Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within
Transcription
Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within
A STUDY FOR FRIENDS OF HOPEWELL FURNACE NHS Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Study by Susan Speros and Michelle Lynch 5/10/2013 Page 1 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Table of Contents Introduction………………………………………………………………………….…..3 Goals of the Hopewell Big Woods Partnership…………………………………….……6 Geographical Scope of Work………………………………………………………........6 County-wide Historic Resource Survey…………………………………………….….10 Classification and Evaluation of Historic and Cultural Resources………………….....12 Analysis of Previous Studies………………...…………………………………………14 Hopewell Bif Woods Monitoring, Evaluation, and Adaptive Management Plan……...23 Recommendations for Ongoing Assessment………………………………………......25 Heritage Tourism Studies…………………………………………………………...…26 Brief Historical Analysis……………………………………………………………....28 Historic Resources Listed by Township…………………………………………….....30 Prioritizing Historic and Cultural Resources Within and Nearby the HBW…………..33 Union Township………………………………………………………………………..33 Robeson Township……………………………………………………………………..51 Birdsboro Borough…………………………………………………………………......70 Caernarvon Township…………………………………………………………………..75 New Morgan Borough……………………………………………………………….....85 Exeter Township……………………………………………………………………..…87 St. Lawrence Borough………………………………………………………………...101 Amity Township……………………………………………………………………....104 Douglass Township…………………………………………………………………...118 Conclusion………………………………………………………………………….…125 Bibliography…………………………………………………………………………..128 Biographies……………………………………………………………………………133 Appendix………………………………………………………………………….…..134 Article: The Town of Brower by Susan Speros………………………………….……153 Maps Hopewell Big Woods……………………………………………………………………3 Hopewell Big Woods Partnership……………………………………………………….5 Berks County Map…………………………………………………………………...….7 Berks County Township Map……………………………………………………...……7 Union Township………………………………………………………………………..33 Robeson Township…………………………………………………………………......51 Birdsboro Borough……………………………………………………………………..70 Caernarvon Township……………………………………………………………….….75 New Morgan Borough……………………………………………………………….…85 Exeter Township………………………………………………………………………..87 Amity Township……………………………………………………………………....104 Douglass Township…………………………………………………………………...118 Township maps of 1862………………………………………………………………133 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 2 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Hopewell Big Woods Maps…………………………………………………………..136 Introduction Hopewell Big Woods Hopewell Big Woods (HBW) is the last large, unbroken forest remaining in southeastern Pennsylvania. Located within the counties of Berks and Chester, it is one of the most important natural areas in the region and an exceptional resource containing hundreds of plant and bird species, pristine forest, unique wetlands, and clean streams and providing open space, drinking water, and unique scenic, cultural, and natural resources. This conservation area encircles French Creek State Park and the Hopewell Furnace National Historic Site, and is greatly valued as an asset for public recreation and as a tourist destination. As an expanse of more than 73,000 acres, or 110 square miles, the Hopewell Big Woods is a rarity in the Mid-Atlantic landscape. Map of Hopewell Big Woods, courtesy of hopewellbigwoods.org A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 3 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Hopewell Big Woods Partnership The Hopewell Big Woods Partnership, led by the Natural Lands Trust, is a group of over 30 government agencies, private non-profits, and municipal entities. The Partnership seeks to conserve at least 4,000 acres of old-growth forest, 15,000 acres of unbroken forest, and the watersheds supported by this forest, as well as to protect and conserve other natural and cultural resources within the Hopewell Big Woods. In November 2003, the Natural Lands Trust published an initial conservation plan for the Hopewell Big Woods entitled Hopewell Big Woods Landscape Conservation Plan. This plan outlined four conservation goals focusing on the protection and stewardship of natural resources. In 2011, James F. Thorne, Ph.D. and Robin Eisman, Ph.D. prepared the Hopewell Big Woods Monitoring, Evaluation, and Adaptive Management Plan. In advance of this plan, discussions of the Partnership identified two additional goals for managing economic development and the protection of cultural and historic resources, making a total of six goals. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 4 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Courtesy of http://www.rpa.org/northeastlandscapes/maps/800/834-InitiativeMapBook_73.png A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 5 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Goals of the Hopewell Big Woods Partnership The Hopewell Big Woods Partnership has identified the following six conservation goals: 1. The permanent protection and stewardship of at least 15,000 acres of unbroken forest in and around French Creek State Park. 2. The conservation of water quality and quantity in the watersheds of the Upper Reaches of French Creek, the entirety of Hay Creek and the other smaller watersheds within the Hopewell Big Woods. The primary indicator for watershed conservation is retaining impervious cover below 6% in these watersheds. 3. The conservation of state and federally listed and other rate species, occurring within the Hopewell Big Woods. 4. The promotion of the recreational resources located in and around the Hopewell Big Woods. 5. The encouragement of compatible economic development within the Hopewell Big Woods that is consistent with the other conservation goals. 6. The protection of historic and other cultural resources occurring within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods. This report takes a first step in meeting goal six by prioritizing identified historic and cultural resources within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods within the geographical boundaries of Berks County. Geographical Scope of Work The geographical scope of work was limited to townships, boroughs, and municipalities in Berks County within the Hopewell Big Woods, with exceptions made for nearby municipal areas that significantly contribute to the historic and cultural fabric of the Hopewell Big Woods Area. The geographical boundaries of the Hopewell Big Woods in Berks County were defined as the Schuylkill River as the eastern and partial southern boundary and the upper reaches of the French Creek and the Hay Creek watershed as far north as the Allegheny Aqueduct as the northern boundary. The western boundary follows Route 176 with the exception of the Southwest reaches of the Berks Hopewell Big Woods area near the borough of New Morgan that extend southwestward across Route 176. Nearby resources include those along the east bank of the Schuylkill River corridor and the western side of Route 176 that are considered pertinent to the historic and cultural fabric of the Hopewell Big Woods Area. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 6 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Map of Berks County Map of Berks Showing Municipalities A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 7 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Berks County Municipalities within the Geographical Scope Townships Union Township: including Unionville (fka Browertown), Hopewell National Historic Site, French Creek State Park, Geigertown, and others. Robeson Township: including Joanna Furnace, Allegheny Aqueduct Park, and others. Caernarvon Township: including Morgantown Boroughs Birdsboro New Morgan Nearby Contributing Municipalities Exeter Township and St. Lawrence Borough: including Daniel Boone Homestead, Mordecai Lincoln Homestead, Exeter Friends Meeting House, and others which are Class I and/or II Amity Township: including Old Morlatton Village, St. Gabriel’s Episcopal Church, and others which are Class I and/or II. Douglass Township: including Pine Forge, and others which are Class I and/or II. Scope of Work and Methodology In the narrative presented, there are a few pages of introduction and comprehensive overview to acquaint the many stakeholders, some of which may not be entirely familiar with the Hopewell Big Woods and the Hopewell Big Woods Partnership, with the background and goals of this project. To properly explain the concept of "historic resources," and their inception into the fabric of Berks County, this study begins by introducing previous studies, plans, and efforts at identifying and preserving historic and cultural resources within the targeted area. The Berks County Comprehensive Plan of 2001-2002 is the earliest cited. This plan sparked the later and more area-specific plans such as the Southern Berks Regional Joint Comprehensive Plan. These plans are listed in the order in which they were produced. Differences and similarities in each are noted. The identified plans are directly connected to the Berks County land area that the HBW lies within, including related nearby areas. Each of these plans identified and listed the most significant historic and cultural resources found within the areas addressed. These resources are, for the most part, those on or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 8 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Along with the production of these plans, county municipalities participated in an update of the Countywide Historic Resources Survey in 2006-2007. Implementation of any and all of these plans is/was dependent upon this update, yet the update could not have been accomplished without the development of these plans. All of these plans segued into each other, and became more detailed and relevant as they became more area specific. All historic resources within the HBW and nearby areas that are listed on the National Register of Historic Places have been identified, and a brief narrative description of each, including historical and architectural significance and current condition has been included. Additional sites and structures that are historically significant and/or are eligible for the National Register are similarly identified. Threats to these historic resources were analyzed using recommendations and suggestions concerning historic preservation that are listed in the area Comprehensive Plans, Municipal Zoning Ordinances, and consultations with planners, municipal officials, preservation advocates, and other interested parties. Criteria and regulations listed in Municipal Planning Codes and adopted by Municipal Historical Architectural Review Boards along with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties were applied during analysis. To understand the importance of these historic resources, their relationship with each other and their contribution to the HBW, the historical, cultural, ethnic, religious, architectural and economic ties of the HBW area within Berks County were studied. A summary of the research and an interpretation of the findings are included in this report. To demonstrate how diverse communities and geographic areas were linked from the earliest years of European settlement in the 18th century through the present a brief narrative history of the region encompassing the HBW is provided. Robeson Township, a region traditionally called “The Forest” and containing prominent early 19th century industrial sites such as Joanna Furnace and historically important villages such as Geigertown and Birdsboro, was found to have a historically important relationship with Hopewell Furnace and Village. The history and importance of the Joanna Furnace site as well as knowledge of the widespread charcoal making within "The Forest" of Robeson are essential for a complete understanding of iron industry heritage in and nearby the HBW. Clusters of important sites that have an interrelated history such as Morlatton Village, now Douglassville, and Browertown, now Unionville, which are directly across the river from each other, were historically interdependent and related to other communities within the greater HBW region including those across the Berks border in Chester County. They have a direct tie with Hopewell NHS, as several factors who dealt in buying and selling the iron goods produced at Hopewell lived in Morlatton and Browertown and many of the drovers that served Hopewell stayed at inns at Morlatton or Browertown. Included in the Appendix is an article by Susan Speros on historic Browertown. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 9 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods County-wide Comprehensive Historic Resource Survey In 1983, under the direction of Phoebe Hopkins, the Berks County Conservancy’s division of historic preservation completed a comprehensive survey of all known historic and cultural resources throughout Berks County. This survey was updated 20 years later. Historic resources that were missed in 1983 were added and structures that have been lost were eliminated. In addition to a brief description and history, an explanation of threats was noted for each structure or resource on the survey forms. The Berks County Planners are still in the process of collating all the information submitted and plotting the resources on Geographic Information Systems (GIS) maps. Initially, the time period of structures surveyed was limited to the 1700s (18th century) through 1850. The updated survey distinctly incorporated later 19th century and early 20th century structures, including bridges, churches, mills, factories, commercial buildings, and other significant structures. However, thousands of bungalows, four-squares and other houses and buildings of the pre- and post-WWII era are not represented in the survey and remain beyond the scope of this study. It is important to note that the survey and data entry method devised and used by the Berks County Planning Commission is incompatible with the system currently used by the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission Bureau for Historic Preservation (PHMC BHP). For that reason, the PHMC BHP considers Berks County an “unsurveyed county”with regard to historic resources. Berks County is not, in fact, unsurveyed. Its historic resources have been surveyed. The survey and data entry methods are simply incompatible with the state data bank system at this time. Prioritizing Identified Historic and Cultural Resources This study, prioritizing the historic and cultural resources in the Hopewell Big Woods and nearby areas, reflects this expanded scope of the updated Berks Historic Resource Survey, with the above named limitations. In many ways, the scope of work for the prioritization of historic resources in and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods reflects the chapters concerning Historic Preservation in the Berks County Greenway, Park and Recreation Plan. It is the intention of this study to enhance the mutual goals of both the Hopewell Big Woods Partnership and Berks County to protect and preserve the historic and cultural resources within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods, particularly within Berks County. The Berks County Planning Commission and the Berks County Parks and Recreation Department are stake holders in this historic resources prioritization endeavor, and provided support as needed in this undertaking. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 10 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The prioritizing of historic and cultural resources in and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods area was accomplished by utilizing the Historic Resource Survey information for the townships, boroughs, and nearby municipalities, which was available from the Berks County Planning Commission. This study identified specific and unique threats and conditions within the targeted area, but also found the overall larger problems concerning historic preservation to be reflective of those displayed throughout Berks County. Hopewell Anthracite Furnace, Courtesy of Hopewell Furnace NHS A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 11 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Classification and Evaluation of Berks County Historic and Cultural Resources of the Area within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Overview This classification of historic and cultural resources reflects National Register of Historic Places guidelines and/or designations made by municipalities. Class I and II resources are considered to be of critical importance to maintenance of the quality of life in Berks County, and planning is highly recommended to protect these resources. The goals are to evaluate, monitor, and preserve valuable historic and cultural resources with the knowledge that these historic preservation goals may be more difficult to quantify and to implement than those of land preservation. Classification System The Classification System of historic resources that is used for prioritizing historic and cultural resources within and nearby the HBW in Berks County is the same as the system that was developed and implemented for use in the prioritizing of historic and cultural resources within the HBW in Chester County. Minor alterations were made to accomodate special conditions in Berks County. Precise efforts were made to make the two systems comparable and compatible, enabling a focus on critical historic and cultural resources within the greater HBW area and nearby. This facilitates establishing priorities across county lines and provides greater flexibility in planning strategies to conserve and protect multi-county resources. Class I: The resource is listed on, contributes to, or is determined eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places. This includes contributing resources in a listed or eligible National Register Historic District. Class II: The resource is considered by the municipality to meet the standards to be considered for the National Register of Historic Places and/or is identified as significant at a local level. Class III: All remaining resources surveyed. Class IV: Demolished or significantly altered property. Evaluation Using the existing Berks County Historic Resource Surveys provided by the Berks County Planning Commission, resources were evaluated based on historical, cultural and architectural A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 12 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods value, integrity, and condition. Priority was assigned based on a resource’s contributive value to the Hopewell Big Woods and nearby areas. Those resources threatened by neglect, development, or other factors were also identified and prioritized. The National Register Bulletin series published by the National Parks Service provides guidance on evaluating, documenting, and listing different types of historic places. National Register bulletins used or recommended for possible future use in evaluating historic and other cultural resources within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods include: The Basics How to Apply the National Register Criteria for Evaluation Property Types Historic Residential Suburbs: Guidelines for Evaluation and Documentation for the National Register of Historic Places Guidelines for Evaluating and Registering Archeological Properties Guidelines for Evaluating and Registering Cemeteries and Burial Places How to Evaluate and Nominate Designed Historic Landscapes Guidelines for Identifying, Evaluating and Registering Historic Mining Properties Guidelines for Evaluating and Nominating Properties that Have Achieved Significance Within the Past Fifty Years How to Apply National Register Criteria to Post Offices Guidelines for Evaluating and Documenting Rural Historic Landscapes Guidelines for Evaluating and Documenting Properties Associated with Significant Persons Guidelines for Evaluating and Documenting Traditional Cultural Properties A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 13 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Previous Studies BERKS COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, 2001-2002: “Berks Vision 2020” “The purpose of this Plan, known as “Berks Vision 2020,” is to revise and update certain aspects of the Comprehensive Plan of 1991.” This updated Plan acknowledges its relationship to the plans of county municipalities and regional plans, and also addresses additional and new requirements concerning historic preservation. Developed by the Berks County Planning Commission, this revised Plan acts as a guide to growth and development, and establishes goals and objectives for the direction of future growth, preservation, and transportation decisions within Berks County. As stated in this plan, “Berks County has a multitude of historic structures distributed throughout the County. Due to sheer numbers, the County Comprehensive Plan focused only on those certified and registered on the National Register of Historic Places. Some of the sites such as Hopewell NHS, French Creek, Daniel Boone Homestead, and Allegheny Aqueduct are within or nearby the Hopewell Big Woods, and are significant components in the County’s system of open space and recreation areas. Southern Berks Regional Joint Comprehensive Plan, 2004 To promote joint municipal planning, intergovernmental, and regional cooperation, Berks County initiated a Local Planning Partnership Fund, to fund the preparation of local comprehensive plans for municipalities that engage in joint planning efforts. A joint comprehensive plan for Union, Robeson, and Caernarvon townships and the borough of Birdsboro resulted in 2004. Termed the Southern Berks Region, this designated area of Berks County is at the heart of the Hopewell Big Woods. These municipalities also fall within the larger area designated as the Southern Highlands Region. The Joint Comprehensive Plan’s introduction states, “This plan was prepared to provide direction and guidance for future growth, development, and preservation efforts for this generation as well as the next generations.” It was adopted by the respective municipal governments in 2004. Chapter VIII, Section E of the Joint Comprehensive Plan addresses historic and cultural resources, noting that historic preservation is a crucial and essential component of planning that enhances the “exceptional” quality of life in this area. It further notes, “The Southern Berks Region has a rich and diverse heritage that is reflected in the historic and cultural resources that are integrated within the existing land use patterns. The preservation of these historic and cultural resources is essential to establishing a community bond from past generations to future generations.” A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 14 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The following strategies for historic preservation were recommended in the Southern Berks Joint Comprehensive Plan: 1. Formulate and adopt an official policy statement for the protection and preservation of historic resources within the Southern Berks Region. 2. Appoint a local and/or regional HARB to initially document the historic and cultural resources within the Southern Berks Region. 3. Coordinate planning efforts with the PHMC, Berks County Conservancy, Berks County Planning Commission, Hay Creek Valley Historical Commission, Schuylkill River Greenway Association, Natural Lands Trust, Sierra Club, and other state, county, or local groups who share similar visions for the protection and preservation of historic and cultural resources. 4. Conduct a municipal survey of all known or potential sites, buildings, structures, objects, districts, and land areas, which have historic and cultural significance. The PHMC provides local assistance in the preparation of such surveys. The recommended procedures and survey format are further documented in Guidelines for Historic Resource Surveys in Pennsylvania. 5. Solicit qualified consultants in the fields of historic preservation, architecture, and planning to review the results of the survey and prioritize the significance of the historic and cultural resources. 6. Develop a draft list of short-term and long-term strategies that will protect and preserve each historic and cultural resource. 7. Establish a community education program on the benefits of effective historic protection and preservation efforts. As part of this effort, meet with the owners and tenants of the historic sites with the highest significance to gain support and discuss preservation strategies. 8. Identify potential funding opportunities, which could provide financial assistance for historic preservation activities within the Southern Berks Region. 9. Consider establishing historic overlay districts for selected areas within Birdsboro, Morgantown, and Hopewell. Appoint a local or regional HARB to advise the local governing bodies of building or construction activity within the historic district. As part of this process, develop ordinances with standards and specifications for historic protection and preservation. 10. Consider the adoption of effective zoning, subdivision, and land development amendments, which consider provisions for buffer yards, scenic vistas, adaptive reuse, landscaping, signs, and other visual enhancements within historic overlay districts. 11. Promote tourism opportunities within established historic districts. 12. Promote adequate buffer areas around prominent and culturally significant historic sites to retain the character and setting of the site and minimize the encroachment of new development that may have an adverse effect on the overall integrity of the site. Brief historic profiles of the municipalities are included in the plan and historic sites within the region identified. In 2004 there were 14 sites that were either listed on the National Register A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 15 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods of Historic Places, or were considered eligible within the Southern Berks Regional Area. (Please note that the list has been updated since then, with more historic sites, structures, and village districts recognized by PHMC.) These resources are not renewable, making it essential to recognize their value and promote a land use plan that will preserve, protect, and enhance their presence within the community. Southern Berks Regional Area National Historic Areas and Sites, 2004 St Michael’s Episcopal Church Edward Brooke II Mansion Colonel Jacob Morgan Homestead Morgantown Historic District Colonel Jonathan Jones Homestead Jones/Hertzler House Allegheny Aqueduct Thompson’s Mill Joanna Furnace Complex Geiger Mill Hopewell Furnace NHS Six Penny Creek French Creek State Park Camp Site Joint Comprehensive Plan for Amity Township, Exeter Township, and St. Lawrence Borough, 2005 Another result of the Local Planning Partnership Fund was the joint comprehensive plan for Amity Township, Exeter Township and St. Lawrence Borough which was published in 2005. Exeter and Amity townships adjoin the Hopewell Big Woods and are considered nearby contributing resources. The Borough of St. Lawrence falls within the geographic boundaries of Exeter Township. These three municipalities fall within the area identified as the Southern Highlands Region. The joint plan incorporates a chapter planning for the protection of natural and historic resources and a further chapter incorporating a brief narrative of the history of the region and identifying historic resources within the three municipalities. Chapter 9 of the joint plan outlines the goal and objective for preserving and enhancing historic, architectural, and cultural resources within the three municipalities as follows: Goal: Preserve and enhance the historic, architectural and cultural resources of Amity, Exeter and St. Lawrence. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 16 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Objectives: Encourage the preservation, protection, and enhancement of historic and architectural resources and their context. Discourage demolition by neglect and deterioration of historic resources. Foster increased public awareness of the history of and historic resources within the municipalities. Support efforts of organizations to identify, mark, register and protect historic resources and work with local and state agencies to protect historic resources. Require new development to reflect and consider the history, architecture and development patterns of the municipalities in order to preserve the important historic and architectural resources of the region. Determine the role which municipalities should play in historic preservation through land use ordinance incentives, controls and regulations, and efforts to create historic districts and/or historic overlay zoning. Encourage adaptive re-use of historic structures where appropriate. Identify existing contemporary sites which could be considered part of the historic or cultural heritage of future generations and preserve these sites for future generations. Support cultural events, which celebrate the historic and cultural heritage of the region. The following actions were recommended to protect historic resources within the region: 1. Utilize Historic Resource Overlay Zoning. 2. Utilizing demolition by neglect provisions in zoning ordinances. 3. Adopt Town Center and Rural Village design standards. 4. Require historic resource impact studies in subdivision and land development ordinances. 5. Encourage active involvement of Historical Commissions to: – Identify, evaluate, mark and foster awareness of historic resources – Investigate participation in Certified Local Government Program – Investigate creation of historic districts – Inform and involve public – Encourage retention, restoration, enhancement and appropriate adaptive re-use of historic resources and discourage removal of historic structures – Conceive programs, events and interpretive signage and exhibits which emphasize the history of the region – Identify contemporary sites for future preservation In 2005, there were 13 sites that were listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and three sites considered eligible within the Amity-Exeter-St. Lawrence region. Please note that additional historic sites, structures, and districts have been recognized by PHMC and/or listed on the National Register since 2005. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 17 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Exeter Township Daniel Boone Homestead Site and Bertolet Cabin John Bishop House Boonecroft Mordacai Lincoln Mill Tract Farm Snyder Mill Bishop-Tyson House Oley Line Hotel Exeter Friends Meeting House St. Lawrence Borough Levan Farm John Lutz Furniture Factory Amity Township Griesemer/Brown Mill Complex Mounce Jones (Old Swede’s) House Old St. Gabriel’s Episcopal Church Weidner Mill White Horse Tavern A total of 136 historic resources were identified in the region using a number of resources identified in the comprehensive plan. Of these resources, 107 are located within Exeter Township. It should be noted that of these 107, many have been identified as Class IV resources—those that have been demolished or that have been significantly altered and lack integrity. Others remain unidentified. Identified resources are classified and prioritized further in this report. Berks County Historic Resource Inventory Update, 2006-2007 The Berks County Comprehensive Plan of 2001 and subsequent localized Plans stressed the need to update the County Historic Resource Inventory, completed in the early 1980s. Therefore, in May 2006, the Berks County Planning Commission initiated the undertaking of a County wide update of the 1983 Historic Resource Inventory. This Project was the first implementation of the 2007 Berks County Greenway, Parks and Recreation Plan. The Planners held a meeting of all historical societies in Berks County, which essentially comprised members of the Berks County Museum Council (BCMC). BCMC members represent almost all county historic sites, historical societies, and museums. At the meeting, municipal maps and existing survey forms for all known historic sites and districts in Berks County were distributed. Individual BCMC members present volunteered to update surveys in their specific areas. For example, the Heidelberg Heritage Society members complete all the surveys in the three Heidelberg townships: Lower, South, and Heidelberg. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 18 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Groups were asked to field check all of the sites indicated and to add additional sites and structures overlooked in previous surveys. Double-sided forms were provided, which groups used to complete information for each site, including historic function, architectural details, updated photos, and threats to the site/structure. Completed forms were returned to the county planners, with copies retained by each group and sent to each subject municipality to increase awareness of the historic resources in local communities. Information on protecting these resources through zoning and other historic district ordinances was made available to the municipalities. The historic resource inventory update is an ongoing project, and the Berks County planners are still in the process of compiling and collating this and an ever-growing body of new information and plotting all resources onto a series of GIS Maps. These updated Historical Resource Surveys and GIS Maps form a critical resource for this HBW Project. The GIS Maps pinpointing the locations of all historic resources listed on or eligible for the NRHP and all historic resources identified as locally significant are an important resource that municipalities and HBW partners will use in preservation planning. Hay Creek Watershed Greenway Plan, 2007 “This plan was prepared by the Hay Creek Watershed Association to help guide future conservation activities and economic development within the watershed, resulting in a community which is both environmentally sustainable and economically vibrant.” The Hay Creek watershed includes portions of Robeson, Union, Brecknock, and Caernarvon Townships and Birdsboro and New Morgan Boroughs. All of the Hay Creek Watershed rests within the Hopewell Big Woods, representing nearly one quarter of that landscape. Goals of the Hay Creek Greenway Plan include promoting the protection and interpretation of historic buildings and places in order to preserve the heritage of the watershed, and make these historically significant sites accessible to the public. Nationally recognized and locally important heritage resources are located throughout the Hay Creek Watershed, and remind us of our priceless historic heritage. These goals and objectives include: Conduct a comprehensive inventory of historic resources Protect existing historic and cultural resources from degradation and demolition Preserve and restore existing historic and historic and cultural resources Increase heritage-related tourism opportunities National Register of Historic Places properties listed in the Hay Creek Greenway Plan are the following: A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 19 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods St Michael’s Protestant Episcopal Church Morgantown Historic District Allegheny Aqueduct Geiger Mill Joanna Furnace Complex Thompson Mill French Creek Park Org. Group Camp 4 French Creek Sixpenny Day Use Area Hopewell Furnace NHS In addition to the historic sites listed on the NRHP in the Hay Creek Watershed, there are 13 additional historic sites recognized by PHMC as NRHP eligible. Also, importantly, there are numerous locally historically significant places within the Hay Creek Watershed. Berks County Greenway Park and Recreation Plan, 2007 “Berks Southern Highlands Region” The Berks Southern Highlands Region encompasses the areas within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods. It was studied as part of the county’s 2007 Greenway Park and Recreation Plan. The region was mapped by the Berks County Planning Commission and historic resources within it were plotted on a GIS Map of Historic Resources produced by the commission. Significant cultural and historic resources, such as Hopewell NHS and the Allegheny Aqueduct Park are identified with key numbers and dots on this map. Lesser resources are signified simply with dots on the map. The planning commission found that “the Southern Highlands region has a rich and diverse heritage that is reflected in the historic and cultural resources that are integrated within the existing land use patterns. The preservation of these historic and cultural resources is essential to establish a community bond from past generations to future generations. Since these resources are non-renewable, it is essential to recognize their value and promote a future land use plan that is based upon fundamental principals in an effort to preserve, protect, and enhance their presence within the region.” The National Register of Historic Places is a comprehensive listing of districts, sites, buildings, structures, and objects of historic and cultural significance to the locality, state or nation. Within the Southern Highlands Region, the planning commission identified 29 sites that are either listed on the National Register or are considered eligible for listing on the National Register. Individual sites listed on the National Register include: Allegheny Aqueduct Boonecroft Farm Bitler Farm A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 20 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Geiger Mill Griesemer Mill Complex Ironstone Bridge John Bishop House Isaac Levan Farm Mill Tract Farm Mounce Jones (Old Swede) House Snyder Mill St. Michael’s Church Thompson Mill Weidner Mill White Horse Tavern (Be aware that some of these sites are complexes including multiple related structures.) Districts listed on the National Register include: Daniel Boone Homestead French Creek Six Penny French Creek Organized Group Camp Hopewell Furnace NHS Joanna Furnace Complex Morgantown Historic District Berks County Comprehensive Plan, 2012 “Berks Vision 2030” This draft plan is an update of the “Berks Vision 2020” Plan. This updated plan sets forth the following goals and policies for the preservation of historic and cultural resources. Historic and Cultural Resources Goal: To recognize historic preservation and cultural resources as a means of retaining community character, providing affordable housing, and assisting economic development. Policies: (1) The County encourages public and private entities to work together to identify and protect historic resources. (2) The County encourages economic development organizations to include historic preservation as a component of economic development strategies. (3) The County supports revision and enforcement of codes and regulations to promote the preservation of historic buildings. (4) The County will assist municipalities seeking information about historic preservation A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 21 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods and, when necessary, refer them to the appropriate agencies. (5) The County will promote land use regulations that consider historic resources and help retain the character of rural villages. (6) The County encourages training for municipal officials in land use and historic preservation issues, and how they relate to economic development. (7) The County will continue to update the Greenway, Park and Recreation Plan, which includes recommendations regarding historic preservation. The problem with the County Comprehensive Plan is that it cannot provide any preservation regulations and/or legislation at the local level and can only offer suggestions and support to the municipalities. Any preservation regulations and/or legislation protecting historic and cultural resources in the county must come at the municipal level via local zoning or preservation ordinances. Berks County's municipal governments are encouraged to plan for historic preservation, establish historic districts, enact historic preservation ordinances, and appoint historic preservation commissions or review boards. At a minimum, municipalities are encouraged provide for some type of review and public comment before demolition of privately owned historic resources is permitted. The legality of this has been challenged many times, so the municipalities are reluctant to take any action. Historical Architectural Review Boards or Commissions, such as the Exeter Historical Commission make recommendations in such cases, but the these are recommendations only—not requirements—due to the limitations of law. There is very little that can be done via municipal legislation to protect individual, privately owned historic or cultural resources. Historically, when municipalities outside of Berks County have tried to protect such resources with restrictive legislation, the legislation has been challenged as "spot zoning.” Historic preservation ordinances for historic districts apply regulations to structures within areas (districts) and, therefore, are not considered "spot zoning." Conclusions Drawn From Earlier Studies and Plans All of the above studies and plans are relevant to how the prioritization of Historic Resources in the HBW and nearby areas can be achieved. In many ways, the plans and studies cited are the result of the 1960s movement towards realizing the importance of green and open space, and how it enhances life, especially in urban and suburban spaces. Our Berks County Parks System, an outgrowth of this movement, came about in the late 1960s, as a "green" answer to the increasing development and the loss of open space in the county. Increased growth with accompanying "urban sprawl" made it imperative for the county and its municipalities to create comprehensive plans to delineate and control growth, essentially guiding "smart growth." Along with this realization and understanding, came the appreciation of the role that our historic heritage and historic preservation play in enhancing overall quality of life in the county. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 22 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods When begun in the late 1960s, the process was new, and the county cautiously made gains in protecting open space, controlling development, and defining the role of historic preservation into the 21st century. As time went on, a better understanding of the unique situation and needs of Berks County, and the special needs and differences of each municipality evolved, making the development of each subsequent plan more comprehensive and specific. Utilizing these earlier studies and plans with the recently updated Survey of Historic Resources, the prioritization of Historic Resources in the HBW and nearby areas was accomplished with depth and knowledge. Hopewell Big Woods Monitoring, Evaluation, and Adaptive Management Plan, 2011 Prepared by James F. Thorne, Ph.D. and Robin Eisman, Ph.D. In the 10th anniversary year of the Hopewell Big Woods Partnership (which had by then grown to a membership of 47 public and private partners), the Partnership modified its original four conservation goals to further address the need for compatible economic development and the protection of historic and other cultural resources, developing the six goals outlined in the introduction to this study: 1. The permanent protection and stewardship of at least 15,000 acres of unbroken forest in and around French Creek State Park. 2. The conservation of water quality and quantity in the watersheds of the Upper Reaches of French Creek, the entirety of Hay Creek and the other smaller watersheds within the Hopewell Big Woods. The primary indicator for watershed conservation is retaining impervious cover below 6% in these watersheds. 3. The conservation of state and federally listed and other rate species, occurring within the Hopewell Big Woods. 4. The promotion of the recreational resources located in and around the Hopewell Big Woods. 5. The encouragement of compatible economic development within the Hopewell Big Woods that is consistent with the other conservation goals. 6. The protection of historic and other cultural resources occurring within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods. The partnership further commissioned a plan for the monitoring, evaluation, and adaptive management of the Hopewell Big Woods. The plan identified approaches for meeting the goals of the Hopewell Big Woods Partnership in Section III. According to the Plan: “The first step in monitoring historic and cultural resources was to generate an official list of significant sites for the Hopewell Big Woods. A Goal 6 Working Group formed for this purpose. A list has been compiled, and once it is finalized, a Baseline Condition Report will be developed for each resource, along with a set of standards to measure any deterioration or improvement of the resource. Assessments will be conducted on a rotating basis, with each site assessed once every 5 years.” A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 23 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The Plan does not identify who or what entity/entities will be responsible for formulating the Baseline Condition Report or monitoring the ongoing assessment of resources or what criteria will be applied in assessing the baseline conditions. This Study, Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historic Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods, takes a first step in meeting goal six by prioritizing identified historic and cultural resources within and nearby the Hopewell Big Woods within the boundaries of Berks County. Baseline conditions were assessed during the update of the Countywide Historic Resources Survey in 2006-2007. As part of this study, the conditions of resources NR listed or eligible resources within or nearby the HBW were observed. Any deterioration or alteration that occurred since the 2006-2007 survey was noted. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 24 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Recommendations for the Ongoing Assessments of Historic Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods HBW Partnership should determine which entity/entities will be responsible for the ongoing assessment of historic resources. For privately owned resources, the responsible entity could be the property owner. Criteria for assessment should be developed that will include a complete architectural evaluation of all exterior and interior features and finishes. Architectural features, materials and finishes that are character-defining and therefore significant and which must be preserved, should be identified. Prioritization of architectural features of each resource (premiere, important, contributing, non-contributing) is advised. Room-by-room evaluation of each resource, including the identification of materials, construction techniques, finishes and features such as lighting, paneling, wainscoting, glazing, cabinetwork, fireplaces, etc. should be undertaken. Prioritization of architectural significance of interior spaces (premiere, important, contributing, non-contributing) is advised. It is recognized that access to privately owned historic resources is often limited and interior assessment and evaluation of such resources might not be possible. A description and evaluation of any historic resource’s mechanical systems (heating, lighting, plumbing, electrical, etc.) is also recommended. Existing Conditions, such as damage, structural problems, materials deterioration, etc., should be analyzed and recorded. Recommended repair and/or stabilization work should be prioritized. Materials needed for restoration and/or conservation should be assessed and identified. A plan or program for general and periodic maintenance should be developed, recognizing that deferred maintenance is not an option for historic resources. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 25 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Heritage Tourism In 2011, a report was presented to the U.S. President’s Advisory Council on Historic Preservation entitled “Measuring Economic Impacts of Historic Preservation.” The report’s authors, Donovan Rypkema and Caroline Cheong of PlaceEconomics, Washington, DC, and Randall Mason, PhD of University of Pennsylvania School of Design, Historic Preservation Program, found that tourism is a growth industry worldwide. Consistent evidence showed heritage tourism as one of the fastest growing segments of that industry, and many states report tourism as one of their largest industries, particularly when measured by number of employees. The authors of the 2011 report found that tourism impact studies are survey based. They analyzed and reported on the method employed by the National Park Service – the method used at Hopewell Furnace NHS. “For the past several years the National Park Service has evaluated the economic impact of park visitors using MGM2 – Money Generation Model. This relatively user-friendly approach requires the park to enter three basic pieces of information: number of visitor nights; visitor segments (based on nature of accommodations); and a choice of multipliers (rural, small metro area, large metro area, or region). Based on this input the MGM2 system will calculate: sales, jobs, personal income and value added, broken down in the twelve industries most affected by tourism expenditures.”1 The authors determined that surveys are an adequate means of gathering data provided the survey base is large enough and the proper questions are asked. However, two problems in analyzing the data were identified: 1) what constitutes a “heritage tourist”? and 2) how much of the visitor’s expenditures should be included in the impact analysis? (For example: Should the cost of transportation be included?)2 Heritage tourists are considered a sub-set of all tourists. The authors reported that in nearly all the comparative analyses, heritage tourists (however defined) tend to stay longer, visit more places, and spend more money per day than tourists in general, thereby having a significantly greater economic impact per trip.3 According to a study commissioned by HeritagePA, an estimated 17.3 million visitors visited the entire network of Pennsylvania Heritage Areas in 2008. The impact of this tourism activity is significant to the local economies of each region.4 “In 2008, eight heritage areas participated in the study to assess the characteristics of the visitors to their sites and estimate the impact of the visitors on the local economies. The results from the surveys were used to estimate the total economic impact of the entire Pennsylvania heritage area network. Based on those surveys, it was estimated that: • Visitors to the entire HeritagePA network generated $1.6 billion in direct and indirect sales in 2007. “Measuring Economic Impacts of Historic Preservation.” Advisory Council on Historic Preservation. Donovan Rypkema and Caroline Cheong, PlaceEconomics, Washington, DC, and Randall Mason, PhD, University of Pennsylvania School of Design, Historic Preservation Program. 2 Ibid. 3 Ibid. 4 Ibid. 1 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 26 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods • These sales were enough to support more than 31,500 jobs, which paid nearly $600 million in wages and salaries. • The total direct and indirect value-added to the community from the heritage tourism related activity, in the form of personal income to workers, profits and rents to businesses, and in direct business taxes paid to government, was estimated to be $934 million in 2008.”5 According to the Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development website, “Pennsylvania has long been a travel destination, boasting a rich, multifaceted history and an ideal combination of sleek cityscapes, charming small towns, rugged woodlands and lush countryside to explore. As such, the tourism industry has always been a strong component of the state economy and continues to attract new visitors each year.”6 “Tourism bolsters the economy in a variety of direct and far-reaching ways. Tourism’s total economic impact on the state’s economy in 2011 was $32.9 billion. Tourism and its resulting impacts are providing job sustainability across the state. The number of jobs supported by Pennsylvania’s travel and tourism industry in 2011 was 450,000+. Visitors to Pennsylvania’s state parks [of which French Creek within HBW is one] spent $859 million in 2010.”7 The “charming small towns, rugged woodlands and lush countryside” described as major draws for tourists are all present within and nearby the Berks County section of the HBW. The potential to market the area for heritage tourism should be developed and capitalized upon as a means of promoting interest in cultural and historic resources and of generating funds for their preservation. HBW partners are advised to work together to develop a regional self-guided “Heritage Trail” or “Heritage Tour” similar Chester County Park & Recreation’s “Iron and Steel Tours” for Berks County that will include multiple historic sites within and nearby the HBW, particularly those that are open to the public such as Hopewell Furnace NHS, Daniel Boone Homestead, Joanna Furnace Complex, Allegheny Aquaduct, Old Morlatton Village, and Pine Forge. An obvious focus or link is the local industrial and transportation heritage with emphasis on the iron industry. 5 http://www.newpa.com/business/key-industries/tourism Ibid. 7 Ibid. 6 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 27 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Promotional postcard for an event held at Hopewell Furnace NHS in November, 2009 Brief Historical Analysis Southeastern Townships in Berks County Within and Nearby the HBW An overwhelming impetus for the settlement of the entire Hopewell Big Woods area and nearby areas was the iron industry. In the “Coventries,” the sphere of northern Chester County, we find the second oldest iron producer in Pennsylvania: Coventry Forge and Iron Works, founded by Samuel Nutt in 1717. Across the river, in nearby Douglass Township of Berks County, is Pennsylvania’s first iron works, Rutter’s Bloomery Forge, founded by Thomas Rutter in 1716. From these two earliest iron producers grew a proliferation of other major iron works, many within the Berks County Hopewell Big Woods area and nearby. These Townships of southeastern Berks County that contain historic iron works are the earliest settled section of the County. It is important to note that upon the founding of Berks County in1752, Union Township, a core township of the Hopewell Big Woods, was formed in part from North Coventry Township of Chester County and from Robeson Township of Lancaster County. The name Union was chosen because the township was a union of two sections of territory. Union Township and the Coventries of Chester County retain to this day strong historical and architectural ties, as well as A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 28 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods geographical, geological, genealogical, and socio-economic connections. This close border area of Chester and Berks counties lies at the heart of the Hopewell Big Woods. Beginning with the start of the 18th century, colonists moved up the Schuylkill into this region. Because of this early pattern of settlement, the Berks Townships of Union, Robeson, and nearby areas of Exeter, Amity and Douglass, have critically important historic sites such as Hopewell Furnace NHS, Joanna Furnace, Pine Forge, and the Daniel Boone and Mordechai Lincoln Homesteads. Other historic resources of importance include early small villages such as Old Morlatton Village (Douglassville), Browertown (Unionville), and the Borough of Birdsboro. Besides these well known sites, there is a plethora of other eighteenth and early-19th century structures, many of them built of stone, within the Hopewell Big woods area of Berks and nearby Berks environs. For example, the southern corner of the Berks County area of the Hopewell Big Woods, lies Caernarvon Township, with the ancient village of Morgantown. The historical background of Caernarvon Township differs somewhat from that of the other core Berks townships of the Hopewell Big Woods, as it was settled by Welsh colonists from the earlier “Welsh Tract.” However, its historic resources are significant. To understand the importance of these historic resources, their relationship with each other, and their contribution to the HBW, the historical, cultural, ethnic, religious, architectural and economic ties of the HBW area within Berks County were studied. A summary of the research and an interpretation of the findings are included in the report. To demonstrate how diverse communities and geographic areas were linked from the earliest years of the 18th century into the present, a brief narrative history of the region encompassing the HBW in Berks and nearby is provided. Robeson Township, a region traditionally called “The Forest” and containing prominently early industrial sites such as Joanna Furnace and historically important villages such as Geigertown and Birdsboro, was found to have a historically important relationship with Hopewell Furnace and Village. The history and importance of Robeson are essential for a complete understanding of iron industry in and nearby the Berks County HBW and environs. Clusters of historically important sites that have an interrelated history such as Morlatton Village and Browertown (Unionville), which are directly across the Schuylkill River from each other, were historically interdependent and related to other communities within the greater HBW region, including those across the Berks border in Chester County. They have a direct tie with Hopewell NHS, as several factors, who dealt in buying and selling the iron goods produced at Hopewell NHS lived in Morlatton and Browertown (now Douglassville and Unionville), and many of the Inns that served the drovers for Hopewell stayed at Morlatton or Browertown. These individual sites will be studied further in the Prioritization and Interpretation Section that follows. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 29 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Historic Resources By Township Within the Hopewell Big Woods in Berks County Union Township Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (3) Hopewell Furnace NHS French Creek State Park: 1) Six Penny Day Use Area, 2) Organized Group Camp Class I Historic Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (1) Yocom House (in Unionville) Pre Historic Native American Flint Site in Unionville Class I Historic Districts Recognized by PHMC (4) Hopewell Village NHS Browertown / Unionville French Creek State Park 1) Six Penny Day Use Area, 2) Organized Group Camp Class II Historic Resources/Sites Schuylkill Navigation Canal Structures Unionville Aqueduct Brower Farm(s) Brower Forge Unionville Inn (Hotel) Route 724, “Old Coventry Road” corridor (Birdsboro to Chester County line) Monocacy/Mt Airy Other Class II Historic Resources Mills, bridges, barns, farms, historic houses, churches and graveyards, forges Robeson Township Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (4) Allegheny Aqueduct (Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park) Geiger Mill Joanna Furnace Complex Thompson Mill Class I Historic Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (3) Beidler House and Mill Site (Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park) Bitler Farm White Bear Tavern A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 30 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Class I Historic Districts Recognized by PHMC (4) Beidler House and Mill Site Joanna Furnace Complex Geigertown, Geiger’s Mill Class II Sites Scarlett’s Mill Old Mill Inn Other Class II Sites Forges, grist mills, graveyards, historic houses, barns, farms Caernarvon Township Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (1) Morgantown Historic District Class I Historic Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places Col. Jacob Morgan Homestead Ames House Col. Jonathan Jones House Donald Zagar Farm Jacob Herztler House J.Kurtz Limekiln Kurtz Beiler Farmstead (7) Class I Historic Districts Recognized by PHMC (1) Morgantown Historic District Class II Sites Graveyards Other Class II Resources Forges, grist mills, historic houses, farms, barns Borough of Birdsboro Class I Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (1) St. Michael’s Protestant Episcopal Church Class I Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (3) Bird Mansion Edward Brooke II Mansion E & G Brooke Ironworks A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 31 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Class I Historic Districts Recognized by PHMC (6) Birdsboro Iron Industry Mill Street Worker’s Houses “Brooklyn” Worker’s Houses “Mexico” Worker’s Houses “Texas” Worker’s Houses Route 82 Section Class II Sites Canal Lock House Schuylkill Navigation Canal Structures Hay Creek Aqueduct Other Class II Sites Mills, bridges, iron industry structures A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 32 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Prioritizing Historic and Cultural Resources Within and Nearby the HBW in Berks County Union Township Background Union Township in Berks County lies at the heart of the Hopewell Big Woods. Historically part of the Coventry Township(s) of northern Chester County, Union Township signifies the “union” of two portions of land. One was from Lancaster County, and the other from Chester County, and these portions were joined in 1752 when Berks County was created. Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in Union Township At present, 2012, Union Township has three (3) Class I historic resources listed on the National Register of Historic Places: Hopewell Furnace NHS Village French Creek State Park /Organized Group Camp 4 (Presently Group Camps #1 and #2) French Creek State Park/ Six Penny Day Use Area Two (2) Class I historic resources are listed by PHMC as Eligible for the NRHP The John Yocom House in Unionville/Browertown A prehistoric Native American Site in Unionville. Four (4) Class I Historic Districts are recognized by a PHMC Survey. These four “Districts” include: Hopewell Furnace NHS Village, French Creek State Park/Organized Group Camp 4 (Presently Group Camps #1 and #2) French Creek State Park /Six Penny Day Use Area The village of Browertown / Unionville Within each “District” there are innumerable historic structures that reflect the history of this Township, beginning with the 18th century Hopewell Furnace and its village, the late-18th, early19th century village of “Browertown”/Unionville with its deep ties to Hopewell Furnace and the A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 33 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Schuylkill Navigation Canal, and on to the 20th century French Creek State Park with its 1930s CCC camping and day use areas. As Union Township is one of the oldest Township areas to be included in Berks County, there are large numbers of 18th and early 19th century structures, including barns, farmhouses, spring houses, farm dependencies, inns, canal structures, bridges, mills, churches, graveyards, and other structures. Many of these structures, particularly in the village of Browertown/Unionville, would qualify for eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places in terms of historic significance and uniqueness, identification with a specific historical period, and/or a specific prominent builder. A good number of these venerable structures were listed by the county as Historic Resources in the Survey of Historic Resources that was undertaken by the Berks County Conservancy in the early 1980s. These listing were updated, and many Historic and Cultural Resources were added to the list in 2007 under the auspices of the Berks County Planning Commission. More Resources are being added on a continuing basis. Presently, 2012, there are 65 Historic and Cultural Resources listed by the Berks Planners for Union Township, and this number by no means represents the total number of cultural and historic resources that lie within Union Township. National Register of Historic Places Properties in Union Township Hopewell Furnace NHS Overview Of utmost historic significance, within the HBW area of Berks County is Hopewell Furnace NHS. It is of FIRST PRIORITY in fulfilling the stringent criteria for inclusion as a National Register of Historic Places property. As a nationally recognized site of historic importance, Hopewell Furnace NHS is vitally important for interpreting the history of the area, is a premier draw for historic tourism, and is an important economic entity in a largely forested area of scattered small villages. The historic significance of Hopewell Furnace NHS village lies in its association with the American Revolution, as well as its long life as an industrial community, and is representative of the many charcoal ironworks that flourished in Berks and Chester Counties in 18th and early 19th century Pennsylvania. Hopewell Furnace NHS is one of the finest examples existing of a rural American 19th century iron plantation. It showcases an early American industrial landscape, from natural resource extraction to present day enlightened conservation. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 34 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Brief History Hopewell Furnace was founded in 1771 by ironmaster Mark Bird, for whose family nearby Birdsboro was named. Spanning the years from 1771 to 1883, Hopewell produced vital ordnance such as shot, shell and cannon for the Revolutionary War effort. Its most prosperous years were the 1820-1840 period, with another boom in production during the American Civil War. In the mid-19th century changes in iron making, including a shift from charcoal to anthracite fuel, rendered smaller furnaces like Hopewell obsolete. The site discontinued operations in 1883. Historic and Cultural Resources at Hopewell NHS Hopewell Furnace is significant for its cultural and historic resources. In the core historic area there are 14 restored structures, 52 features on the List of Classified Structures, and a total of 848 mostly wooded acres. Hopewell Furnace NHS is surrounded by French Creek State Park on three sides, and State game Lands to the south, which preserves the lands the furnace utilized for its natural resources, charcoal making. This vast wooded acreage that is part of the site itself and the surrounding woodland is part of the great eastern American forests; it is part of the Hopewell Big Woods. Hopewell Furnace NHS Village principal core buildings consist of a blast furnace and its dependant buildings and structures (cast house, bridge house etc.), the ironmaster’s mansion and its auxiliary dependencies (bake ovens, spring house, smoke house). Also included in the Village are a company store and office, a blacksmith shop, a fieldstone barn, and several stone workers’ houses, including a “boarding house.” Outlying buildings include the Bethesda Chapel, the John Church House, and other structures. Threats and Mitigation In 1935 the Federal government purchased Hopewell Furnace and approximately 6,200 acres of land with the primary purpose of developing a park and recreation area. By 1938, after research and the beginnings of restoration, the Hopewell Furnace was designated “Hopewell Village National Historic Site” because of its “relationship to the Colonial history of the United States.” Hopewell Furnace NHS, as a national historic site with its surrounding forest, is protected from many outside influences and degradation such as zoning laws that fail to protect historic properties, neglect, and abandonment. Nevertheless, the pressure of development in this area is a constant threat, as the site and its surrounding State Parks and State Games Lands are nearby to several large urban clusters such as Philadelphia and the greater Philadelphia area. Safeguards must be taken to ensure the continued funding, interest, and protection by the Federal Government and the State of Pennsylvania. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 35 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Hopewell NHS, because of its historic ties to other cultural and historic resources of the HBW area, will continue to be a developing and important “hub” for local and regional historic tourism. As seen within the past year, unforeseen threats such as forest fires in the HBW near Hopewell NHS must always be an aware and informed consideration, and constant preparedness and vigilance must be taken to protect this priceless historic resource. French Creek State Park Six Penny Day Use Area Organized Group Camp 4 Overview Structures in the two above named areas within French Creek State Park are on the National Register of Historic Structures. Dating from the 1930s, they are part of the originally constructed sections of the Park. Due to their early construction and being part of a large and popular State Park with its many visitors, and the fact that the Park itself encompasses another historic and core tourist attraction, Hopewell NHS, these French Creek buildings are to be considered to be of HIGH PRIORITY. French Creek State Park is a 7,526 acre Pennsylvania State Park in North Coventry and Warwick Townships in Chester County, and Robeson and Union Townships in Berks County. It straddles northern Chester County and southern Berks County along French Creek. Nearby Hopewell Furnace NHS is surrounded by the Park. This beautiful park is part of the Schuylkill Highlands/Hopewell Big Woods, and is the largest block of contiguous forest between Washington DC and New York City. Its historic significance lies in the fact that it once was part of the Hopewell Furnace early American industrial complex, and its vast forest lands supplied the charcoal for the furnace. Even to this day one can find areas of old “charcoal burns” and the ancient “roads” leading to the furnace or meandering through the woods to the river and main roads such as “the Coventry Road” (Route 724). Brief History Once dominated by old growth American chestnut, clearing of these forests began in 1771 with the need to produce charcoal to feed the iron furnace at nearby Hopewell. By the close of the furnace in 1883 after 112 years of rounds of growth and clearance, damage was done to the natural local ecology. But the forest growth slowly began to grow back. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 36 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods In 1935 the Federal government purchased approximately 6,200 acres of land with the primary purpose of developing a park and recreational area. In the 1930s the land of French Creek State Park was reclaimed by the efforts of the Civilian Conservation Corps created during the great depression by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to offset unemployment. The CCC worked to clear the forests and streams of brush. They also built many of the facilities still in use today at the park, including several tent camping areas, two small dams and lakes, two group camps, picnic areas, and extensive roads and trails throughout the park. They also began restoration of the historic Hopewell Furnace. Historic and Cultural Resources at French Creek State Park There are several original wooden buildings built by the CCC in the 1930s that are still in use in the park. The construction of these CCC built structures is of wood, weatherboard, and log. One is the Six Penny Day Use Area, and near the Park Office is a long prominent, one story wooden building. It resembles a barracks, and was used, most likely, as a barracks when the CCC was encamped there. Presently called “The Chapel,” it has served in various other capacities, and is presently used to store maintenance equipment. Behind the barracks/Chapel is another CCC built wooden structure which is the office of the Park Naturalist. Also of CCC construction is the Organized Group Camp 4, comprised of camper and staff cabins, dining halls, and central washhouses. The many other structures built by the CCC, such as the two small dams and lakes, and roads and trails, are to be considered as historic and cultural resources as well. They contribute to the enjoyment of hiking, fishing, boating and biking for the many people who come there. UPDATE: December 2012. A field trip was made to French Creek State Park to ascertain the condition of the original CCC structures of the park. Personnel at the park office stated that the original campgrounds present designations are Camp #1 and Camp #2. At this time revisions and repairs are being done at Camp #2. The day use area with the barracks/Chapel is kept in good repair. In the original 1982 Survey of Historic Resources at the park the original CCC built Park Office was listed. That building was removed and a new Park Office, better suited to its purposes of education and service, was constructed in 1997. Threats and Mitigation The forests, lakes, wetlands and fields of this state park are an important attraction for the people of southeast Pennsylvania. There is immense pressure for development in all the areas surrounding this park. This development can contribute to pollution, overuse of local roads, and other degradations. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 37 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Being a state park, funding for it can be subject to the whims of whatever political party is ensconced in Harrisburg. Vigilance must be ever present to physically maintain all of the structural historic resources, including “the Barracks,” presently used as a maintenance building. Always of great concern is the threat of forest fire. As seen in the “Hopewell Fire of 2012,” it was the “longest, largest, and most expensive fire operation in the Pennsylvania Bureau of Forestry history.” Great care was made to lessen the threat to private homes and property, and there were optimistic predictions for new forest growth in the areas that were affected by the fire. Structures Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places The Yocom House in Unionville (formerly Browertown) This early 19th stone house with its functioning spring house, barn, and other structures, is part of the historic rural village of Unionville, which is historically known and documented as Browertown. It will be described in the following section concerning the Browertown/ Unionville Historic District. Prehistoric Native American Site in Unionville Described at length in the section concerning Browertown/Unionville Historic Districts Recognized by a PHMC Survey Hopewell Furnace NHS Village – See above French Creek State Park. Six Penny Day Use Area – See above French Creek State Park, Organized Group Camp 4, Now Camps #1 and #2 – See above Village of Unionville/Browertown A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 38 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The Browertown/Unionville Historic District The home built by Abraham Brower for his daughter Mary and her husband, David Jones, has an 1812 datestone. Photograph by Susan Speros. Overview The village of Unionville, earlier called Browertown after its founders, the Abraham Brower family, is the oldest hamlet in Union Township. Its historic resources include twelve or more 18th and early 19th century structures, are grouped together principally along the Unionville Road, with several on Route 724, the old Coventry Road. The town borders consist of the Schuylkill River, and southerly the village environs go beyond the bed of the Schuylkill Navigation Canal, which cuts through the middle of the town. Its easternmost boundary is the Chester County line, which lies about ½ mile from the village center. With its unusual and historic architecture, its close ties to Hopewell Furnace NHS and the early iron industry, and its proximity to the Canal, the historic village of Unionville/Browertown is of HIGH PRIORITY and historic significance. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 39 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Brief History The land area that encompasses the town of Unionville is part of the original WangerBrower tract, (Patented in 1750). In 1793 the large tract was willed to 33 year old Abraham Brower Sr. by his uncle Abraham Wanger. Abraham Brower Sr. and his sons, Abraham Jr., John, and Nicholas built a town and a small commercial empire out of it. Besides houses of unique herringbone-pattern stonework, masonry identical to that of nearby 1802 St. Gabriel’s Chapel (across the River Schuylkill in Douglassville, Amity Township), where they were members, the Brower family constructed Canal warehouses and docks Unionville Landing, and a store/Post Office called Brower (structure still in existence as a private home), as well as a large foundry, (Abraham Brower Jr. Furnace and Farm). They enlarged the large Georgian c.1770-80 Abraham Wanger house, and ran it as an Inn on the Coventry Road, known as Brower’s Inn or The Unionville Hotel. This Inn on the Coventry Road served drovers for nearby Hopewell Furnace and is now a private home. All of this, the foundry, the Inn, the Canal warehouses, store, and a boat yard run by their Yocom cousins, was in collaboration with the great iron works at Hopewell. Besides running their farms, store, Inn, foundry, and Canal warehouse, all the Brower men worked for Hopewell. John Brower was the Clerk for Hopewell for several years, and his father and brothers were Factors for Hopewell, selling and shipping the goods from Hopewell and their Brower foundry via the Schuylkill Navigation Canal. Not incidentally, the foundations of the Brower foundry remain, as well as its waterwheel, pit and race. Historic and Cultural Resources in Browertown/Unionville Unionville’s major buildings were built in the early 1800s by Abraham Brower Sr. and his sons. The Brower built structures, of the local red sandstone, are distinctly Federal in style. There are several Georgian 18th century structures in the town and immediate environs as well. Perhaps one of the oldest buildings in the Township is the Unionville Hotel formerly known as Brower’s Inn located on the Old Coventry Road, Route 724. Built c. 1750 and enlarged with a Georgian addition in c.1770-80, and enlarged again c.1820, it is a red sandstone, center hall structure with Georgian corner fireplaces. There is a small area of herringbone-pattern stone work over one of the later doorways. Of great prominence are the two herringbone-pattern stonework houses in the village of Browertown/Unionville. These two charming red sandstone, 2 ½-story center hall Federal period homes sit across from each other on Unionville Road in the village. Constructed by Abraham Brower Sr. for his daughter Mary, one of the houses has a date stone DMJ 1812. They are the initials of David and Mary (Brower) Jones. (He is a descendant of Swedish pioneer Mounce Jones, whose 1716 stone house at Old Morlatton Village in Amity Township is considered the oldest extant house in Berks County.) A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 40 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Of additional importance is the fact that beautiful original woodwork is intact in both homes. This woodwork has been identified to be that of local master carpenters Jacob and John Bunn. There are many structures in the area that are the work of the Bunns, including St.Gabriel’s Chapel with its red sandstone herringbone-pattern masonry. It is interesting to note that one of Mary Brower Jones’ sisters was married to master carpenter John Bunn. Identified Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places John Yocom House, c. 1780, rebuilt c. 1820 Situated in the town on the Unionville Road, it is a five-bay, 2 ½-story Georgian/Federal style red sandstone farmhouse with a center hall, and is very similar to the other early 19th century houses in Unionville. It has several intact dependencies including a spring house and rebuilt barn. It was originally a dairy farm owned by the Yocom family, one of the original Swedish settlers of this area. Prehistoric Native American Site Located in Unionville, situated on a small rise with a strongly flowing springhead, over 1800 artifacts, including numerous flints, identifying it as a flint manufacturing site, were recovered during an archaeological dig that was required prior to the start of the development “Union Greene.” There are many contributing historic structures within and surrounding Browertown/Unionville. Besides the commercial buildings named, there are several all but complete historic 18th century “Brower farms” which could qualify for NRHP status, and were highlighted in the PHMC Survey of Historic Resources in the early 1980s. Also very prominent in the village vicinity are the Unionville Aqueduct and other Schuylkill Navigation Canal structures. Threats and Mitigation The threats to this charming rural village cannot be overestimated, and are an echo of the existing profound threats to the rural character of Union Township itself. In 2006 there posed a grave threat to the historic village of Browertown/Unionville and its environs. Heritage Building Group of Bucks County wanted to build a development of 137 houses on 110 aces, right in the middle of historic Unionville. Scheduled to be destroyed was the c.1825 Yocom barn. Also threatened were Canal remains and structures. Most disturbing was the plan to utterly obliterate a well documented Prehistoric Native American site that is eligible for the NRHP. Local Unionville residents formed a grassroots group called Unionville Neighbors, committed to saving these important parts of their local historic identity and history. In response A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 41 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods to negative publicity and pressure from the Unionville Neighbors, Heritage Building Group agreed to make changes to its plans for its upcoming development “Union Greene.” Plans were redrawn to “significantly preserve the Native American site and springhead” and donate to Union Township the 1,800 artifacts recovered in a mandated archaeological dig. Rather than outright demolition, the Yocom barn was turned over to “John High the Barn Saver” who carefully dismantled the historic barn. Although the original Yocom Canal Boatyard site was completely obliterated by earth moving equipment, other canal structures and ruins were monitored by the Unionville Neighbors, and were left intact. These outcomes show that even though citizens did not stop the development, they did mitigate it significantly. Heritage’s change of plans demonstrates that grassroots neighborhood preservation groups do have a voice, and the political will to preserve priceless architectural and cultural heritage. UPDATE: December 2012. With the financial crash, “Heritage Building Group” also crashed monumentally, but, not without inflicting a great deal of damage to the venerable geographic, architectural, and agricultural landscape of Unionville. There forlornly sits a handful of houses that Heritage built on land that has lost its gentle agricultural contours and legacy. The Canal bed and boat basin on this piece of land are gone forever. The fine Federal period Yocom barn was removed, along with the heritage apple orchard that was behind it. This is a stark reminder that even “mitigated” development can and does have a deleterious effect on the essential fabric of a historic community. Important Contributing Historic Structures of Undetermined NRHP Status in Union Township There are many important historic structures and resources in Union Township that are recognized as such by both state and local governance, but their NRHP status has not been determined. Although not of high priority such as Hopewell NHS and/or structures found in French Creek State Park, these other sites and structures contribute greatly to the historic landscape of Union Township and the heart of the HBW. Many of them could be declared eligible for NRHP status as they meet one or more of the requirements, if the applications were filled out and sent to PHMC. The early historic and cultural landscape of Union Township within the HBW is old, with ancient ties between the several iron producing enterprises that made up this landscape, be it in Berks or Chester County. The small villages, churches, and early farms all had connections with each other, and one finds intertwined family and business ties throughout the area encompassing the HBW. The Schuylkill Navigation Canal Era further opened up the region, and brought new enterprise, and an expansion of older industry, farming, and commerce. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 42 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods There are innumerable historic structures and sites in Union Township, and the ones listed below contributed greatly to the early story of the Township. Contributing Historic Sites and Structures Farms and Period Houses, Unionville Vicinity Federal Period House AKA Morris House, c. 1820-25 On Unionville Road in Browertown, it is a five bay red sandstone house, 2 ½ stories with Federal characteristics. Built by John Brower, a son of town founder Abraham Brower. Daniel Yocom House, c. pre1800, rebuilt c. 1830-40 Three bay, stucco over stone house situated on the Coventry Road and diagonally across from the Unionville Hotel. Originally a 2-room, 1½-story house, it was enlarged in c. 1830-40. Brower Home Farm AKA ClayMir Farm or Root Farm, c. 1752, addition1820 Situated on Unionville Road, is an almost complete 18th century farm complex with settler’s house/summer kitchen, ice house, commodious barn, pond, and other buildings. The fine original woodwork was done by master carpenters Jacob and John Bunn. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 43 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods th The Abraham Brower, Sr. farmstead consists of an almost complete 18 -century complex including a settler’s cabin, summer kitchen, icehouse, barn and other outbuildings. Photograph by Susan Speros. Brower Farm, c. 1750, addition 1806 Situated uphill from and adjacent to the Brower Home Farm, is this almost complete 18th century farm complex of Abraham Brower, Sr. The stone barn has Federal characteristics, including semi circular door arches of beautifully cut stone. Jones Farm, c.1780, addition c.1850 Situated on Unionville Road. Georgian 2 ½-story stone banked farmhouse, with spring house, barn, and 18th century stone cabin. Connected to the Jones family, early Swedish settlers of the region. Schuylkill Navigation Canal Structures Unionville Aqueduct AKA Cold Spring Aqueduct, 1822 Constructed as part of the Schuylkill Navigation Canal, the Aqueduct conducted water over Goose Neck Creek. It sits in the middle of the Unionville environs on private property, and is very difficult to access. This Aqueduct is in good condition and is similar to the one at Gibraltar. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 44 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Hopewell Landing/Port Union, c. 1700s, Schuylkill Nav. Canal era, 1820 Situated at Red Corner Road and the Coventry Road AKA Route 724, this was first the depot for an 18th century track that ran from Hopewell Furnace to the Coventry Road. It became the site of a boatyard, mule barn, and commodious Federal style inn/tavern for the Schuylkill Navigation Canal. There are remains of the Canal prism and walls for the boatyard structures, further back from the Canal is the well preserved Inn, now a private home, and further along are the foundations of the Canal mule barn, now functioning as a garage/barn. There was also a Canal store located here, associated with A. Bannon. This wooden structure is now a private home. Mule Barn for Schuylkill Navigation System, 1820s Located in the vicinity of the Berks/Chester County line off the Coventry Road, Route 724, this Canal mule barn is in excellent condition, and is on private land. It is near a long and hidden stretch of Schuylkill Navigation Canal prism that is relatively intact. Farms and Period Houses, Union Township Old Sycamore Farm, c. 1770, addition 1790 Located on Sycamore Road, this Colonial era log and stone home has been recently restored. There is also a barn and spring head. New Sycamore Farm, c. 1823 Across the road from Old Sycamore Farm is a complex that was once a dairy farm. A small building on the premises houses an old bank of batteries, one of the first sources of electricity in the area. NOTE: “Sycamore Farms” was once a consortium of several area farms in the 20th century, which served as working farms year round and as a summer home for the owners. John Wanger House, c. 1771 Located on Hallman Road, this large early house was built by a member of the local Wanger family. It is a Georgian three bay with side hall plan, stone banked house. There is an intact summer kitchen, the barn has been demolished. Structures on Route 724 AKA The Old Coventry Road The Old Coventry Road, Route 724, dating from the 18th century, is one of the earliest roads in the area. It is a road that conveyed iron from Hopewell into Chester County and beyond and later the Schuylkill Navigation Canal bordered it. There are many historic structures along this road, including 18th century farms and farmhouses. Inns and taverns that serviced drovers for the furnaces also later did a lively A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 45 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods business for Canal boat men and travelers. In the early 19th century, between the Villages of Browertown and Monocacy, there were many homes built with a distinctive regional Federal vernacular appearance. Still standing, these structures continue to serve as fine private homes. Monocacy Village AKA Mt Airy, Monocacy, Teresa Furnace, 1857 Located on Route 724 this anthracite Iron Furnace moved from Hopewell to this site in 1857 due to the cost of hauling the coal from the Schuylkill Nav. Canal to Hopewell and the finished iron back to the Canal. First called “Teresa Furnace,” and then operated as Monocacy Furnace, the furnace was situated in the village of Monocacy, which grew up around it. The furnace no longer exists. However the village remains with various housing, and a group of company houses, and a small church and schoolhouse, both are dwellings at present. Flannery’s Mill and House, 1859 Located near the present Village of Monocacy, the Flannery Grist Mill, built in 1859, was a large wooden structure that was demolished in 1972. The nearby handsome miller’s house with its Italianate detail stands in good condition. Kerlin House, c.1800, additions c. 1840-50 Located at Route 724 and Black Matt Road. Georgian/Federal, two five bay stone houses set at right angles to each other, and joined at the ell of the first house. Contains woodwork and an identical mantel to that of other Bunn carpentry found in Unionville. Barn converted to apartments. Built by the Kerlin family, who were early settlers in the area. Kerlin House, Date Stone “1789 IK” Located on Route724 AKA The Old Covenry Road. Original section Georgian three bay, side hall entry 2 ½-story, red sandstone with heavy quoins and a gable pent eave, later section 1½-story, 6-bay with dormers. There is also a handsome barn on the property. Property not far from the Kerlin property located at Route 724 and Black Matt Road. William Kerlin’s Gun Barrel Shop, c. 1750, revised c. 1800 Situated on Route 724 near other early Kerlin family holdings. A small 1 ½-story Colonial era red sandstone structure with a steep pitched roof. Presently a dwelling place. Covatta’s Brinton Lodge AKA Flannery’s Tavern, c. 1750, Federal section 1800 This rambling red sandstone structure has a long history. An early mill was located at this site, built by Millard, and then owned by Yocom, Wanger, Brower, Kerlin, and Flannery. No traces of the mill can be found. The original core is a c.1750 one room stone structure in which a large fireplace and open beams are found. The main wing is a five bay Federal structure with a A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 46 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods fireplace mantel identical to that found in houses in Browertown/Unionville and the Brower home farm. On site is a small barn. Black Bear Tavern, 1831 Situated on Route 724, Associated with St. Paul’s Mission Catholic Church across the street. It was built by Matthew Ryan, who was an Irish immigrant engineer who helped build the local Canals. Five-bay, 2-story red sandstone structure. It is presently a dwelling. Houses built by Matthew Ryan and Henry Flannery, prominent Irish immigrants to the neighborhood, still stand on Route 724, and are private dwellings. Churches and Graveyards St. Paul’s Mission Catholic Chapel, 1853 Located on Route 724 this small Catholic Chapel was constructed by H. Flannery and M. Ryan for nearby Irish Catholic Canal and railroad workers. Bishop John Newman, now a Roman Catholic saint, dedicated the Church. Constructed of stucco over stone, with an apse in the rear, it is now in disuse though still owned by the Diocese of Allentown. Presently in a moderate state of decay, attempts have been made to restore the building, and it was re-roofed several years ago. St. Paul’s Graveyard: Contains many Flannery and Ryan burials. Outside the walls proper of the Cemetery is a separate graveyard for many people who died in the terrible Influenza epidemic of 1918. Overall, the Graveyard of St. Paul’s is neglected. Mount Frisby AME Church AKA The Six Penny Colored Church or Mt. Zion Church, 1856 Located near Birdsboro and three miles from Hopewell Furnace NHS, this church and its small community was a haven for “free coloreds” and escaping slaves, many of whom worked at nearby Hopewell Furnace. By 1860, there were nine houses surrounding the Church, and this little community was an important stop in the Underground Railroad. Constructed of the local red sandstone, the Church is a one story three bay structure. Mount Frisby Graveyard: The graveyard is the oldest African American cemetery in Berks County. Buried here is Isaac Cole, one of the Church founders. The church stands upon land that he owned. He served in the US Colored Troops in the Civil War and was a long time worker at Hopewell Furnace. His Cole descendants continue to live nearby, own the land where the Church is located, and care for the Church and Graveyard. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 47 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods CONCLUSION Union Township Threats to the Historic Architectural Landscape There are grave threats to Union Township’s historic and cultural legacy. The unique architectural legacy of this area is singular, and is threatened with ever increasing pressures of development. For example, the village of Unionville/Browertown is architecturally cohesive with 18th and early 19th century structures, and has few 20th century intrusions in its fabric. These are scattered and blend into the town landscape fairly unobtrusively. The proposed large scale development that was to be inflicted on the village in 2006 would have ruined the remaining architectural integrity of this charming, sleepy village. Luckily, plans fell through, but not until after permanent damage was done. Another, and perhaps gravest threat, is the proposed racetrack. This recreational amusement will inflict noise, crowds, a heavy burden on what are largely rural roads; a burden on Police and Fire protection; ecological damage; and certain damage to the historic nature of the Township. Nevertheless, this township has done better than most other townships in dealing with threats to its rural and historic integrity. In response to the racetrack there has been heavy support of the people in backing their township’s expensive fight against the racetrack. The population is quite vocal, cohesive, and involved, and they do attend and voice their opinions at township meetings. Along with this were citizen’s groups such as UTU-Union Township United, which fought the good fight against the racetrack. Another active and vociferous group was Unionville Neighbors who organized against the development group that wanted to drop 137 homes into the middle of their historic neighborhood. Mitigation Union Township is largely rural, dominated by vast forests, with the Hopewell Big Woods encompassing the lands of French Creek State Park, Hopewell NHS, and State Game Lands. The rest of the township is composed of small farms, scattered single homes, and sleepy hamlets. Although the large Federal and State Lands and historic sites are protected, the heavy and increasing pressures for development are targeted at the remaining unprotected lands. The strength of Union Township lies in its rural character. Its charming villages and rural architectural legacy is an attraction for those seeking our past. They come to Hopewell NHS for its strong sense of history and striking visual story. It would be a natural progression to tour the attractive back roads of Union Township, and linger through the charming village of Unionville, or stroll along its remaining Canal tow path. The potential for historic tourism in Union Township is real. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 48 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Protection of this historic architectural legacy begins at the township level. Besides the vigilance of its people, Union Township officials will continue to tread the fine line in enforcing what should be strong zoning laws concerning historic preservation, and adhering to the suggestions concerning protection of its priceless cultural and historic resources set forth in the Joint Comprehensive Plan for the township, and all the while cautiously dealing with development. A Township Citizen’s Advisory Board overseeing historic preservation is strongly recommended to monitor any demolition permits of historic properties, and make recommendations for mitigation such as demolition delays, or even suggesting alternate uses for the building or structures, or adaptive re-use. Surrounding Counties such as Chester and Lancaster have a historic preservationist, usually attached with the County Planning Commission, who oversees all historic preservation issues in their County. Unfortunately Berks County does not have an appointed historic preservationist for the County to oversee pending demolition of historic structures and make recommendations for mitigation. So, in Berks County NRHP eligible historic structures can and do disappear overnight. At the present time The Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County, based in nearby Douglassville, is to assume the role of historic preservation consultant for the County, and would make an excellent working partner for Union Township in cultural and historic preservation matters. UPDATE: The Commonwealth Pipeline, March 2013. In the past the HBW community of related townships has reacted resourcefully to threats to its historic and natural landscape and legacy, as evidenced by Union Township’s creative and partially successful method of dealing with a housing development’s threat to its historic architectural legacy in Unionville. Another example in Union Township of the galvanizing combined forces of municipality and citizenry was their well fought battle against the racetrack, which remains a real threat to the historic and ecological fabric of the community. Now a new, and potentially harmful threat has cropped up, namely The Commonwealth Gas Pipeline. Extending from the Marcellus Shale gas fields in northern Pennsylvania, and heading southeast through Chester and Berks Counties, the 120 mile pipeline is proposed to run through the heart of the HBW. The HBW is a very sensitive and important ecological area with many priceless historic resources. With the amount of clear cutting and ecological destruction required for the pipeline, among other potentially disastrous effects, it is imperative that it be stopped from coming even close to the HBW. Several municipalities of Chester County that will be affected have adopted resolutions against the proposed interstate pipeline. Union Township does not want it either, and township officials are proposing sensible mitigations. Suggestions are to change the pipeline’s route away from such ecologically sensitive areas like the Big Woods, and protect township resident’s property rights as well. An alternative would be installation routes that follow public right of ways, or follow the PA Turnpike, or even put the pipe under roads. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 49 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Further damaging the pipeline’s negative public image is the fact that officials representing the pipeline seem to be avoiding inquiries and phone calls from officials of the townships involved. In the meantime, citizens will move forward with continued awareness, and increase public knowledge and education about the potential negative impacts of this pipeline. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 50 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Robeson Township Historical Background Robeson Township was originally part of Lancaster County until 1752 when Berks County was founded. First settled in the early 1720s and becoming an organized township by 1729, it was named Robeson after one of its first settlers, Andrew Robeson (originally Robinson). Andrew Robeson/Robinson was a wealthy and influential man who owned large parcels of land in the Philadelphia area and west New Jersey. In 1714 he settled on the 500+ acres he had bought on the south side of the Schuylkill River and west of Birdsboro. Robeson/Robinson was of lowland Scots Quaker background, whose family sojourned in Ireland for some years before coming to the Colonies. Like Robeson, most of the earliest settlers in the area were from the British Isles with English and Welsh being the most predominant. Geographically, this township is largely composed of wooded hills and narrow valleys. Its chief settlement and industry was along the Hay and Allegheny Creeks. The iron industry came early to Robeson Township, with the original Gibraltar Forge established by the Quaker Lewis family in 1779 and Joanna Furnace by Samuel Potts in 1789. Historically known as The Forest, Robeson Township remains largely wooded and rural and is a vital part of the HBW. Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in Robeson Township At present, 2012, within Robeson Township there are four (4) Class I historic resources listed On the National Register of Historic Places. Allegheny Aqueduct (Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park) Joanna Furnace Complex Geiger Mill Thompson Mill There are three (3) Class I historic resources listed by PHMC as Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. Beidler House and Mill Site (Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park) A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 51 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods 1803 Farm Complex White Bear Tavern Three (3) Class I Historic Districts are recognized by a PHMC Survey. Beidler House and Mill Site Joanna Furnace Complex Geiger’s Mill, Geigertown The sites and properties that are noted above are a very good indicator of the chief industries and focus of the early settlers of Robeson Township. Certainly there was a great deal of farming in the area, but the steep hills and ravines precluded any large scale farming such as that found in the Oley Valley. The sandstone shale soil of the district could not support such a large scale farming endeavor. However, abundant strong flowing streams like the Hay and Allegheny Creeks supported wide scale milling operations from earliest times, and the iron industry was an important endeavor. The vast forested slopes provided excellent charcoal for nearby furnaces like Joanna, and Hopewell in Union Township. Tucked away in the hills and valleys of Robeson Township are a wealth of historic 18th and 19th century structures. Constructed of the local red sandstone, there are mills, farmhouses, barns, springhouses, churches and graveyards, bridges and forges and farms. As of the present, 2012, there are 100 properties listed in the Countywide Survey of Historic Resources for Robeson Township. Using the original 1983 Surveys as a base, historic properties were carefully re-evaluated in 2007, and heretofore unknown or missed properties were added to the list. These Surveys are being continuously updated by the Berks County Planners. National Register of Historic Places Properties in Robeson Township Joanna Furnace Overview In the late-18th century, the placement of the Joanna Furnace site in the midst of “The Forest” of Robeson Township was a natural one. The vital components for a large scale iron furnace were all there, iron ore, the large forest that furnished wood for charcoal, limestone for flux or tempering, and strong waterways to provide power. Its historic significance lies in the fact that Joanna Furnace was a vital link in the thriving iron making industry of this area of Berks County. The intermarriages of the iron master’s families of this important furnace further linked Joanna to the larger early iron industry of southeast Pennsylvania. The rise and restoration of this long forgotten furnace complex, and its position on the National Register of Historic Places places it as a HIGHEST PRIORITY historic site within the HBW of Berks County. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 52 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Brief History Relatively speaking, Joanna Furnace had a long life. It operated from 1791 to 1898 when it permanently went out of blast. The furnace was a cold blast, charcoal iron furnace, but several major upgrades through the years, such as conversion from water power to steam, helped keep it in business. The 19th century upgrades were believed to be assisted by prominent iron master Clement Grubb whose daughter Ella Jane was married to L. Heber Smith, the last iron master of Joanna. Joanna Furnace was founded in 1791 by a partnership of Samuel Potts, Thomas May, Thomas Bull, and Thomas Rutter III, and named after Samuel Potts’ wife Joanna Holland Potts. As in keeping with these families of “iron royalty,” all of these men and their families were heavily involved in the 18th century Pennsylvania iron industry, and many of them had concentrated iron wealth through intermarriage. Historic and Cultural Resources at Joanna Furnace The restored structures of this iron making village are numerous, especially when one considers that when the Hay Creek Valley Historical Association started to restore this site in the 1970s, it was an overgrown jungle of vines and crumbling stone walls. Significant restored and rebuilt structures are the casting house, furnace and engine house, stack, stables, office/store, and blacksmith’s structure. Much work remains, and is on-going. The site was acquired by Bethlehem Steel who deeded it to the Hay Creek Valley Association in 1979. The designated Joanna Furnace Historic District is on the National Register of Historic Places of Historic Places and is open to the public. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 53 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Joanna Furnace as photographed in June 2011 by “Archeology Dude” Marc Henshaw, courtesy of http://www.archaeologydude.com/2011_06_01_archive.html Threats and Mitigation The non-profit group which oversees all aspects of the preservation and restoration of Joanna Furnace, The Hay Creek Valley Association, is a strong, viable, and dedicated organization. With over 1000 members, it relies on volunteer efforts and donations to preserve the history of Joanna Furnace. Through wise management of funds and manpower it has managed to vibrantly resurrect this relic of our Berks County past. Concerning threats to the site, its strength is its weakness. As long as the HCV Association continues to be a strong advocate for the Furnace it will continue its advancement. In addition, sources of revenue such as Events and Presentations remain popular with good visitation numbers. Joanna Furnace will continue to be a strong attraction for historic tourism within the HBW area of Berks County. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 54 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park and the Beidler House and Grist Mill, 1783 Overview The Beidler House and Grist Mill/Allegheny Aqueduct Park and its “Gibraltar Neighborhood” have long been a hub of early industry in Berks County. From the saw mill established by 1735, to Conrad Beidler’s purchase of the property and construction of a grist mill in c.1770, and on through the Canal Era of the early 1800s and beyond, this site has been a microcosm of the lives of the early settlers and people who lived in Berks County and southeastern Pennsylvania in the 18th and 19th centuries. Owned by Berks County and administered by the Berks County Parks and Recreation Department, the restored Allegheny Aqueduct, which is on the NRHP , and the 1783 Beidler House, and c.1770 Grist Mill ruins, are a testament to the early industrial power, strong architectural expressiveness, and steadfast resourcefulness of our earliest settlers. The mill ruins alone as a historic resource might mistakenly be viewed as Class IV: Demolished or significantly altered property. However, they are important as an archeological resource. The combined historic qualities of the site define its importance and significance, and make it of HIGHEST PRIORITY as a historic and archeological resource. Brief History The Allegheny Aqueduct Park site is one of the earliest industrial sites in Berks County. As early as 1735 there was a large commercial saw mill situated on the strong and swift flowing Allegheny Creek, which flowed into the Schuylkill River, just a few hundred yards away. Reflective of the early demographics of the area, this sawmill was founded by “English Quakers” George Boone, James Lewis, and Jonathan Robeson, son of Andrew Robeson. By the mid 1700s there was a large influx of German settlers, and the sawmill site and its acreage was bought in 1761 by Conrad Beidler, son of a German immigrant. Conrad Beidler built a large merchant grist mill in c.1770, and he amassed enough wealth to build his beautiful Georgian house in 1783. Retiring in1787 and buying a large farm in Cumru Township, Conrad Beidler willed the house, grist and saw mills to his eldest son John. The property remained in the hands of the Beidler family until 1837 when William Beidler sold the property to ironmaster John Delcamp. It passed through several hands until the Berks County Parks Department acquired the site in the 1980s and obtained a Pennsylvania Keystone Grant to restore the house, and stabilize the mill ruins which had been badly damaged by a fire in the 1950s. The Allegheny Aqueduct is a tangible reminder of the fabled Canal era in Berks County. Once a “water bridge” over the Allegheny Creek, this important link for the Schuylkill A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 55 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Navigation System was restored through efforts of the Schuylkill River Greenway Association, and was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1984. The Beidler House, Photograph by Susan Speros Historic and Cultural Resources at the Allegheny Aqueduct and the Beidler House and Mill Designated as a Historic District by PHMC, the historic resources are of two different time periods, but are linked together historically. The grist mill ruins are considerable in size. Built as a merchant grist mill that ground grains for export as well as for local needs, this c.1770 Georgian structure is built of the local red sandstone, with the quarry of origin nearby. Badly damaged in the 1950s by a fire, it is still easy to discern where the giant water wheel was located as the wheel pit and head race are largely intact. The possibility exists that it may have been a combination house/mill, as corner fireplaces are readily seen in the remaining stone walls, and perhaps the family did live there until Conrad built his beautiful house in 1783. The 1783 banked house with its side hall entry, drip courses, pent roof, and regular fenestration with keystone motifs expresses the Georgian, early Federal aesthetics of the time. The stonework of the local red sandstone is masterful with dressed and regular courses and the load bearing walls having a slight taper towards the top. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 56 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Inside, the beautiful Georgian woodwork with its heavy crown molding and corner fireplaces is as to be expected in this fine house. Conrad Beidler expressed his high status in the community with a fine English Georgian house, but retained all the comforts and conveniences of German practicality with a stove room-back parlor and easy, banked cellar entrance. Outside, there remains a well preserved cold cellar, and in back of the house one can see the “banked” entrance of the original bank barn. The original spring house was likely situated where the present well is now. The “waterworks” for the grist mill were considerable, with two holding ponds and a long head race. There is little to be discerned of the saw mill site. The Allegheny Aqueduct was built by the Schuylkill Navigation Company in 1824 under the direction of engineer Ephraim Beech. It is a massive structure that is composed of five sandstone arches marking the “keystone” theme. The Canal was important in the neighborhood as it created a new and safer way of shipping goods, such as the Beidler lumber and grain. Because of its changes to the landscape at the earlier Beidler home and mill site, modifications had to be made to the mill race leading to the grist mill. Allegheny Aquaduct, Photograph by Susan Speros Threats and Mitigation The 15-acre Aqueduct and Beidler House and Mill site are administered by the Berks County Parks Department. There are plans to further develop the Park with meeting and workshop facilities, a small dock on the Schuylkill, and to further stabilize the mill ruins. At present, funding for Park development is inadequate, though increased Interpretive Programs and Events at the Park and Beidler House have taken place over the past few years. Another positive A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 57 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods development at the site is the Schuylkill River Sojourn, which has used the Park as an overnight stop on their week long “paddle” down the river. Beidler Mill Ruins, Photograph by Susan Speros Geiger’s Mill/Geigertown Overview The 1783 Geiger Mill Complex, located in the village of Geigertown along the Cold Run Creek, is representative of the importance of milling to the early Berks County economy. This property is an architecturally significant example of an 18th century mill complex. Although this mill does not have a great deal of milling equipment left in its interior, its multi-level plan and fenestration gives us valuable information on the placement of machinery and the operation of an 18th century grist mill. Because many of the architectural features of the original mill still exist on the exterior as well as the interior, this is an important mill in the Berks County section of the HBW. All of these significant Architectural, Industrial, and Engineering features qualify Geiger’s Mill for the NRHP and makes it of HIGHEST PRIORITY as a Historic and Cultural Resource Historic District. Brief History As early as 1768 Paul Geiger applied for a land warrant. He built his Georgian style grist mill in 1783 as the date stone attests, “Paul Geiger Anno 1783.” Near this building John Geiger had a carding mill, and a later Paul Geiger had a sickle factory, both of which are no longer in existence. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 58 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The Geiger family is shown as the owners on 1816, 1854 and 1862 county maps. The owner listed on the 1850 Census of Manufacture is James Geiger, the mill having a capital of $2,000, processing 6,000 bushels of wheat and rye with a product value of $5,400. In 1876 John Marquat purchased the mill from the Geiger family, ending the Geiger family’s more than 100 year ownership. Marquat sold the mill in 1893 to Wayne Dampman. Since that time the mill changed hands frequently, and ceased operation shortly after World War I in about 1919. Historic and Cultural Resources at the Geiger Mill Complex The historic resources include watercourses (pond and races), a banked 2½-story plus basement stucco over stone grist mill, a c.1783 Georgian/Federal style banked 2½-story stucco over stone house, a c.1800 stone smoke house with a hipped roof. This mill complex has few changes that interfere with its ability to depict its significant time period. The mill appears to be a 2½-story structure, but the interior floor plan has a multi-level configuration with five different floor elevations, with the fenestration reflecting these levels. The mill has Dutch doors, an internal bag hoist, and several original features indicating an early mill, such as the Hurst frame, and corner fireplaces on the first and second levels. The original floor boards measure up to 17½ inches. The exterior and interior of the mill has changed very little since its construction in 1783. The water power for the mill was supplied by the Cold Run Creek. The pond and head and tail races still exist, though there is no longer water in the system. The stucco over stone house has several additions, but the interior retains many original features such as fine and detailed Georgian/Federal mantels, and reeded trim around the windows and doors. The mill and house complement each other in their careful construction, workmanship, style, scale, and setting. Threats and Mitigation The Geiger Mill Complex is privately owned, and the owners appear to be taking proper care of this valuable historic resource. However, as is well known, being on the NRHP is no guarantee of its existence in perpetuity. Geiger’s Mill is one of only six 18th century mill survivors in Berks County, thus making it one of the most important early grist mills in the County. The Geiger Mill was in operation for 136 years, a long association to the milling industry of Berks County. Geigertown and Vicinity In addition to housing the grist mill, the local post office was operated from the mill and was known as “Geiger’s Mill,” and was later changed to Geigertown. Found in Geigertown and on the nearby Geigertown Road are several significant historic resources. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 59 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Geigertown Hotel, c. late 1700s, 1800 Georgian/Federal style, stucco over stone 2 ½-story, 6-bay structure. Currently a dwelling, it appears to have been built in three sections over three time periods. There is also a barn, spring house and smoke house. St Paul’s Methodist Episcopal Church, 1858 This church structure is of Gothic Revival style, and has a front gable steep pitched roof. There is an associated graveyard nearby. St James Evangelical Lutheran Church, 1850 This stone church structure is of Victorian Gothic style, and has a steep pitched front gable. There is an associated graveyard nearby. Thompson Mill Overview In the late 1980s the Berks County Conservancy performed a Gristmill Survey in Berks County under Phoebe Hopkins, Director of Historic Preservation for the Conservancy. This was a multi list of the 104 mills still in existence in the County; six of these mills were definitely 18th century survivors. Thompson’s Mill was one of the Berks County Mills that was on a Multi-Property National Register Nomination which was submitted in 1990, largely through the efforts of Stephen Kindig, a respected expert on the history and function of grist mills. Thompson’s Mill was placed on the NRHP in November 1990. As this mill qualified for the NRHP, having historic intactness both externally and internally, and gives us a better understanding of milling operation and history in Berks County, it is of HIGHEST PRIORITY. Brief History Thompson’s Mill was on a County Map of 1816, but was surely built before that time period, although the exact date is unknown. There are several architectural features indicating that it could have been built in the late 1700s, as some local architectural historians believe. It was shown to belong to Henry Thompson on an 1850 census. The mill has had several renovations through the years, and later additions built on. From the road it appears to be of one floor, and of a later vintage, but as one goes around to the front of this banked structure, it is plain that the stone exterior is earlier and original, and the building is indeed 2½ stories including the ground floor basement. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 60 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods There is also an accompanying banked sandstone farm/miller’s house with detached bake oven. The barn is relatively new. The mill races are partially intact with running water, as well as the holding pond and dam. This mill is by the Seidel Creek and was part of a working farm. Historic and Cultural Resources at Thompson’s Mill Built and in operation prior to 1816, the mill is a 2½-story banked stone and frame (possibly log) structure with a later frame extension that was used for storage of grain and equipment. The foundation and ground level front stone wall is of the local brown sandstone, with an exterior supporting buttress that appears to be of the same time period. The upper levels are built of framed siding, with the front appearing to be relatively recent. Much of the rest of the framing is covered with asbestos siding, but a piece that is torn off reveals what may be log siding. The ground floor stone front wall has four bays, three windows, and a door with four lights overhead. All three original 9-over-6 windows and the door have well modeled stone Keystones overhead. The appearance of the Keystones and window lights are that of the late 18th century, and correspond with the Keystones over several windows of the nearby farm/miller’s house. The present water wheel is later and is an overshot wheel. The head and tail races were restored, and there is running water in both that leads eventually to the Seidel Creek. The interior of the mill has much of its original equipment, including the Hurst Frame, indicating a relatively early date for this mill. Interestingly, the interior woodwork is quite well finished, unusual for a country mill of this type. The 2½-story banked stone farmhouse with gable fireplaces may be of the same time period as the mill, as the stonework is similar, and most revealing are the same stone Keystones over several of the windows. Nearby is a detached bake oven. On the far opposite side of the mill is a one room 19th century schoolhouse. Threats and Mitigation As with all privately owned structures on the NRHP, having this honor is no guarantee of its being free of neglect and eventual destruction. This structure is only in fair condition, the roof is intact, but the building shows signs of neglect and presently is not in use. It is a good example of a moderate sized farm grist mill, relatively intact, and is valuable in showing and interpreting an important part of our early industrial history. Hopefully, municipal zoning and local interest and intervention will help protect this valuable relic. Structures Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places, three (3) As these sites and structures are considered “Eligible for the NRHP” by PHMC, they are to be considered of HIGH PRIORITY as historic and cultural resources. Without a doubt, there are other sites and structures in Robeson Township that could meet the criteria for eligibility. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 61 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Beidler House and Mill Site See above: Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park. White Bear Tavern AKA Spread Eagle Inn, c. 1810-15 This large evenly coursed red sandstone structure with large quoins was built in two sections. The larger is 2½ stories, four bays, with large gable end flush chimneys and plain cornice trim. The windows are 6-over-6 with plain trim and frames. The smaller section is 1½-stories, 3 bays, plain cornice trim, 6-over-9 windows with plain trim and frames. Both parts of the structure were built at the same time, and both sections have dormer windows which were added later. The tavern/inn was operated in 1815 by Herman Beard and is an important local landmark. It is near Route 82 and Buck Hollow Road. 1803 Farm Complex, Date stone “1803” This farm complex is located on Route 568, near Gunhart Road and is composed of a beautifully restored red sandstone dwelling, barn, summer kitchen, and springhouse. The house is a 2½-story Federal style structure with 5 bays and a gable pent roof with box cornice trim. There are chimneys at both gable ends. The windows have jack arches with Keystone motif and shutters, and there is a four light transom over the front door. The house is a refined and prominent example of its period. Historic Districts Recognized by PHMC Allegheny Aqueduct Historic Park/Beidler House and Mill – See above. Joanna Furnace Complex – See above. Geiger Mill, Geigertown – See above. Important Contributing Historic Structures of Undetermined NR Status in Robeson Township Robeson Township was a hotbed of industrial activity in the late 18th and 19th century. This is seen in the many identified forges, mills, sawmills etc. that were listed in the 1983 Survey of Historic Resources. Some of these resources were relatively intact, and others had but a few stone walls or a slag heap to identify where they originally had been. The most prominent were the ruins of the many forges, furnaces, and rolling mill operated in the 19th century on the Allegheny Creek by the Seyfert family near the villages of Gibraltar and Seyfert. Of course, the presence of first the Schuylkill Navigation Canal in the 1820s, and subsequently the railroad, encouraged the growth of these industries by making it easier to receive needed supplies, and ship out the finished goods and distribute them to points far away. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 62 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A very distinct historic settlement pattern has emerged in this Township. The earliest 18th century industries and settlement was along the River Schuylkill and pushed very early up the swift flowing Allegheny and Hay Creeks. The refined 18th century Georgian and very early Federal homes and structures are to be found clustered in this distinct area. It is in the hinterlands and hilly inland areas of the Township that we find the burgeoning 19th century small family farms composed of the native red sandstone with their regional vernacular architecture. Near the River Schuylkill and the confluences of several creeks, particularly the Allegheny and Hay Creeks, there were many busy forges and mills. The early and wealthier settlers with capital to invest saw the abundant natural resources and quickly established these industries. Good examples are the c.1770 Beidler merchant grist mill and the earlier 1735 commercial saw mill on that site, and the 1779 Richard Lewis Forge in Gibraltar. The sons of Andrew Robeson, Israel and Jonathan and Moses, were prominent settlers and investors in industry in the Township. Jonathan Robeson, George Boone and James Lewis, father of Richard Lewis, were investors in the 1735 sawmill “Lebanon” that later became Beidler’s sawmill. It is noticeable that many of the identified prominent and stylish 18th century Georgian/Federal stone houses in the Township were built by these wealthy investors and merchants, and these stone homes were a rare commodity. What were more common are the log structures that most of the population lived in. There are only a few identified early log structures in the Township, perhaps there are more not yet “found,” but at least two of them were the “core” of later stone-built houses. Tucked away in the center of the Township, the “Forest” area of winding and hilly back roads, are a plethora of small and charming stone-built farms, all constructed within the 18301875 time period. As the area is relatively isolated, the vernacular style and old methods of construction lingered on for a longer period here than other parts of the county. These farms have a universal local vernacular style of stone built houses, barns, and outbuildings, and still remain in an agricultural or open-land setting, for the time being. It is likely that all the buildings of these small farms are at least second generation, as the Township was settled in the early 18th century. Nevertheless, in the 19th century there was a building boom and apparent relative prosperity. Contributing Historic Sites and Structures 18th Century Farms and Period Houses, Robeson Township In Robeson Township there are several areas with refined Georgian/Federal homes and structures, chiefly near the River Schuylkill and the downstream creek valleys of early industry such as the Allegheny and Hay Creeks. On a stretch of Old River (Schuylkill) Road between Birdsboro and Robeson’s Crossing there are to be found a cluster of relatively untouched and well preserved 18th and early 19th century farms with their houses, barns, and outbuildings. There are very few modern intrusions A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 63 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods in this area. This is an area that could possibly be designated a Historic District, and should be protected by the Municipality. Ramsden Farm AKA Israel Robeson’s Farm, c.1740, 1780 Ramsden Farm is chief among the well-preserved farms located along Old River Road. The large and beautifully preserved red sandstone house has a core area that dates to the 1735-1745 time period, and was built and owned by Israel Robeson, son of early settler Andrew Robeson. Additions were built at later time periods. The stone barn was built c. 1800, and is a fine example of a Federal period barn with its well crafted arched doorways. Even though it has a bank, it is often called an English barn! Moses Robeson Farm, c.1740, 1780 Built by Andrew Robeson’s son Moses, and located near Ramsden Farm on Old River Road, this restored red sandstone farmhouse is built around a core 1½-story stone cabin, like his brother Israel’s. An addition was built by the late 1700s, and one can see on the second floor where the roof was raised when the house was enlarged. There is a large early-19th century red sandstone barn on the property. Another area of 18th and early-19th century farms and structures is the beginning reaches of Cedar Hill Road between Birdsboro and Gibraltar, where several intact early homesteads can be found. Lewandowski Farm, c. 1770 Located on Cedar Hill Road, this large restored farm with its beautiful house with pent roof and back to back corner fireplaces, 18th and 19th century barns, summer kitchen which may predate the 1770 house, spring house, and other outbuildings, is a complete example of a mid-18th century prosperous farm. The property was part of 600 acres that was originally owned by Andrew Robeson, and divided into 200 acre parcels for three of his sons. Andrew Robeson also had other large holdings in Amity Township. Off Cedar Hill Road in this area are 18th century log and stone houses and structures that are to be noted on the Survey of Historic Structures. All of the early structures of these defined two areas, Old River Road and Cedar Hill Road, are especially noted as good examples of the historic building legacy of Robeson Township, and should be protected by the Municipality with proper zoning codes, public recognition etc. They all have the potential, historical integrity of structure, and association with an important historic personage, which could place them on the NRHP. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 64 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Historic Churches in Robeson Township Robeson Friends Meeting, 1740, and Graveyard, 1780 Located at the Intersection of Plow and Zion Road, this early Friend’s meeting was formed in 1740, with the Scarlet family influential in its founding. The first burials were in the Scarlet family orchard until 1780, when a burial ground was measured out near the meeting house. There are 216 known burials, with the latest ones from the 1890s. The building is a ruin with little left to discern, and the graveyard is on private property. St. John’s UCC, 1809, rebuilt 1893 Located in Gibraltar, this is a rectangular coursed red sandstone structure with quoins. It is two stories, and the windows and doorway are round arched with a Keystone motif. The bell tower is in the front. There is a walled graveyard surrounding the Church. Robeson Evangelical Lutheran Church AKA Plow Church, Founded 1779, 1810, remodeled before 1900 Located on Route 10 in Plowville and first known as the “Forest” Church, it was founded in 1779 as a Lutheran Church. After 1810 it became a Union Church with the Reformed Church. It is presently a Lutheran Church again, and is popularly called “the Plow.” It is constructed of the local red sandstone which is dressed and coursed, and has two stories with rounded arched windows. The bell tower is in the front. Outside there is a sizable graveyard with a famous burial, author John Updike. Frieden’s Bible Chapel, 1866 This is a stucco over stone vernacular church located on the White Bear Road. It has semicircular gable windows with a cupola at a gable end. Historically its most common use was for funerals. Historic Mills Old Mill Inn AKA Seifrit’s Grist Mill, c. 1773 Located in a narrow wooded valley on the Allegheny Creek along Route 568, this is a large 4½-story (including basement) red sandstone grist mill with large quoins and corner chimney. Its peak of operation and production was in the1820s. It went through several proprietors; among them was the Seifrit/Seyfert family in the 19th century. It has been a popular restaurant for several decades, and underwent a devastating fire in 1992. It was restored, and to this day serves as a popular restaurant. This is an excellent example of adaptive re-use of a historic structure. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 65 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Scarlet’s Mill Site, Scarlet’s Mill Hamlet/Hay Creek Scarlet’s Mill was one of the earliest grist mills in Berks County; it was established by Quaker John Scarlet c.1740s on his patented 208 acres. In 1766 he conveyed his grist mill to his son John Jr. Continuing the family tradition, John Jr. also owned several other mills in the area; one of them was a scythe mill. His son, Ephraim Scarlet, built a woolen factory in 1830 near the original Scarlet’s Mill, making the Scarlet’s Mill area a hub of mill industry. There is little to see of these early mills, but a small hamlet called Scarlet’s Mill remains near the milling area. The Scarlet family was associated with the Underground Railroad. Documented Log Structures Presently, there are not many documented log structures in Robeson Township, the ones that are should be considered to be of PRIORITY. Besides the ones listed here, we know of several that retain the stone foundations of the original log structure, with the log building replaced entirely by stone in the early-to-mid 19th century. There are most certainly log structures in the Township that are covered over by siding, and are hidden. Care must be taken to further identify these earliest structures and implement protection measures for all log buildings in Robeson Township. Mouland House, c. 1740, 1790 This log and stone house is located near Buck Hollow Road. The 1½-story log section is a mid-18th century three room German Plan house, much like the Bertolet Log Cabin at the Daniel Boone Homestead. The small stone section was added c. 1790, giving the house four bays. There is a small shed roof dormer window. This banked house is on its original site, is in excellent condition, and retains its authenticity both inside and out. Geiger’s Tavern, c. 1734, 1775, 1880 Located on Old River Road near Gilbraltar, the tavern was built over three distinct time periods, this structure’s middle segment is the original log house that was built by settler Welsh Quaker James Lewis. The stone structure on the east end is a side hall entry Georgian building with a corner fireplace mantel and woodwork identical to that of the nearby 1783 Beidler house. The third section is mid-to-late 19th century. In addition, there are many farm buildings on the site, including an outstanding Federal Period barn/stable with well executed rounded stone archways. All the structures are in only fair condition, and a fire in the log section of the house several years ago caused considerable damage, but the original log walls remain and are preserved with siding. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 66 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods When it passed out of the hands of the Lewis family c. 1750, it was purchased by Antony Geiger, whose family expanded the structure and ran it for many years as a prominent tavern and inn called “Geiger’s.” Schuylkill Navigation Canal Structures The Schuylkill Navigation Canal ran close to and parallel with the River Schuylkill in parts of Robeson Township, especially the industrial towns of Gibraltar and Seyfert (Naomi) in the western section of the township. Even though sites and structures which were associated with the Canal are not on the NRHP or declared eligible for it, they should be considered to be of PRIORITY as they were an important part of the long industrial and agricultural history of the area surrounding it. Naomi Hotel, c.1800-1825 Located on Old River Road at the Village of Seyfert (Naomi), this large rambling wooden structure was constructed in several sections with a log core (as reported). It has seven bays and a gable chimney. There is a porch along the entire front façade. Behind the main structure there are a stone summer kitchen and round stone smoke house, and also a root cellar. Naomi Hotel was a popular tavern for the Schuylkill Navigation Canal trade. It was close to the “Dick Boat Yard” in Seyfert, making it a busy stop and exchange for the nearby iron industries and farms. One of its proprietors, John H. Klauser b.1836, had a limekiln on his nearby farm, and brought the lime via his own boat to the city of Reading several miles upstream. He was proprietor of “Naomi” for over 30 years. The “Dick Boat Yard” Schuylkill Navigation System Canal, Village of Seyfert/Naomi. The Dick Boat yard was established by the “Dick brothers” whose family home was the large and prominent “Ridgewood Farm” less than ¼ mile away on Route 724. There is still a large depression and swampy area where the boat yard was located. Besides being a boat repair and shipping exchange for the iron industry nearby, this was an important outlet for the large amount of produce the Dick/ Kissinger Farm produced and sent to the well known “Kissinger’s Market” in the nearby city of Reading. Forges, Furnaces and Rolling Mills in Robeson Township The 18th century settlers in this area had capital and invested early in the iron industry by establishing forges along the swift currents of the Allegheny and Hay Creeks. These early industries were expanded throughout the 19th century. There were many forges/ironworks along these creeks, but there is very little physical evidence of their existence remaining. However, along the Allegheny Creek near the corner of Route 724, and climbing up the steep ravine of the creek on Route 568, there can be seen many stone foundations of dams, and walls that were forges and ironworks along this creek. Accompanying them are a number of late-18th and early- A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 67 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods 19th century homes and structures that were most certainly connected with this nearby industry. Special care and notice should be taken of this history laden creek valley! Lewis Forge AKA Gibraltar Forge, c. 1779 This early forge was located on the north side of the Allegheny Creek on Route 568 and established by Welsh Quaker Richard Lewis. The Lewis family were engaged in the iron industry early on, as Richard Lewis’ mother was a Potts cousin of the John Potts family of Pottsgrove, and his father, James Lewis, was an investor in Pool Forge II of Douglass Township, and was connected with the establishment of the Colebrookdale Furnace. This forge was later owned by the Seyfert family who expanded the works in the 19th century and operated it in connection with the Mt Penn Furnace. Remains of the charcoal house and a stone dam can be seen, as well as the iron master’s house built by Seyfert Do Well Forges I and II AKA Seidels Forges, mid-1800s Near Seidel’s Creek on Golf Course road. At present the site houses a saw mill (Mohr’s) which as of 2012 still appears to be in operation. There is also a silted-in dam at the site. Seifert’s Rolling Mill, 1880 Located south of the present Route 724 by the village of Naomi/Seyfert. The Canal and Railroad are conveniently nearby. Remnants of brick foundations can be seen as well as a series of concrete trestles. Many of the houses in Seyfert were built for the workers at the rolling mill. CONCLUSION Robeson Township Threats to the Historic Architectural Landscape Though vastly rural in nature, there are manifold threats to the bucolic charm of this Township. Threats are seen in the form of at least a half dozen or more planned developments that have been approved for this Township. Presently, because of a sluggish economy, these developments have remained in their beginning stages, with a relatively small number of houses built. Expansion as planned will add greatly to a negative environmental impact, and also a greater demand for services, perhaps necessitating increased taxes to meet the greater need for schools, road improvements, fire and police protection etc. The pressure for development is great throughout Berks County, especially in the southeastern Berks Townships that are associated with the Hopewell Big Woods and the Route 422 corridor to Philadelphia and its suburbs. The Regional Comprehensive Plan addresses some of these concerns, and has suggestions for dealing with them. Among the concerns addressed is that of Historic Preservation. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 68 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Mitigation The need to be aware of, and address Historic Preservation needs In Robeson Township is well illustrated by a recent situation in the Township. A number of years ago 168 acres were to be developed into 670 high density houses, a potential disaster for this beautiful country acreage with its scattered small farms. A small early 19th century farm house, barn, and spring house were abandoned and left to deteriorate over the years. Fortunately, when the bank foreclosed, the Natural Lands Trust was able to obtain the funding for the land and acquired it to become the “Green Hills Preserve,” an area of open space that is vital to the community. Unfortunately, the stone farm house and barn on the property were so neglected that they had to be demolished, the spring house with its swift and abundant spring, remains. This early 19th century farm and its structures, so typical of the historic small farms of Robeson, were to be placed on the updated Berks County Survey of Historic Structures. Unfortunately, it was in the process of being demolished when the field worker got there. This is what happens all too often, in Berks County and other places. Deliberate neglect, and what else is left to do but demolish? At this time Berks does not have a County Historic Preservationist to oversee demolition of historic structures, and apply any type of delay, or seek alternative uses or adaptive re-use of structures in a case such as this. Recently, the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County has taken on the task of assisting municipalities with their preservation needs and preservation zoning and laws, so that perhaps such a situation as this can find mitigation other than demolition. The Natural Lands Trust, whose mission is preserving landscape and land, certainly met with a quandary here. It preserved beautiful farm fields, woodland, and wetland for which everyone is grateful, and happy NLT prevented a potential environmental and aesthetic nightmare. Nevertheless, that early farm was part of the Robeson Township historic landscape, and vital to it. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 69 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Birdsboro Borough Overview The Borough of Birdsboro is a perfect example, in miniature, of a “gritty” Pennsylvania city. Its history is long, splendid, and industrial. Like the nearby larger city of Reading, Birdsboro has a mixture of industry, worker’s houses, and the mansions of the captains of industry. All are democratically mixed together, and in many ways, the iron industry lies at its smoking heart. It is on the Schuylkill River, about 8 miles southeast of the city of Reading, and this location on the river with its easy access to the Schuylkill Navigation System Canal, and later the railroad, helped sustain its large foundries and machine shops through the Borough’s long history. Most of these foundries and machine shops are shuttered now, but this large and ancient Borough remains the hub of the surrounding rural Townships. Brief History Birdsboro was named after its founder William Bird, who started in the iron industry as a young man at Colebrookdale Furnace and Pine Forge across the River Schuylkill in nearby Douglass Township. He took warrants for land on Hay Creek and Six Penny Creek in the 1730s and by 1740 established Birdsboro/Bird’s Landing and his Bird Iron Works on the west branch of Hay Creek A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 70 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods where it flows into the Schuylkill River. He also established a grist mill and saw mill nearby, and more forges on the Hay Creek. In1751 he built the Bird Manor House near the mills. Upon William Bird’s death in 1761, his vast businesses were taken over by his son Mark, who established the Hopewell Iron Works, and enlarged the Bird Manor House to the spacious mansion we see today. At the time of the Revolution Birdsboro had become a sizable and busy town. Mark Bird’s iron industries at Hopewell and Birdsboro produced shot and cannon for the Colonial Army, unfortunately, overextension and governmental nonpayment of military contracts bankrupted Mark Bird after the revolution, and he was forced to sell his holdings and land. The holdings and land went through several hands, but it is with the Brooke family in the 1800s that the iron and steel works were greatly expanded. In 1880 the Brooke family interest was reorganized into the Birdsboro Iron Foundry Manufacturing Unit, and the E&G Brooke Land Company was established to supervise the holdings and transactions. The Borough continued to grow, and a great deal of worker’s housing and new businesses were built through the 1800s. Birdsboro was incorporated into a Borough in 1872 from portions of Robeson and Union Townships. In 1905 the Birdsboro Iron Foundry became the Birdsboro Steel Company. The chief employer in the Borough, the Birdsboro Steel Company closed in 1988. Historic and Cultural Resources in Birdsboro Borough Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places St. Michael’s Episcopal Church, 1853, renovated 1884 Originally built in 1853, and renovated in 1884 by noted Architect Frank Furness, this beautiful church was placed on the NRHP in 1992. Unfortunately, the Church went out of the hands of the Diocese several years ago, and the outstanding architectural features were stripped and sold. The Church continues to be in use. Class I Historic Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places Edward Brooke Mansion, 1888 This shingle style mansion was built for wealthy iron magnate Edward Brooke for his bride Ann Louise Klingan. It was designed by one of the most inventive and distinctive Architects of the period, Frank Furness. The well-preserved mansion has many special features, including fanciful cast iron fireplaces that were produced at the Brooke manufactories right in Birdsboro. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 71 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Class II Historic Resources Noted on PHMC Survey The Bird Mansion 1751 Located on Birdsboro’s Main Street near the River Schuylkill, this large 2½-story mansion, constructed of the local red sandstone, is a continuous eight bay structure with gable end chimneys. Once having a stucco application, the original red sandstone has been revealed and restored. Built by William Bird in 1751, and enlarged by his son Mark, this stately structure has undergone many changes and reversals in fortune in its long history, such as becoming a boarding house and hotel for Canal workers in the 1800s. Also at that time, when the canal was built between the mansion and the River, the front of the house was changed to the back, along with a corresponding relocation of the road. Presently restored to its 18th century exterior appearance, the interior retains few of its 18th century historical characteristics, and is now used as a community center for the Borough. Threats and Mitigation These three structures are vital, and expressive of the long history of the Borough of Birdsboro. They are to be considered to be of HIGHEST PRIORITY. Nevertheless, being on the NRHP is no guarantee that a structure will remain free from ravage and destruction, and especially deliberate and indifferent destruction. We have seen this with St Michael’s Church in the borough. After being sold it was deliberately stripped of its soul, and its priceless ecclesiastical adornments were sold. Surveyed Historic Districts in Birdsboro Although there are no PHMC recognized Historic Districts in Birdsboro, the County Survey of Historic Resources recognized several historic areas of worker’s housing that was built in the 19th century into even the early 20th, and as they make up an important aspect of the Borough’s iron and steel history, are worthy of note. Mexico, c.1837 Built by Matthew Brooke Stucco over stone worker’s housing. Mill Street, c.1850 Built by E&G Brooke Stone worker’s housing. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 72 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Brooklyn, c. mid-late 1800s Built by E&G Brooke Worker’s housing. Texas, c. 1800s Built by Brooke. Worker’s housing. Route 82 Section, c. 1860 Built by E&G Brooke. Stone worker’s housing. Schuylkill Navigation Canal Structures The Canal was a boon to the industries of Birdsboro, and there were many Canal related structures in and near the Borough. Almost all are now gone, lost to disrepair, river erosion, a change in land use, the advent of the railroads and paved roads, and a decline in the iron and steel industry of Birdsboro. Canal Lock Tender’s House, Lock 51, c. 1820s Located on Schuylkill Road, Birdsboro, this c.1820s Canal Lock Tender’s House is a well preserved 2½-story red sandstone structure with four bays and gable end chimneys. It is built in two sections, and the large cooking fireplace was apparently in the smaller section. The Lock and Canal was to the rear of the house and served into the early 20th century as a conduit for water into the nearby Birdsboro Steel Works. Presently, the Canal and Lock are filled in. The Hay Creek Aqueduct, c. 1820s Little remains of this five pier sandstone Aqueduct over Hay Creek at Birdsboro. It was removed years ago because during flooding of the Hay Creek it served as a dam keeping the flood waters back, to the detriment of the Borough. The two abutments remained, but apparently have been removed as of 2013. Industry in Birdsboro There are many Brooke Industry related structures in the Borough, and remain occupied and have an adapted re-use. Among the structures are: The Mercantile Building Now M&T Bank A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 73 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Brook Iron Office Birdsboro Steel Foundry Now the site of several smaller manufacturing companies. Conclusion Presently, in the 21st century, the industry that Birdsboro was famous for has largely ceased, and many of the hulking buildings lie idle. But there have been serious attempts to revive and re-use some of them, with good results. The old Birdsboro Steel Foundry has been refurbished and houses several small manufacturing companies, making it a hub for the community, though on a much smaller scale than previously. The Borough has many individuals who take an interest in its local history, and strive to retain its historic structures and sense of history. They initiated and produced an illustrated pamphlet that presents a walking tour of the Borough. This was partially funded by the SRHA and Natural Lands Trust. It is through partnerships such as this that municipalities like Birdsboro can secure its past, present, and future. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 74 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Caernarvon Township Background Of all the southeastern Berks County Townships studied in this historic resource prioritization project for the Hopewell Big Woods, Caernarvon Township has perhaps the most singular and unique history. Although it was carved out of Lancaster County, as was nearby Robeson Township, Caernarvon was one of the three heavily Welsh settled areas of Berks County, the others being Cumru and Brecknock Townships. All of the three Townships bear Welsh names, Caernarvon means “fort on the river or water.” Already feeling crowded by the early 1700s, second generation Welsh in the Chester County “Welsh Tract” at St. David’s, Radnor, pushed their way north and westward into what became Caernarvon, Brecknock, and Cumru Townships. These second generation Welsh Quakers and Episcopalian/Baptists were born on Pennsylvania soil and were accustomed to the rigors of the wilderness. An exploratory group of Welsh arrived in the Conestoga Valley of Caernarvon after c.1710, and were soon followed by others from the “Welsh Tract,” the settlement pattern and timing being very similar to that of Cumru and Brecknock Townships. That is, settling along strong flowing creeks and establishing many mills and an Episcopal church. Caernarvon Township was established in Lancaster County in 1729, and the Township was divided in half in 1752 when Berks County was established. As in the other Welsh Townships of Berks, many of the Welsh populace moved on within two generations, and were superseded by the Swiss/Germans who were flooding in. By the census of 1790, more than half of the dwellers of Berks’ Caernarvon Township had a German background. The Welsh settlers did not leave a great deal behind in the built environment, but they did leave their living legacy of place names. Today, the population of Caernarvon Township of Lancaster County is heavily Amish and Mennonite, Berks’ Caernarvon Township less so. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 75 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in Caernarvon Township Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places Properties The village of Morgantown is listed on the NRHP as a Historic District. It was listed on the NRHP in 1995. Class I Historic Sites and Structures Listed on the Berks County Historic Resources Survey as Significant and/or Eligible for the NRHP Col. Jacob Morgan Homestead Col. Jonathan Jones Homestead Jones/ Hertzler House St. Thomas Episcopal Church, Morgantown Class II Other sites and structures of Historic Value Other sites and structures such as Churches, graveyards, limekilns, mills, forges, schools, inns etc. are prevalent throughout the Township and have cultural and historic significance. The geography was the determiner of much of this Township’s early history and settlement by the Welsh. The most southern boundary of this southernmost Berks Township is the Welsh Mountains, more northerly are the boundary hills of “The Forest” of Robeson Township. Dominant in the settlement pattern of the whole of Caernarvon Township is the fertile Conestoga Creek Valley whose source is in the Township, and was thickly settled early on by the Welsh. However, within two or three generations they were superseded by the Swiss-Germans who bought the farms of the Welsh, enlarged them, and built the large stone Pennsylvania farmhouses and barns characteristic of the Pennsylvania Dutch. The more prominent Caernarvon Township names, besides the Welsh Morgan and Jones, are Mast, Kurtz, and Hertzler, Amish/Mennonite Anabaptists who intermarried and built large farmsteads throughout the Township. Also settling in this Conestoga Valley were the Scotch-Irish, making for a more diverse population than in some of the distinctly Germanic Townships of Berks and Lancaster Counties. The Conestoga Creek or River was the center of the Township in many ways. Early on the centrally located Old Conestoga Road, once an Indian path, was built and connected Philadelphia with Lancaster and Harrisburg. The rich soil of the valley produced abundant crops, the creek supported many mills and forges, and the Conestoga Road with its Conestoga wagons made it easier to bring goods and crops to market. There were many taverns along this ancient road to accommodate the drovers and wagons, some of these old taverns exist to this day. Morgantown Historic District “Old Main Street Historic District” Overview Strategically located at the convergence of three Indian paths which became trails and then roads for early settlers and traders, the village developed quickly, and had a number of buildings A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 76 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods by the 1750s. Another point of importance is the fact that Morgantown is seated in the Conestoga Valley between the Welsh mountains and the “Forest Hills.” Surveyed and formally laid out in 1770 by Colonel Jacob Morgan, the town continued to grow and serve the local farm community and the local iron and mining industry. Morgantown went through several phases of development over the years and differing eras and styles of architecture are represented in the village. With the modern PA Turnpike nearby, the thoughtless demolition of several significant historic buildings on its Main Street, and expanded large scale commercial growth near the Chester County line, Morgantown is making an effort to remain viable. The Morgantown Historic District is considered to be of HIGHEST PRIORITY as a Historic and Cultural Resource in Caernarvon Township. Brief History The charming village of Morgantown was well established some 20 or 30 years before it was formally organized in the 1770s and known as Morgan’s Town. From its very beginning, this early Welsh hamlet of several log and stone structures was an important stopping place on the busy Conestoga Road. Local historians characterize the growth of the town as occurring in several phases, corresponding with the historical, demographic and architectural changes the town underwent in its long history. By the early 1770s there was enough activity in the hamlet to make its potential as a regional commercial center noticed. In 1772 one of the area’s leading citizens, Colonel Jacob Morgan, donated land to further enlarge the village, and he formally laid out the streets. He laid out 32 plots along Center Street. Jacob Morgan was the son of Thomas Morgan, who was one of the original Welsh settlers of the area, and was owner of large choice tracts of land in the Township that totaled over 1000 acres. Thomas’ four sons inherited this land in the Township from their father, acquired more land, and built large English/Welsh style houses of their own. The best known is the home of Colonel Jacob Morgan, an imposing stone structure built in two sections. Growth of the town was steady during the Revolutionary War due to the close proximity to the Jones Mine and the charcoal iron furnaces and forges at Hopewell, Warwick, Windsor, and Reading Furnaces. The town grew, and by 1802 the village had 12 stone houses and 19 log or frame houses. There were two stores, three taverns, one school house and other structures. Residents included store keepers, cabinet makers, a spinning wheel maker, carpenters, stone masons, and many other skilled workers and business owners. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 77 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods After a short decline the town prospered again during the late 19th and early 20th centuries and retained its historical and architectural integrity until very recently. Surrounded by prosperous farms, it became an agricultural and commercial center for the area. Historic Resources in the “Old Main Street Historic District” of Morgantown Historic Old Main Street of Morgantown encompasses several original blocks along the Main Street, including what was the central square of the town. Clustered around the central square are/were some of the oldest documented structures in the town. The historic district reflects the periods of architecture that were prevalent during the different growth periods of the town. Clustered around the “town square” are the documented late 18th-century structures, most of them are substantial Georgian and Federal buildings, and are largely constructed of brown sandstone. There was also a log structure next to the old Morgantown Hotel. During the c.1850-1920 period there was a great deal of commercial growth, with numerous corresponding Victorian style structures built of (German) wood siding and sometimes stone. For the most part, these structures have retained their historical character and integrity. Old Village Inn, c. 1800 Located on the Town Square. Federal style brown sandstone, 2 ½ stories, built in several sections. The core is a three bay sandstone structure with cornice trim and two arched dormer windows. The building has functioned as an inn/restaurant for a long period of time. Mary Morgan Hudson House AKA John Gable House, c. 1790, enlargement c.1890 Located on the Town Square. Originally Lot #1 in the town plan, this 2½-story stone house was built for Jacob Morgan’s daughter. It was enlarged and the Gothic gable was built onto the front by 1900. Odd Fellows Hall, 1868 Located on the Town Square. This large structure is/was a meeting hall and restaurant. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 78 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Morgantown Odd Fellows Hall, courtesy of https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f0/Morgantown_PA_Oddfellows.JPG Early Stone House, c. 1750-1800 Located on Main Street. Built in two sections, this early Germanic style house is built of cut sandstone, and features a box winder staircase and smoke house in the garret. Significant Town Square Structures Demolished in 2006-07 Morgantown Hotel, 1799 Connected with David Morgan. This was a large 2½-story brown sandstone Georgian structure. Constructed as a hotel, it served the busy traffic between the Coventry furnaces and the Lancaster City forges. It continued to be a popular restaurant until shortly before its demolition. Log Cabin, mid-late 1700s. Situated next to the Morgantown Hotel, this documented “original log cabin” was demolished when the Morgantown Hotel was destroyed. The sad and irresponsible demolition of these important and significant historical structures in Morgantown in the years c.2006-08 cannot be emphasized enough. The destruction of the A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 79 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Morgantown Hotel, the log structure, and other structures literally tore the historic heart out of the community. NRHP designation was blatantly shown to be not enough to prevent this tragedy. Historic tourism is big business in Berks and surrounding counties, charming Morgantown was looking for its share, only now it has an awkward modern “big box” drugstore sitting on is historic town square. While compromised, the town of Morgantown and its historic district remain of Highest Priority in Caernarvon Township. Conclusion As the local economy is no longer farm related, the modern day focus of Morgantown is as a Tourist Gateway to the area. Many of the structures and businesses in the town now cater to tourist oriented services. This turnover was inevitable with the Turnpike Exchange just outside the town, and a busy highway connecting the town with the nearby picturesque counties of Chester, Lancaster, and Berks. Another important factor that can determine the success, or failure and decline of this town is the overwhelming commercial and business growth just a scant mile down the road (Route 23) towards Chester County. As with many small historic towns, there is a lot of commercial competition from the large “big box” stores “down the pike.” Also, the destruction of important historic structures in the middle of Morgantown certainly did not enhance its historic appeal to tourists, and only emphasizes the overall threat to historic preservation in the area. Class I NRHP Eligible Structures in Caernarvon Township Colonel Jacob Morgan Homestead, c. early 1750s, 1783 Georgian wing Located at Hartz and Shiloh Roads, this home is perhaps the structure of most importance in the history of the Township, and is of the Highest Priority. The Col. Jacob Morgan homestead is one of the earliest structures in the Township, and its core early1750s stone cabin is a good example of the local Welsh/English vernacular architecture. The original c. 1753 1½-story stone cabin is a three bay gambrel roofed structure with architectural characteristics that confirm its early date and Morgan’s Welsh origins. The main wing, built in 1783, is a 2½-story, 3-bay, single-pile Georgian structure denoting an original English style hall parlor type plan. All of the architectural elements are original including the corner fireplaces, corner cupboards, floors, stairs, and trim. There is a large gable fireplace in the stone cabin. This structure is significant for several reasons. Its great antiquity and excellent state of preservation are well observed. In addition, it was the house built by one of the original Welsh settlers sons who in his own right became one of the most influential and wealthy men of his era, Revolutionary War leader Colonel Jacob Morgan. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 80 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Along with this historic house is an early 19th century stone barn. The barn appears to have been enlarged at one point, perhaps when the small frame Victorian section was built onto the house. Jones-Hertzler House, 1799, Significant period 1750-1800 Located on Valley Road. Recently owned by a local real estate developer, this large five bay stone structure was to be the headquarters of the Tri County Historical Society. Due to repeated vandalism and expense of upkeep, this structure was demolished. Class IV. Class II Important Contributing Structures of Undetermined NRHP Status in Caernarvon Township 18th Century Farms and Period Structures, Colonial Welsh Vernacular Structures in Caernarvon Township There are several historic structures in the Township that were recommended to the NRHP, but their status remains undetermined. Many of these buildings are connected to the Morgan and Jones families, Caernarvon’s most distinguished settlers. Also, unlike the Welsh settlers of Cumru and Brecknock, many of the Welsh pioneer families of Caernarvon stayed through many generations, and built fine Georgian structures in the second and third generations. Caernarvon Township has quite a few documented 18th century structures that prominently display their Welsh/English features. Local architectural historians call it “Welsh Vernacular” or “Colonial Welsh Vernacular.” The main characteristics include a stone single pile hall-parlor lay out, massive gable end chimney(s), three bays, and often 2 ½ stories, giving that tall narrow “English” appearance. All of these structures and farms are of High Priority. Settler’s Farm, Later Ammon Farm, c.1745 Located on Swamp Road. Early vernacular Welsh farmhouse constructed of stone, 2 ½ stories, three bays with a single pile hall-parlor layout. Stone Cabin, c. 1800 This cabin along swamp road is located on a property that includes a very early c. 1720 Vernacular Welsh style spring house, one of very few Welsh structures known to survive. Sand’s Farm, c.1775 Located on Ranck Road, this early log and stone structure has a large walk-in fireplace. The core of this farm house is log. Robert Ellis’ House AKA Proudfoot/Lund House, c. 1740 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 81 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Located on Twin Valley Road, the house is a typical mid-18th century Welsh Vernacular or Colonial Welsh Vernacular house. Stone structure with hall-parlor layout. Colonel Jonathan Jones Farm, c. 1750, 1799 Located on Route 23. Prominent Welsh settlers such as the Jones family were deeply associated with the early iron industry and ore mining, and Jones also owned one of the first copper mines in the area. The Jones Iron Mine produced iron ore that was sent to Hopewell and other nearby furnaces. The mine is abandoned. The Jones family rivaled the Morgan family in terms of prestige, wealth, and amount of land owned. An almost complete 18th century farm, it consists of a five bay Colonial English 2½-story stone house built in two sections, with the most prominent part built in the late 1700s. There is a mid1700s 2½-story spring house, a large stone barn, and several sheds and outbuildings. Radelberger/Ammom Homestead, c. 1768 or later Located off Shiloh Road. This remote banked 2½-story three bay stone structure with large quoins has a large walk-in fireplace and a spring in the cellar. There is also a banked “stone ender” barn with an 1816 date stone. It is noted as a “Colonial German Pioneer Farm.” Mast Farm, c. 1750-1799 Located at the corner of Route 23 and Route 401, this farm is notable farm, partly due to its present critical location. Much of the land is sold off, and a large proportion is now the site of a new Township school. The sprawling barn has been demolished, but the 2½-story stucco covered stone farm house with dentil trim remains. It was built by David Mast in 1801, and the large 2-story banked settler/spring house was constructed c.1750, and consists of a living space on the second floor with a large gable end fireplace. Historic Sites Associated With the Morgan Family The Morgan Family was one of the earliest families to arrive in the Conestoga Valley from the Welsh Tract. Pioneer Thomas Morgan arrived in 1718. Within a few years he acquired more than 1000 acres, including all of the land that makes up the village of Morgantown and environs. He willed his land in parcels to his several sons. Each claimed his legacy and built substantial stone cabins in the vernacular Welsh style. Within a generation a fine Georgian or Federal addition was built onto each house, demonstrating the wealth and importance the family had acquired over the years. The Colonel Jacob Morgan Farm—See above Notes A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 82 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods John Morgan House, c.1750, Federal section1800 Formerly located at Morgan Way/Mineview Drive. Exceptional house built by John Morgan, brother of Colonel Jacob Morgan. Earliest section built c.1750 with a later Federal addition featuring fine period woodwork. Outbuildings include a large barn and early spring house. The site was declared eligible for the NRHP. Formerly noted as high priority, this house and outbuildings have been demolished. The resource is now ranked Class IV – low priority. Francis Morgan House, c. 1750, enlarged c.1800 Located Off Mill Road. Built by Francis Morgan, a brother of Colonel Jacob Morgan. Large five bay stone house built in three sections. Thomas Morgan Homestead Site, c.1720, 1870 Located Off Mill Road. This was the original Thomas Morgan 1718 homestead site. A newer c. 1870 house has replaced the original settler’s cabin. David Morgan House, c. 1769 Located on Lane off Best Road. This is another Morgan family associated house. It is a three bay stone house. Contributing Historic Sites and Structures in Caernarvon Township There are many contributing historic structures including Churches, mills, schools, early industrial sites such as mines and forges. In addition, there are many scattered farms associated with the large German/Swiss influx of Mennonites and Amish settlers. Many large farms are attributed to the Mast, Hertzler, Kurtz and other families. To this day these Anabaptist settlers have a strong presence in the Township. Historic Churches Ammon Church and School Complex AKA Mt Shiloh UB Church Located on Shiloh Road. Built as a Union congregation church in 1886, this 1½-story stone structure is now a residence. Adjacent to it is the former Mt Shiloh School. The school was started c.1880 by John Ammon. St. Thomas Episcopal Church, Present structure 1800-1824 Located in Morgantown and determined NRHP eligible, this church is HIGH PRIORITY. This Church complex, with a church, cemetery, and school building, has significant ties to the original inhabitants of the Township and town. When the Welsh came to this area they brought A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 83 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods their religion with them, the majority of them being Episcopalian. They established a log church very early on land donated by Thomas Morgan. The present charming stucco covered stone structure with its steep roof was completed by 1824. The earliest burials that were contemporary with the original log church were removed when the log church was demolished. The present site of “The New Cemetery” has several 18th century burials, including Jacob and Rachel Morgan. The accompanying school building is dated c.1827 and was remodeled in 1879. It is a two bay, 2½-story structure described as Welsh Vernacular. Harmony Church, c. 1810, rebuilt late 19th century Located on Elverson Road. This stone structure with steep gable roof, bell tower and stained glass windows, also has a cemetery surrounded by an ornamental iron fence. Historic Mills The Welsh settlers from the Welsh Tract who came to what would become Caernarvon, Cumru, and Brecknock Townships in Berks County, were distinguished by their preference for settlement on swift flowing streams. They harnessed the waters of the Conestoga and French Creeks to produce the power needed to operate the iron furnaces and forges, and the many mills they built. There are several surveyed early mills sites in the Township. Gristmill, c. 1775-1800 Located on Mill Road this mill is associated with John and Jacob Morgan. The Site consists of a stone grist mill, and a five bay center hall miller’s house. Graham’s Mill AKA Levi Bull Hotel, c. 1750-1799 Located on Old Conestoga Road AKA Route 23 the mill is a large Welsh Colonial sandstone mill structure with a distillery and several chimneys. There is also a root cellar and carriage barn. Old Inns/Hotels There are several historic Inns/Hotels along the Old Conestoga Road and near the junction of Twin Valley Road. This small cluster of late-18th century, early-19th century structures are worth mentioning as they were an important part of the history of this venerable roadway. During its heyday as a vital connection between the great city of Philadelphia and the hinterlands of Lancaster and beyond to Harrisburg and the Susquehanna, there were inns and taverns every two or three miles to service the many drovers and travelers. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 84 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods New Morgan Borough Established in 1967, and consisting of 3,500 acres, this relatively new Borough is in large part forest, with a well developed area of industry consisting principally of the Conestoga Landfill and a trash to steam plant. Nearby, and owned by Bethlehem Steel, Grace Mines existed from the 1940s to the 1970s for the extraction of ore. In 1967 there was a petition by Raymond Carr to the Berks County Court to create a new Borough out of the 3,500 acres, which were in both Robeson and Caernarvon Townships. The petition was granted a year later. The borough remains sparsely populated to this day, but there have been plans presented through the years for development of a large residential area to include many homes, a shopping center, and even a hospital. So far these ambitious plans for development have stalled. Conclusion Caernarvon Township Ongoing Threats to the Historic Landscape Compared to the Townships of Union and Robeson, Caernarvon Township’s Historic Landscape has suffered greatly. The area around Morgantown has become a center of commercial and industrial growth. When this was in its initial stages some 10-15 years ago there was a great deal of publicity concerning this real threat to the important historic structures that were in the area of growth. Many of them were historic structures and farms connected with the Morgan family. Unfortunately several of these historic structures were owned by the nearby industrial interests and a notable and NHS eligible farm was demolished, and the rural and historic architectural landscape in the commercial and industrial areas has been destroyed. There were town meetings, the County Commissioners became involved, and there was a concerted effort by preservation advocates such as the Tri County Historians to avert and mitigate the wholesale destruction of local history, but zoning and other means to attenuate the situation could not avert this disaster. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 85 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The most devastating blow to historic preservation in Caernarvon Township was the wholesale destruction of the core of Morgantown’s Historic District. The historic town square is now graced by a large commercial “big box” drugstore which unfortunately degrades the whole town. Morgantown and Caernarvon Township simply did not have the needed and clear strong historic preservation zoning in place to mitigate the disaster. Mitigation Strong historic preservation zoning laws and enforcement, for a start, would lead the pathway towards more stringent attention to the historic landscape, and the critical importance of historic preservation. The Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County has been approved by the County Commissioners to work with Townships to meet the goals of effective Historic Preservation. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 86 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Exeter Township Historical Background Exeter Township was originally part of Philadelphia County until 1752 when Berks County was founded. Landowners in 1725 in the area that would become Exeter were identified by Philip E. Pendeleton in his book Oley Valley Heritage. They are: Jerg Ritter (George Rutter), George Boone, Sr., Richard Tueman, George Boone, Jr., the estate of Andrew Robeson, John Jones (resident of Philadelphia), Joseph Kirkbride (resident of Bucks County), William Morgan, and Israel Robeson (resident of Chester County). James Lewis and Francis Hughes were settled on homesteads in the region, but had not yet claimed land. Three resources listed on the National Register of Historic Places are associated with the Quaker Boone family: the Daniel Boone Homestead, Mill Tract Farm, and Boonecroft. The extended family built mills, a tilt hammer forge and a tannery, and helped to shape the early industry of the township. In 1740, a mixed group of second and third generation French Hugeonots, Swiss and German Anabaptists, Swedish Baptists, Lutherans and Reformists, English and Welsh Quakers and others in the greater Oley Valley region petitioned Philadelphia County for the formation of Oley Township. The area that now forms Exeter was included as part of the Oley Township at that time. It was discovered that the homesteads of 50 families had been excluded from the boundaries of Oley Township. So, within six months of the establishment of Oley, residents of this section, petitioned for the creation of their own township, Exeter. The petitioners, James Boone, Benjamin Boone, John Boone, Squire Boone, John Hughes, William Hughes, Francis Yarnell, Peter Yarnell, Michael Warren, Peter Huyett, Peter Higo, Ezekiel Mathias, Roger Rogers, Joseph Brown, Jacob Vetter, and Ellis Hughes. A Quaker Meeting House was built in Exeter in 1725 and these families, which were mostly settled in the vicinity of the meeting house, largely represented the Quaker community. However, the most prevalent denominations found in the township were German Lutheran and Reformed. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 87 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Union church was founded in 1747 at Schwarzwald, an area named for its dense forest and resemblance to Germany’s Black Forest. Lutheran and Reformed congregations shared space and expenses in a simple frontier log church in one of earliest union arrangements in North America. Union churches are peculiar to the greater Berks County region. Later union churches were formed at Baumstown, Lorane, St. Lawrence and Stonersville. Union Chapels were located in Stonetown, Neversink and Reiffton. The first village to form in Exeter was Snyderville also known as Limekiln and Oley Line. Local historian George M. Meiser, IX identified an inn catering to cattle drovers and other travelers established at the busy crossroads on the border between Exeter and Oley. Brothers Jacob and Peter Snyder replaced an older log tavern with the present stone hotel building in 1835. The hotel is an identified NRHP resource. The settlement was originally called Snyderville, but for obvious reasons, it was referred to as Oley Line. The official designation became Limekiln in 1870 when the U.S. post office opened in the Snyders’ Oley Line Hotel. Swiss immigrant Johannes Schneider, father of Jacob and Peter, built a gristmill in the vicinity prior to 1775. The extant 1780 Schneider grist mill is a resource listed on the NRHP. The nearby pioneer Snyder homestead and graveyard are located in the heart of Snyderville at the crossroads. It was in an ancillary building on this farmstead that the infamous Susanna Cox hid her murdered illegitimate child. She became the last woman hanged in Reading when she was executed for the crime on June 10, 1809. (Note: the boundary line between Exeter and Oley townships run through the historic Snyder homestead.) The character of the township remained predominantly rural well into the 20th century. However, the industrial revolution brought development to Exeter Township and helped to spur the growth of villages. The village of Lorane was established on land purchased in 1835 by Isaac Kass. Kass bought a large tract from the Lincoln family, who had ancestors in common with the 16th president, and owned a number of farms in the southeastern section of the township. The Philadelphia and Reading Railroad followed the course of the river through Exeter Township, and the company built a station at Lorane, called Exeter, in 1860. In 1900, the name was changed to Lorane for the Alsace-Lorraine territory in Europe from which many of the local settlers had immigrated, due to confusion with another Exeter in Luzerne County. Other villages include Baumstown, Stonetown, Stonersville, Jacksonwald, and St. Lawrence Borough, formerly Esterly. The St. Lawrence community grew around the Brumbach knitting mills. Other successful businesses and industries helped to shape the growth of Exeter Township. These included: A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 88 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Washington Kissinger’s 1860 hotel, store, and distillery; H.B. Levan’s 1881 creamery and 1892 picnic grove; James Toole’s broom factory; in 1883 Henry Graeff’s 1883 poultry plant John H. Close and A.H. Kretz’s (D/B/A Kretz & Close, later Neversink Distilling Co., Ltd ) 1892 distillery and a warehouse No. 1 with a capacity of 12,000 barrels, and 1893 warehouse No. 2 with a capacity of 25,000 barrels. Between 1900 to1960 the population of Exeter Township steadily increased from 2,503 to 8,488 persons. This growth has been attributed to suburban movement from Reading rather than local industries or agriculture. Reiffton, one of the first suburban communities in the township, developed shortly before and after World War I. It was named for the Reiff family, which owned land in the area at the time. The township’s middle school, junior high school, and senior high school are found on a parcel bordering the Antietam Creek in Reiffton. With a population of 25,550 as of the 2010 census, Exeter is now the third most populous municipality in Berks County. With the continuous development, the former agricultural character of the township is shifting to a suburban landscape of shopping strip malls, industrial plazas and housing developments all of which pose a constant threat to the remaining historic resources. Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in Exeter Township At present, 2012, within Exeter Township there are six (6) Class I historic resources listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Daniel Boone Homestead AKA Maugridge-DeTurck House Boonecroft AKA George Boone, III Homestead John Bishop House Mill Tract Farm AKA George Boone Homestead Mordacai Lincoln Home Snyder Mill AKA Schneider Mill There are three (3) Class I historic resources listed by PHMC as eligible for the National Historic Register. Bishop-Tyson House Hans Martin Gohrig House AKA Hans Martin Gerrick House Oley Line Hotel AKA Snyderville Hotel 1835 There are fourteen (15) Class II historic resources of local significance identified by the Exeter Historical Commission within Exeter Township. Hill Mill AKA Wanner's Mill and Miller’s House Koch Farmhouse Jacksonwald One-room Schoolhouse Carsonia Inn Trolley Bridge A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 89 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Troxel Property P.O.S. of A. Hall and New Snyderville Hotel, General Store and Post Office George Boone, Sr. Stone House and Tannery 1733 Judah Boone Home, 1824 Christian Link Pottery (later used as Stonetown Sunday School) Toll Gate #1, Oley Turnpike Jacksonwald Hotel Schwarzwald Lutheran Church Schwarzwald U.C.C. Church; Stone School; Cemetery Ritter Tavern Limekiln-Toll Gate #2, Oley Turnpike Road Boyertown Trolley Bridge There are twenty-four (24) Class III and IV historic resources identified by the Exeter Historical Commission within the geographical boundaries of Exeter Township, including St. Lawrence Borough. These sites have been severely compromised or significantly altered, have been demolished or have gone to ruin. Some are of potential archeological value. Schofer Sawmill Schofer Farmstead Breiner Paper Mill; Rifle Boring Moyer & Yocum Tilt-Hammer Forge AKA Althouse Feed Mill, Police Home, Ice House (only ice house and miller’s house survive) Seidel Mill Carsonia Park Area Bechtel Grist Mill Keim Clover Mill & Forge Dam & Race to Bishop Mill Bishop Grist Mill AKA Wamsher's Mill Lincoln Sawmill Seidel Steam Forge #3 Furnace of E & G Brooke Iron Co. 35 Limekiln Creamery (burned in tragic fire May 9, 2009, killing two children) Eight-Cornered (Octagonal) Schoolhouse at Limekiln/Snyderville Judah Boone Tilt-Hammer Forge, 1824 Judah Boone Grist Mill AKA Bechtel Mill James Boone Mine Moses Boone Wheelwright Shop James Boone Sawmill Gehr Fulling Mill Mahlon Guldin Potter Green Tree One-room Schoolhouse (converted residence) House of Miller at Bishop Mill Site A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 90 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods House at the site of the Judah Boone Tilt Hammer Forge off Loder Road, Photograph by Michelle N. Lynch There are many resources of note classified as Class II that are listed as “NRHP Status Undetermined,” basically meaning that they could meet criteria for the NRHP but applications were not submitted. The sites and properties that are noted above are representative of the early history and development of Exeter Township, pre-industrial revolution. A wealth of 18th and 19th century structures remain to be identified and fully surveyed. The Exeter Township Historical Commission has been charged with updating the township’s historic sites survey. Its volunteers have been working on the project since 2006. Progress remains slow since these volunteers have limited time to commit to the project. It should be noted that many of the sites previously identified by the commission are not actual historic resources, but merely sites where historic structures once stood. These sites might possibly yield some archeological information, but are classified here as Class IV since the resources have been significantly altered or demolished. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 91 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods National Historic Register Properties in Exeter Township Daniel Boone Homestead Daniel Boone Homestead, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Daniel_Boone's_Birthplace.jpg Overview Located on a tract of 579 acres, Daniel Boone Homestead, is the largest museum site administered by the PHMC. It is birthplace of American frontiersman Daniel Boone. However, the lives of the three main families that lived at the Homestead: the Boones, the Maugridges and the DeTurks are interpreted at the site. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania purchased the property in 1937 in order to preserve and protect the birthplace of Daniel Boone and began restoration soon afterward. Other examples 18th century architecture from the area have been relocated to and/or restored on the site, including, a circa 1769 blacksmith's shop; the Bertolet sawmill, a water-powered vertical blade sawmill; the Bertolet House, an example of 18th century Pennsylvania German architecture; a blacksmith’s shop; and the early 19th century DeTurck house, now an education center. The educational value of this public site, its 579 acres of open space, its position on the National Register of Historic Places, and its proximity to the HBW combine to rank it as a HIGHEST PRIORITY historic and cultural resource. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 92 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Brief History In 1731, Squire Boone, Daniel Boone's father, built a log cabin with one wall constructed of native stone in the Oley Valley in what is now Exeter Township. The basement of the house served as a spring house, providing easy access to water for cleaning, cooking and drinking and was also was useful for cold storage. Daniel Boone was born in this 11⁄2-story log house. William Maugridge, a shipwright/carpenter and relative of the Boones, purchased the homestead in 1750. The home underwent an expansion to two full stories either just prior to or after the time that it was transferred to Maugridge. After Maugridge’s death in 1766, the property was purchased by John DeTurk. He removed the walls of the log cabin and rebuilt them with stone. He also changed the floor plan from the hall and parlor type and built a smokehouse that still exists. The homestead changed hands several times before it was acquired by the PHMC. Historic and Cultural Resources at Daniel Boone Homestead 1. Visitor’s Center 2. Boone House – The present-day, 2-story Boone House is representative of typical Oley Valley farmhouses and shows evidence of both English and German architectural influences. 3. Boone House Cellar – This is the original spring cellar of Squire Boones log house. The stone walls are the foundations of the Boones’ log house where Daniel Boone was born. 4. Smokehouse – This structure was used to smoke pork and other meats as a means of preservation. 5. Blacksmith Shop – This structure was built near Amityville in 1769 and moved to the Daniel Boone Homestead. Squire Boone was a blacksmith by trade and would have had a similar shop on the premises. 6. Homestead Barn – This Pennsylvania German bank barn is the type that the DeTurck family likely had in the late 18th century. Portions of the barn are original. 7. Barn Threshing Floor – The upper level of the barn was used to store straw, hay, and grain. The central bay was used as a threshing floor and work area. 8. Bertolet House – The Bertolet House was built in 1737 on another site in the Oley Valley and relocated to the Daniel Boone Homestead in 1968. 9. Bertolet Bakehouse/Smokehouse – This structure was moved to the Daniel Boone Homestead along with the Bertolet House in 1968. 10. Bertolet Sawmill – This water-powered vertical-blade sawmill was built in Oley Township by Daniel Bertoilet in the late 18th or early 19th century and was moved to the Daniel Boone Homestead in 1972. 11. DeTurk Cemetery – The cemetery is the burial place of several members of the DeTurk family. 12. Daniel Boone Lake – This man-made lake serves as the nesting place for numerous species of waterfowl A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 93 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods 13. Rifle Range – This 18th century target range is the scene of a number of yearly flintlock marksmanship demonstrations by the First Pennsylvania Regiment. 14. North Picnic Area – This is one of three picnic areas. 15. Picnic Grove – This is a wooded picnic area. 16. Utility Building – This storage building is not a contributing structure. 17. South Picnic Area – This is another of the three picnic areas. 18. Wayside Lodge – This is a log camping facility with two bunk room, each with its own bathroom and 11 bunks (22 beds). 19. Deturk Education Center – This house was built in 1812 by Samuel DeTurk, the brother of Johannes DeTurk, who bought the Daniel Boone Homestead. The building is now used for educational programs. 20. Maintenance Barn – The former DeTurk barn, this 19th century structure is now used for storage of maintenance equipment. Threats and Mitigation Daniel Boone Homestead was one of 11 PHMC sites identified for possible closure in 2009. Its buildings were closed on December 1 of that year and events ceased with the exception of special tours and events conducted through the efforts of the non-profit volunteer organization, Friends of the Daniel Boone Homestead. The grounds remain open to the public. The PHMC has withdrawn support with the exception of one part-time staff person. The Friends of Daniel Boone Homestead, now oversee all aspects of programming, preservation and restoration at Daniel Boone Homestead. The Friends is a strong, viable, and dedicated organization that relies on volunteer efforts. The state’s withdrawal of support is a form of public neglect. This historic resource is threatened by public neglect since the state has withdrawn active support and full-time staffing, and is of high priority because of its value as a publically accessible recreational, environmental, and historic resource and its proximity to the HBW. Boonecroft AKA George Boone, III Homestead, 1720 Located on Oley Line Road and listed on the NRHP in 1982, this stone house was built by George Boone, an ancestor of Daniel Boone. The property includes the ruins of a chimney from the 1720 log cabin built by Quaker settler George Boone, III, grandfather of Daniel Boone. The log cabin burned in 1924. A commemorated stone marker was erected in 1925 by the Historical Society of Berks County. The adjacent farmhouse, built in 1733, is a 2½ -story Colonial English style structure built of fieldstone with sandstone quoins. It has a 1-story, stone addition. Also on the property are a contributing spring house, smoke house and barn. The homestead is considered the ancestral home of the Boone Family in America that includes frontiersman Daniel Boone, grandson of George Boone, III. The house is privately owned and wellmaintained. It is an important Class I resource that is not presently threatened. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 94 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods John Bishop House, http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:John_Bishop_House.JPG John Bishop House, c. 1763 Located on Perkiomen Avenue AKA Route 422, the John Bishop House is a 2½-story stone Georgian style house. It features a cut-stone primary facade, Georgian entryway, and open staircase rising three stories. The father of John Bishop arrived in Exeter with the Boones and Lincolns. Bishop had iron interests and became an extensive land holder in the area and in Virginia. It was listed on the NRHP in 1985 and is currently well maintained and not threatened. The house is presently used as a lawyer’s office and is not publically accessible. An identified threat is the proximity of the highway, which encroaches on the property. Mill Tract Farm AKA George Boone Homestead, gristmill 1728, house 1750 Located off of Limekiln Road, this expansive tract is an excellent example of an 18th century farm-mill complex. The majority of the buildings date from the mid or late 18th century. The 2½story gristmill was built in 1728 by George Boone, III, the grandfather of Daniel Boone. The earliest section of the L-shaped fieldstone Georgian farmhouse was built by his son James, an uncle of Daniel Boone, in 1750. An addition was built to the west about 1790 and another to the rear about 1820. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 95 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The tract also includes an early 19th century 2½-story fieldstone tenant house and large late18th century stone and frame barn. The property, which was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1978, is presently privately owned, inaccessible and well maintained. Mordacai Lincoln Home, 1733 Located on Lincoln Road this was the homestead of President Lincoln’s ancestor, though the 16 president only had a vague knowledge of his Pennsylvania ancestors, believing that they were Quakers from Berks County. The Mordecai Lincoln House is four miles south of the Daniel Boone Homestead, birthplace of Daniel Boone, and the Boone and Lincoln families were acquainted. th Mordecai Lincoln Jr. served as a justice of the peace, road inspector, and militia captain or commissioner for defense against the Indians. He died in 1736, shortly before the birth of a son, also named Abraham, who married the first cousin of Daniel Boone, Anne Boone, a Quaker who was censured by the Exeter Friends Meeting for marrying outside her faith. This suggests that the Lincolns were not Quakers, even though Mordecai Jr. is believed to have been buried in the Exeter Friends Burial Ground. The oldest section of the house dates to 1733. The gable faces the road and is banked into the hill with two stories rising above the basement level. This is one of the oldest English-style houses in Berks County, and resembles the Penn Plan design propagated by William Penn in the early days of Pennsylvania. However, the banked design is consistent with the German vernacular style common in Berks County in the 18th century. The basement contains a walk-in fireplace about 7 feet wide. The 1760 addition is stepped up the hill and has a similar plan. Dormers were added to the roof about 1830, and have been retained in the restoration that began in 1987. A summer kitchen, about 20 feet south of the 1760 addition, was built of red sandstone in the early 19th century. The house was renovated during 1987-88 to affect its c. 1760 form. This historic resource is privately owned, inaccessible and well maintained. It was listed on the NRHP in 1988. Snyder Mill AKA Schneider Mill, 1780 Located on Oley Line Road, this 1½-story banked stone gristmill harnessed the power of the Monocacy Creek. It measures 26 feet by 50 feet, with a frame addition of 20 feet, 3 inches, by 25 feet 10 inches. The wooden water wheel is intact. The mill ceased operations in 1930. This resource is representative of 18th century county gristmills and is significant for its association with the county grist milling industry. It was listed on the NRHP in 1990. It is privately owned and inaccessible. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 96 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods National Historic Register Eligible Properties in Exeter Township Bishop-Tyson House, early to mid-18th century This stone farmhouse is located on Perkiomen Avenue AKA Route 422 opposite the John Bishop House and is closely related to the site. With the widening of the highway, the house is now right on the roadway and endangered by encroaching traffic. It was neglected for many years, but appears to have new owners. Within the past year (2012-2013), it underwent some renovations, unfortunately these appear to be somewhat misguided and not in accordance with the Secretary of the Interiors Standards for Historic Preservation. Hans Martin Gohrig (Gerrick) House AKA Hans Martin House, 1741 The 1741 Hans Martin Gohrig House on Kerr Road is one of the most impressive examples of colonial period architecture in Berks County. According to James A. Lewars, director of the PHMC’s Landis Valley Farm Museum in Lancaster, “The house immediately impresses the viewer with its medieval proportions and lack of fenestration. There are expanses of stuccoed wall between small casement windows. The massive roof covers a double-attic and is ‘kicked’ or bellcast, with a more pronounced kick on the north façade. “Perhaps the most striking and unusual aspect of the house is the hip on the roof at each gable, forming a medieval jerkin roofline. The massive center chimney rises through the roof, not in the exact center, but more toward the east gable in typical Pennsylvania-German fashion.”8 The Gohrig house floor plan exemplifies the typical Pennsylvania German 3-room plan. On the first floor there is a kuche (cookery), stube (sitting room), and kamer (bed chamber). Unlike many other early homes of the area, the Gohrig house features a full second story. One of the rooms upstairs could have been the master bedroom. The other two may have been used as bedrooms for children or for storage. Documentary evidence exists to show that at least part of the attic was used for grain storage. Local historian, George M. Meiser, IX, has called the house “The most Germanic of Berks County’s surviving colonial structures.”9 Historian Philip Pendleton named it one of the ten most important colonial-era houses in Pennsylvania. The PHMC’s Jim Lewars stated, “The Hans Martin Gohrig House must take its place with other outstanding examples of Germanic architecture in Pennsylvania. The combination of a surviving 18th century jerkin roof, the sparse fenestration, casement-sized windows, spring cellar and cellar construction, along with classic Germanic floorplan dimensions and proportions make this house a unique surviving example.”10 The Gohrig House is at present unoccupied, after having been rented as an apartment house during the 1980s and 1990s. In 2005, it was purchased by a non-profit organization created specifically for the purpose of stabilizing the building, which was in an advanced state of disrepair, and for finding a buyer willing to restore it. A new roof was installed in 2006, but to date a buyer has not been found. 8 The Hans Martin Gohrig House Colonial Landmark in Danger, Historical Review of Berks County, Spring 2003 Ibid. 10 Ibid. 9 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 97 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The new roof is preventing further deterioration, but the house remains in a precarious position and is a high priority. It will be a true tragedy for Berks County and Pennsylvania if such an important colonial house is lost. A purchaser who has the means of preserving this valuable landmark could do a great service to the preservation of colonial heritage. Oley Line Hotel with Snyderville P.O.S. of A. Hall seen across the street at right. Photograph by Ben Hasty for the Reading Eagle. Oley Line Hotel AKA Snyderville Hotel 1835 Located at 800 Lime Kiln Road, this former hotel hugs the border line between Exeter and Oley. It was once a bustling crossroads hotel, post office and general store. An inn catering to cattle drovers and other travelers was established at this busy intersection quite early. Brothers Jacob and Peter Snyder replaced an older log tavern with the present stone hotel building in 1835. According to historian George M. Meiser, IX, the settlement here was originally called Snyderville, but for obvious reasons, it was referred to as Oley Line. The official designation became Limekiln in 1870 when the U.S. post office opened in the Snyders’ Oley Line Hotel. At first glance, the old hotel appears similar to other Pennsylvania Dutch country hotels, but a closer look under the late-19th century veranda reveals Greek revival decorative details, A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 98 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods fashionable in the U.S. from 1820 to 1860. A frieze ornamented with anthemion – a radiating leaf motif found in classical design – crowns each of the three entrances. The left entrance led to the general store and post office, the middle entrance opened onto a 51-inch-wide center hallway and conducted patrons up the grand staircase to the second floor bedrooms and ballroom or channeled lodge members to the third floor meeting rooms. The right entrance provided immediate access to the barroom. As the social center of the community, the hotel was designed to host a variety of activities. Meiser found the Oley Line Patriotic Order Sons of America was established there in 1874. Third-floor meeting rooms retain door peep holes where lodge members gave the secret password before gaining admittance. The inn’s kitchen, now the present owner’s living room, contains an open-hearth cooking fireplace once used to prepare meals for patrons. The former general store is now the owner’s dining room. On the second floor, ceiling-high room-dividing panels could be folded back opening two rooms into one to accommodate crowds and dancing. The hotel, which has been converted to residential use, recently underwent a three-year restoration. A stone outbuilding in the yard was restored with 2,500 antique red-clay tiles shipped from Germany to give its roof an authentic Oley Valley look. The property is privately owned, inaccessible and well maintained and no longer threatened by neglect. Exeter Friends Meetinghouse, 1759 Located on Meetinghouse Road, this meeting was established in 1725 as the Oley Friends. The name was changed to Exeter in 1742 and a log structure predating the present 1759 stone meetinghouse served the early Quaker settlers in Exeter Township such as the Boone, Ellis, Hughes, and Lee families. A historical marker near the site states that worship was discontinued in the building in 1899 but resumed in 1949. In March 2011, the roof of historic meetinghouse was damaged by a chimney fire. The building also sustained water damage. The structure has since been repaired. The Exeter Friends Burial Ground is adjacent to the Meetinghouse and contains the burials of some of Exeter’s pioneer families. The first internment was John Hughes, who died Oct. 10, 1736 at the age of 84. By 1817, the burial ground was filled. Since no additional land was available, ground was hauled in and filled to a depth of four feet and a second tier of graves was begun. There are no headstones or grave markers at this site. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 99 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Hill Mill aka Wanner Mill as photographed in 2006 by Robert T. Kinsey, http://millpictures.com/mills.php?millid=806 Wanner Mill aka Hill Mill and Miller’s House, c. 1790 The exact age of this small frame mill on Exeter Road is uncertain, but it is known that John Hill operated at rifle boring mill here from 1790 to 1809/1810. In the 20th century, Peter Spuhler converted the mill to a grist mill and operated it until 1959. The mill and associated miller’s house across the street are now deeded separately and under different ownership. The house is beautifully maintained. However, the mill itself is suffering from advanced neglect and is one of the most endangered historic resources within Exeter Township. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 100 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Conclusion Exeter Township Ongoing Threats and Mitigation Exeter Township has a Historical Commission but does not have any designated or protected historic districts or an ordinance protecting historic districts and/or historic resources. The commission can make recommendations or offer advice only if consulted. Its recommendations are not legally binding. The commission has been charged with identifying historic resources within the township and has been steadily working on that mission since 2006. Some sites previously identified as historic resources are not resources, but merely historic sites where buildings or structures once stood. They have the potential to yield archeological information only. The greatest threats to the township’s historic resources are development and neglect. Development encroaches on the resources and compromises their integrity. In some cases unidentified resources have been lost to development. In other cases buildings have deteriorated to such an advanced state of disrepair that they have fallen down or have to be torn down for safety reasons. Still other resources remain in an advanced state of disrepair and decay. This underscores the historical commission’s mission to identify resources before it is too late and they are lost to the rapid development or to neglect. A historic preservation ordinance and its enforcement would lead toward preservation of the historic landscape. Any such ordinance should include a “demolition by neglect” clause, requiring private property owners to maintain their buildings to code. It is strongly recommended to monitor any demolition permits of historic properties, and to strengthen the authority of the existing historical commission to make recommendations for demolition delays, alternate uses for historic buildings or structures, adaptive re-use and other mitigation of adverse effects on historic resources. The recommendations of the 2005 Joint Comprehensive Plan for Amity, Exeter and St. Lawrence for the protection of historic resources within the region remain valid. These are: 1. Utilize Historic Resource Overlay Zoning. 2. Utilizing demolition by neglect provisions in zoning ordinances. 3. Adopt Town Center and Rural Village design standards. 4. Require historic resource impact studies in subdivision and land development ordinances. 5. Encourage active involvement of Historical Commissions to: – Identify, evaluate, mark and foster awareness of historic resources – Investigate participation in Certified Local Government Program – Investigate creation of historic districts – Inform and involve public A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 101 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods – Encourage retention, restoration, enhancement and appropriate adaptive re-use of historic resources and discourage removal of historic structures – Conceive programs, events and interpretive signage and exhibits which emphasize the history of the region – Identify contemporary sites for future preservation St. Lawrence Borough Historical Background The village of St. Lawrence developed around two woolen mills, the A.J. Brumbach Woolen Mill and the Esterly Woolen Mill, which were both established in the 19th century and were major employers in the area. Employment opportunities in the community attracted residential development and further commercial development. The St. Lawrence Dairy was founded in 1888 and the John F. Lutz Furniture and Undertaking business was founded 1884. All employed steady work forces. The services a family doctor, a veterinarian, a blacksmith (David Lutz), a painter, a cabinetmaker, a plumber, and carpenters were also available within the village. The village was known as St. Lawrence, the name of a successful brand of woolen goods manufactured at the local mill. By the middle of 1890s, the villagers petitioned for a post office to be named St. Lawrence. However, since there was an existing post office by that name, the postal designation became Esterly. St. Lawrence lies geographically within the boundaries of Exeter Township, but was incorporated as a borough in 1927. Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in St. Lawrence Borough At present, 2012, within St. Lawrence Borough there are two (2) Class I historic resources listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Levan Farm AKA Isaac Levan Tract or Jacob Levan Farm John F. Lutz Furniture Co. & Funerary Levan Farm AKA Isaac Levan Tract orJacob Levan Farm, 1837 Located off Elm Ave. this historic house and farm complex includes a 2-story, 5-bay by 2pile, Georgian style fieldstone farmhouse with red sandstone quoins. It has a later 1½-story rear addition. Also on the property are a stone and wood frame bank barn, spring house, granary, corn crib, lime kiln, and wagon shed. The Levan Farm was established by Isaac Levan about 1730 on land granted from William Penn. The collection of farm structures makes this farm a good example of a working, self-sufficient farm. It was listed on the NRHP in 1978. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 102 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods John F. Lutz Furniture Co. & Funerary Located at 3559 and 3561 St. Lawrence Ave., this historic building complex consists of a combination house/shop, warehouse/showroom, and carriage house. The combination house/shop was built in 1878, and is a 2-story, brick and frame building in the Italianate style. Two small 2-story, frame additions were built in 1885 and 1910. The warehouse/showroom building was built in 1900 and is a 4-story building in the commercial style. A 4-story brick addition was built in 1928 and a 2-story, concrete block addition in 1955. The 2-story, brick carriage house was built in 1896. It is also in the Italianate style. John F. Lutz (1863-1936) was a furniture maker. Like many furniture makers of his era, he also built coffins and thus also learned to be an undertaker and opened a funerary business. The John F. Lutz Co. remained in business until 1968, after which a furniture outlet occupied the warehouse/showroom building until 1990. It was added to the NRHP in 1996. At present, 2012, within St. Lawrence Borough there are two (2) Class II Unidentified Historic Resources Daniel Housum Fulling Mill Complex and Miller’s Manor Stone Cabin Daniel Housum Fulling Mill Complex, pre-1830 and Miller’s Manor, c. 1802-1815 Daniel Housum established a fulling mill along the Antietam Creek at what is now 499 Parkview Ave. (40.323426,-75.866301) prior to 1830. In 1830, it was sold to Jacob Brumbach, who learned the fulling trade at DeTurck’s Fulling Mill near Monocacy in Exeter Township. Jacob sold the business to his sons, William and Jacob B., in 1842. This was the foundation of the Brumbach knitting mills of St. Lawrence. The entire Brumbach mills complex, including the associated tenant houses, should be evaluated and assessed as a potential historic resource. The miller’s manor across the street from the fulling mill is a federal style house built of brown sandstone, which possibly predates Housum’s ownership. Fine interior carpentry may be the work of the Bunn family of carpenters from Amity Township as it has similarities with their known works. The miller’s house became the workers’ boarding house for the Brumbach mill. Stone Cabin, c. 1800 Located behind 3327 Oley Turnpike Road (40.327043,-75.869664), this possible settler’s cabin or ancillary building was discovered by Susan Speros and inspected by Ms. Speros and Michelle Lynch in summer, 2012. The 2-room cabin was found to have the hallmarks of a typical late-18th century or early-19th century smallholder’s farmhouse or an ancillary workhouse on a larger farm. The cabin is located on a parcel #18 on the Exeter warrantee map. That parcel originally contained 152 acres and 130 perches. It was warranteed on May 2, 1744 to Friederich Limebach (probably Leinbach) and patented June 15, 1763 to Paul Durst. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 103 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The adjacent late-19th century house on the property appears to have been divided into rental units based on the number of electric meters on site. The cabin appears to be in use as a storage facility and trash staging area. The walls and roof are presently sound, but the building is neglected and in danger due to lack of maintenance and neglect. The recommendations of the 2005 Joint Comprehensive Plan for Amity, Exeter and St. Lawrence for the protection of historic resources within the region remain valid. These are: 1. Utilize Historic Resource Overlay Zoning. 2. Utilizing demolition by neglect provisions in zoning ordinances. 3. Adopt Town Center and Rural Village design standards. 4. Require historic resource impact studies in subdivision and land development ordinances. 5. Encourage active involvement of Historical Commissions to: – Identify, evaluate, mark and foster awareness of historic resources – Investigate participation in Certified Local Government Program – Investigate creation of historic districts – Inform and involve public – Encourage retention, restoration, enhancement and appropriate adaptive re-use of historic resources and discourage removal of historic structures – Conceive programs, events and interpretive signage and exhibits which emphasize the history of the region – Identify contemporary sites for future preservation A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 104 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Amity Township Historical Background Amity Township is the oldest incorporated Township in Berks County. Its boundaries are almost identical to the boundaries of an area originally known as the Swedes’ tract. During December 1699, Swedish Lutheran pastor Andreas Rudman met with Governor William Penn of Pennsylvania to discuss the Swedish situation. Rudman pointed out that many of the residents of the former Swedish colony of New Sweden felt cheated by the preemption of their lands for Quaker settlement. He secured an order from William Penn in October 1701 setting aside 10,000 acres upstream on the Schuylkill River near the Manatawny Creek for the members of his congregation. River frontage was important to these Swedes and their tracts are long narrow parcels fronting the Schuylkill at what is now known as Old Morlatton Village. The oldest extant house in Berks County, the stone 1716 Mounce Jones House is located here, but Jones had an even earlier log house on his tract. St. Gabriel’s Church, in Douglassville, formerly Morlatton, founded in 1720 by these Swedish Lutherans, is the first church congregation to be organized in Berks County. Services were first held in 1708 by the Reverend Andrew Sandel. When the Swedes could no longer secure ministers from their own country, they entered into full communion and fellowship with the Anglican Church and were provided with priests of the Church of England. By 1719, the Swede’s settlement had progressed to the point that the establishment of a local government was needed. An application was presented to the court in Philadelphia, requesting to form a Township called Amity. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 105 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Morlatton Village, administered by the non-profit Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County, represents the remnants of the Swedish Settlement begun in the early 1700s, when Berks County was still the frontier. During colonial times, the village became a center of commerce for the region as a routing center for refined iron from Pennsylvania’s earliest furnaces and for grains from the Oley Valley heading down river to Philadelphia. Morlatton’s importance grew as roads leading to Tulpehocken, Oley, Reading, and Philadelphia all intersected here. In addition to the Swedes, the English, Irish, and Germans migrated into the township contributing to its growth. The fertility of the soils made Amity an attractive place for settlement. The population of Amity Township increased steadily during the 18th century, through the 19th and into the 20th century. The population was 12,583 at the time of the 2010 census and the township, especially in the Douglassville area, is seeing growth in development, which is a threat to historic resources. Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in Amity Township At present, 2012, within Amity Township there are six (6) Class I historic resources listed on the National Register of Historic Places. George Douglass Mansion Mounce Jones House AKA Old Swede’s House White Horse Tavern Old St. Gabriel’s Episcopal Church Griesemer Mill Complex AKA Brown Mill Complex Weidner Mill At present, 2012, within Amity Township there are four (4) Class I historic resources identified as eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. NRHP Eligible Michael Fulp House T.B. Charles Farm Ben Franklin Inn AKA La Casa Musso Moyer’s School The following thirteen (13) Class II historic resources have been surveyed and found locally significant. Yellow House Store and Tavern William Ellis Farm Thomas Powell Farm Spott’s Mill Ron Rhoads Farm Amity Vale Farm Earlville Hotel Five Springs Farm A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 106 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods James Guthrie Farm Joseph Brewer Farm Leonard Ebert Farm Richard Conlin Farm Dr. Elia Kitchen House Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in Amity Township Old Morlatton Village George Douglass Mansion at Old Morlatton Village, photograph by Michelle N. Lynch George Douglass Mansion, 1763 The mansion located on Old Philadelphia Pike and built in 1763, is part of the Old Morlatton Village Historic Site. It is a 2-story, 5-bay sandstone building with a gable roof. The main section is classic Georgian in style and plan. Attached to the main section is a 2-story store wing built about 1800 and a 1-story smokehouse and wash house addition built about 1833. The house is owned by the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County, which has been working on A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 107 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods restoration since 1995. Great progress has been made during 2012 and 2013. The house listed on the NRHP in 2009. It is accessible to the public and open by appointment. Historical and Architectural Significance Condensed from the HPTBC’s website: Family History George Douglass was descended from Scottish nobility and spent his formative years in Salisbury Township in eastern Lancaster County. He married a Mary Piersol—another resident of Salisbury Township—in 1747. A 1750 tax list shows him still residing in Salisbury Township, but the 1754 and 1760 tax lists show him as a renter in Reading. It is likely he was one of many inn or tavern keepers in the busy county seat and market town because at the time he bought the White Horse Inn, in 1762, he was referred to as “innholder.” Douglass was thirty-six years old when he came to Morlatton. During the 1760s, he was active in petitioning for road creation. He lived from 1726 to 1799, was a Revolutionary War veteran (fighting in the battles for Long Island as a captain in the Berks County militia) and is buried in St. Gabriel’s church yard. Social History George Douglass was a Justice of the Peace for Berks County from 1764-1776. Two important factors for the post were high local social and economic status, and potential usefulness to the Proprietary government as a local political organizer and exerter of influence for the Proprietary interest. As a Justice of the Peace in the 18th century, George Douglass would have conducted county business from his home. Local residents would have gone to him to deal with land disputes, wills, water right agreements, and probate records, as well as crime. Architectural History After purchasing the White Horse Inn, George Douglass decided to build a separate sandstone Georgian mansion. The 2½-story structure provided ample living space for his family. The mansion must have been one of the first full-blown Georgian structures in the region. It is a central passage, double pile structure with 5 principle façade bays. The dormers appear to be original to the structure. A western corner entry was a later alteration. The exterior consists a plaster cove cornice and fine cut stone with evidence of a pent roof. There is a date stone with an unusual arrangement of initials and numerals. The interior and exterior of the structure is currently in the process of being restored. Much of the first floor’s original woodwork has been lost. There is evidence that the first floor walls had been fully paneled. The fine corner cupboard in the southeast room is probably a Federal period addition. However, the second floor and attic retain much of their original woodwork and hardware. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 108 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Mounce (Mouns) Jones House aka Old Swede’s House at Old Morlatton Village, photograph by Michelle N. Lynch Mounce (Mouns) Jones House aka Old Swede’s House, 1716 Located on Old Philadelphia Pike, the Mouns Jones House, part of the Old Morlatton Village Historic Site, is the oldest extant house in Berks County. It is owned, was restored by and is maintained by the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County. It was listed on the NRHP in 1974 and is open to the public by appointment. Historical and Architectural Significance Condensed from the HPTBC’s website: Family History Mounce Jones, son of Jonas Nilsson, was born in 1663 and eventually settled on the land he acquired from his father and built a modest stone dwelling. He married Ingabor Laicon around 1690 at Gloria Dei Church (the Old Swedes Church in Philadelphia). Their known children were Margaret (1691), Peter (1693), Christina (1695), Jonas (1698), Andrew (1702), and Brigitta (1704). When he moved to present-day Berks County, he deeded the stone house he had built in West Philadelphia to his son-in-law, Frederick Schopenhousen. It was later incorporated into John Bartram’s “Bartram’s Garden.” A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 109 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods The Jones family was one of four large families which settled together in the Oley Valley. The Swedish enclave which arose in southeastern Berks County was mostly related to Jones through either blood or marriage. Mounce Jones died in 1727 and is buried in the St. Gabriel’s church yard in Douglassville, Pennsylvania. In 1735, Brigitte Huling (granddaughter of Mounce Jones) married William Bird of Hopewell Furnace fame. Andrew Jones (son of Mounce) married Dorothy Gouther in 1736. John Kirlin, a later owner of the property, was living in the Morlatton region by 1754. John and his wife, Elizabeth, have a son named Samuel in 1762. Also, Kirlin was a vestryman at St. Gabriel’s Church from 1763 to 1767. The late-18th century and early-19th century history of the property is directly related to the Douglass family. Social History The history of the Mounce Jones property and its surrounding area are directly linked to the Schuylkill River. At the earliest period, canoes were the primary form of transportation, even to Philadelphia. Nevertheless, in 1709, Mounce Jones signed a petition to have a road made to Manatawny. Jones was appointed to lay out this road, but it was never approved and therefore never created. Probably during the ownership of Andrew Jones (son of Mounce) and definitely prior to 1820, the house was used as a tavern and known as the Lamb’s Inn. The tavern was probably operated by Mounce Jones’ grandson. Much like the White Horse Inn, choosing to operate a tavern from this location was wise due to the proximity of the ford and the road junction near the house. Probably due to the ford being located near his home, Mounce Jones was a known confidant with the local Native American population. Later in life, he donated a portion of his land for the construction of St. Gabriel’s Church. Architectural History The house, built in 1716, is the oldest documented dwelling in Berks County, but while it is considered the oldest extant structure in the county, it is by no means the first structure that was ever built here. Considering the amount of restoration and reconstruction that the building has gone through, it is hard to truly consider it the oldest standing structure in the county. The original structure on the property was probably a log structure located somewhere on the river side of the current structure. A foundation for this structure had been located during the restoration of the house. The current stone house stands at the south end of what was the original 498-acre tract acquired by Mounce Jones in 1701. It is a 2½-story sandstone structure. Stone construction was adopted by the Swedes only after the mass immigration of English and Welsh Quakers to Pennsylvania in the 1680s. The house reflects the fact that the Swedes were becoming acculturated into Anglo-American society. Originally, the building would have been a 20 by 36 foot home in the style of an English hall-parlor house with casement-style windows. At some point, the original partition wall on the first floor was removed—this wall would have divided the hall and parlor. There is a corner fireplace in the parlor (representing lingering Swedish A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 110 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods influence) and a gable roof. At some point, the second floor had been divided into three small rooms with a hall running from east to west for access on the river side. There also was a deep cellar which was filled in over the years by continuous flooding by the Schuylkill River. By 1961, the structure was in ruins, was regularly being flooded by the Schuylkill River, and contained a heavy deposit of silt in the cellar and first floor. The roof and second floor had collapsed along with the entire eastern elevation. Part of the northeastern chimney had fallen as well. The area around the house was heavily wooded and overgrown. The Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County began restoring the property in 1965 and took three years to complete the work. The HPTBC has continued to restore and maintain the house since that time. Amity Colonial Dancers at the White Horse Tavern in Old Morlatton Village, photograph by Michelle Lynch White Horse Tavern, 1765 The tavern was originally built in 1765, and is a 2½-story, 5-bay, sandstone building with a gable roof. A 2½-story, 3-bay, addition was constructed in 1780. The building operated as an inn and tavern until 1870, when it was converted to a 3-family residence. The house was obtained in 1971 by the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County and subsequently restored. It is part of A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 111 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods the Morlatton Village historic site and was listed on the NRHP in 1975. It is accessible and open to the public by appointment. Historical and Architectural Significance Condensed from the HPTBC’s website: Family History The first person to utilize the property as a public house location was Marcus Huling. Huling, a Swedish Indian trader, was married to Mounce Jones’ daughter Margaret. Marcus Huling lived from 1687 to 1757 and is buried in the St. Gabriel’s church yard. Huling was a well known Indian interpreter and a man of great wealth. He was a vestryman at St. Gabriel’s Church in 1753. Perhaps due to his association with a tavern, Huling was very active in the 1730s and 40s in seeking roads through petition. In 1744, Huling signed the petition which created Amity Township. Social History Early in the tavern’s existence, it was known as the “White Stag.” Nevertheless, the White Horse Inn was the first stop on the highway from Reading to Philadelphia. Near here was a ford originally known as the “White Horse Ford.” The ford was apparently located slightly upriver from here. The Philadelphia stage would have passed by the inn twice a week. This inn would have been well known since it was a day’s journey from Philadelphia and located near a ford of the river. The White Horse was the Oley Valley’s first house for public entertainment and accommodation. After the covered bridge was built, the White Horse’s business declined because traffic began to bypass its location and people began to use the Black Horse Tavern (present-day Douglassville Hotel). By 1770 the only road from Reading to Philadelphia passed the White Horse, the ford across the river that most people used to get to Thomas Millard’s mill was near here with a road across it, and the road to Oley terminated near the Douglass House. Therefore, this was a major 18th century crossroads. This would have been a very good place to locate an inn. During its existence, the tavern housed many notably people. George Washington visited the property twice. On November 10, 1793, during an inspection tour of Reading in the aftermath of the yellow fever epidemic, he stopped at the inn. Washington stopped again during his journey west to suppress the Whiskey Rebellion in 1794. He traveled in a coach of state with a military escort at the head of a militia column. The Whiskey Rebellion was an insurrection in the Pennsylvania counties west of the Alleghany Mountains in response to an excise tax which had been placed on whiskey by the government. Most people in this region made a living by producing whiskey. Architectural History The current structure is Georgian style with a principle façade constructed of coursed, dressed sandstone. The remaining three facades are constructed of undressed sandstone. The original section of the structure was the eastern section and was of the double cell type; this section consisted of two rooms on each floor. Today, this section includes the main entrance room, the “meeting” room, and the office and storage rooms on the second floor. Around 1762, A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 112 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods George Douglass enlarged the structure to the west. Douglass’ addition consisted of one room on the first floor with two rooms above. Today, this includes the tap room and the caretaker’s apartment on the second floor. The western door opened into the bar and the eastern door opened into a women’s sitting room in the 18th century. Old Morlatton Village Threats The above three NRHP resources together with the NRHP eligible Michael Fulp House comprise the historic sites of Old Morlatton Village, a historic site owned, administered, and maintained by the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County. Application to the PHMC for the nomination of Morlatton Village as a historic district to the National Register of Historic Places was denied based on the number of intrusions in the village. While this is regrettable, it does not preclude the township from declaring the village a historic district and protecting it with a historic district ordinance in order to regulate existing structures and prevent further intrusions. Fortunately, the HPTBC has control of the four most important historic sites within the village, and nearby St. Gabriel’s Church, which historically served the village, is well preserved by the congregation. The HPTBC has done an admirable job of restoring and maintaining the resources it owns, but it faces some challenges, most significantly, lack of funds and a dwindling volunteer base. The educational value of the historic resources in Old Morlatton Village, their accessibility to the public, their position on the National Register of Historic Places, and their proximity to the HBW combine to rank them as HIGH PRIORITY historic and cultural resources. Old St. Gabriel’s Episcopal Church, 1801 St. Gabriel’s Church served the village of Morlatton. The congregation is the oldest in Berks County. The 1801 stone church was constructed in a plain classically influenced style, typical of rural churches in the region. Noted features of the building are the herring-bone pattern masonry, an arched ceiling, galleries on three sides reached by two stairways converging to the main entrance way, windows above and below the galleries, and high backed pew boxes furnished with doors and capped with cornices at the height of the adult occupant's shoulders. A wineglass shaped pulpit, surmounted by a sounding board, projected the minister’s voice into the congregation. The church, known as the chapel by the present congregation, was listed on the NRHP in 1978. It has been restored, is well maintained, is publically accessible and is open to the public by appointment. Griesemer Mill Complex AKA Brown Mill Complex, farmhouse c. 1830, mill 1843 Located on Brown’s Mill Road, this historic gristmill complex along the Monocacy Creek consists of 1½-story, stuccoed sandstone mill (1843); a 2½-story, stucco-over-stone farmhouse (c. 1830); 1½-story, stucco over stone, brick and frame summer kitchen (c. 1830); stone and A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 113 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods frame barn (c. 1850); two small barns (c. 1900); wagonshed with corn crib (c. 1920); and frame garage (c. 1920). The mill is representative of a country custom mill, built as part of a working farm and is important for its association with the county gristmill industry. Architecturally, it is a good representative of a country custom mill of the mid-19th century. It was listed on the NRHP in 1990 and is privately owned. Weidner Mill, 1855 Located on Blacksmith Road, this is a historic gristmill was powered by the Manatawny Creek was built as part of a working farm. The complex consists of the 2½-story, stone and brick banked mill (1855); 2½-story, stucco over stone farmhouse (c. 1840); 1 ½-story, stucco over stone, combined smokehouse/springhouse (c. 1820); 2½-story, stucco over stone tenant house (c. 1820); stucco over stone bank barn (c. 1850); and the millrace and dam. The mill ceased operation in the 1940s. The mill is an example of 19th century mill architecture and was listed on the NRHP in 1990. It is privately owned. Class I Historic Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places in Amity Township Michael Fulp House, c. 1783 This modest stone house was built for yeoman farmer Michael Fulp (c.1743-1808). It offers insight into the lives of the local working people of the 18th century. Fulp’s name first appears on the Amity tax rolls of 1773 where he is described as a landless single freeman. He served as a private in the local militia during the Revolutionary War. Around 1783, he purchased a ¼-acre lot from his neighbor, John Kerlin (a later owner of the Mounce Jones tract), and had a stone house built. The house originally had two rooms on the main floor with an open attic and a cellar under one half of the building. The main floor includes a fireplace with chimney for cooking on one gable end and until the 20th century the room opposite was heated by a stove, which had its own chimney on the opposite gable. In the mid-20th century, the house became known as the Bridge Keeper’s House, although there is no official record of a bridge keeper here. It was acquired by the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County in 1965. During 2011-2012 the HPTBC completed extensive repair and restoration on the Fulp House. The Fulp House is open to the public by appointment. Ben Franklin Inn AKA La Casa Musso, 1809 Located at 824 East Benjamin Franklin Hwy. AKA Route 422 East, this stone building was historically known as Gressmoyer Tavern. It was the Ben Franklin Inn when it was determined eligible for the NRHP in 1992. The property has changed hands several times within the last two decades. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 114 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Moyer’s School, 1860 Located on East Benjamin Franklin Hwy. AKA Route 422 East, this brick one-room school house served the community until its 1918 closing. The schoolhouse lay abandoned for many years before being converted to commercial use in the 1970s. Note: Irey Mansion AKA Roselawn, 1850s (formerly Class I, now demolish) Formerly located on the East Benjamin Franklin Hwy. AKA Route 422 East, 1000ft. West of Old Swede Rd., this historic resource on a former dairy farm was identified as eligible for the NRHP by the PHMC in 1998, the year a Wawa convenience store and gas station was proposed for the site. A group of preservation-minded residents from the community banded together in an attempt to save the mansion and its associated outbuildings, involving the PHMC and successfully delaying the project. Unfortunately, that did not stop it from being demolished to make way for the Wawa in 1999. A “demolition” auction was held in June of that year. Attendees bid on eight fireplace mantels, a 3-story walnut staircase, interior trim and other architectural salvage to be removed at their own expense. The Wawa store, its parking lot and gas pumps now occupy the site. William Ellis Farm, 1739 This 18th century stucco-over-stone farmhouse, summer kitchen, and barn complex is located at the intersection of Blacksmith Road and Pleasant Meadow Road. Class II Historic Resources Surveyed in Amity Township Yellow House Store and Tavern, 1801 Located on Old Swede Road at the intersection of the Boyertown Pike (Intersection of Routes 662 and 562), the Yellow House Hotel originally served as a stagecoach stop and country store for travelers between Reading and Philadelphia. The stucco-over-stone structure has long been painted yellow, hence its name. The hotel played an important role in the local community, housing a general store, the village switchboard, and a post office. The ownership and cuisine of the Yellow House has changed hands more than 25 times over the years, but the hotel remains a popular gathering place, restaurant and guest inn. William Ellis Farm, 1739 This 18th century stucco-over-stone farmhouse, summer kitchen, and barn complex is located at the intersection of Blacksmith Road and Pleasant Meadow Road. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 115 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Thomas Powell Farm, 1782, enlarged 1820 This stucco-over-stone farmhouse and barn are located on Valley Road Spott’s Mill, 1840 This mid-19th century stone gristmill is found on Spott’s Mill Road. Ron Rhoads Farm, 1840, 1875 This mid-to-late-19th century stone farmhouse and barn are located on Memorial Highway AKA Route 662 AKA Old Swede Road. Amity Vale Farm, 1798 This late-18th century farm complex includes a stone Georgian style farmhouse, barn, and other outbuildings located on Pine Lane. Earlville Hotel, 1794, 1838 This is stucco-over-stone building is a typical country roadside hotel of the late-18th to early19 century. It is located on Boyertown Pike AKA Route 562. th Five Springs Farm AKA Rhoads/Lorah Farm, 1830 Known as Five Springs or The Rhoads/Lorah Homestead, this farmstead complex with a stone Georgian style farmhouse, summer kitchen, spring house, and barn is located at 1832 Old Swede Road near the hamlet of Yellow House. Family patriarch, Johan Jacob Rhoads (Rodt), came with his family to Amity Township from Wurtemberg in 1717. Together with Johann Theodorick Griener (possibly a relative), he purchased 300 acres, later divided on a prorated basis, so that the Rhoads family retained 100 acres, including the Five Springs Farm tract. The land remained in the family for five successive generations, until 1925. This wonderful c.1830 Pennsylvania German limestone house has been remarkably preserved and restored. The elegant proportions and understated neo-classical details are in keeping with Federal architectural style of the period. However, as a rural example, house retains many of the traditional elements and utilitarian features of a typical farmhouse. In front of the main house is a springhouse in which foods were preserved in the days before refrigeration. The grounds are comprised of over 11 acres of gardens, huge specimen trees, rolling-meadows and lawns. A summer kitchen, with a cellar spring, was converted in the 1930s to a guesthouse overlooking two more springs and the stream that feeds the pond. A large Pennsylvania stone-ender bank barn and numerous outbuildings complete the farmstead. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 116 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods James Guthrie Farm, 1807 This is another fine early 19th century farm complex with a stone Federal style farmhouse and two barns located on Blacksmith Road Joseph Brewer Farm, 1830, 1850 This property features a 5-bay stone farmhouse located on Pine Lane. Leonard Ebert Property, 1820, 1860 This stucco-over-stone house on Worman Road was converted from a one room school. Richard Conlin Farm, 1860, 1880 This stone Italianate style house, located on Route 662 AKA Old Swede Road, is similar to some others in the region such as the now-demolished Irey Mansion and the Dr. Elias Kitchen House. The complex includes a summer kitchen. Dr. Elias Kitchen House, 1860 Built in 1857, this house is significant both for its unusual blend of architectural styles and its residents over the years. The rear section of the house was constructed with the proportions and architectural details of the Greek revival style. The larger front section exhibits the massing, scale and decorative details of the slightly later Italianate style. Curiously, the house is also embellished with some Gothic Revival elements. These are present, predominantly, in the main entrance and porch areas and in the lancet arches of the third story windows. The house was built for Dr. Elias Carey Kitchin (1827-1909), a native of Bucks County, who received his certification in medicine at the age of 23 in 1850. In 1856, Dr. Kitchin married Ellen Filbert, whose father had been the proprietor of the Yellow House Hotel. An interesting chapter in the life of Dr. Kitchin concerns his service during the Civil War. When Dr. Kitchin learned that the Confederates were marching through Pennsylvania, he started for Harrisburg with a rifle. There, he chanced to meet Surgeon-General King of the Union Army, who made him assistant surgeon and assigned him to the 21st Pennsylvania Cavalry. Dr. Kitchin was lauded for both duty and bravery before being mustered out in 1865 and returning to his Amity practice. In 1933, the house was purchased by Robert and Esther Merritt. The couple began their wellknown antique business here in the home. Following Esther’s passing, Robert remarried. His second wife, Mary Merrit, is fondly remembered by generations of Berks County girls for the doll museum she founded and operated for many years. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 117 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Conclusion Amity Township Ongoing Threats and Mitigation As one of the oldest settlement sites in Berks County, Amity Township has a wealth of historic resources and is particularly rich in 18th and early 19th century resources. However, the township does not have a historical commission to assist in identifying historic resources within the township or to make recommendation on mitigating adverse effects to historic resources. With its proximity to the Route 422 corridor and easy access to the greater Philadelphia region, the greatest threat to Amity’s historic resources is suburban development, which has rapidly increased in the past two decades. Development encroaches on the resources and compromises their integrity. In some cases unidentified resources have been lost to development. The township is advised to identify potential historic districts such as the village of Amityville and thematic districts for 18th century farmsteads and to adopt a historic district ordinance to protect identified resources before they are lost this rapid development. A historic preservation ordinance and its enforcement would assist in the preservation of the historic landscape. The recommendations of the 2005 Joint Comprehensive Plan for Amity, Exeter and St. Lawrence for the protection of historic resources within the region remain valid. These are: 1. Utilize Historic Resource Overlay Zoning. 2. Utilizing demolition by neglect provisions in zoning ordinances. 3. Adopt Town Center and Rural Village design standards. 4. Require historic resource impact studies in subdivision and land development ordinances. 5. Encourage active involvement of Historical Commissions to: – Identify, evaluate, mark and foster awareness of historic resources – Investigate participation in Certified Local Government Program – Investigate creation of historic districts – Inform and involve public – Encourage retention, restoration, enhancement and appropriate adaptive re-use of historic resources and discourage removal of historic structures – Conceive programs, events and interpretive signage and exhibits which emphasize the history of the region – Identify contemporary sites for future preservation A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 118 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Douglass Township Historical Background Douglass Township was named for the prosperous Douglass family of Douglassville, formerly Old Morlatton in Amity Township and there is a close relationship between the two townships. They are part of a region historically identified as the Manatawny Section, which takes its name from the stream draining this area also including Exeter and Oley Townships. This was the first region of Berks County to be settled by Europeans, when a small colony of Swedes took up residence in1701. Their friendly relationship with the area Natives gave the name “Amity” to the territory that became that township. German and English settlers followed, beginning about 1712. This southern section of the Manatawny Valley is rich in iron. Beginning in 1716, Douglass Township became the site of the earliest iron industry in Berks County and in Pennsylvania when Thomas Rutter founded Rutter’s Bloomery Forge, later known as Pine Forge. His early effort led to a proliferation of other major iron works, including the Colebrookdale Furnace, also in Douglass Township, and others within and nearby the HBW. The high iron content of the soil is evident in the reddish-brown color of the stone used to construct farmhouses, barns and outbuildings in this region. Compare this color with the bluegray of the lime-rich stone found farther north in the Manatawny Valley. The heavy lime enriched soil there allowed wheat farming to prosper during the colonial period and gave rise to the construction of local grist mills powered by the townships’ streams and waterways. The entire Manatawny region experienced unequaled and unprecedented wealth at this time. Vestiges of this wealth remain in the legacy of the built environment found here. Today, modern bridges span the Schuylkill River, uniting the geographic regions on the eastern and western banks. However, Amity and Douglass Townships on the eastern bank and A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 119 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Union on the western bank were historically identified within separate geographical regions, each having its own unique, yet interrelated, heritage and history. Across the Schuylkill River in Union Township, there was a different settlement pattern. European colonization here began in 1715, more than a decade after the settlement of the Manatawny Section and during a time when this region was still part of Chester County. The first settlers here were of Welsh and English origin with some Swiss-German Mennonites. This region on the opposite bank is historically known as the “Schuylkill Section” and includes Brecknock, Caernarvon and Robeson Townships, much of the heart of the HBW. It, too, is known for deposits of iron ore and the reddish-brown sandstone found here. In both of these regions, the Manatawny and the Schuylkill, we witness the “melting pot” that is America. The early settlers in each region borrowed ideas from one another, and the 18th century structures they left behind often exhibit a curious mixture of various post-medieval European traditions and American innovations. Significant Historic and Cultural Resources in Douglass Township At present, 2012, within Douglass Township there are two (2) Class I historic resources listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Ironstone Bridge Bahr’s Mill At present, 2012, within Douglass Township there is one (1) Class I historic districts listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Pine Forge Mansion and Industrial Site At present, 2012, within Douglass Township there is one (1) Class I historic districts eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. Colebrookdale Furnace Complex At present, 2012, within Douglass Township there ten (10) Class I historic resources eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. Popodickon Manor Jacob Bunn House Wooden Trestle Bridge Greshville Hotel, General Store and Post Office Willow Glen AKA Major James Wren Mansion Little Oley Post Office AKA Greshville Store A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 120 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Little Oley Hotel Gilbert Miller Gristmill Levengood-Wagner Gristmill Glendale 2-Room Schoolhouse Class I Historic Resources Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in Douglass Township Ironstone Bridge, 1907 Located on Farmingdale Ave. this historic concrete arch bridge crossed the Ironstone Creek. It is a single span, 104-foot long, barrel arch bridge. It was listed on the NRHP in 1988. Bahr Mill at Gablesville, photograph by Robert T. Kinsey, http://millpictures.com/mills.php?millid=3114 Bahr’s Mill, 1897 Part of a farm complex in the village of Gabelsville, this stone mill was built in 1897 to house Jacob Bahr's (pronounced Bear) woodworking and grist mill business. An older linseed oil A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 121 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods mill dating prior to 1828 occupied the site until the 1890s. That mill was converted for woodworking in the early 1870s, and the new mill was built in 1897. The original machinery includes a duplicating lathe, a polishing machine (belt sander) and a spoke-tenoning machine with 1870 and 1871 patent dates. There are also two standard lathes, both over 10 feet long. The mill was water-powered by an overshot wheel until the dam washed out with flooding in 1938. Then, in 1945, the Bahr Family’s saw mill across the street won a contract from the Boyertown Burial Casket Company. This required more hours of operation than the millponds could provide. The family woodworking business was largely ignored from that time until Lawrence Bahr closed the sawmill in 1967. The mill is listed on the NRHP. It is privately owned and is open to the public by appointment. Class I Historic Districts Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in Douglass Township Pine Forge Mansion, courtesy of Preservation Trades Network, https://www.facebook.com/pages/Preservation-Trades-Network/36544679589 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 122 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Pine Forge Mansion and Industrial Site, 1716 This site consists of five (5) historic buildings, several masonry ruins, and the remains of a dam and mill race. The primary complex of buildings includes a large stone manor house, small stone barn, small stone outbuilding, stone root cellar, smokehouse, and a garage.11 Pine Forge, established in 1716, was owned by six generations of the Rutter family and three generations of the Potts family and is particularly significant as the first iron forge and furnace established in Pennsylvania. The iron master’s house is significant for its association with Thomas Rutter founder of Pine Forge and for its association with successor generations of his family and the Potts family. As abolitionists, the Rutters are believed to have used the manor as a stop on the underground railroad, a network that assisted runaway slaves in escaping to freedom. The buildings and neighboring grounds are currently owned by the nonprofit Allegheny-East Conference Corp. of Seventh-day Adventists and used for the Conference’s Pine Forge Academy. The conference hopes to restore the remaining structures for use as an education center. Public tours, living-history events, and musical and education programs would be hosted on site. However, estimates for restoration range up to $20 million. In 2002, the “Pine Forge Iron Plantation” site and its associated buildings were the subject of a study for a graduate thesis in historic preservation by Melissa Pilar LaValley. Ms. LaValley traced the history and building chronology of the site and made recommendations for its preservation. This thesis is available for download in PDF at http://ia700208.us.archive.org/1/items/pineforgeironpla00lava/pineforgeironpla00lava.pdf. Class I Historic Resources Eligible for the National Register of Historic Places in Douglass Township Popodickon Popodickon was built near present day Boyertown in 1731 by Thomas Potts, the father of John Potts. A year earlier, in 1730, Potts purchased 250 acres adjoining the Colebrookdale Furnace from Thomas Rutter. He then built Popodickon on this land about one mile upstream from the furnace. According to family legend the house was named for an Indian chief allegedly buried on the property. However, the house may have been named after the nearby creek, then called Popodickon, and now Ironstone Creek. “Pine Forge Iron Plantation: History, Building Chronology and Recommendations for Preservation” Historic Preservation Graduate Thesis by Melissa Pilar LaValley, 2002 11 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 123 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A few days after his son, John’s marriage to Ruth Savage in 1734, Thomas gave the property to John and it became home to the newlyweds. The couple built Pottsgrove manor in 1753 and in 1760, John gave the Popodickon property to his son-in-law, Thomas Rutter III. The original circa 1731 portion of the house is built of brick with a typical English centerhall plan and a gable chimney situated at each end. The house is 5 bays wide, with center entrance door. There are two rooms on the first floor and two on the second floor. An attic with fireplaces at each end and windows in the gables provided additional living space. In some ways, the smaller and slightly less grand Popodickon served as a model for Pottsgrove, the house John Potts built twenty years later at Pottsgrove. There are stylistic similarities between the two homes, most notably in the front halls. Jacob Bunn House, 1760s Located at 411 Old Philadelphia Pike, this house was once considered part of Morlatton Village. This is the showplace of all the homes attributed to the premier master carpenters of Berks County, Jacob Bunn and his son, John Bunn. The large body of their work encompasses the late 18th and early 19th centuries, and can be found throughout Berks County and parts of Chester County. Notable early examples reveal a distinctly Georgian influence, while later examples executed by Jacob’s son, John, have a decidedly Federal appearance. This house, Jacob’s own home, consists of an early circa 1760s stuccoed stone section in the rear, two-and-a-half stories, with two rooms on each floor. The slightly banked cellar is very interesting with its barrel vaulted root cellar, and well/spring, all indicators of an earlier vintage than the rest of the house. The main section of the house was built by master carpenter Jacob Bunn in about 1790. The late Georgian front addition, of clapboard sheathed logs, features an elegantly and masterfully fashioned front entry with fluted pilasters, fanlight and raised panel door. All six-over-nine windows are crowned with wooden keystone centered cornices. The interior woodwork in the large front room is most masterful, with all details fashioned to be prime examples of the master carpenter's work for prospective clients. Adjacent, in full view for clients, the magnificent central stairway features the Bunn's characteristically modeled drop finials and intricately turned spindles. The crowning feature of the home is the truly magnificent carved and paneled second floor parlor. This room features dentil moldings and pitch-pedimented windows, with a mantel and overmantel flanked by a pedimented cupboard. Similar rich architectural details in a second floor parlor are found in two houses credited to the Bunns, the 1801 Fisher house in Oley, and the 1802 Hain house (“Greystone”) near Wernersville. The elegant upstairs parlor or master bedroom with an ornately carved fireplace and flanking cupboards is a characteristic almost universally seen in the Bunns’ work. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 124 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Wooden Trestle Bridge This is an old wooden trestle railroad bridge for the Reading Colebrookdale Branch of the railroad. Greshville Hotel, General Store and Post Office, 1853 Located on the Boyertown Pike AKA Route 562, this typical mid-19th century stucco-overstone country hotel was originally known as Limestone Hotel due to the local limestone quarrying operation. Willow Glen AKA Major James Wren Mansion, 1870 Located on Route 100 near the intersection of Route 562, this mid-19 th century home was built for the owner of a woolen mill. Colebrookdale Ironworks, 1830 Located along Route 100, the earliest building in this complex dates to 1830 when W.W. Weaver established a forge/foundry here to make wood burning stoves, kettles and iron utensils. The complex includes “company houses” or tenant houses. Little Oley Post Office AKA Greshville Store, 1871 Located at the intersection of Route 100 and Greshville Road the short-lived post office was designated Little Oley. Little Oley Hotel, 1885 This late 19th century hotel was rebuilt by William Turner. It is located adjacent to the Little Oley Post Office or Greshville Store. Gilbert Miller Gristmill, enlarged by F. Neiman, 1880 This is an example of a mid-to-late 19th century gristmill, located on Gristmill Road. Levengood-Wagner Gristmill, 1840s This is a mid-19th century brown sandstone gristmill located on Gristmill Road. Glendale 2-Room Schoolhouse, 1883 Located on Glendale Road, this old schoolhouse closed in 1932. Glendale was an old name for Pine Forge Village. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 125 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Threats and Mitigations Douglass Township does not have a historical commission. Historic resource surveys for the township have not been updated, and are presently inadequate. The township remains largely rural, wooded, and undeveloped outside of agricultural operations. A substantial quarry forms an intrusion on the landscape in the southeastern corner of the township. Threats include encroaching suburban sprawl from Amity Township to the west, greater Pottstown and Upper Pottsgrove Township to the east, and Boyertown to the north. It is imperative that the township take action to identify and assess its historic resources at this time. The township is advised to appoint a historical commission, similar to that in nearby Exeter Township, to undertake this task. CONCLUSION Cultural and Historic Resources Prioritized Within and Nearby the HBW in Southeastern Berks County The Municipalities within the southeastern area of Berks County that have ties to the HBW are distinguished more by their differences than their similarities. The similarities are rather obvious, the underlying Colonial era English base, with the general Pennsylvania Dutch overlay. The differences can be sometimes dramatic, and the settlement patterns and motivation of the earliest “English” settlers tell the story of that HBW Berks area’s cultural and architectural history and legacy. Of all, Caernarvon Township has the most singular history, with the first settlers coming exclusively from the Welsh Tract. It is interesting to note that Berks County historians view townships such as Amity, Douglass, Exeter and Union as part of the “greater Oley Valley” sphere, which is not necessarily so. Conversely, due to their close historic ties, Chester County historians view Union Township as a natural extension of the Coventry Townships’ sphere. Additionally, Douglass Township experienced a steady settlement directly from Germantown via Philadelphia (Montgomery) County. Certainly the early Swedish “Morlatton” community of parts of Amity, Union and Douglass Townships can be viewed a historic entity unto itself, with close ties of family, culture, commerce, and church. Certainly in the 18th and 19th century there were dealings with the Germanic enclave of the nearby Oley Valley, but the culture and frank Germanic architectural legacy of the Oley Valley tells a different story than that of the HBW Townships of southeastern Berks. With study and analysis, these “HBW Townships” of Berks yield their individual stories, and the settlement pattern of each reveals the time line of distribution of historic resources. The earliest settlers, Welsh and English entrepreneurs, from Philadelphia via Chester and Philadelphia (Montgomery) counties were largely connected with the iron trade and commerce. This is clearly seen in the more prominent structures in our architectural legacy, and notably discerned in the very Georgian influenced homes they built by the mid-to-late 18th century. This A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 126 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods pattern is seen in all Townships, but particularly in Caernarvon and Robeson Townships. Historic resources here are of HIGHEST PRIORITY to the HBW. We find the earliest and most prominent vestiges of the early iron industry in Berks County in Douglass, Union, and Robeson Townships, with several historic resources being on the NRHP or eligible for it. These are all of HIGH PRIORITY to the HBW. In Amity, we find the village of Morlatton with its ties to the early Swedish pioneers, the local iron industry and agriculture. The educational value of the historic resources in Old Morlatton Village, their accessibility to the public, their position on the National Register of Historic Places, and proximity to the HBW combine to rank them as HIGH PRIORITY to the HBW. All of the early Berks iron dynasty families retained ties through generations with the iron dynasties of Montgomery and Chester Counties. These iron rich histories have indelible ties to each other, making county lines superfluous. The HBW area encompasses the whole of this rich and important early history, be it Berks, Chester or Montgomery (Philadelphia) County. This interconnectedness of early culture, architecture, commerce, and family, is what ties the historic and cultural resources of all of the HBW together and makes these resources and their protection of utmost and primary importance. Class I historic resources that are Berks Heritage Council heritage sites within and nearby the HBW include: Allegheny Aquaduct and Beidler Mansion (Berks County Parks Department) Daniel Boone Homestead (PHMC and Friends of Daniel Boone Homestead) Historic Joanna Furnace (Hay Creek Valley Historical Association) Old Morlatton Village: 4 sites (Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County) Thomas Rutter Mansion and Pine Forge Industrial Site (Pine Forge Historical Society) These historic resources are of highest priority to the HBW. This does not imply that they are more significant historically or architecturally than other Class I historic resources found within or nearby the HBW. As publically accessible museum sites, these historic resources complement Hopewell Village NHS and the larger conservation, recreation, education, and tourism goals of the HBW. As non-profit heritage/museum sites, they are of high educational value. The extensive park-like grounds associated with these resources contribute to the HBW’s forest and provide open space for recreation. Both the grounds and the historic sites themselves attract visitors and tourists. These heritage sites and Hopewell Village NHS are advised to work together to develop a regional selfguided “Heritage Trail” or “Heritage Tour.” Obvious connections are the iron industry and transportation heritage. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 127 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Regarding Historic Preservation and support for identified critical Prioritized Historic and Cultural Resources, they all face the same threats: Neglect, industrialization, sprawl, lack of funds, inadequate zoning laws at the ground level to protect them, lack of education regarding the importance of safeguarding our historic resources, and indifference. The bottom line is: Mitigation and Remediation is to found at the ground or municipal level. Ordinary citizens need to have the “will” to preserve our past! It is the needed “first step!” BIBLIOGRAPHY County of Berks/Municipal Publications Berks County Comprehensive Plan, 2001-2002 “Berks Vision 2020” Berks County Comprehensive Plan, 2012 (draft) “Berks Vision 2030” Berks County Historic and Cultural Resource Survey/Inventory, 1983, Update 2006-2007 Berks County Greenway Park and Recreation Plan, 2007 Hay Creek Watershed Greenway Plan, 2007 Southern Berks Regional Joint Comprehensive Plan, 2004 “Union Township, Robeson Township, Caernarvon Township, Borough of Birdsboro” Joint Comprehensive Plan, 2003 “Lower Alsace Township, Mt Penn Borough” Joint Comprehensive Plan, 2005 “Exeter Township, Amity Township, St Lawrence Borough” Joint Comprehensive Plan, 2008 “Oley Township, Alsace Township, Ruscombmanor Township” Excel Files: Survey of Historic Resources of Berks County Pennsylvania, 1984, Update 2006. Amity, Exeter, Douglass, Union, Robeson, Caernarvon Townships, Birdsboro Borough. Berks County Planning Commission County of Berks, Recorder of Deeds- Land Records County of Berks, Wills and Estate Records including Orphan’s Court and Administrative Records County of Berks, Taxables 1752- 1790 Reading Area Transportation Study, Minutes of the Technical Committee Meeting July 12, 2012. Business From the Floor, Dr. James Thorne. Concerning the Proposed Mascaro Raceway in Union Township and its negative environmental impacts. Books Oley Valley Heritage: The Colonial Years 1700-1775, Philip E. Pendleton, 1994 Coventry “The Skool Kill District”1700-1810, Estelle Cremers and Pamela Shenk, 2003 Architecture of Chester County, Margaret Berwind Schiffer, 1984 Southeastern Berks County, Patricia Wanger Smith, 2006 Journey Through Our Land, W. Edmunds Claussen, 1970 Poole Forge: Pioneers Along the Manatawny, W.E. Claussen, 1968 Historical and Biographical Annals of Berks County, Morton L. Montgomery, 1884 The Ford at the Schuylkill, Kathy M. Scogna, 1998 The Story of Berks County, F.W. Balthaser, 1925, Reprinted 2002 The Berks County Story, 1953 Indian Paths of Pennsylvania, A.W. Wallace, 1998 History of the Conestoga Turnpike, S.H. Quillman A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 128 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Pennsylvania Iron Manufacture in the Eighteenth Century, Arthur Cecil Bining, Reprint 1987 The Iron Industry in Pennsylvania, Gerald G. Eggart, 1994 Hopewell Village, Joseph E. Walker, 1966 NPS Historic Handbook Hopewell Village NHS America’s Valley Forges and Valley Furnaces, J. Lawrence Pool The Schuylkill Navigation, Harry L. Rinker Exeter Township: The Forgotten Corner, 225th Anniversary, 1966, Anniversary Committee Newspaper Articles Natural Lands Trust: “Property Once Slated for Development Becomes Nature Preserve,” July 24, 2012 Reading Eagle: “Green Hills Preserve a Win For All Residents of Berks,” August 6, 2012 Natural Lands Trust: “French Creek State park Wildfire,” April 10, 2012 Philadelphia Inquirer: “In Chesco Town, Opposition Helped Stop Proposed Gas Line,” March 12, 2013 The Reporter: “Chester County Marcellus Gas Pipeline Opponents Draw a Crowd in Warwick, March 2013 Daily Local News: “Alternate Natural Gas Pipeline Route Offered Through County,” March 28, 2013 Reading Eagle: “Right Through the Heart,” February 27, 2013 Reading Eagle: Your Community “New Developer Wants to Take Over Project in Union Township” January 25, 2013 Reading Eagle: “Gas Pipeline Project Quiet; Critics Not So,” February 21, 2013 Reading Eagle: “Workshop Will Spotlight Potential Pipeline in Berks,” March 6, 2013 Reading Eagle: “Jacob Morgan” November 19, 1967 Maps Berks County Maps 1856, 1862, 1876 1862 Berks County Map: Union Township, Amity Township, Douglass Township, Baumstown Historical Map Works Historical Sites of Reading and Berks County PA George M. Meiser, IX, 1976 Warranty and Patent Maps, Counties of Berks and Chester Hopewell Big Woods Map and Guide Exeter Township Historical Site Map USGS Maps http://www.usgwarchives.org/maps/pa/county/berks/usgs/ Hope Big Woods Partnership Map http://www.rpa.org/northeastlandscapes/maps/800/834InitiativeMapBook_73.png Periodicals and Articles “Opportunity Knocks” Open Space as a Community Investment by Michael Frank The Heritage Conservancy 2000 “Ironmaster William Bird 1706-1761” by Terry L. Lester, Linton Research Fund, Inc. 1992 “Mark Bird 1738-1812” by Terry L. Lester, Linton Research Fund, Inc., 1992 “The Morgan Homestead” Tri-County Historical Society, 2009 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 129 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Caernarvon Township: Globalization of Morgantown and Elverson, Pa., Thesis by Lynn Gernegan, 2004 “The Town of Brower” by Susan Miller-Speros, Historical Review of Berks County, Winter 2006-2007 “The Hans Martin Gohrig House Colonial Landmark in Danger” by Michelle Lynch based on the research of James Lewars, Historical Review of Berks County, Spring 2003 Canal Resources Appraisal Book Lock 51 Birdsboro Files, c.1890 Appraisal Schuylkill Navigation Company Canal for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Schuylkill Navigation Maps at RACC The Schuylkill Navigation by Harry L. Rinker PHMC and Other Government Documents and Publications PHMC: Pennsylvania Historic Resource Survey Forms, Bureau for Historic Preservation PHMC: Cultural Resources Data Base PHMC: NRHP Structures in Berks County PA www.philadelphiabuildings.org PHMC: Berks County NRHP Mill List Application and Registration, Multi Structure Nomination for NRHP 1990 PHMC: “Village of Browertown/Unionville Historic District” A Proposal for A Historic District by Susan Miller-Speros Hopewell Furnace NHS Records, Historical Database French Creek State Park, PA Department of Conservation and Natural Resources 2007 Lebanon County Comprehensive Plan, Historic Resources Profile Secretary of Interior’s Standards and Guidelines (As Amended and Annotated) Archaeology and Historic Preservation www.nps.gov PA Census Records, County of Berks 1752-1860 St Gabriel’s Church Records, Douglassville, PA Lancaster County Planning Commission, Heritage Planning Division Pennsylvania MPC, NR Historic District “Iron and Steel Tours” Iron and Steel Heritage Partnership, National Park Service c/o Hopewell Big Woods and Natural Lands Trust Publications National Parks Service Assists Recreation Plan for the Hopewell Big Woods 2008 Parks For the People: A Student Competition to Reimagine America’s National Parks Hopewell html Hopewell Big Woods Partnership Hopewell Big Woods Project. Natural Lands Trust. Land Conservation in the Greater Philadelphia Area (www.natlands.org) Hopewell Big Woods: Monitoring, Evaluation, and Adaptive Management Plan December 2011 The Pennsylvania Highlands Conservation Atlas 2006 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 130 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Websites www.co.berks.pa.us (Union Township Berks County PA: About Union Township: History) http://www.nationalregisterofhistoricplaces.com/pa/Berks/state.html www.natlands.org www.haycreek.org (Joanna Furnace) www.oldindustry.org (Hay Creek, Joanna Furnace) http://www.historicpreservationtrust.org/ http://files.usgwarchives.net/pa/berks/cemeteries/zions002.txt (Burials at Robeson AKA Zion Friend’s Meeting House Cemetery Diana Quinones, PA Gen Web Project) http://www.findagrave.com/ (Robeson Lutheran Church “Plow Church”) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robeson_Township,_Berks_County,_Pennsylvania http://www.co.berks.pa.us/Muni/Robeson/Pages/Default.aspx http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Union_Township,_Berks_County,_Pennsylvania http://www.co.berks.pa.us/Muni/Union/Pages/Default.aspx http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caernarvon_Township,_Berks_County,_Pennsylvania http://www.caernarvon.org/history/background.html http://www.caernarvon.org/ http://www.ushistory.org/philadelphia/street_conestoga.htm (“Old Conestoga Road”) http://www.achp.gov/docs/economic-impacts-of-historic-preservation-study.pdf (“Measuring Economic Impacts of Historic Preservation.” Advisory Council on Historic Preservation. Donovan Rypkema and Caroline Cheong, Place Economics, Washington, DC, and Randall Mason, PhD, University of Pennsylvania School of Design, Historic Preservation Program.) http://www.endlessmountainsheritage.org/upload/HeritagePA%20Economic%20Impact%20Stud y%20Preliminary%20Summary%202008.pdf (Heritage Tourism Spending in Pennsylvania Heritage Areas: Creating Jobs and Spurring Local Economic Activity, Heritage PA, 2008) http://www.bahrsmill.org/ http://www.exetertownship.com/Pages/Home.aspx http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exeter_Township,_Berks_County,_Pennsylvania http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amity_Township,_Berks_County,_Pennsylvania http://www.amitytownshippa.com/ http://www.douglasstownship.org/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglass_Township,_Berks_County,_Pennsylvania http://www.montcopa.org/DocumentCenter/View/4473 (Popodickon Manor) www.nps.gov http://www.nps.gov/hps/tps/standguide/ http://www.nps.gov/nr/publications/bulletins/nrb15/ http://www.nps.gov/history/nr/publications/ http://ia700208.us.archive.org/1/items/pineforgeironpla00lava/pineforgeironpla00lava.pdf (“Pine Forge Iron Plantation: History, Building Chronology and Recommendations for Preservation” Historic Preservation Graduate Thesis by Melissa Pilar LaValley) http://articles.philly.com/2013-04-18/news/38619215_1_native-americans-iron-workers (“Preserving Pine Forge Mansion” by Edward Colimore, Philadelphia Inquirer, April 18, 2013) http://www.newpa.com/business/key-industries/tourism http://www.phmc.state.pa.us/bah/dam/rg/di/r17-522WarranteeTwpMaps http://www.mapsofpa.com/atlaslist.htm A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 131 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods http://explorepahistory.com/regions_hershey.php http://www.archaeologydude.com/2011_06_01_archive.html http://www.co.berks.pa.us/Dept/Parks/Pages/AlleghenyAqueductHistoricalPark.aspx http://millpictures.com/mills.php?millid=806 http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:John_Bishop_House.JPG Other NAACP “The Underground Railroad in the 19th Century” Misty Dorne “African Americans at Hopewell Furnace” Hopewell Furnace NHS Document “Birdsboro: An Iron and Steel Town Then and Now” Historical Walking Tour By the Birdsboro Historical Society Caernarvon Township History, Published by Caernarvon Township, 2006 Federal Census 1790: Caernarvon Township Excerpts from the History of Lancaster County: Caernarvon Township Dr. Fred Klein 1924 Morgantown Historic District, Caernarvon Township Berks Living Places, The Gombach Group 1997-2013 Local Historians, Preservation Professionals, and Other Experts Consulted Hilary Fraley Brad Kissam James Lewars George M. Meiser, IX Philip Pendleton Leslie Rebmann Laurence Ward A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 132 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Biographies Susan Speros is an award winning author and museum professional on the Interpretive Services staff at the Berks County Heritage Center, a historic interpretive complex with two museums on site, where she does historic interpretive programming and interpretation. The Heritage Center is part of the Berks County Parks and Recreation Department. In addition, she is a living historian, and performs open hearth cooking demonstrations and fiber interpretation, and Colonial era dancing with an interpretive dance troupe "The Amity Colonial Dancers," at various historic sites. She is an avid and active historic preservationist, serving as a Director of the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County. She is also a former Trustee of the Historical Society of Berks County, and former Board member of the Genealogical Society of Berks County, and the Tri-County Historical Society. In addition, she wrote the proposal for a Historic District in Unionville/Browertown, and actively participated in the updating of the Historical and Cultural Resources of Berks County, particularly municipalities in Southeastern Berks, and participated in producing "The Berks County Greenway Park and Recreation Plan 2007." With Michelle Lynch, she composes the annual commemorative booklet for the Historical Society of Berks County’s 4 Centuries in Berks Historic Properties Tour. Her articles have been published in the Historical Review of Berks County and other journals. She has degrees in Anthropology and Historic Travel and Tourism. Michelle Napoletano Lynch holds a bachelor’s degree with a double major in historic preservation and American studies. She interned with the Berks County Conservancy’s nowdefunct historic preservation program and served for eight years as the Historic Preservation Specialist for the City of Reading. She was editor of the Historical Society of Berks County quarterly journal, The Historical Review of Berks County, from autumn 2002 through winter 2012. She is a former trustee of Centre Park Historic District, Inc., a former member of the Exeter Township Historical Commission, and a former trustee of the Historical Society of Berks County. She currently serves on the boards of the Historic Preservation Trust of Berks County and the Charles Evans Cemetery. She lectures on topics of Berks County’s history and architecture and leads walking tours of historic neighborhoods and graveyards in Reading and Berks. She performs as a living historian, interpreting well-known and forgotten women of different centuries, who share a connection to Berks County history. With Susan Speros, she composes the annual commemorative booklet for the Historical Society of Berks County’s 4 Centuries in Berks Historic Properties Tour. Her articles have been published in the Historical Review and other journals. She writes a weekly feature, Floor Plans, focusing on interesting country homes and the people who live in them, for Berks Country in the Wednesday Reading Eagle. A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 133 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Appendix A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 134 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Maps Maps from the Berks County Atlas of 1862 Surveyed by L. Fagan, Published by H. Brigens, Philadelphia, 1862 A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 135 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Caernarvon and Robeson Townships A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 136 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Union, Amity, and Douglass Townships A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 137 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Exeter, Oley, and Amity Townships A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 138 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Hopewell Big Woods Maps A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 139 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 140 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 141 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 142 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 143 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 144 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 145 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 146 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 147 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 148 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 149 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 150 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 151 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods Articles A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 152 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 153 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 154 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 155 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 156 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 157 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 158 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 159 Prioritizing Berks County Cultural and Historical Resources Within and Nearby the Hopewell Big Woods A Study for the Friends of Hopewell Furnace NHS Page 160