DLN 07-10-09 - Hertz Schram
Transcription
DLN 07-10-09 - Hertz Schram
DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 1 Entertaining notion News you cannot get anywhere else. www.legalnews.com Vol. CXIV No.137 DAILY BRIEFS Herstein re-elected secretary of Supreme Court historical board Carl W. Herstein, a partner in Honigman Miller Schwartz and Cohn LLP’s Real Estate Department, again has been elected Secretary of the Board of DirecMichigan tors, Supreme Court Historical Society. Herstein was elected to the organization’s Board in 2004, elected to Secretary in Carl W. 2006 and has been Herstein re-elected to the position in each succeeding year. Herstein’s law practice focuses on real estate, real estate finance and real estate tax appeals, interest/usury and equine law. He currently serves on the University Musical Society Board of Directors, of which he is the immediate past Chair. His professional accolades include notation in The Best Lawyers in America (20082009), Michigan Super Lawyers (2007-2009) and Who’s Who in American Law. He received a J.D. from the Yale Law School and a B.A. in Political Science and History from the University of Michigan. The Michigan Supreme Court Historical Society is a non profit corporation, which collects, preserves and displays documents, records and memorabilia relating to the study of the Michigan Supreme Court and other courts of Michigan to increase awareness of Michigan’s legal heritage. For more information visit micourthistory.org. Deputy convicted, demoted to jail duty MOUNT CLEMENS (AP) — A Macomb County sheriff ’s deputy who was accused of drunken driving, resisting arrest and possession of marijuana has been demoted but not fired after he pleaded guilty to two misdemeanors. Former Lt. Joseph Guzdziol will start his new position as a turnkey in the county jail on Saturday. He will lose about $50,000 annually in salary but will continue to build his pension. Guzdziol was charged with drunken driving, resisting arrest, child endangerment and marijuana possession after a Feb. 20 incident in Bay County. He pleaded guilty to lesser charges. Sheriff Mark Hackel says demoting Guzdziol was one of the toughest things he’s had to do as sheriff. Hackel says Guzdziol has had “an impeccable career.” Man pleads guilty to poaching fish GRAND RAPIDS (AP) — A man has pleaded guilty to illegally taking a 5-foot sturgeon from the Grand River in Grand Rapids. Thirty-year-old Secilio David Cantu admitted Thursday in district court he knew the fish was a sturgeon when he poached it in mid-May. A sentencing date was not set. Cantu faces 30 to 180 days in jail, fines of up to $2,000 and other penalties. The lake sturgeon is a protected species in Michigan. The state Department of Natural Resources says the Grand Rapids man hooked the fish in the tail and dragged it to a waiting truck driven by his father. Onlookers took cell phone pictures and called out to him to return the fish. Cantu turned himself in after seeing his picture was being circulated by the media and online. He declined to comment Thursday. INSIDE DLN Abandoned Car Auctions ............10 Building Permits ..........................41 Calendar ...................................51 City Request for Bids .....................6 Classified Ads ..............................4 Crossword ...................................4 Legal Notices ...............................6 Mortgages ...................................4 State Tax Liens ............................45 Friday, July 10, 2009 75 Cents Attorney sees opportunities in field of entertainment law BY MIKE SCOTT Legal News From public defender to lawyer to the stars, Howard Hertz has become perhaps one of the most accomplished and experienced entertainment law experts in Michigan. Now Hertz is hoping that the incentives the state legislature gave to filmmakers last year will continue to be offered in the wake of debate over whether the credits should still be offered. Hertz’s experience in entertainment law is significant. He and partner Bradley Schram established the Bloomfield Hills-based law firm of Hertz Schram, P.C. in 1979. The firm provides legal services in a wide variety of specialties, although practically all of Hertz’s practice is the in entertainment field. Since 1976 Hertz has represented numerous artists and entities in entertainment, including authors, screenwriters, recording artists, radio personalities, producers, production companies, record labels, agents, artist managers, music publishers, songwriters and athletes. Among others, his most well-known clients have included George Clinton, Sippie Wallace, The Romantics, The Bass Brothers, Eminem, Marilyn Manson, Russell Simmons, O-Town, Pantera, The GO, Elmore Leonard, Warner Tamerlane and Atlantic Records. Hertz’s start in the specialty field came about in an innocuous way. He was working as a public defender for the city of Detroit, fresh out of law school at Wayne State University, working on armed robbery and other criminal cases. That’s when local singer and songwriter Ted Strunck was offered a publishing contract and was referred to Hertz through a mutual friend. Strunck gave Hertz the book This Business of Music by M. William Krasilovsky. As the only lawyer he knew, Strunck suggested to Hertz that he could use the book as a resource to help the Lunch Date Over the years, Southfield attorney Harvey Heller has amassed a premiere collection of 110 antique lunchboxes that span four decades of pop culture. See his story on the Back Page. performer negotiate a fair contract. “It’s not something I had anticipated getting into but I had always had this interest in music, whether singing or strumming the guitar,” Hertz said. “At that time I didn’t even know there was something known as entertainment law and in reality it was a pretty new (practice).” So Hertz began educating himself more about the field. He took classes through the Practicing Law Institute in New York City and began working with some local brands, helping them to finalize contracts and negotiate terms. During the time when Hertz was establishing an entertainment law specialty, he discussed opening a firm with Schram, who was then working for the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office. Schram had a personal interest in film and television scriptwriting and developed a friendship with the novelist and screenwriter Elmore Leonard. While still working as a prosecuting attorney, he invited Leonard to Detroit to tour the office and learn more about the law enforcement and legal systems during a time when Leonard was interested in changing genres from westerns to crime dramas. Schram introduced Leonard to his new law partner. And around this time Hertz began doing legal work for Joel Martin, the publisher that first offered Strunck a contract. Over time, Martin became an influential producer and manager in the music business, and remains a client. The rest is history. “It wasn’t long before I started doing work for Leonard and he has been with us for the last 30 years,” Hertz said. For years much of his entertainment law work has been focused in the music industry. He attends MIDEM, the international music festival in Cannes, France, each year that See ENTERTAINING, Page 2 Eye on the Blogosphere Would you like some ointment for that burn? BY TARYN HARTMAN Legal News It’s killing me not to write about Michael Jackson this week. It would be so easy, given my unbridled passion for the King of Pop and because the story has so dominated the continuous news cycle that the blogosphere has helped create. But in the interest of not contributing to the “problem” of overcoverage that many are complaining about, I’ll guess I’ll just say this: the story of Michael Jackson’s death is all the proof we need that the Internet really has changed everything. From the fact that celebrity gossip site TMZ.com broke the story to the never-ending, constantly updating stream of information on blogs and Web sites — a sea so deep that I’ve only waded in up to my ankles when it comes to sifting through which outlet or writer is saying what — to the fact that Tuesday’s memorial service was streamed live over the Web likely to millions in addition to the 31 million TV viewers Nielsen is reporting, what we know (and in many cases, don’t know and choose to speculate on instead) and when we know it are definitely never going to be the same. I was a sixth-grader watching a Saturday night rerun of “Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman” when a ticker crawled across the screen informing me that Princess Diana had been in a car accident, and the newspaper headlines the next morning read, “Crash Kills Diana.” When Michael Jackson died, I found out via text message. Furthermore, the advent of online social networking sites has turned us into a worldwide community of grievers connected through highspeed, wireless and mobile internet connections. Who’s to say that the death of Elvis thirty years ago wouldn’t have elicited the same kind of response as MJ’s passing were there countless cable news outlets and Web sites to cover it and the technology available to let his fans around the world share their grief over Twitter and Facebook? But now it’s time to get down to business. Do you “remember the time” (from 1991’s Dangerous) when Lowering the Bar (www.loweringthe- bar.net/) informed us of a court decision ruling that Crunchberries weren’t actually a fruit? Hang on, give me a minute…the devastation is washing back over me. Well, they’re back to burst our bubble again, this time with the news that you aren’t entitled to sue anybody if you suffer burns at a place called — wait for it — BURNING MAN. “Trying to explain what Burning Man is to someone who has never been to the event is a bit like trying to explain what a particular color looks like to someone who is blind,” reads the Web site (www.burningman.com/whatisburningman/) for the annual festival in Nevada’s Black Rock Desert. The basic concept is this: each year, close to 50,000 people descend on the usually desolate area and build a makeshift city housing the week-long festival of whatever-youmake-of-it, an “experimental community which challenges its members to express themselves and rely on themselves to a degree that is not normally encountered in one’s day-to-day life. “There are no rules about how one must behave or express oneself at this event (save the rules that serve to protect the health, safety, and experience of the community at large); rather, it is up to each participant to decide how they will contribute and what they will give to this community,” the site reads. Near the end of the festival, a 60-foot tall wooden statue (the Burning Man) is set on fire and burns until it collapses into a big bonfire, and this is where Anthony Beninati ran into trouble. You see, as Lowering the Bar explains, according to Beninati’s complaint, “He walked around the bonf ire three times, each time ‘circl[ing] a little closer to the fire.’ Eventually, he walked still closer, into what was variously described as an area of ‘embers,’ ‘low flames,’ ‘burning remnants,’ and ‘a spot where there was fire on either side of him.’ Basically, he had walked inside a huge bonfire. Then, as you might have expected, he tripped on something and fell into the actual fiery part of the bonfire, burning his hand.” So he did what’s becoming more and more common in our society when it comes to shifting the blame for one’s own moronic behavior elsewhere: he sued. As defendants, the festival organizers argued Beninati could not file his suit under the “primary assumption of the risk” doctrine, which “bars negligence claims by some- one who was hurt while participating in an activity ‘involving an inherent risk of injury to voluntary participants . . ., where the risk cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity,’” Lowering the Bar writes. The post continues, “In his deposition, Beninati admitted he knew ‘fire was dangerous and caused burns’ before he walked into one. He knew there was some possibility of falling into said fire. He admitted no one affiliated with the defendants asked him to walk into the fire or told him it would be safe to do so. But he testified that he did not think it would be dangerous to walk into the fire, although he knew it ‘was not ‘absolutely safe, because there [was] a fire present.’ And, as noted, fire is hot.” The California Court of Appeals agreed in a decision that’s important because it marks the first time it’s applied the primary assumption of risk doctrine to something other than a sport, “unless you think ‘recreational dancing’ and being pulled behind a boat on an inner tube are ‘sports.’” Lowering the Bar snarks. Ouch…burn. After greeting jurors, Chief Judge Marylin E. Atkins (second from left) visits with Jury Depar tment staff Eileen Foley Schumaker, Karen Woolfolk and Carol Michalak Duff. 36th District Court marks juror’s month The 36th District Court is celebrating Juror Appreciation Month during the month of July to recognize city of Detroit residents who have completed jury duty and to highlight the honor and importance of serving on a jury. Throughout the month activities will include airing of the court’s jury service video, “Jurors in Paradise,” and the recently released production, “36th District Court: Justice for All” as well as a variety of documentaries and musical performances provided by The Detroit Public Library. In addition to light morning refreshments, jurors will receive a copy of the resolution issued by the Michigan Supreme Court, bookmarks imprinted with a juror appreciation message and Certificates of Appreciation. They will also receive visitdetroit bags filled with visitdetroit magazines, maps and DET bumper stickers, provided by the Detroit Metro Convention & Visitors Bureau. Station to Station Guides that highlight great destinations in downtown Detroit along the Detroit People Mover route are also being provided to jurors by The Detroit People Mover, a Detroit Transportation Corporation. New to this year’s observance is the Tour Ren Cen guide, inviting jurors to join in for a complimentary walking tour of the landmark GM Renaissance Center. According to Chief Judge Marylin E. Atkins, the objective of Juror Appreciation Month is to show past and prospective jurors that their contributions are greatly appreciated by the Court. A member of the bench greets the jurors daily and thanks them for serving. “Jury service is a vital aspect of our government,” said Judge Atkins. “When you serve as juror, you not only serve your country, but you serve as an integral part of the justice system. “We want every juror to feel appreciated and to know how much we value their time and commitment to our system of justice,” Atkins continued. “We would also like to thank the many private companies, government agencies, small businesses, school districts, and all those who encourage and support their employees when they are called to jury service. “We depend on your service — thank you for doing your duty!” Clark Hill Cares Greg Moore and more than 200 other Clark Hill PLC employees volunteered June 27 to sort and pack food at Gleaners Community Food bank and partner locations near the firm’s offices in three Michigan communities (Detroit, Grand Rapids and Lansing), as well as Chicago and Phoenix. While the firm has supported many community organizations in the past, this companywide initiative was the first formal community project orchestrated under the firm’s new “Clark Hill Cares” banner. For more photos from the event see page 51. Photo courtesy of Tanner Friedman Official Newspaper: City of Detroit • Wayne Circuit Court • U.S. District Court • U.S. Bankruptcy Court ■ Taking Stock ■ Commentary ■ Book Case Berko recommends replacing Geitner with midwesterner Page 2 The untaught law of unexpected consequences Page 3 Review of ‘Three Felonies,’ an indictment against the Justice Dept. Page 50 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 2 Page 2, The Detroit Legal News Taking Stock MALCOLM BERKO Solid midwesterner needed to balance Obama’s books Dear Mr. Berko: I understand that you are uncomfortable with the Obama administration’s handling of this financial crisis. What changes would you recommend to put our economy back on track? This is not a trick question, rather other readers and I would appreciate your point of view. Are you in the Rush Limbaugh camp? Do you agree with Rush, who wants President Barack Obama’s policies to fail? G.G., Oklahoma City Dear G.G.: Please understand that Rush Limbaugh is neither an economist nor a financial impresario. He’s a fantastic entertainer who would probably win every vote on “American Idol.” And I don’t believe, for even a minute, that Rush wants Obama’s policies to fail. Rush is not vindictive and he doesn’t wish economic failure on 310 million Americans. His job is to sell advertising for the radio stations that broadcast his program and he’s doing yeoman’s work. There are simple solutions to most complicated problems concerning government policies. However, the solutions are complicated by thousands of sniveling lobbyists who deluge billions of dollars of bribe money on members of Congress to favor the smirking fat cats who employ them. It was L. William Seidman, former chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., who said: “Lobbyists are the poison of America’s middle class.” Because we’re prohibited from shooting lobbyists, I suggest that the administration demand each lobbyist wear a Nazi armband and a red swastika on his lapel. Solving our economic problems is made even more complicated because Democrats and Republicans practice politics like the Hatfields and McCoys. Just imagine what we could accomplish if Congress banished political parties. One TRILLION dollars, a whole number followed by 12 zeros, has been bequeathed by the administration to purchase “toxic” assets from our financial institutions. That’s wrong! A second $1 TRILLION of largess was bestowed upon the banks, insurance companies, and the auto and brokerage industry so they can meet their f inancial obligations. That’s wrong! Every penny, peso and pound of this $2 trillion (more TRILLIONS to come later) is euchred from the pockets of every American taxpayer. Most of those TRILLIONS (giveaway dollars) belong to Americans who lost homes to foreclosure due to unprincipled lenders and to Americans who don’t have money for health insurance because of fraud, greed and waste in our medical system. This money is usurped from Americans who can’t make credit card payments due to unscrupulous bank practices and from Americans who purchased Detroit’s cars that implode three years later. Finally, this money belongs to Americans who lost TRILLIONS in their retirement accounts due to the criminal activities and marauding greed of Merrill Lynch, Goldman Saks, Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns. This money doesn’t belong to Bank of America, GM, Merrill Lynch, AIG or Countrywide Mortgage. It’s our money, and there’s not a single snippet of personal responsibility attached to its taking by corporate America. History books will refer to this event as the “slickest train robbery in the history of the world.” It’s so easy to spend money when it doesn’t belong to you. Everybody complains about the solutions but few offer a better solution. Well here is a better solution. Congress goofed big time handing out $1 billion checks like cheese samples on toothpicks at Costco! I’d insist that the executives of companies receiving bailout bucks personally sign an enforceable IOU for their prorata share of the largess. They too should be on the hook. I would insist that members of the respective corporate boards sign identical IOUs. Then I would get rid of Treasury Secretary Timmy “The Giveaway Kid” Geithner, a Brooklyn boy who got his doctorate from Dartmouth, one of those amnesia-inducing Ivy League schools. I would replace him with Thomas M. Hoenig, a Midwest lad born in Fort Madison, Iowa. Hoenig earned his doctorate at Iowa State University. He’s a financial conservative and president of the Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank, the second largest in the United States next to the San Francisco Federal Reserve Bank. If this were done, I believe the Dow Jones industrial averages would be making new highs today. –––––––––– Please address your financial questions to Malcolm Berko, P.O. Box 1416, Boca Raton, FL 33429 or e-mail him at [email protected]. Visit Creators Syndicate Web site at www.creators.com. © 2009 Creators Syndicate Inc. FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Business & Economy THE INFLUENCE GAME Business, health split starting to form Sharp divisions emerging over how to achieve health care reform BY ALAN FRAM Associated Press Writer WASHINGTON (AP) — Health care providers have been crowing in recent days about deals they’ve cut with lawmakers to help pay for President Barack Obama’s health care overhaul. Those agreements have been announced in flashy White House ceremonies — but off camera and quietly, business lobbyists have been stewing. Their concern: The many billions in savings health providers are promising will ultimately come from the pockets of the nation’s employers, who are already drowning in medical costs. The growing divide underlines that while almost every group in Washington says it favors health care reform, sharp divisions emerge over how to achieve it. The chasm also fractures the overall business community, making it harder for opponents of an over- includes more than 10,000 industry professionals. The festival is created to help these professionals network and build business with others. In 1995 Martin signed a young Detroit performer named Marshall Mathers to a record contract. The rapper, now known as Eminem, has also been a client of Hertz’s for the last 14 years. Over time, Hertz has expanded his practice to include legal work for non-musical performers as well. The majority of his legal work falls into one of three areas: contract negotiations, litigation work such as copyright and settlements for artist fees and networking activities. As a networker, Hertz helps to get interest in his clients’ talents, helps to introduce them to other industry insiders and promotes his clients to industry executives. “Much of my networking group involves taking projects to the next level,” Hertz said. “A lot of my role is similar to what an agent can provide.” Three years ago, when the state first began investigating how to attract f ilmmakers, Hertz was tapped by Gov. Jennifer Granholm to serve on the Michigan Film Advisory Commission. He was closely involved in the initial discussions on how to create tax years. Even if the deals survive, business groups say, hospitals and drug companies may find ways to shift the costs to the country’s private employers, who provide most Americans with health care coverage. “We as private payers are first in line to take increased costs as hospitals and others who are playing ‘Let’s Make a Deal’ try to make up these costs,” said E. Neil Trautwein, chief health care lobbyist for the National Retail Federation, umbrella group for the nation’s retail industry. “So we are not a fan of these backroom deals.” Health insurance premiums grew by 78 percent between 2001 and 2007, far higher than the 19 percent growth in wages during that period, according to the private Kaiser Family Foundation. Companies providing medical coverage paid health care expenses that were typically 11 percent the size of their payrolls in 2005, up Prosecutors recommend sentence of 145 years BY LARRY NEUMEISTER Associated Press Writer NEW YORK (AP) — A prominent lawyer who prosecutors say should spend 145 years behind bars for a giant fraud says envy of more successful colleagues and clients fueled a mid-life ambitious crusade to build prestige and wealth by stealing hundreds of millions of dollars. “I lost my perspective and my moral grounding, and, really, in a sense, I just lost my mind,” 59year-old Marc Dreier told U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff in an unusually blunt letter made public Wednesday. Rakoff is scheduled to sentence the one-time high flying lawyer on Monday after he admitted losing more than $400 million by bilking hedge funds with bogus claims of investments safely placed with clients he had once represented. Dreier said in his letter that he started his firm, Dreier LLP, in 1996 when he became envious that “colleagues of mine and certainly clients of mine were doing much better financially and seemingly enjoying more status.” Dreier’s December arrest forced the closure of his firm with 250 attorneys and a roster of clients that Hertz: Tax incentives should remain fixed incentives that could help bring these movies to Michigan. Over the course of the next two years, he worked with legislative aides to try and get the bills through committee and to the state House and Senate floors. “It happened pretty quickly in that we were able to accomplish quite a bit in the (first 15 months) now that the incentives have been in place,” Hertz said. But to ensure that the f ilm industry’s presence in Michigan grows, it is imperative that some onsite studios open, Hertz said. That’s when Hollywood will recognize that the Michigan opportunity is a long-term one. It is one of the topics that Hertz works on with Wayne County, one of his f irm’s clients. The county is attempting to attract more filmmakers to the region. “That’s when you will see more commitment to making movies here and when you’ll see more of the (big budget) movies being made here,” Hertz said. “It will take some time to build the infrastructure that we need.” Hertz opposes rolling back some of the tax incentives that have helped to attract filmmakers and studios to the state. He wants the incentives to remain fixed for at least five years, by which time the movie industry in Michigan could grow to be more than $1 billion. haul to form broad coalitions that might defeat it, such as the largely united business front that doomed President Bill Clinton’s drive to remake the medical system in the early 1990s. Three major hospital groups agreed with White House officials and Senate Finance Committee leaders this week to accept $155 billion in reduced Medicare and Medicaid payments over the coming decade. The deal would allow hospitals to limit the damage to their budgets. Two weeks ago, the nation’s drug producers agreed to swallow $80 billion in savings, largely by reducing the prices they charge for some Medicare prescriptions. People following the health care debate say a deal with doctors groups may be next. There are no guarantees these agreements will emerge intact as Congress labors to send Obama a health system overhaul that could cost $1 trillion over the next 10 Once-prominent lawyer blames envy for $400 million fraud ENTERTAINING: From Page 1 Submit news & views to [email protected] “Putting a cap on the incentives would kill this,” Hertz said. “Yes the incentives cost the state money from the coffers but the money is coming back to our residents in terms of new jobs. And not only has it contributed financially to the state but it has helped our collective (psyche) during a very tough economic time.” And there should be opportunities for lawyers to grow an entertainment practice here in the state. Hertz said lawyers should get educated on the intricacies of entertainment law. Existing entertainment lawyers, working with such agencies as the Michigan Film Office, need to continue promoting the state to studio and production companies scattered throughout the country. “There are so many benefits to hiring lawyers from the state,” Hertz said. ”First our hourly rates are generally less expensive across the board than lawyers in New York and Los Angeles. Second they get the double benefit because some of these legal fees would qualify for tax incentives under state law,” he added. Already law f irms can help Michigan-based production companies find the funding they need to develop a project within the state, Hertz said. “There are and will be opportunities but we need to keep (the incentives) going,” Hertz said. included celebrities, including retired football star Michael Strahan and former News Corp. publishing executive Judith Regan. Prosecutors urged the judge to sentence the Harvard and Yaletrained attorney to 145 years in prison while Dreier’s defense lawyer, Gerald Shargel, said between 10 and 12 1/2 years in prison was a fair punishment. “Dreier could have pursued a rewarding and productive life as a lawyer, serving clients and the law, with compensation in the top few percent of the general population,” prosecutors said. “Instead, Dreier decided to seek vast personal riches and prestige through a life of fraud and through dishonor to his profession,” they wrote. In his letter dated Tuesday and filed with the court Wednesday, Dreier said he suffers “every day from the shame and self-loathing and regret with which I will always have to live.” “I expect and deserve a significant prison sentence,” he wrote. He said he asked his lawyers to file his letter in the public record “in the hope that it may do some good as a warning to others not to follow in my path.” “I will always be remembered as a thief,” Dreier wrote. “I have lost my past and my future. I have lost everything a man can lose. And now I will lose my freedom as well, and rightly so.” Prosecutors noted that Rakoff has already said Dreier should be “ranked with those who have committed some of the most egregious frauds in history.” Last week, disgraced money manager Bernard Madoff was sentenced to 150 years in prison after admitting he carried on a Ponzi scheme for at least two decades that cost thousands of investors tens of billions of dollars. Dreier, who remains under house arrest, carried out his fraud over a seven-year period by distributing phony client and accounting firm documents to his customers and by impersonating clients in person and on the phone and recruiting others to join his charades, prosecutors said. Prosecutors say Dreier lost more than $400 million as he fraudulently obtained as much as $740 million through deceit. They said he committed the fraud “simply to satisfy his own greed and vanity” and they noted his accumulation of numerous expensive assets. Those assets included millions of dollars in artwork, beachfront homes on both coasts and an $18.5 million yacht. A court-appointed receiver said Dreier had little cash left when he was arrested in early December. Dreier said in his letter that he started stealing in 2002 when he felt overwhelmed by debts, a disappointing career and a failed marriage. “As I sit here today, I can’t remember or imagine why I didn’t stop myself,” he wrote. “It all seems so obviously deplorable now. I recall only that I was desperate for some measure of the success that I felt had eluded me.” He added: “I lost myself to my ambition and sacrificed everything else.” Shargel said a sentence should be rational and proportionate. Notice to attorneys In case of an emergency relating to Third Judicial Circuit matters occurring on a weekend, holiday or during non-business hours, please contact Ms. Kelli D. Moore, Deputy Court Administrator, at (313) 468-0372. Please have all pertinent information available, i.e., case caption, case number, attorney names, telephone numbers, and client names. Ms. Moore will contact the assigned emergency judge. Ronald R. Ruffin, Executive Court Administrator Third Judicial Circuit Weekend/Holiday Arraignment on Warrants for Wayne County Court begins at 12 p.m. at both 34th and 36th District Court: Cases originating outside the City of Detroit, but within Wayne County, will be held at: Thirty-Fourth District Court 11131 S. Wayne Road Romulus, MI 48174 Cases originating within the City of Detroit will be held at: Thirty-Sixth District Court 421 Madison Detroit, MI 48226 Ronald R. Ruffin Executive Court Administrator Third Judicial Circuit from 8 percent in 2000, the group said. While agreeing that reducing health costs is essential for companies, business groups like Trautwein’s have been critical of the effort to reshape health care. They have explicitly opposed some key Democratic tenets such as creating a government-run insurance plan and requiring employers to provide medical coverage for their workers. In interviews, leaders of health industry groups say their agreements with lawmakers would help the business community. “Part of our goal is to achieve health care reform that makes health care more affordable for employers,” said Billy Tauzin, head of the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, whose deal was announced June 22. He said while there are “no guarantees about future inflation, no guarantees about the future economies our country will go through,” economic models show making the health care system more efficient “will save you dramatically over the long term.” Rich Umbdenstock, president of the American Hospital Association, said health overhaul is aimed at covering more people, thus reducing the costs that hospitals pass on for care of uninsured and underinsured patients. It also would create a new pool of insured — and a potential source of income. But he cautioned that reimbursements hospitals receive for treating Medicaid and Medicare recipients — people 65 and over, the poor and the disabled — remain too low. “We’re all concerned about cost shifts and the burden that places on the private sector,” he said. None of that is enough for many business groups, large and small. Maureen Davenport, spokeswoman for the National Association of Manufacturers, said her group was watching the health industry’s emerging agreements with an eye to money. “We would be concerned with anything that would raise the cost for manufacturers,” she said. Also leery is John Satagaj, president of the Small Business Legislative Council, which represents about 60 small business trade groups such as florists. He said he cannot tell how the savings that health groups have agreed to would be enforced. “I don’t know where the pressure points are yet to make sure we control the entire system” of reducing health costs, he said. If there’s no way to ensure that the health industry bears the cost of the savings, “where you go is who is left to pay for it. If it’s not individuals and not the government, it’s going to be business.” Citigroup shuffles top execs, chair/former CFO leaving Bank received $45B in government aid BY STEPHEN BERNARD AP Business Writer NEW YORK (AP) — Citigroup Inc. said Thursday that its former chief financial officer and current chairman of Citi Holdings, Gary Crittenden, is leaving the company as part of the bank’s latest shuffling of management. Crittenden took over as chairman of newly created Citi Holdings in March after the New York-based bank separated some of its riskier assets from more traditional banking operations, which became known as Citicorp. Citigroup has been among the hardest hit banks by the credit crisis and ongoing recession. Pressure has been mounting on the bank and its CEO, Vikram Pandit, to return the bank to profitability and stabilize operations. The bank has received $45 billion in aid from the government since last fall, part of which is being converted to a 34 percent equity stake in the bank. Crittenden is leaving the compa- ny to spend more time with his family and pursue other business interests, Citigroup said in a statement. Aside from his departure, Citigroup said Edward Kelly, who had been serving as CFO since Crittenden switched positions, will become vice chairman of Citigroup. Kelly will take on responsibilities for strategy and mergers and acquisitions in the new position. John Gerspach will assume the role of CFO, becoming Citigroup’s third CFO this year. Gerspach previously served as controller and chief accounting officer at Citigroup. Also, Citigroup has hired Eugene McQuade to serve as CEO of Citibank NA, the company’s retail banking business. McQuade most recently served as vice chairman of Merrill Lynch and president of Merrill Lynch Banks. He left that position in February, a month after the New York-based investment bank was acquired by Charlotte, N.C.-based Bank of America Corp. THIRD CIRCUIT COURT NOTICE – DETROIT, MI Effective January 1, 2007, any voucher submitted for any services rendered more than sixty (60) days from the case disposition on criminal matters will be denied in accordance with the Local Administrative Order 2006-08, Plan for Assignment of Counsel in the Third Judicial Circuit. This includes payment requests for either regular or extraordinary services. Ronald R. Ruffin Executive Court Administrator Third Judicial Circuit United States District Court Eastern District of Michigan Public Notice for Reappointment of Incumbent Magistrate Judge Donald A. Scheer The current term of office of United States Magistrate Judge Donald A. Scheer at Detroit, Michigan is due to expire on February 28, 2010. The United States District Court is required by law to establish a Merit Selection Panel to consider the reappointment of Magistrate Judge Scheer to a new eight-year term. The duties of a magistrate judge position include (1) the conduct of most preliminary proceedings in criminal cases; (2) trial and disposition of misdemeanor cases; (3) the conduct of various pretrial matters and evidentiary proceedings on delegation from the judges of the district court; and (4) trial and disposition of civil cases upon consent of the litigants. Comments from members of the bar and the public are invited as to whether Magistrate Judge Scheer should be recommended by the Panel for reappointment by the Court. Comments must be received by 5:00 p.m., Friday, July 17, 2009, and should be directed to: Merit Selection Panel 814 Theodore Levin United States Courthouse 231 W. Lafayette Boulevard Detroit, Michigan 48226 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 3 The Detroit Legal News, Page 3 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Commentary Under Analysis The Legal News presents a weekly Commentary Page. Anyone interested in contributing on an occasional or weekly basis to future commentary pages should contact the editor at [email protected] Funny you should say that... SPENCER FARRIS, THE LEVISON GROUP One Law we never discussed in law school There is never any air conditioning in the Levison Towers Library on the weekend. This is not really a big problem in the winter time (when there is no heat of course) but the heat is noticeable on June weekends. I am stuck in the library on a holiday weekend, doing research. For me, the lack of air conditioning is killer. I would open a window if they hadn’t been painted shut years ago. Good thing — I am having a research problem that makes me want to jump. Here on the second floor, I doubt I would be killed, but am certain the resultant ankle sprain would put this research chore on someone else’s plate. Not that anyone else is available — my email requests for help keep coming back with auto replies from my partners on vacation. As are the law clerks. Legal research is the enemy of middle aged lawyers. We think we know the law, and when it changes, we have to hit the books. Older lawyers send clerks, middle aged lawyers are on our own. It is said that the term (and loathing) “activist judges” began when middle aged lawyers noticed that they change the law we have learned, forcing us to relearn what we thought we knew. My research keeps hitting a dead end. I can’t understand it, since examples are everywhere. My friend Don had a classic case. Actually, his wife Lola did. Lola took her kids to shop for Don for Father’s day. The kids, all under 8, decided to buy Don the first shiny thing they saw — a picture of Dale Earnhardt Junior. Lola chuckled and made the purchase. Dale Junior is the son of Dale Senior, known in NASCAR circles as “our Racer who art in Heaven.” Don didn’t know this, however, as he is not a NASCAR fan. He opened the picture with great pride, as a good father would. Then he put it out on display on the dresser in his bedroom. This was two weeks ago. Lola recently asked when he was going to take the picture down. Don said never. “It is a Father’s day gift and I am going to enjoy it.” Lola was beside herself at the glossy insult to her décor, but utterly powerless. She is a victim of the Law. Thousands of Americans pur- chased new Chrysler and General Motors vehicles. Some, like me, made their purchases after it was clear that these two automakers would soon be under gubmint protection. We were assured that our warranties would be honored, and for GM folk, that the Onstar service would continue even if the companies did not. Thousands purchased their bailout-baby cars well before the trouble in Detroit was well known. A few hundred of these drivers were injured due to alleged flaws in the cars. Their cases were working their way through the court system when the “Little Two” declared bankruptcy. In bankruptcy, lawsuits go out of the civil justice system and into the bankruptcy courts. So, these folk, some badly burned or otherwise maimed by the defects, were stalled from pursuing their lawsuits. A product liability lawsuit is expensive to everyone involved. The Little Two got bankruptcy protection to stop the stream of attorney and expert fees related to litigation. The victims (and their lawyers, who had footed the litigation bills in return for contingent attorney fees) lost control of the lawsuits to the bankruptcy courts. As unsecured creditors they went to the back of the line behind suppliers and others with more definable claims. Injury claims would be liquidated, and since no result in a lawsuit is guaranteed, they were effectively worth nothing. Many of these victims suffered devastating injuries. If they cannot hold the automakers responsible for the damages caused by the dangerous cars, they will undoubtedly follow them into bankruptcy. If they haven’t already. And behind them will be the small law firms who lent time and money to the cause. The Law strikes again. Someone will have to take care of the injury victims who are unable to work and support their families. (The lawyers are on their own, of course.) This burden would fall on state governments, with the burden of higher medical bills and state aid for defective car victims shifting to the taxpayers. Coincidentally, these are the same taxpayers who were bailing out the Little Two in the first place. This is called the trickle down effect of the Law. States are a more formidable foe than severely injured consumers, however. Several state attorneys general went to bankruptcy court to fight the additional tax burden. Pretty good idea, since state revenues are down. GM agreed to honor product liability claims made on vehicles sold before the bankruptcy. No word yet on Chrysler, but I expect they will follow suit. Seems the Law cuts both ways. One member of the old Big Three didn’t get a nickel in bail outs — Ford Motor Company. It was rewarded for keeping its financial house in order by getting to compete in the automobile market without protection from product liability claims. Against the backdrop of a declining economy, add this hurdle to Ford’s list. We can only wonder if they too will belly up to the gubmint bailout trough, if only to stay competitive. Invoking the Law against other injury victims, and starting the cycle all over again. I am pretty sure we never covered this Law in law school. I missed a few classes, and didn’t pay attention in some others, but I have never had any formal training on the Law of Unintended Consequences. My education, and that of the automobile makers, injury victims and taxpayers continues. Stay tuned. ————— ©2009 Under Analysis, LLC. Under Analysis is a nationally syndicated column of the Levison Group. Spencer Farris is the founding partner of The S.E. Farris Law Firm in St Louis, Missouri. He drives a big hybrid Tahoe, and thinks GM would be a different company if it had sold this vehicle years ago. Comments or criticisms about this column may be sent c/o this newspaper or directly to the Levison Group via email at [email protected]. One Perspective LEON DROLET, DIRECTOR, MICHIGAN TAXPAYERS ALLIANCE Some Detroit leaders providing hope Sadly, the word “Detroit” is synonymous with “dysfunction” thanks to the scandals of Monica Conyers and former Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick and the ineptitude of the City Council. But let’s not let those dark clouds obscure several bright lights emerging from the ranks of Detroit’s political leaders. Detroit Public Schools Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb is the brightest of those lights. Since being appointed in March, Mr. Bobb has tackled the seemingly hopeless disaster that is the Detroit Public School System with inspiring vigor. In just a few months, Bobb has slashed a $430 million def icit nearly in half by eliminating bloated staffing and uncovering fraud. Bobb has cut 181 positions out of the 231 person curriculum department, terminated half of the district’s assistant superintendents, the 21 and dumped eleven of “executive cabinet” members. Bob hasn’t just juggled num- bers and laid off unnecessary personnel — he’s aggressively tackled fraud and corruption. In the past two weeks, Bobb uncovered over 250 non-existent “ghost workers” on the payroll and suspended seven more employees accused of theft and embezzlement after investigations were initiated under his watch. And Mr. Bobb isn’t finished yet. He plans on privatizing the district’s transportation services, is considering additional privatization, and will close 29 schools this fall. Cold hearted? Only if one believes that a school district’s primary job is to employ adults and coddle unions instead of putting resources into educating children. The kids and taxpayers of Detroit should hail Bobb as a hero. And Mayor Bing should take notice. The Mayor started out on the right foot by rejecting the perk of the Manoogian Mansion, opting to rent out the building for the benefit of taxpayers. Bing then sug- COMMENTARY PAGE The Legal News presents a weekly Commentary Page every Friday. We invite letters to the editor as well as opinion pieces on facets of the legal community. Anyone interested in contributing on an occasional or weekly basis to future commentary pages is encouraged to contact Brian Cox at [email protected] or at (313) 967-5532. gested that the City’s grossly inefficient public lighting department be outsourced, only to back away when confronted by union intimidation. Let’s hope the Mayor regains his nerve. Bing need only to look to the Wayne County Building downtown for another example of strong, responsible fiscal leadership. Wayne County Executive Robert Ficano, facing a sizable deficit, isn’t foisting a tax hike on suffering citizens like nearby Macomb County. Instead, he’s proposing a 20 percent budget cut - including the layoffs of about 500 county employees and consolidation of two departments. Ficano is also asking the county’s employees to accept cuts in wages and benef its to avert 440 more layoffs. Ficano’s crusade to put Wayne County’s financial house in order is good for Detroit. With Mayor Bing joining Detroit’s widely-respected City Clerk Janice Winfrey in City government, there’s hope for ethical and stable leadership. Now, Mayor, please take on the City’s sacred cows. And Robert Bobb’s professionalism, courage and leadership may finally result in a functional school district for the City. Michigan’s next governor should take notice and bring Mr. Bobb to Lansing. ————— Leon Drolet can be contacted at [email protected] or at www.mitaxpayer.org. On Point JARRETT SKORUP, MACKINAC CENTER FOR PUBLIC POLICY Detroit: The triumph of progressive public policy Imagine a city where all the major economic planks of the statist or “progressive” platform have been enacted: • A “living wage” ordinance, far above the federal minimum wage, for all public employees and private contractors. • A school system that spends significantly more per pupil than the national average. • A powerful school employee union that militantly defends the exceptional pay, benefits and job security it has won for its members. • A powerful government employee union that does the same for its members. • A tax system that aggressively redistributes income from businesses and the wealthy to the poor and to government bureaucracies. Would this be a shining city on a hill, exciting the admiration of all? We don’t have to guess, because there is such a city right here in our state: Detroit Detroit has been dubbed “the most liberal city in America” and each of these “progressive” policies is alive and well there. How have they worked out? In 1950, Detroit was the wealthiest city in America on a per capita income basis. Today, the Census Bureau reports that it is the nation’s 2nd poorest major city, just “edging out” Cleveland. Could it be pure coincidence that the decline occurred over the same period in which union power, the city government bureaucracy, taxes and business regulations all multiplied? While correlation is not causation, it is striking that the decline in per capita income is exactly what classical economists predict would occur when wage controls are imposed and taxes are increased. Specif ically, “price theory” predicts that artificially high business costs caused by excessive regulation and above-market labor compensation rates imposed by so-called “living wages” will lead to an increase in unemployment. Detroit’s minimum wage is a whopping $7.40 an hour, more than $2 above the federal minimum wage when it was enacted; and pressure groups are pushing for more. Additionally, any company contracting with the city must pay its employees $8.23 an hour if they offer benef its or $10.28 an hour if they do not offer benefits. Such high wage mandates are especially hard on individuals with a poor education and low skills. If struggling and heavily taxed businesses cannot pay such high wages, then they are more selective about the few workers they do hire or go out of business altogether. Those who have promulgated these polices may be well intentioned, but mainstream economists have warned for decades that such policies were very likely to bring about the abject poverty and unemployment that characterize Detroit today. The city has the highest unemployment rate among all large U.S. cities. (On a side note, Michigan is home to eight of the 20 cities overall with the highest unemployment and has the highest state unemployment in the country.) A similar pattern has played out in public education. It is now conventional wisdom among the political class that higher pay for teachers and increased spending per student lead to improvements in teacher quality and student performance. Again, correlation is not causation, but Detroit Public Schools strongly suggests that this theory must be rejected. It has chronically underperformed state averages, yet reforms are vehemently opposed by the system’s powerful school employee union. At the same time that union, the Detroit Federation of Teachers, has won rich salary and benef its packages for its members. Median compensation for a DPS teacher is $76,000 and Detroit spends the third highest amount of money per student among 76 large cities nationwide. Statewide, Detroit’s spending per pupil is in the 91st percentile and DPS teachers are paid at the 96th percentile. For all that, by almost any measure Detroit schools have for decades failed their students: test scores, safety, drop out rates, etc. For example, Detroit’s public school students perform at the 3rd percentile in the state — that is, they are in the lowest 3 percent, and the district is in its second state takeover in a decade. In the private sector such failure would result in mass firings for unsatisfactory performance. No doubt such a response would be condemned by the progressives who support the school employee unions that have made similar actions impossible in their institutions, and have opposed major transformation at every turn. For example, in 2003 philanthropist Bob Thompson offered $200 million to build 15 charter public schools in the city in which he would guarantee a 90 percent graduation rate. In response, the DFT balked because charter schools are not unionized. The outcome was that the union jobs trumped better outcomes for children. People vote with their feet, and all the above suggests why, over the past decade, DPS has lost about 10,000 students each year to charter, independent and suburban schools. Of course it would be unfair to place all the blame for the city’s decline on public employee unions. Detroit is home to the Big Three, whose contracts with their own powerful unions provided the model for those public employee arrangements. The UAW successfully extracted wages and benefits estimated at $71 per hour before the recent shake-ups began. This is about $25 more per hour than the amount foreignowned U.S. auto manufacturing plants pay their non-unionized American workers. Due to this disparity, Japanese car companies earn some $1,000 to $2,000 more on each car sold than their American counterparts. The outcome has been a relentless loss of market share that, among other things, has devastated the economic engine that once powered Motor City prosperity. In addition to being a model of progressive economic, labor and education policy, Detroit is also a case study in welfare statism. Tom Bray, former editorial page editor for The Detroit News, has made the following observation: “Detroit, remember, was going to be the ‘Model City’ of Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society, the shining example of what the ‘fairness’ of the welfare state can produce. Billions of dollars later, Detroit instead has become the model of everything that can go wrong when you hook people on the idea of something for nothing - a oncemiddle class city of nearly 2 million that is now a poverty-stricken city of less than 900,000.” Progressives will complain that this portrait oversimplif ies the factors involved in a great city’s decline. Perhaps it does, but with this question in mind: At what point does the weight of evidence and logic make it impossible to avoid concluding that in the case of Detroit, correlation is causation? ————— Jarrett Skorup is a 2009 graduate of Grove City College with a dual major in history and political science. He is a research intern at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, a research and educational institute headquartered in Midland, Mich. Founded 1895 Suzanne Favale Publisher Tom Kirvan Editor in Chief Brian Cox Editor [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Paul Arlon Director of Advertising Sales Dawn Keith, Carol Raeside Probate Representatives [email protected] [email protected], [email protected] Taryn Hartman Staff Writer Christine L. Mobley Staff Writer [email protected] [email protected] Deborah James Graphic Designer Ban Ibrahim Circulation Ann Gjolaj Production Mark Weatherford Web Master [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] The Detroit Legal News Publishing L.L.C. Bradley L. Thompson II President [email protected] Suzanne Favale Publisher Steve Fowler Treasurer [email protected] [email protected] Published Daily Except Saturday and Sunday by The Detroit Legal News Co. Detroit Legal News, 2001 W. Lafayette, Detroit, MI 48216 PHONE: (313) 961-3949, or toll-free: 1-800-875-5275. FAX: 248-577-6111 Postmaster: Send address changes to: The Detroit Legal News 2001 W. Lafayette Detroit, MI 48216 PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID AT DETROIT, MICHIGAN. USPS 0155-580 Subscription rates, payable in advance: $140.00 One Year Back copies after 30 days available at $1.25 each. ADVERTISING RATES ON REQUEST Under no circumstances will any Judgment, Decree or other matter of record be withheld from publication in this paper. QUALIFIED under all statutory requirements for the publication of public and legal notices including a 100% paid circulation status, existence of over two years and Act 246 of 1993 requiring an average of 25% general and legal news content. The reproduction in whole or in part of any item appearing herein for the purpose of sale or republication without permission is expressly prohibited. Member of Associated Press (AP) Member: American Court and Commercial Newspapers, Inc. Michigan Press Association ASSOCIATED LEGAL PUBLICATIONS Oakland County Legal News, Macomb County Legal News, Flint-Genesee County Legal News, Washtenaw County Legal News, Jackson County Legal News, Ingham County Legal News, Grand Rapids Legal News, Muskegon County Legal News. The Detroit Legal News is printed on recycled newsprint using soy based ink at the Inland Press in Detroit. DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 4 Page 4, The Detroit Legal News FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Classified To Submit Classified Ads call 1-800-875-5275 CLASSIFIED AD RATES DISPLAY RATES 1 day — $23/inch 2-9 days — $17/inch/day 10-19 days — $13/inch/day 20+ days — $11/inch/day INSTRUCTIONS: All advertising insertion orders are due 48 hours prior to publication date. Orders can be accepted by phone, by Fax or by writing: Inch is approximately 7 lines with 4 to 5 words per line. Advertising Dept. Detroit Legal News 1409 Allen Drive, Suite B Troy, MI 48083-4003 800-875-5275 BOX NUMBERS are available at $9.00 per ad. Please request a box number assignment when placing ad. Fax No. 248-577-6111 All real estate advertised herein is subject to the Federal Fair Housing Act, which makes it illegal to advertise any preference, limitation, or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin, or intention to make any such preference, limitation, or discrimination. We will not knowingly accept any advertising for real estate which is in violation of the law. All persons are hereby informed that all dwellings advertised are available on an equal opportunity basis. EQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITY ERRORS: The Detroit Legal News and its advertisers assume no financial responsibility for typographical errors in classified advertising but will reprint without charge a corrected version of the ad. The Detroit Legal News will be responsible for one incorrect insertion only. ✂ Clip and mail Place Your Classified Ad Now! It’s as easy as A, B, C. (A) Write your ad on the form below. (B) Clip the form and (C) mail it with your check, your Visa, or MasterCard number, your address and your phone number. This form is for a 1-inch ad, which holds 4 to 5 words per line. For a 1-inch ad, the cost will be: ❐ 1 Day @ $23 col. inch ❐ 2-9 Days @ $17 col. inch ❐ 10-19 Days @ $13 col. inch ❐ 20+ Days @ $11 col. inch ■ A 1-inch ad will hold approximately 35 words. ■ A 1-inch ad is not a minimum size. For larger sizes, please call for rates. Detroit Legal News ❐ 1409 Allen Drive, Suite B; Troy, MI 48083 Check enclosed ❐ Visa ❐ MasterCard Name on Card: ____________________________________________________________ Phone No.: __________________ Card No: _________________________________________________________________ Expiration Date: ____________________ Address: _________________________________________ City: ____________________ State: _________ ■ Phone: 800.875.5275 ■ Fax: 248.577.6111 LEGAL SECRETARY WANTED FOR RENT ATTORNEY WANTED New Luxury Condos Plaintiff P.I. Litigation Firm requires experienced Litigator, 3+ years, to join team-oriented practice. Knowledge of Michigan N-F and Premises Liability. Excellent writing, computer, and communication skills are required. O F F I C E S PAC E AVA I L A B L E BINGHAM OFFICE PARK LAW OFFICES ■ e-mail: [email protected] DETROIT WATERFRONT , , , , ANN ARBOR Forward resume to: Detroit Legal News-Box 1478 1409 Allen Drive, Suite B Troy, MI 48083 , , , , BIRMINGHAM Short- or long-term lease available. Fully furnished spacious units. 1, 2 and 3 bedroom units available. 248.733.0333 TEMPORARY VIP SUITES Call OOOOOOOO DELUXE OFFICES FOR RENT Reception, photocopy, library services & secretary. To share available, attractive and professional office suite. NEED FURNITURE? Call Judy at has brand name furniture available for lease or sale. We have what you need for an apartment, home, cottage or dorm room. Short- or long-term leases give you flexibility and keep you on budget. Call today (248) 645-1700 EXPEDITE YOUR PUBLIC NOTICES Fax them to the FAX 248.577.6111 AFR Furniture Rental 248.733.0344 AFR Furniture Rental State-Wide Ads -FOR SALEPOND LAKE PROBLEMS ? Algae and weed control, aeration systems, windmill aerators, pond consultation, equipment installation, fish stocking. Free catalog. Harrietta Hills Trout Farm 877389-2514. www.harriettahills.com and Present? If the Kugel patch was removed due to complications of bowel perforation, abdominal wall tears, puncture of abdominal organs or intestinal fistulae, you may be entitled to compensation. Attorney Charles Johnson 1-800-535-5727. -FOR SALESAWMILLS FROM ONLY $2,990.00 Convert your logs to valuable lumber with your own Norwood Portable band sawmill. Log skidders also available. www.norwoodsawmills.com/300n - Free information: 1-800-5781363 ext. 300-N. -MISCELLANEOUSCRIMINAL RECORD? MISDEMEANOR, FELONY? Have them expunged for $99.95, 30 to 60 days including DUIs. Get a fresh start today. Call 1-800-621-4889 24/7days. -FOR SALESCHROEDER LOG HOME SUPPLY, Inc., Quality Log Home Products. Construction or Maintenance. Shipping from MN, MT, IN, TN. Free catalog available. 1800-359-6614. www.loghelp.com -MISCELLANEOUSHERNIA REPAIR? DID YOU Receive a Composix Kugel Mesh Patch between Januar y 2001 Zip: ____________ -MISCELLANEOUSREACH 3.1 MILLION Michigan readers with a 2 x 2 display ad for only $999 - Contact the Legal News at 1-800-875-5275 for details. -MISCELLANEOUSPLACE YOUR STATEWIDE AD HERE! $299 buys a 25-word classified ad offering over 1.6 million circulation and 3.6 million readers. Contact the Legal News at 1-800-875-5275 for details. Edited by Will Shortz Across 1 Important church 8 Like controversial issues 15 Bob Marley classic 16 It lets you see who’s calling 17 Something to prove 18 Fictional psychiatrist 19 “___ sow’t with nettle-seed”: Shak. 20 Gang members 22 Year in Nero’s reign 23 Psychoanalyst Fromm 25 From, in some European names 26 It may be worn on a sneaker 28 Phnom Penh cash 29 Like many an omen 31 Works in the Uffizi 32 Poorhouse bedding 35 Termini 36 Totally benign 42 It’s often pinched 43 Act rudely, in a way 44 Foul 56 Got high gradually 58 Like Victor Hugo when he finished “Les Misérables” 59 Pole position or pool position 60 Some like them hot 61 Registered for Down 1 They deliver 45 Street magician 2 Be a willing ___ Angel participant? 47 Character lineup 3 Requiring more 48 Proceed (from) support 49 Regional setting 4 Brief warning for almost eight 5 What an months per yr. unrequited lover 50 It may begin with carries an exordium 6 Loving leader? 7 30-Down 53 Got into a thoroughly pickle? 8 Billy the Kid 54 1912 headline used one for his name nickname 9 Jane ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE Rochester’s H A M L E T D E I S T S maiden name P O S T U R E R E S O R T S 10 Half of a Disney I N T A I L S A L L R I S E duo, with “the” C O O P S T A W A B B I E 11 They often mean A R L O F S L I C S U M P “I see” R E A A L I E N O R T O E D E T O N A T E L E G E N D 12 Slaves 13 Up P E T E R O S E H I T S A T M O R E L A N D 14 Pooh-poohs E O E R A R E B I T I E R 21 One between A D M S X E N O N A L A E two cardinals? P I P E T C U T I G E T A 24 Red choices E D U A R D O I G N O R E D 27 Part of a D E R N I E R C I T R O N S backwoods mixS A S S E D S L O A N S up 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 15 16 17 18 20 19 23 9 11 12 13 14 40 41 22 25 26 29 28 10 21 24 32 No. 0605 30 33 27 31 34 35 36 37 38 39 43 42 45 46 49 50 54 44 47 48 51 55 52 56 58 59 60 61 53 57 Puzzle by Martin Ashwood-Smith 29 Lets off 48 Regarding 30 See 7-Down 51 Moon marking 37 Subway rider during rush hour, metaphorically 33 Not sanguine 38 Striking brilliance 34 ___ Reiss Merin, 39 Post, for one babysitter player 40 Make a B in “Don’t Tell instead of an A? Mom the Babysitter’s 41 Like some Dead” profanity 46 “Peter and the 36 Like some Wolf” duck monks 52 North African harbor site 55 Bad ___, Mich. (seat of Huron County) 57 Peruvian capital? For answers, call 1-900-285-5656, $1.49 a minute; or, with a credit card, 1-800-814-5554. Annual subscriptions are available for the best of Sunday crosswords from the last 50 years: 1-888-7-ACROSS. AT&T users: Text NYTX to 386 to download puzzles, or visit nytimes.com/mobilexword for more information. Online subscriptions: Today’s puzzle and more than 2,000 past puzzles, nytimes.com/crosswords ($39.95 a year). Share tips: nytimes.com/wordplay. Crosswords for young solvers: nytimes.com/learning/xwords. Mortgages Recorded Bernard J. Youngblood Register of Deeds As recorded in the office of the Register of Deeds $50,000 and above The mortgage lender (i.e. ABN AMRO MTG GROUP) as indicated by capital letters and applies to all subsequent listings until another lender is noted. May 18 - May 22, 2009 Michele M Farbstrom 13572 Crosley Redford 4 8 2 3 9 - 4 5 1 9 PA R K S I D E CREDIT UNION $33,000 Dino Makowski 39595 Winesap St Plymouth 48170-4551 PHH MTG SERVICES $91,000 Sachiko Reidy 1297 Crowndale Ln Canton 4 8 1 8 8 - 6 2 1 1 P L AT I N U M HOME MTG CORP $192,000 P a u l A Po w e l l 1 2 7 Clarence St Belleville 48111-2775 PLAZA HOME MTG INC $187,000 Nicole Sawyer 27231 5 Mile Rd Redford 482393960 POLARIS HOME FUNDING CORP $54,000 Demeka Saffold 13997 Sarasota Redford 482392836 $75,000 To nya L Va rc o e 5 3 8 N Hanlon St We s t l a n d 48185-8505 $162,000 Mariana Idita 27808 Pe r t h S t L i vo n i a 4 8 1 5 4 4673 $79,000 Philip J Said 44273 Richmond Ct Canton 48187-1919 $139,000 Scott Fluharty 1100 17th St Wyandotte 481923100 PRIMARY RESIDENT I A L M O R T G AG E I N C $111,000 Karen Sklar Aka 78 K e r c h e v a l Av e G r o s s e Pointe Farms 48236-3604 P R I VAT E B A N K AND TRUST CO $50,000 Folkert Schmidt 310 H i l l c r e s t Av e G r o s s e Pointe Farms 48236-3116 FUNDING P R OV I D E N T ASSOC $217,000 Tina Mroue 22812 Cherry Hill St Dearborn 48124-1021 $107,000 Benjamin J Czerniawski 840 Sunningdale Dr G r o s s e Po i n t e Wo o d s 48236-1630 $280,000 Amy Alper t 9357 W Walden Dr Van Buren Twp 48111-2491 $156,000 John J Roy 43532 Karli Ln Canton 48188-1700 $141,000 Ling Wang 48987 Runn i n g Tro u t L n N o r t h v i l l e 48168-6842 $195,000 George W Gibson Iii St 19508 Pinehurst 48221-1426 Detroit $103,000 Bassam Hamade 16506 Winchester Dr Northville 48168-2370 $131,000 Brent W Coffey 16062 Culpepper Rd Browns t o w n To w n s h i p 4 8 1 7 3 9670 $186,000 Stamatina E Ziemba 1 3 1 5 G r ay t o n S t G ro s s e Po i n t e Pa r k 4 8 2 3 0 - 1 1 2 7 $50,000 Melissa Sorenen 31219 S t e p h e n Av e W e s t l a n d 48185-1636 $138,000 M e l v i n Wa l l a c e 1 8 2 7 6 Lindsay St Detroit 482353242 $31,000 Elizabeth C Mangan Richmond St 14843 Southgate 48195-3708 $45,000 Wa l t e r A J a c e k 4 9 7 6 Mckinley St Dearborn 48125-2513 Heights $26,000 Brian Brenner 667 Lakepointe St Grosse Po i n t e Pa r k 4 8 2 3 0 - 1 7 0 3 $243,000 Ali Awada 7311 Rutherford St Detroit 48228-4820 $50,000 Delores Greer 223 Windward Ct Detroit 48207-5054 PUBLIC SERVICE CREDIT UNION $20,000 Juanita Rembert 42819 W i n d i n g Po n d Tr l Va n B u r e n Tw p 4 8 1 1 1 - 7 2 0 4 $170,000 Rodger Prong 14233 Merriman Rd Livonia 48154-4262 $107,000 Cheryl Sharpley 15526 P l a i nv i e w Av e D e t r o i t 48223-1769 $43,000 Carol M Doyle 579 Morgan Ct Nor thville 481672724 $136,000 Archana Somayaji 7335 Hedgerow Ct Canton 48187-1565 $179,000 Scot Havera Aka 16917 Ln Romulus Hawick 48174-3192 $30,000 Robert J Wa t e r s 2 4 1 5 2 G r a n d Tr a v e r s e Av e B r o w n s t o w n To w n ship 48134-8050 $149,000 Cathy Harless 3811 Mckinley St Dearborn 48124-3675 $114,000 German Barbe Aka 15540 Windmill Pointe Dr Grosse Po i n t e Park 48230-1857 QUICKEN LOANS INC $335,000 David S Warunek 24399 Emily Dr Brownstown To w n s h i p 48183-5415 $168,000 Liviu Maghear 8162 Riverdale St Dearborn Heights 48127-1569 $86,000 Arlene F Tomasz ewski 6910 Amboy St Dearborn Heights 48127-1904 $129,000 Melody Blackman 44625 Cranbrook Ct Canton 48188-1672 $163,000 Jerri K Mcmahon 8533 Mathias Dr Grosse Ile 48138-2307 $115,000 L a t o ya D M a r t i n 5 2 6 0 Yo r k s h i r e R d D e t r o i t 48224-2139 $85,000 Barbara A Kalil 33867 Elmira Ct Livonia 481505636 $230,000 Joseph M Cody 950 D o u g l a s S t G a rd e n C i t y 48135-3062 $159,000 Jennifer Buchanan 32318 Wisconsin St Livonia 48150-3882 $174,000 K a r e n A Tr a c y 2 8 5 0 1 Brandes Rd Brownstown 48134-9741 RBS CITIZENS $100,000 Jerome A Dietz 6613 N E va n g e l i n e S t D e a r b o r n Heights 48127-2030 $84,000 Arl Ene J Labadie Dr We s t wo o d 23262 B r o w n s t o w n To w n s h i p 48183-3255 $122,000 Usha Maheshkar Aka 3 7 7 Tr o o n L n C a n t o n 48188-3098 $14,000 Thomas J Siepierski 1637 Nightingale St Dearborn 48128-1068 $157,000 Helen Costis 267 Victorian Ln Belleville 481114936 $150,000 Ibrahim Hasson Aka 6934 Steadman St Dearborn 48126-1761 $39,000 J o y c e Wa r d 23825 Ashley Dr Brownstown 48134-9095 To w n s h i p $149,000 Anthony Rimanelli 298 University Pl Grosse 48230-1636 Po i n t e $237,000 C D Bargamian 8615 Cadillac Cir Grosse Ile 48138-2217 $178,000 Deanna Pusdesris 8150 Burning Bush Rd Grosse Ile 48138-1304 $227,000 Helen E Donahoe 12742 Catalpa St Southgate 48195-1208 $73,000 David Edick 20137 M a p l ewo o d S t L i vo n i a 48152-2050 $168,000 D a v i d J Po r e m b i a k 2 0 1 7 5 L a u r e l D r L i vo n i a 48152-1196 $235,000 Marita Horia 5725 Jonathon St Dearborn 48126-2247 $23,000 Yu h a s z E Robert 18226 Parkshore Dr Northville 48168-8588 $417,000 Robert E Yu h a s z Dr 18226 Parkshore Northville 48168-8588 $47,000 Karen K Liederbach 1047 Whittier Rd Grosse Po i n t e Pa r k 4 8 2 3 0 - 1 4 6 0 $200,000 Barbara S Fisher 26841 C o a c h l i g h t S t Tr e n t o n 48183-5302 RIVERS EDGE COMMUNITY CREDIT UNION $168,000 Dennis A Guzenda 4109 19th St Wyandotte 481926927 $25,000 Robert N Ellis 10832 B a r ag a S t Tay l o r 4 8 1 8 0 3729 $76,000 Ann M Boggs 9377 N i v e r Av e A l l e n P a r k 48101-1541 $50,000 Shawver Chevonna 19951 Pierson St Detroit 48219-1357 ROCKWELL MTG CO $52,000 Debra M Bumstead 29816 Bayview Dr Grosse Ile 48138-1959 $59,000 Kathryn Pulk 7817 A u g u s t Av e W e s t l a n d 48185-2505 ROSS MTG CORP $80,000 Stamatina E Ziemba 1 3 1 5 G r ay t o n S t G ro s s e Po i n t e Pa r k 4 8 2 3 0 - 1 1 2 7 $100,000 Amy K Clor 1050 Hawthorne Rd Grosse Pointe Woods 48236-1466 $142,000 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 5 The Detroit Legal News, Page 5 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Road Construction Report For additional details click on: www.AAATraffic.com. For recorded road condition information, call 1-800-AAA-MICH (222-6424). To report accidents and slowdowns, call 1-877TIP-ROAD (847-7623). Long-term projects are listed by interstate, U.S. and M route designations. Adverse weather conditions and other unforeseen situations can sometimes add to the length of a project’s timetable. AAA Traffic reminds motorists that despite rigorous safety precautions, road work is dangerous business ... and it could be costly to you. Injuring or killing anyone in a work zone could get you a large fine and jail time. So reduce your speed and your stress ... and drive smart right from the start. Key: “ * ” = a revised listing “ ** ” = a new listing METRO DETROIT: I-75 * In Wayne County, the North Huron River Drive entrance ramp to southbound I-75 is closed until July 15. * In Wayne County, the southbound I-75 exit ramp to westbound Gibraltar Road (29B) is closed until July 15. Exit 29A is the alternate exit. In Wayne County, Woodruff over I-75 is closed through July 15. * In Wayne County, I-75 is now open between I-96 and Clark Street. Intermittent lane closures, along with some ramp and surface street closures, remain in place until mid August as work is completed. I-94 * In Macomb and St. Clair counties, there are lane closures and shifted traffic on I-94 between St. Clair Highway and the Macomb County line until August 31. The Adair rest area is also closed. I-96 In Wayne County, the eastbound I-96 ramp to southbound I-75 is closed until December 1. I-94, M-39 and I-75 are the alternate routes. In Wayne County, repairs are being made to 13 bridges above I-96 between Livernois and Davison avenues until fall 2010. I-96, I-696 * In Oakland County, Halsted Road between Hills Tech Drive and Howard Street is closed until late August; the ramps from Novi Road to eastbound I-96 are closed until late October; there are lane shifts on I-96 between Beck Road and M-5 until September 15 (eastbound) and July 13 (west- early August. Also, the right lane on eastbound mainline Eight Mile is closed. In Wayne County, the left lane of eastbound Eight Mile Road is closed between Van Dyke and I-94 through July 18. bound); and the ramp from southbound M-5 to westbound I96 is closed until July 13. I-696 In Macomb County, the left lane in each direction of I-696 is closed between I-94 and Hayes Road, along with a single lane on the ramp from eastbound I-94 to westbound I-696, until August 3. In Macomb County, the northbound and southbound Mound entrance ramps to I-696 in both directions are closed until late August. In Macomb County, the eastbound I-696 exit ramp to 11 Mile Road is closed until September 4. In Oakland County, both shoulders on I-696 east of Orchard Lake Road are closed until July 25. In Oakland County, watch for the lane restrictions on the following roads which cross over I696 until late July: Southfield Road, one lane open southbound and three lanes open northbound; Greenfield Road, one lane open in each direction; Coolidge Highway, one lane open southbound and three lanes open northbound. In Oakland County, watch for the following restrictions: the Meadowbrook bridge is closed until July 28. The detour is 12 Mile Road, Novi Road and Grand River; the Lahser Road on ramp to eastbound I-696 is closed until July 7; the Evergreen Road on ramp to westbound I-696 is closed until July 7; Orchard Lake Road over I-696 is reduced to two lanes in each direction until early August. In conjunction, the southbound Orchard Lake loop ramp to eastbound I-696 is closed until July 15. US-12 (Michigan Avenue) In Wayne County, US-12 is reduced to two lanes in each direction between Evergreen Road and M-39 (Southfield Freeway) until July 31. Also, watch for intermittent daytime closures of an additional westbound lane here through July 31; US-12 is down to one lane in each direction between Monroe and Elm until July 31: the eastbound US-12 ramp to southbound M-39 is closed through July 31; the eastbound US-12 ramp to northbound Evergreen is closed until November 1; and the southbound Evergreen ramp to eastbound US-12 is closed until November 1. US-24 (Telegraph Road) In Wayne County, southbound Telegraph is 26 Mile Road In Macomb County, 26 Mile Road over M-53 is closed until July 31. Also, the ramp from eastbound 26 Mile Road to southbound M-53, and the southbound M-53 exit to westbound 26 Mile, are closed until late July. being resurfaced between Plymouth and Joy roads, while both directions are improved between Vreeland Road and South Huron River Drive. M-3 In Macomb County, northbound Gratiot is closed at the railroad tracks near M-59 until August 12. M-14 In Wayne County, watch for single and double lane closures on M-14 in both directions between Beck Road and I-275 until approximately September 10. Grand River Avenue In Oakland County, Grand River is down to one lane in each direction between Farmington and Power roads until July 20. After July 20, traffic will be shifted to the north side of the road until sometime in October. SOUTHEAST: I-69 In St. Clair County, I-69 traffic is down to one shifted lane in each direction on the eastbound side from Miller Road to the county line until October 15. M-39 (Southfield Freeway) * In Wayne County, the southbound M-39 exit to Grand River is closed until July 9. I-75 In Monroe County, Sterns Road over I-75 is closed. Two lanes of traffic are open both ways on I-75, with brief, off-peak full closures planned. M-125, Manhattan and Summit are the alternate routes until August 31. M-53 In Macomb County, during peak travel times, two shifted lanes are open in each direction on M53 between 18 Mile and 27 Mile roads. During overnights and weekends, only one lane is open each way. The northbound M-53 to westbound 23 Mile Road is closed until August 1. The end date for all of this work is November 15. I-94 * In Jackson County, watch for nighttime lane closures in each direction on I-94 between West Avenue and Sargent Road until July 14. * In Jackson County, Hawkins Road over I-94 is closed and traffic is detoured until early October. Also, until July 18, the outside shoulders on I-94 at Hawkins are closed. M-85 (Fort Street) In Wayne County, southbound M-85 is closed between Gibraltar Road and I-75, and the southbound on ramp to southbound I-75 is closed, until July 15. I-94 Business Loop In Jackson County, there are single lane closures in each direction on the I-94 Business Loop/Michigan Avenue between Perrine and Elm streets until July 24. In Washtenaw County, one lane of eastbound Huron Street is closed at State Street until September 30. Also, State Street northbound is closed north of Washington Street. Fletcher and Huron are the alternate routes. M-102 (Eight Mile Road) In Oakland and Wayne counties, the Eight Mile Road service drive bridges over M-10 (Lodge Freeway) are closed and detoured until I-96 In Livingston County, watch for intermittent midday, overnight and weekend lane closures in each direction on I-96 between US-23 and the Livingston/Oakland line until November 30. The Kensington Road bridge is closed until August 7, and the Pleasant Valley Road bridge will be repaired later this summer. US-12 (Michigan Avenue) In Washtenaw County, there is a single lane closure and a 12-foot width restriction on US-12 at and to a point one-half mile west of State Road until July 31. Platt, Bemis and Industrial Drive are the alternate routes. US-127 In Jackson County, US-127 is down to one lane in each direction on the east side of the road Ayers Road and Floyd Avenue through August 13. US-223 In Lenawee County, watch for lane restrictions and shifted traffic on US-223 near Treat Highway until September 5. M-17 (Washtenaw Avenue) In Washtenaw County, the center three lanes are closed in each direction on M-17 between Carpenter Road and Normal Street in Ypsilanti through August 31. M-36 In Livingston County, there are intermittent midday shoulder and single lane closures on M36 in each direction at Merrill Road through August 27. In Livingston County, M-36 will close for two weeks or less near Pettys Road. When it reopens, one lane will be maintained in each direction until late August. M-50 In Lenawee County, there are shoulder closures, width limits and flagger-controlled daytime traffic on M-50 from Nortley Highway to M-52 through September 30. In Monroe County, watch for midday and overnight alternating single lane traffic controlled by flaggers on M-50 (South Custer Road) from Lewis Avenue to US-24 (Telegraph Road) through July 15. M-59 In Livingston County, there are midday single lane closures in each direction of M-59 between US-23 and Clark Road until September 30. www.AAATRAFFIC.com Wayne County Probate Court Approved List of Mediators AVAILABLE INFORMATION LAST UPDATED 10-26-07 H. ROLLIN. ALLEN Sommers Schwartz 2000 Town Center, Suite 900 Southfield, MI 48075 (248) 355-0300 Hourly rate: $250 TRACY L. ALLEN Sommers, Schwartz, Silver, Schwartz 2000 Town Center, Suite 900 Southfield, MI 48075 (248) 355-0300 Hourly rate: $300 BARBARA P. ANDRUCCIOLI Kemp, Klein, Umphrey, Endelman & May, P.C. 201 W. Big Beaver Road, Suite 600 Troy, MI 48084 (248) 740-5683 Hourly rate: $180 DANIEL G. BEYER Kerr, Russell & Weber 500 Woodward Avenue, Suite 2500 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 961-0200 Hourly rate: $225 CURTIS B. BLESSING Curtis B. Blessing, P.C. 645 Griswold Street, Suite 4300 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 963-3344 Hourly rate: $195-$225 ANGELINE BILLUPS 655 Rivard, #304 Detroit, MI 48207 (313) 567-0474 Hourly rate: $150 JOSEPH A. BONVENTRE Clark Hill PLC 500 Woodward Avenue, Suite 3500 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 965-8293 Hourly rate: $250 GARRY I. BORIN Garry I. Borin, P.C. 24520 Meadowbrook Novi, MI 48375 (248) 478-8260 Hourly rate: $160 JOSEPH M. BOURBEAU Joseph M. Bourbeau, P.C. 23100 Jefferson St. Clair Shores, MI 48080 (586) 778-1234 Hourly rate: $200-$300 SUSAN BUTTERWICK Law Office of Susan Butterwick 2950 S. State Street, Suite 300 Ann Arbor, MI 48104 (734) 665-4808 Hourly rate: $150 BARBARA CLARK Clark Consulting 3520 N. Sand Lake Road Allen, MI 49227 Hourly rate: $150 MARGARET A. COSTELLO Dykema Gossett, PLLC ($1500 per day) 400 Renaissance Center Detroit, MI 48243 (313) 568-5306 Hourly rate: $300 ($1,500 per day) COMMUNITY DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROGRAM Wayne Mediation Center 19855 W. Outer Drive, Suite 206 – East Building Dearborn, MI 48124 (313) 561-3500 Rate: $200 per mediation KAREN C. CRUSSE Law Office of Karen C. Crusse 525 E. Big Beaver Rd., Suite 250 Troy, MI 48083 (248) 743-6800 Hourly rate: $150 MARK R. DANCER Mark R. Dancer, Esq. 100 Park St Traverse City, MI 49684 (616) 929-0500 Hourly rate: $250 DENISE M. HUDSON DEAN Law Office of Denise M. Hudson Dean 645 Griswold, Suite 717 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 964-5945 Hourly rate: $175 LAWRENCE DONALDSON Plunkett & Cooney, P.C. 10 S. Main Street, Suite 400 Mt. Clemons, MI 48230 (586) 783-7633 Hourly rate: $250 CYNTHIA L.M. JOHNSON Couzens, Lansky, Fealk, Ellis 645 Griswold, Suite 1301 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 967-9000 Hourly rate: $230 (including preparation time) J. PATRICK MARTIN Law Office of J. Patrick Martin 1663 Hoit Tower Bloomfield Hills, MI 48302 (248) 932-8694 Hourly rate: $175-$200 PATRICIA GORMELY PRINCE Patricia Gormely Prince, P.C. 31300 Northwestern Highway Farmington Hills, MI 48334-2523 (248) 865-8810 Hourly rate: $225 LAWRENCE G. SNYDER Kemp Klein Law Firm 201 West Big Beaver, Suite 600 Troy, MI 48084 (248) 528-1111 Hourly rate: $185 FREEMAN L. FARROW Miller, Canfield, Paddock and Stone, PLC 150 West Jefferson, Suite 2500 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 496-7598 Hourly rate: $200 HON. DAVID P. KERWIN 4162 Breckenridge Drive West Bloomfield, MI 48322 (248) 797-3409 Hourly rate: $175 SHARON MILLER 4455 West 14 Mile Road Royal Oak, MI 48073 (248) 549-8544 Rate: $500 per mediation (up to 4 hours) DALTON A. ROBERSON 640 Apelehama Circle Diamondhead MS 39925 (228) 255-6027 — or — 8900 E. Jefferson, Apt. 626 Detroit, MI 48214 (313) 822-0419 Hourly rate: $200 (Negotiable) MICHAEL J. SOLNER Solner & Solner 2057 Orchard Lake Road Sylvan Lake, MI 48320 (248) 334-5200 Hourly rate: $190 MICHELE P. FULLER Fuller & Stubbs, PLLC 45700 Village Blvd. Shelby Township, MI 48315 (586) 532-9100 Rate: $1,500 per day FREDERIC I. KEYWELL Executive Hotel Management Company 31800 Northwestern Hwy, Suite 130 Farmington Hills, MI 48334 (248) 626-7900 Hourly rate: $250 BYRON P. GALLAGHER, JR. The Gallagher Law Firm, PLC 2408 Lake Lansing Road Lansing, Michigan 48912 Hourly rate: $200 MARJORIE L. KOLIN Kolin & Associates 31555 W. 14 Mile Road, Suite 214 Farmington Hills, MI 48334 (248) 539-5400 Hourly rate: $205 MAXINE GRAFF GOODMAN Office of Maxine Graff Goodman 30965 Hitching Post Court Farmington Hills, MI 48331 (248) 891-7820 Hourly rate: $150 WILLIAM J. LAWSON, JR. Law Office of William J. Lawson, Jr. 8529 N. Territorial Plymouth, MI 48170 (734) 455-2245 Hourly rate: $180 MARK W. HAFELI Hafeli Staran Hallahan Christ & Dudek, PC 4190 Telegraph Road, Suite 3000 Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304-2361 (248) 731-3080 Hourly rate: $195 MICHAEL C. LEVINE Fraser, Trebilcock, Davis & Dunlap 124 W. Allegan, Suite 1000 Lansing, MI 48933 (517) 482-5800 Hourly rate: $190 EDWARD L. HAROUTUNIAN Haroutunian, Licata & Haroutunian 30700 Telegraph Road, Suite 3475 Bingham Farms, MI 48025 (248) 594-9071 Hourly rate: $200 SHAHEEN I. IMAMI Patricia Gormely Prince, P.C. 31300 Northwestern Highway Farmington Hills, MI 48334 (248) 865-8810 Hourly rate: $180 HOWARD T. LINDEN Law Office of Howard T. Linden 3000 Town Center, Suite 2200 Southfield, MI 48075 (248) 358-4545 Hourly rate: $175 HOWARD A. LISCHERON Wayne Mediation Center 19855 West Outer Drive Suite 206-East Building Dearborn Heights, MI 48124 (313) 561-3500 Rate: $450 per mediation JAMES MICHAEL MONDRO Pochelon Building 1000 Farmer Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 965-3464 Hourly rate: $150 PAUL F. MONICATTI 1301 W. Long Lake Road, Suite 355 Troy, MI 48098 (248) 641-3849 Hourly rate: $195-$250 JONATHAN L. MOODY Law Office of Jonathan L. Moody 719 Griswold – Suite 820 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 967-7787 Hourly rate: $125 LINDA MOORE 6015 Glen Eagles Drive West Bloomfield, MI 48323 (248) 681-0991 Rate: $150 per mediation (maximum of 3 hours per session) JEFFREY T. NEILSON Lipson, Neilson, Cole, Seltzer & Garin, P.C. 3910 Telegraph Road, Suite 200 Bloomfield Hills, MI 48302 (248) 593-5000 Hourly rate: $250 ANTHEA PAPISTA Urso, Palmer & Ross 535 Griswold, Suite 800 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 965-1688 Hourly rate: $200 MAYRA A. RODRIGUEZ Law Office of Mayra Rodriguez 1966 Penobscot Building Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 965-0586 Hourly rate: $200 RAMON F. ROLF, JR. Currie, Kendall, Polasky, Meisel, PLC 6024 Eastman Avenue P.O. Box 2765 Midland, MI 48641-2765 (989) 839-0300 Hourly rate: Negotiable CARL J. SCHOENINGER 16291 W. Fourteen Mile Road Suite 280 Beverly Hills, Michigan 48025 (248) 645-1122 Hourly rate: $225 DIANNE P. SCHULTZ Mediation Service 250 E. Harbortown Drive, #1209 Detroit, MI 48207 (313) 392-9334 Rate: $400 per mediation STEVEN L. SCHWARTZ ADR Solutions 24750 Lahser Road Southfield, MI 48034 (248) 355-9960 Hourly rate: $250-$300 CHARLENE SNOW 17517 Birchcrest Drive Detroit, MI 48221 (313) 342-4423 Hourly rate: $150-$175 CARTER H. STEVENSON 18205 Wildemere Detroit, MI 48221 (313) 224-6820 Rate: $600 per mediation JOELYNN STOKES J.T. Stokes & Associates, P.C. 23880 Woodward Avenue Pleasant Ridge, MI 48069 (248) 291-0500 Hourly rate: $150 TOWANA TATE Law Offices of Towana Tate, PC 30300 Northwestern Hwy., Suite 250 Farmington Hills, MI 48334 (248) 785-0200 x396 Hourly rate: $175 GUY VINING Berkley, Mengel & Vining 3100 Penobscot Building Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 961-0220 Hourly rate: $200 GEORGE WARD Law Office of George Ward P.O. Box 2148 Riverview, MI 48192 (734) 812-4173 Hourly rate: $150 JERMAINE A. WYRICK Law Office of Jermaine A. Wyrick, PLLC 615 Griswold, Suite 1610 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 964-8950 Hourly rate: $150 Last updated 10/26/07 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 6 Page 42, The Detroit Legal News FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Non-profit or Community Based Advocacy and Legal Projects These “free-standing” progra m s a r e n o t f u n d e d by t h e Legal Services Corporation and every program has unique client eligibility requirements. Attorneys interested in volunteering assistance should contact the programs directly to lear n of pro b o n o o p p o r t u n i t i e s. Po t e n t i a l clients are free to call them directly – each has an intake or screening process for callers in order to determine if the program will be able to help. Changes can occur often to this list so please double check the information listed below. ACCOUNTING AID SOCIETY Serves: Metro Detroit Tax Assistance Program 18145 Mack Avenue Detroit, MI 48224 Tel: (313) 647-9620 Fax: (313) 647-9628 E-mail: [email protected] Accounting Aid Society assists low-income taxpayers in preparing their personal income tax returns for free. AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FUND OF MICHIGAN Serves: Statewide 60 W. Hancock St. Detroit, MI 48201-1343 Tel: (313) 578-6800 (Intake Number) Fax (313) 578-6811 Website: www.aclumich.org American Civil Liber ties Union Fund of Michigan provides services in the following legal areas: • Constitutional Issues • Freedom of Speech • Due Process • Privacy CENTER FOR CIVIL JUSTICE Serves: Arenac, Bay, Clare, Genesee, Gladwin, Gratiot, Isabella, Lapeer, Midland and Saginaw Counties Statewide services on significant anti-hunger issues. 320 South Washington, 2 nd Floor Saginaw, MI 48607 Tel: (989) 755–3120 Fax: (989) 755–3558 Website: www.mlan.net/ccj Issue aler ts available on www.mplp.org; community education mater ials available on www.mlan.net and www.foodstamphelp.org. Newsletter: Michigan Connections (available by subscription) Center for Civil Justice emphasizes legal issues and services that cannot be funded by LSC-funded programs, with priority given to the following legal areas: • Public Benefits • Health • Housing – especially subsidized programs • Food Stamp and Nutrition Programs • Legal issues affecting groups of low income persons that requires advocacy that cannot be provided by an LSC-funded grantee due to funding restrictions • Work First / Education and Training programs Center for Civil Justice will design and present substantive and advocacy training for advocates and agencies, generally on a contract basis. CHILDREN'S LAW CENTER Serves: Kent County 1695 Service Rd. NE, Ste. 101 Grand Rapids, MI 49503 Tel: (616) 458–0330 Fax: (616) 458–8630 Website: www.grchildrenslawcenter.org Children’s Law Center provides ser vices in the following legal areas: • Divorce • Guardian ad litem • Custody • Juvenile matters • Probate (nonjuvenile) • Guardianship COMMON GROUND SANCTUARY LEGAL CLINIC Ser ves: Macomb, Oakland and Wayne Counties 1410 South Telegraph Bloomfield Hills, MI 48302 Tel: (248) 456-8158 Business Line (248) 456–0909 Crisis Line Fax (248) 456–8147 Common Ground Sanctuar y Legal Clinic provides services in the following legal areas: • Criminal • Domestic • Civil • Eviction • Wills • Probate • Guardian ad litem • Juvenile matters • Custody COMMUNITY LEGAL RESOURCES Serves: Statewide 900 Michigan Bldg. 220 Bagley Ave. Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 964–4130 Fax: (313) 964–1192 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.mlan.net/mls/clr.htm Community Legal Resources provides services to nonprofit organizations serving low-income or distressed neighborhoods in the following legal areas: • Corporate Law • Tax and Nonprofit Organizations Law • Other Business Law or Transactional Matters • Real Estate Law DETROIT LEGAL SERVICES CLINIC Serves: All counties in the Eastern District of Michigan Detroit Metropolitan Bar Association Volunteer Legal Services 645 Griswold, Suite 3550 Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 961–6120 Fax: (313) 965-0842 Website: www.detroitlawyer.org In conjunction with the Legal Aid and Defender Association of Detroit, Wayne County Neighborhood Legal Services and various other legal ser vice agencies. Detroit Legal Services Clinic provides services in the following legal areas: • Housing • Probate Matters • Tax/Employment • Real Estate • Consumer Rights • Guardianship ELDER LAW OF MICHIGAN, INC. Serves: Statewide 221 N. Pine Street Lansing, MI 48933 Tel: (517) 372-5959 Fax: (517) 372-0792 Elder Law of Michigan, Inc. is a non profit organization that serves the legal needs of seniors statewide through the Legal Hotline for Michigan Seniors, the Michigan/Ohio Pension Rights Project, Long Term Care Personal Responsibility Project. This organization houses the Michigan Long Term Care Ombudsman, which monitors and takes complaints of long term care facilities. FEDERAL CIVIL PRO BONO PROJECT Serves: All counties in the Eastern District of Michigan Detroit Metropolitan Bar Association Volunteer Legal Services 645 Griswold, Suite 3550 Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 961–6120 Fax: (313) 965-0842 Website: www.detroitlawyer.org In conjunction with the Michigan Trial Lawyers Association and the U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan. Federal Civil Pro Bono Project provides services to pro se clients in the following legal areas: • Prisoner Civil Rights • Employment Discrimination FIRST STEP LEGAL ADVOCACY PROJECT Serves: Western Wayne County and Downriver areas Taylor Office 26650 Eureka Road, Suite E Taylor, MI 48180-4835 Tel: (734) 955-3850 Fax (734) 955-3855 Toll-free (888) 453-5900 24 hour Help Line or (734) 459-5900 (Local) Plymouth Office 44567 Pinetree Drive Plymouth, MI 48170-3840 Tel: (734) 416-1111 Fax (734) 416-5555 First Step Legal Advocacy Project provides services in the following legal areas: • Domestic Violence • Sexual Assault FREE LEGAL AID CLINIC, INC. (FLAC) Serves: Wayne County 5435 Woodward Avenue Detroit, MI 48202 Tel: (313) 879-2429 Fax: (313) 577-3728 e-mail: [email protected] FLAC’s purpose is to render legal assistance to low-income and indigent residents of Wayne County in a manner which Wayne State University Law School students are educated in a clinical setting. FREEDOM HOUSE 2630 W. Lafayette Detroit, MI 48216-2019 Tel: (313) 964-4320 Fax: (313) 963-1077 E-mail: [email protected] Freedom House is a shelter for refugees seeking political asylum in the United States. The refugees live at Freedom House while their asylum cases are pending before the Immigration and Naturalization Ser vice. Freedom House is an interdenominational, nonprofit charity that provides food, clothing, shelter and social and legal services to people of all races and creeds. Its mission is to extend love and human dignity to people who have been devastated by torture and the denial of human rights. Freedom House works to legally resettle refugees into Canada or the United States, speaks out against injustice and educates for systemic change. All Freedom House residents are indigent. The purpose of Freedom House is to provide legal representation to indigent refugees seeking political asylum in the U.S. The Legal Department provides services in the following legal areas: • Prepares Asylum Applications for residents • Represents residents before the U. S. I m m i g r a t i o n C o u r t , t h e Board of Immigration Appeals and the federal courts. HAVEN Serves: Pontiac, Southfield, Farmington, Rochester Hills P.O. Box 430787 Pontiac, MI 48343-0787 P.O. Box 431045 Pontiac, MI 48343-1045 Tel: (248) 334-1284 Fax: (248) 334-3161 Website: www.haven-oakland.org Crisis and Support: (877) 922-1274 Haven provides services in the following legal areas: • Dedicated to the elimination of Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Child Abuse by providing prevention and treatment services throughout Oakland County. IMMIGRATION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM – DIOCESE OF KALAMAZOO Serves: Allegan, Barry, Berrien, Branch, Calhoun, Cass, Kalamazoo, St. Joseph and Van Buren 1128 Race Street Kalamazoo, MI 49001 Tel: (616) 385-1019 Fax: (616) 344-6602 Immigration Assistance Project – Hispanic American Council provides services in the following legal areas: • General Consultations • Family Based Immigration Petitions • Adjustment of Status Applications • Naturalization Applications • Violence Against Women Act Petitions • Temporar y Protected Status Applications IMMIGRATION LEGAL SERVICES Serves: Statewide Services available in multiple languages including Spanish, Arabic, Chaldean, French, Vietnamese, and Serbo-Croatian. Archdiocese of Detroit 305 Michigan Ave., 5 th Floor Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 237–4646 (English or Spanish) Fax (313) 237–5866 (313) 237–4699 (Arabic or Chaldean) Immigration Legal Services provides services in the following legal areas: • General consultations • Family petitions • Adjustments of status • Asylum and refugee applications • Deportation/removal proceedings • Citizen and nationality law • Non-Immigrant visas and work authorizations INNOCENCE PROJECT The Thomas M. Cooley Law School 300 S. Capitol Ave., Lansing, MI 48933 Tel: (517) 334–5760 Fax (517) 334–5761 www.cooley.edu Case intake criteria include all of the following three categories: • Persons who claim actual innocence saying they did not commit the crime for which they were convicted; • Persons who are serving a substantial sentence in prison in the State of Michigan; and • Persons whose innocence could be established by DNA testing of biological evidence that was collected during the course of the criminal investigation of their case. LACASA LEGAL INTERVENTION PROJECT Serves: Livingston County Legal Intervention Project P.O. Box 72 Howell, MI 48844 Tel: (517) 548-1350 Crisis – Domestic Violence: (810) 227-7100 Crisis – Sexual Assault: (517) 548-4228 Fax: (517) 548-3034 LACASA Legal Intervention Project provides services in the following legal areas: • Aid in creating and completing Safety Plans • Court Accompaniment • Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault informational materials • Expert witnesses available • Shelter • Support groups and individuals counseling for adults and children • Victim Impact Statement and PPO assistance • 24 Hour crisis line and 24 hour on-call response for both domestic violence and sexual assault. LEGAL ASSISTANCE CENTER Serves: Allegan, Kent, Muskegon and Ottawa counties. 180 Ottawa Ave., N.W., Ste. 5100 Grand Rapids, MI 49503 Business Phone: (616) 632-6014 Patron Phone: (616) 632-6000 Toll Free: (888) 454-9554 TTY: (616) 632-6010 Fax: (616) 632-6011 Website: http://www.legalassistancecenter.org Legal Assistance Center provides the following services: • Referrals to community agencies and attorneys. • Information and assistance with various legal self-help materials and forms on the following areas of law: 1. Conservatorship of an adult 2. Guardianship of a Child 3. Guardianship of an Adult 4. Change of Parenting Time 5. Change of Custody 6. Change of Child Support 7. Garnishment 8. Rental Property Information for Landlords 9. Rental Property Information for Tenants 10. Small Claims 11. Small Estate Fees: $25 for initial consultation with an attorney. All other services are free. LEGAL HOTLINE FOR MICHIGAN SENIORS Serves: Statewide 221 N. Pine St Lansing, MI 48933 Tel: (517) 372–5959 Toll Free: (800) 347–5297 Fax (517) 372–0792 Legal Hotline for Michigan Seniors provides services in the following legal areas: • Wills and Estate Planning • Medicaid • Medicare • Consumer Law • Housing/Real Estate • Pensions • Public Benefits • Other MICHIGAN ADVOCATES EXCHANGE, INC. 2048 Washtenaw, Upper Ste. Ypsilanti, MI 48197 Tel: (734) 484-6900 Toll: (888) MAX-3660 Fax: (734) 484-6943 E-mail: [email protected] Enhancing and supporting the independence and self-sufficiency of people living with HIV/AIDS through programs for: • Critical Needs Advocacy • Case Manager Support • Legal Services • Legal Training • Resource Guides • Information Clearinghouse • Peer Support Networks MICHIGAN FOSTER ADOPTIVE PARENT ASSOCIATION 2450 Delhi Commerce Drive, Suite 13 Holt, MI 48842 Tel: (517) 694-1056 Toll Free: (800) 632-4180 Fax: (517) 694-3092 MICHIGAN LEGAL SERVICES Serves: Statewide/emphasis on Detroit metro area. 900 Michigan Bldg. 220 Bagley Ave. Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 964–4130 Fax: (313) 964–1192 Email: [email protected] Website: ww.mlan.net/mls/mls.html Michigan Legal Ser vices engages in impact oriented litigation and systemic policy advocacy to address root causes of poverty in the areas of: • Housing • Health • Mental Health • Public Benefits Law Nonprofit community organizations engaged in community economic development strategies for rebuilding low-income communities are represented through its Community Legal Resources program. See Community Legal Resources link. MICHIGAN MIGRANT LEGAL ASSISTANCE PROJECT, INC. Serves: Farmworkers Statewide Grand Rapids Office 648 Monroe, N.W., Suite 318 Grand Rapids, MI 49503 Tel: (616) 454-5055 Fax: (616) 454-7022 Toll Free (1-800-418-3390) E-mail: [email protected] Michigan Migrant Legal Assistance Project provides bilingual ser vices in the following legal areas: • Employment • Housing • Civil Rights • Education • Consumer • Public Benefits • Immigration • Health MICHIGAN PROTECTION AND ADVOCACY SERVICE, INC. Serves: Statewide 106 W. Allegan, Suite 300 Lansing, MI 48933-1706 Tel: (517) 487–1755 Toll Free (800) 288–5923 Fax (517) 487–0827 Michigan Protection and Advocacy Service, Inc., provides services in the following legal areas: • Disability Rights Issues • HIV/AIDS Rights • Children’s Disability/Special Education Rights MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY DETROIT COLLEGE OF LAW CLINICAL LAW PROGRAMS Serves: Clinton, Ingham, and Eaton Counties Rental Housing and Tax Clinics 541 E. Grand River P.O. Box 310 East Lansing, MI 48826 Tel: (517) 336–8088 Fax (517) 336-8089 MSU – Detroit College of Law Rental Housing Clinic provides services in the following legal areas: • Landlord/Tenant Rights MSU – Detroit College of Law Tax Clinic provides services in the following legal areas: • Represent low-income taxpayers in cases and controversies before the Internal Revenue Service and the United States Tax Court • Prepare income tax returns for persons for whom English is a second language. MIDLAND ALLIANCE FOR JUSTICE Serves: Midland County P.O. Box 121 Midland, MI 48640-0121 Tel: (989) 430-0460 Fax: (989) 631-1170 Midland Alliance for Justice provides services in the following legal areas: • Domestic Relations • Landlord/Tenant NEIGHBORHOOD LEGAL SERVICES MICHIGAN Ser ves: Principal Area Wayne County Disability/AIDS Law: Southeast Michigan Emergency Legal Advice/Victims of Crime: Statewide Law Center and the Disability Law Clinic 104 Lothrop, Suite B Detroit, MI 48202 Tel: (313) 874-5820 Fax (313) 874-5497 Housing Assistance for the Disabled At American Indian Services 1110 Southrifld Rd. Lincoln Park, MI 48146 Tel: (313) 357-2658 Fax: (313) 357-2678 Administrative Offices and Housing Placement Center 455 W. Fort Street, Suite 214 Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 964-1975 Fax: (313) 963-2584 Neighborhood Legal Services Michigan provides victims of crime and people seeking to obtain Social Security disability benefits with legal representation. Housing placement services are available for homeless persons and families. Law related education is available to the community through classroom outreach in conjunction with the Detroit Public Schools and other educational facilities in Wayne County. The following activities are housed at the Law Center on Lothrop: • AIDS Law Center – Tel: (313) 874-5820 Fax: (313) 874-5497 Law • Child & Family Center/Domestic Violence Clinic – Tel: (313) 874-5820 Fax: (313) 8745497 • Children’s Center for Justice and Peace – Tel: (313) 874-5820 Fax: (313) 874-5497 • Disability Law Clinic – Tel: (313) 874-5820 Fax: (313) 874-5497 NLG/SUGAR LAW CENTER FOR ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL JUSTICE (GUILD LAW CENTER) Serves: Nationwide 733 St. Antoine, 3 rd Floor Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 962–6540 Fax (313) 962-4492 Website: http://www.sugarlaw.org Sugar Law Center for Economic and Social Justice provides services in the following legal areas: • Plant Closings (Warn Act) • Poverty Rights Issues • Environmental Justice Issues • Economic Rights and Living Wage Issues PARTNERS FOR PRO BONO’S LOW-INCOME TAX PAYER PRO BONO PROJECT Legal Aid and Defender Association, Inc. 645 Griswold Street, Suite 2400 Detroit, MI 48226-4201 Tel: (313) 964-4111 Par tners for Pro Bono’s lowincome taxpayer pro bono project represent low-income taxpayers with disputes before the Internal Revenue Services. PRISON LEGAL SERVICES OF MICHIGAN, INC. Serves: Statewide State Prison of Southern Michigan 3855 Cooper St. Jackson, MI 49201 Tel: (517) 780–6639 Fax (517) 780–5887 Prison Legal Services of Michigan, Inc., provides services in the following legal areas: • All civil legal aid matters (other than civil rights suits against prison officials); • Detainees and federal habeas corpus; • Assistance after the right of criminal appeal is exhausted and other post conviction matters; • Advice in prison administrative matters; • Paralegal training for selected inmates and job placement assistance for released paralegals. • Provide information sheets on numerous post-conviction, civil and prison administrative topics. • Provide self-help packets in selected criminal, prisoners’ rights, and prison administrative matters. • Represent male prisoner class in statewide class action in Court of Claims raising access to courts, classification, property and telephone system issues. SAFE HOUSE Serves: Washtenaw County Domestic Violence Project P.O. Box 7052 Ann Arbor, MI 48107-7052 Tel: (734) 973–0242 ext. 204 Crisis Line (734) 995–5444 Fax (734) 973-7817 Safe House provides the following information: • Domestic Violence Mentors • Domestic Violence Materials • Client protection and meeting locations • Referrals to attorneys and to pro bono legal services • Assistance with personal protection orders • Court accompaniment for survivors of domestic violence • Expert witnesses on issues of domestic violence • Temporary shelter • Support Groups • 24 hour crisis line • 24 hour on-call response team • Domestic violence and legal training for law enforcement, lawyers, paralegals, other professionals SIXTY PLUS, INC., ELDERLAW CLINIC Serves: Clinton, Ingham, and Eaton Counties 300 S. Capitol Avenue P.O. Box 13038 Lansing, MI 48901-3038 Tel: (517) 334–5760 Fax (517) 334–5761 www.cooley.edu Sixty Plus, Inc., Elderlaw Clinic provides services in the following legal areas: • Public Benefits • Housing • Landlord/Tenant • Consumer Protection • Age Discrimination • Family Law • Probate • Guardianship/Conservatorship STUDENT ADVOCACY CENTER OF MICHIGAN 2301 Platt Road Ann Arbor, MI 48104 Tel: (734) 973-7860 Fax: (734) 973-7864 The Student Advocacy Center of Michigan (SAC) provides free, non-legal advocacy to students (and their parents) who are eligible for general and special public education programs. SAC’s purpose is: • To encourage and promote school policies and practices that work for children. • To challenge those that, however well-intentioned, have a harmful impact. • To afford particular concern for those children who are chronically underserved by public schools. THE INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF METROPOLITAN DETROIT, INC. 111 East Kirby Street Detroit, MI 48202 Tel: (313) 871-8600 Fax: (313) 871-1651 The International Institute of Metropolitan Detroit, Inc. provides ser vices in the following legal areas: • Immigration/Social Services • Refugee Resettlement • Ethnic Enrichment • Languages/ESL Education THE SALVATION ARMY WILLIAM BOOTH LEGAL AID CLINIC Serves: Eastern Michigan The Salvation Army Harbor Light Center 2643 Park Ave. Detroit, MI 48201 Tel: (313) 961-2201 Fax (313) 961-6288 E-mail: [email protected] The Salvation Ar my William Booth Legal Aid Clinic provides free legal services to people who are pre-screened and referred to us by the Eastern Michigan Division of The Salvation Army in the following areas: • Divorce/Family Law • Landlord/Tenant • Public Benefits and Entitlements • Juvenile/Guardianships • Immigration • Child/Spouse Abuse • Traffic Offense • Criminal Matters THIRD LEVEL CRISIS CENTER FREE LEGAL AID CLINIC/LEGAL SERVICES PROGRAM Serves: Antrim, Grand Traverse and Leelanau Counties 1022 E. Front Street Traverse City, MI 49684 Tel: (231) 922-4800 Crisis Line: 800-442-7315 Fax: (231) 941-5786 Website: www.traverse.net/members/thirdlevel/index.htm Third Level Crisis Center Free Legal Aid Clinic/Legal Services Program provides services in the following legal areas: • Divorces without contested custody • Landlord/Tenant • Consumer Issues • Governmental Entitlements • Miscellaneous on a case by case basis UNDERGROUND RAILROAD, INC. P.O. Box 2451 Saginaw, MI 48605 Tel: (989) 755-0413 The purpose of Underground Railroad, Inc. is to provide shelter and services (including legal services) for survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault and stalking. UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN LAW SCHOOL CLINICAL LAW PROGRAM Serves: Washtenaw County Michigan Clinical Law Program 363 Legal Research Building 801 Monroe Street Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1215 Tel: (734) 763–4319 Fax (734) 764-4702 Clinics: Asylum and Refugee, Civil, Criminal, Neighborhood Legal, and Poverty University of Michigan Law School provides services in the following legal areas through the clinics named above: • Housing • Consumer Issues • Civil Rights • Employment Discrimination • Immigration Law • Refugee Law VOLUNTEER CIVIL LAW PROJECT Serves: Wayne County (In conjunction with Legal Aid and Defender Association of Detroit.) Detroit Metropolitan Bar Association Volunteer Legal Services 645 Griswold, Suite 3550 Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 961–6120 Fax: (313) 965-0842 Website: www.detroitlawyer.org Volunteer Civil Law Project provides services in the following legal areas: • All types of civil law • Provides client meeting location WAYNE STATE UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL Serves: Wayne County 468 Ferry Mall Detroit, MI 48202-3620 Tel: (313) 577-3348 Fax: (313) 577-2620 Clinics: Free Legal Aid Clinic (FLAC), Disability Law Clinic, Nonprofit Cor porations and Urban Development Law Clinic, Criminal Appellate Practice, and Civil Rights Litigation Clinic Wayne State University Law School provides services in the following legal areas through the clinics named above: • Litigation • Administrative Law • Transactional Work WEST SIDE MOTHERS WELFARE RIGHTS ORGANIZATION 23 East Adams Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 964-3980 Fax: (313) 965-4328 West Side Mothers Welfare Rights Organization provides services in the following areas: • Social Security Hearings • Family Independence Agency Hearings WOMEN'S JUSTICE CENTER Serves: Wayne County 1150 Griswold, Suite 2000 Detroit, MI 48226 Tel: (313) 961–5528 Fax (313) 961-4057 Women’s Justice Center provides services in the following legal areas: • Domestic Violence • General Family Law; Divorce and Custody Actions, Paternity • Landlord/Tenant • Abuse and Neglect WOMEN'S SURVIVAL CENTER Serves: Oakland County 761 W. Huron Street, 2nd Floor Pontiac, MI 48341 Tel: (248) 335–2685 (business line) (248) 335–1520 (information/referral line) Fax (248) 745–0192 Women’s Survival Center provides services in the following legal areas: • Adoptions • Family Law • Juvenile Defense • Paternity • Protective Services • Probate • Wills and Trusts • Social Security • Contracts • Landlord/Tenant • Bankruptcy • Collections • Workers Compensation • Civil Rights • Discrimination • Wrongful Discharge • Sexual Harassment • Immigration • Malpractice • Personal Injury • Product Liability • Criminal • Traffic Violations YWCA OF GRAND RAPIDS 25 Sheldon SE Grand Rapids, MI 49503 Tel: (616) 459-4681 The purpose of the YWCA of Grand Rapids is to empower women, promote diversity and advocate for justice and equality. Updates? Changes? Please fax information to (313) 961-3082 Attn: Editor/Editorial Dept. or e-mail to [email protected] DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 7 The Detroit Legal News, Page 43 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Michigan Prosecuting Attorneys Directory ATTORNEY GENERAL Mike Cox G. Mennen Williams Law Bldg. 525 W. Ottawa, 7th Floor P.O. Box 30212 Lansing, MI 48909 (517) 373-1110 [Main Office/Lansing] www.ag.state.mi.us (313) 256-2519 [Detroit Office] (616) 356-0400 [Grand Rapids Office] (313) 256-2892 [Computer/Internet Crime] (517) 373-1140 [Consumer Protection] (517) 373-3042 [Fax] (517) 373-1111 [TDD] ALCONA Thomas J. Weichel County Courthouse 106 5th St., P.O. Box 189 Harrisville, MI 48740 (989) 724-9460 (989) 724-9469 [Fax] E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ alcona/ ALGER Karen Bahrman Courthouse Complex 101 E. Varnum St. Munising, MI 49862 (906) 387-2117 (906) 387-2200 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ alger/ ALLEGAN Frederick L. Anderson County Building 113 Chestnut Allegan, MI 49010 (269) 673-0280 (269) 673-0599 [Fax] www.allegancounty.org/ Government/ProsecutingAtty www.michiganprosecutor.org/ allegan/ ALPENA Ed Black County Annex 719 Chisholm Alpena, MI 49707 (989) 354-9738 (989) 354-9788 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ alpena/ ANTRIM Charles H. Koop 1905 Courthouse, P.O. Box 280 Bellaire, MI 49615 (231) 533-6860 (231) 533-5718 [Fax] www.antrimcounty.org/ prosecutor.asp/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ antrim/ ARENAC Curtis Broughton 120 N. Grove, P.O. Box 1309 Standish, MI 48658 (989) 846-4597 (989) 846-6271 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ arenac/ BARAGA Joseph O’Leary 12 N. Third Courthouse Annex L’Anse, MI 49946 (906) 524-5440 (906) 524-5832 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ baraga/ BARRY Thomas E. Evans 220 W. Court Street, Suite 201 Hastings, MI 49058 (269) 945-1297 (269) 948-3316 [Fax] www.barrycounty.org/courts-andlaw-enforcement/prosecutingattorney/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ barry/ BAY Kurt Asbury Bay County Courthouse 1230 Washington Ave, Suite 768 Bay City, MI 48708 (989) 895-4185 (989) 895-4167 [Fax] www.co.bay.mi.us/bay/home.nsf/ Public/ProsecutorsOffice.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ bay/ BENZIE John Daugherty Government Center 448 Court Place, P.O. Box 377 Beulah, MI 49617 (231) 882-0043 (231) 882-0559[Fax] www.benzieco.net/dept prosecutor.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ benzie/ BERRIEN Arthur J. Cotter Main Office County Courthouse 811 Port St. St. Joseph, MI 49085 (269) 983-7111, ext. 8311 (269) 983-5757 [Fax] Niles Office 1205 N. Front Street Niles, MI 49120 (616) 684-5274 U.S. ATTORNEY Eastern District Stephen J. Murphy III 211 W. Fort St., Suite 2001 Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 226-9100 (313) 226-4609 [Fax] www.usdoj.gov/usao/mie/ U.S. ATTORNEY Western District Donald A. Davis 330 Ionia NW P.O. Box 208 Grand Rapids, MI 49501 (616) 456-2404 (616) 456-2408 [Fax] www.usdoj.gov/usao/miw/ Flint Office 210 Federal Building 600 Church Street Flint, MI 48502 (810) 766-5177 (810) 766-5427 [Fax] Bay City Office 101 First St, Suite 200 Bay City, MI 48708 (517) 895-5712 (517) 895-5790 [Fax] Prosecutor’s Support Division FIA 408 8th Street Benton Harbor, MI 49022 (616) 934-2250 www.berriencounty.org/ E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ berrien/ BRANCH Terri Norris Courthouse 31 Division St. Coldwater, MI 49036 (517) 279-4319, ext. 0 (517) 279-6437 [Fax] www.countyofbranch.com/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ branch/ CALHOUN Susan K. Mladenoff Justice Complex 161 E. Michigan Battle Creek, MI 49014 (269) 969-6976 (269) 969-6967 [Fax] www.calhouncountymi.org/Departments/ProsecutingAttorney.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ calhoun/ CASS Victor A. Fitz Cass County Law and Courts Building 60296 M-62, Suite 6 Cassopolis, MI 49031 (269) 445-4460 (269) 445-8629 [after 4pm] (269) 445-4409 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ cass/ CHARLEVOIX John Jarema County Building Annex 301 State St. Charlevoix, MI 49720 (231) 547-7207 (231) 547-7262 [Fax] www.charlevoixcounty.org/ prosecutor.asp www.michiganprosecutor.org/ charlevoix/ Information Source: Michigan Prosecuting Attorneys Coordinating Council Web site — www.michiganprosecutor.org DICKINSON Stephanie Brule 300 East D, P.O. Box 609 Iron Mountain, MI 49801 (906) 774-1294 (906) 774-8603 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ dickinson/ EATON Jeffrey L. Sauter 1045 Independence Blvd. Charlotte, MI 48813 (517) 543-4801, x1265 (517) 543-3348 [Fax] (517) 543-0738/485-0673 [Witnesses] http://207.74.121.45/Prosecutor/ Index.htm E-mail: prosecutingattorney@ eatoncounty.org www.michiganprosecutor.org/ eaton/ IRON Melissa Powell Weston 2 S. Sixth St., Suite 1 Crystal Falls, MI 49920-1413 (906) 875-6628 (906) 875-0646 [Fax] http://www.iron.org/edc/ gov-prosecutor.php E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ iron/ GENESEE David Leyton Courthouse, Rm. 200 900 S. Saginaw Flint, MI 48502 (810) 257-3210 (810) 257-3219[Fax] www.co.genesee.mi.us/ prosecutors www.michiganprosecutor.org/ genesee/ JACKSON Henry C. Zavislak 312 S. Jackson St. Jackson, MI 49201 (517) 788-4283 (517) 780-4714 [Fax] (517) 780-4767 - Child Support (517) 780-4771 - Child Supp [Fax] (517) 788-4072 - Victim Rights http://www.co.jackson.mi.us/ Prosecutor/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ jackson/ GLADWIN Aaron W. Miller 401 W. Cedar Gladwin, MI 48624 (989) 426-8592 (989) 426-4248 [Fax] http://gladwinco.com/prosecutor www.michiganprosecutor.org/ gladwin/ CHIPPEWA Brian A. Peppler County Courthouse 319 Court St. Sault Ste. Marie, MI 49783 (906) 635-6342 (906) 635-6850 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ chippewa/ GRAND TRAVERSE Al Schneider 324 Court St. Traverse City, MI 49684 (231) 922-4600 (231) 922-4698 [Fax] www.co.grand-traverse.mi.us/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ grandtraverse/ CLARE Michelle Ambrozaitis 225 W. Main St., P.O. Box 586 Harrison, MI 48625 (989) 539-9831, ext. 2605 (989) 539-1807 [Fax] www.clareco.net/Prosecutor/ home.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ clare/ GRATIOT Keith J. Kushion 214 E. Center St. Ithaca, MI 48847 (989) 875-5236 (989) 875-5298 [Fax] www.co.gratiot.mi.us/prosecutor/ index.htm E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ gratiot/ DELTA Steve Parks 310 Ludington Escanaba, MI 49829 (906) 789-5115 (906) 789-5149 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ delta/ IOSCO Gary W. Rapp County Building P.O. Box 548 422 Lake St. Tawas City, MI 48763 (989) 362-6141 (989) 984-1106 [Fax] www.iosco.m33access.com/ prosecutor.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ iosco/ ISABELLA Larry J. Burdick 200 N. Main Mt. Pleasant, MI 48858 (989) 772-0911 ext. 311 (989) 775-8413 [Fax] http://www.isabellacounty.org/pa www.michiganprosecutor.org/ isabella/ GOGEBIC Richard B. Adams Courthouse 200 N. Moore Bessemer, MI 49911 (906) 667-0471 (906) 663-1102 [Fax] www.gogebic.org/pros.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ gogebic/ CRAWFORD Everett Ayers Courthouse 200 W. Michigan Ave. Grayling, MI 49738 (989) 348-2844, ext. 246 (989) 348-7582 [Fax] www.crawfordco.org/offices/ prosecutor.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ crawford/ IONIA Ron Schafer Courthouse 100 Main St. Ionia, MI 48846 (616) 527-5302 www.ioniacounty.org/prosecutor/ homepage.asp www.michiganprosecutor.org/ ionia/ EMMET James R. Linderman City-County Building 200 Division St. Petoskey, MI 49770 (231) 348-1725 (231) 348-0686 [Fax] www.co.emmet.mi.us/ prosattny www.michiganprosecutor.org/ emmet/ CHEBOYGAN Daryl Vizina County Building 870 S. Main, P.O. Box 70 Cheboygan, MI 49721 (231) 627-8450 (231) 627-8405 [Fax] www.cheboygancounty.net/ pages/prosecuting attorney/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ cheboygan/ CLINTON Charles D. Sherman County Courthouse Suite 3100, 100 E. State St. St. Johns, MI 48879 (989) 224-5260 (989) 224-5259 [Fax] www.co.clinton.mi.us/ prosecutor.html www.michiganprosecutor.org/ clinton/ INGHAM Stuart J. Dunnings, III 303 W. Kalamazoo St., 2nd Fl. Lansing, MI 48933 (517) 483-6108 (517) 483-6397 [Fax] (517) 483-6545 [PPOs] (517) 483-6256 [Victim/Witness] www.ingham.org/PA/PAindex.htm E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ ingham/ KALAMAZOO Jeffery R. Fink 227 W. Michigan Ave. Kalamazoo, MI 49007 (269) 383-8900 (269) 383-0475 [Fax] www.kalcounty.com/opa/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ kalamazoo/ KALKASKA Brian Donnelly Courthouse 605 N. Birch St. Kalkaska, MI 49646 (231) 258-3325 (231) 258-3339 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ kalkaska/ KENT William A. Forsyth 82 Ionia Ave., NW Suite 450 Grand Rapids, MI 49503 (616) 632-6710 (616) 632-6714 [Fax] www.accesskent.com/Courts AndLawEnforcement/ ProsecutorsOffice/pros index.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ kent/ KEWEENAW Donna L. Jaaskelainen 316 Sixth St. Calumet, MI 49913 (906) 337-6802 (906) 482-6804 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ keweenaw/ HILLSDALE Neal A. Brady 61 McCollum St. Hillsdale, MI 49242 (517) 439-1419 (517) 439-5141 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ hillsdale/ LAKE Michael J. Riley 800 10th St., P.O. Box 428 Baldwin, MI 49304 (231) 745-2775 (231) 745-6224 [Fax] E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ lake/ HOUGHTON Fraser Strome County Courthouse 401 E. Houghton Ave. Houghton, MI 49931 (906) 482-3214 (906) 487-5961 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ houghton/ LAPEER Byron Konschuh 255 Clay St. Lapeer, MI 48446 (810) 667-0326 (810) 667-0340 [Fax] www.prosecutors.county.lapeer.org www.michiganprosecutor.org/ lapeer/ HURON Timothy Rutkowski Huron County Building 250 E. Huron Ave., Ste 103 Bad Axe, MI 48413-1317 (989) 269-9255 (989) 269-2744 [Fax] E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ huron/ LEELANAU Joseph T. Hubbell 8527 E. Government Center Drive, Suite 202 Suttons Bay, MI 49682 (231) 256-9872 (231) 256-0133 [Fax] www.leelanaucounty.com/ coprosecutor.asp/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ leelanau/ LENAWEE Jonathan L. Poer 425 N. Main St. Adrian, MI 49221 (517) 264-4640 (517) 265-9314 [Fax] http://www.lenawee.mi.us/ prosecuting attorney/index/htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ lenawee/ LIVINGSTON David L. Morse 210 Highlander Way Howell, MI 48843 (517) 546-1850 (517) 546-0728 [Fax] //co.livingston.mi.us/ Prosecutor www.michiganprosecutor.org/ livingston/ LUCE Peter Tazelaar II 407 W. Harrie St. Newberry, MI 49868 (906) 293-3277 (906) 293-4890 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ luce/ MACKINAC Fred Feleppa 100 North Marley Street St. Ignace, MI 49781 (906) 643-7329/7331 (906) 643-6530 [Fax] www.mackinaccounty.net/ content/view/20/43/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ mackinac/ MACOMB Eric J. Smith 1 South Main St. Mt. Clemens, MI 48043 (586) 469-5350 (586) 469-5609 [Fax] (586) 469-5675 [Victim Rights] http://macombcountymi.gov/ PROSECUTORSOFFICE/ index.asp www.michiganprosecutor.org/ macomb/ MANISTEE Ford K. Stone Courthouse 415 Third St. Manistee, MI 49660 (231) 723-7518 (231) 723-1727 [Fax] www.manisteecounty.net/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ manistee/ We try to keep things as current as possible, if you know of any updates or changes please fax information to (313) 961-3082 Attn: Editor/Editorial Dept. or e-mail to [email protected] MONTCALM Andrea Krause 621 North State St., P.O. Box 38 Stanton, MI 48888 (989) 831-7327 (989) 831-7417 [Fax] http://www.montcalm.org/ prosecutor.asp E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ montcalm/ MONTMORENCY Terrie J. Case County Courthouse, M-32 East P.O. Box 789 Atlanta, MI 49709 (989) 785-8070 (989) 785-8071 [Fax] E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ montmorency/ MUSKEGON Tony D. Tague County Building, 5th Floor 990 Terrace Muskegon, MI 49442 (231) 724-6435 (231) 724-6685 [Fax] www.co.muskegon.mi.us/ prosecutor/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ muskegon/ NEWAYGO Chrystal Roach 1092 Newell, P.O. Box 885 White Cloud, MI 49349 (231) 689-7283 (231) 689-7289 [Fax] www.countyonewaygo.com/ PA/PAHome.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ newaygo/ OAKLAND Jessica Cooper 1200 N. Telegraph Pontiac, MI 48341 (248) 858-0656 (248) 452-2208 [Fax] www.co.oakland.mi.us/prosatty/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ oakland/ OCEANA Terry L. Shaw P.O. Box 169, 100 State St. Hart, MI 49420 (231) 873-4608 (231) 873-8955 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ oceana/ MARQUETTE Gary L. Walker Courthouse Annex 234 W. Baraga Ave. Marquette, MI 49855 (906) 225-8310 (906) 228-1649 [Fax] www.co.marquette.mi.us/ prosecut.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ marquette/ OGEMAW LaDona Schultz County Bldg. #109 806 W. Houghton Ave. West Branch, MI 48661 (989) 345-5700 (989) 345-5913 [Fax] www.ogemacountymi.gov/ prosecuting/index.php www.michiganprosecutor.org/ ogemaw/ MASON Paul Spaniola County Courthouse 304 E. Ludington Ave. Ludington, MI 49431 (231) 845-7377 (231) 845-8125 [Fax] www.masoncounty.net www.michiganprosecutor.org/ mason/ ONTONAGON James Jessup Courthouse 725 Greenland Rd. Ontonagon, MI 49953 (906) 884-4155 (906) 884-2916 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ ontonagon/ MECOSTA Peter Jaklevic Courthouse 400 Elm St. Big Rapids, MI 49307 (231) 592-0141 (231) 796-3050 [Fax] www.co.mecosta.mi.us/ prosecuting.asp www.michiganprosecutor.org/ mecosta/ MENOMINEE Daniel E. Hass Courthouse 839 10th Ave. Menominee, MI 49858 (906) 863-2002 (906) 863-2980 [Fax] www.menomineecounty.com www.michiganprosecutor.org/ menominee/ MIDLAND Michael Carpenter Courthouse 301 W. Main Midland, MI 48640 (989) 832-6722 (989) 832-6393 [Fax] http://www.co.midland.mi.us/ departments/home.php www.michiganprosecutor.org/ midland/ MISSAUKEE William Donnelly, Jr. 209 S. Canal, P.O. Box 363 Lake City, MI 49651 (231) 839-3111 (231) 839-3869 [Fax] www.missaukee.org/prosdept.htm E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ missaukee/ MONROE William P. Nichols 125 East Second St. Monroe, MI 48162 (734) 240-7600 (734) 240-7626 [Fax] //www.co.monroe.mi.us/monroe/ default.aspx www.michiganprosecutor.org/ monroe/ OSCEOLA James Sims 410 W. Upton Reed City, MI 49677 (231) 832-3226 (231) 832-6147 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ osceola/ OSCODA Kathleen Solomon 105 S. Court, P.O. Box 399 Mio, MI 48647 (989) 826-1120 (989) 826-1188 [Fax] www.oscodacountymi.com www.michiganprosecutor.org/ oscoda/ OTSEGO Kyle Legel 100 Livingston Blvd. P.O. Box 367 Gaylord, MI 49734 (989) 731-7430 (989) 731-7433 [after 4:30 pm] (989) 731-7449 [Fax] www.otsegocountymi.gov/ prosecutor/prosecutor.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ otsego/ OTTAWA Ronald J. Frantz Main Office County Building, Room 201 414 Washington Grand Haven, MI 49417 (616) 846-8215 (616) 846-8178 [Fax] Holland Office 57 W. 8th St., Suite 110 Holland, MI 49423-3103 (616) 392-1446 www.miottawa.org/CourtsLE/ Prosecutor/ www.michiganprosecutor.org/ ottawa/ PRESQUE ISLE Richard Steiger Courthouse P.O. Box 110, 151 E. Huron Ave. Rogers City, MI 49779 (989) 734-4709 (989) 734-7667 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ presqueisle/ ROSCOMMON Mark Jernigan 500 Lake St., P.O. Box 425 Roscommon, MI 48653 (989) 275-5233 (989) 275-3024 [Fax] www.roscommoncounty.net/ Courts/prosecutor.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ roscommon/ SAGINAW Michael D. Thomas Courthouse 111 S. Michigan Ave. Saginaw, MI 48602 (989) 790-5330 (989) 792-0803 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ saginaw/ SANILAC James V. Young Courthouse 60 W. Sanilac Sandusky, MI 48471 (810) 648-3402 (810) 648-2332 [Fax] E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ sanilac/ SCHOOLCRAFT Peter J. Hollenbeck County Building, Rm. 209 300 Walnut St. Manistique, MI 49854 (906) 341-3691 (906) 341-8220 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ schoolcraft/ SHIAWASSEE Randy O. Colbry 201 N. Shiawassee Surbeck Bldg., 2nd Fl. Corunna, MI 48817 (989) 743-2373 (989) 743-2237 [Fax] E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ shiawassee/ ST. CLAIR Mike Wendling 301 County Building 201 McMorran Blvd. Port Huron, MI 48060 (810) 985-2400 (810) 985-2424 [Fax] www.stclaircounty.org/Offices/ prosecuting attorney/ E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ stclair/ ST. JOSEPH John McDonough Courthouse 125 Main St., P.O. Box 250 Centreville, MI 49032 (269) 467-5547 (269) 467-5628 [Fax] www.stjosephcountymi.org/ prosecutingatty.htm www.michiganprosecutor.org/ stjoseph/ TUSCOLA Mark Reene Courthouse 440 N. State St. Caro, MI 48723 (989) 672-3900 (989) 673-8612 [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ tuscola/ VAN BUREN Juris Kaps Courthouse 212 Paw Paw St. Paw Paw, MI 49079 (616) 657-8236 (616) 657-1944 [Fax] (616) 637-5177 - S. Haven (616) 637-9169 - S. Haven [Fax] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ vanburen/ WASHTENAW Brian L. Mackie Courthouse P.O. Box 8645 200 N. Main, Suite 320 Ann Arbor, MI 48107-8645 (734) 222-6620 (734) 222-6610 [Fax] www.ewashtenaw.org/ government/prosecuting_ attorney/pa_index.html E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ washtenaw/ WAYNE Kym L. Worthy Main Office Frank Murphy Hall of Justice 1441 St. Antoine Detroit, MI 48226 (313) 224-5777 (313) 224-0974 [Fax] Juvenile Division (313) 833-3300 www.waynecounty.com/ prosecutor www.michiganprosecutor.org/ wayne/ WEXFORD Mark Smathers 1200 S. Mitchell, P.O. Box 863 Cadillac, MI 49601 (231) 779-9505 (231) 779-9108 [Fax] www.wexfordcounty.org/ Courts/Prosecutor/ E-mail: [email protected] www.michiganprosecutor.org/ wexford/ DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 8 Page 44, The Detroit Legal News FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Michigan Attorney General’s Consumer Protection Division — Complaint Directory Michigan Department of Attorney General Consumer Protection Division • PO Box 30213 • Lansing MI 48909 • 517-373-1140 • Toll free: 877-765-8388 • Web site: http://www.michigan.gov/ag (This Complaint Directory is available on the Attorney General’s website at http://www.michigan.gov/ag ) Last update: 5/2007 Not all consumer complaints/inquires are handled by the Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division, however. By law, many other state and federal agencies and departments are involved in assisting consumers. To direct your complaint/inquiry to the appropriate agency, consult our Consumer Complaint Directory. CLASSIFICATION ADVERTISING State AGENCY ADDRESS/PHONE/WEB Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division National Federal Trade Commission Consumer Response Center PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 600 Pennsylvania Ave NW Washington DC 20580 877-382-4357 (toll free) 9:00 AM-8:00 PM EST http://www.ftc.gov General PO Box 30755 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-1123 http://www.michigan.gov/ag ANTITRUST Office of the Attorney Consumer Protection Division Special Litigation Section AUTOMOBILES/MOTORCYCLES Used Car & Dealer Secretary of State Problems, Repair Facilities, Bureau of Regulatory Services Odometers Out of state callers Automobiles Within the Manufacturer’s Warranty Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division Safety Recall Information US Dept of Transportation National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Center for Auto Safety BAIL BONDSMEN State BANKS State National Bank Issued Credit Cards Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office of Financial & Insurance Serv Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office of Financial & Insurance Serv Consumer Services Comptroller of the Currency Customer Assistance Group Federal Deposit Insurance Corp (FDIC) BUILDERS & HOME IMPROVEMENT COMPANIES (Completion date within 18 Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Commercial Services months and over $600.00) Commercial Enforcement Division (Completion date over 18 months or under $600.00) License Verification CANADIAN SCAMS Scams based in or mailed from Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Commercial Services Phone Busters E-Mail Advanced Fee Fraud (including Nigerian & Lottery Scams) CHARITIES Office of the Attorney General Licensing & Solicitation Consumer Protection Division Charitable Trust Section CHILD SUPPORT “Dead-Beat” Parents Dead-Beat” Parents Complaints vs. Friend of the Court COLLECTIONS Creditor Collection Practices Office of the Attorney General Child Support Division Pay Kids Foundation Friend of the Court Bureau State Court Administrative Office Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division Third Party Collection Agencies Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Commercial Services Commercial Enforcement Division CONTRACTORS (electrical, plumber, mechanical) Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Construction Codes General Complaints Complaints vs. Licensed Electrical Complaints vs. Licensed Plumbers Complaints vs. Licensed Mechanical CORPORATIONS "Register Agent" Info Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Corporation Division CREDIT CARD FRAUD Credit Card Companies Unauthorized Charges CREDIT REPORTING BUREAUS Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division US Secret Service Fraud Dept Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division Federal Trade Commission Consumer Response Center CREDIT UNIONS State Chartered Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office of Financial & Insurance Serv. Credit Union Division Federally Chartered National Credit Union Admin. Region I – Albany DISCRIMINATION/CIVIL RIGHTS Dept of Civil Rights DRUGS Prescription & Over-the-Counter EDUCATION Private Occupational Schools US Food and Drug Administration Office of Regulatory Affairs Detroit District MI Dept of Education Proprietary School Unit General Info: PO Box 30046 Lansing MI 48909 888-767-6424 (toll free in MI) 517-636-6400 http://www.michigan.gov/sos PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 400 7th St SW Rm 5232 Washington DC 20590 800-424-9393 (toll free) http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov 2001 S Street NW Ste 410 Washington DC 20009 202-328-7700 http://www.autosafety.org PO Box 30220 Lansing MI 48909 877-999-6442 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30224 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-0220 http://www.michigan.gov/cis 1301 McKinney St, Ste 3450 Houston TX 77010 800-613-6743 (toll free) http://www.occ.treas.gov 2345 Grand Boulevard, Ste 100 Kansas City MO 64108 800-378-9581 (toll free) 816-234-9060 (fax) http://www.fdic.gov PO Box 30018 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9202 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 517-241-9254 http://www.cis.state.mi.us/verify.htm Box 686 North Bay, Ontario, Canada P1B 8J8 888-495-8501 (toll free in US) 888-654-9426 (fax) http://http://www.phonebusters.com [email protected] [email protected] PO Box 30214 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-1152 http://www.michigan.gov/ag PO Box 30758 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-1111 http://www.michigan.gov/ag PO Box 13222 Lansing MI 48933 866-PAY-KIDS (729-5437) 734-674-6807 (Complaint Line) http://www.paykids.com Michigan Hall of Justice PO Box 30048 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-5975 517-373-8740 (fax) E-Mail [email protected] PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag PO Box 30018 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9202 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30222 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9347 517-241-9320 517-241-9330 517-241-9325 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30054 Lansing MI 48909-7554 517-241-6470 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 1000 Patrick McNamara Bldg 477 Michigan Ave Detroit MI 48226 313-226-6400 http://www.ifccfbi.gov PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 600 Pennsylvania Ave NW Washington DC 20580 877-382-4357 (toll free) 9:00 AM-8:00 PM EST http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/menu-credit.htm PO Box 30224 Lansing MI 48909 877-999-6442 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/cis 9 Washington Square Washington Avenue Extension Albany NY 12205 518-862-7400 http://www.ncua.gov 800-482-3604 (toll free) http://www.michigan.gov/mdcr 300 River Place Suite 5900 Detroit MI 48207 313-393-8100 http://www.fda.gov PO Box 30008 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-6774 517-373-3324 http://www.michigan.gov/mde CLASSIFICATION EMPLOYMENT AGENCIES Licensing and Complaints ENERGY Public Utility Service Complaints Energy Assistance Hotline FEDERAL INFORMATION FOOD Accurate Weights & Measures, Food Quality Food & Seafood Quality Meat & Poultry Quality FREE ANNUAL CREDIT REPORTS FUNERAL HOMES & OPERATORS GASOLINE Fuel Quality & Measurement HEALTH CARE Nursing & Health Facility AGENCY ADDRESS/PHONE/WEB Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office of Commercial Services Commercial Enforcement Division http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30018 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9202 Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Public Service Commission Complaint Hotline http://www.michigan.gov/mpsc Family Independence Agency PO Box 30221 Lansing MI 48909 800-292-9555 (toll free in MI) MI Dept of Agriculture Laboratory Division MI Dept of Agriculture Food & Dairy Division US Food & Drug Administration Detroit Regional Office Food & Seafood Info Line US Dept of Agriculture Food Safety & Inspection Service Meat & Poultry Hotline 3 Free per year from each of the 3 Major Credit Report Agencies Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Commercial Services Enforcement Division MI Dept of Agriculture Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Health Systems Complaint Hotline HOMELAND SECURITY Federal US Dept of Homeland Security State MI Dept of Homeland Security HOUSING Dept of Labor & Economic Growth MI State Housing Dev. Auth. Radon Levels Dept of Environmental Quality Radiological Protection Div. Mold Levels Dept of Community Health Local Mold Information Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office of Financial & Insurance Serv. INSURANCE ITEM PRICING Overcharges Non-pricing JUDICIAL TENURE COMM. Complaints vs. Judges Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division MI Dept of Agriculture Laboratory Division MI Judicial Tenure Commission E-mail: LANDLORD/TENANT Complaints Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division Michigan State University College of Law E-mail: LAWYERS Complaints Michigan Supreme Court Attorney Grievance Commission Referrals State Bar of Michigan Lawyer Referral Service LICENSED PROFESSIONS AND/OR OCCUPATIONS Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Individual Healthcare Providers Bureau of Health Services Complaint & Allegations Division Other Licensed Professions (See Contractors for add'l info) Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Commercial Services Enforcement Division License Verification Hotline MAIL FRAUD SCHEMES US Postal Inspection Service National USPS Fraud Hotline MILITARY & VETERAN AFFAIRS State Dept of Military & Veteran Affairs MOBILE HOMES/PARKS Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Licensing Office of Local Government Park Problems (Including Water Rates & Complaints) MORTGAGE COMPANIES Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office Financial & Insurance Services Licensing & Enforcement Division MOVERS Intrastate Local POLICE Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Public Service Commission Licensing & Enforcement Division Safety & Compliance Section Office of Attorney General Consumer Protection Division MI State Police General Info 800-292-5650 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/fia 800-FED-INFO (333-4636) 940 Venture Lane Williamston MI 48895 800-292-3939 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/mda P.O. Box 30017 Lansing MI 48909 1-800-292-3939 517-373-1060 http://www.michigan.gov/mda 1560 E Jefferson Detroit MI 48207 313-226-6260 http://www.fda.gov 800-332-4010 (toll free) Room 1175, South Building 1400 Independence Ave. SW Washington DC 20250 202-720-7943 http://www.fsis.usda.gov 800-535-4555 (toll free) 877-322-8228 (toll free in USA) CLASSIFICATION POLICE (continued) AGENCY Arson Tip Line HEMP Tip Line Internet Safety Methamphetamine Labs PRODUCT SAFETY Consumer Product Safety Comm. PRODUCT WARRANTY & DEFECTS Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division PYRAMID SCHEMES, FRANCHISES & BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES Office of the Attorney General Consumer Protection Division Franchise Section REAL ESTATE/REALTORS Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Bureau of Commercial Services Commercial Enforcement Division SAVINGS & LOANS Federal US Dept of Treasury Office of Thrift Supervision Consumer Affairs State Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Office of Financial & Insurance Serv. Licensing & Enforcement Division STOCKS/BONDS/SECURITIES Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Corporation, Securities, and Land Development Bureau 401(k)’s (State Employees) Dept of Management & Budget Office of Retirement Services Non-State Retirement US Dept of Labor Frances 800-MDA-FUEL (632-3835) http://www.michigan.gov/mda STUDENT LOANS PO Box 30664 Lansing MI 48909 517-334-8408 http://www.michigan.gov/cis 800-882-6006 (toll free in MI) MI Dept of Education Ombudsman MI Dept of Treasury-Fed Stafford Loan MI Dept of Treasury-Fed Perkins Loan Federal Student Aid Info Center Assistance and Student Loan Authority TAXES Federal PO Box 30018 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9202 http://www.michigan.gov/cis Washington DC 20528 800-BE-READY (237-3239) http://www.dhs.gov PO Box 30212 Lansing MI 48909 517-335-5747 http://www.michigan.gov/homeland PO Box 30044 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-8370 http://www.michigan.gov/mshda PO Box 30630 Lansing MI 48909-8130 231-775-3960 800-RADON GAS (723-6642) http://www.michigan.gov/deqradon 800-648-6942 (hotline) 517-335-9436 PO Box 30220 Lansing MI 48909 877-999-6442 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 940 Venture Lane Williamston MI 48895 517-655-8202 http://www.michigan.gov/mda 1-800-292-3939 Toll free 3034 West Grand Blvd, Ste 8-450 Detroit MI 48202 313-875-5110 313-875-5154 (fax) [email protected] http://jtc.courts.mi.gov PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag Rental Housing Clinic 541 E. Grand River PO Box 310 East Lansing MI 48826 517-336-8088 [email protected] http://www.law.msu.edu/rhc/ 243 W Congress Ste 256 Detroit MI 48226 313-961-6585 313-961-5819 (fax) http://www.agcmi.com 306 Townsend St Lansing MI 48933 800-968-0738 (toll-free MI Only) Out-of-State Callers 517-346-6300 517-482-6248 (fax) http://www.michbar.org PO Box 30670 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-9196 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30018 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9202 517-241-9254 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 330119 Detroit MI 48232-6119 313-226-8184 800-372-8347 http://www.usps.com/postalinspectors/ 2500 South Washington Ave Lansing MI 48913-5101 517-483-5500 http://www.michigan.gov/dmva PO Box 30703 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9317 517-241-9347 http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30224 Lansing MI 48909 877-999-6442 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30221 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-6030 517-241-6031 (fax) PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag 714 S. Harrison Road East Lansing MI 48823 517-332-2521 Internal Revenue Service State MI Dept of Treasury Income tax Sales/Use/Withholding Tax Tobacco MI Dept of Treasury Carbonated Beverage Container Deposits TELEMARKETING Federal MI Dept of Treasury Sales/Use/Withholding Tax Federal Trade Commission Consumer Response Center ADDRESS/PHONE/WEB 800-44-ARSON (442-7766) 800-235-HEMP (235-4367) 877-5CYBER3 (529-2373) 866-METH-TIP (638-4847) http://www.michigan.gov/msp Washington DC 20207 800-638-2772 (toll free) http://www.cpsc.gov PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag PO Box 30213 Lansing MI 48909 517-373-7117 http://www.michigan.gov/ag PO Box 30018 Lansing MI 48909 517-241-9202 http://www.michigan.gov/cis 1475 Peachtree Street NE Atlanta GA 30309 404-888-0771 http://www.ots.treas.gov PO Box 30224 Lansing MI 48909 877-999-6442 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30222 Lansing MI 48909 877-999-6442 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30171 Lansing MI 48909 800-381-5111 (toll free) http://www.michigan.gov/ors Perkins Building 200 Constitution Avenue, NW Washington DC 20210 800-998-7542 (toll free) http://www.dol.gov 877-557-2575 (toll free in MI) 800-642-5626 (toll free in MI) 877-323-2287 (toll free in MI) 800-433-3243 (toll free) http://www.mi-studentaid.org 800-TAX-1040 (829-1040) http://www.irs.ustreas.gov Lansing MI 48922 800-487-7000 (toll free in MI) 517-636-4730 http://www.michigan.gov/treasury Lansing MI 48922 800-292-2824 (toll free in MI) Lansing MI 48922 517-636-4730 600 Pennsylvania Ave NW Washington DC 20580 877-382-4357 (toll free) 9:00 AM-8:00 PM (EST) 888-382-1222 (toll free) FTC Do Not Call Registry (must call from number to be registered) http://www.ftc.gov State Office of the Attorney General PO Box 30213 Consumer Protection Division Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag TOYS & OTHER DANGEROUS PRODUCTS/SUBSTANCES Washington DC 20207 US Consumer Product Federal 800-638-2772 (toll free) Safety Commission http://www.cpsc.gov PO Box 30017 MI Dept of Agriculture State Food & Dairy Division Lansing MI 48909 800-292-3939 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/mda TRAVEL 400 Seventh Street SW #4107 US Dept of Transportation Air Service Complaints Aviation Consumer Protection Div. Washington DC 20590 202-366-2220 E-mail: [email protected] http://airconsumer.ost.dot.gov/ Federal Aviation Administration 800 Independence Ave SW Air Safety Safety Hotline Washington DC 20591 800-322-7873 (toll free) http://www.faa.gov Railway Safety Federal Railroad Administration 400 Seventh St SW Office of Safety Washington DC 20590 202-632-3700 http://www.fra.dot.gov/ Travel Agencies/Tour Operators Office of the Attorney General PO Box 30213 Consumer Protection Division Lansing MI 48909 877-765-8388 (toll free in MI) http://www.michigan.gov/ag UTILITIES Dept of Labor & Economic Growth PO Box 30221 Lansing MI 48909 Public Service Commission 800-292-9555 (toll free in MI) Complaint Hotline http://www.michigan.gov/cis PO Box 30476 WAGES Dept of Labor & Economic Growth Wage Hour Division Lansing MI 48909 517-335-0400 http://www.michigan.gov/cis MISCELLANEOUS RESOURCES Automobile Dispute Resolution 1500 Kendale Blvd Nat’l Automobile Dealers Association. East Lansing MI 48823 Automotive Consumer Action Program (AUTOCAP) 517-351-7800 Hotline 800-292-1923 (toll free) Chrysler Corporation Chrysler Customer Center (Chrysler, Plymouth, Dodge, Jeep) PO Box 21-8004 Auburn Hills MI 48321 800-992-1997 (toll free) http://www.chryslercorp.com Customer Relationship Center Ford Motor Co. (Ford, Lincoln, Mercury) PO Box 6248 Dearborn MI 48121 800-392-3673 (toll free) http://www.ford.com http://www.gm.com General Motors Corporation Buick 800-521-7300 (toll free) 800-458-8006 (toll free) Cadillac 800-222-1020 (toll free) Chevrolet GMC 800-462-8782 (toll free) Oldsmobile 800-422-6537 (toll free) Pontiac 800-762-2737 (toll free) 800-553-6000 (toll free) Saturn Better Business Bureaus Eastern Michigan 30555 Southfield Rd Ste 200 Southfield MI 48076 & Upper Peninsula 248-644-9100 Complaints 248-644-5026 (fax) In Flint 810-232-1239 [email protected] E-mail http://www.easternmichiganbbb.org Western Michigan Grand Rapids MI 49503 616-774-8236 616-774-2014 (fax) 800-684-3222 (toll free in MI) Hotline (Western MI only) E-mail [email protected] http://www.grandrapids.bbb.org Hillsdale, Monroe, Lenawee Cos. Toledo OH 43606 419-531-3116 419-578-6001 (fax) Hotline (OH, SW MI only) 800-734-4222 (toll free in MI) [email protected] E-mail http://www.toledobbb.org City/County Agencies City of Detroit 1600 Cadillac Tower Detroit MI 48226 313-224-3508 Information Complaints 313-224-6995 40 N Main St 6th Floor Macomb County Prosecutor Mt Clemens MI 48043 Consumer Protection Dept 810-469-5350 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 9 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 The Detroit Legal News, Page 45 State Tax Liens Bernard J. Youngblood Register of Deeds The following state and federal tax liens have been rounded to the nearest dollar. 209155760 47847 643 $14,078.16 3/25/2009GTE BYBLOS SHORES INC GTR MIT 209155761 47847 644 $6,295.41 3/25/2009GTE FRAME X INC GTE JANS SIGNS INC GTR MIT 209155762 47847 645 $3,847.39 3/25/2009GTE PAUL R SWANSON & ASSOC PC GTR MIT 209155763 47847 646 $4,991.80 3/25/2009GTE SAM OCO CORP GTR MIT 209155764 47847 647 $20,099.74 3/25/2009GTE RECYCLEMAX INC GTR MIT 209155765 47847 648 $6,240.98 3/25/2009GTE PRO LINE BUILDING INC GTR MIT 209155766 47847 649 $13,943.44 3/25/2009GTE BANKS ENTERPRISE LLC GTR MIT 209155767 47847 650 $5,443.12 3/25/2009GTE DAVIS BROTHERS COLLISION CLINIC INC GTR MIT 209155768 47847 651 $19,024.29 3/25/2009GTE ELDORADO USA INC GTR MIT 209155769 47847 652 $6,569.61 3/25/2009GTE SMITH HELEN C GTR MIT 209155770 47847 653 $1,452.47 3/25/2009GTE CLARK GILBERT T GTR MIT 209155771 47847 654 $1,676.25 3/25/2009GTE BARKER CHARLOTTE A GTR MIT 209155784 47847 667 $1,299.37 3/25/2009GTE AYALA REYNA H GTR MIT 209155772 47847 655 $886.05 3/25/2009GTE THOMPSON PAUL A GTR MIT 209155785 47847 668 $1,043.99 3/25/2009GTE MERRITT RAYMOND A GTR MIT 209155773 47847 656 $867.86 3/25/2009GTE WILDER CHRISTOPHER K GTR MIT 209155786 47847 669 $947.94 3/25/2009GTE GRANT MARKISHA R GTR MIT 209155774 47847 657 $1,725.57 3/25/2009GTE MILLER STEVE GTR MIT 209155787 47847 670 $656.80 3/25/2009GTE WILSON NICOLE R GTR MIT 209155775 47847 658 $1,461.24 3/25/2009GTE MORRISON SHEENAH GTR MIT 209155788 47847 671 $1,101.73 3/25/2009GTE JONES MILES I GTR MIT 209155776 47847 659 $1,236.77 3/25/2009GTE THOMAS CARMEN GTR MIT 209155789 47847 672 $1,101.41 3/25/2009GTE REDDICK SHIRLEY GTR MIT 209155777 47847 660 $3,148.72 3/25/2009GTE SMITH ANTASHA D GTR MIT 209155790 47847 673 $1,704.70 3/25/2009GTE JOHNSON STEPHANIE GTR MIT 209155778 47847 661 $562.83 3/25/2009GTE S K Y N A R G R E G O RY A G T E S K Y N A R K I M M GTR MIT 209155791 47847 674 $2,791.23 3/25/2009GTE TUPPER DEIDRIC I GTE TUPPER NATASHA C GTR MIT 209155779 47847 662 $800.61 3/25/2009GTE COGBURN DONNIE GTR MIT 209155792 47847 675 $2,097.99 3/25/2009GTE GRAY ROBERT GTR MIT 209155780 47847 663 $625.77 3/25/2009GTE PANCOAST GALE E GTE PANCOAST JEFFREY W GTR MIT 209155793 47847 676 $517.51 3/25/2009GTE WHITE JAMIE Y GTR MIT 209155781 47847 664 $517.21 3/25/2009GTE GARLAND DAVID GTR MIT 209155782 47847 665 $862.06 3/25/2009GTE REED ANDREA S GTR MIT 209155783 47847 666 $579.67 3/25/2009GTE LANE KATHLEEN M GTE LANE WILLIAM E GTR MIT 209155794 47847 677 $1,116.53 3/25/2009GTE RICKSTAD CATHY S GTR MIT 209155795 47847 678 $960.00 3/25/2009GTE BLACKMON ANGELO A GTR MIT 209155796 47847 679 $714.27 3/25/2009GTE HEARNS ROBIN GTR MIT 209155797 47847 680 $1,325.01 3/25/2009GTE JACKSON NOLA L GTR MIT 209155798 47847 681 $1,664.40 3/25/2009GTE RUSSELL LILLIAN GTR MIT 209155799 47847 682 $521.12 3/25/2009GTE BURNS TOMMY D JR GTR MIT 209155800 47847 683 $880.44 3/25/2009GTE BLOODSAW LATONJA M GTR MIT 209155801 47847 684 $973.95 3/25/2009GTE WILKERSON ROBERT L GTR MIT 209155802 47847 685 $1,225.24 3/25/2009GTE SMITH ALMA GTR MIT 209155803 47847 686 $1,053.12 3/25/2009GTE BAKER LOVER GTR MIT 209155804 47847 687 $1,348.27 3/25/2009GTE OLIVER HOSIE L III GTR MIT 209155805 47847 688 $1,026.29 3/25/2009GTE PRICE JOE J JR GTR MIT 209155806 47847 689 $6,742.33 3/25/2009GTE MARTINEZ JUAN A GTR MIT 209155807 47847 690 $86,231.31 3/26/2009GTE ANJALI INC GTR MIT 209155808 47847 693 $11,279.12 3/26/2009GTE A B C O M O B I L E H O M E S E RV I C E I N C G T R MIT 209155809 47847 695 $6,807.02 3/26/2009GTE SHERMAN EQUIPMENT CO GTR MIT 209155810 47847 697 $200,428.82 3/26/2009GTE OMEGA ON SOUTHFIELD INC GTR MIT 209155811 47847 699 $4,057.04 3/26/2009GTE CUISINE INC GTR MIT 209155812 47847 700 $6,364.69 3/26/2009GTE PAPA ROMANOS OF WAYNE GTE YUMMY BOYS INC GTR MIT 209155813 47847 701 $45,744.28 3/26/2009GTE 6500 GRATIOT AVE INC GTE 6500 GRATIOT AVENUE GTR MIT 209155814 47847 702 $13,454.64 3/26/2009GTE HORIZON INTERESTS INC GTE INTERIORS H O R I Z O N M I L LWO R K M F G G T E J D & M I L L WORK MID AMERICA GTR MIT 209155815 47847 703 $2,069.99 3/26/2009GTE NEW SPEED AUTP TECH INC GTR MIT 209155816 47847 704 $6,021.00 3/26/2009GTE Z & Z ENTERPRISES INC GTR MIT 209155817 47847 705 $10,664.05 3/26/2009GTE WALKER JEFFREY GTR MIT 209155818 47847 706 $4,433.72 3/26/2009GTE J WEST SALON II PC GTR MIT 209155819 47847 707 $1,431.73 3/26/2009GTE JENKINS NORENE GTR MIT 209155820 47847 708 $628.75 3/26/2009GTE NATION LARRY GTR MIT 209155821 47847 709 $508.17 3/26/2009GTE WALKER GREGORY GTR MIT 209155822 47847 710 $531.36 3/26/2009GTE WARE DAVID K GTR MIT 209155823 47847 711 $1,108.31 3/26/2009GTE ETTER CHRISTY D GTR MIT 209155824 47847 712 $1,383.76 3/26/2009GTE PONIUS SHIRLEY GTR MIT 209155825 47847 713 $1,512.90 3/26/2009GTE HAYNES RILEY JR GTR MIT 209155826 47847 714 $1,069.58 3/26/2009GTE REAVES VINCENT L GTR MIT 209155827 47847 715 $820.02 3/26/2009GTE THOMAS WILBERT D GTR MIT 209155828 47847 716 $5,858.98 3/26/2009GTE RUTTENBURG ANDREA L GTR MIT 209155829 47847 717 $1,282.92 3/26/2009GTE HINES KIMYANA W GTR MIT 209155830 47847 718 $509.79 3/26/2009GTE LAKES GARY L GTR MIT 209155831 47847 719 $960.57 3/26/2009GTE JONES CHAKESHA GTR MIT 209155832 47847 720 $2,845.53 3/26/2009GTE BOLINGER MARTIN R GTR MIT 209155833 47847 721 $1,249.91 3/26/2009GTE SCOTT KIMBERLY GTR MIT Continued on Page 46 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 10 Page 46, The Detroit Legal News FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 State Tax Liens Bernard J. Youngblood Register of Deeds The following state and federal tax liens have been rounded to the nearest dollar. Continued from Page 45 209155834 47847 722 $937.67 3/26/2009GTE JONES TASHA GTR MIT 209155835 47847 723 $941.36 3/26/2009GTE SOLTESZ JOSEPH A GTR MIT 209155836 47847 724 $807.43 3/26/2009GTE TRUXELL TOD C GTR MIT 209155837 47847 725 $869.86 3/26/2009GTE MIDDLEDITCH JAY W GTR MIT 209155838 47847 726 $590.36 3/26/2009GTE THOMPSON MARCUS GTR MIT 209155839 47847 727 $509.27 3/26/2009GTE PHILLIPS BEVERLY S GTE PHILLIPS GARY L GTR MIT 209155840 47847 728 $1,937.74 3/26/2009GTE FARDOUN ELIZABETH M GTR MIT 209155841 47847 729 $957.29 3/26/2009GTE TALLEY WARREN GTR MIT 209155842 47847 730 $919.05 3/26/2009GTE GREEN ALFRED W GTE GREEN VANESSA GTR MIT 209155868 47847 756 $1,133.06 3/26/2009GTE HESTER RACHEL N GTR MIT 209155885 47847 773 $2,200.28 3/26/2009GTE GRICE VERONIQUE D GTR MIT 209155902 47847 790 $508.34 3/26/2009GTE GADSON FRANK GTR MIT 209155869 47847 757 $1,545.29 3/26/2009GTE KRAUS PAUL GTR MIT 209155886 47847 774 $511.90 3/26/2009GTE WATKINS ANGELA GTR MIT 209155903 47847 791 $971.09 3/26/2009GTE HAWKINS EDWIN D JR GTR MIT 209155870 47847 758 $1,295.04 3/26/2009GTE LOCKHART YOLANDA GTR MIT 209155887 47847 775 $545.97 3/26/2009GTE GILLESPIE TAMMIE A GTR MIT 209155904 47847 792 $1,299.05 3/26/2009GTE AKIL AHMAD GTE AKIL SOUAD F GTR MIT 209155871 47847 759 $1,637.44 3/26/2009GTE BROWN DANIEL L GTR MIT 209155888 47847 776 $712.71 3/26/2009GTE AUSTIN YOLANDA A GTR MIT 209155905 47847 793 $1,337.04 3/26/2009GTE NELSON CARMELLA GTR MIT 209155872 47847 760 $625.10 3/26/2009GTE CROSS ROSELL JR GTR MIT 209155889 47847 777 $945.79 3/26/2009GTE SANDELIN KENNETH L GTR MIT 209155906 47847 794 $1,547.07 3/26/2009GTE PRATT DWAYNE P GTR MIT 209155873 47847 761 $2,840.98 3/26/2009GTE STONGE JENNIFER L GTR MIT 209155890 47847 778 $986.38 3/26/2009GTE HUDSON ALESE M GTR MIT 209155907 47847 795 $1,205.91 3/26/2009GTE VACHON TORRENCE L GTR MIT 209155874 47847 762 $1,351.35 3/26/2009GTE EARLY SHIRLEY J GTR MIT 209155891 47847 779 $2,913.44 3/26/2009GTE LANG YVETTE E GTR MIT 209155908 47847 796 $546.55 3/26/2009GTE RICHMOND SEAN J GTR MIT 209155875 47847 763 $1,889.27 3/26/2009GTE DAVIS MARCIA A GTR MIT 209155892 47847 780 $890.05 3/26/2009GTE DAVIS KELI GTR MIT 209155909 47847 797 $811.96 3/26/2009GTE BRYANT CARLOS F GTR MIT 209155876 47847 764 $2,314.52 3/26/2009GTE DELLEPELLE ANTHONY GTR MIT 209155893 47847 781 $1,271.12 3/26/2009GTE KERSTEIN JAMES F GTR MIT 209155910 47847 798 $738.20 3/26/2009GTE OLSON MATTHEW J GTR MIT 209155877 47847 765 $2,068.35 3/26/2009GTE ROBERT PAUL GTR MIT 209155894 47847 782 $10,781.20 3/26/2009GTE ROBERSON RAYMOND M GTR MIT 209155911 47847 799 $590.69 3/26/2009GTE LITTLETON STEPHINE GTR MIT 209155878 47847 766 $3,061.30 3/26/2009GTE KADRICH BRYAN GTE KADRICH MARGARET GTR MIT 209155895 47847 783 $3,341.03 3/26/2009GTE WILLIAMS JOHN T GTR MIT 209155912 47847 800 $924.04 3/26/2009GTE JUSTICE KEVIN M GTR MIT 209155896 47847 784 $869.32 3/26/2009GTE HOWARD ALYSON S GTE HOWARD KENNETH W GTR MIT 209155913 47847 801 $519.89 3/26/2009GTE CRANE LAWRENCE J GTR MIT 209155879 47847 767 $761.54 3/26/2009GTE YOUNG LADONNA GTR MIT 209155880 47847 768 $1,106.90 3/26/2009GTE AYRES LISA R GTE AYRES TIM R GTR MIT 209155897 47847 785 $908.27 3/26/2009GTE LLOYD CHINTELE GTR MIT 209155914 47847 802 $1,779.15 3/26/2009GTE A S C E N C I O N J UA N I TA GTE ASCENCION MIGUEL GTR MIT 209155843 47847 731 $977.38 3/26/2009GTE WINCEL LOIS E GTE WINCEL RALPH M GTR MIT 209155881 47847 769 $1,869.66 3/26/2009GTE BIRD JASON GTR MIT 209155898 47847 786 $1,848.14 3/26/2009GTE REDMOND DANIEL GTR MIT 209155915 47847 803 $4,741.39 3/26/2009GTE SHELTON JIMMY A GTR MIT 209155844 47847 732 $2,586.09 3/26/2009GTE SELLS FRED GTR MIT 209155882 47847 770 $863.88 3/26/2009GTE GARY PAMELA GTR MIT 209155899 47847 787 $952.85 3/26/2009GTE MCCULLOUGH ESSIE M GTR MIT 209155916 47847 804 $607.84 3/26/2009GTE HODGES GLENN J GTE HODGES TRACEY L GTR MIT 209155845 47847 733 $1,301.07 3/26/2009GTE WOODS MARIE GTR MIT 209155883 47847 771 $990.82 3/26/2009GTE PATINO NORMA GTR MIT 209155900 47847 788 $553.10 3/26/2009GTE SHAVERS DAMON D GTR MIT 209155846 47847 734 $546.87 3/26/2009GTE WYCHE KIMBERLY GTR MIT 209155884 47847 772 $1,327.01 3/26/2009GTE FAILS DWIGHT GTR MIT 209155901 47847 789 $914.98 3/26/2009GTE ROBERTS PAUL GTR MIT 209155847 47847 735 $976.64 3/26/2009GTE TERRY ROSYLAND GTR MIT 209155848 47847 736 $1,248.77 3/26/2009GTE DANDRIDGE LAWERENCE GTR MIT 209155849 47847 737 $548.46 3/26/2009GTE HUNT DONALD D GTE HUNT SUZETTE A GTR MIT 209155850 47847 738 $2,981.22 3/26/2009GTE SMITH FREDERICKA GTR MIT 209155851 47847 739 $1,257.80 3/26/2009GTE WALK TRACEY Y GTR MIT 209155852 47847 740 $2,048.42 3/26/2009GTE KELLY TRACEY A GTR MIT 209155853 47847 741 $1,173.26 3/26/2009GTE TYSON DEMETRIA R GTR MIT 209155854 47847 742 $954.07 3/26/2009GTE BOWEN PAUL D GTR MIT 209155855 47847 743 $22,281.30 3/26/2009GTE GRAY MICHAEL A GTR MIT 209155856 47847 744 $566.35 3/26/2009GTE ROMERO RAUL A GTR MIT 209155857 47847 745 $677.78 3/26/2009GTE CHANDLER CASEY A GTR MIT 209155858 47847 746 $1,094.37 3/26/2009GTE ALIAHMAD MARK GTR MIT 209155859 47847 747 $2,264.63 3/26/2009GTE GAMBLIN MELVIN L GTR MIT 209155860 47847 748 $1,406.71 3/26/2009GTE BENNETT JEFFREY GTR MIT 209155861 47847 749 $846.49 3/26/2009GTE GARDNER ANGELA L GTR MIT 209155862 47847 750 $870.19 3/26/2009GTE BUTLER TYSHANDA M GTR MIT 209155863 47847 751 $6,028.26 3/26/2009GTE SHEVROVICH SCOTT B GTR MIT 209155864 47847 752 $532.69 3/26/2009GTE SMITH THEODORE A GTR MIT 209155865 47847 753 $518.51 3/26/2009GTE THOMAS ERICK R GTR MIT 209155866 47847 754 $941.43 3/26/2009GTE HICKS LAURIE A GTE HICKS TERRY L GTR MIT 209155867 47847 755 $522.09 3/26/2009GTE WHITFIELD JOSEPH R GTR MIT 209155917 47847 805 $867.07 3/26/2009GTE PARRISH KEITH D GTR MIT Continued on Page 47 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 11 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 The Detroit Legal News, Page 47 State Tax Liens Bernard J. Youngblood Register of Deeds The following state and federal tax liens have been rounded to the nearest dollar. Continued from Page 46 209155918 47847 806 $917.93 3/26/2009GTE THOMAS GREGORY GTR MIT 209155919 47847 807 $995.69 3/26/2009GTE KOCHER ROBERT GTR MIT 209155920 47847 808 $777.60 3/26/2009GTE THOMAS SHELIA R GTR MIT 209155931 47847 819 $3,538.86 3/26/2009GTE PARKER MACKENZIE N GTR MIT 209155947 47847 835 $1,670.13 3/27/2009GTE QUINN JOSEPH A GTR MIT 209155983 47847 871 $1,394.74 3/27/2009GTE WINFREY MILLICENT G GTR MIT 209155932 47847 820 $1,028.05 3/26/2009GTE ROBERTSON BERNARD GTR MIT 209155948 47847 836 $524.00 3/27/2009GTE TARRAF GHASSAN H GTE TARRAF RANIA G GTR MIT 209155984 47847 872 $1,723.43 3/27/2009GTE RICHTER LEROY W GTR MIT 209155933 47847 821 $2,240.73 3/26/2009GTE DIAZ LINDA GTR MIT 209155934 47847 822 $10,598.60 3/27/2009GTE RANA ABIDA GTR MIT 209155935 47847 823 $5,495.65 3/27/2009GTE BIROU STELIAN S GTR MIT 209155936 47847 824 $6,597.81 3/27/2009GTE LEOS TRANSPORT INC GTR MIT 209155921 47847 809 $526.97 3/26/2009GTE SCHMELZER SHAWN M GTR MIT 209155937 47847 825 $10,422.81 3/27/2009GTE C A B L E C O M M U N I C AT I O N S P U B L I C B E N E F I T CORP GTR MIT 209155922 47847 810 $596.82 3/26/2009GTE UPSHAW CATRINA A GTR MIT 209155938 47847 826 $2,137.64 3/27/2009GTE R & L COLOR GRAPHICS INC GTR MIT 209155923 47847 811 $1,218.67 3/26/2009GTE RAGLAND BRENDA GTE STPETER JASON GTR MIT 209155939 47847 827 $6,732.85 3/27/2009GTE PHOENIX COMMUNITIES INC GTR MIT 209155924 47847 812 $1,379.16 3/26/2009GTE PARKER WARREN J GTR MIT 209155925 47847 813 $1,261.09 3/26/2009GTE WOODS LAFAYE C GTR MIT 209155940 47847 828 $4,497.26 3/27/2009GTE DAYTONA CONTRACTING CO INC GTR MIT 209155941 47847 829 $6,548.88 3/27/2009GTE GENESIS SAND & GRAVEL INC GTR MIT 209155926 47847 814 $530.88 3/26/2009GTE BRYAN SHERMAN GTR MIT 209155942 47847 830 $6,597.81 3/27/2009GTE DY E R L E A N N G T E W O N D E R F U L E X P R E S S GTR MIT 209155927 47847 815 $516.58 3/26/2009GTE RIES CHRISTOPHER A GTR MIT 209155943 47847 831 $1,485.40 3/27/2009GTE MERRIMAN RICK E GTR MIT 209155928 47847 816 $1,279.40 3/26/2009GTE WHITE SHIRLEY GTR MIT 209155944 47847 832 $4,904.53 3/27/2009GTE WILLIAMS BETTY S GTR MIT 209155929 47847 817 $23,599.99 3/26/2009GTE GARCIA JAIME GTR MIT 209155945 47847 833 $7,322.38 3/27/2009GTE CEASAR LONNIE GTR MIT 209155930 47847 818 $1,339.34 3/26/2009GTE NUNEZ B M GTE NUNEZ GABRIEL GTR MIT 209155946 47847 834 $730.74 3/27/2009GTE TAYLOR GARY R GTR MIT 209155949 47847 837 $1,470.31 3/27/2009GTE CALMESE FRANK V GTR MIT 209155950 47847 838 $683.23 3/27/2009GTE BURRELL DARRETT GTR MIT 209155951 47847 839 $833.53 3/27/2009GTE DICKERSON LINEOUS GTE DICKERSON ROGINA L GTR MIT 209155952 47847 840 $951.94 3/27/2009GTE BOGUS TAVARIS L GTR MIT 209155953 47847 841 $752.13 3/27/2009GTE PATTERSON GARY GTR MIT 209155954 47847 842 $5,339.01 3/27/2009GTE LESHORE WANDA GTR MIT 209155985 47847 873 $3,395.31 3/27/2009GTE GENTILE KENNETH P GTR MIT 209155986 47847 874 $4,545.15 3/27/2009GTE BELL ERIC L II GTE BELL KEELY A GTR MIT 209155987 47847 875 $879.03 3/27/2009GTE SPARKS LAURIE GTE SPARKS TERRY W GTR MIT 209155988 47847 876 $26,329.62 3/27/2009GTE WELLS RAYMOND GTR MIT 209155989 47847 877 $7,261.07 3/27/2009GTE CANADA FAYE GTR MIT 209155990 47847 878 $1,054.44 3/27/2009GTE JOHNSON ALFRED GTR MIT 209155955 47847 843 $1,623.86 3/27/2009GTE GILBERT JOHNNY S GTR MIT 209155991 47847 879 $1,455.98 3/27/2009GTE M AT T H E W S C H A R L E S L G T E M AT T H E W S SHAUNTE GTR MIT 209155956 47847 844 $828.00 3/27/2009GTE CRAWFORD MARY GTE CRAWFORD REGINALD GTR MIT 209155992 47847 880 $1,163.93 3/27/2009GTE GHOSSEIN ALI I GTE GHOSSEIN AMAL GTR MIT 209155957 47847 845 $641.14 3/27/2009GTE RINGO CHRISTINA GTR MIT 209155993 47847 881 $1,589.76 3/27/2009GTE LODOLO GENA GTE LODOLO JOHN M GTR MIT 209155958 47847 846 $642.11 3/27/2009GTE WATSON CALVIN A GTE WATSON KARA V GTR MIT 209155994 47847 882 $537.95 3/27/2009GTE JOHNSON JENNIFER J IV GTR MIT 209155959 47847 847 $889.10 3/27/2009GTE TELL GEORGIA GTR MIT 209155995 47847 883 $647.04 3/27/2009GTE SWINFORD BILL R GTR MIT 209155960 47847 848 $1,126.00 3/27/2009GTE CURETON CORLISS GTR MIT 209155996 47847 884 $924.28 3/27/2009GTE MONROE LOIS A GTR MIT 209155961 47847 849 $849.90 3/27/2009GTE HUNTER RENA GTR MIT 209155997 47847 885 $1,605.86 3/27/2009GTE ROMAN JULIO C GTR MIT 209155962 47847 850 $3,198.49 3/27/2009GTE CARR LAKIESHA M GTR MIT 209155998 47847 886 $32,249.21 3/30/2009GTE OAK LEAF L L C GTR MIT 209155963 47847 851 $559.00 3/27/2009GTE WADE DEANGELO GTR MIT 209155999 47847 887 $8,172.44 3/30/2009GTE GTR DEARBORN MART & FUEL INC MIT 209155964 47847 852 $2,858.68 3/27/2009GTE MACLIN AKEIA M GTR MIT 209155965 47847 853 $1,505.90 3/27/2009GTE JOYCE MICHAEL GTR MIT 209156000 47847 888 $3,737.94 3/30/2009GTE GOOD BREAD CO OF MICHIGAN DEARBORN LLC GTR MIT 209155966 47847 854 $891.13 3/27/2009GTE RUSSELL CAROLYN O GTR MIT 209156001 47847 889 $2,379.41 3/30/2009GTE 4 BROTHERS TRUCK & TRAILERS SERVICES INC GTR MIT 209155967 47847 855 $1,116.47 3/27/2009GTE MOON SHONDRA GTR MIT 209156002 47847 890 $4,344.52 3/30/2009GTE OAKMAN WHOLESALE INC GTR MIT 209155968 47847 856 $2,313.36 3/27/2009GTE EVERETT CHRISTINE A GTR MIT 209156003 47847 891 $2,070.14 3/30/2009GTE K & S CUSTOMS LLC GTR MIT 209155969 47847 857 $835.47 3/27/2009GTE KOZLOWSKI JULIA GTR MIT 209156004 47847 892 $4,567.30 3/30/2009GTE HARGROW & ASSOC INC GTR MIT 209155970 47847 858 $2,457.30 3/27/2009GTE HORTON THOMAS S GTR MIT 209156005 47847 893 $10,017.83 3/30/2009GTE RBK AUTOMATION INC GTR MIT 209155971 47847 859 $933.47 3/27/2009GTE RO D R I G U E Z B A R B A R A A G T E RO D R I G U E Z RALPH GTR MIT 209156006 47847 894 $27,159.78 3/30/2009GTE THABATA DIAB GTR MIT 209155972 47847 860 $1,024.69 3/27/2009GTE JACKSON STACY J GTR MIT 209155973 47847 861 $1,522.89 3/27/2009GTE CANNON GWENDOLYN GTR MIT 209155974 47847 862 $972.50 3/27/2009GTE KELL MICHAEL J GTR MIT 209155975 47847 863 $1,169.53 3/27/2009GTE W E S T B RO O K G R E G O RY G T E W E S T B RO O K WENDY R GTR MIT 209155976 47847 864 $543.33 3/27/2009GTE KORHONEN RONALD C GTR MIT 209155977 47847 865 $1,220.00 3/27/2009GTE KADAF FADI J GTR MIT 209156007 47847 895 $94,017.42 3/30/2009GTE BONKS BAY L L C GTR MIT 209156008 47847 896 $788.60 3/30/2009GTE CARY LOSSIE GTR MIT 209156009 47847 897 $1,293.06 3/30/2009GTE HINTON WYNORA GTR MIT 209156010 47847 898 $3,697.29 3/30/2009GTE JOHNSON LULA B GTR MIT 209156011 47847 899 $983.61 3/30/2009GTE HOHMANN THOMAS M GTR MIT 209156012 47847 900 $7,761.10 3/30/2009GTE HICKS JOHNNIE GTR MIT 209156013 47847 901 $3,271.36 3/30/2009GTE SEALES SERENA L GTR MIT 209155978 47847 866 $1,340.00 3/27/2009GTE KERR CHRISTIE A GTE KERR EDWIN JR GTR MIT 209156014 47847 902 $2,180.83 3/30/2009GTE CARSWELL NICOLE GTR MIT 209155979 47847 867 $1,531.53 3/27/2009GTE STINER TRACI K GTR MIT 209156015 47847 903 $9,674.47 3/30/2009GTE SMITH CORTEZ GTR MIT 209155980 47847 868 $829.89 3/27/2009GTE JONES EDMOND A GTE JONES TINA L GTR MIT 209156016 47847 904 $723.83 3/30/2009GTE MARSHALL CHAUNDRA L GTR MIT 209155981 47847 869 $816.16 3/27/2009GTE ALSTON KENNETH GTR MIT 209155982 47847 870 $1,489.93 3/27/2009GTE JAMES ALICE M GTR MIT 209156017 47847 905 $1,270.81 3/30/2009GTE MURPHY CLIFTON J GTR MIT 209156018 47847 906 $656.80 3/30/2009GTE CLINTON ARTHUR JR GTR MIT Continued on Page 48 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 12 Page 48, The Detroit Legal News FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 State Tax Liens Bernard J. Youngblood Register of Deeds The following state and federal tax liens have been rounded to the nearest dollar. Continued from Page 47 209156019 47847 907 $2,170.23 3/30/2009GTE GHANT KEITH W GTR MIT 209156020 47847 908 $1,867.03 3/30/2009GTE WHITE JOHN G GTR MIT 209156021 47847 909 $4,177.00 3/30/2009GTE GILLON MATTHEW A GTR MIT 209156022 47847 910 $784.28 3/30/2009GTE WILLIAMS JOSEPH L GTR MIT 209156023 47847 911 $887.95 3/30/2009GTE MILLER MARVIN GTR MIT 209156024 47847 912 $872.71 3/30/2009GTE HARGROVE KIANDREA L GTR MIT 209156025 47847 913 $7,846.27 3/30/2009GTE MORTON CHARLES GTR MIT 209156026 47847 914 $810.97 3/30/2009GTE TUCKER NORENE M GTR MIT 209156027 47847 915 $976.80 3/30/2009GTE GLEAVES CYNTHIA H GTR MIT 209156028 47847 916 $762.96 3/30/2009GTE SALLOUM THOMAS A GTR MIT 209156029 47847 917 $877.17 3/30/2009GTE EAST KENYATTE O GTR MIT 209156030 47847 918 $602.45 3/30/2009GTE RICKETT GORDON GTR MIT 209156031 47847 919 $16,822.97 3/30/2009GTE BEBBER GREGORY GTR MIT 209156032 47847 920 $727.11 3/30/2009GTE HAMILTON DEMETROUS M GTR MIT 209156033 47847 921 $742.62 3/30/2009GTE ROBINSON ANTHONY E GTR MIT 209156034 47847 922 $1,296.97 3/30/2009GTE PINGSTON RUTH A GTR MIT 209156035 47847 923 $1,642.88 3/30/2009GTE JOHNSON EDITH C GTE JOHNSON JOHN A GTR MIT 209156036 47847 924 $1,159.20 3/30/2009GTE GRAVES LINDA A GTR MIT 209156037 47847 925 $721.26 3/30/2009GTE GUTHRIE SANDRA F GTR MIT 209156038 47847 926 $573.56 3/30/2009GTE HOWARD PHILIP GTR MIT 209156039 47847 927 $2,857.13 3/30/2009GTE WILLIAMS WENDY GTR MIT 209156040 47847 928 $8,384.31 3/30/2009GTE GAMBRELL MILVIA GTR MIT 209156041 47847 929 $1,236.77 3/30/2009GTE MORGAN JOHN GTE MORGAN MARY GTR MIT 209156042 47847 930 $773.49 3/30/2009GTE FOSTER JEFFREY R GTE FOSTER LISA D GTR MIT 209156043 47847 931 $628.75 3/30/2009GTE HOLLOWAY LAWRENCE A GTR MIT 209156044 47847 932 $792.01 3/30/2009GTE NORMAN BETTY J GTR MIT 209156045 47847 933 $1,278.83 3/30/2009GTE SMITH MICHAEL A GTR MIT 209156046 47847 934 $717.10 3/30/2009GTE BURNETT MAURICE B GTE PERR HELEN GTR MIT 209156047 47847 935 $738.31 3/30/2009GTE GRAHAM LAURA K GTR MIT 209156048 47847 936 $1,381.19 3/30/2009GTE ANTHONY CHELITA GTR MIT 209156049 47847 937 $905.76 3/30/2009GTE HALL WILLIAM GTR MIT 209156050 47847 938 $4,940.06 3/30/2009GTE PATRICK CRAIG D GTR MIT 209156051 47847 939 $1,687.24 3/30/2009GTE DUNBAR STEVEN GTR MIT 209156052 47847 940 $5,610.17 3/30/2009GTE FINKLEY RICHARD GTR MIT 209156053 47847 941 $656.80 3/30/2009GTE GREEN TROY GTR MIT 209156054 47847 942 $904.56 3/30/2009GTE WHITTY WILLIAM GTR MIT 209156082 47847 970 $910.10 3/30/2009GTE DAVIS KATONYA C GTR MIT 209156109 47847 997 $1,352.75 3/30/2009GTE WILLIAMS DARRYL K GTR MIT 209156055 47847 943 $778.07 3/30/2009GTE SUTHERLAND CARLA M GTR MIT 209156083 47847 971 $543.24 3/30/2009GTE BUFORD DETREDA C GTE BUFORD EWAM W GTR MIT 209156110 47847 998 $2,348.81 3/30/2009GTE MAKLED ALI GTR MIT 209156056 47847 944 $656.70 3/30/2009GTE KELLEY MARTINA E GTR MIT 209156057 47847 945 $5,073.38 3/30/2009GTE ROWE ARTHUR L GTR MIT 209156058 47847 946 $850.09 3/30/2009GTE CRUTCHER FLORA J GTR MIT 209156059 47847 947 $5,873.43 3/30/2009GTE THOMAS DONALD A GTR MIT 209156060 47847 948 $724.98 3/30/2009GTE CORRETHERS KIMBERLY R GTR MIT 209156061 47847 949 $1,351.05 3/30/2009GTE CHANDLER JASON T GTR MIT 209156062 47847 950 $952.42 3/30/2009GTE BELL INEKA A GTR MIT 209156063 47847 951 $1,446.24 3/30/2009GTE MULLIN LESTER J GTR MIT 209156064 47847 952 $2,902.77 3/30/2009GTE NUNN EUNICE L GTE NUNN JODY GTR MIT 209156065 47847 953 $1,201.12 3/30/2009GTE JHONS HARRIS ANNIEBELLE GTR MIT 209156066 47847 954 $510.30 3/30/2009GTE DESANA YVONNE M GTR MIT 209156067 47847 955 $1,360.22 3/30/2009GTE WHITE CARLEY D GTR MIT 209156084 47847 972 $2,242.80 3/30/2009GTE ZOHR CHERYL A GTE ZOHR DENNIS G GTR MIT 209156085 47847 973 $3,926.74 3/30/2009GTE MYLES LEE GTR MIT 209156086 47847 974 $1,865.49 3/30/2009GTE KLOC SCOTT GTR MIT 209156087 47847 975 $4,966.14 3/30/2009GTE WASKIEWICZ BRIAN J GTR MIT 209156088 47847 976 $3,863.57 3/30/2009GTE WILTSHIRE CHRISTOPHER J GTR MIT 209156089 47847 977 $1,185.15 3/30/2009GTE DOUGLAS SOTHIA J GTR MIT 209156090 47847 978 $1,292.94 3/30/2009GTE DAVIS KEIJUAN T GTR MIT 209156091 47847 979 $9,447.57 3/30/2009GTE MENDEZ JOHN GTR MIT 209156092 47847 980 $693.61 3/30/2009GTE SEAY RODNEY A GTR MIT 209156093 47847 981 $2,447.54 3/30/2009GTE BRIGGS BASIL E GTR MIT 209156094 47847 982 $629.35 3/30/2009GTE HOWARD LORISSA GTR MIT 209156068 47847 956 $7,830.68 3/30/2009GTE REA FABIAN GTR MIT 209156095 47847 983 $880.30 3/30/2009GTE CRESENT PLACE % GTE MASSEY NICOLE M GTR MIT 209156069 47847 957 $776.92 3/30/2009GTE MEDONIS PAUL R GTR MIT 209156096 47847 984 $598.17 3/30/2009GTE HOLMES LAMONT JR GTR MIT 209156070 47847 958 $2,917.59 3/30/2009GTE MOORE NICOLAS K GTR MIT 209156097 47847 985 $2,501.59 3/30/2009GTE SMITH DAVID GTR MIT 209156071 47847 959 $1,066.67 3/30/2009GTE YATES STEVEN D GTR MIT 209156098 47847 986 $6,412.63 3/30/2009GTE BOBBISH DIANE GTE BOBBISH GARY A GTR MIT 209156072 47847 960 $1,057.56 3/30/2009GTE HALL LOREDANA GTR MIT 209156073 47847 961 $1,569.60 3/30/2009GTE MURPHY FREDDIE GTR MIT 209156074 47847 962 $786.31 3/30/2009GTE DARNELL TONI R GTR MIT 209156075 47847 963 $1,095.63 3/30/2009GTE ROBINSON ANGELICA M GTR MIT 209156076 47847 964 $807.37 3/30/2009GTE DAVIS KENYA GTR MIT 209156077 47847 965 $1,491.44 3/30/2009GTE AVERITT THOMAS GTR MIT 209156078 47847 966 $24,182.95 3/30/2009GTE STEELE DESMOND P GTR MIT 209156099 47847 987 $1,867.02 3/30/2009GTE JAMES CHARMAINE GTR MIT 209156100 47847 988 $1,488.60 3/30/2009GTE MEIRTHEW DIANE M GTR MIT 209156101 47847 989 $548.78 3/30/2009GTE GREEN BRANDY GTR MIT 209156102 47847 990 $815.29 3/30/2009GTE KILLMER JEANETTE M GTR MIT 209156103 47847 991 $642.20 3/30/2009GTE FOSTER RYAN E GTR MIT 209156104 47847 992 $2,869.32 3/30/2009GTE ASMUS KIMBERLY GTE ASMUS KURT GTR MIT 209156105 47847 993 $633.89 3/30/2009GTE DALEY SHEILA M GTR MIT 209156079 47847 967 $1,425.13 3/30/2009GTE SANDERS CUTTINA L GTE SANDERS RODNEY E GTR MIT 209156106 47847 994 $632.26 3/30/2009GTE DENNIS ERIC GTR MIT 209156080 47847 968 $1,467.52 3/30/2009GTE ROLLINS DARRYL GTR MIT 209156107 47847 995 $1,021.59 3/30/2009GTE ROZWOOD DEBORAH C GTR MIT 209156081 47847 969 $565.67 3/30/2009GTE ECHOLS MELVERA GTR MIT 209156108 47847 996 $1,458.22 3/30/2009GTE MORRIS SHERYL D GTR MIT 209156111 47847 999 $737.17 3/30/2009GTE JANICE ROBERTSON GTR MIT 209156112 47847 1000 $3,193.74 3/30/2009GTE GARDNER STEVEN L GTE GARDNER TRACY A GTR MIT 209156113 47847 1001 $864.41 3/30/2009GTE WOOTEN SHIRLEY A GTR MIT 209156114 47847 1002 $1,084.02 3/30/2009GTE MOHAN CAROLYN S GTR MIT 209156115 47847 1003 $1,103.58 3/30/2009GTE CURTIS ROTHCHILD GTE RICH JANICE GTR MIT 209156116 47847 1004 $7,562.40 3/30/2009GTE CHAPMAN GREGORY GTR MIT 209156117 47847 1005 $710.79 3/30/2009GTE EARL FRANKLIN GTR MIT 209156118 47847 1006 $786.43 3/30/2009GTE MORRIS CHARMAINE GTR MIT 209156119 47847 1007 $2,547.28 3/30/2009GTE RANGEL RICARDO GTR MIT 209156120 47847 1008 $663.55 3/30/2009GTE SCHIFFER KIMBERLY M GTR MIT 209156121 47847 1009 $802.96 3/30/2009GTE WATSON RUTH A GTR MIT 209156122 47847 1010 $656.80 3/30/2009GTE WYATT QUINTEL D GTR MIT 209156123 47847 1011 $793.75 3/30/2009GTE GUESS RUTH M GTR MIT 209156124 47847 1012 $1,358.49 3/30/2009GTE ATTERBURY DANNY GTR MIT 209156125 47847 1013 $1,017.60 3/30/2009GTE WATSON LINDA GTR MIT 209156126 47847 1014 $518.72 3/30/2009GTE LLEWELLYN DENT GTR MIT 209156127 47847 1015 $45.23 3/30/2009GTE SANCHEZ DOMITILA D GTE SANCHEZ ROGELIO G GTR MIT 209156128 47847 1016 $1,473.55 3/30/2009GTE BARMAKZIAN ANAYES GTR MIT 209156129 47847 1017 $806.36 3/30/2009GTE GUAJARDO MARIA E GTR MIT 209156130 47847 1018 $6,376.91 3/31/2009GTE LINCOLN PARK MINI MART INC GTR MIT 209156131 47847 1019 $870.61 3/31/2009GTE NELSON CRYSTAL GTR MIT 209156132 47847 1020 $5,537.38 3/31/2009GTE FIRST CUP ORGANIC COFFEE LLC GTR MIT 209156133 47847 1021 $3,172.50 3/31/2009GTE CITY SMOKER LIMITED LLC GTR MIT 209156134 47847 1022 $1,709.52 3/31/2009GTE KEYS CHARLES GTR MIT 209156135 47847 1023 $1,286.86 3/31/2009GTE GUY BOBBY G GTR MIT Continued on Page 49 DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 13 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 The Detroit Legal News, Page 49 State Tax Liens Bernard J. Youngblood Register of Deeds The following state and federal tax liens have been rounded to the nearest dollar. Continued from Page 48 209156171 47847 1059 $1,324.62 3/31/2009GTE GARCIA CONNIE A GTE GARCIA JESUS R GTR MIT 209156172 47847 1060 $1,352.42 3/31/2009GTE MASON KHARY U GTR MIT 209156173 47847 1061 $945.82 3/31/2009GTE GRAVES KISZAR A GTR MIT & H FOOD INC GTE MT ELLIOT SUNOCO GTR MIT 209173912 47865 97 $804.22 4/2/2009GTE BIVINS VERDELL GTR MIT 209173901 47865 80 $14,992.10 4/3/2009GTE FARHAT ALI GTR MIT 209173913 47865 98 $787.48 4/2/2009GTE JONES JAMES GTR MIT 209173902 47865 82 $55,301.73 4/1/2009GTE GRAND MEYER SOPHIA BEAUTY SUPPLY INC GTR MIT 209173914 47865 99 $7,756.91 4/2/2009GTE REYNOLDS TARA A GTR MIT 209156136 47847 1024 $774.05 3/31/2009GTE RIDER JACQUELINE GTR MIT 209156174 47847 1062 $707.36 3/31/2009GTE KING CATHY GTR MIT 209173903 47865 85 $80,147.61 4/1/2009GTE WOODWARD SOPHIA BEAUTY INC GTR MIT 209173915 47865 100 $1,596.46 4/2/2009GTE PESKO MYRA M GTE PESKO ROBERT J GTR MIT 209156137 47847 1025 $662.44 3/31/2009GTE ATCHISON TAMEMIA K GTR MIT 209156175 47847 1063 $713.32 3/31/2009GTE FINAZZO MARIE A GTR MIT 209173904 47865 89 $3,599.59 4/2/2009GTE DL COMMODITIES LLC GTR MIT 209173916 47865 101 $564.59 4/2/2009GTE BREISH LAURA GTR MIT 209156138 47847 1026 $1,667.31 3/31/2009GTE BOWEN GERALD R JR GTR MIT 209156176 47847 1064 $4,116.73 3/31/2009GTE RICHARDSON ROBERT GTR MIT 209173905 47865 90 $15,284.79 4/2/2009GTE CW III INC GTE PINNACLE FASHIONS GTR MIT 209173917 47865 102 $1,813.18 4/2/2009GTE SPICER MONICA P GTR MIT 209156139 47847 1027 $55,463.45 3/31/2009GTE CLEMENT NORMAN J GTR MIT 209156177 47847 1065 $1,394.99 3/31/2009GTE HAMPTON QUINTON D GTR MIT 209173906 47865 91 $4,291,737.38 4/2/2009GTE SYNERGY PETROLEUM INC GTR MIT 209173918 47865 103 $650.46 4/2/2009GTE SEWELL JAMES P GTE SEWELL PHYLLIS GTR MIT 209156140 47847 1028 $1,576.40 3/31/2009GTE KHAALIDA MUHAMMAD GTR MIT 209156178 47847 1066 $2,405.97 3/31/2009GTE SOUDERS TRACY F GTR MIT 209173907 47865 92 $6,931.74 4/2/2009GTE COMPLETE SERVICE HEAT COOL REFRIGERATION INC GTR MIT 209156141 47847 1029 $739.46 3/31/2009GTE MYATT DION L GTR MIT 209156179 47847 1067 $776.30 3/31/2009GTE COLGROVE ALLEN B GTR MIT 209156142 47847 1030 $800.91 3/31/2009GTE REDMOND RACHEL GTR MIT 209156180 47847 1068 $886.51 3/31/2009GTE CARTER STANLEY P GTR MIT 209156143 47847 1031 $4,429.99 3/31/2009GTE RICE DOUGLAS B GTE RICE SHERRY J GTR MIT 209156181 47847 1069 $751.54 3/31/2009GTE JACKSON KAREN D GTR MIT 209156144 47847 1032 $693.50 3/31/2009GTE MCGHEE DENISE GTR MIT 209156182 47847 1070 $1,045.56 3/31/2009GTE GREENLAW ROBERT GTE GREENLAW VERONICA M GTR MIT 209156145 47847 1033 $12,913.82 3/31/2009GTE SHATTLEROE EDWARD J GTR MIT 209156146 47847 1034 $514.97 3/31/2009GTE ALVILLAR MARTIN C GTR MIT 209156183 47847 1071 $942.39 3/31/2009GTE HAWKINS DEVON GTR MIT 209156184 47847 1072 $1,393.67 3/31/2009GTE OLSEN THOMAS F GTR MIT 209156147 47847 1035 $750.98 3/31/2009GTE HERBERT JAMES JR GTE HERBERT TERESA GTR MIT 209156185 47847 1073 $695.62 3/31/2009GTE HUDSON JEROME D GTR MIT 209156148 47847 1036 $765.98 3/31/2009GTE ALLMAN KELLI D GTR MIT 209156186 47847 1074 $743.48 3/31/2009GTE WOODS MALCOLM GTR MIT 209156149 47847 1037 $742.74 3/31/2009GTE WREYON LONDON GTR MIT 209156187 47847 1075 $773.84 3/31/2009GTE SAKEENA BASHIER DORINDA M GTR MIT 209156150 47847 1038 $1,282.02 3/31/2009GTE GADDIS DIANE GTR MIT 209156188 47847 1076 $5,474.15 3/31/2009GTE ROOKS SYDNEY GTR MIT 209156151 47847 1039 $1,758.91 3/31/2009GTE HINTON MARTINUS GTR MIT 209156189 47847 1077 $1,277.03 3/31/2009GTE JEMISON RICHARD GTR MIT 209156152 47847 1040 $1,140.55 3/31/2009GTE DOUGLAS TERRANCE GTR MIT 209156190 47847 1078 $824.30 3/31/2009GTE HICKEY DONNA GTR MIT 209156153 47847 1041 $1,401.57 3/31/2009GTE FLORES KAREN R GTR MIT 209156191 47847 1079 $667.76 3/31/2009GTE RAKOWSKI PAUL M GTR MIT 209156154 47847 1042 $64,540.85 3/31/2009GTE MUSTAPHA HAIDAR R GTR MIT 209156192 47847 1080 $661.24 3/31/2009GTE BOWLING BILLY F GTE BOWLING SUSAN GTR MIT 209156155 47847 1043 $554.49 3/31/2009GTE TINSLEY EDDIE GTR MIT 209156156 47847 1044 $656.80 3/31/2009GTE PRATHER WARDELL GTR MIT 209156157 47847 1045 $996.82 3/31/2009GTE THOMAS ADA GTR MIT 209156158 47847 1046 $1,897.40 3/31/2009GTE GONZALO ALICEA GTR MIT 209156159 47847 1047 $1,333.68 3/31/2009GTE JOHNSON THERESA L GTR MIT 209156193 47847 1081 $906.00 3/31/2009GTE EPPERSON JAMES L GTR MIT 209156194 47847 1082 $1,929.52 3/31/2009GTE HENDERSON PANOLA L GTR MIT 209156195 47847 1083 $1,986.23 3/31/2009GTE AUSTIN ALONZO D GTR MIT 209156196 47847 1084 $923.41 3/31/2009GTE GILDERSLEEVE MARLO GTR MIT 209156197 47847 1085 $983.00 3/31/2009GTE NEWELL JAMES GTR MIT 209156160 47847 1048 $704.26 3/31/2009GTE GTE HONEYCUTT HONEYCUTT JEFF W REBECCA L GTR MIT 209156198 47847 1086 $723.83 3/31/2009GTE GADISON CHRISTOPHER GTR MIT 209156161 47847 1049 $1,230.15 3/31/2009GTE PATRICK RYAN M GTR MIT 209156199 47847 1087 $526.77 3/31/2009GTE NASH ARTHUR K GTR MIT 209156162 47847 1050 $1,071.55 3/31/2009GTE WALTON ANTHONY E GTR MIT 209156200 47847 1088 $879.73 3/31/2009GTE PENA NABOR GTR MIT 209156163 47847 1051 $885.39 3/31/2009GTE STEIGERWALD GERTRUDE M GTR MIT 209156201 47847 1089 $561.71 3/31/2009GTE HEARD DENNIS S GTR MIT 209156164 47847 1052 $1,392.36 3/31/2009GTE BOYKINS LAKISHA P GTR MIT 209156202 47847 1090 $1,417.38 3/31/2009GTE TORRES MARCELO GTR MIT 209156165 47847 1053 $1,271.12 3/31/2009GTE EDWARDS JAMES GTR MIT 209156203 47847 1091 $1,209.00 3/31/2009GTE AVE ANTHONY GTR MIT 209156166 47847 1054 $1,298.74 3/31/2009GTE NORTHROP JACQUELINE GTR MIT 209156204 47847 1092 $878.32 3/31/2009GTE ALSAYDE ABUBAKER A GTR MIT 209156167 47847 1055 $576.19 3/31/2009GTE ELAMIN AJAMU M GTR MIT 209173897 47865 72 $61,891.60 4/1/2009GTE GTR H A L L S A D U LT F O S T E R C A R E I N C MIT 209156168 47847 1056 $1,284.77 3/31/2009GTE JORDAN LEROY GTR MIT 209156169 47847 1057 $822.81 3/31/2009GTE WILEY STEPHEN B GTR MIT 209156170 47847 1058 $5,348.49 3/31/2009GTE SCHULTZ TIMOTHY E GTR MIT 209173898 47865 74 $27,344.48 4/6/2009GTE ALICES BAR & GRILL INC GTR MIT 209173899 47865 76 $7,425.39 4/6/2009GTE DRAKE BARRY D GTR MIT 209173900 47865 78 $363,613.68 4/2/2009GTE A 209173908 47865 93 $3,645.46 4/2/2009GTE GOYAL MARKETING CORP GTR MIT 209173909 47865 94 $28,240.07 4/2/2009GTE J J ENTERPRISES INC GTR MIT 209173911 47865 96 $1,193.75 4/2/2009GTE RAHMAN MAHFUZLR GTE SAERIN SULTA GTR MIT 209173919 47865 104 $3,383.34 4/2/2009GTE HILL JOHNNY E GTR MIT 209173920 47865 105 $20,520.60 4/2/2009GTE W O LT E R J A M E S B G T E W O LT E R S H O N A L GTR MIT 209173921 47865 106 $505.16 4/2/2009GTE MIRIANI CAROLYN G GTE MIRIANI DENNIS G GTR MIT DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 14 Page 50, The Detroit Legal News Book Case ROBERTA A. CORNETTA, THE DAILY RECORD NEWSWIRE ‘Three Felonies’ an indictment against Justice Department Three Felonies a Day: How the Feds Target the Innocent By Harvey A. Silverglate Encounter Books, 2009 306 pages; $25.95 In a work that is sure to stir sharp public debate, veteran Massachusetts defense-attorney-turned-author Harvey A. Silverglate examines the legally and politically charged issues sur rounding recent federal criminal prosecutions. The author begins with the premise that federal criminal statutes have become so pervasive and ambiguous that every person in America can be seen to have committed a federal crime any time a prosecutor subjectively deter mines the same. Added to this theor y is Silverglate’s suggestion that federal prosecutions frequently are brought for other than legitimate law enforcement purposes. “Three Felonies a Day” borrows heavily from a host of locally and nationally prominent federal criminal cases to espouse a compelling argument that the Justice Department’s U.S. attorneys’ off ices have developed a pattern of prosecution that plays to personal and political agendas while discarding the framework of constitutional due process and fairness. Silverglate, no stranger to federal criminal defense work, analyzes a series of cases tightly grouped within eight chapters to make the point that in such diverse areas as prosecutions of politicians, doctors, drug companies, lawyers and accounting firms, U.S. attorneys have misapplied vague federal criminal statutes and used the tactics of indicting low-level suspects, plying them with promises and then “rolling” them to deliver “the big kahuna.” The author relates cases of local interest involving attempts by the government to indict former Boston Mayor Kevin White and the prosecutions of former Massachusetts House Speaker Thomas Finneran and criminal defense attorney William Cintolo in proffering his theme of prosecutors overstepping legally permissible bounds in interpreting and employing federal criminal law. He goes on to cite cases involving, among others, Michael Milken, former Miami Mayor Raul Martinez, attorney Philip Russell of Connecticut and the Ar thur Andersen accounting firm in examining just how prosecutors have made national headlines while disregarding due process and exacting pleas from defendants under the threat of long prison terms and personal and financial ruin. Added to this collection of noteworthy prosecutions, Silverglate further examines the prosecutions of Martha Stewart, Enron and its executives, and non profit groups and, in one instance, even the threatened prosecution of the American Bar Association in discussing how he believes federal prose- cutors, the FBI, DEA and SEC have often turned to criminal prosecutions where clearly civil action only was warranted. Lest the potential reader believe this work is simply a rehash of prior criminal prosecutions and old news, it should be noted that the author goes behind the scenes and in depth to reveal his analysis of tactics that have been used by federal prosecutors in, among other things, visiting potential witnesses (and future indictment targets) with strong, if not threatening, messages to cooperate or else. Silverglate recounts instances of out-of-control inducements and rewards made to government witnesses and the employment of whistleblower rewards in the tens of millions of dollars, which just might influence testimony. The author posits a vexing examination of federal criminal law said to be enacted in deliberately vague language so that it might be applied to citizens. In one example of such an unintended result, Silverglate recounts the use by prosecutors of the Sarbanes-Oxley federal investment reporting statute in seeking to pierce attorney-client privilege. He goes on to identify the federal RICO statute as a prosecutorial vehicle he sees as both overused and misused by prosecutors. The “chilling effect” of such prosecutions on business, professional and political figures is reviewed in depth, while the aftermath of such prosecutions is portrayed in the vivid light of ruined reputations, f inancial wipeout, divorce and mental anguish. Of particular interest is the number of federal convictions that end up reversed by circuit courts of appeals. Meanwhile, the now-exonerated defendant is left to figure out how to get his reputation back, recover from bankruptcy and put his life together again, often having spent months in jail awaiting the outcome of his appeal. And while Silverglate recounts the details of these prosecutions and those who have brought them around the country, he is not content to leave his subject matter there. In both an earnest and candid foreword by Alan M. Dershowitz (could Alan pen anything less?), and a sobering conclusion by the author, both writers plainly warn that only when prosecutors, judges and defense attorneys assume strong initiatives to uphold constitutional due process and fairness in the face of such attempted prosecutions will the public be safe and secure in their constitutional rights. As the book concludes, unless the organized bar and public are prepared to stand up for these rights, the bell “tolls for us all.” ————— Robert A. Cornetta is presiding justice of the Salem District Court in Salem, Mass. FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Across the Nation CALIFORNIA Drug dealer found guilty of murdering 15-year-old Kidnapping and murder were basis for 2007 movie “Alpha Dog” BY JACOB ADELMAN Associated Press Writer SANTA BARBARA, Calif. (AP) — Marijuana dealer Jesse James Hollywood faces a possible death sentence after his conviction for kidnapping and murdering a 15-year-old boy over an escalating drug debt, a crime that inspired the 2007 movie “Alpha Dog.” A Santa Barbara Superior Court jury on Wednesday also found Hollywood guilty of the special circumstance allegation of being a principal in a murder committed in the course of a kidnapping and being involved in a crime in which an assault weapon or machine gun was used, making him eligible for the death penalty. The jury deliberated for about four days. Hollywood, 29, stared straight ahead as the verdict was read. “I can’t believe they found him guilty of that murder,” his father, Jack Hollywood, said out- WASHINGTON (AP) — States across the country are violating part of the federal “motor voter” law requiring voter registration help for low-income residents, according to a coalition of advocacy groups trying to force change through the courts. The groups filed a lawsuit in Indiana Thursday and planned to sue in New Mexico later in the day, on the heels of a successful settlement in Missouri. They say the problem is not isolated in those few states, but widespread across the nation and they are trying to help other states follow the law without litigation. Brenda Wright, director of the Democracy Program at the nonprofit group Demos, one of the groups behind the lawsuits, said 2.6 million people were registered through public assistance off ices in 1995-1996, the f irst two years the law was in effect. But she said registration has dropped precipitously throughout the nation since then, as much as 90 percent or more in some states. Wright said 2 million to 3 million more low-income people could be registered each year if all states followed the law. The suits say that the states are violating the 1993 National Voter Registration Act, commonly known as “motor voter” because Hoyt months before the murder. Prosecutors did not call Hoyt as a witness — the one person who could definitely say if Hollywood ordered the slaying. Also left out of Hollywood’s trial were Jesse Rugge and William Skidmore, two others convicted in the case. Prosecutors contend Hollywood decided to get rid of Nicholas after learning from an attorney that he could face life in prison for kidnapping. They also believe the murder was a way for Hoyt to settle his own drug debt with Hollywood. The crime was the inspiration for “Alpha Dog,” which starred Bruce Willis, Justin Timberlake, Sharon Stone and Emile Hirsch, who played “Johnny Truelove,” a character based on Hollywood. Hollywood fled after the slaying and later testified he had lived in Colorado, the Mojave Desert and various parts of Canada before he was captured in Brazil. CALIFORNIA California’s long process to resuming executions Reinstating the death penalty expected to take up to a year BY PAUL ELIAS Associated Press Writer SACRAMENTO (AP) — A Contra Costa County judge late last month sentenced Dar ryl Kemp to death for the random rape and murder of a young jogger. But chances are that Kemp will not be executed anytime soon, if at all. He is 73. It takes an average of 20 years to execute an inmate in California. And capital punishment has been suspended since February 2006 when Michael Morales came within two hours of execution for the rape and murder of a 17-year-old girl. The return to capital punishment took a step forward when prison officials recently convened a daylong public hearing on proposed rules for lethally injecting condemned inmates with three drugs. Even if the proposal passes legal muster, reinstating the death penalty is expected to take up to a year. Whatever is decided in California, where there are 680 condemned inmates, is expected to shape how other states carry out executions. Since the U.S. Supreme Court signed off on Kentucky’s lethal injection process last year and lifted a brief nationwide moratorium, 36 states and the federal government, which employ the execution method, have experienced varying degrees of success in restarting capital punishment. A federal judge in 2006 halted executions in California until officials expanded the death chamber at San Quentin prison and provided more executioner training and other upgrades to ensure the condemned do not suffer cruel and unusual punishment. The Department of Correc- Suit filed in Indiana, New Mexico, more planned Associated Press Writer admitted mariside the courtroom. juana dealer, The victim’s par15-year-old Nicholas Markowitz was said Ben ents said they were relieved but declined taken to Santa Barbara and held for several M a r k o w i t z owed him a to comment further days before being shot and buried in a $2,500 drug because of a gag shallow grave. Jesse James Hollywood was debt — more order issued in the twice the case. Prosecutors found guilty of orchestrating the kidnapping than amount proseand defense attorand killing over a $2,500 drug debt. cutors have neys also declined to cited. speak. Hollywood The penalty phase of the case was scheduled to begin experts say is rare and potentially said he was afraid after Ben risky. He testified that he and two Markowitz left threatening mesMonday. Hollywood was accused of friends grabbed Markowitz off a sages, poisoned his dog and broke orchestrating the kidnapping and street in the San Fernando Valley a window at his home, only hours eventual killing of Nicholas area of Los Angeles but did not before Nicholas was abducted. Hollywood called the taking of Markowitz in August 2000 order the teen’s murder. “I just feel ter rible about Nicholas irrational and not wellbecause the teen’s half brother everything that happened,” Holly- thought out. owed a drug debt. Hollywood said Ryan Hoyt, the Nicholas was taken to Santa wood testified. “I feel terrible for Barbara and held for several days the Markowitz family. I feel terri- gunman who was convicted and before being shot and buried in a ble that anyone would think I sentenced to death, acted on his own because of concern about shallow grave. Four others have could do something like that.” He said the teen was taken in Ben Markowitz finding out about been convicted in connection with an escalating dispute between him the abduction. Hollywood also the crime. Hollywood took the stand in and the boy’s older half-brother, said the gun used to kill Nicholas his own defense, a move legal Ben Markowitz. Hollywood, an was once his but that he gave it to ▼ Advocacy groups say states violating voter registration law BY NEDRA PICKLER Submit news & views to [email protected] it requires states to offer voter registration when residents are applying for a driver’s license or state ID. To reach low-income citizens who are less likely to own vehicles, the law also requires that voter registration be distributed along with applications for public assistance like food stamps and Medicaid. The coalition of advocacy groups, which also includes the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now, Project Vote and the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, say most states have programs for driver’s license registration, but many are ignoring the public assistance requirement. tions and Rehabilitation has since constructed a new death chamber and the proposed new regulations require execution team members to undergo monthly mock executions. The rules would require three syringes, each filled with different drugs, to be administered by staff licensed to give injections in California. A physician must be on hand to declare death. A state judge ruled that the 42 pages of execution protocols, including instructions for mixing and injecting the drugs, had to be subjected to California’s lengthy regulatory process, starting with a 45-day public comment period. Cor rections off icials have received more than 1,400 written comments, the vast majority opposed to the proposed procedures or death penalty generally. For the mother of Morales’ victim, the wait for his execution has been too long. “There has been too much ‘red tape,’ paperwork, and time lost in this matter,” Barbara Christian, the mother of Ter ri Winchell, wrote in an e-mail. “Other victims such as I are grieving and waiting for justice for their loved ones. We are the ones bearing the brunt of this fiasco. The lethal injection is humane with no pain. Let’s get on with it.” Maryland has embarked on a public comment process like California’s. A federal judge has ordered a halt to executions in Missouri. And other states such as Texas have carried out a com- bined 68 lethal injection executions since the Supreme Court’s ruling in 2008. Michael Rushford, president of the death penalty advocates Criminal Justice Legal Foundation in Sacramento, said he is confident that California also will resume executions, partly because the state’s protocols are more detailed than the Kentucky procedures approved by the U.S. Supreme Court. Most comments opposing the new protocols stemmed from letter campaigns organized by the ACLU, Catholic Legislative Network and other death penalty foes. The ACLU complained that the proposed process shrouds in secret most of the lethal injection procedures. At least 10 death row inmates complained in writing that they have not received copies of the new regulations. The son of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg noted the profound impact of the death penalty on the children of the condemned. “There is an apparent disregard for children who have had a family member executed,” wrote Robert Meeropol, a lawyer in Easthampton, Mass. The Rosenbergs were executed at a New York prison in 1953 for passing atomic secrets to the Soviet Union when Meeropol was 6. “My earliest distinct memories of my parents are of visiting them on death row,” Meeropol wrote. “I have clear memories of the last week of my parents’ lives.” DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 15 The Detroit Legal News, Page 51 FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Legal Affairs Submit news & views to [email protected] Mark the Date Retirement party for Eric Braverman July 10 The Wayne County Probate Bar Association will hold a retirement party for Eric A. Braverman Friday, July 10 at 5 p.m. at Duggan’s Irish Pub, located at 31501 Woodward Avenue in Royal Oak (north of 13 Mile Road on the west side of Woodward). Braverman was one of the founders of the Wayne County Probate Bar Association and has made a substantial contribution to the practice of probate law and the procedure for more than 30 years. Food and beverages will be served at the event. For additional information, contact Les Braverman at (734) 283-7700 or Howard Linden at (248) 358-4545. Criminal Procedure Night at the Skyline Club July 16 Take in the view from the 28th floor of the Town Center while enjoying hors d’oeuvres and drinks and mingling with current and prospective members of the Detroit Metropolitan Bar Association Criminal Procedure Section. The event will take place from 5:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. in Southf ield. While at the event, Section members can schedule an appointment with a photographer in order to be included in a composite photograph of the local bar, which will be displayed at the Frank Murphy Hall of Justice. Registration deadline is July 14. Non-members contact Mitzy Sharp Futro at (313) 961-6120, ext. 201 or [email protected] for membership information. NALS of Detroit to host annual banquet July 17 NALS of Detroit, a 50-year plus legal professional support organization, provides quality continuing educational opportunities, certification and training for members and nonmembers alike. The local Detroit chapter will hold the 53rd Annual Awards and Installation Banquet Friday, July 17, at the Holiday Inn Express & Suites, 2nd Floor Washington Room, 1020 Washington Boulevard in Detroit. A meet and greet social begins at 6 p.m. Dinner will follow. NALS of Detroit will welcome Roxann Repasy as the sched- uled guest speaker. Repasy was recently installed as the newly elected state president of NALS of Michigan at the organization’s annual meeting held in April 2009 in Grand Rapids. Repasy has been a member of NALS of Jackson County for more than 30 years. She is an administrative assistant at Comerica Bank, Charitable Services Group, in Ann Arbor. In order to make a reservation or for any additional information about the event and dinner, contact Mary Tortomose at (313) 965-9725, ext. 319 or mtortomose@ bsdd.com no later than Friday, July 10. LADA holds free legal clinic July 17 Legal Aid and Defender Association (LADA) will hold a free legal aid clinic for income eligible residents under 60 years of age who qualify for services on Friday, July 17, from 9 a.m. to noon at Oakland Livingston Human Services located at 345 East Nine Mile Road in Ferndale. Those seeking assistance are asked to arrive before 10 a.m. to register as LADA staff will assist only those persons registered before 10 a.m. For more information, contact Stacey Felder at (248) 253-1548 ext. 4005 or 1-877964-4700. OCBA to hold golf outing at Oakland Hills July 20 One of the top country clubs in the country will be the site of this year’s Oakland County Bar Association golf outing on Monday, July 20, beginning with registration at 11 a.m., while lunch will be served from 11:30 a.m. with a shotgun start scheduled for 1 p.m. Dinner will follow the outing at 6 p.m. The cost is $200 per golfer or $800 for a foursome. A hole sponsorship is $300, while a combination hole sponsorship and foursome costs $1,050. For those electing to attend the dinner only, the price is $100 per ticket. Reservations are due by Friday, July 10, by calling Dennise Gac at (248) 334-3400. Online registration is available at www.ocba.org. Barristers 22nd Annual Summer Breeze and Law Clerk Party July 23 Join the Detroit Metropolitan Bar Clark Hill Cares Association Barristers for the best networking event of the summer. The Barristers 22nd Annual Summer Breeze and Law Clerk Party is a great opportunity for summer associates and law clerks to meet their peers, members of the judiciary and other legal professions. This year’s event, held at Sinbad’s at the River from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m., will also include the opportunity to enjoy a “mini-cruise” on the Detroit River. The event is free for members of the DMBA Barristers and Law Student Sections. Tickerts for other members and nonmembers is $20. Contact Mitzy Sharp Futro at [email protected] or (313) 961-6120, ext. 201 for more information. Gordon Advisors PC to host free seminar July 24 Gordon Advisors PC will host a seminar titled “Measuring, Creating, and Maintaining the Value of Your Company” on Friday, July 24, beginning with registration/networking at 8:30 a.m. at Automation Alley in Troy. This free seminar will run from 9 to 10:30 a.m. As seating is limited, pre-registration for this event is required. To register for this event, contact Lauren McDowell at (248) 952-0275 or [email protected]. MMLA’s annual lending conference Aug. 2-4 Photo by John Meiu Some 200 Clark Hill PLC employees volunteered June 27 to sort and pack food at Gleaners Community Food bank and partner locations near the firm’s offices in three Michigan communities (Detroit, Grand Rapids and Lansing), as well as Chicago and Phoenix. While the firm has supported many community organizations in the past, the company-wide initiative was the first formal community project orchestrated under the firm’s new “Clark Hill Cares” banner. “In lieu of holiday cards we felt like we’d take our money and time and spend it better and so we’re donating time in all seven (firm) cities across the United States. Why are we doing it in the middle of summer? Because most non-profits need our help during the summer,” Don Lee, chief marketing officer at Clark Hill’s Detroit office, said. “That’s the kind of culture we want as a firm. It’s a family culture but it’s also a culture that cares and gives.” “Back to the Future” is the title of the Michigan Mortgage Lenders Association’s Annual Lending Conference hosted Sunday through Tuesday, August 2-4, at Soaring Eagle Casino & Resort in Mt. Pleasant. There are many different options available to fit all schedules and budgets. Visit www.mmla.net to view the choices and prices. Early registration prices are through Friday, July 17. Overnight accommodations must be arranged separately using the Soaring Eagle registration form found on the conference Web site page. To register, go online to www.mmla.net. For additional information, contact Joanne Misuraca, MMLA executive director, (586) 226-2823 or at [email protected]. Cynthia Filipovich (left) and Caryn Gordon packaging potatoes. Photo courtesy of Tanner Friedman To include your event in “Mark the Date,” send information to [email protected]. ANALYSIS Get The New Issue Today! Your life is always in Could face groundbreaking cases on national security MOTION BY MARK SHERMAN Associated Press Writer MOTION is the definitive lifestyle magazine for Metro Detroit’s legal professionals. Each quarterly issue contains articles on Professional Development, Wealth Strategies, People of Interest, Arts and Entertainment, Gourmet Foods, Courtroom Tools and Tactics, Event Photo Galleries and much, much more. Make MOTION Your Legal Lifestyle Magazine. Subscribe Today and Don’t Miss An Issue! The Detroit Legal News has printed “News you cannot get anywhere else” each weekday since 1895. That tradition continues inside the pages of MOTION our quarterly magazine for and about YOU. Sotomayor’s record thin when it comes to executive power matters WASHINGTON (AP) — Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor’s thin record on the limits of presidential power suggests she will be neither reflexively hostile to broad expansion of a president’s authority nor a reliable rubber stamp in support of it. Three cases in particular offer clues: — As a judge on the 2nd Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, Sotomayor dismissed complaints of commuters about random searches aimed at stopping terrorists on a ferry 300 miles north of New York City. — Citing an earlier ruling by the Supreme Court on the same topic, she upheld President George W. Bush’s decision to prohibit U.S. aid to international family planning groups that support abortion. — On the other hand, Sotomayor joined colleagues in striking down parts of the anti-terror USA Patriot Act that Bush sought automatically prohibiting Internet service providers from telling customers when the government asks for private information about them. Sotomayor has ruled in only a handful of foreign policy and national security cases that turned in part on constitutional limits to the powers enjoyed by the president, including the government’s ability to respond to the threats, fears and vulnerabilities laid bare by the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorism attacks. In those rulings, as well as a speech she gave in 2003 at the Indiana University law school, she appeared to be more willing to consider robust use of presidential authority than was Justice David Souter, the man she would replace. Souter, who retired last week, was among the justices most skeptical of the powers asserted by the Bush administration following Sept. 11. While Sotomayor has leaned heavily on earlier court decisions to support her rulings — as appeals court judges must — she soon could face potentially groundbreaking cases on national security if President Barack Obama asserts executive authority to continue detaining suspected terrorists. “What you have from Sotomayor is fairly mixed,” said Gene Healy, vice president at the libertarian Cato Institute in Washington. In the case over aid to family planning groups, Sotomayor stuck squarely with precedents from the 2nd Circuit and the Supreme Court in ruling for Bush. The dispute stemmed from President Ronald Reagan’s decision in 1984 to institute the Mexico City Policy that bars U.S. financial help for international family planning groups that support abortion, even with their own money, through services, counseling or lobbying. President Bill Clinton rescinded the policy in 1993, but Bush reimposed it shortly after taking office. “The Supreme Court has made clear that the government is free to favor the anti-abortion position over the pro-choice position,” she wrote for a three-judge panel in 2002. Obama lifted the so-called global gag rule in January. The appeals court in New York, where Sotomayor has been a judge since 1998, does not hear many national security cases. But Sotomayor’s sparse record indicates “she won’t be a pushover for the claim that the president gets to do what he wants in any area that he defines as national security,” Healy said. In the most recent ruling, in December, Sotomayor signed onto an opinion by Judge Jon Newman that forces the government to seek a court’s approval if it wants to prevent an Internet provider from telling a customer that authorities are seeking information about him. The appeals court said the courts must be given a role in protecting rights even when the government says disclosure of information may endanger national security or interfere with diplomatic relations. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee that will question Sotomayor next week, said the case raises important questions about the role of courts in the fight against terrorism. “Does Judge Sotomayor believe that the Constitution permits any deference to the elected branches in the area of national security?” he said. Based on Sotomayor’s opinion in the ferry case, the answer is yes. Two regular ferry passengers who crossed Lake Champlain from their homes in Vermont to their jobs in New York objected to random searches instituted by the ferry operator in 2004. One man, traveling by car, was asked to open his trunk. The other, a bicyclist, had to open a pack he carried. The Coast Guard had determined that operators of vessels over 100 tons were required to carry out the searches because they are at a high risk of terrorist attacks. Sotomayor, writing for a unanimous three-judge panel, said the ferry company’s policy might not be the most effective way to prevent terrorist attacks, but “it is minimally intrusive, and we cannot say, particularly in light of the deference we owe to the Coast Guard, that it does not constitute a reasonable method of deterring the prohibited conduct.” Even so, she recognized as a legitimate concern — though not in the ferry searches — the slippery-slope argument that “because the threat of terrorism is omnipresent, there is no clear limit to the government power to conduct suspicionless searches.” DLN Front Jul10-1 7/9/09 2:41 PM Page 16 Page 52, The Detroit Legal News FRIDAY, JULY 10, 2009 Friday Feature Submit news & views to [email protected] Photos by Robert Chase Maddin Hauser Wartell Roth & Heller attorney Harvey Heller poses with just two pieces from the extensive collection of antique lunchboxes on display in his kitchen. At left, he’s pictured with his favorite model, a purple-and-green depiction of comic-book hero The Green Hornet. Lawyer captures pop culture history in unique collection BY TARYN HARTMAN Legal News T he color palette splashing across Harvey Heller’s West Bloomfield kitchen would be the envy of any interior decorator. But the bright hues don’t come from the cabinets (white with red handles), the floor (black-and-white checkerboard linoleum) or the appliances (standard stainless steel). Lining the walls is Harvey, a partner at Maddin Hauser Wartell Roth & Heller in Southfield and head of the firm’s insurance coverage and defense practice group, and wife Ronna’s collection of antique lunchboxes, an array of oranges and turquoises and hot pinks some 110 strong that immortalize pop culture icons like Superman, G.I. Joe and the casts of “Bonanza,” “Lost in Space,” and “Get Smart.” “They’re a specialty,” Harvey says. “This is very much a premiere collection for this area, because the condition of the boxes are very, very good, for the most part. There are some bad ones, but overall it’s an excellent collection and not a lot of people collect lunchboxes.” It all started in Royal Oak, where the Hellers found their first two lunchboxes — a 1973 Dr. Seuss model that is still Ronna’s favorite and the first of what would grow into three Popeye lunchboxes, this one yellow with red trim. “And we said, ‘Gee, those would look cute above the sink,’” Harvey remembers. “One thing led to another, and we found ourselves at flea markets and collectible shows for years thereafter.” The blue and white Dr. Seuss box has since been moved to the center of the top shelf running the length of the back wall above the sliding glass door to the patio, and the Popeye box has joined its siblings on the shelf above the entrance to the kitchen. The bulk of the collection rests on custombuilt white shelves edging the far end of the kitchen. To peruse the Hellers’ collection is to take a tour through the history of decorated lunchboxes, each one telling its own story, beginning with a 1946 Joe Palooka edition decorated with the characters from a comic strip that would become the precursor to Bazooka Bubble Gum and its in-wrapper Bazooka Joe comics. “The history of lunchboxes, really, before the early ’50s there wasn’t much going on in lunchboxes,” Harvey says, pulling the Palooka box from the shelf like a library book. “It wasn’t much of something that was done until the early ’50s, when one of the box companies came out with two boxes” — he replaces Palooka for another model — “this one, Hopalong Cassidy with a simple decal on it, and then you see those two space boxes up there on the right.” He gestures across the kitchen to shelves next to the microwave where one red and one blue box feature illustrated stickers in their middles. “And so when they did that, the competition came out with a fully decorated Roy Rogers,” Heller continues. “And in response to that, they then started this process, and so the legend goes, decorated lunchboxes were born.” “As a collection, for all the effort we have undertaken, we He explains that each year, lunchbox companies unveiled six or eight new models just in time for the back-to-school season, can’t imagine parting with it. I think Ronna and I probably said at most designs not repeating year to year. one point in time it would take six figures to turn our heads, but even “Throughout the ’50s you get a lot of the Westerns here,” Heller says, gesturing to one shelf lined with the likes of the then we probably wouldn’t get turned enough. That’s how we feel original Lone Ranger lunchbox, boxes featuring Wild Bill Hickabout our lunchboxes. ock and Zorro and “this 1954, pristine-condition Annie Oakley, just perfect” that Heller convinced a Macomb County collector into selling him. “In the late ’50s, these boxes took off, and that’s sort of like “ ” your conventional workman’s lunch pail box,” Heller says, pulling a box with a curved top painted in a pirate motif off a shelf. “There were 41 dome boxes that were designed, you’re seeing 34 of them,” he adds. “And this is the rarest box of these types, called Hometown Airport,” he continues. “Rare, because no cool kid wanted this box.” Heller estimates it could easily fetch $2,000. The un-cool factor of the planes adorning Hometown Airport may explain why there was no Perry Mason lunchbox. “It would have to be something that was kind of cool,” like a cartoon or superhero, Heller says. “In those days, that’s how they did it.” “A little later on, in the ’60s, you get to the TV shows.” Heller points out a “Land of the Giants” box adorned with a self-portrait of the artist who painted it. “There was a lot of that going on, they drew pictures of themselves and they inserted them,” he explains. There’s also an original Star Trek box featuring the mugs of William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy, versions featuring The Man from U.N.C.L.E and the Flintstones and Jetsons. “This is the original Mickey Mouse Club box,” Heller says. “So there’s Annette, and there’s Bobby and there’s Jimmie Dodd and there’s whatever her name is. But the interesting thing about this is there was a little boy on the show and his name was Cubby O’Brien. And Cubby O’Brien, in later years and currently I still believe, if somebody like Cher was on the road, he might be in the orchestra being a drummer. “Anyway, we were at the Fisher, and we sit down and we’re always looking through the playbill, and I look down and it says ‘Cubby O’Brien.’ So I walk down and I said, ‘Is it really you?’ and he said it was, so the following week I convinced my partner, when it was his season ticket, to walk down the center aisle with this and have Cubby sign it. ” He turns the box over, where there’s a signature in Sharpie over an illustration on the bottom of the box. “Now, we weren’t so lucky, nor did we try when Paul McCartney was in town for the Beatles box,” Heller says with a laugh. There are two Beatles models near the superhero section of the Hellers’s collection: a blue one and one embodying the famed yellow submarine. “This one was unusual.” Heller picks up one of the brighter boxes, day-glo colors featuring the visage of actress Diahann Carroll. “This is Julia. ‘Julia’ was a TV show in the early ’60s, very ahead of its time as a TV show because it was pre-Cosby. And we found this wrapped, fully covered with a flocked wallpaper. We found it at the Royal Oak flea market, and all I could do was try to peel it back, and I peeled it back and I saw this green edge, and I said, ‘This is worth buying.’ And we bought it, we took it home, I worked on it for a long time and discovered this was underneath it.” Portraits of live actors on lunchboxes got to be so serious that when the original Dr. Dolittle movie was filmed in 1967, “Rex Harrison, who played Dr. Dolittle insisted to have prior refusal rights,” Heller explains in legalese, “and he insisted that his likeness be exact.” The lunchbox Heller carried to school as a child is in the collection, although by the time he wanted to display it his mother had gotten rid of the original model and Heller had to pick up another one. His calls his favorite lunchbox, the purple and lime green Green Hornet design, “one of the best superhero boxes ever produced just because of the action scenes” that include sketches of Bruce Lee as Kato. Parts of the collection have been out of the house on loan at various times to the West Bloomfield public library for back-to-school displays. “We love the opportunity to-you could’ve said you were from the Weekly Reader,” Harvey says. “We love the opportunity to show our collection.” Heller estimates his insured collection is worth more than $25,000, but it’s never been about the money and he has no interest in selling. “As a collection, for all the effort we have undertaken, we can’t imagine parting with it,” he says. “I think Ronna and I probably said at one point in time it would take six figures to turn our heads, but even then we probably wouldn’t get turned enough. That’s how we feel about our lunchboxes. Fair statement, honey?” he asks his wife. “I think so,” she answers. “I actually had an offer yesterday for somebody to buy a Beatles box. I told them no.” “... The chances of us parting company…we love them too much,” says Heller. “We get a lot of joy just sitting in here and enjoying them.”