Magic carpet, SatMar-Style
Transcription
Magic carpet, SatMar-Style
YIDDISH YEMEN IN Rabbi Yitzchak Freund (top left) with Talmud Torah students in Yemen: “We’ve been supporting them for years” The covert rescue of sixty Jews from the Amran province in Yemen and their transfer to the United Aryeh Ehrlich States — under the auspices of Satmar chassidim and backed by the United Jewish Communities and he babble of languages in the arrivals terminal at Kennedy Airport was, as usual, almost deafening. The busy New York international airport bustled with the noisy routine, but in a corner, a drama of utmost secrecy was in the process of unfolding. A handful of bearded, bespectacled chassidim conversed in urgent whispers with US State Department personnel, waiting nervously for the arrival of their guests. These guests, remnants of a poor and war-torn land, were about to enter the United States after a US State Department — has raised the ire of the Jewish Agency. The JA claims that Satmar forbids the Yemenites from moving to Eretz Yisrael, and has undermined their decades-long efforts; Satmar activists counter that the Israeli government’s promises for a smooth absorption have been empty. In an exclusive interview with Mishpacha, Satmar activist Rabbi Yitzchak Freund — who has traveled to Yemen dozens of times — reveals the details of secret operations in Yemen, exposes the challenges of integrating old-world Yemenites into the modern world of Monsey, and defends his community against anti-Israel accusations 22 Magic Carpet, Satmar-Style 24 Cheshvan 5770 11.11.09 T covertly orchestrated, round-about itinerary through several other countries. “Here they are,” one chassid whispered to his friend. “Zei huben gekimmen, b’shoh toivah imitzlaches.” (They have arrived.) Excitement combined with fear flickered on the dark, solemn faces of the group that had just disembarked from a complicated journey. They looked around in bewilderment. Their eyes, which had only known primitive village scenes, had just begun taking in the modern world for the first time. This group of Jews had just arrived from Yemen, with not much more than the rucksacks in their arms. They drew closer to the group of American chassidim, residents of Monroe, Williamsburg and Boro Park. Some members of the welcoming committee were familiar to the new arrivals. The men with the tightly curled peyos shook hands with the members of the delegation that had been anxiously awaiting their arrival. “Bruchim habaim besheim Hashem,” they exclaimed in their American chassidic accent. “Bruchim hanimtzaim,” the guests replied with their equally unique Yemenite pronunciation that has been uncorrupted throughout the ages. Until now. This was the fifth and final group that 23 Learning Torah in the ancient dialect: is this the end of Yemen's glorious jewish community? has emigrated from Yemen to the United States in the last year. After the coldblooded murder of Moshe Yaish Nahari in Raida, Yemen, earlier this year, the gates of the country have been secretly opened for Jews wishing to leave. The revised 2009 version of Operation Magic Carpet was organized swiftly and secretly; but this time, the carpet took the refugees to the “holy” land of New York. Virtually none of them, with the exceptions of Yaish Nahari’s own family and community leader Rabbi Said Ben-Yisrael, chose to live in Eretz Yisrael. They bid a final farewell to Yemen, the land of their birth and ancestors, and traveled to America, where they were warmly welcomed by the Satmar community. Behind the secret rescue operation was a small group of American activists, Satmar chassidim who have worked for years among Yemenite Jews. The State Department cooperated with them in arranging visas. Only after the operation was completed, and the sixty Jews were safe on US soil, was the Wall Street Journal allowed to report that they had been smuggled out of Amran in northwest Yemen, due to a rise in anti-Semitic incidents in Yemen in general and in Amran in particular. The first group of seventeen landed in New York on July 8, after traveling from Sana’a to Frankfurt, Germany. They were followed by another four groups totaling sixty people. Official American government sources have also revealed that an additional one hundred Jews may arrive in the U.S. in the near future. This latest operation to extricate the remaining Jews of Yemen effectively puts an end to a community that has survived, and thrived, for the past 2,500 years — preserving original biblical Hebrew, liturgy 24 24 Cheshvan 5770 11.11.09 When the Jewish Agency in Israel heard the reports of the operation, they grew furious. Satmar won this last round in the bitter, ongoing fight and cantillation throughout centuries of change and upheaval. Yeshiva University Professor Hayim Tawil issued the death certificate. “This is the end of the Jewish Diaspora of Yemen. That’s it,” Tawil, an expert on Yemeni Jewry, told the Wall Street Journal. When the Jewish Agency in Israel heard the reports of the operation, they grew furious. Satmar won this last round in the bitter, ongoing fight between the Aliyah Department of the Jewish Agency and organizations in the United States affiliated with the chassidic sect. War In Yemen At least half of Yemen’s The Jewish Agency continues to claim that while they punctiliously adhere to requests by the State Department not to publicize anything regarding the emigration of Yemenite Jews, so as not to endanger those who remain behind, the State Department violated its own secrecy rules in this case. Moreover, they claim that cooperation with elements close to Satmar defied an unwritten agreement of understanding between the US and the Israeli government. The Jewish Agency couldn’t decide on whom to vent their fury first, especially since the United Jewish Communities (formed from the 1999 merger of the United Jewish Appeal and the Council of Jewish Federations), which identifies with Zionist causes, stood behind Satmar in this case and took part in the transfer operation. “We are resolutely opposed to transferring Jews to the United States. The place for Jews is in their homeland, the Land of Israel, and like all the Jews of the world, the Jews of Yemen have to make aliyah to Israel. That is their destiny,” a JA spokesman said. Jews who left their native country in the last three years have chosen the United States as their destination, where they received the status of refugees, with support from the almost magical influence that the Satmar askanim have had on the Yemenite community. What the Jewish Agency can’t forgive is that the UJC, headed by Howard Rieger, was involved in their resettlement. But UJC officials were unruffled by the accusations. “We decided to help with the immigration, resettling and absorption of the Yemenite Jews whose lives are in danger due to the rise in anti-Jewish violence in the country,” the organization said in a statement, adding, “We work together with the Jewish Agency to encourage those Jews remaining in Yemen to emigrate to Israel. With that, we will work to ensure the safety of those who have chosen to come to the United States.” Still, the battle of the authorities in Israel against the Satmar influence became so desperate that the Finance Ministry was willing to release huge sums of money that it doesn’t have toward Yemenite absorption. According to recent reports in Israel, a deal has been reached between the Absorption the success of the Satmar activists, a group not backed by a single official body or organized federation, has become a huge headache for veteran, well-heeled institutions that have brought Jews from all over the world to Israel and Finance Ministries, under which Jews from Yemen who decide to come to Israel will receive grants of hundreds of thousands of shekels to purchase apartments, in order to entice them away from going to America and joining the Satmar enclave. According to the agreement, every Yemenite family will receive between five and seven hundred thousand shekels as a mortgage loan for an apartment, 90 percent of which will eventually become a grant. “The Jewish Agency believes that these people belong in Israel and that their absorption conditions must be improved, because they come without any money or possessions,” JA sources state. “In any case, this is not a major expense. It would be a huge crime to leave these Jews in the hands of Satmar.” The battle is over the soul of every Jew in Yemen who is a candidate for emigration. Both groups have targeted each and every person to try and gain their confidence. And the success of the Satmar activists, a group not backed by a single official body or organized federation, has become a huge headache for veteran, well-heeled institutions that have brought Jews from all over the world to Israel. The Jewish Agency giant, however, was no match for the chassidim from America, whose opposition to Zionism and everything it represents has led them to fight on the Yemenite front — and win. The Committee for the Rescue of Yemenite Jews is the organization behind the recent wave of emigration. It is comprised of a small group of veteran askanim, most of whom have made the New York-Sana’a trip dozens of times. This Innocent eyes adjust to the light upon arrival in the US 25 group subsists on donations by chareidi businessmen, primarily those who identify with the anti-Zionist doctrine of Rav Yoel of Satmar, ztz”l. The issue of Yemenite Jews was very close to Reb Yoelish’s heart. He made sure his chassidim were actively involved in their salvation, and was the inspiration for all the activities currently undertaken by the Committee. The Committee divides its activities into three primary areas: helping Jews live and subsist in Yemen; transferring Jews from Yemen to the United States; and establishing kehillos for Yemenite immigrants who were brought by Satmar chassidim to London. The London community is headed by Rabbi Meir Schlesinger, a Satmar activist and native of Jerusalem, who lives in Stamford Hill, London, and leads the Yemenite refugee community that has settled there. He is assisted by Reb Eliezer Lev. The head of the Committee is Rabbi Yitzchak Berel Hershkowitz, who lives in Kiryas Yoel, Monroe. For the past thirty years, Rabbi Hershkowitz has been active on the Yemenite scene, and he has been involved in every initiative on behalf of that community. He has made the trip to Yemen dozens of times since his first visit in 1994. “I go to Yemen twice a year,” Rabbi Hershkowitz tells Mishpacha. “Next Motzaei Shabbos, I’m heading back.” In today’s heated political climate, how are the Jews faring there? “The situation is very tense,” Hershkowitz states. “Since they killed Reb Moshe Nahari, Hy”d, all the Jews know that they have to leave. There are about thirty families left in Yemen, some in Sana’a and some in Raida.” Are you connected with the operations that smuggle Yemenite Jews out of their native country? Rabbi Yitzchak Freund: “They are in danger. They don’t know about immodesty, video or internet” 26 24 Cheshvan 5770 11.11.09 Unusual benefactors. Yemenite children wear jackets donated by chassidim in Monsey over their traditional garb “After Nahari was murdered, we private people took the reins. We began to lobby Americans to bring the Jews over from Yemen to America. The American government agreed, but conditioned it on secrecy” Reb Yitzchak Berel Hershkowitz says he is not. “I am there as long as they are there. I have built two mikvaos there, a Talmud Torah for boys and a school for girls.” It is Rabbi Yitzchak Freund who is behind the immigration operations to the United States. He is the real headache for the Zionist aliyah entities. Since he was appointed by Eida Chareidis Dayan Moshe Aryeh Freund, ztz”l, to head the Committee two decades ago, he has dealt his Zionist counterparts no small number of disappointments. He has been the subject of incisive investigations by Israeli media outlets, and efforts have been made to neutralize his activities. “I received a brachah from Rav Moshe Aryeh Freund, ztz”l, who urged me to get involved. I started in 1992; we were together in Russia on behalf of Russian Jews at the time. I told him that there was a possibility of smuggling Jews out of Yemen and the question was where to send them to. He told me that under no circumstances should they go to Eretz Yisrael.” He has been to Yemen twenty-five times since 1994. He visits members of the shrinking community and arranges their exit from Yemen. Officially, he serves as a regular member of the Committee for the Rescue of Yemenite Jews but in truth, he is the fire behind it. We caught up with Rabbi Freund between trips to Yemen. He was on his way to the offices of the immigration authorities in New York, to settle the status of several refugees who had just arrived in this final stage of the secret operation. He explains his approach: “The group that we just brought is the fifth, and in the meantime the last, group that is coming,” Freund reveals. “We brought in five groups but we had to keep it a total secret. The US Department of the Interior didn’t allow us to talk about it.” Why the secrecy? “The Zionists were opposed to the operation,” he explains. Rabbi Freund isn’t shy about exposing his constant battles with the Jewish Agency and its affiliates. But he concedes that that wasn’t the only factor. “The Yemenite government has a friendly relationship with the United States and it does not want a head-on confrontation. There is also military cooperation between the two countries. The United States defense establishment has been assisting the Yemenite prime minister, Ali Abdullah Salah, subdue the activities of Al Qaeda in his country. The prime minister comes to the US frequently and meets with government officials. These relations began during the second Gulf War in 2003.” Over the past few years, however, Yemen’s remaining Jews have been victims of escalating persecution by their Muslim countrymen. “The media reported that the Jews who lived in the village of Garhir were expelled. The local non-Jews threatened to kill the Jewish families who refused to leave. They fled to Sa’ada, but there, too, “The Yemenite government decided to transfer the nine families to Sana’a by helicopter. The trip by car takes five hours, but there was a fear that the Jews would be killed en route” there were death threats. The local mayor called the prime minister and begged him to take them, to relieve him of the responsibility of the fate of the Jews. The Yemenite government decided to transfer the nine families to Sana’a by helicopter. The trip by car takes five hours, but there was a fear that the Jews would be killed en route. The Garhir refugees were transferred to a safe location in Sana’a where they are under round-the-clock protection. These nine families have been there for three years.” But if the Yemenite Jews felt protected, that illusion was shattered by the murder of Moshe Yaish Nahari last December. Mori Moshe Nahari left his house in Raida on his way to the Talmud Torah, where his students awaited him. In the courtyard he was confronted by Abed Al Aziz Abadi, a deranged Muslim who had been jailed for killing his own wife. The Arab demanded that Nahari convert to Islam, saying that he had a religious document signed by Muslim scholars according to which if a Jew refuses to convert, he can be killed. The murderer pulled out his Kalashnikov, shot five bullets and snuffed out Moshe Yaish Nahari’s young life. Freund relates that eight months before Nahari’s murder, the United States sent two envoys from Washington to evaluate firsthand the situation of Yemen’s Jews. “In the report they Yemenites at a traditonal wedding wear talleisim donated by Satmar chassidim: “Can I help it if they choose America?” “When the Zionists heard about this cooperation they pressured HIAS to stop helping us. It came to the point that HIAS told the government, ‘We have a problem. We can help, but Israel doesn’t let us.’ As a result, the American government decided that no one was allowed to discuss these activities” compiled they explained that the Jews are in great danger. The American authorities discussed how to smuggle them out without causing a diplomatic incident with the Yemenis. They didn’t want to offend the prime minister, who considered the Jews under his protection. He could get offended and refuse. So it dragged out for months. “After Nahari was murdered, we private people took the reins. We began to lobby Americans to bring the Jews over from Yemen to America. The American government agreed, but conditioned it on secrecy. The Yemeni government agreed. The Americans told the Yemenis that they would take the Jews out slowly, as long as the Yemenis provided exit visas. And we began to work. “But, as soon as the Jewish Agency found out about our plan to take the Jews to the US, they began pressuring the Americans not to accept them, and to send them against their will to Israel.” On whom was pressure applied? “When the American government brings refugees it assigns special people to help with the absorption. HIAS (Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society) handles Jewish refugees. And although they are pro-Israel and operated by secular Jews, they help Jews settle everywhere. Because they have experience in the field, they were summoned to handle the Yemeni refugees as well. Baruch Hashem we managed to establish cooperation with HIAS and they worked together with our organization in Monsey. “When the Zionists heard about this cooperation they pressured HIAS to stop helping us. It came to the point that HIAS told the government, ‘We have a problem. We can help, but Israel doesn’t let us.’ “As a result,” Freund claims, “the American government decided that no one was allowed to discuss these activities. That’s one reason for the secrecy.” Rabbi Freund relates that during that period he secretly flew to Yemen, with the blessings of the American government. How do you know this? “It was all over the media. It was reported in the Jerusalem Post that the Zionists were applying pressure to prevent the Yemenite Jews from being taken to America.” Did you know about the transfer? “I was very involved in all the details. But when I came to the shtieblach or the mikveh I told everyone that I don’t know a thing. There were whispers, but I responded with a raised eyebrow.” And did they leave? “Three of Moshe’s daughters left Yemen even before I got there. In Shevat I sent the Naharis $12,000 from America to cover their outstanding debts and their father’s burial expenses. The money was also used to erect a respectable headstone on his grave. Of course, most of the money was used for procedural matters related to getting them out of Yemen.” Rabbi Freund continues to describe his activities from the time Nahari was murdered. “I knew him well,” he says. “He was a special person, whose Jewish purity and wisdom were his outstanding character traits. He was a talmid chacham who knew both how to learn and how to teach,” Rabbi Freund eulogizes, adding, “I No wedding is too far: chassidim escort the chasan in Sana’a 28 24 Cheshvan 5770 11.11.09 What did you do there? Freund ponders for a minute, and then says, “I can’t tell you. It’s secret.” Nevertheless, perhaps just a hint… Freund gives in and says, “I took care of the bribery arrangements for the Jews who were having difficulty obtaining passports. I spoke with twenty-five Jewish families privately and persuaded them to leave. They all wanted to leave, but none of them wanted anyone else to know about it. Each one warned me that everything we discussed must remain under wraps. That’s the kind of fear they live in; everyone is afraid of everyone else. Simultaneously, I helped take care of Moshe Nahari’s widow and children so that they could be sent out of the country.” contacted the police in Yemen and insisted that they fully investigate the murder. “At the time we decided that it was worthwhile to send a relative from Eretz Yisrael to be with the widow during this awful time for her. Moshe’s three sisters came from Israel to Yemen, through a third country. Likewise, I sent money to a member of Nahari’s family who lives in Rechovot, so he could travel to Yemen and stay for six months, to help the widow and Moshe’s aging, ailing parents. “Moshe Nahari left behind two sons and seven daughters; Sasson was twelve at the time and Daniel is eight. We made intense efforts for them to leave Yemen, but it was very difficult. They could not obtain exit visas because of the international ruckus that the murder had generated. The Yemenite immigration authorities used delaying tactics: once they said the computers were down, another time the family was sent away and told to come back a different time. This dragged out for four months. “And then I realized that I had to go there myself in order to see what was going on. I traveled to Yemen, bribed the necessary persons, and arranged for Nahari’s two sons to be sent to Eretz Yisrael so that they could say Kaddish for their father. There, in The new mikveh: “As long as Jews are here, we are here” Yemen, there is no tefillah betzibbur. The Jews are afraid to gather to pray together. “On Rosh Chodesh Elul the boys arrived in Eretz Yisrael. Today they both learn in Sephardi yeshivos in Bnei Brak. Two days after they arrived, the older son celebrated his bar mitzvah.” Smear Campaign The mountain of claims against the Satmar organization for Yemenite Jews does not originate solely with the Jewish Agency. Even people who are not flag-waving Zionists claim that the Satmar chassidim conduct smear campaigns against Israel, that they slander the Land, and that they are ready to send a fortune of money to every Yemenite Jew who chooses the United States or Britain as their destination for emigration. Those not familiar with the internal Satmar hierarchy might heap these claims on the doorsteps of both factions of the Chassidus. But those in the know say there is a more specific address: that of Rabbi Yitzchak Freund. He is the one who travels frequently to Yemen, persuading the Jews to leave. But Yitzchak Freund is unruffled by these charges. He says some are based on unfounded myths, and denies that he continued on page 54 29 YIDDISH IN YEMEN continued from page 29 unequivocally opposes the emigration of Yemenite Jews to Eretz Yisrael. They say that you do everything to ensure that Yemenite Jews don’t come to Israel… “That’s absolutely not true,” he declares. “If there’s an organization or institution in Bnei Brak or Beit Shemesh that is ready to help them spiritually, then I don’t object to them making aliyah to Eretz Yisrael. The problem is that most Yemenites have already visited there once and saw how the Yemenite Jews are nothing more than a floor to be trampled on, so to speak.” What makes you say that? Don’t they have an absorption package? Just recently huge grants were announced for Jews from Yemen who choose to immigrate to Israel. Freund snickers. “You can’t trust promises. Just look at Said Ben-Yisrael, whose aliyah to Israel was widely covered by the media because Nahari’s murderer was really targeting him as the leader of the community. Said decided to flee. He wanted to go to America but the visa did not come through. He called me on Tu B’Shevat, telling me that he was in danger and in hiding while waiting for a visa. ‘There’s a Jewish Agency representative who promised me that if I come to Israel I’ll get $100,000 to buy an apartment, and other benefits.’ I told him to go to Israel. “When he arrived he was sent to Beer Sheva, even though he wanted to go to Beit Shemesh. We exerted a lot of pressure until the JA agreed to pay his rent in Beit Shemesh. I told the Jews still in Yemen to contact Said and ask him if he got all that he was promised. So they called him and he told them the truth. Can I help it if they choose America over Israel?” You told the Jews in Yemen that it’s not worth it to go to Israel? Freund denies the charge. “I didn’t tell them where to go. I told them that they should each choose where they want to live. I urged them to make inquiries among their relatives to see what’s best for them.” And what do you offer them in the United States? “Here they have everything. We built them a shul in Monsey. We appointed a Rav, Rav Shimshon Chatuka from Bnei Brak. He is very successful and works well with 54 24 Cheshvan 5770 11.11.09 people. All the Rabbanim in Monsey—and there are 120 Rabbanim from all streams— respect Rav Chatuka. We want them to have Rabbanim and leaders of their own. We don’t want the Ashkenazim to be their leaders. We just help them with money.” “The Jews of Yemen are so pure that they are weak when it comes to facing challenges. That’s because they have never faced anything. They don’t have challenges of immodesty, or videos, or Internet. The level of modesty is high, even among the Arabs. They are very innocent” Does it bother you that the Israeli media slanders you? “It’s a long story,” Rabbi Freund sighs. “We’d have to sit on that for hours. But briefly let me tell you that Satmar chassidim, myself among them, have helped Jews from Iran, Russia, Syria, Argentina, Morocco, and even Yemenites from Eretz Yisrael whose parents emigrated there years ago. “Nineteen years ago, when I was asked to get involved on behalf of Yemenite Jews, I could have refused or said that I was unable to help them. The Jewish Agency and their allies would have likely been happy had I refused, and then they could have brought all of Yemen’s Jews to Israel. But who knows what would have happened had they fallen into the hands of the anti-religious element?” But you prevent them from coming to the Holy Land… “That is not true,” Freund exclaims. “I personally paid for Moshe Nahari’s boys to go to Eretz Yisrael. They didn’t want to take money from the Jewish Agency, because then they would never be allowed to return to Yemen to visit their mother. “There’s a family in Israel that also got money from our organization so that they could go to Israel. But we conditioned giving them the money on their living in Bnei Brak, and not in Rechovot or Ashkelon. “There’s a big problem in Eretz Yisrael,” Yitzchak Freund says after a prolonged pause. “There’s one askan in Bnei Brak who said to me, ‘I want to open a yeshivah for Yemenites, but I have no money.’ I told him that there are many askanim, and he should ask them for money. Nothing came out of it. Why? Because there is no one to help there. We work very hard. We collect money, build shuls, establish kehillos, and pay the salaries of the Rabbanim. That’s why the conditions in America, both spiritually and materially, are better. “Anyone who’s really looking for Yiddishkeit can go to Eretz Yisrael,” Freund remarks after another moment of thought. “There was one rebellious person in Yemen who said to me, ‘Give me money to go to Israel or I’m converting to Islam.’ I told him that I won’t help him, because if he’s not looking for Torah, I have nothing to help him with. “You have to realize something,” he points out. “The Jews of Yemen are so pure that they are weak when it comes to facing challenges. That’s because they have never faced anything. They don’t have challenges of immodesty, or videos, or Internet. The level of modesty is high, even among the Arabs. They are very innocent. That’s why in the first years after they leave Yemen, they are in great danger. Their minds cannot withstand so many challenges. They need a lot of support in those first years.” Vindicated Rabbi Freund describes a moment he experienced after returning from one of his dozens of journeys to the Middle East. Jet lag notwithstanding, he pulled himself together for a pre-dawn mikveh. There he met a young Yemenite youth who was exiting the mikveh at that early hour, his curly simanim (peyos) dripping water and a small Gemara under his arm. He was murmuring the morning Birchos HaShachar with the rich Yemenite pronunciation, and whispered “gut morgen” in an American, chassidic accent — no less rich. At moments like these, Freund forgets about all the problems, all the attacks. He knows that his efforts of so many years have paid off. n