a PDF - Front of House
Transcription
a PDF - Front of House
Pro Audio Network Wars: Will It Take A Guitar Maker to Get It Right? ThE NEws MagazinE For LivE Sound December 2005 Vol. 4 No. 3 Jackson Honored With Parnelli Innovator Award AUSTIN, TX—Either the FOH crew is prescient or we got lucky. Last month, we covered the plethora of competing formats in the pro audio world for the delivery and control of digital sound, and while we were busy kvetching, the leading company in the network world and one of the most important MI manufacturers were working out a deal that may have implications in the live event audio world. Gibson Guitar Corp. and chipmaker Cirrus Logic, Inc. have entered into an agreement to develop and deliver a new generation of digital audio networking products beginning in 2006. Building upon Cirrus Logic’s CobraNet technology and Gibson’s MaGIC technology, the new products will provide high-channel count-media transport solutions for professional markets while enabling secure multiroom distribution of media content in consumer markets. Gibson and Cirrus Logic will focus on the development of next-generation gigabit Ethernet-based products designed to continued on page 35 Counterfeiters Caught in Southeast Asia NILES, IL—Shure Incorporated has conducted a series of raids in cooperation with Thai authorities, which has dealt a significant blow to those involved with the importation and distribution of counterfeit Shure products in Thailand. Initiatives by the Thai Customs authorities earlier this year have resulted in the seizure of a container of counterfeit audio goods that were imported through Klongtoey Port, Bangkok. Among the products in this shipment was a large quantity of counterfeit SM58 microphones destined for retail outlets around Thailand. In addition to the seizure of these goods, the importer was subsequently arrested and charged with trafficking counterfeit products into Thailand. “These successful and decisive actions in Thailand go a long way to show our commitment in ensuring that Shure customers receive a genuine Shure product every time they purchase a product that bears our name,” said Rob Ascough, managing director of Shure Asia Ltd. continued on page 35 New President for AKG VIENNA, AUSTRIA—Stefan Gubi has assumed responsibility as president of AKG Acoustics. Gubi succeeds Dr. Hugo Lenhard Backhaus, who left AKG at the end of June. "As a music enthusiast, it is fascinating to me to lead an organization which is preeminent in the international world of music and audio technology,” Gubi said recently. The term “music enthusiast” is key. In its 58 years AKG has registered more than 1,500 worldwide patents and most of its leaders came from backgrounds continued on page 10 In This Issue: Sound Sanctuary Architecture versus Inteligibility, who wins? Bleeding Edge You thought line arrays were the end of all steering sound? Think again. ORLANDO, FL —With clients ranging from Springsteen to Streisand, technology breakthroughs that include pragmatic consoles and cutting-edge processors—as well as the first flown speaker systems—and, lest we forget, mixing The King, Bruce Jackson is a hard guy to miss. He was among the honorees at the 5th Annual Parnelli Awards. See pg. 14 for full coverage. Stefan Gubi Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Cover.EP.indd 1 12/1/05 5:16:25 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 2 12/1/05 5:00:41 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 1 12/1/05 5:01:57 PM Table of Contents December 2005, Vol. 4.03 What’s What’s Hot What’s Hot What’s HotHot 29. The Biz Features 14. Parnelli Awards 2005 The industry gathers once again to honor its finest audio practitioners. Along with a bunch of squints and production slackers that we pretended to care about for the night. 16 Parnelli winner Dave Rat goes to Lampyland and lives to tell the tale. He even took pictures! 24. Installations What do a bunch of churches and a bunch of “gentlemen’s clubs” have in common? Could it be their audio installers? 32. Sound Sanctuary EV Zx4 speakers and a passel of mics from audio legend Bob Heil. We go waaaay off the Great White Way to look at Stomp!, a show that is still running a dozen years after it first opened. 22. The Anklebiters How much does technology matter? What is the price (and the value) of keeping current? 28. On The Bleeding Edge A peek behind the U2 LED curtain with Dave Skaff and Joe O’Herlihy. 36. FOH-at-Large Departments 19. On Broadway 20 How can we get architects to understand that no matter how beautiful it is, if you can’t understand what the pastor is saying, then the building sucks? Baker gets his hands on a nonlethal audio weapon. Not necessarily a great idea… Columns FOH Interview 31. Theory & Practice Okay, we have avoided the math thing for a while, but when it comes to figuring out SPL and power and coverage, there is no avoiding it. 26. Road Tests LDI/ETS Coverage Product placement has come to the world of pro audio. Can a new reality show called The A-1 be far behind? Sure, line arrays improve pattern control, but put audio, a bunch of DSP and some really smart guys together, and you can really steer sound. 4. Editor’s Note 6. News 10. On the Move 12. Showtime 30. In the Trenches 30. Welcome to My Nightmare Feedback Okay, I Give! We received some letters last month in regard to a Road Test on the dbx DriveRack 260. The letters were not about the review or the gear, but about an offhanded and—OK, I admit it—derogatory comment I made about drummers at the end of the piece. These two letters kind of sum up the general feelings I hurt. (And, no, I don’t even know what a factorial is…) —Ed. I must tell you that I take personal offense to the “conclusion” section of your article about the dbx DriveRack 260. I use a DriveRack P.A. myself (I don’t need most of the extra features of the 260), work with a soundman who I trained and I am very comfortable with using all sorts of signal-processing gear. I agree that the unit is intuitive enough that most guys with some KNOWLEDGE (not the same as experience) can use it fairly easily. I am curious as to your technical background and 200.0512.TOC.rg.indd 2 qualifications to judge others. Perhaps you could include this information and disseminate it to the masses in one of your future articles. Still, I am a fan and find most of your (and other writers’) information useful. Perhaps you will print this for others, some of whom might be less “aware”. Don’t judge anyone by their “cover”! Here’s a “simple” little test for you (I know its math, but so is the entire electronics field): Why is the factorial of the number 0 = 1? It really is a simple question, do you know the answer? Best Regards, Tom Blazek, B.S.E.E., B.S. Physics, MBA… DRUMMER!!! I read with much interest your review of the DriveRack 260, mainly because we have the DriveRack P.A. and have been very happy, and if this version had been available when we purchased ours, the 260 is what we’d have right now. The difference the DriveRack makes and the time it saves me in sound checks has been a lifesaver. When you are in a different place every weekend, it is very reassuring that you can pink the room and be even more confident in your mix. But I take exception with you on one statement in your review’s conclusion. You see, here in the wilds of West Virginia and Ohio, most (and I mean ALL) bars that have bands on the weekends do not have their own P.A. or sound girl (wink, wink). My husband is originally from Roanoke, Va., and then Detroit, so this was very strange for him to contend with. He is used to clubs that provide the bands with sound and an engineer. My husband joined a band here, and the P.A. that was continued on page 27 12/1/05 5:25:57 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 3 12/1/05 5:03:36 PM Editor’s Note What’s It All About? D on’t you just hate it when I use this limited amount of space to wax philosophical instead of writing about something cool like gear or new tech? I can hear the groans already. “Oh crap, here he goes again. Can he please just get to the f’ing point? Forget it, maybe I’ll just turn to the FOH Interview or the Road Tests.” Sorry, but this is what happens when I actually have a little time to think. A bunch of stuff has gone down in the past couple of months that may seem unrelated, but—at least in my twisted mind—adds up to an important point. Item #1—A good friend of mine who does some writing for FOH told me about a gig he did with an act aimed at the preteen set. It was, as you might expect, a track act. We all get to do these, and everyone I have ever done came with a manager or someone who cued the tracks, telling me when to start and stop the prerecorded backing tracks. But on this gig, our intrepid FOH writer reports that he was handed a CD and, when he asked who would be giving cues, was told to just hit “play” and let it go. He did, and it went off flawlessly. The talent had the act so down that even the timing of stage patter was consistent so they could say their little bit and start the next tune. Item #2—Another friend, touring with a major pop act, told me that he was playing every night, but had no idea if the audience ever heard him because “there were eight DA88s in the rack.” That would be eight Tascam eight-track digital recorders for a potential total of 64 playback tracks. Another big pop singer’s tour relied so much on backing tracks that, while the band was “playing” every night, they had to rehearse for two full days to get one song down when a TV talk show refused to let them use their prerecorded tracks as “doubling” (wink, wink). At least, that is what I hear on the lowdown. In these days of nondisclosure agreements on most tours, no one will actually go on record about this stuff. Item #3—I saw an alleged live performance of another preteen act on TV. Three girls, two with guitars that they appeared to be able to play, and a third with a mic. But the guitars were not plugged into anything, and the girls playing them were singing big backup harmonies, but there were no mics onstage except the handheld being used by the lead singer. And the crowd of kiddies cheered and no one seemed to notice anything amiss in this “live” performance. Item #4—Yet another friend called after seeing the Stones to report that Mick Jagger must have “gone down to the crossroads” because it was the only explanation for a man of his age having that kind of energy and charisma. He raved about how Ron Wood and Keith Richards were so tuned in to each other that they finished one another’s musical sentences. Item #5—Took my daughter to see one of those Big Screen Concert shows at a movie theatre that featured film of a Bruce Springsteen show from 1975. (Just to brag about my kid’s taste for a second: At 15, she was the youngest person in attendance by a good 20 years.) Watching this show with minimal lighting and primitive sound (the monitors appeared to be a couple of Bose cabs leaned back against a box or crate) and Publisher Terry Lowe [email protected] Editor Bill Evans [email protected] Technical Editor Mark Amundson [email protected] Associate Editor Allison Rost [email protected] By BillEvans being blown away by the power and presence and sheer talent of this band made me really think about items 1 through 3 above. You know, we are service providers. We don’t control who gets onstage or what they do while they are there. But the accelerating move toward packaged, prerecorded acts aimed at kids does not bode well for the future of live event audio. If these kids are raised to think that Ashlee Simpson or anyone else dancing around and pretending to sing and/or play is a live performance, why are they going to bother going out to a show? We need to educate the next generation on what real music is really all about. FOH publisher Terry Lowe has often called concerts the modern equivalent of the ancient tribal gathering, and I think he is right. But if there is nothing really live about a live show, then why not just stay home and watch it on that 60-inch plasma display in pristine 7.1 surround sound? What can we do about it? Probably not a lot, but keep it in mind, and the next time you get a chance to provide sound for a “real” band—real people playing real music—take it and cherish it as the gift it is. And I am not naive enough—as sucky as it is to be part of The Big Lie—to suggest that any of us turn down work, but if the time comes when you really have to make a choice between that real talent and a canned act that pays better, and there is no way to pull off doing both gigs, well, let’s just say that I trust that you will do the right thing. Contributing Writers Jerry Cobb, Dan Daley, Steve La Cerra, David John Farinella, Nort Johnson, Paul H. Overson, Baker Lee, Tony Mah, Bryan Reesman, Jamie Rio, Richard Rutherford, Photographers Steve Jennings, Bree Kristel Production Manager Shawnee Schneider [email protected] Senior Graphic Designer Robert A. Gonzalez [email protected] Graphic Designers Ezra Padua [email protected] Josh Harris [email protected] National Sales Manager Peggy Blaze [email protected] National Advertising Director Gregory Gallardo [email protected] General Manager William Hamilton Vanyo [email protected] Business and Advertising Office 18425 Burbank Blvd. Suite 613 Tarzana, CA 91356 Ph: 818.654.2474 Fax: 818.654.2485 Circulation Stark Services P.O. Box 16147 North Hollywood, CA 91615 Front Of House (ISSN 1549-831X) Volume 4 Number 3 is published monthly by Timeless Communications Inc., 18425 Burbank Blvd., Suite 613, Tarzana, CA 913566902. Periodicals Postage Paid at Tarzana, CA and additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send address changes to Front Of House, PO Box 16147, North Hollywood, CA 91615-6147. Front Of House is distributed free to qualified individuals in the live sound industry in the United States and Canada. Mailed in Canada under Publications Mail Agreement Number 40033037, 1415 Janette Ave., Windsor, ON N8X 1Z1 Overseas subscriptions are available and can be obtained by calling 1-818-654-2474. Editorial submissions are encouraged but will not be returned. All Rights Reserved. Duplication, transmission by any method of this publication is strictly prohibited without the permission of Front Of House. ES TA E NTERTAINMENT SERVICES & TECHNOLOGY ASSOC IATION Publishers of... Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc December 2005 200.0512.EdNote.rg.indd 4 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:20:28 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 5 12/1/05 5:04:32 PM News D A V Productions Makes First Use of Yamaha M7CL in North America LAS VEGAS, NV—In a move that can only be described as “gutsy,” D A V Productions recently picked up a Yamaha M7CL desk at midnight, spent an hour learning the ins and outs of the new digital board and put it on the truck for load-in of a large corporate event that same afternoon. The digital console was purchased through T.C. Furlong of Lake Forest, Ill., expedited via air freight for a midnight pickup in Las Vegas and was immediately pressed into service for the Pepsi Big Air show at Mandalay Bay. “This latest addition to Yamaha’s lineup of digital mixing consoles is a perfect fit for much of what we do,” says part-owner and chief operating officer Ben Brownback. “After about an hour of learning the console,” Brownback adds, “the guys had it down. We made the decision to load it into the Pepsi show that afternoon, where it has performed flawlessly. Based on the fact that it’s part of the first 20 shipped out, and the fact that we fast-tracked it onto our show site, this is probably the first production use of the new M7CL in North America.” Why See the Movie When Rent is Still Rocking on Broadway? NEW YORK, NY—“In theatre, unintelligibility is not an option.” With that, award-winning Broadway sound designer Brian Ronan sums up his attitude toward vocal reinforcement and explains the chief hurdle he faced in designing an all-new sound system for the musical Rent, which he characterizes as a “rock opera.” Achieving the required clarity is fairly straightforward on the orchestra level of the 1,200-seat house, but not as easy in the steeply-raked 500-seat balcony. “The Nederlander is a room with two very different sounds upstairs and down,” Ronan explains. Despite the differing needs of the upper and lower parts of the hall, Ronan had little time to experiment on the long-running show, currently in its 10th year at New York’s Nederlander Theatre. “It’s very unusual to replace the system on a running show,” Ronan explains. “However, they had always felt they could improve the sound, so when the musical director brought up the subject they decided, to their credit, to take the hit.” Ronan was allotted one week to strip the old system, install the new one, rehearse with the band and cast twice and then reopen. “I had taken a class this past summer on Meyer’s MAPP Online Pro acoustical prediction program,” Ronan says. “I contacted design services manager Todd Meier at Meyer Sound on a Friday, and by Sunday evening, Meyer’s technical support representative Mike Maxson had visited the theater to hear what would be expected of the system. Monday, we ‘MAPPed.’ We knocked it right out, and by Tuesday, I had a rental order together.” Design in hand, Ronan turned to the Mt. Vernon, N.Y., office of Production Resource Group (PRG) to provide the equipment he needed. continued on page 8 200.0512.News.JH.indd 6 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc December 2005 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:28:18 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 7 12/1/05 5:06:14 PM News America West Arena Installs Flexible Sound System PHOENIX, AZ—Since installing a Martin Audio loudspeaker system as part of multimillion dollar audio and video upgrade last year, America West Arena has found new uses for the sound system. Recently, they were able to reconfigure the speaker clusters for the University of Phoenix Online’s graduation ceremonies. As described by AWA audio manager Carson Price, the process was quick and relatively painless. “When we set up for normal concerts or this type of event, instead of our usual setup in the round, the stage goes at the north end, so we took our northwest and northeast clusters of the 12 Martin Audio W8LCs, moved them around and faced them in the proper direction, south,” Price explains “Then, we took those two clusters of 12 and moved them to the edge of the stage, like a normal concert, and we have extension cables that live on our catwalk and drop down. So, we didn’t have to do any reprogramming; we just muted the clusters we weren’t using and we were off to the races.” Price says. “Putting the system together didn’t take much time at all and saved on labor as well. We actually have an extra Crest 48-input console on the floor and we mix the event just like a concert.” AWA hosted three graduation ceremonies over two successive days, each with approximately 1,200 graduates. The results? As Price puts it, “The clients couldn’t have been any happier. You could hear every word of every speech. We had two podiums and video playback, and also recorded it on DVD for sale.” The overall system consists of eight clusters, with each cluster having different speaker combinations. The four main clusters have W8LC Compacts, and there are two clusters with four WLX Subs and eight W8LM Minis; and two clusters with eight W8LX Subs and two W8LM Minis. To further accommodate concert work, the installer, Genesis Audio Systems, installed a wireless network, Crown IQ, with a graphic interface for the arena to allow for control of the P.A. for the floor. Why See the Movie When Rent is Still Rocking on Broadway? continued from page 6 The system settled on was based around a center cluster design with a main array of eight M2D compact curvilinear array loudspeakers. “I knew I wanted a single array in the balcony to cut down on reflections, and I chose M2Ds for their power and size. The 90º spread took care of the whole balcony.” The cluster was augmented with two 600-HP compact high-power subwoofers, one on either side of the array, with another four 600-HP cabinets used for floor subs. “The new 600-HPs tucked under an overhang in the stage for a perfect fit,” Ronan says. “They gave much-needed bottom to the balcony, and added punch to the orchestra level.” Ronan also used four CQ-1 wide coverage main loudspeakers for some of the stereo effects and to act as mains on the orchestra floor. The cabinets were hung on the proscenium, two at about the height of the actors’ heads and two higher up for the balcony. “The CQ-1’s 80º horizontal spread filled in the orchestra level with nice smooth coverage,” he says,“and I know and love that horn.” Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.News.JH.indd 8 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc December 2005 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:29:00 PM News PRG in Jeopardy! and Behind the Wheel LOS ANGELES, CA—When Sony Pictures Television’s Wheel of Fortune and Jeopardy! leave their respective studios to tape shows, PRG is there, providing substantial gear and support for both productions. During November, both Jeopardy! and Wheel of Fortune aired shows that took place on the road late this summer. Jeopardy! taped a college tournament at RBC Center in Raleigh, N.C., while Wheel of Fortune taped their shows in New Orleans, La. “Typically, when people think of a show like this coming to their town, I doubt they have any idea how much is involved. We travel with more than 100 staff and crewmembers, and there are usually 14 to 17 trucks of equipment and set,” explains FOH mixer and system designer Bill Daly from PRG Audio. Daly takes a significant quantity of PRG’s audio gear out on the road with both shows. “Our equipment packages rival any large scale touring show,” Daly contends. For both game shows, Daly uses a line array P.A. that includes cabinets from JBL, L-ACOUSTICS and NEXO. “Having a variety of gear options really does help. Due to the depth of PRG’s inventory, I have the luxury of great equipment availability and choosing how it will all fit together in a cohesive package,” he explains. PRG also provides an experienced audio crew that knows how to deal with the intricacies of doing TV shows out of the studio. The PRG Audio crew consists of crew chief/system engineer Alan Henig and system engineer/ floor A2 Larry Borgarding. David Hoover manages the account in PRG’s Orlando office. Hot New Nightclub Calls Queens Home Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc QUEENS, NY—One of the newest nightclubs in New York bears a name that implies sleepiness. But Soma, a high-end nightspot in the Astoria area of Queens, is hardly a sleepinducing place. On the contrary, Soma is playing host to some of the hottest acts in the New York metro area with a new sound system built around Turbosound. Frank Garcia, owner of Mainline Pro Lighting, Sound and Video, the Flushing, N.Y., company that installed the sound system, says a complement of four Turbosound models, each with distinct capabilities, work together to deliver the kind of sound splash the club’s new owners were looking to make. “We needed near-field capabilities with even distribution,” Garcia says. “All of the speakers work together, and the result is what the client wanted—do the sound system install once and do it right.” In all, Garcia used 28 Turbosound speakers to cover four main areas of the club, which is spread over two floors. In the club’s two VIP lounges, Garcia selected Turbosound TCS-59s. Four were deployed in the larger of the two, and two were installed in the other. In the 30- by 30-foot room, the four were installed catty-corner to each other, all facing toward the center of the room. In the 30- by 20-foot room, two TCS-59s are deployed in two corners, one across from the other. Additionally, four TCS-59s were used to provide coverage for the bar, while four TQ-315s provide sound to the dance floor area. In the entrance area, Garcia opted for TCS-35 speakers, installing six. And the TCS-35s also are deployed in the larger VIP lounge; eight of them complement the TCS-59s. In addition to their sound capabilities, the Turbosound products also addressed the owner’s aesthetic concerns. With their low profile, the speakers fit well into the ceiling areas. Their availability in white also helped Garcia blend the speakers into the club’s environment in the downstairs area. www.fohonline.com 200.0512.News.JH.indd 9 December 2005 12/2/05 2:08:51 PM On The Move BC Sound and Lighting of Battle Creek, Mich., a longtime dealer and contractor of ISP Technologies products, has expanded their operations. BC Sound and Lighting has recently moved into a 12,000-square-foot building in Battle Creek. In addition, Jason A. Hinz has joined ISP as vice president of sales. Cadac Electronics Plc has appointed Bob Thomas as its managing director. Formerly MD of TEAC (UK), Thomas takes up this new post as Clive Green formally retires after more than 37 years at the helm. Bob Thomas Community Professional Loudspeakers has named Benchmark Audio Sales as their new Northeastern sales representatives. Based in Norwalk, Conn., Benchmark will represent the company in the states of Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Maine, Vermont and New Hampshire. Eventide has named Dino Virella Pro Sales & Marketing as its representative for professional audio products for Northern California and northern Nevada. Dino Virella Inter-M Americas, Inc. has named Metro Tek as its new rep for the New York City metro area and northern New JerBarry Seiden sey. The firm is led by Barry Seiden with the assistance of Amy Weinstock. JBL Professional has made three new appointments. Simon Jones has been named director of portable P.A. marketSimon Jones ing, Phil Sanchez has been appointed product manager for commercial sound prod- Phil Sanchez Harald Kanz ucts and Harald Kanz is JBL Professional’s new product manager for portable P.A. products. Mills James Productions recently broke ground on a 3,000-square-foot addition to its new warehouse complex in Columbus, Ohio. The additional space, expected to be completed by April 1, 2006, will feature an enclosed loading docks, scene shop and set storage area. Bryan Dowd has joined ProSonic Solutions as a sales representative for several live and retail audio product lines. Bryan Dowd Shure Incorporated has appointed Jim Schanz as a regional sales manager. He will be responsible for managing the company’s regional sales in a variety of Midwestern and East Coast regions. Jim Schanz Solid State Logic has made three new appointments at its UK headquarters in Oxford. Jim Motley has been appointed as partnership manager for the XLogic range of products, Filip Saelen has been appointed software product manager and Jon Jannaway is a new marketing manager. New President for AKG continued from front cover compatible with developing technology for the music industry. Gubi is described as “an industry veteran with a 20-yearplus track record of achievement in sales, marketing and general management.” His resumé includes positions on the executive committee of Austrian IT firm Kapsch Business Com AG, as managing director of the Upper Austrian National Publishing House and in senior management with Ericsson Austria. In what may be seen as an extension of the industry’s move toward “adult supervision” in its executive ranks, experience in anything related to audio on Gubi's CV is notable in its absence. We have seen others struggle as talented execs from other fields try to adapt to or change the culture of the pro audio world to line up with traditional business templates. Stay tuned. Thanks for a Great Year! 2005 has been a banner year for FOH and we have seen significant increases in both reader awareness and industry acceptance. From the staff and management of Timeless Communications, we would like to say thank you to our readers, contributors and advertisers for their continuing support. Here’s to a great 2006. 10 December 2005 200.0512.OnTheMove.JH.indd 10 www.fohonline.com 12/2/05 10:18:24 AM Everything you need literally at your fingertips with a touch screen panel display. Access and control console parameters, name and configure input and output channels, set up built-in effects, dynamic processors, noise gates, mix assignments and much more... No layers...everything is on the surface. In/out channel section configured in blocks of 8 for easy access. Easier and more efficient that analog! CentralogicTM operation allows the mix engineer to remain at the center of the console, where all channels and mixes can be controlled. Two models. The M7CL is available in 32 and 48 channel configurations. Its small footprint saves seats when installed. Its light weight saves your back when on the road! Placed in just the right spot, the meter bridge is located over the touch panel. Instant visual confirmation of all input and output levels. 3 MY card slots on the rear panel give you 48 channels of I/O for stage monitors, multi-track recording and playback. CentralogicTM controls get you where you need to go quickly. The recall section gives instant access to the 300 scene memories. 12 user define keys get you to the places that you’ve pre-selected. CentralogicTM keys bring input channels, mixes and DCA’s to the center controls in an instant. Sound Logic Yamaha pioneered the transition from analog to digital in disregards in live mixing is finally solved in the digital sound reinforcement mixing consoles. We led, we listened, domain. The features are another price/performance break- we learned. M7CL is the answer to all the challenges raised through in the tradition of PROMIX 01, 02R and DM2000. by our customers and posed to our engineers. With our new This is the board you’ve been waiting for. All you could Centralogic operational platform and non-layered fader ask for in a digital mixer, backed by Yamaha’s 24-7 technical function/touch-screen interface, the reaction time Murphy support, training, and exclusive dealer network. The New M7CL Digital Mixer. Sounds Logical. Find out more at www.yamahaca.com Yamaha Corporation of America • P.O. Box 6600, Buena Park, CA 90622-6600 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 11 ©2005 Yamaha Corporation of America 12/1/05 5:22:51 PM Showtime Gothicfest 2005 Venue Odeum Sports and Expo Center, Villa Park, IL Crew Sound Co/Provider: Tantra Tour Sound, Inc. FOH Engineer: Dave Lowum Monitor Engineers: Ed Marzano, Rich Koc, Jeff Evans Systems Engineer: Mike “Bo” Topousis, Chris Bowie System Techs: Tedd Lupella, Alex Lupella, Jim Griffith Crew Sound Company : Rat Sound Systems Inc. Band’s FOH Engineer: Greg Nelson Band Monitor Engineer: Karrie Keyes Crew Chief: Tommy LBC System Technician: Brian Teed Assistant Technician: Jamie Harris, Taka Nakai, Peter Baigent Tour Manager: Mark Smith Production Manager: Lyle Centola Gear FOH Console: Soundcraft MH4-48, Allen & Heath ML5000-48 Speakers: NEXO Alpha Amps: Crest Pro9200 Processing: Roland SRV2000; Yamaha SPX990, SPX2000, REV-500; TC M2000 and D-Two, Drawmer DS501, DS201, DS404, dbx 160A, KT DN360 Mics: Shure, Audix, Sennheiser, AKG, Countryman Power Distro: TTS custom/Motion Labs Rigging: CM 1-Ton MON Console: Allen & Heath, Yamaha Speakers: Yorkville TX5M, TX4, EV MTL2 Amps: QSC PL218 and PL236 Pearl Jam Winter Tour 2005 Gear FOH Console: Yamaha PM5D Speakers: L-ACOUSTICS V-DOSC, dV-DOSC, Arcs, Kudo, MTD 108a Amps: Crown MA5000VZ, L-ACOUSTICS LA48 Processing: BSS DPR901, Empirical Labs Distressor, XTA DP226 Mics: Shure, Audix OM6 MON Console: Midas Heritage 3000 Speakers: Rat L Wedge, Microwedge 12 Amps: Crest, Chevin Processing: BSS FCS-960, Aphex 720, Klark Teknik DN410 PEM: Sennheiser IEM300G2 34th International Steel Guitar Convention Venue Millennium Hotel, St. Louis, MO Crew Sound Co/Provider: Pearl Productions FOH Engineer: Don Lanier Monitor Engineer: Earl Parrish Systems Engineer: Steven Lanier Production Manager: Mike Brown of Peavey Electronics Tour Manager: Bill Ferguson System Tech: Lou Watson Speakers: Peavey Q wave and DTH S5 Amps: Peavey CS4080HZ, CS3000, CS800S Processing: Peavey Kosmos Pro, TC Electronic M-One XL, D-Two, dbx, Lexicon Mics: Peavey Diamond 46, 520I, 535I PVM Drum Series Power Distro: PearlPro 200-amp 3-phase custom Rigging: Genie MON Console: Peavey 2410M Speakers: 10 x Peavey DTH M L/R Amps: Peavey CS800S Processing: Peavey, Lexicon, dbx Mics: Peavey Gear FOH Console: Crest Audio HP-8/32 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.showtime.rg.indd 12 12/1/05 5:28:57 PM Jon Secada/Joey Daniels Venue Gear Windjammer, Guantanamo Bay, Cuba FOH Console: AudioArts Wheatstone Speakers: Proprietary LRC Amps: Carver Processing: Ashly, Martin Mics: Shure, Sennheiser, A-T Power Distro: Proprietary Crew Sound Co/Provider: Clearwing Productions, Inc. FOH Engineer: Gary J. Brunclik Monitor Engineer: Adam Webb Systems Engineer: Chris Balke Production Manager: Gary J. Brunclik Tour Manager: Will Byrd System Techs: Shorty, Reed and Robo Viento de Agua Latin Tour Venue Woodrow Wilson Auditorium, Beckley, WV Crew Sound Co/Provider: Welsh Sound LLC FOH Engineer: James Welsh Monitor Engineer: Chris Kourtsis Systems Engineer: Michael Monseur Production Manager: Hector “Tito” Matos Tour Manager: Dawn Welsh System Techs: Michael Monseur, Albert Felicio III Gear MON Console: Soundcraft Spirit Monitor 2 32 x 12 Speakers: 10 x Wharfedale EVP-M12s and 4 x Twin 12 Coaxial Bi-Amp Wedges Amps: Wharfedale SE1200, 970, QSC MX700 Processing: TDM Crossovers, dbx and Behringer Graphic EQs Power Distro: WSLP 100 AMP Single Phase Rigging: CM Loadstar 1-Tons The Roots w/ Jill Scott & Friends Venue Kimmel Center for the Performing Arts, Philadelphia, PA Crew Sound Co/Provider: Clear Sound Inc. FOH Engineer: Artless Poole, Jim Roach Monitor Engineer: Ephrem Jenkins, Foster Systems Engineer: Jim Roach Production Manager: Dave Theile Tour Manager: Keith McPhee System Techs: Foster Gear Crew FOH Console: Yamaha PM5D Speakers: 12 x Meyer MSL-4, 4 x Meyer CQ1, 4 x Meyer UPA-1P, 8 x EAW SB-1000 Amps: Crown MA-3600 Processing: 2 x Summit TLA-100, BSS DPR901ii, FDS-355, Yamaha SPX990, Lexicon PCM-42, TC Electronic M2000, D-Two Mics: Shure SM58, Beta58, SM57, Beta57, Beta98, Beta91, Beta52, SM 81, AKG C451, Neumann KMi-84, Yamaha Sub Kick, Sennheiser 421, Countryman Type 85 DI Power Distro: Motion Labs Rigging: House System Sound Co/Provider: Third Ear Sound FOH Engineer: Raul Suarez Monitor Engineer: Michael Grass Systems Engineer: Paul Cain MON Console: Yamaha PM5D-RH Speakers: EAW SM200, SM500, Shure PSM700, PSM600 Sensaphonics Earphones Amps: Crown MA3600 Processing: Ashly Protea 4.24C Mics: Shure, AKG, Sennheiser, Neumann Power Distro: Motion Labs Rigging: House System Breakout Systems: Whirlwind Snake Systems: Whirlwind KSOL Festival del Sol w/ Intocable Gear FOH Console: Yamaha PM4000 Speakers: JBL VerTec VT-4888 Amps: QSC PL6.0 Processing: XTA DPR226, BSS 960, dbx160X, 166A, Roland SDE3000, Yamaha SPX1000, Lexicon PCM80 Mics: Shure, AKG, Sennheiser, Countryman Power Distro: Third Ear Custom and Motion Labs Rigging: CM Loadstar MON Console: Yamaha PM4000M and Ramsa WR-840 Speakers: Third Ear PowerPoint, JBL 4894, Radian TES-218 Amps: QSC PL236 and PL6.0 Processing: dbx DriveRack 480, JBL DSC260 Mics: Shure, AKG, Sennheiser, Countryman Power Distro: Third Ear Custom and Motion Labs Venue Santa Clara County Fairgrounds, San Jose, CA Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc FOH Console: Soundcraft Series Two 40 x 8 Speakers: 6 x Wharfedale Lix-15, 4 x EV 2x18 Subs Amps: QSC EX and RMX Series Processing: dbx Drive Rack, 2231, 166XL, 166A, Samson S-Gates, Alesis, Lexicon and TC Electronic Effects, Smaart Live Mics: Shure Beta 58, SM52, SM57, A-T MBK4, Pro 37R, Samson CO3, MXL 990, Whirlwind DIs Power Distro: WSLP 100 AMP Single Phase Rigging: CM Loadstar 1-Tons Breakout Assemblies: Whirlwind and Horizon Sub snakes Snake Assemblies: Whirlwind Concert 52 2-way splitter MON Console: AudioArts Wheatstone Speakers: PSM600, PSM700 Processing: Aphex, dbx IEM Mics: Shure, Sennheiser, A-T Power Distro: Proprietary www.fohonline.com 200.0512.showtime.rg.indd 13 December 2005 13 12/1/05 5:29:54 PM Parnelli Innovator Award Wimmer Bruce Jackson Star-Studded Parnelli Honors Industry’s B Bruce Jackson Receives Innovator Award, Dave Rat honored as FOH Mixer of the Year FOH Mixer of the Year Award Winner Dave Rat By Kevin M.Mitchell “W “I spent my career making sure I’m not in front of the mic when the audience is in the house, and here you go and do this to me.” – Dave Rat Presenter Dave Shadoan Rergional Sound Company of the Year Award Winner Kerry Darenkamp of Mid-America 14 December 2005 200.0512.Parnelli.ep.indd 14 elcome to the 5th Annual Parnelli Awards,” said PLSN and FOH publisher and Parnelli Award dinner host Terry Lowe. And thus began LDI/ETS convention’s most anticipated event. Held this year at the beautiful Rosen Centre, the industry’s legends, stars, up-andcomers and likely a few ne’er-do-wells came to honor this year’s top performers in 18 categories. Additionally, highlights included bestowing achievement awards on Patrick Stansfield and Bruce Jackson. “Tonight, the production community comes together to honor its own,” Lowe said in his introduction. He pointed out that the industry’s influence could be found in the way we worship, how we present our political leaders, at tradeshows and “all the way to retail. Many of those pioneers who developed the technology and methodology of our industry are here with us tonight.” Indeed. The night featured a star-studded crowd that was mostly on its best behavior (save for a hilariously obscene phone call from Keith Kevan) and mostly looking classier than usual (save for the always Hawaiian shirt-attired Dave Shadoan). Brian Croft and Mike Brown, both also Lifetime Achievement Award winners, took the podium next. They handed the Set/Scenic Designer of the Year award to Mark Fisher for his work with the Rolling Stones; Set Construction Company of the Year was a surprise tie, going to both All Access Staging and Production and Tait Towers; Staging Company of the Year to Mountain Productions; and the Rigging Company of the Year honor going to Atlanta Rigging Systems. Appropriately, Roy Clair of Clair Bros was on hand to present Bruce Jackson with the 2005 Parnelli Innovator Award. Clair was an influential player in Jackson’s extraordinary and prolific life. As the documentary Lowe produced to highlight just a few of his remarkable achievements said:“Any part of the career of Bruce Jackson is enviable, any part worthy of honor. Anyone who has worked the knobs of a mixing board would love to have the names of Bruce Springsteen, Barbra Streisand, Fleetwood Mac, Johnny Cash and Elvis on their resume. But from his development of parametric EQ for live mixing boards to his groundbreaking work in digital sound, he has and continues to drastically improve the live event experience.” Jackson had flown all the way from his native Australia to receive the award. FOH editor Bill Evans, with sound engineer Buford Jones, came next, presenting the Sound Company of the Year award to Clair Brothers. An evening highlight came next when well-respected Dave “Rat” Levine of Rat Sound received the FOH Mixer of the Year honor for his work with the Red Hot Chili Peppers. A noticeably humbled Rat got one of the biggest laughs of the night when he said in accepting the award, “I spent my career making sure I’m not in front of the mic when the audience is in the house, and here you go and do this to me.” Monitor Mixer of the Year went to Dave Skaff for his work with U2, and Evans and Jones presented the Parnelli to Mid-America Sound for Regional Sound Company of the Year. The audience gasped, laughed and then applauded wildly when a special video tribute to Patrick Stansfield from the current Neil Diamond crew, including Neil himself, was presented prior to Michael Chugg taking the stage. Chugg, yet another Aussie who made the trek to be part of the evening, is a long time friend and associate of Stansfield. In presenting the lifetime achievement award to Stansfield, Chugg shared many www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:31:06 PM All photos by Bree Kristel Clarke Parnelli Lifetime Achievement Award Winner Patrick Stansfield s Best Sound Company of the Year Award Winner Roy Claire of Claire B rothers Presenter Buford Jones www.fohonline.com 200.0512.Parnelli.ep.indd 15 Production Manager of the Year Award Winner Jake Berry Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc funny personal stories before saying of the respected production and tour manager that he “exemplifies all that is great about our industry—he has always had time for the little people and people not as lucky as us with an open heart, a big grin and plenty of advice.” An eloquent and humbled Stansfield received a standing ovation, and graciously thanked the many who worked with him over his long, successful career, which included a quarter century with Diamond in addition to working with Barbra Streisand, Bob Dylan and many more. “The fashion plate of the audio industry,” Shadoan presented the Coach Company of the Year award to Ziggy’s Custom Coaches and the Trucking Company of the Year to Upstaging. PLSN editor Richard Cadena was joined by Niel Diamon LD Marilyn Lowey, and the two presented the Video Rental Company of the Year to XL Video. Then, Rock-It Cargo received the Freight Forwarding Company of the Year honor and Pryotek Special Effects the Pyro Company of the Year honor. Publisher Lowe was then joined by LD great Peter Morse, and presented a pair of the most highly anticipated awards of the show. Jake Berry received the Production Manager of the Year honor for his work with U2, while David Milam of Toby Keith received Tour Manager of the Year. Lowe thanked all the Parnelli sponsors, without whom the evening and the contributions to the Parnelli Education Fund for Rick “Parnelli” O’Brien’s three children would not be possible: All Access, Apollo, ASI, Brown United, Littlite, Paradise, Martin, PRG, Robe, Rock-It Cargo and Techni-Lux. The multimedia award dinner was produced by Kent Black. December 2005 15 12/1/05 5:31:48 PM THE RATS By DaveRat I feel it prudent to be very thorough in the search and listen to everything possible. Go to “Mouse Town” to Explore LAMPYLAND by Dave Rat W hy in the heck would Soundies go to LDI? Hellooooo? “Lighting Dimension International,” oh boy! Come on, sound people, let’s go listen to the lights! You must be joking. After the fifth person asked me, I began to wonder a bit and decided to do some research. Well, actually, I just walked over and asked Jon Rat what the deal was. Turns out that unlike the “real” audio trade shows, these Lampies came up with the idea of setting up a round robin of full-blown sound systems on actual stages all pointed to a central area. Over the course of three hours, you can hear each of the six stages do a 30-minute presentation showing why they are the magic solution to all that is sound. After some internal deliberation, it was decided; Rat would delegate Daniella Rat and Dave Rat on a journey to ‘Mouse Town East’ to see what the real deal is all about. Unfortunately, due to prior audio commitments, Jon would stay back and hold down the Rat’s nest. Our mission—seek out the things that make sound and determine if the legend is true. 16 December 2005 200.0512.DaveRat.ep.indd 16 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:17:20 PM Right away, even with the blanket term “Entertainment” plastered on the banners, it is immediately evident that we are entering the depths of Lampyland. Is it safe for t wo sound humans to enter? And then, there it is, off in the distance, a distinct sound of something musical, like a magnet drawing me nearer—I find a clue. Yes, something made by “our” people, yet still, this empty, unsatisfied feeling lingers. Not to make these little guys feel bad, but “they are just a bit small.” Obviously some sort of weapon. The Lampies clearly have considerable defenses set up in their lair. I sure hope we are not wearing out our welcome; this could get messy if we upset the Lampy natives. And then I stumble into what I feared most, a Lampy trap. Aaaaaah! As I had suspected, it is true—the Lampy tribes do practice the dark arts. I have obviously been spotted and they are trying to disintegrate me. Now, I realize we are clearly on the right path as we come across a sonic oasis in a desert of lights. At last, something I truly feel at home with—a fishing hole! And so, a little R ‘n R is in order. Aha! There, I see a sign with the names of many tribes with which I am familiar. Are these possibly directions to their lost city? Could it be? But this means re-entering the Dark Chamber of Lights. We must move with haste, Daniella, let’s hurry! That was much too dangerous—we must find a way out! Then, suddenly, we come across some cryptic hieroglyphics. Could be a guidepost, but what does it mean? And where are we? The questions just keep building; we need some answers and we need them fast. D Another breakthrough—an artifact from one of the many sound tribes. We must be getting closer. Behold! Six magnificent structures, each a dedication to a particular sound god. The first to awaken is the structure dedicated to the orange sound god Harmanicus. Notice the cluster of sound worshippers gathering. Not to be outdone though, the temple dedicated to L-GOD is preparing to rise from slumber. And then I spot—in all their magnificence—the Monoliths of the Lost City of Sound. Understandably, I am unable to contain my enthusiasm. Daniella watches as I sprint towards SoundHenge. www.fohonline.com 200.0512.DaveRat.ep.indd 17 December 2005 17 12/1/05 5:18:21 PM The tension builds as an ode to the god NEXOicus releases its rumbling fury. Note the tribal dances of the sound followers as they are moved by the sonic landscape. I bask in pools of sound from of one of the pillars of SoundHenge. The next beast prepares to blanket us with the unseen powers of sound. Hopefully, the sound god Meyericus Micarius will be pleased. I find something about this shrine particularly interesting to listen to. The ‘Sound God of Q’ is paid due respect. As was the Sound Goddess A-Line. As I stood in the middle of SoundHenge, I realized that I was in a truly rare and unique place. Here, each shrine has been designed and constructed to highlight the assets of that specific sound god, some more successfully than others. Some shrines were flawed in design while others were out of their element, and yet others were less-than-optimally implemented. So, without risking bringing the wrath of the sound gods upon myself, I would like to share some thoughts on the shrines. I will leave it up to you to unravel the mysteries of which entity I’m referencing. Subwoofer LF Coverage: The range varied from amazing to pathetic. Best: One had a truly amazing new idea, and while it may run into implementation issues in some venues, I see true vision. Another was just as solid and smooth as the subs should have been. Worst: Holes so deep in coverage that you could fall in them and end up in Japan. Subwoofer Tone: The range was much tighter; at least two manufacturers have a well-damped, low-tuned box that lacks that irritating 40 to 60Hz “bonging” that so many companies love to sell. Main System High-Frequency Fidelity: I always listen to see if the high hat sounds like sand blocks or as though there is actually something metal being hit. Before I walked in, I knew of at least one shrine that would not pass this test. Several shrines did well in this area. Sonic Implementation: I was stunned when one P.A. came up sounding like a wet blanket was over it, especially considering I know the system can perform better. One excellent-sounding system came up so loud and hard, it sent the worshippers scrambling, while a third had such poor quality input signal sent that it was hard to hear its flaws. I felt that all in all, two shrines did a fine job, and one did a great job with three falling behind. Those gods will surely be displeased. Main System Coverage: This was one of my favorites, and it truly points out the beauty of “robin” forums such as this round one. Though not as drastic as the subs’ diversity, there were clearly superior and inferior shrines. I was listening for actual coverage width, tonal quality at the fringes and tonal smoothness within the coverage area. I did my best to factor out system size. The field faired pretty well here with most falling well within the window of acceptability. Two of the designs were excellent. General Look of the Stage: You can figure that one out on your own from the pictures. 18 December 2005 200.0512.DaveRat.ep.indd 18 Thoroughness of Presentation: I was surprised to see gorgeous stages and messy mix positions, like they don’t count. Oh, hey, I’m going to apply for a job, I will wear a nice suit and no shoes because they won’t be looking at my feet. I found it interesting to analyze what the various presenters felt was important. The shrines ranged from sloppy and hodge podge to three-quarters pristine. Not one was thoroughly flawless to the “car show room” level that we should expect from some of these manufacturers, though one was closer. Biggest Screw-Up: No beer, no water, no food, nada! Hello? Let’s see, lure all the Soundies a mile away with lots of P.A., as a carrot of temptation in the hot Florida sun, and then try to dehydrate and starve them during a three-hour sound marathon. It’s an evil Lampy plot, I tell ya! Biggest Wish: That each shrine would have picked a CD track that was then combined into a medley with the tracks from all other shrines that they would then all approve. This medley would then have played through all of the systems in succession after each round robin, as a grand finale, so we would have had a fair and common reference point to compare by. OK, kidding or seriousness aside, whichever you prefer, I must say that the idea of the “sound-off” is brilliant. Finally, a way to truly hear and compare large-scale systems and an opportunity for manufacturers to step up and be judged on the products they offer in real time. Hell, if they can’t set them up to sound good and impress the heck out of us, how can they expect us from the sound engineer tribe to do so? Is there any excuse for a manufacturer with total control over every variable to present anything less than a stellar presentation? That being said, this is a new concept and developing. Manufacturers have shown they are willing, and we as engineers and vendors must support it with our interaction. I learned a tremendous amount about multiple systems in an extremely short period of time. I only wish the presentations were more refined. And I hope our Soundy tribe attendance was strong enough for manufacturers to press the presentations to new levels. Plus, letting so many Lampies congregate without any Soundies keeping them in check is never a good idea. And finally, thank you to Daniella Rat for taking all the photos, for her massive patience, inspiration and changing her holiday plans to investigate the worthy cause of locating SoundHenge! Dave Rat is the founder of Rat Sound Systems Inc. He can be reached at www.ratsound.com. www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:19:25 PM On Broadway By BryanReesman What’s That Stomping Sound? Robert Capellan O ne of the most unusual theatre events you’ll ever experience is Stomp, a percussion-driven ensemble piece with a great sense of fun and playfulness that has been delighting audiences in Manhattan’s East Village for nearly 12 years. During the various acts, eight performers play all manner of objects as instruments— brooms, tubes, lighters, candy boxes, metal objects, poles, pipes, customized percussion kits, even their own bodies. They toss in everything, including four kitchen sinks. The man now running the boards of this long-running show is first-time sound man Robert Capellan, a former DJ who has the challenge of tackling a non-stop, 90-minute performance that requires him to maintain even levels from a constantly mutating aural tapestry. With 18 microphones, 12 speakers and four amplifiers, there is a lot of sound to balance. When did you start working on Stomp? Robert Capellan: I started sound in October. I first started with Stomp as a crewmember with the props, and then I was trained as an assistant stage manager. The show has a lot of energy! It’s very creative…just the energy that they put into instruments that people don’t even know are instruments. There’s not a Broadway or off-Broadway show like this. How many mics are used in the show? There are actually 18 mics on the set. We have four Sennheiser MKH-60 shotguns, including two on the front. We have an AKG at the front center. We have a couple of SM57s within the drums in the back. We have four or five more in the drums at the top of the set. What mics are in the drums up top in the back? There are two Shure 985-TMs, and we have five AKG SE300s. I’m surprised there are so many mics because the show doesn’t sound amplified. The way the show is designed is that you can’t really tell that the show is being amplified because of the way it blends in during each and every act. Stomp takes you on a journey, not knowing what’s going to come up next. You have so many different sounds to juggle—brooms, tubes, trash can lids, lighters…how much are you riding the levels from act to act? We have 96 cues during the show. During “brooms,” every time they hit the handles I move up, and then I move down for the sweeping, so the level in the equalizer is coming back down and up. Hit the sticks, take them back down. It runs like that throughout the show. So you have a lot of preset levels? Yes. Just like during “Poles,” when you hear the click-click-click-click-boom. You want to hear the extra couple of steps that they take after the slamdown. Everything has its own little sound effect for every little part, like during “Hands and Feet,” when they start snapping their fingers. That’s pretty hard to catch up to, but you have to make sure you time it so you can actually hear the volume blend in exactly where it was for the cue before. It’s all about timing and knowing when to hit the cue. In terms of the dB and the gain, we have everything set up at a tone where I try not to get any type of feedback. I’ll come in two hours prior to the show to make sure that the equipment is running well, and that I don’t get any type of feedback. I run a sound meter and make sure that the sound in the theatre is still up to its standards. I do a noise test to make sure that the people in Row X are hearing the same thing as the people in Row C and the same as the people in the balcony, and it’s not like they’re getting a delayed effect on it. What kind of console are you running? We have two O1Vs by Yamaha. We have a graphic equalizer for the main system and two different equalizers for the monitors. What kind of amps are you using? We use Crown amps—Micro-Tech. We have two Micro-Tech 2400s, and also two Crown Micro-Tech 5000 DZs. It’s a small theatre, so we try not to have it too loud and at a basic level that people are satisfied with. What are the biggest challenges for you with this show? Sometimes a mic cable will go out during the show, and I’ll have to find the problem and learn how to recover and jump back on it. If nobody knows a mic went dead, I’ll manually put the faders up on different microphones so they can get that same tone. The challenge mentally right now is learning more. At this moment, I have someone from the UK show over here showing me everything about the system. So this is your first sound gig? This is my first sound job for theatre. I’ve been dealing with sound since I was in my teens, DJing at parties, but I never thought I’d have the opportunity to work in a theatre. Now I hunger to learn more. I’m reading more books and trying to learn more about sound. Music is my life. www.fohonline.com 200.0512.Broadway.rg.indd 19 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc We’re picking up a whole bunch of sound. You can probably only see two or three of them, but they’re there. Some of them are undercover. December 2005 19 12/1/05 5:15:24 PM FOH Interview Dave Skaff — Two Decades on the U2 Team By BillEvans D ave Skaff won the Parnelli Award for Monitor Mixer of the Year in 2005 for his work on the current U2 tour, which is keeping his hands full. In addition to it being a very high profile gig with a band that expects a lot, monitor world is under the stage, so he has to rely on video feeds and a complex talkback system to communicate with his clients. All that and he is using a new console… FOH: Let’s get the obvious out of the way first. You are using the Digidesign Venue… Dave Skaff: I love it. It’s my favorite so far. From what they tell me—I haven’t actually taken it apart and looked at it—the thing was built from the ground up. The mic pre’s are real warm-sounding—closest to what I’ve heard on analog desks that I like. Prior to the Venue? I worked on the D5, and I was able to get around on those pretty easily. It’s laid out very well. There’s a lot of power in the package of a D5. But when I got onto the Venues—when I was with Alicia Keys earlier this year—I spoke to the guys from Digi, and I said, “Hey, can I try one?” They said, “Sure,” and brought one down. I did the last Alicia show on it. In a day where we start everything from scratch and we mix the show that night, it sounded good. With all the associated problems in a day—like, the local company could not figure out how to get the patch straight at all. So, line checks were pushed back and all that. But even so, it was still easy to get around on the desk and do a show. How much of the Venue thing is being driven by the ProTools integration? There seem to be two schools of thought. One is the Pro Tools people, who think it’s a control surface. The other ones are older sound guys who think it’s Pro Tools. It’s a console. The part that most Pro Tools users would be familiar with is the plug-ins availability, which is a whole new world. It’s a really cool new world as well. How are plug-ins going to work for touring? Are there going to be timed versions? A time-out at the end of the tour? I think that’s how it’s going to end up. And for the vendors, it’s going to be something interesting, because it’s all happening a bit fast, actually. I don’t think that there’s any solid consensus on how the vendors want to handle that yet. I still see a lot of outboard gear… That’s our Sennheiser personal monitor transfer rack. This double rack is for Bono and Edge, so there is the standard or normal amount of effects in there. The little Yamaha mixer just handles the talk-backs, because the whole talk-back system is set up to where the back-line guys from the other side of the stage—the ones that we can’t see over here—just open a mic, and it comes straight to my PMs. And I can pick up a mic and talk straight back to them. Without the band hearing it? Without having to hit a switch or anything else? Correct. It saves our life because the band was pretty solid on things happening immediately in their lifetime. They can’t see us, so they’ve gotta have the trust that what they say is gonna happen right away. Sammy the drum tech sits right there. Larry looks over at him and says something. Half the time, I can see it on my screen, but he’s turned his head. I know something’s going on, but Sammy will just pick up a mic and talk right to me. I’ll pick up my talk-back mic and go, “Got it! Acknowledged.” So in the post-mortems later on, if there was something to discuss about some request during the show, it was. “Did From the Beginning—Joe O’Herlihy Front of House ’78. They were doing a college gig in Cork, Ireland, and I was supplying the sound company for the college gig. They were the fifth act on a five-act bill for the night, and I’ve been there ever since. How do you like your D5? You’ve been with the band how long? Twenty-seven years this September. I’m in the entire spectrum, really, from the Bijou and the Bayou club in Philadelphia mixing inside the telephone box to a half-dozen people in the audience, to Giants Stadium and back— from clubs and bars, to clubs and theatres, to gymnasiums, to arenas, to stadiums and back again. It’s been one hell of a ride so far. Do you do anybody else, or do they keep you busy full-time? I’m pretty much full-time, but I started my career with Rory Gallagher from ’72 to ’78, and I met these guys in September of 20 December 2005 200.0512.FOHInterview.ep.indd 20 The D5 is absolutely wonderful. To be perfectly honest, to genuflect in front of the technology pacemakers, I have lived my entire life, through my career, with the concept of “Wouldn’t it be fantastic to be able to do this?” When things like the D5 come along, it’s like an extraordinary experience because it’s fantastic to see the sound reinforcement side of the industry catching up with the studio aspect of the industry. It’s another life because 90% of what we do in the context of using a console like the D5 is preparation. So, you’ll have your band rehearsals. You’ll have your preproduction rehearsals where you get the chance to work on, in my case, 60 or 70 songs. So, at a moment in time, Bono decides, “OK, tonight we’re going to play ‘I Will Follow.’” And the next song up in the set list for everybody might be something else. For me, it’s a touch of a button now, whereas before with my three XL4s, two or three guys would be turning this on and that off… Don’t very often find a guy who’s been around as long as you have who’s really embracing the digital thing like this. You have to be futuristic in your thinking. Working for a band like this pushes the envelope every time in all aspects of technology, from the drawing board of creating a new song, to a blank canvas, to the studio element. Then, it transitions from the studio to the stage, and any technology we can use to make that transition as good and as perfect as it needs to be when we’re trying to replicate what we’re doing on the record or something like that, and introducing the adrenaline-based aspect that associates itself with the performance…all of that— anything to do technology-wise that will enhance that—we embrace wholeheartedly. I’m seeing studio guys out on the road a lot. There’ll be a lot more of it, but you will find out simply because all of the guys like myself are lagging back and not embracing the concept. Look at this as another instrument, as in all the instruments that are on stage. You develop that train of thought, and that’s another way of looking at it. So, what’s the best thing about mixing U2? The best thing about mixing U2 is that every show is different. The set list might remain the same, but there’s an extraordinary energy that develops from the stage to the audience in that whole communication and connection thing, and for me, you learn something new in every show. I wake up every day and I love my job. What’s the hardest thing about mixing U2? I’m a perfectionist at the end of the day. When planes fly over the building, or when the environmental condition in the building doesn’t adhere to the theatrical sonic value of the night, that’s the most frustrating thing for me—making it sit right. There’s a beauty in looking upstage from my perspective, and at the end of the night when everybody comes around and walks out and they pass you by, you see an expression of joy, enjoyment, delight on peoples’ faces…that they’ve been to a show that’s been the best thing ever. Just to get that feeling from it, for me, is the reason why I do what I do. www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:22:04 PM m you get it?”“Yes, I got the messages,” and all that stuff. That’s something we developed a few years ago. Have you been working this way with them for a while? I’ve actually been doing monitors with this band for 20 years. I started doing five or six shows on the Unforgettable Fire tour in 1985. I filled in for a couple of shows mixing just the drum monitors. Then, towards the end of the tour, mixing everybody else. I guess the size of my hair and my nose impressed them, because the call was, “We want the guy with the big nose and the curly hair to come back and do the tour.” It took a lot of time, but my nose finally got me in. All right! A landmark they can sink their teeth into. Three Front of House guys. I don’t want to think about what the budget is. to hear it—tend to be a bit different than the other three guys. He’s always trying new stuff, and at one point early on, he tried a few different things. It’s not that he didn’t like the Future Sonics. He did. He’s done a couple of tours on them, but there was something about this tour and those ears that didn’t work well for him. How many guitar channels do you guys run? Twelve. Something in that neighborhood. Remember the days when you would just walk in and you just plugged an amp in? I do. There’s a difference in the style of music, as well. With Alicia’s band, the guy had a Twin, and that was it. But then again, it wasn’t the feature of the music. It was just an accent. This is different. This has been called the “Edge Orchestra.” So that is quite a bit of guitar stuff. Are there any challenges to doing this band that you don’t have with other bands? Or is it basically a rock ‘n’ roll band with 12 guitar inputs? In the music, there’s a lot going on with these guys and it’s trying to stay on top of it. Like any band, if you can break it down to its most basic parts, it’s a service kind of thing with them. You want to make sure that when you know what they want and you can get there with them, that you stay as true to that as you can all the time. And then, some of them—like Bono—like to be challenged. You can do effects for him in his ears while he’s listening to delays, reverbs and effects. He loves that stuff. It makes it more interesting for him to be out there doing it that way. Where do you see yourself in 10 years? Hopefully healthy, still married and somewhere where I’m still making a good living and enjoying what I’m doing. It’s a good industry and there is a passion about what we do. You love it. You hate it. It’s all there. I try to get off the road once every five or six years. But there’s still nothing like it when you mix a show, to put this whole thing of work together, it’s a very vague thing. There’s a feeling of accomplishment, like I’ve just taken all of these impossible factors and pulled it together and made something— as fleeting as it is—work. There’s three of us doing monitors. Robbie Adams mixes Bono and Nile Slevin mixes Edge, and I do the other guys…the rest of the team. So, we talked about the Pro-Tools integration. My theory is that it’s becoming part of just the business plan for releasing live recordings, for putting things out on the Internet, for… It’s definitely something that’s in the realm of what this can do. When we first started the tour, because I didn’t know how much time I’d have with the band, I had a 64-track recording. So when the band wasn’t on stage, I could take the night before or the sound check, play it back, do my mixing and work on a few things and a few sounds and snapshots, or whatever. It was very, very helpful. Now with the ability to record last night’s show, is the day of the sound check over? Oh no. By no means at all. Every building is different. Every day is different. I used to say, the warranty’s off. As soon as it rolls out of the truck, the warranty’s off. The show that was in the box when you put it in the truck and it was a good show—that show’s gone. The next day the truck opens up, the guarantee’s off. We’ve all gotta start from scratch. Now is everybody on PMs these days? Everyone, including the bass player Adam, is on PMs. They went to PMs in 1993. Bass players have always been harder because they didn’t feel the low-end kind of thing. But Adam, in fair play to him, decided that he could do this the right way. He was going to give it a fair shot, and he did. You know, he’s totally settled into them. He’s up there on the ramps playing bass. For the rest of the guys in the band, it’s like, “Well, look at him! He used to stay in the little pocket there on the stage.” So that’s all Sennheiser wireless… What about the actual earpieces? Three guys in the band are wearing Future Sonics, and Edge is wearing one of these pieces made by Etymotic. Edge’s ears— what he likes to hear and the way he likes www.fohonline.com 200.0512.FOHInterview.ep.indd 21 December 2005 21 12/1/05 5:22:27 PM The Anklebiters The Latest and Greatest Dear Anklebiters, I operate a sound company that is currently healthy and making money. My concern, however, is that sound reinforcement technology is moving too fast to keep up with. How can I compete in this rapidly changing market? Thanks, Pete Hampton, Spokane, WA Jamie: Pete, the first thing to remember is: You do not need to have every new toy and gizmo in your arsenal to be competitive. You already have a clientele, and the fact that you are making money tells me that you are satisfying your clients. Right? But is it a good idea to keep up on tech and equipment trends, and of course, the latest and greatest innovations out there. Look, dude, you’re already reading FOH. Need I say more? Paul, what do you think? Paul: Thanks, Jamie. I just finished a festival that lasted more than a week and involved three stages operating simultaneously. The move that sealed getting the contract was renting a Yamaha PM5D RH for the main stage. All of the performers on that stage had heard what the FOH console was and how their settings could be recalled at any time. Was it expensive to use this new technology? Yes! Was it worth the effort? Yes! Did I By JamieRio and Paul H.Overson Was it expensive to use this new technology? Yes! Was it worth the effort? Yes! Did I have the skills to use the 5D at that time? No! I hired someone with those skills and then learned from them. have the skills to use the 5D at that time? No! I hired someone with those skills and then learned from them. I saved all of the settings from this year and will use those settings again next year when most of the same acts return. I cannot afford to purchase a 5D and it was expensive to rent one, but it sealed the deal for me—and I got next year’s festival. Jamie, have you had experiences like this one? Jamie: Not exactly, but I recently bought a rather special snake just to accommodate the needs of a particular artist. The motivation for this investment was the promise of contracting all of this singer’s California and Nevada shows. At the time, I was only in for one show. However, with the use of my new snake (and my own expertise), I got the gig for all of this year and next year’s events. That’s about 15 to 20 shows. Anyway, the point here is that I bought a snake that is technologically more advanced than any of my other snakes because it was on the artist rider. Of course, I can use it on other shows. In this case, I wasn’t keeping up with technology as much as attempting to satisfy my client and secure more work. So, with your gig, Paul, was the Yamaha a rider request, or did you just decide to rent it and make your show easier? Paul: I decided to rent it because of the nature of the festival. Each year, the biggest names in this type of music perform. I thought that it would be best to dial in each performer and then save those settings. Over the course of the festival, the same people performed on the main stage at least three times. In years past, the FOH engineer had to reset their console and then dial it in again and again. Because of the 5D I had rented, the mix was the same each time, and so sound checks were done once and then saved. The performances were saved, so we had a choice of which one we liked the best. I now have skills that are more marketable, and the performers started asking if I would do other shows with them. The rental was easier for me, but also helped me keep up with technology. It cost more money, but in the long run, it proved to be valuable to my business. Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 22 December 2005 200.0512.Anklebiters.JH.indd 22 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:11:23 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 23 12/1/05 5:08:15 PM Installations Rick’s Cabaret NYC Patrons Couldn’t Find the Speakers at This Upscale Adult Entertainment Establishment Even If They Were Looking For Them By Kevin M.Mitchell I t’s September 21, 2005, and Tim Hannum finds himself among the more than 500 patrons at the opening of one of the most anticipated adult entertainment spots (or “gentlemen’s clubs”) in Manhattan. Located in the former Paradise Club spot, the building alone cost $7.6 million, plus another $3 million to make it pole-worthy, and it’s in the desirable spot between Madison Square Garden and the Empire State Building. It’s the 10th club opened by Rick’s, a publicly-traded company. “It was crazy, a zoo,” Hannum says of the opening. In addition to being project director, Hannum was also the audio designer, and he was prowling the scene to make sure all was running well. Luckily, it was—though owner and visionary Eric Langan was always on him about one thing: “He kept coming up to me going, ‘Can you make it louder? Can you make it louder?’” Hannum laughs. “And I could and I did. I kept cranking it up, but only because it was a remarkable system.” “The Devil is in the Details” When Hannum looks back on his career so far, he says he feels lucky to be here. “I started with McFadden Ventures, where I was lucky enough to work for Lance 24 December 2005 200.0512.Installations.ep.indd 24 McFadden,” Hannum says. For most of the 1980s, he traveled, finding lighting and audio for promotions of the confetti company. When the company was bought out in 1989, he went out on his own doing lighting installations for nightclubs and trendy bars. He ended up living a little too much of the rock-star life. “After becoming a sober individual and responsible adult again, I founded Diavolo Systems,” he says. The name of his company comes from his work philosophy— he was always hearing himself say that the “devil was in the details.” Founded in 1996, the company has an impressive list of clients, so diverse as to include the seemingly contradictory church business in addition to his most recent stripper venture. “I love old buildings,” Hannum says of taking on the defunct Paradise. “It’s what makes a job exciting and challenging. It’s like this jigsaw puzzle that’s thrown to the ground, and you have to put it together. You have the find the nooks and crannies for installing audio.” On the first floor of Rick’s is the main stage and drinking area. The second floor features an upscale dining room plus private VIP rooms, and on the third floor, there are more VIP rooms. “Rick’s is a Houston-based company, like we are, and we’ve been working with Langan, the owner, on his other clubs for years,” Hannum says.“He decided the old Paradise would be the place for his flagship New York project about a year and a half ago.” First, the old building had to be completely redesigned, and Hannum credits Joe Kleinmann of the Kleinmann Group for taking the original concept of Rick’s adult clubs in Houston, Minneapolis, New Orleans and Charlotte, and modifying it for the New York market. Typically, sound is not a top priority for places like this, but Langan is not typical. “I went to competing adult clubs only after I already spec’d out Rick’s, because I do things a little differently,” he says. “I know that Langan wanted it to be able to be a party place, and he wanted every area separately zoned.” Generally preferring Martin Audio, he would end up using it almost exclusively. He says Martin’s Rob Hofkamp was particularly key to the success of the sound installation. “This was a great opportunity to be one of the first big installs of their new AQ series,” he says. “Rick’s Red” Introduced just this past summer, the new integrated AQ Series of installation loudspeakers were designed to be architecturally unobtrusive. The main stage at Rick’s features four AQ15 two-way passive loudspeakers and with its 400-watt AES (1600-watt peak), 15-inch direct radiator and high-efficiency HF compression drive. It’s the most powerful in the six-speaker series. At the other extreme, the ultracompact version, the AQ5, were installed in places like the entrance, dressing rooms and VIP rooms. AQ10s, featuring wide 90º by 50º dispersion and rotatable HF horns, were placed in the house and bar areas. A Backline S18 SubBass System, placed under the stage, is used as the main subwoofer. “The place rumbles,” Hannum says. While he uses and sells equipment other than Martin, and admits that they aren’t “the cheapest speakers in the world,” the variety of mounting devices that come with the speakers and the ever-important eye-pleasing nature of the cabinets were factors in his choice. Mostly, though,“they sound really good—and Langan likes to be able to crank the music. Everything is a tight, clean sound with this system. He’s a hands-on owner, playing with everything,” Hannum says. Apparently, the folks at Martin’s London headquarters got a laugh when Hannum sent them the paint chip that the speakers www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:25:59 PM A Growing Trend? “I love old buildings. It’s like this jigsaw puzzle that’s thrown to the ground, and you have to put it together.” – Tim Hannum Strip club, gentlemen’s club, adult entertainment venue—call it whatever you want, but what it really should be called is a money-printing press. Rick’s Cabaret International, Inc., is just one of several prosperous publicly-held companies in the industry (NASDAQ: RICK). Their new club in Manhattan is projected to increase the company’s revenue by 50% in fiscal 2006, and while fiscal 2005 figures are still coming in, fiscal 2004 numbers reveal that revenue was $16 million. “It’s hard to gauge, because it’s essentially a cash industry,” says Christopher Buttner, who writes and edits for adult entertainment trade magazines in addition to running his own firm, PR That Rocks. “Some think there are 3,000 adult clubs out there, some think 5,000. And while there are 60,000 nightclubs, this segment is by far the most lucrative.” He says the strip club cliché still exists: The woman on stage with three teeth gyrates to an old jukebox bellowing dirty tenor sax riffs while her three kids wait in the car. But now, as “pornography becomes more mainstream,” these upscale high-tech joints are growing significantly, especially in major markets like New York, southeastern Florida, Las Vegas and Los Angeles. “In Vegas, some of these freestanding clubs have property values of $10 million alone, even before you put in any of the interior decorations,” Buttner says. “Now, typically, the budget for the lights and sound makes up 10% of the venue’s overall cost, so we’re looking at some pretty impressive sound and lighting systems.” While Rick’s seems to be an exception to this, the typical approach to sound is different in these clubs: “Conversation is king, as guys want to talk to these beautiful women. So while they can be loud, the speakers need to be smooth, and most importantly, blend into the architecture. They are designed to be transparent. You don’t want it to look like a nightclub; you want it to look like a lounge,” Buttner says. Also, there is a lack of trussing and moving heads, elaborate pieces of lighting technology that get in the way of the comfort level. “You want a guy to think he’s in his living room with his own sound system, only with four beautiful, scantily-clad babes there,” he says. Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc were to match. “The speakers needed to match the color of the wall exactly, and they thought it was funny to be painting them this very specific Ralph Lauren Balmoral Red color. They took to referring to it as ‘Rick’s red,’” he laughs. “But everything turned out beautiful.” Having the speakers match the walls was more critical than one would think. “Most people would have put in ceiling speakers, but we didn’t want to do that, because the ceiling couldn’t handle the abuse, and we couldn’t have gotten speakers up there that would be loud enough,” Hannum says. The larger speakers placed in the rooms might seem bigger than necessary to some engineers, but they really needed the horsepower everywhere, he says, and were interested in blanketing the room with sound. After that, they squeezed in the smaller AQs to fill out the sound. The DJ booth features a Rane MP24Z Mixer and two Technics SL-DZ1200 CD/MP3 Players. The monitor is a single AQ10. Time was an issue:“We never have enough time!” he laughs.“But that’s another reason why people are hiring us. If you have to turn a place around in 60 or 90 days, we tend to get the call because we can get in there with a crew and start work immediately.” Despite the high growth of the adult entertainment industry, Hannum says he doesn’t make it a habit going after such gigs. “Eric Langan is a great person to deal with—he’s creative, hands-on and wants to know everything about what he’s getting. He’s also a team-builder and makes it fun. It’s really a party atmosphere,” he says. www.fohonline.com 200.0512.Installations.ep.indd 25 December 2005 25 12/1/05 5:26:52 PM Road Tests Heil Sound PR Series PR20 Microphones What it is: Dynamic microphones with high-tech performance. By MarkAmundson A t the AES show, I met a brash older man with some amazing microphones. That man was Bob Heil, a legend in his own right as the owner of a sound company and builder of sound system speakers, amplifiers and mixers years ahead of what has been available from other manufacturers. While most us thought that Heil Sound Limited had faded into history, Heil’s other passion of amateur radio has kept his engineering skills sharp. And that sharpness was enough to design microphones for ham operators and broadcast talent that kept Heil innovating in microphone technology. Through the encouragement of collaboration with Heil’s longtime amateur radio friend, Joe Walsh of the Eagles, Heil brought forth the PR series of large diaphragm dynamic microphones suitable for live sound applications. For this Road Test, I received three PRseries microphones (PR-20, PR-30, PR-40). Although only the PR-20 is a handheld vocal microphone, the PR-30 and PR-40 work well in other live sound applications, such as critical instrument or instrument amplifier pickup. The PR-20 is a 14-ounce handheld vocal mic with a nice steel grille and gold trim ring attached to a nicely curved zinc grip. The PR-20’s tight cardioid pattern is impressive, but its lack of bass proximity effect makes it almost impossible to believe. The PR-20’s 40Hz to 18KHz frequency response hides reality: Its ultra lightweight quiltedaluminum diaphragm over a neodymium magnet gives the mic an amazing highfrequency response that rivals diva-grade condenser in response and betters it in fidelity at high input SPLs. And the high-tech sorbothane shock-mount system makes handling noise disappear. The PR-30 is no slouch either. While aimed for broadcast usage with its barrel-shaped body/windscreen and 1.5-inch dynamic element, the PR-30 comes with a normal mic clip and makes a killer instrument microphone perfect for corporate-type gigs. Also with a 40Hz to 18KHz frequency 26 December 2005 200.0512.RoadTests.JH.indd 26 response, the PR-30 takes the PR-20’s perfect mid- and high-frequency and adds a real warmth to the low-mids without the expected proximity effect mud that other mics can add. The PR-40 mic takes its position on the top of the series with even better cosmetics and a beautiful dark hardwood case to store the mic after performance. The PR-40 is 15ounce beauty of a microphone with 28Hz to 18KHz frequency, and it is apparent that this mic is at home in recording, broadcast and live sound applications. The barrel mic casing and very large diaphragm dynamic element provides more warmth at the expense of a little top-end frequency response. The Tests and the Gigs rolled off a touch above 10KHz. Out at the gigs, the PR-20 held its own as lead singer’s dream microphone. The almost hyper-cardioid pattern and the lack of prox effect meant that the singer’s lyrics cut through a loud rock ‘n’ roll band with ease. And placing the PR-30 and PR-40 on guitar amps made those sources light up compared to the usual suspect instrument mics. If you are collector of mics as tools for tough vocal and instrument applications, then having all the Heil Sound PR-series mics is a must. And at their prices, you can purchase the whole bunch for the price of a typical professional studio condenser mic. And if someone offered up a bunch of PR-20s at a house gig, I would have thought I had died and gone to heaven. Placing my focus on the PR-20, I went to my mic trunk and collected up my usual best-in-class vocal mic suspects. No, this is not a shootout, but listening to a good mic requires a perspective that only some A-B listening can resolve. So I brought out a bunch of Audix, Beyer, Electro-Voice and Shure dynamic and condenser vocal mics for critical listening. My conclusions were that the PR20’s mids and highs are as good as the best live sound condenser microphones, and the lack of any low-frequency proximity effect is almost spooky with the transparent low-end. Because the lows are so well-balanced with the rest of the frequency spectrum, the PR-20 would excel with bass voices, or for all those mumbling mic eaters out there to help catch a little more diction on their lyrics. And the rappers and their live sound mixers could really enjoy the diction enhancement and high SPL cleanliness, even with the windscreen partially cupped. Running the PR-30 and PR-40 through similar tests was just plain unfair as the even larger diaphragms warmed up the low-end, but mostly kept things brilliant through the presence band. I liked the PR-30 as an all-around perfect voice and instrument mic. The PR-40 was nice too, but all top end from PR-20 and PR-30 spoiled me when the PR-40 Who it’s for: Professionals of all types needing the benefits of condenser mic clearity, but with dynamic mic SPL handling. Pros: Low cost, astounding performance, great looks. Cons: None. How much: PR-20 $160 SRP, PR-30 $289 SRP, PR-40 $325 SRP. PR40 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:32:31 PM Electro-Voice Zx4 Speakers By MarkAmundson I am not one to really endorse plastic speakers, but of all of the poly-whatever speakers I have reviewed, the ElectroVoice Zx4 comes right to the top in preference. First of all, it “delivers” in terms of sound quality, and that applies whether it’s wood or plastic. Next, it is an unpowered speaker, which is great because I only have one Neutrik Speakon cable to attach, and the weight is a modest 44.4 pounds for a 15-inch + 1-inch cabinet. But until I see RF wireless receivers and serious and lightweight power amplifiers in powered speakers, I will prefer minimal interfacing and power amplifiers on the ground. With the Zx4’s program power rating about 800 watts, I would like an 800watt at 8-Ohm audio power amplifier to be inside before thinking it could be adequate for live sound usage. The Gear The EV Zx4 is a step back from the Zx5 version in that the drivers are standard off-the-shelf, tried and true. The DH3 1-inch What it is: A plastic portable speaker cabinet good for multiple uses. Who it’s for: Professional users who need good cosmetics and great quality of sound reproduction. How much: Electro-Voice Zx4 $700 SRP. Pros: Plug-and-play simplicity, good looks and quality sound. Cons: A second handle would be nice. throat driver is smaller than what I prefer for a 15-inch low-frequency driver, but this combination does work and the midrange does not seem to exhibit any wild frequency response peaks or dips. I have been substituting the DH3 for JBL 1-inch drivers in many home brew wedges for years because of the reliability and great presence band sound. The EVS15SF LF driver is less familiar to me, but in the Zx4 cabinet it does its job well by staying flat down into the 60Hz (-3dB) corner frequency. So as a complete system, the Zx4 delivers 400-watt continous/1,600-watt peak power handling across the 60 to 20KHz audio frequency band (-3dB), and does it with a 1,500Hz crossover frequency at 8 Ohms nominal impedance. From a mechanical perspective, the Zx4 has an integral HF horn with a 90º by 50º short throw to handle the typical smaller rooms it was designed for. By keeping the grille on the LF driver only and matching the colors to a very dark gray, this means that the Zx4 is perfect for corporate events as well as rock ‘n’ roll, as it’s visually unobtrusive. One large handle is molded into the Zx4, and it also contains the now standard 1 3/8-inch pole socket for tripod (stick) mounting. For installs, there are multiple threads for rigging I-bolts. And even the stage monitor usage was considered by having two flush feet that can be flipped around to create a flatter 55º tilt from its normal 45º rear shape. The Gigs Putting the Zx4 to use was pretty much a plug-and-play experience. I started the evaluation on sticks with CD tracks and a QSC PLX3402 smacking it around through various musical genres. While I get spoiled listening to subwoofer supported speaker systems, the 60Hz corner and 42Hz bottom (-10dB) provided enough thump that performed better than most plastic speaker offerings I have worked with. Out at the gigs, I put the Zx4 into a small corporate event setting, and into stage wedge operation for a rock cover band. In both scenarios, I found the Zx4 coming up well. While I prefer narrower HF coverages and bigger HF drivers (1.4-inch throat, please), the Zx4 did not run out of gas on high SPL stage monitor duty, and had plenty of fidelity playing tracks and doing P.A. work at the corporate gig. I wished I had a second handle on the opposite side to two-hand the cabinet up on the tripods, but that was about all I could find to niggle about. Feedback continued from page 2 used to play out was the same one used for practice. It was a small Carvin system that you can get from the local music store for about $700, and it was run from the stage (YIKES!). You couldn’t mic the drums—not enough channels—so the snare always overpowered the rest of the kit. The guitar players used stage volume instead of the 10-inch monitors that I assume were mainly for looks at that point, and because the stage volume was so high, and oh my, it was a cluster you-know-what. I was always telling them to change this and do that to try and help, mainly because they would ask the wives,“How’s that sound?” and I was the only one who didn’t stroke their ego. I had done a good bit of singing before I met my husband, so I’ve been around good and bad sound production. So after a while, I was the only one they looked to, but the system was limited. We both know that generally, when someone is complaining that the band is too loud, the mix is just bad—which, because everyone runs their own limited P.A. system from the stage around here, well, you get the point. Because of that, we began to build a real P.A. We now have one of the best P.A.s (owned by a band member and not a sound production company) in the area. I have become a very proficient FOH and MON engineer, which has allowed the guitar player to focus on what he is good at—which is not mixing! My husband and I have been called on to provide sound for bands when they really needed a good show to make an impression. We have even provided sound for a two-day outdoor gig, during which it rained for a day and a half, had 14 different bands—of various talent and ability—and had to have the board and gear set up inside our van because the tent they set up for the sound equipment was almost behind the stage My husband had a gig across town on the final night of this outdoor fiesta, which required that he leave as soon as he got the last band situated on stage. He was very anxious about leaving because we had a ton of gear to pack and load after the show, and his gig didn’t end until 2 a.m. Now, I could really expand on this gig, which would make for some serious laughs, especially if I told you about the karaoke segment! But, we’ll save that bit of hilarity for a Nightmare because, right now, I’m about to bring you the AHA! moment. After all that work—hot, smelly and dirty as I was—I headed over to my husband’s gig. Why would I go to his gig being as dead tired as I must have been, you might ask? Because, you see, my husband left a crucial piece of his gear behind with me earlier that evening, and I thought the poor guy might want his throne rather than a hard chair from the bar while he PLAYED HIS DRUMS!! We enjoy FOH, so keep it coming. ‘Cause with all the drums, and stands and cymbals and speakers, monitors, amps, EQs, compressors, mixer and cables; we are still adding more, and your reviews and comparisons are very helpful. Karen Morgan www.fohonline.com 200.0512.RoadTests.JH.indd 27 SPL Computation continued from page 31 Looking at Fig. 1 and adding 10dB SPL, this means that 132dB SPL emanates from the speakers (1,000 watts input), and at four meters, the 120dB SPL requirement is met. Doing the math with drops of 6dB at distance doubles tells me that 92dB SPL is still maintained at 64 meters (208 feet) away from the stacks. Looking at the problem differently, suppose you wanted at least 90dB at 100 feet away (about 32 meters)? Then, in the Fig. 1 configuration, you’d need 96dB at 16 meters, 102dB at eight meters, 108dB at four meters, 114dB at two meters and 120dB at the reference one-meter distance. But let’s say you have 15-inch +1.4-inch top box speakers that only deliver 98dB SPL at one watt and one meter. Then, 120dB minus 98dB sensitivity says you need 22dB watts program into the cabinet from the amplifiers. Then, you must take the 22dB, divide by 10 (power is in 10-log dB scaling) and do the base-10 anti-log computation on 2.2 for 158 watts program power. If 90dB at 100 feet then suddenly becomes 100dB, then you’d need 32dB watts or 1,580 watts of voicecoil melting power. This is where two speakers sharing the 1,580 watts (790 watts per cabinet) on each side of the stage works; or better yet, coupled together to minimize phasing. Final Thoughts While people do absorb acoustic power, they do not rob power (loudness) from adjacent areas. Thus, the watts per person theory should be thrown out. And the how-manyspeakers computation also falls away, as different speakers have different sensitivities/efficiencies and large quantities of the same speaker rarely couple together well, to place increased SPL into any one location or locations. What does matter is the intensity of the emitter (speaker with amplifier) that is pointed in your direction, and your distance away from that emitter. Things can get complex in big venues with many emitters and coverage areas that can overlap. That is why the big shows have system engineers, and they are in charge of the math and physics to deliver the correct loudness, in the right areas, with the best sound fidelity. December 2005 27 12/1/05 5:35:28 PM On The Bleeding Edge “I Hope You Like Our New Direction…” I t may not be obvious, but the directionality of a sound reinforcement loudspeaker is as important a characteristic as its frequency response or power-handling capability. Control of “spill” is critical for sound reinforcement because the environments we deal with are almost always reverberant. If we cannot control the direction of sound, not only does it miss our audience, but it also does nasty things like bounce off walls, create comb filtering and decrease intelligibility. Traditionally, sound reinforcement loudspeakers have featured fixed directionality. In other words, the manufacturer designed the cabinet for a certain angle of coverage, such as 60º by 45º, and once you purchased the box, you were stuck with the dispersion pattern. For that reason, many sound companies need to purchase and stock loudspeakers Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 28 December 2005 200.0512.BleedingEdge.JH.indd 28 that are identical except for their coverage attributes, requiring an investment in more cabinets as well as the space in which have the ability to turn the box on its side (turning the box on its side is, of course, the poor man’s way of modifying the dispersion Loudspeaker manufacturers recognize this coverage quandary. to store them. Several manufacturers offer molded horns that can be removed from their cabinets and turned 90º, allowing a modification of coverage from (for example) 60º by 90º to 90º by 60º for use in situations where you want to swap the vertical and horizontal coverage angles. This is a clever design feature that’s useful when you need to change the horn’s coverage, but don’t pattern of a speaker). Unfortunately, removing, rotating and replacing the horn is timeconsuming and not something you’re likely to do on-site unless the P.A. is going into a fixed installation, and even with that, you’ll only have two choices. What if you could quickly change the directional pattern of a loudspeaker without having to dismantle components, or without the need to change the orientation of the cabinet? Life would truly be easier and you could provide better sound in the process. Sound reinforcement loudspeaker manufacturers recognize this quandary and are working on solutions. One of the most startling introductions at the October AES (and one of those hit-yourself-in-the-headbecause-it’s-so-obvious developments) was a new loudspeaker called KUDO from L-ACOUSTICS, those wonderful folks who pioneered the line array and brought us V-DOSC. KUDO (K-Louver Modular Directivity United With DOSC Waveguide Technology) is a line-source array designed with two specific goals in mind: 1. To provide their Wavefront Sculpture Technology (WST) in both vertical and horizontal planes, and 2. To make this coverage adjustable to fit a wide range of applications. A medium-format three-way active system, the full-range KUDO cabinet incorporates two 12-inch, four five-inch and two one-inch drivers. The unique design aspect of KUDO is that each cabinet features L-ACOUSTICS’ K-Louver technology (patent pending) incorporating two DOSC waveguides. The user can mechanically adjust the K-Louver, providing control over the coverage angle of the mid/high section (above 800Hz) and allowing the cabinet to easily be reconfigured with four different horizontal coverage pattern settings (50º, 110º, 80º left or right). Combined with the ability to orient the cabinet vertically or horizontally, these four settings yield a total of eight coverage options from a single cabinet. This versatility means that KUDO cabinets can quickly be optimized on-site to suit a specific venue, allows the array to be adapted for venues with odd physical characteristics and cuts down on the amount of inventory a sound company needs in order to accommodate a wide variety of coverage requirements. Taking a completely different approach to manipulating loudspeaker directivity is Renkus-Heinz with their ICONYX digitallysteerable array technology. ICONYX employs Renkus-Heinz’s IC series of loudspeakers designed to provide unobtrusive sound coverage under difficult acoustic circumstances. Primarily intended for speech and music reinforcement in houses of worship By SteveLaCerra and transportation center P.A. systems, IC cabinets are modular columns comprised of eight full-range coax transducers and eight channels of Class D amplification developed specifically for the ICONYX system by D2 Audio (16-, 24- and 32-channel systems are available). Each amplifier channel incorporates DSP control over a single transducer via Renkus-Heinz’s Windows-based LobeWare software. Manipulating the drivers via DSP, LobeWare lets the user adjust the beam’s shape and directivity, even after the ICONYX array has been installed. If it turns out a column was hung too low, that column’s acoustic center can be raised using software instead of by physically moving the array. The software also enables level and EQ modifications of up to eight IC columns after installation. I can already feel my back getting better. A similar approach is taken by EAW with their DSA Series Digitally Steerable Array intended for use in small and mid-size permanent applications. Each driver in a column-shaped DSA loudspeaker has its own amplification and DSP controlled by EAW’s DSA Pilot software. The software allows the user to vary the vertical coverage pattern from 15º to 120º as well as aim the coverage plus or minus 30º. The DSA draws technology from EAW’s KF900 which employs Phased PointSource Technology™ (PPST). This technology was engineered to overcome the challenge of long-throw (more than 600 feet) sound reinforcement in which high frequencies become attenuated more quickly than lows. A truly long-throw system must have an extremely focused high-frequency section with very high output. PSST accomplishes this by clustering the high-frequency horns closely together so there are no gaps in the resulting wavefront, and using a measurement and optimization process to create specific DSP settings for each driver in the array. The low and mid arrays are separated from the high-frequency array ultimately making the system behave like a single giant loudspeaker. Addressing the issue of directionality from a completely different angle (!) is Groove Tubes. Their SFX technology is intended for musicians who perform through stereo rigs but are frustrated with the typical limitations of doing so: Spreading speakers widely on stage produces a stereo image only for listeners in the center, and listeners to either side miss the opposite channel. SFX overcomes this by employing proprietary DSP and two speakers housed in a single cabinet to create a clear stereo image anywhere in the audience. The technology has been licensed by Fender for their Acoustasonic amplifier and is also available from Groove Tubes for musicians who want SFX Stereo, but wish to keep their existing front-end. Hmmm…maybe they can build us one really BIG stereo P.A. cabinet… Steve “Woody” La Cerra is the Front of House engineer and tour manager for Blue Öyster Cult. He can be reached via email at [email protected]. www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:13:06 PM The Biz A iewers of Rock Star: INXS, the reality show that sought to find a new lead singer for the vocally-decapitated Australian rock band, were getting a little more reality than they might have bargained for. Or a little less. On the other hand, John Gott had carved out a great niche for himself and should be the envy of every FOH mixer over the age of 30: After mixing live sound for artists including Pat Benatar and the Talking Heads in the 1970s, he combined a technical gift with an entrepreneur’s eye to create a few new live sound and lighting products, one of which eventually became SLS Loudspeakers. When INXS was at the top of the charts the old-fashioned way (by merely selling records), you’d see some of the usual logos on their touring gear, including JBL and EAW. But on their reality show, a larger-than-life “SLS” was stenciled on the speaker bins. Welcome to the new landscape of marketing pro audio. Show producer Mark Burnett has created a slew of hit reality programs, but the big money may be in the product placement. According to Ad Age, the Survivor creator picked up $16 million alone from Toyota for placements on the less-than-successful The Contender show. That might make the $100,000 in stock options that Gott compensated Burnett with to put the SLS logo into the picture seem like small change, but from the perspective of a cottage industry like pro audio, it’s a small fortune. And possibly one well spent—right around the time Rock Star: INXS was hitting its stride in September, SLS’s stock was hitting a quarterly high of a little more than $2.40 a share. Look at any back issues of pro audio trade publications going back past 1990 and you’ll see plenty of advertisements with spec sheets in them—S/N ratios, gainbefore-feedback values, etc. In the early 1990s, as the home recording phenomenon was beginning to get significant traction, the spec sheets disappeared, replaced with beautiful, smiling faces and, in the case of microphones, more than a few subliminally suggestive poses. This was the industry’s primitive stab at addressing what has been a massive change in how products are now marketed. But there’s a lot of catching up to do. Projecting logos on video screens might seem almost quaint when other companies are projecting them on the foreheads of college students. That’s a true story, and it underscores the assertion made by the great New Yorker financial writer, James Surowiecki, writing in Wired a year ago, when he noted that brands alone may no longer work. “Businesses are now dealing with buyers who are armed with both information and harsh expectations,” Surowiecki wrote. “In this envi- Businesss ronment, companies that slip up—even if it’s simply failing to match customer tastes—can no longer count on their good names to carry them through.” The entire sound and music business has become aware of this sea change to varying degrees. Guitar maker Fender makes a surprising amount (it won’t say exactly From within the industry, the importance of continuing to preach the message of professional products to the choir remains important. Microphone companies and speaker makers will still need to have the endorsements of leading mixers. But pull back and widen the picture: What once seemed an end in itself—getting the high-profile profes- But reliance on brand alone is a dangerous path, as anyone who seen a video clip of a rockthrowing Palestinian wearing a Nike jacket and a New York Yankees cap can understand. how much) of its annual revenue from clothing sales, which, when you think about it, is no different than selling a T-shirt at a concert. Rival Gibson used to advertise in Vanity Fair—you won’t see many reviews of API products in there—aiming at the nowaffluent aging yuppie who long ago traded his Strat for an MBA. A Web site, www.musicindustrystocks.com, monitors how publicly-traded companies with a stake in the pro audio business—and there’s plenty of them, from SLS to Harman to Mackie/ EAW—are using synergistic marketing to bask their burgeoning consumer products lines (and they’re making plenty of them, too) in the backstage glow of their professional products. That’s the strategy that SLS was following with Rock Star: INXS—their newest product line was developed with input from Quincy Jones and intends to convey a professional sound experience in a residential setting. In fact, given that the $500 Q-Line speaker systems are sold at Wal-Mart, it could soon bring the concert experience to a trailer park near you. Harman Industries, owner of JBL, has been particularly astute at trying to leverage the value of its professional products to benefit its consumer divisions. JBL’s VerTecs are easy to spot both at the Cream performances and in the ads for the band, even as Harman’s consumer division sponsors Eric Clapton appearances. Paul McCartney is another Harman endorser, when he’s not doing the same for Lexus. Autos, auto sound—is the connection getting clearer? sional to like your product—now becomes one step in a longer chain that culminates in the star of the show getting into a Jaguar on www.fohonline.com 200.0512.Biz.rg.indd 29 By DanDaley a commercial that ran just after one for Merrill Lynch on the FOX News Network . Pro audio companies are right to try to wring as much benefit as they can from their brands, and there’s considerable headroom for them to enjoy it as they run to catch up after slumbering as long as many have in the cocoon of an insular industry. (At least, if they want to—an editor of a well-known music publication recently told me that his regular advertisers threatened to pull their ads if the magazine ran “lifestyle” ads alongside gear advertisements, asserting that an Infinity auto ad could dilute the impact of a value of the speaker that goes in it.) But reliance on brand alone is a dangerous path, as anyone who seen a video clip of a rock-throwing Palestinian wearing a Nike jacket and a New York Yankees cap can understand. Does a focus on the brand put the product itself at risk? Surowiecki seems to think so, but goes on to say that that’s what can also save a brand in the end. “When companies can’t count on their reputations to carry them through, they’re forced to innovate to stay alive,” he wrote. “The erosion of brand value, then, means heightened competition—and everything we know about economics tells us that the more competition, the better off consumers will be.” Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc V d e d n a r B December 2005 29 12/1/05 5:12:09 PM In The Trenches By AllisonRost Jay Ohsiek Kevin P. Glendinning Monitor/FOH Engineer Rody’s Music/Industrial Sound and Lights Savannah, GA 912.352.4666 [email protected] Monitor Engineer Los Angeles, CA 847.347.1918 [email protected] Personal Info: I have been playing drums my whole life. I got tired of the club scene, but found a knack for sound. I ran our recording studio, but after a massive fire, we didn’t rebuild. My favorite thing about sound is wiring the rigs up. The only downside is being away from my wife and kids. Quote: I do what I can and can what I do, nothing more, nothing less. Hobbies: Saltwater fishing, boating, playing ball with my son and daughter. Quote: After two weeks at home, I miss my bunk! Services Provided: Full-service production—sound, lighting, backline. Equipment: Crest LMX and GTX, Midas Venice, NEXO Alpha rig,PS10, Yorkville TX4 and TX9, Crest power and, believe it or not, Peavey. Shure, AT, Audix. Yamaha Spx90, rev7, Roland, dbx. Services Provided: Touring monitor engineer. Clients: The Cure, Staind, No Doubt, Babyface, Weezer, Gwen Stefani, deftones, Liz Phair, Audioslave, The Flaming Lips, Fiona Apple (upcoming). Personal Info: Started out in the clubs of Chicago while running my own P.A. company and attending college. Hit the road and the rest, as they say, is history. Still enjoy touring and mixing shows and the people who you encounter. World’s finest in my book. Hobbies: Surfing, pints, baseball, Michael Mann films. Equipment: Consoles: Midas XL4, Yamaha PM1D, Cadac “M-Type.” Wedges: Firehouse F15, CBA 12AMII(Stealth), ShowCo SRM, EVXW15, Radian Micros. Mics: Audio-Technica, Sennheiser, Beyer, Sony RF. Transmitters: Sennheiser 3056 (ear systems), Professional Wireless Helical w/ Combiners. Ear Pieces: Ultimate Ears UE Hybrid/UE7/UE10. FX Outboard: Lexicon PCM/TC M5000/ TC 2290. Dynamic Outboard: Drawmer DS201, dbx 160SL, Imperial Labs EL8, Al Smart C2, BSS 609. EQ Systems: TC EQ Station, dbx DriveRack, Lake Contour. Software: SIA Smaart, Driveware, SpectraFoo. Clients: Toni Braxton, Sammy Kershaw, Billy Ray Cyrus, Chevelle, Andy Griggs, Swinging Medallions, The Embers, The Tams and more. Don’t Leave Home Without: Passport, electrical adapters, a good attitude and frequent flier numbers. Don’t Leave Home Without: My backpack, which has my whole world in it, my multimeter, my headphones. If you’d like to see yourself featured in “In the Trenches,” visit www.fohonline.com/trenches to submit your information to FOH, or e-mail [email protected] for more information. http://go.to/tonygleeson Welcome To My Nightmare a Stink Don’t Make on the Road W hat started as a normal seven-trailer load-out ended in a big stink. Earlier that day, a member of the headlining band had to “lighten his load,” so to speak. Everybody in the industry knows that you don’t do “number two” on the bus, so he respectfully deferred until we got to the venue. It just so happened that the dressing room he chose to use belonged not to him or his band, but to the lead singer of the opening band. Load-in and setup went on as planned, that is, until the opening band and the lead singer arrived and went to their dressing rooms. Said singer went in to find a horrible stench.“What the...? I’m a rock star”, he surmised.“This is unacceptable,” he ranted.“My room should smell like roses and be trimmed in gold.” When he caught word that a member of the headlining band was the guilty party, he was very upset. After the show, he confronted Mr. Number Two on the loading docks. When confronted, the culprit admitted to his action and acknowledged the problem. 30 December 2005 200.0512.Trenches.JH.indd 30 “But we’re all in this together,” he said. “We work together every day and I have to put up with your rock star attitude, but I still make you look good.” So a fight ensued, and the entire crew of the headlining act went at it with the crew of the opening act. The next thing you know, the cops showed up while Mr. Lead Singer was taking punches like a punching bag. It was a very sad load-out that night, and it seemed to drag on forever. Needless to say, the opening band was booted off the tour and the headlining act is still on the road. The lesson is, if you’re a newly emerging artist and you’re opening for an established act, perhaps it’s a good idea to respect the people you work for and the crew who sets up their rig every night. Don’t put up a stink even if someone else does. Alex Council Bandit Lites Gigs from Hell. We’ve all had ‘em and the good folks at FOH want to hear about yours. Write it up and send it to us and we’ll illustrate the most worthy. Send your nightmares to [email protected] or fax them to 818.654.2485 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:24:55 PM Theory & Practice 122 - 26 =104? SPL Computation By MarkAmundson O ne of the things that still aggravates me are questions about loudness that are formatted like; “How many amplifier watts per person are needed for a rock ‘n’ roll show?” And the oft-repeated,“How many speakers do I need for a room of this size?” While the innocent are allowed to ask such questions, I find it disconcerting to hear experienced sound people asking the very same questions. This Theory & Practice column shall attempt to cover the basics on estimating the Sound Pressure Levels provided and—the reverse—to estimate the amount of gear need to achieve a desired SPL. First of all, there is virtually no such thing as uniform SPL; short of handing everyone personal MP3 players with the volume controls fixed. Once you assume the locations for the speakers, common sense tells you it will be louder near the speakers and softer further away. (I remember some folded horn bass bins—Altecs, I think—that I had back in the day that were louder 15 feet away than they were right next to the speaker… -Ed.) The tradeoff will be that you will specify the “range” SPL, and that will drive the choice of speakers and maybe even require more speakers dispersed into the audience if the range is tight. But in most small venue situations, speakers are located above or to the side of the performance stage, and no capability or accommodation will be made for additional speaker locations. Speaker Coverage Sound g Stagin Ligh ting But all is not lost if you are limited to speaker stacks at the sides of the stage. As many of you know, dispersed speaker positions require an electronic delay of the mix audio to get the stage wash and side-stage speakers to align with speakers placed further away. Given your favorite speed of sound number for temperature and humidity conditions (about 1,100 feet/second), just back off about 0.9 milliseconds per foot of distance from the stage front for each dispersed speaker. Of course, the downside is the complexity of having to route delayed signals to the speakers and determine the HF nets. This way, the dominant SPL source does not have significant competition at mid and high frequencies. If you did not know it already, most subwoofer cabinets offer very little dispersion 102db SPL @ 1w -1m + 20dB watts for 122dB SPL@ 1 meter Fig. 1 horn coverage to the zones desired. In smaller and straightforward room shapes, the side-stage speaker stacks can do all the work. For smaller rooms, the traditional speaker on a stick (tripod) with the 90º by 40º horn is the standard, to toss fewer-thanconcert SPLs at the audience. In bigger and louder applications, medium-throw speaker enclosures use 60º by 40º horns enclosed in trapezoidal cabinets, for throw 100 feet or a bit more. In wider rooms, two or three medium throw cabinets are splayed together to widen out the coverage and still keep the SPLs high. As in the dispersed speaker setup, the idea is to have one speaker focused to each audience section, with other speakers not covering the section by virtue of being out of the rated horn dispersion of the cabi- spherically and diminishes its intensity as an inverse square with distance. With speakers as a transducer, dB electrical watts in correlates to dB SPL out via the sensitivity rating of the speakers. In Fig. 1, a 102dB SPL per watt per meter sensitivity cabinet with 100watt electrical input (20dB watts) equates to 122dB SPL at one meter. From the illustration, each doubling of distance away from the speaker drops the SPL by 6dB. So 122dB SPL at one meter equates to 98dB SPL at 16 meters, or about 52 feet away from the speaker. The only way to avoid this rule is to get into line array speaker systems for cylindrical dispersion and 3dB per distance double losses. But even with line arrays, once you get below the critical low frequency, the low frequencies begin drop off faster like the spherical dispersion model. Then you have a real need to add delay low-frequency cabinets to keep up with the mids and highs screaming along in the cylindrical dispersion rate. Running the Numbers pattern control below 100Hz. With this known, most subwoofer cabinets are close to the stage, either onstage, below the stage or sidestage as space is available and the audience locations are factored in. With wavelengths at 10 feet or larger, massing identical cabinets together forms a virtual single cabinet with the same sensitivity, but with the input power effectively summed together. Inverse Square Law To get at the problem of delivering SPL into an area, I have created Fig. 1 to show how SPL diminishes with distance from the “point” source. Because a speaker or small cluster of speakers aimed together represents a single point source, when examined from afar; the resulting acoustic wave acts The old rule of thumb for rock concert SPLs in audience areas is the 90 to 120dB SPL range of loudness. With a normal conversation at 70dB SPL and each 10dB representing a doubling of perceived loudness, you can see that at concert levels, conversations can only be carried on by shouting into each other’s ears. Now, we can assume that most concertgoers will not get within a couple meters of the speaker stacks, so the first 6 to 12dB of SPL loss from the speakers will not normally be hitting eardrums. So, with medium- to long-throw speaker cabinets, it is likely that the maximum SPL capability may exceed 135 to 140 dB SPL at the one-meter reference. And that is why those levels are needed when the demand is 120dB SPL into audience seating. continued on page 27 BOOKSHELF 1 Your# resource for continued education. 200.0512.TheoryPractice.JH.indd 31 WANT DETAILS? LOG ON NOW! Order online TODAY at www.fohbookshelf.com 12/1/05 5:26:58 PM Sound Sanctuary Beat Mixing in the Sanctuary… N o, it’s not what you think. What we’re talking about is getting a controlled drum beat we can mix with the rest of the worship band. It’s no secret that many church music programs have been incorporating more aggressive/contemporary live music into some—if not all—of their services over the past several years. While the amplified guitars, bass, keyboards and drums help add energy and passion to a service, many organizations are now fighting a new problem: The problem of overpowering sound levels, with acoustic drums seeming to be the main culprit. I have always included live drum kits in my list of the Evils of Church Sound. The problem with live kits is usually three-fold: The first problem revolves around the fact that very few sanctuaries have acoustic properties conducive to loud percussive instruments. If the acoustic decay, also know as reverb, time of the room is longer than two to three seconds, the room should be treated with sound-absorbing products. Unfortunately, this is hardly ever an inexpensive fix. Think in terms of $15 to $25 per square foot for a good, finished look and proper acoustic fix. (I have come to the conclusion that very few architectural schools teach the importance of good acoustics because every architect I have ever met is much more concerned with incorporating aesthetically-pleasing hard materials like glass, wood and tile into a room design than the detrimental effect that these materials have on room acoustics. No one seems to be telling the architects that if the congregation cannot understand what the preacher is saying and what the choir is singing, the space is a design failure.) If you have not built yet, make sure that your architect places a premium on acoustic performance. seats! Think about just how good and loud your main system would have to be to get over that! The previously mentioned problems compound the third problem—obtaining sufficient acoustic separation between the vocals and the other instruments. Because the drums and other instruments are so much louder than the vocals, some of the drum and instrument sound ends up “bleed- No one seems to be telling the architects that if the congregation cannot understand what the preacher is saying and what the choir is singing, the space is a design failure. Regardless of your room acoustics, if the drums are too loud, the other musicians can no longer hear their instruments, so they do what you would expect—they turn it up louder! Then everyone else has to turn up the stage wedges! It is not unusual for us to visit a facility and see 68 to 78dB coming off the stage to the first four or five rows of ing” into the vocal and choir mics. In this situation, if the person at the audio console attempts to bring up the vocals, a large amount of a very unpleasant and roomysounding drum and instrument bleed is also fed into the mix. This makes the mix very muddy and washes out the vocals. If only there were a way to bring the drums under control, you could get the other instruments to come back down to a reasonable level. If you have made the decision that something has to be done about excessive volumes, here are a couple of ideas. One option, of course, is to invest in an electronic drum set. Electric kits have the advantage of giving the sound engineer a lot of control over the drum levels in the various mixes. If you have tech-savvy drummers and qualified sound personnel, an electronic drum kit can be a great solution. The disadvantages include having to deal with a fairly complex system of wiring and programming, and a less natural drum sound and feel that many drummers dislike. Good, quality elec- By RichardRutherford tronic drum kits like the mesh-head Roland V-Drums start at around $3,800. Don’t waste your money on an inexpensive electronic kit unless you crave aggravation. Also note that while the pads are much quieter than drums, they still make clicking noises that you may find annoying in quiet passages. If you decide that you would like to keep the sound and feel of a real drum kit, you may want to try out one of the new portable isolation enclosures now finding popularity in many churches. Some of the more popular systems are made by ClearSonic Manufacturing. ClearSonic IsoPacs are portable isolation booths that combine acrylic drum shields with patented absorption baffles and are available in a variety of configurations and sizes. The acrylic shields act as a see-through acoustic barrier while the 1.6-inch-thick absorption panels are very efficient at soaking up sound. Some of their latest systems also use a lid system. If you have a room with a long decay time, the lid option is highly recommended. While not completely sound tight, using an IsoPac or similar product will significantly reduce the amount of drum sound that will be leaked into the vocal and other instrument mics. This will allow the audio engineer to bring the vocals, choir or other quiet instruments up in the mix without introducing the unpleasant bleed described earlier. For most applications, just adding a kick and two overhead mics can bring a bit of controlled drum presence back into the P.A. mix. A PZM-style flat mic attached by Velcro to the underside of the booth lid may also work great because this method eliminates the need for large overhead mic stands that will clutter up the inside of your enclosure. Either way, if you can control the drums, you’ll have a good beat to mix. (Special thanks to Brian Smith at Clearsonics.) Richard Rutherford is the owner of Rutherford Design, a lighting, video and audio contractor. He can be reached at [email protected]. Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 32 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc December 2005 200.0512.SoundSanc.JH.indd 32 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:34:03 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 33 12/1/05 5:08:57 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc Low or No Minimum Purchase your source for DIY or repair parts Case and Rack Hardware www.dblittle.com 34 December 2005 200.0512.Index.ss.indd 34 www.fohonline.com 12/1/05 5:24:22 PM PG# PH# URL COMPANY Audio-Technica Aviom Crest Audio dbx DiGiCo Consoles EAW Hear Technologies JBL Professional Lab.gruppen LSC Meyer Sound Mid-America Sound NSCA Expo Power Plus Rutherford Design SLS Loudspeakers Spectr Audio TC-Helicon TCS Audio 21 06 07 23 03 12 08 05 C1 28 C2 15 25 32 29 19 08 09 22 www.audio-technica.com www.aviom.com www.crestaudio.com www.dbxpro.com www.digico.org www.eaw.com www.heartechnologies.com www.jblpro.com www.labgruppen.com www.lcsaudio.com www.meyersound.com www.midamericasound.com www.nscaexpo.com www.ppslinc.com www.rutherforddesign.com www.slsloudspeakers.com www.spectraudio.com www.tc-helicon.com www.tcsaudio.com TMB 13 Westone Music Products 04 WorxAudio Technologies 32 Yamaha Commercial Audio 01,11,33,C3 330.686.2600 610.738.9005 866.812.7378 801.568.7660 877.292.1623 800.992.5013 256.922.1200 818.894.8850 818.665.4900 626.836.4883 510.486.1166 317.947.9980 800.446.6722 760.744.8555 818.775.0046 417.883.4549 800.549.1990 818.665.4900 858.487.1600 Pro Audio Network Wars: Will It Take A Guitar Maker to Get It Right? continued from front cover provide high-bandwidth, ultra-low latency and secure audio and video transport. Such technologies will dramatically improve distribution and management of digital content for use in such fields as live music distribution and network-based consumer content delivery, while providing the foundation for media content protection. “The world has migrated to digital media formats, but many audio/video manufacturers continue to endorse old analog or proprietary connectivity methods,” said Henry Juszkiewicz, chairman and CEO of Gibson. “Gibson is committed to leveraging existing networking infrastructure as the basis for the high-quality, secure and open method of transporting digital media. “ “By working with Gibson, Cirrus Logic looks forward to extending our leadership position in networked digital audio markets through a new generation of products for Gigabit Ethernet networks,” said David D. French, president and CEO of Cirrus Logic. As part of the agreement, Cirrus Logic and Gibson will jointly develop specifications for the software protocol that will form the basis for new products, with Cirrus Logic’s engineering teams driving the development of the resulting ICs. The new protocol will provide backward compatibility with CobraNet, helping ensure existing customers an easy migration path that can utilize the ultra-high provided by gigabit Ethernet networks. PG# PH# URL 818.899.8818 800.525.5071 336.275.7474 714.522.9000 www.tmb.com www.westone.com/music www.worxaudio.com www.yamahaca.com 866.274.4590 800.888.6360 423.892.1837 650.742.9166 800.346.4638 800.890.1073 866.796.6232 800.861.3111 818.609.9972 800.203.5611 www.audioeast.com www.clearsonic.com www.dblittle.com www.hi-techaudio.com www.discount-distributors.com www.kanagroocases.com www.northernsound.net MARKETPLACE Audio East ClearSonic Manufacturing, Inc. dblittle.com Hi-Tech Audio Systems Hybrid Case Kangaroo Cases Northern Sound & Light Roadshow Services, Inc. Sound Arena Sound Productions 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 35 INDEX COMPANY www.soundarena.com www.soundpro.com For advertiser information go to www.fohonline.com and click on Instant Info. Counterfeiters Caught in Southeast Asia continued from front cover “These raids also yielded a significant amount of information that will allow us to conduct further operations to strike at the manufacturing sources of these counterfeits. We will continue to pursue those who seek to deceive our customers.” In a further series of raids conducted in September, Shure investigators, assisted by the Thai Crime Supervision Division, raided six locations around the Baan Mor and Phra-pitak roads located in the Phra-Nakorn district of Bangkok. Several thousand counterfeit Shure products and infringing items were seized. In addition to these seizures, five people were arrested and charged. “As the authorized distributor for Shure products in Thailand, we are extremely grateful for the persistence of Shure Asia Limited in helping us to remove infringing products from our market. Their committed actions will help us to ensure that Thai customers are not cheated into buying substandard counterfeit products,” said Kasemsin Kanchanachayphoom, assistant managing director of Mahajak Development Co., Ltd., Shure’s distributor in Thailand. To date, Shure has successfully conducted operations to stem intellectual property breaches in many countries including Australia, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand. Stop Answering Stupid Questions! Let the FOH FAQ T-Shirt do the answering for you. You may have already heard about these shirts designed by mixer-extraodinaire James Geddes that feature the answers to the Top 10 stupid questions audience members ask. Now you can order one of these beauties and all of the net proceeds will benefit the music and arts programs of the Rogue River, Ore School District (Where James' kids go to school). Only 24 00 $ . 2XL and 3XL $29.00 Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc TO ORDER: Go to www .fohonline.com/tshirt THE NEWS MAGAZINE FOR LIVE SOUND "Making the world a better-sounding place one gig at a time." Or send your check to: Ti meless Communications, Inc. Attn: FOH T-Shirt 18425 Burbank Blvd. Ste. 613 Tarzana, CA 91356 www.jamesgeddes.com www.fohonline.com 200.0512.Index.ss.indd 35 December 2005 35 12/2/05 2:00:25 PM FOH-at-Large Non-Fatal Sound Defense W hile riding the train one day in November, I came across an item reported by the News Wire Service and, tucked away in the New York Daily News. The headline over the following article read: “Ship’s hi-tech noise turned away pirates.” MIAMI-The crew of a luxury cruise ship used a military-style sonic weapon that blasts beams of ear-splitting noise to ward off a shocking attack over the weekend by a gang of pirates off Africa, the Seabourn Cruise Line revealed yesterday. The ship, the Seabourn Spirit, had a Long Range Acoustic Device installed to defend itself, said Bruce Good, a company spokesman. The Spirit was 100 miles off Somalia when pirates fired rocket-propelled grenades and machine guns as they tried to get on board. The device is a so-called “nonlethal weapon” developed for the military after the 2000 attack on the destroyer Cole off Yemen. The devices have been deployed on commercial vessels since summer 2003, officials said. I’m sure that one can understand how this small piece of reporting piqued my imagination while I was being held hostage by the New Jersey Transit Authority. I have flown to Istanbul in less time than it takes to travel the 60-mile stretch between Trenton and Manhattan, and was therefore quite appreciative for this little article that made my overactive imagination wonder. Once I lock on to something as juicy as this little piece of reporting, I can amuse myself for hours deliberating each point and nuance, and in a short time, I can have a whole screenplay written, directed and produced, with a marketing strategy to boot. My first question regarding this article is, “If pirates could board a vessel in the middle of the ocean, couldn’t they do the same with a slow-moving train?” That said, I began to wonder why these so-called pirates would want to board a ship 100 miles out to sea—and what kind of booty would they be seeking? Did they really think that firing rockets and machine guns at an ocean liner wouldn’t alert the captain to signal for help from the Coast Guard or the military? After all, in this day and age, the buccaneer lifestyle can’t be that easy. An F-18 plane, if deployed, can travel the 100-mile distance and have a pirate ship blown out of the water in less than 20 minutes after receiving a call for help. Which brings me once again to the thought of “booty.” What kind of spoils were these pirates seeking? Jewels, liquor, ship furnishings? Arr matey, something was not adding up. After all, why attack a cruise ship unless the holds were filled with a much more nefarious cargo, such as military supplies? Africa is a huge continent. A cruise ship off the west coast of Africa has easy access 36 December 2005 200.0512.FOHatLarge.JH.indd 36 to Venezuela, Brazil or Cuba, and if a ship is cruising off the east coast of Africa, it could easily sail to Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Iran and even Iraq. These pirates in question seemed fairly well-armed and funded, which makes me believe that their attack on the Seabourn Spirit had a much more sinister purpose, at this time in our history, than to line their pockets with the passenger’s personal belongings. I suggest that someone should check into the ship’s manifest and also consider this attack as much more than a high-sea hoist by a bunch of miscreant picaroons. Anyway, you can see how my feverish imagination works, and I even had Harrison Ford cast as the ship captain who saved the day by setting off the so-called “nonlethal“ weapons that “blasts beams of ear-splitting noise.” My next thought centered on these beams of ear-splitting noise. I wondered, if they were so directional, how could they be accurately aimed at a target without affecting anything but the desired mark? What frequencies did they utilize? After all, this has to be more serious than 2.5K at 150dB, because once the “pirates” encounter this ear-splitting noise, wouldn’t one assume that these dastardly buccaneers would run out and buy some aviator, noise-blocking headphones and attack again? My guess is that the frequency used by this “device” is a much lower frequency, say, anywhere from 50Hz and down. At this frequency range, if a beam of sound were directed towards the pirates at a very loud volume, it could possibly make them move their bowels and empty their bladders and, as I’m sure we all know, it is almost impossible to attack and board a ship with a wet load in your pants. Of course, if the generated noise were not directional, then everyone onboard the cruise ship would also be affected by the sound of the “device,” which would then incapacitate the crew as well as the passengers. My script has now morphed into a comedy starring Will Ferrell as the captain, who is put in the precarious position of defending a ship filled with pas- sengers and crew members suffering bleeding eardrums while walking around with a full load in their pants. Since the pirates are enduring the same fate, it should make for a very interesting encounter indeed. I have delivered you a messy scenario based upon the scant knowledge given in the Daily News article but, once again, I assume that the brainiacs who devised this sonic nonlethal weapon did a sound check with it before they deployed it on commercial vessels and placed said object into the hands of sailors and ship captains. Though incorrect, it would be typical for the ship owners to let a layman handle the responsibility of the “ear-splitting beams,” in the same way that many bar owners let their bar backs run their sound systems. Then again, does this device really require a technician and, if so, what does it pay to travel around the high seas on cruise ships just waiting for the chance to fire up the rig? My guess is that for a gig like this, a www.fohonline.com By BakerLee technician would be on-call 24-7 and that the device would be on standby at all times, but I would still need some other questions answered before taking a gig such as this. Does the sound technician have to be on watch in the crow’s nest as part of the job? If so, it might require a second and even third technician with whom to split shifts, and if this is the case, who is considered the A-1 tech? How much power is needed to run a nonlethal weapon, and does this device have more than one setting, or is it always set for nonlethal? If there is a spike in power, is it possible it can turn a nonlethal weapon into a lethal weapon? Is the audio technician liable? I can only assume (again) because of the weapon’s nonlethal status, the scientists responsible for it have also developed a lethal version, and if so, is the lethal version only louder, or does the lethal version utilize different frequencies? Is this a full-range weapon or can it be run two in a two- and three-way mode? Is an equalizer required? Can this weapon be run with an active crossover, or just a passive crossover? How long is “long range,” and if the party that one is attacking with said weapon is further away than that prescribed distance, would a delay weapon be needed? For that matter, can we actually apply this longrange technology to our speaker systems and do away with delay stacks? Do they make this device in a handheld version similar to an audio taser gun? If sound is classified as a weapon, does that mean only qualified, licensed audio technicians will be allowed to mix bands? Finally, if sound is determined to have a lethal status, does that mean all audio technicians will be required to register their hands as lethal weapons? Coming Next Month... • FOH Interview Pab Boothroyd on mixing for real rock royalty— Sir Paul McCartney • Product Gallery Line array systems were once so “new” that we could cover the entire spectrum. This time, we concentrate on self-powered boxes. • Installations It’s high noon for the horse set as South Coast sets to open in Las Vegas. 12/1/05 5:21:17 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 3 12/1/05 5:09:42 PM Ad info: www.fohonline.com/rsc 200.0512.Ads.ss.indt 4 12/1/05 5:10:21 PM