Loudoun Street Pedestrian Mall
Transcription
Loudoun Street Pedestrian Mall
May 20, 2013 Page C1 Loudoun Street Mall 2013: A NEW LOOK FOR OLD TOWN JEFF TAYLOR/The Winchester Star Participating in the ribbon-cutting to rededicate the Loudoun Street Mall on Friday are (from left) John Tagnesi, City Council; Jennifer Bell, downtown manager; Rick McClendon, Old Town Development Board; Dale Iman, city manager; Jeffrey Buettner, City Council; Milt McInturff, City Council; Elizabeth Minor, mayor; John A. Willingham, City Council; John Hill, City Council; Ben Weber, City Council; Evan Clark, City Council; Stan Corneal, Old Town Development Board; Mark Lore, Old Town Development Board; and Lauri Bridgeforth, Old Town Development Board. Loudoun Street Mall gets a $7.1 million renovation By VIC BRADSHAW The Winchester Star WINCHESTER T he Loudoun Street Mall is only 1,600 feet long, but it has been described as the city’s “living room,” the heartbeat of historic downtown. When it was created in 1974, the Loudoun Street Mall was the first pedestrian mall in Virginia — a concept that was popular across the country in the late 1960s and early 1970s. In their heyday, pedestrian malls could be found in 200 to 300 communities in the United States. Today, less than 50 still exist. In Virginia, only Winchester and Charlottesville have them. But while the urban planning experiment failed in other places, it succeeded in Winchester, so much so that $7.1 million has just been spent renovating the downtown attraction. The improvements, which began Jan. 2 and took about four months to complete, included replacing aging water and sewer mains and adding aboveground amenities such as gateway entrances, a splash pad and a public restroom. A grand reopening was held Friday and Saturday. The aesthetic changes aren’t dramatic, but they do help better define the Loudoun Street Mall as a dining, entertainment and shopping destination. The area itself has been a vital marketplace since the city’s founding more than 250 years ago. “We have spruced it up,” City Manager Dale Iman said. “We encourage people to look at downtown as our living room and to bring company here, show off what we have to offer here in Winchester.” ‘A sense of place’ Thirty-nine years ago, the Loudoun Street Mall was created when the city closed a stretch of Loudoun Street from Piccadilly to Cork streets to traffic. The transformation from street to pedestrian walkway took seven months to complete and cost $587,000, including stormwater management improvements. The goal: preventing urban decay in the city’s core. RIGHT: People instrumental in the Loudoun Street Mall renovation enjoy the city’s “living room” quite literally on furnishings courtesy of Patton’s Furniture, a longtime business on the mall. Seated on the ground at left is Perry Eisenach, public services director; seated on the ground at right is Will Moore, city planner and former interim downtown manager. Seated on the furniture are (from left) Lauri Bridgeforth, Old Town Development Board (OTDB) chairwoman and OTDB Design Committee chairwoman; David Smith, former OTDB chairman, Dave Spence, former OTDB Design Committee chairman; Jennifer Bell, downtown manager; and Dale Iman, city manager. JEFF TAYLOR/The Winchester Star Index A difficult jobsite .......................... C3 Map of Old Town businesses........ C4-5 New public restroom, splash pad ... C7 Photos: Start to finish .................. C8 A look back .................................. D1 Changing the face of downtown ... D3 Downtown though the centuries ... D4-5 Saving the old Taylor Hotel .......... D6 A place to park it......................... D7 “We encourage people to look at downtown as our living room and to bring company here, show off what we have to offer here in Winchester.” — City Manager Dale Iman In the nearly four decades since then, there have been informal talks about tearing up the pedestrian mall and reopening it to vehicular traffic, but nothing ever amounted from those discussions. “A sense of place is what it comes down to, first and foremost,” Winchester Planning Director Tim Youmans said. “When you look at any literature that promotes Winchester, whether it’s tourism or economic development, it’s necessary to have an image of the Loudoun Street Mall. “It defines us like Charlottesville’s walking mall defines them. It is the center of our universe in the lower Shenandoah Valley.” And with the new improvements, the hope is that the mall will continue to define the city for decades to come. Below the surface Contrary to what some might think, the city did not tear up and replace the Loudoun Street Mall just to give it a facelift. The reason was feet deeper and perhaps six decades older. Perry Eisenach, Winchester’s public services director, said the project had to be done because the utility infrastructure underneath the pedestrian mall was failing. Some of the water main was more than 100 years old, he estimated, and was the source of numerous See Vision, Page C2 SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star Officials from the City of Winchester and general contractor HRI Inc. watch the splash pad in April after it was turned on. C2 LOUDOUN STREET MALL MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR Vision from Page C1 Did you know? breaks over the past decade. Old sewer main also had caused multiple sewage backups. “It was past time to replace them,” Eisenach said. Storm sewer and cityowned mall electric lines also were replaced as part of the $7.1 million project, and conduit was installed for future needs. Tearing up the pedestrian mall to replace infrastructure provided an opportunity to make long-desired aesthetic changes to the mall and freshen its look. And a new look it has. Gateways mark the north, south and central entrances to the mall. Water features greet visitors at the north and south gateways, and a splash pad was added to the south end of the mall. Bricks and pavers replaced the former all-brick walking surface, and new lighting and landscaping have been installed. Stone planters are tall enough to be used for seating. The renovation also addressed a basic need merchants have requested for years — a public bathroom. Long planning process Plans for the mall’s above-ground improvements weren’t finalized until late 2012, but preparations began years ago. Discussions about potential changes started in 2004, according to Karen Helm, former executive director of the Old Town Development Board (OTDB), a city advisory panel focused on the vitality of the downtown’s special taxing districts. In 2007, the OTDB held public input sessions and a design charrette. “That’s when we heard loud and clear what a lot of people wanted,” Helm said. The OTDB’s Design Committee, comprised of board members and other downtown stakeholders, began meeting in 2010 to decide what changes should be made. City staffers and Design Committee members visited Charlottesville’s Downtown Mall (which Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development staff members think is the only other pedestrian mall in the state) and renowned Old Town Alexandria (like Winchester, also part of a historic district) to see those areas and learn from them. Dave Spence, an agent with Winchester-based Colony Realty who was the Design Committee’s chairman at the time, said the group came away from the trip to Alexandria with the idea that uniform standards needed to be set for restaurant cafe areas because “if you had one different it would take away from the cor ridor.” A splash pad fountain was seen elsewhere and brought to the committee’s attention, he said, and Eisenach determined that it was a viable option. The planning process was driven by the city’s engineering staff, the OTDB and the project engineers, the Manassas office of Michael Baker Corp. City Council was kept apprised of the design process through its OTDB liaison, but OTDB members said the elected leaders largely stayed out of the planning effort. The only real design change was a last-minute switch to a straight walkway design instead of a serpentine pattern, which would have restricted the use of public space in front of some buildings. “They were pretty supportive of the whole project,” said David Smith, coowner of Village Square Restaurant and Village Market and Bistro on the Loudoun Street Mall and the chairman of the OTDB during the project planning process. “The Old Town Development Board and City Council worked closely together, keeping them abreast of things more than we previously had.” The gateways, splash pad fountain and public bathrooms accounted for $700,000 of the project’s cost. The OTDB will have $50,000 deducted from its budget for the next 14 years to cover the expense. The remainder will be paid for with water and sewer rate increases. Defining the destination Each of the mall’s new features has a purpose. Public restrooms have been longed for by mall merchants for some time, and they were considered a 1,776 linear feet of new water main pipe was installed as part of the Loudoun Street Mall renovation. Total weight of the pipe: approximately 46,530 pounds. ber, a member of City Council and former OTDB member. “The underground damage from roots was hurting our mixed-use programming with second- and third-floor living.” Communication key SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star City of Winchester engineer Robert Brown (from left), inspector Cameron Metzger, facilities director Corey MacKnight and engineer Kelly Henshaw helped see the $7.1 million Loudoun Street Mall renovation to fruition. The bulk of the project entailed replacing infrastructure underneath the pedestrian walkway, including water and sewer mains. The mall also was resurfaced with new bricks and pavers, and gateway entrances were added to the mall’s north and south ends. A splash pad and a public toilet are among the other additions. bar rier,” she said. “We want visitors to come, but we don’t want them driving on the mall.” And the kid-friendly splash pad fountain, Helm said, was placed on the south end of the mall to be close to churches with preschool programs, venues with arts classes and the Shenandoah Valley Discovery Museum, a hands-on children’s museum that is located on the mall but will soon move to its new home nearby on Cork Street. The goal was to create a family zone. Lastly, 51 new planters were built to a height to provide additional seating for visitors. Helm said they also provide a space for colorful flowers along the mall and soften its look. The renovation has resulted in a few unplanned benefits as well. A number of trees had to be removed from the mall because they were in the way of utility lines or would suffer root damage during the construction work and likely wouldn’t sur vive. With the trees gone, Bell said she has heard from people who have noticed businesses they had overlooked, while others have noted that the mall’s architecture is more visible. The utility improvements also have made it easier for owners to renovate upper floors for apartments, because the water and sewer service is more reliable. “The number one thing some people noticed was our stunning buildings and, quite frankly, some that need work,” said Ben We- A key component to the success of the mall renovation was communication between merchants and property owners, city officials and officials with HRI Inc., the State College, Pa., company that was the project’s general contractor and coordinated the effort from its Winchester office. Will Moore, the city planner who served as the interim downtown manager before Bell arrived, acted as a liaison before the project started, either helping merchants get questions answered or assisting city utilities staff with disseminating information. When the project began, the city held weekly progress update meetings. Information from those meetings was posted on the city’s website. Bell added a promotion element when she moved into the liaison role. She worked to make sure people knew that the mall’s more than 70 businesses were open throughout the project and came up with promotions designed to bring people downtown when it was a construction zone and afterward. Occasionally, however, there wasn’t time to go through a liaison. Drew Brady, the city construction inspector who was onsite throughout most of the project, has been called “the most helpful person in the city that they’ve ever encountered” by some downtown busiSee Vision, Page C6 SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star Winchester City Manager Dale Iman (left) and Mayor Elizabeth Minor address a crowd of dignitaries Jan. 4 at the First Friday Dig on the Loudoun Street Mall, two days after renovation construction began. The project took about four months to complete. Irvin Shendow Scott Shendow JEFF TAYLOR/The Winchester Star To meet the May 1 construction deadline, crews often worked into the night under spotlights. Workers are shown here digging up the mall on Jan. 10. must-have by most. “They had to be somewhere,” said Lauri Bridgeforth, chairman of the OTDB and owner of Full Frame Photography on the Loudoun Street Mall. “I have opened my door to many a parent with a dancing 3-year-old. “You’ve got to make families comfortable, and that’s what we needed to do.” Downtown Manager Jennifer Bell, who started her job on Jan. 3, a day after the mall renovation project began, said having a public restroom will encourage people to “stay and linger downtown as opposed to having to make a quick run home.” The cost to use the public bathroom is 25 cents. The gateway entrances were a key addition. Helm said the desire to have them emerged in 2002 during discussions about the need for wayfinding signs to Old Town and something to let visitors know they had arrived at their destination. “That’s one thing we heard loud and clear,” she said. “There was nothing real special about the north or south end of the mall. We wanted to create a sense of place.” Bridgeforth, whose business is located near the mall’s south entrance, said she was a proponent of the gateways because she’s often seen unwitting drivers headed up or down the mall. “The gateways are very important to create a visual Stephen Shendow Wardrobe Consultants “Very seldom does a customer walk into a clothing store today and find second- and third-generation expertise” BellsFineClothing.com Historic Downtown Winchester | 540.667.1430 Mon-Fri 9:30 - 6 | Sat 9:30 - 5 LOUDOUN STREET MALL THE WINCHESTER STAR MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 C3 A difficult job site Crews, businesses had to coexist in construction zone By VIC BRADSHAW The Winchester Star H The biggest challenge for the general contractor was maintaining public access to businesses along the mall. WINCHESTER RI Inc. completed the Loudoun Street Mall’s $7.1 million infrastructure replacement project in just four winter months, but work began well before construction crews descended on the pedestrian mall on Jan. 2. To meet the project’s tight deadline, the State College, Pa.based firm was busy getting ready. Jason Lemire, operations manager for HRI’s Winchester office, said preparation is critical for such a project. Advance planning sessions and meetings with city staff allowed HRI to set a plan of action to get the job done on time. Just as important was the physical work done in 2012, including preparing construction zone barricades and building planters that would be added to the mall. “Being able to pre-construct certain items,” he said, “allowed us to start fast.” But the main credit, Lemire said, goes to the men who worked up to 16 hours a day, sometimes in temperatures in the teens and sometimes late into the night, to replace utility lines and piece together Winchester’s renovated pedestrian mall. “For their dedication and working through all kinds of weather,” he said, “they’re the ones who deserve the most credit for getting this project done successfully.” In addition to the utility work and installing a new walking surface, crews built a public bathroom facility, put up gateway entrances and added a splash pad water feature. New planters now hold trees, shrubs and flowers. Perry Eisenach, the city’s public services director since October 2007, called the project the “most challenging” of his tenure because of the need to complete the project within four months so it wouldn’t interfere with the main events of the 86th Shenandoah Apple Blossom Festival May 2-5. The bulk of the work also had GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Jason Lemire (from left), operations manager for State College, Pa.-based HRI Inc.; Kurt Reese, HRI superintendent; Drew Brady, construction inspector for the City of Winchester; and Bill Weicenburg, HRI superintendent, look over blueprints for the Loudoun Street Mall project at the HRI office on Boscawen Street. The stuffed bear seated in the background wearing a hard hat showed up on the jobsite as part of a practical joke and became the project mascot. LEFT: Standing on the Loudoun Street Mall in the midst of construction are Jason Lemire (from left), operations manager for HRI, and Bill Weicenburg and Kurt Reese, HRI superintendents. to be done in the winter. HRI had a May 1 deadline to finish construction and a May 31 deadline to finish landscaping, and the company more than met both. “They’ve been fantastic,” Eisenach said of HRI. “They’ve done a great job throughout the whole project.” Crews worked in two shifts — up to 16 hours a day, three to four days in a row — to get the work done. Lemire estimated that at the project’s peak, about 75 HRI employees and subcontractor workers were on the jobsite. Meanwhile, the project’s two superintendents generally worked all day the entire week. Curt Reese said he usually handled office duties, and Bill Weicenburg was in the construction zone. Reese said the mall was a difficult jobsite — only 45 feet wide, with few access points. On a scale of one to 10, with 10 being the most difficult, he rated the project a nine. He credits Weicenburg with figuring out how best to manage it. “[Weicenburg] spent a good month going through the nuts and bolts of it and figuring out what we needed to do to build it,” Reese said. The biggest challenge, Weicenburg said, was maintaining public access to businesses along the mall. He said property owners were “great” throughout the pro- cess, while a few pedestrians became frustrated by the sometimes confusing temporary fencing used to keep them out of the work zone while the new surface was laid. City officials were very cooperative whenever problems arose, Reese said, and the business owners were extremely supportive. “For every one complaint we had 50 compliments,” he said, “and with us being right up against the businesses for the duration of the project, you’d think it would be the other way around. It was really nice to have people tell us how good we were doing on a daily basis.” Communication was key to keeping downtown merchants content, Lemire said, especially notification of when access to their business would be limited. “It helps the business owners to know when work is going to be done so they can plan for it,” he said. Lemire said he’s very pleased with the project and that HRI employees and subcontractors who worked on it have plenty to be proud of. “Not just the complexity of the project,” he said, “but also to be part of a project that’s such a signature for the city is something that will stay with our guys for a long time. There’s satisfaction in doing that high visibility of a project as well. “I’m very proud of the project we’ve constructed and the teamwork between us and the city and our subcontractors. There’s a lot of credit to be given to everybody involved.” — Contact Vic Bradshaw at [email protected] C4 MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR C5 THE WINCHESTER STAR Loudoun Street Mall Here are some of the faces behind the more than 70 businesses and two churches on the Loudoun Street Mall. Theresa Hoover, owner of the Colonial Wig Room and South End Barber Shop Stephen Shendow, co-owner of Bell’s Fine Clothing Lauri Bridgeforth, owner of Full Frame Photography Rae Carter, owner of All Seasons Racing and Gifts Pastor Mark D. Kennerly, Impact Christian Center Marilyn Finnemore, owner of Bright Box James T. Riley, certified public accountant ❞ ❞ ❞ The walking mall is a true city center, a true downtown. And in this age of sprawl and chain stores, it’s rare and precious indeed. The mall looks and feels more open and spacious. This is a view looking south down the Loudoun Street Mall from Boscawen Street in early March. New planters were added as paving work continued. Lori Thompson, owner of 147 North Artist Eugene Smith looks out the second floor window of his studio in January to watch a piece of excavating equipment dig up the mall to replace underground infrastructure. Some of the pipes were estimated to be 100 years old. I just like being downtown. It has a post office, places to eat, and it’s a nice place to walk. SCOTT MASON/ The Winchester Star A worker from HRI Inc. builds the foundation for the splash pad in March on the mall’s south end. GINGER PERRY/ The Winchester Star Scott Shendow, co-owner of Bell’s Fine Clothing SCOTT MASON/ The Winchester Star 101 125 123 121 117 115 111 49 41½ 41 39 33 29 21 17 15 13 11 7 North Indian Alley 1 1 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 21 23 25 27 29 101 103 107 South Loudoun Steet 126 106 54 48 40 38 28 24 22 16 14 10 6 4 2 116 W S E South Loudoun Street Addresses - West Side 115 The Taylor Hotel 131 N 100 112 116 118 120 122 126 128 130 132 North Loudoun Street Addresses - West Side 101 Wisteria House 2 Village Market & Bistro 38 The Hair Company/Echo Vintage 1 El Centro Mexican Food & Drink 15 Bright Box Theater 147 147 North 7 Wilkins’ Shoe Center 111 Awabi Sushi 4 Second Skin 40 RBC Wealth Management 7 Polka Dot Pot 21 Giovanni’s Restaurant & Bar 149 SEArenity Massage 115 Judy Bowen’s Hair Design & Tanning 6 Swirls 48 Once Upon a Find 25 Eugene B. Smith Gallery 151 Olde Towne Armory & Heirlooms 13 James R. Wilkins & Associates 117 Virginia Retirement Specialists (VRSI) 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 27 Fashion Worthy 159 Snow White Grill 29 JBC Limited Co. 161 Old Town Stained Glass 29 Howard J. Manheimer 165 Espresso Bar & Café 17 The Early Birds 21 Harrison & Johnston Attorneys 29 Patton’s Furniture 33 Imagination Gallery 39 An Affair to Remember 41 Our Children’s Closet 41½ FROG - Families Reaching Out Group 49 Hable’s Real Estate HRI Inc. workers Kevin Moore (left) and James Bookwalter tap holes for water service in an 8-inch diameter water line that was installed underneath the Loudoun Street Mall to replace an old 4-inch diameter line. SCOTT MASON/ The WInchester Star 123 Law Offices of Christian J. Griffin 123 Enid McConnell Design, LLC 125 Studio 125 125 Full Frame Photography 54 Shenandoah Valley Discovery Museum 14 Bangz Salon 106 Tech Team Solutions 16 Posh Pets 106 Old Town General Store 22 Bruce, Renner & Co. BRC 116 First Presbyterian Church 24 Thai Winchester 126 Hill’s Keep 28 Godfrey Miller Home & Fellowship Center 136-142 Donegal House 129-131 Design Concepts – Tim Machado, AIA 137 Beyond the Fringe 141 Luciole 134 The Bright Center Affordable Massage Bright Cowork Covenant Real Estate Management Karen Holman Mediation Partners, LLC Rachel Heberle, LPC Strategy Bridge International Sanaa Gallery SIPA Small Business Development Center The Hearing Health Care Center The Scylla Group Inc. Virginia Premier Health Wire & Web, #203 150 152 156 158 160 Old Court House Civil War Museum 100 BB&T Scott & Stringfellow 112 BB&T and JV Arthur Insurance 118 Winchester Masonic Temple 101 Union Jack Pub & Restaurant 167 Murphy Beverage Company 103 Village Square Restaurant 173 The Floor Shop 107 V2 181 Violino Ristorante Italiano 111 Incredible Flying Objects 185 Winchester Book Gallery 115 The Potomac Bead Company 131 Old Warsaw Galleries 135 Runners’ Retreat 145 Dollar General GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Pictured are pieces of the old 4-inch diameter water line dug from the Loudoun Street Mall. 146 116 The Door Mouse LEFT: A pedestrian barricade goes up on the north end of the Loudoun Street Mall on Jan. 2 as renovations to the walking mall get under way. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star 142 20 11 Main Street Fare 121 James T. Riley, CPA 165 167 173 181 185 168 186 North Loudoun Street Addresses - East Side 1 Make Nest Interiors 15 The Black Rose 157 159 161 20 South Loudoun Street Addresses - East Side 10 Scarpa Alta 135 139 145 147 149 151 North Loudoun Street East Boscawen Street 136 East Cork Street 142 111 East Piccadilly Street 137 129 131 West Piccadilly Street South Indian Alley 141 BUSINESSES West Boscawen Street West Cork Street OLD TOWN RIGHT: An HRI Inc. worker attaches a crosspiece to the gateway entrance on the mall’s north end on April 24. SCOTT MASON/ The Winchester Star 122 Bell’s Fine Clothing 126 Abija Blue 128 Richard’s Jewelry 130 Sensel Signs Inc. 132 U.S. Post Office 134 Impact Christian Center 142 The Dharma Studio 146 Red Fox Creamery 150 Handworks Gallery 152 Old Town Silversmiths 156 RealiteaZe Hair Designs 158 Patsy’s Pastry Pizzas 160 Blind Faith Enterprises 168 Brewbakers Restaurant 186 Virginia National Bank C6 LOUDOUN STREET MALL MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR Vision from Page C2 ness owners, according to Smith. He said Brady did everything from keeping people informed about when work would be done in front of their buildings to getting a welder to repair cafe railings damaged after the city removed them from the mall in December. A downtown with a vision The visible changes to the mall get the most buzz, but the underground work is even more important to some people. Eisenach said the improvements will result in more reliable water and sewer service for years to come. Stormwater drainage also should be much better. Part of the mall, however, is in the Town Run flood plain (the waterway actually flows underneath the southern part of the mall), and the improvements won’t prevent flooding, Eisenach said. Local developer Jim Vickers has redeveloped multiple buildings in the city’s downtown, and he said the infrastructure project sends the right message to people looking to invest there. “I think one of the things that’s been overlooked with the project infrastructure replacements is that they will last us another 50 years, and that’s just huge,” said Vickers, CEO and chairman of OakCrest Cos. “For an investor and property owner downtown, it’s crucial to know the city has a vision to enhance city properties and allow investments to be put back into the community. “For me, that makes it very easy to begin the process of starting to think about the next renovation project downtown with the city making the investments it’s making. I’ve already set up design teams, already identified other buildings I might target.” Jeffrey Buettner, a member of City Council since 1998, said the governing body never really formed a complete plan for downtown renovations. But in piecemeal fashion, it has spent $18.3 million in just the last four years on utility and improvement projects along Braddock and Cameron streets ($8 million), Piccadilly Street ($2 million), Indian Alley ($1.2 million) and the mall. “After we did Cameron and Braddock, after we changed them to two-way streets, downtown became much more of a focal point for council,” he said. Council President John Will- GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Shane Nickleson, owner of SkyView Tree Experts LLC of Augusta, W.Va., cuts top branches off a tree on the south end of the Loudoun Street Mall as work begins on the renovations. Forty-six trees had to be removed to make way for the changes. Local woodworkers reclaimed some of the wood for artisan projects. ingham, who has served on the body since 2009, said councilors want Old Town to become a place where people want to live, work and shop. “Delivering infrastructure downtown was extremely important to us,” he said. “I think Old Town is a way for us to differentiate ourselves from other localities, and it shows business owners and property owners that we’ve made a significant investment in Old Town.” Showing it off With so much public investment, downtown will become even more of a focal point in the city’s marketing efforts, according to city officials. They want the pedestrian mall to be the image people remember when they think of Winchester. “It’s authentic,” Youmans said of downtown. “People can come here and not see somebody’s attempt to recreate an atmosphere. It retains so much integrity and isn’t fake.” Buettner said everyone has malls and strip shopping centers with big-box stores, but an area like the Loudoun Street Mall is a SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star HRI workers dismantle the fountain on the Loudoun Street Mall Jan. 4. Its new home will be at the Our Health campus on North Cameron Street. jewel few localities possess. “As we’re trying to market and brand Winchester as a destination point,” he said, “I think downtown has to be that cornerstone.” Jim Deskins, the city’s eco- SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star Local artists were invited to create murals to dress up the green construction barriers that were erected along the mall to keep people out of the construction zone. nomic redevelopment director, agrees. “Winchester’s largest and most effective branding image is that walking mall area,” he said. “It becomes etched in the minds of all the people who visit Winchester as the picture of what Winchester is.” A key component in Old Town’s future health is the continued development of apartments and condominiums in underused space. Deskins and Vickers said demand for quality downtown housing remains insatiable, and the area commands the highest rents in Winchester. Jeff Sadler, manager of the Virginia Main Street program, said continued development of upperstory housing and adding familyfriendly amenities like the splash pad fountain are important for thriving downtown areas. The restaurants and cafes, he added, also have proven to be big draws. “The emphasis on the al frescodining is something pedestrian malls have a long history of,” Sadler said, “and because of a change in people’s preferences, there seems to be renewed excitement around them as revitalization tools in commercial districts.” All those factors seem to be keys to the success of pedestrian malls, he said, and Winchester appears to have chosen a good time to update its mall. Deskins said he could see the mall essentially becoming downtown’s food court. Diners would head to the mall and check out what specials restaurateurs were offering before deciding where to eat, much as is the case in an area like the Georgetown section of Washington. He said he’s also optimistic that the downtown will achieve enough residential density to draw a grocery store or food cooperative that people can walk to. Those days, however, are still ahead. What Winchester has right now is a renovated, authentic centerpiece attraction that’s ready to draw locals and tourists alike. “Downtown is the living room of our community,” Iman said. “Just like your living room, when you’re going to have company in, you want to spruce it up, want to get it looking good.” — Contact Vic Bradshaw at [email protected] Did you know? About 7,440,000 pounds of new concrete was placed under the mall’s new bricks and pavers. LOUDOUN STREET MALL THE WINCHESTER STAR MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 C7 New additions: Public toilet, splash pad One amenity is practical, the other is just plain fun By CYNTHIA CATHER BURTON The Winchester Star O WINCHESTER ne of the additions to the Loudoun Street Mall is a talking, selfcleaning public toilet that costs 25 cents for people to use. “Welcome to Exeloo,” the restroom greets customers in English and Spanish. “It’s a ver y polite thing,” Jim Scardino joked on a recent afternoon as he programmed the automated toilet for use. Scardino works for Atlantabased Public Facilities & Services Inc., which is a distributor of Exeloo restrooms in the United States. The brand is based in Auckland, New Zealand. Exeloo — short for excellent loo — has supplied and installed more than 1,000 public toilets in Australia, New Zealand and the U.S. over the past 20 years, according to the company website, exeloo.com. It was recommended by a city official who had seen the brand while traveling overseas. The city toilet is on the mall’s southern end in a 27-foot-by-13-foot stone building. It cost $300,000 and sits behind the new splash pad and contains two unisex bathrooms — one on either side of the structure. Her e’s how it works: After a “customer” inserts a quarter, the bathr oom’s stainless steel door slides open and a recording of a m an ’s voice begins of fering instructions on how the automated restroom works. Everything inside is operated by sensors and is touch-free — from the flushing of the toilet to the dispensing of toilet paper. The toilet flushes once the customer washes his or her hands. Music plays while the bathroom is in use, and a baby-changing station is available. After ever y 30 uses, or two hours, the bathroom cleans itself, which it announces by saying somewhat urgently, “This public toilet will soon be cleaned and sanitized with detergent. Please leave immediately.” The cleaning doesn’t start until the sensors no longer detect motion inside the bathroom. Soap then shoots from a nozzle above the toilet, while water shoots from another nozzle aimed at the toilet and five other nozzles spray water on the floor. A jet drier then comes on and blows the water across the slightly slanted floor into a drain. The frequency of the cleanings can be adjusted, according to city facilities director Corey Mac Knight, whose staff also will help maintain the facility and its supplies. Though the voice emanating from the toilet is polite, it gets testy when a customer is approaching the maximum 10-minute time limit. It encourages the customer to finish up, but, after the third warning, the stainless steel door slides open. Despite its automation, Scardino said it’s impossible to get locked inside the toilet. The door has a magnetic lock, and if the power goes out, the lock releases. He added that there’s a groove on the inside of the door that a person can use to pull it open. A touch of the hand also keeps the door from closing. Housed in the center of toilet building between the two bathrooms is a mechanical system for the $150,000 splash pad — an attraction with three “dance” settings for the water and three light settings. “With the touch of a button, we can change either,” MacK night said. GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Perry Eisenach (left), city public services director, and Corey MacKnight, city facilities manager, stand in front of the new public toilet on the south end of the mall. The restroom cost $300,000 to build and costs 25 cents to use. JEFF TAYLOR/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Employees of Patton’s Masonry in Edinburg work on the foundation of the new public restroom on Jan. 6. First Presbyterian Church — one of two churches on the mall — can be seen in the background. GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Corey MacKnight gives a tour of the new restroom. The stone building houses two automated unisex toilets and a pump/control room for the splash pad. The splash pad’s more than two dozen fountains shoot water into the air, and the water is re-circulated and treated with chemicals like swimming pool water. “I like the water,” 6-year-old Mikiah Diggs of Stephens City shouted as he ran through the erupting fountains on a recent afternoon, his shoes and clothes soaking wet. Right behind him was his 4-year-old sister, Jada, who squealed with delight as she tried to figure out which fountain would spout next. Though their mother, Erin, had two wet children to take home, she didn’t seem to mind. “I love the fountain,” she said. “I think it’s really pretty.” SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star A loader pours gravel into the new public restroom while a worker spreads it on March 12. v Hours of operation for the splash pad are 8 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday to Thursday and 8 a.m. to midnight Friday to Sunday. The toilet is open daily from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. — Contact Cynthia Cather Burton at [email protected] SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star A worker pours concrete for the splash pad on March 14. RIGHT: MacKnight demonstrates the handsfree hand washing area of the restrooms. GINGER PERRY/ The Winchester Star SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star ABOVE: The water to the splash pad is turned on April 26. LEFT: Workers from HRI Inc. lay the groundwork for the splash pad. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star C8 LOUDOUN STREET MALL MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR The renovation: From start to finish Januar y JEFF TAYLOR/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Heavy equipment operators from State College, Pa.-based HRI Inc. drive their excavating equipment in parade fashion on Cork Street as they travel from City Yards to the Loudoun Street Mall construction site on Jan. 3. RIGHT: The northern section of the mall remained intact Jan. 14 as crews worked on the $7.1 million infrastructure replacement project. Construction began Jan. 2. The project involved replacing infrastructure along the mall, in addition to adding a public bathroom, gateway entrances, and a splash pad. This view shows North Loudoun Street looking south. Februar y GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star ABOVE: An equipment operator digs around storm drains and water and sewer pipes on the mall on Jan. 8. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Sewer replacement work had reached the intersection of North Loudoun and Piccadilly streets by Feb. 20. March GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star ABOVE: The mall’s construction zone is shown looking south from the third floor of the Winchester Hiram Lodge No. 21 on Feb. 25. April JEFF TAYLOR/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Attorney Anne M. Williams walks to her office on the Loudoun Street Mall on March 15 after the new bricks, pavers and planters had been installed. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Renovation work to the mall’s northern end neared completion April 10. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Construction workers take a lunch break on the Loudoun Street Mall on March 26. ABOVE: Karen Helm, former Old Town Development Board executive director, stands at the north entrance to the mall off Piccadilly Street. Behind her is a new gateway flanked by illuminated fountains. This picture was taken at night. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star ABOVE: This is a March 31 view of construction work on the mall looking south. May LEFT: This view shows the new entrance to the mall’s south end off Cork Street on May 10. GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star May 20, 2013 Page D1 Loudoun Street Mall 1974: A LOOK BACK A child listens to a speaker that was installed on the Loudoun Street Mall in 1974. The downtown sound system no longer exists. A sign welcomes people to the Loudoun Street Mall in 1974. A worker constructs the mall fountain, which was moved as part of the 2013 renovation. Its new home will be at the Our Health campus on North Cameron Street. The switch from street to mall eliminated traffic, allowing people to sit on a bench or take a stroll. How did this happen? A water fountain on the mall is toppled. A dedication ceremony is held for the new Loudoun Street Mall in 1974. When it was built, it was the first pedestrian mall in Virginia. The project, which cost $587,000 and took about seven months to complete, transformed 1,600 feet of Loudoun Street into a walkway. Shoppers look for a store on a map of the downtown mall. A bold plan for downtown In creating the mall, city leaders looked to the future By VIC BRADSHAW The Winchester Star L WINCHESTER ike many great things, it all started with a fourhour lunch. The discussion at that midday gathering in the fall of 1963 was downtown Win chester, specifically how to prevent the city’s core from decaying when its major stores bolted for the shopping mall that would inevitably come to the area. The idea three men conceived that day would gestate for 11 years before yielding its desired outcome — the Loudoun Street Mall. When it opened in November 1974, it was the first pedestrian mall in Virginia. Nearly four decades later, some of the downtown’s key business owners from that era say the decision to close a 1,600-foot section of Loudoun Street to traffic has been a wise one. James R. “Jimmy” Wilkins Jr., who then operated his family’s Wilkins Shoe Center at 7 S. Loudoun St., said city leaders — his father among them — saw the importance in drastically changing what was the region’s main shopping district. “Winchester built the mall when we didn’t have a problem,” said Wilkins, who still has an office overlooking the Loudoun Street Mall as the vice president of the Wilkins Companies, a development firm. “Winchester was proactive. Our downtown was packed; it was busy. “Those business leaders anticipated what things were going to be like 10 years in the future, when there’s more shopping centers and a [shopping] mall. We went through vacancies downtown, but we never had that boarded-up look.” A plan for downtown A general outline of the luncheon discussion that started Winchester moving toward a pedestrian mall was published in a February 1974 special section in what was then the Winchester Evening Star. Jack F. Davis, The Star’s general manager and executive editor for many years, broke bread that day with John Larson, a marketing vice president with what was Historic photos from Winchester Star files The downtown shopping district had a new look and feel once the pedestrian mall was completed. To build the Loudoun Street Mall in 1974, general contractor Howard Shockey & Sons had to make some changes underground. Ralph D. Shockey (left) said recently that while the existing water, sewer and stormwater lines weren’t touched, some water inlets and manholes had to be moved and some service lines to buildings had to be replaced. GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star then the Northern Virginia Power Co., and local architect C. Thomas Cooper. Afterward, the trio and some of the power company’s planners spent months analyzing the downtown’s strengths and weaknesses. That led to the publication of the data-intensive “Downtown Progress” on Feb. 12, 1964, in The Star. The report prompted the formation of the Winchester Parking Authority to acquire and manage property for parking — the report cited a lacking of parking as a downtown weakness — and the creation of the Downtown Development Commission (DDC) to study other ways to improve the city’s core. The Parking Authority, funded by downtown merchants and property owners, went to work quickly. It began acquiring land on which surface lots and eventually a parking garage could be built. The DDC, whose members included Davis and Wilkins Sr., proceeded at a deliberate pace. It studied downtown for three years before its “Loudoun Street Corridor” recommendations were published in the newspaper on Feb. 23, 1967. The plan developed by the DDC called for Loudoun to be- come a one-way street with no parking. However, pull-off areas for cars to load and unload would alternate sides of the street, creating a serpentine-looking passageway. Rouss Avenue would be closed to traffic, too, creating a one-block pedestrian mall alongside Rouss City Hall and the Frederick County Courthouse, now the Old Court House Civil War Museum. The hope was that parking lots and streetscape improvements would lure shoppers and diners downtown. “It was all about appealing to the customer,” said Julius Armel, who was assistant manager of the Leggett department store on Loudoun Street and later a DDC member. “That was the main attraction. “We were looking at it from a retail merchant standpoint, what would be the most appealing, what would customers like.” Lots had to be done before that could happen, though. That included adding parking, a mission that was accomplished in November 1972 when the Braddock Jack F. Davis Street Autopark opened with 303 spaces. The time it took to get everything else in place, it now appears, was fortuitous. The plan changes Once the parking situation was improved, Irvin Shendow said, the DDC could focus on Loudoun Street. A co-owner of Bell’s Fine Clothing, then and now, Shendow was appointed to the DDC in 1971 and immediately chosen as its chairman. Shendow recalled that Ray Jennings, head of design for Rubbermaid Commercial Products in Winchester, had joined the DDC and recommended a pedestrian mall. The idea took off from there. While delivery vehicles still needed access to Loudoun Street to service businesses, closing off the mall to general traffic was the best move because of the width of the corridor, which was only 45 feet. “Your main street (Loudoun) was so narrow that your sidewalks were narrow,” Wilkins remembered. “It’s hard to mix vehicle and pedestrian traffic, particularly when you have children and strollers and things like that. “We wanted to keep our doors open (at the Shoe Center), but we didn’t because we were afraid a child would run out in traffic.” The DDC only had about $10,000 at the time, and Shendow said the money was spent to hire F. Eugene Smith Associates from Bath, Ohio, to design a pedestrian mall. See Look back, Page D2 D2 LOUDOUN STREET MALL MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR Look back from Page D1 DDC members visited pedestrian malls in places such as Salisbury, Md., and Cape May, N.J., and downtown historic districts to see what they liked and didn’t like about them, and their ideas were incorporated into the design. The response to the pedestrian mall concept was positive from city leaders, merchants and the public, John Lewis recalled. “It just seemed to make sense at the time,” said Lewis, who owned radio station WINC and was a DDC member. “There were little problems, individual things that had to be worked out. “But I don’t remember any real dissent. I just remember a community united to improve the downtown.” However, Wilbur Feltner, then the chairman and CEO of Farmer’s and Merchants Bank, whose headquarters were on Loudoun Street, remembered some apprehension. “The merchants that I talked to,” he said recently, “felt that it would hurt their business if they had no traffic on Loudoun Street. “Public acceptance was a gradual process. When it first started off, the mall was pretty slow, but as time went on and people became accustomed to it, it gained new life and now it’s pretty vibrant.” A pedestrian mall is born: paying for it, building it Gaining city approval for the pedestrian mall was the easy part. Funding was another matter. “City Council loved the concept,” Shendow recalled, but with a condition. “That’s when the council said, ‘We like the idea, but we don’t have the money. Find the money.’ ” The DDC didn’t have the money, either, so Shendow came up with the idea of creating a special downtown tax district, with the extra money collected by the tax going to pay off the project’s bonds. The tax was used to pay half of the $587,000 total project cost, with the city picking up the tab for the remainder. “We felt at the time that it was something that was really necessary because we were going to require additional services and needs and that was going to cost money,” said Bob Bartley, whose family operated Bartley’s Shoe Repair and Orthopedic Shop “The mall was good some 40 years ago and is now, as evidenced by the restoration project. Yes, the project did prevent downtown decay.” — Former City Manager Wendell Seldon downtown for 60 years. Shendow got more than 70 percent of downtown property owners to agree to the special tax, only to learn that legislation had to be passed by the Virginia General Assembly for it to be enacted. He and Wendell Seldon, Winchester’s city manager from January 1967 to June 1986, convinced state Sen. William Truban of Woodstock to carry a bill that allowed Winchester — and only Winchester — to establish such a tax district. City Council approval of the new taxing district followed. Published reports indicate that property owners along Loudoun Street from Cork to Piccadilly streets would pay an additional 58 cents per $100 of assessed value to support the pedestrian mall. To build the mall, general contractor Howard Shockey & Sons of Winchester had to make some changes underground. Ralph D. Shockey said recently that while the existing water, sewer and stormwater lines weren’t touched, some water inlets and manholes had to be moved and some service lines to buildings had to be replaced. The biggest construction problem in 1974, not unlike 2013, was maintaining access to businesses. The transformation from a street to a pedestrian venue took seven months. “People going into stores had GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Former Winchester Mayor Charles Zuckerman (from left) and downtown businessmen James R. “Jimmy” Wilkins Jr. and Wilbur Feltner pose on the newly renovated Loudoun Street Mall. Wilkins said city leaders in the late 1960s and early 1970s saw the importance in drastically changing the region’s main shopping district to keep it vibrant. But Feltner admitted the new pedestrian mall took a little getting used to. Ultimately, they say, the experiment succeeded. to make their way over planks and gravel and plywood,” Shockey, now 92 and the company’s chairman of the board emeritus, said recently. “Trying to keep those people going in and out of those buildings was quite a task. “We just went out of our way to try to work with all the merchants. It’s amazing how all the stores were kept open and were able to work around it.” The construction itself actually became somewhat of an attraction, something that apparently was good for some businesses. Shendow said he asked the owners of nine different types of mall businesses to report to him weekly throughout the project whether their sales increased or decreased during the week when compared with 1973 sales. His recollection is that six of the nine reported sales increases over the length of the project. “It was attracting people down, for sure,” he said. “People were interested. It was going to be the first pedestrian mall in Virginia. I’d never experienced the construction of a pedestrian mall, and neither had anyone else.” The Loudoun Street Mall, Shockey said, is the only pedestrian mall the company ever built. It cost $587,000 to construct — an amount that was split evenly between the downtown property owners (via the special tax) and the city, which paid for the drainage improvements. Preserving history While creating a pleasant shopping atmosphere was the goal for most downtown merchants, others looked at the pedestrian mall as a way to preserve the corridor’s history and architecture. Loudoun Street was part of the original layout of Winchester, which was founded in 1744 and officially established in 1752. The city essentially grew up around that area. Betsy Helm, who served on the DDC for years before becoming Winchester’s first female mayor in 1988, said those involved in the founding of Preservation of Historic Winchester saw the mall project as an opportunity to protect the area. She recalled preservation experts from places like Charleston, S.C., Savannah, Ga., and Pittsburgh being brought in to “let council know what a jewel we had in the central business community. They were able to enlighten us on things people in the community always had and took for granted.” Lewis Ebert, a former DDC member who worked in The Star’s advertising department at the time, agreed that historic preservation was a goal. “Our thinking on that mall was to use the aesthetics of the city, its history,” the 82-year-old recalled recently. “You walk down there now and look at the cornices of the buildings and they’re beautiful.” Many of the building facades along the pedestrian mall have been frozen in time. That’s something Winchester can claim that few other cities can. “We probably have one of the more authentic [pedestrian] malls from a preservation perspective,” Helm said. “Some have gone to the point that they’re kind of plastic.” And, she added, probably one of the most successful. Added attractions The switch from street to pedestrian mall drastically affected how the corridor was used. With vehicles barred, people were free to stroll and shop there. Harold Patton, the 92-year-old founder of Patton’s Furniture, remembered coming with his family to Loudoun Street on Saturday nights as a child. “They had all the retail merchants and everything,” said Patton, who moved his business to 29 S. Loudoun St. in 1967 after its showroom on North Cameron See Look back, Page D3 LOUDOUN STREET MALL THE WINCHESTER STAR MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 D3 Changing the face of downtown The right people at the right time By VIC BRADSHAW “I was scared. I was scared I was going to fail. I didn’t want to have egg on my face.” The Winchester Star W WINCHESTER hen Irvin Shendow walked into his first Downtown Development Commission (DDC) meeting in late 1971, he didn’t know he’d wind up playing a key role in forever changing the face of downtown. It was at this meeting that the newly appointed Shendow — to his recollection the youngest person in the room at age 33 — was selected as the DDC’s chairman. The group’s unenviable task: figure out a way to prevent the decay that would occur when major retailers left downtown for the enclosed shopping mall that would come to Winchester. Whether the group saw potential in their newest member or longed for fresh ideas or just thought he was naive enough to accept the post, city leaders say history has proven that they found the right man. Shendow, now 75 and still coowner of Bell’s Fine Clothing on the Loudoun Street Mall, is the man most people credit for turning discussion about what to do about Loudoun Street into action — specifically the creation of the pedestrian mall. His success in doing so was driven by a most basic emotion. “I was scared,” he recalled recently. “I was scared I was going to fail. I didn’t want to have egg on my face.” Parking a key component Dozens of people took active roles in the projects that created downtown Winchester as it exists today, and dozens more — the majority of the property owners in the city’s core — bought into and paid for the revolutionary changes. The Winchester Parking Authority, created to obtain the lots and build the garages necessary to eliminate parking on Loudoun Street, was funded privately by downtown property owners. They later agreed to pay an additional property tax to cover the cost of — Irvin Shendow, chairman of the Downtown Development Commission in the early 1970s GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star John Lewis (from left), Betsy Helm, Irvin Shendow, Julius Armel and Lewis Ebert were some of the members of the Downtown Development Commission that laid the groundwork for the mall. The group’s unenviable task in 1971: to figure out a way to prevent the expected decay that would occur when major stores left downtown for the enclosed mall that inevitably would come to Winchester. Their response was the creation of the Loudoun Street Mall, which was completed in 1974. They are pictured here on the newly renovated mall in 2013. creating the mall. While Shendow is the man credited with bringing the mall project to fruition, the late Jack Davis is touted for making downtown redevelopment a priority. Though the idea wasn’t wholly his, Davis used his position as the executive editor and general manager of what was then the Winchester Evening Star and preached the need for change on the newspaper’s pages. Lewis Ebert, who worked in advertising at The Star from 1953 to 1981, said Davis brought a much-needed outsider’s perspective when he joined the paper after working as bureau chief for the Associated Press in Charleston, W.Va. “Jack had a plaque on his desk that said, ‘When you’re through changing, you’re through,” Eber t, now 82, reminisced. Though the original plan called for reducing, not eliminating, traffic on Loudoun Street, the idea from the beginning was to remove parking. To do that, however, other accommodations had to be made. The Parking Authority was created to handle that mission, and the late Richard Martin was its driving force from the beginning. “He was very enthusiastic from the Parking Authority standpoint,” Jimmie Shipp, Winchester’s assistant city manager from 1971 to 1989, said about the manager of the downtown J.C. Penney. Ebert said Martin was “a gogetter.” James R. “Jimmy” Wilkins Jr.’s family owned Wilkins Shoe Center at the time, and his father was an early Parking Authority member. He recalled Martin as a strong, effective advocate for im- proved parking. “Dick Martin provided leadership,” said Wilkins, who later served on both the Parking Authority and City Council. “He had a high energy level, and as a downtown retail business owner, he pushed City Council that we needed to build these parking garages.” Seldon, Shendow led the way While Martin touted improved parking openly and often, City Manager Wendell Seldon worked quietly to help maintain momentum. Wilkins said Seldon “prefer red a behind-the-scenes role” as a manager, making suggestions behind the scenes on whatever issue the city was facing. “He worked for the citizens of Winchester, he worked for the City Council and he worked for the mayor,” Wilkins said. “To me, Look back from Page D2 Street burned. “It was busy every Saturday night. “I don’t know if they improved (Loudoun Street), but it’s a very comfortable place to shop if you want to walk and take it leisurely.” The street closing also allowed the public space in front of buildings to be used by business owners, which eventually led to it becoming more of a dining district with some eateries adding outdoor seating. “The mall is the thing that enabled the restaurants to come downtown,” Helm said. “We had some restaurants downtown, but they were more places to go for breakfast and lunch. “The restaurants really attract people, tourists and local people, and people who live downtown near the mall and can walk there. That’s important.” Dining wasn’t the only new use for the mall. It has become the location of choice for many events. Bartley later was appointed to the Downtown Development Board (formerly the DDC and now known as the Old Town Development Board) and served as its chairman in the 1980s. During his tenure, the board pushed many programs aimed at improving the city’s core. They included a $1 million streetscape project, establishing wayfinding signs, and providing design assistance for facade improvements. He also helped bring the Bluemont Concert Series to the mall. The free summer concerts draw people downtown who shop or dine or just are reminded about Old Town’s offerings. Jimmie Shipp, Winchester’s assistant city manager from 1971 to 1989, said the Loudoun Street Mall “just provides a sense of community, a town center. I’m very pleased to see the apartment development starting to occur now, getting people down there around the clock.” ‘The Heart of Winchester’ Did the pedestrian mall prevent downtown from decaying? To find out the answer, local business owners suggest looking at downtowns along U.S. 11, the old Valley Pike. Shendow said that when the Loudoun Street Mall was created, he never envisioned the vibrant evening activity that its restaurants and stores generate now. The mall, he said, “created a platform or venue that let regular entrepreneurs with capitalistic instincts take place, and it’s morphed into what we see now.” Bartley said the downtown tax base has remained strong, a sign of a good business district, and Winchester’s core is sounder than some of its neighbors. “The appearance is much better, the buildings are better maintained, and there are less vacancies than in many cities,” Bar t- ley said. “I was in Martinsburg (W.Va.) recently and when I walked down main street there I was very, very surprised to see so many vacant and unkempt buildings, boarded up buildings.” Seldon thinks the only evidence needed to know that the pedestrian mall has benefited the city is the fact that it was redone this year instead of torn up and reopened to traffic. “The mall was good some 40 years ago and is now, as evidenced by the restoration project,” he wrote in an email. “Yes, the project did prevent downtown decay.” And that’s the way it should be, as far as Charles Zuckerman is concerned. A 14-year member of City Council and mayor from 1980 to 1988, he called the mall “the heart of Winchester.” “There’s just so much attraction there,” Zuckerman said, “and I don’t think the mall will ever, ever go away.” That would be fine by Wilkins, who served on City Council during Zuckerman’s mayoral tenure. “I think the mall is the greatest thing that’s happened to Winchester,” Wilkins said. “Downtown is like an antique — we’re older but we’re cherished, we’re special. We’re a place people want to come to.” — Contact Vic Bradshaw at vbradshaw@ winchesterstar.com Winchester Mayor Elizabeth Minor talks about construction on the Loudoun Street Mall during the First Friday Dig ceremonies on Jan. 4. SCOTT MASON The Winchester Star Wendell Seldon is the definition of what a city manager should be.” Ultimately, Shendow said, Seldon was effective. “Wendell wanted to see the city progress. He thought [the plan for downtown] was a good idea, and Wendell was the type of individual that when he spoke, people listened to Wendell,” he said. Once the parking was in place and other details had been wrapped up, all that remained was to decide what to do with Loudoun Street. It was time for Shendow to move front and center. After Ray Jennings, who headed design for Rubbermaid Commercial Products in Winchester, opined that a pedestrian mall was a better idea for the narrow corridor, DDC members flew to places such as Salisbury, Md., and Cape May, N.J., to see their walking malls, with Shendow serving as their pilot. “Irv was the one who kind of headed the things, planning and getting information on the other areas that had pedestrian malls,” said Julius Armel, then the assistant manager of the downtown Leggett department store and a DDC member. “He did a lot of legwork.” Shendow, however, said the best thing he did was surround himself with “good people” willing to work to better downtown. “We had people who, when we asked them to do something, they got out and did the work,” he remembered. — Contact Vic Bradshaw at [email protected] Shenandoah Valley’s Most Beautiful And Historical Cemetery ----------------------------------------------------A Full Service Cemetery ESTABLISHED 1844 No High Pressure Sales Interest Free Financing Cash Discounts Low Down Payments In-Ground Tradition Burial Sites Family Lots Estate Section with Shrubbery Veterans Cemetery Cremation In-Ground Burial Sites Scatter Garden Columbarium Niches Personal Columbariums Veterans Columbarium Niches Above Ground Companion Crypts Personal Mausoleums Products (lowest prices) Monuments Vases Cremation Urns Burial Vaults Services Death Date Engraving Cleaning Pre-Need Planning Chapel (no charge) All Burial Sites Include Prepetual Care 540-662-4868 305 East Boscawen Street, Winchester, VA 22601 www.mthebroncemetery.org Not For Profit – All revenues used solely for the regular maintenance and preservation of the cemetery. D4 MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR Loudoun Street Mall A PLACE TO SEE AND BE SEEN A street named for a war hero OVER FOUR CENTURIES 1700s 1800s Since the city’s earliest days, Loudoun Street has been the heart of Winchester, a place for shopping and parades — a place to see and be seen. v Loudoun Street was one of two streets — the other being Boscawen Street — drawn by Winchester founder James Wood in 1744 in his initial plans for Winchester, who named the town for his hometown of W inchester, England. The town was officially established by an act of the colonial legislature in 1752. A circus parade with horse-drawn floats and people watching from the sidewalk goes down Loudoun Street in 1892. On March 9, 1744, James Wood laid out the town’s first 30 lots, each containing half an acre. v Loudoun Street is named for John Campbell, Four th Earl of Loudoun, a hero of the French and Indian War, according to Garland R. Quarle s’ book “Winchester, Virginia: Streets, Churches and Schools.” Since it was the primary business district of the city, residents began referring to the street as Main Street. In 1926, Dr. William P. McGuire pushed the City Council to pass a resolution restoring the original name of the street, according to Quarles’ book. Boys play in the floodwaters in 1906 at Loudoun and Boscawen streets (then called Main and Water streets, respectively). This photo was taken looking east on Boscawen Street. 1900s Two brave souls ride horseback along North Loudoun Street after a blizzard in February 1899. Survivors of Company I, 116th Virginia Infantry (Winchester’s National Guard), 29th Division, march on North Loudoun Street in a World War I Victory Parade in August 1919. Raylass Department Store at 134 N. Loudoun St. after the natural gas explosion in 1948. Merchandise can be seen piled on sidewalk and firefighters on ladders. 2000s Children and their bikes pose in front of the Montgomery Ward store in the late 1950s. Notice the boy on the left wearing a coonskin ”Davy Crockett” cap. GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Preschoolers watch workers move a stone building from Cork Street to the south end of the Loudoun Street Mall on Sept. 15, 2004. First Presbyterian Church moved the structure onto the mall to make way for a new fellowship hall. The new location is just a few feet from the former Cork Street site. Band members stand in front of the Colonial Theatre on Dec. 7, 1930. Girls ages 5 and under, compete on May 28, 2012, in the Loudoun Street Mile. The run, which benefits the Laurel Center, will again by held on Memorial Day this year. GINGER PERRY The Winchester Star Photos courtesy of Stewart Bell Jr. Archives of Handley Regional Library The statue of the Confederate soldier that stands in front of the former Frederick County Courthouse is unveiled in October/November 1916. The Apple Blossom Parade draws a crowd in this photo taken around 1926. D5 D6 LOUDOUN STREET MALL MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR Saving a piece of the past Rebirth of former Taylor Hotel part of downtown revitalization By VIC BRADSHAW The Winchester Star T WINCHESTER he building has been vacant for years, a decaying hulk casting a shadow over the northern end of the Loudoun Street Mall. But the former Taylor Hotel is hailed as one of the most important structures on the mall, and, by the beginning of next year, it should be resurrected. Downtown merchants and property owners are elated that something finally is being done with the dilapidated structure at 119129 N. Loudoun St. The $3.6 million project to reclaim sections of the heavily damaged building, including the historic hotel, began in November. The project — slated to result in restaurant, retail and residential space as well as a farmer’s market and grassy entertainment pavilion — should be substantially complete by the end of 2013. Transforming the blighted property should help businesses in the downtown dining and shopping district. It could also return the address to what it once was — a focal point around which much of Winchester society revolved. The Taylor Hotel’s storied past includes stints as headquarters for both the Union and Confederate armies and as a hospital during the Civil War. Bushrod Taylor built the front part of the structure in 1846. “I think the finished product will be very valuable for the city,” said Jim Deskins, executive director of the Winchester Economic Development Authority (EDA), one of the partners in the redevelopment effort. “The hotel building and outdoor entertainment venue will be very critical for the vibrancy of downtown, and the farmers market also will be a very positive thing.” Sending the right message The old Taylor Hotel almost didn’t make it, though. A partial roof collapse in 2007 hastened its already advanced demise, and a planned redevelopment project languished during a prolonged economic recession that followed. City Council twice declared the building blighted, which could have led to its demolition. In May 2010 it was placed on Preservation Virginia’s list of the most endangered historic sites in the state. “It would have left a gaping hole in the streetscape of the mall,” Frank Wright, president of Preservation of Historic Winchester, said of the prospect of the building being razed. “I cannot image the mall without at least the remnants of the Taylor Hotel that now stand.” In addition to the visual impact, Wright said the loss of the building — best known as Confederate Gen. Thomas J. “Stonewall” Jackson’s temporary headquarters when he arrived in Winchester in November 1861 to plan his defense of the Shenandoah Valley — would have been a strike against the community. He said the only building on the mall that rivals the Taylor Hotel in historical im- Courtesy of Stewart Bell Jr. Archives of Handley Regional Library The Taylor Hotel, circa 1869 Courtesy of Stewart Bell Jr. Archives of Handley Regional Library The Taylor Hotel property as J.G. McCrory Co. 5- and 10-cent Store, circa 1935 SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star Eric Wishneff (left) of Taylor Plaza LLC and Jim Deskins, executive director of the Winchester Economic Development Authority, stand in front of the former Taylor Hotel on the Loudoun Street Mall. The dilapidated property, built in 1846, is undergoing a massive renovation. The end result will be a mixed-use building with restaurant, retail and residential space. The $3.6 million project to reclaim sections of the heavily damaged structure, including the historic hotel, began in November. portance is the 1840 Frederick County Court House, now the site of the Old Court House Civil War Museum. “What that would have said about Winchester is that we don’t care, the town and the citizens don’t care about our history,” Wright said. “That would have been entirely the wrong message to send.” ‘All I saw was oppor tunity’ In June 2010, a private developer with a penchant for historic preservation made public its interest in buying the Taylor Hotel. Nine months later, the EDA joined Taylor Plaza LLC in a public-private effort to save and redevelop it. “We had already been working in Winchester,” said Erik Wishneff of the Washington office of Roanoke-based Brian Wishneff & Associates, a partner in the Taylor Plaza group, “and every time I was walking down the mall, looking over at the Taylor, all I saw was opportunity. Given its central location on the walking mall, it seemed like a great opportunity, and given our interest in rehabilitating historical buildings, it was a natural fit.” For City Manager Dale Iman, the former Taylor Hotel building is “such an integral part of our history that it’s worthy of preservation. It has splendid architecture. “Think of the sheer history of the site, the stories attached to the site and the economic prosperity that resulted from that site. It’s an example of how location, location, location drives economic success.” City Planning Director Tim Youmans said the Taylor Hotel project represents “a good marrying of land use, transportation and historic preservation.” The apartments, restaurant and retail space represent solid mixed-use principles. Transportation is aided by the demolition of a one-story addition on the building’s south side that widens the alley connecting Indian Alley and the Braddock Street Autopark to the pedestrian mall. The pavilion will provide green space downtown, and people will mingle at the entertainment venue and farmers market. “We talk in the [city’s] Comprehensive Plan about being environmentally, socially and economically sustainable,” Youmans said. “It’s going to green up some space, the farmers market and entertainment space will spark social interaction. Once the project’s done, it should be economically sustainable for a long time.” Model project Bill Wiley, the OakCrest Commercial Real Estate agent who’s listing the commercial space in the rede- veloped space, said the Taylor Hotel’s condition has had a negative impact on surrounding properties for years. But he thinks the proper ty’s renovation can be a positive influence that ripples through the community. “It serves as a model, if you will, for other investment opportunities in the downtown market,” said Wiley, chairman of the Winchester Planning Commission. “It represents what can be done with tax credits.” Deskins agrees. “With this project, as well as the work on the mall,” Deskins said, “it’s very evident activity is happening, there’s work under way, and activity begets activity.” — Contact Vic Bradshaw at vbradshaw@ winchesterstar.com Grace Evangelical Lutheran Church Summer Worship Schedule 6:00 pm Saturday Worship & Holy Communion 10:00 am Sunday Worship & Holy Communion VACATION BIBLE SCHOOL July 8-12 9 am till Noon Age 2-6th grade ALL ARE WELCOME! GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star The former Taylor Hotel is shown in a photograph taken from the third floor of the Winchester Hiram Lodge No. 21 on the Loudoun Street Mall in February 2013. 26 W. Boscawen St. • Winchester www.gracewin.org LOUDOUN STREET MALL THE WINCHESTER STAR MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 D7 A place to park it Winchester Parking Authority helped pave way for mall Changing patterns By VIC BRADSHAW The Winchester Star I WINCHESTER n the 1960s, city leaders readily agreed that changes should be made along Loudoun Street to enhance the shopping experience by making it more pedestrian-friendly. But there was one issue that had to be resolved before anything could be done to Loudoun Street — parking. There just wasn’t enough. And the problem would only be exacerbated by making any changes that eliminated parking spaces. “The one thing we didn’t have at the time was really adequate parking,” recalled James R. Wilkins Jr., whose family ran Wilkins Shoe Center on Loudoun Street and whose father was an early member of the Winchester Parking Authority. “We had gravel lots.” That began to change in 1964 when the Parking Authority was created by the Virginia General Assembly at the behest of City Council. Its charge was to acquire and manage downtown parking assets, and because it was an authority it could take on debt that didn’t have to be carried on the city’s books. By the time the Loudoun Street Mall opened in November 1974, the authority controlled 715 off-street spaces, including 303 in the 2-year-old Braddock Street Autopark. The authority now manages about 500 on-street and surfacelot parking spaces and more than 1,700 garage spots. Its garages are the Braddock Street Autopark at 30 N. Braddock St., the Loudoun Street Autopark at 50 E. Fairfax Lane, the Court Square Autopark at 2 S. Cameron St. and the George Washington Autopark at 131 N. Kent St. Parking is everything Adequate, safe, easy-to-find parking is vital for a business district, according to economic development professionals. “Somebody can come to a business district, drive around for three blocks, find nothing, and drive off and never come back again,” said Terry Holzheimer, director of economic development for Arlington County and a professor in practice in the urban affairs and planning department at Vir- How much do you know about the mall? GINGER PERRY/The Winchester Star Winchester Parking Authority Chairman Richard Helm and Winchester Parking Authority Director Samantha Anderson pose on the seventh floor of the George Washington Autopark in the city’s downtown. Adequate, safe, easy-to-find parking is vital for a business district, according to economic development professionals. ginia Tech. “You need good signage to parking garages and information about where other parking is. People want to be able to find parking quickly, they want to be able to feel safe, and they want it as cheap as humanly possible.” Jim Deskins, Winchester’s economic redevelopment director, agrees. He said downtown parking resources support the city’s financial district, government district, and legal and accounting firms as well as the restaurants and retailers along Loudoun Street Mall. “Parking’s ever ything for commercial space,” Deskins said. “People are not going to come downtown for our nightclubs and restaurants if they don’t have a place to park.” City Manager Dale Iman has seen a lack of adequate parking inhibit the redevelopment of downtown districts, especially in Winchester Star file photo Curbside parking was available for a few cars along Loudoun Street in the 1960s. Knowing that these spaces would be eliminated with the creation of a pedestrian mall, the city formed a Parking Authority that built the city’s first parking garage and created more off-street parking. Fayetteville, N.C., where he worked before coming to Winchester. During his tenure there, steps were taken to rectify a decades-old parking problem. “They’re undergoing a renaissance period,” Iman said, “and the parking has helped.” Wilkins, who has served on both the Parking Authority and City Council, said many people don’t understand how parking spaces are supposed to be used. Garages are the best place for long-term parkers because onstreet spaces should be left open for quick stops. “Your spaces are supposed to turn over,” he said. “I don’t like paying for parking any more than the next guy, but the space in front of your store should turn over 20 or 30 times in a day.” Questions Answers No. 1: The popcorn machine from the Palace Theater, which was destroyed by fire in November 1969. The popper allegedly fell into the basement as a result of the blaze and it was deemed easier to bury than move. No. 2: The Bright Box at 9 and 15 N. Loudoun St. The escalator was part of the Leggett Department Store that formerly occupied the site. When the store moved to Apple Blossom Mall in the early 1980s, the escalator was left behind. It’s now a “funky” staircase, according to Bright Box owner Marilyn Finnemore. No. 3: 10 mph. No. 4: A natural gas explosion destroyed the building, forcing the business to close. No. 5:The Godfrey Miller Home at 28 S. Loudoun St., which was built circa 1785 as a private residence. Today it operates as a senior center. No. 6:Excluding the steeple on the First Presbyterian Church and the theater fly tower behind the former Taylor Hotel, it’s the four-story Winchester Book Gallery at 185 N. Loudoun St. No. 7: Two. First Presbyterian at 116 S. Loudoun St. and Impact Christian Center at 134 N. Loudoun St. No. 8:The Town Run. No. 9: 1744 is when Winchester was founded; 1752 is when it was officially established by an act of the colonial legislature, No. 10: George Washington. The 23-year-old was elected on that date to the Virginia House of Burgesses and served two terms as the Frederick County representative. No. 11: William McKinley. A plaque on the side of the Virginia National Bank building at 186 N. Loudoun St. commemorates the spot where McKinley became a Mason. — Contact Vic Bradshaw at [email protected] Under construction: Life on the mall Test your knowledge about the Loudoun Street Mall by answering the following questions. The answers are at the end. No. 1: An interesting artifact is rumored to be buried beneath the “Palace” parking lot on the mall’s southern end. What is it? No. 2: Name the only building on the mall that has an escalator, though it’s no longer in use. No. 3 As a pedestrian venue, the Loudoun Street Mall is closed to traffic, but delivery trucks are currently still allowed. What’s the speed limit? No. 4: What catastrophic event happened in 1948 at the Raylass Depar tment Store at 134 N. Loudoun St.? No. 5: What’s the oldest original building on the mall? No. 6: What’s the tallest? No. 7: How many places of worship are on the mall? No. 8: What body of water flows underneath the mall? No. 9: Special manhole covers on the mall are embossed with the year 1744, while 1752 is listed on the new gateway entrances. What’s the significance of the two dates? No. 10: What famous politician began his political career on July 24, 1756, on the site of what is now the Old Court House Civil War Museum at 20 N. Loudoun St.? No. 11: What future U.S. president became a Mason on Loudoun Street in 1865? The city subsidized parking for years, according to Richard Helm, the Parking Authority’s chairman. But in recent years the philosophy has shifted more toward having parkers carry the financial load to pay for parking service instead of the greater taxpaying public. Deskins said the construction of parking garages was necessitated because of the presence of Winchester’s National Historic District. Old buildings can’t be torn down to create surface lots, he said, so garages have both met the parking demand and preserved the architecture and character that draws people downtown. Though the city’s four autoparks get heavy use each weekday, the garages only fill to capacity on the Friday and Saturday of the annual Shenandoah Apple Blossom Festival, according to Samantha Anderson, the Parking Authority’s executive director, But usage patterns are changing. Anderson said more people are using the garages while dining or enjoying entertainment downtown, and the increased number of downtown apartments is boosting use by residents. Iman sums it up like this: People are not going to come and enjoy what we have on the Loudoun Street Mall if parking isn’t convenient or if they don’t feel safe getting from parking to the restaurants and shops. “I see the parking structures as a real asset for Old Town Winchester. They’re strategically located in that they provide access from a variety of adjacent locations.” Helm, a commercial real estate agent with the Virginia Property Group, said parking seldom is an issue for clients seeking commercial space downtown. Some “old-school business people” want to see spaces that they control in front of their business, he said, but parking rarely is an issue for most potential tenants from outside the area. “Most of the folks who come in are used to going to the big malls, the big urban centers,” Helm said. “They look around and say parking around here is not a problem.” SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star ABOVE: Monica Schultz of Winchester and her daughter, Lillianna, 5, watch an excavator move from a mound of gravel on the Old Town Mall on Jan. 20. RIGHT: Megan McIntyre stands in front her home in the renovated Solenberger Building in January. LEFT: Luke Bailey, 2, gets a boost from his mother, Megan Bailey, to get a better view of an excavator on Feb. 7. The Baileys are from Winchester. SCOTT MASON The Winchester Star LEFT: Swirls restaurant owner Stephen Furst hands change across the fence on the Loudoun Street Mall to HRI worker Tony Gold after Gold bought lunch from the restaurant. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star RIGHT: Mackenna Bell, 2, and her brother, Jedidiah Bell, 6, look over the fence on the Loudoun Street Mall on Jan. 4 to watch construction workers. Mackenna is held by her father, Daryl Bell. SCOTT MASON/The Winchester Star D8 MONDAY, MAY 20, 2013 THE WINCHESTER STAR THANK YOU CITY OF WINCHESTER for allowing to bring in the New to the Old Town Mall! ounded in 1947, HRI, INC. has continued to evolve from a small, family-owned paving company in State College, Pennyslvania, to a major integrated construction company working throughout the region and beyond. Today, as a part of the multi-national corporation Colas SA, we have the support of a global organization dedicated to all aspects of the industry. HRI delivers diverse, cost-effective construction solutions, along with innovative asphalt and emulsion products. F NO PROJECT TOO SMALL OR TOO LARGE! UTILITIES HRI has a large and diverse portfolio of projects completed. Included are water sewer lines, pumping stations, water and wastewater treatment plants, boring and jacking, directional drilling, pipe bursting, video inspection service and more. Projects vary in size from several thousand dollars to multimillion dollar pipeline and treatment plant work. HEAVY & HIGHWAY CONSTRUCTION The diversity of HRI makes it possible to include all aspects of site development with heavy highway construction services, which include small to large bridge construction and mass earth moving capabilities. HRI SPECIALTIES INCLUDE: – Bridges & Culverts – Chip Seal – Clearing & Grubbing – Concrete & Concrete Paving – Erosion & Sedimentation Control – Excavation & Embankments – Grading – Landfill Construction – Retaining & Sound Walls – Sewage Treatment Plants – Site Development – Stone Bases & Storm Basins – Utility Installation – Water Treatment Plants – Well Pads – Wetland Construction CORPORATE OFFICE WINCHESTER OFFICE 1750 West College Avenue, State College, PA 16801 T 877.HRI.9999 (877.474.9999) E [email protected] 2273 Valley Avenue, Winchester, VA 22601 T 540.665.9570 E [email protected] WWW.HRIINC.COM