Act 1 deliverables 2012 - European Union Agency for Fundamental

Transcription

Austria
FRANET National Focal Point
Social Thematic Study
The situation of Roma
2012
European Training and Research Centre for Human Rights
and Democracy – ETC Graz
This study was prepared under contract by the FRA’s
multidisciplinary research network FRANET. It is made available for information
purposes only and does not necessarily reflect the views or the official position of the
FRA.
DISCLAIMER:
1
Table of Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................................... 3
1
ROMA POPULATION .................................................................................................... 8
2
EDUCATION .................................................................................................................. 11
3
EMPLOYMENT ............................................................................................................. 20
4.
HOUSING AND NEIGHBOURHOOD ........................................................................ 30
5.
HEALTH ......................................................................................................................... 37
6.
POVERTY/ECONOMIC SITUATION........................................................................ 45
7.
ACTIVE CITIZENSHIP/RIGHTS AWARENESS ..................................................... 49
ANNEXES ............................................................................................................................... 53
1.
Bibliography .................................................................................................................... 53
2.
Statistical tables ............................................................................................................... 60
3.
Table of complaints ......................................................................................................... 63
4.
Table of sources (reports and studies on Roma) .......................................................... 64
5.
Roma networks................................................................................................................ 91
2
Executive Summary
In Austria, data concerning Roma regarding specific sections of the areas covered in this report is not
collected systematically by official and non-official institutions, which is due to various reasons.
Firstly, there is no legal obligation to collect data: according to various laws (e.g. relevant electoral
laws1, the Federal Law on the Documentation in the Educational System (Bundesgesetz über die
Dokumentation im Bildungswesen2), data disaggregated by ethnicity is not collected.
Secondly, members of the Roma community are hard to identify: according to §1 (3) and (4) of the
Ethnic Groups Act (Volksgruppengesetz), persons are not obligated to indicate whether they are a
member of an acknowledged ethnic group or not. Although large scale quantitative surveys would be
legitimate according to this provision, the Federal Chancellery (Bundeskanzleramt, BKA) raises
concerns regarding such surveys and does not consider them to be necessary.
Finally, it is perceived as problematic that data on ethnicity (and on membership of an acknowledged
ethnic group) may contribute to racially motivated political activities against persons as well as to
polarisation amongst the population and thus having negative consequences for certain ethnic groups.3
This problem has also been pointed out by several institutions which answered our information
requests (particularly the Federal Ministries) and by interviewed experts (e.g. an employee of Romano
Centro) who also assess the collection of persons’ ethnicity as problematic due to the experiences
during the Nazi regime. However, particularly members of Roma NGOs stress that the funding and
supporting of surveys (even qualitative ones) that highlight the situation of Roma in Austria is not on
the agenda of the Austrian government.
However, some empirical (mainly qualitative) research on topics which are relevant for some sections
of this report has been conducted in Austria, e.g. in the Province of Burgenland or the “Weinviertel” in
Lower Austria. Furthermore, there exist several master theses dealing with the situation of Roma in
Austria in certain areas. Data and results of these studies are provided. In an attempt to compensate for
the lacking (quantitative) data, interviews with experts were conducted for this study. However, data
provided are only estimations.
Education
In Austria, all persons have access to public schools; however, the educational system is perceived as
being highly selective because pupils of early age are transferred into different school types after
having completed primary school (usually at the age of 10). Some attempts to change this early
selection have been made by introducing an integrated school system for 10-14 year-old pupils (pilot
project “New Grammar School”, Pilotprojekt “Neue Mittelschule”). However, there are no schools in
segregated areas, particular classes, or special needs schools predominantly attended by Roma children
in Austria. Still, discrimination of Roma is perceived as playing a major role in the educational
system.
1
Information received by the Federal Ministry of the Interior (Bundesministerium für Inneres, BMI) on 22
August 2012.
2
Austria, Federal Chancellery (Bundeskanzleramt, BKA) (2010), p. 27.
3
Austria, Federal Chancellery (2010), pp. 26-28.
3
Although the situation of Roma with migratory background is not well known, their educational
achievements are estimated to be rather low. Thus, supporting measures are deemed necessary to
prevent transferring them to special needs schools. According to the perception of an expert in the
field of education, the educational situation of autochthonous Roma in Austria has been improved
during the last 25 years. However, other experts in this field as well as representatives of Roma
organisations share the opinion that the educational attainment of Roma children is still low. Since the
1980s, Roma children who have had difficulties following classes in the regular schooling system;
have often been transferred to special needs schools; the situation improved during the last years for
autochthonous Roma, who are now better integrated in the regular schooling system compared to nonautochthonous Roma children.
According to the results of a qualitative study, which has been conducted at several primary schools in
Vienna from 2007 until 2009, teachers are not properly educated in dealing with heterogeneous
classes, especially when Roma children are concerned. The most important factor influencing the
educational attainment of Roma children in a negative way is the lack of German language skills.
Furthermore, a lack of cooperation between teachers, parents and the school as well as a lack of
support from parents of Roma pupils are identified as being problematic in this regard.
Measures to improve the educational situation of Roma have been implemented, e.g. additional care in
the afternoon in compulsory schools and the implementation of the principle of “intercultural
learning” as an educational goal in curricula of primary schools to respond to the cultural and
linguistic diversity of pupils. Especially measures to improve the language skills have been
implemented in kindergarten, pre-school and compulsory school. Furthermore, learning-aid
programmes for Roma children are offered by several Roma organisations (e.g. Roma assistants).
THARA offers counselling and preparation courses for career entry for Roma pupils and adults.
Housing/neighbourhood
In general, most Roma with enduring residence in Austria are sedentary, travelling is a rare
phenomenon and only practiced by a very limited number of Austrian Sinti families or by Roma from
other countries (e. g. France and Germany) who visit Austria on a temporary basis. Furthermore, in
Austria there are no segregated and marginalised Roma settlements to a similar extent to that of other
Central and Eastern European countries. However, many Austrian Roma live in disadvantaged
neighbourhoods and districts with a higher density of people with low income. Such areas show a
rather high variance of different social strata and ethnic backgrounds (including rather large shares of
people without a migratory background). However such areas are not considered as real problem
areas. Since the access to public and social housing was opened for non-citizens, the access of Roma
with a migratory background to these facilities should be given. However, particularly in the field of
private housing, racist discrimination is believed to exist—although it is difficult to prove.
The primary settlements of Roma are located in the Austrian provinces Burgenland, Vienna and
Lower Austria. In the Burgenland’s district Oberwart there is a rather visible settlement of
autochthonous Roma called “Am Anger”. In connection to a bomb attack in the 1990s, the bad housing
conditions in this settlement came to public attention and subsequent attempts have been made to
renovate it.
Qualitative data indicates that most of the Roma households are over-crowded: in many cases parents
share a bedroom with their children, which is used as living room during the day. Furthermore, many
4
dwellings are in a bad condition: leaking roofs, living in condemned houses without electricity or
water or at least substandard living (without sanitary installations inside).
There are only two halting sites for travelling Roma in Austria; both are located in the province Upper
Austria. Besides space, these halting sites offer water, electricity and waste disposal services, but they
are not cost-free. For a fee of €10 per day and per caravan, travelling Roma receive water, sanitary
installations, waste disposal and electricity. The halting site in Braunau offers space for 20 caravans
and the one in Linz for 25 caravans. Further halting sites are negotiated in the municipalities of
Innsbruck, Wels and St. Pölten.
In general, regarding the readiness of the Austrian government to adopt measures to improve the
housing situation of the Roma, it has to be stated that the disadvantage of Roma in the field of housing
(which is assumed to be true for the migrant Roma only, not for the autochthonous group) is traced
back to disadvantages in education. Therefore, the Austrian government prioritises affirmative action
and assistance measures in the field of education.
Employment
It is difficult to find precise data regarding the integration of the Roma in the labour market. It is only
possible to collect a sample of data in a specific project or action/activity. If Roma are employed, most
of them work in unskilled or semi-skilled positions, mainly in the sector of services. Also, male Roma
are mainly employed in the sector of services. A high percentage of Roma hold more than one job.
Self-employment, especially different trading activities, still appears as an important source of income.
The rate of unemployment of Roma is very high, which is due to a variety of factors: low school
education, migration status, as well as poor health condition are the most prominent ones. For some
Roma, begging could be a form of survival. The prohibition of begging by most federal states in
Austria affects Roma negatively as Roma form the majority of beggars in Austria.
Roma face various forms of discrimination regarding their integration or non-integration into the
labour market.
Numerous projects for the integration of Roma into the labour market can be found. Good examples
are the THARA projects from the NGO Public Aid (Volkshilfe) as well as a project from the Vinzenz
Community of Graz.
Health
Most of the health problems of Roma are rather due to their socio-economic status than to their
ethnicity. Low or no education, a vulnerable position on the labour market and bad housing conditions
affect the health conditions of Roma. Most of them have been working for decades within the
unqualified labour market (in assembly lines, in construction, as cleaners or cook maids). The poor
working conditions in these fields affect the health status of the Roma particularly in old age. The
main health problems are also due to unhealthy behaviour: particularly smoking and malnutrition,
which leads to overweight. Especially among female Roma, a significant number of psychosomatic
health issues due to excessive demands (in reconciling care work and paid employment) or fatigue are
identified.
5
Particularly psychosomatic illnesses and mental illnesses are a problem among the Roma because they
are a taboo within the communities. In general there is reluctance among Roma to look for help in case
of health restrictions or afflictions. A particular health problem concerning Roma is the mental and
psychosomatic illnesses, which are a late sequel from the Holocaust. They do not only concern the
witnesses of the Holocaust but also their descendants and the treatment of those traumata is recognized
as an unmet need in the area of health.
Concerning the number of medically uninsured Roma, there is no data available. However, there are
specific groups among the Austrian Roma, which are assumed as risk-groups for being uninsured.
These are (mainly male) young adults and adolescents without (completed) education, respectively
early school leavers. This specific group is also a risk-group among other marginalised groups;
therefore, it can be assumed that it is not a matter of ethnicity. Another risk-group consists of female
migrants who moved to Austria within the framework of family reunion. Concerning their medical
insurance, they are dependent on their husbands who might refuse to co-insure them. A third riskgroup consists of Roma-migrants from Bulgaria, Serbia or Romania. If they do not have access to the
labour market (which is usually the case, particularly in the beginning of their residence in Austria),
they have no entitlements to allowances from social welfare and therefore, to medical insurance.
Poverty/economic situation
No data is available on income poverty and deprivation of Roma in Austria. Due to the fact that most
of the Roma work in unskilled or semi-skilled positions, their income tends to be very low. 75% of
Roma working full-time earn €1,399 at a maximum. The financial situation of most Roma is
precarious. Most of them are indebted and depend on social transfers. Some persons, mostly women
and youths, have no income at all and depend on the assistance of their families. Also, lacking
insurance could be a source for debts for Roma in case of illness. Only little evidence can be found
that Roma suffer from hunger and material deprivation.
Active citizenship/rights awareness
According to the assessment of an interviewed expert, Roma in Austria are quite aware that being
discriminated against is illegitimate. Especially autochthonous Roma seem to be aware of their rights
and tend to combat discrimination. However, not all cases of discrimination are perceived as such, e.g.
structural discrimination in the educational system. Possibilities to combat discrimination are not well
known and not often used because Roma fear negative consequences.
The Equal Treatment Commission (Gleichbehandlungskommission, GBK), the Ombudsperson for
Equal Treatment (Gleichbehandlungsanwaltschaft, GAW) and the “Klagsverband” are statutory bodies
that record and process complaints of rights violations as well as racism and/or discrimination. In its
statistics programme the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment does not systematically collect data on
their clients’ ethnicity. Statistical evaluations are only possible regarding discrimination grounds and
facts of the cases. Based on their experience in counselling, the Ombudsperson only receives a few
requests from Roma. The Equal Treatment Commission does not collect data on discrimination
disaggregated by ethnicity.
Furthermore, ZARA, an organisation that provides advice for persons who experience racist
discrimination, documents cases of racism and racist discrimination. Only ZARA documented cases of
the discriminatory usage of the term “gypsy” for the reference period. According to the European
6
Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI), the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups
(Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum), the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment, the Equal
Treatment Commission and Romano Centro, Roma experience racist/ethnic discrimination in Austria
in different areas of their lives.
Several NGOs and associations representing and/or working for or with Roma exist in Austria.
According to the assessment of interviewed experts, it is difficult to determine whether Roma are
aware of the existence of representative Roma organisations, although various Roma communities
exist in Austria as well as various Roma organisations that offer a variety of programmes for different
target groups. The autochthonous Roma, particularly those in Burgenland, seem to be rather aware of
the existence of representative Roma organisations and other civil society organisations, at least of
those located in Burgenland. The NGO Romano Centro seems to be known amongst Roma who
immigrated from former Yugoslavia and are currently living in Vienna. Also, the association RomaService raises awareness with the Rom-Bus in rural areas in Burgenland and might thus be noticed.
According to the assessment of interviewed experts, Roma are represented in non-governmental
organisations, e.g. the Cultural Association of Austrian Roma (Kulturverein österreichischer Roma),
the project THARA of the NGO Public Aid (Volkshilfe) and the Adult Education Centre of
Burgenland-Roma (Volkshochschule der burgenländischen Roma). The exercise of their active
electoral rights cannot be assessed. At least one Roma is employed at the department for integration
and diversity in Vienna (Magistratsabteilung 17 - Integration und Diversität, MA 17) of the Viennese
municipality and one Roma/Sinti-representative was elected to the Advisory Board for Migration and
Integration (Migrations- und Integrationsbeirat) in Linz to strengthen the position of the
acknowledged ethnic groups (anerkannte Volksgruppen) when dealing with questions of integration
and diversity and to compensate a marginalisation in regular democratic processes. According to the
assessment of an interviewed expert, Roma are thus underrepresented in politics.
7
1
Roma population
In 2001 it was estimated that between 10.000 and 20.000 Roma were living in Austria,4 compared to at
least 25.000 Roma in 2004.5 There are no official statistics regarding the Roma population living in
Austria. In 2001, the national census interviewed Austrian citizens on which colloquial language
(Umgangssprache) they most often used. 4.348 Austrian citizens named Romanes as their colloquial
language (Umgangssprache).6
The Roma are one of six officially acknowledged ethnic groups in Austria (the other groups are
Slovenes, Croatians, Hungarians, Czechs and Slovaks.) The recognition as a “Volksgruppe” obliges
the state to take action as to preserve the culture and language of the respective ethnic group through
both social and financial means. According to §1 (2) of the Ethnic Groups Act (Volksgruppengesetz),
prerequisites for recognition are: Austrian citizenship, a separate language and culture and a secluded
settlement area. In 1993, the “ethnic group of Roma” (a generic term for all autochthonous subgroups
living in Austria, which are Burgeland-Roma, Sinti, and most Lovara7) was recognised as a
“Volksgruppe”.8 According to the Regulation on Ethnic Groups Advisory Boards (Verordnung über
die Volksgruppenbeiräte)9, an Advisory Board must be established for Roma issues. According to §7
of the Regulation, this Advisory Board is to be made up of eight members, four of them assigned by
Roma associations as mentioned in the Ethnic Groups Act.10 According to §4 of the Ethnic Groups
Act, the members of the Advisory Boards which are installed to inform the Federal Government on
issues regarding ethnic groups in Austria (§3 of the Ethnic Groups Act) are assigned by the Federal
Government for four years. The Advisory Boards have to preserve the cultural, social and economic
common interest of the ethnic group and are to be heard within a reasonable period of time before
adopting legal norms and general plans in the area of funding. Currently an amendment to the Ethnic
Groups Act is being discussed but not decided on yet.11
The Roma population in Austria is heterogeneous. The groups differ regarding socio-cultural
background and current socio-political status, as is the norm for almost all minority ethnic groups in
Austria.12
4
Austria, Austrian Center for Ethnic Groups (Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum) (2007), p. 15.
Halwachs, D. W. (2004) Roma and Romani in Austria, Graz, available at: http://romani.unigraz.at/romani/download/files/ling_rom_at_e.pdf.
6
Statistik Austria (2001) Volkszählung 2001 - Umgangssprache von Personen mit österreichischer
Staatsbürgerschaft, einschließlich Kombination mit Deutsch, Vienna, Statistik Austria.
7
Ibid, p. 3.
8
Polis (2010) Soziale Ausgrenzung im Fokus: Roma in Österreich, Vienna, Zentrum polis, available at:
www.politik-lernen.at/site/gratisshop/shop.item/105771.html.
9
Austria, Regulation on Ethnic Groups Advisory Boards (Verordnung über die Volksgruppenbeiräte), BGBl. Nr.
38/1977, last modified by BGBl. Nr. 895/1993.
10
Austria, Ethnic Groups Act (Bundesgesetz über die Rechtsstellung der Volksgruppen in Österreich –
Volksgruppengesetz - VoGrG), BGBl. Nr. 396/1976, last modified by BGBl. I Nr. 46/2011.
11
Austria, Draft Amendment Act to the Ethnic Groups Act (Entwurf eines Bundesgesetzes, mit dem das
Volksgruppengesetz geändert wird), available at
http://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/VHG/XXIV/ME/ME_00371/fname_245271.pdf.
5
12
Halwachs, D. W. (2004) Roma and Romani in Austria, Graz, p.6, available at: http://romani.unigraz.at/romani/download/files/ling_rom_at_e.pdf.
8
Halwachs (2004) suggests that amongst all Roma living in Austria, five large groups can be
distinguished but he does not provide any estimates on the size of these groups or Roma from western
Balkans or other EU countries. The five large groups that could be distinguished are: the Roma in
Burgenland, Sinti and Lovara as well as Vlax and Muslim Roma of the Balkans (e.g. Arlije).13 Further
identifiable Roma groups include Roma who emigrated from former communist countries of central
and Eastern Europe in the 1980s, and Roma who emigrated from Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, etc.14
The Roma in Burgenland have the longest historical link with Austria, with communities dating back
to the 15th century. Lovara and Sinti arrived in the late 19th century. During the work-related migratory
influx of the 1960ies, further groups of Roma emigrated from Ex-Yugoslavia.15
There is an estimated population of between 2.500 and 5.000 persons who are considered to belong to
the Burgenland Roma group. Burgenland Roma who immigrated to Austria from Hungary are
sedentary and are living in rural areas or small cities; the majority lives in Wart. They name their
language “Roman”, which is currently only used in certain families. To revive the language, several
projects have been organised, e.g. the Roman Language Bus (Roma-Sprachbus) and several language
courses.16
The majority of the Sinti population in Austria came in the late 19th century from Germany and the
Czech Republic. The Nazi genocide of the Roma people destroyed the Sinti social structures, as it
happened with the other Roma subgroups.17 The Sinti living in larger Austrian cities are not a
marginalised group. “As far as their economic situation goes, they hardly differ from the average
Austrian citizen.”18
The Lovara belong to the Vlach-Roma, who had been living in Romanic-Hungarian language regions
for a considerable period of time. Consequently, their language has been strongly influenced by this
regional setting. Austrian Lovara first arrived in the late 19th century, with a second phase of
immigration during the Hungarian revolution in 1956.19 They are mostly living in Vienna and other
larger cities in Eastern Austria. They adapted their lifestyle to the majority society and are thus not a
marginalised group.20
The Kalderas, Gurbet and Arlije came to Austria in the 1960s as immigrant workers from Serbia and
Macedonia. Other Roma groups immigrated to Austria from the Balkan regions for the same reason
13
ROMBASE (2004) Didactically edited information on Roma, Graz, available at: http://romani.unigraz.at/rombase/.
14
15
Ibid, p. 2.
16
Polis (2010) Soziale Ausgrenzung im Fokus: Roma in Österreich, Vienna, Zentrum polis, p. 17, available at:
www.politik-lernen.at/site/gratisshop/shop.item/105771.html and ROMBASE (2004) Didactically edited
information on Roma, Graz, available at: http://romani.uni-graz.at/rombase/.
17
18
Ibid.
19
20
9
during the 1980s. Unlike Burgenland-Roma, Lovara and Sinti, they are perceived as foreigners by the
Austrian population.21
In Austria, most Roma groups are considered to be sedentary. However, in this regard, no statistics are
available.22
The religion of Roma groups living in Austria is dominated by their country of origin. BurgenlandRoma and Lovara are mostly Roman Catholic or Protestant; Vlax, Arlije and Muslim Roma are mostly
Orthodox or Muslim, respectively.23
21
Halwachs, D. W. (2004) Roma and Romani in Austria, Graz, p.1-3, available at: http://romani.unigraz.at/romani/download/files/ling_rom_at_e.pdf
22
23
Halwachs, D. W. (2004) Roma and Romani in Austria, Graz, p.1-2, available at: http://romani.unigraz.at/romani/download/files/ling_rom_at_e.pdf
10
2
Education
a. Pre-school/Kindergarten
Within the EU Framework for National Roma Integration Strategies up to 2020 (EU-Rahmen für
nationale Stragtegien zur Integration der Roma bis 2020), Austria aims at improving the educational
situation of Roma. The strategy aims at improving the situation of underprivileged persons through
fostering equal opportunities in pre-school.
In 2008 the educational model “early advancement 1+1” (Frühe Förderung 1+1) was implemented for
all pupils in pre-school. Children with a lack of German language skills are especially supported in
childcare facilities to improve their language skills before they enter compulsory school.24
Since September 2010, half-day kindergarten has been free of charge and obligatory for children (on at
least four days a week) in all federal states in Austria during the last year before they enter compulsory
schools. Kindergarten teachers are trained to improve the children’s language skills.25 Especially
Roma migrants benefit from this measure.26 Furthermore, special educational measures are offered by
child care facilities in Vienna, aiming at improving the language skills of children. In some Viennese
kindergartens children who speak a foreign first language are supported by kindergarten teachers who
speak their first language.27
The Austrian Educational Strategy (Bildungsstrategie) does not explicitly address Roma but also has
an impact on this target group. A major goal of the strategy for pre-school is that 95% of children
between the age of four and the age of school enrolment should attend pre-school until 2020.28
No special pre-school programmes for Roma-refugees are provided in Austria.29 No further
information on factors influencing the enrolment and attendance of Roma children in pre-school (e.g.
family reasons, costs of education, need to work, dismissed from school, etc.) is available.30
24
Austria, Federal Chancellery (Bundeskanzleramt, BKA) (2011), EU-Rahmen für nationale Strategien zur
Integration der Roma bis 2020. Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p.12.
25
Ibid., pp. 12f.
26
Austria, Federal Chancellery (2010), 3. Bericht der Republik Österreich gemäß Artikel 25 Abs. 2 des
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, p. 11.
27
Austria, Federal Chancellery (2011), EU-Rahmen für nationale Strategien zur Integration der Roma bis 2020.
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p. 13.
28
Ibid., p. 15.
29
Luciak, M. (2011), Roma mit Migrationshintergrund an österreichischen Volksschulen, in: Diehm,
I./Panagiotopoulou (2011), Bildungsbedingungen in europäischen Migrationsgesellschaften: Ergebnisse
qualitativer Studien in Vor- und Grundschulen, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, p. 114.
30
All relevant sources have been searched (websites of Roma organisations who provide offers for Roma, other
official institutions and ministries); information requests have been sent to The Association of Roma Oberwart
(Verein Roma Oberwart), the Ketani Association (Verein Ketani), the Cultural Association of Austrian Roma
(Kulturverein österreichischer Roma), Romano Centro, Roma Service, the Adult Education Centre of BurgenlandRoma (Volkshochschule der burgenländischen Roma), NGO Public Aid (Volkshilfe), Caritas Austria (Caritas
Österreich), the Federal Ministry of Education, Arts and Culture (Bundesministerium für Unterricht, Kunst und
Kultur, BMUKK), the department of statistics at the government in Burgenland (Abteilung für Statistik der
Landesregierung Burgenland); all information requests have been answered.
11
b. Compulsory school attendance
No statistical information on the compulsory school attendance of Roma is available.31 The share of
Roma children in certain Viennese primary schools is estimated to be rather high with a share between
7% and 10% and thus, it is not representative for primary schools in Vienna or Austria where the share
of Roma children is estimated to be lower.32
During the last years, improvements in the area of education were achieved, such as additional care in
the afternoon at schools, the introduction of full-time schools or the pilot project “New Grammar
School” (Schulversuch “Neue Mittelschule”). Although these measures do not explicitly address
Roma, they benefit from them.33
Since 1990 “intercultural learning” has been implemented as an educational goal in curricula of
primary schools to respond to the cultural and linguistic diversity of pupils. “Intercultural learning”
should be considered in all subjects taught and aims at fostering better knowledge and understanding
of other cultures and the reduction of prejudices. Studies show that the implementation of the principle
“intercultural learning” has still room for improvement, especially in the context of teachers’
trainings.34
An empirical qualitative study, conducted in several primary schools in Vienna from 2007 to 2009 to
investigate the educational situation of Roma with migratory background and a study to evaluate the
effectiveness and efficiency of learning-aid programmes for Roma children have been carried out.
Interviews with ten teachers at compulsory schools, two principals of compulsory schools, six teachers
at centres for special needs education and one head of a centre for special needs education, eight Roma
children who attend compulsory schools, ten parents of Roma pupils, five learning assistants and
seven heads of Roma-associations have been conducted. In addition, participant observation has been
conducted in learning-aid groups for Roma children offered at compulsory schools or other
institutions. The study shows that the principle of “intercultural learning” (see section a) is not
properly implemented and thus, does not address the needs of Roma children. According to the
perception of some interviewed teachers, they themselves are not properly educated to deal with
heterogeneous classes, especially with Roma children.35
According to the interviewed teachers, the lack of cooperation between teachers, parents and the
school is perceived as being problematic as is the lack of support from parents of Roma children. Most
of the interviewed parents are little educated, do not have time to support their children in the
31
Response to an information request received by Statistics Austria on 1 August 2012, a response received
from the National Contact Point at the Federal Chancellery on 13 August 2012, a response received from
Caritas Austria on 2 August 2012, a response received from the NGO Public Aid on 3 August 2012, a response
received from the department of statistics at the government in Burgenland and the Federal Ministry for
Education, Arts and Culture.
32
33
34
qualitativer Studien in Vor- und Grundschulen, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 111f.
35
Ibid., p. 113.
12
afternoon and are often not familiar with the educational system in Austria. Thus, learning aid is of
great importance for the educational attainment of their children (see section c).36
No further information on factors influencing the enrolment and attendance of Roma children in
compulsory (and secondary) education (e.g. costs of education, need to work, etc.) is available.37
c. Educational attainment
Drop-out rates of persons being between 18 and 24 years old who did not complete compulsory school
lie at 9.6%, regarding persons with migratory background at 29.8% and regarding persons in the
second or third generation of migrants at 15.6%.38 According to an expert in the area of education who
is employed at the University of Vienna and has conducted research on the educational situation of
Roma in Austria, no informative statistics concerning the educational situation of Roma (e.g.
attendance at schools, educational achievements, and higher educational qualifications) are available.
This expert assumes that the educational situation of Roma living in Austria for a long time has
improved during the last 25 years. They often graduate from compulsory school and sometimes
achieve higher education. Roma children with migratory background often achieve rather low
educational success and do not attain further education. Supporting measures are deemed necessary to
improve their educational attainment and to prevent transferring them to special needs schools.39 Other
experts in the area of education and representatives of Roma organisations share the opinion that the
educational attainment of Roma children is still low.40
Especially the educational situation of Roma with migratory background is not well known; a
qualitative study in Austria is planned to be carried out in order to gain information about the
educational situation of different Roma communities.41
The qualitative study, which is described in section a, shows that the support of parents is important
for children’s school achievements but is often missing in Roma families.42 Parents of Roma pupils
have low expectations concerning the educational attainment of their children.43 Also, Roma children
36
Ibid., pp. 117f.
official institutions and ministries); information requests have been sent to The Association of Roma Oberwart
(Verein Roma Oberwart), the Ketani Association, the Cultural Association of Austrian Roma, Romano Centro,
Roma Service, the Adult Education Centre of Burgenland-Roma, NGO Public Aid, Caritas, the Federal Ministry of
Education, Arts and Culture, the department of statistics at the government in; all information requests have
been answered. Telephonic interviews have been conducted with two experts (one employee of Romano
Centro and one employee of the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups).
38
39
Luciak, M. (2012), Roma und Sinti in Österreich – auf dem Weg zu höherer Bildung, in: Die Kupfzeitung (2012),
p. 22.
40
Kälin Schreiblehner, I. and Schinnerl, H. (2011), „… damit meine Kinder nicht dasselbe durchmachen müssen
wie ich.“ Armutslagen der bosnischen Roma im niederösterreichischen Weinviertel, in: Rosecker, M. (Ed.), Armut
und Reichtum. Ungleiche Lebenslagen, -chancen, -stile und –welten in Österreich, Vienna: Verein Alltag Verlag,
p. 360.
41
Luciak, M. (2012), Roma und Sinti in Österreich – auf dem Weg zu höherer Bildung, in: Die Kupfzeitung (2012)
p. 22.
42
43
Response to a telephonic request received by Romano Centro on 27 August 2012.
37
13
often do not complete their homework and relatively often miss classes. Children who grew up in a
foreign country and came to Austria shortly before they started school or even during the school year
have difficulties following classes due to their lack of German language skills, none or poor education
they received in their country of origin, or traumatic experiences.44
Another reason for the rather low educational achievements of Roma children is the lack of German
language skills. German as second language is foreseen in the regular schooling system
(Regelschulwesen). Remedial education in German is provided either parallel to class, integrated in
classes or in addition to classes. Classes in the pupils’ mother tongue can be offered as non-obligatory
classes.45 During the school year 2007/2008 two teachers who offer classes in Romanes have been
employed at public schools in Vienna.46 With the exception of recent immigrants, Roma children with
migratory background do not attend classes for German as a second language although they have
problems in writing German.47 Furthermore, it is pointed out that Roma sometimes do not assess
education as being important or as improving the economic security or social integration. Even if they
do, the income of the families is too low to make further education possible for their children
(particularly the efforts for school boarding house, school materials and travel costs often exceed the
family budget). Furthermore, Roma children often apprentice themselves to contribute to the family
income earlier.48 A qualitative study conducted in 2004 shows that most of the fourteen Roma
interviewed in Lower Austria share the opinion that education is important.49 No information
concerning school accessibility (e.g. lack of public transport; Roma populations situated long distance
from school, etc.) is available.50
The department MA 17 of the Viennese government, in cooperation with Roma associations in
Austria, is developing measures to increase the participation of Roma in education and to improve
educational attainment of Roma children. A platform, consisting of the department MA 17 of the
Viennese government and six Roma associations, is currently working on further developing learning
44
qualitativer Studien in Vor- und Grundschulen, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 114- 117.
45
Ibid., p. 112.
46
47
48
Response to an information request received from the association of Roma Oberwart (Verein Roma
Oberwart) on 10 September 2012.
49
pp. 362f.
50
official institutions and ministries); information requests have been sent to The Association of Roma Oberwart,
the Ketani Association, the Cultural Association of Austrian Roma, Romano Centro, Roma Service, the Adult
Education Centre of Burgenland-Roma, NGO Public Aid, Caritas Austria, the Federal Ministry of Education, Arts
and Culture, the department of statistics at the government in; all information requests have been answered. A
telephonic interview has been conducted with an expert (an employee of the Austrian Centre for Ethnic
Groups.
14
aid programmes for children between age 6 and 16 and supporting measures for parents. The project is
carried out in Vienna.51
The Association Romano Centro focuses on education and culture of Roma. Since 1995, learning
assistants have provided learning aid for children at children’s homes, who attend compulsory school.
In the school year 2011/2012, 25 learning assistants supported 132 Roma children in Vienna and
close-by municipalities. Learning assistants were free of charge until 2008; since then, they cost three
Euros per hour. Exceptions can be made in case parents cannot afford this amount.52 Furthermore,
Romano Centro has offered Roma assistants for Roma children since 2000. Roma assistants, who
speak Romanes, have the responsibility to mediate between teachers, pupils and parents. They
motivate children and accompany them in class, assist pupils when they are having difficulties in class
and try to facilitate access to school for the parents. Furthermore, they arrange additional learning aid
possibilities and accompany pupils on school trips.53
The “RomBus”, a project carried out by Roma-Service, aims at raising awareness of the importance
of educational attainment and provides learning aid and counselling for the everyday-life at school in
Roma’s houses or flats.54
According to the EU Framework for National Roma Integration Strategies up to 2020, measures which
aim at improving the attainment of educational career of Roma children are especially supported.
Possibilities to improve and intensify the instrument of “Roma assistants” are currently examined.
Also, additional measures regarding learning aid provided by private Roma organisations should be
supported.55
According to an evaluation of learning aid provided by six Roma-associations and sponsored by the
city of Vienna, which was conducted in 2008, learning aid fosters the improvement of educational
attainment of Roma children and improves the involvement of their parents.56
No further information on factors influencing the educational attainment of Roma children (e.g. costs
of education, need to work, etc.) is available.57
51
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, pp. 16f.
52
Romano Centro, Learning aid and work with parents, available at: www.romanocentro.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3%3Alernhilfe&catid=12%3Aprojekte&Itemid=4
&lang=de.
53
Romano Centro, Roma assistants at Viennese schools, available at: http://www.romanocentro.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=4%3Aromaassistenten&catid=12%3Aprojekte&Itemid=4&lang=de.
54
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, pp. 13f.
55
Ibid., p. 11f.
56
qualitativer Studien in Vor- und Grundschulen, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, p.119.
57
official institutions and ministries); information requests have been sent to The Association of Roma Oberwart,
the Ketani Association, the Cultural Association of Austrian Roma, Romano Centro, Roma Service, the Adult
Education Centre of Burgenland-Roma; NGO Public Aid, Caritas Austria, the Federal Ministry of Education, Arts
and Culture, the department of statistics at the government in Burgenland; all information requests have been
answered. Telephonic interviews have been conducted with two experts (one employee of Romano Centro and
one employee of the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups).
15
d. Vocational training/qualifications
The “Thara-house”, a cooperation project between Roma and non-Roma organisations, is based in
Vienna and offers counselling for Roma aged 13 to 65 years old in the areas of education and
employment. For youths, who are between 13 and 24 years old, preparation courses for career entry
are offered. Furthermore, the project tries to foster dialogue in the areas of employment (to build
networks with Roma organisations), economy, politics and NGOs to gain contacts for Roma in the
labour market on a national and international level. The project is well known amongst Roma
communities.58
The project “THARA.AMAROTRAJO”, initiated by the NGO Public Aid (Volkshilfe), aims at
improving the occupational outlook for Roma. Counselling for Roma aged 13 to 40 years old in the
area of employment and social issues is offered. Furthermore, vocational and educational preparation
offers and assistance to find apprenticeship openings is provided as well as courses on the following
topics: computer skills, internet, job applications and language skills. All offers are free of charge.59
In 2007, the Initiative for Minorities (Initiative Minderheiten) organised a conference on equal
opportunities in the area of employment, education, social issues, law and politics. This conference
was sponsored by the Federal Ministry of Labour, Social Affairs and Consumer Protection
(Bundesministerium für Arbeit, Soziales und Konsumentenschutz, BMASK).60
e. Different types of schooling (home education, special schools, etc.)
Since the 1980s61, Roma children who have difficulties following classes in the regular schooling
system have often been transferred to special needs schools. A requirement for this transfer is the
assessment that the child has a disability. This practice is perceived as being problematic, because
attending special needs schools is associated with having a disability and is thus most likely
influencing the pupil’s further educational career in a negative way. 62 The situation improved during
the last years for autochthonous Roma, who are integrated in the regular school system. 63 Nonautochthonous Roma still attend special needs schools more often mostly due to their poor German
language skills and/or unfavourable learning environment. First steps to improve the situation of nonautochthonous Roma children can be seen in the introduction of alternative school models instead of
special need schools. In 2008, the Federal Ministry for Education, Arts and Culture
(Bundesministerium für Unterricht, Kunst und Kultur, BMUKK) provided guidelines aiming at
integrating Roma children with a foreign first language in the regular school system. If learning
difficulties occur, factors that cause these difficulties have to be identified in the first step. Qualified
personnel who speak the child’s native language have to be consulted. Poor language skills are no
58
59
NGO Public Aid (Volkshilfe), THARA AMAROTRAJO, available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/1217,,,2.html.
60
61
Ibid., p. 77.
62
qualitativer Studien in Vor- und Grundschulen, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 116f.
63
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, pp. 13f.; Austria, Federal Chancellery (2010), 3. Bericht der Republik
Österreich gemäß Artikel 25 Abs. 2 des Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, p. 77.
16
reason to transfer children to special needs schools and assistance to improve the language skills
should be provided.64
In Austria, no bilingual schools for Roma exist.65 In the school year 2005/2006, classes in children’s
first language have been offered in several schools: 253 primary schools, 144 secondary modern
schools (Hauptschulen), 30 special needs schools, five polytechnic schools and five grammar schools
(in Vienna). Amongst 17 languages, Romanes has also been offered. The number of compulsory
schools and secondary modern schools that offer classes in children’s first language has decreased in
Austria with the exception of Vienna during the last years (compulsory schools from 522 to 253,
secondary modern schools from 270 to 144).66 In the school year 2009/2010, 5 children learned
Romanes at schools in Burgenland.67
f.
Issues of segregation and integration
Learning aid programmes have been provided by Roma organisations for about 15 years and aim at
raising awareness of educational attainment amongst Roma and thus improving the social and
economic integration of Roma.68
No schools in segregated areas, classes or special need schools predominantly attended by Roma
children exist in Austria. Roma children are mostly attending regular schools (Regelschulen).69 (For
information concerning the question of whether or not Roma children are directly or indirectly
excluded and positioned in special needs schools, see section c, e and g.) In post-secondary education,
Roma have the same rights and obligations as any other student.70
ZARA launched its workshop on discrimination, equal treatment and civil courage on 8 May 2012 in
twelve schools in Vienna. Although the workshop does not explicitly focus on Roma, one can assume
that it contributes to an improvement of the situation of Roma as well because it sensitises pupils with
regard to other cultures and diversity and aims at reducing prejudices. In 2011, 15 workshops have
been offered and 239 pupils participated.71
g. Experiences and perceptions of discrimination
Citizenship or migratory background does not have any influence on the access to public schools in
Austria. According to §4 (1) of the School Organisation Act (Schulorganisationsgesetz, SchOG)
64
65
Luciak, M. and Binder, S. (2010), Informationen und Anregungen zur Umsetzung des Unterrichtsprinzips
“Interkulturelles Lernen” – Ein Handbuch für den Bereich allgemeinbildende Pflichtschulen und
allgemeinbildende höhere Schulen Wien, pp. 6f.
66
Ibid., p. 21.
67
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, pp. 92f.
68
69
70
Austria, Federal Chancellery (2011 Austria, Federal Chancellery (2011), EU-Rahmen für nationale Strategien
zur Integration der Roma bis 2020. Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p. 16.
71
ZARA, Zara macht Schule, available at: www.zara.or.at/index.php/projekte/aktuelles/zara-macht-schule.
17
public schools are accessible for all persons regardless of their place of birth, gender, “race”, status,
class, language or religious denomination. For private schools, a selection of pupils according to the
fulfilment of certain criteria, e.g. language, is foreseen in §4 (3) School Organisation Act.72 In practice
it can be observed that children with migratory background are often transferred to special needs
schools (see also section e). In 2011 the system of special needs schools has been strongly criticised by
the UN Human Rights Council. Pupils with migratory background are highly concentrated in special
needs schools (27.8%). Persons with a foreign background (including students from other EU-states
coming to Austria to pursue their academic studies) are represented above average at universities or
technical colleges (34.9%). No statistical information on the share of Roma in the group of pupils or
students with migratory background is available.73
The educational system in Austria is perceived as being highly selective because pupils are transferred
to different school types after having completed primary school at the age of ten.74 However, some
attempts to change this early selection are made by introducing an integrated school system for 10 to
14 year old pupils (pilot project “New Grammar School”).75
Discrimination of Roma is perceived as playing a major role in the educational system. 76 One case of
discrimination in the area of education has been reported in the journal of the association Memorial
Service (Gedenkdienst). A Roma-child has been insulted and beaten on the head by a classmate. The
parents called attention upon this case; the Federal Ministry for Education, Arts and Culture and the
school inspector of the federal state investigated the case. Attending on the commission, the teacher
said that she/he did not see anything and the parents did not want to file a complaint at a court.77
Major projects or initiatives
In general, the Roma culture and language are not part of teachers’ trainings.78 It is planned to extend
and improve classes in languages of officially acknowledged ethnic groups (anerkannte
Volksgruppen) present in Austria. One example is the project “QualiRom”, which was initiated in
2009 and is being carried out by Venue of languages (Treffpunkt Sprachen) at the University of Graz
and Romano Centro. Dealing with learning material for Roma and knowing about the European
Language Portfolio should be part of the training of teachers, who speak Romanes as their first
language.79
72
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p.13.
73
ENARA (2012), ENAR SHADOW REPORT. Racism and Related Discriminatory Practices in Austria, p. 16
74
Ibid, p. 16; Luciak, M. (2011), Roma mit Migrationshintergrund an österreichischen Volksschulen, in: Diehm,
75
ENARA (2012), ENAR SHADOW REPORT. Racism and Related Discriminatory Practices in Austria, p. 16
76
p. 359.
77
Memorial Service (n.n.), (n.n.), available at: http://www.gedenkdienst.at/
78
79
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, p.14.
18
The Private Teacher Training College Foundation Burgenland (Private Pädagogische Hochschule
(PH) Stiftung Burgenland) implemented an obligatory class on Multilingualism and Intercultural
Education for teachers at compulsory schools and special needs schools. The class aims at fostering
teachers skills in everyday communication; they can choose Romanes amongst other languages.80
In general, not many school books or further learning material providing information on the history,
culture and language of Roma are available. Since 2004, the project “Rombase” has provided material
for teachers and Roma mediators. Furthermore, the Council of Europe provides material concerning
the history, culture and language of Roma.81 Learning material in the language of officially
acknowledged ethnic groups is constantly being updated and extended. However, the preparation of
these materials is perceived as being a challenge because school books which are used in other
countries cannot be easily adapted for Austria; thus, a cooperation with experts, e.g. the department for
linguistics of the University of Graz and Roma organisations, is necessary. The “Education Server
Burgenland” (Bildungsserver Burgenland) provides learning material in languages of ethnic groups
(Volksgruppen) which are located in Burgenland. The Croatian journal for children “moj novi mini
multi” is translated in the language of Burgenland Roma and can also be used for school classes and
other classes for Roma. The association “Exile” organises events and workshops with school classes to
inform pupils about Roma and their culture.82
80
Ibid., p.74.
82
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, pp. 72-74.
81
19
3
Employment
a. Paid employment
In the Council of the European Union’ conclusions from 19 May 2011, Member States were requested
to facilitate access to employment and particularly a non-discriminatory access to the labour market as
well as to turn attention towards an active labour market policy, labour market programmes, adult
education, vocational training and support of self-employed persons. Relating to this Austria would
pay specific attention to the ability of different actions to improve the social and economic situation of
the Roma.83
Due to the current legal situation, and furthermore the norms of the Data Protection Act 2000
(Datenschutzgesetz 2000, DSG 2000) it is not allowed to label ethnic origin within the data of the
Labour Market Service (Arbeitsmarktservice, AMS). Therefore no statement can be made on how
many Roma have participated in actions related to professional qualification, employment and support
financed by the AMS.84
There is no general data on the integration of Roma in the labour market available. Nonetheless
sample data can be extracted from specific projects or actions.85
For example 90 telephone interviews were conducted by Riesenfelder et al. for the Chamber of Labour
(Arbeiterkammer, AK) with Roma (36 male and 54 female) in 2011.86 83% of the interviewed Roma
were employed (unselbständig Beschäftigte)87 and 13 % of them held more than one job. Especially
women were affected by this phenomenon as every fifth Roma woman interviewed held more than one
job.88 The interviewed Roma were primarily employed (90% of the interviewees) in the services sector
(Dienstleistungssektor).89 This high percentage could be explained by the fact that also men from the
Roma community were employed mainly (83%) in the sector of services.90 Roughly one third of Roma
interviewees were employed in the areas of retail (Handel) and accommodation/gastronomy. Only
11% of the Roma were employed in constructions (Bau) and only 6% in the area of producing goods
83
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p. 20.; see also:
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//TEXT+TA+P6-TA-20080035+0+DOC+XML+V0//DE.
84
85
Telephone interview with Usnija Buligovic, project coordinator of THARA projects, Volkshilfe, on 17 August
2012.
86
Riesenfelder, A. et. al. (2011), Beschäftigungssituation von Personen mit Migrationshintergrund in Wien –
Endbericht, Study commissioned by the Chamber of Labour, available at:
www.arbeiterkammer.at/bilder/d164/Studie_MigrantInnen_2012.pdf.
87
www.arbeiterkammer.at/bilder/d164/Studie_MigrantInnen_2012.pdf, p. 271.
88
Ibid.
89
Ibid., p.272.
90
Ibid., p.272.
20
which is very low compared to other groups of ethnic minorities (29%, resp. 12%). 19% of the Roma
were employed in the sector of traffic/transport and storage (Lagerei).91
The interviewed Roma women were mainly (50%) employed in the sectors of
accommodation/gastronomy (often as subsidiaries in the kitchen), retail (as shop assistants) and other
services. Especially occupations in the areas of tourism, gastronomy and cleaning have high
significance.92
80% of the interviewed Roma worked in small companies (with a maximum of 50 employees).93
Especially Roma women (53% resp. 28% of Roma interviewed) were employed in small companies
(with a maximum of ten employees).94 77% of the interviewed Roma worked as unskilled or semiskilled (angelernt) workers, compared to 60% of migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority. 95
14% of the interviewed Roma were only marginally employed (geringfügig beschäftigt), compared to
only 4% of migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority, which could probably be connected with the
relative high percentage of persons below 24 years of age (19% Roma compared to 15% of migrants
not belonging to an ethnic minority) who were marginally employed in addition to a vocational
training course or studying.96
The duration of employment at the last working place amounts to an average of 3.83 years for the
Roma interviewed, compared to 4.74 years concerning migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority. 97
41% Roma worked part time, compared to 26% of migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority.98
60% of the interviewed Roma worked on weekends and holidays on a regular basis compared to 42%
of migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority.99 61% Roma worked overtime (55% migrants not
belonging to an ethnic minority), and 14% of them did not get paid for it.100
Regarding the employment situation of Roma in the Oberwart district, a survey was conducted in 2004
in the framework of the EQUAL integration project “Mri Buti”. The interviews were conducted by a
member of the Roma Community.101 According to this study, Roma women worked in
simple/unskilled job positions in textile, clothing, leather and electronic industries. Male Roma mainly
91
Ibid., p.272; see also: Fink, M. (2011), Austria. Promoting Social Inclusion of Roma. A Study of National
Policies. Report to the European Commission via Network of Independent Experts in Social Inclusion, p. 21
92
www.arbeiterkammer.at/bilder/d164/Studie_MigrantInnen_2012.pdf, p. 272; see also. Fink, M. (2011),
Austria. Promoting Social Inclusion of Roma. A Study of National Policies. Report to the European Commission
via Network of Independent Experts in Social Inclusion, p. 21.
93
94
Ibid., p. 274.
95
Ibid., p. 277; see also: Fink, M. (2011), Austria. Promoting Social Inclusion of Roma. A Study of National
Policies. Report to the European Commission via Network of Independent Experts in Social Inclusion, p. 21.
96
97
Ibid., p. 278.
98
Ibid, p. 279.
99
Ibid, p. 280.
100
Ibid., p. 282.
101
Biffl, G. et. al. (2005), Verschärfung der Arbeitsmarktprobleme von Randgruppen in Grenzregionen im
Gefolge der Ostöffnung – Das Beispiel der Roma in Oberwart, FN 8.
21
worked in the metal industry and in the area of constructions. The interviewed Roma mainly worked
in large companies and indicated that they suffered less personal discrimination in larger companies
compared to smaller ones.102
Through the dislocation of simple manufacturing activities into the East since the 1990s, the access for
Roma to the labour market has declined.
b. Self-employment
Within special groups of Roma, like the Lovara and the Sinti, self-employment, especially different
trading activities, still appears to be an important source of income. Women often trade textiles,
whereas men are increasingly engaged in trading used cars. Furthermore, it appears that “new”
professions within self-employment gain increased importance, e.g. in the area of web design and
graphics.103
Very little is known about the living conditions of Roma with a migration background engaged in selfemployment, who probably constitute a large group.104
As a service for work seekers, employees and companies, special yellow pages with a list of Roma
employers is currently developed in framework of a “THARA” project.105
c. Communal work and other forms of payment schemes
Non-standard forms of employment like marginal part-time employment, so-called freelance contracts
(freie Dienstverträge), and temporary agency work appear to play a rather important role for Roma,
compared to other groups of the population.106
According to the study conducted by Riesenfelder et. al., the proportion of Roma working in the field
of labour leasing is relatively high: 9% of the interviewed persons compared to 2% of migrants not
belonging to an ethnic minority. Men are more concerned than women: 18% of Roma are leased
labourers.107
d. Unemployment
As there was no national strategy on Roma inclusion for a long time, Roma often did and still do not
manage to enter the labour market successfully. As a result, they are a minority group that is,
102
Gefolge der Ostöffnung – Das Beispiel der Roma in Oberwart, p. 125.
103
Fink, M. (2011), Austria. Promoting Social Inclusion of Roma. A Study of National Policies. Report to the
European Commission via Network of Independent Experts in Social Inclusion, p. 20.
104
Ibid., p. 21.
105
Regarding THARA-projects see Projects/Initiatives and: www.thara-biznis.at/.
106
107
22
especially due to language barriers, excluded from the official services for the unemployed. To earn a
living, Roma have to find other ways of self-subsistence.108
According to the study conducted by Riesenfelder et. al., 13% Roma were unemployed. Men are more
concerned than women: every fifth man was unemployed at the time of the study. Probably not only
unemployment but especially long-time unemployment is a specific problem in this group.109
In the Oberwart district a high percentage of long-time unemployment of Roma was found110: the
labour force participation rate (Erwerbsquote) for persons between 15 and 64 years old amounted to
63.9% in 2004, that was a little below the Austrian average of 69%. The rate of employment
(Beschäftigungsquote) amounted to 20.8% and therefore lay clearly under the Austrian average of
65%. Also the rate of unemployment (Arbeitslosenquote) of 67.4% was much higher than the Austrian
average (11%). The rate of unemployment of Roma women is a little lower than that of Roma men
(63.2% compared to 70.4%).111
More detailed data and information regarding Burgenland Roma outside the area of Oberwart is not
available, but it appears that many of those who left Burgenland towards the greater Vienna area are
nowadays showing a labour market attachment comparable to the one of the majority population.112
Also some assessments from inside the Roma community seem to be credible in stating that young
Roma do not present a higher percentage of unemployment compared to that of non-Roma.113
A variety of factors is responsible for the high rate of unemployment of Roma or the high rate of
employment of Roma only in low wages sectors: low school education, migration status and poor
health are the most important factors to be mentioned. 114 Other factors are the reduction of need for
unskilled or semi-skilled workers, replacement of Roma through foreign workers as well as societal
stigmatisation of Roma.115 In a broader sense other factors come along like lacking assistance in child
care or a lack of mobility.116
Low school education:
108
ENARA (2012), ENAR SHADOW REPORT. Racism and Related Discriminatory Practices in Austria, p. 36.
110
111
Ibid., p. 126.
112
113
114
Gefolge der Ostöffnung – Das Beispiel der Roma in Oberwart,, p. 125.
115
Ibid., p. 126.
116
p. 358f.
109
23
The disadvantages Roma face in the labour market correlate with their low school education. Low
interest in education and poor employment chances start a vicious circle which can hardly be
broken.117
According to the study of Riesenfelder et. al. Roma show a significant low level of education. 52% of
the interviewed Roma have enjoyed only compulsory education at a maximum, 19% have a
university-entrance diploma (Matura) and only 4% have finished university, compared to 24% persons
not belonging to an ethnic minority who have only enjoyed a compulsory education, 24% with an
university-entrance diploma and 15% who finished university. Thus, the interviewed Roma show a
significant substandard level of formal education.118 Andrea Härle estimates that the rate of illiteracy
among Roma women is higher than that of Roma men.119
Other estimations say that 90% of the Roma only hold a Certificate of Secondary Education
(Hauptschulabschluss). Further education or vocational training is rare, especially in rural areas. A lot
of young Roma women drop out of school to marry. Marrying and getting children at an early age
affects Roma women as well as Roma men, but Roma women are affected by this in their attempt to
access the labour market in a different way than Roma men.120 Yet, it can be noted that parents tend to
send their children to higher schools more often than in the past.121
In Oberwart 28.8% of the surveyed Roma over 15 years old do not finish compulsory education
(Pflichtschule), 59.1% hold a Certificate of Secondary Education, 3% have finished a vocational
training, 4.6% hold a Certificate of a vocational school (berufsbildende mittlere Schule) and 4,5%
have finished higher education. Roma men tend to undergo vocational training while Roma women
tend to go to secondary schools.122 Under senior/older Roma the lack of education is still much higher:
37.5% have only finished a special school (Sonderschule) while 50% hold a Certificate of Compulsory
School (Pflichtschulabschluss).123
A survey from 2008 showed that about 40% of persons between 25 and 64 years old with low
qualifications do not participate in the labour market. It can be assumed that the percentage of Roma in
this group is relatively high.124
Migration:
The fact that Roma are also often migrants correlates with low education levels and leads to
unemployment or employment in low wages sectors. 125
117
118
119
Telephone interview with Andrea Härle, Verein Romano Centro, on 27th August 2012.
120
121
Aurora (2010) MigrantInnen und Armut, available at:
www.bawo.at/fileadmin/user_upload/public/Dokumente/Projekte/AURORA/AURORAplus/AuroraPlus_Bericht
_MigrantInnen.pdf.
122
123
Ibid.
124
Bock-Schappelwein, J./Falk, M. (2009), Die Bedeutung von Bildung im Spannungsfeld zwischen Staat, Markt
und Gesellschaft, p. 9.
24
The family reunification policies (Familienzusammenführung) disadvantage women because of their
residence permit status (Aufenthaltsstatus), as mostly it depends on the status of their husbands.126
Another problem is the lack of information regarding the nostrification of qualifications which Roma
achieved in their countries of origin. 20% of the interviewed Roma in the frame of the study of
Riesenfelder et al. did not know about this possibility. 127
Poor health:
Especially older Roma suffer from a weak health status. Overweight and abuse of nicotine are most
common problems (see Chapter HEALTH)128. But also mental-health problems are widely spread. 129
Begging:
Begging can be a way of living for people to ensure their survival, especially for women who are
unemployed or have dropped out of their work places in times of economic crises. Most of the begging
Roma in different Austrian cities come from Romania, Slovakia or Bulgaria. They do not want to stay
in Austria on a permanent basis but come for several days or weeks. Begging is not connected with
any capital expenditure except the travel costs to Austria (which could be very high for them).
Begging does not lead to any deletion of social transfers in the countries of origin.130
e. Child labour
No data or information is available regarding Roma child labour in Austria. 131 Child labour is
prohibited in Austria. Child labour plays a role in some family enterprises and in farming but is not
ethnicised. 132
f.
Old age pension
No data or information is available regarding old age pension of Roma.133
g. Experiences and perceptions of discrimination
According to the survey in the Oberwart district, the interviewed Roma faced many experiences of
discrimination in small companies.134
125
126
127
128
129
Interview with a former project assistant in the Mri Buti project, Oberwart; see: Gneisz, E. (2010),
Arbeitsmarktpolitische Projekte für Romnja und Roma in Österreich, Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna,
p. 94.
130
Thuswald, M. (2008), Betteln als Beruf? Wissensaneignung und Kompetenzerwerb von Bettlerinnen in Wien,
Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna.
131
Email from Gilda Horvath, Verein Lovara, on 31 August 2012.
132
Telephone interview with Andrea Härle on 27 August 2012.
133
Email from Gilda Horvath, Verein Lovara, on 27 August 2012.
25
Also waiting for an asylum decision for years, which is connected with restricted working
permissions, could be defined as a form of discrimination. In the Weinviertel some of the 14
interviewed Bosnian Roma are still waiting for this decision for over ten years.135
Begging Roma are often characterised by using problematic terms, and divided in two subgroups:
criminal – mostly male – mafia bosses who exploit the other group – mainly women, children and
persons with disabilities. This leads to a criminalisation of all begging Roma, racist or anti-ziganistic
statements against them as well as to massive acts of displacement.136
Prohibition of begging:
Begging is prohibited in Austrian provinces (Bundesländer) with the exception of Burgenland. This
particularly affects Roma negatively as Roma from East-European countries form the majority of
beggars in Austria.137 In 2011 the province of Styria, for example, installed a prohibition of begging
through the §3a amendment of the Styrian Security Act (Landessicherheitsgesetz). Therefore begging
is prohibited in public places and is punished with an administrative fine (Verwaltungsstrafe) of up to
€2.000. The communities can name zones of exception (Ausnahmezonen) where begging is allowed.138
Some cities like the Styrian capital Graz have not named any zones of exception so far. In other
provinces begging could lead to administrative fines of up to €1.000 (Niederösterreich)139, €720
(Oberösterreich)140, €700 (Kärnten141, Wien142), €500 (Salzburg)143, €400 (Vorarlberg)144 or €360
134
135
p.357.
136
Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna; ENARA (2010), ENAR Shadow Report 2009/2010: Racism and
Discrimination in Austria, p. 15.
137
ENAR (2010), ENAR Shadow Report 2009/2010: Racism and Discrimination in Austria; Thuswald, M. (2008),
Betteln als Beruf? Wissensaneignung und Kompetenzerwerb von Bettlerinnen in Wien, Diploma Thesis at the
University of Vienna, p. 87; available at
http://www.bawo.at/fileadmin/user_upload/public/Dokumente/News/b_wie_betteln_Bettelverbote_in_OEste
rreich_HSchoibl.pdf
138
Styria, Gesetz vom 18. Jänner 2005, mit dem ein Steiermärkisches Landes Sicherheitsgesetz erlassen wird
(StLSG), LGBl. Nr. 24/2005 last modified by LGBl. Nr. 37/2011, §3a Abs. 2.
139
Austria, Niederösterreichisches Polizeistrafgesetz, LGBl 135/75 last amended by LBGl. 107/2012, available
at: www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokumente/LrNo/LRNI_2012107/LRNI_2012107.html.
140
Austria, Oberösterreichisches Polizeistrafgesetz. LGBl. 36/1979 last amended by LGBl. Nr. 36/2011, available
at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=LrOO&Dokumentnummer=LOO40011184&ResultFunctionToken=d
fc0a4ba-24c5-4626-9e09f156e7e1f183&Position=1&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=&Gesetzesnummer=&VonArtikel=&BisArtikel
=&VonParagraf=&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsda
tum=&FassungVom=08.10.2012&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPage
Size=100&Suchworte=bettelei.
141
Austria, §27 Kärntner Landessicherheitsgesetz, LGBl. 74/1977, last amended by LGBl. 44/2011, available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=LrK&Dokumentnummer=LKT40006499&ResultFunctionToken=81b
26
(Tirol)145. The Austrian Constitutional Court (Verfassungsgerichtshof, VfGH) is currently judging on
the constitutionality of these regulations.146 The judgments of the VfGH regarding the prohibition of
begging in Carinthia, Salzburg and Upper Austria were issued in June 2012: prohibitions of begging
without any exception are unconstitutional. They constitute a violation of the Freedom of Expression
(Art. 10 ECHR).147 The decisions regarding the prohibition of begging in Graz and Vienna will be
expected in autumn.
Roma are, for example, employed by local authorities in Vienna or Oberwart, Burgenland. At least
one Roma is employed in the department for integration and diversity in Vienna (Magistratsabteilung
17 - Integration und Diversität).148
In 2009 an advisory board for migration and integration (Migrations- und Integrationsbeirat, MIB)
was set up in the city of Linz. One person from the Roma community was elected as member to bring
in Roma concerns regarding questions of integration and diversity and to balance possible
marginalisation.149
136d2-1e65-402f-9e8b8742568c9fa2&Position=1&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=landessicherheitsgesetz&Gesetzesnummer=
&VonArtikel=&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnum
mer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=08.10.2012&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSe
it=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=.
142
Austria, §2 Wiener Landessicherheitsgesetz, LGBl. 51/1993, last amended by LGBl. 25/2010, available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokumente/LrW/LRWI_I110_000/LRWI_I110_000.pdf
143
Austria, §29 Salzburger Landessicherheitsgesetz, LGBl 57/2009 last amended by LBGl. 66/2012, available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=LrSbg&Gesetzesnummer=20000632.
144
Austria, Gesetz zur Regelung öffentlicher Sammlungen, LGBl. 48/1969 last amended by LGBl. 58/2001,
available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=LrVbg&Dokumentnummer=LRVB_2200_000_20020101_99999999
&ResultFunctionToken=64f81f5a-ec1a-41a5-a0bc4900fc5f7c42&Position=1&Titel=&Lgblnummer=&Typ=&Index=&FassungVom=08.10.2012&ImRisSeit=Undefine
d&ResultPageSize=50&Suchworte=sammlung.
145
Austria, Tirol Landespolizeigesetz, LGBl. 60/1976 last amended by LGBl. Nr. 94/2012, available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=LrT&Gesetzesnummer=20000176.
146
Der Standard (2011), ‚Das Bettelverbot wurde in fünf Bundesländern angefochten‘, 14 December 2011.
Constitutional Court case numbers G 132/11, G 155/10 and G 118/11 of 30 June 2012.
148
149
Ibid., p. 30.
147
27
New employment possibilities were found for former begging persons: they sell the magazines
MEGAPHON or global player. In Graz, four Roma work in the pilot project “Sauberes Uni-Viertel”
of the cleaning company Saubermacher as fully employed workers. 150
According to information from the Ministry of Labour, Social Affairs and Consumer Protection
(Bundesministerium für Arbeit, Soziales und Konsumentenschutz, BMASK) the actions of the Labour
Market Service do not provide for any special projects for ethnic minorities or groups of migrants.
People with specific problems regarding their access to the labour market will be supported primarily
and sustainably.151 Some of the listed projects for Roma were financed through the (then) Ministry of
Economy and Labour and the BMASK.152
The project “Mri Buti” (2003-2004) in Oberwart, conducted by Caritas and financed through the
European Social Fund and the (then) Ministry of Economy and Labour, was developed as part of the
bigger EU co-financed project “EQUAL/IdA” (Integration through employment). The EQUAL
programme (2000-2006) was part of the EU strategy to create more and better work places.153 The
project “Mri Buti” had three modules concerning employment, qualification and networking.154 It was
implemented between 2005 and 2008 and 86 Roma participated. The objective of this project was
empowerment through actions of education and employment for the labour market. Around 30% of
the participants were integrated in the first labour market, i.e. the labour market without state benefits
compared to the subsidised second labour market.155
Since 2005 the “THARA” projects (Caritas) have conducted a series of actions for the integration of
Roma in the labour market.156 The projects include vocational counselling, counselling on education,
intercultural coaching and training regarding the labour market. All Roma regardless of gender, origin,
language, belonging to an association, etc. can participate in the THARA projects.157
“THARA house” (Haus) was an initiative in the framework of the EQUAL programme in the fifth
district of Vienna which supported youth Roma regarding their access to education, social and cultural
needs and the labour market.158 325 Roma participated in this project.
The project “THARA Amarotrajo” in Vienna ran from 2007-2008.159 It covered an information
centre with an integrated pilot action for Roma between 13 and 40 years old. The target groups were
unemployed persons, jobseekers as well as persons at risk of unemployment.160
150
Caritas (2011), Megaphon 10/2011; available at: http://saubermacher.at/web/at/archiv-1547-die-romaraeumen-auf.
151
Compare to this the conclusions of the Council of the European Union from 19th May 2011:
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//TEXT+TA+P6-TA-20080035+0+DOC+XML+V0//DE
152
Gneisz, E. (2010), Arbeitsmarktpolitische Projekte für Romnja und Roma in Österreich, Diploma Thesis at the
University of Vienna, p. 55.
153
Ibid., p. 57.
154
Ibid., p. 92.
155
See: ORF Burgenland (2007): http://bglv1.orf.at/stories/264450; see also APA (2005):
http://www.ots.at/presseaussendung/OTS_20050919_OTS0170/roma-beschaeftigungsprojekt-mri-buti-meinearbeit-gesichert.
156
Volkshilfe Österreich, THARA Projekte, available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/THARA.
157
Ibid.
158
Volkshilfe Österreich, Projekt THARA Hause, available at: www.volkshilfe.at/1194,,,2.html; see also: Austria,
Federal Chancellery (2010), p. 31; Gneisz, E. (2010), p. 72.
159
See: Volkshilfe Österreich, Endbericht THARA Amarotrajo (2009), available at:
http://www.volkshilfe.at/1217,,,2.html.
28
The project “THARA – Roma in Transition” ran from 2008 to2009 and had two modules:
Amarotrajo, an information centre regarding the labour market and Nevodrom; young Roma could
participate in an 18 week course to prepare for accessing the labour market.161
The project “THARA – counselling and dialogue” (Beratung und Dialog) was the continuation of
the prior THARA projects and ran from 2009 to 2011. 120 Roma participated in the action Amarotrajo
and 16 youth Roma participated in the action Nevodrom.162
The project “THARA – Romani Butji” ran from 2011 to 2012.163 It had 4 modules: sensitising (for
multipliers), empowerment, community work and public relation. The target groups of this project
were Roma who plan to establish their own business. One output of the project was the brochure
“Romnja/Roma in the labour market”.
The project “THARA – Novi Vidici” is the continuation of THARA – Romani Butji and runs from
2012 to 2013.164 Compared to its predecessor it covers the fifth module “counselling events” which
means workshops with a musical programme. The development of yellow pages with a list of Roma
employers is also part of the project.165
The information centre for Roma in Oberwart works in close connection with the local Labour Market
Service. It offers counselling and information regarding possibilities of employment as well as support
regarding and preparing job applications.166
The Vinzenz Community of Graz (Vinzenzgemeinschaft) organises some employment projects for
Roma. The main target groups of these projects are Roma from the Rimavská Sobota district in
Slovakia. In one of the projects Roma produce bike trailers. In another project, which is co-financed
by the Lions Club, four Roma women completed a vocational training as healthcare assistants at the
LKH Stolzalpe (Pflegehelferinnen).167
160
161
See: Volkshilfe Österreich, Endbericht THARA – Roma in Transition, available at:
www.volkshilfe.at/1235,,,2.html; see also: Gneisz, E. (2010), Arbeitsmarktpolitische Projekte für Romnja und
Roma in Österreich, Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna, p. 75.
162
Volkshilfe Österreich, Tätigkeitsbericht THARA – Beratung und Dialog (2010), p. 6.; available at:
www.volkshilfe.at/1224,,,2.html; see also:
www.bmask.gv.at/cms/site/index_presseaussendung.html?doc=CMS1277713867186.
163
See: Volkshilfe Österreich, Endbericht THARA Romani Butji (2012), available at:
www.volkshilfe.at/1430,,,2.html.
164
Volkshilfe Österreich, THARA – Novi Vidici, available at: www.volkshilfe.at/1462,,,2.html.
165
See: www.thara-biznis.at/.
166
Verein Roma Oberwart, Projekt Roma_Beratungsstelle, available at: www.vereinroma.at/html/projekte.htm; see also: Austria, Federal Chancellery (2011), EU-Rahmen für nationale Strategien
zur Integration der Roma bis 2020. Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p. 21; Austria, Federal Chancellery
(2010), 3. Bericht der Republik Österreich gemäß Artikel 25 Abs. 2 des Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz
nationaler Minderheiten, p. 31.
167
Caritas (2011), Megaphon 10/1011, available at: http://saubermacher.at/web/at/archiv-1547-die-romaraeumen-auf/; ORF Steiermark (2012), available at: http://steiermark.orf.at/news/stories/2523274/
29
4
Housing and Neighbourhood
a. Quality and affordability of housing
The primary settlements of Roma are located in the Austrian provinces Burgenland, Vienna and
Lower Austria. In Burgenland’s district Oberwart there is a rather visible settlement of autochthonous
Roma called “Am Anger”. After a bomb attack in the 1990s (see part f), the bad housing conditions in
this settlement came to public attention and subsequent attempts were made to renovate it. In spite of
that, a considerable amount of former residents moved away, mostly to public or social housing in
urban areas. Altogether the housing situation of Roma in Oberwart has improved since the 1990s
although the settlement “Am Anger” still seems to represent a marginalised settlement.168 Solely for
the rural areas in Burgenland, a limited access to public utilities is stated (that is also due to lacking
public transport) but not for those living in Vienna or other urban areas.169
Quantitative data on the housing conditions does not exist separately for Roma in Austria.170 Data of a
qualitative survey among autochthonous Roma living in the Weinviertel region in Lower Austria (14
interviewees aged between 19 and 68 participated in the survey) indicates that most of the households
are over-crowded; in many cases parents share a bedroom with their children, which is used as a living
room during the day. Furthermore, many dwellings are in poor condition: leaking roofs, living in
condemned houses without electricity or water or at least substandard living (without sanitary
installations inside). Most of the Roma who were interviewed for the survey state that they would
change their living conditions if they had enough money. Particularly they would carry out renovation
measures, buy new furniture, rent a larger dwelling or at least a dwelling for their own family. 171
According to an expert there are still small Roma settlements located in the south of Burgenland,
where no electricity or water supply is available in some houses, and therefore water wells still
exist.172
Concrete initiatives to improve the living conditions were carried out for the Roma-settlement in
Oberwart only. According to an expert these included the bituminisation of the road that leads to the
settlement, landscaping the environment of the settlement, rendering houses and completing
renovation measures of the roofs on small houses.173
168
169
Response to a telephonic request received from the Roma NGO “Romano Centro” on 27 August 2012 and
response to an information request received from the association of Roma Oberwart (Verein Roma Oberwart)
on 10 September 2012.
170
Response to an information request received from the Department of Statistics at the government in
Burgenland (Abteilung für Statistik der Burgenländischen Landesregierung) on 16 August 2012.
171
p. 355.
172
Response to an information request received from the association of Roma Oberwart (Verein Roma
Oberwart) on 10 September 2012.
173
Response to a telephonic request received from the Austrian Center of ethnic groups (Österreichisches
Volksgruppenzentrum) on 30 August 2012.
30
b. Access to social or private housing
In Vienna access to municipal housing was opened for people without Austrian citizenship in 2006.
Beside social needs, the only remaining requirement for municipal housing is having had the main
residence in Vienna for at least two years. Access to municipal housing or subsidies for house building
(Wohnbauförderung) is also not restricted to Austrian citizens in other provinces.174 However it is
unclear to which degree immigrants of Roma origin have been benefiting from these reforms. There
are no reports indicating that Roma would directly be discriminated against in accessing public
housing in Vienna.175
A project called “Equality in Housing” was co-funded by the European Commission and national
funders. It was collaborative work carried out by the Austrian NGOs Public Aid (Volkshilfe), the
litigation association of NGOs against discrimination (Klagsverband) and the Federal Association for
help for the homeless (Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft Wohnungslosenhilfe). The project is divided into
three parts: the first is a survey assessing the access to public and social housing of disadvantaged
groups, particularly migrants in Austria. The survey is divided into a legal part that examines the
European and Austrian legal regulations concerning the allocation of public/social housing with a
special interest regarding the implementation of the EU antidiscrimination directives. Furthermore the
possibilities of complaints were investigated. Building on the findings, recommendations addressing
legislative bodies were addressed. The social survey analyses the administrative practices in the
allocation of public/social housing, with a specific interest in discrimination and disadvantages
experienced by migrants in particular. The second part of the project consists of advanced training
measures and expert workshops to identify good practices for an anti-discriminatory allocation of
social housing. Finally the third part consists of policy counselling and public relations.176
Within the social survey, experts who are responsible for the allocation of public housing across
Austria were interviewed. In general they emphasise that the allocation proceedings are free from
discrimination and respectively exclusion of certain social groups. According to the experts’
perceptions, the allocation of public housing follows the public procurement regulations and therefore
focuses on the relevant social aspects (i.e. the housing and living situation of the applicants such as
income, urgency of housing supply, current living situation). Based on these indicators, a waiting list
is prepared and issues of citizenship or ethnic origin do not play a role in the process, at least not
officially. However, the interviewed NGO experts relativise this perception with reference to their
clients. According to them, discrimination indeed plays a role in practice. They criticise the lack of
transparency in the allocation of public housing, which entails the necessity of further counselling and
sometimes also the need for interventions for the purpose of their clients. According to the interviewed
NGO members, the allocation of public housing becomes even more complicated for those responsible
if questions of co-existence, integration and ethnic conflicts arise within the residential environment.177
174
Integration der Roma bis 2020. Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, pp. 26ff.
175
European Commission via Network of Independent Experts in Social Inclusion, pp. 21f.
176
See: www.volkshilfe.at/1351,,,2.html.
177
Schoibl, H. (2011), Equality in Housing, pp. 8ff.
31
Regarding the Roma settlement “Am Anger”, the mayor of the Oberwart district stated in an interview
that the municipality will not collect a rent for housing in the settlement. Until now, the inhabitants
have to pay for electricity and gas only.178
However, concerning access to governmental homeless institutions by virtue of the city law on social
welfare, persons who cannot prove more than five years of continuous residence in Austria and those
without access to the Austrian labour market are excluded from the system of social assistance and
therefore from access to homeless institutions. Although access to homeless institutions and social
welfare is independent from citizenship, many migrants and members of ethnic minorities (particularly
those of short-term residence) are confronted with various obstacles and complex regulations in this
regard.179 Yet, there is no data that explicitly deals with Roma.180
Regarding access to private housing there is evidence of discrimination. Furthermore, due to financial
constraints Roma are largely forced to renting low standard dwellings (see section f).
c. Location and access to public utilities and infrastructure
Commonly, most Roma with enduring residence in Austria are sedentary, travelling is a rare
phenomenon and only practised by a very limited number of Austrian Sinti families or by Roma from
other countries (e. g. France and Germany) who visit Austria on a temporary basis.181
Most of the Roma immigrants from the Balkans are residing in the greater Vienna area. The number of
Roma in general decreases when going from the eastern to the western side of Austria. The greatest
majority of the Burgenland Roma (which are mostly autochthonous Roma) resides in rural areas or in
small towns. The Austrian Federal Chancellery acknowledges economic disadvantages and
particularities due to the peripheral position of ethnic minorities in certain areas, particularly outside
the settlements in rural regions in the Provinces Burgenland and Carinthia. For these, the Austrian
government funds Roma NGOs to offer education and social meeting points.182 However, the Austrian
Federal Chancellery acknowledges that also members of the majority population live in these areas
and therefore are affected by disadvantages too.183
Predominantly Roma who do not declare themselves as being Roma have migrated from Burgenland
to eastern Austrian cities, in particular to Vienna. Today they are largely assimilated in the majority
population.184 Regarding Vienna, the Federal Chancellery does not suppose that there are separate
settlements in certain neighbourhoods, therefore having access to public utilities and infrastructure
should be given.185
178
Kaspar, R. (2009), Die Burgenland-Roma Die Situation der jüngsten österreichischen Volksgruppe 15 Jahre
nach ihrer Anerkennung, Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna, p. 74 and p. 99.
179
ENARA (2012), ENAR SHADOW REPORT. Racism and Related Discriminatory Practices in Austria,p. 14.
180
Response to an information request received from the Austrian Federal Ministry of Labor, Social Affairs and
Consumer Protection (Bundesministerium für Arbeit, Soziales und KonsumentInnenschutz, BMASK) on 30
August 2012.
181
182
183
Ibid., p. 28.
184
Halwachs, D.W. et al. (2004), Roma and Romani in Austria, p. 2.
185
32
Apart from the initiatives to improve the Roma settlement in Burgenland which are completed by now,
no other initiatives or projects are known. Such initiatives depend on the engagement of the respective
municipalities.186
d. Security of tenure (including forced evictions and expulsions)
There is no specific regulation of security of tenure targeting explicitly Roma in Austria.187
There is no data available concerning forced evictions affecting Roma. In 2011, 5.253 forced evictions
were executed by the district courts all over Austria.188 There is no information available whether
alternative accommodation has been provided, although there is no evidence that it has been offered or
organised.189
There is no separate data available for Roma, but EU-SILC data indicates that migrants (in particular
those at risk of poverty) live more often in private renting or social housing in large blocks of flats
than in owned homes. One explanation for this is the restricted access to subsidies for house building
(Wohnbauförderung) for migrants in Austria because the land acquisition permission
(Grunderwerbsgenehmigung) is necessary. For migrants, it is a burden to receive the land acquisition
permissions, therefore in practice they have to acquire Austrian citizenship in order to get access to
government funded home ownership.190
According to an expert there are no support schemes for buying a house or apartment explicitly
targeting Roma. However, Roma should also not be excluded from the general supporting schemes if
they meet the requirements for the entitlements.191
Rented accommodation entails monthly fix costs and for poor persons they are high. The definition of
costs for housing includes rent, overheads (Betriebskosten), electricity, home loan interests
(Hypothekarzinsbelastung), maintenance and repair. 34% of persons without Austrian citizenship
spend more than a quarter of their income for housing, among naturalised citizens it is 28%. Even if
the objective burden of housing expenses is the same, the subjective perception of the material burden
varies by education level as findings of the EU-SILC indicate that 18% of persons with compulsory
school perceive a financial burden due to housing expenses but only 6% of the academics do so.
Therefore, absolutely perceived, persons with a high income have more money available for
consummation even if the share of housing-related expenses is the same when compared to that of
persons belonging to marginalised groups.192
57% of the persons at risk of poverty stated that they live in over-crowded housing in urban areas. In
larger cities, 14% of the persons at risk of poverty but only 3% of the persons not at risk of poverty are
186
Response to a telephonic request received from the Roma NGO “Romano Centro” on 27 August 2012, a
response received from the Austrian Center of ethnic groups on 30 August 2012, a response received from
Roma-Association Lovara-Roma Austria (Lovara-Roma Österreich) on 31 August 2012 and a response received
from the association of Roma Oberwart (Verein Roma Oberwart) on 10 September 2012.
187
Response to a telephonic request received from the Austrian Center of ethnic groups on 30 August 2012.
188
See: www.bawo.at/de/content/wohnungslosigkeit/delogierung.html.
189
Schoibl, H. (2011), Equality in Housing, p. 7.
190
Ibid., pp. 45f.
191
Response to a telephonic request received from the Austrian Center of ethnic groups on 30 August 2012 and
response to an information request received from the association of Roma Oberwart on 10 September 2012.
192
Datler, G./Mahidi, M. (2009), Armutsgefährdung und Wohnsituation - Modul zur Wohnsituation in EU-SILC
2007, p. 462.
33
unable to heat their flat in an adequate way. Particularly in rural areas persons at risk of poverty are
disadvantaged in accessing the necessary facilities.193
e. Residential segregation
In Austria there are no segregated and marginalised Roma settlements to a similar extent to that of
other Central and Eastern European countries. However, many Austrian Roma live in disadvantaged
neighbourhoods and districts with a higher density of people with low income. Such areas show a
rather high variance of different social strata and ethnic backgrounds (including rather large shares of
people without a migration background). However, such areas are not considered real problem areas or
social ghettos.194
According to an interviewed expert, residential segregation of Roma still exists. Particularly in
Burgenland, there are so called Roma settlements located at the margins of other settlements. Mainly
because of compensatory damages due to the NS regime, several Roma settlements were terminated.
In general, Roma settlements are grown historically and not because of legal regulations, although
currently there are no noticeable tendencies enforcing or initiating such segregation.195
There is neither official nor unofficial data available, however as travelling Sinti and Roma are often
said to be rejected in normal campsites (see section f), therefore having “wild camping” as the only
option. “Wild camping” is accompanied by a lack of access to water or electricity and it often entails
problems with the neighbourhood and authorities.196 One such situation occurred in Salzburg when a
number of Roma caravans were parked for six days nearby a swimming bath in Flachgau. As it had
happened in the previous years, there were massive complaints coming from the neighbourhood with
regard to the dirt left behind. In order to avoid “wild camping” and the conflicts this entails, the NGO
Ketani suggested funding a halting site for Roma in Salzburg and offered mediation and counselling
service in case of further conflicts. However the local government of Salzburg is very reluctant in
funding a halting site for Roma in Salzburg.197
An expert stated that although there is no evidence of unregulated encampments in Austria, like for
instance in France, there are certain groups of travelling Roma families passing through Austria who
usually rest for some days nearby official camping sites. As a result, there are always tensions with the
neighbourhood, which call authorities for help in order to expel the Roma groups from the area.
Meanwhile Roma mediators are consulted to avoid problems with the neighbourhood.198
There are only two halting sites for travelling Roma in Austria; both are located in the Province Upper
Austria (Oberösterreich), one in Braunau (founded in 2001) and another one nearby Linz (founded in
2009). Apart from space, the halting sites offer water, electricity and waste disposal services, but they
are not cost-free.199 For a fee of € 10 per day and caravan, travelling Roma receive water, sanitary
installations, waste disposal and electricity. The halting site in Braunau offers space for 20 caravans
193
Ibid.
195
Response to a telephonic request received from the Austrian Center of ethnic groups on 30 August 2012 and
response to an information request received from the association of Roma Oberwart on 10 September 2012.
196
197
Der Standard (2011), ‚Ein Campingplatz für die Unerwünschten‘, 12 August 2011.
198
199
See: www.sinti-roma.at/lagerplatz.htm.
194
34
and the one in Linz for 25 caravans. Further halting sites are negotiated in the municipalities of
Innsbruck, Wels and St. Pölten.200
The NGO Ketani, which manages the two Austrian halting sites, also offers counselling services for
municipalities and provides support in case they plan funding halting sites for Roma travellers.
Furthermore, it volunteers for mediation and counselling in case of conflicts with travelling Roma
groups; several Austrian municipalities have already made use of this service.201
f.
Experiences and perceptions of racial/ethnic discrimination
In general, the housing situation of migrants in Austria has improved since the EU anti-discrimination
directives and the EU directive concerning the status of third country nationals who are long-term
residents (Directive 2003/109/EC) have been implemented in national law. The share of migrants and
third-country nationals within the social and municipal housing market increased. However, there are
still differences in housing supply between Austrian citizens and persons with a migratory background
as migrants tend to live in worse housing conditions and are confronted with higher expenses for
housing than Austrian citizens. Therefore it remains to assume that the access of migrants to public
housing is still restricted.202
Within the survey mentioned in section b) those responsible for the allocation of public housing were
asked for discrimination of migrants in access to housing.203 They name among others the following
reasons for discrimination or disadvantage of migrants:
Language barriers and lacking advice and counselling of migrant apartment seekers:
In private housing, migrants with entitlements to social welfare are more often offered dwellings in a
poor condition because the social welfare department pays rent allowance even for dwellings in need
of redevelopment.
Particularly in private housing the existence of racism plays a role as landlords refuse contracts with
foreigners (however, experts mainly assume persons with darker skin are more affected than Roma)
due to prejudices according to which foreigners would have many children, would be loud and/or
unable to pay for the dwelling on time.204
Particularly racial or ethnic discrimination are very difficult to prove because landlords very seldom
admit: “You will not get that dwelling because you are a Roma”. Instead they say: “Unfortunately the
dwelling has already been rented out.”205
An information request to the Austrian Equal Treatment Commission (Gleichbehandlungskommission,
GBK) shows that there was only one complaint that explicitly affected Roma in the field of housing
and it concerned a sign placed at the reception of a camping site saying: “No place for gypsies” (Kein
200
Der Standard (2011), ‚Ein Campingplatz für die Unerwünschten‘, 12 August 2011.
See: www.sinti-roma.at/lagerplatz.htm.
202
Schoibl, H. (2011), Equality in Housing, p. 23, available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/1351,,,2.html.
203
Ibid., p. 33.
201
204
205
Ibid.
35
Platz für Zigeuner). This sign was reported by the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment
(Gleichbehandlungsanwaltschaft, GBA) in August 2005.206
In 1995 there was a racist attack in the Roma settlement „Am Anger“ when an intentionally placed
pipe bomb killed four young Roma men. It was acknowledged as the worst attack against Roma since
the NS regime. However, at first the local authorities did not consider the possibility of an attack from
outside the Roma community and subsequently – after obtaining a legal approval – executed a search
warrant within the whole Roma settlement in Oberwart. After concluding this investigation without
any results, the Federal Ministry of the Interior (Bundesministerium für Inneres, BMI) considered the
possibility of a (politically motivated) attack. The way in which the police and the public authorities
proceeded clearly indicated a different treatment of Roma compared to the members of the majority
population.207 Particularly for the relatives of the victims, the suspicion and the search warrants were
an additional burden to the bereavement, as some of them felt relegated to the NS regime. Although
the self-esteem of the Roma was growing very slowly anyway, this treatment was a heavy setback.208
The initiative “help for the homeless” which is located at the department for social affairs of the
government of Upper Austria is planning measures explicitly targeting Roma in Upper Austria.209
In general, regarding the readiness of the Austrian government to provide measures to improve the
housing situation of the Roma, one has to state that the disadvantage of Roma in the field of housing
(which is assumed to be true for migrant Roma only, not for the autochthonous group) is traced back
to disadvantages in education. Therefore, the Austrian government prioritises affirmative action and
assistance measures in the field of education.210
206
Response to an information request received from the Austrian Equal Treatment Commission
(Gleichbehandlungskommission, GBK) on 13 August 2012.
207
nach ihrer Anerkennung, Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna, pp. 49f.
208
Polis (2010), Soziale Ausgrenzung Fokus: Roma in Österreich, p. 9.
209
Response to an information request received from the Caritas Linz on 4 September 2012.
210
36
5
Health
a. Health status/limitations in daily activities/disability
Leoni et al. conducted a survey among the Roma in Burgenland’s district Oberwart. Although the
authors focused on the employment situation, they also examined health problems of the Roma as an
indicator of social exclusion.211 Based on the fact that socio-economic factors are often correlated with
health indicators, they identified health problems related to health-affecting behaviour, particularly
overweight/obesity and smoking. Based on these data, it is estimated that the body-mass-index (BMI)
mean value for male Roma in Oberwart is 30.9 (comparing to an average male Viennese mean value
of 25.5 according to the Vienna health survey) and for Roma women 30.4 (Viennese women: 24.3).
Additionally the share of smokers among the Roma in Oberwart lies significantly above the national
average. While in Austria 30% of persons aged 16 and older are smokers, among the Roma this share
is 72.7%. Moreover, among the Austrian population, about 50% have been smoking at one stage in
life, while almost 90% of the interviewed Roma stated that they have been smoking at any point of
their life. Additionally, the frequency of smoking is rather high among Roma: 80% of smoking men
and 60% of smoking women reported to consume one pack (20 cigarettes) or more per day. The
authors also investigated correlations between smoking rates and BMI among the Roma population in
Oberwart. Thereby they identified an age-specific pattern: whereas younger Roma have a healthier
body weight, they also have the highest share of smokers (this concerns particularly the group of
Roma younger than 40). After the age of 40, obesity becomes an issue for a much larger share of the
Roma population, while the number of smokers declines in older cohorts.212 In general, health issues
for the Roma population become more intense with increasing age.213
According to the results of the study, almost 41% of the interviewed Roma in Oberwart suffer from a
chronic disease and more than three quarters go to the doctor frequently. Compared to that, the number
of Roma who pay regular visits to the dentist is low: slightly more than 30% (compared to 54.3%
Viennese men and 62.1% Viennese women who reported that they have seen the dentist at least five
times over the past 5 years according to the Viennese health report from 2001). However, the share of
Roma who regularly see the dentist is still low if Viennese data is controlled by socio-economic
indicators like education: 42.5% of Viennese men and 46.7% of Viennese women with compulsory
education state that they regularly see the dentist (among Viennese persons with higher education the
share is 57.2% for men and 68.9% for women).214
However, in general the authors noted that Roma in Austria are not an exception compared to other
marginalised social groups with similar characteristics, therefore health issues connected with
bodyweight are not a feature that is unique to Roma; instead, it is shared to different degrees with
other social groups as they can be associated with poverty, exclusion, low income and low
education.215 Although the authors did not provide an in-depth medical analysis, they concluded that
health is a very serious issue for the Roma community. The poor health status of the Roma can be
partly explained by their low educational level and their extremely precarious income situation.
211
Leoni, A. (2004), The Labour Market Development of Oberwart and the Socio-Economic Situation of the
Roma, pp. 48ff.
212
Ibid., pp. 50ff.
213
Ibid., p. 55.
214
Ibid., pp. 51ff.
215
Ibid., p. 49.
37
However, the unhealthy behaviour of the Roma, acute health problems and the subjectively perceived
health condition point out a malaise that goes beyond socio-economic factors and is assumed as the
expression of social exclusion.216
There is no ethnic data collection in Austria, and therefore there is no data available on mortality rates
specifically among Roma. However, data on causes of death in different regions of Austria indicate
that the highest Austrian mortality rates are found in the east and southeast of Austria, particularly in
the Burgenland district Oberwart where most of the autochthonous Roma population is resident. The
death rates in this district (and in the Lower Austrian district Tulln) are 14% above the national mean.
Oberwart, the district with the highest mortality in the 1998–2004 period, exhibits a mortality rate high
above the Austrian average, which is due diseases of the circulatory system (+18%) and to deaths from
other causes (+22%) . Concerning the risk factor obesity, research indicates the highest percentages of
overweight for men in Lower Austria and Burgenland and for women in Burgenland and Styria. In
Burgenland obesity concerns 14.4% of inhabitants while only 5.4% of inhabitants in Salzburg and 6.7
% in Tyrol. Accordingly in Burgenland, Vienna and in Lower Austria health-awareness actions are
undertaken most seldom, in Salzburg and Carinthia most frequently. This regional pattern of
behaviour also refers to individual health activities, like healthy diets, physical activity or taking
public or private advice concerning health and illness-prevention issues.217 However, also in this
regard, data is not separately collected for the group of Roma.
In 1998 the Austrian Federal Ministry of Health in cooperation with the Austrian Provinces and the
main association of the social insurance carriers (Hauptverband der Sozialversicherungsträger)
founded a so-called vaccination concept. It offers all children up to the age of 15 living in Austria a
cost-free access to initial immunisation and booster injections.218 However specific data concerning
the group of Roma does not exist.
According to an expert there is no data on infant mortality rates for Roma in Austria, 219 as, in general,
there is no official or non-official data collected separately for ethnic groups.220
The head of an ambulance offering low-threshold healthcare services also for medically uninsured
persons in the Province of Styria (Ambulatorium Caritas Marienambulanz) corroborate these findings.
In general, the uninsured young patients are rather healthy but the health status of older patients is
poor, particularly if they suffer from chronic illnesses (diabetes, hypertonic diseases). According to the
expert, one reason for that is the lack of access to continuous medical healthcare services due to
missing medical insurance and/or changes of residence. Furthermore, the dental health of the patients
is very poor (tooth spaces, caries), which is traced to a lack of prophylaxis and missing treatment
options. However, data is not collected for Roma separately.221
216
Ibid., p. 54.
Statistics Austria (2007), Österreichischer Todesursachenatlas 1998-2004, pp. 38ff.
218
Austria, Federal Ministry of Health (Bundesministerium für Gesundheit, BMG) (2012), Impfkonzept.
219
Information requests were sent to: Federal Ministry of Health, Statistics Austria (Statistik Austria), Federal
Chancellery, several Roma-NGOs.
220
Response to an information request received from Roma-Association Lovara-Roma Austria on 31 August
2012.
221
Response to an information request received from the outpatient department “Caritas Marienambulance”
(Ambulatorium Caritas Marienambulanz) on 4 September 2012.
217
38
b. Unmet needs in the area of health
According to an expert many of the unmet needs in the area of health are not explicitly due to ethnic
origin but due to the socio-economic status of Roma. Low or no education, a vulnerable position on
the labour market and bad housing conditions (e.g. living in condemned houses without electricity or
water; no separate rooms for family members; substandard living conditions) affect the health status of
Roma. Furthermore psychosomatic and mental illnesses are a problem among the Roma particularly
because these illnesses are tabooed within the communities. In general, there is reluctance to seek help
in case of health restrictions or afflictions.222
Various particular health issues affecting Roma are due to the socio-economic status. Most Roma have
been working for decades within the unqualified labour market (in assembly lines, construction, as
cleaners or cook maids). The bad working conditions in these fields affect the health status of the
Roma particularly in old age. Especially among female Roma, there are many reported psychosomatic
health issues due to excessive demands (in reconciling care work and paid employment) or fatigue.223
In the Holocaust, over 90% of Roma (about 600.000 persons) were killed due to their ethnic or social
origin in Austria. Therefore the survivors and their descendants are affected by late sequela. According
to an expert, the treatment of traumata resulting from the Holocaust is an unmet need in the area of
health explicitly affecting the Roma. Therefore more services in trauma therapy should be offered for
Roma Holocaust survivors and their descendants in the second generation.224
Particularly in the Austrian province Burgenland where many autochthonous Roma reside, the
accessibility of healthcare services is restricted due to large distances form health centres/hospitals and
a lack of public transport. In urban areas this is not a problem but there are other barriers in accessing
healthcare services, particularly a lack of information and mistrust in the Austrian medical system.
Many (particularly migrant) Roma do not know where to go in case of afflictions. Furthermore there
are language barriers and a lack of awareness particularly concerning mental and psychosomatic
illnesses (see above). Another barrier derives from illiteracy: patients usually have to fill in numerous
forms, which according to an expert discourages some Roma to see a doctor or visit a hospital even if
medical insurance exists.225
There is one major project explicitly targeting Roma and concerning the issue of Holocaust-related
traumata. In cooperation with the Jewish psycho-social centre ESRA (which is as a Jewish centre
experienced in services provided to NS victims and their descendants) the Roma association Ketani
(Verein Ketani) offers psychotherapy and psycho-social counselling services free of charge for Roma
NS survivors and their descendants in the second and third generation in Upper Austria and Vienna.
The aims of the therapy are to alleviate mental and physical suffering of the affected persons, to
reinforce social contacts, to provide support in crises concerning personal relationships, and
particularly to offer guidance in dealing with the burdening experiences.226
222
Response to a telephonic request received from the Viennese Roma-NGO “Romano Centro” on 27 August
2012.
223
2012.
224
Response to an information request received from the Roma-Association Lovara-Roma Austria (LovaraRoma Österreich) on 31 August 2012.
225
Response to a telephonic information request received from the Viennese Roma-NGO “Romano Centro” on
27 August 2012.
226
Verein Ketani, Hilfe für die Seele – Schrei einer Minderheit, available at: www.sinti-roma.at/projekte.htm.
39
c. Medical insurance coverage
According to the Austrian Federal Ministry of Health (Bundesministerium für Gesundheit, BMG),
there is no separate collection of data for ethnic groups concerning social insurance, especially since
there is neither a legal obligation nor a factual necessity to do so. Austrian citizenship is also not
relevant for the existence of an insurance contract. Therefore it can be assumed that neither the
Austrian social insurance carriers nor their umbrella organisation collect data particularly regarding
Roma.227
Neither in the law on social insurance nor in medical law, the Roma group is adjusted separately. If the
prerequisites for medical insurance prevail, access to medical care is basically equal. In Austria, the
prerequisites for medical insurance are paid employment with a monthly income above € 374.26 or coinsurance with a family member (under certain prerequisites, particularly caring obligations or
entitlement to maintenance) or entitlements to social welfare (main residence in Austria).
The government programme (Regierungsprogramm) for the period 2008–2013 puts an emphasis of
health policies on the guarantee of qualitative medical care for all persons in Austria irrespective of
income, age, ethnic origin, religion or gender. The programme encompasses an adaption of the range
of public health care services to the needs of patients that belong to marginalised groups (particularly
concerning dental medicine, psychotherapy and vaccination of children).228 One improvement
regarding medical insurance coverage was made in 2010/2011 through the introduction of the needsoriented guaranteed minimum resources benefit system (Bedarfsorientierte Mindestsicherung, BMS).
It replaces and harmonises the former social welfare income support (Sozialhilfe). The group of
entitled persons was harmonised, foreigners (e.g. refugees, EU/EEA citizens and their relatives and
persons who have resided in Austria for at least five years) are treated equally to Austrian citizens.
Concerning healthcare, it is important to mention that the needs-oriented guaranteed minimum
resources benefit system includes claimants without health insurance coverage into the legal medical
insurance.229 However, it is unclear to what degree Roma have been (or will be) benefiting from these
reforms.
According to a member of the NGO Romano-Centro230 there are specific groups among the Austrian
Roma who are at risk of being medically uninsured. These are (mainly male) young adults and
adolescents without (completed) education, respectively early school leavers. However, this specific
group is also a risk-group among other marginalised groups, therefore it can be assumed that it is not a
matter of ethnicity. Another risk-group for being medically uninsured consists of female migrants who
moved to Austria within the framework of family reunification. Concerning their medical insurance,
they are dependent on their husbands who might refuse to co-insure them. A third risk-group consists
of Roma migrants and asylum seekers (moving from other EU member states) who are at high risk of
being uninsured and therefore having no access to healthcare services.231 Roma migrants from
Bulgaria, Serbia or Romania are in a difficult position because if they do not have access to the labour
227
Response to an information request received from the Austrian Federal Ministry of Health
(Bundesministerium für Gesundheit, BMG) on 28 August 2012.
228
Integration der Roma bis 2020. Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, p. 23.
229
Ibid., pp. 24ff.
230
2012.
231
Response to a telephonic information request received from the Viennese Roma-NGO “Romano Centro” on
27 August 2012.
40
market (which is usually the case, particularly in the beginning of their residence in Austria), they
have no entitlements to allowances from social welfare and therefore to medical insurance.
According to the head of an ambulance that offers low-threshold healthcare services also for medically
uninsured persons in Styria, about 50% of their patients are not insured. The ambulance collects
information on the patient’s nationality but not on their ethnic origin. Although there is no separate
data concerning Roma; according to the ambulance’s head it can be estimated that among the group of
uninsured patients from Slovakia, Hungary or Romania there are many Roma.232 According to the
ambulance’s annual report, in 2011 there were altogether 1.756 patients and among them 767 were
uninsured. Among these 767 uninsured patients 353 patients had either a Romanian or a Slovakian
nationality.233
d. Circumstances around giving birth
According to an expert, female Roma tend to be less aware of the necessity of health care services and
the need of medical investigations in case of pregnancy and breastfeeding. Furthermore, there are only
a few maternity wards for women without medical insurance in Austria (e.g. four for the entire
Viennese area). This is particularly a problem for female migrants who move to Austria heavily
pregnant in the hope that they will get health care services when giving birth. In general, medical care
awareness is lacking among female Roma and additionally there is a lack of understanding and
information about treatment options particularly among Roma with a migratory background.234
According to the head of an ambulance that offers low-threshold healthcare services in the Province of
Styria, a problem among pregnant patients is syphilis and hepatitis B, which are diagnosed quite late,
namely during the mother-child-pass-check-ups (Mutter-Kind-Pass-Untersuchung). This set of
medical check-ups is provided for pregnant women, starting from pregnancy until the child’s age of
five. It is cost-free for insured women, and entitlements to childcare allowance are linked to the
participation in the mother-child-pass-check-ups.235
e. Experiences and perceptions of racial/ethnic discrimination
According to an expert, there is no evidence of direct or indirect discrimination regarding access to
and provision of health services affecting Roma. However, Roma may be indirectly disadvantaged due
to cultural reasons as if a Roma person is hospitalised, usually the whole family is concerned and visits
the patient. The medical staff and also the roommate patients are often challenged by these visits of
many family members and therefore may feel disturbed.236
There is no data available concerning segregation of Roma patients by health care providers.237
Interviewed experts stated that they were not aware of such evidence.238
232
233
Marienambulanz (2012), Jahresbericht 2011, p. 12.
234
2012.
235
236
Response to an information request received from the Roma-Association Lovara-Roma Austria on 31 August
2012.
237
Information requests were sent to: Federal Ministry of Health, Statistics Austria, Federal Chancellery, several
Roma-NGOs.
41
No significant projects or initiatives exist with regard to ensuring access to identity cards, birth
certificates, and other official documents through provision of adequate information to Roma
However, based on the Austrian Ethnic Groups Act (Volksgruppengesetz), on 5 March 1996 the
Constitutional Court ruled that all members of Austrian minorities are entitled to receive personal
documents (birth certificates, marriage certificates, death certificates) also in their mother tongue.
Prior to this verdict, local authorities acknowledged this entitlement only for the inhabitants of legally
recognised bilingual municipalities. Because a majority of children were born in hospitals outside the
bilingual area and consequently many people died in hospitals outside the bilingual area, members of
ethnic minorities received their personal documents in their mother tongue very seldom.239
There are no projects for training and employing Roma health mediators known in Austria.240
However, an interviewed expert assessed the importance of Roma health mediators as being high,
particularly in facilitating access to maternal healthcare for Roma women. However, until now, Roma
mediators have only been appointed in the field of education.241
The impartation of a fundamental attitude to honour the dignity and the fundamental rights of all
persons irrespective of nationality, ethnic origin, religion, skin colour, age, gender, mother tongue,
political affiliation or attitude and socio-economic status is an objective enshrined by the training rules
for health professionals enacted by provinces. All health professionals’ trainings encompass these
issues within the obligatory subject “professional ethics”. Furthermore, the training rules for health
professionals at a college level particularly integrate addressing cultural and religious needs, lifestyle
and value systems into their competence profile.242
The Project “PROMO” 243 (duration from September 2007 to August 2010) is co-funded by the EU
Commission’s Directorate General for Health and Consumer Affairs. Its aims are promoting mental
health and preventing mental illness among socially marginalised persons, consolidating the
knowledge in this field and identifying best practices. Among others, one target group are Roma
(travelling communities). Using the example of two Viennese districts, the Austrian project partner,
the Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Social Psychiatry from Vienna, investigates the efforts of social
238
Response to an information request received from Gilda Horvath, chairwomen of the Roma-Association
Lovara-Roma Austria on 31 August 2012.
239
Council of the Slovene Minority in Carinthia (Rat der Kärntner Slowenen) (2006), Zur Lage der Kärntner
Slowenen 2006 im Jahr der EU Präsidentschaft der Republik Österreich p. 12.
240
Information requests were sent out to: Federal Ministry of Health, Statistics Austria, Federal Chancellery,
several Roma-NGOs.
241
2012.
242
243
See: www.promostudy.org/.
42
and medical organisations regarding mental health promotion services for marginalised groups.
According to the project’s website PROMO has the following specific objectives:

To review policies and legislations related to promoting mental health and preventing mentalill health among socially marginalised individuals;

To develop tools to assess programmes and systems of services in the participating states that
aim at promoting mental health in the socially marginalised through describing services in
terms of their organisational characteristics, type of clients, components of care, and funding
arrangements, and how these services interconnect to form systems; the assessment will refer
to the distinction between the three levels of health care suggested by the WHO;

To define the best inter-sectoral practice to promote mental health and prevent mental-ill
health among the socially marginalised, identify barriers to implementing it, and suggest ways
to overcome the barriers;

To disseminate the findings, including guidelines on best practice, widely among all relevant
stakeholder groups; and

To formulate policy recommendations based on the best inter-sectoral practices identified.
In Vienna there is a pilot project called “I look out for myself” (Ich schaue auf mich), which offers
cost-free mammographic screening for all women aged between 50 and 69 years, living in the 15th,
16th, 17th districts (these are districts with a high density of people with low income and/or migrants).
Women receive a personal invitation per post to a mammographic screening at the participating
hospitals. Participation is voluntary, cost-free and independent from being medically insured and/or
having a referral. Invitations are sent in German, English, Turkish and Bosnian, and an information
folder about mammographic screening is attached to the invitation. The project is conducted in
cooperation with all Viennese medical insurance carriers. If a biopsy is necessary the Viennese breast
cancer centre of the Viennese Hanusch-Hospital or the oncologic centre of the Viennese Wilhelminen
hospital is available.245
The project “Mri Buti” (meaning „my work“) was funded by the European Social Fonds (ESF) within
the framework of the EQUAL-Programme and was implemented from May 2003 to 2007. Although it
focuses on the occupation and qualification of Roma in view of labour market integration, it also
offers health and nutrition counselling and activities for the target group. However, based on the fact
that many participants in this project were overweight, the project leader assumes that obesity is not
only a factor of restricted mobility and resilience, but also an obstacle to find paid employment.
Therefore the integration of nutrition counselling and motivation for exercise into the project “Mri
Buti” should improve the self-confidence of the participants and therefore reduce anxiety regarding
the labour market. The health programme was integrated within the qualification programme and was
offered twice a week. It included walking, gymnastics, dance and nutrition, apart from EDV and basic
education. The qualification programme was implemented from September 2005 to February 2008;
the objective was to achieve 70 participants; however, only 52 Roma took part. A project worker
associated this with a lack of stamina or endurance among the participants. Although the interest in
245
See: www.ich-schau-auf-mich.at (Viennese medical insurance in cooperation with the Viennese program for
women’s health, project: mammographic-screening „I look at myself”)245
See: www.ich-schau-auf-mich.at (Viennese medical insurance in cooperation with the Viennese program for
women’s health, project: mammographic-screening „I look at myself”)-
43
this programme was measured before the start and it was high, the willingness to take part in it was
low.246
246
University of Vienna, pp. 98f.
44
6
Poverty/Economic situation
a. Households at risk-of-poverty
No data is available on income poverty and deprivation of Roma in Austria. The respective situation is
likely to be very heterogeneous.247
According to the 2008 poverty report of Austria, the poverty endangering quote
(Armutsgefährdungsquote) of single mothers is situated at 27%, thus very high when compared to
the12.7% average in Austria.248 According to the study conducted by Riesenfelder et al. for the
Chamber of Labour (Arbeiterkammer, AK), 17% of the interviewed Roma women are single
mothers.249
b. Income/Expenditure
According to the study of Riesenfelder et al. for the Chamber of Labour, 15% of the interviewed
Roma working full-time earn €899 at a maximum, 60% earn between €900 and €1.399, 19% have an
income up to €1.899, 4% up to €2.399 and 2% have an income beyond €2.400. The income of the
interviewed Roma is much lower compared to that of migrants not belonging of an ethnic minority
which is 6% (earning maximum €899), 52% (earning between €900 and €1.399, 28% (earning up to to
€1.899), 9% (earning up to up to €2.399) and 5% (earning beyond €2.400).250
38 % of the interviewed Roma working part-time have an income of maximum €399, 41% earn
between €400 and €899 and 21% have an income up to €1.399. No interviewed Roma from this group
had an income above this amount. Once again, the income of the interviewed Roma is low compared
to that of migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority, which is 10%, 53% and 29% each. 5 % of
migrants not belonging to an ethnic minority working part-time have an income between €1.400 and
€1.899 and 2% have an income up to €2.399.251
c. Financial situation/social transfers/debts/borrowing
According to the estimation of experts, the financial situation of Roma in Austria is better compared to
that of Roma in East-European countries but it is not satisfying.252 In the Oberwart district where the
long odds of being unemployed lead to a precarious income status, most of the surveyed families live
in difficult financial situations.253 Due to a combination of poverty, racism and exclusion regarding
247
European Commission via Network of Independent Experts in Social Inclusion, p. 17; see also email from Gilda
Horvath, Verein Lovara, from 31th August 2012.
248
Österreichische Gesellschaft für Politikberatung und Politikentwicklung (OGPP) (2008), 2. Armuts- und
Reichtumsbericht für Österreich, p. 125.
249
250
Ibid., p. 289.
251
Ibid., p. 289.
252
Aurora (2010) MigrantInnen und Armut, available at:
www.bawo.at/fileadmin/user_upload/public/Dokumente/Projekte/AURORA/AURORAplus/AuroraPlus_Bericht
_MigrantInnen.pdf.
253
Gefolge der Ostöffnung – Das Beispiel der Roma in Oberwart, p. 126;: Kaspar, R. (2009), Die Burgenland-Roma
45
economy and society, a high percentage of Roma depends on social transfers to save their survival.254
Many surveyed Roma from the Oberwart district live on benefits, mostly on help provided in state of
emergency (Notstandshilfe), as well as on social welfare (Sozialhilfe). Some of the surveyed persons,
mostly women and youths without any right to unemployment benefits (Arbeitslosengeld) have no
income at all and depend on assistance from their families.255
Experts from inside the Roma community criticize that the pay-out of social transfers is connected to
only little obligations in Austria. It is possible to live (modestly) depending on these transfers in
combination with a small additional income. Therefore, the motivation for looking for a job or aiming
at receiving better qualifications decreases. While the dependency of many Roma on social transfers
increases, the chance of being placed in the labour market decreases.256
The low income and the instability of employment add to the fact that Roma are in debt at a high
percentage. 78.8% of the surveyed Roma from the Oberwart district have debts, especially bank and
mail order business (Versandhaus) debts. All age groups are affected by this situation, but Roma
between 41 and 55 years old seem to be most affected (90.9% of respondents were in debt).257
The study on the poverty situation of Bosnian Roma in the Weinviertel, revealed that almost all of the
interviewed Roma have debts. Unpaid credits as well as unpaid bills for mobile phones and electricity
are widely spread. One family has to pay a very high amount to a hospital because they do not have
health insurance and their baby had been hospitalised for several times.258
d. Malnutrition/hunger
Only indications could be found whether hunger is a (widespread) phenomenon within the Roma
communities:
In the Oberwart district, many of the local Roma families accept the offer of a free lunch for their
children at school. Most of these families are in a difficult financial situation due to unemployment. 259
Also begging Roma often receive food from public authorities or churches such as soup kitchens.
Others are begging for food in front of supermarkets.260
Many Roma suffer from the consequences of bad alimentation, i.e. overweight is widely spread.261
Die Situation der jüngsten österreichischen Volksgruppe 15 Jahre nach ihrer Anerkennung, Diploma Thesis at
the University of Vienna, p. 74.
254
255
256
University of Vienna, p. 49; Sarközi, R. (2008), ROMA, Österreichische Volksgruppe. Von der Verfolgung bis zur
Anerkennung.
257
258
p. 354f.
259
nach ihrer Anerkennung, Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna, p. 74.
260
Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna.
261
See Chapter Health.
46
e. Material deprivation and/or other non-income poverty indicators
The data of EU-SILC 2009 does not provide enough information on severe material deprivation for an
assessment of the specific situation of Roma in Austria. According to EU-SILC 2009 about 3.7% of all
Austrian citizens recently faced severe material deprivation in Austria. The respective number for EU27 citizens (without Austrian citizens) is 3.3%, while it is 17% for citizens of other countries (which is
higher than the respective number at average of all countries of EU-27, amounting to 15.4%). Roma
who immigrated recently from Kosovo, Serbia or Macedonia could be concerned by this at a high
degree.262
Describing their life, most of the interviewed Bosnian Roma in the Weinviertel said they have to live a
life without any luxury and that they manage to survive somehow. A few of them did not know how to
fill their fridge in the middle of the month.263
Major projects or initiatives:
Local initiatives or projects aiming at improving the situation of Roma either in Austria or at their
primary place of residence (if Roma travel to Austria to work and do not have a permanent place of
residence in Austria) exist.
In 2008, a local initiative in Vienna started the production of cucumbers in Hostice/Slovakia. The
costs of production were carried by the Viennese association “Direct Aid Roma” (Direkthilfe Roma)
and the cucumbers were then sold in Austria. As of 2011 seven families participated in this project and
12.000 glasses of cucumbers could be produced and 1.000 glasses of cabbage.264
The Vinzenz-Association (Vinzenzgemeinschaft) based in Graz, Styria, conducts a number of projects
directed at migrants including Roma. For instance, they offer an emergency sleeping camp (Vinzinest
for men, Vinzischutz for women)265 for all people in urgent need for a sleeping opportunity.
Furthermore, the Vinzenzgemeinschaft initiated a project in Hostice/Slovakia called “Vinzipasta”.
Women in Hostice produce noodles following the motto “work instead of begging” and receive over
50% of the purchase price. This pasta is now available in smaller stores and even one supermarket
chain all over Austria.266
After implementing the begging prohibition in Graz, Styria, the city together with other partners
started a project called “Bio Garlic Romanes” (Bioknoblauch Romanes) conducted by the association
European Neighbours to offer an alternative to persons affected by the prohibition of begging. The city
262
263
p. 354f.
264
Direkthilfe Roma, Gib der Armut ein Gurkerl, available at: www.direkthilferoma.at/verein/gurken.
265
Vinzinest, available at: www.vinzi.at/vinzenz/frames.html; Vinzischutz, available at:
www.vinzi.at/vinzenz/frames.html.
266
Vinzipasta, available at: www.vinzi.at/vinzenz/frames.html.
47
and the region of Styria paid around €25.000 for this initiative. Roma in five countries produce garlic
which is sold in Austria.267 This project was criticised as being full of clichés regarding Roma.268
267
268
European Neighbours, available at: www.european-neighnours.net/cms/.
Der Standard (2011), ‚Knoblauchanbau daheim statt Betteln in Graz‘, 27 December 2011.
48
7
Active citizenship/Rights awareness
a. Awareness of the existence of representative Roma organisations, other civil society
organisations, anti-discrimination legislation and equality bodies
Several Roma organisations and other organisations in Austria offer various projects and provide
material or workshops for Roma, for example in the areas of education, culture and history of Roma
(see also section c). Reports and information materials provided by these organisations indicate that
their offers are accepted by their target groups.269 However, an assessment of the awareness of the
existence of representative Roma associations or their offers is not possible based on desk research.
According to the opinion of employees of one representative Roma organisation (Romano Centro) and
another civil society organisation (Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups (Österreichisches
Volksgruppenzentrum)), it is difficult to assess whether Roma are aware of the existence of
representative Roma organisations because various Roma communities exist in Austria as well as
various Roma organisations that offer a variety of programmes for different target groups.
According to the assessment of the interviewed experts, autochthonous Roma seem to be aware of the
existence of representative Roma organisations and other civil society organisations. Burgenland
Roma seem to be aware of the existence of representative Roma organisations in Burgenland because
they are present in discussions. Also, the association Roma-Service raises awareness with the RomBus and might thus be noticed. Furthermore, the association Romano Centro seems to be known
amongst Roma who immigrated from former Yugoslavia and currently live in Vienna.270
According to the assessment of one interviewed expert, Roma in Austria are aware that being
discriminated against is illegitimate. Especially autochthonous Roma seem to be aware of their rights
and tend to combat discrimination. However, not all cases of discrimination are perceived as such, e.g.
structural discrimination in the educational system. Possibilities to combat discrimination are not well
known. Even if anti-discrimination law and equality bodies are known, Roma often are not confident
enough in combating discrimination because they fear negative consequences.271
In 2011, the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment (Gleichbehandlungsanwaltschaft, GAW) organised a
discussion in Vienna on this topic. According to the assessment of an employee of the Ombudsperson
for Equal Treatment, it is important to further raise awareness amongst Roma and to inform
(potentially) affected persons of the Equal Treatment Act (Gleichbehandlungsgesetz, GlBG), their
options and institutions they can turn to when they experience discrimination.272 No other projects or
269
Romano Centro, See for example, Lernhilfe und Elternarbeit, available at: www.romanocentro.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3%3Alernhilfe&catid=12%3Aprojekte&Itemid=4
&lang=de; Roma Service, available: www.roma-service.at/dromablog/?p=20023; Association Ketani for Roma
and Sinti, available at: www.sinti-roma.at/lagerplatz.htm; Public Aid (Volkshilfe) (2009), Thara, Romnija and
Roma in transition – Endbericht, available at:
http://www.volkshilfe.at/folder/84/Thara_Transition_ENDBERICHT_2009_09_FINAL.pdf.; Public Aid, Zara
macht Schule, available at: www.volkshilfe.at/1430,,,2.html.
270
Response to a telephonic request received by Romano Centro on 27. August 2012 and a response to a
telephonic request received by the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups (Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum)
on 30 August 2012.
271
Ibid.
272
Response to an information request received from the Ombud for Equal Treatment
(Gleichbehandlungsanwaltschaft, GAW) on 14 August 2012.
49
initiatives, campaigns, media campaigns, training schemes undertaken by national or regional
institutions for raising awareness among the Roma community on the national legislation that
prohibits discrimination on ethnic or racial grounds are available.273
b. Participation in elections and political representation
According to Austrian legislation, data concerning the participation of Roma in elections is not being
collected, on the national and the regional levels, by the Federal Ministry of the Interior
(Bundesministerium für Inneres, BMI). Data on the participation of Roma in elections in Austria can
thus not be provided.274
An Advisory Board must be established for Roma issues according to the Regulation on Ethnic
Groups Advisory Boards (Verordnung über die Volksgruppenbeiräte)275. According to §7 of the
Regulation, this Advisory Board is to be made up of eight members, four of them assigned by Roma
associations as mentioned in the Ethnic Groups Act.276 According to §4 of the Ethnic Groups Act, the
members of the Advisory Boards, which are installed to inform the Federal Government on issues
regarding ethnic groups in Austria (§3 of the Ethnic Groups Act), are assigned by the Federal
Government for four years. The Advisory Boards have to preserve the cultural, social and economic
common interest of the ethnic group and are to be heard within a reasonable period of time before
adopting legal norms and general plans in the area of funding. Currently an amendment to the Ethnic
Groups Act is being discussed, but was not yet decided on.277
In 2009, an Advisory Board for Migration and Integration (Migrations- und Integrationsbeirat) was
established in Linz and in which one Roma/Sinti-representative was elected to strengthen the position
of the acknowledged ethnic groups (anerkannte Volksgruppen) when dealing with questions of
integration and diversity and to compensate marginalisation in regular democratic processes.278
Vienna aims at recruiting persons with migratory background in the Viennese administration. Roma
are currently employed at the municipality of Vienna and Oberwart. At least one Roma is employed at
the department for integration and diversity in Vienna (Magistratsabteilung 17 - Integration und
Diversität, MA 17) of the Viennese government.279
According to the assessment of an interviewed expert, Roma are currently underrepresented in
politics.280 However, according to the perception of a different interviewed expert, Roma seem to be
increasingly interested in politics. The exercise of their active electoral rights cannot be assessed. 281
273
All relevant sources have been searched (websites of Roma organisations who provide offers for Roma,
other official institutions and ministries); one interview has been conducted with an expert (an employee of
Romano Centro).
274
Response to an information request received from the Federal Ministry of the Interior (Bundesministerium
für Inneres, BMI) on 22 August 2012.
275
Austria, Regulation on Ethnic Groups Advisory Boards (Verordnung über die Volksgruppenbeiräte), BGBl. Nr.
38/1977, last modified by BGBl. Nr. 895/1993.
276
Austria, Ethnic Groups Act (Bundesgesetz über die Rechtsstellung der Volksgruppen in Österreich –
Volksgruppengesetz - VoGrG), BGBl. Nr. 396/1976, last modified by BGBl. I Nr. 46/2011.
277
Austria, Draft Amendment Act to the Ethnic Groups Act (Entwurf eines Bundesgesetzes, mit dem das
Volksgruppengesetz geändert wird).
278
279
Ibid., p. 30; no further information given by the Federal Ministry of the Interior – information request on 24
August 2012 remained unanswered.
280
Response to a telephonic request received by the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups on 30 August 2012.
281
50
No projects or initiatives for raising awareness of or to encourage civil/voting registration are
available.282
c. Participation and representation in non-governmental organisations
Several NGOs and associations representing and/or working for and with Roma exist in Austria (The
Association of Roma Oberwart (Verein Roma Oberwart), the Ketani Association (Verein Ketani), the
Cultural Association of Austrian Roma (Kulturverein österreichischer Roma), the Association
Romano Centro, the Association Roma Service, the Adult Education Centre of Burgenland-Roma
(Volkshochschule der burgenländischen Roma) and the Association Baro Ilo). In addition, other NGOs
and associations provide offers for Roma, e.g. the NGO Public Aid (Volkshilfe).
According to the assessment of interviewed experts, Roma are represented in non-governmental
organisations. According to another employee working at the Cultural Association of Austrian Roma
(Kulturverein österreichischer Roma), between five and six Roma are represented in the board of this
association. Furthermore, Roma are for example represented in the THARA project of the NGO Public
Aid (Volkshilfe) and the Adult Education Centre of Burgenland Roma (Volkshochschule der
burgenländischen Roma). Further information or data concerning the representation or participation of
Roma in non-governmental organisations have not been provided.283
d. Awareness and use of complaints procedures
The Equal Treatment Commission, the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment, the “Klagsverband” are
statutory bodies that record and process complaints of rights violations as well as racism and/or
discrimination. Furthermore, the association "Civil Courage and Anti-Racism Work" (Zivilcourage
und Anti-Rassismus-Arbeit, ZARA) provides advice for persons who experience racism and racist
discrimination, and documents cases of discrimination.
In the database of ZARA data concerning the discrimination of Roma or the discriminatory use of the
term “gypsy” is being collected (see Annex 2).284
The Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment did not provide data on persons’ ethnicity, origin or
citizenship. In its statistics, the Ombudsperson does not systematically collect data on their clients’
ethnicity. Statistical evaluations are only possible regarding discrimination grounds and facts of the
cases. Based on their experience in counselling, the Ombudsperson only receives a few requests from
Roma.285 The Equal Treatment Commission (Gleichbehandlungskommission, GBK) does not collect
data on discrimination disaggregated by ethnicity. No further information on awareness or use of
complaint procedures by Roma was provided by the Equal Treatment Commission.286
282
All relevant sources have been searched (websites of Roma organisations who provide offers for Roma,
other official institutions and ministries); one interview has been conducted with an expert (an employee of the
Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups).
283
Response to a telephonic request received by Romano Centro on 27 August 2012, a response received by
the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups on 30 August 2012 and a response received by the Cultural Association of
Austrian Roma (Kulturverein österreichischer Roma) on 4 September 2012.
284
Response to an information request received from ZARA on 21 August 2012.
285
Response to an information request received from the Ombud for Equal Treatment
(Gleichbehandlungsanwaltschaft) on 14 August 2012.
286
Response to an information request received from the Equal Treatment Commission
(Gleichbehandlungskommission, GBK) on 13 August 2012.
51
The “Klagsverband”, a litigation association of NGOs against discrimination, did not receive any
requests from Romano Centro, which is a member of the “Klagsverband”.287
e. Experiences and perceptions of racial/ethnic discrimination
According to the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI), Roma, amongst
others, have often been exposed to racism and discrimination in Austria. “Roma continue to suffer
from unequal treatment in the socio-economic sphere largely because of the negative prejudices
towards them from the mainstream media and some public figures.”288 According to the anti-racism
reports published by ZARA, Roma experience racial and ethnic discrimination in different areas, e.g.
media and politics289, police290, work291 and access to establishments.292
The Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups (Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum) reported that Roma
have repeatedly been denied access to a discotheque in Oberwart in January 2007. According to the
owner of the discotheque, Roma are not welcome in this establishment. The police was informed by
the affected Roma, but did not intervene.293
In 2005, the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment received a complaint because Roma had been denied
access to a camping site where a “No room for gypsies” sign was placed. According to the assessment
of the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment, the denial of access and the use of the term “gypsy”
qualify as discrimination because a group of persons are denied access to services [Dienstleistungen]
based on their ethnicity; furthermore, the term “gypsy” is perceived as being offensive and addresses
persons’ ethnicity in a discriminatory way. Acting upon a request of the Ombudsperson for Equal
Treatment, the third senate of the Equal Treatment Commission wrote an expert opinion on 21 April
2006 confirming the assessment of the Ombudsperson for Equal Treatment. Furthermore, the Equal
Treatment Commission points out that the term “gypsy” is associated with negative individual,
political and legal consequences by Roma and thus perceived as being stigmatising. 294
As already outlined (see section a), Roma are not always aware of being discriminated against.
According to an interviewed expert who is working at the association Romano Centro, insults are a
common form of discrimination against Roma, for example using the term “gypsy”. In general,
antiziganism is perceived as being a form of racism that is increasing and Romano Centro intends to
publish
a
report
on
this
issue.295
287
Response to an information request received from the „Klagsverband“ on 30 August 2012.
ENARA (2012), ENAR SHADOW REPORT. Racism and Related Discriminatory Practices in Austria, p. 8.
289
ZARA (2012), Rassismus Report 2011. Einzelfall-Bericht über rassistische Übergriffe und Strukturen in
Österreich, Wien, p. 29.
290
Österreich, Wien, p. 37.
291
Ibid., p. 45.
292
Österreich, p. 57.
293
Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups (Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum) 2007, p. 158.
294
Expert opinion provided by the Equal Treatment Commission on 13 August 2012 (response to an
information request), pp. 1-5.
295
288
52
ANNEXES
1.
Bibliography
APA (2001) ‚Das Bettelverbot wurde in fünf Bundesländern angefochten‘, Der Standard, 14
December 2011.
APA (2011) ,Ein Campingplatz für die Unerwünschten‘, Der Standard, 12 August 2012.
Aurora (2010) Migrantinnen und Armut, available at:
http://www.bawo.at/fileadmin/user_upload/public/Dokumente/Projekte/AURORA/AURORApl
us/AuroraPlus_Bericht_MigrantInnen.pdf.
Austria, §2 Wiener Landessicherheitsgesetz, LGBl. 51/1993, last amended by LGBl. 25/2010,
available at: www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokumente/LrW/LRWI_I110_000/LRWI_I110_000.pdf.
Austria, §27 Kärntner Landessicherheitsgesetz, LGBl. 74/1977, last amended by LGBl. 44/2011,
available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=LrK&Dokumentnummer=LKT40006499&ResultF
unctionToken=81b136d2-1e65-402f-9e8b8742568c9fa2&Position=1&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=landessicherheitsgesetz&G
esetzesnummer=&VonArtikel=&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&Bi
sAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=08.10.20
12&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&S
uchworte=.
Austria, §29 Salzburger Landessicherheitsgesetz, LGBl 57/2009 last amended by LBGl. 66/2012,
available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=LrSbg&Gesetzesnummer=20000632.
Austria, Gesetz zur Regelung öffentlicher Sammlungen, LGBl. 48/1969 last amended by LGBl.
58/2001, available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=LrVbg&Dokumentnummer=LRVB_2200_000_20
020101_99999999&ResultFunctionToken=64f81f5a-ec1a-41a5-a0bc4900fc5f7c42&Position=1&Titel=&Lgblnummer=&Typ=&Index=&FassungVom=08.10.2012
&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=50&Suchworte=sammlung.
Austria, Niederösterreichisches Polizeistrafgesetz, LGBl 135/75 last amended by LBGl. 107/2012,
available at: http://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokumente/LrNo/LRNI_2012107/LRNI_2012107.html.
Austria, Oberösterreichisches Polizeistrafgesetz. LGBl. 36/1979 last amended by LGBl. Nr. 36/2011,
available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=LrOO&Dokumentnummer=LOO40011184&Resul
tFunctionToken=dfc0a4ba-24c5-4626-9e0953
f156e7e1f183&Position=1&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=&Gesetzesnummer=&Von
Artikel=&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kun
dmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=08.10.2012&Normabschnittnu
mmerKombination=Und&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=bettelei.
Austria, Tirol Landespolizeigesetz, LGBl. 60/1976 last amended by LGBl. Nr. 94/2012, available at:
www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=LrT&Gesetzesnummer=20000176.
Biffl, G., Bok-Schappelwein, J. et al. (2005) Verschärfung der Arbeitsmarktprobleme von
Randgruppen in Grenzregionen im Gefolge der Ostöffnung, Vienna, WIFO, available at:
Bock-Schappelwein, J. und Falk, M. (2009) Die Bedeutung von Bildung im Spannungsfeld zwischen
Staat, Markt und Gesellschaft, available at:
http://www.bmukk.gv.at/medienpool/17601/bildung_spannungsfeld.pdf.
Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft Wohnungslosenhilfe Delogierung, available at:
http://www.bawo.at/de/content/wohnungslosigkeit/delogierung.html.
Bundesgesetz mit dem das Volksgruppengesetz geändert wird, available at
http://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/VHG/XXIV/ME/ME_00371/fname_245271.pdf.
Bundesgesetz über die Rechtsstellung der Volksgruppen in Österreich – Volksgruppengesetz –
VoGrG, BGBl. Nr. 396/1976, last modified by BGBl. I Nr. 46/2011.
Bundeskanzleramt (2010) 3. Bericht der Republik Österreich gemäß Artikel 25 Abs.2 des
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten, Vienna, available at:
http://www.bka.gv.at/DocView.axd?CobId=42120.
Bundeskanzleramt (2011) EU-Rahmen für nationale Strategien zur Integration der Roma bis 2020.
Politische und rechtliche Maßnahmen, Vienna, available at:
http://www.bka.gv.at/DocView.axd?CobId=47025.
Bundesministerium für Arbeit, Soziales und Konsumentenschutz (2010) Hundstorfer: “Roma haben
Zukunft am Arbeitsmarkt”, available at:
http://www.bmask.gv.at/cms/site/index_presseaussendung.html?doc=CMS1277713867186.
Bundesministerium für Gesundheit (2012) Impfplan Österreich 2012, available at:
http://bmg.gv.at/cms/home/attachments/3/3/6/CH1100/CMS1327680589121/impfplan_2012_fi
nal,_1.2.2012.pdf.
Caritas Jahresbericht 2011, available at: http://www.caritassteiermark.at/fileadmin/user/steiermark/2012_02/Marienambulanz_2011_web.pdf.
54
Datler, G./Mahidi, M. (2009), Armutsgefährdung und Wohnsituation-Modul zur Wohnsituation in
EU-SILC 2007, In: Statistische Nachrichten 6/2009.
Direkthilfe Roma, ‚Gib der Armut ein Gurkerl‘, available at: www.direkthilferoma.at/verein/gurken.
ENAR (2012) ENAR Shadow Report 2010-2011. Racism and Related Discriminatory Practices in
Austria, available at:
http://cms.horus.be/files/99935/MediaArchive/publications/shadow%20report%20201011/1.%20Austria.pdf.
Entschließung des Europäischen Parlaments vom 31.Januar 2008 zu einer europäischen Strategie für
die Roma, available at: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=//EP//TEXT+TA+P6-TA-2008-0035+0+DOC+XML+V0//DE
European Neighbours, available at: http://www.european-neighbours.net/cms/.
Fink, M. (2011) Austria, Promoting Social Inclusion of Roma. A Study of National Policies, (n.n.).
FRA (2012) The Situation of Roma in 11 EU Member States. Survey results at a glance, Luxemburg,
available at: http://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/2099-FRA-2012-Roma-at-aglance_EN.pdf.
Gneisz, E. (2010) Arbeitsmarktpolitische Projekte für Romnja und Roma in Österreich. Eine
sozialanthropologische Untersuchung der Projekte „Thara.Amarotrajo“ und „Mri Buti“,
Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna, available at: http://othes.univie.ac.at/11133/1/201006-03_8301114.pdf.
Halwachs, D. W. (2004) Roma and Romani in Austria, Graz, available at: http://romani.unigraz.at/romani/download/files/ling_rom_at_e.pdf.
http://www.wifo.ac.at/wwa/downloadController/displayDbDoc.htm?item=MB_2005_02_07_ARBEIT
SMARKTPROBLEME$.PDF.
Kälin Schreiblehner, I. and Schinnerl, H. (2011) „… damit meine Kinder nicht dasselbe durchmachen
müssen wie ich.“ Armutslagen der bosnischen Roma im niederösterreichischen Weinviertel, in:
Rosecker, M. (Ed.), Armut und Reichtum. Ungleiche Lebenslagen, -chancen, -stile und –welten
in Österreich, Vienna: Verein Alltag Verlag.
Kasper, R.O. (2009) Die Burgenland-Roma. Die Situation der jüngsten österreichischen Volksgruppe
15 Jahre nach ihrer Anerkennung, Diploma Thesis at the University of Vienna.
Lagerplatz für Roma und Sinti, gegründet und organisiert vom Verein Ketani available at: www.sintiroma.at/lagerplatz.htm
Ludwig Boltzmann Institut für Menschenrechte, available at: http://www.promostudy.org/.
55
Leoni, T. (2004) The Labour Market Developement of Oberwart and the Socio-Economic Situation of
Roma, WIFO Working Papers, No.226, available at:
http://www.wifo.ac.at/wwa/servlet/wwa.upload.DownloadServlet/bdoc/WP_2004_226$.PDF.
Luciak, M. (2011) Roma mit Migrationshintergrund an österreichischen Volksschulen, in: Diehm,
I./Panagiotopoulou (2011), Bildungsbedingungen in europäischen Migrationsgesellschaften:
Ergebnisse qualitativer Studien in Vor- und Grundschulen. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für
Sozialwissenschaften.
Luciak, M. (2012) Roma und Sinti in Österreich – auf dem Weg zu höherer Bildung, in: Die
Kupfzeitung (2012), available at: http://www.kupf.at/medien/zeitung/2011-2012/142/roma-undsinti-sterreich-auf-dem-weg-zu-h-herer-bildung.
Luciak, M. and Binder, S. (2010) Informationen und Anregungen zur Umsetzung des
Unterrichtsprinzips „Interkulturelles Lernen“ – Ein Handbuch für den Bereich
allgemeinbildende Pflichtschulen und allgemeinbildende höhere Schulen, Vienna, ASSA,
available at: http://www.univie.ac.at/alumni.ksa/images/text-documents/ASSA/ASSA-SN2010-01.pdf.
Memorial Service, (n.n.), (n.n.), available at: http://www.gedenkdienst.at/.
ORF Burgenland (2007) Roma-Projekt “Mri Buti” in Auflösphase, available at:
http://bglv1.orf.at/stories/264450.
ORF Steiermark (2012) Roma-Frauen zu Pflegerinnen ausgebildet available at:
http://steiermark.orf.at/news/stories/2523274/.
Österreichische Gesellschaft für Politikberatung und Politikentwicklung (OGPP) (2008) 2. Armutsund Reichtumsbericht für Österreich, Vienna, available at:
http://www.arbeiterkammer.com/bilder/d89/Armuts_und_Reichtumsbericht2008.pdf.
Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum (2007) 2. Bericht zur Durchführung des Europäischen
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler Minderheiten in der Republik Österreich,
Vienna, Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum.
OTS (2005) Roma-Beschäftigungsprojekt „Mri Buti – meine Arbeit“ gesichert, available at:
http://www.ots.at/presseaussendung/OTS_20050919_OTS0170/roma-beschaeftigungsprojektmri-buti-meine-arbeit-gesichert
Pilotprojekt für Mammografie Screening: “Ich schau auf mich”, available at: www.ich-schau-aufmich.at
56
Polis (2010) Soziale Ausgrenzung im Fokus: Roma in Österreich, Vienna, Zentrum polis, available at:
www.politik-lernen.at/site/gratisshop/shop.item/105771.html.
Rat der Kärntner Slowenen (2006) Zur Lage der Kärntner Slowenen 2006 im Jahr der EU
Präsidentschaft der Republik Österreich, available at:
http://www.slomak.net/images/uploads/brosura_de.pdf.
Riesenfelder, A. et al. (2011) Beschäftigungssituation von Personen mit Migrationshintergrund in
Wien – Endbericht , available at:
www.arbeiterkammer.at/bilder/d164/Studie_MigrantInnen_2012.pdf.
Roma Service, available at: www.roma-service.at/dromablog/?p=20023.
Romano Centro, Lernhilfe und Elternarbeit, available at: www.romanocentro.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3%3Alernhilfe&catid=12%3Apro
jekte&Itemid=4&lang=de.
Romano centro, Roma-SchulmediatorInnen an Wiener Schulen, available at: http://www.romanocentro.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=4%3Aromaassistenten&catid=12%3Aprojekte&Itemid=4&lang=de.
Schmidt, Colette M. (2011) ,Knoblauchanbau daheim statt Betteln in Graz‘, Der Standard, 28
December 2011.
Schoibl, H. (2011), Equality in Housing. Gleichbehandlung am Wohnungsmarkt, Salzburg.
Statistik Austria (2001) Volkszählung 2001 - Umgangssprache von Personen mit österreichischer
Staatsbürgerschaft, einschließlich Kombination mit Deutsch, Vienna, Statistik Austria.
Statistik Austria (2007), Österreichischer Todesursachenatlas 1998-2004, Vienna: Statistik Austria.
Steiermark, Gesetz vom 18.Jänner 2005, mit dem ein Steiermärkisches Landes-Sicherheitsgesetz
erlassen wird (StLSG), LGBL.Nr.24/2005, last modified by LGBL. Nr.37/2011, §3a Abs.2.
THARA BIZNIS Die Website für Unternehmen und Arbeit, available at: http://www.thara-biznis.at/.
Thuswald, M. (2008) Betteln als Beruf? Wissensaneignung und Kompetenzerwerb von Bettlerinnen in
Wien, Diploma Thesis at the Universität of Vienna, available at:
http://www.bawo.at/fileadmin/user_upload/public/Dokumente/News/b_wie_betteln_Bettelverbo
te_in_OEsterreich_HSchoibl.pdf.
57
Verein Ketani für Roma und Sinti, available at: www.sinti-roma.at/lagerplatz.htm.
Verein Ketani Hilfe für die Seele – Schrei einer Minderheit, available at: www.sintiroma.at/projekte.htm.
Verein Roma Oberwart, available at: www.verein-roma.at/html/projekte.htm.
Verfassungsgerichtshof, G155/10 vom 30. Juni 2012; Verfassungsgerichtshof, G118/11 vom 30. Juni
2012; Verfassungsgerichtshof, G132/11 vom 30. Juni 2012.
Verordnung über die Volksgruppenbeiräte, BGBl. Nr. 38/1977, last modified by BGBl. Nr. 895/1993.
Vinzinest, available at: www.vinzi.at/vinzenz/frames.html.
Vinzipasta, available at: www.vinzi.at/vinzenz/frames.html.
Vinzischutz, available at: www.vinzi.at/vinzenz/frames.html.
Volkshilfe (2010) Tätigkeitsbericht THARA – Beratung und Dialog, available at:
www.volkshilfe.at/1224,,,2.html.
Volkshilfe (2011) THARA AMAROTHRAJO, available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/1217,,,2.html.
Volkshilfe (2012), Endbericht THARA Romani Butji, available at:
http://www.volkshilfe.at/1430,,,2.html.
Volkshilfe Österreich, Projekt Thara Haus, available at: www.volkshilfe.at/1194,,,2.html.
Volkshilfe Österreich, THARA – Novi Vidici, available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/1462,,,2.html.
Volkshilfe Österreich, THARA Projekte , available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/THARA
Volkshilfe Thara, Romnija and Roma in transition – Endbericht, available at:
http://www.volkshilfe.at/folder/84/Thara_Transition_ENDBERICHT_2009_09_FINAL.pdf.;
Public Aid, Zara macht Schule, available at: www.volkshilfe.at/1430,,,2.html.
Volkshilfe, Equality in Housing, available at: http://www.volkshilfe.at/1351,,,2.html.
ZARA (2008) Rassismus Report 2007. Einzelfall-Bericht über rassistische Übergriffe und Strukturen
in Österreich, Wien.
58
ZARA Zara macht Schule, available at: www.zara.or.at/index.php/projekte/aktuelles/zara-machtschule.
59
2.
Statistical Tables
Table 1: Occupation level and ethnic minorities
Source: Austria, Riesenfelder, A., Schelepa, S. and Wetzel, P. (2011), Beschäftigungssituation von Personen mit Migrationshintergrund in Wien – Endbericht,
Study commissioned by the Chamber of Labour, p. 277, available at: www.arbeiterkammer.at/bilder/d164/Studie_MigrantInnen_2012.pdf
60
Table 2: Highest attained education and ethnic minorities
61
Table 3: Earned income per month (net) and ethnic minorities
62
3.
Table of complaints
Table 1: Discrimination of Roma and discriminatory usage of the term “gypsy”
Year
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012 (including August)
Number Cases
7
4
13
8
9
17
8
In the database of the Austrian association “Civil Courage and Anti-Racism Work” (Zivilcourage und Anti-Rassismus-Arbeit, ZARA) data
concerning discrimination of Roma and the discriminatory usage of the term “gypsy” is being collected.
Source:
Response
to
an
information
request
received
from
ZARA
on
21
August
2012.
63
4.
Table of sources (reports and studies on Roma)
Title, author, source
Austria, Baumgartner, Gerhard und Freund, Florian (2007),
Roma Politik in Österreich
Source and type
Non-governmental, socio-historical report

Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment

Health

Poverty

Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
No empirical research conducted
Location
n.a.
Target population
Roma in Austria
Key findings
The report provides information on the history of Roma in Austria
and on the political initiatives and measures targeting Roma
explicitly.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Generally for Roma in Austria
Austria,
Biffl, Gudrun (2005), Verschärfung der
Arbeitsmarktprobleme von Randgruppen in Grenzregionen
im Gefolge der Ostöffnung – Das Beispiel der Roma in
Oberwart
Non-governmental, social
The
mat
ic
are
a
Source and type
Education
64
Housing
Employment

Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
Sample size: 99 Roma
Location
Oberwart
Target population
Roma in Oberwart
Key findings
The study provides information on the employment situation in
the district of Oberwart in general and the socio-economic
situation of the Roma in particular.
The unemployment rate of members of the Roma community is
much higher than that of the major population, which is due to a
variety of factors: low school education, migratory background as
well as poor health status are the most important ones.
Methodology
Qualitative face-to-face interviews
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Representative for Roma in the district of Oberwart
Austria,
Bundeskanzleramt (2010), 3. Bericht der Republik Österreich
gemäß Artikel 25 Abs. 2 des Rahmenübereinkommens zum
Schutz nationaler Minderheiten
Thematic area
Source and type
Education
Governmental

Housing
Employment

Health
65
Poverty
Migration
Thematic area
Active citizenship

Sample
Location
Austria
Target population
National Minorities
Key findings
New developments regarding the implementation of the
Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities
are presented by the Federal Chancellery.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Generally for National Minorities in Austria
Austria, Bundeskanzleramt (2011), EU-Rahmen für nationale
Strategien zur Integration der Roma bis 2020. Politische und
rechtliche Maßnahmen
Source and type
Governmental
Education

Housing

Employment

Health

Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
Location
Austria
Target population
Roma in Austria
Key findings
This report summarises major goals as well as legal and political
measures on a national level to improve the integration of Roma
66
by 2020 according to the conclusions of the Council of Europe on
19 May 2012. The measures concern the fields of education,
employment, health and housing. Furthermore, general
information on Roma in Austria and information on rights of
minorities and research activities is provided.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not applicable
Austria,
Caritas Marienambulanz (2012),
Jahresbericht 2011
Source and type
Non governmental report
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health

Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
n. a.
Location
Province of Styria
Target population
Socially marginalised people in need of health care services
Key findings
Annual Report of the Caritas Marienambulance which offers lowthreshold healthcare services also for medically uninsured persons
Methodology
Quantitative survey (frequency of visits, frequency of services
offered and descriptive analysis of the visitors)
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Only regional (Province of Styria)
67
Datler, Georg und Mahidi, Margareta (2009),
Armutsgefährdung und Wohnsituation – Modul zur
Wohnsituation in EU-SILC 2007
Source and type
Non governmental, social
Education
Thematic area
Housing

Employment
Health
Poverty

Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
EU-SILC data 2007
Location
Austria
Target population
Persons at risk of poverty
Key findings
The research objective was to identify correlations between
housing conditions and risk of poverty, affecting certain groups
among the Austrian population. In general, persons at risk of
poverty are more likely to live in large dwellings in urban areas;
their efforts for housing are rather high compared to their income,
the floor space of their dwellings is rather small, and particularly
in urban areas the problem of adequate heating arises. In rural
areas there is a lacking access to public utilities and infrastructure
for persons at risk of poverty.
Methodology
Quantitative: secondary analysis of EU-SILC data
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Austria
Austria, ENARA (2012), ENAR SHADOW REPORT. Racism
and Related Discriminatory Practices in Austria
68
Thematic area
Source and type
Non-governmental report
Education

Housing

Employment

Health

Poverty

Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
No empirical research conducted (findings are based on legal
research and anecdotal information gathered from civil society
organisations and NGOs)
Location
Austria
Target population
Migrants in Austria
Key findings
The ENAR Shadow Report provides information on racism and
related discriminatory practices in Austria, covering the period
from March 2010 to March 2011.
Concerning housing one main finding is that although access to
homeless institutions and social welfare is independent form
citizenship, many migrants and members of ethnic minorities
(particularly those of short-term residence) are confronted with
various obstacles in the access to public housing and even to
homeless institutions.
One main finding in the area of employment is that Roma as a
minority group did and do not manage to access the labour market
successfully. But they are also excluded from the official service
for the unemployed. To earn a living, they have to find ways of
self-subsistence.
In the area of education, the transfer of pupils with migratory
background to special needs schools and the lack of diversity in
the education curricula are criticised.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Migrants in Austria
69
Austria, Federal Ministry of Health, (2012) Impfkonzept
Source and type
governmental
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health

Poverty
Migration
Thematic area
Active citizenship
Sample
n. a.
Location
Austria
Target population
Austrian children
Key findings
Vaccination plan of Austria that includes all cost-free vaccinations
for children up to the age of 15 in Austria.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Austria, Fink, Marcel (2011), Austria. Promoting Social
Inclusion of Roma. A Study of National Policies. Report to the
European Commission via Network of Independent Experts in
Social Inclusion
Source and type
Non-governmental, political
Education

Housing

Employment

Health

70
Poverty

Migration

Active citizenship

Sample
No empirical research conducted (desk research)
Location
Austria
Target population
Roma in Austria
Key findings
A study of national policies targeting respectively affecting the
situation of Roma in Austria. The report highlights structural and
specific problems and challenges, which should be addressed in
the Austrian national integration strategy for Roma and gives
recommendations for politics and stakeholders.
Methodology
Desk research (literature overview, legal analysis)
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Austria
Austria, Gneisz, Elisabeth (2010), Arbeitsmarktpolitische
Projekte für Romnja und Roma in Österreich Eine
sozialanthropologische
Untersuchung
der
Projekte
„Thara.Amarotrajo“ und „Mri Buti“
Source and type
Master thesis
Education

Thematic area
Housing
Employment

Health

Poverty

Migration
Active citizenship
Sample

Female and male Roma and non-Roma experts; Female and male
participants in Roma-projects;
Politically engaged Roma and non-Roma Sample-size: 16
71
Location
Eastern Austria
Target population
Roma in Vienna/Burgenland/Upper Austria
Key findings
Roma are still discriminated and disadvantaged on the labour
market; furthermore, according to media reports, Roma are
described as “problem group” and therefore seem to be selfblamed for their situation.
Labour-market policy projects and initiatives targeting Roma are
meaningful, however if they are short-term funded, rather than
used for long-term labour market policies or unlimited labour
contracts for Roma, their impact is restricted. The author suggests
the long-term integration of Roma projects into NGOs and
consequently encouraging Roma to find employment and to
secure their livelihood through their own initiative.
Methodology
Qualitative guideline-based interviews with experts and
employees in projects for Roma; one focus group with experts.
Qualitative semi- and unstructured interviews with Roma and
non-Roma who are politically engaged for the concerns of Roma
in Vienna.
Number of interviewees:
Roma participating in Roma-projects: 8
Non-Roma experts: 1 and one focus group with 4 participants
Thematic area
Roma experts: 3
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Only local: for Roma in eastern Austria
Austria, Halwachs Dieter W., (2004) Roma and Romani in
Austria
Source and type
Education

Housing
Employment
Health
72
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
Various locations of Roma population in Austria, e.g. Vienna,
Burgenland.
Target population
Roma in eastern Austria
Key findings
The report provides an in-depth analysis of the history of Roma in
Austria and deals with linguistic questions regarding Romani
languages and issues regarding education and schools.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Particularly eastern Austria
Austria,
Kälin Schreiblehner, Schinnerl, Ines und Herwig (2011), »…
damit meine Kinder nicht dasselbe durchmachen müssen wie
ich.« Armutslagen der bosnischen Roma im
niederösterreichischen Weinviertel
Thematic area
Source and type
Education

Housing

Employment

Health
Poverty

Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
14 Roma aged between 19 and 68 who belong to an officially
acknowledged ethnic group (anerkannte Volksgruppe)
Location
Region in Lower Austria (Weinviertel)
73
Target population
Autochthonous Roma living in the region Weinviertel in Lower
Austria
Key findings
Based on the qualitative data collected by Caritas Vienna within
the project “Missing Link”, the authors focus on several issues
that are related to poverty.
In the area of education, the transfer of Roma children to special
needs schools and several factors that influence school attainment
of Roma children, e.g. lack of parents’ support and poor education
of parents are addressed. According to the perception of
interviewed Roma, education is important for them.
In the area of housing, the findings indicate poor living conditions
(over-crowding and substandard dwellings.
One main finding in the area of employment is that various factors
are responsible for unemployment or employment in low wages
sectors. Lacking assistance in child care or a lack of mobility
plays a role.
Methodology
Qualitative interviews
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not representative
Austria,
(only a few cases, only local)
Kaspar, Ruth (2009),
Die Burgenland-Roma.
Die Situation der jüngsten österreichischen Volksgruppe 15
Jahre nach ihrer Anerkennung
Source and type
Master Thesis
Thematic area
Education
Housing

Employment

Health
Poverty

Migration
74
Active citizenship
Sample

Sample size: 24 (consisting of
19 Roma of two generations and 5 non-Roma)
Location
Province of Burgenland: Oberwart and surroundings
Target population
Autochthonous Roma (particularly those living in Oberwart and
surroundings)
Key findings
Intergenerational developments have been identified: the
education and housing situation improved for the Roma of the
second generation, which is also due to the political engagement
of individual Roma and Roma NGOs. However, Roma are still
affected by discrimination and disadvantage.
Methodology
Qualitative guided interviews with autochthonous Roma and
experts, working in Roma-organisations, schools or
municipalities.
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Only regional: Roma in Oberwart
Austria, Leoni, T. (2004),
The Labour Market Development of Oberwart and the SocioEconomic Situation of the Roma
Thematic area
Source and type
Education

Housing

Employment

Health

Poverty

Migration
Active citizenship
75
Sample
99 male and female members of the Roma population in the
Oberwart settlement „Am Anger“
Location
Province of Burgenland, municipalities Oberwart and Unterwart
Target population
Roma in Oberwart and Unterwart
Key findings
The author analyses the situation of the Roma in Oberwart and
Unterwart in connection with the economic and structural
developments in this region. He identifies similarities and
differences concerning the situation of the Roma in Oberwart and
Unterwart compared to the rest of the Austrian population.
Concerning education and employment the Roma are placed far
below the national average. Particularly older Roma are in a weak
socio-economic position: very few among them are employed,
their health situation is poor. While the younger Roma benefit
from the regional educational improvement the older ones do not.
However young males without completed education and mid-aged
women without regular employment are still disadvantaged
groups among the Roma population in Burgenland.
Methodology
Face-to-face Interviews among the population in the Roma
settlement
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Only regional: for the Roma in Oberwart and Unterwart
Austria, Luciak, Mikael (2011), Roma mit
Migrationshintergrund an österreichischen Volksschulen
Source and type
Education

Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
Interviews with 10 teachers at compulsory schools, two principals
of compulsory schools, six teachers at centres for special needs
76
education, one head of a centre for special needs education, eight
Roma-children who attend compulsory school, 10 parents of
Roma-pupils, five learning assistants, seven heads of Romaassociations
Location
Vienna; for further information on institutions involved, see
„sample“
Target population
Roma migrants (relevant actors have been interviewed to analyse
the educational situation of Roma-migrants; for further
information on the target group, see “sample”)
Key findings
The situation of Roma pupils with migratory background is not
well known. The study aims at investigating this topic and
presents several factors that influence the school attainment of
Roma children, e.g. lack of German language skills, problematic
family situations or lack of parents’ support. Learning aid
programmes are of great importance for the educational
attainment of Roma children.
Thematic
area
Furthermore, the principle of “intercultural learning” is not
properly implemented at selected Viennese primary schools and
thus does not address the needs of Roma children. Only a few
classes in the mother tongue of Roma are offered in Vienna.
Methodology
Qualitative research (interviews)
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not representative (only a few cases, only local)
Austria, Luciak, Mikael und Binder, Susanne (2010),
Informationen und Anregungen zur Umsetzung des
Unterrichtsprinzips “INTERKULTURELLES LERNEN”.
Ein Handbuch für den Bereich der allgemeinbildenden
Pflichtschulen und allgemeinbildenden höheren Schulen
Source and type
Education

Housing
Employment
77
Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
n.a.
Target population
Roma pupils in Austria
Key findings
The handbook provides information on the principle of
“intercultural learning”. In the first chapter of the handbook
general information on pupils with migratory background, pupils
who are part of minorities or acknowledged ethnic groups
(anerkannte Volksgruppen) is presented. The remaining chapters
of the handbook focus for example on the principle of
“intercultural learning” from a didactical point of view and
present possible strategies to implement the principle in practice.
Methodology
No empirical research conducted (literature review, supplemented
by the analysis of two cases of Roma pupils)
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not applicable
Austria,
Österreichische Gesellschaft für Politikberatung und
Politikentwicklung (2008), 2. Armuts- und Reichtumsbericht
für Österreich
Source and type
Governmental
Thematic area
Education
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty

Migration
78
Active citizenship
Sample
Location
Austria
Target population
Austrian population
Key findings
The report provides information on the poverty and wealth
situation in Austria. Main findings: 12-13% of the Austrian
population lives in households at or under the poverty
endangering quote. Especially single mothers and migrants are at
risk.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Representative for the situation in Austria
Austria, Österreichisches Volksgruppenzentrum (2007), 2.
Bericht zur Durchführung des Europäischen
Rahmenübereinkommens zum Schutz nationaler
Minderheiten in der Republik Österreich
Source and type
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
n.a.
Target population
n.a.
Key findings
In addition to the second state report regarding the implementation
79
of the Framework Convention for the Protection of National
Minorities, an NGO report on the topic has been published.
Besides general information about acknowledged ethnic groups
(anerkannte Volksgruppen), relevant legal aspects and other issues
a critical evaluation of certain constitutional regulations
concerning the rights of minorities is carried out. Amongst others
the Austrian Centre for Ethnic Groups (Österreichisches
Volksgruppenzentrum) reported that Roma have repeatedly been
denied access to a discotheque in Oberwart in January 2007.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not applicable
Austria, Polis (Hrsg.) (2010),
Soziale Ausgrenzung Fokus: Roma in Österreich
Source and type
Non- governmental report
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty

Migration
Active citizenship

Sample
n. a.
Location
Austria
Target population
Roma in Austria
Key findings
On occasion of the European Year against Poverty and Social
Exclusion (2009) this report analyses the history and the current
situation of Roma in Austria.
Methodology
80
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Austria
Title, author,
source
Austria, Riesenfelder, A., Schelepa, S. und Wetzel, P. (2011),
Beschäftigungssituation von Personen mit
Migrationshintergrund in Wien – Endbericht, Study
commissioned by the Chamber of Labour, available at:
www.arbeiterkammer.at/bilder/d164/Studie_MigrantInnen_2012
.pdf
Source and type
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment

Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
99 Roma, male and female
Location
Vienna
Target population
Roma in Vienna
Key findings
Roma are highly disadvantaged in the employment sector,
particularly male Roma are more likely to be unemployed than
female Roma or non-Roma. Compared to non-Roma there is a higher
percentage of Roma employed part time. Particularly among female
Roma there is a high share of multiple employments.
Methodology
Qualitative telephone interviews
Representativenes
s, transferability
of findings
81
Austria, Der Rat der Kärntner Slowenen (Hrsg.) (2006), Zur
Lage der Kärntner Slowenen 2006 im Jahr der EU
Präsidentschaft der Republik Österreich
Source and type
Non-governmental report, political
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship

Sample
Location
Province of Carinthia
Target population
Slovene Minority in the Province of Carinthia
Key findings
This report provides information about the situation of the
Slovene Minority in the Province of Carinthia in reference to the
Austrian Ethnic Groups Act (Volksgruppengesetz).
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Only regional and for the specific group of the Slovene Minority
in the Province of Carinthia
Austria, Schoibl, Heinz (2011), Equality in Housing
Source and type
Thematic area
Education
Housing

Employment
Health
Poverty

82
Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
300 experts, responsible for the allocation of public housing
(employees of housing offices, welfare departments, other clerks,
housing managements), NGO-experts and equality bodies
Location
Vorarlberg, Upper Austria, Lower Austria, Tyrol, Vienna
Target population
Applicants for public, social or private housing (particularly thirdcountry-nationals)
Key findings
Third-country nationals are still disadvantaged in the access to
public and private housing, although the public housing market
has been opened for non-citizens. The burden of housing efforts is
much higher for migrants than for Austrian citizens. Migrants live
in smaller dwellings than Austrian citizens. Mostly affected by
residential segregation in urban areas are migrants from Africa,
Asia and Turkey.
Methodology
Quantitative: 300 questionnaires and qualitative case studies in
model regions
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Austria
Austria, Statistics Austria (ed.) (2007), Atlas of Mortality in
Austria by causes of Death
Source and type
Thematic area
Education
Housing
Employment
Health

Poverty
Migration
83
Active citizenship
Sample
Empirical basis of the study: Official death records and the results
of the 1971, 1981, 1991 and 2001 population census
Location
Austria
Target population
Austrian population
Key findings
In Austria, mortality shows an east-west divide, with a higher
mortality risk in the east than in the west.
In general, when distinguishing urban and rural areas, the overall
mortality risk is higher in the urban communes than in the rural
ones. However, large cities (excluding Vienna) as well as
communes with very high agriculture quota register the lowest
mortality rates, while Vienna and small towns (2,000 to 10,000
inhabitants) show the highest.
Methodology
Quantitative survey (secondary data analysis)
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Austria, Verein Gedenkdienst (o.J.), 03/01 Roma und Sinti
(des)integriert
Source and type
Non-governmental

Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
n.a.
84
Target population
Roma
Key findings
One case of discrimination in the area of education has been
reported: a Roma child was insulted and beaten on the head by his
classmate.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not applicable
Austria, Volkshilfe Österreich (2009), Endbericht THARA
Amarotrajo
Source and type
Non- governmental
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment

Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
(project report)
Location
Vienna
Target population
Roma in Vienna
Key findings
The report provides information on the conducted project THARA
Amarotrajo.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not representative
85
Austria, Volkshilfe Österreich (2009), Endbericht THARA
Roma in Transition
Source and type
Non- governmental
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment

Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
(project report)
Location
Vienna
Target population
Roma in Vienna
Key findings
Roma in Transition.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not representative
Austria, Volkshilfe Österreich (2011), Tätigkeitsbericht
THARA – Beratung und Dialog
Source and type
Non- governmental
Thematic area
Education
Housing
Employment

Health
Poverty
86
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
(project report)
Location
Vienna
Target population
Roma in Vienna
Key findings
Beratung und Dialog, which is a follow-up project to the above
named project THARA Roma in Transition.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not representative
Austria, Volkshilfe Österreich (2012), Endbericht THARA –
Romani Butji
Source and type
Non- governmental
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment

Health
Poverty
Migration
Active citizenship
Sample
(project report)
Location
Vienna
Target population
Roma in Vienna
87
Key findings
Romani Butji.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not representative
Austria, ZARA (2008), Rassismus Report 2007. EinzelfallBericht über rassistische Übergriffe und Strukturen in
Österreich
Source and type
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
n.a.
Target population
n.a.
Key findings
ZARA annually publishes its report providing statistical
information on the complaints received disaggregated by area
(e.g. employment, police) and other information related to racism,
e.g. experiences of racist/ethnic discrimination in different areas,
projects to raise awareness in this regard, etc.
Discrimination cases involving Roma were in the areas of police
and housing. One discrimination case involving Roma was
reported: entrance into a discotheque was denied.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
Not applicable
88
findings
Österreich
Source and type
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
n.a.
Target population
n.a.
Key findings
information on the complaints received disaggregated by area of
discrimination (e.g. employment, police) and other information
related to racism, e.g. experiences of racist/ethnic discrimination
in different areas, projects to raise awareness in this regard, etc.
One discrimination case involving Roma was reported in the area
of police.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not applicable
Österreich
Source and type
89
Education
Thematic area
Housing
Employment
Health
Poverty
Migration

Active citizenship
Sample
n.a.
Location
n.a.
Target population
n.a.
Key findings
information on the complaints received disaggregated by area
(e.g. employment, police) and other information related to racism,
e.g. experiences of racist/ethnic discrimination in different areas,
projects to raise awareness in this regard, etc. One discrimination
case involving Roma was reported: it was a Roma discriminating
statement, made by an actor in a TV show.
Methodology
Representativeness,
transferability of
findings
Not applicable
90
5.
Roma networks
Type of
Associations,
Organisations,
NGOs
Association
Association
Association
Name of Organisation
Association of Roma
Oberwart (Verein Roma
Oberwart)
Ketani Association
(Verein Ketani)
Cultural Association of
Austrian Roma
(Kulturverreich
österreichischer Roma)
Email/Website
Roma involvement
[email protected],
http://www.verein-roma.at/
[email protected],
http://www.sinti-roma.at/
[email protected],
http://www.kv-roma.at/
91
Main area of expertise
Association of Roma Oberwart
aims at improving the living
situation of Roma in Austria. The
association established an
information center to support
members of “Volksgruppen” in
social, economic, societal and
cultural matters.
Education
The Ketani Association is active in
the field of protection and
maintenance of Romani culture
and language, and aims at
improving the social, economic and
legal status of Roma and Sinti in
Austria.
Education
The Cultural Association of
Austrian Roma hosts a permanent
exhibition on history and travels of
Roma, and publishes the
Culture and Language
Employment
Culture
Discrimination
Awareness-Raising
History of Roma in Austria
Housing
History of Roma
Improving social and political
Association
Romano Centro
[email protected],
http://www.romanocentro.org/NEW/index.php?optio
n=com_content&view=article&id
=12&Itemid=2&lang=de
Association
Roma Service
[email protected],
http://www.roma-service.at/
Part of an
association
Adult Education Centre
for Burgenland-Roma
(Volkshochschule der
burgenländischen Roma)
[email protected],
Association
Baro Ilo
[email protected],
http://www.vhs-roma.eu/
http://www.baroilo.at/
Member of the
BishopConference
(Bischofskonfer
enz)
Roma-Pastoral
[email protected],
http://www.martinus.at/fmi/xsl/m
artinuspro/allgemein/Allgemein/
browse/browserecord.xsl?lay=WEB_Seite&WEB_BEREIC
H::_kp_BereichID=1432112200
92
newspaper “Romano Kipo”.
status of Roma
Romano Centro is concerned with
education and culture; it publishes
the newspaper “Romano Centro”.
Education
Culture
Housing
The association is concerned with
preserving, documenting and
promoting the culture of
Burgenland-Roma and is active in
the area of education.
Culture
The Adult Education Centre for
Burgenland-Roma offers education
programmes for persons who are
interested in the culture and
language of Roma.
Baro Ilo aims at fostering culture
and language of Roma in Vienna.
The Roma-Pastoral has caritative
and social duties (e.g. pastoral
care, pilgrimage, support of cultural
identity, support in difficult or
emergency situations).
Culture and Tradition
Language
Education
Support in difficult or emergency
situations
7205529&sortfield.1=Reihenfolge&sortfield.2=ref_Sortierung_Aktue
ll&sortfield.3=ref_Sortierung_Termi
n&-sortorder.1=ascend&sortorder.2=descend&sortorder.3=ascend&-max=1&find
Association
Public Aid (Volkshilfe)
[email protected],
http://www.volkshilfe.at/1428,,,2.
html
93
Volkshilfe realised several projects
for Roma, in particular in the area
of employment.
Employment

Act 1 deliverables 2012 - European Union Agency for Fundamental

Transcription

Similar documents

Nr. 60, März 2008 - Romano

Cloud Computing - CPS Schließmann

Todsünde war gestern

Kurs Kalender 2015/2016