Collection Profile Colombia

Euler Hermes Collections
Collection
Profile
Colombia
Collecting in Colombia
•
•
The payment behavior of domestic companies is good but DSO remains high and late payments are frequent.
•
When it comes to insolvent debtors, collecting debt is a genuine challenge and, overall, negotiating payment
during the pre-legal action phase remains the most efficient alternative.
The court system lacks transparency and procedural costs and delays are significant so that court proceedings
overall should be avoided.
Collection complexity
Notable
High
Complexity relating to
Payments
Court proceedings
Insolvency proceedings
Very High
Severe
Notable
Severe
World Bank
Doing Business
Insolvency rating for
2016: 30/189 countries
(against 28/189 countries
in 2015).
Contents
General Information.........................................................................................................................................3
Availability of financial information................................................................................................................3
Main corporate structures................................................................................................................................3
Regulatory environment...................................................................................................................................3
Getting Paid.........................................................................................................................................................4
Days Sales Outstanding (DSO)........................................................................................................................4
Late payment interest........................................................................................................................................4
Debt collection costs.........................................................................................................................................4
Payments..............................................................................................................................................................4
Collecting Overdues.........................................................................................................................................5
Amicable action.................................................................................................................................................. 5
Legal action.......................................................................................................................................................... 5
Alternatives to legal action...............................................................................................................................6
Handling Insolvent Debtors........................................................................................................................... 7
Insolvency proceedings.................................................................................................................................... 7
General information
Availability of financial information
Companies must report their financial information annually
to the Superintendence of Corporations (Superintendencia de
Sociedades de Colombia) and the Commerce Chambers (Camara
de Comercio) located in the main cities. However, relevant and
reliable financial information is difficult to obtain as the system
lacks transparency. Private channels may help obtain reputational
data and use of specialized providers is recommended.
Euler Hermes allocates each company a grade reflecting its
financial health and how it conducts business. EH grades
represent a core of Euler Hermes’ knowledge and analyses,
helping clients identify and avoid risk. Data is continuously
monitored to offer the most up-to-date information to support
management decisions.
Days Sales Outstanding
(DSO): Payment terms in
Colombia usually provide
for 30 to 60 days payment.
However, the average DSO
stands more around 60
days.
Main corporate structures
Liability for business debts is determined by legal structures, which
may be described as follows:
• Limited Partnerships (Sociedad en Comandita) involve one
or more managing partners (jointly liable for the company‘s
operations and debts) together with silent partners. Partners
are liable in two different ways: a backer’s liability is limited
to the amount contributed whilst a representative shares full
responsibility.
• Limited Liability Companies (Ltda.) require a minimum of
two partners (up to 25), each liable for the amount of their
capital contributions. Management is made through a Board
of partners and decisions are taken in proportion with the
partners‘ shares. Corporations (SA) require a minimum of
five shareholders, each being liable for the amount of its
capital contribution. Simplified Shares Corporations (SAS) are
increasingly relied upon as the main incorporated structure as
they may be owned by a single shareholder, whose liability is
also strictly limited to its contribution.
Regulatory environment
Colombia has a codified Civil Law system inspired by continental
legal frameworks, distinguishing constitutional and administrative
jurisdiction from ordinary (civil and commercial) jurisdiction. At the
first instance, claims are allocated to Municipal Courts and Circuit
Courts depending on the amount of the claim. Different Courts
of Appeal (Tribunales Superiores del Distrito Judicial) then deal
with cases in their specific districts, depending on their expertise.
Civil procedure is governed by the Civil Procedure Code (Decrees
No. 1400 and No. 2019 of 1970) - the last amendment (Law No.
1564 of 2012) coming into force in January 2014. Colombia also
has a codified Commercial Law with a special policy and judgment
process for companies and debtors. In a Civil Court, judges apply
different policies for companies and private individuals. Where
an individual trades as a company, the judge could apply both
poilicies. Colombian judiciary is influenced by political authorities
and authority given to the rule of law has room for improvement.
3
Late payment interest:
The law provides a
maximum interest rate
(Tasa de Usura). Each entity
is given liberty in deciding
whether or not interest will
be charged.
Getting Paid
Days Sales Outstanding (DSO)
Payment terms in Colombia usually provide 30 to 60 days for
payment. However, the average DSO stands more around 60 days as
transactions tend to be delayed by 10 to 30 days on average.
Late payment interest
It is possible to charge interest for late payment in Colombia however
the system is singular. Instead of providing a minimum interest rate in
case late payment occurs, the law provides a maximum interest rate
(Tasa de Usura) applicable in case of late payment, and each entity is
given liberty in deciding whether or not interest will be charged.
Debt collection costs
Article 1629 of the Colombian Civil Procedure Code clearly stipulates
that all cost caused by collection activities are to be supported by the
debtor provided that costs and efforts undertaken to recover the debt
may be justified.
Payments
The most common payment methods are as follows:
Swift bank transfers are amongst the most popular payment
methods as they are fast, secured, and supported by an increasingly
developed banking network internationally and domestically.
Export transactions are usually guaranteed through an Export
Credit Insurance policy, which helps to minimize the risk of sudden
or unexpected customer insolvency. Euler Hermes’ worldwide
network of risk offices monitors the financial well-being of your
customers and grants them a specific credit limit up to which you
may trade and claim should something go wrong. Alternatively,
Standby Letters of Credit (a bank guarantees the debtor’s credit
quality and repayment abilities) constitute reliable guarantees
which can be interpreted as a sign of good faith since they can be
triggered as a ‘payment of last resort’ if the client fails to fulfil a
contractual commitment. Also, irrevocable and confirmed
Documentary Letters of Credit (a debtor guarantees that a certain
amount of money is made available to a beneficiary through a bank
once certain terms specifically agreed by the parties have been
met) may be considered.
Generally speaking, bank guarantees often tend to be expensive. As
a result, negotiating down payments is common and advisable.
Bills of exchange (and promissory notes) support nearly 90% of
business transactions in the country and tend to be considered as
debt recognition titles which could help gain access to accelerated
proceedings before the courts.
4
Collecting overdues
Amicable action
Negotiating
As a result of the last amendment of 2012, civil and commercial
procedures ought to become more oral in the future but, in the
meantime, formal legal action remains overly lengthy and unreliable.
As a result, amicable settlement opportunities should always be
considered as a strong alternative to formal proceedings. As a
matter of fact, it is actually mandatory (under Law 640 of 2001) to
conduct conciliation or mediation hearings before commencing
formal proceedings (and pre-trial mediation must also be
conducted in administrative litigations under Statutory Law of
Justice Administration n°270 of 1996).
Before starting legal proceedings against a debtor, in addition,
assessment of its solvency and assets is essential as it allows
verification as to whether the company is still active and whether
recovery chances are at best: if insolvency proceedings have been
initiated, indeed, it often becomes impossible to enforce a debt
(see below).
It is worth noting that most conciliations are agreed before the
matter goes to court as an attorney will look to resolve the matter
in conciliation or arbitration centres.
Legal action
Ordinary proceedings
Ordinary legal action would usually commence when amicable
collection has failed. When the debt is certain and undisputed (for
instance if a promissory note or bill of exchange is available as
provided under Law 1321 of 2008) the creditors may initiate
summary proceedings to obtain a Payment Order, in which case the
debtor must comply with the decision (or bring a defence) within
four to ten days. Having said this, Law 1231 has made it more difficult
to commence proceedings on the basis of a bill because it has
established various restrictive conditions to their admissibility.
Otherwise, formal proceedings may commence as soon as a judge
has authorized the action and the debtor has been served with a
Writ. The debtor must answer the claim within twenty days, but any
failure of the defendant to bring a defence would normally lead the
judge to issue a default judgment depriving the defendant from their
right to appeal. Otherwise, the courts would systematically invite the
parties to attend a mediation proceeding in order to reach an
agreement. If the parties fail to do so, evidence collection may
commence, and the court will consider the parties arguments before
rendering a decision.
The courts would usually award specific performance or issue an order
to execute an obligation or abstain from doing something. As a rule,
the claimant must be fully compensated so the courts tend to award
damages by taking into account profit losses. Similarly, interest on
overdue debts is usually awarded upon the claimant’s request. There
are however no punitive damaged under Colombian law.
Necessary documents
• Copies of invoices
• Promissory notes
• Detailed account status
• General information about debtor
Time limitations
As a general rule, claims must be brought within specific periods
of time which vary depending on the subject matter. Ordinary
proceedings must be brought within ten years, debt-related
claims within five years (six months for bad cheques, three years
for negotiable instruments). Insurance and transportation claims
must be presented within two years. Courts have no authority to
alter time limitations which are considered a matter of substantive
law, but cases are rarely dismissed because of time limitation
issue.
Provisional measures
Provisional measures (autos) may help to preserve the creditor’s
interests pending a final and enforceable judgment. Indeed, the
courts may order protective pre-action measures such as
attachment and sequestration of the defendant’s assets, ex parte
(without the presence of both parties) to avoid irreparable
damage, preserve the status quo or to protect evidence. The
courts would however usually order the claimant to provide
security on costs in order to protect the respondent from
irresponsible action.
Lodging an appeal
The parties may lodge an appeal within three days of service.
Decisions rendered in the first instance are brought before the
Court of Appeal, but Supreme Courts only rarely reviews decisions
rendered in appeal (casación). Arbitration awards are not subject
to appeal.
Collection @ Euler Hermes
It is always advised to attempt collection prior to any legal action
in order to maximize chances of successful recovery and avoid
legal costs and delays. Our key principle is to collect in close
proximity to the debtor, using a series of letters, emails and
phone calls in the local debtor language. Our World Collection
Network of Euler Hermes offices and External Providers are
experts in professional trade debt collection and negotiation,
ensuring positive outcomes whilst retaining important client
relationships. Euler Hermes can handle the complete collections
process from amicable, pre-legal action through to judgment
and enforcement.
5
Enforcing court decisions
A judgment is enforceable as soon as it becomes final (i.e. when all
appeal venues have been exhausted). Enforcement proceedings may
then commence. Usually, compulsory enforcement would occur
through the seizure and auctioning of the debtor’s assets, but
garnishment orders allowing collection of the debt from a third party
owing money to the debtor may also be delivered.
How long could legal action take?
By law, (Law 1395 of 2010), first instance decisions in Colombia ought
to be rendered within a year, whilst Courts of Appeal ought to render
their decisions within an additional six months period of time. In
practice, it may take five years to obtain a first instance ruling whilst a
full disputed lawsuit could spread over 10 years.
In principle, domestic courts would not take longer to deal with cases
involving a foreign party than to deal with cases involving domestic
parties only. In practice, some extra delays would nonetheless occur
depending on the complexity of each case.
How much could this cost?
As a general rule, the winning party may demand the court to hold the
defeated party liable for the payment of the judicial tariff paid during
the collection phase, the court fees as well as for part of its legal costs.
Following the decision to strike down Law 1653 of 2013, Law 1394 of
2010 is now in effect. This law statest that a court fee of 2% of the
monetary claim applies once the legal process has been completed.
Conditional arrangements whereby attorneys are not paid upfront but
instead receive a fixed sum upon success and contingent fees whereby
the legal professionals are entitled to receive a percentage of the final
award are common in Colombia. Use of third-party litigation funding
companies is also common.
Alternatives to legal action
Alternative Dispute Resolution methods (ADR)
As previously mentioned, use of Alternative Dispute Resolution
methods has increased over the last years following the introduction of
mandatory conciliation proceedings as a prerequisite to bringing a
claim before the courts (Law 640 of 2001). The settlement agreements
achieved through this phase are binding and enforceable as final
judgments.
In addition, domestic or international arbitration proceedings provide
for confidential settlement opportunities whilst arbitral awards are final
and enforceable. Though Arbitrators are entitled to grant interim relief,
ADR methods have shown no monetary benefit because they are
expensive and often do not resolve the conflict. If legal action is
subsequently taken, proceedings are not influenced by any issues
resolved during the arbitration.
Foreign forums
It is relevant to emphasize that Colombian law does not allow the
parties to a contract to limit or waive the jurisdiction of Colombian
courts through foreign jurisdiction clauses. In practice, the courts of
Colombia strongly protect their role towards public policy preservation
and have thus only admitted foreign jurisdiction clauses in
international arbitration proceedings (Article 62 of Law 1563/2012) or
where the contract was to be executed abroad (article 869 of the
Commercial Code).
Enforcing foreign awards
Although foreign decisions against Colombian debtors aiming at
bypassing the authority of Colombian courts would not be enforced in
Colombia (except in case of arbitration), domestic courts would
normally enforce foreign judgments provided that they have been
recognized by the Supreme Court of Justice, through an exequatur
procedure, as having the value of a local judgment (Article 694 of the
Civil Procedure Code).
The court would typically verify whether the foreign award is final and
enforceable in the issuing country and whether the foreign court was
seized with a matter normally falling under the exclusive jurisdiction of
Colombian courts. It would also verify that the foreign decision was
rendered without fraud whilst providing the parties with a due process
of law. Of course, the foreign decision must be compatible with
Colombian public policy. Recognition finally depends on reciprocity,
which means that Colombian Courts will not recognize and enforce
foreign decisions issued in countries which do not recognize
Colombian decisions. Once exequatur is granted, the interested party
may commence execution proceedings before a lower court.
In addition, Colombia is a signatory to the New York Convention on the
Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards of 1958.
Therefore, domestic courts also ought to recognize and enforce
decisions rendered through international arbitration proceedings.
Litigation @ Euler Hermes
Should legal action be necessary Euler Hermes can provide
support throughout the legal process from judgment to
enforcement via our World Collection Network of Euler Hermes
offices and External Providers. Legal action can often be
complicated and expensive, you will be informed of all costs
prior to any action and advised on which route is best to take.
6
Handling insolvent debtors
A debtor is deemed insolvent when it faces the imminent inability to
satisfy its obligations, or whenever it fails to satisfy two or more
obligations representing 10% or more of its total liabilities for a period
exceeding ninety days.
The Colombian Insolvency Act (Law 1116 of 2006) provides for
reorganization proceedings similar to U.S. Chapter 11 proceedings, as
well as judicial liquidation proceedings (similar to U.S. Chapter 7).
Insolvency proceedings
Out-of-Court proceedings
Out-of-Court negotiations allow debtors to discuss debt restructuration
with their creditors before they have become insolvent. The rules of
normal court proceedings are applied informally, but the final
agreement must be validated by an insolvency judge.
Restructuring the debt
Debt restructuration proceedings are becoming increasingly efficient
and may be commenced upon the filing of a petition by the debtor, by
one or more of the defaulted creditors, or by the Superintendent. If the
court admits the petition, the debtor is deemed insolvent and all
enforcement claims are stayed: secured creditors lose their
preferential treatment and their guarantees are put on hold until the
reorganization plan is terminated. The reorganization plan submitted
by the debtor must be approved by its creditors (simple majority of the
five voting classes / or a 75% majority notwithstanding debtors’
classes) and by the judge to be final and binding. The company’s
Directors often retain power to manage the business under the
supervision of the Creditors’ Committee, but the court may in certain
circumstances designate a different ‘Promoter’. Where a Promoter is
assigned, the management role is taken by the Promoter. If the
Company Director want to continue managing the company,
authorisation is needed from the creditors.
Debt reorganization proceedings terminate upon compliance of all
obligations by the debtor, or turn into a liquidation procedure if
implementation of the plan fails.
Winding up proceedings
Liquidation proceedings typically occur as a result of a failure to reach
a reorganization compromise, or where the debtor has failed to abide
by the negotiated terms.
Liquidation may otherwise be ordered upon at the request of both the
debtor and the creditors. A liquidator is appointed to establish a list of
the creditors’ claims, and to manage the estate’s liquidation.
Priority rules
Priority is always given to secured credits which include court costs.
Priority rules normally apply whilst distributing the proceeds to the
creditors and the Civil Procedure Code (Articles 2495, 2497 and 2506)
define how the credits should be repaid. Five classes of creditors would
be considered by order of priority: employees’ salaries and tax credits,
credits with pledge, credits with mortgage, suppliers, and credits
without previous preferences.
How long could insolvency proceedings take?
Although it is difficult to provide an average duration of insolvency
proceedings, these could last for over seven years.
Necessary documents
The reorganization judge must normally receive original bills,
promissory notes or any other document to support the debt.
Insolvency @ Euler Hermes
Euler Hermes work closely with debtors, creditors and lawyers to
provide support during insolvency and restructuring processes.
With many options available when it comes to insolvency action,
we can offer advice on which option is suitable.
7
© Copyright 2016 Euler Hermes Collections. All rights reserved.
Euler Hermes Collections provide a global commercial debt collection service with true end-to-end capability. It is part of
Euler Hermes, a company of Allianz, leader in credit insurance solutions helping companies grow their business safely at
home and abroad. Euler Hermes Collections manage both domestic and international trade debt collection services
worldwide. Through our network of Euler Hermes sister offices and partners, we use our experience and knowledge of
local markets to ensure a professional service for our clients from pre-legal action through to legal proceedings.
Visit Euler Hermes Collections: www.eulerhermes-collections.com
Contact Euler Hermes Collections: [email protected]
Country Profile: Colombia Apr 16
This Collection Profile is published by Euler Hermes Collections, part of the Euler Hermes Group and a company of
Allianz, for information purposes only. The information provided therein shall not be regarded as providing any legal
advice or advice of any kind. Readers should make their own independent evaluation of this information and under no
circumstances shall any action be undertaken solely relying on it whilst legal advice should at all times be sought with
legal practitioners. Whilst this information has been collected and drafted by recognised experts in their field and it is believed to be correct and reliable, Euler Hermes Collections makes no warranty (express or implied) of any kind, as regards
the accuracy or completeness of this information, nor does it accept any responsibility or liability for any loss or damage
arising in any way from any use made of or reliance placed on, this information. This material should not be reproduced
or disclosed without our consent. It is not intended for distribution in any jurisdiction in which this would be prohibited
and Collection Profiles are subject to change without notice.