Rogers Park Community Health Assessment
Transcription
Rogers Park Community Health Assessment
Rogers Park Community Health Assessment “Quality, Affordable Health Care for All” 2006 / 2007 Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park Loyola University of Chicago Cook County Commissioner, Larry Suffredin Howard Area Community Center Table of Contents I. Introduction/Purpose II. Phase I – Quantitative Data a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. j. Physical Environment A Brief History of Rogers Park Education Safety Politics and Government Communication Health and Social Services Economics Recreation in Rogers Park Health Status III. Phase II – Qualitative Data a. b. c. Community Perspectives Focus Groups Summary IV. Conclusion V. References VI. Appendix 2 Introduction/Purpose In January, 2006 a group of Rogers Park residents testified at the Cook County Budget Hearing held in Skokie, Illinois about the lack of affordable health care for the uninsured and underinsured of the Rogers Park community. The Cook County Commissioners and Cook County Board President John H. Stroger Jr. listened to the testimony, and said there was no money in the current budget to place a Cook County Clinic in Rogers Park. They went on to say that the residents of Rogers Park should keep working to “get the word out” about the lack of affordable health care. Cook County Commissioner Larry Suffredin, wrote an amendment to the 2006 budget to include $2 million for a Cook County Clinic for his 13th District, which includes Rogers Park. The amendment was voted down in committee and was never brought up for a board vote. Meanwhile, the 13th District Health Care Task Force recommended pursing the placement of a Federally Qualified Health Center (FQHC) because the need for quality, affordable health care in Rogers Park was so great. In February, 2006 the “Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park” (NHRP), many of whom testified at the Cook County Budget Hearing the month before, Commissioner Larry Suffredin, and members of the 13th District Health Care Task Force began to meet with Heartland Health Outreach (HHO) to discuss and plan for the placement of a FQHC in Rogers Park. The primary reason NHRP reached out to HHO was because of their mission to treat all regardless of ability to pay, and their experience working with diverse cultures, new immigrants, and persons with chronic illnesses who require a medical home. This community health assessment is being done as a requirement for the FQHC federal grant application process and also for community members and community groups to use 3 to improve the overall health care safety net of the Rogers Park Community. We plan to post this community assessment on the NHRP website, which can be found at www.HealthyRP.org. NHRP wanted to gather as much community support as possible to complete the assessment. NHRP approached Loyola University, Center for Urban Learning (CURL) and the Marcella Niehoff School of Nursing, as Rogers Park community partners for their professional expertise and advice. We are grateful for the help we received in compiling and writing this community health assessment. CURL provided a generous grant to implement and analyze the focus group section of the assessment. Members from the community participated with completing the windshield survey, the community leadership interviews, participating in focus groups, and with writing the community history and other subsections. Phase I of the assessment is a general description of the community. Its purpose is to help understand the community of Rogers Park through all aspects of community life. The information is objective data meant to describe and understand the community’s social capital and capacities. In order to understand the systems at work in Rogers Park, the “Community Assessment Wheel” by Anderson and McFarlane was adopted (Anderson and McFarlane, 2000). The wheel divides the community into eight subsystems: Economic, Physical Environment, Education, Safety, Recreation and the Arts, Politics and Government, Health and Social Services and Communication. It is important to understand that the subsystems relate to each other and to the population of Rogers Park. The population of the community is captured through its history, demographics, racial/ethnic composition, building occupancy status and health status. The information was gathered through written data and observation from the following sources: • • • • • • • The Rogers Park Historical Society Loyola University of Chicago, Center for Urban Research and Learning (CURL) 2000 Census Data Windshield surveys conducted during day and night time. A windshield survey is a visual survey of the physical environment of the community. The community is described objectively through the surveyor’s senses (vision, hearing, touch, smell and taste). A literature review and review of data, including Internet sources, local newspapers, on-line articles, Websites and information written by community agencies. City of Chicago, Department of Public Health regional and community reports. Other health reports related to specific disease processes prevalent in Rogers Park. Phase II of the assessment addresses the specific issue of the lack of quality affordable health care in the Rogers Park Community. Phase II is the qualitative measurement of the assessment. Community Leadership Interviews were done to document community health need information from professionals and others who work with organizations, groups, churches and other coalitions within the community. Focus groups throughout the community were also done in an attempt to capture the impact the lack of affordable health care has on both the family and the individual. This section helps to plan for future needs and address specific gaps in health care. 4 Ongoing Discourse This Community Needs Assessment is both a broad analysis of trends and careful examination of certain specific influences on neighborhood health in Rogers Park. Its usefulness to the community in procuring services and revealing connections makes it an integral part of today’s community health environment. However, its lasting relevance will depend upon cooperation between the various agencies, elected officials and neighborhood groups responsible for its creation. Today’s health care environment abruptly shifts as various interests struggle for survival and profit, often at the expense of consumers. Unlike government agencies and corporate players, the people of Rogers Park have no “health identity” with which to express their needs and priorities. A regularly updated Needs Assessment provides that. This document is the basis upon which a truly effective community health delivery system can be built. Updates are critical because the needs of Rogers Park’s economically and racially diverse population will not remain the same. Communities and health risks are fluid, and only an analysis mechanism dexterous enough to document motility in a complex urban environment can successfully track those changes. We are confident that this Assessment will benefit from periodic factual additions by both the original authors and other concerned parties. We welcome such participation, and encourage the use of this document to effect positive change in our community. 5 Phase I – Quantitative Data: General Description Rogers Park is one of the most ethnically and culturally diverse communities in Chicago. There are over 53 different languages spoken in the community. Rogers Park has always been considered a port of entry for immigrants coming to the United States. According to the 2000 Census, about 30% of the population is foreign born; 43% speak a language other than English at home. Of the 63,484 residents, 30% are African American, 32% are white, 28% are Hispanic, 6% are Asian/Pacific Islanders, and 4% are Native American or other. “In a city made famous for an accepted and often enforced cultural and socio-economic homogeneity within neighborhoods,” said the Chicago Tribune, “Rogers Park stands almost alone as an exception.” Racial & Ethnic Diversity in Rogers Park Census 2000 White/Caucasian African American Hispanic Asian/Pacific Islander Native American Other or more than one race Chicago 31.32% 36.39% 26.02% 4.33% 0.15% 1.79% Rogers Park 31.77% 29.56% 27.78% 6.47% 0.31% 4.10% 6 Physical Environment _____________________________________________________________________ The Rogers Park community is located in the northeast corner of the city of Chicago, is home to 63,400 residents, and has an area of about 1.85 square miles. Driving through the Rogers Park community reveals a neighborhood rich in cultural diversity and architectural variance. Other communities in Chicago can be described in simpler and more homogenous terms, but Rogers Park is a community of contrast and complexity. While there are no sharp borders delineating one neighborhood in Rogers Park from another, there exist communities within the community. The southern border is Devon Avenue, home to a number of Middle Eastern cultures. Devon Avenue is lined with Middle Eastern businesses which attracts visitors from all over the region. The eastern border is Lake Michigan and has a college community flavor at the southeast end of the community. The northern border is Evanston Township, just a few blocks north of Howard Street. The northern section is home to many African Americans and West Africans. The western border is Ridge Boulevard. In the western section, a large Hispanic population lives along the Clark Street corridor. Rogers Park housing stock can vary house to house and block to block. Multiunit apartment rental buildings, single family brick bungalows, condo conversions and an occasional architectural wonder often sit on the same block Photo courtesy of the Rogers Park Historical Society At the south eastern border of the community is Loyola University of Chicago, Lake Shore Campus, a private university founded in 1906 by the Jesuits. Approximately 40% of the undergraduate students are from outside Illinois. The campus has 40 building including the “Mundelein Center”, a national historic landmark which is currently under renovation. Soon the Mundelein Center will be home to a multipurpose community fine arts and theatre programming center. The University is a major local employer and the Loyola community contributes to the economic stability of the area. Lake Michigan is the entire eastern border of Rogers Park. There are public and private beaches along the lakefront. Many lakefront Chicago Parks with bike/pedestrian paths can be seen crowded with bicyclists, roller bladders, walkers and runners. Large multiunit buildings undergoing condominium conversion renovation work are evident 7 throughout Rogers Park especially near the Lake front. Other large multiunit rental buildings appear to be in advanced states of disrepair in some place. About 75% of the housing stock in Rogers Park was built before 1975. Over 75% of the housing stock is rental units; most rental unit buildings were built in the 20’s and 30’s. (www.rpcc.org) Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis The northern section of Rogers Park, upon visual inspection, has many boarded up storefront properties. Groups of young men can be seen standing on street corners. Businesses along Morse and Howard Streets include launder mats, liquor stores, currency exchanges and dollar stores. A Belizean Bakery, a Jamaican restaurant and a number of ethnic African businesses dot Howard Street too. The Gateway Mall, at the corner of Howard and Clark has about 50% occupancy and contains the only grocery store owned by a large supermarket chain in the community. Although Rogers Park’s art community is present throughout the neighborhood, a number of studios have clustered on a small side street, Glenwood Avenue. Glenwood is divided north and south by elevated train tracks, and much of the concrete embankment is painted with murals. One section still retains its original cobblestones, and combined with foliage growing on the embankment provides an atmosphere of pensive separation from the surrounding neighborhood. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis 8 The Clark Street corridor is home to a vibrant Hispanic community. Many small Hispanic businesses line Clark Street including Ayutta Bakery, Western Wear and the Clark Street Mega Mall. Rental units exist above stores along Clark Street. This area seems to be a densely populated neighborhood. Community residents who live on or along Clark Street can be seen walking with children and pushing strollers. The west end of Rogers Park has single family homes and multiunit buildings. Many Reform, Conservative and Hasidic synagogues are present in West Rogers Park. On Saturdays, entire families can be seen walking to temple together along arterial and main streets. Also located in West Rogers Park is the only factory in the community. S&C Electric, a major local employer, has been located at Ridge and Pratt for almost 100 years. Misericordia, a residential home for children and adults living with developmental disabilities has a two acre complex with dozens of buildings located at the corner of Devon and Ridge in West Rogers Park. Misericordia is a privately funded residential complex owned and operated by the Misericordia Sisters. Their mission to serve the medically complex residents is largely funded by private donations and fund raising. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Quite noticeable throughout Rogers Park is the elevated train system. The “L” connects Rogers Park to Downtown Chicago in about 40 minutes. The “L” can bring residents to surrounding suburbs and O’Hare Airport. Bus lines run up and down most major streets with a few exceptions. Ridge Avenue, the western border of the community currently has no bus service in Chicago. The two hospitals which serve most of Rogers Park are situated out of the community on Ridge Avenue in Evanston. Rogers Park has no hospital within the community. Gentrification is evident throughout Rogers Park, but the North of Howard Area is where home ownership has nearly doubled in the last ten years (from 6.84% to 11.3% of the total housing stock). According to the Rogers Park Builders Group, 1018 rental units have been converted to condominiums. This represents about 5% of the Rental housing stock. So, rental units remain the predominant form of housing stock in Rogers Park with 75% of all housing being rental units. According to Loyola University, Center for Urban Research, about 9% of all Rogers Park housing is subsidized and 12% of the rental housing units are subsidized. (www.rpcc.org) 9 Owner Occupied Renter Occupied Units Vacant Units TOTAL 1990 # units 2000 # units # Change % Change 20.14% 1990 % of Units 14.05% 2000 % of Units 17.14% 3,902 4,688 786 21,363 20,849 -514 -2.41% 76.93% 76.21% 2,505 1,821 -684 -27.31% 9.02% 6.66% 27,770 27,358 -412 -1.48 100% 100% 10 A Brief History of Rogers Park _____________________________________________________________________ Rogers Park is a community of exceptional racial and economic diversity located on Chicago’s Northeast side along the lake. The most racially diverse zip code in the United States, the 53 languages spoken in Rogers Park demonstrate the steady addition of new arrivals to the country and the many cultures now part of the fabric of the neighborhood. Photo courtesy of the Rogers Park Historical Society Rogers Park was located north of several cemeteries at the edge of the City of Chicago. A small town with its own government, it was named after one of its founding residents, Mr. Philip Rogers. Rogers Park was annexed by Chicago in 1893. An early and lasting member of the community, Loyola University got its start in 1906 when land purchased for $161.00 was given to the school. Classes at the Lakeshore campus began in 1912. In 1935 the School of Nursing was added, followed by the landmark art deco Madonna Della Strada Chapel in 1938. Modern Rogers Park came into being after World War Two, when a severe housing shortage resulted in an aggressive homebuilding program. Rogers Park and neighboring West Ridge added so many units without any overall plan that new infrastructure had to be designed to accommodate the new requirements. Rogers Park has remained a dense urban environment ever since. Though the neighborhood was always attractive to new residents, in the last thirty years Rogers Park has attracted just about every immigrant culture in Chicago. Reasons for this include good access to public transportation and the affordability of rental housing. In the late 1960s, additional demand was met by removing old mansions and replacing them with “4+1” style apartment complexes. Innovative though not especially attractive, these buildings feature garage space on the ground level and four floors of apartments above. Their appearance radically changed the character many streets, including Sheridan Road. 11 Photo courtesy of the Rogers Park Historical Society One area that has evolved without losing its essential social function is the Lakefront Park System. Always a hub for recreation, in the days prior to air conditioning hundreds if not thousands of people spent hot summer nights on the cool waterfront. A man named Sam Leone started a lifeguard program that endured long after his death and trained several generations of neighborhood lifeguards. A seminal event occurred in 1952, when the drive for housing collided with local desire to preserve beach access. In what became a template for a culture of aggressive activism in Rogers Park, neighbors discovered that land they had always believed was park space along the lake was in fact available for purchase by developers. A long struggle with the City of Chicago ensued, including hundreds of residents mailing bags of sand to the Mayor’s office and culminating in the permanent designation of thirteen beaches as parkland. The success gave rise to the Rogers Park Community Council, a group that remains active on issues such as housing and domestic violence today. Other activist groups also thrive, and in recent years new generations of activists have been using blogs to get their message out. Rogers Park has a reputation of being more liberal than much of the rest of the city, something enhanced by the media labeling Rogers Park “lakefront liberals” during the hotly contested mayoral elections of the 1980’s. Many feel that the wide variety of cultures and economic status has made Rogers Park the most tolerant community in Chicago. 12 Education _____________________________________________________________________ There are 20 early childhood/preschool programs, 4 public grammar schools, 3 private grade schools, 1 public high school, 1 private high school and one alternative high school. A private university, Loyola University of Chicago, is located in the Rogers Park community. Public Grammar Schools include Jordan, Kilmer, Gale and Armstrong. Private Grammar Schools are Chicago Waldorf, Sacred Heart and St. Margaret Mary School. The students who attend the local public grade schools generally have poor academic achievement. The standardized test scores for the students at Gale and Jordan are very low. The 2005 Illinois School Report Card indicates that only 35.1% of Gale students tested met or exceeded the state’s learning goals as measured by The Illinois Standards Achievement Test. The state average is 65%. Gale remains on the state’s “Academic Watch List”. Jordan did slightly better in 2005 with 45% of the students tested meeting or exceeding the state’s learning goals. Jordan is on the state’s “Academic Early Warning List”. 85% of the Gale School population comes from low income families, 95% of the Jordan school community live within low income family structures. Photo courtesy of the Rogers Park Historical Society Sullivan High School is the only public high school in the community. Currently there are 1100 hundred students enrolled. Last year Sullivan graduated 50% of the students who started out as freshmen and earned a diploma within five years. About 42% of the graduating seniors last year went on to College or Post Secondary education. 22% of the students met or exceeded PSAE State Standards. Students were absent an average of 28 school days per year, ranking Sullivan High School 67 out of 81 CPS High Schools in regards to attendance. 88% of the faculty is “highly qualified” teachers ranking the teaching staff 8 out of 76 Chicago High Schools. 94% of the Sullivan High School student body is from low income families. Sullivan is currently on the “Academic Watch List” after failing to meet state and federal academic expected outcomes and could be subjected to additional state sanctions. We made multiple attempts to speak with a member of the administration and members of the Local School Council to seek more information for the needs assessment and to specifically ask about adolescent health issues. We were able to interview the Nurse Practioner from Sullivan School Based Health Center. 13 Sullivan High School has had a School-Based Health Clinic for two years. Students can receive acute and preventative primary health care from 9am to 5pm daily, twelve months/year. Loyola University of Chicago boasts an enrollment of 14,764 students. Almost 40% of the undergraduate students are from outside Illinois. Loyola University offers 68 undergraduate majors. There are 77 Master’s programs, 36 Doctoral Programs and 3 professional degree programs. Undergraduate tuition is $26, 000/year. Loyola University of Chicago has 120,000 alumni, 80,000 reside in Chicago. Lakeshore campus, in Rogers Park, has 3000 students living on or around the campus. 14 Safety _____________________________________________________________________ Personal and public safety overlaps with community health in many ways. Injury prevention is one example of how community health education from health care providers working in the community can directly impact safety. Health education about car seat safety and window fall prevention provided to parents at well child visits helps children living in the community be at less risk for preventable injuries (see specific data related to pediatric injuries in Rogers Park in the Health Status section). Health education related to fire safety, gun safety, poison prevention, bike safety and water safety are also important health/safety topics in terms of community health education efforts. The most widespread form of violence against women is carried out by a husband or boyfriend. Domestic violence has been linked to many long term physical, emotional and psychological problems. Women are at a greater risk of abuse during pregnancy. Family and domestic violence is often first assessed by health care providers trained to recognize the physical and psychological signs of abuse. In fact, a recent study demonstrated that 37% of battered women admitted abuse to their health care provider, (National Coalition against Domestic Violence). Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis In addition, “there is an ever increasing body of research showing that young children who are exposed to violence in their homes and/or communities often experience significant psychological and behavioral challenges as a result of their exposure to violence” (Chicago Safe Start). One of the goals for a new clinic in the community could be to implement a formalized and coordinated response for initial intervention and referral for children and women exposed to violence or who may be victims of family violence. Another important goal for a community health clinic would be to implement an early violence prevention community health education project. Violence is a learned behavior which can be prevented with early violence prevention education within the community to parents and other adults who surround children. Problem solving skills, dealing with 15 frustration in a constructive manner and anger management are skills that can be taught at the community level to very young children. For children to feel safe, they need to be protected from violence in their environments, whether on TV or in the neighborhood (Adults and Children Together against Violence). Community Crime Data The 24th police district encompasses a few communities including Rogers Park. There are nine police beats in the 24th District, five of which include Rogers Park. Rogers Park Beats include 2422, 2423, 2424, 2431, and 2432. Below is a chart of the most frequently occurring crimes by Beat: Crime Domestic battery, simple Simple battery Criminal damage to vehicle Theft $300 and under Narcotics possession: Cannabis less than 30 grams Theft from building Criminal damage to property Simple assault 2422 138 108 69 67 94 2423 80 71 93 72 55 2424 79 79 69 56 74 2431 61 54 32 51 30 2432 98 131 82 90 62 Total 456 443 345 336 315 71 66 61 58 69 44 50 54 36 41 35 38 82 73 67 302 297 246 Year to Date figures as of Oct. 2, 2006 from www.chicagocrime.org Of note, the Chicago Police Department’s 2004 Report on Hate Crimes identified Rogers Park as having the greatest number of reported hate crimes (11) in Chicago. See Exhibit 13, Reported Hate Crimes by Police District and Classification, 2004 in the Appendix. 16 Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis CAPS Chicago Alternative Policing Strategy (CAPS) is a partnership between police and the community, and is considered the foundation of Chicago’s own philosophy of community policing. CAPS brings together the police, the community and other City Agencies to identify and solve neighborhood crime problems. It is a proactive approach to policing rather than a reactive approach to after the fact crime. Specific strategies include: • Neighborhood based beat officers • Regular Beat meetings involving the police and residents • Extensive training for both police and the community • More efficient use of City Services that impact crime • New Technology to help police and residents target crime hot spots. CAPS was initiated in 1993 using five of the city’s 25 police districts as prototypes. Rogers Park was one of the five designated prototype districts. CAPS partnerships have tackled not only serious crime problems, but also those neighborhood conditions which breed crime such as abandoned buildings and vehicles, vacant lots, drug houses and graffiti (Chicago Police Department, “How CAPS works”, http://www.egov.cityofchicago/webportal). 17 Politics and Government _____________________________________________________________________ Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis On the municipal level, Rogers Park is served by three different members of the Chicago City Council. The majority of the neighborhood falls within the 49th ward, which is represented by Alderman Joseph Moore. The western parts of the neighborhood are included in the 50th ward, represented by Alderman Bernie Stone. The southwestern edge of Rogers Park is served by 40th ward Alderman Patrick O’Connor. The City Council is the legislative body of the city of Chicago. It has 19 standing committees, including one on Health. The City Council approves the annual city-wide budget proposed by Mayor Richard M. Daley. This includes funding for the City’s Department of Public Health. Commissioner Larry Suffredin Rogers Park is included in the 13th District of the Cook County Board of Commissioners. The Cook County government sets policy that controls the funding for public health services as administered by the Cook County Department of Public Health, including the hospital system. 13th District Commissioner Larry Suffredin has been a leader in the effort to bring affordable health care to Rogers Park. 18 Rogers Park is represented in the Illinois General Assembly by 7th District Senator Carol Ronen, 9th District Senator Jeffrey Schoenberg, 14th District Representative Harry Osterman, and the 18th District Representative Julie Hamos. All have been active in sponsoring health-related legislation. In the 2006 session, the Assembly approved Governor Rod Blagojevich’s All Kids program that makes all children eligible for health care coverage in the state of Illinois. In the United States Congress, Rogers Park is served by 9th Congressional District Representative Jan Schakowsky and Senators Richard Durbin and Barack Obama. These representatives vote on legislation that affects the funding of the federal health programs such as Medicare, Medicaid and the Veteran’s Administration hospital system. 19 Communication _____________________________________________________________________ With approximately 53 different languages spoken in the Rogers Park community, and 43% of the community stating they speak a language other than English at home (2000 Census); communication or the exchange of thoughts and information by speech, writing or signs can be difficult. If you ask ten people living in Rogers Park how best to communicate, you may well receive ten different answers. About a year ago, the Consortium to Lower Obesity in Chicago Children (CLOCC) held a series of focus groups in Rogers Park to examine how best to communicate and share information. The results from the focus group study indicated informal communication methods are what work in Rogers Park. “Word of mouth”, organization newsletters, church bulletins, blog sites, web sites, school “communication” folders, community bulletin boards, flyers on storefront windows are a few examples. There seems to be no one central way to communicate information in Rogers Park and information needs to be translated into many different languages. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Health Literacy and its Barriers to Health Health literacy has been defined as the degree to which individuals have the capacity to obtain process and understand basic health information and services in order to make appropriate health decisions (Healthy People 2010). Health literacy has long been a concern among health care providers in Rogers Park. Barriers to care naturally exist when a health care provider cannot speak a common language with a patient or when a patient is unable to read. According to the Institute of Medicine, nearly half of all Americans have difficulty understanding and using health information, and there is a higher rate of hospitalization and Emergency Room use among patients with limited health literacy. Limited health literacy leads to billions of dollars in avoidable health care costs. One research study done in a public hospital found that one-third of the English speaking patients could not read basic health information. More than a quarter of the participants could not read an appointment card and 42% could not understand labels on prescription bottles. The US Surgeon General has highlighted health literacy needs and has stated “ 20 the ability to access, understand and use health related information and services is critical to the success of 1) improving emergency preparedness 2) eliminating health disparities and 3)preventing disease” (Office of the Surgeon General www.surgeongeneral.gov). Health literacy barriers can be addressed at the community level. Health literacy curriculums need to be incorporated into kindergarten through 12th grade classes in all grade schools, in adult education classes, and other community programming. Community health outreach programs train people who are community members to work in the community to promote health awareness. Such efforts must be sensitive to cultural and language preferences. Howard Area Community Center has had a community health outreach program in place for about ten years. Local Media Besides the two Chicago daily newspapers, the Chicago Tribune and the Chicago Suntimes, Rogers Park residents also read the News Star, the Chicago Reader and the Chicago Defender newspapers. The Chicago Reader, founded in 1971, is “widely recognized as one of the leading alternative weeklies in the United States. It specializes in features rather than news, with an emphasis on urban issues and politics, arts and culture, and the literary journalism that seeks to capture the spirit of contemporary city life”. The Chicago Defender, founded in 1905, “has been the voice of the African-American community in Chicago and across the United States”. Newspapers published in Spanish, read locally, are Hoy and La Raza. The ChiTown Daily News is an online news publication. The Gay Chicago Magazine has a following in Rogers Park. Rogers Park 2000 is a free community newspaper published quarterly designed to increase awareness about community issues and resources. The newspaper is distributed to over 10,000 households and is available in 50 local businesses and organizations. Regular columns highlight Rogers Park restaurants, give updates on governmental issues, Loyola University and publish stories about local businesses. Stories are written by volunteer journalists. The Loyola Phoenix is Loyola University of Chicago’s student newspaper. It is published weekly during Fall and Spring semesters. WLUW is an independent community radio station serving Chicago and the northern suburbs. It is a “listener supported” station located on 88.7 FM band. WLUW programming has an alternative radio format with community, genre, news and specialty shows. The station broadcasts on Loyola University’s campus, but is financially independent from the university. There are many blog sites in cyberspace originating from Rogers Park. Two of the most popular blogs are the “Morse Hellhole” and “24/7 North of Howard”. 21 Health and Social Services _____________________________________________________________________ Photo courtesy of the Rogers Park Historical Society Health Services There are currently two primary care clinics, Evanston-Rogers Park Access Family Health Center (ERP) and St. Francis Community Clinic, a not for profit clinic owned by the Resurrection Health Care System, in Rogers Park. A School Based Health Center (SBHC) is operating out of Sullivan High School by the Access Community Health Network also. Evanston-Rogers Park Access Family Health Center (ERP) is the only FQHC in Rogers Park. ERP is one of 46 health centers run by the Access Community Health Network, the largest private community health center organization in Chicago. Over 200,000 patients are served by the network annually. ERP has a mission to provide “high quality, cost effective, safe, comprehensive primary and preventative health care in underserved Chicago land communities”. HIV services, pain management services, prenatal care and primary care are services offered. Fees are based on a sliding scale determined by income. Discounted pharmaceutical programs are available (Access Community Health Network). Sullivan High School Health Center is a school based health center run by the Access Community Health Network. The Sullivan SBHC is located in Sullivan High school and is a full-service health center for students of Sullivan High School. Saint Francis Community Health Center located at 7464 N. Clark Street opened in 1986 to serve the pediatric population in the Rogers Park area. The clinic’s services have now been expanded to offer prenatal care, pediatric and adult medicine. Women with pregnancies complicated by gestational diabetes can receive care at the clinic too. Health promotion activities are provided by the clinic to the community. Examples of these activities include nutrition, baby care, car safety and parenting classes. Disease management programs for adults with diabetes, asthma and hypertension are offered. 22 Medicaid, Medicare, and private insurance are accepted. St. Francis Clinic has a charity care program in place for patients and families without health insurance coverage or any other means of payment. St. Francis Clinic has no discounted pharmaceutical programs (Resurrection Health Care, Community Clinics) St. Francis Clinic provided 13,003 visits last year (2005). This number is down slightly from previous years due to the retirement of three primary care staff physicians (Conversation with the Clinic Manager). Pediatric visits … 4415 Internal Medicine visits … 4095 Postpartum visits … 271 Prenatal visits … 2292 Labs … 1930 There are about ten private practice physicians in the community who accept Medicaid, Medicare and other forms of private insurance. 23 Medically Underserved Population (MUP), Medically Underserved Area (MUA), and Health Professionals Shortage Area (HPSA) Designations. Rogers Park has been designated a Medically Underserved Population, a Medically Underserved Area and a Health Professional Shortage Area. The definitions of these terms are as follows: MUA/P Legend Label Outline Color Fill Color Fill Style Governor Backward diagonal lines Medically Underserved Area Forward diagonal lines Medically Underserved Population Horizontal lines MUA/P Labels are Underlined 24 HPSA Legend Label Outline Color Fill Color Fill Style Geographical Area Horizontal lines Population Group Horizontal lines Single County Crossing lines HPSA Labels are in ITALICS Social Services Howard Area Community Center (HACC) is a multi-service, community based agency serving low-income residents of Rogers Park. HACC provides comprehensive social services, operates an Alternative High School, a Family Center Campus which includes a child care center for 124 children 6 weeks through 5 years old, an Intensive Home Visiting Program for families with children Zero – 3 years old, a Education and Employment Program and Youth Programs. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Rogers Park Community Council (RPCC) is an organization created in 1952 to “improve the quality of life in the neighborhood through civic and educational purposes that foster health and welfare, urban renewal, law enforcement and community organization”. Community – based services include a Housing Action Program, Victim Advocacy and Support Program, a Senior Intervention Program, the Rogers Park Youth Network, a Community Awareness and Pride Program and a community newspaper, the “Rogers Park 2000.” Family Matters is a “family-centered organization in the North of Howard Area that seeks to be a catalyst for change- building and strengthening the community through programs that support personal growth and change”. After school programs, teen programs, parent programs, community organizing, and a community tutoring program are some of the services offered through Family Matters. 25 Jewish Child and Family Services (JCFS) is located in West Rogers Park but serves many East Rogers Park residents. They offer Family Counseling, Individual Therapy and Child Therapy. JCFS operates a therapeutic day school for children K-12, Preschool aged Speech, Occupational and Developmental Therapy, Special Education, Respite Care and Adoption services. JCFS operates the Virginia Frank Child Developmental Center offering services to families with children Zero-6 years old including a therapeutic nursery, drop-in groups, a Family Life Parenting Series and other human services. Misericordia is a home to 550 children and adults with mild to profound developmental disabilities from all racial, religious and socio-economic backgrounds, Misericordia’s services include residential placement and day to day support, job training and employment opportunities, physical, occupational and speech therapy, fitness and healthy living guidance, social and recreational outings and opportunities for spiritual growth. Misericordia is operated by the Sisters of Mercy under the auspices of the Catholic Bishop of Chicago. 26 Economics _____________________________________________________________________ Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis The median income for Rogers Park is $35,622. Although, the City of Chicago experienced a decline in the numbers of people living in poverty, the Rogers Park community has experienced a steady increase in the numbers of person’s living in poverty since the 1970’s (see poverty table under “health report”). The 2000 Census states that 21.3% of the residents in Rogers Park were living in poverty and nearly 34% of the residents living in the North of Howard Area neighborhood of Rogers Park were living below poverty level. 20% of all households in Rogers Park had annual incomes below $15,000. Profile of Selected Economic Characteristics Rogers Park – Estimates and Projections Change Subject EMPLOYMENT STATUS Employed, Total (Pop 16+) Employed, Males (Pop 16+) Employed, Females (Pop 16+) Change 2005 Est. (2000 - 05) 2010 Proj. (2005 - 10) Number Percentage Number Percentage 31,940 3.4 32,919 3.1 17,313 3.4 17,727 2.4 14,627 3.3 15,192 3.9 Unemployed, Male 1,250 -16.4 1,157 -7.4 Unemployed, Female Not in the Labor Force Male (Pop 16+) Not in the Labor Force Female (Pop 16+) 1,227 -5.4 1,236 0.7 7,636 9.5 8,268 8.3 9,380 2.6 9,530 1.6 Employment (Pop 16+) 27 Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting, and Mining 30 -11.8 23 Construction 1,305 12.1 1,371 5.1 Manufacturing 2,702 -13 2,370 -12.3 609 -8.3 555 -8.9 Retail Trade Transportation and Warehousing, and Utilities (Pop 16+) 2,534 -14.6 2,091 -17.5 1,608 6 1,693 5.3 Information Finance, insurance, real estate, and rental and leasing Professional, Scientific, Management, Administrative, etc. Educational, Health and Social Services Arts, entertainment,recreation, accommodation and food services 1,096 -0.2 1,174 7.1 2,350 0.4 2,324 -1.1 4,293 10.7 4,715 9.8 7,716 9.7 8,379 8.6 4,759 9.8 5,124 7.7 Other Services (Pop 16+) 2,129 9.3 2,307 8.4 809 -1 793 -2 57 3.6 57 0 Management, Business, and Financial Operations 3,681 6.7 3,920 6.5 Professional and Related 7,553 6.8 8,106 7.3 Service 7,105 3.9 7,444 4.8 Sales and Office Farming, Fishing, and Forestry Construction, Extraction, and Maintenance Production, Transportation, and Material Moving 7,672 0.5 7,571 -1.3 5 -28.6 3 -40 1,669 1.9 1,611 -3.5 4,255 -0.1 4,264 0.2 4,239 5.8 4,536 7 1,787 0.3 1,812 1.4 629 0.6 636 1.1 581 -6 546 -6 1,341 1.1 1,348 0.5 Less than $15,000 5,882 1.2 4,959 -15.7 $15,000 to $24,999 4,002 0.6 3,358 -16.1 $25,000 to $34,999 4,330 -1.9 3,427 -20.9 $35,000 to $49,999 4,726 3.9 5,103 8 $50,000 to $74,999 3,982 7.1 4,962 24.6 Wholesale Trade Public administration Unpaid Family Workers -23.3 Occupation (Pop 16+) CLASS OF WORKER Private Not-for-Profit Wage and Salary Workers Local Government Workers State Government Workers Federal Government Workers Self-Employed Workers in Own Not Incorporated Business Household INCOME 28 $75,000 to $99,999 1,673 20.5 2,821 68.6 $100,000 to $124,999 893 13.2 1,351 51.3 $125,000 to $149,999 434 29.6 804 85.3 $150,000 to $199,999 324 11.3 351 8.3 $200,000 or more Median Household Income 323 23.8 514 59.1 33,026 3.7 41,008 24.2 Less than $15,000 2,111 -4.9 1,766 -16.3 $15,000 to $24,999 1,645 -6.4 1,300 -21 $25,000 to $34,999 1,884 -7.6 1,409 -25.2 $35,000 to $49,999 2,264 4.9 2,365 4.5 $50,000 to $74,999 2,292 8.4 2,551 11.3 $75,000 to $99,999 Family INCOME 1,158 29.4 1,736 49.9 $100,000 to $124,999 668 16.6 940 40.7 $125,000 to $149,999 339 41.3 600 77 $150,000 to $199,999 242 19.2 234 -3.3 $200,000 or more 261 29.9 392 50.2 53,001 9.7 65,430 23.5 Median Family Income Data Source: Aggregated From EASI Data Set (MCIC) 29 Recreation in Rogers Park _____________________________________________________________________ Recreation in Rogers Park centers on playgrounds, parks and a lakefront park system as well as an arts community that primarily works out of small studios. Also, there are many small bars and taverns that cater to the tastes of the diverse population. Rogers Park has an exceptionally vibrant arts community, and is known as a hub for writers. Individual craftspeople in small studios create everything from paintings and sculpture to performance art and music. Some studios become galleries several times a year as artists show and sell their work, much of it at prices affordable to the community. Several organized annual events link studios together for arts fests and studio walks, and many artists also teach classes in various media or work at local parks. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Nightlife Entertainment venues in Rogers Park include several theaters, a small movie theater, bars and some restaurants. Concerns about street crime are often cited as challenges to attracting more such business, and many people in Rogers Park either have been victims of some sort of crime or know someone that has. This has a chilling effect on physical activity for some who see themselves as vulnerable, and safety concerns are often expressed by local teens. People who choose to walk home after drinking at bars are especially vulnerable to assaults, many of which go unreported. Also, the severe shortage of parking forces people returning from work late at night to walk significant distances, usually alone. 30 Lakefront Park System The lakefront park system is secured by a “Lakefront Protection Ordinance”, which was enacted to prevent high rise development and other uses that might deprive the neighborhood’s residents of access to the lake. Roger’s Park’s lakefront park system differs significantly from much of the rest of Chicago’s lakefront. Planner Daniel Burnham foresaw an accessible lake frontage kept for use by all of the city’s residents, but his work did not directly address Rogers Park. Included in Rogers Park’s annexation by Chicago was the transfer of land along the lakefront that had not been designated as park space. The majority of that space later became parkland. Lake Shore Drive, a well known stretch of urban expressway turns away from the lakefront just south of Rogers Park, becoming Sheridan Road. Sheridan moves through Rogers Park approximately one block west of Lake Michigan, with homes, apartment buildings, and beaches to the east. One of the major priorities of neighborhood activists has been preserving beachfront from development of marinas, and as well as from rumored ambitious and cost prohibitive Lake Shore Drive extensions. Such proposals remain a political lightning rod during election year debates. Washrooms and Sanitation Washroom facilities at the lakefront are limited to the Loyola Park field house and a 1000 square foot free standing brick structure located about one block to the south. The lack of other facilities is a sanitation concern during summer. Swimmers report relieving themselves in the water, and trees and bushes are frequently used as well. Some people cite lack of adequate sanitary facilities as a discouraging factor in planning to use park facilities. Other nearby public restroom facilities are scarce and limited to businesses who allow use by non-customers. Many of these businesses are closed in the evenings and it is not uncommon to see homeless or intoxicated individuals using alleys for these purposes. Homelessness in Rogers Park Rogers Park has a noticeable Homeless population, many of whom spend days and often nights in the parks. Lakefront parks, because of their spaciousness and lack of foot traffic at night are especially popular destinations. Community response, especially among homeowners who live close to the parks has moved from quiet tolerance to indignation and calls by some for ending the nighttime Homeless presence. Several people report incidents of nuisance behavior, such as public urination and intoxication, as well as threats that are usually connected to some discourse regarding behavior. Police response to complaints has been to periodically attempt to empty the parks at night. However, Police have said repeatedly that their options are severely limited in terms of effective sanctions to permanently deter homelessness. Police and others have suggested a focused outreach effort in the summer months (when shelters are closed) to connect Homeless with resources and mental health assistance. Repeated arrests and citations for trespassing and nuisance crimes have almost no effect on behavior and use significant police resources, especially if Homeless are detained. 31 Interviews with several homeless individuals make clear that a significant mental health component is needed to achieve significant results in terms of placement. Even more critical is the development of a comprehensive plan to deal with the multifaceted challenges that define persistent homelessness in Rogers Park. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Boating In summer the horizon is typically filled with sailboats, powerboats and jet skis with a smattering of windsailers and kayakers. The nearest boat launch facility is at Diversey Harbor, approximately four miles to the south. Although several proposals for expanded harbor facilities have been made by various entities, vigorous opposition from the community has effectively prevented their completion. Fishing A small but dedicated culture of anglers makes regular use of piers and shores, particularly Pratt Pier. The 6th largest lake in the world, Lake Michigan is a freshwater lake. Around 21 million pounds of fish are harvested from the lake annually, with only a small portion caught by anglers fishing from the shore. Species of fish include Rainbow and Lake Trout, Large and Smallmouth Bass, Carp, Lake Whitefish, Coho Salmon, Yellow Perch, Channel Catfish, and Pike. One imported fish that has thrived since its introduction is the smelt. Others that are active threats to existing ecology are the Asian Carp, Snakefish, and Zebra Mussel. Fish caught from Lake Michigan are considered by the EPA to be safe to eat in limited amounts. The chief concern is methyl mercury and PCB contaminants in larger fish and particularly among frequent consumers. Pregnant women, nursing mothers and children are advised to avoid eating large predator fish, though how well publicized these hazards are isn’t clear, especially among non-English speaking communities. Bicycling Bicycling along the lakefront in Rogers Park is difficult because the trail system is not clearly defined, nor is it continuous. Instead a series of paved segments along the larger 32 beaches terminate frequently and force riders to detour as far west as Sheridan Road. Sheridan has no bike lanes, and is considered hazardous by many riders. Frequently bicycles travel on sidewalks. This is not legal and sometimes draws criticism for safety reasons at local Community Policing meetings. The usual result is a few tickets being written to adults (juveniles can’t be ticketed by Chicago Police). A significant hazard are riders on side walks bordered by buildings on one side and small parkway fences meant to protect grass on the other. Riders often have difficulty avoiding pedestrians emerging from buildings, who fail to see them coming. Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Beaches There are about ten named beaches, varying in size and joined by other water access points that are either not technically beaches or are privately held. About 16 percent of the waterfront is not public property. Access to those points is at the discretion of the owners and varies. For example, one condominium building restricts access almost completely while Loyola University grants access very liberally. Swimming The Park District allows swimming from late May until early September. The beaches are served by a lifeguard corps based at Pratt Beach. Guarded beaches are staffed between the hours of 9:00 A.M. and 9:30 P.M., and during those hours swimmers are required to remain within areas determined by the guards as manageable. Lifeguards use a fleet of rowboats to observe swimmers, limiting their activity to within about thirty- five feet of the shoreline. This is an extremely unpopular arrangement among accomplished swimmers, who desire a deep water swimming option similar to one maintained downtown. Emergency Services Incidents of distress or potential drowning trigger a highly organized response by the Chicago Fire Department, the Chicago Police, and most of the Pratt Beach Life Guard team. Neighbors often assist when needed. Resources include Dive Teams, Fire and Police Boats, and Fire Department helicopters. 33 In several observed incidents in 2006 the response was well coordinated and significant assets deployed very quickly, allowing First Responders to resolve emergencies rapidly. There is also HH65A Helicopter stationed over the summer at a Waukegan helipad that can be dispatched when needed. Water Quality Water quality on the beaches is an ongoing and serious concern. When beaches are open the Park District conducts water tests daily. However, because of the testing requirements results are not known until the following day. Beach closings for contamination are a regular occurrence, but are done one day following the test that determines the safety of the water. Conditions can change substantially in the interval. Swimmers report mysterious rashes sometimes appear after being in the lake, but no comprehensive record of such incidents in Rogers Park is known to exist. Causes of contamination are often debated, with Chicago city officials blaming places like Milwaukee, WI for pollution. Though no permanent streams discharge into Lake Michigan from Illinois’ 63 miles of coastline, one potential local source of pollutants is the overflow of storm water following major storms. The Chicago Metropolitan Water Reclamation District has invested heavily in an alternative drainage system, the “Deep Tunnel” project. This network of tunnels some three hundred feet below ground was designed to absorb the overflow from such storms. In recent years the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District has also significantly upgraded its notification process when it diverts overflow into local waterways. Another potential contaminant source is damage to antiquated sewage pipes that collapse underground and divert waste undetected into the lake, as recently happened in another area of the city. It is highly unlikely that local industry is directly dumping pollutants, as no company in Rogers Park capable of producing such waste has facilities on the lake. Loyola Park The largest park in the lakefront park system is Loyola Park, a “Large Urban Park” which occupies about six square blocks beginning three blocks north of Loyola University. Loyola Park has a large field house which houses a gymnasium and other facilities. These include a woodshop, a weaving room complete with looms, and a 400 square foot room that features a stage. There is also a 700 square foot “Sky Room” which is used for larger gatherings and yoga classes. (Current enrollment in the free yoga program tops one hundred.) Activities at the field house are maximized and a variety of programming is underway throughout most of the day and evening. The basketball program was recently extended to an earlier starting date as well as a later end date. A referee program was also added, a program with the secondary benefit of giving youth the tools to resolve disputes in unsupervised games away from the park. There are also baseball, day camp, and numerous after- school programs. These programs include weightlifting, boxing, wrestling, aerobics, self defense, girl’s fitness, dance, gymnastics, textiles, and arts and crafts. Also offered are early childhood recreation and gymnastics, as well as Special Olympic and special needs recreation. There is also a woodshop used by community members. There are some partnerships in place with outside entities. A theater group is expanding a program of theater performing and creative writing to include kids between 8 and 12 years of age. 34 Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Outdoor Areas: The entire outdoor area of Loyola Park is managed by the park supervisor, although she is often at the mercy of various Park District Departments for things like garbage pick ups and facility repairs. In the park area garbage collection was observed to be very swift, even on especially high volume days such as the fifth of July when refuse far exceeded the capacity of collection points. Outdoor facilities include basketball and tennis courts. There are also baseball diamonds and a playground. There are large sidewalks that accommodate both bicycles and pedestrians and allow access for emergency vehicles in much of the park. Less reliable are the repair services, as several damaged park benches and damaged exercise equipment have lingered for months unattended. The beaches are cleaned and raked by a tractor every morning, and although broken glass in the sand remains an unseen hazard the beaches look pristine each day at sunrise, which are dramatic enough to bring people out at early hours. The fields are primarily grasses, mowed on a regular basis. Trees sporadically dot the landscape and are most dense close to the apartment and condominium buildings that line the west side of the park. Significant bare spots occur where use is especially heavy, as in the open spaces where soccer is often played by informal large teams. There are also significant ruts from tires of police and park service vehicles. 35 Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Dog Walking: Off-leash dog walking is not permitted, but is generally accepted during off hours and colder months. It is common to see upwards of twenty dogs playing together in the early morning hours on some beaches. Although sanitary reasons (related to concerns about cryptosporidium, and others) are often cited for not allowing dogs on beaches during the day, the great majority of owners pick up after their animals and the City of Chicago has recently begun using small dogs to chase birds from other beaches. During the day, dogs are not allowed on any part of the sand, making travel along the shoreline impossible for dog owners, who are forced to detour to Sheridan Road to complete their journey. Lifeguards are used to enforce this rule. Parking: Most of the parking close to the Field House is metered. Also, some side streets near the beaches reserve parking “for residents only” at certain hours of the day. Parking availability is inadequate on busy weekends in summer, and frequent traffic jams occur at the ends of some small streets that dead end at the lakefront. Inadequate parking is an issue in many other areas of Rogers Park as well. Issuance of Parking Citations appears to be the primary means of controlling the situation, something many residents find annoying and financially burdensome. Grasslands: A conservation area exists at the shoreline devoted to preservation of pre-settlement grassland and other plant life. Access is voluntarily restricted, with a four foot wire fence surrounding the preserve and an opening with a sign explaining its use and the activities allowed within the area. The preserve is maintained by volunteers in three scheduled visits per year. Heartland-on-the-Lake Stand: Food for sale at the lake is limited to a small food stand operated by a local restaurant. Its fare is consistent with the health conscious offerings of the main restaurant, which is located two blocks away. The close proximity allows a pretty consistent stocking arrangement and some flexibility of staffing. It operates only in summer. There are also ice cream and elotes push carts operated by private citizens. 36 Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Artists of the wall: A concrete retaining wall poured into a bench configuration extends about 200 feet along one of the beaches. It is sandblasted clean each spring and a contest is held among local artists who each pay a small fee to paint a four foot section of the wall. There are no limits on design outside of profanity and gang symbols. The result is a variegated edifice with images that range from small children’s handprints to discussions of political topics. The event is an annual tradition and extends for two days. Other Parks Pottawattamie Park: Pottawattomie Park, located in the Rogers Park neighborhood, offers baseball, basketball, bridge club, dance, floor hockey, soccer, step aerobics, track & field, tumbling, a teen club, volleyball, Black History Month celebrations, holiday parties and special events for Chicago Public School non-attendance days. Pottawatomie Park also sponsors Park Kids, Park Voyagers, and Camp 3-D programs. The Park Kids after-school program gives kids with working parents a supervised place to learn new sports and music, do arts & crafts, have a quiet area for homework, and gain socialization skills. The Park Voyagers program, a collaboration with Museums in the Parks, introduces families to museums. Camp 3-D is a sports and arts camp available at the end of summer, after standard day camps conclude. About nine acres, the park is comprised of three baseball fields, a combination footballsoccer field, four basketball standards, two tennis courts, two playgrounds including a spray pool. The air-conditioned field house contains a fitness center, racquetball court, gymnasium, kitchen, and four club rooms. Touhy Park: Touhy Park covers about six acres, with two softball fields, a football field, two tennis courts, and two playgrounds. A small field house allows children to participate in a number of activities. Weekly programming focuses on early childhood recreation (18 months-5 years) during the morning hours. After school programming for ages 7-12 offers a variety of sports, such as flag football, floor hockey and wrestling, and fun dancing and crafts activities. Planning for new programming is currently underway. 37 The park’s playground has a sandbox and there are four outdoor basketball courts and a volleyball court. Paschen Park: During the school year, Paschen Park offers an after-school program for ages 6-12 that combines drama, arts & crafts, gymnastics, sports, game room and homework hour. Computers are available to participants. Cultural programs at Paschen Park include arts and crafts, play production and dance such as hip-hop, tap, and jazz. There is also track and field, floor hockey, recreational tumbling, co-recreational volleyball, and basketball and summer day camp. Berger Park: Berger Park is a Lakefront location at the south edge of the neighborhood, somewhat isolated by Loyola University’s campus and a curve of Sheridan Road. A new playground was erected in 2005, and the facilities include an old home that is rented to the community for events, though some residents consider rates excessive. Berger is very well maintained and is a popular reception facility. Berger offers acting classes, bridge, various exercise classes, music, jewelry, dance, pottery, computer use, writing, and yoga. Warren Park: Warren Park lies at the western edge of Rogers Park, and is spread over more than eighty nine acres. Its many amenities include batting cages and a nine-hole golf course. A skate park with features such as quarter pipes and street spines offer a quality alternative to parking lots and streets. Winter sports include a skating rink and a sled hill. Warren also offers drum and photography classes, and team sports such as volleyball and basketball. Warren is less focused on crafts than other parks, and is an unusual opportunity to play golf in an urban setting. There are also nearly two miles of walking trails around the golf course. Other facilities: In addition to centers for programmed activities, the Chicago Park District maintains nine play lots, ten named beaches, and two “open space” parks. There is also a Chicago Public Library, and Loyola University allows some access to its library facilities. 38 Photo courtesy of Tom Mannis Health Status _____________________________________________________________________ Community Health is more than the absence of illness and disease. A community’s health can be best measured by its physical, mental and social wellness. There are certain quality of life indicators that can help us to predict how well the community is (access to early prenatal care for instance). For Rogers Park to be truly a well community, efforts need to be made to promote health, prevent illness/disease, reduce risks for injury and environmental hazards, and most of all, to remove barriers to care so that every individual may have access to primary, preventative care and medications. Maternal and Infant Statistics While Chicago experienced a 43% drop in the rate of women receiving no prenatal care over the 10 year period from 1993 to 2003, Rogers Park almost doubled its rate, with an 81% increase in the rate of women receiving no prenatal care. Out of 77 Chicago community areas, Rogers Park had the 10th highest rate of women receiving no prenatal care. Many women do not receive care until their third trimester, when the benefit of prenatal care is greatly reduced. Women who do not receive adequate early prenatal care are more likely to give birth to low birth-weight babies. This trend was accompanied by a 22% increase in the number of foreign born residents living in Rogers Park, with 43% of the households speaking a language other than English at home (Census 2000). There has been a steady increase in the number of births to teenage mothers in Rogers Park. According to the Chicago Department of Public Health, it has nearly doubled during the past decade. 39 Mortality Mortality is defined as the relative frequency of deaths in a specific population. Rogers Park ranks in the top ten percent of Chicago’s community areas for deaths from preventable respiratory diseases. The community ranks third in deaths from influenza and pneumonia and eighth in its rate of deaths from Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). Chicago’s leading causes of death in 2003 were heart disease, cancer, stroke, accidents, and diabetes. Rogers Park ranks in the top 25% of Chicago’s community areas for deaths from cancer, and even higher for lung cancer, ranking 14th out of 77 community areas. Mortality rates also show Rogers Park to rank in the top third of Chicago’s community areas for deaths rates from heart disease (22nd out of 77 areas), diabetes (28th out of 77 areas), and chronic liver disease and cirrhosis (22nd out of 77 areas). All rankings were based on age-adjusted rates which are not influenced by the age distribution of individual community areas. Morbidity Morbidity is defined as the proportion of sickness related to a specific disease in a geographical locality. Rogers Park’s rates of sexually transmitted infections (STI’s) are high relative to other areas of Chicago. Rogers Park has the 7th highest rate of syphilis and ranks 13th in its rate of AIDS cases. The community falls in the top quarter of Chicago areas for deaths from HIV with a ranking of 19 out of 77 community areas. Rogers Park ranks in the top half (34th out of 77 areas) for rates of gonorrhea and Chlamydia, the leading bacterial STI’s. Although the number of newly diagnosed tuberculosis cases in Chicago is at an all-time low, Rogers Park ranks in the top half (34th out of 77 community areas) for TB cases. Chicago has one of highest lead poisoning rates in the U.S. Rogers Park ranks in the top half (36th out of 77 community areas) for children with elevated lead screenings. Childhood Obesity Chicago’s kindergarten-aged children have a rate of obesity that is double the national average. Children living in Chicago’s predominantly minority neighborhoods are overweight at three to four times the national average. The Consortium to Lower Obesity in Chicago Children (CLOCC) selected Rogers Park as one of six community areas for program development and implementation aimed at addressing the problem of childhood obesity in those communities with a high prevalence of the problem. Pediatric Asthma Asthma morbidity has been found to be especially sensitive to poverty. It is estimated that 21.4% of the Rogers park population live below poverty level (2000 Census). This number has been creeping upward since 1970. The percentage of the Rogers Park population living below poverty level in 1970 = 8.1%, 1980 = 15.8%, 1990 = 18.5%, 2000 = 21.3. 40 At Jordan Elementary School in Rogers Park, 95% of the students are from low income families. Gale Elementary School in Rogers Park has 85% of the student population coming from low income families. The state average is 39% (Greatschools.net). Asthma Among Medicaid Recipients in Zip Code 60626 Percentage of Patients with Appropriate Kids Medication Use Adults Kids Percentage of Recipients with Regular Physician Visits Adults Kids Hospitalization Rate of Medicaid Recipients by Zip Code (per 1000) Adults 46.22 43.22 54.44 61.05 109.24 110.17 Source: The University of Chicago Asthma Center Among Medicaid recipients in the community with asthma, only an estimated 47% of the children demonstrated appropriate asthma medication use, 55% of the children regularly visited a physician for asthma treatment or follow up, and the hospitalization rate for asthma of these same children was 109.24/1000 (U of C, 2004). The Illinois asthma morbidity rate was 0.8 per 100,000 children, ranking it higher than the national average of 0.3 per 100,000 children (CDC, 2002). The asthma hospitalization rate for all of Chicago is nearly double the national average (Defeating Asthma in Chicago, 2005). Hospitalization rates due to asthma for Medicaid recipient children ages 3 to 17 are even higher for the two zip codes in Rogers Park. The 60626 zip code has 74% greater incidence than the national average during 1998-1999. The 60645 zip code was 70% higher than the national average during the same time period (Chicago Asthma Atlas & CDC). Child and Adolescent Injuries According to The Child Health Data Lab at Children’s Memorial Research Center, the total hospitalization rate for unintentional injuries for Rogers Park children is 281.2 (rate/100,000). The city of Chicago rate is 186.7. For intentional injuries, the city’s rate is about 45.4, whereas Rogers Park rate is 51.6. 41 Source: Chicago Health Data Lab This may mean more child safety education is needed both at the well child visit and to the community in general. Assuring that children under 18 y/o have a medical home where child safety education can occur as part of the anticipatory guidance outlined by the American Academy of Pediatrics would be key. Effort to identify children at risk for child abuse would also be important. Members of the Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park have worked with Children’s Memorial Hospital’s Child Window Fall Coalition in an effort to put forth legislation to mandate window safety devices in rental units. Approximately 75% of all the housing in Rogers Park is rental units. About 4670 children (7.9% of the total Rogers Park population) are under 5 y/o in Rogers Park. Children under six years old are at greatest risk for window falls. Rogers Park has been a community identified by Children’s Memorial Hospital to be at high risk for window falls (Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park) Women’s Health Per the 2000 census, there were 19,352 women (30% of the total population of Rogers Park) between the ages of 18-65 living in Rogers Park. Access to women’s health is vital to the health and well being of the women living in the community. Currently there are no health care providers and/or clinics receiving Title X Federal funding for women’s reproductive health care including contraceptive services and education, pregnancy testing and treatment for sexually transmitted infections in Rogers 42 Park. Therefore, low-income women must travel out of the community for free women’s reproductive health care such as contraceptive services, STI screenings and pap smears. Furthermore, the Title X program has always provided family planning services to adolescents. In fact, in 1978, Congress amended the Title X program to “place special emphasis on preventing pregnancies among sexually active adolescents”. Title X funding also provides free and/or low cost breast and cervical cancer screenings for all women. Hospitalization Although the leading causes of hospitalization in Chicago are for delivery of an infant and heart disease, Rogers Park residents are most likely to be hospitalized for mental disorders that are not drug or alcohol related. Consistent with aforementioned mortality and morbidity data, residents of Rogers Park have higher rates of hospitalization for pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and infectious diseases. Gaps in Health Care In Chicago, 2002, it was estimated that 19.9% of the population was deemed uninsured and “medically needy”. In Rogers Park, 2002, approximately 30% of the population was uninsured and “medically needy” (CDPH, “Casting Chicago’s Health Care Safety Net”). These numbers do not include persons who work and are without health insurance and whose income exceeds 200% over poverty level. According to 2005 Metro Chicago Information Center (MCIC) estimates, 17,775 persons or 27% of the total population of Rogers Park are non-citizens. According to a MCIC 2010 projection, the numbers of noncitizens in the Rogers Park community could increase by 8.1%. Non-citizens, who are not permanent residents, do not qualify for state funded health insurance programs and are not likely to have health insurance. The numbers of “medically needy” in Chicago declined less than 1% from 1990 to 2000. But for Rogers Park, from 1990 to 2000, there was an 8.3% increase in the number of “medically needy” residents. Medically needy is defined by calculating the population under 65y/o who have family incomes under 200% poverty and then subtracting the number of Chicagoans enrolled in the State’s Medicaid program in 2002. The outcome will be a reasonable estimate of the low-income uninsured or under-insured. (Serving Chicago’s “Underserved: Regional Health Systems Profile, October, 2005”). According to the CDPH, The North Region of Chicago, where Rogers Park exists, there were six new community centers added between 1990 and 2000. The North Region is comprised of eight community areas, but more than half of the safety net providers are located in the Uptown community. Rogers Park currently has only one center, added to the community in October, 2001. Also of interest, 63% of the North Region’s safety net patients (patients using community based safety net sites) were uninsured in 2002. The North Region had the largest percentage of uninsured patients across the city’s seven regions (Citywide 48% of safety net patients lacked health insurance). And the North Region’s safety net providers cared for the highest proportion of the uninsured patients when compared to the other six regions. Lastly, The CDPH reports that the North Region is home to 18% of the city’s medically needy, but only 10% of safety net system capacity. 43 Access to Medications Access to truly affordable medications remains one of the most common barriers to wellness for the Rogers Park uninsured. St. Francis clinic has no pharmaceutical program in place for the uninsured. Evanston – Rogers Park has a reduced cost pharmaceutical program, but “reduced” cost, for many patients is not enough of a price reduction to make purchasing medications affordable. For most patients requiring two or more medications, as is the case for many diabetics who take up to six medications a day to control the disease, Cook County Hospital pharmacy and clinic remains their only viable option. This means a community resident must travel 15.2 miles on two buses and a train to see yet another doctor who can prescribe the very same medications the community clinic doctor prescribed. This results in a wasteful duplication of service and patients endure eight to twelve hour waits to see an initial physician. Then the patient often waits another few days for the medications to be ready to be picked up at the Cook County pharmacy (Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park). A new pharmaceutical mail order service is now available to chronic illness medication refills, but if the patient’s dosage has been changed, the patient has to repeat the cycle of going down to Cook County Hospital all over again. Rogers Park residents also report concerns related to having medications being delivered to broken mailboxes in large apartment complexes etc. Medications for acute illnesses require a visit to Cook County Hospital clinics and a wait for up to eight hours in the out-patient pharmacy line, and certain pain medication, narcotics, can’t be mailed in the US Mail (Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park). 44 Phase II – Health Focus: “Affordable Health Care for All” Qualitative Data: Community Perspectives ________________________________________________________________________ As part of our community health needs assessment 18 community leadership interviews were done in an attempt to fully understand the strengths, challenges and complex needs of the community. Leaders were identified by members of the Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park for their commitment, work and unique insights into what makes Rogers Park work and what limits Rogers Park. Community leaders were chosen from various organizations representing the eight subsystems identified in the community wheel subsystems. We made a special effort to reach out to existing health care providers and leaders who currently serve Rogers Park residents. Community leadership interviews were done using a semi-formal interviewing style. Four central questions were asked, and if the opportunity presented itself, more questions were solicited in an effort to clarify and expand on individuals thoughts. The questions are purposely open ended. Whenever possible we attempted to ask questions to illustrate complex concepts. Questions related to health and specific health care needs of the community were incorporated into each interview at varying depths depending on the interviewee’s background. • • • • What does community health mean to you? What are Rogers Park assets? What are Rogers Park challenges/obstacles? What is your vision for the future of Rogers Park . A few central themes came up during the leadership interviews. Almost all of the leaders interviewed understood community health to include not only physical health, but psychological, emotional and spiritual wellness as well. Quality of life was identified as a means to abstractly measure community health. “The community is healthy if at the end of the day, its members can perform activities of daily life, learn something new, not be harmed, laugh or be amused by something or someone, interact or communicate with the world around him/her and fall asleep with a fundamental assurance the next day will bring forth a continued connection to an individual, family, community and the greater world”. Community leaders identified the people of Rogers Park as its strongest asset. Many community assets were identified by the leadership. The community’s cultural, ethnic, and economic diversity was a key asset identified by all. Paradoxically, preserving the community’s diversities was identified as one of the greatest challenges for the future. One leader commented “in order to preserve our greatest community treasure, our diversity, we must find ways to stabilize the housing market to ensure members from every economic group can afford to live here”. Another key asset identified by the community leadership was transportation. CTA buses and trains connect Rogers Park residents to employment, educational, cultural and recreational opportunities all over Chicago and the suburbs. A couple of interviewees 45 mentioned that a CTA bus to run along Ridge would be beneficial for school children and residents wishing to access St. Francis and Evanston Hospitals (located on Ridge in Evanston). The community was described by a few to be “walkable” in that, it is fairly easy to find what you need within walking distance in most of the neighborhoods. Though some identified the “walkability” of the community as an asset, many leaders thought more should be done to make the community “pedestrian friendly” to encourage walking as a form of physical activity. Designating “walking paths” to schools and business areas was suggested. Expanding bike paths along the lakefront and within the community itself to encourage bicycling as a form of physical activity was also mentioned. An idea to close off certain streets on Sundays to give individuals and families opportunities to walk, bike and roller blade together was suggested. Interestingly, one leader thought more should be done to create a method of transportation using the lakefront waterway in the form of a “water taxi” system downtown. Gentrification was viewed as both an asset and a challenge depending on who the interviewee was. But, all leaders interviewed agreed that there should be a development plan in place to balance more affluent owner occupied housing with affordable rental unit housing. All agreed that landlords need to be responsible to maintain their properties so that the community can take on a more aesthetic character. Employment within the community was a concern for most people interviewed. The abundance of low paying service jobs without benefits was articulated as a concern. Almost all interviewed mentioned concerns about workers without health insurance, and the long term effects the lack of health insurance will have on the community and its individual members in terms of quality of life. The economic burden on society for caring for persons with debilitating illness created by long term neglect of personal health due to lack of access to affordable health care was mentioned by a few leaders. Creating a more comprehensive community health education outreach program was viewed as necessary. Many leaders thought that manufacturing jobs such as those provided by long time community employer, S&C Electric were essential for the overall economic stability of the community. S&C Electric was referred to as an employer well invested in both the community and its residents. Loyola University was mentioned several times by leaders as being a just and fair employer, offering college tuition reimbursement and a generous benefit package. Crime/personal safety was another challenge believed to exist within the community. Gangs, guns and drugs are viewed as major obstacles for community development. The war on drugs and its social implications resonated throughout many interviews. The lack of in-patient and out-patient drug and alcohol programs were sited repeatedly as an urgent community need. Currently, the closest affordable treatment programs exist on the west side of the city. CAPS, the community policing program, have been somewhat successful in bringing together community members and local police officers to work as one to make the community safer. Efforts such as youth outreach attempts by the police to create a youth run beat meeting were viewed as a community asset as well as Cease Fire, a community based anti-gun violence outreach program. Education, especially at the high school level was verbalized as a serious challenge by most people interviewed. Issues such as underperformance on standardized tests, being on the state’s Academic Warning List, overcrowding, gang presence, safety, the lack of 46 closed campus policy, mandatory uniforms and parental involvement were concerns identified. The health care providers interviewed said the greatest barriers to care were lack of affordable medications, diagnostics and specialists. Health care providers said their greatest frustrations are trying to diagnose a health problem without diagnostic testing support services (like x-rays, MRI’s etc.) and knowing that the prescriptions they give to patients to treat health problems will most likely never be filled in many cases. Other concerns were the lack of ability to educate patients about preventative care due to time constraints. The ability to communicate with patients due to language barriers was also mention. The lack of youth programming was frequently seen as a challenge for Rogers Park by persons interviewed. Children ages 11 -14 are often not eligible for after school programming. A Boys/Girls Club with a variety of cultural, artistic, academic and athletic opportunities could be a possible solution verbalized by some community leaders. It is hoped that the planned Gale Park community center, will accommodate some of the youth programming needs identified. 47 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Medical Director (also served as Medical Director at Evanston-Rogers Park Access Family Health Center from 2000 -2004). Organization: Misericordia Type of Interview: Written Key Findings: What does community health mean to you? A healthy community has people whose basic needs are cared for and met. Those needs include jobs, housing, safety, nutrition, education and health care (medical, dental and mental health) among others. Mutual respect, delight in other peoples talents and cultures, and empathy for their difficulties are also evident in a healthy community. What are Rogers Park’s assets? Many people choose to live in Rogers Park because they want to be part of an ethically and racially diverse, culturally and artistically vibrant community. So the people are the main asset. The Howard Area Community Center, the Rogers Park Community Council, DevCorp and the two SSAs, Access Community Health Network’s health center, St. Francis Hospital’s health center, Trilogy and the Alderman and his office are some of the community’s resources. What are some of Rogers Park’s challenges? Poverty, drugs, and violence and the discouragement caused by those problems. What is your vision for the future of Rogers Park? That it continue to grow toward being a community where people come together to assure the well-being of each other by supporting initiatives for jobs, housing, safety, nutrition, education, and health care. What are the health care needs in Rogers Park? We have routine health care needs such as immunizations, lead screening, and developmental screenings for children, and cancer and cholesterol screenings in adults, the care of chronic diseases such as diabetes, hypertension, depression and other mental illnesses, HIV/AIDS, and obesity. To attend to these needs we need significantly more access to primary care. We also need some access to specialty care and diagnostic testing. Besides the access to primary care, we need access to basic medications used to treat acute and especially chronic illnesses. The diagnosis without the medication is nearly useless in many situations. Access to affordable exercise facilities and healthy food, as well as culturally aware nutrition and exercise counseling would also go a long way toward meeting the health care needs of the community. 48 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Former Private High School Principal Organization: St. Scholastica High School Type of Interview: Phone Date: August 13, 2006 Key Findings: What does “community health” mean to you? Community health is having accessible health services, reasonably attained for the uninsured that may need “system assistance”. Community Health Clinics need to be multilingual in a location with easy access to transportation. Two of the most prevalent health problems I saw as principal of St. Scholastica High School were obesity and asthma. It seems as though students need help making healthier eating choices and they need more physical activity. What are Rogers Park’s Assets? • Diversity. Rogers Park has an international quality. People in Rogers Park are more welcoming than in other communities. There are populations of highly educated people who choose to live in Rogers Park; they are an asset. • There are many active organizations in Rogers Park which do good works. RPCC and DevCorp are two of them. The Bernard Horowitz Center sponsored by the Jewish community has contributed much to the community. • Top educational institutions like Loyola University, Northwestern University and St. Scholastica High School are assets to Rogers Park. • We have financial institutions which assist the community by supporting local businesses. Devon Bank is one of the finest neighborhood financial institutions. • Rogers Park has a variety of artistic ventures. We have the Center for cultural dance studio. The art community represents artists from many different forms of art from graphic art to music and dance. Rogers Park does capitalize on its international qualities especially in the artistic arena. What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • Communication can be an obstacle at times. At St. Scholastica High School, 45 different languages are spoken by the students and their parents. 53% of the student’s primary languages are other than English. • Trying to hold multilingual meetings can be challenging at times. I wonder if communication problems r/t a multilingual community prevents coordination between groups and projects. 49 • Rogers Park websites are an effective way to communicate for persons with computers. The local churches help facilitate communication too through their weekly bulletins and announcements. • Rogers Park has a limited amount of manufacturing jobs and/or jobs which provide a decent wage and benefits. S&C Electric in West Rogers Park has been up and running for almost as long as our monastery (close to 100yrs). But they are the only large business in Rogers Park that I can think of. • Affordable housing in light of the current revitalization of Rogers Park is an obstacle. As where we all want new housing opportunities, we need to make sure there is also affordable housing for low income families. • Crime and personal safety remains an obstacle for Rogers Park. We have been fortunate at the Monastery and the school in that we have had to deal with only a few episodes of minor crime. • Lack of transportation on Ridge Avenue is a barrier for students trying to access schools located on or near Ridge. It can be a barrier for persons trying to access physicians and hospitals (St. Francis and ENH) located on Ridge too. What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park? • An improved quality of life manifested by improvements in housing, though not at the expense of affordable housing. • I would like to see strong education systems in place, especially at the public high school level. Rogers Park needs a model high school representative of the rich group of multicultural people who live here. • Good opportunities for meaningful employment are another quality of life dream I want for Rogers Park. • And, lastly, I wish Rogers Park residents’ good health. We can do this by improving access to affordable health care for all. 50 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Activist Organization: Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park Type of Interview: In Person Date: September 29th 2006 Key Findings: What does “community health” mean to you? • A healthy community understands it own population. It uses that awareness to anticipate needs and confront them with an effective plan. • Neighborhood health should include Medical Homes within the community for the majority of residents. What are Rogers Park’s assets? • The people of Rogers Park. • Rogers Park has a strong community activist tradition, which helps deal with certain kinds of problems. • Its economic and racial diversity make Rogers Park ideal for genuine co-mingling of cultures. This promotes the shared experiences that lead to tolerance and understanding. • Affordable housing has attracted many good and creative people. What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • Working people forced out by gentrification. • A public education system that is failing its students. • Limited health resources and over 30% of the community currently without health insurance • “Medically Underserved” status. • One thing we need to do is begin proper training for residents in our community policing program. The CAPS program in Rogers Park is supposed to be on a Problem Solving format but needs to use this training to work. Right now consistent problems don't receive the tracking and accountability that really stops persistent crime. 51 What is your vision for the future of Rogers Park? “The time to build a community that works for the majority of people living here is now. The lack of health resources, for example is a chance to find new ways to meet the needs of our diverse population. The same is true of crime and education. This community can and should do much more for itself.” 52 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Community Activist Organizations: Illinois Healthcare Now; Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park Type of Interview: In person Date: August 8, 2006 Key Findings: What does community health mean to you? • Community Health is having adequate facilities and services to meet the needs of the uninsured, underinsured and the self-employed. Rogers Park is home to many artists who work in the service industry and do not receive health care benefits. Many of them are forced to utilize Cook County Health Care services, and have not received the best of care. An acquaintance of mine recently injured her hand on the job, and required wound care. She went to Cook County for treatment. After the doctor treated her injury, someone came into the room and told her she needs to bandage her own hand and apply her own splint. Institutionally there currently isn’t a way to deal with persons of different cultures who have complex medical problems. Local support for persons with serious illness isn’t present. Unless someone has an intact social network, they have to deal with their illness in isolation. • There is a waitress who works at a local café who is dealing with serious cancer and who goes to Cook County for treatments. She is here from the Ukraine, by herself, and her family is unable to come here to care for her now. The local community is hosting a benefit to raise money for her living expenses while she is undergoing treatment. Without the local community working together to help her, where would she be? And how many other people are out there, in the same situation, dealing with a major illness in isolation, without support? What are Rogers Park’s Challenges? • Crime/Personal Safety - I have neighbors who have been victims of gooning. A gooning occurs when someone is assaulted by 4 or more teens without the intent to rob. There have been shootings recently. Ceasefire works in the community by organizing public safety walks, and I go to those. Psychologically, living in a community where crime and personal safety are constant issues leaves me and the greater community nervous, on edge and anxious. Quality of life is impaired. I can see crime and fear of being a crime victim as a barrier to medical care. Morse Avenue would be an ideal site for a new clinic, but many neighborhood people are afraid to walk down Morse because of the drug dealers and the goonings. • Youth - Rogers Park is an unhealthy community in that there is a lack of attention paid to youth. School aged kids and teens are idle, just hanging out without the structure of after school programs. “They lack the positive expression of self through sports, the arts and culture”. 53 What are Rogers Park’s Obstacles? • Diversity of Population is Rogers Park’s greatest asset. • Living in such a diverse community helps to break down barriers of all kinds. The Rogers Park community appreciates different cultures. • Rogers Park is a welcoming community. There is an openness, acceptance and respect for people from every avenue of life. • Rogers Park is home to many artist and persons with artistic endeavors. Artist bring with them a creative energy which work well in Rogers Park. Artists have unique ways of looking at the world, the community and others. How do organizations in Rogers Park work together? • Unfortunately groups often work in isolation, replicating efforts of other groups. Sometimes organizations act in territorial ways; this impedes progress. Working in isolation brings about small changes. By working together and networking with each other groups, could potentially facilitate changes with much greater impact. Greater change could be an outcome of an effort to collaborate with each other. • An example of a group who has worked well with other groups, and has accomplished much in the process is the “Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park”. The NHRP have worked successfully with community residents, politicians, local health care providers and others to improve access to health care for the uninsured. • The Universal Health Care/Single Payer Referendum group I belong to has had success looking for a larger legislative answer to the lack of access to affordable health care epidemic. It is a longer term project specifically aimed at looking for solutions to rising health care costs for all. What is your vision for the future of Rogers Park? • I would like to see at least one new clinic placed in Rogers Park to bring affordable health care to the 20,000 uninsured residents of Rogers Park. • I would like to see an effective CAPS Program implemented in Rogers Park which would include the community in strategizing. • I would like to see the implementation of many more youth programs to foster positive expression of youth through sports, the arts and culture. “Rogers Park has tremendous potential for good, but has steep blocks to climb to provide access to care and services”. 54 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Nurse Practioner Organization: Sullivan High School Health Center Type of Interview: In Person Date: August 9, 2006 Key Findings: What does “community health” mean to you? Community Health is health care which is delivered in the community/neighborhood. It is accessible and affordable. Community health should be delivered in languages the community understands. Community health should be sensitive to all the cultures represented in the community. It should also be mindful of specific needs related to age and gender. What are Rogers Park’s assets? • Its diversity is its greatest asset. • There are a core of community leaders that truly care for the community and its people. What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • Regarding health care, there are gaps in care which impact people’s health. We have limited primary care, so we can initiate care. But we have no access to specialty care and diagnostics. So if someone needs an x-ray or an MRI, there is nothing we can do for them at the community level. We are forced to send them to Cook County Hospital where they wait all day, are seen by a physician who does exactly what we just did in the community, and then the patient gets his xray. So there is duplication of physician services which is a waste. Same thing goes for when someone needs to see an eye doctor. We have to send them 16 miles away to Cook County Hospital, they wait all day, are seen by a primary care doctor or nurse practioner, like me and then they get a referral to see an eye doctor in 4 or 5 months. • There is a huge gap in access to medicines. • We see patients who have chronic illnesses like diabetes and hypertension, tell them their disease is out of control, hand them a wad of prescriptions which sit in a drawer at home because the patient can’t afford to buy them. They eventually become seriously ill, end up in the emergency room and/or admitted to a local hospital and receive a bill they cannot pay in a lifetime. • We can send them to Cook County for their medicines, but then they have to wait all day to see yet another doctor to evaluate them and prescribe the medicines. And afterwards they must continue to receive care at Cook County rather than in the community. 55 How does your organization contribute to community health? Sullivan High School Based Clinic delivers primary care services mostly to adolescents who attend Sullivan High School. What works in Rogers Park? Informal “word of mouth communication” especially amongst the Latina women in the community, works well. Latina women are tight knit and close. They tend to take care of each other. What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park? I would like to see a Youth Center built in Rogers Park which would have a large activities program, social services and a teen health clinic all built into one building. Teens need a “wrap around” approach to their care. 56 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Community Activist/Volunteer Tutor/Howard Area Community Center Senior Club Moderator Organization: Howard Area Community Center Type of Interview: In person Date: August 12, 2006 What does “Community Health” mean to you? A healthy community is more than “not sick”. Wellness occurs when information is healthy and available for all. A holist approach to creating a well community is what works best. Wellness has more than one aspect - spiritual, physical, emotional, and psychological aspects to name a few. What are Rogers Park’s assets? • Good transportation is an asset. Having access to both the bus and “el” is convenient. • Communication is an asset too. There are many organizations that help get the word out through various venues… computer, word of mouth, at churches and through groups. Unfortunately many organizations have separate missions and the missions overlap at times. Some organizations compete for funding too. • Rogers Park has many coalitions all over the community. An example of a coalition which worked well was the CAPS pilot project in Rogers Park. Because of the collaborations of many different groups we were able to start CAPS in Rogers Park. CAPS met monthly to discuss crime and ways to prevent crime. There were citizen leadership training opportunities through CAPS trainings. Public relations improved between the police and the residents. • Another example of various groups coming together to collaborate in a positive way can be seen with the Gale Park Field House Project. The community has been working for the park community center for over five years. Just recently ground has been broken. The Field House project would include structured programs for youth, adults, seniors and teens. These are sorely needed programs. • Another asset is the variety of community businesses, restraints, and grocery stores. In my opinion Rogers Park needs to expand on or highlight the internationality of the cultural based businesses. They are a major asset to the community. For example, I was traveling through the state of Washington not long ago, and ran across a small town were the major factory closed and moved out of the county. The leadership of the town monopolized on the specific German cultural influences of the citizens of the town and developed a “Germantown” atmosphere with German bars, restaurants, stores, artists and other culturally owned businesses. 57 What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • One of the greatest obstacles we have in Rogers Park is the lack of structured programs for youth ages 11-14 y/o. After school programs pick up the need for the school aged kids up to age 11. From 5pm to 9pm there are no programs for kids. Many of their parents are not home from work at these hours, so the children are unsupervised. • Another obstacle we have is the lack of a second High School to lessen the crowdedness at Sullivan High School. There are way too many kids at Sullivan and too much of a gang influence. The Sullivan High School needs a closed campus to protect the students there. The grammar school children do not receive the individualization many of them desperately need... • We need more businesses willing to hire Rogers Park residents for manufacturing jobs. We have service jobs available, but they are low paying and without benefits. • We need to develop the international and cultural flavor of the community through businesses. What are your hopes and dreams for the future of Rogers Park? I would like to see a community equal in culture and accessibility for all cultures to business, health, and education. I would like our image to continue to be a welcoming one for anyone who would like to live here. That means we need to work together. We need to steer the housing market forces in Rogers Park to curb gentrification and provide affordable housing to residents who have lived here all of their lives. The displacement of long time Rogers Park residents needs to stop. We need a mixed housing community where everyone feels welcomed. Rogers Park religious groups need to come together and work on common goals. We have such a diverse group of religious institutions in Rogers Park. We should do more to work with each other in the future. 58 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Community Activist Type of Interview: Phone Interview Date: October 2, 2006 Key Findings: What comes to mind when you think of “community health”? • Cook County Hospital: place where community can go and get services Where she’s been receiving health care, don’t have to pay They have ambulatory care clinic where anyone can walk in ER: long waits b/c anyone from county can come • On Community Level: Evanston Rogers Park on Howard Street (caring staff and she appreciates that They call people to remind them of appointments. • Board of Health Clinics throughout city • Cook County Hospital Assets? - Don’t have to pay - Good doctors committed to providing quality services • Obstacles? - Has waited to be seen for 23 hours, it has gotten a bit better if you have an appointment - Wait hours to find out if medicines are ready - Wait two weeks for medicines - Don’t care enough about customer services and people’s time What are some of Rogers Park’s assets? • Caring community, focused on doing health care, legitimately concerned with infant mortality and stuff like that, agencies are genuinely concerned What are some obstacles, or challenges that Rogers Park faces? • • Rogers Park could use another free, or low cost (sliding scale) clinic is needed because grants run out Would like to see the following in a clinic… - Clinic should be easily acceptable by public transportation (bus/train line) - Accessible to people with disabilities (not on a second floor without an elevator) - Make hours flexible so people working can come (have a night or two a week where staff works late, and definitely be open on Saturdays) - Dental and eye care component would be great 59 - Affordable drug options Space set aside in clinic for children to play with toys and books Attach a fitness component (yoga/exercise) Nutrition (especially with diabetics) Mental health worker Specialists at clinics, or at least rotating specialists who can come in from time to time Social worker connected to a clinic to meet needs outside of medical needs (need clothes, domestic violence) • Would like to see the clinic collaborate with other organizations within the community so access to specialists could be shared, etc. The networking is good in Rogers Park, but this clinic must also network with other health care facilities and social organizations to keep people informed of what can benefit them. • Would also like to see a community advisory board so the clinic can get feedback from the clients they serve (ex. The staff is not congenial) What is your dream for health care in Rogers Park? That every person would be able to have health care. No one would have a problem. Those who need eyeglasses would have eyeglasses. Open health care. No one would go untreated who needed health care in Rogers Park. People don’t think about their teeth and feet as much as other things. They also need to be able to afford drugs. 60 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Pastor Organization: St. Ignatius Church Type of Interview: In person Date: August 22, 2006 Key Findings: What are Rogers Park’s Assets? • Diversity – Rogers Park is a community rich in diversity, cultural diversity as well as religious diversity. There have always been good relationships between the Christians, the Muslims and the Jewish faithful in Rogers Park. Many of the poorer Jewish immigrants from Russia and Bosnia have found Rogers Park to be a welcoming community. • Loyola University – The University has helped to stabilize the community in a number of ways. Loyola has recently expanded their police patrols to include the surrounding neighborhood. Community residents are grateful for this added service. Loyola has always been a fair employer in the community; the students occupy rental units around the university and provide a much needed economic fabric to the area. Faculty members live in the community and contribute to the social capital. • There exists a core of long time, multigenerational families who have welcomed newcomers as part of their faith. This strong core group of community residents/parishioners has worked to help the poor. We have a food pantry at St. Ignatius, supported by parishioners who have a mission to help those in need. Sadly, we have had a steady increase in the number of individuals and families who need assistance from the food pantry. We adhere to geographic boundaries as to who we can serve, so we know there are increasing numbers of people struggling, financially, in the area. • Community groups and organizations work well together. CAPS is an example of a community policing program that has successfully worked with organizations to promote positive change in the area. What are some of the challenges Rogers Park faces? • Youth Programs are needed in Rogers Park. At times, I wonder whether our youth are falling through the cracks. There are Catholic Schools nearby, but not everyone can afford them, and not every student can gain admission to a CPS magnet school. The local high school seems to be struggling with overcrowding and gang issues. • Access to mental health resources is another area that remains a challenge for Rogers Park. Long term case management and a clinic where mental health providers can treat the chronically mentally ill are needed. Access to affordable health care for the uninsured is another area of need. • 61 • Health care prevention programs are especially needed since many people are uninsured. Early detection of behavioral/mental health issues can prevent many sad outcomes. What is your vision for the future of Rogers Park? • • • • • • • We need to maintain the ethnic and religious diversity of the community. We need to work together to deal with crime in the area. There is a commonality of interest and cohesion which occurs when we all work for improved health care. Individuals, families and the community all gain. In regards to housing, we need to work together to maintain the proper balance of housing stock. Affordable rental housing as well as owner occupied housing needs to exist here for the community to retain its character and expand upon its history of being welcoming and a port of entry to anyone who wishes to live here. We need to expand service for our youth. We need local affordable health care for the uninsured. We need mental health services and case management, substance abuse programs and peer counseling programs 62 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Commissioner, 13th Cook County District Organization: Cook County Type of Interview: In Person Date: August 14, 2006 Key Findings: What does community health mean to you? When I think of community health, I think of two things: • Traditional Public Health which studies the broader community trends such as rising HIV infection rates, childhood lead poisoning, and poor early prenatal care rates. • Community health also means the monitoring of access to adequate numbers of medical personnel. Are individuals medical needs being addressed? Is the care quality care? And is it affordable care? What are Rogers Park’s assets? • Rogers Park’s greatest asset is a core group of citizens who challenge gangs, government, landlords and other threats to the peacefulness of the community. • For instance, the citizens acquired the police camera pod to deter crime on this very street. • Loyola University is a stable employer who employs community persons, pays them fairly and provides benefits. What are Rogers Park’s Challenges? • Lack of a stable business base. Rogers Park attracts small businesses like dollar stores, but not the larger businesses which could potentially employ residents and add economic vitality to the community. • Too many of the properties are run down and not properly cared for. Properties are either in a state of extreme neglect, or are newly condo converted. These types of properties do not really attract long term, rooted residents with a feeling of ownership. Much of the properties are “transitional types of properties”. • A problem related to access to health is Rogers Park’s connection to Level one trauma care. Currently Illinois Masonic dictates where trauma patients injured in Rogers Park go. Illinois Masonic is approximately a 20+ minute ride from Rogers Park - vs. - St. Francis Hospital which is a closer distance and could be a 5 to 10 minute ride. 63 What is your vision for Rogers Park? “I would like to see better health care coverage for the residents of Rogers Park in terms of access to affordable primary health care services. I especially am interested in seeing residents without insurance have access to care in their own community. The traditional form of employer provided health insurance will disappear; it is a dinosaur. Only the CEOs and the very wealthy will be able to afford it. We need to look for alternatives to providing health insurance coverage for people”. We spoke briefly about the new health care policy report published by the Institute for Health Care Studies at Northwestern released yesterday. It urges the Cook County Board to restructure how health care is delivered. For instance, primary health care should be delivered in communities by Federally Qualified Health Centers (exactly like the clinic we are trying to place in Rogers Park). The Cook County Hospital and clinic systems should be used for specialty care. The Commissioner strongly supports this recommendation. 64 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Executive Director Organization: Rogers Park Community Council (RPCC) Type of Interview: Telephone Date: August 31, 2006 Key Findings: What does “community health” mean to you? Health services and knowledge about health. Knowledge about health comes through education. What are Rogers Park’s assets? People are Rogers Park’s greatest assets; they are smart, have a variety of backgrounds and educational levels and have a unique energy. The location is an asset; Rogers Park is in Chicago and a lakefront community. The diversity of the community gives it a unique energy. What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • Housing is an ongoing challenge; specifically the cost of housing is the challenge. Though I think it may be safe to predict a leveling off of condo construction. There are unique problems associated with housing in Rogers Park. Developing new housing while keeping some affordable housing available so lower income families are not displaced is the challenge. • Crime continues to be a problem in RP. People want and need to feel safe. Struggling small businesses are a challenge in RP. I think we have many of the cute mom and pop stores, and we love to look at them. But are we shopping at them? • We need more restaurants and places of entertainment. We need stores which sell healthy foods at affordable prices. To be honest, I shop for fresh fruits and vegetables in the suburbs. • Public education is in a state of chaos in RP. We have lots of kids; the schools are overcrowded and under funded. • The lack of support services for persons with mental illness is a challenge. Specifically persons with paranoid symptoms not taking their medications have problems trying to live independently in community. They have problems maintaining housing, employment and can fall through the cracks easily. • The mental health system needs to be revamped from head to toe. There needs to be major public policy changes made related to long term mental health care for persons with chronic mental health issues. 65 What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park? I hope Rogers Park stays the neighborhood where people want to live. I hope the community can maintain its unique diversity and that affordable housing will be available to everyone who wishes to call Rogers Park home. 66 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Restaurant Owner/Community Activist Type of Interview: In person Date: August 10, 2004 What does community health mean to you? “Community Health is a dream”. Community Health happens when members of the community care for all of its members, make room for new members and know the members of the community. Community health is what keeps us all well. What are Rogers Park’s assets? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Its variety of people. Its proximity to the lake. Its progressive populist history. Its shared history amongst its members Its walkability. It is easy to get around on foot or bike. I wouldn’t call it pedestrian friendly; there is no place in the city really welcoming to pedestrians. But you can live easily in Rogers Park without a car and still get around. 6. Core people who work together well are an asset. 7. Events work well in RP… some examples would be “Artist on the Wall”, The Clark Street Festival, and any form of celebration works well. 8. Art, Theater and culture are RP gifts What are Rogers Park’s challenges? 1. Cynicism – cynicism forms a shield around how much we care. Cynicism is how our selves protect self. 2. Politics is an obstacle – politics unfortunately disconnects and divides people. It can sometimes divide good people who should be working together. Why can’t liberals work with conservatives and democrats work with republicans? Our political system is set up to cause divisiveness. 3. City bureaucracy often times does not support community efforts. What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park? Preserving existing green space and adding additional green space in the community is one of my hopes. Developing rooftop gardening is another. Adding walking paths and bike paths would be good for the environment and everyone’s health. Rogers Park needs more businesses. We could use small storefront businesses which would offer some special uniqueness to Rogers Park. Art stores and book stores would do well here. We need a local hardware store. We need multi-cultural stores, independently owned. Creative businesses would thrive here. Look at the “Biz-Arts” group here in Rogers Park; they just celebrated their 5th anniversary. BizArts is a group of business owners who are in the Arts field, like gallery owners, restaurant owners, own theater groups and the like. We also need more quality and affordable childcare in Rogers Park. 67 We could use more coffee shops and computer cafes. We need more businesses aimed at young people. A well run video arcade would be ok if the owners had the intention of serving youth in a positive manner. 68 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Alderman, 49th Ward of Chicago 1) What do you think of when you hear “community health”? Ensuring that community residents have access to a wide range of services to meet both their physical and mental needs. The Alderman believes the county should expand health services, but there is not the money to do so. He asked where the money for this federally funded clinic is coming from. The interviewer explained that money would come from the Bureau of Primary Care, Department of Health and Human Services, and that the funds would be administered by Heartland Health Alliance. In 1999, Rogers Park was designated as a medically underserved community by the federal government. 2) What are the assets of Rogers Park? • • • • • • Diversity Energy in grassroots organizations/community based organizations Location: access to great public transportation, proximity to lake Urban setting with a neighborhood feel Little animosity/competition between large organizations Collaboration between organizations is improving, especially among staff 3a) What are the obstacles in Rogers Park? The Alderman prefers the word “challenge” instead of obstacle because all of these issues can be overcome. • There have been changes within the community that can be very positive. However, these changes must be channeled to maintain the unique flavor of Rogers Park. Diversity must be embraced because it is what sets Rogers Park apart from other communities in the nation. Yet, some changes are definitely improvements, such as a reduction in crime. The challenge is to welcome the improvements without losing the racial, economic, and cultural diversity of Rogers Park. • Community activism is often a good thing. Free thinkers are attracted to Rogers Park and bring a lot of energy, but sometimes this energy is negative. Such negative energy leads to mistrust and cynicism that impede progress. • Converting property to condos has pluses and minuses. A plus is that these conversions bring stability and ownership to the community. A negative is that these conversions are replacing the people who used to live in the community with higher-income people. The Alderman would like to maintain a diversity of housing options for a variety of people to be able to own and rent, but the dwindling resources make it difficult to do so. 69 • Marketing the diversity of Rogers Park has been suggested by some community leaders. However, the Alderman fears that this would turn Rogers Park into some sort of theme park where the diversity is a false tourist attraction, such as what happened in Greek Town. In Greek Town, there are many Greek restaurants, but the actual Greek population has moved out of the community. Similar things have happened in the Puerto Rican community and in the gay and lesbian communities. The Alderman wants to maintain authentic diversity by keeping the current population in Rogers Park. The Alderman also stated the need for citywide direction by the mayor, and state and national help. 3b) What are some of the obstacles to health in Rogers Park? • There is more demand for health care than available health care. There are some good health clinics in the area, but also a lot of unmet need. • There are health issues associated with low-income communities, such as a lack of proper nutrition, treatment for drug and alcohol abuse, and affordable mental health services. There are lots of mental health agencies, but there is still a need for more. The isolation and unstable living conditions in Rogers Park breed mental health problems. 3c) What are some of the obstacles to education in Rogers Park? • The Chicago Math and Science Academy has helped the education system because it offers an option other than Sullivan. • Sullivan is overcrowded and although it has some good teachers, it has some problems as well. When the Alderman was asked to comment on the value of Sullivan having a closed campus and uniforms, he suggested those involved with the school could better answer those questions. • The Alderman referred to some principals in the past at a variety of schools who were probably not the most qualified for their positions. 4a) What is your vision for Rogers Park? • Maintain the economic, cultural, and racial diversity • Be a thriving example of how people of various backgrounds can live and work together in peace Rogers Park is on the cutting edge of the future of this country (a country of minorities living with one another). Can we survive as a diverse nation? Are we going to live in gated communities, or live together? In Rogers Park, every block is different and such diversity is both rare and special. • 4b) What does Rogers Park need more, or less of? • The Alderman does not think we need many more dollar stores, but the fact that so many are in Rogers Park and doing well shows that there is a demand for such stores (bars are another example). We need a diversity of retail opportunities, such as a variety of restaurants. Because the cultural backgrounds in Rogers Park are so different, there is a wide range of desires for the community. Everyone seems to want something different, so the challenge is finding a BALANCE that 70 will maintain the diversity of not only retail, but the population at large. (example of the Top Cat Lounge debate and now the desire for an upscale nightclub) • In conclusion, the Alderman said he has been liberated by the realization that he cannot please everyone in such a diverse community. 71 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Physician Organization: Self Employed Date: June 27, 2006 Key Findings: The physician sat down and spoke with me on June 27, 2006. I reminded him that I was doing a community needs assessment in partnership with Heartland Alliance in regards to building a new health center on or South of Morse Avenue. I also mentioned to him that Commissioner Larry Suffredin recommended that we ask his input, being that he has helped serve this community for years and knows the needs of the community. The physician then said, “I have spoken with the Commissioner several years ago and recently and we were thinking my center could be utilized because of the space. There is 5,500 square feet upstairs for full service and 4,000 square feet downstairs available.” Rogers Park “Rogers Park is a nice area. It’s becoming more diverse which is why I located my facility here to take care of the Evanston and Rogers Park community.” Role of Agency “My vision is to render health care services to the working poor, the needy, and the surrounding community in Evanston and Rogers Park area. I wanted to make myself and the people I work with available to the people who need services. Now those people are becoming the old and young.” Rogers Park’s assets “Rogers Park is a very racially diverse population; its harmonious and a nice place to live. It seems to be growing and getting better day to day, month to month. It’s a very interesting area to be in.” Rogers Park obstacles “I’m not sure if there are any. I have not heard of much gang violence. There are some crime episodes. Health care services could be increased.” Accomplishments of Rogers Park “There is a building boom.” Important concerns for community members “With expanding population I am focusing on health care and do we have enough available services to meet the needs of growing population and to keep crime rate as low as possible and to attract the best citizens to the community.” Hopes and dreams “I would like to work together to utilize this building. The commissioner wants to work with me. I want to bring full service at reduced cost.” 72 Health care, quality of health care “Everywhere in the country there is expanding population, more people who are using health care services are using it with less revenue. Everywhere you go demands for practitioners or health care deliverers. It is so important to localize and centralize so people can come and receive maximum service such as dental, medical, chiropractic, and obstetrics in a specific location. We need to get services for medication. Cost of drugs are going up because Americans are living longer which requires more medicine. We should overcome by coming together to reduce cost and at the same time reduce the need for medication. Sometimes just good information or education can be helpful for the future. 73 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Vice President Organization: St. Francis Hospital, Resurrection Health Care System Type of Interview: In person Date: August 3, 2006 Tell me what “community health” means to you: • Community health is dependent on cooperation amongst health care providers. Only if all health care providers cooperate together do we raise the level of health care in the community. We can address the full spectrum of community health needs that starts with education/prevention and ends with treatment if we strategize and work together. If we bring community resources together, we do more than just fix the “broken arm”; we prevent the injury from ever occurring through educating about safety, for example. • Community health is holistic health, rather than disease management. It requires the total effort of the community to raise the level of health and wellness in the community. • This can vary in different sections of the community depending on socioeconomic and ethnocentric variants. For instance, in a completely gentrified subsection of the community, access to health care will not be an issue. But in other sections of the community, safety concerns for instance, can prevent a lowincome senior citizen from accessing health care. • For a community to be truly healthy, all service providers must be active participants in delivering health care to every subsection of the community. What are Rogers Park’s Strengths? • Rogers Park is a proactive community. Community residents care about the community and each other. Residents are directly invested in the community. What are Rogers Park’s Challenges? • Safety concerns and crime limits what Rogers Park could potentially be. • There are neglected segments of the Rogers Park Community. Senior Citizens are often neglected. There are not enough programs in place to assist seniors to maintain their independence in the community. Supportive services for senior citizens are a real need. • Residents who are low income and suffering from culturally prevalent diseases like diabetes and hypertension do not have access to the supportive services they need to properly manage their disease process. There is simply not a strong enough response to chronic illness in the community. 74 • The largest unmet health need in the community is access to pharmaceuticals. Most low income residents have to make difficult choices about buying medications. How does your organization contribute to the community? • St. Francis Hospital is the hospital closest to Rogers Park. We operate the largest not for profit clinic in the community on Clark Street. Last year we provided 13,000 patient visits, mostly to uninsured or underinsured Rogers Park residents at discounted or no cost. • St. Francis Hospital is the community’s trauma treatment center for motor vehicle crashes, violence, injury and all other types of trauma. • St. Francis Hospital and clinic provides health education to the community: prenatal classes, nutrition education, car safety programs and health fairs. We also do prevention health screenings for hypertension, diabetes and melanoma. • We all need to do more about educating the community about health care systems and the importance of seeking early treatment to avoid costly ER visits and hospitalizations. • A cooperative approach to community health care is every providers and residents responsibility. 75 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Director, Family Center Program Organization: Howard Area Community Center Type of Interview: In Person Date: June 6, 2006 How would you describe Rogers Park? • “Diverse in income and ages, unique housing stock, mixed cultures, tense at times. West Rogers Park vastly different than East Rogers Park” Describe the role of your agency in Rogers Park and its goals: • “The goals of the Family Center Campus at HACC are to support parents of Zero to 6 year olds. Assess and make sure all the children in the programs are healthy and developing appropriately. We support parents by assisting them to cope with social struggles like unemployment, domestic violence, drug addictions, parenting issues etc... The children in our programs are excited about learning, and when they leave us to transition to kindergarten, they are ready. Essentially we augment and assist with the developing child and family”. What are Rogers Park’s assets? • Close to public transportation, lake, bike trails, fun things to do. Rogers Park residents are committed to RP and take pride in the community. • Good partnerships amongst agencies in the community What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • Poorly performing Chicago Public Schools, need for affordable childcare (HACC has a waiting list of 600 children). • Crime and feeling unsafe are obstacles for this community. • Lack of quality health care; this has repeatedly been identified by community stakeholders. • Lack of early prenatal care is especially a concern. We need universal health care coverage for the working class, especially. • Employment/Job opportunities can be an obstacle. RP has jobs, but mainly service oriented jobs which are not high paying. 76 What are some of the accomplishments made by Rogers Park residents? • The Family Center Campus was built after a needs assessment revealed local parents had almost no access to affordable childcare. The FCC can accommodate 128 children, but we could use about five more Centers just like this one. What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park? • • • • Good paying, meaningful jobs in RP. Education Reform Affordable quality health care Increase in quality care services for Infants and Toddlers/Affordable childcare 77 Community Leadership Interview ________________________________________________________________________ Title: Police officer for 25 years, the last five years with CAPS Organization: Chicago Police Department, 24th District which includes Rogers Park Type of Interview: In Person Date: August 22, 2006 What does “community health” mean to you? Community health is affordable health care located in the community. What are Rogers Park’s assets? • Recently, it is the revitalization of the area. We have property owners, condo owners and apartment dwellers. All the new housing construction occurring has helped to stabilize the community. The downside is the reduction of affordable housing. Many low income families cannot afford to buy a condo-conversion and risk being displaced from the community. • There has been a revitalization of businesses too. The businesses on Clark and Devon Streets are thriving and expanding. We need more coffee houses and internet cafes. We need less dollar stores and liquor stores. • We are fortunate to have the youth programs we have in Rogers Park. HACC youth programs and YES (Youth employment services) have done a good job. But we need more structured programs for youth. • S&C Electric Company brings much needed industry/manufacturing jobs to the community. We need more industry jobs from large manufacturing businesses like S&C. But we have small thriving ethnic business which are thriving and doing well. • Loyola University is a very stabilizing influence in the community. They are a large employer, and many of their students live in Rogers Park surrounding the campus. Their instructors and professors live in Rogers Park bring many professionals to the area. Loyola has done much development to the campus and the surrounding area. This year they have the largest freshman class ever. • Rogers Park has many strong ethnic communities that get along well with each other. We strong and well developed Spanish, Pakistani, Indian and Jewish communities who work well with each other. • In some ways we communicate well. We have good email networks, and the various community groups are experienced at getting the word out about various issues. • Here at CAPS we continuously work on communicating with all different ethnic groups and age groups. We have nine beat meetings held monthly. We have started a new Spanish speaking beat meeting and a new Youth Beat meeting here at the district. We are hoping to meet with 12 to 15 neighborhood youths to 78 determine specific youth issues and take it from there. We will hold this initial youth forum soon. • We have great Senior Citizen Programs and Services in Rogers Park. We have the Council for Jewish elderly who provide social services and programming for seniors. We have four senior only housing buildings through CHO. We have plenty of long-term nursing homes in Rogers Park. I am not sure of their quality, just that they exist. We have special officers assigned to senior programs here at the station. We participate in the large three day senior fair being held next month. We estimate in the 24th District to have approximately eight to ten thousand senior citizens, but our borders are not exclusively Rogers Park. We support a senior citizen ID bracelet Program What are Rogers Park’s challenges? • We need meaningful employment opportunities, especially for youth. And we need to look at sustainable, affordable housing for low-income families. • Sullivan High School is overcrowded and it needs an enforceable dress code to be rid of gang colors and culture within the school. Sullivan High School is the only High School for thirty public and private grammar schools to feed into. So of course it is overcrowded. Sullivan High School needs to be a closed campus in order to keep the students and the community safe. • We need to bolster youth programs. We need more for kids to do after school. • We do not have enough mental health resources to deal with persons with chronic mental illness and addictions. It used to be the police could pick up and bring in someone intoxicated or high… for their own safety. We are unable to do that anymore. We need many more mental health resources, and perhaps this could be incorporated into a community health clinic. What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park? • • • • Affordable housing for low and fix income individuals and families. An increase in meaningful employment opportunities. An improved quality of life and the continuing revitalization of the community effort. Improved CPS educational opportunities especially at the high school level. 79 Qualitative Data: Focus Groups ________________________________________________________________________ Introduction (Note: The following two paragraphs are excerpted from, with minor changes, “Exercising Our Right to Health in Uptown,” a Community Health Assessment compiled by Christine Cannon, Shannon Kenney, and Nada Mlinarevich.) Focus groups are a way of gathering data through listening to people and learning from them (Morgan, 1998). The Rogers Park Community Health Assessment is based on the understanding that community members are experts on their own existence/experience. The use of focus groups allows for community members to converse with one another regarding health issues in Rogers Park as well as for us to learn more through listening to their conversation. The use of focus groups further allows for community members to participate in the research process by acting as cofacilitators, observers, and note takers. This process, often called participatory action research, endeavors to produce knowledge that is linked simultaneously and intimately to social action as well as helping the downtrodden to be self-reliant, self-assertive, and selfsufficient (Park, 1993). As is demonstrated below, each Rogers Park focus group took on its own character, as participants of each group took advantage of the opportunity in different ways. As a qualitative method, focus groups have certain strengths and limitations. Major strengths of focus groups are the ability to investigate complex behavior and motivations as well as diversity in the community (Morgan, 1998). Focus groups also provide an opportunity to focus on whole individuals and their relation to the community. Dietz (2001) utilized focus groups to gather preliminary data in planning an intervention to prevent obesity in African-Americans. Here, focus groups were seen as a way to engage the community in the research process and the issue at hand. Focus groups also have some limitations. Because focus groups rely on volunteers they have an unrepresentative sample, thus making the results hard to generalize to a larger population. Also, focus groups rely on individuals to accurately report their own experiences. Because these experiences are subjective and are subject to human error and perspective, it is often necessary to validate information gained in focus groups with other methods of research (Morgan, 1998). Had we unlimited time and resources, we would have conducted a comprehensive Rogers Park Community Health Assessment survey. Rogers Park Focus Groups on Community Health However, focus groups are very useful for gathering preliminary data. We were able to speak with several community groups: a youth organization, residents of a low income senior apartment building, members of a senior club (who reside in independent houses or apartments), a Latin American women’s support group. Other groups were considered, and in some cases initially contacted, but scheduling conflicts and other time constraints limited this process. Regardless, the results below demonstrate a clear repetition of themes and results between the various groups. What follows are profiles and session overviews of each group. Rogers Park Youth Network and Youth Intervention Program The Rogers Park Community Council convenes two youth programs, one a longstanding Youth Intervention Program, which focuses on reducing juvenile delinquency, youth crime and gang affiliation. The other, the Rogers Park Youth Network, also called 80 “Mayor Daley’s Region 1 Youth Net,” stems from a 1995 City of Chicago report calling for the coordination between community agencies for the benefit of teens aged 13-19 years old (www.rogerspark.org). The Youth Network and the Youth Intervention Program (YIP) work in tandem, and we met at one of their regular Wednesday afternoon meetings at the Rogers Park Community Council for an hour and a half to discuss community health. 26 youth were present, 15 women and 11 men, 21 African American and five Hispanic. Five YIP and Youth Net advisors served as conveners to the session as well as note takers and observers throughout the session. Advisors selected five peer leaders, or group discussants, from within the group of youth to lead each of five break-out sessions. Peer leaders, following a ten minute training session where they received a common set of questions about community health, took responsibility for leading the small discussion groups. We then convened as a large group, in order to review and clarify the discussed topics as a collective. In the breakout sessions, peer leaders asked, “What does community health mean to you?” Several youth immediately mentioned physical health, stating phrases as “Community Health is healthy kids,” “People are able to afford their medications in a healthy community,” “healthy kids and a better community,” “healthy, no disease,” and “free testing, clinics.” Youth comments were not restricted to bodily health, however. Most notably, youth were very concerned about “the street,” a term they repeated often. For example, when asked about what Rogers Park needed the most, several youth responded that we needed to “get bums off the street” and “drugs off the street.” Other phrases used were “clean up [drugs, bums] off the street,” and a few people mentioned we need more “street cleaning,” and that “Streets are clean in a healthy community.” “Bums,” “Drugs,” and “Clean Streets” – used both literally and euphemistically – were language that dominated the youth discussion. When asked “What works in Rogers Park?” many of the youth rapidly counted the local organizations that serve various social purposes, including their own. Most often mentioned was CeaseFire, a violence prevention initiative – particularly of shootings and killings (ceasefirechicago.org). Also repeated between groups was the local D.A.R.E. program (drug prevention), the Rogers Park “Clean and Green” initiative (cleaning litter out of public parks), and the Good News Community Soup Kitchen (see focus group discussion, below). Notably, these success stories that the youth either participate or witness in Rogers Park work toward the end of making “clean streets” the marker of a healthy community. In an information sheet passed around to group participants, we discovered that nearly every youth, in 17 out of 19 responses, reported having either Medicaid or Medicare. 11 out of 22 responses reported visiting an emergency room in the last 12 months at least one time, often two or three times. When asked “What concerns you most about your health?” youth responded most frequently “weight” and “cancer,” but also mentioned “my teeth,” “sex,” “diabetes,” and “getting the right medications.” When asked if they have any chronic health conditions, the only condition documented – by a quarter of the participants – was “asthma.” Howard Area Senior Club The Howard Area Senior Club is a support group of older women (in their 70s and 80s), who live in Rogers Park. The ten members present were interviewed in a full group. Our 81 opening question, “What does community health mean to you,” immediately elicited stories of transport to and from doctor’s offices. The first person stated it means that “there are doctors in the community who can see community people regardless of their ability to pay” (my emphasis). I emphasize “in the community,” because the following seven comments from participant indicated difficulties of physically getting themselves to a doctor. How do seniors of the club transport themselves to a doctor? Two participants reported using the public bus system; one stated that she must walk six blocks from the bus stop to her doctor in Evanston, and she “is finding it harder to walk that distance these days.” The second person takes a bus and “hopes that the weather cooperates” on doctor appointment days. Two seniors reported using “paratransit” and a “medicar” that takes them to doctors’ offices eight and 15 miles away, respectively. One participant noted that this system only worked for advance appointments – urgent care visits required calling a taxicab, costing considerably more money. Finally, two seniors reported that they have “mobile docs” or visiting nurses or doctors visit them in their homes, and one in particular noted that she “very fortunate” for the personal attention. In a follow up question, we asked members if they can afford their medications. All ten participants indicated that they could not. Three members told stories of skipping on medications in one form or another: one person fills only her heart medication prescriptions, another is on a fixed income and does not buy medicine (at a $7 copay) if she does not have the money, a third “maximizes” a bottle of blood pressure medicine by taking her pill every other day instead of every day. Regarding access to medicine, one senior receives her prescriptions by means of the county hospital’s mail order system. But for every medicine adjustment, she stated having to “go down to the county and wait for up to six to eight hours.” This reduces the wait to only an hour or two, but adds time and money to the ends of public transportation, repeating an earlier theme. When asked, “What are Rogers Park’s assets,” many of the responses had to do with transportation, either being thankful that a public transit system exists, or by mentioning that the post office, local library, and launder mat were in close proximity to their homes. Not only were the services important to the participants, but the accessibility or closeness of those services were important. In addition, one member stated that Howard Area Community Center helped to “maintain [her] independence,” specifically citing the work of a volunteer social worker. Finally, one senior noted that Northwestern and Loyola Universities played a role in “educating young children,” many of whom then worked with service agencies in the community. In response to the question, “What are Rogers Park’s obstacles,” three seniors immediately mentioned problems with grocery shopping. One person stated there was a “lack of affordable grocery stores,” another complained that the ALDI she frequented was too far away to travel to, and she was unable to bag her own groceries. Several seniors agreed with one member who wanted “less liquor and dollar stores and more large grocery stores with low cost delivery service.” Besides access to food, seniors discussed problems of affordable housing. One person stated that both apartment buildings on either side of her apartment building “went condo,” and she stated that she would not be able afford to live in her building if this happened. Three seniors stated that they live in section eight housing, but one stated that “the apartments are overcrowded with extended family, adult children, and grandchildren who come to live with grandma when they have no where else to go.” This contributed to “noise and chaos” in the building, and the group member suggested that “there needs to be enforcement of the rules which state that only the person on the lease can live 82 there.” Another woman stated that his rule was unfair, adding that she is the sole guardian of her nine year old granddaughter in her section eight apartment building. Seniors also mentioned issues of “more crime” and “more dangerous” neighborhoods now as opposed to twenty years ago. They cited “overcrowding,” “gang activity on the street,” and one stated that she “doesn’t socialize or go outside unless I have to.” Further, seniors agreed they felt that they knew people in the neighborhood years ago, so they felt safer. By linking “knowing people” to crime and safety, seniors demonstrate a loss of social capital – or the collective value of social networks – in their neighborhood (Putnam 2000). In response to the question, “What are you hopes and dreams for Rogers Park,” seniors overwhelmingly agreed they wanted “a large senior apartment building” or “senior center” with “activities and social services” built in Rogers Park. They collectively described a full service building with an attached community senior center, laundry, pool, nurse and social worker offices. The seniors would like to see some alternative types of housing situations available for them. One senior suggested “intergenerational low income housing.” Another mentioned that seniors have much to contribute in terms of “role modeling,” “good parenting skills,” and “living around younger people in a controlled environment.” Finally, seniors said they would hope a new clinic would hire a social worker to “just work with seniors” and could help them access resources and medications. They specifically mentioned they thought a social worker who could visit them at home, assess their capabilities and limits, could best address ways in which they could remain as independent as possible and therefore would be able to remain in the community. Centro Romero Women’s Leadership Group “I need to learn to live in pain,” stated one member of the Centro Romero Women’s Leadership Group, a support group for Hispanic women in the Rogers Park community. Mediated by an interpreter, 16 women (aged 17–62) took part in our focus group at the Centro Romero community center. The predominating theme for the women was affordability of medication, the first issue mentioned following our general opening question, “What does community health mean to you?” One woman stated: As it is now, most people in our community cannot afford to see a doctor in this community. There are no free clinics and the low cost clinics are not so low cost once you have to pay for medicines and procedures like procedures and x-rays to diagnose the problem. Two participants spoke specifically about the dollars they spend: One participant said she was sent to a hospital on the west side associated with the Access clinic on Howard. She had to pay the reduced rate for a diagnostic test which cost $282.00. She also had to spend $103.00 for medications. She said this was not “low cost” to her because she brings home about $1100.00 per month. Another participant was diagnosed with osteoporosis and the medicine was $130.00 per month, an amount she stated that she cannot afford. Here are the words of another group member, who seeks quality and affordable dental care: I think that community health means preventing health problems. I was diagnosed by a local dentist with extensive periodontal disease and I needed 83 specific oral health treatment. There are no low cost dental services anywhere in the city including this neighborhood. My dentist quoted me a price I could not afford. I am looking for low cost dental care that will treat my problem, and not simply advise me to have my teeth pulled. Another woman stated seeing a local physician for regular “excruciating menstrual pain” which left her unable to work or function a few days per month. The doctor ordered birth control pills for her to prevent the pain. She said she was able to afford them for a few months, and she received much relief from pain, but she has not been able to afford them for a few months. This woman stated, “I need to learn to live in pain.” Following this story, Monica Dillon, Community Nurse at Howard Area Community Center, referred this woman to the Evanston Board of Health who has access to “Title Ten federal funding for birth control at no cost.” On this theme of support through medicine referrals, another woman broke from the formal Q&A format of the focus group, and asked the other women, “How do you receive your medications?” Twelve of the women in the group said they have their medicines (specifically citing meds for diabetes, depression, and hypothyroidism) mailed to them from their home countries in Central and Latin America. They reported that these very same medicines are sold “over the counter” in their native countries. Often the women guess at the dosage of medicine they need to take and hope the medicine types are compatible to what their American doctors have ordered. Not only do these stories demonstrate a lack of affordability for medications, but they also indicate the value of such support groups, as convened by Centro Romero, in assisting women to share resources and get ideas about how to deal with their situations. In another instance, a woman said she “is very stressed with life here and cannot afford to see a therapist.” Her doctor prescribed antidepressants she cannot afford to buy. She stated “the whole situation is hopeless and there is no one to help. My family and friends are in Mexico.” Following this story, other women in the group suggested “walking,” “working out,” journaling her feelings, and “start going to church.” Finally, one group member told her she “felt the same way until I found this group which has helped me tremendously.” In response to the question, “What does not work [or are obstacles] in Rogers Park,” women immediately identified crime as a major problem in the community. One woman said she had witnessed a gang shooting and that she will “never be the same.” Some of the ladies requested information for a self-defense class, in which case Monica Dillon referred them to “Chicago Image,” a not-for-profit agency which teaches women selfdefense skills. Again, this is an example of the women of Centro Romero citing a problem, and immediately asking about resources in order to address that problem. A few women nodded in agreement when one group member cited concern for pedestrians, especially children, who run across Broadway (crossing against the light at Granville) without looking at traffic. She mentioned that “police should be present on school days to issue warnings to people who run across the busy street with small kids.” Another woman said she is concerned about childhood obesity because her children were overweight. She stated, “I don’t know what to cook, and I can’t take the children outside because it is unsafe and there are no places to bring kids to play.” She added that once the children turn five years old, there is no access to a WIC dietician. Notably, these concerns share a common theme of health and safety of young children. Women spent less time on the question, “What are Rogers Parks assets,” but pointedly mentioned that the public transportation system “helps to find work,” libraries “help with 84 learning about the U.S. and English,” Centro Romero assists in “support and education,” and public parks “are pretty and a place to bring children.” In conclusion, the women responded to the question “What are your hopes and dreams for Rogers Park” by responding that they want “happy and healthy people,” “advanced English classes” (Centro Romero provides only introductory courses), “a dentist to fix my teeth,” “less bars and less crime,” and “to be able to feel safe here.” Five of the women agreed and repeated the words of one group member who stated, “I need a low cost doctor and medicine.” Morse Avenue HUD Subsidized Senior Center. Nine residents gathered for an hour at a HUD subsidized Senior Center on Morse Avenue, including three black men, one white woman, one Hispanic man, and three black women. One of the residents, a black woman, was in a wheelchair. In response to the question, “What does community health mean to you,” members immediately mentioned problems of emergency services in the neighborhood. One person stated “a place in the neighborhood to be treated on an emergency basis,” and three other people mentioned delayed service when calling 911. When a fifth person added that “waiting for the CTA is an issue,” we asked where people went to the doctor, and if these places were hard to get to. A black woman sat back in her chair and replied slowly, “Let me tell you a story.” She described her trip to the doctor the day before our session, which involved taking public transportation, since her private transportation service was unavailable. She was fifteen minutes late to the office, and stated that “The doctor turned around and sent me home.” Later she stated that “the doctor was bitter to have to take my Medicaid.” She goes to Swedish Covenant Hospital. Eight out the nine residents agreed that they had problems with transportation to and from the doctor. In addition to this, residents thought that services should be located in a centralized location in the neighborhood. One man stated, “You don’t go to one grocery store to get biscuits and one to get corn meal. Why would medical assistance be so spread out?” One woman stated that her services at Swedish Covenant Hospital are centralized, but the central location is too far away. Clearly, this issue of centralized medical services is closely tied to the problem of transportation. Of interest, none of the residents cited problems of affording their medications, once prescribed. One woman even muttered, “That’s not the problem [her emphasis]” and returned to her stated problem of getting to a doctor in the first place. When asked “What benefits do you have in Rogers Park?” one resident said “the El,” or the Elevated public train. Indeed, as residents agreed and explained, there was an Elevated train stop only one block away from their apartment building. However, one woman in a wheelchair stated, “I wish they would build elevators at this stop.” This disabled resident reported that she could not wheel herself all the way to the next El station, as the sidewalks in her neighborhood were in disrepair, making for difficult wheelchair access. We asked if there were other “benefits” in the area besides the El; residents paused, and then said, “The 155 Bus,” which travels close to their building. We asked residents to comment on additional benefits. On the topic of food, which several people agreed that they liked the Morse Market because it was close and they delivered. We asked about entertainment, and residents listed organized places for activities (game room, exercise room, community center), community meetings they attend (tenants association, CAPS [local policing initiative] meeting) and “fishing.” Of interest, the residents’ stated reason for liking the Morse Market did not have to do with 85 price or selection, but rather the closeness in proximity and the delivery service. Further, the listed organized places for activities took place either in their building or at the community center next door. This, combined with the initial discussion of public transportation, suggests a strong interest in issues of proximity of activities and services. Finally, we asked the question of whether or not residents “feel safe.” To this, residents quickly and unanimously responded “No.” When asked “in what ways,” the woman in a wheelchair stated, “We need a generator for the elevator in case the power goes out.” After some discussion about the elevator, we discovered that there were no stairs in the building (in that any resident was aware), so the issue of an emergency generator was an important one to all. This problem was exacerbated by the comment of a new resident to the building, who stated “We need a good security guard.” He and the other residents then collectively told a story about a man who “got into the building” and was “knocking on doors” throughout the residence. Notably, both issues of safety took place inside the seniors’ apartment building. As the meeting broke up and we were leaving, the woman in the wheelchair concluded by a question to us, the organizers. She asked, “Is one of you going to say something about the generator?” Most likely, members of the community do not visit this senior residence, especially for the purpose of asking the residents about issues they have in their building and community. Monica suggested the name of an “advocate” located at the neighboring community center. Pointedly, similar to the Centro Romero women’s leadership group, the senior center group session ended in a time for exchanging community resources. Summary and Analysis The four interviewed groups highlighted different community health needs that clearly intersect at very important places. The youth, most concerned with the community health of “the street,” most commonly noted their gratitude for anti-violence, drug prevention, and educational community programs. Centro Romero women’s leadership group and the Howard Area Senior Club expressed great concern over availability of affordable medicine, and the low-income senior center residents focused on the accessibility to doctors in the first place, citing transportation as the most common problem facing them today. Most notably, the Howard Area Senior Club demonstrated an increasing lack of social capital, by means of not feeling safe, as well as by not having affordable services in close proximity to them in Rogers Park. They are aware of solutions to transportation problems, but they also are aware of the limitations of such solutions when traveling a distance does not assist in times of emergency. Similarly, group members are aware of solutions to affordability of medications, but these solutions involve inconveniences as traveling to the “county” and waiting in line, or depending on mail order programs for prescription medicine. The issue of social capital was present also in the Centro Romero session, as women cited ordering medications through relatives in their home countries, and then guessing as to the exact prescription and proper dosage. Further, a break down in services is present as the women took advantage of the presence of a community nurse to ask several questions about affordability and access to medicinal care. Not only are medicines not affordable or accessible, but they are not always aware of where to find them. In addition, the connecting theme of social networks arose in both the youth group and the low-income senior center group, in both positive and negative ways. Positive, as the 86 youth shared community and cited family resources, most often citing their “momma” or “grandmother” as the person who assists them in medical decisions. Negative, as residents of the senior center lacked a security guard or emergency exits in the case of power failure to their building – and further did not know who to ask about this problem. In sum, all four groups depended on other group members for resources and temporary solutions to their community health issues. Focus group members also collectively appreciated the presence of a community nurse for even a one hour session. Given the impact on these groups from even a one hour session, there is demonstrably a community need for greater communication of local medical experts and the various residents of Rogers Park. Expanding the resources and availability of local health professionals for low-income groups as these, and fostering increased communication of those resources with neighborhood groups and individuals, will increase the social network ties in the community and in turn improve the social capital of Rogers Park. Improving social capital by means of expanding community health resources will further realize the need for safer streets, be that literally and euphemistically. It will improve the access to activities and services, be that by means of quality transportation or by means of increasing local and centrally located services. Most importantly, as the women’s group of Centro Romero and the Howard Area Senior Club repeatedly stated, it will improve the affordability of care in the community, by means of both doctors’ visits and prescription medication. In all, these links will connect health professionals to lowincome members of the community in such a way that will improve the overall community health status of Rogers Park. Qualitative Data: Summary ________________________________________________________________________ Phase II of Rogers Park Community Health Assessment “Quality, Affordable Health Care for All” focused on collecting qualitative data from community leaders and focus groups of community residents. This phase aims to lay the foundation for planning, implementing and evaluating current and future access to health care systems and education. 87 Conclusion ________________________________________________________________________ This community health assessment was initiated in order to improve health care access for all Rogers Park residents. The Rogers Park community is a diverse community of people who are its strongest asset. While the existing health care providers are working to provide quality health care, they can no longer accommodate the increasing numbers of uninsured and underinsured community members and their health care needs. Community health limitations include: • • • • • • • • • • • • Reaching out to pregnant women to connect them with early prenatal care services. Working to prevent childhood obesity with a special emphasis on promoting physical activity. Establishing a medical home model for all community members in Rogers Park. Initiating a disease case management approach to chronic illness, especially for community members suffering from chronic asthma, diabetes, and hypertension. Special attention needs to be made to address the lack of adolescent health providers The need for expansion of primary pediatric and adult health care services with an emphasis on prevention. Diagnostic Services. Access to specialists and specialty care. Access to truly affordable medications. Women’s Health/Reproductive Health services and Title X Funding. Health education to prevent injury and window falls. Health literacy awareness. Specific disease processes that need special attention are respiratory illnesses (influenza, pneumonia, COPD, and lower respiratory diseases), HIV/AIDS, sexually transmitted infections, lung and colon cancer prevention, liver diseases. Behavioral health interventions such as early violence prevention, including anger management, conflict resolution and dealing with frustration should be incorporated into health curriculums starting in preschool. Providing seamless, compassionate and comprehensive care to victims of domestic violence by partnering with existing domestic violence prevention programs is also important. 88 References ________________________________________________________________________ American Lung Association. (2006). Trends in Asthma Morbidity and Mortality. Retrieved September 14, 2006 from http://www.lungusa.org. Chicago Asthma Facts 2005. Retrieved September 1, 2006 from http://www.lungchicago.org/site/files/487/ 23882/88861/135505/ASTHMA_FACT_SHEET_Chicago_05_05.pdf Chicago Department of Public Health. (2006). Chicago Community Health Profile; Rogers Park. Retrieved August 12, 2006 from http://www.cityofchicago.org/Health/profiles The University of Chicago Asthma Center. (2005). Asthma Among Medicaid Recipients. Retrieved August 15, 2006 from http://www.chicagoasthmaatlas.org. Greatschools.net. (2005). Your Free On-line Guide to K-12 Schools. Retrieved September 21, 2006, from http://www.greatschools.net/cgi_bin/il/other/print/1092 Howard Area Community Center. History of Howard Area Community Center. Retrieved July 18, 2006 from http://www.howardarea.org. Disease tightens grip in Illinois doc. (2004) Retrieved September 10, 2006, from http://www.asthmaactionplanchicago.org/site/files/ Dey, A., & Bloom,B. (2005) Summary Health Statistics for US Children: National Health Survey. Vital Health Statistics. Retrieved July 8, 2006, from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_10/sr10_223.pdf. Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. (2006). Rogers Park, Chicago. Retrieved on September 25, 2006 from, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Park The Institute of Medicine. (2005) Health Literacy: A Prescription to End Confusion. Retrieved on July 30, 2006 from, http://www.iom.edu/?id=19750 The National Coalition Against Domestic Violence (2006). Health Care & Domestic Violence Facts. Retrieved on September 1, 2006, from, http://[email protected] Chicago Crime. (2006) Crimes by District/District 24 (Rogers Park), District 24/Beat 2422, Beat 2423, Beat 2424, Beat 2431, Beat 2432. Retrieved on October 9, 2006 from, http://www.chicagocrime.org/district/24/ City of Chicago. (2006) What is CAPS? Retrieved on September 2, 2006 from http://egov.cityofchicago.org/city/webportal/jsp/content/showDynamicContentItem.jsp?t op... Chicago Safe Start. (2006) About Chicago Safe Start. Retrieved on July 3, 2006 from, http://chicagosafestart.net/Components/AboutSafeStart.asp 89 Adults and Children Together Against Violence. (2006) Early Violence Prevention. Retrieved on July 7, 2006 from, http://www.actagainstviolence.org/violprevent/index.html Rogers Park Community Council. (2006) Retrieved on July 18, 2006 from, http://www.rogerspark.org DevCorp North. (2006). Our Mission, Vision and Values. Retrieved on October 9, 2006 from, http://www.rogers-park.com/2006/06/our_mission_vis_html National Library of Medicine, National Institute of Health. (2006). Understanding Health Literacy and its Barriers. Retrieved on August 6, 2006, from, http://www.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/cbm/healthliteracybarriers.html WLUW. (2006). 88.7 Independent Community Radio. Retrieved on August 2, 2006 from, Http://www.wluw.org Loyola Phoenix. (2006). The Phoenix. Retrieved on September 29, 2006, from, Http://www.loyolaphoenix.com/home/generalinformation/ Center for Reproductive Rights. (2006). Title X Family Planning. Retrieved on September 30, 2006, from, Http://www.crlp.org/pub_fac_titlex2.html Chicago Defender. (2006). History. Retrieved on October 8, 2006, from, Http://www.chicagodefender.com/page/aboutus.cfm Chicago Reader. (2006). About the Chicago Reader Publications. Retrieved on October 8, 2006, from Http://www.chicagoreader.com/readerinc/aboutR.htm Metro Chicago Information Center. (2006). Profiles of Selected Social. Demographic, Economic and Housing Characteristics of Rogers Park: 2005 Estimates and 2010 Projections. Retrieved on September 4, 2006, from Http://www.info.mcfol.org/www/datainfo/mapreports/census05_dp2.asp?cname=01&are a=a City of Chicago. (2006). Casting Chicago’s Health Care Safety Net: A 12-year Review of Chicago’s Community-Based Primary Care Systems. Retrieved on June 3, 2006, from, Http://www.cchsd.org/pdfs/summitdr.pdf Rogers Park Community Council. (2206). Our Neighborhood. Retrieved on August 7, 2006, from, Http://www.rogerspark.org/Rogers%20Park%20-20demographics.htm Chicago Area Housing. (2006). CCA Rogers Park, Demographics, Property. Retrieved from Http://www.chicagoareahousing.org/Query_DisplayData.asp?nodisplay=f&pf=t&sort=& Anderson, E.T.& McFarlane, J. (2000) Community Assessment, Chapter 9. Community as a Partner: Theory and Practice in Nursing, 3rd ed. Lippincott. Misericordia (2006), Retrieved on October 1, 2006, from, www.misericordia.org. Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park (2006), Retrieved on September 12, 2006, from, www.healthyrp.org 90 Office of the Surgeon General (2006), Health Priorities, Retrieved on September 12, 2006, from, www.surgeongeneral.gov. Access Community Health Network (2006), Retrieved on September 12, 2006, from, www.accesscommunityhealth.net. Resurrection Health Care, Community Clinics (2006), Retrieved on September 12, 2006, from, www.Reshealth.org/locations/community_clinics.cfm Loyola University of Chicago, Key Facts, (2006), Retrieved on September 14, 2006, from, www.luc.edu/keyfacts/ Interactive Illinois Report Card (2006), Retrieved on September 14, 2006, from, http://iirc.niu.edu/scripts/schools.asp? Chicago ICAM (2006), Retrieved on September 30, 2006, from, http://12.17.79.6/ctznicam/ctznicam.asp Northeastern Illinois Planning Commission (2006), Retrieved on September 4, 2006, from, http://www.nipc.org/test/y2k_sfi_cca.htm Child Health Data Lab, The Mary Ann and J. Milburn Smith Child Health Research Program, Children’s Memorial Research Center (2005), Child and Adolescent Injury in Chicago, 1999-2001. History of Rogers Park Sources: Loyola University Rogers Park Community Council "Chicago's Far North Side - An Illustrated History of Rogers Park and West Ridge" by Neal Samors, Mary Jo Doyle, Martin Lewin and Michael Williams. Oral interviews, various residents Recreation Sources: Artists of the Wall Festival Chicago Coalition for the Homeless Chicago Park District Chicago Police Department Chicago Public Library "Chicago's Far North Side - An Illustrated History of Rogers Park and West Ridge" Book by Neal Samors, Mary Jo Doyle, Martin Lewin and Michael Williams, 2006 91 Eidolon Art Studio Glenwood Avenue Arts Festival Great Lakes Information Network Heartland Cafe Illinois Department Natural Resources Lake Michigan Forum Loyola University Metropolitan Water Reclamation District “Morsehellhole” blog “Nature’s Metropolis”, Book: by William Cronin, 1991 Neighbors for a Healthy Rogers Park Observations and Measurements, by Jim Ginderske, 2006 Oral Interviews with Neighborhood Residents, June-Sep., 2006 Rogers Park Community Council Rogerspark.org US Coast Guard US Environmental Protection Agency Wisdom Bridge Arts Project Health Status Sources: City of Chicago Department of Public Health Office of Epidemiology (2006). Community Area Health Inventory. Consortium to Lower Obesity in Chicago Children (CLOCC) 2005 Annual Report. USEPA. Childhood Lead Poisoning in Chicago: Mapping a Strategy to Improve Screening. Chicago Department of Public Health (October, 2005) “Serving Chicago’s Underserved; Regional Health Systems Profiles” Chicago Department of Public Health (2006). “Casting Chicago’s Health Care Safety Net: A 12-Year Review of Chicago’s Community-Based Primary Care System”. 92 Center for Reproductive Rights, www.crlp.org/pub_fac_titlex2.html Focus Groups Sources: Dietz, W. (2001). “Focus group data pertinent to the prevention of obesity in AfricanAmericans.” American Journal of Medical Sciences, 322(5), 275-278. Morgan, D.L. (1998). The Focus Group Guidebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Park, P. (1993). “The essence of Uptown: Can the latest hot neighborhood move up without leaving itself behind?” Chicago Tribune online edition. Putnam, Robert. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of the American Community. New York: Simon and Schuster. 93 Appendix ________________________________________________________________________ Community Leadership Interview and Focus Group Questions The following interview is to be conducted in a semi-structured format. Use the following questions as a guideline to solicit information from the interviewee. Please write down the community leaders answers in a summary format, but also using quotes when needed for effect. Feel free to use your own interviewing style and interject clarifying questions as needed. 1. Describe Rogers Park: 2. Describe the role of your agency, institution or business in Rogers Park including the goals of your organization: 3. What are Rogers Park’s assets? 4. What are Rogers Park’s obstacles? 5. What accomplishments have been made by resident’s of Rogers Park? 6. What are the most important concerns for the community members of Rogers Park? 7. Comment on the resources and organizations at work in the community? 8. What are the hopes and dreams for the future of Rogers Park? 9. Access to affordable health care: Do community stake holders identify this as an area of concern? 10. Is there anything you would like to say about health care, quality of health care, access to health care, and/or access to affordable medications in Rogers Park? 94 U.S. Census Bureau: 2004 Industry Code Summary Zip Code 60626 Chicago, IL Total for ZIP Code 60626 Number of establishments: 553 First quarter payroll in $1,000: 63,517 Number of employees: 9,159 Annual payroll in $1,000: 268,168 Number of Establishments by Employment-size class Industry Code Industry Code Description Total Estabs 1-4 1019 5-9 20-49 5099 1000 or more 100- 250- 500249 499 999 ------ Total 553 376 84 28 37 18 6 2 0 2 23---- Construction 12 9 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 31---- Manufacturing 15 7 2 1 4 0 0 0 0 1 42---- Wholesale trade 20 17 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 44---- Retail trade 102 75 16 2 7 2 0 0 0 0 48---- Transportation & warehousing 7 3 3 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 51---- Information 12 10 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 52---- Finance & insurance 26 17 7 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 53---- Real estate & rental & leasing 48 33 11 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 54---- Professional, scientific & technical servi 52 46 2 0 3 1 0 0 0 0 55---- Management of companies & enterprises 3 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 56---- Admin, support, waste mgt, remediation ser 18 14 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 61---- Educational services 13 6 1 2 2 1 0 0 0 1 62---- Health care and social assistance 84 36 21 6 6 8 5 2 0 0 Arts, 71---- entertainment & recreation 16 13 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 Accommodatio n & food services 63 34 9 8 9 3 0 0 0 0 60 52 6 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 72---81---- Other services (except public administration 95 (except public administration 99---- Unclassified establishments 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 HEALTH STATISTICS U.S. 4.9 U.S. 15 U.S. 4.8 U.S. 9.5 Deaths from AIDS/HIV – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago 3.9 12 Rogers Park 21 Number of New AIDS Cases – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 13.2 37 66 TB Cases –Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago 8.5 13 Rogers Park 14 Chronic Liver Disease/ Cirrhosis –Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 8.2 11 15 Chronic Lower Respiratory Disease – Rate per 100,000 U.S. Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 43.5 38.4 33 52 U.S. 192 Cancer – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago 193 212 Rogers Park 252 U.S. 2.2 New Cases of Syphilis – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago 5.7 12 Rogers Park 22 U.S. 116 New Cases of Gonorrhea – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 166 477 339 96 U.S. 304 New Cases of Chlamydia – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 379 852 592 U.S. 3.6% Percentage of Mothers Receiving No Prenatal Care Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 4% 1.8% 4.1% U.S. 222.7 Heart Disease – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago 236 287 Rogers Park 320 U.S. 25.5 Diabetes – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago 24 30 Rogers Park 35 U.S. 22.4 Influenza and Pneumonia – Rate per 100,000 Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 22.7 26 42 Children Age Six and Younger with Elevated Blood Lead Levels – Rate per 1,000 U.S. Illinois Chicago Rogers Park 15 16 31 47 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106