The 1920s Ku Klux Klan in Oakland, California
Transcription
The 1920s Ku Klux Klan in Oakland, California
White Nativism and Urban Politics: The 1920s Ku Klux Klan in Oakland, California Author(s): Chris Rhomberg Source: Journal of American Ethnic History, Vol. 17, No. 2 (Winter, 1998), pp. 39-55 Published by: University of Illinois Press on behalf of the Immigration & Ethnic History Society Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/27502269 . Accessed: 05/06/2015 01:04 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. . University of Illinois Press and Immigration & Ethnic History Society are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of American Ethnic History. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions White Nativism and Urban Politics: The 1920s Ku Klux Klan in Oakland, California CHRIS RHOMBERG a horde in white robes and masks 1,500 men a in in hills the above Oakland, gathered valley across the sky, as a fiery cross Two searchlights beamed California. burned behind an altar draped with the American flag. At a given signal, 500 more unmasked men marched four abreast toward the altar, to take 5 MAY ON 1922, in silence of at night their oaths and be initiated into the order of theKnights of theKu Klux Klan.1 Hooded Klansmen from as far away San Jose and Los Angeles mento, Fresno, brethren in the ceremony. In the 1920s, the city of Oakland was as San Francisco, Sacra came to join their Oakland a center in 1921, within three years members. Local Klan leaders California. Started at least 2,000 late into the decade, an election led directly to a major the mid-twenties, and Western west Inc., grew J. Simmons, theKnights of to an estimated extending well states, before County OF THE TWENTIES Founded inAtlanta in 1915 by William Klan, district attorney and justice) Earl Warren, reform of the Oakland charter. city THE KLAN MOVEMENT the Ku Klux in activity Klan grew to success political enjoyed for county sheriff in 1926 and in a broken power was finally winning in 1927. Their for city commissioner trial celebrated graft prosecuted by Alameda States Supreme Court chief (and later United the scandal of Klan the Oakland beyond three million the Old South members in into the Mid declining rapidly by the end of the it of Klan" portrayed decade.2 Traditional this "Second interpretations as an irrational, backward-looking extremist movement of low status or the last gasp of a dying rural and individuals, symbolizing marginal in the face of urban modernism and a mass small-town Protestantism have seen the growth class.3 Recent years, however, immigrant working in the United of a new historiography of the 1920s era Ku Klux Klan case studies have appeared that question States. A number of detailed This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Journal of American 40 Ethnic History /Winter 1998 about the Klan.4 As early as 1967, Kenneth assumptions was as much an urban as a rural showed that the movement the traditional Jackson Other studies have shown that the Klan were frequently phenomenon.5 more successful where native white Protestants were a majority, and not or minority a declining resembled the group. Klan members generally in occupational overall white male status, with relatively population collar and skilled workers and less among white greater representation among the very elite and the unskilled. articulated prevailing white middle-class in civic and electoral Such politics.6 the movement often Moreover, values and participated actively that the Klan, features suggest rather than a deviant actor in should be seen as a significant aberration, the urban political arena. to this debate with a study of the 1920s Klan This essay contributes movement in Oakland. It begins with a review of contemporary socio economic conditions in the city, the size including the examines population. Next, study the rise of white nativism. These will Protestant white context and and impact of the Ku Klux Klan organization OAKLAND and status of the the local political the help explain in Oakland. IN 1920 was a rapidly maturing metropolis on the an on with built manufac economy Bay, tures of capital goods, construction, coastal trade and the processing of was Oakland the West from the area's rural hinterland. Coast goods terminus for three transcontinental rail lines, and the Southern Pacific In 1920, the city of Oakland shore of San Francisco eastern was major yards. The War One, and other property city also and was owner and experienced fast becoming in its huge West Oakland employer a brief ship-building in World boom a branch plant center for automobiles industries.7 came population In addi economic Alongside development growth. to of Oakland from the 1906 San Francisco tion, migration refugees areas east of the city, brought and annexation of outlying earthquake, total city population from 66,960 in 1900 to 150,174 in 1910, to 216,261 1920.8 At that time Oakland this group was was but the 95 percent white, of In whites 1910, composition "foreign changing. or native-born stock" (foreign-born of foreign or mixed had parents) in the city. With for 61 percent of all whites of accounted the decline in World War One and after, however, of native whites immigration by almost of native parents in Oakland grew from 39 percent of all whites This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions in 1910 to 41 Rhomberg 44 percent in 1920, and continued rising to 49 percent by 1930.9At the same total of Roman Catholics the city's time, the proportion among in 1916 to 53.5 percent in fell from 68.4 percent church membership 1926.10 industrial development, the city as a whole was Moreover, despite class. Commercial and residential growth meant becoming more middle rose from 35 percent of clerical and trade employment that professional, the city's working population in 1920 to 42 percent in 1930, while the fell from 49 percent to 42 percent. Simi employment rates also increased: owner occupancy increased larly, homeownership share of industrial from 41 percent of Oakland homes in 1920 to 49 percent in 1930.11 In short, the typical base of the Klan, native white Protestant middle classes, were hardly a declining the data more closely group in Oakland. Rather, of a rising group, with a corresponding in fit a hypothesis greater weight the political arena. ETHNIC FORMATION AND URBAN POLITICS in Oakland were around contending urban loosely organized on Alameda boss Michael J. factions, County ("Mike") in 1864, Kelly was appointed Born in West county Kelly. Virginia treasurer in 1906 and county tax collector in 1919. A Catholic, Kelly Politics centered machine rose to power by allying with Governor Hiram Johnson and the Republi can progressives. In 1921, he was named Superintendent of the United in San Francisco, with the aid of (now United States Mint States Sena tor) Hiram Johnson.12 As in other American pattern provided of ethnic access tied to the cities, machine politics was closely and working class formation.13 Patronage and nepotism to jobs and served as crude forms of social insurance, ethnic group formation and maintaining corporate loyalty reinforcing the The latter were concentrated classes.14 among dependent working in the old lower-income Fourth and Sixth wards, located near especially in the multi-racial and ethnic West the railroad yards and the waterfront one of the oldest sections of the city.15 neighborhood, over a city In Oakland, the popular Mayor John L. Davie presided of streets, of four commissioners council composed heading departments revenue and finance, health and public safety, and public works.16 Elected in alliance with the in 1915, Davie won re-election three times, usually a A Davie and colorful machine.17 vote-getter, Kelly figure prodigious Oakland was a master of public spectacle and of the maneuverings This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions on the coun 42 Journal of American latter were cil. The often Ethnic History /Winter 1998 as incumbent commissioners quickly own into their departments political fiefdoms.18 The constant and factionalism in city hall, however, under logrolling mined the machine's and alienated governing ability public opinion, complex, turned their administrative the stage for popular setting opposition AND WHITE NATIVISM ANTI-MACHINISM Anti-machine sentiments like the Alameda County to the machine. were groups expressed by good government Its 1918 campaign literature de Federation. has been in clared, "For many years the 'MIKE KELLY MACHINE' come The bulk of its financial control.... has from the support always the the and the 'Red saloons, liquor interests, gambling joints, Light District.' It has consistently in the Legisla fought every DRY measure candidates for County and State of ture, and is now supporting WET in an endeavor fices to save everything for the saloon" in [emphasis original].19 As the above often found close shows, anti-machine progressivism The latter incorporated Protestant middle company with prohibitionism. class prejudice ethnic and especially Catholic mor against lower-class as as a test well of of the als, providing key probity public officials.20 Postwar November also merged patriotism easily 1921 issue of the Oakland "published forcement in the interests into xenophobia and bigotry. The a monthly Crusader, magazine of American and Ideals, Law En Principles as follows: editorialized "The Reform," as a to the United States is serious problem of immigration problem for are the same.... this country as Irish ascendancy. The dangers The more we get of Southern Ireland and Southern Europe the quicker the control and Social of the United and Moral States will pass into their hands."21 These values had an impact on mainstream The Oakland politics. are wrote of schools in thousands of men "There 1920, superintendent or the English in Oakland who, without of citizen knowledge language, ship, are sources of greatest danger to our government." Shortly before J.H. for Congress in 1922, insurance salesman campaign was as touted in the defense and perpetuation "[a believer] MacLafferty ... he of American ideals as they were handed down by our forefathers stresses the need of protecting the Government from its enemies within? his successful the 'reds'?and the enemies without?the antagonism was Japanese. Americanism is his creed."22 Anti-machine perhaps greatest in East Oakland. This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Only 43 Rhomberg in 1909, East Oakland residents were distant from the factions based in the older and more diverse West political ethnically Oakland.23 At the same time, East Oakland was the most rapidly grow annexed recently ing area in the city. By the end of the decade, the population of East Oakland (Brooklyn Township) nearly doubled from 1920, surpassing that of the rest of the city.24 This swelling population a substantial part of the potential Oakland electorate for ground political entrepreneurs. Boomtown conditions also growth made East and a competitive led to mounting like sewers against city grievances and street paving, prime authorities, particularly sources of patronage for the machine. Such complaints were often di rected against Commissioner of Streets William Baccus, himself a build over services ing contractor in 1903 from veteran and a twenty-two-year the old machine Sixth Ward of the council, first elected In one Oakland.25 inWest in 1925, members of the 13th Avenue Club in instance, Improvement on their street, East Oakland claimed contractor overcharges of $16,000 which after completion. allegedly began cracking up only three months and when initiated the council an unsuccessful recall petition against Commissioner Baccus.26 saw the emergence the twenties of a rising Protestant middle class in Oakland, parts of which the decade Overall, white native-born remained institutions. city and got an investigation by the City Council, ruled the the club residents, ultimately against demanded Club members of in or alienated from the city's political incorporated concerns such as moral reform, law enforcement, and this conflict with established ethnic into group brought weakly Civic services The prevalence of nativist power in the urban machine. ideology a in frame these ethnic and issues racial and terms, provided helped of a white nativist movement. fertile ground for the development group THE KU KLUX KLAN IN OAKLAND, 1921-1925 and R.M. Carruthers of the 1921, organizers W.G. McRae By August in downtown Ku of the Klux had Inc., Klan, Knights opened an office as the other Klan Oakland. Among agents promoted organization things, a patriotic fraternal society, committed to "keep closer check upon pub to prevent "laxity in the discharging of the duties of public lic officials," of cases involving and to "fix its attention on the prosecution offices," in January Oakland Kl?n No. 9 was chartered the honor of women."27 were to witness and in March 1,000 1922, reporters secretly brought masked members initiate 200 more in the rural Contra Costa This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions hills north Journal of American 44 Ethnic History /Winter of the city. A week later, journalists were again invited to watch in full regalia performed Klansmen funeral services for a deceased 1998 as six mem ber at a local crematorium.28 in the California Klan was interrupted in the summer of 1922, Los Angeles District Attorney Thomas Lee Woolwine raided Klan re there and uncovered membership lists for the entire Pacific offices to district attorneys lists were circulated the gion. These throughout Growth when state, and the resulting publicity brought reaction against the order and mass defections In Oakland, of exposed members. the city council unani an to ban masking in public. Yet, although the ordinance passed mously names of fifty Oakland some current and former residents (including city police) were ney Ezra DeCoto Oakland Klan reportedly on the list, Alameda County District never released the names, and the scandal seemingly unscathed.29 in Oakland the contrary, Klan activity ber elections that fall. The state Governor's On dry Republican District Attorney lic Democrat. comment candidate during week, with the the Novem race pitted the conservative from Berkeley, Richardson, against the Klan's hated adversary Woolwine, The state KKK endorsed Richardson, Woolwine stage Friend escalated Attor left and a wet Catho who to refused on his alleged the campaign ties to the order.30 When a band of Klansmen in Oakland in October rushed the spoke and tried to place a Klan a Klan rally at the Oakland The following image on the platform. featured one speaker who Auditorium if we are to remove "The election of Richardson is imperative declared, and Negroes in the Jews, Catholics from public Anti life California." also played a role in local contests, especially the campaign Catholicism Police Edward the city with flooded against Judge Tyrrell. Opponents to "Catholi candidates literature endorsing purportedly seeking phony a names cize America," and signed with false Catholic orga suggesting nization.31 Tyrrell survived the challenge to his re-election, but Richardson won an overwhelming to become statewide majority the new Governor. as a the functioned Klan semi-official group, ac Locally, vigilante a on as secret federal agents fraternal raids, and prohibition companying society, at a time when grassroots political tary) Ed L. Arnest fraternal societies were a common In 1923, Klan No. organization.32 and Exalted Cyclops for city commissioner vehicle of 9 Kligrapp (Secre C. Francis ran (President) Leon and school board, respectively. fields in both races, Arnest won 9 percent and Francis 18 percent of the vote.33 By 1924, Klan No. 9 had at least 2,000 mem a following of many thousands more. That summer, bers and claimed in the primaries crowded Despite This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 45 Rhomberg organizers planned a statewide in Oakland convention and secured a parade permit from the city for the Fourth of July. Citing the threat of Commissioner of Health and Public however, Safety Frank the permit. Hundreds later revoked and of Klan members a at council but firm. Colbourn remained supporters protested hearing, to the nearby city of Rich The convention and parade were relocated a reported 3,000 Klansmen on July 4, followed marched mond, where violence, Colbourn by an evening initiation in the El Cerrito Newspaper, local Klansmen civil case ceremony and criminal records hills.34 the names reveal of 69 of whom 58 were identifiable through city sources. a not directory Although sample, these representative some of the most and their included and active members, prominent are characteristics included Protestant church suggestive.35 Klan members in Oakland, and other and salesmen, small businessmen, skilled men, managers professionals, of the Oakland Fire Department, and even blue-collar workers, members for 49 per the son of a congressman. data were available Household sons; of these 41 (84 percent) lived in households, and 8 (16 percent) roomers or boarders. Fifty of the known Klansmen lived in Oak with the in remainder Piedmont land, (an affluent residing Berkeley, or more enclave in the Oakland suburban distant suburbs. Among hills), were Oakland residents, 29 (58 percent) lived inEast Oakland, 8(16 percent) lived inNorth Oakland, and 13 (26 percent) lived inDowntown orWest lived in only 22 percent of the known Klansmen more the older neighborhood of West Oakland, while than three-quar ters lived in the outer areas of the city or the suburbs. Oakland.36 Altogether, data are consistent These socioeconomic base with other case studies that show of Klan a broad in Moreover, membership. strength does not appear to have been concentrated among residents of older or ethnically but rather in the changing neighborhoods, Oakland declining newer, more homogeneous ascendant group, asserting Klan middle-class itself areas.37 This independently in the Oakland population. changes As late as October 1924, the Oakland Klan of initiations 50 or more recruits. group ing fact and reflecting an suggests the overall to grow, hold the end of the year, By the Atlanta-based national Klan over its continued tensions erupted with however, efforts to impose greater control over the California realm. At a meeting on 28 November some 500 members of Klan No. 9 unanimously 1924, the authority of Imperial repre passed a resolution refusing to recognize sentative acting G.W. Price and asking for his Hiram Evans, for Imperial Wizard removal. suspended next day, Price, the charter of Klan The This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Journal of American 46 Ethnic History /Winter 1998 filed suit to 9, and the following January the parent corporation recover assets and rights to its name. Klan No. 9 remained active through its property was seized as part of the protracted 1925, when litiga April No. won all of its legal battles tion. Although Klan No. 9 eventually (its was on ruled its resources were illegal procedural grounds) suspension exhausted and the organization effectively disintegrated.38 not the end of the Klan movement. this was apparently However, the Klan No. 9 leaders had transferred their suspension, their Before a to called Inc. Some funds East Bay Club, group's parallel organization J.F. DeBorde and Charles months earlier, Southern California Klansmen a rival corporation under the laws of the state of Hayes had organized Inc. called the Invisible Empire Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, Nevada the end of 1924 and into 1925, Klan No. 9 leaders collaborated Through with DeBorde in recruiting and Hayes their members In February Klan. and others to join the Nevada a Cali organized 1925, DeBorde, Hayes called the White Cross Clan, and corporation charter was granted to Oakland Clan No. 9 of theWhite fornia this time there were 9 in Oakland, 1925, in a show No. a 1925 in May Cross Clan. By at least three organizations known as Klan (or Clan) as well as the East Bay Club.39 Finally, in August the national Great Titan T.S. of strength by order, an initiation into the apparently loyal Oak in the Oakland ceremony was conducted and their support attended by 8,500 klansmen and women Auditorium, a and band from the Oakland ers, and featured organization 75-piece of the Ku Klux and Women drill teams from the national Klavaliers held Moodie land Klan Nos. of 500 "aliens" 1 and 3. The Klan.40 the decline or proliferation this signified is unclear, as the fate of the other klaverns the Oakland movement its internal struggles Whether nization of local Klan orga is not known. apparently Yet, suffered despite on the contrary, hundreds of spectators packed no public discredit; the to show their support.41 Moreover, Oakland Klan civil case hearings ties to with numerous active political leaders remained entrepreneurs, of other civic, fraternal and political activities. Leon C. Francis, Cyclops of the East Bay Club, and vice-president of the Klan No. 9, president state White and Legion, Fred Haase ment effort officers the American of the Masons, Clan, was a member state the central Klansman committee.42 later, Republican testified as an expert witness for the 13th Avenue Improve Cross in their paving against Commissioner Club Andrew Brooks, controversy of Streets Danver in the recall and participated along with Klan No. 9 Baccus, MacGregor and J.H. MacLafferty, This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Jr. 47 Rhomberg J.H. MacLafferty).43 Haase was also active in the (son of Congressman Nevada and CD. Klan, as were Jack Garbutt, Tudor, who had worked on Francis's 1923 school board campaign. In the 1925 city elections, as a delegate to the Better for the Knights of Pythias a Government coalition of civic and improvement clubs that League, included the East Bay Club.44 The most successful Klan politicians were Burton F. Becker and Wil Garbutt served liam H. Parker, Kailiff and Kleopard (lecturer) of Klan (vice-president) was No. 9, respectively.45 Becker the popular chief of police of Pied to the Moose, and belonged of America, the Modern Woodmen mont, and several Masonic ance orders. Parker was a self-made realtor and insur in the prosperous Dimond district of East Oakland. Ac tive in the Dimond Club, Parker edited a monthly Progressive neighbor and was first president of the East Oakland Consoli hood newspaper salesman of some thirty neighborhood dated Clubs, an association improvement to "questions of paving, clubs dedicated sewage, new park sites, trans lighting and other civic improvements."46 portation, its internal difficulties, then, the vitality of the Oakland Klan's Despite of its active and the legitimacy influence. The extent to which popular base, the movement's framed Klan in ethnic leaders were stream. and nativist able to cross to sustain leaders, helped civic issues were already the ease with which into the political success would come main terms underscores over the movement's and enter Indeed, greatest as County latter half of the decade, with the election of Becker of Streets in 1927. in 1926 and Parker as City Commissioner KLANSMEN The electoral and material victories of Becker issues that motivated in the Sheriff IN POWER and Parker the Klan movement the moral epitomized in Oakland. Becker was already publicly identified with theKlan in 1922 when he ran for over 23,000 votes, or about 34 percent, against sheriff, winning long Barnet was Frank Barnet.47 An ally of Mike Kelly, time incumbent sheriff with a tolerant attitude known as a traditional, patrimonial-style in the he was implicated and vice.48 In 1925, however, woman a had blackmailed who of young gruesome allegedly into believing several prominent men of the county (including Barnet) no to their child. she had given birth charges were Although illegitimate toward alcohol murder and destroyed filed, the scandal was widely publicized career. In their rematch the following year, Kelly was Barnet's forced This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions political to abandon Journal of American 48 Ethnic History /Winter 1998 and support Becker, who won easily as a modern, professional, reformist candidate. Upon immediately appointed taking office, Becker Leon C. Francis as county and fellow Klansman Parker as under-sheriff Barnet jailor.49 A few months Commissioners and later, the 1927 city council races put Mayor Davie Davie for Baccus and William Moorehead reelection. up in the primary to and won a clear majority ties with Kelly for while Parker ran independently retain his mayoralty, against Baccus hard on the street paving seat.50 Campaigning the commissioner's issue, H.T. in the primary Baccus and led runner-up eliminated Parker an opportunity to win a new into the final. Seeing going Hempstead and to recapture city patronage, Kelly and Davie backed council majority renewed Parker sioner his and challenger Charles Young support from Kelly spots. With for the two commis and with Parker's own and Davie, Parker club base in East Oakland, in the runoffs and neighborhood improvement and Young were swept into office.51 short lived. and the Klan leaders was The alliance between Kelly more even to be Klan in power, Once opportunistic proved politicians On the city council, Parker broke and corrupt than their predecessors. Klan with Davie Parker faction with Commissioners his own majority and Jack Garbutt Fred Klansmen Haase, Sturgis. his election after and in active Parker's campaign, and formed and Eugene Young E.Q. Norman were hired Garbutt surveillance and Norman on as "special to conduct investigators" later and Norman Garbutt city employees.52 and agreed to in a street paving business partners with Haase their contracts cent for foot per square specifying pay Parker one-half included over 800,000 Such contracts subsequently paving. patented in the city.53 or street work all of one-third square feet, paving political became an aggressive established In the county, Sheriff Becker system of Sheriffs and deputies gambling. bribery and extortion from bootlegging from still operators thousands of dollars of protection money collected a plan to rationalize in rural southern Alameda County and developed less and smaller the bootlegging profitable produc industry by arresting in a single designated ers and centralizing both supply and payoffs the attor men also arranged with Cromwell source. Becker's Ormsby, raids in to tip off impending ney for several Chinese lottery operators, later conspired with Garbutt and Norman for payments. Ormsby exchange Police Morals to influence the Oakland in an attempt Squad, while for the pro Mills the from received Garbutt $5,000 Company Novelty tection of slot machines.54 This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 49 Rhomberg con leaders' corruption quickly alienated their middle-class cause to In the Lions and alarm. 1928, began stituency public February a meeting of business, civic and improvement clubs to Club convened The Klan a charter launch Manager Harry reform was League The Harding. and by April the Oakland Council campaign, led local banker Lions and formed, by president to create a more efficient reformers promised city on with a strong city manager administration, system modeled explicitly the private corporation. However, the city council was able to stall the on the ballot, and the issue re efforts to place the question League's over a tied up in litigation for mained year.55 in January Earl Warren 1930, District Attorney Meanwhile, the and in Hall and the Sheriffs graft pursuing corruption City began office. Even at this time, Klan legitimacy in Oakland was high enough that Warren refuse Warren on the Alameda that Klan members feared would to indict fellow Klansmen.56 transcripts of the Grand resulted in the swift resignations released and the publicity Commissioners Parker, and others were Ormsby and the scandal County Grand Jury In an effort to break the case, to the press, Jury investigations Young and of Sheriff Becker and Sturgis. Becker, indicted, convicted eventually turned public opinion Parker, Garbutt, and sent to prison, against the commis increasingly sion form of government.57 to editorialize The Oakland in favor of the Tribune began heavily and with the the of Chamber of Com Lions, reform, manager support the Protestant Ministerial the and other Council merce, Union, groups, on a charter amend 35,000 signatures effort to save the old machine, Mayor Davie to draft their own strong called a Freeholders' election labor ethnic organizations charter, supported by unions, obtained Manager League ment petition.58 In a final and his allies mayor-council and machine-favored over In the November both elections, and the City Hall Freeholder slate were victo rious. The Freeholders submitted their charter in March 1931, but by to mobilize had lost its capacity its base. Middle this time the machine the manager businessmen.59 amendments turned out heavily slate League Council-Manager class voters charter to reject it and in the first new later elected council Knowland, The the end of popular machine in Oakland. politics under the of Tribune elites, publisher Joseph leadership thereafter assumed leading influence over city hall.60 reform marked Business the entire elections. This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Journal of American 50 Ethnic History /Winter 1998 THE LEGACY OF THE KLAN body study adds to the developing In Oakland, States. in the United This 1920s anti-machine made that was of the a rising mobilized the Klan system population against an established on leaders capitalized and machine politics. Klan de and on specific material and anti-ethnic ideologies an form middle-class residents, organizational by using white, middle-class of ethnic patronage mands on the Klan of research both Protestant to their followers familiar a critical and ultimately source of weakness. shed some light on the interpretive debate surrounding These findings In Oakland, white middle-class Protestants were not a the movement. a them and the issues that concerned but group rising one, declining as nor were neither backward but anti-modern, contemporary looking as well-paved streets. Yet, the point is not whether or with more ethnic with civic problems concerned concerns to extent law the which like but good government, prejudice, enforcement and city services could be framed in ethnic terms, and the and mundane Klansmen were ease with which Klan political entrepreneurs crossed over into the main stream. the Oakland Klan's Similarly, base nor of its socio-economic demise was due neither to the decline to its ideological marginalism. Rather, form of the secret fraternal society proved insufficient the organizational to hold the movement Klan leaders suc and opportunistic together, to of machine the corruptions cumbed politics. The defeat of the Klan, did not necessarily hinder the agenda of white middle-class however, as a group. The latter transferred from the Protestants their allegiance more to the reformers vehicle of the Klan effective anti-machine faulty elite. The crisis of Klan leaders' fall led to a deci among the business or in victory in the city's political institutions. Whether sive change an movement in the Klan left Oakland. defeat, enduring legacy NOTES 1. Oakland Post Enquirer, 6 May 1922; San Francisco Examiner, 1 May 1922. 2. David Chalmers, Hooded Americanism: The First Century of the Ku Klux Klan (New York, 1965), p. 119. 3. Richard Hofstadter, The Age of Reform: From Bryan toFDR (1955; reprint, ed., New York, 1977), p. 291; Arnold Rice, The Ku Klux Klan inAmerican Politics (New York, 1972), p. 13; George Mowry and Blaine Brownell, The Urban Nation: 1920-1980, Revised Edition (New York, 1981), p. 31; Seymour M. Lipset and Earl This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 51 Rhomberg Raab, The Politics of Unreason: (New York, 1970), p. 114. 4. For review see essays, in America, Right-Wing Extremism Leonard "Historical Moore, 1790-1970 the of Interpretations 1920's Klan: The Traditional View and the Populist Revision," Journal of Social History, 24 (Winter, 1990): 341-357; and Stanley Coben, "Ordinary White Protes tants: The KKKof the 1920s," Journal of Social History, 28 (Fall, 1994): 157-165. 5. Kenneth Jackson, The Ku Klux Klan in the City, 1915-1930 (New York, 1967). 6. Shawn Lay, Hooded Knights on the Niagara: The Ku Klux Klan in Buffalo, New York (New York, 1995); Shawn Lay, ed., The Invisible Empire in the West (Urbana, 111., 1992); Kathleen Blee, Women of theKlan: Racism and Gender in the 1920s (Berkeley, 1991), pp. 154-173; Leonard Moore, Citizen Klansmen: The Ku Klux Klan in Indiana, 1921-1928 (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1991); William Jenkins, Steel Valley Klan: The Ku Klux Klan in Ohio's Mahoning Valley (Kent, Ohio, 1991); Robert Goldberg, Hooded Empire: The Ku Klux Klan inColorado (Urbana, 111.,1981). 7. John Dykstra, "A History of the Physical Development of the City of Oak land: The Formative Years, 1850-1930," (unpublished Ph.D diss., University of California, Berkeley, 1952), p. 192; E. T. H. Bunje, "Oakland Industries, 1848 1938," Oakland: Works Progress Administration, 1939. 8. Dallas "An Smythe, Economic of Local History and Interurban Transporta tion in the East Bay Cities with Particular Reference to the Properties Developed by F. M. Smith,"(Ph.D. diss., University of California, Berkeley, 1939), pp. 130-132. Beth Bagwell, Oakland: Story of a City (Oakland, 1994) pp. 175-179; U.S., Bureau of the Census, Thirteenth Census of the United States, 1910: Vol. I, Reports by States: Supplement for California (Washington, D.C., 1913) p. 582; Abstract of Fourteenth Census of the United States: 1920 (Washington, D.C., 1923) p. 108. 9. U.S., Bureau of the Census, Abstract of the Thirteenth Census of the United States, 1910 (Washington, D.C., 1913) p. 95; Abstract of Fourteenth Census of the United States: 1920 (Washington, D.C., 1923) p. 109; Abstract of Fifteenth Census of the United States: 1930 (Washington, D.C., 1933), p. 100. 10. U.S., Bureau of Census the Census, Bodies, of Religious 1916, Part One: Summary and General Tables (Washington, D.C., 1919) p. 126; U.S. Bureau of the Census, Census of Religious Bodies, 1926, Vol. One: Summary and Detailed Tables (Washington, D.C., 1930) p. 496. 11. "Industrial manufacturing" here includes See U.S., Bureau employment" occupations. and transportation of the Census, and "mechanical Fourteenth Census of the United States, 1920: Population, Vol. IV: Occupations (Washington, D.C., 1923) pp. 1185-1188; U.S., Bureau of the Census, Fifteenth Census of the United States, 1930: Population, Vol. IV: Occupations (Washington, D.C., 1933; pp. 202-216; U.S., Bureau of the Census, tion, Vol. VI: Families 12. John F. Mullins, Census Fifteenth (Washington, D.C., "How of the United States: 1930?Popula 1933), p. 57. Earl Warren District Became an Attorney," oral history conducted in 1963 by Amelia Fry, in Perspectives on the Alameda County District Attorney's Office, Regional Oral History Office, The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1972, pp. 2-8; Hiram Johnson toMajor Archibald 13 July 1931, and Hiram Johnson Johnson, in The Diary Letters Johnson, of Hiram Past and Present York, 1983); Joseph Baker, (Chicago, Enquirer, state and 1914) p. 369; Oakland 20 November federal jobs 1940. In in the county. to Hiram County, Tribune, 20 November 1923, it was Observer, 15 January E. Burke Johnson, Jr., ed. Robert 1917-1945, of Alameda estimated 12 August California, 1933, New 2 vol. 1940; Oakland Post there were 1923. This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions more than 500 52 Journal of American Ethnic History /Winter 1998 13. Steven Erie, Rainbow's End: Irish Americans and the Dilemmas of Urban Machine Politics, 1840-1985 (Berkeley, 1988), p. 13. 14. Interview with Donald Mockel, an oral history conducted in 1981 by Sally Thomas and Padraigin McGillicuddy, Oakland Neighborhood History Project, Oak land History Room, Public Library, Oakland, California. 15. Judith May, brary, University and "Progressives and Council-Manager Commission the Poor," Environmental ms., Li Design 1970, pp. 2, 10; Steven Blutza, "Oakland's of California, Berkeley, Plans?Causes and Consequences" diss., (Ph.D. University of California, Berkeley, 1978), pp. 7-14; California Department of Trans portation, Historic Property Survey Report: For the Proposed 1-880 Reconstruction Project (San Francisco, 1990); Bagwell, Oakland: Story of a City, pp. 85-89; Lawrence Lonnie Crouchette, ward Tomorrow: A History III, and Martha Bunch, K. Winnacker, Visions of the East Bay Afro-American Community To 1852-1977 (Oakland, 1989). 16. Blutza, Oakland's 17. Observer, and Progressives Plans, Manager 18. Blutza, and Council-Manager Commission 5 February the Poor, pp. 1921, 30 April 55-56; 1921, Plans, 17 March Blutza, Oakland's and Council-Manager pp. 210-212. Commission Oakland's 164-174. pp. 1923; also May, Commission Plans, and Council pp. 208-209; Observer, 29 January 1921; Alameda County Union Labor Record, 9March 1923. 19. "Alameda County Federation Stands for Good Government," Alameda County Politics and Government Pamphlet File, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. President of the Federation was R. H. Marchant, president and general manager of theMarchant Calculating Machine Company; and its Executive Com mittee was Chair John L. Howard, vice of president the Chamber of Commerce. Polk's Oakland City Directory (Oakland, 1918). 20. James Timberlake, Prohibition and the Progressive Movement, 1900-1920 (Cambridge, Mass., 1963). In 1910, 37 percent of Oakland voters had favored a dry amendment to the city charter (the neighboring town of Berkeley was already dry), well before the 18thAmendment took effect in 1920. Oakland City Clerk, Elections 1852 to the Present, (Oakland, 1988), p. 18. 21. Crusader, (Oakland), November 1921, 2. 22. Fred Hunter, "Oakland Has Started the Second Largest School Building Campaign in the United States," Oakland Tribune Yearbook (Oakland, 1920), p. 98; Oakland Tribune Yearbook (Oakland, 1921), p. 117. 23. Observer, 2 December 1922. In 1910 the East Oakland 7th Ward voted 44 percent in favor of a city charter amendment to ban saloons in residential neighbor hoods, compared to 22 and 9 percent, respectively, in the machine's West Oakland 4th and 6th Wards. Only the North Oakland 1stWard, bordering on dry Berkeley, gave a higher share (46 percent) for the amendment. Blutza, Oakland's Commission and Plans, Council-Manager pp. Parts 185-186. of East Oakland remained loosely under the authority of city hall: In 1921, residents of the Dimond own formed their political broadside and force, police vigilante "Free Press" was reportedly his home on 93rd Avenue 1922. the following tarred and only district the editor of the year near feathered by a mob 1921; Western Appeal, 22 in Elmhurst. Observer, 2 April April 24. After boomed land from combined. years of shortages housing during the war, residential construction in the early twenties: 12,823 new single family houses were built in Oak 1921-1924, According more than to estimates, a 50 percent nearly 85 increase over percent of ten years the previous were new homes these located in East Oakland. Harry Lafler, "Oakland and Eastbay Cities Maintain Proud This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 53 Rhomberg Rank of Pacific Coast Industrial Center," Oakland Tribune Yearbook (Oakland, 1925) p. 10; U.S. Bureau of the Census, Fourteenth Census of the United States. 1920, Vol. I, Population (Washington, D.C., 1921), p. 353, Seventeenth Census of the United States, 1950, Population, Vol. II, Part 5: California (Washington, D.C., 1952) pp. 5-13. 25. Oakland Post-Enquirer, 24 April 1924, San Francisco Examiner, 25 April 1924; Oakland Daily Record, 2 May 1925; Joseph Baker, Past and Present of Alameda County, California, vol. 2 (Chicago, 1914), p. 19; Blutza, Oakland's and Council-Manager Commission p. 53. Plans, 26. Oakland Daily Record, 18December 1924; 4, 7 February 1925. 27. San Francisco Chronicle, 12August 1921; 11, 15May 1922. 28. San Francisco Chronicle, 4, 12March 1922. 29. Jackson, Ku Klux Klan in the City, p. 190; Oakland Post-Enquirer, 1922; Oakland Tribune, 9, 25 May 1922. 30. Hooded Chalmers, Americanism, 5 May 122. p. 31. Observer, 9 September; 21, 28 October; 4 November 1922. 32. Oscar Jahnsen, "Enforcing the Law against Gambling, Bootlegging, Graft, Fraud, and Subversion," an oral history conducted by Alice King andMiriam Stein, 1970, Regional Oral History Office, The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1976, pp. 36-37. 33. Knights of theKu Klux Klan, Inc., v. East Bay Club of Alameda County, et al, civil case file #82470, Cal. Superior Ct. Alameda County, 1925; Oakland City Clerk, Elections 1852 to thePresent, (Oakland, 1988), p. 32. 34. Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, v. Leon Inc,. et al.', C. Francis, case civil #81245, Cal. Super. Ct., Alameda County, 1925; Oakland Post-Enquirer, June 1924. San Francisco Chronicle, 5 July 1924. 35. Knights of the Ku Klux v. Inc., Klan, Leon C. Francis, et al, file 19, 23 case file #81118; Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, Inc., v. Leon C. Francis, et al, case file #82491, W. F. Courtney, et al, v. John L. McVey, et al, case file #82948, Civil Division, Cal. Super. Ct., Alameda County, 1925; EliJ. Coon, et al, v. Fidelity and Deposit Company ofMaryland, Inc., case file #101707, Civil Division, Cal. Super. Alameda Ct., County, Eli 1928; J. et al, Coon, v. H. Sephton, et al, case file #107549, Civil Division, Cal. Super. Ct., Alameda County, 1929; California v. Parker, et al, case file #11369, Criminal Division, Cal. Super. Ct., Alameda County, 1930; Folk's Oakland City Directory (Oakland, 1924, 1925, 1929, 1930); Oakland Daily Record, 17 January 1925. 36. East Oakland is defined here as the pre-1910 charter 7th ward, including the annexed territories east of Lake Merritt. North Oakland comprises the old 1stward bordering on the Berkeley line, including Rockridge. West Oakland includes the 3rd, 4th, and street to the 2nd, 36th 6th wards, estuary. from Blutza, the western Oakland's waterfront Commission to downtown and and from Council-Manager Plans, pp. 502-504; J. H. MacDonald and Company, Map of the City of Oakland (Oakland, 1900) Earth Sciences and Map Library, University of California, Berke ley. 37. See Lay, Hooded Knights on theNiagara; 38. Ku Klux Klan v. Francis, et al,, case file pp. 102-105. #81245; Coon, et al, v. Sephton. et al case file #81245; et al, Ku Klux Inc., v. Francis, Klan, were The purposes of the California Club. organization as "1) To promote of the Caucasian the welfare papers 39. Ku Klux v. East Bay incorporation teach the doctrine of white Klan, stated race Inc., in its and to supremacy, 2) To promote the doctrines and tenets of This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 54 Journal of American /Winter Ethnic History 1998 Protestant Christianity, 3) To promote and maintain the purity of white blood, and 4) To promote, develop, and safeguard the ideals of American citizens and the high standards in social and political relations, including the rightful use of ballots and of the enforcement law by regular constituted San Francisco authorities." Chronicle, 12August 1924. 40. Oakland Tribune, 24 August 1925. 41. Oakland Daily Record, 24 January, 19 May 1925; Oakland Tribune, 18 May 1925. 42. Ku Klux Klan, Inc., v. East Bay Club; Frank C. Merritt, History of Alameda County, (Chicago, 1928), pp. 102-103. 43. MacLafferty, Jr.,was chaplain of Klan No. 9 and of the East Bay Club until 18 May 1925. Brooks was appointed secretary of Klan No. 9 in 1925, while on served MacGregor the executive committee as chair and of the auditing commit tee. Both men acted as verification deputies for the petition drive. The petition itself accused Baccus of corruption, negligence, and having "used intoxicating liquors to excess." Oakland Daily Record, 17 December 1924, 17, 22 January, 25 February 1925; Ku Klux Klan, Inc., v. East Bay Club; et al Courtney, et al, v. Sephton, et al; City Clerk's Office, v. McVey, et al; Coon, 1925 Election Files, Oakland, Califor nia. 44. Ku Klux Klan, Inc., v. East Bay Club; City Clerk's Office, 1923 election files, Oakland, California; Oakland Daily Record, 18, 20 April 1925. 45. Oakland Tribune, 4 December 1924. 46. Merritt, History of Alameda County, pp. 517-518. Dimond News, 23 March 1923; 29 January 1926; Oakland Daily Record, 20 July 1925. 47. Merritt, History of Alameda County, pp. 218-221; Observer, 15, 29 July 1 September 1922; Oakland Tribune, 30 August 1922; Oakland Post-Enquirer, 1922. 48. A law fellow official enforcement recalled, "Frank Barnet was very liberal. He'd sit down and drink during Prohibition. He was what a lot of people would call a regular guy. He didn't think anything of prostitutes and open gambling operating. He believed you needed those!" [Interviewer: "That's life, huh?"] "Yes. You needed a common see. It was these places belief that if you close up, you'll this, you on your hands. Well, that's what many lot of rape cases thought." people a short, stocky-built a very generous sort of person. He was was man?always have a "Barnet wore a big diamond stud and a big diamond ring, and smoked a cigar, and very worldly sort of fella. He just couldn't see anything wrong in the bootlegging business. ..." Jahnsen oral history, pp. 34, 38. 49. Parker had also managed Becker's 1926 campaign. Earl Warren, The Mem oirs of Earl Warren, (New York, 1977), pp. 83-85; Mary Shaw, "Perspectives of a an oral history conducted in 1970 by Miriam Feingold, in Newspaperwoman," Perspectives on the Alameda County District Attorney's Office, Regional Oral His tory Office, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1972, pp. 12-15; 1926, 20 Observer, 6 March 1926; Oakland Tribune, 24 August, 4 November February 1927; Merritt, History of Alameda County, pp. 102, 517-518. 50. Oakland Tribune, 3 April 1927. 51. Oakland Times, 9May 1927; Observer, 24 May 1930. 11 February 1930; Oakland Tribune, 31 October 52. Oakland Post-Enquirer, 1927. 53. According to the trial summary, when Norman proposed the paving deal, "Parker said that he was glad Norman had it; that he was not in office for his health; that if Norman and Garbutt expected to lay vibrolithic pavement in the City of This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Rhomberg 55 Oakland they would have to pay; that he was getting one cent per sq. ft. from the Black Top people; that since Norman and Garbutt had supported him in his cam paign and done a lot of work for him around the City Hall he would make it one half cent per sq. ft. for them." California v. Garbutt, case file No. 11369, California v. Parker, case file No. 11399, Criminal Division, Cal. Super. Ct., Alameda County, 1930. 54. Warren, Memoirs, pp. 86ff; California v. Becker, case file no. 11359, Cali fornia v. Ormsby, case file no. 11359, California v. Shurtleff, case file 11360, Criminal Division, Cal. Super. Ct., Alameda County, 1930. 55. Blutza, Oakland's Commission and Council-Manager Plans, pp. Oakland's Commission and Council-Manager Plans, p. 227, 235, 247-257. 56. Blutza, ren, Memoirs, 57. Warren pp. 99-100. himself endorsed tion, declaring "the commission Commission 58. Blutza, the manager amendments form of government 262; in the November War elec is a failure," Blutza, Oakland's and Plans, pp. 288, 356-357. Council-Manager Oakland's Commission and Council-Manager Plans, pp. 265, 278, 355; San Francisco Chronicle, 20 March 1930. InMarch, the Lions Club passed a resolution thanking the Tribune for its "articles and forceful editorials" in favor of themanager reform. Oakland Tribune, 28 March; 16, 23 October 1930. 59. The Citizens' Freeholder Committee included representatives from the Ital ian American Federation, theWestern Waterfront Industries Association, and Cen tral Labor Council, whose secretary, William Spooner, chaired the committee. The League Council-Manager concentrate but instead Council-Manager 60. Blutza, Plans, Oakland's chose on the not to run candidates amendments. pp. 282-285. Commission and Blutza, the Freeholders' against Oakland's Commission Council-Manager Plans, pp. slate, and 290-308; St. Sure oral history, pp. 359-363; John Gothberg, (1968) "The Local Influence of J.R. Knowland's Oakland Tribune," Journalism Quarterly, 43, #3, (Autumn, 1968): 487-95. This content downloaded from 75.149.54.193 on Fri, 5 Jun 2015 01:04:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions