norwegian defence and security industries association
Transcription
norwegian defence and security industries association
1/2014 RETURUKE22 Kr 48,INTERPRESS NORGE N orwegian D efence and S ecurity I ndustries A ssociation CONTENTS Contents: Editor-in-Chief: M.Sc. Bjørn Domaas Josefsen CORRUPTION AND ANTI-CORRUPTION In Norway, the Kongsberg Group is under investigation for corruptionin connection with a contract with Rumania towards the end of the 1990’s. As of today, a single person has been charged, but the matter is still under investigation, and the scope of the matterhas yet to be determined. Kongsberg, like many other major defence suppliers, has duringrecent years done a great deal to combat corruption and unethical behaviours, both internally and in its relations with subcontractors. Kongsberg’s system for ethichs and anti-corruption has in fact been used as a basis by other businesses, both in Norwayand internationally, when these are developing their own systems for the same purpose. It is therefore quite an embarrassment to Kongsberg that the company has now become the subject of an investigation. The struggle against corruption and unethical business practiceshas been stepped up in a big way in most parts of the world. Laws have become stricter and tighter, police and prose cution have become more active, and both purchasers and providershave made major efforts towards the development of routines and systems to uncover corruption in their own organisations. In parallel, active work has been done to achange the attitudes towards corruption in both public and private enterprises. And these attitudes have changed markedly over recent years. Actions or relations that were until recently regarded as ‘par for the course’ in international business, have in the current climate become unthinkable. Healthier attitudes and higher consciousness regarding businessethics means that people will be more aware of how business is conducted today, while many will take a critical look at actions taken during years in the not so distant past. And when organisations and businesses are starting to look back upon ‘old cases’ with fresh eyes and attitudes, chances are that suspicious or illegal dealings may be brought to light. These matters, even while discovered in hindsight, must of course be taken as seriously as if they were happening today. It is a paradox, however, that the businesses who over recentyears have worked with the greatest seriousness on anticorruptionmeasures, and have developed the best attitudes and the most effective systems to maintain a high level of business ethics, may also be the ones that uncover the highest number of previous mistakes. While businesses and organisation with a less vigilant attitude and less effective systems to counter corruption and bad ethics, are more likely to bury their earlier questionable dealings forever. For businesses like Kongsberg, who bring their suspicions on earlier misdeeds out into the open, the consequences may be severe. These companies are penalised judicially, while also taking severe punishment in terms of market position and reputation. But still, the uncovering of old mistakes shows that the work on ethics and anti-corruption yields results. It should be hoped that this work will bring even greater rewards in the long term. GRIPEN 2 Gripen for Brazil 6 New Logistic Ship 8 Camp Supply Group 10 NASAMS contract with Oman FSi 11 NORWEGIAN DEFENCE AND SECURITY INDUSTRIES ASSOCIATION BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE 17 Kongsbeg to support Polish minehunter vesselprogramme 19 Nammo – Finland partnership 22 Three candidates for Danish Artillery System 3M 26 Broad spectrum of products 28 Invisible film offers bomb protection F-35 29 Still troubled but also on the roll 32 Norway out of Archer Coverphoto: Gripen close-up The Swedish fighter aircraft Gripen is heading for an exciting year with possible sales to both Brazil and Switzerland. Photo: Katsuhiko Tokunaga MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 3 GRIPEN GRIPEN FOR BRAZIL Gripen has edged out both the French Rafale and the US Super Hornet, winning the contract to supply Brazil´s Air Force with 36 new multirole fighter aircraft. Now the negotiation process regarding contract details and a comprehensive industrial cooperation package has started, and signing of final contract is scheduled before the end of this year. S aab edged out French and US rivals to win a multi-billion-dollar contract to supply Brazil’s air force with 36 new fighter jets, Defence Minister Celso Amorim said. Saab’s Gripen NG was in compe titionwith the Rafale made by France’s DassaultCompany and US aviation giant Boeing’s F/A-18 fighter for the longdeferredFX-2 air force replacement program. Next to the Indian MMRCA (Medium Multi-role Combat Aircraft) competition, the BrazilianFX-2 program has been regarded as the most important fighter aircraft procurement competition of the decade. Going on for more than 10 years, the FX-2 program aims to replace the ageingMirage 2000 fleet of the Brazilian air force. The importance of the contract in the international fighter aircraft market is not only in regards of the 36 unit as of today. Marked analysts expect this merely to be a first buy, and some commentators estimate a likely total number of up to 100 air craft, assuming the Brazilian air force likes what they are getting. But besides the numbers of aircraft, from a business strategy point of view, a Brazil contract is recognised as a bridgehead into the entire Latin American fighter market. When announcing the winner of the contract, the Brazilian Defence Minister A key requirement for the sale was technology transfers so that the planes can be assembled in Brazil. This will be of great benefit to Brazilian industry, and particularly Embraer – Brazil´s top aircraft manufacturer – will be closely involved in the industrial co-operation with Sweden. Saab and Embraer have been working together for many years. The Saab ERIEYE airborne radar mounted on the Embraer 145 aircraft is not only operated by the Brazilian air force, but has also been a success in the export market. Photo: Saab 4 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 put the actual value of the contract, earlier estimated at $5 billion, at $4.5 billion since Saab offered the cheapest price. Amorim said the Gripen NG, a state-of-the-art, multi-role fighter, got the nod based on performance, assurances of full technology transfer and overall costs. The offer presented to the Brazilian Government by Saab includes the Gripen NG aircraft, sub-systems for Gripen NG, an extensive technology transfer package, a financing package as well as long term bilateralcollaboration between the Brazilian and Swedish Governments. Negotiations with Saab is scheduled to take 10-12 months, with the signing of the contract expected at the end of next year and delivery of the first aircraft 48 months later. The Swedish aircraft, which for years has been the preferred alternative by the Brazilian air force, is capable of performingan extensive range of air-toair, air-to-surface and reconnaissance missions. The air force states that the new fighter aircraftis needed to maintain an adequateair defence, as their 12 Mirage 2000 jets now are being retired. Gripen will meet the Air Force operationalneeds for the coming 30 years, an Air Force spokesman stated. GRIPEN Gripen for Brazil. The Brazilian government has announced Gripen NG as the winner of the contract for delivery of 36 fighters for the Brazilian Air Force Photo: Gripen International/ K.Tokunaga REFERENDUM IN SWITZERLAND In August 2012, the plan to order 22 Gripen E was confirmed by both the Swedish and Swiss authorities. The aircraft are expected to be delivered from 2018 to 2021 at a fixed price of CHF 3.126 billion ($3.27 billion). While awaiting their new aircraft, Switzerland will lease 11 Gripen C/D from 2016 to 2020, to train Swiss pilots and allow the retirement of the old Swiss Air Force F-5 fighters. T he contract has been approved by Swiss political authorities, but a final decision will not be made until a national referendum is held on the order on May 18th this year. So far, a poll on the question in September last year shows that approximate 60% of the voters are against buying fighter aircraft at all. But the recent event of a hijacked Etiopian Airline jet being forced to land on Geneva airport, may have changed the public opinion regarding new fighter aircraft. D espite an early warning, the Swiss Air Force was unable to respond as the hijacked airliner entered Swiss airspace. Instead the airliner was intercepted by Italian Eurofighters and French Mirage 2000s. A fter the incident a Swiss air force spokesman stated that the Swiss air force has insufficient fighters, insufficient budgets and insufficient staff. The humiliation did not become less when international press put out that the hijacking incident occurred at 0600 in the morning, while the Swiss air force bases do not open until 0800. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 5 GRIPEN MARKET While Saab receives good news from Brazil, the company still awaits a referendum in Switzerland on May 18th this year, to seal the procurement of 22 Gripen E aircraft now under development for the Swedish Air Force and possible export customers. I f both the Swiss and the Brazilian contract are finalised, Saab has to work on a three-way development plan encompassing Swedish, Brazilian and Swiss industry. But even if this may be challenging for Saab, it is also regarded as a golden opportunity for Gripen in the export market. Conclusion of the deals with Switzerland and Brazil would give the Gripen E program critical mass and enhance the aircraft’s position in further export contests. Today Gripen are working towards several countries. Sea Gripen. There is also the chance that a maritime version of the Gripen could meet Brazilian Navy requirements to equip an aircraft carrier sometime in the future. Saab has already carried out early design work on a possible Sea Gripen offering for the export market. Ill. Gripen International Denmark has a fighter program in progress, and it is expected that the candidates will be Gripen, Eurofighter, F-35 Joint Strike Fighter and F-18 Super Hornet. The Slovak republic and Sweden have had initial discussions regarding Gripen, but it is far too early to say what this will lead to, and if the Slovak republic will lease or buy aircraft. Representatives from the Bulgarian ministry of Defence visited Sweden last year and had a closer look at Gripen. Among the current Gripen customers, the Check Republic has for ten years been leasing 14 Gripen C/D. This lease period comes to an end in 2015, but a new leasing contract is ready for the governmentsto sign. In 2003 Hungary signed a 10-year lease contract for 14 Gripen C/D with an optionto purchase the aircraft at the end of the lease period. In 2012 that the lease period was extended until 2026, and according to the contract, the Gripen fighters will be the property of the Hungarian Air force when the lease period comes to an end. Thailand has bought 12 Gripen C/D from Sweden, and the last six fighters were delivered in 2013. South Africa has bought 26 Gripen C/D, and the fighters are operational in the South African Air Force. NEW LOGISTIC SHIP Art impression of the new Norwegian Logistic Vessel refueling a Fridtjof Nansen class frigate. Ill. Norwegian Navy THE LOGISTICS SHIP PASSES ITS FIRST MILESTONE Work on the 26,260 ton logistics vessel for the Norwegian Navy at the Daewoo Shipyards in South Korea turns its first corner in April 2014, with the completion of the Basic Design phase. The job was done by the British company BMT of Bath. This is the first time that the Navy builds a ship in the Far East. Text: Tor Husby The largest ever With an overall length of 181 meters and rom the spring, the production will a beam of 26 meters, the ship will be the transition to the phase designated largestin Navy history, at some five times the Detail Design, which will be done under size of the frigates. It will have an operating the direction of the Korean shipyard. The range of 10,000 nautical miles at a cruising detail design phase will have a durationof speed of 16 knots. The maximum speed is one year, and will determine most aspects 18 knots. When the new era is launched of the ship. From this summer on, two after 2017, the ship will provide the Navy representativesof the FLO – the Defence with an operational ability across the seven Logistics Organisation – will be following seas, by providing supplies of fuel to two the building process on-site at the yard. frigates at the same time, as well as replaceThe Detail Design phase concludes ment crews. The new frigates will in one with the hauling of the keel in April stroke achieve a much greater action range, 2015, accordingto the Project Manager, with increased firepower and stamina. The Commander Christian Irgens. latter is estimatedto 30 days between calls The contract amount is some 1.3 to port. The frigates have until now been billion NOK (170 MEUR), and the agree- required to call in to port for fuelling every ment calls for offset purchases in the 5-6 days. amount of 100 percent. At this time, only The freight capacity of the logistics a few Norwegian sub-deliveries have been vessel will be 7000 tons of bunkers oil and agreed to. Among the few is the bridge, 300 tons of helicopter fuel, 40 units of 20 production of which is contracted to L-3 foot containers and 200 tons of ammuniValmarine in Drammen. tion. For its own protection, the ship will Wãrtsila in Finland is contracted to be armed with four Sea Protector 12.7 mm supply the propulsion machinery, which machine guns. will be a hybrid solution of electrical and The new Navy giant will be diesel power. equipped with two NH90 helicopters and –The Navy will interfere as little hangars with maintenance functions. On as possible with Daewoo’s choices of co- board, there will be a hospital with capacity operatingpartners for sub-deliveries, says for 48 patients. The ship will have two surIrgens. gical teams. The total crew supplement will be 43 persons, and the bunk capacity will be a total of just under 120 men. The Navy F 8 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 currently operates two logistics vessels – the KNM “Valkyrien” and the KNM “Trym” – which will form the basis for the new vessel. According to the latest revision, planning is for sea launch in February 2016, delivery to the Navy in October 2016, for entry into operational service one year later. 2nd round in 2012 The building of the logistics ship was delayed for about a year, because it became necessary to hold a second round of competitive bids. The first short list, ready in December 2011, featured Bergen Group, the German P & S Werften and Hyundai. The offers that came in were too expensive, however, and the result was that the entire bidding contest was cancelled in May 2012. The following July, a new contest was announced; a step back was made to include the original eleven pre-qualified shipyards, requirements were lowered, and the upper financial framework was set at 1.3 billion NOK. –We took away the requirement of a roll-on, roll-off deck, introduced some ‘should have’ features such as the logistics ship s hould be able to carry more fuel, should have more space for containers on deck, and should have space for two helicopters. Briefly told, there were fewer military and more civilian requirements, said Commander Irgens. In January 2013, a new evaluation of the shipyards was held. At the time, some five or six yards were still in the running. Some had dropped out, others had gone under, such as the German P&S Werften. The end result was that Daewoo pulled the longest straw in the final bidding round. CAMP SUPPLY GROUP 5-STAR QUALITY CAMPS The four Norwegian companies of CSI, Norlense, GIAX, and HRO, joined forces in 2012 under the umbrella organisation of Camp Supply Group. For many years, all these companies have been working individually along several lines versus the Armed Forces in Norway and NATO. Text and photo: Tor Husby A t the start of the co-operation last year, the four had a combined defencerelated turnover of nearly 400 MNOK (44 MEUR), and a staff of 277 employees. When major projects come along, they will pool their resources to become a total provider of services at a high level of quality. Military purchasing organisations are increasingly looking for the “One Stop Shop”. It is practical and economical for them to have as few businesses to relate to as possible, in terms of purchasing, service, transport, customs, etc. Stronger together And on the other side of the table, each company gets stronger when they are togetherin a complex delivery than standingon their own. All four companies have several years’ standing as defence contractors in Norway, and all have frame agreements with NATO. The tents supplied by Norlense and GIAX, for example, have been developed in close co-operation with the Armed Forces, who are looking for inEngineering Manager Kjell Plassen and Executive Project Manager Karianne Andersen. The CSI office is practically situated on the Torp Airfield. novation and specific products. Networked co-operation in Norway is also necessary to meet the competition from the major players in other countries. stylishlydressed in a well-appointed office and pointing to urgent issues to be handled by subordinates is not this manager’s style when the going gets tough. Instead, he switches from civvies to fatigues and enters the arena himself. The company motto is ‘service anywhere, anytime within 48 hours’. And with offices practically on the runway at Torp International Airport, the distance to the planes is manageable indeed. Specialised CSI specialises in containers for kitchens, sanitary units, washrooms, water and trash handling and special containers. And lots A small story will illustrate their more besides. Partly manufactured in will to make the extra effort: Norway, partly made in China, for a broad Three days before Christmas 2004, Harald range of climates and temperature zones. Andersen, owner and CEO of Camp Supply Maintenance, on the other hand, is always International, was queried by the Defence done in Norway. Kitchen containers have whether the field kitchen that CSI had been supplied to SFOR and KFOR in the delivered to the Camp Invictia in Kabul Balkans, and to ISAF in Afghanistan. in Afghanistan, could be ready as early as Executive Project Manager Christmas Eve. Everyone in the camp just KarianneAndersen i CSI acknowledges HAD to have the traditional pork ribs that that the market is very much subject to particular evening. Andersen poked some change at these times. key assistants, and was airborne in a matter - But NATO and the Norwegian of hours. Arriving in the camp, they rolled Defence is still demanding precisely what up their sleeves and went to work, and as we are selling. Soldiers must eat and rest the 5PM bell tolled on the magic evening, somewhere, and must have effective sanithe ribs with all attendant trimmings were tary facilities at hand. Whet the group on the table. provides, is on an entirely different level I recount the episode as an illus- of quality than what used to prevail in the tration that the top dog of the CSI doesn’t market. Our kitchen containers are deshrink back from taking on demanding signed to match the standards of a five star manual tasks in awkward locations at hotel. A high standard on this point is no the most uncomfortable of times. Sitting wasteful luxury, but a basic necessity. Food poisoning is a clear and present danger, and can knock out entire units for days. Norwegian ISAF units have fortunately been spared of accidents like this, after the standard of food and kitchens was improved tremendously. High comfort is also offered in sleeping, sanitary and living containers, as well as containers for freezing and cooling, offices and overnight visitors. While the purchase price may be higher, the lifetime costs will be less. The containers have a design life of at least 20 years. As much as possible of the equipment shall be able to withstand being moved again and again, without being damaged, she emphasises. Inventions CSI is also proud to have developed containers with solar cell panels mounted on the roof. The invention cuts energy use by 80 percent. A further improvement is vacuum lavatories that reduces water consumption to just a pint per flush, vs. over a 10 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 CAMP SUPPLY GROUP gallon before. A 450 gallon water bladder in the roof provides heated water all of its own. These inventions are worth pure gold in desert areas. The company teaches the Defence to perform the simpler service tasks on its own. Any operations requiring skilled labour is carried out by CSI’s professional service engineers. Employees are continuously stationed in Afghanistan almost all the time. Last year, CSI received a surprise addition to its customer group when the Russian Defence placed an order for four complete camps with partial deliveries for two more. All the units are in place in the Russian Artillery’s biggest exercise area between Volgograd (ex-Stalingrad) and Astrakhan near the Caspian Sea. The main contractor was the German Roeder HTS Höcker. - The export order is a typical exampleto show that customers are looking for total solutions. But we did receive some unusual requests for the kitchen container– such as cooking pots that could prepare 300 litres of tea, or soup, for example, Karianne Andersen notes with a smile. Technically advanced military tents While containers for all kinds of use are the speciality field of CSI, the special field of collaborator GIAX is tents in advanced designs and sophisticated materials. The common trait of the two companies is the premium quality, which was initiated by the Defence. Thermal solutions have been developed, consisting of multi-layered sheets with air pockets in between. The tents are sufficiently strong to allow persons to walk across their roofs. Lamps, lights and cabling are integrated in the tents. Following the first sale of this type of tent to the Defence in 2005, 650 units have been supplied to defence units in Norway, Denmark, Sweden and Austria, along with an additional 140 connection tents. These can be connected to the containers of CSI with simple attachments. - When we connect to the kitchen containers, we have no problem serving 500 soldiers in one seating, says Engineering Manager Kjell Plassen. The tents can be extended as required – for example in a star configuration, as far as the need indicates. The company populates them with all the desired inventory. The functions are just as flexible. GIAX tents can be found all over, from the Arctic to desert areas. Kjell Plassen notes that the tents that were sent to Camp Nidaros were meant to stay there for two years. But they are still standing, having been nearly sand-blown. The commander of the Norwegian ISAF force, Col. Svein Harthor Andersen, gave the GIAX tents official recognition for their high quality. When a new camp is erected, sanitary tents are the first to go up. They are followed by the quickly inflatable tents of Norlense. In just a few minutes, these are inflated by high-pressure air. As a given, they can also be connected to the GIAX tents that are erected in the next building phase, in a process that takes just a few hours. Norlense has incidentally received an order for delivery of a field hospital to Singapore. HRO is the fourth wheel on the wagon, having specialised in road transport, special transport and storage services for the Defence. From the autumn, more than 800 containers will be freighted from Afghanistan back to the Armed Forces storage units at Eggemoen and Hensmoen; a shipment valued at several billion NOK. Like their CSG partners, HRO also maintains a crew in Afghanistan. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 11 NASAMS NORWEGIAN DEFENCE AND SECURITY INDUSTRIES ASSOCIATION ( FSI ) NASAMS CONTRACT WITH OMAN BREAKS ALL RECORDS Kongsberg: A single contract valued at 3.7 BNOK (435 MEUR) is not small potatoes, even for a defence industry company with roots dating back for 200 years. But never before has the Kongsberg Group landed such a serious fish as was accomplishedby Kongsberg Defence Systems, when the sale of NASAMS air defence systems to Oman was a fact in January 2014. Kongsberg Defence Systems is a subcontractor to Raytheonof the USA, which has the main contract for 1,2 bn USD (7.32 BNOK). Text and photo: Tor Husby O man buys the world’s best selling air defence system in order to protect cities, airports and other vital infrastructure elements against cruise missiles, fighterbombers and other low-flying threats. The choice was made following an extensive international bidding competition. Oman will receive the NASAMS system over a periodof four years, followed by two years’ support. The air defence system is the latestversion of NASAMS II. The system is subject to continuous development. –The system undergoes constant evolution. NASAMS must comprise solutions that can deal with future threats, says Eirik Lie, Executive Vice President for Integrated Defence Systems. Kongsberg Defence Systems is charged with command and control, as well as missile launchers (where each can fire six missiles), communications solutions, and training and education, while Raytheon among other things provides the radar systems of the Sentinel MPQ-64 type. Raytheon also holds the role of systems integrator. The missiles are standard AMRAAM version, and are delivered by the US Government. ary 2005, has been under a permanent NASAMSumbrella for 24 hours a day, speaks volumes of the value and capacity of the Norwegian-developed system. When President Barack Obama accepted the Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo in 2009, the Air Force similarly held a NASAMS umbrellaover him and his entourage. By purchasing the advanced air defence system, Oman joins the ever-growing ranks of nations that have made the same choice: Norway, Finland, Greece, Nederland, Poland, Spain, Sweden, Turkey, and the USA. Effort with a long view –This is the first time in history that Norwegian defence industry lands a contract of this size outside Europe. Really, the deal is something of a quantum leap. The export contract to Oman is the result of Norwegian long-term investments from the early 1990’s, where not just the Kongsberg Group, but also the Air Force and the Defence Research Establishment FFI col- Eirik Lie (rear) and Kyrre Lohne. Photo: Tor Husby laborated on the development of new solutions. The Air Force needed air defence systems that would accommodate Norwegian topography. Satisfactory solutions to this were found using NASAMS, and were soon in hot demand by other countries. Altogether, the Kongsberg Group has exported NASAMS to a value of more than 13 bn NOK (1.5 bn EUR), says Kyrre Lohne, Vice President for Strategic Communication with Kongsberg Defence Systems. One upshot of the Oman contract is that Kongsberg is outsourcing industry contracts of considerable magnitude to small and medium businesses, not just in Norway, but also in foreign countries. Another effect is that the company will need to increase its staff by 50 to 100 new employees over the next few years. Today, the concern staff amounts to approx. 7500 men and women, some 300 of whom are working on NASAMS. More contracts are to be expected in the air defence segment over the years ahead. Unique Air Image NASAMS (National Advanced Surface to Air Missile Systems) provides the defence with a unique air image in the course of milliseconds, and has proven its capacity and mobility through exercises in Norway and abroad over a period of many years. The unique features of the air defencesystem include the network structure, which can cover a large geographicalarea, and the flexibility with regard to the numberof launchers that can be connected. The fact that Washington, ever since the inauguration of President George W. Bush in Janu- 12 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 Test firing with NASAMS at Andøya test range. Photo: FMS NORWEGIAN DEFENCE AND SECURITY INDUSTRIES ASSOCIATION ( FSI ) N o r w e g i a n D e f e n c e a nd S e c u r i t y I nd u s t r i e s A ss o c i at i o n ( F S i ) THE LEADING ASSOCIATION IN NORWAY ADVOCATING THE INTERESTS OF ITS SECTOR, AND THE PRIMARY INTERLOCUTOR FOR THE GOVERNMENT IN MATTERS OF IMPORTANCE TO THE INDUSTRY. AFFILIATED WITH THE CONFEDERATION OF NORWEGIAN ENTERPRISE (NHO) AND REPRESENTING MORE THAN 100 COMPANIES Lederen har ordet: EKSPORTKONTROLL – FORUTSIGBARHET EN FORUTSETNING FOR KONKURRANSEEVNE Stortinget har akkurat avsluttet behandlingen av meldingen om eksport av forsvarsmateriell i 2012. Det er betryggende at det hersker bred politisk enighet i Stortinget om at praktiseringen av eksportkontrollen skal videreføres uten endringer. Det sikrer norsk forsvarsindustri stabile og forutsigbare rammebetingelser som gjør det mulig å satse langsiktig i det internasjonale forsvarsmarkedet i trygg forvissning om at så lenge bedriftene innretter seg etter etablert praksis vil nødvendige lisenser bli innvilget. For norsk forsvarsindustri er det helt avgjørende at det ikke skapes tvil om hvordan norske myndigheter vil praktisere eksportkontrollregimet. I internasjonal sammenheng er norsk forsvarsindustri en liten aktør som er helt avhengig av et tett og forpliktende samarbeid med andre lands industri for å kunne hevde oss i en stadig mer krevende konkurranse. Internasjonal forsvarsindustri er i endring. Et fremtredende trekk er at det etableres noen få store systemleverandører som er i stand til å utvikle og levere tunge komplekse våpensystemer og -plattformer. De aller fleste av disse hører hjemme i de store europeiske landene eller i USA. Et annet fremtredende trekk er at disse aktørene i mye større omfang enn tidligere benytter underleverandører, også for leveranser av kritiske delsystemer og komponenter som er helt avgjørende for at det komplette systemet skal fungere som forutsatt. Tidligere var det gjerne slik at systemleverandørene hadde all kritisk kompetanse i egen organisasjon. Dersom det allikevel var behov for å gå til under leverandører var det ikke uvanlig at det ble etablert to alternative leverandører for å ivareta leve ransesikkerheten. Slik er det ikke lenger. Fordi utviklingskostnadene har økt betydelig, volumet av anskaffelsene har blitt redusert, bud- P.O. Box 5250 Majorstuen, NO- 0303 Oslo. NORWAY sjettene er mindre og kompetanse er et knapphetsgode i forsvars industrien, er det ikke lengre mulig å gjennomføre store forsvars materiellprosjekter med et sett av overlappende underleverandører av kritiske delsystemer og komponenter. Utvikling av nytt forsvars materiell tar gjerne ti år eller mer og kostnadene er ofte mange milliarder kroner. Derfor blir stadig flere prosjekter gjennomført som flernasjonale prosjekter der industrien i de landene som finansierer utviklingen samarbeider. Som regel er det en leverandør, hjemmehørende i ett land som er ansvarlig for å sluttmontere og levere det ferdige produktet. Det betyr selvsagt også at eksport av det ferdige produktet må følge eksportkontrollregimet i nasjonen der ferdigstillelsen skjer. Det sier seg selv at dersom norsk forsvarsindustri i fremtiden skal få anledning til å delta i store flernasjonale forsvarsmateriellprosjekter, så må vi akseptere at våre leveranser av delsystemer og komponenter ikke begrenser Tel: + 47 23 08 80 00 Telefax: + 47 23 08 80 18 muligheten til å eksportere det ferdige produktet. Hvis ikke vil norsk industri bli utelukket fra å delta i slike prosjekter. Andre nasjoners industri vil ikke akseptere å involvere partnere der det hersker tvil om hvorvidt myndighetene vil sikre stabile og forutsigbare ramme betingelser for eksport. Norsk industri må være en troverdig og pålitelig partner og leverandør i flernasjonale samarbeid, som ofte har tidshorisont på tretti år eller mer fra utvikling starter til materiellet avhendes. Hvis ikke, vil det meste av norsk forsvarsindustri måtte legge ned sin virksomhet fordi det ikke lenger er økonomisk grunnlag for bransjen til å opprettholde aktiviteten og investere i ny teknologi, kunnskap og industriutvikling. Da kan vi heller ikke opp rettholde et nasjonalt kompe tansemiljø som Forsvaret trenger, og som skaper attraktive, lønnsomme og utfordrende arbeidsplasser i høyteknologiske bedrifter over hele landet. Heldigvis har et bredt politisk flertall på Stortinget forstått dette. E-mail:[email protected] Internet: www.fsi.no MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 13 NORWEGIAN DEFENCE AND SECURITY INDUSTRIES ASSOCIATION ( FSI ) NEW EU DIRECTIVE; NEW RULES FOR PROCUREMENT In January, the FSi hosted a seminar on the new procurement regulations for the Defence sector. The new regulations are a direct result of the new EU Directive on Defence Procurement, which has now entered into force. M r. Are Thengs from the matters and judicial cases will Ministry of Defence , be greater. At the same time, sectionfor joint judicial the directive may have opened services, opened his address by up for a greated degree of comgiving an overview of the new petition for the contracts, said regulations and the procedures Thengs in conclusion. that now apply, and which have Rolf Axel Berg from the been adapted to the terms of the Ministry of Defence presented new Directive. the new procurement regula–The new EU directive en- tions for the Defence (Nytt Antails that even defence and na- skaffelsesReglement for Forsvational security procurements ret – New ARF), which entered are now to be subject to open into force on the 1st of January competitive bidding from sup- 2014. Berg started by emphasispliers in the EU/EEA area. But ing that the new ARF is an inthe Article 123 of the EEA ternal use set of instructions on Agreement will still provide how the procurement activities scope for the parties to exercise of the Defence are to be conoptions to manage and protect ducted. the security interests of their –What we are seeing so far is country, Thengs explained. that the new directive demands However, there is currently a a high level of compliance and shortage of legal sources that cautiousness by the procurelaborate on the understanding ing authorities, Berg explained, of Article 123. adding that as time provides Thengs also gave a review more experience and fuller legal of experiences shared from sources on how the new EEA other countries where the new Directive is to be implemented EU Directivehas already been in practice, there will probably appliedfor some time. be a need for further revisions –What we see is that of the ARF. the procurement process is Mr. Åge Skøelv from the becomingmore important, and Norwegian Defence Research Esthat the incidence of complaint tablisment (FFI) reported that all From the left, Åge Skøelv, Rolf Axel Berg and Are Thengs. Photo: MilitærTeknikk 14 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 the EU countries are currently at work with efforts to give favour to and to stimulate their own defence industry. Skøelv was able to illustrate his points using quite specific figures. Despite the fact that many of the larger EU countries have put quite a significant number of contracts up for open bidding according to the stipulations of the directive, the result has still been that less than a single percent of the total contract values have ended up with a supplier from another EU country. The remainder has been assigned to the nations’ own defence industries. At the same time, the directive favours the major nations in different manners. The EU directive does not apply to the development of all-new types of materiel. And this new materiel will be exempt from the directive for the entire life span of the materiel in question. An example of this may be the NH 90 helicopters, which in all likelihood can be regarded as a new type of materiel, and will therefore be exempt from the directive’s regulations on open competition for procure- ments in the EEA region. The favour angle comes in through the fact that development projects of this magnitude can only be pushed through by the biggest economies in the European Union. Smaller nations like Norway can at the best of times only hope to play a part as subcontractor. –If you look at Norway, you will see that the Norwegian Defence buys only a third of its material from its own national industry. From this angle, you might say that Norway even today is compliant with the intentions of the directive, Skøelv remarked pointedly. In times ahead, it will be important that the defence market in the entire EU/EEA region as a whole will live up to the intentions on open competition and equal opportunity. In that case, Norwegian defence industry will win competitive contracts, and this will compensate for the disappearance of offset buying. –But if it turns out that it will be difficult to abide with the intentions of the EU directive, to provide a “Level playing field” in the defence acquisitions market, the consequences to the Norwegian defence industry will be felt. –And thus far, there is little to indicate that the intentions of the EU directive will be complied with in all the EU countries. But we will be monitoring the development closely, Skøelv concluded. NORWEGIAN DEFENCE AND SECURITY INDUSTRIES ASSOCIATION ( FSI ) PROGRAMME CONFERENCE ON INI AND AIR SYSTEMS The first Program Conference, on INI and Air Systems, was held on the 13th of January. It attracted a total of 100 participants from 35 companies. A Norwegian P-3 Orion reconnaissance plane has taken part in the pirate chase in the Bay of Aden and along the African east coast. Captain Trond-Are Lillejord from the 333 Squadron took part in these operations, and was able to report on the Norwegian contribution to the war on piracy. The Norwegian Orion plane was stationed on the Seychelles Islands, and had the ocean areas south of the Bay of Aden as its operational field of responsibility. The main task of the Orion plane was to register ships and traffic in the area, and take pictures of vessels of interest. The pictures were then analysed to determine whether an innocuous-looking fishing boat was really just this, or whether it was a boat equipped for acts of piracy. This information was passed on along with the pictures to allied navy ships in the area. –Our Orion planes proved themselves very well suited to this assignment. In particular, our ability to take pictures at night showed itself as very valuable, Lillejord explained. The pirate boats are generally open boats, loaded up with barrels of provisions such as fuel, water and food. The pirates may stay at sea for periods of maybe three to four weeks. When the pirates manage to hijack a ship, the regular pirate crewmembers take home some 500 USD. All in all, ransom payments of some 125 million USD have been paid to pirates along the east coast of Africa over recent years. Of this amount, only pocket change goes to the individual pirate crews. Indications are that the greater share goes to the Islamic guerrilla group AlShabaab. Frequent Attacks in the Cyber Domain Senior advisor Jon-Arne Nyland from the Ministry of Defence gave a rundown on the materiel projects currently in the works. Photo: MilitærTeknikk Major General Odd Egil Pedersen is the new commander of CYFOR, which stands for Cyber Defence, and gave a presentation of the tasks and challenges posed to CYFOR. –We are today seeing an ever-increasing incidence of threats in the cyber domain, Pedersen explained, while emphasising that even though the criminal element is a serious challenge, it is the governmentsupported players that pose the most menacing threat. –And the worst scenario is that these players can manage to sabotage or disrupt critical processes, which in its turn can cause physical destruction. –Defending oneself against attacks from these players entails not least to gain a full understanding of the situation in the cyber domain, which can be extremely difficult. But it is of fundamental importance in order to make the correct and not least timely decisions, Pedersen underscored. New Government, while most things remain as they were John Arne Nyland from the Ministry of Defence made his approach the change of government, and the attendant signals that have been discussed in the various media. –There has been a lot of speculation on the possibility of a re-match on a number of matters, given the fact that we now have a new Minister of Defence. In our interpretation of things, the new political management for now wishes to review the basis for the decisions made by the last government, and only in extreme cases will any major revisions to these decisions MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 15 NORWEGIAN DEFENCE AND SECURITY INDUSTRIES ASSOCIATION ( FSI ) be considered a possibility. And the major projects, such as the F-35 procurement, remain unchanged, emphasised Nyland. Nyland presented various projects currently in the works on the air side, and mentioned among other things that the F-16 aircraft will be retained as a first line fighter plane for many years to come. How many fuselages that will be upgraded to the top level has still not been clarified. Nyland mentioned that many of the Norwegian air warning radars, placed on mountain tops along our coast, are rapidly approaching the end of their useful life span, and work is in progress to uprate or replace these. –It is our hope that deliveries of new systems can start as early as 2018, explained Nyland. Nyland also mentioned in closing a new tactical transport helicopter, while emphasizing that the time frame for this will be well into the future. 16 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 Captain Trond-Are Lillejord from the 333 Squadron and Major General Odd Egil Pedersen, newly appointed commander of CYFOR. Photo: MilitærTeknikk BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE – B u ll e t i n B o a r d for 250 military logistic vehicles for France D e f e n c e , I nd u s t ry a nd Trade – Ammunition Market 2013 – 2023 Global conflicts, territorial The largest portion of this disputesand insurgencies will spending will, despite high fisdrive growth in the military am- cal deficits and the planned munition market over the next pullout from Afghanistan, be acdecade, despite Western mili- counted for by North America; tary withdrawal from combat the limitations on US spending zones in the Middle East brought about by the decreasing Global spending on mili- strategic relevance of direct intary ammunition is set to re- fantry conflicts will see the gap main relatively constant over between the North American the next ten years, according to and Asia-Pacific ammunition new market study (ASDReports. markets close however, with Incom) – The Global Military Am- dia, China, Australia and South munition Market 2013-2023 – Korea all predicted to spend sigwhich forecasts market growth nificantly on ammunition in the Kongsberg to support Polish at a annual growth rate of next decade. 2.21%, primarily driven by the This will take the market’s minehunter vessel programme sustained demand of existing value from US$6.1 billion in Remontowa Shipbuilding navigation and payload data conflicts, territorial disputes, 2013 to US$7.6 billion by 2023. has awarded a subcontract to quality to a depth of 1,000m, and insurgencies. Kongsberg Maritime to pro- 3,000m or 4,500m, depending vide the Hugin 1000 MR au- on configuration. tonomous underwater vehicle “The HUGIN 1000 MR AUV Terma ceases contract (AUV) in support of the Polish can detect, classify and identify Navy’s minehunter class vessel mines in a single mission.”For Denmark-based aerospace, de- issueda summons against the programme. synchronised and simultaneous fense and security group Terma PolishMinistry of National Under the contract, Kongs- operation, the underwater sys- has ceased the $30m contract Defence.”Terma defense and berg will deliver the AUV and tem can accommodate several with Polish Armaments Inspec- security senior vice-president associated underwater com- different types of high-perfor- torate (IU), the Ministry of Na- Steen Lynenskjold said the legal munications and positioning mance survey sensors. tional Defence of Poland. action has been considered very equipment for mine counterIn addition to enabling inteThe terminated contract thoroughly and is regarded as a measures (MCM) applications. gration of alternative sensors for scope included the supply of last resort by the company. Specifically designed for geophysical, search and inspec- aircraft survivability equipment Lynenskjold said, “We have MCM operations, the HUGIN tion purposes as per the require- for the Polish helicopters of the never previously experienced 1000 MR AUV can detect, clas- ments, the Hugin can be used Mi-17 and Mi-24 types. a customer’s refusal to receive sify and identify mines in a sin- for MCM, rapid environmental As a result of contract termi- an Aircraft Survivability Equipgle mission. assessment (REA)/ battlespace nation, Terma has issued a sum- ment despite the fact that Kongsberg will also deliver access, and intelligence, surveil- mons against the Polish Minis- Terma’ssolutions are installed the HiPAP underwater commu- lance and reconnaissance (ISR) try of National Defence. on 2,000+ aircraft platforms in nication and positioning system missions. Terma had been contracted 20 countries around the globe. to provide ultra short base line Other applications for the by IU to equip 22 Polish heli“IU has not been willing (USBL) updates and underwa- Hugin system include offshore copters of the Mi-17 and Mi-24 to accept the commonly used ter data communication with oil and gas geophysical survey, types with aircraft survivability de-facto standard to such tests the HUGIN 1000, or other un- inspection of pipelines and equipment in June 2010. based on the extensive experiderwater vehicles, as part of the underwater engineering strucThe dispute between ence Terma has with similar contract. tures, environmental monitor- Termaand IU related to con- deliveriesto allied partners.” Currently in service with ing, hydrography and marine tractual matters, as the firm Terma has provided airseveral navies including the research. and IU interpretthe contrac- craft survivability equipment Royal Norwegian Navy, the Remontowa serves as the tual requirementon false alarms for 20 different fighter aircrafts, Finnish Navy and the Italian prime contractor for developing very differently, according to the transportaircrafts and helicopNavy, in addition to commercial and delivering the new minehu- company. ter platforms in 20 Nato councompanies, the AUS can con- nter class vessels for the Polish “As a result of con- tries and Nato collaborative duct high-speed surveys with Navy. tract termination, Terma has countries. The Division of General Armaments (DGA) of the French Ministry of Defence placed an order for 250 logistic military trucks with the Iveco (CNH industrial Group) and Soframe (Lohr group) consortium. This batch forms part of the French «Porteurs Polyvalents Terrestres» (PPT) Programme. Delivery of the batch will start in 2016. The order includes two variants: a logistic vehicle and a recovery vehicle. Both vehicles share the same chassis with 4 axle 8 wheel drive (8x8), ensuring on and off road mobility in all climatic conditions (for example on snow covered mountain roads). MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 19 BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE Iranian upgrades C-130 Hercules Mobile Medical Shelters aircraft Smiths Detection has received a logical threats. They provide a The Iranian maintenance and logistics experts have repaired and overhauled the Islamic Republic of Iran’s Air Force (IRIAF) C-130 Hercules tactical transport aircraft. Carried out at the Martyr Major General Abbas Doran 7th Base, located in the western city of Shiraz, Iran, the overhauling operations took 23,000 man/ hours of professional work, Fars News Agency reports. The aircraft has joined the Iranian Air Force fleet following completion of its maiden flight test. Iran currently uses C-130E, C-130H and 1 RC-130 aircraft for troop and cargo transport operations. The Iranian experts have also successfully overhauled two mirage F-1 fighter jets at Shahid Nasser Habibi air base in north-eastern Iran, following 45,000 man/hours of work in August 2013. Iran also revealed in June last year that its experts were also upgrading different aircraft types, including the strategic Mig-29 and F-5 fighter jets, according to the news agency. 13 Percent Fuel Savings on T56 Engine Rolls-Royce has completed assemblyand ground testing of the first enhanced T56 engine for the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) WP-3D aircraft, demonstrating fuel use reduction over 13 per cent. NOAA’s “Hurricane Hunters” will be the first aircraft to fly the Rolls-Royce T56 engine enhancement, known as the Series 3.5. While C-130 flight tests and engine ground tests have shown significant improvement over requirements, the Series 3.5 package requirements call for a 7.9 per cent fuel reduction. Rolls-Royce and the US Air Force (USAF) have also started planning discussions for the introduction of the Series 3.5 into its fleet of C-130s. Initial funding of $15.7 million for the engine enhancement package was approved by Congress last month, launching the technology insertion for the USAF, Air Force Reserve and Air National Guard fleets. In addition to reduced fuel consumption, the enhancement package allows T56 engines to operate at significantly lower 20 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 turbine temperatures, extending parts life and improving reliability by 22 percent. The P-3 Series 3.5 flight test and qualification program, supported by Lockheed Martin, is planned to be completed later this year. The first fully equipped NOAA WP-3D aircraft with Series 3.5 enhancements is expected to enter service beginning in early 2015. The engine enhancement package is in the final stages of completing all requirements for US Air Force qualification on the C-130 and recently received FAA certification for the commercial version of the T56 engine. Deliveries of the new engine enhancement packages to the Air Force are expected to begin in 2016. The T56 Series 3.5 engine enhancement can be installed as part of a conventional engine overhaul, and does not require any aircraft or engine control system modifications. In addition to USAF and NOAA, international operators of C-130 and P-3 aircraft are also considering incorporating the T56 engine enhancement into their fleets. $42 million follow-on production order from the US Department of the Army for Chemical Biological Protective Shelters (CBPS) to equip the National Guard. CBPS systems are mobile medical shelters - designed to military specifications - highly resistant to chemical and bio- chemical/biological agent free environment in which to administer healthcare without the need for protective clothing and act as a safe haven for patients. CBPS systems are manufactured at Smiths Detection’s U.S. headquarters in Edgewood, Maryland. Germany cuts order for Eurofighter jets Germany’s defence ministry is planning to reduce its order for Eurofighter jets from 180 to 143. National news agency DPA quoted “government sources” as saying that the ministry’s number two, Stephane Beemelmans, had informed parliament’s defence committee about the decision. The reduction had already been decided in late 2011 by the then defence minister Thomas de Maziere, the report said. Out of the total order, more than 100 jets worth around 14 billion euros ($19.2 billion) have already been delivered. The defence ministry and manufacturer Eurofighter Jagdflugzeug GmbH did not comment on the report. Beemelmans was fired from his post as secretary of state over a series of procurement problems, including of a scan- German Eurofighter dal-tainted drone project, by new Defence Minister Ursula von der Leyen. Defence Committee chairman Hans-Peter Bartels meanwhile said Germany should further cut its Eurofighter fleet, according to business daily Handelsblatt. “We should reduce the Euro Fighter fleet to 108 machines, that’s enough,” he said. The Eurofighter consortium, Europe’s largest defence programme, is in fierce competition with other fighter-jet makers such as Lockheed Martin, Boeing and Dassault Aviation. Industry players and analysts voiced little surprise over the reduced German order of Eurofighters, a joint project of the Airbus Group, BAE Systems and Italian defence group Finmeccanica. Photo: Eurofighter BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE Bergen Group wins maintenance and service contract The Norwegian Defence Logistics Organisation (FLO) has awarded a framework agreement to Bergen Group Services for maintenance and service work related to MTU engines in the Norwegian Armed Forces. Under the four-year Nkr60m ($11m) framework agreement, Bergen Group will provide maintenance and service on the propulsion engines of a variety of naval vessels and combat vehicles. The agreement also includes maintenance for engines on the Navy’s Skjold-class coastal corvettes, minesweeper vessels and frigates, as well as Combat Leopard vehicles. Norwegian Navy Skjold-class corvettes Photo: Norwegian Navy / Forsvarets mediesenter P-8 for Australia The Australian Government has approved the acquisition of eight P-8A Poseidon maritime surveillance aircraft, worth approximately A$4bn ($3.6bn), including support facilities, to boost The Royal Australia Air Force’ (RAAF) maritime surveillance capabilities. All the eight aircraft are scheduled to be fully operational by 2021 while the first aircraft is expected to be delivered to Australia in 2017. An option for a further four aircraft has also been approved by the government subject to the results of the defence white paper review. RAAF will deploy the aircraft to replace the AP-3C Orion aircraft, which have been in service for more than 40 years Indian Navy´s P-8I Poseidon as well as to monitor maritime approachesand patrol more than 2.5 million square kilometres of marine jurisdiction. The P-8A is a potent and highly versatile aircraft that can also support missions including search and rescue, antisubmarine and maritime strike missions using torpedoes and Harpoon missiles. The P-8A is a long-range anti-submarine warfare, antisurface warfare, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance aircraft designed to ensure maximum interoperability in the future battle space. Capable of conducting broad-area maritime and littoral operations, the aircraft is based on Boeing’s Next-Generation 737-800 platform. Photo: Indian Navy Nammo – Finland partnership Nammo has signed a partnership agreement with the Finnish Ministry of Defense. The agreement covers security of supply and a long term partnership within the area of ammunition and propellants. This agreement is related to the recent acquisition by Nammo Lapua Oy of the propellant plant in Vihtavuori, which is today named Nammo Vihtavuori Oy. Nammo Vihtavuori Oy has been and continues to be an important supplier of propellants for Nammo’s civil and military products. “Patria owns 50% of the Nammo Group. Finland has always been one of the most important home markets for Nammo. This partnership agreement will strengthen our position and responsibility towards the Finnish Defense Forces even more than before. We are really looking forward to a long lasting and fruitful cooperation, says Edgar Fossheim, President & CEO of the Nammo Group.” General Dynamics wins $13bn military vehicle deal from Saudi Arabia General Dynamics Land Systems-Canada (GDLS) has won a $13bn contract from the Saudi Arabia Government to build and deliver military and civilian light-armoured vehicles, marking Canada’s largest advanced manufacturing export win. The 14-year contract, which involves the manufacturing and delivery of heavyarmoured fighting vehicles, ancillary equipment, training and support services, is valued at $10bn, but it could reach $13bn if all available options are exercised. The Saudi Arabia Government has been purchasing light, fast and off-road manoeuvrable A New Zeeland army’s LAV III. armoured vehicles from different firms since 2009. GDLS is behind the development of light-armoured vehicle three (LAV III), which is used by the Canadian army in Afghanistan, in addition to similar Stryker armoured vehicles for the US army. The latest contract for GDLS would boost the US weapons maker, who has been hit with drop in revenues amid declining US army spending on weaponry. Recently, the defence firm has been hit by Canada’s cancellation of a $2bn deal for the procurement of 108 heavy armoured personnel carriers. Photo: New Zeeland Army MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 21 BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE New Zealand selects Penguin KONGSBERG has signed a contract with the New Zealand Defence Force for the delivery of Penguin Mk 2 Mod 7 anti-ship missiles and associated equipment. The missiles will be deployed on the Royal New Zealand Navy new Kaman SH-2G Super Seasprite maritime helicopters. This contract strongly confirms the Penguin missile’s position as the leading missile within its segment. The contract is for a limited number of missiles, however it is considered an important upgrade of New Zealand’s navy,” says Pål Bratlie, EVP Kongsberg Defence Systems. RUAG and Patria team up for F/A-18 support An Industry Teaming Agreement has been signed between Finland’s Patria Aviation and Switzerland’s RUAG Aviation. The two companies are collaborating to deliver life cycle support for the F/A-18 fleets of the Finnish and Swiss air forces, as well as those of other prospective customers. The Finnish Ministry of Defence and the Swiss Department of Defence, Civil Protection and Sports have agreed to study the impacts of the worldwide F/A18 sundown programmes that will progressively affect the Finnish and Swiss fleets. The Industry Teaming Agreement supports the Finn-Swiss F/A-18 joint Life Cycle planning, which aims to improve cost efficiency in future sustainment as well as information exchange between the two countries and their respective industries. Chinook and Apache contracts this year? Kaman SH-2G Super Seasprite. Photo: US Navy Saab contract to Ruag Saab awards Ruag in Emmen LU a contract worth 68 million francs for the development and production of pylons for Gripen E. 15.5 million francs of this contract are effective immediately. Ruag has agreed to fulfil a fifth of the contract in collaboration with small and medium size subcontractors from the French and Italian speaking regions of Switzerland. The pylons are important and significant structural parts of Gripen E and act as mounts for weapons, reconnaissance pods and external fuel tanks. They have been ordered to feature in the 22 Gripen E for Switzerland and 60 Gripen E for Sweden. Saab reserves the right to award the actual large-scale production for all Gripen E for Sweden and Switzerland to an other party than Ruag, depend- 22 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 ing on the result of the Gripen E referendum. The sale of Gripen E to Switzerland – conditional on the outcome of the referendum in May – is contingent on Saab delivering an industrial cooperation programme with Swiss industry, valued at 2.2 billion francs. By the end of 2013 Saab had already arranged for business in Switzerland, valued at over 300 million francs with 125 companies and has ten years time to fulfil its remaining obligation. armasuisse, the Swiss defence procurement agency has so far analysed and accepted 250 million francs as offset transactions and is investigating the remaining. The suppliers of Gripen E weapons have an additional offset obligation of 300 million francs, making the total industrial programme for Switzerland worth 2.5 billion francs. Boeing is anticipating contract awards for 15 CH-47F Chinook heavy-lift helicopters and 22 AH64E Apache combat helicopters from India by later this year. Currently in last signature routing with the Ministry of Defence for both the planned procurements, India submitted final offers for acquiring Apache and Chinook in 2009 and 2010 respectively and the company has also held the prices for both helicopters since then. Boeing Vertical Lift vicepresident and general manager Leanne Caret said: “We expect that the contract award for the Chinook will come in the first half of the year, and the award for the Apache in the second half of the year.” “We expect that the contract award for the Chinook AH-64E Apache combat helicopter will come in the first half of the year.””We really have taken on an affordability measure being able to give that back to the customer.” Boeing is also working on further developments for the AH-64 programme, which claims to incorporate more technologies. India has recently allocated about $36.3bn in defence spending for 2014-2015, up 10%, with $14.93bn being allotted for weapon and equipment purchases during the next fiscal year. Of the overall fund diverted for defence, about $1.16bn is anticipated to be used for procuring Boeing AH-64-D Apache helicopters, and about $833m will be spent for Chinook heavy-lift helicopters. Photo: MilitærTeknikk BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE New vessel for the Arctic The Danish Navy is building a new ship for operations in the Northern Atlantic region. The ship is to be built at Karstensens Skibsværft A/S, and will carry a price tag of half a billion DKK, or 65 million EUR. The vessel will be 72 meters long, with a beam of 14.6 meters, and a draught of some 5 meters. The ship will have a crew complement of 18 to 20 persons. The ship will be equipped with a variety of sensors for monitoring the air space, in addition to sonar systems for sea floor measurements. Furthermore, the ship will get an advanced firing control systems for its 76 mm cannon. Formation flight of five A400M Photo: Airbus Germany’s first A400M aircraft Saab and Kalyani Group team up for Indian Army air defence projects Saab has entered into a strategic alliance with India’s high-technology multinational Kalyani Group to address critical Indian Army air defence projects. The agreement will initially focus on the army’s very short range air defence (VSHORAD) and short-range surface-to-air missiles (SRSAM) programmes. Saab president and CEO Hakan Bushke said that the company has made a long-term commitment to India and is keen to support the country’s efforts to create an indigenous defence industry. Saab is offering a system based on its Robotsystem (RBS) 70 new generation (NG) missile system for the VSHORAD project. An upgraded version of RBS 70 man-portable air-defence system (MANPADS), RBS 70 NG, is designed to deliver a highly accurate, man-portable system with 24/7 all-target ca- Ashok Leyland´s Super Stallion 8x8 pability that is immune to countermeasures. For the SRSAM requirement, the company is offering a unique combination of its BAMSE advanced ground-based air defence missile system and Giraffe agile multi-beam (AMB) 3D surveillance radar, command and control system. Saab, Ashok Leyland join forces for Indian Army’s SRSAM programme Saab has also partnered with India-based transport specialist Ashok Leyland to compete for the Indian Army’s short range surface to air missile (SRSAM) air defence programme. The solution offered for the SRSAM requirement combines the Saab BAMSE missile system with Ashok Leyland’s Super Stallion 8x8, a high-mobility vehicle capable of operating in all types of terrain under all weather conditions. Photo: Ashok Leyland Airbus Defence and Space has started final assembly of the German Air Force’s (Luftwaffe) first A400M Atlas next-generation military transport aircraft. The assembly of the aircraft, designated MSN18, commenced with the arrival of all major structures, including fuselage at the company’s final assembly line (FAL) in Seville, Spain. Around 60 A400M nextgeneration airlifters were initially ordered by Germany in November 2010, but the number was later reduced to 53, including seven options, due to budgetary constraints. In addition to this, Germany expressed plans to sell 13 of the aircraft it has committed to purchase from Airbus to foreign customers in a bid to further reduce the programme costs. Apart from Germany, the A400M aircraft has also been ordered by the air forces of Belgium, France, Luxembourg, Malaysia, Spain, Turkey and the UK. Delivery of the first aircraft to the German Air Force is scheduled to take place in November 2014. Big order from Norway placed with DOCKSTAVARVET DOCKSTAVARVET has entered into a contract with the Norwegian Defence Logistics Organisation, FLO, for the supply of two Search, Rescue and Service Vessels with options for one further vessel as well as future supplies of spare parts and maintenance. The total order value including options can go as high as 100 MSEK (just under 10 MEUR). The term of delivery for the basic order is a total of 19 months. The boats will carry the yard’s designation of IC 20 M, will have a length of 20 meters, and are built entirely from aluminium. They will be equipped with waterjet propulsion systems from MJP, and two MTU main engines of some 1200 kW each, and with extensive electrics and electronics installa- tions. The FLO has posed high demands to performance, load capacity and seaworthiness. “We have in the past supplied 20 units of Stridsbåt 90 N to the Norwegian Navy, and built a vast number of very fast patrol boats of the IC 16 M type for export to other countries, and we believe that it is our documented experience and reliable delivery performance which has swayed the decision in our favour”, says the shipyard’s Chairman of the Board, K-A Sundin. The yard has also recently signed a contract for a newbuilding for The Swedish Maritime Administration – Sjöfartsverket – and in total, the shipyard has a very satisfactory order reserve through the summer of 2015. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 23 BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE Berget AS 9100 certified for Aerospace production On the 6th of January 2014, Berget was certified and approved according to AS9100C . –We have completed this certification based on our faith in the aerospace market over the next years to come, says General Manager for Berget AS, Mr. Arnstein Frøymyr. Berget AS is a manufacturer of fine mechanics components. The company is located in Notodden, Telemark, approximately 110 km south-west of Oslo. The company has 48 employees, and is a contractor for high quality/high precision mechanics. The customer list includes names like Kongsberg Defence and Aerospace as well as GKN. –We realise that the major share of the Norwegian defence budget will go to the F-35 procurement, which is the reason why we feel it is prudent to secure a position in the aerospace market. The certification also gives us good opportunities within the civilian air traffic market, says Frøymyr, adding that there is an increasing tendency for customers even outside the aerospace market to look for certifications of this kind. The Ministry of Defence has contributed some support to the certification process. As per today, less than 10 businesses in Norway hold this certification. 24 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 Saab has signed a contract comprising missile components amounting to approx SEK 437 million. Deliveries will take place during 2015-2017. Saab is a significant supplier of high-performing and costeffective missile systems and components for air, land and naval operations. The strong product portfolio includes air defence system RBS 70, and the latest generation RBS 70 NG, NLAW anti-tank system and RBS15 anti-ship missile system. Furthermore, Saab also participates in a number of multinational cooperation missile development programmes. The industry’s nature is such that depending on circumstances concerning the product and customer, information regarding the customer will not be announced. IMP engages Josi Tech to find offset partners General Manager Arnstein Frøymyr of Berget AS. The business has now been certified with a view to targeting customers in the aerospace market. Photo: MilitærTeknikk Three candidates for Danish Artillery System There are now three candidates remaining in the running for the role of upcoming supplier of artillery systems for the Danish Defence. In the beginning there were four, which have now been pared down to three. In the competitive contest for becoming the next supplier of artillery systems, one of the potential suppliers has been excluded from the contest, for reasons of failing to meet with the minimum requirements of the Defence. The non-conforming candidate is the artillery system from the American BAE Systems Land & Armaments, which cannot fulfil the minimum require- Order for missile components ments defined for the invitation to tender. This ITT called for the four pre-qualified candidates to submit an introductory offer by the end of November 2013. These submissions have led to a negotiating process with the remaining candidates, which are Nexter with the CAESAR system, Elbit Systems with the Atmos system, and Samsung with K9 Thunder. A contract signing is expected towards the end of 2014. The contract will cover a number of 9 to 21 artillery systems, to become the replacement for the howitzers of the M109 type, dating back to 1965. Canadian company IMP Aerospace & Defence Ltd has completed a major contract upgrading Norwegian P-3 Orion surveillance aircraft. This has raised a offset purchase obligation on the part of the Canadian business vis-à-vis Norway in the region of 300-350 million NOK (approximately 40 mill EUR). IMP has now engaged Norwegian Josi Tech to coordinate the company’s offset activities towards Norway and Norwegian industry. Josi Tech is a Norwegian company based in Oslo, representing a number of foreign businesses in Norway. –Our job is to come up with possible Norwegian industry partners, and to be a kind of “match maker” between IMP and the Norwegian companies, says Siri Andresen at Josi Tech. –Hopefully we can find some interesting areas of industrial co-operation, to the long term benefit of both Norwegian and Canadian industry. CANSEC 2014 –One of our main tasks this spring will be to coordinate Norwegian Industry participation at CANSEC 2014, Siri Andresen continues. CANSEC is Canada’s foremost defence trade show, and will take place in Ottawa on the 28th to 29th of May this year. The trade show is organized by the Canadian Association of Defence and Security Industries (CADSI), a defence business association representing more than 1000 member companies. –We hope that we can gather a group of Norwegian defence companies to participate at CANSEC, as a part of the IMP offset activities here in Norway, Andresen says in conclusion. Norwegian P-3 Orion surveillance aircraft. The recent upgrading of the Norwegian P-3 Orion fleet has raised an offset purchase obligation of approximately 300-350 million NOK. Photo: Peder Torp Mathisen/FMS BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE JSM development contract KONGSBERG has today signed a bridging-phase contract leading to phase 3 with Norwegian Defence Logistics Organization (NDLO) for further development of the JSM (Joint Strike Missile). The contract is valued at NOK 480 million. The JSM development phase 2 has been finalized and to ensure competence and progress between JSM phase 2 and phase 3, the Norwegian Armed Forces have signed a bridging phase contract prior to parliamentary proceedings and approval of the entire JSM development phase 3. In phase 2 of the project the missile underwent detailed design and a successful integration check for the F-35 as well as for the F-16 and the F-18. In phase three the missile will be completed and ready for serial production, and there will also be produced several units that will be tested from fighter jets in several practical exercises. The JSM is the only long-range sea and landtarget missile that can be carried internally in the F-35 and thus ensuring the aircrafts low-signature (stealth) capabilities. After a successful phase 3 KONGSBERG will be ready to receive orders and start serial production. Danish MLRS vehicles sold to Finland The Defence Materiel Service (Forsvarets Materieltjeneste) has sold the Danish Multiple Launch Rocket Systems (MLRS) vehicles to the Finnish Defence. Forsvarets Materieltjeneste has entered into an agreement with the Finnish Defence, for the sale of Denmark’s fleet of Multiple Launch Rocket Systems (MLRS). The agreement covers the sale of twelve rocket launchers, which is the entire complement of MLRS systems in the Danish Defence. At the present time, Defence spokespeople say the agreement for the HLRS sale has a value of a two-digit number of millions of DKK. Test firing with a U.S. MLRS system. The Danish Defence procuredits total of 12 MLRS systemsin 1998, along with some 300 rockets. The decision to phase out the systemswas made in 2005. Denmarkhas never utilised the systems in connection with international operations. Photo: US Army Afghan National Army receives additional Mi-17V-5 helicopters Afghan Mi-17V-5 multi-mission helicopters in flight The Afghan National Army (ANA) has taken delivery of the second batch of Mil Mi-17V-5 military-transport helicopters from Russia. The six helicopters were delivered by Kazan Helicopter Plant under a contract signed between state-arm-exporter Rosoboronexport and the US government in 2013, for supply of a total of 30 helicopters to ANA this year. Around 39 Mi-17V-5 helicopters have been delivered to date, under a $367.5m contract signed between the US Army Forces Command and Rosoboronexport in May 2011, and an additional agreement concluded with the US under an option to the main contract. A total of 63 Mi-17V-5s Photo: U.S. Air Force worth $1.333bn are scheduled to be handed over to Afghan National Army within the framework of joint efforts to combat international terrorism. Capable of transporting up to 36 passengers or 4t of cargo, the helicopter features a loading ramp instead of clam-shell doors, an additional door and a new dolphin nose. The helicopters are primarily intended to enhance the Afghan national security forces’ capabilities for conducting urban warfare and special units operations against Taliban insurgents. Remaining helicopters under the contract are scheduled to be delivered through the year in batches comprising six helicopters each. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 25 BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE Corruption charges levied against Kongsberg Russia plans for new military command in Arctic The Norwegian National Authority for Investigation and Prosecution of Economic and Environmental Crime (ØKOKRIM) has taken out charges against KONGSBERG with allegations of corruption The charge is related to allegations of corruption (cf. Norwegian penal code §276a, cf. §276b, cf. §48a) related to deliveries of communication equipment to Rumania from 1999 to 2008. The deliveries to Rumania have consisted of several partial contracts with a total contract value of some 1.4 billion NOK, or 160 million EUR. The main parts of the deliveries have been communications gear for border control and the police. KONGSBERG was informed about the charges today, and the Chairman of the Board has been informed. KONGSBERG will cooperate closely with Økokrim and other relevant authorities to clarify all the facts in relation to the charges. Russia is planning to create a new strategic military command in the Arctic by the end of 2014, to defend its interests in the region. An undisclosed source in Russia’s General Staff was quoted by RIA Novosti as saying that, “The new command will comprise the Northern Fleet, Arctic warfare brigades, air force and air defence units as well as additional administrative structures.” The Northern Fleet-Unified Strategic Command will take the responsibility of protecting Russia’s Arctic shipping and fishing, oil and gas fields on the Arctic shelf, along with country’s national borders in the north. In December 2013, Russia President Vladimir Putin ordered the military to increase its presence in the Arctic and complete the military infrastructure development in the region in 2014. “The military has started the deployment of aero- space defense units in the Arctic.”According to the Aerospace Defense Forces commander Alexander Golovko, the military has started the deployment of aerospace defense units in the Arctic and also construction of warning missile radar in extreme north of Russia. The Defense Ministry is also planning to re-open airfields and ports on the New Siberian Islands and Franz Josef Land archipelago. In addition to this, the ministry intends to re-open around seven airstrips on the Arctic Circle’s continental part, which were mothballed in 1993. Arctic territories, which hold vast untapped oil and gas reserves, are the centre of disputes between the US, Russia, Canada, Norway and Denmark. The countries believe that the rising temperatures in the region will lead to a reduction in sea ice, which is expected to provide easy access to energy reserves. The systems, along with other equipment, are expected to be used to protect Brazil’s strategic infrastructure, and the major sporting events the country will host in future, including the 2014 FIFA World Cup, and the 2016 Summer Olympics in Rio de Janeiro. Originally designed and manufactured by Saab Bo- fors Dynamics, the RBS 70 is a man-portable air-defense system (MANPADS) designed for anti-aircraft warfare and for protection of mobile units in all climate zones, with little to no support from other forces. The basic RBS 70 comprises a tripod firing stand, optical sight and the missile in a launch container, which can be operated independently in stand-alone mode or can be configured with several firing units linked with a surveillance radar to form an anti-aircraft battery. Saab has also developed an upgraded version of the system, called RBS 70 NG, which is designed to deliver a highly accurate, man-portable system with 24/7 all-target capability that is immune to countermeasures. Initial deliveries under the contract are scheduled to take place this year. CEO Walter Qvam explained that the company launched an internal investigation into the matter in the spring of 2012, based on rumours circulating in the company. The company used PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) as independent external reviewers of the matter. In conjunction with PwC, the matter was provisionally closed in the autumn of 2013, as no sufficient grounds were found to proceed further with the matter. The matter has now found its way to ØKOKRIM, which in its turn has filed charges against an as yet unnamed person from the Kongsberg Group. CEO Qvam says, however, that the person in question is not a part of the corporate executive management group. To secure evidence, ØKOKRIM has performed significant seizures of documents and other material from the company. Brazilian army orders Robot 70 Saab has been awarded a contract to supply the Robotsystem (RBS) 70 very short range air defence system (VSHORAD) to the Brazilian Army. Valued at SEK80m ($12.3m), the contract covers delivery of an undisclosed number of RBS 70 man-portable Test firing with RBS 70 26 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 launchers, Mk II type missiles and associated equipment. Specific equipment to be supplied includes simulators, night vision equipment, a test set, maintenance tools, spares and associated equipment, as well as training for the weapon’s operators and maintainers. Photo: Saab BULLETIN BOARD FOR DEFENCE, INDUSTRY AND TRADE CARL-GUSTAF; Standard Issue for US Army Carl-Gustaf has been chosen by the U.S. Department of the Army to be a Program of Record within the U.S. Army. This means that the shoulder fired weapon system, with a long service record with the U.S. Special Operations Forces, will now become standard issue to the U.S. Army’s Light Infantry units. The Carl-Gustaf system will provide the U.S. Army with a capability that units using disposable shoulder fired munitions currently lack. This system has been a key component of the U.S. Special Operations Forces for over twenty years. “The fact that the U.S. Army has now elected to designate Carl-Gustaf (M3 MAAWS in the U.S.) as a Program of Record, thereby enabling it to be broadly fielded to its light Infantry units speaks for itself. The Carl-Gustaf has repeatedly proven itself in U.S. Special Operations Forces firing Carl-Gustaf in Iraq the world’s most demanding environments as a versatile, powerful tool for the infantry soldier”, says Jonas Hjelm, President of Saab North America. As true multi-role, manportable shoulder-fired weapon, the Carl-Gustaf weapon system is currently in use in more than 40 countries worldwide. The highly modern system has a long and successful history, Photo: US Armed Forces / Christopher Perez and it has been continuously modernized to adapt to the users’ ever changing needs. Anticipating future operational needs, Saab is constantly working to make a great system even better. A new, lighter weight, version of the Carl-Gustaf is currently under development. Furthermore, advances are also being made to the Carl-Gus- taf ammunition family with the recent release of the new 655 CS (Confined Space) High explosive anti-tank (HEAT) round. This is the first in a new generation of munitions for the Carl-Gustaf designed to reduce back blast. This will allow soldiers to safely employ the weapon in confined spaces, minimizing the hazardous effects of traditional shoulder fired munitions. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 27 3M 3M: A CORPORATION WITH A BROAD SPECTRUM OF PRODUCTS Say 3M, and most people’s thoughts will spring to the yellow Post-it® note pads adorning office desk and kitchen tables everywhere. But 3M is the source of a massivearray of highly diverseproducts; the company is also a major supplier to the defence industry, to Norway as well as worldwide. T he 3M Company, formerly known as the Minnesota Mining and Manu facturingCompany, is an American multinational conglomerate corporation based in St. Paul, Minnesota. 3M headquarters are in the St. Paul suburb of Maplewood, Minnesota. With $30 billion in sales, 3M employs 88,000 people worldwide and produces more than 55,000 products, including: adhesives, abrasives, laminates, passive fire protection, dental products, electronic materials, medical products, carcareproducts (sun films, polish, wax, car shampoo, treatment for the exterior, interior and the under chassis rust protection), electronic circuits, and optical films. 3M has operations in more than 65 countries 28 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 Military vehicles covered in plastic film: The plastic film reduces wear on the painted surfaces, and many countries use this type of film on vehicles, planes and helicopters in Afghanistan, where airborne sand and dust cause extraordinary wear on all exposed surfaces. including 29 international companies with manufacturing operations and 35 companies with laboratories. 3M products are available for purchase through distributors and retailers in more than 196 countries, and online directly from the company. Major Defence Supplier In the defence sphere, 3M provides prod- ucts within the areas of health and medical services, protective and safety gear and equipment, as well as a variety of protective foils. Furthermore, the company provides a range of grinding and cutting products that are found in huge numbers in military workshops all over the world. For many years, 3M has been a provider of various protective gear prod- 3M also provides safety goggles for civilian as well as military use. Films for promotion and protection 3M is also a major supplier of medical equipment, among other things of various types of bandages and field dressings. In addition to deliveries to the individual countries’ medical units, the company also provides deliveries to the NATO supply system. ucts like face masks, goggles etc. 3M has acquired a controlling interest in the Swedish hearing protection manufacturer Peltor. Peltor has since its start-up in 1950 been a close collaborating partner to the Swedish Defence, and over the years, headsets from Peltor has been sold to defence organisations in a number of countries, Norway among them. Hardly a single soldier at a military shooting range in Norway or Swedenhas avoided close contact with 3M Peltor hearing defenders. Today, however, these units offer far more than simply passive protection against noise. 3M provides a range of headset solutions that could include built-in communication systems. Under the protective heading, 3M Most people will have observed promotional markings and images on cars and aircraft, for example the famous Scandinavians depicted on the tail fin of the planes of the airline Norwegian Air Shuttle. These are attached to the vehicle or aircraft as a film from 3M. But a similar technology is used by many countries’ defence to protect their vehicles against abnormal wear and tear. A case in point is Afghanistan, where materiel has been subject to extreme wear due to flying sand and dust in the air, and where many countries have been using plastic foils on their vehicles to protect the painted surfaces underneath. But not just vehicles have been protected in this manner. Aircraft and helicopters have also been equipped with a protective film to reduce wear. In some cases, even rotor blades on helicopters have been covered with 3M films to protect them from extraordinary wear in the sandy environment of Afghanistan. For defence vehicles, the use of these types of film offers a number of other opportunities. When changing the camouflage colours and patterns on the vehicles, for instance from summer to winter camouflage, or in connection with foreign missions or UN missions, this can be accomplished by applying plastic films with the desired appearance on the surfaces of the vehicle. Returning the vehicle to its original colour then becomes merely a matter of peeling off the tape. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 29 3M INVISIBLE FILM OFFERS BOMB PROTECTION Explosion test of window film. The nearest window is covered with 3M film. The glass is held back and people (“white dummy heads”) inside are protected from glass slivers. The window to the right is a regular window without the 3M film, and the exsplosion makes glass slivers fly like projectiles. Photo: 3M The attaching of a simple, invisible plastic film to the inside of exposed widows will help prevent shards of glass from flying through the room when a bomb goes off in the street outside. The foil or film is envisioned as used in public or government as well as private buildings to offer added protection in the face of terror attacks. A lmost every day, the news brings us gruesome images and horror stories from bomb actions around the globe. As often as not, these are bombs placed in streets or built-up areas, to ensure the highest possible amount of damage and injury to people in the streets and the surrounding buildings. The images from these kinds of actionsoften depict buildings where every window has been impacted. Much of the damage from these bombs is inflicted upon the people inside the buildings, where glass slivers from broken windows fly like projectiles through the rooms inside. It has actually been determined that up to 90 percent of the injuries to personnel inside a building outside of which a bomb is set off, can be ascribed to damages from flying glass. And one thing is the bigger slivers that cut up whatever they hit. These larger splinters can be removed and extracted through surgery. But even worse is the damage from the microscopic glass splinters that enter a body, penetrate the blood vessels and are carried around in these. They are extremely difficult to locate and 30 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 remove surgically, while continuing to inflict damage and pain for a long time after penetration into the body. There is, however, a simple and inexpensive solution that reduces the risk of glass-related injuries in an explosion to a minimum. The attaching of a special, invisible plastic film to the inside of exposed widows will help hold broken shards of glass back from flying through the room in the event of a bomb going off outside the building. The window will still be broken per se, but the amount of splintering in the room on the inside will be reduced to virtuallyzero. This will reduce the amount of injuries to the personnel inside. Typical application areas for the film will be all kinds of buildings regarded as a possible target for terrorist attacks, such as public and government buildings, embassies and office complexes in exposed areas, housing complexes and the like. One particular advantage of the film is that it can easily be attached to the inside glass areas with no outside indication of its presence. Attaching the film will also not change the architectural impression or appearanceof After the explosion. The glass is broken, but held back by the 3M film. Special attention should also be made to glass surfaces inside the building as ie. Office walls. Usuall the type of glass used for this purpose is less resistant to breakage and as the pressure waves from a detonnation hit a building it can have a more devestating result than that of the glass on the front og the building. Photo: 3M the building. The film also allows just a minimum of resistance to light ingression, so that the people inside the building will not have to suffer a reduction in light or visibility outside. F-35 F-35: STILL TROUBLED BUT ALSO ON THE ROLL MilitærTeknikk visited Lockheed Martin’s facility in Fort Worth, Texas, where the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter is rolling of the assembly line. It is in production but it still has some major unsolved issues. By Andreas Krog journalists do not collide with cars with aircraft parts. uring World War Two this enormous At three-story high assembly stabuilding was housing an assembly line tions Lockheed Martin’s engineers work for B-29 bomber aircraft. Today the 1725 steadily on assembling aircraft for the U.S. meters long building in the western part of Air Force , Navy and Marine Corps as well Fort Worth in Texas is home to Lockheed as to countries such as Australia and Italy. Martin’s F-35 Joint Strike Fighter assembly The assembly line has seven stations at the line, which MilitærTeknikk visited in moment. But a major expansion is underNovemberlast year. way and when the project reaches the full In a small golf cart with factory production rate in 2018, the plan is to have chief Kevin McCormick as a driver and 12 mating stations. avidly telling us about the assembly line, The engineers barely see us rolling we roll down the long roads in the by in the golf cart. We are just another delefactory. Stop signs ensure that golf carts with gation of politicians, journalists or business D Every Wednesday the aircraft are moved to the next station on the assembly line in the 1700 meter long factory. people getting the big sales tour around the factory. Eight countries, including Denmark and Norway, have been partners in the huge project since 1997. Norway selected the F-35 in 2008. But not all partner countries have decided to procure the plane, and Lockheed Martin is also working hard on selling the plane in other countries. Tours for foreign visitors is therefore an almost daily event at the factory. Four years of negotiations Kevin McCormick stops the golf cart at a carefully selected assembly station. Here we can see one of the components that the Danish weapons manufacturer Terma produces to be fitted on the aircraft. This is tangible proof that the plane is creating Danish jobs. But as long as Denmark haven’t decided that the F-35 shall become the country’s future combat aircraft, Terma Photo: Lockheed Martin MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 31 F-35 will only be producing parts for the low rate initial production phases. Denmark needs to buy the plane for the Danish industry to be sub-suppliers when the aircraft goes into full production in 2019. It took Norway more than four years to negotiate the final contract for Norway’s 56 F-35 aircrafts. The big hurdle was securing the Norwegian defense industry a feasible amount of work on the F-35 project. Train tracks in the ceiling are used to move the aircraft to new assembly stations. Every Wednesday night is moving time until the aircraft finally reaches the end of the assembly hall. The aircraft is then checked with laser beams in a special room to make sure everything is installed correctly. Up to five days of painting Designed in from the beginning After an engine test in front of the assembly hall, the aircraft is rolled into the nearby painting hangar. It actually consists of eight smaller hangars inside the hangar; four on each side. In the first three on the left side technicians make the plane ready for painting. Cockpit windows, antennas and sensors are being masked before the plane is rolled into one of the two fully automatic paint facilities at the end. Three robots work on giving the aircraft the necessary primer and paint. This is a job that takes up to five days for a single airplane. An extraction system on the back wall keeps flies and other impurities away. When the robots have done their work, people take over again and add squadron markings and tail decorations. After the factory tour, director Dave Scott from Lockheed Martin gives us a thorough run through of the F-35 project and the difference between that and legacy combat aircrafts. “Advanced stealth capabilities must be designed into the aircraft from the beginning. You can’t suddenly change the edges on an F-16 to be aligned so that the plane can deflect radar detection just as good as the F-35 can,” says Dave Scott, director for F-35 International Customer Engagement at Lockheed Martin. The F-35 is not 100 percent invisible, but it is a lot less visible than legacy aircrafts like the F-16 and the F-18. Internal weapon bays, embedded antennas, nozzles designed especially with focus on reducing the radar signature and a special “air superiority grey” color scheme are just some of the features aimed at making the F-35 as stealthy as possible. Tough work still ahead The F-35’s software consists of over 8.6 million lines of code. In comparison the F-22 had 2,2 million lines of code and the F-16 had a little over one million lines of code. Pentagon’s director for operational test and evaluation, Michael Gilmore, and the American Government’s Accountability Office, often warns that a lot of software code still needs to be written and that most of the tough work is still ahead. Dave Scott admits that they still have some coding to do. But not as much and not as critical as the outside evaluators say. “We are flying with 88 percent of the software and have coded over 96 percent so far. The software development will be completed in the beginning of 2017,” assures Dave Scott. Total different price The outside evaluators estimate the average unit procurement cost for the F-35 to be well over 100 million US Dollars for the low rate initial production aircrafts being produced at the moment. Dave Scott doesn’t question this estimate, but he promises that the price will be a totally different one when the aircraft goes into full production in 2019. “I can guarantee that the flyaway cost including engine in 2018 will be 75 million 2012-US Dollars, equal to 85 million Dollars in 2018,” says Dave Scott. 32 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 F-35 HELMET BACK ON TRACK The development of the F-35’s advanced helmet is now on track after some major glitches. A parallel development of a traditional helmet has been stopped. By Andreas Krog T he helmet is one of the F -35 aircraft’s major innovations. The images from the six cameras on the outside of the aircraft are merged into one image and allows the pilot to see 360 degrees around the aircraft as well as down through the floor and behind the plane. “More than 100 pilots have flown with the helmet and they have all been very pleased with it. It really is “freaky” to see all around, underneath and behind the plane,” says Lockheed Martin test pilot Billie Flynn to MilitærTeknikk when we visit him in a hangar next to the assembly line in Fort Worth. Billie Flynn is standing in front of a F-35 test aircraft with his helmet in his hand. The Canadian former F-18 and Eurofighter pilot is very kind and open to the group of journalists. But he will not let anyone touch his helmet. It is too valuable for that. No matter how many F-35 planes our countries intend to procure. Excessive heat Later we have the possibility to get a small taste of the helmet’s features when we visit a special F-35 simulator. Seated in the simulator we try a simplified version of the helmet and sense how we can look through the floor and around the landscape, as we fly the F-35 simulator. The helmet is being developed by the sub-contractors Rockwell Collins and Elbit Systems. It has previously posed problems, following a delay of the image if the pilot moved his head too fast, and there has been some vibration and excessive heat from the helmet’s advanced electronics. In 2011 Pentagon identified the helmet design as one of the F-35 program’s major problem areas. Lockheed Martin therefore gave primary subcontractor BAE Systems the task of developing a traditional helmet parallel to the development of the new helmet. The results from the new third generation helmet have convinced the F-35 Joint Program Office that Rockwell Collins and Elbit Systems are on the right track. Therefore the funding for the development of the traditional helmet was stopped in the autumn of last year. Roughly $60 million has been spent for BAE to develop its helmet. Confidence in the helmet’s performance The third generation helmet will be introduced as part of the low-rate initial production lot 7 in 2016. It will come with “improved night vision camera, new liquid-crystal displays (LCD), automated alignment and software improvements,” according to the Joint Program Office. “The government’s decision to proceed exclusively with the principal helmet is indicative of their confidence in the helmet’s performance and the successful resolution of previously identified technical challenges,” said Lorraine Martin, Lockheed’s vice president and general manager of the F-35 program, in a company statement last year. MILITÆRTEKNIKK 1/2014 33 ARCHER NORWAY OUT OF ARCHER The Norwegian Government, on the recommendation of the Norwegian Armed Forces, has decided to terminate the part of the Archer co-operation which concerns the cannons in particular. The Archer cooperation between Norway and Sweden was started in 2007. –T he Norwegian Government has concluded that the artillery system Archer will not be able to fulfil the requirements of the Norwegian Defence within the time frame that is at our disposal, and this is the reason why we are withdrawing from the contract, says Minister of Defence, Ms Ine Marie Eriksen Søreide. Søreide further underscores that the Norwegian Defence sees a need to renew its artillery, following the Army’s change of operational concept towards becomingmore mobile and working faster. There has been, and there still remains, a goal of procuring materiel through multinational co-operation. –There are two main reasons why the Norwegian Defence chose to recommendto the Government a withdrawal from the Archerproject, says Lt. Col. Bent-Ivan Myhre, as the spokesman for the NorwegianDefence Commander-in-Chief. –Firstly, we cannot foresee that Archerwill be able to fulfil the Norwegian Army’s requirements of its new artillery. ISSN 0806–6159 Publisher/Utgiver: Norsk Militærteknisk Forlag Prinsens gate 22, N-0157 OSLO Administration/Administrasjon: Castra AS Org.nr. NO 971 161 531 MVA 34 MILITÆRTEKNIKK 6/2013 Archer trails in Norway. The main components of the system include a fully automated 155 mm/L52 gun howitzer mounted on a modified 6×6 chassis of the Volvo A30D, all-terrain articulated hauler. According to independent analysts, one of the Norwegian army´s requirements that the gun did not fulfil was sufficient on-target precision when fired on automatic. But this has not been confirmed. Photo: FMS Secondly, shipments of Archer systems have been considerably delayed. Myhre declines to go into specifics regarding which technical requirements cannot be met by Archer. This is out of consideration to the supplier. The Norwegian side also empha sises that it is the part of the agreement that concerns the cannons specifically that has now been terminated. Norway will continueits co-operation with Sweden regarding systems such as the artillery localisation radar (ARTHUR), the firing control system (ODIN) and ammunition. With regard to the Norwegian artilleryof the future, Myhre continues to say that a thorough evaluation of different alternativesneeds to be made. For the time being, the current artillery systems can be kept in operation until about 2020. In response, the Swedish FMV (Swedish Defence Materiel Administration) claims that Archer offers equal or better performance vs. competitors at a lower price, and has found the balance it needs between protection and weight. Sweden’s FMV also announces it will pursuethe acquisitionon its own. The FMV goes on to say that the co-operation with Norway has not been in vain. Sweden and Norway have shared the actual development costs for the artillery system, which has saved the Swedish state several hundred millions of kroner. On the other hand, there will be fewer systems among which to spread the operational costs in the future. The first Archer systems have already been supplied to the Swedish Defence, and the FMV is in a position to formally complete the procurement on its own. It has been pointed out from severalsources that Sweden might demand compensation for breach of contract on the part of Norway, but whether this will happenhas yet to be determined. From the Norwegian side, it is held that the Norwegian defence will now initiate a dialogue with its Swedish partners regarding the onward process. Editor-in-Chief/Ansvarlig redaktør: Marketing Director/Markedsansvarlig: M.Sc./Siv.ing. Bjørn Domaas Josefsen Knut Berg E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] Editorial Office/Redaksjon: Prinsens gate 22, N-0157 OSLO Tlf. (+47) 22 41 60 77 Fax. (+47) 22 41 60 11 Denmark; Andreas Krog, E-mail: [email protected] Advertising Office/Annonser: Prinsens gate 22, N-0157 OSLO Tlf. (+47) 22 41 60 41 Fax. (+47) 22 41 60 11 Subscriptions/ Abonnementservice: Tlf. (+47) 22 41 60 77 Fax. (+47) 22 41 60 11 Design/layout: Molvik Grafisk AS Printed by/Trykkeri: PRINFO UNIQUE Larvik Returadresse: MilitærTeknikk, Prinsens gate 22, N-0157 OSLO Norway