REALNET® TOp 10 YTD* ApARTmENT TRANSAcTIONS IN ThE GTA, GcA AND
Transcription
REALNET® TOp 10 YTD* ApARTmENT TRANSAcTIONS IN ThE GTA, GcA AND
Annual 2014 / Issue 10 REALNET® Top 10 YTD* Apartment Transactions in the GTA, GCA and GVA Top Transaction Report by Market PP 08-09 Save the Date Quebec Apartment Investment Conference February 10, 2015 Palais des congrès de Montréal Canadian Apartment Investment Conference September 17, 2015 Metro Toronto Convention Centre, North Building www.realestateforums.com 04 Wise Dollars Steady Growth 12 Old Stock New Opportunities 14 View from a Third-Generation Investor UNRIVALED TALENT. UNMATCHED RESULTS. Ontario Toronto David Montressor* 416 815 2332 [email protected] Local Knowledge National Reach Waterloo Region London 519 340 2317 [email protected] 519 286 2013 [email protected] Martin Cote* Quebec Montreal Benoit Poulin 514 905 2142 benoit.poulin @cbre.com Nico Zentil* Manitoba Alberta Montreal Winnipeg 514 906 0891 [email protected] 204 943 5700 [email protected] Marc Hetu Ottawa Kevin W. MacDougall* Trevor Clay 613 788 2708 [email protected] Calgary Grant Potter 403 750 0528 [email protected] CBRE’s National Apartment Group is comprised of 16 dedicated professionals in 10 offices across Canada with over $8.0 billion sold. Alberta Edmonton Bradley Gingerich 780 917 4626 [email protected] Edmonton Edmonton 780 229 4689 [email protected] 780 229 4691 [email protected] Cody Nelson British Columbia Vancouver David Ho 604 662 5168 [email protected] Paul Chaput Edmonton Bradyn Arth 780 917 4649 [email protected] Nova Scotia Vancouver Halifax 604 662 5141 [email protected] 902 492 2085 [email protected] Lance Coulson Chris Carter Halifax Robert Mussett 902 492 2065 [email protected] * Sales Representative This disclaimer shall apply to CBRE Limited, Real Estate Brokerage, and to all other divisions of the Corporation (“CBRE”). The information set out herein, including, without limitation, any projections, images, opinions, assumptions and estimates obtained from third parties (the “Information”) has not been verified by CBRE, and CBRE does not represent, warrant or guarantee the accuracy, correctness and completeness of the Information. CBRE does not accept or assume any responsibility or liability, direct or consequential, for the Information or the recipient’s reliance upon the Information. The recipient of the Information should take such steps as the recipient may deem necessary to verify the Information prior to placing any reliance upon the Information. The Information may change and any property described in the Information may be withdrawn from the market at any time without notice or obligation to the recipient from CBRE. CBRE and the CBRE logo are the service marks of CBRE Limited and/or its affiliated or related companies in other countries. All other marks displayed on this document are the property of their respective owners. All Rights Reserved. cbre.ca/nag-canada CONTENTS 03 Message from the 2014 Canadian Apartment Investment Conference Co-Chairs 04 Wise Dollars, Steady Growth 06 Immigration and Urbanization Increase Rentals 10 The Retrofit Opportunity 06 New Ways to Build New 08 REALNET Top 10 YTD Apartment Transactions in the GTA, GCA and GVA ® * A Message from the 2014 Canadian Apartment Investment Conference Co-Chairs Many investors consider the multiresidential asset class to be a safe haven. Like all markets, though, it has its quirks and unexpected turns. Steven Gross, Managing Partner, Real Estate Investments Romspen Investment Corporation Sandy Mandel, President, Sanford Mandel & Associates Inc. Demographics have supported the rental industry over the past ten years, particularly with the echo-boom generation bolstering demand. As the millennials advance into the next phases of their lives, it remains to be seen what living choices they will make and if they will have the means or the inclination to rent apartments. Could a bigger opportunity come from the older-boomer/empty-nester generation? While a lifelong homeownership mentality will be a challenge, leading edge operators will have to figure out how to target their marketing and educate this rapidly growing cohort about the financial and lifestyle advantages of renting versus ownership. On the ownership side, there’s no ignoring the industry’s growing number of institutional players. Yet the old-school and up-and-coming private investors 12 Old Stock, New Opportunities 14 View from a Third-Generation Investor continue to be a force. While some private owners are more in tune than others when it comes to elevating their game, the institutionalization of this asset class has put pressure on all to keep pace. On the investment side, as always, there is never enough product to acquire. Investors are looking at building, intensification or pure development sites, as a means toward growing best-in-class portfolios. Others are exploring adding value by modernizing, repositioning or converting suites. Is consolidation on the horizon? What will drive value next? If cap rates can only go so low, the focus will shift to operations and NOI. However, since much of the low hanging fruit has been harvested, many building owners have streamlined operations, retrofitted and upgraded building systems, implemented management best-practices and become savvy marketers. One has to ask where are the next opportunities? One thing upon which we can all agree on is that multi-residential properties are small communities, intrinsically exciting and constantly changing as a result of dynamic internal and external factors. ¡ Steven Gross and Sandy Mandel Editor & Designer Conferences Advertisement Inquiries Michel Rémy & Vivien Lin For more information on our Conferences, visit our website at www.realestateforums.com Frank Scalisi Director of Sponsorship and Advertising Sales T: 416-512-3815 E: [email protected] ©2014 Informa Canada Inc. Disclaimer: The views, opinions, positions or strategies expressed by the authors and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions or strategies of Informa Canada. 3 CAPREIT - The Marker Wise dollars - steady growth Tom Schwartz, President and CEO, CAPREIT Tom Schwartz is often asked what was the magic that created CAPREIT, one of the Canada’s most successful real estate investment trusts. The company’s President and CEO speaks with a calm that baffles the sceptics, and a confidence that comes with 4 building a large company through years of strategic, low risk investments. Tom summarizes CAPREIT’s success this way: “We’ve got tremendous low cost of capital, tremendous economies of scale, and we can take advantage of those economies.” A landlord committed to its tenants, CAPREIT is also environmentally progressive and finding new success thanks to its energy management programs. And, in a move that’s arousing much interest in the market, the company recently sponsored a REIT in Ireland. CAPREIT originated during the recession, when Schwartz couldn’t get financing as a developer. “The original REITs all came out of that period,” he says. “We were all little guys at a time when the big companies all came down because of their very heavy debt loads, even though their real estate was the best in the world. We were the evolution, the newcomers with the much more conservative capital structure.” Tom will never forget the lessons of that time. Today, a career based on carefully planned decisions allows him to calmly face what some see as challenges. Competition from the condo market? The wide price gap has made apartments more obviously affordable and had a positive impact on CAPREIT. Predictions of another recession? “We generally benefit in a recession,” Schwartz says. “People stay in the rentals longer and don’t jump into home ownership.” Nor is he too concerned about competition from pension funds. In his experience, while the players keep changing, multifamily has always been competitive and always will be. “Apartments are a great investment, an easy entry business. Five doctors can get together and buy an apartment building on a weekend.” ¡ Michelle Morra-Carlisle Canadian Apartment Investment Report / September 2014 Immigration and urbanization increase rentals Benjamin Tal, Deputy Chief Economist, CIBC World Markets Inc. New Ways to Build New David Bloomstone, Director, TD Securities Inc. Let’s face it, the 40 to 50-year-old buildings in the traditional rental market now offer limited supply and bring major cap-ex to prospective investors. That is why for the first time in a long while, many large institutional pension funds are considering new construction of not only condos but purpose-built rental projects too. David adds, of course there are other alternatives to 6 “Young people are gravitating to downtown cities now more than ten or fifteen years ago and immigration will continue to be a major demand driver for condos and apartments,” says Benjamin Tal, CIBC World Markets Deputy Chief Economist. “We are more sensitive to the risk of higher interest rates than any other time in history, but they need to start rising, probably in May 2015,” said Tal. “The actual increase will be moderate and it will take time, so the impact will not be immediate.” “Not only will the demand for condos and apartments continue to rise, but the propensity to rent will be higher than ever before.” Meanwhile, Tal advises as the global economy improves, exports and investment can compensate for lackluster domestic spending and building activity. To encourage exports, however, the Bank of Canada must weaken the dollar by keeping interest rates low. Current economic factors also benefit the market. A high level of household debt means limited growth in consumer spending and a significant lack of supply in new housing and the resale market. In this situation, the apartment and condo market plays an important stabilizing force that might be disrupted if interest rates rise. buying old buildings. In another recent trend, investors that don’t necessarily have deep pockets are building on excess land on their existing sites, where the land is effectively free. In the GTA, highrise concrete buildings with numerous amenities are successfully rivalling the condo market. David Bloomstone, Director of TD Securities Inc., is seeing this type of activity among his clients in high-end locations such as Forest Hill, for example, as well as in the downtown core. “But you can also build in the Ontario market at a cheaper cost and still make the numbers make sense,” he says, “in the secondary markets like Kitchener and London where they’re constructing low-rise ‘stick built’ types of buildings, or in some cases slightly higher-rise wood frame projects.” It goes without saying that markets out West with strong employment and growth have taken off in recent years. In terms of purpose-built multiresidential construction, thousands of units are being built in Calgary and Edmonton. Canada’s East Coast is also experiencing a similar phenomenon The circle means that we are likely to see “low interest rates for a long time.” ¡ Tracey Arial thanks to jobs created by the Irving Shipbuilding contract. If developers have anything to worry about in the upcoming year, it’s likely either the possibility of an interest rate hike or rising construction costs. “Of course,” Bloomstone says, “higher interest rates come on the heels of improving the economy with inflation, which can help your rents at the end of the day.” ¡ Michelle Morra-Carlisle Download the Mobile App Access all 22 of our events in once place. BlackBerry download instructions visit: www.realestateforums.com/mobile to access the web app. Sponsored By Canadian Apartment Investment Report / September 2014 ® Peoples’ Trust Ad - Middle & CAIC Onsite Insert REALNET® Top 10 YTD* Apartment Transactions in the GTA, GCA and GVA Rank Municipality Address Total Price # of Units Cap Rate Purchaser Broker(s) 1 Markham 7411 Yonge St. $71,250,000 380 5.0% Starlight Investments Ltd. D Montressor, CBRE Limited 2 Toronto 295 Dufferin St. $45,000,000 200 4.3% Starlight Investments Ltd. D Montressor, CBRE Limited 3 Milton 611 Farmstead Dr. $38,500,000 104 4.3% Regal Lifestyles 4 Toronto 230 Oak St. $38,000,000 327 5 Aurora 145 Wellington St. W. $34,750,000 204 5.6% Akelius Fastigheter AB D Lieberman, J Hittner, Avison Young Starlight Investments Ltd. D Montressor, CBRE Limited Seasons Retirement Communities 6 Clarington 65 Clarington Blvd. $26,575,000 112 7 York 230 Woolner Ave. $21,850,000 260 8 Georgina 15 The Queensway S. $19,127,323 97 9 Toronto 680 Roselawn Ave. $17,250,000 64 10 Toronto 2663 Lake Shore Blvd. W. $14,000,000 112 Municipality Address Total Price # of Units 1 Calgary 120 2nd Ave. S.W. $17,642,545 129 2 Calgary 1505 23rd Ave. S.W. $5,900,000 11 Paragon Capital Corporation Ltd. 3 Canmore 110 Montane Rd. $4,600,000 20 110 Montane Capital Corp. 4 Calgary 516 18th Ave. S.W. $3,500,000 11 W. Chan Investments Ltd. 5 Calgary 203 6th Ave. N.E. $2,480,000 14 Avanti Housing Inc. 6 Calgary 318 14th Ave. S.W. $2,250,000 18 Mainstreet Equity Corp. M Fleming, Michael Fleming Realty Corporation; B Dhillon, RE/MAX 7 Calgary 810 Drury Ave. N.E. $1,900,000 11 Rainbow Motor Inn Macklin Ltd. L Scarcelli, N Libzo, Sutton Group Canwest Vista; C Zaharko, Royal LePage Foothills 8 Calgary 1737 26th Ave. S.W. $1,900,000 12 1807964 Alberta Ltd. 9 Calgary 4503 73rd St. N.W. $1,900,000 17 Vista Group Inc. 10 Calgary 1537 14th Ave. S.W. $1,826,000 15 Alston Properties Ltd. Municipality Address Total Price # of Units Cap Rate 1 North Vancouver 151 East Keith Rd. $25,500,000 88 3.4% 2 Vancouver 6347 West Blvd. $11,000,000 22 3 Vancouver 1009 West 10th Ave. $11,000,000 41 4 Abbotsford 2929 Tims St. $10,300,000 108 5 Vancouver 1075 Nelson St. $9,000,000 24 6 Vancouver 555 East 6th Ave. $8,880,000 7 Vancouver 2394 Cornwall Ave. $8,500,000 20 8 Vancouver 1137 Bute St. $8,100,000 33 9 North Vancouver 170 West 4th St. $7,000,000 36 10 Vancouver 2182 West 39th Ave. $6,873,500 21 Rank Rank 5.9% An individual(s) acting in his/ her own capacity L Wallace, RE/MAX Unique Inc. Housing York Inc. 3.3% O'Shanter Development Company Ltd. D Bloomstone, J Ziegel, I Saksznajder, TD Securities Royal York Shores (2663) Inc. Cap Rate Purchaser Broker(s) 1159646 Alberta Ltd. 4.0% P Dave, RE/MAX Complete Commercial Purchaser Broker(s) Starlight Apartments D Goodman, M Goodman, HQ Real Estate Services West Boulevard Property Ltd. C Anderson, A Fergusson, Cushman & Wakefield Ltd. 0992980 B.C. Ltd. D Schulz, MacDonald Commercial Mainstreet Equity Corp. Wall Financial Corp. D Taylor, Colliers International Property Consultants Inc. G & M Enterprises Ltd. M.A. Cedar Place Properties Ltd. J Tang, B Harding, T Harding, NAI Commercial 1004905 B.C. Ltd. C Wieser, R Greer, M Hannah, Avison Young 4.2% Eduardo Holdings Ltd. P McEvay, B Goold, RE/MAX Bill Goold 3.7% AP Yew Investment Ltd. B Goold, P McEvay, J Blair, RE/MAX Bill Goold Realty 2.7% * Year to Date (YTD) January 1, 2014 - August 25, 2014 8 Canadian Apartment Investment Report / September 2014 Top 10 GTA Apartment Transactions - YTD 2014 Top 10 GCA Apartment Transactions - YTD 2014 Source: RealNet Canada Inc. Top 10 GVA Apartment Transactions - YTD 2014 Source: RealNet Canada Inc. Source: RealNet Canada Inc. Building a Better Canadian Property Market Together Looking to Buy, Build, Improve, Sell, or Finance in the Apartment Sector? • • • Make better informed decisions—search and analyze the most comprehensive Apartment Sector property sale and listings research across Canada Use research details to make better connections with qualified brokers, buyers, sellers and lenders Identify and take advantage of emerging trends with our unique perspective on the interconnectedness of the Commercial Investment and Residential Development Markets With REALNET®, your response time drops to minutes, your productivity increases ten-fold, your confidence is strengthened and your competition is left further behind. Let us help you get started, contact: Jason Lo VP, Sales & Client Services | TEL: 416 596 7676 x250 | [email protected] 9 The Retrofit Opportunity Sarah Gray, Project Principal, Halsall Associates (a Parsons Brinkerhoff company) Recent safety concerns have put garage, balcony, elevator and generator upgrades on the must-do list says Halsall Project Principal Sarah Gray. of code and local property standards? What are the should-do’s in terms of maintenance when putting together a capital plan?” Owners like to focus on interior upgrades, window replacement and energy-use reduction, but Gray often begins her inspections by documenting visible deterioration – such as loose concrete on garage ceilings – that may lead to public safety risks. Engineers also recommend opening up interior plaster and drywall to determine whether structural walls are made of concrete block or steel studs behind a brick veneer. The latter construction was popular in the 70s and 80s, but it can hide interior leaks and possible water damage, says Gray. “We want to make sure that water hasn’t been getting into the wall and corroding the studs.” The engineering consultant helps the owners of older buildings create multi-year plans for upgrades, repairs and maintenance. After identifying the structure of the building, Gray inspects elevators, generators, roofs and balcony railings to flag potential safety concerns and any needed repairs. She advises that too often landlords avoid maintaining these areas. “What are the major concerns? What are the must-dos in terms “I would say that rental property owners often defer fixing garages and balconies 10 because these things are just not sexy,” says the Toronto-based engineer. “Repairs claims are really disruptive to residents; and owners don’t get immediately visible returns after these types of jobs are done.” Gray encourages property owners to consider basic structural necessities as opportunities and claims that investments in these can really pay off. Using a building with balconies as an example, she proposes that railings that must be retrofitted to conform to height and gap restrictions can benefit from upgrading the look at the same time. In this instance, not only is the landlord conforming to regulations, in modernizing the building too they can anticipate attracting better tenants. “If you’re going to make a balcony conform, that gives you an opportunity to add some curb appeal.” Balconies that are safe combined with bright tidy garages make tenants feel good. Happy Tenants = Happy Landlord! ¡ Tracey Arial Canadian Apartment Investment Report / September 2014 COI 001 RHB Ad_v2_Layout 1 7/25/14 9:55 AM Page 1 WE TAKE THE HASSLE OUT OF LAUNDRY ROOMS. Unfortunately not the sorting, separating or folding though. For over 65 years, Coinamatic has been the leading provider of multi-housing laundry services in Canada offering premium coin vended and smart card-activated laundry services. Contact us and see what we can do for your facility. (1-877-755-5302) • [email protected] • www.coinamatic.com Old stock new Opportunities Robert Geremia, President, Boardwalk REIT After 30 years of strictly buying and refurbishing buildings, Boardwalk Real Estate Investment Trust has only recently begun to build and develop properties. The company saw an opportunity in some of its multi-family projects that were built in the mid to late 70s and had a lot of extra density. resulting in better returns for us as well,” Geremia says. “One in particular that we selected was in Calgary, where we were able to open up some ground between two of our buildings and put a building in between,” says Boardwalk’s President, Roberto Geremia. The company even partnered with the government of Alberta to provide affordable housing within the new building. With experience, a real estate company can also recognize opportunity in challenges. Sometimes the market presents obstacles for REITS that, like Boardwalk, classify themselves as “fixed income” and must compete against yield return types of investments. Meanwhile, giving new life to old buildings remains an exciting prospect, especially in Canada where so many apartment buildings were built 40+ years ago. As the condominium market accommodates new needs for renters, rental units are following suit. Party rooms in older buildings, for example, are now being retrofitted into gyms. “The condo upper scale development is actually forcing us to provide more common area amenities which are “In a fixed income kind of market, you’re not really trading on the underlying asset value of the portfolio in general,” Geremia says, adding that in REITs in general, the actual share price of trading is well above the implied private market net asset value of the company. “We’ve taken advantage of that,” he says. “We’ve sold some of our projects to the private market — which will pay much more than the public market — and are currently buying back our stock.” ¡ Michelle Morra-Carlisle Boardwalk REIT 12 Canadian Apartment Investment Report / September 2014 Disciplined Visionaries In Real Estate Asset Management Starlight Investments is one of Canada’s most dynamic real estate investment and asset management companies. Managed by a proven team of disciplined visionaries, our property portfolio encompasses more than 27,500 high quality multi-family units and two million square feet of commercial space across Canada and the southeastern United States. We strategically seek growth by acquiring single properties, portfolios and both private and public real estate entities. Starlight only invests where we believe we can efficiently and effectively create value for our investors, and we take a significant ownership stake in every property we manage to align with our investors in successfully creating value and maximizing returns. To learn more, visit www.starlightinvest.com or contact us at [email protected] Starlight Investments Ltd. 401 The West Mall, Suite 1100, Toronto, Ontario (416) 234-8444 View from a third-generation investor Multi-family real estate has no shortage of buyers. Even low cap rates are apparently no deterrent to pension fund, private equity and private investors. Unlike office, retail and industrial properties that mostly appeal to institutions, multi-family has long attracted private buyers. Mark Zolty, Managing Director, Brass Enterprises Mark Zolty is a third-generation real estate investor who learned from his father and grandfather. In his teens he saw multi-family (then called “apartments”) as a The Experienced Lawyers You Can Count On Aird & Berlis LLP has extensive expertise in all aspects of the rental housing industry. From acquisitions, dispositions and financing, redevelopment and intensification, to tax and regulatory matters, we provide seamless, timely and cost-effective practical solutions to your multi-residential property issues. more personal, mom-and-pop type of business, but says it became “a lot more about trading cash flows than actually buying buildings.” Today Mark is Managing Director of Brass Enterprises and works primarily in secondary U.S. cities in Texas and Southern Florida mostly suburban settings. There, tenant needs are very different from those in Canada. “Properties need to be a lot more highly amenitized,” he says. “Where people live is much more of a lifestyle rather than just a place to put their furniture in and sleep.” He considers that environment a stark contrast to Canadian development, which is largely about condos. “I don’t think [Canadian] municipalities are focused on multi-family but on how to get the quick development dollars,” he says. “But as soon as you have a change in development policy you’re going to see a big change in how people live in apartments.” Is a third-gen investor better equipped to handle risk? Zolty thinks so. Members of his family have seen various cycles and learned from each other’s experiences. “A lot of the newer players in the multi-family space haven’t seen the worst of times,” he says. “We have!” Robert Doumani [email protected] · 416.865.3060 ¡ Michelle Morra-Carlisle Tom Halinski [email protected] · 416.865.7767 Thank You to our Advertisers airdberlis.com Brookfield Place, 181 Bay Street Suite 1800, Box 754 Toronto, ON M5J 2T9 14 Aird & Berlis LLP IFC CBRE Limited National Apartment Group 05 Centurion Asset Management Inc 11 Coinamatic Canada OBC First National Financial 10Minto 07 Peoples Trust 09RealNet 13 14 Starlight Investments Canadian Apartment Investment Report / September 2014 Information To build on Canada’s Leading Annual Real Estate Conferences Take Advantage of Our Upcoming Events October 2014 RealLeasing October 7, 2014 Metro Toronto Convention Centre, North Building Ottawa Real Estate Forum October 9, 2014 Ottawa Conference & Event Centre Calgary Real Estate Forum October 23, 2014 Calgary TELUS Convention Centre Vancouver Real Estate Leasing Conference October 29, 2014 Vancouver Conference Centre West December 2014 Global Property Market December 2, 2014 Metro Toronto Convention Centre, South Building Toronto Real Estate Forum December 3 - 4, 2014 Metro Toronto Convention Centre, South Building 2015 Quebec Apartment Investment Conference February 10, 2015 Palais des congrès de Montréal Canadian Apartment Investment Conference September 17, 2015 Metro Toronto Convention Centre, North Building For details on these conferences and to register online visit www.realestateforums.com Sponsorship and advertising opportunities available. Contact Frank Scalisi: [email protected] 416-512-3815 Canadian Apartment Investment Report The magazine is published annually, coinciding with the Canadian Apartment Investment Conference in Toronto in September. An online version is available throughout the year at www.realestateforums.com About Informa Informa Canada Inc. BRINGING KNOWLEDGE TO LIFE Businesses, professionals and academics worldwide turn to Informa for unparalleled knowledge, up-to-the-minute information and highly specialist skills and services. Our ability to deliver high quality knowledge and services through multiple channels, in dynamic and rapidly changing environments, makes our offer unique and extremely valuable to individuals and organizations. www.informacanada.com Will Morris, President George Przybylowski, Vice President Mark Stephenson, Vice President 15 Robert Fleet Assistant Vice President Business Development Commercial Financing $3.2 B Ilan Barda Assistant Vice President Commercial Financing Darryl Bellwood Assistant Vice President Commercial Financing commercial loans in 2013 Do you know why? Because we focus on more than just the deal. We invest time up front to ask the right questions, visit your property and know your portfolio and growth plans. We apply ingenuity when developing financing solutions with you, relying on our broad product lineup, expertise, network and spirit to take smart risks. Most importantly, we execute. Quickly. Simply. Responsively. Every time. recent financings: cMHc 1st mortgage at 70% of purchase price High lTV bridge loan to purchase, reposition & increase rents before a cMHc takeout $44.4 million 500 units, multi-res Ottawa, ON $8.0 million 71 units, multi-res Edmonton, AB cMBS - new Product conventional 1st mortgage at 75% of purchase price $50 million CMBS loans signed 10 yr term 30 yr amortization $4.0 million 52 units, multi-res Toronto, ON VancouVer calgary firstnational.ca 604.681.5300 800.567.8711 403.509.0900 888.923.9194 ToronTo 416.593.1100 800.465.0039 MonTreal 514.499.8900 888.499.1733 Halifax 902.452.0776 Ontario Mortgage Brokerage License No. 10514