High Performance Energy Conserving Biobased Lubricants

High Performance Energy
Conserving
Biobased Lubricants
Great Lakes Boat Captain’s Association
&
Great Lakes Association of Science Ships
January, 24 2007
Renewable Lubricants, Inc.
476 Griggy Rd., PO Box 474
Hartville, OH 44632
Voice: 330.877.9982 Fax: 330.877.2266
www.renewablelube.com
Why Biobased?
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
2002 Farm Bill (Economic Security)
Renewable, recyclable
Biodegradable
Food Grade
No Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC's)
Fire Resistant
Energy Efficiency =Super High Viscosity Index
Excellent Lubricity
Why Renewable Lubricants?
• Performance equal or better than petroleum-based at
similar cost
• Performance of synthetic at lower cost
• Excellent High and Low Temperature Performance
• Wide Range of Viscosities
RLI: Who Are We?
•
Renewable Lubricants (RLI) is the world’s leader in
biobased lubricant technology. RLI is the only company
in the world that has Worldwide Patented Biobase
Products that directly replace petroleum lubricants.
•
Since 1991 RLI has pioneered this field with both
government and industrial support.
•
Today, RLI offers of full line of high performance
lubricants with well-documented field successes.
•
Expertise in R&D and application knowledge.
•
RLI has Proven to the World our High Performance
Products
•
“Biobased Lubricants that Perform Like Synthetics.”
Biobased and Renewable
(Green)
• Green is Hot
• Green makes
sense
Legislation
• Two Executive Orders in 1998 and 1999
Promoted the use of Renewable and Biobased
Products by all Government Agencies
• Farm Security and Rural Investment Act (2002)
• Procurement Program (designated Items)
• Agency Promotion Program
• Annual Review and Monitoring of Plan
• As a Result, Federal Agencies are Required to
Buy Biobased Products to the Maximum Extent
Practicable, Provided:
• Products are Available
• Meet Performance Standards
• Reasonable Priced / Best Value
Pentagon DoD
Biobased Products-Enhancing
DOD’s Mission, Protecting The
Environment Sept 12-13, 2006
Pictured l-r are: Dep. Sec. of Defense, Gordon England; Sec. of Agriculture, Mike Johanns; Senator
Richard Lugar R, Indiana; Representative Marcy Kaptur D Ohio and Senator Thomas Harkin D,
Iowa.
Why RLI ?
Advantages Over Competition:
¾Improved Oxidation Stability
¾Improved Cold Temperature Performance
¾Ability to Formulate Many More Products
¾More Price Competitive
¾Ability to Prove High Performance
Technology
¾Full Service Product Line
¾Compatible with most Petroleum &
Synthetic Lubricants
Renewable Lubricants Products Perform!
Rotary Bomb Oxidation Test @ 1500C (ASTM D-2272):
A Comparative Study of Hydraulic Fluids Over Time
540
Bio-Ultimax 2000 ISO 32 (Biobased)
359
Bio-Ultimax 1000 ISO 68 (Biobased)
237
Bio-HVO2 FR ISO 46 (Biobased)
260
Petroleum AW Hyd Oil B
200
Petroleum AW Hyd Oil C
190
LZ Biobased/Synthetic Polyolester
Renewable Lubricants
Petroleum Based
Other Biobased
177
Biobased Polyolester
165
FR -H Biobased ISO 68
102
Synthetic Ester
35.2
UTF-T 46 (Biobased)
C-130 FG Mineral Oil
30
LZ Canola Biobased A
27
Cargill (Biobased)
27
Commercial Biobased B
26
17.6
AU-F 68 Biobased
0
100
200
300
400
Oxidation Time, Minutes
500
600
Renewable Lubricants Products Perform!
Rotary Bomb Oxidation Test (ASTM D-2272):
A Comparative Study of Hydraulic Fluids Over Time
540
Bio-Ultimax 2000 ISO 32 (Biobased)
359
Bio-Ultimax 1000 ISO 68 (Biobased)
237
Bio-HVO2 FR ISO 46 (Biobased)
260
Petroleum AW Hyd Oil B
200
Petroleum AW Hyd Oil C
190
LZ Biobased/Synthetic Polyolester
177
Quaker Oil Biobased Polyolester
Renewable Lubricants
Petroleum Based
Renewable
Lubricants
Other Biobased
165
Houghton Biobased ISO 68
102
Synthetic Ester
35.2
Terresolve UTF 46 (Biobased)
Castrol 130 FG Mineral Oil
30
LZ Canola Biobased A
27
Cargill (Biobased)
27
Commercial Biobased B
26
Fuchs Plantohyd 68 Biobased
17.6
0
Petroleum based
Other Biobased
Unknown base oil
100
200
300
Oxidation Time, Minutes
400
500
600
RLI - MRV Cold Weather Superiority
Hydraulic Fluid
Viscosity
0C
Pass / Fail
Cargill/
Fuchs
Solidified
-25
Fail
Lubrizol
Commercial
Solidified
-25
Fail
RLI
1948 cps
2730 cps
-25
-30
Pass
Pass
RLI
1791 cps
3438 cps
-25
-30
Pass
Pass
PPD (2%)
Hydraulic Cold Static Test -200 C
Formula #
Result
Comments
Northern Iowa Hydraulic
Fluid (ELM)
Fail - 1 day
Solid < 12 hrs.
AgroManagement
AMG 2000
Fail - 1 day
Solid < 24 hrs.
Mobil EAL 224
Hydraulic Fluid
Mobil EAL 224
Hydraulic Fluid
Fail - 22 days
5 % - ice crystals
formed
Fail - 60 days
95% solidified
RLI Bio-32 Hydraulic
Fluid
Pass-90 days
Liquid (clear)
Energy Conserving Formulas
ENERGY CONSERVING FORMULATIONS
WITH RESERVE FLUID VALUE
5500
5000
4500
4000
V isco sity (cSt)
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
Temperature (C)
0
0C
10 C
20 C
30 C
40 C
50 C
60 C
Conventional Gear O il ISO 220 VI 96
5105.26
1907.2
820.96
397.34
212
122.71
76.05
Bio-Syn EP Gear ISO 220 VI 179
1826.58
931.3
514.6
304.48
191
125.98
86.76
70 C
80 C
90 C
49.93
34.42
24.72
62.03
45.81
34.8
Energy Conserving Formulas
Viscosity (cSt.)
ENERGY CONSERVING FORMULATIONS
WITH RESERVED FLUID VALUE
625
600
575
550
525
500
475
450
425
400
375
350
325
300
275
250
225
200
175
150
125
100
75
50
25
Te mpe rature (C)0
0C
10 C
20 C
30 C
Conve ntional Hyd 46 VI 100 Vis
575.87 257.48 130.22
Conve ntional Hyd 46 VI 100 5%
Re duction in Vis
555.92 246.58 124.04 69.11
72.8
40 C
50 C
60 C
70 C
80 C
90 C
100 C 110 C 120 C
44.17
28.67
19.68
14.14
10.56
8.15
6.46
5.24
4.34
41.85
27.13
18.61
13.37
9.99
7.71
6.12
4.97
4.12
Bio-Ultimax 1000 ISO 46 VI 195 Viscosity 281.42 160.5
98.29
63.91
43.7
31.18
23.08
17.62
13.81
11.08
9.07
7.55
6.39
Bio-Ultimax 1000 ISO 32 VI 186 Viscosity 200.02 114.47
70.5
46.15
31.8
22.87
17.06
13.13
10.37
8.38
6.91
5.79
4.93
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance: Army TACOM
• Four years of Development of Biobased DOD
Hydraulic Fluid for M1 Tanks & Howitzers
– Refer to Letter From CTC July 29, 2004 (Product Data Book)
– RLI Passes Grueling, Demanding Military Specifications
• Fire Resistant
• Biodegradable
• Meets –600 C Pour Point (Cold Weather Performance)
• Very High Oxidation Stability (High Temperature
Performance)
– RLI finished on top out of 30 Companies
– More testing to be completed
– RLI Will Move to Field Study for the DOD
– Hydraulic Sales to DOD 31 Million Gallons
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
Navy Seals
Submersible
• Testing for Bio-Ultimax 1000 Hydraulic Fluid
ISO 32 for Navy Submarine Advanced Seal
Delivery System Replacing MIL-PRF-17672D
– Northrop Grumman requested samples
– RLI Passes Grueling, Demanding Navy Military Specifications
• Pass - Out Gas Test for Diver Safety
• Approved by Navy Medical – Non Toxic
• Pass - Biodegradable
• Improved High & Low Temperature Fluidity
• Exceeds Oxidation Requirements in RBOT of 174 minutes
– Navy Requested Pricing for future Purchasing
– This Product will be issued a NSN (National Stock Number
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
Navy Seals
Submersible
• Testing for Bio-Ultimax 1000 Hydraulic Fluid ISO 32 for
Navy Submarine Advanced Seal Delivery System Replacing
MIL-PRF-17672D
Navy ASDS and Fleet
• Replace Hydraulic Fluid in submersible fleet
– Environmental Issues in applications over water
– Present lubricant (Castrol 130) is toxic to divers
• Solution: RLI Bio Ultimax 1000 ISO 32 Hydraulic Fluid
– Environmentally Friendly, Biodegradable
– RLI Passes Grueling, Demanding Navy Military Specifications
• Pass - Out Gas Test for Diver Safety
• Approved by Navy Medical Non Toxic
• Pass - Biodegradable
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™Seven years of Superior Performance
at Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore
wins the White House Closing the Circle
Award using RLI Products
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
BMW Oracle Racing Team
www.bmworacleracing.com
Bio Ultimax Hydraulic Steering Fluid that is formulated exclusively for
BMW-Oracle Racing. The hydraulic steering system was designed by
PWS Motion Control. www.pwsdirect.com
Why RLI Biobased?
Bio Ultimax Hydraulic Steering Fluid that is formulated exclusively for
BMW-Oracle Racing.
Why RLI Biobased?
Bio Ultimax Hydraulic Steering Fluid that is formulated exclusively for
BMW-Oracle Racing.
Why RLI Biobased?
Sails are stored below deck. This is where the Bio-Ultimax pays off!
BMW Oracle Racing Team “Report”
“Nothing separates the men from the boys during extreme competition
such as the regattas leading up to the 07 America's Cup”. And, I wanted
to share with RLI an interesting report I received from the field using
the specially formulated, low foaming, high performance Bio-Ultimax
fluid that you formulated exclusively for BMWOracle Racing.
BMWOracle has constructed one of two of their 07 Cup boats. Their
chief hydraulic fabricator technician and boat builder Rolf Engleberts,
had called me about converting from their MIL SPEC 83272 fluid to the
special Bio-Ultimax.
Ultimax And, I reviewed the flushing procedure with him.
Two days later Rolf called me and said they changed out the old fluid to
the Bio Ultimax overnight without telling the sailing team.
After the day of racing, the sailing team returned to port asking Rolf
"what did you do to the hydraulic system?" Rolf replied, "what do you
mean”? The grinders and pumpers all noticed less frictional operation.
When Rolf told them that all he had done was to change out the fluid to
the Bio-Ultimax special formula - they could not believe it. As a foot
note, I was also told that any time they spilled the Bio-Ultimax such as in
changing out a fitting. it was very easy on the hands too. Reported to be
almost like a hand lotion.....but very easy to clean up. I share with you
this comment because the MIL SPEC oils have a notorious reputation of
eating up the sails stored under deck and are difficult to clean up do to
their wicking characteristics.
The BMWOracle Team thanks RLI for your good work. We hope that
BMWOracle Racing will bring back the Cup to where it rightfully
deserves.....the USA! Signed: Phil Emmons, PWS Direct Inc.
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
RapidHydra Fluids Subsea Drilling in the Gulf
of Mexico- Using Bio Ultimax 1000 ISO 68
Hydraulic Fluids
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance: Smith International
using Bio Rock Drill Oils ISO 20W60. Saving the
environment and having excellent results.
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
California. Bio-Ultimax 1000 ISO 46 High Performance
Hydraulic Fluid is used to lubricate the gangways at the
Berth 93 Port of Los Angeles the home of the Love Boat.
www.pwsdirect.com
Berth 93 is capable of berthing three of the most modern cruise ships in the world simultaneously and
accommodate the largest mega ships currently sailing.
Port of Los Angeles Gangway is Lubricated with RLI Bio Ultimax 1000 Hydraulic Fluid
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
The Tehachapi Reservoir in California. Bio-Ultimax
1000 ISO 46 High Performance Hydraulic Fluid is used to
open the reservoir gates when performance is critical.
Parker OEM www.pwsdirect.com
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ NOAA won the DOE Leadership
Award for the First Petroleum
Free Federal Vehicle using RLI
Biobased Products throughout.
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ NOAA won the DOE Leadership
Award for the First Petroleum
Free Federal Vehicle using RLI
Biobased Products throughout.
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ NOAA Ship Nancy Foster Oceanic Research (Atlantic)
All Hydraulic Systems on board using Bio-Ultimax 1000 Hydraulic Fluids. Over
1100 gallons.
Humpback with NANCY FOSTER - Look closely and you
can see the tag.
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ NOAA Ship Nancy Foster Deck Equipment
A-Frame Type: Appleton Marine, Inc.
Vertical Clearance: 23ft
Max Load: 25,000 lbs
Type: Electrohydraulic
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ NOAA Ship Nancy Foster Deck Equipment
J-Frame:
Type: Electrohydraulic
Lifting Capacity: 5,000 lbs
EM Winch: 01 Deck
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ NOAA Ship Nancy Foster Deck Equipment
AFT Deck Crane Type: North American Crane
Max Length: 35ft
Lifting Capacity: 2,325 lbs
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
The Great Lakes Towing Company in the great lakes
is Making the Change to RLI Bio Lubricants in the
Tug Boats
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ Cheboygan MI lock slides lubricated with RLI
Lubricants
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
™ USDA Agricultural Research Center at Beltsville MD
wins the Closing the Circle Award using RLI Products
in 380 Equipment & Vehicles using RLI Bio-Products
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High
Performance:
™ USDA
Agricultural
Research
Center at
Beltsville MD
Tour Bus
Power by B-20
and fully
lubricated by
RLI Biolubricants,
Hydraulic and
Engine oils
Why RLI Biobased?
Proven High Performance:
• RLI’s Engine, Transmission, and Differential
Fluids have lubricated Mark Thomas’ 3500 HP
racer to 6 IHRA World Championships.
.
Mark Thomas
6 Time IHRA World Champion Alcohol Funny Car
Sponsored by Corn Growers Association
SAE 70 Corn Engine Oil -- SAE 75W140 Corn Oil Gear Oil
SAE 10 Corn Based Transmission Fluid
Why RLI Biobased?
Kent State University thru PARTA is Using RLI Biobased Fuel
Additives in Service Fleet
Bio-Power Performs
Bio-Power Diesel Fuel Conditioner
“Solves The Problems With Ultra Low Sulfur
Diesel Fuel”
Portage Area Transit Authority (Kent, Ohio) Taking
advantage of the excellent products and great
prices!
◆ Improves Fuel Economy (4.1% to 13.6%)
and horsepower (up to 5.6%)
◆ Reduces Exhaust Emission (up to 42%
less black smoke)
◆ Provides approved EPA standards for world
class “Premium Diesel” injector cleanliness,
lubricity, and stability
◆ Bio-Power Winter formula protects against
low temperature gelling and icing
◆ Less than $ .01 to treat per gallon of fuel
when purchasing Bio-Power by the drum
◆ Improved drive ability, reduced combustion
noise, longer component life, and reduced
operating costs
PARTA gained over 10% fuel efficiency resulting
in more than $50,000 in savings per year!
PARTA testing shows significant reduction in
engine wear!
Why RLI Biobased?
“REGIONAL TRANS IT AUTHORITIES ”
BIOBAS ED FLUIDS PERFORM
"Biobased Lubricants that Perform Like Synthetics"
Bio-Power T M Performs / PARTA Leading the W ay
Portage Area Region al Tran sit Authority (Kent, Ohio) Taking adv antage of Outstanding
Biobased Lubricant Performance
PARTA gained up to 10% fuel efficiency as a result of using Bio-Power TM Fuel Conditioners to clean
up the carbon deposit problems on the injectors in in their 72v ehicle fleet, as a result PARTA could
see over $50,000 in sav ings on fuel costs this year. PARTA’s exhaust emissions have also been
significantly reduced resulting in a more friendly env ironment for their riders.
Testing has shown that the use of this Biobased technology results in an av erage gain of 4.1% to
13.6% fuel efficiency depending upon the size and type of engine being used.
Bio--Power TM Diesel Fuel
Bio
Conditioner
“Solves The Problems With Ultra Low Sulfur
Diesel Fuel”
◆ Improves Fuel Economy (4.1% to 13.6%) and
horsepower (up to 5.6%)
◆ Reduces Exhaust Emission (up to 42% less
black smoke)
◆ Provides approved EPA standards for world
class “Premium Diesel” injector cleanliness,
lubricity, and stability
◆ Improved drive ability, reduced combustion noise,
longer component life, and reduced operating
costs
◆ Less than $ .01 to treat per gallon of fuel when
purchased by the drum
Renewable Lu bricants, Inc.
476 Griggy Rd., P.O. Box 474, Hartville, Ohio USA 44632
Voice: 330.877.9982 Fax: 330.877.2266
www.renewablelube.com
◆ Bio-Power Winter formula protects against low
temperature gelling and icing
• Renewable Lubricants is an Ohio Manufacturer w/over 120 Biobased Fluids
• Not all Biobased Fluids are the same, Independent Testing Confirms RLI Bio-Fluids co nsistently outperform
the others time and again
• Bi obased Fluids Perform and Protect Your Environment while Extending the Life of Your Equipment
Co py righ t 1 99 9 , by Ren ewab le Lub rican ts, In c.
Why RLI Biobased?
“REGIONAL TRANSIT AUTHORITIES”
BIOBASED FLUIDS PERFORM
Bio-PowerTM Performs / PARTA Leading the Way
Portage Area Regional Transit Authority (Kent, Ohio) Taking advantage of Outstanding Biobased Lubricant
Performance
PARTA gained up to 10% fuel efficiency as a result of using Bio-PowerTM Fuel Conditioners
to clean up the carbon deposit problems on the injectors in in their 72 vehicle fleet, as a
result PARTA could see over $50,000 in savings on fuel costs this year. PARTA’s exhaust
emissions have also been significantly reduced resulting in a more friendly environment for
their riders.
•Renewable Lubricants is a Manufacturer w/over 120 Biobased Fluids
•Not all Biobased Fluids are the same, Independent Testing Confirms RLI Bio-Fluids consistently
outperform the others time and again
•Biobased Fluids Perform and Protect Your Environment while Extending the Life of Your Equipment
Why RLI Biobased?
Benefits of Bio-Hydraulic & Bio-Trans Fluids
•Energy conserving
•Zinc-free additive systems
•Proven field performance
•Environmentally non-toxic, Ultimate
Biodegradable)
•Meets or exceeds pump requirements (J20C –
J20D, J14A)
•Extremely low volatility increases flash and fire
safety features
•Compatible with Petroleum Based Hydraulic Fluid
“YES YOU CAN TOP FILL”
Why RLI Biobased?
Bio-Penetrating Lubricant (BPL)
"Biobased Lubricants that Perform Like Synthetics"
A specially formulated, ultimately biodegradable1 penetrant that can be used as a light lubricant.
Because of the super high viscosity index of the HOBS, this product performs in many applications.
BPL’s patented composition of additives and base fluids provides a protective, thin film lubricant.
This natural oily film has shown in laboratory and field tests to outperform petroleum base oils in
terms of natural lubricity.
BPL is formulated to penetrate into close tolerant areas, then lubricate, and prevent corrosion. BPL’s
ability to creep is demonstrated by placing a 3/8” x 2” bolt on its head with ¼” of BPL in the bottom of
a lab beaker; BPL creeps vertically up the threads. It protects deep into the core of a cable or chain
link and is excellent as a light air tool lubricant and preservative oil for parts. BPL contains no VOCs,
displaces moisture, and provides a high dielectric (47 kV ASTM D-887) insulating property in
electrical equipment. This product has exceptional benefits over petroleum oils in these applications
because there is direct danger of polluting the water, soil, or work environment through loss of the
petroleum lubricant.
Applications
- Military
Tools
Jacks
Dies
Locks
- Industrial
- Transportation
Machine Tools
Assembly Parts
Shafts
Linkage Cables
Typical Data
Specific Gravity @60OF.
Viscosity @40OC., cSt.
Flash Point, PMCC
Pour Point (Rotational)
Four Ball Wear
Copper Corrosion Prevention
Rust Prevention
Distilled Water
Synthetic Sea Water
Bearings
Wire ropes
Hinges
Air Valves
ASTM
ASTM
ASTM
ASTM
ASTM
ASTM
ASTM
D-287
D-445
D-93
D-5985
D-2266
D-130
D-665
- Marine
- Agricultural
Bolts
Chains
Firearms
Air Tools
.88
15.4
295OF (146OC)
-30OC
.40 mm
1A
Pass-Clean
Pass-Clean
Why RLI Biobased?
Awards
• Beltsville MD Agricultural Research
Center
– 2001 Winner of White House Closing the Circle
Award “Team Biodiesel”
– 2002 Winner of White House Closing the Circle
Award Using RLI Biobased Lubricants
• Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore
– 2002 Winner of White House Closing the Circle
Award Environmental Award for using RLI Biobased
Products
White House Closing the Circle (CTC) Awards recognizes outstanding
achievements of Federal employees and their facilities for efforts which resulted in
significant contributions to or have made a significant impact on
promoting environmental stewardship.
RLI Test Vehicle At USDA in DC Earth Day
1999 Ford Turbo Diesel
SAE 15W40 HO Soybean Formula
Over 100,000 miles with Soybean Oil in Engine
RLI MARKETING
• Government/GSA/DLA
- Department of Interior
• Bureau of Land Management
• National Parks
- Department of Agriculture
• Forestry
- Department of Defense
- Department of Energy
- Department of Transportation
- State and Local government
• Including city, county, township,
and village
• State and city parks
•Aerospace
•Heavy Industrial
•Food Processing Industry
•Agriculture
•Marine
•Mining
•Construction
•Retail Consumer
MARKET/COMMERCIALIZATION & R&D PARTNERS
¾ DOD, USDA, DOI, DOE (Grants)
¾ United Soybean Board (Grants)
¾ Lubrizol (In-Kind)
¾
¾
¾
¾
¾
¾
¾
¾
¾
Chevron Phillips Chemical (Cash & In-Kind)
Dow Agro Sciences LLC (Cash & In-Kind)
Ohio Soybean Council (Grant)
Michigan & Virginia Soybean (In-Kind)
Cenex/Land O’ Lakes CHS (In-Kind)
Ohio Corn Growers (Grant)
CTC (In-Kind)
Battelle (Cash)
Universities (In-Kind)
Bio Ultimax Hyd & Gear Oil
Benefits
Product
Name
Biobased
Eco-Non
Toxic
Biodegradable
Renewable
Super
High VI
USDA
Food
Grade
OSHA
ISO-14000
Complian
t
Bio- Food Grade
Hydraulic Oil
YES
YES
YES
YES
YES
YES
YES
Ultimax 1000
Hydraulic Oil
YES
YES
YES
YES
YES
NO
YES
Bio-Gear Oil
YES
YES
YES
YES
YES
NO
YES
Conventional
Mineral Oil
Group 1
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Conventional
Mineral White Oil
NO
??
NO
NO
NO
YES
NO
Bio Penetrant Benefits
Product
Name
NO
VOC’s
EcoNonToxic
Biodegradable
Flammable
Combustible
AntiWear
OSHA
ISO14000
Complian
t
USD
A
Food
Grad
e
Biobased
Renewabl
e
Plastic
&
Rubber
YES
YES
YES
NO
YES
YES
NO
YES
Good
YES
YES
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
YES
Good
LPS-1
NO
NO
NO
YES
NO
NO
NO
NO
Poor
LPS-2
NO
NO
NO
YES
NO
NO
NO
NO
Good
WD-40
NO
NO
NO
YES
NO
NO
NO
NO
Poor
BPL
BPL
FG