Downloaded from by guest on September 9, 2014 ajcn.nutrition.org
Transcription
Downloaded from by guest on September 9, 2014 ajcn.nutrition.org
Treatment of Pica with Mineral F. IARGARET GUTELIUS, M.D.,* J. GEORGE I the N long history recurring relationship In 1 order of pica 1895. in association the type eating with pica, which dirt, slaves rarely reported other hand, of recent years associating The by from in this brief one type not In Gutelius and It On of pica and Ford,6 interviews based third of in 1942 geophagy acid were children with pica children. trol that the children iron was more the with of the * the Research District of Assistant Foundation, Columbia, Clinical Washington tion. University Columbia; Children’s of address: Psychology, Iowa; I)istrict George Washington, Iowa of and District Professor, ; in School 1Medical Social of of of investigation was supported by a Public Anzerican Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that blood levels lower in the of thirty control Health Division 388 pica supplement and protein was considered had effect. have child However, been desirable diets to fit obviously addition of cal- children previous the Vol. a nutri- a practical since that with tailored of these unnecessary demonstrated pica were the the curative from procedures that in prove or a complete the and lacking diet to rela- Despite of such soluthe treatment Furthermore, ones saline remains thus each of the anemia nutrients would for of view, and and needs. not than that possibility adequate specific of deficiency or cause did pica suggested the it studies authors in curing nutrient impossible. Maryland. This niacin. administration of cause the point Bethesda, one investigate his these iron findings, other tive the Medicine, Service research gramit (RG-5923R1) from the of Research Grants, U. S. Public Health Service. not completely Pediatrics, Worker, low and in a comparable effective Theoretically to Pleasant, Hospital Associate University C. Columbia, Mount and evidence diet might in treatment. of Department Children’s and \Vashing- of was some Children’s HosChief Psychologist, College, Staff, Columbia, D. the others9 significantly between these George Department thiamine than higher particularly administration Their pica C. Medicine, Associate, Wesleyan Washington of Foundation, Head § Associate D. of Pediatrics, School Hospital Hospital Washington, Professor ton, D. C. ; f Research Psychiatry and Research pital of the District of present Children’s were intramuscular intramuscular diets tionship From Institute of a significantly However, find indicated former subjects, Tuskegee concentrations obtained grade Mississippi, association until malnutrition. on data diets the control of eighty-six control at the ascorbic was sigAfrican group. In addition, they found that the amount of milk, meat and foods rich in vitamin C contained in the diet of the children with pica was less satisfactory than that of the con- evidence presented with in much with the pregnant Moreover, 1962 hemoglobin is finding, and been evidence county possible iron, race.5 has suggestive Dickens calcium, among otherst that diets twenty in calories, century.3 and and of children Negro there pica percentage ‘ the women with the reported problem Lanzkowsky in comparable This serious young than analyzing diets nineteenth among pica In inadequate the recently with Edwards involves PH.D.4 children is found in this country today.4 ‘benign’ pica is a common ‘ especially a More pica primarily the in iron. LAYMAN, II BA. that iron deficiency anemia more severe in twelve South women in M. EMMA DUBLIN, showed nificantly children. two die of malnutrition. was in it of M.D.,t C. deficient of by Thomson extremely often of male MILLICAN, CHRISTINA problem existence or cachectic victims of this the differentiated “Malignant” and M.D. a question understand recognize first K. AND FRANCES has been the nature of the this habit and malnutri- to to Supplement COHEN, pica, and fat 12, May pads, 1963 Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on September 9, 2014 is important types of interest between a Vitamin Pica muscle mass pica were of the and eighty weight children that in cent children of drinking protein intake The present controlled to test pie vitamin treatment tageous the which in the major- the as many as of the value without of this evaluated . iron nutrient and the D. C. during 196 1 . The cepted for Negro children (two chronic illness (including study velopment represented four whose METHODS AND method method and Roe psychiatrist poisoning) using the the the or and the M.) pica was during a taken and of unsuitable sucked, of More ingestion presence chewed of such pica and as in particles other rating was devised for 18 ITh)miths than once than Frequency a week once a week not but daily 2 One 3 Frequently to 4 stantly Practically 0 Not three times a day each day but 1 Ingests nonedibie substances vorites are available 2 Seeks 3 stances Unselective stances all the not con- timiie out certain in eating 0 Stops when 1 Stops when nonedible foods nonedible other materials to Resistance told, food to Control does not reproved, resume resumes when reproved in a few minutes Stops when reproved immediately Does not stop 4 sub- unavailable in situation Stops 3 sub- are preferred when Prefers if fa- nonedible which 4 2 Intensity present but resumes but resumes Scores C. Duration Frequency Intensity D. Resistance ___________ factors intensity to thirty investigain workwas obof sucking, materials ingested the ; the stools; of the a scale of each child. Four 0 to possible was usually scored between constant over mained was demonstrated pica was rated in worker at several weeks later The medical on each complete for ova The maximal of weeks, series ten the cases, time by the first of a fact in by screening pica rewhich which the the medical and again psychiatrist.9 worker Further and physical urinalysis blood. total those with severe 10 to 14. The scores another social occult i). frequency, each rated a period family. history standard and 16 ; in social data history-duration, to control-were 4 (Table rating ; possible in the members from the pica and resistance pometry, pica of age) of family. A 1 ,,zonths months than Total for by twenty with pica. Information the onset and duration the Less cyan- obtained patients concerning ingestion Rating nionths de- level titration interview with the mother. This seven years of previous experience substances proof and K. of 18 Pica Coleman-Junior fasting plasma colorimetric Kuether,’#{176} were history (F. chewing 0 on detailed tamed More PROCEDURE with and of child. with 4 without growth concentration, using minute tor had 7-12 13-18 A. B. normal. spectrophotometer, ascorbic acid, A 2 3 D. series old) lead (after Obtain to 3 months of Washington, years chronic been methemoglobin ing the research of Children’s a consecutive to hemoglobin each to from May 1960 to March screened by the medical deficiency, had of been (C. C. D.) during a preliminary intermother. The twenty-four patients ac- mental The already clinics period were Duration . Less than 3-6 months C. therapeutic had Order as MATERIAL well-baby the cases view obvious the in pica worker with the social contained elements with pica were referred the Outpatient Department Hospital available which trace since 4 0 1 . CLINICAL Children team from one and I in B. multi- in the advan- readily as Pica Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on September 9, 2014 but well vitamins Scoring undertaken of a standard a preparation market, possible, was of C., fact and mineral preparation of pica. It was considered to study on study efficacy 389 at of cases. in order Supplement TABLE adequate a Mineral 1’detliocl records D. milk, and with the nutritionally were of sufficient Vitamin Washington, amounts indicated of studied 83 per excessive with A review Hospital showed ity body adequate.9 Children’s or Treated secured work-up socioeconomic included examination, anthroand stool examination a Gutelius 39() General et TABLE II on Twenty-Four Information Case ernoglobmn (gm./100 ml.) (mo.) and Sex Children with Pica Pica i-I Age al. Ascorbic Blood Acid Level (mg./l Substances Duration ml.) (mo.) I 27,F 10. 7 0.55 2 3 30,M 42,F 12 . 6 10 . 4 4 5 36,M 39,M 6 31,F 7 31,M 11 .6 11 .9 9 .9 9.9 0 . 75 0 . 50 1 . 05 0 . 48 S 23,F 7.9 (per wk.) 18 20 3-6 1-2 35 26 1-2 35 + Dirt, starch Crayons, ashes Plaster, Paster, Constant 0.50 27 22 22 35+ 35+ Plaster, Paper, Paper, 0.92 15 7-21 Plaster, . . . Ingested Frequency dirt paper, dirt dirt, starch dirt, ashes matches, paper, cigarettes dirt, starch, matches, ashes 9 1 1 .3 24,F 23,M 31,M 10.4 12 . 3 18 0.83 0 . 60 Plaster, 35 + 10 13 paint, 35+ 3-6 Paper, dirt, rettes, Plaster, 40,F 37,M 8.8 14 15 17 27,F 33,M 29,F 46,F 12.0 12 .3 9.9 10. 1 0.31 0. 15 0.40 39 35+ 18 36,F 8. 1 1 .36 29 Constant Plaster, dirt, 19 2(1 27,M 25,F 7.0 11 .3 1 .05 1 . 60 16 19 7-21 21 + Plaster, Paper, paper, erasers 21 24,F 9.9 1 .00 16 35 Plaster, 16 24,M 22 3 1 . 00 3 1 0.90 25 35+ Paper, crayons, 15 26 22 7-21 7-21 Constant Paint, Plaster, Plaster, Plaster, paper, paper, paper, paper, . 10.9 . . . . Constant 15 . crayons, chalk, string stones, string dirt starch dirt, starch ashes dirt paper, dirt, starch, matches, cigarettes Plaster, paper, paint, 35+ ciga- pencils, sticks paint, dirt, “anything” 13 . cigarettes, soap matches, 12 12 paper, stones, sticks Dirt, matches, chalk, dirt, matches, cigarettes 23 24 27,M 10.9 0. 77 15 27,M 10.0 0.40 15 Meami 30.8 10.52 The multiple vitamin chosen for the This foil-wrapped sidered and handle. tamed all the usual A, 5,00() units; B,, B6, 1 (1 mg. thenol, 0.1 5.0 mg.; 2.5 ; and the vitamin mg. ; 75 rug. ; vitamin vitamin I3, 125.0 ; fluorine, 0.1 Mg.; mg. = 20.0 rutin, 0.1 mg. 0.2 ; iodine, 1.0 mg. ; con- groups group U.S.P. one 2 acid, calcium Supplied by White Laboratories, Inc. 2. 5 ing. unusually out a table received each by the The high. code order preparations 0.1 assigned to 1.0 visited the the number left were random were taken, area the of in seven more two The first group were for the mother the a slip nurse Washington which for into known to one investigator on the regularity with home once a week. of chocolate pieces she gave used preparation, second Preparations Association the were vitamin con- identi- divided The daily. C numbers. and a meal. number to check vitamin Placebos,* in taste, mineral with placebo Nurse week of the day one In and * was Visiting ; magnesium, molybdenum, l)Otassitim, using ceived lU.; mg. ; vitamin 3.0 g. ; panmg.; paper paper cal in appearance and similar the control children. The twenty-four patients : vita- mg. ; cobalt, mg. in and (75 mg.) 1,000 mg. ; folic 12.0 to used E, B2, 2.5 easy ; tent of iron vitamin tug. ; boron, :3.0 Ing. ; manganese, D, activity ing. ; nicotinamnide, 30.0 minerals exception units; C, biotin, carbonate, tug. with U.S.P. vitamin vitamin preparation to children and study Delectavites vitamins PreParatiOns mm mineral Plaster, Plaster, 21.2 treatment of pica was Delectavites#{174}* preparation of chocolate was con- generally acceptable At the time of such 0.738 21 + 21+ the following of paper only. which from the who was patient She made remaining, regiven lived a note of if any, week. on which Each she Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on September 9, 2014 10 11 0 . 38 Pica was the to check the days preparation. The available significant rise (Cases 7 and of in plasma levels not The patient the like time levels the three patients took the These children prescribed 7 and but were the ascorbic for to thirteen levels of months status of ascorbic after pica acid the was determined blood not I)ifferences at the are pr ) the deter- (1.05). In test was testing used for difTerence sltmare the also statistically for Yates significant confidence or better (P the two-tailed and scores. number checked vith test of for significance measurements l)etween was series as level of cures for 1.05 5 0.48 l)atiellts hemoglobin in the order of acid, pica per gested. week There were the 9 8 0.00 1.00 8 10 chi- 1.0.) 10 12 Mean 0.701 Patient * ple 9.1 unable of and III. hemoglobin level was range 7.0 from of months one paper The the pica ratings both seven weeks later, for the twelve 0.738 mg. to an than children 1.60 a year levels treatment at end who a received of was found 0 0 ± 1.5(1 9 2+ improve(I 1.02 7 2+ 1.45 170 2 . 30 1 . 80 0 0 2+ 0 9 8 ± improved ± improved 1.549 5.2 history pica obtained from The there all but ascorbic initially and treatment, multi- six ml. given is for the pica rating is also twelve given and in (P decreased were about the in rise < 1)001). from 9. 1 to as being iml)roved and same. children rise mg. This reported nsarkedly in the was I .549 of treatment. significant three no initially, end highly twelve was who the served mean as controls blood level acid, which was 0.779 mg. per and (1.744 mg. per 100 ml. at improved and five remained oi 10(1 nil. the of the treatment period. The mean pica decreased from 10.2 to 4.4. Six children reported as being without pica, one was edly and pica placebos children In the 21.2 acid are on information to be pica, of by lOt) at the remained 100 and the 7 0 7 check received per without five frequency. before the mg. matches of ascorbic 1(h) ml. Four followed starch, mg. per mean ingested popular, 0.701 5.2. per in relapse mean blood level of ascorbic acid children who received treatment The plasma substances relapse (mild) 1+ preparation final same who with with average of decreasing to ml. was most blood 10() mean laundry in order fasting per 0 after Iv. mean girls The Of the of in- The gm. for more 10). the dirt, cigarettes for frequency twelve (1.13 present (Case was plaster, from been and case 10.52 acid a range had and months. 12.6 ascorbic with pica to boys 1+ 0 1.00 1.50 1 . 80 but mineral A The The twelve sex, level substances 30.8 return to vitamin Table Table age, of pica, 1.80 ii 11 . . . 0.31 0.-to in blood unsuitable twelve age ml. giving 10 13 each the twenty-four fasting duration and average level study 0 * Pici mother. continuity. of 1.17 of to Months Treatment Pica Rating 5 0.92 0.38 patients series concentration, of ascorbic an shows Status - 10 0.77 t RESULTS ii Treatment Ascorbic Acid (mg./I00 ml.) 9 recorded. Table Ratings < The in by significance correction After 23 24 PROCEDURES reported cent 0.75 4 9 11 12 14 15 19 aimed. STATISTICAL 2 8 but were Pica (mild) of treat- investigated the in of re-evaluation, period amid Acid ----.- Pica Rating (mg./100 ml.) adequate At the end so that the be a final III Ascorbic about end rating were markthe same. Thus, there were at were apparently the seven end of the children cured treatment in each or much period, group improved who and Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on September 9, 2014 the could At of Treatment Acid a period 391 Ascorbic Case placebos. daily acid re-evaluated. Levels Before preparation receiving given Blood (Cases took were Supplement for Twelve Childremi with Pica Before and After Six to Seven Weeks of Treatmuemit with Multiple Vitamin ami(l Mineral Preparation, and Final Status of Pica C in the vitamin exceptions ; both of pica ment, Mineral TABLE two candy preparations blood and took with six to seven weeks, which was considered to saturate body stores with vitamin C.” of this timne the Patients were seen again and Vitamin a statistically of that, regularly. the the including indicated 22), preparations most which evidence, patients, did on with Fasting treated 22) Treated 392 Gutelius TABLE Fasting Blood Levels iv of Ascorbic for Twelve Children with Seven Weeks of Placebos Acid Pica Pica Before and and Daily, and Final Given Ratings After Six to Treatment Acid (mg/lOt) ml.) : io Treatment 0.55 8 0.50 12 0.45 9 0.48 ... group. 1.00 0 ± improved 2+ 0 0.00 0.90 1.20 It; 0_is 13 0.51 3+ i7 18 0.40 11 0.4:3 1.36 10 0 1+ relapse Lost * to but group, significant. Among provement ascorbic in acid than in initially. the the difference treated those whose were low initially those whose blood and eleven and five in each three and control three in improvement. control after apparent are summarized Delectavites placebos pica. in children, blood was not im- levels of no greater were high the large treated results series pica there children. Four of the forlatter were without pica, were markedly improved, each group showed treated little children or and was above children in distributrue for all that mineral for than neither The though pica, cause per at the remission. 10(1 ml., end of other improving the habit number of cures observed and control children can none ; of of them one had indicates that be associated conditions groups TABLE no yet study socioeconomic of Pica Treatment in five Delectavites a even with important dietary for six or seven weeks offers Both pica and poor nutrition from lowest than these prove to be given alone. Table II shows is not in itself an At least a standard given cure. result in the might one present experiment poor nutrition may it probably of pica. supplement concentration who received 12 gm. was cured temporary Supplement exist Negro V with and which of the a Vitamnin Summary and of Mimieral Results one relapses two to six months cures. The results of treatment in Table v. It is clear that proved no more effective than or con- more successfully a possibility that had curing to such it is not of preschool and any is that the hemoglobin the twelve children may . - I ype Preparation of No. Patients of COMMENTS The a large a vitamin supplement no specific took place three treatment period, treated patients the group of Two child was levels The final interview, which to thirteen months after the was completed for twelve mer final medications given together more effective than either This seems most improbable. 0.744 study. treated nor can cure placebos, 2+ five who did not improve. The pica ratings suggested that the improvement in the untreated group was somewhat greater than in the the pica no difference was found by sex,9’2 and this fact holds iron9 0 0 0.75 10.2 continued given improved 10 0.779 that support those of the other sex. Since it has been demonstrated 0.30 Mean shown age groups.5 Thus, there is no tendency children of one sex to be cured more easily 1+ 1 .50 In with tion improved 7 7 been nondirective .:.t or End reatment of 3-13 Months Months after Treatment % No. NoH Medication Placebo in both be ex- of Cured * One 12 12 lost to study. 7 7 58 58 Much Improved 9 8 % 75 73* Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on September 9, 2014 13 10 i2 . - . has of spontaneous with increasing sidered of any importance that eight boys and four girls were assigned by chance to the treated 0.50 0.83 0.90 1.60 1.00 also and of the pica.9 In evaluating 13 20 21 22 It the result takes place families are factors in curing children with pica even when no advice is given on management Ascorbic Acid (mg./100 ml.) Pica Rating plained partly as improvement which interest After Ascorbic Case al. age.5 Status of Pica Before et Pica race in which these pica is most conditions other lack home is may the acceptable logic problems are conimon than In poor present with the ernment one living pica of for two confined children other twelve turbed parents, family mother to cope home. Thus support to pica involves tural and their 3. Africana or the Negro 146, 1844-5. 4. GARDNER, J. genographic in children. 5. MILLICAN, F. families on public TAKAHASHI, working lence of substances or clay series had during the preg- habit was families of pica. quarrels or her with of numerous environmental, mm and of 75 etiology of six to twelve seven At much acid not pica end in rose three treatment each group Treatment to the treatment were The with preparation or improving the only habit no seven 12. 13. group after three to have 7 : 59, more effective of pica than but on the end children of in pica. and mm- in curing placebos. Orleans of dirt eating in M. S. 1: & J., TEVETOGLU, and mouthing children. Clin. of Proc. nonedible Child. Ilosp., FORD, N. R. school Geophagy children. among An,. Sociol. LANZKOWSKY, acid in whole 147:399, blood and urine. J. Biol. 1943. R. W. Ascorbic acid. In: The Vitamins, 1, sec. 10, chapt. 2, p. 378. Edited by Sebrell, \v. H. and Harris, R. S. New York, 1954. Academic Press Inc. COOPER, M. Pica, p. 62. Springfield, Ill., 1957. Charles C Thomas. WILLIAMS, H. , KAPLAN, E. , COUCHMAN, C. E. and SAYERS, R. R. Lead poisoning in children. VILTER, 14. Health Rep., R. and MELLIN5, logical check frequent vitamin cacliexia on effects F. Time roentof geophagia (dirt-eating) J. Pediat., 51 : 667, 1957. K. , LAYMAN, E. M. , LOURIE, R. S., L. and DUBLIN, C. C. Time preva- D. and DICKENS, Pub. or of ascorbic a final months a multiple was period treated At reported served children. vol. of who level in the period, group symptom-free plasma group. thirteen were a period 11. daily. group control which for pica, placebos significantly the the eral of each daily, acid, with given improved. in vita- A comparable children were the children of ascorbic weeks. Negro as controls, Negro New E. and diagnosis in 1962. Chem., twelve 1957. P. Investigation into the aetiology and treatment of pica. Arch. Dis. Childhood, 34: 140, 1959. 8. EDWARDS, C. H., MCDONALD, S. , MITCHELL, J. T., JONES, L. , KEMP, A. M. , LAING, D. and TRIGG, L. Clay and cornstarch-eating women. J. Ant. Dietet. A., 35: 810, 1959. 9. GUTELIUS, M. F. , MILLICAN, F. K., LAYMAN, E. M., COHEN, G. J. and DUBLIN, C. C. Nutritional studies of children with pica. I’ediatrics, 29: 1012, 1962. 10. ROE, J. H. and KUETHER, C. A. Determination of 7. cul- a multiple preparation mg. race. by ascorbic given Observations and 1942. adds the experiment mineral contained - 3: 81, 1895. M. Rev., 9 were en Ill., dirt-eating or hal)it had the pica the Negro in the experiment that pica with problem. Springfield, \V. Mississippi disof the inability present 6. 5. Rep., not At least responsibilities hypothesis a double-blind psychologic p. ingestion 18:207, SUMMARY Iii CARPENTER, with in the On Hosp. three psychologic children J. THOMSON, benefits, a history the in accord is a complicated and Pica, more 16 were obviously seriously problems as separation the are pica C Thomas. Edinburgh included Fourteen with 2. in gov- six M. COOPER, families of them with families by such homes The pregnancy. that cultural Charles extremely incomes starch in many to four mothers laundry and and was projects. 1. groups. housing Seventeen nancy, pica significantly satisfactory and mothers. with be exception experiment findings REFERENCES Psycho- control on disability assistance vironmental, culturally group.5 to series most in of this 393 in children. 15. 16. 67: B. and 230, 1952. C. D. JENKINS, psychological study J.A.JII.A., of lead Epidemiopoisomsing 158: 15, 1955. MILLIcAN, F. K., LouIE, R. S. and LAYMAN, E. M. Emotional factors in the etiology and treatment of lead poisoning. Aiti. J. Dis. Child., 91 : 144, 1956. LOURIE, R. S. , LAYMAN, E. M., MILLICAN, F. K., SOKOLOFF, B. and TAKAHASHI, L. A study of the etiology of i)iCa in young children. In : Problems by of Hoch, Grune Addiction R. H. & Stratton, and amid Zubin, Inc. Habituation, J. New p. York, 74. 1958. Downloaded from ajcn.nutrition.org by guest on September 9, 2014 the live of pica. often population housing with previous dangers is in comparable the in inadequate. of the thought Results of Supplement Super- in children families Mineral out usually frequently habit in this and Some play be ignorant Furthermore, Vitamin pointed children which at Parents been These areas vision with prevalent.5 have studies.9 slum Treated