Shendell complaint filed by owner at Lighthouse Point

Transcription

The Florida Bar
Inquiry/Complaint Form
P A R T O N E (See Page 1, P A R T O N E - Complainant Information.):
Your Name: Deborah Raney
Organization:
Address: 1440 SW 28th Avenue
City, State, Zip Code: Pompano Beach Florida 33069
Telephone: 954-591-4554
E-mail: [email protected]
ACAP Reference No.:
Have you ever filed a complaint against a member of The Florida Bar: Yes
If yes, how many complaints have you filed? _1
Does this complaint pertain to a matter currently in litigation? Yes L J
PART TWO
•X
No
No I
J
X
(See Page 1, P A R T T W O - Attorney Information.):
Attorney's Name: TAMAR DUFFNER SHENDELL, LARRY SHENDELL
Address: 5240 N FEDERAL HWY, SUITE 201
City, State, Zip Code: LIGHTHOUSE POINT FLORIDA 33064
Telephone: 954-781-3747
P A R T T H R E E (See Page 1, P A R T T H R E E - Facts/Allegations.): The specific thing or things I
am complaining about are: (attach additional sheets as necessary)
The attached letter of May 11, 2015 clearly spells out the matter at hand;
However today May 12, 2015 I received a telephone call at my office at around 1:00pm from Mr. Larry
Shendell, of SHENDELL & ASSOCIATES, P.A. it was not the phone call that prompted this complaint
but his conduct unbecoming of a professional.
He introduced himself as "this is attorney shendell" and I replied that is odd, because I was informed that
attorney Shendell was a female by his secretary.
He replied "Yes, I had a sex change", Laughing and I then replied is this Larry? he stated yes "Larry
Shendell". I knew that Larry was the person that I had been speaking with from the beginning and
sending information to, he did not want to identify himself to me on the phone.
Since this matter is of a sensitive nature to begin with, I was taken back as to his conduct and statement
since I never thought an attorney should be practicing like this. I told Larry that I don't know how he ever
passed the bar but this is not acceptable behavior.
I now understand that his wife is the attorney of record "Tamar Duffner Shendell" and this is the person I
wanted to speak with; however she never returned my calls and never would geton the phone. This is also
why I addressed the letter of May 11, 2015 to her attention. Her Husband Larry Shendell, who I am not
sure is an attorney now was covering up for her.
This kind of practice as I stated in my letter is totally not acceptable. It appears that Shendell, letter of
May 4th 2015 which was totally false and Shendell attempting to take legal action for eviction on a
matter that was addressed constitutes as entrapment.
I was also informed by the association that Tamar Duffner Shendell, was the person who was appointed
to handle all matters pertaining to Orchid Grove association which is why I was trying to get in touch
with her after I did not receive any solution from Larry. As I own a company I also understand that we
put other people in charge of matters; however when an employee cannot fulfill a client needs and they
request myself I then will return the call or email so this is no excuse.
I am asking The Florida Bar to take the necessary disciplinary action on this matter.
Sincerely,
Owner of 223 SW 6 place
Orchid Grove
th
Contact information
below:
President | STAT Industry, Inc, j [email protected]
OFFICE ( 9 5 4 ) 3 6 6 - 1 9 8 5 | FAX ( 9 5 4 ) 8 7 6 - 1 2 1 8
FACEBOOK STAT INDUSTRY INC
| SKYPE: s t a t i n d u s t r y _
| LINKEDIN:
www.linkedin.com/
| A D D R E S S 1 4 4 0 S W 2 8 t h A v e n u e P o m p a n o B e a c h , FL 3 3 0 6 9
For e x c e l l e n t s e r v i c e l o g o n t o www.statindustry.com o r call o u r Business P r e m i e r Line @ 8 6 6 - 9 4 7 - S T A T ( 7 8 2 8 ) .
FAA-AC-O0-56A CERTIFIED SUPPLIER | TAC CERTIFICATE if S291111A | CAGE - 57FA3
| DDTC (Approved M a n u f a c t u r e ' s f o r
Military Contracts) j Boeing Rights Guard Approved Vendor I Approved Contractor US Navy NAVSEA 08 / (NRP) Nuclear
Reactor Program I DOD M e n t o r Protege Program | JCP Certification -License #0059368 | ORCA Registered | CCR/SAM | FAA
DAR/DER o n Staff • Lockheed M a r t i n C-5A - Cj7- O 3 0 •• KC135 approved Vendor | GSA j NASA Space Center MFG Approved |
P A R T F O U R (See Page 1, P A R T F O U R - Witnesses.): The witnesses in support of my
allegations are: [see attached sheet].
P A R T F I V E (See Page 1, P A R T F I V E - Signature.): Under penalties of perjury, I declare that
the foregoing facts are true, correct and complete.
n Y N a m e s i
Signature
Date
/ I I
Deborah Raney
1440 SW 28 Avenue
Pompano Beach Florida 33069
(t) 954-591-4554
Email: [email protected]
th
May 11, 2015
Tamar Duffner Shendell - s e n t regular mail and fax to: 954-781-3748 - 19 pages of attachments
Shendell & Associates, P.A.
5240 N Federal Hwy
Suite 201
Lighthouse Point, Florida 33064
Re: Orchid Grove Property, 223 SW 6
th
Place, Pompano Beach Florida 33069
Ms. Shendell,
I made several telephone calls to your office this morning in order to have a conversation with
you to no avail. I just return f r o m travels and prior to leaving Friday I received a disturbing
letter f r o m you as to allegations that are incorrect and false.
I have been in contact with your office prior to April 14 2015 and have spoken on numerous
occasions with Larry as to my HOA payments. I informed Larry and sent him copies of my
payments made to date, t have discussed in great detail as t o the process that I make my
payments monthly and gave him the association payment method website in order for him to
further look into the matter.
Larry told me he would get back to me, to my surprise I then now receive a letter dated May 4,
2015 f r o m your office that you are going to go for eviction and that I have disregarded your
previous request.
This is a false statement; it is also entrapment and harassment. I have made all payments
according to the HOA Management web site and balances that are due. Property Keepers was
hired by the Orchid Grove association to collect funding for the association, I feel that I am
being targeted, harass and being entrapped on false statements in order to gain possession of
my property.
Below is Property Keepers website that is posted on my account:
As you can see highlighted in RED "BALANCE DUE" and the amount the association
accountability claims I owe to date. This is a printout of today May 11, 2015 and a copy of an
email that I sent to Brett.
Brett,
I just logged into your system and as you can see this is what your system is stating that I owe: scroll
down to the highlighted RED mark. It states:
Balance Due:
Balance Due
$54.12
(Balance as of Mon Dec 08 10:56:30 PM PST. This balance is determined by
your property manager. If it is not updated or you believe it is incorrect, please
contact your property manager. )
Below that when you make a payment you put the amount that is due to make the
payment: etc...
W E L C O M E B A C K , DEBORAH!
Account Information
Deborah Raney
Unit: 223 SW 6th Place
Orchid Grove Master Association
5320 NE 15th Avenue
Fort Lauderdale. F l . 33334
(954)616-6999
Payment Method
ending, in ... 9089
Add Payment Method
#
New Card Account
T o p of Form
Card Number
Card Number
Month Year
rtvpiration Dale
First Name
Last Name
Bottom of Form
Billing Address
223 SW 6th Place
Pompano Beach FL 33060
edil
Update Billing Address
T o p of Form
Street
City
Florida
Zip
OK
Bottom of Form
cancel S A V E
New Bank Account
T o p of F o r m
Name on Account
05/11/2015
Pay to the
Order of
Orchid drove Master Association
9 Digit Routing Number
Account Number
Confirm Account Number
Bottom of F o r m
cancel S A V E
Setup AutoPay
Payment Summary
Top of Form
Balance Due
$54.12
(Balance as of Mon Dec OS 10:56:30 PM PST. This balance is determined by your property manager. If it is not updated or you believe it is incorrect, please contact your
property manager.)
Dues
$0.00
Electronic Payment Service Fee
Total Payment A m o u n t
Payment Date
Payments must be completed by Text or Email to comply with card regulations
05/11/2015
Email
By Email
You will receive an email confirmation to complete your payment in one
C lick
999() 999 - 9999
By Text
You will receive a text message for confirmation. Reply to the message to
complete your payment.
Rent By Text ™
Option
I want to receive a monthly text message reminder to pay rent
CONTINUE
From: Brett Barnes f mailto:[email protected]
Sent: Monday, May 11, 2015 1:56 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Orchid Grove
Attached is a copy of your ledger.
Thanks,
Brett Barnes
President
Property Keepers Management, LLC.
1350 NE 56th Street
Suite 180
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33334
http://www.Property-Keepers.com
[email protected]
Phone: 954-586-5111
Fax: 954-586-5113
In closing, I find that now I have to take all legal actions to protect my property and interest due
to Property Keepers continue false allegation and entrapment on my property. Ms. Schendell
you and your office also has no right to send me this type of letter. I did send to your office all
the documentation without any decent reply; whereby I will also be issuing a complaint with
the Florida Bar association as to the harassment.
Deborah Raney
Owner of 223 SW 6
th
Place, Pompano Beach
cc: Property Keepers, 1350 NE 56 Street, Suite 180, Fort Lauderdale Florida 33334 - 954-586-5111-Bret Barnes
cc: Mr. Anthony Garano, President of Orchid Grove Association - Hand Delivered
1
S H E N D E L L & ASSOCIATES, P.A.
5340 N Federal Highway * Suite 201« Lighthouse Point, F L 33064 • Phone 954-781-3747 » Fax 954-781-3748 • [email protected]
April 2, 2015
Via Regular and Certified Mail
Return Receipt Requested
70132630000167223399
Current Tenant/Occupant
223 SW 6 Place
Pompano Beach, Florida 33060
th
RE:
PAYMENT OF RENT DIRECTLY TO ASSOCIATION
223 SW 6 Place, Pompano Beach, Florida 33060
th
Dear Tenant/Current Occupant:
This firm represents Orchid Grove Association, Inc. ("Association"), the homeowners association
governing the above referenced property. Pursuant to section 720.3085(8), Florida Statutes, we demand
that you make your rent payments directly to the homeowners' association and continue doing so until the
association notifies you otherwise.
Payment due to the homeowners' association may be in the same form as you paid your landlord and must
be sent by United States mail or hand delivery to 5340 N. Federal Highway, Suite 201, Lighthouse Point,
Florida 33064, payable to Shendell & Associates, P.A.
Your obligation to pay your rent to the association begins immediately, unless you have already paid rent to
your landlord for the current period before receiving this notice. In that case, you must provide the
association written proof of your payment within 14 days after receiving this notice and your obligation to
pay rent to the association would then begin with the next rental period.
Pursuant to section 720.3085(8), Florida Statutes, your payment of rent to the association gives you
complete immunity from any claim for the rent by your landlord.
Should you have any questions, piease contact the undersigned.
cooperation.
Very truly yours,
Thank you for your anticipated
Tamar Du finer Shendell
For the Firm
cc:
Deborah Raney (Via Regular and Certified Mail, 70132630000167223405)
2328 Vintage Circle
SHENDELL & ASSOCIATES, P.A,
5340 N Federal Highway • Suite 201 • Lighthouse Point, F L 330(54 • Phone (954)781-3747 • Fax (954)781-3748 • [email protected]
May 4, 2015
70140150000016849019
223 SW 6 Place
th
RE:
223 SW 6 Place, Pompano Beach, Florida 33060
th
As you are aware from my previous correspondence to you, this firm represents Orchid Grove
Association, Inc. ("Association"). In my previous letter to you, I demanded that you forward future
rent payments to the Association c/o Shendell & Associates, P.A. pursuant to Florida Statutes, Section
720.3085(8) which authorizes the Association to collect the rent from you in the event that the unit
owner becomes delinquent in payment of any monetary obligation to the Association. Unfortunately,
you have failed to pay the rent payments to the Association.
This shall serve as a final demand that you forward your rent payments to Association within five (5)
days of the date of this letter. Please make your payments payable to the Shendell & Associates, P.A.
Trust Account and deliver them to the undersigned at the address noted on the letterhead. Please be
advised that should you fail to pay the rent as directed herein, the Association will proceed with further
legal action for eviction.
There will be no further warnings or requests. Should you have any questions, please contact the
undersigned. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation.
Tamar Duffner Shendell
For the Firm
cc:
2328 Vintage Circle
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Deborah R <deborah,[email protected]>
Tuesday, April 14, 2015 10:36 AM
'Larry Shendell'
RE: Orchid
Larry I have no why of making these figures up.
When you log into rent payment.com
as you can see paymnt for May 1st i f as follows.. I don't make up these payments the computer generates it.
W E L C O M E BACK, DEBORAH!
Account Information
Deborah Raney
5320 NE 15th Avenue
(954) 616-6999
Payment Method
Add Payment Method
1
New Card Account
Card Number
T o p of F o r m
Card Number
Expiration Date
First Name
Last Name
B o t t o m of F o r m
Billing Address
223 SW 6th Place
T o p of F o r m
Street
City
OK
Bottom of Form
SAVE
New Bank Account
2
Top of Form
Name on Account
04/14/2015
Pay to the
Order of
Account Number
Bottom of Form
SAVE
Payment Summary
T o p of Form
Balance Due
$54.12
(Balance as of Mon Dec 08 10:56:30 PMPST. This balance is determined by your property manager. If it is not updated or you believe it is incorrect, please
contact your property manager.)
Dues
$0.00
Total Payment Amount
Payment Date
04/14/2015
By Email
• Email
You will receive an email confirmation to complete your payment in one click.
By Text
999() 999 - 9999
You will receive a text message for confirmation. Reply to the message to complete
your payment.
RentByText™
Option
CONTINUE
Bottom of Form
From: Larry Shendell [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, April 14, 2015 10:27 AM
To: Deborah Raney
Subject: Re: Orchid
The monthly maintenance that you have been paying is not the correct amount. Please check your records
tx
Larry Shendell, Esq.
5340 North Federal Highway
Suite 201
Lighthouse Point, FL 33064
Phone: (954)781-3747
Fax: (954)781-3748
The following statement is being provided as required by federal law: We have been retained by the Association
to collect a debt owed to the Association and any information will be used for that purpose.
The contents of this e-mail message and any attachments are intended solely for the addressee(s) named in this
message. This communication is confidential and may be subject to applicable lawyer-client and/or work
product privileges. I f you are not the intended recipient of this message, or i f this message has been addressed to
you in error, please immediately alert the sender by reply e-mail and then delete this message and its
attachments. Do not deliver, distribute or copy this message and/or any attachments and i f you are not the
intended recipient, do not disclose the contents or take any action in reliance upon the information contained in
this communication or any attachments.
4
On Tue, Apr 14, 2015 at 10:05 A M , Deborah R <
> wrote:
Good morning Larry,
Because I overpaid in November the payments that follow are the payments that the computer genereated
monthly, which I paid up to date. A l l my payments are up to date and April 2014 has also been paid and
attached.
D. Raney
=_
"£i
OFFICE
|FAX
| S K Y P E : statindustry_ | L I N K E D I N :
www.linkedin.com/
F A C E B O O K STAT INDUSTRY INC | A D D R E S S 1440 SW 28th Avenue Pompano Beach, FL 33069
For excellent service log on to www.statindustry.com or call our Business Premier L i n e @ 866-947-STAT(7828).
FAA-AC-00-56A CERTIFIED SUPPLIER | TAG CERTIFICATE # S291111A | CAGE - 57FA3 | DDTC (Approved Manufecturers for Military
Contracts) | Boeing Rights Guard Approved Vendor j Approved Contractor US Navy NA.VSEA 08 / (NRP) Nuclear Reactor Program | DOD
Mentor Protege Program | .TCP Certification -License #0059368 | ORCA Registered | CCR/SAM | F A A DAR/DER on Staff j Lockheed Martin C5A - C I 7 - COO - KC135 approved Vendor | GSA \ NASA Space Center MFG Approved |
5
From: Larry Shendell [mailto:
Sent: Tuesday, April 07, 2015 3:38 PM
To:
Subject: Orchid
]
Pis call me
pis check your stubs
From 2013
Suite 201
Phone:
Fax:
The following statement is being provided as required by federal law: We have been retained by the
Association to collect a debt owed to the Association and any information will be used for that purpose.
product privileges. I f you are not the intended recipient of this message, or i f this message has been addressed
to you in error, please immediately alert the sender by reply e-mail and then delete this message and its
6
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
Monday, April 20, 2015 5:09 AM
[email protected]
Important RentPayment Account information
[ Orchid Grove Master Association ]
Important RentPayment Account Information
Deborah,
The credit card you have on file with us is about to expire. In order to keep your account
current, please login and update your card information or contact our customer service
team at 1-866-289-5977. You can login at:
https://www.rentpayment.com/pay/login.html.
Thank you for using RentPayment,
The RentPayment Customer Service Team
At RentPayment,
we take pride in making collection of payments fast, easy and secure.
This email was automatically generated by Orchid Grove Master Association.
Please do not reply to this email directly.
Please contact Orchid Grove Master Association at (954) 616-6999 or email
[email protected] if you have any questions.
PAYMENT HISTORY
Reference
May 11,. 2015
11:11:07 AM PDT
May 1, 2015
07:08:26 AM PDT
Apr 3, 2015
07:34:51 AM PDT
2788651540
2763144240
1771903036
;
T
y
p
Initiated
e
Deborah;
Raney
******
0280
s t a
,
u s
PROCESSING
Does
$1,194.08
$9.35
VISA
******
n
CLEARED
0280
Dues
$54.12 \
$9.95 :
Deborah
Raney
5142
CLEARED
Jan 20, 2015
05:38:28 AM PST
2646820240
1704911636
VISA
Deborah
Raney
0280
Nov 1, 2014
07:30:54 AM PDT
Aug 10, 2014
04:35:57 PM PDT
1638700236
1579555036
$54.12 ••
$9,95
Dues
$54.12 \
$9.95 j
Rebeck
5142
Deborah
Raney
CLEARED
Dues
2510964240
4.07
CLEARED
Dec 17, 2014
04:52:02 AM PST
$64.07
Raney
Dues
Mar 3, 2015
03:31:03 AM PST
; $1,204 03
Deborah
Raney
9453
CLEARED
$64.07
$54.12
$9.95 i
$64.07
Dues
$54.12
$9.95
Deborah
Raney
5142
CLEARED
$1,009.95
Dues
$1,000.00
$9.95
Rebeck
Deborah
Raney
CLEARED
$15.77
Dues
$5.82
$9.95
$679.11
https://vv\vw.reiitpayincntxom/pay/()/invoiccs.html?cd 734411858982146985
5/11/2015
Jul 22, 2014
06:09:44 AM PDT
May 11, 2013
09:19:27 AM PDT
Apr 2, 2013
06:40:41 AM PDT
Mar 4, 2013
10:42:46 AM PST
Feb 1, 2013
06:41:49 AM PST
15586914- : /?check
36
1068634740
•
Deborah
Raney
Dues
$669.16
$9.95
'VISA
Raney
0280
$276.00
$9.85
CLEARED
$285.95
Dues
$276.00
$9.95
988894340
Deborah
Raney
CLEARED
$285.95
Dues
$276.00
$9.95
S^SSl
Deborah
Raney
CLEARED
Dues
https://ww.rentpayment.com/pay/0/invoices.htm
$285,95
Dues
Deborah
Raney
******
5142
CLEARED
1020932440
709966136
:
$285.95
$276. Op
$9.9,5
5/11/2015
Deborah R
Deborah R <[email protected]>
Friday, May 01, 2015 10:09 AM
[email protected]
From:
Sent:
To:
ESPAYMEN
P O W E R E D 8Y Y A P S T O N E
THANK Y O U FOR Y O U R PAYMENT
Your Payment was. Success
A payment receipt will be sent to [email protected]
Payment
Summary
5320 NE 15th Avenue
Deborah Raney
Unit/Address - 223 SW 6th Place
Payment Method
VJ5A nding in ... 0280
e
$54.12
Dues
$9.95
$64.07
Fri May 01, 2015 07:08 A M PDT
Payment Date
56014891-47
Reference Number
* The service fee is non-refundable.
* All payments are subject to the terms of your current lease agreement.
View Payment History
Print
1
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
customerservice@duespayment. com
Friday, April 03, 2015 10:36 AM
[email protected]
Payment Receipt - Reference #
55136243-47
Payment Receipt - Reference #55136243-47
This payment was SUCCESSFULLY P R O C E S S E D !
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Apr 03, 2015, 07: 34 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
SUBMITTED*
$54.12
Dues:
Sub Total:
$54.12
$9.95
eCheck Service Fee:
$64.07
Total:
Account:
COMMERCE BANK ... 5142
Reference # :
55136243-47
* Please note, correctly submitted eCheck/ACH payments take
three to five business days to process and successfully clear.
Thank you for using DuesPayment!
1
Deborah R
[email protected]
[email protected]
From:
Sent:
To:
Msg(l/2) RentPayment Receipt
Date:04/03/15 Property: Orchid Grove
Master Association Name:Deborah Raney
Amt:$54.12 Amt:$9.95 TOTAL:$64.07
Acct #:5142 Ref
0?
-Mnhiit-
1W*fMS«ge<t«K « * * to )«hi iff a "N**fca*«ow phone.
1
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
Tuesday, March 03, 2015 6:32 AM
[email protected]
54047860-47
This payment was SUCCESSFULLY PROCESSED!
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Mar 03, 2015, 03:31 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
A
d
d
.
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
PAID
$54.12
Dues:
Sub Total:
$54.12
$9.95
Visa Service Fee:
Total:
$64.07
Account:
Visa ending in ....0280
Reference # :
54047860-47
Please contact Orchid Grove Master Association at (954) 616-6999 if you have any
questions
1
PAYMEN'
Pa y m e r: i S u rn rn a ry
5320 NE 15th Avenue
Deborah Raney
VISA ending
Payment Method
$54.12
Dues
Electronic Payment Service Fe
S9.S5
$64.07
! oca! Payment Amount
Payment Date
Tue Mar 03, 2 0 t 5 03:31 AM PST
54047860-47
Reference Number
The service fee is non-refundable.
Ail payments ore subject to the terms of your current lease agreement.
https ://w w w . e r e n t p a y e r . c o m
in ... 0280
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
Tuesday, January 20, 2015 8:39 AM
[email protected]
52591515-47
This payment was SUCCESSFULLY P R O C E S S E D !
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Jan 20, 2015, 05:38 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
PAID
$54.12
Dues:
Sub Total:
$54.12
$9.95
eCheck Service Fee:
$64.07
Total:
Account:
Reference # :
52591515-47
questions
1
1 hank you tor you payment | ueooran Kaney icv, uuesraymeni j
a
?//y^£jns
rage i ui i
* 'Ofs t > j » f i p * ; f T i t s :
Orchid Grave Master Association
5 3 2 0 N E 15th A v e n u e
Unit/Address - 223 S W 6th Place
Deborah Raney
e n d i n g in ... 9 4 5 3
Payment Method
354.12
Dues
B e c t r o n i c Payment Service Fee
$9.95
$64.07'
Wed' D e c 17. 2 3 1 4 04:52 A M P S T
Payment Date
ihtj s e r v i c e fee is r
https://www.erentpayer.eom/pay/m
12/17/2014
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
Saturday, November 01, 2014 10:32 AM
[email protected]
50216051-47
Flag Status:
Flagged
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Nov 01, 2014, 07:30 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
PAID
$1,000.00
Dues:
Sub Total:
$1,000.00
$9.95
eCheck Service Fee:
Total:
$1,009.95
Account:
Reference #:
50216051-47
questions
JH KyocERa
r
Send Result Report
M F P
CS 500ci
Firmware Version
Job N o . :
05/11/2015 15:13
[ZH7_1000.024.0013 [2H7_1100.002.003] [2H7_7000.013.006]
2H7 2F00.E15.002 2014.07.30
172876
Total
Time:
0°03'50"
Page:
025
Complete
Document:
doc20150511150903
No.
D a t e and Time
001
05/11/15 15:09 9 5 4 7 8 1 3 7 4 8
Times
Destination
Type
0°03'50" FAX
1
Result
Resolution/ECM
OK
200x100 Normal/On
[ QEK9800391 ]
£g i<y DCERa
Send Result Report
M F P
Firmware Version
Job No.:
05/11/2015 15:22
[2H7 1000.024.001] [2H7J100.002.003] [2H7_7000.013.006]
2H7 2F00.E15.002 2014.07.30
Total
172877
Time:
0°05'02"
Page:
025
Complete
Document:
doc20150511151000
No.
Date and Time
001
05/11/15 15:14 9 5 4 5 8 6 5 1 1 3
Destination
T i mes
Type
0°05'02" FAX
i
Result
Resolution/ECM
OK
200x100 Normal/On
[ QEK9800391 ]
THE FLORIDA BAR
JOHN F. HARKNESS, JR.
651 EAST JEFFERSON STREET
TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32399-2300
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
(850) 561-5600
WWW.FLABAR.ORG
June 3, 2015
Ms. Deborah Raney
1440 S.W. 28th Avenue
Pompano Beach, FL 33069
Re:
Mr. Lawrence Alan Shendell; RFA No.: 15-19103
Dear Ms. Raney:
Your inquiry concerning the above-referenced attorney has been referred to me for my review.
While I understand that you are upset at the tone and language that the lawyer used when he was
communicating with you and your family, I must conclude that it was not unethical.
After careful consideration, I conclude that the matters referenced in your inquiry do not
constitute violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, and accordingly, your inquiry does
not fall within the purview of the grievance system framework. Consequently, I have closed our
record in this matter. Please be advised that my action does not preclude you from consulting
with private counsel, nor does it preclude you from exercising any legal remedy which may be
available to you.
Pursuant to the Bar’s records retention schedule, the computer record and file will be disposed of
one year from the date of closing.
Sincerely,
Theodore P. Littlewood Jr., Bar Counsel
Attorney Consumer Assistance Program
ACAP Hotline 866-352-0707
cc:
Mr. Lawrence Alan Shendell
RECEIVED
M 1. fj 2015
The Florida Bar-ACAP
Tallahassee, Florida
6/11/2015
1440 SW 28 Avenue
in
Mr. Theodore P. Littlewood Jr.
651 East Jefferson Street
954-591-4554
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2300
[email protected]
RFA No.: 15-19103 - Mr. Lawrence Alan Shendell
Enclosure
Good day Mr. Shendell,
I am in receipt of your letter of June 3 , 2015, as to my
rd
complaint regarding the unethical Conduct of Mr. Shendell.
I differ
with
your opinion as to the grievance system
framework. Attached you will find additional information that
this representative has placed a bogus lien on my property.
Sincerely,
INSTR # 112286375, OR BK 50777 PG 277, Page 1 o f 1, Recorded 05/14/2014 a t
11:19 AM, Broward County Commission, Deputy C l e r k 3110
3
Prepared by:
Steven B. Katz
Kubicki Draper, P.A.
One East Broward Boulevard
Suite 1600
File # 0076253
CLAIM OF LIEN FOR MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENTS
BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Steven B. Katz, who being duly
sworn, deposes and says that he is the Attorney-in-Fact for Orchid Grove Association, Inc., the
Lienor herein, whose post office address is c/o Property Keepers MGMT, LLC. 159 SW 6*
street, Pompano Bch., FL 33060, and that pursuant to the Section of §720.3085(5) of the
Florida Statute as well as the Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions for Orchid Grove
Association, Inc., said Association is owed the following amount for the following assessment(s):
1
In accordance with the Declaratory then
Pas; C >ue N lainteriarct Assessments
Feeîirau&d 07/3^20^-S3j72D>4
d|atM 02032014
Amount Due....$ 4,341.88
This amount does not include interest at the rate as set forth in the Declaration of Covenants
and Restrictions from the due dates. This Claim of Lien shall also secure all unpaid
assessments, interest, costs, and attorneys fees which are due and which may accrue
subsequent to the recording of this Claim of Lien and prior to entry of a final judgment of
foreclosure.
The Lienor claims this lien on the following described property in Broward County, Florida:
Lot 134, Cypress Grove, according to the map or plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 175, Page(s) 137
through 150, inclusive, of the Public Records of Broward County, Florida.
Current owner of record is Deborah Raney
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT
Orchid Grove Association, Inc.
By:
SteveirB. Katz, Esq.
One East Broward Blvd.
Suite 1600
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTRY OF BROWARD
)
)
The foregoing Claim of Lien was acknowledged before me this 14th day of May, 2014 by Steven
B. Katz, asAAgent for the Association, who is personally known to me.
4-
Notary Public, State of Florida
My commission expires:
Christine SchreibOT
Name of Notary Public
CHrWnNEA.aCNREBER
MY COMMISSION I IT 011077
EXPIRES: Apr* 22,2017
BonMTtnfWlvMklMwHMJ
THE FLORIDA BAR
TALLAHASSEE, FL 32399-2300
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
850/561-5600
WWW.FLORIDABAR.ORG
August 17, 2015
Ms. Deborah Raney
Re:
Mr. Lawrence Alan Shendell; RFA# 15-19103
Dear Ms. Raney:
Pursuant to your request for review I have reviewed the file in my capacity as Director of ACAP
and conclude that the decision to close the file was appropriate. Please be advised that The
Florida Bar is without jurisdiction to determine whether the lien filed against the subject property
is valid. Furthermore, Mr. Shendell is not the attorney who filed the lien, so any inquiry
concerning the lien is not appropriately maintained against him.
I have reviewed the information you provided concerning your exchange with Mr. Shendell and
determined there is insufficient evidence that Mr. Shendell has violated the Rules Regulating
The Florida Bar warranting the imposition of discipline. If you would like to pursue a
determination of whether his communication may have been unprofessional, the contact for the
Local Professionalism Panel in the 17th Judicial Circuit is Kenneth Joyce,
[email protected], www.17th.Flcourts.org. The Local Professionalism Panel was
established by Order of the Supreme Court of Florida dated June 6, 2013, which mandated that
each circuit institute a Local Professionalism Panel.
Sincerely,
Shanell M. Schuyler, Director of Intake
cc:
Ms. Deborah Raney
5340 N Federal Hwy Ste 201
Lighthouse Point, FL 33064-7058
The Florida Bar
Inquiry/Complaint Form
MAY 18 '2015 f
PART ONE (See Page 1, PART ONE - Complainant Information.):
Your Name: Deborah Raney
Organization:
Address: 1440 SW 28th Avenue
City, State, Zip Code: Pompano Beach Florida 33069
Telephone: 954-591-4554
E-mail: [email protected]
ACAP Reference No.:
Have you ever filed a complaint against a member of The Florida Bar: Yes
If yes, how many complaints have youfiled?J
Does this complaint pertain to a matter currently in litigation? Yes •
'X
No
No
CHI
fx]
PART TWO (See Page 1, PART TWO - Attorney Information.):
Attorney's Name: TAMAR DUFFNER SHENDELL, LARRY SHENDELL
Address: 5240 N FEDERAL HWY, SUITE 201
City, State, Zip Code: LIGHTHOUSE POINT FLORIDA 33064
Telephone: 954-781-3747
PART T H R E E (See Page 1, PART T H R E E - Facts/Allegations.): The specific thing or things I
am complaining about are: (attach additional sheets as necessary)
The attached letter of May 11, 2015 clearly spells out the matter at hand;
However today May 12, 2015 I received a telephone call at my office at around 1:00pm from Mr. Larry
Shendell, of SHENDELL & ASSOCIATES, P.A. it was not the phone call that prompted this complaint
but his conduct unbecoming of a professional.
He introduced himself as "this is attorney shendell" and I replied that is odd, because I was informed that
attorney Shendell was a female by his secretary.
He replied "Yes, I had a sex change", Laughing and I then replied is this Larry? he stated yes "Larry
Shendell". I knew that Larry was the person that I had been speaking with from the beginning and
sending information to, he did not want to identify himself to me on the phone.
Since this matter is of a sensitive nature to begin with, I was taken back as to his conduct and statement
since I never thought an attorney should be practicing like this. I told Larry that I don't know how he ever
passed the bar but this is not acceptable behavior.
I now understand that his wife is the attorney of record "Tamar Duffher Shendell" and this is the person I
wanted to speak with; however she never returned my calls and never would geton the phone. This is also
why I addressed the letter of May 11, 2015 to her attention. Her Husband Larry Shendell, who I am not
sure is an attorney now was covering up for her.
This kind of practice as I stated in my letter is totally not acceptable. It appears that Shendell, letter of
May 4th 2015 which was totally false and Shendell attempting to take legal action for eviction on a
matter that was addressed constitutes as entrapment.
I was also informed by the association that Tamar Duffner Shendell, was the person who was appointed
to handle all matters pertaining to Orchid Grove association which is why I was trying to get in touch
with her after I did not receive any solution from Larry. As I own a company I also understand that we
put other people in charge of matters; however when an employee cannot fulfill a client needs and they
request myself I then will return the call or email so this is no excuse.
I am asking The Florida Bar to take the necessary disciplinary action on this matter.
Sincerely,
Owner of 223 SW 6 place
Orchid Grove
Contact information below:
President | STAT Industry, Inc. | [email protected]
OFFICE (954) 366-1985 | FAX (954) 876-1218 | SKYPE: statindustry_ | LINKEDIN: www.linkedin.com/
FACEB00K STAT INDUSTRY INC | ADDRESS 1440 SW 28th Avenue Pompano Beach, FL 33069
For excellent service log on to www.statindustrv.com or call our Business Premier Line @ 866-947-STAT(7828).
FAA-AC-00-56A CERTIFIED SUPPLIER | TAC CERTIFICATE #S291111A | CAGE-57FA3 | DDTC (Approved Manufacturers for
Military Contracts) | Boeing Rights Guard Approved Vendor | Approved Contractor US Navy NAVSEA 08 / (NRP) Nuclear
Reactor Program | DOD Mentor Protege Program | JCP Certification -License #0059368 | ORCA Registered | CCR/SAM | FAA
DAR/DER on Staff | Lockheed Martin C-5A - C17 - C130 - KC135 approved Vendor | GSA | NASA Space Center MFG Approved |
Hie e-mail message and anv attachment m i H * e-mail messae- may contain privileged and confidential information intended only f o r the use o f (he
rdo ideal or . m i l } named a e w e If" the icadei o f lbK me'-saae is i-.oi die intended r . r : p i c t s . v«u ate nerebs mniili.il tbat any diVicminalioi). distribul-on. oi
cope ojdliis comma acado" ::: -iriedy piolnbiied. l f j o u laaene die conimaincapon in srroi. please hmiiediaiaiv notify the sender bv return e-mail and
dclek: this, inceaiye I'liank sou S I A i industry inc.
PART FOUR (See Page 1, PART FOUR - Witnesses.): The witnesses in support of my
allegations are: [see attached sheet].
PART F I V E (See Page 1, PART F I V E - Signature.): Under penalties of perjury, I declare that
the foregoing facts are true, correct and complete.
Sigi
Deborah Raney
1440 SW 2 8 Avenue
(t) 954-591-4554
Email: [email protected]
th
May 11, 2015
Tamar Duffner Shendell - sent regular mail and fax to: 954-781-3748
Shendell & Associates, P.A.
5240 N Federal Hwy
Suite 201
19 pa<^ of attachments
Re: Orchid Grove Property, 223 SW 6
t h
Place, Pompano Beach Florida 33069
Ms. Shendell,
I made several telephone calls t o your office this morning in order t o have a conversation with
you to no avail. I just return f r o m travels and prior t o leaving Friday I received a disturbing
letter f r o m you as t o allegations that are incorrect and false.
I have been in contact with your office prior t o April 14 2015 and have spoken on numerous
occasions w i t h Larry as t o my HOA payments. I informed Larry and sent him copies of my
payments made t o date. I have discussed in great detail as t o the process that f make my
payments monthly and gave him the association payment method website in order f o r him t o
further look into the matter.
Larry told me he would get back to me, t o my surprise I then now receive a letter dated May 4,
2015 f r o m your office that you are going t o go f o r eviction and that I have disregarded your
previous request.
This is a false statement; it is also entrapment and harassment. I have made all payments
according t o the HOA Management web site and balances that are due. Property Keepers was
hired by the Orchid Grove association to collect funding f o r the association, I feel that I am
being targeted, harass and being entrapped on false statements in order t o gain possession of
my property.
Below is Property Keepers website t h a t is posted on my account:
As you can see highlighted in RED "BALANCE DUE" and the amount the association
accountability claims I owe to date. This is a printout of today May 1 1 , 2015 and a copy of an
email that I sent t o Brett.
Brett,
I just logged into your system and as you can see this is what your system is stating that I owe: scroll
down to the highlighted RED mark. It states:
Balance Due:
Balance Due
$54.12
Below that when you make a payment you put the amount that is due to make the
payment: etc...
DUESPAYMENT
P O W I S E O BY Y A P S T O N E
WELCOME BACK. DEBORAH!
Account Information
Deborah Raney
5320 NF 15th Avenue
Fort Lauderdale, Fl . 33334
(954)616-6999
Payment Method
ending in ...9089
Add Payment Method
New Card Account
Card Number
Top of Form
Card Number
Month Year
Expiration Date
First Name
Last Name
Bottom of Form
Billing Address
223 SW 6th Place
edit
Top of Form
Street
City
Florida
Zip
OK
Bottom of Form
cancel SAVE
New Bank Account
Top of Form
Name on Account
05/11/2015
Pay 10 the
Order or
Orchid (irove Master Association
Account Number
Bottom of Form
SAVE
|
G O
MOBILE
W I T H
ANPP0»D C0M«N6 SOON
Setup AutoPav
Payment Summary
Top of Form
Balance Due
$54.12
determined by your property manager, tf it is not updated or you believe it it incorrect, please contact your
(Balance as a/Man Dec St 10:56:39 PM PST. Tkit balance &
property manager.)
Dues
$0.00
Payment Date
05/11/2015
By Email
b
m
a
u
You will receive an email confirmation to complete your payment in one
click.
By Text
9 9 9 ( ) 9 9 9 -9999
You will receive a text message for confirmation. Reply to the message to
complete your payment.
RenlByTexl™ Option
1 want to receive a monthly text message reminder to pay rent
CONTINUE
From: Brett Barnes f mailto:brettg>propertv-keeDers.coml
Sent: Monday, May 11, 2015 1:56 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Orchid Grove
Attached is a copy of your ledger.
Thanks,
Brett Barnes
President
Property Keepers Management, LLC.
1350 NE 56th Street
Suite 180
http://www.Propertv-Keepers.com
brett(S)prope rtv-keepers.com
Phone: 954-586-5111
Fax: 954-586-5113
In closing, I find that now I have to take all legal actions to protect my property and interest due
to Property Keepers continue false allegation and entrapment on rimy property. Ms. Scher»dell
you and your office also has no right t o send me this type of letter. I did send to your office all
the documentation without any decent reply; whereby I will also be issuing a complaint w i t h
the Florida Bar association as t o the harassment.
/
Sincerely,
Deborah Raney
Owner of 223 SW 6
th
Place, Pompano Beach
cc: Property Keepers, 1350 NE 56 Street, Suite 180, Fort Lauderdale Florida 33334 - 954-586-5111-Bret Barnestel^tft-cc: Mr. Anthony Garano, President of Orchid Grove Association - Hand Delivered
\r*"»*w&
th
n
5340 N Federal Highway • Suite 201 • Lighthouse Point, F L 33064 • Phone 954-781-3747 • Fax 954-781-3748 • [email protected]
April 2, 2015
70132630000167223399
223 SW 6 Place
th
RE:
^SWtfînace;^
This firm represents Orchid Grove Association, Inc. ("Association"), the homeowners association
governing the above referenced property. Pursuant to section 720.3085(8), Florida Statutes, we demand
that you make your rent payments directly to the homeowners' association and continue doing so until the.
associafton notifies you otherwise.
Payment due to the homeowners' association may be in the same form as you paid your landlord and must
be sent by United States mail or hand delivery to 5340 N. Federal Highway, Suite 201, Lighthouse Point,
Florida 33064, payable to Shendell & Associates, P.A.
Your obligation to pay your rent to the association begins immediately, unless you have already paid rent to
your landlord for the current period before receiving this notice. In that case, you must provide the
association written proof of your payment within 14 days after receiving this notice and your obligation to
pay rent to the association would then begin with the next rental period.
Pursuant to section 720.3085(8), Florida Statutes, your payment of rent to the association gives you
complete immunity from any claim for the rent by your landlord.
Should you have any questions, please contact the undersigned.
cooperation.
Very truly yours,
Thank you for your anticipated
Tamar Dufmer Shendell
For the Firm
cc:
2328 Vintage Circle
5340 N Federal Highway • Suite 201 • Lighthouse Point, F L 33064 • Phone (954)781-3747 • Fax (954)781-3748 • [email protected]
' May 4,2015
70140150000016849019
223 SW 6 Place
th
RE:
223 SW 6* Place, Pompano Beach, Florida 33060
Dear Tehaht/Currerit Occupant:
As you are aware from my previous correspondence to you, this firm represents Orchid Grove
Association, Inc. ("Association"). In my previous letter to you, I demanded that you forward future
rent payments to the Association c/o Shendell & Associates, P.A. pursuant to Florida Statutes, Section
720.3085(8) which authorizes the Association to collect the rent from you in the event that the unit
owner becomes delinquent in payment of any monetary obligation to the Association. Unfortunately,
you have failed to pay the rent payments to the Association.
This shall serve as a final demand that you forward your rent payments to Association within five (5)
days of the date of this letter. Please make your payments payable to the Shendell & Associates, P.A.
Trust Account and deliver them to the undersigned at the address noted on the letterhead. Please be
advised that should you fail to pay the rent as directed herein, the Association will proceed with further
legal action for eviction.
There will be no further warnings or requests. Should you have any questions, please contact the
undersigned. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation.
Tamar Duffner Shendell
For the Firm
cc:
2328 Vintage Circle
Deborah R
Tuesday, April 14,20161036 AM
t a r r y Shendeff
RE: Orchid
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Larry I have no why e f making thesefiguresup.
When you log into rent payment.com
as you can see paymnt for May 1st i f as follows.. I don't make up these payments the computer generates it.
^_
Pay me m i
P O W I R C P BY Y A f STOWH
EL.COME BACK . DEBORAH
Account Information
Deborah Raney
5320 NE 15th Avenue
(954) 616-6999
Payment Method
Select
Account
Add Payment Method
1
New Card Account
Card Number
Top of Form
Card Number
Expiration Date
JEirsLName
Last Name
Bottom of Form
Billing Address
223 SW 6th Place
Top of Form
Street
City
Zip
OK
Bottom of Form
SAVE
New Bank Account
2
Top of Form
Name on Account
04/14/2015
Pay to the
Order of
Account Number
Bottom of Form
SAVE
Payment Summary
Top of Form
Balance Due
$54.12
S Balance asofMmDecOB 10:56:30 PM PST. This balance is determined by your property manager, [fit is not updated or you believe it is incorrect, please
contact your property manager.)
Dues
$0.00
Payment Date
*
04/14/2015
By Email
Email
You will receive an email confirmation to complete your payment in one click.
By Text
999() 999 - 9999
You will receive a text message for confirmation. Reply to the message to complete
your payment.
RentByText™ Option
CONTINUE
Piease confirm the information above is correct.
Bottom of Form
From: Larry Shendell [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, April 14, 201510:27 AM
To: Deborah Raney
Subject: Re: Orchid
The monthly maintenance that you have been paying is not the correct amount. Please check your records
tx
Suite 201
Phone: (954)781-3747
Fax: (954)781-3748
The following statement is being provided as required by federal law: We have been retained by the Association
to collect a debt owed to the Association and any information will be used for that purpose.
product privileges. I f you are not the intended recipient of this message, or i f this message has been addressed to
you i n error, please immediately alert the sender by reply e-mail and thea4elete4his message^ndits
4
On Tue, Apr 14,2015 at 10:05 A M , Deborah R <
> wrote:
Good morning Larry,
Because I overpaid in November the payments that follow are the payments that the computer genereated
monthly, which I paid up to date. A l l my payments are up to date and April 2014 has also been paid and
attached.
D. Raney
Best Regards,
OFFICE
;
i FAX
• | S K Y P E : sMindustry_ | L I N K E D I N : www.linkedin.com/
F A C E B O O K STAT INDUSTRY INC | A D D R E S S 1440 SW 28th Avenue Pompano Beach, FL 33069
For excellent service log on to www.statindustry.com or call our Business Premier Line @ 866-947-STAT(7828).
FAA-AC-00-56A CERTIFIED SUPPLIER | TAG CERTIFICATE # S291111A | CAGE - 57FA3 | DDTC (Approved Manufacturers for Military
Contracts) | Boeing Rights Guard Approved Vendor | Approved Contractor US Navy NAVSEA 08 / (NRP) Nuclear Reactor Program | DOD
Mentor Protege Program | JCP Certification -License #0059368 | ORCA Registered | OCR/SAM | F A A DAR/DER on Staff | Lockheed Martin C5A - C17 - C130 - KC135 approved Vendor | GSA | NASA Space Center MFG Approved |
5
From: Larry Shendell [mailto:
Sent: Tuesday, April 07, 2015 3:38 PM
To:
Subject: Orchid
]
Pis call me
pis check your stubs
From 2013
Suite 201
Phone:
Fax: '
i>V
The following statement is being provided as required by federal law: We have been retained by the
Association to collect a debt owed to the Association and any information will be used for that purpose.
product privileges. I f you are not the intended recipient of this message, or i f this message has been addressed
to you in error, please immediately alert the sender by reply e-mail and then delete this message and its
Deborah R
[email protected]
Monday, April 20, 2015 5:09 AM
[email protected]
Irrôrtant RentPayment Account Jnformafion
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Important RentPayment Account Information
Deborah,
The credit card you have on file with us is about to expire. In order to keep your account
~~ curWrit,^
team at 1-866-289-5977. You can login at:
https://wvw.nentpayment.com/pay/fogm
Thank you for using RentPayment,
The RentPayment Customer Service Team
At RentPayment, we take pride in making collection of payments fast, easy and secure.
Please contact Orchid Grove Master Association at (954) 616-6999 or email
[email protected] if you have any questions.
1
Jl
DUESPAYMENT
POWERED
BY YAPSIONE
PAYMENT HISTORY
Reference
Date
May 11, WtS
11:11:07 AM POT
! 27886515- I
•
May 1, 2015
07:08:26 AM PDT
40
Type
Initiated
By
VISA
Pctaat)
PSawsy
0280
2763144240
Amount
Status
S P R O C E S S E S j W.ZW.08
Dues
$1,1®*.0$:
Electron® Payment Swvtem Pee
•
VISA
; Deborah
Raney
0280
CLEARED
$64.07
• smrrr
Apr 3, 2015
07:34:511 AM PDT
1771903036
Mar 3, 2015
03:31:03 AM P S T
2646820240
Jan 20, 2015
05:38:28 AM P S T
1704911636
Deborah
Raney
5142
$9.95 !
CLEARED
364..07
Dues
$54J2 I
$9.95 i
Deborah
Raney
0280
CLEARED
$64.07
Dues
$54.12
$8.95
i Deborah
; Raney
5142
CLEARED
$64.07
$5*12 \
Dues
Dec 17, 2014
04:52:02 AM P S T
2510964240
Deborah
Raney
9453
$9.95 \
CLEARED
$64.07
Dues
$54.12 ;
Nov 1, 2014
07:30:54 AM PDT
Aug 10, 2014
04:35:57 PM PDT
1638700236
^
: 1579555036
| ~ "
; Deborah
Raney
5142
CLEARED
$1,009.95
Dues
$1,000.00
$9.95
SSfefcSfc
******
•
5142
; Deborah !
• Raney
.
CLEARED
c
D
c
:
n
;
$15.77
Dues
$5.82
$9.95
CLEARED
https://vvww.rentpayment.eom/pay/0/invoices.htm
$9.95
11858982146985
$679.11
5/11/2015
Jul 22, 2014
06:09:44 AM PDT
15586914- I £>check
36
Deborah
Raney
5142
May 11, 2013
09:19:27 AM PDT
1068634740
Dues
$669. tfi
$9.95
Deborah
Raney
0280
CLEARED
Dues
Apr 2, 2013
06:40:41 AM PDT
1020932440
i Deborah
Raney
9453
CLEARED
Dues
Mar 4, 2013
10:42:46 AM P S T
Feb 1, 2013
06:41:49 AM P S T
3* •
988894340
„„,
709966136
Deborah
Raney
9453
:
$276.00
$9.9]$
$285.95
$2.76.00
$9.9]5
$285.95
Dues
$276.00
$9.95
#»check
5142
CLEARED
$285.95
Deborah
Raney
CLEARED
Dues
https://ww.rentpayment.com/pay/0/invoices.html?cd=734411858982146985
$285.9$
$276.00
$9.95
5/11/2015
Deborah R
Friday, May 01, 2015 10:09 AM
[email protected]
From:
Sent:
To:
©
DUESPAYMENT
P O W E R E D BY Y A P S T O N E
Your Payment was Successful!
A payment receipt will be sent to [email protected]
Payment Summary
Deborah Raney
5320 NE 15th Avenue
Payment Method
Dues
Payment Date
Reference Number
* i"he service fee is non-refundable.
* A l l payments are subject to the terms of your current lease agreement.
View Payment History
Print
WSA iing i . . . 0280
en(
n
$54.12
$9.95
$64.07
Fri May 01,2015 07:08 A M PDT
56014891-47
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
[email protected]
55136243-47
This payment w a s SUCCESSFULLY PROCESSED!
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Apr 03, 2015,07:34 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
SUBMITTED*
$54.12
Dues:
$54.12
Sub Total:
eCheck Service Fee:
$9.95
Total:
$64.07
Account:
Reference #:
55136243-47
* Please note, correctly submitted eCheck/ACH payments take
three to five business days to process and successfully clear.
l
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
[email protected]
[email protected]
Msg(l/2) RentPayment Receipt
Date:04A>3/15 Properry:Orchid Grove
Master Association Name:Deborah Raney
Amt:$54.12 Amt:$9.95 TOTAL:$64.07
Acct #:5142 Ref
•F - - M o b i l e - *
This massage was ssM to you by a t-MoWls wtaSsss phone.
1
Deborah R
[email protected]
Tuesday, March 03, 2015 6:32 AM
[email protected]
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
54047860-47
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Mar 03, 2015, 03:31 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
PAID
Dues:
$54.12
Sub Total:
$54.12
Visa Service Fee:
$9.95
Total:
Account:
Reference #:
$64.07
Visa ending in ....0280
54047860-47
questions
l
O
DUESPAYf"
povnaeo
by
yap*7<»!>
Payment Summary
Orchid G r o v e M a s t e r Association
5 3 2 0 N E 15th A v e n u e
Unit/Address - 2 2 3 S W 6th Place
Deborah Raney
VISA e n d i n g
Payment Method
in ... 0 2 8 0
$54.12
Dues
Electronic P a y m e n t Service F e e
$9.95
$84.07
Total Payment A m o u n t
T u e Mar 0 3 , 2 0 1 5 0 3 : 3 1 A M PST
P a y m e n t Date
Reference Number
54047860-47
* T h e service fee is non-refundable.
* Alt payments are subject to the terms of your current lease agreement.
https://vvw.erent^
1/1
Deborah R
From:
[email protected]
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Tuesday, January 20, 2015 8:39 AM
[email protected]
52591515-47
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Jan 20, 2015, 05:38 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
deborah. [email protected]
Association:
Status:
PAID
Dues:
$54.12
Sub Total:
$54.12
eCheck Service Fee:
$9.95
Total:
$64.07
Account:
Reference #:
52591515-47
questions
1
Thank you tor you payment [ ueDoran Kaney ô, uuesrayment j
rage i u i i
f i l PUEBFAVMENTI
t»«TMCMTa FOB PflOPtBTIt**'
Payment Summary
Orchid Grove Muster Association
5320 NE 15th Avenue
Deborah Raney
| ending in ... 9453
Payment Method
Dues
$54.12
$9.95
SM.07
Totsi Payment Amourrt
Wad Dmc 17, 2614 0 4 * 2 AM PST
Paymeni Date
Reference Nuter
"The service fee is non-refundsbfe.
AH payments are subject to the terms of your current lease agreement.
1
https://ww.erentpayerxonT/pay/makePaymentOneClicMhanks.htmI
12/17/2014
Deborah R
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
Saturday, November 01, 2014 10:32 AM
[email protected]
50216051-47
Flag Status:
Flagged
Name:
Deborah Raney
Date:
Nov 0 1 , 2014, 07:30 AM
Unit:
223 SW 6th Place
Address:
223 SW 6th Place
Phone:
(954) 591-4554
Email:
[email protected]
Association:
Status:
PAID
$1,000.00
Dues:
Sub Total:
$1,000.00
$9.95
eCheck Service Fee:
$1,009.95
Total:
Account:
Reference #:
50216051-47
This email was automatically"generated by Orchid Grove M ^ t e r Association.
questions
1
:5i<yocERa
Send Result Report
MFP
65/11/2015 15:13
Firmware Version
[2H7_1000.024.001] [2H7_1100.002.003] [2H7_7000.013.006]
2H7 2F00.E15.002 2014.07.30
Total Time: 0°03'50"
Job No.: 172876
mm
Page: 025
Complete
Document:
doc20150511150903
No.
Date and Time
001
05/11/15 15:09 9 5 4 7 8 1 3 7 4 8
Times
Destination
Type
0°03'50" FAX
i
Result
Resolution/ECM
OK
200x100 Normal/On
[ QEK9800391 ]
Send Result Report
cgKyocERa
CS 5 0 0 c i
Firmware Version
05/11/2015 15:22
2H7_2F00.E15.002 2014.07.30
Job No.: 172877
Total Time: 0°05'02"
[2H7_iooo.024.ooi]
[2H7_IIOO.OO2.OO3]
[2H7_700o.oi3.oo6]
Page: 025
Complete
Document:
doc20150511151OOO
No.
Date and Time Destination
Times
001
05/11/15 15:14 9 5 4 5 8 6 5 1 1 3
0°05'02" FAX
1
Type
Result
Resolution/ECM
OK
200x100 Normal/On
[ QEK9800391 ]
THE FLORIDA BAR
TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32399-2300
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
(850) 561-5600
WWW.FLABAR.ORG
June 3, 2015
Ms. Deborah Raney
Re:
Ms. Tamar Duffner Shendell; RFA No.: 15-19138
Dear Ms. Raney:
Your inquiry concerning the above-referenced attorney has been referred to me for my review.
While I understand that you believe the attorney’s opinion is incorrect, I must conclude that your
complaint constitutes a civil dispute which is best resolved through the civil system. The
Supreme Court of Florida has ruled that the disciplinary process and proceedings are not to be
used as a substitute for civil proceedings and remedies.
After careful consideration, I conclude that the matters referenced in your inquiry do not
constitute violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, and accordingly, your inquiry does
not fall within the purview of the grievance system framework. Consequently, I have closed our
record in this matter. Please be advised that my action does not preclude you from consulting
with private counsel, nor does it preclude you from exercising any legal remedy which may be
available to you.
Pursuant to the Bar’s records retention schedule, the computer record and file will be disposed of
one year from the date of closing.
Sincerely,
Theodore P. Littlewood Jr., Bar Counsel
Attorney Consumer Assistance Program
cc:
Ms. Tamar Duffner Shendell

Shendell complaint filed by owner at Lighthouse Point

Transcription

Similar documents

25–26 june 2016 manchester, uk

SUSTAINABLE PACIFIC GROVE APRIL MEETING

Web Safety

Mother - One Heart Bulgaria

fiscal year 2013 annual report

black history month - The Pinder Group, LLC.

March - Massachusetts Orchid Society

Customer`s recommendations using the SCI technology:

March 2009 - Platinum Coast Orchid Society

August 2012 - Virginia Orchid Society