ASHRAE TC/TG/TRG MINUTES COVER SHEET

ASHRAE
American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers Inc.
1791 Tullie Circle, NE • Atlanta, Georgia 30329-2305
404-636-8400 • Fax 404-321-5478
TC/TG/TRG MINUTES COVER SHEET
(Minutes of all TC/TG/TRG Meetings are to be distributed to all persons listed below within 60 days following the meeting.)
TC/TG/TRG NO.:
TC 9.01
ISSUE DATE:
TC/TG/TRG TITLE:
Large Building Air-Conditioning Systems
DATE OF MEETING:
January 30, 2007
MEMBERS PRESENT
TERM END
Members:
Dennis J Wessel, Chair
Phillip M Trafton, VC
Stephen W Duda, Sec
Howard J McKew
Mark W Fly
Charles E Henck
Gene R Strehlow
Lynn F Werman
Hollace S Bailey
Harvey Brickman
Kelley P Cramm
K Quinn Hart
William K Klock
John L Kuempel Jr
Rodney H Lewis
John I Vucci
John E Wolfert
June 30 of
2007
2009
2007
2009
2009
2009
2009
2007
2009
2007
2010
2009
2009
2009
2010
2010
2007
March 21, 2007
LOCATION: Dallas, TX
MEMBERS ABSENT
Members:
Warren G Hahn
TERM END
June 30 of
2009
International Members:
Branko M Markovic
ADDITIONAL ATTENDANCE
Corresponding Members:
Charles G Arnold
Ken E Gill
Alonzo B Blalock
James E Harrison
Jeff J Traylor
Liaisons / Staff / Ex-Officio Members:
Sriram Somasundaram (RAC)
Julian R DeBullet (EDUC)
Guests:
Amanda McKew
Sarah Maston
R. Lee Millies, Jr.
Paul Pieper
Jay Eldridge
Doug Cochrane
International Members:
none present
DISTRIBUTION
ALL MEMBERS OF TC/TG/TRG
TAC COMMITTEE CHAIR: Patricia Thomas Graef
TAC SECTION HEAD: Matt R Hargan
LIAISONS:
Program: David W Reid
Special Pubs: Kimball E Ferguson
Handbook: Walter T Grondzik
RAC: Piotr A Domanski
Professional Development: Gordon Holness
Staff Liaison/Research/Technical Services: Michael R Vaughn
Staff Liaison (Standards): Claire B Ramspeck
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
1
ASHRAE TC/TG/TRG ACTIVITIES SHEET
ISSUE DATE: March 21, 2007
TC/TG/TRG NO.:
T.C. 9.01
CHAIR: Dennis Wessel
TC/TG/TRG TITLE: Large Building Air-Conditioning Systems
VICE-CHAIR: Phil Trafton
SECRETARY: Steve Duda
TC/TG/TRG MEETING SCHEDULE
Location - Past 48 Months
Date
Kansas City, MO
Anaheim, CA
Nashville, TN
Orlando, FL
Denver, CO
Chicago, IL
Quebec, PQ (Canada)
Dallas, TX
Location - Planned Next 24 Months
7.01.2003
1.27.2004
6.29.2004
2.08.2005
6.28.2005
1.24.2006
6.27.2006
1.30.2007
Date
Long Beach, CA
New York, NY
Salt Lake City, UT
Chicago, IL
6.26.2007
1.22.2008
6.24.2008
1.27.2009
TC/TG/TRG SUBCOMMITTEES
Function
Subcommittee Chair
ALI Coordinator
Handbook
Honors and Awards
Journal / Insights
Membership
Program
Research
Standards
Standards Issues
Webmaster
Gene Strehlow & Bryan Sherman
Howard McKew
Rodney Lewis
Warren Hahn
Lynn Werman
Chuck Arnold
Ken Gill
Charlie Henck
Phil Trafton
Mark Fly
RESEARCH PROJECTS – CURRENT
Project Title
Contractor
Monitoring Comm. Chairperson
Design Guide for HVAC Systems
W. Gronzik
W. Hahn
W/S Written
Approved
Report Made At Mtg.
Yes, Completed
LONG RANGE RESEARCH PLAN
Rank
1.
Title
Ventilation Requirements for
Refrigerating Machinery Rooms
No
To RAC
RTAR voted by TC 9.01 to be
submitted to RAC (2005 Annual)
Yes, approved
HANDBOOK RESPONSIBILITIES
Year & Volume
Chapter Title
Chapter No
Deadline
Lead Reviser
2008 Systems & Equip
HVAC System Analysis and Selection
1
01.2007
Howard McKew
2008 Systems & Equip
Decentralized Cooling and Heating
2 (old 5)
01.2007
Amanda McKew
2008 Systems & Equip
Centralized Cooling and Heating
3 (old 4)
01.2007
John Vucci
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
2
2008 Systems & Equip
Air-Handing and Distribution
4 (old 2)
01.2007
Steve Duda
2008 Systems & Equip
In-Room Units and Distribution
5 (old 3)
01.2007
Sarah Marston
STANDARDS ACTIVITIES - List and Describe Subjects
STD 15-2004 Safety Standard for Refrigeration Systems – Continuous Maintenance, Cognizant TC is 9.01, Steve Duda is liaison.
Guideline 0-2005 The Commissioning Process – TC 9.01 is co-cognizant.
Guideline 16-2003 Selecting Outdoor, Return, and Relief Dampers for Air-Side Economizer Systems – Cognizant TC is 9.01.
TECHNICAL PAPERS from Sponsored Research – Title, when presented (past 3 yrs. present & planned)
1.
Not tracked.
TC/TG SPONSORED TRANSACTION SESSIONS – Title, when presented (past 3 yrs. present & planned) & Chair
1.
FUTURE: Transaction Session discussing GPC 22 results (target for Chicago 2009) / no details.
TC SPONSORED SEMINARS – Title, when presented (past 3 years, present, & planned) & Chair; Speaker, Speaker, Speaker
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Adaptive Reuse of Existing Buildings (2004 Annual – Nashville) / Hahn; Duda, Trafton, Kuempel, Lewis
Measures to Improve the Efficiency of Chilled Wtr Plants (2004 Annual) / Arnold; Avery, W. Dietrich, C. Miller, Traylor
Chiller-Tower Interactions During Operation (2005 Winter – Orlando) / Arnold; P. Lindahl, F. Morrison, M. Schwedler
Economizers, Air and Water: Case Studies (2005 Annual – Denver) / Hahn; McKew, Avery, Wolfert, Kuempel
Chilled Water Systems: Lessons Learned (2006 Winter – Chicago) / Traylor; Duda, McKew, Kuempel
Back-to-Basics: HVAC System Selection (2006 Annual – Quebec) / Wessel; Duda, McKew, Kuempel
Case Studies in Humidity Control Pt. 1 / (2007 Winter – Dallas) / Trafton; Gill, Duda, Kuempel
Case Studies in Humidity Control Pt. 2 / (2007 Winter – Dallas) / E Sterling; S Brown, J Murphy, Lewis
PROPOSED: Case Studies in Retrofit of Existing Systems (Long Beach) / Arnold; Cramm, Lewis, Traylor, Kuempel, Hart.
PROPOSED: Lessons Learned – Underfloor Air (New York City) / Brickman; TBA.
PROPOSED: Introducing the New HVAC Systems Design Guide (New York City) / Hahn; TBA.
PROPOSED: HVAC Case Studies for Extreme Climates (New York City) / Wessel; W. Lawton, M. Lentz, Gill.
PROPOSED: Introduction to 2008 Handbook (Salt Lake City) / no details.
FUTURE: Water-side Economizer Systems / no details
TC/TG SPONSORED FORUMS - Title, when presented (past 3 years, present, & planned) & Moderator
1.
Does ASHRAE Need a Guideline for Extreme Climates? (2005 Annual – Denver) / D. Wessel
JOURNAL PUBLICATIONS, when published (past 3 years, present, & planned) & Author
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Atria Smoke Exhaust: 3 Approaches to Replacement Air Delivery (2004-06) / S. Duda
How to Start a Consulting Engineering Business (2004-07) / W. Hahn
Energy and Money Savings Without Increasing Time, Costs (2004-09) / S. Hayter
Simplifying Contemporary HVAC Piping (2005-02) / J. Rishel
Selecting Valves for Variable Flow Hydronic Systems (2005-09) / G. Avery
Chilled Water System for University Campus (2006-05) / S. Duda
Respectfully submitted by:
Stephen W. Duda, Secretary
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
3
ASHRAE
American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers Inc.
1791 Tullie Circle, NE • Atlanta, Georgia 30329-2305
404-636-8400 • Fax 404-321-5478
TC 9.01 Large Building Air-Conditioning Systems
Meeting Minutes
Meeting Date: January 30, 2007
Dallas, TX
I.
Call to Order
a) Chairman Wessel called the meeting to order at 1:05 PM local time.
II.
Introduction of Members And Guests
a) Self-introductions of members and guests were made around the table as the attendance roster was circulated.
Chairman Wessel welcomed all members and visitors. A quorum was verified.
Voting Members:
International Members:
Corresponding Members:
Society Liaisons:
Staff Liaisons:
Guests:
17 Present, 1 Absent, Quorum achieved.
0 Present
5 Present
2 Present
0 Present
6 Present
Note: International members are voting members if present, but do not count against quorum if absent.
III.
Approval of Quebec City June 27, 2006 Meeting Minutes
a) Minutes distributed. S. Duda offered a Motion to approve the Quebec City June 27, 2006 Meeting Minutes as
written. H. Brickman offered a Second. No discussion nor corrections. Motion carried (15-0-0-3).
Secretary’s Note: All votes recorded herein are formatted as (Aye-Nay-Abstain-Absent).
IV.
Agenda Comments / Updates (D. Wessel)
a) An updated agenda was handed out at the meeting.
V.
Chairman’s Comments and Section 9 Report (D. Wessel)
a) D. Wessel summarized the key items from Sunday’s TC Chair’s breakfast as follows:
b) A new registration policy for speakers and session chairs was announced. Transaction paper presenters will
continue to receive full complimentary registration at the applicable Winter or Annual Meeting. Seminar speakers
will receive a one-day complimentary registration only. Seminar chairs will receive no complimentary
registration. P. Trafton offered a MOTION “TC 09.01 is strongly opposed to the revised registration policy for
seminar speakers/chairs and asks Chairman Wessel to write a letter to the Section 9 Chair advocating to revert to
the previous policy.” J. Vucci offered a Second. Motion carried (15-0-0-3). Post-meeting Secretary’s Note: The
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
4
Board subsequently voted to rescind this action and restore the previous policy of complimentary registration for
speakers and seminar chairs.
c) The overall program theme for Long Beach is Natural Ventilation; for New York City is Zero Energy Design.
d) Due to New York State PDH approval requirements, papers and seminars are requested 30-60 days in advance for
the New York City meeting (Winter 2008).
e) Handbook training for subcommittee chairs is offered every Winter Meeting.
f) Title, Purpose & Scope: D. Wessel will seek confirmation from TAC that our TPS has been officially adopted as
“TC 9.01 is concerned with the general design concepts of the HVAC Systems that are utilized for the
conditioning of large buildings, including the integration of components into centralized and decentralized
systems.”
VI.
Rollover Roster (D. Wessel)
a) K. Cramm will become new Secretary effective 7.01.2007.
b) S. Duda will become new Vice-Chair effective 7.01.2007.
c) P. Trafton will become new Chair effective 7.01.2007.
d) J. Traylor will become new Handbook subcommittee chair effective 7.01.2007.
e) D. Wessel will become liaison to TC 6.01 effective 7.01.2007.
f) C. Lawson has been nominated to become Research subcommittee chair effective 7.01.2007 subject to his
acceptance. Post-meeting Chairman’s Note: Subsequent to the meeting, Lawson advised that he will be unable to
fill the position of research Chair. Bill Klock has agreed to fill this position.
g) Voting Members Rolling On, effective 7.01.2007: Ken Gill, Chuck Arnold, Jeff Traylor.
VII.
Status of Chilled Water Plant Subcommittee (D. Wessel)
a) TC 6.01 will re-establish this subcommittee and assign a chair. TC 9.01 is encouraged to recruit members as well.
We will drop this subcommittee from our future schedule of meetings.
VIII.
Society Liaison Reports
a) Research: Sriram Somasundaram introduced himself as the current RAC liaison.
b) No other Society Liaisons present.
IX.
TC 9.01 Subcommittee Reports
a) Membership (L. Werman): Rollover roster discussed per Item VI above.
b) Chilled Water Plants (C. Arnold): See Item VII above.
c) Handbook (H. McKew):
•
Thanks were expressed to the Chapter revisers: S. Duda, H. McKew, A. McKew, S. Maston, J. Vucci.
•
McKew has reviewed all 5 Chapters for sustainability, maintenance, commissioning, operations, rules of
thumb, and homeland security prior to this meeting.
•
McKew had issued all 5 Chapters to the full TC membership in advance of this meeting.
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
5
•
McKew will discuss with Walt Grodnik: Move fan-coil manufacturer design criteria (but not the system
discussion) from our Chapters.
•
Discussed handling of CAD files on CD version of the Handbook.
•
Brickman initiated discussion on a better index in the Handbook and a solicitation of ideas on how to
make the handbook more user-friendly.
•
M. Fly offered a Motion to approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 1 as
distributed by H. McKew; with the unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook
Subcommittee / Strehlow offered a Second. No discussion nor amendments. Motion carried (17-0-0-1).
•
J. Kuempel offered a Motion to approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 2 as
distributed by H. McKew; with the unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook
Subcommittee / R. Lewis offered a Second. No discussion nor amendments. Motion carried (17-0-0-1).
•
H. Brickman offered a Motion to approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 3 as
distributed by H. McKew; with the unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook
Subcommittee / M. Fly offered a Second. No discussion nor amendments. Motion carried (17-0-0-1).
•
P. Trafton offered a Motion to approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 4 as
distributed by H. McKew; with the unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook
Subcommittee / K. Cramm offered a Second. No discussion nor amendments. Motion carried (17-0-0-1).
•
G. Strehlow offered a Motion to approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 5 as
distributed by H. McKew; with the unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook
Subcommittee / C. Henck offered a Second. No discussion nor amendments. Motion carried (17-0-0-1).
d) Standards (C. Henck):
•
Standard 79-2002 (RA 2006) – Method of Testing for Rating Fan-Coil Conditioners is in the process of
having an error corrected.
•
Guideline 16-2003 – Selecting Outdoor, Return, and Relief Dampers for Air-Side Economizer Systems is
due to be re-affirmed; and a Call for Members of GPC 16 is being issued.
e) Research (K. Gill):
•
RAC reviewed our RTAR concerning Chiller Room Ventilation research has been approved and has been
assigned the number RTAR-1448. Steve Taylor is writing the work statement. S. Duda and J. Vucci will
be part of the monitoring subcommittee.
•
This TC is cosponsoring (with TC 9.02) further research on 1395TRP (Design Guide for Heat Losses
from Electrical Equipment). Second phase is just getting started; D. Wessel will update us as required.
•
Submitted by W. Hahn via e-mail: Air Conditioning Systems Design Manual 2nd Edition was completed by
author Walter Grondzik. Final review and approval was received from the subcommittee membership
after some debate regarding Appendix E, Dehumidification Technologies. TC 09.01 membership voted
via e—mail to approve for publication, and an approval letter was sent to Micki Geshweiler of ASHRAE
Publications. See Attachment D.
f) Program (C. Arnold): Future proposed programs:
•
For Long Beach: Retrofit of Existing Systems Chaired by C. Arnold; potential speakers K. Cramm, R.
Lewis, J. Traylor, J. Kuempel, Q. Hart. Alternate if somebody drops out is S. Duda. Priority #1.
•
For New York City: Brickman promotes underfloor air programs for New York and will chair – has 3
NYC speakers. He will seek cosponsor from TC 9.08. Priority #1.
•
For New York City: Introducing the New HVAC Systems Design Guide Chaired by W. Hahn (Traylor is
backup); speakers to be announced. Suggest it as being appropriate for the AHR Expo location. Priority
#2.
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
6
•
For New York City: HVAC Case Studies for Extreme Climates Chaired by D. Wessel; potential speakers
are Wayne Lawton and Mark Lentz. Priority #3.
•
For Salt Lake City: Handbook Introduction Seminar, introducing new changes to the 2008 Handbook,
timed to coincide with its release to members.
•
Forward planning: Transaction Session on GPC 22 results down the road.
g) ALI (G. Strehlow): 4 courses offered at this meeting. DeBullet solicits ideas for what courses are needed, and
submit to PDC.
h) Honors & Awards (R. Lewis): S. Duda is championing H. McKew for submission as Fellow, and submitted all
paperwork as required prior to December 1, 2006. W. Hahn is being championed for Fellow via his Chapter. R.
Lewis reminded the group about their potential eligibility for the Distinguished Service Award (DSA).
i)
Journal / Insights (W. Hahn): W. Hahn absent but submitted a report via e-mail: He submitted one article to
Insights which was accepted and edited by Tony Giometti but was not published. See Attachment E.
j)
Members Petition Drafting Ad-Hoc (R. Lewis): No meeting was held and there is no intent to meet in the future.
k) Standards Issues (R. Lewis): R. Lewis provided the following Report from the Standards Issues Subcommittee
Meeting held Monday at 4:30 pm:
l)
X.
•
Attendees were Rodney Lewis and Phil Trafton.
•
There is a proposed amendment to ASHRAE Standard 62.1 which may require outdoor air ventilation
24/7/365.
•
Forum was held on Standard 62.1 at this meeting, with about 70% of attendees in favor of it remaining a
ventilation Standard.
Webmaster Report (M. Fly): M. Fly solicits the TC 9.01-sponsored Seminar #1 powerpoint presentations to be emailed to him in *.pdf format for inclusion on the new website.
Sustainable Design Issues (D. Wessel)
a) No discussion.
XI.
TC/PC Liaison Reports
a) TC 1.04 – Control Theory & Application (H. McKew): No report.
b) TC 1.12 – Moisture Management in Buildings (C. Lawson) Holly Bailey reports Hot & Humid Climate Design
Guide is in progress.
c) TC 7.04 – Building Operation Dynamics (G. Strehlow): This TC is interested in research mostly applicable to
academics and basic theory.
d) TC 5.06 – Control of Fire & Smoke (R. Lewis): No Report.
e) TC 6.01 – Hydronic & Steam Heating Equipment & Systems (K. Cramm): No report, as TC 6.01’s meeting is
coincident with our meeting.
f) TC 7.07 – Testing & Balancing (R. Lewis): No Report.
g) TC 7.09 – Building Commissioning (J. Traylor): Commissioning is 2nd in ASHRAE’s line for Certification.
Guideline 0 is on continuous maintenance.
h) TC 9.06 – Health Care Facilities (D. Wessel): No Report.
i)
TC 9.08 – Large Building Air-Conditioning Applications (C. Lawson): Report given by K. Gill. They have
passed a resolution claiming they are cognizant for underfloor air.
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
7
j)
TC 9.10 – No report; their meeting is subsequent to this one.
k) TC 9.12 – Tall Buildings (L. Werman): Meets after our meeting.
l)
GPC 16 – Selecting Outdoor, Return, and Relief Dampers for Air-Side Economizer Systems (G. Avery): Absent;
no Report.
m) GPC 22 – Instrumentation for Monitoring Central Chilled Water Plant Efficiency (Arnold/Vucci): Public Review
Draft is coming out.
n) SSPC 62.1 – Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality (P. Trafton): Report given in Item IX (k) above.
o) SSPC 15 – Safety Standard for Refrigeration Systems (S. Duda): Met Sunday, January 28, 2007. Report follows.
•
Duda’s Change Proposal, to close a loophole under which a refrigerant relief device might otherwise be
permitted to discharge directly into a Refrigeration Machinery Room, has passed for Publication Public
Review.
p) TG.Aerospace – (D. Walkinshaw): Not present, no report.
XII.
Old Business
a) None.
XIII.
New Business
a) H. Brickman offered a MOTION stating “TC 09.01 shall be the cognizant technical committee for comfort
underfloor heating and air-conditioning systems, as it is included in the Handbook Chapters assigned to this
committee.” P. Trafton offered a Second. No discussion nor amendments. Motion carried (14-0-0-4). Chair
submitted this in letter format to TAC Section 9 Chair before the end of the day.
XIV.
Adjournment
a) Next Meeting: Tuesday, June 26, 2007 at 1:00 pm PDT in Long Beach, CA.
b) C. Henck offered a Motion to adjourn. P. Trafton offered a Second. Approved unanimously by Voice Vote.
Chairman Wessel declared the meeting adjourned at 3:03 pm local time.
Attachments:
A:
B:
C:
D:
E:
Summary of Motions
Summary of Action Items
TC 9.01 Scope Statement
October 30, 2006 Design Manual Approval Letter
Proposed (but never published) Insights Article re: Handbook
End of Minutes
Respectfully submitted by:
Stephen W. Duda, Secretary
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
8
ATTACHMENT “A”
SUMMARY OF MOTIONS:
Secretary’s Note: All votes recorded herein are formatted as Aye-Nay-Abstain-Absent. Chair voted unless noted
otherwise.
Motion:
Second:
Text:
S. Duda
H. Brickman
Approve the Quebec City June 27, 2006 Meeting Minutes as written.
Vote:
Motion Carried 15-0-0-3
Motion:
Second:
P. Trafton
J. Vucci
Text:
TC 09.01 is strongly opposed to the revised registration policy for seminar speakers/chairs and asks
Chairman Wessel to write a letter to the Section 9 Chair advocating to revert to the previous policy. Postmeeting Secretary’s Note: The Board subsequently voted to rescind this action and restore the previous
policy of complimentary registration for speakers and seminar chairs. Therefore, this item is moot.
Vote:
Motion Passed 15-0-0-3
Motion:
Second:
M. Fly
G. Strehlow
Text:
Approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 1 as distributed by H. McKew; with the
unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook Subcommittee.
Vote:
Motion Passed 17-0-0-1
Motion:
Second:
J. Kuempel
R. Lewis
Text:
Approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 2 as distributed by H. McKew; with the
unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook Subcommittee.
Vote:
Motion Passed 17-0-0-1
Motion:
Second:
H. Brickman
M. Fly
Text:
Vote:
Approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 3 as distributed by H. McKew; with the
unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook Subcommittee.
Motion Passed 17-0-0-1
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
9
Motion:
Second:
Text:
P. Trafton
K. Cramm
Approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 4 as distributed by H. McKew; with the
unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook Subcommittee.
Vote:
Motion Passed 17-0-0-1
Motion:
Second:
G. Strehlow
C. Henck
Text:
Approve the final draft of the 2008 Edition of Handbook Chapter 5 as distributed by H. McKew; with the
unanimous favorable recommendation of the Handbook Subcommittee.
Vote:
Motion Passed 17-0-0-1
Motion:
Second:
H. Brickman
P. Trafton
Text:
TC 09.01 shall be the cognizant technical committee for comfort underfloor heating and air-conditioning
systems, as it is included in the Handbook Chapters assigned to this committee.
Vote:
Motion Passed 14-0-0-4
Motion:
Second:
C. Henck
P. Trafton
Text:
Vote:
Adjournment.
Motion Passed unanimously by voice vote.
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
10
ATTACHMENT “B”
SUMMARY OF ACTION ITEMS:
Responsible Party: D. Wessel
Action: Contact TAC to confirm final acceptance of TC 9.01 Scope.
Due Date: Long Beach 2007 Annual Meeting.
Responsible Party: H. McKew
Action: McKew will discuss with Walt Grodnik: Move fan-coil manufacturer design criteria (but not the system
discussion) from our Chapters.
Due Date: April 1, 2007.
Responsible Party: C. Arnold
Action: Submit Retrofit of Existing Systems Parts 1 & 2 Seminar programs for Long Beach.
Due Date: February 9, 2007.
Responsible Party: S. Duda / J. Kuempel / K. Gill / R. Lewis
Action: Submit PowerPoint presentations (in *.pdf format) of Dallas Humidity Control Case Studies Seminar to
M. Fly for posting on the TC 9.01 website.
Due Date: As soon as possible.
Responsible Party: S. Duda / J. Vucci
Action: Monitor Steve Taylor’s progress in writing the work statement for research #1448 concerning Chiller
Room Ventilation.
Due Date: Long Beach 2007 Annual Meeting.
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
11
ATTACHMENT “C”
TC 9.01 Scope:
TC 9.1 is concerned with HVAC systems utilized for the conditioning of large buildings, including the integration of
components into centralized and decentralized systems.
NOTICE: These Draft Minutes have not been approved and are not the official, approved record until approved by this committee.
21-Mar-2007
12
ATTACHMENT “D”
ASHRAE
American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers Inc.
1791 Tullie Circle, NE • Atlanta, Georgia 30329-2305
404-636-8400 • Fax 404-321-5478
Reply To: Dennis J. Wessel, P.E.
Karpinski Engineering
3135 Euclid Avenue
Cleveland, Ohio 44115
(216) 391-3700
October 30, 2006
Ms.Micki Geshweiler
ASHRAE
1791 Tullie Circle NE
Atlanta, Ga. 30329-2305
Micki,
The updated Air Conditioning Design Manual is being or has been submitted by the author who
was retained for the purpose of updating that document, Walter Grondzick.
The technical Committee, TC-9.1 Large Building Air Conditioning Systems has voted on the
acceptance of this Manual update. The vote was on the following motion:
To approve the manuscript entitled Air Conditioning Design Manual Update and
Revision revised and submitted by the author, Walter Grondzik.
The final vote of the committee was (13,0,0)18 CNV. The Technical Committee has therefore
approved the research project being done by Walter to update the design manual.
Sincerely,
Dennis J. Wessel, PE
Chair
CC: Warren Hahn, TC-9.1
U:\SWD\Public\ASHRAE\TC 0901\Meetings\20061030 AC Design Review Manual Update Approval Letter.DOC
ATTACHMENT “E”
TC 9.1 Plans Updates to Systems and Equipment Handbook
By Warren Hahn, TC 9.1
Fellow ASHRAE
Technical Committee 9.1, Large Building Air-Conditioning Systems, participated in a May 2005
workshop to improve the 2008 Systems and Equipment volume of the ASHRAE Handbook. The
TC was represented by Howard McKew and also in attendance were the revisers of chapters 1
through 5 for which the TC is responsible.
TC 9.1’s planned updates to the 2008 Handbook included numerous electronic
enhancements for the 2005-2008 ASHRAE HandbookCD+ version. TC 9.1 agreed to include
electronic attachments in the 2005-2008 HandbookCD+ that users could link to as part of their
system analysis and selection process.
With a focus on assisting the users in determining the optimum system(s) for their
project, TC 9.1's revisers are providing the following planned revisions to the 2008 ASHRAE
Handbook:
Chapter 1 shall include a system "process" flow diagram. This diagram can be a user's
"roadmap" to assessing the project needs/goals, analyzing the possible systems for the job, and
through a numerical scorecard process, determining the optimum system for the job. The 20052008 HandbookCD+ will feature a "System Selection Matrix" that will analytically determine the
optimum system, leading to the user's recommendation and the generation of a report to support
the recommendation. A demonstration of how this application would work was presented at the
2006 ASHRAE Annual Meeting in Quebec City where TC 9.1 rolled out this back to basics
methodology in Seminar 1. It was presented by Steve Duda who gave an overview of Chapter 1
procedure using the Process Flow Diagram to analyze and select the optimum system. (This
presentation is included on the Seminar DVD for this meeting. Also, the seminar can be viewed
online. Visit the online ASHRAE bookstore for ordering information.)
U:\SWD\Public\ASHRAE\TC 0901\Meetings\070706ASHRAEInsightsArticleChp15McKew revGiometti tg.doc
Proposed Chapter 2 (currently Chapter 5 in the 2004 Handbook) is the Decentralized Cooling
and Heating chapter. This chapter/topic relocation is based on the natural progression from
chapter 1 to go to either decentralized or centralized cooling and heating system analysis and
selection. Based on the assumption that the majority of HVAC systems selected are
decentralized, it is being proposed that chapter 5 be moved to the chapter 2 spot. The 20052008 HandbookCD+ will include an electronic "System Selection Matrix" document enhanced
from the chapter 1 matrix and geared more specifically towards chapter 2. The TC 9.1’s Back to
Basics Seminar 1 at the Quebec City meeting featured John Kuempel providing an overview of
the proposed chapter 2 procedure using the Process Flow Diagram as the guide to analyzing and
selecting the optimum system along with a case study example using the System Selection
Matrix from an actual project.
Proposed Chapter 3 (currently Chapter 4 in the 2004 Handbook) will be Central Cooling and
Heating chapter. This chapter/topic proposed relocation is based on the same agreement by the
revisers that the natural progression from chapter 1 is to go to either decentralized or centralized
cooling and heating system analysis and selection. The chapter reviser, John Vucci, brings an
owner/operator point of view. In the May workshop, it was stressed that this chapter offer
guidelines for design engineers, builders and facility managers and that an experienced facility
manager could enhance this update. For the 2005-2008 HandbookCD+, there will also be an
electronic "System Selection Matrix" document enhanced from the chapter 1 matrix and geared
more specifically towards chapter 3.
Proposed Chapter 4 (currently Chapter 2 in the 2004 Handbook) will be Building Air Handling
and Distribution. This chapter update shall include discussion on UFAD (under floor air
displacement) system consideration along with other updated chapter material. The 2005-2008
HandbookCD+ will include an electronic "System Selection Matrix" document enhanced from the
chapter 1 matrix and geared more specifically towards chapter 4.
U:\SWD\Public\ASHRAE\TC 0901\Meetings\070706ASHRAEInsightsArticleChp15McKew revGiometti tg.doc
Proposed Chapter 5 (currently Chapter 3 in the 2004 Handbook) will be In-Room Terminal
Systems and Distribution. This chapter update shall include discussion on some of the latest
system considerations (i.e., radiant and valence cooling) system along with other updated chapter
material. The 2005-2008 HandbookCD+ will include an electronic "System Selection Matrix"
document enhanced from the chapter 1 matrix and geared more specifically towards chapter 5.
CAD drawings will replace all the current system flow diagrams in chapters 2 - 4. The
drawings are being produced by Kim McKew, a CAD operator at Richard D. Kimball, Inc. a
consulting engineering firm in Massachusetts and New Jersey. TC 9.1 decided that all the
drawings in these chapters should be updated and computerized and that the drawings should
show a consistency and quality with each of the flow diagrams presented. ASHRAE is currently
working on a means for users of the 2005-2008 HandbookCD+ to be able to get access to these
CAD files for their use in the system selection and reporting process.
In updating these five chapters, the revisers sought out less senior engineers (Sarah
Maston and Amanda McKew) for their professional prospective to improving these chapters
versus recruiting past revisers of these chapters. This approach was discussed at the May 2nd
Workshop as a way to get a "fresh look" at each chapter from those more apt to use the
Handbook on a regular basis.
In general, the revision of chapters 1-5 in the 2008 Handbook by TC 9.1 will have a more
consistent look, latest technology/system consideration, CAD documents, links to system
selection matrix files, and consideration towards LEED, commissioning, security, operation and
maintenance, value engineering and rules-of-thumb.
The workshop was attended by representatives from all the TCs responsible for updating
the 2008 ASHRAE Handbook and 2005-2008 HandbookCD+.
U:\SWD\Public\ASHRAE\TC 0901\Meetings\070706ASHRAEInsightsArticleChp15McKew revGiometti tg.doc