Oklahoma City - TCN Worldwide
Transcription
Oklahoma City - TCN Worldwide
Oklahoma City 2015 Mid-Year Retail Market Summary TABLE OF CONTENTS Retail Market Summary Submarket Map 1-2 3 Quick Hits 4-5 North Submarket 6-7 Northwest Submarket 8-9 South Submarket 10-11 Edmond Submarket 12-13 West-Central Submarket 14-15 Moore / Norman Submarket 16-17 Eastern OK County Submarket 18-19 Retail Sales Summary 20-21 Von Maur Theconstruction Outlet Shoppes at Quail at Oklahoma Springs Mall City The information contained herein has been obtained from reasonably reliable sources. Price Edwards & Company makes no guarantee, either express or implied, as to the accuracy of such information. All data contained herein is subject to errors, omissions and changes. Reproduction in whole or in part, without prior written consent is prohibited. Oklahoma City 2015 Mid-Year Retail Market Summary THE RETAIL MARKET Retail is becoming a story of the haves and the have nots. The overall market vacancy ticked up to 9.3 percent at midyear from 8.25 percent at year-end. Activity in newer centers remains strong; overall vacancy in centers built since 2000 is right at 3 percent. We continue to see a shortage of quality space which is leading to new development. However, the rest of the market is not as robust. If you dig into the numbers, you see two things. First, many older centers have significant vacancy, most due to either years of deferred maintenance and/or being located in an area that is no longer a prime retail area. Smaller local tenants often have a problem paying significantly higher rents than they have in the past. Their occupancy may, therefore, be limited somewhat to the older centers which have a much lower cost basis and can meet the needs of these locals insofar as rent is concerned and create a “win-win” situation for all parties. Second, the numbers show several large neighborhood centers that have developed some vacancy due to loss of anchors, missed deals or ownership difficulties. Parkway Plaza in Norman is a good example: this center has 53,000 square feet available as it has lost some big tenants to University Northpark and has a TIC ownership structure which limits their flexibility in doing deals. A number of centers have similar stories. On our stand-alone store list, a few big boxes have become available due to closures, including four Homeland stores. With all the excitement at the top of the market, there is some churning in the mid and lower-end markets, creating more overall vacancy and increasing the distance from top to bottom. Oil & the Economy From talking with retailers and seeing the amount of activity in the market, the downturn in energy prices has had little or no effect on the retail market to date. Perhaps the best indication of national firms’ view of Oklahoma City is Kite Realty’s purchase of Belle Isle Station at a 5.4 capitalization rate (see the investment sales summary on page 21). In addition, the numbers retailers rely on - income & job growth, population growth, employment – all still look good. It’s helped that energy prices have rebounded but they remain well-below pre-downturn levels. State and city tax revenues are down as a result, OKC TOTAL RETAIL MARKET VACANCY royalty payments are down. So, while the numbers currently look good, there is still reason to pause as we look forward. Since retail tends to lag changes in the economy, it becomes a question of how long energy prices are down. If it’s an extended period, expect to see some weakness; if prices continue to rebound, we may see little long-term effect. New & Expanding Retailers The health of the upper end of our market is illustrated by the quality of new tenants either entering our market or about to enter our market. As noted for the last several reports, Walmart continues to expand and grow its footprint in Oklahoma City with three new Sam’s Clubs either open or under construction, four new Neighborhood Markets and three new or planned Supercenters. H & M announced its first Oklahoma store at Quail Springs Mall, which continues General Growth’s revitalization of the mall. Winco, which announced four stores last year, is moving forward and should start construction soon. Uptown Market, Crest, Sprouts and Natural Grocers are all adding metro locations. Grocery has been one of the OKC TOTAL RETAIL MARKET INVENTORY 12% 50 GLA SF (millions of square feet) 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Freestanding SF 40 30 20 10 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 1 OKC TOTAL RETAIL MARKET ABSORPTION 0.8 Survey Footnote: (millions of square feet) 0.7 Our survey tracks 28.3 million square feet in 242 buildings of over 25,000 square feet and 13.0 million square feet of standalone buildings for a total market of 41.3 million square feet. 0.6 0.5 0.4 There continues to be a significant number of smaller strip centers in the market (under 25,000 s.f. in size). We would estimate there are easily 3.9 million square feet of these properties in the market. 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0 2011 2012 2013 2014 most active market sectors, although we do not see one of the national full-line chains entering our market in the near term. iFLY will join Top Golf and Cabella’s at Chisolm Creek. Tenants of interest that are reportedly close to finalizing deals include Costco, REI, The Fresh Market, Trader Joes, Gander Mountain, Crate & Barrel, as well as a number of smaller boutiques. We are on the radar of a number of other name tenants as well. This interest combined with our lack of quality space is what is driving existing and planned new development. Development & Re-development The last few years, retailers and developers have responded to growing demand by expanding existing centers, building stand-alone stores, and, for smaller tenants, building small lower risk to the developer strip centers. This trend has continued. Westgate Marketplace has added approximately 40,000 square feet that includes 5 Below, Versona and Cavenders. Shops at Fox Lake is adding nearly 30,000 square feet of small shop space. Winco, as an example, is building stand-alone stores. And, we are seeing OKC Retail Market Totals 2015 a significant number of 10,000 to 20,000 square foot strip centers built throughout the market. The market has reached a point that this incremental growth has not kept up with retailer demand. Consequently, a number of larger developments are either underway or planned. Leading the way is Chisolm Creek. Chisolm Creek has already made a splash in the market by bringing in Cabela’s, Top Golf and iFLY. Their first 60,000 square foot multi-tenant building will be started later this year. This 190 acre mixed-use development will add to the retail dominance of the Memorial Corridor. Other developers are in the planning/preleasing stages of projects in the same area, including the Shoppes at Quail Springs that is currently under construction at May and Memorial. Two or three other significant Memorial Road developments are also possibilities. Westgate Marketplace is expected to start their south of Interstate 40 development in the not too distant future. 240 Penn Park is planning to add 70,000 to 100,000 square feet to their development anchored by an expanded Conns. University Northpark is pre-leasing both the restaurant space around the new park and phase three of the larger retail development. New developments in the works include the grocery anchored GBT center at Interstate 40 and Czech Hall Road, the Bridges at Springcreek in Edmond, and Highland Park Village at NW 178th street and Western. One of the more interesting is Glimcher’s addition to the Triangle at 63rd and Grand; initial plans call for a more dense, walkable, urban development unlike any other in Oklahoma City. It should be noted that retailer demand has increased rents in the market, particularly for new developments. Outparcels in front of big boxes and preferred small shop space is seeing rent above $30 per square foot and, with triple net charges included, nearing $40 per square foot in some instances. While this helps pull up rents market-wide, the benefit to many of the older, established centers has been limited, particularly those relying on primarily local tenants. GLA SF Vacant SF Vacant % 28,338,216 2,635,624 9.30 RETAIL SUBMARKET MAP 3 Apple stores are the most profitable re generating over $5,000/SF in sale U.S. Real Retail & Food Service Sales $ Billions – Seasonally Adjusted '15 '12 '13 '14 '10 '11 '07 '08 '09 '05 '06 '03 '04 98 99 '00 '01 '02 95 96 97 93 94 92 0 $100 $120 $140 $160 $180 $200 Recession U.S. Real Retail & Food Service Sales $ Billions – Seasonally Adjusted $190 $180 $170 $160 $150 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 4 etail stores, es on average Oklahoma City Quick Hits LOCAL • Plaza Mayor recently opened its Mercado in a portion of the former Dillard’s space. • Inland American is now known as InvenTrust Properties; it owns Memorial Square and Rockwell Plaza in Oklahoma City and Tulsa Hills in Tulsa. • In the past 12 months, downtown Oklahoma City has added or is close to adding nearly 190,000 square feet of retail/restaurant tenants, led by the Dust Bowl & Fassler Hall (40,000 s.f.). RETAIL •99% of shoppers veer right when entering a store, making just to the right of the entrance the prime display area 71% of retail stores have fewer than 10 employees 5 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary NORTH SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY The North Oklahoma City submarket is the highest concentration of retail in the City, 6.6 million square feet of space, and is seeing the first large-scale new development with the 190 acre mixed use Chisolm Creek and the 91,000 square foot Shoppes at Quail Springs. Submarket vacancy is a low 6.2 percent. Developers are also exploring at least three other projects along this corridor, further cementing its status as Oklahoma City’s leading retail corridor. The area around Penn Square Mall, Oklahoma’s leading mall, is probably even more highly desired among retailers, but there is limited availability of land for development. Glimcher’s proposed development at 63rd and Grand Blvd. could bring REI and a number of national boutique retailers to the City in an upscale urban setting. May Avenue was historically the primary shopping corridor in this submarket; over the past 20 years, retailers have migrated to Memorial Road and left some vacancy along May Avenue. We’ve begun to see the backfill of some of the vacancy on the May Avenue retail corridor with Natural Grocer, and the addition of the Uptown Grocer north of Britton Road, among others. Some centers with significant vacancy, like Quail Plaza, had deals in place for large tenants that didn’t get done. We view this as temporary and expect many of these holes to be filled over the second half of the year. NORTH OKC SUBMARKET ABSORPTION (thousands of square feet) NORTH 150 120 90 60 30 0 -30 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 NORTH OKC SUBMARKET VACANCY 8% 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% 0% 6 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary NORTH SUBMARKET North 50 Penn Place NW 50th St & N Pennsylvania Ave 6900 Place 6900 N May Ave Belle Isle Station NW Expressway & N Classen Blvd Britton Plaza Shopping Center 2648 W Britton Rd Britton Square N May Ave & NW Britton Rd Camelot Square NW 122nd St & N Pennsylvania Ave Casady Square Built/Updated 1973/1985/2000 1981/1991/1992 2000 1955/2000 1983 1984 1953/1983/1995 W Britton Rd & N Pennsylvania Ave Centennial Plaza 5801 N May Ave Charter At May 1993 1963/1988/1996 9494 N May Ave Classen Curve 1984 9600 N May Ave Colonial Plaza 9225 N May Ave Country Club Corner 6410 N May Ave Country Club Plaza 2800 W Country Club Dr Cross Rock Shops 3521-3561 W Memoral Rd Fenwick Plaza 16524 N Pennsylvania Ave French Market Mall 2836 NW 63rd St Gold's Gym Center 2301 W. Memorial Golden Court 1121 NW 23rd St Highland Park Retail Center W 178th St & N Western Ave Lakehurst Plaza 8025 N May Ave Lakeside Shops Shopping Center 7500 N May Ave Lakewood Shopping Center 2003 1959/1996 1970/1992/2003 2001 2009/2015 1985 1982/2008 2010 2009 1978/1990 2012 1980/2015 1978 2006 1961 NW Expressway & Independence Nichols Hills Plaza 1963 6501 Avondale Dr North Penn Plaza 5601 N Pennsylvania Ave Northpark Mall 12100 N May Ave Penn Square Mall 1901 NW Expressway Penn-Hefner Plaza 2121 W Hefner Rd Quail Plaza 10950 N May Ave Quail Springs Mall W Memorial Rd & N Pennsylvania Ave Quail Springs MarketPlace W Memorial Rd & N Pennsylvania Ave Quail Springs Village 13801 N Pennsylvania Ave Quail Village 1970/71 1971/1981 1960/1988 1973/1977 1965/1989/1991 1980/1999 1998 1983 1983 14101 N May Ave Shoppes at the Veranda 150th St & N Western Ave Spring Creek North 12200 N May Ave The Plaza at Quail Springs 2221 NW 138th St The Rise 511 NW 23rd St The Shoppes at North Pointe W Memorial Rd & N May Ave The Shops @ Quail Springs 2006 1981 2005 1920/2014 2002 2012 NW 146th & Pennsylvania The Triangle @ Classen Curve 2009 6001 N Western Town & Country Shopping Center 12325 N May Ave Village at Quail Springs 2201 W Memorial Rd Village Park South 10405 N May Ave Village Plaza 1501 - 1529 W Britton Rd Wilshire Village W Wilshire Blvd & N Western Ave North Totals Available Space Vacant Rate 1 49,502 7,091 14.32% $10.00 $8.00 433,333 4,365 1.01% $20.00 $28.00 27,340 5,050 18.47% $8.00 $11.00 27,326 0 0% $9.50 $0.00 107,799 2,800 2.60% $15.00 $0.00 158,764 42,927 27.04% $12.00 $16.00 233,794 880 0.38% $12.00 $16.00 99,757 6,000 6.01% $12.00 $15.50 93,970 8,250 8.78% $0.00 $0.00 59,000 3,040 5.15% $12.00 $0.00 86,802 44,419 51.17% $13.50 Rate 2 $16.50 1982/1992 2004 1972 1964/1973/1989 1986 Blanton Properties Tom Blanton/Laci Jackson Ravina Newmark Grubb Levy Jim Rose/Carl Archiniaco/DannyOjeda Eric Roberts 2,500 1.77% $8.00 $0.00 0 0% $16.00 $0.00 38,436 0 0% $14.00 $14.00 Medallion Management Whitney Rainbolt Westbrook Properties Gretchen Bybee CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman Hawkins Companies Ryan Manteuffel CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer CBRE/OKLA Stuart Graham Graystone Properties David Rush Pippin Properties Linette Roberts 24,578 1,350 5.49% $19.00 $20.00 41,804 2,000 4.78% $12.00 $12.00 244,724 2,345 0.96% $0.00 $0.00 66,662 0 0% $12.00 $18.00 26,000 2,750 10.58% $12.00 $16.00 42,428 7,200 16.97% $18.00 $22.00 32,637 0 0% $11.00 $12.00 68,220 2,750 4.03% $10.00 $13.00 64,937 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 $15.00 95,000 10,591 11.15% $12.00 225,000 4,881 2.17% $20.00 $23.00 54,272 3,503 6.45% $0.00 $0.00 Blanton Properties 129,670 29,200 22.52% $0.00 $0.00 Tom Blanton/Laci Jackson Ravina Steve Hetherington 32,000 1,400 4.38% $0.00 $0.00 202,106 50,506 24.99% $12.00 $18.00 1,057,000 1,036 0.10% $0.00 $0.00 69,392 0 0% $14.00 $14.00 144,335 60,104 41.64% $12.00 $17.00 1,140,038 51,623 4.53% $0.00 $0.00 410,613 1,698 0.41% $20.00 $0.00 26,350 0 0% $16.00 $20.00 49,845 13,323 26.73% $18.50 $20.00 29,712 7,313 24.61% $0.00 $0.00 89,006 4,950 5.56% $14.00 $12.00 NAI Sullivan Lee Bollinger NAI Sullivan Group David Hartnack / Sam Swanson Scott Samara,M.D. Dana Best Buy Home Depot Luby's Cafeteria Bank of America, Tuesday Morning Balliet's, Republic The Runner Cafe Pranzo 53,477 Morris Enterprises Kevyn Colburn Simon Property Group Jeff Reynolds Haydel Associates Buddy Haydel Morris Enterprises Kevyn Colburn General Growth Mgmt.,Inc. Kelly Waswo Bayer Properties Mary Beyer Lell JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin Newmark Grubb Levy John Cohlmia/Louis Almaraz/ Michael Almaraz Irish Realty Shannon Foreman JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin Land Run Commercial Anna Fresonke Price Edwards & Company George Williams/Phillip Mazaheri Blanton Properties Tom Blanton/Laci Jackson Ravina Blanton Properties Tom Blanton/Laci Jackson Ravina Brady's Properties Ali Ghaniabadi Lincoln Property Company Kim Wah Restaurant Gourmet Yarn Company Cox Communications Casa Perico's CVS Pharmacy, Walgreens Red Coyote 141,456 Oxford Group Full Circle Books Belle Isle Brewery Ted's Cafe Escondito Four Star Fitness WalMart SuperCenter Old Navy, Nordstrom Rack Johnnies' Charcoal Broiler Wal Mart Neighborhood Market JAH Realty, LP Jeff Norman/Ethan Slavin owner managed Gabby Villareal Price Edwards & Company Karleen Krywucki CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman/Stuart Graham Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/George Williams Anchor Tenants Homeland Cato Sprouts Half Price Books Fitness Together Edward Jones, Beau's Wine Bin ME/CU Credit Union McAlister's Deli Allstate Fenwick Liquor Bed Bath & Beyond Staples, Petco ATT Flagship Store Gold's Gym T-Mobile Rent-A-Center Louie's The Sushi Bar Gulfport Sea Food Movement Innovations Dance Blue Seven Bernina Sewing Ctr, Natural Grocers Stork Land & Kids Too Akin's Health Foods PetsMart, Big Lots Super Target, Marshalls DSW, Golf Galaxy Conn's Panera Bread CK & Company, S.J. Haggard & Co NORTH 6901 N May Ave Mayfair Place 2900 NW 63rd St Memorial Square 13730 N Pennsylvania Midland Center Total Space Fred Boettcher 2008 5820 NW Grand Blvd Collonade Shops Leasing Agent Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Vicki Knotts CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham CBRE Dan Shoevlin/Andrew Lehner Gerald Gamble Co. Gerald Gamble Box Real Estate David Box Blanton Properties Laci Jackson Ravina Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/George Williams CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman The Boettcher Companies Starbucks Koslow's Furs Bank of The West B.C. Clark Rococo's Apple, Dillards Macy's Buy For Less Beauty World Old School Bagel Goodyear Tire Dillard's Von Maur Old Navy, Ross, Michaels Office Depot, Ulta RadioShack Pier 1 Imports Cafe 7 Coolgreens 105,299 1,500 1.42% $14.00 $0.00 37,186 9,000 24.20% $22.00 $18.00 37,684 5,414 14.37% $15.00 $0.00 90,856 1,595 1.76% $0.00 $0.00 Perfect Tan, ER Oklahoma One Lucky Mutt CVS Pharmacy Homeland Hobby Lobby Dollar Tree Anytime Fitness Cox Cable;Interior Gilt Chase Bank Jimmy's Egg Dick's Sporting Goods 66,862 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 Whole Foods, West Elm 43,491 0 0% $12.00 $12.00 100,404 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 42,573 0 0% $7.00 $10.00 47,580 2,400 5.04% $8.00 $10.00 27,000 0 0% $11.00 $12.00 Backwoods Subway, At the Beach Gordmans Best Buy Relax the Back Fedex Westlake Hardware Dollar General Dodson Art Gallery Makeup Bar 6,576,020 405,754 6.17% Petco Anthropologie 7 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary NORTHWEST SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY The Northwest Oklahoma City submarket, which saw some improvement in occupancy in 2014, lost most of that gain in the first half of the year with vacancy declining to 14.6 from 13.4 percent. Most of the additional vacancy was at Rockwell Plaza, particularly in a back building. Rockwell may be clearing room to reconfigure and expand that area of the center. The overall Northwest submarket has seen limited activity when compared to the Memorial Road corridor to the north and the Interstate 40 corridor to the south. The Northwest submarket is one of the most mature areas of the City: much of the retail product is established neighborhood shopping centers. For many retailers, this market is their second or third choice. This is reflective of the area demographics and the distressed condition of some of these properties: the northwest submarket is characterized by established neighborhoods with limited population growth and relatively unchanged demographics. There is a sizable gap in performance between these older, poorly maintained and often ill-configured centers and the newer, well-positioned centers; eight centers have a vacancy of over 25 percent. The first significant development in this submarket is taking place at 122nd Street and MacArthur with Zerby Interests building a 70,000 square feet Sprouts anchored center, Oak Grove. 90 NORTHWEST OKC SUBMARKET ABSORPTION 20% NORTHWEST OKC SUBMARKET VACANCY 8 (thousands of square feet) NORTHWEST 60 30 15% 0 -30 10% -60 -90 5% -120 -150 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 0% 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary NORTHWEST SUBMARKET Northwest Built/Updated 122nd & MacArthur 1985 12203 Warwick 2016 NW 39th St 1982 2016 NW 39th St Brixton Square 1985 7101 NW Expressway Cornerstone Plaza NW 39th St & N MacArthur Blvd Council Crossing 8101 NW Expressway Courtyard Plaza 4200 NW Expressway Lakeshore Shops 7930 N MacArthur Blvd MacArthur Shops W Britton Rd & N MacArthur Blvd Market Place OKC 1958/1978/2003 1986/1992/2003 1984 2002 1998 1983 1985 5501 NW Expressway Market Plaza 1981/1982 7001 NW Expressway Mayfair Village 1948/1990 Peppertree Square 6444 NW Expressway Portland Plaza NW 39th St & N Portland Ave Quailbrook Plaza 1972 1983/2000 1996/1998 1984 1994 1987 4401 W Memorial Rd Rock Center 1982 6714 NW Expressway Rockwell Crossing 1986 12100 N Rockwell Ave Rockwell Northwest 7000 NW Expressway Rockwell Plaza 1985/1999 1981/2000 7104 NW Expressway 2000 Springbrook Shopping Center 1968 6207 NW Expressway 2014 NW 50th St & N Meridian Ave Walnut Village 1986/2000 NW 122nd St & N MacArthur Blvd Northwest Totals 34,000 3,100 9.12% $4.00 $10.00 Dollar General 33,408 9,662 28.92% $8.00 $8.00 Goodwill 122,042 16,229 13.30% $8.00 $13.00 65,285 7,500 11.49% $6.50 $8.50 141,112 55,340 39.22% $12.50 $3.75 38,998 5,900 15.13% $14.00 $15.00 Panera Bread, Fit For Her Party Galaxy Family Dollar, City Bites Ocean Dental Goodwill Chelino's Knockouts Haircuts GBR Properties NAI Sullivan Group David Hartnack JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham/ Mark Inman Oxford Group Gaby Villarreal Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Price Edwards & Company Rosha Wood Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Louis Almaraz/Michael Almaraz CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham/ Mark Inman Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/ George Williams Charles Shadid Charles Shadid ORDA Corporation Gena Hurst Core Real Estate Jim Sanders Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Jim Rose JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin Price Edwards & Company George Williams/Phillip Mazaheri Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort John Cohlmia NAI Sullivan Group David Hartnack/Sam Swanson JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin CBRE/OKLA CBRE/OKLA Stuart Graham/Ryan Storer Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Louis Almaraz/Michael Almaraz Grace Commercial Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort 1960/1994 1995 Core Real Estate Jim Sanders NAI Sullivan Group 139,447 22,383 16.05% $0.00 $0.00 33,140 0 0% $5.00 $8.00 23,645 5,600 23.68% $9.00 $0.00 178,854 25,163 14.07% $12.00 $12.00 Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Academy Sporting Goods Planet Fitness Freedom Pawn Al's Bicycles Farmers Insurance Spotted Zebra Bike One, Vatterott College Subway Tuesday Morning, ALDI 152,726 17,805 11.66% $6.00 $12.00 174,911 58,886 33.67% $12.00 $10.00 Michael's 25,740 0 0% $5.00 $6.00 143,579 25,698 17.90% $0.00 $0.00 34,640 25,100 72.46% $7.00 $12.00 7-Eleven Sunshine Laundry Family Leisure TJ Maxx Cal's Deli Nailtique 77,171 23,434 30.37% $8.00 $9.00 Allstate, My Dentist 103,312 2,612 2.53% $0.00 $0.00 90,389 2,000 2.21% $15.00 $12.00 AAA of Oklahoma Locke Supply Panera Bread 29,000 6,000 20.69% $10.00 $10.50 H&R Block 30,200 7,700 25.50% $14.00 $12.00 Express Tag Agency YMCA 154,944 6,345 4.10% $20.00 $12.00 414,507 79,157 19.10% $0.00 $0.00 700,000 11,783 1.68% $15.00 $20.00 50,000 10,000 20% $12.00 $12.00 10 Gym Fitness 126,000 13,778 10.93% $8.00 $8.00 Dollar General Super Mercado Moreles 53,088 13,900 26.18% $15.00 $0.00 Fortune Chinese 34,400 17,400 50.58% $8.00 $12.00 31,804 7,627 23.98% $7.00 $9.00 60,433 0 0% $4.00 $11.00 Westlake Hardware Steinmart Mercy Health System Pizza Hut David Hartnack 1985 Anchor Tenants Gentle Dental Michael Almaraz 6909 W Hefner Rd Warwick Plaza Rate 2 Mary R. Grace 12301 N Rockwell Ave Warr Acres Shops NW 50th St & N MacArthur Blvd Warwick Crossing Rate 1 Mark Inman Silver Springs Pointe 7640 NW Expressway Springdale Vacant Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort John Cohlmia CBRE/OKLA Stuart Graham/Mark Inman/ Ryan Storer Available Space NORTHWEST NW 50th St & N May Ave Newport 9120 N MacArthur Blvd OKC Market Square 8400 NW Expressway Olympia Plaza 7202 W Hefner Rd Total Space Randy Vaillancourt 6401 NW Expressway Lakeshore Shopping Center Leasing Agent John Cohlmia Hobby Lobby Hancock Fabrics Target Ross Dress for Less, PetSmart Wal-Mart Home Depot Leslie's Pool Supplies Goodwill Big Red Shop Flexible Fitness Watch Me Grow Childcare Dollar General Subway, Eden Salon 3,296,775 480,102 14.56% 9 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary SOUTH SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY The South OKC submarket is another market that experienced a rise in vacancy. Vacancy on June 30 was 13.6 percent as compared to 10.6 at year-end, a sizable increase. Digging into the figures shows a general increase, but a concentration in about 5 centers that either lost an anchor or saw a few move-outs. The 13.6 percent vacancy is consistent with historic levels, and, for now, should not be cause for concern. The South submarket is comprised of predominantly neighborhood centers and stand-alone buildings. Much attention has been paid to the I-240 corridor with the Envision 240; currently, an effort is underway to make this corridor a Business Improvement District which, if adopted, should solidify the area for retail in the long-run. Retailers along this corridor tend to do quite well which is not always the perception since the corridor is somewhat fragmented among uses and is not the most shopper friendly area. The northern half of this submarket is heavily reliant on the Hispanic shopper. Plaza Mayor recently added its Mercado area in a portion of the former Dillards. Its progress has been slow to date and the project is in need of an anchor. Its too early to judge its success but still has the potential to transform the east end of this corridor and be the center of Hispanic retail. 240 Penn Park is pre-leasing a 70,000 square foot addition to the west of its current location; this will be anchored by an expanded Conn’s store. The planned improvements, incremental growth and Plaza Mayor should further strengthen the area. SOUTH OKC SUBMARKET VACANCY 15% SOUTH 12% 9% 6% 3% 0% 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 SOUTH OKC SUBMARKET ABSORPTION 60 (thousands of square feet) 40 20 0 -20 -40 -60 -80 -100 -120 10 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary SOUTH SUBMARKET South Built/Updated Leasing Agent Total Space Rate 2 Anchor Tenants 0% $18.00 $0.00 Ross, Marshalls 0 0% $4.00 $0.00 Family Dollar 240 Penn Park 2005 CBRE/OKLA 242,023 0 29th & Kentucky Shops 1970 L & S Real Estate 32,500 1409 W I-240 SW 29th St & S Kentucky Ave Mark Inman/Stuart Graham Available Space Vacant Rate 1 Young Shin PetSmart New Century Food 74 South Centre 1973/1977/2006 Paul B. Odom Construction 50,000 9,600 19.20% $14.00 $16.00 At the Beach 89'er Plaza 1984 Lauren Weyhe 30,000 0 0% $6.00 $7.00 The Vintage Cowgirl Airline 1999 Charles Shadid 121,368 17,000 14.01% $3.00 $5.00 Tom's Tires Price Edwards & Company 107,676 55,928 51.94% $0.00 $0.00 Charles Shadid 58,249 2,800 4.81% $5.00 $8.00 SW 74th St & S Pennsylvania Ave SW 89th St & S Walker Ave Paul Odom L 3400 SW 29th St Almonte Square 6100 S May Ave 89th Street Liquor El Rodeo Carnecaria 1963 Everest Ernst Oklahoma Metropolitan Library Family Dollar, Planet Fitness Brookwood North I & II 1998 Brookwood Shopping Center 1979/2012 Precor Ruffin 80,615 26,926 33.40% $9.00 $12.00 Centre 8400 1984 Precor Ruffin, LLC 29,355 1,560 5.31% $9.00 $9.00 Chatenay Square 2000 PB Odom, III 114,115 2,000 1.75% $16.50 $0.00 Country Park Shopping Center 1978 Jireh Properties 24,360 0 0% $6.00 $6.00 Crest Center 2010 Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort 96,000 2,700 2.81% $17.50 $20.00 Crest Foods Crossroads Shopping Center 1987 Precor Ruffin 31,282 30,000 95.90% $10.00 $0.00 Concentra Medical Ctr Economy Square 1963/98 Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort 203,451 2,800 1.38% $18.00 $20.00 Big Lots Grant Square 1958/1991/1992 Price Edwards & Company 103,810 9,690 9.33% $8.00 $5.00 Family Dollar Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort 117,251 13,323 11.36% $18.50 $20.00 Westlake Hardware Blanton Properties 50,000 30,000 60% $6.00 $8.00 Rent-A-Center Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort 27,120 1,200 4.42% $8.00 $8.00 Pro Nails Lightning Creek Complex 48,005 2,700 5.62% $8.00 $0.00 Costume Shop, Allstate Haydel Associates 38,000 0 0% $5.00 $5.00 Paul B. Odom Construction 49,003 8,000 16.33% $16.50 $0.00 Pizza Hut, Jump Zone JAH Realty, L.P. 69,488 15,000 21.59% $12.00 $7.00 Buy For Less Super Mercardo Zerby Interests 157,663 15,055 9.55% $8.00 $17.00 Langston's Western Wear Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort 36,000 8,000 22.22% $12.00 $17.00 South Park 86,848 17,369 20% $0.00 $0.00 Messiah Church Quan Minh Nguyen 90,000 12,575 13.97% $7.00 $12.00 Family Dollar Buy For less SW 89th St & S Western Ave SW 89th St & S Western Ave 8400 S Western Ave SW 104th St & Pennsylvania Ave 5906 S Agnew Ave 3000 SW 104th 7100 S. I-35 Service Rd. SW 29th St & S May Ave SW 44th St & S Pennsylvania Ave Rick Pritchett Rick Pritchett PB Odom, III Jess Hwang John Cohlmia Rick Pritchett Michael Almaraz/Louis Almaraz Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/George Williams Hillcrest Shopping Center 1971 I-240 Plaza 1988 Lightning Creek 1985 Mayridge Shopping Center 1956 Palagio Shops 2005 Reding Shopping Center 1972 Shields Plaza 1972/85/92/2005/2011 South Meridian Plaza 1983 South Park 1975 South Penn Plaza 1984 Southeast Plaza 1964 HGM Inv. 185,266 13,300 7.18% $4.29 $4.50 Southern Hills 1964/1989/1990 CBRE/OKLA 202,247 30,016 14.84% $9.00 $21.00 Southwestern Plaza 1962/87 Coldwell Banker Commercial 127,406 17,068 13.40% $7.00 $0.00 Stonebriar Shopping Center 2005 Brady Properties 30,000 1,300 4.33% $12.00 $0.00 2100 SW 59th St 7800 S Western 8100 S Western Ave SW 44th St & May Ave SW 104th St & S Western Ave Grand Blvd & S Western Ave SW 74th & S Shields Blvd 1025 S Meridian Ave 4500 S May Ave 1620 SW 89th St SE 44th St & S High Ave SW 74th St & S Pennsylvania Ave SW 59th St & S Western Ave 13316 S Western Ave Laci Jackson Ravina Carl Archiniaco/Jim Rose Debra Gutierrez Buddy Haydel Paul Odom III Ethan Slavin Michael Rapella Michael Almaraz/Jim Rose Henry Russell Hunt, Jr. Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham Jack James/Jerry Hocker Planet Fitness Goodwill H&R Block Citi Financial Homeland Panera Bread Value Thrift Cox Cable Walgreens, Griders Food Ali Ghaniabadi Tuesday Morning Jackson Hewitt State Farm, Jewel Box Dollar General El Chico Burlington, Fallas Waffle House State Farm Family Dollar Northern Tool Joe's Crab Shack Cocina De Mino Restaurant Family Dollar Studio Art Photography Allied Medical, Adams Chiropractic Summit Pointe Plaza 2008 Equity Commercial Realty 30,414 2,400 7.89% $15.75 $0.00 SW 119th Street Marketplace 2009 Price Edwards & Company 28,676 6,000 20.92% $14.00 $14.00 Lemon Grass Towne South Center 2004/2005/2010 Price Edwards & Company 130,000 34,461 26.51% $15.00 $15.00 Heartland Dental Walker Square 1983 Precor Ruffin 100,430 34,461 34.31% $9.00 $14.00 El Mariachi Super Marcado Walnut Square 1985 Price Edwards & Company 316,351 19,533 6.17% $12.00 $14.00 Big Lots, Hobby Lobby CBRE/OKLA 104,000 21,335 20.51% $6.00 $10.00 Taste of China Brady Properties 79,500 3,325 4.18% $12.00 $12.00 Westminster Executive Suite 3,428,472 467,425 13.63% SW 89th St & S Western Ave 801 SW 119th St SW 74th St & S Walker Ave SW 59th St & S Walker Ave 2209 SW 74th St Westernview Center 1958/78 Westminster Village 1986 7107 S Western Ave 10601 S Western Ave South Totals Judy Hatfield Susan Brinklety George Williams/Phillip Mazaheri Rick Pritchett Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/George Williams Ryan Storer SOUTH 1985 Jim Rose Chelino's Restaurant Aaron Rents Greenway Plaza SW 119th St & S Western Ave China Wok Restaurant Louie's Papa Murphys Chuck E Cheese Superior Loan Conn's Dollar General Ali Ghaniabadi 11 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary EDMOND SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY EDMOND The Edmond market saw little change in vacancy during the first half of the year, ending June at 8.9 percent. Edmond Marketplace, near the end of their renovation, has accounted for nearly 3 percent of the overall market vacancy. They have secured Natural Grocers as an anchor and are in the process of leasing the small-shop space; as a result, market vacancy should improve over the remainder of the year. With the market as tight as it is, several developers are working on new projects, including the Bridges at Springcreek, the addition of small shop space at Shops at Fox Lake, and the hotel/convention center anchored development at Interstate 35 and Covell being done by Raptor. Edmond is not typically the first choice of most retailers but virtually all multi-store retailers want to be in the market. Edmond’s demographics, particularly incomes and disposable spending, lead all Oklahoma City submarkets, making it very attractive for retailers. National retail is moving to Interstate locations; it will be interesting to see if Interstate 35 in Edmond can become one of these high growth retail nodes or if its too close to the Memorial Road corridor. EDMOND SUBMARKET ABSORPTION (thousands of square feet) 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 EDMOND SUBMARKET VACANCY 15% 12% 9% 6% 3% 0% 12 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary EDMOND SUBMARKET Edmond 33rd & Boulevard E 33rd St & S Boulevard St Alta Mesa 301 S Bryant Ave Berkshire Plaza W 15th St & S Broadway Boulevard Village 3404-3456 S Boulevard St Broadway South 3320 S Broadway Broadway Square 3601 S Broadway Bryant Square Leasing Agent 1982 Lee Segal Lee Segal JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin Foraker Co Jeremy Foraker Irish Realty Misty Doney NAI Sulivan Group Nicole Mayes Land Run Commercial Anna Fresonke CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman/Stuart Graham Newmark Grubb Levy Beffort Carl Archiniaco/Jim Rose Land Run Commercial Anna Fresonke Price Edwards & Company Ev Ernst/George Williams JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman/Stuart Graham/Ryan Storer Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/George Williams Sooner Investment Brad Goodwin Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley Matrix David Lide Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Carl Archiniaco/Jim Rose Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Jim Rose Midcon Property Management Greg Blakely Coury Properties Sam Coury Wiggin Properties Mote Nickel Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley Key Investments 2008 2002 1985 1977 1968/1994 1973/1992 E 2nd St& N Bryant Ave Danforth Plaza 2003 2000 W Danforth Rd Danforth Square W Danforth Rd & S Kelly Ave 1999 Edmond Crossing 1995 24 E 33rd St Edmond Exchange 3233 S Broadway Edmond Market Place 2003 3301 S Boulevard Edmond Plaza 1964/1989/2005 E 15th St & Broadway Ext. Edmond Trails 289 S Santa Fe Ave 2007 Homestead Center 2003 W Danforth Rd & N Santa Fe Ave Kelly Centre Shopping Center 610 S Kelly Ave 2003 Kelly Plaza 1984 W Edmond Rd & S Kelly Ave Kickingbird Square 1983/88 1323 W Danforth Rd Market Depot 3409 S. Broadway North Oaks 821 W Danforth Rd Oak Brook 2113 W Edmond Rd 1965 1983/1989 1982/1992/2015 Oxford Pointe Shops 1986 E 2nd St & S Bryant Ave Pebble Creek W Danforth Rd & N Santa Fe Ave 2001 Shoppes On Broadway 2008 E 33rd St & S Broadway Signal Shops LLC 1700 S Kelly Ave Spring Creek Plaza 1986 2000 E 15th St & S Bryant Ave Spring Creek Village of Edmond 2007 E 15th St & S Bryant Ave University Plaza 3 E 2nd St & S Bryant Ave 2000 University Village II 2000 2011 E 2nd St & S Bryant Ave Uptown Grocery Center 1230 W. Covell Village Center Plaza Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley/Everest Ernst/George Williams Fotis Bargeliotes Fotis Bargeliotes Ward Construction Amanda Ward, Kent Ward Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Michael Almaraz/Louis Almaraz Sooner Investment Brad Goodwin Total Space Available Space Vacant Rate 1 Rate 2 Anchor Tenants 0 0% $7.00 $0.00 30,908 1,550 5.01% $26.00 $0.00 35,612 1,800 5.05% $12.00 $15.00 36,604 7,122 19.46% $0.00 $0.00 61,524 3,000 4.88% $15.00 $0.00 91,055 4,597 5.05% $12.00 $14.50 278,198 19,787 7.11% $0.00 $0.00 Mardel's Family Dollar Qdoba, Edward Jones Panda Express Office Depot Nhinja Sushi & Wok Pizza Hut McBride Clinic Edmond Music Courtyard Antiques City Bites Duncan Bros Salon Bed Bath & Beyond 49,400 Steinmart 30,282 7,996 26.41% $10.00 $12.00 108,000 2,400 2.22% $14.00 $0.00 Twid's Star Steps 151,664 30,713 20.25% $12.00 $16.00 Homeland 71,218 11,030 15.49% $0.00 $0.00 96,974 52,848 54.50% $0.00 $0.00 TJ Maxx Edmond Totals Natural Grocers 158,373 1,150 0.73% $8.00 $14.00 25,215 1,500 5.95% $14.00 $12.00 Westlake Hardware YMCA of Edmond Spinal Wellness Center 39,000 0 0% $14.00 $0.00 Anytime Fitness 43,769 7,000 15.99% $12.00 $12.00 Buffalo Wild Wings Dance Makers Kim Massay Dance Studio 87,503 9,839 11.24% $10.50 $12.00 Big Lots, Staples Colortyme Thrift Elite Store 110,000 0 0% $14.00 $0.00 Regal Cinema Interurban 82,325 0 0% $12.00 $18.00 70,672 12,000 16.98% $12.00 $12.00 43,006 12,230 28.44% $12.50 $0.00 Alfredo Westlake Hardware Dollar General Homeland 26,600 0 0% $10.50 $12.00 The Archives 107,944 0 0% $18.00 $0.00 The Vision Center Kohl's, LA Fitness Dollar Tree 160,000 7,550 4.72% $18.00 $22.00 Hobby Lobby 35,000 0 0% $9.00 $10.00 62,000 4,900 7.90% $25.00 $28.00 Physician's PM Daylight Donuts Talbots, Jos. A Bank Charleston's IO Metro Chico's, Panera Bread 72,273 11,823 16.36% $22.00 $28.00 Legacy Bank, Starbucks Louie's, Lucca 10,200 2.55% $16.00 $18.00 Sooner Investment 76,500 12,826 16.77% $16.00 $22.00 Brad Goodwin Esperanza Real Estate Investments Susan Binkoski 73,350 7,500 10.22% $21.00 $0.00 Target Super Center Lowe's Wal Mart Neighborhood Market Pei Wei, AT&T Uptown Grocery Juice Blendz Cafe 27,656 2,000 7.23% $20.00 $17.00 31,200 2,400 7.69% $0.00 $0.00 2,773,825 245,701 8.86% 805 - 755 W. Covell Willow Creek E 2nd St & N Santa Fe Ave On the Border Traditions, Delta Cafe 400,000 2008 Payless Shoe Source At the Beach EDMOND Built/Updated Pampered Pets Old School Bagel 1985 Coury Properties Tina Newton Edward Jones Family Dentistry 13 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary WEST–CENTRAL SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY The West Central submarket vacancy ended mid-year at 8.0 percent vacancy up from 6.7 percent. About a third of the increase was vacancy at Chisholm; the rest was a general increase in the older centers across the market. As with much of the rest of the submarkets, the newer properties in the area are doing well with a continued focus on Interstate 40. Westgate added a little over 40,000 square feet of space that was already leased to Cavenders, Versona and 5 Below, bringing the development to nearly 1 million square feet. Westgate has commitments in place to expand to the south side of Interstate 40 although timing is uncertain. Westgate Marketplace, Yukon Village, and West End Pointe and the Outlet Shoppes of Oklahoma comprise nearly half the total product in the submarket and an even higher percentage of sales. The corridor draws not only from the Interstate 40 traffic but from a large swath of homes north of Interstate 40 that have limited access to retail, particularly new retail. Incomes of the area aren’t great, but density is high. GBT’s on-again, off-again development at Interstate 40 and Czech Hall Road appears to be moving forward. WEST–CENTRAL The Interstate 40 and Portland area, home to 34 stores, containing over 2.0 million square feet that specializes in furniture and accessories, remains the hub of furniture sales for the City. Mathis Brothers is finishing up the construction of a new warehouse/distribution center which will allow it to remodel and expand its flagship store at the corner of Interstate 44 & Interstate 40. 10% WEST−CENTRAL SUBMARKET VACANCY 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% (thousands of square feet) 500 2012 2013 2014 2015 WEST−CENTRAL SUBMARKET ABSORPTION 400 300 200 100 0 -100 14 2011 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary WEST–CENTRAL SUBMARKET West-Central 36th & May Center SW 36th St & S May Ave Ann Arbor Terrace 4913 NW 23 St Chisholm I-40 & Garth Brooks Blvd DeVille Shopping Center 2408 N. Council Road Glen Oaks NW 23rd St & N Rockwell Ave Indiana Center 1708 N Indiana Ave MacArthur Court Built/Updated 1986 1971 1979/1982 1962/92/94 1968/98 2002 1985 3804 N MacArthur Blvd MacArthur Park 2300 N MacArthur Blvd 1997 Meridian Plaza 1959 4546 NW 16th St Morgan Creek Plaza 1701 S Morgan Rd 1988 Mustang Shopping Center 2004 1983 1974 2010 1994 1970/2012 1958/1987 1994 1965 1974/1994 1958/1991 NW 10th St & N Meridian Ave The Plaza Shoppes of Yukon 1986/2000 915-951 S Cornwell Dr Walnut Creek 1110 N MacArthur Blvd 1974 West End Pointe 2001 I-40 & Garth Brooks Blvd West Pointe Shoppes 700 S Mustang Rd Westgate Marketplace 2006 2000/2014 I-40 & S MacArthur Blvd 1964 NW 10th St & N Rockwell Ave Westpoint Plaza 2000 320 S Mustang Rd Windsor Hills 1982 1960/1998 4601 NW 23rd St Windsor Park 2500 N Meridian Ave Yukon Hills S Cornwell Dr & E Vandament Ave Yukon Shopping Center I-40 & Garth Brooks Blvd Yukon Village I-40 & Garth Brooks Blvd West-Central Totals Vacant Rate 1 Rate 2 Anchor Tenants 0% $9.00 $0.00 Pole Position Raceway Feria Latina Super Market Ultimate Thrift Store Planet Fitness, Hibbet Sports Tuesday Morning Buy For Less Heart & Hand Thrift Westlake Hardware Anytime Fitness Discount Dollar Store Bad Granny's B.D. Eddie Enterprises Terry McGuire 97,500 0 30,000 8,000 26.67% $6.00 $0.00 CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham 227,630 60,950 26.78% $5.00 $10.00 125,407 24,004 19.14% $3.00 $4.00 JAH Realty, L.P. Ethan Slavin 49,161 8,220 16.72% $18.00 $6.00 26,000 0 0% $5.00 $9.00 51,198 29,900 58.40% $12.50 $13.50 55,506 0 0% $5.00 $8.00 Community Thrift Store Queen of Sheba Restaurant 92,353 15,220 16.48% $6.00 $0.00 James Lighting 39,530 4,620 11.69% $8.64 $10.05 Dollar General Salon 152 35,846 0 0% $16.00 $0.00 CATO 106,850 2,050 1.92% $7.00 $7.00 82,730 10,000 12.09% $8.00 $4.00 406,835 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 133,356 3,500 2.62% $10.00 $0.00 26,892 6,400 23.80% $4.00 $8.00 Ingrid's Pantry 38,000 0 0% $4.00 $0.00 25,308 3,000 11.85% $3.50 $0.00 Sam's Wholesale Liquor OK Family Thrift Samaritan Services 40,736 0 0% $14.00 $16.00 CVS 88,851 15,641 17.60% $7.00 $10.00 Tractor Supply 33,100 17,200 51.96% $8.00 $9.00 Beauty World 32,600 9,600 29.45% $10.00 $11.00 Tony’s Pizzeria 52,822 10,400 19.69% $3.00 $4.00 522,500 0 0% $22.00 $12.00 Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Louis Almaraz/Michael Almaraz Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Jim Rose/Michael Almaraz Westbrook Properties Gretchen Bybee Schostak Brothers & Company Rebecca Dragin LandRun Commercial Anna Fresonke National Properties Ray Wright Horizon Group Mall Manager CBRE/OKLA Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Charles Johnson, DDS Chuck Johnson Harry Pro Realty Greg Downs Price Edwards & Company Susan Brinkley/Ev Ernst/ George Williams Price Edwards & Co Susan Brinkley/Everest Ernst/George Williams Ferguson Company Jim Ferguson/Lee Spivey/ Debbie Servati Charles Shadid Charles Shadid McGee Commercial Real Estate Chris Reed NAI Sulivan Group David Hartnack Zerby Interests 1982 1975 Baker First Commercial Real Estate Lori Petit NAI Sullivan Group David Hartnack/Sam Swanson Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Arc Real Estate Investor Solutions Sam Vinall Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Jim Rose JAH Realty, L.P. 2005 2009 Dollar Tree Dollar General Factory Connection Locke Supply Nike, Brooks Brothers Coach Outlet, Anne Taylor Loft Wal Mart Neighborhood Market Dollar Tree, CitiTrends, Westlake Salvation Army Turtle Creek Wine Thermo Roll Shutters Lowe's, Staples Kohl's, Gold's Gym Ultimate Vision SuperCuts, All American Pizza Wal Mart, Panera Bread, Home Depot Best Buy, Ulta, Dick's Sporting Goods 27,004 0 0% $13.00 $15.00 900,500 36,000 4% $0.00 $0.00 93,270 0 0% $3.90 $3.90 Family Dollar 25,680 4,400 17.13% $10.00 $12.00 Cabinet Outlet Subway 160,000 69,700 43.56% $4.00 $6.00 Oriental Imports McSalty's Pizza 256,250 9,200 3.59% $5.00 $13.00 Crest Foods, Cato 26,000 1,215 4.67% $10.00 $11.00 Ci Ci's Pizza $8.00 SuperCuts Dollar General Hunan Express Fitness 19, DD's Discount 125,465 5,173 4.12% $15.00 Ethan Slavin Schostak Brothers & Company Rebecca Dragin Chase Properties Brendon Ruth Jersey Mikes Red River Credit Michael Rapella Westoaks Village Will Rogers 3000 N Portland Ave Available Space Ryan Storer 101 N Mustang Rd Ten-M Total Space WEST–CENTRAL 216 N Mustang Mall Terr Mustang Trade Center Hwy 152 & S Mustang Rd. Old Mill 301 Elm Ave Outlet Shops of Oklahoma NE C of 1-40 & Council Rd Penn Crossing NW 23rd St & N Pennsylvania Ave Plaza DeVille 2409 N Council Road Portland Square NW 23rd St & N Portland Ave Rockglen Retail Center 1500 N Rockwell Ave Shartel Plaza 5225 N Shartel Ave Silver City Town Center Leasing Agent Buy For Less 211,500 1,200 0.57% 332,571 9,557 2.87% 4,578,951 365,150 7.98% $14.00 $0.00 $16.00 Dollar Tree $0.00 Cato Target, Hobby Lobby Big Lots, Petsmart 15 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary MOORE–NORMAN SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY The Moore-Norman market saw a marked increase in vacancy during the first six months of the year, ending June at 7.7 percent, up from 5.1 percent at the end of 2014. As you look at the numbers, about half the increase is attributable to a general increase in vacancy across the market. The other half is holes in centers like Parkway Plaza which is 375,000 square feet that is now 14 percent vacant. University North Park has also experience some modest vacancy as a few of the first generation tenants have vacated. We see most of the activity in this market as normal market dynamics; the submarket remains strong with the Fritt’s Farm Market area continuing to be a draw and the third phase of University North Park being marketed. Overall, this submarket is a highly desirable location for retailers – incomes are good and housing density is high. The strong performance should continue. 8% MOORE−NORMAN SUBMARKET VACANCY 200 7% (thousands of square feet) 150 6% 5% MOORE–NORMAN 4% 16 3% 2% 100 50 0 -50 -100 1% 0% MOORE−NORMAN SUBMARKET ABSORPTION 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 -150 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary MOORE–NORMAN SUBMARKET Moore-Norman 550 24th Ave NW Built/Updated Leasing Agent 1984/2011 Equity Commercial Realty Judy Hatfield Price Edwards & Company Rosha Wood Equity Commercial Realty Gayla Artman Home Creations Mo Price Edwards & Company Rosha Wood Equity Commercial Realty, LLC Judy Hatfield Gus Gianos Family Partnership Peter Gianos Heather O'Connell Heather O'Connell CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham 550 24th Ave NW Alameda Square 1984 12th Ave SE & E Alameda St Anatole 1985 12th Ave SE & E Alameda St Broadway Plaza 2200 N Broadway St 2004 Brookhaven Village 1985 36th Ave NW & W Robinson St Campus Corner Shops 1911/1993 301 W Boyd St Carriage Plaza 2001 W Main St Center on Main 500 Main St Colonial Estates 1983 1965 Ren. 1988 12th Ave SE & E Lindsey St Total Space Available Space Vacant Rate 1 Rate 2 Anchor Tenants 31,558 3,217 10.19% $13.00 $13.00 Sooner Bowler Center 93,858 12,408 13.22% $14.00 $10.00 Gold's Gym 64,555 13,278 20.57% $14.00 $0.00 Harbor Freight Tools 31,588 1,200 3.80% $14.00 $14.00 Home Creation Remax/Elite Dollar Tree 153,277 21,200 13.83% $0.00 $0.00 Chico's, White House Black Market The Health Club, The Loft 225,000 4,200 1.87% $16.00 $18.00 747, CVS 25,500 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 The Webb 107,000 2,250 2.10% $0.00 $0.00 104,225 31,325 30.06% $9.00 $0.00 Louie's, Lucca Cayman's Sprouts Firestone Buy for Less Dollar General Cleveland County Health Dept. (shadow tenant) Dollar General Subway Athletic Loft Home Depot,Hemisphere's Target; Dick's Sporting Goods Homeland, Ace Hardware East Moore Shopping Center 2006 Grace Commercial 24,484 1,080 4.41% $9.00 $9.00 406 S Eastern Ave Empire Plaza 3040- 3058 Classen Blvd 2006 Mary Grace Dillard Group Scott Heiple 30,000 2,980 9.93% $13.00 $13.00 2006/2012 TBP LLC Development 453,550 0 0% $24.00 $26.00 93,000 5,475 5.89% $13.00 $15.00 127,600 980 0.77% $0.00 $0.00 30,359 30,359 106.42% $20.00 $20.00 21,000 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 Advance America Cash Armstrong McCall 33,753 0 0% $9.00 $13.50 Play It Again Sports Fritts Farm SW 19th Street & Telephone Rd Heisman Square Terry Fritts 1999 12th Ave SE & E Alameda St 1964 2014 480 24th NW Malibu Shopping Center 824 NW 12th St 2006 Merkle Creek 1985 2203 W Main St Moore Towne Center I-35 & SW 19th St New City Center 605 N Moore Ave. Normandy Creek 2200 W Main St North Park Center 1024 N Flood Parkway Plaza Gayla Artman Riverwalk Plaza 35,000 1,800 5.14% $17.50 $0.00 1963/1998 Precor Ruffin, LLC 181,170 25,383 14.01% $9.00 $15.00 107,366 10,000 9.31% $12.00 $14.00 37,000 18,000 48.65% $8.00 $10.00 375,000 52,973 14.13% $10.00 $19.00 Barnes & Noble 152,720 3,960 2.59% $18.00 $0.00 Maurice's Midwest Regional Hospital Integris Physical Therapy Alfredo's 1974 1960 1996 2000 2000 2006 2713 S I-35 Service Rd Robinson Crossing 1300 N Interstate Dr Shops at Moore Power Center 1986/1989 2007/2014 2650 S I-35 Rd Silver Leaf NE 12th St & N Eastern Ave Sooner Mall 1985 1976/1988/1999 I-35 & W Main St Sooner Shopping Center NW 5th St & N Broadway St 1966 Sooner West Plaza 1981 36th Ave SW & W Main St Stubbeman Village Elm Ave & Elmwood Dr The Main Center 24th & Main St University Town Center 1972 2005 2008 1500 24th Ave NW West Port Shopping Center 1200 N Santa Fe Ave Moore-Norman Totals World Acceptance Corporation McAlester's Mazzios Pizza Aarons, Supermercados Morelos Family Dollar Hastings Books Party Galaxy NAI Sullivan Group David Hartnack I-35 & SW 19th St 2109-2139 Riverwalk Dr Riverwalk Shops Homeland Hancock Fabric In Lease-Up 2005 520 - 700 Ed Noble Parkway Riverwalk Centre At the Beach 1980 Rick Pritchett Raptor Properties Heidi Vanlandingham owner managed NAI Sullivan Group Davdi Hartnack/Sam Swanson CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham/Mark Inman Precor Ruffin, LLC Rick Pritchett CBRE/OKLA Ryan Storer/Stuart Graham Brady's Properties Ali Ghaniabadi CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman/Stuart Graham Bright Star Realty Sun Lee General Growth Properties Steve Hughes Buchanan Realty Steve Buchanan Equity Commercial Realty, LLC Gayla Artman University of Oklahoma HEW Marketing, Inc. Heather Warrington CBRE/OKLA Mark Inman/Stuart Graham NAI Sullivan David Hartnack MOORE–NORMAN Hollywood Center 1600 W Lindsey St Madison Square Shopping Center CBRE/OKLA Stuart Graham/Ryan Storer Capital Realty Wendy Foreman CBRE/OKLA Stuart Graham/Mark Inman/Ryan Storer Gerald Gamble Co. Gerald Gamble Equity Commercial Realty, LLC Bed Bath & Beyond Gordman's 26,939 2,853 10.59% $15.00 $15.00 34,200 3,000 8.77% $20.00 $20.00 116,400 33,558 28.83% $14.00 $7.00 568,679 28,850 5.07% $16.50 $19.75 88,097 10,100 11.46% $8.50 $8.50 503,851 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 Dillard's 50,000 4,695 9.39% $0.00 $0.00 Sears Moore Tag Agency 68,440 35,500 51.87% $16.50 $18.50 Tuesday Morning Chapala Mexican Grill Ratcliffe's Bookstore Hobby Lobby Mardel's Kohl's, Target, Crest Dominos Pizza Back Woods Equipment Office Depot, JC Penney Best Buy 33,475 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 106,307 0 0% $0.00 $9.00 1,066,119 37,750 3.54% $22.00 $24.00 40,898 1,800 4.40% $8.00 $14.50 5,241,968 400,174 7.63% Family Dollar Academy, HomeGoods Moore Family Clinic GFF Foods 17 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary EASTERN OK COUNTY SUBMARKET SUBMARKET SUMMARY Eastern Oklahoma County vacancy improved moderately, ending mid-year at 13.6 percent from 13.9 percent at year-end. This is one of the submarkets with a significant amount of product that is older, several of which have significant deferred maintenance or difficult configurations. Seven centers in this submarket remain over 25 percent vacant as they are older and, as we discussed in the summary, either have significant deferred maintenance or retail shopping patterns have shifted away from them. Ultimately, for the submarket to show significant improvement, these centers will need to be re-modeled, re-purposed, or just torn down. This is happening in other submarkets, albeit slowly. Nonetheless, the newer, better located centers reflect the performance or the greater market with vacancies in the 5-7 percent range. EASTERN OKLAHOMA COUNTY Town Center Plaza, started in 2005 and expanded over the years has remained a strong performer and is, in our opinion, indicative of the demand for newer product in the area. Although, the mixed demographics and overall vacancy of the area can make it a hard sell for some retailers and developers. We see growth in the submarket limited to primarily pad sites and smaller strip development over the near term. Developers are exploring the area, primarily Midwest City, for larger projects, but none have been able to put together a deal yet. 15% EASTERN OK COUNTY SUBMARKET VACANCY 12% 9% 6% 3% 0% 120 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 EASTERN OK COUNTY SUBMARKET ABSORPTION (thousands of square feet) 100 80 60 40 20 0 -20 18 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2015 Mid-Year Oklahoma City Retail Market Summary EASTERN OK COUNTY SUBMARKET Eastern OK County 10th Street Plaza 9207 NE 10th St 23 Post Plaza NE 23rd St & N Post Rd Boulevard Marketplace Built/ Updated Leasing Agent Total Space Available Space Vacant Rate 1 Rate 2 Anchor Tenants 1960 owner managed 33,000 0 0% $6.00 $0.00 Dollar General 1986 Nancy Brewer Nancy Brewer Benchmark Opportunity Partners Seth Grubstein/Randy Twist Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Michael Almaraz Brady's Properties Ali Ghaniabadi Price Edwards & Company Karleen Krywucki/Ev Ernst 35,000 0 0% $7.00 $0.00 Spencer's Smokehouse Farmer's Insurance 35,765 6,000 16.78% $16.00 $0.00 Dollar Tree 131,000 1978/1980 1965 1984 101 N Douglas Ave Choctaw Plaza 14407 NE 23rd St Decker Center 1200 S Air Depot Blvd Del Crest Shops 1974/1984 1982 1957/1990 SE 15th & Sunnylane Dixon Plaza 1985 1995 1987 1974 1970 1966 1952 1952 1993 2012 I-40 & Sooner Rd Sooner Market Place E Reno Ave & N Sooner Rd Spencer's Center NE 23rd St & N Spencer Rd Sunnylane Plaza SE44th St & S Sunnylane Rd Tan & Tone America Center 1900 S Air Depot Blvd The Village Shopping Center 4720 - 4754 SE 29th St Town & Country E Reno Ave & N Air Depot Ave Town Center Plaza SE 29th St & S Air Depot Blvd Uptown Plaza 7430 SE15th St Village Oak Plaza 1995 NE 23rd St & S Westminster Rd Eastern OK County Totals 35.94% 6.57% $12.00 $8.00 57,770 41,050 71.06% $6.00 $0.00 Dynasty Care Services Joe Leon 34,900 0 0% $8.00 $0.00 Shapes Gym Joe Leon North Star Joseph Atkinson 51,052 25,399 49.75% $8.00 $0.00 Farmer's Insurance Family Dollar 98,947 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 50,000 22,700 45.40% $3.00 $5.00 75,071 20,290 27.03% $7.50 $10.00 86,200 11,145 12.93% $5.00 $0.00 100,000 43,000 43% $3.00 $5.00 51,000 0 0% $5.00 $5.00 38,000 4,700 12.37% $3.00 $0.00 38,000 4,700 12.37% $3.00 $0.00 38,268 0 0% $3.00 $4.00 28,160 0 0% $0.00 $0.00 Bobby Tritten Charles Shadid Charles Shadid GBR Properties,Inc. Randy Vaillancourt Equity Commercial Realty Mark Hyde Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Shapard Properties,Inc. Bill Shapard Shapard Properties,Inc. Bill Shapard Charles Shadid Charles Shadid CBRE/OKLA Stuart Graham/Ryan Storer Charles Shadid 63,013 9,500 15.08% Chelino's $3.00 $5.00 0% $6.00 $5.00 Speed Mart Conoco Discount Beauty Supply 8,600 33.99% $7.00 $12.00 Super Cuts My Dentist 32,353 4,350 13.45% $7.00 $7.00 Rent-A-Center 133,974 10,000 7.46% $12.00 $16.00 795,000 0 0% $24.00 $0.00 168,032 2,400 1.43% $10.00 $14.00 26,012 2,200 8.46% $8.00 $12.00 Lupe's Restaurant $6.00 Angel's Furniture, 23rd Street Auction 84,888 0 2005 Ta Real Estate 25,300 2005 1981 $5.00 Jim Rose/Carl Archiniaco 1963 V C Davidson Scott Cleaners Dollar General Scott Cleaners Dollar General Diva Beauty Supply Plaza Event Center Ted's Cafe Escondido $7.00 1979 Michael Biddinger Real Estate Meagan Royer Weingarten Realty Brandon Schane Sooner Investment Brad Goodwin Northstar Properties Joseph Atkinson Newmark Grubb Levy, Beffort Dollar Tree Hobby Lobby Highlander Laundry Beauty Supply Edward Jones Economy Hearing Aid The Dance Department Lucky Bingo Options Unlimited Jackson Hewitt Tom's Tires The Garage, Volcano Sushi 12.50% 1966/1989 Chase Bank 2,200 5,000 1973 $8.95 33,500 40,000 2000 $6.95 Dollar General Cool Smile FedEx Charles Shadid Charles Shadid Charles Shadid owner managed 1000 S Douglas Blvd Westminster Shopping Center 47,084 EASTERN OKLAHOMA COUNTY SE 15th St & S Post Rd Eastgate Shopping Center 1100 N Midwest Blvd Gateway Plaza SE 15th St & S Air Depot Blvd Hartsdel SE 44th St & S Bryant Ave Heritage Plaza 351 N Air Depot Blvd Holiday Square 1100 S Air Depot Blvd North East Shopping Center 1124 NE 36th St Oakcliff Shopping Center 3102 SE 44th Street Park Estates NE 36th & N Kelly Ave Park Estates NE 36th & N Kelly Ave Park Plaza 3700 Springlake Dr Shops at Del City AAA, Check 'N Go, Papa Murphy's Akropolis Greek Restaurant Ross, Big Lots, Ace Hardware, Aarons Target, J C Penney Lowe's, Kohl's Langston's, Hancock Fabric Tuesday Morning Papa John Pizza 58,000 1,000 1.72% Davidson $5.00 Miles Millwork 2,442,205 271,318 11.11% 19 RETAIL MARKET SALES SUMMARY Property Address Submarket Building Sales Price Price PSF Sale Date Square Feet Deville Shopping Center 2408 N Council Road West 115,693 $1,900,000.00 $16.42 1/1/15 OKC Market Square 8400 NW Expressway Northwest 146,346 $5,325,000.00 $36.39 3/1/15 South Penn Plaza 1620-1648 SW 89th Southwest 33,050 $2,200,001.00 $66.56 3/23/15 Cherry Hollow Shopping 13516 N Eastern Ave Northeast 20,404 $2,800,000.00 $137.23 2/1/15 1100 S Air Depot Mid/Del 86,200 $1,950,000.00 $22.62 2/1/15 Glen Eagles Plaza 1000 NW 150th Edmond 20,238 $4,250,000.00 $210.00 4/1/15 Village Center Plaza 805-755 Covell Edmond 27,656 $4,774,000.00 $172.62 4/30/15 Sooner Shopping Center 623 N Broadway Moore 31,372 $1,200,000.00 $38.25 5/27/15 Belle Isle Station 1741 Belle Isle Station Blvd North 202,147 $51,000,000.00 $252.29 5/1/15 Village at Quail Springs 2201 W. Memorial Road North 100,404 $11,350,000 $113.04 6/17/15 May Crossings 5401 N. May Ave. Northwest 21,750 $7,100,000 $326.43 6/29/15 Center Holiday Square Shopping Center The sale that stands out is Belle Isle Station; this 15 year-old power center traded at a 5.4 percent capitalization rate in May. This is fully 125 basis points lower than any other power center sale in the last 5 years, that translates into almost $10 million in additional value. While the location of the center next to Penn Square Mall and its Nordstrom Rack anchor account for some of the value, much can be traced to aggressive national firms with lots of money to place and limited product. This acquisition is the fourth class A property Kite Realty has purchased in our market. Its hard to read too much into one sale. But we have been a seller’s market for a number of years with far more potential buyers than sellers. It remains to be seen if the Belle Isle sale is a signal that capitalization rates are headed down for all classes of product or not. Perhaps this will entice a few more sellers to enter the market. The remaining six sales were indicative of our non-class A sales over the past several years, that is, sales are split between larger distressed properties sold at a discount and smaller strip center sales. 21 Why the Internet of Things won’t be about the ‘things’ The biggest opportunity for retailers isn’t selling smart gadgets. It’s about understanding the customer and solving their problems. By Ian P. Murphy | July 2, 2015 “Smart” objects such as self-operating thermostats and self-driving cars may sound like science fiction. But many experts say these and other early possibilities suggested by the Internet of Things (IoT) are only a hint of what’s to come—and the massive amounts of consumer data they are set to collect. “Do you want an Internet-connected refrigerator? No!” McQuivey said. “But do you want a service that solves a problem? Yes, you absolutely do. The trick is that in order to get those experiences and services, you need devices—and that’s exactly what the Internet of Things is going to enable.” Seen as the fifth wave of online technology that’s emerging as the mobile and social revolution begins to peak and wind down, the IoT era will be marked not by people talking to each other using new technologies, but instead by machine-to-machine communication. McQuivey described an IoT-linked vase that notifies a florist when the flowers are wilting, noting that the merchant of the future wouldn’t sell a consumer the vase; they would give it away to ensure they could refill it. “The relationship is the goal,” he said. This example is reminiscent of Amazon’s new Dash button that lets Prime members order household supplies with just the push of a button located in the home. While the button is only available on an invitation-only basis now, the device could offer Amazon a way to bypass retailers with the ability to stock items without going to the store or even going online. Alternatively, a shopper might soon be able to put on virtual reality glasses, check out how a vase of flowers looks on an end table, and then order a vase and flowers by voicing their wants into a monitoring microphone. “At any moment you could say, ‘(Insert name of retail relationship here), send me toothpaste,’” McQuivey posited. Tapping even bigger data “Machines can and will chatter with each other at a level that a few billion people on Facebook can’t even begin to approach,” James McQuivey, vice president of research and principal analyst at Forrester Research, said at the recent Internet Retailer Conference + Exhibition (IRCE) in Chicago. ‘We are all early adopters now’ The Internet of Things is a symptom of two larger trends, McQuivey noted. “First, consumers are hyperadopting new technologies, and companies are engaging in digital disruption.” “Hyperadoption is the rapid and simultaneous uptake of unprecedented behaviors,” he said, pointing to texting or talking on smartphones—things people didn’t do much 10 years ago, but now embrace quickly. “If you think, ‘Oh, I’ll never need that,’” pointing to a slide depicting the Apple Watch, “get that out of your system. ” Forrester surveyed consumers about the Apple Watch upon its release for preorder in April, and 26%—representing about 50 million people in the United States—said they expect to own a smartwatch someday. What’s more, “8% want their next car to be a self-driving car, and they don’t even exist yet,” McQuivey said. “This is a consumer base that has learned the lesson of the last 10 years: ‘New stuff is going to come out, and it’s going to benefit me,” he added. “We are all early adopters now.” The economics of innovation The reason new technologies are being adopted so quickly is that their creation is no longer limited to large companies and research universities. And that’s increasing the number of new ideas in the marketplace exponentially. “The economics of providing what customers want is getting more favorable,” McQuivey said. “Many more people can participate, each of them operating at significantly lower cost than before. Multiply those two things together, and you get an explosion of ideas. This is what’s happening in every industry.” The result for retailers is the proliferation of sensors, cameras, microphones, and gadgets such as the Apple Watch, all of which are set to capture the data that powers the Internet of Things. But it isn’t sensors that consumers are interested in, McQuivey said; they are looking for new purchase experiences. 22 The data that IoT devices generate is going to make today’s big data look like small potatoes. “By 2020, the amount of data consumers give off will be 100 times what we have today,” he said. “You will know more about your customer, including data your customer never knew about themselves. That information is gold.” Machine-to-machine communication could soon guess a consumer’s mood or whether they are in a hurry based on mobile usage, helping determine the best time to serve them an offer. Or Home Depot and Whirlpool might collaborate on a sensor that reports when a washing machine needs more detergent, service or replacement, McQuivey suggested. Marketers won’t have much time to prepare for the onslaught of data, and should be prepared to move to the cloud to handle it. “Consumers will unleash this wave of data faster than you think, and you must digitally disrupt yourselves to ride this wave with them,” McQuivey said. “But don’t just collect data to collect data; there has to be an analytics plan,” he added. “Right now, analytics are designed to push transactions, and that’s appropriate. The next layer of analytics will be about understanding your customer: What are their behaviors and the drivers of those behaviors, and how can we influence and participate in them? “The big question mark is not what people want or what will people do with it. It’s, what will we do with that information so that we can anticipate our customer’s next need?”