The HAPI Volkswagen Engine
Transcription
The HAPI Volkswagen Engine
H.A..P.I. VOLKSWAGEN ENGINE By: R. E. and P. J. Taylor (EAA 87893) P. O. Box 5951 Calexico, CA 92231 3OUT THREE YEARS ago we started designing an aeroplane to fill the gap left by the lack of the Cub or Champ type aircraft. Remember how we used to fly? Putt-putting around the sky, nowhere in particular to go but loving every minute we spent in the air? We'd fly around the local airports, no need for a radio, ILS, VOR, DME, tower or any of the other so called modern conveniencesf?), we simply flew for the sheer joy of it. We wanted to design a kit aircraft to again capture that thrill of flying, without the disastrous effect on the family budget that even a low cost factory built flivver can cause now. Our aircraft would be two place, side by side, strut braced, fixed gear, lots of wing area, stable, safe and FUN! The wings would fold, you take it home on it's own trailer and keep it there. Assembly for flight would take less than five minutes. It would be built by somewhat unconventional methods, prefabricated similar to a radio controlled model kit — we spent years as R.C. kit manufacturers are astronomical! Continental no longer builds engines smaller than 230 hp and the smallest new Lycoming available is 115 hp and about $5000 ready to install. So, sad to say, we all too often see another ad for an unfinished project, the engine obstacle having been too great a hurdle for our would-be builder to surmount. In the past few years we have seen some tremendous advances in homebuilt technology, with designers such as Ken Rand throwing away the book of years-old methods and designing an airplane that really preforms on a 36 hp Volkswagen engine. By using a new unconventional structure Ken's first KR-1 flew on a 36 hp Volksie that had little more done to it than installation of a magneto and a prop hub. Rutan and Friends are obtaining fantastic performance from an 18 hp Onan engine in their Quickie, another fine example of an aircraft being engineered to an engine. Bert Sisler's Cygnet is a beautiful modern cross-country machine for two standard adults, reasonably light baggage, a useful fuel load and he does this on a Volkswagen engine. The new Windwagon design has very good performance on only the front half of a Volkswagen engine! These designs are flying proof that an aircraft can carry a useful load on minimal horsepower engines or be a very snappy performer on those same powerplants. It very soon became obvious that Volkswagen was about the only logical choice for our aircraft. We started buying conversion drawings from various sources and trying to gather as much information regarding converting a Volkswagen to aircraft as possible. We studied the various ways developed by others to convert the Volkswagen to aircraft use. While most of these drawings were very complete in details of fabricating the unique aircraft adaption parts, they said little or nothing about the Volkswagen engine or how to properly set it up for aircraft, none of the many pitfalls in building an engine that can cause major problems were mentioned. Since the basic engine is the heart of reliability we wanted to know how best to set it up for flight. There are other engines being converted to aircraft but since VW starts out as a horizontally opposed four cylinder air cooled engine with many similarities with the Lye's and Continentals and the fact they have been exported in plentiful supply everywhere in the world has made them the most common engine in aircraft conversion. The Volkswagen engine is a very sturdy unit and is quite capable of taking fantastic abuse and continuing to deliver service. They have been hopped up in every conceivable manner and used in about every kind of racing you can think of. They are capable of being modified to develop over 250 hp starting with the basic 1600cc engine. You can spend a fortune on racing goodies such as roller bearing crankshafts and turbochargers to pull the power out of these little mills or you can use the wealth of knowledge gained in racing to build a very strong lightweight engine that will develop a reasonable — and would require no welding, fiber glass or epoxy amount of power over a long period of time with a high work, fabric work or other methods more exotic than a model aircraft. The design would be capable of being built by any average model builder. This project is all very possible but the first step had to be deciding on the most suitable, and more importantly perhaps, most available powerplant. There are homebuilders in this old world who have degree of reliability. Our family has been Volkswagen oriented for fifteen years and we have built several dune buggies and Baja Bugs for off road use. We had built high performance engines for our vehicles and over the years learned what you can and cannot expect from a Volkswagen engine. We had decided that since this was to be an aircraft engine and we quite literally bet our lives on such an engine, we would not be satisfied with less than aircraft standards. bought themselves some plans or sketched out their own original design to utilize an engine in the 50 to 10 hp range. Some have gotten well into their projects before looking for and pricing engines and found that nowadays you really have to turn over a lot of rocks to even find an engine. Usually when you find one, it needs rebuilding, parts are hard to get or unavailable and prices 34 FEBRUARY 1979 We knew from racing that you can never just assume that everything is right. You have to tear it down, clean, inspect, measure, smooth, file, adjust, balance, reassemble, torque and reinspect to KNOW what you Ofr Development of the H.A.P.I. Volkswagen engine and tooling up for production have occupied our time for the last year. Following are some of the procedures we consider essential to Volkswagen engine conversions. Our aircraft is to have the capability for radio so the electrical systems demand an alternator. Most airports don't welcome a hand propped aircraft now and many pilots have never started an engine without a starter. On the H.A.P.I. engine conversion the starter is a standard feature. We wanted to provide for a larger powerplant on our kit airplane so motor mounts on the VW accessory case were made the same as Continental A-65 through 0-200. Standard Continental rubber bushings are used to isolate vibration. The alternator rotor is immediately behind the starter ring inside the case. The magneto coupler is attached to the rear of the rotor in what we call a "stack" arrangement. The stator ring is around the rotor inside the bulge that can be seen in the photos and is bolted to the accessory case casting. Our alternators are 10 amp motorcycle units but can be rewound to produce 20 amps at slight additional cost. The magneto is a Slick 4016 with shielded harness and spark plugs as standard equipment. As soon as Slick releases its new 6000 series magneto which is field serviceable, we will use it. Sheet metal ducting directs outside air over crankcase bottom and through rear mounted oil cooler for efficient heat dissipation. have if you are to achieve the reliability it takes to win. In an aircraft we are so much more dependent on this reliability than in a racer. We can't simply pull off of the course if something fails. So the first step in our aircraft kit is the engine and we gathered people with the expertise to help us design a conversion to meet our goals. We are located in Calexico in southern California, right smack on the Mexican border where Volkswagen powered off-road vehicles are probably more numerous than anywhere on earth. There are many racing enthusiasts here with Volkswagen know how and mechanical services in abundance. We set about to literally pick these guy's brains and learn everything possible about these engines. Many of the tricks, of course, aren't applicable to aircraft, but many others are suitable and desirable It was obvious at the outset that to hop up or ask for big horsepower would be to trade off reliability and service life, and we have kept everything on the conservative side. We have achieved what we feel to be the best set of compromises, choosing from among power, high reliability and reasonable cost. We had by now decided that the engine conversions we have looked over in our studies hadn't gone as far as we felt was necessary, so we started to design and build our own engines. We were fortunate in having Joe Cole near us and in being able to draw upon his many years of experience in building engines and setting up cars for the "Baja 1OOO", one of the toughest races in the world. Just to keep engine and car together to finish is quite an accomplishment Joe has worked with us in our develop- ment program and now contracts certain unique Volkswagen machine work on our engines that he has developed the hard tooling and methods for accomplishing. The help and services of Rodger Ring, machinist, tool and die maker has been invaluable, particularly in the areas of production tooling and methods. Rodger owned a fifty man shop until his retirement recently and supplied precision machine parts to Rohr Aircraft. Engine has low frontal area. Lower cylinder shrouding on this engine is basis for pressure cowling. Oil cooler is seen through duct above carburetor. We do not offer dual ignition at this time. We will be doing some testing in the future to find out what happens to cylinder heads when extra plug holes are added and will possibly offer it at a later date. There are four other castings used in our conversion, all of which are cast in magnesium and have large cooling fins for both appearance and cooling. Two identical castings permit remote oil cooler location and circulate the oil via oil lines. These castings as well as all of the parts we use in building our engines are available separately if you are building your own engine and wish to use some H.A.P.I. parts. Our engines start with a factory new Volkswagen 1600 crankcase which is now being manufactured at the SPORT AVIATION 35 Mexican Volkswagen plant. Our location on the International border gives us easy access to new VW parts in Mexico at reasonable prices and instant availability.) We then machine the case to accept 92mm cylinders which increases displacement to 1835cc. At the same time we also modify the main bearings for suitability to aircraft demands. We then inspect, smooth corners, clean and ready the case to receive the crankshaft assembly. This is made up of the crankshaft which has been machined to accept our forged steel propeller hub, fitted with all the parts that rotate with it, such as the starter ring, alternator rotor and magneto drive plate, timing gear and the propeller hub. The whole rotating assembly is electronically balanced and marked to insure correct reassembly. The piston, wrist pin, ring assembly have also been balanced to match their weights perfectly. The connecting rods are balanced end to end to each other before as- This Model "60" engine when photographed had 68 hours test stand time at power settings from 8(X; to wide open. It will be installed on H.A.P.I.'s KR-1 with a tuned exhaust system by Dix Homebuilt Supply. sembly. Rods used are forged steel units much stronger than stock rods. Balancing is a race proven absolute essential in engine build-up. You may think your engine was balanced at the factory but you have now removed the flywheel, probably changed rods and pistons, put on a propeller hub and other things that rotate with the crank, so it is in no way a balanced assembly now. While you may be lucky and have all the various out-of-balance parts tend to cancel each other out, usually they seem to go in the same direction and the engine will shake like the dickens. Consider these figures: '/4 oz. extra weight four inches from the center of a rotating element creates forces of imbalance equal to 7 Ibs. at 2000 rpm, 15.8 Ibs. at 3000 rpm, 28 Ibs. at 4000 rpm, much like whirling a weight on the end of a string. The whirling weights can and do exert side loads on bearings that greatly decrease their life expectancy and increase chances for a bearing failure. . 36 FEBRUARY 1979 The crankshaft with rods attached, properly torqued and safetied is then placed in the case. The other half of the case is placed over the studs with all bolts being tightened in proper sequence with a torque wrench. (I can't overemphasize the importance of proper torque values in building a VW engine.) We then install the piston and cylinder assemblies, installing special cylinder air baffles to direct air over the bottom side properly. This is an essential on VW engines. If provided with plenty of cooling air properly circulated around the heads and cylinders, plus a plentiful supply of clean cool oil under adequate pressure, these powerplants are hard to hurt. We strongly recommend that a H.A.P.I. engine be pressure cowled. Positive forced cooling is the best way to avoid the problems associated with a hot running engine, such as burnt valves, cracked cylinder heads, excessive wear and in extreme cases, possible sudden seizure in flight. Magnesium accessory case houses starter ring and alternator internally and mounts magneto and starter. Motor mount is same as Continental A-65 through 0-200. Remote oil cooler and lines are seen below starter. Next come the cylinder heads which have had considerable work. We use aluminum bronze valve guides and stainless steel valves. These guides have been selected because their expansion rate closely matches the aluminum heads. They have very good wear characteristics when used with the stainless valves. The valves are single piece relatively soft valves that can withstand high exhaust temperatures without burning and have a history free of the breakage problems associated with the harder valves. Stem to guide clearance is very important and is set up to allow for the troublesome buildup we get in using the so called 100 octane "Low Lead" avgas, which contains four times as much lead as 80-87. The cylinder heads have been precisely measured for combustion chamber volume and metal removed until volume in all chambers is equal. This is another step in "balancing' the engine. Combustion chambers as cast may vary considerably in volume so that instead of a consistent ratio of compression on all cylinders there may be variations that can cause engine roughness even Amigo is powered with a Lycoming 0-290-D2 rated at 135 hp. (Photo page 30, May '77 SPORT AVIATION). Amigo was built with front and rear cylinders on each side feeding a separate exhaust. As soon as the new crossover system was installed and flown an immediate increase in performance was obvious. Rate of climb is noticeably better and with throttle set at 24" manifold pressure, an increase of 160 rpm from 2400 to 2560 was obtained. Cruise speed is now 10 mph faster at the same MP settings. Ground observers say that the aircraft is now quieter. Cylinder head temperature has decreased slightly at full power climb settings. This was the only change made at the time so performance increase is entirely due to better exhaust tuning. H.A.P.I. has furnished Dix with a test engine to be installed on the dynamometer and used to develop an efficient exhaust system for VW conversions. We are sure that a similar performance gain can be obtained on H.A.P.I. engines or any VW conversion. Dix should have his testing finished and exhaust system near production by the time you read this. Carburetor and exhaust heat muffs when installed on this system will provide safety and comfort. Dix says that pipes will be tucked in snugly around the engine so tight cowls will still be possible. The engines we build are still "Experimental" engines, of course, and cannot be used on a certified aircraft. The aim of our company is to take as much of the "experiment" out of "experimental" as possible and deliver to you an engine that can be bolted on your aircraft, filled with oil, fueled and run without your having to be an expert engine mechanic to keep it airworthy. At present we build the 1835cc model "60" engine and 1600cc model "50" engine. We also have available a complete line of engine gauges and accessories compatible with VW conversions. Our engines, engine instruments and other products are now being delivered. H.A.P.I. will have a book on the market by March 1, 1979 that shows you in step by step detail, complete with pictures, diagrams, torque charts, bearing sizes, etc., what to do and what NOT to do to build an aircraft engine out of a Volkswagen. When you start your conversion, it ceases to be a VW and becomes an aircraft engine. Anything less than aircraft standards of work- manship and design can be dangerous. We tell you how and where to get everything you need. A list of the stock VW parts numbers that work best in aircraft conversions is included. We prefer to use a new crankcase, but a good used engine can be built up also. A used engine should be one with a traceable history. NEVER use an engine that has trashed out bearings or any other part because the oil gallery system will be contaminated with small metal particles that are nearly impossible to clean out. These will get into your oil system after rebuilding. If you buy a used engine, get a 1600cc engine with the late transporter case. Find one that's running. There should be no knocks or other indications of internal problems. A wrecked VW totaled from the front end is a good source. After you find such an engine, tear it down completely and clean it up spotlessly, measure every part. Don't assume that its good because it ran well and don't be too dollar conscious to throw away parts that are not of first quality. We will build an engine for you or help you build your own, but whatever you do, don't just go to the local junkyard, get an engine and bolt on a prop and mag. It may get you up into the air, but it's not an aircraft engine! All of the machining operations mentioned in this article are available to those building their own engines. An illustrated brochure on all our products is available for $3.00 refundable with order from H.A.P.I. (Homebuilt Aircraft Products International), P. 0. Box 5951, Calexico, CA 92231. We are located at Hangar 4, Calexico International Airport, Calexico, CA. Phone 714357-6342. Our kit aircraft, the HAPICRAFT, is still a long way off, but we can provide engines for some of the many excellent lightweight designs available now. Perhaps the day of low cost flying is not really gone, just taking a new form. Maybe all you need to get your dream into the air is a H.A.P.I. ENGINE! Specifications MODEL 60 1834cc Horsepower . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 at 3200 rpm Bore . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92mm Stroke . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69mm Compression . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 to 1 Fuel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100 octane Av-gas or equivalent O i l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 qts. capacity Garb. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Posa Fuel Injector Carb. Ignition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Slick Magneto - Shielded Spark Plugs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aircraft - Shielded Starter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bosch 12v. A l t e r n a t o r . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 amp. Prop Hub . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C1020 steel forging Oil Cooler . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Standard Equipment Engine Mounts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rubber Isolation Type All Castings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lightweight Magnesium Dry W e i g h t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152 Ibs. Prop Mounting . . . . . . . . . . 6 holes .375 dia. on 4.00 B.C. MODEL 50 ENGINE Same Specifications As Above Except: 50 Horsepower at 3200 Displacement — 1600cc 38 FEBRUARY 1979 Calexico Airport's Robert Garcia refueling a test engine. Engines are set up for and tested on 100 octane because of its universal availability. Fuel consumption is 3.4 at 3200 recommended cruise rpm.