1 | Page Raleigh County Community Action Association Community
Transcription
1 | Page Raleigh County Community Action Association Community
1 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Table of Contents Introduction ________________________________________________ 3 Executive Summary __________________________________________ 3 RCCAA Agency Profile and Services ____________________________ 10 Develop the Plan ____________________________________________ 14 Collect Data ________________________________________________ 22 County Profile ______________________________________________ 29 Survey Respondent Profile and Overall Results ____________________ 32 Poverty Indicators Employment ____________________________________________________ 38 Education ______________________________________________________ 46 Housing ________________________________________________________ 51 Health _________________________________________________________ 56 Nutrition _______________________________________________________ 64 Use of Income ___________________________________________________ 68 Transportation __________________________________________________ 74 Emergency Situations _____________________________________________ 77 Additional Key Indicator: Children’s Needs _____________________________ 83 Analyze Data ______________________________________________ 103 Raleigh County _________________________________________________ 105 Take Action _______________________________________________ 107 Appendices: A - RCCAA Community Needs Survey B - Resources 2 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report INTRODUCTION Community Action Agencies have been key players in the war on poverty since their inception in the 1960s. Because they work directly with low-income individuals and families in dealing with the problems of poverty on a daily basis, Community Action Agencies are uniquely qualified to examine the needs of communities and individuals as they strive to eliminate poverty. In most cases, Community Action Agencies provide a wide range of services that address a variety of poverty problems. Why, then, does poverty continue to affect so many Americans? How can Raleigh County Community Action Association (RCCAA) develop and improve strategies to be more effective in helping people move out of poverty? Before answering these questions and deciding upon an approach, RCCAA must determine what NEEDS exist in Raleigh County. Before determining a plan of action, RCCAA must develop a deep understanding of the current conditions, likely future trends, and issues of greatest concern within the county. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In May 2013, Raleigh County Community Action Association enlisted the assistance of Kingery and Company, LLC, to conduct a needs assessment in Raleigh County. The project included surveying residents, interviewing community stakeholders, conducting secondary data research, facilitating an analysis retreat, and providing a summary report with key findings and recommendations. Goal: Plan and conduct an all-inclusive Community Needs Assessment for RCCAA in 2013 ensuring compliance with the Community Services Block Grant and Head Start/Early Head Start program requirements. Objectives: Provide a broad view of demographic and economic changes, region and county infrastructure, and community-wide changes. Focus on providing a localized assessment of needs by reporting county level data. Collect primary data by gathering external community feedback through surveys and interviews with key stakeholders, etc. Collect secondary data by researching national, state and local data resources, and utilizing RCCAA’s customer outcome tracking system. Facilitate an analysis process that identifies potential causes of poverty. Mobilize RCCAA and community resources in action plans that address priority needs. Coverage Area: Raleigh County, West Virginia RCCAA Agency Overview: RCCAA is one of 16 Community Action Agencies located in West Virginia. RCCAA is a private, non-profit corporation that provides a wide variety of services to low-income individuals and families. RCCAA Mission: RCCAA empowers individuals and families to reach their highest levels of social and economic self-sufficiency, while identifying and eliminating causes of poverty. 3 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report RCCAA Vision: RCCAA will strive to eliminate poverty by serving as a leader, resource, and advocate for individuals and families in need. RCCAA Programs: Head Start Action Auto Repair Transportation Pine Haven Center Housing Services Community needs assessments can and should be more than just a gathering and analyzing of data; they can also be a basis for creating change. A comprehensive community-based needs assessment can help an agency address community and family needs by providing a snapshot of the community and families within that community, including their economic well-being, educational status, health, and welfare. A comprehensive assessment can provide important community information regarding the work of other agencies or organizations may be working on to address particular issues, and where gaps in community services lie. It provides a mechanism to meet and develop partnerships with other community groups interested in strengthening services to citizens in the area. Finally, a comprehensive community needs assessment can help an agency in its planning process by providing the foundation for strategic and operational planning, assessing the agency’s impact on meeting the needs of the community, determining what programs or strategies may have become obsolete, and deciding what strategies may provide new opportunities for the agency and the community. A multi-level community needs assessment approach was used to provide guidance in the planning process for improving services and programs to combat poverty in Raleigh County. The comprehensive needs assessment can be used for a variety of situations, including the following: Guide board governance in sound decision-making Create opportunities for community buy-in to the agency’s planning process Create opportunities for new alliances and connections with new partners Form successful strategies Ensure services meet the current needs of the community Build credibility Provide a foundation for pursuing new/different funding Guide staff training and educational planning Enhance RCCAA’s capacity to respond to change Generate authentic input from stakeholders Indicate causes as well as conditions of poverty Assessing Needs - The Four Step Process Step One: Develop a Plan The first step with any project begins with development of a plan, a plan that maintains focus on the big picture all the while accounting for every detail. A work plan comprised of tasks, timelines, responsible persons, and progress updates served to guide the needs assessment process. As with any quality planning process, it was critical to bring the right people to the table. Thinking beyond RCCAA staff, it was important to engage members of the community in the 4 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report needs assessment process. This took place in the formation of a Needs Assessment Steering Committee comprised of internal staff (management and staff) and external community stakeholders. External stakeholders included representatives of City of Beckley, United Way, FMRS, DHHR, The Dream Center, Salvation Army, Beckley-Raleigh County Health Department, United Bank, Access Health, Commission on Aging, YMCA, Memorial Baptist Church, and Birth to Three. The Steering Committee served to set direction, assist with the collection of primary data, monitor progress, and analyze results. Step Two: Collect Data Since RCCAA is an anti-poverty organization, it was important to use the community action areas as the foundation on which to build the needs assessment. They include the following: To remove obstacles and solve problems that block the achievement of self-sufficiency, the statewide needs assessment explores the eight community action poverty indicators. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. To secure and retain meaningful employment. To obtain and maintain adequate housing and a suitable living environment. To benefit from accessible and affordable healthcare. To attain an adequate education, with particular attention toward improving literacy skills of the low-income families. To ensure proper nutrition by encouraging healthy eating habits. To make better use of available income. To utilize available transportation options. To obtain emergency assistance to meet immediate and urgent family and individual basic living needs. With guidance from the WV Community Action Partnership, the state association representing 16 community action agencies, and the WV Office of Economic Opportunity, the following poverty indicators served as our primary and secondary data collection issue areas. Poverty Indicators: Health Employment Transportation Education Use of Income Housing Nutrition Emergency Situations Supplemental Indicators: Children’s Needs Primary and Secondary Data Collection After determining the poverty indicators, our focus shifted to the identification of primary data collection sources. Primary sources included gathering quantitative and qualitative feedback through surveys and interviews. 5 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Survey Results The Needs Assessment Steering Committee identified survey distribution partners throughout Raleigh County. As a result, there were 1,141 needs assessment survey respondents, with the largest segment of respondents ages 24-44. The majority were female (65.6%), White (78.2%), with a monthly household income of $2,001+ (29.5%) listing high school/G.E.D. as the highest level of education completed (40.0%). Survey respondents were asked whether a key area or poverty indicator was an issue for them and/or their family. The overall ranking of the eight key poverty indicators along with the top three reasons identified for each was as follows: 1. Health – 35% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of medical insurance 2. Lack of dental services 3. Affordability of prescription drugs 2. Transportation – 30.7% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Cost of owning and operating a vehicle 2. Lack of credit to buy a vehicle 3. Do not own a vehicle/no access to a vehicle 3. Employment – 27.4% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of employment opportunities 2. Lack of good-paying jobs with benefits 3. Lack of reliable transportation 4. Housing – 22.9% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Affordability of rent/house payments 2. Lack of affordable/suitable housing 3. Affordability of additional housing costs, i.e. utilities, insurance, deposits, etc. 5. Use of Income – 21.5% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of knowledge on how to save/invest money 2. Lack of knowledge about money management, i.e. credit card debt, budgeting, checking accounts, etc. 3. Lack of knowledge about addressing credit issues 6. Nutrition – 17.1% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Not enough income to cover food cost 2. Lack of transportation, i.e. to grocery store, food pantry or other food resources 3. Not eligible for food stamps 6 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 7. Education – 13.7% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of transportation (school-related) 2. Lack of vocational skills or training 3. Lack of computer access at home 8. Emergency Situations* The top three reasons identified were: 1. Alcohol, drug abuse and/or gambling 2. No health insurance 3. Access to medical emergency resources, not covered by insurance *(NOTE: The format of the Emergency Situations did not allow for a ranking or percentage; rather it asked respondents to choose the three most important emergency situations that may be problems in the area.) Community Stakeholder Feedback The second form of primary data collection came from interviewing community stakeholder representatives from a variety of social service agencies in the region including YMCA, Raleigh County Schools, City of Beckley, Raleigh County Commission on Aging, WV DHHR, United Bank and Raleigh County Community Action Association. The purpose of these interviews was to identify how other agencies might be addressing the key poverty indicators. Open-ended questions about each of the key poverty indicators encouraged expression of qualitative feedback. Questions such as, “Is your agency addressing EMPLOYMENT issues in your community and if so, how? The responses in detail are included at the end of each poverty issue as part of the county reports. Overall questions and responses included the following feedback. What one thing do you like most about your community? Abundance of activities (ex. chili night, friends of coal auto fair, etc.) Agencies work together to meet the needs of our community. There is a great deal of support in our community-both from the corporate world and individuals. There is obviously not enough financial support to curb poverty; however, having people that care about the community allows us to maximize the opportunities we do have. Not too big or too small The cooperativeness of serving organizations and our community leaders. The people are generally pretty friendly. I love the sense of community that exists in the Beckley/Raleigh County area. The more I travel and visit other parts of the country, I realize how much I like the overall feel of our community, the "small town" feel, and the genuineness of the people that live here. What is ONE thing you would change to improve your community? I would like to see more people take ownership and responsibility for their lives and those they are responsible for. This is a national problem, so we are not unique. However, I feel that real opportunity exists everywhere. However, decisions have to be made to take full advantage of them. Create more jobs. Increase drug rehab to reduce the drug use in the community. Drug usage 7 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Would like to see less drug abuse. More employment opportunities Drugs are an epidemic in seemingly all rural communities. I do not know of any better ways to curb the problem than what already exists; however, having a more involved drug prevention, detoxification, and rehabilitation program in our area would have to help. In your opinion, what would your community look like without poverty? I think we would see less crime and more community involvement Utopia. Without poverty, the community would have less crime, better education systems, and fewer drug problems. Less crime, less abuse and neglect of children and adults, and more educated individuals. Safer, especially in the strong poverty areas, as well as better kept. Lower crime rates associated with poverty. Obviously, attention and energy currently being directed towards meeting basic needs could be re-directed towards other more advantageous activities, whether that be educational, family structure, community development, as well as a host of other endeavors. In your opinion, what keeps families in poverty in your community? I feel it’s a combination of issues. One is the "model" that has been provided to individuals and families in that they feel self-responsibility is not an option. Another related issue is the educational and career opportunities needed to break this cycle, whether that includes programs offered to make a difference in this area or the willingness to take advantage of them. Lastly, on a more global front, I believe it's the breakdown of the family unit as a whole that has led to poverty and other negative situations affecting our country. Lack of jobs. Shortage of community support. Raleigh County is plagued with generational poverty. Regardless of how good the economy is, the poverty rate remains high because many people in this area simply do not want to work. Drugs, Alcohol, lack of education, transportation Loss of jobs, unable to find employment, drugs Unemployment There are a great deal of drugs, especially prescription pills, in the poverty areas of our community. Also, a lack in education from generation to generation aided by the coal industry that detracts young adults from attending college, hurts our community-especially when the coal industry is down, the companies have layoffs, and we have a great deal of individuals who are not skilled in any other industry, nor will they settle for jobs paying substantially less than what they make in the mines. Secondary Data Collection Secondary data collection included gathering relevant and current statistics and research from reliable sources such as other social agencies and government entities in an effort to supplement the survey results and community stakeholder feedback. Research on each of the poverty indicators was compiled and is presented in detail as part of the Poverty Indicators sections of this report. 8 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Data sources included: Center for Budget & Policy. West Virginia Federal Rental Assistant Facts Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CFED – Assets & Opportunities Scorecard County Health Rankings Opportunity Nation United States Census Bureau, 20072011 American Community Survey United States Department of Labor U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development U.S. Department of Health & Human Services West Virginia Division of Local Health Wikipedia WV Bureau for Behavioral Health and Health Facilities WV Department of Health and Human Resources WV Department of Education WV Department of Education, Office of Special Programs WV KIDS COUNT FUND WV State Police Department Zero to Three – National Center for Infants, Toddlers and Families Step Three: Analyze Data As part of a one-day debriefing retreat with the Needs Assessment Steering Committee that took place on August 14, 2013, Kingery & Company presented primary and secondary data of each key poverty issue. Using a paired comparison technique, county representatives (RCCAA staff and external stakeholder representatives) analyzed the information presented and prioritized the issues that are in most need in their community. In addition to the top three priority needs, children’s needs was identified as an issue in Raleigh County. The top issues in Raleigh County are as follows: Raleigh County 1. Health 2. Transportation 3. Employment 4. Children’s Needs Step Four: Take Action The report is where it all comes together to tell the needs assessment story that captures the process, results, and action plans. The report that you are reading now provides a succinct record of the four step process: 1-Develop a plan; 2-Collect data; 3-Analyze results; and 4-Take action. The final report was shared with the Needs Assessment Steering Committee in advance of the public release. Steering Committee members were asked to share the report with their own organizations and other groups in an effort to mobilize community resources to address needs beyond that of RCCAA. Although RCCAA spearheaded the needs assessment project, the agency considers the report as the ‘community’s report’. Results will be shared in a news release and electronic copies will be made available upon request. In addition, the report will be incorporated into the next agency-wide strategic planning process. 9 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report RCCAA: AGENCY PROFILE & SERVICES 10 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report RCCAA AGENCY PROFILE & SERVICES RCCAA Mission: RCCAA empowers individuals and families to reach their highest levels of social and economic self-sufficiency, while identifying and eliminating causes of poverty. RCCAA Vision: RCCAA will strive to eliminate poverty by serving as a leader, resource, and advocate for individuals and families in need. Head Start Head Start is the premier pre-k provider in the nation. Through the use of evidenced-based curricula and best practices, Head Start addresses the cognitive, social, emotional, and physical well-being of each child in the program. Not only does Head Start address the needs of the child, but the needs of the entire family are very important to Head Start. RCCAA Head Start uses Creative Curriculum in the classroom to spark curiosity and promote learning. The Family Services department works with the family to address any areas of interest to parents or guardians. Head Start addresses health, mental health, and the nutritional needs of the child throughout the program. Head Start provides transportation to and from each center for the convenience of the family. RCCAA Head Start offers comprehensive services to eligible 3, 4, and 5 year old children throughout Raleigh County. Transportation Program Raleigh Express Transit Routes: RCCAA operates a transit system consisting of two city and two county shuttle routes to provide transportation to the residents of Beckley and Raleigh County. All shuttle buses are ADA approved. Hours of operation are Monday-Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Dial-A-Ride: RCCAA offers curb to curb transportation to the general public to doctor’s offices, hospitals, shopping, etc. Transportation is provided by appointment only. Hours of operation are Monday-Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Non-Emergency Medical Transportation for Medicaid Patients: RCCAA offers nonemergency transportation to doctor’s appointments. Medicaid is accepted for payment of non-emergency medical transportation to medical appointments. Hours of operation are Monday-Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Job Access and Reverse Commute (JARC) & New Freedom: RCCAA transports individuals to and from work, school and employment training. Transportation is arranged by submitting a schedule in advance. Services are available on a first come first serve basis. Hours of operation are Monday-Saturday, 6:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. and dispatching hours are Monday - Friday 7:00 AM until 8:00 PM. Homeless Services The goal of RCCAA Homeless Services is to assist residents in the development of economic and social self-sufficiency. Pine Haven Center offers emergency shelter to 150 men, women, children and families. All residents receive case management services, referral services, crisis intervention, three nutritious meals a day, and a safe, structured living environment. 11 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report The Project for Assistance in Transition from Homelessness (PATH) program provides case management and assessment services to homeless individuals suffering from mental illness, substance abuse and coexisting disorders. Child Mentor Program is available to children and their families while residing at Pine Haven Center. The program provides parenting skills training and provides safe, structured learning activities for children. Housing Services The Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG) program is designed to eliminate homelessness. The program provides homeless prevention and rapid re-housing services including rental assistance, re-housing assistance, housing search and placement and case management. The ultimate goal is to ensure no one is homeless for more than 30 days. Permanent Supportive Housing is designed to assist individuals and families that are chronically homeless and have a diagnosed disability, in the transition to permanent housing. Participants receive continuous case management and evaluation while residing in the homes to ensure their transition from homelessness to permanent living. LIEAP (Low Income Energy Assistance Program) facilitates the process for low income individuals to receive assistance with heating bills through the state LIEAP Program by assisting clients with the application process. Action Auto Repair The Action Auto Repair program offers quality auto repair services to everyone in the community, while providing discounted rates to individuals whose income does not exceed 150% of the federal poverty guidelines. Action Auto Repair also offers auto mechanic training opportunities to residents of Raleigh County. VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) The VITA program prepares and electronically files income tax returns for low income individuals at no cost to the client. VITA operates from February 1 through April1 of each year. Times of operation may vary. Case Management The RCCAA case management program evaluates the individual needs of clients and/or families to assist them in finding the resources they need. The goal of the case management program is to help clients attain self-sufficiency. 12 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report ASSESSING NEEDS: THE FOUR STEP PROCESS 13 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP ONE: DEVELOP A PLAN 14 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP ONE: Develop a Plan Kingery & Company along with RCCAA management established a Needs Assessment Steering Committee to develop a plan that included setting direction, assisting with the collection of primary data, monitoring progress, and reviewing results. Needs Assessment Steering Committee Members: Bobbi Thomas-Bailey, Executive Director, RCCAA Billie Meador, Homeless Service Director, RCCAA Kim Canterbury, Housing Director, RCCAA Cindy Heltzel, CFO, RCCAA Emily Elkins, Head Start Director, RCCAA Leland Swafford, Case Manager Supervisor, RCCAA Tennille Limer, Executive Assistant, RCCAA Andy Austin, Transportation Director, RCCAA Melissa Hunt, Community Developer, RCCAA Brittany Doss, Family Service Coordinator, RCCAA Tammy Trent, Administrative Assistant, WV DHHR Dr. Tiffany Thymius, Physician/Program Director, Access Health Kim Buckhannon, Child Care Director, YWCA Brandi Seabolt, APPI Specialist, Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention Initiative Kathy Armentrout, Associate Director, FMRS Dr. Charles Bright, Senior Adult Pastor, Memorial Baptist Church Jack Tanner, Executive Director, Raleigh County Commission on Aging Kenny Moles, Assistant Superintendent, Raleigh County Schools Margaret Ann O’Neal, Executive Director, United Way of Southern WV Candy Hurd, Director of Nursing, Beckley-Raleigh County Health Department Brad Limer, Assistant Vice President, United Bank Kevin Taylor, Director of Emergency Services, City of Beckley Sharon Meadows, Vice President, RCCAA Board of Directors Shelby Warden, Director, The Dream Center Timothy Deem, Chief of Police, Beckley City Police Tricia Kingery, Facilitator, Kingery & Company, LLC Angie Gardner, Kingery & Company, LLC At organizational and planning meetings, the Needs Assessment Steering Committee focused on conducting a situational analysis that included the following: Orienting the Needs Assessment Steering Committee to the purpose, process and roles. Conducting a media analysis by reviewing newspaper articles that reported on unmet needs. Identifying target participant individuals/groups for surveying. Reviewing work plan including tasks, responsibilities and deadlines. The responsibilities of the Needs Assessment Steering Committee included: Attend two meetings (beginning and end of project). Assist in identifying places where the Community Needs Assessments survey might be distributed. Assist in providing access to secondary research information (research or data developed by other organizations that already exist). Play a key role in reviewing the data collected, determining priority community needs and identifying ways that RCCAA and other community organizations might meet the needs. (This took place at the second meeting in the form of a retreat.) 15 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Be recognized in the report, provided a draft copy of the report in advance of the public release and receive a final electronic PDF version so that they too can share the report with their stakeholders and colleagues. Work Plan Task Approve Community Needs Assessment Planning Process Work Plan Identify members of the Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee (internal staff and external community representatives) Begin work on the county profile. Define content needed Determine process for capturing content Review deadlines Meet with RCCAA management to: Review work plan Clarify roles, responsibilities and timelines Prepare for the first Steering Committee meeting and Community Focus Group RCCCA Clients to begin taking survey Begin collecting Secondary Data Collection of national, state and local data resources Begin collecting Secondary Data to meet Head Start requirements The demographic make-up of HS eligible children 0-5 years old and their families, including their racial and ethnic composition Other child development and child care programs that are serving HS eligible children Estimated number of children with disabilities, four years old or younger; their types of disabilities; and available community services and resources Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of HS eligible children and their families Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of Head Start eligible children and their families as defined by the families themselves and local institutions Community resources that could address 16 | P a g e Responsible *Primary Responsibility By When RCCAA Executive Director* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison (RCCAA staff designated as our primary contact on this project) Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Program Staff May 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director June 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* June 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director June 2013 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report May 2013 May 2013 the needs of HS eligible children and their families. Conduct organizational meeting of the Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee Articulate the project goal, determine oversight responsibilities and establish a development process Informally identify unmet needs already known or talked about in the community by conducting a media analysis and reviewing previous needs assessments Discuss data collection methods (possible survey subjects, method of delivery, locations, etc.). Steering committee to brainstorm potential external survey distribution partners Review survey questions Distribute electronic survey link to the Steering Committee asking them to complete it and forward to their contacts RCCAA clients to complete survey RCCAA Head Start parents to complete survey Contact survey distribution partners to make plans to for them to complete the online survey or hard copy version Send link and/or mail hard copies of the survey Collect any remaining RCCAA client or Head Start parent surveys Assess status of county profiles Continue collecting Secondary Data Collection of national, state and local data resources Assess status of Secondary Data Collection to meet Head Start requirements The demographic make-up of HS eligible children 0-5 years old and their families, including their racial and ethnic composition Other child development and child care programs that are serving HS eligible children Estimated number of children with 17 | P a g e Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee June 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee Kingery & Company Consultants* Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director Kingery & Company Consultants* June 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* June - July 2013 July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* June - July 2013 June - July 2013 June - July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Program Staff Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director July 2013 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report July 2013 disabilities, four years old or younger; their types of disabilities; and available community services and resources Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of HS eligible children and their families Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of Head Start eligible children and their families as defined by the families themselves and local institutions Community resources that could address the needs of HS eligible children and their families. Monitor progress of survey completion Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Program Staff Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Executive Director RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director July 2013 Finalize any remaining online surveys or collect any remaining hard copy surveys Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Compile Survey Results - prepare graphs and insert them into draft report Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Assess status of county profiles. Continue collecting Secondary Data of national, state and local data resources Email RCCAA management to review progress and next steps Assess status of Secondary Data Collection to meet Head Start requirements The demographic make-up of HS eligible children 0-5 years old and their families, including their racial and ethnic composition Other child development and child care programs that are serving HS eligible children Estimated number of children with disabilities, four years old or younger; their types of disabilities; and available community services and resources Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of HS eligible children and their families Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of Head Start eligible children and their families as defined by the families themselves and local institutions Community resources that could address the needs of HS eligible children and their families. 18 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report July 2013 July 2013 Begin preparing PowerPoint for retreat by inserting all of the survey results/graphs into slides Gather and compile qualitative feedback from external reps on the steering committee and place results in draft report Finalize County Profiles and place it in draft report Finalize Secondary Data Collection and place it in draft report and in the retreat PowerPoint Finalize Secondary Data Collection to meet Head Start requirements and place it in draft report and in the retreat PowerPoint The demographic make-up of HS eligible children 0-5 years old and their families, including their racial and ethnic composition Other child development and child care programs that are serving HS eligible children Estimated number of children with disabilities, four years old or younger; their types of disabilities; and available community services and resources Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of HS eligible children and their families Education, health, nutrition, and social service needs of Head Start eligible children and their families as defined by the families themselves and local institutions Community resources that could address the needs of HS eligible children and their families. Finalize PowerPoint for retreat including primary and secondary data, prepare agenda, handouts, door prizes Conduct final meeting of the Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee (NOTE: This would be a one day retreat where internal and external reps would attend.) Present primary and secondary data collection results Facilitate an analysis process that identifies potential causes of poverty and mobilizes RCCAA and community resources in a plan to address the issues. Write draft report Review draft report 19 | P a g e Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison Kingery & Company Consultants* July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director July 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* August 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee August 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* July – August 2013 August 2013 Kingery & Company Consultants* RCCAA Executive Director Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report July 2013 RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Liaison RCCAA Head Start Director Kingery & Company Consultants* Final Report August 2013 Needs Assessment Steering Committee Meetings The committee met two times over a period of four months. The following information includes the meeting agendas with presentation topics, activities and assignments. Meeting One: June 18, 2013 AGENDA 11:30 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. Networking Lunch Complete Contact Info Complete Survey 12:00 p.m. – 12:15 p.m. Welcome and Introductions Agenda Review About Raleigh County Community Action 12:45 p.m. – 12:45 p.m. What is a Community Needs Assessment? Goals and Objectives Your Experience People Bingo Following the Rules and Guidelines Introduction of the Four Assessment Steps 12:45 p.m. – 1:15 p.m. Step 1: Develop a Plan Work Plan Community Action Key Areas Steering Committee Roles and Responsibilities Media Analysis Activity 1:15 p.m. – 1:45 p.m. Step 2: Collect Data Quantitative Surveys Target Audience: Broad Community o Review Survey o Identify Survey Distribution Partners Qualitative Surveys Target Audience: Select Community Stakeholders o Sample Survey Questions o Identify Survey Participants Secondary Research o Review Secondary Data Collection Plan 1:45 p.m. – 1:50 p.m. Step 3: Data Analysis Process - A Preview Three Steps 1:50 p.m. – 1:55 p.m. Step 4: Take Action - A Preview Report Outline 1:55 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Wrap Up 20 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Meeting Two: August 14, 2013 AGENDA 11:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. I Lunch 11:30 a.m. II. Welcome, Introductions and Agenda Review 12:00 p.m. III. This or That? 12:10 p.m. IV. Needs Assessment Process 12:20 p.m. V. Presentation of Primary and Secondary Data What Did You Hear?, Trivia Questions Demographics Employment Education Housing Health Nutrition Use of Income Transportation Emergency Situations Children’s Issues 12:30 p.m. VI. Prioritization Exercise 2:00 p.m. VII. Break 2:30 p.m. VIII. Issues, Challenges, Barriers and Goals Worksheet 2:45 p.m. IX. 3:20 p.m. Wrap Up and Next Steps 21 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP TWO: COLLECT DATA 22 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP TWO: Collect Data Primary and secondary data sources were identified. Primary sources included quantitative surveys and qualitative feedback from community stakeholders. Primary Data Collection Survey Methodology A needs assessment survey was developed to garner the opinion of Raleigh County residents on the indicators of poverty. The Needs Assessment Steering Committee identified a variety of methods to distribute the survey to county residents. Survey areas explored the eight community action key areas that are indicators of poverty. They include employment, education, housing, health, nutrition, use of income, transportation, and emergency situations. The survey also explored the area of children’s needs. The Needs Assessment Steering Committee identified target audiences including partners, services providers and community leaders, and the community at-large for survey delivery and developed an outreach plan that identified the method of survey delivery for each target audience, i.e. mail, electronic. In addition, two methods were used to obtain feedback from RCCAA clients. In one method, clients completed the survey while receiving services with staff available to answer any questions. The other method involved surveying parents of RCCAA Head Start children. By utilizing Survey Monkey, an electronic online survey tool, RCCAA was able to effectively reach the some of the target audiences. However, hard copy surveys were also distributed using strategic outreach partners. The process included Kingery & Company preparing hard copy versions of the survey and mailing packets directly to the survey distribution partners. RCCAA staff manually entered hard copy survey feedback into the Survey Monkey system. Survey Data Collection Plan Target Population Parents of Young Children (Head Start) 23 | P a g e Method of Delivery Survey Distribution Partner Paper surveys RCCAA Head Start Parents Paper surveys Busy Bee Day Care Paper surveys WIC Office Paper surveys Paper surveys Raleigh County Board of Education Summer Schools Dr. Lucero – Pediatrician Paper surveys Dr. Stanton’s Office – Pediatrician Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Teens (High School Students) Adults (Clients of Social Service Non-Profit Organizations) Adults (Community Members) 24 | P a g e Paper surveys Raleigh County Board of Education – Summer Schools Electronic surveys Just For Kids Paper surveys 4-H Electronic and Paper surveys RCCAA Clients Electronic surveys RCCAA’s website Paper surveys Heritage House Apartments Paper surveys Wild Wood House Apartments Paper surveys Southern Regional Jail Paper surveys AA Meetings Electronic surveys Health Rite Paper surveys Health Department Paper surveys DHHR Paper and electronic surveys Electronic surveys FMRS Paper surveys Pain Clinics Electronic surveys United Way and Partner Agencies Paper surveys Birth to Three Paper surveys Women’s Resource Center Paper surveys Friday’s in the Park Paper surveys Rotary Club Paper surveys New River Pool Carpenters Corner Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Electronic surveys Seniors Paper surveys City of Beckley – Emergency Services contact list Access Health Electronic surveys United Bank Paper surveys VA Hospital Paper surveys Local churches Electronic surveys First Property Solutions Paper surveys Electronic and paper surveys RCCAA staff on public transportation bus Senior Center – Commission on Aging Electronic surveys First Property Solutions Paper surveys Pettus Senior Nutrition Site Survey Results Summary There were 1,141 needs assessment survey respondents, with the largest segment of respondents ages 24-44. The majority were female (65.6%), White (78.2%), with a monthly household income of $2,001+ (29.5%) listing high school/G.E.D. as the highest level of education completed (40.0%). Survey respondents were asked whether a key area or poverty indicator was an issue for them and/or their family. The overall ranking of the eight key poverty indicators along with the top three reasons identified for each was as follows: 1. Health – 35% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of medical insurance 2. Lack of dental services 3. Affordability of prescription drugs 2. Transportation – 30.7% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Cost of owning and operating a vehicle 2. Lack of credit to buy a vehicle 3. Do not own a vehicle/no access to a vehicle 3. Employment – 27.4% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of employment opportunities 2. Lack of good-paying jobs with benefits 3. Lack of reliable transportation 25 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 4. Housing – 22.9% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Affordability of rent/house payments 2. Lack of affordable/suitable housing 3. Affordability of additional housing costs, i.e. utilities, insurance, deposits, etc. 5. Use of Income – 21.5% The top three reasons 1. Lack of knowledge 2. Lack of knowledge accounts, etc. 3. Lack of knowledge identified were: on how to save/invest money about money management, i.e. credit card debt, budgeting, checking about addressing credit issues 6. Nutrition – 17.1% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Not enough income to cover food cost 2. Lack of transportation, i.e. to grocery store, food pantry or other food resources 3. Not eligible for food stamps 7. Education – 13.7% The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of transportation (school-related) 2. Lack of vocational skills or training 3. Lack of computer access at home 8. Emergency Situations* The top three reasons identified were: 1. Alcohol, drug abuse and/or gambling 2. No health insurance 3. Access to medical emergency resources, not covered by insurance *(NOTE: The format of the Emergency Situations did not allow for a ranking or percentage; rather it asked respondents to choose the three most important emergency situations that may be problems in the area.) Community Stakeholder Feedback In an effort to gather qualitative primary data, external members of the Community Needs Assessment Steering Committee were asked open ended questions that focused on finding out how their agencies might be addressing the key poverty issues. Area agencies provided in depth feedback on ways they are making an impact on the key poverty indicators. The agencies included: YMCA Raleigh County Schools City of Beckley Raleigh County Commission on Aging WV DHHR United Bank Raleigh County Community Action Association 26 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Open-ended questions about each of the key poverty indicators encouraged expression of qualitative feedback. Questions such as, “Is your agency addressing EMPLOYMENT issues in your community and if so, how? The responses in detail are included at the end of each poverty issue as part of the county reports. Overall questions and responses included the following feedback. What one thing do you like most about your community? Abundance of activities (ex. chili night, friends of coal auto fair, etc.) Agencies work together to meet the needs of our community. There is a great deal of support in our community-both from the corporate world and individuals. There is obviously not enough financial support to curb poverty; however, having people that care about the community allows us to maximize the opportunities we do have. Not too big or too small The cooperativeness of serving organizations and our community leaders. The people are generally pretty friendly. I love the sense of community that exists in the Beckley/Raleigh County area. The more I travel and visit other parts of the country, I realize how much I like the overall feel of our community, the "small town" feel, and the genuineness of the people that live here. What is ONE thing you would change to improve your community? I would like to see more people take ownership and responsibility for their lives and those they are responsible for. This is a national problem, so we are not unique. However, I feel that real opportunity exists everywhere. However, decisions have to be made to take full advantage of them. Create more jobs. Increase drug rehab to reduce the drug use in the community. Drug usage Would like to see less drug abuse. More employment opportunities Drugs are an epidemic in seemingly all rural communities. I do not know of any better ways to curb the problem than what already exists; however, having a more involved drug prevention, detoxification, and rehabilitation program in our area would have to help. In your opinion, what would your community look like without poverty? I think we would see less crime and more community involvement Utopia. Without poverty, the community would have less crime, better education systems, and fewer drug problems. Less crime, less abuse and neglect of children and adults, and more educated individuals. Safer, especially in the strong poverty areas, as well as better kept. Lower crime rates associated with poverty. Obviously, attention and energy currently being directed towards meeting basic needs could be re-directed towards other more advantageous activities, whether that be educational, family structure, community development, as well as a host of other endeavors. In your opinion, what keeps families in poverty in your community? I feel it’s a combination of issues. One is the "model" that has been provided to individuals and families in that they feel self-responsibility is not an option. Another related issue is the educational and career opportunities needed to break this cycle, whether that includes programs offered to make a difference in this area or the willingness to take advantage of 27 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report them. Lastly, on a more global front, I believe it's the breakdown of the family unit as a whole that has led to poverty and other negative situations affecting our country. Lack of jobs. Shortage of community support. Raleigh County is plagued with generational poverty. Regardless of how good the economy is, the poverty rate remains high because many people in this area simply do not want to work. Drugs, Alcohol, lack of education, transportation Loss of jobs, unable to find employment, drugs Unemployment There are a great deal of drugs, especially prescription pills, in the poverty areas of our community. Also, a lack in education from generation to generation aided by the coal industry that detracts young adults from attending college, hurts our community-especially when the coal industry is down, the companies have layoffs, and we have a great deal of individuals who are not skilled in any other industry, nor will they settle for jobs paying substantially less than what they make in the mines. Secondary Data Collection Secondary data included collecting relevant and current statistics and research from reliable sources such as other non-profit agencies and government entities in an effort to complement the survey results and community stakeholder feedback. Research on each of the eight poverty indicators was compiled and are presented in detail as part of the Poverty Indicator sections. SOURCES OF DATA Center for Budget & Policy. West Virgina Federal Rental Assistant Facts Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CFED – Assets & Opportunities Scorecard County Health Rankings Opportunity Nation United States Census Bureau, 2007-2011 American Community Survey United States Department of Labor U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development U.S. Department of Health & Human Services West Virginia Division of Local Health Wikipedia. Raleigh County, West Virginia Workforce West Virginia WV Bureau for Behavioral Health and Health Facilities WV Department of Health and Human Resources WV Department of Education WV Department of Education, Office of Special Programs WV KIDS COUNT FUND WV State Police Department Zero to Three – National Center for Infants, Toddlers and Families 28 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report COUNTY PROFILE 29 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report COUNTY PROFILE RALEIGH COUNTY History & Geography Raleigh County was formed on January 23, 1850 from portions of Fayette County, then a part of Virginia. Alfred Beckley (1802–1888) said he gave Raleigh County its name in honor of Sir Walter Raleigh (1552–1618), the “enterprising and far-seeing patron of the earliest attempts to colonize our old Mother State of Virginia,” according to Raleigh County: West Virginia by Jim Wood. The county was the scene in 1914 of the Eccles Mine Disaster, the second-worst coal mining disaster in West Virginia history. The death toll was at least 180. More recently, the Upper Big Branch Mine disaster of 2010, which killed 29, also occurred in Raleigh County. Longtime Senator Robert Byrd's home town was Sophia. The county seat is Beckley. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the county has a total area of 609 square miles, of which 607 square miles is land and 2 square miles is water. Population Facts Population Change 2000-2011 Geographic Area Raleigh County, West Virginia West Virginia Census 2000 Population ACS 2007-2011 Population Population Change 79,220 78,701 -519 -0.66 1,808,344 1,846,372 38,028 2.10 Population by Age 2007-2011 30 | P a g e % Change Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Population by Gender 2007-2011 Geographic Area 0 to 4 5 to 17 M Raleigh County F 18 to 64 M F M Over 64 F M F 2,419 2,316 5,974 5,711 25,574 24,163 4,845 7,248 West Virginia 53,371 50,811 145,334 138,478 582,546 581,361 116,223 167,074 United States 10,308,314 9,862,063 27,583,764 26,293,608 95,838,920 97,108,272 15,282,403 22,599,606 Population by Race 2007-2011 Geographic Area Population by Race 2007-2011 Black American Indian White F M F M Native Hawaiian F M F Mixed Race M F Raleigh County 34,414 35,529 3,656 2,903 108 189 356 497 21 0 538 220 West Virginia 851,645 884,816 31,657 26,639 1,768 1,284 5,557 6,252 381 75 15,357 16,726 United States M Asian M F 112,055,360 115,111,656 18,290,588 20,105,268 1,243,909 1,258,744 6,896,938 7,600,247 251,420 249,172 3,889,436 3,927,218 31 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report SURVEY RESPONDENTS PROFILE AND OVERALL RESULTS 32 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report SURVEY RESPONDENT PROFILE Throughout the survey process, 1,141 individuals who live and/or work in Raleigh County completed the Needs Assessment Survey. Participants included educators, senior citizens, elected officials, high school seniors, employees and board members of various local non-profit organizations, and clients served by non-profit social service agencies. Below is a demographic synopsis of the individuals who took part in the process: Your age: 70 and older 6.2% 55-69 20.0% 45-54 16.2% 24-44 18-23 12-17 0.0% 42.9% 8.1% 6.6% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% Your gender: 65.6% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 34.4% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Male 33 | P a g e Female Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Your ethnic background: Other (please specify) Multi-Race (any 2 or more of… 1.3% Other responses: • Indian – X • Hispanic – XXXXX • Mexican American • Mexican • Multi-Race/ Hispanic 2.4% Native Hawaiian and Other… 0.2% Asian 0.1% American Indian and Alaska… 0.4% Black/African American 17.4% White 78.2% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% Number of people in your household: 7 or more 6 5 2.3% 3.1% 9.0% 4 13.9% 3 18.0% 2 30.0% 1 0.0% 34 | P a g e 23.8% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Household Type: Multi-Family 6.1% Two Adults/No Children 19.3% Single Person 22.0% Two Parent Household 26.8% Single Parent/Male 4.8% Single Parent/Female 21.1% 0.0% Sources of HOUSEHOLD income: (Choose all that apply.) 57.8% 5.4% 3.8% 0.6% TANF Farming 11.3% I do not work/receive any benefits. 2.8% Odd jobs Social Security 8.7% Pension or retirement benefits Contract work 3.0% Workers Compensation or other disability… 26.6% Wages or salary 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% Monthly HOUSEHOLD income: I do not know how much… 4.4% $2,001+ 29.5% $1,501 - $2,000 9.8% $1,001 - $1,500 13.6% $751 - $1,000 11.6% $501 - $750 $251 - $500 $100 - $250 Less than $100 0.0% 35 | P a g e 13.4% 6.1% 2.1% 9.4% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Highest Level of Education in Your HOUSEHOLD: Graduate/Professional 15.0% Bachelors Degree Associates Degree Trade School 12.6% 4.9% 3.2% Some College 18.0% High School/GED Middle/Junior High School Elementary School 40.0% 4.7% 1.6% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% Do you live and/or work in Raleigh County? 120.0% 100.0% 97.8% 80.0% 60.0% 40.0% 20.0% 2.2% 0.0% Yes No Zip Code: (Multiple responses are noted next to each zip code.) • 24701 (2) • 25067 • 24739 • 25118 • 24740 • 25140 (6) • 24870 • 25162 • 24874 • 25174 (5) • 24901 (3) • 25701 • 25007 (3) • 25703 • 25008 • 25801 (719) • 25044 (5) • 25802 (9) • 25045 • 25803 • 25048 • 25811 • 25062 • 25813 (54) 36 | P a g e • • • • • • • • • • • • 25817 25818 25821 25822 25823 25824 25825 25827 25831 25832 25836 25839 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report (6) (4) (14) (22) (20) (2) (39) (4) (16) • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 25840 25843 25844 25851 25853 25855 25864 25865 25866 25871 25873 25876 25878 25879 25880 (2) (7) (8) (2) (4) (12) (3) (9) (31) • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 25882 25894 25901 25902 25906 25908 25909 25910 25911 25915 25917 25918 25919 25921 25925 (13) (2) (5) (2) (2) (4) (29) • • • • • • • • • • • 25927 (2) 25932 (6) 25969 25976 (2) 25989 (4) 26651 28206 28214 33518 (2) 40403 Live in Fayette (25917) but work in Raleigh (25880) (15) Overall SURVEY RESULTS The top three needs identified by the survey respondents were as follows: 1. Health The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of medical insurance 2. Lack of dental services 3. Affordability of prescription drugs 2. Transportation The top three reasons identified were: 1. Cost of owning and operating a vehicle 2. Lack of credit to buy a vehicle 3. Do not own a vehicle/no access to a vehicle 3. Employment The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of employment opportunities 2. Lack of good-paying jobs with benefits 3. Lack of reliable transportation 37 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: EMPLOYMENT 38 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: EMPLOYMENT MOYMENT Primary Data: Survey Results EMPLOYMENT Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is employment an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,093 individuals who answered the question, 27.4% of respondents felt that employment was in fact an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of employment issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY employment was an issue. Is employment an issue for you and/or your family? 80.0% The top three reasons identified were: 72.6% 70.0% 60.0% 1. Lack of employment opportunities 2. Lack of good-paying jobs with benefits 3. Lack of reliable transportation 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 27.4% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Yes No If employment is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 60.0% 47.7% 50.0% 40.0% 18.5% 20.4% 12.8% 12.2% Cost of child care (workrelated) 20.0% 36.8% Lack of child care (workrelated) 30.0% 40.4% 10.0% 17.6% 7.0% 39 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Unknown Lack of resume/job application/interview skills Lack of reliable transportation Lack of good-paying jobs with benefits Lack of employment opportunities Lack of training to obtain a job Lack of education to obtain a job 0.0% Participants Speak Out – Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing EMPLOYMENT issues in your community and if so, how? Raleigh County Schools is one of largest employers in county. Raleigh County Commission on Aging is looking for and promoting opportunities through grants and special programs. RCCAA operates a garage training program, and also works with clients to prepare resumes, work on interview skills, etc. RCCAA also maintains a "Job Bank" with a list of businesses that are currently hiring and also keep applications on hand for clients that come in for assistance. WV DHHR’s TANF program assists customers in obtaining employment and assists them with the necessary skills to maintain their employment. United Bank, Inc. has not laid off any employees in West Virginia, even during the great recession. Our company continues to offer many full-time positions with health benefits for members of our community. Secondary Data: Research Understanding the employment situation in the community provides the background necessary for determining what types of jobs are available, what skills business and industry heed and what it takes for a family to become self-sufficient. Amidst falling home equity, the rising cost of food, health care and housing along with national unemployment rates, employment plays a tremendous role in a community’s ability to overcome a recession. National Poverty Guidelines: Persons in Family or Household 48 Contiguous States and D.C. 1 $11,170 2 15,130 3 19,090 4 23,050 5 27,010 6 30,970 7 34,930 8 38,890 For each additional person, add 3,950 *United States Department of Health and Human Services, 2013 40 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Poverty Rate According to the 2007-2011 U.S. Census, the poverty rate in Raleigh County is 17%. slightly lower than the state average of 18.7%. This is Poverty 2011 Geographic Area All Ages Number of Persons Raleigh County Age 0-17 Poverty Rate Number of Persons Age 5-17 Poverty Rate Number of Persons Poverty Rate 12,758 17.0 3,776 23.4 2,428 21.3 West Virginia 336,658 18.7 98,270 26.1 65,497 24.0 United States 48,452,035 22.5 10,976,987 20.8 15.9 16,386,500 Poverty Rate Change 2007-2011 Geographic Area Persons in Poverty, 2000 Raleigh County Poverty Rate, 2000 Persons in Poverty, 2011 Poverty Rate, 2011 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2011 12,911 17.2 12,758 17.0 -0.2 West Virginia 273,986 15.5 336,658 18.7 3.2 United States 31,581,086 11.3 48,452,035 15.9 4.6 Households in Poverty 2007-2011 Geographic Area Raleigh County Total Households, 2007/2011 Households in Poverty, 2007/2011 % Households in Poverty, 2007/2011 31,211 5,415 17.4 West Virginia 740,080 128,927 17.4 United States 114,761,360 15,337,307 13.4 Percent of Household in Poverty by Type 41 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Childhood (0-17) Poverty Rate 2000 – 2011 Geographic Area Children in Poverty, 2000 Poverty Rate, 2000 Children in Poverty, 2011 Poverty Rate, 2011 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2011 Raleigh County, West Virginia 4,098 24.9 3,776 23.4 -1.5 West Virginia 85,417 21.9 98,270 26.1 4.2 United States 11,587,118 16.2 16,386,500 22.5 6.3 Poverty Rate Change for Children under Five, 2000 – 2011 Geographic Area Children 0-4 in Poverty, 2000 Poverty Rate, 2000 Children 0-4 in Poverty, 2011 Poverty Rate, 2011 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2011 Raleigh County, West Virginia 1,361 31.3 1,348 28.5 -2.9 West Virginia 27,891 26.9 32,773 31.6 4.8 United States 4,050,543 20.3 5,409,513 27.0 6.6 Poverty Rate Change for Children Ages Five to Seventeen, 2000 - 2011 Geographic Area Children 5-17 in Poverty, 2000 Poverty Rate, 2000 Children 5-17 in Poverty, 2011 Poverty Rate, 2011 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2011 Raleigh County, West Virginia 2,737 22.6 2,428 21.3 -1.3 West Virginia 57,526 20.1 65,497 24.0 3.9 United States 7,536,575 14.6 10,976,987 20.8 6.2 Seniors in Poverty 2007-2011 Geographic Area Raleigh County, West Virginia Seniors Seniors in Poverty Senior Poverty Rate 12,266 1,078 8.8 West Virginia 285,284 29,310 10.3 United States 38,283,844 3,593,580 9.4 42 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Median Household Income The following chart shows the national, state and county level median household income. Raleigh County is below the national average of $50,502. 2011 Median Household Income Area United States Amount $50,502 West Virginia $38,482 Raleigh County $38,596 *U.S. Census Bureau, 2013 Unemployment Rates The unemployment rate is the number in the civilian labor force divided by the number of unemployed. The Bureau of Labor Statistics defines unemployment as people who do not have a job, have actively looked for work in the past four weeks, and are currently available for work. It also includes people who were temporarily laid off and are waiting to be called back to that job. It doesn't count the jobless who: Didn't look for a job in the past four weeks. Are so discouraged that they have stopped looking for a job. The unemployment rate is important as a gauge of joblessness. For this reason, it is also a gauge of the economy's growth rate. However, the unemployment rate is a lagging indicator. This means it measures the effect of a recession and so occurs after one has already started. Employers are reluctant to lay people off when the economy turns bad, and even more reluctant to hire them when the economy improves. For that reason, the unemployment rate can only confirm what the other indicators are showing. For example, if the other indicators show a quickening economy and the unemployment rate is declining, then we know businesses are confident enough to start hiring again. Since it is a lagging indicator, unemployment can worsen even after the economy starts to improve. For example, unemployment went from 5.6% in 2002 to 6% in 2003 even though the recession ended in 2002. Area United States West Virginia Raleigh County Unemployment Rates May 2012 May 2013 Net Change 7.9% 7.3% -0.6% 7.3% 5.9% -1.4% 6.8% 5.9% -0.9% United States Department of Labor, 2013 43 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report According to the U.S. Department of Labor, unemployment for this five year period fell from 7.3 percent to 5.9 percent in Raleigh County. Employers In many communities across America, local officials and leaders wrestle with the role of providing enough local jobs and income to maintain the economic viability of their communities. National and international events and trends can have a major impact on the rate and type of income and the employment growth communities can achieve. But communities that take an active role in attracting and retaining jobs, in addition to having a skilled and educated workforce, have an advantage over those communities that allow external events to exclusively dictate the pace of local economic growth. According to the CFED’s 2013, Assets and Opportunities Scorecard, 33.3% of jobs in West Virginia are considered low-wage jobs. This is defined as the percentage of jobs in occupations with median annual pay below 100% poverty threshold for a family of four ($22,314), 2010. (CFED, Assets & Opportunities Scorecard, 2013) 44 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report According to Workforce West Virginia in 2012, the following are the top two industries providing employment in Raleigh County: 1. Education, Health & Social Services- 23.8% 2. Retail Trade – 14.5% According to the WV Employment and Wage Report, the top 10 employers in Raleigh County are: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Raleigh County Board of Education Raleigh General Hospital Marfork Coal Company Wal-Mart Associates, Inc. Department of Veterans Affairs, Beckley Vet Center 45 | P a g e 6. Appalachian Regional Healthcare 7. University of Charleston 8. New Winterplace Ski Resort 9. Pocahontas Coal Company 10. Cramer Security & Investigation Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: EDUCATION 46 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: EDUCATION EDUCATION Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is education an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,097 individuals who answered the question, 13.7% of respondents felt that education was an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of the education issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY they felt education was an issue. Is education an issue for you and/or your family? 100.0% 86.3% 80.0% 1. Lack of transportation (school-related) 2. Lack of vocational skills or training 3. Lack of computer access at home 60.0% 40.0% 13.7% 20.0% The top three reasons identified were: 0.0% Yes No If education is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 31.4% 47 | P a g e 19.8% 20.3% Poor communication with teachers, principals, counselors Unknown Lack of dropout prevention for youth Lack of child care (schoolrelated) 9.9% 24.4% Lack of transportation (school-related) 9.3% Lack of computer access at home 25.6% 22.7% Threats of violence in schools Lack of GED/Adult Education classes 21.5% Availability and/or location of classes 26.7% Lack of vocational skills or training 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Participants Speak Out – Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing EDUCATION issues in your community and if so, how? YMCA offers a child care program that focuses on pre-reading and pre-writing skills, as well as many other educational components. Raleigh County Schools - Providing free public education. City of Beckley, Department of Emergency Services - Educational concerns are specifically directed on how individuals, businesses, churches, and other entities can best prepare themselves for whatever emergency might impact our area. Raleigh County Commission on Aging - We conduct classes on WV and US history, computer training, and addressing the needs of Alzheimer's patients and their caregivers. RCCAA operates Head Start in Raleigh County and also operates a garage training program in partnership with the Academy of Careers and Technology and New River Technical and Community College. United Bank, Inc. does offer a college course reimbursement program to all employees. WV DHHR offers educational reimbursement to its employees. Secondary Data: Research Data and information on the educational levels of clients as well as the issues surrounding access to education provide a framework for helping to move people from poverty into self-sufficiency. It has been shown that low income children who attend Head Start are more likely to graduate from high school and attend college (National Center for Children in Poverty). Schools Raleigh County The Raleigh County public school system has 19 elementary schools, five middle schools, four high schools and one career-technical center. Raleigh County Schools maintained a graduation rate of 85.73% for the 2010-2011 school year. The average class size in Raleigh County Schools in the 2010-2011 school year was 21.4 students with an attendance rate of 95.99%. The dropout rate for that year was 2.5% (WV Department of Education, 2013). The current enrollment in Raleigh County Schools for the 2012-2013 school year is 12,580 students. This is an increase from the previous year’s enrollment of 12,456 students. Of the students currently enrolled, 50.20% are considered low income. This is lower than the state average of 51.38% (WV Department of Education, 2013). Post-secondary education in Raleigh County is available at: Academy of Careers and Technology, Appalachian Bible College, Erma Byrd Center (Houses classrooms used by Marshall, Concord, and Bluefield State), New River Community and Technical College, University of Charleston – Beckley, Valley College 48 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Raleigh County West Virginia United States 78.7% 77.0% 75.5% 21% 18.8% 14.7% On-Time High School Graduation (% of freshmen who graduate in four years) Youth Not in School and Not Working (% ages 16 to 24) (Raleigh County Opportunity Index, 2013) Educational Attainment West Virginia Educational Attainment Population 25 years and over 1,282,621 Less than 9th grade 9 th to 12 th 87,410 (6.8%) grade, no diploma 144,591 (11.3%) High school graduate (includes equivalency) Some college, no degree Associate’s degree Bachelor’s degree Graduate or professional degree 529,569 (41.3%) 225,320 (17.6%) 74,457 (5.8%) 135,525 (10.6%) 85,749 (6.7%) *U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey 2007-2011 Raleigh County Educational Attainment Population 25 years and over 55,785 Less than 9th grade th th 4,245 (7.6%) 9 to 12 grade, no diploma High school graduate (includes equivalency) Some college, no degree Associate’s degree Bachelor’s degree Graduate or professional degree 7,505 (13.5%) 21,805 (39.1%) 9,983 (17.9%) 3,170 (5.7%) 5,499 (9.9%) 3,578 (6.4%) Persons Lacking Basic Literacy Skills Geographic Area Estimated Population over 16 Percent Lacking Literacy Skills 61,207 14% West Virginia 1,418,672 13% United States 15,058,111 22% Raleigh County 49 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Special Education – Students with Disabilities (Ages 3 – 21) Raleigh County Students with Disabilities (Ages 3-21) Percent of Total Student Enrollment 2012-2013 School Year District State Autism 35 0.28% 1,619 0.57% Behavior Disorders 15 0.12% 1,491 0.53% * * 279 0.10% 17 0.14% 449 0.16% * * 11 0.00% 255 2.03% 6,934 2.46% * * 127 0.04% Other Health Impairments 243 1.93% 5,585 1.98% Preschool Special Needs 118 0.94% 2,047 0.73% Specific Learning Disabilities 346 2.75% 11,925 4.22% Speech/Language Impairments 522 4.15% 13,923 4.93% * * 97 0.03% 1,562 12.42% 44,487 15.76% Blind and Partially Sighted Hard of Hearing Deaf-Blindness Mental Impairments Orthopedic Impairments Traumatic Brain Injury TOTAL *WV District Special Education Data Report, 2013 50 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: HOUSING 51 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: HOUSING Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is housing an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,099 individuals who answered the question, 22.9% felt that housing was in fact an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of housing issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY housing was an issue. Is housing an issue for you and/or your family? 90.0% The top 3 reasons identified were: 77.1% 80.0% 70.0% 1. Affordability of rent/house payments 2. Lack of affordable/suitable housing 3. Affordability of additional housing costs, i.e. utilities, insurance, deposits, etc. 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 22.9% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Yes If housing is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 64.1% 52 | P a g e 20.7% 10.4% 9.3% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Unknown 5.6% Lack of funds to ensure energy efficiency of my home 6.7% Lack of temporary emergency housing 27.8% Lack of knowledge about buying a home Affordability of needed housing repairs or weatherization, i.e. roof,… Affordability of additional housing costs, i.e. utilities, insurance, deposits, etc. Housing size doesn't meet family needs Lack of affordable/suitable housing 13.3% 19.6% Lack of down payment on a house 32.2% Credit issues 39.3% Affordability of rent/house payments 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% No Participants Speak Out – Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing HOUSING issues in your community and if so, how? Raleigh County Schools partner with the homeless shelter. Raleigh County Commission on Aging - We refer people who inquire to possible resources. RCCAA operates a housing program that consists of eight permanent supportive housing units and a Rapid Re-housing program. Secondary Data: Research Finding affordable housing (both rental and available for homeownership) continues to be a challenge for many Americans. Safe, decent, sanitary and affordable housing provides not only shelter for families, but stabilization for children, and in cases of homeownership—the ability for individuals and families to build and retain an asset for the future. Occupancy and Home Value Attainable housing is defined as housing that is in a safe and acceptable condition and does not financially burden a family. Federal government guidelines, primarily those developed by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), define attainable housing as housing that costs a homeowner or renter no more than 30% of the household's gross monthly income. This figure includes mortgage payments, home insurance, taxes, homeowner association and/or condominium fees, and utilities. Total Housing Units Occupied Housing Units Vacant Housing Units Owner Occupied Renter Occupied Median Value Median Rent Asked Raleigh County Housing Data 35,954 31,211 4,743 23,701 6,417 $89,100 $548 Housing Units without Plumbing, 2000 and 2007 - 2011 Geographic Area Raleigh County West Virginia United States 53 | P a g e Occupied Housing Housing Units without Units, 2000 Plumbing, 2000 Percent without Plumbing, 2000 Occupied Housing Housing Units without Units, 2007- Plumbing, 2011 2007-2011 Percent without Plumbing, 2007-2011 31,793 287 0.80 35,954 52 0.17 736,481 7,451 0.88 880,962 4,947 0.67 1,737,080 11,005 0.56 2,161,247 9,688 0.53 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Rentals About 27% of all West Virginia households – or 201,500 households – are renters. Federal rental assistance programs enable more than 36,300 low-income households in West Virginia to rent modest housing at an affordable cost. About 58% of these households are headed by people who are elderly or have disabilities; approximately 31% are families with children. (Center on Budget & Policy Priorities, 2013) Federal programs reach only a small share of the low-income West Virginia households that pay unaffordable rental housing costs and are therefore at increased risk of homelessness and other types of housing instability: In West Virginia, 41,000 low-income renter households pay more than half their monthly cash income for housing costs. On average, these households have incomes of $790 and pay housing costs of $710, leaving only $80 to pay for other necessities. About 41% of these cost-burdened renters are elderly or people with disabilities, while 27% are families with children. When housing costs consume more than half of household income, low-income families are at greater risk of becoming homeless. Point-in-time surveys suggest that at least 2,200 people are homeless in West Virginia.(Center on Budget & Policy Priorities, 2013) The following chart contains the Fair Market Rents for Raleigh County, WV. Fair Market Rents (FMRs) are estimates of rental housing costs in local housing markets that the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) prepares using rent survey data to serve as the basis for determining the maximum subsidy levels in the Housing Choice Voucher program. In general, FMRs are set at the 40th percentile rent i.e., the dollar amount which allows voucher-holders access to 40 percent of standard quality rental units. Adjustments are made to exclude public housing units, newly built units and substandard units (U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2013). Raleigh County FAIR MARKET RENT ($/month) 0 BR 1 BR 2 BR 3 BR 4 BR 2012 440 468 528 674 694 2013 528 532 701 873 937 (US Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2013) 54 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report According to the 2013 Assets & Opportunities Scorecard, 72.3% of West Virginia households are homeowners. 55 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: HEALTH 56 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: HEALTH Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is health an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,090 individuals who answered the question, 35% felt that health was in fact an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of health issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY health was an issue. Is health an issue for you and/or your family? The top three reasons identified were: 1. Lack of medical insurance 2. Lack of dental services 3. Affordability of prescription drugs 65.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% 35.0% Yes No If health is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 60.0% 53.1% 50.0% 40.0% 33.7% 33.9% 36.5% 30.0% 24.4% 20.0% 13.7% 13.2% 5.4% 6.2% 10.0% 4.7% 0.8% 2.8% 9.3% 57 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Unknown Lack of mental health services Lack of substance abuse services Lack of prenatal care services Lack of adequate in-home care services for seniors Lack of healthcare services for handicapped individuals Lack of vision services Lack of dental services Affordability of prescription drugs Lack of free or low-cost medical services Lack of healthcare providers who accept my medical… Lack of healthcare providers in the area Lack of medical insurance 0.0% Do you have public water? 100.0% 94.6% 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 5.4% 10.0% 0.0% Yes No Do your children receive fluoride supplements? 100.0% 86.8% 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 13.2% 10.0% 0.0% Yes 58 | P a g e No Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Participants Speak Out - Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing HEALTH issues in your community and if so, how? As the YMCA we offer many wellness opportunities (PEIA, aerobics, etc.) for community members. We also incorporate physical fitness into our Preschool Program. Raleigh County Schools - Nurses in schools. Health fairs in schools. Raleigh County Commission on Aging has a fitness facility, conducts exercise activities, have health screenings, sponsor wellness, end of life and abuse seminars, and have frequent presentations on health issues with our luncheon crowd. Indirectly through other programs. RCCAA ensures that all Head Start children have a medical and dental home, that all homeless clients are connected to a source for primary health care and mental health care, and that uninsured clients that are eligible are connected with Medicaid and/or CHIPS. WVDHHR assists with SNAP benefits for our customers. Secondary Data: Research Those struggling in poverty, as well as many families moving out of poverty, find it difficult at times to find available and affordable healthcare options. Health Overview Raleigh County According to the Beckley-Raleigh County Health Department, the top three health concerns in Raleigh County are: Hepatitis B with drug use, oral health and heart disease. Residents can access health care at the following location in Raleigh County: Hospitals: • Beckley Appalachian Regional Hospital • Beckley VA Medical Center • Raleigh General Hospital Urgent Care Facilities: • Doctors Immedicare, Beckley • Express Care, Crab Orchard • Med Express, Beckley • Primary Care Plus, Beckley Primary Healthcare: • Access Health • Eleanor Hurt Beckley-Raleigh County Health Department • Health Right Vision Services: • Beckley Vision Center, Beckley • Blaydes Eye Clinic, Beckley • Carr Eye Care, Beckley • Clarke Eye Clinic, Beckley 59 | P a g e • • • Eye Care One, Beckley (Wal-Mart) Family Vision Care, Beckley Waitkus Eye Care, Beckley Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Dental Services: • Steve Childress DDS Beckley • M.A. Farid, DDS Beckley • Andrew Dickens & Lance Dillon, DDS Beckley • Kevin Lucky, DDS Beckley • Shady Spring Dental Care, Shady Spring, WV Beckley • Gregory Harvey, DDS Beckley • Charles Cappellari Dentist Office Beckley • Andrada & Rose Dentistry Beckley • Associates in Family Dentistry Beckley • • • • • • • • • • • • Kevin Bailey DDS Beckley Beckley Dental Center Beckley Jeff Clay, DDS Beckley Eckley Orthodontics Beckley Stephen Finch, DDS Beckley Trevor Gray, DDS Beckley Francis Hajash, DDS Beckley Jeff Harvey, DDS Beckley Syner & Wine, DDS Beckley Foley Orthodontics Beckley Michael Smith, DDS, Crab Orchard New River Family Health Center Mental Health Services: • FMRS, Beckley • Beckley Appalachian Regional Hospital • Dr. Faheem • Dr. Hassan County Health Rankings Many health factors shape our communities' health outcomes. We know that much of what influences our health happens outside of the doctor’s office—in our workplaces, schools and neighborhoods. The following information is from the County Health Rankings & Roadmaps program. This programs looks at health statistics across the nation to help communities create solutions that make it easier for people to be healthy in their own communities, focusing on specific factors that we know affect health, such as education and income. Rankings illustrate what we know when it comes to what’s making people sick or healthy (County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, 2012). The chart below focuses on health behaviors, clinical care, and the physical environment. It also measures two types of health outcomes to show how healthy the county is: how long people live (mortality) and how healthy people feel (morbidity). Below are the results for Raleigh County and the state of West Virginia. Health Outcomes Mortality Premature Death Morbidity Poor or fair health Poor physical health days Poor mental health days Low birth weight Health Factors Health Behaviors 60 | P a g e Raleigh County West Virginia 10,893 9,351 27% 5.4 4.7 11.8% 22% 4.9 4.4 9.4% Rank (out of 55 counties) 45 46 46 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 23 27 Adult smoking Adult obesity Physical inactivity Excessive drinking` Motor vehicle crash death rate Sexually transmitted infections Teen birth rate Clinical Care Uninsured Primary care physicians** Dentists** Preventable hospital stays Diabetic screening Mammography screening 24% 34% 36% 7% 19 186 26% 33% 33% 10% 20 209 55 45 17% 1,091:1 1,970:1 124 80% 60% 17% 1,310:1 2,305:1 99 83% 61% 18 Behavioral Health Profile The West Virginia Bureau of Behavioral Health and Health Facilities (BHHF) is the designated host agency for the State Epidemiological Outcomes Workgroup (SEOW), a project funded by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). The SEOW was assembled to lead the statewide systematic process to gather, review, analyze, translate, and disseminate information about substance use and abuse and mental health in West Virginia. The following data has been developed based upon the most current and available data on substance use and its related consequences (Raleigh County Behavioral Health Profile, 2012). Indicator Cigarette smoking Smokeless tobacco use Binge drinking Behavioral Risk Factors 2004-2008 Raleigh County 24.3% 11.1% 5.8% Rank in WV* 30 10 31 Source: WV Behavioral Risk Factor Survey, WV Bureau for Public Health, Health Statistics Center. *Ranking in WV is based on 36 geographic entities. Entities include 12 groups of counties and 24 stand-alone counties. Rankings based on prevalence; 1st highest rate and 36th lowest rate. Many types of prescription drugs are abused. Currently there is a growing, deadly epidemic of prescription painkiller abuse in West Virginia and across the country. In the US, nearly three out of four prescription drug overdoses are caused by prescription painkillers also called opioid painkillers. Raleigh County has seen a rise in prescription drug overdose deaths of nearly 177% since 2003. More than 12 million people reported using prescription painkillers non-medically across the US in 2010, that is, using them without a prescription or for the feeling they cause. (Raleigh County Behavioral Health Profile, 2012) Drug Use in the Past Year among Persons 12 Years or Older, 2006-2008 Raleigh County West Virginia Marijuana 7.9% 9.2% Cocaine 2.2% 2.6% Nonmedical Use of Pain Relievers 4.8% 5.5% 61 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Statistics on Children and Teens - Healthcare and Related Issues The following children and teen statistics were obtained from the latest WV KIDS COUNT Data Book. Percent low birth-weight babies County 2005 2011 West Virginia Raleigh County 9.2% 9.6% 9.3% 10.5% % Change (+Better, -Worse) -1.1% -9.3% *West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund 2012 Data Book Infant Mortality Rate (per 1,000 live births) 2005 2011 County West Virginia Raleigh County 7.9 7.0 7.5 7.6 % Change (+Better, -Worse) +4.0% -8.4% *West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund 2012 Data Book County Child Death Rate (ages 1-14 per 100,000 children) 2005 2011 % Change (+Better, -Worse) +10.9% +6.6% West Virginia 24.6 21.9 Raleigh County 27.2 25.4 (perths)*West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund 2012 Data Book County Teen Birth Rate (ages 15-19 per 1,000 females) 2005 2011 % Change (+Better, -Worse) -6.8% -18.7% West Virginia 43.4 46.3 Raleigh County 47.2 56.0 (per 1,*West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund 2012 Data Book County West Virginia Raleigh County Percent Births to Unmarried Teens (ages 10-19) 2005 2011 9.2% 8.6% 10.6% 10.6% % Change (+Better, -Worse) -15.2% -22.8% (per 1 *West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund 2012 Data Book 62 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Teen Injury Death Rate (ages 15-19 per 100,000 teens) 2005 2011 County West Virginia Raleigh County 70.1 46.0 53.5 75.8 % Change (+Better, -Worse) +23.7% -64.8% (per *West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund 2012 Data Book Public Health The County Health Departments in each county provides a variety of services including community education, family planning, breast & cervical cancer services and many more. The following chart summarizes the services offered by the Beckley-Raleigh County Health Department. Services Provided Raleigh Breast & Cervical Cancer Services Community Education Community Health Services Environmental Epidemiology Family Planning HIV/Aids Hypertension Immunization Provider Education Sexually Transmitted Diseases Tuberculosis Other X X X X X X X X X (WV DHHR, 2013) Uninsured Persons, 2010 Geographic Area Raleigh County Insurance Population (2010 Estimate) Number Insured Number Uninsured Percent Uninsured 62,568 51,911 10,657 17.0 West Virginia 1,508,370 1,245,576 262,794 17.4 United States 262,403,379 215,846,576 46,556,803 17.7 63 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: NUTRITION 64 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: NUTRITION Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is nutrition an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,085 individuals who answered the question, 17.1% felt that nutrition was in fact an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of nutrition issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY nutrition was an issue. Is nutrition an issue for you and/or your family? 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% The top three reasons identified were: 82.9% 1. Not enough income to cover food cost 2. Lack of transportation, i.e. to grocery store, food pantry or other food resources 3. Not eligible for food stamps 17.1% Yes No If nutrition is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 65 | P a g e 61.0% 36.6% 25.8% 16.0% 6.6% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Unknown Lack of knowledge on available nutrition resources, i.e. WIC, food… Not eligible for food stamps 10.8% Not eligible for free or reduced school meals 16.0% Lack of time to prepare meals Lack of transportation, i.e. to grocery store, food pantry or other food… Not enough income to cover food cost Lack of knowledge on healthy food choices 20.7% 20.2% Food resources not available, i.e. Senior Citizens meals, meals… 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Participants Speak Out - Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing NUTRITION issues in your community and if so, how? Raleigh County Schools - Upgrading nutrition programs. Removed soda machines in schools. Summer programs that offers meals. Raleigh County Commission on Aging - We follow the federal nutritional guidelines with all of our meal programs. We provide healthy meals to seniors throughout the county. RCCAA provides mass feeding sites at Head Start and Pine Haven and contracts to provide a senior nutrition site in Pettus. Health Secondary Data Good nutrition, physical activity, and a healthy body weight are essential parts of a person’s overall health and well-being. Together, these factors can help decrease a person’s risk of developing serious health conditions, such as high blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease, high cholesterol, stroke, and cancer. A healthful diet, regular physical activity, and achieving and maintaining a healthy weight also are important to managing health conditions so they do not worsen over time. (Healthy People, 2013) Most Americans do not eat a healthful diet and are not physically active at levels needed to maintain proper health. Fewer than 1 in 3 adults and an even lower proportion of adolescents eat the recommended amount of vegetables each day. The majority of adults (81.6%) and adolescents (81.8%) do not get the recommended amount of physical activity. As a result of these behaviors, the country has experienced a dramatic increase in obesity. Today, approximately 1 in 3 adults (34.0%) and 1 in 6 children and adolescents (16.2%) are obese. (Healthy People, 2013) According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), during the past 20 years, there has been a dramatic increase in obesity in the United States and rates remain high. In 2011, no state had an obesity rate of less than 20%. Twelve states had a rate higher than 30% and West Virginia was one of those states with an obesity rate of 32.4%. West Virginia has the 2nd highest obesity rate in the United States. (Centers for Disease Control, 2013) Raleigh County The obesity rate in Raleigh County is 34%. This is slightly higher than state average of 33%. According to the 2013 County Health Rankings, 49% of all restaurants in Raleigh County are fast food restaurants. The following food pantries are located in Raleigh County: Calvalry Assembly of God, Beckley, WV The Dream Center/Fishes and Loaves Food Pantry, Beckley, WV Food for Body and Soul, Beckley, WV Food Pantry/Emergency Services, Whitesville, WV Helping Hands, Beckley, WV Salvation Army, Beckley, WV 66 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report According to the 2012 West Virginia KIDS COUNT Fund data book, the number of children approved for free and reduced-priced school meals has slightly decreased in Raleigh County. In 2005, 53.9% of children were eligible and in 2011 the percentage decreased to 52.3%. 67 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: USE OF INCOME 68 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: USE OF INCOME Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is use of income an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,072 individuals who answered the question, 21.5% felt that use of income was in fact an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of use of income issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY use of income was an issue. Is use of income an issue for you and/or your family? 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% The top three identified were: 78.5% 1. Lack of knowledge on how to save/invest money 2. Lack of knowledge about money management, i.e. credit card debt, budgeting, checking accounts, etc. 3. Lack of knowledge about addressing credit issues 21.5% Yes 60.0% No If use of income is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 50.4% 50.0% 44.1% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 32.2% 20.3% 19.5% 16.5% 20.8% 14.0% 10.0% Unknown Lack of knowledge on how to get/enforce child support Lack of interest in appropriate use of income Lack of knowledge about money management, i.e. credit care debt, budgeting, checking accounts, etc. Lack of knowledge about tax credits Lack of knowledge about addressing credit issues Lack of knowledge on how to save/invest money Lack of knowledge about possible resources, i.e. food stamps, medical coverage, etc. 0.0% 69 | P a g e reasons Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Participants Speak Out - Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing USE OF INCOME issues in your community and if so, how? Raleigh County Schools - Some schools have financial education programs. Raleigh County Commission on Aging - Our social worker frequently counsels seniors on fraud, credit card abuse and management of resources. RCCAA periodically offers budgeting classes and also operates VITA sites during the tax season. WVDHHR - Our TANF staff assists our customers with this issue. United Bank, Inc. addresses financial needs with customers, usually on a customer by customer basis. United Bank, Inc. has also been involved in teaching sessions to employees of various companies. Secondary Data: Research All Americans face challenges relative to use of income. As a society, we are constantly bombarded with commercials wanting to sell us the latest and greatest. Those with low incomes are not the only persons facing a crisis in money management with debt spiraling and costs of health care and other items rising. In fact, many Americans are living one paycheck away from financial crisis. The foundation for reaching the American Dream rests on two pillars: first, a family's ability to build assets that can be used to invest for the future, send children to college, and weather unexpected financial storms; and second, safety nets and safeguards that provide financial security in the event of a job loss, medical emergency, or other life events that could otherwise put a family in a tailspin. The information a community can gather on use of income can help an agency think about services which can lead individuals to build their safety net and eventually achieve many goals. Financial Institutions The following financial institutions are located in Raleigh County: BB&T, Beckley Bank of Mount Hope, Beckley Chase Bank, Beckley/Beaver City National Bank, Beckley/Beaver/MacArthur First Community Bank, Beckley/Beaver MCNB Bank Beckley United Bank, Beckley Whitesville State Bank, MacArthur/Glen Daniel Woodforest Bank, Beckley Credit Counseling There are no credit counseling services available in Raleigh County. 70 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report The following chart contains the estimated number of people receiving Social Security Income, retirement income, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), public cash assistance and Food Stamps/Supplemental Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits and the average amount of income paid to those recipients. The following information was obtained from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2011 American Community Survey. Raleigh County Total Households With Social Security Mean Social Security income (dollars) With retirement income Mean Retirement Income (dollars) With Supplemental Security Income Mean Supplemental Security Income (dollars) With Food Stamp/SNAP benefits in the past 12 months Number 31,211 13,478 $15,517 8,369 $12,641 2,629 $8,198 4,295 Percentage 43.2% 26.8% 8.4% 13.8% Credit Conditions The following information was obtained from the CFED’s Assets & Opportunities Scorecard. The average credit card debt of West Virginia borrowers is $7,578. This number has increased over the past ten years. 71 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 72 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 73 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: TRANSPORTATION 74 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: TRANSPORTATION Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked the basic question, is transportation an issue for you and/or your family. Of the 1,083 individuals who answered the question, 30.7% felt that transportation was in fact an issue. In order to gain an understanding of the root causes of use of transportation issues in the community, the Needs Assessment Survey provided the opportunity for respondents to identify WHY transportation was an issue. Is transportation an issue for you and/or your family? 80.0% 69.3% The top three reasons identified were: 60.0% 1. Cost of owning and operating a vehicle 2. Lack of credit to buy a vehicle 3. Do not own a vehicle/no access to a vehicle 40.0% 30.7% 20.0% 0.0% Yes No If transportation is an issue, please choose the THREE most important reasons why. 39.6% 35.3% 75 | P a g e 34.4% 32.7% 29.5% 26.9% 21.4% Do not own a vehicle/No access to a vehicle Lack of public transportation 8.4% Does not like to rely on others for transportation Lack of valid driver's license Cost of owning and operating a vehicle Cost of vehicle repair Lack of credit to buy a vehicle Lack of knowledge about buying a vehicle Lack of help learning to drive/getting a license 8.4% 7.8% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Unknown 18.2% Lack of knowledge about available services 45.0% 40.0% 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% Participants Speak Out – Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing TRANSPORTATION issues in your community and if so, how? Raleigh County Schools provide transportation to and from school. City of Beckley - Again, the only segment concerning transportation would be in regards to an emergency situation. In fact, I have spoken several times with representatives from the RCCAA concerning this very issue and how their services might be needed in an evacuation scenario. Raleigh County Commission on Aging - We provide transportation for seniors to our centers, to essential services, for educational and recreation purposes, and for medical services. RCCAA is the primary public transportation provider in Raleigh County. Secondary Data: Research Transportation is a key component to a person’s ability to obtain employment, an education and access to medical treatment. Transportation Overview Raleigh County Interstate 64 and 77, U.S. Highway 19, WV Routes 3, 16, 41, 54, 61, 97, 99, 210 and 307 serve as the main transportation arteries in Raleigh County. Raleigh County has a limited public transportation system. RCCAA provides the only public transportation services to residents in Raleigh County. The Commission on Aging provides transportation for seniors and there is one taxi in the county – Beckley Cash Cab. Commuting to Work – RALEIGH COUNTY Workers 16 years and over Car, truck, or van -- drove alone Car, truck, or van -- carpooled Public transportation (excluding taxicab) Walked Other means Worked at home Mean travel time to work (minutes) Total Number 29,772 25,410 2,104 47 723 791 697 23.3 Percentage 85.3% 7.1% 0.2% 2.4% 2.7% 2.3% US Census 2007-2011 American Community Survey 76 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: EMERGENCY SITUATIONS 77 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report POVERTY INDICATOR: EMERGENCY SITUATIONS Primary Data: Survey Results The Needs Assessment Survey asked respondents to choose the 3 most important emergency situations that seem to be particular problems in this area. 948 individuals answered the question and selected the following as the top three problems. The top three problems identified were: 1. Alcohol, drug abuse and/or gambling 2. No health insurance 3. Access to medical emergency resources, not covered by insurance 4. . 50.0% The following are emergency situations that may be particular problems in this area. Choose the THREE most important reasons. 46.8% 45.0% 40.4% 40.0% 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 30.3% 25.2% 26.9% 25.6% 23.6% 20.0% 15.0% 11.1% 9.7% 9.7% 10.0% 12.3% 5.2% 5.0% 78 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Other (please specify) Losing/lost home Lack of healthcare providers local services Legal assistance No health insurance Lack of income for utilities/fuel Alcohol, drug abuse and/or gambling Lack of income for prescription drugs Access to mental health services Lack of emergency shelter, i.e. due to fire, flood, eviction,… Access to medical emergency resources, not covered by… Lack of food 0.0% Other, please specify: Hospital is 1 hour away CURENTLY UNEMPLOYED LACK OF EMPLOYMENT Parents not willing to care for and provide homes for their own children in turn forcing Grandparents who are living on limited income and with failing health having to raise grandchildren. If I had to choose the most important problems in the area it would be lack of education and higher paying jobs for those who are educated as well as those that are trained for well-paying jobs. Lack of education and support leads to those interested in furthering themselves or their family be forced to leave the area, once they are trained or educated, there are few and far good-paying jobs outside of the medical field and coalmining! We need to support our local artists, entrepreneurs, and anyone willing further our education locally. CAR Unknown – (2 responses) N/A – (3 responses) Transportation is a problem for people to get to places, keep scheduled appointments that they need to get to for all areas of their life..legal, medical, mental health, food etc. No comment – (8 responses) All of the above I believe we have a high drug problem in our area, High welfare. Welfare recipients need to be drug tested in order to draw benefits. 79 | P a g e People have no motivation to better their lives, they would rather ride the system and let us working class pay for their lifestyles. People have no motivation to better their lives, they would rather ride the system and let us working class pay for their lifestyles. I do not understand the question. Legal assistance is an emergency. Culture. We have to expose people to a better way of life so they want to be successful. For example, taking young people to colleges so they can become excited. Lazy welfare abusers / meth heads I feel all of these are accessible to all people living in Raleigh County. Lack of ambition. Loss of jobs/economy Lack of transportation – (2 repsones) Lack of QUALITY healthcare. Low cost dental care Repair of residence (roof) water damage. Lack of income for housing New to area I'm not sure what is needed in this area. Only can speak for myself and transportation is a need for me right now. Some people are just lazy and want to sit back and collect their monthly checks, while not contributing anything in our community. Lack of response time from police, fire, ambulance, etc. Very inadequate police protection! Lack of really getting some help! Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Participants Speak Out – Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing EMERGENCY SITUATION issues in your community and if so, how? Raleigh County Schools provides shelters in place City of Beckley - Whether it's developing emergency operations plans, conducting training and educational offerings, developing and promoting emergency and non-emergency communication mediums, or a host of other activities, this is predominantly what I am involved in. Raleigh County Commission on Aging - Representatives sit on emergency planning boards, emergency medical responder boards, emergency food and shelter boards, participate in emergency exercises, and serve as an emergency shelter. RCCAA operates the homeless shelter and provides limited rental and utility assistance for those at eminent danger of becoming homeless. WVDHHR - We provide emergency assistance for shelter, food, utilities. United Bank, Inc.'s Beckley Main branch does have the only nuclear fallout shelter in the area to my knowledge. Secondary Data: Research The following fire departments and rescue services are available to Raleigh County residents: Fire Departments: Beaver Volunteer Fire Department, Beaver, WV Beckley Fire Department, Beckley, WV Bradley/Prosperity Volunteer Fire Department, Bradley, WV Clear Creek Volunteer Fire Department, Clear Creek, WV Coal City Volunteer Fire Department, Coal City, WV Coal River Volunteer Fire Department, Arnett, WV Ghent Volunteer Fired Department, Ghent, WV Lester Volunteer Fire Department, Lester, WV Mabscott Volunteer Fire Department, Mabscott, WV Rhodell Volunteer Fire Department, Rhodell, WV Sophia Area Volunteer Fire Department, Sophia, WV Sophia City Volunteer Fire Department, Sophia, WV Trap Hill Volunteer Fire Department, Glen Daniel, WV Whitesville Volunteer Fire Department, Whitesville, WV Rescue Services: Best Ambulance Service General Ambulance Service Jan Care Ambulance Service Ghent Ambulance Service Trap Hill Ambulance Service Whitesville Ambulance Service 80 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report The West Virginia State Police Department reports the following crime statistics in the following in their 2012 Annual Report: Type of Call Calls for Service Felony Arrests Misdemeanor Arrests Hazardous Moving Violations (HMV) Citations Beckley WV 7,565 797 1,722 1,089 HMV Warnings 4,563 DUI Motorist Assists Crash Reports Major Incidents Investigations Offenses (WV State Police, 2013) 54 470 157 1,335 3,048 The following information was obtained from the West Virginia Bureau of Behavioral Health and Health Facilities – Raleigh County Behavioral Health County Profile. Raleigh DUI arrests Raleigh rate per 10,000 WV DUI arrests WV rate per 10,000 Raleigh WV 2005 40% 31% DUI Arrests, 2008-2010 2008 2009 240 255 30.5 32.2 6,886 6,622 38.0 36.4 2010 276 35.0 6,154 33.2 Alcohol-Related Fatal Vehicle Crashes 2006 2007 2008 6% 36% 29% 31% 39% 37% 2009 39% 38% Source: Fatality Analysis Reporting System Note: Data reflects persons killed in motor vehicle crashes where driver blood alcohol content (BAC) was 0.01% or higher. 2001-2002 Drug Overdose Deaths 2001-2010, Number of Deaths per 10,000 Raleigh County West Virginia 2.5 2.2 2003-2004 5.7 3.3 2005-2006 6.8 4.4 2007-2008 7.0 5.2 2009-2010 10.0 5.3 81 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report The National Violent Death Reporting System reported in a recent study that one third of those who died by suicide tested positive for alcohol at the time of death. Raleigh County ranks 20th in the state by prevalence of suicides. A history of depression or other mental illness can increase a person’s risk for committing suicide. (Raleigh County Behavioral Health Profile, 2012) Number of Suicides Rater per 10,000 2000-2009 Suicide Deaths Raleigh County 134 West Virginia 2,810 1.69 1.54 WV Coalition to End Homelessness On January 24, 2013, the WV Coalition to End Homelessness, the Lead Agency for the Balance of State CoC (44 of 55 counties) worked in coordination with the other 3 CoC’s in WV to conduct the 3rd Annual statewide PIT Count. The data from this count helps determine the amount of funding awarded for homeless programs- across the state. Data received from the PIT Count also helps providers understand the changes in trends among the homeless populations and raise public awareness of homelessness. It is the intent of the WVCEH as the Lead Agency for the Balance of State Continuum of Care to conduct a complete and accurate Point in Time Count on an annual basis using a standardized data collection form and longitudinal data collected from the Homeless. Households with Children in Emergency Shelter Number of Total Number of Households Individuals Children in (under 18) Households Raleigh 19 63 35 County Number of Adults Chronically Homeless Individuals 28 27 Households without Children in Emergency Shelter Region Number of Total Individuals in Households Households Raleigh County 99 105 82 | P a g e Chronically Homeless Individuals 6 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report ADDITIONAL INDICATORS: CHILDREN’S NEEDS 83 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 84 | P a g e 0.0% Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Unknown Family support in caring for children 11.7% Money to provide for child’s wants, i.e. video games, name brand… 20.0% Knowledge about proper child nutrition in the home Money to properly provide for child’s physical needs, i.e. food,… Summer activities for children 10.0% Knowledge on childrearing methods 7.2% Safe, suitable forms of recreation 13.4% Adequate childcare/daycare facilities After school programs 10.0% Knowledge about available childcare/daycare resources 15.0% Early child education programs (Age 0-5) Money to afford childcare/daycare Live in an unsafe area to raise children ADDITIONAL KEY INDICATORS: Children’s Needs Primary Data: Survey Results The top three unmet children’s needs identified were: 1. Money to properly provide for child's physical needs, i.e. food, clothing, shelter 2. Summer activities for children 3. After school programs Choose the THREE most important unmet children's needs in your community. 32.9%33.1% 35.0% 31.3% 28.9% 27.2% 30.0% 24.9% 25.0% 19.1% 15.0% 13.7% 10.5% 5.0% Are there children living in your household? 50.8% 51.0% 50.5% 50.0% 49.5% 49.2% 49.0% 48.5% 48.0% Yes No If so, how many in each age group below? 184 147 122 200 5 or more 122 112 4 150 17 100 1 50 0 0 0 0-2 years 85 | P a g e 0 3-5 years 45 21 22 9 0 0 6-11 years 12 2 0 1 67 0 12-14 years 10 1 1 1 2 1 2 0 3 3 1 1 2 1 4 5 or more 15-17 years 18-25 years Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report List the number of children currently in your household that will be: 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 59 43 5 or more 32 3025 34 4 3 0000 0 0 0 1 4 years of 3 years of age by September 1 age by September 1 2 years of age by September 1 2 0 0 0 1 1 1 years of age by September 1 Is anyone pregnant in your household? 120.0% 96.2% 100.0% 80.0% 60.0% 40.0% 20.0% 3.8% 0.0% Yes If yes, what is the due date? 08/30/2013 12/01/2013 07/29/2013 09/04/2013 07/16/2013 11/05/2013 01/04/2013 10/12/2013 02/24/2014 86 | P a g e No 03/05/2014 08/23/2013 10/22/2013 01/08/2014 10/14/2013 July 22 Sept. 23 September – (2 responses) 08/23/2013 08/01/2013 07/21/2013 01/26/2014 October 01/19/2014 01/19/2014 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Are there children in your household that need or utilize childcare services? 83.8% 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 16.6% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Yes If there are children in your household that need or utilize childcare services, how often do the children need childcare? (Choose all that apply.) 38.3% 30.1% 14.8% Other (please specify) My childcare needs are taken care of. Only on weekends During the summer A few days/evenings each week Every evening 1.8% Other, please specify: ROTATING SHIFT AT WORK Monday – Friday – (2 responses) HALF DAY(4 HOURS) / 9 MONTH PROGRAM Not all people should become parents; educate children No children in household Too old now; have to be under 12 87 | P a g e 10.5% 9.3% 4.8% Every day 45.0% 40.0% 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% No when I get a job whenever I work AFTER SCHOOL SOMETIMES Live with grandparents Monday - Friday 8am - 5pm I don't need childcare – (17 responses) Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Why do you need childcare? (Choose ONE.) 55.8% 60.0% 50.0% 27.0% 20.0% 10.0% 7.0% 5.2% Education/Training 30.0% Part Time Employment 40.0% 6.1% 2.0% Other, please specify: STAY AT HOME MOM One parent must stay home due to the unavailability of a full day pre-k in our area. We would have liked to utilize the half day to add to halfday preschool but we made it work. IF I GET A JOB I NEED TO OBTAIN EMPLOYMENT To get a job Foster parent N/A – (6 responses) TO FIND A JOB – (3 responses) No comment 88 | P a g e Other (please specify) I don't need childcare. Welfare to Work Program Full Time Employment 0.0% Daughter Looking for work When laid off I want to work WHEN I GET A JOB WHEN I GO TO THE WORK Nowhere for teens Sister's child Need to get to summer school, from July 5 and three weeks all together in July Have no children My childcare needs are taken care of. Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report If your child(ren) need childcare, select your preference to participate: 45.0% 40.0% 35.0% 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% 41.3% 31.4% 18.6% 15.7% Half day (4 Half day Full day (minimum Full day (minimum hours)/9 month (4hours)/12 month 6 hours)/9 month 6 hours)/12 month program program program program Do children in your household attend an early child learning program such as Early Head Start or Head Start/Preschool? 100.0% 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% 86.5% 13.8% Yes No If your child does attend an early child learning program, what is the name of the program? Attended 3yr old Raleigh Co. Head Fairdale Elementary Preschool – (4 Start program, 4yr old Pre-K program responses) at Daniels Elem. Will be starting My children did not attend a head start Kindergarten in the fall. program but did attend pre-k at Beckley elementary pre-k Bradley Elementary Greater Beckley Birth to 3 Christian School BRADLEY SCHOOL – (3 responses) Greenbrier county Head Start Central Head Start – (10 responses) Head Start – (12 responses) Daniels Elementary/Pre-K – (2 Happy Kids Preschool responses) L. A. EAST 89 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Lebanon - head start My daughter attended Pre-School for 3 years at LA East, but is now in Public Schools N/A – (4 responses) Not old enough to attend these programs. Pre School – (5 responses) Private preschool Public school 4 year old program Mabscott RCCAA – (2 responses) Shady Spring Pre-K Sophia Christian Academy – (3 responses) Stratton elem. school United Methodist Temple Wonderfully Made Pre-School at Greater Beckley Christian School If your children do not attend an early child learning program such as Early Head Start or Head Start/Preschool, what might prevent you? 70.0% 63.7% 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 15.0% 11.9% 10.0% 8.5% 3.6% 0.0% Not needed Lack of transportation No program available N/A – (8 responses) MONEY In another faith based program POTTY TRAINING Smart already Summertime plan on enrolling this year No children in household – (8 responses) Have no confidence it is of any benefit. No comment – (5 responses) OLDER CHILDREN My child is too old for Head Start – (7 responses) Will attend school this coming year Not aware of Other (please program specify) Other, please specify: 90 | P a g e Not old enough – (9 responses) The Community feels that Head Start is considered a babysitting service. Wasn’t able to get a spot in local Head Start for 3 year olds. Friend 2nd grade DONT TRUST PEOPLE Both children in school ALREADY ATTENDED Age My child DID attend Head Start for 2 years in Fayette County WV Not time yet Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report If there was an Early Head Start (pregnant - 3 years old) program available would you send your child? 60.0% 50.0% 50.0% 40.0% 33.3% 30.0% 16.7% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Yes No Not applicable Participants Speak Out – Community Stakeholder Feedback Is your agency addressing CHILDREN’S NEEDS issues in your community and if so, how? YMCA - Offering child care to community members at a low cost. We also have scholarship opportunities, and accept state subsidies. Raleigh County Schools provides public education ages 4-18. City of Beckley - Only to the degree that it effects what they need to know if they find themselves in an emergency situation (i.e. getting out of the house if their smoke detector goes off). Raleigh County Commission on Aging - Only in educational activities and supporting events for grandparents caring for their grandchildren. RCCAA offers Head Start services in Raleigh County and also employees a Child Mentor at the homeless shelter. WV DHHR - Our Child Protective Service Workers assist the children who have been abused and neglected. Secondary Research Head Start Head Start is the premier pre-k provider in the nation. Through the use of evidenced-based curricula and best practices, Head Start addresses the cognitive, social, emotional, and physical well-being of each child in the program. Not only does Head Start address the needs of the child, but the needs of the entire family are very important to Head Start. RCCAA Head Start uses Creative Curriculum in the classroom to spark curiosity and promote learning. The Family Services department works with the family to address any areas of interest to parents or guardians. Head Start addresses health, mental health, and the nutritional needs of the child throughout the program. Head Start provides transportation to and from each center for the convenience of the family. 91 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report RCCAA Head Start offers comprehensive services to eligible 3, 4, and 5 year old children throughout Raleigh County. Below is a list of Head Start sites along with the number of children enrolled, number of classrooms available, hours of operation and staff development. Head Start # of children enrolled 171 # of classrooms Sophia Head Start 75 4 Fairdale Head Start 20 Pettus Head Start 20 Central Head Start 9 Hours of Operation 8:30 a.m. 2:30 p.m. MondayThursday 8:30 a.m. 2:30 p.m. MondayThursday 8:30 a.m. 2:30 p.m. MondayThursday 8:30 a.m. 2:30 p.m. MondayThursday 7 Collaborative sites at the Board of Education Teacher Staff Development Teacher Aide Staff Development 5 – B. A. 4 – ACDS – 5 – B. A. 4 – A. A. – 2 – B. A. 2 – A. A. – 1- B.A. 1 – B. A. 1 – A. A. 2 - not finished with ACDS 1 – CDA/ACDS – 1 – B.A. 1 – ACDS 7 – B.A. 7 – ACDS Head Start Demographic Information The following information was compiled based on information in RCCAA’s DBA Facs Pro, database tracking system. Head Start Families and Children Served Raleigh County Families Served 437 Children Served 458 Head Start Funded Enrollment Head Start Funded Enrollment by County Raleigh County 381 Total 381 GENDER County Raleigh County 92 | P a g e Female 273 Male 183 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report RACE County Caucasian Raleigh County 299 ETHNICITY County American Indian 5 Bi-Racial 43 Non-Hispanic or Latino 456 Raleigh County Raleigh County 14 Raleigh County 53 Spanish Other 2 0 Living with Grandparents Two Parents (w/children) 12 255 Rent – Subsidized 125 111 Living w/friends or family 105 Head Start Special Needs Services Services for Head Start Children with Special Needs Special Need Raleigh County Total Funded Enrollment Health Impairment Emotional/Behavioral Disorders Speech or Language Impairment Mental Retardation Hearing Impairment Orthopedic Impairment/Physical Therapy Visual Impairment Learning Disabilities Autism Traumatic Brain Injury Non-categorical/Developmental Delay Total by County 93 | P a g e Other or Unspecified 2 2 Single Parent (Male) 11 LIVING ARRANGEMENTS County Own RentUnsubsidized Native Hawaiian 0 Hispanic or Latino PRIMARY LANGUAGE County English as primary language Raleigh County 456 FAMILY TYPE County Multi-Adults (w/children) African American 109 381 0 0 28 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 19 48 Single Parent (Female) 145 Transitional/ Shelter /Homeless 5 Other Total by Need 381 0 0 28 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 19 48 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 38 Educational Attainment Educational Attainment of Head Start parents Raleigh County # less than a high school diploma 73 # high school or GED 233 # some college or vocational 112 # Bachelor’s or Advanced Degree 19 Head Start Homeless Children/Families Served Head Start Homeless Children/Families Served Raleigh County # of Homeless Families Served 5 # of Homeless Children Served 12 # of Homeless Families that acquired 2 housing during enrollment year # Bachelor’s or Advanced Degree 0 Additional Licensed Child Care Centers There are a total of 11 licensed child care centers in Raleigh County. Information about each center is below. Bullfrogs and Butterflies #2 113 Church Street Beckley, WV 25801 304-255-1090 Capacity 5 Age From 0 Years 1 Months Age To 0 Years 11 Months Capacity 7 Age From 1 Year 0 Months Age to 1 Year 11 Months Capacity 51 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age To 12 Years 11 Months Head Start Eligible Approximately 20 Children Served Bullfrogs and Butterflies 1 306 Ragland Road Beckley, WV 25801 304-253-8749 Capacity 20 Age From 0 Years 3 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 94 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 13 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible Approximately 40 Children Served 94 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Sophia Day Care PO Box 987 Sophia, WV 25921 304-683-3227 Capacity 11 Age From 0 Years 1 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 49 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 13 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible 12 Children Served YMCA Happy Kids Preschool and Summer Camp 121 E. Main Street Beckley, WV 25801 304-255-1745 Capacity 54 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age To 5 Years 11 Months Capacity 90 Age From 3 Years 0 Months Age to 13 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible 17-22 Children Served United Methodist Temple (A Place for Kids) 201 Temple View Drive Beckley, WV 25801 304-929-3436 Capacity 104 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age To 12 Years 11 Months Head Start Eligible Approximately 35 Children Served Kids B Kids Day Care Center 1239 Ritter Drive Daniels, WV 25832 304-255-9200 Capacity 4 Age From 1 Years 0 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 36 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 13 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible 12 Children Served 95 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Busy Bee Child Care Center, Inc. 600 New River Drive Beckley, WV 25801 304-255-2900 Capacity 12 Age From 0 Years 2 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 38 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 12 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible 18 Children Served Stepping Stones Academy at the Woodlands 169 Commerce Drive Beaver, WV 25813 304-255-1107 Capacity 24 Age From 0 Years 1 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 70 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 13 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible 20 Children Served Lollipops and Lullabies 173 Dry Hill Road Beckley, WV 25801 304-250-0224 Capacity 8 Age From 1 Years 0 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 52 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 12 Years 11 Months Head Start Eligible Approximately 30 Children Served Kids of Harmony Preschool 159 Granby Circle Beaver, WV 25813 304-207-0543 Capacity 1 Age From 0 Years 1 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 31 Age From 3 Years 0 Months Age to 6 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible 13 Children Served 96 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Rising Stars ChildCare, Inc. 1509 S. Kanawha Street Beckley, WV 25801 304-763-7419 Capacity 8 Age From 0 Years 2 Months Age To 2 Years 0 Months Capacity 30 Age From 2 Years 0 Months Age to 13 Years 0 Months Head Start Eligible Approximately 10-12 Children Served Registered Family Child Care Homes According to the most current WV KIDS COUNT Fund Data Book, there are 145 registered family child care homes in Raleigh County. This number has increased since 2008 when there were 125 registered family child care homes. WVDHHR Division of Early Care and Education will not release the list of names of family day care providers. They also have an inadequate data report system and were unable to provide the number of Head Start eligible children in the family day care homes/private schools in the county. Location West Virginia Raleigh County 2008 1,918 2009 1,938 2010 1,855 2011 1,835 2012 1,741 125 136 139 140 145 Special Needs Children The following information was obtained from the West Virginia Department of Education, Office of Special Programs. The charts contain the number of students with disabilities and types of disabilities for children ages 3 – 5, for the 2012-2013 school year. (WV Department of Education, 2013) RALEIGH COUNTY Students with Disabilities by Age Ages 3-5 December 1, 2012 3 years old 4 years old Autism Blind and Partially Sighted Hard of Hearing Intellectual Disability Other Health Impairments Preschool Special Needs Speech/Language Impairments TOTAL 97 | P a g e * * * * * 42 8 50 * * * * * 58 29 87 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 5 years old * * * * * 18 83 101 Resources for Special Needs Children West Virginia Birth to Three West Virginia Birth to Three (WV BTT) is a statewide system of service to assist families in meeting the developmental needs of their toddler or infant with special needs. All children under the age of three who are found eligible by having a developmental delay, medical condition or multiple risk factors are entitled to services needed by them and their family as identified on their Individual Family Service Plan (IFSP). WV BTT provides linkage to specialized therapy services in accordance with Part C of the Individuals with Disabilities Act and assures that family-centered, community-based services are available to all eligible children and families. Services provided include physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, educational service, etc. (WV Birth to Three, 2013). WV Birth to Three served a total of 232 children in Raleigh County from December 2011 to December 2012. Disabilities Resource Guide of West Virginia According to the Disabilities Resource Guide of West Virginia, the following services are available for children with disabilities: WVDHHR/BHHF MR/DD Crisis Respite Program WVDHHR- Specialized Family Care Program Augusta Levy Learning Center West Virginia Schools for the Deaf and Blind Parent/Educator Resource Center West Virginia Autism Training Center West Virginia Birth to Three The Taliris Institute, a leader in materials about the social emotional development of children birth to five, offers a developmental timeline on their webpage at www.parentingcounts.org. Parents can log in and view physical, social, learning, and communication milestones that children experience between birth to five. There are over 250 articles to help parents learn about their infant and toddlers development. Tip sheets for Families Families can find a variety of tip sheets below: Bonding With Your Baby Connecting With Your Teen Ten Ways to Be A Better Dad Dealing With Temper Tantrums Teen Parents...You're Not Alone! Raising Your Grandchildren Topic 98 | P a g e specific tip sheets include: Defying Defiance To Discipline Means to Teach! Handling Resistance Hugging Lying Making Mealtimes More Pleasant Parent Magic! The Power of Choice Say What You Mean: Mean What You Say Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Brain Schoolwork Rules: What's Fair? Setting Rules and Consequences With Teens Sibling Rivalry Swearing Tantrums Time Out! Winning the Chore War Development Series 2 to 6 months 6 to 12 months 12 to 18 months 18 to 24 months 24 to 36 months Temperament series What is Temperament? Tuning in to Temperament: Tuning in to Temperament: Tuning in to Temperament: Tuning in to Temperament: Tuning in to Temperament: Emotional Intensity and Reactivity Activity Level Sociability Coping with Change Frustration Tolerance School readiness series Encouraging School Readiness from Birth to Three What You Can Do to Support School Readiness Skills: Birth to 12 Months What You Can Do to Support School Readiness Skills: 12 to 24 Months What You Can Do to Support School Readiness Skills: 24 to 36 Months Healthy eating series Eating Well, Starting Early: Healthy Eating Habits from 0 to 3 Feeding: What to Expect from Birth to 12 Months Feeding: What to Expect from 12 to 24 Months Feeding: What to Expect from 24 to 36 Months Here's to Healthy Eating: Habits to Start and Habits to Avoid Making Life Easier Series Diapering Bedtime and Naptime Running Errands Additional materials at the TASCEI family community 99 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report The following information was obtained from the latest WV KIDS COUNT Data Book. Data Type Location Children Under Age 6 4-year-olds enrolled in Pre-K Births to Mothers with Less Than a 12th Grade Education Families with Related Children who Receive Cash Assistance Children Approved for Free and Reduced-Price School Meals (K-12) Low BirthWeight Babies MedicaidEnrolled Children Under 5 who Receive Dental Care Child Abuse/ Neglect (Per 1,000 Children) 100 | P a g e 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 West Virginia 125,916 126,493 127,500 125,045 124,386 Raleigh County West Virginia Raleigh County West Virginia 5,407 5,402 5,589 5,649 5,724 38.0% 50.6% 59.2% 62.6% 65.4% 36.7% 53.6% 65.2% 63.1% 69.5% 18.5% 18.3% 18.4% 18.6% 18.5% 17.5% 16.3% 15.4% 15.8% 16.5% West Virginia 2.2% 2.6% 2.8% 3.2% 2.8% Raleigh County West Virginia 1.7% 1.9% 2.1% 2.7% 2.1% 52.5% 53.6% 55.6% 53.5% 52.8% 55.7% 55.5% 55.2% 54.4% 52.3% 9.5% 9.6% 9.6% 9.4% 9.3% 10.0% 10.3% 9.9% 10.2% 10.5% Raleigh County Raleigh County West Virginia Raleigh County West Virginia 2006 Raleigh County 29.9% 38.4% 25.8% 38.4% West Virginia 23.1 19.6 18.9 17.6 16.4 Raleigh County 26.4 24.9 24.1 22.4 20.3 Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 2012 Under age 1 Age 1 Age 2 Age 3 Age 4 Age 5 Age 5 and under Total Number of Children by Age, 2011 Raleigh County West Virginia 948 20,571 949 20,143 950 20,322 1,001 21,348 918 21,072 958 20,930 5,724 124,386 *WV KIDS COUNT Fund, 2013 Teen Pregnancy According to the 2012, WV KIDS dropping in WV and the nation. But between WV and the nation became have a baby. One in eight babies in COUNT Data Book, teen pregnancy rates have been in 2006, WV’s rates began to worsen, and the disparity much greater. One in 22 West Virginia teenage girls will WV is born to a teen mother. The Raleigh County teen pregnancy (per 1,000 births) is 56.02%, which is the 13th highest in the state. Dropping Out. One in three girls cites pregnancy as her reason for dropping out of high school. Poverty. The poverty rate for kids born to teenage mothers who have never married and did not graduate from high school is 78%, compared to 9% of children born to married women over 20 who are high school graduates. Unhealthy Babies. Children born to teen mothers are at higher risk of being born underweight and dying within their first year of life. They are less likely to get the emotional and intellectual stimulation they need for healthy child development. The following information was obtained from Zero to Three – National Center for Infants, Toddlers and Families All babies need good health, strong families, and positive early learning experiences to foster healthy brain development and realize their potential. A baby’s early experiences shape the brain’s architecture into a strong—or fragile—foundation for learning, health, and success in the workplace. Adverse early experiences, such as poverty, can weaken babies’ brain development and follow them their entire lives. Of o o o West Virginia’s 59,367 infants, toddlers and their families: 14% live with unemployed parents 35% live with a single parent 66% have at least one risk factor known to increase the chance of poor health, school, and developmental outcomes o West Virginia ranks 44th among all states for child well-being Health and Nutrition Good health is the foundation from which young children grow and develop physically, cognitively, emotionally, and socially. Quality medical care and adequate nutrition, starting before birth, are key building blocks for this healthy development. Lack of nutritious food during pregnancy increases the risk of infant mortality and poor long-term health. Preterm babies may endure lifelong consequences like blindness, chronic lung disease, and other conditions. Underweight babies are 166% more likely to be at developmental risk compared to normal weight babies 101 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Good Health & Nutrition: West Virginia Infants & Toddlers: o 9.5% have low birth weight (U.S. average 8.2%) o 82% are born to mothers who receive early prenatal care (National Healthy People goal is 90%) o 73% of two-year-olds are immunized (U.S. average 75%) o Compared to the U.S. average of 8.9%, approximately 3.0% of West Virginia’s young children under age 6 do not have health insurance. West Virginia Family Index: An estimated 2,012 homeless children are under age 6 47% of children living with their grandparents are under age 6 Over 20% of children under age 6 are in families spending more than half of their income on rent 25% of West Virginia’s maltreated children are under age 3 102 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP THREE: ANALYZE DATA 103 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP THREE: Analyze Data As part of a one-day debriefing retreat with the Needs Assessment Steering Committee that took place on August 14, 2013, Kingery & Company presented primary and secondary data of each key poverty issue in Raleigh County. Using a paired comparison technique, county representatives (RCCAA staff and external stakeholder representatives) analyzed the information presented and prioritized the issues that are in most need in their communities. In addition to the top three priority needs, children’s needs was identified as an issue. The top issues are as follows: Raleigh County: 1. Health 2. Transportation 3. Employment 4. Children’s Needs After the retreat, RCCAA management team continued to focus on the priority issues by discussing how RCCAA could improve current programs, add programs or partner with other organizations to better meet the needs of Raleigh County residents. Steering Committee members were then tasked with developing a Plan of Action that included identification of the Greatest Challenge, Barriers and Goals for the priority issues for Raleigh County. 104 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report County Action Plans RALEIGH COUNTY ACTION PLAN Issue #1: HEALTH Greatest Challenge: Lack of health insurance Barriers: Cost of Private Health Insurance Not qualified for Medicaid/CHIPS Lack of knowledge of available Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC’s) and sliding fee clinics Lack of affordable dental services What’s our goal? Strategies that could be taken to make a positive impact on this issue. a. RCCAA has applied for a grant to hire four individual personal assistants to enroll eligible individuals into Medicaid and private market place under the Affordable Care Act. Also applied to be Community Assisters to enroll eligible people to Medicaid. b. Provide educational opportunities to promote awareness of the options currently available and becoming available in the near future. c. Increase the number of FQHC’s offering dental services in the area and educate/encourage private dentists to accept Medicaid/CHIPS, and educate clients about the importance of keeping appointments so they are not released by doctors/dentists. Issue #2: TRANSPORTATION Greatest Challenge: Awareness and availability of existing transportation options. Lack of financial management skills to own/maintain a vehicle. Barriers: Lack of funds to pay for vehicle maintenance Lack of awareness about public transportation options Fear of losing independence when using public transportation What’s our goal? Strategies that could be taken to make a positive impact on this issue. a. Increase awareness about RCCAA public transportation by sharing success stories and testimonials from current clients that use the transportation. b. Provide education seminars to the public on money management issues including credit repair, budgeting and wants vs. needs. 105 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report Issue #3: EMPLOYMENT Greatest Challenge: Lack of good paying job opportunities, Need to increase minimum wage Barriers: Lack of basic skills and training Transportation Child Care Assistance (although some provided by DHHR) Unable to pass drug screen What’s our goal? Strategies that could be taken to make a positive impact on this issue. a. Initiate training for basic employment skills and educate individuals on the locations for GED training. b. Research and possibly create a “Junior Achievement Program”. c. Promote information about available jobs and resources to current RCCAA clients. Issue #4: CHILDREN’S NEEDS Greatest Challenge: Inability to properly provide for children’s physical needs, i.e. food, clothing and shelter. Barriers: Lack of job training Lack of knowledge of money management, available resources, etc. Lack of support What’s our goal? Three strategies that could be taken to make a positive impact on this issue. a. Develop a fee for service program to offer family development services (case management) to members of the county to assist them in developing realistic goals and a detailed plan to achieve those goals. b. Provide regular seminars, to the public, on topics that affect families with children such as budgeting, meal planning, resources available in the community, etc. c. Use previously established partnerships with agencies such as WorkForce WV and the Academy of Careers and Technology to connect community members to job training. In addition, create new partnerships with other agencies offering job skills training. 106 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP FOUR: TAKE ACTION 107 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report STEP FOUR: Take Action A Community Needs Assessment report explains the process, identifies the people involved, succinctly presents primary and secondary data, includes an analysis of the results and concludes with overall recommendations on how best RCCAA can meet the needs of Raleigh County. This report serves as the final written report. The report is where it all comes together to tell the needs assessment story that captures the process, results and action plans. The report that you are reading now provides a succinct record of the four step process: 1-Develop a plan; 2-Collect data; 3-Analyze results; and 4-Take action. The final report was shared with the Needs Assessment Steering Committee in advance of the public release. Steering Committee members were asked to share the report with their own organizations and other groups in an effort mobilize community resources to address needs beyond that of RCCAA. Although RCCAA spearheaded the needs assessment project, the agency considers the report the ‘community’s report’. Results will be shared in a news release and electronic copies will be made available upon request. In addition, the report will be incorporated into the next agency-wide strategic planning process. 108 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report APPENDIX A: RCCAA Community Needs Assessment Survey 1. Please circle the appropriate response under each demographic heading. AGE 12 – 17 18 – 23 24 – 44 45 – 54 55 – 69 70 & older GENDER Male Female HOUSEHOLD TYPE Single Parent/Female Single Parent/Male Two Parent Household Single Person Two Adults/No children Multi-Family ETHNIC BACKGROUND White Black/African American American Indian and Alaska Native Asian Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander Multi-Race (any 2 or more of the above) Other: ___________________________ NUMBER IN HOUSEHOLD 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 or more SOURCES OF HOUSEHOLD INCOME (Choose all that apply.) MONTHLY HOUSEHOLD INCOME Wages or Salary Less than $100 Contract Work $100 - $250 Pension or retirement benefits $251 - $500 Social Security $501 - $750 Workers’ Compensation or other disability $751 - $1,000 Odd jobs $1,001 - $1,500 TANF $1,501 - $2,000 Farming $2,001 + I do not work/receive any benefits. I do not know how much my parents/guardians make. HIGHEST LEVEL OF EDUCATION IN YOUR HOUSEHOLD. (Choose ONE) _____ Elementary School _____ Middle/Junior High School _____ High School/GED _____ Some College _____ Trade School _____ Associates Degree _____ Bachelor’s Degree _____ Graduate/Professional DO YOU LIVE AND/OR WORK IN RALEIGH COUNTY? ___________YES _____________NO ZIP CODE: ___________________ 2. Is Employment an issue for you and/or your family? ________________YES ________________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Lack of education to obtain a job _____Lack of training to obtain a job _____Lack of employment opportunities _____Lack of good-paying jobs with benefits _____Lack of reliable transportation _____Lack of child care (work-related) _____Lack of resume/job application/interview skills _____Cost of child care (work-related) _____Unknown 3. Is Education an issue for you and/or your family? ________________YES ________________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Lack of vocational skills or training _____Lack of transportation (school-related) _____Lack of GED/Adult Education Classes _____Lack of child care (school-related) _____Availability and/or location of classes _____Poor communication with teachers, _____Threats of violence in schools principals, counselors _____Lack of dropout prevention for youth _____Unknown _____Lack of computer access at home 109 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 4. Is Housing an issue for you and/or your family? ________________YES ________________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Affordability of rent/house payments _____Credit issues _____Lack of affordable/suitable housing _____Lack of down payment on a house _____Housing size doesn’t meet family needs _____Lack of knowledge about buying a home _____Affordability of needed housing repairs, i.e. _____Lack of temporary emergency housing roof, foundation, insulation, storm _____Lack of funds to ensure energy efficiency windows, etc. of my home _____Affordability of additional housing costs, _____Unknown i.e. utilities, insurance, deposits 5. Is Health an issue for you and/or your family? ________________YES ________________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Lack of medical insurance _____Lack of healthcare services for handicapped _____Lack of healthcare providers in the area individuals _____Lack of healthcare providers who accept _____Lack of adequate in-home care services for my medical insurance seniors _____Lack of free or low-cost medical services _____Lack of prenatal care services _____Affordability of prescription drugs _____Lack of substance abuse services _____Lack of dental services _____Lack of mental health services _____Lack of vision services _____Unknown 6. Do you have public water? __________________________YES ___________________________NO 7. Do your children receive fluoride supplements? _________________YES ___________________NO 8. Is Nutrition an issue for you and/or your family? ________________YES __________________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Food resources not available, i.e. Senior _____Not eligible for food stamps Citizens meals, meals on wheels, food _____Lack of knowledge on available nutrition pantries, etc. resources, i.e. WIC, food stamps, food _____Not enough income to cover food cost programs _____Lack of transportation, i.e. to grocery store, _____Not eligible for free or reduced school food pantry or other food resources meals _____Lack of knowledge on healthy food choices _____Unknown _____Lack of time to prepare meals 9. Is Use of Income an issue for you and/or your family? ______________YES _______________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Lack of knowledge about possible _____Lack of knowledge about money resources, i.e. food stamps, medical management, i.e. credit card debt, coverage, etc. budgeting, checking accounts, etc. _____Lack of knowledge on how to save/invest _____Lack of interest in appropriate use of money income _____Lack of knowledge about addressing credit _____Lack of knowledge on how to get/enforce Issues child support _____Lack of knowledge about tax credits _____Unknown 110 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report 10. Is Transportation an issue for you and/or your family? _______________YES _____________NO If yes, choose the THREE most important reasons why: _____Lack of knowledge about available services _____Cost of vehicle repair _____Lack of knowledge about buying a vehicle _____Does not like to rely on others for _____Lack of credit to buy a vehicle transportation _____Cost of owning and operating a vehicle _____Lack of public transportation _____Lack of valid driver’s license _____Do not own a vehicle/No access to a _____Lack of help learning to drive/getting a vehicle license _____Unknown 11. The following are Emergency Situations that may be particular problems in this area. Choose the THREE most important reasons: _____Lack of food _____Alcohol, drug abuse and/or gambling _____Access to medical emergency resources, _____Lack of income for utilities/fuel not covered by insurance _____No health insurance _____Lack of emergency shelter, i.e. due to _____Legal Assistance fire, flood, eviction, domestic violence, etc. _____Lack of health care providers- local services _____Access to mental health services _____Losing/Lost Home _____Lack of income for prescription drugs _____Other: _____________________________ 12. Choose the three most important unmet children’s needs in your community. _____Live in an unsafe area to raise children _____Money to properly provide for child’s _____Money to afford childcare/daycare physical needs, i.e. food, clothing, shelter _____Early child education programs (age 0-5) _____Knowledge about proper child nutrition in _____Knowledge about available childcare/ the home daycare resources _____Money to provide for child’s wants, i.e. _____After school programs video games, name brand clothing, _____Adequate childcare/daycare facilities activities with friends _____Safe, suitable forms of recreation _____Family support in caring for children _____Knowledge on childrearing methods _____Unknown _____Summer activities for children 13. Are there children living in your household? _____Yes _____No If so, how many in each age group below? _____0 – 2 years _____3 – 5 years _____6 – 11 years _____12 – 14 years _____15 – 17 years _____18 – 25 years 14. List the number of children currently in your household that will be: _____4 years of age by September 1 _____3 years of age by September 1 _____2 years of age by September 1 _____1 years of age by September 1 15. Is anyone pregnant in your household? _____Yes _____No If yes, what is the due date? ________________ 16. Are there children in your household that need or utilize childcare services? _____Yes _____No 17. If there are children in your household that need or utilize childcare services, how often do the children need childcare? (Choose all that apply.) _____ Every day _____ Every evening _____ A few days/evenings each week _____ During the summer _____ Only on weekends 111 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report _____ My childcare needs are taken care of. _____ Other: _____________________________ 20. Do children in your household attend an early child learning program such as Early Head Start or Head Start/Preschool? 18. Why do you need childcare? (Choose ONE.) _____Yes. Name of program ___________________ _____No _____ Full Time Employment _____ Part Time Employment _____ Education/Training _____ Welfare to Work Program _____I don’t need childcare. _____ Other: _____________________________ If no, what might prevent you? 19. If your child(ren) need child care, select your preference to participate: _____Half day (4 hours)/9 month program _____Half day (4 hours)/12 month program _____Full day (minimum 6 hours)/9 month program _____Full day (minimum 6 hours)/12 month program _____ Not needed _____Lack of transportation _____Not aware of program _____No program available _____Other: __________________________ 21. If there was an Early Head Start (pregnant – 3 years old) program available, would you send your child? ______Yes ______No ______Not applicable THANK YOU!!!!! 112 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report APPENDIX B: Resources Center for Budget & Policy. West Virgina Federal Rental Assistant Facts. Retrieved June 25, 2013 from: http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=3586 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Data and Statistics: Overweight & Obesity. Retreived June 25, 2013 from: http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/index.html CFED. Assets & Opportunities Scorecard. Retrieved July 17, 2013 from: http://assetsandopportunity.org/scorecard/ County Health Rankings & Roadmaps. Raleigh County, WV. Retrieved June 11, 2013 from: http://www.countyhealthrankings.org Opportunity Index. Raleigh County Profile. Retrieved July 25, 2013 from http://opportunityindex.org/#4.00/36.00/-97.00/ United States Census Bureau, 2007-2011 American Community Survey. American Factfinder. Retrieved June 11, 2013 from American Factfinder : http://factfinder2.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/index.xhtml United States Department of Labor. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Retrieved July 24, 2013 from MidAtlantic Information Office: http://www.bls.gov/ro3/wvlaus.htm U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Fair Market Rent Data Sets. Retrieved July 17, 2013, from: http://www.huduser.org/portal/datasets/fmr.html U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. National Poverty Guidelines. Retrieved June 25, 2013 from: http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty/11poverty.shtml West Virginia Division of Local Health. Local Health Department Information. Retrieved June 25, 2013 from: http://www.wvdhhr.org/wvlocalhealth/lhd_profiles/lhdreport/index.asp Wikipedia. Raleigh County, West Virginia. Retrieved on July 17, 2013 from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raleigh_County,_West_Virginia Workforce West Virginia. Workforce West Virginia County Profiles. Retrieved June 11, 2013, from: http://www.workforcewv.org/lmi/cntyprof/DEFAULT.HTM WV Bureau for Behavioral Health & Health Facilities. Raleigh County Behavioral Health Profile. Retrieved June 11, 2013 from: http://www.dhhr.wv.gov/bhhf/Pages/default.aspx WV Department of Education. WVEIS Data On-Demand School Profiles. Retrieved July 17, 2013 from: http://wveis.k12.wv.us/nclb/profiles/index.cfm WV Department of Education. Office of Special Programs. WV District Special Education. Retrieved July 17, 2013 from: http://wveis.k12.wv.us/nclb/OSEcf/Data/replist1.cfm WV KIDS COUNT FUND. 2012 WV Kids Count Data Book. Retrieved June 25, 2013 from: 2012 WV KIDS COUNT Fund Data Book: Teen Pregnancy in West Virginia 113 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report WV State Police Department. West Virginia State Police Annual Report. Retrieved June 25, 2013, from: http://www.statepolice.wv.gov/about/Documents/AnnualReports/2011AnnualReport.pdf Zero to Three – National Center for Infants, Toddlers and Families. State Baby Facts. Retrieved June 25, 2013 from: http://www.zerotothree.org 114 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report For more information or clarification about this report, please contact: Tricia Kingery, M.A., M.B.A. Kingery & Company, LLC 2 Hale Street, Suite 100 Charleston, WV 25301 [email protected] www.kingeryandcompany.com Toll free: 1-888-541-7553 (304) 541-7553 115 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report RCCAA Community Needs Assessment In Action A Photo Gallery 116 | P a g e Raleigh County Community Action Association Community Needs Assessment Report