Hebron – Luray Area Plan
Transcription
Hebron – Luray Area Plan
Table of Contents This document is….. Introduction……………….....……….…………...….....……......2 A review of the current conditions of the general area of Hebron and Luray. Intended to begin dialogue about the future and potential of this region. A snapshot of possible projects and alterations that could help guide this community to a desirable future. Filled with concepts produced by the LCPC staff, which are not intended to be considered engineered designs or completed projects. There are many projects and designs suggested in this review which should be considered in a concept phase to simply help elaborate upon and illustrate ideas within the plan. General Review...………………....………………………....…...4 How We Got to Where we Are Today…...………………....4 The Community’s Assets……………………………….….....7 Limitations & Threats………………………………..……....11 The Grand Idea………………………..…….……………….….16 Concepts to Help Facilitate Expansion, Build Upon Assets, and Overcome Problem Areas……………....……..…….….…19 Future Use of Land…………………………………...……...19 Flooding Concerns…………………………………………...25 Prime Agricultural Ground…………………………..……...25 Water and Sewer Facilities……………………………...……25 Road Improvements & Connectivity…………….…………26 This document is NOT….. Small-Town Connectivity…………………….…….…...…...29 A Comprehensive Plan. An all-inclusive list of every task or modification that should be considered for this area. A set of recommendations that requires conformance with every suggestion. Any number of suggestions contained in this review can be pursued at the discretion of the appropriate entities. Sense of Place………………………………………................30 National Road Design……………………………..………...34 Attachment A: Conceptual Drawing of Hebron Town Center.......36 Attachment B: Sketch of Crossroads Corridor Concept....…….…37 Attachment C: Bubble Map of Nat’l Trail Raceway Complex…....38 Attachment D: Conceptual Future Land Use Map………………..40 Attachment E: Existing Union Township Draft Zoning Map & Future Land Use Map……………………………………………..41 Attachment F: Existing Village of Hebron Zoning Map & Future Land Use Map…………………………………………………….42 Hebron – Luray Area Plan This review was prepared by the Licking County Planning & Development Department, under Executive Director Gerald Newton. Chris Harkness, Senior Planner, served as the project administrator with assistance from Angela Werner. Additional support was provided by Jay Fisher and Brad Mercer. Adopted by the Licking County Planning Commission on May 19, 2014 under Resolution number 2014-004. On May 29, 2014 this plan was presented to the local officials, residents, business owners, and community stakeholders at the National Trail Raceway. The Licking County Planning Commission would like the thank the following individuals for their contribution of time, information, data, and thoughts that went into this plan: Penny Slater Rick Black Mark Slater Paula Greene Curt Painter Ralph Wise Rob O’Neill Linda Nicodemus Mike Fornataro John Slater Ty Thompson Jim Carter Jason Sturgeon Dan Evers Dan Blatter Kevin Eby Larry Finkes Jack Justice Carolyn Creiglow Brian Harkness Doug Smith ~1~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan is reviewing a series of areas and towns along the National Road in an effort to bring recognition and continuity to this tremendous asset of the county. This corridor brings rich history and a built environment along the historic National Road as well as tremendous opportunity with the National Road’s replacement, Interstate 70. This review also focuses on incorporating a portion of the Ohio Historic National Road Design Handbook. This handbook was administered by the Ohio National Road Association and the Ohio Historic Preservation Office and is intended to give guidance to local agencies and groups to help “preserve, protect, and enhance the very qualities of the National Road that led to its designation as a National Scenic Introduction Area Plan Defined: What is this document? This document is titled the “Hebron--Luray Area Plan” and is intended to be a review of the general vicinity of Hebron Village and the Luray section of Union Township. This review is a snapshot of the planning principles necessary to guide this community into the future. The review area incorporates a large region Byway All-American Road.” This which is generally bounded Hebron – Luray planning area shown on a Licking County map. review integrated many of the by Beaver Run Road, the concepts and ideas from the design handbook and highly South Fork of the Licking River, Interstate 70, and the recommends the continued use of the handbook by local National Trail Raceway. The Licking County Planning officials. Commission staff has compiled this report with additional input from township and village officials, local elected officials, property owners, business owners, developers, and Goals of the Area Plan: the Ohio Department of Transportation, District 5 (ODOT). This review is not a comprehensive plan and is What do you hope to achieve with this not intended to be used as such. document? Purpose: Why are you reviewing the Hebron and Luray area? In large part this review is simply intended to initiate a conversation surrounding the future of the Hebron/Luray community. This is a community that has already spent time planning for the future and sees the benefits of guiding the community through these efforts. This is an essential time The purpose of this review is to evaluate the current to intensify the efforts to steer this region toward a common conditions of the Hebron and Luray area and propose key vision. It is our hope that this review also sparks investment concepts to help guide the area in a positive direction. In and enthusiasm about the community’s future. This truly is a addition, water and sewer is available to be extended into special place in Licking County, worthy of financial Union Township. These new services would have the ability investment and the devotion of to spur development and change the the community’s time and local landscape in the near future. The "to assist the local entities......in resources. Investments are made Licking County Planning Commission dismantling any potential threats that when people are excited about an staff seeks to facilitate proper planning may be looming and capitalizing on area and have hope for the future, at a critical time in the history of this region. This review is intended to assist the budding opportunities available in whether that investment takes the form of rehabbing an existing the local entities in dismantling any this terrific area of Licking County." home, redeveloping a business, potential threats that may be looming constructing a new development, and capitalizing on the budding providing funding for public improvement projects, or opportunities available in this terrific area of Licking County. simply setting aside personal time to better the community. Additionally, the Licking County Planning Commission staff ~2~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan This review is also intended to give suggestions and concepts aimed at reestablishing and promoting a positive identity for the region. Further, many of the proposals in this review are deliberately aimed at preventing the weakening of the community's identity with the National Road which brings a wealth of history and unique qualities. Implementation of the Area Plan: How do I apply this plan? This review will be most helpful to the Board of Trustees and Village Council within the local entities (Union Township and Village of Hebron) as they are the key factor in the implementation of these recommendations. It will also be helpful for the Licking County Board of Commissioners in implementing countywide items. However, this review is intended to benefit the entire area, including residents, business owners, and prospective investors. Therefore, any entity, group, or individual may find use in the review and proceed with one of the concepts. As stated above, this document is not a specific plan for any individual entity and therefore it is not expected that this document will necessarily be adopted by any particular local entity, or any other organization. It is also not anticipated that all of the proposals in this document will be agreed upon or deemed feasible by any one entity. However, it is our hope that many of the concepts presented in this document, or variations of the concepts, will be welcomed and initiated by the appropriate organizations. In addition, if any particular entity does desire to adopt this area plan we would encourage them to do that. The Licking County Planning Commission staff is willing to help guide any organization toward the implementation of the goals and concepts outlined in this review for the betterment of the Hebron and Luray area. Hebron – Luray planning area boundary map. ~3~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan General Review How We Got to Where We Are Today At a quick glance one could potentially misconstrue this region as merely a small town on one end and an intersection of two highways at the other end, without many assets in between. However, after spending any amount of time in this area one would find that perspective to be far from reality. This region boasts a proud and unique history that has shaped much its current setting. This community's rich past has carved character and spirit into the built environment, the infrastructure, the businesses, and the local flavor. The modern establishment of this area occurred in the early 19th century when pioneers began the process of primitively settling here. However, it wasn’t long before two significant construction projects would bring abundant life to this community, the Ohio & Erie Canal and the National Road. The new canal would reach Hebron in 1831 with the National Road being extended through the area in 1833. A region that was recently considered pioneer wilderness quickly grew into a booming center of agricultural production, shipping goods, and traveler accommodations. This new farming and industrial community flourished Birth of Hebron & Luray The construction of the National Road began in 1811 and was intended to open trade and travel to the west. The construction began in Cumberland, Maryland and the road reached the Ohio River at Wheeling by 1818. In the 1820s the U.S. Congress authorized the continuation of the National Road into Ohio. At the same time period the Ohio Legislature had authorized a survey of the planned Ohio and Erie Canal system. With the construction of these two projects looming, some savvy local land owners took advantage of their locations by platting “pike towns” which would accommodate the surveyed alignments of the National Road and the Ohio and Erie Canal. Hence, the town of Hebron was born in 1827 with a plat by property owner John Smith which was oriented around the road and the canal. It was a mere five years later when a second pike town was produced in the area when Luray was platted in 1832. Original Plat of Hebron (1827) Looking south across the Ohio & Erie Canal into town and at the National Road bridge, 1910 (Photo courtesy of Doug Smith Collection). National Road through Hebron, 1910 (Photo courtesy of Doug Smith Collection). Original Plat of Luray (1832) ~4~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan through most of the 19th After a period of decline in the late 19th and early 20th century with the aid of The Crossroads these two assets, the canal centuries, Hebron and Luray received another shot in the The Ohio and Erie and the National Road. arm with the development of the Ohio Electric Interurban Canal and the Toledo & Even when the role of the rail line out of Columbus. With the onset of this new mode Ohio Central Railroad canals were reduced due to of mass transit and the invention of the automobile, this crossed over the the more efficient railroad region was back in business. The early 20th century brought National Road less than system in the mid 1800s, growth in the form of several platted additions to Hebron 1,000 feet from one this area still thrived as the on both the east and west sides of town. another. The locations Toledo and Ohio of the crossings were Central Railway near the modern day was extended into intersections of Hebron National Road and immediately west Basin Street and the of the junction of National Road and West the canal and the Street. National Road. With the railroad and the canal both crossing the National Road in the center of Hebron, the town bustled with activity. The crossings, especially of the canal and National Road, have also given Hebron a unique identity that continues to permeate the region. Many developments and local slogans still reference the “crossroads”. The Village of Hebron’s slogan has become “The Historic Crossroads of Ohio”. Additionally, many other roads, parks, and businesses also celebrate the canal or the National Road as part of their naming Interurban Station and car in Hebron (Courtesy of Hebron Village Website). or marketing. On November 10, 1936 Luray played Modern day examples of history's lasting impact on this region. The names of many businesses and public facilities still reflect the area’s storied past. host to one of the largest sporting events ever held in this country at the time. A crowd of approximately 160,000 gathered at the Oyler farm at the southwest corner of the National Road and Lancaster Road (SR 37) to witness and participate in the State Corn Shocking and the National Corn Husking Contests. At the time, corn husking was a national pastime. In 1936 TIME Magazine declared corn husking "...the fastest growing sporting spectacle in the world." This contest was broadcast nationally over the radio. It wasn't until World War II that these events halted and then faded away. However, this seemed to foreshadow the large sporting events that would soon be held regularly among these cornfields with the onset ~5~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan November 11, 1936 Columbus Dispatch article on the National Corn Husking Contest held in Luray. The contest site, the Oyler farm at the southwest corner of SR 37 and National Road, is shown in the aerial view above. (Photo courtesy of the Doug Smith Collection) of the National Trail Raceway. The 1950s brought another major construction project to provide a modern upgrade to the National Road nearly 125 years after its opening. Interstate 70, one of the first federal interstate highways, was constructed through the Hebron and Luray region in 1959. National Trail Raceway Opened in 1964 by the Rader family. Hosted the NHRA SpringNationals for the first time in 1972. The crowds exceeded 120,000 during the 1990s. 1996, the track was purchased by the NHRA from the Rader family. The NHRA constructed a new VIP and operations tower and brought several other improvements. In 2007 the NHRA Nationals event (f.k.a Springnationals and Pontiac Performance Nationals) was moved from the NTR to the Summit Motorsports Park in Norwalk, OH. This project, much like the National Road and Ohio and Erie Canal, also sparked the interest of local businessmen. Clark Rader Sr. broke ground on a 320 acre racing facility on the National Road in 1963. The construction was completed in 1964, and so began the National Trail Raceway. A few years later (late 1960s) another businessman would capitalize on the tremendous transportation infrastructure of this area and the newly constructed Interstate system. Jack O’Neill, founder of Southgate Corporation, began developing the Newark Ohio Industrial Park. Both the National Trail Raceway and the Newark Ohio Industrial Park are key assets to this community and have played a big role in shaping the current character and conditions of this region. The late 1980s into the 1990s brought more noteworthy changes to the area. This rural farming community was confronted with a new challenge when several large-lot subdivisions were created and developed right in the heart of the rural portion of Union Township. This type of subdivision development had not previously been prevalent throughout most of the township. A change in the atmosphere and mood of the rural countryside would follow ~6~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan New Homes in Union Twp Late ‘80s – ‘90s Subdivision Year Platted No. Lots Pinecrest Estates **1974 22 Waters Edge Estates 1994-2000 52 Canyon Villa Estates 1992 17 Hartman Farms 1995 25 Individual Lots on Beaver Run / Late ‘80s – ‘90s ~50 Canyon / Blacks **Most homes not built until late ‘80s and early ‘90s. the new residential growth and a rural residential character bloomed. In 1995 ODOT constructed the SR 79 bypass of Hebron. No longer did excessive volumes of traffic flow up and down High Street. Instead most of the regional traffic now bypassed the town completely. This too had an effect on the character of the area, especially the town of Hebron. By changing the traffic flow, some of the service oriented businesses within the town were negatively affected, while many manufacturing and logistics businesses in the industrial park benefited. Throughout the mid 1990s a new green space was being planned in Hebron at the northwest edge of town. By the late ‘90s and early 2000s, Evans Park was well under way. Phase 1 of the overall park master plan has been completed through the coordinated effort of multiple agencies and funds including the Village of Hebron, Union Township, T.J. Evans Foundation, Ohio Department of Natural Resources, and several private and non-profit organizations. The result of these efforts is a tremendous accomplishment for the area that now boasts a nearly 50 acre park which includes: an attractive wetland area, 4 baseball fields, soccer and football fields, 2 basketball courts, a playground area, a disc golf course, and a multi-use path (0.8 miles). The Community’s Assets: As just alluded to, this region has a unique and interesting story which helps residents and business owners understand the community at a deeper level. This “story” is one the best assets a community can embrace. The individual history of an area provides a sense of pride, a deeper understanding of the community, and building blocks for future development. The positioning of this region has played a huge role in its “Location, location, prosperity throughout the location…” generations. From the beginning, this area has benefited from its excellent location. If it weren’t for the National Road and the Ohio and Erie Canal, Hebron and Luray would likely never have existed. The location of this area is still a tremendous asset today. The area is still served by superior transportation and shipping facilities. The National Road now functions as a local collector highway with SR 37 and SR 79 both functioning as key north/south arterial highways for the region. Interstate 70 provides the largest transportation advantage to the area as it carries Approximate AADT (Average Adjusted Daily Traffic) Counts State Route 79: 13,000 - 18,000 State Route 37: 9,000 - 14,000 U.S. 40 / National Road: 3,000 - 7,000 Interstate 70: 41,000 - 52,000 vehicles across and through the state at the highest rate of speeds allowed in Ohio. These highways allow for expedient travel to several local markets (Newark, Lancaster, Zanesville), the Columbus regional market, and other major Midwestern markets. The majority of this planning area can access Interstate 70 within 2 miles. The significance of this detail is displayed with the arrival of an employee to downtown Columbus, a shopper to Easton Town Center, or a truck driver to Rickenbacker International Airport, all within less than a half hour from Hebron. Local Community Assets Unique Hist or y Locat ion & Proximit y t o market s Near Buckeye Lake & Dawes Ar boret um Safe small-t o wn set t ing Walkable co mmunit y St rong neighborhoods and affordable housing Pr ime far mland and agr icult ural businesses Nat ional Trail Raceway Newark Ohio Indust r ial Park Regio nal co mmer cial acco mmodat ions Out st anding local bus inesses Valuable park s and green spaces Co mmunit y Support ~7~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan with many people from this area it appears that is a common thread that is shared amongst many. The small town feeling is enhanced by being exceptionally walkable with a majority of the town being connected via sidewalks, paths, or interconnecting low-volume streets. The reason the residents of the area feel safe is because in comparison to other areas, they are. The crime rates for Hebron are typically much lower than the U.S. average. In addition, the crime rates for Hebron are also well below neighboring communities such as Buckeye Lake, Heath, and Newark. Another discovery from our review is that there appears to be an abundance of stable residential neighborhoods in this area. There is not a vast amount of diversity in the local housing stock, but for an older small town the neighborhoods have been well maintained, alluding to a sense of pride in the community. The homes are also of a more affordable range. The estimated average house value in Hebron is around $104,000, which is less than the average house value for Heath, Newark, Pataskala, and the State of Ohio. In contrast the average house value in Union Township is approximately $123,000. The newer large lot residential subdivisions have certainly played a part in the gap in these two averages. This location also benefits from being only a few miles from a prominent water attraction and a premier public park. Buckeye Lake was originally built as a reservoir to feed the canal system, but today it has become a popular vacation spot for those interested in boating, fishing, and water recreation. The Dawes Arboretum is one of the most attractive landscape gardens in the country and is a local treasure that brings visitors from great distances to take in the beautiful scenery and learn about nature. These attractions are recreational benefits to the Hebron and Luray area residents but they also draw visitors to the local (Based on available data from city‐data.com) businesses. Average Crime Rates Since 2008 The small town setting of Hebron and the rural setting of the surrounding countryside appear to be a desirable atmosphere for most of the residents in the area. According to the Hebron Comprehensive Plan, two of the main reasons why people live in Hebron are the small town atmosphere and the low crime rate. In speaking 500 450 400 466.1 350 300 315.7 250 306.9 200 150 100 104.5 117.7 50 0 Pataskala Hebron Heath Newark Buckeye Lake Average crime rates for Hebron and other local communities since 2008. Rates are based upon factors such as number of crimes per capita, additional daily population, and seriousness of crimes. ~8~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan The National Trail Raceway, which got its start in 1964, holds numerous racing events throughout the spring, summer and fall months, with approximately 100 racing days per year. The quarter-mile raceway and facility is owned and operated by the NHRA (National Hot Rod Association). This business provides the largest tourist draw in Licking County. The racing events provide an influx of thousands of spectators and Prime Agricultural Map with the prime agricultural lands shown in brown. (Map from Hebron Master Plan) participants that For nearly 200 years, during the modern era, this spend large amounts of money locally on gas, food, and community has benefited from highly productive lodging. During the larger racing events (e.g. MOPAR farmland. The soils are conducive to growing crops such as Nationals) it is difficult to find a hotel room in the county corn, wheat, and soybean. There is some animal husbandry because of the number of visitors. This facility has achieved of livestock in this area, but most of the agricultural activity great success, but it has yet to translate into the creation of is related to the production of food products. This industry service and ancillary businesses surrounding the raceway. is a boon for the community in multiple ways. As a result of There is some untapped potential with regards to the the farming community there is locally grown food, taxable National Trail Raceway and what it can facilitate for this property with very little cost to the community, beneficial area. use of undevelopable property, and sources of employment and income which are infused back into the community. In There are approximately 4,000 people employed at the addition there is an element of Agri-tourism that has spun Newark Ohio Industrial Park. They are employees of 41 off from the different companies which make up nearly 6.2 million square local farming feet of floor space. These activities of the companies are involved in a Newark Ohio area. Both the range of manufacturing, Industrial Park Devine Farms industrial, warehousing, and and Pigeon logistics activities. Specifically 4,000+ Jobs Roost Farms there are a number of businesses 41 Businesses facilities bring related to automotive and exciting family 48 Buildings plastics manufacturing. The park fun to the area has proven its viability as a solid 6,200,000 during the fall environment for business and season with hay rides, petting square feet of industry as it has steadily grown zoo, corn maze, pumpkin floor space over the past 45 years. There is patches, and outdoor play currently only about 300,000 Over 600 acres areas. square feet of potential building ~9~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan space remaining at the park. It appears that groundwork is already in place to expand the park and continue to capitalize on the location and the existing development. The Village of Hebron has plenty of capacity with their water and sewer facilities, a solid transportation network, and there is a high quality workforce. An expansion of the park could lead to more sites served by railroad which have become more uncommon in recent years. In short, the Newark Ohio Industrial Park has added massive employment opportunities, big business, and tax revenue to this area. Other local businesses have also served the region well. One such business, MPW Industrial Services, has a story with humble beginnings and has grown rapidly over the 40 years of its existence. MPW is a business that is growing quickly and future needs may dictate the extension of water and sewer services to their headquarters. Many other businesses in the Luray area could also benefit from water and sewer expansion. A newer commercial complex was developed after the SR 79 bypass was completed. This area serves as an excellent regional marketplace and is anchored by a Kroger grocery store and Buckeye Outdoors. There have been additions to the Kroger center within the last 10 years but some of the commercial spaces are currently empty. If necessary in the future, there is room for retail and service expansion. There is also a strong contingent of local, non-franchise, businesses sprinkled throughout the region. Many of those businesses are considered staples of the community, such as; Hayman's Dari-Bar, Clay's Cafe, Sunset Inn, and UniPAC. High quality green spaces and parks are assets desired by most communities. This region is blessed with several terrific park settings. Not only are Dawes Arboretum and the Infirmary Mound Park nearby, there are also two great local parks right in the heart of this community. Canal Park is located in downtown Hebron at the former location of the Ohio and Erie Canal. The park functions more as an urban pocket park but is big enough to cater to festivals and larger gatherings. The park contains a shelter house, gazebo, playground, 2 baseball fields, and batting cages. In addition the park functions as the trailhead for the unimproved multi-use trail that runs along the former Toledo and Ohio Central Phase I Phase II Master Plan for Evans Park Athletic Complex. (Map by Environmental Planning Associates in Jan., 2008) ~10~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Railroad tracks. Evans Park is located at the northwest corner of the Village on Refugee Road. This park is placed in a more rural setting and is much larger (74 acres) than Canal Park. Evans Park functions as a regional recreational park with amenities for youth sports, exercising, and recreation. inside of the 100-year floodplain. The inability for flood waters to flow out of the area fast enough causes the South Fork Licking River and Beaver Run to back up into this low area and frequently flood agricultural grounds and other development which has occurred in the floodplain. Furthermore, due to the potential of flooding there is a large increase in the cost and risk of developing anywhere within the 100-year floodplain. Regulatory requirements also add to the challenge of developing in the floodplain. These Another asset of the community is its strong local support. There is a real 'sense' of community in this region. This stems from the multiple ways the community is tied together such as; the Lakewood Local Schools, a defined town center (Hebron), many local organizations (churches, civic associations, etc.), and community events (Hebron Music and Arts Festival, National Road Yard Sale Days, etc.). A sense of pride in a community permeates the entire area and attracts current and future investors. This local support will be a key in any implementation of Floodplain Map. The red area shown on the western fringe of Hebron Village shows approximately 80 acres of future planning land that will likely be removed from the floodplain during FEMA’s current update to the FIRM maps. efforts. Blue = Existing to Remain; Red = Potential Decrease; Green = Potential Increase regulations can be burdensome but their intent In evaluating this area, there is to ensure the potential area Flo o d ing Issue s & Flo o dp la in Limit at io ns were a few items that emerged of flooding is not modified so Defic ient Ho using Var iet y as apparent limitations or as to properly manage this E liminat io n o f Agr icu lt ural Land potential threats for the environmentally sensitive Lac k o f Resid e nt ial Gro wt h community. One of the most area. Developments within Missing a ‘Sense o f P lace’ obvious limitations being the the floodplain have to existence of, and potential for, Lo cal Desig n is no t Co nt ext Sensit ive consider the possibility of flooding within the Co ngest io n at SR 37 and U.S. 40 increased time and expenses designated 100-year resulting from hydraulic and Wat er and Sewer need s in Lur ay floodplain. A large portion of hydrologic studies, site No nexist ent Unified P lan fo r t he Reg io n this area is in a low-lying basin development challenges along the South Fork Licking (which may include raising River, which provides several challenges. Just within this the building site above the flood elevation, significant planning area alone there are well over 2,300 acres that are grading alterations, and the elevation and material used for Limitations & Threats Local Limitations ~11~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan the structures), and the potential of buying flood insurance. These hurdles make it much less desirable to attempt to develop in these areas, even though the land within in the floodplain in this region would otherwise be very attractive for development purposes. As was discussed earlier, the stable residential neighborhoods and abundance of quality affordable housing are strengths of this area. However, there does appear to be a lack of variety in the local housing market. Up until the last 25 years, housing options have traditionally included small village lots, multi-family apartments, or rural residential. More recently, residential development has crept into the township which now provides single-family residential options on two to four acre lots. A medium density suburban style residential subdivision is also in progress on the southern edge of the village as well as a condominium development on the western fringe, both of which provide new housing alternatives to the area. However, both of these developments have stalled due to various reasons, including market demand and the recent economy. Specifically, what seems to be missing are large suburban style residential lots, newer homes, condominium units, and senior housing facilities. It appears there is a deficient number of large-lot residential properties in the area, however there have been nearly 150 of these types of lots Case Study: created over the last 25 years. Placement of The Southwest Licking these subdivisions in Community Water and the rural portions of Sewer District was formed as the township a result of failing sewer exclusively has been a systems of residential downside to their subdivisions in Etna, Lima, development, and Harrison Townships. presenting several Due to the fact that these difficulties. First, as subdivisions were scattered previously mentioned, throughout a rural area in the character of the 1989, the new water and area around Beaver sewer district was forced to Run Road, SR 37, and cover a massive area. This Canyon Road has been significantly altered. A endeavor proved expensive suburban residential and put the district in a flavor has become difficult position from the prevalent in the start. This is not a scenario township. This type that the Hebron and Union of transition, from Township area should look rural to suburban, to repeat. tends to introduce new mindsets and needs in reference to community services and amenities. Second, these large lot subdivisions have developed without public water and sewer services due to their location in the rural countryside. In many instances, increased densities while lacking public water and sewer services have led to problems down the road. Recent examples include Jacksontown and Gratiot, while the closest parallel is probably the western Licking County area. Third, these developments have begun to eat away the prime agricultural land. Additionally, because they are located in the rural area instead of around the village fringe, there is a real potential for these developments to decrease the long-term viability of adjacent farming activities. Some of the conflicts that tend to arise when residential developments abut agricultural business include the access to farm fields, transportation of farm equipment along public roads, and quality of life issues (e.g. hours of operation, odors, chemicals, dust clouds, etc.). Fourth, these developments have generally occurred along rural roadways that were not necessarily designed or planned for the increased traffic that they now receive. In these situations, the township is forced to make decisions on whether or not to improve these rural roadways which may include new pavement, widening, and striping costs in order to serve their residents within these developments. Slower residential growth has been a blemish on this area in recent years. Particularly in the village, there have been fewer residential developments over the past 25 years than expected given the area's assets and location. The one key single-family development that has occurred in that Lake Forest Subdivision timeframe has been the Lake Forest Subdivision on High Street. During that same time, there were three large multifamily developments initiated including Cumberland Meadows Condominiums, Crossroads Manor Apartments, and Sharon Court Townhomes. From 1990 to 2012 the Village of Hebron grew by 7.45%. This rate of growth may not seem alarming at first glance. However, if you compare ~12~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Population Change from 1990 ‐ 2012 Central Ohio Ring Communities 113.40% Marysville** 104.76% Sunbury 96.89% S. Bloomfield 80.09% Ashville 77.52% Delaware** 45.81% Johnstown Union Twp 38.76% Centerburg 38.67% 29.70% Granville 24.90% London** Lancaster** Population Increase by Community 7%–-12% 25%--46% 78%--113% Represents approx. 30 min. travel time from Downtown Columbus 40.96% Heath 11.94% Hebron 7.45% Circleville** 6.68% Newark** 6.61% **Indicates a county seat community. Bar Graph and Map Representing the Population Increases for a Sampling of Central Ohio Ring Communities from 1990‐‐2012 it to other communities around the central Ohio region which are located approximately the same distance away from Columbus, the picture becomes much clearer. As you can see in this bar graph the majority of these communities have had tremendous growth over this time period. Hebron is third from the bottom of the list. Of the bottom five rates, Hebron is the only community that is not a county seat. This is significant because county seats are typically the largest municipality in the county and have inflated growth from county government, hospitals, and other major industries that would have typically been located there long before 1990. There are likely several factors that contribute to Hebron's slow growth, but one in particular is probably linked to the previous point regarding the growth within the rural township areas. In some of these other communities, the surrounding township areas received little growth with most of the development occurring within the municipality. In this region that growth pattern is flipped. Union Township, over the same time frame, increased in population by nearly 40%, much closer to the median growth rate of the other communities reviewed. Therefore, one reason for this slow growth could be that the market demand for the area is being met within the township instead of the village. ~13~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan achieved this goal and several that have fallen short. The Custom Living Solutions redevelopment, the Christopher Court residential subdivision addition, and the Kroger complex are examples of recent developments that have a fitting design context and have added value to surrounding properties. There are plenty of other developments in the area that have not been as successful with integrating their site design with the existing context. Two obvious illustrations are the Village Shopping Center and the Lake Forest Subdivision. “A sense of place is a unique collection of qualities and characteristics—visual, cultural, social, and environmental—that provide meaning to a location. Sense of place is what makes one city or town different from another, but sense of place is also what makes our physical surroundings worth caring about.” -Edward T. McMahon (Senior Resident Fellow at the Urban Land Institute) For having such rich history, great businesses, and superior community support, there is a real lack of a ‘sense of place’ for this region. Individual elements that allude to a strong sense of place can be found at specific businesses or developments (e.g. Hayman's Dari-Bar, Clay's Cafe, Old Hebron Mill, Hebron downtown, Devine Farms). However, there is no collection of development or public space that really embodies this concept in the Hebron and Luray area. As development occurs, it should certainly enhance and harmonize with the existing character and built environment. There are several examples of developments that have The Village Shopping Center was designed much like many of the shopping centers that were developed in the 1970s. The design did not take into account its location within the heart of the village. Large setbacks, a massive parking lot in the front, and a lack of architectural detail, are all items that are not typically found in this setting. The Lake Forest Subdivision provided needed residential expansion but the end product does not mesh well with the surrounding existing residences. In addition, the subdivision does not interconnect with adjacent residential streets and the result is a feeling of separation from the village. This development is immediately adjacent to the existing village street network and an opportunity may have been missed to connect with and expand upon the existing neighborhoods. Custom Living Solutions redesigned a National Road motel into an assisted living complex. The design scheme maintains the original integrity of the motel while integrating the business into the surrounding village development. The Christopher Court addition is an example of a residential subdivision that continues the lot configuration and street connectivity of the existing development while enhancing the neighborhood with new homes of larger size and updated design. Although there is nothing unique about the design of the Kroger store, the development is appropriate given its location on the opposite side of SR 79 from the urbanized village area. The eastern side of the SR 79 and U.S. 40 interchange has developed as a regional commercial marketplace with a suburban arrangement. Custom Living Solutions Christopher Court Add. Kroger Complex ~14~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Village Shopping Center Lake Forest Subdivision Generally, the infrastructure in this area is a positive attribute with the highways and oversized water and sewer facilities. However, in Luray these items are currently in need of improvement. The SR 37 and U.S. 40 intersection has become a point of congestion, especially during events at the National Trail Raceway. The local transportation agencies have reviewed this intersection several times in recent years to preliminarily investigate the opportunity for improvements. However, each time it was reviewed there were hurdles such as the existing corner developments, historical structures, and the alignment of the existing road intersection. Even though it may be a challenge, eventually this intersection will need to be improved. This intersection does not allow for the efficient flow of traffic during racing events and at times causes traffic back-ups down SR 37 and onto Interstate 70 causing dangerous and frustrating situations. The structure at the southwest corner of the existing intersection was demolished in 2012, thereby alleviating one of the potential hurdles to an improvement project. future of this area should or could look like. Consequently, there is no single unified plan between the township and the village. The region could undoubtedly benefit from having both local entities on the same page and working toward a cohesive goal. This plan could lay the foundation for achieving unity in this region if the various stakeholders will utilize this plan to facilitate discussion and review. National Trail Raceway VIP & Communications Tower The other roadblock for the Luray area in regards to infrastructure is the lack of public water and sewer facilities. The two largest businesses in the area, MPW Industrial Services and the National Trail Raceway, have expressed interest in having access to water and sewer services. Other local businesses (e.g. UniPac Inc. and Strait & Lamp Lumber) could benefit from these services as well. In order to encourage additional successful businesses and accommodate potential expansions, water and sewer service will be necessary. For example, the raceway senses that the lack of these services has hindered their ability to grow and attract larger events to the track. In speaking with many local officials, property owners, and business owners, it has been brought to our attention that there are a variety of different outlooks and ideas about what the Hebron Master Plan was a document that attempted to review this entire region based upon future availability of water and sewer facilities. However, the document has not been used as a unified document for the township and the village. ~15~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan The Pockets of Development: The Grand Idea After thoroughly reviewing this area, speaking with more than 20 local stakeholders, and studying the unique details of this community, the conclusion is simple: This region should facilitate and encourage appropriate expansion around the existing pockets of development by capitalizing on current assets and resolving minor weaknesses of the community. We believe this conclusion is absolutely appropriate due in large part to the tremendous assets that are already in place. It is all too easy to take the existing assets for granted and just attempt to plug in a plan or concept that worked in another community. Even though it may seem uncomplicated, this is a goal worth pursuing that will take foresight and a lot of effort by the local community to implement. Four main pockets of development exist in this region (National Trail Raceway; Urbanized Village; Newark Ohio Industrial Park; Regional Commercial). Building the future around these pockets will allow for full advantage of the existing development while retaining the existing character. The Village of Hebron has proven to be stable over the nearly 200 years of its existence. This town has the benefit of unique character and a wealth of history as previously discussed. Infrastructure is already in place (interconnected system of roads; water and sewer with plenty of capacity; private utilities, etc.) to make redevelopment and new development on the fringe of the urban area realistic and logical. The density of the village is able to support small businesses and attract site selectors of large companies. The village also has two great parks that drastically improve the quality of life by providing convenient access to recreation, leisure, and green spaces. Industrial Park National Trail Raceway Village Area Floodplain Floodplain Map of the four main pockets of development in this region. ~16~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Regional Commercial The National Trail Raceway accommodates thousands of visitors at a time, yet there has been little to no ancillary business development near the track. This business as an underutilized asset of the community that could potentially become much more than it is today. The track was developed in an odd location in the middle of agricultural fields, in a floodplain, and crammed between two roads. Despite all of that, the track has been successful and does not appear to be leaving anytime soon. Therefore, it is recommended that the community rally behind this business and help facilitate its growth. This is another pocket of development that should be expanded. Floodplain & Agriculture: One of the primary reasons why we believe that growth should be focused around the existing pockets of development is due to the floodplain and agricultural land of the region. As mentioned earlier in this plan, there are over 2,300 acres of property within the 100-year floodplain in this region. During the initial review, possibilities to reduce the floodplain and increase ground available for development were researched. However, what was discovered is that this endeavor was unnecessary and unlikely. There is already plenty of developable ground in the Hebron area. In this planning area alone there is enough ground to triple the geographic size of the urbanized village, increase the industrial park by 50%, double the acreage used in or ancillary to the raceway, and double the regional commercial complex, all while preserving a majority of the agricultural land and avoiding the existing floodplain. The other finding made was during the review of the history of the South Licking Watershed Conservancy District. This district was created in 1969 after devastating flooding that closed down Interstate 70 in 1959. The district and its steering committee worked for nearly 40 years to develop workable solutions to the flooding issues. In the mid 1980s an initial Aerial Photo of Newark Ohio Industrial Park (From Southgate Corporation website) Forty-one large companies, hundreds of acres, thousands of jobs and local customers, and millions of dollars paid out in property taxes and personal wages. This is a description of what the Newark Ohio Industrial Park provides this community. This is the largest of the four pockets of development. The park has provided a solid tax base (village and township), employment opportunity, and an increased customer base for local businesses. The park is nearly full and it would be wise to find a suitable site for expansion to continue building upon these qualities. The regional commercial area east of SR 79 is the perfect location for large retail establishments and potential big box type buildings. This development is cut off from the town area both visually and by the road network. The interchange at SR 79 and U.S. 40 allows regional traffic to come into the area without burdening the village center with vehicular congestion. Given the current number of available units at the Kroger complex and the over 100 developable acres that remain, there is plenty of space to accommodate commercial uses well into the future. This eliminates the need for accommodating regional commercial development elsewhere in this region. ~17~ 1983 Project Map from the South Fork Licking River Watershed Plan. The Green areas show the drainage area controlled by the proposed Lobdell & Big Hollow Reservoirs. Hebron – Luray Area Plan plan was approved by the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives. This plan called for two new reservoirs (Lobdell and Big Hollow) which would help control the headwaters, a new bypass channel on the north side of Interstate 70, widening of existing channels, and a new dike from Hebron to the South Fork Licking River. However, farming community by preventing a scattered pattern of growth which would create more of those potential conflicts as detailed earlier (access, roadway use, odors, etc.). Guiding the growth to these pockets increases the likelihood of continued farming activity in this area primed for development. Primed Growth: for The reason it is so important to plan for agricultural production into the future is because this area is primed for growth. Although it hasn’t happened yet, it is easy to envision a real explosion for this community over the next 20 years, similar to what has occurred in other small communities around the Columbus Hebron/Luray portion of the 1983 Project Map from the South Fork Licking River Watershed Plan. The region. As mentioned, bypass channel, existing channel enlargement, and Hebron dike are all shown in this map. The yellow area the existing infrastructure, was the proposed area to benefit from the projects. access, location, jobs, and the project began to run into trouble in the ‘90s when high quality of life make this area attractive to future appraisal letters were mailed out to 38,000 property owners development. If that occurs, the agricultural ground could within the district. The project was significantly delayed be in jeopardy and unplanned growth could make it more when more than 6,000 residents filed appeals to those difficult to retain the rural farming businesses and character. appraisals in the court system. Additionally, later If unplanned growth is allowed to happen the cost of local investigation uncovered flaws in the project’s design due to services is likely to go up, the character of the area will be the shallow aquifer which would not allow for the proposed altered, and the community will be saddled with the negative bypass channel and poor soil types that would not hold attributes that the growth may bring well into the future. water within some of the proposed reservoirs. This group was still meeting until recent years but does not appear to be actively pursuing any major flood control measures at this point. This history helps give some perspective on the difficult issues surrounding the local floodplain. In short, the floodplain will likely need to remain undeveloped into the foreseeable future. Preservation of nearly 2,000 acres of prime agricultural ground within the planning boundary is one positive result of the floodplain remaining undeveloped. As mentioned earlier, a majority of the land in this area is considered prime agricultural land. One of the local farmers explained that they are “well blessed with productive soils”. By concentrating future development around the already existing pockets of development more of the local farmland can be preserved. It also helps put fewer burdens on the “…we are well blessed with productive soils” -Local Farmer ~18~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Concepts to Help Facilitate Expansion, Build Upon Assets, and Overcome Problem Areas: The existing Union Township Zoning Map has approximately 700 acres of General Business zoning in the SR 37 and U.S. 40 area, not including any of the property owned by National Trail Raceway. The majority of this General Business zoned area is also in the floodplain. This acreage is roughly the same size as all of the commercial zoning in the City of Heath. There has typically been several empty units at the Arrowhead Plaza (Kroger Complex) and the Village Shopping Center which indicates there is not a local need for additional commercial property at this time. Future Use of Land: One of the most direct ways to guide future growth is to ensure that the appropriate land uses are being utilized. This is typically done through local zoning regulations which are steered by the comprehensive plan and future land use map of a locality. The zoning map, zoning districts, and future land use map must be up-to-date and representative of the community’s desires in order to facilitate properly planned growth. Both of the local entities in this region have recently worked on these documents. The Village of Hebron updated their Comprehensive Plan in 2008. Union Township is currently in the process of updating their zoning map to more accurately reflect their existing conditions and mesh with the zoning text. However, during the course of our review some gaps have been identified between the local zoning and comprehensive planning documents and what we’ve discerned as the desired direction of the community. Concept: Reduce the amount of commercial zoning and land use shown on the zoning maps and future land use plans. There is an excessive amount of commercial business shown on both the village and township plans. Over zoning for business development can reduce the value of the local commercial zoning. It can also create an unsuccessful business environment by encouraging development to occur outside of the existing or truly desired business areas. The top priorities should be to support filling up the existing commercial units, redevelopment in the Hebron town center, and business expansion surrounding the National Trail Raceway. Future business should not be encouraged to develop in a sprawling manner along the major highways, but rather, they should be arranged as a condensed business core. Proposed Union Township Zoning Map. The pink areas are General Business and the dark red are Sports Entertainment (Owned by the National Trail Raceway). Concept: Union Township should consider expanding the currently proposed Sports Entertainment district to parcels adjacent to the National Trail Raceway. The district should also include uses that are ancillary to or supportive of the sports entertainment venue itself (e.g. automotive parts and sales, condominium residential, campgrounds, hotels, restaurants, gas stations, museums, etc.). Concept: The village should consider adding an Agricultural zoning district to the zoning ordinance. Most of the village area is planned for development, but if the village expands and annexes additional ground then it may be necessary to allow for long-term agricultural activity. In addition, there are nearly 600 acres of ground currently being farmed inside the village and an agricultural district could accommodate those existing land uses more appropriately. ~19~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Concept: The Village of Hebron should consider implementing the Neighborhood Commercial (NC) zoning district into the Village Zoning Map. Currently, this NC district is within the zoning ordinance but is not mapped anywhere in the village. All of the commercial areas are currently zoned General Commercial which is intended to cater to a broad range of businesses which serve a regional customer base. The Neighborhood Commercial district intends to provide the daily staple needs of the local population. This district would likely be more appropriate for the Hebron town center or other small clusters of commercial development within the village area. The village should also consider increasing the maximum floor space restriction within this district which is currently 5,000 sq. ft. This may unnecessarily limit the potential businesses or expansion of existing businesses. Concept: The residential districts within the Village of Hebron Zoning Ordinance should be thoroughly examined to ensure that the districts mesh well with the existing built environment. These districts should allow for and encourage the density, setbacks, and character of the original village setting. In review of the R1, R-2, and R-3 residential zoning, these districts force a vast majority of the existing parcels and structures into a non-conforming status. The grouping of the residential districts should also be logical and fit together with the existing parcels. The village may also consider creating brand new residential and commercial districts that are specifically aimed at maintaining the small lot sizes, density, and setbacks typical of the existing village lots. Existing Village of Hebron Zoning Map. This shows that there is not a single Neighborhood Commercial district mapped. Further, the Kroger complex and the town center commercial are both zoned GC although the two areas are very different in use and scheme. ~20~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan of the commercial land uses in the SR 37/U.S. 40 area, the encouragement of rural residential development throughout the entire township, and a lack of protection for the agricultural businesses. Additionally, with the availability of water and sewer services extending further into the township, now would be a reasonable time to review the future plans for the community. Matching up Village Parcels with Zoning A majority of the lots within the town area have the following typical measurements: Lot Widths: 48' - 58' Common Original Lot Dimensions: 50' x 175' Lot Sizes: 6750 sq. ft. - 12384 sq. ft. Front Yard Setbacks: 0' - 20' The following are the three residential district requirements that regulate these town lots: Summary of Hebron Res. Zoning Requirements Min. Lot Width Min. Lot Size Min. Front Setback R-1 R-2 R-3 120’ 100’ 80’ 20,000 sf 14,000 sf 11,200 sf 40’ 35’ 35’ This is an example of a typical residential village lot (50’ x 175’). This parcel happens to be zoned R-1. You can see in the table above how this lot becomes nonconforming with all three of the listed zoning requirements. This is the current Union Township Future Land Use Map which was last updated in 1998. The red shows business use sprawling along the entirety of U.S. 40 and up to Refugee Road along SR 37. The yellow represents Rural Residential and Agricultural use. Concept: Union Township should contemplate updating their Comprehensive Plan, or at least the Future Land Use Map. The current plan was put in place in 1998 and does not seem to match the community’s direction. Specifically, there are concerns with the amount and location ~21~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Conceptual Future Land Use Map Considering the concepts that were just covered regarding the local zoning and land use, we developed a conceptual future land use map. This map incorporates these ideas and attempts to allow growth surrounding the existing pockets of development that were described. This map illustrates how these ideas should shape the future land use of this region. This map allows for expansion of the National Trail Raceway, the regional commercial complex, and the Newark Ohio Industrial Park. Growth surrounding the periphery of the village is also shown. Additional residential land use advances to the northwest of the village to wrap around the Evans Park and merge with the existing residential development on Beaver Run and Canyon Roads. The categories (colors) and subcategories (numbers) used for the conceptual future land use map are based upon density and design and are described more thoroughly on the right side of this page. The proceeding pages show the map in more detail for individual sections of the reviewed area. 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 1 2 Village Res.: small lots with size, density, and design of the original village (.2—.35 acres) intermixed with local business Medium Density Res.: medium density with suburban style design and character (0.25—2 acres) Low Density Res.: larger lots with estate style design and character (2—4 acres) Village Commercial: town center businesses on small parcels or combined parcels with typical village design Local Commercial: suburban/rural style service businesses Regional Commercial: larger stores catering to broad customer base inside and outside of this region Interstate Commercial: accommodation business for interstate traffic Industrial: warehouse and manufacturing businesses with large buildings and parcels Business Office: smaller office development in an individual or office park setting Conceptual Future Land Use Map for the Hebron—Luray Region ~22~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan This is a portion of the conceptual future land use map zoomed in around the village. A reduction in the amount of commercial land use is visible in this map as well as expanded regional commercial and industrial areas. The residential density fans out from village residential to rural residential toward the northwest of the village. Three proposed road extensions are shown (Enterprise Drive, Canyon Road, and Refuge Road) to connect collector roadways together and allow development to build from. Conceptual roadways are also shown to illustrate the density and design indicated, but they are not studied roadway locations. ~23~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan This is a portion of the conceptual future land use map zoomed in around the SR 37 Corridor. A reduction in the amount of commercial land use is visible in this portion of the map as well. Large portions of agriculture is shown as being preserved and the residential in the area is low density and rural residential. Conceptual roadways are also shown to illustrate the density and design indicated, but they are not studied roadway locations. ~24~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Flooding Concerns: As mentioned in this plan, one problem area has been the flooding issues which cause issues with local and regional traffic and destroy personal property (homes, crops, businesses, etc.). We’ve also discussed that there have been extensive investigation done in regards to combating the flooding issues and eradicating the floodplain in the area. However, none of those efforts have been fruitful to date. Concept: Prevent large amounts of impervious development within the floodplain that would increase the flooding issues that already exist. This can be accomplished through the Licking County Floodplain Regulations and through local zoning regulations. Prime Agricultural Ground: There are thousands of acres of prime agricultural soils in this area that produce an abundance of food for the local and regional community. These businesses are an asset and help maintain the desired rural character of the community. Concept: Preserve as much of the prime agricultural land as possible and ensure that agricultural production is truly feasible into the future. This can be facilitated by guiding new growth toward the existing pockets of development through local zoning controls (township and village). Local zoning can also enable the feasibility of agricultural business by excluding conflicting uses within the agricultural zoning district. The village does not currently have an agricultural zoning district and should consider adding one for use on those lands that annex into the village but are not planned for growth. Utilizing the Agricultural Easement Purchase program is another way to ensure the farmland of this area remains well into the future while compensating the property owners who have developable property. Water & Sewer Facilities: The Village and the Newark Ohio Industrial Park are already served by water and sewer facilities. However, these services currently do not extend to the Luray area. With MPW, the Water & Sewer Extension Map showing possible expansions to the Luray area, including the National Trail Raceway and MPW Industrial Services. ~25~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan off access from the public roadways to adjacent developable properties (i.e. Crossroads Manor). National Trail Raceway, and other local businesses desiring to grow their business, this lack of services causes a real challenge. Concept: Licking County should partner with MPW and National Trail Raceway to extend water and sanitary sewer services to these businesses. The sanitary sewer could come from existing Licking County sanitary sewer lines near the I-70/SR 37 Interchange. The water service would likely come from the Village of Hebron or the Southwest Licking Community Water and Sewer District. The analysis to extend these services should take into account costs, level of cost recovery, capacity, distance, and timing. According to the Village, their water treatment facility is currently operating at about ¼ of capacity and the sanitary sewer facility is operating at about ½ capacity. This extension would not only be able to service MPW and National Trail Raceway, but also the anticipated future growth in this area as indicated in the Conceptual Future Land Use Map. Road Improvements & Connectivity: Benefits of the existing highway system have already been discussed as they allow for smooth movement of the regional traffic through the area. The local road network is also good. The original grid pattern in Hebron provides ample opportunity for connection and circulation around the village to the various collector roads leading out of town such as; Canal Road, Refugee Road, Canyon Road, High Street, and of course National Road. The one key concern in regards to the local road network is the interconnectivity of current and future development around the periphery of the village area. The one obvious area of weakness for the highway system is the long term functionality of the at-grade intersection of SR 37 and US 40. This intersection can become congested even on a daily basis with the amount of daily traffic, but it becomes a real liability during events at the National Trail Raceway. Concept: Interconnect fringe development with the existing road network and continue the grid pattern adjacent to the existing village where feasible. Not only will this provide better circulation throughout the town, but it will ensure all future development is associated to the community and will prevent a sense of isolation or separation (i.e. Lake Forest Subdivision). This concept also focuses on avoiding growth that cuts Crossroads Manor has been developed in a way which has reduced the possibility of extending 6th Street to adjacent property. This is an example to avoid in order to allow for connectivity and extension of the current grid pattern. Concept: Plan for the extension of Canyon Road (from Refugee Road to National Road) and Enterprise Drive (from High Street to Canyon Road). Both of these extensions are alluded to in the Hebron Comprehensive Plan and are logical street extensions. They would both allow for development on the fringe of the village and surrounding Evans Park as well as expansion of the Newark Ohio Industrial Park. These extensions would also help ensure that the local collector roads can adequately serve the future increases in traffic by providing convenient connections to National Road and SR 79. This map shows the location of the three proposed roadway extensions. Canyon Road extended to U.S. 40 (Purple); Enterprise Drive extended to Canyon Road (Red); Refugee Road extended to High Street (Orange). ~26~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Concept: Investigate the ability to extend Refugee Road to High Street. This collector roadway currently merges with Ninth Street and functionally extends to National Road. Extending Refugee would build upon the idea of creating convenient collector roadways that would serve the future development. In addition, a roadway in this location would potentially allow for multiple connections to the existing grid network and open up the expansion of that network north of the village. This proposal would be presented with some challenges including the increased cost of multiple stream crossings and the tight spacing between existing structures. However, the spirit of this concept could be achieved by numerous methods. Concept: Avoid extending Integrity Drive to National Road. This is the one extension proposed in the Hebron Comprehensive Plan that may not be a good idea. This extension seems unnecessary and would not open up any additional property for development. Furthermore, the extension of this industrial road would intersect National Road at the entry point of the village which would detract from the quaint residential character presented at the westbound entrance from SR 79. Concept: Place upgrades to Refugee Road (National Trail Raceway to Ninth Street) and Canyon Road (Beaver Run Road to Refugee Road) on the local Capital Improvement Plans. These roads are likely to see increased development This road extension will have its challenges but the point of the concept is to find a way to increase the connectivity on the north side of the village to future development. Between the stream, the floodplain, and the Crossroads Manor extending 6th, 8th, or 9th Streets would be difficult so it will be important to find a way to do this so future development is not cut off from the village core. The options shown are a two‐way extension from Refugee to High with connections to 8th & 6th Streets (Top Left); two‐way extension from High to 6th Street with a one way extension from Refugee to 6th Street (Bottom Left); two‐way extension from High to Enterprise Drive expansion connecting 6th Street (Right). ~27~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan activity and their functional role as collector roadways will escalate. Therefore, these roads will eventually need to be repaved and widened. At a minimum, these rural collector roadways should be widened to 20 feet with 4 foot berms and left turn lanes installed where necessary. It may be appropriate to widen small portions of these roadways to as much as 36 feet with a middle turn-lane if the development occurs similar to Existing Road Conditions Refugee Road is 18-20 feet wide. *Within the Village Refugee Road has been repaved in the last few years and has 1-2 foot berms. *There are no berms on the township portion. Canyon Road is 17-18 feet wide with little to no berms. what is shown on the conceptual future land use map in this plan. Concept: Evaluate the options to improve the intersection at SR 37 and US 40 with left turn lanes. As discussed earlier, improvements are needed at this intersection in order to accommodate event traffic to the National Trail Raceway and long-term daily traffic. This should include an analysis of the existing intersection and a realigned intersection. If it is determined that these improvements would be too costly due to the taking of adjacent property or the angle of the existing intersection then realignment should be considered. Conceptual graphic of a potential realigned intersection of SR 37 and U.S. 40. Realignment would give ample room for turn‐lanes at the intersection and could adjust the intersection to a more desirable 90 degree angle as well. The existing SR 37 roadway could have cul‐de‐sac’s installed at the termination and that roadway would become a local roadway only. Further, the MPW driveway could be extended to the new alignment without losing direct access to the highway. This proposed project would require approximately 0.9 miles of new roadway. ~28~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan National Road. The connection with National Road is important for two reasons. There are existing sidewalks on both the north and south sides of National Road which means anywhere in the village would be easily accessible to the Licking Park District path. Secondly, the draft Licking County Multi-Use Trail Plan specifies an on-street bike lane on the National Road to serve as a major east/west connection. The park district path extension would link with any potential on-street bike lane. Small-Town Connectivity: One of the biggest strengths noted in this review is the small-town walkability of the Hebron village. This is a great asset which adds to the charm of the town and helps make it an enjoyable place to live. The village has made pedestrian travel a priority by actively pursuing sidewalk projects that will increase the walkability. In part, this goal is achievable due to the compactness of the developed village which is only about 1 mile wide “If we can connect every and 1 mile long. Within a half mile walk (8-11 part of Hebron then minutes) a pedestrian we’ve connected can travel from the Hebron town center to people!” nearly any part of the -Local Official urbanized village. Concept: Continue to support pedestrian activity throughout the village by investing in projects, facilities, and amenities. These improvements should make it safe, convenient, and fun to walk around the town. Consideration should be given to design of individual sites and to community projects. Each project should endeavor to link existing and planned paths. Pedestrian scale amenities (i.e. street furniture, crosswalks, pedestrian signals, pedestrian lighting, etc.) and interest points (i.e. interpretive signage, statues, artwork, murals, walking tours, etc.) should be incorporated into the overall walking experience. Concept: Link together the Hebron High Street sidewalk project and the Hebron CDBG sidewalk project (6th Street) through the future redevelopment of the old dealership property. This will provide a unique connection which can be further extended to Evans Park along the proposed Refugee Road extension. Further, this path should follow along the stream to increase the aesthetic benefits. This is a concept that would take full advantage of current projects in the village and ultimately shorten the distance from Canal Park to Evans Park. Concept: Partner with the Licking County Area Transportation Study to conduct a “Sidewalk Inventory”. Such an inventory would likely include the location (GIS mapping) of the existing sidewalks, the condition of the sidewalks, and the location of pedestrian improvements (i.e. curb ramps, crosswalks, etc.). This could prove useful in determining the top priorities for new or replacement sidewalk projects based upon the existing network and the condition of the network. It could also assist with future grant applications for pedestrian or non-motorized improvements. Concept: Extend the unimproved Licking Park District path through Canal Park to the planned sidewalk project along South High Street. This would extend the current path to about 3 miles in length and would connect the path with ~29~ A portion of the proposed sidewalk project map. This project will extend sidewalk (red) from U.S. 40 south through Canal Park and along High Street all the way to Lake Forest Subdivision. Hebron – Luray Area Plan Sense of Place: As asserted, this region is missing a strong sense of place, however, that certainly does not indicate that the community is boring, ordinary, or unsuccessful. However, creating an environment with a sense of place does allow residents and visitors to experience and remember the exciting and unique aspects of the community. Concept: Look for opportunities to design spaces with purpose that relate to the human scale and exhibit the special qualities of the region. If this is accomplished the expected outcomes would be: successful businesses, high-quality built environment, connection with the local history, amplified association to the 'hometown', and improved attraction and perception of the region. The foundations (history, parks, unique buildings and businesses, etc.) are already available to achieve this idea and should be aligned as part of this concept. A great public space with a strong sense of place should..... Concept: Consider facilitating the creation of unique spaces in the “Crossroads Corridor” and the National Trail Raceway complex. These are two areas that have a Crossroads Corridor tremendous Defined: In the Hebron potential to create town center where the canal a sense of place in and railroad crossed over two very different National Road and came ways. There are together in current day numerous Canal Park. characteristics of Sense of Place and opportunities already in existence in these two locations to build from. In order for facilitation and encouragement of these concepts the village and township should work with the property owners to design a master plan for each location. These plans could be implemented through a Planned Unit Development zoning district. Existing Spaces with an Opportunity for the Creation of a Sense of Place …promote human contact, social activities, and community involvement. The Crossroads Corridor …provide a space that is safe, welcoming, and accommodating for all users. Canal Park (social activities, attractive green space) History of the canal/railroad/National Road (Unique opportunities for marking and remembering the crossings in park or business districts) Hayman’s Dari-Bar (successful business, human contact, cultural landmark) Hebron downtown commercial business (special character, unique architectural design) Hebron Mill (appealing architecture and history, well maintained exterior public space) Hebron OHS Historical Marker & ONRA Interpretive Sign (remembrance of local history) Redevelopment Opportunity at old Bowman Dealership Hebron Fire Station/American Legion (Community involvement) ……Continued on next page …incorporate design and architectural features that are visually interesting and inviting. …reflect the local character, culture, and history. …relate well to adjacent uses. …be well maintained and defined. …have a unique or special character. …offer comfortable green spaces and landscapes. …allow people to arrive at the environment via multiple modes of transportation. …create and sustain successful businesses. Sources: American Planning Association's "Characteristics and Guidelines of Great Public Spaces" “Elevating the Sense of Place: The First Impression of Urban Spaces” by Corrie Meyer, ASLA (ASLA Urban Design Newsletter, Summer 2011) ~30~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Continued… National Trail Raceway Human interaction Future development can reflect National Road design character and be visually inviting. Cultural Landmark with unique history at track and site of Luray Cornhusking Event. Master plan of complex would be well defined and largely maintained by NHRA. Offers enormous green spaces. Has a specialized racing/automotive theme. Allows arrival by multiple modes of transportation (Buckeye Executive Airport). Successful business. The town center in Hebron already has many businesses and spaces that make it a logical choice for attempting to create and build upon a sense of place. There’s a real symmetry amongst the Canal Park, redevelopment of the old dealership, the old village hall, the downtown commercial businesses, the Old Hebron Mill, the Hebron Fire Station, Hayman’s Dari‐Bar, and the High Street sidewalk project. All of these items lay a foundation with the characteristics listed in the description above of great public spaces. Given these items the community should find a way to expound upon these strengths and link them all in a way which creates the “place to be” and facilitates successful businesses. The conceptual drawing below is just one idea on how to go about creating such a space. This illustration shows a variety of improvements and alterations to the downtown area intended to help create an exciting place that is all linked together. ~31~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Specifically, this plan shows increased pedestrian linkages, reduced widths on National Road, defined on‐street parking, street trees, pedestrian amenities, redevelopment of the dealership space with a traditional village design, redevelopment of the Ours Garage into a farmer’s market and attractive business space, brick design of Canal Street, a pedestrian linkage between Canal Street and the downtown businesses on Main Street, artistic features to reflect history of the canal and railroad. The Ours Garage and Wrecking Service is a successful current business on Canal Street. The reason this location was chosen to demonstrate the concept of sense of place is largely due to its location. This business is on top of the old canal bed, directly across High Street from Canal Park, and immediately behind the Main Street business strip. It has the opportunity to link many of the special places in this area and create a unique place of its own. We’ve suggested a farmer’s market and restaurants with outdoor dining as well as a potential relocation of the Hebron Museum. ~32~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan The other area that has many of the qualities of sense of place is the National Trail Raceway. This is a business and a venue with all the possibilities in the world to create a great experience for residents and visitors. The track itself has been quite successful, but there is still untapped potential. A robust complex with many businesses feeding off this anchor business should be feasible. Other uses such as: condominiums, storage, lodging, restaurants, an automotive parts store, other racing venues, a museum, are possibilities to enhance the experience at the track and make a unique space for the visitors which in turn creates a special place for the residents as well. Larger events and more customers means the track can also expand its facilities. This type of development would also create an abundance of tax revenue as well. This map shows some possibilities for supplementary uses to the National Trail Raceway if the appropriate infrastructure and master planning is put in place. The bubbles shown on the map are merely suggested locations for potential development of those uses. ~33~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Concept: The township and village should encourage context sensitive design guidelines along the The wealth of history and character in the Hebron and National Road. These guidelines should apply Luray area has been discussed and documented throughout to new, infill, and redevelopment projects. This this plan. This character is worth protecting through specific National Road design type should preservation, site development, and roadway design. Site especially be prominent in the village west of SR and building design is extremely critical to a community’s 79, in Luray, and at the National Road Raceway character and identity. The approach that is taken in the complex. This can be accomplished through design of a property may result in a development that is collaboration with property owners or through completely out of context with the existing built incorporation of architectural standards into the environment of the area (i.e. Village Shopping Center). It is zoning regulations. The township could utilize important that new development, infill development, and these standards within the proposed National redevelopment efforts be cognizant and respectful of the Trail Raceway PUD district, and the village could existing community. The Ohio National Road Association apply these standards in a zoning overlay district worked with consultants to develop a design handbook in along National road. A wonderful set of site 2006 which specifically addresses the development and roadway corridor Identified Critical historical character and design of property guidelines are listed in the Ohio Historic Resources along the National Road throughout the National Road Design Handbook (Rural various settings found in Ohio. This Scenic Section for Union Twp & Hebron Downtown publication, the Ohio Historic National Commercial Main Street and Historic Road Design Handbook, is a wonderful Commercial Buildings Urban Fringe for Hebron Village). These resource for local entities and should be Hebron Mill Building sections help guide building placement, consulted by all design professionals Former Hebron School architectural features, parking design, working along the National Road. access management, landscaping and (Masonic Lodge) screening materials, and the use of Former Hebron Village Concept: Create a “Comprehensive accessory structures (sidewalks, lighting, Hall Critical Resources Inventory” fencing, and signage). The current Devine Farms which will be a tool to help farmhouse and barns Examples of appropriate rural design elements. guide the protection and Old Luray Schoolhouse preservation of historical Cornhusking Event Site structures, significant sites, Canal Park (Site of scenic views, and natural original canal) features. This effort is necessary Site of original Canal to ensure the long-term and National Road maintenance of the region’s history, character, and assets. crossing National Trail Raceway Concept: Incentivize the preservation National Road and rehabilitation of Milemarkers significant or historical structures through tax credits or other means of enticement. It can often be very expensive to rehabilitate old structures. Therefore, if the local entities believe these private projects (i.e. Hebron Mill rehabilitation, Devine Farms preservation) are priorities for the overall community then those owners creating attractive and historically appropriate rehabilitation and preservation projects should be rewarded. National Road Design: ~34~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Hebron Master Plan elaborates upon the concept of design in a section entitled “Urban Design/Placemaking.. The ideas within this section of the plan should be pursued and they mesh well with and build upon the concepts within this plan. Specifically, the master plan offers specific thoughts on redeveloping the building facades and streetscapes. Examples of appropriate urban design elements. There are many features in this area which represent the small town character. These include outdoor dining, projecting signs, and traditional urban residential and commercial buildings. There are also plenty of institutional buildings which exemplify the National Road’s urban setting as well. Specifically, the former Hebron United Methodist Church (shown) has recently merged with the New Life Methodist Church and now the old church building is for sale. This site is an opportunity for reuse of a traditional building. Much like the Custom Living Solutions example, this building could be redesigned into a senior living facility or a multi‐family residential use while maintaining the integrity of the original church building. Concept: Integrate the celebration of the local history and the National Road into the fabric of the community with every chance including signage, structures, and events. In a way this develops a theme for the community and builds upon the reputation of the area. This can also help promote travel and tourism because many visitors already travel the National Road due to its designation as an Ohio Scenic Byway and All American Road. Providing interpretive opportunities in the community which tell the various stories of the area will attract even more travelers. This region already has two interpretive Examples of features that celebrate and enhance the signs installed by the Ohio National Road history and character of the Association, but there is another currently area. (National Road planned (Luray/Cornhusking) and a fourth community banners, possibility may be the National Trail Raceway. interpretive signs, murals, milemarkers, OHS historical markers). ~35~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Attachment A: Conceptual Drawing of Hebron Town Center (Illustration by AW) ~36~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Attachment B: Sketch of Crossroads Corridor Concept (Sketch by AW) ~37~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Attachment C: Bubble Map of National Trail Raceway Complex ~38~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Attachment D: Conceptual Future Land Use Map (Proposed by this plan) ~39~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Attachment E: Existing Union Township Draft Zoning Map & Future Land Use Map This zoning map is being proposed by the township at the same time as the completion of this plan. It is anticipated that this zoning map will be adopted by the township and will become the official Union Township Zoning Map. Current Union Township Future Land Use Map. ~40~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan Attachment F: Existing Village of Hebron Zoning Map & Future Land Use Map Current Village of Hebron Future Land Use Map. Current Village of Hebron Zoning Map. ~41~ Hebron – Luray Area Plan