Download/View EMAS Statement
Transcription
Download/View EMAS Statement
T h e Av e n u e R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t Environmental Statement Validated Statement 24 July 2007 Ted Rosser EMAS Verifier T h e Av e n u e 3 Environmental Statement site location R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t The Avenue Project Introduction The overall aim of The Avenue project is to regenerate the site of the former Avenue Coking Works near Chesterfield. The project is being promoted by the East Midlands Development Agency (emda), who owns the site, with funding provided by National Regeneration Agency English Partnerships through the National Coalfields Programme, European Structural Funds and the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI). Introduction and scope of this Environmental Statement This statement includes: resource use welcome message from Mike Fenton, emda Avenue Project Director waste generation and disposal introduction to The Avenue project, organisation and The Avenue site ecology and biodiversity the remediation strategy and works to date the Environmental Management System (EMS) description and discussion of the significant environmental aspects and impacts: contaminated land and groundwater water environment and sewers traffic and transportation legal compliance communication overall project goals looking ahead to next year contacts glossary Welcome message from Mike Fenton, emda Avenue Project Director The Avenue project aims to reclaim the highly contaminated former Avenue coking plant and chemical works bringing it back into effective re-use for leisure, recreation and economic regeneration via provision of a nature reserve, sports facilities, new job opportunities and housing. emda are committed to carrying out this project in the most sustainable manner possible and using it as an opportunity to promote best practice in this and other fields. This includes extensive public/stakeholder involvement and we see this document as a valuable tool to communicate and inform the stakeholders about the measures that are being implemented to continually improve the environmental performance of the project. Every fact and figure in the statement is third party validated by LRQA who are giving their affirmation that we are carrying out our commitments.” Mike Fenton The west of the site is bounded by the A61 trunk road and to the east by the Midland Mainline Railway. Residential housing is located close to the site; the nearest is situated to the south and west, adjacent to the A61 trunk road. Another residential area is located approximately 400m to the southeast. other environmental performance climate change and air quality including nuisance “The Avenue project is a major environmental and regeneration challenge for the East Midlands Development Agency (emda). National Regeneration Agency English Partnerships, our funders through the National Coalfields Programme, emda and the project team are committed to leading and promoting best practice and in keeping with this commitment, welcome to the first EMAS Environmental Statement to be produced for The Avenue project in Chesterfield, Derbyshire. The Avenue site is located approximately 30km north of Derby and 3km south of Chesterfield and covers an area of 98 ha. It is approximately 3,200m long north to south and approximately 700m east to west at its widest extent. Arial view of the Avenue site in 2001 This Environmental Statement is the first prepared for The Avenue project. The Statement provides a brief description of the project, the significant environmental aspects associated with it and the measures implemented to reduce the negative environmental impacts. Also included is a summary of the progress made to date. This statement has been prepared for the financial year April 2006 to March 2007 and reports details of the environmental performance of the project during the last two financial years (April 2005 to March 2007) as a baseline. The final part of the statement describes the measures east midlands development agentcy (emda) and the project team are committed to implementing up until the end of this financial year (to March 2008). this is in order to continually improve the environmental performance of The Avenue project. The Avenue Site Organisation Following privatisation of the UK coal industry in 1994, ownership of the site passed to English Partnerships (EP) in 1996, along with 56 other former colliery and industrial sites. In 1999, ownership of the site was transferred to (emda), who is now responsible for delivering the reclamation of the site. Funding for the project is provided by EP through the National Coalfields Programme, with further monies provided by the DTI and European Structural funds. The management team consists of: emda, the site owners jacobs, lead consultants and designers, supported by their sub-consultants Turner & Townsend Project Management (TTPM), project managers and cost consultants, and The Environment Partnership (TEP). The majority of site works is carried out by contractors; the contract for the overall remediation of the site is being procured in three stages: Stage one comprised the collation of information about the site and development of an outline remediation strategy in order to prepare a tender for the detailed design of the remediation. Following a pre-qualification exercise, the stage one tender was submitted to seven tenderers in May 2005. The tenderers completed their submissions by August 2005 and in April 2006 VSD Avenue, a joint venture consisting of Volker Stevin, Dec NV and Sita Remediation (with Entec, the consultant advising VSD) were awarded the stage two contract. Stage two is currently nearing completion. It comprises the detailed design of the remediation, including phasing of the earthworks and the design of the contaminated material treatment. It also includes the agreement of the overall target price for completion of the project. VSD Avenue has submitted a planning application and supporting environmental statement to Derbyshire County Council on behalf of emda in May 2007, and will also obtain all licences and permits required to undertake the works. The stage three contract will be awarded at the end of stage two. This Environmental Statement primarily covers stage two activities. www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 4 Environmental Report 5 The Avenue Remediation Strategy and works to date Historic activities at the site The Avenue Coking Works opened in 1956 as a fully integrated facility to produce smokeless fuels and associated coke carbonisation by-products. These included benzole, tar and sulphuric acids. The plant also produced town gas, which was supplied for domestic use in Chesterfield. The plant was constructed on a series of level terraces formed by cut and fill earthworks. Other parts of the site were used for stockpiling coal and coke and for the disposal of waste products. The site contained a waste tip and settlement Lagoons for the disposal of solid and liquid wastes. Disposal in the Lagoons was based on the ‘attenuate and disperse’ principal, which was an accepted technique at the time. Contamination from the site, particularly the waste tip and Lagoons, is known to have polluted the River Rother that runs through the north of the site. The former plant also contaminated the underlying soils through leaks and spills from the numerous tanks, pipelines and sumps. Following closure in 1992 the works lay disused until emda commenced the task of dismantling the plant structures and cleaning the site in 1999. The majority of the above ground structures have now been removed, apart from some areas of hardstanding, most notably the High Level Stocking Area (HLSA) and other smaller areas within the former plant area. Background Remediation of the site is required in order to mitigate or reduce potential risks to human health and the environment and enable return to beneficial use. The remediation is undertaken on a voluntary basis. However, a ‘do nothing’ approach is not an acceptable alternative. If emda had not progressed voluntary actions, it is likely that The Avenue site would be declared as ‘contaminated land’ under Part IIA of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 by North East Derbyshire District Council (NEDDC) and a remediation notice would be served to emda requiring remediation of the site as a legal requirement. Non-compliance with the requirements of the remediation notice is likely to lead to prosecution by the Environment Agency. emda aim to implement remediation and reclamation of The Avenue in an economically and environmentally sustainable way. The proposed landform and masterplan, designed by Rick Mather and TEP respectively, and the remediation strategy are focussed on achieving this goal. Spent Oxide, known as ‘Blue Billy’ from the gas purification process found on the waste tip Avenue chemical plant in 2001 Prior to construction of the coking works, the site had contained The Avenue Colliery, which was later expanded to include a lime and iron works. By 1938, historic maps show that the colliery, lime and iron works were all disused and large areas of the site had returned to agricultural use. The site also has a history of near-surface and underground mining, and included within the boundary is the former Old Avenue Colliery, located in a separate area on the eastern side of the railway. www.theavenueproject.co.uk Sampling of sediments from Lagoon 2 The most significant sources of contamination are the waste tip and sludge Lagoons. In addition, contamination is found in soils in the former plant area. When emda took ownership of the site large parts of the former plant had been laying dormant for a number of years. Some of the structures, tanks and pipes were unsafe. This had the potential to cause environmental harm through leaks and drips, as not all hazardous chemicals had been removed following closure of the plant. Progress to date In order to address urgent safety concerns a programme of demolition and drain down of the above-ground tanks, pipelines and underground sumps commenced in 1999. Another early action was the precautionary stabilisation of the Lagoon 2 Bund adjacent to the River Rother in 2000 and 2001. This Bund had been identified as being unstable and failure could have led to significant environmental impacts. Between 2000 and 2001 a detailed site investigation was undertaken, which aided characterisation of the soils and development of a conceptual model of the site. The results of this initial investigation have been supplemented by additional investigations, the most recent of which was an investigation by VSD Avenue between autumn 2006 and spring 2007. Soil and water samples were taken, chemically tested and the results assessed in order to scope the contamination problems. Risk assessments were undertaken which considered human health receptors and the water environment, mainly the River Rother. These set out thresholds for contaminants of concern and specific material reuse criteria which were reviewed by the Environment Agency and North East Derbyshire District Council. The final reuse criteria were agreed by these Regulators in February 2005 and May 2007 respectively. From the outset, emda has been committed to incorporating the principles of sustainability in the strategy for the reclamation of the site. Previously acceptable solutions, such as offsite landfill disposal or on-site encapsulation became undesirable in view of new legislation, and this paved the way for the investigation and employment of more innovative remediation techniques. A number of remediation trials were conducted between 2001 and 2004 in order to identify the most suitable techniques for the remediation of contaminated materials at The Avenue. Trialled techniques included: Bioremeduation trial Contamination from historic activities at the site Historic activities at The Avenue site have led to contamination of the ground, which poses risks to humans and to the water environment, particularly to the River Rother. The contamination is mainly in the form of organic substances, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and inorganics such as cyanides (found in spent oxides, also known as ‘Blue Billy’, used in the gas purification process). Some areas also contain heavy metals, and asbestos containing materials were found in the waste tip and some of the site structures and buildings. This was completed in early 2003 with the removal of remaining tar waste from site. Tank with tar in plant area during demolition Stage three will comprise the remediation of The Avenue site. Depending on all required permits and consents being in place at the end of stage two, mobilisation of plant and equipment is envisaged to commence January 2008. Remediation of the site, including all landscaping works, is expected to be completed by 2012. bioremediation, which uses microorganisms such as bacteria to degrade organic contaminants soil stabilisation, in which soils are mixed with a binder such as cement to chemically and physically stabilise and immobilise contaminants to minimise release to the environment soil washing, in which contaminants are separated and concentrated into a sludge fraction that can be removed from the treated soil using water or an aqueous solution www.theavenueproject.co.uk R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 6 thermal desorption, which uses hot air to heat the soils and convert (desorb) contaminants from solid or liquid states into the gaseous phase, which is extracted from the soil and treated separately to destroy the desorbed contaminants In January 2005 work began on reclaiming and landscaping the former rail sidings area. This area of land stretches south for about 1km from Mill Lane to Bridge Street and was the route of the old rail sidings, along which coal was transported to the coke ovens. The works included the creation of a bridleway access for pedestrians and wheelchair users, cyclists, and horse riders, and pasture for the grazing of livestock. In the western part of this area, a section of Redleadmill Brook has been regraded and a wetland created. This is designed to be suitable for the translocation of water voles (another protected species) that currently inhabit the River Rother in the northern section of the site that will be A remediation strategy for the site has been developed by Jacobs in consultation with and agreed to by the Regulators: the Environment Agency and North East Derbyshire District Council (NEDDC). Derbyshire County Council (DCC) as the local planning authority is reviewing the planning application for the remediation. The former rail sidings are now managed by Derbyshire Wildlife Trust (DWT). The Vision The vision for remediation and reclamation of The Avenue is to return the site to beneficial use, including public open space and a development platform for high quality homes and employment, in an economically and environmentally sustainable manner. The strategy describes the reclamation works necessary to mitigate against or reduce risks to humans and the environment. It will result in the redevelopment of the site such that it is suitable for its proposed end uses. In order to achieve a high quality landform for the regenerated site, emda and EP organised a national design competition to produce a masterplan and development strategy. Entrants were invited to submit visions for the regeneration and development of The Avenue and associated conceptual designs. The preferred submission was made by Rick Mather Architects. The detailed masterplan, which was based on the Rick Mather Architects design, was finalised by TEP (The Environment Partnership). The masterplan includes a platform for mixed use development, which incorporates a range of recreational, leisure and community facilities as well as wetland habitats. The proposal also includes the remediation of the River Rother in the northern section of the site. This includes the environmental enhancement of the floodplain and creation of habitats for water voles, great crested newts, butterflies, bats and other species. The public open space includes an events area and amenity and sports facilities, such as football/rugby pitches and a cricket pitch. View of wetlands The Project Team sought public views on the proposals during five consultation events that took place over a two week period in January and February 2005, finishing with an open day at the site. Many useful comments were received during and following the events that were considered in the final proposal. The masterplan aims for a ‘material balance’, i.e. the creation of a final landform that utilises the soils and materials available on site. This sustainable approach reduces the need for both the transport of surplus soils for offsite disposal, and the import of additional materials onto site. The project also includes the creation of a flood alleviation scheme which has been promoted by the Environment Agency to benefit properties in Chesterfield downstream of The Avenue site. www.theavenueproject.co.uk Proposed masterplan Newt habitat Due to the presence of certain protected species, in particular great crested newts and grass snakes, a series of ecological exclusion works have been undertaken to minimise the negative impacts of the works. For example, special fencing has been erected to separate a ditch located along the eastern boundary from site activities. This ditch acts as a receiving habitat for newts translocated from areas that have to be disturbed during site works. This existing habitat was enhanced by the creation of additional ponds, and now supports a significant population of great crested and other newts, as detailed further in the ‘ecology and biodiversity’ section. The Remediation Strategy Due to the range of contamination encountered at The Avenue, no one single technique will provide the optimum remediation solution for the site. It is estimated that approximately 423,000m3 of materials require treatment prior to reuse by bioremediation or thermal desorption. Bioremediation has been found to be suitable for the treatment of moderately contaminated soils, which applies to approximately 218,000m3 of material. Thermal desorption has been shown to be highly effective in treating significantly contaminated materials; in fact some materials, Thermal desorption treatment trial in Rotterdam Of particular benefit to the project were the results of a thermal desorption trial completed in a plant in Rotterdam, the Netherlands in March 2004. This demonstrated the technical and economic feasibility of the technique and allowed emda to make the decision not to implement plans to excavate and dispose of in an offsite landfill the contaminated sediments from Lagoons 2 and 4. disturbed during future remediation works. This habitat is also suitable for various species of birds, particularly waterfowl and waders. The strategy aims to reduce as far as possible the offsite disposal of materials. Some of the soils have been identified as suitable for reuse without any or with only limited treatment. However, significant volumes of materials are too contaminated and require treatment prior to reuse. As described above a number of remediation techniques have been investigated for technical effectiveness, but also assessed in terms of environmental and sustainability impacts, with consideration of public perception and financial implications. The most suitable techniques, including physical screening, soils washing, thermal desorption and bioremediation, have been taken forward to the detailed design stage. Proposed works The remediation strategy developed by Jacobs envisaged that approximately 1.58 million m3 required excavation to meet the proposed landform and to remove contamination. Of these 1.58 million m3, approximately 530,000m3 were identified as requiring treatment by thermal desorption, bioremediation or soil washing and approximately 70,900m3 required offsite disposal to landfill. The remediation strategy created by Jacobs is being developed further by VSD. This detailed design also takes account of additional information obtained during stage two which has led to a revision of the quantities, which are summarised below. Of the approximately 1.98 million m3 of material identified for excavation, approximately 1.6 million m3 (including an allowance for bulking of the materials following excavation) is expected to be suitable for reuse on site with little or no treatment. This applies to, for example, concrete, bricks and other large oversized items, which although they will require screening, crushing and grading and potentially soil washing, are then expected to be suitable for use. Environmental Report such as most of the Lagoon sediments, are not considered suitable for any other treatment. Approximately 205,000m3 of material will probably be treated by thermal desorption. Some items, such as metals, plastics, rubber, asbestos containing materials and other wastes will be segregated during the works. These materials are not suitable for treatment or reuse and will be sent offsite for recycling if possible or disposal if not. It is estimated that approximately 60,800m3 of such materials, mainly from the waste tip, will be excavated and segregated. In order to achieve the proposed beneficial end-use of the site, the near surface soils will need to be suitable media for the growing of plants. There is currently a shortage of suitable materials on site and a soil strategy has therefore been developed that includes the treatment of existing soils with imported organic material. Approximately 140,000m3 organic material needs to be imported to site to create approximately 577,000m3 of ‘horticultural soils’. This option is considered more sustainable than and preferable to the importation of top soil from offsite. Total material excavation (m3) Total material for treatment (m3) Treatment by thermal desorption (m3) Treatment by bioremediation (m3) 1,980,000 533,000 205,000 218,000 www.theavenueproject.co.uk 7 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 8 Environmental Report The Avenue Environmental Management System Although the project is ultimately envisaged to significantly improve the local environment, emda and the project team members recognise that there is potential for significant environmental impacts to occur before the overall aim is achieved. emda and the project team are committed to continually improving environmental performance in order to reduce negative impacts on the environment associated with the site, and wherever possible, to generate environmental benefits. To ensure that all work at The Avenue is carried out in an environmentally responsible manner, an Environmental Management System (EMS) has been developed and will be implemented at the site for the duration of the project. The Avenue EMS is in accordance with the requirements of, and has been certified to, the International Standard ISO14001 since 2001. Lloyd’s Register Quality Assurance (LRQA) regularly audits the implementation and maintenance of the EMS. The EMS covers the site and all site activities are included in its scope. As part of the commitment to the EMS the project team ratified an Environmental Policy in November 2001. The Policy is implemented through the setting of objectives and targets and monitoring of progress. It is reviewed at least annually. The EMS establishes the Site Environmental Rules (SERs), which cover good site practice and housekeeping; water and wastewater; waste management; storage, use and handling of hazardous substances; emissions to air and statutory nuisance; and conservation and ecology. All site activities must adhere to the SERs. Presented below are the identified current and predicted future significant environmental aspects and impacts associated with the project. Also included are descriptions of current and recent environmental performance in these areas and measures undertaken to reduce environmental impacts. Environmental performance is checked on a regular basis by the site management through environmental inspections and audits. In addition, all site personnel can raise environmental concerns via the Health, Safety and Environmental Concern Forms. An environmental suggestion box system is being implemented which aims to aid continual improvement of environmental performance through involvement of all site employees. Contaminated Land and Groundwater Historic use of the site has left a legacy of contaminated ground on the site. The most significant contamination is found in the former waste tip and two sludge Lagoons. The waste tip also contains small amounts of asbestos containing materials. Whilst all chemicals and hazardous materials have been drained from the over-ground pipes and tanks, which have subsequently been demolished, residual hazardous chemicals are also present in below ground pipes, tanks, and sumps. These could not be accessed during the previous drain-down and demolition works. Significant Environmental Aspects and Impacts A detailed review of the site condition and activities has been undertaken in order to establish the significant environmental aspects of The Avenue. Environmental aspects result from the interaction of the project with the surrounding environment; the review assessed what the potentially significant resulting (positive or negative) environmental impacts of this interaction would be. On the basis of this assessment a series of environmental Objectives and Targets have been developed, which aim to address the environmental aspects and reduce negative environmental impacts where possible. The significant aspects and associated Objectives and Targets are reviewed at least annually. Measures, such as fencing and 24 hour security, are in place to restrict access and prevent direct contact with contaminated materials and hazardous chemicals, which help reduce associated health risks. However, contamination can leach and migrate from the above sources into the underlying ground and the shallow perched groundwater, and also potentially into the deeper groundwater found beneath the site. Some of the groundwater, particularly the shallow sources, provides baseflow to the River Rother, contamination of which can lead to a reduction of river water quality. This in turn can have a negative effect on flora and fauna living in and adjacent to the river. The removal and treatment of contaminated materials is expected to prevent future leaching and migration of contaminants into the shallow groundwater. The significant aspects have been grouped into seven categories: contaminated land and groundwater climate change and air quality Climate Change and Air Quality including nuisance An ambient air quality monitoring programme has been implemented at The Avenue since 2001. The programme, which is operated by Bureau Veritas (BV), includes for the monitoring of: PM10 (particulate matter with a diameter of less than 10µm), deposited dust, and at one on-site and one offsite station PM2.5 (particulate matter with a diameter of less than 2.5µm) metals (arsenic, cadmium, chromium, copper, mercury, manganese, nickel, lead, selenium and zinc) organic compounds: polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), phenols and BTEX (benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene and xylene) cyanide nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and sulphur dioxide (SO2) The programme includes four on-site monitoring stations close to the site boundary to assess cross-boundary migration of pollutants, and six offsite stations to assess the resulting impact on the surrounding area. A weather station is operated at The Avenue site to relate the air quality information to meteorological conditions. In addition to the permanent stations, targeted air monitoring is also undertaken around specific site operations; results are used to supplement data from the permanent stations. The results are assessed on a monthly basis and a report of the findings is published on The Avenue website (www.theavenueproject.co.uk/Air_Monitoring). During the remediation uncontaminated and contaminated water will be separated through a system of cut-off ditches and ponds prior to treatment and reuse or discharge. Shallow groundwater encountered in excavations will be pumped and treated in an onsite wastewater treatment plant. Where possible, this water will be reused during the site works, e.g. for dust suppression, or discharged to sewer under a discharge consent. resource use waste generation and disposal water environment and sewers ecology and biodiversity and traffic and transportation View of waste tip edge and Lagoon The Environment Agency has agreed that deep groundwater that is unlikely to provide baseflow to the River Rother will not require treatment as this would be considered to create little benefit for high costs. However, removal and treatment of the identified contaminated source materials would reduce further contamination of the groundwater associated with the site. The Avenue Environmental Policy Statement www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk 9 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 10 The main significant climate change and air quality aspects are associated with emissions from site vehicles, plant and equipment. During remediation of the site, emissions to atmosphere will also be generated by soil treatment operations, particularly the thermal desorption plant, and from disturbance of contaminated materials. Presented below are the average monthly results for PM10 at the on-site monitoring stations A - D between April 2005 and March 2007. station A - immediately adjacent to the site offices (northwestern corner of the site) station B - adjacent to the eastern boundary, just south of the bear pits and the Lagoons station C - further south along the eastern boundary, approximately half way along A gap exists in the data for station D for November and December 2006. This was due to a loss of electrical power to the station on 16 October, when the former Ruberoid plant was decommissioned. The station was connected to an alternative power source in January 2007. Other determinands, such as Benzene, were also compared against assessment criteria that are based on AQOs. Concentrations of Benzene were low during the period and did not exceed the assessment criterion. Further discussion of air monitoring results is included in the ‘Other Environmental Performance’ section. station D - on the western boundary, adjacent to the former Ruberoid plant The graph shows that the concentrations were below the assessment criterion level at all on-site monitoring stations during the period. PM10 data is continuously logged in 15 minute intervals with this information converted to 24 hour means for comparison with the AQO of 50 µg/m3 as a 24 hour average. These 24 hour means are also converted to monthly averages and compared to the AQO of 40 µg/m3 as an annual average. Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 c 2 N tob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 5 nu 20 a Fe ry 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 2 b 00 O er 6 c 2 N tob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 6 nu 20 Fe ary 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar ch 07 20 07 PM10 (_g/m3) The remaining emissions from the site, including from vehicles and plant, disturbance of contaminated materials such as the Lagoons and other treatment systems such as bioremediation, are envisaged to be mainly particulates, metals, organics and cyanide. This pollutant is considered to be relevant to activities at the site. The levels have been compared to the assessment criterion developed for the project, which is based on the statutory Air Quality Objectives (AQOs) applicable to local authorites. The on-site monitoring stations are located as following: www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk Air monitoring station Emissions from the thermal desorption plant stack differ somewhat from other site emissions. They are envisaged to be carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx: NO and NO2) and sulphur dioxide (SO2) from treatment of contaminants and combustion products from the fuel used to heat the soil. These emissions will be monitored continuously in the stack. CO2 is associated with climate change, while NOx and SO2 are mainly associated with acid rain and a reduction in urban air quality (through generation of photochemical smog in combination with volatile organic compounds and sunlight). A dispersion modelling exercise has been undertaken to predict emissions generated during remediation of the site. This is used to assess the dispersion of emissions and their likely concentrations at different receptors, including residential properties, close to the site. The results of the exercise suggested that emissions would not cause the quality of the surrounding air to reduce below appropriate standards and that there are therefore not expected to be significant impacts on the health of humans close to the site. Environmental Report 11 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 12 Environmental Report Directional Dust levels 2005-2007 During remediation activities dust could be generated from excavation, treatment, stockpiling and transportation of dry materials, such as soils or concrete. Dust suppression measures will be employed, including the use of water sprays to limit dust arisings. Presented overleaf are the monthly results of deposited dust monitoring at all on-site monitoring stations between April 2005 and March 2007. The graph indicates that exceedances were experienced on four occasions at station B, and five occasions at station C. On all occasions, as soon as data became available, measures (such as dust suppression and street sweeping) were taken to address the problems. Most of the exceedances were recorded between April and August 2005, at which time works on-site included the creation of the rail sidings habitat and wetlands. This involved the excavation, haulage and temporary stockpiling of soils; the associated increase in site traffic could have lead to the excessive dust generation. During remediation activities mitigation measures will be implemented to reduce the generation of dust, which may include damping down and cleaning of site roads. It is important to note that this criterion is a threshold above which dust has the potential to cause nuisance, and is not directly related to human health effects. Furthermore data collected from other monitoring stations indicates that the dust did not migrate offsite to cause negative impacts on sensitive receptors. www.theavenueproject.co.uk Odour A number of substances at the site are inherently odourous and have the potential to cause offsite nuisance, even where the source substances are at very low concentrations. Odours can be generated through disturbance of contaminated materials, particularly from Lagoons 2 and 4 sediments and the waste tip, and its handling, transportation, stockpiling and treatment. Odours are considered unlikely to be released from the thermal desorption plant stack or the treated materials, but could be generated from bioremediation. Trial of odour suppressant spray during disturbance of Lagoon 4 sediments Furthermore, the total fuel consumption does not include fuel used by other contractors. In the year April 2005 March 2006 site works by other contractors included the creation of the railsidings habitat and in the following year, a subcontractor of VSD completed the additional site investigation. No fuel consumption data was available for these pieces of work. In the future a more accurate system to collect representative fuel consumption data will be implemented. Under dry atmospheric conditions dust can be generated from site roads through movement of plant and vehicles, particularly on unsurfaced haul roads. Dust can also arise under dry, windy conditions from stockpiles of dry materials. The main impact of wind-blown dust is considered to be nuisance to site neighbours if transported beyond the site boundary. Ap ril M 200 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 005 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 2 5 ct 0 N obe 05 ov em r 20 0 D ec ber 5 em 2 be 005 Ja r nu 20 0 Fe ary 5 br 2 ua 00 ry 6 M 2 ar 00 ch 6 2 Ap 00 ril 6 M 200 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 006 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 20 0 b O er 6 ct 2 N obe 006 ov em r 20 0 b D ec er 6 em 20 0 Ja ber 6 nu 20 Fe ary 07 br 2 ua 00 ry 7 20 M ar ch 07 20 07 The biggest users of fuel on site are contractors rather than emda and the Project Team. The total amount of CO2 released from use of fuel and electricity generation during 2005 - 2006 was 103 tonnes, compared to 134 tonnes during 2006/07. The higher CO2 generation in 2006/07 is considered to be due to the use of more fuel for site works, in particular for the over-pumping of the River Rother during culvert repair works. The figures include fuel consumption of site vehicles and mobile plant from emda and fuel consumption from VSD. However, the VSD data is not precise as only a total figure for fuel consumption over various months was available which has been divided by the number of months. Dust Dust mg/m2/day The most significant sources of CO2 emissions are currently associated with the use of diesel fuel for site vehicles and mobile plant. CO2 is also emitted during the offsite generation of electricity in power stations. Electricity is used in the site offices (lighting, heating, operation of electric/electronic equipment) and some site operations (lighting, operation of pumps, monitoring equipment, etc.). The odours can then be transported by the wind and can reach receptors such as site neighbours. The main impact of odours is considered to be nuisance to neighbours, although the scale depends on the nature (i.e. pleasant or offensive), concentration and frequency of the odours. In autumn 2006, odour trials were undertaken at The Avenue which aimed to assess the potential for release and dispersion of odours during excavation of sediments from Lagoons 2 and 4. Subsequent modelling indicated that, with the application of careful working methods and mitigation measures, the impacts on receptors such as site neighbours would not be expected to be significant. However, there may be times during the project when odours could be detectable offsite, which could cause nuisance. For these short-term events, on-site mitigation measures will be implemented. An odour monitoring programme was implemented in early 2007. This comprises routine ‘sniff-tests’ at the site boundary, the monitoring of complaints about odour and the completion of odour diaries by a selection of volunteering local residents. The data collected from this programme will serve as a basis against which the impacts of odour emitted from the site can be assessed, and will complement more targeted monitoring undertaken by the remediation contractor. The trials also included testing of such odour mitigation systems. This indicated that the use of foam blankets to cover exposed surfaces following disturbance of odorous materials could be useful in limiting release of odours. This control measure will therefore be implemented when particularly adverse emissions are expected. It may also be necessary to temporarily close the footpath that runs immediately adjacent to Lagoon four for the period when sediments from the Lagoon are being excavated. The main source of noise at The Avenue is considered to be the operation of site vehicles and mobile plant. During remediation of the site, operation of items such as excavators, will increase. Other sources of noise will be the operation of fixed plant, such as the thermal desorption unit. The main negative impact associated with noise is considered to be the annoyance or nuisance of residents local to the site. Noise Noise surveys have been carried out and the results modelled to predict the generation and dispersion of noise from different operations and at different times of the day. www.theavenueproject.co.uk 13 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 14 Currently, a single water meter serves the entire site. Prior to February 2007 the water was sub-metered from the former Ruberoid plant, an on-site tenant, although only a limited number of water readings were taken and few conclusions can be drawn. In order to better understand consumption going forward, it is proposed to implement sub-metering of the site and offices by September 2007. This information has been used to assess the potential impacts on receptors such as nearby residential properties. The exercise indicated that most site operations are unlikely to result in negative impacts on receptors. However, certain operations, for example breaking-out of concrete, would lead to temporarily higher noise levels. Prior to the start of site works, VSD Avenue will prepare a Noise Management Plan for submission to NEDDC. During remediation a number of measures will also be implemented in order to reduce generation of noise. These will include the use of modern and properly maintained mobile plant, and the location of material stockpiles or other barriers between key noise sources and receptors where possible. Diesel is used on site for the operation of the security vehicles, equipment such as the wheel wash, generators and mobile plant such as excavators. These items are fuelled from a central bowser. All other site vehicles are fuelled with diesel at offsite service stations. Associated environmental impacts include the depletion of natural resources, pollution from the processing of raw materials, reduction in local air quality and global climate change. Resource use The most significant use of resources associated with the project are the use of potable water and energy, particularly during remediation activities. This includes the use of electricity and diesel for the operation of the remediation plant, equipment and site vehicles. Diesel bowser Electricity is used for the operation of equipment such as for monitoring, pumps, etc. and for office facilities. Currently there are two electricity meters on site, one serving the offices and maintenance buildings, and the other the decontamination unit with a draw-off point for uses associated with the wider site. The associated environmental impacts include the depletion of natural resources, pollution from the processing of raw materials, reduction in local air quality and global climate change. In addition the use of energy has a significant financial cost implication. Prior to the beginning of remediation activities, the main uses of potable water are office activities, the decontamination block (including welfare facilities), initial filling of the wheel wash and attached mains water hosepipe, and draw-off for site activities (e.g. filling of bowsers for local cleaning of equipment and dust suppression). During remediation, water will be required for dust suppression, soil washing and rehydration of thermally treated soil. The negative impacts of water use include depletion of natural resources, and the use of energy and production of waste products associated with treatment of water. During remediation of the site, water consumption will increase, although where possible uncontaminated surface water run-off or treated water from the treatment plant will be used. The site generates a number of waste streams for offsite recycling or disposal. Negative environmental impacts associated with offsite disposal of wastes are the depletion of landfill space, waste of resources if useful materials are not recycled, the use of energy in transportation and processing, and the generation of traffic and associated environmental impacts (noise, air quality, carbon emissions, depletion of resources etc.). The remediation strategy emphasises the maximisation of materials re-use within the site where possible and only disposing of materials offsite when necessary. This was driven by legislative changes in 20041, which precluded offsite disposal to landfill of some of the materials and paved the way for use of soil treatment technologies. This approach aligns to a greater degree with the principles of sustainable waste management, proposed in national planning policy (Planning Policy Statement 10). During 2005 - 2006, 2500 litres fuel were used on site, compared to 21,819 litres in 2006/07. The higher consumption in year 2006/07 is mainly associated with VSD mobilising to site for culvert works in August 2006. However, the fuel consumption figures for both years are under-representations as they do not include the fuel consumed by (sub-)contractors operating the mobile plant and completing the site works. An improved system to record fuel used on site for future works is being developed and more representative fuel consumption data is envisaged to be available for reporting in future updates and statements. In addition, electricity use per person was lower in late 2006 than the corresponding time in 2005, as there were significantly more people on site. This is when the large scale site investigation and other works were undertaken. Information about CO2 production associated with the electricity generation is presented in the ‘Climate Change and Air Quality’ section. We aim to reduce the annual energy consumption per person at the site offices by 5%, compared to 2006/07 levels, by April 2008. During remediation of the site, fuel and electricity will also be required for the operation and control of the remediation plant, particularly the thermal desorption unit. This will use natural gas to fuel the burners that generate hot air for heating of the soil. This will transfer (desorb) contaminants into the gaseous phase for extraction and further treatment. The treatment of off-gases will also require use of gas as fuel. The thermal desorption plant includes various heat exchangers and recycling of waste heat for the pretreatment of materials. These measures will increase energy efficiency and reduce fuel consumption. Wheel wash Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 A ly 2 Se ugu 00 pt st 5 em 2 0 0 b O er 5 c 2 N tob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 b 00 Ja er 5 nu 20 Fe ary 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 2 Ap 00 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 A ly 2 Se ugu 00 pt st 6 em 2 0 0 b O er 6 c 2 N tob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 b 00 Ja er 6 nu 20 Fe ary 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar ch 07 20 07 Electricity kWh used per person Total electricity used at The Avenue (invoice data) Electricity kWh used Waste Generation and Disposal Office and site derived waste streams are currently reported separately. They comprise: Skip for general office derived waste Presented below are the monthly figures for total electricity used between April 2005 and March 2007, and a calculation of electricity use per person. The graph shows that electricity usage follows seasonal trends, with particularly high usage in winter 2005-06 compared to the same months in 2006-07. It is considered that at least some of the difference can be explained by the fact that winter 2005-06 was much colder than winter 2006-07, and that the electric heaters in the site offices would have been used much more. Environmental Report Office waste general waste for offsite disposal to landfill paper/cardboard, glass, etc for offsite recycling Site-derived wastes metals and wood for offsite recycling hazardous waste from standard maintenance operations (for example sediments and contaminants deposited in the wheel wash, bear pits or another catchment pit near the River Rother) Non-hazardous waste includes mainly general waste from various activities and isolated other sources, for example sewer arisings. Waste generation is expected to increase during the main remediation. However, the remediation strategy aims at minimising waste disposal offsite, treating and reusing materials on-site where possible. Development proposals have been designed to meet the objectives of both the contaminated land regime and future land use requirements. During remediation of the site, some materials will be suitable for use with limited, or even without treatment, whilst others will require some treatment, as described previously. Disposal will be required for some materials that cannot be treated for reuse, such as rubber, plastics and asbestos containing materials. 1The waste acceptance requirements of the Landfill Directive (as given in Landfill (England and Wales) Regulations 2002) brought into force on 16th July 2004 specify certain criteria hazardous wastes have to meet to allow disposal to landfill. www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk 15 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 16 This programme varies depending on conditions and activities at the site but generally includes: The tables below shows the volume of waste removed from site between April 2005 and March 2007, reported separately for office and site derived waste. physical properties (pH) Cardboard/ packaging waste per person in kg Total weight of general waste (office) in tonnes General weight of office waste per person in kg Total weight of waste per person (inc. general office waste and cardboard/ packaging) in kg April 2005 to March 2006 1.6 0.256 20.02 3.2094 3.466 April 2006 to March 2007 3.44 0.374 9.26 1.0063 1.38 Total weight of non hazardous waste (site derived) in tonnes Total weight of general waste (site derived) in tonnes April 2005 to March 2006 71.63 7.88 8.84 April 2006 to March 2007 137.06 7.75 3.12 Water environment and sewers The quality of surface water and treated wastewater discharged from The Avenue site has been monitored since the early 1990s. This allows the site’s impact on the surrounding environment, and compliance with the consents to discharge issued by the Environment Agency (EA) and Yorkshire Water (YW), to be assessed. www.theavenueproject.co.uk Contamination from soils, and more significantly the Lagoon sediments, leaches into the River Rother, which leads to a reduction in the water and sediment quality adjacent to and downstream of the site. This could in turn have a negative effect on flora and fauna in and adjacent to the river. During remediation this source of contamination will be removed. The strategy also includes the remediation of some contaminated sediments in the River Rother, thereby directly improving the water quality. River Rother near the bear pits Hazardous waste (site derived) in tonnes During the coming reporting year, the detailed design of the remediation works will be finalised. Where possible further opportunities will be taken to minimise offsite disposal to landfill, through maximisation of material treatment and reuse on site. organics (BOD, COD, total petroleum hydrocarbons, phenols, poly-cyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), volatile organic compounds (VOCs), Diesel Range Organics and Petrol Range Organics, BTEX (benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene and xylene)). The amount of site-derived general waste decreased between 2005/06 and 2006/07, considered to be mainly due to less overall activity than the previous year. The table below suggests an increase in the amount of sitederived hazardous waste generated at The Avenue between April 2006 and March 2007, compared to the figures for the previous year. This is largely due to one hazardous waste stream that was disposed off to landfill in May 2006, but did not occur at any other time during the period. This comprised the removal of 60.88 tonnes of sediments from the bear pits and transport for offsite disposal to landfill. Site waste inorganics (chloride, electrical conductivity, cyanide, nitrate, ammonia, total suspended solids (TSS), thiocyanate) Skips for site derived wastes This indicates that the volume of cardboard/packaging waste increased between 2005/06 and 2006/07, largely due to more commercial activity on site and the presence of more contractor staff as of mid 2006. However, the amount of general office waste decreased over the period. This is believed to be due to increased environmental awareness, with more segregation of wastes for recycling. metals (cadmium, chromium, iron, copper, mercury, lead, nickel and zinc) Presented below are the average monthly monitoring results for pH, total suspended solids (TSS), thiocyanate, iron and COD between April 2005 and March 2007, taken at the bear pits. These determinands are reported as they are of particular significance for the site and are subject to EA consent limits. The graphs show that average pH, iron and COD levels were below consent limits within the period. However one breach each of average TSS and thiocyanate were experienced during the period. The TSS breach in December 2006 is believed to be associated with heavy rain that led to excessive flows through the bearpits and therefore settling out of sediments to be less effective. The average thiocyanate breach in November 2005 is not considered to be due to activities or conditions at the site; this conclusion was reached following a review of all site activities/circumstances and sampling results around the date of the breach. It is considered to be associated with drainage from an adjacent site that is discharged together with surface and storm water from The Avenue site through the bear pits. A monitoring and improvement programme is being implemented to reduce thiocyanate concentrations in the discharge. Individual exceedances are discussed further in the ‘Legal compliance’ section. PH Total weight of cardboard/ packaging waste in tonnes Surface and storm water collected by the site drainage system is discharged to the River Rother through a structure called the ‘bear pits’ under an EA discharge consent. The bear pits consist of a series of baffles and weirs designed to remove suspended solids and any floating products from the water before it is discharged. During remediation operations runoff will be collected in a series of ‘clean’ and ‘dirty’ holding ponds. Water from the dirty holding pond will be pumped to an on-site water treatment facility from where it can either be discharged into the public sewer or, where possible, reused on site. Water from the clean holding pond can be used on site, for example for dust suppression, or can be discharged to the River Rother under a discharge consent. Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 ct 2 N ob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 5 nu 20 a Fe ry 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 2 b 00 O er 6 ct 20 o N ov ber 06 em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 b 00 Ja er 6 nu 20 Fe ary 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar 0 ch 7 20 07 Office waste Environmental Report www.theavenueproject.co.uk 17 www.theavenueproject.co.uk Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 ct 2 N ob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 5 nu 20 a Fe ry 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 2 b 00 O er 6 ct 2 N ob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 6 nu 20 a Fe ry 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar ch 07 20 07 Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 c 2 N tob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 5 nu 20 a Fe ry 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 2 b 00 O er 6 c 2 N tob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 6 nu 20 a Fe ry 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar ch 07 20 07 COD (mg/l) Thiocyanate (mg/l) Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 c 2 N tob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 5 nu 20 a Fe ry 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 6 pt st em 2 b 00 O er 6 ct 2 N ob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 6 nu 20 0 a Fe ry 7 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar ch 07 20 07 Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 ct 20 o N ov ber 05 em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 b 00 Ja er 5 nu 20 Fe ary 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 2 b 00 O er 6 c 2 N tob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 6 nu 20 a Fe ry 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar ch 07 20 07 Iron (mg/l) TSS (mg/l) 18 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t www.theavenueproject.co.uk Environmental Report Drainage waters from the waste tip and Lagoon 2 are pumped to a water treatment plant before being discharged to sewer under a discharge consent issued by YW, whilst a separate consent covers the discharge of water contained within Lagoon 4, which is discharged directly to sewer. Discharges in excess of consent limits could result in damage to sewers, or affect the effectiveness of the YW wastewater treatment facility, resulting in indirect negative impacts on the receiving environment. Exceedances of the discharge consent are discussed in the ‘Legal compliance’ section. 19 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 20 EA River Quality Data for the River Rother The EA classify river quality on the basis of biological, chemistry and nutrient criteria. Unfortunately, there are no EA sampling locations sufficiently close to the site to allow a meaningful assessment of the overall impact of the site on the River Rother. It is considered that the site impacts more significantly through leaching of contaminants from the Lagoons rather than from surface water discharges from the bear pits. The assessment of ecology and biodiversity includes plants, animals and their habitats. There are no nationally designated ecological sites near to The Avenue, although there are locally important areas within 1km which could potentially be affected by activities or conditions at the site. To the north is Birdholme Marsh County Wildlife Site and McGregor’s Pond and Rough Grassland County Wildlife Site (CWS), whilst to the south there is Hasland Railway Margins County Wildlife Site and Sutcliffe and Hanging Banks Woods County Wildlife Site. After remediation works have finished, The DWT Avenue Washlands Reserve will have been created which will encompass the existing Redleadmill Brook Habitat Creation Works, Hasland Railway Sidings CWS, part of the Newt reserve and Mill Lane Habitat Creation Works2. During the remediation work any water voles and protected reptiles will be systematically translocated to the Rail Sidings habitat area in the south of the site, part of the Hasland Railway Margins CWS. GCNs will be translocated to the newt reserve, which is protected by ‘one-way’ amphibian fencing, allowing individuals to get into the reserve but not to leave it. Overall, the remediation will have significant positive impacts through the creation of additional and enhancement of existing habitats. This includes new waterbodies, a new underground roost chamber and enhancement of existing habitats such as the roosting and foraging habitat. Since 2000, spring/summer surveys of GCNs have been undertaken at the site by TEP, with the results for the current reporting period presented in the table overleaf. This indicates a reduction in total numbers in June 2005, although numbers subsequently recovered. Another decline was recorded in March 2007, believed to be due to the sewage spill in the railside ditch. 2The Avenue Remediation Project, Non-Technical Summary of the Environmental Impact Assessment www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk Water vole The most significant ecology and biodiversity aspects are associated with the presence of sensitive and legally protected ecological features, in particular great crested newts (GCNs), reptiles (mainly grass snakes), water voles, protected birds, bats and a badger sett. Detailed monitoring surveys have been undertaken of a number of these species, including GCNs, grass snakes and water voles. Negative impacts during remediation could include disturbance of or damage to the protected species or their habitats. Habitats could be reduced or lost altogether during the works, so mitigation measures are required to protect the sensitive features. Although some adverse effects may occur during the remediation works, it is thought that they will not be significant. Current measures to protect and where possible enhance species and their habitats have included the release of elvers into the south wetlands by DWT. In the rail sidings habitat limestone chippings were deposited to provide nesting sites for the little ringed plover. There has also been enhancement work at the newt reserve, where the majority of individuals are located. Unfortunately in September 2006 there was a surcharge of raw sewage from the public sewer adjacent to the rail sidings ditch into the newt habitat. This sewer is under the ownership of Yorkshire Water as the statutory undertaker, and is thus their responsibility. This incident is discussed further in the ‘Legal Compliance’ section. Grass snake However, it is proposed to investigate during the coming reporting year whether or how the programme can be amended to allow the overall impacts of the site to be more closely monitored, and allow a direct comparison against the EA classification system. Ecology and biodiversity Great crested newt Over the period April 2005 to March 2007, discharges to sewer from Lagoon 4 were made between 4 and 14 January 2007. Analysis of the water showed it to be in accordance with the discharge consent. Environmental Report 21 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 22 Environmental Report Legal Compliance Date Compliance with legislation and other legal requirements, such as planning permissions and discharge consents (e.g. to the River Rother or sewer) is assessed regularly. Mill Lane Ponds Pond 1 Pond 2 Pond 3 Railside Ditch Sidings Ditch Total Compliance with discharge consents April 05 7 22 11 229 0 269 May 05 10 13 7 421 DRY 451 for discharge of storm water to the River Rother June 05 16 14 1 145 DRY 176 for discharge of treated water from the on-site wastewater treatment plant to sewer March 06 9 11 6 226 1 253 April 06 22 7 10 293 1 333 May 06 48 5 12 415 5 485 March 07 37 27 10 60 3 137 Traffic during the remediation phase will include HGVs transporting materials for recycling or disposal (those that cannot be treated on-site). In addition traffic will arise from the requirement to import organic materials for the creation of horticultural soils, the delivery and removal of equipment, the delivery of fuel and other substances and materials, and the arrival and departure of employees. Due to the nature of the remediation process, the only practical transport solution involves the use of the existing site access and road network. As such the A61 is the main receptor for traffic associated with the remediation phase; predictions of the likely traffic levels have been made in the EIA which accompanied the planning application. A summary of the maximum, worst case predicted two-way traffic flows including staff travel and HGV movements during the different development phases is presented in the chart below. The first phase (0-10 month) is due to commence in January 2008 and should be completed in October 2008. A number of breaches were recorded between April 2005 and March 2007, mainly for total suspended solids (TSS), iron and thiocyanate. While thiocyanate is associated with the legacy of contamination, iron is a substance that appears naturally in the soils of the Coal Measures underlying The Avenue. TSS comprises very small soil or other particles that are transported with the water. Number of exceedancees When The Avenue Coking and Chemical Works was operational traffic movements were believed to be high. Currently, traffic to and from the site is limited to employee trips; it is estimated that approximately 80 two-way car trips per day use the existing site access point with the A61. There are also a limited number of HGV movements associated with deliveries to site and transportation of waste from the site. The remediation strategy aims to minimise offsite disposal to landfill, by retaining and treating materials on site. This will in turn reduce the need for traffic movements. During this period, the highest number of HGV trips are predicted to be due to the delivery of plant and machinery associated with initial mobilisation. This is in addition to employee trips. HGV movements form a comparably small percentage of the overall traffic movements generated by the site summarised below. The consent for discharge of storm water to the River Rother is granted by the Environment Agency, and includes specified limits for 22 substances. A water monitoring programme is in operation, which includes weekly sampling of the discharge. In addition to this, the Environment Agency regularly visit the site to take their own samples. The graph below indicates the number of exceedances of the specified discharge consent conditions. Stage of Project (months) The traffic assessment undertaken by Entec/VSD Avenue assessed the likely impacts of these traffic movements on the A61 and its users. The results of the assessment suggest that the impact on the A61 and its users will not be significant. However, a number of mitigation measures have been proposed, including: Ap ril 2 M 00 ay 5 Ju 200 ne 5 2 Ju 00 5 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 5 em 2 b 00 O er 5 ct 2 N ob 005 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 05 em 2 0 0 b Ja er 5 nu 20 a Fe ry 05 br 2 ua 00 6 r M y 20 ar ch 06 Ap 200 ril 6 2 M 00 ay 6 Ju 200 ne 6 2 Ju 00 6 Au ly 2 Se gu 00 pt st 6 em 2 b 00 O er 6 c 2 N tob 006 ov er em 2 0 D ec ber 06 em 2 b 00 Ja er 6 nu 20 Fe ary 07 br 2 ua 00 7 r M y 20 ar 0 ch 7 20 07 Traffic associated with The Avenue is generated by the movement of staff to and from the site and by deliveries of plant, equipment and consumables to the site and transportation offsite of wastes. During remediation the volume of traffic is expected to increase. Negative impacts associated with traffic are congestion and accident risks, pollution from vehicle emissions, and nuisance to local residents in terms of noise, visual disturbance and dust nuisance. for discharge of surface water ponding on Lagoon 4 to sewer Average Monthly Two-Way Trips Traffic and transportation The site currently holds three discharge consents: The discharge to sewer from the wastewater treatment plant and Lagoon 4 is consented by Yorkshire Water, which is the sewerage undertaker in this area. The water monitoring programme includes regular sampling of this discharge, to determine the effectiveness of the operation of the plant and assess compliance with the 13 consented substances. Water from Lagoon 4 is discharged infrequently; prior to discharge, it is sampled and analysed to confirm that it complies with consent limits for eight chemical and physical parameters. improvements to visibility at the site access junction by the maintenance of roadside vegetation within The Avenue installation of traffic warning signs on approach to the site access upgrade of the existing on-site wheel washing facilities to allow use by all HGVs to limit the deposition of mud and debris on the carriageway. In addition road sweeping of the access bellmouth would take place at frequent intervals a traffic Management Plan will be prepared in consultation with DCC www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk 23 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 24 Environmental Report Other Environmental Performance The Avenue site is in the process of implementing measures aimed at reducing breaches of discharge consent conditions. The breaches and mitigation measures are discussed regularly with the EA, who are aware of the issues and do not intend to pursue prosecution of the site for these occasional breaches. The graph also shows a number of breaches of the consent to discharge to sewer from the wastewater treatment plant. This discharge is monitored regularly, and if elevated levels are identified measures to mitigate are investigated and implemented. Yorkshire Water is kept fully informed of any breaches and the mitigation measures implemented. They are aware of the current situation and again do not intend to pursue prosecution of the site for these occasional breaches. Water from Lagoon 4 was discharged to sewer during January 2007. Testing of the water showed it to be in accordance with the discharge consent limits and no exceedances were recorded. Environmental incidents In September 2006, untreated sewage surcharged from a manhole on the public Yorkshire Water sewer into the railsidings ditch near the eastern site boundary. This ditch and associated ponds support a population of GCNs, which are a protected species, and act as a receptor habitat for individuals that require translocation from active areas of the site. The newt population is surveyed regularly by TEP. Immediately following discovery of the surcharge Yorkshire Water was contacted. Their operatives visited the site and cleared a blockage in the sewer that had caused the event. The EA and Natural England were also contacted, who are the regulators for pollution incidents and protected species, respectively. A clean-up programme has been undertaken by YW and the impact on the GCN population is being monitored by TEP. Although the spill occurred at The Avenue site and impacted on a habitat that contained translocated GCNs, as statutory undertakers YW are responsible. Air Quality As indicated by the graph on the previous page, exceedances of air quality assessment criteria were experienced on six occasions between April 2005 and March 2007; all of these were of deposited dust. This criterion is a threshold above which dust has the potential to cause nuisance, and is not directly related to human health effects. The exceedances were all recorded at stations B and C, which are both located adjacent to a haul road in the east of the site and, and it is thought that dust could have been liberated by vehicles using the road. Data collected from other monitoring stations indicates that the dust did not migrate offsite to cause negative impacts on sensitive receptors. However, other exceedances of dust were recorded at offsite monitoring station 5, near to the eastern boundary of the site, in July and August 2005. Chemical analysis of the dust suggested that the elevated levels might be due to conditions local to the station but the results were inconclusive. Most of the exceedances experienced during the period were recorded between April and August 2005, at which time works on-site included the creation of the rail sidings habitat and wetlands. This involved the excavation, haulage and temporary stockpiling of soils; the associated increase in site traffic could have lead to the excessive dust generation. Mitigation measures will be implemented to reduce the generation of dust, which may include damping down and cleaning of site roads. Complaints The Avenue project operates a complaints procedure which requires that all complaints are recorded and responded to within seven days. In the period April 2005 to March 2007 the site received two complaints, in October 2005 and January 2007. Both related to flooding of fields near the former rail sidings at the south of The Avenue site. Both complaints were responded to satisfactorily. Communication emda and the Project Team are committed to engaging in open communication with all stakeholders of The Avenue project. This includes communicating the significant environmental aspects and impacts and the environmental performance of the site. Internal communication Communication amongst the different parties working on the project takes place on various levels, and includes the regular relaying of information about environmental performance, for example in the form of quarterly Health, Safety and Environment review meetings. Information can also be posted on a notice board located in the communal area of the site offices. www.theavenueproject.co.uk The Project Team appreciates that in order to continually improve the environmental performance of the project the active engagement of everybody working at The Avenue is essential. A suggestion box system has recently been implemented to give all staff working at the site a say in improving the environmental performance of the project. EMS notice board Discharge to the River Rother from the bear pits Although surface water usually passes through a series of settling tanks and weirs prior to discharge (bear pits), during high flow conditions following heavy rain water can partially bypass the treatment or pass through too quickly to allow for satisfactory settlement. This can lead to exceedance of the discharge consent, particularly for TSS. Furthermore, historic contamination of both The Avenue and a neighbouring site is thought to be leached by rainwater into cracked drains, also affecting compliance with consent conditions. Prior to working on the site, all staff are required to complete an induction which includes details of the environmental policy, the site environmental rules, and the key environmental impacts, roles and responsibilities associated with the work. In addition to the inductions, key staff with particular responsibilities under the EMS are provided with environmental training for undertaking their roles. Employees will also be briefed on the content of this Environmental Statement. External communication A number of forums and liaison meetings have been created at The Avenue over the years to enable open communications between the stakeholders of the site and emda and the Project Team. Regulator Liaison meetings have been held for many years and include the Environment Agency, North East Derbyshire District Council (NEDDC), Chesterfield Borough Council (CBC) and the Primary Care Trust (PCT). A critical aspect of the delivery of the project is securing planning consent for the remediation and landscape scheme, while reserving part of the site for built development. emda has set up a Plannnig Liaison Group that meets regularly to ensure effective communication with key stakeholders. The group includes local councillors and planning officers from the three local authorities affected by the scheme, i.e. NEDDC, Derbyshire County Council (DCC) and CBC. www.theavenueproject.co.uk 25 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 26 Wetlands created at The Avenue Presented below are the numbers of liaison group meetings in the period April 2005 to March 2007. External communication Number completed April 2005 - March 2006 April 2006 - March 2007 Regulator Liaison Meetings 7 6 Regulator Liaison Reports 12 12 Planning Liaison Reports 3 7 Newsletters 0 1 In addition, a series of newsletters have been published and a website created (www.theavenueproject.co.uk) which provides regular updates on progress of the project. The website is also used to publish the monthly air monitoring data and reports and this environmental statement. The last newsletter was published in February 2007. Avenue Visitor Centre The local community has been involved in a number of ways at The Avenue. In January and February 2005, emda and the Project Team invited views from the public and the local community on the proposed masterplan for the site. The planning consultation events concluded in an open day at The Avenue. Further open days are planned for the future. The overall goal of the project is “the remediation of contaminated land that may represent a risk to human health and the environment, taking into account the proposed enduse of the site”. This is supported by a number of secondary objectives, which are to: reduce the impact of the site to the River Rother reduce flood risk to properties downstream of the site through the construction of a flood embankment, and incorporating flood storage into the design of the final landform Achievements enhance the biodiversity value of the site The ‘Brownfield Briefing Remediation Innovation Awards’ aim to recognise best practice in remediation and use of remediation technology throughout the UK. The awards are organised by the Brownfield Briefing publication and Newzeye, and are divided into three categories of remediation techniques, with separate awards for the most innovative method and conceptual design work carried out before remediation begins. Jacobs Babtie (now Jacobs UK) won the award for the best conceptual design for their work at The Avenue site and was presented with the award in a ceremony in London in September 2006. effectively manage asbestos containing materials Brownfield Briefing RIA ‘Best Conceptual Design’ Award Brownfield Briefing RIA ‘Best Conceptual Design’ Award The Avenue has been recognised as a beacon project, which uses the latest technology from the UK and abroad, to solve the complex remediation problems posed by decades of industrial contamination at the site. www.theavenueproject.co.uk The photo shows emda’s Mike Fenton, Jacobs Design Manager, Brian Sims and Jacobs Technical Director, Clive Paxton receiving the award from Quentin Leiper of the Institution of Civil Engineers. In March 2007 The Avenue Project won the Institution of Civil Engineers’ East Midlands Merit Award for design and innovation. The award recognises and encourages excellence in design and construction in civil engineering. In 2006 Derbyshire Wildlife Trust and emda won first place in the Conservation Category of the BTO (British Trust for Ornithology) Business Bird Challenge for their work at The Avenue. This award promotes biodiversity on industrial sites, and recognises efforts to improve The Avenue’s conservation value through the creation of a wetland and development of good relations with local communities. implement the remediation strategy that encourages pollution prevention, waste minimisation and reduction of resource consumption, including energy and potable water consumption prevent uncontrolled releases to the environment prevent all potential statutory nuisance issues associated with the site from affecting neighbouring communities promote active employee involvement to achieve continual improvement in environmental performance inform interested stakeholder groups of project progress, environmental performance and continual improvement and provide forums for discussions with stakeholders. reduce risks to human health and the environment from the presence of historic mine-shafts Looking ahead to next year A number of activities and initiatives are due to be implemented by the end of the next reporting period, in March 2008. These comprise programme milestones relating to the commencement of site works for the overall delivery of the project, and activities that aim to improve the environmental performance of The Avenue. These include: ICE Innovation Award BTO Bird Challenge Overall Project Goals emda are planning to open a visitor centre near the southern boundary of the site during an Open Day on 3rd August 2007. This will serve to provide information about the project, but will also be available for use by the local community for training and education purposes, and includes a classroom that can be used for presentations. The Avenue site has received a number of awards. Environmental Report improved internal and external communication about environmental performance and sustainability through active employee involvement, the implementation of a system of sustainability KPIs (see below), achievement of an ‘excellent’ CEEQUAL rating (see below), and organisation of open days the completion of the detailed design of the remediation, including the final design of the thermal desorption plant, which features heat recovery systems to increase fuel efficiency the preparation and agreement of method statements, an Environmental Management Plan and Health & Safety Plan for the works the preparation and undertaking of public information exhibitions the gaining of all other requisite licences and permissions, including the Planning Permission, a Mobile Treatment Licence for the operation of remediation plants, consents for discharges to the River Rother and the public sewer, etc. the agreement of the target price and award of the contract for the remediation of the site the commencement of mobilisation of plant and equipment to site, construction and assembly of plant and equipment the commencement of ecological protection works, i.e. translocation of protected species from areas that will be disturbed to receptor habitats www.theavenueproject.co.uk 27 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 28 Environmental Report Glossary the commencement of preparation works, including vegetation clearance and construction of temporary site roads following commissioning of the relevant plant and equipment, the commencement of breaking out, crushing and screening of concrete in the former main plant area Acid rain Rain containing acids that are formed from pollutants, particularly sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide, that are released from industrial and domestic combustion processes and vehicle emissions Air quality objectives (AQO) Maximum concentrations set for a number of air pollutants which are not or only for a certain number permitted to be exceeded in the ambient air. Baseflow The part of the water flow in a stream that originates from groundwater rather than surface run-off. Biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) A chemical procedure for determining how fast biological organisms use up oxygen in a body of water. It is used in water quality management and assessment, ecology and environmental science. BOD is not an accurate quantitative test, although it could be considered as an indication of the quality of a water source.8 Bioremediation A process that uses microorganisms such as bacteria or fungi, or plants, to degrade contaminants into CO2 and water (complete degradation) or to other products (incomplete degradation). Some fungi can bind contaminants into the humic soil structure so that they are not or less available. CEEQUAL Blue Billy ‘Blue Billy’ is a term used for spent oxide due to its blue-green colour. CEEQUAL is an awards scheme which involves the assessment of the environmental quality of civil engineering projects. The key objective of the scheme is to encourage the attainment of environmental excellence in civil engineering projects, and thus to deliver improved environmental performance in project specification, design and construction. BTEX A group of volatile organic compounds made up of benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes Chemical oxygen demand (COD) A test that is commonly used to indirectly measure the amount of organic compounds in water. Most applications of COD determine the amount of organic pollutants found in surface water, making COD a useful measure of water quality.8 Coal Measures Sequence of rocks from the carboniferous period which often, but not always, includes coal seams of commercially exploitable thickness.3 Conceptual model A representation of the characteristics of a site in a diagrammatic or written form that shows the possible relationships between contaminants, pathways and receptors.4 Cyanide Molecules containing a carbon and nitrogen group (CN) that can be found in various forms with different solubilities and toxicities. Decontamination unit At The Avenue, a decontamination facility with changing, washing and shower facilities is provided to prevent transfer of contaminants to clean site areas, clothing, etc. Desorb A term that describes the release of a substance from another material. For example, in thermal desorption, contaminants are released from the soil matrix through the application of heat. Discharge consent A permit, issued by the Environment Agency where waters are concerned and issued by the sewerage undertakers where sewers are concerned, that allows the release of water or liquid effluent in accordance with specified chemical, physical and/or flow requirements. Dispersion modelling The mathematical simulation of how air pollutants disperse in the ambient atmosphere. It is performed with computer programs that solve the mathematical equations and algorithms which simulate the pollutant dispersion. The dispersion models are used to estimate or to predict the downwind concentration of air pollutants emitted from sources such as industrial plants and vehicular traffic.8 Encapsulation Physical containment of materials to prevent their release to the environment. Environmental aspects An element of an organisation’s activities, products or services that can interact with the environment; a significant environmental aspect is an environmental aspect that has or can have a significant environmental impact.7 Objectives The objectives of the KPIs are to: enable communication of the sustainability progress of the site provide a standardised methodology for measuring performance a reduction in the amount of office-derived waste going to offsite disposal or recycling of 5% per person, compared to 2006/07 financial year quantities provide focus on areas where emda can make a difference a reduction in the energy consumption and associated CO2 generation associated with the operation of site offices of 5% per person, compared with 2006/07 levels allow a lifecycle costing approach, and the implementation of water consumption sub-metering for office and site operations the development and implementation of a system for collecting more accurate fuel consumption data, including that of subcontractors Large scale excavation, earth movement and material treatment operations are not considered likely to commence until the end of the reporting period. Sustainability Key Performance Indicators Although the project will significantly improve the local environment, emda recognise that there is potential for environmental impacts and harm to occur during the works. With this in mind a set of sustainability Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) is being developed, which aim to provide the project with a means of monitoring performance against sustainability goals. The KPIs are being developed with regard to a number of initiatives. For example, emda’s Regional Economic Strategy (RES) established a vision for regional progress to ensure a quality of life for people in the East Midlands region, embracing social and environmental, as well as economic, objectives. The indicators reflect this to ensure that the project encompasses this overarching vision. A mechanism for measuring progress in terms of sustainable economic well-being has been developed by emda, entitled ‘Regional Index of Sustainable Economic Well-being’. Among the measures suggested are the long term costs of climate change, loss of natural habitat and costs associated with different sources of local pollution. The Avenue indicators will contribute to this regional index. Objectives have also been closely aligned with the aspirations of ‘Regeneration of European Sites in Cities and Urban Environments’ (RESCUE) Guidance for Sustainable Brownfield Generation. Additional input has been made in line with ‘One Planet Living’ Principles and Sustainable Construction targets. transfer sustainable knowledge throughout the lifecycle assist in technology selection and decision making. CEEQUAL uses a credit-based assessment framework, which is applicable to any civil engineering project and includes environmental aspects such as the use of water, energy and land as well as ecology, landscape, nuisance to neighbours, archaeology, waste minimisation and management, and community amenity. A CEEQUAL award publicly recognises the achievement of high environmental performance. Awards are made to projects in which the clients, designers and contractors (in this case the remediation team) go beyond the legal and environmental minima to achieve distinctive environmental standards of performance. To summarise, CEEQUAL will: promote improved environmental performance in specification, design and remediation of the site demonstrate the commitment of emda to environmental quality, and celebrate the achievement of high environmental standards during the project. emda are fully committed to the attainment of a CEEQUAL award, and it is intended to submit the project for assessment around the middle of 2007. The site is aiming to achieve a CEEQUAL rating of ‘excellent’. The system of indicators will be applied under the framework of EMAS. www.theavenueproject.co.uk www.theavenueproject.co.uk 29 R e g e n e r a t i o n P ro j e c t 30 Environmental management plan A written plan that specifies the methods, measures, procedures and programmes that will be employed in executing construction work to ensure works will be undertaken in accordance with sound environmental management procedures, including identification and mitigation of environmental impacts Environmental management system (EMS) The part of the overall management system that includes the organisational structure, planning activities, responsibilities, practices, procedures, processes and resources for developing, implementing, achieving, reviewing and maintaining the environmental policy.5 Health & safety plan A written plan prepared by a contractor that describes the procedures and equipment the contractor will have in place at a site to prevent site workers from becoming sick or injured while conducting an investigation or cleanup.6 Key performance indicators (KPI) Lifecycle Lifecycle costing Masterplan Soil stabilisation A soil treatment technology that aims at physically encapsulating and/or chemically immobilising contaminants in the soil by addition of binders such as cement. Soil washing A soil treatment technology which uses water with or without addition of detergents or solvents to separate contaminants from the soil and concentrate them into a sludge/fines fraction. Spent oxides During the gas purification process at The Avenue, iron oxides were used to clean sulphur and cyanides from the gas stream. When the sulphur content of the iron oxides reached a certain level, the material became ineffective in the gas purification. It was then called ‘spent oxide’ and was removed from the process. Sustainability The Brundtland Commission,a UN Commission formerly known as the World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) defined sustainable development as development that “meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs”. Sustainability relates to the continuity of economic, social, institutional and environmental aspects of human society, as well as the non-human environment8. Thermal desorption A soil treatment technology which utilises heat to transfer (desorb) contaminants in soil from a solid or liquid phase into the gas phase which is removed from the soil and treated separately. Volatile organic compound (VOC) Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are organic chemical compounds that have high enough vapour pressures under normal conditions to significantly vaporise into a gas phase8. Financial and non-financial metrics used to quantify objectives to reflect strategic performance of an organisation.8 They can be used to measure the environmental performance of an organisation. The length of time that something lasts or remains useful,7 in environmental terms it includes all time and processes from manufacturing of a product or service through its use to its final disposal. A process that identifies that costs associated with the full life cycle of a product or service from its manufacture through use to final disposal. In environmental economics this process can also be used to allocate costs to environmental impacts. A comprehensive, often long-term strategy,8 it shows how the proposals for a site will be realised in detail in the final design. 3Jones, G., Robertson, A., Forbes, J. and Hollier, G. (1990) Collins Dictionary of Environmental Science, Harper Collins Publishers, Glasgow. 4Environment Method statement A description of methods and measures that will be employed in executing construction work. Normalisation In statistics, normalisation refers to the division of multiple sets of data by a common variable in order to negate that variable’s effect on the data, thus allowing underlying characteristics of the data sets to be compared8. For example, the total volume of water used in the site offices is divided by the number of staff and visitors to make the figure comparable to the data of other time periods or other organisations. Perched groundwater A groundwater zone that is separate from the groundwater table. At The Avenue, perched groundwater can be found on top of lower permeability zones, for example areas of clay in the underground. Photochemical smog The product of reactions induced by the energy of sunlight between pollutants produced by combustion processes and vehicle emissions with components of the ambient air. Compounds of photochemical smog include oxides of nitrogen (NO and NO2), ozone and certain hydrocarbons. PM10 Particulates with a particle size of up to 10 micrometer (um, 1000um = 1mm). Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) A group of organic molecules that consist of two or more condensed aromatic rings. PAH are commonly produced by fossil fuel combustion. Remediation Action taken to prevent, minimise, remedy or mitigate the effects of any identified unacceptable risks5. Remediation strategy A plan that involves one or more remediation options to reduce or control the risks from all relevant pollutant linkages associated with the site5. Site Investigation / Ground investigation Investigation of a site that can include drilling of boreholes and sampling of soils and water. www.theavenueproject.co.uk Environmental Report Agency: Model Procedures for the Management of Land Contamination, Contaminated Land Reports 11 5Regulation (EC) No 761/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 March 2001 allowing voluntary participation by organisations in a Community eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) 6Oregon Department of Environmental Quality, Retrieved June 22 2007 from Google web definitions Website: www.deq.state.or.us/wmc/cleanup/glossary.htm 7Macmillan 8Collins English Dictionary, Bloomsbury Publishing, 2002 English Dictionary, 2004 www.theavenueproject.co.uk 31 This statement has been prepared by the Avenue EMAS Team. For further information about the project please visit The Avenue website (www.theavenueproject.co.uk) or contact us at: The Avenue Derby Road Wingerworth Chesterfield S42 6NB Telephone: 01246 207825 Email: [email protected] The Avenue EMAS team from left to right: Tim Murdoch, Louis Jacobs, Phil Shaw, Anke O’Donnell