Presentation
Transcription
Presentation
Data Driven Suicide Prevention & Means Reduction Wesley Schweikhard & Ken Crandall Facilitators Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 1 Today’s Panel Theresa Ly, MPH Suicide Prevention Program Specialist EDC [email protected] | 916.494.9616 Sandra Black, MSW Education Development Center | [email protected] | 530.771.7551 Robert K. Stohr, M.S., L.M.F.T. Division Director Suicide Prevention Center [email protected] 310-895-2352/Fax310-895-2370 Katie Cassidy, M.S. Community Development Coordinator Shasta County Health & Human Services Agency (530)225-5940 [email protected] Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Using Data for Suicide Prevention Sept. 18, 2013 CalMHSA Statewide Coordinating Workgroup Theresa Ly, EDC Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Using data for planning • Provides a focus for prevention & intervention activities • Evaluation tool • Informs policy • Disproves common misconceptions Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 4 Types of data relating to suicide Mortality* Attempts* Ideation Cost of injury Associated risk factors Access to mental health services • Crisis hotline access • • • • • • * can be paired with information about method Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 5 How to use data • Get a fuller picture by examining data over a number of years (at least 5) • Look at multiple data sets to get a better understanding of suicide in your community • For example, if mortality data shows that males have higher suicide rates… • And crisis center data shows that fewer males are calling in for assistance… • This may suggest a need to re-examine how resources are portrayed and marketed to men Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 6 Considerations when using data Age-Adjusted Mortality Rate per 100,000 for Suicide Fatalities of Humboldt County Residents, 2008-2012 30.0 24.8 25.0 23.7 23.5 19.7 19.2 Rate/100,000 20.0 15.0 10.0 5.0 AAMR 0.0 2008 2009 5-year trend 2010 Year 2011 2012 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 7 When using data… • Don’t sensationalize the data • Consider social math “183 suicides have occurred in Nevada County in the past 10 years” vs. “As many people died by suicide in the past 10 years in Nevada County as would fill almost 4 school buses” Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 8 Case studies • Trinity County: Examined coroner data and found that people who killed themselves in Trinity County resided within the County • San Diego: Used 10 years of suicide mortality data to determine that middle-aged white men were at highest risk for suicide and implemented the Tough Times Campaign as a result Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 9 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Demographics Call Volume Reason for Call Risk Follow-Up Caller Satisfaction Robert Stohr, M.S., L.M.F.T., Division Director Georgina Parra Morris, Ph.D., Program Evaluator Didi Hirsch Mental Health Services [email protected] (310) 895-2318 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Crisis Line Common Metrics Topic Input: Demographics • Important in increasing access to Crisis line. Reason for Call • • Educates people about what presenting problems are and how main issues are defined. Knowing about presenting mental illness is useful during call. • • • • Shows the work that is being done by Crisis Lines. The number of people who call a crisis line is an outcome that speaks to efficacy. Useful for expanding scope to other counties and regions. Gives us trends that help identify communities that are being served and service gaps. Risk • • Follow-Up • • People at varying levels of risk call Crisis Lines. Pairing level of risk with resolution of call can help in understanding reduction of suicide risk. Allows for outreach to highest risk callers and serves as a reminder to call again. Allows for tracking calls post-attempt & post-hospitalization. Call volume Caller Satisfaction • Provides information on effectiveness of call. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out What are caller’s presenting problems? Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out *Data for July 2013. Data is based on 10 Crisis Centers that are part of CA Suicide Prevention Network. Reducing Access to Lethal Means Sept. 18, 2013 CalMHSA Statewide Coordinating Workgroup Sandra Black, MSW EDC Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out What do we mean by “lethal means”? • • • • • • Firearms Poisons/drugs/medications - Overdoses CO, plastic bags - Suffocation Ropes - Strangulation Heights - Jumping Sharp objects - Cutting Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 15 Suicide methods in California 2001-2010 Other, 1874 Poisoning 6856 Jumping 1282 Cut/Pierce 845 Firearm 14335 Hanging 9245 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 16 What do we mean by “restricting access”? Insulate, limit or create barriers between a person and means of harm Temporarily removing the person from the means OR removing the means from the person Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 17 Restricting access is not a new idea! Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 18 “Won’t they just die some other way?” • • • • • • • Bern, Switzerland (Reisch & Michel, 2005) Augusta, Maine (Pelletier, 2007) New Zealand (Beautrais, 2001) Bristol, England (Bennewith, 2007) United Kingdom (Kreitman, 1976) Sri Lanka (Gunnell, 2007) 90% of suicide attempt survivors don’t later die by suicide Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 19 Means Matter* • Many suicide attempts occur with little planning during short term crisis • When the means to die by suicide are less available or less deadly, suicide rates decline – More time for crisis to pass – More time for intervention to occur *Harvard School of Public Health Means Matter Campaign http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/means-matter/ Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Why focus on firearms? • Most lethal & most commonly used method • Suicidal acts with firearms are fatal 85% of the time • Study showed that firearms used in youth suicides mostly belong to a family member, usually a parent – As many as 64% were stored unlocked Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Programs & Strategies Responsible gun ownership is the key • Engage gun shops, range owners & hunter safety instructors • Gun Storage – Locks, Safes, Ammo Separation Protecting people during a suicidal crisis using lethal means counseling • Assess whether a person at risk has access to firearms or other lethal means • Work with them and their support system to restrict access until they are no longer feeling suicidal Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Moving on to other means • How can we restrict access to other means? Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Cold Spring Canyon Bridge Barrier, Santa Barbara County Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 24 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 25 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 26 How to address overdoses? • • • • Prescription drug monitoring Information at pharmacies Drug collection programs Increase availability of treatment Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 27 Reducing suicide no matter what method • Counseling on access to lethal means • Screening and assessments • Reducing media contagion Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 28 “Injury prevention research can have real and lasting effects. Over the last 20 years, the number of Americans dying in motor vehicle crashes has decreased by 31%. Death from fires and drowning have been reduced even more, by 38% and 52%, respectively. This progress was achieved without banning automobiles, swimming pools, or matches. Instead, it came from translating research findings into effective interventions.” • Drs. Arthur Kellermann and Frederick Rivara, JAMA 2012 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Resources • Means Matter at www.meansmatter.org to download materials and use them in your work • CALM: Counseling on Access to Lethal Means Free online workshop http://training.sprc.org/course/description.php#cours e3 • Find programs in the Best Practices Registry at www.sprc.org/bpr Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 30 Shasta County Suicide Prevention & Firearm Safety Know the Signs >> Find the Katie Cassidy, MS Shasta County Health & Human Services Agency (530) 225-5940 Words >> Reach Out [email protected] Presentation Introduce Shasta County Suicide Prevention Workgroup Suicide Prevention & Firearms Safety Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 50.8% female 86.7% identify as White 47 people per square mile Median age 41.8 years 91.5% speak English at home Shasta County Residents: Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 3 part assessment: Shasta County Suicide Data, Community Perception, Community Response Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach “When spider webs unite, they can tie up a lion.” ~ Ethiopian Proverb Out Challenges Stigma Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach It is hard to measure prevention Public criticism through media and common myths & O u t misconceptions Data Effective Prevention Strategies Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Easy Suicide Prevention Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out “Have fun stormin' da castle.” “Think it'll work?” “It would take a miracle!” Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Challenges: Anything resembling gun control Assuming that firearms owners are not safe Telling people what to do with their guns in their own homes Recommendations that were not feasible, legal or responsible Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Solutions: Be clear about the purpose/intent of the project Include the experts Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Purpose Communicate suicide prevention information and resources to our communities. Engage firearms owners in suicide awareness and prevention efforts. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Who are the Experts? Shasta County Suicide Prevention Workgroup Law Enforcement Firearms Retailers Firearms Safety Instructors Shooting Clubs Gun Ranges Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Next Steps Materials were created/adapted Feedback was sought from friends and families Packets were distributed to Law Enforcement Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out February 2012 26 packets were mailed to Shasta County firearms experts Initial follow-up contact via phone and email Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out March 2012 Additional follow up via phone, email and in person visit (5 interviews completed) Survey tool (possibly too formal) Good feedback was obtained Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out What worked: Reinforcing positive practices Highlighting safety successes Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Initial Impressions: Education on safe handling of firearms is always of first importance Advising locked containers is the preferred method of storage Provide more specific information on who is allowed to take custody of firearms for someone Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Let people know California approved locks are free and where to obtain Out Initial Impressions: Most important issue for anyone around guns is safety, safety, safety. More focus on safety is good. #1 and #2 cover it all. Everyone needs to be aware of gun safety. It might be prudent to emphasize storing OTHER weapons in safes or with locks. This is great info. Safety should always be reinforced. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Additional feedback: “This information will be most productive if included with other methods.” “Universal suicide prevention education would be good, for example what to do with someone before they get to the point of choosing the method.” “Any information that helps identify and get help before the 5150 call is good for gun owners.” “Information on EARLY warning signs, drug use and who to call (phone numbers) for options would be good.” Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Advice for the project: Several instructors would like to teach firearm safety for the general public, especially non-firearm owners at a suicide prevention summit. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Advice for the project: “Put this info with other information about suicide prevention, it is better than trying to make it stand alone.” Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Keep this advice in the context of overall safety, NOT emergency information. Advice for the project: This will help keep someone from trying to grab a gun out of another’s hand. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Warning signs are key. Advice for the project: Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Advice for the project: Reinforce safety information including proper storage with locking devices. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Lessons Learned: Suicide prevention info should not only be about firearms. Safety is a huge concern to firearm owners; safety messages are good to reinforce. Suicide prevention information is important to everyone, important to reinforce early warning signs and resources for help. Include information and resources on how/where to help. Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Brochures are posted in Sheriff’s office Butte County is adopting similar approach Gun store sponsorship for Out of Darkness Walk Plans to revisit and follow up www.shastasuicideprevention.com Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Suicide Prevention Best Practices Project Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out Superior Region Needs Assessment Data Suicide Death Rates from 2000-2010 Rate Per 100,000 25.0 20.0 18.6 19.5 19.1 20.3 18.2 19.4 20.1 18.6 19.1 20.3 15.8 15.0 10.0 9.1 9.3 9.0 9.4 9.2 8.6 8.8 9.3 9.7 9.7 9.8 5.0 Superior Region CA 0.0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 2009 2010 Superior Region Needs Assessment Data 40.0 35.0 Suicide Death Rates By Gender (2010) 35.3 Rates Per 100,000 30.0 Superior Region 25.0 20.0 16 15.0 10.0 7.1 4.6 5.0 0.0 Male Female Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out CA Superior Region Needs Assessment Data Suicide Death Rates by Age (2010) 60.0 Superior Region 48.3 50.0 CA Rate Per 100,00 40.0 34.2 31.8 28.0 30.0 22.0 20.0 17.1 16.4 15.6 10.0 10.0 16.3 10.0 5.3 0.0 0.0 1.1 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-44 45-64 Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 65-84 85+ Superior Region Needs Assessment Data Suicide Deaths by Cause/ Mechanism (2010) 60.0% 55.0% 50.0% Superior Region 38.3% 40.0% 30.5% 30.0% 20.5% 20.0% 10.0% 1.2% 2.3% 17.0% 2.9% 3.8% 0.0% Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 20.0% 3.5% 5.0% CA Suicide Deaths by Cause/Mechanism (2010): Ages 20-44 45% 41% 39% 40% 35% Superior Region CA 39% 30% 30% 25% 20% 14% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 2% 4% 5% Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 18% 2% 6% Suicide Deaths by Cause/Mechanism (2010): Ages 45-64 70% 63% Superior Region CA 60% 50% 39% 40% 28% 30% 19% 20% 10% 26% 11% 3% 3% 3% 4% 0% Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 1% 5% Suicide Deaths by Cause/Mechanism (2010): Ages 65-84 70% 57% 60% 60% Superior Region CA 50% 40% 27% 30% 16% 20% 10% 0% 16% 10% 0% 1% 0% 3% Know the Signs >> Find the Words >> Reach Out 7% 5%