The ToneQuest Report
Transcription
The ToneQuest Report
INSIDE Mountainview Publishing, LLC the Jump Sturdy… Our long and sometimes tortured history with the Stratocaster comes to a happy ending in Ensenada 4 Why the new Roadworn Stratocaster is the best we have ever owned Pickups! 6 We revisit the Custom Shop ‘69s and ‘‘54s Slider’s Classic ‘57s & a few simple improvements to the Roadworn make a big difference 9 Nolatone Ampworks We review three variations on the venerable Road Hogg, plus the Road Hogg Lite combo – the best 1x12 rocker yet! 14 How many ways can a distorted guitar signal be created with a pedal? Brian Wampler on what’s really happening with overdrive, distortion and boost pedals 17 The best echo/delay pedal ever… The Wampler Faux Tape Echo 18 The amazing Collings J35 The Player’s Guide to Ultimate Tone $15.00 US, May 2014/Vol.15 NO.7 Report TM Jump Sturdy Jump what? Oh, man, where you been? Jump Sturdy was a swamp witch roots hustler on Dr. John the Night Tripper’s 1967 debut Gris-Gris album on Atlantic records. The patois of the street in New Orleans often swings between the language of the cool and a more literal interpretation, which is what we’re workin’ here – a fonky dance move to be conjured in your personal Quest for tone, and you’re gonna need it by the time we’re finished with this edition of the Quest… Five years have passed since a Stratocaster was featured on the cover of these pages, and even then it wasn’t a Fender Stratocaster, but a Bill Nash Trenchtown beater. When confronted by Fender, Nash hired a lawyer, stood his ground and successfully reached a compromise that would allow him to continue to build guitars inspired by the original Fender designs. Anyone building Fender copies today owes Bill Nash a debt of gratitude for ponying up the necessary baksheesh when the rest of them were quaking in fear beneath their workbenches. The Strat is undoubtedly the most copied guitar in history, and the number of variations produced by Fender alone is hard to wrap your mind around. For anyone craving a Stratocaster today there are hundreds of options among vintoid booteek Strats, and those made by Fender in Japan, Malaysia, China, Mexico and Corona, California. You could spend as much as $120,000 for a mint condition ‘56 recently sold on GBase, and as little as $99.99 for a Torino red Squier mini Strat. Our perception of the Stratocaster has constantly evolved in the past 14 years with every guitar acquired. We have easily bought a dozen Custom Shop ‘50s and ‘60s Stratocasters, including a desirable shoreline gold Cunetto Relic. We optimized and reviewed several early Japanese reissues, a USA ‘07 Hot Rod ‘62, a Dakota red USA ‘62, a 1999 Olympic White ‘60 Relic with John Cruz neck, a late ‘80s Eric Clapton blackie, three Robert Cray Signature models, a 2010 ‘60 Relic, a couple of Nash Strats, and we created a limited number of ToneQuest Stratocasters in 2006 that were team built with the assistance of USA Custom Guitars, Lollar Guitars and Callaham Guitars. Peter Stroud was given the first prototype, www.tonequest.com cover story and he has told us it is one of his favorite guitars. When we first launched TQR in 1999, we owned a vintage ‘56 hardtail Stratocaster refinished by New York painter Jack Pidgeon. Just a few serial numbers away from Eric Clapton’s famous Brownie, the ‘56 was an impressive instrument with a set of utterly captivating original pickups that uniformly measured around 5.4K ohms. Our very first Strat was a candy apple red ‘66 with the big headstock, found in the Atlanta Journal and Constitution want ads in 1980 and purchased for $400. Despite our best intentions, we could never make that one work for us at all. As much as we have admired and pursued them over the years, the perfect contemporary Stratocaster has always seemed to elude us. Until now… The Custom Shop Strats we acquired have all been well made, but in each case we always felt that we had been forced to make nagging compromises. The Cunetto was cool, but the maple neck never really felt quite right in an odd way, and the guitar seemed stiff and unresponsive. We bought an Aztec gold Custom Shop guitar with a great maple neck stamped by John Cruz, and while the Strat sounded great, it was a bit of a boat anchor, deep into the 8 pound range. We sat in with Bob Margolin one night and Bob mercilessly chastised us over “the heaviest Strat he had ever seen.” We didn’t keep it much longer. Thanks, Bob. We bought a 1960 Custom Shop Relic in Fiesta red that was super light. We were thinking of Ronnie Earl’s Mahalia when we bought it, but the neck profile and frets were too small, and it just seemed to lack power and punch. It looked cool, but the guitar had no attitude. Truthfully, it was probably too light. Imagine that. The gamble you take with solidbody guitars is that some of them just don’t encourage resonant vibrations in all the right frequencies. It’s the wood, and being wood, it can vary to the extreme when used to make musical instruments. You’ll recall the Relic ‘60 we bought for the July-August 2010 Jeff Beck issue, and that was a good guitar except for the artificially corroded saddles and tuners we had to replace. Our last Custom Shop Strat was a beautifully aged relic in 3-tone burst with a rosewood fingerboard, but again the tapered neck profile was too thin and the ‘vintage’ frets just didn’t work for us. We tried to make all these Strats work, sometimes willing ourselves into embracing features that didn’t make them bad guitars – they just weren’t the right guitars for us. If there is one variation that we could call a consistent favorite it has been the Robert Cray Signature Strat made in Mexico. The neck profile is much bigger than Custom Shop guitars with rosewood fingerboards or ‘62 reissues, medium jumbo frets are standard, and the pickups sound just like Cray’s, because they are. Like our old ‘56, hardtails also have a very unique and soulful sound. Have Stratocasters occasionally gone in and out of style? It seems so, especially during Led Zeppelin’s zenith and after Stevie Ray Vaughan hit his stride. On one level there were too many players trying to sound like Stevie in the ‘90s and a lot of working pros eventually decided that it was kind of pointless bringing a Strat out after he had utterly burned down the house so convincingly. Clapton wasn’t intimidated, but the boost circuit in his Signature Stratocaster places it on a completely different level that far exceeds stereotypical Stratocaster tones. The original Clapton Strat loaded with gold Lace Sensor pickups is completely underrated, although the neck on ours could no longer be fully straightened with the truss rod. The Stratocaster remains a consummate workhorse, exceptionally comfortable to play, and capable of cutting the gig in a very wide range of musical styles. With the right amp and pedals, it is also one of the most formidable hard rockin’ guitars ever created. Of course, the champion strangler of the Stratocaster in our time remains Jeff Beck, and this isn’t even open to debate, with a respectful nod to Mark Knopfler, David Gilmour, Doyle Bramhall II, Anson Funderburgh, Ronnie Earl, and your favorites, too. In the past decade prices for vintage Strats and even those from the late ‘60s that no one wanted in the ‘80s have steadily swelled, now Stephen Bruton elevated to collectible commodities rather than musical instruments. We -continued- 2 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 cover story will never forget what the late and great Stephen Bruton said to us about the vintage guitar scene in the November ‘02 issue of TQR: “Well, I got in before eBay destroyed everything. You can’t get a deal on anything anymore. I mean, everybody wants to get as much as they can for something they’re selling, but there are also a lot of us that don’t do that. We keep placing instruments and amps with other players, and not for top dollar, with the hope that we might get it back at some point if they ever have to sell it. I don’t go to guitar shows. I don’t like that whole scene. There are a lot of people that buy rare things and just put ‘em on the wall, and that pisses me off. These instruments and amps are supposed to be played, and played by people who can afford them. It’s ridiculous – people paying six figures for a freaking guitar that’s just a bunch of wires and wood. Frankly, I don’t think there’s a Telecaster or Stratocaster made that’s worth more than about $500. Greed is the number one of the Seven Deadlies, you know? And no one is immune to it – I’m not, you’re not – but this eBay thing has destroyed anybody gettin’ a deal.” Bruton planted a seed that resonated with the truth… Let’s see, you got a maple neck, fret wire, an alder or ash body – neither of which costs much at all, three primitive single coil pickups, some hardware and screws, lacquer, labor, and the entire thing is held together with four screws… How much could it cost to build that? Put another way, how much should it cost to buy that? When you are procuring as much wood and hardware as Fender does, their unit cost is very, very low before you add the expense of doing anything in California, labor and employee benefits. On the other hand, there are artists and builders like Tom Anderson, John Suhr, Scott Lentz, Chuck Thornton, Ron Thorn, Andy Elliott and many others building guitars inspired by the Stratocaster that are expensive because they have to be for the builder to survive. Still, for an unadorned, straight ahead vintage-style Strat, two or three grand seems a little steep. As players and consumers, things are also so much more complicated now. We have dozens of pickup winders all claiming to have tapped into the holy grail… How many different ways can you wind a Stratocaster coil, and in 2014, how many different sources exist in the world for pickup wire, bobbins and magnets? Not many. Sure, a winder can tug on the wire to alter the tension and stretch the wire as it goes on the bobbin, guide the wire by hand in a random or uniform pattern, and vary the type of magnets used between Alnico II,III, IV and V. They can vary the number of turns on the coils, choose wire with different insulating coatings and gauges, and in the end it is the sum of all these variables that determines the sound of a pickup and whether we like it or not. Pickup winders are mechanized chefs, and every one of them is selling a secret sauce for what has remained a very rudimentary device, yet one with the potential of delivering gloriously magical tones. So what is the state of the Stratocaster today? It remains an immensely popular guitar, and rightfully so. The basic design is brilliant, nothing less. As potential buyers, we are all affected by different motivating factors… Some people feel that they must spend big to get the best. Collectors don’t evaluate guitars by their worth as instruments or by their tone. They are in the business of buying trophy guitars. Look what I have. Even if their friends don’t have a clue why one guitar should be more important than another, collectors develop their own hierarchy that is inextricably tied to exclusivity and the price paid. More expensive must be better. A limited edition must be better still… Fender has been wisely milking this marketing strategy for years with Masterbuilt guitars, limited editions and escalating prices for ordinary Custom Shop instruments that sell for many times what it costs to build them. And who can blame Fender for doing that? We don’t. But we’ve had our fling with spending $2600 on a used Fender Custom Shop guitar, and the fling is over. We no longer feel that we need to spend that much to get the best. Ironically, as Fender has steadily increased the prices of their Custom Shop instruments, they have also dramatically increased the quality of lower priced guitars, and that is the story we are about to share. How can you navigate the mind-numbing number of Stratocasters in existence and find the guitar of your dreams? First and foremost, you got to have enough faith and nerve to Jump Sturdy. Now grab a cold drink, put yer feet up, open your mind and Enjoy… -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 3 guitars 2013 Roadworn Stratocaster Last month we shared our past aversion to the Roadworn series of guitars. It’s one thing to mangle a guitar in an effort to create the impression of heavy use – Bill Nash has done very well with that concept even though we have never seen an old Strat that has suffered quite the level of abuse equal to a Nash beater… But the sanding and aging on the Roadworn Strats and Teles Nash beater were wholly unbelievable – amateurish and crude, as if to suggest “I couldn’t afford a relic, so I settled for this.” It’s kinda hard to strut your stuff with a really bad parody of an old guitar hanging on your neck, eh? Fender’s Mike Eldred wouldn’t be caught dead playing one of the early Roadworns sitting in at the Doll Hut in Anaheim. Hell, no he wouldn’t. As originally conceived, they weren’t serious guitars. They are now. The Roadworn Tele featured last month inspired us to look for a 2013 Roadworn Stratocaster. Our search in early March failed to turn up what we wanted as new stock, so we trolled eBay and found a 2013 Roadworn ‘50s Strat described by the seller as having been bought a month earlier at Sweetwater, and his son had decided he wanted a Les Paul. Three bids were placed and we sniped it for $590 – $300 less than the actual $899 street price. The Strat arrived the following week and like our 2013 Roadworn Telecaster, the craftsmanship, fine details, finish, aging and overall appearance were equal to any Custom Shop guitar we have owned. Well, except for one thing… the seller, who was located in Vermont, had kept the guitar in a hot and arid room causing the neck to shrink and sharp fret ends to pop out on all 21 frets. Razor sharp, the guitar was unplayable, and the seller hadn’t bothered to mention it. Welcome to eBay. We hit Duane The Vermont Ass Clown with an e-mail – send a $100 refund for our trouble or take it back, your call. He agreed to a refund, but then decided not to pay it after we ended our claim with eBay, so we left him some well-deserved stinky feedback and moved on. There are no mistakes. Aside from the fret ends, the Strat was an utterly amazing departure from the Roadworn guitars we had seen before. You can read about all kinds of home remedies for sharp fret ends online. We recall one cold winter when Dave Tiller at Midtown Music had to bring in three humidifiers after all the necks had shrunk on dozens of new Fender guitars, but we decided to go to the source and call Joe Glaser in Nashville. Joe suggested we buy a long, fine file and try to find one that was a little bowed and not dead straight, have at it, running the file along the fret ends, up and down the neck. He also said that using a humidifier would work, but we’d be facing the same problem next winter… Whipping out a big steel file on yer precious baby sounds scary, but it isn’t if you’re careful and not too jacked up on a triple vente latte. We bought a 9-inch bastard file for $9 at Home Depot and had the fret tangs filed back down in less than an hour. The neck otherwise looked untouched, and since the file was indeed just a little bowed, we found it easy to file the tangs without scraping wood. The actual fret ends still felt a little rough, so we broke out a package of Stew-Mac Fret Erasers provided by Erick Coleman, TQR advisory board member and tech at Stew-Mac. The Fret Erasers come in five grits ranging from coarse #180 to extra fine #1000 and being soft, they conform to the fret profile as you use them with the stainless steel fingerboard guards Erick included. The pack of five Fret Erasers sells for $30.95. Using the coarse grit and then repeating with #400, we were able to nicely smooth and polish the fret ends with excellent results. Recommended. www.stewmac.com Now we could finally get down to business, beginning with a proper setup and an evaluation of the stock Tex-Mex Fender pickups, which we had never heard. If you aren’t experienced at setting up Strats with a tremolo bridge, it can be frustrating, and it is always a little more time consuming. We began by changing the strings to a set of .010-.048 Pyramid roundcore Nickel Classics. Tuned to pitch, the bridge was now canted too far out of the body, so we detuned and adjusted the -continued- 4 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 guitars screws for the trem claw, adding enough tension to the three springs to leave the bridge almost but not quite flat on the body at pitch. Next we sighted the neck, and as we anticipated, it was bowed now because of the extra tension exerted from our adjustment to the trem claw. We removed the strings from the tuner posts and pulled the neck, noting a September 2013 date stamp on the heel. We gave the truss rod a couple of full turns, bolted the neck back on and tuned up. Whoah! Way too much back bow now, so off with the neck again, back the truss rod off a full turn (yes, it’s guess work) and try again. Perfect! The neck now revealed just a hint of slight relief on the treble side, so we began to adjust the height of each saddle. Tedious? Yes, but you got to keep yer eye on the prize… Like anything in life, repetition has its rewards, and we have become very adept at adjusting saddle height to follow the radius of the fingerboard and achieve the desired string height, feel and action with minor final adjustments. It didn’t take long to nail the setup and set intonation. Finally, we were ready to actually play the Strat. But first, we should describe the guitar… Weighing 7.15 lbs., the body is finished in nitro and the neck in urethane. The 2-tone vintage sunburst finish really does do justice to an original ‘50s Strat, with the subtle alder grain highlighted within the burst. Whatever you may have heard about ‘butcher block’ bodies from Mexico assembled from glued up pieces of wood covered in a thin veneer, the body of the Roadworn is definitely solid. We have seen original ‘50s 2-tone bursts at guitar shows that didn’t look nearly as good. The 2-piece alder body reveals a perfectly matched and barely visible single center seam – no 3-piece or off-center seams that you may have seen on other ‘affordable’ sunburst Strats. The slight aging is extremely well done, and far more subtle and realistic than many of the Custom Shop relics we have owned from the past decade. The hardware is also aged very realistically with none of the chemically induced heavy corrosion that we have bitched about with relics in the past. It appears, at least, that the hardware is being aged by tumbling instead of being chemically treated. Like our Roadworn Tele, the finish on the back of the neck has been lightly sanded to a matte finish without scraping the finish down to bare wood. The neck shape is a perfectly executed ‘50s V consistently measuring 13/16” thick with no taper, with a vintage 7.5” fingerboard radius and ample tall fret wire similar to 6105. You’ll note no heavy aging on the fingerboard – like the back of the neck, it has been lightly sanded just enough to take off the gloss, leaving a smooth surface that doesn’t feel tacky like a gloss finish. Tone Let’s see… when it comes to Stratocaster pickups we have installed and evaluated a lot – original ‘50s vintage Fender, Fender ‘Original’ ‘57/’62 (standard in Fender Relics), Custom Shop Fat ‘50s, ‘54s and ‘69s, Fender Vintage Noiseless, Texas Specials, Fender Robert Cray, Amalfitano, Kinman, Don Mare, Harmonic Design, Kent Armstrong, Van Zandt, Alan Hamel, Barden, Rio Grande, Will Boggs, Lindy Fralin, Lollar, Slider and Rolph, among others. We had not heard the stock Fender Tex-Mex pickups initially designed for the Jimmie Vaughan Signature Strat, and the pickups measured 6.25K/neck, 6.31K middle and 7.07K bridge. That seems overwound by anyone’s standards, yet the Alnico 5 Tex-Mex pickups capture classic Fender tones played clean, with brilliant treble and mind-altering low end. The crisp and shimmering out-of phase 2 and 4 positions were among the best we have ever heard, the neck pickup is stunning, and the middle is brighter and more complex than most Strat middle pickups – often a weakness. The bridge is bright for sure, but not screechy or brash. This may not be your first choice for heavily overdriven rock where you want a thicker tone, but for cleaner tones and blues they are damn good and absolutely worthy of your attention. We were really quite impressed. -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 5 guitars For this project we initially decided to revisit very affordable Fender pickups, and we bought a set of Custom Shop ‘69s and ‘54s online for $135 and $115 respectively. We have reviewed them in the past but it’s been ten years or more, and we were interested in hearing them in the Roadworn Strat. With all the hype surrounding the next boutique, musthave set of custom pickups that are destined to appear on the merry-go-round of tone, should we really ignore pickups designed and wound by Fender? We suppose some people might assume that being as big as they are, Fender no longer maintains rigid quality control standards or sources the highest quality materials equal to pickups made by small, custom winders. In other words, they have no pride whatsoever, and among all the deeply experienced guitar nuts that happen to work there, nobody gives a rat’s ass about tone… Sounds pretty stupid, doesn’t it? Well, we are about to find out… Fender Custom Shop ‘69s The last and only time we have previously reviewed these pickups was in a Japanese reissue Stratocaster featured in our January 2000 issue. We sent the neck to Stevie Ray Vaughan’s former tech in Dallas, Rene Martinez for a refret (no bass frets for us, thank you), and for $400 that was a nice guitar, although the pickups, pots and wiring had to be replaced, and the urethane finish on the Japanese reissues is extremely thick. Things have only gotten better, and if you had asked us in 2000 we would have never seen it coming. The Custom Shop ‘69s were originally wound by Abagail Ybarra, Fender’s longtime pickup winder since 1958 who retired last year. Of course, her signed ‘69 sets now sell for $250-$500. We didn’t feel inclined to pony up the Abby tax, so we bought a new set online for about half of what someone’s custom set would cost. The ‘69s are wound on bobbins with ‘60s-era grey fibre bottoms using staggered Alnico 5 magnets and enamel coated wire with a stated resistance measurement of 5.8K for all three pickups. The concept of purposefully staggering the output of Stratocaster pickups was not something done at Fender during the ‘50s and ‘60s. The pickups randomly varied, but in the late ‘60s they were more consistent than they had been in the past. The first thing we noted as we unpacked the new set of Custom Shop ‘69s was their actual resistance readings, which were considerably lower than the 5.8K stated by Fender, at 5.15K/Neck, 5.13K/Middle, and 5.17K/Bridge. Whether this can fairly be viewed as a negative is debatable, although if you are going to cite a precise specification, it would be more reassuring to get closer than the pickups we bought. Since the actual size of the wire on a spool can also vary from the specified gauge, discrepancies can occur in resistance readings among pickups wound with the exact same number of turns. The ambient temperature at the time you take measurements can also affect readings. Resistance measurements aside, the Custom Shop ‘69s sound really good – bright, clear and extremely percussive, with scooped mids, and a very unique, piano-like timbre. The wound strings are rich, vocal and clear, and treble tones are classic Fender with a shimmering, pristine quality. The ‘69 neck pickup is truly one of the best you will ever experience, and the middle pickup is equally clear, vocal and toneful. Our memories of this set quickly returned as we played, and in our opinion this is the most distinctive and easily recognizable pickup set wound by the Custom Shop. As we recalled, the keenly bright character of the ‘69 bridge pickup is the sole potential weakness for some players, and especially those who use overdrive effects or play through high gain amplifiers. The ‘69 bridge is so bright that it can sound too thin and sharp with pedals or a cranked amp. One possible remedy would be to substitute a warmer bridge pickup like that found in the Custom Shop ‘54 set. Nevertheless, the Custom Shop ‘69 pickups produce an utterly classic Fender tone that is both unmistakable and unforgettable. We can’t possibly know if they will be your favorites, but if we had two Stratocasters, it seems that at least one loaded with Custom Shop ‘69s would be desirable. Fender Custom Shop ‘54s We should note that the installation of our new Fender pickups was fairly straightforward, with a few caveats… We happened to have a new, high quality USA CRL Centralab 5-way spring-loaded switch on hand so we swapped it for the cheaper, stock 5-way in the Roadworn. The stock plastic covered wiring is substantial enough, but unfortunately they tightly wrap the wire around -continued- 6 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 guitars the lugs on the 5-way prior to soldering and the lead-free, environmentally PC RoHS solder is a bitch to melt where the three pickup ground wires are soldered to the volume pot. Junking the 5-way switch makes pickup replacement much easier than trying to get the wrapped wires and solder off the lugs. The stock 250K +/- 10% pots are CTS and worth keeping, and you can avoid burning up the volume pot by melting solder on top of the existing solder when removing the pickup ground wires. Not recommended with a low-wattage hardware store soldering iron, however. We also modified the wiring to add a tone control to the bridge pickup (see diagram). If any of the pickups in a Stratocaster need a tone control, it’s the bridge, yet adhering to ‘vintage’ dogma, few Fender production Strats are wired with a tone control for the bridge pickup. It’s an easy fix, and in our opinion, essential. The Custom Shop ‘54s were one of our favorite Fender pickup sets when we first reviewed them over ten years ago, and nothing has changed. They lack the crystalline shimmer and clarity of the ‘69s, yet they offer another equally desirable flavor among classic Fender Stratocaster tones. The treble tones are slightly warmer and less piercing, and you do lose the glassy shimmer of the ‘69s. The ‘54s feature staggered output measuring 5.88K/Neck, 6.12K/ Middle and 6.24K/Bridge with staggered and beveled Alnico 5 polepieces. Overall, the ‘54 set is just a little warmer and rounder sounding in all five positions than both the Tex-Mex and ‘69 pickups. You will lose some of the pop, quack and presence in the out-of-phase 2 and 4 positions, but the ‘54s are very agreeable and likely to please both blues and rock players. It really comes down to your individual level of treble sensitivity and the character of the amps and other gear you use. The ‘54s offer the perfect middle ground for Strat players, not too bright and chiseled, yet still delivering quintessential Stratocaster tones. Just to confirm our fallibility, as we were screwing the pickguard on after installing the ‘54s we got a little sloppy with our electric drill and torqued a screw too hard, cracking the pickguard. We had a couple of Fender USA spares that feel less brittle and probably wouldn’t have cracked. While we were replacing the pickguard we added an aluminum shield/ground plate to the wiring harness. The stock Roadworn pickguard comes with an adhesive foil ground – the aluminum plate is much better, and like the CRL 5-way switch, a worthwhile and easy upgrade. Slider’s Classic ‘57s The review articles we present here often seem to write themselves. A certain degree of planning is required, finding and acquiring a guitar and pickups in this case, but as we begin the process of comparative evaluation, the objects themselves seem to tell a story that we could not anticipate in advance. You kinda have an idea how things might stack up, but until you put in the time and effort to intently dig in and listen over several days in multiple sessions, you really don’t know. The impressions left by Fender’s Custom Shop ‘69s and ‘54s more than a decade ago returned quickly, as if we were re-reading our original reviews (which we didn’t do.) In fact, the last time we read those reviews was in the final edit before the original print run. Having completed our return to the Custom Shop pickups, we sorted through a few other sets with the idea of including a custom pickup winder’s work in contrast to the Fender coils. We were tempted to review a set of Alan Hamel pickups given to us by Peter Stroud, but since your chances of finding a set of Hamel’s pickups are slim indeed, we passed. We could have broken out a set of Will Boggs pickups wound with NOS wire, but he kinda evaporated, too… We chose instead Slider’s Classic ‘57s last reviewed in a Custom Shop Fiesta red Relic Strat in January 2009. Slider has sourced the only authentic ‘50s covers with those unmistakable rounded curves that we have ever seen, and while we really liked the Classic ‘57 pickups, the beautiful Fiesta red Strat became suspect the longer we kept it. Oh, it was an outstanding example of a Relic in terms of its classic appearance and appeal, but as we mentioned earlier, in hindsight it was too light, and in combination with the slim tapered neck the ownership experience was not unlike dating a really beautiful girl long -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 7 guitars enough to realize that beneath the physical charms there was something missing. Like a personality… So Slider’s Classic ‘57s went into the Roadworn Strat with no preconceptions, although when you see those creamy covers, you do get the impression that a serious piece of work lurks beneath. Measuring 6.04K/Neck, 5.96K/ Middle, and 6.12K/Bridge, Rod McQueen’s Classic ‘57s are wound with 42 gauge Formvar wire using artfully aged, beveled and staggered Alnico 5 magnets, and the middle pickup is not reverse-wound. We noted that the middle pickup resistance was lower than the neck, and that the staggered polepieces revealed a slightly different height alignment, so we checked in with Slider, who updated us on what’s new with Stratocaster pickups in Melbourne and answered our questions about the Classic ‘57s … I need to get you two of my newer sets to check out! The 59/SRV scatterwound pickup sets are re-productions of Fender pickups produced in the late 1950’s. Throughout this period Strat pickups were built from similar materials and to the same basic specification. Any variation was mainly due to the different batches of AlNiCo, 42g Fmv-H wire, and very importantly, the individual operator that actually wound a particular set. I am also winding the slightly warmer/fatter ‘60s set in AlNiCo 2. These have about a 6% overwind compared to the 59/ SRVs so they are more in line with the 62/63 vintage sets and I am using AlNiCo 2 for warmth and fuller mids. I originally made these for an artist friend to help carry through his solo gigs where his guitar and voice are all that’s up there, so we needed a full, warm and easily overdriven pickup set that could do everything at reasonable volumes, no icy tone or fear of going for the bridge position! Regarding the resistance and pole stagger in relation to positional placement on the Classic ‘57s... I vary my placement of a specific pickup within a set dependent on the balance between the resistance (as measured via a Ohm meter) and the actual magnetic gauss or strength and acoustic performance of a given pickup. I generally build my Strat pickups in small batches of 3 sets at a time. Once completed, including my special wax potting, each pickup is extensively tested and plugged directly into a Class A tube amp and “tap tested.” I treat each pickup batch like a chef testing his latest creation, tasting a spoonful and making any final adjustments by taste, feel and experience. One of the adjustments I do is to select each individual pickup that will go into a specific set. Small variations in measured resistance are one of the least important of my placement parameters. As for pole length, I use an “adjusted” vintage stagger on my production sets which lends some tonal assistance to the lighter B/E strings. I do use a totally vintage correct pole stagger, down to the 1/100” for my “Replique Elite” 100% accurate reproduction sets, which have the low E and even lower A pole you mentioned on the Classic ‘57 set. A true ‘54 stagger should also have the lower G pole. As with the Fender pickups reviewed, we began with clean tones played through our ‘74 Princeton, ‘64 Pro with outboard reverb and the ‘65 Super Beater Reverb, and the Roadworn Strat painted the room with deep, soulful tones entirely unique to Slider’s pickups. Difficult to describe in words, we can only say that the tone of the guitar seemed more colorful and alive with rich harmonic overtones and an even deeper voice than what we had thought was deep with the Fender sets. The neck pickup is astonishingly good as only a Stratocaster can be, and for a long while we were happily stuck in a jazzy Jeff Beck groove playing a haunting, slowed down and less busy instrumental version of Blind Faith’s “Can’t Find My Way Home.” The guitar inspired all of that, and we have no idea where it came from. Slider can also be credited for nailing the most difficult trick, which is to produce adequate treble in the 2 and 4 positions. Without it, you get a muffled, indistinct and rather useless tone, but when the treble is there, these two settings can be very cool indeed, as noted in so many of Eric Clapton’s slightly tipsy recorded live solos from the ‘70s. The middle pickup is bright enough to cut, yet rich with mid tones, and one you will use often, clean or dirty. The -continued- 8 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 amps bridge pickup is bright, clear and clean with none of the trashy overtones that are often produced by overwound or ‘hot’ bridge pickups. And again, adding the bridge tone control makes all the difference in moving from a trebly ‘50s traditional, Eldon Shamblin vibe to a heavier tone suitable for hard rockin.’ We have been playing the Roadworn Strat now for almost two weeks, yet it feels as if we have been playing it for years – as if it had been made for us, perfect in all the ways that so many other Stratocasters had fallen short of what we had wished for, and yes, we have been pondering why… Mostly, it’s the neck, although the entire guitar seems to fit us like a custommade suit. For whatever reason, the vintage 7.5” fingerboard radius on a Fender makes all the difference, where a 9.5” radius feels awkward and wrong. The slight curve to the fretboard makes playing seem effortless and easy. The neck shape on the Roadworn is equally righteous – an elegantly conceived moderate V that is neither too thick or thin at 13/16.” Just perfect. No less important is the way the urethane lacquer has been sanded to a smooth matte finish that allows your hand and finger tips to glide along the neck with no fight whatsoever. The taller frets are essential, too. String bends are easy with just a little added tension from the curved fretboard, chords seem easier to hold and sustain, and playing this guitar really does feel completely effortless, natural and familiar. The tremolo is also uncannily precise, yet forgiving. It seemed as if we nailed the initial setup almost too easily, setting the trem just right (with a peek at our picture of Jeff Beck’s trem height), and we’ve been using the tremolo as a beautiful effect now where in the past we left the trem arm in a drawer. And the Roadworn comes right back to pitch every time. Bizarre, almost. In every respect, this Stratocaster simply feels and sounds right with absolutely no ‘what ifs” or shortcomings. If not for the tiny Made in Mexico decal on the back of the Roadworn headstock, you couldn’t tell the difference between it and a $3800 Custom Shop relic. What? You aren’t swallowing that? Consider this – all those classic ‘50s Strats and Teles were largely made by Mexicans, too, like the famous ‘TG’ neck carver Tadeo Gomez and ‘XA’, Xavier Armente… It’s about time we found a Stratocaster like this, and our advice to you? Set your sights on a Roadworn Stratocaster from 2013-14, and when you find it… Jump Sturdy.TQ www.fender.com www.sliderspickups.com Nolatone Ampworks We first featured Paul Sander’s Nolatone Wicked Garden in the November 2012 issue of TQR, and when Paul told us about his new line of Road Hoggs, we were all in. Inspired to some extent by the classic tone of a Marshall plexi, Sanders has developed four new variations of the Road Hogg featured here. If a new amplifier is in your future, we suggest you give Nolatone a serious look. Like a lot of us, Paul struggled to find an amp with adequate clean headroom that could still deliver overdriven tones without driving the patrons out of his pub. His amps are entirely unique, supremely well-built, exceptionally toneful and simply a blast to play. Our reviews follow Paul’s interview. Enjoy… TQR: Let’s start by reminding our readers of your background in electronics, and how, why, and when you were inspired to begin designing and building amplifiers. I started in electronics when I joined the US Navy Advance Electronics Field back in 1983. That’s where I was trained in wiring and soldering as well. I’ve owned and loved a whole range of classic and boutique amps over the years and ultimately decided to design an amp that fit the specific needs of the pub I owned and played music in at the time – Lefty’s Pub in Buford, Georgia. I needed enough clean headroom to play funk and Johnny Cash, but I also wanted to be able to push the amp to get crunchy for more rocking tunes but without killing the people with overwhelming volume levels. I tried literally dozens of different amps in the 15-40 watt range trying to find that balance and never could. They were either not clean enough, or too loud when pushed. So, the first Nolatone was born. I quit buying so many amps at that time as well, but I never stopped wanting them, so when I get an idea, I have a bad habit of creating a new design or a variation of an existing one to fulfill that idea. So 6 years later, here I am with a whole line of models which are the result of my perpetual GAS. I think I spent less money on amps when I just bought them! TQR: Can you briefly describe the different models you build and the major differences among them in terms of design and sound? -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 9 amps I have a pretty diverse range of models these days, in no particular order: added versatility. What is it about the original plexi design that made them sound so unique in your opinion, and to what extent are those features in terms of design and component choices evident in your amps? The Chimey Limey 15 and 30 are based on Chimey Limey a 1960 AC15/ AC30. This is pre-top boost, which to me is the more pure and simple Vox circuit which delivers wonderful sweetness, bloom, and chime. I always knew Plexis were wonderful, but I learned that lesson in extra depth while developing the Road Hogg. Initially the Road Hogg was intended to be based on the Rotten Johnny preamp because the Rotten Johnny has such great versatility due to the way the tone shaping is configured (it’s not a typical tone stack like a Marshall or a Fender uses). The initial goal was for Nicky Moroch who needed his Road Hogg 50 to be loud enough in a 1x12 combo to be heard on stage without monitors or in-ears, and he plays on some damned loud stages. The Wicked Garden is our channel switcher. The clean channel uses the same tone stack as an AC30 top boost, and the overdrive channel is my Wicked Garden own design which was tonally bench-marked to an amazing sounding vintage Marshall Silver Jubilee Dave from SoundPure in Durham, NC loaned me. The circuit is in no way a clone, totally different approach to the circuitry, but the type of preamp distortion is in the same ball park. Rotten Johnny is a 28 lb. grab and go 15 watt amp with amazing versatility while staying very simple at the same time. It has nice clean headroom for a smallish amp, too (and getting cleaner in the next generation). Wicked Johnny is the same package as Rotten Johnny, but uses the overdrive channel of the Wicked Garden. For you guys who want rock & roll gain from the preamp, bring out the 28 lb. Wicked Johnny, turn it up and leave that 100 watt half stack that you can’t turn up past 1 at home. The Junebug 2 is a 5 watt (single ended) “Super Princeton”. Tango Wreck is coming soon – the next generation of the 22 Tango (my first design). My current plan is to make a Nolatone-ized Trainwreck Express type amp as a tribute to the late Ken Fischer, but who knows, it could end up being a Fender type amp with reverb. We’ll see where the winds take me on that one. Road Hogg/Road Hogg Lite are Plexi based with extra tricks. TQR: Reading the commentary on your web site, you do not hesitate to point to the classic Marshall plexi amps as having inspired some of the greatest rock music in history as well as inspiring your work as a designer, with a few twists and enhancements for I was comparing the Road Hogg prototype to my 50 watt Plexi clone which represents an example of an amp that indeed would deliver the required volume levels. I noticed that the Road Hogg prototype just didn’t have that “smack you in the forehead” punch the Plexi clone did. I tore what little hair I have out for weeks trying to figure out where I was losing that in the circuit that originated with the Rotten Johnny. Finally I decided to wire up a Plexi tone stack in the prototype, and BAM, there it was! I started looking at the wave forms on my tone stack calculator tool and realized the way the filter network used in the Plexi tone stack shapes the frequencies, all the energy is right there where it’s needed for that punch. Sure, the output section, power supply, etc. are all part of it, but all things equal between the original Road Hogg prototype and the Plexi clone, that tone stack was the difference, so I proceeded with the design based on that at the core, and then added my own tweaks to improve versatility. TQR: Focusing on the Road Hogg amps that you have provided for review, please describe the specific features and differences among the variations you provided. -continued- 10 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 amps The amps provided are the Road Hogg 50, 37, 32, and Road Hogg Lite. The idea is to provide an interesting review of how differences in bias, filtering and voltage can effect the tone. The Road Hogg 50 uses a traditional 50 watt Plexi configuration with fixed bias el34s, traditional filtering, etc. It is very loud, punchy, and bold. The Road Hogg 37 and 32 are an interesting comparison. They both use identical output transformer and power tubes: KT66’s into a Radio Spares JTM45 style OT, which is not quite as large as the 50 watt Plexi style OT used in the Road Hogg 50. Both of these also use the original filtering used in the early JTM45, which is considerably smaller filter cap values than the RH50 uses. These are key to extra juicy harmonics and cozy sag found in the 37 and 32. The difference between the 37 and the 32 is, the 37 is fixed bias with about 420vdc B+, and the 32 is cathode biased with about 380vdc B+. Those two details alone make the 32 a completely different experience from the 37, with all other things identical. The 32 with the lower B+ and cathode bias runs much closer to Class A and sounds astonishingly Vox-like in comparison to the juicy classic old-school harmonics dripping from the 37. Both drip with harmonics, but I think of the 37 as being more “crunchy” and the 32 as being more “chimey” if that makes any sense. The Road Hogg Lite uses a pair of 6V6’s cathode biased for about 20 watts. I use about 420v B+ to give it good clean headroom. It’s a smaller transformer set on a smaller chassis to save weight and cost. In the standard 1x12 combo you have an amp that can hang with most drummers in a very portable 35lb package. GREAT for gigging small to medium sized clubs. The preamp is identical to the other Hoggs, just the controls are set differently to fit on the smaller chassis. Note that a new head box is coming soon for the small chassis amps – a smaller version of the TV front head box used on the Road Hogg amps. TQR: We always like to consider the true intention of an amp’s design... What did the builder wish to accomplish, and for what type of player and music? Is this a performance amp built for big stages, or is it intended to be used at home by players who typically want distortion at low volume levels? Is the amp intended to produce usable clean headroom at high volume levels, or is it designed for players who rely primarily on overdriven tones and distortion? In other words, what did you want the Road Hogg to be and how should it be perceived in practical terms? The Road Hogg was designed with the touring musician in mind. The idea was to offer enough clean headroom for most needs, but that is also expressive, dynamic, and inspiring to play. The Road Hoggs are also designed to be very pedal friendly. It’s easy to dial in night after night, and great if you mark your dial positions with tape. However it also allows enough tonal flexibility to tweak for different rooms (or moods) if needed. All that said, any amp is capable of being a living room amp...it just depends on the level of tolerance of family, neighbors, and local law enforcement! You don’t have to be a touring musician to enjoy these Hoggs at home. TQR: Please describe the various options that are available with the Road Hogg in regard to circuits, tubes, head/cabinet and combo configurations. The Road Hogg line includes the Road Hogg and Road Hogg Lite, offering a range of combinations so most any player will be able to get something that will work for their situation: The Road Hogg is the higher end of the line built on the larger chassis with higher end appointments. It comes in: 22 watt (fixed bias 6V6s) 32 watt (cathode biased KT66s) 37 watt (fixed bias KT66s) 50 watt (fixed bias EL34s) (6L6’s available on request) 100 watt (available on request) -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 11 amps Road Hogg Lite is 20 watts with a pair of cathode biased 6V6s on our small chassis with a smaller output transformer for lighter weight/lower cost. Heads: Two styles, TV front or clear glaze panel. Also coming soon, a new TV front head for the Road Hogg Lite (and other small chassis models) Extension cabinets: There are two styles of cabinets: Solid pine TV Front and birch ply split panel. The Pine cabinets tend to offer that more “swirly” tone due to the resonance of the pine. The birch ply cabs are a bit more focused sounding. They all sound great. They are available in 1x12 and 2x12. I am also evaluating 4x12 cabinets and may be offering those as well soon. Combos: The same combinations in extension cabinets are also available as combos. The Road Hogg lite uses a smaller cabinet as standard but is also available in the larger TV front cabinet for an upcharge. Options: Series (unbuffered) FX loop ($50), custom color ($50 per cabinetry piece), premium oversized cabinet (Road Hogg Lite only) ($100) TQR: What is the wait time for delivery once and amp has been ordered? Wait time depends on current backlog. Generally it is 4-6 weeks, but I always quote the current lead time when the order is placed. TQR: What’s ahead, Paul? What do you want to accomplish long term? I keep Nolatone small to assure I can keep my finger on quality and be responsive to customers. I was at a crossroads before when I was deciding whether to grow or not and I realized in order to grow I would have to do things I didn’t want to do. I don’t want this to become a “job”. Nolatone is fueled by passion. I get great pleasure from bringing my ideas to life and knowing people make music with instruments I created. For long term viability, I have set up Nolatone to be immune to economic conditions. This assures I can keep doing this without pressure of shipping any set number of amps to survive. Ultimately I will employ my kids to the extent they are interested in being involved, and then down the road when I have a 20 year track record, maybe they will take it to the next level. But in the meantime I will solder every joint, tug on every wire to assure it’s solid, and every amp I build will be the best one yet, and I will stand behind them all. Though some great players are playing Nolatone amps, I would get a real kick out of having still more musicians I admire playing Nolatone. I realize that is tough when flying under the radar like I do and I don’t give amps away. But I would love to work with guys like Keith Urban (Keith, I’ll also design a custom t-shirt for ya!) Joe Walsh, Dave, Chris, and Pat from the Foo Fighters, Dean DeLeo from STP, just to name a few who inspire me. I will be here when they are ready! Road Hoggs We received four variations of the Road Hogg for review, each slightly different, but with the same basic features and controls. The Road Hogg platform consists of a Master Volume control, Treble, Midrange and Bass, a toggled Plexi Boost switch, Volume with pull boost, a Bright Blend control and a toggled Bright/Normal switch. Dual speaker jacks are located on the back panel with convenient bias test points and a bias pot. We have seen a lot of booteek amps inside and out, and the quality of Paul Sander’s work is second to none. We can also tell you that he is very hands-on, personally building every amp, and from what we have heard from some of you, he genuinely values his clients and is a joy to deal with. All of the Road Hoggs are built with big Mercury Magnetics transformers to Sander’s specs. The Road Hogg 50 runs on dual EL34s, the 37 and 32 use two big KT66s. The Road Hogg Lite combo uses 6V6s (or EL34s) but trust us, it sounds bigger… Road Hogg 50 The 50 delivers those famously thick EL34 tones and plenty of power and volume when you need it, but the Master -continued- 12 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 amps Volume also does a nice job of holding the volume down while maintaining the character of the amp opened up. No fizzy, weeny tones here… Paul provided a Road Hogg 2x12 open back cabinet loaded with two excellent Warehouse 30 watt Reaper speakers that we ran with all three heads. The Reaper is described as a drop-in replacement for the Celestion G12H30, and you can expect deep low end, full mids and pleasing treble that is a bit rolled off. The Treble, Bass and Mid Controls on the Road Hogg 50 display an even taper and while you can use them effectively to tweak EQ with different guitars, the essence of this amp is undeniably British. The Plexi Boost toggle pushes mids slightly while adding smooth sustain in the style of a cranked Plexi, but again, you don’t have to crank your Road Hogg too loud to get those tones unless you want to. The Volume with Pull Boost impressed us as a Depth control, adding low end and a bigger overall tone. Combined with the Plexi Boost you get a massive tone with lots of rich overdriven sustain. The Bright Blend is a very cool tool that enables you to gradually increase brightness like a bright switch, but with a knob on it, eh? The Bright/Normal toggle acts like a normal bright switch – especially useful with heavier humbuckers. Just consider the Road Hogg 50 to be a solid EL34 rock amp with decent headroom and beautiful, singing sustain with fat upper mid emphasis in the style of a vintage Marshall – just more versatile. Road Hogg 37 Equipped with KT66s, the Road Hogg 37 shares the same features and controls with the other amps, but the fixed bias KT66 configuration provides plenty of almost clean headroom with single coils. Compared to the EL34 50 and cathode-biased 32, the 37 sounds and responds dynamically more like a big 6L6 amp, with an imposing voice that is clear and singing. The clean tones aren’t quite as pristine as a Fender, but our Strat and Telecaster sounded really good with the amp set more or less clean, lending just enough of a subtle edge for truly great rhythm tones. Like the 50, this amp can growl, but none of the Road Hoggs sound harsh and gritty. The distortion and sustain are consistently smooth and rich. Our goldtop with vintage Gibson humbuckers lights up all of these amps with much more intense distortion than the single coils at comparable settings. You probably won’t need an overdrive pedal with humbuckers, but for gonzo Jimi tones with a Strat you might need to add a boost or overdrive pedal to the mix. The Road Hoggs aren’t extreme gain monsters, but neither were the Marshall plexi amps. Among all the Road Hoggs we actually liked the cleaner tones of the 37 with our Strat and Tele best. Both sounded big, clean and Fendery, with the perfect hint of loose breakup. Road Hogg 32 Paul was correct when he described this amp as having more chime in the style of a Vox AC30. Compared to the other amps the 32 definitely displays more complex harmonic textures in the upper mid and treble frequencies with lots of chime and treble shimmer. It’s a great amp for any guitar with single coil pickups, but it also sounds just as good with our Les Paul – rich, thick and perhaps more cutting and penetrating depending on how you set the Bright Blend and tone controls. The Road Hogg 32 just seems to have more sparkle in it, yet you can still shape EQ, sustain and distortion using the tone controls, Plexi boost and Volume pull/boost. If the 32 isn’t quite as loud as the 37 we couldn’t tell, but it does seem to be a little more finessed in the style of an AC30, without sounding as compressed, stiff and boxy. Road Hogg Lite Lite? Not really. This is the 35 lb. 20 watt combo amp that Marshall shoulda woulda coulda built… Aside from power and volume, the little Road Hogg has absolutely noth-continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 13 effects ing in common with a Deluxe Reverb or any other 20 watt amp we can recall, because it is basically a smaller version of the big Road Hoggs. For those of you who prefer small combos that are easy to carry and don’t take up much space, this is a true performance amp with a big, big voice disguised as a small combo. How cool is that? No reverb, no tremolo, just tone, and lots of it. Our review model came loaded with a 25 watt Warehouse Green Beret, and of course you get the meaning of the word play… The $69 Paducah, Kentucky version of the vaunted Celestion Greenback is perfect for the little Road Hogg, rich in mid tones, dynamic, loaded with character, and it seems to enjoy being abused. Despite its size, you’ll find that this version of the Road Hogg has plenty of headroom in reserve, and if you want more power it can be ordered with EL34s. Paul Sanders wisely chose a pine cabinet for his combo – lighter in weight and less stiff sounding than birchply, and you can hear the difference. This is without a doubt the best pure 1x12 rock combo we have ever heard short of a Dumble we cranked at the Dallas Guitar Show years ago, and all the Road Hogg standard enhancements make it even more versatile and desirable. We like all four Road Hoggs provided for review a lot, and choosing a favorite really comes down to your personal needs and taste. If you have always craved a big 50 watt Marshall rig the EL34 Road Hogg 50 embodies all of that and more. The 37 has more of a Marshall tone equipped with 6550 tubes – not as middy as the 50, although you can make it so with the tone controls and Plexi boost switch. Let’s just say that the soundstage of the 37 is a little wider… The Road Hogg 32 beautifully captures the enhanced harmonic detail and chimey sustain of a Vox design without the inherent limitations, and this is an amp that will leave the field wide open for possible speaker combinations, perhaps mixing a bright Alnico with a heavier ceramic magnet speaker. The Road Hogg Lite, or little Road Hogg as we like to call it is, as we said, the ultimate 1x12 rock combo. Short of death metal, there isn’t much you can’t do with it. Nolatone is right here in Atlanta, so hit the web site, check out all the available options and Quest forth, ya’ll…TQ www.nolatone.com, 404-290-9140 14 Distortion & Overdrive SRV’s Fuzzface How many ways can you create an overdriven or distorted guitar signal? A candid interview with Brian Wampler, founder of Wampler Pedals sheds some light on what is really going on inside overdrive and distortion effects. There is no doubt that distortion and overdrive pedals are the most popular of all guitar effects ever created. The number of pedals produced since the ‘70s is mind numbing, and more new distortion and overdrive effects are introduced each year than any other product related to the electric guitar. No matter how many new pedals may be launched this year, you can be sure that more will follow, and guitarists will continue to chase the next “best” overdrive, distortion or clean boost pedal. In this regard, competition to identify and acquire the latest and “best” new effect creates a constantly moving target in which last year’s phenomenal new pedal is quickly eclipsed by another, and the quest to keep pace in the race to the top can become time consuming and expensive. While we can’t realistically point to a single pedal with an ironclad guarantee that it will rock your world, we do know that none of us can ever hope to experience every distortion or overdrive effect that has or will be built. You can never hear them all, so how can you possibly know when you may have finally acquired “the best?” Does the search ever end, or is the quest for the holy grail among overdrive and distortion effects an adventure in myth and fantasy driven by hype, the flavor of the month on your favorite forum, and a catchy name? In the interest of truth and in an effort to gently blow some fresh -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 effects air into the fog, we approached Brian Wampler, founder of Wampler Pedals with a simple question: “How many ways are there to create an overdrive, boost or distortion effect for guitar, and without giving away any design secrets, what’s the trick in making a more pleasing and musical distorted or overdriven sound that will sound as good in my rig as it does in yours?” Enjoy… ing with various types of circuits. I figured out what makes some circuits have a certain ‘feel’ or reaction to them, and I learned all the intricacies of overdrive/distortion and fuzz circuits. I never stop growing or evolving with that though – even 14 years later I still experiment with various circuits and constantly challenge myself to do better. When you love this stuff as much as I do, I think its part of the passion. TQR: Several years later I was getting a lot of folks asking me how to modify various pedals to get certain tones, so I self published a few books. While they aren’t available anymore, I still get a lot of newer pedal company owners tell me that those old books helped them get their start. It’s really humbling to have played a small part in growing the “boutique” pedal industry. It’s an industry that is really different than other industries – many of us keep in contact and help each other when needed. It’s a brotherhood of sorts. Thanks for agreeing to walk us through the art of creating cool-sounding distortion and overdrive effects, Brian. Let’s start by touching on the guitar effects that first rocked your world and inspired you to begin building pedals… Which pedals really caught your intention and why? That’s a good question… I wouldn’t say that there was a certain pedal that happened to catapult my interests. Rather, it was the possibility of what could be done using analog circuitry in order to create something with life, something that didn’t feel stale or cheap. What brought me to that realization was a period of time where I was buying a ton of different pedals in order to achieve certain sounds. I would routinely save up for the next “greatest” pedal that I would hear about via magazines or gear forums and I was quite underwhelmed. A friend of mine sold me a Boss DS-1 distortion that he had modified slightly and I was blown away by how different the modified version sounded from the stock version, especially just by changing some capacitors and resistors. Keep in mind that this was a period of time when I didn’t know anything about electronics really – I just new what type of sounds I wanted and I refused to believe that the only way to get those tones were with expensive and vintage amps. After picking his brain for a bit I found out there were a few DIY websites (such as DIYstompboxes.com, Geofex.com, and Muzique.com just to name a few) that would help explain some basics of electronics. From there I went on to absorb as much information as I could. I bought a breadboard (which allows one to quickly build a circuit temporarily without soldering) and just practiced building and experiment- TQR: As the pedal world has grown and expanded, certain terms are now used with vague and uncertain meanings… Can you describe the difference between distortion and ‘boost’ or ‘overdrive’ effects? We are really just referring to different levels of clipping, aren’t we? Kind of, sort of. Yes, there are definite differences in clipping between distortion, overdrive, and just volume boosting. However, it’s possible to create a very heavy gain distortion and a lighter gain type of fuzz. It’s also a bit of gray area…. What one considers distortion another person may consider it more of a fuzz. However, if I had to really narrow it down and simplify it a bit, I personally would consider these as the main attributes: Distortion utilizes harder clipping, overdrive would be softer clipping, fuzz would be very hard clipping. A boost would more or less just be boosting volume. Of course, these aren’t rules or anything, it’s more or less just my opinion. TQR: So, how many ways can you really create distortion, overdrive and various levels of clipping with a pedal design? There can’t be that many ways to do it… There are several different ways, mainly using transistors/ FETs of some sort and connected in a few various ways to boost and/or clip a signal, op-amps set up various ways, as well as other IC chips (which can be used to clip a signal). You can also saturate a small transformer, even though it’s not common. The real beauty is in the details. For example, a tube amp uses the same basic process to clip the signal, -continued- TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 15 effects but every amp sounds dramatically different… a JCM800 sounds nothing like a Blackface twin even though they are both tube amps. There are a ton of variables that go into creating a really good sounding and feeling overdrive or distortion – resistance, capacitance, EQ, the number of stages, types of stages, bias of stages… many different ways. I look at it like cooking. There are a million things you bake with flour, depending on what other ingredients you add to it and how it’s used. TQR: What makes some pedal effects sound rich, lush and juicy, while others may sound less musical and pleasing? Where is the secret sauce in shaping the tone of effects? TQR: A bit, yes – however it’s much more than that. A gain pot is just changing resistance, so depending on the circuit, an ‘audio’ taper may increase gain more gradually than a linear pot for example, however, it won’t change the EQ, and it won’t change the amount of gain if they are the same value. Geofex.com has an excellent article that describes pot tapers, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking to read into more about that. TQR: Without giving away specifics, each circuit is tuned to react in a certain way. While no one is using some magic component in order to create a dirt circuit, the magic is in the details. It’s what sets us apart. As I design things, I’m doing it with a guitar in my hand, while most guys start with a computer in front of them. I know how different clipping circuits react, and generally I have a good understanding of what type of circuit to use to achieve what I want just from tons of experience and tenacity. TQR: Most pedals use op-amps to boost the signal, right? We also hear about mosfet pedals… What does that mean? It would seem as if the sweep of the pots used for things like gain and volume would determine how pedals behave to a great extent. True? Should we care about the impedance of a pedal? Yes, to an extent – I usually strive for high input impedance, and low output impedance. Most importantly is really just how they sound and react though – if they inspire a person to create or not. However, it is definitely true that every pedal works together cohesively in a way that makes impedances matter a bit. For example, many traditional fuzz style circuits do not like a buffered (low output impedance) signal – noise can result as well as the circuit not sounding as intended. Some wahs can be finicky as well, but it’s not just limited to those two types of circuits – if in doubt, send an email to the pedal company whose product you are contemplating purchasing and they should be able to help guide you. Not always – both op-amps and mosfets can be used to boost a signal. Op-amps are basically a type of circuit and mosfets are a type of transistor. There isn’t one type that’s necessarily “better” in every application though. Mosfet’s have a particular sound and feel, just as NPN transistors, JFET’s, and opamps do. All have advantages and disadvantages. For example, mosfet’s have a good sound and feel, but they can also tend to have odd impedance issues with other pedals. Same with NPN or PNP type transistor boosts. If a person wants a full frequency type boost with very little noise and distortion, then an op-amp based booster may be best. Once again, these aren’t rules per-se, but they are more of a general guideline. As with everything, exclusions apply, especially depending on the exact circuitry. TQR: Is true bypass really so important? Pete Cornish says, “no.” The answer isn’t that simple. The true answer is yes, and no. Sort of like asking “is cookie dough bad?”… Here is my preference. All true bypass pedals without one buffer as -continued- 16 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 effects close to the guitar is bad. All buffered pedals are bad. Too many buffered pedals can be bad, but there are no hard and fast number as to what that is. My preference is to use as many true bypassed pedals as you can, run a buffer up front as close to the guitar as possible (except after a wah or fuzz), and try to use pedals that have an analog signal path. I’m not a fan of pedals that convert the signal to digital and then back to analog again – I feel something gets lost in the sound and definitely the ‘feel’. TQR: It might be helpful at this point to clarify what a buffer is and what it does… A buffer is a device that changes a high impedance signal into a low impedance signal to drive capacitance. You generally only need one buffer in order to drive the signal into the amp as a low impedance. However if you use a pedal that happens to have a high impedance output then it may be necessary to use a second buffer after that effect. The thing you will notice most without a buffer is that you will lose quite a bit of highs dependent on how long of a cable or cables you are using. Some pedals (for example some Boss or Ibanez) use buffers in the signal path at all times. Sometimes those pedals have two, even four buffers that are in the signal path when the pedal is off. These buffers are generally simple transistor type of buffers which some feel are not of the highest quality and do not always have a very good signal-to-noise ratio. So including multiples of these types of pedals can give you a lot of extra noise hiss as well as a little bit lower signal due to the fact that these type of buffers are not always necessarily 1:1 (an exact gain of 1). TQR: Can you recommend any specific buffers? There are several different buffers that are pretty good. I always recommend an opamp based buffer. As far as examples, our “decibel +” pedal works as a standalone buffer, and Emperess makes one as well. I know there are others – check http://proguitarshop.com/ effects/buffers.html Note that some of the buffers on this page are transistor based, which personally I’m not a fan of. The opamp based buffers tend to have a better signal to noise ratio, as well as better signal (actual 1:1 ratio, or gain of 1). Some of the transistor based buffers have a gain of a little less than 1. TQR: What uncharted territory remains for you to explore as a designer and builder? Tons of things in the works, look for more pedals of course (including more delays, a tremolo, phase, more 2 in 1 type pedals), a line of bass effects as well as some other companion products. And as always, make sure to subscribe to our newsletter at http://www.wamplerpedals.com/subscribe to be eligible for our free pedal drawings, and check out our youtube, facebook, instagram, and twitter pages. Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/user/wampcat Instagram: http://instagram.com/wamplerpedals Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/wamplerpedals Twitter: https://twitter.com/WamplerPedals Wampler Faux Tape Echo Having devoted much of an entire issue to the vintage Market Electronics Echoplex in December 2010 and interviewed the late Mike Battle, inventor of the original Echoplex in August 2001, you could call us big fans of tape echo. Not just for the ‘echo’ effect, but for the way it can be used to fatten the sound of the guitar without resorting to heavy slapback repeats. Tape echo is simply one of the all-time classic guitar sounds, yet we knew when we published our in-depth articles on the Echoplex that many of you would understandably shy away from the initial expense involved in finding an old Echoplex and dealing with common restoration and maintenance issues. When we discovered that Brian Wampler had developed a new faux Tape Echo, we jumped at the chance to evaluate it on your behalf. Compact, intuitive, yet feature rich, we approached our evaluation with high expectations, and we were not disappointed. Wampler has succeeded in creating a very warm, pure analog tape echo effect with the added clarity of digital technology while preserving the fundamental, unaffected tone of your guitar and amplifier. In addition Jeff Bakos uncorks an Echoplex -continuedTONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 17 guitars to the basic controls, he has also added Tap Tempo. Controls Level controls the level of the delayed signal, interactive with the Shade and Repeat controls. Repeats controls the level of feedback and at higher settings, very interesting oscillation effects in combination with the setting of the Level control. Lots of fascinating effects to be mined here… Shade functions as the name implies, coloring the tone of the delayed signal from soft and warm to more fluid and defined in the high frequencies. Delay controls the actual delay time, from audible ‘slap’ at around 9 o’clock to 300 ms at 12 0’clock all the way to 600 ms beyond. Extending the delay time adds soft distortion at the end of the notes in keeping with the character of an analog tape delay. Tap Tempo is a soft switch set by tapping on the switch several times to set the tempo, overriding the Delay control setting. The tempo you set is also displayed in the red LED. Faux Tape Reel emulates the character, wow and flutter of true tape delay. A toggle switch takes you in and out of the tape reel modulation effect. Within the Faux Tape Reel controls, Movement controls the rate of modulation, and Sway controls the depth of the modulation effect. Neither of these controls affect the sound of the pedal when bypassed. The quickest way to get started is to follow the three example settings provided in the owner’s manual. They will provide you with a good understanding of the broad capabilities and extended range of each control, and from there you can begin to experiment with different settings and combinations. You really couldn’t wish for more flexibility or varied delay sounds within the Faux Tape Echo controls, but most significant is the smooth and real analog fidelity that Wampler has achieved. As a result, our old standby Japanese-era Boss DD3 and its bucket brigade COMPANDER chip will be retired. Wampler’s Faux Tape Echo is the new standard in compact delay pedals for guitar, period. $219.97 Quest forth-forthforth-forth…TQ www.wamplerpedals.com, 765-352-8626 Collings CJ35 The original Gibson J45 is one of the most mysteriously toneful acoustic guitars we have ever played, and among all the guitars we have acquired in the past +30 years, our 1952 J45 remains the sole survivor, even being passed over by the thief that stole our Stephen Stills ‘50s Telecaster from our Midtown apartment in the ‘80s. Someone stole it from Stills before we bought it, so maybe that’s how it goes with stolen guitars. In the summer of 1980 we made one of many spontaneous trips to Nashville looking for guitars. Returning to Atlanta empty handed we made an obligatory stop at Chamber’s Music and Golf on South Rossville Blvd. in Chattanooga. Charlie Chamber’s store was near the Rossville traffic circle, housed in a cavernous old building filled with all kinds of old guitars, crappy amps, broken pedals and a ridiculous stash of old golf clubs and bags. Charlie would usually hang all the old Gretsch guitars with their pleather belly pads and funky Mosrites in the front along with anything else he thought was cool, but that didn’t mean he would sell them to you, and beyond the front room the place was a godawful mess. Charlie did happen to own an original Hank Garland Signature Byrdland he would show you, and Garland was king at Chambers Music and Golf… With his coal black hair slicked back Johnny Cash style in the hot summer, Charlie was a pure Tennessee trip, never really looking you straight in the eye, as if making eye contact was a show of weakness. It also made him hard to read, probably by design. Half the time when you asked him what he wanted for something he’d say it wasn’t for sale. Really? Or is that your first serve in the volley we are about to have? You never knew. Sometimes he meant it, other times he’d make you ask two or three times and then he would tell you what he would “need to git fer it.” He could size people up pretty good -continued- 18 TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 guitars and we always figured there was a special tax added for city people from Atlanta. On that hot summer day we were in no hurry to get back on the road, so we patiently waded into a pile of guitar cases on the floor that was 5-6 deep sprawling in every direction for 20 feet. These were not neatly arranged stacks of cases, but a haphazard mess. Some of the cases were empty, others held cheap and uncool knock-offs, but as we dug down deep we eventually spied a ‘50s brown Gibson Lifton case. We pried it out of the pile, opened the latches and inside was an old Gibson J45 that had been played real hard. Oh, if that guitar could only talk…There were two identical cracks emerging in the top on each side of the lower bout, and we didn’t even bother trying to tune it up for fear that the top would go, but we wanted it. Charlie looked kinda surprised to see it, but after we pointed out that some serious repair work was needed, we were able to agree on a price of $400.00. Steep, yes, but if Charlie didn’t get his price he seemed perfectly content to throw it back in the pile and go sell some golf clubs. We had legendary Atlanta guitar builder Jay Riness restore the J45, and it has remained with us ever since. We wrote to Gibson in Kalamazoo inquiring about the serial number and they sent us a post card to inform us that “your instrument was manufactured in 1952.” Everyone who plays the J45 grows quiet out of respect for its soulful tone, speaking in a hushed whisper as if there is something lurking inside the guitar that is not to be disturbed. This happens every time… We are not the only ones to have noticed the magic in those sloped shoulders, and we asked the folks at Collings to send us one of their new CJ35s. While the CJ35 stylistically honors the long history of the first Gibson J35 and post-war J45, the Collings is predictably built to a much higher standard than those old Gibsons, which were actually among the less expensive Gibson acoustics. Like everything they build, the Collings is a stunning work of art, from the pound cake Sitka spruce top with pre-war non-scalloped Adirondack bracing and 3 tone bars, the beautiful bound mahogany back and sides, the elegantly shaped mahogany neck and 14”-26” compound radius rosewood fretboard. Collings has also shortened the scale on this model to 24 7/8” making it more percussive and responsive. Nothing else sounds like these slope-shouldered guitars. The Collings is vocal to the extreme, responsive lightly fingerpicked yet robust enough to be strummed loud and proud with a pick, kinda like two guitars in one, and the Collings nails it, capturing the very essence of this style while adding their own signature touches from Austin. The sunburst is stunning, the medium fretwire flawlessly dressed, the nickel Waverlies precise, every structural and cosmetic detail utter perfection. Lots of companies can build pretty guitars, but the Collings J35 truly sounds as good as it looks. Options include European or Adirondack spruce, Ivoroid fingerboard and headstock binding, varnish finish. $4,860 list with sunburst finish. TQ www.collingsguitars.com ToneQuest Straps On Sale! Our German leather ToneQuest straps crafted by Longhollow Leather in Franklin, TN are on sale now! As many of our happy readers have confirmed over the years, these handcrafted guitar straps are incredibly well-made of the finest imported leather, durable enough to last for decades yet so soft to the touch and they won’t snag on your best gig wear. Longhollow is a family business that specialized in making custom saddles and harnesses in Tennessee for decades. Serious leather straps for serious tonehounds with style! Order yours now in chestnut brown or black for just $45.00 shipping included. Sale ends June 30 or when they run out. Don’t delay, order yours today at www.tonequest.com or call 1-877-MAX-TONE. TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 19 ToneQuest Report the PO Box 717 Decatur, GA. 30031-0717 PERIODICAL POSTAGE PAID AT DECATUR,GA AND ADDITIONAL MAILING OFFICES TM the ToneQuest ToneQuest Report TM Editor/Publisher David Wilson Associate Publisher Liz Medley Graphic Design Rick Johnson EDITORIAL BOARD Billy F. Gibbons Greg Martin Joe Glaser Richard McDonald Tom Guerra Joe Mloganoski Bakos AmpWorks Johnny Hiland Todd Money Dick Boak Gregg Hopkins CF Martin & Co. Vintage Amp Restoration Joe Bonamassa Mark Johnson Analogman Tom Anderson Tom Anderson GuitarWorks Mark Baier Victoria Amplifiers Jeff Bakos Phil Brown Acquire Your Personal Copy of the 1999-2013 TQR Archives NEW SALE PRICE You know you want it… you know you need it… In celebration of our 14th year of publication you can now acquire the complete ToneQuest Archives on CD for just $219.00 shipped. You will receive every issue of TQR spanning November 1999-April 2014 in PDF format, keyword searchable for easy reference with a complete Back Issue Index in MS Word. Save these files to your PC or tablet for access to every review article and interview. Order now online at www.tonequest.com using the coupon code TQXCD at checkout or by phone at 1-877-MAX-TONE (629-8663). Offer expires July 1, 2014, so don’t delay! Dan Butler Butler Custom Sound Don Butler The Toneman Steve Carr Carr Amplifiers Erick Coleman Stewart-McacDonald Larry Cragg Neil Young Jol Dantzig Jol Dantzig Guitar Design Ronnie Earl Dan Erlewine ZZ Top Glaser Instruments Mambo Sons Delta Moon Phil Jones Gruhn Guitars Mark Karan Bob Weir & Ratdog Robert Keeley Robert Keeley Electronics Gordon Kennedy Ernest King Gibson Custom Shop Chris Kinman Kinman AVn Pickups Mike Kropotkin KCA NOS Tubes Sonny Landreth Stewart-MacDonald Albert Lee Larry Fishman Adrian Legg Fishman Transducers Bill Finnegan Klon Centaur Lindy Fralin Peter Frampton Greg Germino Germino Amplification Dave Malone The Kentucky Headhunters VP Mktg, Fender Musical Instruments Co-Founder K&M Anaslog Designs Manager Gibson Repair & Restoration Justin Norvell Sr. Mktg Mgr, Fender Guitars James Pennebaker Artist Relations, Fender Musical Instruments, Nashville Riverhorse Tommy Shannon Double Trouble Todd Sharp Nashville Amp Service Tim Shaw Fender Musical Instruments Corp. Randall C. Smith Designer & President, Mesa/Boogie Ltd. John Sprung American Guitar Center Peter Stroud Buddy Whittington John Mayall & The Bluesbreakers Greg V Los Angeles The Radiators Lou Vito Jimbo Mathus Mike Voltz Shane Nicholas R&D / Product Development, Gibson Memphis Sr. Mktg Mgr, Fender Guitar Amplifers René Martinez The Guitar Whiz The ToneQuest Report™ (ISSN 1525-3392) is published monthly by Mountainview Publishing LLC, P.O. Box 717 Decatur, GA. 30031-0717, 1-877-MAX-TONE, email: [email protected]. Periodicals Postage Paid at Decatur, GA and At Additional Mailing Offices. Postmaster: Send address changes to:TheToneQuest Report™, PO Box 717, Decatur, GA. 30031-0717.The annual subscription fee for The ToneQuest Report™ is $89 per year for 10 issues. International subscribers please add US $40. Please remit payment in U.S. funds only. VISA, MasterCard and American Express accepted. The ToneQuest Report™ is published solely for the benefit of its subscribers. Copyright © 2014 by Mountainview Publishing LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this newsletter may be reproduced in any form or incorporated into any information retrieval system without the written permission of the copyright holder. Please forward all subscription requests, comments, questions and other inquiries to the above address or contact the publisher at [email protected]. Opinions expressed in The ToneQuest Report™ are not necessarily those of this publication.Mention of specific products, services or technical advice does not constitute an endorsement. Readers are advised to exercise extreme caution in handling electronic devices and musical instruments. TONEQUEST REPORT V.15 N.7 May 2014 20