The BudapesT Times The BudapesT Times
Transcription
The BudapesT Times The BudapesT Times
Volume 12, Nr. 41 Budapest, 10 October – 16 October 2014 www.bzt.hu HUF 750 9 771785 110000 14041 The Budapest Times Understanding Hungary Navracsics’s past catches up with him Int erv iew of wi Ist th EX vá La C n T jos L arl Bo U ós kr SI for os, V Bu the E da m pe ai st n c M ha ay lle or ng er Denied The Budapest Times Editorial Just another weird week in the life of MSZP It’s like the Hungarian Socialist Party is trying to kill itself off with its local elections campaign. A lot was said about Ferenc Falus – who was supposed to be their “saviour candidate” – and about the Socialists’ jumbled endorsement messages for Lajos Bokros after Falus finally stepped down (it turns out he would most likely have beaten Bokros, by the way). At that point – a couple of weeks ago – one could have thought that that would be it, but MSZP then somehow managed to ridicule itself once again. This week they released a couple of videos that probably even have experienced campaign managers scratching their heads. One is about the future, where there is a Viktor Orbán Nuclear Power Plant, a Zsolt Semjén horse statue and a Pál Schmitt Museum. Apparently the last chance to avoid this fate is by voting for MSZP this Sunday. I doubt that there are many people who believe that but it could mobilise a few thousand voters. Which is exactly a few thousand more than the number of people running to the polls upon seeing the second message will be. This video shows a series called Hungarian Folktales and it includes a quote from poet Sándor Petőfi and MSZP chief József Tóbiás. The problem is that the typeface of Hungarian Folktales is practically illegible, especially with longer texts. Perhaps, it’s for the better, as the message – about power, words and truths within words – does not make much sense. According to Tóbiás, 13 October will mark the beginning of a new era for MSZP. That’s if the party still exists after the whopping it is about to receive. Attila Leitner Democracy and welfare News 4 | The Brief History of the Week – The headlines of the past seven days Politics 8 | Navracsics on knife edge as past catches up with him 10 | “Democracy and welfare” – Interview with Lajos Bokros, MOMA presi- After withdrawals from the Budapest mayoral election. the conservative Lajos Bokros is suddenly the great hope of the left parties. We asked the former minister of finance about this paradoxical situation and his strong will to oppose the Orbán 10 system in the capital. dent and Budapest mayoral candidate 15 | Saviour or chain around city’s neck? – Budapest Mayor István Tarlós, backed by Fidesz, is sitting pretty for re-election this Sunday 18 | Half a lifetime admiring Viktor Orbán – Portrait of new Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade Péter Szijjártó 20 | The current left side will never win over Viktor Orbán – Prime minister’s political method proves great 21 | Winter means death on streets again – “Seven percent of Hungarian society has a friend or a family member who is (homeless).” Business/Economy 22 | Life will still be more expensive – Reduction of utility costs and the full picture Budapest 24 | Nature fights back amid concrete jungle 26 | Legacy of Arad Martyrs passed on to today – Remembering the 1848-49 revolution 29 | There’s no recipe for tastiness – Review: Cake Shop Budapest, District V 33 | What lies beneath – Into the unknown on wings of imagination There’s no recipe for tastiness Pastel colours, cakes and soft piano music – even being an atheist I felt like I was in heaven. Cake Shop Budapest brings this place alive and offers dozens of sweet and savoury treats along with workshops, where people can learn how to prepare the heavenly “cakes” at home. Fanni Sallay, the proprietor, tells how her hobby became her profession and reveals the golden 29 rules of baking. 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 3 The Budapest Times Photos: MTI Politik 4 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times If you missed it The news that made headlines The Brief History of the Week The Budapest Times is unrivalled among English-language print publications in the capital for its coverage of the week’s most important national stories, whether they be economic, political, cultural, sporting or among the hundreds of other happenings that go on daily in a major European city. Here, in one concise package, we present some of the important and fascinating news developments of the past seven days. Early glimpse of Táncsics Prison The former Táncsics Prison, which held writer and politician Mihály Táncsics, one of the heroes of the 1848 Hungarian Revolution, opened to the public for two days this week after more than six decades. The compound in Buda Castle was returned by the United States, which owned it since 1948, in June. Táncsics was imprisoned for his radical political views in 1846 and freed on 15 March 1848, the day the revolution broke out. Lajos Kossuth, the regent-president of Hungary in 1849, was also imprisoned in the compound in 1837-40. Other statesmen and politicians jailed there included Miklós Wesselényi in 183940 and Lajos Batthyány from 1849 until his execution. Táncsics Prison is planned to be opened to the public in the near future. Mediaworks arrives with a bang Austria’s Vienna Capital Partners has set up one of Hungary’s largest media companies under the name of Mediaworks Hungary. The move follows approval from the Hungarian Competition Office and involved buying most parts of the portfolios the international media companies Ringier and Axel Springer had operated in Hungary. The Mediaworks chief executive is Attila Mihók, previously president-CEO of the daily Népszabadság, and the board comprises former top managers of Ringier and the regional management of Axel Springer in Hungary. Mediaworks Hungary’s portfolio includes 12 companies, employs 700 people and puts out 63 media products with 1.8 million readers and 1.6 online visitors, Mihók said. Included are Hungary’s largest daily Népszabadság, business daily Világgazdaság and Manager Magazin, plus eight regional dailies, sports daily Nemzeti Sport and several youth, women’s and gastronomy magazines. Mediaworks operates Hungary’s most modern printing house that publishes 600,000 copies of papers a day. Hungary flies to defence of Slovenia Hungary’s Gripen fighters started defending Slovenian airspace on Saturday, in line with an agreement signed by the two countries’ defence ministers in January. The Defence Ministry said the Gripens are sharing the task with their Italian counterparts. When Slovenia joined NATO in 2004 it opted to guarantee the security of its airspace in cooperation with its allies rather than buying fighters. Hungary, with its fleet of fourth-generation aircraft, agreed to participate. Government centralised PR office starts up The new National Communication Office has started to carry out communications-related procurement for a wide spectrum of state institutions. It takes over the public procurement tasks related to marketing, public relations, research and communication activities from central budget-funded institutions, such as ministries and directly or indirectly majority stateowned companies, according to a decree. The National Communication Office will not be responsible for the PR of independently run state administrative or institutions bodies such as 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 è 5 Photos: Olivier Despicht / Euroskills.org The Budapest Times the central bank or regulators. It will be run under the authority of the cabinet office. around the country and in neighbouring regions last year. It trains about 2,000 mothers a year in seminars and at conferences. EuroSkills medals ‘proof of success’ Donations query on red sludge anniversary Hungary has won 20 medals at EuroSkills, the largest European skills competition, in Lille, France. Hungarian skilled workers won gold in joinery, information and communication technology, surface cleaning and cleaning services, and silver in mechatronics and woodcraft technology. Overall, Hungary finished sixth in the 25-nation field. Sándor Czomba, state secretary for vocational training and the labour market, said the achievements demonstrate that the country’s vocational training system tailored to market needs is successful, and that Hungarians belong to the European elite in several crafts. Pictured is a Hungarian surface cleaning competitor and a Dutch entrant in the wall and floor tiling event. The government and opposition have marked the 4th anniversary of the red sludge disaster, with deputy Socialist leader Zoltán Gőgös saying that still no proper account has been given to the many people countrywide who donated HUF 2 billion on how exactly the money was spent. On 4 October 2010 about a million cubic metres of If you missed it toxic sludge spilled from the Ajka alumina plant reservoir, flooding Kolontár, Devecser and Somlóvásárhely villages. It killed ten people, injured over 200, destroyed 358 homes, wiped out all life in two small rivers and polluted over 1,000 hectares. Many of those who came in contact with the highly alkaline substance suffered severe burns and 120 people were hospitalised. Over 700 people suffered material damage and HUF 35 billion was spent from the central budget on compensation and reconstruction. A government spokeswoman said on Saturday it was Hungary’s worst ecological disaster caused by industrial activity. Bubi bikes catch on, come rain or shine Budapest’s public bike-sharing system has registered its 100,000th user, Budapest Transport Centre (BKK) says. The MOL Bubi system was launched on 8 September, since when 4,000 people have bought weekly or monthly passes and thousands have had a one-off rental. Rentals often exceed 5,000 a day in nice weather and there are over 3,000 users even on a rainy day, BKK said. Prize for business-with-nappies scheme Hungary’s Gazdagmami.hu, which encourages business start-ups by mothers with young children, has won the grand jury prize in this year’s European Enterprise Promotion Awards, the European Commission said. Gazdagmami.hu – which means “rich mommy” in Hungarian – helps mothers acquire the entrepreneurial skills and mind-set to start a business and make it profitable, the Commission said. The Ministry for National Economy said Gazdagmami.hu had organised presentations for young mothers in 64 communities 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 7 Politics The Budapest Times Navracsics will most likely get a reduced portfolio 8 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times Politics Navracsics on knife edge as past catches up with him A European parliamentary committee has found Tibor Navracsics suitable for commissioner but denied its support for giving the Hungarian candidate the portfolio of culture, education, youth and EU citizenship. C saba Molnár, MEP of the opposition Democratic Coalition, told reporters that the culture and education committee first decided that Navracsics was suitable for commissioner by 15-10 votes with two abstentions. A second vote to decide whether he should be given the proposed portfolio went against Navracsics 14-12 votes with one abstention, Molnár said. Andrea Bocskor, MEP of Hungary’s ruling Fidesz party and member of the culture and education committee, said it would be up to incoming European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker if Navracsics should be given a reduced portfolio or a completely different one. Bocskor said much of the criticism Navracsics had received at the hearing had been of a political nature, rather than concerning his professional experience. Those voting against the candidate mostly questioned his commitment to European values or said that his political background was not acceptable for a commissioner, Bocskor said. MEPs of the ruling Fidesz and Christian Democratic parties said Navracsics’s hearing in the European Parliament had been an “especially great success” in light of the “political and ideological attacks of recent weeks”. Their statement said: “In effect, nobody could question his experience. The leftist majority of the committee, however, proposed that the content of his portfolio should be changed, as it is expected in the case of other commissioners, too.” Hungarian Socialist MEP Tibor Szanyi said it would not be easy for Juncker to find another portfolio for Navracsics, because in most cases the hearings have been held and the majority of candidates have won support. Sources in Brussels told Hungarian state news agency MTI that Navracsics’s portfolio could be stripped of EU citizenship affairs, which could then go to Frans Timmermans, incoming vice-president of the Commission. Opposition E-PM said the European parliamentary committee’s rejection of Navracsics for the portfolio is a warning to the government that its policies run contrary to European values. E-PM’s Nóra Hajdú called on the government to “return to the European path” and nominate a “worthy and suitable” candidate. Radical nationalist party Jobbik called it “hypocrisy” that Navracsics had “tried to distance himself from the government” during his hearing when he had been a member of the government until just recently. Juncker is not planning to redistribute portfolios in the new Commission in light of the committee’s assessment of answers given by Navracsics to six questions put by its members, the president’s spokesperson said. Natasha Bertaud said Juncker welcomed that “some barriers have been removed”, such as the committee’s support for Navracsics as a commissioner. During his hearing Navracsics said he was committed to the freedom of opinions, in response to Danish conservative MEP Rikke Karlsson’s criticism that he had been a member of the Hungarian government when it approved its controversial media laws. Navracsics noted that he was a negotiator with the Council of Europe and the European Commission, helping to smooth out disputed issues, which were resolved and Hungary amended the law where necessary. He pledged that he would not be influenced by party lines in seeking cooperation during his mission. He said he believed in the basic principles enshrined in the EU’s treaty and vowed to be independent as a commissioner. Szépvölgyi Tennis Centre Whether in rain or shine – at our centre you can play in dry conditions throughout the year High-quality clay courts in a beautiful environment. (On rainy days you can make use of our hall with artificial courts). Qualified trainers are on hand to give lessons to children and adults. 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 9 P Po ol ilti itki c s The Budapest Times Interview with Lajos Bokros, MOMA president and Budapest mayoral candidate “Democracy and welfare” After a couple of withdrawals by candidates from the Budapest mayoral election this Sunday, the conservative Lajos Bokros is suddenly the great hope of the left parties. We asked the former minister of finance about this paradoxical situation and his strong will to oppose the Orbán system in the capital. What is your party actually like? The Modern Magyarország Mozgalom (Movement for a Modern Hungary, MOMA) was founded half a year ago. We define it as a middle-right party, which is conservative, free and loyal to Europe and to the nation. 10 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 This is the exact definition of a party in the Western European set of norms. This is very important because in the Hungarian politics the terms “left“ and “right“ have a completely different meaning than in Germany or Great Britain. I have been sitting in the fraction of European Conservatives and Reformists in the European Parliament for five years, along with the British Conservative Party. According to the traditions of this party and the Christian Democratic Union, we define ourselves as a conservative party, which means in terms of economy that we are unconditional supporters of the market economy, the free competition, the freedom of entrepreneurs and free trade. We welcome foreign investors and we do not think that the state needs to create workplaces. We also do not believe that the state is responsible for funding the welfare; instead we say that the individual common trade activity of the free citizens is the basis for the economic development and democracy. This is in strict contradiction with all the ideas of Fidesz, who are representing the illiberal democracy. From the point of view of the Western civilisation this state and economy model is clearly a dead end. Fidesz thinks the same about the liberal model... Although the Hungarians are a nation who loves freedom, the government interprets freedom in a collectivist, nationalist and popular way. We on the other hand believe that the freedom of individuals is important, together with the individuals’ responsibility. We do say that there is no democracy without liberalism. You rather stand for the conservative and liberal values, yet right now you seem to represent the last hope of the left wing in Budapest. Yes, this is a paradox. However, I remember that in Germany the CDU/CSU and SPD formed a common government, so the left and the middle-right wing built up a common coalition. You cannot call it scarce or unusual in Hungary when the middle right in the Western European sense of the word, what we are, and the left wing in the Western European sense of the word, which means a couple of Hungarian parties, work together for the goal that the restoration of democracy gets the highest priority in Hungary. In addition, in Germany no one questions the rule of the law and constitution. No one questions the democracy; no one questions the sovereignty of the municipal governments. In Germany no one speaks of an “illiberal democracy”. In Germany no one is building up monopolies in order to suppress the free market and competition. In Germany the foreign capital is not tracked. Photos: Nóra Halász / MTI Ja n M a i n k a The Budapest Times In Germany they do not want to hold the banks accountable, at least from the side of the government. There are some extreme parties which are sounding such tones. In Hungary though, this Russian type of authoritarian leadership is the governing power. For that reason we need a broad coalition of the democratic forces, no matter if their viewpoints are rather left or right in specific issues of professional policies. So you assume that due to the current conditions the left-oriented people in Budapest are willing to vote for a conservative or, better said, a right-oriented candidate? Absolutely. The most important task today is to restore the market economy based on free competition, the rule of law and constitution and the representative democracy. When this will be settled, the age of “boring politics“ will return in Hungary, when we can discuss about things like how much the minimal rent should be and what kind of pension system would we like to have. Was the resignation of Falus, which made you the candidate for the leftists in Budapest, agreed with you beforehand? Yes, we agreed on that when Viktor Szigetvári (of Együtt-PM) and Ferenc Gyurcsány (of Democratic Coalition) visited us at the meeting of the Modern Hungary Meeting in order to negotiate. They made it clear that they had the full consent and support of all the left parties, including the MSZP and the party group “Párbeszéd Magyarországért” (Dialogue for Hungary). On the next Monday we found out that MSZP was divided on this question, since the Budapest party council supported me but the national party council did not. Concerning the Együtt-PM formation I found out that I was only supporter by Együtt and not by Párbeszéd Magyarországért. So I cannot say that the whole left wing stood up to support me. I have to say thank you however that compared to the situation in the weeks before so many stepped forward and we could finally form a broad coalition of democrats. There are some new risks as well. Many people associate your name with the Bokros package, and think of a neoliberal, heartless, hard politician, which could mean that they say: “rather not”. This is a double-edged sword. That’s true but there are no black and white situations in politics. It’s clear that there are many left-oriented voters who think that capitalism, the free market economy and the competition is not good and similarly to Fidesz they want a sort of state socialism. However, this system has no chance to create welfare in the country. When we look closely at Fidesz, they behave like a neo-communist party. They hate the market, hate the competition and hate the foreign investors. They are practising an economic policy that makes the entrepreneurs and investors lose their trust in the system. They punish different sectors with plundering taxes. The model of this state-centred, based on monopoles, anti-competitive oligarchic order is a dead end in terms of development because it leads to isolation. It might work in Russia. Hungary on the other hand is a small economy without its own raw materials, importing energy sources and completely open, as a part of the European Union. Please explain us a contradiction. On one side there are the Hungarians who are terrified of the Orbán system due to the reasons that you described. When it comes to opting out, then they get into conflicts among themselves and commit the most serious conceptual mistakes. This was the case at the time of the elections this spring and now it is happening again. What are those destructive forces which are working in the background for the left parties especially? You are asking me a very hard question, since I am not from the left wing and I do not have any insider information. I can’t look behind the scenes and see what kind of fights are going on there - between the four parties. I think the main reason is that Hungary did not develop a social democratic set of values in the Western European sense. I see an ideological wasteland here. The Orbán government functions basically as a neo-communist party. Therefore it is quite hard to position yourself left of them. This is how it happens that in the Hungarian Parlia- Politics In brief US court rules in Hungary’s favour in Sukoró case An international arbitration court in Washington, DC, specialising in legal disputes between international investors has ruled in favour of Hungary in a case involving a cancelled casino investment project in Sukoró, National Economy Minister Mihály Varga has said. “The international court today rejected the Israeli investors’ claim and compensation demand of HUF 100 billion,” Varga said this week. “Accordingly, the Hungarian state acted lawfully in this case and did not violate any investment protection agreement or disable the investors’ operations in Hungary.” Lawyer Beatrix Bártfai, who represented the state in the case, told state news agency MTI that the court ruled Hungary had acted fully in line with the law when it cancelled the concession contract for the casino. In connection with the related land-swap case the court had reached the same position as the Kúria, Hungary’s Supreme Court, in the past by stating that the land-swap contract was illegal and therefore null and void. The Washington court’s ruling is final and cannot be appealed, she added. The plans to build a casino and resort at Lake Velence for more than EUR 1 billion were derailed after a land swap involving the site was put under scrutiny. The affair was during the term of the Hungarian Socialist Party government. The Kúria declared the contract on the exchange of farm land for prime lakefront property null and void in 2012. Vigotop, owned by Ronald Lauder and managed by Joav Blum, turned to the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes in Washington, DC, seeking damages under an international investment protection agreement between Hungary and Cyprus, where the company is registered. è 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 11 Politics In brief Nation weak if 4 million are poor: Socialists There are no strong municipalities, and there is no strong Hungary, if four million people are living in poverty, the chairman of the opposition Socialists, József Tóbiás (pictured), has said on the campaign trail for the local elections this Sunday. “This group has been left without representation and partnership and without a safety belt,” Tóbiás told a public forum in Pápa. There are 620,000 children living in mouldy and damp homes, 170,000 lack access to proper baths and another 300,000 do not get proper meals, he said, making reference to a new international study about Hungarian society. Tóbiás said it is the responsibility of municipalities to manage social tension generated by the government’s decisions. Socialist MP Ildikó Borbély Bangó said the party demands the Central Statistical Office (KSH) release figures on poverty in Hungary to the public. She noted that Eurostat, the EU’s statistical office, has already reported on the basis of data received from KSH that the number in poverty in Hungary increased 100,000 in 2013. In comparison, poverty had dropped in neighbouring countries, with the proportion to the population at 26% in Poland, 20% in Slovakia and 14.6% in the Czech Republic. The figure in Hungary is 33%, Bangó said. The Budapest Times ment there are basically only social parties. They are all more or less against capitalism, against the market and competition and believe in the almighty power of the state. There is only my party that is committed wholeheartedly to the Western European world view. Although we are not members of the Parliament. Then is it you or rather your party who will provide a united left front for Budapest now? The values that we represent are in reality not particularly popular, because many people believe that the political turn did not bring them improvement, or quite on the contrary it made them go bankrupt. They are longing for a paternalistic state of the late Kádár era. However, at the end of that era Hungary was heavily in debt and on the edge of national bankruptcy. The problem is not that we lost a million workplaces but that there were no million new workplaces created instead – ones that efficiently produce quality products for the global market. In order for that to happen an educational reform would be necessary, and a much better quality in education, free companies, which we do not have, because monopolies are being built. We would need much less redistribution of values by the state and to reduce corruption. There are many people who would like to have the same welfare here as in Germany but not the competitiveness, the pace of work and culture of work as in Germany. This is however an illusion, which is unfortunately encouraged in the people by the Hungarian socialist parties. Why are you taking up the challenge to change all that? You could just quietly continue teaching in the country or even abroad right until the end of your career. Instead of that you expose yourself and you risk that you will be scorned verbally for your unpopular views. … unfortunately not only verbally, sometimes also physically. The Orbán government made violence acceptable. The culture of the mob is the ruling power. Why are you doing this? I would not like to say big words... I would simply like to see my children 12 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 and grandchildren grow up in a happy, liveable democracy with Western European culture. I will be turning 60 this year and I could take the pension in a short time, but I would still like to contribute to the rebuilding of the Hungarian democracy before I do. So you do not think that there are any other people who would be able to fulfil this task? No way. There are many of us, in the party as well. I just spoke to Erzsébet Pusztai, to the deputy president, who is fighting side by side with me. This will not be the fight of a lonely warrior; this is not about Don Quixote de la Mancha. Everyone must fight along for the sake of civility and reason. Whoever can manage to engage in political activities beside his daily job, whoever does not have to run for earning bread all the time, has a duty to give back to his home, to his nation what he has received. Even among the left-oriented people there are many sane-minded democrats, who want to rebuild their home country. And there are always more and more of us. More and more people realise what is going on. We are choosing now between democracy and dictatorship, West and East, the rule of law and constitution and the arbitrary ruling, and the free, self-developing competitive market economy and the state-centred monopolies and oligarchs. The choice we have to make is perfectly clear. Nevertheless, most Hungarians support the current course of the country. When we continue in this direction we will surely hit a dead end. You can already feel the gap widening between Hungary and not only Germany or Great Britain, but also the three other Visegrád countries or the Baltic countries. Twenty years ago, when we have been working on the stabilisation, which we did with success and beside the resetting of the balance we laid down the foundation for the long-term growth, it was a time when Hungary was solely left behind by the Czechs or Slovenia. Today we are lagging behind Slovakia, Poland, Estonia, Latvia and in next year even Lithuania. Hungary The Budapest Times has become part of the Balkans from the point of view of the investors. Our country belongs in the same group as Romania, Serbia or Ukraine. This reflects in the risk premiums on the capital markets. Who would like to invest their capital here where there is no legal certainty? You can even compare to Romania from first-hand experience. Yes, I have been teaching in Kolozsvár (Cluj-Napoca in Romanian) at the Babes-Bolyai University for ten years. I am there for every second month. When I was working for the World Bank I advised the Romanian government for years. I have a very good relationship with a large part of the Romanian elite, top managers and scientific superpowers. There are many more free discussions there in the television; the newspapers are much more readable. In Hungary there is no press freedom, there is no equal rights provided for the churches, the civil organisations are under attack, the municipal governments are weakened. In conclusion, this is about the choice between dictatorship and democracy in Hungary. I would not like my children and grandchildren to grow up in a land that will disappear from the map of history. Right now, when for the first time in 500 years there are no Politics foreign oppressing troops in the country! We have received freedom from Mikhail Gorbachev. We are members of the European Union, which is the community of nations that are liberal and equal, and we are fighting a war of freedom against this Union – although we are constantly receiving huge sums of money from there. This is not only paradox, this is ridiculous! On 12 October the voting will also be over the communal topics. What would you do differently than the current holder of the position, István Tarlós? First of all I find it the most important matter that the capital preserves 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 è 13 Politics its assets by any means and does not let anything become centralised. Because without own assets it will have no own income, and without own income there will be no high-quality public services. The public transportation will not become any better if it will be transferred to the national government to direct. As we have already experienced in the case of schools and hospitals, centralisation only made the situation worse. When we develop something we have to make sure that it goes with good quality, cost efficient and without corruption. We do not need to repair each street each year, but when we do we need to ask a quality guarantee from the contractor that the road will serve the urban population for many years. Furthermore, in the case of every development we have to make sure that the costs of future operation will be covered. It is not enough to say that we will build a new Museum Quarter with the money from the decadent West. The question is whether we can maintain it. The maintenance is very important. In addition we have our own ideas for solving the housing shortage problem, the development of public transportation, the improvement of the health services, the preservation of the green surfaces – practically for all the areas which influence the everyday life of the citizens. In general the corruption should be fought against harder because today it is present in every level of the state, not only in the central government but also the local authorities. In terms of corruption the era before 2010 was not too perfect either... I have not said that it was better. That is partly the reason for the twothirds majority of Orbán. We can see it quite clearly that the current dictatorial rule of command is not without any precedent. The restoration of democracy is a necessary but not sufficient condition in order to eradicate corruption. How has your Budapest campaign run so far? I see it as an enrichment that I can meet with the Budapest citizens on a regular basis. This way I have the op14 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times portunity to speak to people directly and find out what matters to them. The majority of the feedback that I receive is absolutely positive. Of course there is always some dirty talk but less and less than in April. You can feel a clear change of mood in the population since then. What do you think the reason for that is? mocracy must be restored not only because we will feel better but also because democracy has a cultural value in itself. Just like the free expression of opinions, the free founding of churches, the freedom to congregate, the rule of law and constitution and the legal certainty. No company should be simply dispossessed in this country only because one or other oligarch cast his eye on it. In the summer the term “illiberal democracy“ was spread. In my view the government head has done damage to himself with that. He has unmasked his government and pulled the earth from under the feet of some of his followers. Until now I have always heard in Brussels, where I was working as a representative of the European Parliament for five years, that Viktor Orbán is the greatest democrat and only the Western press wants to spread the image that he does not believe in liberal democracy. But now he said it himself and with that he revealed himself! He brought shame to all of those people who have been protecting him so far. From now on no one will protect him any more, everyone will think three times before they raise a finger for him. Because nobody knows what foolish things he will say in his next speech – simply because he thinks that he can do whatever he wants. Finally he has told what he really thinks. Are there any chances that you will reach a common approach with the Liberals or LMP too? Did the mood of the population change for the worse? Isn’t it crazy to take such a rigid position due to personal motivation with the social background that you have just described? The citizens are mad that their tax money is used for financing party propaganda. Just take a look around the streets, what do you see among the political posters other than posters advertising parties? Where is the equality of chances here? The municipal elections might be free but they are not fair and clean for sure. According to you this happens more and more often in Hungary! We are hoping that there will be always a larger part of society which will understand that this system does not bring us material growth, no cultural development, no national reconciliation and in addition it is based upon lies. De- Probably not. They simply do not want that. Are the differences between your program and theirs so decisive? Not even that! There was a discussion between the candidates for the lord mayor position not long ago, at which beside György Magyar – the candidate of the Civilians, who has resigned for my benefit the same as Ferenc Falus – also Zoltán Bodnár, the candidate of the liberals, and Antal Csárdi, the LMP candidate, were participating. They could not answer the question what they would like to do differently, but at the same time they were convinced that they would like to continue the fight because they want to represent the only credible party. From my personal, very private point of view it is, without a doubt. As a party leader, however, I have to refrain from making such comments. We, the Movement for a Modern Hungary, are preparing not only for the elections; we would like to create a new political culture in Hungary. We will not take part in attacking the political opponents. For that reason, I will never express myself formally about anyone in a way that reminds me of the widespread mud fight which is going on in the current Hungarian political scene. I would only say one thing: I don’t say that I disagree with the assessment that you have just made here. Politics The Budapest Times Budapest Mayor István Tarlós, backed by Fidesz, is sitting pretty for re-election this Sunday Saviour or chain around city’s neck? No other city will receive such attention in the nationwide municipal elections this Sunday as the capital. The man to beat as mayor is the incumbent and Fidesz candidate István Tarlós. D a n i el H i r sch ”This is the mistake of the former city leadership, who did not do anything for the last 20 years.” This mantra is Tarlós’ favourite with the press, though at the same time he finds journalists basically annoying because he feels they – just like the left opposition – do not understand him and therefore report about him in a wrong way. Well then, who is this misunderstood István Tarlós actually? Let’s take a look at his professional career so far. Tarlós was born in 1948 in Budapest, as a son of a lawyer and an accountant, who were both working at the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, in a bourgeois family. He grew up and studied in District III, and after his military service he studied engineering in Budapest and Győr. Tarlós worked in the construction industry for 15 years and started his own engineering office together with his wife, Cecília Nagy, shortly before the change of regime. In 1989 he became a member of the liberal Alliance of Free Democrats (SZDSZ), according to him because of the “prominent government-critical tone”. After he was elected to represent the citizens in his home district many times, he entered the first free elections in 1990 in the colours of SZDSZ and Fidesz and won the position of district mayor. In 1994 he left SZDSZ due to conflict of opinions (and not least because of the coalition built with the Hungarian Socialist Party). In the same year he entered the district mayor elections as an independent candidate supported by Fidesz, and won, just like at the following two elections. In 2006 Fidesz nominated him to stand as mayor of Budapest but he lost to long-time incumbent and free democratic Gábor Demszky. In April 2010 he entered the Hungarian Parliament – still as an independent politician – as the fraction leader of Fidesz in the capital, but he left these offices after his election as mayor in October that year. He placed urban politics in front of national politics, because the first was more of a “service” while the other was “pure politics”. The man of conflicts and contradictions According to his right-wing colleagues Tarlós is a conservative realist politician (“Even two-thirds majorities do not last for ever, even Rome did not last for ever”). His critics say his methods are autocratic. In a recent interview with economic magazine Figyelő he said that upon re-election he would need to create difficulties for the national government in order to be able to continue his job. This was a reference to his conflict with è Mayoral candidates in Budapest (in alphabetical order) 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 15 Politics Never trailing in the polls, the campaign of Tarlós has lacked the political element and mainly included inaugurations and ceremonial events 16 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times The Budapest Times Chancellor János Lázár over the distribution of EU grants for development of the city. The conflict with Lázár was not a “show” but it was not “that serious as some people think” either. Weekly magazine Hetek revealed that Tarlós sees himself as humorous and frank, and this is why he makes remarkable statements, such as during the back-and-forth with Lázár recently. Tarlós is not always free of contradictions, despite his frankness: he has a good, although not conflict-free relationship with Fidesz, on the other hand he likes to argue with Lázár or Dávid Vitézy, the president of Budapest Transport Centre BKK supported by Fidesz, the interview revealed. As a “man of the city” and experienced politician he always fought for the benefit of Budapest and he did not want to get involved with national politics, but in topics like funding he could hardly avoid it. He does not worry about the election, telling Lánchíd Rádió he has never seen such a hectic and mistake-ridden campaign from the left side: “They are desperately trying to criticise everything that the present city leadership ever did. Such hysterical accusations do not even deserve any reaction.” Tarlós pointed out to state news agency MTI the things he has accomplished (Metro 4, replacing public transport vehicles, renovation of sewers, etc.) and the things he is still planning (utilisation of the gas plant in Óbuda or the train station in Józsefváros, disposing of BKK and stopping its integration in the city administration, traffic tax introduction from 2016, etc.). He admitted to Népszava that he does not have the money to complete all his plans. The renewal of Metro 3 would take about HUF 200 billion; the appropriate funding request would be submitted to the Chancellor’s Office. A mayor who supported the government could achieve more than one who is government-critical, he said. Tarlós does not take opposition seriously To the liberal opposition’s criticism about the unauthorised use of the capital’s logo on his electoral poster, Tarlós told TV channel atv: “I have been rightfully using the logo for the last four years as lord mayor, so even now I did not think that it will disturb anyone if I do so. I am surprised that we have to talk about the exterior of the electoral campaign instead of its contents.” He would not ask citizens to vote for him; instead he would ask them to consider what has been achieved in Budapest in the last four years, and which candidate knows something about urban politics. Basically he does not care about his challengers, believing they have neither the knowledge nor experience. Tarlós was criticised in 2012 for appointing the radical-right-oriented György Dörner as director of Budapest New Theatre (Újszínház) and in 2013 for naming a street after anti-Semitic writer Cécile Tormay. He was also Politics scorned due to the homeless law (“I do not represent the couple thousand homeless people, I represent 1.7 million citizens of Budapest”), the proposed expropriation of the former ballet institute building and his rough behaviour towards the press (for example the word fight with atv moderator Olga Kálmán). According to opinion research institute Medián, the familiarity of Tarlós has grown from 68% (2008) to 80% (2010) and has been around 90% ever since. His popularity was around 40% between 2008 and 2010 and increased to almost 50% by November 2010. After a collapse (March 2013: 26%) it levelled off again around 38%. Opinion research institute Ipsos puts Tarlós as clear favourite to win: 35% of respondents will vote for him, MSZP and Jobbik only earned 12%, with LMP, DK and Together Dialogue on 3% each. 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 17 18 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times Péter Szijjártó’s (left) first trip was to Slovakia, where he met Prime Minister Robert Fico Photos: Nóra Halász PBoulsiitni ek s s Politics The Budapest Times Portrait of new Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade Péter Szijjártó Half a lifetime admiring Viktor Orbán Prime Minister Viktor Orbán probably does not have any more loyal politician in his ranks than Péter Szijjártó, who at age 35 has been appointed Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade. Szijjártó was 16 years old when he first met Orbán. T he occasion was when Orbán was invited to speak at the Benedictine high school in Győr, where Szijjártó studied. For the teenager it was a key experience. He says that after listening to the speech he told his schoolmates: “It is my big dream to get to know Viktor Orbán and to work beside him.” Driven by this admiration, Szijjártó joined Fidesz in 1998. The restless and workaholic young political activist quickly became known in Győr. In 2002, aged 23, he became an MP. His career rose like a comet. He was president of Fidelitas, the Fidesz youth organisation, from 2005-9. Unbelievable pace of work His party colleagues recall a highly ambitious person who demanded the same hellish work rate from his employees as his own. For Szijjártó, a workday often began at 5am and ended at 10pm. Sometimes he asked a colleague to get out of bed at 7am on a Sunday to discuss some project or other with him. Szijjártó put everything behind his political career right from the beginning. Losing control was anathema to him. When he went to a party, which happened quite rarely, you could see him standing by shyly, drinking cola. Szijjártó neither drinks alcohol nor smokes. According to him, the smell of alcohol makes him feel sick. His favourite topics are football and politics. As a child he dreamed of becoming a footballer. Passionate futsal player This partly came true and he plays in the local futsal team (futsal is a variant of indoor soccer) at his current home in Dunakeszi, just north of Budapest. Teammates say he is fully committed and will analyse their mistakes for hours. He shares this fanatical enthusiasm for football with model and mentor Orbán. Szijjártó earned his first political successes as leader of a committee that investigated the “enrichment” of former prime minister Ferenc Gyurcsány (2004-2009). Orbán took notice. The articulate and confident Szijjártó was quickly appointed Fidesz spokesman, alongside Gabriella Selmeczi. Tamás Deutsch, a founding member of Fidesz, who discovered Szijjártó, has a very positive opinion of him. Deutsch says he is one of the most talented politicians of Fidesz’s “second generation”, beside Minister in charge of the Prime Minister’s Office János Lázár and Fidesz faction leader Antal Rogán. Deutsch values Szijjártó’s political instincts and communication skills most of all. A boy’s dream comes true Szijjártó quickly convinced Orbán of his political and rhetorical talents, and in 2010 the Prime Minister appointed him as his personal spokesman. Szíjjártó’s biggest childhood dream had come true. The political upstart became Orbán’s shadow, once accidentally taking home the PM’s suit jacket, thinking it was his own. Szijjártó spent two years as Orbán’s spokesman. In 2012 it was time for his next career move: he became president of the State Secretariat of Foreign Trade. His most important tasks were opening the Hungarian economy eastwards, namely towards Russia, Turkey, China and Asia. Szijjártó’s elevation to Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade has been expect- ed for months, with Tibor Navracsics expected to vacate the post to become a European Commissioner in Brussels. Inconsistencies around house purchase The Hungarian media has honed in on the new minister’s private life, discovering that he spent the stately sum of HUF 167 million buying a luxury villa for his family in Dunakeszi. The couple have two small children. When TV channel RTL Klub asked Szijjártó how he had that much money, he said he funded the purchase partly from own savings up to HUF 80 million and from savings of his wife and her parents (HUF 20 million) and his own parents (HUF 67 million). A little later he revised his answer: only HUF 68 million had come from his private savings, HUF 20 million from his wife and her parents, and the other HUF 79 million given by his own parents. The government-critical media and the opposition have two questions: how did he save so much money while employed only as a politician, and why were his explanations of the financing so contradictory? Obama is rebuked Szijjártó has also been sharply criticised for his first move as minister, which consisted of putting US President Barack Obama in his place. Obama had criticised Hungary among others for acting against non-governmental organisations. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a press release that tersely stated Obama’s words had “no real basis”. The short explanation said the Hungarian nation loves freedom and would not tolerate such a restriction ▶▶ Peter Bognar 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 19 Opinion The Budapest Times The current left side will never win over Viktor Orbán Prime minister’s political method proves great “I will have two main statements. The first one, Viktor Orbán is a very good politician. The second, that the current left wing will never beat him. Let me explain.” Thus begins Gábor Török, political scientist, on his blog post about the Premier of Hungary. T örök explains in his analysis that he thinks lots of things about Orbán, like many people in the country, and over the years he tried to understand Orbán’s political thinking and methods, but his conclusion was this: Viktor Orbán is a terrific politician, and nobody from the current pool of rival politicians will defeat him. He lists two possible solutions to this, the methods of the opposition and Orbán’s political method. “If Gyurcsány did not win in 2004, if Őszöd did not happen, if Gyurcsány resigned in autumn 2006, if we had an early election, etc. things would have been different.” He explains that if the other parties acted differently, Orbán may not have been this successful. And apart from the clumsiness of the opposing parties, Török believes that Orbán’s political method over the past 25 years has been far better than anybody else’s. “They say that all of Orbán’s luck in politics comes from his political method; that he first got rid of his enemies in his own parties, and later in the whole country. This means: Orbán can reign because he builds dictatorship everywhere. This argument is of course impossible to win, because those who believe in this will not care if others shout about dictatorship in the media, or if other parties want to win over this dictatorship in a free electoral system. “Viktor Orbán really loves power. Especially to use it. He does a lot of things for this, to get hold of power, and keep it. He does almost everything that he can do in democratic circumstances. He does not like gestures, 20 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 temperance, and liberality. As he him- Maybe he will not wait for this, and self says: he kills the enemy, if he has resign earlier, but this will end once.” However, Török also states that the the chance. “Those who believe that he is in a current left wing cannot defeat Orbán leading position because he makes now, unless they too understand how himself unbeatable with his adminis- the political pendulum works in Huntrative tools, knows nothing about his gary. As right now, it is only him, who secret. Because he has no secret: he is understands that it is not himself that the only one in the country who real- he has to convince about his ideas, but ly understands this game, and is most the electors. And unless the opposition realises this, they have no chance to conscious in how he plays it.” FW Török says that whatever people take over. think, Viktor Orbán is one of the biggest figures in ELEBRATES UNGARIAN Hungarian politics since the end ASHION ESIGN AND ULTURE of communism. A Showcase of Talented Local Designers and their Creations Still he believes that it is ineviCome and enjoy, in the company of your NAWA friends, a morning fashion show by some of the most promising young Hungarian designers presented by table the prime beautiful models and accompanied by music. minister will fail Local Hungarian fashion designers including Zagabo Fashions, Ille/Olla in the future. This Designs and Barbara Leber will display some of their new autumn/winter is because he will collections. Jewelry designer, Ivonne Hercia with Latin American and European never build a real cultural roots, will present her beautifully mystical and unique pearl and precious metal jewelry. dictatorship. You will have a chance to meet the designers and perhaps even make plans to “Popularity will update your wardrobe for the coming season. fade once, the To make our get together even more special, two gifted, up and coming guitarmistakes will turn ists, Zsurgy Gergely and Varga Bálint from The Conservatorium will entertain into consequencus with some enchanting melodies. es, the mood will You won’t want to miss it! change, time will WHEN: Tuesday, October 14th run out... And then he will not WHERE: Radisson Blu Beke Hotel be protected by 1067 Budapest Teréz körút 43 the created elecTIME: 10 am to noon toral rules, or the thoroughly conNAWA MEMBERS: free structed media GUEST FEE: 2,000 HUF background, just like it did not save For more information contact [email protected] anybody before. NAWA C F D H C Society The Budapest Times “Seven percent of Hungarian society has a friend or a family member who is (homeless).” Winter means death on streets again The warm autumn has masked the fact that the time which social workers consider as the start of the winter homeless crisis period is only a month away. U nited Nations’ estimates are that 8,000 people live on the streets of Budapest and another 22,000 nationwide. The numbers prove that homelessness is not something politicians can avoid, and a recent conference looked at the problem. The Friedrich Ebert Foundation together with Political Capital Policy Research and Consulting Institute, numerous sociologists, social workers and politicians tried to find the answers to the most urgent questions. Péter Krekó, the director of Political Capital, said that while homeless people are often treated as scapegoats in today’s politics, their perception by society is quite different. He said the majority of society is much more positive and helpful towards them than the behaviour of some leading politicians would suggest. His Political Capital colleague, Attila Juhász, supported this view with excerpts from a recent study. More than 50% of the respondents would rather help than punish. “We have to make a differentiation between homeless people, people who do not have a flat and people who do not have a home, in order to be able to understand the problem,” Juhász said. Péter Győri from Menhely Alapítvány (Shelter Foundation), the largest organisation helping homeless in Budapest, agreed: not having an apartment does not necessarily mean that someone becomes homeless but it is a fundamental part of the problem, and thereby it belongs to the solution as well. Győri said: “Since the political turn there is virtually no social housing, so whoever gets in trouble paying the rent or the instalments of the loan does not really have alternatives.” It was a fact that there were many people in Budapest today who were employed but they still had to make a choice: food or rent? To call attention to the dramatic shortage in affordable housing, about 60 activists and supporters of A Város Mindenkié (The city belongs to everyone), have occupied an empty former private sanatorium in District VI. The building has been owned by an offshore company for many years. “There could be some social housing created here, which is so urgently needed,” the group argues. Győri said politics has the main responsibility: “But here we are facing another round of municipal elections without the candidates having any plan for the housing problem.” It was usual that the district and city leaderships blamed each other without looking for a solution together. And this was why accommodation for homeless people was full virtually all year. Győri said he is sure that the districts would be able to provide affordable housing. Endre Hann of research organisation Medián added: “Seven percent of Hungarian society has a friend or a family member who is living on the street.” These are issues that should have been addressed in the second part of the conference, but sadly the politicians present used the opportunity instead to present themselves in a positive light and their opponents in a negative light. Municipal elections will be held this Sunday. Friedrich Ebert Foundation and Political Capital invited Zoltán Bodnár from the Hungarian Liberal Party; Péter Juhász, the founder of Milla, who is the candidate from the Together-Dialogue Party for District V; Ágnes Kunhalmi, president of the Hungarian Socialist Party in Budapest; Ágnes Osztolykán from green party LMP; and the Budapest mayor candidate of the far-right party Jobbik, Gábor Staudt. Beside proposing only too general solutions (“There must be more affordable housing made available, with costs taken over by the state from the homeless”: Juhász) and prevention measures (“It’s cheaper to save a family that could not afford its rent for the last three months than to get the same family out of the trap of homelessness”: Kúnhalmi), the participants mostly only talked past each other. There was no real discussion between the politicians. Only Osztolykán opposed Staudt when he opined that “the majority of homeless people want to improve their situation, but there is a smaller renitent part who simply do not want to be helped”. For them, Staudt would advise “hard treatment”. Osztolykán, a political scientist, responded in a very clear way: “When someone says ‘He does not want to be helped’ it makes me furious.” She pointed out, to applause, that the homeless problem is a very complex issue that cannot be solved by keywords. Unfortunately this was the only useful contribution from the politicians participating. Instead of discussing with each other and the many professionals present how the growing problem might be solved, they were campaigning. It appears they are unwilling to act. The strategy of “if I don’t see it, it doesn’t exist”, as shown by the criminalisation of homelessness in the city centre, will claim human lives again this winter. ▶▶ Elisabeth Katalin Grabow 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 21 Economy The Budapest Times Reduction of utility costs and the full picture Life will still be more expensive Luckily we will put the municipal elections behind us this Sunday. Then the politicians will not feel obliged in the next three and half years to stuff our pockets full. Maybe this relaxed period will help the economy to revive for the long term. T he two-thirds majority has the clear advantage that the government rules communication across the country. At least it does not come to a battle of wild promises that have hardly anything to do with reality. Fidesz-KDNP only has to take care not to promise all sunshine and happiness yet. Although even that would be no problem because the voters do not see any other political option... Breaking down annual utility cost-cutting for stronger effect in media They are raving about the settlement with the banks that will save about a million people from the trap of for- eign-currency loans. A lot of people will only get confused once the loan is converted to forints, inclusive the interest rate for forint loans – but that will only happen in the first semester of 2015. Plus there is constant communication about the policy of utility cost-cutting. These measures are being introduced this year divided over three months. This way the Fidesz-supportive media have the chance to praise this third round of the welfare policy not once but three times. The previous utility cost-cuttings of around 10%, which were executed in one single step, clearly received less media attention than the reductions that are happening this year: 6.5% on natural gas, 5.7% on electricity and 3.3% on cen- tral heating. The gas prices were cut on 1 April, which might have been the end of the heating season but was an ideal date directly before the parliamentary elections. The electricity prices were cut next on 1 September, and one month later and just 11 days before the municipal elections the central heating tariffs were also reduced. This way both elections could have a slice from the cake of utility cost-cutting. 2010-2013: general inflation undermines effect of utility cost reduction If the politicians would rely more on the data and conclusions of the Cen- Hungarian Heritage House, 1011 Budapest, Corvin tér 8. www.dancetheatre.hu | info: (+36 1) 201 4407 Kostenfreie Nummer: (+36 80) 10 44 55 Saturday, 11 October 8 p.m. Hungarian National Dance Ensemble Living Martin Archive – Kalotaszeg /Dance workshop after the performance/ 22 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 Economy The Budapest Times tral Statistical Office (KSH) in their speeches, they might be closer to reality. The KSH publishes a lot of indicators about consumer prices, so it is possible to compare prices even in the distance of decades. Before the political turn there was nothing to highlight; let’s just mention that HUF 5,000 was a fortune at that time, a tram ticket costing around HUF 2-3 and a good imported Czech beer HUF 14-18. Since nowadays Fidesz likes to emphasise how great the government is doing in reducing prices, we should compare specific prices from 2010 and 2013 (the yearly average prices for 2014 are of course not available yet). The consumer price index was around 6.4% at the beginning of 2010 and it decreased to 3.1% by the summer of 2011. After that – note under the leadership of the “price-breaker” Orbán government! – it increased back to 6.6% until September 2012, no matter that the inflation was practically brought down to zero by the policy of utility cost-cutting by the end of 2013. KSH calculated an average price decline in the last four years of around 20% for an average Hungarian household. Although you should not be shocked to learn that eggs, cheese and oil cost about one fifth more than four years ago. The explosion in the prices of sugar and cigarettes, however, exceeded the tolerance threshold of the population, so shopping tourism into the neighbouring countries began to flourish, just like the black markets. In the meanwhile the price corrections of fuel sold at service stations happening even several times a week are unnerving the millions of drivers; the bottom line is that owners of cars with petrol engines are paying about one fourth more than four years ago, while diesel owners pay about a good one third more. Wood prices increase further on, unaffected In the same time, between 2010 and 2013, average gross salaries rose by about 14% in the Hungarian economy, coming to about HUF 230,000 a month. The net amount that remains in the pockets of full-time employees is on average around HUF 150,000; the increase here kept up with the rise of gross salaries in terms of percentages, and if we express it in absolute value we would find HUF 20,000 more in purses after the monthly payment on average. Unfortunately the average indicators do not show that according to the deep sociological studies around 60% of people are actually doing worse than before. For these families inflation takes away the surplus amount of money. These are families who can rarely enjoy the larger price advantage of household items planned for long-term use (such as fridges and LCD-TVs) due to their limited budget. For these people wood and propane-butane gas are the most commonly used energy sources, not electricity, central heating and natural gas, where Fidesz announced the end of “extra profits”. No wonder that the prices of these energy sources on the market are growing further, uninfluenced by the intention of the government. However, the real joke in the official KSH statistics is that the prices of electricity and natural gas behave quite differently than the Fidesz publicity would have us believe. Fidesz showed a statistic during the electoral campaign according to which people only have to pay three-fourths of the price for electricity that they had to pay under the social-liberal government. KSH calculated though that two rounds of electricity price-cutting with a nominal 20% decrease only reached a real decrease of 6% if compared against the prices of 2010, and a cubic metre of natural gas became even more expensive! (To be correct it should be noted that the second round only came into effect in November 2013, therefore the results will only be reflected by the middle of 2014. For the full picture we also have to see that electricity and gas became more expensive under the rule of Fidesz – it might be that the Orbán government did not have the energy in the beginning to take on the fight with the multinationals, since they had their hands full with the expulsion of the International Monetary Fund and weakening the forint.) Untouched middle class Those members of the middle class who are benefitting from Fidesz’s tax policy might read all this with understandable reservation. If someone, regarded as a politically welcome citizen, is taking home HUF 50,000, 70,000 or even 100,000 more each month, he might not be (financially) upset by the introduced price increases. However, even these people will notice that today they are clearly paying more for everyday goods than they did in 2010. ▶▶ Rainer Ackermann New ways in medical science Seeing the invisible: Somatoinfra sees inside the body It is the desire of both the doctor and the patient to see the processes happening inside the patient’s body. Radiation caused by X-rays prevents its use for multiple examinations; CTs and MRIs are very expensive and only provide still images. A Hungarian invention, however, reached the point where it should be included among the public health screening procedures. At the second global forum of the World Health Organisation (WHO), Dr. Mihály Szacsky and the team of developers received a prominent spot with their modern imaging technology. The WHO recommended that it be involved in the preventive procedures of the future because it is fast, reliable, comfortable, cheap and does not have side effects. Similar to infrared images, the machine essentially provides feedback about the body’s energy utilisation on a photonic level. With the help of this special, functional anatomic image, diagnostics, tumours, unseen pain centres, hidden inflammations and malfunctioning organs become immediately visible. The method has already made its debut in Hungary and it proved to be a great success. As someone put it: the diagnostic tool of the future, already available today. Further information: www.pannonpalatinus.hu/somatoinfra University of Technology, Nature and Sport Science Association Dr. Mihály Szacsky Bertalan Lajos street 24, District XI, Budapest Email: [email protected], Tel.: (+36-1) 209-9176 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 23 Diplomacy 24 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times D i pPl oo ml iatci ky The Budapest Times Nature fights back amid concrete jungle An inner-city “park” now finally deserves the name after being converted from an unprepossessing grey and concrete nowhere-land into a greener modernised and landscaped area. A ngyal István Park, on the traffic-trams-metro corner of District IX’s Üllői út and Ferenc körút, was hardly a spot to sit around and rest in, despite being just metres from the architecturally splendid Museum of Applied Arts. Now the park has been refurbished with the support of the Municipality of Budapest and under the Swedish Sustainability Program, supported by the Swedish Embassy, Business Sweden and Swedish companies operating in Hungary. Angyal István Park has become a “modern social place” with free internet coverage. The reconstruction was to create a biodiverse, sustainable park. To enrich the ecological and visual diversity of the city landscape, almost 20 domestic, drought-tolerant and city-proof plants with energy-efficient maintenance have been planted. A paper-plane installation is a memorial to István Angyal, a hero of the 1956 Uprising. The plane displays a few lines from his last letter to a friend. A Wi-Fi hotspot has been installed to allow anybody with a suitable device – such as a smartphone or tablet – to use the internet for free. Easy-to-understand information signs help those getting acquainted with the world of hi-tech. Anna Boda, Chargé d’affaires a.i. of the Embassy of Sweden in Budapest, said: “I am especially happy to see that this park has been refurbished in the spirit of sustainability, thanks to the unique cooperation between the Hungarian and the Swedish state and private companies. This is another extraordinary step towards a greener and more sustainable urban lifestyle.” Deputy Mayor of Budapest Dr. Gábor Bagdy said: “The management of the city has created a vision of a city that is as green, friendly, and beautiful as can be. It is important to us to make sure that the people living here and foreigners alike see Budapest as a city sizzling with social life and developing dynamically. I hope that the renovation of Angyal István Park is another step in this direction.” The main goal of the Swedish Sustainability Program is the dissemination of an environmentally conscious way of life and thinking, and the establishment of a sustainable urban environment. The first result of the cooperation was the first eco-playground in Hungary, on Margaret Island, in 2011. The following year, the walk and park at the Buda end of Chain Bridge were renovated, and now a self-service bicycle repair station, and an information and meeting point await those riding bicycles at the northern corner of Vérmező, the large park area outside Déli rail station. The major partners of the Swedish Sustainability Program are Electrolux, Ericsson, Saab and Sigma Technology. Additional partners are HAGS, Metropol, Skanska and Volvo Autó Hungária. Swedish-Hungarian Smart Forum: www.shsmartforum.hu Chargé d’affaires a.i. of the Embassy of Sweden in Budapest Anna Boda and Deputy Mayor of Budapest Dr. Gábor Bagdy 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 25 Diplomacy 26 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times The Budapest Times Remembering the 1848-49 revolution Legacy of Arad Martyrs passed on to today B u d a pe s t In brief sponsored by The national flag was hoisted and lowered to half-mast on Monday in a military salute to commemorate the leaders of Hungary’s revolution and freedom fight who were executed by Austria in 1849. 6 October was declared a national day of mourning in 2001. S tate commemorations on the square before Parliament were attended by President János Áder, Defence Minister Csaba Hende, Interior Minister Sándor Pintér, Chief of Staff Tibor Benkő and members of the diplomatic corps. The names of the 13 Martyrs of Arad were read out loud in tribute. The dignitaries then moved on to pay their respects by the memorial for Lajos Batthyány, the prime minister of Hungary’s first independent government, nearby. Later in the day, Áder told a commemoration ceremony that the martyrs had passed on to us “a legacy of freedom, faithfulness and courage”. Their sacrifice, together with ideals of freedom, independence and development “have been fired into the memory of our political nation”, the president added. Those values could not be questioned because Hungarians “will always find a way to achieve their freedom. ... That love of freedom is one of the most beautiful and most valuable components of our being Hungarian”. József Tóbiás, leader of the opposition Socialists, said Hungary must progress on the path of freedom in order to be independent and successful. “When we remember the martyrs, we must remember how fragile and precious freedom can be,” he said. “We must not waste it and must not give it up for anyone. … If we surrender any of the rights that constitute freedom, the rest will be taken away from us by despotism.” Ferenc Gyurcsány, leader of the opposition DK, said 6 October is a memorial day for self-sacrifice and the progress that this sacrifice enables. The sacrifice of the generals in Arad and their supporters was an inspiration for modesty and work today, and it was the democrats’ task to work on fulfilling the dreams of the 48-ers. Lajos Bokros, leader of the Modern Hungary Movement and the left-of-centre opposition’s candidate for mayor of Budapest, said 6 October is a time to remember all who fought against suppression and for the freedom of the Hungarian people over the centuries. After placing wreaths on the Batthyány memorial, he said he and his supporters are fighting as democrats against “a despotic dictatorship”. Industry gathering fetes Liszt Ferenc Budapest Airport won a prominent marketing award at the largest and most important annual global gathering of the aviation industry, the World Routes conference, in Chicago recently. The operator of Liszt Ferenc International Airport triumphed in its category in 2011, was voted among the best in 2012 and was ranked 20th from several hundred airports worldwide this year, receiving the “highly commended” award. Executives use the three-day event to decide on potential new routes planned for the near future. A highlight is an award gala, where airline representatives assess the performance of airports in various areas, including innovative marketing tools, market research, traffic forecasts and other services supporting airline operations. Steadfast route development efforts have seen passenger traffic at Budapest Airport increase 7.4% year-to-date until 31 August, with total traffic projected to reach an all-time high by year’s end. The appearance of four new airlines and the launch of nine new flights in 2014 contributed to the growth, with Emirates set to launch a daily flight between Dubai and Budapest. “We are thrilled at being recognised for one of the most widely acclaimed industry achievement awards,” said Kam Jandu, chief commercial officer for Budapest Airport. “The award is testament to the non-stop hard work of the great team we have working for us. We strongly believe in our innovative marketing activities, the messages they carry and how this translates into real business results. In spite of losing a national airline two years ago, we are on course to break our all-time passenger record in 2014.” 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 27 The Budapest Times 4th DWC OktOberfest Saturday, 18 October from 5pm Festival tent at the Batthyány Square property of the Maltese Charity Service (Bem rakpart 28, District I.) Original Bavarian festival beer, Haxen (roasted pork knuckle), cold Bavarian culinary treats and other delicacies. Responsible for the authentic beer-tent atmosphere will be once again the Tirol-based band “de Drei”. Lieselore Cyrus Patron: Germany’s Ambassador to Hungary Guests of honour: former president of Hungary Pál Schmitt Prof. Dr. Árpád Kovács President of the Budgetary Council Entry fee varies between HUF 3,000 and 12,500 depending on DWC membership and the type of meal chosen. In association with: Further information and registration: +36-1-312-1123, [email protected], www.dwc.hu or on the Facebook page of the DWC (Deutscher Wirtschaftsclub Budapest-German Business Club Budapest). Review The Budapest Times Review: Cake Shop Budapest, District V There’s no recipe for tastiness Pastel colours, cakes and soft piano music – even being an atheist I felt like I was in heaven. Cake Shop Budapest brings this place alive and offers dozens of sweet and savoury treats along with workshops, where people can learn how to prepare the heavenly cakes at home. Fanni Sallay, the proprietor, tells how her hobby became her profession and reveals the golden rules of baking. L isa Wei l B ehind the counter the confectioners are busy in their white gloves mixing, kneading and decorating. There are cakes, muffins, biscuits, cakepops, meringues, macarons, cupcakes and even more things behind the glass; for a sweet tooth, even looking at them makes your mouth water. Besides all kinds of desserts, there are quiche, bagels and sandwiches. The menu will be widened with more baked goods and salads soon. Hot and cold drinks to enjoy with your cake range from coffee to cola, and you can even buy part of the interior decoration: the ornate cups, cans and plates displayed on the shelves. I would like to state this absolute truth about the Cake Shop right away: everything looks pretty and tastes great here. By the way, everything is handmade, the ingredients do not contain V. Zoltán u. 16 (at Szabadság tér) Reservation: +36 1 331 4352 Arany Kaviar Restaurant Thinking Relocation? Think Interdean. Tel. 888-6750 [email protected] “We make it easy” Relocation Immigration è Moving Real Estate For sale OR For rent! In XII. Béla Király street (near the German School) separated villapart in 3000 sqm nature park for rent. 200 sqm, 4 rooms+hall, 2 baths, 200 sqm terrace, 300 sqm garden, sauna, garage. South-facing, panoramic views. Feng-shui biohuse. Pets are allowed. Rent: 1500 EUR/month. (Selling price: to be discussed) Call (evenings or mornings): +36/ 20 267-4018. Lunchtime Russian Bistro in our garden area: Menu for 3.900 Ft From 12pm to 3pm! 1015 Budapest, Ostrom u. 19 Open: 12pm-3pm, 6pm-12am Monday closed! Tel.: (+36 1) 201 6737 www.aranykaviar.hu 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 29 Photos: Nóra Halász Review 30 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 The Budapest Times The Budapest Times any artificial preservatives and the wonderful rainbow colours are also natural. Finally, no matter what diet you are following, you will surely find something to nibble on. “We take it very seriously that we should be able to offer something for everyone,” says Sallay, the head of the Cake Shop and inventor of the concept. “For example we use coconut milk for the coconut cake so that lactose-sensitive people can safely eat this cake. For similar reasons there are always vegetarian varieties among the offered quiches and sandwiches too. Even people allergic to gluten do not have to miss out on our cakes.” Review Fanni Sallay Perfectionism and love I got to try the gluten-free (or in other words: grain-free) cakes via the strawberry-poppy seed cake. It does not contain any flour; the base is a juicy mouse of poppy seeds crowned by a layer of fresh strawberry cream. The cake tastes really wonderful; not too heavy and not too sweet. No wonder, since Sallay’s standards are high. As soon as she notices a mistake, she acts. She changes the empty honey container on our table right away, and she inspects the birthday cake for a client one last time before it is collected. She does this not because she is pushy or strict but because quality matters for her. “I am not a classic chef, I need partners,” Sallay says, while she looks towards her team of bakers and waitresses respectfully. Sallay is only 27 years old and a mother of three children of two, four and six years. She needs good management skills for both her private and her professional life. Sallay loves her Cake Shop and baking very much – although she only began baking as a hobby. Already as a child she liked to watch her mother bake, she decorated cakes and she learned the right technique of kneading from her grandmother. As a young woman, she decided to go in the commercial direction, and studied economics. However, she decided to make her favourite spare-time activity her profession, and started to bake for a café in District II until more and more patisseries and cafés began asking for her desserts. She also began to work for and counsel catering companies such as Tchibo and McCafé. “The Cake Shop is actually the smallest part of my work but it’s my favourite job with which I still have a lot of plans,” Sallay tells us. “To be honest, I cannot fit in here everything that I would like to do.” Baking with intuition However, many things do fit in – among others there are regular workshops. These are usually organised in Hungarian, with some in Danish and French. If you are interested in a workshop in English or German, it can be arranged. “Our team does not consist of skilled workers and trained pastry chefs. Many have similar backgrounds as I do. They have studied something completely different but never lost their love for baking and have preserved their intellect too. Thanks to their studies and training many of my employees speak several languages.” The topic of the workshops changes from month to month. In the summer, feasts such as weddings and birthday parties for children are on the program, while in autumn the workshops are oriented more to10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 è 31 Review The Budapest Times wards seasonal baking. If you have further ideas for workshop topics, Sallay and her team would be happy to hear them. The young mother says the process of the workshops is uncomplicated and people-oriented. “There is no educational lesson, we rather work together on something. In our small groups of eight participants we share the method ’rules instead of recipes’, which I developed and we use in Cake Shop. “These 28 golden rules are about paying attention rather to ratios than measurements in order to create perfect dishes, which is especially important in baking.” She offers the example of a chocolate cake that they want to prepare in a gluten-free way. Instead of removing the ingredients that contain gluten from the original recipe, she takes the rest of the ingredients and combines them in a new way, adding further ingredients that match (for example almonds, honey, mint) to create something completely new. Sallay would like to detail this “science of baking” in a book she is writing. Don’t expect a usual recipe book. The focus will be cooking and baking with intuition, with the help of the golden rules. Cakes for everyone If you are longing for sweets, you can have your own individual cake customised at the Cake Shop, for any occasion. “It does not matter if someone has special wishes or, quite to the contrary, no specific idea, but at least knows in what direction the tastes should be heading – we will think about it and create something nice together. Of course, the more time we have, the better, but it also happened already that we had to conjure a birthday cake within half an hour.” Sallay and her team would never accept such an order if they knew they would be unable to fulfil it due to lack of time. Ideally they need about a week for planning and realisation. They plan to open three more Cake Shops in the next five years. One thing is for sure: they will guarantee heavenly delights for their clients. Cake Shop Budapest József Attila utca 12, District V Open Monday to Friday 8am-8pm, Saturday 10am-8pm, Sunday 10am-6pm. Tel.: (+36) 30 721-0773 www.cakeshop.hu 32 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 Workshops in October 12 October: Dessert table inspired by pumpkin 19 October: World of the strudel 26 October: Sweet Halloween To apply for the workshops, phone (+36) 30 7210773, (+36) 30 303-1407), email at cakeshop@ cakeshop.hu or Facebook message. They begin at 6pm. The fee is HUF 8,500. The Budapest Times W h at l i e s b e n e at h The Capital with the Eye of an Expat Into the unknown on wings of imagination You would think that after seven years in a sometimes volatile but never boring relationship, I would have glimpsed, even if not fully understood, most facets of Budapest life. Seven years is long enough to get to know a city, its museums, its theatres, its bars and restaurants, its cafés, its libraries. Of course, some of these often change their names and offers; that’s to be expected. But when it comes to the more established establishments, even if I’ve not set foot in every one of them, their names should register if mentioned. I thought I was particularly up to date on my markets, having been to all I’d heard of at least once, if not repeatedly. So it was with some surprise that I learned of one I had missed: Bakancsos utcai piac in District XVII. I have been to Örs vezér tere, the terminus of the No. 2 metro line, on numerous occasions. I’ve been mildly curious about the buses that leave from there, too, but I’ve never had reason to get on one. Any place past Örs vezér was a mystery, a part of the city I’d never seen. Last weekend though, I ventured forth. The instructions were clear: Örs Vezér térről 67-es busz Szürkebegy utcai megálló (uszoda utáni 2. megálló) – take the 67 bus and get off two stops after the swimming pool. The 25-minute trip threw up some wonderful place names that both simplified and confused. Uszoda (swimming pool) said it all, but what of 513 utca? What’s that about? What’s so significant about the number 513? I checked on Google maps and saw there is a large square area in the XVIIth where all the streets are numbered in the 500s (from 500 to 545) and at its centre sits 525 tér. There’s a near-perfect symmetry in the layout of the streets that suggests it’s a planned neighbourhood, and if viewed from the air I imagine it would look quite impressive. I now want to go see for myself. The market itself is set in what for all the world looks like a piece of wasteland in the middle of a residential neighbourhood. We didn’t have to worry about finding our way: it seemed like everyone on the bus was heading in the same direction. Inside a walled area, hundreds of vendors had laid blankets on the ground or set up tables and were selling their wares. Clothes, shoes, china, cutlery, books, records, photographs, pictures, vases, statues, light bulbs – anything and everything you might ever want or need was there for the finding. And, unlike the city-centre markets such as Petőfi Csarnok or the better-known suburban market Esceri piac, both of which are common tourist haunts, the prices in Bakancsos were reasonable. Very reasonable. Flea markets like this are wonderful places to take a trip into a parallel universe. I lost some time looking at framed portraits, so engaged was I in imagining the lives of those in the pictures. Leafing through autograph books I was struck again by the stories that lay behind each and every item on sale. If only they could talk. It’s a mecca for anyone with an imagination. The old adage that one man’s trash is another man’s treasure is so true. People were buying the most unlikely things: why would you buy a wedding photo of total strangers? Trying to figure out why others had bought what they had was nearly as much fun as sifting through the remnants of bygone eras in search of something I didn’t know that I couldn’t live without myself. Open Friday to Sunday 6am-1pm, it’s a grand way to pass a Saturday morning. Mary Murphy is a freelance writer and public speaker who is constantly on the look-out for new markets. Do share. Read more at www.stolenchild66.wordpress.com Photo: bakancsospiac.hu M ary Murphy 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 33 Panorama To advertise in The Budapest Times call +36 1 453 0752 The Budapest Times Where to go? – Music mix Liszt Ferenc Memorial Museum: Saturday chamber music recitals in museum with reconstruction of the composer’s last Budapest flat containing his original instruments, furniture, books, scores, personal objects and memorabilia. District VI, Vörösmarty u. 35. www.lisztmuseum.hu Budapest Congress Centre: Occasional pop and ballet shows. District XII, Jagelló út 1-3. www.bcwtc.hu Budapest Jazz Club: Regular programming of mostly Hungarian jazz. District XIII, Hollán Ernő u. 7. www.bjc.hu The Budapest Times ISSN 1785-1106 Published by: BZT Media Kft. 1073 Budapest, Erzsébet körút 43-49. (Corinthia Hotel Budapest) Publisher: Jan Mainka Subscriptions, sales and editorial offices Tel: 4530752, 453-0753 Fax: 240-7583 E-mail: [email protected] Internet: www.budapesttimes.hu Managing Editor: Attila Leitner News Editorial: Elisabeth Katalin Grabow Writers/editors: Christopher Maddock, Mary Murphy, Thomas Pernecker, Daniel Hirsch, Réka Hamvas, Fruzsina Wilheim, Mátyás Csikós Translator: Edina Nagy Letters to the editor: We welcome letters to the editor, analysis and opinion pieces. The views expressed by external contributors do not necessarily reflect those of this newspaper. Advertising and Sales: Jan Mainka, Péter Szentesi Classifieds & Distribution: Ildikó Varga Advertising design: Zsuzsa Urbán Advertising E-mail: [email protected] Printed by: Pharma Press Kft. Newsstand Distribution: Hungaropress Kft., 1097 Budapest, Táblás u. 32 Subscriptions: Call 453-0752 or e-mail [email protected] Price In forints In euros (to EU) 6 months 16,000 120 1 year 30,000210 Pdf/1 year 14,00050 The Budapest Times is the partner newspaper of Budapester Zeitung Where can I buy The Budapest Times? You can buy our paper at a number of newsstands, especially the ones in shopping malls. Here are a few examples: Mammut 2, Budagyöngye, Rózsakert Center, WestEnd, Aréna Plaza, Arkád, Mom Park, Alle Center, Campona and Köki Terminál. You can also visit our office to purchase a copy of the current or a previous edition at Corinthia Hotel Budapest am Erzsébet krt. Outside the capital The Budapest Times is only available via subscription. 34 10 October 2014 | Nr. 41 Subscription fees of The Budapest Times Postage... Period ...to Hungary ... to EU ... to outside EU ½ year HUF 16,000 EUR 120 EUR 150 1 year HUF 30,000 EUR 210 EUR 260 EUR 50 EUR 50 PDF 1 year HUF 14,000 Walk elegantly throughout the year: with shoes from Dinkelacker. www.heinrich-dinkelacker.de Comfortably through autumn. Let it blow, let it rain, with our shoes nothing stands in your way. You can learn about and, of course, purchase our shoes conveniently in our Budapest showroom (1225 Budapest, Március 15. u. 1-3). You can also take a look in our shoe workshop and get a glimpse of the unique handcrafting of our special shoes. The showroom is open Monday to Friday from 8 to 2.30pm, or by prior appointment (Tel.:+36-1-207-6185 or mobile: +36-20-537-8683). Ms. Andrea Nyerges is happy to advise you in English and show you through our workshop.