devonian spores from outer trøndelag, norway nor
Transcription
devonian spores from outer trøndelag, norway nor
DEVONIAN SPORES FROM OUTER TRØNDELAG, NORWAY KEITH C. ALLEN Allen, K. C.: Devonian spores from outer TrØndelag, Norway. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift, Vol. 56, pp. 437-448. Oslo 1976. Rock samples for palynological study were collected from a number of localities in outer Trøndelag. From these samples, poorly preserved but identifiable spores were obtained from three localities. Those from small islands north of Tristein indicate an Emsian age equivalent, those from Døsvik on Ørlandet a probable Lower Devonian age, and those from an island west of Storfosna a probable Emsian or Eifelian age equivalent. K. C. A Ilen, Department of Botany, The University, Bristol, BS8 l UG, England. Samples for palynological study were collected by the author from Hitra, Døsvik and along a road section near Bjugn in Ørlandet, Storfosna and islands west of Storfosna, and from the Tristein island region north-west of Vallersund (Fig. 1). Samples collected by S. Siedlecki from Hitra and from Løvøya south of Smøla in southernmost outer Trøndelag were also prepared. In none of these samples were the spores well-preserved, most being highly carbonised. Those from the small islands north of Tristein produced the best spores, but identifiable spores were also obtained from an island west of Storfosna and from Døsvik. Samples from the road section near Bjugn produced a few simple spores, which gave no clear indication of their age. Several samples prepared from Hitra, mostly from member D of the Hitra Formation (Siedlecka & Siedlecki 1972: 3), yielded dark apparently organic remains, but no spores. Preparation of samples The extraction of the spores followed the usual palynological techniques, employing warm hydrofluoric acid, dilute hydrochloric acid, and Schulze's reagent. Samples were not treated with a weak alkaline solution, as this tended to further darken the spores. Residues were mounted in Clearol, and after drying, in D.P.X. mountant. All figured specimens are housed in the Palaeobotanical Collection, Department of Botany, University of Bristol, England, and are referred to by a preparation slide number, followed by 'east-west' and 'north-south' NOR 5/11, 58.9 99.6, N31). The stage readings are from a Leitz Orthoplan Micro scope serial no. 715334 in the Department of Botany, University of Bristol. mechanical stage readings, and then by a rock specimen number (e.g. 438 K. C. ALLEN The Tristein region Rock samples were collected from lenses of fine grey sandstones and silt stones within the reddish conglomerate sequence, on four small islands north of Tristein (Fig. 1). The samples contained an abundance of Hyenia ramosa (Høeg) mostly as impression material. The samples are all from about the same stratigraphical horizon, and form part of a single assemblage. Vogt (1929) recorded fossil plants from some islands north of Tristein, which were referred to Psilophyton princeps by Halle. Høeg (1945) collected and identified Psilophyton sp. and Hyenia ramosa from several skerries near Tristein. It is clear that both Høeg's samples and those collected by the author are from about the same horizon, though Høeg's samples were red rather than grey. Based on the presence of Hyenia, Høeg indicated a Middle Devonian age for these beds. Later, Høeg (1966) suggested that Psilophyton sp. may be Thursophyton, and again indicated a Middle Devonian age. Nilsen (1973) suggested that this outcrop probably represents a separate Devonian basin slightly younger than that further south in this area. Microfloral assemblage Twenty-seven of the thirty-one species shown in Table l were recorded from the Tristein region. The abundance of each species is expressed as a figure out of a count of 200 specimens. Where a species was not recorded in the count, it is marked with an X. All species are illustrated in Figs. 2-4. .. tfJ.,..., a er/'" � Vallersund Tristeino /) CJ o l 5 l Fig. 1. The outer TrØndelag region from which palynological samples were collected. 439 DEVONIAN SPORES FROM TRØNDELAG Table l. Age (where restricted) The Spore species Tristein Island Døsvik region Lower Devonian Leiotriletes pagius Allen west of Storfosna 3 Calamospora atava (Naumova) McGregor *Calamospora pannucea Richardson Retusotriletes dubiosus McGregor Retusotriletes pychovii Naumova *Apiculiretusispora plicata (Allen) Streel Apiculiretusi.rpora sp. 20 7 2 22 67 X X X X 4 X X *Apiculatisporites perpusillus (Naumova) McGregor Emsian *Dibolisporites wetteldorjensis Emsian *Anapiculatisporites grandispinus Emsian *cf. Procoronaspora ambigua Emsian *Verrusosisporites devonicus McGregor Lanninger (Naumova) Schultz Butterworth and Williams X 14 X l l 13 X Converrucosisporites minor (Schultz) comb. nov. (Schopfites minor of Schultz) *Brochotriletes sp. Emsian and Siegenian 2 2 Dictyotriletes emsiensis (Allen) McGregor Dictyotriletes sp. l X Emphanisporites rotatus (McGregor) MeGregor Emphanisporites robustus McGregor X l Lower Devonian *Acinosporites munstereijeliensis (Franke) Streel Emsian and Siegenian Eifelian to Siegenian Lower Eifelian 13 Aneurospora sp. l *Geminospora sp. 3 Craspedispora craspeda Allen X Stenozonotriletes incessus Allen X Rhabdosporites cymatilis Allen l to Siegenian Rhabdosporites langii (Eisenack) Richardson X X Rhabdosporites parvulus Richardson 7 X Perotrilites sp. Punctatisporites sp. dominant! y Middle 15 X X X Dibolisporites echinaceus (Eisenack) Richardson X Devonian dominantly Hystricosporites sp. X Grandispora sp. X Middle Devonian dominant! y Middle Devonian K. C. ALLEN 440 Notes on selected species The species mentioned here are indicated with an asterisk in Table l. Ca/anspora pannucea Richardson. - I have followed McGregor (1973) in separating this species from Calamospora atava (Naumova) McGregor, on size difference. In C. pannucea, the darkened central area often extends over half the proximal surface. _ (Allen) Streel. - This is the most common species in the Tristein Region assemblage. It shows a wide size range (40-150 !!)· The ornament is sometimes very small, and in such cases unless studied under oil, resembles Retusotriletes. Two specimens have a small papilla on each of the three contact areas. Apiculiretusispora plicata (Naumova) McGregor. - The author follows McGregor (1973: 24) in separating this species from Granulatisporites new portensis Chaloner and Streel on the basis that it lacks interradial papillae. Apiculatisporites perpusillus Lanninger. - One of the more common species, it usually has a larger ornament in the equatorial region, especially in the interradial areas (Fig. 2, N). This species is recorded from the Emsian of Germany by Lanninger 1968 and the Emsian (Battery Point, Lower As semblage) of Canada by McGregor 1973. Dibolisporites wetteldorfensis Fig. 2. All photographs X 500 unless otherwise stated; from unretouched negatives. Leiotriletes pagius Allen. A. Proximal surface; NOR 2113,59.7 98.4, N33. B. A,B. Broken specimen showing azonate nature of the exine; NOR 2124, 54.7 103.3 N33. Calamospora atava (Nau�va) McGregor. Proximal surface; NOR 2113, 49.8 110.3, N33. C. D. Calamospora pannucea Richardson. NOR 2/20, 40.1 100.1, N33. E. Retusotriletes dubiosus McGregor. Proximal surface; NOR 15/1, 50.1 105.4, N28. F. Retusotriletes pychovii Naumova. Proximal surface; NOR 5/35, 53.0 107.4, N31. G,H, Apiculiretusispora plicata (Allen) Streel. G. Typically folded specimen, NOR 2115, 48.9 103.2, N33. H. Specimen showing curvaturae; NOR 2124, 52.0 97.2, N33. I. Apiculiretusispora sp. Proximal surface; NOR 2121, 52.3 106.7, N33. J. Apiculatispories perpusillus. Chaloner & Streel. Distal surface; NOR 512, 47.4 K. Anapiculatisporites grandispinus (Naumova) Schultz. Distal surface; 106.6, N31. NOR 212, 47.4 98.7, N33. L. cf. Procoronaspora ambigua Butterworth & Williams. Proximal surface; NOR 2110, 30.6 98.6, N33. M,N. Dibolisporites wetteldorfensis Lanninger. M. Distal surface; NOR 2110, 47.6 102.2, N33. N. Proximal surface; NOR 2121, 38.3 97.5, N 33. Both specimens show larger ornament in the equatorial interradial area. 0-Q. Converrucosisporites minor (Schultz) comb. nov. O. Equatorial surface; NOR 512, 38.8, 108.2, N31. P. The same X1000. Q. Distal surface (X 1,000) showing verrucae which are often angled as seen in surface view, and having a denser exine in the angles. NOR 2121, 45.6 108.0, N33. DEVONIAN SPORES FROM TRØNDELAG Fig. 2. 441 442 K. C. ALLEN (Naumova) Schultz. - This species is re corded from the Emsian of West Germany by Schultz 1968. Streel (1967) records Anapiculatisporites sp. C. a similar spore, from the Emsian of Bel gium, cf. Procoronaspora ambigua resembles P. ambigua Butterworth and Williams, but the Norwegian spores, although having a larger ornament in the interradial equatorial region, also have a small ornament radially. This would also appear to be the case in Schultz's specimens. Anapiculatisporites grandispinus Verrucosisporites devonicus McGregor. - The Norwegian specimens have a smaller size range than that recorded by McGregor in Canada from rocks of Emsian age. Also, the proximal surface is never flat or laevigate. sp. - Too few specimens are present for specific designation. They appear to be intermediate between McGregor's Brochotriletes robustus and Brochotriletes sp. B. Brochotriletes (Franke) Streel. - This is the !argest spore in this assemblage, ranging from 80---180 11 (there are same unidentifiable fragments of spores reaching 220 !1). In same specimens, the bases of the biform ornament do not anastomose, and the specimens could be included within Dibolisporites. In overmacerated specimens, a closely appressed in texine can be seen. The illustration of Retusotriletes antiquus Kedo in Lan ninger 1968 (pl. 20, fig. 22) appears similar. Acinosporites munstereifeliensis Geminospora differs from sp. - Too few specimens are present, to erect a new species. It Reigel, in having a verrucate ornament. Geminospora traverica Age of the assemblage A number of points suggest an Emsian age equivalent for this assemblage. Fig. 3. All photographs X 500 unless otherwise stated; from unretouched negatives. A,B. Verrucosisporites devonicus McGregor. A. Lateral view; NOR 5/11, 52.4 105.4, N31. B. Lateral view, showing smaller ornamentation on the proximal surface, a feature of about half the specimens; NOR 5/11, 58.9 99.6, N31. D. Brochotrilets sp. Distal surface; Dictyotriletes ernsiensis (Allen) E,F. Dictyotriletes C. NOR 5/2, 40.3 109.5, N31. McGregor. Distal surface; NOR 2/19, 51.5 96.0 N33. sp. E. Distal surface; NOR 5/17, 46.4 93.4, N31. F. The same X 1,000, showing the low, narrow reticulate ornament. G,H. Emphanisporites rotatus (McGregor) McGregor. G. Proximal surface; NOR 5/46, 51.6 107.1, N31. H. Proximal surface; NOR 5/16, 35.7 107.3, N31. Ernphanisporites robustus McGregor. Proximal surface; NOR 17/5,26.3 Acinosporites rnunstereifeliensis (Franke) Streel K. Typical large dark K,L. Acinosporites munstereifeliensis (Franke) Streel. K. Typical large dark l. J. 95.4, N33. specimen; specimen; NOR 2134, 34.7 93.8, N33. L. Showing ornament separating from the rest of the exine in the lower part of the photograph; NOR 2/7, 61.3 111.5, N33. DEVONIAN SPORES FROM TRØNDELAG Fig. 3. 443 444 K. C. ALLEN The overall species list includes several species found only in the Emsian or Lower Devonian (see Table 1). Both Craspedispora craspeda Allen and Dictyotriletes emsiensis (Allen) McGregor have to date been found only in the Emsian and Siegenian. In the Norwegian specimens of D. emsiensis, the muri in the equatorial region form a distinct 'zone' (Fig. 3, D), unlike those from Spitsbergen (Allen 1965) and Canada (McGregor 1973). Procoro naspora sp. is recorded by McGregor et al. 1970, from the Stooping River and Sextant Formation in Canada; by Jardine and Yapandjian 1968 from the Emsian of the Sahara (McGregor 1970: 47); and by Konior and Turnau 1973 from probable Emsian rocks of Poland. There is a high proportion of both laevigate and apiculate retusoid forms, a common feature of the Lower Devonian, and especially the Emsian (Lan ninger 1968: 159). There is also a tendency for the ornament to separate from the. rest of the exine (Fig. 3, L), a common feature in Lower Devonian spores, and particularly in the Emsian (e.g. Streel 1964 (pl. 3, fig. 40) and McGregor 1973 (pl. 2, fig. 14)). Another characteristic which appears to be a quite common feature of upper Lower Devonian spores is a tendency for the ornament to be larger in the interradial equatorial region, not only in cf. Procoronaspora ambigua, but also in Dibolisporites wetteldorfensis, Acino sporites munstereifeliensis, Anapiculatisporites grandispinus, and Rhabdo sporites parvulus. The only dominantly Middle Devonian spore which occurs, albeit rarely, in this assemblage is Rhabdosporites langii (Eisenack) Richardson. lts lowest published record is Eifelian (Richardson 1974), but Riegel (pers. comm.) finds R. langii in beds of Upper Emsian age in Germany, where there is good stratigraphic control. In terms of spore construction, the Norwe gian material shows quite close comparison with Schultz's (1968) and Lan ninger's (1968) Emsian assemblages, rather than with the more varied con struction of Riegel's (1968, 1973) or Hamid's (1974) Eifelian assemblages, all from West Germany. Døsvik, Ørlandet Rock samples were collected from the coast just north-east of Døsvik (Fig. 1). Fig. 4. All photographs X 500, from unretouched negatives. A,B. Geminospora sp. A, NOR 2/16, 31.9 94.8, N33, B. Distal surface; NOR 2116, 36.7 107.8, N33. C. D. E. F. G. H. I. J. Craspedispora craspeda Allen. Proximal surface; NOR 5/16, 60.4 111.1, N31. Stenozonotriletes incessus Allen. Proximal surface; NOR 5/17, 42.1 109.2, N31. Rhabdosporites cymatilis Allen. NOR 17/6, 39.9 98.5, N33. Rhabdosporites parvulus Richardson. Distal surface; NOR 1111, 39.7 100.0, N27. Rhabdosporites langii Richardson. Equatorial view; NOR 11/1 52.7 96.0, N27. Perotrilites sp. Proximal surface; NOR 2/13 26.7 111.4, N33. Hystricosporites sp. Lateral view; NOR 11/1, 48.7 102.5, N27. Grandispora sp. Distal surface; NOR 15/2, 30.0 105.2, N28. DEVONIAN SPORES FROM TRØNDELAG Fig. 4. 445 446 K. C. ALLEN These were mostly hard, dark grey siltstones with occasional unidentifiable dichotomising stem fragments, from below the polymictic conglomerate (Richter 1949, 1958). Vogt 1929 recorded plants from Døsvik, and these were later described by Høeg 1945 as Psilophyton rectissimum Høeg, Hostimella sp., and the sporangium of a psilophyte. On the basis of these plant remains, Høeg sug gested very tentatively a Lower Devonian age. Later Høeg (1966) also recorded Drepanophycus spinaeformis, a Lower Devonian plant, from Døsvik. Microfloral assemblage The seven species recorded are shown in Table l. Because of poor preservation, several of the specimens, particularly simple laevigate and apiculate forms, are difficult to identify. The spores which are identifiable also occur in the hetter preserved samples from the Tristein region. On the basis of the few species present a Lower Devonian age seems probable. Island west of Storfosna Samples were collected from well-bedded grey micaceous sandstones within the massive conglomerate sequence on a small island between Storslåttøy and Storfosna (Fig. 1). Small, unidentifiable, poorly preserved, unbranched stem axes were present. Vogt 1924 recorded some fossil plants, which, according to his map (Vogt 1929: 60, fig. 4), would appear to be from Storslåttøy. However, no clear indication of the age was given, either here, or in subsequent publica tions (Richter 1949, 1958, Holtedahl 1960). Microfloral assemblage The nine species recorded are shown in Table l. The presence of Hystricosporites sp., Grandispora sp., and Rhabdosporites langii (up to 240 fl, and more common than in the Tristein region) suggests an age slightly younger than that for the Tristein region, possibly an Eifelian age equivalent, and certainly not older than the Tristein sediments. Conclusions Firstly, a more exact age based on the microflora can now be given for the Devonian of the Tristein region, and west of Storfosna, with confirmation of a Lower Devonian age at Døsvik. Secondly, the rocks west of Storfosna are at least as young and probably younger than those in the Tristein region. Thirdly, the spore assemblage of the Tristein region indicates an Emsian age, and represents the oldest rocks from which Hyenia has yet been recorded. Though the author has not processed samples for palynological study from DEVONIAN SPORES FROM TRØNDELAG 447 the Nordfjord region, it would appear that the Hye nia-bearing sediments north of Tristein are older than the Hyenia bearing rocks of the Nordfjord region, which are dated as Givetion on the fish fauna (Jarvik 1949). Fourthly, it is probable that the Devonian of the Tristein region and the Døsvik area are about the same age, and are at least both Lower Devonian. Fifthly, the youngest Devonian rocks in the north-east, south-west trending series of exposures from south of Smøla to Ørlandet, are as young and prob ably younger than those of the Tristein region, contrary to what is suggested by Nilsen (1973, 477). Finally, it is interesting to note that if the north-east, south-west trending Hitra sequence is late Ludlovian or possibly Down tonian, based on Dictyocaris slimoni and eurypterid fragments (Reusch 1914, Størmer 1935), it has both to its south-west (Smøla, Peacock's communication in Allen et al. 1967), and to its immediate north-east (present study - west of Storfosna) rocks of considerably younger age. It is unfortunate that neither the Hitra nor the Løvøya samples produced any spores. - Acknowledgements. - I would especially like to thank Dr. S. Siedlecki, who took me to all the localities, and has kindly read the manuscript, and Norges Geologiske Undersø kelse, who supplied the transport. September 1975 REFERENCES Allen, J. R. L., Dineley, D. L. & Friend, P. F. 1967: Old Red Sandstone basins of North America and northwest Europe. In D. H. Oswald (ed.), International Symposium on the Devonian System, Vol. l, Calgary. Alberta Soc. Petroleum Geologists, 69-98. Allen,K. C. 1%5: Lower and Middle Devonian spores of north and central Vestspits bergen. Palaeontology 8, 687-748. Butterworth, M. A. & Williams, R. W. 1958: The small spore floras of coals in the Limestone Coal Group and Upper Limestone Group of the Lower Carboniferous of Scotland. Trans. R. Soc. Edinb. 63, 353-392. Challoner, W. G. & Streel, M. 1968: Lower Devonian spores from South Wales. Argu menta Palaeobot. l, 87-101. Eisenack, A. 1944: Dber einige pflanzliche Funde in Geschieben, nebst Bemerkungen zum Hystrichosphaerideen-Problem. Z. Geschiebeforsch. Flachldgeol. 19, 103-124, 182-186. Franke, F. 1965: Mikrofossilien eines Unterdevonischen Brandschieferprofiles nahe Miinstereifel. lnaug. Dissert. Freien Universitat Berlin. 1-86. Hamid, P. M. 1974: Sporenvergesellschaftungen aus dem unteren Mitteldevon (Eifel Stufe) des siidlichen Bergischen Landes (Rheinisches Schiefergebirge). Neues lb. Geo[. Paliiont. Abh. 147, 163-217. Høeg, O. A. 1945: Contributions to the Devonian flora of western Norway, Ill. Nor. Geol. Tidsskr. 25, 183-192. Høeg, O. A. 1966: Devonfloraen i ytre Trøndelag. Blyttia 24, 218-221. Holtedahl, O. 1960: Devonian. In Holtedahl, O. (ed.), Geology of Norway. Nor. Geo[. Unders. 208, 285-297. Jardine, S. & Yapandjian, L. 1%8: Lithostratigraphie et palynologie du Devonien Gothlandien greseux du Bassin de Polignac (Sahara). Revue Inst. fr. Petrole, 23, 439469. Jarvik, E. 1949: On the Middle Devonian Crossopterygians from the Hornelen Field in western Norway. Univ. Bergen Årb. 1948, 8. 448 K. C. ALLEN Konior, K. & Turnau, E. 1973: Preliminary study of microflora from Lower Devonian deposits in the area of Bielsko-Wadowice. Roczn. pol. Tow. geol. 43, 273-282. Lanninger, E. P. 1968: Sporen-Gesellschaften aus dem Ems der SW-Eifel. Palaeonto graphica B 122, 95-170. McGregor, D. G. 1967: Composition and range of some Devonian spore assemblages of Canada. Rev. Palaeobot. & Palynol. l, 173-183. McGregor, D.C., Sanford, B. V. & Norris, A. W. 1970: Palynology and correlation of Devonian formations in the Moose River. Basin, northern Ontario. Proc. geol. Ass. Can. 22, 45-54. McGregor, D. C. 1973: Lower and Middle Devonian spores of eastern Gaspe, Canada. Palaeontographica B 142, 1-77. Mortimer, M. G. 1967: Some Lower Devonian microfloras from southern Britain. Rev. Palaeobot. & Palynol. l, 95-109. Naumova, S. N. 1953: Spore- pollen assemblages of the Upper Devonian of the Russian Platform and their stratigraphic significance. Trans. Inst. Geol. Sei. Acad. Sei. U.S.S.R. 143 (Geol. Ser. 60), 1-204. [In Russian]. Nilsen, T. H. 1973: Devonian (Old Red Sandstone) sedimentation and tectonics of Norway. Am. Ass. Pet. Geol. Memoir. 19, 471-481. Reusch, H. 1914: Nogen bidrag til Hitterens og Smølens geologi. Nor. Geo[. Unders. 69, 1-50. Richardsen, J. B. 1960: Spores from the Middle Old Red Sandstone of Cromarty, Scot land. Palaeontology 3, 45--63. Richardsen, J. B. 1974: The stratigraphic utilization of some Silurian and Devonian miospore species in the Northern Hemisphere; an attempt at a synthesis. International Symposium on Belgian Micropalaeontological Limits. Min. of Econ. Alf. Adm. Mines. Geol. Surv. of Belgium. 1-13. Richter, M. 1949: Die Devonmollasse am Ausgang des Drontheimfjordes. Z. Dt. Geol. Ges. 99, 1-7. Berlin. Richter, M. 1958: Die Halbinsel orland am Ausgang des Trondheimfjordes. Geologie 7, 757-769. Berlin. Riegel, W. 1968: Die Mitteldevon-Flora von Lindlar (Rheinland). Palaeontographica B 123, 76-96. Riegel, W. 1973: Sporenformen aus den Heisdorf, Lauch, und Nohn-Schichten (Emsium und Eifelium) der Eifel, Rheinland. Palaeontographica B 142, 78-104. Schultz, G. 1968: Eine unterdevonische Mikroflora aus den Klefer Schichten der Eifel (Rheinisches Schiefergebirge). Palaeontographica B 123, 5-42. Siedlecka, A. & Siedlecki, S. 1972: A contribution to the geology of the Downtonian sedimentary rocks of Hitra. Nor. Geol. Unders. 275, 1-28. Størmer, L. 1935: Dictyocaris salter, a large crustacean from the Upper Silurian and Downtonian. Nor. Geo[. Tidsskr. 15, 267-298. Streel, M. 1964: Une association de spores due Givetien inferieur de la Vesdre, a Goe (Belgique). Annls Soc. geol. Belg. 87, 1-30. Streel, M. 1967: Association de spores due Devonien inferieur Beige et leur signification stratigraphique. Annls. Soc. geol. Belg. 90, 11-53. Vogt, T. 1924: Plantefossiler fra Storfosens devonske lagrække. Naturen, 53-56. Vogt, T. 1929: Undersøkelser over den underdevoniske konglomerat-sandstens serie Ytre Trøndelagen. Nor. Geol. Unders. 133, 59--61.