WQ: Supreme Interpreters - iCivics | Free Lesson Plans and Games
Transcription
WQ: Supreme Interpreters - iCivics | Free Lesson Plans and Games
WQ: Supreme Interpreters Name: Instructions: Use this worksheet to collect your answers from the WebQuest. NOTE: There may be questions on this worksheet that are not online. Slide 1: Constitutional Rights Slide 2: It Means What It Says 1. Write the phrases that go in the two blanks. 1. What does judicial review allow the Supreme Court to do? _________________ of ________________ __________ and __________ ________________ 2. Do these rights sound familiar? 2. Why do you think the Supreme Court needs to be able to interpret the Constitution? Yes No 3. Do you see any explanation of what these phrases mean? Yes No Slide 3: Freedom to Lie? Slide 4: Freedom to Lie: The Court’s Opinion Your Interpretation: Should Alvarez be charged with a crime for his lie, or should his lie be protected by freedom of speech? Explain your opinion. 1. Justice Kennedy talked about two kinds of speech that the First Amendment protects. What did he say? 2. Three justices dissented (disagreed). Why did they think this kind of lie should not be protected? Slide 5: Protected Speech 1. Choose one kind of speech NOT protected by freedom of speech. Explain why you think people don’t have the right to do that. 2. Is there an activity you think is on the wrong list? (Something you think the Court should have decided differently?) Yes No Explain why you think people should or should not have that right. Supreme Interpreters WQ Companion Worksheet p. 1 WQ: Supreme Interpreters Name: Slide 6: That’s cruel and unusual! Slide 7: Very Detailed Interpretations 1. Which execution methods are constitutional? (Hint: They’re the ones states are still using.) 1. How many points is the “margin of error” built into the IQ test? (Margin of error is a measure of uncertainty about how accurate the score is.) ________ points 2. Some states have abolished the death penalty on their own. Is the death penalty legal in your state? Yes 2. Your Interpretation: Is it cruel and unusual to execute someone after using such a strict method to decide they are not intellectually disabled? No Slide 8: IQ Test: The Court’s Opinion 1. What was the “unacceptable risk” that Florida’s law caused? Slide 9: Should the Death Penalty be Unconstitutional? 1. Do you support or oppose the death penalty? Support Oppose 2. The Court’s written opinion said, “Intellectual disability is a condition, not a number.” What do you think the Court was trying to say to Florida? 2. Find one reason on the list that you agree with and use it to explain your opinion. 3. Percent of Americans that... Support the death penalty % Oppose the death penalty % Slide 10: There’s Always a New Twist Think about everything you’ve learned in this WebQuest. What if the Supreme Court did not have the power to interpret the Constitution? Supreme Interpreters WQ Companion Worksheet p. 2 WQ: Supreme Interpreters Name: ** TEACHER GUIDE ** Instructions: Use this worksheet to collect your answers from the WebQuest. NOTE: There may be questions on this worksheet that are not online. Slide 1: Constitutional Rights Slide 2: It Means What It Says 1. Write the phrases that go in the two blanks. 1. What does judicial review allow the Supreme Court to do? ____freedom____ of _____speech_____ __cruel__ and __unusual_ ___punishment__ 2. Do these rights sound familiar? Yes No Judicial review lets the judicial branch make sure the other branches of government are following the Constitution. 2. Why do you think the Supreme Court needs to be able to interpret the Constitution? Answers will vary 3. Do you see any explanation of what these phrases mean? Answers will vary Yes No Slide 3: Freedom to Lie? Slide 4: Freedom to Lie: The Court’s Opinion Your Interpretation: Should Alvarez be charged with a crime for his lie, or should his lie be protected by freedom of speech? Explain your opinion. 1. Justice Kennedy talked about two kinds of speech that the First Amendment protects. What did he say? Answers will vary He said the First Amendment "protects the speech we detest as well as the speech we embrace." 2. Three justices dissented (disagreed). Why did they think this kind of lie should not be protected? They think the law does not threaten free speech and that lies about military medals harm those who receive the medals and undermine our country’s system of military honors. Slide 5: Protected Speech 1. Choose one kind of speech NOT protected by freedom of speech. Explain why you think people don’t have the right to do that. Answers will vary 2. Is there an activity you think is on the wrong list? (Something you think the Court should have decided differently?) Yes No Explain why you think people should or should not have that right. Answers will vary Supreme Interpreters WQ Companion Worksheet p. 1 WQ: Supreme Interpreters Name: ** TEACHER GUIDE ** Slide 6: That’s cruel and unusual! Slide 7: Very Detailed Interpretations 1. Which execution methods are constitutional? (Hint: They’re the ones states are still using.) 1. How many points is the “margin of error” built into the IQ test? (Margin of error is a measure of uncertainty about how accurate the score is.) Lethal injection; electrocution; gas chamber; hanging; firing squad. 2. Some states have abolished the death penalty on their own. Is the death penalty legal in your state? Yes No ___5___ points 2. Your Interpretation: Is it cruel and unusual to execute someone after using such a strict method to decide they are not intellectually disabled? Answers will vary Answers will vary by state Slide 8: IQ Test: The Court’s Opinion 1. What was the “unacceptable risk” that Florida’s law caused? That people with intellectual disabilities will be executed. 2. The Court’s written opinion said, “Intellectual disability is a condition, not a number.” What do you think the Court was trying to say to Florida? Answers will vary, but students should indicate that the Court wanted Florida to be more flexible and consider additional factors. Slide 9: Should the Death Penalty be Unconstitutional? 1. Do you support or oppose the death penalty? Support Oppose 2. Find one reason on the list that you agree with and use it to explain your opinion. Answers will vary 3. Percent of Americans that... Support the death penalty 63 % Oppose the death penalty 33 % Slide 10: There’s Always a New Twist Think about everything you’ve learned in this WebQuest. What if the Supreme Court did not have the power to interpret the Constitution? Answers will vary, but students should indicate that the Court would have a hard time adapting the Constitution to specific situations; they might also say that it would be difficult for the Court (or anyone) to know what the Constitution means. Supreme Interpreters WQ Companion Worksheet p. 2