EXPERIENCE MAKES FOR A STRONGER TAILWIND
Transcription
EXPERIENCE MAKES FOR A STRONGER TAILWIND
EXPERIENCE MAKES FOR A STRONGER TAILWIND 2013 CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS EXPERIENCE MAKES FOR A STRONGER TAILWIND Letter from Richard H. Anderson, CEO............................................................................................................................................ 3 About Delta...............................................................................................................................................................................................4 GOVERNANCE .................................................................................................................................................................... 5 ENVIRONMENT ................................................................................................................................................................ 8 COMMUNITY .....................................................................................................................................................................22 SUPPLY CHAIN ................................................................................................................................................................28 EMPLOYEES ............................................................................................................................................................................31 CUSTOMERS ....................................................................................................................................................................... 44 INVESTORS . .......................................................................................................................................................................... 54 AWARDS AND RECOGNITION .............................................................................................................59 APPENDIX GRI 3.1 Indicators...................................................................................................................................................................................62 Reconciliation of GAAP Financial Measures to Non-GAAP Financial Measures.......................................................... 66 ABOUT THIS REPORT This report describes Delta Air Lines, Inc.’s corporate responsibility activities and performance since the last report, the 2012 Delta Corporate Responsibility Report. Data included in this report are from the year 2013, unless otherwise noted. Delta self-declares this report to meet application level B of the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) G3.1 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines. This year’s report covers Delta’s mainline operations in the United States; regional carriers and international facilities are not included in this report unless otherwise noted. For more information about this report, please contact Helen Howes, Managing Director – Safety, Health and Environment, Delta Air Lines, Inc., 1020 Delta Boulevard, Atlanta, GA, 30354, email: [email protected] 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 2 A MESSAGE FROM RICHARD Our core commitment at Delta is providing customers with safe, comfortable and efficient air travel. We are a values-based business and focus all of our long-term, strategic decisions on building and maintaining a sustainable business for our employees, our customers and our shareowners. This commitment naturally extends to the communities in which Delta people live and work. Through teamwork and a commitment to common values and goals, Delta in 2013 reported a $2.7 billion profit, excluding special items; paid more than $500 million in profit sharing for Delta people; and provided a $350 million return of capital to our shareholders. Delta was listed once again on the S&P 500; delivered operational performance that is unheard of in our industry with 99.7 percent completion factor and 84.5 percent on-time arrival; and made sweeping investments to our fleet and operations as well as in select international partnerships including Virgin Atlantic, GOL and Aeromexico to improve the Delta experience for our customers. We also focused on continuous improvement in other areas. In 2013, Delta: • Introduced the first of 100 Boeing 737-900ERs which are expected to burn a quarter less fuel than the aircraft they replace • Reduced our employee injury rate by 11 percent relative to 2012 levels • Reduced billed water consumption by 10 percent and improved estimates of customer and employee water consumption at our airport facilities • Provided more than 60,000 Delta employees (as of January 2014) with better tools for identifying and reporting suspected instances of human trafficking through the Department of Homeland Security’s Blue Lightning training program Among the core values outlined in Delta’s Rules of the Road is caring for our customers, our community and each other. This dedication to servant leadership extends globally. Delta donates thousands of hours and millions of dollars as part of our Force for Global Good to a host of philanthropic causes, including the American Red Cross, Breast Cancer Research Foundation (BCRF), United Way and Habitat for Humanity, among others. In addition to this report, you can find more information about our commitment to the places we serve and the people who live there at delta.com/responsibility. Thanks, and we look forward to seeing you on your next Delta flight. Chief Executive Officer Delta Air Lines, Inc. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 3 ABOUT DELTA WORLDWIDE SERVICE Delta Air Lines serves nearly 165 million customers each year. With an industry-leading global network, Delta and the Delta Connection carriers offer peak-day service to 340 destinations in 64 countries on six continents. Headquartered in Atlanta, Delta employs nearly 80,000 employees worldwide and operates a combined fleet of nearly 1,300 aircraft. The airline is a founding member of the SkyTeam global alliance and participates in the industry’s leading trans-Atlantic joint venture with Air France-KLM and Alitalia as well as a newly formed joint venture with Virgin Atlantic. Including its worldwide alliance partners, Delta offers customers more than 15,000 daily flights, with hubs in Amsterdam, Atlanta, Cincinnati, Detroit, Minneapolis-St. Paul, New YorkLaGuardia, New York-JFK, Paris-Charles de Gaulle, Salt Lake City and Tokyo-Narita. Delta has invested billions of dollars in airport facilities and global products, services and technology to enhance the customer experience in the air and on the ground. Additional information is available on delta.com, Twitter @Delta, Google.com/+Delta, Facebook.com/delta and Delta’s blog takingoff.delta.com. 100 positive things This report features that Delta has done regarding the environment, communities, its supply chain, customers and investors. Look for these highlighted throughout the report. 100 things 01 KEY FIGURES Nearly 165 Million Customers Served About 80,000 Employees Worldwide 1,300 Aircraft in Combined Operation 340 Destinations 64 Countries 245 Domestic U.S. & Canada Destinations 47 Latin America Destinations 34 Europe, Middle East & Africa Destinations 14 Asia Pacific Destinations 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 4 GOVERNANCE 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 5 Strong core values and a clear set of unifying behaviors provide a solid foundation for Delta’s culture. Our values are the basis for everything we do. When Delta people encounter situations, they use their values and professionalism, along with training and experience to guide their actions and decisions. These core values make up Delta’s Rules of the Road. BOARD OF DIRECTORS The Board of Directors held six regular meetings in 2013, scheduled special meetings when required, and also met in executive session without management. The Board believes sound corporate governance practices provide an important framework in assisting to discharge responsibilities. Accordingly, the Board has adopted corporate governance principles relating to its functions, structure, and operations. Currently, the Board is made up of 14 members, 11 of whom are independent. RULES OF THE ROAD 02 Delta’s Core Values HONESTY | Always tell the truth INTEGRITY | Always keep your deals RESPECT | Don’t hurt anyone PERSEVERANCE | Try harder than all our competitors—never give up SUSTAINABILITY AT DELTA At Delta, sustainability is defined as “meeting the company’s financial goals of growth and profitability over time, through business practices that minimize the environmental impacts of our operations and promote the health, welfare, and productivity of the individuals and communities we employ and serve.” SERVANT LEADERSHIP | Care for our customers, our community and each other To meet this definition of sustainability, Delta does more than simply satisfy its legal obligations. Delta’s stakeholders - investors, customers, SkyTeam partners, employees, NGOs, governments, and communities have come to expect Delta to produce sustainable positive financial results, invest in healthy communities, maintain a robust workforce and protect natural environments. Collectively, these expectations drive Delta’s approach to sustainability and social responsibility. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 6 EXECUTIVE ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP COUNCIL (EELC) Delta’s EELC establishes, develops and supports implementation of the airline’s environmental sustainability policy and strategy. The Council meets at least three times a year and consists of key leaders from various departments that play a role in determining Delta’s strategy and policy related to sustainability. In 2013, the EELC oversaw the company’s management of the following issues: • Industry engagement on climate change policy at the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) 38th Assembly • Compliance with European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) and French CO2 reporting • Performance against our fuel efficiency goal • Climate change and biofuel strategy and planning • Customer and employee engagement on sustainability establishes, develops and supports • Environmental partnerships, specifically Delta’s carbon offset implementation of environmental offering through The Nature Conservancy (TNC) partnership sustainability policy and strategy. • Sustainability reporting and disclosures through the Corporate Responsibility Report, the CDP, and the Dow Jones Sustainability Index 03 DELTA’S EXECUTIVE ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP COUNCIL EELC Members are senior leaders from the following departments: • Chief Operating Officer • Airport Customer Service and Tech Ops • Corporate Communications • Corporate Real Estate • E-Commerce • Finance • Fleet Strategy and Transactions • Flight Operations • Fuel Optimization • Government Affairs • Legal • Marketing • Safety, Health and Environment • Safety, Security and Compliance • Supply Chain Management 04 Delta participated in the SASB (Sustainability Accounting Standards Board) industry working group to provide feedback on disclosure items that are considered material issues to the airlines. ENTERPRISE RISK MANAGEMENT Delta’s Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) process is designed to provide a framework for risk management for Delta. The ERM system helps assess significant risks that could prevent Delta from achieving its overall objectives, identify and document strategies to mitigate these risks and monitor progress against the mitigation strategies. ERM activities include supporting management’s ERM process, documenting risk assessments utilizing a consistent framework, identifying and evaluating risk mitigation activities and controls, and reporting objectively on the results of risk evaluations. Delta conducts a combination of inquiry, observation, inspection, and re-performance testing to establish whether the controls and processes are mitigating risks as designed. Summary reports are issued to Delta’s Corporate Leadership Team for each study completed to indicate the effectiveness of controls and risk mitigation activities for the business process in review. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 7 ENVIRONMENT “We’re always focused on the future at Delta and continue to promote a transparent business model that we believe will improve our sustainability for many years to come. That includes air traffic initiatives, green practices at our airports and other facilities, fleet renewals and a robust recycling program both in the air and on the ground, among other initiatives. We continue to verify our complete greenhouse gas emissions inventory verified under The Climate Registry and have been named to Dow Jones Sustainability North American Index three years in a row.” -- John Laughter - senior vice president, Corporate Safety, Security and Compliance 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 8 2013 GOALS Notices of Violations...ACHIEVED Non-Compliance/Permit Exceedences...DID NOT MEET STRETCH GOAL Spills...DID NOT MEET Achieve 1.5% fuel efficiency improvement...IN PROGRESS Reduce greenhouse gas emissions below 2012 levels...MET WITH USE OF CARBON OFFSETS 2014 GOALS Achieve 1.5% fuel efficiency improvement Reduce electricity consumption at selected Atlanta facilities by 10% Set and achieve a water reduction goal for Atlanta TechOps Meet Environmental Goals for Notices of Violations (2), NonCompliance/Permit Exceedences (4), Spills (69) Reduce greenhouse gas emissions below 2013 levels ENSURING ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE Delta is committed to minimizing its impact on the environment by conducting operations in an environmentally sustainable manner. As a minimum requirement, the airline works to comply with all environmental laws and regulations which govern our industry. In the absence of government regulation, Delta follows the best practices of the aviation industry. This is accomplished through setting environmental performance goals with the operating divisions, measuring and reporting progress to leaders in these respective divisions on a monthly and quarterly basis, and sharing relevant information with customers and external stakeholders on an annual basis. Another effective method to ensure compliance is the development of a robust environmental audit program that promotes accountability and environmental awareness throughout Delta’s operations. The audit team’s findings, concerns and observations are communicated to station and divisional leaders so that improvements can be implemented at stations and maintenance facilities. Delta has developed several environmental management tools to improve environmental compliance and awareness. The Environmental Programs Manual provides policies and procedures for compliance with all applicable environmental regulations. In developing and frequently updating this manual, applicable federal, state and local environmental regulations are reviewed to establish a consistent set of guidelines for Delta’s operations. The Environmental Management System helps all stations maintain compliance with environmental requirements and includes the company’s environmental policy, objectives and targets, roles and responsibilities, operating procedures, and inspection and document control requirements. Additionally, the Environmental Management Information System (EMIS) is a computer-based system that manages environmental data, improves compliance and support environmental programs and processes across the company. This system is configured from the corporate level down to the station level and is available to track and report compliance task completion by corporate, operational and station leaders. A final element in maintaining environmental compliance is the day-today management responsibilities of the environmental coordinators in airport locations and maintenance departments, who ensure compliance with environmental requirements associated with their operations and Based on Delta’s fleet as activities. Their responsibilities range from conducting daily, weekly or of Dec. 31, 2013, 79 percent of monthly inspections and recordkeeping, performing on-call spill response aircraft meet Stage 4 criteria - the and reporting, ensuring staff with assigned environmental tasks are trained, quietest aircraft category. acting as a liaison to airport environmental staff, overseeing contractors whose actions may impact the environment, escorting regulatory authorities during an inspection, coordinating and communicating environmental responsibilities among operating divisions, and meeting regularly with station or division leadership to discuss environmental programs and make improvements. 05 NOTICES OF VIOLATIONS/NON-COMPLIANCES Four notices of violations (NOV) and five non-compliance incidents were received from environmental regulatory agencies in 2013. The NOV goal (four) was achieved but the non-compliance goal (zero) was not achieved. One NOV, which resulted in a monetary penalty of $8,500, was associated with petroleum storage tank compliance requirements at New-York LaGuardia. The second NOV, received in Los Angeles, was associated with hazardous waste management practices and the penalty was $12,000. All four NOVs were promptly resolved through the appropriate regulatory authority and practices have been established to address reoccurrence. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 9 In 2013, Delta received a total of five additional notices that permit conditions had been exceeded. This is an increase of three noncompliance incidents over 2012 and several were administrative in nature or associated with permit limits. NOTICE OF VIOLATIONS 2011 2012 2013 Notice of Violation N/A 4 4 Non-Compliance/Permit Exceedences N/A 3 0 Notice of Violation 9 6 4 Non-Compliance/Permit Exceedences 2 2 5 Monetary Value ($) of significant fines $630* $2,000 $20,500 GOALS PERFORMANCE * plus “annual emission fee of 1.5 times the actual emissions for 2012” for Minneapolis and Minneapolis Building J MANAGING SPILLS Delta sets a spill goal for each of the following divisions: Airport Customer Service; Corporate Real Estate; Safety, Health and Environment; and Technical Operations. Performance is tracked against these individual goals to determine Delta’s progress in minimizing its environmental footprint. While Delta is committed to reducing and eliminating the potential for spills, the company saw an increase in Class I Spills this year. The airline accepts the responsibility to not only clean up spills and respond to any impacted environmental media, but also report to state and/or federal regulatory agencies. Delta’s lavatory, Ground Support Equipment (GSE) and deicing operations saw 19 more spills in 2013 compared to 2012. 06 To address spills, the INCIDENT RESPONSE TEAM will meet with the incident station for all Class I spills to identify the root cause, contributing factors and corrective actions. In response, Delta is partnering with GSE to identify and replace parts on support vehicles that have a manufactured shelf life, such as hydraulic hoses, even if they appear to be in good condition. The Incident Response Team will meet with the incident station for all Class I spills to identify root cause, contributing factors and corrective actions. These meetings will help to identify not only station specific issues, but also potentially regional or systemic concerns where preemptive action can be taken to avoid similar spill scenarios. SPILLS 2011 2012 2013 GOALS Spills (Class I + Class II) 55 PERFORMANCE 30 28 35 Class II 46 42 43 Total Spills (Class I + Class II) 76 70 78 Regulatory Reportable3 16 18 17 Class I1 2 1. Class I: any spill that reaches soil and/or water and/or any spill equal to or greater than 25 gallons. 2. Class II: any spill that is equal to or more than 5 gallons, but less than 25 gallons and does not reach soil and/or water. 3. Spill that is reported to a regulatory authority under local, state or federal spill reporting guidelines. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 10 IMPROVING AIR QUALITY In an effort towards continuous improvement, Delta contracts with certified professional environmental auditors to review its station compliance programs with a focus on local requirements according to all state, city, county and district regulations that impact the airline’s operations. These third party reviews provide a multi-media inspection of records and work practices that help Delta remain compliant. As a result of one such review, the New York-LaGuardia station recognized the need to register certain pieces of combustion equipment with the NYC Department of Environmental Protection as part of a local environmental requirement they were not previously aware of. Delta operations are now in full compliance with this local rule, and will continue to respond to similar reviews in order to update compliance measures. The following table shows a summary of criteria pollutant emissions from Atlanta, Minneapolis, Detroit, Cincinnati and Los Angeles. These locations are included because an annual inventory is filed with the respective states, providing a breakdown of estimated emissions. The Delta Atlanta Technical Operations Center contributes the majority of emissions within the Delta operations for these five pollutants. The VOC emissions increase in 2013 is driven by miscellaneous material usage in Atlanta, which accounts for 90 percent of total VOC emissions. VOC emissions from miscellaneous material usage in 2012 were low compared to previous years, thus 2013 emission levels are more in line with recent trends. EMISSIONS (tons/year) CO emissions NOx emissions PM emissions SO2 emissions VOC emissions 2011 63.4 131.3 13.9 14.8 208.7 ENCOURAGING ALTERNATIVE COMMUTES Delta engages its employees on clean commute options in an effort to improve air quality in local areas of operation. Flexible work options, alternative commutes and on-site amenities are offered to encourage employees to reduce vehicles miles traveled. These include: • Teleworking: work at home for a certain number of days a month •C ompressed Work Week: longer work days in exchange for a day off in the same pay period • F lextime: variation of a normal eight-hour day in order to avoid peak-hour traffic and improve air quality •C ommuter Benefits Program: allows employees to pay for eligible commuting costs through automatic, pre-tax payroll deductions •O n-site amenities at World Headquarters: gym, cafeteria, dry cleaning, walk-in clinic, Walmart, Starbucks, farmers market during summer months 2012 57.9 122.2 12.9 14.3 183.6 2013 56.6 124.8 11.6 13.0 261.6 No-idle program 07 to improve indoor and outdoor air quality. In partnership with The Clean Air Campaign, a “No-Idle Program” was implemented to improve air quality at the Cargo facility in Atlanta. Signs posted throughout the cargo warehouse and on ground service equipment vehicles notify employees and customers to turn off their engines to avoid unnecessary idling whenever possible. 08 Because Delta is a 24/7 operation with shift work, Delta works with Delta won the Georgia Commute local transportation management associations to promote alternative Options award for “Best Overall commutes in the most effective way for employees in many locations: Program - Large Employer.” • A Clean Air Campaign Task Force with representatives from each operating division in Atlanta meets on a quarterly basis to discuss the best way to overcome the challenges related to promoting alternative commutes to airport employees. As a result of the task force efforts to create tailored communication 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 11 and events, Delta won the Georgia Commute Options “Best Overall Program - Large Employer.” • Delta’s IT Green Initiatives Group supports Delta’s relationship with MetroTransit in Minneapolis by planning events for employees to talk directly with MetroTransit about alternative commute options that would work for them. In 2013, a zip code party was hosted to visualize options for carpooling and vanpooling with other employees who live in the same area. • The monthly “Hubbub” newsletter sent to all employees in Salt Lake City features TravelWise options for public transport to and from SLC airport. MINIMIZING WASTE Hazardous waste volumes generated by routine operations decreased in 2013 from previous years. Total non-hazardous waste volumes (landfilled, incinerated and recycled) decreased three percent from 2012. In an effort to decrease hazardous and nonhazardous waste, waste minimization plans were developed for two of the largest stations, Atlanta and Detroit. These plans will be implemented and evaluated in 2014, and a new plan will be drafted for an additional station. WASTE 2011 2012 2013 609 638 591 0 0 2291 Landfilled or Incinerated 615 Recycled 850 1,045 946 1,105 827 0 21,9882 0 HAZARDOUS WASTE in tons Total Generated Construction Debris NON-HAZARDOUS WASTE in tons Construction Debris One time construction project at LaGuardia International Airport 1 One time construction projects in Memphis and Detroit 2 DIVERTING WASTE IN-FLIGHT RECYCLING Launched in 2007, Delta’s In-Flight Recycling Program has since expanded to 27 domestic locations and one international location. Between 2007 and 2013, more than 8.5 million pounds of materials have been diverted from landfills. Five Habitat for Humanity homes have been funded by the $500,000 in rebates from plastic, aluminum and paper recycled on board. The fifth Habitat for Humanity home funded completely by in-flight recycling rebates was constructed in Seattle, Wash. in October 2013. Recycling volumes have remained steady since 2009, though region-specific requirements and poor tracking of recycling volumes have posed challenges along the way. Despite this, Delta continuously seeks to expand its in-flight recycling program beyond its large domestic stations by adding new stations and working with recycling service providers and airport authorities to receive better visibility to volumes that Delta passengers, business partners, and employees collect for recycling. 09 2011 2012 2013 27 stations 29 stations 28 stations RECYCLABLES (in tons) ALUMINIUM IN-F REC LIGHT Y PRO CLING GRA M 478 596 704 $118,153 $130,593 $115,642 tons in flight rebates tons in flight rebates PLASTICS 154 174 139 42 42 24 2011 2011 2012 2013 2012 2013 PAPER CO-MINGLED tons in flight rebates 256 334 61 26 46 480 } 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 12 2011 2012 2013 2011 2012 2013 INTERNATIONAL ON-BOARD RECYCLING One of the challenges of international recycling is that materials contaminated with dairy, meat, and/or produce are considered “regulated garbage” and must be incinerated or autoclaved. Recent discussions with Atlanta Customs indicate the future possibility of recycling aluminum cans that are not contaminated with these materials. To address the issue of international recycling, London Heathrow International Airport, the International Air Transport Association (IATA), and outside consultants launched a cabin waste study among several international airlines that fly into London Heathrow regularly. The study was prompted by increased landfill disposal costs in London and the desire by the airport to seek alternatives to landfilling international waste. The two flights chosen for this study were DL 84 and DL 10 from Atlanta to Heathrow on Oct. 23, 2013. Corporate Environment and Onboard Services led the effort by briefing flight attendants, local Catering and Cabin Service on the collection process. Outside consultants collected cabin waste data from these flights, as well as other carrier flights involved in the study. The data from the audit are being analyzed and next steps are being discussed. AIRPORT PARTNERSHIPS Delta in LaGuardia teamed up with the airport’s food and beverage operator, OTG, to divert waste where possible. Since March 2013, 2,100 gallons of waste oil has been collected and sent to be converted to biodiesel fuel, and 7,965 pounds of food waste have been collected for recycling. Rebates received from these processes are donated to the Delta Employee and Retiree Care Fund. Carpet from the aircraft is recycled and burned for energy. 363 TONS 12 10 Recycling ATLANTA EMPLOYEE RECYCLING CENTER have been converted to energy from 2011 through 2013 By the end of 2014, all of Delta’s 11,000 pilots will swap their 38-pound pilot flight bags for Microsoft Surface 2 tablets that will provide quick and easy access to flight information, charts, weather products and navigation utilities. The Surface 2 devices are expected to save 7.5 million sheets of paper, save $13 million a year in reduced fuel burn and other associated costs, and prevent the release of 12,500 tons of carbon annually. 11 allows employees without access to curbside recycling to bring their aluminum cans, plastic bottles, glass, tin and paper to be recycled at the Headquarters. Rebates are donated to the Delta Employee & Retiree Care to help individuals who 2011 Fund suffer from severe financial 440 tons/$22,162 hardship from unforeseen 2012 and unavoidable crisis, such 381 tons/$609 as Hurricane Sandy. The 2013 reduction in ERC recycling in 2013 is likely due to a new 256 tons/$5,754 residential curbside recycling program launched by the City of Atlanta at the end of 2012. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 13 13 up cycle used safety vests Customer Service operations in Atlanta donated approximately 400 used safety vests to the weavers of re:loom. 16 Sensitive documents are shredded and recycled by In 2013, IRON MOUNTAIN . 506 TONS of paper were recycled through this program. 14 Due to sustainable re-upholstery practices, the seats of ground support equipment can be reused, rather than replaced. 15 GOING GREEN WITH COFFEE GROUNDS In Atlanta and Minneapolis, Delta partnered with catering vendor Sodexo to allow employees to pick up used coffee grounds for their gardens. This initiative diverts an estimated 75 pounds of waste at the Atlanta campus each week. UPCYCLING USED SAFETY VESTS Customer Service operations in Atlanta donates used safety vests to the weavers of re:loom, who upcycle the vests into tablet cases, passport covers and clutches that are available for sale. A program of the Initiative for Affordable Housing, re:loom supports homeless and low-income adults in the metro Atlanta area by training them to weave original products out of upcycled materials. The weavers receive a stable salary and full healthcare coverage, and the organization takes donations of textiles in an effort to divert waste. LEATHER SEATS UPGRADED TO WITHSTAND THE HEAT The black seats on ground support equipment in Tucson typically measure between 250-260º Fahrenheit in the extreme summer heat. As a result, the seats would start to crack after four to five months. Employees in Tucson replaced the seats in white Marine type leather, which are significantly cooler, clocking in between 120-160 Fahrenheit. These seats are re-upholstered as necessary (about every two years) and no seats have been thrown away in 10 years. Due to the success of this project, seats in Phoenix are brought down to Tucson where the seat replacement process is implemented. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 14 ASSESSING WATER IMPACT With the growing global concerns about water scarcity, Delta’s operation recognizes a responsibility to conserve water wherever and whenever possible. Water usage is metered and billed at Atlanta and Minneapolis Technical Operations, along with the Atlanta General Office, and accounts for approximately 39 percent of Delta’s water usage. From 2012 to 2013, Delta decreased its total billed water usage by nearly 10 percent, or 22 million gallons. DAILY WATER CONSUMPTION (for employees and passengers per the U.S. Green Building Council) 6.15 gallons 7.35 gallons 0.69 gallons 0.93 gallons Employees Passengers BILLED WATER CONSUMPTION (in gallons) Because Delta does not receive bills for water usage at airports, total consumption is estimated. An airport-focused water estimation calculator, which was developed based on U.S. Green Building Council guidance, was used to estimate passenger and employee water consumption at Delta’s U.S. airport facilities. 2011 2012 2013 274,582,800.5 225,010,975.5 203,021,010 Delta employees and passengers at U.S. airports consumed more than 320 million gallons of water, representing approximately 61 percent of the total domestic water consumption. In total, more than 523 million gallons were consumed in 2013 across airport and owned facilities. Further work will be done to validate this estimate. 17 From 2012 to 2013, Delta DECREASED its total billed WATER USAGE by nearly 10%, or 22 MILLION GALLONS. Note that in the 2012 Corporate Responsibility Report, an estimate of 640 million gallons of water consumed was attributed to Delta passengers alone. This estimate was derived using the American Water Works Association’s guidance on daily consumption of four gallons per day. The 2013 estimation tool estimated transient consumption, and is a more accurate estimate of passenger consumption at between 0.69 and 0.93 gallons per day. This change in estimating methodology had a material impact on the estimated domestic water footprint for 2013. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 15 18 THE INDUSTRY, DELTA AND CLIMATE CHANGE Delta played a substantial role in helping drive positive outcomes from the 38th ICAO Assembly in Montreal. The International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) is a branch of the United Nations that establishes standards and guidelines for international air transport to ensure safe and orderly growth for the ICAO member states. The International Air Transport Association (IATA), the largest global airline trade association in the world, interacts with ICAO by contributing to the various ICAO technical panels and has been granted permanent observer status to ICAO. Based on input from IATA, the 38th ICAO Assembly made significant progress on the issue of climate change and the role that market-based measures (MBMs) will play under a global climate change scheme for aviation. Before the Assembly concluded in Montreal on October 4, 2013, representatives unanimously decided to develop a global MBM for international aviation emissions, leaving it up to the 2016 Assembly to flesh out details and a plan to implement it in 2020. ALIGNED with IATA, 19 Delta’s goal is to improve annual fuel efficiency by an average of 1.5 percent a year between 2009 and 2020. In June 2013, the IATA 69th Annual General Meeting overwhelmingly endorsed a resolution on “Implementation of the Aviation Carbon-Neutral Growth (CNG2020) Strategy.” The resolution provides governments with a set of principles on how they can establish and integrate procedures for a single MBM as part of an overall package of measures to achieve CNG2020. Delta played a substantial role in helping to drive these positive outcomes. RESPONSIBILITY AND RISKS REGARDING CLIMATE CHANGE Delta implemented a comprehensive Climate Change Strategy in 2010, which was approved by the EELC and the CEO. The Strategy is reviewed and revised annually, and the EELC receives updates at least twice per year on the status of progress made on actions identified in the Climate Change Strategic Plan, which has driven the integration of climate change policy, legislative, and regulatory risks into various business analysis and planning processes. Delta is also participating in an Airport Cooperative Research Program (ACRP) panel on climate change risk assessment and adaptation at airports. The panel supports the development of a tool tailored for airports and airline industry stakeholders to assess the risks and plan for adapting to climate change. In the future, the intention is to take this tool, or subsequent iterations tailored for airlines, and use it to conduct a targeted, comprehensive climate change risk assessment for Delta. Delta participated in multiple events hosted by the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions (C2ES), which focused heavily on climate change resilience in 2013. Delta participated in C2ES webinars on the following topics: • The latest in climate science, in anticipation of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) releasing the first segment of its Fifth Assessment Report • Planning for Climate Resilience, intended as a follow-up to the building climate resiliency report C2ES published in August • Building Business Resiliency to Climate Change Delta also participated in the quarterly C2ES Business Environmental Leadership Council meetings, as well as a policy discussion on the Renewable Fuel Standard. REGULATORY RISKS AND ASSOCIATED COSTS IATA has prepared marginal abatement cost curves at the industry level, which Delta uses to help guide policy decisions and advocate cost-effective options for emissions reductions. In addition to the cost of fuel, Delta has incorporated current CO2 emissions 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 16 costs into business decisions regarding routes to/from countries within the European Union to ensure compliance with the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) as well as future expectations of CO2 emissions costs into decisions for future aircraft purchases. In the event that legislation or regulation is enacted in the U.S. or in the event similar legislation or regulation is enacted in jurisdictions where Delta operates, other than the EU, it could result in significant costs to Delta. OPPORTUNITIES FOR INNOVATION: EXPLORING BIOFUELS Delta’s biggest driver for exploring biofuel alternatives is the reality of its carbon footprint and industry climate change goals. To address greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, the airline remains committed to a global sectoral approach put forth by the International Air Transport Association (IATA). Delta supports the aviation industry’s emissions reduction goals through IATA’s four pillars strategy, which Led by KLM, Delta participated in the includes technology enhancements, such as deployment of alternative launch of the first-ever series of biofuelfuels. 20 powered intercontinental flights. TRAINER REFINERY In late 2012, a Delta subsidiary acquired a refinery in Trainer, Pa. The refinery asset secures a less expensive jet fuel supply into our top priority NYC markets. Furthermore, it potentially affords Delta a unique opportunity among airlines to blend and refine biofuels. A cross-functional team continues to actively screen and study potential petroleum fuel substitutes that are in late-stage technology development and assess any realistic opportunities for engagement. 21 biofuel DETROIT BIOFUEL INITIATIVE In the fall of 2012, Detroit launched a pilot project using biodiesel (B5) in six of the deicer trucks. Results of that pilot showed measurable cost and emissions reductions, with no issues relating to fuel reliability or quality concerns. In 2013, the program was scaled up to include the full deicer fleet of 31 trucks, with an estimated CO2 emissions reduction of 35 metric tons for the full deicing season. JFK GREEN LANE PROGRAM Delta joined KLM, Sky NRG, the Schiphol Group and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) in the launch of the first-ever series of biofuel-powered intercontinental flights. This 26-week pilot program, undertaken by KLM, involved weekly flights using a blend of biofuel derived from used cooking oil or camelina with conventional jet fuel. Between March 8 and Aug. 22, 2013, a total of 26 KLM flights were fueled with sustainable biojet fuel; one from Schiphol airport to JFK airport and 25 from JFK airport to Schiphol airport. The estimated greenhouse gas emissions savings relative to conventional jet fuel is between 70 percent and 80 percent for the bio-portion of the jet fuel blend. This program successfully demonstrated the feasibility of flying regular scheduled flights on sustainable jet fuel. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 17 FOCUSING ON CARBON EMISSIONS Delta calculates and verifies a complete greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions inventory1 in an effort to manage all sources of carbon. Since 2005, Delta has reduced its annual emissions (Scope 1, 2 and 3) by 7.9 million metric tons, a 17.2 percent reduction over eight years. On an absolute basis, Delta saw a 550,000 metric ton (1.5 percent) increase of carbon emissions in 2013 compared to 2012 due to more flying. Delta is exploring the possibility of retiring a block of carbon credits against the 2013 inventory which would result in a 0.6 percent emissions reduction compared to 2012. TOTAL GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS 2013 EMISSIONS (in metric tons) (in metric tons) GROUND SUPPORT EQUIPMENT 0.3% 46,372,657 38,614,756 38,248,968 37,685,493 37,460,492 OTHER 0.2% AIRCRAFT EMISSIONS: REGIONAL AIRCRAFT + DELTA PRIVATE JETS 17.2% ELECTRICITY 0.9% AIRCRAFT EMISSIONS: MAINLINE 81.4% 2005 2011 2012 2013 2013 with offsets AIRCRAFT EMISSIONS (in metric tons) 7,391,313 7,137,858 6,787,188 6,565,279 38,158,942 30,867,313 30,359,915 31,159,188 2005 2011 2012 2013 Regional + Delta Jets Mainline AIRCRAFT EMISSIONS More than 98.5 percent of Delta’s footprint is due to emissions from mainline and regional aircraft. Both are included in the inventory to ensure emissions reductions for Delta are not realized merely by moving flights from mainline to regional – all fuel consumed on behalf of Delta is accounted for. OTHER SOURCES OTHER SOURCES The other 1.5 percent of Delta’s footprint is comprised of electricity (at owned and leased facilities), ground support equipment, refrigerants, chemicals and stationary combustion equipment. TRAINER EMISSIONS In 2013, Delta’s full inventory will also include the emissions from Trainer, a refinery operated by a whollyowned subsidiary. Most of Trainer’s emissions as reported under the Environmental Protection Agency’s Mandatory Reporting Rule are available at epa.gov/ ghgreporting. (in metric tons) 600,000 Emergency Gen/FirePumps Refrigerants Chemicals Stat Combust Facilities GSE Electricity 0 2005 2011 2012 2013 Delta’s GHG emissions inventory follows guidance set out in The Climate Registry’s General Reporting Protocol and emissions factors from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Guidelines 1 for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. Delta’s full inventory from 2005 onward is available on The Climate Registry’s Member Reports website. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 18 FUEL EFFICIENCY In addition to calculating emissions on an absolute basis, fuel efficiency is tracked as liters of fuel consumed per 100 revenue tonnekilometers. Aligned with IATA, Delta’s goal is to improve annual fuel efficiency by an average of 1.5 percent a year between 2009 and 2020. This means using an average of 1.5 percent less fuel to transport the same weight the same distance, every year from 2009 until 2020. 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Total Fuel Consumed (liters) 14,655,267,563 14,464,872,741 14,584,619,038 14,252,065,385 14,477,609,330 Weight transported1 33,778,915,200 34,434,525,639 34,545,872,861 34,628,843,557 34,844,652,685 43.39 42.01 42.22 41.16 41.55 3.18% 1.35% 1.7% 1.06% 1 Fuel used to transport 100 revenue tonne kilometers (I/100RTK) Average Annual Fuel Efficiency Improvement since 2009 (IATA goal of 1.5%) 1 Mainline and regional flights. During 2012, Delta was using an average of 1.7 percent less fuel to transport 100 tonnes a distance of 1 kilometer, exceeding the IATA goal of 1.5 percent. In order to maintain a 1.5 percent average annual improvement, fuel usage had to decrease, load factors had to increase, or a combination of both needed to occur. CONVERTING TO ELECTRIC GROUND SUPPORT EQUIPMENT 22 In partnership with the Center for Transportation and Environment and Clean Cities-Georgia, Delta transformed While passenger and cargo loads transported increased by 0.62 percent for 2013, this was not enough to offset the 1.58 percent fuel increase and maintain a 1.5 percent annual efficiency improvement average. Delta ended the year with an average 1.06 percent fuel efficiency improvement since 2009 and is not currently meeting the IATA goal. 11 In 2014, the delivery of the 110-seat Boeing 717-200s to replace 50-seat jets will result in upgauging that will provide fuel savings and efficiency improvements by operating one flight instead of two while maintaining the same capacity currently available. In addition, Delta’s Fleet Committee and Fuel Council will continue to address efficiency in aircraft and champion potential fuel savings initiatives that can be implemented. from diesel to electric-powered machines under the Diesel Emissions Reduction Act. The expected savings from this project total more than 100,000 gallons of diesel fuel and 575 tons of emissions annually. container loaders belt loaders & 24 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 19 23–29 IN AN EFFORT TO REDUCE THE NEARLY 4 BILLION GALLONS FUEL SAVINGS To reduce Delta’s carbon emissions on an absolute, per revenue and per revenue tonne kilometer basis, aggressive fuel savings initiatives are tracked in an effort to reduce the near 4 billion gallons of jet fuel that accounts for more than 98.5 percent of Delta’s annual carbon footprint. of jet fuel Delta consumes a year, 20 aggressive fuel savings initiatives were tracked in 2013. FLIGHT PLANNING Flight planning initiatives provided the greatest fuel savings to Delta in 2013. AttillaTM Managed Arrivals System ensures an even flow of Delta arrivals, thus reducing hold times and saving fuel. In Detroit and Minneapolis, planning saved 1.6 million gallons of fuel. Other initiatives, such as using child weights during fuel planning, route efficiencies, and adjusting the MD-88 and MD-90 low fuel warning to illuminate at 2,000 pounds instead of 2,500 pounds, have led to savings of more than 5 million gallons of fuel. TAXI Although fuel use during taxi time is a small percentage of overall consumption, the impact is compounded when applied across all flights, all year. In 2013, use of single-engine taxi on A319, A320, and B757 aircraft, along with taxi time savings on mainline flights, saved more than 4 million gallons of fuel. OPERATIONAL ADJUSTMENTS Promoting flaps 3 landing on the A319 and A320 aircraft to reduce drag, reducing overfuels, and measuring domestic contingency fuel have resulted in 1.3 million gallons of fuel saved. DRAG REDUCING WINGTIP DEVICES Delta currently has drag reducing wingtip devices on 433 of its mainline fleet. In 2013, winglets were installed on six additional Boeing 757 and on two additional Boeing 767 aircraft, saving 1.6 million gallons of fuel. REMOVING UNNECESSARY WEIGHT In an effort to reduce weight carried on each flight, sliding carpet cargo loading systems were removed and overhead CRT screens were replaced with liquid crystal displays on Boeing 757-200s. Unnecessary portable water tanks were removed from the Boeing 767-300ER fleet, and the amount of ice boarded on overnight international flights was reduced to more accurately meet consumption. These four initiatives saved more than 142,000 gallons of fuel. HIGH FREQUENCY RADIO High frequency radios allow for more efficient flight paths from JFK to eastern Caribbean destinations, reducing trip time and in turn, fuel. The average savings per flight is 663 gallons, and a total of 30,000 gallons of fuel has been saved since this initiative began. SOFTWARE UPDATES Software modification on the Boeing 737s allow aircraft to retain location of original waypoints and reference those waypoints when new routing is added. Better aircraft performance trajectories result in a reduction in fuel burn. Software modifications on Boeing 747400 and Boeing 767-300/-400 continue to reduce fuel consumption. 13,719,000 135,156 $42,117,330 TOTAL GALLONS SAVED TOTAL C02e REDUCED (metric tons) TOTAL SAVINGS THE EQUIVALENT OF… ANNUAL CARBON FOOTPRINT OF EMISSIONS FROM AMERICANS DRIVES ACROSS THE U.S. 8,045 103,445 THE ANNUAL EMISSIONS OF 27,031 2013 CARS DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 20 ENGAGEMENT ON CARBON EMISSIONS Through a partnership with The Nature Conservancy, Delta offers its passengers the opportunity to offset the carbon emissions of any flight. The average tree conserved through this Carbon Offset Program sequesters up to 7.5 metric tons of CO2 over its lifetime. For comparison, a round-trip flight from New York to London emits about 1 metric ton of CO2 per passenger. In 2013, an updated carbon calculator was launched at www.delta.com/co2 to allow passengers to enter their flight itineraries, view the carbon emissions associated with each part of their trip, and offset to the project of their choice: The Rio Bravo Climate Action Project located in northwest Belize or the newly launched Clinch Valley Conservation Forestry Program in southwestern Virginia. For the year, Delta, Delta customers and employees offset 2,689 metric tons of carbon emissions. The Nature Conservancy’s Rio Bravo Climate Action Project was added to the program in 2012, followed by the Clinch Valley Conservation Forestry Program in 2013. The Rio Bravo Climate Action Project is a partnership between The Nature Conservancy and Programme for Belize. The 6,296 hectare project, located in northwest Belize, reduces GHG emissions through the acquisition and protection of forest lands threatened by agricultural conversion. The new Clinch Valley Conservation Forestry Program aims to protect wildlife, promote clean water, and sustain local timber jobs and economic productivity. The program protects and manages 22,000 acres of forestlands in the rural countryside of southwestern Virginia. With up to 30 tree species per acre, the broad-leaf forests sustain one of the most unique collections of plants and animals on Earth, supporting iconic wildlife species like black bear as well as globally rare aquatic species. After the launch of this program, Delta volunteers from different divisions helped remove invasive species from the site in an effort to fully understand the role of the offset program in promoting forest growth and biodiversity. 30 EMPLOYEE SUSTAINABILITY GROUPS The IT Green Initiatives Group works with other divisions and employees across the business to look for opportunities to make Delta an increasingly environmentally conscious organization. In 2013, the group hosted Earth Day events in both Atlanta and Minneapolis to ask employees to commit to trying alternative commutes, recycling, turning off lights and composting. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 21 COMMUNITY “Delta flies to more than 300 destinations across six continents, which means the world truly is our community. Whether we’re building a home with Habitat for Humanity International in Mexico, constructing a playground with KaBOOM! in Seattle, or educating students through Junior Achievement in New York, our company promotes employee engagement in the communities where we live and work. Through our Force for Global Good, Delta contributes thousands of volunteer hours and millions of dollars through corporate contributions, the Delta Air Lines Foundation and employee contributions to a host of civic causes including the American Red Cross, United Way and the Breast Cancer Research Foundation.” Tad Hutcheson, vice president – Community Affairs 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 22 31 Delta is proud to be an American business which serves international communities. In addition to many programs in the U.S., Delta and Delta employees support communities around the world. ASIA • 20 employees participated in a Habitat for Humanity Build in the tsunami-affected area of Higashi-Matsushma, Japan. EUROPE • The IT team in the UK provides young school children the opportunity to work with Delta through traineeship programs. • Delta sponsored the American Women’s Club of Amsterdam benefit, raising €18,000 for the Blijfgroep’s Oranjehuis, to help end gender-based violence. • Airport employees in Singapore hosted “Mr. and Ms. Pinktober” in an effort to raise money for the Breast Cancer Research Foundation. • Books, children’s clothing and stationary were donated to a local orphanage in Thailand. • Winter wear, thermal jackets and blankets were collected and donated to Syria through Mercy Relief. • Manila In-Flight Services raised $4,111 for Habitat for Humanity to support projects to help rebuild homes in Tacloban and other areas hit by Typhoon Haiyan. LATIN/SOUTH AMERICA • Delta and GOL Linhas Aéreas Inteligentes partnered with the American Society of Sao Paulo to provide orphans with a Christmas-themed celebration. • The 4th annual Christmas Party was hosted for children at Sagrada Familia Orphanage in Lima. Funds are currently being raised to install a new water filtration system in partnership with Leave A Trace Foundation in Lima, Peru. • The Children of Huestros Pequenos Hermanos orphanage in Guatemala and Haiti received 7,400 BusinessElite duvets and 20,000 toothbrushes, socks and sleeping eye masks. AFRICA • Employees have donated infant medication and more than $20,000 to a local Catholic orphanage in Dakar, Senegal. • Airport Customer Service in Johannesburg, South Africa recycles all paper and delivers to a non-profit local charity organization. • BusinessElite duvets are donated to orphanages in Johannesburg and Cape Town before the winter season in South Africa. • Travel and support are awarded to the winner of the local Ghana National Spelling Bee in Accra for participation in the Scripps Spelling Bee in the U.S. • Delta supports the Liberian Market Women Initiative in Monrovia in an effort to empower women in business to help see a way out of poverty and provide education for their children. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 23 COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIPS: DELTA’S FORCE FOR GLOBAL GOOD Delta and its employees have always demonstrated a civic obligation to give back to the communities where they live and work. As part of its Force for Global Good, Delta people contribute their time, energy and millions of dollars to help make the world a better place in which to live. SUPPORTING GLOBAL DIVERSITY Delta proudly embraces diverse people, thinking and styles. On a global scale, Delta maintains a culture of inclusion and employees represent many ethnicities, languages, religions, cultures, races and ages. Delta believes that these differences among employees help to strengthen the airline and underscore global diversity as a core Delta value. In line with this belief, Delta is proud to provide corporate support to organizations such as GLAAD, the National Center for Civil and Human Rights, 100 Black Men of America, the Japanese American Association, the Japan Society, the Latin American Association and the National Association of Chinese Americans. In 2013, Delta sponsored annual Pride festivals in Atlanta, Los Angeles, Minneapolis/St. Paul, New York and Seattle to celebrate the LGBT community. EXPANDING GLOBAL HEALTH AND WELLNESS Expanding global health and wellness means addressing overall well-being at its core. Each year, Delta employees and customers raise millions of dollars for organizations such as the Foundation for AIDS Research (amfAR), the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, CARE, Children’s Miracle Network and Covenant House. These organizations and others supported by Delta work to fight cancer and other diseases, reduce homelessness and poverty and find solutions to other pressing social issues. In 2013, Delta employees and customers raised more than $1 million both for the American Cancer Society and the Breast Cancer Research Foundation. AMERICAN CANCER SOCIETY In May, as part of the Delta Day of Hope, in conjunction with the American Cancer Society, thousands of airport and other Delta employees participated in relay events. At more than 70 airports around the globe, these employees raised more than $500,000 to help end cancer. The American Cancer Society presented its 2013 Pinnacle Award to Delta in recognition of its efforts to educate, promote awareness of cancer and raise funds that help save lives. FIVE CORE PILLARS TO GLOBAL GOOD 32 These are the guiding principles for Delta’s community involvement its Delta’s Force for Global Good: Supporting Global Diversity Expanding Global Health and Wellness Promoting Arts and Culture Advancing Education Improving the Environment 33 Gail Grimmett, senior vice presidentNew York, participated in Covenant House’s Executive Sleep Out, a unique charity fundraiser where 180 executives spent one night on the streets with homeless children to help raise awareness and funds to support homeless youth. With just a sleeping bag and a piece of cardboard to serve as a cushion, Gail spent the night on the sidewalk near the entrance to the Lincoln Tunnel by the Port Authority Bus Terminal. “What struck me most is how inspiring these kids are,” Gail said. “The youth that use Covenant House to better their lives are courageous.” Together, the executives raised $1.3 million for Covenant House, a nonprofit organization that provides food, shelter and immediate crisis care to homeless and runaway youth throughout the U.S. and Canada. Delta is a committed partner and supporter of Covenant House. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 24 2 UNITED WAY Delta is a corporate leader of sustainable change in education, income, health and reducing homelessness through its partnership with the United Way. Delta employees continued their support for the United Way in 2013, giving more than $1.8 million to help those less fortunate in communities served. In 2013, Steve Sear, senior vice president of Global Sales, served on the Board of Directors for the United Way of Greater Atlanta and encouraged employees to contribute through Delta’s payroll deduction program to help achieve its financial goal. GLOBAL HEALTH he 2013 Jet Drag competition at Atlanta T TOC raised $133,384 for the American Cancer Society. A total of 39 teams of 20 people each competed to see how far and fast they could pull a full-size jet. AMERICAN RED CROSS Delta and the American Red Cross are continuing a vital partnership that has spanned more than 70 years. Supporting one of its most critical roles, Delta was the top blood donor in the Southeast in 2013 and ranked 10th nationally for the Red Cross. Last year, Delta employees donated more than 4,600 pints of blood. Delta also increased its proactive participation as a National Disaster Responder for the international aid provider. HABITAT FOR HUMANITY INTERNATIONAL Acknowledging the need for safe, decent and affordable shelter around the globe, Delta is proud of its ongoing support of Habitat for Humanity International. Delta employees have helped to build more than 100 homes through the partnership with Habitat. In 2013, more than 2,000 employees took part in Delta-sponsored Habitat build projects, building and improving homes for 12 deserving families throughout the United States. New houses were built in Atlanta, Detroit and Minneapolis-St. Paul, and existing structures in Los Angeles, New York City and Seattle were rehabilitated to current building standards. In March 2013, a team of more than 50 Delta employees, retirees and customers traveled to Puebla, Mexico, to participate in the 9th Annual International Habitat for Humanity Global Build, where they constructed six 34 elta employees raised more than D $500,000 for the American Cancer Society during the Delta Day of Hope relay events. elta was the top blood donor in the D Southeast in 2013 and highly- ranked nationally for the Red Cross. 35 36 37 I n 2013, more than 2,000 employees worked with Habitat for Humanity to build and improve homes for 12 families throughout the U.S. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 25 homes for families in the community. The team collaborated with employee volunteers from Delta’s SkyTeam partner, Aeromexico. PROMOTING ARTS AND CULTURE Delta is an active partner in supporting community musical and fine arts organizations, museums and other institutions around the country that inform, enlighten and inspire people to better themselves and their world. Included in Delta’s ongoing 2013 classical music partnerships were the Atlanta and Seattle Symphony Orchestras. With assistance from Delta, both of these organizations will be traveling to New York City to perform at the renowned and historic Carnegie Hall in 2014. Other historic performing arts venues supported by Delta include the Fox Theatres in Atlanta and Detroit, the Woodruff Arts Center in Atlanta and the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis. As the Official Airline of Madison Square Garden, Delta has branded space at many iconic sports and entertainment venues in the country, including New York City’s Radio City Music Hall, The Theater at Madison Square Garden and the Beacon Theatre, as well as The Chicago Theatre and the Wang Theatre in Boston. Important visual arts partnerships in 2013 included Atlanta’s High Museum of Art, the Seattle Art Museum, the Whitney Museum in New York City and many others. Delta continues its long-running support for the National Academy of Recording Arts & Sciences (NARAS), which produces the annual GRAMMY and Latin GRAMMY awards presentations. With assistance from Delta, NARAS also sponsors MusiCares, a philanthropic organization that provides financial, medical and personal assistance for musicians in times of need. 38 DELTA EMPLOYEES SALUTE THE U.S. MILITARY Delta and its employees proudly support the men and women who serve in the U.S. armed forces. Contributions and volunteer efforts by employees help support the USO, airport military lounges, including the Freedom Center in Detroit, the Marine Toys for Tots campaign and the Fisher House Foundation. In the past year, more than $250,000, thousands of toys and bicycles and countless volunteer hours were donated to the Marine Toys for Tots campaign. For many years, Delta, our employees and customers have donated SkyMiles and funds to the Fisher House Foundation, which provides a network of homes at major military and Veteran’s Administration medical centers where military and veterans’ families can stay at no cost while a loved one is receiving treatment. In 2013, Delta donated $200,000 to the Fisher House Foundation, which in part will support the construction of a second Fisher House facility at Joint Base Lewis-McChord, near Seattle. Through Delta’s growing partnership with community food banks throughout the U.S., Delta employees 39 have helped to provide hot meals to thousands of hungry people. In 2013, Delta was recognized by the Food Bank for New York City as its 2013 DELTA of CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT Corporate Partner the Year. | 26 9 40 ADVANCING EDUCATION Delta recognizes the essential role of education in improving the lives and life prospects of young people across the U.S. Delta employees help teach students financial literacy, entrepreneurship, business readiness and economics through national partnership with Junior Achievement. In New York City, high school students spent a day observing Delta employees in a variety of positions at LaGuardia and JFK airports to learn what it takes to succeed in the business world. Additionally, in Atlanta, Delta employees volunteered to teach financial literacy to middle school students at the Junior Achievement Discovery Center. Whether learning to swim or attending after-school tutoring sessions, thousands of young people have also benefited from Delta’s partnership with the YMCA in the communities Delta serves. Delta played a leading role in the capital campaign of the YMCA of the Rockaways in New York following the destruction caused by Hurricane Sandy. In addition, Delta helped to restore a playground at the Ken-Ton YMCA in Buffalo, New York, for kids to have a safe place to play. Delta is also the proud sponsor of the Joseph E. Lowery scholarships affiliated with Morehouse and Spelman Colleges and Clark Atlanta University in Atlanta, and nationally continues its support for the United Negro College Fund. Delta also supports the Morehouse School of Medicine. THE GIFT OF PLAY This past year in Auburn, Wash., a suburb of Seattle, more than 150 Delta employees teamed up with 100 community leaders and built a new playground in a single day with new partner, KaBOOM!, to provide deserving kids a safe place to play in their neighborhood. In just six hours, Delta employees and the rest of the volunteer team assembled and painted the new recreational area that features swings, slides, a see-saw, bridge and other equipment. The team also constructed picnic tables, park benches and arbors, poured concrete, installed landscaping and shoveled a mountain of mulch to complete the playground. The project marked the first partnership between Delta and the nonprofit organization, which has already built more than 2,300 playgrounds and renovated 2,000 others throughout North America since its inception in 1996. KaBOOM! also encourages all playground builders to recycle the packaging from the building materials they use during these projects. DELTA EMPLOYEES GIVE SMILES 41 Through Delta’s participation in the Champions program of the Children’s Miracle Network (CMN) Hospitals, Delta employees help bring smiles to children who are undergoing medical treatment and their families. Last October, more than 50 children and their families traveled on a Deltachartered plane to Washington, D.C. where they met with President Obama as part of the CMN Champions Week. The trip capped off with the CMN Hospitals’ annual Children’s Miracle Awards event, honoring individuals who have made significant contributions in the lives of children. Delta’s year-round commitment to CMN Hospitals involves hospital fundraising and public awareness, both in flight and on the ground, through employee volunteerism and underwriting air travel for CMN Hospitals and its beneficiaries. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 27 SUPPLY CHAIN “Delta is committed to including diverse businesses in our supply chain, and we actively seek partners whose creativity, innovation and flexible solutions help us to deliver world-class products and services that are relevant to our global customer base. As a company, we want our social responsibility to extend beyond our business by addressing environmental, social and governance issues with those we choose to do business with.” -- Chris Collette, senior vice president – Supply Chain Management 2013 GOALS Achieve set targets in percentage spend through MBE, WBE and Continue to support all NMSDC and WBENC local and regional organizations and efforts SBE…ACHIEVED 2014 GOALS Achieve set targets in percentage spend through MBE, WBE and SBE Focus on further maturation of 2nd tier supplier diversity reporting, and 2nd tier goal of increasing MWBE by 10% overall Focus on ethics and compliance for SCM staff, suppliers and entire corporation DOING BUSINESS WITH DELTA Delta’s Supply Chain Management (SCM) organization is composed of multiple units that partner with business divisions to formulate business and sourcing strategies and deliver sustainable results to the company. This ensures a continuous supply of cost-competitive, quality goods and services to meet the company’s business needs. DRIVING SUSTAINABILITY IN THE PROCUREMENT PROCESS Delta has adopted a strategic sourcing process that defines how to manage and engage suppliers to ensure that they practice responsible and sustainable business. Suppliers are provided a summary of expectations and requirements through Doing Business With Delta. Sourcing professionals are required to include environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors in the selection process for all contracts with significant spend. In 2013, more than 140 business reviews were held with Delta suppliers who were asked to provide a report summarizing their corporate sustainability practices through the Supplier Performance Management (SPM) program. The SPM scorecards measure supplier performance, including ESG performance. In 2013, Delta SCM received a Dow Jones Sustainability Index score of 87 -- the highest of any airline. Delta SCM attributes its high score to its internal processes, which include the use of ESG factors for supplier selection and supplier performance measurement. 42 In 2013, Delta SCM received a Dow Jones Sustainability Index score of 87 — the highest of any airline. 43 The Supply Chain Management and supplier diversity team members met with small, minority, and women-owned firms at national and regional supplier diversity tradeshows and conferences in 2013 to help Delta identify and do business with leading suppliers from around the world. 44 In 2013, Delta launched a Supplier Diversity Advisory Stakeholder Council made up of 12 external community leaders from across the country. COMMITMENT TO SUPPLIER DIVERSITY Delta recognizes the importance of small, minority, and women-owned businesses (MWBEs) to the overall strength of the U.S. economy and, ultimately, to Delta stakeholders. To maximize returns to customers, shareholders, employees and local communities in which the airline operates, every effort is made to build relationships and utilize the products and services of qualified MWBEs. As a result of this commitment, Delta exceeded its 2013 minority performance goal with a spend of $286 million, and its woman-owned business performance goal with a spend of $395 million. In 2013, Delta launched a Supplier Diversity Advisory Stakeholder Council, made up of 12 external community leaders from across the country. The Council offers constructive input, advice and best practice recommendations to support continued efforts in sustainability and achieving a diverse supply base. The Supply Chain Management and supplier diversity team members met with small, minority, and women-owned firms at national and regional supplier diversity tradeshows and conferences in 2013 to help Delta identify and do business with leading suppliers from around the world. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 29 REWARDING SUPPLIER DIVERSITY At Delta’s 14th annual Supplier Diversity ‘Star Awards’ luncheon, small, minority and women-owned supplier partners are recognized for exceptional cost savings, quality and reliability, innovation, outreach and community involvement. Keynote speaker Magic Johnson, CEO of Magic Johnson Enterprises, shared his business experience. The awards also honor Delta’s internal advocates of supplier diversity, who are instrumental in supporting Delta’s business goals and values. 2013 RECIPIENTS Xtra Aerospace 2013 Minority-Owned Business of the Year Magno International 2013 New Minority-Owned Business NogginLabs Inc 2013 Women-Owned Business of the Year Flightstar Small Business of the Year Delta Advocate of the Year Lani Gustafson, Marketing & In-Flight Services Delta Supply Chain Management Team of the Year Corporate Travel Delta Supply Chain Management leaders with Traci Knudson, CEO of NogginLabs Inc. READY, SET, JET 45 NogginLabs Inc. won the Women-Owned Business category for the year. Their team built Ready, Set, Jet!, a game-like training program for Reservation Sales agents to help improve global awareness and to assist with customer service and sales. “The Delta team came to the table with some really great ideas to share with us, and so it was a nice sort of collaboration to come up with the best way forward for the project” – Quinn Goodwillie, Senior Account Representative at NogginLabs Inc. Suppliers appreciated Delta’s show of recognition and support through these awards. “Everyone works really hard and it’s very unique to have your clients take time off and celebrate what we’ve done together,’’ said Traci Knudson, CEO of NogginLabs Inc. Left: Magic Johnson, keynote speaker at Star Awards “I can’t stress enough to you, that when you get that deal, when you get that contract, it’s not only for you, it’s for those who are coming after you.” — Magic Johnson 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 30 EMPLOYEES “Our employees are stakeholders, not spectators. The best investment we make is in our people, who in turn, invest every day in our customers and reward our shareholders. Our greatest strength for long-term sustainability lies in our culture and values.” -- Mike Campbell, executive vice president – Human Resources and Labor Relations 2013 GOALS Pay profit sharing at or above target…ACHIEVED Earn 21 or more Shared Reward payments…ACHIEVED Continue building a great place to work and achieve a 5 percent overall improvement on the 2013 Employee Survey…ACHIEVED Pursue two additional VPP sites…ACHIEVED Submit application to OSHA for two sites…ACHIEVED Continue to focus on reducing serious injuries from driving on the ramp through increased observations; provide third party to conduct observations and several locations…ACHIEVED Provide a safe work environment for employees…ACHIEVED 2014 GOALS Pay profit sharing at or above target Earn 21 or more Shared Reward payments Invest $1.5 billion in retirement plans (pension and 401K) Provide a safe work environment for employees EMPLOYEE SAFETY Delta’s 2013 Flight Plan solidifies Delta’s commitment to providing a safe work environment for its employees. Delta’s commitment to safety is further expressed by the Corporate Leadership Team’s annual Safety and Security Policy letter, which reiterates that every employee has specific responsibilities to comply with existing safety and health policies, procedures and regulations. These responsibilities include, but are not limited to: • Following all safety, security and environmental health policies and procedures • Reporting all hazardous conditions or unsafe equipment • Reporting any injuries, illnesses, ground damages or near misses • Using required safety equipment and protective clothing • Refraining from the use of any equipment without proper instructions 46 Installing, enforcing and observing compliance with the OSHA seatbelt agreement resulted in a 25 percent reduction in serious injuries from driving on the ramp. OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION (OSHA) Delta’s OSHA recordable occupational injury/illness rate for 2013 saw an 11 percent improvement compared to 2012. Delta’s safety record continues to be significantly stronger than the industry average based on 2013 Airlines for America benchmarking data and based on a comparison with the most recent 2012 Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) numbers. Delta’s OSHA rate is 57 percent better than the BLS industry average, and the Days Away Restricted Transferred (DART) rate is 55 percent better than the industry average. There were no work-related fatalities during 2013. Delta executed and met the terms of the seatbelt agreement with OSHA early in 2013. Interim goals were established for installation of seatbelts, enforcing usage, and third party observations began in July 2013. These actions contributed to a decrease of approximately 25 percent in serious injuries from driving on the ramp. OSHA RECORDABLE INJURY & ILLNESS RATE 7.0 8.8 7.9 4.52 OSHA DART RATE 3.82 8.0 3.40 Bureau of Labor Statistics Rate (most recent industry average) 3.62 6.1 3.11 6.1 Bureau of Labor Statistics DART Rate (most recent industry average) 2.72 Delta’s OSHA Recordable Rate 2011 2012 2013 2011 2012 Delta’s OSHA DART Rate 2013 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 32 47 Delta was the first airline in OSHA’s Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) and remains as one of only five companies in their corporate VPP program. SAFETY PROGRAMS Delta’s safety strategy includes the utilization of site-specific Safety Business Plans, which are based on compliance with key elements of OSHA’s Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP). To validate compliance, Delta conducts annual Safety and Health Gap Assessments in strategic locations. These assessments are safety learning opportunities and include an onsite visit, a review of required documentation and employee interviews. In 2013, Safety Gap Assessments were conducted for six Delta locations. These assessments involved an entire worksite inspection for safety hazards, compliance to regulatory requirements, safety program reviews and interviews with employees regarding the local safety culture. Findings were risk-rated as high, medium or low based on severity and likelihood for injury. Follow-ups were completed to ensure that corrective actions were taken. VPP Additionally, a newly established Ergonomics Team made up of trained personnel conducts ergonomic assessments of defined work areas. To assist work groups with proper equipment selection, the Ergonomics Team has also developed an approved ergonomics equipment catalog, available for review by all employees. The Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) Committee reviews and tests new PPE products to ensure that employees have the best products providing the highest amount of protection. Through these programs and many others, Delta strives to ensure that all employees enjoy a safe working environment. 48 STAR WORK SITE IN SAVANNAH, GA Members of the Savannah, GA Airport Customer Service and Technical Operations team celebrated their acceptance into VPP in 2013 PREVENTING SLIP AND FALL INJURIES In response to an increase in slip and fall injuries during winter weather events, Corporate Safety initiated an analysis of anti-slip footwear products. A cross divisional team was designated to identify candidate products based on the potential for these products to aid in preventing slip and fall incidents and potential for damage to Delta equipment and facilities caused by usage of anti-slip footwear. After field testing, Delta’s Corporate PPE Committee approved two anti-slip footwear products. Since implementation, more than 12 Delta facilities prone to winter weather have instituted usage of anti-slip footwear. In 2014, a cross divisional campaign will be initiated to further communicate product availability and effectiveness. Delta will continue to work with the manufacturer to enhance existing products, making them more suited to the operation. The usage versus the rate of injuries will be monitored to determine viability. 8.8 7.9 BLS Industry Average 4.52 OSHA’S VOLUNTARY PROTECTION PROGRAMS Delta was the first airline in OSHA’s Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) and remains one of only five U.S. companies in their Corporate VPP program. VPP provides Delta the unique opportunity to improve employee safety and health through cooperation among 8 3.82 3.40 DL Corporate Rate 2.87 2.46 2011 2012 1.93 DL VPP Rate 2013 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 33 employees, management and government. Through 2013, Delta has 15 facilities in OSHA’s Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP): • These VPP sites represent 13.2 percent of our U.S. facilities and 8.7 percent of all U.S. personnel (6,714 employees). • This year, the total OSHA recordable rate for these facilities was 1.93 injuries per 100 employees per year and the DART rate was 0.87. • The OSHA recordable rate was 45.6 percent better at VPP sites than non-VPP sites at Delta. • Additionally, the VPP OSHA recordable rate was 75.8 percent better than the industry average. In 2013, one facility participated in a VPP recertification and two new sites had their initial onsite reviews. Denver Technical Operations received official approval, while the other is pending notification regarding official status. Savannah Airport Customer Service and Savannah Technical Operations underwent onsite reviews in 2012 and received official approval in 2013 for participation as a VPP Star site. Two facilities withdrew from the program, while three other facilities submitted applications for participation in VPP in 2013: Memphis TechOps, Minneapolis Reservations and Albany Airport Customer Service. In 2014, Delta plans to obtain official VPP approval for two new sites and obtain VPP recertification of Star status for two facilities. SAFETY TRAINING In addition to operational and basic safety training, Delta’s Corporate Safety team facilitates an annual Safety Leadership Workshop that is open to all safety coordinators, safety representatives, VPP coordinators, facility managers, supervisors and leaders from the various divisions. In 2013, more than 450 employees attended the event, which included Delta’s CEO Richard Anderson and Andy Zarras, vice president of Airport Customer Service – Minneapolis as guest speakers. Attendees could also choose from a variety of safety-related breakout sessions throughout the day to enhance the learning experience. 49 Narita Airport Customer Service, second-place winners of the annual Safety Video Contest, donated their winnings to typhoon victims in the Philippines. The winners of the annual Safety Video Contest were also announced at this workshop. Entries were submitted by teams in Airport Customer Service, Delta Cargo, In-Flight Service, Reservation Sales and Delta TechOps. Employees were instructed to develop a video using a key message or slogan, and to use humor and creativity to emphasize ways for Delta people to protect themselves, friends and family at work or home. The Atlanta Airport Customer Service team won first place for their entry, “SOS - Spirit of Safety,” a unique ‘spirit’-themed entry. Second place went to Narita Airport Customer Service, with “Stay Safe,” a video that tied in safety at work and at home. The team chose to donate their $500 winnings to typhoon victims in the Philippines. DEPARTMENTAL SAFETY REPRESENTATIVES Delta has a number of designated safety representatives available in each department, and each location holds monthly safety meetings: DEPARTMENTAL SAFETY REPRESENTATIVES AIRPORT CUSTOMER SERVICE CARGO Divisional…5 Regional…19 Divisional…2 Regional…45 FLIGHT OPERATIONS Divisional…49 IN-FLIGHT SERVICE Divisional…6 Location…15 System…5 RESERVATIONS Divisional…3 Location…15 System…187 TECHNICAL OPERATIONS Divisional…14 Line Safety Domestic…123 International…22 Shops…160 CORPORATE Corporate Safety, Security and Compliance…89 Flight Safety…11 TOTAL SAFETY REPRESENTATIVES: 660 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 34 ASSESSING WORKPLACES THROUGH INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE To protect employees from long-term health problems, Delta’s industrial hygiene program identifies and addresses potential workplace hazards. Air sampling, indoor air quality surveys, noise monitoring, drinking water testing, chemical hazard assessments, industrial hygiene compliance reviews and health hazard awareness training are used to minimize workplace risks. In all cases, Delta goes beyond the minimum regulatory requirements, enforcing standards set by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists; STUTTGART STATION the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning; the WINS GRAND SLAM American National Standards Institute; and the International Organization for AWARD Standardization. 50 REWARDING EMPLOYEES WHO MAKE SAFETY A PRIORITY SAVING THE DAY ON BOARD A FLIGHT On Jan. 10, 2013, Memphis-based flight attendant Marsha Cowling was serving lunch when a passenger yelled, “My wife is choking.” After verifying the situation, Marsha calmly and professionally took control. She administered the Heimlich maneuver and dislodged the item. Her quick thinking and conscientious actions helped to save this passenger’s life. She was given a ‘Saved the Day’ award from Corporate Safety for her actions. On April 5, 2013, Carol Quinlan Hall, a Cincinnati Reservations work-at-home agent, was able to help an 87-year-old passenger on her flight who was having severe chest pains. As a retired nurse, Carol was able to assist an on-board physician with CPR and used the AED. They provided two shocks and then stayed with the passenger through the rest of the flight. After the flight, the paramedics commended her efforts and said his life had been saved. Delta rewards stations for operational safety excellence in their regional. Stuttgart’s airport team earned the Grand Slam award from Corporate Safety for their 1st quarter 2013 performance, competing against other stations in the Atlantic Region. The Grand Slam award is Delta’s highest recognition for operational safety excellence in the Atlantic region and is awarded to the station that records -m ost improved global injury rate - z ero aircraft ground damages in specified categories - zero environmental spills - z ero high risk or unresolved safety related quality control audit findings - t he highest number of near miss observation reports and one of the top five in on time D0 performance rates for the quarter THE FIGHT AGAINST HUMAN TRAFFICKING In the U.S., human trafficking is a $9.5 billion industry according to the United Nations. The U.S. Department of Justice estimates that 17,500 people are trafficked into the U.S. each year. A total of 300,000 children in the U.S. are at risk of being trafficked sexually right now. In 2011, Delta became the first U.S. carrier to sign the End Child Prostitution, Pornography and Trafficking International Code of Conduct for Tourism (ECPAT). Additionally, the airline was one of twelve founding companies of the Global Business Coalition against Human Trafficking in 2012. In 2013, Delta continued its commitment to raise awareness about human trafficking by implementing training for frontline employee groups. Delta adopted the Department of Homeland Security’s Blue Lightning Initiative The CVG RES management team presented Carol with Corporate Safety’s Saved the Day award Delta’s ground automated electronic defibrillator (AED) program added a computer-based CPR & AED training course, which is accessible to all employees worldwide. 51 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 35 training program that provides airline employees with tools to identify and report suspected instances of human trafficking. More than 60,000 Delta people have taken the training as of January 2014. More than 60,000 frontline employees have taken Delta’s course that provides employees with the tools to identify and report suspected instances of human trafficking. A portal dedicated to human trafficking awareness was published to Delta’s internal communications system where employees can read about activities related to Delta’s commitment to the ECPAT Code and partnerships with gBCAT and Transportation Leaders Against Human Trafficking (TLAHT). Furthermore, a statement regarding Delta’s commitment to the ECPAT Code has been added to supplier contracts, and the company’s human rights abuse policy is integrated as appropriate in business processes. 52 On June 5, 2013 Delta CEO Richard Anderson joined U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood at a press conference in Washington, DC to announce Delta’s partnership with the DOT and Delta’s support of the Blue Lightning Initiative. Richard told reporters and others in attendance that Delta knew it had a duty to work with the CBP and DOT on the Blue Lightning Initiative project as soon as it was introduced. “This isn’t our duty as an airline,” Richard told attendees. “It is our duty as human beings to fight this problem.” 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 36 2 VIEW OF DELTA EMPLOYEES FEMALE AND ETHNIC MINORITY1 EMPLOYEES 62.40% Number of female and ethnic minority employees of total employees in 2013 EMPLOYEES BY REGION EUROPE, MIDDLE EAST AND AFRICA CANADA .4% 287 UNITED STATES LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN .5% 421 ASIA-PACIFIC 1% 95.4% 2.7% 792 74,033 2,112 OPERATIONAL DIVISIONS AIRPORT CUSTOMER SERVICE CARGO FLIGHT OPERATIONS IN-FLIGHT SERVICE RESERVATIONS 31.9% 2.3% 14.5% 23.3% of total employees in 2013 of total employees in 2013 of total employees in 2013 of total employees in 2013 11,236 18,097 24,733 1 1,756 TECHNICAL OPERATIONS CORPORATE 6.4% 10% 11.7% of total employees in 2013 of total employees in 2013 of total employees in 2013 4,979 7,727 9,117 Ethnic minority = non-white ENGAGING EMPLOYEES ANNUAL EMPLOYEE SURVEY Delta promotes a culture of open, honest and direct communication. In 2013, employees were provided an opportunity to participate in an employee engagement survey to assess employee attitudes and perceptions of the current work environment, leadership, employee engagement and specific strategic initiatives. More than 48 percent of eligible employees completed the survey - a 15 percent increase over 2012. Additionally, 82 percent of employees indicated Delta is a great place to work, meeting the Flight Plan goal of increasing 5 percent over 2012 results. The annual survey is administered in the first quarter. Throughout the rest of the year, divisional leaders work with employees to create actions plans based on the results of the survey. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 37 EMPLOYEE INVOLVEMENT GROUPS Across the company, employees have the opportunity to get involved. Divisional groups including In-Flight Service’s Employee Involvement Group (EIG), the TechOps’ EIG, Reservation Sales’ ResLINC and the Airport Customer Service and Cargo Frontline Involvement Team (FIT), promote employee engagement and serve as a liaison between frontline employees and leadership. Membership in these groups provides an experience the gives employees the opportunity to increase their knowledge and exposure to the complexities that drive decisions affecting Delta’s work environment. Group members partner with divisional leaders to ensure employee issues and concerns are identified and addressed, and create and support continuous improvement that improves the work environment and customer experience. Airport Customer Service’s FIT allows frontline employees to get involved in the implementation of divisional initiatives and employee-driven suggestions. The group’s mission is to partner with leadership in support of the company’s Flight Plan, while maintaining an inclusive culture. Airport Customer Service’s FIT is responsible for resolving problems with creative solutions, and keeping employees informed while assisting them with their recommendations or feedback. DELTA BOARD COUNCIL 53 Through the Delta Board Council, employees have a more direct, effective voice in the board room and with senior management. While they relay employee concerns to senior leaders, the Council also communicates with the employees about new business developments and the rationale for particular company decisions or policy changes. 54 INVOLVEMENT Delta employee groups help resolve employee issues, keep employees informed, and assist with recommendations and feedback. In 2013, Airport Customer Service’s FIT and In-Flight Service’s EIG collaborated to address issues regarding carry-on baggage compliance, unaccompanied minors, customers with disabilities, and exit row seating. Airport Customer Service FIT-led focus groups have resulted in things such as the Dangerous Goods Topic of the Month communication, an Aircraft Walk Around video, and various pet acceptance/handling communications. EXECUTIVE ENGAGEMENT In addition, Delta provides many forums for Delta people to engage with leaders. Two such programs – Delta’s popular Velvet-360 Tour and the Town Hall Program – promote two-way, face-to-face conversation between executives and employees, and provide employees with corporate information and updates on issues important to them. In 2013, over 65 interactive sessions were held at stations throughout the world. The Delta Board Council (DBC) is composed of five employee-members elected by their peers to provide executives and the Board of Directors candid, unfiltered reports on the “pulse of the company” as seen from the frontline. The DBC is a unique communication channel with Delta leaders but by no means the only one. The DBC is part of Delta’s broader philosophy of employee inclusion and servant leadership. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 38 3 TRAINING DEVELOPMENT Delta provides its employees with numerous training and career development opportunities each year. Training requirements are specific to each operational division, and Delta’s eLearning database allows employees access to a broad array of courses at any time. Whether it is mandatory compliance, new hire, annual recurrent training Based on feedback from the 2012 or seminars, employees have numerous opportunities to increase their Employee Survey, the Performance knowledge, skills and abilities. Delta provides employee education and Talent Management tool was and communication via magazines, mailings, emails and web-based upgraded to include a focus on career documents about pay, benefits, compensation and corporate programs. development. Employee resources for the management of career endings include financial planning resources, EAP retirement counseling and pension and 401(k) investment advice and modeling. 55 AVERAGE TRAINING HOURS PER EMPLOYEE PER YEAR AVERAGE TRAINING HOURS PER EMPLOYEE PER YEAR AIRPORT CUSTOMER SERVICE CARGO FLIGHT OPERATIONS IN-FLIGHT SERVICE Frontline…22.9 Merit…27.4 Frontline…7 Merit…8 Frontline…45 Merit…8.2 Frontline…22.5 Merit…6.3 RESERVATIONS Frontline…62.3 Merit…10.2 TECHNICAL OPERATIONS CORPORATE Frontline…38.9 Merit…21.9 Frontline…20.5 Merit…6.4 PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT Each year, employees engage in a performance management process to ensure that all activities and results are consistent with the organizational goals expressed through the Rules of the Road and the annual Flight Plan. This review process takes place in three phases: • Performance Planning - Employees create performance objectives aligned with the goals of their manager, division and the overall corporation. Performance plans address both performance objectives and Delta’s High Performance Attributes (HPAs). HPAs are the behaviors demonstrated to achieve performance objectives. • Mid-year Review - Each employee has an opportunity to discuss progress on performance objectives and HPAs made over the previous six months. • Year-end Review - Individual performance is evaluated against the results delivered for each objective and demonstration of Delta’s HPAs. Each of these components accounts for 50 percent of an individual’s overall rating, and a final performance summary and rating is provided at the end of the year. Launched in early 2013, the new Performance & Talent Management system for merit employees was created to support the performance planning process. The new system was designed with a focus on career and professional development, an area of interest to employees based on feedback Delta received via the 2012 Employee Survey. Features include an integrated talent profile and ability to track development activities. For the 2013 year-end review process, there was an overall performance management completion rate of 98 percent among Delta’s merit employee population. Delta ensures that all other employees receive performance feedback and career development opportunities through their respective divisions. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 39 EMPLOYEE COMPENSATION Delta is committed to providing industry standard pay at the top of the pay scale in addition to competitive starting pay and appropriate pay growth within the scale. Effective Jan 1, 2013, U.S. scale positions were given 4-5 percent base pay increases. Base pay for international frontline employees not covered by industry, government or union collective agreements was increased by of 4-5 percent. Also effective Jan. 1, 2013, most merit employees participated in a 5 percent merit pool based on 2012 individual performance and pay compared to others performing similar work. 56 During summer of 2013, Delta was awarded the 2013 Alfred P. Sloan Awards for Excellence in Workplace Effectiveness and Flexibility by When Work Works, a joint initiative between the Families and Work Institute and The Society for Human Resource Management. SHARED REWARDS FOR OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE Delta’s Shared Rewards Program drives employees to deliver safe, clean, ontime travel to our customers. Eligible employees have an opportunity to earn a monthly cash bonus based on specific operational goals - baggage handling, completion factor and on-time arrivals. The Shared Rewards Program provides a payout of $25 for meeting or exceeding one goal, $75 for two and $100 for all three, with a maximum payout of $1,200 per year for U.S.-based employees. Eligible international employees participate in Shared Rewards with target payout values appropriate for each country. In 2013, the 3 operational goals were met every month, meaning Delta employees received maximum Shared Reward payouts of $1,200 for the year, totaling approximately $92 million in Shared Rewards. PROFIT SHARING TO REWARD FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE When Delta performs well as a company, customers win, shareholders win and employees win. U.S.-based employees and the majority of international employees earn more when Delta performs well through Delta’s annual Profit Sharing Program. As a result of record profits, Delta’s profit sharing totaled $506 million in 2013. Employees received a Valentine’s Day bonus payout equal to 8.26 percent of their eligible annual pay. Delta’s Profit Sharing Program, among the most generous in any industry, recognizes employee contributions to Delta’s successful journey. Executives have the same health care and retirement plans as U.S.based frontline employees. 57 EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION Executive compensation at Delta is highly dependent on Delta’s performance and is aligned with compensation for all employees. Because the achievement of operational and financial performance goals are essential to Delta’s success, goals that drive payouts to employees under the Profit Sharing Program and Shared Rewards Program are included in Delta’s annual management incentive plan. If no profit sharing is paid to Delta employees in a given year, then payouts under the management incentive plan are capped at target award levels and executive officers receive any payouts related to operational or revenue performance only in restricted stock rather than cash. These stock awards generally will not vest until there is a future payout under the Profit Sharing Program. This structure provides management with incentives to deliver value to Delta shareholders, customers and employees, and aligns their interests with those of employees. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 40 58 BENEFITS Most U.S.-based Delta employees are eligible to participate in a comprehensive program of benefits and privileges that range from heath care coverage, travel privileges and retirement plans to employee assistance, WorkLife programs and discounts on a wide variety of products and services. Executives have the same health care and retirement plans as U.S.-based frontline employees. Outside the U.S., Delta typically provides a set of benefits that is competitive with what other, similar employers provide in each market. COMPREHENSIVE HEALTH CARE COVERAGE In addition to comprehensive health care coverage, Delta offers dental, vision and flexible spending account benefits to eligible employees. To promote disease prevention, employees enrolled in a Delta Account-Based Healthcare Plan are covered for preventive care services performed by a network provider based on recommendations of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF). Beyond the USPSTF recommendations, employees covered by Delta’s medical options also receive other preventive services, such as assistance with new and chronic medical conditions. RES EMPLOYEE CREDITS DELTA HEALTH REWARDS WITH SAVING HUSBAND’S LIFE In order to realize the benefits of the Delta Health Rewards program, Dick made an appointment for a routine check-up and was sent for a follow-up stress test. Within a matter of hours, Dick was sent to the hospital, where he underwent an angiogram. One artery was completely blocked, and two others were 95 percent blocked. Doctors called his dire health situation a “ticking time bomb” and noted that had he experienced a heart event, he would not have survived. Both Judy and Dick credit preventive care with saving Dick’s life. “What do you have to lose?” Judy said of the Delta Health Rewards program. “If everything is fine, you’ll get that check mark of good health. If everything isn’t fine, you’ll find out and be able to treat it.” 59 DELTA HEALTH REWARDS Delta provides top-tier global medical assistance to help Delta employees Delta Health Rewards is a voluntary, incentive-based wellness program for U.S. who become ill or injured while on employees enrolled in a Delta account-based medical option. It helps these company business. employees and their spouses, or same-sex domestic partners, reach health goals and allows each to earn rewards dollars by completing specific “health actions,” including getting an annual physical exam, completing the online health assessment and refraining from the use of tobacco products. The rewards dollars are put into the employees’ health reimbursement account (HRA) or Optum Bank health savings account (HSA) on January 1st and can be used to pay for eligible medical expenses. Participation results for each station were shared with leaders, who were encouraged to promote the program to their teams. Many employees shared stories that through a simple annual physical exam, they were able to detect a medical condition very early and make positive changes in their health habits to avoid a potentially serious illness. TRAVEL HEALTH Delta’s medical plans provide unique travel vaccine coverage in recognition of global travel by employees and family members. Special programs target employees who travel internationally on company business, especially to developing countries with risks of malaria, yellow fever, dengue fever and food/waterborne illness. To address these health challenges, Delta provides education, travel health consultation, company-paid vaccination, anti-malaria medication and insect repellent to these employees. Travel illness referrals and RN case management are also important components to Delta’s health strategy. Employee education focuses on promoting awareness, the use of personal protection measures, early symptom recognition, a 24/7 malaria hotline and prompt medical treatment. Delta provides top-tier global medical assistance to help its employees who become ill or injured while on company business. Telephone consultation (available 24/7) can result in a hotel physician visit, a doctor’s office appointment or referral to an emergency room. Case management continues until the ill employee can travel back home. In rare circumstances, an air ambulance staffed with a highly skilled transport team of health care professionals is engaged. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 41 BENEFITS FOR SAME-SEX COUPLES In 2013, Delta took full advantage of changes in U.S. law to implement more comprehensive spousal benefits for legally married, same-sex couples. The benefits include tax-free travel and healthcare benefits for all legally married same-sex couples, regardless of the state where the married same-sex couples reside or where they were married. This also includes changes from after-tax to pre-tax dollars to pay premiums for medical, dental and vision benefits. Employees that had reported their same-sex marriage to Delta were provided a special enrollment right to modify 2013 healthcare and insurance benefits. Delta will continue to follow guidance from the law and the related government entities and will keep the best interests of its people at the forefront when making any changes to benefits policies. WORK-LIFE Employees and their eligible family members have access to Delta’s Employee Assistance Program, which offers confidential counseling, assessment and referral service support. Delta also supports flexible employment opportunities. Ready Reserve employees are eligible to work fewer weekly hours, receive competitive pay, profit sharing, shared rewards and travel privileges, but are not eligible to participate in health and welfare or retirement income benefit plans. The Reservation Sales Work-at-Home program allows employees to receive many of the same benefits as those working in the call center without the time and expense of traveling between home and the call center. The Alliance for Work-Life Progress (AWLP) awarded Delta the 2014 WorkLife Seal of Distinction for the airline’s best-in-class work-life policies as demonstrated in 2013. Such workplace strategies and practices include Delta’s flexibility programs, health and wellness initiatives, community involvement and success in transforming organizational culture. Delta and other organizations that achieved this award will be recognized at the Work-Life Awards Gala during the AWLP Work-Life Forum in Baltimore. 60 Delta received the the Alliance for Work-Life Progress 2014 Work-Life Seal of Distinction for top tier work-life policies. 61 Travel privileges extend to same and opposite sex spouses and domestic partners, dependent and adult children, parents and stepparents, and extended family and close friends. 62 CHAIRMAN’S CLUB In 2013, the 17th year for the program, more than 10,000 nominations were received. Honorees represented 30 Delta stations in five countries, and on average, had about 22 years of service. RISE 63 Delta’s Employee Network Groups ended 2013 with a 25 percent increase in enrollment from the previous year, with RISE Latin America scheduled to launch in 2014. TRAVEL PERKS Through Delta’s pass travel program, employees and family members are eligible for free or reduced fare travel to any destination that Delta serves. Travel privileges extend to spouses and domestic partners, dependent and adult children, parents and stepparents, and extended family and close friends. RECOGNIZING EMPLOYEE CONTRIBUTIONS Delta’s Chairman’s Club recognizes employees, excluding officers and directors, who consistently demonstrate the highest standards of service to customers, coworkers and the communities Delta serves. Honorees are nominated by their colleagues and are recognized at a gala hosted by senior Delta leaders at the Fox Theater in Atlanta each fall. Along with recognition at the gala, their name is displayed on a Delta aircraft for one year, and they receive two confirmed travel tickets to anywhere Delta serves. In 2013, the 17th year for the program, over 10,000 nominations were received for the 100 to be recognized.. Honorees represented 30 Delta stations in five countries, and on average, had about 22 years of service. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 42 EMBRACING DIVERSITY AT DELTA Delta’s global diversity initiatives strategically position the company for long-term success in a dynamic and challenging environment. The demands of a rapidly changing global business environment are being met by a creative process of design and implementation of 21st century workforce development initiatives. For example, the mission of the Realizing Individual Standards of Excellence (RISE) program is to provide mentors and mentor partners a forum for networking, mutual development, and self-empowerment, thereby increasing individual and collective career advancement. The program provides opportunities for Delta employees by exposing them to other divisions within the organization and providing the opportunity to learn from the mentors’ experiences, challenges and successes in their careers. Mentors and partners also get involved in additional community service and educational opportunities offered by Delta. MARTIN LUTHER KING (MLK), JR. DAY Delta celebrated the MLK legacy with a series of celebrations across the system in January. What started as a celebration in one city branched out to four locations – Atlanta, Minneapolis/St. Paul, Detroit and New York – with more than 1,600 employees in attendance in addition to hundreds of members of local communities. COMMITMENT TO GLOBAL DIVERSITY Employee Network Groups: 64 ABLE Network on Disability Asian-Pacific Employee Network CARING FOR DELTA EMPLOYEES Black Employee Network DELTA EMPLOYEE & RETIREE CARE FUND The Delta Employee & Retiree Care Fund is a nonprofit organization established and managed by Delta employees, retirees and their survivors to provide assistance during severe financial hardships and disasters. Since the October 2007 launch of the Delta Employee & Retiree Care Fund, more than 5,000 Delta family members have received assistance in response to a personal hardship, with many affected by disasters during 2013, including Oklahoma tornados, Typhoon Haiyan, Superstorm Sandy, fires and floods. More than $1.1 million was provided in 2013 to help Delta families facing a crisis. Latin American Hispanic Employee Network Gay and Lesbian Employee Network Veterans Employee Network Women’s Employee Network Realizing Individual Standards of Excellence (RISE) Realizing Individual Standards of Excellence (RISE) Asia Pacific DELTA SCHOLARSHIP FUND The Delta Scholarship Fund, a 501(c)(3) charitable organization directed by a volunteer board of employees, provides academic scholarships to employees, their spouse or domestic partner and eligible dependents pursuing an undergraduate or graduate degree. More than $2.1 million representing 1,780 scholarships has been provided since the Fund launched in 2008 including 506 new awards for the 2014-15 academic year. WRENCHED HEARTS Wrenched Hearts is Delta Air Lines’ employee peer support group for parents who have suffered the tragic loss of a child. Only those who have experienced this specific loss can truly know the impact that a parent experiences. The founder of Wrenched Hearts, Tim Moye, knows the pain and struggle of daily life after experiencing such a loss firsthand. Parents never forget, and having the opportunity to talk about their children is priceless. Wrenched Hearts also provides training in grief support and coping skills. Members develop relationships and find strength and peace in helping others. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 43 CUSTOMERS “For our customers, we continue to invest in the overall travel experience and strive for operational excellence every flight, every day. In 2013, we delivered industry-leading operations with on-time, cancellations, baggage and customer complaint records that uphold our commitment of reliability to our customers.” -- Gil West, executive vice president and Chief Operating Officer 2013 GOALS 2014 GOALS Improve customer preference measured by “net promoter” score for both domestic and international service by 10%…ACHIEVED Earn J.D. Power award for customer service among network carriers Earn J.D. Power award for customer service among network carriers…IN PROGRESS Win Business Travel News survey Win Business Travel News survey…ACHIEVED Be industry leader in D0 (on-time departure) and taxi times Increase “net promoter” score in select categories by 10% SAFEGUARDING PASSENGER HEALTH Because passenger safety during flight is paramount, Delta voluntarily contracts with STAT-MD, a division of emergency services of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. STAT-MD provides 24/7 ground-based medical support for in-flight medical events in addition to fitness to fly medical screening of passengers. Board certified emergency medicine physicians are knowledgeable about Delta’s on-board medical capabilities and the effects of altitude on physiology. In consultation with the captain and medical volunteers, the STAT-MD physician provides treatment recommendations including whether or not the flight should divert for more immediate medical care. Delta exceeds FAA regulatory guidance for on-board medical equipment, supplies and medication. Delta accommodates battery-operated medical devices, including portable oxygen concentrators (POCs) that have been pre-approved by the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) and Delta to ensure compatibility with aviation electronic systems. STAT-MD 65 Delta voluntarily contracts with STAT-MD, a division of emergency services of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. STAT-MD provides 24/7 ground-based medical support for in-flight medical events that occur at 30,000 feet. In 2013, Delta participated in a Transportation Research Board-funded research project on how to make flying an even healthier experience for passengers and crew. SUSTAINING OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE The most important thing Delta can provide its customers is a safe and ontime flight. Delta’s operational performance in 2013 led the U.S.-based, global network carriers. In data published by the U.S. Department of Transportation, Delta people drove best-in-class on-time arrivals at 84.5 percent and a completion factor of 99.7 percent. During the year, there were 119 days where no cancellations were seen due to aircraft maintenance reasons and 72 days of no cancellations for any reason. CUSTOMER SATISFACTION SURVEYS & RANKINGS Delta has established a proactive customer survey program that sends customers one of 20 possible surveys based on the customer’s known experience during their travels. The surveys capture Delta’s performance with the following areas: handling of special situations (e.g., oversold flight), service recovery situations, airport experience, and experience onboard the aircraft. Results are aggregated into scores for all levels of the organization from frontline agents to executive leaders. Delta included customer satisfaction measures in key performance indicators. 66 Delta people drove best-in-class on-time arrivals at 84.5 percent and a completion factor of 99.7 percent. 67 During the year, there were 119 days where no cancellations were seen due to aircraft maintenance reasons and 72 days of no cancellations for any reason. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 45 ALL THE WAY UP In 2013, customers ranked Delta at 4.39 on a 5.00 point scale for airport experience; a 2 percent improvement over 2012 and a 6 percent improvement over 2011. With respect to service recovery, customers ranked Delta at 3.49 representing a 3 percent improvement over 2012 and a 6 percent improvement over 2011. In some instances, airport leaders will contact customers that provided low scores to better understand and resolve the customer’s concern and take local action if necessary. Customers may also voice concerns or complaints through Delta’s Customer Care center. Using survey feedback, Delta implemented “Care While Waiting,” a program designed to give a personal touch to service recovery situations by accommodating a customer’s needs in a given situation rather than having a ‘one-size fits all’ response to a recovery event. To date, customers have shown they prefer this approach and customer satisfactions scores indicate further upward momentum as a result. Delta has begun linking Net Promoter Score (NPS) to survey results in order to improve the customer experience. In 2014, Delta also began surveys related to the customer’s experience with Reservations and SkyClub. Additionally in 2014, customers will be surveyed on aircraft cleanliness which has been selected as a key performance indicator for 2014. INNOVATING EMERGENCY READINESS, RESPONSE AND RECOVERY The goal of Delta’s Emergency Response and Business Continuity programs is to ensure the airline has appropriate plans to mitigate most major business disruptions. The groups are comprised of both corporate and divisional representatives who work hand in hand to develop, maintain, and exercise the plans implemented during a crisis. The focus of Emergency Response is to continuously improve the processes for responding to an aircraft incident. Delta complies with both foreign and domestic family assistance laws enacted to protect accident victims and their families, and ensure airlines meet specific obligations. In order to meet these laws, Delta trains thousands of employee volunteers– known as the Delta Care Team– who work with survivors and/or their families involved in an aircraft incident. The team is capable of being deployed anywhere in the world within hours of an initial notification. In 2013, the Emergency Response program completed the worldwide roll-out of the Local Emergency Response Action Plan (LERAP) template. This document guides all stations when responding to an aircraft incident and ensures a Delta ended 2013 ranked No. 2 for fewest customer complaints reported to the U.S. Department of Transportation, with a complaint ratio of .59 per 100,000 customers. With this, Delta met a year-end goal to lower the rate by 20 percent as part of its All The Way Up campaign. The program highlights the most common complaint drivers and helps provide awareness and solutions to improve customer service. 68 Delta has an established proactive CUSTOMER SURVEY PROGRAM that sends customers one of 20 possible surveys based on the customer’s known experience during their travels. 70 69 The “CARE WHILE WAITING” program provides a personal touch to service recovery situations by accommodating a customer’s needs in a given situation, rather than having a ‘one-size fits all’ response to a recovery event. 71 MINIMIZING CUSTOMER INCONVENIENCE Delta’s VIPER automated rebooking system, launched in 2013, has helped minimize customer inconvenience by getting them to their destinations as quickly as possible. The software, an acronym for Virtual Inconvenienced Passenger Expedited Reprotection, uses creative routings and connecting points to get customer where they need to go, helping to minimize delays after a cancellation. VIPER’s ultimate goal is to minimize average lateness and provide customers with more options within the same day when possible. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 46 8 consistent and timely response. The same document is used by joint venture partners AirFrance and KLM to provide mutual assistance at joint stations around the world. The Business Continuity group works to mitigate disruptions to customers and employees from the loss of key business infrastructure - technology, facilities, personnel, vendor, and natural/man-made disasters. Due to the wide-ranging nature of events/disasters that can occur at any global corporation, it is just as important to maintain an overall response plan for consistently responding to any given crisis. This plan allows for variation yet maintains focus on key company objectives with timeliness being key to success. In addition to departmental business continuity plans, Delta has taken the steps to greatly improve its response capabilities which includes a state-of-the-art notification tool to notify key responders, a crisis management center designed to facilitate communication, and training for key responders so they understand their role in the response process. Having the right tools in the hands of those who can make key decisions and allocate the company’s resources as necessary is important. At the heart of any Delta response is the Operations and Customer Center (OCC) located at the world headquarters in Atlanta. This center operates 24/7/365 with the daily task of managing Delta’s day-to-day operation, but when a crisis occurs, this is the team that kicks off the initial response plan. The OCC will take the lead in responding until the crisis responders are in place and ready to assume control of the event. DEDICATION TO FLIGHT SAFETY Delta’s mission focuses on reducing risk and supporting safe flying operations. In 2013, Delta advanced the safety culture of the airline through program enhancements and continuous improvement. In addition to the advancements made internally, Delta also participated in and led many industry safety initiatives. AVIATION SAFETY ACTION PROGRAM (ASAP) Previously, Delta operated the Aviation Safety Action Program (ASAP) for pilots, load planners, dispatchers, and maintenance technicians. During 2013, 72 In 2013, the Emergency Response program completed the worldwide roll-out of the LERAP template, which guides all stations when responding to an aircraft incident and ensures a consistent and timely response. 73 DELTA’S ADVISORY BOARD ON DISABILITY met in August 2013 to discuss recommendations into the travel experience for passengers with disabilities. During this annual event, Delta partners with the disability community to look for ways to improve customer support and further differentiate their services from the competition. During the two-day working meeting, board members from around the country shared their own recent travel experiences along with presentations on customer-focused projects and innovative tools to aid in the training and education on different disabilities. Research conducted through Delta’s Task Analysis Assessment Tool and the Disability Action Plan - two long-term projects aimed at identifying where passengers with disabilities experience difficulty while traveling - was discussed in addition to meaningful best practices for supporting people with specific disabilities. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 47 Delta implemented a new ASAP for flight attendants. With the addition of the In-Flight division, Delta now provides a safety reporting mechanism for approximately 40,000 frontline employees. With an improved reporting culture and the power of information sharing, numerous systemic safety and operational improvements were completed during the year. FLIGHT OPERATIONAL QUALITY ASSURANCE (FOQA) During 2013, the Flight Operational Quality Assurance (FOQA) team continued to expand its capabilities with the addition of the Boeing 737-900 and Boeing 717-200 fleets into the program. The Boeing 737-900 aircraft is the first fleet at Delta to utilize wireless FOQA technology. Wireless technology will revolutionize FOQA’s ability to collect and analyze flight data with significantly improved speed and efficiency. Additionally, the FOQA team continued to target new avenues for data utilization such as NextGen airspace enhancements, support of improved meteorology tools, fuel conservation, and improved education for maintenance taxi operations. SPECIAL WINTER OPERATIONS AIRPORT (SWOA) PROGRAM Delta continued an industry leading safety program, the Special Winter Operations Airport (SWOA) program, during 2013. With a focus on mitigating the risk of runway excursions during winter weather conditions, the SWOA program included two new airports for the 2013-14 winter season. This program focuses on airport infrastructure, surrounding terrain, snow removal and runway friction measuring procedures, and the timely and accurate communication of field conditions. Delta and Delta Connection carriers completed many airport visits throughout the year to promote and enhance winter operations policies and procedures. With the addition of the In-Flight Service division to the 74 AVIATION SAFETY ACTION PROGRAM, AVIATION SAFETY INFORMATION ANALYSIS AND SHARING (ASIAS) As with many internal improvements, Delta has continued to support industry safety objectives through many organizations such as our participation in Delta now provides a safety reporting and the use of the Aviation Safety Information Analysis and Sharing (ASIAS) system. The ASIAS system is a tool provided by the FAA that promotes the mechanism for approximately 40,000 open exchange of de-identified safety information in order to continuously frontline employees. improve aviation safety. In addition to ASIAS, Delta is an active partner in many national and global safety groups, such as Airlines for America and, SkyTeam. Delta has also led an effort to promote safety advances with each of the Delta Connection partners through the Delta Connection Carrier Safety Alliance. In addition to enhancements to ASAP, FOQA, SWOA and other industry programs, Delta completed numerous investigations, studies, and recommendations that led to training, as well as technical, and procedural enhancements for Delta, Delta Connection, and the entire aviation industry. Delta Flight Safety remains dedicated to the safety of every passenger and crew member on board Delta flights. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 48 Delta was the FIRST PASSENGER AIR CARRIER SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS Implementation of regulator, air carrier and airport Safety Management Systems (SMS) is the next step in the evolution of safety in the aviation industry’s global to formally be offered and join arena. Mandated by the the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), SMS concepts are already regulatory standards in Canada, most of Europe and the FAA’s Safety Management many other countries. In an effort to ensure a complete understanding and Systems (SMS) pilot project for consistency of such a system, the U.S. has not yet mandated the implementation the development of an of SMS. Delta was the first passenger air carrier to formally be offered and join the FAA’s SMS pilot project for the development of an SMS program. This project SMS program. set forth a phased approach to SMS implementation. Delta’s SMS was fully implemented by January 2011; however, the FAA has yet to release a final rule. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) will require SMS by 2015 for all carriers seeking IATA Operational Safety Audit (IOSA) registry. 75 The philosophy behind SMS is that the majority of the operational safety risks remaining and not already engineered out of the system cannot be mitigated through traditional one-sided and reactive policies. Only through a formal, top-down and systemic approach that includes the necessary organizational structures, accountabilities, policies, and procedures, can operational safety hazards be identified and risks mitigated to establish and promote a safety culture. Flight safety is a continuous improvement process and the journey continues at Delta. While SMS is not complex, an airline is a complex, integrated business. Delta not only flies an aircraft between two cities, but employees also maintain, cater, load and unload, and dispatch safe and accurate flight plans, taking into account weather, routing, and any other unique information the crews need to know. Each of those activities is a separate process that has its own inherent risks and mitigation strategies. A comprehensive SMS considers each piece individually, as well as all organizational interfaces and potential process changes needed to run our business safely and efficiently. SMS allows Delta to manage those changes effectively within the scope of the entire operation. Internally, Delta is partnering with the Delta Connection carriers to share best practices, lessons learned and implementation strategies, ensuring all Delta carriers have initiated steps to develop SMS. SkyTeam Alliance partners participate in joint safety assessments and initiatives where one or more carriers face similar safety concerns. Together with its partners in the industry, Delta continues to make SMS an even more robust safety process. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 49 HAZARDOUS MATERIALS Delta transports hazardous materials (HazMat) as revenue cargo and as company material to support technical operations. More than half (53 percent) of these shipments are dry ice used to cool items that are not classified as HazMat. Almost 10 percent of these shipments are diagnostic specimens shipped for testing or analysis. Company material makes up 17 percent of the total shipments in 2013 and the final 20 percent are fully regulated HazMat moved as revenue cargo. Delta has an active HazMat program that is compliant to Titles 14 and 49, Code of Regulations, as well as the ICAO Technical Instructions. To ensure compliance, the Delta Dangerous Goods Council oversees HazMat processes in all affected divisions at Delta and Delta Connection partners. The Delta program also has oversight on HazMat regulations for passengers and crew. One change for 2013 was the addition of HazMat awareness screens for passenger’s carryon and checked baggage. These screens are displayed during ticket purchase and flight check-in and on the internet at delta.com, mobile devices and airport kiosks. ENSURING FLIGHT SECURITY Delta continues to evolve its security program, seeking to mitigate securityrelated risks to passengers and employees while minimizing the impact through customer service initiatives. Throughout 2013, Delta continued to work with government partners to expand a number of these customer service initiatives for the benefit of our passengers, helping to streamline various aspects of the security and immigration process to provide for a better overall travel experience. AUTOMATED PASSPORT CONTROL (APC) KIOSKS Delta has partnered closely with U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) to develop and deploy efficient self-service kiosks, where customers provide government required information and scan their passport before speaking with a CBP officer. Implementation of these kiosks at two Delta gateways (New York’s John F Kennedy International Airport and the Seattle Tacoma International Airport) has significantly reduced the time passengers have to wait for processing into the United States. This program is currently being deployed at a number of additional international gateways. TSA PRE✓ Working with the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), Delta has continued to serve as an industry leader in facilitating increased passenger access to expedited security screening through the Pre✓ program. In addition to working with the TSA to explore ways to expand the program to a larger population of customers, Delta has taken a leading role in the implementation of TSA application centers at major hubs and gateways so that customers have the opportunity to sign up for the program. 76 AWARENESS HAZMAT screens for passenger’s carry-on and checked baggage are displayed during ticket purchase and flight check-in. They are also available on mobile devices, airport kiosks and delta.com. delta.com 77 The new and improved delta.com offers customers an easier way to organize and prepare for their trip with sections like My Trips and My Wallets. 78 IN FLIGHT IDEAS As Delta explores new ways to improve the onboard experience, the company has launched Ideas in Flight, which will test new products and services by gathering real-time feedback from passengers. Customers can participate by accessing the program’s website for free via inflight Wi-Fi while on board transcontinental flights, or through the dedicated tab on the Delta Facebook page. Using these outlets, customers can view Delta initiatives and provide feedback. Delta will use this feedback to determine if the product or service should be refined, added permanently to the transcontinental service, or expanded across the system. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 50 SOCIAL MEDIA 79 UPDATES Seeking to enhance Portuguese-speaking customer experience, Delta launched two new social media channels. Delta’s Twitter (@DeltaAjuda) and Facebook channels were created to improve the travel experience for Brazilian consumers. Delta’s blog (takingoff.delta.com) was also launched in 2013. 680 Delta partnered with TSA to help expedite the security screening program for Delta passengers. 7 SELF SERVE KIOSKS 81 Delta has partnered closely with U.S. Customs and Borders Protection (CBP) to develop and deploy selfservice kiosks where customers provide government required information and scan their passport before speaking with a CBP officer. ALTERNATE PASSENGER PRESCREENING METHOD Building on a successful pilot at London Heathrow Airport over the past two years, Delta continues to work with partners in both the U.S. and UK to develop and deploy an alternate passenger interview methodology that is more effective and efficient for security purposes. CUSTOMER INPUT Delta collects and analyzes a vast amount of customer feedback on their experiences with U.S. government security screening procedures, as well as wait times, in order to work with the government on improving the passenger experience. MOBILE AND BOOKING ENHANCEMENTS MOBILE AND BOOKING ENHANCEMENTS Delta continues to focus on an improved customer experience across the delta.com website. Such improvements include an enhanced SkyMiles tracking experience, the opportunity for customers to offset their carbon emissions at any point in their trip, and the ability to opt into TSA Pre✓. Furthermore, customers can now experience 100 percent WiFi coverage on all domestic mainline aircraft and two-class regional jets, with free access to delta.com, mobile apps and select shopping sites. In-flight enhancements include a library of stored entertainment options, power outlets at select seats, and individual on-demand entertainment on all flights longer than three hours. Delta was the first carrier to apply to the FAA for permission to allow the passengers to use portable electronic devices in all phases of flight. On average, the change offers customers an additional 20-30 minutes of time with their devices on. FLY DELTA APP FOR IPAD Delta released its new Fly Delta app for iPad, adding new functionality and a new look to the already popular app including a feature that lets passengers “see” through the bottom of the plane, with Glass Bottom Jet. Customers on flights have the ability to view the ground below in a unique way that includes maps, social networks and content while connected to the Internet on any of Delta’s more than 800 Wi-Fi-equipped aircraft. The app also includes travel planning tools to book a trip, destination guides, flight check-in, an interactive trip map and a “What’s Next” feature to help guide customers to the next point in their journey. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 51 DELTA.COM The new delta.com design features a new My Delta section which consolidates trip summaries, account details, personal preferences, payment information and travel settings in a single location. This allows customers to easily access the personalized features that mean the most to them and helps maximize their travel plans. An improved My Trips section brings together all details of a customer’s trip including air, car, hotel, Trip Extras, weather information and travel alerts. TERMINAL ENHANCEMENTS PORSCHE 82 PICK UP PROGRAM Delta’s Porsche pick-up service, which began at Atlanta Hartsfield- Jackson International Airport in 2011, has expanded to three major airports: Los Angeles International Airport, New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport and Minneapolis/St. Paul International Airport. The service selects Diamond Medallion members to help them make tight connections. The unsuspecting customers will be greeted at the aircraft boarding door by a Delta Elite Services representative, who will escort them with their baggage to an awaiting vehicle and on to their connecting gate. Each customer is selected for transfer based on a number of factors, including flight operation, connection timing and member status. SELF-SERVICE KIOSKS Changes to Delta’s self-service check-in kiosk designs were launched across all worldwide locations in September 2012 on more than 2,500 individual kiosks. The new design made customer check-in more efficient in 2013, as it reduced the average check-in time by more than 15 percent. The improved design streamlines the process, improves the speed of check-in, offers 12 language options and gives customers the ability to self-select options they find most important in their experience. SKY CLUB INVESTMENTS As Delta focuses on Sky Club upgrades at various airports, these new build projects are becoming increasingly more sustainable in design. Many of the typical components used in new builds are LEED point contributors and include materials such as recycled carpeting manufactured by Shaw, DuPont Quartz surface; Toto faucets and flush valves; glass wall tiles manufactured by Crossville; and HVAC systems which balance airflow, reduce airflow supply in areas not in use, and reduce system operation during closures. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 52 IN-FLIGHT UPGRADES BUSINESSELITE IMPROVEMENTS Delta will complete the installation of flat-bed seating across its fleet of 145 widebody international aircraft in June 2014. Each day, Delta offers more than 5,000 flat-bed seats with direct aisle in BusinessElite® - more than any other airline. Installation of flat-bed seating on the 757-200 transcontinental fleet operating between New York-JFK and Los Angeles, San Francisco and Seattle - will be complete in June 2015. Delta partnered with Westin to offer new Westin Heavenly In-Flight bedding in BusinessElite cabins throughout the world. Old BusinessElite duvets were donated to various charities and orphanages of local communities where we fly: South Africa, Japan, Peru, Guatemala and Haiti. Additionally, BusinessElite amenities kits were upgraded to feature Tumi and Malin+Goetz products. Old sleep masks, socks and toiletries were donated to organizations in Guatemala, Honduras and Haiti. MENU ENHANCEMENTS Delta’s high value customers and members of the media were invited to Restaurant Eugene in Atlanta to sample the airline’s BusinessElite menus for key transatlantic routes from Atlanta. The menus have been designed by Chef Linton Hopkins, winner of Delta’s “Cabin Pressure Cook-Off” competition, who uses ingredients grown or sourced in Georgia to prepare his latest offerings. Chef Hopkins sources his poultry from White Oak Pastures, a Georgia farm that exemplifies responsible livestock practices. Delta has also expanded Economy Comfort offerings on transcontinental flights with healthy wraps developed by California-based Luvo. The recent addition comes in response to positive customer feedback on Luvo snacks that are featured on Delta’s West Coast Shuttle between Los Angeles and San Francisco. The airline was commended by The Pew Charitable Trusts for its new in-flight food selection, including poultry from partner Luvo that was raised without antibiotics or added hormones. FLY DELTA The new app for iPad offers a feature called “Glass Bottom Jet,” which allows passengers to “see” through the bottom of their plane. 83 84 SKY CLUB INVESTMENTS The Delta Sky Club at San Diego International Airport features LEED certified paint, ceiling tile products and water-based HVAC duct sealant. IN-FLIGHT AMENITIES 85 Delta partnered with Westin to offer new Westin Heavenly In-Flight bedding in BusinessElite cabin. Old BusinessElite duvets were donated to charities in South Africa, Japan, Peru, Guatemala and Haiti. 86 HEALTHIER MENUS Delta expanded the Economy Comfort menu on transcontinental flights with healthy wraps developed by California-based Luvo. 87 Chef Linton Hopkins, winner of Delta’s “Cabin Pressure Cook-Off” competition, uses ingredients grown or sourced in Georgia. Poultry is sourced from White Oak Pastures, a Georgia farm that exemplifies responsible livestock practices. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 53 INVESTORS “Delta is leading an industry revival and attracting new investors. In 2013, we achieved our fourth consecutive year of profitability, rejoined the S&P 500 index and began rewarding shareholders with quarterly dividends and a share repurchase program. Over the years, we have reshaped our business model to reduce financial risk and to further enhance our sustainability, striving to be the airline of choice for employees, customers and investors.” -- Paul Jacobson, executive vice president and Chief Financial Officer 2013 FINANCIAL GOALS 2014 FINANCIAL GOALS Produce at least $300M of value through the Monroe Trainer Refinery…IN PROGRESS Quarterly dividends of approximately $200 million a year Deliver projected return from $1 billion ancillary and seat related revenue … ACHIEVED Produce at least $300M of value through the Monroe Trainer Refinery Improve ancillary revenue to $670M and improve digital channel customer satisfaction to industry-leading levels FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE 2013 2011 2012 2013 $35,115 $36,670 $37,773 $25, 714 $26,432 $26,021 Employee Wages and Benefits $7,158 $7,638 $8,226 Payments to Providers of Capital $1,122 $1,044 $1,243 $76 $100 $89 Payroll $1,541 $1,550 $1,858 Other $300 $377 $312 $9.7 $11.3 $23.4 $8.09 $11.87 $27.47 $6.62-13.00 $8.01-12.1 $11.97-29.44 $490.0 $340.0 $461.0 Net Profit1 $1,190 $1,552 $2,699 Operating Profit1 $2,243 $2,600 $3,526 (in millions USD, except per share data) DIRECT ECONOMIC VALUE GENERATED Revenue ECONOMIC VALUE DISTRIBUTED Non-Labor Operating Costs1 Payments to Government Income, federal, state Property COMMUNITY INVESTMENTS Contributions SHAREHOLDER VALUE Share price at Dec. 31 Share price range SUPPLIER SPEND Minority Women owned Business Enterprise spend ECONOMIC VALUE RETAINED These items are non-GAAP financial measures as defined in the Appendix. Reconciliations to the corresponding GAAP financial measures and the reasons Non-GAAP financial measures are used are 1. included in the Appendix. Delta’s net income for 2013 was $2.7 billion, excluding special items, a $1.1 billion increase over 2012. 2013 results include $506 million in profit sharing expense. Delta generated nearly $5 billion of operating cash flow and $2.1 billion of free cash flow in 2013, allowing the company to reduce its adjusted net debt at the end of 2013 to $9.4 billion, contribute an incremental $250 million above its minimum required funding to its defined benefit pension plans, and return $350 million to shareholders through a combination of $100 million of dividends and $250 million of share repurchases. 88 S&P 500 On Sept. 10, 2013, Delta shares were added to Standard & Poor’s 500 index of large companies. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 55 89 90 91 STOCK PRICE PERFORMANCE In 2013, Delta’s stock price increased more than 130 percent, resulting in the highest market capitalization of any U.S. carrier. In 2013, Delta was the fourth best performing stock in the S&P 500. STANDARD & POORS CREDIT RATING In December 2013, Delta’s corporate credit rating was raised to a “BB- and Stable Outlook” from a “B+ and CreditWatch Positive” rating. This improvement in credit rating lowers the company’s borrowing costs and increases Delta’s access to capital. CAPITAL DEPLOYMENT In May 2013, Delta’s Board of Directors approved a capital deployment program that will return more than $5 billion of value to shareholders by 2016 through the following channels: • Quarterly dividends of approximately $200 million per year • Share repurchases of $500 million • Debt reduction of $3 billion • Pension funding of $1 billion MANAGING DELTA’S LARGEST EXPENSE As global jet fuel prices have risen significantly in recent years, Delta has focused on finding innovative solutions to managing its largest expense. The fuel optimization campaign is a broad effort that touches numerous areas of Delta’s operation and financial strategy. One major focus is on reshaping Delta’s domestic fleet, reducing the number of aircraft that are less fuel-efficient and replacing them with larger, more efficient aircraft that also provide a superior on-board experience for customers and are more environmentally friendly. Delta has also implemented a sophisticated financial hedging program, which reduces the risk of volatility in global energy markets and makes it easier to plan for fuel costs. 92 Delta’s refinery in Trainer, Penn., provides approximately 80 percent of Delta’s domestic fuel needs in the United States. Additionally, Delta’s Monroe Energy subsidiary operates the airline industry’s only oil refinery, in Trainer, Pa., which refines jet fuel and exchanges gasoline and other refined products for additional jet fuel, providing about 80 percent of Delta’s domestic fuel needs in the U.S. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 56 2 Alongside jet fuel production, Delta believes that Monroe Energy has helped keep the overall cost of jet fuel down by maintaining the refining capacity in the northeastern U.S. that otherwise would have been shuttered. A team of energy industry experts continues the process of improving the refinery’s operations and maximizing the amount of jet fuel produced, which is expected to provide further savings in 2014. FLEET STRATEGY Delta’s ongoing sustainability efforts include implementing innovative strategies to reduce aircraft fuel burn per passenger as a response to the volatility and magnitude of Delta’s largest variable cost. Delta’s fleet strategy also aims to improve revenue generation and produce capacity more efficiently. In 2013, Delta began taking delivery of the first of 100 new Boeing 737-900ERs, 88 Boeing 717-200s, and 40 new Bombardier CRJ-900s. These larger and more fuel-efficient jets pave the way to continue to retire 50-seat regional jets, as well as older mainline aircraft. These investments are key to ensuring Delta reduces its carbon footprint and meets the IATA 1.5 percent average fuel efficiency improvement goal year over year. The combination of these aircraft deliveries and retirements and more efficient use of aircraft cabins allows Delta to generate the same capacity levels with fewer departures, yielding economic improvement, environmental benefits, and reduced airspace congestion. INVESTING IN STRATEGIC REGIONAL PARTNERSHIPS Initiatives such as replacing older aircraft with larger, more fuel efficient jets help to reduce carbon emissions per passenger. 93 94 Delta gained improved access to London Heathrow, the leading transatlantic Delta PARTNERED with Virgin Atlantic, marketplace, through its alliance with Virgin Atlantic. The alliance began allowing the airline to expand its access with a codesharing agreement in July 2013, and the airlines were granted full to trans-Atlantic routes out of LondonAntitrust Immunity in September 2013. On Jan. 4, 2014, the alliance began Heathrow, in particular to and from New operating with both airlines sharing both revenue and expenses from all joint York-JFK. venture transatlantic flights regardless of which carrier operates the service. The partnership will help Delta compete in the London Heathrow market and significantly expand its London to JFK service. The enhanced London service also allows Delta and its partners to offer service in each of Europe’s leading markets, a network unmatched by others in the industry. Virgin Atlantic’s reach will expand significantly with its new access to Delta’s North America network. BECOMING THE BEST U.S. AIRLINE IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN Delta has invested more than U.S. $65 million in Aeroméxico as part of a long-term exclusive commercial alliance and entered a code sharing agreement with Aerolíneas Argentinas solidifying its footprint in Latin America. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 57 BRAZIL As Brazil is expected to become the fourth-largest aviation market in the world by 2014, with increased customer interest in the upcoming 2014 FIFA World Cup and the 2016 Summer Olympics, the Delta-GOL codeshare agreement enhances Delta’s network by providing access to 23 destinations in Brazil. Through this partnership, customers have reciprocal access to GOL’s VIP lounges in Sao Paulo, Rio de Janerio, Atlanta, New York-JFK and Detroit. Access to priority check-in and boarding are available for customers on both carriers. Delta was recognized with the “Best Airline to North America” award on the Prêmio Destaque Companhia de Viagem. 95 Based on feedback from frequent business travelers, new BusinessElite flat-bed seats with direct aisle access are available on flights from New York to Sao Paolo. In addition, Westin Heavenly In-Flight bedding, Tumi and Malin+Goetz amenity kits and Latin-inspired meal selections are available in the BusinessElite cabin. As a result of these efforts, Delta was recognized with the “Best Airline to North America” award on the Prêmio Destaque Companhia de Viagem. The award was delivered by Grupo Companhia, responsible for travel magazine and television show Companhia de Viagem. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 58 AS A RESULT OF THE EFFORTS OF OUR EMPLOYEES… THREE GOLD ADDY AWARDS FOR THE DELTA KIOSK THE ADVERTISING CLUB OF METROPOLITAN WASHINGTON BEST AIRFRAME MRO PROVIDER IN THE AMERICAS AIRCRAFT TECHNOLOGY ENGINEERING & MAINTENANCE MAGAZINE FIVE STAR DIAMOND AWARD FOR THE NEW TERMINAL 4 AT NEW YORK - JFK AMERICAN ACADEMY OF HOSPITALITY SCIENCES BEST NORTH AMERICAN AIRLINE BUSINESS TRAVELLER MAGAZINE NAMED FOR THE THIRD CONSECUTIVE YEAR TO THE DJSI FOR NORTH AMERICA, RECOGNIZING COMMITMENT TO INTEGRATE SUSTAINABLE PRACTICES INTO THE WORKPLACE BRONZE LION FOR THE FLY DELTA APP THE CANNES LIONS INTERNATIONAL FESTIVAL OF CREATIVITY DOW JONES SUSTAINABILITY INDEX 96 DELTA AWARDS NO. 1 RANKING IN THE HOLISTIC WORLD SAFETY AWARDS AIR TRANSPORT RATING AGENCY “MOST ADMIRED AIRLINE” AND OVERALL “SUPPLIER OF THE YEAR” BY THE READERS' CHOICE AWARDS THE BEAT NO. 1 FOR THE THIRD CONSECUTIVE YEAR IN THE BTN ANNUAL AIRLINE SURVEY; ED BASTIAN NAMED ONE OF THE TOP 25 MOST INFLUENTIAL BUSINESS TRAVEL EXECUTIVES OF 2013 BUSINESS TRAVEL NEWS 97 RESERVATION SALES AND CUSTOMER CARE NAMED “BEST OF THE BEST” AND ALLISON AUSBAND, V.P.RESERVATION SALES AND CUSTOMER CARE, NAMED TOP CUSTOMER SERVICE EXECUTIVE AS PART OF THE INTERNATIONAL SERVICE EXCELLENCE AWARDS 14 LEADING EDGE AWARDS FOR U.S. AIRLINES INCLUDING GOLD FOR BEST DOMESTIC AIRLINE, DOMESTIC AIRLINE AIRPORT LOUNGE, BEST DOMESTIC AIRLINE FREQUENT-FLYER PROGRAM, BEST DOMESTIC AIRLINE PREMIUM-CLASS SERVICE, BEST FLIGHT EXPERIENCE TO AFRICA AND BEST PRIVATE JET TYPE FOR DELTA PRIVATE JETS EXECUTIVE TRAVEL MAGAZINE CUSTOMER SERVICE INSTITUTE OF AMERICA 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 59 98 MOST ADMIRED AIRLINE WORLDWIDE IN THE 2013 WORLD'S MOST ADMIRED COMPANIES AIRLINE INDUSTRY LIST NAMED MOST HONORED COMPANY, ACKNOWLEDGING RICHARD ANDERSON AS BEST CEO (BUY AND SELL SIDE), PAUL JACOBSON AS BEST CFO (BUY SIDE) AND DELTA AS BEST COMPANY INVESTOR RELATIONS (BUY SIDE) INSTITUTIONAL INVESTOR FORTUNE MAGAZINE CORPORATE COMPANY OF THE YEAR PENCIL AWARD FOR MOBILE APPLICATIONS /SITES/ SERVICES/ UTILITIES FOR THE FLY DELTA APP THE ONE SHOW LATINO TRENDSETTER AWARDS 99 DELTA CEO RICHARD ANDERSON NAMED 2013 TONY JANNUS AWARD WINNER BEST DOMESTIC AIRLINE AT THE READER’S CHOICE AWARDS; RICHARD ANDERSON RECEIVES LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT AWARD BEST DOMESTIC AIRLINE TRAVELAGE WEST THE TONY JANNUS DISTINGUISHED AVIATION SOCIETY TRAVEL WEEKLY DELTA RECOGNITION BEST AIRLINE FOR DOMESTIC FIRST CLASS, BEST FREQUENT-FLYER CUSTOMER SERVICE, AMERICAS (SKYMILES) AND BEST FREQUENT-FLYER AFFINITY CREDIT CARD PROMOTIONS (DELTA SKYMILES BY AMERICAN EXPRESS). GLOBAL TRAVELER MAGAZINE 2ND AMONG MAJOR NETWORK AIRLINES J.D. POWER AND ASSOCIATES: NORTH AMERICAN AIRLINE SATISFACTION STUDY GOLD, SILVER AND BRONZE STEVIES FOR DELTA RESERVATIONS IN FRONTLINE CUSTOMER SERVICE PROFESSIONAL OF THE YEAR TRANSPORTATION GOLD AIRLINE OF THE YEAR LAURIERS DU VOYAGE D’AFFAIRS GOLD STEVIE FOR @DELTAASSIST IN THE ECOMMERCE CUSTOMER SERVICE AWARD AIRLINE INDUSTRY LEADERSHIP AWARD TOP TRAVEL MAGAZINE IN CHINA TOP U.S. AIRLINE FOR BEST OVERALL USE OF SOCIAL MEDIA TRAVEL+LEISURE GOLD STEVIE FOR DELTA SALES SUPPORT AND SILVER STEVIE FOR RESERVATIONS AND CUSTOMER CARE IN CUSTOMER SERVICE DEPARTMENT OF THE YEAR AIRLINES, DISTRIBUTION & TRANSPORTATION STEVIE AWARDS FOR SALES & CUSTOMER SERVICE ALFRED P. SLOAN AWARD FOR EXCELLENCE IN WORKPLACE EFFECTIVENESS AND FLEXIBILITY WHEN WORK WORKS AND THE SOCIETY FOR HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 100 AIRLINE OF THE YEAR 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 60 Delta was named the Airline of the Year by ATW. APPENDIX 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 61 GRI 3.1 INDICATORS While a complete materiality analysis has not been completed for Delta in the transition over to G4, SASB and internal materiality analyses were used to identify 23 GRI indicators to include within the body of the report. Data for an additional 16 indicators have been included for reference. EC1 Direct economic value generated and distributed, including revenues, operating costs, employee compensation, donations and other community investments, retained earnings, and payments to capital providers and governments. Page 55 EC2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities for the organization's activities due to climate change. Page 16 EC6 Policy, practices, and proportion of spending on locally-based suppliers at significant locations of operation. Page 29 EN6 Initiatives to provide energy-efficient or renewable energy based products and services, and reductions in energy requirements as a result of these initiatives. Page 11-20 EN7 Initiatives to reduce indirect energy consumption and reductions achieved Page 9 EN8 Total water withdrawal by source Page 15 EN12 Description of significant impacts of activities, products, and services on biodiversity in protected areas and areas of high biodiversity value outside protected areas. Page 21 EN16 Total direct and indirect greenhouse gas emissions by weight Page 18 EN17 Other relevant indirect greenhouse gas emissions by weight Page 18 EN18 Initiatives to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and reductions achieved Page 17-20 EN20 NO, SO, and other significant air emissions by type and weight Page 11 EN22 Total weight of waste by type and disposal method Page 12 EN23 Total number and volume of significant spills. Page 10 EN26 Initiatives to mitigate environmental impacts of products and services, and extent of impact mitigation Page 16-21 EN28 Monetary value of significant fines and total number of non-monetary sanctions for noncompliance with environmental laws and regulations Page 10 HR3 Total hours of employee training on policies and procedures concerning aspects of human rights that are relevant to operations, including the percentage of employees trained Page 35-36 LA2 Benefits provided to full-time employees that are not provided to temporary or part-time employees, by significant location of operation. Page 40-42 LA6 Percentage of total workforce represented in formal joint management-worker health and safety committees that help monitor and advise on occupational health and safety programs. Page 34 LA7 Rates of injury, occupational diseases, lost days, and absenteeism, and total number of workrelated fatalities, by region and by gender Page 32 LA8 Education, training, counseling prevention, and risk-control programs in place to assist workforce members, their families, or community members regarding serious diseases Page 41 LA10 Average hours of training per year per employee by gender, and by employee category Page 39 LA12 Percentage of employees receiving regular performance and career development reviews, by gender. Page 39 PR5 Practices related to customer satisfaction, including results of surveys measuring customer satisfaction Page 45-46 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 62 Additional GRI 3.1 Indicators: EC3 | Coverage of the organization’s defined benefit plan obligations Based on the most recent estimates, Delta’s four defined benefit plans are funded between 46 percent and 68 percent, based on interest rates used for funding purposes. Delta expects to fully meet its obligations under the defined benefit plans by a combination of employer contributions and investment return. In 2013, Delta contributed nearly $900 million to its defined benefit plans. EC4 | Significant financial assistance received from government The Iron Range Resources Rehabilitation Board in Minnesota agreed in 2013 to provide $5.9 million to Delta to refurbish the Delta Customer Engagement Center in Chisholm, MN. The State of Minnesota gave a grant of $550,000 to Endeavor Air (formerly Pinnacle), a Delta wholly owned subsidiary to move its headquarters from MEM to MSP. EC5 | Range of ratios of standard entry level wage by gender compared to local minimum wage at significant locations of operation Entry-level pay for published scale positions meets or exceeds all U.S. federal, state and local minimum wage requirements and complies with the U.S. Equal Pay Act that requires men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work. Delta is equally committed to competitive pay in all international locations. EC7 | Procedures for local hiring and proportion of senior management hired from the local community at locations of significant operation 90.4% of total management employees are hired locally. EC9 | Understanding and describing significant indirect economic impacts, including the extent of impacts. According to ATAG’s Aviation: Benefits beyond borders report, aviation provides 56.6 million jobs worldwide and $2.2 trillion of global GDP. If aviation were a country, it would be the 19th largest economy in the world. Air transport carries around 35% of world trade by value and only 0.5% by volume. EN3 & EN4 | Direct (and indirect) energy consumption by primary energy source Energy Source Consumed Mainline aircraft Fuel oil Amount consumed 3,162,801,043 Units US gallons Conversion factor GJ 0.144 455,443,350.19 Subsidiary: 0.00 Delta Private Jets Fuel oil 4,152,539.50 US gallons 0.144 597,965.69 Endeavor 76,022,832 US gallons 0.144 10,947,287.81 Fuel oil Jet Fuel Fuel oil US gallons 0.144 0.00 Diesel Diesel US gallons 0.138 0.00 Gasoline Gasoline US gallons 0.125 0.00 Natural Gas Electricity 1,253,305.47 Mmbtu 1.055 1,322,237.27 Owned Facilities Electricity 370,351,590.28 kilowatt-hour 0.0036 1,333,265.73 Leased Facilities Electricity 200,064,605.64 kilowatt-hour 0.0036 720,232.58 TOTAL: 470,364,339.26 EN24 | Weight of transported, imported, exported or treated waste deemed hazardous under the terms of the Basel Convention Annex I, II, III, and VIII, and percentage of transported waste shipped internationally Zero 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 63 HR1 & HR2 | Percentage and total number of significant investment agreements and contracts that include clauses incorporating human rights concerns, or that have undergone human rights screening, Percentage of significant suppliers, contractors, and other business partners that have undergone human rights screening, and actions taken Introduce a clause in contracts with relevant suppliers, stating a common repudiation of commercial sexual exploitation of children. Supply Chain Management has developed specific language to use in contracts that support the code on a case by case basis. To date, this has been included in six contracts. In addition, Supply Chain Management will include related language in Delta’s Supplier Code of Conduct, which was distributed in 2013. Compliance with Delta’s Supplier Code of Conduct will be a requirement for doing business with Delta. LA4 | Percentage of employees covered by collective bargaining agreements Union Participation as % of Total Employees: 16% LA5 | Minimum notice period(s) regarding operational changes, including whether it is specified in collective agreements In rare instances where Delta must close a facility or significantly reduce the size of its workforce, affected employees are usually offered an opportunity for employment in a similar position in another city or through voluntary retirement incentive programs. In addition, Delta follows the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act requirements for U.S.-based employees which requires most employers with 100 or more employees to provide notification 60 calendar days in advance of station closings and significant workforce reductions. Similarly, all individual country legal requirements are adhered to prior to significant operational changes at Delta’s international stations. LA9 | Health and safety topics covered in formal agreements with trade unions Formal domestic and international union agreements also address safety and health at a broad level to ensure compliance with governmental regulations and standards. Health and safety topics include employee safety committees; participation of employees in health and safety inspections, audits, and accident investigations; and training and education. LA11 | Programs for skills management and lifelong learning that support the continued employability of employees and assist them in managing career endings To support employees in meeting financial goals for retirement, Delta sponsors both defined benefit and defined contribution 401(k) plans in the U.S. and in some international locations. Employee resources for the management of career endings include financial planning resources, EAP retirement counseling and pension and 401(k) investment advice and modeling. S03| Percentage of employees trained in organization’s anti-corruption policies and procedures 97 percent of Delta’s salaried employees have completed Delta’s Ethics and Compliance course for 2013 S06| Total value of financial and in-kind contributions to political parties, politicians, and related institutions by country In 2013, DeltaPAC contributed a total of $160,100 to various candidates for federal election campaigns. Corporate political contributions totaled $57,700 in Georgia and $16,250 in Michigan. 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 64 DELTA AIR LINES GHG EMISSIONS INVENTORY SUMMARY TABLE GHG Emissions (Metric Tons CO2e) EMISSIONS SOURCE 2005 2011 2012 2013 Mainline Aircraft 38,158,943 30,867,314 30,359,915 31,159,188 Wholly Owned Subsidiaries Aircraft 3,582,676 872,763 465,057 794,547 Ground Support Equipment 133,194 107,784 94,706 99,441 Stationary Combustion Facilities 55,593 76,404 67,675 78,180 Refrigerants 10,513 4,629 4,820 4,323 Chemicals 3,469 2,974 2,127 1,895 242 208 234 221 Directly Billed 227,169 299,107 251,428 226,029 Leased Facilities 193,249 117,478 117,433 114,411 Regional Partners 3,808,637 6,265,095 6,322,131 5,770,732 Total 46,173,685 38,613,757 37,685,527 38,248,968 Scope 1 Emergency Generators Scope 2 Scope 3 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 65 RECONCILIATION OF GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES TO NONGAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES Delta sometimes uses information (“non-GAAP financial measures”) that is derived from the Consolidated Financial Statements, but that is not presented in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the U.S. (“GAAP”). Under the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission rules, non-GAAP financial measures may be considered in addition to results prepared in accordance with GAAP, but should not be considered a substitute for or superior to GAAP results. The tables below show reconciliations of nonGAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures. Net Profit, Operating Income, all excluding special items. Delta excludes special items from net income and other measures because management believes the exclusion of these items is helpful to investors to evaluate the company’s recurring core operational performance in the period shown. Therefore, Delta adjusts for these amounts to arrive at more meaningful financial measures. Special items excluded in the tables below are: • Mark-to-market adjustments for fuel hedges recorded in periods other than the settlement period (“MTM adjustments”). MTM adjustments are based on market prices at the end of the reporting period for contracts settling in future periods. Such market prices are not necessarily indicative of the actual future value of the underlying hedge in the contract settlement period. Therefore, excluding these adjustments allows investors to better understand and analyze the company’s core operational performance in the periods shown. • Restructuring and other items. Because of the variability in restructuring and other items, the exclusion of this item is helpful to investors to analyze the company’s recurring core operational performance in the period shown. • Release of tax valuation allowance. Because of the uniqueness of the net gain related to the reversal of the tax valuation allowance, the exclusion of this gain allows investors to better understand and analyze the company’s core operational performance in the period shown. • Loss on extinguishment of debt. Because of the variability in loss on extinguishment of debt, the exclusion of this item is helpful to investors to analyze the company’s recurring core operational performance in the period shown. YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2011 (in millions) NET INCOME $ 2012 854 $ 1,009 2013 $ 10,540 Items excluded: MTM adjustments 26 (27) (276) Loss on extinguishment of debt 68 118 - Restructuring and other items 242 452 424 Release of tax valuation allowance Net income excluding special items OPERATING INCOME (7,989) $ $ 1,190 1,975 $ $ 1,552 2,175 $ $ 2,699 3,400 Items excluded: MTM adjustments Restructuring and other items Operating income excluding special items $ 26 (27) (276) 242 452 402 2,243 $ 2,600 $ 3,526 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 66 OPERATING EXPENSES (NON-LABOR OPERATING COSTS) In addition to the special items described above, Delta excludes salaries and related costs and profit sharing to show non-labor operating costs because this metric allows investors to better understand and analyze recurring costs of the business other than labor. YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2011 (in millions) OPERATING EXPENSES $ 2012 33,140 $ 34,495 2013 $ 34,373 Items excluded: MTM adjustments (26) 27 276 Restructuring and other items (242) (452) (402) Operating expenses excluding special items $ 32,872 $ 34,070 $ 34,247 Less: Salaries and related costs 6,894 7,266 7,720 Profit sharing 264 372 506 Non-Labor Operating Costs(1) $ 25,714 $ 26,432 $ 26,021 Operating expenses excluding special items and employee wages and benefits (1) FUEL HEDGE GAINS (LOSSES), EXCLUDING MTM ADJUSTMENTS Delta excludes MTM adjustments from total fuel hedge gains (losses) because, as described above, excluding these adjustments allows investors to better understand and analyze Delta’s costs for the periods reported. YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2011 (in millions) FUEL HEDGE GAINS (LOSSES) $ 2012 420 $ (66) 2013 $ 444 Items excluded: MTM adjustments Fuel hedge gains (losses) excluding MTM adjustments 26 $ 446 (27) $ (93) (276) $ 168 ADJUSTED NET DEBT: Delta uses adjusted total debt, including aircraft rent, in addition to long-term adjusted debt and capital leases, to present estimated financial obligations. Delta reduces adjusted total debt by cash, cash equivalents, and short-term investments, resulting in adjusted net debt to present the amount of additional assets needed to satisfy the debt. Management believes this metric is helpful to investors in assessing the company’s overall debt profile. YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, (in billions) 2013 DEBT AND CAPITAL LEASE OBLIGATIONS $11.3 Plus: unamortized discount, net from purchase accounting and fresh start reporting Adjusted debt and capital lease obligations .4 $ 11.7 Plus: 7x last twelve months' aircraft rent 1.5 Adjusted total debt 13.2 Less: cash, cash equivalents and short-term investments (3.8) ADJUSTED NET DEBT $9.4 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 67 FREE CASH FLOW Delta presents free cash flow because management believes this metric is helpful to investors to evaluate the company’s ability to generate cash that is available for use for debt service or general corporate initiatives. YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, (in billions) 2013 NET CASH PROVIDED BY OPERATING ACTIVITIES (GAAP) $4.5 Net cash used in investing activities (GAAP) (2.7) Adjustment: SkyMiles used pursuant to advance purchase under AMEX agreement Total free cash flow 0.3 $2.1 OPERATING CASH FLOW, ADJUSTED Delta presents net cash provided by operations because management believes adjusting for certain items is helpful to investors to evaluate the company’s operating activities. YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, (in billions) 2013 NET CASH PROVIDED BY OPERATING ACTIVITIES (GAAP) $4.5 Adjustment: SkyMiles used pursuant to advance purchase under AMEX agreement 0.3 Operating cash flow, adjusted $4.8 2013 DELTA CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY REPORT | 68