the bikes
Transcription
the bikes
W e love riding $1 OK wUnderbikes as much as anyone, and probably more than most. But all that bling can spoil us. Feeling the need to pull our heads out of the clouds (some might say out of our asses), we hunted down six $2,500 full-suspension trail bikes, loaded them into the van, and headed south from Pittsburgh to the Stokesville Lodge in Harrisonburg, Virginia, to ride the rowdy trails and reconnect with bikes that have price tags well below the cost of a new motorcycle. There are basic similarities with the six we chose: All have hydro-formed aluminum frames, tapered forks and air rear shocks. Not a single piece of carbon fiber anywhere-but lots of wrs rims and saddles. Almost every bike needed wider bars, and that is coming from a bunch of tight-woods riding Easterners. And not a single fork had stanchions over 32mm wide-the Camber only had 30mm stanchions. Nearly every bike had bars, stems and dropper posts swapped out for personal preference and comfort. We tried stock tires, but switched those when the wet, leafy trails demanded more aggressive knobs. We'd consider this pretty par for the course for most experienced riders setting up a new bike. As for the dropper posts, that is just simple math: How many mountain bikes would be improved by the installation of a dropper post? All of them. While there was some bellyaching before the trip, along the lines of ruining a fall riding retreat with less than top-of-the-line machinery, everyone stopped complaining from the first ride onward. For the price, these bikes are a much better deal than many two to four times the cost. 52 DIRT RAG #175_2.15.14 DIRTRAGMAG.COM 53 NORCO FLUID 9.1 DIAMONDBACK SORTIE 129 THE BIKES derailleur and brakes. The brakes are especially sweet, crushing sheet ~ The Web Editor and Resident Grump Adam Newman rode a pair of anything else at their price point. Worth noting , however, is that the longer- travel 29ers, a 120mm Norco Fluid 9. 1 and a 130mm Dia- XT parts are from the M780 lineup, not the current M786 series. Still, series hydraulic brakes work fine as long as you tug the levers a little harder than you would on some high-end units. mondback Sortie 1 29. it was good in 2012 and it remains good now. The Fluid 9.1 rings the register at $2,250, a number so impressive I actually contacted Norco threaded bottom bracket, a rear thru-axle and my size XL sports and 160mm rear rotors. The brakes offered ample power, with con- NORCO FlUID 9.1 $2,275 to make sure the price listed wasn't a typo. It is the least expensive a number of gussets to keep things stiff. Cables are run externally sistency not often found on higher-end Elixir brakes. I couldn't have along the bottom of the downtube, though there is an entry port been more impressed with how well these "budget" parts perfonmed. I think it's safe to say the runaway success of Norco's 27.5 models bike in our group and had some of the nicest components. DIAMONDBACK SORTIE 129 $2,400 I'm surprised to see a lack of ISCG mounts, as this chassis is AM kit, complete with RockShox Sektor Gold fork and Fox Float CTD rear shock. Drivetrain is mostly Deore, including a clutch rear derailleur. Shifting was crisp and reliable, with action feeling quite similar to Shimano's higher-end product. Avid Elixir 1 brakes sport 180mm front SRAM hubs laced to WTB i23 rims round out the package. Most impressively, the Heckler ships with Stan's NoTubes sealant and the models. New for 2014 is the Fluid 9.1, a 120mm do-it-all trail bike It's amazing the difference a few millimeters can make. Ten certainly capable of being built into a bruiser. Bolt on a 140mm fork, same awesome Maxxis High Roller II EXO 2.3-inch tires found on the that is a bit more modest than its predecessor, the Shinobi, in both millimeters up front, five millimeters out back, and two bikes with a chainguide and some beefier tires, and you'd have quite a monster on your hands ... $1 OK Bronson. This prima tire spec is largely responsible for much of this bike's trail confidence price and aggression . The Fluid 9.1 is built around a Horst Link rear suspension, with a pivot located below the rear axle, offering excellent small-bump compliance. The frame itself is hydroformed aluminum with a traditional remarkably similar numbers can have vastly distinct personalities. The Diamondback Sortie 29 seems to pair well with the brand's hard- MONGOOSE TEOCAU EXPERT $2.500 hitting image, as it begs to be ridden hard and fast. The Sortie 1 29 is the entry-level model in the lineup and, as Photographer!CFO/GM and Beard Farmer Justin Steiner was on the threaded bottom bracket and external cable routing along the un- such, makes do with a mix of Shimano components, from Alvino to 150mm travel bikes of the group, the evergreen Santa Cruz Heckler derside of the downtube. Lots of folks claim the cables and housing SU<. Built around Diamondback's venerable Knuckle Box suspen- with 0 AM build kit and the Mongoose Teocali Expert. are in danger there, but I've never seen or heard of a problem on the sian design, the Sortie has its mass centered and low, adding a lot SANTACRUZ HECKlER DAM $2.600 of stability in motion. You can sense that mass floating just above while riding, so eventually I added an extra zip-tie to keep it in place. the bottom bracket. OK, let's face it, at 34.9-lbs., you can sense the Standover on the size XL I rode was more than ample. mass everywhere. This isn't a light bike, but it feels incredibly solid. year and while it still sports 150mm of travel from a simple single It's also the only bike in our group with a nine-speed drivetrain, pivot, it now steps into the "enduro" age with 27.5-inch wheels. Shimano XT shifters and rear derailleur, and Deore cranks, front DIRTRAG#175_2.15.14 though to be honest I didn't even notice until I checked the spec In this collection of bikes, the Mongoose Teocali's matchy-matchy black, white and red aesthetic stands out with the most rad-dudebro, millennia! appeal. Fortunately, this flashy branding undersells the Teocali's ability to deliver an impressive ride quality. As the only trail. The rear derailleur housing would sag down below the downtube The parts kit is extremely impressive given the price point, with 54 The aluminum frame is hydroformed with a tapered head tube, above the bottom bracket for stealth dropper post routing. have left its 29ers in the dust. What was once a full range of bigwheeled double-bouncers has now been narrowed to a few select Alvino shifters have a light throw and the Shimano non- The fourth iteration of the Heckler is just old enough to vote this . Our Heckler came built up with Santa Cruz's lowest price point D consumer-direct bike in this group, sizing, shipping charges and assembly are the responsibility of the buyer. Mongoose does offer assembly videos via their website, but be realistic about your mechanical abilities when purchasing . Where the Heckler is at the bottom of the Santa Cruz heap, the DIRTRAGMAG.COM 55 JAM IS DAKAR XCT 650 COMP SPECIALIZED CAMBER 29 Teocali Expert is the most expensive Mongoose offering. A mixed SRAM XS and X7 drivetrain performed exceptionally well. Like the The bottom bracket actually swings rearward as the suspension travel Dakar XCT. This is the latest generation, utilizing the lessons are Shimano M445s with 180/160 rotors. Crankbrothers provided the compresses in order to keep chain growth reasonable. learned from the last five years of not always smooth sailing. cockpit, although the 100mm stem was swapped for an 80 pretty The Dakar uses Jamis' MP4 suspension, a low leverage single Heckler, the Avid Elixir 1 brakes instilled confidence and worked quickly. The stock WTB Volt saddle is a personal favorite, and WTB pivot design. The X-Fusion 02 RL rear shock is activated with a seat SX19 rims with Geax Goma 2.25-inch tires rounded out a respectable Tech Editor/Chief Naysayer Eric McKeegan rode bikes right smack in tube mounted linkage. This basic design has been refined by Jamis parts kit. to see wider rims on a 150mm bike as I did put a hurting on the the middle of this mess, a 130mm travel Jamis Dakar XCT 650 Comp for years, and while it may look somewhat old school, it works well, Teocali's rear wheel. Some of that was likely due to the 2.1-inch rear and a 11 Omm travel Specialized Camber 29. even without a fancy 3-position shock. This interaction on the frame flawlessly throughout the test period. Rolling stock consists of noname hubs laced to 26-inch WTB Team i19 rims, though I'd prefer tire. I liked the Kenda Excavators, but this bike deserves a matching 2.35-inch rear tire. The Teocali's Freedrive suspension system is similar in concept design is actually less swoopy than years past, and looked a bit JAMIS DAKAR XCT 650 COMP $2.400 Jamis was an early adopter of the 27.5-inch wheel size, with mod- dated parked next to some of the other bikes here. The fork is a 130mm X-Fusion Velvet RL with a 15mm thru-axle, SPECIALIZED CAMBER COMP 29 $2.600 Even after years of production, the Camber somehow never made it to Dirt Rag headquarters for review until now. The racier Epic, or longer-travel Stumpjumper and Enduro stole all the attention. But after an eye-opening blast riding a Camber on some French trails this to GT's i-Drive system. The high single pivot defines the upward and els appearing five years ago it's old hat to the brand. Seeing the ad- which once again proved itself as a basic, but very functional fork. rearward axle path while two additional links actuate the rear shock. vantage of the wheelsize for trail bikes, the first model was a five-inch The drivetrain is mostly Shimano Deore, with a 38/24 crank. Brakes summer, it became a top pick for 2014 test bikes. loft with three single beds and one bunk bed and bathroom. The kitchen is fully accessorized with modern appliances and all the pots, pans, plates, utensils and pint glasses you'll need. The bedrooms are supplied with linens and the bathrooms are stocked. The Shenandoah Mountain 100 has always used the Stokesville Campground behind th·e lodge as its Start/Finish and camping area, so has the Virginia Mountain Bike Festival put on by the Shenandoah Valley Bicycle Coalition. Though the lodge is open for rent year round, the campground was available only during these two events. Lodge owner Chris Scott has recently obtained ownership of the campground property through a cooperative pur- For reservations and more information go to ':sti>.ke$~Vill:etocfg4~;Cjifn,,:: Book early for the Virginia Mountain Bike Festi~Bl May Shenandoah 100 on Sunday, August ~ 't. Much like the Heckler, the Camber doesn't look at all out of place hanging out with bikes double and triple its price. The frame design bike that could haven taken advantage of a Fox 34 or RockShox Pike. The drivetrain parts work well and without drama. The less fit swap in new pads and rotors, you can pick up Shimano's Ice-Tech parts and have some serious power at your fingertips. to take. The thru-axle and tapered steerer on the fork keep things . and paint job are refined and almost classic looking. Even the skinny among us are happy to see some triple cranks, but all the bikes had legged RockShox XC 30 fork looked surprisingly proportional. A plenty of range for most riders. The Norco stands out here for its un- Monarch RL rear shock utilizes Specialized's AutoSag feature and an believable spec: Shimano XT is pretty swanky at this price, although easy-to-reach lockout lever. SRAM covers the drivetrain with a 36/22 the previous generation rear derailleur lacks a clutch, as do all the percent sag, the Fluid suspension is active and plush, needing to be line, though, as the capabilities of this bike can quickly overpower crank and XS shifting bits. Formula provides the brakes with large bikes, save for the Heckler. The Camber uses Specialized's Dangler, tempered with the Float CTD shock's Trail setting. Adjusted back to them, leaving .nearly as many skid marks in the chamois as they do 200/180mm rotors. The rest of the bike is almost all Specialized- a minimalist chain guide, which is quiet and worked perfectly. We 20-25 percent sag, it feels much more balanced and largely elimi- on the trail. branded components, including tubeless-ready rims and Ground weren't tossing chains left and right, but it did happen, more often on nates the need for switch flipping and knob twiddling. The Horst Link Control tires. the triple cranks. suspension design has a reputation around the Dirt Rag office as isfying cushion upon landing. It almost feels like a little bonus shock not being the most pedal-friendly, but with a higher air pressure, the at the end of its travel. Small-bump compliance is excellent as well, THE RIDES although we've always found the less expensive Elixir brakes to be Fluid 9.1 is a set-it-and-forget-it bike that climbs without significant so if you're a wheels-on-the-ground type, you're going to be pleased. more reliable than the high-end units. All the Shimano's preformed suspension movement sapping your energy. The long wheelbase and sion tuning was relatively painless with everything taking minimal flawlessly, and we continue to rate them at the top of the heap. The big wheels actually make it amazingly capable over short, steep and pivot of the Knuckle Box suspension tunes out most pedal-induced fiddling. It looks like Fox has ironed out some of the problems with the Formulas on the Camber, even with the 200mm front rotor, were techy power-climbs. movements and [sn't overly plush on small bumps. It feels more Evolution series forks, as the 2014 models we rode worked smoothly. underwhelming in regards to power, but not enough to swap with The RockShox and X-Fusion suspension bits were stellar performers something else. Nothing will ruin your ride like a lousy set of brakes for the price. The tapered steerers and 32mm stanctions (30mm on the Camber) were plenty stiff, with the Heckler and Sortie being the only All of the brakes stopped as expected, even the notorious Avids, The first order of business was getting the bikes dialed in. Suspen- NORCO FLUID 9.1 AND DIAMONDBACK SORTIE 129 These longer-travel 29ers had very distinct personalities. At 30-35 It's standard quick-release rear axle doesn't help the rear-end right in line up front, perhaps highlighting the flex out back. The stock Continental X-King tires don't invite riders to take the gnarlyist The Fluid 9.1 has a progressive ramp-up that gives a uniquely sat- On the other hand, the Sortie loves to get physical. The high main controlled overall and requires a bit more force to move it through its stiffness, and it also lacks the hollow, one-piece linkage found on travel. It took a fair bit of tuning to get the air pressure in the shock and Shimano's Deere units might hit a price point, but are as good some of Norco's higher-end bikes. On full-speed, rocky descents, just right: too much sag and the suspension blows through the travel as the top-level stoppers from many other brands. When it's time to the front and rear wheel can feel like they're arguing over which line rather than softening up the ride. Less sag keeps the bike riding high Brothers brewery (threebrosbrew.com) right in the middle of downtown offers tastings, but its beer can be found at most local restaurants. The Capital Ale House (capitalalehouse.com) has a huge microbrew list that should keep any beer snob happy, along with a full menu. We spent a pleasant (though chilly) evening on the roof top deck of Rick's Cantina (rickscantina.com) sipping tequila and eating $1 gringo tacos. The fine folks at Shenandoah Bicycle Company have everything you could need from parts and repairs to local trail knowledge and rental bikes (www.shenandoahbicycle.com). It's a great shop and a fine place to stop and ask for advice on where to ride, or where to eat. On the advocacy front, the Shenandoah Valley Bicycle Coalitton (SVBC), formed from the merger of the Shenaneoah Valley Bicycle the Shenandoah Mountain Bike Club in 2008, has been worK:ing hard building trails and gaining access. www.svbcoalition.org Bike culture is obviously strong in this town, with big events like Jeremiah Bishop's Alpine Loop Gran Fonda, the Shenanaoah 100, Shenandoah Mountain Bike Festival, and the Shenandoah Fall Eoliage Bike Festival. A healthy group of more underground events flourishes as well. Those looking for more down and dirty can check out tile SixPack Downhill series, or try slumming it at the brutal Tour de Burg, an annual six-day singletrack and dirt road stage race. I in the stroke. Best to hit things harder and not worry so much about pussy-footing over the small (and big) stuff. The Sortie's stouter frame and longer rear create a bike you don't so much turn, rather it's a bike you guide. If you favor straight-lining over an obstacle instead of zipping around it, you are going to feel aren't fnuch of a surprise. Firm things up in Trail mode and you 'll find a more controlled, settled chassis at the slight expense of small bump performance. Trail is a good all-around setting; still plusher right at home. Despite the positive feedback from the Fox Float 32 than some multi-link bikes-great climbing traction-but efficient fork, the long, 17.9-inch chainstays make it difficult to manual over enough for exuberant pedaling efforts with reasonable bob. Trail obstacles. Think long, fast, sweeping berms instead of quick, darting also provides more damping support during bigger hits. Climb mode motions. In fact, the Sortie thrived in just such conditions during our last day at the bike park. favors efficiency over traction; save it for use on smooth surfaces. Since it has similar geometry to the Bronson, the Heckler also has The steep head angle of the Sortie seems a little out of place here, a nearly perfect balance of stability and agility. This bike is just slack leading to a touch of the mullet handling (quick front end, slow rear), and low enough to encourage rapid descending, but never feels the and the skinny little 670mm bars looked almost comical. Wider bars and bigger tires helped to unleash the beast within. least bit unwieldy. It's neutral and highly intuitive on any terrain. SANTA CRUZ HECKLER DAM AND MONGOOSE TEOCALI EXPERT The Heckler's single pivot suspension is super plush in Descend The Teocali's suspension has a little bit of a split personality. While coasting, the rearward axle path feels plush and supple. Even with the Teocali's 26-inch wheels, the rear wheel never hangs up like it shock offers only rebound adjustment, no compression settings here. In reality, the system works so well, there is no need for climbing- yet confident style. The chainstay length is similar to the 29ers in oriented compression settings, and flipping damping levers wasn't this group, but with the bottom bracket higher in relation to the ax- missed at all. Despite the bottom bracket visually moving rearward while riding, it isn 't felt. is not terribly slack, and responds well in tight terrain. While it is a The Teocali package feels a bit livelier than the Heckler. Much of mode, gobbling up lumpy terrain like a champ. Given the plushness, up quite a bit due to chain growth, which adds a substantial measure of efficiency. Good thing, because the RockShox Monarch R rear capable descender, between the tires and head angle, things can this feeling is due to the 26-inch wheels, but it's also the result of a 1o start getting dicey at warp speeds and loose terrain. Swapping bet- steeper headtube angle, 0.3-inch shorter chainstays and a wheelbase ter tires and an 80mm stem (vs the stock 1OOmm) improved almost everything about the handling. nearly two inches shorter. The 0.3-inch lower bottom bracket helps to gain back a little stability by lowering your center of gravity. The result is a ride that's more responsive and playful. It's awesomely fun on The suspension seems a bit soft when bouncing around at low speeds, but once underway it comes into its own, working well on smoother, flowy trails with lots of opportunity to take advantage of the all sizes of trail debris. With the seat down and trying to maintain Teocali's snappiness on jumps. In the rough, rocky, burly backcoun- momentum on rolling terrain, it could feel bouncy, highlighting.the try-style riding of our testing location, the shorter wheelbase and lack of platform adjustment on the rear shock. The lockout setting small wheels got hung up more than the Heckler's longer wheelbase and bigger wheels. was surprisingly plush though, and much more usable than expect- might with a more vertical axle path. Under power, the system firms this bike's bob under power and occasional wallow when fully open les, this 27.5 is more playful and maneuverable. The 69° head angle ed, even on rough ascents. Climbing was the only real complaint on this bike. Between the poor loose surface traction of the tires and JAM IS DAKAR XCT 650 COMP AND SPECIALIZED CAMBER COMP 29 The Dakar strikes a balance in all things, riding in an understated the shorter cockpit, it was hard to balance rear wheel traction while keeping the front wheel on the ground . The Camber was the first AutoSag bike we've used where we changed. The SVBC will have day passes available by the time the trails reopen this spring. They will be sold at local bike shops though pricing has not yet been announced. This is great news because the Massanutten trails are worth the investment in cash and sweat. The climbing is mellow, with a conversational pace easy to maintain. The descents are an incredible hybrid of rocks and flow, rewarded with good lines and full commitment. The centerpiece of the system is the 2,000 Hour Trail, named for the amount of labor used to make it. Approximately a mile long, this is easily one of the top ten trails in the country. All that labor went into an impressive amount of stonewo(R, everywhere, both supporting the hillside traih of its surface. Drops, berms, kickers, good dens-it's all there. We•ve never ridden also manages to flow so nicely. We finished off the week at Bryce of Harrisonburg. A small farnily 7frienrfl\, system packed tightly on its small with a few wood stunts and steep. to end the trip. If you 're stellar way to introduce a nnn-riti<>r't" didn't have to fiddle with air pressure after setting pressure with the tiny relief valve. with other bikes. This was the only tester ridden with all of the stock cockpit parts On paper, it seems to have more in common with cross-country race bikes, but while riding it feels much more trail bike. Other than ,, in place, although a dropper post was missed and the seatpost QR was utilized regularly. The Ground Control tires are great all- occasional harsh (and loud) bottoming, the suspension was perfect, purpose treads, and added to the surprisingly hard-charging feel of seemingly growing to more than 11 Omm in rough terrain, and less the Camber. When things started to get a little lopsided, it was still when pedaling. The Camber dispatched climbs with little drama, controllable. Simply put, it's an easy bike to ride fast, up and down allowing the rider to continue upward when we had to start walking the mountain. D[;] TESTER: Eric McKeegan AGE: 39 HEIGHT: 5'11" WEIGHT: 155!bs. INSEAM: 32" l iteville isn't a brand you'll see much of on this side of the pond. A sister company to German component maker Syntace, Liteville makes just three understated models, which, when examined closely, display some of the finest design and engineering in the industry. Rather than complaining about what wasn't on the market, Liteville SANTA CRUZ HECKLER DAM was formed to create bikes its founders wanted to ride, but weren't Overall, the Heckler has reset our ex- available. The 601 is an obvious example, with a whopping 190mm of pectations for how well a $2,600 trail bike . rear travel, adjustable geometry, and a full range of gearing capable of going up as well as down. can be. Watching Steiner launch repeatedly into a wet, off-camber rock garden The 601 attracts very little attention on the trail because its flat that the rest of us either barely cleaned or black, ball-peened finish hides enough features to fill the rest of this walked was proof-positive this bike is the page. Some highlights: super smart cable routing, model specific real deal. Regardless of price point, the Syntace chain guide and a rear derailleur rock guard. Liteville de- Heckler is an amazing bike. Considering to improve. signed specific aluminum tubing for each size and model, and the the performance and retail cost, the Heck- amount of shaping is nothing short of impressive. The 601 looks like ler might just be the pick of this litter. the bicycle equivalent of an assault rifle; all business, and in the right hands, very dangerous. MONGOOSE TEOCALI EXPERT The Teocali is a damn fine bike, perhaps best suited for someone with a Its adjustable geometry (with a Fox 36 180mm fork) is solidly between trail and downhill slack, with a head angle of 64.3- 65.5°, quickly adjustable with a single bolt. Chain stays vary with frame size, from a tiny 16.3" on the 24" rear-wheeled XS, to 17.5" on XL (my size bit of a DIY attitude and a playful riding L tester measured 17.3".) BB height ranges from 14-14.5"-a pretty style. The more time you spend in the air, neutral place to be considering where it will end up when the suspen- the more this bike suits you. And for the sion is properly sagged. Those looking for more slack can go another 26-inch holdouts, this might be pne of the 1.5-degrees in either direction with an aftermarket Syntace VarioSpin angled headset. few choices left for 150mm bikes in 2014. One other key feature to the 601 is massive standover height, allowing riders to fit on more than one size, making it easier to get great performance even with proportions outside the norm. 62 '\ / 11\ So how's all this understated technology actually ride? The Horst- ~ link style suspension pedals amazingly well for something with this much travel and a downhill-specific shock. Long climbs had me twisting up the compression damping, and seriously technical climbs are probably going to result in some walking, as the slack head angle and long travel suspension combine to make things less than ideal for scrambling up the steep stuff. But for self-shuttling with fireroad access and more mellow grades, this gets an A+. Going down is much the same, with the ride being most rewarding when speeds are high and moves are big. The suspension is impressively bottomless, with a smooth progression from a supple beginning stroke, a non-wallowing middle, to a not-harsh end stroke. After switching to the slackest setting, the 601 proved itself more than enough bike for my bike park ability. Plenty of wheelbase (47.3'') to keep things in check and very forgiving suspension. A dual crown fork is an option, and something I would look into for more regular park use, the 36 is an awesome fork, but no replacement for a true DH fork in the park. The upcoming 601 Mk3 will have additional gussets and built in bumpers for better dual-crown fork compatibility, along with a redesigned downtube shock mount for a flatter leverage rate. As a trail bike I was a little less happy, as all that travel felt like overkill most places. Most of our local gnar is in short bursts, rather than the sustained beat-down areas with more elevation are able to dish out. This is a pretty oddball bike, but for the right rider in the right area, the 601 is going to be a revelation. It goes down like a DH bike, but has the gearing and pedaling performance to earn your turns. For less steep areas and sub-warp speeds, modern trail bikes can tackle 90% of most riders needs. For those always looking to go bigger and faster, the 601 is adaptable, capable, and unique. That is well-worth the asking price for the right rider. DIRTRAG#175_2.15.14 DIRTRAGMAG.COM 63