September 2012 Oklahoma Publisher
Transcription
September 2012 Oklahoma Publisher
The Oklahoma Publisher Official Publication of the Oklahoma Press Association www.OkPress.com www.Facebook.com/okpress INSIDE ONF INTERNS: For the next three months students who interned at member newspapers share their experiences. Read what the first six have to say about working at newspapers – and the ONF Internship Program. PAGE 8 GRAMMAR GUIDE: Dr. Terry Clark takes on punctuation with an easy-to-use guide in his monthly column. PAGE 16 SUPERHEROES: Read Jeff Shultz’s second installment of his visits to Oklahoma newspapers. PAGE 18 Vol. 83, No. 9 20 Pages • September 2012 Judge unseals records in Enid perjury case Van Dyck also said he was aware of the “appearance of impropriety” in the original sealing of the court records and that keeping those records sealed would “heighten suspicions.” News & Eagle pub‘With openness, Oklahomans lisher Jeff Funk said the can have greater confidence newspaper was pleased with the judge’s deciin their court system.’ sion. Jeff Funk, Enid News & Eagle publisher “The criminal charge against attorney Eric on Sept. 4 that the paper had Edwards should have been grounds to intervene in the handled as other such chargcase and that court records es are handled — with public pertaining to the case should records in open court,” Funk said. be unsealed. “We hope other judges take “The court finds the newspaper has a First Amendment note of this ruling. The court right to publish the news as it system was designed to serve finds it,” Van Dyck said. “The the public, all Oklahomans, public needs to know what its and criminal cases need to elected officials are up to. The remain open to the public. public has a right to know.” The court records of a sealed felony perjury case were finally unsealed after the Enid News & Eagle sued to intervene in the case. Grady County District Judge Richard Van Dyck ruled Continued on Page 3 The Nowata Printing Company in Nowata, Okla., sustained damage from a passing storm front on Sept. 7, 2012. Missing sections of the roof exposed the newsprint storage area resulting in a sizable paper loss, said Mike Brown, publisher of Neighbor News publications in the Tulsa area. Neighbor News publications are printed at Nowata Printing. Both companies are owned by Community Publishers, Inc. Brown said all presses are up and running and no delays on any printing schedules were expected. Observe National Newspaper Week October 7-13 National Newspaper Week, a week-long promotion of the newspaper industry in the United States, will be celebrated October 7-13. The theme this year is “NEWSPAPERS – The cornerstone of your community.” The theme and supporting materials were developed by the Michigan Press Association. The packet is available to download at www.nationalnewspaperweek.com. Material includes the 2012 NNW logo, a crossword puzzle and word search, and an editorial cartoon. Also available are columns by Caroline H. Little, president and CEO of the Newspaper Association of America; Mike MacLaren, executive director for the Michigan Press Association; Ron Dzwonkowski, associate editor for the Detroit Free Press, and U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers (R-MI). Newspaper Association Managers (NAM) has sponsored and supported – and made material available – to all newspapers NNW since 1940. National Newspaper Week is the only industry observance of newspapers during the year. 2 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 UP, UP AND AWAY! 23$35(6,'(17·6&2/801 &HOHEUDWLQJ1HZVSDSHU+HURHV3DVW3UHVHQW By Jeff Shultz, Garvin County News Star The history of newspapers in our nation and state is a rich story, filled with many historical figures that either influenced our nation or shaped the literary world after their work in the newspaper industry. Two men in particular are personal heroes of mine – Benjamin Franklin and Mark Twain. You all know their stories. Franklin was one of the founding fathers of our country while Twain gave us memorable stories and characters that have stood the test of time. In 1730 there were two so-called newspapers in Philadelphia – The American Mercury and The Universal Instructor and Pennsylvania Gazette. Both were more like newsletters than newspapers, often reprinting instructional material on the arts and sciences from other books or newssheets. Franklin took over the Instructor in 1730 and changed its name to simply the Pennsylvania Gazette. The Gazette quickly became one of the more popular newspapers in the original colonies. Franklin used the paper to promote his experiments and philosophical and political viewpoints. In 1752, Franklin used the paper to give a third-person account of his now famous kite experiment, though he didn’t mention the fact it was he that conducted the test. Under his leadership, the paper became the first paper to publish an editorial cartoon. Titled “Join or Die,” the May 1754 cartoon depicted a snake cut into various parts, with each segment of the snake labeled with the initials of one of the colonies at that time. Franklin, who was the artist, accompanied the cartoon with an editorial about the “disunited state of the colonies” and the cartoon was used to help make his point about the need for colonial unity. The Gazette also was instrumental in providing news of the Revolution. In July of 1776, for example, the front page of the paper had a list of military actions announced by John Hancock. While Franklin used his newspaper as a means to inform and influence Americans on the upcoming Revolution, Mark Twain used his newspaper experiences to further his career as a storyteller. Twain admitted his career as an author would not have come about if it weren’t his work as a newspaper reporter. His big break came in 1866 as he was working on the Hawaiian island of Oahu. Twain had heard of the tale of two brothers who had been shipwrecked and got the scoop on what happened. Most of his life up to that point had been spent in the newspaper business, starting at the age of 12 as a printer’s apprentice for the Missouri Courier. But it was his stint in Oahu as a correspondent for the Sacramento Union that got his pen name published nationwide. When two Stamford, Conn., brothers washed ashore in Honolulu, they had been on a longboat for 43 days, ultimately surviving on strips of their own boots after 10 days of rations had depleted. The two were sailing to California to seek a better life and healthier climate, since one of them had contracted tuberculosis. However, the ship they were on caught fire off the coast of South America, forcing them to abandon ship and drift aimlessly at sea. When the news reached Twain, he was suffering from what he called “saddle-boils,” which made it difficult to walk or sit. Twain convinced the U.S. Minister to China to carry him on a stretcher to the hospital where the brothers were being treated. He spent the next night writing the story of their ordeal. When he finished the story he was able to just catch the ship sailing for Sacramento, Calif., tossing the manuscript onto the ship as it sailed away. The story was published in the Union and was soon telegraphed to newspapers across the nation, thus introducing Twain to a much larger audience of readers who would later give us such memorable characters as Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer. THE FIRST OF SIX regional workshops on the Open Meeting and Open Records Acts begins this month. On Sept. 27, representatives from the Oklahoma Attorney General’s office will be on hand in Lawton to answer questions concerning the state’s open meeting and records laws and inform elected or appointed officials about their responsibility under the acts. The meeting will be held from 1-4 p.m. at the Great Plains Technology Center, 4500 W. Lee Blvd., in Lawton. This is a good time for your elected officials to gain a deeper understanding of the laws, which we as a press association are watchdogs over. The meetings will also be some good, free training for new reporters on your staff. Please plan to encourage public officials in your area, as well as staff members, to attend one of these important workshops. For a complete listing of where the seminars will be held, go to the OPA’s website. OVER THE PAST SEVERAL MONTHS, many of our members have been extremely busy covering wildfires and other breaking news stories in their area along with the normal news coverage they give their readers on a daily or weekly basis. It takes a lot of dedication and drive to cover everything and sometimes it can be mentally and physically draining. The commitment to excellence is evident as I look over some of the papers I get as exchange papers and I just want to say how proud I am of our association and everyone for doing such a great job. OPA CALENDAR OF EVENTS Complete Listing of Events at www.OkPress.com THU., OCT. 18, WEATHERFORD OPEN MEETING/OPEN RECORDS ACTS SEMINAR Attorney General Scott Pruitt, the Oklahoma Press Association and Oklahoma Newspaper Foundation invite you to attend a seminar designed to deal directly with your questions and concerns about Oklahoma’s Open Meeting and Records Acts. Oklahoma First Attorney General Rob Hudson and Communications Director Diane Clay will present the seminar. It’s free and open to the public. The seminar will be held six times in 2012 across the state. For more information, a press release or a letter from the attorney general’s office, visit okpress.com/eventscalendar. Other dates of seminars include: THU., OCT. 25, Oklahoma City, OK THU., NOV. 29, McAlester, OK THU., DEC. 6, Tulsa, OK THU., DEC. 13, Enid, OK For more information on upcoming events, visit the OPA website at www.OkPress.com or contact Member Services Director Lisa Potts at (405) 499-0026, 1-888-815-2672 or e-mail [email protected]. Chickasha Leader applies for OPA business membership The Chickasha Leader has applied for business membership in the Oklahoma Press Association. The application lists Jerry Pittman as owner, publisher, editor and advertising manager. The twice-weekly (Wednesday and Friday) publication is located at 428 W. Kansas Ave. in Chickasha, Okla. The Leader’s website is chickashaleader. com. The Leader was admitted to the United States mails as Periodicals mail matter on Sept. 15, 2010. The newspaper is printed in Canadian County and entered in the U.S. mails at Chickasha, Okla. Any current business member wishing to object to application of the Chickasha Leader must do so in writing to the OPA at 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd., Oklahoma City, OK 73105-5499, by Oct. 5, 2012. The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 RECORDS Continued from Page 1 “When cases are improperly closed, it gives the appearance of favoritism or improper treatment,” said Funk. “With openness, Oklahomans can have greater confidence in their court system.” Major County District Judge Ray Dean Linder sealed the court records of a felony perjury case against attorney Eric Edwards on May 17, hours after the case was filed. No hearings, announcements or notice of sealing the case were given. Judge Van Dyck dismissed the perjury case on July 16 after Oklahoma County District Attorney David Prater filed a motion to dismiss, stating the case lacked merit. On June 26, the News & Eagle filed its motion to intervene in the case and to unseal the records. Stephen Jones, Edwards’ attorney, objected to the intervention, stating the News & Eagle had violated a gag order about the case. Mike Minnis, representing the News & Eagle, said Jones’ objection was “based on an assumption that somehow the Enid News & Eagle has violated an order it has never seen…The Enid News & Eagle has never seen the order or been given the order.” Minnis also told the court he believed the newspaper had several rights to have the records made public. “The court has held there is a constitutional right, and I believe there is a statutory right, and that’s the Open Records Act,” Minnis said. Jones argued that not all court records are open to public view and that it was not Judge Linder’s intention to keep the records sealed until the paper began to report on the case. “If the newspaper would have just waited a few days, Judge Linder would have unsealed the records, but he was never given that opportunity,” Jones said. Jones also asked for the probable cause affidavit to remain sealed. However, Minnis argued that the unsealing is for the benefit of Edwards. “If this whole case is a sham brought by a district attorney or a judge, the probable cause affidavit he is trying to keep sealed will not embarrass his client,” Minnis said. “If he (Linder) was going to open them, I don’t see why it is harmful now.” The records were released to the News & Eagle on Sept. 5. Court to decide if private contractor is in violation of Open Records Act The Oklahoma Supreme Court has been asked to decide whether a private contractor charging subscription fees for online court records while allowing a select group to access the records is a violation of the Open Records Act. After multiple complaints, Mike Evans, administrative director of the courts, asked the Supreme Court to look at the practice of the contractor KellPro. Kellpro only allows Oklahoma Bar Association members to purchase subscription access to online court records in the 64 counties serviced by KellPro’s On Demand Court Records (ODCR) system. In those counties, residents can access court dockets online but only Oklahoma Bar Association members can download the actual court documents. Subscriptions to ODCR cost $50 per month or $600 per year. Residents that are not members of the state bar association have to drive to individual county courthouses to retrieve the documents and often must pay for copies. Currently, there are two online court records systems in the state. ODCR and the Oklahoma State Courts Network (OSCN). Since 2007, Oklahomans have been paying for the construction of a statewide, free public court system for free public records. The new system should phase out both OSCN and ODCR. The unified system is at least six months to one year behind schedule. Until the new unified system is completed, residents looking for records in OSCN districts like Tulsa and Oklahoma counties have more access to records than those in counties served by KellPro’s system. “This setup gives one organization special access to records that are clearly public; the Open Records Act doesn’t allow for that,” said Joey Senat, a board member of Freedom of Information Oklahoma, Inc. KellPro maintains the state directed the company to only allow bar association members to purchase subscriptions while the state maintains they weren’t asked before KellPro created the subscription system with court clerks in counties using ODCR. The Oklahoma Publisher ISSN 1526-811X Official Publication of the Oklahoma Press Association PUBLISHER Mark Thomas [email protected] EDITOR Jennifer Gilliland [email protected] OPA OFFICERS Jeff Shultz, President The Garvin County News Star Jeff Mayo, Vice President Sequoyah County Times Gracie Montgomery, Treasurer The Purcell Register Mark Thomas, Executive Vice President, Oklahoma City OPA DIRECTORS Rusty Ferguson, Past President The Cleveland American Jeff Funk, Enid News & Eagle Robby Trammell, The Oklahoman OU student media begins study Internet entrepreneur Rob Curley was slated to kick off a semester-long study of student media offerings at the University of Oklahoma on Sept. 17. Curley has spearheaded change in new media and interactive news at the Washington Post and elsewhere. The study, Imagine the Future: Campus Media in a Digital Age, will help OU Student Media determine the future course of its 96-year-old independent student newspaper, The Oklahoma Daily, and its website, OUDaily.com. The study will include a student survey, roundtable discussions, advertiser focus groups and other events. A blog (http://imaginedfuture.wordpress.com/) will keep the community informed about each event and the study’s progress. Curley, who was named metro editor of the Pulitzer Prize-winning Orange County Register in August, was scheduled to discuss how journalism and society are evolving as a result of changing media technology, changing uses and changing relationships between the players. “I hope Rob Curley will present details about how he made money from his digital news sites, said Mark Thomas, Oklahoma Press Association executive vice president. “That’s a presentation we would all like to hear. Otherwise we’re just imagining a future where we all go broke.” Curley has worked in management positions at the Topeka (Kansas) Capital-Journal, the Lawrence (Kansas) Journal-World, the Washington Post, the Naples (Florida) Daily News and the Las Vegas Sun, where he was chief content editor for the paper’s Internet media division. Dayva Spitzer, Sayre Record & Beckham County Democrat Brian Blansett, Shawnee News-Star Mike Brown, Neighbor News Ted Streuli, The Journal Record 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd. Oklahoma City, OK 73105-5499 (405) 499-0020 Toll-Free in Oklahoma: (888) 815-2672 www.OkPress.com [email protected] www.Facebook.com/OKPress SUBSCRIBE TO THE OKLAHOMA PUBLISHER $12 PER YEAR THE OKLAHOMA PUBLISHER (USPS 406-920) is published monthly for $12 per year by the Oklahoma Press Association, 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd., Oklahoma City, OK 73105-5499. Periodicals postage paid at Oklahoma City, OK. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to THE OKLAHOMA PUBLISHER, 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd., Oklahoma City, OK 73105-5499. 3 4 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 Morgans sell Wetumka newspaper After 55 years in the Morgan family, the Hughes County Times in Wetumka has been sold. Bill and Dayna Robinson, owners of the Holdenville Tribune, The Allen Advocate and Coalgate Record-Register, bought the paper earlier this month. Bill Morgan took over the Wetumka Gazette in 1957 and renamed it the Hughes County Times. Following his death on Feb. 2, 2012, his daughter, Julie Morgan, stepped into that role. “My Dad, Bill Morgan, dedicated his life to the Times and The Weleetkan newspapers as the newspaper business was his passion,” said Julie. “We feel confident The Robinsons will produce the Hughes County Times in the same style our readers know and have depended on for the last 55 years.” The Robinsons plan to keep the same format of the paper as the Morgans. Two longtime Hughes County Times staff members, Peggy Smith and Tracy Goza, will remain at the paper. In addition to their newspapers, the Robinsons also own Lewis Printing. Bill Robinson served eight years in the legislature and also served as Holdenville’s mayor. Longtime Clinton Daily News staff member plans to retire Clinton Daily News’ employee Ann Marcy is retiring from the newspaper business after more than 20 years of service. Marcy has spent most of the last five years working in the composing department at The Clinton Daily News. Before that, Marcy worked at the Weatherford Daily News for 17 years and also spent time working in Lubbock and Amarillo, Texas. She spent most of her newspaper career as a reporter before working in the composing department at Clinton. “I just like words and going out and talking to people and finding out about a lot of things when reporting,” Marcy said. In addition to putting together each page of The Clinton Daily News, Marcy has also been responsible for looking through the paper’s bound volumes to come up with material for the “This Week in History” segment. She will still continue in that capacity. “I’ve always been a history buff,” Marcy said. “Most of it I can remember from living here and I look forward to doing it. Now I can take my time or spend as much time with it as I want.” Rod Serfoss, publisher of the Clinton Daily News, said he hates to see Marcy retire, but is happy for her. “The combination of her work ethic and skills will be sorely missed,” Serfoss said. City Sentinel announces staff changes Lee Vincent, graphics designer at The City Sentinel in Oklahoma City, has been promoted to the position of creative and content director. Former City Sentinel managing editor Stacy Martin will become a full-time staff reporter for CapitolBeatOK.com. She will stay on at The City Sentinel as a contributing editor. “I have appreciated Stacy Martin’s skills as a journalist since I first met her when we both worked at The Oklahoman,” said Patrick McGuigan, editor of CapitolBeatOK.com and associate publisher of The City Sentinel. “I am blessed to have her join the staff of the Oklahoma Capitol Bureau.” Vincent has won awards for her page one design from the Society of Professional Journalists. She “has proven herself as a capable ‘conductor’ of weekly production at the newspaper,” said McGuigan. Martin was a real estate and business reporter for The Oklahoman in the 1980s and ’90s. She was also a business reporter at the Tulsa Tribune. The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 5 Elk City Daily News names new editor Veteran journalist J.B. Blosser Bittner recently joined The Elk City Daily News as managing editor. “We could not be more excited to have such an experienced and enthusiastic journalist join our team,” Daily News publisher Elizabeth Perkinson said. An Oklahoma native, Bittner holds a bachelor’s degree in news-editorial journalism from Oklahoma State University. She was the 2003 recipient of the Oklahoma Newspaper Foundation’s Beachy Musselman Award, recognizing contributions to the field of printed journalism. Bittner has received top Associated Press and Oklahoma Press Association awards for news reporting, including a number of investigative projects. She is a member of the board of directors of the Associated Press Media Editors as well as a member of Investigative Reporters and Editors and the Society of American Business Editors and Writers. Bittner served 12 years with Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc., most recently as editor of the Stillwater NewsPress. She previously worked at the corporate level as a CNHI News Service national editor and has been CNHI Oklahoma bureau chief and managing editor of the Woodward News. Before joining CNHI, Bittner staffed a Northwest Oklahoma bureau 12 years for the Enid News & Eagle, was Northwest correspondent for the Oklahoman and was a staff writer, legislative reporter and bureau manager for United Press International. She also has been an adjunct journalism instructor for Northwestern Oklahoma State University. Cherokee Messenger & Republican welcomes new managing editor After months of searching, the Cherokee Messenger & Republican has hired a new editor, Kathleen Lourde. Lourde grew up in Oklahoma, spending some time at Woodward High School before graduating from Jenks High School near Tulsa. She has been a resident of rural Dacoma for the last eight years. She attended Oklahoma State University and then moved on to State University of New York at Buffalo and two years at Old Dominion University. She started her journalism career in 1992 as editor at Our Own Com- munity Press in Norfolk, Va. In 1997, she became senior editor for Provider magazine, covering business, finance and politics. After spending years in the Washington D.C. area, Lourde decided to move back to northwestern Oklahoma. “I can’t think of a better way to fully immerse myself in what northwestern Oklahoma is than to be editor of a newspaper that tracks the big things – like the oil boom and minutiae of ‘the minutes were read,’” said Lourde. “To make sure we cover the stories that really hit us where we live.” New editor at Sequoyah County Times The Sequoyah County Times has hired experienced journalist Eric Viccaro as news editor. Viccaro has been a journalist in 11 states. This isn’t his first time to work in Oklahoma. In 2003-04, Viccaro was the sports editor at the Blackwell Journal Tribune. In 2007-08, he served in the same position at the Guymon Daily Herald. Before coming to Sequoyah County, Viccaro worked for more than two years as editor of the Sioux County Index-Reporter in Hull, Iowa. “Let the editor tell everyone up front that we will continue with the basic tenets of journalism set down by the family that owns this publication,” said Viccaro in his introductory column. “We will be fair. We will be balanced. If you ever have a complaint with how the editor wrote about a certain topic, call me or email me and we will talk.” THE COMANCHE TIMES recently moved to a new location at 513 Hillery Dr., Suite A, in Comanche. The community was invited to an open house celebration on Aug. 3 to celebrate the new location and the paper’s 20th anniversary. Open House guests were invited to sign up for a drawing for a $100 gift certificate to Delbert’s Supermarket. Steve Bolton, publisher and editor of The Times, said the first issue of the newspaper came out on Sept. 2, 1992. “It has been a privilege to be Comanche’s hometown newspaper for these past 20 years and we are looking forward to many more,” Bolton said. Tulsa World receives awards in business development contest The Tulsa World took home several awards in the 2012 Newspaper Business Development Contest sponsored by the Inland Press Association. Winners were selected from 130 entries in the contest to recognize special sections, niche publications and other publications that generated new revenue for their parent newspapers. Awards were presented at the 2012 Newspaper Business Development Conference held Aug. 9 and 10 at the Seyfarth Shaw Conference Center in The Citadel in downtown Chicago. The Tulsa World placed first in Marketing Materials/Collateral Items & Incentives (50,000-100,000 & Over 100,000 Combined) with its Holiday Packages and also second in the same category with its World Advantage Club. The World also received first place in the Theme Pages category for its Service Directory; second in Arts/Entertainment for its Last-Minute Gift Guide; third in Travel/Tourism/ Transportation for its Road Trips; third in Health, Family & Youth for Health Answers; and third in Education/ Career with a College Guide. “The winners in this year’s Inland News Business Development Contest represent a truly impressive collection of innovative and creative projects,” said Inland Executive Director Tom Slaughter. “All the entrants demonstrate their commitment to strengthening their brand in the communities they serve while working to sustain the newspaper in those cities and towns.” NEWSPAPER & PUBLICATION BINDING Before you have your next issue bound, give us a call. We offer exceptional quality, competitive pricing and fast turnaround times. With three generations of experience, we have the knowledge and skill to get your job done. Other services include Bible binding and restoration, embossing and much more. ACE BOOKBINDING CO. 825 N. Classen Blvd., Oklahoma City, OK 73106 (405) 525-8888 or Toll-Free at 1-800-525-8896 E-mail: [email protected] • www.AceBookBinding.com 6 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 PLAYER PROFILE Name: GLORIA TROTTER, Publisher/Editor, THE COUNTYWIDE & SUN, Tecumseh EDUCATION: BS in journalism, University of Memphis FAMILY: Husband: Wayne, partner and co-publisher of the newspaper. Son: Greg, systems administrator, National Severe Storm Lab, Norman, Okla. NEWSPAPER EXPERIENCE: First newspaper job in Bristol, Va.-Tenn., while in high school and college (early ’60s). Worked for the society department writing weddings and features. Married a co-worker and married ge myself out of a job; in those days, newspapers would not hire spouses. Worked college public relations at University of Memphis and Randolph Technical Institute most of thee time after that until we bought the Tecumseh newspaper in 1983. Each month, The Publisher will profile a newspaper executive in this space. Learn more about your peers from all corners of the state. To request the questionnaire for your Player Profile, email [email protected]. Q: A: Q: A: What’s something most people don’t know about you? I once worked at a bubble gum factory doing clerical work (couldn’t type fast enough to be a clerk/secretary). Also worked at a check printing company while finishing college. Q: What’s the best/most unusual part of your job? A: The job is different every day. There’s never a boring moment. I worked enough other jobs along the way to know how unusual that is, and I’m grateful. I love meeting all kinds of different people and telling their stories, and I especially love covering government and doing my small part in ensuring the citizens are being properly represented. What’s the most unusual? How about taking someone’s subscription renewal at the produce counter of the grocery store? Q: A: Q: A: Q: A: Looking for a Complete Chamber of Commerce, of course – every newspaper person should be involved with the local chamber. I’ve served on lots of boards over the years – Red Cross, YMCA, Downtown Shawnee, League of Women Voters, Redbud Arts Council, Central Oklahoma Juvenile Center Advisory Board, several others. Helped found the Tecumseh Historical Society, Leadership Tecumseh and the Redbud Arts Council. And of course I’m involved in OPA, SPJ and FOI Oklahoma Who’s had the biggest influence on your career? Wayne, my husband. He’s an exceptionally fine journalist with very high professional and ethical standards. He’s way better than any of the teachers I had in college! What would you describe as the three most important responsibilities of your job? Accuracy, timeliness and fairness. What about newspaper publishing gets you out of bed in the morning? What makes you want to stay in bed? I get out of bed to find out what’s going Combination Solution ? for Print and Online Special Sections + Metro Creative Graphics, Inc. 1.800.223.1600 www.metrocreativeconnection.com to happen today! I’d rather stay in bed most any day, but especially when it’s income tax time, there’s a fight with the post office, Wayne is in a bad mood or I have to report bad news on a friend. What civic activities are you involved in? Now you can get fully-templated, full-color print special sections & companion, ready-topost online MicroSite sections from Metro Editorial Services! View samples and get more information from metrocreativeconnection.com, call Metro Client Services at 1-800-223-1600, or send an e-mail to [email protected] Q: A: What’s the biggest obstacle you’ve overcome in your career? Other than the no spouses rules that delayed my career, I can honestly say I haven’t had any huge obstacles. Q: A: What are you most proud of? Q: A: What are your hobbies? Q: A: That our community knows we are fair and accurate, and tells us we do a better job than the dailies. Hobbies? Who has time for hobbies? When I catch a few minutes to myself I read — novels, especially mysteries, suspense, Southern literature, historical fiction and other stuff. I love to sing, but haven’t been able to make it to choir practice in months. Q: Wh t ttype off annuall events What t iis your newspaper involved in? A: Frontier Days, Chamber auction, several others. Q: In what ways has your newspaper positively impacted the community? A: I think the answer is pretty much the same as the one about the role we play. It’s a lot of those “I wouldn’t have known if it hadn’t been for the Countywide” comments we get from readers. Q: What challenges are facing your newspaper today and in the future? A: Paywalls for websites. Retaining circulation in the digital age. Adapting our product to play a crucial part in the changing information delivery system. Q: What are some area attractions in your community visitors shouldn’t miss? A: We have some amazing places to eat for a small town. Neighboring Shawnee, in our circulation area, has a wonderful and under-appreciated art museum, an incredible old train depot (now the county historical museum) and several other sights worth seeing. And our county is rich in tribal history and culture, not to mention a bunch of casinos! Does your newspaper have a website? Yes, we do. After a lot of experimentation, we post condensed “teaser” stories each week pointing to the print copy, and of course we use it throughout the week for breaking news and other timely information. Q: How does your newspaper play an important part in the community? A: It is absolutely the best source — and often the only source — of local government news. We explain issues and describe candidates to the voters. We support issues and candidates when we agree with them, and oppose them when we don’t. We’re cheerleaders for the community in promoting economic development initiatives, events, etc. We are vital to our community’s health, we believe. The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 DEATHS married Judith Ann Malm on Oct. 10, 1959, in Winthrop. A long-time resident of Meeker, Friskup was the previous owner of the Meeker Livestock Auction. At the time of his death, he was a self-employed grant consultant, auctioneer and in real estate sales. He was a charter member and threetime past president of the Meeker Chamber of Commerce, member and vice-chair of Gordon Cooper Career Technology Center, and vice-chair of the Lincoln County Industry Authority. In 2001, Friskup received the Meeker Chamber of Commerce Lifetime Achievement Award. He is survived by his wife of 52 years, Judy Friskup; son and daughterin-law Steve and Robin Friskup of Muleshoe, Texas; daughter Debbie Grisson of Prague; sister Marilyn DeBoer of Lafayette, Minn.; five grandchildren and four great-grandchildren. a longtime Oklahoma journalist and outdoor writer, died Aug. 21, 2012. He was 73. Holladay grew up in Hico, Texas, and attended the University of Texas at El Paso. He covered forestry and natural resources for the state department of agriculture and later was a writer for the McAlester News-Capital. Holladay worked at the McCurtain Daily Gazette and Gazette-News for 14 years. He covered a variety of topics from general news to veterans’ issues and social and political issues. He also wrote farm and forestry stories for the Sunday Gazette-News. Holladay and the late J.D. Cash collaborated on a series of articles that scooped journalists across the U.S. and world when they covered the Oklahoma City Bombing. Holladay won numerous awards for his writing throughout his career. He was preceeded in death by his wife, Tisha. He is survived by his son Joseph Holladay, daughter-in-law Angie Holladay, three grandchildren and his sister Judy Taylor. PHILIP EDWIN STOUT, an Oklahoma journalist, died Aug. 26, 2012. He was 71. Stout was born on Sept. 3, 1940. He was a graduate of Stillwater High School and attended Oklahoma State University. He received a degree in marketing from OSU in 1963. Stout served in the U.S. Air Force and as a flight nurse in the Oklahoma Air National Guard. His journalism career began on the Alumni Magazine at OSU and as head of market research at the Oklahoma Publishing Company. He also held newspaper positions with the Dallas Times Herald and The Advocate in Baton Rouge, La. Stout returned to Oklahoma and became sales and marketing director for the Tulsa World from 1992 to 1994. He later started a newspaper con- sulting firm with a partner before retiring in 2010. He enjoyed gardening on his family farm near Perkins, Okla., and raising Labrador Retrievers. Stout is survived by his wife of 48 years, Jean; two daughters, Penelope and husband Nic Daniels of Mannford, and Natalie and husband Steve Coker of Tulsa; a sister, Barbara Stout of Monterey, Calif.; brother Ronald P. Stout of Edmond; and four grandchildren. GENEVA B. WILEY, former owner and publisher of The Grove Sun, died Aug. 13, 2012. She was 95. Geneva moved with her husband Don to Grove in 1953 after Don purchased The Grove Sun. Don reported and wrote while Geneva handled the bookkeeping and other tasks. The couple sold the newspaper to Pete Crow in 1969. They might not have been trained journalists but they personified the Grove Sun, said Crow about the couple. “Together they were owners, publishers, reporters, bookkeepers and sales staff,” said current Grove Sun publisher Cheryl Franklin. Geneva was a member of the Grove Women’s Business and Professional Group that helped found the Grove library in 1965. She was also president of the Grove Public Library for many years. L. KENT FRISKUP, former publisher of the Meeker News, died Sept. 5, 2012. He was 71. Friskup bought the Meeker News in 1990 and owned it for 10 years. He also served one term in the Oklahoma House of Representatives from 2001 to 2002. Born on Nov. 27, 1940, in New Ulm, Minn., Friskup graduated from Winthrop (MN) High School in 1958. He GEOFFREY HOLLADAY, Oklahoma Pulitzer Prize winner pens new novel Pulitzer Prize-winner Vance Trimble of Wewoka has published a new book, his 14th, about Will Rogers attempting a daredevil flying stunt in a small Oklahoma town for a 1922 Hollywood silent movie. “It is low-key suspense but dangerous and exciting,” says Trimble. “Will is supposed to stand on the wing of Wiley Post’s World War I biplane and lasso Mary Pickford on top of a tall water tower to rescue her from kidnappers. Of course, everything goes wrong.” The novel’s title is “Will Rogers and His Daredevil Movie,” a 312-page library-quality soft cover available from Amazon.com at $14.95. It also is an e-Book on Kindle and Nook. “The yarn,” says Trimble, “is not too serious, but is feisty and humerous. Besides Will and Mary Pickford, other characters are Douglas Fairbanks, W. C. Fields, and assorted and colorful vigorous Okies. Even bank robber Henry Starr appears.” Trimble has written more serious books, including biographies of Sam Walton, FedEx’s Fred Smith, publisher E.W. Scripps, even an activist history of hyperbaric medicine. On July 6, Trimble observed his 99th birthday with a five-mile walk. DONATE TO ONF A donation to the Oklahoma Newspaper Foundation will support its efforts to improve the state’s newspaper industry and quality of journalism. ONF’s programs include training and education for professional journalists, scholarship and internship programs for journalism students, and Newspaper in Education efforts. ONF relies on donations and memorial contributions to fund these programs. If you would like to make a donation, please send a check to: OKLAHOMA NEWSPAPER FOUNDATION 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd. Oklahoma City, OK 73105 7 8 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 Journalism students hone new This summer, 18 journalism students learned new skills at Oklahoma newspapers, thanks to the Oklahoma Newspaper Foundation’s internship program. The paid internships were made possible by a grant from the Ethics and Excellence in Journalism Foundation. The ONF’s internship program promotes the value of working at Oklahoma newspapers and benefits students as they begin their professional careers. This month, The Publisher features articles by six of the interns describing what they learned at the newspaper they worked at this summer. Six more interns will be featured in the October issue and the final six will be featured in the November issue. THAD AYERS, Oklahoma State University, Interned at THE EDMOND SUN On one of my last days at The Edmond Sun, publisher Karan Ediger told me I fit right in with the staff, and managing editor Lisa Shearer and reporter Patty Miller agreed. When I walked into one of Oklahoma’s oldest newspaper at 123 S. Broadway on June 4, I immediately saw this paper’s history on its walls. Copies of cornerstone newspapers told of wars, the Murrah building bombing, the 1986 Edmond Post Office Massacre, numerous awards and photos from readers connected to a newspaper whose life began nearly 20 years before the state of Oklahoma. I’m proud to now say I’m part of its history. During my time, I covered the 2012 University of Central Oklahoma Endeavor Games and was encouraged by the athletes. I reported on an ever-expanding Edmond community and, in turn, the pains associated with a growing city. I also got to experience the 2012 LibertyFest, which was a blast. But most of all, I picked up a new skill -photography. My first pictures sucked. Ask Lisa and news editor Drew Harmon. They coached me and helped craft me into a better photographer and writer. I learned that journalists end up eating a lot of pizza. Between June primary election coverage, office shindigs, the celebration of the 2011 Sequoyah Award in the OPA Better Newspaper Contest and my going away party (yes, they even sent me off), I ate a lot of Mazzio’s. It was spectacular. At the end of my eight weeks I had a lot of photos, a lot of clips, a Pinterest page I created for the paper, a lot of connections and a building full of friends in Edmond. Thanks, Kari Tompkins, for sitting in the same room as me for eight weeks and answering my questions. I know a lot more about Doctor Who because of you. Thanks to fellow reporters James Coburn, Patty Miller and Mark Schlachtenhaufen for lending me your many years of expertise, your beats and your Yellow Pages (because CARMEN BOURLON, Oklahoma City University, Interned at THE SHAWNEE NEWS-STAR My time at The Shawnee News-Star has been wonderful. Working at the News-Star reminded me of why I studied journalism in the first place. Everyone was very welcoming, and incredibly helpful. At first I was a bit rusty, because it’d been a while since I worked at my school’s paper, but it’s like rid- ing a bike, as they say, and I picked it back up quickly. I rekindled my love of writing, and remembered exactly how thrilling it was to see the finished product and to know people were really reading it. From covering city meetings to features on retired Sunday school teachers, and everything in-between, I had the chance not everything is on the Internet). Hopefully we’ll cross paths again. In July I asked Lisa if I had kept up with the hectic pace in her newsroom. She told me I did. A special thanks goes to her for her patience, guidance, coaching and getting my $14.89 back from the City of Edmond. Drew imparted his photography knowledge to me, laughed at a few of my jokes and was a lot of fun to work with as well. Thanks to him. I want to thank my wife Nicole for her support. I had to drive an hour away for work, but you were patient and were a great help. I love you. I also want to thank the Oklahoma Newspaper Foundation for this program. The experience I gained went beyond what I could learn in a classroom. Anyone thinking about becoming a journalist should intern in this program. And if you want to understand the rigors of an excellent modern daily newspaper, work at The Edmond Sun. You will be busy, but you will also have a lot of fun. to write a little of everything and it was great. The variety kept me interested, and working on the different subjects at the same time proved an exciting challenge. But it didn’t stop there. This internship helped me fine-tune my writing style and showed me that there is always more to learn. I learned something new every day, and I came away from my internship ready to tackle the next thing, and confident that I could. JULIE BRAGG, University of Central Oklahoma, Interned at THE NORMAN TRANSCRIPT A week ago, I began reflecting on my summer internship at The Norman Transcript, and what I was going to write for my column. Up to this point, my photography assignments had included summer activities around town, concerts, construction projects and various news assignments. Last Friday, the unthinkable happened in our county. A wildfire devastated more than 2,000 acres of land and destroyed 50 homes, affecting hundreds of people in our community. What started as a slow news day turned into four or five days of emotional, sometimes heart-wrenching coverage. The day after the fire, I was sent into the affected area to photograph families returning to their homes (or what was left of them). Many families found they lost everything they owned, including their pets. Midway through the day, I returned to town to photograph a beautiful woman celebrating her 104th birthday, only to return back to the fire zone to take more photographs. While it was a very emotional day, I felt very privileged to be able to document this tragic event that will be remembered for a lifetime. During my summer at The Transcript, I gained skills that are impossible to learn in the classroom. I gained experience in dealing with the public, gathering news and cutline information and an increased confidence to do what it takes to “get the shot.” By the end of my internship, I felt increasingly confident to face most news situations and be able to create good photographs, especially in spot news situations. Through the summer some of my favorite shoots included Olympic athletes from Norman, the Norman Conquest bicycle ride, Photo by Julie Bragg The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 9 skills through ONF internships the Midsummer Night’s Fair, soccer tournaments, Fourth of July activities, a barbecue competition, drama performance rehearsals, a sailboat regatta and various spot news events. Because The Norman Transcript also publishes a magazine, I was able to gain experience in magazine pro- duction, still photography and issue planning. I especially enjoyed food and corporate photography. One of my favorite shoots was the Ghost Tours at the University of Oklahoma. My only regret is that the internship wasn’t longer. I have established good working relationships with the various editors and writers, as well as local police and fire officials, and now my internship is over. The experience I gained is priceless. I so appreciate my fellow photographers taking me under their wings, as well as the editors and reporters assisting me with news gathering and WHITT CARTER, University of Central Oklahoma, Interned at SULPHUR TIMES-DEMOCRAT In mid-April, I received a phone call from longtime Sulphur Times-Democrat publisher Jamey John. He asked if I wanted to return home this summer to take an internship at his newspaper. A chance to write for the paper I grew up reading every week? My response was issued back to Jamey in less than three seconds. And what a great experience it was. It was a summer that will go a long way in my young, but prospering jour- nalism career. From distributing the newspaper to learning how to lay out page after page, I was fortunate enough to learn many tricks of the trade, something I will carry with me as I go. Not only was I able to learn different ins and outs about the newspaper business, but also I was given the opportunity to write. I wrote about as many different types of things as I could get my hands on. From sport event recaps, to police CARMEN FORMAN, University of Central Oklahoma, Interned at THE OKLAHOMAN I was in high spirits Tuesday morning the last week of my internship as I walked through The Oklahoman’s newsroom to my desk. Those spirits vanished quickly as I scrolled through my email. The editor of a local blog had emailed me about a story I had done on the effectiveness of sobriety checkpoints in Oklahoma City. He asserted that something in my story was inaccurate and “borderline slanderous”. My mind raced, I kept thinking I knew this was going to happen. Before I started my internship, I realized I was one of the youngest interns out of a class of 22 that summer at The Oklahoman. I was terrified I was going to make some sort of huge mistake and people in the newsroom would wonder how this youngster ever got hired. But that never happened. I talked to my editor who said the story was fine and nothing was going to get changed just because somebody was unhappy about it. I pushed the email out of my mind and spent the afternoon covering a roaring chemical fire. When I got back from the fire looking like a hot mess I was told by a fellow intern that the HOPE FORSYTH, University of Tulsa, Interned at CUSHING CITIZEN I had little experience with the newspaper and publishing world before my internship. A liberal arts media studies major, I had studied journalism a bit, but nothing takes the place of the hands-on experience I acquired during my internship. I learned quite a few new vocabulary words – rails, flags, refers and the like – and studied the AP Stylebook. Yet, the people I interacted with were the most interesting part of my job. My internship provided opportu- nities for me to learn about a variety of people I might not have otherwise encountered – like the man who received the Red Cross’ highest award for saving a young boy from drowning at the city pool or the woman who overcame partial blindness caused by brain surgery in order to write a book. It was intimidating to scale their stories into readable news articles, and I hope I did them justice. Before my internship and the elementary school talent show I covered, chases through a nearby town, to even a feature on a former 4th grade teacher of mine who was honored as “Teacher of the Year.” The Sulphur Times-Democrat staff and I were able to issue a new feature in the newspaper titled “Where are you now?” This special was a Q&A with former Sulphur athletes about their playing days and the lives they live now. Without a doubt, it was a lucky experience. Not very often are you given an expressing their confidence in me. It has been a very exciting and beneficial summer. I look forward to returning to the classroom for my final year of college with a wealth of practical experiences. opportunity to express your creativity and ideas through writing at such a young age. The John family gave me that opportunity. I’m not sure where my journalism path will end up, at this age most aren’t, but there’s one thing I’m sure of: my time at the Sulphur Times-Democrat will be time that I’m grateful for. It’s time that I’ll probably never forget. same angry blogger from the email had done what bloggers do best, he blogged. So there I was, called out for inaccuracies on The Lost Ogle’s website, ironically with my name spelled wrong. The same feeling of dread from earlier that day welled up inside me. I learned a valuable lesson that day. If you aren’t pissing someone off as a journalist, you probably aren’t doing your job correctly. Another reporter told me about all of the times he and other Oklahoman reporters had been blogged about by the Ogle. He called it a “rite of passage” and basically said if someone isn’t getting angry then you aren’t doing quality journalism. Thanks to the Oklahoma Newspaper Foundation, my summer as a breaking news intern was a summer full of lessons. From the editor of the paper I learned to show up mentally for work every day. From the court reporter I learned that sometimes you get the story just by being there, wherever there may be. But the gem of summer lessons came from my mentor who told me to use buttocks in my ledes whenever possible. It was a summer full of breaking news, lessons and buttocks, thanks to wonderful people at The Oklahoman and I wouldn’t trade it for the world. I wasn’t aware that there is an Alvin and the Chipmunks version of Michael Jackson’s “Beat It,” or that the local fifth graders have some serious moonwalking skills. I did some fun research throughout the summer, such as when I interviewed this year’s inductee into the local high school’s hall of fame – a zoologist and safari leader – and he said his favorite animal was the scimitar-horned oryx. I made an account on The Knot website while researching an article about planning weddings; every time I logged in, I got a chuckle from the prompt to link my Facebook account to share the news of my (non-existent) engagement. My internship’s story would not have been possible without other people’s stories, including those shared generously by Art Bieri, Dale Tuttle, the Clift family, and Majel Redick, among others, and I’m grateful to everyone who made this internship possible, especially the Citizen’s publishers, David and Myra Reid. 10 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 THE OGE PHOTO CONTEST JULY 2012 DAILY WINNER: ED BLOCHOWIAK Ty Scott of Sanger, Texas, makes a safe escape after failing to score in the bull riding competition at the International Finals Youth Rodeo at the Expo Center. The Shawnee News-Star Photo by ED BLOCHOWIAK,The Shawnee News-Star, July 11, 2012 JULY 2012 WEEKLY WINNER: RACHEL ANNE SEYMOUR The Bigheart Times Enter and Win a $100 Check from OGE Energy Corp. View contest rules and all winning photos at www.OkPress.com/OGE-Photo-Contest Justin Palmer of Mounce Arena isn’t competing in the bronc riding event. He was bucked off by his own horse during the senior men’s calf roping at the annual Cavalcade Rodeo in Pawhuska, Okla. Photo by RACHEL ANNE SEYMOUR,The Bigheart Times, July 26, 2012 It’s time … for OG&E’ss new SmartHours Price Plans. ™ 1-877-898-3834 OGE.COM MIDNIGHT 12 1 2 3 4 5 MONEY- SAVING OFF PEAK 6 7 8 9 10 11 NOON 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 PEAK TIME, WATCH YOUR USE 8 9 10 MIDNIGHT 11 12 PEAK OVER . START SAVING … © 2012 OGE Energy Corp. The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 11 State newspapers embrace public notice ad campaign This summer the Oklahoma Press Association launched a public notice advertising campaign consisting of six ads. The series of six-column by 6.5-inch ads began in July to remind readers of the importance of public notices in the newspaper. Each ad asked readers how they would know about events in the community without public notices. Featured topics included transferal of water rights, zoning on an agenda, termination of parental rights, school election, sale of oil and gas leases, and property being sold for delinquent property tax. Copy on all six ads was identical, as was the anchored logo in the lower right-hand side. Large artwork drew readers in to answer questions that ended in “how will you know?”. The campaign was highly effective, said OPA executive vice president Mark Thomas. “They got noticed around the state,” he said. “We got feedback from several industries.” OPA members were asked to run the ads on a space available basis. Anywhere from 122 to 131 newspapers ran the ads each week. Fifty-six members ran all six of the ads; 46 ran five of the ads; 24 ran four ads; 14 ran two ads, and 13 ran one ad. A second round of public notice ads is being planned for distribution in mid-December through January. Jeff Funk, chairman of the OPA marketing committee and publisher of the Enid News & Eagle, asked members to suggest topics for the new series of public notice ads. IF HER PARENTS’ RIGHTS ARE BEING TERMINATED HOW WILL YOU KNOW? State and local laws require public notice because you need to know when actions that affect you are about to happen. We expect accountability, transparency and warnings from our state and local governments. Many important notices are included as part of this newspaper. Printed newspaper notices are permanent, affordable, archived, independent of government and well-read. In a statewide survey, 68% of Oklahomans said government should be required to publish notices in local newspapers. Furthermore, 70% said government should not be allowed to put notices only on their own website. Oklahomans know internet postings don’t achieve the same result as printed public notice put in the hands of local citizens. Public notice is for you – when you need to know. What topics do you want in the next Public Notice Ads? Email your suggestions to [email protected] or mail to Oklahoma Press Association Attn: Marketing Committee 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd. Oklahoma City, OK 73105. IF THERE’S A SCHOOL ELECTION TODAY HOW WILL YOU KNOW? IF WATER RIGHTS ARE BEING TRANSFERRED HOW WILL YOU KNOW? IF ZONING IS ON THE AGENDA TONIGHT HOW WILL YOU KNOW? State and local laws require public notice because you need to know when actions that affect you are about to happen. We expect accountability, transparency and warnings from our state and local governments. State and local laws require public notice because you need to know when actions that affect you are about to happen. We expect accountability, transparency and warnings from our state and local governments. Many important notices are included as part of this newspaper. Printed newspaper notices are permanent, affordable, archived, independent of government and well-read. Many important notices are included as part of this newspaper. Printed newspaper notices are permanent, affordable, archived, independent of government and well-read. In a statewide survey, 68% of Oklahomans said government should be required to publish notices in local newspapers. Furthermore, 70% said government should not be allowed to put notices only on their own website. Oklahomans know internet postings don’t achieve the same result as printed public notice put in the hands of local citizens. In a statewide survey, 68% of Oklahomans said government should be required to publish notices in local newspapers. Furthermore, 70% said government should not be allowed to put notices only on their own website. Oklahomans know internet postings don’t achieve the same result as printed public notice put in the hands of local citizens. Public notice is for you – when you need to know. Public notice is for you – when you need to know. IF OIL & GAS LEASES ARE BEING SOLD HOW WILL YOU KNOW? IF PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD FOR DELINQUENT TAXES HOW WILL YOU KNOW? State and local laws require public notice because you need to know when actions that affect you are about to happen. We expect accountability, transparency and warnings from our state and local governments. State and local laws require public notice because you need to know when actions that affect you are about to happen. We expect accountability, transparency and warnings from our state and local governments. State and local laws require public notice because you need to know when actions that affect you are about to happen. We expect accountability, transparency and warnings from our state and local governments. Many important notices are included as part of this newspaper. Printed newspaper notices are permanent, affordable, archived, independent of government and well-read. Many important notices are included as part of this newspaper. Printed newspaper notices are permanent, affordable, archived, independent of government and well-read. Many important notices are included as part of this newspaper. Printed newspaper notices are permanent, affordable, archived, independent of government and well-read. In a statewide survey, 68% of Oklahomans said government should be required to publish notices in local newspapers. Furthermore, 70% said government should not be allowed to put notices only on their own website. Oklahomans know internet postings don’t achieve the same result as printed public notice put in the hands of local citizens. In a statewide survey, 68% of Oklahomans said government should be required to publish notices in local newspapers. Furthermore, 70% said government should not be allowed to put notices only on their own website. Oklahomans know internet postings don’t achieve the same result as printed public notice put in the hands of local citizens. In a statewide survey, 68% of Oklahomans said government should be required to publish notices in local newspapers. Furthermore, 70% said government should not be allowed to put notices only on their own website. Oklahomans know internet postings don’t achieve the same result as printed public notice put in the hands of local citizens. Public notice is for you – when you need to know. Public notice is for you – when you need to know. Public notice is for you – when you need to know. 12 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 Students invited to enter essay contest The 14th annual First Amendment Congress for high school students will be held Wednesday, Oct. 31, on the University of Central Oklahoma campus in Edmond, Okla. The theme of this year’s event is Truth, Lies and the First Amendment. The First Amendment Congress, sponsored by FOI Oklahoma, Inc., features special sessions for high school and the cost is $5 per student. Oklahoma high school students are invited to enter the annual First Amendment Congress Essay Contest. The first-place winner of the 2012 Zach Taylor Essay Contest will receive a $300 cash prize, second place will win $200 and third place will get $100. Students are asked to write about 500 words on this year’s question: “What, in your opinion, is the greatest threat to First Amendment Freedoms in this day and age?’’ Students are encouraged to do factual research on the topic and to write creatively and personally rather than write a report. Entries should be typed doublespace. Grammar and spelling will be considered. Deadline for entries is 5 p.m. Oct. 11. Entries must include the student’s name, name of school, name of teacher, mailing address and phone number and an email address if available. Entries should be emailed to Dr. Vickie Williams, Associate Director, Cooperative Council of Oklahoma School Administration: ccosabulk@ gmail.com. Winners will be recognized and prizes awarded during the First Amendment Congress. For more information about the event contact Dr. Vickie Williams, (405) 524-1191, or Kay Boies, (405) 525-5100. FOI Oklahoma is a statewide organization that for 23 years has promoted education of the public on the First Amendment and openness in government. The organization counts among its members journalists, librarians and educators. FOI Oklahoma is a national leader in training educators to teach the First Amendment in Oklahoma classrooms. For more info, visit their website at www.foioklahoma.org. The Elk City Daily News car won second place in the commercial division of the Elk City Rodeo of Champions Parade. Kids affectionately called the vehicle covered in newspapers “The Paper Car.” Daily News publisher Elizabeth Perkinson and circulation director Brady Russell toss candy to the kids along the parade route while Jerry Perkinson drives. Closing case files may violate First Amendment rights Legal Notes by Michael Minnis OPA Attorney A judge in Grady County has found that the closing of entire case files within hours of the filing of a felony perjury charge violated the First Amendment to the Constitution. After learning that the court had sealed the case file, the Enid News & Eagle obtained a copy of the docket sheet from the online On Demand website before the sealing order became effective. This docket sheet merely showed that a felony perjury charge had been filed by the district attorney’s office against a lawyer. However, by that eve- ning, even the docket sheet was no longer available. The closing of entire case files appears to be somewhat epidemic even though no specific law authorizes judges to summarily close a case file. It is as if the entire case never existed. Newspapers in several counties have checked the docket sheets and noticed gaps in the numbering of the docket sheets that are available. The missing numbers for several counties are significant. These closings could have been consistent with an expungement order, which would have been entered after the case file had been opened for a considerable period of time. However, the possibility also is that these closings had nothing to do with expungement laws, but were merely closures based on requests by the parties for reasons unknown that may have violated the First Amendment and the Open Records Act. Fortunately, a district judge has now clearly placed on the record that the closing of a case file other than by expungement violates First Amendment rights. Although the court did not specifically so find, such an order would also probably violate the Oklahoma Open Records Act, which applies to court records. This decision is not part of a reported appellate case and hence not controlling on other judges, but one would hope that other judges would take notice and act consistent therewith. The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 13 NAA files appeal to stay Valassis decision The Postal Regulatory Commission’s decision to approve a contract between the U.S. Postal Service and Valassis Direct Mail shocked the newspaper industry. On Aug. 23, the PRC voted 4-1 against the newspaper industry’s united opposition to the contract, which the National Newspaper Association and the Newspaper Association of America labeled harmful to the marketplace. Within 24 hours, NAA filed an appeal with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit and filed an emergency motion for a stay of the decision. “NAA believes this decision is contrary to law, and will challenge it immediately and vigorously in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit,” said NAA Chairman James M. Moroney III, CEO and publisher of The Dallas Morning News. Prior to the decision, NAA and its members called on Postmaster General Patrick R. Donahoe to acknowledge the overwhelming opposition expressed by the newspaper industry and others in the mailing community during this proceeding, and urged him to withdraw this special deal that benefits only one mailer. As NAA’s comments filed with the PRC noted, granting this special rate to one major competitor in the mailing business will cause significant financial harm to newspapers throughout the country, and will not improve the financial condition of the nation’s postal system. NNA President Reed Anfinson, publisher of the Swift County Moni- tor-News in Benson, Minn., said the National Newspaper Association was deeply disappointed in the PRC’s analysis. “The mailing contract with Valassis is an unfair deal in which the principal result is to drive down the advertiser’s prices and not necessarily to bring any new mail volume to the Postal Service,” said Anfinson. “What the commission does not explain is why this goal is in the best interest of either newspapers or the Postal Service. Nor does it take seriously the arguments raised by many that this deal will force more newspapers out of the mail and create a net loss for the Postal Service after the deal kicks in.” Anfinson said the NNA board of directors will explore all avenues for reversing the decision. “We know that in thousands of communities around this nation that newspapers remain the most vigorous watchdog of government as well as the primary source of community news,” said Anfinson. “The Founding Fathers recognized that the post office needed to work in a partnership with newspapers to provide citizens with the news fundamental to their ability to make informed decisions. Despite the Internet, TV and radio, newspapers still play this essential role. “However, it appears the Postal Service is abandoning this founding principle to compete with rather than support newspapers.” Avoid postal delays; how to count electronic subscriptions Postal Notes by Bill Newell OPA Postal consultant [email protected] It wasn’t very long ago that a threedigit container of newspapers labeled “Clinton, OK 736” would go to the Clinton, Okla., Post Office for processing and distribution even though the container might have had single pieces and five-digit bundles. Under new guidelines, this container is being directed to the Oklahoma City Processing Center where the processing and distribution will be performed and is labeled “Oklahoma City, OK 736”. This process could result in newspapers being delivered two days later instead of the next day. Publishers may avoid this possible delay of delivery on the five-digit bundles by placing all bundles for the same five-digit ZIP code in their own container and labeling it to the five-digit destination. However, the mailer must still pay the rate they would have paid if the bundle had remained in the three-digit containers. This option should only be used for those five-digit bundles remaining in your own three-digit ZIP code area. POSTAL SERVICE’S POSTPLAN “Save the Post Office” recently reported that USPS is beginning the process of notifying people of possible changes in either the hours or discontinuance of their Post Office. Offices that come up for review seem to be especially those that currently do not have a postmaster – currently around 4,000. Many patrons have received or will be receiving a letter describing plans and options that are being considered. The implementation of the plan involves scheduling a community meeting, sending out surveys about six weeks prior to the meeting and asking customers to return the surveys within two weeks. After the postal service tabulates the results, a meeting will be scheduled to discuss the survey results. Approximately a week later, the Post Office will announce its decision regarding that particular office. More to come on this as the Post Office tries to re-invent itself. HOW TO CLAIM ELECTRONIC SUBSCRIPTIONS Do you plan to claim electronic subscribers on your Statement of Ownership? These subscribers may be reported on the Oct. 1, 2012, Statement of Ownership. You will be required to complete the Statement of Ownership PS Form 3526 in hard copy and also attach a Statement of Ownership PS Form 3526X where you record your paid electronic copies. To obtain this worksheet go to pe.usps.gov. Now select Postage Statements (found in the left column). Then select Periodicals Forms, look for PS Form 3526-X (pdf), print it, complete it and attach it to PS Form 3526. POSTAL RATES TO INCREASE Mailers can begin projecting a possible rate increase to be implemented on Jan. 27, 2013. The exact amount of the increase will probably be announced in October. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is currently 2.5 to 3.0 percent. Hopefully the legislation being considered in Congress will delay any rate increases for periodicals for at least two years. POST OFFICE FACTS LARGEST POST OFFICE: James A. Farley Post Office, New York, NY – 393,000 square feet. SMALLEST POST OFFICE: Ochopee, FL – 61.3 square feet. THE PEACH SPRINGS, ARIZ., POST OFFICE has walk-in freezers for food destined for delivery for the Havasupai Indians at the bottom of the Grand Canyon. Mail – along with food, supplies and furniture – is delivered by mule train via an eight-mile trail. Each mule carries about 130 pounds and the total delivered in a week averages 41,000 pounds of goods. LEGAL ADVICE is just one of the benefits of being a member of the Oklahoma Press Association’s Legal Services Plan. Remove the worry of needing professional advice by enrolling today. For more information contact: OKLAHOMA PRESS ASSOCIATION’S LEGAL SERVICES PLAN 1-888-815-2672 or 405-499-0020 14 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 Two Oklahoma journalists to be honored by OCU Oklahoma City University’s Meinders School of Business will honor five local business leaders including Mary Mélon and Russell Perry at the annual Oklahoma Commerce & Industry Hall of Honor luncheon Oct. 24 at the Cox Center. Mélon will receive the President’s Award and Perry the Lifetime Achievement Award. Other 2012 inductees are Bill Cameron, recipient of the Chairman’s Award; Jane Jayroe Gamble, Outstanding Achievement Award; and G. Stephen Mason, Entrepreneurial Spirit Award. Mélon was named publisher of The Journal Record Publishing Co. in September 2001, and president and publisher in 2006. She previously served as associate publisher and advertising director. She was appointed by Oklahoma City Mayor Mick Cornett and currently serves as the first woman on the Oklahoma City Urban Renewal Authority and Oklahoma City Urban Redevelopment Authority. She was appointed by State Health Commissioner Terry Cline to serve on the advisory committee for Healthy Communities and Healthy Schools. Perry is a businessman, banker, community leader, former state official, publisher and broadcaster. Perry started the Black Chronicle, a weekly paid newspaper in Oklahoma City, in 1979. Perry Publishing & Broadcasting is one of the largest independently-owned radio groups in Oklahoma. Its network of eleven stations reaches African American communities in Oklahoma with Urban radio. Perry also owns the controlling interest in a small Oklahoma City bank. Gov. Frank Keating appointed Perry his Secretary of Commerce, and he was the first African American to ever serve in that position. In addition to recognizing members of the business community, the Oklahoma Commerce & Industry Hall of Honor luncheon benefits the Meinders School of Business scholarship program. When you need legal advice… THINK LSP When you have legal questions, you need answers. LSP (Legal Services Plan) provides legal assistance, advice and some defense services at a reasonable cost. Between April 1 and June 30, 2012, LSP processed 20 inquiries: 9 were answered immediately, none were answered by letter, and 11 were answered by letter after research. Following are some of the questions the Plan received for the quarter ending June 30, 2012: ACCESS MUG SHOTS In an apparent effort to mimic what Federal judges are doing, the Cleveland County District Attorney’s Office sought to deny access to mug shots. Such a denial appears to violate the Open Records Act Section 24A.8A(1), which states that the public has a right to “an arrestee description, including the name, date-of-birth, address, race, sex, physical description, and occupation of the arrestee.” A photograph is a record of an arrestee description and a physical description that is arguably more accurate than any articulated description. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR When receiving letters to the editor, particularly those containing controversial statements, a newspaper would be prudent to call the person who allegedly sent the letter to confirm that the name on the letter is accurate. This policy would be facilitated by having those who submit letters to include their phone numbers. EMPLOYEE RESIGNATIONS If an employee resigns, the employer accepts that resignation, and thereafter the employee asks to withdraw his resignation, whether to accept the withdrawal is up to the employer who should be certain that the resignation or the refusal to accept the withdrawal were not prompted by an alleged violation of Federal or State Anti-Discrimination laws. PLAN A BENEFIT INCLUDES: • • • • • Legal Newspapers (25 O.S. 106) Sales & Use Tax Exemption Excise Tax Advertising Management • Circulation • Production • Anti-Trust • News • Open Meeting Law • Open Records Law • Libel, defamation, slander • Honest Mistake Act • Minutes Request Law • News Reporter, Shield Law • Juvenile Names • Cameras in Courtroom • Copyright • First Amendment • Subpoenas • Invasion of Privacy • Internet Law PLAN B BENEFIT INCLUDES: Provides defense of suits and subpoenas. For complete benefits under both Plan A and B, visit the OPA website at www.OkPress.com/LSP For dues and other information about the Legal Services Plan, or to become an LSP member, contact Mark Thomas at the Oklahoma Press Association. OKLAHOMA PRESS ASSOCIATION Don’t be left with your questions unanswered. Join the OPA Legal Services Plan today. Call (405) 499-0020 for more information. Phone: (405) 499-0020 Information in this advertisement is not a substitute for legal advice provided by a licensed attorney. Toll-free in Oklahoma: 1-888-815-2672 Fax: (405) 499-0048 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd., Oklahoma City, OK 73105-5499 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 15 Replacing older servers – Windows 8 Preview Computer Notes from the road by Wilma Melot [email protected] Several years ago Apple dropped its line of business servers and decided to focus on server software for home use. I have been looking for a good solution to this problem since then. Many Windows home servers aren’t full featured enough for what a newspaper needs and full business servers are often too expensive for most small businesses. Many papers have adopted a USB external drive hooked to a stand-alone computer as a server but it’s slow and can’t handle the network traffic like a real server software. Likewise, the networked external drives some papers use have been too slow for larger groups. The NAS (network-attached storage) servers have greatly improved in the last couple of years and I think these will handle the traffic and do the tasks mid-sized papers need. The fastest in data transfer for the money is the Synology DS712+. It’s pricier than others in its class but it is fast, flexible and-top rated in many reviews for 2012. It works well with Mac’s file format and with Windows computers. It does not come with the hard drives so you must buy them separately. The good news is that the price is still under $800 – less than the price of many new computers. For those of you who have been using stand-alone external USB drives, it provides a much more reliable setup. The interface is easy to use and your files can be retrieved from home via FTP. This type of setup has fewer virus problems than big servers but it can still serve email and up to 30 websites. If the DS712+ doesn’t have enough storage for you, there are expansion options. The Synology DX510 expansion unit is a good choice and allows you to increase storage by adding five hard drive bays. The Synology DX510 securely connects to the DS712+ via an eSATA cable with specially-designed locking connectors. The Synology DX510 expands the existing storage on the Synology DS712+ up to a maximum 28TB capacity. This serve also offers USB printer sharing capability, which can cut cost by sharing printing resources throughout the office. Comprehensive network protocol support assures seamless file sharing across Windows, Mac and Linux platforms. The software only works with OSX 10.5 and above but the file sharing works with older Mac operating systems. This system offers locks on both drives and comes with keys to prevent theft as well. If you want to speed up your operation for a minimum outlay of money, give this system – or one similar to it – a look. Western Digital also makes a special class of hard drives for NAS. Red WD10EFRX is a good choice. It comes in 1TB, 2TB and 3TB sizes. Remember that you will need two drives to create a RAID for live file backup. WINDOWS 8 RELEASE DATE The Windows 8 release date for desktops, notebooks and tablets is Oct. 26. The preview download is available now. Hang on to your hats because the world is about to shift again. Don’t worry, though. It’s not that drastic of a change. It’s just an attempt by Microsoft to keep up with the Apple/ Google crowd. Microsoft will release Windows 8 for its phones on Oct. 29 in a massive rollout. The tablet/phone market is really a small computer market these days. With quad core co-processors and 1 to 2 GB of RAM, some phones and tablets are better computers than many newspaper employees sit in front of every day. Many even run the Internet better than our older computers. You might want to heed this warning: the early adopters of new technology often have many troubles so give it a month or two before you take the plunge. It seems that with Windows 8 Microsoft wants to turn your computer into a tablet. It’s all set up as if your computer has a touch screen. It works well with a mouse but sure seems like you’re taking extra steps during the very long learning process. Windows 8 has two operating systems in one. The new “Metro” OS runs over the Windows 7 interface – much like we used to run Mac OS9 under OSX in classic mode. Metro appears to be more tailored for tablets. But what this all means is that some programs will open in the Metro system and other programs will open in the Windows 7 environment that we’re used to. It’s confusing but it enables Microsoft to sell you apps on your computer like they do on a tablet or phone. Microsoft also created a barrier where all new applications must be authorized before they are available to buy. This will help with virus problems but it makes it harder for the end user to put a third party program on their own computer. I can’t say whether this is a good idea or a bad one, but it’s coming and we’re going to have to deal with it. As with all computer changes, it takes time learn your way around the new Windows OS. Just expect a steep learning curve and be ready to do a lot of extra clicking to go between the two interfaces until Microsoft moves programs to the “Metro” style. I personally think that will take several years since so many Microsoft users are still on Windows XP. Note: As a word of caution, I should mention this. If you create installation media by first starting your PC from the media and then installing Windows 8 Release Preview you won’t be able to keep your files, programs or settings this way. If you want to keep files, programs and settings, you need to install Windows 8 Release Preview by starting your installation from within Windows. Windows 8 will keep all your settings and programs from Windows 7 but older operating systems will lose some system settings. The user accounts and files should be the same but some programs may not work. Check to see if your programs will run on Windows 8 before upgrading. The Start screen replaces the start menu in Windows 8. You can pin apps, contacts and websites to Start to easily access what you use most. All applications – those installed from the Windows store and desktop applications – are available from the Start screen. You can also use the Windows key on your keyboard to go to Start. OPA Computer Consultant Wilma Melot’s column is brought to you by the Oklahoma Advertising Network (OAN). For more information on the OAN program, contact Oklahoma Press Service at (405) 499-0020. 16 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 CLARK’S GUIDE TO PUNCTUATION Clark’s Critique by Terry Clark Journalism Professor, University of Central Oklahoma, [email protected] “Broadcasters pronounce better, but newspaper people punctuate correctly,” joked Mark Thomas at one of the Journalism Hall of Fame ceremonies. After looking at some of our stories, I’d have to add, “Sometimes.” I also know that many of my students have not had grammar since they were in eighth grade. As an old English major who repented and turned to journalism, I know the Gospel of Correct Punctuation may have been amended some for us heretics, but the basics are the same. Correct punctuation is essential for accurate writing. So here is the Revised Version of the Gospel of Punctuation, also known as Clark’s Easy Reference Punctuation Guide for Journalists. Let’s start with our “problem children,” the ones we have the most trouble with. Next month I’ll cover periods, question marks, virgules, dashes, ellipses and parentheses. Clip the guide below and put it near your computer. Revised Version of the Gospel of Punctuation, also known as CLARK’S EASY REFERENCE PUNCTUATION GUIDE FOR JOURNALISTS THE APOSTROPHE – We have an apostrophe catastrophe in this country. A. Contractions, possessives. It’s and its are the most misused in the country. Its is comparable to his and hers (a pronoun). It’s is a contraction for it is. There is no its’. I saw a sign once that read “Deliciou’s Apple’s.” B. With plurals: • With singular common nouns ending in s, add ’s unless the next word begins with s. For singular proper names ending in s use only an apostrophe: “Mark Thomas’ job is to lead the OPA.” • With regular plural nouns, add only an apostrophe, “The Thomases’ children….” • With irregular plural nouns, add an apostrophe ‘s’, “The children’s” • Never add an apostrophe to a noun that ends in ‘s’ if there is no possessive. Wrong: “These word’s…” • If it’s a compound noun, only the last word gets an apostrophe: “The editor-in-chief’s job….” • Compound possessives, only on the second noun, Lewis and Clark’s journey… COLONS – AVOID. They stop the reader’s flow in the sentence. They always come at the end of a complete sentence: He bought five vegetables: cukes, tomatoes, corn, okra and radishes. Do not use it in the following manner (as in this sentence): He bought the following: cukes, tomatoes, corn. Rewrite both. He bought cukes, corn and radishes. EXCLAMATION MARKS – AVOID! Especially more than one at a time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! They show you don’t know how to write for emphasis and cheapen your writing like all those ads in the inserts that put exclamation marks after every item: “Hair Dryer”! Two speeds! Black or brown! Wall mount!” Etc. You should use it in a quote only when clearly called for. “Don’t use exclamation marks!” Clark yelled. QUOTATION MARKS. In America, quote marks always, always, always go outside the period and comma. Question marks and exclamation marks depend on context. This includes single quotes: “I told you he said ‘I quit,’” Clark yelled. With question marks, quotes go inside if the quote is a question as in “Are you cold?” he asked. But outside like this, Did Clark say, “Question marks go inside quotes”? COMMAS – THE MOST DEBATABLE. Best rule – always use for clarity and according to AP style on addresses, etc. Other than that, try omitting or rewriting to avoid as many as possible. • Use with a non-restrictive clause or appositive (one that’s not essential). Clark, who grew up in New Mexico, lives in Oklahoma. vs. The man who was bleeding from the wound died in 20 minutes. Try to write around it and cut the words. Clark grew up in New Mexico and lives in Oklahoma. • In a series, omit the comma before the last item: He loves tomatoes, iced tea and jalapenos. Your English teacher and others would insert a comma after iced tea. That’s called the “Oxford comma.” Oxford is in England. This is America. Journalists don’t use it except in rare cases where needed for clarity. • Setting off introductory clauses and phrases, In the beginning, God created…. Or Although the city council met for five hours, it took no action. It’s usually better for us to rewrite it and get to the point first. After five hours the council accomplished nothing. No comma because it’s essential to the meaning, it’s shorter and easier to read. Get to the point. Always ask yourself if you have a question about punctuation, “Why do I need this?” or “Why am I using this?”. Most grammatical problems can be cured with short sentences. (Lots of periods.) LOOKIN’EM OVER. How old is the courthouse in your county? In Ellis County, folks are planning the 100th birthday party for theirs later this month. Here’s how Jerry and Anita Denson of The Gage Record start the story out: “The year was 1912 and William Taft was President of the United States; 3,000 cherry trees were planted in Washington D.C. to symbolize friendship between Japan and the U.S. The Titanic sinks in the Atlantic Ocean, Jim Thorpe won two gold medals in the Olympics and the Boston Red Sox won the World Series. / Ellis County residents voted in 1908 and selected the township of Arnett, formerly in Day County, to be the site of the Courthouse. The brick building was built on the town square and completed in 1912. … There were seven towns within Ellis County and a total of 107 school districts.” I know the courthouse in Hobart was built in 1902, predating statehood. I think there are others. Stories are begging to be told here that will interest all your readers. Need ideas? The Edmond Sun carried a disturbing story that could be localized all over the state. Did you now the number of suicides in Oklahoma is double the number of homicides? Mark Schlachtenhaufen writes about a local training program for counselors to help prevent it. Edmond has had 13 suicides this year. Sister newspapers The Shawnee News-Star and The Ardmoreite teamed to carry stories about meth and its effects. Carmen Bourlon of Shawnee interviewed a meth addict and Marsha Miller and Michael Pineda of Ardmore wrote about the effects of the drug. Karen Atkinson of the The Madill Record wrote a story you can localize with the help of a game ranger. Cougar population is up in the state, and one attacked and injured some local horses. Karen West Sanchez of the Stigler News Sentinel wrote a strong feature story on a 13-year-old girl who will be the poster child for a fund raising rodeo in the fight against diabetes. The Chelsea Reporter salutes, with lots of photos, local firemen working on Labor Day Continued on Page 17 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 17 Clark’s Critique Continued from Page 16 CLARK’S FEATURED PAGES: From local stories to great headlines, Oklahoma newspapers keep citizens informed. Featured this month are the Enid News & Eagle, The Gage Record, Okmulgee Times and Durant Daily Democrat. with the fill-the-boot campaign against muscular dystrophy. At The Miami News-Record, Melinda Stotts wrote about a new chaplain corps organized by the police department. Does such a thing exist elsewhere in this state? Jeff Harrison of The Tuttle Times reported on the increasing number of people driving off without paying for gasoline. How’s your municipal water supply? James Neal of the Enid News & Eagle writes that the city has outgrown its aquifer. And Phyllis Zorn reported about how the drought has affected the canned food exhibits at the Garfield county fair. How many children are homeschooled in your area? Bill Johnston of the Collinsville News reported on a group project of home schooled students. “What, When & Where” is the title of the front page feature in The Lindsay News, carrying short items on scheduled events – a good way to handle all that short stuff and guarantee high readership. Also, kudos to the Enid News & Eagle for winning its fight with a county judge to open the records on a lawsuit. Congratulations to Bill and Dayna Robinson, the new owners of the Hughes County Times, buying it from Julie Morgan. HEAD’EM UP AWARDS: First place, The Okarche Chieftain, on Matt Montgomery’s story about West Nile virus: Fight the Bite. Second place, Marietta Monitor, on Willis Choate’s photograph of casino hotel construction (accompanying a story on county property valuation growing rapidly) Rooms to grow. Third place, tie, Muskogee Phoenix and Yukon Review. Muskogee, on D.E. Smoot’s report about the city taking back an employee raise: Sweet raise sours for city workers Yukon, on Conrad Dudderer’s story about an antique tool show in town: Just tooling around. Honorable mentions: Okmulgee Times, “Up in Smoke,” on the state- Muscogee (Creek) tobacco settlement; The Norman Transcript, “Classical gas,” on Hanna Cruz’s story about a local car show; The Bigheart Times, on Louise RedCorn’s story about a Ben Affleck movie in the state, “Affleck movie afflicted with boos, mixed reviews”; Sequoyah County Times, on a Mark Evens story about a 7-0 football game, “Defensive Dandy”; The Okarche Chieftain, “Pain at the pump,” about rising gas prices. FEATURED FLAGS NEWSPAPER BROKERS, APPRAISERS, CONSULTANTS Serving the Newspaper Industry Since 1966 When the time comes to explore the sale of your community newspaper, you can count on us. We offer decades of experience and a record of success in community newspaper sales. Community newspapers still have good value. If you’re ready to sell, call us for a confidential discussion. THOMAS C. BOLITHO P.O. Box 849, Ada, OK 74821 (580) 421-9600 • [email protected] EDWARD M. ANDERSON P.O. Box 2001, Branson, MO 65616 (417) 336-3457 • [email protected] NATIONAL EDIA A SSOC IATES www.nationalmediasales.com 18 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 ADVENTURES IN PART 2 … it’s a bird …it’s a plane … it’s OPA President Jeff Shultz visiting superheroes at Oklahoma newspapers. We began the second day of our road trip last month in Idabel with our first stop at the McCurtain Daily Gazette. Owner and publisher Bruce Willingham says he first fell in love with the newspaper business in 1972 when he was editor and chief of his high school newspaper. After high school, he studied at the University of North Carolina and worked at the Chapel Hill newspaper while in college. After college he came home and dabbled in some other business interests. “I got into chicken farming for a while,” Willingham said, with a chuckle. However, it didn’t take long for him to get back into newspapers as he soon became part owner of a weekly newspaper – The Tribune – that was a competitor to the Gazette. Shortly after starting at the Tribune the owner of the Gazette convinced Willingham to come to work for him. “It was good timing,” Willingham recalled. “I was having some problems with my business partner. So, I went to work as the advertising director of the Broken Bow News.” Later he became executive editor of both papers – the Gazette and the Broken Bow News – and when the owner, Jim Monroe, decided to retire in 1988, Bruce and his wife Gwen bought both papers from him. Bruce said his biggest challenge is finding quality reporters for his newsroom. “We have very low turnover in our editorial department, but when we do we have difficulty getting good reporters to relocate in a distant part of the state,” he said. “It’s important to have really good reporters,” Bruce added. “It’s difficult to get them to come to this part of the state. They usually have to have some type of family tie to want to come to this area. “It’s kind of sad that they all want to work at the large metro papers when in reality there’s probably more job stability with the smaller papers,” he continued. The Gazette’s number one priority, says Willingham, is a commitment to local news. “We feel it is important to have a strong focus on local news and our front page is 100 percent local every day,” he said. The Gazette’s dedication to quality reporting has given them some notable accolades over the years. During the dark days of the Oklahoma City bombing, it was the Gazette’s coverage of the bombing and how it affected McCurtain County that received national attention from the New Yorker magazine and NBC News. But it’s all not serious reporting for Willingham and his editorial staff. Sometimes they blend the more serious crime news with a little humor. “One year we started noticing a trend of sorts in our police news. There had been several reports of domestic assaults where chicken and dumplings were the weapon of choice,” he recalled. “It happened three times and every time we reported it our readers loved it.” OUR NEXT STOP was just across the street from the Gazette, at the Southeast Times co-owned and published by State Senator Jerry Ellis. As we walked into the Southeast Times’ office, Ellis was busy getting his paper ready to mail out. Being a state senator, Ellis said the best time to get his paper out is on Friday since the legislature is not in session on that day. Ellis started the Southeast Times in 1988 and recalled the first issue. “We went around collecting stuff off of bulletin boards at grocery stores and laundry mats for several weeks,” said Ellis. “We finally got our first issue out and we decided to throw a little party to celebrate. “We were sitting around, enjoying some ice cream, and then it dawned on us. We had told these people we were going to put out a weekly paper. “We had been collecting for a month to six weeks for our first issue. What are we going to do now?” Ellis said laughingly. Some in the area didn’t give the Southeast Times much of a chance. Some, Ellis said, thought it was only a fly-by-night operation that wouldn’t be around much longer than six months. “The biggest question people were asking me at the time was, ‘How much longer are you going to last?’ They just thought it was a matter of time until we would fold up. “So, it got to the point when someone would ask me that, my response was, ‘Long enough to print your obituary,’” Ellis said. “That kind of stopped the questions.” Ellis was elected to the Oklahoma House in 2002 and then in 2008 he was elected to the Oklahoma Senate. Despite the hectic schedule of a Continued on Page 19 It’s a family effort for the Willinghams to put out the McCurtain Daily Gazette in Idabel. Starting his training early is 18-month-old Parker, son of Angie and Christopher and grandson of Bruce and Gwen. The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 Sen. Jerry Ellis at the Southeast Times newspaper office in Idabel. Ellis launched the weekly newspaper in 1988 and today remains as its owner and publisher in addition to serving as a state senator. ADVENTURES Continued from page 18 state lawmaker, Ellis finds a way to publish his paper each week. “I’d like to dedicate more time to it,” he said. “Once I term limit out I’ll be able to dedicate more time to the paper.” Meanwhile, Ellis has been a strong proponent for newspapers. Whenever a threat to our industry is proposed, Ellis is there, ready to fight for newspapers on the Senate floor. It may not be a popular stance to take, but Ellis takes it because he knows first hand how important newspapers are to our state. OUR FINAL STOP on this road trip was in Wilburton to visit Mitch Mullin. Mullin publishes the Latimer County News Tribune, Latimer County Today, Clayton Today and Talhina American under the company name of Tri-County Publications. Mitch admits he’s from the advertising side of the ledger and depends on a professional editorial staff to get the news so many of his readers desire. “They really work at being accurate,” he said. One of his editors, Gloria Criswell, shared with us how she is very diligent in editing the paper, making sure errors were corrected. “I attended an OPA seminar where they showed pictures of some Oklahoma newspapers and pointed out various editing mistakes made by those newspapers,” she recalled. One of the newspapers depicted in that seminar was a paper she was the editor of. 19 At Wilburton, publisher Mitch Mullin publishes four papers under the Tri-County Publications flag, which include Latimer County News Tribune, Latimer County Today, Clayton Today and Talihina American. Staff members at the weekly publications include Mullin’s son Mitchel Mullin (Tri-County Publications), Brenda Showell and Mark Showell (Latimer County News-Tribune) and Gloria Criswell (Tri-County Publications). “I decided then that I never wanted to be there again, so I’ve been very diligent in finding and correcting errors before the paper goes to press,” she said. Mitch understands the balance between news and advertising and often comes to the rescue of advertisers, helping them with their business decisions. He shared with us how he began working with local grocers to keep them from accepting offers from wholesalers to run their inserts. Many grocers, he explained, are forced to stock what the wholesalers advertise in the inserts instead of stocking what they know their customers want. “I just told them they needed to take control of their business and not let the wholesalers make decisions on what they should stock in their stores,” he said. His papers have a full-page grocery ad in them each week as a result of Mitch’s advice. “Their stores are benefiting from the full-page ads more than if they ran the inserts,” he noted. Heroes are dedicated to the truth and making sure the truth is given to the public whether it’s in the form of a news story or advertising. They care about the people they are serving while making a stand for what they know and believe is right. On this second day of our road trip, I met three heroes who are fine examples of those attributes. OPA STAFF DIRECTORY ADMINISTRATION MARK THOMAS Executive Vice President [email protected] (405) 499-0033 ROBERT WALLAR Accounting Manager [email protected] (405) 499-0027 SCOTT WILKERSON Front Office/Building Mgr. [email protected] (405) 499-0020 MEMBER SERVICES ADVERTISING LISA POTTS Media Manager [email protected] (405) 499-0023 Member Services Director [email protected] (405) 499-0026 ELI NICHOLS Member Services Coordinator [email protected] (405) 499-0040 CINDY SHEA LANDON COBB Account Executive [email protected] (405) 499-0022 COURTNI SPOON Advertising Assistant & OCAN/2X2 Contact [email protected] (405) 499-0035 CREATIVE SERVICES COMPUTER ADVICE OPEN OPEN (CONT’D) NELSON SOLOMON WILMA MELOT (DIGITAL CLIPPING) KEITH BURGIN JENNIFER GILLILAND Creative Services Director [email protected] (405) 499-0028 Computer Consultant [email protected] (405) 499-0031 OPEN Manager [email protected] (405) 499-0024 MORGAN BROWNE POSTAL ADVICE KYLE GRANT Creative Assistant [email protected] (405) 499-0029 BILL NEWELL Postal Consultant [email protected] (405) 499-0020 Digital Clipping Dept. [email protected] (405) 499-0045 Digital Clipping Dept. [email protected] (405) 499-0032 GENERAL INQUIRIES (405) 499-0020 • Fax: (405) 499-0048 Toll-free in OK: 1-888-815-2672 20 The Oklahoma Publisher // September 2012 CONGRATULATIONS TO THE JULY 2012 CONTEST WINNERS Column: Editorial: TED STREULI DAVID BURGESS The Journal Record Vinita Daily Journal JULY 2012 EDITORIAL WINNER DAVID BURGESS, VINITA DAILY JOURNAL It’s time to make county elections non-partisan Imagine this scenario: You live in rural Craig County. You arrive home one night to find that your house has been burglarized. You call the Craig County Sheriff’s Department. And the first question is, “Are you a Democrat or a Republican?” Of course, that question would never be asked. But asking it would be no more ridiculous than the current system of electing county officials. Craig County voters – Republican voters, anyway – got their latest taste of the flawed system three weeks ago, as did voters for county offices throughout the state. There are 2,200 registered Republicans in Craig County, and none was able to vote in the primary. There are 682 registered Independents in Craig County, and none was able to vote in the primary. That’s because all six candidates running for office were Democrats, even though the offices they were running for – sheriff, county clerk and county commissioner – administer their services in a non-partisan way. Craig County Dist. 2 County Commissioner Hugh Gordon should be commended for pointing out, as he did in the weeks leading up to the primary, that the system used to elect county officers needs to be changed. It’s been tried before. Almost a decade ago, Rep. Larry Ferguson (R-Cleveland) and Rep. Dale DeWitt (R- Braman) attempted to change the closed primary system, pointing out that it was particularly troublesome in county races, which often draw candidates from only one party. For evidence, Ferguson cited a 2004 election in which Rep. Leonard Sullivan was elected Oklahoma County assessor exclusively by Republicans, since the only two candidates for the office were from that party. That left more than 200,000 Oklahoma County residents excluded from voting in that race. The trend was repeated in other elections across the state, with the parties taking turns. Only Democrats elected the sheriff and county clerk in Logan County, while only Republicans elected the sheriff, county clerk and court clerk in Canadian County. Is this any way to run county government? But the proposal to change the way the system works was shot down in the Legislature in 2004, as it had been in 1999 and 2001. Rep. Randy Grau and Sen. Rob Johnson attempted to change one part of the system earlier this year, but they came up just short. SB 327 would have required elections for county sheriffs in Oklahoma to be non-partisan. It stood a good chance of being passed, with perhaps only the Oklahoma Sheriff’s Association’s lack of support dooming it. Some sheriffs like the current system, and the Sheriff’s Association chose not to take an official position. The lack of support likely doomed the bill, which eventually failed in the House by a single vote. But even if SB 327 had passed, it would have only changed a single piece of the flawed system. The next time county elections come up, the other races would still have been partisan – for no good reason – and many voters would still likely have been unable to vote. In rural counties, such as Craig, the shut-out voters are usually Republicans. In more urban counties, the shut-out voters are usually Democrats. There is a better way to run elections, and Vinita went with it more than 20 years ago. After years of being saddled with the same problem that county voters are still saddled with – partisan elections for non-partisan positions – Vinita made a change for the better in 1989. Now everyone gets to vote in city elections, not just those who happen to be registered with a certain party. That’s the way it should always have been, since all city residents are affected by the decisions of, say, the mayor. And that’s the way it should be in county elections. Of course, the difference is that, unlike Vinita, Craig County and other Oklahoma counties can’t make that change at the local level. It will have to be done in the Legislature, which means prodding legislators. It’s time to start prodding. Enter and Win a $100 Check from ONG! 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Each month, send a tear sheet or photocopy of your best column and/ or editorial to ONG Contest, c/o OPA, 3601 N. Lincoln Blvd., Oklahoma City, OK 73105-5499. Include the author’s name, name of publication, date of publication and category entered (column or editorial). Only ONE editorial and/or ONE column per writer per month will be accepted. All entries for the previous month must be at the OPA office by the 15th of the current month. Winning entries will be reproduced on the OPA website at www.OkPress. com. Entries must have been previously published. Contest open to all OPA member newspapers. Although Oklahoma Natural Gas Company selects representative contest winners’ work for use in this monthly ad, the views expressed in winning columns and editorials are those of the writers and don’t necessarily reflect the Company’s opinions. Thank you for continued support of “Share The Warmth” Read the Winning Columns and Editorials on the OPA website: www.OkPress.com (Under Contests)