Commercial Mixed Use Design Guidelines
Transcription
Commercial Mixed Use Design Guidelines
MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES CITY A I R D R I E , A L B E RTA JANUARY 2005 OF MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES CITY A I R D R I E , A L B E RTA JANUARY 2005 OF Several diagrams and elements of the Transect Overlay Code and Design Guidelines contained within this document represent a partial implementation of the more comprehensive SmartCode. The intellectual property rights associated with SmartCode text and diagrams belong to DPZ & Co. and are used by separate agreement through Civic Design Group Inc. MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................1 1.1 Overview .........................................................................................................................................1 1.2 The Purpose of this Document ........................................................................................................2 1.3 Design Guidelines Application ..........................................................................................................2 1.4 Historical Context ............................................................................................................................4 1.5 What is a Mixed Use Development? ..................................................................................................4 2.0 Regional Context .......................................................................................................................................7 2.1 Overview ..........................................................................................................................................7 2.2 Regional Framework .........................................................................................................................7 2.3 The Walkable Pedestrian Shed ..........................................................................................................8 2.4 Transportation and Regional Competition ........................................................................................9 2.5 Regional Commercial Types ..............................................................................................................9 3.0 The Transect ...............................................................................................................................................12 3.1 Description .......................................................................................................................................12 3.2 Application .......................................................................................................................................12 4.0 Mixed Use Neighbourhood Design ..............................................................................................................16 4.1 Overview ..........................................................................................................................................16 4.2 What Makes it Walkable? .................................................................................................................17 4.3 Essential Elements of The Walkable Neighbourhood .......................................................................17 4.5 Urban Structure ....................................................................................................................................18 4.4 Neighbourhood Design Guidelines ..................................................................................................18 Principle A: Identif Identify A Centre .................................................................................................................19 Principle B: Block Structure ....................................................................................................................20 Principle C: Public Space ........................................................................................................................21 Principle D: Identify Shopping Streets ...................................................................................................23 Principle E: Transect Zone Placement ....................................................................................................24 Principle F: Platting ................................................................................................................................25 Principle G: Residential Interface (Edge Transition T-3) ..........................................................................26 Principle H: Large Format Interface ........................................................................................................27 Principle I: Horizontal Mixed Use ...........................................................................................................31 Principle J: Mixed Use Development over Time ......................................................................................32 5.0 Transect Overlay Code (TOC) ....................................................................................................................33 5.1 Overview & Purpose ........................................................................................................................33 5.2 Application .......................................................................................................................................33 TOC-A: Vertical Mixed Use Standards ...................................................................................................34 TOC-B: Building Placement ..................................................................................................................37 TOC-C. Building Form .........................................................................................................................39 TOC-D. Public Frontage Character ........................................................................................................42 TOC-E. Parking Strategies ......................................................................................................................44 Appendix dix............................................................................................................................................................ 46 Appendix A: Land Use Bylaw Amendment: Transect Overlay (TO) .......................................................47 Appendix B: Proposed Land Use District: Mixed Use District (MU) .....................................................49 Appendix C: Sample Regulating Plan .....................................................................................................50 CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES i CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES ii 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 OVERVIEW The City of Airdrie recently annexed approximately 3000 acres of land to accommodate its long term planning goals to accommodate a 30 year population total of 65,000 people. The purpose of this annexation is to create a “whole community” where non-residential and residential uses complement each other while facilitating vital new employment opportunities. Further, it is the city of Airdrie’s goal as a City to preserve and enhance the central focus of its downtown core while allowing complementary regional and community commercial development opportunities. Responding to this goal, the Growth Area Management Plan (GAMP) was written to assess the new growth areas and how they might develop over time. One of the primary findings from the GAMP report encourages Mixed Use development in new growth areas by intensifying land uses around commercial nodes. Since this report however, concerns have been raised over whether or not mixed use development will detract from the viability of the downtown core. The city of Airdrie’s primary goal is to create a strong and vibrant downtown core while still ensuring that alternative and emerging trends in Mixed Use development can strengthen the unique appeal of the City of Airdrie. This report seeks to specifically answer the both broad and detailed questions regarding mixed use development in Airdrie. CITY OF Lands annexed development or currently under City of Airdrie - Future Growth Shed 2005 AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES INTRODUCTION 1 1.2 THE PURPOSE OF THIS DOCUMENT 1.3 DESIGN GUIDELINES APPLICATION The City of Airdrie is currently undergoing tremendous growth in both residential and commercial development. Although positive, this growth requires that the right principles and development strategies are in place in order to ensure development occurs according to smart growth principles. The Growth Area Management Plan (GAMP) was written in response to this need and provides the following recommendations for the overall future development of residential, industrial and commercial land. These recommendations are: The figure on the following page identifies the subject sites for immediate application to the design principles outlined in this report. To achieve broader smart growth principles , the guidelines and Transect Overlay Code established within this document are intended for optional use in existing and future commercial and residential sites within the City of Airdrie • • • • • • • Downtown as a focus of commercial development Increasing Density Providing Appropriate Interfacing and buffering Creating a Comprehensive Community Encouraging non-residential development Effective Infrastructure Management Identifying a comprehensive Park and Open Space System The purpose of this document is to take these recommendations to a further level of detail and illustrate how to implement responsible smart growth principles. These urban design guidelines illustrate the principles and practical components necessary for the successful implementation of mixed uses for both the downtown and local neighbourhood centres. The goal of this document is to provide the Development and Building Industry, as well as the City of Airdrie with an easy to read, illustrative design manual for Mixed Use neighbourhoods and buildings within the City of Airdrie. The following is a synopsis of the main elements of this document: • Section 2.0 provides a regional context for the relationship between automobile focused commercial development, suburban mixed uses development, and the downtown core. • Section 3.0 provides a description of the Transect, an organizing principle to achieve the mixing of uses in the context of a segregated land use bylaw. • Section 4.0 provides the basis for creating complete mixed use neighbourhoods. The Neighbourhood Design Guidelines (Section 4.5) provides essential principles for achieving mixed use development and provides a basis for achieving vertical mixed use. These principles should be considered as part of the neighbourhood structure plan approval process. • Section 5.0 provides the Transect Overlay Code to regulate mixed use development and is the reference document for the Transect Overlay as part of the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw. • The Appendix provides the two enabling policies contained within the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw and a sample project. In addition, it is also the purpose of this document to provide practical answers to the following questions: • • • • • • What is good urban form? What is mixed use development? How does mixed use work? What is the regional context of mixed use? What are the practical design guidelines to building Mixed Use? Where does mixed use happen in Airdrie? CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES INTRODUCTION 2 Identification of Subject Sites Consistent with the 2004 Growth Area Management Plan. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES INTRODUCTION 3 1.4 HISTORICAL CONTEXT 1.5 WHAT IS A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT? For centuries, human settlement patterns have been inherently mixed use. Some of the most treasured urban places in the world exhibit a high degree of land use integration and a distinct human scale. During the industrial revolution, a surge of rural migrant workers into cities along with the growth of heavy industry combined to created squalid, overcrowded living conditions within urban centres. As a result, it became necessary to segregate heavy industry from residential areas to promote healthier living conditions. The scope of mixed use can range from the single building in a local neighbourhood centre, to the full master plan of a downtown core seeking to encourage a variety of uses, population densities, and memorable destinations. With the rise of the automobile as the dominant transportation mode, the segregation of land uses exists today in spite of the original reasons for doing so. Where originally designed to protect residents from polluting factories, segregated land use practices continue today on the momentum of the status quo, and for the ease of traffic count calculations for automobile focused transportation planning. The results of this pattern has led to the separation of most daily needs by a car trip and have come with a great number of consequences. At the beginning of the 20th century, Alberta had a rich history of human scaled mixed use centres inherent to almost every small town throughout the prairies. The past 80 years have seen the proliferation of segregated land uses and car dominated transportation patterns at the detriment of our cities. These guidelines provide a means to reestablish the tradition of mixed use place making within the modern urban context. The mark of a successful and sustainable local neighbourhood is determined by the distance people are required to walk in order to access daily facilities that support their needs, as well as places where a variety of activities take place. Mixed Use Developments are characterized by: • three or more significant revenue producing uses (such as retail/entertainment, office, residential, hotel, and/or civic/cultural/recreational) that in well planned projects are mutually supporting; • significant physical and functional integration of project components (and thus a relatively closeknit and intensive use of land), including uninterrupted pedestrian connections; and • development in conformance with a coherent plan (that frequently stipulates the type and scale or uses, permitted densities, and related items). • the abundance of a significant residential component to ensure the development is animated 24/7. Assembling the elements of Mixed Use DPZ & Co. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES INTRODUCTION 4 Mixed Use Types Mixed Use occurs in two basic forms: 1. Horizontal Mixed Use Set within an interconnected block structure, building types and land uses change along a street, around the corner, or mid block at the alley. This is distinct from conventional land use patterns that typically change land uses at berms, fences and across busy streets. The residential component is integral within horizontal mixed use to ensure its social and economical viability. The enabling of Horizontal Mixed Use is described in Chapter 4. 2. Vertical Mixed Use Set within a single building, uses change vertically by stories, typically residential and/or office located over shops. Typical configurations can vary from a simple live/work units in a neighbourhood centre location, to the combination of both office and residential uses within a main street downtown setting. The enabling of Vertical Mixed Use is discussed in Chapter 5. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES INTRODUCTION 5 CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES INTRODUCTION 6 2.0 REGIONAL CONTEXT 2.1 OVERVIEW 2.2 REGIONAL FRAMEWORK Considering mixed use development at a regional level, a common concern is whether the promotion of mixed use centres outside of the downtown core affect the economic viability of the downtown business district. To effectively address this concern, it is necessary to understand the effects of the form and distribution of retail uses in the regional context. Current segregated land use practices and automobile focused transportation patterns have created a significant regional distortion in the commercial market. Where most of life’s daily activities require an automobile trip, there is a distressing disconnect between commercial land uses and the markets they serve. Mixed use development has traditionally located at important road and pedestrian crossings, and significant public spaces like common greens, squares, and plazas. Since WWII tradtional mixed use patterns have been largely ignored. In the modern context, mixed use developments are often the exception rather than the rule. It is the City of Airdrie’s intention to create walkable mixed use centres while at the same time increasing the appeal of the downtown core. This section provides a regional context for mixed use development in Airdrie To meet the broader gaols of sustainability and an increased quality of life for Airdrie residents, it is critical that mixed use development, and retail districts in general, be integrated into a coherent regional context that links land use and transportation. The Airdrie Growth Area Management Plan approved in 2004 begins to address some of these issues by identifying “smart growth” principles and provisions for mixed use development. To achieve these goals, it is necessary to first consider design implications at the regional level. A balanced, human scaled regional plan is composed of coherent, walkable neighbourhoods where higher density residential land uses are matched to commercial concentrations, cultural and civic amenities, and viable transit hubs. This is the basis for the critical CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES REGIONAL CONTEXT 7 link between land use and transportation in a balanced regional plan. While a comprehensive regional planning process is beyond the scope of these guidelines, this section provides basic regional design considerations that directly support viable mixed use centres and the redevelopment of a vital downtown. 2.3 THE WALKABLE PEDESTRIAN SHED The basic building block of the human scaled regional plan is the pedestrian shed. The pedestrian shed defines an area measured by a 5-minute walk (roughly 400 metres) at a leisurely pace from centre to edge. This is the distance where people may choose to walk to daily services, a corner store, or a bus stop, rather than drive provided that there is a pedestrian-friendly environment. This is a time-tested pattern that intuitively defines some of the most cherished urban places in the world from the scale of intimate rural hamlets to the intensity of the metropolis. As a regional tool, the pedestrian shed defines human scaled neighbourhood units where jobs, shopping, a variety of homes, and civic amenities are placed within a walkable proximity. By providing the opportunity for more pedestrian trips, pressure on regional transportation thoroughfares to serve both regional and localized traffic is reduced. This also allows increased access and safety for roughly 1/3 of the population who do not drive. For the mixed use centre and the downtown core, the pedestrian shed provides a retail and transportation catchment area that quantifies pedestrian circulation. Within a walkable development context, this provides a framework to link transportation to land use. By placing higher density residential development in proximity to jobs, retail stores, civic amenities, and transit hubs, the broader goals of mixed-use development, “smart growth”, and sus400 Meter Radius tainable growth can 5-Minute Walk be achieved. Pedestrian Shed CITY OF The Pedestrian Shed Defines The Bounds of the Walkable, Mixed Use Neighbourhood. Two Walkable Neighbourhoods May form a mixed use shopping street where they overlap. The Pedestrian Shed Defines a Walkable Commercial Catchement for “park-once and shop” retail areas. A commercial catchment may also define a walkable neighbourhood on its own. Pedestrian Sheds are the building blocks of the walkable region. AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES REGIONAL CONTEXT 8 2.4 TRANSPORTATION AND REGIONAL COMPETITION Retail and commercial uses are the most fragile component of mixed use development within the regional context. In addition to household incomes and economic growth, transportation and land use play a significant role in the viability of commercial development. Adjustments to land use policy can guide balanced retail development, but must be matched by balanced transportation practices as well. Current automobile focused transportation patterns define increasingly higher speed, higher capacity thoroughfares. Concentrating vehicles on a small number of large streets creates regional retail market distortions as these streets create a demand for commercial uses at a proportional scale to the street. It is inevitable then that low density residential is developed directly adjacent to large concentrations of commercial development. This has not proven to be a sustainable land use pattern, nor does it support the viability of Airdie’s downtown core and the broader goals of smart growth. To put this in perspective, mixed use retail expert Seth Harry analyzed the retail development patterns in Omaha, Nebraska, from the compact, walkable traditional neighbourhoods to the more recent development patterns: While overall regional design and transportation planning choices are part of a broader discussion, the immediate redevelopment of the downtown along with suburban mixed use centres will have considerable effects on future development patterns. As the city moves towards more sustainable development models, these issues should be at the forefront of the discussion. 2.5 REGIONAL COMMERCIAL TYPES To place mixed use development into the regional Airdrie context, there is a general relationship between three types of commercial typologies. One of the primary distinctions of these retail typologies is the determination of a trade area based on the automobile trip versus the pedestrian trip, thus providing a framework that can begin to appropriately reconnect retail demand and supply. A. Large Format Retail Districts In order to inject commercial viability into the downtown core, recent changes to Airdrie land use policy provide for the creation of a large-format retail district where the minimum store size is restricted to 8000 square feet. This satisfies the demand for large format retailers outside of the downtown while providing a means to balance smaller retailers within the downtown Because the basic merchandise categories haven’t changed, only the scale of the retail formats in response to the ability to capture a much larger number of residential units through the increased dependence on fewer, but much larger arterial streets, the actual sales per square foot of the individual stores, as well as the square footage allocation per household unit does not actually vary greatly across the three diagrams. However, the larger capture, combined with the much lower densities typical of sprawl, results in substantially larger trade areas, geographically speaking, resulting in proportionally, and substantially more vehicle miles per trip, just to satisfy the same basic retail needs. - From the Smart Code Retail Paper, Seth Harry and Associates, Inc. CITY OF Comparative Regional Retail Scale- Seth Harry and Associates Inc. AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES REGIONAL CONTEXT 9 At The Scale of the Car Trip Regional retail and automobile scaled commercial areas serve a regional market first as they are linked by a required automobile trip to individual destinations. As a direct destination, each store offers a similar experience regardless of location and therefore compete directly with one another at the scale of the automobile trip. At the Scale of the Walking Trip The walkable mixed use centre as defined by a pedestrian shed first serves a local commercial market measured by comfortable walking distance. At a regional scale a “park once and shop” experience is offered at each location and competition is among unique destinations, or “places”. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES REGIONAL CONTEXT 10 and localized commercial centres. Large format commercial districts define single retail use with a market area at the scale of the region and measured at the scale of the car trip (the auto-shed). Although provisions for sidewalks and a proximity to residential areas are typical, each store acts as an individual destination accessed primarily by the automobile. B. Mixed Use and Neighbourhood Commercial There are a number of localized commercial districts identified within the land use bylaw. The C-1 and C2 districts are smaller scaled districts, but still encourage disconnected single use development patterns. By creating automobile-focused commercial areas, an opportunity is lost to link these areas to their surrounding land uses without an automobile trip. The proposed Mixed Use district explicitly creates this link by creating an integrated urban area that accommodates both automobile trips and the pedestrian. Further, these links are made internally reducing traffic on the regional street system. market as well (the ped- shed). This unique combination draws residents and tenants who want to be in the centre of the action. While healthy competition may exist between the downtown and suburban retail, there is enough differentiation through the unique intensity and opportunities offered by the downtown core. To build this intensity through redevelopment, initial development incentives and supportive policy will be necessary. Further, a limited number of strategically placed large format retailers should be considered to create downtown anchors. Because of the limited supply of large format opportunities in the downtown, retailers motivated to take advantage of downtown activity are more likely to accommodate alternative building formats that meet the urban design objectives for creating walkability and mixed uses. There are currently three mixed use centres identified explicitly within the future expansion lands. These mixed use centres can form a commercial core within a walkable 400 metre ped-shed. This defines pedestrian oriented “place-based” shopping that offers a “park once and shop” experience while at the same time integrating the local market (residential units) directly. The integrated market and regional access by the automobile and transit together provide commercial viability. A concentration of residential in and near the mixed use centre allow commercial to be sized to a localized, integrated market. While regional access by the car will be common, the centre will not compete greatly with downtown shopping. When appropriately integrated into a local market and designed in a pedestrian friendly manner, the mixed use centre provides a balanced relationship with the downtown core. This raises a question: besides large format commercial districts, which commercial areas can justify not being mixed use and walkable? There should be consideration that shops below 8000 square feet be required to be street oriented and pedestrian friendly. C. The Downtown The downtown has the advantage of being both a regional draw (the car-shed) and serving a local, integrated CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES REGIONAL CONTEXT 11 3.0 THE TRANSECT 3.1 DESCRIPTION Responding to the need for land use and transportation reform, one of the most significant approaches emerging from current town planning practice is the rural-urban transect. Based on the study of ecology, the transect represents the classification of urbanism on a continuum from most urban to most rural. This continuum is divided into tiers, into which each urban or rural element may find its place. While these tiers may be defined simply as edge, general, and centre, the transect is generally broken into seven tiers: Rural Preserve (T-1), Rural Reserve (T-2), Sub-Urban (T-3), General Urban (T-4), Urban Center (T-5), and Urban Core (T-6), and Special Districts (D) to accommodate necessarily single use areas such as heavy industrial, airports, hospitals, university campuses, and in the case of Airdrie, large format retail uses. As a departure from use based zoning, the transect intuitively regulates for mixed use and for appropriate character within each tier rather than for strict, yet unnecessary segregation of land uses and residential incomes. Each of these tiers can be considered as zoning districts categorized for appropriate scale, typology, urban intensity, density, and character. Regionally, the transect can effectively integrate residential densities CITY OF and commercial uses thereby matching specific consumer patterns with their localized market. 3.2 APPLICATION The transect provides not only a way to effectively deliver mixed use development and the principles of smart growth, but allows for a system that can be layered or integrated with conventional zoning practices. In this way, transect zoning is able to provide a special form-based district as an overlay to the current land-use bylaw. At the regional scale, the establishment of the walkable pedestrian shed, regional corridors, and single use districts form the regional building block of transect planning. At the community scale, the interconnected neighbourhood of streets, development blocks, and public spaces creates a framework for arranging transect zones. Public spaces such as streets respond with appropriate character to the adjacent transect zone. At the building level, the transect defines density, building placement, frontages character, signage standards, and building function. AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT 12 Transect Illustrated CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES (DPZ & Co.) TRANSECT 13 Transect Descriptions The following provides the general definitions for each transect zone. Although there are universal principles applicable to North American urbanism, the detail of specific transect zones vary by locally. For example, the Airdrie transect is unique from the Calgary transect. T1 The Natural Zone consists of lands approximating or reverting to a wilderness condition, including lands unsuitable for settlement due to topography, hydrology or vegetation. T2 The Rural Zone consists of lands in open or cultivated state, or sparsely settled. These may include woodland, agricultural lands and grasslands. T3 The Sub-Urban Zone, though similar to conventional suburban single-family house areas, differs by its street connectivity and by allowing home occupations. It is typically adjacent to other urban T-Zones. This zone is naturalistic in its planting. Blocks may be large and the roads irregular to accommodate site conditions. T4 The Neighborhood General Zone has a denser, primarily residential urban fabric. Mixed use is confined to certain corner locations. This Zone has the wide range of building types. Single, sideyard, and row houses are set close to the frontages. Streets typically define medium-sized blocks. T5 The Neighborhood Center Zone is the equivalent of a Main Street. This Zone includes mixeduse building types that accommodate retail, offices, and dwellings, including rowhouses and apartments. The T-5 Zone is a tight network of streets and blocks, with wide sidewalks, steady street tree planting, and buildings set close to the frontages. T6 The Urban Core Zone occurs at regional centers. It is the equivalent of a town or to the downtown of a city. It contains the densest urbanism—the tallest buildings, and the greatest variety of uses, particularly unique ones such as the city hall, financial district, and important civic buildings. The Urban Core is the least naturalistic of all the Zones; trees are formally arranged and waterways are often contained in embankments. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT 14 Airdrie Mixed Use Centres Transect When arranged into a interconnected neighbourhood unit, single family housing development in Airdrie is generally considered T3 Sub-Urban. The downtown is the most urban condition and should be established as T6 Urban Core. Classic Main Street Alberta is T5 Neighbourhood Centre. This zone defines the commercial core of suburban mixed use centres and acts as a transition area within the downtown core. The T4 General district provides a necessary transition to existing and future T3 Sub-Urban development. In the context of these guidelines, the Suburban Mixed Use Centres include T4 and T5, Airdrie’s Downtown Core includes T4, T5, and T6. Downtown Airdrie Suburban Mixed Use Centres Transect Basics T-5 T-4 CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES T-6 TRANSECT 15 4.0 MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 4.1 OVERVIEW The factors that contribute to the creation of great places are not achieved through the construction of a single building. They must consider the street, block and building as a comprehensive unit. Urban design provides for the logical organization of building design, landscape, open space, transportation and the mix of land uses that is essential to the creation of timeless places. It is the intention of these urban design guidelines to bring clarity and harmony to the public realm. In order to achieve horizontal mixed use, and to set an appropriate framework for vertical mixed use, this section provides an urban design basis for creating walkable neighbourhoods. Automobile focused neighbourhood design is unwalkable. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 16 4.2 WHAT MAKES IT WALKABLE? • • • • • • • • A Destination. A balanced mix of uses provides a variety of destinations and goes beyond recreational walking. Permeable Streets. Through block structure, paths, and passages between buildings, pedestrians need a direct route to their destination. Enclosure. The feeling of enclosure adds to pedestrian comfort and contributes to the quality of the journey. Adequate Pedestrian Facilities. Sidewalks that accommodate two people abreast (1.5m min.), crosswalks, and shading elements contribute to walkability. Human Scale. Gigantic parking lots, blank facades, 3 story sign posts, and oversize stucco building details are at the scale of the car. Comfortable Car Interaction. Slow cars are much more comfortable to walk around than fast moving ones. Planting strips and on-street parking adds to pedestrian comfort. Dignified Transit. As part of a non-car trip, a transit stop should be comfortable, clean, and share the elements of walkability. A bench on the side of a busy road does not do this. Visual Interest. Clear, continuous commercial windows, landscaping, building diversity, front doors to buildings, architectural detailing, and other people all contribute to visual interest. 4.3 ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS OF THE WALKABLE NEIGHBOURHOOD As bounded by the 5 minute walk pedestrian shed, the following outlines the basic principles of human scaled neighbourhoods to achieve walkability. 1. The neighborhood has a discernible center, usually a main street, public square or green, typically bordered by civic buildings, shops, and/or residences. 2. The neighborhood has visually discernible edges where the neighborhood ends, formed by transportation corridors (such as major streets or rail lines), or by natural and agricultural landscapes. 3. The neighborhood is limited in size so that a majority of the population is within a five-minute walking distance of its center (1/4 mile). 4. The neighborhood has a variety of dwelling types. 5. The neighborhood has concentrations of civic, institutional and commercial activity embedded within it, not isolated in remote, single-use complexes. 6. Dispersed throughout the neighborhood are a range of parks, from tot-lots and village greens. Conservation areas and open lands are used to define and connect different neighborhoods and districts. 7. The neighborhood has a connected network of streets offering greater choice for alternate routes. This permits humanly scaled streets with narrow lanes and reduced speeds. Such streets are equitable for both vehicles and pedestrians, encourage walking, and reduce the number and length of automobile trips. 8. The neighborhood centre places its buildings close to the street to spatially define squares and plazas as ‘outdoor rooms’. 9. Street parking is encouraged, while parking lots and garages rarely if ever front the streets and are typically relegated to the rear of the lot and accessed by alleys. 10. The neighborhood reserves prominent sites for civic buildings and community monuments with terminating street vistas. Walkable environments balance the car and pedestrian. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 17 4.4 URBAN STRUCTURE 4.5 NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN GUIDELINES Urban Structure is the arrangement of streets, blocks, buildings, and public space that physically define the shape of the neighbourhood. It is the interrelationship between these elements, rather than individual buildings, that creates a sense of place. Sound urban structure is as necessary at the city’s suburban edge as it is in the urban downtown centre. The following ten principles provide a framework for the effective and sound design of mixed use centres and neighbourhoods. These provide the basis for the subsequent land use districts and Transect Overlay Code. Urban Structure provides the foundation for detailed urban design. It provides the mechanism for the design of a coherent urban framework by guiding the design of individual development sites executed by different actors. This allows for the following: • Integration Connection and overlap with surrounding areas • Functional Efficiency So that individual elements (buildings, streets, open space etc.) work together as part of an efficient whole. • Environmental Harmony Creating development forms that are energy efficient and ecologically sensitive • A Sense of Place Creating somewhere that is recognizably distinct but simultaneously strengthens local identity. • Commercial Viability Responding to the realities of market influence on development mix and delivery.* Horizontal Mixed Use Along the Transect- (Dover Kohl and Associates) CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 18 PRINCIPLE A: IDENTIFY A CENTRE A coherent mixed use centre starts with a central “heart”. Generally defined by a public space such as an important intersection, a square, or a plaza, this “heart” forms an identifiable gathering place that is at the focal point of commercial activity and residential density. It is also the centre point of the 400-metre-radius pedestrian shed. GUIDELINES • The mixed use centre should have a central focal point. • The centre should be defined by a public gathering space such as a plaza, square, intersection, or along a section of a special street. This is the most active part of the mixed use centre. • This focal point forms the centre of a walkable pedestrian shed, or Commercial Catchment and can serve as a guide for organizing less intense land uses and key commercial areas. • The centre should be part of or define the most intense commercial and residential density. • A major transit stop should be located at the centre A new town centre in Southlake, Texas. (Dover Kohl and Associates) CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 19 PRINCIPLE B: BLOCK STRUCTURE Block structure is essential to the creation of fine grained, mixed use urbanism. This time tested pattern provides an interconnected system of streets that allows multiple, direct routes for pedestrians and automobiles. A single block is defined by a perimeter of buildings at its edge. The outside of the block is the “public facade” that shapes streets and public space. The centre of the block provides for private space such as a yard, or semi public space such as a courtyard or parking. Block structure is resilient to market forces and allows for evolution of uses and urbanism over time. Block Exterior: This is the Public Edge with the front door on the street and at the perimeter of the block. Block Interior: This is the Private or Semi-Private side reserved for rear yards, courts, and parking lots. Madrid OF • Development pattern should exhibit a block structure • Block structure should support a network of interconnected streets detailed for character and capacity. • To shape streets and public spaces, buildings should be built close to the perimeter of the block. • A block should define a public front at the perimeter and private/ semi-private back at the interior. • Generally a block face should not exceed 150 metres in length, and 600 metres for the perimeter length of the block. Larger blocks with internal parking facilities can be up to 900 metres perimeter length. • Block shape may be square, rectilinear, or irregular and may change with the transect. • Disconnected streets, dead ended roads, and cul de sacs are strongly discouraged and do not provide block structure. Savannah Historical Airdrie with interconnected Block Structure CITY GUIDELINES Conventional Airdrie lacks Block Structure AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 20 PRINCIPLE C: PUBLIC SPACE Streets are the most significant public space in the urban context and should be detailed for character and capacity. Public spaces are generally defined by block structure and shaped by buildings. This allows for the creation of “outdoor rooms” that contribute to the sense of place. Public spaces may anchor civic buildings, form terminated vistas, and can accommodate a range of activities. They are generally detailed in relation to their adjacent transect zone. Other public spaces include civic buildings, parks, environmentally significant areas, and agricultural preserves. GUIDELINES Creating Outdoor Rooms: Principles of Spatial Enclosure CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES • A diversity of public spaces should be provided including a central space within the mixed use centre, and generally at the centre of a neighbourhood pedestrian shed. • Urban public spaces such as squares and plazas should not exceed 3200 square metres (35,000 sf ) • Streets in an urban context should be considered as public space and designed appropriately. • Generally, a 1:3 building height to street width ratio is preferred in order to provide an effective sense of enclosure, or “outdoor room”. • Civic buildings are considered “public space” and should be placed at important sites such as the termination of a street or on a public square. • Civic Space and Civic Buildings should be identified on the regulating plan as a reserve designated with a ‘CS’ for Civic Space and ‘CB’ for Civic Building. As public facilities, these designations count towards fulfilling the required Municipal Reserve dedication. MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 21 Civic Space Types A. Park: A natural preserve available for unstructured recreation. A park may be independent of surrounding building frontages. Its landscape shall consist of paths and trails, meadows, woodland and open shelters, all naturalistically disposed. Parks may be lineal, following the trajectories of natural corridors. The minimum size shall be 15 acres. CS B. Green: An open space, available for unstructured recreation. A green may be spatially defined by landscaping rather than building frontages. Its landscape shall consist of lawn and trees, naturalistically disposed. The minimum size shall be 2 acres and the maximum shall be 15 acres. C. Square: An open space available for unstructured recreation and civic purposes. A square is spatially defined by building frontages. Its landscape shall consist of paths, lawns and trees, formally disposed. Squares shall be located at the intersection of important thoroughfares. The minimum size shall be 1 acre and the maximum shall be 5 acres. F. Civic Building: A public building located on an importance site such as a roadway termination, a square or plaza, or within a special viewshed. Civic Buildings may be located within any tier of the transect and in conjunction with another civic space type. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES T3 T4 T5 CS T4 T5 T6 CS T5 T6 D. Plaza: An open space, available for civic purposes and commercial activities. A plaza shall be spatially defined by building frontages. Its landscape shall consist primarily of pavement. Trees are optional. Plazas shall be located at the intersection of important streets. The minimum size shall be 1 acre and the maximum shall be 2 acres. E. Playground: An open space designed and equipped for the recreation of children. A playground shall be fenced and may include an open shelter. Playgrounds shall be interspersed within residential areas and may be placed within a block. Playgrounds may be included within parks and greens. There shall be no minimum or maximum size. T1 T2 T3 CS T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 CS CB MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 22 PRINCIPLE D: IDENTIFY SHOPPING STREETS A simple network of shopping streets should be identified within the mixed use development. These should be designated as required retail frontages in order to secure a synergy between retail tenants, similarly to a conventional mall. A commercial street is defined by shopfronts in a “main street” composition that are built up to the sidewalk, typically on both sides of a street, with at-grade entries. GUIDELINES • • • • • Shopping Streets • • CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES A simple network of shopping streets should be designated as “required retail frontages” within a mixed use development plan. Commercial streets may be part of an existing commercial corridor or define a new commercial street and should preferably connect to a major thoroughfare. The length of an initial main street within a mixed use development should not generally be longer than about 500 metres (1600 lf ). Shopfronts should be on both sides of a street and should form a simple, coherent, and circuitous route for shoppers. Uses within shopfronts may include retail, services, office, and institutional uses but should be designed to provide physical and visual permeability for the pedestrian. Other shopfronts may be allowed outside of the required retail frontage in the appropriate transect zone. The use of anchor tenants, such as a grocery store, drug store, or a destination retail tenant are recommended to increase commercial viability. MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 23 PRINCIPLE E: TRANSECT ZONE PLACEMENT More intensive transect zones should go near the centre of the mixed use development. In the downtown core, T6 should be applied throughout with less-urban T5 and T4 zones buffering residential uses at the edge. In mixed use centres, commercial streets and the centre are defined by T5 with T4 providing a transition to adjacent residential uses, or T3 zones. GUIDELINES Sample Transect Plan T5-T3 • More intense transect zones should be at the central heart of the mixed use centre and downtown core. • Transect zones should be similar across streets, changing at the mid block or perpendicular to a street. Transect Dispersion Within a neighbourhood defined by the 400 meter radius pedestrian shed, the following provide guidelines for dispersion of transect zones. Maximums for transect zones that may be part of a Mixed Use District or Overlay District as regulated by this document are identified in black. Suburban Mixed Use Neighbourhoods Within an 80 Acre Neighbourhood T5- 10 - 30 % T4- 30 - 50 % T3- 10 - 30 % T2- no min. Within a 30 Acre Mixed Use District T5- 60 - 80 % T4- 20 - 40 % T3- 10 - 30 % T2- no min. • Commercial Streets are defined by T5 in mixed use centres and T6 in the downtown core. • Transect placement generally transitions in sequence (T5 -T4 -T3), but may skip tiers to create unique relationships. • Pedestrian friendly buildings along a human scaled street are more effective at providing a transition from mixed use centres to adjacent neighbourhoods than berms, fences, and walls. Downtown Within 80 Acre Downtown Pedestrian Shed T6- 40 - 70 % CITY OF T5- 10 - 30 % T4- 10 - 30 % AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 24 PRINCIPLE F: PLATTING Platting is the process of subdividing urban blocks into saleable or leasable increments. Conventional development patterns have seen an increase in lot sizes within single-use commercial pods. A variety of lot sizes allows for diversity and a fine grain mix of uses that are able to evolve incrementally and adapt to changing market conditions. Platting allows for independent ownership at a variety of scales. Platting by rods is an often overlooked approach that is particularly suitable for mixed use and commercial areas. Blocks are subdivided by rods into small increments (such as 25’ as traditionally seen in Alberta or the more flexible 6’ increment) The mixed use district can then be purchased in increments suitable for both larger users and smaller ‘mom and pop’ type users. GUIDELINES Shopping Street • When Platting by subdivided lots, a diversity of lot sizes is encouraged from 5.5m (18’) for row houses and live/ work units to 30m (100’) for larger commercial and multifamily uses. • Platting by rods is a more flexible and adaptable approach to subdivision allowing development parcels to be purchased by linear increments. This is directly suited to bareland condominium. Secondary Street A. Platting by Block or Pod B. Platting by Subdivided Lots C. Platting Increments • Creates large development lots and parcels • Less able to adapt over time • Limited to large builders • Eliminates smaller developments opportunities and reduces diversity • Requires subdivision to change lot configuration • Smaller, predetermined parcels formed by subdivided lots • A variety of lot sizes allows for diversity • Requires anticipation of future market • Somewhat flexible to changing market conditions • Requires subdivision to change lot configuration • Parcels formed by rod increments • Large lots may be divided into saleable increments by bareland condominium or other means. • Allows a flexible diversity of lot types • Highly adaptable to changing market conditions • As a bareland condominium, requires no subdivision process to create parcels. CITY OF by Rod AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES • Rod Increments may be as small as 1.8m (6’) which ideally integrate with parking dimensions, or the more historic and less flexible 7.62m (25’). • When subdividing by 1.8m (6’) rods , a min. lot width of 5.5m (18’) is recommended. • When developing a lot platted by rods, a subdivision application is not required allowing flexibility byright. This is generally made possible by bareland condominium, but other methods may be explored. • Subdivision by block should be minimized to encourage flexibility and diversity. MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 25 PRINCIPLE G: RESIDENTIAL INTERFACE (EDGE TRANSITION T-3) Arterial Street Mixed use centres in suburban areas can provide a significant amenity and value enhancement to surrounding residential land uses. The vast majority of existing residential uses in Airdrie are of a T3 scale (R-1 Zoning) but are not generally arranged into a neighbourhood pattern that supports integration of mixed use development and T4 multifamily types. However there are a number of ways to integrate mixed use development with lower density development that are far more functional and aesthetically pleasing than barriers and buffers such as berms, walls, and fences. T5 T4 GUIDELINES Provide Adjacent Connections Existing R-1 (Or T3) Blocks Side onto Arterial to avoid facing rear of buildings to street. Alternatively, buildings could face onto a frontage road and square or directly onto the arterial if properly designed. Picture of Airdrie T-3/Interface Types Automobile focused strip development (top) makes for a bad neighbor. This requires buffers and berms between adjacent land uses. Walkable mixed use development patterns allow uses to change along streets. Shopping streets and a diversity of uses within walking distance provides a valuable amenity to adjacent communities. (Images: Dover Kohl) • Generally, walls, fences, and berms should be avoided as “buffers” except against incompatible uses such as industrial districts. • New mixed use centres should provide connections into adjacent streets and pedestrian walkways. • The edge of a mixed use centre should compliment adjacent uses by transitioning along Transect zones. T4 compliments T3 (or existing R-1 zoning) • Where buildings cannot front directly onto a major street, the block should side onto the street or provide a frontage road. Facing the rear of a building onto a street is discouraged. • Where buffers are constructed, there should be suitable breaks for vehicular and pedestrian access. • Future residential uses should be arranged in a coherent, neighbourhood fashion transitioning to mixed use centres by methods described in Guideline ‘E’. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 26 PRINCIPLE H: LARGE FORMAT INTERFACE Airdrie land use policy recognizes the need to concentrate smaller retailers into mixed use centres and the downtown core. To achieve this, the C-3 land use district has been amended as a large format district where stores under 8000 sf are not permitted. However, there is a benefit to integrating large format retailers into walkable mixed use areas both for the large retailer who taps into valuable “foot traffic,” and for the small shops who benefit from an anchor store. To maintain walkability and human scale, a number of strategies have been identified to appropriately integrate larger format commercial uses into mixed use developments. These fall under three general categories: • • • Block Strategies Liner Strategies Direct Integration H1: Block Strategies Block strategies allow the large format retailer to strategically integrate into a human scaled block structure while remaining a standalone building. An advantage to this format is that retailers may retain a conventional building and parking arrangement while benefiting from proximity to pedestrian activity. A disadvantage is that the storefront interface does not directly tap into commercial street activity and can create a pedestrian unfriendly edge condition. • Anchor Street: The shopping street terminates onto a retail storefront creating valuable visibility for cars and pedestrians. GUIDELINES • Strategically placed large format retail uses can act as valuable anchors to smaller mixed use development when appropriately integrated. • The main building entry for large format uses directly accessing the street should exhibit a shopfront character with clear windows, pedestrian level showcases, awnings, and pedestrian level signage. • Large format districts should arrange buildings and parking lots into a block structure defined by an interconnected network of streets to allow for future infill and redevelopment opportunities. Pattern Washingtonian Centre • Lanes between parking lots and along building frontages within large format retail district should be designed as pedestrian friendly streets. • Through a combination of interfaces, multiple anchors can be integrated within the mixed use context. Placing storefronts at the termination or deflected vista of a street provides invaluable exposure for large tenants and can be used as an incentive. Mackenzie Towne, Calgary CITY OF Reston Town Centre, Washington AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 27 • ‘L’ Configuration: The large format building is ‘around the corner’ from the main shopping street. Grocery Store Pattern Stapleton, Colorado • Imbedded: The large format building is within the block, visible from the shopping street through the parking access. • Block Structure: By arranging large format retailers and their parking lots into a pattern of urban blocks, flexibility for redevelopment potential is increased. When the new community of Kentlands, Maryland was designed nearly two decades ago, there was foresight to arrange the regional retail into blocks. Initially there was a hesitation for vertically mixed use development within Kentland’s suburban context, but Following the success of the live/ work units, the developer was able to redevelop a parking lot into a mixed use development nearly two decades later. This exhibits the viability of achieving mixed use over time. Grocery Store Kentlands Block Structure Pattern Garrison Woods, Calgary • Alley Separated: The large format building faces a parking lot opposite from the shopping street and separated by an alley. Kentlands Before Pattern King Farm, Maryland Kentlands Mixed Use Infill After CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 28 H2: Liner Strategies Liner buildings provide a means to hide the blank facade of large format retailers with active, pedestrian scaled shopfronts. This is a technique that was successfully pioneered by the shopping mall industry over the past several decades. In a mixed use urban setting, the interior mall corridors in effect become the pedestrian friendly commercial street. Like malls, the larger retailer has a smaller shopfront entry that takes direct advantage of commercial street activity while allowing for a secondary entry onto a parking lot. Liner buildings may include shopfronts, offices, and residential uses. Liners may also mask parking structures. Pattern LoDo, Denver (Parking Structure) Liner Guidelines: • Liners should have a habitable depth of no less than 7m from the front facade. • The shopfront entry to the large format retailer should be recessed from the sidewalk, but by no more than 4m. • The shopfront entry should present a visually and physically permeable shopfront towards the street and should be no wider than 15m. • Multi story liners are preferred in order to mask the entire facade of the larger building. Vertical Mixed Use Liner for Theatre, Belmar Center, Colorado Mixed Use Home Depot, Portland (Concept Only) CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 29 H3: Direct Integration Traditionally, large department stores have successfully integrated into a mixed use setting by utilizing multiple stories and by providing continuous shopfronts along their street interface. As retailers recognize the advantages to having a presence on a pedestrian friendly commercial street, they are once again seeking possibilities for direct integration. While larger format retailers are generally discouraged along pedestrian main streets, their direct integration provides valuable anchoring for smaller shops and are particularly suitable in the downtown core. Pattern Two Storey Bookstore, Bethesda, MD The Bay, Calgary Shoppers Drug Mart, Calgary Safeway, Tribeca Seattle Sportchek, Vancouver CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES Direct Integration Guidelines: • The floorplate should generally not exceed 8000 sf. Larger floorplates may be considered on a corner location or deeper lot. • Multiple storey store formats allow for larger stores. • A continuous shopfront should be maintained along the shopping street. • The shopfront width along the shopping street should be no longer than 20m. • Direct integration is most appropriate in T6 and should be considered as a strategically place anchor. MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 30 PRINCIPLE I: HORIZONTAL MIXED USE Typically, mixed use development is viewed as the changing of uses within a single building (vertical mixed use) such as apartments over shops. However, more importantly, good urbanism exhibits the horizontal mixture of uses where building types and land uses can change along a street, around the corner, or at the alley. This is distinct from conventional segregated land use patterns where uses change at berms, fences, and across busy streets. The residential component of horizontal mixed use is integral and essential. GUIDELINES • The transect maintains appropriate scale and character within the block structure while allowing for flexibility in specific uses • Land uses and building types may change around the corner, along the street, along the block face, and at the alley as regulated by the transect. Changing of Residential Types along a Street, Bradburn, Colorado B • Transect changes should not generally change across a street with exception uses such as a corner store or in special circumstances. • A horizontally integrated residential component is required for all Mixed Use Districts. Residential uses are an integral component of horizontally mixing uses. A C (Plan: DPZ & Co.) Changing Building Types and/or Transect Zones: A: Along a Street B: Turning the corner C: At mid block CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 31 PRINCIPLE J: MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT OVER TIME One of the most important, and most frequently overlooked elements of mixed use is the element of time. Most great places do not occur overnight. They evolve and mature over time. The transect allows for the natural evolution of urbanism to take place while maintaining suitable standards for urban form. While single storey commercial development may be desirable in the early phase of a development, the desire to capitalize from upper storey development is an emerging trend within a variety of market conditions. Similarly, as the Kentlands Story demonstrates in section H1, large format retail development along with older, outdated shopping malls show great redevelopment potential. The subsequent form based code is intended to grant flexible mixed-use development by right. GUIDELINES Future Liner • Single storey, street oriented commercial is allowable as an exception in the early reemergence of mixed use development within Airdrie. • Provisions for the eventuality of vertical mixed use development is encouraged through means such as small lot platting and shared parking standards. Provisions for future residential liner building in Stapleton, Colorado • To achieve objectives and principles set out within this document, the element of time should be considered as part of the approval process. If an element cannot be achieved today, the provisions for future realization should be made. (See the Stapleton example to the left.) Eastgate Demalling (Dover Kohl) CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES MIXED USE NEIGHBOURHOOD DESIGN 32 5.0 TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE (TOC) 5.1 OVERVIEW & PURPOSE The general purpose of the Transect Overlay Code is to provide clear direction and standards for the design and regulation of new mixed use centres. This provides the City of Airdrie Planning Staff with the means to ensure that the design of new mixed use developments complies with the goals and objectives of this report, “To create vibrant mixed use centres which are pedestrian friendly, cohesive and most importantly contribute to the overall economic, social, and environmental vitality of the City of Airdrie”. 5.2 APPLICATION The Transect Overlay (TO) section of the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw establishes a link to the Transect Overlay Code (TOC) contained in this chapter. The TO enables this code and provides instructions for establishing a Transect Overlay. Generally, a Transect Overlay is established by the submission of a regulating plan along with the Neighbourhood Structure Plan process. The appendix of this document provides a sample regulating plan. The following urban design standards and guidelines ensure the effective design of mixed use centres and neighbourhoods and should be considered in conjunction with the principles described in section 4.5. CITY OF Policy Flow Chart AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 33 TOC-A: VERTICAL MIXED USE STANDARDS The classic mixed use building is the vertically mixed “apartment flats over shops” building. Typically, vertically mixed buildings occur within the T5 and T6 tiers of the transect. As demographics and market trends evolve, there is increasing demand for apartments over shops on a vibrant street, or live-work units that allow residents to use or rent out a commercial space at the ground floor. Offices over shops are also ideal allowing office users to capture the value and convenience of a commercial street. A.1 GENERAL STANDARDS Compounded Mixed Use in Portland: Residential over Office over Parking Over Shops. Live Work Units in Kentlands (Suburban Maryland) CITY OF • Upper storey residential uses are strongly encouraged along shopping streets. • Upper storey development may also include office, institutional, and appropriately scaled parking facilities. • Generally, all land uses are allowable by discretion within the Transect Overlay as regulated by A.2 and A.3. • The approving authority may establish additional land use restrictions on specific lots. • The changing of land uses within the Transect Overlay are permitted by right as guided by the provisions within the Transect Overlay Code. New Mixed Use in Santana Row (Suburban San Jose, CA) AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 34 A.2 Prohibited Land Uses All uses within the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw are allowable by discretion and by right, excepting the uses within the following table which are not allowed within the associated Transect Zone. Additional restrictions and exceptions may be established by the approving authority. T4 GENERAL URBAN Adult Entertainment Agriculture, Commercial Agriculture, Extensive Agriculture, Intensive Auction Establishments Automotive Service Boarding and Impounding Kennels Cemeteries College or Trade School Equipment Rentals Hospital or Medical Clinic Hotel (Excepting max. 12 room Inns and Bed and Breakfast uses .) Civic Uses, Intensive (Excepting Outdoor Auditorium, Playground, Public Art, Bus Shelter) Industrial Key Lock Gas Service Liquor Sales Manufactured Homes Manufactured Home Sales Modular Home Sales Recreation Facilities, Outdoor Recreation Facilities, Indoor Storage Facilities, Indoor Storage, Recreational Vehicle Warehouse Retail CITY OF URBAN T5 CENTRE Adult Entertainment Agriculture, Commercial Agriculture, Extensive Agriculture, Intensive Auction Establishments Boarding and Impounding Kennels Cemeteries Dwellings- Single family Detached Semi-Detached Equipment Rentals Industrial, Intensive Key Lock Gas Service Manufactured Home Sales Manufactured Homes Modular Home Sales Recreation Facilities, Outdoor Recreation Facilities, Indoor Shopping Centre or Mall (Automobile Focused) Storage Facilities, Indoor Storage, Recreational Vehicle Warehouse Retail AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES URBAN T6 CORE Adult Entertainment Agriculture, Commercial Agriculture, Extensive Agriculture, Intensive Auction Establishments Boarding and Impounding Kennels Cemeteries Dwellings- Single family Detached Semi-Detached Industrial, Intensive Equipment Rentals Key Lock Gas Service Manufactured Home Sales Manufactured Homes Modular Home Sales Recreation Facilities, Outdoor Recreation Facilities, Indoor: Over 8000 sf Shopping Centre (Automobile Focused) Storage Facilities, Indoor over 8000 sf Storage, Recreational Vehicle Warehouse Retail TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 35 A.3 General Functional Intensity Generally, development density is constrained by allowable building height, lot coverage, parking availability, financial and market considerations, and allowable uses. The following table provides additional land use provisions within each transect zone. T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 a. RESIDENTIAL Restricted Residential: The number of dwellings on each lot is restricted by parking requirements.. Both dwellings shall be under single ownership. The habitable area of the ancillary dwelling shall not exceed 500 square feet. Limited Residential:The number of dwellings on each lot is limited by parking requirements, a ratio which may be reduced according to the shared parking standards. Open Residential:The number of dwellings on each lot is limited by the requirement of 1.5 parking places for each dwelling, a ratio which may be reduced according to the shared parking standards. b. LODGING Restricted Lodging: The number of bedrooms available on each lot for lodging is limited by parking requirements, up to five rooms, in addition to the parking requirement for the dwelling. Food service may be provided in the a.m. The maximum length of stay shall not exceed ten days. Limited Lodging: The number of bedrooms available on each lot for lodging is limited by parking requirements and up to twelve rooms, in addition to the parking requirement for the associated dwelling. Food service may be provided in the a.m. The maximum length of stay shall not exceed ten days. Open Lodging: The number of bedrooms available on each lot for lodging is limited by parking requirements. Food service may be provided at all times. The maximum length of stay shall not exceed ten days. c. OFFICE Restricted Office: The building area available for office use on each lot is restricted to the first story of the principal or the ancillary building and by parking requirements, in addition to the parking requirement for each associated dwelling. Limited Office: The building area available for office use on each lot is limited to the first story of the principal building and/or to the ancillary building, and by parking requirements, in addition to the parking requirement for each dwelling. Open Office: The building area available for office use on each lot is limited by the by parking requirements. d. RETAIL Restricted Retail: The building area available for retail use is restricted to one block corner location at the first story for each 300 dwelling units and by parking requirements, in addition to the parking requirement of each associated dwelling. This specific use shall be further limited to neighborhood store or food service seating of no more than 20. Limited Retail: The building area available for retail use is limited to the first story of buildings at corner locations, not more than one per block, and by parking requirements, in addition to the parking requirement of each associated dwelling. The specific use shall be further limited to neighborhood store, or food service seating no more than 40. Open Retail: The building area available for retail use is limited by parking requirements. By Discretion By Discretion By Discretion By allowable use and Land Use Bylaw By allowable use and Land Use Bylaw By allowable use and Land Use Bylaw e. CIVIC f. OTHER CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 36 TOC-B: BUILDING PLACEMENT Building placement regulates the position of the building within the lot and is regulated by the transect tier and placement type. This includes setbacks, allowable encroachments into setbacks, and yard requirements. B.2 Building Placement Standards The Airdrie Land Use Bylaw defines minimum standards for yard requirements. The TOC regulates for a specific character as appropriate to each transect zone. As an overlay, these standards exceed and/or supersede the standards set within the Land Use Bylaw. B.1 GENERAL STANDARDS • T4 SETBACK Front Side Rear PLACEMENT A. Edge Yard B. Side Yard C. Rear Yard D. Court Yard MIN.% BUILDING FRONTAGE REQ. GENERAL URBAN T5 URBAN CENTRE T6 URBAN CORE • 1.5m - 3.0m 0.0m - 10.0m 1.0m 0m - 1.5m 0.0 - 3.0m 1.0m 0m - 1.5 Side - 3.0m 1.0m Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Prohibited Permitted Permitted Permitted Prohibited Prohibited Permitted Permitted Principal 50% Secondary 30% Principal 75% Secondary 35% Principal 90% Secondary 50% 70% Max 80% Max 90% Max • • • LOT COVERAGE • B.3 Definitions Principal Frontage: The principal frontage is the front property line along a thoroughfare. Secondary Frontage: On a corner lot, the secondary frontage is the side property line along side property line. Setbacks: Setbacks are measured from the associated lot/property line. The front yard is at the principal frontage. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES • • One principal building at the frontage, and one outbuilding to the rear of it, may be built on each lot. Facades shall be built parallel or tangent to the principal frontage line. Encroachments: Awnings may encroach the public sidewalk without limit. Stoops may encroach 100% of the depth of a setback. Open porches and awnings may encroach up to 50% of the depth of the required setback. Balconies and bay windows may encroach up to 25% of the depth of the required setback. Setbacks are from associated property lines as regulated in section B.2 Lot coverage by building shall not exceed that shown in section B.2 Civic Buildings are generally allowed more flexibility and may be set back on their lot to signify their importance. Facades shall be built parallel to the principal and secondary frontage lines along a minimum percentage of their length and along the setback as shown in section B.2 In the absence of a building along the remainder of the frontage line, a Streetscreen shall be built co-planar with the facade. TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 37 B.4 Large Format Retail Placement Large format, or “Big Box” retail formats with individual store footprints above 8000 square feet are prohibited within the Transect Overlay District with the following exceptions: • Large format retail stores above 8,000 square feet shall be allowed as an exception within a Transect Overlay District as strategically placed anchor stores at the discretion of the approving authority.. The footprint shall be limited to 8,000 with additional square footage in upper stories. • Where multiple stories are not possible, large format retail footprints over 8,000 square feet shall be allowed as an exception within a Transect Overlay District as strategically placed anchor stores at the discretion of the approving authority. • Excepted large format retail stores shall follow the Transect Overlay Code and Chapter 4, “Mixed Use Neighbourhood Design.” B.5 Placement Typologies The following provides the general definitions for each transect zone. Although there are universal principles applicable to North American urbanism, the detail of specific transect zones vary by locally. The Airdrie transect is unique from the Calgary transect. A. Edge Yard: T4 A building that occupies the center of its lot with setbacks on all sides. This is the least urban of types as the front yard sets it back from the frontage, while the side yards weaken the spatial definition of the public thoroughfare space. The front yard is intended to be visually continuous with the yards of adjacent buildings. The rear yard can be secured for privacy by fences and a well-placed backbuilding and/or outbuilding. B. Side Yard: T4 T5 T6 A building that occupies one side of the lot with the setback to the other side. The visual opening of the side yard on the street frontage causes this building type to appear freestanding. A shallow frontage setback defines a more urban condition. If the adjacent building is similar with a blank party wall, the yard can be quite private. This type permits systematic climatic orientation in response to the sun or the breeze. C. Rear Yard: A building that occupies the full frontage, leaving the rear of the lot as the sole yard. This is a very urban type as the continuous facade steadily defines the public thoroughfare. The rear elevations may be articulated for functional purposes. In its residential form, this type is the rowhouse. For its commercial form, the rear yard can accommodate substantial parking. T4 T5 T6 D. Court Yard: A building that occupies the boundaries of its lot while internally defining one or more private patios. This is the most urban of types, as it is able to shield the private realm from all sides while strongly defining the public thoroughfare. Because of its ability to accommodate incompatible activities, masking them from all sides, it is recommended for workshops, lodging and schools. The high security provided by the continuous enclosure is useful for crime-prone areas. T4 T5 T6 CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 38 TOC-C. BUILDING FORM Building form is regulated by building height, allowable frontage types along the first storey, shopfront standards, and vertical building elements. Individual developments should utilize Architectural Guidelines for more detailed architectural control at the Development Permit stage. C.2 Building Form Standards The Airdrie Land Use Bylaw defines minimum standards for building height and building configuration. The TOC regulates for a specific character as appropriate to each transect zone. As an overlay, these standards exceed and/or supersede the standards set within the Land Use Bylaw. C.1 GENERAL STANDARDS • T4 GENERAL URBAN URBAN T5 CENTRE BUILDING HEIGHT Principal Bldg Max. 3 Stories Max. 4 Stories Outbuilding Max. 2 Stories Max. 2 Stories FRONTAGE TYPES A. Porch and Fence B. Stoop C. Terrace or Light Court D. Forecourt E. Shopfront and Awning F. Gallery G. Arcade URBAN T6 CORE • Max. 5 Stories Min. 2 Stories N/A • • Permitted Prohibited Prohibited Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Prohibited Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Prohibited Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted • • • CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES The vertical extent of a building shall be measured by number of stories, not including a raised basement or an inhabited attic as described in section C.2. Height limits shall not apply to towers with a lot coverage of less of 400 square feet, masts, belfries, chimneys, water tanks, elevator bulkheads, etc. Allowable frontages are described in section C.2 As “foreground buildings”, Civic buildings should be allowed more architectural freedom (while respecting the pedestrian realm and human scale) while private buildings should act as “background buildings designed in harmony with one another. Sections C.3 through C.6 establish basic building design standards. An architectural code submitted at the Development Permit stage can further elaborate on architectural character. Buildings should generally be composed of a clear base, middle, and top with lighter materials over heavier. (i.e. shingles over wood siding over brick over stone) Materials should generally change vertically on the facade (i.e. a wood siding second storey over a brick first storey) TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 39 C.3 Building Heights Illustrated T4 T5 C.4 Vertical Building Elements T6 C.5 Arcade Standards C.6 Shopfront Standards CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 40 C.7 Frontage Types A. Porch & Fence: A frontage wherein the facade is set back from the frontage line with an attached porch permitted to encroach into the setback. A fence or garden wall at the frontage line maintains the demarcation of the yard. The porches should be no less than 2.5m deep. T4 B. Stoop: A frontage wherein the facade is aligned close to the frontage line with the first story elevated from the sidewalk sufficiently to secure privacy for the windows. The entrance is usually an exterior stair and landing. This type is recommended for groundfloor residential use. T4 T5 T6 C. Terrace or Light Court: A frontage wherein the facade is set back from the frontage line by an elevated terrace or a sunken light court. This type buffers residential use from urban sidewalks and removes the private yard from public encroachment. The terrace is suitable for conversion to outdoor cafes. The light court is suitable for live/work commercial. T4 T5 D. Forecourt: A frontage wherein a portion of the facade is close to the frontage line and the central portion is set back. The forecourt created is suitable for vehicular dropoffs. This type should be allocated in conjunction with other frontage types. Large trees within the forecourts may overhang the sidewalks. T4 T5 T6 E. Shopfront and Awning: A frontage wherein the facade is aligned close to the frontage line with the building entrance at sidewalk grade. This type is conventional for retail use. It has a substantial glazing on the sidewalk level and an awning that may overlap the sidewalk to the maximum extent possible. T5 T6 F. Gallery: A frontage wherein the facade is aligned close to the frontage line with an attached cantilevered shed or a lightweight colonnade overlapping the sidewalk. This type is conventional for retail use. The gallery shall be no less than 10 feet wide and may overlap the whole width of the sidewalk to within 2 feet of the curb. T5 T6 G. Arcade: A frontage wherein the first storey facade is setback beneath a colonnade along the sidewalk. This type is conventional for retail and requires a highly permeable shopfront facade. The arcade shall be no less than 3.0m deep and no more than 5.0m. T5 T6 CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 41 TOC-D. PUBLIC FRONTAGE CHARACTER In a mixed use urban setting, the street forms the one of the primary public spaces and community amenities. The public frontage is the portion of a thoroughfare between the vehicular lanes and the property line. These vital public spaces should be designed within the context of their appropriate transect character. Because of the pedestrian focus of mixed use centres and the downtown, pedestrian comfort should be the primary consideration of public thoroughfares. Vehicular lanes should balance character and capacity, and streetscape elements such as planters, sidewalks, and other features should be a primary consideration. Pending a review of vehicular lane standards, these guidelines focus mainly on the general character of the pedestrian scaled public frontage. D.2 General Character Guidelines The following table provides an example of how the character of public frontages details change with transect zones. Street Light Type T1 T2 T33 T4 T55 T66 D.1 GENERAL STANDARDS • Continuous Planting Strips are strongly discouraged along shopping streets. Wide Curb-to-property line sidewalks and street trees in grates are highly encouraged. • The frontages contribute to the character of the Transect Zone. They include the types of sidewalk, curbing, planter, and street tree. • Thoroughfares shall be designed for capacity and modified according to the Transect Zones through which they pass. Thoroughfares that pass from one Transect Zone to another shall adjust their Public Frontages accordingly or, alternatively, the Transect Zone may follow the trajectory [alignment] of the thoroughfare to the depth of one lot, retaining a single public frontage throughout its trajectory. • Within the more urban Transect Zones (T4 through T6) pedestrian comfort shall be a primary consideration of the thoroughfare. Design conflict between vehicular and pedestrian movement shall be decided in favor of the pedestrian. Cobra Head Pipe Wood Post Column Double Column CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 42 D.3 Public Frontage Guidelines The following table provides general guidelines to the character of public frontages as they relate to transect zones. Specific dimensions are to be established to the satisfaction and in collaboration with the approving authority. R TRANSECT ZONE U R A L T1 T2 T3 l l l l l l T1 T2 T3 l l l T R A N T4 S E C T T4 T5 l l l l l l l T5 T6 l U R B A N T5 T6 *Appropriate for Shopping Streets A. Assembly: The principal variables are the type and dimension of curbs, walkways, planters and landscape. Total Width 16-24 feet 12-24 feet 12-18 feet 12-18 feet 18-24 feet 18-30 feet Open swale 10-30 feet . Open swale 10-30 feet . Raised curb 5 - 20 feet Raised curb 5 - 20 feet Raised curb 5 - 20 feet Raised curb 5 - 20 feet Path optional n/a Path 4-8 feet Sidewalk 4-8 feet Sidewalk 4-8 feet Sidewalk 12-20 feet Sidewalk 12-30 feet Clustered Multiple Continuous swale 8 feet-16 feet Clustered Multiple Continuous swale 8 feet-16 feet Regular Alternating Continuous planter 8 feet-12 feet Regular Single Continuous planter 8 feet-12 feet Regular Single Continuous planter 4 feet-6 feet Opportunistic Single Tree well 4 feet-6 feet B. Curb (See Note): The detailing of the edge of the vehicular pavement, incorporating drainage. Type Radius C. Walkway: The pavement dedicated exclusively to pedestrian activity. Type Width D. Planter: The layer accommodates trees and landscape. which street other Arrangement Species Planter Type Planter Width Curb Note: Parallel parking lanes allow for a pedestrian friendly corner radii while allowing for an appropriate emergency vehicle turning radii. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 43 TOC-E. PARKING STRATEGIES To encourage walkability and the creation of humanly scaled places, parking lots should be concealed from the public street. On-street parking provides a buffer between pedestrians and moving traffic, provides convenient short term parking, slows moving traffic, and increases retail viability for adjacent shops. The following parking strategies are intended to achieve the broad objectives of mixed use development. Shared parking standards and on-street parking counts are intended as incentives for encouraging the use of Transect Overlay. E.2 Parking Locations E.1 GENERAL STANDARDS • • On-Street Underground Behind Buildings, Within the Block On The Side by Exception E.3 Shared Parking Standards The following shared parking standards are intended to allow for increased density or reduce parking requirements for new developments. Given the available parking for a building or use, the building density (units or square footage) may be increased by the factor in the table below. Conversely, given the square footage or unit density of the building, the sharing factor can divide into the density to reduce parking requirements. The sharing factor applies to two functions within any pair of adjacent blocks or within a building. The sharing factor can be applied only once per use or building. SHARING FACTOR with RESIDENTIAL LODGING LODGING OFFICE OF • Function RESIDENTIAL CITY • • Function RETAIL • 1.2 1.4 1.3 1.1 1.7 1.2 1 1 1 1 1.1 1.7 1.2 OFFICE 1.4 1.3 1.2 RETAIL AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES • Parking requirements for all uses within T5 and T6 zones shall be consistent with the CB land use district parking requirements within the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw. Parking requirements for all uses within the T4 land use district shall be consistent with the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw. Shared Parking Standards (see E.3) shall apply to T4, T5, and T6 zones. Surface Parking Lots directly adjacent to public thoroughfares are strongly discouraged. Appropriately detailed surface parking lots with a “parking square” character (i.e. surrounded by streets, set within a block structure, combined with pedestrian amenities, non-asphalt surface treatments, and with minimal striping) are allowed by exception. On-street parking is strongly encouraged on all streets and shall count toward the parking requirements of the immediately adjacent building or land use. Parking structures should be lined with habitable uses or concealed within blocks. TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 44 CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES TRANSECT OVERLAY CODE 45 APPENDIX CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES APPENDIX 46 APPENDIX A: LAND USE BYLAW AMENDMENT: TRANSECT OVERLAY (TO) (1) Purpose and Intent An Overlay provides a means to alter and refine regulations and design standards within otherwise appropriate land use districts in order to achieve specific urban design standards and municipal policy objectives. The Transect Overlay is intended to enable and qualify the Transect Overlay Code contained within the Airdrie Mixed Use Centres Design Guidelines policy document. The Transect Overlay is intended to achieve the following objectives: • • • • • • • • • • • • Encourage, Guide, and Enable Smart Growth Development Patterns Provide Precise, yet Flexible Form-Based Design Standards Allow Mixed Use By Right Increase Infrastructure Efficiency Decrease Municipal Infrastructure Costs Increase Lifestyle Choices Decrease Traffic Congestion Promote a Balanced Transportation System Increase Transit Viability and Efficiency Connect Land Use and Transportation Allow for Expanded Development Opportunities and Land Use Flexibility Allow for the Natural Evolution of Urbanism Over Time (2) Application (a) The Transect Overlay is optional for all land use districts except for the following districts: RR-1, R-1, R-1C, R-1, MH-P, industrial districts that prohibit residential integration, C-HWY, and Mixed Use (MU) districts. (b) The Transect Overlay option may be exercised at the discretion of the Approving Authority and must be designed in accordance with the Airdrie Mixed Use Centres Design Guidelines policy document. (c) A Transect Overlay is mandatory for all MU and CB districts. (d) With exception to the Mixed Use District, the Transect Overlay is intended as an optional regulatory mechanism. Use of the Transect Overlay is encouraged by increased development opportunities and by other incentives. (3) Authority (a) The Transect Overlay Code is intended to supersede and/or exceed the standards within the underlying land use district in the following categories: • • • • • • CITY OF Permitted, Prohibited, and Discretionary Uses Setback and Yard Requirements Density Building Heights Parking Standards Landscaping Requirements AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES APPENDIX 47 (b) Where the Transect Overlay Code does not provide provisions, the requirements of the underlying land use district shall apply. (c) Pre-existing special land use requirements shall be maintained or instituted at the discretion of Council. (d) The Transect Overlay Code may set additional design requirements above and beyond the provisions set within land use districts. (4) Regulating Plan A Regulating Plan is required to establish the Transect Overlay and is submitted as part of the normal Neighbourhood Structure Plan process. The Regulating Plan establishes the location of Transect Zones which are regulated by the Transect Overlay Code. A sample regulating plan is included within the Airdrie Mixed Use Centres Development Guidelines. Regulating Plans will be filed within the Land Use Bylaw and added to a citywide key map identifying Transect Overlays. The Regulating Plan identifies the following: (a) The Name of the Transect Overlay as (Development Name) Transect Overlay” (b) Internal streets and alleys including connections to adjacent properties (c) Allocation of Transect Zones within Development Blocks (d) Allocated Civic Spaces and Civic Space Types (e) Designation of Mandatory and Recommended At-Grade Retail Frontages along a Shopping Street (f ) Designation of Terminated Vista locations that require that the building be provided with architectural articulation of a type and character that responds to the location during Development Permit application to the satisfaction of the approving authority. (g) Designation of existing Buildings of Value, requiring that such buildings and structures may be altered or demolished only when in accordance with procedure outlined for such structure by the City of Airdrie. (h) Designation of Internal Block Parking Lot Locations (5) Incentives To increase mixed use viability and to encourage further mixed use development, the following incentives are provide as part of the Transect Overlay: • • • • • • • • • • Provision for Mixed Use to occur “By Right” allowing for increased development options and adaptability on individual development sites. Adoption of Central Business District parking standards for all Transect Overlays as established within section xxx of the Airdrie Land Use Bylaw. Allowance of Shared Parking Standards as established within section xxx of the Transect Overlay Code. This allows for increased density. Tax Incentive 1 (Property) Tax Incentive 2 (First Businesses) Expedite or Alter Approvals Process (check MGA) Review Fees Waived Traffic Impact Study Waived Municipal Investment of Public Amenities and Thoroughfares Waiving of Transportation Impact Fees (in the future?) **The above incentives are for discussion purposes only. Each one needs to be explored for viability and legality. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES APPENDIX 48 APPENDIX B: PROPOSED LAND USE DISTRICT: MIXED USE DISTRICT (MU) (1) Purpose and Intent The purpose of the MU District is to provide for development sites that explicitly allow for a variety of land uses integrated vertically and horizontally within a comprehensively designed development area. An emphasis on street oriented, compact, and pedestrian oriented urban development patterns are regulated by urban design standards set forth within the Transect Overlay Code (TOC) as enabled by the Transect Overlay (TO). A Transect Overlay is required for MU districts as described within the Transect Overlay section(Chapter) x-x. (2) List of Prohibited Uses All uses defined in the Land Use Bylaw are discretionary uses excepting the following, which are not allowed: Adult Entertainment Agriculture, Commercial Agriculture, Extensive Agriculture, Intensive Auction Establishments Boarding and Impounding Kennels Cemeteries Equipment Rentals Key Lock Gas Service Manufactured Home Sales Modular Home Sales Recreation Facilities, Outdoor Recreation Facilities, Indoor (Or size limit?) Storage Facilities, Indoor Storage, Recreational Vehicle Warehouse Retail (3) General Requirements A transect overlay as described in section xxx is mandatory for all MU districts. A regulating plan must be submitted in accordance to section xxx and the Airdrie Mixed Use Centre Design Guidelines. General Land Use provisions contained in Sections 3.1 - 3.4 and 5.1of this Bylaw, which are not superceded by the Transect Overlay, shall still apply to all development areas within the MU district. CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES APPENDIX 49 APPENDIX C: SAMPLE REGULATING PLAN (Plan and Regualting Plan by DPZ&Co.) CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES APPENDIX 50 Sample Regulating Plan: This regulating plan is from Bradburn in Westminster, Colorado. The site context is similar to the suburban mixed use centres identified within Airdrie. The following are photos of the project under construction. A B F A D C B E C D E F CITY OF AIRDRIE MIXED USE CENTRES | DESIGN GUIDELINES APPENDIX 51