Office Ergonomic Analysis and Workplace Design

Transcription

Office Ergonomic Analysis and Workplace Design
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing
Hazards and Identifying
Solutions
Presented by:
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workplace Consultant
Workers’ Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
March 25, 2011
Session Overview
• In this session, you will:
– Discover what design related hazards exist in
almost all office workplaces
– Learn why these hazards can lead to
discomfort / pain, reduced performance and
increased costs
– Begin to ‘see’ the design-related hazards that
may contribute to discomfort / pain in office
workplace settings.
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
1
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Session Objectives
• At the end of this session you will:
– Know why office ergonomics is important
– Understand why and how poor design
contributes to pain and discomfort
– Be able to identify design related hazards in
your office workplace
– Know how to make simple changes to the setup of computer workstations and the equipment
in order to:
improve the health and well-being of workers
reduce costs for your organization!
First Things First!
• Computerized office workplaces have
hazards!
– Research shows that
 exposure to these hazards can lead to
increased pain / discomfort, reduced
performance and increased costs
 reducing exposure to these hazards can
reduce the risk for workers, improve
performance and reduce costs
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
2
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
What do you think is the
biggest ‘hazard’ most office
workers are exposed to?
First Things First!
• The focus of this workshop is on
design-related hazards
– Physical design
 Equipment design, set-up, etc.
– Organizational / task design
 Work organization, cognitive and physical
variety, work methods, etc.
• The worker is not a hazard
– We need to design for them!
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
3
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Ergonomics - Definition
• Ergonomics is a systematic process for
designing the workplace for people through the
application of our knowledge of humans to:
–
–
–
–
the equipment they use
the environments in which they work
the tasks they perform and
the management systems in which they work
• The key to good ergonomics is taking a
human-centred view
– Capabilities and needs of the users must be taken into
account
Office Ergonomics
• Office Ergonomics tends to focus on
computer workstations
– Designing workstation components to fit the
user and the task(s) they are performing
• What design features do we need to
consider when looking at the ergonomics of
an office / computer workstation?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
4
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Office Ergonomics
• Key workstation design features:
– Work surfaces and work space, leg room and
knee space
– Chair design, fit, comfort
– Set-up of keyboard, input devices, telephones
– Documents, paper-work
– Other equipments (calculators, etc)
– Filing cabinets, shelves
– Space (for movement)
Office Ergonomics
• We also need to consider
– The specific task(s) being performed
 Accounting is different than computer based
drafting, which is different than customer service
– The work environment
– Work organization issues
 Opportunities for mental and physical variety
 Opportunities for rest / recovery
– Other hazards that might exist (manual
material handling, etc.)
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
5
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
The Goals Ergonomics
• Optimize the ‘fit’ between
– the person
– the task(s) they are required to perform
– the equipment needed to perform the task
• Maximize comfort, health and performance
• Ensure that individual needs are
addressed.
What are some ‘individual needs’
that we need to consider?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
6
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
What are the consequences of
poor design in office workplaces?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
7
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Consequences of Poor Design
• Pain and discomfort
–
–
–
–
MSIs
Headaches
Neck and shoulder
Eye discomfort
• Vision concerns
– Dry eyes
• Errors
• Low productivity
• Poor customer service
Musculoskeletal Disorders (MSDs)
• Types of MSDs
– General Muscle Pain
 Forearm, arm
 Shoulder, upper back
– Lower Back Pain
 Muscles
 Discs / nerves
– Rotator Cuff Syndrome
 Shoulder
–
–
–
–
Tension Neck Syndrome
Tendonitis
Tenosynovitis
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
8
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Key MSD Hazards
Force
Repetition
Posture
Key MSD Hazards
• Force, posture, and repetition
hazards are all influenced by time
• Time / Duration
– The longer the exposure to the hazard the
greater the risk
 20 minutes vs. 4 hours
– Long duration tasks / postures with little or no
opportunity for recovery / postural change are
higher risk
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
9
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Other MSD Hazards
• Some other MSD hazards found in
offices include:
–
–
–
–
–
Cold temperatures
Hot work environments
Lighting / Glare
Work organization
Work methods
Key MSD Hazards in Offices
• Can you think of any force-related
hazards we will find in an office?
– Low level forces for long duration




Gripping mice
‘Fingers’ hovering over mouse buttons
Keying Tasks
‘Force’ to maintain sitting & working postures
– High level forces
 Lifting of paper boxes
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
10
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Key MSD Hazards in Offices
• Can you think of any awkward / sustained
postures found in an office?
– Sitting
– Sitting while not using the backrest, feet not fully
supported, no lumbar support
– Reaching, wrist extension / deviation when mousing
– Wrist extension and deviation when keyboarding
– Neck extension, ‘chin out’, neck rotation
– Holding phone handset between ear and shoulder
Key MSD Hazards in Offices
• Can you think of any repetition-related
hazards found in an office?
– Repetitive keyboarding
– Repetitive mousing
– Repetitive neck flexion and rotation when
viewing documents
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
11
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Key MSD Hazards in Offices
• Duration
– Performing the same tasks, adopting the same
postures
All day, day after day
– Lack of physical variety is a major issue in
offices
Lack of mental variety is also often a problems
– Sitting for long periods with little or no posture
change is a major hazard in office work
settings
Design-Related Hazards
• A mismatch between the design / set-up of
work, the person doing the work, and / or
the tasks being performed
• Poor design contributes to awkward and
hazardous working postures
• Awkward / hazardous postures can lead to
pain and discomfort
• Design also impacts performance, errors,
job satisfaction, operational costs, etc.
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
12
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
We are never without the best
tools for recognizing designrelated hazards in offices!
What do you think these tools
are?
Key Point To Remember …
• There is no such thing as an ergonomic:
– Chair, keyboard, mouse!!
• Why is this important to remember?
• Nothing is in of itself ergonomic … a work
system could be described as being
ergonomic but individual components are
only ergonomic if they:
– Match the task, the user, the environment and
‘fit’ the other components in the system
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
13
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Recognizing Hazards
• Postural hazards are most common
hazards in offices
– Most of us can easily see / recognize when
others are working in awkward / non-neutral
postures
• We need to ask the worker about their
concerns, discomfort, issues
• We need to find out what the worker does
and how perform their job tasks
Office Ergonomics Checklists
• A checklist can be used to help guide your
observations and questions
– Remember that a checklist can never be all
inclusive
• Use the one provided if it works for you!
• There are lots of them out there!
• Search the Internet and find one that works
for you!
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
14
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Keyboard too high or low
- on high work surface
- on poorly designed / improperly adjusted support
Why is this an issue?
Common Design Issues
Mouse and keyboard at
different heights
- keyboard support too
small for mouse
- mouse under a work
surface so it can’t be used
comfortably
Why is this an issue?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
15
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Mouse too far away from
the user’s side
- arm / elbow must be
moved away from the body
Why is this an issue?
Keyboard / Mouse Supports
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
16
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Chair does not provide optimal fit / comfort
- adjustments not used / understood
- adjustments / design not adequate
- chair too large / too small
Common Design Issues
Chair Issues
- seat pan too long / wide
- arm rests too wide
- lack of adequate lumbar
support
- armrests that are too
long / not padded
- armrests that are not
adjustable
- chair will not adjust high
or low enough
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
17
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Monitor set-up / location
- too far away / too close
- too high / too low
- not set-up so that it is directly in front of user
Why is this an issue?
Common Design Issues
Work surfaces that are
too high / too low
- for paper-based tasks
such as reading, writing,
editing, etc.
- for keyboarding
- for legs (too low)
Why is this an issue?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
18
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Inadequate knee space, room for legs / feet
- due to file drawers
- due to legs and other workstation structures
- due to shoes, boxes, etc.
Why is this an issue?
Common Design Issues
Reading from / referring to
documents while keying
- documents placed to one
side / at an angle
- documents flat on the work
surface
Writing on documents
while working at computer
- documents off to one side
- far reach over keyboard
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
19
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Telephone use with the
computer or when working
with documents
- holding the telephone
handset between shoulder
and ear
- reaching for phone to dial /
answer
Why is this an issue?
Common Design Issues
Contact stress with hard or sharp surfaces
Why is this an issue?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
20
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Glare on screen
- direct from windows or
lights
- indirect due to bright
visual background such
as windows or bright
lights behind the
monitor
Why is this an issue?
Common Design Issues
Using a laptop in an
office
- Keyboard too high
- Monitor too low
- Text / screen too small
Why is this an issue?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
21
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Common Design Issues
Sitting for too long
- even good sitting postures,
if held for too long, can lead
to pain and discomfort
- even with the best chair,
prolonged sitting can lead to
discomfort
Why is this an issue?
Recognizing Hazards
Image 1: what do you see?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
22
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Recognizing Hazards
Image 2: what do you see?
Recognizing Hazards
Image 3: what do you see?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
23
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions for
Design-Related Hazards in
Computerized Offices
Simple Solutions - Seating
• Find a chair that fits the user
• One style / model of chair will
NOT fit all potential users
– small and extra large folks can
be very hard to fit
• Users should have the
opportunity to try chairs
before purchase
– Five days minimum
recommended
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
24
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions - Seating
Simple Solutions - Seating
• Adjustable features that all chairs should
have:
– Seat Height
– Seat Pan Depth
 Critical adjustment
– Seat Lock/Rocking
– Seat Tension
– Back Rest Height
– Back Rest Angle
– Back Rest Lock/Rocking
– Lumbar Support Height
– Lumbar Support Amount
– Arm Rest Height / Width
 Critical adjustment
– If Headrest, Adjustable for Height and Angle
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
25
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions - Seating
• Ensure seat pan depth is not
too long
– ~2” free space before back of
knee
– Sometimes very hard to find a
chair with a short enough seat
pan
• Set seat pan at correct height
– Feet firmly on the floor
– Back up against lumbar support
– Knees slightly lower than hips
• Lumbar support is set to
provide firm support the small
of back
Simple Solutions - Seating
• Armrests at correct height /
width
– If can’t be set to correct height /
width consider removing them
• Back rest angle set for a
slightly reclined sitting posture
• The user knows how to use all
of the chair’s adjustable
features
– And why they should be used!
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
26
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Key Point To Remember
• Many people think a
good chair will solve
all their problems!
• The best chair in the
world is not going to
compensate for a bad
workstation design
Simple Solutions – Keyboard / Mouse
• Keyboard and mouse on same surface, at correct height
- shoulders relaxed
- elbows at approx. right angles, wrists straight
• Can be on desk surface or with keyboard / mouse tray
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
27
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Keyboard / Mouse
• Keyboard / mouse tray
designed to fit the
workstation
– wide enough for both
the keyboard & mouse
– adjusted so top of
keyboard is at seated
elbow height
– keyboard and tray
should be flat
– support should be
designed to ‘fit’ the
workstation
Simple Solutions – Keyboard / Mouse
• A couple of points about keyboard / mouse trays
– Well-designed trays can be very beneficial
– With most workstations they do tend to push you
back away from your other work surfaces
 Reaching for phone, etc.
 Reaching over to read / write on documents
• Palm / wrist rests – good or bad?
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
28
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Keyboard / Mouse
• When the mouse is too
far away from the side of
the body
– Change mouse to left side
– Use keyboard without
number pad or number
pad on the left side
Simple Solutions –Alternative Mouse
• Some people can really
benefit from alternative
mice / input devices
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
29
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Monitors
• Always buy monitors with
height adjustable stands
• Set the top of monitor at
eye level
– ~15 degrees downward
gaze angle to centre of
screen
– Unless user wearing
bifocals (then lower)
• Monitor set as far away
as practical
– User can easily see / read
information / text on
screen
Simple Solutions – Monitors
• Move monitors so
they are aligned with
the letter ‘H’ on the
keyboard
– for users who type
– may need to adjust the
location of the
keyboard / mouse
 adjustable mechanism
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
30
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Documents
• Use in-line document holders
– Documents in-line with monitor and
keyboard
– Holder between monitor and
keyboard
– Documents angled up towards the
user’s face
• Use an in-line document holder
that is stable / strong enough to
allow for writing
– Consider one where the surface can
be pull out over the keyboard
Simple Solutions – Documents
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
31
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Workstations
• Work surfaces too high /
high
– Adjustable height keyboard /
mouse supports
– Raise / lower work surface
heights
 1 – 2” above seated elbow
height
 Feet firmly supported on floor
 Sitting back in chair
– Raise seat pan height / use a
foot rest only as a last resort!
Simple Solutions – Workstations
• Buy / use easily adjustable
workstations
– For seated work
– Sit / Stand
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
32
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Workstations
?
?
?
• Provide good work surface
area for all job tasks
• Ensure adequate knee
room
– 30” min free space
• Ensure adequate leg / foot
space
• Provide a separate work
space for computer- and
paper-based tasks
• Provide adequate, easily
accessible storage
Instructions
· Choose the workstation configuration that most closely
applies.
· Where appropriate, indicate chair position relative to
the workstation.
· Indicate relavent dimensions.
· Is there a keyboard support in place? (yes / no)
· Does it adjust in height? (yes / no)
· Is the mouse on a separate worksurface? (yes / no)
· Is the mouse higher or lower than the keyboard?
(higher / lower / same)
· Is the monitor 90° to an outside light source? (yes / no)
· Is there indirect glare on the monitor from an overhead
light source? (yes / no)
About Footrests
• Footrests are a MUST
if your feet don’t rest
firmly on the floor!
• BUT … everyone can
benefit from using a
good foot rest
– Vary the posture of your
feet & legs
– Push you back into your
chair!
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
33
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Glare
• Position monitor
perpendicular to windows
and between overhead light
fixtures
• Use blinds
• Use indirect lighting or welldesigned louvers
– Parabolic / egg crate
• Use matte surfaces
• Consider task lighting for
documents
Simple Solutions – Laptop Use
• Use a docking station
for the laptop
– Separate, adjustable
height monitor
– External keyboard and
mouse
• Limit use to < 2 hr if
external devices not
provided
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
34
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Telephones
• Provide a headset
– Wireless headsets are
preferred
– Consider accessory that
allows for automatic lifting of
phone handset
• Where practical consider
using a speaker phone
• Move phone close to front
edge of work surface
– Even when using a headset
Simple Solutions – Contact Stress
• Ensure work surfaces
are at the correct height
• Ensure keyboard /
mouse are at the correct
height
• Consider a palm rest
– Use when resting not
when keying / mousing
– Make sure there isn’t
pressure on the wrist
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
35
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Simple Solutions – Sitting
• Stand up
– 5 minutes each hour
• Move about
– When possible stand up and
walk about
– Use wireless headsets
– Don’t provide local printers
– Take breaks / meals away
from desk
• Use sit / stand workstations
Simple Solutions – Sitting
• Interject keying tasks with
other work tasks to add variety
and a break
• Use natural pauses in work to
relax muscles (e.g. stand
occasionally when on
telephone, remove hands from
keyboard when waiting for
computer)
• Vary your posture by
rearranging adjustments of
furniture (e.g. recline and work
for 10 minutes every hour)
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
36
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Thank you for coming!
Any questions?
HumanScale – 500 Big Board
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
37
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
HumanScale – 400 Diagonal Board
HumanScale – 800 Radius
Ergonomic Accessories
Ergonomic Accessories
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
38
Office Ergonomics: Recognizing Hazards and
Identifying Solutions
May 25, 2011
Banana Board
Reversible Corner Platform
Workrite
Jonathan Tyson, MASc, CPE
Workers Compensation Board of Nova Scotia
39