The Role of Geometry and Proportions in Shaping the
Transcription
The Role of Geometry and Proportions in Shaping the
EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) The Role of Geometry and Proportions in Shaping the Fabric of Space in Traditional Iranian Architecture: Case Study of Mosques in Safavie Period in Isfahan Mohamad reza mabhoot1, Seyyed Mahdi Madahi*2, seyyed ehsan sayadi 3 1,3 2 Faculty member, Khavaran Institute of higher education, Iran, mashhad Ph.d student, Iran university of Science and Technology, Iran, Tehran and Faculty member, Khavaran Institute of higher education, Iran, mashhad ABSTRACT Iranian architecture is found not in form, but in perceiving and creating space. The main feature of traditional Iranian architecture can be defined as the production of a space for living. In other words, architecture is first formed in the mind of the architect and is then expressed and is finally placed on the ground. Geometry has been the primary tool of all Iranian traditional architects in creating architectural works. Considering that one of the most important factors of creating a particular feeling in a space is its geometry, in the architecture of buildings such as mosques, particular attention should be paid to geometry and spatial proportions; this will not be possible unless we consider the geometrical relations applied in traditional valuable mosques. As to the creation of valuable buildings such as mosques, etc., Safavid architecture has admirable features, and the culmination of architecture of this period is observed in Isfahan. Therefore, the geometrical analysis of Safavid mosques will reveal that how the architect's abstract ideas are converted into a plan. The present research attempts to answer the following question: what factors have affected the shaping of architect's abstract ideas of building the Safavid mosques of Isfahan? Findings of the study show that the art of geometry is a key element for making connections between the building and the ideas that the builder has had in his mind. This is not the material that creates his space; rather, it is his space that requires a special fabric, and this is the point that our past architects have fully understood. Methodology of this research is analytic-descriptive and it has been conducted through geometrical analysis of Safavid mosques of Isfahan (Imam Mosque, Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque and Agha Noor Mosque). KEY WORDS: geometry and proportions, traditional Iranian architecture, mosques of Safavid period, Isfahan 1 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Research questions 1. What factors have affected the shaping of architect's abstract ideas of building the Safavid mosques of Isfahan? 2. How geometry has influenced the forming of mosques’ fabric of space in Safavid period in Isfahan? Introduction Spatial forms of Iranian architecture can provide the experience of intimate, personal and private environments along with huge and magnificent spaces. They can provide the experience of closed, semi-closed, semi-opened and opened spaces in combination with each other so that one feels that he has found a shelter or has made an initiation. Basically, Iranian architect’s thought for building a space is completely different from today’s methods. The Iranian architect knew all that would change the insipid, rigid and neutral quality of space. He was at the same time the architect, accountant, expert in materials, and craftsman. He was so entangled with his contemporary society that he did not need to separately study the required functions and later make their diagrams, turn them into a map and finally have spatial imagination. He had spatial imagination for the plan that he received from his employer. The fundamental element and the basic theme of art and architecture are geometry and proportions. It is in the systematic area of geometry and proportions that everything including the components of a house and even a city can come into existence. Creation of the nature, the entire universe including skies, earth, etc., and particularly the mankind has been based on geometry and proportions. In Sura Al-Furqan, Verse 2, it has been stated that meaning that “It is He who created all things and ordered them in due proportions” . If any of the works which are created in this world are out of the essential measurements of the nature, it will be unusual, unpleasant and unacceptable, and it cannot find a way to the ideal state. In contemporary times, despite its evolutions and diversity, lifestyle has been reduced to a number of functions, space organizing, and forms. Contemporary architecture should revive all the lost areas of architecture. Architecture is the creator of an environment in which life, with all its aspects, is flourished and not suppressed. 2 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Literature review By reviewing the background of the previous studies, it is observed that much research has been conducted on the methods of using geometry as an efficient tool in architectural techniques. We will take a look at some cases. In an article entitled as The Sacred Geometry in Nature and Iranian Architecture, Hejazi has geometrically analyzed a number of Iranian historical monuments in which the golden ratio has been used and this has been the basis of Iranian architecture aesthetics. Traditional architecture represents the cosmos in earthly dimensions. In an architectural monument, all dimensions, both in its integrity (height, length and width) and its components (including geometrical surface patterns), are interrelated and never divorced from geometry (Hejazi, 2008). In an paper entitled as Applying the Hanjar Triangles in the Mathematical Calculation and Implementation of Geometry in Construction and Enforcement of Traditional Iranian Architecture, Mahdizadeh Seraj, Tehrani, and Valibeig studied the position of geometry in view of the architects and artists, and demonstrated that past architects with their familiarity with geometry and their ability in actualizing the geometrical relations, attempted to match the methods of theoretical geometry with their own tools (Mahdizadeh Seraj, Tehrani and Valibeig, 2011). In another article entitled as Geometrical Analysis of Architecture of Sheik Lotfollah Mosque to Find the Geometrical Relations between its Prayer Hall and the Entrance, Dahar and Alipour have revealed some of the geometrical relations between the components of this valuable building; and the position of the prayer hall with the entrance has been determined by geometrical-graphical methods. In designing Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque, golden ratio and its construction geometrical methods have been used in making fitness between the building components. As a result, the architect of this building, with his comprehensive knowledge of geometry and the scientific methods of its application, has skillfully adjusted the size and position of the building components to each other and has made an eye-catching harmony between them (Dahar, Alipour, 2013). In this research, it has been attempted to have a geometrical analysis on the architecture of Imam, Sheikh Lotfollah and Agha Noor Mosques in Isfahan, and 3 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) thereby reveal that how the architect’s abstract ideas have been turned into an architectural plan. Methodology Methodology of this research is analytic-descriptive and it has been conducted based on library studies, documents, photos, as well as the geometrical analysis of Safavid mosques of Isfahan (Imam, Sheikh Lotfollah and Agha Noor Mosques). First these mosques are introduced, then they are geometrically analyzed, and finally the results of the analyses are compared. 1. Geometry in architecture 1.1. Geometry is the disciplinary element of architecture, and organizes other elements. In fact, geometry for architecture is the same as the thread for beads, without which there is no organization and system for connecting the beads to each other. Geometry provides harmony and continuity in architectural works. As previously stated, in Iranian architecture, geometry plays an important role. In fact, it can be considered as the architectural language of Iran (Okhovvat, Baghayi and Bemanian, 2011). 1.2. Geometry is the main theme of all architects in creating architectural works. What makes the works semantically different is the type and the way of referring to these general components of architecture. In his ascent, a Muslim architect creates the ever-best by the use of geometry (Nadimi, 2000) (Diag.1). Diagram1: source: authors 4 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) In order to visualize a transcendental, provocative, sublime and timeless space, the architect uses some unique principles and criteria in the building's structure. Paying attention to order and continuously observing the proportions will lead the architect to a pure, special and precise geometry (Bavandian, 2005). 2. The sacred geometry in Iranian architecture The traditional architect uses geometry for having more exploration into the natural phenomena so that he can lead the mind of the revelation-seeker from the tangible world to the intelligible world. Geometry plays an essential role in designing the Iranian architectural buildings. In terms of external function, utilization of geometry as an art for creating forms, patterns and proportions, reminds us of the world's Greatest Architect. Therefore, the art of geometry is a key element in connecting the building to the builder's abstract ideas (Diag.2). Diagram2: source: authors Iranian architecture is a mirror which reflects the divine beauty – the one that is sacred, and as a harmonic continuity of logical proportions, it can be reflected through patterns that are exactly built based on the right proportions. The sacred geometry is a powerful tool for creating the right proportions in architecture for the sake of adapting the sky and the earth. The sacred geometry and the proportions that are found in many forms of life in the nature are skillfully applied by the traditional Iranian architect so that he creates a traditional architectural object which is indicative of the right designing methods and the correct engineering. Iranian architecture is the sacred geometricizing of the divine beauty (Hejazi, 2009) (Diag.3). 5 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Architecture is first formed in the architect's mind (truth); it is then expressed (medium); and it is finally placed on the ground or in the space (trope) (Diag.4). Any type of architectural design is basically a work of geometry. Both deal with the properties of lines, surfaces and forms in the space. Therefore, any analysis on an architectural work is to some extent a research about its geometry. For a mosque, the primary requirement is to provide a suitable space for the rows of prayer-sayers who stand facing the Qibla, and based on a special manner, stand on foot and then prostrate on the ground. Since circular or centralized designs do not match this requirement, rectangular designs are more suitable for mosques (Muhammad Al-As’ad). The architect of a building like mosque intends to present a spiritual setting. To do so, it is necessary that he reflects in the space the concept of divinity, monotheism, and the soar of soul, so that his space creates the sense of spirituality in the mosque. This is not the materials that create his space; rather, it is his space that requires a special fabric and material, and this is the point that our past architects have fully understood. Transparency whose roots can be found in Iranian architecture at the time of the building of Takht-e Jamshid, results from the very attitude of Iranian architects towards space (Haeri, 2009) (Diag.5). Diagram3: source: authors Diagram5: source: authors 6 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Diagram6: source: authors When creating a work, the artist creates a “jug” so that he leads the addressee from “the visible jug” to “the invisible wine” through it, and conducts him from what is visible to what is hidden from the addressee. He searches the scenes and creates them, and then, through different means such as invitations, guidance, movements, outlooks, emphases, combinations, etc., faces the addressee with a condition in which he can feel that “sense” (Navayi and Haji Ghasemi, 2011) (Diag.6). Islamic historians such as Beihaghi, Ibn Khaldun and Khaje Rashid Al-Din have written useful materials about architecture and architects. These people have written that architects were familiar with mathematics and geometry, and when they wanted to construct buildings, they attempted designing and mapping before any other work. The great philosopher of Iran, Farabi, states that architecture is based on the science of mechanics, and mechanics includes skills, arts and techniques that are shown by skillful and artistic works in geometrical forms (Kiani, 2012). 3. The role of geometry in mosques’ architecture Considering the importance that it has in Islam religion, the architecture of mosque as Muslims’ place of worship has always followed special fabric and geometrical principles of its own period. One of the most important factors that creates a particular sense in the space for users and consumers results from the geometrical relations and proportions which have been applied in the architecture of that space. Considering its application, any architectural building 7 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) should have some properties that can meet the intended requirements of that building. Using a suitable geometry which suits that function is one the important tools of the architect for meeting a main part of the special requirements of that building. In fact, the basic factor of creating unity among the components of the universe, particularly among the components of the corpus of each architecture culture, can be nothing but geometry. Although in the history of architecture, in many of the buildings including personal houses and even the rulers’ castles and palaces, and although today in some of the buildings such as museums, offices, etc., the architect and the employer can decide about the destiny of a building, in the architecture of buildings such as the places of worship which have a special importance and position for people, the architect cannot be inattentive towards the effect that his work has on the addressee. Therefore, the task of building a mosque has been always assigned to architects who were expert in mathematics and geometry and were so-called engineers (Sattari Sarbangholi, 2012). In the architecture of Iranian mosques, geometrical tools have been used proportional to the temporal and spatial conditions and requirements of each building (Dahar, 2013). Safavid architecture, not only as to the creation of valuable architectural buildings such as mosques, bridges, inns, etc. has admirable and special features, but also the implementation of these works is indicative of an efficient management in this period. The culmination of architecture of this period is observed in Isfahan (Haji Kazemi, 2007). Architectural features of this period are as follows: The simplification of designs which, in buildings and spaces, are mostly square or rectangle - Applying simple geometry and fragmental forms and lines Modularization and use of equal parts and sizes in the building (Pirnia, 2011). 8 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) 4. Imam Mosque in Isfahan The building process of the mosque has started in 1020 lunar year, and its architect is Ali Akbar Esfahani (ibid). Shaping traditions, ideals, slogans and religious concepts, the map that has slowly progressed from the combination of the older and simpler types, huge constructional elements and ornaments, all have been realized in the Imam Mosque and that has ranked it among the biggest buildings of the world. The forecourt which is almost constructional, has a sense of invitation which calls the outside crowd to the shelter, security and refection inside the mosque. The forecourt faces towards the North as it necessitates, but since sanctuary should be faced towards Qibla (i.e. east north to west south), in order to prevent deformation, much style and precision was needed; this problem was successfully solved. People enter an excellent corridor through the forecourt, which is one of the features of Iranian historical monuments in the past. This corridor is circular and hence it has no direction; it can be like a pivot on which the building’s axis rotates. The corridor opens into the tall arch of the northern porch, and from its deep darkness one can suddenly observe the sunlit yard. On the other side of the yard, there is the vast entrance of the seraglio which is a window to another world of grandeur and centralized power (Pope, 2011). 4.1. Geometrical analysis of Imam Mosque The ABCD square shows the northern porch of the mosque in which a circle with center O and a radius half of the side of the mentioned square is drawn in a surrounded way. We mark the point O” in the middle of the side BC and move the drawn circle along the radius OO” so that its center is adjusted to the point O”. With a 45o angle to the length of the horizontal line OO”, the radius of the circle is drawn so that it crosses its perimeter in point S. If we extend the radius O”S, it will be adjusted to the symmetry axis of the building entrance. With a 45o angle to the horizontal line OO”, the ABCD square turns and is placed surrounding the circle O”. This square is moved to the center O”; A”B”C”D”. From the middle of the side D”C” i.e. point N, an arch with radius NB” and center N is drawn so that it crosses length D”C” at point E. The A”FD”E rectangle that is obtained through this method is a golden rectangle1. As explained, we extend the radius O”S so that it crosses the side FE at point Y. The length O”S is adjusted to the symmetry axis of the mosque entrance and 9 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) point Y is placed in the middle of the side FE. With the center Y of the point in the middle of the side FE and with a radius equal to YM (M in the middle of the side A”B”) an arch is drawn so that it crosses the length FE at point G. Once again this is repeated for the other side of the entrance axis as follows: with the center Y of the point in the middle of the side FE and with a radius equal to YN (N in the middle of the side D”C”) an arch is drawn so that it crosses the length FE at point H. In this way, the location of the two vestibules on the two sides of the entrance axis is specified. The two rectangles ENIG and FMJH are golden rectangles. After passing the entrance corridor, we arrive at the yard court and can see the southern porch (Table.1). Table1: geometrical analysis of Imam Mosque in Isfahan. Source: authors 10 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) 5. Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque The smaller Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque (1012-1028 lunar year) is another building of that period which is more easily perceived due to its fit size and simplified function. Its firm domical form on a square-shaped room which is the inheritance of Sassanid architecture has once again emerged in this beautiful small mosque. This is an individual and interesting room which is more like a private prayer hall. Similar to Imam Mosque, here for placing the seraglio towards the Qibla, some adjustments have been made which require a 45o angle from the northern-southern axis of the field. To do so, a creative and hidden twist has been used in the corridor. When one enters the seraglio, sanctuary is exactly in front of him (Pope, 2011). Passing the entrance door, we enter the vestibule which is the beginning of a 28-meter corridor to the seraglio. Some steps after entering the corridor, there is a grille on the right which provides a view for the observer of the seraglio and it somehow encourages the observer to continue his way. After that and in the middle of the corridor and before arriving at the nick, there is a door on the left which leads to the winter seraglio. 14 meters after the entrance door, the corridor turns right with a 90o angle. At the nick, there is a granite 100×70 cm window. Construction of such a corridor with these ornaments and lighting, makes us think that this corridor has been built not only for solving the problem of Qibla, but also for gradually separating the worshiper from the outside commotion and for gradually preparing him to enter another space. On the other hand, this corridor makes the eyes get used to dim light. If the observer enters suddenly from the outside bright environment into the half-bright seraglio, he cannot experience the grandeur of this space. In order to show the light to the observer, the builder has first confirmed the lack of light and then in the seraglio, he conducts the observer to the world of light and color. After passing this dim corridor, we surprisingly enter the seraglio – a world of color, pattern and light. And it is perhaps here and at this moment that we find out the philosophy of building this corridor. 5.1. Geometrical analysis of the prayer hall space First a circle with center O and a radius equal to the radius of the dome base is drawn, which due to the squareness of the prayer hall, the mentioned circle is surrounded by the square. With a 45o angle to the horizontal line, the circle radius OA is drawn. The plotted circle moves along the radius OA so that its center adapts to point A. Using this circle, the ABCD square with a side equal 11 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) to the radius of the circle is drawn. According to the Table, it is clear that point B is placed with very good approximation on the symmetry axis of the building entrance and in the middle of the entrance doorway. With center K of the middle point of the side DC and with the radius KB, an arch is drawn so that it crosses the length DC at point F. The AEFD rectangle that has been so obtained is a golden rectangle. At the final stage, the EGHF square is drawn. According to the previous stages, it is clear that the length of the side of this square is equal to the radius of the circle with center O. The BGHC rectangle is a rectangle with golden proportion between its sides (Table.2). Table2: geometrical analysis of Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque in Isfahan. Source: authors 12 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) 6. Agha Noor Mosque in Isfahan In Dardasht district of Isfahan, there is a mosque which has been designed based on Iranian architecture traditions in the form of four porches. The entrances of Agha Noor Mosque are located at the northern and eastern sides of the mosque, which lead through the surrounding allies to Dardasht market and a same-called district. The founder of the mosque, Noor Al-Din Mohammad Esfahani, was one of the benefactors of his own time. Agha Noor Mosque’s seraglio is among the most beautiful seraglios of Isfahan mosques. Its pillars are made from stone and its numerous arches have some pieces made from transparent marble which provides light during the day for the seraglio (Wikipedia website). 6.1. Geometrical analysis of the mosque The usage of golden proportions can be observed in different parts of the mosque. In the dome-house space, a circle with the center O and a radius equal to the radius of the dome base is drawn, which due to the squareness of the space of the mosque, it is surrounded by GHIJ square. With the center K of the point in the middle of the side IJ and with the radius KH, an arch is drawn so that it crosses the length IJ at point N. The GMNI rectangle which has been so obtained is a rectangle with golden proportions between its sides. In the springhouse next to the entrance corridor of the mosque, the ABCD square is drawn. With the center X of the point in the middle of the side DC and with radius XB, an arch is drawn so that it crosses the length DC at point F. The AEFD rectangle is a golden rectangle (Table.3). 13 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Table3: geometrical analysis of Agha Noor Mosque of Isfahan. Source: authors Comparing the results of the analyses By comparing the results, we can conclude that through using geometry in the mosques, first the outside and inside of the mosque have become separated appropriately, and second it has caused prayer-sayers to enter the mosque’s dome-house directly towards the Qibla. However, by following the general principles of geometry and proportions of traditional mosques, we can create in the users the feeling of pacing into a spiritual and religious place. The traditional architect had focused on the presence of people in the space, and by giving order to dark, half-bright and bright spaces, he has tried to conduct people from one world to another (Fig.1). 14 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Fig.1: comparison of the geometrical analysis of mosques. Source: authors Conclusion Through analyzing three mosques of Safavid period in Isfahan (Imam Mosque, Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque and Agha Noor Mosque), it can be stated that the thing which is important in Iranian architecture is that the architect focuses on creating and perceiving the spaces. In order to depict a spiritual space, the Iranian architect has been at first visualizing space and thinking about how to separate the addressee from the madding world, and during a special process, enter him into another world. As can be seen in the architecture of Imam Mosque in Isfahan, the addressee gradually enters the yard through two twisted corridors which are located in the two sides of the northern porch; this can depict passage from darkness to the light. The addressee would also observe the seraglio’s entrance on the other side of the yard. In Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque, the addressee passes through a corridor which twists 90o to the right and gradually goes far away from the outside world and is prepared for entering into another space and enters the dome-house space while he is standing in front of the Qibla. In Agha Noor Mosque also the addressee enters into the yard from a corner through a dark corridor, and on the opposite angle, he can see the gate of entering into the dome-house. In all these three studied samples, by means of geometry, the designer architect has created a space for the mosque, which can make the addressee feel a spiritual sense and be prepared for entering into another world. 15 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) Endnote 1Geometrical method of drawing a golden ratio: in order to draw a rectangle with golden ratio, we consider the CBGD rectangle. We find point A in the middle of DG, and draw a circle with center A and radius AB. We extend the line DG so that it crosses the mentioned circle at point E. The ratio of DE to DC is the golden ratio, and the CFED rectangle is a golden rectangle (Fig.2). DE/DC = 1.618 Figure2: golden rectangle. Source: authors References 1- Ahangar Azizi. Babak; Sattari Sarbangholi. Hasan. 2012 . A survey on the geometrical features and proportions of mosques in Safavid period: A case study of Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque: National Conference of Iranian-Islamic Architecture and Urbanization. 2- Bavandian. Ali Reza. 2005. Islamic architecture geometry – a joint between material and sense: Zaer Publication. No. 204. 3- Dahar. Ali; Alipour. Reza. 2013. Geometrical analysis of architecture of Sheik Lotfollah Mosque to find the geometrical relations between its prayer hall and the entrance: Bagh Nazar. No. 26. 4- Haeri. Mohammad Reza. 2009. The role of space in Iranian architecture: 1st ed., Nil Publication. 5- Haji Ghasemi. Kambiz; Navayi. Kambiz. 2011. Brick and imagination: Soroush Publication in cooperation with Shahid Beheshti University. 6- Haji Kazemi. Kambiz. 2007. Architectural outlook of Safavid period in Iran: Saffeh Publication. 16th year. No. 44. 7- Hejazi. Mehrdad. 2009. The sacred geometry in nature and Iranian architecture: Tarikh-e Elm Magazine. 16 EPHEMERA http://ephemerajournal.com/ ISSN: 1298-0595 Vol.27; No. 4 (2015) 8- Kiani. Mohammad Yusof. 2012. The history of the architectural art of Iran in the Islamic period: 14th ed., SAMT Publication. 9- Mahdizadeh. Seraj. Fatemeh; Tehrani, Farhad; Valibeig, Nima. 2011, Applying the Hanjar triangles in the mathematical calculation and implementation of geometry in construction and enforcement of traditional Iranian architecture. Scientific-research two-quarterly journal of restoration, monuments, and culturalhistorical textures. 10- Muhammad Al-As’ad. The applications of geometry in mosques’ architecture: trans. by Saeed Saeedpour, Quarterly Journal of Art. No. 33. 11- Nadimi, Hadi. 2000. The truth of role: Keyhan Publication. 23. 12- Okhovvat. Haniye; Baghayi. Parham; Bemanian. Mohammad Reza. 2011. Applying geometry and proportions in architecture: 1st ed., Tahan Publication. 13- Pirnia. Mohammad Karim. 2011. Iranian architecture stylistics: 10th ed., Soroushe Danesh Publication. 14- Pope. Arthur. 2011. Iranian architecture: 9th ed., Dot Publication. 15- Website of Center for Documentation of Cultural Heritage Organization: www.ichodoc.ir. 16- Website: www.wikipedia.org. 17