Polloway, Edward A. and Lubin, Jacqueline
Transcription
Polloway, Edward A. and Lubin, Jacqueline
0 . Graphic Models and Instructional Tools for Students with Special Needs Edward A. Polloway and Jacqueline Lubin LYNCHBURG COLLEGE APRIL 2016 1 To the Reader: This document is intended for educators with interest in students with special needs. It provides various graphical models and instructional tools that relates to teaching reading, writing, math, social studies and science to students with disabilities. The paper is divided into four sections: reading, writing, math, social studies and science. In each section, multiple examples of models are provided. The information provided can be used for general knowledge, as part of course content in special education classes and/or as reference material. The authors acknowledge the work of Allison Meade in developing an earlier edition of this document. 2 Table of Contents SECTION ONE: READING a. Key Reading Components ............................................................................................... 5 b. Model for Consistent Deficit Effects in Reading .............................................................. 6 c. Hypothesized Mathew Effects ........................................................................................ 7 d. Phonological Considerations........................................................................................... 8 e. Stepping Down: Elements in the Alphabetic Principle ..................................................... 9 f. Phonics Generalizations ............................................................................................... 10 g. English Language Phonemes ........................................................................................ 11 h. Assessment of Oral Reading ......................................................................................... 13 i. Word Recognition Emphases ....................................................................................... 14 j. Vocabulary Development ............................................................................................. 15 k. 50 High-Frequency Words for Older Students .............................................................. 16 l. Survival Words ............................................................................................................ 17 m. Morpheme Meanings: Examples and Non-Examples..................................................... 18 n. Bound and Free Morphemes ....................................................................................... 19 o. Most Common Prefixes ................................................................................................ 20 p. Example of Semantic Mapping ..................................................................................... 21 q. Reading Comprehension: Informal Assessment Techniques ......................................... 22 r. Graphic Organizer for Summarizing: Peer-Mediated .................................................... 24 s. Main Idea Map ............................................................................................................ 25 SECTION TWO: WRITING a. Narrative Story Frame .................................................................................................. 27 b. Writing Process ............................................................................................................ 28 c. Using a Story Map: Snow White.................................................................................... 29 d. Writing Characteristics ................................................................................................. 30 e. Use of Pronouns ........................................................................................................... 31 f. Story: Cluster Sentences (Sentence Combining) ............................................................ 32 g. Paragraph Graphic Organizer ........................................................................................ 33 h. Four Strategies for Composition Writing ....................................................................... 34 i. High Utility Words ....................................................................................................... 35 j. Graphic Organization for an Explanation Paragraph ...................................................... 36 3 k. Post-Writing Learning Strategy ..................................................................................... 37 l. Noun-Verb Agreement ................................................................................................. 38 SECTION THREE: MATH t. Problem Solving: Dilemmas & Strategies ...................................................................... 40 u. Problem-Solving Strategy: SOLVE-IT .............................................................................. 41 v. Problem Solving Strategy: Determining Correct Computation ....................................... 42 w. Strategy for Solving Word Problems: Look & Create, Select Usefully, Revise and Restrategize if necessary .................................................................................................. 43 x. Simple Math Computation Matrix ................................................................................ 44 SECTION FOUR: SOCIAL STUDIES AND SCIENCE y. Social Studies Acrostics ................................................................................................. 46 z. Social Studies Acronyms ............................................................................................... 48 aa. Keywords for Social Studies .......................................................................................... 49 bb. Graphic Organizer: Two Variant Models ....................................................................... 50 cc. Science Acronyms......................................................................................................... 51 dd. Science Acrostics .......................................................................................................... 52 4 Section One: Reading 5 Key Reading Components 6 Model for Consistent Deficit Effects in Reading 7 Hypothesized Mathew Effects 8 Source: Adapted from Brenda Virgile and used with permission 9 Stepping Down: Elements of the Alphabetic Principle 10 Phonics Generalizations Rule Examples Exceptions (numbers) Utility Rate Ch= 1 sound church (103) - (0) 100% Ee= long deem (85) keen (2) 98% -are (care) bare (9) are (1) 90% Silent e tone (180) gone (106) 63% 2 v’s walking lead (309) been (377) 45% Medial vowel Vowel ends 1 syllable word west (408) she (23) cold (249) to (88) 62% 21% r sound born (484) fire (134) 78% ow as long flown (50) clown (35) 56% y vowel =long “i” sky (29) sunny (170) 15% c=s before e, i city (66) ocean (3) 96% c=k before a, o car (143) - (0) 100% 11 English Language Phonemes Consonant Phonemes Vowel Phonemes Phonetic Spelling Example (Common Phonetic Spelling Example (Common Symbol Graphemes) Symbol Graphemes) /b/ ball /a/ bar /d/ dig, down /æ/ sat, after /f/ fish, photograph /ai/ by, pie, dry /g/ mug, goal /aʊ/ now, south /h/ home, hot /ɔ / claw, thought /j/ yet /ɔɪ/ choice /k/ cup, luck, kale /e/ pet /l/ lazy, call, lap /ei/ reign, play /m/ more, hammer /i/ tea, flee /n/ name, knife /o/ fox /p/ pig /ou/ grow, boat /r/ run, wrap /u/ blue, influence /s/ cite, same /ʊ/ boot, food /t/ Time, trap /ʊə/ poor, manure /v/ vote /^/ cut /w/ what /ɜ/ purse, prefer /z/ zip, zebra /dз/ judge, ridge 12 /l з / treasure /∫/ nation, ship /t∫/ / perch, church /ŋ/ sing /θ/ thing /ö / mother, them 13 Assessment of Oral Reading Adapted from Language Instruction for Students with Disabilities (4th ed., rev.), by E. A. Polloway, L. Miller and T. E. C. Smith, 2012, Denver, CO: Love Publishing (p. 272) 14 Word-Recognition Emphases 15 Vocabulary Development 16 50 High-Frequency Words after did his school through always done inside semester two any because each first just subject what morning teacher where become friend need teenager which black give open tell while book great people the white choice help please their why class her remember there yes could here run they your 17 Survival Words and Phrases Beware of dog Exit Keep away No turns Restrooms Boys Exit only Keep closed On Slippery when wet Bus Stop Flammable Keep off One way Slow down Closed Girls Keep out Off Smoking prohibited Danger Go Ladies Open Step down Do not cross Help Men Out of order Stop Do not enter Help wanted No parking Poison Walk Do not touch Hospital zone No right turn Private Warning Don’t walk Hot No smoking Pull Watch your step Down Entrance In Information No swimming Push Women No trespassing Quiet Wrong way Adapted from Polloway, E. A., & Polloway, C. H. (1981). Survival words for disabled readers. Academic Therapy, 16, 446- 447. 18 Morpheme Meanings: Examples and Non-Examples Morpheme: Meaning Prefix/Suffix/Root Example Non-example bi- two bicycle binder un- not unlikely unite pan- all pandemic panther -ject to throw interject subject -hood body of people priesthood likelihood port to carry teleport report post after postdate poster -able capable of being suitable table -pel- to drive compel spelling 19 Bound and Free Morphemes Free Morpheme Bound Morpheme boy un- cat -able tree -er gentle -s man -ceive port -ful post de- script -atic- script -tion book -ing 20 Most Common Prefixes Prefixes Example Un- unfaithful Re- reconnect In- incredible Dis- disappoint En- endanger Non- nonsense Im- impractical Over- overanalyze Mis- misfortune Sub- sublet Pre- prejudge Inter- interlock Fore- aforementioned 21 Example of Semantic Mapping 22 Reading Comprehension: Informal Assessment Techniques Strategy Description and Implementation Change questioning Cloze Passages Direct observation Informal Reading Inventories Oral Reading Speed Pocket Vocabulary Retelling Running Record Vary type of questions asked If student is not responding correctly to literal questions; change to interpretive or vice versa. Note this and watch for improvement Model how to respond to various types of questions Include a paragraph (or set of paragraphs) with missing words at strategic points Student read the passage and use context clues to determine the missing word Scoring rubric is used to determine comprehension level Observe student in different texts- informational text is more difficult Take notes and keep in student file Form and test hypothesis for instruction Helps determine independent, instructional, and frustrational reading levels Student reads a set of graded word lists and reading passages (orally and silently) Student is asked comprehension questions at varying levels Score determines reading level Choppy reading - analyze for decoding issue of word or whole phrase Helps develop fluency Student has to ‘pocket’ word for vocabulary that has been introduced Known vocabulary should kept in ‘pocket’ at all times Requires student to recall parts of a story, for example, “tell me about you just read” Ask for more details if student do not say much, by rephrasing the question or making it more specific, for example, “what happen after…” Works for entire passage, and specific word issues Helps with recalling of facts, sequencing, and developing vocabulary Requires student to read from text of known readability level Listen to student read roughly 100 words in book used for reading instruction Mark check for each word read correctly Write in word said (and write underneath word that should have been said) 23 Strategy Think Alouds Description and Implementation Helps determine student’s reading instructional level Student openly share thoughts about reading material. It could be before, during or after reading. Activates prior knowledge, and so leads to more inferential thinking It helps teacher know how student is processing text as it provides information on student understanding of the reading material Source: Adapted in part from Reading Comprehension: Strategies for Independent Learners, by Blachowicz and Ogle, 2001. Developed by Jeri Watts, Lynchburg College, 2015. 24 Graphic Organizer for Summarizing: Peer-Mediated Strategy Summarizing What do I know after reading? _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ What questions/answers do I have for my buddy/partner? _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ What answers do I have for my buddy/partner? _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ How can I summarize what I read in one paragraph? _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ 25 Main Idea Map 26 Section Two: Writing 27 Narrative Story Frame Narrative Story Frame Characters _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ Setting _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ Plot _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ Conflict _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ Resolution _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ 28 Writing Process 29 Using a Story Map: Snow White Questions Who are the characters? Answers Snow White Seven Dwarfs Wicked Queen Prince Charming Magic Mirror Where does it take place? A faraway land When does it begin? Once upon a time What is the problem? Snow White is in an enchanted sleep due to a poison apple What is the goal? To awaken Snow White with true love’s kiss Magic Mirror reveals Snow White is the fairest in the land Wicked Queen tries to have Snow White killed Snow White escapes and meets Dwarfs. Snow White eats poison apple. Prince Charming kisses Snow White What are the events? What is the result? The prince and Snow White live happily ever after. Polloway, E. A., Meade, A. L., & Lubin, J. (2015). Graphical models and instructional tools in reading, writing and math for students with special needs. Lynchburg College Journal of Special Education, Lynchburg College, Lynchburg, VA. 30 Writing Characteristics Stages of Writing Planning Transcribing Revising Editing Revising/Editing Unskilled Writer Skilled Writer 31 Use of Pronouns Pronouns it’s (or) Question Can you replace the word with: it is or it has ? Applicability Yes→ Example it’s No→ its Can you replace the word with Yes→ who’s who is or No→ whose Yes→ use I its ? who’s (or) whose ? who has ? I (or) Is I/me the SAME person as the subject of the sentence? (“The winner was I.” Winner and I are the same person) me ? No→ use me (1.“Sally called me.” Sally and me are not the same person. 2. “The ball hit me.” Ball and me are not the same person.) Stan and me (or) If you take “Stan” away, is it still right? Yes→ Keep what you have* *remember “be polite,” and put yourself last. No→ Switch to the other one* Stan and I ? *remember to “be polite,” put yourself last Adapted from Scott, J. (2011) and used with permission. 32 Story: Cluster Sentences (for Sentence Combining) 1. It was her birthday. 2. She was very happy. Cluster: ____________________________________, and she__________________________. 3. She had planned all year for her party. 4. She had reserved the location with a swimming pool. Cluster: As a result of ___________________ , she was able to_________________________. 5. Her father had assisted her. 6. He was very helpful too. Cluster: Her father, ________________________, had __________________________. 7. Her father had ordered all the decorations. 8. She was very surprised when it came a month before her birthday. Cluster: Prior_____________________________, and she__________________________. 9. She was bubbling with joy. 10. “I love you daddy,” she whispered in his ear while she hugged him. Cluster: Feeling _________________________, she said “_____________________________.” 33 Paragraph Graphic Organizer 34 Four Strategies for Composition Writing 35 High Utility Spelling Words a am as be best boy children down far found give hand her how it left look me next off other ran said she stop the think together up was when woman about and at because better but could each fast friend go happy here i it’s let made my night on our red sat show story them this too us water where work after another away been big by day eat find from good has him if jump like make name no once out ride saw small take then thought try very we who yes again any back before blue call did even first fun got have his in keep little man need not one over right say so tell these through two walk went why you all are bad began book come do ever fly get grow he home into know live many never now only play room school some than they time under want were will your always around ball behind box can does every for girl had help house is last long may new of or put run see something that thing to until way what with zoo 36 Graphic Organization for an Explanation Paragraph Explanation Writing Provide setting background (for task to be explained) First, (initial step) Second, (second step) Third, (third step) Finally, (last step) 37 Post- Writing Learning Strategy 38 Noun-Verb Agreement Source: Adapted from Carry Mays (n.d.) 39 Section Three: Math 40 Problem Solving: Dilemmas and Strategies 41 Problem-Solving Strategy: SOLVE-IT S ay the problem to yourself (repeat) O mit information not needed L isten for clue words V change vocabulary to numbers, symbols* E write math equation I ndicate the answer T ransfer answer to problem’s context 42 Problem Solving Strategy: Determining Correct Computation Miguel had 60 cents. He spent 38 cents for lunch. How much does he have? Do you have the big number (name total)? Do you need the big number (need total)? Same size/equal groups? / X Different size/unequal _ + 43 Strategy for Solving Word Problems: Look & Create, Select Usefully, Review and ReStrategize if necessary Look for operational terms in word problems Create Select Use a concrete or mental picture of word problem a strategy to be used that strategy Review strategy and solution Re-strategize if answer is incorrect 44 Simple Math Computation Matrix Add, no distractor Add, with distractor Subtract, no distractor Subtract, w/ distractor 1 digit, 2 items Mary had two apples. Her brother gave her two bananas. How many fruits does she have? Mary had two apples. Her brother gave her two bananas and a lollipop. How many fruits does she have? Mary had nine apples and five bananas. Her brother ate two apples and one banana for lunch. How many fruits does she have left? Mary had nine apples and five bananas. Her brother ate one banana, one carrot and two apples for lunch. How many fruits does she have left? 2 digit, 2 items Jon bought 22 pencils and 17 pens. How many items did he buy? At the bookstore, Jon bought 13 pencils, 12 pens and 10 magazines. How many pens and pencils did he buy? Jon bought 22 pencils and 17 pens. He gave 10 pens and 13 pencils to his best friend. How many pens and pencils does he have left? Jon bought 22 pencils and 17 pens. He gave 10 pens, 12 magazines and 13 pencils to his best friend. How many pens and pencils does he have left? 45 Section Four: Social Studies & Science 46 Social Studies Acrostics Category Data to be Learned Assassinated Lincoln, Garfield, American McKinley, Kennedy Sample Acrostic/s Lunatic gunmen maliciously killed. Presidents Cabinet offices ( in order of creation,1-25) State, Treasury, Defense, Justice, Interior, Agriculture, Commerce, Labor, Health/Human Services, Housing & Urban Development, Transportation, Energy, Education, Veterans’ Affairs, Homeland Security See The Dog Jump In A Circle and Leave Her House To Entertain at Virginia Homes in the Suburbs Central America nations Mexico, Belize, Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama Confederate States (seceding from Union) Virginia, North Carolina, Virgil needs fundamentally good teaching Florida, Georgia, Texas, methods about learning ability techniques Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, Arkansas, Tennessee Continents Africa, Asia, Antarctica, Australia, South America, Europe, North America First 16 American Presidents George Washington Washington Adams Just Made Many John Adams Admirers, Thomas Jefferson James Madison ==== James Monroe John Quincy Adams _______________ (in order) My best girl, Elizabeth, has no Cocoa Puffs! 4As simply exhibit necessity 47 Category (Lubin & Polloway, 2016) Data to be Learned Sample Acrostic/s Andrew Jackson Martin Van Buren William Henry Harrison John Tyler ___________________ Juggling Various Heavy Trumpets. James Polk Zachary Taylor Millard Fillmore Franklin Pierce James Buchannan Abraham Lincoln_ ==== Please Try Following Pretty Boy’s Legacy. Oceans of the World Southern, Arctic, Pacific, Indian, Atlantic Silly Ants Play In Attics Virginia Geographical Regions Tidewater, Piedmont, Blue Ridge, Shenandoah Valley, Appalachians Tim Picks Blue Stars Again 48 Social Studies Acronyms Category Data to be Learned Continents 4ANSE Africa, Asia, Antarctica, Australia, North America, South America, Europe Huron, Ontario, Michigan, HOMES Erie, Superior Great Lakes Sample Acronym James, Potomac, Rappahannock, York J-PRY Allied Powers France, Italy, Russia, England FIRE Central Powers Turkey, Austria-Hungary, Germany TAG Virginia Rivers of Chesapeake Bay Watershed WWI Powers 49 Keywords for Virginia State Capital Keyword for Virginia is Virgin (Oil). Keyword for Richmond is Rich-Man. Keywords for Connecticut State Capital Keyword for Connecticut is Connect. Keyword for Hartford is Heart. Source: Lubin, J., & Polloway, E. A., (2015). Mnemonic instruction in science and social studies for students with learning disabilities: A review. 50 Graphic Organizer: Two Variant Models Considerations Evolution Core Focus Explains variety and complexity of life forms on Earth Evidence gleaned from scientific research More than 3.5 billion years old Source of Position Life on Earth Belief system Implication Scientific method: testable theories supported by multiple lines of evidence Teach scientific method as best means of understanding natural world Creationism (Intelligent Design) Explains origins of earth and life forms Biblical interpretation based on Book of Genesis Approximately 6000-10,000 years old based on literal reading of Genesis Faith in strict Biblical interpretation and believe in its inerrancy Teach creationism as reflection of belief via Biblical interpretation 51 Sample Science Acronyms Category Data to be Learned Sample Acronym Characteristics of living animals Movement, Reproduction, sensation, Growth, Respiration, Excretion, Environmental Sensitivity, Nutrition red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo, violet Bananas, rice,apples, toast pancreas, pituitary, hypothalmus, adrenal, ovaries, testes, thyroid Cnidarians, Annelids, Mollusks, Sponges, Echinoderms, Arthropods MRS GREEN Life Cycle of a Butterfly Egg, Larva, Pupa, Adult EL PA (“the father”) Main Insect Body Parts Newborn Vital Signs (after Virginia Apgar) Parts of Atom head, abdomen, thorax HAT Activity, Pulse, Grimace, Appearance, Respiration APGAR protons, electrons, neutrons PEN Parts of the Pistil Stigma, Ovule, Ovary, Style SO2S Plane Take-off Preparation Controls, Instruments, Gas, Altitude indicator, Radio CIGAR Primary Parts of Seed Seed Coat, Embryo, Endosperm SCEE (“see”) Simple Machines Pulley, gear, jackscrew, axle and wheel, inclined plane, lever PG JAIL Stroke Warning Face: does one side droop? Arm: does one drift downward, cannot be raised? Speech: sound slurred or strange? Time: identify time of symptom Call 911 immediately Fish, amphibians, reptiles, mammals, birds FAST…. as in Think FAST Colors of Rainbow Diet for Diarrhea Endocrine Glands Invertebrate classes Vertebrate Classes ROYGBIV BRAT TOPP HAT CAM SEA (“calm sea”) FARM-B 52 Sample Science Acrostics Category Data to be Learned Sample Acrostic/s Colors of Rainbow red, orange, yellow, green, Riding on your grandmothers’ bike (that) is violet. blue, indigo, violet Layers of the Earth Crust, Mantle, Core (inner), Core (outer) CMC2 Lifecycle of cells interphase, prophase, metaphase, anaphase, telophase, cytokinesis Icy penguins make Antarctica too cold. Metrics King Henry’s deeds brought deep cheers to many. Order of Mohs Hardness Scale Metric prefixes: kilo-, hecto-, deca-, (base), deci, centi-, millitalc, gypsum, calcite, fluoride, apatite, orthoclase feldspar, quartz, topaz, corundum, diamond Parts of the Flower stamen, pistil, receptacle, sepal, petal Sister Paula received six prizes. Plant Life Cycle seed, seedling, flower, mature plant Some singers frequent music places. Properties of matter Mass, density, volume, weight Monkeys dance very well Problem, Research, Form Scientific a hypothesis, Test Method (a) (Humphrey, n.d.) hypothesis, Observations, Conclusion Scientific Method (b) Observe, Inquire, Hypothesize, Experiment, Conclude Texas girls can fly and other quiet things can do. People run faster than old chimps! Only Ivan has eight cats. 53 Category Data to be Learned Sample Acrostic/s Simple Machines Pulley, gear, wheel, inclined plane, lever Poor Gary wants ice-cream lowfat Solar System (planets by size) Mercury, Mars, Venus, Earth, Neptune, Uranus, Saturn, Jupiter Men March to VENUS Joyfully. Solar System planets in sequence (after Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune (Pluto) My Very Eager Mother Just Served Us Nachos (but not Peanuts) Pluto’s demise) Taxonomic Classification Types of Environmental Pollution kingdom, phylum, class, King Phillip came over for great soup. order, family, genus, species Air, Thermal, Water, Altogether, Tom’s wife, Victoria, learned Visual, Land, Noise, Light nine languages.