Session A - WoodMusICK
Transcription
Session A - WoodMusICK
Museum versus Mausoleums? Annalisa Bini Director; Laura Bognetti Assistant Curator. Musical Instruments Museum of the Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia in Rome Instruments museums are mausoleums, places for the display of the musically dead, with the organologists acting as morticians, preparing dead instruments bodies for preservation and display Elio Bates, The Social Life of Musical Instruments, “Ethnomusicology”, vol. 56/3 - Fall 2012, pp. 363-95: 365 Silent instruments museums? Musical instruments museums are peculiar museums. Like all other functional objects on display in museums, they should be resting, not “working” and are thus silent to be preserved for future generations. But visitors’ expectation for a music-related museum are to be able to listen and see how they are or were used and even researchers sometimes share the same opinion. Actual controversies in and about establish a museum’s policy of use • Can we manage to fulfil both these expectations and duties of preservation? • Do we have to treat musical instruments differently from other museum’s objects? • Can we or could be a serious risk for their preservation? Sounds and video samples, guided tours, concerts are often used to satisfy visitors’ needs, but still left them with some curiosity, especially about most famous instruments “voices”. Undoubtedly musicians and researchers are not satisfied by these educational devices, since they are differently interested in knowing the exact sound of these particular instruments. A very limited use is allowed in these cases, but there are no scientific researches about or certain rules. The players’ point of view: ancient instruments as “live” tools A musical instrument displayed in a case is a nonsense for most musicians. Ancient bowed instruments, above all, are still considered to be good as or better than modern ones, not just nearly as a theory, but in the direct experience of most important performers: museums’ instruments are actual tools for their art, so why should they be taken apart from “live” experience? Famous soloists and their instruments: Janine Jansen currently uses the 1727 Stradivari “Barrere” violin; Giovanni Sollima plays on a 1679cello by Francesco Ruggeri; Leonidas Kavakos plays the “Abergavenny” Stradivarius of 1724 but from 2010 he also owns three modern violins. Can research give further help to museums’ policies? Some scientific project, especially those ran by the University of Florence (DISTAF - Department of Environmental and Forestry Studies) and presented here by Marco Fioravanti, are deepening our knowledge of wood instruments reaction to use and this is the only way to have proper answers and to define certain rules and use policies. More studies must be conducted on different musical instruments types, especially woodwinds. About the Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia and its Museum The Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia is one of the most ancient musical institutions in the world. Founded in 1585, today it is a modern musical foundation producing more than 250 events per year with its renown Symphonic Orchestra and Choir. It also carries out educational activities with high-level music courses and the first children’s orchestra in Italy. It’s cultural heritage is held in the Musical Instruments Museum and Archives which are accessible to the public on-site from the Multimedia Library and remotely through the internet. www.santacecilia.it http://museo.santacecilia.it Woodwind Musical Instruments: the Effect of Restoration on Some Acoustic Properties Doganis E., Koutsouris A., Pournou A. Department of Conservation of Antiquities and Works of Art, Technological Educational Institute of Athens AG. SPYRIDONOS, AEGALEO,12210, ATHENS, GREECE 1. Introduction In 2011, a small-scale research project started at the Laboratory of wood conservation, TEI of Athens, which studied whether the repair of cracks in woodwind instruments could alter their amplitude or/and frequency. More specifically different types of natural and synthetic adhesives/fillers were tested in order to examine their ability to repair and preserve the acoustic properties of bamboo flutes. 2. Experiment Samples Fig. 8 a. Sound spectra of the flute repaired with keromasticho (Φ4), on the 6th fingering position (1st octave); black: the original; green: after the crack and red after restoration; b, c, d: dual display plots. For the experimental part, five bamboo flutes were used (fig. 1). Each flute’s sound spectrum was recorded a) at its undamaged condition b) after developing an artificial crack between the third and fourth hole (fig. 2) and c) after repairing the crack. Fig. 2 The position of the artificial crack Fig. 3 Flute at the fingering position 3 where 3 holes were closed 2 3 Fig. 4 The mass flow controller 4 5 Fig. 9: Sound spectra of the flute repaired with fish glue (Φ3), on the 6th fingering position (1st octave); black: the original; green: after the crack and red after restoration; b, c, d: dual display plots. Table 1 Flutes' fingering positions Fig. 1 Flutes used in this study Sound The flutes' sound spectrum was studied in eight different fingering positions as it is shown in table 1. However, this poster presents the results from four fingering positions of the first octave (2, 3, 4, and 6 closed holes) and from one of the second octave (6 closed holes). For Fig. 6 The area of the sound spectrum that a human ear perceives Fig. 5 Placemen of the cardioid microphone obtaining reliable and repeatable results an air compressor was used, providing stable airflow of 5 mbar pressure. The compressor was connected to a mass flow controller (fig. 4), which operated by monitoring temperature fluctuations via a temperature sensor. Initially, flutes were tested based on the amount of airflow entering the pipe (table 1) in each fingering position in order to yield the correct note. The sound quality was recorded with a cardioid microphone (fig. 5) and studied with a "Fast Fourier Analysis" (FFT) system in order to obtain data on both amplitude and frequency of the instrument. The experimental setup for the sound recording is shown in figure 7. Adhesives/fillers Instrument’s practical manufacturers in Greece are usually repairing woodwind instruments with natural adhesives/fillers that have not been chemically processed. These are mainly plant resins and protein-based adhesives. Therefore, the materials selected in the current study for repairing flutes’ cracks were fish glue and a mixture of beeswax and mastic called "keromasticho", a traditional material used in Greece for repairing woodwind instruments. For comparative 3. Results and discussion Comparing the initial sound spectrum of each flute before the crack with the spectrum after the restoration, it can be evaluated the impact of each adhesive to flutes sound properties. In figures 8, 9 and 10 it is observed that in fingering positions 4, 5 and 6, the sound spectrum remained altered in both octaves spectra before and after Fig. 10: Sound spectra of the flute repaired with Paraloid-B72 (Φ5), on the 6th fingering position (1st octave); black: the original; green: after the crack and red after restoration; b, c, d: dual display plots. restoration. More specifically with all types of adhesives used, amplitude picks were increased but never reached their initial level (before the crack). In addition it is showed that the sound spectrum after restoration has been shifted from 2 to 3 Hz right or left from its original position. This could signify that flutes have eventually lost their tone. Furthermore, it should be taken into account that the human ear perceives only a number of notes and harmonics in a specific range of the sound spectrum. Therefore, the sound differences observed before and after the restoration can be distinguish by humans if they are higher than 20dB and between 20 and 19.000 Hz (fig. 6). 4. Conclusions Based on the results obtained, it appears that the acoustic properties of flutes are influenced by the adhesives used for their restoration. The most appropriate adhesive, based on flutes audio properties, appears to be keromasticho. Fish glue is the second best material studied, followed by Paraloid B-72. Nevertheless, both natural fillers, keromasticho and fish glue, do not meet some conservation requirements regarding biodegradability, durability and physicochemical properties over time, unless they get improved with purposes, three more adhesives were studied: polyvinyl acetate various additives. Paraloid B-72 could be a candidate material as it (PVAc, modified homopolymer), the white glue commonly used in could compromise both physicochemical properties over time and woodworking; an epoxy resin for its durability; and Paraloid B-72, an acceptable post-restoration acoustic properties. ethyl methacrylate and methyl acrylate copolymer (70:30) in acetone Finally, it is worth mentioning that the shifting of 2 to 3 Hz, observed (40% w/v), used for its reversibility and stability over time (table 2). after restoration in picks' position, can be further improved during playing by the musician, by blowing more or less air into the pipe. In contrast the 1000 - 3000 Hz shifting, observed before after the development of the crack, cannot be corrected without restoration. 5. Acknowledgments FFT Table 2 The adhesives/fillers used in this study Fig. 7 The experimental setup for the sound recording The authors wish to thank Kostas Fotopoulos, musisian-physisist for his valuable help and support, Professor Maria Founti, School of Mechanical Engineering, NTUA, for providing the mass flow controller equipment and Mr. C. Cheramiotis and Mr. I. Mandilara PhD students, School of Mechanical Engineering, NTUA, for their assistance. Marc Ecochard Tuning of baroque and classical oboes (hautboys) Original baroque and classical oboes, before 1850 and the Boehm-Triebert system, have a specific tuning, far from the balance of modern instruments and modern copies of authentic instruments. Bore and tone holes Bore – Concavity of general profile and concavity of the profile of each joint - Long bell, wide flare, rim at the opening - Steps between each joint Tone holes – Small diameter - Drilled at angle - undercutting Tuning of 3 authentic instruments Pierre Naust Carlo Palanca Prudent Diversion in cents in relation to the 0 of equal temperament for 3 hautboys stamped Pierre Naust, Carlo Palanca and Prudent Tuning methods Early sources : none Late source : a letter by K. F. Golde (ca 1850) published in Zeitschrift für Instrumentenbau, 52, 1932, Leipzig by F. Drechsel. - Action on the bore by « chambering ». -Action on the tone holes by undercutting. Shrinkage, warping deformation Source : Cary Karp, Woodwind instrument bore Measurement, Galpin Society Journal, XXXI, may 1978. Effects of shrinkage upon the tuning of an original instrument. Tuning adaptation to modern hautboy Influence of reed setup Tuning corrections in order to bring the intervals of the natural scale closer to equal temperament. Musical instrument making at the School of Arts Hogent University College Manu Frederickx, Jan Boon, Francis Ponseele, Wim Raymaekers, Geerten Verberkmoes, Andreas Korczak, Jolien Paeshuys, Maarten Quanten, Kersten Cottyn, Claudia Ibarra 3 year Bachelor and 2 year Master programme Studies the morphology of musical instruments in view of their: construction reconstruction preservation Studying a Peeter Borbon viola da gamba at the MIM, Brussels Study and documentation of instruments from private and public collections Exploration of historical sources and treatises, iconography and specialist literature Make a contribution to the performance practice of music CT x-ray scan of a Cornetto at the Department of Physics and Astrnomy of Ghent University. Digital endoscope image of the neck joint of a Boussu violin, MIM, Brussels Original Allemanische violins and reconstruction by Andreas Korczak at Muzikinstrumenten Museum Berlin Current and past PhD's and research projects: Wooden organ pipes for the reconstruction of an “Organo Di Legno” by Jan Boon Conception and realization of an 'organo di legno' (PhD) Boon, Jan Pipe organ tuning by means of physical modelling (PhD) Steenbrugge, Dirk Research about the building methods of the North-Alpin violin making tradition from the 17th century Korczak, Andreas School Of Arts Campus Hoogpoort, Nederpolder 26, 9000 Gent, Belgium, [email protected] ) $' $ %&98 !"#$ ! , + ) $ + '() ) ,+ +)'' A ) )$' 2 + , 8$+ 55 6754 8 / 6759/ ::1 / :: 1 :/ / 011; :; 1 :// :5. / :<; :<1 :<=> :<519 ? / :76/ :76$@/$ U)$E $$ 0'>+) $ ')$ ! )* +' ! 0$> 1 ' ! ).$ ! ))' (, $+ ')) + " %:8)1 ) %9 ) ') ' ( $' ) $' ! * $-)'$')$-$' -)$ -)T Revisiting historical sources Multidisciplinary research on old bowed instruments Correct dating, geographical location and attribution are huge problems in the study of historical stringed instruments. Were historical bowed instruments in our collections originally the instruments we see today? Examples: - Were 16th century viols always really viols, or can we find indications that parts came from different instruments? - Did instruments with a special design and characteristics always have the appearance they have today, or is it possible that they have been made from mangled instruments with a less spectacular shape? Did old violins, viola’s and violoncello’s have the dimensions they have today, or are they often made from larger instruments, such as “haute-contre de violon”, “taille de violon” or “basse de violon” ? - Are signatures or labels reliable? Do the most important parts originally belong together? Need for an profound and systematic multidisciplinary collaboration between curators, conservators, musicologist, wood scientist, chemist, … Karel Moens - Music museum Vleeshuis Antwerp [email protected] Oriol Rossinyol – Conservator [email protected] Manel Barcons – Curator [email protected] 2.000 instruments 500 chordophones PLAYING ON HISTORICAL INSTRUMENTS MUSICAL USE OF STRING INSTRUMENTS The study of an historical instrument tells us whether we will be able or not to use it musically and if we will start or not a restoration. The analysis of the materials that make up the instrument and its possible wear will determine the limits of its use: a single recording or a frequency of use under some controls. Initial state of the MDMB 438 guitar: a study of the instrument Restoration Restored guitar. © Rafael Vargas Musical use THE PRESERVATION OF THE HISTORICAL INSTRUMENT IN USE The continued use of a historical instrument involves a certain impairment of some parts that will become unrecoverable. To build a partial facsimile means keeping the sound of the instrument and preserving the original piece. The whole reconstruction of an instrument based on an historical model may have two goals: meeting its constructive and sound essence or building an exact whole facsimile. Harpsichord. Christian Zell. MDMB 418. © Rafael Vargas Jacks. Wear of mechanisms. © Rafael Vargas Registers. Wear of mechanisms Musical use of the instrument. © May/Circus STUDY OF THE SOUNDBOARD OF THE GUITAR TO BUILD FACSIMILES One of the projects that the Museum has launched this year is a daily concert with historic guitars. Understanding how the soundboard of a guitar works provides us information for the construction of facsimiles that will replace the original instrument without losing sound quality and preserving the museum piece at the same time. Study of the Antonio de Torres guitar MDMB 626 Inside detail of the guitar Study of the vibration of the soundboard Graphic of frequencies Museu de la Música · L’Auditori C/ Lepant, 150. 08013 Barcelona · Tel. 93 256 36 50 · www.museumusica.bcn.cat A0_woodmusic.indd 1 18/03/2014 10:13:04 Royal College of Music – Museum of Music Galleria dell’Accademia – Musical Instrument Dept. COMBINED APPROACHES TO THE ATTRIBUTION AND IDENTIFICATION OF BOWED INSTRUMENTS Gabriele Rossi Rognoni ([email protected]) Introduction The Galleria dell’Accademia in Florence hosts since 2001 the Collection of Musical Instruments of the Conservatory of Music, particularly famous for ca 40 instruments from the collections of the Medici and Lorraine, grandukes of Tuscany, including the only instrument by Stradivary surviving in entirely original conditions and the earliest instrument made by the inventor of the piano. The Museum also own the largest public collection of bowed instruments attributed to makers of the Tuscan School. Documentary research The current knowledge of several making schools is still very sketchy, often limited to information about the main makers gathered from the labels of the surviving instruments. Documentary research was carried out by Gabriele Rossi Rognoni and Gloria Leitao Venceslau leading to the identification of chronological boundaries, foreign influences and external and internal connections of the makers with other schools or among families, sometimes leading to evident stylistic relationships. The research also increased considerably the number of known makers, therefore leading to a reconsideration of several attributions previously formulated “for lack of a better choice”. Wood identification The study was carried out by Marco Fioravanti (Univ. of Florence, Dept. of Environmental Forestry) and Giovanni Signorini (Univ. of Perugia, Dept. Human Sciences and Education), with the aim of defining with certainty the wood species selected by Tuscan makers for their instruments, and also to lay the fundations for the further studies on materials. The very shape and construction of bowed instruments poses difficulties such as the impossibility to take samples, varnish and preparation interfering with observation and worn down surfaces due to use. These were the main subject of a campaign of studies carried out between 2006 and 2009 that included: - Documentary research - Material studies - Identification of wood species - Dendrochronology - Dendroprovenance - CT scan - Stylistic analysis The project laid the fundations for a comparative study into the shared elements of this school, leading to a different methodological approach to the identification and attribution of bowed instruments. Dendrochronology and provenance The study was carried out by Mauro Bernabei and Jarno Bontadi (CNR/IVALSA) measuring 52 instruments using Video Time Table, a device that combines a portable dendrochronograph with a high resolution digital video camera. Results later led to the publication of a new ‘master chronology’ 558 year long (spanning 1396-1953) and eventually to a study of the provenance of the wood used for the soundboard, highlighting the preponderant use of spruce from the Appennine region, rather than the more famous Alpine wood. CT scan The possibility to compare peculiarities in model and assembling technique is at the basis of any attribution and identification of bowed instruments. For this reason all instruments were scanned, thanks to the support of the Andrea Cesalpino Institute in Terontola, using a General Electric HiSpeed CT scanner. A ‘set’ of slices was then selected for each instrument, in order to compare vaults, thicknesses and construction details such as the shape of blocks, etc. Conclusions The project allowed to radically increase current knowledge on the makers, interactions and instruments related to the Tuscan School, and is now leading to new attributions and a reconsideration of many of the previous ones. This is the result of the combination of competences and approaches that range from human sciences to hard science in a collaborative effort. Analytical study of instruments from the Ruckers family Steven Saverwyns, Marina Van Bos and Ina Vanden Berghe Royal Institute for Cultural Heritage (KIK/IRPA) ● Laboratories Department ● Jubelpark 1 ● 1000 Brussels ● Belgium [email protected] ● [email protected] ● [email protected] ● www.kikirpa.be 1. Introduction The laboratory department of the Royal Institute of Cultural Heritage (KIK/IRPA) is involved in a research project coordinated by the Musical Instruments Museum (MIM, Brussels), focussing on the study of 18 instruments made by the Ruckers dynasty. The analytical techniques applied during the study and the first results obtained on the composition of the painting palette and decorative papers, are presented. The Ruckers family were Flemish harpsichord and virginal makers based in Antwerp in the 16th and 17th century: Hans Ruckers (1540s–1598) ● Ioannes Ruckers (1578 – 1642) ● Andreas Ruckers I (1579 – after 1645) ● Andreas Ruckers II (1607- before 1667) 2. Non-invasive analyses X-ray fluorescence (XRF) is a technique producing information on the elemental composition of pigments. Besides being non-invasive, the technique is fast and the instrument transportable, making insitu analysis feasible. Micro-Raman spectroscopy (MRS) is applied complimentary to XRF, providing detailed molecular information on the composition of both inorganic and organic pigments. Pigments non-invasively identified on a virginal (MIM-1971.027) by Andreas Ruckers I (1633): Original pigments: vermillion, massicot, orpiment, lead-tin yellow type I, yellow ochre, brochantite, malachite and azurite Overpaint: vermillion, yellow ochre, ultramarine, pigment green 7 (PG7), lithopone and/or zinc white and/or barium sulphate 3. Sample analyses Using cross-sections, the stratigraphy of the paint layers is studied. Pigments are identified by scanning electron microscopy (SEM-EDX) and MRS. ©MIM The original porphyry stone imitation becomes visible after removing the overpaint (Virginal MIM-2930 by Ioannes Ruckers, 1614) The characterisation of the pulp composition of the decorative paper is executed by transmitted light microscopy using a colouring agent. Together with the applied pigments, it can give additional information to evaluate the authenticity of the decorative papers on the instrument. Cross-section from the original porphyry stone imitation (with overpaint) under white light (left) and UV light (right); original magnification 500x (Virginal MIM-2930 by Ioannes Ruckers, 1614) Other studies include the identification of green glazes (found on the original porphyry stone imitation of the exterior decoration) by FTIR, and the identification of binding media with (ATR-)FTIR (on cross-sections) and GC/MS. Comparative study of Ruckers instruments WHICH? The Antwerp Ruckers family is to the harpsichord as Stradivarius is to the violin. From the end of the 16th century, its influence is predominant and its reputation considerable. About one hundred Ruckers instruments are preserved in the world. 18 are in the mim. 4’ - Andreas - 1613 4’ - Andreas -1632 4’ - Andreas - 1613 Andreas - 1639 Hans – 17th cent. Ioannes - 1619 5’ – Ioannes & Andreas - 1604 4 ½’ - Ioannes - 1629 Hans ? – c1590 Mother & child – Ioannes - 1610 6’ - Ioannes - 1614 Hans - c1580 6’ - Andreas - 1620 Mother - Ioannes - 1628 6’ – Andreas - 1633 Ioannes Couchet - 1646 6’ – Ioannes - 1638 Hans/Taskin – 1612/1774 Dr. VANDERVELLEN Pascale - Keyboard instruments curator Project manager • DE VALCK Joris - Head of the conservation workshop Conservators coordination • EGAN Simon - Paintings conservator & photograph Photos • ESQUIROL Agnès - Paintings conservator Study of decoration FREDERICKX Manu - Harpsichords maker & conservator Technical drawings, organological study • HUART Livine - Paintings conservator Study of decoration • TERLINCK Michel - Instrument maker, draughtsman Technical drawings • Dr. VEKEMANS Marcel - Musicologist Iconographical research • mim • • • • • • • AKKERMANS Emily - Antwerp University, student in Conservation-Restoration Study of the metal roses Pr. Dr. BALÉRIAUX Danielle - Erasme Hospital, neurologist CAT scannings Dr. CURRIE Christina & FONDAIRE Catherine - Royal Institute for Cultural Heritage, scientists Scientific imagery, X-radiographs Dr. SAVERWYNS Steven & Dr. VAN BOS Marina - Royal Institute for Cultural Heritage, scientists Pigment and medium analysis VANDEN BERGHE Ina - Royal Institute for Cultural Heritage, scientist Paper analysis VERSTEEG Arjan - Instrument maker & dendrochronologist Dendrochronology of the soundboards S t u d y Repertory of soundboard decoration motifs o f Ultra-violet photo Macrophoto of the paint layers Infra-red photo d e c o r a t i o n X—ray fluorescence analysis Study of the metal roses Moldings O r g a n o l o g i c a l external CAT scanning or X-radiographs s t u d y Dendrochronology of the soundboards -research on Nikolaus Warneke [email protected] African France xylophones -making -restoration -itinerant language exhibition African xylo phones form shapes shapes form language bwamou lobi balante cerma and... sara Sara xylophone orchestra, N'Djamena, Chad, photo Marcel Filleton, 1962 bamanan malinke senoufo subjects for discussion: wooden key: the resonator: -analysis of -analysis of sound wood species makes production a sound -treatment similar to a -shape and -problems of voice? harmonics conservation the buzz membrane the tuning: scale and sonorous sound meets language Digitising Musical Instruments Collections in Africa Sa sk i a W ill a e r t - s. w ill a e r t@ m i m . b e Music al In strumen ts M useum MI M , B russels Musée de la Musique, Avenue d’Oubitrenga, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso: digitisation campaign, 10 – 22 November 2014 Musical bow, (inv. MMO-PRIMA-020) Musée de la musique de Ouagadougou. Left: July 2005; right: November 2013 Storage of the collection of musical instruments of the Musée Panafricain de la musique in Brazzaville (Congo) Kundi, Nzakara, RDC, mim inv. 1929 Lukombe, Kuba, RDC, mim inv. 1983.051 WHY? 1 Online access to musical instruments conserved in African museums is limited (exclusively through Western museums) 2 Musical heritage under threat 3 Relatively unknown but rich part of world music heritage - Diversity - Uniqueness - Reference value (historical; acoustical; sociological) HOW? PRIMA Projet Réseau International des Instruments de Musique Africains Project Partners - Musée de la musique de Ouagadougou - Musée Panafricain de la Musique, Brazzaville - Muziekinstrumentenmuseum mim, Brussels Workshops and inventory & photographic digitisation campaigns - Brussels, June 2013 - Ouagadougou, November 2013 - Brazzaville, July 2014 Tasks: - Cleaning, conserving and restoring the instruments - Measuring the instruments and determining the materials - Photographing the instruments in conformity with the MIMO digitsation standard - Encoding the metadata (MuseumPlus – Zetcom) in conformity with the MIMO standards musical instruments museum BRUSSELS RESULTS 1 Global access 2 Integration into international db: www.mimo-international.com 3 Research tool: - Contextual information : recording local names, identifying materials used (wood species), makers names (African informants) - Diversity of data - Expansion of existing thesauri - Addition to international reference works on ethnomusicology and organology 4 Growing involvement of African decision makers → more governmental resources at disposal of African museums? 5 Growing involvement of African public? 6 Better conservation of cultural world heritage; added protection against theft and losses (photographs establish proof of ownership and help with tracing an instrument & recuperation after theft) 7 Digital archive