B2B
Transcription
B2B
Business-to-Business Contents What is B2B What is e-procurement? Who are the key players in e-procurement? What are the value propositions? What is B2B ? • Business-to-Business (B2B) – B2B is about the exchange of information between organizations for the purpose of supporting commerce – The information exchange can occur using: • Internet • Private data networks • Voice networks • etc. Why it’s Important • Business-to-Business (B2B) – B2B enables organizations to move toward integration of business processes across extended enterprises (collaboration) – At a minimum, B2B represents a way to improve the flow of information between businesses, leading to • More effective allocation of resources to core value added activities • Leaner operations – Integration with business partners can lead to substantial operational & financial improvements Big Picture B2B supports the full rang business activities - raw materials to end product B2B e-Commerce B2C Tier N Scheduling Manufacturing Sales & Marketing Procurement & Supply Tier 1 Retailers Distributors Engineering e-Procurement Exchanges e-Supply Chain Buy-side Inside Sell-side Consumers Big Picture VM •Au •Re ction ver se A uct ion Company X MRO HM Direct Link Direct Materials VM HM VM •Ex •Au chan ctio ge n Company Z Company Y HM Enabling Technology XML is document structure/syntax used for creating structured elements beyond those provided in HTML Enable internationalized media-independent electronic publishing Allow industries to define platform-independent protocols for the exchange of data, the lifeblood of electronic commerce Deliver information to user agents in a form that allows automatic processing after receipt Make it easy for people to process data using inexpensive software Allow people to display information the way they want it Provide metadata -- data about information -- that will help people find information and help information producers and consumers find each other Enabling Technology XML goes beyond HTML and enables… – Mediation between heterogeneous databases • Example: allowing medical information systems to exchange patient data, eliminating data re-entry and allowing applications to quickly note critical issues like drug allergies – Common data representations for use by client-based manipulation tools • Example: design tools in the semiconductor industry – Presentations customized to user viewpoints • Example: showing only the sections of a multi-component manual that apply to a customer’s system, or presenting one manual to a user and a different one to a system administrator – Agent-based systems, where a particular user’s preferences can be applied to the data • Example: customized TV guides that list only “interesting” shows Enabling Technology Bandwidth constraints are disappearing… Here comes an era of connectivity 64 M/second We’ We’llll have have infinite infinite bandwidth bandwidth n aa decade’ decade’ss time.” time.” l Gates, Gates, CEO CEO of of Microsoft Microsoft -- October October 94* 94* . K/second hest Speed over ndard Phone Lines T1 1.5 M/second Standard Enterprise Access Price: 20/month Price: $1,600/month † www.teledesic.com * PC Magazine, October 1994 3 M/second AT&T, @Home Now available in Major US Cities Price: $40/month Starting in 2003, Teledesi a low earth orbiting satelli based system, will offer 64M or greater, two-way capaci This represents access spe more than 2,000 times fast than today’s standard analog modems. † Price ??? B2B Market It’s BIG and it’s growing rapidly B2B Opportunities Billions of Dollars 1400 1200 1000 800 B2C 600 B2B 400 200 0 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 Source: Deloitte Research and Forrester Research • Note that B2B will far outpace B2C 2003 B2B Market Some estimates are even greater… B2B Market size $8,000 7300 Billions of Dollars $7,000 $6,000 $5,000 0% 0 0 ~5 $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 145 $0 1999 2000 2001 Source: Gartner Group 2002 2003 2004 B2B Market • More interesting numbers: – Product and process cost savings afforded by “metamediaries” will amount to $57 billion in the year 2003. (Bear Sterns) – “Metamediaries” will have a valuation of $228 billion in 2002. (Bear Sterns) B2B Market Exponential growth is forecast for e-Business $1,400 $1,200 (US $ Billions) $1,000 1,234 Internet Internet traffic traffic doubling doubling every every 100 100 days days Total Total bandwidth bandwidth increasing increasing 300% 300% annually annually Internet Internet business business doubling doubling annually annually 717 $800 $600 World GDP (1998) $30 trillion $400 377 180 $200 0.1 2.7 21.8 1995 1996 1997 73.9 $0 Source: "The Real Numbers behind 'Net Profits 1998”, Copyright 1998, ActivMedia, Inc., research @activmedia.com, http://www.activmedia.com 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 B2B Market 4,253 Other 509 1998 US Internet Services Spending 2,653 Business Services 353 2003 US Internet Services Spending 1,990 Utilities 218 2,848 Government 311 1,170 Healthcare 125 9,169 Manufacturing (includes E&C) 975 4,018 Communications & Media 566 3,043 Retail 436 9,871 Financial Sevices $0 1,146 $2,000 $4,000 $6,000 $8,000 $10,000 $12,000 $ Millions of Dollars Source: Preliminary Data From a Deloitte e-Procurement survey Internet Internet professional professional services services spending spending is is expected expected to to grow grow on on average average move move than than 700% 700% across across industries, industries, from from an an average average $515M $515M in in 1998 1998 to to $4.3 $4.3 billion billion in in 2003 2003 B2B Market Opportunities Opportunities in in the the Business-2-Business Business-2-Business (B2B) (B2B) segment segment dominate dominate the the e-commerce e-commerce marketplace marketplace $1,331 Business to-Business $843 Business to-Consume $499 ( $ Billions ) Source: Forrester Research $251 $108 $109 $43 1998 1999E 2000E 2001E 2002E 2003E Contents What is B2B ? What is e-procurement? Who are the key players in e-procurement? What are the value propositions? Current Market Trends in e-Procurement Top e-Commerce Objectives 4.3 er service & satisfaction improvement 4.0 Improved supply chain performance 4.0 Reduce overall costs 3.8 Improved supplier relationships 3.8 e-Commerce procurement 3.7 Improved information / reporting 3.3 Revenue grow th 3.3 e-Commerce selling 1.8 Mergers/acquisitions - 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 Source: Preliminary Data From Deloitte e-Procurement survey Four Four out out of of five five top top e-commerce e-commerce objectives objectives focus focus on on procurement procurement & & supply supply chain chain Why e-Procurement? • Traditionally, procurement organizations have focused their efforts on improving the supply management of direct materials • Legacy and ERP systems have supported this effort by providing tools that automate the procurement of direct materials spend • Procurement organizations that have done work on the supply management of indirect items have found that legacy and ERP systems and processes do not provide the ease of use required to assist end-users in complying with the organization’s purchasing agreements 1% of respondents in a recent Deloitte survey are either implementing, planning or considering e-Procurement for their organizations What is happening now? Today, procurement typically involves too many people, begs for streamlining, a is ineffective in obtaining operating resources at the lowest cost… • Current Procurement functions face many of the following challenges: – Procurement is very transaction-intensive – Many buyers are immersed in day-to-day tactical details – Little time is devoted to value-added activities • • • • Value engineering Developing common design standards and specifications Developing service strategies Managing the total cost of ownership – Managing paper flow is very time-consuming • Documentation • Obtaining necessary approvals (QA/QC) – Time to process can be extensive (requestor, Procurement, A/P, Receiving etc.) – Vendor management is often an afterthought What is happening now? … today’s procurement process is highly complex ements Paper Catalogs Online Requisitioning System Email Corporate Purchasing Requisition Sourc Pricin John Hancock John Hancock John Hancock Express Mail PO Creation Co-workers John Hancock Signature Approval (1-2 weeks) John Hancock John Hancock John Hancock John Hancock John Hancock Corporate Purchasing System fax/mail/phone Ordering Shipment Payment Invoicing Central Receiving Enterprise Acco Asset Tagging #1234 Supplier Commodity Manager Accounts Payable PO Key Issues • Slow process (weeks) • High error rates • Business consumer has poo visibility of preferred supplie pricing, order status • Requisitioning and sourcing separate tasks (leading to p compliance) What is happening now? eProcurement presents a comprehensive, automated way to effectively manage and reduce cost of operating resources… Product Selection Availability/ Price Check • Product Selection - Enhanced content management of non-catalog ID items reduces time requirements; common user interface allows users to easily navigate system and eliminates the time associated with obsolete products and/or descriptions • Requisition Approval Availability/Price Check - System automatically associates and/or queries; system eliminates obsolete pricing and supplier “up-selling” Requisition • Requisition - System generates requisition based upon product selection; replaces manual process; carries all standard information (dept. #, account codes, etc.); process eliminates downstream rework P.O. Generation P.O. Submission Blanket Release • Requisition Approval - Dynamic routing occurs automatically; needs only actual supervisor approval; all information is standard and system confirmed • P.O. Generation - System automatically generates P.O. from requisition Receipt of Product P.O. Confirmation Status Check • Submission/Release - System automatically sends P.O. to supplier • Confirmation/Status - All queries are completed electronically; hierarchy is preserved for tracking purposes Receipt of Invoice Invoice Review & Payment • Receipt of Product - No changes • Receipt of Invoice - Increased electronic transactions effectively eliminate this step - automatically matched to P.O. • Invoice Payment - System supports multiple payment methods (ERS, EFT, P-card, etc.) What is happening now? … the eProcurement process is greatly simplified Key Improvements • Fast process (days) • Completely automated (no p • Single point of contact for business consumer. • Involvement by “purchasing” required. • Catalog based selection.ens compliance with approved vendors. • Real-time access to order st eProcurement Application Online Approval and Asset Tagging 1-2 days #1234 Enterprise Accountin Other Internal Stakeholders Shipment Supplier Ordering EDI, internet Supplier Mgt./ Catalog Mgt. / Process Mgt. Proof of Receipt Invoicing Payment Approved Purchase Order mmodity Manager Accounts Payable What is e-procurement? eProcurement solutions focus in four areas… Capturing and Leveraging Spend Managing Content E-Procurement Solution Connecting the Players Constructing the Supply Base and Incentives Capturing and Leveraging Spend By using the corporate computing network and ERP systems, eProcurem solutions automate and enhance the product selection and order placemen processes Users ERP System(s) Process Owners Common User Interface Approvers MRO Catalogs Services Acquisition eProcurement System Capital Acquisition Expense Management Managing Content eProcurement solutions capture and automate the presentation of customized supplier information to multiple users , one of the most diffic activities to manage for many companies External Catalogs SIC Mapping Internet Catalog Adapter Aggregated Catalog Intranet Internal Catalogs Catalog Addresses: URL, File End-User Navigation Connecting the Players and Constructing the Supply Base eProcurement systems providers are moving towards a marketplace mode for connecting buyers and suppliers Transaction Enabler Company Supplier (ED EDI XML Order Routing Company OBI Supplier (ED E-mail Auto-Fax Supplier (XM Supplier Registration Supplier (OB Catalog Management Company News, Info, Other Svcs. Supplier (E-m Understanding the e-Procurement Process By simplifying communication and reducing marketplace friction for both buyers and suppliers eProcurement solutions result in significant value creation Current Buyer-Supplier Relationship A B C A B C D E Buyers B B C D E F A e-Commerce Procurement A eProcurement Relationship D C D E F Suppliers CONSISTENT WITH CURRENT ENVIRONMENT E F F Buyers Suppliers MARKET PLACE STRATEGY 91% 91% of of respondents respondents in in aa recent recent survey survey are are either either implementing, implementing, planning planning or or considering considering eProcurement eProcurement for for their their organizations organizations Source: Preliminary Data from a Deloitte eProcurement survey Contents What is B2B ? What is e-procurement? Who are the key players in e-procurement? What are the value propositions? Understanding the e-Procurement Players Companies in the eProcurement arena are offering a variety of solutions using different architectures to meet varying customer needs Selling Companies mployees ntranet Marketing, Selling, & Servicing ERP -Side Solutions: roadVision onnect OrderStream M Merchant Server icrosoft Site Server ommerce Edition (SSCE) etscape SellerXpert & erchantXpert pen Market andesic MART Technologies LinxTM/eToolsTM Buying Companies Internet Transactions & Data Transfer Collaboration Data Aggregation Solutions: • Ariba Network • ASPECT • Commerce One MarketSite • Harbinger • Requisite Technology Transaction Solutions: • Ariba Network • Commerce One MarketSite • Netscape ECXpert • Tradex • Open Buying on the Internet (OBI) • webMethods • WebDITM • VAN Strategic Procurement Employe Intrane ERP Buy-Side Solutions: • Ariba ORMS • Commerce One BuySit • Concur • Clarus • Intelisys • Netscape BuyerXpert • Oracle Internet Procurement • RightWorks • SAP B2B • Tradex • eLinxTM/eToolsTM Understanding the e-Procurement Players Process Rules Seller-Centric Solution Transaction Mgmt Content er from Company A er from Company B uyer from Company C Seller Organization Seller’s Infrastructure Characteristics Different look, feel, etc. per seller for buyers n Content presented in a seller-biased format n Transaction managed by seller’s system n No governance of purchase for buyer n Facilitates integration with Seller’s system n Need to establish secure connections to multiple vendor sites n Examples… eTools, CommerceOne SupplySite, Grainger.com, Industry.net, Open Market, most supplier web sites Understanding the e-Procurement Players Process Rules Buyer-Centric Solution Transaction Mgmt (Buyer-managed content) Content uyer’s anization Seller from Compa Buyer’s Infrastructure racteristics ferent support requirements per buyer for sellers ntent management more complex & costly ller access required (price changes, availability, etc.) ftware, hardware and infrastructure costs pedes real-time interaction with sellers cilitates integration with the Buyer’s system mples… Ariba ORMS, Clarus Procurement, CommerceOne Site, TradeEx, Intelisys Seller from Compa Seller from Comp Understanding the e-Procurement Players Process Rules Buyer-Centric Solution Transaction Mgmt (3rd Party Aggregated Content) Content uyer’s anization Buyer’s Infrastructure A G G R E G A T O R Seller from Compa racteristics gregator offers a value added service to convert data a standard,I.e. build content ferent support requirements per buyer for sellers gregator access required ftware, hardware and infrastructure costs pedes real-time interaction with sellers cilitates integration with the Buyer’s system mples… , Van, Harbinger, Requisite, Aspect, CommerceOne, Ariba through partners Seller from Compa Seller from Comp Understanding the e-Procurement Players OBI Solution uyer’s anization Process Rules Content Transaction Mgmt Transaction Mgmt Seller from Comp Buyer’s Infrastructure racteristics verages catalog content & search functionality supplier sites siness rules, approval workflow, order history, . reside on buyer’s system cess controlled from buyer side erent look, feel, etc. per seller for buyers ntent presented in a seller-biased format mples… sys, Ariba “Punchout” Seller from Comp Seller from Com Understanding the e-Procurement Players Process Rules Extranet Solution Transaction Mgmt Content Multiple Buyers Multiple Sellers Electronic Marketplace haracteristics Data standard implemented by the Electronic Marketplace The Electronic Marketplace offers a value added service to convert data to a andard, (i.e., build content) Generally supports parametric search capability across suppliers Dependant on critical mass xamples… ommerceOne, Ariba Network, Grainger.com Vendor Analysis: Overall Description Connections to ERP & Legacy Buy-Side Software Electronic Marketplace Sellers Catalogs ORMS Ariba Network Buy Site Market Site SAP PeopleSoft JDE Baan Oracle Aggregat Internet Procurement Oracle Exchange Grainger Chem gacy Systems TPN B2B mySAP.com Aspe Vendor Analysis: Vision Buy-Side Software Electronic Marketplace ORMS Ariba Network Deep Functionality Focus on Users Capture Full ORM Spend Secure Largest Market Share in Fortune 1000 ASP Solutions for Mid Market “Distributed” Content Buyers will Attract Suppliers/Partners Availability of Content will Attract More Buyers Network Effect Grows Participation Free for Buyers & Suppliers Buy Site Build Competitive Product While Promoting BuySide Solutions to Hook-Up to Market Site PeopleSoft is a Reseller/Partner Market Site Vision is Focused Here Regional Franchise Model Vs. Owning Buyer Aggregated Content Network Effect Fully Automated Process Internet Procurement Oracle Exchange Build Full Solution for Direct & Indirect Build a Solution that Works Beyond Oracle Installed Base Leverage Oracle’s Resources To First Build an Electronic Marketplace With Capabilities Similar to Ariba, Then to Leverage Oracle’s Customer Base to Participate B2B mySAP.com Built an Integrated e-Procurement Solution Focused on SAP Installed Base Leverage Installed Base Beyond Just e-Procurement Offer Full-Scale of Services for SAP Customers Vendor Analysis: Strengths - Features & Functionality Buy-Side Software ORMS User Interface & Wizards Dynamic Workflow Multi ERP w/Prebuilt Adapters Program Scalability Integrated T&E & e-Forms # Live Customers/Referenceability Automated P-Card Processes Buy Site Electronic Marketplace Ariba Network Punch-Out Feature Flexible Transaction Routing Large # Suppliers & Buyers Supplier Hook-Up Fast & Free Leverage Vertical & Horizontal Marketplaces Market Site Current Version Meets Basic Needs New Release (6.0) Promises to be Competitive with Ariba Price Open to Multiple e-Procurement Systems Data Aggregation Model Developed/Planned Range of Business Services Transaction Engine Large # of Suppliers Internet Procurement Oracle Exchange Synonym Search Reporting/Analysis Oracle Integration Price B2B SAP Integration Price Global Solution Vision mySAP.com Vision Vendor Analysis: Weaknesses Buy-Side Software ORMS High Initial Price Java-Client (Download) Buy Site Electronic Marketplace Ariba Network Closed to other Buy-Side Solutions Market Site Inadequate Workflow Limited ERP Integration-Multiple ERP Limited References/Scalability Microsoft (only) Platform Scalability of Aggregated Model Suppliers Required to Pay Internet Procurement Oracle Exchange Limited Functionality Poor Ease of Use Limited References (live) B2B Late to Market Schedule Keeps Slipping Not really in Existence mySAP.com Not Yet in Existence Vendor Analysis: How They Win Buy-Side Software Electronic Marketplace ORMS Ariba Network Strongest Buy-Side Solution & User Interface (With Wizards) Integrated T&E & e-Forms of Live Customers, Reference-ability & Proper Scalability Large Aggressive Sales Force Lots of Demos Strength of Buying Community Suppliers can Sign-Up Fast/Free # of Suppliers Promise of New Features Buy Site Market Site De-emphasize Buy-Side Solution Partner for T&E and e-Forms Positioning/Marketing Aggregated Content Model Current & Future Value Leverage Market Site “Franchise” Partners Internet Procurement Focus on Oracle Install Base Extremely Aggressive Sales/Pricing Focus on Vision Bold Claims Leverage “Quals” from Strategic Procurement B2B Focus on SAP Install Base Strong Existing Client Base/Market Share Focus on Vision and Strength of Development Oracle Exchange Focus on Vision Leverage TPN/Requisite in Interim mySAP.com ? Vendor Analysis: Market Buzz Buy-Side Software ORMS “Buy-side software is a commodity” “SAP & Oracle will kill them!” “Their price will have to come down” Electronic Marketplace Ariba Network “Why would anyone want to maintain a catalog?” Buy Site “Their strategy keeps changing” “They are losing some of their key clients - poor references @ others” “They have given up buy-side to Ariba” Market Site “Content management still required, they have 5 people @ Sabre Internet Procurement “Their references/claims don’t hold up including their largest - AT&T” “Clients are purchasing other solutions even when they have a free IP package” “Demos unstable at best” “Not really pure HTML - still Java client” “Don’t see how they can compete outside of giveaways in Oracle installed base” B2B “All they have is Vapor-Wear” “SAP is expensive to implement” Oracle Exchange “They don’t have an exchange only TPN - and they can’t get it to work” mySAP.com “What is it?” Contents What is B2B ? What is e-procurement? Who are the key players in e-procurement? What are the value propositions? Value of eProcurement • Standard Procurement (GartnerGroup and NAPM) – – – – Up to 60% of company revenue is spent on outside purchases 75% of invoices are typically for items costing less than $1,000 Cost in time/paperwork to create a purchase order (P.O.) is $70 to $300 Nearly 1/3 of non-production purchases are made outside the formal procurement process at an average of 15% to 27% higher costs – Overhead to procure a $5 item is the same as a $5,000 item • eProcurement (GartnerGroup) – Cost of an eProcurement P.O. averages approximately $6 – Best Practice eProcurement solutions can bring P.O. costs to below $1 – The Business-to-Business Web commerce application market will reach $1.27 billion by 2002; the buy-side portion of this market will be $300 million Depending on current Firm practices, eProcurement can potentially reduce internal buying and selling costs by more than 90%. Source: RB Webber & Associates $70 $6 – Derived from sources including CAPS, NAPM, and Stanford University Value of eProcurement eProcurement solutions are delivering quantifiable benefits… Improved strategic sourcing of difficult to manage categories* Supplier Cost Reduction Improved leverage due to better sourcing contract compliance 7 - 10% % Improved supplier processing costs s a v i n g s 4 - 7% 2 - 3% * If category has no prior strategic sourcing effort, savings can be significantly greater Value of eProcurement … these benefits are focused on a significant portion of corporate spendin indirect operating resources Manufacturing Resources 28% Operating Resources 36% Human Resources 17% Top 10 Operating Resources Rank Products / Services Office Supplies Office Equipment Computer HW/SW Travel Goods for resale/merchandise And Raw Materials Temporary services Printing Telecom Package Advertising Source: Preliminary Data from a Deloitte eProcurement survey Profit, Dividends 6% Taxes, Other 13% Source: Killen & Associates, 199 Companies Companies that that have have implemented implemented eProcurement eProcurement solutions solutions have have experienced experienced significant significant benefits: benefits: more more than than 7.5% 7.5% savings savings on on average average Source: Preliminary Data from a Deloitte eProcurement survey Where Does the e-Procurement Savings Come From? mponents of Cost Savings Distribution of Savings Routing & Authorization Procurement Operations 5.0% 8.8% Receiving & Payment Operating Goods & Services 5.5% Value of eProcurement The eProcurement value proposition captures these benefits and supports the case for change… Savings on Procurement Spend n Larger discounts from vendors, typically 2+% additional off for using eProcurement n Ability to source & configure non-traditional items (e.g., advertising) n Compliance to item level standards n Increased compliance for corporate contracts from 20% to 90% Savings on Processing and Transaction n Reduced PO costs n Reduced time required to process and approve POs and requisitions n Ability to strategically source and leverage smaller purchases n Continuous improvement on cost reduction n Auctioning for commodities n Reducing high margin substitutions n Reporting n Reduction in associated process costs through automated forms capability n Reduced errors n Reduced cycle times to both find and process purchase Lower head count requirements n Reduce head count in appropriate departments Cost of implementation and maintenance n Software license and maintenance fees n Hardware costs and maintenance fees Value proposition n NPV n IRR n Payback Period n Implementation n Catalogs, and Ongoing Support training and enhancements Value of eProcurement An integrated Strategic Sourcing and eProcurement approach enables Procurement Transformation and provides tools for improved supplier management Strategic Sourcing • A collaborative and systematic approach for dramatically reducing “external spend”while improving quality and internal processes • Has typically been an under-utilized lever which provides a “high-gain, low-pain”alternative for reducing costs E-Procurement • Extends product selection and order initiation to the desktops of frontline employees while maintaining the contracts and business rules of the organization • Captures and automates the presentation of customized supplier information to multiple user Procurement Transformation • Enhances the procurement function with an integrated supply chain, streamlined processes, cost reductions, and strategic supplier alliances • Leverages detailed vendor performance and transaction information to support strategic procurement decisions Value of eProcurement By leveraging the benefits derived from each initiative, synergistic and sustainable results may be attained E-Procurement Strategic Sourcing Encourages use of supplier agreements (i.e., eliminates “maverick”buying ) Better data provided from E-Procurement system to support sourcing Frees up Procurement resources to focus on strategic efforts Results in consolidated supplier lists 10% – 30% Total Savings • Focuses development work with preferred suppliers • Reduces number and complexity of catalogs • Focuses catalog content and features on priori • Allows required supplier efforts to be included negotiated agreements • Reduces maintenance cost and complexity of catalog and system • Prioritizes roll-out based on benefits Procurement Transformation • • • • • Instills “customer focus” Eliminates low-value activities Improves procurement process workflow Standardizes procurement practices Promotes capture and use of data to enable supplier alliances Value of eProcurement Concurrent projects ensure that strategic sourcing best practices are integrated into eProcurement efforts Impact on Purchasing Cost Savings as % of Total Spend Up to 10% Up to 20% Initiatives Strategic Sourcing Initiative • • • • Total cost of ownership Product substitutions/standardization Corporate wide purchasing Supplier rationalization eProcurement Initiative • • • • Contract management Demand management (changing buyer behavio Streamlined transactions Continuous improvement