Facility Master Plan Update
Transcription
Facility Master Plan Update
WakeMed Soccer Park Page 1 Facility Master Plan Update Facility Master Plan Update FOR THE TOWN OF CARY PARKS, RECREATION, & CULTURAL RESOURCES DEPARTMENT BY INTEGRATED DESIGN, PA ARCHITECTS • ENGINEERS • PLANNERS August 2010 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 2 Facility Master Plan Update Acknowledgements Town Council Ervin Portman, "At-Large" Representative Gale Adcock, District "D" Representative Harold Weinbrecht, "Mayor" Jennifer Robinson, District "A" Representative Jack Smith, District "C" Representative Julie Aberg Robison, Mayor Pro Tem, "At-Large" Representative Don Frantz, District "B" Representative Parks, Recreation and Cultural Resources Advisory Board Jeff Boucher Robert Bush Sal Cammarata Susan Davenport Dennis Hoadley – Chair Ed Langan David Lindquist Tullie Johnson Neema Patel Kay Struffolino Athletics Committee Ed Langan Andy Mcree Jeffrey Trendel Thomas Griffin Walker Reagan Randall Bennett Pete Burke King Prather Larry Miller Ken Berry Christine Nacewicz, Teen Representative Caycee Dorrier, Teen Representative Town of Cary Staff Mary Henderson, Director, PRCR Doug McRainey, Parks Planning Manager, PRCR William Davis, Athletics Manager, PRCR Paul Kuhn, Senior Parks Planner, PRCR Keith Jenkins, Facility Manager, PRCR David Crotts, Assistant Facility Manager, PRCR Larry Dempsey, Facilities Division Manager, PW James Walters, Facilities District Coordinator, PW WakeMed Soccer Park Page 3 Facility Master Plan Update Table of Contents I Executive Summary……………………………..Page 4 II Project Overview…………………………………Page 5 III Soccer Park History……………………………...Page 6 IV User Group Data Collection……………………..Page 10 A Town of Cary SWOT Analysis B Invited User Group Forum C Group Meetings V Data Analysis Narrative………………………….Page 21 A WakeMed Soccer Stadium B Koka Booth Stadium C Park Fields D Park and Cross Country E Parking and Circulation F Future Stadium VI Implementation and Cost Estimate……………..Page 42 Appendix A1 – User Group Meeting 3.19.09 A2 – Survey Results A3 – Interview Notes A4 – Meeting minutes – Athletic Committee A5 – Meeting minutes – PRCR Advisory Board A6 - WakeMed Soccer Park Stadium Graphics WakeMed Soccer Park Page 4 Facility Master Plan Update I. Executive Summary To ensure WakeMed Soccer Park continued role as a premier soccer park and to meet its new role as a community park an updated Master Plan was developed for the facility. This Master Plan will guide the Town of Cary into the future to ensure it can continue to serve the community needs. Premier events such as the RailHawk’s, ACC & NCAA Tournaments, regional cross-country events all the way to local youth events will continue to be hosted at this facility with the implementation of this plan. Listed below is a summary of the recommendations for the facility to be implemented based on current user groups feedback: A. WakeMed Soccer Stadium 1. Expand stadium capacity to 15,000 seats, improve seating quality 2. Upgrade existing concessions 3. Install video boards 4. Develop new team room facility with multi-purpose space 5. Construct administrative offices with meeting space 6. Upgrade field lighting B. Koka Booth Stadium 1. Improve field lighting/electrical system 2. Expand seating to 1,500 seats 3. Develop new press box 4. Provide video board - portable C. Park Fields 1. Install artificial turf field conversions (fields 4,5 & 8) with lights 2. Develop new irrigation pond & continue water stewardship 3. Provide a shelter for fields 4, 5 & 8 D. Park and Cross Country Course 1. Expansion of Cross Country Course 2. Install shelter with restroom near fields 6 & 7 3. Add park comforts – wireless access, play area & public art 4. Expand maintenance facility 5. Increase signage E. Parking & Circulation 1. Pave parking lot between fields 6 & 7 2. Develop a new parking lot on south side of WakeMed Soccer Stadium 3. Upgrade circulation between WakeMed Soccer Stadium and Fields 6 & 7 4. Close south loop of existing road near stadium entrance 5. Extend Trinity Road 6. Improve pedestrian circulation and Walnut creek Greenway Improvements 7. Land expansion/future development F. Future Stadium 1. Construct a 25,000 capacity stadium WakeMed Soccer Park Page 5 Facility Master Plan Update II. Project Overview WakeMed Soccer Park is a 158 acre facility located in the Town of Cary that was originally completed in May 2002 as a regional soccer competition facility and home to the WUSA professional soccer team, the Carolina Courage. In 2004, the Town of Cary assumed management and operational responsibilities for the park. Since this time, the facility has begun a dual role as a community park as well as its original role as a premier soccer center. Today the Park is more accessible to local sports groups and near-by schools as well as the home of the Carolina Railhawks, a USL Division 1 men’s professional soccer team. During the past five years, under the direction of the Town of Cary Parks, Recreation, & Cultural Resources Department, the Park has increased the variety of user groups as well as increased the number of high caliber soccer events. As use of the Park has grown, the department has commissioned a Facility Master Plan update to reflect the changing needs of the Park and shape its future growth. In November 2008, the architects, engineers, and planners of Integrated Design, PA began work on updating the Facility Master Plan. Integrated Design was the Designer of Record for the original facility and prepared a Master Plan during the initial planning of the Park. The objectives of the Facility Master Plan Update include: To update the WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan based on the Town of Cary’s current facility management and operating goals. To develop a facility that is both a national soccer venue as well as a community-based sports park accessible to local sports groups. To define the ultimate scope and scale of the existing stadium in terms of seating capacity, seating types, and support facilities. To analyze both current and future circulation for accessing and exiting events. This analysis will include a review of the impact of the Trinity Road extension through the facility. To analyze all remaining undeveloped land area within the soccer park to maximize use of entire facility. To develop a priority list, estimated cost, and schedule of capital projects necessary to achieve the updated Master Plan. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 6 Facility Master Plan Update III. Soccer Park History Under the leadership of Cary Mayor, Koka Booth, a state owned property at the edge of the town was identified as a suitable site for a Soccer Park. Working through Wake County using the Inter-Local Agreement funded by hotel, motel, and prepared food tax, Phase IA (See Graphic) of the Soccer Park was put into motion. This phase included a 3,000 seat stadium, 5 Competition Soccer Fields, 3 Buildings, and parking for over 1,000 automobiles. In the quest for a WUSA team, Wake County increased the scope and budget of the park (again using funding from the Inter-Local Agreement) to build Phase IB (See Graphic) as part of the initial park completion. This phase increased the stadium to 5,000 seats, added two additional Competition Soccer Fields, increased the building amenities, and added parking to accommodate over 1,800 automobiles. Early Schematic of the Park (1998) During construction, the Soccer Park became the new home of the WUSA team, the Carolina Courage. Team owners of the Carolina Courage provided the funding for Phase IC, which increased the stadium to 7,000 spectators, an addition to Building A for the Team’s use, and an increase in the parking capacity to over 2,600 automobiles. Final construction on the Soccer Park’s initial phases was May 2002. In 2001 a Master Plan was completed (See Graphic) based on the Phase 1A, 1B & 1C and included a 25,000 seat stadium and support facilities. The 2001 Master Plan is the starting point for this current Master Plan. WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan Update State Capital Soccer Park – Phase IA Page 7 WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan Update State Capital Soccer Park – Phase IB Page 8 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 9 Facility Master Plan Update State Capital Soccer Park – 2001 Master Plan WakeMed Soccer Park Page 10 Facility Master Plan Update IV. User Group Data Collection In accordance with the Town of Cary’s WakeMed Soccer Park Business Plan (May 2009), the Town of Cary and Integrated Design collected input from the sports community. The purpose of collecting data from current user groups is to assist in determining planning for Capital needs and programming options. In collecting data from the current users of the Soccer Park, Integrated Design used three different sources of information. The first was a SWOT Analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) of the park conducted previously by the town staff. The second source was a invited user group forum with various community groups conducted at the Town of Cary’s Bond Park Community Center on March 19, 2009. The third source of information was a series of small group meetings and conference calls with major users of the park. A. Town of Cary SWOT Analysis Prior to the WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan Update, the Town of Cary staff conducted a SWOT Analysis (Strength, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats). The first analysis was compiled from input by Town staff members. The second analysis was compiled from input provided by staff members for the Carolina Railhawks and the third analysis was compiled from input provided from representatives of a number of the user groups that regularly rent the soccer fields as representatives of the soccer playing community. The following is the compiled lists: Town Staff SWOT Strengths Stadium Quality Athletic Field Turf Quality Professional Team Tenant Seating Size of Stadium Geographic Location Cross Country Course Number of Fields (allows multiuse) Event Reputation Huge Success of CASL Design Naming Rights Partners Weaknesses Ingress/Egress Parking for Capacity Can’t Host Large Tournaments Lack of Skyboxes Programming Lack of Lighting on Practice Fields Lack of Artificial Turf Capital Needs: Concessions Locker Rooms Meeting Space Marketing Design – Multiple Concurrent Uses WakeMed Soccer Park Page 11 Facility Master Plan Update Town Staff SWOT Strengths Park Logo Town’s Investment Opportunities Expansion Options Facility Improvements Stadium Fields Cross Country NCAA Championship City Working with CASL and other Orgs. Programming Balancing Use vs. Maintenance Community Support Lacross Cultivating Spectators Branding Master Plan Academy Programs Weaknesses Soccer Only Perception Capturing Cross Country Revenue Signage Finding Spectators for Events Threats Size of Stadium Competition from Comparable Facilities Retaining Pro Tenant Balance Maintenance vs. Use Sustainability Political Support Economy More Things to Do – Competition for People’s Time User Groups SWOT Strengths Weaknesses Quality of Fields, especially 6 & 7 Field Numbering System does not make sense Master Scheduling Process (although maybe should change Not always parking access for Fields from June to June) 6&7 Maintenance Schedule Locker Room Facilities (lack of) for Field 2 Overall running of the park is better than it has been Lack of PA system for Field 2 Communicating the philosophy / Closing for Over-seeding operating plan has improved Communication for Game Times Accessibility Flexibility with parents/siblings utilizing open fields while waiting for Mid-week games on Field #2 team (not allowed) Weather Update earlier – now is 1 hour prior, in many cases teams & opponents coming from a couple WakeMed Soccer Park Page 12 Facility Master Plan Update User Groups SWOT Strengths Opportunities More Lights Turf Fields Small Size Fields More Play on Field 3 Additional Locker Rooms Additional Fields More Ball Netting on Fields 4, 5, & 8 Open Restrooms on east side of Stadium for Fields 6 & 7 Port-A-Johns Scheduling done more consistently, keep the same groups on the same fields Add 6K course to Cross Country (Women’s Collegiate Distance) Add 8K course to Cross Country (Men’s Collegiate Distance) Weaknesses hours away and need to know earlier Threats Concessions Large Crowd Ingress/Egress Stadium Map and Way-finding Signage Lack of Video Board Number on Seats in Section 200 Worn Off Goals Outdated Lack of Team Benches Lack of Luxury Suites Lack of Covered Seats Planning – both short and long term Too muck talking, not enough followup and implementation (capital items) Need additional end zone seating Educating Stakeholders on Economic Opportunity Increase in Number of User Groups (Lack of Space) Groups from outside Cary wanting space Lack of Funding for Improvements WakeMed Soccer Park Page 13 Facility Master Plan Update Carolina Railhawks SWOT Strengths Weaknesses Stadium Signage Opportunities Field Conditions Maintenance Staff Number of Fields Opportunities Threats Concessions PDL Team operated by another group Permanent Signage Opportunities Railhawks staff members don’t Stadium Map understand the process to get Town Permanent Marquee Sign at Road authorization and funding to make Video Board capital changes to stadium TV Cameras Pointing toward If certain changes don’t happen, Press Box team may not be able to survive Canopy for Patrons in Bleachers financially Upgrade the Entertainment Value of Stadium Economic Opportunity for Town of Cary Entertainment for the Town B. Invited User Group Forum In March 2009, Integrated Design conducted a user group forum inviting the Park’s user groups to meet with the design team and the Town staff to discuss updating the Master Plan. The purpose of the forum was to bring the user groups together to continue conversations and to shape the future of the park. The user groups were introduced to the Master Plan Update with a brief history of the Soccer Park by Integrated Design with a charge: continue park improvement, be responsible stewards of tax money, and continue a great place for Wake County citizens. The users were broken up into small groups to discuss their needs and opportunities they foresee. The groups saw the strengths of the park being the quality and location of the facility and the cooperative staff running the facility. They appreciated the lighted fields (when available) and the Cross Country Course. They noted that the Cross Country Course is one of the few of this caliber around (others being in Greensboro and Charlotte), and that it was very affordable. Representatives from the Senior Games stated that the Soccer Stadium was very appropriate for their needs. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 14 Facility Master Plan Update For improvements to the Park, the user groups listed that a restroom and shelter were needed for Fields 6 & 7. Potable water in this area would also improve the Cross Country Course experience. They expressed a need for more fields (multi-purpose and small sized fields) and that they would like lights on the fields. Many expressed a strong interest in artificial turf fields to increase playing time. They saw the addition of park land as a way to accommodate this growth. Integrated Design also asked these groups to comment on the experiences at the Soccer Stadium, which few use for their own groups. Generally, the comments were very positive although the expressed a desire to see an improvement in the concessions. They thought it could use additional seating and the pedestrian connection between the two sides of the stadium should be improved. Automobile egress out of the park was a stated weakness. Other ideas that came out of the forum were a desire for the area to build an Indoor Track Facility. The region currently does not have one nearby. The facility would ideally have 5 to 6 lanes in a 200 meter oval. Together, Integrated Design and the Town of Cary staff prepared a Questionnaire for participants in the Public Forum. The tallied results of the questionnaire represent fifteen user groups: Carolina Copper Heads Carolina Soccer Club Cary High School Meredith College Soccer Meredith College Cross Country NC Adult Soccer Association NC High School Athletic Association NC Senior Games NC State Cross Country Peace College Soccer St. Timothy’s School Triangle Flying Disc Triangle Futbol UNC Soccer Cary Academy Cross Country The first section of the questionnaire was a list of areas in the Park to rate their quality. The responses indicated a high rating for the amount and location of parking. Nearly all groups gave an extremely high rating for the quality of the playing fields, with the exception of the small field (Field 8). The groups gave high ratings for both the quality of lights on Fields 2 & 3 and the cleanliness of the restroom facilities. Poor ratings were given to the quality of food served in the concessions. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 15 Facility Master Plan Update The second section of the survey listed a number of items mentioned in the SWOT Analysis and soccer group participants were asked to rate the importance of each of these items. Of highest importance to all of the user groups was the quality of the playing surfaces. This was followed by having restroom facilities and parking in close proximity to the fields. Other items given some importance were having lights for the practice fields and permanent seating. Items listed of less importance were scoreboards (for practice fields), concessions (for practice fields), and “other (non-specific) support facilities.” The survey also included a section specifically addressing the Cross Country Course. Of most important to the user groups is the quality of the running surface, the course signage, and a permanently defined start and finish area. Other items that ranked very high were a group of possible improvements to the course: restrooms in close proximity, a sound system, and parking in close proximity. Items that were indicated to be of less importance were a running clock, seating, and a concession stand. The final section of the questionnaire asked the user groups to rate the importance of potential facility improvements. The highest response was for additional restrooms for fields away from the stadium. This was closely followed by picnic shelters. Also rated high in importance was better internal signage and concession stands. Items falling in the middle included additional meeting space, conversion of natural fields, and additional lighted fields. Items having lower rating score were additional safety lighting at night, additional fields, scoreboards for practice fields, and finally additional park amenities such as a playground. Although additional fields and lighted fields received relatively low scores as a total, many of the groups rated these to be of the highest importance. C. Group Meetings During March and April 2009, Integrated Design with the Town of Cary staff conducted several small group meetings or conference calls with major repeat user groups of the park. Local Soccer The first small group meeting was with local soccer groups CASL and Triangle Futbol. Generally, these groups have some games on Field 2 and practice on Fields 4, 5, 6, and 7. The clubs felt that the parking at the facility was adequate for their needs but offered suggestions for improvements to both the park in general and Koka Booth Stadium (Field 2). WakeMed Soccer Park Page 16 Facility Master Plan Update For the park, the soccer clubs both expressed an interest in having toilets near Fields 6 and 7. Each group of fields should have a covered structure that would serve as an area of safety during storms and give a place where parents and siblings could view games and practice. An idea that had not been expressed before was wireless internet access at these structures so that parents could work or kids could do homework. There was a strong feeling that parents and siblings need to be by the fields and the groups had absolutely no interest in playgrounds. They felt the playgrounds presented a liability and parents needed to be watching the soccer rather than off watching other kids. The Town of Cary noted that other user groups have expressed an opposing opinion regarding playgrounds at the park. As for the fields, the clubs thought that at least two fields should be converted to artificial turf to gain more playing time. Fields 4 and 5 seemed to be the best candidates. The groups liked to train on artificial turf, but still preferred playing games on natural grass. Field lighting should accompany any turf conversion, but they expressed that investing in field lighting was not worth the money for a natural grass field. It was suggested that more netting would help many of the fields with their wear areas and smaller goals be made available for younger groups. Permanent seating for practice fields was helpful as long as it did not affect the size of the fields or the ability for fields to shift around to avoid wear areas. There was not much interest in scoreboards for practice fields. Koka Booth Stadium (Field 2) has improved with seating, but additional seats could be added. Both clubs feel that the level of lighting on Field 2 could be improved. Two locker rooms are important additions to this field. The locker rooms do not have to be full locker rooms with showers, but more just open rooms for changing and meeting along with toilets. Concessions serving the stadium need to be upgraded to be able to cook foods. Additional drink stands could serve the stadium. To liven up the park, the clubs wouldn’t mind seeing club signs around the park identifying the groups that play regularly. They also expressed an interest in a “photo op. spot.” The current public art in the park is too tall to be a backdrop for group pictures. The concrete soccer ball is closer, but not ideal because it could be larger. Professional Soccer The WakeMed Soccer Stadium is the home of the professional soccer team, the Carolina Railhawks since 2007. During the information gathering phase of the Facility Master Plan Update, Integrated Design conducted two separate meetings with the Railhawks. A different member of Railhawks ownership attended each meeting. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 17 Facility Master Plan Update While the owners expressed difference in each other’s opinions about stadium seating, both agreed that the item to correct was the state of the concessions. The concessions need cooking abilities to sell items other than pre-packaged foods. Another item of high importance is a Video Board. The PA system is out-dated for advertising and the video board would help grow TV contracts. It was noted that two video boards/score boards would be needed for the stadium if the stadium developed seating at both north and south ends. Differences were expressed in how the stadium seating should be improved. One owner stressed a high need in a canopy cover over the seating due to the revenue lost for rained out events. The canopy could be integrated into boxed seating which is also an item that would improve the stadium. Another owner expressed that improving the quality of the existing seating would be a low cost high return item, such as plastic seat backs. An extended plaza area where spectators could get concessions, but still see the game would be a positive addition, and it could be covered with additional seating or club boxes. Office and meeting space would be beneficial. Other than vehicular ingress and egress, other improvements to the park in general were not discussed. One owner suggested that improvements made to the stadium would generate revenue to pay for other park improvements. NCAA and ACC Both the NCAA and the ACC are major repeat user groups that hold their championships at the WakeMed Soccer Park. The ACC has held both their women’s and men’s soccer championships at the park during 2003-2005 and for the past years have been alternating either the women’s or the men’s championship at the park. During the off-years, the championships have been held at the Disney Wide World of Sports Soccer Complex, Florida State campus, or the Maryland Soccerplex. The NCAA has held Division 1 championships at the park each year since 2005. The men’s championships were held in 2005 and in 2007 and will continue in 2009. The women’s championships were held in 2006 and 2008 and will continue in 2010. Both groups stated that they return to WakeMed Soccer Park because of the quality of both the stadium field and the practice fields. Similar to professional soccer, one of the highly recommended items from these groups is a Video Board. They use Video Boards for public service announcements, trivia, interviews, and to broadcast the National Anthem. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 18 Facility Master Plan Update Events that these groups host typically need many multi-purpose areas. In the past they have been using tents, but feel that at minimum the Park should have four locker rooms. Similar to views expressed by local soccer groups, the locker rooms would not require showers but be toilets and changing areas. Even actual lockers are not being used as much by the teams at these events. The size of the current locker rooms is adequate for soccer although may be a little small if these groups were to host lacrosse events at the Park. There should be a clear delineation between areas for teams and areas for officials. Other tents are being used for media workspace and ESPN interviews. This is somewhat hampered in the tents because of the wind. In addition to a more permanent solution to the tents, these areas need more power. Generators are being brought in for electrical needs for these areas, inflatables, and other interactive and media items. A number of quarter-final and semi-final games are played on the Koka Booth Field (Field 2), which garnered a lot of suggestions for improvement. Specifically the lights on this field need to be increased, as sometimes the lights from the main stadium are causing vision issues with the goal keepers. The NCAA and ACC representatives expressed that the temporary press box constructed for events on Field 2 was adequate, but locker room/changing facilities were not. Temporary changing facilities were set up in portable tents, but their location required players to travel through the stands to reach the fields. Also recommended were upgraded concession facilities. Although these groups currently use only the soccer aspect of the Park, the conversation also included improvements that could be made to attract more lacrosse and cross country events. Although a North Carolina location might be deemed a little “South” to be a championship location for lacrosse (owing to the fact that many southern schools don’t compete in this sport), the fields at the Park are quite suitable for lacrosse play by adding safety nets behind goals and preserving extra sideline space. Lacrosse practice typically occurs on turf fields or natural fields dedicated to the sport given that the wear is usually harder on the field than soccer. For cross country events, the most stringent factor is the start/finish area of the course. The quality of the grass in this area needs to be well kept. Other minor improvements may include a permanent structure signifying the start/finish, grandstands to watch the finish, and an area for awards staging and results posting. A portable video board is often brought in for events. Both the NCAA and the ACC gave many other general comments about the Park and their preferences when selecting venues. These groups prefer playing their games on a natural grass surface, but often utilize artificial turf for practice. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 19 Facility Master Plan Update Parking at the facility is not the Park’s best aspect due to ingress and egress time, but has not been a problem. They are comfortable with solutions that transport spectators via shuttle if needed. Additional seating could be added as the events grow, but would like to maintain the open aspect of these concourses. When asked about canopy covered seating, they replied that a few of the venues that they use are large, soccer-specific stadiums that have canopies and that it is nice, but that it was not required nor an expectation. Local Cross Country The final small group meeting was conducted with coaches of local cross country groups that use the Park. Although the Park is known for soccer, it also has one of the best kept cross country courses in the region. The purpose of the conversation was to look for items of improvement that might attract larger cross country events, such as the ACC championship, which was held at the University of Miami this past year. The main item of the course that needs improvement is the start/finish line. Although the turf in this area has seen improvement since Park staff have restricted the parking near Fields 6 & 7, the distance from the start line to the first curve is currently around 450 meters. This distance needs to be revised to around 600 meters if possible to meet official specifications. While this might prohibit the course from being a Division 1 NCAA site, it would most likely not prevent regional meets. During the invited group forum, some cross country groups stated that current distance of 5k is nice because there is not a lot of repeat looping. In the group meeting, it was expressed that the course did need some 2k loops to hold events of other distances, such as 6, 8 and 10k runs. The ideal course has looping, but long enough to prevent lapping. The NCAA can require up to 30 feet maintained for width, but the current width of the course is nice and is not causing problems. This width would also be sufficient for regional or Division 2 meets. The materials on the course are working well, including the ‘crush and run’ stone on the trails. The trails have somewhat of a reputation as being a fast course because the stone can compact to an almost track-like surface. There has been some feedback that there are still too many rocks in the start/finish area. To hold larger meets, these groups would like to see a pavilion with power and a few toilets. Port-a-johns are sufficient for large events such as meets that typically have 2,500 people including 1,600 athletes or the Great American which typically has 4,000-5,000 in attendance. The pavilion would like to have a tiered area for awards stage, but be generally similar to the pavilion in Cary’s Bond Park. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 20 Facility Master Plan Update While most of their concerns were about the course itself, the design team pressed the group for more ideas, even asking for “pie in the sky” wish items. Under this umbrella of thinking, the groups mentioned items discussed with the NCAA and ACC such as a permanent start/finish structure, seating to make the course more fan-friendly, and Mondo mats to cover road crossings. There preference was to re-route the course so there would not be any more road crossings. Technology was discussed as a way to make the course more accessible. Similar to local soccer groups, they expressed an interest in Park wireless internet access and have thought about putting cameras on the course that could broadcast runners’ progress via the web or a portable Video Board. The local cross country groups appreciate and value their place in the Park even though the Park is more geared toward soccer. They would like the Town to keep them in mind and secure greenway rights from developers should the State sell the property immediately to the south of the Park. A simple foot bridge could expand the course dramatically. Both the cross country group and other groups that have spoken to the Town of Cary staff have talked about altering the cross country course to accommodate the growing sport of Disc Golf. There is a relatively fine example of a course at Middle Creek Park in Cary. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 21 Facility Master Plan Update V. Data Analysis Narrative While the Park’s user groups represent a great diversity, there are common elements to their needs. The groups represent a varying degree of skill, from high school to college and professional, and a varying degree of locality, from Cary and Wake County groups to colleges and professional teams from around the region and country. The items that are common between the groups will make the greatest impact and should be categorized into immediate and shortterm needs. Items pertaining to specific groups or items that expand or improve existing functions have been categorized into medium and long-range planning. Most improvement items recommended will be location-specific within the Park and are categorized as WakeMed Soccer Stadium, Koka Booth Stadium, Park Fields, Park and Cross Country Course, Parking and Circulation and Future Stadium. There are a number of items that are general Park items that may cross these categories and also create a greater impact. The Master Plan diagram on the next page highlights recommended improvements and shows their general locations. Additionally, the letters and numbers used in the diagram correspond with the text laid out within this document. WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan Update Page 22 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 23 Facility Master Plan Update A. WakeMed Soccer Stadium A.1 Stadium Capacity: Quantity and Quality Current stadium capacity is 7,000 spectator seats. Given the current number of college-level events the Town is hosting and the need to increase capacity, it is recommended that the ultimate capacity for the WakeMed Stadium would need to increase to 15,000 seats. (Beyond this capacity is possible, but would require major renovation and investment that may be better suited to the eventual planning of the larger future stadium discussed at the end of this section.) The key to expanding the facility is to find the balance in the seating number. Currently, the stadium has a good small-stadium feel that enhances the excitement of the game. A smaller sold-out stadium retains a better feeling than a larger stadium with open seats. An immediate need is to increase the stadium capacity from 7,000 seats to 10,000 seats in order to attract and retain the NCAA Championships which occur each fall. The north end zone is where this can occur without negative impacts to other areas. Once this need is met then the focus should return to improving the quality of the seating. The WakeMed Soccer Stadium ultimate size will depend on vehicular access to the site. Chatham Street is currently configured as a 2-lane road with a center turn lane and is not conducive to high volumes of traffic which are created during stadium events. Consideration has been given to using some type of shuttle system to access the site; however it is limited based on Chatham Street’s current configuration. The current site is designed for 3200 parking spaces and should be able to handle a stadium event seating up to 10,000. As the facility expands, a traffic study will be required with any proposed seating expansion to further detail requirements needed to appropriately handle stadium events. Seating Quality: Typical attendance numbers are not indicating a strong need for additional seating beyond increasing it to 10,000 seats in the short term. Instead, seating expansions should focus on different types of seating ranging from causal viewing plazas to luxury seating. These diverse options will help to enhance the stadium experience needed to lure additional spectators. Medium-term goals should improve the quality of existing seating to improve both the spectator and the player experience in the stadium. Along the east and west sides of the stadium there are a number of seating areas that can be converted to plastic seats with plastic seat backs. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 24 Facility Master Plan Update Small improvements can also include upgraded goals and team benches. Currently, TV platforms are only located on the west side of the stadium. It has been noted that if this were also accommodated on the east side of the stadium, the dramatic ‘face’ of the west side with its press box could be a TV feature. Similar seating goals should include an increase in luxury boxes and club seating. Current luxury boxes were designed to overlook the main stadium as well as the Koka Booth Stadium. Luxury boxes oriented length-wise with the stadium would create opportunities to generate higher revenue for private party seating. North Stadium Expansion: The capacity of the north stadium is not recommended to exceed capacity on the dominant (east and west) sides of the stadium. The recommendation is to plan up to 4,000 seats on the north side while providing a pedestrian concourse that connects the east and west sides. An immediate need is to expand the stadium by 3,000 seats which could be done at this location with the remainder of seats done at a later time. South Stadium Expansion: Similarly, large capacity seating should not be planned for the south side of the stadium. Seating on the south side of the stadium currently has a capacity roughly of 2,000. The existing seating should be modified to be accessed from the rear to improve the circulation of the stadium once the concourse is extended along the southern side of the stadium. Seating could be expanded by an additional 2,000 seats to reach a total of 4,000 on the south side. West Stadium Expansion: Expansion of seating on the west side of the stadium involves adding luxury suites. It is recommended that luxury suites be located along both sides of the press box on the west side of the stadium. Planning must include a connection to the existing elevator in Building A with attention to preserving the concourse’s open and pedestrian characteristics that are favorably viewed. East Stadium Expansion: Expansion of seating on the east side of the stadium should be an incremental expansion as related to the elevated concessions plaza. The plaza on the east side of the stadium would have field views that would boost revenue by encouraging concessions buying during play time and also create a social atmosphere. While this idea doesn’t dramatically increase the amount of seating at the stadium, it can increase the diversity and quality of the seating. On this elevated plaza would included new concession area along with restroom facilities. This new concession area could be in lieu of major upgrades to the existing concession facilities and should be studied further. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 25 Facility Master Plan Update The concessions plaza begins as a low capacity covered gathering area but is expanded with seating over the plaza of up to an additional 1,500 seats. At the top of the additional seating, luxury suites would be added and the entire area covered. Stadium Canopy: The lack of space around the stadium also has implications with the medium and long-range item of canopy covered seating. A 40’ wide canopy on all four sides of the stadium is possible. The expense of a canopy addition ranges between one million dollars to cover the elevated plaza seating to five million dollars based on coverage and design. Careful planning must be given to a design that preserves the concourse and unites the divergent seating types. WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan Update Page 26 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 27 Facility Master Plan Update A.2 Concessions The most pressing need of the main soccer stadium is an upgrade of its concessions. This opinion was expressed by nearly every user group. The Town is currently in the process of making alterations to improve the concessions area attached to Building A, an incremental stage that should also be applied to the concessions areas of Buildings B and E in the future. Medium and long-term planning needs should address the need for a larger concessions area dedicated specifically to food preparation and storage. This function needs vehicular access away from pedestrian paths. A recommended location is the under-utilized southwest corner of the stadium. Planning should include a new plaza behind the south seating to improve the connectivity between the east and west sides of the stadium. Vehicular access should be provided by paving the stadium parking lot on the east side and extending it along the south side of the stadium. Medium and Long-range planning goals for concessions include an outdoor seating plaza with field views. The recommended location is an elevated platform behind the east grandstands. The nature of the soccer game tends to keep spectators in the stands during play. With connections to the stands and the plaza area around Building B, the concessions plaza would create an informal gathering area that could increase concession sales with its visual connectivity to the field. Initially, the plaza could be built with a tensile structure covering the area from the weather with long-range planning to include it covered by a seating expansion above. As seating capacity increases, additional concessions build-out should be included at the back of the platform. Beneath the platform plaza, circulation patterns and the children’s play zone should remain. A.3 Video Board The second improvement that should be considered short-term or immediate would be the procurement of a Video Board for the stadium. This item is a priority for both the national collegiate users of the stadium as well as the professional soccer tenant. Besides potential revenue for advertisement, video boards have the ability to capture the attention of a wider soccer audience. The recommendation is for the video board to be located in the existing scoreboard area on the north side of the stadium. Long-term planning should include a second video board as the stadium seating capacity increases. A second video board should be installed on the south side of the stadium once seating is constructed on the north side. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 28 Facility Master Plan Update A.4 Team Rooms and Multi-purpose Space There are immediate needs for additional multi-purpose space and team rooms. There is currently a need for multiple changing areas for teams that include toilets, a few showers but not necessarily lockers when more than two teams play on the same day. Currently, the existing stadium features two full locker rooms, team room, and changing room without lockers or showers that is currently used for office space by the Railhawks. This spaces currently works fine when only 2 teams are playing. However, additional space is needed when multiple teams plan and or tournaments are held. It is recommended that two team rooms (each including toilets) be built on the lower level of Building “C” in the southwest corner of the stadium. The building’s location with vehicular access on the south side of the stadium will allow buses to load and unload teams outside of the spectator crowds. The team rooms should have direct access to the Koka Booth Field. Another opportunity to consider during the design of Building “C” is to include a tunnel beneath the plaza that directly exits onto WakeMed Soccer Stadium field. The upper level would be multipurpose space that can be used for large events as well as for regular programming by the Town of Cary. See the attached conceptual plan for potential layout of the building. WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan Update Page 29 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 30 Facility Master Plan Update A.5 Administrative Office with Meeting Space An administrative office building with meeting space is a long-range goal for the facility. Office space is not a goal that will increase the public image of the park, yet the current office space is barely adequate. The offices of the Railhawks are currently housed in the space designed to be a Team Room for the Carolina Courage. Offices for the Town of Cary staff are located in a space designed for storage. It is recommended that an office building be located near the public entrance of the stadium. The landscaped area near the flagpoles and northeast of Building “B” is an ideal location for offices and additional meeting space. The location would put offices in a location that is easily identified and accessed by the public, is in visual control of access to the park, and can also include additional box office functions as the stadium capacity increases. Construction of the office building would also reverse the Railhawks office space back to an additional team room or a meeting space. Event functions that are currently held in tents on the plaza could occur in this space as well. A.6 Field Lighting Upgrades The current lighting system has a field average of 95 footcandles and currently just meets the minimum lighting requirements for televised events. As use of the field grows with increased capacity and higher tiered events, improvements to lighting levels is recommended to be a long term planning priority. Any lighting improvements should meet the latest “NCAA Best Lighting Practices”. The current recommended requirements are listed below: NCAA National Broadcast Minimum Footcandle 125 Average Footcandle 140 Uniformity 1.5:1 or less Any Stadium lighting upgrades should take into consideration the addition of canopy’s over seating areas. The current lighting is designed around the Building “A” roof line. Any canopy that extends higher or further out than the Building “A” roof line will interfere with the current lighting system. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 31 Facility Master Plan Update B. Koka Booth Stadium The addition of 510 permanent seats in 2008 to the Koka Booth Stadium (Field 2) has had a great effect on the park. With the creation of Koka Booth Stadium, the Park is able to reduce the wear on the main stadium and accommodate smaller games with greater quality. As many of the user groups are using this smaller stadium more, obvious improvements mimic those to the main stadium to a lesser degree. Koka Booth Stadium is unique in that Field 3 is immediately adjacent to the Koka Booth Stadium (Field 2) providing distinct opportunities to host special events that may need the use of two adjacent fields. In addition, it is also immediately adjacent to WakeMed Stadium. As described in the WakeMed Soccer Stadium section regarding Team Rooms, the lower level of the Building C location would provide direct access to the Koka Booth Field without players having to walk through the spectator seating. Toilets and concessions for Koka Booth Stadium are well served by Building “A” and Building “D” of the main stadium due to their close proximity. B.1 Lighting & Electrical As use of Koka Booth Stadium grows with increased capacity and higher tiered events, improvements to lighting levels are recommended to be a short-term priority. Limited TV broadcast is currently needed at the facility to host the existing events. Any lighting improvements should meet the latest “NCAA Best Lighting Practices”. The current minimum requirements are listed below: NCAA Limited Broadcast Footcandle 75 Uniformity 2:1 or less Note: Lighting should be designed so that it can be reduced to match Field 3 Field 3 Recommended lighting Class Footcandle II 50 Uniformity 2.5:1 or less Due to increasing power needs by events, it is recommended that projects near either stadium should increase the electrical capabilities of the park rather than relying on using spares of the existing service. B.2 Seating Capacity As a medium-term planning priority, the seating should be a focus in increasing the spectator use of Koka Booth Stadium to a total of 1500 seats. Similar to the main stadium, incremental seating expansions are WakeMed Soccer Park Page 32 Facility Master Plan Update recommended. High quality seating should not be a focus of the planning as regular bench seating was selected by the Town for the initial 510 seats and this row size will not accommodate seat backs or individual plastic seats with backs. B.3 Press The concourse plaza between Koka Booth and WakeMed Stadiums currently includes an area that is naturally suited for a Press Box. Depending on need, this area can be a temporary press area, a small permanent one-story press box, or a raised press box connected to Building “A’s” existing elevator with space for concessions or merchandise beneath. The addition of a press box may also fulfill broadcasting and PA needs for Koka Booth Stadium. Due to the current flexibility of the space this is listed as a long term priority. B.4 Video Board - Portable As more preliminary games for championship events are played at Koka Booth Stadium, the Park will receive more frequent requests for a Video Board at this stadium. A permanent Video Board at this location may not provide a reasonable return on investment; however, there are several options by Video Board manufacturers for “mobile units” that have a fully functional Video Board that extends into the air from a trailer unit. While much more expensive than a typical Video Board, this unit could be ported to Koka Booth Stadium, the Cross Country Course, or any of the other venues at the Town of Cary’s such as USA Baseball or even the annual Lazy Daze Event. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 33 Facility Master Plan Update C. Park Fields Outside of the two stadiums, which have traditionally served large event competitions, the remaining fields (4,5,6,7 & 8) of the Park have transitioned from event practice fields to serving a community role since the Town of Cary has assumed the management of the Park. C.1 Artificial Turf Fields with Lights Due to the limited amount of developable space at the Park, the best answer to increase play time at the fields is the conversion to artificial turf. During the master plan process the design team reviewed options for additional fields. Due to the significant impact it would have on the site (tree removal, retaining walls, parking needs) it was determined that the best way to accommodate the need for additional playing time would be converting existing grass fields to artificial turf fields. Recent advancements in the manufacturing of artificial turf fields have led to safer playing environments than previous generations of artificial turf. Turf fields provide playing surfaces that are less susceptible to wear and weather cancellations. They have a higher initial cost than an under-drained natural playing surface, however the costs between the two types of fields even out over the 10 year life span when factoring maintenance costs. It is recommended that short-term planning include the conversion of one or two fields. Fields 4 and 5 are recommended due to their prominent location within the Park. These two fields could easily become prime local competition fields with a few other amenities. It is recommended that field 8 be considered in the mix when planning for artificial turf fields. Long-term planning should consider Fields 6 and 7. With increased playing time available on artificial field, the conversion must include the addition of field lighting. Electrical infrastructure is already in place for lighting at Fields 4 and 5, strengthening the recommendation to covert these fields to artificial turf first. The most efficient type of lighting should be used taking into consideration the long term operating cost. A remote operating system should be used that will control, monitor and manage the lighting system. The current standards of Illuminating Engineering Society of North American (IESNA) should be met. To determine the appropriate illumination criteria, the IESNA has developed 4 classes based on the skill levels of the players and the anticipated number of spectators. The table below shows the current recommended light levels: Class III Footcandle 30 Uniformity 3:1 or less WakeMed Soccer Park Page 34 Facility Master Plan Update C.2 Irrigation Pond and Water Stewardship Since its inception, the ability for the WakeMed Soccer Park to provide and control its own water sources has been crucial to its success. Irrigation water is currently provided by a pond to the north of the fields that is fed from wells and storm water collection. The current water demand for the 8 fields is higher then what this pond can supply during extended times without rain. The Town of Cary has improved the quality of the park’s fields by blending a sand mixture into the native soil to produce a healthier grass growing medium producing a more durable surface. This increase in the field quality, coupled with recent droughts, has shown a need to increase the Park’s ability to collect water. Town staff reviewed the current master plan for reclaimed water. The reclaimed water master plan does not show reclaimed water being extended within range to serve this facility. Conversion to artificial turf fields will help alleviate the need for some irrigation. Currently artificial turf fields do require supplemental potable water to cool the fields during the warm months. An underdrainage system would be installed to capture any water that does not evaporate which could be reused for irrigation of the existing turf fields. Medium-term planning should include an additional storm-water collection pond south of the main stadium. This pond could potentially function as both a storm water detention pond (for expansion of the WakeMed Stadium) as well as an irrigation pond. HVAC condensate as well as the existing field underdrains should be routed to this pond in order to collect as much water as possible. The design of this pond would need to minimize impacts to the existing cross country trail that loops through this area. Discussions were held regarding expanding the existing pond. The design team reviewed the option and felt the overall benefit would be minimal due to the existing site constraints. One option that could be considered is contacting the adjacent state property designated for the future stadium which includes wells that produce a higher volume than Park property wells. Negotiations for use of their wells may be another option to increase the amount of water however this option is no more sustainable than using potable water. C.3 Park Shelters It is recommended that short-term, medium-term and long-term planning include shelters near the park fields. User groups identified shelters as a place to gather for events as well as an accessible haven during rain or to WakeMed Soccer Park Page 35 Facility Master Plan Update provide a location to get out of the sun. While a shelter or pavilion for Fields 4,5 & 8 should be considered for long-range planning, a shelter near Fields 6 and 7 should be considered a short-term planning priority for the Park and is discussed further in section D. D. Park and Cross Country Course D.1 Cross Country Course Expansion The Cross Country Course may be one of the best kept secrets of the park. Much of the public doesn’t realize that it is part of the park, and yet cross country groups in our area recognize it as one of the best maintained courses in our region. Planning a new 2k loop through the park will dramatically increase the amount of distances the course can provide for both men and women’s events. There is an existing sewerline that runs between the western property line and field 3 where a trail could be constructed. Any alterations to the course should take into consideration the required distances needed at the start and finish of the course, should try to avoid road crossings, and should be of similar materials as the existing course. A disc golf course in conjunction with the cross country course was discussed. Due to the course’s regional importance it is not recommended that disc golf or any other type of facility be added along the course at this time. D.2 Shelter with Restroom near Fields 6 & 7 The Cross Country Course shares its start/finish area with the existing grass parking around Fields 6 and 7, although this area has little fanfare. It is recommended that adding a shelter to this area be a short-term planning priority to resolve toilet and potable water needs for the cross country course runners as well as also resolve needs for users of Fields 6 & 7. Planning for the shelter should consider the needs of both user groups (fields and cross country). A signature pavilion that offers toilets, shelter, and awards staging area should be developed for this area. D.3 Park Comforts – Wireless Internet, Play Area & Public Art It is recommended that on-going planning address several smaller items that can be improved over the years to improve the creature comforts of the park. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 36 Facility Master Plan Update Two user groups expressed an interest in the Park having wireless internet access. Providing this relatively low cost service could pull in more users as well as establish a backbone for new technological improvements in the Park as described by local soccer and cross country groups. A traditional play area at the park was not highly requested by many of the user groups at the current time. Long term planning should consider a future play area near the existing public art “Balancing Act” due to the fact that the facility will grow and become more diverse over time. Many groups expressed continued inclusion of public art in the Park. It is recommended that public art serve as a focal point for group pictures at events. The current large-scale art “Balancing Act” is not conducive to this purpose however it does serve as an entrance feature to the park and functions quite well in this manner. Across from “Balancing Act” there is an existing concrete wall with a sign on it. Currently it is an underused space and staff is looking into options of how this can be used as a focal point. There may be additional opportunities to include public art throughout the facility as well. D.4 Maintenance Facility Expansion A medium term planning priority is the expansion of the existing facility maintenance area currently located near field 8. Secured, covered areas for equipment are needed to protect the investment the Town has placed into the equipment. In addition, current environmental regulations require covered washbays for equipment that drain to sanitary sewer in order to protect the streams. A small office in the maintenance yard would enable facility maintenance staff to move out of the basement of Building D and return this to a needed storage area. D.5 Signage It is recommended that the Town of Cary continue to consider signage in the Park. Many user groups expressed interest in displaying club signs. Respondents felt that the current field numbering system was confusing. The Park entrance sign, recently replaced, is problematic to those who are not familiar with the Park, such as regional and national groups. While it is commendable that the Town has followed their own restrictions as to size and color, the sign is not prominent enough for a major Town destination. This is especially true given that the mass of the Park is far from the road and not immediately visible. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 37 Facility Master Plan Update E. Parking and Circulation E.1 Pave parking lot between Fields 6 & 7 Many field user groups expressed dissatisfaction with the lack of parking near Fields 6 and 7. While an unpaved parking lot is located in this area and open during major events, normal park operations has the parking closed to prevent damage to the Cross Country start/finish area. The parking lot at this location is recommended to be paved. In addition, this parking area should be linked to both the stadium as well as to the unpaved overflow parking area located to the north. The existing gravel drive that parallels Field 6 and links the parking lot located between Fields 6 & 7 should be paved. Appropriate landscaping should be considered along the edge of this drive due to its proximity to the Cross County Starting line. Once circulation improvements are complete, a loop system will be completed which will provide more options for exiting the facility. Paving this access road will alter the existing parking configuration in the grass/overflow parking area. Careful analysis should be completed to ensure significant parking spaces are not lost and there is not a negative impact to the cross country course start finish line. E.2 Develop a new parking lot on south side of WakeMed Stadium A new 195 space parking lot is recommended on the south side of the Stadium. This is necessary to provide access for the increased seating that is proposed on the southern end of the Stadium as well as the proposed Building “C”. In addition, the existing parking lot and circulation on the east side of the Stadium will need to be re-designed and paved so that it will function with the new parking lot proposed on the south side. E.3 Upgrade circulation between WakeMed Stadium and Fields 6 & 7 The current “land bridge” connecting the parking lot between fields 6 & 7 to the stadium parking should be re-engineered to handle car traffic in an effort to create a paved circulation loop through the WakeMed Stadium. It should be paved and linked to the eastern stadium parking lot. The land bridge should be better identified as a crossing area between the stadium and the eastern fields. Parking on the east side of the stadium is actually fairly close to these fields and may have increased use if paved. Given its immediate location to the main stadium, paving this area could also provide more VIP parking and possible revenue for the main stadium. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 38 Facility Master Plan Update E.4 Close south loop of existing road near stadium entrance The loop drive that currently exists surrounding the island where the public art is located “Balancing Act” should be altered. It is recommended that the southern leg of this be closed off to thru traffic. Closing off this segment will create a pedestrian refuge and provide pedestrians more access to the sculpture and play area that is proposed at this location. During large events this area could be used for bus parking or other temporary uses. E.5 Trinity Road Extension While traffic flow is not problematic for many of the smaller user groups, it has always been noticed during the professional soccer games and large championship events. The 2001 Soccer Park Master Plan includes a traffic pattern that was one of several options discussed with the North Carolina Department of Transportation during the original construction. The proposed extension of Trinity Road for the 2001 Soccer Park Master Plan was to follow the eastern boarder of the site and connect to a larger parking area that would be required for the future stadium discussed in the next section. Since the 2001 Soccer Park Master Plan, the extension of Trinity Road through the park has not been constructed. Trinity Road was extended from Cary Towne Boulevard to the southern edge of the WakeMed property. With the inclusion of a vehicular bridge, an extension of the parking could provide an important part of solving the traffic flow in and out of the park by connecting the Park to Cary Towne Boulevard – a street that is better designed to handle larger traffic patterns than Chatham Street if NCDOT would allows this to occur. This short-term solution would help alleviate traffic problems at larger events until the full Trinity Road Extension could be constructed. The Town of Cary Capital Project ST1091 evaluated possible roadway alignments. However, no alignments were established for Trinity Road extension. In addition CAMPO and the I-40 Partnership are looking at this area and the Town should continue to work with these and other organizations to ensure negative impacts to the WakeMed Soccer Park do not occur. In the meantime, it is recommended that Town of Cary take advantage of this lull in the construction of Trinity Drive to analyze the impact that this will have on WakeMed Soccer Park. The current design of Trinity Drive indicates the removal of the entire buffer along the eastern edge of the WakeMed facility. With the widening of I-40 along this side of WakeMed, which is currently underway and the resulting increase in noise levels, every effort should be made to buffer WakeMed Soccer Park from the future extension of Trinity Road as well as from Interstate 40. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 39 Facility Master Plan Update While the extension of Trinity Road will continue to be a long-term planning item, it should be given a high priority as it will solve one of the major problems plaguing a top class facility. E.6 Pedestrian Circulation and Walnut Creek Greenway As the vehicular circulation system is improved within WakeMed Soccer Park, consideration should be made to improve the pedestrian circulation as well. Any improvements or additional parking lots should include generous walkways and visible crosswalks. A 10’ wide multi-use trail is proposed adjacent to the west side of Trinity Road. The pedestrian system within WakeMed Soccer Park should link to this to facilitate pedestrian access to the Park. In addition, the PRCR Comprehensive Facilities Master Plan includes the future Walnut Creek Greenway along the Walnut Creek buffer, through WakeMed Soccer Park. It is recommended that this greenway be located along the southern side of the buffer (State Property) so that its use does not conflict with Cross Country Course. The greenway and the cross-country course should connect to encourage and increase loops. This greenway would be a development requirement by Town of Cary to provide the easement by the commercial developers of the property when the property is developed. E.7 Land Expansion/Future Development Surrounding the park is undeveloped or under-developed land. As this land develops the Town should work with the developers to ensure that compatible uses develop immediately adjacent to WakeMed Soccer Park. In addition, the Town should keep open the option to acquire additional land for future expansion if the right opportunity presents itself. F. Future Stadium F.1 25,000 Capacity Soccer Stadium The 2001 Master Plan included area designated for a 25,000 capacity soccerspecific stadium. While a 25,000 capacity stadium will most likely not be considered a priority in the next 10 years, it is recommended to keep the stadium in the Master Plan to reserve its place. Soccer has long been the fastest growing sport in the United States and statistics this past year has placed the Raleigh/Cary metro area as one of the fastest growing areas in terms of population growth. With strong local soccer clubs, such as CASL, it is envisioned that soccer will WakeMed Soccer Park Page 40 Facility Master Plan Update become a more dominate past time as the current generation of young fans become parents guiding the next generation. While the Triangle has a strong women’s collegiate following, Cary can capitalize on the growing popularity of soccer by nurturing and hosting events with the college and professional teams. It is the success of the professional team or teams located in this area that will eventually push the need for the larger stadium. Ideally, the faster this professional success occurs, the more likely the Soccer Park will be able to retain regional and national events as those events also grow. If the expansion of these two user groups coincide, it is likely that the Town of Cary will remain a “NCAA Championship City.” A larger capacity stadium will require several improvements to the park. One of these improvements must be the extension of Trinity Road through the park and connected to its parking. Additional parking must be made available through parking decks, community transit, and/or shuttles from remote parking. The stadium is recommended to be planned as an arena, with toilets, concessions, and other functions built into multi-level concourses within the seating rather than placed on ground level outside of the seating. With its proximity to the road, the stadium should have a signature design and feature a canopy over the structure. Summary of Recommendations A. WakeMed Soccer Stadium 1. Stadium Capacity: Expand stadium capacity from the current capacity of 7,000 to 15,000 seats Improve Seating Quality - Seatbacks North End Zone Seating Expansion (4,000) South Stadium Seating Alteration and Expansion (2,000) West Stadium Luxury Suites East Stadium Expansion Including Plaza o Elevated Concessions Plaza o Plaza Cover o Additional Concessions/Restrooms o Additional 1,500 grandstand seating o Luxury suites Stadium Canopy 2. Upgrade existing concessions throughout stadium Upgrade Building A Concessions (Under construction 2010) Upgrade Building B Concessions Upgrade Building E Concessions WakeMed Soccer Park Page 41 Facility Master Plan Update 3. Install video boards Install video board at North End (Priority) Install video board at South End 4. Construct new team rooms at Building C (Multi-purpose space main level and 2 Team Rooms lower level) 5. Administrative office building with meeting spaces 6. Field Lighting Upgrades B. Koka Booth Stadium (Fields 2 & 3) 1. Lighting Improvements 2. Seating Expansion from 510 seats to 1500 seats 3. Press Box 4. Video board - portable C. Park Fields 1. Artificial turf fields with lights 2. Irrigation and water stewardship – construct new irrigation pond on southern end of facility 3. Park shelters for fields 4,5 & 8 D. Park Amenities and Cross Country 1. Complete Cross Country Course expansion with loops and alterations 2. Install new pavilion shelter for fields 6 & 7 and cross country course that includes a restroom 3. Park comforts – wireless internet, playground and public art 4. Maintenance facility expansion 5. Signage improvements E. Parking & Circulation 1. Pave existing gravel lot located between Fields 6 & 7 2. Develop a new parking lot on south side of Stadium 3. Re-engineer landbridge, pave and connect to parking lot on east side of Stadium. 4. Close off south loop to provide pedestrian refuge near stadium entrance 5. Analyze future extension of Trinity Road to ensure that proposed multi-use trail is in design and that an adequate buffer remains between the Soccer Park and Trinity Road. 6. Locate future Walnut Creek Greenway along the south side of the Walnut Creek buffer. 7. Land expansion/Future Development F. Future Stadium 25,000 capacity soccer stadium WakeMed Soccer Park Page 42 Facility Master Plan Update VI. Implementation and Cost Estimate Plan The benefit to having a Master Plan for the WakeMed Soccer Park is it lists out all of the current needs and prioritizes them. As needs change the overall goals can be reviewed to better understand what impact changes to the Master Plan will have and adjustments to the overall plan can be made. The implementation plan is broken into 4 planning priorities from immediate planning priorities to long term planning priorities. The cost are in 2010 amounts and should be adjusted based on inflation and other factors as the plan is implemented. ***Note: Letters and Numbers below correspond with the Master Plan diagram located at the beginning of Section V. Refer to this diagram for general locations of recommended improvements. Immediate Planning Priorities Construction NA $900,000.00 $400,000.00 Design $125,000.00 NA NA A.1 A.2 A.3 WakeMed Soccer Stadium Stadium Expansion Schematics North End Zone Seating Expansion Video Board (North End) A.4 Team Rooms & Multipurpose Space (Building C) $1,500,000.00 $140,000.00 Immediate Subtotal: $2,800,000.00 $ 265,000.00 Total $125,000.00 $900,000.00 $400,000.00 $1,640,000.00 $ 3,065,000.00 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 43 Facility Master Plan Update Short-term Planning Priorities A.1 A.2 WakeMed Soccer Stadium Elevated Plaza Concessions Upgrade (E) Construction $700,000.00 $300,000.00 Design $70,000.00 $30,000.00 Total $770,000.00 $330,000.00 Koka Booth Soccer Stadium B.1 C.1 C.1 D.2 E.1 E.5 E.6 E.7 Lighting Improvements (Fields 2 & 3)(75 FC for TV Field 2 and 50 FC on Field 3) Park, Park Fields, Cross Country & Parking and Circulation Artificial Turf Field Conversion (Fields 4 & 5) (or Fields 4 & 8 for less) Lighting Fields 4, 5(30 footcandles) & 8 for practice* Pavilion Shelter with Restroom by Field 6&7 Vehicular Circulation Improvements Fields 6&7 Trinity Road Extension Pedestrian Circulation and Walnut Creek Greenway Land Expansion Short-Term Subtotal: $690,000.00 $1,500,000.00 $410,000.00 NA $150,000.00 NA $690,000.00 $1,650,000.00 $410,000.00 $350,000.00 $35,000.00 $385,000.00 $200,000.00 TBD $20,000.00 TBD $220,000.00 TBD $550,000.00 TBD 55,000.00 TBD $605,000.00 TBD $4,700,000.00 $360,000.00 $5,060,000.00 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 44 Facility Master Plan Update Medium-term Planning Priorities Construction Design Total A.1 A.1 WakeMed Soccer Stadium Elevated Plaza Plaza Cover Additional Concessions Area and Expansion of B East Stadium Seating Expansion A.1, C.2 & E.2 A.1 South Stadium Improvements - Seating alternations, Concourse Plaza, Parking Improvements including including first 65 spaces of south parking lot and Irrigation Pond/BMP Existing Seating Upgrades (Seatbacks) $650,000.00 $350,000.00 $65,000.00 $35,000.00 $715,000.00 $385,000.00 B.2 Koka Booth Soccer Stadium Seating Expansion (1000 additional seats) $300,000.00 $30,000.00 $330,000.00 D.1 D.4 D.5 Park, Park Fields, Cross Country & Parking and Circulation Cross Country Course Loops and Alterations Maintenance Facility Upgrade Signage $100,000.00 $300,000.00 $50,000.00 $10,000.00 $30,000.00 NA $110,000.00 $330,000.00 $50,000.00 $475,000.00 $5,275,000.00 A.1 Medium Subtotal: $850,000.00 $85,000.00 $935,000.00 $700,000.00 $1,500,000.00 $70,000.00 $150,000.00 $770,000.00 $1,650,000.00 $4,800,000.00 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 45 Facility Master Plan Update Long-term Planning Priorities Construction $5,000,000.00 $4,000,000.00 $1,500,000.00 $400,000.00 Design $500,000.00 $400,000.00 $150,000.00 NA Total $5,500,000.00 $4,400,000.00 $1,650,000.00 $400,000.00 A.7 WakeMed Soccer Stadium Stadium Canopy (40’ wide on 4 sides) Luxury Suites Administrative Office with Meeting Spaces Video Board (South End) Lighting Upgrades (125 FC minimum, 140 FC avg)* B.3 B.4 Koka Booth Soccer Stadium Press Box Video Board - Portable $300,000.00 TBD $30,000.00 TBD $330,000.00 TBD C.3 D.3 Park, Park Fields, Cross Country & Parking and Circulation Shelter for Fields 4 & 5 Playground/Park Amenities $100,000.00 $250,000.00 $10,000.00 $25,000.00 $110,000.00 $275,000.00 E.2 Vehicular Circulation (South Stadium Expansion 130 spaces & East Stadium Parking Upgrades) $1,275,000.00 $127,500.00 $1,402,500.00 $ 13,625,500.00 $1,242,500.00 $14,867,500.00 A.1 A.1 A.5 A.3 Long-term Subtotal: $800,000.00 NA $800,000.00 * Lighting cost from Musco and includes their energy efficiency system, 25 year warranty including re-lamp and remote operation WakeMed Soccer Park Page 46 Facility Master Plan Update APPENDIX WakeMed Soccer Park Page 47 Facility Master Plan Update Appendix – A1 User Group Meeting - March 19th, 2009 – 7 PM Cary Senior Center Overview: 15 mins. – Introductions/Overview 20 mins. – break into groups (min. 5) 10 mins. – each group leader summarize 15 mins. – review survey/answer questions Staff in Attendance: Gail Taylor - PRCR, William Davis – PRCR, Athletics’ Manager, Keith Jenkins – PRCR, Facility Supervisor, David Crotts – PRCR, Assist Facility Supervisor, Doug McRainey – PRCR, Parks Planning Manager, Paul Kuhn, PRCR – Senior Parks PlannerMichael Sutton, AIA – Integrated Design User Group Attendance: Amy Olsen(Meredith), Chris Seaton(NC State), Lynn Harrell(NC Senior Games), Michael Feranec(Copperhead Football), Doug Shonk(TFC), Kelly McEleney(Peace College), Jenna Bailey(Carolina Soccer Club), Bill Koester (Meredith) Objectives of this planning effort include the following: 1. To update the master plan based on the Town of Cary’s current facility management and operating goals. 2. To develop a facility that is both a national soccer venue as well as community-based park accessible for local sports groups. 3. To define the ultimate scope and scale of the existing stadium in terms of overall seating capacity, specialized seating (loge, skyboxes, etc) and concessions. 4. To analyze both current and future circulation for accessing and exiting events. This analysis will include a review of the impact of the Trinity Road extension through the facility. 5. To analyze all remaining undeveloped land area within the soccer park to maximize use of entire facility. 6. To develop a priority list and schedule of capital projects necessary to achieve the updated master plan. # of organizations that use WakeMed Soccer Park: Over 60 - Over the past 4 years data is being gathered on facility use. - Facility use will very from year to year but an overall trend line is developing. - Weather, drought and other issues can affect field usage - For example in 2007 field useage had to be cut back due to the drought. - Facility is currently being maximized and groups are being turned away - Once a year a request for field usage is placed out to all the groups - Maintenance is the first item that is programmed - For fields 3 -7, one of the fields is off-line at a time for 7 days - A business plan is currently being developed with a lot of background info on the facility WakeMed Soccer Park Page 48 Facility Master Plan Update Group Discussion: 1. What are the reasons that your group chooses WakeMed Soccer Park, ie the positives or strengths of the park? Quality of facility Location of facility Cooperative staff Lighted fields (when available) Stadium - Appropriate for Senior Games XC course - affordable - one of only a few around (Greensborro and Charlotte) - don't have to repeat path - can handle large woods 2. What improvements could be made to WakeMed Soccer Park that would make it a better park for your group? Restroom for outlying fields Shelter near fields 6 & 7 (Ritter Park size) More fields - small sided fields More multipurpose fields Indoor Track facility is needed in area (200 M oval) - 5 or 6 lanes Concession s Cheaper fees for the fields More lighted fields Artificial Turf Add Land Playground Need water near XC course More stadium seating Egress from Park could be improved Pedestrian access to north side of stadium needed. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 49 Facility Master Plan Update Appendix – A2 Survey Results NC Adult Soccer Assoc. NC HS Athletic Assoc. NC Senior Games NC State Cross Country Peace College St. Timothy Triangle Flying Disc Triangle Futbol UNC #4 Meredith College Cross Country #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 5 5 na 5 5 4 3 4 2 5 3 5 na 5 na 5 4 na na 5 na 5 na 5 na na 5 4 na na na na Quality of playing surface field 4 na 5 na na 5 na na na na Quality of playing surface field 5 na 5 na na 5 na na na Quality of playing surface field 6 3 4 na na 5 na na Quality of playing surface field 7 3 4 na na 5 na Quality of playing surface field 8 na n/ na na 5 Quality of lighting for field 2 & 3 na 4 na na Quality of food served in concessions na na na Cleanliness of restrooms 4 na 5 Carolina Copper Heads Carolina Soccer Club Cary High School Meredith College #1 #2 #3 Rate Facility Quality for Your Group (1-5+) Amount and location of parking 3 3 Quality of playing surface field 2 na Quality of playing surface field 3 WMSP Master Plan Survey Cary Academ y Cross Country #15 TOTAL 5 4 56 5 5 na 48 5 5 5 na 29 3 4 4 4 na 25 na 3 4 4 4 na 25 na na 4 4 4 na na 24 na na na 5 3 4 na na 24 na na na na 3 3 2 na na 13 5 3 na na na na Na 5 4 na 21 na 3 4 na na na na Na Na na 1 8 na 4 4 4 5 4 4 5 5 4 48 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 50 Facility Master Plan Update Meredith College Cross Country #5 NC Adult Soccer Assoc. NC HS Athletic Assoc. NC Senior Games NC State Cross Country Peace College St. Timothy Triangle Flying Disc Triangle Futbol UNC #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 5 na 5 5 3 4 4 5 5 5 45 4 5 na 5 4 3 2 1 Na 4 5 33 Restrooms in close proximity to the field 4 3 na 4 4 5 4 4 2 4 4 38 Scoreboard for the field 3 3 na 3 4 1 5 1 1 1 4 26 Permanent seating for spectators for a field 2 3 na 3 5 4 4 1 1 1 4 28 Concession in close proximity to facilities 3 3 na 4 4 1 1 1 1 4 22 Parking Facilities in close proximity to facilities 3 4 na 3 4 5 5 2 2 4 34 Other support facilities 3 2 na 4 1 4 4 22 Other * Carolina Copper Heads Carolina Soccer Club Cary High School Meredith College #1 #2 #3 #4 Rate Importance to Your Group (1-5+) Quality of the playing surface 4 Lights for the field WMSP Master Plan Survey 4 4 Cary Academ y Cross Country #15 TOTAL Rate Importance to Cross Country Groups (1-5+) Quality of the running surface Restrooms in close proximity to the field Running clock for start / finish area for the field Seating for start / finish area Concession stand in close proximity to start / finish area Parking Facilities in close proximity to the start area Course signage Permanently defined starting/finish areas Sound system Other na na na na na na na na na na na na na na na na 5 4 3 3 2 4 5 5 3 5 4 3 3 4 1 5 5 5 1 5 3 3 1 1 2 4 3 3 5 3 4 2 4 4 4 4 5 4 5 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 5 5 3 2 1 5 5 5 1 5 4 1 4 2 4 4 4 4 33 27 19 18 12 23 30 29 25 6 WakeMed Soccer Park Page 51 Facility Master Plan Update WMSP Master Plan Survey NC Adult Soccer Assoc. NC HS Athletic Assoc. NC Senior Games NC State Cross Country Peace College St. Timothy Triangle Flying Disc Triangle Futbol UNC #4 Meredith College Cross Country #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 Carolina Copper Heads Carolina Soccer Club Cary High School Meredith College #1 #2 #3 Cary Academ y Cross Country #15 Potential Facility Improvements Additional fields for practice or games 10 1 10 11 1 1 5 na 10 2 2 9 7 1 10 1 10 1 1 2 1 3 Additional lighted fields 10 2 10 10 1 1 5 na 10 5 9 3 1 8 8 2 8 2 10 11 1 4 Conversion of natural fields to artificial turf 7 5 10 9 1 1 5 na 10 1 1 7 5 6 7 3 10 3 8 10 1 1 Additional restrooms for fields away from stadium 7 3 6 8 10 10 10 na 8 8 11 8 2 1 7 2 3 6 6 4 8 9 8 9 Additional park amenities (ie. Playground) 6 4 5 7 1 1 5 na 4 1 3 6 4 8 7 3 4 5 5 6 1 1 4 Better internal signage for locating facilities 3 8 5 6 9 9 5 na 7 3 6 1 6 2 1 11 2 10 1 9 1 3 5 8 Additional meeting space 2 9 4 3 10 8 5 na 7 1 5 2 5 5 5 2 11 2 7 1 4 10 10 Providing a picnic shelter for user groups 6 7 3 1 10 8 10 na 8 1 4 6 3 10 7 4 6 4 3 5 2 5 10 11 10 4 5 1 1 5 na 7 3 8 4 1 7 3 10 4 8 2 8 2 6 4 4 9 8 5 na 9 1 7 6 1 9 3 8 5 10 2 6 4 7 11 3 2 1 1 na 7 5 1 10 3 7 1 11 2 7 1 Additional safety lighting at night 4 Concession stands open during rentals 6 Scoreboards on outlying fields 4-8 3 Other Other 10 10 11 10 10 1 Comments: #1 Field availability August – Oct-Aug (only use 5 & 6) #6 -Fields need to be more affordable -Most expensive fields in the Southeast -Would love to host region or national events but cost do not fit budget -More access #8 -Add stadium seating #10 None of these relate to our needs (we only use field 2 during daylight) #12 In general, we favor more access to fields, whether plush ones or scrubby ones- everything else is pie in the sky. Our leagues need blocks of time that can be honored from week to week. we pursued lit fields in the winter months, perhaps we’d have more success booking fields. #14 Turf fields would help 6 5 2 TOTAL WakeMed Soccer Park Page 52 Facility Master Plan Update Appendix – A3 Interview Notes Local Soccer (26 March 09) Charlie – CASL Pete – Triangle Futbol Parking is adequate for clubs Toilets for Fields 6 & 7 No interest in playgrounds at soccer park – believes there is liability as parents watch soccer instead of watching kids on playground. Parents need to be by the fields. Park should have WiFi access for kids to do homework and parents to work between practices and games Safety structures near the fields for lighting storms More goals (smaller) Lighting on 4, 5, 6, and 7 At least two fields should be synthetic turf. Any synthetic turf field should have lighting. Not sure how much foot candles are needed but amount on Field 2 and 3 is plenty. Not interested in scoreboards on other fields. Seating at other fields would be fine as long as it wouldn’t effect the size of the field. Doesn’t like the ‘permanent tents’ Build a space that could be flexible for meetings and other needs Add seats to Koka Booth Stadium and more lighting 2 more locker rooms are needed Concessions upgrades for cooking Place for a Photo Op – people often take some at the concrete soccer ball. Turf Fields should probably be Fields 4 & 5 Turf is good for training – games should be on grass Futbol club has 8 field locations, mostly in Durham Wouldn’t mind seeing club signs in the park Needs more netting behind goals, especially on Field 8 Needs better way-finding system Needs more traffic control for cross-country Portable bleachers Class rooms for Officials and Teams Spectator Cover and Club Boxes for Stadium would be fine College (26 March 09) David Whitfield – ACC Jeff and Dee Ann Keller – NCAA Have had Men’s & Women’s Championship games in 03, 04, 05 and alternated men’s and women’s in 06 & 07 Also use Disney, Flordia St. Campus, Maryland Soccerplex Needs media workspace WakeMed Soccer Park Page 53 Facility Master Plan Update Needs Video Board and manpower who knows how to run it 4 total locker rooms Best thing about Soccer Park is the quality of the fields, even has high quality practice fields. Priorities include lockers, press, and additional seating Parking is difficult getting in and out – consider shuttles Tents aren’t always great on windy nights for media workspace Not really using lockers or showers – teams just need space to dress and meet, restrooms are important, TV, grease board – dual purpose rooms Soccer locker rooms need a little less space than lacrosse which has a large squad, but otherwise similar needs. Could use an athletic training room. Officials should be kept in different locations that the teams. Tents have been about 40x40 with sound, lights, heat, and wireless. Have been draping lines around the back field and using loud generators. Inflatables and interactive devices will all need power. Stresses the need for video board – PSA, trivia, interviews, mic – anthem Lacrosse Our location may be a little too “south” for lacrosse. Would need more room on sidelines and safety net at goals. Koka Booth In 2011 the championship games may be combined with men and women at the same location at the same time. Our seating capacity is Ok, but could use a little more (10,000 mentioned for combined event) Width of concourse is small. Need to increase the lighting foot candles on Koka Booth. Lights from main stadium cause issues with goal keepers on Koka field. Temporary press location was Ok. Locker room were tents and players accessing them mean going through spectators. Needs more Concessions! Cross Country Needs grand structure for good identification of start & finish Video Board could be brought in (mobile) Needs Awards staging and results posting place General Preferences Prefer a natural grass playing surface for soccer, synthetic turf is fine for lacrosse and soccer practice. Covered Seating is not required or expected. Railhawks (26 March 09) Brian Wellman Number 1 priority is Concessions Video Board is very high up on their list. Grow TV Contracts Interested in hosting men’s national team Could use Office Space / Classroom Space Interested in how much the park exceeds the required number of restrooms. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 54 Facility Master Plan Update Discussed at length about seating at the stadium. Indicated that members in the Railhawks organization are torn between if covered seating is more important or more seats. Quality of seating is important with more seats with seat backs and is interested in the idea of a Concessions Terrace with view of the game. Would like to see Club Boxes and covered areas for spectators, but priority list was 1 Concessions 2 Seats 3 Video Board Cross-Country (20 April 09) ACC Championship this year at University of Miami Distance from start line to first curve should be about 600m – is currently around 450m Materials – crush and run on trail is working well Current track is not fan friendly (parents). Tracks want looping, but not lapping European tracks usually have 2k loops Not crossing the road would be positive NCAA recommends maintaining 30’ width. Current width is not causing problems – ok for regional and Div. 2. Current distance is 5k 6, 8, 10k distances currently don’t have. Course could use power outlets Pavilion is needed, but not necessarily a press area. Needs to have a map of the course and tiered awards stage. Needs PA System Great American event has a 4-5,000 attendance. About 2,500 + 1,600 athletes. “Pie in the Sky” Wish list” Permanent finish line structure Crowd control – keep parents from crossing course WiFi – for opertations and to mount cameras on the course – video could be streamed to the web or to a video board in the park. Mats to cover any road crossing Foot bridge over to the south parcel Greenway easements from developers on the south parcel Other notes Needs a longer run up @ finish line for Nationals Feedback from others suggest too many rocks on our start / finish Some call it a track because of the crush and run surface may be a little too fast Perhaps a play area or golf Frisbee course at this location. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 55 Facility Master Plan Update Appendix – A4 Meeting Minutes – Athletic Committee Cary Parks Recreation and Cultural Resources Department Athletic Committee Meeting July 29, 2010 Cary Town Hall, Room 1130 Call to Order/Roll Call Ed Langan called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. Members Present – Ed Langan, Jeff Trendel, Randall Bennett, Walker Reagan, Andy McRee, Pete Burke, King Prather, Larry Miller, Ken Berry, Taylor Slade Absent – Tom Griffin, Caycee Dorrier Staff – Ted Jeffcoate, Paul Kuhn Adoption of Agenda The committee reviewed the July agenda. Action: Pete Burke made a motion to accept the July agenda, second by Jeff Trendel, motion carried by a unanimous vote. Adoption of Minutes The committee reviewed the May minutes. Action: Walker Reagan made a motion to accept the May minutes, second by Larry Miller, motion carried by a unanimous vote. Public Speaks Out None PRCR Advisory Board Update At their most recent meeting, the members of the Advisory Board toured the downtown arts building under construction. Board members were impressed with the facility, and pleased that everything appears to be moving along on schedule. League Representative Reports Baseball – Pete Burke – No report Softball – King Prather – No report Girls Basketball – Larry Miller – No report Boys Basketball – Ken Berry – No report Teen Council Report – Taylor Slade – No report Staff Reports – Ted Jeffcoate – No report WakeMed Soccer Park Master Plan discussion & recommendation Staff distributed a handout that contained a text change from the report originally distributed at the May meeting. The small change clarified the parking situation as contained in the Master Plan. Staff indicated that, if recommended, the Master Plan would be taken to the Advisory Board at their August meeting. Walker Reagan asked whether there were plans to widen Chatham Street. Staff did not know of any WakeMed Soccer Park Page 56 Facility Master Plan Update immediate plans, and indicated that stadium expansion to 10,000 could be accommodated without a widening of Chatham. If the stadium is expanded to 15,000, Chatham will need to be widened. Walker asked for a recap of how the stadium would be expanded, for those who did not attend the May meeting. Andy McRee asked what the NCAA and ACC requirements were for the stadium. Staff indicated that 10,000 seats were needed, and larger team room space was needed. Ed Langan asked how many competing facilities there are nationwide. Staff indicated that the master planners looked at 6-12 similar facilities nationwide, and that WakeMed Soccer Park is in the middle of that group by capacity. Randall Bennett asked whether the extension of Trinity Road is imminent. Staff indicated that it was not, and that extension would depend on other market forces. Action: Larry Miller made motion to recommend the plan, seconded by Walker Reagan, passed by unanimous vote. Spring Baseball/Softball Issues Staff indicated that the spring baseball and softball season went well. However, there was a conflict following the protest of a Colt league tournament semi-final. A team played a farm team player more than they played a regular team member, which is in violation of the farm team rules. The proscribed penalty, which was enforced at the tournament game, is a forfeit. Some parents associated with the team that lost by forfeit did not take the decision well, believing the penalty to be excessive. The committee members discussed whether changes to rules or procedures for farm teams would be appropriate. Walker Reagan asked whether the scorekeeper could help coaches track playing time, as they do in basketball. Pete Burke sympathized with the coach, as he has seen that happen accidentally in the past, but believes the responsibility should remain with the coach to follow the rule. Larry Miller, King Prather, and Randall Bennett all indicated that they felt the game forfeiture was an appropriate penalty. Several committee members expressed a willingness to make recommendations on any rule changes staff would like to consider. Maintaining quality coaching staff Staff described a situation toward the end of the youth softball season in which an 18 & Under coach displayed very unsportsmanlike conduct following his team’s final regular season game. Staff’s decision was to suspend the coach for the post-season tournament. Staff also discussed a Pony baseball coach who, it is clear, lacks the knowledge and teaching ability to coach older players. Staff indicated that both of these situations help illustrate the fact that some changes to the coach selection and training process need to be considered. Pete Burke suggested that the athletic committee and/or staff might interview all coaches new to a league. King Prather indicated that the great majority of coaches are placed appropriately, but that a system needs to be in place to handle problem coaches. He suggested rigorous use of independent reviews of coaches and parental feedback. Walker Reagan stressed the importance of having a quality training program for coaches who are having problems. Ken Berry stressed the importance of making sure any criteria for removing coaches are objective. Several committee members agreed that maintaining the highest quality coaching staff is very important, and they would happy to help in any way they can. Adjourned 7:09 p.m. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 57 Facility Master Plan Update Appendix – A5 Meeting Minutes – PRCR Advisory Board Parks, Recreation and Cultural Resources Advisory Board MEETING MINUTES DRAFT August 2, 2010, 5:15 p.m. Cary Town Hall – Conference Room #11130 316 North Academy Street – Cary, NC 27513 www.townofcary.org Attendance: Dennis Hoadley, Chair; Jeff Boucher; Robert Bush; Sal Cammarata; Tullie Johnson; Ed Langan; David Lindquist; Neema Patel; Kay Struffolino; Teen Council Representative; Don Frantz, Council Liaison Staff: William Davis; Dwayne Jones; Doug McRainey; Linda Smith; Gail Taylor; Mark Johns; Larry Dempsey, Public Works. I. Call to Order/Roll Call – Denny Hoadley, Chair II. Adoption of the August 2, 2010 Meeting Agenda – Denny Hoadley, Chair ACTION: Kay made a motion to approve the August agenda as presented; David Lindquist seconded the motion. The motion carried by a unanimous vote. III. Adoption of June 7, 2010 Meeting Minutes – Denny Hoadley, Chair ACTION: Kay noted two spelling corrections and with that noted, made a motion to approve the June 7th minutes; David Lindquist seconded the motion. The motion carried by a unanimous vote. Chair Denny Hoadley shared a thank you note from former PRCR Director Mary Henderson for her retirement gift from board members. --Proclamation: July National Parks and Recreation Month in Cary – Chair Denny Hoadley accepted the proclamation at the July council meeting. Town Council Member Don Frantz presented the Proclamation on behalf of the Mayor and Council and made favorable comments about the boards’ work in helping to make Cary one of the greatest places to live. IV. Public Speaks Out - None V. Special Presentation ► Woolly Adelgids/Hemlock Bluffs Nature Preserve – Larry Dempsey, Facility Division Manager, Public Works Recreation Manager Dwayne Jones passed out copies of the press release telling of the recent discovery of Hemlock Woolly Adelgids at Hemlock Bluffs. Larry Dempsey, Facility Division Manager for Public Works and the project manager for treating these insects gave an overview of the discovery and the treatment process. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 58 Facility Master Plan Update The insects have impacted about 11 of the Preserve’s 234 Eastern Hemlock trees and, if left unchecked, will kill Hemlocks by feeding at the base of their needles preventing nutrients from flowing to the needless. Mr. Dempsey noted that the Town is collaborating with the divisions of the NC Department of Environment and Natural Resources, the United States Forest Services, North Carolina State University; Bartlett Tree Experts and others to finalize a multi-phased approach to eliminate existing Adelgids. Laura White, Facility Manager and Mark Johns, Naturalist were commend for proactively updating the Hemlock Woolly Adelgid management plan (created in 2005) and the recent infestation discovery during their Hemlock Tree inventory. The Preserve will remain open to the public, treatment, nor do the insects, pose any threats to people, pets or other plants. Citizens wishing to share ideas, questions, comments or concerns about the Hemlock Woolly Adelgid at Hemlock Bluffs Nature Preserve may email [email protected] or call (919) 387-5980. For regular updates and project information, visit Woolly Adelgid at www.townofcary.org and follow the Town on Twitter @TownofCary. VI. LAND DEDICATION – Doug McRainey, Parks Planning Manager - None VII. Reports ►Administration -- WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan – Paul Kuhn, Senior Parks Planner Paul presented the Plan to this Board at the June meeting for review and it comes before the Board this evening for action. Paul noted the Master Plan was approved by the Athletics Committee at its July meeting. Pending action by this Board, the Plan will move forward to Town Council in September. Mr. Kuhn made reference to Board member concerns with regard to traffic flow and parking with the proposed increased stadium seating. Paul addressed those concerns in Attachment 1 of the minutes. MOTION: Kay Struffolino made a motion to accept the WakeMed Soccer Park Facility Master Plan as proposed at the June meeting, including the edits (Attachment 1); the motion was seconded by Tullie Johnson. Discussion: Board members asked about NCAA requirements for seating. It was noted that this plan meets the current minimum seating requirement of 10,000. Parks Planner Paul Kuhn noted that this plan can ultimately, incrementally provide for seating 15,000. The bid packet guarantees a minimum of 10,000 and that we will offer seating for the number of tickets sold beyond 10,000 with temporary seating. Athletics Manager William Davis noted that Cary is currently competing with 5 solid venues for NCAA events. Also noted, that even with more seating; Cary may still loose the bid as more stadiums come onboard each year. Mr. Davis did comment that other major conferences return to Cary; they like the locations and working with staff. Parks Planning Manager Doug McRainey commented that the Team Facility will go back to Council requesting that concession funding be appropriated for designing the Team Facility and Additional funds are anticipated from the Hotel Occupancy Tax. Paul commented that the Town continues to look for opportunities to purchase land between the facility and Interstate 40. ACTION: The motion carried unanimously. Chair Denny Hoadley commended Paul Kuhn for his work on the Master Plan. ►Public Meetings - None WakeMed Soccer Park Page 59 Facility Master Plan Update ►Staff Reports – PR11-01 Artwork Donations from Don Mertz and LD (Lori) White/Town Council (7/15) ►Parks Planning --Greenways Committee Report – Robert Bush, Chair Robert noted two presenters at the July meeting: 1) Karen Gray, Deputy Town Clerk explained emails and public records and 2) Deanna Boone, Deputy Public Information Officer talked about the Use of Social Media. The Committee talked about the renovations taking place at Annie Jones Park and Parks Planning Manager Doug McRainey briefed members on the process, soon to begin, for updating the Town’s Parks, Greenways and Bikeways Master Plan. Mr. Bush commented on the publics’ interest with ‘picture taking’ with the sculptures recently installed on the Black Creek Greenway. --Doug McRainey, Parks Planning Manager Doug noted that staff is developing the Scope-of-Service for the Parks, Greenways and Bikeways Master Plan. Staff’s goal is to submit the Request for Proposals to consultants in September; with a January 2011 ‘kick-off’. ►Athletics --Athletics Committee – Ed Langan, Chair Ed reported the Committee voted to approve the proposed WakeMed Soccer Park Master Plan. Additionally, the Committee is working to streamline the current Inclement Weather Policy and staff is also working with Committee members to have a plan in place for the spring season to improve sportsmanship among our coaches. --Athletic Division – William Davis, Athletics Manager William referred members to the Program Update and noted a few of the recent high profile events at Cary facilities: Pony Nationals; USTA National Zone Team; USTA Women’s Nationals. William noted that 4 area hotels are onboard for the NCAA Championship City Program and staff recommend those hotels for other event goers as well. Board Chair Denny Hoadley asked if revenues from the recent events are reflected in the Manager’s Quarterly Report. PRCR Operations Analyst Bruce Crocker provided Board members with copes of the report. It was noted that the naming contract for WakeMed Soccer Park expires the end of 2010. – ►Cultural Arts --Cultural Arts Committee – David Lindquist, Chair David noted the Committee welcomed two teen representatives in addition to their one teen representative returning for a second year. Members listened to a presentation by a representative of the American Turkish Association of North Carolina telling of their origin and their anticipation of the April 2011 3rd Annual Nazim Hikmet Poetry Festival at the Page-Walker Arts and History Center. The Association was particularly complimentary of the facility and staff for their support of the 2010 Festival. Committee member Phil Shepard is coordinating planning efforts for cultural arts organizations to participate in the Cultural Arts Row at Lazy Daze. On sale that day, historic lockers from old Cary Elementary. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 60 Facility Master Plan Update --Festivals Committee Report – Kay Struffolino, Liaison Kay provided members with handouts capturing committee updates for June and July. The Committee is focusing on Lazy Daze, August 28th. Volunteers are needed to assist staff and artisans throughout the day; volunteer information sheets were included in board member packets. Cultural Arts Manager Lyman Collins challenged board members to continue Honorary Festival Committee Member Herb Young’s legacy of volunteering. Herb took great pride in enlisting volunteers for our festivals. --Cultural Arts Division – Lyman Collins, Cultural Arts Manager Lyman remarked on several pieces of public art: 1) the two recently installed bus shelters with art components; 2) the brick sculptural benches, first installation of a three part project that will incorporate artwork along Black Creek Greenway; next phase, wing walls of the tunnel and four brick plinths at the pedestrian bridge that will cross the railroad tracks Also noted FOHB has forwarded their recommendation to the Public Art Advisory Board for the Hemlock Bluffs gate artist. Lyman mentioned the upcoming Marvelous Music Series identified in the brochure and also that tickets are now on sale for the August 28th production of Shakespeares Twelfth Night at the Koka Booth Amphitheatre. With Twelfth Night, the same day as Lazy Daze, staff is hopeful event attendees will take advantage of both events and spend the night in Cary give a boost to the economy Chair Denny Hoadley reintegrated the need for volunteers at Lazy Daze and asked board members to consider helping. ►Recreation Programs --Senior Center Report – Kay Struffolino, Liaison Kay provided members with a handout of recent activities. Kay did note the recent 6th Annual Yard Sale netted $572.00 for each participating senior club; largest revenue producing yard sale event for the Cary Senior Center. Staff continues to plan for a December celebration of the 10th Anniversary of the Cary Senior Center facility. --Hemlock Bluffs Report – Tullie Johnson, Liaison Tullie provided members with a handout of recent activities noting the following: ---the Town received an REI grant for $20,000 for boardwalk repairs, trail edgers and creek bank revegetation; ---Friends of Hemlock Bluffs (FOHB) recommended an artist for the Hemlock Bluffs entrance gate. This recommendation will go before the Public Art Advisory Board and then onto Town Council for approval; ---Two upcoming adult programs: Nature at Night/August 7th and Yoga in Nature/August 7; ---FOHB Yard Sale, Saturday, October 30th; drop off days October 28 & 29. ---Teen Council Update – Teen Representative Teen Council Vice Chairman reported. Members were provided with a handout of recent activities noting participation numbers for May and June: teen participation in May: 770 members contributed 1433 volunteer hours; and in June: 254 members contributed 1815.25 volunteer hours. The annual Cary Teen Council Awards Picnic took place May 18th. In addition to award presentations, the Lazy Daze Scholarship was presented to Wesley Lo. Other notable achievements for 2010: Cary’s Teen Council was the recipient of the 2010 Voluntary Service Award presented by the National Recreation and Park Association. Teen Council coordinator Cindi King will accept this award at the national convention in October. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 61 Facility Master Plan Update Cary will have two members on the State Youth Council this year and Cary’s Teen Council, for the 5th year in a row, received the Most Diverse Council Award. Teen appointments to nine Parks, Recreation and Cultural Resources’ boards and committees were also announced. ►Goals Committee Reports ---Scholarship Program – Sal Cammarata Sal reported data for the quarter ending in June: Scholarships served 50 families through full, partial and payment plans. Scholarships served a total of 79 participants through full; partial and payment plans. Funding to date: Revenues, $38,728; Scholarships approved in 2010, $27,565 and a balance of $11,163. Sal announced plans are underway for the second scholarship fundraiser; a ‘Corn-hole Toss Tournament’. The tournament will take place September 25, at the last Railhawk season game. As plans are finalized, further details about the event will be announced. PRCR Advisory Board Chair Denny Hoadley asked about the Town’s involvement in the Black Creek Watershed. Parks Planning Manager Doug McRainey noted that the Town’s Stormwater Management Division attends the watershed meetings. Mr. McRainey will contact them for an update and also about any plans to shut down portions of the Black Green Greenway. Mr. McRainey did note the funding will be requested in FY12 to work with the Black Creek Watershed group. VIII. New Business ►Annual PRCR Report to Council Board members received a ‘draft’ staff report highlighting the PRCR Board’s activities for 2010. Board members were asked to email Denny if they felt additional information should be included. Mr. Hoadley did ask about capturing the contributions the teens are making not only in the community but as board/committee representatives. Recreation Manager Dwayne Jones noted that a separate staff report to Council would address the teens’ contributions as well as the growth of Teen Council and the impact on staff. Mr. Hoadley noted that at the August 26th Council meeting, he would summarize the report; talking about the highlights; the 10-year business plan going forward; the board’s positive impact as well as plans to continue to move forward with Safety Town as soon as funding is available.. ►PRCR Committee Recruitment Schedule – Chair Denny Hoadley announced the recruitment has begun for committee members of the Athletics; Cultural Arts and the Greenways Committee. The deadline for applications is October 8, 2010. ►Volunteer Recognition Picnic, September 19th at Koka Booth Amphitheatre – Chair Denny Hoadley asked Board members to mark September 19th on their calendars; invitations to the picnic will be mailed in September. ►Citizen Board Member State Forum/Greensboro/ August 13 - Chair Denny Hoadley told Board members that he and Dwayne Jones, Recreation Manager will be attending the Forum. ► Proclamation designating July 2010 as Park and Recreation Month in Cary – Chair Denny Hoadley reported accepting the Proclamation earlier in the agenda. IX. Old Business ►Board Member Information Share --North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences – Tullie Johnson noted two exhibits: Glow, Living Lights now open and Bug Fest 2010 will run September 11, 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. --PRCR Quarterly Report – PRCR Budget Analyst Bruce Crocker provided members with the quarterly report as requested earlier in the evening by Chair Denny Hoadley. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 62 Facility Master Plan Update --Space Camp – Board member Sal Cammarata commented that his children attended space camp at Middle Creek Community Center and thoroughly enjoyed the camp experience. Sal highly recommended the camp and hats off to camp staff. --Sculpture Exhibits – Cultural Arts Manager Lyman Collins reported that this month Cary Visual Arts will be replacing the temporary sculpture exhibit on Town Hall Campus. On August 19th, the Cary Chamber will host Business After Hours at the Page-Walker with a walking tour to view the sculptures. X. Adjourn ACTION: Kay Struffolino made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 6:45 p.m.; the motion was seconded by Tullie Johnson. The motion carried by a unanimous vote. Please contact the Department of Parks, Recreation and Cultural Resources with any questions about the minutes. The e-mail address is [email protected], and the phone number is (919) 462-3961. WakeMed Soccer Park Page 63 Facility Master Plan Update Appendix – A6 Stadium Graphics PLAZA EXPANSION WAKEMED SOCCER PARK LOWER LEVEL PLAN BUILDING "C" TEAM ROOMS KOKA BOOTH STADIUM SEATING EXPANSION EXISTING 2,500 SEATS LUXURY SUITES ABOVE LUXURY SUITES ABOVE PARKING EXPANSION EXISTING 2,000 SEATS GRANSTANDS TO SEAT 2,000 SEATING EXPANSION ABOVE EXISTING 2,500 SEATS Job Code: SCSPMP SEATING EXPANSION ABOVE Date: DEC 09 CONCESSIONS PLAZA ABOVE WAKEMED SOCCER PARK MID-LEVEL PLAN PLAZA EXPANSION BELOW BUILDING "C" FLEX SPACE KOKA BOOTH STADIUM SEATING EXPANSION EXISTING 2,500 SEATS LUXURY SUITES LUXURY SUITES PARKING EXPANSION GRANDSTAND EXPANSTION TO SEAT 2,000 EXISTING 2,000 SEATS GRANSTANDS TO SEAT 2,000 GRANDSTAND EXPANSTION TO SEAT 2,000 CONCESSIONS PLAZA +/- 600 SPECTATORS EXISTING 2,500 SEATS Job Code: SCSPMP Date: DEC 09 CONCESSIONS AND TOILETS WAKEMED SOCCER PARK UPPER LEVEL PLAN PLAZA EXPANSION BELOW BUILDING "C" BELOW KOKA BOOTH STADIUM SEATING EXPANSION EXISTING 2,500 SEATS LUXURY SUITES LUXURY SUITES PARKING EXPANSION GRANDSTAND EXPANSTION TO SEAT 2,000 EXISTING 2,000 SEATS GRANSTANDS TO SEAT 2,000 GRANDSTAND EXPANSTION TO SEAT 2,000 GRANDSTANDS TO SEAT 1,500 EXISTING 2,500 SEATS Job Code: SCSPMP Date: DEC 09 LUXURY SUITES WAKEMED SOCCER PARK ROOF AND CANOPY PLAN EXISTING 2,000 SEATS GRANSTANDS TO SEAT 2,000 GRANDSTAND EXPANSTION TO SEAT 2,000 CANOPY EXPANSION EXISTING 2,500 SEATS NEW CANOPY ABOVE GRANDSTAND EXPANSTION TO SEAT 2,000 CANOPY EXPANSION GRANDSTANDS TO SEAT 1,500 WITH CANOPY ABOVE EXISTING 2,500 SEATS Job Code: SCSPMP Date: DEC 09 EXISTING GRANDSTANDS LOWER LEVEL ACTIVITY AREA NEW CONCESSIONS PLAZA NEW GRANDSTANDS WAKEMED SOCCER PARK CONCESSIONS PLAZA AND SEATING EXPANSION CENTER FIELD BLDG. A ROOF CANOPY AND LIGHTS PARKING Job Code: SCSPMP CONCESSIONS TOILETS LUXURY SUITES Date: DEC 09 BLDG. B PLAZA BLDG. B ROOF