docComments and Responses
download 
Report Transcription
Comments and Responses
POLICY ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN THE PERMIT REVIEW PROCESS (DEP ID: 012-0900-003) COMMENT-RESPONSE DOCUMENT FEBRUARY 28, 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents ......................................................................................................................................... i List of Commentators ..................................................................................................................................1 Comments and Responses..........................................................................................................................78 Section I: Background....................................................................................................................... 78 Section II: How This Policy Relates to Other Public Participation Options .................................... 78 Section III: General Policy................................................................................................................ 79 Section IV: Public Participation Options .......................................................................................... 84 IV.A: Written/Electronic Comments in Response to a Pennsylvania Bulletin Notice ..................87 IV.B: Public Hearings ....................................................................................................................88 Timing and Location of a Public Hearing................................................................................. 89 Notice of Scheduling or Cancellation of a Public Hearing ....................................................... 90 Public Hearing Guidelines/Attachment B ................................................................................. 91 Transcripts from Public Hearings ............................................................................................. 93 Web-based Public Hearings ...................................................................................................... 94 IV.C: Public Information Meetings ...............................................................................................94 IV.D: Informal Meetings ...............................................................................................................95 Section VI: Extension of Public Comment Period ........................................................................... 98 Section VII: Comment-Response Document .................................................................................... 98 VII.A: Format of Comment-Response Document/Attachment A .................................................99 VII.B: Public Availability of the Comment-Response Document...............................................100 VII.C: Relation of Comment-Response Document to Other Department Policies .....................101 Land Use ................................................................................................................................. 101 Section VIII: Additional Information ............................................................................................. 101 General/Miscellaneous Comments ................................................................................................. 102 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page i LIST OF COMMENTATORS Number 1 Commentator Lisa Schaefer County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania 17 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17101-1624 Number 9 Commentator Elizabeth Tatham League of Women Voters of PA 79 Old Mill Lane Holland, PA 18966 2 Ginny Kreitler National Audobon Society, Natural Lands Trust, French and Pickering Creeks Conservation Trust, and Green Valleys Association 646 Lakeview Circle Newtown Square, PA 19073 10 Ruth Likowski 900 Shoemaker Ave. West Wyoming, PA 186441122 11 Tracie Blummer 12 Ruth Ayn Hocker Chesapeake Bay Foundation Old Waterworks Building 614 North Front Street, Ste. G Harrisburg, PA 17101 Tracy Carluccio Delaware Riverkeeper Network 925 Canal St., Suite 3701 Bristol, PA 19007 13 Deron Gabriel South Fayette Twp. Bd. of Commissioners Kate J. Darby, Ph.D. 606 Walnut St. Meadville, PA 16335 14 Lynda and Steve Farrell 331 Norwood Rd. Downingtown, PA 193353215 15 Gary A. Miller 187 Tipton Road Tyrone, PA 16686 16 Elizabeth Arnold 4821 Baltimore Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-2015 17 Alison Rupert 568 S Frymire Rd. Hughesville, PA 17737-8483 18 Matt Walker for Joseph Minott Clean Air Council 135 South 19th Street, Suite 300 Philadelphia, PA 19103 3 4 5 6 7 8 Shellie Northrop 124 Frances St. Sayser, PA 18840 John Waffenschmidt Covanta Energy Group 445 South St. Morristown, NJ 07960 Terry L. Dayton Citizens Advisory Council to the DEP P.O. Box 8459 Harrisburg, PA 17105 Lisa Widawsky Hallowell Environmental Integrity Project and six other signatories 1 Thomas Circle, Suite 900 Washington, DC 20005 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 1 Number 19 Commentator Kristin Landon 11 Baker Hirkey Rd. Tunkhannock, PA 18657 Number 28 Commentator Ralph Kisberg 1736 Almond St. Williamsport, PA 17701 20 Lauren Burge Group Against Smog and Pollution 5135 Penn Avenue Pittsburgh, PA 15224 29 James E. Rosenberg 555 Davidson Rd. Grindstone, PA 15442 30 Beverly Braverman Mountain Watershed Association P.O. Box 408 Melcroft, PA 15462 31 Steve Hvozdovich Clean Water Action and 29 other signatories 32 Kathryn Z. Klaber Marcellus Shale Coalition 24 Summit Park Drive, 2nd Fl. Pittsburgh, PA 15275 33 Aaron Birk 4845 Cedar Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-2034 34 Adrienne Eisenberg 522 Masthope Plank Rd. Lackawaxen, PA 18435-9714 35 Adrienne Panuski 214 Stites St. West Wyoming, PA 186441321 36 Aislinn Pentecost-Farren 1208 S. 46th St. Philadelphia, PA 19143-3826 37 Alexander Milone 6213 Hilltop Dr. Brookhaven, PA 19015-1319 38 Amanda Buchko 965 Route 434 Greeley, PA 18425-9641 21 22 23 24 Anthony Palombaro E.L. Rose Conservancy 20159 State Route 167 Brackney, PA 18812-8209 Mike Kamandulis 101 Brown Rd. Kersey, PA 15846-9704 Emily E. Krafjack Connection for Oil, Gas & Environment in the Northern Tier, Inc. 1155 Nimble Hill Road Mehoopany, PA 18629 David Presley for Joeseph Minott Clean Air Council and 30 other Signatories 135 South 19th Street, Suite 300 Philadelphia, PA 19103 25 C. J. Herring 26 Environmental Justice Advisory Board c/o Dr. Arthur Frank Drexel University School of Public Health 245 N. 15th St., Mail Stop 1034 Philadelphia PA 19102-1192 27 Barbra L. Smith 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 2 Number 39 Commentator Angel Kelsey 25 Custer St. Wilkes Barre, PA 18702-6509 Number 50 Commentator Beverly Moranski 20 Bunker Hill Rd. Wyoming, PA 18644-9387 40 Angel Smith 1316 Rock Hill Church Rd. Clearville, PA 15535-5128 51 Bill Ferullo 4834 Leraysville Rd. Warren Center, PA 188517824 41 Angela Fanelli 219 Lincoln Ave. West Wyoming, PA 186441311 52 Bob Bernhardy 53 Meade St. Wellsboro, PA 16901-1838 53 Bonne South 432 N. 29th St. Allentown, PA 18104-4843 54 Bonnie Steelman 101 Carpenter Ln. Philadelphia, PA 19119-2572 55 Bryan Katulka 208 Lincoln Ave. West Wyoming, PA 186441312 56 Carolee Schneemann 437 Springtown Rd. New Paltz, NY 12561-3027 57 Carolyn Speranza 2021 Plainview Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15226-1334 58 Charles Ingraham 554 S. Lake Rd. Brackney, PA 18812-7941 42 Anita Panuski 214 Stites St. West Wyoming, PA 186441321 43 Ann Rosenthal 431 Dargan St. Pittsburgh, PA 15224-1801 44 Anna Bario 438 Olive St. Philadelphia, PA 19123-2815 45 Audrey Gozdiskowski 621 SR 29 N. Tunkhannock, PA 186577112 46 Audrey Simpson 72 Green Rd. Shavertown, PA 18708-9669 47 Barbara Clifford 374 Prospect St. Montrose, PA 18801-1486 59 48 Barbara Jarmoska 766 Butternut Grove Rd. Montoursville, PA 177549078 Charles Morgan 609 E. Fm 489 Buffalo, TX 75831-6814 60 Ben Burrows 406 Shoemaker Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2420 Cheryl Dzubak 69 Elton Ave. Trenton, NJ 86201-1531 61 Chris Coccodrilli 170 Belmont St. Waymart, PA 18472-9212 49 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 3 Number 62 Commentator Chris Nogic 76 Sando St. Hunlock Creek, PA 186214248 63 Christine Cato 7217 Witherspoon St. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-1045 64 Christopher Miles 3330 Tilden St. Philadelphia, PA 19129-1412 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 Number 74 Commentator David Kagan 885 Torbert Ln. Jersey Shore, PA 17740-8732 75 David Stone 539 E. Foster Ave. State College, PA 168015723 76 David Wasilewski 239 Golf Course Rd. Hunlock Creek, PA 186213128 Chuck and Janis Winschuh 2128 State Route 3021 Springville, PA 18844-7525 77 D. E. Bassett 5 Ida St. Imperial, PA 15126-1016 Cindy Michelini 4116 Highland Ave. Butler, PA 16001-2942 78 Dean Marshall 52 Railroad Rd. Benton, PA 17814-7611 Claudia Crane 2335 Perot St. Philadelphia, PA 19130-2525 79 Deborah Lambert 114 Logtown Rd. Darlington, PA 16115-1202 Colin Burch 1141 Chislett St. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-1303 80 Deirdre Lally 161 Beach Glen Rd. Benton, PA 17814-7950 Coryn Wolk 2 Schiller Ave. Penn Valley, PA 19072-1534 81 Dennis Schlott 5356 Brownsville Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-2922 Cynthia Keiser 623 Henrys Crossing Rd. Cresco, PA 18326-7957 82 Devona Renee 2 Adams St. Denver, CO 80206-5724 Dave Bankovic 123 Meredith Rd. Kersey, PA 15846-8909 83 Diane Dilendik 527 6th Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-5203 David Butler 639 Hermitage St. Philadelphia, PA 19128-2605 84 Diane Karasevicz 2750 Carley Rd. Alpine, NY 14805-9717 David Hunt 125 Dilworth St. Pittsburgh, PA 15211-1829 85 Dianne Arnold 1461 E. Cruikshank Rd. Valencia, PA 16059-3709 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 4 Number 86 Commentator Dorene Pasekoff 75 Creamery Rd. Pottstown, PA 19465-8128 Number 98 Commentator Evangeline Hoffman-Lorah 1635 4th St. Bethlehem, PA 18020-6514 87 Dorothy Hudson 44 Nelson Ave. Cooperstown, NY 133261053 99 Eve Goodman 602 Whitney Ave # 2 Wilkinsburg, PA 15221-3345 100 Frank Kohn 6655 Mccallum St. Philadelphia, PA 19119-3154 101 G. Brian Uhler 2259 Turkey Ridge Rd. New Kensington, PA 150681934 102 Gail Brown 1670 Lisa Ln. Clarks Summit, PA 184119528 88 Dr. Alicia Pagano 12562 County Highway 23 Unadilla, NY 13849-2331 89 Dr. Thomas Jiunta 252 Hayfield Rd. Shavertown, PA 18708-8025 90 Earl Fraim 59 Eby Rd. Forksville, PA 18616-8825 91 Eleanor Skibo 22 Cedar Rd. Uniontown, PA 15401-2206 103 Garrett Socling 1854 Dutch Hollow Rd. Jersey Shore, PA 17740-6902 Elizabeth Engleman 72 Linden Pl. Sewickley, PA 15143-1339 104 Gib Davis 314 E. Pitt St. Bedford, PA 15522-1439 Elizabeth Monoian 4729 Hatfield St. Pittsburgh, PA 15201-2911 105 Greg Flood 108 Royal View Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15239-2937 Ellen A. Smith 192 Heart Lake Rd. Montrose, PA 18801-8442 106 Gregory Pais 2304 Steam Valley Rd. Trout Run, PA 17771-9115 Ellen Ziegler 3 Dore Ct. New City, NY 10956-6801 107 Gregory Steele 1108 Crease St. Philadelphia, PA 19125-4108 Epifanio Bevilacqua 964 Finch Rd. Franklin, NY 13775-3214 108 Gusti Bogok 130 W. 16th St. New York, NY 10011-6281 Erwin Brown 1060 W. Main St. Troy, PA 16947-1171 109 Henry Frank 2763 Island Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19153-2225 92 93 94 95 96 97 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 5 Number 110 Commentator Howard Hannum 1221 Higley Rd. Sidney Center, NY 138393161 Number 121 Commentator Jeff Salvaryn 1528 Herrin St. Redondo Beach, CA 902782849 111 Hyla Willis 511 E. End Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15221-3231 122 Jeffrey Shralow 893 N. Bucknell St. Philadelphia, PA 19130-1934 112 Irene Barrie 5215 Maple Grove Rd. Bulger, PA 15019-9722 123 Jennifer Kobylski 303 Gist St. Pittsburgh, PA 15219-5905 113 Iris Marie Bloom 4808 Windsor Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-3416 124 Jeri Carroll 25 S Elm St. Kutztown, PA 19530-1301 114 James Little 522 Winston Dr. Endwell, NY 13760-2435 125 Jerry Yeager 146 Honor Roll Rd. Lake Lynn, PA 15451-1216 115 Janet Golden 19 W. Levering Mill Rd. Bala Cynwyd, PA 190042508 126 Jill Wiener P.O. BexX 198 Callicoon Center, NY 127240198 116 Janice Metzo 56 Fire Cut Rd. Wyoming, PA 18644-9384 127 Jim Black 5978 Newtown Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19120-1131 117 Janis Winschuh 2128 State Route 3021 Springville, PA 18844-7525 128 Jim Keller 308 Sunset Rd. West Reading, PA 196111306 118 Jason Bell 223 Pattison St. Evans City, PA 16033-1320 129 Jeanette Elbattah 29 Circle Dr. Wyoming, PA 18644-9313 John Bijarney 101 South St. Chenango Forks, NY 137461105 130 Jeanette Stump 5508 Montmorenci Rd. Ridgway, PA 15853-7234 John Dulik 209 Rex Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19118-3718 131 John Osgood 265 46th St., Apt. 2102 Pittsburgh, PA 15201-2858 119 120 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 6 Number 132 Commentator Jonathan Cain 671 Margaret St. Pittsburgh, PA 15210-2427 Number 144 Commentator Kathy Martin 3122 Tall Oaks Cir. Norman, OK 73072-4717 133 Joseph & Constance Kikta 202 Cutler Rd. Smock, PA 15480-1210 145 Kevin Snyder 309 W. Main St. Kutztown, PA 19530-1605 134 Joseph Bridy 709 Morris St. Philadelphia, PA 19148-1226 146 Kevin Starbard 318 Valley Rd. Oreland, PA 19075-1122 135 Joseph Mercurio 538 Esther Ave. New Kensington, PA 150684734 147 Kim Felter 245 Buttermilk Falls Rd. New Berlin, NY 13411-2703 148 136 Josh Miller 1920 L St., N.W. Washington,, DC 200365004 Kristian Boose 1802 N. 54th St. Seattle, WA 98103-6122 149 Lana Gulden 255 Honey Locust Ln. Northumberland, PA 178579679 150 Larry Franklin 935 Longvue Dr. Ellwood City, PA 161173433 151 Lawrence Dellegrotto 41 Fairway Dr. West Pittston, PA 186431250 137 Joyce Stone 655 Woodbourne Rd. Montrose, PA 18801-6870 138 Judith Ross 317 Rauch St. Bethlehem, PA 18018-5615 139 Julie Edgar 534 North Cir. Bethlehem, PA 18018-4323 140 Justin Steiner 5433 Carnegie St. Pittsburgh, PA 15201-2553 152 Lea Stabinski 1885 Meredith Ln. Blue Bell, PA 19422-3657 Karen Davis 10 Crescent Park Warren, PA 16365-2217 153 Linda Davenport 412 Center Hill Rd. Upper Black Eddy, PA 18972-9615 154 Linda Norden 390 Riverside Dr., Apt. 11F New York, NY 10025-1831 141 142 143 Kathleen Campbell 800 Avondale Rd. Wallingford, PA 19086-6665 Kathy Douglass 225 Cherry Valley Rd. Saxonburg, PA 16056-9127 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 7 Number 155 Commentator Lois Klotz 2332 Warren Center Rd. Warren Center, PA 188517889 156 Lorraine Whalen 106 Spruce Dr. Slippery Rock, PA 160571410 157 158 159 Number 166 Commentator Marta Guttenberg 226 W. Rittenhouse Sq. Philadelphia, PA 19103-5768 167 Martha Black, DE Frias 1320 W. Somerville Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19141-2968 168 Lucas Savage 303 Gist St. Pittsburgh, PA 15219-5905 Martha Keller 39 Walker St., Apt. 2R New York, NY 10013-6002 169 Lyle Millard 5584 Gillingham Rd. Frenchville, PA 16836-7618 Martha Wilson 432 Dean St. Brooklyn, NY 11217-2011 170 Madeline Rawley 361 Birdsong Way Doylestown, PA 18901-4893 Marvin Feil 69-75 Sparta Ave. Newton, NJ 78602-2425 171 Mary & Joe McKeon 270 Searles Rd. Margaretville, NY 124553023 172 Mary Himmer 1035 Hereford Dr. Blue Bell, PA 19422-1925 173 Michael Brock 258 Taft Rd. Saint Marys, PA 15857-3442 174 Michael Pagano 451 Youngwood Dr. East Stroudsburg, PA 183011008 175 Ms. Mary Pirt 344 Warrick Dr. Mars, PA 16046-8018 176 Nancy and Sam McCaughey 9 Norris St. Wellsboro, PA 16901-1402 177 Nancy Brockmon 112 Webster Ave. Wyncote, PA 19095-1527 160 Margaret Wood 324 Germantown Rd. West Milford, NJ 74802-2404 161 Maria Payan 9 Aubel Rd. Delta, PA 17314-8833 162 Marigrace Butela 1601 W. Crawford Ave. Connellsville, PA 154252313 163 Marion Yaglinski 1248 Hunt Club Ln. Media, PA 19063-2003 164 Mark Pezzati 56 Mayer Rd. Andes, NY 13731-2648 165 Mark Schmerling P.O. Box 335 Saluda, NC 28773-0335 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 8 Number 178 Commentator Nancy Dolan 41 Fairway Dr. West Pittston, PA 188431250 179 Nancy Novak 223 E. Fourth St. Media, PA 19063-3008 180 Natalie Hodapp 19585 599th Ave. Mankato, MN 56001-8447 181 Noreen McCarthy 1 Millstone Ln. Pottstown, PA 19465-8878 182 Patricia Bloomer 99 E. Silver Lake Rd. Brackney, PA 18812-8172 183 Patricia Cook 38911 Watson Ave. North Ridgeville, OH 440392719 184 Patricia Libbey 379 Ripka St., Apt. 3B Philadelphia, PA 19128-4608 185 Patti Gorcheff 2444 W. South Range Rd. North Lima, OH 44452-9537 186 Paul Karpich 729 Fitch Hill Rd. Springville, PA 18844-7761 187 Number 190 Commentator Pramilla Srivastava 3731 Lawrence Ave. Moosic, PA 18507-1622 191 Preeti Gupta 109 Oakview Dr. Media, PA 19063-2112 192 R. Dunleavey 101 Kelly Rd. Arkville, NY 12406-1548 193 Randall Baird 1200 Highland Street Ext. Dubois, PA 15801-4542 194 Rebecca Casstevens 22 Winding Way Binghamton, NY 13905-2419 195 Rebecca DeWitt P.O. Box 83 Brooktondale, NY 148170083 196 Rebecca Roter 575 Turnpike Rd. Kingsley, PA 18826-7142 197 Rhonda Keller 49 Dunkleberger Rd. Millerton, PA 16936-9535 198 Robert Deering 628 Old Post Office Rd. Jersey Mills, PA 17739-9212 199 Roberta Camp 713 S. Warnock St. Philadelphia, PA 19147-1927 200 Ron Cehelsky 221 Carbon Center Rd. Butler, PA 16002-1021 201 Ronald Gulla 302 Linden Creek Rd. Canonsburg, PA 15317-4834 Paul Roden 307 Daleview Dr. Yardley, PA 19067-3406 188 Peter DeNardis 1943 Brodhead Rd. Aliquippa, PA 15001-4961 189 Phyllis Carr 520 Hope Hollow Rd. Lake Lynn, PA 15451-1092 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 9 Number 202 Commentator Roscoe McCloskey 592 Old Cement Rd. Montoursville, PA 177548279 Number 213 Commentator Sherry Vargson 2331 Bailey Corners Rd. Granville Summit, PA 169269204 203 Russell Zerbo 2014 Bainbridge St. Philadelphia, PA 19146-1309 214 Shirley Hartman 430 Hanover Ave. Allentown, PA 18109-2150 204 Ruth Hardinger 20 N. Moore St. New York, NY 10013-2435 215 Stephanie Burch 1141 Chislett St. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-1303 205 Samantha Gurry 2014 Bainbridge St. Philadelphia, PA 19146-1309 216 Susan Ader 94 Adamstown Rd. Reinholds, PA 17569-9652 206 Scott Cannon 61 Girard Ave. Plymouth, PA 18651-2205 217 Susan Mayr 723 Humboldt St. Brooklyn, NY 11222-3521 207 Seth Feinberg 2575 River Rd. Damascus, PA 18415-3503 218 Tasha Doremus 2224 Coral St. Philadelphia, PA 19125-1533 208 Seth Gernot 157 Lloyd Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15218-1645 219 Theresa Epp 4736 Osage Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-1815 209 Shannon Pendleton P.O. Box 306 Bryn Athyn, PA 19009-0306 220 Thomas Nelson 105 Drexel Ave. Lansdowne, PA 19050-1304 210 Sharon Furlong 133 E. Bristol Rd. Feasterville Trevose, PA 19053-3341 221 Todd Underwood 424 Fairview Dr. Kutztown, PA 19530-1022 222 Sharon Kind 1330 Old Ford Rd. Huntingdon Valley, PA 19006-8106 Tom Ferguson 543 N. Macdonald Mesa, AZ 85201-5017 223 Sheilah Rechtschaffefr 5 Rocky Ln. Garrison, NY 10524-3810 Vera Scroggins 55 Gus Park Ln. Brackney, PA 18812-7832 224 Veronica Thomas 59 Reynolds Rd. Kingsley, PA 18826-6909 211 212 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 10 Number 225 Commentator Victoria Switzer P.O. Box 113 Dimock, PA 18816-0113 226 227 228 Number 236 Commentator Daniel Beck 1821 Barton Hollow Rd. East Waterford, PA 170217295 Vivian Schatz 6907 Sherman St. Philadelphia, PA 19119-3421 237 Gail Neustadt 1503 Grand Cypress Ln. Presto, PA 15142-1608 Walter Tsou 325 E. Durham St. Philadelphia, PA 19119-1219 238 Jason Walters 5344 Seip Rd. Bethlehem, PA 18017-8205 239 Jeffrey Shuben 46204 Delaire Landing Rd. Philadelphia, PA 19114-5320 Wanda Cawein 4516 County Highway 6 Margaretville, NY 124554216 229 Will Fraser 15 W. Girard Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19123-1707 240 Kelly Riley 1343 Needham Cir. Hatfield, PA 19440-4132 230 William Haaf 1923 Marlboro Rd. Kennett Square, PA 193481906 241 Laura Neiman 37 Meadowland Dr. Damascus, PA 18415-3026 242 231 William Hufford 106 Virginia St. Latrobe, PA 15650-3826 Pounes Saberi 1504 Montrose St. Philadelphia, PA 19146-2115 243 232 William Huston P.O. Box 2873 Binghamton, NY 13902-2873 Sandra Folzer 209 Rex Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19118-3718 244 233 William Leavy 317 S. Main St. Winston Salem, NC 271015216 Theresa Knapp 2615 Hornbrook Rd. Towanda, PA 18848-9567 245 Brynn Schmitt 1178 Wood Rd. Mansfield, PA 16933-8883 Alice Zinnes 1255 Milanville Rd. Milanville, PA 18443-3047 246 Catherine Smith 383 Olde House Ln. Media, PA 19063-5319 Mary Jane Hyde 235 Stein Ln. Lewisburg, PA 17837-1744 247 Mary Leitch 526 Reed St. Philadelphia, PA 19147-5823 234 235 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 11 Number 248 Commentator Susan Shaak 3440 Stoner Ave. Reading, PA 19606-2335 Number 260 Commentator Jack & Jan Milburn 114 Mountain Rd. Ligonier, PA 15658-9213 249 Bernard Handler 30 Delaware Ave. Damascus, PA 18415-3506 261 Jean Mcfarlane 102 Grayling Ave. Narberth, PA 19072-1900 250 Annie Prince 6015 Domarray St. Coopersburg, PA 18036-8937 262 John Trallo 47 Main St. Sonestown, PA 17758-5360 251 Barbara Grover 5526 Wilkins Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1210 263 Jon Levin 1899 Aster Rd. Macungie, PA 18062-8944 252 Carolyn Auwaerter 5 Primrose Ln. Malvern, PA 19355-9693 264 Jonathan Nadle 858 Gladys Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15216-3903 253 Christine Hendryx P.O. Box 364 Tionesta, PA 16353-0364 265 Judy Scriptunas 3434 Camp Robin Hood Rd. Chambersburg, PA 172029215 254 David Barlup 1027 Drexel Hills Blvd. New Cumberland, PA 170701737 266 Michael Boyd 105 George St. Turtle Creek, PA 15145-1014 255 Delite Hawk 1963 Meadow Ln. Wyomissing, PA 19610-2710 267 Otto Lehrbach 282 Treichler Rd. Alburtis, PA 18011-2035 256 Eric Durante 241 Goss Hollow Ln. Port Matilda, PA 16870-8663 268 Ramona Sahni 46 Mallard Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15238-1129 257 Grant Silverstein 171 Benson Ave. Mansfield, PA 16933-9218 269 Reid Joyce 114 Keithwood Dr. Valencia, PA 16059-2544 258 Henry Berkowitz 141 Sperry and Young Rd. Sabinsville, PA 16943-9797 270 Sherry McNeil 170 Royal Oak Dr. Butler, PA 16002-0452 259 J. Stephen Cleghorn 2771 Paradise Rd. Reynoldsville, PA 158518621 271 Al Benner 303 Upper Woods Rd. Honesdale, PA 18431 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 12 Number 272 Commentator Alice Mcgough 16 Nohonord Mashpee, MA 02649 Number 284 Commentator Barbara Adkins 7104 Tulip St. Philadelphia, PA 19135-1428 273 Alicia Guidarelli 77 Wild Birch Farms Cortlandt Manor, NY 10567 285 Beth Beck 8925 Timber Wolf Trail Madison, WI 53717 274 Allon Massil 30 Manetto Hill Rd. Plainview, NY 11803 286 Bob Hamburg 532 Georgian Rd. Glenside, PA 19038 275 Alyssa Fanning 4 Highland Ave. Dumont, NJ 07628 287 Brenda Norris 313 E Dutton Mill Rd. Brookhaven, PA 19015-1108 276 Andrea Zinn 629 East 24th St. Brooklyn, NY 11210 288 Briget Shields 2329 Tilbury Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15217 277 Andrew McGrath 358 Lombardy Rd. Drexel Hill, PA 19026 289 Byron Fiegel 185 Long Lane P.O. Box 181 Oley, PA 19547-0181 278 Angela Gradek 623 Old Glory Ln. Freedom, PA 15042 290 Cakky Evans 1132 Lindsay Ln. Rydal, PA 19046 Anna Louise E. Fontaine 102 Chemin Du Lac Cloutier Lantier QC 291 Carroll Bever 154 Plainsboro Rd. Cranbury, NJ 08512 Anne Veraldi 21 Lapidge San Francisco, CA 94110 292 Catherine Hunt 309 Rivercrest Dr. Piscataway, NJ 08854-4734 Anthony Montapert 1375 Ficus Way Ventura, CA 93004 293 Cathy Reuscher 717 North New St. Bethlehem, PA 18018 Arthur Satter 301 Prospect St. Hawley, PA 18428 294 Celia M Janosik 305 Hoenig Rd. Sewickley, PA 15143 295 Charles Shelton P.O. Box 453 Grottoes, VA 24441 279 280 281 282 283 B. Thomas Diener 405 Zena Lona St., N.E., Unit E Albuquerque, NM 871233089 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 13 Number 296 Commentator Chris Hazynski 12 Cypress Court Bordentown, NJ 08505 Number 308 Commentator Dr. John Sorrentino 819 Edge Hill Rd. Glenside, PA 19038-3821 297 Clyde Ackerman 25 Doe Ridge Dr. Fleetwood, PA 19522 309 Dr. Lih Young 1121 Pipestem Pl. Rockville, MD 20854 298 Darvin Schild 118 Arlington Blvd. North Arlington, NJ 07031 310 Drew Cucuzza 51 Central Ave. New Haven CT 06515 299 David Jenkins 300 North Fretz Ave. Edmond, OK 73003-5357 311 Edeltraut Renk Montecaminetto Sacrofano Italy 00060 300 David S. Miller 55 Plumer Road Newton, NJ 7860 312 Edward Thornton 7 Swarthmore Pl. Swarthmore, PA 19081-1023 301 David Stemac 728 Main St. Addison, PA 154119 313 Elizabeth Seltzer Parkside, PA 19015 314 302 Dennis Higgins 592 County Rte. 5 Otego, NY 12825 Eric Bare 1010 Powderhouse Rd. Vestal, NY 13850 315 Eugene Mosca 301 Constitution Blvd. Kutztown, PA 19530 316 Faith Zerbe 379 Upland Way Drexel Hill, PA 19026 317 Frances Demillion Kennett Square, PA 193482592 318 Fulvio Fiorentini Via Attilio Bonanni 7 Civita Castellana (vt)-italy 01033 319 Geoff & Nancy Motts 1223 Jamie Brooks Ln. 320 George Mullen Wellsboro, PA 16901 303 Dennis Lieb 1208 Chidsey St. Easton, PA 18042 304 Diane Burke 147 Bingham Ave. Rumson, NJ 07760 305 Diane Macinnes 739 Oquaga Lake Rd. Deposit, NY 13754 306 Diane Shaughnessy 7308 N. Skyview Pl., A208 Tacoma, WA 98406 307 Dianne Douglas 2723 E. Valencia Dr. Phoenix, AZ 85042 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 14 Number 321 Commentator Gerry 25222 Madrin Murrieta, CA 92563 Number 333 Commentator Janet I. Hill 1770 Old Plains Rd. Pennsburg, PA 18073-2418 322 Gibson Reynolds 320 Richey Ave. Collingswood, NJ 08107 334 Jared Blumer 43 Carpenter Lane Philadelphia, PA 19119 323 Gina Flores P.O. Box 934 Milford, PA 18337 335 Jay Sweeney Daltonk, PA 18414 336 Jay Wagner 75 Lilac Ln. Roscoe, NY 12776 337 Jean Barrell 1373 Holicong Rd. New Hope, PA 18938 338 Jean Wiant 141 Red Oak Ln. Philipsburg, PA 16866 339 Jeanne Heldwarmkessel 110 Santa Anita Dr. North Wales, PA 19454 340 Jeanne Walton P.O. Box 504 Point Pleasant, PA 18950 341 Jed Williams 615 Bainbridge St. Philadelphia, PA 19147-2111 324 Gloria Morotti 5305 15th Street Court East Bradenton, FL 34203-4454 325 Heather Nelson 371 Levengood Rd. D Douglassville, PA 19518 326 Hilary Persky 100 Cuyler Rd. Princeton, NJ 08540 327 Ingrid Guiter 1430 County Highway 8 Otego, NY 13825 328 Irwin Cantos 36 7th Ave. Brooklyn, NY 11217 329 Isaac Shamah Nyack, NY 10960 330 Jan Goodwin 1396 Milanville Rd. Milanville, PA 18443 342 Jennifer Foulk 112 Circle Dr. Chalfont, PA 18914 331 Jan Milburn 114 Mountain Rd. Ligonier, PA 15658 343 Jerry Davies 1945 Deer Path Rd. Harrisburg, PA 17110 332 Janet Cavallo 1276 Providence Rd. Secane, PA 19018 344 Jo Clayson 842 Phillip Rd. Fort Plain, NY 13339 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 15 Number 345 Commentator Joan Schooley 190 Gypsy Ln. Dallas, PA 18612 Number 357 Commentator Judith Wells P.O. Box 72 Poyntelle, PA 18454 346 Joanne Freedman 705 Fordham Road Bala Cynwyd, PA 19004 358 Julie Nuss 3274 Susquehanna Rd. Dresher, PA 19025 347 Joe Morrissey 201 African Rd. Vestal 13850 359 June Cattell 200 Pineview Rd. West Columbia, SC 29169 348 John Cooper 36 N. 7th St. Lewisburg, PA 17837 360 K. Darlington 44 Glenloch Way Malvern, PA 19355 349 John Eschen 308 E St. Grand Coulee, WA 991339749 361 Karen Feridun 260 East Main St. Kutztown, PA 19530 362 350 John Flynn 88 Dillon Way Washington Crossing, PA 18977 Karen Petley 724 13th Street Ambridge, PA 15003 363 John Hoekstra 32 Sheeder Mill Rd. Spring City, PA 19475 Kathleen M. Howe 54 Grand View Dr. Sayorsburg, PA 18353 364 John Kyser 3323 Aldine St. Philadelphia, PA 19136 Kathy Dabanian 210 Washington Ave. Sellersville, PA 18960 365 John Papandrea 110 West 90 St. New York, NY 10024 Katie Higgins 592 County Route 5 Otego, NY 13825 366 John Schwarzenbach 345 Old Penllyn Pike Penllyn, PA 19422 Kelsi Randall 1420 Lincoln Chapel Rd. Millmont, PA 17845 367 Joseph Quirk 147 Avenue A New York, NY 10009-4884 Ken Johnston 7 Long Rd. Denville, NJ 07834-3120 368 Kris Azzarello 153 Madison Ave. Greensburg, PA 15601 351 352 353 354 355 356 Judith Foester 5 Pilot Ave. West Milford, NJ 07480 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 16 Number 369 Commentator Kurt Bauereiss 579 County Rd. Hampton, NJ 08827 Number 381 Commentator Lynn Henderson P.O. Box 12 Stanton, NJ 08885 370 Lacey Wozny 1614 Madison Ave. Kansas City, MO 64108 382 Manuel Rodriguez 1559 Betts Hill Rd. Delhi, NY 13753 371 Larry Siegel 2113 Fox Run Dr. Plainsboro, NJ 08536 383 Marcia L. Lehman 998 Mayfield Ave. Ambridge, PA 15003 372 Laura 422 Wendy Rd. 384 373 Laura Cosentino 602 Sonnett Pl. Lawrenceville, NJ 08648 Marianne Vetter 775 Newark Pompton Turnpike Pompton Plains, NJ 07444 385 Lawrence Crowley 441 Pheasant Run Louisville, CO 80027 80027 Marilyn Tjaden 73 Beaver Run Rd. Ottsville, PA 18942 386 Leslie E. Carey 1805 Inn Ln. Wilmington, DE 19810 Mark Andrew Battiste 427 S.W. 41st St. Gainesville, FL 32607-2791 387 Linda Jones 1349 Hollowell St. Ontario, CA 91762 Mark Dodel 584 Hickory Valley Rd. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-6846 388 Martina Patterson In Der Otterkaul 8 Lisa Daly 837 Goshen Rd. West Chester, PA 19380 389 Mary Ann Smith Maryknoll Sisters Maryknoll, NY 10545 Logan Welde 36 Cr Terrace Ardmore, PA 19003-2204 390 Mary Cellucci 56 James Rd. Broomall, PA 19008 Lorraine Skala 6219 Crescent Ave. Bensalem, PA 19020 391 Maryann Burch Sherwood Rd. Aurora, NY 13026 Ly Ho 7010 Gillespie St. Philadelphia, PA 19135 392 Maureen Biesel 58 Pleasant Valley Rd. Ephrata, PA 17552 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 17 Number 393 Commentator Maureen Sheehan 6 Holland Brook Rd. Whitehouse Station, NJ 08889 394 Megan Krout 5108 N. 23rd Rd. Arlington, VA 22207 Number 405 Commentator Mmascio 3828 Coventryville Rd. Pottstown, PA 19465 406 Ms. Terry Vaccaro Corbet Plainfield, NJ 07060 407 Nathaniel Posner 1432 County Highway 8 Otego, NY 13825 408 Ned Coates 154 English Hill Rd. Cogan Station, PA 17728 9376 395 Megan Peterson 3063 Comfort Rd. New Hope, PA 18938 396 Melissa Troutman P.O. Box 488 Coudersport, PA 16915 397 Mercedes Lackey 16525 E. 470 Rd. Claremore, OK 74017 409 Nicole Schildcrout 115 Market St. Amesbury, MA 01913 398 Meredith Carpenter 114 South Rd. Brooktondale, NY 14817 410 Ninua Q P.O. Box 533 Pahoa, HI 96778 399 Michael Amoroso 39 Salter Pl. Maplewood, NJ 07040 411 Paul Durkin 2913 Salyers Rd. Clermont, FL 34714 400 Michael Cooper 1434 S. 21st St. Philadelphia, PA 19146 412 Paula Hesse 718 West Nittny Ave. State College, PA 16801 401 Michael Hardesty 339 Duck Harbor Rd. Equinunk, PA 18417 413 Paula Kline 1019 Ashley Rd. West Chester, PA 19382 402 Michael Staats 164 11th Avenue New York, NY 10011 414 Peggy Hartzell 1967 Fairview Rd. Glenmoore, PA 19343 403 Michael W Evans 3731 S. Sepulveda Blvd. Apt. 1 Los Angeles, CA 90034 415 Peter Coleman 58 Shadyside Ave. Staten Island, NY 10309 416 404 Michelle Robinson 23 Kerry Ln. Malvern, PA 19355 Peter Pray 240 Barbara Blvd. Felton, DE 19943 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 18 Number 417 Commentator Phyllis Mollen New York, NY 1002-1322 418 Poune Saberi 1504 Montrose St. Philadelphia, PA 19146 Number 430 Commentator Sandy Sobanski 358 East 19th St. New York, NY 10003 431 Sara Corrigan Hoboken, NJ 07030 432 Sara Hart 92 Park Ave. Amityville, NY 11701 419 Preston Brooks New York, NY 10010 420 Probyn Gregory 10877 Deliban St. Tujunga, CA 91042 433 Sheila Conry 328 Highland Ln. Edgeworth, PA 15143 Ralph Zelman 4 N. Dennison Dr. Hightstown, NJ 08520 434 Sondra Wolferman 112 Buckhill Road Albrightsville, PA 18210 Richard H. Mcnutt Stump Pipersville, PA 18947 435 Stephen Carl 1337 N. Broad St. Lansdale, PA 19446 Richard Romanelli P.O. Box 254 Reeders, PA 18352 436 Stephen Kunz 1015 Brookwood Dr. Phoenixville, PA 19460 R. J. Lane 4930 E. Texas Rd. Allentown, PA 18106 437 Rob Heist 22 Somerset Dr. East Fallowfield, PA 19320 Steve Todd 629 Bullfrog Valley Rd. Hummelstown, PA 170369743 438 Robert Bruckman 421 Anglesey West Chester, PA 19380 Stuart Anderson 238 Main St. Otego, NY 13825 439 Robert Janusko 1329 Eaton Bethlehem, PA 18018 Sue Roeloffs 217 Fern Ave. Haddon Township, NJ 08108 440 Robin Blair 15 Buttonwood Dr. Shrewsbury, NJ 07702 Susan Babbitt 319 South 10th St. Philadelphia, PA 19107 441 Susan Clancy 29 Cliff Trail Kinnelon, NJ 07405 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 Rosalyn Robitaille 603 Terrace Rd. Ligonier, PA 15658 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 19 Number 442 Commentator Susan Delone 4300 Church Rd. Doylestown, PA 18902 Number 454 Commentator William Edelman 529 Simms St. Philadelphia, PA 19116 443 Susan Garelik 44 Yale Ave. Swarthmore, PA 19081 455 William M. Stark 2700 D Herradura 456 444 Suzanne Martin 1108 W Ridge Road Linwood, PA 19061-3916 William Sharfman 50 Riverside Dr. New York, NY 10024 457 William Short 38w615 Bonnie Ct. Saint Charles, IL 60175 458 [email protected] 459 [email protected] 460 [email protected] 461 [email protected] 462 [email protected] 463 [email protected] 464 [email protected] 465 [email protected] 466 [email protected] 467 [email protected] 468 [email protected] 469 [email protected] 470 [email protected] 471 [email protected] 472 [email protected] 473 [email protected] 474 [email protected] 445 Tammie Auld 645 Flower Ave. Grove City, PA 16127 446 Tery Slotter 110 Koch Road Tafton, PA 18464 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 Than Hansen 7092 Ely Rd. New Hope, PA 18938 Thomas Alba 259 Highland Ave. Ambler, PA 19002-4802 Tina Mizhir 9 N. Pearl St. Port Chester, NY 10573 Tom Koven Charlestown Rd. Hampton, NJ 08827 Ursula Zangrilli 203 Lytton Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15213 Veronica Cox Canastota, NY 13032-4794 Wanda Crain 22 Gifford Rd. Sidney, NY 13838 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 20 Number 475 Commentator [email protected] 476 [email protected] 477 478 479 Number 488 Commentator Lisa Rochelle P.O. Box 202 Martins Creek, PA 180630202 Catherine Greer 324 Lisbon Rd. Beaver Falls, PA 15010-9732 489 Mary Ann Bentz 733 N . Pennsylvania Ave. Morrisville, PA 19067 Charles Younger 125 Cummiskey Rd. Dushore, PA 18614-7888 490 Michael Merold 304 High Bridge Damascus, PA 18443 491 Mike Roome 49 May Rd. Thompson, PA 18465-9763 Craig Martin P.O. Box 394 111 Hemlock Lane New Stanton, PA 15672-0394 480 David Laverne 844 Lincoln St. Dickson City, PA 18519-1429 492 Rocco and Katie Covello 109 N. Delmorr Ave. Morrisville, PA 19067-6205 481 Denise Coyle 1660 McElree Rd. Washington, PA 15301-8387 493 Sonia Liskoski 7 Mary St. Coraopolis, PA 15108-3636 482 George Hawley 715 Trenton Rd. Fairless Hills, PA 19030-2409 494 William Henry 117 Harshaville Rd. Clinton, PA 15026-1415 483 Grace Bergin 216 E Scribner Ave. Du Bois, PA 15801-2250 495 A. J. Frye P.O. Box 345 Donegal, PA 15628-0345 484 Greg Navarro 6325 Greene St. Philadelphia, PA 19144-2509 496 A. Pelligreno 166 Link Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-1895 485 James Bordell 1704 Kimball Ave. New Kensington, PA 150684018 497 A. Puza 720 15th St. New Cumberland, PA 170701511 486 Jan Tyniec 100 Gelderman Rd. Hawley, PA 18428-7847 498 Aaron Gutwein 506 Heist Ln. Mohnton, PA 19540-8615 487 Kathy Piltz 662 Behrens Rd. Jim Thorpe, PA 18229-2736 499 Adam Fronheiser 152 Stone Hill Dr. Pottstown, PA 19464-7512 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 21 Number 500 Commentator Adolfo Fernandez 1111 W. Turner St. Allentown, PA 18102-3834 501 Adrienne Lorah 115 Cocalico Creek Rd. Stevens, PA 17578-9482 502 Agatha Aleniak 259 Cottage Ave. Williamsport, PA 17701-1154 Number 511 Commentator Alexa Manning 805 Graystone Ln. Downingtown, PA 193354444 512 Alice Horton 225 Ellis Ln. West Chester, PA 193806247 513 Alice Schmid P.O. Box 156 Connoquenessing, PA 160270156 514 Alice Sheerr 1051 McKean Rd. Ambler, PA 19002-1601 515 Alice Wampole 1507 N. Line St. Lansdale, PA 19446-1629 503 Aimee Maisano 28 Jackson Dr. Monessen, PA 15062-2540 504 Al Cochrane 334 Danbury Ct. Glen Mills, PA 19342-2041 505 Al Ferrucci 5720 Friendship Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-3653 516 506 Alan Heldon 300 Inman Ter. # A Willow Grove, PA 190903516 Alicia Haupt 917 Wellesley Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-1728 517 Alanna Paradis-Beland 6334 Sherman St. Philadelphia, PA 19144-3115 Alicia Mishinski 5732 Crickett Ln. Harrisburg, PA 17112-3111 518 Alesia Miller 242 Everglade Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15235-2013 Alison Corradini 5277 W. State St. Coopersburg, PA 18036-1340 519 Alison Gray 219 N. 8th St., Apt. B Stroudsburg, PA 18360-1721 520 Allan Larsen 98 Glenn Rd. Grove City, PA 16127-3102 521 Allan Winey 765 Mount Airy Rd. Lewisberry, PA 17339-9766 507 508 509 510 Alex Demczak 1199 Eldersville Rd. Burgettstown, PA 150212502 Alex Scavone 731 Spruce Rd. Warminster, PA 18974-4323 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 22 Number 522 Commentator Allison Sly 215 1/2 Erie St. Edinboro, PA 16412-2210 Number 534 Commentator Andrew Sharp 107 Lexington Ave. Altoona, PA 16601-4933 523 Amanda C 86 Washington, PA 15301-1353 535 Andrew Wadsworth 125 W. 33rd St. Reading, PA 19606-2905 524 Amelia, DE Rose 707 Fulton St. Philadelphia, PA 19147-2816 536 Andrew Welsbacher 432 Green Valley Rd. Eighty Four, PA 15330-2518 525 Amy Fox 1040 Orange St. Steelton, PA 17113-1360 537 Angela Leventis 205 Adams St. Philipsburg, PA 16866-1901 526 Andrea Palmer 158 Crosslands Dr. Kennett Square, PA 193482018 538 Angela Smale 3770 37th Street Ext. Beaver Falls, PA 15010-1106 539 527 Andrea Theisson 965 Black Horse Tavern Rd. Gettysburg, PA 17325-7219 Angelique Polakovic 257 Oak Entrance Dr. Jefferson Hills, PA 150253023 528 Andrew Askins 102 W. Middle St. Gettysburg, PA 17325-2110 540 Angie Lenkevich 1300 W. Hannah St. Houtzdale, PA 16651-1926 529 Andrew Craig 8 Ellsworth Ter. Pittsburgh, PA 15213-2808 541 Anissa Gage 501 W. 3rd St. Oil City, PA 16301-3101 530 Andrew Johnson 549 Macleod Dr. Gibsonia, PA 15044-8962 542 Anita Brosky 3240 Mountain View Dr. Danielsville, PA 18038-9784 531 Andrew Moreland 402 Main St. Jamestown, PA 16134-8408 543 Anita Cartwright 29 Upper Idlewild Dr. New Castle, PA 16101-9201 532 Andrew Perkins 1615 Spruce St. Philadelphia, PA 19103-6306 544 Ann McHale 50 Kingsgate Ct. Gettysburg, PA 17325-8295 533 Andrew Perron 7227 Penn Ave., Apt. 1B Pittsburgh, PA 15208-2535 545 Ann Miller 1 Pearl Dr. Duncannon, PA 17020-9654 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 23 Number 546 Commentator Anna Bower 829 4th Ave. Williamsport, PA 17701-3022 Number 558 Commentator Ashley Lutz 134 Davis Ln. Greensburg, PA 15601-6949 547 Anne Faigen 128 N. Craig St., Apt. 503 Pittsburgh, PA 15213-2742 559 August Pusateri 221 S Aiken Ave. # 2 Pittsburgh, PA 15206-3407 548 Anne Jackson P.O. Box 516 Morgantown, PA 19543-0516 560 B. Gallagher 309 13th Ave. Scranton, PA 18504-2510 549 Anne Lane 1420 Russell Tavern Rd. Gettysburg, PA 17325-8057 561 B. Lynne Reba 19976 State Route 92 Susquehanna, PA 18847-8217 550 Annette Grove 651 E. Guardlock Dr. Lock Haven, PA 17745-1849 562 Barb Bittenbinder 9433 Katherine Dr. Allison Park, PA 15101-2020 551 Annette Logan 5874 River Dr. York, PA 17406-8862 563 Barbara Beebe 3 Meadowlake Dr. Downingtown, PA 193352133 552 Anthony Buffalari 6900 Zuck Rd. Erie, PA 16509-4443 564 Barbara Dougherty 1221 Hawleyton Tpke. Brackney, PA 18812-7845 Anthony Capobianco 101 Keystone Ct., Ste. 203 Bethel Park, PA 15102-4612 565 Barbara Field 318 Richfield St. Pittsburgh, PA 15234-2935 Arnold Pell 149 Club House Rd., Apt. 101 Saylorsburg, PA 18353-8784 566 Arthur Naylor 1302 Dauphin Ave. Wyomissing, PA 19610-2114 Barbara Hillenbrand 1369 Bridge Rd. West Chester, PA 193822088 567 Arthur Wyse 2015 Reservoir Rd. Reading, PA 19604-1110 Barbara Macdonald 315 Evans Rd. Zelienople, PA 16063-3007 568 Barbara Mcgraw 209 N. Mulberry St. Lancaster, PA 17603-3523 553 554 555 556 557 Ashley Duchinski 11 Fox Chase Cir. Newtown Square, PA 190732405 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 24 Number 569 Commentator Barbara McIlvaine Smith 1705 W. Street Rd. West Chester, PA 193824400 570 Barbara Nadel 120 W. Mulberry Dr. Milford, PA 18337-7223 571 Barbara Root 435 Kauffman Rd. Annville, PA 17003-9341 572 Barbara Rosenzweig 105 Meadowfield Dr. Southampton, PA 189663045 573 Barbara Silverstein 171 Benson Ave. Mansfield, PA 16933-9218 574 Barbara Spiegelberg 240 Steinman Farm Rd. Pequea, PA 17565-9723 575 Barbara Tompkins 2370 Robert Fulton Hwy. Peach Bottom, PA 175639742 576 Number 580 Commentator Bart Wert 2334 S. Lumber St. Allentown, PA 18103-6746 581 Bea Landis 501 Yorktown Rd. Lancaster, PA 17603-6061 582 Becky Tierney 233 4th St. Hallstead, PA 18822-9471 583 Becky Watson 1328 6th Ave. New Brighton, PA 150662130 584 Becky Wood 216 Blandford, PA 15432 585 Ben Barbash 1682 Sullivan Dr. Blue Bell, PA 19422-3623 586 Ben Hoskins 354 Sundance Ridge Rd. Lewisburg, PA 17837-8155 587 Benita Campbell 23 Hindman Ave. Burgettstown, PA 150211165 588 Bernard Rubb 434 Oliver Rd. Sewickley, PA 15143-1034 589 Beth Mattei-Miller 31 Carroll St. Pittston, PA 18640-1901 590 Betsy Eichelberger 268 Kralltown Rd. Dillsburg, PA 17019-8620 Barry Fulks 1516 Valmont St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1422 577 Barry Simon 1030 Kinzua Rd. Warren, PA 16365-9628 578 Barry Summers 232 Aspen Rd. Yardley, PA 19067-5773 579 Barry Tuscano 354 Grave Yard Hill Rd. Bolivar, PA 15923-2010 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 25 Number 591 Commentator Betty Hoehn 614 Garfield Dr. Elizabethtown, PA 170228496 592 Betty Reefer 3672 State Route 819 Saltsburg, PA 15681-3287 593 Beverly Brilhart Ibanez 815 W. 15th St. Tyrone, PA 16686-1913 594 Beverly Williamson-Pecori 1295 Silver Ln. Mc Kees Rocks, PA 151361063 595 Bill Abraham 778 S Front St. Philadelphia, PA 19147-3502 596 Bill Cook 32 Eley St. Kingston, PA 18704-3920 597 Bill Deutsche 7 Solar Dr. New Providence, PA 175609677 598 Bill Ridgeway 842 N. Sumner Ave. Scranton, PA 18504-1545 Number 602 Commentator Bob & Donna Janusko 1329 Eaton Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-1807 603 Bob & Pat Thompson 2255 Ramsey Rd. Monroeville, PA 15146-4823 604 Bob Allen 1007 Golfview Ave. State College, PA 168012809 605 Bob Fetters 3569 Teton Rd. Philadelphia, PA 19154-1511 606 Bob Riggs 1113 Prospect Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-4913 607 Bob Roach 3143 W. 42nd St. Erie, PA 16506-5319 608 Bob Weinstein 452 N. Alexander St. Monongahela, PA 150632545 609 Bobb Carson 1576 Parkland Rd. Coopersburg, PA 18036-9060 610 Bobbie Potsic 1057 Beaumont Rd. Berwyn, PA 19312-2007 599 Billie Williams 385 Maple Hill Rd. Wellsboro, PA 16901-6933 611 600 Bing Morris 643 Berkshire Dr. State College, PA 168033341 Bonnie Pang 2992 Amy Dr. South Park, PA 15129-9348 612 B. J. Novack 1021 Washington St. Easton, PA 18042-4125 Bonnie Piestrak 1001 Wood St. Yardley, PA 19067-7413 613 Bonnie Readinger 208 Hillside Rd. Harrisburg, PA 17104-1414 601 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 26 Number 614 Commentator Bonnie Sonder 354 Baird Rd. Merion Station, PA 190661415 615 Brad Vorac 31 Riverside Rd. Airville, PA 17302-9112 616 Brenda Hartman 1138 Douglass St. Reading, PA 19604-2439 617 Brenda Sauter 242 S. Spruce St. Lititz, PA 17543-2316 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 Number 625 Commentator Brion Vallone 3903 Lower Saucon Rd. Hellertown, PA 18055-3236 626 Brooke Espersen 125 Ashley Ln. Slippery Rock, PA 160574101 627 Brooke Garcia 3175 Penn Est. East Stroudsburg, PA 183018490 628 Bruce Fink 350 Cobblestone Cir. Mc Kees Rocks, PA 151361000 629 Bryan Gahres 552 W. Walnut St. Cleona, PA 17042-3150 Brennan Breene 1410 Reissing Rd. Mc Donald, PA 15057-2402 630 Bryan Mccarthy 212 Peebles St., Apt. A Pittsburgh, PA 15221-2702 Brett Heffner 2457 S. 5th St. Allentown, PA 18103-6829 631 Bryan Stinchfield 507 State St. Lancaster, PA 17603-2607 Brian Brown 87 Henry B Ln. Lewisburg, PA 17837-7067 632 C. Allan Miller 255 Conti Rd. Brownsville, PA 15417-9233 Brian Earley 962 Salisbury Ct. Lancaster, PA 17601-5164 633 C. Gene Boyer 550 Marigold Ln. Slippery Rock, PA 160575226 634 C. Van Youngman 1610 Chestnut St. Philadelphia, PA 19103-5119 635 Cara Bintrim 1520 Benshoff Hill Rd. Johnstown, PA 15906-3806 Brendan Hickey 224 New Kent Dr. West Chester, PA 193806111 Brian Sesack 118 Carnegie Pl. Pittsburgh, PA 15208-2704 Bridgette Crockett 3131 Meetinghouse Rd. Upper Chichester, PA 190612947 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 27 Number 636 Commentator Carl Bower 35 Cheryl Trl. Fairfield, PA 17320-8026 Number 647 Commentator Carol Zupancic 146 Hawthorne Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15209-1916 637 Carl Worthington 448 Washington Ave. West Wyoming, PA 186441323 648 Carole Norbeck 510 Moores Mountain Rd. Mechanicsburg, PA 170556035 638 Carla Ryba 108 E. Waldheim Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15215-1931 649 Caroline Binder 1140 Union Church Rd. Mc Connellsburg, PA 172338764 639 Caroe Ludwig 6050 Franklin Hill Rd. East Stroudsburg, PA 183019268 650 Caroline Brady 2825 Four Mile Dr. Montoursville, PA 177549584 Carol Baker 863 Euclid Ave. Warrington, PA 18976-2165 651 Caroline Wilson P.O. Box 395 Furlong, PA 18925-0395 Carol Famariss 331 Trolls Lake Rd. Somerset, PA 15501-6712 652 Carolyn Glass 4006 Northminster St. Pittsburgh, PA 15212-1622 Carol Garber 502 Milner Dr. Red Lion, PA 17356-8910 653 Carolyn Hughes 221 N. 5th St. Mcsherrystown, PA 173441518 654 Carolyn Rogers 24 Mark Dr. Delmont, PA 15626-1624 655 Catherine Gerenser 28 Mystery Rose Ln. West Grove, PA 19390-8812 Carol Waldner 5360 Wilshire Rd. Harrisburg, PA 17112-3422 656 Catherine Mott 79 Plummer McCullough Rd. Mercer, PA 16137-4947 Carol Williams 238 College Lodge Rd. Indiana, PA 15701-4008 657 Catherine Penta 108 W. High St. Womelsdorf, PA 19567-1206 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 Carol Karl 6122 Boxer Dr. Bethel Park, PA 15102-3214 Carol Molyneaux 12 Fox Run Ln. Newtown Square, PA 190731004 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 28 Number 658 Commentator Catherine Ryan 1703 Red Maple Grv. Ambler, PA 19002-5037 Number 669 Commentator Charles Heck 96 Orchard Ave. Greenville, PA 16125-2411 659 Cathie White 2206 Windfield Ct. Glen Mills, PA 19342-8137 670 Charles Henry 577 Hamel Ave. Greensburg, PA 15601-4470 660 Cathleen Wilk 24 2nd St., Apt. 3 Catasauqua, PA 18032-1904 671 Charles J. Millman 114 Black Hill Rd. Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462-1804 661 Cece Baker Viti 133 W. Locust St., Apt. 203 Mechanicsburg, PA 170556361 672 Charles L. Cales Jr. 990 E. James St. Lehighton, PA 18235-5228 662 Chad Collins 63 Eastern Ave., Apt. A Greencastle, PA 17225-1171 673 Charles Leiden 306 Coleridge Ave. Altoona, PA 16602-3112 663 Charlene Rush 2670 Thoroughbred Ct., Apt. 835 Allison Park, PA 15101-5111 674 Charles Maxwell, Jr. 312 Huron Ave. Renovo, PA 17764-1021 675 664 Charles & Christine Welsh 503 Maplewood Ave. Wayne, PA 19087-4704 Charles Spiroff 118 Hiddenwood Dr. Harrisburg, PA 17110-3919 676 665 Charles Beitinger 1 Prospect Dr. Sinking Spring, PA 196088975 Charles Stierheim 11 Peppertree Dr. Coraopolis, PA 15108-9126 677 Charlie Mcnutt 5225 Wilson Ln., Apt. 2138 Mechanicsburg, PA 170556667 678 Charlotte Harris 239 N. Robinson St. Philadelphia, PA 19139-1123 679 Charlotte Tancin 315 Leax Ln. Turtle Creek, PA 15145-1127 680 Charlotte Whiting 1316 Quarry Ln. Lancaster, PA 17603-2424 666 Charles Davis 4012 Little John Dr. York, PA 17408-8987 667 Charles Evans 38 Filbert St. Forty Fort, PA 18704-4212 668 Charles Gerlach 138 Berry Ln. New Albany, PA 18833-8872 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 29 Number 681 Commentator Cheryl Crise 175 Old Furnace Rd. Hopwood, PA 15445-2027 682 683 684 685 686 687 688 689 690 691 692 Number 693 Commentator Christian Sell 42 Corson Rd. Conshohocken, PA 194282133 Cheryl Jarvis-Johnson 480 Harmon Rd. Philadelphia, PA 19128-4201 694 Christina Wildrick 105 Sandy Ct. Avondale, PA 19311-1447 Cheryl Schwartz 371 Dartmouth Ct. Bensalem, PA 19020-8204 695 Christine Castorani 13 Wyndham Ct. Downingtown, PA 193351115 696 Christine Sandvik 725 Lower State Rd. North Wales, PA 19454-1301 697 Christine Walturz 204 N. 10th St. Easton, PA 18042-3312 Chester Elewski 204 Highland Pines Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-2014 698 Christopher Aichele 1035 N. 4th St. Philadelphia, PA 19123-1528 Chris Calvert 2412 Fitzgerald St. Philadelphia, PA 19145-3217 699 Christopher Daly 298 S. Roberts Rd. Bryn Mawr, PA 19010-1351 Chris Hudock 638 10th Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-5038 700 Christopher Hall 682 W. Market St., Trlr. 5 Marietta, PA 17547-1023 Chris Minich 313 Roberts Rd. Lewis Run, PA 16738-1823 701 Christopher Horwitz 2200 Beechwood Blvd. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1816 Chris Parzyck 1533 Barnes Ave. South Park, PA 15129-9123 702 Christopher Jagielski 4234 Mohican Dr. Schnecksville, PA 180782618 703 Christopher Omiros 73 Belmont Cir. Uniontown, PA 15401-4761 Cheryl Schwartz-Grenetz 371 Dartmouth Ct. Bensalem, PA 19020-8204 Cheryl Whittaker 2007 Lenape Unionville Rd. Kennett Square, PA 193481325 Chris Pearsall 1712 Aurelius St. Pittsburgh, PA 15218-2376 Chris Swatsworth 307 W. Pauline Dr. Clearfield, PA 16830-1005 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 30 Number 704 Commentator Christopher Roche 4811 Saint George St. Reading, PA 19606-3370 Number 716 Commentator Claudia Schoedel 1201 N. Front St., Apt. 701 Harrisburg, PA 17102-2812 705 Christopher Smith 740 Schuylkill Rd. Birdsboro, PA 19508-9224 717 Clement Blazewick 4919 Roberta Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-2046 706 Christopher Squire 1003 Wible Run Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15209-1038 718 Colin Mitchell 263 Cherry Ln. Kennett Square, PA 193484708 707 Christopher Tobias 2711 Locust Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15241-1809 719 Connie Conaway 655 Old Hickory Ridge Rd. Washington, PA 15301-8662 Chrys Morris 3259 Burgettstown Rd. Imperial, PA 15126-2125 720 Connie Kowalski 223 Hillvue Dr. Seven Fields, PA 16046-7854 Chuck Oatman 1610 Fishing Creek Rd. Drumore, PA 17518-9713 721 Connie Williams 9 Chapel Dr. Lewistown, PA 17044-9041 Cindy Black 2320 Wagon Wheel Dr. Easton, PA 18040-7816 722 Craig Conn 1200 Termon Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15212-1900 723 Craig Kaufman 312 Rural Ave. Williamsport, PA 17701-3341 708 709 710 711 Cindy Zembryki 106 Tinker Stevens Rd. Shinglehouse, PA 167482416 712 Clair Chronister 2371 Wedgewood Way York, PA 17408-9464 724 Craig Meyer 612 Ballytore Rd. Wynnewood, PA 19096-2210 713 Claire Cusin 6313 Glenview Pl. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-2225 725 Craig Sundberg 2918 W. 42nd St. Erie, PA 16506-4470 714 Clark Grenoble 179 Weathervane Ln. Lewisburg, PA 17837-8129 726 Cris Larson Wynnewood Road Philadelphia, PA 19151 715 Clark Hiestand 151 Old River Rd. Wilkes Barre, PA 18702-1729 727 Crisane Cook 1147 Old Danville Hwy. Northumberland, PA 178578752 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 31 Number 728 Commentator Curtis Holgate 1915 Lititz Pike Lancaster, PA 17601-3805 Number 740 Commentator Dale Musselman 133 Rossmor Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15229-3107 729 Cyndi Noonan 1904 Yorktown S. Norristown, PA 19403-3523 741 Dan Hydock 100 Briar Ln. New Kensington, PA 150687138 730 Cynthia Bauer 112 Snowden Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15229-1033 742 Danette Paris 281 Coralwood Dr. Moon Township, PA 151083115 743 Daniel Camacho 328 Highland Ln. Sewickley, PA 15143-1041 744 Cynthia Murdough 380 W. Oak Ave. Robesonia, PA 19551-1406 Daniel Dubbs 4 Dogwood Rd. Schuylkill Haven, PA 179729331 745 Cynthia Zeth 1056 Teal Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-2057 Daniel Natt 1911 Echo Beach Rd. Towanda, PA 18848-7756 746 D. Bietler Pinto Pittsburgh, PA 15238-1352 Daniel Sleator 15 Hollenden Pl. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1553 747 D. Oppenheimer 1977 Meadow Ln. Wyomissing, PA 19610-2724 Daniel Young 1207 Harrow Hill Ct. Moon Twp., PA 15108-9019 748 D. Scott Eaby 29 S. State St. Ephrata, PA 17522-2410 Daphne Pleasonton 5136 Roseberry Dr. Doylestown, PA 18902-1075 749 D. Taylor 3135 N. 17th St. Philadelphia, PA 19132-2360 Darcy Augello 1094 Sandy Ridge Rd. Doylestown, PA 18901-2435 750 Daryl Lesko 2670 Santa Barbara Dr. Bethel Park, PA 15102-1728 731 732 733 734 735 736 737 738 739 Cynthia Iberg 95 Grouse Trl. Mc Alisterville, PA 170498691 Cynthia March 76 Monroe Ave. Dallas, PA 18612-1512 Dale Kashner 313 Claremont Dr. Seven Valleys, PA 173609200 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 32 Number 751 Commentator Dave Boorse P.O. Box 238 Woxall, PA 18979-0238 Number 762 Commentator David Mccormick 801 Yale Ave., Apt. 628 Swarthmore, PA 19081-1811 752 Dave White 38 Phineas Ln. Coatesville, PA 19320-6546 763 David Meade 115 N. Pennsylvania Ave. Apollo, PA 15613-1353 753 David And Judith Allara 2517 Sleepy Hollow Dr. State College, PA 168032227 764 David Natishyn P.O. Box 996 Pocono Pines, PA 183500996 754 David Arscott 354 Little Elk Creek Rd. Lincoln University, PA 19352-9431 765 David Paine 132 Woodland Dr. Mt. Lebanon, PA 15228-1793 766 755 David Casker 195r Derby St. Johnstown, PA 15905-4514 David Platt 253a Dimpsey Rd. Halifax, PA 17032-9665 767 David Romero 2760 Anvil Pl. Doylestown, PA 18902-1814 768 David York 1207 Hillcrest Rd. Akron, PA 17501-1519 756 David Clemens P.O. Box 276 Milton, PA 17847-0276 757 David Dewalt 257 Westley Rd. Mohnton, PA 19540-8014 769 758 David Greene 283 Carpenter Ln. North Huntingdon, PA 15642-1239 Deacon Skip La Police 560 Hemlock Rd. Tamaqua, PA 18252-5558 770 David Hemberger 47 Sycamore Dr. Reading, PA 19606-9538 Dean Bottorf 23 Hickory Dr. Lock Haven, PA 17745-1610 771 Dean Reigle 114 N. Mann Ave. Yeagertown, PA 17099-9665 772 Deane Lavender 253 Norman Dr. Cranberry Twp., PA 160664234 773 Deanna Delaura 27 W. 33rd St. Erie, PA 16508-2807 759 760 761 David Hunsberger 1033 S. Spruce St. Elizabethtown, PA 170222753 David Marshall 343 Faculty Rd. Duncannon, PA 17020-9788 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 33 Number 774 Commentator Deanne O'Donnell 1177 Spruce St. Greensburg, PA 15601-5344 Number 786 Commentator Dennis Ober 1833 Upper Rd. Shamokin, PA 17872-7816 775 Debbie Fry 7922 Farnsworth St. Philadelphia, PA 19152-3434 787 Dennis Urban 2105 Afton St. Philadelphia, PA 19152-4021 776 Debby Nemecek 1207 Farmington Ln. West Chester, PA 193804606 788 Dennis Wickizer 1188 Elk Grove Rd. Benton, PA 17814-7699 789 777 Deborah Malinak 2600 Biglerville Rd. Gettysburg, PA 17325-8045 Dennis Wildasin 1307 Valley Rd. Seven Valleys, PA 173609080 778 Deborah Reumann 891 Wilhelm Ave. Lebanon, PA 17042-7254 790 Dennis Wilson P.O. Box 266 Strausstown, PA 19559-0266 779 Deborah Ritchey 1404 Green St. Harrisburg, PA 17102-2639 791 Diana Bekkerman 1 Gruver St. Nanticoke, PA 18634-4205 780 Debra Burk 4440 Battlehill Rd. Brogue, PA 17309-9072 792 Diana Goslin 225 Rohrbach Rd. Chicora, PA 16025-4805 781 Debra George 910 N. 5th St. Reading, PA 19601-1802 793 Diana Hulboy 308 Ripka St. Philadelphia, PA 19128-4606 782 Denise Whitney 4657 Duncan Rd. Erie, PA 16505-1311 794 Diane and Dale Snyder 1181 King Rd. West Chester, PA 193801426 783 Dennis & Ann Umphrey 1300 Mount Hope Ave. Pottsville, PA 17901-1409 795 Diane Lancaster 407 W. Elm St. Dunmore, PA 18512-3067 Dennis Hartenstine 2425 Hay Creek Rd. Birdsboro, PA 19508-8036 796 Diane Stone 53 Maple Grove Rd. Starrucca, PA 18462-1117 Dennis Keller 1429 Old Reliance Rd. Middletown, PA 17057-5906 797 Diane Strohm 3252 Comly Rd. Philadelphia, PA 19154-3324 784 785 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 34 Number 798 Commentator Diane Veath 111 Penrod St. Johnstown, PA 15902-3324 799 800 801 802 Number 810 Diann Deangelis 452 Holyoke Rd. Butler, PA 16001-1344 Commentator Donald Martin 300 Willow Vly. Lks. Dr., Apt. E-225 Willow Street, PA 175849442 811 Dino Ciabattoni P.O. Box 567 450 Georgetown Rd. Lawrence, PA 15055-0567 Donald Stone 167 Patriot Cir. Mountain Top, PA 187072039 812 Dolores Piech 256 Georges Rd. Wapwallopen, PA 186601747 Donald Waltman 587 Melissa Ln. State College, PA 168031250 813 Dominic Haberstumpf 311 8th Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-5001 Donna Edwards 153 Kings Hwy. Altoona, PA 16602-7505 814 Donna Erb 724 S. Market St. Elizabethtown, PA 170222726 815 Donna Logan 452 Clokey Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15228-1425 816 Donna Sherman 147 Greenhill Dr. Butler, PA 16001-1942 817 Donna Tuggle 748 Tower Dr. Greencastle, PA 17225-9590 818 Donna Vetter 10481 Perry Dr. Espyville, PA 16424-3947 819 Dorothy Hvozda 2310 Sidney St., Apt. 1 Pittsburgh, PA 15203-2115 820 Dot Bosley 13 Leslie Dr. Scranton, PA 18505-2215 803 Don Consul 255 Mountain Mary Rd. Boyertown, PA 19512-7822 804 Don Hayhurst P.O. Box 177 Waverly, PA 18471-0177 805 Don Robertson 6966 Susquehanna Trl. S. York, PA 17403-9324 806 Donald Accorsi 104 Rocky Mountain Ct. Latrobe, PA 15650-2409 807 Donald Helm 45 Edswood Ter. Easton, PA 18042-7034 808 Donald Kempson 310 E. 3rd St. Lansdale, PA 19446-2803 809 Donald Lambert 605 Cly Rd. York Haven, PA 17370-9041 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 35 Number 821 Commentator Doug Keith 151 Fairlawn Ave. State College, PA 168017208 822 Douglas Mason 120 E. Beaver Ave., Apt. 310 State College, PA 168014991 823 824 825 Number 832 Commentator Ed Fedorchak 223 Stevens Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-4113 833 Ed Hermance 3214 Winter St. Philadelphia, PA 19104-2719 834 Douglas Robinson 401 Riverview Rd. Swarthmore, PA 19081-1222 Ed Koller 155 Lazy Hollow Ln. Duncansville, PA 16635-6569 835 Drea Noll 502 N. 2nd St. Halifax, PA 17032-9007 Ed Martnick 231 Hanna St. Sugarloaf, PA 18249-1046 836 Ed Moore 694 Fishing Creek Rd. New Cumberland, PA 170702750 837 Ed Sarver 203 Jacobs Ct. Cranberry Twp., PA 160663377 838 Edda Gentry P.O. Box 121 307 Harter Rd. Spring Mills, PA 16875-0121 839 Edith Kwasnoski 545 Grant St. Newtown, PA 18940-1836 840 Edmund Swiger 5850 Meridian Rd., Apt. 502c Gibsonia, PA 15044-9693 841 Edwasrd and Linda Moody P.O. Box 182 1247 River Rd. Washington Crossing, PA 18977-0182 842 Edward Bendick 179 Reichley Rd. Winfield, PA 17889-8614 Duane Burtner 175 Rockdale Rd. Butler, PA 16002-0953 826 Duane Stanton 50 Viola Rd. Kimberton, PA 19442 827 Duncan Perry P.O. Box 443 Dalton, PA 18414-0443 828 E Unger Bethlehem Township Easton, PA 18020 829 E. Nan Edmunds 1417 Shopes Church Rd. Hummelstown, PA 170369623 830 E. Thornton P.O. Box 1203 Bradford, PA 16701-5203 831 Earl Buchmoyer 204 E.Derry Rd. Hershey, PA 17033-2709 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 36 Number 843 Commentator Edward Davis 8462 Algon Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19152-1725 Number 855 Commentator Eileen Walsh 208 W. Ridge St. Nanticoke, PA 18634-2111 844 Edward Goryl 716 Church St. Reading, PA 19601-2218 856 Elaine Gleason 351 Park Ave. New Cumberland, PA 170701345 845 Edward Gruver 325 Bracken Dr. Lancaster, PA 17601-3963 857 Elana Davis 925 Stonewood Rd. York, PA 17402-8112 Edward Hickey 34 Longenecker Rd. Lititz, PA 17543-7960 858 Elinor Wilson 6730 Geissinger Rd. Zionsville, PA 18092-2249 Edward Mcgraw 910 W Linden St., Fl. 2 Scranton, PA18504-3602 859 Elisabeth West 114 Windsor Ave. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2920 Edward Shaw 6351 Phillips Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1807 860 Elizabeth Anderson 209 Forks Hill Rd. Montrose, PA 18801-8292 Edward Ulrich 673 Candy Rd. Mohnton, PA 19540-7981 861 Elizabeth Anné Steigerwalt Riverview Manor Pittston, PA 18640-2161 Edwin Hiley 1387 Murray Creek Rd. Athens, PA 18810-9591 862 Elizabeth Black 3785 Chase Rd. Shavertown, PA 18708-9737 863 Elizabeth Boyles 2701 Walnut Ave., Apt. 105 Altoona, PA 16601-6801 846 847 848 849 850 851 Eileen Gallagher 500 Blind Ln. Belle Vernon, PA 150121267 852 Eileen Goodman Washington Lane Wyncote, PA 19095 864 Elizabeth Fincke 3 Melody Ln. Selinsgrove, PA 17870-1159 853 Eileen Graham 9 Poplar Hill Rd. Gardners, PA 17324-9588 865 Elizabeth Griffiths 1951 Herrs Ridge Rd. Gettysburg, PA 17325-7229 854 Eileen Oliver 127 Vance Rd. New Wilmington, PA 161422233 866 Elizabeth Manning 1240 Tyler Ave. Phoenixville, PA 19460-4365 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 37 Number 867 Commentator Elizabeth Richie 809 Avenue E Dr. Danville, PA 17821-7649 Number 878 Commentator Emily Pecora 151 Cedar Head Rd. Sugarloaf, PA 18249-3337 868 Elizabeth Shirey 317 W. Prospect Ave. State College, PA 168014617 879 Emily Will 719 Main St., Apt. 1 Akron, PA 17501-1372 880 Emma Rainoff 300 N. Washington St., # 2094 Gettysburg, PA 17325-1400 881 Eric Boyce P.O. Box 274 Hatboro, PA 19040-0274 882 Eric Karrfalt 10261 Fry Rd. Mckean, PA 16426-1721 883 Eric Leach 1807 Timothy Dr. West Mifflin, PA 15122-3111 884 Erika Miller 123 Kready Ave. Millersville, PA 17551-2007 885 Erika Seibel 1173 Thomas 84 Rd. Eighty Four, PA 15330-2589 869 Ellen & Kevin Milligan 316 Spurrier Dr. Lititz, PA 17543-7703 870 Ellen Bardo 121 Creek Rd. Muncy, PA 17756-7764 871 Ellen Dannin 168 E. North Hills Pl. State College, PA 168033029 872 873 Ellen Lewis 153 Buttonwood Ct. East Stroudsburg, PA 183011824 Ellen Prosser 12 Windemere Ct. Downingtown, PA 193351113 874 Ellen Rogovin Hart 457 Crest Ave. Elkins Park, PA 19027-3219 886 Erin & Sydney Caretti 123 E. Seminary St. Mercersburg, PA 17236-1605 875 Elliot Ross Lyon St. Union Dale, PA 18470-7615 887 Erin Devine 8391 Barker Rd. Girard, PA 16417-8706 876 Emeric Deluca 1135 Dry Powder Cir. Mechanicsburg, PA 170507330 888 Erin Kelly 2640 Poplar St. Philadelphia, PA 19130-1322 889 Eugene Mariani 5841 Forward Ave., Apt. 508 Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2329 877 Emile G. Ilchuk 1069 7th St. Catasauqua, PA 18032-2214 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 38 Number 890 Commentator Eva Limbacher 2111 Wentworth Dr. Camp Hill, PA 17011-7450 891 Evangeline Munyan 1210 Mifflin St. Saxton, PA 16678-1327 892 893 894 895 896 897 898 899 900 901 Number 902 Commentator Francis Itzoe P.O. Box 436 New Freedom, PA 173490436 903 Evelize Soto 1824 N. 4th St. Philadelphia, PA 19122-2202 Frank Asturino 5679 Steubenville Pike Mc Kees Rocks, PA 151361415 904 Evelyn Och 871 Bridgewater Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15216-1723 Frank Capaldi 1483 Gene Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15234-1901 905 Frank Denbowski 1030 N. 6th St. Reading, PA 19601-1812 906 Frank E. Jones 1151 Coudersport Pike Lock Haven, PA 17745-8128 Fabe Kuhn 201 Linden Ave. Hanover, PA 17331-4717 907 Frank Little 649 Treetop Ln. Hermitage, PA 16148-3950 Faustino Dunckhorst 5153 Villaview Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-1512 908 Frank Sabatini 119 Aster Ct. Exeter, PA 18643-1146 Fielding Howe ASLA 773 E. Haverford Rd., # 6b Bryn Mawr, PA 19010-3837 909 Frank Whetsell 1207 Ohio Ave. White Oak, PA 15131-1607 910 Fred And Greta Odhner P.O. Box 550 3039 Huntingdon Pike Bryn Athyn, PA 19009-0550 Floyd Martin 20 Heyser Rd. Barto, PA 19504-8959 911 Freda Egnal 4825 Osage Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-1712 Frances Harkins 3700 Venango Ave. Munhall, PA 15120-3054 912 Frederic Strawbridge 1632 Stonington Cir. North Wales, PA 19454-3675 F. David & L. Audrey Marschka 18d Center Dr. Lancaster, PA 17601-3472 Flora Franconi 9 Oak St. Harveys Lake, PA 186183211 Frances Sonne 461 W. Linden St. Allentown, PA 18102-3453 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 39 Number 913 Commentator Frederick Justice 2421 W Chestnut Ave. Altoona, PA 16601-1838 Number 925 Commentator George Banner 1110 Lake Lucy Rd., Lot Bb Tionesta, PA 16353-2338 914 Frederick Schwartz 155 Fairview Dr. Lewisburg, PA 17837-6401 926 George Ehret 1117 Raymond Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-2123 915 Gabrielle Corson 512 Braddock Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15221-3734 927 George Erceg 3079 Donnellville Rd. Natrona Heights, PA 150653917 916 Gabrielle Hafen 419 N. George St. Millersville, PA 17551-2023 928 George Kich 105 Candle Ridge Dr. Wexford, PA 15090-7104 929 George Petrisko P.O. Box 301 Montgomeryville, PA 189360301 Garth Ehrlich 3319 Beechwood Blvd. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2907 930 Gerald Lofstead 507 Hunter Ln. Uniontown, PA 15401-5098 Gary Daubert 142 Daubert Lane Lehighton, PA 182353807 931 Gerald Smith 1008 Orchard View Rd. Reading, PA 19606-3283 Gary Kaminski 231 Henderson Rd. Buena Vista, PA 15018-9538 932 Geraldine Adams 1734 S. Dover St. Philadelphia, PA 19145-1620 Gary Kinkley 3 Clark Rd. Annville, PA 17003-9540 933 Gerritt & Elizabeth BakerSmith 338 Braeside Ave. East Stroudsburg, PA 183012903 934 Gerry Seymour 22 Slitting Mill Rd. Glen Mills, PA 19342-1614 935 Gina Delgadillo 1228 Banbury Cir. West Chester, PA 193804076 917 918 919 920 921 Gail Meister 14210 Hiland Pl. North Huntingdon, PA 15642-1027 922 Gary Lee 228 N. 4th St. Emmaus, PA 18049-2718 923 Gary Williams P.O. Box 196 Blooming Glen, PA 189110196 924 Genava Ebanks 2822 Marvine Ave. Scranton, PA 18508-1472 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 40 Number 936 Commentator Gina Gallo 2664 Maytown Rd. Marietta, PA 17547-9781 Number 948 Commentator Greg Rush 605 Turnberry Ln. Oakdale, PA 15071-9709 937 Glenn Brumbaugh 219 N. 30th St. Camp Hill, PA 17011-2932 949 Greg Skutches 301 E. Washington Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-2522 938 Glenn Klepac 1227 Parkview Blvd. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2586 950 Gregory Binder 5106 Shawnee Blvd. Schnecksville, PA 180782609 939 Glenn Treichler 1017 Hogan Way. Northampton, PA 180672700 951 Gregory Huber 9200 Bustleton Ave., Apt. 1204 Philadelphia, PA 19115-4226 Glenn Wood 1005 Sanlin Dr. Coraopolis, PA 15108-2825 952 Hal Tarr 508 S. 22nd St. Philadelphia, PA 19146-1102 Graeme Thomson 667 Saylors Mill Rd. Spring City, PA 19475-9695 953 Hannah Zabitz 1824 Richmond Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-3315 Grant and Jessica Krow 3118 W. Penn St. Philadelphia, PA 19129-1016 954 Harley Stewart 1303 Allen St. Aliquippa, PA 15001-2907 Gray Seal Old Rd. Kittanning, PA 16201 955 Harold Holtzinger 1235 Golden Way York, PA 17402-9516 Greg Giocolo 88 Elm Ave. Sharon, PA 16146-2302 956 Harriette Carlisle 516 S Highland Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15206-4266 Greg Kochanski 6739 Wilkins Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1318 957 Harry Barr 364 Jefferson Ave. Sharon, PA 16146-3310 Greg Kopich 209 Ridge Ave. Hawley, PA 18428-1127 958 Harry Hochheiser 5742 Woodmont St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1208 959 Harry Robbins 223 Shingle Mill Dr. Drums, PA 18222-1209 940 941 942 943 944 945 946 947 Greg Lamartine 436 W. Dekalb Pike King of Prussia, PA 194062306 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 41 Number 960 Commentator Heather Fastiggi 106 Evergreen Ter. Cresco, PA 18326-7946 961 Heather Kloss P.O. Box 171 Schuylkill Haven, PA 179720171 Number 971 Commentator Hetty Baiz 36 Shore Dr. Tunkhannock, PA 186577925 972 Holly Williams 153 E. King St., Ste. 311 Lancaster, PA 17602-2812 962 Heather Koch 1569 Bushkill Center Rd. Bath, PA 18014-9658 973 Holman Massey 4917 Cedar Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-2013 963 Helen Irvine 708 E. Macada Rd. Bethlehem, PA 18017-2534 974 Hope Larkin 4737 Maripoe St. Pittsburgh, PA 15213-1191 964 Helen Putera P.O. Box 72 Lederach, PA 19450-0072 975 Howard Davison 2020 Mountain Pine Dr. Mechanicsburg, PA 170508503 965 Helen Raymond 240 River Rd. Falls, PA 18615-7911 976 Helen Touster 624 Liberty St., Apt. 216 Clarion, PA 16214-1165 Howard Kolus 419 Kent Dr. Mechanicsburg, PA 170555530 977 Helene Baker 303 Roselyn St. Philadelphia, PA 19120-1834 Howard Snyder 2134 Hemlock Farms Lords Valley, PA 18428-9074 978 Henry Driller 1712 Fisherville Rd. Coatesville, PA 19320-2118 Hugh Mccartney 11078 Freeport Ln. North East, PA 16428-3006 979 Henry Wise, Jr. 3465 Smith Hill Rd. Slatington, PA 18080-3423 Ian Adrian 115 Lenker Ave. Sunbury, PA 17801-2943 980 Ira Gossard 1100 N. 7th St., # 2 Perkasie, PA 18944-1518 981 Irene And Thomas King 604 Society Pl. Newtown, PA 18940-3241 966 967 968 969 970 Herbert Elwell 350 Button Hill Rd. Lawrenceville, PA 169298550 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 42 Number 982 Commentator Ivan Russell 51 Robinhood Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15220-3013 983 984 985 986 987 988 989 990 991 992 993 Number 994 Commentator Jackie Struthers 1287 Belmont Ave. West Chester, PA 193801078 J. Allen Leslie 505 Bell Rd. Christiana, PA 17509-9617 995 Jacob Colon 1811 N. Bouvier St. Philadelphia, PA 19121-3305 J. Sutton 3617 Colby St. Pittsburgh, PA 15214-2109 996 Jacob Staub 7046 Lincoln Dr. Philadelphia, PA 19119-2542 J. Allen Feryok 1520 Jones St. Monessen, PA 15062-1925 997 James Bloomfield P.O. Box 271 Greenville, PA 16125-0271 Jack Barrett 166 Amos Cir. Bushkill, PA 18324-7779 998 James Burke 815 Franklin St., Apt. 711 Reading, PA 19602-1119 Jack Brasch 902 Mews Dr. Sellersville, PA 18960-2742 999 James Bursley 21 Spalding Cir. Pittsburgh, PA 15228-1544 Jack Glancey 5729 Old Durham Rd. Pipersville, PA 18947-1243 1,000 James Cohen 8130 Cedar Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2137 Jack Miller 130 Delong Rd. Middleburg, PA 17842-8182 1,001 James Durko 165 Fawn Valley Dr. Mcmurray, PA 15317-2705 Jack Singer 335 Bougher Hill Rd. Easton, PA 18042-9791 1,002 James Emigh P.O. Box 41 Hawk Run, PA 16840-0041 Jack Troy 8002 Shively Rd. Huntingdon, PA 16652-3213 1,003 James Harland 5538 Bartlett St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1530 1,004 James Johnston 1555 Clear Run Rd. Dubois, PA 15801-6235 1,005 James Knight 109 Charlene Dr. Danville, PA 17821-9157 Jackie Bobnick P.O. Box 152 30 Federal St Lawrence, PA 15055-0152 Jackie Flynn 444 Woodward Rd. Penfield, PA 15849-5324 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 43 Number 1,006 Commentator James Marden 261 Whitehill St. Lemont, PA 16851 Number 1,018 Commentator Jane Derbenwick 660 Barclay Dr. Bethlehem, PA 18017-3882 1,007 James Mcbride 339 S. Buhl Farm Dr. Hermitage, PA 16148-2514 1,019 Jane Druce 1009 Tracy Rd. Lancaster, PA 17601-4854 1,008 James Moss 1749 Hempstead Ln. Pittsburgh, PA 15241-1377 1,020 Jane Hayward 221 S. 15th St. Lewisburg, PA 17837-1652 1,009 James Smith 385 Pencroft Dr. S. Holtwood, PA 17532-9711 1,021 Jane Marsilio-Schmoyer 2717 Foxfire Ct. Coplay, PA 18037-2156 1,010 James Stewart 1104 Edward Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15227-3920 1,022 Janet M. Stevens 309 Florence Ave. Jenkintown, PA 19046-2605 1,011 James Vogt 4296 Upper Smith Gap Rd. Saylorsburg, PA 18353-7356 1,023 Janet Parlett 108 Karen Cir. Coatesville, PA 19320-5506 1,012 James Wylie 208 N. Benjamin Dr. West Chester, PA 193821946 1,024 Janet York 851 Three Degree Rd. Butler, PA 16002-0461 1,025 1,013 James Zoto 36 Winchester Dr. Quakertown, PA 18951-1054 Janette Burkness P.O. Box 89F Kinzua Heights Bradford, PA 16701-0089 1,014 Jamie Caito 1649 Pembroke Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15243-1551 1,026 Jason Mccullough 520 S. Murtland St. Pittsburgh, PA 15208-2835 1,015 Jan Arnold 1580 Cove Lane Rd. Martinsburg, PA 16662-8607 1,027 Jason Walbert 247 Dry Hollow Rd. Bernville, PA 19506-8411 1,016 Jan Loney 227 Academy Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15228-1233 1,028 Jay & Cathy Harter 1785 Harmony Rd. Susquehanna, PA 18847-7638 1,017 Jane Bollinger P.O. Box 122 Prompton, PA 18456-0122 1,029 Jay Holler 1218 Landis Valley Rd. Lancaster, PA 17601-5461 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 44 Number 1,030 Commentator Jean Morse 141 Conashaugh Trl. Milford, PA 18337-3904 Number 1,042 Commentator Jeffrey Onink 140 W. Bond St. Corry, PA 16407-1104 1,031 Jean Randolph 409 Poplar Valley Rd. W. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-7295 1,043 Jeffrey Putt 202 Loucks St. York, PA 17403-9473 1,032 Jean Spangenberg 219 Hempt Rd. Mechanicsburg, PA 170502607 1,044 Jeffrey Varcoe 475 Valley View Rd. Bellefonte, PA 16823-8900 1,045 1,033 Jeanette Dimeo-Tresky 1611 Benson St. Philadelphia, PA 19152-2207 Jeffrey Whitmoyer 215 E. Chestnut St. Lebanon, PA 17042-5535 1,046 1,034 Jeanne Baker 761 Parkside Dr. Altoona, PA 16601-7407 Jen W. Harrison St. Glassport, PA 15045 1,047 1,035 Jeanne Drabik 1716 Terrace St. Braddock, PA 15104-3049 Jennifer Behm 2642 Mount Morris Rd. Waynesburg, PA 15370-2262 1,048 Jennifer Bentzel 33 Lindsay Ln. Hanover, PA 17331-8303 1,049 Jennifer Boyd 1635 Fort Washington Ave. Ambler, PA 19002-3046 1,050 Jennifer Davidson 1038 Welfer St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2651 1,051 Jennifer Lowans 219 Wilkson Ln. Fayetteville, PA 17222-1141 1,052 Jennifer Moss 808 Long Ridge Rd. Hawley, PA 18428-4200 1,053 Jennifer Rittenhouse 723 George St. Lancaster, PA 17603-5160 1,036 Jeanne Passarelli 404 Branch Dr. Apollo, PA 15613-4002 1,037 Jed Fetterman 309 Nursery Rd. Penn Run, PA 15765-7203 1,038 Jeff Munchak 5 Spruce Rd. Chalfont, PA 18914-4022 1,039 Jeff Otte 814 Pennwood Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15235-4337 1,040 Jeff Schmidt 55 Greening Life Ln. Shermans Dale, PA 170908834 1,041 Jeffrey Jenne 45 E. Penn St. Philadelphia, PA 19144-2346 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 45 Number 1,054 Commentator Jennifer Schnakenberg 1604 Denniston St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1458 Number 1,065 Commentator Jill Baer 105 S Prospect St. Nanticoke, PA 18634-2321 1,055 Jennifer Shane 9 Violet Dr. Hatfield, PA 19440-4032 1,066 Jill Goodwin P.O. Box 278 Delaware Water Gap, PA 18327-0278 1,056 Jennifer Tharp 420 N. Taylor Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15212-4523 1,067 Jim Gergat 1689 S. Main St. Bechtelsville, PA 19505-9449 1,068 Jim Mccauley 1710 Riverside Dr. Williamsport, PA 17702-7056 1,057 Jennifer Zielinski 6 Farmington Way New Providence, PA 175609430 1,058 Jerry Kalinoski 412 Weidman St. Lebanon, PA 17046-3649 1,069 Jim Parker 6783 Van Camp Rd. Fairview, PA 16415-2914 1,059 Jess Gonzalez 300 Highland Dr. Brownsville, PA 15417-9360 1,070 Jim Salom 4309 Lauriston St. Philadelphia, PA 19128-4939 1,060 Jesse & David Krempasky 104 Ashbury Dr. South Abington Twp., PA 18411-8892 1,071 Jim Staszewski 315 Old Chapel Trl. Pittsburgh, PA 15238-1255 1,072 1,061 Jesse Siegel 300 N. Washington St ., # 2478 Gettysburg, PA 17325-1400 Jim Szczecina 128 E. White Bear Dr. Summit Hill, PA 18250-1717 1,073 Jessica Gamble 2628 Livingston St. Philadelphia, PA 19125-3814 Jim Thompson Jr. 1766 Ninevah Rd. Knox, PA 16232-6328 1,074 Jessica Morrison 393 Primrose Ln. Mountville, PA 17554-1249 Joan Beregi 544 Chester Ave. Phoenixville, PA 19460-4355 1,075 Jessica Sitko 128 Beth Ellen Dr. Lewisburg, PA 17837-7087 Joan Bromley 2545 Cumberland Ave. Reading, PA 19606-2109 1,076 Joan Bucheli 20 N. 9th St. Coplay, PA 18037-1526 1,062 1,063 1,064 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 46 Number 1,077 Commentator Joann Miehl 1347 Foose Ridge Rd. Elliottsburg, PA 17024-9238 1,078 Joanna Woomer 6771 Tyrone Pike Tyrone, PA 16686-7828 1,079 1,080 1,081 1,082 1,083 1,084 1,085 1,086 1,087 1,088 Number 1,089 Commentator Joe Wehrle P.O. Box 41 Punxsutawney, PA 157670041 1,090 Joanne Hangen 801 Lakeview Dr. Lancaster, PA 17601-6605 Joel Destefano 111 Macdade Blvd., Apt. E010 Folsom, PA 19033-2907 1,091 Joanne Lightner 104 White Gate Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15238-2622 John & Anne Judson 512 Bridgeview Dr. Lemoyne, PA 17043-1379 1,092 Joanne Sharpless 6017 Greene St. Philadelphia, PA 19144-2725 John & Helena Rudiak 219 Hornaday Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15210-4221 1,093 Joe Baylog 650 Paxinosa Rd. E. Easton, PA 18040-1375 John and Janice Hahn 159 W. Shore Rd. Shohola, PA 18458-2245 1,094 Joe Befumo 388 Great Bend Tpke. Pleasant Mount, PA 184534580 John Cairns 704 Erlen Rd. Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462-2429 1,095 Joe Clarke 4813 Walton Ave. Fl. 3 Philadelphia, PA 19143-2018 John Digiandomenico 509 S. 10th St. Sharpsville, PA 16150-1858 1,096 Joe Clifford 5344 James St. Philadelphia, PA 19137-1806 John Ellenberger 325 Morel Ln. Ligonier, PA 15658-2684 1,097 Joe Cover 525 E. Butler Pike Ambler, PA 19002 John Freas 1696 Southlawn Dr. Lancaster, PA 17603-4571 1,098 John Hallenburg 50 Riverside Dr. North East, PA 16428-3446 1,099 John Hamill 1424 Porter St. Conway, PA 15027-1334 Joe Leone 654 Huntington Dr. Cranberry Twp., PA 160666842 Joe O'Toole 333 Anderson Ave. Indiana, PA 15701-2024 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 47 Number 1,100 Commentator John Harvey 36 N. 8th St. Lebanon, PA 17046-5029 Number 1,112 Commentator John Sucha 112 Tillotson Cir. Mcknight, PA 15237-3317 1,101 John Hertzler Jr. 1232 High St. Lancaster, PA 17603-6818 1,113 John Sultzbaugh 261 Romberger Rd. Elizabethville, PA 170238755 1,102 John Hopper 1885 E. Beau St. Washington, PA 15301-3187 1,114 John Swanson 48 Elk St. Albion, PA 16401-1235 John Imsenik 174 Houck Rd. Fleetwood, PA 19522-8923 1,115 John Thomas 405 Rodman Ave. Jenkintown, PA 19046-2118 John Lazar 425 E. Abbott St. Lansford, PA 18232-2202 1,116 John Walker 4407 List Rd. Red Lion, PA 17356-8159 John Leonard 142 Grandview Ave., # B Monaca, PA 15061-2433 1,117 John Young 5 Park Lane Pocono Manor, PA 18349 John Lindberg 186 Meadow St. Meadville, PA 16335-1201 1,118 Jon Piersol 2519 Lindenwood Dr. Wexford, PA 15090-7914 John Linkes 431 2nd St. Leechburg, PA 15656-1151 1,119 Jonathan Tittler 2301 Cherry St., Apt 9G Philadelphia, PA 19103-1042 1,120 Jonathan Williams P.O. Box 124 Bendersville, PA 17306-0124 1,121 Jordan Howells 318 16th Ave. Scranton, PA 18504-2331 1,122 Joseph Candela 173 Lake Meade Dr. East Berlin, PA 17316-9388 1,123 Joseph Clark 102 Tradition Ln. Downingtown, PA 193351318 1,103 1,104 1,105 1,106 1,107 1,108 1,109 John Lysak 553 S. Main St. Cambridge Springs, PA 16403-1141 John Mcdermott 1001 Evergreen Rd. State College, PA 168016835 1,110 John O'Neill 207 S. Webster Ave. Scranton, PA 18505-1482 1,111 John Stephens, Jr. P.O. Box 681 Bloomsburg, PA 17815-0681 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 48 Number 1,124 Commentator Joseph Dunleavy 1901 S. Route 44 Hwy. Jersey Shore, PA 17740-8056 Number 1,136 Commentator Judith Bohler 220 Meadowlark Dr. Ephrata, PA 17522-9625 1,125 Joseph Polansky 2119 Comegys Ave. Scranton, PA 18509-1360 1,137 Judith Coe 210 Church Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2728 1,126 Joseph Saporito 209 Spring St. Moosic, PA 18507-1139 1,138 Judith Gallagher 128 Ober Rd. Stahlstown, PA 15687-1261 1,127 Joseph Veghts 131 Sky Top Rd. Acme, PA 15610-1209 1,139 Judith Hendin P.O. Box 1449 Easton, PA 18044-1449 1,128 Joseph Watkins 16 Grace St. Crafton, PA 15205-2909 1,140 Judith Rettich 2376 Henbird Ln. Lancaster, PA 17601-2830 1,129 Joseph Weinlick 313 E. Main St. Lititz, PA 17543-2013 1,141 Judith Ryan 27 State Route 184 Trout Run, PA 17771-8309 1,130 Josephine Evans 420 Parkview Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15243-1910 1,142 Judith Watson 505 Heise Run Rd. Wellsboro, PA 16901-7881 1,131 Joshua Bickford 1201 Brandywine St., # 34 Philadelphia, PA 19123-3337 1,143 Judy Lofton 4118 Serenity St. Schwenksville, PA 194732062 1,132 Joshua Martin 139 Reibers Church Rd. Shermans Dale, PA 170908867 1,144 Judy Tiberi 235 Klein Rd. Glenshaw, PA 15116-3015 1,145 Julia Powers 211 Willow Valley Sq., Apt. E-213 Lancaster, PA 17602-4861 1,133 Joyce Gilmore 27 Garman Rd. Kutztown, PA 19530-8625 1,134 Joyce Vandersloot 1120 W. Poplar St. York, PA 17404-3517 1,146 Julie Fegley 2701 Beech St. Hatfield, PA 19440-2304 Judith Bibinger 180 Douglas Ln. Kunkletown, PA 18058-3104 1,147 Julie Schampel 1017 Glenn Ave. Mckeesport, PA 15133-2806 1,135 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 49 Number 1,148 Commentator Julius Iwantsch 5610 N. Halbea St. Bethlehem, PA 18017-9293 1,149 June and Charles Dunn 407 S. Miller St. Shillington, PA 19607-3201 1,150 Justin Malick 3609 Sequoia Dr. East Stroudsburg, PA 183029024 Number 1,160 Commentator Karen Rudy 206 10th St. New Cumberland, PA 170701613 1,161 Karen Wolfgang 394 Pigeon Hill Rd. Galeton, PA 16922-9601 1,162 Karol Judy 187 Fernwood Dr. Clinton, PA 15026-1588 1,151 K. Danowski 15 Bower Hill Rd., Apt. 801 Pittsburgh, PA 15228-1437 1,163 Karol Roman 2170 State Line Rd. Brackney, PA 18812-8183 1,152 K. Maffei 4312 Springhouse Ln. Aston, PA 19014-2251 1,164 Karrin Herring 205 Wykes St. Aliquippa, PA 15001-3154 1,153 Kaarin Clark 325 N. Craig St., Apt. 305 Pittsburgh, PA 15213-1219 1,165 Karyn Delaney 135 Green Forest Dr. Baden, PA 15005-9640 1,154 Kai Shaikh 210 Sunridge Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15238-2634 1,166 Kate Frey 2014 Greenbriar Ct. Collegeville, PA 19426-3244 1,155 Kara Puskaric 1120 Monongahela Blvd. White Oak, PA 15131-1524 1,167 Kate Nichols 512 Col. John Kelly Rd. Lewisburg, PA 17837-6355 1,156 Karen Corbett 3941 Route 322 Brookville, PA 15825-3769 1,168 Kathleen Brennan 1542 Asbury Pl. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1444 1,157 Karen Holliman 21 Fox Chase Dr. Hershey, PA 17033-9700 1,169 Kathleen Butler Susan Ave. Croydon, PA 19021 1,158 Karen Mccloskey 180 Bell Ln. Woodland, PA 16881-9347 1,170 Kathleen Gallagher 45 El Camino Rd. Hazleton, PA 18201-7513 1,159 Karen Mcloskey 614 S. Taney St. Philadelphia, PA 19146-2306 1,171 Kathleen Gualtieri 4 Providence Rd. Morton, PA 19070-1134 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 50 Number 1,172 Commentator Kathleen Lockwood 551 Thomas St. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-2104 1,173 Kathleen Rueppel 515 Macarthur St. Mc Kees Rocks, PA 151362007 Number 1,183 Commentator Kathy Stair 3914 Church Rd. Mountain Top, PA 187079039 1,184 Kathy Stewart 6510 Union Deposit Rd. Harrisburg, PA 17111-4805 1,174 Kathryn Ellis 1525 W. Trindle Rd. Carlisle, PA 17015-9760 1,185 Kay Reinfried 797 Scott Ln. Lititz, PA 17543-8868 1,175 Kathryn Mason 7324 Passyunk Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19142-1544 1,186 K. .C Carney S. Evaline St. Pittsburgh, PA 15224 1,176 Kathy Carr 266 Cannel Mine Rd. New Bethlehem, PA 162427708 1,187 Keeley Grant 4112 Beechwood Ln. Harrisburg, PA 17112-2840 1,188 Keith Hileman 11484 E. Reidsburg Rd. Clarion, PA 16214-4446 1,177 Kathy Connors 96 Hellberg Ave. Chalfont, PA 18914-2713 1,189 1,178 Kathy Dinsmore 214 Jenks Ave. Punxsutawney, PA 157671504 Keith Portka 201 Allegheny Ave. Cheswick, PA 15024-1603 1,190 Kathy Erndl 1018 Hastie Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15234-1112 Kelli Cavanaugh 311 W. Wildey St. Philadelphia, PA 19123-2224 1,191 Kathy Robb 1006 Lincoln Heights Ave. Ephrata, PA 17522-1544 Kelli Fizzano 4306 Meadowridge Ln. Collegeville, PA 19426-4194 1,192 Kathy Shellington Stoica 540 Elm St. Leesport, PA 19533-9500 Kelly King 306 S. Diamond St. Mt. Pleasant, PA 15666-2408 1,193 Kathy Stack 303 W. Miller Ave. Munhall, PA 15120-3143 Kelly Rogers 220 N. Cornwall Rd. E. Cornwall, PA 17016 1,194 Ken & Deborah Ely P.O. Box 95 Brooklyn, PA 18813-0095 1,179 1,180 1,181 1,182 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 51 Number 1,195 Commentator Ken Bolden 358 S Winebiddle St. Pittsburgh, PA 15224-2227 Number 1,207 Commentator Kimberly Klein 1401 Mission Rd. Lancaster, PA 17601-5237 1,196 Kenneth Ayre 224 Sunnybrook Dr. Saylorsburg, PA 18353-8379 1,208 Kimberly Mcconnell 1210 S. Negley Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1219 1,197 Kenneth Bickel 1201 Michael Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15227-3921 1,209 Kimberly Mekeal 112 Hidden Ln. Punxsutawney, PA 157673372 1,198 Kenneth Mayer 523 Crest Cir. Mohnton, PA 19540-1417 1,210 Kimberly Tucker 617 S. Mountain Rd. Dillsburg, PA 17019-9448 Kenneth Wieland 50 Woodland Dr. Lansdale, PA 19446-2827 1,211 Kirk Frink 2044 Valentine Run Rd. Russell, PA 16345-3018 Kent Vendrick 146 Rocky Glen Rd. Oxford, PA 19363-2246 1,212 Kirsten Wert 159 Church Hill Rd. Lenhartsville, PA 19534-9318 Kevin Gosztonyi 11 W. 4th St. Bethlehem, PA 18015-1666 1,213 Krissy Kasserman 126 Nedrow Ln. Somerset, PA 15501-5457 Kim Corle 3935 Pine Hollow Rd. Claysburg, PA 16625-8255 1,214 Kristen Coyle 1508 Society Pl. Newtown, PA 18940-3224 Kim Mcclure 704 Skyline Dr. Lancaster, PA 17601-4442 1,215 Kristen Toole 109 Market St. Enola, PA 17025-3228 Kim Springer 6145 Wise Rd. Hermitage, PA 16148-7103 1,216 Kristin Sewak 4265 Mount Carmel Dr. Windber, PA 15963-3101 Kimberly Clemens 439 S. Wyomissing Ave. Shillington, PA 19607-3265 1,217 Kristine Gannon 1590 Shadyside Rd. West Chester, PA 193801567 1,218 Kyle Rennell 219 1/2 W. High St., Apt. 2 Bellefonte, PA 16823-1346 1,199 1,200 1,201 1,202 1,203 1,204 1,205 1,206 Kimberly Heston 1210 Country Oak Dr. Wexford, PA 15090-8765 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 52 Number 1,219 Commentator L. Boone 1493 Blue Course Dr. State College, PA 168012779 1,220 Lance Bogash 4 Wendy Ln. Glen Mills, PA 19342-1122 Number 1,231 Commentator Laura Manz P.O. Box 361 Ingomar, PA 15127-0361 1,232 Laura Russell 205 W. Market St. Pottsville, PA 17901-2918 1,233 Laureen Farr 304 Poplar St. Towanda, PA 18848-1117 1,234 Laurel Person Mecca 2765 Mount Royal Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2547 1,235 Lauren Gantz 1990 County Line Rd. York Springs, PA 173729741 1,221 Lani Fritz 106 Magnolia Dr. Beaver, PA 15009-1024 1,222 Larissa Gula 424 Coolidge Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15228-1236 1,223 Larry and Sharon Haffey 177 E Bacon St. Pottsville, PA 17901-3903 1,224 Larry Falcone 6843 Jewel Ln. Macungie, PA 18062-8025 1,236 Lauren Mccracken 185 Conchester Rd. Glen Mills, PA 19342-1565 1,225 Larry Hamil 530 N. Main St., Apt. 307 Butler, PA 16001-4319 1,237 Laurie Cassidy 2300 Adams Ave. Scranton, PA 18509-1514 1,226 Larry Holman 6746 Souder St. Philadelphia, PA 19149-2208 1,238 Lavern Johnson 1439 Old Stagecoach Rd. Wyalusing, PA 18853-7996 1,227 Larry Moyer 370 W. Johnson St., Apt. C1 Philadelphia, PA 19144-3119 1,239 Lawrence Borowiec 3629 Baxter Dr. New Kensington, PA 150689407 1,228 Larry Sydow 464 W. 7th St. Erie, PA 16502-1329 1,240 Lawrence Ratti 190 Flaugherty Run Rd. Coraopolis, PA 15108-9790 Laura Fake 443 W. High St. Womelsdorf, PA 19567-1413 1,241 Lee Bible 155 Cherry Ln. Abbottstown, PA 17301-9065 Laura Horowitz 6544 Darlington Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1840 1,242 Lee Maloy 106 Claremont Dr. Lansdale, PA 19446-6359 1,229 1,230 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 53 Number 1,243 Commentator Lee West 3611 Mexico St. Pittsburgh, PA 15212-1814 Number 1,255 Commentator Linda Borell 339 Main St., Apt. 4 Royersford, PA 19468-2321 1,244 Leeann Mclaughlin 113 Saybrook Hbr. Bradfordwoods, PA 150151319 1,256 Linda Fetrow 242 Marietta Ave. Mount Joy, PA 17552-3128 1,257 Linda Frederick 1422 Parkland Rd. Coopersburg, PA 18036-9057 1,258 Linda Gordon 1111 Randolph Dr. Yardley, PA 19067-4359 1,259 Linda Huber 85 Packing House Rd. Hanover, PA 17331-7989 1,260 Linda Koenigsberg 2214 Delancey Pl. Philadelphia, PA 19103-6502 1,261 Linda Neumann 239 Parker St. Pittsburgh, PA 15223-1614 1,262 Linda Orr 879 Hunter Rd. Knoxville, PA 16928-9477 1,245 Lena Sirmans 1705 Brookstone Dr. Alburtis, PA 18011-2716 1,246 Leo Deluca 247 Morris Rd. Friedens, PA 15541-7919 1,247 Leo Kucewicz 201 Black Walnut Dr. Phoenixville, PA 19460-4856 1,248 Leonard Clark 128 Weldy Ave. Oreland, PA 19075-1244 1,249 Leonard Douglass 923 Beaver St. Clairton, PA 15025-1307 1,250 Leonard Finegold 206 Dogwood Ln. Wallingford, PA 19086-6006 1,263 1,251 Leslie & Marilyn Sandler 1171 Draymore Ct. Hummelstown, PA 170369018 Linda Peduzzi 354 Patriot Ln. Freedom, PA 15042-2678 1,264 Liana Lloyd 111 Endress Dr. Zelienople, PA 16063-1408 Linda Roach 303 Plouse Ln. Sayre, PA 18840-9271 1,265 Linda Sieber 385 Dark Hollow Rd. Shermans Dale, PA 170908205 1,266 Ling Vargas 536 Pershing Ave. Lancaster, PA 17602-4370 1,252 1,253 Linda Baj 4314 M St. Philadelphia, PA 19124-4330 1,254 Linda Bianchini 238 N. Keswick Ave., # A Glenside, PA 19038-4804 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 54 Number 1,267 Commentator Lisa Augustine 352 Bodle Rd. Wyoming, PA 18644-6016 Number 1,279 Commentator Lora Keeley 3 Old Post Rd. Landenberg, PA 19350-9654 1,268 Lisa Beatty 13 Patricia Dr. Enola, PA 17025-1933 1,280 Lorenzo Varisano 100 William Rd. Millerstown, PA 17062-9429 1,269 Lisa Chassey 124 Jasper Ct. Norristown, PA 19403-4311 1,281 Lori Bae 186 Hummingbird Trl. Bushkill, PA 18324-8113 1,270 Lisa Edwards 7333 Schoyer Ave., # 1 Pittsburgh, PA 15218-2335 1,282 Lori Burris 405 Lee Ct. York, PA 17406-2363 1,271 Lisa Friedland 7831 Mill Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2745 1,283 Lori Lydic 2227 McAleer Rd. Sewickley, PA 15143-8668 1,272 Lisa Grandstaff 8680 Winchester Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-5746 1,284 Lori Shermer 7 Pine Rd. Mount Holly Springs, PA 17065-1933 1,273 Lisa Miller 3158 Fairway Ave. Bristol, PA 19007-1804 1,285 Lori Stover 2232 S Galen Hall Rd. Reinholds, PA 17569-9086 Lisa Miller 54 Jaycee Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15243-1306 1,286 Lorraine Czerniak 419 Springside Dr. E., Apt. 1 Reading, PA 19607-1045 1,287 Lou Hoffman 311 Baker Dr. Lincoln University, PA 19352-9399 1,288 Louis Easton 414 Chatham Park Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15220-2222 1,274 1,275 1,276 Lisa Millhous 113 Snyder Ave. West Chester, PA 193824919 Llew Taylor P.O. Box 32 703 Market Street, Apt. 3 Darlington, PA 16115-0032 1,277 Lloyd Turpin 117 Wentz St. Philadelphia, PA 19120-2435 1,289 Louis Ferretti 250 Shirley Ln. Norristown, PA 19403-3140 1,278 Lois Peddicord 369 Princeton Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15235-4840 1,290 Louis Levi 1215 S Ogontz St. York, PA 17403-3355 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 55 Number 1,291 Commentator Louis Mariani 403 Virginia Ave. Whitehall, PA 18052-7706 Number 1,303 Commentator Lynne Hurd 106 Fair Ave. Hanover, PA 17331-3343 1,292 Louis Martin 32 Clover Ln. Palmyra, PA 17078-3013 1,304 M. Everhart 7 Lakeside Dr. New Providence, PA 175609698 1,293 Louise, DE Simone P.O. Box 58 Damascus, PA 18415-0058 1,305 M. Mehalick 420 Robin Hill Rd. Wayne, PA 1907-2330 Lucinda Slotcavage 20 E Mohler Church Rd. Ephrata, PA 17522-9222 1,306 Madeline Mcgeeney 311 Jefferson Ct. Limerick, PA 19468-3467 Lucy Latham 1107 Manheim Pike Lancaster, PA 17601-3119 1,307 Mafe Garcia 1459 Drake Ln. Lancaster, PA 17601-4595 Lurena Falcone 123 Ed Christine Dr. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-1463 1,308 Malcolm Norton 59 Heller Ln. Berwick, PA 18603-5032 1,309 Mallory Bachman 394 Oak Rd. Chicora, PA 16025-3114 1,310 Mandy Alden 20609 Teepleville Flats Rd. Cambridg Springs, PA 164037157 1,294 1,295 1,296 1,297 Lyn Pipenberg 400 Park Ln. State College, PA 168031438 1,298 Lynda Kolesar 1022 Harvard Rd. Monroeville, PA 15146-4305 1,299 Lynn Benson 73 Dewey St., Fl. 2 Pittsburgh, PA 15223-1744 1,311 Manfred Kodila 449 Atlantic Ave. York, PA 17404-2606 Lynn Glorieux 420 Lockhart St. Pittsburgh, PA 15212-5511 1,312 Mara Smith 48 N. Pine St. Port Allegany, PA 167431239 1,313 Marc Marchioli 2617 Grandview Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15235-2708 1,300 1,301 Lynn Maust Houston, PA 15342 1,302 Lynn Ritter 3732 Park Ave. Neffs, PA 18065-7703 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 56 Number 1,314 Commentator Marci Henzi 2712 Middletown Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15205-2307 Number 1,326 Commentator Margaret Henry 606 Columbiana Rd. Bessemer, PA 16112-2204 1,315 Marcia Eddy 27 Garman Rd. Kutztown, PA 19530-8625 1,327 Margie Sentiwany 207 Bosler Ave. Lemoyne, PA 17043-1928 1,316 Marcia Godich 115 Belleauwood Blvd. Trafford, PA 15085-1222 1,328 Maria Miller 1678 Red Mill Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15241-2826 1,317 Marcia Lehman 998 Mayfield Ave. Ambridge, PA 15003-1484 1,329 Marian Beaudoin 2431 Myers Ln. N. Huntingdon, PA 156422175 1,318 Marcia Webber 7811 Park Ave. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2615 1,330 Marianna Sokol 1317 Elk Grove Rd. Benton, PA 17814-7403 Marcia Williams 770 Roger Rd. Warminster, PA 18974-2541 1,331 Maricarmen Colon 806 Montgomery Ave., Apt. D10 Bryn Mawr, PA 19010-3345 1,332 Mariita Vera 7822 Summerdale Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19111-3538 1,333 Marilyn Bennett 35 Old Union Rd. Equinunk, PA 18417-3341 1,334 Margaret Collins 224 N. Hyde Park Ave. Scranton, PA 18504-3390 Marilyn Costa 963 Old State Rd. Clarks Summit, PA 184119431 1,335 Margaret DeArdo 1311 Fairstead Ln. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2585 Marilyn Jane Rimmer 180 Bunny Ln. Palmyra, PA 17078-8800 1,336 Marion O'Donnell 1864 Upper Smith Gap Rd. Saylorsburg, PA 18353-7303 1,319 1,320 1,321 1,322 1,323 1,324 1,325 Marcie Fleming 2423 Columbia Ave. Harrisburg, PA 17109-6053 Marcus Sellers 5259 Trout Run Ln. Spruce Creek, PA 166831613 Margaret Beitzel 211 N. Barbara St. Mount Joy, PA 17552-1405 Margaret Goodman 51 Broomall Ln. Glen Mills, PA 19342-1734 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 57 Number 1,337 Commentator Mark and Nancy Wolfe 222 Maxwell St. Pittsburgh, PA 15205-2031 Number 1,349 Commentator Martin Mcsweeny 359 S. Pacific Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15224-2350 1,338 Mark Coleman 201 Wilcrest Rd. Roaring Brook Twp., PA 18444-7789 1,350 Mary & Brian Macwhinney 5435 Aylesboro Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1121 1,351 Mary Ann Pastore 550 Innsbruck Dr. Lehighton, PA 18235-8947 1,352 Mary Crozier P.O. Box 237 Akron, PA 17501-0237 1,353 Mary Durando 523 Chesterville Rd. Landenberg, PA 19350-1575 1,339 Mark Fabian 30 Pearl Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15227-2329 1,340 Mark Filetti 109 S. Thomas St. Bellefonte, PA 16823-1245 1,341 Mark Heuer 26 Fairway Dr. Selinsgrove, PA 17870-9103 1,354 1,342 Mark Lichty 188 Winchester Dr. East Stroudsburg, PA 183018134 Mary Eichman 25 Division St. Kingston, PA 18704-3607 1,355 Mark Mendenhall 4926 Osage Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-1609 Mary Green RR 1, Box 1304 Carbondale, PA 18407 1,356 Marlene Knight 790 Tubach Pond Rd. Wyalusing, PA 18853-8398 Mary Hansen 401 Antler Ln. Tobyhanna, PA 18466-9066 1,357 Marshall Conklin 31 Linnet Ln. Lock Haven, PA 17745-1639 Mary Helmetsie 1117 E. End Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15218-1307 1,358 Martha Abell 390 Pleasant St. Rome, PA 18837-8424 Mary Jo Bayer 1089 Lester Rd. Montrose, PA 18801-8779 1,359 Mary Jo Brinker 161 Leonhardt Ln. Ellwood City, PA 161177759 1,360 Mary Jo Searfoss 63 Parnell St. Pittston Township, PA 186403341 1,343 1,344 1,345 1,346 1,347 Martha Direnzo 1715 Boundary St. Aliquippa, PA 15001-3042 1,348 Martha Gilliland 101 Ableview Dr., Apt. 5 Butler, PA 16001-8803 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 58 Number 1,361 Commentator Mary Jo Valletta 102 Vincent Dr. Verona, PA 15147-3214 Number 1,373 Commentator Maryellen Adams 1400 Queen St., Apt. 6 Pottstown, PA 19464-5025 1,362 Mary Lenox 3856 Henley Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15235-5041 1,374 Mason McMonegal 602 Pictwood Dr. Glenshaw, PA 15116-1518 1,363 Mary Lou Kleinbach 31 Sally Ann Furnace Rd. Mertztown, PA 19539-9200 1,375 Matt Nicholas 534 W Springfield Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19118-4124 1,364 Mary Lou Munn 663 Exeter Ct. State College, PA 168031368 1,376 Matthew Carlson 525 Kemmerer Rd. State College, PA 168016410 1,365 Mary Lou Valenti 409 Lackawanna Ave. Scranton, PA 18503-2062 1,377 Maureen Devalia 916 E Baltimore Ave., Apt. A Lansdowne, PA 19050-2702 1,366 Mary Mullen 422 Neyhart Rd. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-8101 1,378 Maureen LaNoce 593 Wigard Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19128-3131 1,367 Mary Norcross P.O. Box 69 Mifflinburg, PA 17844-0069 1,379 Max Prejean 506 Nauvoo Rd. Lewisberry, PA 17339-9322 1,368 Mary Ryan 2318 Tague Ave. Glenside, PA 19038-4306 1,380 Melanie Bowser 264 Ridge Rd. Worthington, PA 16262-5020 1,369 Mary Schneider 3 Tioga St. Elysburg, PA 17824-7193 1,381 Melinda Kokus P.O. Box 133 Harborcreek, PA 16421-0133 1,370 MaryAnn Barrett 627 Coleman St. Easton, PA 18042-1403 1,382 Melinda Richards 1177 Macpherson Dr. West Chester, PA 193803813 1,371 Maryann Cherubini 93 7 Stars Rd. Spring City, PA 19475-2207 1,383 Melissa Evans 103 Kemmerer Ave. Factoryville, PA 18419-2420 Maryann Henninger 206 Greshville Rd. Boyertown, PA 19512-8487 1,384 Melissa Hunt 611 W. Chestnut St., Apt. 2 Lancaster, PA 17603-3410 1,372 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 59 Number 1,385 Commentator Melissa Katterson P.O. Box 253 South Heights, PA 150810253 1,386 Melissa Kraus 667 Fryer Rd. Summerville, PA 15864-3913 Number 1,397 Commentator Michael Genz 214 Fairway Dr. Edinboro, PA 16412-2442 1,398 Michael Guttman 14 Nine Gates Rd. Chadds Ford, PA 19317-9258 1,399 Michael Heller 30 E. Jefferson St. Media, PA 19063-3760 1,400 Michael Keith 1 Linden Cir. Lincoln Univ, PA 193528933 1,387 Memphis Diaz 767 S. 7th St. Philadelphia, PA 19147-2938 1,388 Mesfin Birke 3702 Walnut Ridge Est. Pottstown, PA 19464-3031 1,389 Michael Bertonaschi 6404 Ten Point Cir. Trafford, PA 15085-2314 1,401 Michael Kirchner 5959 Jacobs Ave. Harrisburg, PA 17112-1204 1,390 Michael Bresnahan 310 N. High St. West Chester, PA 193802614 1,402 Michael Koloshinsky 455 Marguerite Rd. Latrobe, PA 15650-5165 1,403 1,391 Michael Compton 2420 2nd Ave. Altoona, PA 16602-3302 Michael Kugler 217 Palmer St. Easton, PA 18042-7238 1,404 1,392 Michael D'Amico 114 Poplar Ln. Kunkletown, PA 18058-7913 Michael LaMark 476 Milbeth Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15228-2631 1,405 1,393 Michael Davin 12439 Roth Dr. Irwin, PA 15642-2957 Michael Lawrence 10 Saxony Dr. Harrison City, PA 156361507 1,394 Michael Dura 1337 E. Oxford St. Philadelphia, PA 19125-3216 1,406 Michael Livermore 10 N. Market St. Muncy, PA 17756-1025 1,395 Michael Fair 1201 Fairfield Station Rd. Fairfield, PA 17320-9762 1,407 Michael McQuown 5218 Laurens St. Philadelphia, PA 19144-4604 1,396 Michael Foreman 80 Quarry Rd., Trlr. 29 Kutztown, PA 19530-9633 1,408 Michael Prozonic 474 Johnston Dr. Bethlehem, PA 18017-1815 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 60 Number 1,409 Commentator Michael Rosenberger 2343 Frostburgh Rd. Punxsutawney, PA 157676435 1,410 Michael Schmotzer 751 Hillcrest Rd. York, PA 17403-4111 1,411 Michael Sinclair 1101 Flexer Ave. Allentown, PA 18103-5445 1,412 Michael Solomon Ii 3900 Rauch St. Harrisburg, PA 17109 1,413 Michael Soso 409 Todd St. Pittsburgh, PA 15221-3334 1,414 Michael Spirnak 360 Lawn St. Pittsburgh, PA 15213-4241 Number 1,421 Commentator Michelle Dunn 316 S. 9th St. Akron, PA 17501-1432 1,422 Michelle Gasperine 500 S. 20th St., #3 Philadelphia, PA 19146-1302 1,423 Michelle Huntley 816 Broadway Bethlehem, PA 18015-2731 1,424 Michelle Pepitone 123 Derwent Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-4079 1,425 Michelle Schramm 160 Pocono Trailer Park Plains, PA 18705 1,426 Mickey Gniadek 20 Cardox Rd. Finleyville, PA 15332-9608 1,427 Mike Turksma 116 Windermere Ave., #Bs-2 Wayne,, PA 19087-4141 1,428 Mike Weaver 107 Haire Ave. Lewisburg, PA 17837-9204 1,429 Mikey Chernega 1039 Oak Ridge Ave. State College, PA 168016906 1,415 Michael Swanson 1121 W. Clay St. Lancaster, PA 17603-2611 1,416 Michael Tierney 624 Summit Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19128-2981 1,417 Michael Weisensee 3706 Hempland Rd. Mountville, PA 17554-1542 1,418 Michele Barbin P.O. Box 142 Snow Shoe, PA 16874-0142 1,430 Mikki Weldman 213 Waterford Way Lebanon, PA 17042-4156 1,419 Michele Conkel 217 Queensberry Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-3333 1,431 Mila Pilz 275 Robin Dale Dr. Leola, PA 17540-1634 1,420 Michelle Alvare 134 Hastings Ave. Havertown, PA 19083-2430 1,432 Mindi Beach 107 Maple Ave.Hatboro, 19040-1507 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 61 Number 1,433 Commentator Miriam Garey 7 S Los Robles Ct. Reading, PA 19606-1541 Number 1,444 Commentator Nancy Latimer 907 Irwin Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-2328 1,434 Mitchell Price 17283 S. Mosiertown Rd. Saegertown, PA 16433-3735 1,445 Nancy Shappell 5449, DE Pues Rd. Bangor, PA 18013-4807 1,435 Molly Maroney 306 Valley View Dr., N. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-8613 1,446 Nancy Walker 270 Barneston Rd. Honey Brook, PA 193449505 1,436 Moomay Piola 58 Bald Cypress Ln. Levittown, PA 19054-2802 1,447 Nancy Wheeler 300 Skyline Dr. Reading, PA 19606-8504 1,448 Nancy Yauger 144 Plum St. Greenville, PA 16125-1768 1,449 Nancy Zimmerman 7470 Henry St. Erie, PA 16509-4550 1,450 Natasha Ufema 844 E Walnut St. Lewistown, PA 17044-2821 1,451 Nathan Sullenberger 185 Winfield Cir. Greensburg, PA 15601-6754 1,452 Nathan Van Velson 410 Alden Dr. Lancaster, PA 17601-4987 1,453 Neal Bracken 2207 Mulberry Ct. Lansdale, PA 19446-4326 1,454 Neal Wooduff 201 Lakeside Dr. Lewisburg, PA 17837-9334 1,455 Neil Erkert 209 Ridge Ave. Perkasie, PA 18944-1125 1,437 Mr. & Mrs. Andrew Pollak 8669 Delaware Ave. North Huntingdon, PA 15642-3280 1,438 Murray Varrese Terwood Road huntindon valley, PA 190065522 1,439 Nadia Knoblock 716 Shadycrest Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15216-3014 1,440 Nancy Avolese 1451 N. Union St. Middletown, PA 17057-3045 1,441 Nancy Chapman 823 Eshelman Dr. Akron, PA 17501-1485 1,442 1,443 Nancy Cohn 100 Shawnee Rd. Ardmore, PA 19003-1629 Nancy Ehmann 81 Bellview Cir. Mc Kees Rocks, PA 151361106 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 62 Number 1,456 Commentator Nelson Robison 754 E. Main St. Reynoldsville, PA 158511602 1,457 Nezka Pfeifer 303 Lakewood Mnr. Scranton, PA 18505-2349 Number 1,467 Commentator Oliver Neith 705 Concord Rd. Nazareth, PA 18064-8952 1,468 Olivia Hecksher 104 Briaridge Dr., Apt. M Turtle Creek, PA 15145-1170 1,469 Ophelia Dixon 7912 Newmeyer St. Pittsburgh, PA 15218-1828 1,458 Nic Hammer 10 Treasure Lk. Dubois, PA 15801-9001 1,470 1,459 Nicholas Disanti 1010 Dunvegan Rd. West Chester, PA 193827102 Pam Macwell 1228 Arkansas Ave. Pittsburgh, PA 15216-2604 1,471 Nicholas Lucarelli 716 Stonehaven Dr. Greensburg, PA 15601-8400 Pamela Breneman 5 Oak Dr. Wernersville, PA 19565-9775 1,472 Pamela Cohen 2401 Pennsylvania Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19130-3010 1,473 Pamela Oriszko 210 Hoenig Rd. Sewickley, PA 15143-9671 Niels Finsen Vailtown Rd. Liberty, PA 16930-9257 1,474 Pat Currie 1394 Windmill Ln. Breinigsville, PA 18031-1173 Niki Miller 31 Cannon Ln. Fleetwood, PA 19522-8318 1,475 Pat Davis 7 Pearl St. Wellsboro, PA 16901-1509 Noemi Miller 4529 Aubrey Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19114-3747 1,476 Pat Dengel 1062 Trail Rd. Hummelstown, PA 170367436 1,477 Pat Eiserer 78 Sun Ln. Millersville, PA 17551-9774 1,478 Pat Lupo 355 E. 9th St. Erie, PA 16503-1107 1,460 1,461 1,462 1,463 1,464 1,465 1,466 Nicola Nicolai 2400 Copper Creek Rd. Chester Springs, PA 194253890 Nora Murphy 977 Jefferies Bridge Rd. West Chester, PA 193822082 Norah Christ 2577 Copper Rd. New Castle, PA 16101-7977 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 63 Number 1,479 Commentator Pat Sadler 718 Ash Ave. Collingdale, PA 19023-3506 1,480 1,481 1,482 Number 1,491 Commentator Patricia Sheets 699 Allendale Rd. New Brighton, PA 150663685 Pat Walker 318 Edgley Ave. Glenside, PA 19038-5304 1,492 Patricia Uhric 106 Glenmore Dr. Coraopolis, PA 15108-9601 Pat Wall 798 Mount Pleasant Rd. Pottstown, PA 19465-8862 1,493 Patrick Arndt 429 Spencer Ave. Lancaster, PA 17603-4932 1,494 Patrick Pagano 1408 Mystic Valley Dr. Sewickley, PA 15143-8873 1,495 Patrick Smith 98 Diamond Ave. Hanover Township, PA 18706-5925 Pat Yannacci 1020 Baythorne Dr. Mechanicsburg, PA 170502100 1,483 Patricia Bond 202 N. Front St. Lewisburg, PA 17837-1510 1,484 Patricia Criscuola 4 Beechwood Dr. Lake Ariel, PA 18436-4774 1,496 Patrick Stahle 1811 Willow Street Pike Lancaster, PA 17602-4831 Patricia Daloni 9 Harding St. Johnstown, PA 15905-2804 1,497 Patrick Vogelsong 443 W. Penn St. Carlisle, PA 17013-2235 Patricia DiRienzo 128 Moorehead St. Erie, PA 16508-1859 1,498 Patricia Jacobs 188 Kent Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15241-2134 Patti Michener 703 Bramblewood Dr. Douglassville, PA 195181259 1,499 Patricia Long 2310 Seneca Dr. York, PA 17408-4323 Patty Oberly 76 Deck Rd. Womelsdorf, PA 19567-9400 1,500 Paul Bednarski P.O. Box 142 32 Dark Hollow Rd. Pipersville, PA 18947-0142 1,501 Paul Bowden 328 Harmar St. Pittsburgh, PA 15219-3748 1,485 1,486 1,487 1,488 1,489 1,490 Patricia Mcgowan P.O. Box 95 North Bend, PA 17760-0095 Patricia Minner 590 Milford Rd. Downingtown, PA 193351589 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 64 Number 1,502 Commentator Paul Exter 314 Lynn Rd. Springfield, PA 19064-3511 Number 1,514 Commentator Pauline Palko 26 Palko Dr. Waymart, PA 18472-3041 1,503 Paul Hagedorn P.O. Box 142 Beach Lake, PA 18405-0142 1,515 Pearl Glatt 1616 W. Liberty St., Apt. 901 Allentown, PA 18102-2051 1,504 Paul Johnson 3927 Ash Dr. Allison Park, PA 15101-3144 1,516 Pedro Rivera Jr. 205 Route 390 Cresco, PA 18326-7371 1,505 Paul Metzloff 26 Saddle Ridge Dr. Dallas, PA 18612-8716 1,517 Peg Chiodo 117 S. Patton Dr. Coraopolis, PA 15108-2523 1,506 Paul Murphy 42 Clifton Blvd. Pittsburgh, PA 15210-4330 1,518 Peggy Dawson 1854 Rivervue N. Drumore, PA 17518-9733 1,507 Paul Nasuti 126 S. 22nd St. Philadelphia, PA 19103-4348 1,519 Peggy Lingwall 118 Oak Ridge Dr. Clarion, PA 16214-1422 1,508 Paul Otruba 96 Thorn Apple Ln. Mansfield, PA 16933-9566 1,520 Peggy Richter 514 E. Sedgwick St. Philadelphia, PA 19119-1326 1,509 Paul Parker 60 Morrow Rd. Avella, PA 15312-2140 1,521 Peter Ammirati 6724 School Rd. New Hope, PA 18938-5746 1,510 Paul Wilson 6730 Geissinger Rd. Zionsville, PA 18092-2249 1,522 Peter Black 315 Canterbury Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15238-3005 1,511 Paul Wolinsky 1252 Ashbourne Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-2703 1,523 Peter Greene 1521 River Rd. Damascus, PA 18415-3003 1,512 Paula Barvin 8001 Heather Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-1309 1,524 Peter Snyder 1632 Lake Ariel Hwy. Lake Ariel, PA 18436-4121 1,513 Paulett Simunich 135 Leffler Dr. Johnstown, PA 15904-1262 1,525 Peter Stone 924 Laurel Dr. Bethlehem, PA 18017-1909 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 65 Number 1,526 Commentator Phillip Fenster 1270 Hemlock Dr. Philadelphia, PA 19116-1449 Number 1,538 Commentator Rachel Luterman 1919 Chestnut St., Apt. 709 Philadelphia, PA 19103-3408 1,527 Phillip Tanner 308 Lauschtown Rd. Denver, PA 17517-8908 1,539 Ralph Meyer 6056 Meadow Ln. Bakerstown, PA 15007-9720 1,528 Phineas Walsh 545 Walnut Ln. Philadelphia, PA 19128-1742 1,540 Ralph Schlesinger P.O. Box 258 Woolrich, PA 17779-0258 1,529 Phyllis Berman 6711 Lincoln Dr. Philadelphia, PA 19119-3119 1,541 Ray O'Rourke 54 Woodhill Dr. Cheswick, PA 15024-9611 1,530 Phyllis Davidson 428 Bigham St. Pittsburgh, PA 15211-1410 1,542 Ray Richardson 224 S. Main St. North Wales, PA 19454-3410 1,531 Phyllis Redman 540 Wanamaker Rd. Jenkintown, PA 19046-2220 1,543 Raymond Fritz 106 Magnolia Dr. Beaver, PA 15009-1024 1,532 Pollyann Rhoads Nh Lane Mohnton, PA 19540-7781 1,544 Raymond Young 94 East Ave., Apt. 3 Wellsboro, PA 16901-1735 1,533 Prudence Sommers 601 E. Elm St. Tamaqua, PA 18252-1611 1,545 Rebecca Heil 1125 W. 29th St. Erie, PA 16508-1535 1,534 Qing Alicia Li 605 Riders Way Moon Township, PA 151084716 1,546 Rebecca Kuligowski 25339 State Highway 99 Cambridge Springs, PA 16403-2805 1,535 Quentin Wenzel 1218 Circle Dr., N. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-6985 1,547 Rebecca Rose 2 S. Market St., Apt. 202 Elizabethtown, PA 170222371 1,536 Rabbi Alan Lapayover 6655 McCallum St. Philadelphia, PA 19119-3154 1,548 Regina Keck 327 S. Spring Rd. Mercer, PA 16137-3835 1,537 Rachel Limas 1652 Cedar Cliff Dr. Camp Hill, PA 17011-7714 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 66 Number 1,549 Commentator Regina Villarreal 3264 Halfmoon Valley Rd. Warriors Mark, PA 168776500 Number 1,561 Commentator Richard Keefer 1545 Knoxlyn Rd. Gettysburg, PA 17325-7322 1,550 Regis Kowalski 5010 Willock Rd., E. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-2237 1,562 Richard Ludwig 6050 Franklin Hill Rd. East Stroudsburg, PA 183019268 1,551 Renee Zuba 1031 W. Main St. Plymouth, PA 18651-4522 1,563 Richard Miller 1921 Woodmont Dr. Bethlehem, PA 18018-1454 1,552 Rex Grubb 1074 Dry Wells Rd. Quarryville, PA 17566-9178 1,564 Richard Plut 820 Struble Rd. State College, PA 168017432 1,553 Rhonda Buttacavoli 270 Reservoir Rd. Apollo, PA 15613-8601 1,565 Richard Renninger 616 Sunny Rst. Palmerton, PA 18071-9789 Richard Baldock 1830 Keystone Rd. Allentown, PA 18103-6977 1,566 Richard Starr 283 Game Lands Rd. Rockton, PA 15856-4613 Richard Barnes 497 Townline Rd. Russell, PA 16345-2805 1,567 Richard Tregidgo 1146 Sunnyside Dr. Holtwood, PA 17532-9726 Richard Burdette 4840 Spring Valley Dr. Allison Park, PA 15101-1012 1,568 Rick Barber 828 Arch Street Brockway, PA 15824-5608 1,569 Ricki Hurwitz 200 Montrose St. Harrisburg, PA 17110-1449 1,554 1,555 1,556 1,557 Richard Campbell 501 Sand Hill Rd. Montoursville, PA 177549563 1,558 Richard Defazio 639 Brown Ave. Erie, PA 16502-2586 1,570 robert D. Missimer Jr. 9 Roberts Rd. Malvern, PA 19355-1714 1,559 Richard Firestine 702 N. Goodwill St. Myerstown, PA 17067-2315 1,571 Robert Banner 322 Schocopee Rd. Milford, PA 18337-9355 1,560 Richard Hughes 1919 Blair St. Williamsport, PA 17701-3833 1,572 Robert Bishop 2033 W. Main St. Ephrata, PA 17522-1115 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 67 Number 1,573 Commentator Robert Butler Box 1a437 Lackawaxen, PA 18435 Number 1,585 Commentator Robert Mclane III 206 Manor Ave. Millersville, PA 17551-1116 1,574 Robert Chaffee 1500 Kelly Hill Rd. Tidioute, PA 16351-4722 1,586 Robert Neuhauser 89 Strasburg Pike Lancaster, PA 17602-1321 1,575 Robert Doll, M.D. P.O. Box 3177 Allentown, PA 18106-0177 1,587 Robert Schwier 716 Redwood Ave. Yeadon, PA 19050-3326 1,576 Robert Edwards 163 Willow St. Wilkes-Barre, PA 187021510 1,588 Robert Steffes 711 Hall St. Aliquippa, PA 15001-3712 1,589 1,577 Robert Garner 127 Creekgate Ct. Millersville, PA 17551-2136 Robert Steininger 100 Westridge Pl., S. Phoenixville, PA 19460-3376 1,590 1,578 Robert Gebert 370 Million Dollar Hwy. Bangor, PA 18013-5502 Robert W. Rhodes, III P.O. Box 355 Mercersburg, PA 17236-0355 1,591 Robert Wasilewski 59 Sorbertown Hl. Hunlock Creek, PA 186213800 1,592 Roberta Bunsick 125 Briarwood Rd. East Stroudsburg, PA 183029318 1,593 Roberta McCall 752 E. 37th St. Erie, PA 16504-1773 1,594 Robin Allaway 104 Fairley Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-3720 1,595 Robin Aurandt 1164 Wertz Rd. Williamsburg, PA 166937803 1,579 Robert Gibb 5036 Revenue St. Homestead, PA 15120-1227 1,580 Robert Havrilla 1501 Monterey St. Pittsburgh, PA 15212-4038 1,581 Robert Hirsh 245 S. 3rd St. Philadelphia, PA 19106-3911 1,582 Robert Johnson 117 Cottage Rd. Shippensburg, PA 172578755 1,583 Robert Kohler 252 Mt. Top Rd. Reinholds, PA 17569-9077 1,584 Robert Kraft 455 Moritz Rd. Orrtanna, PA 17353-9317 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 68 Number 1,596 Commentator Robin Wilson P.O. Box 563 Hawley, PA 18428-0563 Number 1,607 Commentator Ron Pazdro 1171 Neshaminy Valley Dr. Bensalem, PA 19020-1222 1,597 Robyn Walters 401 State Route 87 Montoursville, PA 177547601 1,608 Ron Rabold 1590 Ardnt Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-1413 1,609 Ron Sgrignuoli 407 Summit Ave. Shillington, PA 19607-1428 1,610 Ronald Horiszny 2307 Black River Rd. Bethlehem, PA 18015-5403 1,611 Roni Kampmeyer 145 Francis Dr. Georgetown, PA 15043-1053 1,612 Roosevelt Howard 5121 Willows Ave., #2 Philadelphia, PA 19143-3224 1,613 Roger Latham 207 W. Brookhaven Rd. P.O. Box 57 Wallingford, PA 19086-6213 Rose Rogan 5815 Private Rd. Doylestown, PA 18902-1930 1,614 Roger Smith Cardinal Dr. Palmerton, PA 18071-5535 Rosemary Caolo 1512 E. Gibson St. Scranton, PA 18510-1902 1,615 Roger Westman 500 Lloyd St. Pittsburgh, PA 15208-2831 Rosemary Delpino 128 American Ave. Butler, PA 16001-5540 1,616 Ron Ford 239 Oak Hill Rd. P.O. Box 110 Tannersville, PA 18372-7785 Roxann Steelman 3958 Howertown Rd. Northampton, PA 180679451 1,617 Ron Lawrence 721 Daylily Dr. Langhorne, PA 19047-1765 Roxanne Jones 8044 Leaser Rd. Kempton, PA 19529-8979 1,618 Roy Mccullagh 240 S. Osmond St. State College, PA 168014154 1,598 Rodney Daniels 310 N. Walnut St. Wernersville, PA 19565-1246 1,599 Rodney Martz Sr. 411 N. Delaware Dr. Easton, PA 18040 1,600 Rodney Weaver 119 Beagle Rd. Mill Hall, PA 17751-9495 1,601 Roger Horn 32 Barber St. Clarion, PA 16214-1603 1,602 1,603 1,604 1,605 1,606 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 69 Number 1,619 Commentator Russell Namie 702 Kennedy Dr. Youngwood, PA 15697-1402 Number 1,631 Commentator Samuel Reitman 520 N. Main St. Meadville, PA 16335-3903 1,620 Ruth Kuch 302 Baker Dr. Lincoln University, PA 19352-9398 1,632 Sandi Clark 8239 Highline Blvd. Erie, PA 16509-4961 1,633 Sandra Kirchner 5959 Jacobs Ave. Harrisburg, PA 17112-1204 1,634 Sandra Miller P.O. Box 752 Richlandtown, PA 189550752 1,621 Ruth Roberts 104 Clearview Ct. Irwin, PA 15642-8848 1,622 Rwolfgong X P.O. Box 307 Shippenville, PA 16254-0307 1,623 Ryan Bleacher 703 N. Shippen St. Lancaster, PA 17602-2041 1,635 Sandra Walker 538 Mount Pleasant Rd. Bloomsburg, PA 17815-7242 1,624 Ryan Clay 120 Anonymous Rd. Myerstown, PA 17067-3208 1,636 Sandy Stambaugh 82 W. Hanover St. Gettysburg, PA 17325-7725 1,625 Ryan Moore 1235 N. Rocky Mountain Dr. Effort, PA 18330-7888 1,637 Sarah Costlow 179 Wyndemere Dr. Johnstown, PA 15904-3753 1,626 Ryan Piontkowski 430 Kosciuszko St. Nanticoke, PA 18634-2607 1,638 Sarah Englander Philadelphia, PA 19119 1,639 1,627 Ryan Rendick 3581 Calumet St. Philadelphia, PA 19129-1645 Sarah Lynch 501 Mill Rd. Havertown, PA 19083-4003 1,640 1,628 Sally Jefferies 405 Legendary Ln. Mars, PA 16046-7135 Sarah Mccann 1157 S. 19th St. Philadelphia, PA 19146-2936 1,641 1,629 Sam Hoszwa 120 Duncan Dr. Butler, PA 16001-2620 Sari Steuber 45 Paper Mill Rd. Springfield, PA 19064-2704 1,642 Saundra Petrella 205 Walnut St. Beaver, PA 15009-2430 1,630 Samantha West 5001 Locust Ln. Harrisburg, PA 17109-4541 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 70 Number 1,643 Commentator Scott McClung 249 Planebrook Rd. Malvern, PA 19355-1580 Number 1,655 Commentator Sheila Karmatz 1014 Stanford Dr. Wynnewood, PA 19096-2009 1,644 Sean Donovan 4030 Mohawk Trl. Linesville, PA 16424-4956 1,656 Shellie Ray 700 E. 1st St., Apt. 37 Birdsboro, PA 19508-2356 1,645 Sean Sullivan 2731 Ash St. Philadelphia, PA 19137-2112 1,657 Sherry Morse 321 W. Burke St. Easton, PA 18042-1514 1,646 Seymour Tinkleman 109 Krewson Ln. Cheltenham, PA 19012-1202 1,658 Shirley Dyer 1402 Schweitzer Rd. Mckeesport, PA 15135-2022 1,647 Sharon Blair 400 Penns Ln. Malvern, PA 19355-3214 1,659 Shirley Landis 516 Waln Rd. Glenside, PA 19038-2018 1,648 Sharon Boring 531 Center Grange Rd. Monaca, PA 15061-2819 1,660 Shirley Sivitz 820 Church Rd. Elkins Park, PA 19027-1308 1,649 Sharon Crawford 4140 Merrick St. Philadelphia, PA 19128-3519 1,661 Shuhua Chiu 111 Crosswick Ln. Lancaster, PA 17601-5324 1,650 Sharon Heath 1509 Markley Rd. Pennsburg, PA 18073-1923 1,662 Sigmund Finman 202 Glen Spring Cir. Canonsburg, PA 15317-2308 1,651 Sharon Narushoff 11 Willow Ct. Hanover, PA 17331-4318 1,663 Simone Leiss Portugal Lloret, PA 17310 1,652 Sharon Sielski 17374 Kevin Dr. Meadville, PA 16335-6266 1,664 Sister Joan Marie Madden 129 Depaul Center Rd. Greensburg, PA 15601-1270 1,653 Shaun Little 259 W. Johnson St., Apt. I3 Philadelphia, PA 19144-2542 1,665 Sofia Karvouna Evrysthenous Athens,, PA 15773 1,654 Shawnelle Price 492 E. End Ave. Beaver, PA 15009-1949 1,666 Stella Nobrega-Garcia 101 Valley Stream Park Mountain Top, PA 187079048 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 71 Number 1,667 Commentator Stephanie Kotz 137 S. Main St. Nazareth, PA 18064-2016 Number 1,679 Commentator Stuart Miller 1000 Lagonda Rd. Washington, PA 15301-9019 1,668 Stephen Chaszar 639 4th Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-5558 1,680 Sue Cott 495 Hughes Rd. King of Prussia, PA 194063715 1,669 Stephen Ellis 174 Polo Dr. Shelocta, PA 15774-7332 1,681 Sue Myers 1248 Harding Ave. Hershey, PA 17033-1228 Stephen Mccoubrey 229 S. 42nd St. Philadelphia, PA 19104-3521 1,682 Suellen Snapp 232 Bayard St. Kane, PA 16735-1402 Stephen Orosz 5535 Forbes Ave., Apt. B Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1177 1,683 Summer Coscia 522 Regis Ct. Bensalem, PA 19020-7451 Stephen Smith 708 14th Ave. Bethlehem, PA 18018-3403 1,684 Susan and Tom Yatsky 31 Warwick Cir. Pottstown, PA 19465-8811 Sterling Scott 415 S. 57th St. Philadephia, PA 19143-1336 1,685 Susan Gage 7313 Boyertown Pike Douglassville, PA 195189577 1,686 Susan Gottfried 619 Cricklewood Dr. State College, PA 168032111 1,687 Susan Guido 336 Ivy Dr. Gibsonia, PA 15044-8931 1,688 Susan Jacob 2276 Wood Acres Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15237-1524 1,689 Susan Magee 161 S. Washington St. Greencastle, PA 17225-1331 1,670 1,671 1,672 1,673 1,674 Steve Bremner 1836 Memphis St. Philadelphia, PA 19125-2831 1,675 Steve Gimson 303 W. State St., Apt. 223 Doylestown, PA 18901-3551 1,676 Steve Greco 172 Stecker Mill Rd. Danville, PA 17821-6803 1,677 Steve Reass 124 E. Clearview Dr. Shrewsbury, PA 17361-1206 1,678 Steve Rock 306 W. Ashland St. Doylestown, PA 18901-4004 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 72 Number 1,690 Commentator Susan Miller 4918 Hialeah Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15239-2406 1,691 Susan Poff 1009 Marlin Dr. West Chester, PA 193822360 Number 1,701 Commentator Suzanne Shaffer 417 Hamlet Dr., W. Spring Grove, PA 173621403 1,702 Suzanne Staggenborg 5621 Beacon St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-2011 1,692 Susan Powell 601 Morris Ln. Wallingford, PA 19086-6934 1,703 Tanner Lowry 1725 S. 12th St., Fl. 2 Philadelphia,, PA 19148-1530 1,693 Susan Schulz P.O. Box 438 Kemblesville, PA 193470438 1,704 Tanya Wagner 5007 Apache Dr. Mechanicsburg, PA 170502564 1,694 Susan Stadnicki 101 Coolidge St. Shamokin, PA 17872-6505 1,705 Tara Blackburne 1332 Faunce St. Philadelphia, PA 19111-3344 1,695 Susan Thompson 23516 Shannondell Dr. Audubon, PA 19403-5675 1,706 Tara Pride 617 E. Butter Rd. York, PA 17406-8455 1,696 Susan Valla 108 Gwyn Lynn Dr. Ivyland, PA 18974-1463 1,707 Terence Grail 555 Pearl St., Apt. 301 Reading, PA 19602-2653 1,697 Susan Wagner 6650 Northumberland St. Pittsburgh, PA 15217-1313 1,708 Terrance Alexander Givens I 2810 Primrose Ln., N. York, PA 17404-8531 1,698 Susan Zhang 1018 Putnam Blvd. Wallingford, PA 19086-6746 1,709 Terry Brown 229 Greenview Dr. Lancaster, PA 17601-4997 1,699 Susanne Groenendaal 1313 Old Boalsburg Rd. State College, PA 168016233 1,710 Theodore Burger 3370 Woodbridge Cir. Bethlehem, PA 18017-1736 1,711 1,700 Susanne Hauger 24 Ironwood Dr. Collegeville, PA 19426-3922 Theodore Schurr 4622 Cedar Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19143-2118 1,712 Therese Hoetzlein 5372 Orchard Hill Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15236-1734 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 73 Number 1,713 Commentator Thomas & Ann Marie FinnCusick 308 E. Hinckley Ave., Apt. 2c Ridley Park, PA 19078-2526 1,714 Thomas Brenner 512 Bella St. Hollidaysburg, PA 166482304 1,715 1,716 1,717 1,718 1,719 1,720 1,721 1,722 1,723 Number 1,724 Commentator Tim & Brenda Kauffman 815 McGrann Blvd. Lancaster, PA 17601-4518 1,725 Tim Herman P.O. Box 195 Lewisburg, PA 17837-0195 1,726 Thomas Campanini 1030 Crest Way, Apt. 204 York, PA 17403-9126 Tim Ivers 309 Princeton Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15235-4839 1,727 Thomas Frantz 225 E. Walnut St. Lancaster, PA 17602-2341 Tim Kelly 205 Trailside Dr. Sewickley, PA 15143-8934 1,728 Thomas Frumkin 1204 Stanford Rd. Bethlehem, PA 18018-2214 Timothy Bintrim 1520 Benshoff Hill Rd. Johnstown, PA 15906-3806 1,729 Thomas Garrett 1791 Sapphire Rd. York, PA 17408-4444 Timothy Bock 514 Guyasuta Rd., Apt. 7 Pittsburgh, PA 15215-1640 1,730 Timothy Lennox 112 Glenloch Dr. Landenberg, PA 19350-9663 1,731 Timothy Mannello 31 Tabbs Dr. Williamsport, PA 17701-9646 Thomas Hessley 20 Weld Dr. Warren, PA 16365-3354 1,732 Timothy Moore 141 Moss St. Reading, PA 19601-3671 Thomas Pelzer 6838 Hunt Dr. Macungie, PA 18062-9698 1,733 Thomas Schuster 605 23rd St. Windber, PA 15963-1920 Timothy Murray 602 Maple St. New Bethlehem, PA 162421086 1,734 Thomas Swimley 9808 Route 249 Knoxville, PA 16928-9686 Tina Paloskey 41 Little Mountain Rd. Myerstown, PA 17067-1812 1,735 Todd Cusuman 202 Thunder Cir. Bensalem, PA 19020-2152 Thomas Graney, Jr. 215 Meadowbrook Dr. New Wilmington, PA 161421422 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 74 Number 1,736 Commentator Tom Campbell 4384 Craighead Rd. Allison Park, PA 15101-2604 Number 1,748 Commentator Troy Schreiber 403b Market St. Millersburg, PA 17061-1339 1,737 Tom Ferry 7 Justin Ln. Coatesville, PA 19320-1547 1,749 Tuula Fischer 174 Brink Hill Rd. Greentown, PA 18426-9215 1,738 Tom Fulmer 41 Karen Ct. Lititz, PA 17543-9243 1,750 Ursula White 23 Mitchell Dr. Pittsburgh, PA 15241-1351 1,739 Tom Hocking P.O. Box 501 Mount Gretna, PA 170640501 1,751 Valeri Fornagiel 343 Kelly Rd. Wellsboro, PA 16901-7261 1,752 1,740 Tom Sherman 275 S. 19th St. Philadelphia, PA 19103-5769 Valerie Rutherford 664 Smith Ave. Sharon, PA 16146-3152 1,753 1,741 Tom Trkula 3970 Green St. Harrisburg, PA 17110-1545 Vera Krokonko 78 Ashford Dr. Cranberry Township, PA 16066-7401 1,742 Tomas Sanguinetti 28 N. College St. Carlisle, PA 17013-2311 1,754 Veronice Plewinski 460 Saint Bernardine St. Reading, PA 19607-1737 1,743 Tony Rice 660 Kimmels Rd. Orwigsburg, PA 17961-2016 1,755 Vicki Adams 710 Duncan Ave., Apt. 1403 Pittsburgh, PA 15237-5063 1,744 Tonya Wenger 3 Fairview Dr. Akron, PA 17501-1613 1,756 Vicki l. Craig P.O. Box 54 135 Caporalli Lane Schenley, PA 15682-0054 1,745 Tracey Mangus 1420 4th Ave. Ford City, PA 16226-1310 1,757 Vicky Shank 145 W. Main St. Everett, PA 15537-1133 Tracy Iannarone 214 Wyalusing St. Old Forge, PA 18518-1202 1,758 Victor Tweed 50 Kiltie Dr. New Hope, PA 18938-1403 Tret Lemak 1210 Louise St. Homestead, PA 15120-2042 1,759 Victor Velez 1273 School St. Indiana, PA 15701-2578 1,746 1,747 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 75 Number 1,760 Commentator Victoria Sams 194 Jean Blvd. Lewisburg, PA 17837-8852 Number 1,771 Commentator Wanda Seidle 2725 W. Country Club Rd. Philadelphia, PA 19131-2828 1,761 Victoria Woshner 7106 Card Ln. Pittsburgh, PA 15208-2744 1,772 Wanita Roach 607 Indian Creek Dr. Wilkes Barre, PA 18702-7854 1,762 Viirginia Newlin 299 Devon Ln. West Chester, PA 193806823 1,773 Wayne Markley 611 Green St. Lansdale, PA 19446-5216 1,774 1,763 Vincent Ephault 107 Palm St. Olyphant, PA 18447-1723 Wendi Taylor 435 Parkview Ct. Camp Hill, PA 17011-2132 1,775 1,764 Vincent Young R.R. 1, Box 1454 Little Meadows, PA 188309738 Wendy Farnsworth 7 W. Centre St. Ashland, PA 17921-1305 1,776 Virginia Harden 1031 Oakview Cir. Middletown, PA 17057-3568 Wendy Futrick 4 E. Elm St. Shillington, PA 19607-2606 1,777 Virginia Rivers 665 Crest Ave. Benton, PA 17814-7011 Wilford Vaulx-Smith 31 Hoyt Dr. Indiana, PA 15701-1576 1,778 William & Linda Schmidt 109 Whitby Pl. Gibsonia, PA 15044-9333 1,779 William Bell 1616 Brushy Mountain Rd. East Stroudsburg, PA 183028812 1,780 William Crosby 154 Joliette Ave. Erie, PA 16511-1232 1,781 William D. Prystauk 827 Wilbur St. Easton, PA 18042-1423 1,782 William Engel 64 Clees Dr. Montoursville, PA 177548464 1,765 1,766 1,767 1,768 1,769 1,770 W. Andrew Stover 247 W. Queen St. Chambersburg, PA 172012035 Walt Sakowsk 2504 Four Mile Dr. Montoursville, PA 177549541 Walter Margie 1345 Martin Ct., Apt. 713 Bethlehem, PA 18018-2576 Wanda Rothrock 2916 N. Delaware Dr. Mount Bethel, PA 183435309 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 76 Number 1,783 Commentator William Granche 24 Lincoln St. Ridgway, PA 15853-1918 Number 1,794 Commentator William Thomas 716 N. Maple St. Fleetwood, PA 19522-1053 1,784 William Krouse 106 Bunker Hill Rd. New Cumberland, PA 170702533 1,795 William Thwing 610 Luzerne St. Johnstown, PA 15905-2326 1,796 William Vandermark 518 N. Wilbur Ave. Sayre, PA 18840-1753 1,797 William Yarnell 817 Stonybrook Ln. Lewisberry, PA 17339-8920 1,798 Wilma Caffentzis 7034 Ely Rd. New Hope, PA 18938-5725 1,799 Wood Souders 3333 Aster Ave. Trevose, PA 19053-4902 1,800 William Perry 1059 Alpine Dr. East Stroudsburg, PA 183029242 Wyatt Hale 3 Evans St. Brookville, PA 15825-0903 1,801 William Randolph 409 Poplar Valley Rd., W. Stroudsburg, PA 18360-7295 Youcef Djedid 524 Scaife Rd. Sewickley, PA 15143-9464 1,802 William Rose 856 Acri Rd. Mechanicsburg, PA 170502279 Yvette Banton 176 Chester Ct. Downingtown, PA 193354213 1,803 Zach Colatch Milton, PA 17847-2370 1,785 William Maccumbee 508 Stonedge Ct. Pittsburgh, PA 15239-1068 1,786 William Maruyama 225 N. Broad St. Allentown, PA 18104-5347 1,787 William Montgomery 124 Lindley Ln. Pottstown, PA 19465-7567 1,788 William Moore 3103 Broadway Rd. Easton, PA 18040-7220 1,789 1,790 1,791 1,792 William Rovnak 3837 Saxonburg Blvd. Cheswick, PA 15024-2236 1,793 William Schlupp P.O. Box 63817 Philadelphia, PA 19147-7817 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 77 COMMENTS AND RESPONSES Section I: Background 1. Comment: Several commentators suggest making mandatory public participation rules or codifying these guidelines. (31, 271 – 476) Response: Statutes and regulations at both the state and federal level with mandatory public participation rules already exist for many specific permits and many other aspects of the department’s operations. This policy is intended to standardize department procedures in areas not already covered by applicable laws. As a matter of policy, the department regularly exceeds these requirements and provides more public participation opportunities than required. Section II: How This Policy Relates to Other Public Participation Options 2. Comment: Section II, Existing Legal Requirements by Statue or Regulation, states that the department will follow all requirements set forth in law and regulation and to the extent that the policy conflicts with a legal requirement, the legal requirement governs. The commentator recommends the language should say "state or federal" law and regulation, with the one requiring the most public participation/notice governing (5) Response: By using the language “all legal requirements” the department is referring to both state and federal law. This will normally result in the department applying the most stringent standards, but an analysis of which specific requirements are controlling must be done on a case-by-case basis and is beyond the scope of this policy. 3. Comment: PADEP's Environmental Justice (EJ) policy should be expanded to cover areas that are presently being impacted by natural gas development operations since these areas meet your definition of EJ areas. People in those areas should be involved in the decisions that result from all permitting and all authorizations, not only the narrowly defined permits that are covered in this proposed policy. By including these impacted communities you can trigger the opt-in provisions in your EJ policy and rightfully broaden the applicability of this policy. (28, 234 – 249, 271 – 494) Response: This policy applies to all permits issued by the department. Changes to the department’s EJ policy are beyond the scope of this policy. This comment has been forwarded to the department’s Office of the Environmental Advocate for consideration. 4. Comment: The commentator suggests the DEP maintain areas of significant local interest and Environmental Justice (EJ) areas separate and distinct. (32) Response: The department understands that the existence of an EJ area and the determination that significant local interest has been expressed are separate issues, but both these issues will be considered in determining the public participation options that are appropriate for a given application. 5. Comment: The commentator states that the Public Participation sections of DEP’s Environmental Justice Policy document must be incorporated by reference in the Policy on 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 78 Public Participation. Public comment must be accepted on Environmental Justice public participation policy together with general public participation public comment. The commentator further states the policy should be withdrawn. DEP should issue a new document containing Public Participation policy, Environmental Justice trigger permit criteria, and General Permit eligibility criteria in a single document, so there can be an integrated discussion of public participation across all forms of DEP guidance. If need be, the relevant sections from other policy documents can be indicated in the Public Participation Policy document and incorporated by reference, but comment must be accepted in an integrated discussion of all aspects of Public Participation. (29) Response: The purpose of this policy is to clearly define the department’s public participation policies in cases where existing statutes, regulations, or guidance do not already specify the procedures that will be used. Including additional topics in this policy would be counterproductive—particularly if the issues included would require statutory or regulatory changes. 6. Comment: In light of the expansion of natural gas activities in Pennsylvania, the commentator strongly recommends that the Environmental Justice policy be more robustly applied to communities with regard to public participation in permitting. Also outlined is how an area of concern and status of an Environmental Justice community is to be identified. To be effective, the proposed public participation policy must require inclusion of EJ areas in all permitting considerations. The commentator requests that the Department begin the process of identifying communities where gas development is occurring and that meet the criteria of EJ areas, using the guidelines in the Department’s Environmental Justice Public Participation Policy. The commentator also recommends that the Department refer this critical issue to the Environmental Justice Advisory Board for action at its next scheduled meeting. (31) Response: The Environmental Justice Advisory Board was consulted and provided comments during the development of this policy. The specific comments above are not within the scope of this policy and should be addressed by the Environmental Justice Public Participation Policy (DEP ID: 012-0501-002) developed by the department’s Office of the Environmental Advocate (OEA). The comment has been forwarded to the OEA for their consideration. Section III: General Policy 7. Comment: In Section III, on page 2, if the applicant proposes “substantive changes” to the project proposal due to the review of a project, the DEP may consider an additional opportunity for public comment. This concept also appears in Section VI, on page 5. The commentators request that “substantive changes” be defined. (3, 7, 23, 32) Response: To avoid confusion, the department has removed the word “substantive” from the policy in reference to changes to the application. Furthermore, the department has clarified that it will consider extending the public comment period when changes to the application are made after the close of the public comment period. This is to ensure that the public is afforded the appropriate opportunity to provide comment on the actual project the department is reviewing. Please note that changes made during the technical review of the application will be managed in accordance with the department’s “Policy for Implementing the Department of Environmental 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 79 Protection (Department) Permit Review Process and Permit Decision Guarantee” (Document No. 021-2100-001. 8. Comment: Section III, paragraph 2, currently says that “Department staff will encourage public participation in the permit review process.” The commentator recommends using the phrase “strongly encourage”. (26) Response: This policy outlines procedures and guidelines the department should follow when engaging in public participation activities associated with the permit review process. The department will make every reasonable attempt to facilitate public participation during the permit review process while adhering to the framework of the applicable regulatory and statutory requirements. When pre-application meetings are held for a permit, the Department will discuss and strongly encourage the applicant to conduct public outreach when such activities are not otherwise required by statute or regulation. 9. Comment: In Section III, paragraph 2, the commentator recommends adding the following: “consider and include consulting with the Office of Environmental Advocate, Community Relations Coordinators and/or Local Government Liaisons on the most appropriate methods to obtain the most valuable public participation.” (26) Response: The department agrees and has added the requested language. 10. Comment: In section III, the commentator suggests adding language highlighting section VIII Additional Information. (26) Response: The department agrees and has added the requested language. 11. Comment: PA DEP should maintain and use “Interested Party” lists for notifications of open permit comment windows, and the Policy should be revised to mention the availability of this service. (8, 26) Response: While the Pennsylvania Bulletin is the most authoritative source for such notifications, the department provides additional resources to notify the public of open comment periods. The department recommends interested parties register with the department’s eNotice system for notifications of interest. Interested parties may also check the DEP Calendar of Events, available on the department’s website (DEP Keyword: Public Participation), for upcoming events. 12. Comment: PA DEP’s eNotice emails do not provide enough information for the public. (8) Response: The department appreciates this comment. Improvements to the eNotice system have already been made related to draft technical guidance. Other improvements to the eNotice system are currently being considered and will be implemented as resources allow. 13. Comment: The Policy should encourage public notice for all permit actions to include publication in the local newspaper with the largest circulation in the host municipality. (8) Response: Section IV of the policy details public notification requirements including the use of local media to announce public hearings and public meetings. Notifications related to other 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 80 permit actions are beyond the scope of this policy. While the Pennsylvania Bulletin is the commonwealth’s official gazette for such notifications, the department provides the eNotice service to supplement that notice in an effort to further assist the public in tracking local permitting actions. In addition, the department’s Newsletter and Calendar of Events, both available through the department’s web site, will list open comment periods, public hearings, and meetings. 14. Comment: The commentators suggest that the department consider using other methods such as social media and Public Service Announcements on local radio to enhance its public outreach for participation in permitting. (31, 15) Response: The department appreciates this suggestion and is committed to enhancing public outreach. For example, the department has recently announced an updated website, an improved newsletter, and calendar of events. Other initiatives will be announced as they become available. 15. Comment: The commentator recommends the department take advantage of the use of informational fact sheets and webinars. (19) Response: The department agrees and has been actively expanding the use of such tools. 16. Comment: The commentator encourages PA DEP to provide guidance on how long after permit issuance the notification must appear in the Pennsylvania Bulletin and suggest 14 days. Further, the commentator requests that PA DEP provide guidance on the information that must be provided in the public notice and suggests it include: 1) permit number; 2) owner/operator; 3) facility name; 4) longitude and latitude; 5) equipment associated with the permit; 6) type and quantity of air contaminants being emitted.; 7) applicable regulations; 8) the conditions in the proposed permit (with reference to applicable federal requirements); and GPS coordinates for the proposed facility. (24) Response: The department recognizes this comment and has already begun working to streamline and improve the Pennsylvania Bulletin notices published by each program area. The commentator’s suggestions will be considered in this process where appropriate. 17. Comment: The commentator requests that PA DEP provide mechanisms to enforce public notice and periodically review the Pennsylvania Bulletin to ensure compliance. (24) Response: When and how public notice is to be handled varies by statute and regulation. The department adheres to the requirements outlined for public notice of department action. However, as mentioned in Comment #41, the department has been working to streamline and improve Pennsylvania Bulletin notices that are published by each program area. In addition, the responsibility of consolidation and review of all Pennsylvania Bulletin notices now takes place in the DEP Policy Office; previously this responsibility was split between two different offices. 18. Comment: The proposed policy should include a requirement for timely dissemination to the municipality of the notice of a permit or authorization so that local governments can achieve broad public. For instance, municipalities will often turn an issue over to their Environmental Advisory Commissions, which will assume responsibility for analysis and developing a community response. Additionally, a local government may want to schedule a public 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 81 information session of its own. (2, 6, 8, 31) Response: Apart from this policy, applicants for certain types of permits are required to give written notice to each municipality in which the permit activities are located as indicated in the statute at 71 P.S. Section 510-5 (relating to cooperation with municipalities). To supplement this requirement, municipalities are encouraged to sign-up for eNotice alerts related to permitting activities in their communities. In addition, the department encourages its Local Government Liaisons to forward such public notices to the affected municipalities in their area, and will also be engaging Liaisons in a higher form of municipal notification. 19. Comment: The commentator suggests that the department establish a standard recommending that each noticed municipality and county, in turn, undertake its own outreach to the members of its community to enhance public awareness of the project and of the opportunity for comment. (2) Response: While the department encourages municipality engagement in the permitting process, establishing such standards are beyond the scope of this policy. 20. Comment: In addition to the 10 day public comment period after an application is significantly revised, the proposed Policy should be revised to include a 10 day public comment period to be routinely provided after any hearing or public meeting. (7) Response: While the department encourages such meetings to be conducted as early in the comment period as practical to ensure receipt of all comments within the published comment period, the department strives to allow at least two weeks after a public hearing until the end of the public comment period to allow ample opportunity to provide feedback. 21. Comment: Not every public comment period corresponds with an issued comment and response document. The commentator recommends that the Department outline in the policy whether or not a comment and response document will be issued for the various types of public comment periods. The commentator also recommends that within each Pennsylvania Bulletin notice it is indicated whether or not a corresponding comment and response document will be issued. (23) Response: It is the department’s policy that all timely public comments are considered and responses are provided in the appropriate document. As no comments are received for many public comment periods, the department often does not know in advance if a CommentResponse Document will be issued. 22. Comment: While the policy recommends that the applicant seek public input prior to submitting a permit, such public input needs to be further defined as to the manner in which it is solicited. Is the applicant reaching out to a segment of the population that supports their project, or is this a general outreach to all the citizenry? Will the company be providing an ‘informational open house’ where they are the sole providers of information including regarding how their facility is regulated? If so, there is an inherent inappropriateness to the applicant ‘controlling’ the message. There is not an open forum for an unbiased and accurate detail of the regulatory procedure, there is not an avenue for those present, including press to receive fair and objective information regarding how the facility may add additional sources of pollutants to the local environment or the manner in which the facility is regulated or the manner in which DEP 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 82 and other agencies provide emergency response. Therefore, the Commentator discourages the pre-application input unless there is an across the board public outreach coupled with reliable information provided by DEP. (23) Response: The department agrees that broad public outreach and providing reliable information are key elements of an effective pre-application meeting. It has been the department’s experience that the majority of businesses in Pennsylvania are receptive to engaging the community regarding their proposed projects. 23. Comment: Since permit applicants are encouraged “to schedule a pre-application conference with the Department as soon as practicable to discuss the permitting needs for the project prior to submitting an application.” what about the public that will be affected? These pre-app conferences should also be open to the public and available on-line live and archived. (26) Response: Based upon experience, the department finds the public is better served by encouraging a full and open discussion of any proposal early in the process. Requiring publication of pre-application discussions could discourage such conferences from taking place. 24. Comment: The commentator supports the concept that project applicants should seek public input from affected communities prior to submitting a permit or other authorization to the Department and that local government be included in the proposed policy. It is critical that basic facts and information about a planned project are presented to the public before plans are set in motion, allowing for a more iterative process that might, in fact, substantially change a permit application or project scope in order to ensure that it is more protective of the environment. (31) Response: The department appreciates the supportive comments. 25. Comment: The commentator encourages DEP to recommend, as a matter of course, that the project proponent contact land trusts and comprehensive land use planners in the region for the purpose of identifying high value resources. This step should be part of the checklist that DEP reviews as it proceeds with the project permitting. The commentator further urges DEP to consider requesting written statements from the contacted parties regarding the siting issues pertinent in the project landscape. (2) Response: While the issues raised are beyond the scope of this policy, the department already uses the Pennsylvania Natural Diversity Inventory (PNDI) Environmental Review Tool to identify potential impacts to threatened, endangered and special concern species, and special concern resources. As part of this procedure, the department considers comments and recommendations provided by the applicable resource agencies. In addition, the department will consider comments of other parties during the applicable public comment period. 26. Comment: The commentator agrees that applicants should consider the items in PA DEP’s proposed Outreach Checklist, but recommends DEP require permit applicants to develop and implement a public outreach plan before and throughout their permit application timeframe and further recommends specific checklist items become mandatory. (18) Response: While the department encourages applicants to develop and implement a public outreach plan, adding additional mandatory requirements for applicants would require statutory 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 83 and/or regulatory changes and is beyond the scope of this policy. The department has decided to rescind the “Permit Applicant Outreach Activities Checklist” in order to prevent confusion. It will no longer be available for use. In the future, the information contained in the checklist may be available in a Fact Sheet. The department encourages applicants to contact their local environmental advocate regarding additional public outreach options. 27. Comment: The policy states that Department staff will consider the appropriate method to obtain valuable public comment as the degree of participation requirements differs with each project. Per the Department's commitment to decision-making that is "open, transparent and accountable," (I. Background), the commentator suggests that the region's Environmental Advocate should be consulted at the minimum in these decisions, especially on potentially controversial issues. This will help with public trust. (5) Response: The policy has been revised to include a reference to the Environmental Advocate. 28. Comment: In the current Policy on Public Participation dated July 16, 2005, the Department’s Center for Collaboration and Environmental Dispute Resolution is required to provide consultation. Projects that may be controversial or of great public interest are specifically flagged in the current policy to include the Center to ensure effective public participation. The proposed policy removes this resource, and thereby the expertise and advocacy of the Center— in turn reducing the benefits of review for the public. We recommend that, at a minimum, the regional representative of the Department’s Environmental Advocate be required to provide expertise and support for public participation. (31) Response: The policy has been revised to include consultation with the Environmental Advocate, Community Relations Coordinator, and/or Local Government Liaison as appropriate. 29. Comment: The commentator notes that dwindling newspaper distribution—and the declining number of local papers—makes this medium less and less effective as a means of notifying the affected public of comment periods and processes. The commentator suggests other forms of notification and also suggests that the Department assess whether reliance on publication in the Pennsylvania Bulletin is effectively serving the public notification function and if other alternatives are appropriate. (2) Response: As the Pennsylvania Bulletin is the commonwealth’s official gazette for information and rulemaking, it is the primary and most authoritative source for department notices. To supplement the Bulletin and enhance public outreach, the department also utilizes other forms of public notification, including, but not limited to, the following: use of local media, including newspaper and television; publication on the department website; and use of the department’s eNotice system. These forms of additional notification are mentioned in Section III of the policy. Going forward, the department will be working with the Citizens Advisory Council to explore and develop other options for notifying the public of department actions. Section IV: Public Participation Options 30. Comment: The commentator suggests that Section IV should present the items in chronological order. (7) Response: The department does not wish to indicate a chronological order. While the 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 84 department often holds public meetings prior to public hearings, that order may change to allow for more effective public participation. 31. Comment: The commentator suggests section IV be edited for consistency, noting that part A references the “application decision” where part B references the issuance “of the permit”. (26) Response: The department agrees and has revised the language. 32. Comment: Often the Pennsylvania Bulletin (PaB) notice will detail an exact due date, such as the notice for this particular comment, July 22, 2013. However, some PaB Notices will simply state 60 days, 30 days, 45 days. Therefore, the commentator suggests that in order to avoid any misunderstandings that for example, the notice state “The Department is accepting comments during a 60 day period beginning on the date of this publication and ending August 15, 2013 at 12:00 a.m.” (19, 23) Response: The department is in the process of reviewing its forms and procedures related to public notice and will encourage this change; the department has already consolidated responsibilities regarding Pennsylvania Bulletin notices to be managed by the Policy Office. 33. Comment: Once a public hearing has been scheduled, there should be guidance to the host community on the expected role of the community in outreach to the public. (2) Response: The department appreciates this suggestion and is in the process of developing additional outreach materials and resources for local communities. 34. Comment: The department should allow for two separate comment periods so the public has the opportunity to comment on a company’s application and DEP’s analysis of the application (8, 9, 17, 21, 24, 28, 33 – 270) Response: Opening the comment period after the proposed permit has been submitted allows potential commentators the greatest opportunity to focus their comments on the relevant issues, legal standards, and factual information upon which the department’s decision will be based. In addition, the department maintains a Record of Decision document that becomes part of the application file and is available during a file review. 35. Comment: Notice of an open public comment period is often NOT published in a manner that actually reaches the public. In rural areas where communities span municipal boundaries and where newspaper service areas may be based on political boundaries, notices placed in one newspaper may not reach all landowners. Advertising the scheduling of a public meeting on the department’s website is not an effective method of notifying the public. In rural areas more than 30% of the population does not have computers or the Department’s website. (30) Response: The Pennsylvania Bulletin is the commonwealth’s official gazette for information and rulemaking. As such, it is the most authoritative source for notice of open public comment periods. It is available online at www.pabulletin.com and print subscriptions are also available. In addition to bulleting publication, the department will provide notices in local media, the department’s website, and other methods as necessary. The department is also committed to improving local outreach efforts to supplement official notifications. In addition to advertising notices of public meetings in local media, the department’s website, and other methods as 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 85 required, the department is also committed to improving local outreach efforts to supplement official notifications. 36. Comment: The commentator supports the use of the Pennsylvania Bulletin and additional forums or venues; the greater the opportunity for public participation in decision making, the better and more protective will be the decisions made by the Department. The commentator also supports the continued use of both electronic and written comments so that more people can take part. (31) Response: The department appreciates the supportive comments. 37. Comment: There needs to be a double check that hearing locations are properly advertised (23) Response: The department agrees and will continue to check such information. 38. Comment: The commentator requests publication of notices in advance of the comment period as the typical 30-day period is insufficient to research and respond (13) Response: The department recognizes that, in some cases, a longer public comment period is appropriate. For certain permits, existing regulations require 60 day comment periods and, even when not required, the department may consider extending public comment periods on a caseby-case basis. 39. Comment: The commentator requests posting of such notices should be required at all "involved" Municipality buildings and should be advertised in local newspapers at least twice if not more during the notification period. (15) Response: Consistent with current practice, such notification will be provided when required by statute or regulation or, on a case-by-case basis when the department determines it is appropriate. Going forward, the department will be working with its local government liaisons to enhance municipal outreach. 40. Comment: The commentator recommends that hearings are always preceded by a meeting rather than a stand-alone hearing. Alternatively, where that is not possible, an informational fact sheet with perhaps even a reference to an available webinar that the public can refer to and then have a period in which to submit comments two to three weeks subsequent to the hearing date would be a much valuable tool to the public in lieu of a preceding informational meeting. (19, 23) Response: While it is not always possible to schedule an informational meeting for every action, the department has been expanding the use of such meetings, fact sheets, and webinars related to permitting actions. In addition, the department strives to provide at least two weeks after a public hearing to allow the public to develop and submit comments on a project. 41. Comment: The Policy should include that PA DEP should always clarify if a meeting it is holding is a “formal” public hearing or simply an informal “Public Information Meeting” and all PA DEP offices should use consistent terminology when referring to meetings to ensure the public knows which of their comments will be “on the record.” (8) 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 86 Response: The department agrees with this comment. The purposes of revising this policy include clarifying what different types of meetings exist and to standardize terminology. 42. Comment: The importance of public exchange has been rendered null by the Department setting up tables in corners of a room and only allowing people to present their questions to the Department. The answers are only heard by the individual posing the question. (30) Response: While the set-up the commentator mentions can often be that of an informal meeting, public meetings and public hearings are not organized in the same manner and all individuals attending will be able to hear the questions and answers being posed and in the case of public hearings, the oral testimony being provided. IV.A: Written/Electronic Comments in Response to a Pennsylvania Bulletin Notice 43. Comment: The commentator recommends that this policy reflect a change in how the Department counts the days in a comment period. One of the most constraining factors for the public is when a comment period includes legal or religious holidays. The Department should extend the comment period for these days. The Department should also not count weekends as calendar days in the comment period. (31) Response: While the department understands this issue, it presents comment periods in calendar days to be consistent with statutory and regulatory language. To change the method of calculation in this policy would cause undue confusion. The department frequently extends public comment periods so they do not end on a weekend or holiday and may grant requests to re-open or extend comment periods to ensure the public has ample ability to participate. 44. Comment: A 30-day comment period is too brief. The commentator recommends that no comment period is less than 45 days. (19, 23) Response: Depending on the permit, the department currently uses 30, 45, or 60days as the minimum length for public comment periods. These timeframes are often set by statute or regulation; however, the department may also extend a public comment period where appropriate. While the Pennsylvania Bulletin is the official source where all public comment periods are announced, the department also provides the eNotice service where users can subscribe to receive email notifications of permits in their area. 45. Comment: The commentator commends the department for the ease of submission of public comments through an easy email method. Federal government agencies offer very complex and frustrating methods of submission. We offer kudos to the Department for not only encouraging, but also, for enabling public participation through such an easy email method. (23) Response: The department appreciates the positive comment. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 87 IV.B: Public Hearings 46. Comment: In reference to “written request of the community where significant local interest in the pending application is demonstrated to the Department.” Commentators ask whether the request can come from an individual resident speaking on behalf of his/her community, to which Division of the Department the request should be submitted, and how (email or surface mail). (5, 31) Response: Each bulletin notice formally opening a proposal for public comment will include the name and contact information of a department representative to whom requests should be sent. The department receives many requests for public hearings and/or meetings from individuals on behalf of others, including, but not limited to, communities and groups. When submitting a request on behalf of others, the request should clearly indicate the group(s), community/communities and/or individuals being represented. 47. Comment: The commentator recognizes that the focus of a public hearing is for the department to receive testimony, but suggest that an opportunity be provided for the public to speak with regulators about their questions and concerns. (23) Response: To address this issue, the department often schedules public meetings prior to the more formal public hearings. In addition to program staff at meetings, typically a Community Relations Coordinator, a Local Government Liaison and/or an Environmental Advocate will attend the meeting and can assist with concerns. 48. Comment: In Section IV.B on page 3, the DEP states that a written request for a public hearing should be received by the DEP prior to the close of the official public comment period or early in the public comment period in order to facilitate an efficient public participation process. In addition, the DEP states that it may extend the public comment period to accommodate the public hearing. The Commentator recommends that the DEP only accept written requests for public hearings in the first half of the public comment period in order to accommodate these hearings within the assigned public comment period. (32) Response: While the department encourages requests to be submitted as soon as possible, all comments received during a public comment period—including requests for public hearings— will be considered. In cases where a request for a public hearing is received later in the comment period is granted, the comment period may be extended to accommodate the hearing. 49. Comment: The commentator supports the Department’s willingness to schedule public hearings at the request of affected communities and to accommodate the public comment received in those hearings, above and beyond the statutory and regulatory requirements for such activity. To ensure that communities are able to avail themselves of this opportunity, it is important that a DEP point of contact for each application be identified in all notices and announcements. (2) Response: Although the contents of specific Pennsylvania Bulletin notices is beyond the scope of this policy, the department is reviewing its publication practices and will seek to ensure contact information is made available. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 88 50. Comment: Section IV states that the Department will extend the duration of the public comment period to accommodate the public hearing and "any additional time" required by statue or regulation. This should be a minimum of two weeks after the hearing to allow additional comments. (5) Response: The department recognizes this comment and will consider the appropriate time for an extension on a case-by-case basis. Timing and Location of a Public Hearing 51. Comment: Commentators support meetings being held in the location of the proposed permitted activity. (8, 30, 245 – 270, 477 – 1,803) Response: The department appreciates the supportive comments. 52. Comment: Commentators express concern that meetings are often conducted during the day when most people are at work. (8, 14, 30) Response: The department recognizes this issue. While it is not always possible to schedule meetings at a time convenient for all interested parties, the department will continue to work to improve the public’s ability to participate. 53. Comment: The commentator agrees that hearings on a pending permit where practical occur during the duration of the formal comment period on the pending application. They must not be so late in the process however, that only a few days are remaining to submit comment. The public does need adequate time to prepare and submit their comment. (23) Response: The department appreciates the supportive comment, and agrees that time after the hearing is beneficial to allow submission of comments; the department strives to allow at least two weeks after the hearing and before the end of the public comment period for this purpose. 54. Comment: Public hearings should not occur during the initial 30-day comment period, but should occur only after a comment period is over (if substantial interest has been shown). (9, 21, 24, 28, 33 – 244, 271 – 494). Response: Because the department accepts written testimony at public hearings, it is appropriate to conduct such hearings during the public comment period. In situations where necessary material is unavailable for review by the public, the department will consider extending the comment period on a case-by-case basis. 55. Comment: The commentator supports Public Hearings on permit applications during the formal comment period on all permits that have the potential, individually or cumulatively, to impact communities and the environment. The commentator further supports the Department’s proposal to extend the public comment period if a hearing is granted at the end of a formal comment period, and the proposal that oral comments be given equal weight to written ones, since many individuals choose only to participate in this way. However, the commentator recommends that the policy specify that public hearings will be recorded and that oral testimony will become part of the Comment and Response Document. (31) 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 89 Response: The Department agrees. The requested provisions appear in section IV.B. of the draft policy and will be retained in the final version. 56. Comment: Regarding the postponement of a public hearing, it is very important that attention be paid to conditions in the area where a hearing is to be held. For instance, if local weather is inclement or if there is another local event that could interfere with public participation, a hearing should be postponed and rescheduled. The proposed policy should reflect that the Department’s goal is to maximize the opportunity for input at public hearings. (31) Response: The department agrees. This is addressed under Section IV(B) of the policy under the retitled “Notice of Scheduling or Cancellation of a Public Hearing,” which states that if the department postpones or cancels a public hearing, it will provide appropriate public notice of the postponement or cancellation as well as the rescheduling of the meeting. 57. Comment: The public hearing should be held at a location convenient to the community, where room is sufficient to accommodate a substantial audience, and sufficient time allowed for 5 minute presentations by members of the public. (9, 24) Response: The department attempts to schedule venues that best balance the needs of the event, including convenience of the location for the interested community. Those wishing to testify are encouraged to pre-register to allow for more effective planning. 58. Comment: The commentator supports the department’s proposal that public hearings should be held in the location most affected by a project that is convenient to the impacted community. However, the commentator recommends that these guidelines be inclusive in defining “local interest” by allowing requests to come from a community that will be directly impacted by a proposed project, even if it is not the exact geographic location for it. This is a critical consideration when several small but adjacent communities in rural areas (where much gas development, for example, occurs) inevitably share water and air quality impacts from largescale projects. (31) Response: The department agrees and interprets “local” to include the directly impacted communities near the source in question. This is not limited to the specific municipality where the source is located. Notice of Scheduling or Cancellation of a Public Hearing 59. Comment: The commentator recommends that, when scheduling public hearings, the facilities municipality be contacted to ensure there is no scheduling conflict and a letter be sent advising the municipality of the hearing. (23) Response: The department agrees that communication with municipalities is important; therefore, the department will be engaging it’s Local Government Liaison in a higher level of municipal notification regarding the permitting process. The department also recommends that interested municipal officials and/or staff register with the eNotice system and review the department’s Calendar of Events to be alerted about relevant actions in their area. Like any interested party, if a municipal representative is unable to present testimony because of a scheduling conflict, written testimony may be submitted during the comment period and will be given the same weight as oral testimony. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 90 60. Comment: The commentators do not agree that two weeks is enough time for notice of a hearing and suggests providing at least 30 days’ notice for a hearing or comment period the minimum necessary. (31, 15) Response: The two-week period identified in the policy represents a minimum standard, but the department will strive to provide additional notice where possible. Public Hearing Guidelines/Attachment B 61. Comment: The Policy should specify that although pre-registration for public hearings is a permissible PA DEP practice, PA DEP cannot require written notice of intent to speak in order to testify. (8) Response: The department does not require written notice to testify at a public hearing, but suggests the public should pre-register whenever possible. As Appendix B, indicates, those who pre-register are called to testify first followed by those who have signed in on-site as time allows. Because the department uses pre-registration information to reserve the venue, the department cannot guarantee there will be sufficient time for all those who signed in on-site to provide testimony. The department is reviewing its notice procedures to clarify written notice is not required and pre-registration by email or telephone is permissible. 62. Comment: The Department should formally require that regional offices take pre-registration for public hearings. Pre-registration not only allows speakers to more fully prepare for their testimony, but also assists the Department in planning the public hearing agenda. (24) Response: The department disagrees. Although pre-registration is encouraged, such a requirement could limit valuable testimony by only allowing those who have pre-registered to present comments. As Appendix B, indicates, those who pre-register are called to testify first followed by those who have signed in on-site as time allows. 63. Comment: Commenters recommend removing the requirement in number 10, which asks speakers to state their address before speaking. Speakers do not always feel comfortable stating their home address in front of large audiences, especially when speaking about a contentious issue such as natural gas. Speakers currently provide their address upon pre-registration, or when signing up to speak the night of the hearing; the transcriber can easily obtain a copy of the information already provided. (24) Response: Item number 10 has been revised to clarify that witnesses need not repeat contact information provided during pre-registration. 64. Comment: The commentator agrees with the guidelines in attachment B. (23) Response: The department appreciates the supportive comment. 65. Comment: The Department is commended for adding Appendix B relating to Public Hearing Guidelines. The simple instructions provided should prove helpful to Department staff as they plan and conduct hearings. It is recommended that item #9 be reworked to offer a less authoritative tone by revising it to read “To aid in accurately transcribing the hearing, it is 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 91 important that attendees remain quiet when others are presenting testimony.” (7) Response: The department agrees and has revised Appendix B. 66. Comment: The Policy should clarify that public hearings should not involve speakers addressing a stenographer only—speakers should be able to address the entire audience at once if desired. (8) Response: The department will, to the greatest extent practicable, configure hearing venues to allow those providing testimony to adequately address both representatives of the department and the audience. 67. Comment: The policy states that “Organizations are requested to designate one witness to present testimony on its behalf”. Many participants wish to identify themselves as a member of an organization but are not speaking for that organization, they are speaking for themselves and their family, but also want to be identified with a group. (29) Response: This guideline only applies to comments made on behalf of an organization and has been included to encourage efficiency and to ensure a greater number of attendees have an opportunity to present testimony. Individuals wishing to testify on their own behalf but list any group or organization affiliation(s) are welcome to do so. 68. Comment: The Department should change this public participation policy to allow residents the possibility to speak up to 10 minutes during public testimony if the timing permits. Commenters suggest establishing the time limit for each speaker to be “not less than 5 minutes, but not more than 10 minutes.” (24) Response: The guideline that limits testimony to five minutes was selected to provide adequate time for an individual to present comments while maximizing the number of speakers that can be accommodated. Witnesses who wish to do so are encouraged to supplement their testimony with written comments. 69. Comment: The commentator requests that all public hearing or meeting facilitators be appropriately trained in meeting facilitation so that they can move the hearing forward in an efficient yet respectful manner. (24) Response: The department agrees and will continue to conduct appropriate training. 70. Comment: Commentators agree that visual aides are helpful for residents to use in certain situations and urge the Department to allow relevant photos and videos to be enumerated in the policy as acceptable props that can be used during testimony and included in the official comment record. (24) Response: The purpose of a public hearing is to receive testimony related to a proposed project. While limited use of relevant visual aids that can be reasonably included in the written record is permitted, the use of videos or the submission of other physical evidence is not appropriate and will not be accepted. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 92 Transcripts from Public Hearings 71. Comment: Commentators suggest that transcripts of public hearings be posted online on the Department website or otherwise publically available for free. (24, 26, 31) Response: The department agrees and has adjusted its contracts with private companies to allow the department access to transcripts for posting online. 72. Comment: In the current Policy on Public Participation dated July 16, 2005, it is affirmatively stated that the transcript of a Public Hearing “should be provided to the Department within 21 days of the hearing.” This is not stated in the proposed policy and should be inserted. Timeliness of the availability of the transcript is important so that the public can obtain a copy to review before a Comment and Response document is issued by the Department. (31) Response: While the department would prefer to have transcripts as quickly as possible to not unnecessarily delay the decision making process, the availability of transcripts is often controlled by contractual requirements with the private companies who prepare them in addition to other factors. However, the department has adjusted the language to provide an approximate timeline for availability of three (3) weeks after the hearing is held, depending on the length and complexity of the subject matter 73. Comment: B. Public Hearings Transcripts from Public Hearings - The section should be amended to require the placement of said transcripts at the local library which contains the project specific information. (6) Response: Contractual requirements with the private companies who prepare the transcripts of public hearings often prevent the department from distributing copies as suggested. The department is working to revise existing contract language to allow for a wider distribution of transcripts. Transcripts will also become part of the official record and be available for review at the appropriate regional office. 74. Comment: Under Transcripts from Public Hearings, there is no time deadline given for the Department's receipt of the official transcript. Given that oral statements are given the same weight as written statements, it is hard to understand how effectively the Department can offer an official response to oral comments before making its decision on the application. A deadline should be specified. (5) Response: The time required to receive a transcript is dependent on the contractual agreement between the department and the agency preparing the transcript as well as the length and complexity of the testimony. However, the department has adjusted its contracts with the company preparing the transcripts and has amended the policy to include an approximate timeline for availability of three (3) weeks after the date of the hearing. In addition, the department considers all comments (both oral and written) received during the public comment period and addresses them in the Comment-Response Document prior to making its decision on the associated application. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 93 Web-based Public Hearings 75. Comment: Comments on web- or teleconference- based public participation include: only using them for educational purposes, using them for meetings and conferences but only holding in-person hearings, and supporting their use for all purposes. Commentators uniformly express concern for how such meetings will be conducted and what provisions will be made for those with limited connectivity. (5, 6, 9, 13, 14, 17, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 35, 28, 33 – 244, 271 – 494) Response: While web- or teleconference-based public meetings or hearings would be more convenient for many people and would allow the department to efficiently conduct more hearings and meetings, the department is aware that there are some situations where there are no substitutes for in-person hearings or meetings. The department is also aware that there are those who have limited access to the necessary technology. If the department chooses to offer web- or teleconference-based services, it will consider these issues and take steps to ensure all interested parties have a reasonable opportunity to participate. IV.C: Public Information Meetings 76. Comment: Regarding public meetings, the commentator prefers required attendance and participation by the applicant. (23) Response: While the department encourages participation by the applicant, the requested change could only be made by statute and/or regulation and is, therefore, beyond the scope of this policy. 77. Comment: The commentator discourages the provision for the applicant to hold its own public information meetings lacking regulator presence. While the operator is able to disseminate a great deal of information in such a forum, it does not take much more effort to include the regulator. Folks need to hear from the regulator and gain answers to concerns they may have. Lacking regulator presence provides an avenue for misunderstandings of what is permissible according to the regulations and what regulations exactly are in effect. (23) Response: The department encourages applicants to engage the community in which their project is planned. Should the applicant choose to hold their own public meeting(s), the department also encourages applicants to invite appropriate department staff. While the department lacks the authority to require its staff be invited, the public can address any questions or concerns to the department separately if needed. 78. Comment: The commentator recommends that Section IV, Part C, Paragraph 1 be edited to indicate that public information meetings may take place “at the department’s and/or applicant’s discretion.” (26) Response: Paragraph 1 discusses specific public notification requirements that the department will implement as a matter of policy when public information meetings are held at the department’s discretion. While Paragraph 3 states that the applicant can hold meetings of their own, applicants should refer to the applicable statute and/or regulation for specific requirements concerning public notice requirements for their application. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 94 79. Comment: The Commentator asks why comments at public information meetings do not become part of the record. (26) Response: The purpose of a public information meeting is to provide information and foster a dialog about a proposed project. Such meetings also provide an opportunity for potential commentators to ask questions while they are formulating their official comments. The formality of recording and transcribing the comments and questions during a public information meeting would discourage the open dialog that the department wishes to achieve. Should participants want to have their comments or questions included in the record, they may submit them as testimony during a public hearing and/or as written comments. 80. Comment: The commentator supports Public Information meetings and agrees that such meetings shouldn’t be substituted for a public hearing. The Commentator recommends that that these information sessions will always include a question-and-answer component. The Department should avail itself of all resources available to design and hold a productive public information meeting, including the Department’s Environmental Advocate for the region involved. (31) Response: The department has revised the policy to include a reference to the question-andanswer component and participation of the Office of the Environmental Advocate, Community Relations Coordinators, Local Government Liaisons, and other appropriate staff. 81. Comment: Pennsylvania has led the nation in utilizing the public information meeting format to communicate about projects to communities. The section states that such meetings would occur at the Department's discretion. The commentator would suggest that an applicant desirous of such a meeting should also be given that discretion. There are very specific meeting notice provisions; the commentator would suggest that following the word 'will' on line 4 that the word 'generally' be placed to enable more fluid decision making with regard to such meetings. (6) Response: While the department recognizes the applicant and other organizations may choose to hold public meetings, the guidance in this policy is only applicable to meetings conducted by the department. IV.D: Informal Meetings 82. Comment: The commentator requests the language in section IV.D. of the document be restored to the version in the prior document where it explicitly stated the department would act as an advocate for protecting human health and the environment. (29) Response: Section IV.D. of the prior version of the policy applied specifically to the department’s role at hearings, public meetings and informal meetings. That section was replaced with Section V. of the current policy. In Section V, the department clarifies that in a venue that allows for public dialog, the department’s role is to communicate factual information. It further clarifies that the department is not to act as an advocate for or against the issuance of the permit. Taking an advocacy position at public meetings can discourage open dialog, and is inconsistent with the department’s goals for the public participation process. 83. Comment: All public comment should become part of the official record. Given the aforementioned format of the new “informal public conferences,” it is impossible for this to 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 95 occur given much of the comment occurs off the record at the stations set up by the department, and comments are only recorded if someone wishes to articulate his or her concerns into the recorder device. Is the only way people will be able to ensure that their comments become part of the official record to send them directly to DEP? Is it necessary that they state they want their comments to become part of the official record? (30) Response: For public comments to become part of the official record and considered during the permit process they must be submitted in writing during the public comment period or presented as oral testimony during a public hearing. This is consistent with the procedure used for development of both regulations and non-regulatory guidance. Informal meetings may be held to address questions in a less formal environment. While information from such meetings is often helpful in developing formal comments, the content of the meeting does not become part of the official record. 84. Comment: Regarding Informal Meetings, the commentator suggests that the Department should give some criteria as to how it is determined who is invited, in the interest of transparency. (5) Response: The department agrees and has revised the guidance accordingly. 85. Comment: “Open House” formats are not a defined type of public meeting in Pennsylvania and the Department must cease substituting these unclear meetings for true public hearings. (8) Response: As this policy indicates, the department may use less formal types of meetings to foster dialog with the public, but those sessions are not used as a substitute for a public hearing. Open House formats are a type of informal meeting, for which the intent is to supplement the other avenues for providing input to the Department. 86. Comment: The commentator supports the concept of these conferences as a way for all types of stakeholders to voice their concerns and ask questions of Department staff, but recommends that the policy specify that the Department will respond to and consider all requests for informal conferences equally. This is necessary to avoid the perception or reality of undue influence over permit decisions by applicants and “back-room deals” being worked out directly with the Department, without negotiations ”seeing the light of day” and without the consideration of public input. This change is also necessary to be consistent with the statement in Section V of the proposed policy, which we fully support, that the Department’s role is “communicating to the public the factual information related to the project” and not to “act as an advocate for or against issuance of a permit.” (31) Response: While the department recognizes the concern raised by the commentator, resource considerations may make it necessary to prioritize certain requests over others. Accordingly, the department has revised the guidance to reflect that, while all requests for informal meetings are considered on a case-by-case basis, the department may give added weight to parties involved in or potentially impacted by the proposed project. 87. Comment: In Section IV.D., relating to Informal Meetings, it is not clear when meetings might occur in the review process. The existing Policy contains specific instructions on the meetings and the current wording should be retained. Also, even though the content of the meeting may not become part of the official record, there should be a provision added stating that a record of 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 96 all informal conferences shall be made and retained in the project file, especially in those cases where the meeting is required by statute or regulation. In addition, if new information is developed during an Informal Meeting, it should be handled under the “New Information” process recommended previously. (7) Response: Because informal meetings are an important tool for public outreach and information, the procedural requirements for such meetings have intentionally been kept to a minimum. However, Section IV(D) states that informal meetings will be held when required by statute or regulation or at other times in the review process at the department’s discretion. Specifically and where possible, the department will schedule informal meetings in a timeframe that will allow participants to utilize information from the meeting to develop their official comments. If informal meeting(s) are held, the date(s) of the meeting(s) will be indicated on the cover page of the Comment-Response Document as indicated in Attachment A of the policy. 88. Comment: The commentator recommends there be a system by which residents know that they could request an Informal Conference. They are also helpful when folks are more interested in information than testifying at a hearing. Ideally, the Conference needs to be scheduled prior to the issuance of the permit. There needs to be adequate time for a requestor and others to submit an official comment if they so desire. In such cases involving a general permit, the conference ideally will occur prior to commencement of construction. (23, 29) Response: The policy has been revised to indicate such meetings can be requested by the public and the scheduling should be such that participants can use information from such meetings in the development of their official comments. No permit decision will be made prior to any scheduled public hearing, public meeting or informal meeting. 89. Comment: Informal public conferences were once held so that the community could meet and discuss the proposed application. Comments were recorded and included in the Comment and Response Documents. People were able to air their concerns to the Department and to their neighbors. In addition they were given a venue in which to provide information frequently absent from the application—locations where people have private water supplies; where businesses serve numerous people who rely on their private water supplies; and buildings missing from the permittee’s maps. (30) Response: The department continues to conduct public meetings but the policy clarifies that, in keeping with their informal nature, transcripts of these meetings are not made and comments do not become part of the official record. Public meetings are often followed by public hearings where the testimony is transcribed and comments do become part of the record. Any new information brought to the attention of the department, whether of a formal or informal nature, will be considered when making a permit decision. 90. Comment: The Department has changed the format of these public hearings, now choosing to hold “informal public conferences which seriously limits the opportunity for meaningful public participation. Community members are told they cannot speak publicly at these forums, although the permittee was given a significant portion of the time scheduled to present its plans for the future of their community. This hardly supports the Department’s commitment to the critical component of public input and participation. (30) 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 97 Response: The policy clarifies the differences between formal public hearings and less formal meetings and the purposes of these different types of public forums. Section VI: Extension of Public Comment Period 91. Comment: When projects change sufficiently to warrant additional public review and comment, DEP should notify the affected municipalities and counties in addition to the individuals who previously provided comments on the initial permit application. (2) Response: Municipalities are encouraged to sign-up for eNotice alerts related to permitting activities in their communities. In addition, the department encourages its Local Government Liaisons to forward public notices to the affected municipalities in their area. In accordance with Section VI of the policy, when the public comment period is extended due significant changes to the project the department will publish appropriate notice of the extension in the same venues in which the original notice was published, and will notify all individuals who provided comments on the initial permit application. 92. Comment: Under Section VI relating to Republication to Afford Additional Public Participation, the commentator recommends that the Department retain the language found in the current Policy which states “the Department will consider whether it is appropriate or useful to afford an additional opportunity for public review and comment”, rather than revise the wording as proposed to the “Department may consider”. (7) Response: The department agrees and has included the requested language. 93. Comment: In reviewing the draft public participation policy, the commentator notices that some of the detail from the current policy (dated July 16, 2005) has not transferred to the draft policy. For instance, on page five of the draft policy, the section on republication indicates that when a project “changes substantially” during the review of the application, DEP may consider whether it is appropriate or useful to afford an additional opportunity for public review and comment. The same section on page 7 of the current policy contains specific criteria as to the meaning of “changes substantially,” such as a change of thirty percent or more in the size of the facility or activity, change in the location of the project or change in the environmental impact of the project, which are not in the draft policy. The commentator recommends that DEP retain these or similar criteria in the new policy. (1) Response: Based on experience, the department finds that the need for additional public comment is best decided on a case-by-case basis. Specific criteria were removed to avoid giving the false impression that the listed conditions represent either the minimum threshold to trigger additional comment opportunities or automatic triggers for such opportunities. Section VII: Comment-Response Document 94. Comment: The Comment Response document was once a valuable document, containing substantive information and being sent to the community as part of a give-and-take discussion. The last several the commentator has received came with issuance of the permit and included nothing that really answered the commentator’s questions or comments. (30) Response: Section VII of the current policy provides specific guidance to the department staff 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 98 on the requirements for the Comment-Response Document. It is the department’s policy that all relevant questions and comments be addressed with appropriate answers. VII.A: Format of Comment-Response Document/Attachment A 95. Comment: The current policy notes that “appropriate steps will be taken during the review of an application to address concerns, and the review of relevant comments should occur during the application review rather than held until the end of the process” and that “if the Department does not address the relevant comment through the permit decision, Department staff will provide a reasonable explanation of the Department’s position” (page 4). On page 8, the policy further indicates that “if the Department does not agree with a comment, the document should say so and should provide a reason for rejecting the comment.” This level of consideration for comments with which the Department does not agree or does not address does not appear in the draft policy, but rather simply that a “substantive response” should be provided to each relevant comment (page 2). Under the Comment and Response section of the draft policy (page 6), the Department is required to indicate its agreement with comments and how those comments are addressed, but then notes that the Department may not agree with a comment without requiring an explanation for the disagreement as in the current policy. To encourage better understanding on all sides throughout the permit process, we would encourage DEP to carry over language requiring the Department to respond thoughtfully both to comments with which they agree and comments with which they do not agree. (1) Response: The department agrees and has revised the policy accordingly. 96. Comment: The proposed revisions to Section VII, subsection A. should prove helpful to those responsible for preparing a comment/response document. It includes instruction on what to do if the Department agrees with a comment, but is missing instruction if the Department disagrees with a comment. The commentator recommends that the following sentence, which is contained in Section III. General Policy of the current Policy, be retained in the proposed Policy and moved to Section V.A. Specifically, the sentence to be retained reads: If the Department does not address the relevant comment through the permit decision, Department staff will provide a reasonable explanation of the Department’s position. (7) Response: The department agrees and has revised the policy accordingly. 97. Comment: All documents cited or referred to in a Comment Response document must be made available to the public by publication on the Internet. This is unacceptable. By basing a reply to the commentator’s comment on information the “Department has recently received”, DEP responded to the commentator’s comment using private information. This should not be allowed. The instructions for preparing a Comment Response document must make clear that all information used as the basis for a response must be either contained in or attached to the Comment Response document or cited from public information. (29) Response: The department is currently pursuing initiatives that will allow electronic submission of permit applications and supporting documents. As these systems begin operation, the department may be able to expand the amount of information posted. While the department currently lacks the resources to publish every permit-related document it receives online, such documents are added to the relevant file and available to the public during a file review. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 99 98. Comment: The commentator supports the requirement that the Department responds to each relevant comment, including hearing comments, and that these responses are published in a Comment and Response Document or a Record of Decision. A public document that fully reports the public input and the agency’s response requires justification by the agency of its decisions and shows how the public input influenced the final outcome, lending validity to the process. The documentation of comments ensures much-needed agency transparency. Without it, the public is left in the dark regarding the basis for final permit decisions, the undue influence of project applicants on permit decisions may be reasonably suspected, and the very legitimacy of the agency’s work may be called into question. (31) Response: The department appreciates the supportive comments. 99. Comment: With respect to comments from public hearings and informal conferences, the commentator requests that a timeframe (such as 30-60 days) be required for DEP responses or actions. (32) Response: While the department wishes to avoid any unnecessary delays in its decision making, it is also committed to complete and thorough consideration of all public comments. Because of the potential volume and complexity of comments, the department cannot commit to a specific timeframe. 100. Comment: Attachment A FORMAT FOR COMMENT AND RESPONSE DOCUMENT is lacking several items required by Section VII.A. Format: (1) Public comment period dates; (2) Public hearing date(s), if any; and (3) Public Information Meeting/Informal Meeting date(s), if any. If these items are to be included on the cover page, per the policy document, they should be included on the sample document. (3) Response: The department agrees and has revised the policy accordingly. 101. Comment: The commentator requests that VII part A be edited to say “If the Department does not agree with a comment, the document should say so and should provide a reason or reason for rejecting the comment.” (26) Response: The department has revised the section in question to address this concern. VII.B: Public Availability of the Comment-Response Document 102. Comment: On page 6 of the draft policy, the comment and response document is required to be made available to the public at the time the Department renders a decision on the permit application, but on page 2 it is indicated that the Document may also be made available earlier in the process if appropriate. We recommend the language on page 6 be updated to include the “earlier if appropriate” designation for clarity and consistency. (1) Response: The department agrees and has made the requested change. 103. Comment: The commentator recommends that the comment and response document be provided via email (or made available online) to all participants who submitted comments. (20, 23) 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 100 Response: It is the department’s policy that all commentators who have left appropriate contact information are to be notified of the Comment-Response Document’s availability. Because of technical limitations with bulk emailing of potentially large documents, the department will generally provide a link to the document rather than attach the document itself. 104. Comment: All Comment Response documents must be made available to the public by publication on the Internet. Issues brought up in Public Comment periods tend to recur in permit after permit. While a commenter on a specific permit will receive the Comment Response document on that permit, a commenter will not likely have access to Comment Response documents for earlier permits in which the same issue may have been raised. So while a commenter may be informed by a Comment Response document, the public in general is not. All Comment Response documents must be published on the Internet, and Policy should establish this as DEP’s requirement. (29) Response: The department agrees and is working to ensure all documents are posted appropriately. 105. Comment: It is imperative that a comment/response document is issued before or concurrent with the issuance of the permit. Numerous times Commenters have been notified of permit issuance in the Pennsylvania Bulletin prior to receipt of responses to significant comments. (24) Response: The department agrees and this provision is included in the policy. VII.C: Relation of Comment-Response Document to Other Department Policies Land Use 106. Comment: Several commentators point out inconsistent statements in the draft Policy regarding consideration of public comments, and request that comments from the public regarding land use issues during the public comment period be considered under this Policy. (1, 2, 3, 5, 31) Response: The department agrees with these comments and the Policy has been revised accordingly. 107. Comment: Decisions should be made primarily by those on the ground who fully understand our townships and boroughs, instead of unilateral decision-making by bureaucrats in Harrisburg or DC. Our local ordinances and local laws must be given their proper legal weight. (4) Response: The department believes that the concern described within this comment is addressed by this policy and the Policy for Consideration of Local Comprehensive Plans and Zoning Ordinances in DEP Review of Authorization for Facilities and Infrastructure (DEP ID: 012-0200-001). Section VIII: Additional Information 108. Comment: New Section VIII. Additional Information is a helpful addition to the Policy; however, the section does not contain enough instruction explaining the Permit Applicant Outreach Activities Checklist (0110-FM-CO0110) and how it should be used. Not until you 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 101 track down the Checklist in the eLibrary is it clear that the Department intends for the Checklist to be completed by the applicant and submitted as part of the application package. It is not clear how DEP would consider the information provided on the Checklist. Also, it would be more convenient if the Checklist were offered as an appendix or attachment to the Policy rather than located elsewhere. (7) Response: The department has decided to rescind the “Permit Applicant Outreach Activities Checklist” in order to prevent confusion. It will no longer be available for use. The information contained in the checklist may be available in a Fact Sheet moving forward. General/Miscellaneous Comments 109. Comment: The commentator recommends that the Department expand its disclaimer that “the Department reserves the discretion to deviate from this policy” in order to spell out and clarify which circumstances would warrant deviation. (31) Response: The language in question is standard language used on all of the department’s policies and technical guidance documents. This language makes it clear that the documents do not create enforceable requirements. In addition, it would be impractical to describe how department staff may apply their discretion in the myriad of situations throughout the state, and under a variety of regulatory frameworks, when using the policy. 110. Comment: The commentator states the public participation process is perfunctory and that, if the applicant has followed procedures, the department has no will to deny a permit application, based on issues raised by neighbors property value, quality of life or potentially, family’s health. (29) Response: The department disagrees. Permit and other decisions are made using the applicable statutory and regulatory criteria. 111. Comment: The commentator states that, by removing Article 1, Section 27 of the Pennsylvania Constitution as an authority, the department is “attempting a kind of de facto, back door repeal” of the article. The commentator request it be restored as an authority. (29) Response: The department disagrees. Removing the reference to the constitutional provision does not affect the scope of the legal authority for this policy. 112. Comment: The commentator notes that the use of “significant local interest” is a subjective standard and recommends the policy provide more clarity. (3, 5, 23, 31, 32) Response: Based on experience, the department finds that the need for additional public comment is best decided on a case-by-case basis. Specific criteria were removed to avoid indicating that the listed conditions represent either the minimum threshold to trigger additional comment opportunities or automatic triggers for such opportunities. 113. Comment: The commentators state that the policy would not be applicable for general permits and permits by rule, particularly General Permit 5 (GP-5). The commentators urge the department to change the participation policy to allow public participation and to hold public information meetings regarding facilities using general permits, particularly when they are in 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 102 close proximity to each other. (7, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 16, 21, 22, 24, 27, 28, 29, 31, 33 – 1,803) Response: The purpose of this policy is to provide a general guide to public participation in permitting and other approval processes. These comments address specific programs with their own regulatory requirements, which are beyond the scope of this policy. In addition, the Department has recently issued the general permits mentioned, during which extensive public comment was received and taken into consideration. Any questions about those permits and the associated processes should be directed to the applicable department program. See also Comment 18. 114. Comment: The commentator requests that, all determinations that a source of air pollution is a minor source (especially determinations of synthetic minor source) must be subject to Public Participation, further stating that the determination that specific “artificial” emissions limits establish a site as a synthetic minor source can only be done by examining the specifics of that site. (29) Response: As previously noted, the purpose of this Policy is to provide a general guide to public participation in permitting and other approval processes. These comments address specific programs with their own regulatory requirements, which are beyond the scope of this policy. Nevertheless, air contamination source permitting decisions are subject to the regulatory requirements under 25 Pa. Code Section 127.44 (relating to public notice). 115. Comment: Synthetic minor sources should not in any case be accepted as eligible for GP-5, and must be given full public participation. (29) Response: General permits are used when a specific class of sources can be regulated using standardized specifications and conditions. By issuing a general permit, the department indicates that it approves the activities authorized by the general permit, provided that the owner or operator of the source meets the requirements of the general permit. 116. Comment: The commentator states that public participation must be allowed on any Plan Approval application (general or otherwise) which seeks to establish federally enforceable emissions limits. DEP’s response to EPA’s comment that a permit under GP-5 would not be federally enforceable—due to lack of public participation—was to acknowledge that “the permit” is not federally enforceable but “the emissions limits” are. This ignores completely the determination that the claimed emissions limits apply to the particular facility covered in the application. To state that certain emissions limits (in the abstract) are “federally enforceable” while ignoring clear guidance from EPA that there must be public participation in the determination that these limits apply is unacceptable. DEP must allow public participation in all minor source determinations. (29) Response: When the department first proposes any general permit for an air contamination source a public comment period is provided as required under 25 Pa. Code Section 127.612. The department provided this public comment process when it initially developed GP-5. This comment period is to allow public participation in the development of the specific requirements contained within the general permit. The GP-5 amendments were finalized after a thorough public participation process. When a company wishes to use GP-5 it must demonstrate to the department that the engine (or 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 103 engines) it wishes to install meets the requirements specified by GP-5. If it does, the department authorizes the company to use GP-5 and issues a notice to that effect in the Pennsylvania Bulletin. The public comment provisions under Section 127.612 are not applicable each time the department wants to authorize the use of GP-5. The public comment provisions are only applicable when the department first proposes or proposes revisions to the general permit. The department then finalizes the general permit for use by anyone who can comply with the specific provisions of the general permit. The standardized terms and conditions of GP-5 cannot be modified during the processing of the authorization to use GP-5. Both the Air Pollution Control Act and the implementing regulations require the department to issue authorizations to use the general permits within 30 days of receipt of an application. The Pennsylvania regulations that establish the use of general permits were approved by U.S. EPA and the company must follow the procedures set forth in the regulations. 117. Comment: Individual MS4 Permits, required for all regulated small MS4s that discharge into HQ or EV waters, are subject to public participation requirements. Regulated small MS4s that discharge into HQ or EV waters subject to wasteload allocations in approved TMDLs must prepare an MS4 TMDL Plan for DEP approval. It is the commentator’s understanding that the process for obtaining DEP approval for MS4 TMDL Plans, as part of Individual Permits submitted for MS4s discharging into HQ/EV waters with approved TMDLs, will be done in two phases: (1) an MS4 TMDL Strategy, submitted with NOIs; and (2) MS4 Design Details, which will be submitted for DEP review no later than one-year following DEP’s issuance of the Individual MS4 Permit. Public participation should be facilitated to allow review and comment of the content submitted within the second of this two-phased approval process for MS4 TMDL Plans. However, it is unclear how that would be facilitated as the draft policy is currently written. (3) Response: Public participation of MS4 TMDL plans will be provided consistent with the permitting requirements; however, discussion of procedures for a specific permit type is beyond the scope of this policy. 118. Comment: All permits should be part of the public review process with opportunity for written and oral comments and with 30 days’ notice. (9) Response: Different application types may be subject to varying public participation requirements by statute or regulation. The department will follow all applicable public participation requirements set forth in statute and regulation, and to the extent that anything in this policy conflicts with a legal requirement, the legal requirement governs. This policy builds upon the existing requirements and provides a consistent framework for required public participation activities. 119. Comment: The commentators urge the department to put all permit applications, technical review documents, and any other associated documents or maps online for free public access and in a timely manner to allow for well-informed comments. (8, 9, 11, 13, 14, 16, 17, 20, 21, 24, 25, 27, 28, 29, 33 – 270 ) 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 104 Response: The department recognizes the value of posting these documents online and is currently developing systems that will allow electronic submission of permit information. The ability to receive data in electronic format may allow for such posting and is one of the key benefits of electronic permitting projects currently underway. 120. Comment: The commentators stress the importance of ensuring timely access to permit files. (8, 9, 20, 21, 24, 28, 33 – 270 , 477 – 1,803) Response: The department agrees with this comment and has worked to improve streamlining the informal file review procedures. 121. Comment: PA DEP decisions to deem permit applications “administratively complete” before relevant technical data is submitted deprives the public of the opportunity to submit accurate public comments and must be prohibited. (8) Response: An administratively incomplete application is not generally considered to be an application, because some of the most basic elements are missing. Additionally, an application will not be deemed “administratively complete” if it does not include all necessary documents and information that is sufficiently detailed to perform a Technical Review. 122. Comment: When the permittee is required to make significant alterations to their application after the public meeting/conference/hearing, another public notice should be required and another public meeting/conference/hearing should be required (5, 30, 31) Response: There may be circumstances where additional public comment on a revised project is needed but that doesn’t always mean an additional public meeting/conference/hearing is necessary. The department will use its discretion when it determines whether additional public meetings/conferences/hearings are necessary. The department has included guidelines for extension of a public comment period in Section VI of the policy. 123. Comment: A longer public comment period will also help to address the difficulty that members of the public may have in accessing Department files in a timely manner when preparing comment. The current situation is that Department offices regularly do not make files available for public review within two weeks and that gaining access through a file review or Right to Know request can take a large portion of the typical 30 day comment period on a permit. This leaves commenters at a disadvantage in preparing substantive comments by the deadline. If the Department expects informed public comment, then the Department must improve its public information program to allow citizens to review file information in a timelier manner and to routinely provide more information on the Department’s website. (31) Response: The department recognizes this concern and is working to improve access to necessary information. Should there continue to be difficulties, the department may consider extending public comment periods on a case-by-case basis. 124. Comment: As a companion piece to this Policy, the Department should develop a simple easyto-understand brochure designed to inform the public how and when they can be part of the permit process, the resources available to them, and the key times for input. It is especially important to clearly articulate in the brochure the Department’s authority to require changes to a 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 105 project, or lack of authority to deny a permit if it meets all regulatory requirements. It is misleading for the Department to seek public comment if those comments would have no impact or standing in the permit review. Perhaps this brochure could be launched as part of training the Department provides to assist DEP employees in communicating with the public or as a separate information webinar. Council is available to assist in developing the brochure. (7) Response: The department appreciates this suggestion and is in the process of expanding available web and print resources related to public participation. 125. Comment: The commentator emphasizes that it is key to involve neutral facilitators in the public participation process for controversial permits if the Department is going to achieve robust public participation that helps the agency to arrive at a sound decision on a permit or project. The commentator requests that the Department include trained mediators that specialize in this kind of work since the Department no longer is involving the Center for Collaboration and Environmental Dispute Resolution. Environmental Dispute Resolution is a well-developed field that is involved in many areas of regulation and permitting, such as at the federal regulatory level. The commentator advocates that the Department contract an independent professional (not from within PADEP) with this specific training to help design and implement the public participation and public hearing process for controversial permits. (12) Response: The department recognizes the value of trained facilitators in dispute resolution and maintains a dispute resolution and mediation functions. While an important function, it is not within the scope of this policy. 012-0900-003(CR) / March 1, 2014 / Page 106
