acrylic panel is pulled up it creates a 360 barrier around the user. Storage doors on systems furniture that lift up to reveal the inside inspired this element. 2. Bumpers: The bottom of the headboard and the back of the front panel are coated in 1/8” thick rubber to Figure 26. Well-Being Bed 3D Model allow cushion if the user runs into the sides of the bed. 3. Height adjustable: The bed is designed to act as a skin around a hospital bed to all the bed to move freely within the structure. If a traditional mattress is used, the front of the bed goes up and down to allow the caregiver easy access to the user 4. Steps: Design details on the front of the bed act as steps so the user can easily step up into the bed. This also acts as a barrier for if a wheelchair needs to be pulled up next to the bed, it won’t damage the bed. 5. Easy Access: A strategically placed cut out in the middle of the front panel reveals the top of the mattress and allows for the user to easily slide onto the mattress. This also allows handgrips for anyone in a wheelchair who might need extra help getting into the bed. Svoboda 48 Scale Model The scale model helped show the proportion of the bed to the average size of the user. It also gave hints to possible problems in the construction of the bed. Figure 27. Well-Being Bed Scale Model Full- Scale Mock-Up The full-scale mock-up allows us to see if the function of the front panel of the bed will work properly. This also helped to see the proportion of the size of the bed relative to an actual sized person. Since it is most likely the caregiver who will be bring the front panel up and down, it is important to know if Figure 28. Well-Being Bed Full-Scale Mock-Up it will be able to function properly and with little ease. Swing 3D Model The swing is designed so that the user can straddle and sit on the swing in the way pictured, or they can kneel, stand, lay, and sit in it if it is flipped over. A rubber cushion will coat each side of the swing to allow comfortable use. Figure 29. Well-Being Swing 3D Model Svoboda 49 The rope will be detachable from the swing to allow quick transformation from the straddle position to kneel position. Scale Model Like with the bed, the scale model helped to show the proportion of the model to the user sample as well as possible problems with the construction. For example, the cutout on the side of the swing has to be scaled down in order for the form to be structurally stable. Figure 30. Well-Being Swing Scale Model Full-Scale Mock-Up The full-scale model of the swing shows how the swing would look in a real world application. It also allowed for potential users to test the swing to make sure all dimensions are right. With the help of the scale model, the cutouts are scaled down enough to allow the chair to be Figure 31. Well-Being Swing Full-Scale Mock-Up structurally sound. It also determined that the ropes have to be put in different locations on the chair to allow for stronger support structure. Svoboda 50 Desk 3d Model 1. Height adjustable: The desk is designed to glide up and down on two acrylic discs which are turned by the potential user or caregiver. This allows for the table to be adjusted to accommodate any sized wheelchair. 2. Slightly raised comfort lip: A rubber bumper will be integrated into the top of the desk to allow a comfort barrier between the user and the desk top. The comfort will also act as a Figure 32. Well-Being Desk 3D Model grabbable support bar for anyone who needs extra support while using the table. 3. Way finding: A carefully placed contrast in colors will act as wayfinding to distinguish the table from the cubbies. 4. Wider Base: A wider base allows for a wheelchair to make a turn under the top if needed without running into the legs causing damage. 5. Cubbies: Instead of drawers, the cubbies have the ability to swing out to wrap around a wheelchair for easy reach. Scale Model For this piece, the scale model helped show how the two acrylic discs need to be changed from oval to circles. In the 3d model it ran smoothly, but in real world application it would take a lot of effort to raise up the top on the long side of an oval. Figure 33. Well-Being Desk Scale Model Svoboda 51 Full-Scale Mock-Up The full-scale model of the table allowed for potential users to test the table to see if it functions correctly as well to see if the heights of the table top in different positions is adequate to meet the needs of users in different sized wheelchairs. Figure 34. Well-Being Desk Full-Scale Mock-Up Storage 1. Locking system/Easy access drawers: Instead of having knobs. The storage will have a push to open drawer to negate any possible accidental openings. 2. Customizable: With pre drilled holes. The user can interchange the type of drawer that goes with each cavity. They can choose between an open shelf, a door that swings Figure 35. Well-Being Storage 3D Model open, and a drawer that swings open. Threaded rods and nuts will hold the overall structure of the piece together. This allows the user to customize where the layers go to meet their individual needs. 3. Odd sized objects: With a larger opening in the middle of the piece, it allows for the user to Svoboda 52 store odd sized objects that normally wouldn’t be able to be stored in a storage. 4. Safer: With the drawers opening like a door, the piano hinge will negate any chances of drawers falling out and causing accidents. Scale model The storage scale model showed several things that needed to change when it comes to the aesthetic of the piece. The feet were changed from walnut to maple to be more cohesive with the rest of the design. The kind of acrylic used in the drawer front was also changed to create a better transition from material to material. Figure 36. Well-Being Storage Scale Model Full-Scale Mock up This mock-up showed how well someone in a wheelchair could approach the piece without damaging the chair or the storage. It also helped understand more about how the drawer will function, as well as how someone in a wheelchair can access.the content inside. Figure 37. Well-Being Storage FullScale Mock-Up Svoboda 53 7) Gather feedback After full-scale prototypes were created, they were presented to both the industry and health care professionals. From these meetings, information on what needed to be changed or added was gathered. Thesis Committee Meeting (Fall 2014) Desk: Will structure allow for knee clearance? Wall anchor? Injection molded nylon for stops? Storage How to open drawers? Into the wheelchair our away from wheelchair? Is the cutout deep enough for a wheelchair to approach the storage? Swing Make sure dimensions are right so the most amount of people can use it. How will the swing attach to the ceiling? Can the rope be attached to the swing permanently? Remove the ability for error. Bed Could it change from a bed to a daybed? Will there be enough room between the steps on the bed front to allow foot to come up and out and onto the next step? Bullet catch stop in front of bed. Health Care Professionals w/ Potential users (Fall 2014) Desk Make desk wider Make cutout deeper Can the cubbies move out as well to accommodate for a wider wheelchair? Swing Can there be a strap that provides a barrier around the swing so the user doesn’t fall out? Storage The threaded rod structure isn’t as imperative as the customizable drawers. Bed The acrylic part on the bed isn’t important, and doesn’t look like it would be safe for the user. Svoboda 54 Part 5: Deliver The main goal of the Deliver stage is to finalize designs, fabricate the pieces, and evaluate outcomes. From the last round of feedback, several changes had to be made to before fabrication could begin. Bed The final bed design took into account several of the ideas mentioned from meetings with both health care and industry professionals. For instance, the two steps on the front of the bed were replaced with one step, this allows the user to place their foot on the step and remove it without any hazard from the second step. The acrylic panel was eliminated, and the front panel now travels 7 inches to allow for 5 inches of barrier around the user as per the JPMA standards. The last alteration was that the headboard can now be removed and replaced with another sliding panel to transform the daybed into a traditional bed. Desk The overall appearance of the desk was not altered, but several safety mechanisms were added to the design. Instead of allowing the desk to move only from 25 inches in height to 32 inches, a lock was added so that the desk could stop at points between for more functional use. This also negates the chance of the desktop accidently falling down and injuring the user if the acrylic discs were to malfunction. In order to allow the user to get closer to the workstation, the cutout was offset 1 inch into the desk, and in addition the cubbies were moved outwards 1 inch as well. This allows for the user to move left and right without running into the cubbies causing damage to both the desk and themselves. Svoboda 55 Swing As with the desk, the overall appearance of the swing was not changed, but where the ropes are attached has moved. Instead of being able to detach the rope from two different points on the swing, the ropes will be permanently attached at one point. This takes into account the Universal Design principle tolerance for error. By negating the chance of the knots being able to come undone and potentially hurting the child, it allows for a safer swinging experience. Storage Nothing with the storage changed except for the direction the drawers swing out to the user. Instead of the front drawer panel swinging into the user, it will swing away opening up the contents of the drawer to the user. 5a. Identify capabilities required for delivering solutions Understanding the capabilities needed to fabricate each piece in the collection will determine the feasibility of the pieces. Each of the four pieces in the collection requires different capabilities, and in this context the capabilities are materials and machinery needed. Below is a list of the major materials and primary machinery needed, and where they can be found. Bed Headboard Materials - ½” Maple plywood - ¾” Maple plywood - Socket Cap Screws - Sorta- Clear 40 Rubber - PPG Automotive Paint Machinery - 5-axis CNC Machine Hood Industries- Jacksonville, FL Hood Distribution- Jackonsville, FL McMaster- Atlanta, GA Reynolds Advanced Material- Charlotte, NC Automotive Paint and Equipment- Savannah, GA Gulfstream Center for Design- Savannah, GA Svoboda 56 Sideboards Materials - ¾” Maple Plywood - ¼” Clear Acrylic Panel - ¼” White Acrylic Panel - Tee Nuts Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL E-street plastics- Rockwall, TX E-street plastics- Rockwall, TX McMaster- Atlanta, GA Machinery - 5-axis CNC Machine Gulfstream Center for Design Frontboard Materials - ½” Maple Plywood - ¼” Maple Plywood - ¼” Clear Acrylic - ½” Aluminum Rod - Cabinet Slide - Sorta-Clear 40 Rubber Machinery - 5-axis CNC Machine Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL E-street plastics- Rockwall, TX McMaster- Atlanta, GA McMaster- Atlanta, GA Reynolds Advanced Material- Charlotte, NC Gulfstream Center for Design Storage Structure Materials - 4/4” Maple hardwood - ¾” Maple Plywood - PPG Automotive Paint and Primer - Sorta- Clear 40 Rubber Machinery - Professional Woodshop Equipment Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Automotive Paint and Equipment- Savannah, GA Reynolds Advanced Material- Charlotte, NC Gulfstream Center for Design Drawers Materials - ¾” Maple Plywood - ½” Maple Plywood - ¼” Frosted Clear Acrylic - Piano Hinge Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL E-street plastics- Rockwall, TX McMaster- Atlanta, GA Machinery - 5-axis CNC Machine - Vacuum Bag System Gulfstream Center for Design Gulfstream Center for Design Svoboda 57 Swing Materials - 1/8” Bending Ply - 1/32” Paper Backed Maple Veneer - Eye Bolts - Climbing Rope Clasps - Sorta-Clear 40 Rubber Machinery - Vacuum Bag System Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Meyer Laminate- Pooler, GA McMaster- Atlanta, GA Knot and Rope- Perrysburg, OH Reynolds Advanced Material- Charlotte, NC Gulfstream Center for Design Desk Desktop Materials - 1” Plywood - ¾” Maple Plywood - 1/32” Paper Backed Maple Veneer - 1” Honeycomb Structure - 1/8” UHMW - Sorta-Clear 40 Rubber Home Depot- Savannah, GA Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Meyer Laminate- Pooler, GA Tricel Corp- Gurnee, IL McMaster- Atlanta, GA Reynolds Advanced Material- Charlotte, NC Machinery - Large Laser Cutter - Vacuum Bag System Gulfstream Center for Design Gulfstream Center for Design Structure & Mechanisms Materials - 4/4” Maple Hardwood - ½” Steel Rod - ½” White Acrylic Panel - 2 3D Printed Steel locks - PPG Automotive Paint Machinery - Professional Woodshop Equipment - Milling Machine Hood Distribution- Jacksonville, FL Universal Steel- Garden City, GA E-street plastics- Rockwall, TX Shapeways- New York, NY Automotive Paint and Equipment- Savannah, GA Gulfstream Center for Design Gulfstream Center for Design Svoboda 58 5b & c. Create an implementation timeline & Track Indicators In order to ensure that the pieces get fabricated on time, a spreadsheet was created to keep track of progress (Fig. 38). The spreadsheet was broken up into four categories; Storage, Bed, Desk and Swing. Each of these was then broken up into sub-categories. For example, the sub-categories for the storage pieces are the legs, vertical pieces, horizontal pieces, drawers, and rubber components. For each sub-category there are four sections that must be completed; Parts, details, finished, and assembled. The part section means that all the pieces are cut to final Figure 38. Fabrication Schedule and Check List dimensions and ready to be detailed. The details include gluing pieces together, drilling holes, or applying tee nuts or dowels. A completed finished section means that the piece has been sanded and the chosen finish has been applied. Finally the assembled section is finished when all the components are completed and attached together. Svoboda 59 5d. Evaluate Outcomes Bed Figure 39. Well-Being Bed Step Image The final bed design, seen in Figure 39, encompassed all of the functions found during the interview process. The front board is height adjustable to allow 360-degree structure around the user, while meeting the JPMA standards for heights of a bedrail by being 5 inches above the mattress. The front board is equipped with a firm rubber step and cutout to allow easier access to the bed. It also acts as a bumper to prevent a wheelchair from damaging the wood panel (Fig. 40). The different colored rubber components on the front board and headboard provide comfort bumpers as well wayfinding for ease of use, as well as act as ergonomic grips for the caregiver. All 7 Universal Design principles were taken into account for this piece, but simple and intuitive use, tolerance for error, and low physical effort are important in ensuring the piece can be used easily and safely for the user and Svoboda 60 caregiver Figure 40. Well-Being Bed Step and Bumper Element Figure 41. Well-Being Bed Front Board Slide Element Svoboda 61 Storage Figure 42. Well-Being Storage Image As with the bed, all of the functions found through the interview process were achieved in the storage piece (Fig. 42). The drawers are connected to the structure with piano hinges, which allows the drawers to swing out to the user, rather than having to be pulled out (Fig.43 and 44). This allows someone in a wheelchair easier use of the piece and access to the items inside. It also eliminates the possibility of the drawer falling out and causing harm. A push-lock mechanism can be found inside the drawers, so there is no need for a handle, which allows someone who might have dexterity or vision problems to use the piece easily. The open space in the center can account for odd sized objects, and the drawers can be moved around to customize the piece for the users needs. Rubber components, as seen in Figure 44, were added to integrate Svoboda 62 way finding into the design, as well as act as bumpers to prevent damage of the storage. All Universal Design principles were taken into account, but the main concern with this piece was safety, so tolerance for error and low physical effort were emphasized. Figure 43. Well-Being Storage Drawer Element Figure 44. Well-Being Storage Hinge and Wayfinding Element Svoboda 63 Desk Figure 45. Well-Being Design Desk Image All the functions identified in the interview process were integrated into the desk design, seen in Figure 45. The tabletop is height adjustable, and is able to change from 25 inches to 32 inches in height. Either the user or caregiver achieves this by turning an acrylic handle, which is connected to two other acrylic discs. The tabletop then glides along these two discs upwards to the desired height. With the use of two 3D printed steel locks, the tabletop can then lock into place. The desk also received a rubber bumper, which acts as comfort lip for the user as well as an ergonomic place for hand support if needed. Found on the bumper, two different colored rubbers act as way finding for anyone with a vision disability. It’s purpose is to denote a difference between where there is and isn’t a cubby. The two cubbies are placed on either side of the user, and can turn out towards the user Svoboda 64 for easier access to objects. Unlike the other pieces, all seven of the Universal Design principles were strongly taken into account with the desk. Figure 46. Well-Being Desk Bumper Element Figure 47. Well-Being Desk Cubby Element Swing Figure 48. Well-Being Swing Image Svoboda 65 The main function of the swing, seen in Figure 48, is that the user has options of how to use the swing. They can kneel, stand, lay, sit, and straddle the swing depending on its position. The swing is fabricated out of bending ply to achieve the shape, as well as for strength to not bow or cave-in under pressure as denoted in the JPMA requirements. The rubber padding was added for comfort as well as a tactile element. The rope is attached to the swing permanently to reduce user error, but it can still easily transform from the seated to straddle position. Figure 49. Well-Being Swing Rubber Cushion Element Figure 50. Well-Being Swing Rope and Lock Element Svoboda 66 Part 6: Conclusion Well-Being design is the concept of integrating assistive technology into residential pediatric furnishings to assist someone with a disability. These pieces have a residential aesthetic, which goes against the medicinal and institutional aesthetic found in furnishings provided by the health care industry, while still being able to meet the users functional needs. The Human Centered Design process denoted three elements that have to be achieved before a product can be considered successful: desirability, viability, and feasibility. Through feedback and on-sight observation, this thesis proved that a Well-Being approach to the aesthetic and functional elements of the furnishings creates a level of desirability that is missing in the health care industry. This approach also simplifies the mechanisms required to perform the products functional operations as well as the materials needed to created durable furnishings, making them feasible from a manufacturing standpoint. Viability is the element of the Human Centered Design process that cannot be proven through this thesis. For the products to be determined as viable in the health care industry, market research and testing needs to be done by 2nd hand organizations. The next step would to submit the pieces to the JPMA Organization to hopefully earn approval that the products are safe for the use with children. With that being said, I am confident that Well-Being designed furnishings can successfully develop into its own market in the health care industry, and eventually lead the way to having more furnishings in homes that assist the greatest amount of people. Svoboda 67 Part 7: Appendix Svoboda 68 Works Cited "About Occupational Therapy" AOTA. American Occupational Therapy Association, 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 10 Jan. 2015. http://www.aota.org/about-occupational-therapy.aspx "ASTM International." ASTM International. ASTM, 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 7 Oct. 2014. http://www.astm.org/ABOUT/overview.html Bodine, Cathy. Assistive Technology and Science. Thousand Oaks, Calif- SAGE, 2013. Print. Boggs, Charles. Interview by Tanner Svoboda. Industry Professional Background. 2015. Email. Brady, Erin, William Thies, and Edward Cutrell. "No Access, No Knowledge, or No Interest? Examining Use and Non-use of Assistive Technologies." Web. 8 Dec. 2014. http://cs.rochester.edu/u/brady/non-use-assistive-tech.pdf Brault, Matthew W. "Americans With Disabilities: 2010 Household Economic Studies." U.S. CENSUS BUREAU. U.S. Department of Commerce, 16 Apr. 2012. Web. 10 Mar. 2015. http://www.census.gov/prod/2012pubs/p70-131.pdf “Canvas Office Landscape.” Office Furniture System. 2015. Web. 10 May 2015. http://www.hermanmiller.com/products/workspaces/individual-workstations/canvasoffice-landscape.html "Certification for Manufacturers." JPMA: Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association. Associated Headquarters Inc., 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 25 Sept. 2014. http://jpma.org/content/certification/certification-manufacturers “Dyslexia.” Mayo Clinic. 2015. Web. 20 May 2015 http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/dyslexia/basics/definition/con20021904 Field, Marilyn J. "Coverage of Assistive Technologies and Personal Assistive Services." The Future of Disability in America. Washington, DC: National Academies, 2007. Print. “For what conditions are assistive devices used?.” Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institue of Child Health and Human Development. N.p.. Web. 31 Mar 2014. http://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/rehabtech/conditioninfo/pages/need. aspx Forlizzi, Jodi . “Interactions.” Confessions of a human-centered designer | ACM. N.p., 1 Mar. 2013. Web. 13 Apr. 2014. http://interactions.acm.org/archive/view/march-april-2013/confessions-of-a- Svoboda 69 human-centered-designer "Get Certified." RESNA. Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 10 Jan. 2015. http://www.resna.org/certification/certification-directory.dot>. “How many people use assistive devices?.” Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institue of Child Health and Human Development. N.p.. Web. 31 Mar 2014. https://www. nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/rehabtech/conditioninfo/pages/people.a spx Human Centered Design: Toolkit. 2nd ed. S.l.: IDEO, 2011. Print. Jess & Riley. Interview by Tanner Svoboda. Potential User Background. 2015. Email. “Muscular Dystrophy.” National Institute Neurological disorders and Stroke (NINDS). 8 Apr. 2015. Web. 20 May 2015. http://www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/MD/MD.htm “Myopia.” American Optometric Association. 2014. Web. 20 may 2015. http://www.aoa.org/patients-and-public/eye-and-vision-problems/glossary-of-eye- andvision-conditions/myopia?sso=y Parette, Phil, and Maricia Scherer. "Assistive Technology Use and Stigma." Education and Training in Developmental Disabilities 39.3 (2004): 217–226. Web. 9 Dec. http://www.scribd.com/doc/188341659/Parette-Assistive-Technology-Use-andStigma#scribd Perez, George. Interview by Tanner Svoboda. Industry Professional Background. 2015. Email. Pierson, John. Interview by Tanner Svoboda. Industry Professional Background. 2015. Email. Preiser, Wolfgang F. E.. Universal design handbook. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2001. Print. Ruge, Jane, and Ellen Hanson. “Swings: Not Just for Recess.” Physical Therapy & Rehab Medicine. 10 Dec. 2013. Web. 20 May 2015. "SafeT Bed." Theraposture Assistive Furniture. Theraposture Limited, 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 21 Jan. 2015. http://www.theraposture.co.uk/beds/safeT_bed Scheisser, Sarah. Interview by Tanner Svoboda. Health Care Professional Background. 2015. Email. Svoboda 70 “Types of Hearing Loss.” American Speech- Language- Hearing Association. 2015. Web. 20 May 2015. http://www.asha.org/public/hearing/Types-of-Hearing-Loss/ "Universal Design Principles." The Center for Universal Design. North Caroline State University, 1 Jan. 1997. Web. 19 Sept. 2014. http://www.ncsu.edu/ncsu/design/cud/about_ud/udprinciplestext.htm “What is Assistive Technology? How Is It Funded?.” Assistive Technology Industry Association. N.p.. Web. 31 Mar 2014. http://www.atia.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=3859>. “What is Down Syndrome?” National Down Syndrome Society. 2012. Web. 20 May 2015. http://www.ndss.org/Down-Syndrome/What-Is-Down-Syndrome/ "Who Are Physical Therapists?" APTA. American Physical Therapy Association, 18 Sept. 2014. Web. 12 Jan. 2015. http://www.apta.org/AboutPTs. Furniture References "Kids Desks." Wharfside Furniture. Wharfside, 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 10 Feb. 2015. <http://www.wharfside.co.uk/kids-furniture/desks>. "Medline Beds." Medline Product List Page. Medline Industries, 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 16 Jan. 2015. <http://www.medline.com/catalog/productlist.jsp?trail=&question=&itemId=Z05_12_02_03&addFacet=1004:MEDLINE>. "Toddler Beds." KidKraft. KidKraft, LP, 1 Jan. 2015. Web. 10 Feb. 2015. <http://www.kidkraft.com/furniture-and-decor/toddler-beds/86621>. "UPLIFT 900 Sit-Stand Desk with Premium 1." The Human Solution. Square Grove LLC, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 7 Feb. 2015. <http://www.thehumansolution.com/uplift- -bamboostand-up-desk.html>.