Finance Committee Agenda/Packet 08/15/2011
Transcription
Finance Committee Agenda/Packet 08/15/2011
LEWISTON FINANCE COMMITTEE MEETING Agenda Finance Committee meeting, Monday, August 15, 2011 at 5:15 p.m. in the Administrator’s Conference Room, Lewiston City Hall. 1. Call meeting to order. 2. Review minutes of previous meeting dated August 1, 2011. 3. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-038 for the Inventory Management contract. 4. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding the purchase of computer/server hardware and installation for the City IT Department. 5. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-032 on the Lincoln Street and Locust Street Intersection Improvements. 6. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding Change Order #2 to the contract with Gendron & Gendron on the Lincoln Street Reconstruction Project. 7. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-053 on a Fuel Dispenser/Fuel Tracking System. 8. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-046 for contracts for Snow Plowing and Removal at various municipal parking lots and garages. 9. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-049 for one (1) ½ ton 4X4 Pick Up Truck. 10. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-050 for one (1) ¾ ton 4X4 Pick Up Truck. 11. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-051 for one (1) ¾ ton Van. 12. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding award of Bid 2011-054 for Plow Cutting Edges. 13. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding ratification of award of #2 Heating Oil. Bid awarded by the Purchasing Agent on 8/10/11. 14. Recommendation from the Purchasing Agent regarding the extension of the contract for the purchasing of road salt. 15. Other Business 16. Adjourn FINANCE COMMITTEE LEWISTON, MAINE Minutes of August 1, 2011 PRESENT: Michael Marcotte, Councilor Larry Poulin, Councilor Ronald Jean, Paul Robinson and Stavros Mendros. OTHERS PRESENT: Kevin Gagne and Norm Beauparlant, Purchasing Director. Meeting was called to order at 5:21 p.m. by Chairman Marcotte. At this time, Chairman Marcotte introduced Mr. Paul Robinson as the newly appointed member of the committee. Appointed by Mayor Gilbert to fill the unexpired term of Mr. Mark Paradis. Mr. Marcotte noted that Mr. Robinson’s term would be until January 2013. On motion of Mr. Mendros, seconded by Mr. Poulin it was VOTED: (092-2011) To approve the minutes of the previous meeting dated July 18, 2011 and to accept and place them on file as presented by the Clerk. VOTE: 4-0-1 Mr. Robinson abstained At this time, Chairman Marcotte called for discussion on the part of the committee regarding Finance Committee Rules adopted by the committee at its meeting of January 3, 2011. Following discussion by the committee on a number of areas of concern, the committee agreed to forward specific issue language to the Purchasing Director to build the frame work for discussion at a future meeting. The Purchasing Director indicated that once he had the language, he would work with the Chairman to bring proposed rule changes back to the committee for consideration. No further action taken by the committee at this time. On recommendation of the Purchasing Agent and on motion of Mr. Poulin, seconded by Mr. Robinson, it was VOTED: (093-2011) to award Bid 2011-052 on the Cotton Road Rehabilitation to Gendron & Gendron, Lewiston, Maine, low bidder meeting specifications at their bid price of $175,910.00 VOTE: 5-0 FINANCE COMMITTEE MINUTES August 1, 2011 On recommendation of the Purchasing Agent and on motion of Mr. Poulin, seconded by Mr. Jean, it was VOTED: (094-2011) To authorize Task Order 09-0158.4 with S. W. Cole for Hot Mix Asphalt inspection on the MDOT Lincoln Street Project at an estimated cost of $13,380. VOTE: 5-0 On recommendation of the Purchasing Agent and on motion of Mr. Jean, seconded by Mr. Mendros, it was VOTED: (095-2011) To award Bid 2011-047 for a Truck Chassis & Cab with Plow equipment to Freightliner of Maine, low bidder meeting specifications at their bid price of $102,261 using H. P. Fairfield plow equipment. VOTE: 5-0 Note to award of 2011-047: Mr. Marcotte asked for the department to report back on the final cost of the vehicle including the cost of mounting the City owned sander unit and associated controls. On recommendation of the Purchasing Agent and on motion of Mr. Jean, seconded by Mr. Mendros, it was VOTED: (096-2011) To award of Bid 2011-048 on the Demolition of 445 Sabattus Street (corner of East Avenue and Sabattus Street) to Roland’s Demolition at their bid price of $10,000. VOTE: 4-1 Mr. Marcotte opposed At this time, the Purchasing Agent updated the committee on the status of the Lincoln/Locust Street Intersection Rehabilitation. The Purchasing Agent advised the committee that the MDOT Project Manager had called the City Project Engineer and asked if the City could make the award before the scheduled August 15th meeting. The committee agreed to meet on Monday, August 8th at 5:25 p.m. to consider bids on the project. VOTED: To adjourn at 6:24 p.m. ____________________________________ Norman Beauparlant Clerk Finance Committee Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee from: Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: Bid 2011-038 Public Works Inventory Management System date: August 15, 2011 Proposals were solicited for Inventory Management at the Public Works Department. The Deputy Director’s memo clearly outlines the proposal requirements and expectations. In addition, to his memo is a checklist of issues that was used as the evaluation was done. The proposal and response to questions were reviewed by the Deputy Director, Inventory Manager and Purchasing Director as noted by Kevin’s memo. It is recommended that the contract for Inventory Management be awarded to Everett J. Prescott of Gardiner, Maine, for a three (3) year period with the option at the City’s discretion to extend the contract for two (2) one (1) year periods. NJB/syt Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: Purchase & Installation of computer/server hardware date: August 15, 2011 from: The FY 2011 LCIP funding authorized $40,000 for MIS hardware/software upgrades. The authorization was made as part of a multi-year upgrade that started last year with the conversion to Microsoft. The MIS Department worked with Downeast Networks, Auburn, to make the conversion and install hardware associated with it. The MIS Director has received a proposal from Downeast (an authorized reseller of Dell Hardware). In addition, he has researched the cost to buy the items directly from online sources. It is recommended that the purchase be made through Downeast Networks at an overall cost of $29,272.48 as quoted. NJB/syt Norman Beauparlant * From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Timothy Earle Thursday, August 11,2011 2:26 PM Norman Beauparlant LCIP Purchase Quote001591vl.pdf; R610 RAM.pdf; PS4000E.pdf Good afternoon Norm, The M I S LCIP is $40,000.00 f o r hardware and software. I would like t o purchase the hardware directly from DownEast Networks without going t o an RFP. If I purchase this hardware directly from Dell.com it would cost the City an extra $7,150.34. The hardware being purchased will be shipped t o the M I S Department and installed in the computer room a t City Hall. The purchase of this new hardware will double our current server size allowing us t o add 4 new virtual servers; 2 are new servers f o r the Scale House Software and for the Fuel Management Software, one is t o replace the old Keystone Server and the last one is t o move the current Water Billing Application t o a new database format, Microsoft's SQL. DownEast Networks is one o f the leading resellers in the Northeast and can offer these deep discounts. I have attached documentation supporting this. Sincerely, Tq9-w I.T. Director City of Lewiston 27 Pine Street Lewiston, ME 04240-7242 [email protected] Tel: 207-513-3000 x3252 Fax: 207-784-2959 TDD/TTY 207-513-3007 Downeast Networks Inc. PS4000E/ Extra memory 120 Center Street Suite 205 Auburn, ME 04210 1 www.downeastnetworks.com #001591 Wednesday, August 10, 2011 Michele Herman Phone: 207-689-9900 Fax: 207-221-3517 [email protected] Customer lnformation Timothy Earle City of Lewiston 27 Pine St. Lewiston, ME 04240 Shipping lnformation Timothy Earle City of Lewiston 27 Pine St. Lewiston, ME 04240 Phone: 2075133000 Phone: 2075133000 Description Extendec 1 Products - P ell Equallogic PS4000E Mfr: PS4000E Den Equallogic PS400OE 4 GB repl. memory for Dell PowerEdge R610 Server Mfr: A4976354 4 GB repl. memory module for Dell PowerEdge R610 Server 2Rx8 RDIMM 1333 MHz Prosupport for IT: 7x24 HW / SW Tech Support and Assistance for Certified IT Staff, 3 Year Mfr: PEMCS-3YR Prosupport for IT: 7x24 HW I SW Tech Support and Assistance for Cetiied IT Staff, 3 Shipping: $59.00 $0.00 Terms and Conditions Due to lndustty trends, avallablllty and pricing on all Items Is subject to change at any time. Thanks for conslderlng Downeast Networks for your technology purchase1 Page 1 of 1 The Dell Online Store: Build Your System Print Summary EqualLogic PS4000E SATA, 16 drive Price $33,795.00 I / J ~re1irninal-y Ship Date: 9111201 1 . My Selectione A l l Options - EqwlLogic PSOOOE SATA, 16 drive Date Catalog Number 8111/2011 1:01:46 PM Central Standard Time 8 Retail rc1232625 Catalog Number IDescdption Product Code EqualLoglc PS1(100E: Dell EqualLoglc PS4000E, Cost Efiiclent, High Capacity, 7.2K SATA Drives PS4E SKU Capacity: 16.0 Terabyte capacity, 16 X ITB, 7.2K SATA, Dual Controller Snapshob md Clones: SnapslCbneswith integrationfor MS SQL. Exchange. Hyper V and VMware Rsplkdon: Asynchronous Replication Systmn Monltorlng took: SAN HQ muM gmup monitoring solbare HardwareSupport Senricer: 3 Year Prosupport and W i n Critical 4HR 7x24 Onsite Pack Installation Services: EqualLogic Cuetamer Self Install Option Procrctlve Malnbrnanco: Proadhre Maintenance: 1 event per year, 1 Year Tralnlng Sadces: Dell Educ Svcs - W b Based Training EQL PS SERIES BASIC MGMT IYR Return pollq: EqualLogic array may not be returned ITEMSNR 1 [468-8817] Q 2011 Dell For customers of the 50 United States and the District of Columbia only. Feedback Site Terrns I Terms of Sale I Privacy I Id Find a Laptop, Notebook, Desktop, Server, Printer, Software, Service, Monitor or TV at ... Page 1 of 1 Dell recommendswindowsa 7. ViewJPrint Cart U Print Page Description 4 GB Dell Certiiied Replacement Memory Module for Dell PowerE4ge R610 I RBI0 Sewer 2Rx4 RDlMM 1333MHz - Qty 18 $145.99 Unit Price Manufacturer Part# SNPNN876Cl4G Ddl P a m A2626060 TOTAL: $2,627.82 Total Price Sub-total $2,627.82 andl ling' -- Tax -- TOM price2 -- Shipplng 8 Q 2011 Dell I About Dell ( Regulatory Compliance I Terms of Sale I Limited Warranty I Unresolved Issues 1 Privacy ( About Our Ads and Emails I Dell Recycling ( Contact I Site Map 1 Visit ID I Feedback I Screen Share Large Text Pnang, specifications, availability and terms of offers may change without notice, am not t r a n w l e and are valid only for new purchases from th~ssite for delivery in the 50 Unlted States and the District of Columbia. Taxes, fees, shipma, handling and any aDpliC0ble restockina charnee exha, varv and are not s u b i to discount. Th~ssite and offers contained hasln valid only for end u r e n and not for resell& aidlor o n l i e a u d o b . Dell cannot be responsibie for pricing &other mn,o&issions, a consequences of misuse of site and ib hlndons. Offers not neaaearlly combinable. Discounb cannot be retroectively applied. Orden subject to canallation by Dell. S o h a m and peripheralsoRen do not apply to software and peripheralsin the online system configuration pages ( i n d u d i i PowerConnect switches); you must purchase eligible items through the separate Software 8 Psrlphwals online store.Limit 5 systems and 5 diswunted or promotionalproducts per customer. If items purchased under these pmotions are leased, items leased wlll be subject to applicable end of learn options or requirements. If you have a separate purchase ~ r s e m e nwith t Dell the terms and conditions in that agreement are not applicable to purchases of ink, toner or other printer supplies made by you vla www.dell.com/supplies; all such sale3 am subject to Dell's Terms and Condltlons of Sale located at dell.wWtens, except for the provision(s) regarding separate purchase agreements. All other sales ere subject to Delrs Terms and Conditions of Sale located at www.dell.wdtenns. Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-032 Lincoln Street and Locust Street Intersection Improvements date: August 15, 2011 from: This project is the second project funded through the Maine Department of Transportation. The funding is 80% Federal, 10% State and 10% local. The MDOT has reviewed and approved the award. Note that the project cost schedule provided includes all costs including the demolition of the Avon Mill structure. Also note that the alternate for storm drain work on Lincoln Drive is being recommended with funds available in CSO Separation funds that have a balance of approximately $18,000. It is recommended that bid 2011-032 be awarded to Gendron & Gendron, low bidder at their bid price of $283,425. It is further recommended that the additional alternate work be authorized at $14,035. NJB/syt Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: Change Order #2 to contract with Gendron & Gendron on the Lincoln Street Reconstruction Project date: August 15, 2011 from: The Lincoln Street Reconstruction Project was awarded to Gendron & Gendron on June 6, 2011 in the amount of $2,047,500. This project is funded with Federal, State and local funds on a 80/10/10 basis. Change Order #1 was approved by the Committee on July 18, 2011. Change Order #2 has been reviewed by the City Engineer and by MDOT and has been approved. It is recommended that the Change Order be approved in the amount of $7,421.63 to move a retaining wall because of conflict with new utility poles to be installed. NJB/syt CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 BID DATE: 6/2/11 BID No.: 2011-031 PROJECT Lincoln St Reconstruction - MDOT PIN 16614.00 OWNER: City of Lewiston CONTRACTOR: Gendron and Gendron Inc. You are directed to make the following changes in the Contract Documents. Description: Move retaining wall #1 away from the road by 8 feet. This results in a decrease in wall area of 333.75 SF (Item 635.3 1, $3 1.301sf =$10,446.38 credit) and addition of 600 CY gravel borrow fill (Add Item 203.26) between the road subbase and crushed stone wall backfill ($18.501~~ = $1 1,100). Add 282 LF of granite curb (Item 609.1 1) in front of retaining wall #2 ($24.00/lf = $6,768.00) Reason for Change Order: Wall # 1 needs to be moved because of a conflict with the new and existing utility poles during construction of the wall. Moving the wall away from the poles allows construction without holding the poles and results in an overall cost savings. The original design does not include curb in front of wall #2. Curb is necessary in front of the wall to keep plows from damaging the wall and as a safety issue with cars scraping against the wall. CHANGE IN CONTRACT PRICE: CHANGE IN CONTRACT TIMES: Original contract Price Original Contract Times Substantial Completion: Ready for fmal payment: 713 1112 $2,047.500.00 days or dates Net changes from previous Change Orders No>o No.1 I I $ 24.184.40 I Contract Price prior to this Change Order I $2,071.684.00 Net Increase (decrease) of this change order days Contract Times prior to this Change Order Substantial Completion: Ready for final payment: 713 1/ 12 days or dates - NONE Contract Price with all approved Change Orders $ 2.079.105.63 APPROVED: I I Contract Times with all approved Change Orders Substantial Completion: Ready for f m l payment: 713 1112 By: By: David A. Jones (Public Works Director) Edward A. Barrett (City Administrator) Date: -to No.- Net Increase of this change order $ 7.421.63 RECOMMENDED: Net change from previous Change Orders No. Date: days or dates ACCEPTED: By: Contractor (Authorized Signature) Date: Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-053 Fuel Dispenser/Tracking System date: August 15, 2011 from: Two (2) proposals were received on the replacement of fuel pumps and fuel tracking system at the Public Works Department. The funds are available using encumbered FY 2011 monies in the Municipal Garage account. The current balance is $84,967.47. The budget for the bid was $50,000. When the proposals were opened it was determined that each proposer would meet with City staff to review in detail what was included. The meeting with Adams & Fogg revealed that they had not included items and had included items that did not meet City requirements. Simard & Sons, Lewiston, has met all requirements. It is recommended that the bid be awarded to Simard & Sons at their bid price of $47,790. The annual fees will be charged to a general operating account. NJB/syt Lewiston Department of Public Works Dave A. Jones, P.E. Director Its Happening Here! FUEL DISPENCERJFUEL TRACKER SYTEM There were two bidders for the Fuel Dispenser 1 Fuel Tracker System We met with both the results are as follows; Adams and F o m Falmouth Me. Furnish & Install Units AnyIAll Yearly Fees $29,875.00 $ 668.25 Price does not include the followins; The costs related to cutting the concrete on the Island and adding conduit needed for the Installation of their system. This change is required to meet present day electrical code, as Per the City Electrical Inspector and was identified as part of the spec. Their bid did not include upgraded stainless steel pumps that were required in the Specification. Their yearly fees only cover Con-~putersoftware usagelupgrades and off site trouble shooting by way of the internet. There is no service and repair included. The followins items either do not meet spec or are of some concern to the proper operation of the Tracking svstem; The System keys require programming; the bid spec called for keys that do not require Programming. These type keys are similar to the ones we presently use and are susceptible to being erased. We reprogram keys on a regular basis. The system proposed does offer a bypass feature needed when there is a problem with the System or an emergency, but this feature does not record the fuel usage when activated. While the other bidders system does. The Fuel Master Representative did not have any instances to reference that their system would easily integrate with are RTA System presently in place at the Municipal Garage. The spec requires the system to be compatible. FUEL DISPENCERIFUEL TRACKER SYSTEM CONTINUED SIMARD & SONS Lewiston, Me. Furnish & Install Units $47,790.00 AnyIAIl Yearly Fees $4,910.00 The Yearly fees include the Computer software usagelupgrade, and maintenance contract for the fuel mor~itoringsystem. The System has several references as to its compatibility to the RTA System in place at the Municipal Garage. These references come from both Fuel Force and RTA. . The city MIS Department as well as public works staff met with both bidders to discuss the details of their proposals. After meeting with both bidders, both the city MIS Dept. & Public Works Dept. Feel Simard and Sons proposal meets spec, and appears to be the most compatible with RTA System as well as the existing infrastructure at are facility. Therefore we recommend that the bid be awarded to Simard & Sons for the bid amount of $47,790.00 rector of Public Works TABULATION BID TITLE: FUEL DISPENSEWFUEL TRACKING SYSTEM BID #: 20 11-053 OPEN DATEmIME: JULY 26,20 11 @ 2:00 P.M. REQUESTING DEPT: PUBLIC WORKS Description Furnish & Install Units Any/All Yearly Fees Adams & Fogg Oil Equip. Falrnouth ME Simard & Sons Lewiston ME $29,875.00 $47,790.00 $668.25 $4,9 10.00 Adams & Fogg Oil Equipment: Price is based on re-using of: existing hanging hardware & retrievers; existing CAT5 cable & conduits; and existing electrical & conduits. NOTE: If any of these items can not be re-used, City will be billed on a time & materials basis. Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-046 Snow Plowing and/or Removal Equipment Rentals date: August 15, 2011 from: Each year the City solicits for snow plowing and removal equipment to supplement regular City operations. In the past, the bid included equipment to be assigned to road assignments as well as parking facilities. The past two (2) years Public Works accounts for Outside Equipment Rentals have been eliminated as a means to save budget dollars. This year, the bid included equipment for snow plowing and removal at various municipal parking lots and garages. The bids ask for interested contractors to state available equipment and the rental rate for each including driver on an hourly rate basis. The contractors furnish all labor, equipment and fuel. Once bids are submitted, equipment available, price and individual facility needs are evaluated. Once all equipment is evaluated, the contractors are notified of a tentative assignment contingent upon Finance Committee approval. It is recommended that the following award and assignments be made as follows: Contractor Beaulieu Industries Lewiston D R Caron Minot Washburn & Son Minot NJB/syt Locations Chestnut Street Parking Garage Lincoln Street Parking Garage Mill Street/Mill 5 Lot Centreville Parking Garage Central Fire Station Ash Street Lot Multi-Purpose Center Oak Street Parking Garage & Lot Oak Street Bus Station & Post Office Lot Southern Gateway Parking Garage Department of Public Works David A. Jones, P.E, Director DATE: 08/04/2011 TO: Norm Beauparlant FROM: Dennis R. Boudreau, Eng. Tech. Ill SUBJECT: Contracted Plow Bids 201112012 Norm I have reviewed the bids and I respectfully make the following recommendations. Municipal Parking Lot - Washburn Post Office Lot - Washburn Central Fire Station - D.R. Caron Multi-Purpose Center - D.R. Caron Ash Street Lot - D.R. Caron Oak Street Garage - Washburn Centreville Parking Garage - Beaulieu - Southern Gateway GarageILot Washburn Chestnut Street Garage - Beaulieu I-incoln Street GarageILot - Beaulieu Mill StreetJMill 5 Lot - Beaulieu Oak Street Bus Station - Washburn Dennis R. Boudreau, Eng. Tech. Ill TABULATION BID TITLE: BID #: OPEN DATE/TIME: 1A SNOW PLOWING &/OR REMOVAL EQUIPMENT RENTALS 2011-046 JULY 19, 2011 @ 2:00 P.M. Pick Up Truck w/front end switch plows: CONTRACTOR YEAR/MAKE/SIZE St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME (5) 2005-2010 GMC 3/4 ton $54.88 Beaulieu Industries Lewiston ME 2001 Dodge 1 ton 4X4 w/9' $50.00 1998 Dodge 3/4 ton 4X4 w/8' $50.00 2001 Dodge 3/4 ton 4X4 w/8' $50.00 2001 Chevrolet 3/4 ton 4X4 w/8' $50.00 Washburn & Son Minot ME (4)1995-2009 Dodge 3/4 ton w/8.5' plow $45.00 R C & Son Lewiston ME (7) 2004-2009 ½ ton Chevrolet $54.00 1999 Chevrolet 1 ton $54.00 D R Caron Minot ME 2009 Ford F-350 w/9.5' V plow $51.00 2002 Chevrolet 2500 w8.5' plow $51.00 L P Poirier & Son Lewiston ME 2000 GMC 1 ton $56.00 1994 GMC 1 ton $56.00 (6) GMC 1995-2004 3/4 ton pick ups $54.50 2009 GMC 2500 HD w/9' plow $63.00 Bubier Construction Greene ME 1B 2003 GMC 2500 HD w/9' plow Pick Up Trucks w/front end switch plows with rubber cutting edges: HRLY RATE $63.00 CONTRACTOR YEAR/MAKE/SIZE HRLY RATE St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME 2007 GMC 3/4 ton $63.88 Beaulieu Industries Lewiston ME 2001 Chevrolet 3/4 ton 4X4 w/8' $60.00 2004 Chevrolet 3/4 ton 4X4 w/8' $60.00 2011 Cub Cadet 4X4 (snow plow or blower) $60.00 Washburn & Son Minot ME 2005 Dodge 3/4 ton w/8.5' plow $50.00 R C & Son Lewiston ME (7) 2004-2009 ½ ton Chevrolet $62.00 1999 Chevrolet 1 ton $62.00 2000 GMC 1 ton $62.00 1994 GMC 1 ton $62.00 (6) 1995-2004 GMC 3/4 ton pick ups $60.00 2009 GMC 2500 HD w/9' plow $63.00 2003 GMC 2500 HD w/9' plow Front-end Loader w/plow or plow box: $63.00 L P Poirier & Son Lewiston ME Bubier Construction Greene ME 2 CONTRACTOR YEAR/MAKE/SIZE St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME 2003-2009 Volvo L-70 Beaulieu Industries Sabattus ME 2005 Case w/12' box $88.00 2000 Case Skidsteer w/8' plow w/rubber edge $70.00 2000 Case Skidsteer w/8' plow w/steel edge $68.00 2005 Case 721D w/14' box $80.00 2005 Case 621D w/12' box $75.00 1998 Case 580 w/10' box $70.00 2004 Hyundai 757-7 w/15' plow $95.00 2009 Volvo L70 w/15' plow $95.00 (2) Cat 420 w/15' plow $95.00 1999 Cat 416 w/10' plow $87.00 1991 John Deere 544E w/12' $90.00 2003 Volvo L90 w/12' box $90.00 Washburn & Son Minot ME R C & Sons Lewiston ME D R Caron Minot ME L P Poirier & Son Lewiston ME Bubier Construction Greene ME 3 Dump Trucks HRLY RATE $104.00 1992 Volvo L150 $110.00 1980 Volvo L90 $105.00 2000 Volvo L90 $105.00 2005 John Deere 624H w/12' plow box $105.00 CONTRACTOR SIZE/Capacity/#Available HRLY RATE St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 4 $55.88 Tri-Axle (18-20 CY) - 4 $58.88 Tractor w/dump trailer (32 CY) - $78.88 Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 3 $54.00 Tri-Axle (18-20 CY) - 2 $58.00 Tractor w/dump trailer (50 CY) - 1 $70.00 Washburn & Son Minot ME Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 2 $47.00 Tri-Axle (18-20 CY) - 1 $50.00 R C & Sons Lewiston ME Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 3 $50.00 Tri-Axle (18-20 CY) - 3 $55.00 D R Caron Minot ME Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 2 $57.00 Tri-Axle (18-20 CY) - 1 $61.00 L P Poirier & Son Lewiston ME Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 1 $56.00 Tri-Axle (18-20 CY) - 4 $60.00 Tractor w/dump trailer (40 CY) - 1 $70.00 Beaulieu Industries Lewiston ME Double Axle (12-14 CY) - 1 Bubier Construction Greene ME 4 Bulldozers (minimum Operating Weight of 35,000 lbs) CONTRACTOR St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME 5 Front-end Loaders YEAR/MAKE/SIZE 2000 D-6 Cat 46,000 lb. $59.00 HRLY RATE $123.88 CONTRACTOR YEAR/MAKE/SIZE St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME 2003-2009 Volvo L-70 $104.00 Volvo L-120 $114.88 2004 Cat 420 $89.00 2005 Komatsu 820 $84.88 2005 Case 6210 3 yd $88.00 2005 Case 90XT Skidsteer $68.00 2005 Case 90XT Skidsteer (bucket rubber edge) $70.00 Washburn & Son Minot ME Case 721D 3 yds $80.00 R C & Sons Lewiston ME 2004 Hyundai 757-7 $95.00 2009 Volvo L-70 $95.00 D R Caron Minot ME 1999 Cat 416 1/5 yd $87.00 1991 John Deere 2.5 yd $90.00 2003 Volvo L90 3.5 yd $90.00 Beaulieu Industries Sabattus ME HRLY RATE L P Poirier & Son Lewiston ME Bubier Construction Greene ME 6 Sand Spreader 1992 Volvo L150 $110.00 2000 Volvo L90 $100.00 1988 Volvo L90 $100.00 2005 John Deere 624J 3.5 yd bucket $103.00 CONTRACTOR YEAR/MAKE/SIZE St. Laurent & Son Lewiston ME 2008 Downeaster 10CY $100.00 2004 Downeaster 6 CY $100.00 Beaulieu Industries Lewiston ME 1990 IH 6 yds $100.00 Washburn & Son Minot ME HRLY RATE 2001 Dodge 3 yds $70.00 2011 Cub Cadet Calcium Spreader $60.00 2002 Fontane 3 yd $90.00 1999 Fisher 3 yd $90.00 2010 Myers 3 yd $90.00 R C & Sons Lewiston ME (2) 6 yd $100.00 (1) 3 yd $100.00 D R Caron Minot ME 2006 Swenson 8 yds L P Poirier & Son Lewiston ME Downeaster 6 yd $105.00 Downeaster 5 yd $100.00 Downeaster 3 yd $98.00 2003 GMC 2500 HD 3 yd $69.00 Bubier Construction Greene ME $79.00 Additional Equipment available: St. Laurent & Son Komatsu Skidsteer w/8' plow or 8' bucket w/rubber edges . . . . $84.88 Washburn & Son 2005 Case 70XT Skidsteer w/rubber edge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $65.00 2007 Takeuchi TL140 Skidsteer w/rubber edge . . . . . . . . . . . . $65.00 Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-049 ½ ton 4X4 Pick Up Truck date: August 15, 2011 from: Four (4) bids were received on July 28, 2011 for the replacement of a ¼ ton 4X4 Pick Up Truck. No trade was offered as part of the bid. It is recommended that the bid be awarded to Auburn Motor Sales low bidder at their bid price of $20,177.96. Truck is budgeted in Public Works with a budget estimate of $21,000. NJB/syt Lewiston Department of Public Works kdkd Dave A. Jones, P.E. Director Its Happening Here! L I W I S T O M .AUBURN % Ton 4x4 Pickup Truck Bid # 20 I1-049 There were four bids submitted for the pickup the results are as Follow; 2012 Chevrolet CK10903 Frank Galos Chevrolet. Saco, Maine. $ 21,698.00 (to trade) 2012 Chevrolet Silverado Liberty Chevrolet. $21,654.00 2012 GMC Sierra 1500 O'Conner GMC. $21,593.00 2012 Ford F-I50 (no trade) (notrade) Auburn Motor Sales. $20,177.96 (no trade) $21,698.00 Wakefield, Mass. $21,654.00 Augusta, Maine. $21,593.00 Auburn, Maine. $20,177.96 All three bids meet spec. Therefore the bid should be awarded to the low bidder Auburn Motor Sale for the bid amount of $20,177.96 A \2~--& David ~ o n d sDirector of Public Works TABULATION BID TITLE: BID #: OPEN DATEmIME: REQUESTING DEPT: DESCRIPTION 112 TON 4x4 PICK UP TRUCK 20 11-049 JULY 28,201 1 @ 2:00 P.M. PUBLIC WORKS Auburn Motor Sales Auburn ME Frank Galos Chevrolet Saco ME Liberty Chevrolet Wakefield MA O'Connor GMC Augusta ME Make Ford Chevrolet Chevrolet GMC Model F150 CK10903 Silverado Sierra 1500 Year 2012 2012 2012 2012 20,177.96 21,698.00 21,654.00 21,593.00 90 days 8- 12 weeks 10-12 weeks Net 20 Net 30 Net 14 Unit Price (no trade-in) Delivery Time Terms std Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-050 ¾ ton 4X4 Pick Up Truck date: August 15, 2011 from: Bids have been evaluated by the Public Works Department. All three (3) met specifications. It is recommended that the bid be awarded to O’Connor GMC, Augusta, low bidder at their bid price of $22,703 and to accept the trade in allowance of $888 for a net cost of $21,815. The vehicle is budgeted in the Municipal Garage Capital account with an estimated budget of $28,000. NJB/syt Lewiston Department of Public Works Dave A. Jones, P.E. Director It's Happening Here! . LIWISTDU AUBUIU 5/4 TON 4x4 PICK UP TRUCK Bid # 201 1-050 There were three bids submitted for the pickup truck the Results are as follow; 2012 Ford F-250 Auburn Motor Sales. Auburn, Maine. $23,965.87 600.00) $23,365.87 after trade 2012 Chevrolet CK20903 Frank Galos Chevrolet. Saco, Maine. $23,693.00 1,003.00) $22,690.00 after trade 2012 GMC Sierra 2500 HD O'Conner GMC. Augusta, Maine. $22,703.00 (trade 888.00) $21,815.00 after trade All three bids meet spec. therefore the bid should be awarded to the low bidder O'Conner GMC, for the bid amount of $21,815.00 David ~ d n e sDirector of Public Works TABULATION BID TITLE: BID #: OPEN DATEmIME: REQUESTING DEPT: 314 TON 4x4 PICK UP TRUCK 20 11-050 JULY 28,201 1 @ 2:00 P.M. PUBLIC WORKS Auburn Motor Sales Auburn ME Frank Galos Chevrolet Saco ME O'Connor GMC Augusta ME Make Ford Chevrolet GMC Model F250 CK20903 Sierra 2500HD Year 2012 DESCRIPTION Unit Price (no trade-in) Trade-in Allowance Net Bid Price (less trade in) 23,965.87 23,693.OO 22,703.OO (600.00) (1,003.OO) (888.00) $23,365.87 $22,690.00 $21,815.00 90 days 10-12 weeks Net 20 Net 14 Delivery Time Terms 2012 Net 10 Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-051 ¾ ton Van date: August 15, 2011 from: Bids were opened on July 28, 2011 for a replacement van for the Public Works Department. The bids have been evaluated by the department. It is recommended that the bid be awarded to O’Connor GMC, Augusta, low bidder meeting specifications at their bid price of $23,869 and to accept the trade in allowance of $888 for a net purchase price of $22,981. Van is budgeted in the Water Division. The budget estimate was $30,000. NJB/syt Lewiston Department of Public Works Dave A. Jones, P.E. Director 3/4 TON VAN BID # 2011 - 051 There were two bid proposals submitted for the van the results were as follow; 2012 Ford E-250 van Auburn Motor Sales Auburn, Maine. $22,822.68 (Trade $600.00) $22,222.68 after trade Did not meet specification. Specification called for remote side access panels W I Upgraded lighting. This allows access to the shelving in the van from both sides and the rear of the van. Eliminating the need for workers to clirr~b over whatever is in the cargo bay of the van to access the shelves. 2012 GMC Savana 2500 Van O'Conner GMC Augusta, Maine $23,869.00 (Trade $888.00) $22.981.OO After trade Proposed Van meets spec The Bid should be awarded to O'Conner GMC, how van meets spec. For the bid amount of $22,981.OO David Jones ~ i r 6 c t oof r Public Works TABULATION BID TITLE: BID #: OPEN DATEITIME: REQUESTING DEPT: 314 TON VAN 201 1-051 JULY 28,201 1 @ 2:00 P.M. PUBLIC WORKS Auburn Motor Sales Auburn ME O'Connor GMC Augusta ME Make Ford GMC Model F250 Savana 2500 Year 2012 2012 22,822.68 23,869.00 (600.00) (888.00) $22,222.68 $22,981.00 6-8 weeks 10- 12 weeks DESCRIPTION Unit Price (no trade-in) Trade-in Allowance Net Bid Price (less trade in) Delivery Time Terms Net 14 days Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: 2011-054 Plow Cutting Edges date: August 15, 2011 from: Bids were solicited for plow cutting edges. The cutting edges are mounted to the plows and are the edge that comes in contact with the road. Bids from vendors have been evaluated and it is recommended that the bid be awarded to Viking-Cives, Sidney, Maine, meeting specifications at their bid amount of $16,289.10. Funds for the edges are part of the Winter Road account. The account provides for a number of items including the cutting edges. NJB/syt Lewiston Department of Public Works Dave A. Jones, P.E. Director It!! Happening Here! . L I W I S I O * A U I U I Y PLOW CUTTING EDGE There were six Bids submitted for consideration. Only two meet spec. The results are as follow: Chemung Supply Co. Bid all 3 blades for a total of. $10,644.90 The spec called for flame hardened blades composed of C1074 hot rolled steel with a Rockwell hardness of 57-67. Their bid was for 15B30 Hot rolled steel through Hardened to a Rockwell hardness of 57-67. Does not meet spec requirements. Valk Manufacturina Bid all 3 blades for a total of. $ I1,850.00 'The spec called for flame hardened blades composed of C1074 hot rolled steel with a Rockwell hardness of 57-67. 'Their bid was for blades with a Rockwell hardness of 43-52 Does not meet spec requirements. Jordan Equipment Co. Bid all 3 blades for a total of. $ 20,284.80 The bidder only supplied the Rockwell hardness spec of 57-67 No other info was sent with bid to prove they meet spec. They were higher than others that meet spec. PLOW CUTTING EDGES CONT. Winter Equipment Co. Bid all 3 blades for a total of. $22,489.20 The spec called for flame hardened blades composed of C1074 hot rolled steel with a Rockwell hardness of 57-67. Their bid was for 15B30 Hot rolled steel through Hardened to a Rockwell hardness of 45-52 Does not meet spec requirments. H.P.Fairfield Bid all 3 blades for a total of. 'The bid proposal meets spec. Vikincl - Cives Bid all 3 blades for a total of. The bid proposal meets spec. The bid should be awarded to Viking - Cives for the bid amount of $16,289.10. They are the lowest bidder that meets spec. or of Public Works PLAN HOLDERS' LIST BID TITLE: BID #: OPEN DATEmIME: REQUESTING DEPT: Vendor PLOW CUTTING EDGE 201 1-054 JULY 26,201 1 @ 2:00 P.M. PUBLIC WORKS #3 (30) Grader Blades #2 #1 (60) 5' Plow Blades (30) 6' Plow Blades Makemodel Unit $ Total $ Makemodel Unit $ Total $ Makemodel Unit $ Total $ Bucyrus $133.70 $8,022.00 Bucyrus $160.44 $4,8 13.20 Bucyrus $1 15.13 $3,453.90 Evolution Edges 83.1 1 4,986.60 Evolution Edges 96.96 2,908.80 Evolution Edges 91.65 2,749.50 Bucyrus 8844-501 151.25 9,075.00 Bucyrus 8844-601 181.50 5,445.00 Bucyrus 1845-603 124.25 3,727.50 Valk Manufacturing New Kingstown PA Valk 99.00 5,940.00 Valk 119.00 3,570.00 Valk 78.00 2,340.00 Jordan Equipment West Falmouth ME Esco 162.92 9,775.20 Esco 195.51 5,865.30 Esco 154.81 4,644.30 Black Cat PBB8806044-A 195.75 11,745.00 Black Cat PBB8807244-A 234.70 7,04 1.OO Black Cat CAT 5D9558 123.44 3,703.20 Viking-Cives Sidney ME Chemung Supply Elmira NY H P Fairfield Skowhegan ME Winter Equipment Co Willoughby OH Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: Ratification of award of bid for #2 Fuel Oil date: August 15, 2011 from: The City of Lewiston and the City of Auburn have jointly bid #2 heating oil annually for over 30 years. Over the past 8 years, the group has evolved to include both Lewiston and Auburn School Departments as well as the County Building and the Town of Poland. Within the last 7 years, the group has solicited bids on a fixed price basis for the heating season from September to June. This year, aggregate amount was estimated at 415,400 gallons. On August 10, 2011, six (6) firms provided fixed prices for #2 heating oil. Bids were evaluated by the Lewiston Purchasing Director, Lewiston School Business Manager and Auburn School Business Manager. By unanimous agreement, the award was made to C N Brown at their fixed price of $3.0569 per gallon for Large Loads (7,500+) and $3.2319 for Small Loads.. It is requested that the Finance Committee ratify the award as presented. NJB/syt Location Airport Airport Terminal Airport Maintenance Build. 1-500gal 2-330 gal. Total Airport Androscoggin County Building City of Auburn - Hasty Comm. Center 48 Pettingil Park Rd Pettingill Park 1- 275 gal. Engine 5 Fire Station - Center Street General Use (Gracelawn & PP Equip) General Assistance - Various as needed 1-10,000gal. 1-8,000gal. Total Auburn City Locations City of Lewiston General Assistance - Various as needed Multi Purpose Center 145 Birch St. 1-10,000gal. Total Lewiston Mun. Locations Towns General Assistance - Various as needed 2-275 gal. Poland Town Hall - 1223 Maine St Poland Town Garage 30 Ploand Corner R 1-330gal. Poland (old town office) - 1219 Maine St. 1-275gal. old school house Behind Town Office 1-275gal 1-275gal Ricker Library 1211 Maine St. Poland Community School 1250 Maine S t 1-3,000gal Minot School 23 Shaw Hill Rd. 1-3,000gal Elm St. School Mechanic Falls 129 Elm St 1 4,000 gal Union Central Office 1146 Maine St Poland 1-275gal - - Total Poland and Minot Lewiston School Department Dingley Bldg. - Oak Street Total Lewiston School Department Location Auburn School Department 115 Whitney AMS - 38 Falcon Dr. AMS Portable East Auburn - 15 Andrew Dr. ELHS - 77 Harris Ave. Franklin - 23 High St. Land Lab - Portables- 15 Andrew Dr. Park Ave. Elem. School - 161 Park Ave. RETC 80 Lake Street Support Services- 33 Industry Ave. Total Auburn School Department Total All Agencies Total Combined Small & Large - 40,000 Deliveries 2 of 6/30/201, CN Brown -1 - -- - Gallons - Airport ~ i ~ 6 2l ~6i r ~ o i ~ e r m i n a l .._1.:500 pal 2-330 gal. -+--- - AND; -- ~droscoggin . -- County . ..- . Building - 2-6,000gal. I------- I k .G 4,000 =I.' 8,000 _ 1 275 a 1 3 . m - 48 Pettingil Park Rd Great*@ 19 cademy St. l o t Ave Police Dep- One pettingillpark - ---Engine 5 Ffi Sp-tlon- Cenler StreetGeneral - Use (Gracelawn & PP Equip]-- _ General Assistance - Various as needed- -- - - -- - - - - 1-10,000~.~ 1-10,000 =I. - - 20,- 3 8,901 ,500 -,414 7,345 14,000 30,000 - A ---A 11,000 I - -I Total Auburn City Locations ,- - --- -- - -- - I I - -- -- ! rS,pO 4,000 e 1 64.163 - City of Lewiston - - w 2 7 ]~enera!~ssistan~e Various as Lew. Memorial Armory - 6 5 s s t r a l Ave -- -- - -4,000 1-330 gal. --- Birch S COLE66 _, 'Total Lewiston Mun. Location1 I - ~ -- ~ 1-3.000 -- lgal i m r n i1250 Ma&St ~ Poland Regional H.S. 1 4 5 7 - M a k e 3 Poland Town Fall - 1223 Maine St 30,000 25,791 10,513 Total Poland -and Minot 60.500 -3,332 - -t Lewiston School -- - Department - 1LMS Central Avenue Dingley Bldg. - Oak Street ----t,,,,o ,- - --- - iTotal Lewiston School Department II -- -. AuburnSchool -. - .Department . ..- - - - I 4,700 - -- - ..-- - -----. - --20,0001 i ,--- L 1. - 1 I 1 AMS - 38 Falcon Dr. ELHS 77 Harris Ave. -. I Park Ave. Elem. School 161 Park Ave. Industry Aye- - - -- -- - Franklin 23 High St._ -Land Lab - West Auburn ~ d . 1 East Auburn - 15 AndrewDr. 1 Merrill Hill 16 Western Ave. P o t t a p AMS -. -115 Whitney -. ---Lake Street School - - .-L 3751 -- 70,000; i -- x - Total Auburn School bepartment 8ub Total All Locations -- - -Total All Locations Large + Small -- - - 275 - -7 2,O0OA 1- 69,900 - - W,W - 614,600 29,223 1 64,784 11,328 6,738 6,457 I 100 6,351 2,300 1,471 133,74! - -- . -- wg9W0 463,162 Finance Committee Norman J. Beauparlant Director of Budget/Purchasing [email protected] to: Finance Committee Norman Beauparlant, Purchasing Agent subject: Contract Extension for the purchase of Road Salt date: August 15, 2011 from: Over the last 30 years, the City of Lewiston and the City of Auburn have jointly purchased winter road salt through AVCOG (Androscoggin Valley Council of Governments). The bid was last done in 2009 for the 2009-2010 winter season. Forty-seven of the member towns participated in the bid with a total aggregate tonnage bid at almost 40,000 tons. In 2009, six (6) bidders offered pricing with Morton Salt being the successful bidder at $63.03 per ton. During the past year, two (2) firms, Morton Salt and International Salt, have been acquired by SPL Company and are now International Salt. Mr. Lea at AVCOG has sent out to all agencies an opportunity offered by International Salt to extend the contract for another year and in addition, lower the price per ton by $1.50 for an adjusted per ton price of $61.53. This would mean a budget savings of $9,300 for Lewiston based on the estimated purchase of 6,200 tons. It is recommended that the contract with International Salt be extended for another year at the reduced price of $61.53/ton. NJB/syt lNTERNATIONAL SALT an S P L c o r n p a n y August 11,2011 Attn: Fergus P. Lea, .Ira,P.E. Androscoggin Valley Council of Governments 1125 Manley Road Auburn, ME 04210 Dear Mr. Lea: Re: Sodium Chloride (Road Salt) Contract As you have recently discussed with Doug Koelsch, International Salt Company would be willing to extend the above mentioned contract for an additional year with the same terms and conditions. We have a current short-term opportunity to lock in some lower costs that could save you some additional money on your salt purchases for the coming season. If you could notify us by August 17,2011 that you will be extending the contract for an additional year, we will reduce last year's price by $1.50/ton for all participants on this contract. Please sign and return this letter by August 17,2011. Looking forward to working with you again this winter season. CEO Accepted: By: Date: Name: Phone: Title: 2009-2010 Salt Bid Results Page 2 of 2 September 2, 2009 Vendor FOB Stockpile North Region North Region South Region South Region Base Bid Quantity over 500 tons before Dec. 15 Base Bid Quantity over 1,000 tons before Dec. 15 Cargill Deicing Technology 73.OO 77.95 77.95 No Bid No Bid Eastern Salt Company, Inc. 67.50 80.00 80.00 67.50 67.50 Granite State Minerals 95.00 113.00 113.00 103.00 103.00 International Salt Company, LLC 74.00 79.70 79.70 74.50 74.50 Mid - Atlantic Salt, LLC 69.00 75.50 73.50 75.50 72.50 Morton Salt 63.03 68.45 68.45 63.03 63.03 Sel Warwick No Bid No Bid No Bid No Bid No Bid FYI: Bid results regarding liquid calcium chloride will be available in the beginning of October. Attachments Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Request Detail Account Information August 11,2011 Department: Public Works Division Number: 43320 Division Title: Snow Removal Account Number: 4039800 Account Title: Otber Supplies - FY 2009 $ * Actual 410,934 $ FY 2012 Line Budget FY 2010 FY 2010 $ Budget 550,000 $ Actual 500,785 FY 2011 $ Administrator Department Recommendation Request 490,000 $ 490,000 $ Budget 490,000 FY 2011 $ Council Action 490,000 $ Est. Expended 490,000 Increase (Decrease) 1 This fhding purchases liquid and flake calcium chloride, rock salt and winter sand for use in treating streets for snow and ice conditions. The flake calcium chloride helps clearing fiozen catch basins and drainage structures. - - The agreement with Morton Salt was extended in FY2011. The price for Rock Salt (Ton) remains at $63.03 per ton for FY20 11. There is no way of telling presently what the price per ton for salt will be after the next bid process for FY2012. The Department is however, has made changes in FY2011 to sanding practices in hopes of reducing the amount of salt and sand used in the future. A better rate was acquired by purchasing Flake Calcium by the pallet reducing the price by approximately $1.OO per bag. Also this product was not charged out to the parking garages but instead absorbed within this budget line item. The product is now being charged to the correct accounts. This product was reduced fiom 1000 bags to 600 bags or $4,380. I