docMiami Shooting 4-11-86 Part 7 of 11 - The Vault
download 
Report Transcription
Miami Shooting 4-11-86 Part 7 of 11 - The Vault
92
FEDERAL BUREAU
OF INVESTIGATION
SHOOTING INCIDENT
4/11/86 MIAMI,
FL
PART
BUFILE:
2OF
4
62-121996
i|
Freedom of Information
and
Privacy Acts
SUBJECT
éz pfimg
In c.J:i£!£./I929"1"/4-J//"""g/Q
/0
FILE
NUMBER
_Z "
W
v"" ..' v
<.
4" -£1
* Is» E0
.»
:1»
_an <~
I
Y
1 ?
'lAvt.!!h%'
O4?
<1
>:>
e
?
£4!! OFx
in-" ¢9'
Federal
Bureau
of Investigation
I
If
.
/ " Memorandum I f
_Lu_
i._
&
___-i
."-.H
I !.-"
__;__
92
T0
C
Fmm
Mr.
lull. Dim
All. larva._._
Crllu.low._.._..._
I-Qi.___i....
D818
I-a
ulC
oncm. |.
/
PublicAlb. i
In. I'M.
....-..-.
'|'s¢
lawn. .-.-_
Tnlnlng._._.._..
Tllsplvsnn
II. i
°llI¢l "l §0¢'
i
:
Subject
:
Ila: AD-Ill. _._
_.>5
J-;;.'_"-1
_w Inc:
IDllw.
i_
»'T~
--;=~»~=
INQUIRY
INCIDENT
, FLORIDA
This is to requestthat a 62- tile
number be assigned
CO U118 Hittit-
92
--
APPROVED:cni_n'hY.
A¢m-'~=
'-'*
;_
-=~=----j'f_°'_
~ LC_,'J¥
auh-..
11.?
' '
OH dConB5 Pr.J.1h.,
A s. '"
Director
' ___sw.__-_-
Exec
FD-nth
_______
1,-Q-:.1i.___
,,__
*.!q":'.
_
5,,.;_pQ.:_;;s_2 hlel1,________,__
mm" ---
--"
" BE-74 s_g};Ia_|q
I
Searched_.__
"I'" 8- _ P°"
1_
b
BJW19 198%
Kw
v ,
.
'-'.""."*
' -J;
'-._,-;'
I <92'?-f-- 4- ,;~-
3 JUL141985
,,..._
s
"
.
~
*1
s..
T _ pp
'
L
"
'-l
nu/oo3_.
I .
I92- ,
-'
Memorandum
I
V»
I
-2
'
I3 &#
1, -,1! Aul.
nap:
117.71" lls. Sons. _..
/"-._ ;
1
"
f_V._1, AD
,£_j:V
Ala.
.4
'
7"
W7
CHI. luv. ..__
I ||l._i__
C.
7'
Ilisp.
. '
H'
1.». 1'41- 0&5!
_
knoll _i_
ea. 5/Z/55 till
M M.
OH.C
From
D'.G]:
,
,
ova
cl Y9292I92923
*92-NE,
U """"", m_":_&#
I
Suki : *sHoo'rIuc
IiicrosuriIi92<%_~;n<~5_
I
4" °"
_
4Futile-llh.__
TTIKMI DIVISION
4/11/86
PURPOSE: To
provide a
aeveI0ped to date. _
' DETAILS:
.
summary of
results of
at Miami,
the
inquiry te
-"'¥
Composition
7i
Inspector I
Inspector
Unit
Chief
SSA
bé
:
-C
SSA
Haven
Unit
Division I
an air
crew to
take
Division,
a
had
The Baltimore
aerial photographs
of the
crime scene.
,_
~
-Quantico
In
addition,SSA
ILaboratory
Team repor
ing o
the Inspector.
six-man Forensic
Division provided
L1&1-
nal Investigative
-Chicago
Division [i
Divi -
,/'
as
a shooting
to
Miami.
am
team S
of the
the inquiry
_
-s~se"
4.
,
Interviews of
signed statements
_4 He
-.._.
all participants
obtained. The
ther"__"e-c
Nitnn
infnruinuq
q _"-__.__-_ _"o-c__
.. *
- - -t I-_'
..-~,.--<-
have been
completed
neighborhood investigation,
and +hn
nF -_"_ ,--nabharinn
--. ,
-.3-92-hp ---¢,,-=~»_'-
»v
and
needed backgzguné
_
material been
have comp1eted2_ENCLO§URE
_
__
fmi _M G t 7Se7arched__._...l
N" ""°"" 8
1- Mr.
Revell ?a'!g
: Mir.
Ggzver
8JUN
Q£.:l%
I g
1
1
1
-Mr.
-MI.
Hint:
1
1
_H1 .
_Ur
= goourrsurp--oven!
s
2'
I d-'-
- HI.
Otto
_
7 ''.
_1.".-3;
92
.I ~ = "'h|
.
I1,
<2
Memorandum
J.
D.
Re: Shooting
Glover to
Mr. Otto
Incident
Miami Division
4/ll/86
The FBI Laboratory Team
examinations and laboratory tests;
photographs and
other exhibits
has completed
preparation of
is
underway.
on-the-scene
charts, graphs,
bub
of the
are available
crime scone
for walk
and audio
throughs of the events.
of EB!
Videotape
and Metro-Dads
radio
transmissions
RECOHMENDATIOI
unnmmh :: -'y@§Cmn._____-ai -"* Qm@Kmq_
l.'$tI692U __......._._-
euaaommm",, hut
Fiat "5""-~
RKLmF '._n
E1oc.AD4l'II. q-n-it
:"::n;. v..
Elg K0155 i -
£70 .
..-.,
r-
r='aw~
'1-_-..
1
~.
.4:
Ait
..
,__.
..;_.;.1..
&#
r.._--P92".r.~'3,..;¢_£
.
.-a- '-If
:-
_, E
at _2_
is
Q
D
' ..
.-.4.-p92=.
.'-. ,.- - A-n-, ._..._..
,
.___._12:.
. '
-- .1.-1-#_aa:.,
,;.
tr;
92
._
__
4 ==~ -"
5
__,, __
::;;--L--,; __:;:__WT, I _~,_; ________
_..__-._t.__.._.
n-_..
.. 92_-:__.-r.
_.__i.=.._.._.......;__.__.__..1..
.__...._._..._.....
-
1,
-,1
SUMMARY
SHOOTING INCIDENT
MIAMI DIVISION
APRIL 11,
BACKGROUED OE
INVESTIGATION
Since October,
conducting an
1986
1985, the
investigation to
individuals responsible
for
robberies occurring
in that
Miami Division
identify,
aseries
has been
locate
and
of bank
division." The
apprehend
two
and armored
car
individual crimes
are as
a
follows 4.
5
Inc? ffai 1, on-October
.
|I92u.Il92
1111-9
J.WU
S
HG
It=
Q5"
:1
attempted robberygai
Dixie
Store
E
J_ {M _
located
A tuna
:___ _,1
K
16, 1905,
was
_
the
armored truck,
in frontof aWinn
0Southwest
QIn
104th Street,
In
Miami, Florida.
Q
.
who demanded
that the
I
drive-in facility
be opened
and made
accessible to the robbers. The teller and the guardwere
unable
open the
drive-in facility
was carrying
made
to the
in
license plates.
robber
drive-in; $10,000
" -"etaway
vehicle
on
and the
ablack,
; Incident
money the
was obtained.
Chrysler New
The license
September 30,
took
the
plates
had
to
teller
The robbers
Yorker with
Florida
been stolen
from
another T
1985.
#3 was
the robbery
of the
Professional Savings
?
&Bank
at 13001South Dixie
Highway, Miami,
Florida, onNovember 8,
5
1985
,
at 12: is
;$i:=,W__,_committed
__ gas by
-two white
males ,
fitting th¢'?%§@f?f1°n!
g 9"?
£?§¥
pi?
the aforementioned
- -In
ill"»..: %@'_;:
- '
aw--"3,
-.-~is in
-/.'*r
.1..
-92_--1._,
.!-'
15..-.
ALL
___92_92_ L_.!
__
. .. ?.*.... -r
.-._'5-Z__.
._
_;..,-,-A,
-AJ Q
-."-.-. "-='-1-"vi
a
ruoneries. in t 1§g§ §!!QM§§Q!I runner
was carrying
alarge
rrame
chrome-plated revollv
the other
robbercarrying
was
what
.,-->.r_
*.
appeared
to
be
robbery, both
tellers
either an
subjects entered
to
the
her to
the
H-16 or
the bank
floor. One
back area
had just
made
of the
at the
robbery was
or 1977
beige. Chevrolet
The fourth
January 10,
was obtained.
in
1986, at
10:30 a.m.,
Wells
rargo
robber
in progress.
..
._,,.. .....,
_,. .
..
The getaway vehicle utilized
Monte Carlo
series
of
this
took
number two
,_
robbery, $41,469
was a1976
a teller
and
bank.
The
while the
customers and
bags.
.r
In this
this
and ordered
Wells
Fargo
to the
front door
rifle. During
robbers grabbed
demanding the
a money
delivery
stood
guard
an AR-15
with
avinyl
robberies occurred
and involved
aBrinks
top.
on
armored truck
at the Barnett Bank
at 13593South Dixie
Highway. Again,
this ':
srobbery
was committed
an AR-15
- *1i~&i%
9*
T
or M-16
by
two
white males,
one
rifle and
.
<
the other
q-
t
-
».,
with
2 -.
n.
T
n¢¥*+n
of whom was armed_w1thyH_
ashotgun.
The loss
»<»_r1>:.
in '
as-<»mrm~»n1
~.
T.
,e¢@:»#",,; a*r
,M._
N
_
gi
this robbery
was $54,000.
aBrinks
courier as
prior to
making
guard in
the back
robber sbot
apickup
with the
the guard
away ina
gold, Chevrolet
a citizen
who observed
door of
#7 shot,
range with
rear of
the robbers
arifle.
shot the
and the
truck and
This vehicle
at another
lord 0:46
truck
other
Gne robber
the Brinks
Monte Carlo.
or
beige-colored
One robber
shotgun, utilizing
from the
subjects accosted
his armored
Barnett Bank.
at close
money bag
robbery, the
the back
at the
getaway
i:
4-
During the
he opened
removed a
white-
i
both drove
was followed
location switch
pickup
truck.
by
into a
The original
iigry-was registered
to ll
investigation
6e%i{j;Q§_'Q
»,_ disappeared
id
his with
car
on ;
4-;UV _,::f in . __W_
October
1985.
Ssgono
5, 11¢ shooting
target
the Evergl
in &
. '_
i
M-,,,_,;|
*¢e?
alone, utilizing
his .22-caliber
' On
March 12,
located at
157th Avenue
Trail. This
lake is
rifle.
1986, went
shooting at
and Southwest
utilized by
16th Street,
a lake
near the
local
residents
both for
e
Tamiami
fishing
and target
shooting.
is believed
It that this
isalake
where /
_ __
A_
Aureliano Brlel,
_,
_,
a
mentioned above, disappeared. While_was
J
Q4 '
16$
target practicing he observedtwo whitemales shootingtargets!mm w "
across the
lake from
him. These
and drove
over toand Wesson
.357 Magnum
two white
males entered
The driver,
armed
with
a ModelSmith
13
and the
passenger with
a Roger
Stainless withafolding stock, demanded
weapons.
avehicle
Mini-14
wallet, carand
was then
taken by
one ofthe males
to anarea by1
_
the lake and shotthree timeswith the Magnum. severely
3'
-. i.-. <
_-in
-"
'_w92_.
l___
__
__ _:.__,__:L& ~;E_-|ff ,
-
_-, -_:'*.~92.~_'a..i-3
'
.----J .92-_"~r.'-I|:aéi.~:-.
.. _
er; _Tr"
~: _~_:'7"'
&
m. V!
wounded, played
dead and
survived. The
robbers
took
vehicle, which
is described
with Florida
as a1979,
license NTJ-891.
shooting incident.
This
In addition
Model
14,
black
Monte
Carlo
vehicle used
vehicle, the
in
this
Suspects took
as aSmith and Wesson
Combat
blue with
Model 60, .22-caliber rifle
isthe
to the
_weapons, described
Masterpiece
two-door,
tan rogers
with a
rubber grip
scope Note:
Model 60!.
and
aMartin
this may be
Marlin
-
The fifth
and last
robbery in
this series
took place
at
***d?? - em¢;~emr
the Barnett
QMTQSSQ3
South
'__$ighuay,
-on March
19,1986,
at
9:25
a.m. ~sn'ne1opn_t--____'
to be
identical Iw-
the robbers
at Iii ?
13
H"stationed
robberies, entered
the
bank, went
over thrr, -and took
two money
bags. They
had
preceded
aBrinks
minutes. During
the robbery,
weapon thought
to be
taken. Witnesses
be
the
the Mini-14
observed the
Chevrolet
at the
one of
bank
by
approximately 30
the robbers
rifle. In
carried a
this robbery;
getaway vehicle,
which turned
plate,
Planningwand Equipment M
'
f
shoulder
$8,000 was
out to
L?
Monte
its
Florida license
> i
armored truck
Based
on the
information concerning
mv;q*T ": %qMT _
this
robb_
the Reactive
Squad C-1!
of the Miami Division
formulated plan
a to
!place Agents
in the general area
oi the bank and
armored car
grobberies in
Southwest Miami,
in an
attempt to
spot the robbers_j
en route
to arobbery
--
and apprehend
them. Based
on a known,modus,f,
.-~l
.-...- , .
- 1,=
'_7*~ .1?
Z.- -*?
¢.- F!
plan. Surzeillances
locating the
on two
prior occasions
subjects. The
under the
squad, utilizing
supervision of
decided to
set up
section of
Miami, where
Special Agent
SSA
Gordon
in the
had occurred
Headquarters City
on April
11,
1986,
four banks
all known
prior
activity
was centered.
three Resident
Agents from
since at
participating, %,g_~aaa
general southwest
least one
territory, which
territory in
in
the
oi the
is adjacent
This
the
robberies
to the
Southwest Miami.
-311 14
received-a nriering
all were £ami¬§%%d? Eh
in
Agents,
area of
Agency RA!,
in their
unsuccessful
14
Special
G. HcNeil1,
complement included
Homestead Resident
had been
and instructions,
and
tha;?$?¬E¥;W§i%
of the preceding
%I each
robberies
luv '
yn
" istterbeen
had cloely
cooinated
rdwi the
th _-pol
1tan--Dade
County
icePol
Force;
howeve
no local
officers partle
pared in
the April
11,
1986,
surveillance
activity. ,
Vehicles utilized
and to
the Homestead
radio communications
The Agents
both had
weapons.
shotguns in
surveillance who
H-16 rifles
issued or
RA, and
at
cars belonging
least
one
of
with Metropolitan-Dade
were ermed
had shoulder
were Bureau
with their
SA
ldmundo
and submachine
Mireles and
SSA
Gordon
guns. All
radio.
of the
on the
the shooting
were armed
weapons utilized
of the
Agents
G. Hc eill
Other Agents
and all
squad
had
County Police
anumber
involved in
Bureau-approved weapons
these
vehicles
sidearms and
their vehicles.
were not
to the
with
were Bureau-
Agents were
fully
-
qualified with
the weapons
in their
possession.
-L
_
_
5 aI
5_
, ,§§g§o;;@;@;;
V
_"'"fl" *"'r-K!"--~71---'
7517" 7"
__ __1,
--. - ' ~ ':v__=r
?.__...4.---.-__._
,. .-'._
.,.'
'
. 1_. -
,ne;;ht;$ra#tex:
"
92
;__
T-»_-.._:______
." '_-_'-he
--_:_:.
., H. -,-. -_ _ ;-~
1.; J
SSA McNeill
in the
southwest
assigned teams
area.
These
The exact
distances from
are being
plotted and
possessed
by
known that
that most
the various
and will
all of
of them had the
A" '_:
banks to
the
weapons and
be-made part
shooting incident
report.
other equipment
during this
of the
had been
issued
vests in
four banks
some distance.
the final
Agent personnel
the Agents
to cover
separated by
available in
inventory of
all Special
being compiled
banks were
will be
A complete
of Agents
incident is
final report.
It is
bulletproof vests
their vehicles,
but not
and
all uere
.
wearing thcnb%#f»ph §ime
o§_ Ab; gtident.
.
_.
.,,,'
neE"_@-?h
*+@%;;_;e$i.
..%a;;L&
; ¬§ss.*¢>'
'
"
Th8 ShOOti.I'i
' '1_ 1la .-;
; ----.,
-
rho
. -1:-52'
> 1;...
4
'"4:
.
_.
ng
-.'
has ini its possession a
. ?M?¬%E§QV¬*
transcript ofFBI ildéé hransmissions
which were
monitored and
tape
recorded by acitizen H o
nenspaper and
an effort
is astringer
who monitors
to
pick
via scanner
up astory.
for the
Miami Herald"
law enforcement
In addition,
channels in
the shooting
inquiry
team has
in its possession
fa
11, l986,'8A_Benjamin
P.
=* ..¢.
At approximately 9:30 a.m.,
April
Grogan HM-202!radioed as-follows:
Q
-
6
l -_5_ ,_.._
---
"Hey. Attention
__
-
all
units.
- N.
-.
:';.';-_
, '
"'; ¥+;-1-is-f'i~@v~E._->!;92i.._.."Hit-9
" " '-*1
'-i" 3'
"'
"
.
1*; f"
"'
"
2j -
-M ';'
.-'=- .-E-.'._
_
I3
-T
-':*'"""
=**---~'
"
LY
We're behind
ablack
vehicle two-door
we're headed south on
SA
Grogan
SA
Grogan
OK, where?
two males
radio, "Metro
South Dixie."
radio, "202
replied, "north
right away
SA
Ronald
are you
on South
124th Street.
NTJ-B91.
NTJ-891.
that?"
on the
SA
Grogan,
in it,
North on
" unintel1igible! read
then called
or
south?"
Florida license
South Dixie.
then said
Risner MM-131!
=!
G.
heading north
Dixie,"
SA
Risner,
It's ablack Monte
SSA
McNei1l
MM-214! called
and let'stry and
yank that
Carlo,
on the
guy.
SA
Groganthen Now. Let : gethim yanked.
Let's
ah...get
LL
B111
S,
call
your
give in the 1OCdti.0n.d
,:J,'sws+¢-
Il_ . d|
vou
north
J
A, W
,,»»§._N_,,;H%*
"1-..YOl.I
ate
A
of ther3 5iT?5.o*¥' *ln-+hen
Pe
li=d~ "Rookie"
no
Q ran-1'
a-nwv my
ood,
NTJ-891.
SA
Grogan
id, "12oth
Street,get
let'
here
and
up A
__
____
4- a,H1.
let's stop them if
we
have
to.
SA
Risner
then said
592ll'
on the
radio,
0
-a
OK, hold
on Ben,
replied on
202]
then
till-we get
the radio,
said, Two
mustache.
All right,
SA
Dove
said,
"Them
are making
then said,
"Southwest 81st
inthe
up there.
here."
SA
Grogan
SA
Jerry
vehicle, uh,
whose initial
let's see
if they stop,
NTJ-B91, they
blow up
white males
SSA
Mcneill,
unintelligible then
enough people
Dove MH-
one with
a
transmission is
until we
can get
some help
_;,..
and then
r.,.
92
-.
SA
Grogan said, '¢ordo, thatis
od;Hplate, ma
aright
turn on
Getting spooked,
Road heading
117th, right
guys.
south again."
SA
Dove
on 117th.
then said,
SSA
Mc eill
said, Did
a
you get
Metro?
SA
Mireles
givemea cross
street."
lA
-his
2
§.
MM-55! said,
Right behind
SA
Grogansaid, F tand
by."
you babe,
*'"
,_,..,-_~_
a
'
S i»L 1
bi»?
'
1°° ti° Be ? 5" G ° §"
' "'
92_
Street, right
turn on
f
120th Street
going west.
SA
Mireles
then
came onthe air saying, Ben we're right
behind you
babe.
wanna do
it, let's
some marked
do it."
units. Let's
--_I_.._-. -l.-WI: I:Ju
_ __J
SA
Dove
SA
Grogan
replied, That's
and said,
i_.__
J. GL8
at them,
SA
Grogan
let's get
SA
Risner
.l,92___- __.._2.__
LIIB] Cullllllg
said, OK
I__-=I_ l_._--_._Z
IJGLK I- Judi-U
Mc eill came
they'reguys
loading
then said,
heard saying,in,the
**% K .
broken!."
affirmative. SSA
"Just
looked
the front."
replied, "Negative,
get some
PI :1
"J U-in
You
on the
air
up
something
"Let's do it.
background, Felony
' -
rI H
UIDI
SA
Dove
car stop.
in
can be
Take em,
felony
car atop, 1et@!;%;g§t.'
irg
~iA
as says on the
air,"Jerry?'
=.-..-- -1. .
<-1
-
SA
Doverepli s
L.-...
ft. 1
.--.. _,a'.&:£ £"
imo-=>I:
follow between
SA
'_."..;.':~_:»'::1':j:-:-'-""
I
..... .....
Hm
l__ _,
._,
1_,
.
u-u-1-sun wno
are tryingto é7¢
locate the
scene. I - ii:-suddenly
says the
on air."Pe0P1e dow
6,
SA
Risner
then comes
get some help over
on the
air and
says, We
here.
got people
down, 1et s
l
H
. ,_.._.
It is
broadcast that
became aware
driving on
hereto
positions of
is
a
apparent from
at some
that they
point during
were being
Bide streets
preliminary crime
the vehicles.
the transcript
with which
of the
the surveillance,
. __
FBI radio
the subjects
followed and
then began
they were
familiar. Attached
scene sketch
showing the
slowly
final _~4
I---*.'¢:.1
a.-_
,
"3 --' '1.»
_
,
As the vehicles involved
decision was
made to
driving the
and siren
which was
occupied by
MM-55!,
stop them.
Shs Grogan
vehicle depicted
blue light
from the
came south on Southwest 82nd Avenue, a
rear and
and
SA
in the
to affect
sketch as
a"felony
SA Richard
Vehicle #7,
and Dove
#6, activated
car stop."
A. Hanauzzi
their
Vehicle #4,
MM-66!, was
occupied by
Mireles, pulled
who were
SA John
up alongside
coming up
F. Hanlon,
the subject
Jr.
car.
~>
i
Il
H
HIla HanlonHireles
and are
2Z
_I
alongside the
P- - ° 1Y 5"
swung his
wheels back
vehicle and
right to
may have missed it
SA Manauzzi.
In any
Hireles lost
the wall
to the
event, the
control, ran
depicted in
over a
the sketch.
" " °" "°"
impact against
and struck
the subject
the vehicle
vehicle occupied
short post
operated by
by SAs
and came
The subjects
Hanlon and
to rest
again into
Manauzzi
made
the
the driver's side or
between HM-66, atree
the residence
12201, 12203
sketch, Vehicles
and Vehicle
. e,
tree directly
and
a
turn with
the subject's car,
parked automobile
V
subject vehicle!
in a
yard
Avenue. As
came-to rest
once 2
"
pinning
it
infront
shown in
#1 and $2 were parked unoccupied inthat
#3 the
-. .¢
,q......,.__. _.
.. _-l._ . ~-..-_.-~- -.¢,-- _- ,III-92
then, impacted
Southwest 82nd
against
made a U-turn
heading
..
northbound. SA
'
of
the
residence
between them
and a
'
in front of the subjects and Vehicle i4,5Sa,§anauzzi's
>pw_
- ;e 5,, k _»_
- - Iri
-4» -.7 -:3_..- .v--_
i, ,_- .
W
~
--
9 --
~,,'_ 1- ._
u.;,--
-
t =.
*-.-RI
,..
I.
u
'*-"~'-I-1.5,-;'
L
192;;"e92*
_ -1""
:r',_-f&
S,~.~;
1__~ , r--;~ ._-.'
lg'
-
r
/to
4.-_-_..-_.......
=~-- -.-'__;_,_;_
~_ -__... __,
_
' -r- - '
,_;,,_,
7 7I _
-s-.7. :_1_,-.
I »--. '_
____
_|__..
_...,--
_-it--
_.__, __._k ....___
_.__._-.____ .,_.,_
l'
#5, occupied
vehicle!.- Vehicle
and Vehicle-#6,
and parked
occupied by
to the
rear of
of the
subjects, now
fired a
shotgun blast
shot, penetrated
by SSA
the subjects
at SA
the back
on the
driver's side.
on his
hip in
be the
subject
of the
of the
head as
did not
him
the car.
that SSA
ll
Hc eill
hit
III
Southwest 82nd
Avenue, ,
where
Vehicle
and took
and was
vehicle
principally by
the
~;@
fire by
As he
left the
Mini-14, semiautomatic
across the
SA Manauzzi's
car and
hood of
passenger compartment
of the
and thought
a wall
near
the subjects,
Lee Platt,
Ruger .223-caliber
who was armed with
rifle. SSA
a
hc eill leaned
emptied his
revolver into
Monte Carlo, occupied
by the
""
the handby return
ffire. Bleeding profusely, heattempted to
reload; however,
blood
p'!from
his
hand ran into the cylindersand hecould notput more
'
,rounds
into his
of Vehicle
weapon. SSA
Mcueill then
withdrew toward
#5.
In the
service revolver,
§=
was
impacted. SSA Mcueill
- *'
fubjects.At this
point SSAHcueill washit in
_£
8A Manauzzi
shelter behind
taken under
subject Michael
the
Hanauzai crossed
#7 SAs Hanlon and Mireles! had
exited his
." the
and, in
coming
in
him.
SA
vehicle
weapon strapped
eunarmed.
a
#6
SA Hanauzzi
exiting his
have his
was lying
beside
*£o'the :0!
to be
and struck
he was
one
Hattix,
shot, determined
unable to
vehicle in
area
this point,
William R.
Bureau car
SA Manauzzi
a h_o1ster. It
the you
into the
vehicle. At
Manauzzi. The
the window
back and
McNei1l, turneé
SAs Grogan and Dove, had made aU-turn
thought to
in the
.impact,
_!
the rear
~
-
impact of
not secured
Vehicle #7
on his
-]_ ..-
on the
wall, SA
hip, although
. -_
_.
'
.'
"
12.;
In10n'l '¢ e.
holstered, was
.. 4.. '...,wa__.
.__ ._.
._.
._.... _.-e
..
92
.._.
P
" '_"
7* |_-_ _~:----- -g-4.-;qqg;__,,T,';____;;,_,,|gj;;___4__ _____
7___'
'
___
,_ -._.
_- .4
p
_. *.,.....I;,
._.
. .'I.L_
_____
__
r_-
__-
_;T_.
-;~c.--r - e"!
,_!
lost or
tumbled to
shot Smith
the floor
and Wesson
proceeded into
and were
approached the
proceeded to
wound to
the
from his
rear
of
As SA
and
Mireles had
taken under
fire
arm and
Vehicle #6,
exited
by
the
went down.
crouched and
into the
Hanlon started
.
~,.f,92u'c. u=
V»-':.
_g . _;.
five-
As SA Hireles
his left
five-shot revolver
subject's vehicle.
-
anlon and
he
was
drew his
ankle holster
the scene.
Vehicle #5,
asevere
SA Hanlon
from an
area. SAs
running onto
area of
riflemen, suffered
five rounds
car and
Snubnose Revolver
the shooting
their vehicle
SA Hanlon
of the
back of
m
Alas hit in the gpi ;y §i£le;E$§;§§h§be
gent
the
his weapon,
to reload
p.
fired
he
down.%ait thia'point
or
shortly befo%;L@MJ kSi1§;;£¬§§?.T§§§%ia
and hisner
arrived on
the
5¢B"e| 5t°PS;:§¬%$jl§g@#%?i%¢§l5"%?rorim
the position
shown a
#3 inthe Bketchr
;£a f%f£h tiring
at thesubjects, by
who
this time
were outof their vehié i andmoving inthe areaof Vehiclesil, #2
and #3.
rounds of
utilizing these
vehicles as
.38-caliber +P
Wesson revolver
total from
cover. SA
Orrantia fired
service ammunition
and SA
Risner estimates
his issued
Model 459
from his
he fired
.9m Smith
12
.357 Smith
l3 to
and
14
rounds
and Wesson
semiautomatic
pistol.
_- .
SSA Hc eill
incapacitated due
was shot
to temporary
SAs Grogan
firing on
fire with
ashotgun.
down the-driver :
from an
Following
R. Matti:
second time
area
of
aperiod
apparently took
This was
side of
and
.4, ._
"Q"
became
paralysis.
and Dove,
the subjects.
subject William
for a
of intense
SAs Grogan
evidenced bypa
vehicle i6.*@Ihi1e
-
Vehicle #6,
began
gunfire,
and Dove
pattern nf
under
#6 shot
,_
Mattiriiachanged fire
'
*6
11
__ .-,-_,92-nm»:=.
' ' "" "" *'-"*'
",'
'-""F
__ ;-f *%=fi_ .*'-~ _-_--" - __,'i '__
_
:~-?:----: ¥_-q; ;~r
__ V f -.
_ _ ___"._
__
. ___- ,k__
-.
'
'
"IKE ._'
T 1,
'
--~e
._. .,
.r-. I-a-.---,
~~--
41
-.
with SAs
Grogan and
Dove, Michael
vehicle and-proceeded
of it,
area,
and
shooting and
Immediately
G
wee firing
after
shooting
approached the
Bureau vehicle
their escape.
Both
SA Hireles,
marked
of
them
entered
who was apparently semiconscious,
.4,
23;. .. -
behind car §5§§fi§§
dfire*Qjj¢§uehbjects
oar-err». ¥é+ wQ e?
.-
of
his
cover
Hanlon,
killing SAs
SA Eisner
left
passe
shooting SA
of
time,
Lee Platt
down
the
the trunk
period
I
;;w- g
_11%,;
and
in the
..-,-, if_: :V.=_
QAr
I jm;$%Q'@
his Bureau-is-*:J§'-otgun
waslea
forced
Liv
-=.=s.._"
Q £811
-"
.3
_
-_-r
'
-
'
14- L
ll
legs, racked
it with= .--tight
hand,
nger side
of
car
who
was
#6, leaned
down,
in
rogan and
over
the groin
Dove. During
this
Platt and
Matti:
l92
92.|
'-< ___
- ..':I5-
over the
rear bumper
apparently fired
of the
car and
five rounds
of
the left
front
fender,
driver's wind
His shot
patterns were
found in
this round
of
fire
he
hit
the
the subjec
the Agents,
as
car
the vehicle.
#6, apparently
to
effect
At this
point,_
was slightly
00 buckshot,
mi lto
-- .- =1-_:.*
Q:
_-,,~_'
H-....=
-a-»_~-,},___..__.~
!BI car,¢t111zing
fire the gun
.
neighborhood,
further
and crime
corroborated
Forensic
I
scene
as forensic
A crime
scene
were
the
Laboratory
is
cartridge
cases
not
establishes
probable
that
retrieved.
It
identifications
establish
definitely
All
of
by Matti:
rounds
ir
a Smith
revolvers
and
ammunition.
without
shotgun pellets;
believed
to have been inflicted
entering
the
l3 or
14
however,
SA Orrantia
by shrapnel
have determined
rounds
that
from
his
his
by
superficial
wounds
Ballistics
. ff .
"_.-.I
the following
SA Risner
were recovered.
Agents.
superficial
vehicle.
and had put a second loaded clip
only six cartridges
them
from a .357 round
Agents fired
.9mm.
one a
was inflicted
suffered
passenger'scompartment
of
six
by
Both
of
striking
SA Manauzzi suffered
wounds
from
-
Ballistics
from his shotgun.
Wesson.
the severe damage done to Agent personnel
SA Risner
minimum
of
.357 Magnum revolvers,
the .223-caliber
fired
that
a
sin:-'14.
hm as possibly §@?¥?
W
other
examinations
and
fired
that 40 rounds were fired
and
three
and
rounds
rounds were exchanged.
PJQ223
¢
Dan Wesson
fired
were
estimated
rounds
Both Matti:
Homicide Detectives
rounds
is
total
rum; from
be
developed.
131 identifiable
other
131 and as many as 140-145
three
is
search by Metro-Bade
FBI
fired.
It
evidence
will
it
Examinations
'
and Ballistics
Agents
of
Some
of
investigation.
states
that
. -1 ,
rounds:
he
in the weapon;
SA Grogan
-
nine
rounds from a .9mm. SA Dove - 20 rounds from his .9mm; cartridges
all recovered. SAOrrantia
Magnum.
K: iv
- ,
"
12 rounds.38-caliber»&P_ammunitioniuf.
-. .
from his
.351
..--»l.
SSA Mc eill
___'
.-_,_;._,,__ _,
_,;v__
*
92;-_
-
six
rounds
.38-caliber
+P
,. V. '
- .. '
--._,~,>_,
-._,;_-__, >_
.- .¢1.-:_; ,, .92
-.v- ,_, _- .y '.---. ;._-. 92_
_..
v-V ._ '*
-~ ..
-1" .
-1-: 2 -*-1-A
---.. ..
..
-1--. »__
5 ;";i".ip.?J
-- v
_ -- _='
_,.=-.__.=
'.':.;'.='92'ir:
-.1»- " F
».;.-"
='
-=".'
-:___=,=._,,;;
-{$3
_=-_..,-.1-a
§-$r...e1'
.,_.-.1,-_.-_.;-:
;.- L;.-
"-"'
' "'
'
"f7<
___.__
'
'
'3
.
-. -r 'T'_';fiT"-*¢7{:7'T-:1;'7
""
Y" '?-*_':"
:;* ; p=i-_j;¬r{:_:;;fi_Y#;""'*':5E Z¢-eat .-ii;
r-.'.,4.1"
, .
-"
-" "
'
'' "
'
,
ammunition from
caliber +P
five rounds
his .357
ammunition from
00 buckshot
ammunition from
his service
Magnum. SA
Hanlon
-five
his .38-caliber
from his
shotgun;
rounds .38-
revolver. SA
six
rounds
Mireles -
.38-caliber +P
revolver.
?
e. ___.e
es
":~.-z
57$
l
-'-1
-~--.u¢.->92».I..~J-.v<
..--Q. .-=-.._.-.
3.at
-3- 4,
'p -'
In addition,
I
conducting forensics
~.._----t
_- 1.V
l-.'
.- *~§-ni
V .-P ""
the FBI
examinations involving
Laboratory
_. tr. Ir.
blood typing,
isV
. _.
_ __*___¬%,___ - |._
including
"-14,_
M-
...- "1-*..
J..
. .,. ..~
... >'
..-- -» -=
. . --',
- '
. @¢~i_
'
.
. -.
-- 1- . _'
~°'
" -»==#~_.=.
.92*'~
... .~
.;- -:$-,>
--f _~*'
"'- .92a.1 1'
L -_-:r:-- -- 2 -=..'..-~-.
-_--=1'
>-HF- *H"
I..
~t- »r
_ ~---2
U
- --q-..
'
.».-'"
*'
=.
.-i -,;92_
=1%»
Y -'
9292-- '
.5. -»--=
.._ '
=
.'
'
- ,_.»~.+: -- _
_~-_
4.. - 5;: _"1'
~-- --L 1,-=~<._____
-~v..-__~,..~
.~
M-1 -;, » -r. " 1s~-uni
_ / -4:-1.
-".""" "'."-""v*'I'T:'.
>. .- ___ -»-T -792».-1-- .
I-||:.__._'
* _..
my-_ 1.~
..
_; :___
__ i
-
"FL .
-,.*.-.. * .__
.-i
;
""W
J
paint
scrapings,
to ascertain
also conducting
which
vehicles
hit together,
some
ballistics-type
and is
examinations.
LL
Examinations are
scrapings taken
the gun
being conducted
from
vehicles
fight to
and
ascertain
from
the
now from
blood
street at
whose
blood
the scene
was recovered
of
from the
various locations.
were
t-both
negat
..
subjects
.>--w,.,
were
wear
--V
gloves. Late:_
-jf"hava
conducte
been
other items of evid;n¬%i ¥%%§chicles
involved in
this
-1 the results
of those
complete set
cram nations have not yet been
received.
of photographs
been
provided
and avideotape
and will
be
and measurements
FBI Laboratory,
included in
are being
and will
from all
SSA
Hcueill.
with
the
Based on
the advice
to take
SSA
cneill
until their
told that
in the
team
has
of their
signed statements
Exhibits Section,
A
anumber of
they may be interviewed indetail
statements - *
SA
Hireles
physicians. it
from SA
Mireles
physical condition
have
Charts, graphs
taken signed
exception of
A
crime scene
report.
interviewed
neighborhood, and
Agent participants
decided not
the Special
be included
acomplete
of the
the report.
prepared by
The shooting inquiry
witnesses, done
incident. but
had improved.
and
was
1
and
We are
during_the week
now
__._
~<"
nnpg§@1
..
1
92
~-
"0
The U.
this
shooting
duties and
S. Attorney
has advised
incident were
that their
totally justified.
performing within
Agents involved
the scope
shooting and killing of
The U. S. Attorney
statement to
that the
of their
the subjects
will
provide
in
was
a written
this effect.
27%
. ..
="°
-3* '*
!... '-'~'=
.. ;-'"
1...;,i-'.'
',_ -
'
"-513"' -
_ - -=19-rion to
,.=:~
.- 2
.;.;an
be doneby the
inquiry team and theI».;.:_-.-.;=._
j° *§§*5i.the
forreceipt of forensic
._ _, '
examination results,
anticipated that
"TH: 5~
chi
acomplete
s,
graphs
and other exhibits, it
report will
be
is
submitted within
the next
three weeks.
_..
_r.;
ii _..._H-.... V.--..'-.--. -1-...
t
/_.
.-92
I
.:q]
'
H
0-"
I
f-
8% d
.
- --5
~
i
,.t
4:1
L ~;
_,. ..
--x
,
_
l
.-
'».-- -=-.
U1 '
- .
'
'Iu7f~"'
",
,-,,~---- m ge
'
,
'5!
E
é:
,.I '..
Q,I"--Y"=:=.
A4 ~ "'
6,
6 ,.v -~¥i|um.
u.92-"v'I'¬
NU_'
bf1_-_
m-g-,J_;
'
<_~-'
'
,§§*9~'F
-"j-~%l§§§!
"
'
_
_'~n.
'
?"-7
~
~
'
'
.
77
._.._» *5" -* - >92 __;_ hi ;.. __
. -_ ._:.
- 15
_
_, _
_wit;
i.-_
.__=:_A
»92,_.
_.
,.,_.-~ .:.¢»@?%W%Wm¢e£¢
=~. -r 1* --- -1-_
._ -~~ '--- ~e¢~~rv@w~mmwe#
f%%e£eraF§w;;
x.
e-
--
_cc. i '
t
_-¢.92_ .-nu.
.,
V.
.; _.-z;:_-_-;;r;;§;.._-,;:.__,_,-----..;'.;; Q-.:;T""'-.13 -:"::'::' ';192-92=-Is...-..m
x---.. -~
"fir n
.-.2.-42:,-.-'..
.'.&#
* .
l '!
"CRIME
'
|
SCENE SKETCH
12201
SW
82
AVE.
MIAML FLORIDA
-utmost.
'
I01
IO
ICALI
x I
7 T
. " uunru
~
Ii _;_..
_-
= SE =
1:: ar.
L
ML_ >_
wanna
.lune
AI IA
C nu
:2 Avis.
_I .
.
..
I ..11 .V...
.. , .V1,.
My ,
N __._
.7-C.___
.- _.- ..
_.;._...,
&
. -»~- 92-,|»<-,-.'
.
..
_. . V" .'_
-. _ 92;,--J3-,.
.;:"@_:_~-- .1 ~
=:---'
-»'-92. .-~~..=»-~n--';492--*"_*-"
§9&
.._
,___
_ _ -,
- ._._,,w ,.. 4; ¢ -.
,--
_
.,
' "
r '- '1 92";
V
.'1
.
. ...
..»
LEQEEII '-.
:1 -mnxnn
VEHICLE AT RESIDENCE
I1 - PARKED VEHICLE AT RESIDENCE
#3 -sumncrs
VEHICLE
E O4
- FBIVEHICLE MANAUZ-Z1!
._
as-FBI vsmcu: ucmzrnn!
e
as
-_ -as
-rm VEHICLE GROGAN/DOVE!
01- rm
v:-zmcus HANLON/MIRELES!
as-1- B1
VEHICLE RISNER/ORRANHA!
=.
-
-METRO-DAD!
rnvzmcu
,
_
~
'
-='
+~*-»
:~!=I~.
I; :¢~1*.';:#.
rt e-4."? ~q'.§!u_§'~,l92:.>- i £"
A ..'_'
~-'-<..
.,_1¬-.
.
__,.,
-.
'_"'-"_"-
'
" " ."- ""'"-7""?
'
_A.
'
"E-5
E F~
1:,
,,
-*
,
_.
q
__
'"
_7:.
_H . ,4=.-H.-,-.-_
_ .=,
..-_.._..,.,.....
____.U
~
.,
,
_
.|
-
"-"-.
p
92
499
,I
-.!
ZQMINISTRATIVE
INQUIRY
SHOOTING
INCIDENT
MIAMI DIVISION
4/11/B6
_62'1?1995'34
5'
5
IN ms FILESKIPPED
nmum
SERIALIZATION.
arznovsn
moznmqoan
rm m4
6 0 4 7'
--
_...
6941!é7¢
"--" I1
5
.% ?":*- ii¢¢,§
-I-.
!l/;&
I...
92
..I ~
"~
F »
_..-....,
-:~-
--
- 92
:- ,.
--
4..._..
.=;:_
, --*7?-.-_,--==.,_
., _,_.
, ~,,1-5-v-.;
-I . --r
--u---¢.wa
A
7'-
I;
| .
92".
f
-
'
~'¢-'.1n
-.».'-.-r»~v
~..,
4-"
62-121996-3,
4
a5
II
[If
_
_
.
_____..-V.__.__
_
-.-r.
_..-_..
.
t._. .
_--_
I
I
-- I- -§*§-_=.~:
- '.
.51'"
1':-"fu"';'.
":=,=
=¢.
...'
:... ._4_- _-..-Hp.
..
_... . ....,-_._
7
.
._4...
._
~4_1-.1
_.,
___.m_
I I
. _:
.
I'll/D04
_,.,-I..- --....-~--p- __ -- M, ulv-'_._
.__,
_,
._
_
_
,..
I-_.___-_--.-.-;: z 7;:
~_'
_..
v. .I
¢_ _.__v-,
_...
---.-_.-.~--- _...-.-H.-....».e....._.-=.e._.__.,
-
it
_ ..1. _-_-2-::n'_r-|__ ,__...__.__.:__-_
___-._ .._
Memorandum
. .' "
.'92
I |'.
'k
i i
7"7
I
.il
ilino-
,1 1?I"0m :
vin.
Chairman ,
:
W_ hem
ISTRATIVE
SHOOT
MIAMI
._
h
_-v
|
Dam
Enos:
ID
Ala. __
IZ LE
luI.Di:.:
&#
D. I-nu.
Cu-. hm ...i_
_.._...i
he
' T
Hr.Sharp
R/ I
Z11.
!E ,
i
_
_..
_f
.
P
lanll. i...
6/20/as &
LQL i
In
'I G l"IF . *-_
SIR Q?
'-='~-
*---
g__
-
'|'uohh
Tololhnulli.
Snc'
_
i
INQUIRY
ING nqczomrr
DIVISION, 4/11/as
ence
of Inspector
d.ated 51¢,
6/5/86, captioned
as report
above.
_ '
Ihilwllmo
EB£L '
cements
and
~_
has be
~Group--
xE11
prepared to
of the
Sh
provide the
oo
'
ting
analysis,
Incident Review
at
an
55"
go
51¢
Enclosure
ii,
I -
Glover
.Otto
_92-
/~~@@am%
_.
92
iU?l_-53
1: in-'2:
-snug
~um.
.. 9n £11:
. Revel].
Sharp
Carke
i'
,13
J!-
~%F
Q - "r FKIT ?!" '!'§1!r3[~j
__
""'N ;:a4.¢'_- .
I
'-_.
} _L'a ! X
:°3&#
0-
4-150
4-11-as!
Rev. Mi
92
92-» J
V
n
XXXXXX
FEDERAL BUREAU
DF
FDIPA
DELETED
INVESTIGMTIDN
Pl-GE lllFDIlM!92TlDll SHEET
i__, Page s!
withheld entirely
at
thislocation
theinfile.
Onemore
or the
of following
statements, wh
l
indicated, explain this deletion.
[EDeleted
under
exemption
g s!
material available
for release
to
with
nosegneg
you.
El Information pertained only
to athird partywith noreference
to
you or
the eubiect ofyour request.
_El
Informa m toa urd
ielietadinthetitle only.
D Documents
asency esl
._...__ Pages
These documentswere referredto that
contain inforrnation
by anotherGovernment agency es!. You will be advisedby the FBI as
.to the releasability
of thisinfd tion following our consultation
with theother agcncy cs!.
i. Page s!
El For
withheld for the following reason s!:
your information:
E The following number
is tobe used
for reference
regarding these
pages:
6_?~'L9/97C"6].gZa9""
_i_
/ it
'
.
-
'
yr _;I~
.,_ ~--:1
'10 0 urn 01 es92'e
DELETED PAGE S!
xxxxxx FOR
xxxxxx XXX
xxxxxx
X
~;tno nueucxnon FEE
§
THIS PAGE
X
'
FBI./DO
c;
*
I
Memo from
Acting Chairman,SIRG toMr. Sharp
-RE: Administrative
Shooting Incident
Miami Division,
_
In i qu I- Y
4/1_1/86
-_¢-
':a ~-L
.duH'
~»*>"=#
$1
_.__,_._i_._:7,-3.,
_- _"-- .'.
*"'*
-_
Q
-..-,_ ..._-.._
_.
ii.---..__
- 7-
'
__.
_.
-. .-
_- ..
- .-.
V
.
........ _.
.
,, hr ,
.'4.
1;
_
H..'_-...._._"...;._...:..-.'._
.
~ .- n-- S;-1--.
-.._ -nqcq-'1
,_, .4 1:__ .4-,
_ .4.
..; .
_..___;.'_._.....
92, _
_,.; '3,
, -__,__
____;,-_,--1,'_~
,_
_I' '
-F _
g _.,_..
Mr,4*,,._, =.-;",r,______._
H ; ___ ,. ;,_*"'
- ____*~
D@;_LS_;_
6/12/86,
On
the
SIRG reviewed
the results
of an
administrat ve
Inspector '
in i
55
g ptioned
matter
conducted
by
lI-"'
Referenced
dated
s/5/as
report
vi;
I
Crimes Section,
Crim al
Investigative S
concernin ca
received by
the General
Division, FBIHQ,
on 6/5/86.
By way of background,
at approximately
8:45
a.m.
on
4/11/B6, SSA Gordon G.
McNeil
EDD Clerk:
11/2/60:*EOD Agent:
9/19/66! , Supervisor Squad
C-1 Personal
Crimes Squad!,
FBI
Miami, initiated
aphysical
canvass/surveillance of
an area in
southwest Miami,
approximately 53
blocks in
Street 1a3rd Street!,
bisected north
Dixie
Highwa
y, aka U .S.
Highway 1.
ahigh
density commercial
zone.
g
.-"-- _ --; V.»
..._.,._~.
- ---_.*-
length 3Ot.h_ r
to south
This area
_'.~- - 5_
_ -., ....__',
-. =,-,i__,._
-'"'-_ - __ _
r,
.
_
by. the South '
is described
as
.-u
.. .- ._ .1,.,,-i-.~g-1|.-.:a,
--W!--1'
._92. .
S
A;¢~¢r;4.-..§|_',»;oI,,.,_- --;...._.|,; 1.,-,;;:;: ,.I,'t:;.Z.-'.
r.' ._-.- ',._~_'
7~__.'-_-;~_;. --'-_"3~_>-_--F;-_~__
'_y-1
___-f
¢.-|--=v-92--.. »a-=-.a'u.;s¢I£q
u'-a-.1--- =5&
P
~
--I
- _..-I_-.-L.~ -A ~*¢ ..
..,....-..._ _,.,-_.'L'_'
_.
l.
Memo from Acting Chairman,
RE: Administrative
SIRG to Mr. Sharp
Inquiry
Shooting
Incident
Miami D vision-,
4/ll/B6
The planned surveillance was
armored car robberies which
bank and
same general
locale by
unprovoked violence
o
activity, the
two unknmm
exhibited by
very dangerous
and, if
h
0
located, SSA
to the
assaults on
were also
___
an
two
A'
gh t I'rock pit"
shooting,
_..1=i=°SS times
and
white males.
the robbers
of
the
Based on
the
during this
McNeil believed
might occur.
In addition
.- M.
prompted by aseries
had been perpetrated in
two suspects were considered by SSA McNeil to
violent confrontation
in unnrovoked
'
bank and
Monte Carlo
Sweapon
1919
__
A
_
robberies and
.-
two hold.-1n
Y -
_
_ -.
ee,
- -Ihwtinq It the
while
target
ehot three.
S
two-door, black
and "furnished
descriptions
these
E" of
&#
were taken
from him
at this
a shotgun, an K-16 or AR-15 rifle and/or
revolvers.! ,
-. ,.
or -- license 1~I'I'-I-891
and two
Sfle!
,2-.1?
two sub e s noting they
were in possession of
aSmith
and Wesson
saw! model 12- =35? =...e,='n1_'.H..
and a revolver
P.-age: 2-aini-14 rifle S~
with a folding stock
at the time he was robbed and shot.
S" In
other related
robbery activity,
these
two
subjects were
variously
described as
carrying
I
sen
Sidente which had taken Sr. -SS
_" on3/
g _p
are S-7
that a
armored car
armored - er ------personnel the--
be
_..
S
_ T
-
j. S
rm
1359:Highway,
Dixie
abbe Barnett
on 3/19/86
byBank,
thesame South
two
suspects
util
zing .
. Mia
llowing the
1979asthe
..--. ---_,
3/12/86 robbery
and attempted
murder of
Monte Carlo
still
bearing
Florida
cense
1 to gets -.'a},' vehicle.
A shoulder weapon, believed
be a Ruger Mini-14
rifle, was
used in this -robbery.
v
. S,
S with this and other background information in
SSA McNeil preliminarily discussed
his contemplated
,,.- 5&#
.--~e-v1»-~
mind,
S
_.
lance
plans
withaSA
Benjamin
Grogan
P. SRA_
and b
C
HomesteadatRA!
Miami
firearms trainingsess
on on inc
86. It
was agreed that asurveillance
would
be
set up in
southwest Miami
on 4/ll/86.
A meeting was et
for 8:45
a._m.
on
4/ll/B6
at
the
Home Depot parking lot
in southwest
Miami where
once again Special Agents
would
furnished
and related
background concerning
the suspects
planning session.
A memorandum outlining the
planned activity
was dictated
photos, descriptions
by SSA McNeil to
during afinal
details of
this
SAC Cor1ess ,_ .
I "secretary on 4/10/86 for Hr. Corless' information.
-
.
. '.. *~=
. -.
_
-.
S
-92'92_
- I-gee-i"'."1T"!'».-S-.. ..
*";92:'i.'.-ii"F";
S.
S -~_=-seer!
qeT,= S.& '==~
'~'*"'*'-3*
';;..
--¬*.:,#
-~
--» ~1=.~§i~;;,,.t;»'~_~<>.--
Q'1
___,
__ .
"S 1 V-Jr
1 - __
.'
-I» "
"
...____....., .
___ ___
__
_r.l
4.-.-=...,._.-... --,
_"M -map
V-.92. -. '.... ..-ve.Q-..
'
S
_V .'
.
- _;w1 '
,_-.
._p'. ."
u V . 9--_. _'
--e---
+-- ..-._,¢~~92_--En-:-er!_r'E'l$92I1l~q'k|
__J_6_
_;;,;__._= ._'.r,~:i.i ;§%92ef:e>,?..¢*.
',;;5r_-..
,_-_§-
we@
;
.
*.
'
-_e
__.,.
-.
.. .41
___.-. .._.___.,..___...___., ~ / _.--.:
__._._...-_,
..._.. .
._-
e-
»--_- - ___--»-
_
-S
-
'
rt
'
Memo from Acting Chairman",
SIRG to Mr. Sharp
RE: Administrative
'
Inquiry
- Shooting
Incident -Miami
Division,
4/ll/86
_ operating
On Friday,
atotal
4/11/86, the
-
following 14
of 11
vehicles
met at
Special Agents
the Home Depot parking
R SAJerry
Dove
L.9/13/82!,
BOD:
Richard
Manauzzi
SA 2.- a
_ lot:
SSA McNeil,
l2/14/70!, SA
Orrantia EDD:
__.92 _
SA Benjamin
P. Grogan
BOD: 9/18/61!,
Edmundo llireles,
Jr. EDD
4/18/82 ,
SA John 1" !,
9/1 SA
Gilbert 24.
discussed
ran
the violent
past
descriptions of
the
the subjects
of the
and furnished
- then
made manpow er ore
once again
located and
and bet
advised Iurveilling
arobbery
, gave
might still
be using
two suspects.
- SSA Hclieil
th esurve
il 1 ance began
Agents that
"should
occur, no
arrest
out
i
the suspects
would be made until
the subjects
had left
the bank and then only when
sufficient
units were
on
hand
to safely
make the arrest. Further,
after
in the
be
y
event the
suspects were
located and
could be
safelrg taken
before
é
arobbery
occurred, arrests
were to be made only
necessary
-units
were
present
so that
the
arrests could
be safely
made.
Althou h9 no Metro-Dads Units were participating in
the D
surveillance ,
;_ _
Districts 4,
5and
6had
. impending
FBI surveillance activity.
VT118
as follows.
£s
SSA McNeil
B10118! 4/l0
'
-of the
_-
l
s_
;"
malfunctioned
-not
revolver, model
19
ss-1&1 .35 ! caliber
revolver, model
19-3
Remington model
870 located
pump
shotgun
-or
.
Nv_n.loaded
-4/11/as!
;'
-
_....
,.
__ ..___
.
_.
M
._i
.
' ""."
at
Firearms
used 4/ll
rear seat
of .
SSA HcNsil's
vehicle J
- not
used "
.
~'- -
' "=._..A.:_.
92
- ;:.-;_~--_
,~.=q;_V
.- .- -...u~
. <»-
..
pairings established by ssa HcNei_l on4/11/as were
214 SEW .357 caliber
¥*
been notified
"
5
,
_,¢,
.- _L.=. . ='
».1..;:...-' :_-|.=.;_q-..¢.
/-m|¢ln.ev!seq1ls~il!l'.'l~&#
P -'~--+'
"- '
=- v
A_
s_~;~.:3 L@QW: ;f:m55'_j _- ;
-'-.- -e-='w.-r
- --:-.-;=¢_._1_-.l_'.:.'.I1z'
'-~
._~'*;.1;'..
""
'-'1
" """"' """"'
.r-1-'.,.-ah J '.
"' 'n
.._.-..
'
_
,. .-_____._ .
,.
..
,*_-s
.__
.
'7
Q
._... LI;
..
I ._.
.____¢.-. A,_.......,.-__-- -.-*7,
- --- -7;
.._,_
e.
.
_._.
._..
a
-__-___-I
.._.-:.
-_.
_-~
--s
-~ 7_ __

_.
_. ,
.1 .,_
_.
._ .. r.A
-.1".
.1;.¥'.1;.'_Z.'-...'92_1--1
'?"_*.:-:11
,:,:
'
'
: ':
"'
'
= :"!"
'
= "-' - "-1$""'
"""
"""I
g
.
Memo from Acting chairman,
SIRG to
RB: Administrative
Inquiry
Shooting Incident
Miami Division,
§_pec ial__Aq§Q1;
Hr. Sharp
- _.
4/11/86 .
Llnit Weaponry
_.
in Veh___iclg
Bgarkg
ballistic vest
put on
at arrest
scene Velcro
tastening strips
P
not
totally secured
.I
before
shooting incident!
-@i~- --
fr?
8 6"SA Grogan
83
-f- .=
.---3
"WW
~ <:- -.' '1
5-u..
~_,-u£§';~:;_-~.~->
new°.
--_.>-.--~_
-92_ i,,-
,
- .G1;.!
_.__..
Vl92'92
=-~
lcdel 350]
ballistic vest
M
um_-:
=.92
-A
u l
. :_, -vi 41,-. 2.?-{;V"_
. ~-_
9r r _I
-M;
.
__ -.-1- ;':
'5';
_
~
.=.
»
'==-HP-'!'*'~
I
"
»"':
I
. , ..
'k¥_-W,--.,92-;..
.~.r
~ _. I/, _.
'1"
' Q'3'
'
- " 92 '1'=¥'~"'
K "'--e1.
- e I I
ii
0 92
worn.
V,
'.:_--i;
,_.
92i--"I
--'-37'
-1 4.4- "'7a
:--J.
7" '
'
- '"" i"IIc
ballistic vestworn.
Taove
Q1
Bi 36
"35
SA I-Ienlon
"*3 Q
.
- 5shot! No ballistic
.38 caliber
carried in
holster --
r
1
vest worn.
revolver
ankle
used during
shooting incident!
saw .38
4
revolver loose
seat
SA'Mireles_
-- -ss
-- -¢n-.- --v :.92n+1
92* . ._,.~.8¢-.:'1a-l-.&#
,
. __
caliber
on
- lost
in
crash!
No ballistic
S&W . 357 caliber
__revolver, model
vest worn.
-
686
l
1
a_
_. - t.-....__
. , .T ____
Remington Model
8'70
pump shotgun
located
passenger side
-front
seat
-lceded}
'
P£.l'|.8.92.12.Zi
SEW .357
caliber
66
.1
alojfze!
_'
revolver, model
SK Risner
No ballistic
19
vest worn.
loose on seat,
lost in
crash.!
-
.,.92 . K
u.
p-
_,.___.,_.
..
.. 1,. H4. -..,,_
... l- .,__» ,~we...
,, ..
131
S&W model
459
91am
.
semi-automatic
Hot wearing
ballistic ve
during stake-out
pistol
OD at
st
but put
HITGSC IOBIIB
it
OI !
...i ._.l_.
1..-ea
_____.|___ e "_ .'
:_§__:_'-92'--1
l.II'1.'Vl.Lo
,,
3
$'
'.-'.
-92
-K -=>~.-"~,'-:
~"-M1,;-.
~"-;'="-=*:
:_
;
'
P}
1.
:92
_~ 6... -v_ ~--#?;1¥_"%;
_ _"
I _ -__f',_.:
3.»,
H;
" "i"_&r
6--.
..-v.:~-_.=-l.,1--.1,.,,= 92_
..~
-:1,
--1:-6-._. - -
____
__
.
_.,;_-.._
_;,._,¢._,-_'
.1".-;.
,_.,,_,;
..-..1.-;.;_p-.'..,<-->._..--.._..
-._,.;q..,.,...
._____~
+. --4 , ~. _,p___
..h. '_.
.7.
-. vv ~ __
'
.,,_,,,,,,____
__
__r_
____.....
________._'_;_:______
__
-=_
--
.6. ..
" - .-1*.
-
5'
I.
Memo trom Acting Chairman,
-RE: Adinistrative
SIRG to Mr. Sharp
Inquiry
Shooting
vision,Incident
4/ll/86
Miami
D
ggecial ggegt
Qgig
I = <=
Qetlg
saw
model
so
.38 caliber
A
revolver carried
in ankle
holster.!
Orrantia
l
Not
92iI8r¬E.bQ111lt1C
vest
.
during 0
-out, but put it
'
357
an at
garrival. "
-arrest
scene
on
-
Ballistic
vest
SWAT!
during surveillance
passenger
side
tront
_,.net-. _.loadod!.
-=
worn
_
. SEW. .357 caliber
revolver, model
177
19 -
8&1-I .357 caliber No
revolver, model
66
_~ _-
' --- --<
ballistic
vest
e
worn.
-Remington model 870
pump shotgun located
trout seat -loaded!
133
revolver, model
.
_V
_
',_ .. Ballistic
saw .as7caliber
19
worn.
'
'
"
"
seat -loaded!
Sit-I .357 caliber No
revolver, model
19
ballistic vest
Remington model
B70
located '
vYg
mt
loaded!
' .2"-#5:"
~'¬'.*"
I1:
:"".
p.
. 2;"-5-? -;-:1
-
_'
.-
vi
_____ : ,, _,_ -
_-I
'-
.
92
___ _
__
_._
I
_.
.
I-
.
"
__;~'I,__?,;&#
-_.,
,~..'.
'5:_.. ,>""&.*un
..
-I
2.
.
92
b75V .___.,._ _.._
. - e__-.;,._
'
-H , __:_
-1..
»---__,-,
e-_u..,
worn. .
a
pump shotgun
- i,
__,,
. _.
.. "
. -i-_-~ "as-.--a-11....-~...-~-~~
aw-fr
--
Remington model
870
pump shotgim
located
tront
°
,_ ,__ ,_,
r....,
l.
_
.
vest
,
-
'
M.
"*
_
.._
~_
=.
.. . .-I ..
_,_,,_ _ '.
_4:r':'_.
.._.__-.-..,....-. .- _.-:_.
- ..::.'>-,
'
-i--- l,'92&#
__ . &#
_-. -J;_
..'.:-_-__..
-.,J 5....
- -,- »-'__'_
.......
~-1--u.-.-,.
.--_-_, -,___
- - __-I;-m__
V-.
_ _ ;_
_ ~;__
__-_ 9 3_"_,e,q!'¢._,...;,
vi_.-"" .-- -uas...
w.,-.a_ a.
..1----3'75
' "
a
,
Memo tron
Acting
RE:
SIRG. to Hr 0
Chairman,
Administrative
Shootincr
'
Inquiry
incident
MiamiDivision, 4/11/as
11-16
fully
automatic
rifle
caliber
located
back seat
fully
loaded]
.
,
i
.223
110
'
SIM .357 caliber
revolver,
Ballistic
model
i
3 ,___,_,-;_,;:.w
amnodal459
5 b4 -'
. ..,111'-all
.- -_. r- .--,-»
_ -..
----e
-- -
-
vest
worn.
66
y_ _, "
a
1M...-
:--
in
Ballistic
51
saw4 ,.;i.caliber
--~: vQ1.
19
'
vest
. _--'
__ - __
H"'1_ O.
_
._--oi-1'
_¬ ;__'_
__""_
_ __________
___..
, . ,__ ___,_,*.___ .,-....--,
_-»--S-~-_
--
worn.
'=
.. .-
.-; ,_ ._
---
---
.
.
. -'.'*1iP
-,
-o---- ':::&#
SSA
Hclleil
and
Shs
Grogan
Dove
Hanauzzi 
l
.5
II
were to provide -coverage in the
area
or the Barnett Bank,
Southwest
136th
and South Dixie Highway.
This bank was the
eeene of two previous robberies--1/io/36
irinics armored car
robbed,
$54,000
loss,
t twice: 3/19/86 Barnett Bank
'robbed,
$9,000
SAs I-Ianlon,
Savin
gs
vehicle the getaway car.!
Hireles
Bank
130th and
South
7'
taken,
were to cover the Professional
previously robbed 11/8/85,
$41,469A1oss_!,Southwest
Dixie Highway: SAs Orrantia,
and
Florida
National
Bank
robbed
11
8 85
10
ind
South
Dixie
Hpreviously
ghway
and
SA:
and
Risner,
the
0 loss!, '
.1:
S-&#
e ughway.
the Barnett Bank, ;l.83rdand Sou
a
_
In
_
t on to the notedrobberyactivitv, the two subjectshad
l
robbed
a Wellsfargo
truck
during
a
pickup
at
a Winn
Dixiestore,
I
'
'
7930 Southwest 104th Street, Miami, on 10/16/85.
One
guard
was
shot in the leg during the robbery:
no
noted robbery activity
generally
12 noon on
a
Wednesday or
a
¢
At approximately
moneywas obtained. The
occurred Ia
tw
e
Friday.
'
9:30 a.m.,
Grogan MM-202! radioed as follows:
4/ll/B6,
SA
een
9.30
a.m.
-
Benjamin P.
'
"
"Hey. Attention all units.
~
We're
behind a black vehicle two doorFlorida license I;I 1'J:B9l.
y_ _
a
':ie
headed
re southonsouth ixie. iiorth on South'
ixie."
§
_
read
unintelligible!
that?" Otherradiotrattic: ensued
is
hereatter noted.
SA
V.-___;,92'-;1,-Jq.
._-_,
,, ~_;,,J.
-....- -_-- -. -.-.
_&#
RonaldG. Riener 0-I-131!: "202are you 3
.. -.
.~
e .== Mo . -.
_A.;-_: .-.|.
.92_
__ .!» 4._¬;_.__,_';__
PJ
-.. 92:'§.:~__>..<s_.;,1,--,
!_
,_
.. __ _.
»
1
_
' _:~
- -.-
_
_
"mo.
e"*= ,='="-rm
:1.»~~"="
».-:.~.-.:'=-"
.I
-10~
V
-
"r '
~
-
-_--1'-1
.;-'=-l:¢-¢.,1-¢,
1
_.::'i'*:--..1--.-Z1--r -7*-92'='n'-oi
" . .-._
.? -.-;'-l-_= ; * -:-ee
.
2"
_
l
-e
_
__-_
____V___
______ ._._ .-_-
.-'-_...'
'-
up .
Memo fromhcting
,
E
2" . vehicle,
Chairman, SIRG
RE: Administrative
to Hr.
Inquiry
Shooting Incident
Miami Division,
Sharp
"
4/ll/86
neaoing nortn
or south?
2l4!:
"Metro
riht
SA Grogan:
North on
South
Dixie.
SA Risner:
"OK,
where?"
SA Grogan:
"l24th street.
It's
a
black Monte Carlo,
two
males in
t, NTJ-891."
SSA McNeil MMawa and
7 ah...Bi11,S
tro on
'
lmation
the
HM-B3!:
let's gethim yanked.
Let's get
your unit
and give
em
"...You're at
124, are you north or there
now rogan:
"Looking good,
NTJ-891." SA
Grogan: "12Oth
Street, let's get
up
here and let !
etop than
it we have to.
SA Riener:
OK, hold on
Ben,
till
we
get enough people
up
there." SA
Groqan:
"All
right,
blow
up
here." -SA
Jenygl-. have
one 4:
two white
melee
in
the _-
amutoMcNeil,
irhose
main
p
__
_~I_lid:
"ghee
until
we can get -
transmission
,
lone help let ;
.1-2-3- ?.§=§_>
_-_*_;;§ - .
stop. --an Grogan: "Gordo,
that's our
:_;»laQ'.-'i*!!_'-ll
o_1
l._e..1=:.l..m
-..e e.1;right
e. turn
on 117th,
.
' "
--'
g-ig2tRondl
l;7t1g.!_,§
epoogid,
§@hDdyou guys.
Soutléwest
bL
5oa
ea
-eou
'. SSAllcNe:
e,
Metro?"
Mitzi-I
SA"SA K1353:
"Right
behind
1.1
babe
ave What
mea.. ..: kl7,.C
cross
street."
:
"'Stand
b
S15
your location
San?"
e .=ro_g_a:i:_
{
ligibla
p pe
turn
on lzoth
Street going'92iest.'!
"BA uireleiz"
behind you babe.
You
wanna
do
it, let's do it."
"Negative, let'sget some marked units.
Let's get
some -
$_£>roken!: SA
Risner: "OK we'reatjust
120th and U.S.1, are
92-u-G" coming not tova
'J.S. 32* SA bovez
=1 -hat=e affirmative.
- sSAxMcNeil:"Just looked
at them,they're
guys
loading
something in
the tront."
SA Groqan:
be
heard
saying in the
background,
£_e1ony_car atop, let's do
it."_ SA
"iean."
and SA
_SA
scene. says
- End
Risner: got
of pertinent
roilow
between
"Let's do
it." SA
"Felony car stop. rake
mrele A Dove;
SA a, ¢m-57!
J, who are trying
on the
air, "People
people down, let : get
radio transmissions
up
to
locate
Dove can
em,
the on
. =1
down!" -@~.=-:*'~--K"
some help over here."
on 4/ll/86.!
p
~
'
" yi
51.0
_
l
,§,.
-Memo from Acting Chairman,
SIRG to Mr. Sharp
RE: Administrative
Inquiry
Shootin Incident
-
Miami
Division,
4/11/86 --
As the vehicles involved
Southwest 82nd
Avenue,
edecision
=oer
stop, let's do it."
M
in the pursuit moved
south on
was made to "Take
em, felony
SA Dove's
redio transmission
SA Grogan s statement, "let's do it."!
apparontly based
on
the
rollowing tects:
were preparing
that they
to resist
arrest es
were up"
trensniesion!
3
based
This decision
the subjects
on
was
obviously
evidenced by observetion e!
their weapons
ssA McNeil :
radio
-
.... ":3- .»
b 190'."-1,4,.
_ .'.
£5
bé
.._;b1c_;.
the
Upon implementation ot_tl_1e "£elony oer stop"
Sins rogen end Dove, who were driving
the
vehicle
depicted
sketch es
"B" et
Tab #87
grey
volume!, ectivated
order, '
in
"
their
blue light
and siren.
vehicle "C,"
which
was
occupied by
SA Richard A. heneuzzi MM-66! , was coming up from the rear
vehicle "A,"
by SA John F. Henlon, Jr.
end
"-
Mireles _p
_
. 1,
-,. .
1, is
eot the
SAS
ects made
the turn
with them,
the subjects
eU-turn
heading made
impacted once
oer, pinning
egein into
the
it between his vehicle,
and eparked automobile in the yard in front
3.2291, 1:203
southwest
seet At
driver : side
MM-66, etree
of the residence
82rd Ave.-rue. As show: in the
we
this
sketch at
{
or .
_I;
J__ _
-"'
Tab #87, two vehicles marked RV-residencevehicle! were perked
_1"?
unoccupied! et ,_that
location.
vehicle
"B"
the
eubjectvehicle!
_
I
_
_
_._~;1_
._
.
_
._
_u
.
_
_
_
.H»--'~
.
.
-1'
'
"'-'
i _'
'_.. .e "C"!
ll
_.
was
abruptly
Menauzzi's
vehicle
en
.;..___ 7.,
. _.'_. :31.
=,_._._.,_..:_:
-_._.'-H-L,stopped
_,V- ,,_ -_ .; ___between
.,
__ -- SA
_-_;_-_e_
. ,.- e-.'1~:¬#ur'~¢u-e-»--!
.-+-"=~-».i.--1I-».._-;;;. end
,
_-3.
... . _ - _
-..
-12-
.
-*'-??r* =*
W
"
.
Memo from Acting Chairman,
SIRS to Mr. Sharp
RE: Administrative
inquiry
Shooting Incident
Miami
1:»
"RV."
A
A
vision, 4/11/as
small tree
was located
directly in
front of
the vehicle
"B"
subjects'!
and vehicle
"C" SA Manauzzi's!. "Vehicle "E,"
occupied by SSA McNeil, turned into
the
area and vehicle
"D,"
occupied by SAs Grogan and Dove, made aU-turn
and parked to the
rear of
the e1l-jecte'vehicle approximately
10 feet fui-ther beck
than shown
in
the sketch
at Tab #87. Immediately
after being
stopped, one
of the subjects, now
identified as
William R.
Hatix,
fired a
shotgun blast
at SA
Hanauzzi.
The shot, determined to
be
#6 shot, penetrated the
-passenger window of the Bureau car and
11'!-[idle -Q1
Hanan!!! -Ir;
exiting his
-I-hp hnnlr
nnal
_ __
on
SA
Ma:-1auzzi__"_
his weapon V"
lrI+'|1r'|§I921' _,_
Avenue and
t wall
' sAs Hanlon
and '
scene, SSA Hc eil qui
fire by
iide. '
ht this
-since
holster and - " "'
-
taken
under
1-an hm-10 A0 4-I-us I-92 El
chase,
lying in
jar
V ., ,
In
time; "
he did not have
his lap!
in ; ..._-
J: Z i!.°_'
" ."'-'.&
515°?b'
7
near wherevehicle "A"-~
.__-. -..... . ;-
ii
impacted.
Upon arrival at the
yexited
his vehicle
and was immediately
the subjects,
principally by
:-.c'.~.' ea
identified
.'-£i¢.e=l
Lee Platt,
the individual
who was armed
with
l. __--
r
a Ruger
.223 caliber
Mini-14, semi-automatic
rifle. SSA
McNeil went
- y
directly to
SA
hanauzzi's vehicle, leaned
across the
hood of it
and, in two separate bursts, fired
six rounds
from his SEW .357
caliber revolver
into
the
passenger compartment of the Monte
Carlo %upied
by the stmjetts. '-Ihile firing, SSA
Hcheil was
inthe
hand by return fire.
After emptying his revolver
and
while bleeding profusely from his hand wound, he attempted to
reload: however,
due to
the wound
to
his hand,
he could
not fully
loadAI92_
hisxe pcn. SSA McNeil
than withdrewtowardthe
rear of his
;
v92=ssa.92.¢.LB
92
is
-
_| e
-
- Across
against
"A"!
of his
__
-J- __
the
IV..;._.. . __.____
, -_ _. _V
the street,
wall
on
service revolver
revolver from
area.
an ankle
vehicle "D"!,
holster and
area
of
SA
iianlcn
proceeded into
he
was
"E"!
hip"'7 ""_'
"A"!,
a severe wound
to
his left
proceeded to the rear
revolver into
SA I-Ianlon bent down,
track
the shooting
his vehicle
SSA I-1cNeil's
vehicle
crouched'and fireda total
his SS-W .38 caliber
his
vehicle
had lost
not" been secured on
his
who had also
exited
under fire by Platt,
suffered
went down.
impact of
SA
Hanlon
. ..d _.-... --.- -VA
-- .. --~-*-¢-1
~*.r|_,,>,...
Vii.-..-..s-.-sq--_
,.-a.
his Btu-eau=approvec".
#5 shot saw subncsa
As SA
Hireles,
approached the
following the
82nd Avenue,
which
had
durirag the chase, at
.
. _ V -1.1
V=
_V.
_,.
knelt on
of SA
Grogan s
of five
the subjects
the ground
rounds from
vehicle.
and started
At
thi
point or
V ,-,_._
r
shortly before,
=7
.V..,_
4.. -W
Y
SAs Silbert
_..,-_..
,.-.-_~.._
._
~ -,--3*
o-f -
--- .. - .
I-1 H
As 1-
to reload
his weapon,he washit in the right hand byrifle fire!
down.
taken
arm and
'
and went
ii. rrantia
_..
.
V -.»_ .
.V
- .--, ".._.-,;, , . 5-_»_-__:.
92
.- -, N.
§ 4-_
___ .We I-. . '
92_92_ ___
__
_:
,.., 1-b __»__
<_~___.-_,.~..¢-V»
.;---3.-.
,--~.---~
-1»;
'~_
r-irzge-~:w~=-.-.
.- -4'__
._;__";%
V- 5=¢
'
"""'- " |-»-.-V.-*1 ?_I",e-:9sl
3 --_f'3"
- - - '
--_ g,
, ;~_
.._- .; ,;V';:---»'_
__.-,n-»--e--~
_-_..__,--.-_-- ,'--'
_ . E. -- :i."'
-,
NI-elI-.---1.,-ole-all-92
- is.»- e
_
.
_.__,-VV
-- V-
»- -3-'-3-~
--7h-~~-- -
¢-_- '
_-1:-'
'
"
¢
h
1
Memo from Acting Chairman,
SIRG to Hr. Sharp
RE:
____92
Administ tiv
In
i
5b.mtin~r;.nci;entqu
W
andMiami division,4/11/as
the
thewest
side or 82nd Avenue racing
shooting scene and began firing at
,
f: 1
Gel ______ ______I__ Q
I. i-
zusner arrived
time, were
"RV" vehicles
é
out of
on the
their
vehicle
and vehicle
black Monte Carlo! and
SA Orrantie
scene. They
proceeded to
ammunition from
his
.
$, .-_
-
- '
stopped their
south!, slightly
north of
the subjects,
who by this
and moving in the area
of
the two
"B" su.bjects'vehicle--the stolen
were utilizing
tire
12
rounds
these
vehicles
'.
;,,
F _ _
9:."-.. see
as cover.
or .38-caliber
4-P service
Bureau-issued .357 saw revolver and Sh
Eisner
estimates he
tired 13to 14
round.e totel tram
his
model 459
*
vehicle on
-..e..~*..i»-
Bureau--issued
vehicle '?3I.'
I
-
92
p
F1
Q I.
II 1
lmew
.|.=u5.|.e
-,
_,
___ ____.
, M
4
1
--K :%~.=-
/.
1.inability to
I on
the ground behind his
.a'?;.,-_5§?"*__
qnqe
_;in shot this
SSA 1 -ic eil -unngls iii
1e
She Groqen
I
or
'2
-- --w -.1;
.-*--1-';!:92:f;'-V. --'92-H
..- ,
,..i; .::a'?
w.92;.__
_J-...
-<;;.;;_;,.-~_..'.-,,__,_._,-,§
-, _,..
-~.=~='
"r,f
:::Q1?3
_-;;_;~.»
,
~
e
.'v.'-"
4
--'-"J
_~_';"_
-..
- 4
.
,,
--'-:---
_ was
"Dove,
incapacitated due
~ -'
tron
an
area
to an
i
at the
_,1
side and
5A Grogan's vehicle
_"D"} , had already began tirinu
-
rear
'
the
5
subjects. Following e-period or intense guntire, eubfect, .~ ' """'f? .
'
William R.
Kati: apparently
took she
crogan and
Dove under
tire
with ashotgun. Th swas evidenced byapattern or #6 shot which
'
F
-L; ,<
e1 --3%-1*1.
r
was round on the driver : side
oi! Grogan's
vehicle "D"!
. While
hatix excise-ged tire erith
see err.-gen and mve, Michael Les Platt
'
lert the cover ct his vehicle
"B"! and proceeded, unnoticedby
"
_
SA
Groganweg:-cup,
down
the
passenger side
or SA
Grogan's vehicle
,
"D"!
lean over
the trunk or it, shooting SA I-Ianlon, who was
down, in
the
this period
groin area, and killing SAs Grogan
and Dove. During
or tine,
SA Risner was firing
warnings to SA .Grogan's
group
attempting
oniiatt and
to alert
shouted
them to P1att'e
flanking movements. SA Risner'e
warnings werenot heard by hie
fellow SpecialAgents and
he observed
Platt shootat
the
_
--
- -Q-.92;15'
r
>-1
Agents -
.,
_
92-
F.
Memo from Acting Chairman,
RE: Administrative
SIRG to Hr. Sharp
Inquiry
Shooting Incident
Hiami
iiivision,
_
4/ ll/ S6
apparently fired
five rounds
of O0
repeating this
reloading
procedure
successfully punctured
the car
in
driver's side door window, and the
shot patterns
were later
found in
SA Mireles then rose to his
advanced on SA Sr
buokshot in this manner,
each
time.
The rounds
the left
front fender,
the
windshield. SA
Hireles'
the interior
of the car.!
feet, drew his service
anis vehicle,
firing and
inflicting
revolver,
fatal
wounds
on
both suggests with
his Bureau-issued
saw .357
caliber
e
0
6
medical emergency
units
$7 -
revolver.
F
Several
Special
Agents,
including
;ll1_: V
.e
wed .at
the
_abeerved
92 . _t who had
us
'
" fire.
F;
arrived
and
_W
6
o
g
Agents tohospital
---£aciut.?.._
Aired following their--0
.
--
_I
*
A crime
and Agents
of the !!! ident fiable
_;_ recovered!.
rounds -"
cartridge cases
It is
by Metro-DedeHomicide Detectives
tory established
that 1:1 a
fired from
probable
were not
.
that
other
found and
various weapons
rounds were
cartridges
fired and
retrieved. The
it
all
best available
estimate is that aminimum of 131 and as many as 140-145 total
rounds were exchanged. Ballistics
identifications definitely
establish that
40 rounds
were
fired by Platt from the Ruger .223
semiautomatic Mini-l4. 'l'wo
possglvand
three rounds of l2-gauge
#6 shot were dischargedby Hatix from his saw model3000 shotgun.
Both Matix and Platt
were
one aDan
fired from
any of
also armed with .357
Wesson manufacture,
each
of
the Special
the other
magnum revolvers-
asaw.
Three rounds
these revolvers without apparently
Agents. All
of the
.Agent personnel was apparently inflicted
striking
were
severedamage done to
by the .233 caliber
__ ammunition, fired from the Ruger Mini-'14 rifle. SA Hanauzzi e
suffered superficial
wounds from 12-gauge #6 shotgun pellets
and 3
SA Orrantia suffered superficial
wounds believed to have been
inflicted by
shrapnel from e.35? round entering the passenger :
compartment of his vehicle.
Ballistics examinations
have A_
determined that Agents fired the following
U ;_
92w..
rounds:
EéiE%
SA Risner
.6*
sa Grogan3 .
.,, -
=-92.. _w...<,.__;-.~,
--'
"
_,,
_.-
_
Bureau-issued 5&1-1 model 459
9mm semi-automatic pistol
9Bureau-issued
saw model
Ass
inn seniseutmatic
pistol
I
'
_, »=.-.e
_'..,__
.
._.__
_- ~..--.»e..-e
M H_ _;@;.,___~____;__
ma;-1:-'
I~._
___.
.......t.__..._,'_
_,¢-1-..-Q»:-ai-1-ea-,-1.112-i-.:.-...-e-».._
i___;_-___ -_r-t-.-1151':-r:-.|a»1»-.1-1,
._;_;,-.-.,.,__.,.-..
...e.
~.v,:-'
'92
1
.
_fa,-
Memo from Acting Chairman,
_ RE:
Administrative Inquiry
SIRG to Mr. Sharp
Shooting Incident
4/11/86
Miami Dvision,
2R _
up ..
rienpgn
"~ ="
SA Dove
20 Bureau-issued
S&W model
91m semi-automatic
SA Orrantia
'12
~
?
SSA llc eil
Bureau-issued
SIM .357 caliber
revolver,
model
13-2
A=1
-
459
pistol
saw .357caiiber '
'
ml
EX
19
Ai
Hxl-
ii SIM .38 cal
, nodal
36
Bhlianlon
SA Hireles
' SEW
. t
- -W
.357 caliber
Id
revo1ver,_node1 686
ii-isstied 12-gaugeRemingtonw m
' "SAHire1es "'i'
___
____
,
I
.'
d
* It is
69
M
.
noted that
SA Risner
stated
14 shots and had placed a second loaded clip in
however, only
*T_.
.-
six oi
1 or
the
his casings
were
round.!
he
had
tired 13
his weapon;
or
'
weapons listed here which were fired
by
1 Agents on 4,-'11/36
were either
iureati-issued,
ed or
personally
-.
E
.nodei§'.lQ,o1i.nrl.,oe1'92__ntg1.1_n_
_
owned, Bureau-approved
tirearms.
'
- -.7-"
&#
__
t
.- .-.-.-_~
-
__
iv
17 7C
5'.
. _~ _
*;
Y._'
I..
A 5:
171!?
.
1 L,.......-- ..;,
U.-..-_....-.-_.e.
1
, ____ '
,_£,_.,_;_k;A..
¢__,-.aw=n..-Allan.-.1:
.._..,
..I -Wt,_-IH!,'r:
. '-..
:''§
#92,
. §""
?.. '
".'.5'-'s.~.
I l . ~_-Z -. L'::w
-M4
_ 3* ea-fr,
- --_ 1.?
rt,
J-VHmH
M -- hr"
_-'-il
-~92_
.'-.4,
, "'*~'¢
¢.,;-.
-.-_ _
__
. _-.3-L".| ¢"""2" _
_-M F
_.1.»
1-.
7
E'.x'
,
-~
e
»
'
_.v
_;______;_
____-_ tm
..,. ,;__';_16
9. -.#5.
..1 _;- _.-.
_.
L.-u--._92...y":&#
;
.
.
___,__
~--.=»;_-......;.....;--2:.--,.
.
..-'.."».-4-.5.-..."_"-i-'--.--"
"
-
*
-- -i -_
..
- -- .T*"i'
I
_'.'.
. fr -.
21:4, :1... '...__.." ._... --
._.__._.__. _..L ..___-..*_...-.--.~ ._.,--J.-..
..~ __-...-_- ..___ _._.¢-___---- ~
-
'
'.5t_i..
. 79, ? "'5 *5 E":'".'il=:"
-~ 1--
_
41-750 Rev.
4-17-85!
J "J
XXXXX
KXXXXX
XXXXXX
FEDERAL BU
BEAU
DF
lllVE$TlGl92_TlDll
FDIPA DELETED PAGE. HIFDBIMTIDII SHEET
._§__ Pa.ge
withheld
s!
at
entirely
this
location
theinle.
Onemore
or the
of following
statements,
where
indicated, explain
this deletion.
[E Deleted
under exemption
_
mm!
s! withno segreg
material available for release to you.
[:1 Information
pertained only
toa third
party with no
referenoeyou
to or
the subject
of your
request.
l:| Information "pertained only
to a third
party.
l:l Document:
agency ies!fog
.__i Pages
l:l For
documents were
referred to
that
.
contain information
by another Government agency ies!.
»to the releasability
of this following
i. Page s!
name is Hated in the title only.
You will be advised by the FBl as
our consultation
with theother agency es!.
withheld for the following reasontslz
your infonnation:
_
E TheI following
number
is tobe
used
for reference
regarding pages:
these
4
.
_ _1
4.n
F-I
A4
oa~/215 1_r>- G /'/*L1_e
w
_
92__H., ._J__
.
_
=
" NO
-
,
*
.
'
"'~1-
DELETED -PAGEXS!
DUPLICATION FEE
FOR THIS
PAGE
X
XXXXXX
Fll/DOJ
