Document 6564041

Transcription

Document 6564041

PUBLIC VERSION
UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C.
In the Matter of
CERTAIN INTEGRATED CIRCUITS
AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING THE
SAME
ORDER NO. 17:
Inv. N0. 337-TA-920
GRANTING-IN-PART CORRECTED JOINT MOTION TO
TERMINATE INVESTIGATION
(October 15, 2014)
On September 29, 2014, Complainant Freescale Semiconductor, Inc. (“Freescale”) and
Respondents MediaTek Inc. and MediaTek USA Inc. (collectively “MediaTek”) filed a joint
motion to terminate this Investigation with prejudice based on a settlement agreement. (Motion
Docket No. 920-O22.) On October 3, 2014, the Moving Parties filed a motion for leave to file a
corrected joint motion to terminate this Investigation based on a settlement agreement. (Motion
Docket No. 920-023.) The Moving Parties submitted confidential and public version of the
corrected joint motions to terminate this Investigation with prejudice as attachments to their
motion for leave. The Moving Parties’ motion for leave is hereby GRANTED. The Moving
Parties’ corrected motion to terminate is addressed below and need not be refiled. Motion
Docket No. 920-O22 is hereby DENIED as moot.
In their corrected motion to terminate, the Moving Parties state that an agreement
between Freescalc and MediaTek resolves the dispute as to MediaTek and all non-MediaTek
Respondents. The Moving Parties thus request this Investigation be terminated in its entirety.
The Moving Parties aver that the non-MediaTek Respondents do not oppose the motion] On
1The non-MediaTek Respondents are; Acer Inc.; AmTRAN Technology Co. Ltd.; AmTRAN Logistics, Inc.;
ASUSTek Computer Inc.; ASUS Computer International; BLU Products, Inc.; Sharp Corporation; Sharp Electronics
PUBLIC VERSION
October 7, 2014, Commission Investigative Staff (“Staff”) filed a response to the Moving
Parties’ corrected motion to terminate stating it does not oppose terminating the agreement
without prejudice.
The Moving Parties request that the service of the confidential exhibits be limited to the
settling parties. The Moving Parties state that good cause exists for limiting the service because
the specific tenns of the settlement agreement are highly sensitive business infonnation with
respect to the non-MediaTek Respondents because they have business units that compete directly
with MediaTek. (Mem. at 2.) Staff avers that the Moving Parties have demonstrated good cause
for restricted service because of the highly sensitive nature of the redacted information and
because the non-MediaTek Respondents have business units that compete with MediaTek.
Having shown good cause, the request is GRANTED pursuant to 19 C.F.R. § 21O.21(b).
The Commission’s Rules provide that “[a]ny party may move at any time to terminate an
investigation in whole or in part as to any or all respondents on the basis of a settlement, a
licensing or other agreement, including an agreement to present the_matter for arbitration, or a
consent order, as provided in paragraphs (b), (c) and (d) of this section.” 19 C.F.R. §
2l0.21(a)(2). In the instant Investigation, the motion to tenninate is based on a Settlement
Agreement between Freescale Semiconductor, Ltd. (“the Freescale Party”) and MediaTek Inc.
(“the MediaTek Party”).
Confidential and public copies of the settlement agreement were provided, as required by
19 C.F.R. § 210.21(b)(1). The public settlement agreement is attached hereto as Exhibit A. The
Corporation; Sharp Electronics Manufacturing Company of America, Inc.; Sony Corporation; Sony Corporation of
America; Sony Electronics Inc.; Sony EMCS (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd; Toshiba America Information Systems, Inc.;
Toshiba Logistics America, Inc.; TPV Display Technology (Xiamen) Co., Ltd.; Trend Smart America, Ltd.; Trend
Smart Ce Mexico, S.r.l. de C.V.; VIZIO, Inc.; Best Buy Co., Inc.; Walmart Stores, Inc.; Amazoncom, Inc.; Lenovo
Group Ltd.; Lenovo (United States) Inc.; Yamaha Corporation (Japan); Yamaha Corporation of America; Newegg
Inc.; B & H Foto & Electronics Corp.; Costco VVholesaleCorporation; and Buy.com Inc. (d/b/a Rakuten.com
Shopping).
‘
2
PUBLIC VERSION
Moving Parties have also included a statement that “there are no other agreements, written or
oral, express or implied, between Freescale and MediaTek or between Freescale and any other
Respondent concerning the subject matter of this investigation” as required by Commission Rule
21O.2l(b). (Mem. at 2.)
l9 C.F.R. § 2lO.5O(b)(2)provides that in the case of a proposed termination by
settlement agreement, the parties may file statements regarding the impact of the proposed
termination on the public interest, and the administrative law judge may hear argument, although
no discovery may be compelled, with respect to issues relating solely to the public interest. In I
any initial determination terminating an investigation by settlement agreement or consent order,
the administrative law judge is directed to consider and make appropriate findings regarding the
effect of the proposed settlement on the public health and welfare, competitive conditions in the
United States economy, the production of like or directly competitive articles in the United
States, and United States consumers. 19 C.F.R. § 210.50(b)(2).
The Moving Parties state that “the termination of this investigation will not adversely
affect the public interest because it will not affect the public health and welfare, competitive
conditions in the U.S. economy, the production of like or directly competitive articles in the
United States, or U.S. consumers.” (Mem. at 2.) The Moving Parties further state that “it is in
the interest of the public and administrative economy to grant this Motion.” (Ia'.) Staff says that
it is unaware of any infonnation that indicates that partial termination would hann the public
interest and adds that the public interest favors settlement to avoid needless litigation and to
conserve public resources. Based on the foregoing, I find that tennination of this Investigation
does not impose any undue burdens on the public health and welfare, competitive conditions in
3
PUBLIC VERSION
the United States economy, the production of like or directly competitive articles in the United
States, and United States consumers.
The Moving Parties’ request to terminate this Investigation with prejudice is contrary to
Commission precedent. See, e.g., Certain Bar Clamps, Bar Clamp Pads and Related Packaging,
Displays and Other Materials, Inv. No. 337-TA-429, Comm’n Op., 2001 WL 361 14993, at *2
(Feb. 13, 2001) (“We do not dismiss the complaint in this investigation ‘with prejudice’ because
we believe that such a condition for termination of an investigation is not permitted under section
337(b)(1) of the Tarrif Act of 1930.”) Thus, the Moving Parties’ motion, to the extent it requests
termination with prejudice, is DENIED.
Qlilfl
Accordingly, it is my Initial Determination that the corrected motion to terminate this
Investigation is GRANTED-IN-PART. This Initial Determination, along with supporting
documentation, is hereby certified to the Commission.
Pursuant to 19 C.F.R. § 2l0.42(h), this Initial Determination shall become the
determination of the Commission unless a party files a petition for review of the Initial
Determination pursuant to 19 C.F.R. § 210.43(a), or the Commission, pursuant to 19 C.F.R.
§ 210.44, orders, on its own motion, a review of the Initial Determination or certain issues
herein.
The Moving Parties’ request to limit service of confidential materials to the settling
parties is GRANTED. The Moving Parties’ request for termination, to the extent it requests
termination with prejudice, is DENIED.
SO ORDERED.
4
__i
PUBLIC VERSION
Dee Lord
Administrative Law Judge
5
Exhibit A
(Public Version)
.
This
..
{-51%}
“Sememmt‘ ?¥31$f¢mm1"of "&fl¢¢§m¢nr“37*is>
sigigatuhc
{km“ $
élni eniewséy
aé PF 121%:
flaw of lasi
byand imtwaanfmcszmieS:m‘@w1§du¢1m-.
L261.a mrgsarazimr
qrgasiizezi mm 7e.‘l:ji§ii1ig,'-1uf1dér
13%»Iavésynf fiermmia (f‘i?_re=es¢ili:“',La;1dN¢di§’I_’ci; i1\€4.'3»
cmgmrazian fi1£ani:B:cd'anfl~mdxtin£ fimier rm»;§1m*§;.i1f’I’a§1&Ya'n
(“Madia”11:k‘§§ Freeseaia ind
1vfegiiz;T'e£are iquiividnaily ra_i"er*;"e‘d
in Iiaiifimas :1“"F;r:ga*’~ané mflezztivciy as me "‘Par§i_c:§."’
xwifmni =
V 'W?{ER£AS.Frwsmil: and‘Mediaflfeicdaaireliillwicfiflv wnia L§sa1~A§fim1$'{w
d§i§mk4ii‘n"1"u'x'i<_:§¢
$7:i:2§‘Jx1\v§:
naihing
the pm-I c>£cEihcrPasty.,
’
mew, LTHEREEORS,,
rwcmarm
shin 38¢wmuueé
».
VI
wmimxig
as an ahissiun
'c£§i;b§!§;y

vi -33¢:p'mu\is_c§ma nxiinjaiemenadts
mawiainezmhc Parties. inm':idSng,wi$€Yc&;iiyIb%1ﬂd,.&3f=#
1;: follmw»
A1§g*r:cui»ir?
A: um
ii; tliis $¢_:::;~.m=m
thy: ~fcIks_wi_1{1_g“tmm§
:§haIi aw»: I$15‘ﬁl'!uwingr
meanings:
“

mm.
as ‘<1Q;¥i1z1'v2
='1_'t1@iw¢*i<mj
Or 1 $¢=‘ii¢*
Q?*!¢ifl=<1_
transaeliuns Bywhikzixmhird
whc did not p,r¢vi0fl11s!y
cm1t_m§Ih:,Pl1iY»88in: owncrghig
05 more tjhm §_§y;p¢r¢¢11l($D?»8§~vclingin1:=r¢st%nr"pjquxivalpua;'ig,!z1;~: the Pmtyrgflw seen
immnflivflifi)»

‘ m§‘*
méfls :1
WR69v§b8i=*im=‘s_idiwc1
andivdiffi
cusiomcrs. wtailars. wh6Ycaa1em,1"diatfibiztors,
éeaimz. reseilem; aims, ve,t;d0t‘$;.impmim,
cxpurlcrs, nriginal equipment mannfactuzu-s, Qrkiual design manufadukrem supplies;
nmanufianmrars,1'-_nn€rantxirs,TassbmbIy*feci1iii:§,
izsfing fiwiiixies, wviee pravidem, arrri nits"
$imilir- third p;:lies,: jizxduding wimoui iirlfimian ‘customers -w1m?’di;'ac£Jyor indirectly
purchasa any pmdxrm urxewiws, fiom ma Parties ar flair véisuibviors; as Wei! as me
rcsp¢c(iVep:9_fi_n¢¢sSar§,
sucwssorsvmd assigns qf,w¢h gftbe afozmxemimznd eaatitiesé
_*“ “
qr"' ’§
:hr::sa8~
Fmsaaiw
and"
itsSubairiiarées,
in¢:lud.iagLF'n:cs;caicsm icm\d'm‘:t1;m,
trim, providéci, than Fnascalc‘: Subsidiazirzs are rkenmd in
in a»Fr‘;:e_s¢:§Ie,Bxi:§gy
may an mug amali ch: mqaisiia canriiiienaofbwiag aS11i%fidia11r
in main;
V“Fl'l=_6$€1§i€V"§§\(il');“"&’§5IJ
inrzhadxgay
1im@‘:?£i‘z'cxiva
Daze oflhifi
iwga1,¢i1ti1i¢sthat bwmw
‘ W?
<>f*~.1+.‘$
a Suizsidiaxy bf -Frmsgilé after
“’
mcans the litigaiions,includingany muq»all "claimsand
eoumerszlaims,filad undar the foiiowing eas: mmbcrs:
‘
(a)
Frmsoalz ~SEI?!i¢0!§§1tC!QI‘.
Inc. v. Ammri Ifedmolagy C0.‘ 114.. ex ah, Case
Na. :=12-cv‘-a0s44={w,n. 'I'e:t.)_;
{ii}
GXLD.€d‘};‘
'Mediz:'Tek. 1114:v. F:-evsnaie Sermicundufiior. Jim, Gasefio.
{c}
in _thc Mutter of Cer:¢ia"vIatAegr*axea*
cmw
Saw, US$112imz 3L37»T&»92£?;
and
{:5}
Ffwoaia
rind Produeriwfioniaznizig the
Samimrsducfmz Jae; v. Maiiafei
,?aa~=Mil?‘
1$;I_14{I_i\>'-£§53¢»i
'
USA. in:
zr $1.. Clam: Na‘
15;'§4~ilI¥'~(33i€§~5»i{€.v3J.
€l%1£.}*
“M@diaTIe1;mi¢»;<* Q “ii-6e&iaT¢:i§,£q@§§3¢~s"
mm
Mmiafak
and ix; Subsifiiafigs,
mzumng ikéazfififékU39, am pmvidad ‘mam
Meaiavam sqmigigrm dccmsé
§\->'Im§8T¢ir.
fiiliiy miy sakmg as xii the xaquisiia
“$1!¢diaT¢k vfimiay”/aflsu imiudes any iagai wines
Rifle?{he Effcefive
0! this Agrwumi,
"
’
“g”
ofheixsg aiubsidiflfy
1% vmar,
ii1at'iz4:wm:?:it Suissiziifiry =2!‘'MeéiafF§k“
‘
ruqansmlpmms,
"Manymuhods<;rVpwcwses1lzy
-theMadjaTekze1mn¢sVan¢=Pr¢w¢¢;¢-sgzim»-,
incmaiqg
Budinwgtsied
cimuit
_
ta fie:a
limimmm;mynfiag
er ‘ifnilti-d1ipA11f:o\{1_1h':»s
1*”)
Lfbr
per-fanning, any
imdudihgl‘all Amamiais;
ma
ineimfing
packaging {if°a'ny}—for
such Scmicnnductor
Pmxivers, {B}saflwre; imiudigxg iszglmctionx
and mfiware dramare
qr mnbodied’in or diétrihul/ed far use wifb Scmioonductnr
End Pmdacss, (:5)malarial PXGEUISWS
such as wafas, prof-£38»
matefiala and pine pans fur
Semiconductor End Pmducls. and (:2) circnii dosing: infemmtion such as oirauit dcfigns;
hardware descfipfiaus. mt! biker soft reprcsmratioxts-of eoxnponcsitsof Sctnicxmductor End
Products.
‘"
ofafanyvmeldtmanymrpqtalion.limitedIiabiiitycomgany,amociaiipa
at other busing»: mfiay Q? whic1s,pwne:‘sh§;: inienssts r/q1r¢sen_1ing_m4>r¢
aham 50% of rig, _{1}m1
puwm Lo van: 3;;
e1=¢::w<>»cziireeiars ur
Thanngeiiai £\i§hnrixy'iir lrustws "of £111;
amputation, association or other
entity, cr uihcnwise representing me right m make
Lb: dceiaiom far qimh cnrpqraéon. aasaeiarim: arothe: business entity, is ‘ax1he;zi'av:’ow§z¢d
By that Pmy. An sixtity‘will bu dcdmaél 16 be 1
£11118!this Agreeméut uni; sq
long as 011{hp rvquisiic anndirierm at‘ bdng a Subsidiaxy arc ma, Qfhsmise such
mxpozuioa, {i:_nit¢diizbiiity wmpavry, aswciéfimwor mam: Emsinmseafihfiis asthiniparty.
i§‘*iE¥3
,
2.1,
Am"1c;..2'11
~
the; ircsgacxivePasties (mm;
such Party's Subsidiaries) in each of the Ltgal
Actions win filmajoluz szipulazian efdismissai {or its equivaiemv),r¢.spemiw:1ydismissing all
claims, answers and cr>untem1aim.sin such Lagal Actions, such dismissals being wixh
prcjudim as may miaze In Mcdialhk Emix-iesand Freescale Hmifics, with nach Pany bearing
iisflwn casts. Mureover, Fxeascaie agmes to dismiss all "Claims,Aanswex-5,
and coumerctaims
against any Mcdiflek Cusmmcrs and Suppfiers, Whw Fmesmifs nlzims. KMWQYS.
or
mzumerciaimsagainst mqse Custmners and Suppliers are based on the use of Mediflei:
Pmducts. snub dismissals being with pmjudioe, and Freescale and those Customcrs and
Suppiicxsbearing mm awn casts.
2.2‘
2 1“
2.4.
'
'Pa,g1B4 0! I3
mficxm £11
3.1.
x 1 1_
3.1.2.
3.1.3
3.2.
3.3.
3.3.1.
3$;2.
3.3.3.
fix‘ 5 W713
ARTICLE IV
Fag-:.6o1‘124
AR'T‘If{¥.F, V
Km» “{,g1T§3L
ARTICLE Vl
6.1.
Répmbenlafions.
6!]
6.3.1.
PagB8n€!3,
,
5.2.
_mmmi
fiisnifimifmmmmaurwmbfwés
_
afietflaé Bffeqiw 13% ntifhcx may-;i_»._aiz
“
..
{:1}-$v§iittBfi,§¥i_§t\flffilm\‘w3;s¢:;11a§»!‘»£h¢#3Ul8YPafly;
A A .
Q:-3m my
gmrerhmmmi
Lbzzdy having
iurixaiimiénv and s}fs¥:t:i'§§tfiliy
tflqfiirihg sack?‘diseingure;
'
in} £12
mm"=g-mm*1;wW@_¢r
iawg
as athgrwisé may he-1‘*?l1l1§red3§_y
‘
.
{ti} ¥‘erLkh:;3>ur;aascs;;£Lxiié1¢§<fi!l4%
in aamfifiiibn
Exafimga
wixlh81: Sacwifigs
am! any‘ 4:11-scar
at any oiher fiiings, répmis aw
Am _l?fFL934, as izmendad. §he_Si:au%1:i1§;eg
-Arzi.111‘-1933, as amazdqd;
§i¥§i1T§_ti~i§h
-!h€'Seb1kifi1.:s*mx1
maybe
‘{6} 1éAé@Pany‘n wmunimys,
kvgql“
mg ,nd\*iz0r§_ms
nabs:
financial and Iegalmyispm, suizjgfiip obijgaiiéui flffimfiifinliaiiiy mrréfog
privflage arlqafi
as s3ingni1la3!h0$¢¢’§n§iiHbii'i_1q'¢i!1§1
.
'
(E) ag:'reqXii'ffliidunhg' L tin:
'
'
Y
cf'&ii%"5r_=;i§:maud
i1;\bjec€ _m;p;-nmdva
exddri
howuyfir, lhfli may pwduetiorl
a prqlepfiiva ;o_1der-wqgskiv
iiepmiflfitzd
5iiv“Auémeys am
~<$:si‘g11fikibn,
ii‘ agxpiimbic, ur flu: ¥1i2h¢$i.c<:nfdmtia1By
fir-sigmiiim:available;
'
at>:£gmims,o£wnfidma;11;yéax M51 as miagenz 1§$€i1\(1$¢
iv a wumcrpény in §n:i1;¢¢=ianYwifl1
a pfipoifld merger. mquisifim.
wmain_ed
fmancing, palm:-p1:r;:hw: or simfiar
§>ri=
”
pravidad. hawcvx-J, fithr pnior m"any su::h_»:iisr':ii:su:cpursuant in paxagmpii {:1}immf. the
Mn? ‘seakixigfdisalasurc sbal} ptnmpfly qualify111:
Fmyand, that prim ti:w1;;myfizz}:
disatasnn: punmm: 1;:paragrflphi (£2)undfm (3) hpreafi aka all lmsmahk nztiiaguin m..";§R;n
mih¢,nxmm:ané
.
bwfia
axtexmcsfsusch
dimkisam
#33,.‘
*
i\UnQf?€Qs
126 §§‘§¢‘l!~he~reuuz!_m-zhafi
62$‘ 3111231
5cf8é;Iivcrfi:i -311'
er ifidispataiacd
.pi>=k@_Ig=' ¢=@am:a:s=g'mm¢az@a
'
;:isvfi>Ii;>'wm~
If m Wcmme:
'
=
& :2? L13‘
by
cmrrigr wiliii
posxagié
mfie‘
midramd
A
via i-"zmscaiu
ims
66:33!Wiiiimn filfarmnn Drive ‘Weak
Austin. Texas 78735
L
Aim; General Cuuusul
If in Mediafakz
we
MediaTck Inc.
_
No- L Busing ls! Rm
’
_§-lsimchu
Science Park, Hsimhu City 36973;
Taiwmx; Republic ofilhina
7
A1171: Genera! Counsafl
Such mxiees shail be daemcd in havwbam
when mzfivod by ’
addressca Eizhe:Pmy may give writmeanotice wt‘a change ofaddms and. after notice at’
such r/hang: has been mceivad, any umicn er mqucsr shajl zhcmaBar be givm to such Parzyas;
above-pmyidcd axsuch chmged addrcss.
5.4, Vg;§1jc_igy.iilfliihcr Pany wilt ism: =1arm release mi any mher
announcement regaréing this Agraement unless bath Parties pmvidvapripr cunsml in wdting.
The Parties shail -dime: their rqmesentatives not memake any disclosures of timeterms mi‘this
Agretirlcnt
6.5. gm emigg >Law. This Agra-amen! and mmers cnnnented wflh tin:
pcribnnance thm-=uf:bai1‘be construed, imayretad. appficadand govcmed in aii.respecls in
accardance with the lawéoflhe Unittd Stalgs Q§'A1Ymri¢a,
and the State oi‘Caiifumia, ivizhouz
rnVf'e:-cam
to conflic; ofhws prinéiples.
6.6.
631.
The Pmics each
Mk1':0'§§‘1B@¢,,ficc:pY,
wax-mm and r:.pzcsen:Lt§m_t,(i)they are sophisticawd
Farticfi reprcsenmd
af all rdcmnt times during me negotiation and mcecntianof this Agwemcni by wanes! at‘
their choice, and thanthey have executed ibis Agrcemen; with the sdnseni ma cm lhc advice
afsmh iminyendmi icgnl counsel, and {ii}they and their wunsel haw: dclwminui flumlgh
innicpcpdent im~:sfi_gatiur: and mkust, arm’;-leagti§. negmiaticm d1.a1‘_t'h¢iemxs nf this
Agvbrrmcnishai; nclushmiy uxnbbdy and gavern tixesubjcca maucr ofthis 1\2mw1cm*
_
6%
Ifmy prmlisiennf this Apmpm
is hcid is be iilegal
¢r,nnenforewbi:*. such ganwision“shall in iizniwd 0: aiiminaicd in the minimum extzm
umamryaniisauharzmaixuier-e‘f
xvii!camimm 511%
fameandcfiac:andba
eniisxcaaiiala, The Paniaa agrae to ’negoti.a@e
in good fzsiihan tmfercaahia substimse proséisinn
Pay lfigfifi
firs any invgiiili ax anmr'fm*_ma§;¢ V;wovi$im1~fiat
mm: :$w'!ya::£1§¢vz.~a zlw imersl. .1:-Ysum
provision;
6.9.
its ?a;&t§maaimewiefige, meant, wsmux gm}
rqzrcsmxRm {ii
ism enfizwceablp
"agmanem: {ii}Séaijmhmt
Agqmmept
iheemive and -my anéerstandixagcf each cf than with yspecun the subjectmam! hf rim
‘Settlement
and memes. supersedes and smacks ziii prwious
wmamim.
fiafinifiomgfi
mpiimi, ararisiug
t=epr{:§§n£:_1I;i0n$,
jetmyothersmeznrrm,
by iwpczrflliimof law", wiwezimrerai or writms, wixalsat by‘o1$;imii;m er
bemeen and mnoag than with respnct :0 the subject matter nf the Agcexnau;
iiiijm ma! mlmmion amom! iafimmafionhy aifhq Hmy hem» sfmitvalwrflu;msaning as
inwrpramlimat axis1\zw=.=:r\mr:.
(iv) me rams
fimdirions of this Agwemem may ha
aiiernd. modified, izhangezi 0‘:
my iixyva
agn_=qm¢m'1w:¢cuwé'by duly
repmemnizivas nf the Pmfim. £11}xhe language mf this
bean
approved by qmzmei fur Qzwbnf {item and shafl be wgxsu-and8&1:fwpqmagmonjing-rgin fiiri
mm; of-iim
(mar {heir rgaectiv/e c<iun.\:-zflsfaitbe flmmcd In ha the
tiraiisman of this Agreement in any acxionywixichvmayhereafter nfise wish ra:.jp¢s=t»m{ha
Agraqnqfi,
(vii) zeéort shall ant be m:__dpm a¢:y oflhe \¢s.rrautiasw'it11inspect to any
missingtknm tgpuahiugthrzsuigjact
miw of
Agmwremin my way.
$10. 3M'_1g§§
gggf j~ Wgm, _
Vmadifvéaiién or axnenzksieni ié
Agréhmémqgor any Walvetiifany Fig!na,‘§w?if
heéifécfivb
ésseniedxoin vwrriiizfsg
by my
pm? ta ae_=-1»-g¢d,»u&¢
ilwa-waiwrofchyhmanh mgdeinufc will not censfimse a waive: qf
any
fight beraumler ulfany suiwqumr hréacia m dcfiiuh. Unless mqsmssiy‘mural
isithis Agremntnt is}kneaded affmi £11:indqpeadcnt and separate axeanicm
‘nhmy dafésase,
mbliva, 0:‘mgmm
by my Pmy, imfludingwithout,limimiuu any
Pmyfs assenicm atlas]: ofp¢:s0nnlLj1uisdi¢xi;mL
by the com iru Inga; action.
Bill,
Any mi: Mmasuuuion in aha etlm ma:
azibiguitics
‘:9.be ms*o_lvedagainst ma dmfling party will ma ha agpfied
Q11;
emssnuariau ix -inwrpmarian at Ibis Agreement, As ma ix:-1i:ia_Agr¢e:::eni§.fl§eyvogda
“incl\zdfi"’and "ine1uding" and»1:ariat§ons'd1crenf, wilimf bcdeemed to he terms ai‘ 11,l*mf‘&h_m:.
but mks?-wfli he iiéémed to b; feikmed by the words “xviflmom
limimion."
in this Agrwxsmt w%1$nor‘vbeL.refu:red
-in in bommlim
The headings
wiah the mlisfitrctims or izrtezprqiéiibn
<1!‘
this Agreement ’ ms Agivemma és in the English language oniy. which ianguag; shall
be r.om:oiiing3;1Lail rmwasts, and all tiorir>:s~"un:$;cr
this ixgxeerncnl shat} he in She English
Qanguaic,
'
L» M2V
Nsfihins
in1hi=*#<
slxmid be:-cunsm»ed1 as in umiwatgmliraguiarixmeni,qr ififlflifin er sigbgs or resnedics of rim:
-?a:\‘im in this Aggemmxt with respect to rirghss or rzmqiies agaimst nmqaarliss 3:5"
Asmfalzmwty Time
eécymssly resewe ad! rights and rmmdies undeir-all @p_;;nm1=:
Flfierni
mg; laws is ix;n<m~paai¢snothis Jkgrsemem.
513-‘
?§¢i*h¢¢
Y4“?
W?!
"*‘*§&“
Y”mm“
this
zmzwng any :1-1‘its rights 0? dalégata. un}f'Q1',-iifi‘cbfigzfiazéa
wkcxixer miuatm-ily‘ m -‘iavalnamxiiy, Avéhziiwfby -mgfwsmiion
"of iaw, merger,
wpsnlidafimg fiiwaiulim m any mm: mam,
Fwy,
shelf bc’pe:1¥§ia¢a
zhas
wiihnuxihc_pdot wriima cement af the ‘ether
shzsii. ms: he uumasanabiy
wizhhcéé. mncepx asaigruarzrrm a:p?d(xm’m1fers
ms mnawangwmmfiés: 5}as pmimw
ii {W13
in Sarrfions22-, 25,- 3.2, 3,4
and 3.2 with aspect ma a spiswfi;
(sxmzivixug
zmily and, c) when VaPady
~-bi1-vim:is meg;-4 wsuiis ‘axa
bezzmrdag ‘rim
vfflénwi as pmviéed
Se~é1'iez§
6.ih£
Any nitempt m mfg: w ttann‘er1his
Agxmnmz
in ~
_
_
*
-wilkbevuixi.
'
)1 14
wry;
*‘
of1 fix:.- is mgpmg
i"
U
1:»?wmress
caused
§¢.5ig_rla1b¢ix>'\»11
by1h.@i;I§5pe¢=fi‘¥¢§-=dxa1y
aaémiwi
~F:*e¥:sc‘aIeS§mi€i14i§u¢:tI¢¢r,L!x§;.
"fiiIg:~
F;
amcam;
m¢ai¢1"¢&.:m.
_;MA
Yggé its ai-13
*
in
CERTAIN INTEGRATED CIRCUITS AND PRODUCTS
CONTAINING THE SAME
Inv. No. 337-TA-920
PUBLIC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Lisa R. Barton, hereby certify that the attached ORDER has been served by hand upon
the Commission Investigative Attorney, R. Whitney Winston, Esq., and the following parties as
indicated, on
15 2011]
Lisa R. Barton, Secretary
U.S. International Trade Commission
500 E Street, SW, Room 112
i
Washington, DC 20436
On Behalf of Complainant Freescale Semiconductor, Inc.:
Benjamin Levi, Esq.
McKOOL SMITH PC
1999 K Street, NW, Suite 600
) Via Hand Delivery
) Via Express Delivery
) Via First Class Mail
) Other:
On Behalf of Respondents AmTRAN Logistics. Inc. and
AmTRAN Technology Co.. Ltd.:
Yitai Hu, Esq.
ALSTON & BIRD LLP
1950 University Circle, 5“ Floor
East Palo Alto, CA 94303
( ) Via Hand Delivery
( ) Via Express Delivery
( )Otherzii
(‘~}—)
Via First Class Mail
On Behalf of Respondents Toshiba America Information
Systems, Inc. and Toshiba Logistics America. Inc OI
Liane M. Peterson, Esq.
FOLEY & LARDNER LLP
3000 Street, NW
Suite 600
) Via Hand Delivery
>4) Via First Class Mail
)Other:_i
CONTAINING THE SAME
lnv. No. 337-TA-920
Certificate of Service —Page 2
On Behalf of Respondents TPV Display TechnologL(Xiamen)
Co.. Ltd...Trend Smart America. Ltd.. and Trend Smart Ce
Mexico, S.r.l. de C.V.:
) Via Hand Delivery
Vision L. Winter, Esq.
0’MELVENY & MYERS LLP
400 South Hope Street
Los Angeles, CA 90071
)Other:i__i_
On Behalf of Respondents Costco Wholesale Corporation;
NeweggInc., B & H Foto & Electronics Corp, and Wahnart
Stores, Inc.:
) Via Hand Delivery
Kent E. Baldauf, Jr., Esq.
THE WEBB LAW FIRM
)Otheni
One Gateway Center
420 Ft. Duquesne Boulevard, Suite 1200
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
On Behalf of Respondents Sharp Corporation. Sharp
Electronics Corporation and Sharp Electronics
Manufacturing Company of America, Inc.:
Josh A. Krevitt, Esq.
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
200 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10166
'
(X) Via First Class Mail
(
) Other:
On Behalf of Respondent Amazon.com. Inc.:
Eric C. Rusnak, Esq.
K&L GATES LLP
1601 K Street NW
Q ) Via First Class Mail
( )Other:_i
On Behalf of Respondent Vizio. Inc.:
Mark Lyon, Esq.
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
1881 Page Mill Road
Palo Alto, CA 94304-1211
) Via Hand Delivery
)Otherzq
CONTAINING THE SAME
Inv. No. 337-TA-920
On Behalf Of Respondents Yamaha Corporation and Yamaha
Corporation Of America:
Steven J. Routh , Esq.
) Via Hand Delivery
ORRICK, HERRINGTON & SUTCLIFFE, LLP
1152 15*‘Street NW
)Other:
On Behalf of Respondents ASUSTek Computer Inc. and
ASUS Computer International. Inc.:
Andrew F. Pratt, Esq.
VENABLE LLP
575 7th Street, NW
Washington, DC 20004-1604
) Via Hand Delivery
) Other:
On Behalf of Respondents Sony Corporation, Sony
Corporation of America. Sony Electronics. Inc., and Sony
EMCS {Malaysia} Sdn Bhd:
Jeffrey S. Gerchick, Esq.
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLIVAN LLP
777 6th Street, NW
(>() Via First Class Mail
(
) Other:
On Behalf of Respondents MediaTek Inc. and MediaTek USA
Inc.
S. Alex Lasher, Esq.
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLIVAN LLP
777 6th Street, NW
) Via Hand Delivery
) Other:
On Behalf of Respondent Best Buv C0., Inc.:
Bryan J. Vogel, Esq.
) Via Hand Delivery
ROBINS, KAPLAN, MILLER & CIRESI LLP
601 Lexington Avenue, 34th Floor
New York, NY 10022
><)Via First Class Mail
) Other:
Inv. No. 337-TA-920
CONTAINING THE SAME
On Behalf of Respondent Lenovo Group Ltd. and Lenovo
[United States) Inc.:
Fred I. Williams, Esq.
AIGN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP
600 Congress Avenue, Suite 1350
Austin, TX 78701
(>/) Via First Class Mail
( ) Other:
On Behalf of Respondent Buy.com Inc. d/b/a Rakuten.com
Shopping:
Eric S. Namrow, Esq.
MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP
l l 11 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
) Via Hand Delivery
(><) Via First Class Mail
)Otheni
On Behalf of Respondent Acer Inc.:
Craig Kaufman, Esq.
TECHKNOWLEDGE LAW GROUP LLP
100 Marine Parkway, Suite 200
Redwood Shores, CA 94065
P<) Via First Class Mail
( ) Other:___________
On Behalf of Respondent BLU Products. Inc.:
Bemard L. Egozi, Esq.
EGOZI & BENNETT, P.A.
2999 NE 191st Street, Suite 407
Aventura, FL 33180
) Via Hand Delivery
(>g) Via First Class Mail
(
) Other: