Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit
Transcription
Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit
Reprinted from Diseases of the Nervous System Vol. 36 No . 8 August 1975 Pages 461 465 1975 46 1 Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t A DOLPH R. BERGER . M D.t AND NEIL SPIELHOLZ. Ph .D.tt Abstract The identification of marginal magnesium deficit , such as we ha ve detected in a patient with anxiety, depression , and psychomatic complaints , is a difficult diagnostic problem . Electromyography of a limb, rendered acute ly ischemic either just before or after hyperventilation , can elicit latent tetany in thi s condition , as well as in calcium deficiency . We have demonstrated iterati ve electrical activity in our patient, whose magnesium deficit is auri butable to renal wasting of magnesium . We have e licited s imilar patterns in several other patients. who had margina ll y low serum mag· nesium a nd who also exhibited weak ness. a nxiety, a nd psychosomatic disorders . Thi s preliminary report suggests the need for further cons ideratio n of the possibility tha t chron i~ magnesium-defi c it ma y contribute to the syndro me of la tent teta ny, psychosomatic complaints , and wea kness. Electromyographic evidence of latent tetany has been observed in some patients with marginal magnesium deficit , whose multiple ill-defined complaints may be mistake n for psychon eu rosis .'-7 De fi ciency of magnesium . which i!) predomina ntly a n intracellular cation. is not often diagnosed in this country unless the de ple tion is s0 severe as to cause symptoms referable to overt te ta ny. o r me tabolic encephalopathy , o r both . T hi!) form of encephalopath y has been clearly related to lowered brain and cerebros pinal levels of magnesium in mag ne!)i um-derived rats by C hutkow a nd his ~o lle ag u e!). M-~ · 10 Since 1958. however. lesser degree!) of magnesium Jeticit (a s~oc ia t ed with a neuromuscular syndrome) have been reported by Ro!>selleL 2 as "cryptote tany·· , a nd by Durlach 3 - 7 as ··spasmophilia .·· Although some patients with this !) yndrome exhibit slightl y depressed levels of serum magne~ium , low e rythrocyte levels have bee n reported to occur more consistently .5 · 6 · 7 This syndrome, which occurs more frequently in women than in men , is accompanied by many psychosoma tic complai nts. The physical examination is usuall y normal (or non-contri buto ry). The electrocardiogram sometimes exhibits ventricular premature contrat.:tion or mildl y abnormal fina l deflections . The conventional electromyogram is normal. Howe ver . hyperve ntilation, and ischemia of the tested muscle , produce iterative electrical ac ti vity. We ha ve not t From tht' Departmt'nt (~{ Medicin e . Nt'\1' York University Medical Center. and Goldll'ate r Memorial H ospital ++Jnstitutt' of Rehabilation M edicine found reference to this syndrome in the English language literature since Rosselle' s and Durlach 's monograph s, 1- 7 although there have been numerous publications in French and Italian language journals (over 30 citations by Durlach in his 1969 monograph 7). Recently we diagnosed this condition in a postmenopausal woman . 11 Case Report and Methods SLB , a 57-year-old woman of Italian anl:estry, was of weakness, depression , anxiety , ··spots before the eyes'· , ge neralized pruritus, swelling of the lower extremitie s and puffiness around her eyes and mo uth . This clinical picture , which also included occasional dys pnea and precordial pain , gastrointestinal complaints , without detectable organic cause , had persisted for over two years. Cardiologic examination was normal , psychiatric evaluation indicated only depressive anxiety , which yielded partially and temporarily to treatment , with diazepam and amitryptoline. Although skin testing showed no s pecific allergy , use of antihistamine therapy has been necessary for control of pruritus. The simila rity of her clinical picture to that described as ··cryptotetany" or "spasmophilia" 1 - 7 led to investigation of her magnesium status (details described elsewhere'') . He r initial serum magnesium level was found to be margi nally low ( 1.67 mEq/L) , by the range accepted as no rma l in the hos pital laboratory ( 1.9-2.5).' 3 Conventiona l nerve conduction tests and EMGs had been found normal , but E MG s tudies (by a technique mod ified from that e mployed by RosseUet. 2 and Durlach 3 - 7) elicited iterative a~ ti v ity. * After about three minutes (two minutes of hyperventilation , followed by one minute of ischemia) single motor unit of discharges appeared , firing at a relatively slow rate (two to th ree per second) . At this ti~e , there were no visible muscle twitchings or spasms . Within the next 15-30 seconds , motor unit activity increased in frequency , and the sounds characteristic of visually recorded ho~pitalized becau~e *The typical p~t tt erns of increa~ed electrical activity are described' as (I ) repetitive! potentials of one or more motor units, with repclltr ve d i~char ges (2-8 times) at frequency of 125 to 250 per se.:ond . termed doublets , triple t~ . quadriplets or multiplets, (2) ~pon ta neou ~ dischar ges of a motor unit of high frequency ~~- 1 2 per second) during slight involuntary contraction . Ros!>dle 1 interprets the EMG as positive if regular repetiti ve activity persis ts for at leas t two minutes during the pos t-ischemic phase or after h yperpnea.' If the modification is used , the pa tient hyperve ntilates befo re ische mia is induced (See Appendi x). 462 DISEASES OF THE NERVOUS SYSTEM Figure 1: Doublets fro m abductor pnllio.:i\ hre\i~ afl er two minute' of hypc:rventilation followed by 1.5 mmute~ •>f ischemia. Calibration signifies 100 ms and 100 uV . AUGUST provement experienced following the injection of magnesium . The EMG, taken shortly thereafter, was normal and repetitive firing and spasm could not be provoked by hyperventilation , followed by ischemia for 10 minutes. For several weeks , thereafter, she received oral magnesium supplements, and it was possible to decrease the use of antihistamine and diazepam. However, a month later, the intensity of her complaints completely returned, and she obtained brief (1-2 day) periods of relief only after intramuscular injections of magnesium. Placebo injections produced no clinical change. Rehospita lization . on several occasions. for metabolic and hormone studies, revealed that she was a renal magnesium waster. and that she had intermittent normotensive aldosteronism. with peripheral edema and sodium retention.•• Her serum magnesium level usually remained below I. 7 mEq/ L. serum calcium was normal (9.5-9.7 mg%) . Serum magnesium values of2. 1 mEq were reached after repeated intrave nous or intramuscular injections of magnesium. On one such occasion. her hyperventilation/ischemia EMG did notrevert to norm al. even when te~ted ~hile she was receiving a n intravenous infusion of 200 ml of dextrose and water. to which 2 ml of magnesium sulphate had been added . Her symptoms improved the next day. after a second magnesium-infusion. Two hours after completion of the second infusion. her EMG was normal. Discussion t"igure 2: Complete interference pallerns recorded simultaneously from abductor pollicis bre' i' and ahd uctor digiti quinti after :!.5 minutes of ischemia. doublets and triplet s could he heard. (Fig . I). During the following 60 seconds . the acti\·it j inu eased to such an extent that a complete interference pattern was recorded (Fig. ::!) and at the same time marked wrist and finger spasm were evident. These contractions were completely in voluntary . With release of the cuff after only two and a half minutes of ischemia, all electrical activity disa ppea red within 30 seconds. The next day. to test for magnesium deficit. the patient was given an intramuscular injection of 2 ml of a 50% of solution of magnesium sulphate (to test for percentage retention of magnesium). 1 .. 12 She retained over 60% of the parenterally administered magnesium. in contrast to the normal retention of 15-2® ..... 2 Within two hours of the injection she experienced marked relief of all of her symptoms. In the course of her ho<; pitalization the patient had received many other injections . none of which had evoked the clinical im- Our patient with the abnormal h yperventilation/ischemic EMG pattern and carpal -.pasm. and those described in Europe_. _ , a ll had marginal magnesium deficit.* Similar signs are also seen with hypocalcemic latent teta ny! 4 · 15 · 16 However. Rose1Jel. 2 and Durlach 3 -• have reported that their patients had similar clinica l and electrical phenomena with magnesium deficit, in the absence of hypocalcemia. Similarly. our patient showed these findings with margina lly low serum magnesium levels. but normal serum calcium le vels. *We have su bsequentl y obta ined s imilar electrica l findings on three additional patients without neuromuscul ar disease. In two. the h yperventilation/ ischemia EMG was found abnormal after the diagnosis of magnesi um deficit had been made on the basis of serum magnesium levels of I. 1- 1.4 m Eq/ L and multiple psychosomatic a nd neuromusc ular complaints. In a nother. the hyperve ntil ation/ischemia test was employed because of the patient's biza rre neuromuscu lar complai nts. When strongly positive EMG results were elicited. his serum electrolytes were analyzed. He was normocalcemic. but his serum Mg was I .5 mEq/ L. To evaluate the significance of these pat ients· neuromu scu lar irritability , as demons tra ted by electromyography foll owing h yperve ntilation and ischemia. we tes ted ten normal volunteers. who did not have neuromuscular o r psychiatric abno rmalities. Magnes ium serum levels . "'hich were done only in five. were within normal limits . None exhihited th e EMG pattern descrihed here . .:' en "'h.:n the pl>St-h yperventilation ischemia was maintained for ten minute s. 1975 ' LATENT TETANY AND ANXIETY. MARG INAL. MAGNESI U M DEFICIT Although hypocalcemia and hypomagnesemia each causes clinically ma nifest neuromuscular irritability and electromyographic a bnormalities . suc h as are reported here. nerve ph ysiology studies indicate that the mecha nisms are not the same . Chutkow 17 has reviewed the evidence and points out that, a lthough magnesium deple tion has electrophysiologic effects on nerve axons similar to those of calcium depletion , the calcium effect far outweighs the magnesium effect at this site. Calcium is principa lly involved in nerve membrane potential and stability ; depressive effect of hypercalcemia is caused by ner ve membrane hyperpolarization, dec reased sodium conductance. a nd resultant elevation of the depolari zation threshold . With h ypoct~ lcemi a the re i-; .m increase in depolarization that a llows for response to slow depolariza tio n and loss of accommodation, 2 .. 22 as a result of which peripheral nerves di scharge independe ntl y. 23 When a nerve impul se reaches the skeletal myoneura l junction. the resultant depolariza tion of. the nerve endings re leases ace tyl choline (ACh) into the syna ptic space. 2 u 5 ACh mo lec ules then diffuse across the syna ptic cleft and attach to specific receptors of the spec ialized area in the postsynaptic sarcolemma. which results in non-specific inc reased ionic permeability , flow of'an ionic current , and -depolarization (the end plate potential). When this depolarization reaches the excitation threshold of the adjacent sarcolemma, a muscle action potential develops, that ultimately initiates the mu scle contraction. Magnesium exerts its majo r neuromuscular effects at the myoneural j_unction. 17 · 24 -~ 0 At this site. calcium and mag nesium are a ntagonistic . 2" -28 - 2 !1· 30 -3 1 Calc ium enhances. and magnesium inhibits, therelease of ACh. Additionally. the sensitivity of the motor end plate is diminished by high magn-esiu-m concentrations, 25 such high concentrations also having cholinesterase-activating effects. 32 ·33 Thus, hypocalcemia exerts two paradoxical effects: it increases periphera l nerve excitability , but it decreases release of the neurotransmitter (ACh) into the myoneural synaptic space . We postulate that the hypocalce mia-induced suppressio n of neuromuscular transmission may be overcome by the increased presence of ACh resulting from magnesium deficit. Increased tra nsmitter augments the tendency towards repetitive sarcolemmal depolarization a nd muscle contraction.* Since either hypocalcemia or hypomagnesemia can elicit similar abnormal hyperventilation/ischemia EMG patterns, both cautions must be measured to elucidate the specific deficit. The patients described here, and those reported earlier, 1 - 7 all had margina lly low serum magnesium and normal serum calcium levels. In our gro up, we rarely saw serum magnesium levels below 1.5 mEq/ L. In view of our patient 's la tent tetany a nd neuropsychiatric manifestations, the findings of Chutkow et 463 a J8.11·10 may have s pecial relevance. They demonstrated tha r rars with acute, subacu te or chronic magnesiumdeficiency exhibit decreased brain a'hd cerebrospinal fluid magnesium levels, not necessarily closely related with changes in blood levels of magnes ium. They found that even small decrease s in brain magnesium are accompanied by ma rked a lteratio ns in bra in excitability .t 0 Whether the slight electroencephalographic abnormalities of our patient, elicited only during hyperventilation, reflect a magnesium-deficit encephalopathy, remains to be proved . C hutkow and Grabow 10 also commented on the hi '\ta min e- relea~f' of rnagnc ~in rn -deprivation , 36 - 37 an important point in terms of the evidence that histamine may be a central neurotransmitter. 10 Note should be made. here. that one of our patient's most distressing complaints is generalized pruritus, and that her requirement for antihistamine therapy exceeds the amount tolerated by most subjects . Worth mentioning , also, is the fac t that 75% of Roselle 's patients with latent teta ny of magnesiumdeficiency improvec.'l on treatment with thyroxine.• Th is is a provocative finding. since thyroid h'ormone affects protein-binding of magnesium; its influence on the ratio·oNree to~tround •magn·esium-~i S" no't'<lefmitely established.38 Before instituting this therapeutic approach in our patient , who has thyroid function at the low limit of the normal range, we considered the similarity of some of her findings to those of some patients with periodic paralysis or weakness, who also have intermittent aldosteronism, and who exhibit exacerbations in response to administration of salt: 39 ·40 In this context, we must recall that some patients with periodic para~ysis have responded favorably to thyroid administration or stimulation, -and have experienced rec urrence of weakness or withdrawal of thyroid therapy, 41 whereas others have periodic paralysis in association with hyperthyroidism. 41 · 42 Whether our pa~ tient, who a lso suffers from marked weakness, presents a nother facet of hypoka lemic periodic paralysis (magnesium deficit being known to predispose to.Joss of muscle po tassium , a nd to prevent its repletion)43• 44 requires further elucidation. Remaining to be explored is the relationship of such patients' multiple neuropsychiatric complaints with a possible metabolic encephalopathy , that may be caused by chronic magnesium deficit. 8 · 9 · 10 Study of cerebrospinal fluid levels of magnesium . during phases of exacerbation and remission, possibly in association with meta bolic balance data obta ined during magnesium *Combined deficits give rise to severe forms of neuromuscular irri tabili t y. Whether th e convul s io ns of infanti le hypo magnesemic hypocalcemia, t hat are refractory to treatment unril borh defi ci t ~ (Ire correl: t e~.J. ·11 " are relevant liJ the clinical tetany that is the su bjec t of this paper is moot. What ha ppens at the myoneura l junction· in response to calcium and magnesium may differ from what happens in the central synapses. 464 supplementatio n and restriction , may provide valuable inc;ight intn the syndrome de c;crihect here. 10. C hutkow . J .G .. Grabow . J .0 .: C linical and chemical corre lations in magnesium- depri v:~ ti<>n t> n c e rh alnpath~· of V<>llng r;j r ~ . Am ./. Plr n iol. 221 14!17- 1414. 1972 . Seel ig. M .S .. Berger . A R.: A ne"' c linica l patt,.rn <'f magnesium deficit associated with renal magnesium wa~ting . Oe~c ri ption pf a ' y ndrnme m::~nife<te d hy pruritus. fa t il!lle . depressi ve a nx iety . al>normal electrnmyo(!ram . <~ n d n o rmu t en~ive. inte rmirtent a ld ost e roni~m . !Sub mitted for publ. ) II APPF:NOJX I . The c;ubject . lying completel y rela xed o n a comfortable couch , is ins tructed not to move the hand o r arm (to eliminate voluntary contraction of th e mu scles of the limb being tes ted) throughout the entire test procedure . A blood-pressure cuff i<:> wrapped around the upper arm . 2. A teflon-coated mono~)Ja r needle electrode io; inserted into the a bductor digiti quinti heing tested and a o;urface electrode is ta pt'd over th e insert ion llf thio; muo;cle . A o;imilar pair nf e lectrnde' ;._employed to record from the ipsilatera l ahcluctor po llicio; hrcvis muscle . The e lectri cal ac ti vity from ho th muscles io; dis plaved o;imultaneous ly o n tw1l c hannels llf a Teca TE-4. wit h co nstant mPnitoringo n fiheroptic readout . 12 . Fo urman. P .V .. Morgan. D . B .: C hro 'lic Prl'c. ,'\.utr. Sr.'c-. 21 :34-4 1, 1%2 . n. ElecHom) <•gr;•phoe 1n n enou~ di~ea~ e and in nyptotetany. Ed\ . E . Nauwe l aert~. Pul>l. U ni versi•;j ire 2. l.ouvai n . Be lgi11m . 1951! tin F rench I. 14~4 tin Engli~h): 3. Durlach. J.. Lebru n . R .: Magnesium et p<~tho~genit> mo philie con~titutione lle idiopathiqut> . I R 15l: 1973- 197.~ . 1959 . tfl 1960. Durlach . J .. Dreu x. C. . Le l>run. R . . Jarreau F X . Ba rachet L.: Etude statistique de magne~ium e r ythrocytaire dans Ia s p asmo philie con stitutionelle idiop athique. Ann Endorrinol (Pa ris) 23:83-88. 1%2 . 6 . Durlach . J .. Gremy . F .. Metra l. S .: La s pasmo philie: form s clinique n euromu~culaire du deficit magnesien primitif. Etude s tatistique de Ia valeur diagno~tique et p rojUlostique de~ c riteres clini ques et paracl inique~ . R Po·. Nt>urol . 117: 177- 189. 1967 . 7 Durlach , J.: Spasmophilia a nd magne ~ium clefic it. Pub /. M a.<.<FJn & Cie. Paris . France. 1969. 8 C hutkow. 1 .G .: Clin ical-chemical co rrel a t ion ~ in the t> nce phalopathy of m ;~gnesi um de fi cie ncy . Effect o f rever~al l'f maanes ium deficits . .\f11y(l Clin Pmc· 49:244- 247. 1974. 9. Chutkow. J .G . . Meyers . S .: C ht>mical c hanges in the ce rebrospinal fluid and 1-lrain in magn ~siu m deficiency . \'purt~l'll!." 18:963-9?4, 196S. - .... f-e ld man . R.<i .. <ir ;tn!!er . r:. \ rl e~·trc>mv•JI!raph' in latent reran) . , ._ Fl!l!l. J \-f,.,J Y·4· )()1>4 - l %~ . tOf,l · in Il u man Patho logy . Vitt el. F~anct> 1<17 t· I P-Il4 . i\dt>lman . W Jr .. M•.'Ore. J .: '\c tion of exte rnal di valent ion reduc tion o n <odiu m movement in the <quid 11iant :~ •on J . r;,,_ Plrnio/. 45:91- 101 . 1961 I<I . Adelman. W . Jr.: The e tTe~· t .•lf external ca lcium and magnesium d e plf't io n '-' " ~i ngle nt>l'e fiN>r~ . J . (;,.., Nn·, ir:/. l'J:7<3 T' ~ 195ft :.>n . Guttman. R .: <ital>ilintion of s pi<ler c rab nerve membranes by alkaline eart h s.:~~ ma nifested in resti ng potel't i :~ l meas urements. 2~ : 343 -364 . 1<140. J r.en . Phv.tin/. 2 1. Kugelb<:rg. E.: Acc<'mmodat ion in human ner ves . A r •a . Plrv.<iol. S r·and. 8: Suppl 24 . 1944 . 22 . Soland!. D. Y.: The measuren•ent of -- accom modation ·· in nerve , ,,,_., ._ Rm· Soc . 119: l<_'i - ~i9. 19'5 . ::'l Koenig. H . . Stahlec ker. H . a nd K<lenig. R .S .: The n c uromu ~c oo la r rrechani'ln l'f a lkaloti c a nd h } pnn tl·:l'mic t t'la n} . p,,, '"' l-:.•1•- Hi,J . .\lt-J ~'J · HH- U3. 1<1 ~ ::' . ~.J . DelCastillo . J .. Katz . B.: Quanta! C<rmp<>nenh of the end-plate Jli.'IP.nti;jl. J . /'h niol 1 ]<1 : 5~\..~7' . !'Jq 25·. DelCastillo . J .: The trans mi ~~ion of excitation from nerve to mu ~c l e . in Ad a ms . R . D .. Eato n . L.M . . Shy. M . tedsl : '1/eur.,musc-ular Di.w rdl'n . Ra ltimo re. Williams and Wilkin ~. 196U. 9H-14l . Fffect ~ o f magne<ium conce ntrati<>n in ' enrnr 2f.. HnfT. H . E .. Smith . P . K .. Winkler. A .W .: o n the ner vou~ <ystem in re l:~tion tn Am . J. Plrnio/. 130:292-29.,. 1940. tP<~ri~l 4. Durlach . J .. Lebrun . R .: Jmportanct> de Ia forme h ypomagnesienne de Ia ~ pas mn philie . Ann Endocrirw/1 Paris) 21 : 244 - 2~2 . Seelig . M .S .. Berger . A .R.: R a nge of norma l serum magnes ium Vl' lll e~ !letter tn edil!lr) N Enf!/. J . Ml'd 290:974-975. 1974 17. C hutkow. J.G .: Ro le nf magnesium in neuromuscula r rh v~iol · <>gy . PnK Fir~t International Srmpo~ ium on Magnesium Defi<·it de J;j 'l'a'- s,.,. Bioi deficiency. 1< Alajo11an inc. l .. l.\ >nt~n11n . F . l..athala. H .P.. S.:herrer . J t ·,.ntrihuti<ln elec trnm v•'grapho411e a une delim it,.ti•>n de Ia tt>Ja nie df' J'adHite ,.,,.,." , \f,•./. 1. ~ lN. l42. 19~4 . Ro~se ll e. ~ . · 2. Rosselle . N .. Ooncker. K .: La t etanie magne~ iprive che1 l'ho mme. Etu de 1-lioc hemiqut> f't e lec tromyngraphique . Pculr Bart 7: 17- 11! . 11!35- 1!147. 19'i9. magne~i um 14 . Turpin. R .. Lefe bre. J . Lerique . J .: I.e ~ modifications de J'electromvogramme t>le mentai re et It"< tro•tbles de Ia trans mis~io n n eu r<> m u ~cul:'l ire da ns ),. retanie . C R Arotl Sd . 2 1 f>·~7!! . 194l IR 3. After determining w hethe r there is electrical activity at rest , the patient is asked to hyper ven tilate for two minutes . Then th e c uff is infla ted to a h<lut 20 mm Hg above the pressure which ohliterates the radia l pul se. If o;pontanemts discharge occurs earl y. pre!'s ure is m aintained for two minutes. to a llow for development of the interference pattern . (A pattern .Qf e lectrical acti vit y produced when numerous motor units are active so th at their action potential can no lo nger be identified individuall y). Pressure s ho uld not be mainta inerl lo nl!er tha n ten min11tes. ~- AUG I JSl D ISEASES O F THE NERVOUS SY<;l FM ~7 . i t~ De lCastillo . J.• Engbaek. L.: T he nature nf the neuronou ,.;u lar hloc k produced hy magn esium . J . Phniol. 124. Pfl 'K.t . 1<1<4. 2!1 . Huttar . O.F .. K o~tial . K .: Effect of magnesium ;ontl ~ ak111111 ron< o n the rele il~e nf a cetylcholine . J . l'ln·siol. I ::'-1 :\4 ?-11, 1954. 29. Jenkinson . D.J .: The natu re of t he antagoni,m l>et wt>en calcium a nd magne ~ ium ion~ at the n '!u romu~cula • j unc t ion . -' · Phniol. 131!:414-444. 19~7 . )0. Hubhard. J.L.: The effect of calcium a nd magnes ium o n the spontaneous release of transmitter fro m mammalian motor ner ve e ndings. J. Ph•·siol . 1 59:~07-5 1 7 . 1%1. 31 . Kuruyama. H .: Effec t of calcium and magnesium o n ne uromusc ular transmissio n in the h ypogastric nerve-vas deferens prepa rati<>n of the guinea pig. J . P h\-si•J/. 175· 211 -230. 1964 . 32 Mendel. B . . Mundell. D .. Strelitz . F. : C h oli nester a~e and electrolytes . .\loture 144 :479-480. 19.'9 . 33. Nachmansohn . D : A r t ion of ion~ o n choline es tera\ e . Satun 14~ · 513-~ 1 4. 1940. 34. Da' is. J .. Han e}. 0 . . Yu 1.: Neonatal fits associated with h ypomagnesemia . -'\rclr / )is 1 /ri/d/r . 40:286-290, 1965 . I'J7:'i 3~ . I A rr T TETANY AND A X I ETY. MARtd' -\I. 1\11\(iNlcSil!M DEFICIT 465 fre1dman . M .. Hatcher. G . . Wal\on. L. : Primary h ypomag· nc\emia v. ith ~t"nmdary h y poc:ah:t"mia in an infant . Lanr·n 1 : 7(11.70~. 1%7. 43 . Whang . R .. Morosi . H.J .. Ro dgers . D .. et al: The influence of "'<rained m :~gne< ium dcficicnc~ ,m mthcle P<'' <~""'m re pletion J l .ah C/in . \fed 71)"!!95-902. 1967 . 36. Belanger. L.F . . Van Erkel. G . A . . J a kerow, A .: Behavior of the derm a l maq •·e ll' in magne~ium - defic: ie nt rat~ . 126: ~9- 30. I ')~7 . 44 . Wha ng. R.: Some aspects of t he interrelatio nship of magnesium ;~nd pNa<<ium . .1. Citron . f1iL 21 :207-210. 1%8. s, ;,,,,, ,. 37. Bois. P .. Ga5con. P .. Bea ulnes. A . : Hi stamine- li berating effect of magne~ium deficiency in the ral. NolllrP 1')7:50 1-502. 1%3. 311 . Wal~er , M .: Magnesi um metabo l i~m . Er~:Ph . Phn i" l. 59: 1!!5-2%. 1967. 1<1. Conn. J .W . . Fajans. S .S .. Loui~. I.. H .. Stret"ten . O .H . P .. John- '"". R. D.: Int ermittent a ltlo~terr•ni s m in periodic pa ralv ~i ~ : depem.l .. nc•: nt allao:k' P n rete ntion of ~ ·xl•um a nd failu re to inJoce attack t--v re,tJ iction of dif'•an ~·xlium l .annt 1 : ~0 ?- RO~. 1 4~7 . Ill. I nne,. R \ ' . \ kS"' een•· '. R R . ll roJ• lk S. R V · Peri<>dic pit t:tl\'1' '\ndiurn !nt•t tr • !; I 'IT" 1nd ;tldl'"'t!JnOe · ,:trl il 0. • ~ :t'e' I a''', ., I ~ -- I )( l ' l '4 I ngk . \ <j . lh,nud tunc ti• lll and p.. ri.)clic: para l y~i< . Am . .I \1, " · ln: 127· n ' · 1% t 4? Satoyo<hi . E .. Mura ka mi . K . Knwa. H . . et al: Periodic p;oralvsis in h ypert hyroidi<m . v""'" '"~'· 11 : 74f>.~72 . 1%3. II Acknowledgement Sinare apprrciation is exrresud t o Dr. Jerry Cl111fko 11-.for his rel'i ew of this mantHcript. and for his ntluahll' WRJ!I'S lion L f? ,,(l rint 1/ • .; ~"t 'l (llf'\ { \ · l )•· d /1! /) l'{}tll"///lt' /1/ o( \fedic ·ine ( ; , .{tfwa ft>r . \f t>~IWriul 1/ n ~pita / R<~~H e , · e/r 11-luncl Nl'w Ynrt.. .Vew York {(}(}{7 PRI I\TE D I N U.S.A.