wellington ocean sports centre - Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club
Transcription
wellington ocean sports centre - Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club
novak+middleton WELLINGTON OCEAN SPORTS CENTRE New building for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre At 115 Oriental Parade, Wellington FEASIBILITY STUDY June 2014 Novak+Middleton Limited, 15 Everton terrace, Po Box 12 232, Wellington t 04 472 9729 f 04 472 9728 e [email protected] www.novakmiddleton.co.nz novak+middleton Contents Executive Summary 4 1. The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Restoration Project 1.0 Introduction 1.1 The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Master Plan 1.2 The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre within the Clyde Quay Marina Upgrade 5 5 7 9 2. The Wellington Ocean Sports Active Communities Project 2.0 Introduction 2.1 Establishing a ‘Sportsville’ hub 2.2 The Wellington Ocean Sports philosophy 2.3 The Wellington Ocean Sports programme 2.4 The Wellington Ocean Sports brand 2.5 Marketing the Wellington Ocean Sports programme 11 11 11 11 12 13 14 3. Justification for a Wellington Ocean Sports Centre 15 4. Location Rationale 16 5. Concept Design 5.0 Introduction 5.1 Design brief 5.2 Addressing sea level rise 5.3 Addressing heritage 5.4 Architect’s design statement 5.4.1 The proposal 5.4.2 The site 5.4.3 Key design considerations 5.4.4 Design response 5.5 Digital model images 5.6 Appearance from water and board walk 18 18 18 19 20 20 20 20 21 22 23 25 6. Outline Specification 6.0 Introduction 6.1 Site preparation 6.2 Foundations and structure 6.3 External cladding and finishes 6.4 Internal linings and finishes 6.5 Services 6.6 Provisional sums 6.7 Exclusions 26 26 26 27 29 29 31 32 32 7. Capital Costs 7.0 Introduction 7.1 Summary of capital costs 7.2 Construction cost estimates 33 33 34 8. Staging Plan 8.0 Introduction 8.1 Possible stages for building the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre 8.2 Possible stages for upgrading the Clyde Quay Marina 8.2.1 Stage 1: Wave mitigation and ocean sports ramps and berths 8.2.2 Stage 2: Marina berths and pile moorings 45 45 45 45 46 46 Page | 2 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton Contents (continued) 9. Constitution, Governance and Management Plan 9.0 Introduction 9.1 Constitution 9.2 Governance 9.3 Management 47 47 47 48 48 10. Operating Costs 10.0 Introduction 10.1 Projected annual income and expenses 50 50 50 11. Sustainability 11.0 Introduction 11.1 Additional activities proposed to be supported by the Centre 11.1.1 Model yachts and harbour sails tourist attractions 11.1.2 ‘Powered by the Wind’ export education initiative 11.1.3 Clyde Quay Boat Harbour management 11.1.4 Wellington strategic sailing events framework 11.2 Economic, social and environmental impact 51 51 51 51 51 52 53 54 12. Conclusions and Recommendations 55 Figures 1. The Clyde Quay Precinct Plan - opportunities 5 2. Elements of the Clyde Quay Master Plan 7 3. Clyde Quay Marina layout 9 4. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre space within the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour 10 5. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building site 10 6. A sample of Wellington Ocean Sports activities 13 7. Variations of the Wellington Ocean Sports brand 13 8. Screenshot of the Wellington Ocean Sports website 14 9. Examples of Wellington Ocean Sports marketing material 14 10. Design strategy from the Clyde Quay precinct plan 16 11. Possible locations for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building 17 12. The effect of king tides inside the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour 19 13. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre context plan 21 14-19. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre digital model design images 23-24 20-21. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre rendered design images 25 22. Clyde Quay Marina upgrade stage 1 45 23. Clyde Quay Marina upgrade stage 2 46 24. Proposed Wellington Ocean Sports Centre governance and management structure 49 25. ‘Powered by the Wind’ curriculum framework 52 26-31. Wellington strategic sailing events framework 53-54 Appendices 1. Wellington Ocean Sports Active Communities Investment Exit Report 56 2. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Preliminary Design Drawings (separate document) Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 3 novak+middleton Executive Summary This feasibility report outlines preliminary designs and cost estimates for a new building for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre, which is proposed to be constructed as part of Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project. The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project aims to restore the boat harbour to once again be the jewel in the crown of the Wellington waterfront, able to fulfil its role as a primary means of connecting Wellingtonians to Wellington harbour. The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is one of five key initiatives in the overall restoration project. Insights for this report have been derived from the feedback and experiences of the sports, clubs and national sporting organisations involved in the Sport New Zealand funded Wellington Ocean Sports active communities project which ran for three years from 2011 to 2014, and lead to the development of a sport and recreation programme that enables Wellingtonians to discover, experience and learn ocean sports. Organisations involved in the project included Tunui a Te Ika Outrigger Canoe Club, Canoe and Kayak Ltd, the Wellington Windsurfing Association, Port Nic Paddlers SUP Club, Wild Winds Ltd, Yachting New Zealand, Coastguard Boating Education Services, Windsurfing New Zealand, Surf New Zealand and Water Safety New Zealand. The Steering Group for the project included representatives from Wellington City Council, Sport Wellington, Sport New Zealand, College Sport Wellington and Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club. The building will provide a contemporary purpose built facility that extracts the maximum potential from the ocean sports partnership and caters for the changing nature of sport and recreation participation in society. A site for the building on the north western corner of the harbour was chosen because of its close location and easy access to the boat harbour, proximity to the beach and the availability of existing sheds and building space. The building design addresses the requirements as identified by the ocean sports involved in the partnership, caters for sea level rise projections, addresses heritage requirements, and responds with respect to its iconic location. A full set of preliminary drawings and an outline specification for the building have been created and the total construction cost has been estimated at $1,530,000 + GST. It is recommended that an application be made to the Department of Internal Affairs Community Facilities Fund and to selected community funding agencies for the full cost of construction of the Centre as a community facility within the overall Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project. It is recommended that the Centre be constructed at the same time as wave mitigation systems are installed in the boat harbour and that this could take place ahead of the overall marina upgrade works if necessary. It is recommended that an incorporated society be established with an independent board to govern the Centre and a professional management and instructor team be put in place to oversee the implementation of the Programme. It is estimated that the annual operating expenses for the Centre will be in the order of $535,000 + GST per annum and it is recommended that the Wellington City Council provide funding for the salary cost of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Manager. This feasibility study was funded by a Communities Facilities Grant from the New Zealand Department of Internal Affairs. The report was coordinated by Novak+Middleton Ltd with input from Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club and Rider Levett Bucknall. Page | 4 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 1. The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Restoration Project 1.0 Introduction The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is part of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project. The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project aims to restore the boat harbour to once again be the jewel in the crown of the Wellington waterfront, able to fulfil its role as a primary means of connecting Wellingtonians to Wellington harbour. Figure 1: The Clyde Quay Precinct Plan - opportunities The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project is primarily a social restoration project aimed at increasing public access to Wellington harbour, providing greater public amenity within the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour and completing the waterfront connection from Oriental Bay through to Waitangi Park and beyond. Improving public access and amenity will be achieved through the following elements: • • • • • • • A public plaza in the centre of the harbour. Enhanced entrance ways on western and eastern edges drawing people into the harbour. Improved concrete promenade clearly connecting the western edge to the central plaza. Legible connections from Oriental Parade to the boat harbour via entrance steps. A promenade clearly connecting the central plaza to Oriental Bay beach. Enhanced presentation and restoration of heritage elements. A cluster of heritage yachts and boat harbour heritage interpretation areas. In the centre of the harbour is the Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club. Along with its primary function of running sailing programmes, the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project will see the club increasingly taking on a significant public amenity role. This will be achieved through the following elements: Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 5 novak+middleton • • • • • • A Royal Yacht Club providing a comprehensive year round sailing programme. A centre for the delivery of significant ocean sport events for Wellington. A remote control yacht attraction for public to sail model yachts in the boat harbour. A harbour sails attraction for public to take sailing excursions on Wellington harbour. A cafe and restaurant. A venue for meetings, seminars and other social engagements. A key component of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project is the upgrading of marina facilities within the boat harbour. The harbour is now over a 100 years old and in that time has had very little upgrading. The project will see the functionality of the boat harbour greatly improved for the recreational sport of sailing along with other ocean sports. This will be achieved through the following elements: • • • • • • Removal of mooring blocks and fore/aft mooring systems from the harbour. Installation of a wave attenuation system at the harbour entrance. Selective dredging to increase depth in key areas. Installation of walk on marina berths connected to the promenade. Installation of pile moorings along the eastern and western breakwaters. Establishment of a central bay for the implementation of ocean sports events. From 2011 to 2014 Wellington City Council and Sport New Zealand worked with a group of ocean sports clubs to establish the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme in and around the Clyde Quay precinct. The project was an active communities initiative aimed at establishing a programme to help Wellingtonians actively participate in ocean sports. As the project matured the partner sports began planning for a purpose built Wellington Ocean Sports Centre which is the focus of this report. As you will discover from reading this report the design for the centre includes the following elements: • • • • • • Classrooms for the delivery of ocean sports courses. Office space for ocean sports administration. Changing rooms including drying space for wet weather and safety clothing. Storage space for equipment such as kayaks, windsurfers, paddle boards, sails, etc. Storage space for rescue and coaching craft. Enhanced access to the harbour for a range of ocean sports. Aligned to the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme is the ‘Powered by the Wind’ export education initiative which will be delivered out of the Centre alongside of the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme. New Zealand has a competitive edge in the innovative design and use of composite technologies in the marine sector and Wellington is a leader in the secondary and tertiary education sectors. The ‘Powered by the Wind’ export education initiative aims to capitalise on these advantages through an export led education initiative focusing on the innovative design and use of high tech materials in the marine sector through the context of speed sailing. Ultimately it is planned that the ‘Powered by the Wind’ export education initiative will include the following elements: • • • A sailing academy for secondary schools to use in their export education drives. A tertiary level qualification programme focusing on the design and engineering of structures using high technology materials to capture the power of the wind. An annual international competition aimed at designing, creating and testing craft that can beat the world speed sailing record. Before exploring the design for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre it is necessary to first explore the scope of the Master Plan for the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour and the position of the Centre within the Master Plan. Page | 6 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 1.1 Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Master Plan Figure 2: Elements of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Master Plan Since the middle of 2009 Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club and the Wellington City Council have been working together to develop an overall Master Plan for the Clyde Quay precinct. This work has been documented in the following reports: • • • • • • In 2010 the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project was identified as a catalyst project in Wellington’s Central City Framework Spatial Structure Plan 1. In 2011 the Club and the Council published the Clyde Quay Precinct Plan 2 to provide a framework within which the overall development would take place. In 2011 the Council commissioned a concept review3 of the initial Clyde Quay Boat Harbour development plans. In 2012 the Club and the Council published a draft Master Plan4 for the area. In 2012 the draft Master Plan was peer reviewed in the Wardale Report 5 leading to an updated marina layout and a revised Master Plan. In 2013 the Council commissioned the Club to complete an economic impact summary of the Wellington Yachting Strategy6. In 2012 the Council started work on the implementation of Master Plan by allocating funding to undertake work on the Oriental Parade street frontage and boat harbour entrances in the 20122013 Annual Plan. In 2013 the Council agreed to progress the Marina Upgrade component of the Master Plan in 2013-2014 Annual Plan. Funding was allocated to allow Council to undertake investigations at the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour to allow for the future development of the harbour including the proposed installation of pile moorings, floating pontoons, promenades and public space. 1 Wellington City Council, 2011. ‘Wellington 2040: Reshaping Wellington’s Future’. Wellington City Council, 2011. ‘The Clyde Quay Precinct Plan’.. 3 Beca Infrastructure Ltd, 2011. ‘Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Development – Concept Review’ 4 Wellington City Council and Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club, 2012. ‘Connecting Wellingtonians to Wellington Harbour: The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Master Plan’. 5 Wardale Marine Industry Consulting, 2013. ‘Masterplan Review: Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Redevelopment’. 6 Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club, 2013. ‘Wellington Yachting Strategy: An Economic Impact Summary’. 2 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 7 novak+middleton The scope of work included: • A geotechnical analysis including a preliminary appraisal upon which a plan for detailed investigations was based, leading to a geotechnical assessment report which included: • • • • • • Summary of ground conditions. Comments on geotechnical risks and issues. Comments on the suitability of piles (or alternative systems) for moorings. Advice on design of foundations for proposed structures including pontoons and any wave attenuation system. Results of inspections of the foundations of the existing breakwaters. Summary of measured silt thickness in the seabed. • A seabed survey to determine the contour of the seabed in the harbour and to locate and mark the mooring blocks/chains and other items lying or fixed to the seafloor. It should be noted that Niwa has some base line data as they undertook a multibeam bathymetric survey of the area in 2008. • A coastal ecology report including sampling and analysis of contaminants within the harbour and an ecology survey that provides a baseline for future monitoring. • A wave/wind study (modeller) to determine the effect on the boat harbour and assist with design of the pile moorings, pontoons and any wave attenuation systems and structures that that may be required. The study provides information on: • • • • Sea and tide levels. The wave climate (including storm surge and significant wave height). The potential effects of climate change and predicted rises in sea level over 50 years. Recommendations for the design of wave attenuation systems if it is deemed this is required to protect proposed marina structures. • A topographical survey above the water through to the road’s edge. • A marina concept design and layout plan to meet the specific requirements of the Club and the Council. The scope of work did not include: • • • The urban design work for the boardwalks and enhanced public space. The architectural design work for the proposed Wellington Ocean Sports Centre or RPNYC clubroom alterations. The pre consent tasks such as the heritage report, the traffic report, the urban design report. OPUS International were contracted to undertake the work and subsequently engaged a group of subcontractors to complete some aspects of the work. International Marina Consultants were contracted by OPUS to complete the preliminary layout work for the Clyde Quay Marina Upgrade as depicted in figure 3.7 7 See OPUS International, 2014. ‘Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Investigations Summary Report’ for full details of the marina upgrade design. Page | 8 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 1.2 The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre within the Clyde Quay Marina Upgrade Figure 3: Clyde Quay Marina Layout The layout of the Clyde Quay Marina upgrade includes an area to the North East of the harbour which has been set aside for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. This area includes: • • • • • A ramp into the harbour for the launching and retrieval of kayaks, stand up paddleboards and canoes. Berthing for learn to sail yachts. Berthing for the Wellington Youth Sailing Trust’s youth training yachts. Storage and launching space for waka ama outrigger canoes. Space for ‘learn to paddle’ sessions. The design of these ‘on the water’ components of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is addressed through the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Investigations summary report while the design of the ‘on the land’ components of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is the focus of this feasibility study. Figure 4 below shows the positioning of the various ‘on the water’ elements for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. It also shows the space allocated for the construction of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 9 novak+middleton Figure 4: Wellington Ocean Sports Centre space within Clyde Quay Boat Harbour The building site includes the area covered by the ‘Sailing Academy’ building which is owned by the Club and is on land leased from the Council. It includes the two Coene sheds which are owned by the Council. It also includes the decommissioned slipway space which is between the two Coene sheds and is also owed by the Council. Figure 5 below shows the building site outlined in red. Figure 5: Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building site Page | 10 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 2. The Wellington Ocean Sports Active Communities Project 2.0 Introduction Before investigating the design for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre it is necessary to first explore some of the history behind the centre’s conceptualisation. The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre traces its origins to the Wellington City Council Sports Talent Development Programme. Sailing and diving were both inaugural recipients of talent development funding through the programme and very quickly began collaborating together to share sport science providers. Both sports were encouraged by the success of the collaboration and began to explore ways in which they could expand the concept further by collaborating with other likeminded sports. The sailing talent development programme was based at the Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club Sailing Academy. As work got underway on the Master Plan for the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project the Club realised that it had a facility that was not fully utilised while there were other ocean sports in the precinct who did not have a home. The Club began discussions with some of these ocean sports to see if there were ways in which they could collaborate for mutual benefit. From these initial discussions the seeds of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre were sewn. 2.1 Establishing a ‘Sportsville’ hub In 2011 Wellington City Council signed a contract with Sport New Zealand to implement a three year active communities project aimed at establishing the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme8. The Council in turn entered into an agreement with Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club to project manage the development of the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme. The focus of the project was to begin the process of establishing a Sportsville hub for ocean sports in the Clyde Quay precinct. Sportsvilles are partnership initiatives to bring sports clubs in one location together, sharing ideas, resources, knowledge and skills, and boosting sports participation. Sportsvilles make it easier for sports clubs to offer new programmes, attract new members, and control operational costs by pooling resources and sharing facilities. The primary focus of the active communities project was on the first three of these outcomes with the development of a new shared facility seen as a task to be addressed once the Programme was in place. The sports involved in the project were Sailing, Kayaking/Canoeing, Waka Ama, Windsurfing and Stand Up Paddleboarding. 2.2 The Wellington Ocean Sports programme philosophy The philosophy for the Wellington Ocean Sports programme reflects the four stages to becoming an active participant in sport: 1. 2. 3. 4. “I am interested”. “I want to give it a go”. “It is becoming part of what I do”. “I am doing it!” These four stages can be summarised as … discover … experience … learn … do. ‘Discovering’, ‘experiencing’ and ‘learning’ ocean sports are the domain of the Programme and ‘do’ is the domain of the partner clubs. 8 See Appendix one for the ‘Wellington Ocean Sports Active Communities Investment - Project Exit Report’ which provides an overview of what was achieved during the investment period. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 11 novak+middleton 2.3 The Wellington Ocean Sports Programme The Wellington Ocean Sports Programme is promoted as ‘your place in Wellington to discover, experience and learn ocean sports’. The Programme operates at three levels. Discover Ocean Sports Wellingtonians can discover ocean sports on one of the Programme’s monthly open days. Held on the last Saturday of the month open days give people the opportunity to try out the various ocean sports on offer. All equipment is provided and no experience is necessary. Experience Ocean Sports The Programme has a number of experienced based activities for those who would like to take ocean sports to the next level and get in amongst the action. The Programme offers harbour sails, kayak and SUP hire, windsurfing tasters and also caters for school, corporate and family groups. Learn Ocean Sports For those wishing to gain the skills to regularly participate in ocean sports the Programme includes a comprehensive set of courses in a range of ocean sports. No experience is necessary with the courses designed to equip people with all the skills required for full independence and a lifetime of safe participation in ocean sports. The programme offers the following activities and courses. Harbour Sails Learn to Sail Courses Racing Courses Cruising Courses Corporate Team Building School Group Programmes School Holiday Programmes Family Days Out On The Harbour Advanced Sea Survival Courses Coastguard Boating Education Courses Boatmaster Courses Coastal Skipper Courses VHF Radio Operator Courses RYA Powerboat Level 2 Courses Waka Ama Courses Kayaking Courses Windsurfing Courses Stand Up Paddleboard Courses Have A Go Days Hire of Ocean Sports Equipment Private Tuition SUP Storage The Wellington Ocean Sports Programme provides all of the gear people need to get into ocean sports. The Programme has four purpose built keelboats moored right outside the door and has access to windsurfers, kayaks, waka ama and stand up paddleboards. The Programme supplies high quality wet weather gear for use during the sailing courses and provides life jackets and buoyancy aids for use during all other ocean sports courses and activities. All of the courses are accredited by either Yachting New Zealand, Coastguard Boating Education New Zealand, the Royal Yachting Association, the International Sailing Federation, NZQA, Windsurfing New Zealand or Surf New Zealand. The programme complies with the Maritime Safety New Zealand safe ship management systems for commercial operators covering vessel compliance, safety equipment and operating procedures. The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is a delegate member of Water Safety New Zealand. The Centre delivers a water safety programme to Wellington schools which is funded through Water Safety New Zealand as part of the ACC drowning prevention strategy. Everyone who does a course as part of the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme can join one of the affiliated clubs at a discounted rate and participate in their ongoing club activities. The clubs include Port Nic Paddlers, Tunui a Te Ika Outrigger Canoe Club, Wellington Windsurfers, Yakkity Yak Canoe & Kayak Club and the Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club. They can also hire any of the centre’s equipment such as stand up paddle boards, kayaks, windsurfers and sailboats on an ongoing basis. Page | 12 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton Figure 6: A sample of Wellington Ocean Sports activities 2.4 The Wellington Ocean Sports brand The core symbol for the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme is an 'O' for Ocean. The design inside the O is a derivation of traditional Pacifica patterns for the ocean. The tag line in the logo is DISCOVER - EXPERIENCE - LEARN. The activities delivered by the various sports involved in the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme are grouped around these three calls to action. Figure 7: Variations of the Wellington Ocean Sports brand Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 13 novak+middleton 2.5 Marketing the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme At the core of the marketing strategy is the Wellington Ocean Sports website. The website provides an online booking portal for all the activities delivered through the Centre. Figure 8: Screenshot of the Wellington Ocean Sports website The website includes the following sections. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. News: Articles on activity at the Centre. Discover: Booking for the monthly have a go days. Experience: Booking for ocean sports experiences offered by each sport. Learn: Booking for each of the courses offered by each sport. Sports: Activities and courses listed by each sport. Clubs: A directory of Wellington ocean sports clubs. The website is complemented by a range of other marketing materials. Billboards are used on the building and the Club to draw people’s attention to the Programme. A brochure outlining all the elements of the Programme is available. Specific forms for corporate and school sailing are available for these groups. The Centre uses community sport radio advertising and direct marketing strategies to promote the Programme to a broader audience. Figure 9: Examples of Wellington Ocean Sports marketing material Page | 14 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 3. Justification for a Wellington Ocean Sports Centre There are three major justifications for building a Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. 1. Establishing a contemporary purpose built facility. 2. Extracting maximum benefits from the potential of the Sportsville model. 3. Catering to the changing nature of sport and recreation participation. A key justification for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is the need to establish a contemporary purpose built facility. The Programme to date has been delivered out of sheds which date back to the early to mid-1900s. These sheds are now being flooded in major tidal events and are leaking badly when it rains. The connections to the water for paddling activities are across steep slipways that were built for a different purpose and are very dangerous when the weed has grown on them. A significant area within the space is now a redundant and decommissioned boat repair slipway. There are no showers and the changing facilities are inadequate for the breadth of activities now delivered through the Programme. The classroom and administration space is too small to accommodate the sports involved and the activities now being delivered. There is only limited storage space for equipment for the new ocean sports which have been brought into the Programme. The active communities project ran as a Sportsville project, but not in the traditional sense of the Sportsville model. Often Sportsville projects are catalysed in the first instance by a desire to create a shared facility for a group of sports who share a common sport ground or area. Often the sports all have declining memberships and own depreciating facilities in need of significant repair and maintenance. By pooling their resources into a new facility and establishing a new governance structure the sports can gain the benefits of collaborating together and sharing resources. This project was different in that it focused on the development of the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme in the first instance to make sure that all the sports could work together collaboratively for a common purpose before addressing the need for a facility. It was always the intention that a new facility would be addressed as the project evolved, but that this would only happen once the programme was up and running and the actual requirements of the facility became clear. As the active communities project drew to a conclusion these requirements were identified and a facility eas conceptualised that will maximise benefits from the potential of the Sportsville model. The third major justification is associated with the changing nature of sport and recreation in society. Over the last 40 or so years New Zealand has witnessed a significant change in the way in which people engage in sport and recreation. Forty years ago the vast majority of people participated in formally organised sport through clubs with very few people participating in informally organised or events based recreation pursuits. Nowadays the number of people participating in sport as members of clubs is decreasing while the participation in informally organised or events based recreation pursuits is growing. All clubs need to embrace this change if they are to remain relevant and as such clubs must identify ways to encourage people to participate in their sport without necessarily becoming club members as the first step in the process. The ‘discover’ ‘experience’ ‘learn’ philosophy has proven to be a successful one for each of the sports involved in the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme. The delivery of the Programme through a Centre which represents an amalgam of clubs as opposed to just one club is at the heart of the success of this philosophy. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 15 novak+middleton 4. Location Rationale Figure 10. Design Strategy from Clyde Quay Precinct Plan The choice of location for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre was driven initially by the design strategy for the boat harbour, as articulated in the Clyde Quay Precinct Plan9. The design strategy positioned the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour as a key place in the Wellington waterfront for connecting Wellingtonians to Wellington harbour. The design strategy suggested that the elements designed for the area should facilitate open space connections to the water for people. The design strategy suggested that this be achieved through the development of built structures to help facilitate these connections, along with the clearer articulation of the overall area as public space, through enhancements to entrance ways at either end of the harbour and off Oriental Parade. Three possible locations were identified for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre in the Clyde Quay Precinct Plan. The first of these was the existing park at the Western edge of the harbour which had been identified as a possible building site by Wellington Waterfront Ltd as part of the Waitangi Park design competition. Concept designs had already been created for the Wardle building on this site which was positioned for a sport and recreation purpose. The second suggested site integrated a combination of existing buildings within the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour itself. This involved the replacement or repurposing of the Sailing Academy building, the two Coene sheds and the slipway. The third suggested site in the precinct plan involved an area over hanging the water and breakwater adjacent to the car park for the Freyberg Pool. The precinct plan suggested that this site could include a new public plaza in place of the Freyberg Pool car park. 9 Wellington City Council, 2011. ‘The Clyde Quay Precinct Plan’. Page | 16 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton Site one was deemed to be too far from the beach and its height above the water was seen as requiring too much new infrastructure to enable easy access to the water for waka ama, kayaks, canoes and stand-up paddleboards. It was felt that this site would have had a significant impact on the overall berth allocations within the marina itself and had too much potential for conflicting use of space between ocean sports users and marina berth holders. Site three was discounted as it was seen as too problematic as a building site in terms of gaining appropriate consents and approvals. It was felt that replacing the existing Freyberg Pool car park with a public plaza would be too difficult to achieve. Its connection to the boat harbour was also not as strong as the other two sites. Site two was chosen as the preferred location because of its good access to the boat harbour, the beach and Oriental Parade. This site’s proximity to the Freyberg Pool was seen as an advantage as it reinforced the perception of this section of the Oriental Bay as community recreation space. The connection to berths for learn to sail yachts and for access to calm paddling waters was seen as an advantage of this site. It also provided the least potential for conflicting use of space between ocean sports users and marina berth holders. The ability to repurpose existing buildings was also seen as an advantage of this site. Figure 11: Possible locations for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 17 novak+middleton 5. Concept Design 5.0 Introduction Having operated the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme for three years the manager, instructors, volunteers and sports involved in the various activities developed a good understanding of what infrastructure and equipment is required to deliver on the full potential of the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme. The following design brief reflects the requirements for the Centre as identified by the sports involved in the Programme. It covers all the key requirements from office and classroom space through to storage and workshop space. It also provides comment on the impact of the sea level rise and the heritage requirements that need to be addressed in the design process. 5.1 Design brief Two changing rooms • Capable of holding 20 people at a time. • Two showers in each changing room. • One toilet in each changing room. • Wet floor system. Instructor’s room • Capable of holding 5 people at a time. • Lockers. • Wet floor system. • Shower and toilet. Gear drying space • Capable of housing 40 sets of wet weather gear and 40 life jackets. • Dehumidifier to pump moisture outside. • Wet floor system. • Space for people to change into wet weather gear. Two seminar/meeting rooms • Each room capable of sitting 20 people at tables. • Each room to have large wall mounted TV linked to sound, computer, and video systems. • Each room to have a large whiteboard. • Dividing wall system between the two rooms so that the space can be turned into one room. Reception area • Access from Oriental Parade and from Clyde Quay Boat Harbour. • Space for up to thirty bags to be locked away. • Waiting area for up to 20 people. Storage space • Cupboard space for files. • Cupboard space for resources. • Cupboard space for fitness gear. Kitchen • Tea and coffee facilities for up to forty people. • Dishwasher. • Fridge. Page | 18 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton • Connected to reception area and to seminar rooms. Office space • Capable of housing 6 people at one time. • Reception counter. • ‘Hot desk’ facilities for sports administration. • Large meeting table. Equipment storage • Space for sails and other yacht equipment. • Space for windsurfer storage. • Space for stand up paddleboard storage. • Space for canoe and kayak storage. • Space for equipment such as marker buoys and anchors. Workshop space • Large work bench. • Storage space for spares and tools. 5.2 Addressing sea level rise Sea level rise is one of the key issues to address in the design of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. The existing concrete apron and pathways inside the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour are being overrun by the tide on an average of six to ten days per annum. The existing classroom and admin facility experienced its worst flood in June 2013 when a king tide coincided with a large southerly storm surge resulting in flooding to a level of 5cm above the existing floorboards. The design of the new building will need to factor sea level rise into the calculation of floor heights. Figure 12: The effect of king tides inside the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 19 novak+middleton 5.3 Addressing heritage requirements A conservation plan for the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour was published in 2005 10. The Coene Sheds, old clubrooms and slipway are all listed as heritage items in the conservation plan. These items and their heritage value are: Heritage Item Coene Sheds Historic Value Medium Social Value Medium Aesthetic Value Low Scientific Value Low Overall Value Medium Slipway and cradle Medium Medium Low Medium Medium Former Clubhouse Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club Medium Medium Low Low Medium The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Conservation Plan recommends that “physical changes be made to improve access, to encourage greater public use and enjoyment of the harbour; and that infrastructure be upgraded so that the usefulness of the place for the recreational sport of yachting, one deeply embedded in the lifestyle of Wellingtonians, is enhanced” 11. The conservation plan goes on to state that “these changes can be made without compromising heritage values, and will in fact enhance them”12. The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Conservation Plan defines a conservation policy for the treatment of various elements of the boat harbour, and makes recommendations for future action 13. The policy draws heavily on the ICOMOS New Zealand Charter for the conservation of places of cultural heritage value14. It outlines policies for use, maintenance, repair, restoration, interpretation, recording and adaptation. The design for the new building needs to take account of the policy. 5.4 Architect’s design statement 5.4.1 The proposal The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre involves the development of a new ocean sports facility on the existing site in the north eastern corner of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour, Wellington. The proposal includes the construction of a new building together with the refurbishment of two historic boat sheds (Coene sheds) that are currently on the site. The new building will form an important transitional link between Oriental Parade, Clyde Quay Boat Harbour, and Wellington City beyond and will incorporate a public interface within the design. 5.4.2 The site The proposed site is in the north eastern corner on the existing Clyde Quay Boat Harbour adjacent to the current Freyberg Pool. The existing buildings on the site are single level and are contained between the original sea wall to Oriental Parade and the water’s edge of the boat harbour. The site has had a range of various 10 Cochran C, 2005. ‘Clyde Quay Boat Harbour Wellington Conservation Plan’. Ibid page 1. 12 Ibid page 1. 13 Ibid page 57. 14 Te Mana O Nga Pouwhenua O Te Ao – The New Zealand National Committee of the International Council on Monuments and Sites, 1993. ‘ICOMOS New Zealand Charter for the Conservation of Places of Cultural Heritage Value’. 11 Page | 20 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton uses over the years from boat club facilities, to a base for American landing craft during WW2, to its current occupation as an ocean sports facility. The Clyde Quay Boat Harbour is recognised as one of Wellington’s most significant places in recreational and maritime history. There has been the same continuous use of this part of the harbour since 1905. It is regionally important to Wellington and includes important historic, social, aesthetic and scientific heritage values. The site is surrounded by a diverse range of architecture ranging from individual residential dwellings to apartment buildings, recreational facilities, restaurants and historic boatsheds. The site is located at the interface between the very public promenade of Oriental Parade and Wellington’s unique harbour edge. It acts as a potential link to the range of surrounding public space and provides an opportunity to extend the connection between the built environment and the harbour. Figure 13: Wellington Ocean Sports Centre context plan 5.4.3 Key design considerations In designing a new building for the site there were a number of key design considerations that were identified as being important in creating an appropriate design response. These include: To create a positive contribution to the immediate area and complete the waterfront link between Wellington City and Oriental Bay. To provide an active edge at the public interface and extend the public access to the boat harbour creating a transition between the built environment and the water’s edge. To ensure that the distinctive characteristics of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour such as scale, pattern, grain of development, and treatment of public space are respected and enhanced by the new development, and to develop a creative interpretation of the major underlying themes and patterns that defines the Wellington waterfront. To articulate the building in a consistent manner as an integral part of the overall building design and in a way that allows it to be considered as a whole as well as in part. To continue the existing variety of use and diversity of activity and provide a high level of amenity for building users, occupiers and the public. To create a strong and coherent architectural design response and establish a clear relationship to human scale. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 21 novak+middleton 5.4.4. Design response Wellington currently enjoys a vibrant and accessible waterfront stretching from the Wellington railway station right the way around to Oriental Bay and beyond. Over the years this connection between the city and the harbour has been continually strengthened through creative development and a strong public focus. The only piece that now remains undeveloped - the missing link - is the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour. The redevelopment of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre is very much part of this final piece of the puzzle. The location of the site and surrounding buildings generated an initial design response which was to create a development that acted as a positive interface between Oriental Parade and Wellington’s harbour edge and also looked to complete the water front connection between Waitangi Park and Freyberg Beach. The new building has been designed as a series of components rather than as a whole. Layering of architectural elements, contrasting surface finishes, colours and patterns all emphasise smaller parts of the overall composition of the building and help to create a scale and visual complexity that responds to its surrounding context and also reflects the building’s primary function as an ocean sports facility. With the exception of the building’s main entrance, the height of the proposed building has intentionally been kept below the line of the existing sea wall parapet to preserve views from Oriental Parade across to Wellington City. A transparent entrance to the complex and inclusion of a public viewing platform extend from the Oriental Parade promenade allowing people to engage with the harbour edge and the city beyond, as well as creating greater public awareness of the sporting facilities that are available. A sense of human scale is achieved by treating the building as a series of primary and secondary elements which are readily understood and can be recognised as representing the building’s function. Scale is further moderated by secondary facade elements including screens, fins and frame elements, together with the use of texture and colour. The two historic Coene sheds have been integrated into the design as part of a cohesive overall form. Articulation of the building’s façade in three dimensions creates strong and varied shadow lines that interrupt the perceived size and shape of the building envelope and act to reduce its visual scale. Articulation of the building facade has been balanced with providing maximum exposure to sun, natural light, and ventilation to all areas of the building. Extensive glazing provides good visual connection between public spaces and the building interiors and the proposed boardwalks and decks will also help to activate the building’s edge. The site plays an important role in the fabric of its immediate and wider context. The mixed use nature of the building, with public spaces and sporting facilities will contribute to the richness, diversity and character of Wellington’s waterfront. While appropriately acknowledging the character of the area the proposal helps to establish a new architectural language that maintains a connection with its surrounding context but also sets a framework for the future. Page | 22 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 5.5 Digital model images15 15 For additional digital model images see Novak+Middleton, 2014. ‘Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Preliminary Designs’. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 23 novak+middleton Figures14-19: Digital Model Design Images Page | 24 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 5.6 Appearance from the water and the board walk16 Figures 20-21: Rendered Design Images 16 For additional elevations and floor plan images see Novak+Middleton 2014. ‘Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Preliminary Designs’. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 25 novak+middleton 6. Outline Specification 6.0 Introduction This project involves the construction of a new purpose built two level building together with the restoration and refurbishment of two existing historic boatsheds (Coene sheds). The building site is located on the seaward side of Oriental Parade and adjacent to the Freyberg Pool and consists of a single level timber building in poor condition, two adjacent boatsheds (Coene sheds) which have been recognised as having historic merit, also in poor condition, and the boat harbour slipway which is now disused. The site is subject to flooding in certain weather and sea conditions. The new building and restored boatsheds will house all functional aspects of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre including administration spaces, teaching spaces, toilet and changing facilities, workshop, and storage for equipment. It is proposed to include a new public entrance to the building from Oriental Parade that will assist in raising the Centre’s public profile and also provide disabled access. The proposed building includes a public viewing deck accessed from Oriental Parade that will allow the general public to engage with the boat harbour and view across to Wellington City. Note: The adjacent boardwalk and marina piers shown on the attached drawings are not part of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre project. This outline specification is divided into the following sections and should be read in conjunction with the Preliminary Design drawings prepared by Novak+Middleton dated 20th March 2014. 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 Site preparation and demolition Foundations and structure External cladding and finishes Internal linings and finishes Services Provisional sums Exclusions 6.1 Site preparation and demolition 6.1.1 General 1.1.1 1.1.2 Remove the existing single level timber building adjacent to the Freyberg Pool. Remove existing roof structure to the two Coene sheds including rafters and supporting beams and associated posts. Separate the wall structure of the Coene sheds from their existing concrete foundations and prepare for lifting to new position. Remove small annex structures to each end of Coene sheds adjacent to slipway. Remove slipway cradle and all associated structure in preparation for new building between Coene sheds. Remove timber boardwalk section to existing slipway. Remove floating timber jetty immediately in front of the existing Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. Remove existing piles in immediate location of new building. 1.1.3 1.1.4 1.1.5 1.1.6 1.1.7 Page | 26 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 1.1.8 1.1.9 Excavate existing concrete hardstand area to accommodate footings and foundations for the new Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building adjacent to Freyberg Pool and infill building between the Coene sheds. Excavate existing concrete hardstand area to accommodate new footings and foundations for the raised Coene sheds. 6.2 Foundations and structure 6.2.1 Floors 2.1.1 Construct a 100mm thick, SE72 mesh reinforced concrete slab on driven H6 timber piles with concrete block perimeter footing, on 60mm polystyrene insulation, DPM, sand blinding and hardfill to new building areas and Coene sheds, float finished. Finished slab height to be on average 350mm above existing hardstand level at the outer edge. Provide set-downs in slab edges for all external joinery, and floor/shower wastes. Form drainage channel with falls to slab in area between new rear wall and existing brick seawall (refer 2.2.1 below). Construct the level 2 entry lobby floor with ex 250x50mm H1.2 timber floor joists at 400mm ctrs. Refer below for additional steel structure. Lay 18mm plywood over floor joists. Construct a suspended concrete slab between the existing sea wall to Oriental Parade and the edge of the new building at level 2 (Grid 2) between Grids J & L. Typically a traydeck floor or similar. Allow to fully waterproof. Construct deck structure to level 2 viewing platform from ex 200x50mm H3.2 joists at 400mm ctrs. Refer below for additional steel structure to perimeter. 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.1.4 6.2.2 Walls 2.2.1 Construct new precast concrete wall to rear (Grid1), adjacent to existing brick seawall, along complete length of building. Note: wall varies in height along length. Allow to apply torch-on waterproofing system to back face of wall to be integrated with slab DPM. Construct new precast concrete wall adjacent to the Freyberg Pool (Grid N). Allow to apply torch-on waterproofing system to back face of wall to be integrated with slab DPM. Construct new precast concrete wall to west wall of level 2 entry lobby and level 1 lobby adjacent to existing Coene shed wall (Grid J). Exposed concrete finish to interior surface. Construct all new exterior and interior walls with ex 150x50mm H3.2 timber framing at 400mm ctrs unless otherwise noted. Construct all new Parapet wall upstands to Coene sheds with ex 150x50mm H3.2 timber framing at 400mm ctrs unless otherwise noted. Construct three fin walls to support the suspended concrete slab (refer 2.1.3 above) between the existing sea wall to Oriental Parade and the edge of the new building at level 2 (Grids J, K & L) from 200mm reinforced concrete block. Construct four precast concrete columns to front façade of new building (Grid 4 – K, L, M, & N). 2.2.2 2.2.1 2.2.3 2.2.4 2.2.5 2.2.6 6.2.3 Roof 2.3.1 Allow to construct new low pitched roof structure to the two existing Coene sheds from 18mm H3.2 treated plywood on ex 100mm H3.2 firing over ex 250x50mm H3.2 treated rafters at 400mm ctrs. Allow to create fall to front and rear edges. Form plywood lined internal gutter along front edge of roof. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 27 novak+middleton 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.3.5 2.3.6 2.3.7 2.3.8 Allow to construct lowered low pitched roof structure between Coene sheds and existing brick seawall (between Grids 1 & 2) from 18mm H3.2 treated plywood on ex 100mm H3.2 firing over ex 200x50mm H3.2 treated rafters at 400mm ctrs. Allow to create falls to end of each Coene shed. Allow to construct new low pitched roof structure over new changing area (between Coene sheds) from 18mm H3.2 treated plywood on ex 100mm H3.2 firing over ex 200x50mm H3.2 treated rafters at 400mm ctrs. Allow to fall to front edge. Form plywood lined internal gutter along front edge of roof. Note: underside of rafters set at RL 3.95 Construct boxed skylight to roof area between Grids D & F over corridor behind the changing area. Generally powdercoated aluminium glazing bars at 600mm ctrs on timber box frame, double glazed. Allow to construct new low pitched roof structure to the new building between the Freyberg Pool and Coene sheds from 18mm H3.2 treated plywood on ex 100mm H3.2 firing over ex 250x50mm H3.2 treated rafters at 400mm ctrs. Allow to create fall to front edge. Form plywood lined internal gutter along front edge of roof. Note: Roof runs under proposed level 2 entry/viewing deck (between Grids K & L). Allow to construct new low pitched roof structure to the level 2 entry pod from 18mm H3.2 treated plywood on ex 50mm H3.2 firing over ex 200x50mm H3.2 treated Hyspan rafters at 400mm ctrs. Allow to create fall to all edges. Form plywood lined internal gutter along all edges of roof. Allow to construct the external pergola structure to level 1. Generally 250x50 glulam rafters in the north-south direction on 250x75 glulam beam in the east-west direction supported on 300x100 glulam posts on concrete footing (below finished deck level). All painted. Allow for copper soakers to all exposed ends to rafters, beams and posts. Allow to run the rafters across the new roof to the changing area (between the Coene sheds). Allow to construct the external pergola structure to level 2. Generally 200x50 glulam rafters in the north-south direction on 200x75 glulam beams in the east-west direction supported on 300x100 glulam posts. All painted. Allow for copper soakers to all exposed ends to rafters, beams and posts. 6.2.4 Steelwork 2.4.1 2.4.2 All internal steel work to be hot dip galvanised, prior to being erected on site. Provide and install two 250UB steel beams in the east-west direction to the west Coene shed roof structure equally spaced between Grids 1 & 4. Rafters cut between steel beams. Provide and install a 250UB steel beam in the east-west direction to the east Coene shed roof structure equally spaced between wall to bathroom area and Grid 4. Rafters cut between steel beams. Provide and install a 310UB steel beam in the north-south direction between the two classroom spaces above the operable door. Insert two 250UB steel beams in the eastwest direction above each classroom equally spaced between Grids 1 & 4. Rafters cut between steel beams. Allow to trim two void spaces above level 1 foyer space with 200PFC steel channel to long direction edges. Provide and install a 250UB steel beam in the east-west direction on Grid 2 between Grid D & K. Allow for 89x89mm steel SHS posts to steel beams identified above. Allow for a 200PFC steel channel ring beam to four edges of level 2 entry foyer roof. Allow for 89x89mm steel SHS posts to four corners of ring beam and centrally on Grids J & K. Rafters in same line as steel ring beam. Allow for a 250PFC steel lintel on Grid 4 between Grids K & N. 2.4.3 2.4.4 2.4.5 2.4.6 2.4.7 2.4.8 2.4.9 Page | 28 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 6.3 External cladding and finishes 6.3.1 Walls 3.1.1 3.1.6 Existing bevel back weatherboard to Coene sheds to remain where exposed externally. Allow to strip all existing paintwork and repaint. Supply and install bevel back weatherboards to match existing to exterior of extended walls of Coene sheds forming parapets. Painted. Line new external wall to changing rooms with corten steel panels on stainless steel brackets on Butynol on plywood on a cavity system. Allow for all external concrete walls to be finished with STO plaster system. All concrete foundation walls to be finished with STO plaster system over the insitu concrete. Allow for R2.8 fibreglass insulation to all wall cavities, including Coene sheds. 6.3.2 Exterior window and door joinery 3.2.1 All exterior window and door joinery to be powdercoated aluminium APL Architectural Series unless noted below. Allow for associated flashings to be powder coated aluminium. All glass to be double glazed units, with one pane of the glass being laminated. Allow to remove existing window joinery and sliding door joinery from Coene sheds refurbish, repaint, and reinstall. 3.1.2 3.1.3 3.1.4 3.1.5 3.2.2 3.2.3 6.3.3 Roofing 3.3.1 3.3.3 3.3.4 3.3.5 Allow to clad all roof areas with Ardex Shelterbit torch-on system (or similar) on 18mm H3.2 CCA treated ply substrate, all on treated firing and rafters as above. Allow to dress membrane into gutter on all external edges. Supply and install powdercoated aluminium glazing bars at 600mm centres on upstand to gallery skylight (between Grids D & F). Allow for double glazed units and all flashings. All roof flashings to be powder coated aluminium. All spouting and downpipes to be powder coated aluminium. Allow for heavy duty building paper and R3.6 fibreglass insulation to all roof cavities. 6.3.4 Decking 3.4.1 Level 2 decking to be ex 100x25 hardwood decking over timber framed structure (refer above). Allow for ex25mm solid hardwood timber facing board to vertical edges and ex 50x50 battens with a 10mm gap to line underside of joists. Allow for cantilevered frameless glass balustrade to front edge of deck structure with ex 150x50mm hardwood handrail to top edge. 3.3.2 3.4.2 6. 4 Internal linings and finishes 6.4.1 Flooring 4.1.1 Install ex 100x25mm solid hardwood timber floor boards to level 2 entry foyer. Clear finished. Allow to polish the concrete floor slab to Level 1 foyer and gallery. Clear sealer finish. Concrete floors to west Coene shed and workshop to be left float finish with clear sealer. Supply and install stainless steel trays to showers in changing areas and instructors changing. 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.1.4 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 29 novak+middleton 4.1.5 4.1.6 Supply and lay 100% wool carpet on underlay to the office area and two classrooms. Supply and lay 2mm vinyl flooring to changing rooms, toilet area and instructors changing. Allow to cove up walls 100mm. 6.4.2 Walls 4.2.1 Allow to strap all concrete walls with ex75x50mm strapping unless noted below. Install 13mm gib board, flush stopped to level 4 finish. To all other timber walls install 13mm gib board, flush stopped to level 4 finish unless otherwise noted. Allow for 30% of walls to have level 5 finish. Allow to paint all gib lined walls. Line walls in changing areas, toilets and instructors changing with 13mm Aqualine gib, flush stopped to level 4 and paint finished. Allow to supply and install proprietary toilet and shower partitions to showers and toilets. All gib wall / ceiling junctions to be square stopped (no scotias). Allow for 100x12mm pine clears skirting boards, paint finish, to be installed to all gib board walls. West wall of entry lobby and level 1 foyer to remain concrete finish, clear sealed. Allow to line all internal walls of west Coene shed and workshop with 12mm plywood, clear polyurethane finish. Allow to line rear wall of gallery (behind gear lockers, storage, and kitchenette) with 12mm plywood, clear polyurethane finish. Provide R2.8 fibreglass insulation to all external wall cavities and to all strapping to concrete walls. 4.2.2 4.3.3 4.2.4 4.2.5 4.2.6 4.2.7 4.2.8 4.2.9 6.4.3 Ceilings 4.3.1 4.3.4 Line all ceilings unless noted below with 13mm Ultraline gib on Rondo metal ceiling steel battens, flush stopped to level 5 and paint finished. Allow for expansion joints as required. Allow to line ceilings of west Coene shed and workshop with 12mm plywood, clear polyurethane finish. Line ceilings in changing areas, toilets and instructors changing with 13mm Aqualine gib, flush stopped to level 5 and paint finished. Install R3.6 fibreglass insulation to all ceiling cavities under roofs. 6.4.4 Windows and doors 4.4.1 4.4.5 All interior doors to be 2400mm high flush hollow core leaves in paint quality frames. Allow to dress the gib board wall linings into door rebate, no architraves. Allow to install powdercoated aluminium glazing system to internal classroom wall, including glazed double doors. Double glazed. Allow to install powdercoated aluminium glazing system between level 1 foyer and office, including glazed door. Double glazed. All interior cupboard doors, to be painted hollow core leaves in paint quality frames to suit openings (refer sections). Allow for ex100x25mm pine clears architraves, painted. Allow for all hardware including handles, latch sets, privacy bolts etc. 6.4.5 Miscellaneous 4.5.1 Allow to construct hanging spaces to gear locker area using 18mm plywood divisions, clear finished. Allow for two hooks per bay. 4.5.2 Construct hardwood timber seating on galvanised steel brackets to gear locker area. Clear finished. Construct hardwood timber seating on galvanised steel brackets to changing areas and instructor changing. Clear finished. 4.3.2 4.3.3 4.4.2 4.4.3 4.4.4 4.5.3 Page | 30 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 4.5.4 4.5.5 4.5.6 4.5.7 4.5.8 Stair to be solid timber treads and risers with concealed stringers. Timber species and finish to match timber flooring. Frame and line under stair for storage cupboard. Allow for stainless steel anti slip bar rebated to front edge of each tread. Allow for a frameless glass balustrade on proprietary fixings to level 2 entry foyer north void. Allow for ex50x50mm hardwood timber battens at 100mm centres to form balustrade to level 2 entry foyer south void. Note; battens extend 300mm below level 1 ceiling. Clear finished. Allow to supply and install person lift between level 2 entry and level 1 foyer. Supply and install joinery unit to kitchenette area. Generally stainless steel bench with Meltica cabinetry below and overhead cupboards. Allow for sink and tap. 6.5 Services Allow to disconnect all existing services to the site prior to demolition work. Allow to reinstate and reconnect all new work to existing services. Services include sewer, stormwater, power, water, and phone. 6.5.1 Electrical and communications 5.1.1 Allow for 3 phase power. Power supply to distribution board located in storage cupboard adjacent to Grid J. Allow to reticulate power to all areas, including exterior, for power supply and lighting. Provide phone wiring, including internet, to office and classroom areas. Refer provisional sums for allowance for light fitting supply. Allow for installation. Refer provisional sums for allowance for security system. Allow to install smoke alarms throughout. Allow to install all kitchenette appliances. Refer to provisional sums for supply allowance. 5.1.2 5.1.3 5.1.4 5.1.5 5.1.6 5.1.7 6.5.2 Plumbing and drainage 5.2.1 5.2.2 5.2.5 5.2.6 Distribute water to all areas as required, including x4 outdoor hose taps. Supply and install two large electric hot water cylinders, to be located in two service ducts between changing rooms and toilet areas. Allow to connect new fittings to the hot water system. Allow to install pump system for all sewer waste to sewer main in Oriental Parade. Allow to connect to all fixtures and fittings to sewer drainage system. Refer to provisional sums for the supply of plumbing fittings. Allow for installation. Install new stormwater reticulation to drain to boat harbour. Provide floor wastes to all bathroom areas and run to exterior. 6.5.3 Heating and ventilation 5.3.1 Allow to supply and install heat pump system to the following areas; classrooms, level 1 foyer, office, and changing. Refer to provisional sums for the supply and installation. Allow to install extract ventilation to changing, instructor changing and toilet areas. 5.2.3 5.2.4 5.3.2 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 31 novak+middleton 6.6 Provisional sums Allow to supply and install the following joinery items, fixtures, fittings and appliances. The following sums are for supply only unless otherwise noted. 6.6.1 Joinery and fittings Kitchenette appliances (dishwasher, microwave) Kitchenette joinery (incl. sink, mixer and handles) Toilet vanity joinery Toilet fittings Instructors changing fittings Changing fittings Mirrors 6.6.2 $1,800.00 $3,000.00 $1,000.00 $2,500.00 $1,300.00 $3,600.00 $1,000.00 General Light fittings Security system Miscellaneous hardware Recessed blinds to classrooms (automated) Heat pump heating system (supply and installation) $15,000.00 $2,500.00 $5,000.00 $10,000.00 $15,000.00 6.7 Exclusions The following items are excluded from the estimate: • • • • • • • • All decking and boardwalk areas to level 1. Goods and services tax. Professional fees. Local authority fees. Project contingency sum. Insurance. All furniture. Window treatments (blinds, curtains, etc unless noted in section 6.0 above). Page | 32 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 7. Capital Costs 7.0 Introduction This preliminary estimate is for the new purpose built two level building together with the restoration and refurbishment of two existing historic boatsheds, 115 Oriental Parade, Wellington. The preliminary estaimate has been completed by Rider Levett Bucknall Wellingotn Ltd. 7.1 Summary The total construction cost estimate exclusive of GST is: New Building Works Boatshed Restoration & Refurbishment Works Main Contractors P&G and Margin Costs ESTIMATE TOTAL (excl. GST) $625,000 $735,000 $170,000 $1,530,000 The above estimated costs deal with the actual construction works involved in this project. These construction works will require the existing business premises to be completely vacated whilst the new building work and restoration works are undertaken and will therefore impose a loss of amenity on the premises. 7.2 Construction Cost Estimate Basis of Estimate This preliminary estimate is based on approximate quantities or historical data of similar projects, and priced at rates and prices current as at May 2014, and applicable to a commercial type building. The estimate is based upon the following information provided: Architectural Preliminary Design drawings dated 24 March 2014. Architectural Outline Specification dated 1 May 2014. Estimate Exclusions No allowance has been made for the following: Design & Construction Contingency. Professional Fees & Consent Costs. Furniture, Fittings & Equipment. Audio Visual Equipment. Level 1 Decking & Boardwalk. Voice & Data Equipment. Goods and Services Tax (GST). Contract Works Insurance. Legal Fees. Removal of Hazardous Materials. Consultant Fees or Council Consent Fees. Loss of Rental/Business Income during Construction Period. Cost of Decanting from Premises. Cost Fluctuations from May 2014. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 33 novak+middleton Estimate Summary GFA: Gross Floor Area Rates Current At May 2014 Location GFA m² Cost/m² Total Cost A NEW BUILDING WORKS 197.00 $3,173 $625,000.00 B BOATSHED RESTORATION & REFURBISHMENT WORKS 356.00 $2,065 $735,000.00 553 $2,459 $1,360,000.00 ESTIMATED NET COST MARGINS & ADJUSTMENTS Main Contractors Preliminary & General Costs Main Contractors Margin 8.10% $110,000.00 4.10% $60,000.00 Design Development Contingency Excl. ESTIMATED TENDER PRICE 553 $2,767 $1,530,000.00 Construction Contingency Excl. Professional Fees Excl. Consents Excl. FF&E Excl. Audio Visual Equipment Excl. ESTIMATED TOTAL BUDGET 553 $2,767 $1,530,000.00 Business Interruption Costs Excl. Decanting Costs Excl. Level 1 Decking & Boardwalk Excl. Voice & Data Equipment Excl. Goods & Services Tax (GST) Excl. Insurances Excl. Legal Fees Excl. Removal of Hazardous Materials Excl. Treatment of Contamination Excl. Unknown Underground Services Excl. Cost Fluctuations from May 2014 Excl. ESTIMATED TOTAL COST 553 Page | 34 $2,767 $1,530,000.00 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton Estimate Details A GFA: 197.0 m² Cost/m²: $3,173 Rates Current At May 2014 NEW BUILDING WORKS Description SP 1 Unit Qty Rate Total 157.00 $80.00 $12,560.00 Site Preparation m² 2 Demolish and remove existing single level timber framed building Demolish and remove existing stair Item $1,000.00 3 Remove existing floating timber jetty Item $1,500.00 4 Remove existing piles in location of new building Allowance for removal of existing hardstand as necessary for new footings and foundations Remove section of existing brick wall to Oriental Parade brick wall to provide access to new stairs Remove existing fittings, furnishings & equipment (EXCLUDED) Remove hazardous materials (EXCLUDED) Item $4,000.00 Item $1,000.00 Item $1,000.00 Item Excl. Item Excl. Remove unknown underground services (EXCLUDED) Site Preparation Item Excl. 5 6 7 8 9 SB 14 15 $21,060.00 $140.00 $27,580.00 Substructure Reinforced concrete slab, 100mm thick including thickenings, SE72 mesh, driven H6 piles, 60mm polystyrene insulation, DPM, sand blinding and hardfill Allowance for forming set downs m² 197.00 Item $1,500.00 Substructure FR $107/m² $148/m² $29,080.00 $365.00 $4,015.00 Frame 16 Precast concrete columns, 800mm x 200mm m 17 Allowance for steel structure support to upper floors and roof (hot dip galvanised) Allowance for secondary support steel to stair and lift (hot dip galvanised) Allowance for secondary support steel to operable wall (hot dip galvanised) Frame Item $24,000.00 Item $6,000.00 Item $3,500.00 18 19 SW 11.00 $190/m² $37,515.00 Structural Walls 21 Precast concrete to walls, 200mm thick m² 115.00 $340.00 $39,100.00 22 Reinforced concrete to fin walls, 200mm thick, reinforcing 200kg/m3 Structural Walls m² 10.00 $425.00 $4,250.00 $220/m² $43,350.00 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 35 novak+middleton UF Upper Floors 24 Reinforced concrete to suspended floor slab, 200mm thick 18mm Plywood floor over ex 250x50mm H1.2 floor joists at 400mm centres Extra value for forming steps in level changes in upper floors Upper Floors 25 26 m² 32.00 $180.00 $5,760.00 m² 92.00 $190.00 $17,480.00 No 2.00 $1,000.00 $2,000.00 $128/m² $25,240.00 141.00 $220.00 $31,020.00 m 9.00 $225.00 $2,025.00 RF Roof 29 m² 31 18mm Plywood on ex 100mm firing over ex 250x50mm rafters at 400mm centres 18mm Plywood to internal gutter, including framing 250x50 glulam rafter to pergola m 286.00 $40.00 $11,440.00 32 200x75 glulam beam to pergola m 88.00 $45.00 $3,960.00 33 300x100 glulam posts on concrete footing No 7.00 $750.00 $5,250.00 34 Torch-on waterproofing system to roof m² 141.00 $125.00 $17,625.00 35 Extra value for dressing down in to gutter m 9.00 $35.00 $315.00 36 Building paper and R3.6 fibreglass insulation to roof cavities Allowance for rainwater disposal system (assume run-off into marina) Roof m² 141.00 $20.00 $2,820.00 30 37 Item $4,000.00 $398/m² $78,455.00 EW Exterior Walls and Exterior Finish 41 Torch-on waterproofing system to walls m² 115.00 $120.00 $13,800.00 42 STO plaster system to exterior concrete walls and columns Exterior Walls and Exterior Finish m² 19.00 $60.00 $1,140.00 $76/m² $14,940.00 WW Windows and Exterior Doors 44 Powdercoated aluminium APL architectural series double glazing to exterior window and door joinery Extra value for double door units including hardware Windows and Exterior Doors 45 SC Stairs and Balustrades 49 Solid timber treads and risers to stair with concealed stringers including handrails Frameless glass balustrade with 150x50mm hardwood handrail ex 50mm x 50mm hardwood battens to form balustrade Stairs and Balustrades 50 51 PN Interior Walls 52 Strap and line concrete walls with single layer of 13mm Gib Standard including insulation, stopping to Level 4 and decoration complete Strap and line concrete walls with 12mm plywood including insulation and finishing 53 m² 99.00 $750.00 $74,250.00 No 3.00 $1,000.00 $3,000.00 $392/m² $77,250.00 3.00 $6,000.00 $18,000.00 m 32.00 $850.00 $27,200.00 m 6.00 $750.00 $4,500.00 $252/m² $49,700.00 M/R m² 56.00 $80.00 $4,480.00 m² 22.00 $90.00 $1,980.00 Page | 36 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 54 Standard interior partition walls m² 27.00 $160.00 $4,320.00 55 Glazed partition including manifestations m² 24.00 $275.00 $6,600.00 56 Extra value for Level 5 stopping to interior walls (assume 30% of walls) Sundry trim and sealants m² 33.00 $5.00 $165.00 57 Item $500.00 Interior Walls $92/m² $18,045.00 $22,000.00 DR Interior Doors 60 Operable wall 8.2m wide x 2.6m high No 1.00 61 Single interior door including frame and hardware complete Double interior door including frame and hardware complete Double interior cupboard door including frame and hardware complete Sundry hardware and grilles (SUM) No 1.00 $22,000.0 0 $1,200.00 No 1.00 $1,800.00 $1,800.00 No 7.00 $1,500.00 $10,500.00 62 63 64 Item $1,200.00 $1,500.00 Interior Doors $188/m² $37,000.00 FF Floor Finishes 67 Minor floor preparation m² 197.00 $5.00 $985.00 68 m² 76.00 $60.00 $4,560.00 69 Grind and polish concrete floor slab, sealer finished Carpet flooring m² 123.00 $70.00 $8,610.00 70 100x25mm solid hardwood timber floor m² 83.00 $200.00 $16,600.00 71 Waterproofing system to suspended concrete floor Sundry trim and threshold strips m² 32.00 $25.00 $800.00 72 Item $500.00 Floor Finishes WF Wall Finishes 74 Clear sealed finish to concrete walls m² 11.00 Wall Finishes CD Ceiling Finishes 77 Single layer of 13mm Gib Ultraline on Rondo metal ceiling battens including insulation, stopping to Level 5, decoration and trim ex 50x50mm battens fixed to underside of joists Bulkheads and access hatches 78 79 $163/m² $32,055.00 $20.00 $220.00 $1/m² $220.00 m² 179.00 $110.00 $19,690.00 m² 24.00 $140.00 $3,360.00 Item Ceiling Finishes $3,000.00 $132/m² $26,050.00 FT Fittings and Fixtures 81 Allowance for kitchenette joinery unit (SUM) Item $3,000.00 82 Whiteboards & chalkboards (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. 83 Allowance for miscellaneous hardware (SUM) Kitchenette appliances (SUM) Item $5,000.00 Item $1,800.00 84 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 37 novak+middleton 85 Automated recessed blinds to classrooms (SUM) Fittings and Fixtures PB Sanitary Plumbing 86 Kitchenette plumbing Item $10,000.00 $101/m² Item $4,000.00 Sanitary Plumbing $20/m² HV Heating and Ventilation Services 88 Allowance for heat pump heating system (SUM) Kitchenette extract system (SUM) 89 $19,800.00 $4,000.00 Item $15,000.00 Item $2,000.00 Heating and Ventilation Services $86/m² $17,000.00 $35.00 $6,895.00 FS Fire Services 92 Allowance for smoke detection system m² 93 Allowance for sprinkler installation (EXCLUDED) Provision of fire extinguishers (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. Item Excl. 94 197.00 Fire Services $35/m² $6,895.00 EL Electrical Services 95 Item 97 Distribution board for 3-phase and single phase power and associated mains distribution cabling General power reticulation and outlets m² 197.00 $35.00 $6,895.00 98 Lighting cabling and installation of lights m² 197.00 $25.00 $4,925.00 99 Lighting supply (SUM) Item $7,500.00 100 Emergency lighting (SUM) Item $2,000.00 101 New transformer (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. $7,500.00 Electrical Services $146/m² LS Vertical and Horizontal Transportation 103 New passenger lift including surround and support structure Vertical and Horizontal Transportation Item $28,820.00 $40,000.00 $203/m² $40,000.00 $20.00 $3,940.00 SS Special Services 105 Voice and data cabling m² 106 Voice and data equipment (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. 107 MATV installation (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. 108 Security system installation (SUM) Item $2,500.00 197.00 Special Services DG Drainage 109 Drainage channel to slab between new wall and existing brick seawall Drainage Page | 38 m 19.00 $33/m² $6,440.00 $550.00 $10,450.00 $53/m² $10,450.00 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton SU Sundries 111 Builders work for services Item $3,000.00 112 Signage Item $1,000.00 113 Rounding Item -$2,365.00 Sundries $8/m² FE F.F. & E. 114 Furniture, fittings & equipment (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. F.F. & E. Excl. NEW BUILDING WORKS Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study $1,635.00 $3,173/m² Page | 39 $625,000.00 novak+middleton Estimate Details B BOATSHED RESTORATION & REFURBISHMENT WORKS Description GFA: 356.0 m² Cost/m²: $2,065 Rates Current At May 2014 Unit Qty Rate Total m² 286.00 $15.00 $4,290.00 No 2.00 $4,000.00 $8,000.00 No 2.00 $15,000.00 $30,000.00 No 2.00 $10,000.00 $20,000.00 No 2.00 $10,000.00 $20,000.00 Site Preparation SP 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 Demolish and remove the existing roof structure to the Coene sheds including rafters, supporting beams and associated posts Separate the wall structure of the Coene sheds from the existing foundations Allowance to prepare shed for temporary relocation including all necessary structural support for lifting Allowance temporarily relocate Coene sheds Allowance to move Coene sheds from temporary to permanent location Remove small annex structures to each end of the Coene sheds Remove slipway cradle and all associated structure in preparation for new building, including timber boardwalk section to existing slipway Remove existing fittings, furnishings & equipment (EXCLUDED) Remove hazardous materials (EXCLUDED) Remove unknown underground services (EXCLUDED) Site Preparation SB Substructure 139 Reinforced concrete slab, 100mm thick including thickenings, SE72 mesh, driven H6 piles, 60mm polystyrene insulation, DPM, sand blinding and hardfill Allowance for forming set downs 140 Item $3,000.00 Item $4,000.00 Item Excl. Item Excl. Item Excl. m² 356.00 Frame 142 Allowance for steel structure support to upper floors and roof (hot dip galvanised) Allowance to connect existing shed exterior walls to new foundation structure Frame 145 SW Structural Walls 146 Precast concrete to walls, 200mm thick Structural Walls Page | 40 $89,290.00 $140.00 $49,840.00 Item $2,000.00 Substructure FR $251/m² $146/m² $51,840.00 Item $14,000.00 Item $6,000.00 m² 99.00 $56/m² $20,000.00 $340.00 $33,660.00 $95/m² $33,660.00 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton RF Roof 154 156 18mm Plywood on ex 100mm firing over ex 250x50mm rafters at 400mm centres 18mm Plywood to internal gutter, including framing 250x50 glulam rafter to pergola 157 200x75 glulam beam to pergola 158 m² 349.00 $220.00 $76,780.00 m 33.00 $225.00 $7,425.00 m 286.00 $40.00 $11,440.00 m 33.00 $45.00 $1,485.00 300x100 glulam posts on concrete footing No 8.00 $750.00 $6,000.00 159 Torch-on waterproofing system to roof m² 349.00 $125.00 $43,625.00 160 Extra value for dressing down in to gutter m 33.00 $35.00 $1,155.00 161 Building paper and R3.6 fibreglass insulation to roof cavities Allowance for rainwater system (assume runoff into marina) Aluminium framed double glazed skylight unit m² 349.00 $20.00 $6,980.00 155 162 163 Item m² $4,000.00 9.00 Roof $1,200.00 $10,800.00 $477/m² $169,690.00 EW Exterior Walls and Exterior Finish 164 Torch-on waterproofing system to walls m² 99.00 $120.00 $11,880.00 165 STO plaster system to exterior concrete walls and columns New timber framed exterior wall with Corten steel panels on stainless steel brackets on butynol on plywood on a cavity system Strip back existing weatherboard to Coene sheds, repair and redecorate New timber framed parapet walls with weatherboard cladding Exterior Walls and Exterior Finish m² 17.00 $60.00 $1,020.00 m² 19.00 $475.00 $9,025.00 m² 103.00 $75.00 $7,725.00 m² 48.00 $325.00 $15,600.00 $127/m² $45,250.00 166 167 168 WW Windows and Exterior Doors 169 Powdercoated aluminium APL architectural series double glazing to exterior circular windows joinery Remove existing window joinery and allow to refurbish, repaint and reinstall Remove existing door joinery and allow to refurbish, repaint and reinstall Allowance for sundry window and exterior door hardware (SUM) Windows and Exterior Doors 170 171 172 PN Interior Walls 175 Line interior walls with single layer of 13mm Gib Standard including insulation, stopping to Level 4 and decoration complete Line interior walls with single layer of 13mm Gib Aqualine including insulation, stopping to Level 4 and decoration complete Line interior walls with 12mm plywood including insulation and finishing 176 177 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 41 No 4.00 $1,500.00 $6,000.00 No 4.00 $750.00 $3,000.00 No 2.00 $1,800.00 $3,600.00 Item $8,000.00 $58/m² $20,600.00 m² 127.00 $80.00 $10,160.00 m² 253.00 $85.00 $21,505.00 m² 159.00 $90.00 $14,310.00 novak+middleton 178 Timber framing to new interior partitions m² 168.00 $65.00 $10,920.00 180 m² 114.00 $5.00 $570.00 181 Extra value for Level 5 stopping to interior walls (assume 30% of walls) Proprietary bathroom partitions No 6.00 $1,800.00 $10,800.00 182 Allowance for changing screen No 2.00 $900.00 $1,800.00 183 Sundry trim and sealants Item $1,500.00 Interior Walls DR Interior Doors 185 Single interior door including frame and hardware complete Sundry hardware and grilles (SUM) 188 No 8.00 $201/m² $71,565.00 $1,200.00 $9,600.00 Item $1,000.00 Interior Doors $30/m² $10,600.00 FF Floor Finishes 191 Minor floor preparation m² 356.00 $5.00 $1,780.00 192 Clear sealer finish to concrete floors m² 177.00 $15.00 $2,655.00 193 Grind and polish concrete floors, sealer finish m² 24.00 $60.00 $1,440.00 194 Vinyl flooring including coving m² 125.00 $80.00 $10,000.00 195 Sundry trim and threshold strips Item $500.00 Floor Finishes CD Ceiling Finishes 201 203 Single layer of 13mm Gib Ultraline on Rondo metal ceiling battens including insulation, stopping to Level 5, decoration and trim Single layer of 13mm Gib Aqualine on Rondo metal ceiling battens including insulation, stopping to Level 5, decoration and trim 12mm Plywood, clear polyurethane finish 204 Bulkheads and access hatches 202 $16,375.00 m² 50.00 $110.00 $5,500.00 m² 125.00 $110.00 $13,750.00 m² 34.00 $65.00 $2,210.00 Item $3,000.00 Ceiling Finishes $69/m² FT Fittings and Fixtures 205 Allowance for gear lockers 206 Allowance for hardwood timber seating 207 Allowance for toilet vanity joinery & fittings (SUM) Allowance for Instructors changing, changing fittings & mirrors (SUM) Fittings and Fixtures 208 $46/m² Item Page | 42 m $24,460.00 $8,000.00 45.00 $400.00 $18,000.00 Item $3,500.00 Item $5,900.00 $99/m² $35,400.00 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton PB Sanitary Plumbing 209 210 Allowance for sanitary waste pumping system and associated pipework WC suite including pipework complete 211 212 Item $6,000.00 No 6.00 $2,200.00 $13,200.00 WHB including pipework complete No 5.00 $2,500.00 $12,500.00 Shower including enclosure complete No 5.00 $4,000.00 $20,000.00 $145/m² $51,700.00 Sanitary Plumbing HV Heating and Ventilation Services 213 Allowance for heat pump heating system (SUM) Bathroom and changing extract system (SUM) Heating and Ventilation Services 214 FS Fire Services 216 Allowance for smoke detection system 217 Allowance for sprinkler installation (EXCLUDED) Provision of fire extinguishers (EXCLUDED) 218 Item $10,000.00 Item $8,000.00 m² 356.00 $51/m² $18,000.00 $35.00 $12,460.00 Item Excl. Item Excl. Fire Services $35/m² $12,460.00 EL Electrical Services 219 221 Distribution board for 3-phase and single phase power and associated mains distribution cabling (INCLUDED - Refer Section A, New Building Works) General power reticulation and outlets 222 Lighting cabling and installation of lights 223 Lighting supply (SUM) Item $7,500.00 224 Emergency lighting (SUM) Item $2,500.00 225 New transformer (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. Item Excl. m² 356.00 $35.00 $12,460.00 m² 356.00 $25.00 $8,900.00 Electrical Services $88/m² $31,360.00 $20.00 $7,120.00 SS Special Services 229 Voice and data cabling 230 Voice and data equipment (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. 231 MATV installation (EXCLUDED) Item Excl. 232 Security system installation (INCLUDED Refer Item A, New Building Works) Special Services Item Incl. m² DG Drainage 233 Drainage channel to slab between new wall and existing brick seawall Drainage Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 43 m 356.00 33.00 $20/m² $7,120.00 $550.00 $18,150.00 $51/m² $18,150.00 novak+middleton SU Sundries 235 Builders work for services Item $6,000.00 236 Signage Item $1,000.00 237 Rounding Item $480.00 Sundries $21/m² FE F.F. & E. 238 Furniture, fittings & equipment (EXCLUDED) Item $7,480.00 Excl. F.F. & E. Excl. BOATSHED RESTORATION & REFURBISHMENT WORKS $2,065/m² Page | 44 $735,000.00 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 8. Staging Plan 8.0 Introduction The staging plan for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre cannot be seen in isolation from the staging plan for the overall Clyde Quay Marina upgrade. This feasibility report is primarily concerned with the development of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building, which would ideally be constructed in parallel with the canoe, kayak and sup ramp, the youth scheme yacht berths, the learn to sail yacht berths and the waka ama storage and launching pontoon. Therefore, in considering a staging plan for the building itself it is necessary to also look at how the overall Clyde Quay Marina upgrade could be staged. 8.1 Possible stages for building the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre The building is a relatively straight forward project. It can be constructed independently of the overall Clyde Quay Marina Upgrade although the promenade in from of the building and along the Western edge of the Freyberg Pool will need to be completed at the same time as the construction of the Centre The most complicating factor in the build process is associated with the need to keep the heritage Coene sheds intact while at the same time raising the height of the structure to address predicted sea level change. To achieve this the existing Sailing Academy building will first be demolished and the Coene sheds will be moved to the location where the Sailing Academy stood. The foundations and slabs for the Coene shed will be established at their new level before the sheds are put back in place and refurbished to their new configurations. At the same time as the refurbishment of the Coene sheds is underway the new parts of the building will be constructed including the classrooms, lobby space, changing rooms and entrance deck. It is envisaged that the ocean sports berths ramps and pontoons will be installed at the same time as the building is constructed. The promenades and decking connecting the ramps and berths to the Centre and completing the link to Freyberg beach will be constructed once the building foundation work and framing is completed. 8.2 Possible stages for upgrading the Clyde Quay Marina The Clyde Quay Marina upgrade includes the following elements Wave mitigation system Wellington Ocean Sports Centre ramps and berths Pile moorings Public promenades and decks Walk on marina berths Breakwater capping to address 50 year sea level rise predictions The ideal solution would be to complete all of the Marina elements in a continuous process. Annual planning processes, however, might mean a staged approach is required for the installation process therefore the following staging plan documents how this might best be achieved from the perspective of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 45 novak+middleton 8.2.1 Stage 1: Wave mitigation and Wellington Ocean Sports ramps and berths Before any new structures are added to the Clyde Quay Marina it is important to install the wave mitigation system at the harbour entrance in order to dampen the wind driven waves that enter the harbour. At the same stage as this is installed it would be possible to install the ocean sports ramps and berths along with the promenade and public deck space in this corner of the precinct. At the same time the construction of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre building could commence (see section 8.1 for the staging plan for the building). Figure 22: Clyde Quay Marina upgrade stage 1 8.2.2 Stage 2: Marina berths and pile moorings The marina berths and pile moorings could be the second set of elements to be installed or they could be installed at the same time as the Centre berths and ramps. It is beyond the scope of this feasibility report to suggest how this might be scheduled, however from a Wellington Ocean Sports Centre perspective it is not necessary for the marina berths and moorings to be installed at the same time as the centre berths and ramps are installed. For instance, it could be that the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre buildings, ramps and berths are in place well ahead of the new marina berths and moorings. It is likely that funding will be the major determinant of whether the elements are installed in tandem or independently. Figure 23: Clyde Quay Marina upgrade stage 2 Page | 46 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 9. Constitution, Governance and Management Plan 9.0 Introduction Before embarking on the Wellington Ocean Sports active communities project, Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club and the Wellington City Council invited Peter Burley 17 to talk to the prospective partner sports about the critical success factors involved in a successful sports partnership. In summarising Burley’s evaluation of high performing sport partnerships, Sport New Zealand identifies the critical success factors of an effective sports partnership as: Good governance: Sports club partnerships are complex arrangements that must satisfy multiple stakeholders. They require enlightened leadership and a clear separation of governance and sport delivery functions. Clarity of purpose: The value proposition must be clear, simple, and compelling. The benefits of the partnership must be articulated in ways that everyone can understand. Formal amalgamations are not always necessary: A new entity need not replace existing clubs but instead can umbrella constituent members. Clustering of resources: The close physical proximity of facilities (fields, courts, changing rooms, café etc) is important in the same way the kitchen is central to a home. Staged progression: Building trust is essential as organisations feel their way toward new relationships. The influence of a respected “project champion” is critical, even where there are willing parties and conditions are favourable. Council support: Partnerships appear to have a greater chance of success if local authorities have supportive policies and are prepared to invest 18. With the benefit of hindsight gained from three years of running the Wellington Ocean Sports active communities project it is now even clearer that these success factors were present in the first three years of the partnership and that they will continue to be important in the next phase of the Programme. A steering group was established to oversee the active communities project with ultimate governance responsibility in the hands of the Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club. This model served the project well as the Programme was developed but is not the ideal structure for the future. The prospect of a new Centre provides the catalyst to formalise a governance structure that will help ensure a successful partnership between the sports as the Programme enters its next phase. The following recommendations about the proposed constitutional, governance and management structures for the Centre are drawn from the experience gained during the active communities project as well as from the experience of other Sportsville projects throughout New Zealand. 9.1 Constitution It is recommended that an incorporated society be established as the legal entity with overall responsibility for the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. The focus of the society should be on collaboration, not amalgamation, with each club retaining its history and identity, and with the parameters of the relationship recorded in the society’s constitution. The constitution should assert that the society aims to be beneficial to the community through managing, maintaining, 17 Burley P 2008. ‘SPARC Sport Partnership Project: A review of eight high profile sport club partnerships’. 18 See http://sportnz.org.nz keywords: Sportsville model review. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 47 novak+middleton administering and operating for recreation and other leisure-time activity the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre on behalf of, and for the benefit, of members of the society and the wider community. Furthermore the constitution should assert that the society seeks to arrange and manage the development of Wellington Ocean Sports Centre and seek out and obtain funding and other resources and apply such funding and resources to promote sporting, recreation and community activities that advance the purposes of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. It is important to plan for who will own the assets of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre once complete and to document how Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club in particular will be compensated for the assets it relinquishes in the process of establishing the Centre. Currently the building site for the Centre is on Council owned land. The two Coene sheds and the slipway space are Council owned but rented by Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club. The Sailing Academy building, which is proposed to be demolished to make way for the new classroom spaces, is owned by Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club. The Council owns the promenade space in front of the existing sheds and Sailing Academy building. The Council holds a Wellington Regional Council coastal permit for the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour. Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club owns the existing floating berths in front of the Sailing Academy building. 9.2 Governance It is recommended that an independent board be established to govern the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre. The sports have developed a clear and concise purpose for the Wellington Ocean Sports programme as being a mechanism for Wellingtonians to ‘discover’, ‘experience’ and ‘learn’ ocean sports with the clubs themselves being the vehicle for ongoing participation in ocean sports activities. In developing the future governance structure for the Centre it is important to make sure a clear focus on this purpose is maintained over and above simply the development of the Centre and its operation. The ongoing support of Council as one of the partners alongside the sports in the Programme is critical to the ongoing success of both the Programme and the Centre. In establishing a governance board it is important to avoid the temptation to simply appoint representatives from each of the partners. As Burley points out “sport specific expertise is neither essential nor desirable in the governance board, but is important at the next level down”19. He goes on to state that sport partnerships should avoid the idea of ex-officio board positions, where a board might carry ‘passengers’ who are required to be present to oversee or keep an eye on things for external stakeholders. All board positions therefore need to carry skill sets that maximise the quality of board decision making, strategic planning and other important areas necessary to run the Centre and its Programme for the greater Wellington community as well as the founding member clubs. The quality of governance will be directly related to the quality of the people who make up the board. It is appropriate that the balance is moved away from elected positions to appointed positions for the Centre’s governance board with the Council having a critical role to play in the appointment process. Wider community, business and management skills sets should be considered in the appointment process than might otherwise be the case if a representative model were adopted. 9.3 Management Experience gained during the active communities project has provided a model to work from that clearly demonstrates how the management of the Centre is most likely to succeed beyond the initial set up phase20. The partner clubs have developed a strong understanding of the service that they can expect the Centre to provide in terms of ‘discover’, ‘experience’ and ‘learn’ activities for each sport and how the Centre can manage the process from booking through to delivery through to membership transfer. On the flip side of the partnership the partner clubs have a sound understanding of what they are required to provide in terms of equipment and volunteer support to 19 Ibid 35. See Appendix one for the ‘Wellington Ocean Sports Active Communities Investment - Project Exit Report’ which provides an overview of the lessons learned during the investment period. 20 Page | 48 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton help make the Centre operate effectively along with what is required to transition Wellingtonians into ongoing active participation in ocean sports. A range of management and reporting systems have been developed during the active communities project which will continue to be implemented during the next phase of the Centre’s existence. A set of generic full time and casual employment agreements have been developed and the associated systems for making employment payments, appraising performance, managing employment disputes and providing professional development are in place. Systems for managing risk and ensuring a healthy and safe work environment have been established including a safe ship management plan and risk management plan. The centre has established accreditations to deliver ocean sports qualifications from Yachting New Zealand, the New Zealand Qualifications Authority, Coastguard Boating Education Services, Windsurfing New Zealand, Surf New Zealand, the Royal Yachting Association and the International Sailing Federation. An online booking system for all activities delivered through the Centre and an associated customer management database and financial reporting system has been established. A flat management structure has been put in place for the ongoing management of the Centre. A full time Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Manager position has been established. The active communities project manager has been appointed to this position which should ensure there is continuity beyond the initial set up phase. All other instructor positions are casual employment positions with work on an as required basis. The Centre Manager will continue to report to the Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club until such time as the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre incorporated society and board of governors has been established. It is envisaged that the Centre Manager will have a significant role to play in facilitating the establishment of the society and its board of governors. Figure 24: Proposed Wellington Ocean Sports Centre governance and management structure Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 49 novak+middleton 10. Operating Costs 10.0 Introduction The Wellington Ocean Sports active communities project ran for three years. Funding for the management of the project was accounted for separately from the operating income and expenditure, which means three years of data is available to extrapolate potential future operating income and costs for the Centre. It is assumed that the Centre will run on a full cost recovery basis for courses with grants used to subsidise the cost of the Centre Manager and specific community based activity such as the schools programme, have a go days and the like. The following figures assume that the Wellington City Council will provide funding for the Centre Manager position and that the Centre will be successful in grant applications for targeted programmes. It is assumed that the cost of construction of the Centre will be covered by a combination of a community facilities grant from the Department of Internal Affairs and capital works grants from community funding agencies. As a result interest and capital repayment costs are not included in the figures below. The following figures assume growth of around 20% on the participation numbers that were achieved during the active communities project. All amounts are GST exclusive. 10.1 Projected future income and expenses INCOME Casual Activity Fees Course Fees Equipment Hire Facility Rental Fundraising Grants Harbour Sails Projects Schools Programme EXPENSES Building R & M Computer Costs Course Costs Depreciation Energy Equipment Lease Equipment R & M Fundraising General Expenses Insurance & Security Levies & Subs Office Supplies Personnel - Casual Wages Personnel - Salaries Projects Promotion and Marketing Rent Telecommunication Travel 75,000 180,000 15,000 15,000 15,000 100,000 25,000 90,000 20,000 535,000 15,000 6,000 45,000 20,000 15,000 35,000 20,000 5,000 15,000 25,000 5,000 10,000 124,000 80,000 70,000 25,000 12,000 5,000 3,000 535,000 Page | 50 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 11. Sustainability 11.0 Introduction Sustainability is about assessing whether or not a sport and recreation facility will have a positive impact on economic, social and environmental aspects for future generations21. This assessment needs to consider not only the immediate activities of the facility but must also contemplate the additional opportunities that will arise once it is operational. When assessing the economic, social and environmental impact of the Wellington Ocean Sports Centre it is important to understand the role that the centre holds within the memorandum of understanding between Wellington City Council and Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club 22. The memorandum contains three objectives which seek to: 1. Establish the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour as a base for ocean sports. 2. Attract world class ocean sports events to Wellington. 3. Leverage of yachting to promote Wellington, increase visitor numbers, grow industry and enhance the vibrancy of Wellington. Considerable work has been completed on establishing the boat harbour as a base for ocean sports through the feasibility investigations for the Clyde Quay Marina upgrade and through the design aspects of this feasibility study. These two studies lay the pre-resource consent ground work for the infrastructure that will help attract world class ocean sports events to Wellington and will enable to the Council and the Club to leverage of yachting to promote Wellington, increase visitor numbers, grow industry and enhance liveability. 11.1 Additional activities proposed to be supported by the Centre This section of the report outlines the additional initiatives, over and above the Wellington Ocean Sports Programme, that at this stage are planned to be supported or administered by the Centre. 11.1.1 Model Yachts and Harbour Sails tourist attractions Model Yacht Hire and Wellington Harbour Sails will be attractions targeted at visitors to Wellington as well as Wellingtonians themselves. It is intended that a kiosk be established as part of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project with both the Model Yacht Hire and Wellington Harbour Sails operated out of the kiosk by staff from the Centre. People will be able to hire the radio controlled model yachts from the kiosk and sail them off the deck while friends and family watch on. It is planned that Wellington Harbour Sails will depart from central Clyde Quay twice a day on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays throughout the year. Wellington Harbour Sails will be promoted as a must do tourist attraction for visitors to Wellington ... take a ride on the cable car, visit Te Papa, and experience Wellington’s Wind on a Harbour Sail! 11.1.2 ‘Powered by the Wind’ export education initiative The Powered by the Wind Education initiative is intended to be a partnership between a range of Wellington education institutions and the Centre and is being positioned as an export education initiative designed to attract national and international students to Wellington. 21 Department of Sport and Recreation, Government of Western Australia, 2007. ‘Feasibility Study Guide: Sport and Recreation Facilities’. 22 Wellington City Council and Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club, 2014. ‘Memorandum of Understanding’. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 51 novak+middleton The initiative is in the early stages of development with the first step involving a memorandum of understanding between the New Zealand Institute of Sport and the Centre enabling international students to study towards the following qualifications: NZIS Diploma in Sport (Exercise Prescription & Sport Management) Level 5 (Yachting). NZIS Diploma in Sport (Advanced Sport Management) Level 6 (Yachting). NZIS Diploma in Sport (Advanced Exercise Prescription) Level 6 (Yachting). As the Powered by the Wind export education initiative develops it is planned to add: An ‘academy’ programme that Wellington secondary schools can market as part of their export education drives. A tertiary level qualification programme focusing on the innovative design and construction of speed sailing yachts. Figure 25: ‘Powered by the Wind’ curriculum framework 11.1.3 Clyde Quay Boat Harbour management The memorandum of Understanding between Wellington City Council and Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club envisages that the management of the Clyde Quay Marina will be transferred to the Cllub once the marina upgrade is complete. It is envisaged that the day to day administration of the marina including tasks such as cleaning, maintenance, allocation of events to the events bay, berth allocations and customer enquiries will be implemented by staff at the Centre. Page | 52 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 11.1.4 Wellington Strategic Sailing Events Framework Yachting New Zealand and Wellington City Council have established a strategic sailing events framework for Wellington. The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre will be a key resource to assist with the delivery of these events. The following table summarises the events framework. The Wellington Harbour Festival Continue to support and grow community, regional and national level events each summer as part of the Wellington Harbour Festival concept. New Zealand Sprint Sailing Champs Develop the New Zealand Sprint Sailing Championship concept as a unique annual event in Wellington aligned to Yachting New Zealand’s high performance programme. World Championship Sailing Events Pitch for a World Championships in Wellington each year with the first classes to be targeted: 49er and 49er FX. Windsurfing. Kiteboarding. Ocean Race Stopovers Evaluate and respond to Ocean Racing host city stopover opportunities as and when these arise including any change in focus that may arise out of the review of the A to B race. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 53 novak+middleton Wellington Match Racing Cup Continue to monitor whether the event can be part of the World Match Racing Tour and act if appropriate. Americas Cup World Series Ensure that Wellington is positioned to have the opportunity to bid for host city status for any world series that emerges as part of the next Americas Cup. Figures 26-31: Wellington strategic sailing events framework 11.2 Economic, social and environmental impact The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre will have a positive economic, social and environmental impact on Wellington. Economically the Wellington Ocean Sports programme is designed as a not for loss operation and the additional activities are all based on making a surplus as per Wellington City Council events, marina and economic development policies. Socially the Centre will create a new focal point for community involvement in ocean sports and will provide greater opportunities for Wellingtonians to be active on Wellington Harbour. Environmentally the Centre is a positive addition in the sport and recreation landscape with its philosophy of shared use and co-location and will contribute significantly to the positioning of the Clyde Quay Boat Harbour as a far more public space on the Wellington waterfront. Page | 54 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study novak+middleton 12. Conclusion and Recommendations The Wellington Ocean Sports Centre will be a contemporary purpose built facility that extracts the maximum potential from the ocean sports partnership and caters for the changing nature of sport and recreation participation in society. It will contribute positively to the sport and recreation landscape in Wellington by providing a programme that encourages and supports Wellingtonians to be active on Wellington harbour. In addition the Centre has the potential to deliver on a range of initiatives that will improve the social and economic wellbeing of the community and will enhance the liveability of the City. The following recommendations are contained within the body of the report. 1. It is recommended that the building be constructed on the north western corner of the harbour because of its close location and easy access to the boat harbour, proximity to the beach and the availability of existing sheds and building space. 2. It is recommended that an application be made to the Department of Internal Affairs Community Facilities Fund and to selected community funding agencies for the full cost of construction of the Centre as a community facility within the overall Clyde Quay Boat Harbour restoration project. 3. It is recommended that the Centre be constructed at the same time as wave mitigation systems are installed in the boat harbour and that this could take place ahead of the overall marina upgrade works if necessary. 4. It is recommended that an incorporated society be established with an independent board to govern the Centre and a professional management and instructor team be put in place to oversee the implementation of the Programme. 5. It is recommended that the Wellington City Council provide funding for the salary cost of the Centre Manager in recognition of the significant community based sport and recreation activities that the Centre delivers. Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study Page | 55 novak+middleton Appendices 1. Wellington Ocean Sports Active Communities Investment Project Exit Report Page | 56 Wellington Ocean Sports Centre Feasibility Study